001policy committee meeting of January 13th to order uh the we have a number of items on our agenda the first um agenda item was public comment we don't have anyone signed up so we we're going to move right to the second um item which is a proposed revision to policy 1.20 relating to the board of education and relating to appointments and um staff has flagged for us that there is a provision we need to change um and so I'm gonna ask uh this large the uh policy staff lead to share um what the change is and why staff is recommending a change so as we have been working through this with director Scott's uh resignation we realiz that the policy that provided that if a uh interested candidate into the Zone where the departing director
002is from declares an interest in the vacant if no eligible Zone resident declares an interest our policy says the board shall appoint an eligible resident from the district at large the statute that governs this doesn't actually allow that so this is just a change to bring the policy in conformance with the statute so what happens if you if nobody wants to you have to go find someone to the Zone yes okay all right any questions about the recommended change no okay um so this was uh posted today just for discussion only so um I anticipate that the February meeting we will take action to move it out on the committee okay so are you asking for us to say we're not going to do anything now I mean do we have to go through that
003formal process if it's just we're just trying to align the policy with the ORS uh yeah because it's just a revision of the policy so we just follow the regular policy so I expected the next meeting there won't be a whole bunch of public comment attempting to save that provision um and like I say we only noticed it as a discussion only and so next meeting we i' ask um if we could recommend the modified policy to send it out yes okay great the next uh the next uh the next three actually items on the agenda they're also just for discussion purposes and primarily um I'd like to use this meeting as an opportunity for committee members to sort of raise questions you might have what information you would want at the next meeting um
004we had kind of a condensed meeting this time uh this because of uh tonight's meeting afterwards and so this is really again we're not moving anything this is a very preliminary discussion so what what questions do you have what questions you think community members will have who what information you would need to make decisions um around around this um so that's that's the spirit of the next three items okay um so oh can I ask so there's a draft proposed new policy lobbying and registration but no attachments um um or maybe I need to refresh it would be item number five so we'll be we just discussed item number three I'm wondering four is the ethics and conflicts five is the draft proposed new policy no you're right because there was not anything posted um
005and I'm wondering should I send post that one short paragraph or do you think it's not ready it's not ready for prime time okay okay so we have two more items I was just well I I want to get this one on the table so like also find out what your questions are we can generally talk about it okay um again just for the spirit of um wanting to not be like here it is like push it through but really um sort of talk through like what is the pro what's the problem statement um and what are we trying to solve who should we talk to what information do people need um g in this particular case um I drafted something based on some Metro Lang looking at Metro's um language um we're a little
006bit different than Metro so a little well um we have some similarities and the we're a large Contracting I mean we have a lot of money flowing through the the board and Senior staff um and um on the other hand um we have um generally should we wait till we get there um and we can talk talk through it with with some differences as well um so this next item is um relating to the same policy we just discussed and there is a version with a new draft section to it right okay I'm sorry it's the conflict of interest policy so 51066 and the new language proposed um is a new number eight it should be it's posted in the and this is an issue that has come up before in uh PPS about um
007regarding board members um applying for and accepting employment with the district um while there's still a board member or shortly thereafter and so um this essentially given the fact that um at the school district um we super Vis and manage and evaluate the superintendent um to have board members applying for positions from the person that they're supervising um it what this would do is create a um period of time in which they aren't in a position of unequal power um with the Su with the superintendent or or somebody even below this below the superintendent um so it would create it period of time um between when a board member Cycle's off and when they could either apply for or seek or be offered employment from the district um we did have some initial as you
008may recall some initial feedback from a board member about the um the proposed change and I would put those the the categories of the concerns in three buckets um one is it would be a limit on the the school district's ability to hire whoever they wanted essentially um that it could be a disincentive for board participation um and that impact a board member's career growth um the second category was the time period is too long which current L it's essentially a year and then the third category were ones that fall into sort of um is it legally permissible whether it's legally per legally permissive we right um I'm going to go and RSE order and then we discussion so the legally permissible um just generally yeah just generally as a policy matter um I don't
009have significant concerns about whether it's legally permissible to have a waiting period in this under these conditions so um thank you the issue of the whether it's excessive um I a waiting period which um I think they're in in different um governmental jurisdictions they have um different waiting periods for when you can go back and Lobby your formal employer or or a testify before so there already establishment and some and um there are a number that are a year and some that are shorter um so I think it's a if we were to Institute it like it's a very um it's like open for discuss whether that's the right amount of time um I have a question are we ready for questions yet or yeah um I guess one more thing on the amount of
010time is um recognizing that in the last 30 years I believe we've had three former teachers on this on the board and uh including Patty and Eddie the other being Steve bule um um and so one of the issues that I think we should talk about is um I think of somebody had a um if if you were a teacher before and you went back to teaching again um I think you make the argument that this is not really you're not using your position to get a job that you previously had um so in my mind I I think there it may be there would be an exception for teachers well an exception for people who already had previously had a position with the district like in a particular position or it could be from
011from my perspective I don't think board members should ever be applying for jobs while they're a board member um whether it's a position they held before a teacher or anything like that because it's hard not to um you're in a position of power and influence a as a board member the question for me would be like would there be any waiting period um so um okay I guess I'm still trying to see what problem are we trying to solve here that's my question too and also like how widespread is it are we talking so we've had in 30 years three people that are former teachers what is it that we're trying to actually solve for because this I don't see anything a problem would it be somebody yeah what are we solving for and how
012widespread is this what we're solving for the problem so I don't think it's widespread I think it speaks to The credibility of the board and our ethics um it's awfully hard after it happens to say it shouldn't happen um it has happened previously and yes I also um in a position at the never governmental jurisdiction where it just occurred where you had an individual who was in a position of um Authority overseeing um Department's budgets now becoming the head of the department and I say it's it's unfair to the person afterwards to say well we don't really like even though it doesn't happen very often we don't think it should happen just so is a clear set of rules okay what you mentioned is somebody who was in charge of could be anything Hing and
013or charge of the budget okay in charge of the budget which is the board is I'm saying this isn't another this isn't another jurisdiction um but I'm saying we there has been a board member who has left the board who then immediately went to a senior position at The District in a position that hadn't been that that didn't exist previously which raised questions about the the position position just get created for that individual I'm familiar with the situation um I just if we go on what's happened in the past 30 years and that we don't have a problem here I'm just it doesn't seem like even should be a policy because there's no problem to solve I think that if there was a position if a board member applies for a position at some point
014it's not our we don't make hiring decisions on the board except for the superintend but the person we supervise does and that creates it's their decision though at that point it's not it's out of the board's purview the let's say so we have a current board member let's say I I want to go off the board and the next month I apply for a position at PPS at that point I'm not on the board anymore and it's up to the superintendent or whoever is you know being supervised by her to do the hire in other words it's not the board's business at that point okay so so this a very cut and dry and also if if it's never happened and it it has happened it has happened one time but I say what once
015when it happens when it happens you can't go you can't go back right because it's not sounds like we're solving for another jurisdiction and not for like an actual um actually this this was this was brought up before and the board um didn't act because the person was still in the position but it wasn't that didn't come up so just following on your line um so that would be more if they were off um how do you feel about like when you're a board member not seeking a position at the district I feel like that sort of the first half so the district's going to hire for positions based on a skill set or working relationship to fill a need that the district has and if the need is best filled by someone that has
016pre previously been on the board I I don't see a problem with it what about what about if they're currently on the board currently on the board and because that's kind of the first half of the piece how does that work though if you're currently on the board you're not even allowed to apply to be if you're a PPS employee oh you're saying if you're a board and you're serving yeah I I don't think that I think that would present a conflict okay if you're on the board but you're talking about a 365 time after you're off the board there's two parts to it because you could you could have you could have the same thing but you could have um like while you're serving on the board current board members and those who have
017served as a board member within the preceding Year may not apply for or accept I also wonder like can we tell people not to apply for something it doesn't can we restrict somebody from from my perspective I think that creates a huge conflict of interest because we're actively supervising and evaluating the superintendent so say if you bracketed the card board members and those may not apply for accepting offer of employment from the district while other have there ever been people on the board who are currently working for the District No but no certainly um discussed with the superintendent a job position so there's a statute that prohibits an employee of the district from serving on the board so that's already there it's the other way around okay but it's also not saying while you're a
018board member you can't be seeking this would say be seeking seeking actually employment with the district after you're off the board well I'm just if I were going to take Michelle's point of like no waiting period but but leaving in place that while you're a board member you can't actively be soliciting employment or applying for how would we enforce that or even know about it I mean let's say I'm looking for a job and I'm gonna have a conversation with somebody about seeking employment would I tell you or would it be just a conversation between well obviously if you applied for the position then you've applied for the position I mean this is can we can we enforce that and regulate it though is that's what I'm curious about it doesn't seem like we can
019well I would hope that we can enforce our code of ethics I would hope that too I mean in an Ideal World so the code of ethics already says you cannot be working for the district while you're on the board you can't serve it doesn't say if you serve it's it's basically it before you get into office um you can't have um you can't be a current District employee so if you were still teaching you couldn't run for the board and then be still teaching and be on the board even though I'd have a lot of things to say well you have a lot of things to say which is great it's just you can't you can't hold both um okay so we're just saying we don't want you to hold a position in the
020district after the board except for a certain number of days it would be if one day you're um writing the superintendent's evaluation or voting on the budget or doing any number of the things that are board duties that impact the superintendent and the District staff and then applying for a job at the same time with the district okay so this would be it sounds so un unlikely ever to happen it's happened and like I say when it happens it's then not fair to the that then the response is you can't apply these retroactively I just again I go back to the past performance and what's happened in the past it happened once was that 20 years ago or it was a long time ago um um and it just seems very unlikely to happen I
021know we want to do some of our policy as like worst case scenario but it just it doesn't seem very likely I mean you're talking about senior level not teaching so there would be an exception for teachers and I can I can understand wanting to go from an unpaid job to having a little bit more pay but I it just doesn't seem it's happened one time um in our history and that we can back in recent history and it doesn't seem very likely to happen again well hopefully I would say that all these things that are outlined in our conflict of interest policy hopefully are not happening ever just I mean that's that's why you have them so that they they don't happen so it it does seem though that if you've been on the
022I mean not me because I'm retired but people who maybe are on the board um when they're young might want to work for the district later because they probably have a lot of good skills for that so it it seems that it would be a good idea often to have somebody who was on the board work for PPS as far as skill you know skill level is concerned um you don't want to I but people shouldn't be and and people should not be running for the school board and serving on the school board as a a path to Board District employment right but I would doubt that people do that doesn't seem long route to get to the your your your dream job it's a it's a tough price to pay and that's a long
023job interview process um I I just don't see I would have to hear more be to be convinced that this is a good idea and if it is I I'm question you think it's it's because you don't it's rare or you think it's a good idea that board members should be applying for jobs because it's rare and past performance is a good predictor of future projection well that and I think I mean I can go both ways on either argument whichever one you prefer but it's because it's very unlikely to happen so we don't have a problem to solve right now it happened once we had somebody that was on the board that was applying and another jurisdiction completely different non-education related we had somebody that applied and got a senior level uh position that
024served on the board but I mean I think it's like looking at an apple and orange they're two different jurisdictions with different you know one social services and health you're saying it's you're fine with current board members applying for an accept employment with the district during their board tenure if if they finish their tenure on the board or or someone may that's not a current board that maybe we're agreeing and I don't realize it because a current board member someone that's currently serving I would assume would have to step down from the board but you're saying you want to prohibit the applying for or accepting an offer and I don't think that is the board's purview I believe that the hiring decisions belong in the hands of the superintendent right who who were the boss
025of who were the boss of um and I I feel like that hiring decision uh lies that squarely in outside of the board and in fact I I think it's none of the board's um business um hiring decisions and maybe it's just a philosophical difference but I believe the district the district if if the district has a need it's in all of our best interests in the best interests of our community for that need to be filled with the person that can best you know carry out that job yeah I guess I'm looking at it from like the superintendent's position of it's the um position of if somebody applies for a job that who is evaluates you not picking that individual for the position I think creates um real issues for the super the superintendent
026potentially so the scenario is there's a current board member that applies for a job that doesn't get it and that there could be some like retaliatory negative or the pressure of gosh I don't have I don't think like you I was like that it just seems so unlikely to happen I know it probably does want to be naive I just I don't understand the problem that we're trying to solve I mean most most of the time in employment situations um um you want to avoid um where there's an imbalance of power and there's an imbalance of power between the superintendent and a and a sitting board member because the sitting board member actually evaluates the superintendent in other words the superintendent may be um tempted to say yes to a hire even if they're not
027the best person because of the power IM balance right I thought we just said that you already couldn't work for the district if you're on the board so why would you even apply for that job if you're on the board I mean the you but then you'd be off the board but you actually would be actively soliciting the job while you're on the board okay maybe we could just change it to you may not apply for a job with the district while you're on the board but after you're off the board then you could apply so this 365 days seems very that would be with the El eliminating the words and these who have and those who have served as a board member with the preceding within the preceding 365 days yeah I think the
028waiting period is is too long I think to hear Point Patty you know you're going to be doing one or the other you're either an employee or you're a board member looking for their next professional home let's say is that correct so here's here's a scario so you could cycle you could you could cycle off the board say there's no waiting period you could cycle off the board there's an open position you apply for it you're you're not a position of overseeing the superintendent or the superintendent's budget or their you know priority initiatives and you're you know judged on um your qualif applications um the whe you know whether you're the right fit for the position um if there were no waiting period you could accept the position but say if you were on the
029if you were on the board if you had the no waiting period if you were on the board and there were position open you would need to be either have finished your term or cycle off before you applied for the position before you applied or before you accepted I would say before you applied because you still have that imbalance of power I okay I still feel like I don't I don't feel like we have a problem to solve um hopefully not everybody as nefarious as that would it's not nefarious Behavior it's not nefarious it's just setting standards of um that of conduct of conduct that has been an issue in another jurisdiction that's not education related it's been an issue here um one time one time and at a time we're 173 years well it's
030probably happened more than that maybe it's happen more than that but in a recent history it's happened one time was there an um a negative result as a result of the hire or um I think it undermines the board's credibility um well I I mean this is just discussion right so yeah l so if it's if it's somebody who previously had a position that they're had a license for but it it creates questions about for both for the district I think and for for the board um because of the time I want to keep moving um I think I've got your point of view um but feel but we'll have further discussion okay yeah I just feel since we already say you can't serve on the board and work for the district we could just
031add or apply for a job in the district while you're on the board but they could apply the minute they're off board okay then that would be okay with so that's a no waiting period okay so no waiting all right I think that's a nice um solution elegant all right so the next item on the agenda is the lobbying one but I think I want to because that's the one that we don't have um information on but I can kind of share like here's here's the issue and um we can talk about then like what we what we want to see next meeting um the next issue is the elections and currently we have um board members elected um Citywide and I would um in the spirit of hearing from the broader Community about um
032which did not necessarily happen uh last time we had this discussion um about whether we should um look at potentially switching to running from a zone or and being elected by a running from and being eled by a Zone um one of the things the district is looking at doing is and the state looked at was um in order to make board service um I think more attractive and open to more people is paying a stien um another barrier to Service is like running Citywide potentially um and we have in your packet you have I me it it is a barrier and yet everybody to date has had to run Citywide and it's actually like resulted in the most diverse board in history so I guess my concern about that zoned uh voting first of
033all I did speak with the molma county elections Division I just was curious what this would entail um I spoke with the director he said it would be very challenging to do for this special election oh it's this is not s just clear it's not for no I know but he just offered that information that it would take about at least a year prior to any special election to make changes and that the risk of well that the precincts and the zones don't boundaries do not line up and so they we'd be relying on whatever GIS information that we pay for and population Census Data mapping by census by this federal census lining up with precincts there's going to be split precincts and so there's two there's there's a ballot on this side of the
034street there's a ballot on that side of the street creating confusion for voters and then also um you know the system would need to be tested it would take at least a year to put it on the ballot and then there's it increases the risk of error just because it's untested but my be besides all that and the logistics and getting that underway is the fact of the outcome of our the outcome of our elections that are Citywide we have a better chance of having a diverse board with the current system than if we do in a racially segregated City we we have a history here like we do in every city in the country the red lining and you know there there there are no like ethnic population centers in Portland and so we
035I think we with a Citywide election we have more of a chance of is it harder to run yes has everybody that's been up here run yes have do we have a more Divi diverse board yes will we have a more diverse and more representative board with a Zone election probably no I would just say for hund and whatever however many years we had um Citywide elections we didn't have it so I wouldn't I wouldn't attribute it to necessarily um I don't think we can attribute to cause and effect of like you're running Citywide we have a more diverse board because I mean we didn't have any with with this current system we didn't have any women on the board um for a long long time I mean so yeah and that was a social
036that was the the a social construct you know that we we all agreed to as a community and well I'm just saying but it's not the women and black people can you know join golf clubs now and that type of thing so we we have definitely changed say just it's not the the board it's not the the election mechanism that has created the more diverse board per se that we it's a contributing factor though because of how because of our racial our the way our housing patterns are in every city not just Portland unless we're talking about Cleveland that's it's a little bit different so New Orleans were more racially integrated housing patterns here we don't have that we don't have a black neighborhood we don't have an Italian neighborhood or a Jewish neighborhood anymore
037we used to but so in in that situation it would make sense to be a zoned vote because then you could have someone from the south part of Portland the Italian Jewish neighborhood representing those folks that lived there same thing in Albina but it's it's not that way anymore our housing patterns and our residential housing patterns don't don't line up that mean that every zone is more diverse but it's not and I'll just say from an economic standpoint um running Citywide is one of the most challenging things to do if you're going to be financially able to raise money so we exclude lots of people who feel like they can't possibly raise the money and or take time off their job to run Citywide versus running from a running from a district I mean this
038is just some of us like literally sitting here have done that that's because we have the financial luxury to be able to do that I mean I would say the I don't I would say the well the city well I don't think we should I don't think we should expect for people to take time off their job because I did that as well to take time off their job to run for a volunteer position I mean it doesn't seem and I think actually this is what the city just went through is moving from people running Citywide to people running from districts because um you it's frankly it's more inclusive um than having a having people run I mean just look at the number of people who ran the to have a more distinct manageable population
039to to be talking to in your in your Zone I remember we talked about this a few months ago and Andrew showed some information he had before and a quote that really hit me was if you're talking about just wanting to get more minority representation it said said at large districts lead to over representation of minority voters where racial minority groups are a small part of the population or where Democratic voters make up a larger proportion of the population which would make us more likely to get minority voters if if this is true with an at large uh vote however if you're talking about money that's a whole different thing what I think is good without large is we represent all the schools not just the schools in our so so I your money situation
040makes sense to me but that's the only reason it makes sense to me I mean I I have for 25 years tried to recruit candidates and the number one reason that people don't run who really want to is because for a whole host of reasons I can't take you know around the camp more around the campaign than the serving like the serving is manageable the campaign if you have a contested race if you don't have a contested race I mean it's easy and I will just say some um for people who went through contested races um it um you don't just Breeze into office I mean as we I'll know but but there are we do have board members who don't have to run and that's like kind of the ideal they get the serving
041but they don't actually have to get there um and I would say for me we lose lots of great candidates because it's just not possible for them to they have young kids or a job that doesn't have the flexibility for them to campaign or they don't have the ability to fund raise on a Citywide basis and the way the city dealt with that is that we're we're going to districts um and they also did the um created a funding mechanism for campaigns which I don't think we can which I don't think we can do which was gamed I mean so what is the point though in terms of this policy are we do we want to make it easier to campaign then I think we should not the service are there other ways to encourage
042I mean the bottom line is when we're on TV and people see what we do the teacher strike turned a lot of people off um well then you say and by the way you're going to have to run a competitive race raise money and take time off from your job or away from your kids to run it Citywide versus in your the zone that you live which is still a pretty big it still hard I can say from from experience as a single parent with a job and a mortgage that it was hard and I know how to do hard things and so does everybody up here and I mean I think that I'm looking at the outcome and our outcomes right now today we have a diverse board with lots of women on it
043it seems like the system is working okay to me and I'm I'm probably a little biased if it's a money matter is there any way to limit what you can do like say no yard signs well we will have these these um you can't because it's like a first it's a First Amendment like free speech so you could tell that to candidates um you couldn't tell outside groups that they couldn't do which is what you saw in the city council races um where candidates were limited um and outside groups um were not and frankly um the criticism if you think about like the when you run Citywide up until this last election like Schoolboard candidates ran in the same sort of universe with this almost the same universes as members of the city council and
044um if you were lucky um I think director Scott never had a contested race director Wong never had a contested race but if you had a contested race and you actually um didn't want it just to be a complete crapshoot you had to raise money and spend a lot of time and I would say just like if you're a single parent um if you've got young kids or a job without the flexibility like it just it's doesn't I wouldn't advise somebody to run it's because like you got to be in it to win it but if you're like if you don't have time to do all that in a contested race then like you shouldn't run and yet I'm a testament like I am a single parent with a full-time job and I ran Citywide
045and it was a contested race all of that and it was very difficult and it's difficult time when you're on the board so I guess maybe you learned what you'd get it's not supposed to be fulltime um because then we really won't get um people to serve I I would like to bring back to the committee some data about this I feel like the discussion we've had in the past has been very much driven by the members of the board which obviously we get we get to decide that but I also believe there are other voices that should be part of the discussion about people who might want to serve or whether this makes a difference and again it's always the it's the board's decision so they can decide but I feel feel like when
046we when we had the discussion I was on the committee there wasn't it was more I felt an efficiency like to just we had two things we had to do one we had to adjust after the last s census which we did and then it was sort of like um board members don't want to change it so we're not going to change it so I don't I don't think there has been a discussion about it I think more people should be part of the conversation and we made it land this the same place I'm open to learning more about it for certain I just gave you my best thinking and I don't think I don't see what the problem is we're trying to solve but I'm open to learning if if we want to hear
047from more people and you can provide more people and more voices I would be open to learning more yeah same here I'm happy to hear do you know a lot of people who are interested in talking and is it a lot or is it three people well I would say I know a lot of people who have told me no and not because they don't want to serve in the board there's very few people who are having the conversation who don't want to serve on the board it's just like I don't see how I'm gonna get there okay so there are people who because usually it's oh yeah there's lots to get like one candidate in a race usually I talk to like 10 people I have to and the and the other nine people
048usually want to serve it's just the that's what's so exciting about because because nobody nobody runs for something else and then runs for the school board for most people this is their first yes race it's their Gateway um yeah I so I'm open to learning more I I don't I don't see the problem I mean most women here's a statistic for you need to be asked seven times to run for office so that's just a perception problem like you know can I'm going to run against somebody I might run against a friend you know um there there's a lot of barriers besides just the Citywide it's you know but all of us are a testament to be able to some of us ran contested races and it was difficult and and and we your race
049was contested kind of definitely was contested mine was contested but not difficult in right yeah so yeah through a unique set of circumstances um okay the the last issue is um relating to um and for right now we're gonna just use the word lobbing um but that may not be the um the word that we eventually use but it's um the influencing so we're we're a large public entity that has a lot of contracts and um some of our contracts have competitive processes and some of our expenditures have competitive processes and others do not um and most public agen have a set of rules around um and they're primarily around transparency it's not that you can't seek to influence an outcome um but there's a set of rules around transparency that people know that if
050you have an economic interest that that's apparent I think like construction firms for me the most recent example was like the Yonder representative um and um pardon Frenchie yeah okay well wow yes um again most of the times there are a set of rules in place that um there is just transparency so people know who's attempting to influence register right and it's there's usually thresholds and if you don't have a financial interest I mean I'm thinking like um and and this the word lobing is um probably a placeholder for a better word that you're going to help me help us think of um because I'm not thinking of like parents or staff showing up with a you know we want we want Library assistance um whoops I don't I don't view that as lobbing but
051we we do have a huge book of business and in some ways it's um I think naive to think that there aren't um that we shouldn't be transparent like every other agency um if something goes through a competitive procurement process that's that that is what it is and we have a um I think really good strong standards of you know here's what happens when something goes through I think we don't think anything about it right but something where there that doesn't occur like having um transparency in terms of what that looks like um yeah I appreciate you bringing that forward I think that makes sense to um have an understanding about how not just how we're spending money but how we're starting these conversations and with whom especially in this budget constraint time okay I'm
052really not quite sure what you're talking about so um both Michelle and I are like kind of creatures of like having been around a lot of public processes where you have people attempting to influence expenditures or contracts um Oh you mean like Stu we're getting in the emails like we want to buy this or that right so you're talking about as it relates to board members or and and Senior staff I mean generally it it applies um Metro I was looking at they they have a very sort of robust um process they in the end they don't have that they have all their people who are registered online um who are sort of registered lobbyists with Metro and they they are um say like the people who run the waste the waste hauling because Metro
053has that in their purview um but it allows there to be transparency about who is like seeking contracts who gets contracts um and we don't have that no at all we we we have I think a very good competitive Contracting that's what I thought policy yeah but that's if we have a if they go through if it's a request for proposal a public process proc if it goes through that because then you have like the transparency you can see who applied and there's rules about how they engage um okay so who are you talking about then the like non-competitive give me an example cont contracts well I'll just like have a I have a very concrete example from when I was really new here I don't remember the name so I won't use them but
054we had um a vendor pay us to test out their project their product so it was like so it's like you know maybe you s of like a doctor with well maybe you have a textbook person or a software person or someone that would like to do business with us um and the times like for instance with construction projects we have a process that's where where we put out a request for proposals organizations construction companies would make a proposal and there's a whole process it has to follow the Oregon revised statutes and for Public public procur and then there's the expenditures that happen outside of that public procurement process that it was I think I haven't seen we don't have anything but that's what I say what is it that's the big problem let's say
055let's say I'm I sell vacuum cleaners and I'm going to come yeah but you're not I mean what in the district what tell me something we have all kinds of we have all kinds of things that we spend money on and I just I want us to be I really do need a break today yeah we're going to finish in two minutes yes um but we have a meeting that starts at 6 right so this was going to go from if that clock is right was going to go this meeting was supposed to go from 4ock is not correct okay if it's 6:45 it's 64 it's just one minute off but okay I'm just going to answer Patty's question and I think we've achieved our objective which because what we'll ask is for um staff
056to come back with a sort of maybe draft set of on on this particular issue um but Patty curriculum playground equipment Yonder pouches those are all things yeah um apps so none of that goes through a process some of it does and some of it doesn't Okay um so that and we spend most over a billion dollars and I think we're frankly way behind by not having okay well i' like examples of of concrete examples of what the problem is and then definitely if there's a lot we need to solve it and can I have just say one thing about um something that's come to my attention uh about sorry T the um AP classes and I'd like us to start working on that at the policy committee and I'd talk to you and we'll
057probably start doing that in February because we need a policy about freshman and AP classes this is where case where there's not not a policy and the district has said they're open but they're actually not not open um so Patty in the mean time I'll work with you on what that might look like yeah that's okay okay and thank you for bringing it and I'm sorry I forgot about it I know that's fine you got a lot on your okay and we're adjourned e