CorpusRecord 145453

2025-01-07 Board of Education Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PPS Board of Education
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Multnomah County, OR
Material
Transcript
Extent
25,071 words · about 140 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right let's get [Music] started we're just missing Andrew yeah can't start without him on his last director Scott where's director Scott all right let's get started you ready sir Cara are you ready okay all right this regular let me start all over this public regular meeting of the board of education for January 7th 20124 is called to order all items being considered this evening are posted on the PPS website under the board and meetings tab this meeting is being streamed live on PPS TV services website and on Channel 28 and will be replayed throughout the next two weeks please check the district re website for replay times good evening and welcome thank you for all being here this evening before we get started uh a couple housekeeping reminders uh um we ask everyone at

002this meeting tonight members of the public staff and board members treat each other with respect we are excited that you have taken the time out of the day to watch this boring meeting hopefully I'm just kidding um take time I get involved in our school district uh whether testify or just observe uh if you wish to display signs and or banners please hold those below chin level so as not to block any attendees view behind you of the proceedings for safety reasons we also need to keep all walkways and aisles clear and General we would appreciate if everyone can be mindful of others in the room uh I want to give a update on where we are with filling director Scott's uh soon to be vacant board seat uh in zone one as you all

003know we have three outstanding candidates who have applied for the seat uh chrisy split Jasmine Reese and Jackie wors we are scheduled to interview and vote next Monday January 13th in terms of the format I am proposing the following each candidate will be given the opportunity to give a two-minute opening statement then each board member and student representative will ask a question of the candidate will have two minutes to answer at the conclusion of the board asking questions each each board member will be allowed to ask a follow-up question of which the candidate will have one minute to answer at the conclusion of the interviews we will then each cast a vote a Voice vote at the dice uh each board member will be given two interview questions to choose from to ask the candidates

004I have asked that Miss Powell uh email those to you and for you to let her know which one you want to ask is there are there any questions about this process do you want to clarify that we're asking um everyone the same questions so we compare apples to apples yes part of the reason for doing this is so that we we have a uniform process for each candidate um asking the just a quick question um just given happened last week with the city um and we'll have an even number of um board members are I'm assuming we're requiring a um candidate to get a majority of what would be a quorum of the board versus a majority of the votes yes it would be I think so they need to have four laws state

005that they need to four okay not not a majority of the and chair Wong just for clarity are we asking them the questions that were on the application are these separate questions uh on the application yeah I believe so um I don't know if we added any more um however if if you do have suggestions for questions I think it's fine to send that to uh Miss Powell um who can then send it to the rest of the board to to decide if we would like to include that in the interview yeah I think the idea here is to kind of give them a chance a to say it publicly and also maybe perhaps to expand upon uh some of their answers does that help clarify any other questions okay barly no um all right

006next up is election of board leadership uh May 2021 the board adopted a process by which board members could be considered for board leadership positions the resolution states that in order to be considered for a leadership position board members must notify the board manager in writing by December 1st that they plan to run for the board leadership in the January election at the last meeting in December both uh Vice chair depass and I both indicated that we would like to continue in our role as Vice chair and chair respectively there are no other were no other submissions do we need to take a vote on that because this is a resolution all right uh 7025 would you like a motion yes do I have a motion uh second to adopt resolution 7025 I move that

007we adopt resol resolution 7244 five two5 two5 second thank you we have uh director brim Edwards motions and director Sullivan seconds so any board discussion M Brash any public comment no the board will now vote on uh 7025 election of board chair all in favor please indicate by saying yes yes yes yes yes all opposed please indicate by saying no Student representating kavi please indicate your vote yes thank you um the resolution 7025 is approved by a vote of 7 to zero with student representative canav unofficially voting yes next we have the resolution to consider the election of uh director Michelle to pass as board Vice chair do I have a motion and second to adopt resolution 7026 so moved director Bren M wordss moves director Holland seconds election of board by chair is there

008any board discussion M BR braa any public comment no board will now vote on 7026 election of a board Vice chairperson all in favor please indicate by saying yes yes yes yes all poos please indicate saying no uh student representative con please indicate your vote Yes resolution 7026 is approved by a vote of 7 to Zer with student representative canav unofficially voting yes next up we have the superintendent uh report uh superintendent Armstrong would you like to give your report yeah absolutely good evening chair members of the board Community I'm excited to bring forth my super inent report for the uh start of the new year I think it loaded there we go there we go the very first thing um I want to do sorry I skipped the slide not sure can we get

009some text support so we can watch it in front of us very go all right I think I have the control now I don't know I'm just pointing anywhere it is January which is School Board recognition month and so I want to pause in publicly thank our school board members for their service thank you for being a part of Portland Public Schools [Applause] we look forward to finding multiple ways to recognize and honor you this month and at your chairs you walked into a gif with some Portland Bling That to remind you where you're at and who you serve so thank you as you all know I every report I talk about the first 100 days of school plan and our priorities our final Community transition team meeting is January 23rd 2025 I typically highlight

010an item for each priority area but tonight I want to do something a little different and I want to talk about improving education for American Indian and Alaskan native students here in Portland Public Schools I have appreciated the call to action and the reminder from our students from our families and from community that we're doing we're not doing enough and that um there is a history a failure and repair that needs to happen and I hope that some of these items that I list out that were prepared to take action on immediately begins to address uh some of those things this report is also linked into the uh school board agenda under superintendent report I want to start off with academic support now we will continue to dedicate uh 600,000 in our PPS budget with

011our resj partners that has programs that prioritize native students by grounding and support and culturally relevant ways um of being and the priority has been students in the Cully neighborhood we'd also like to announce that we're enhancing academic support we are immediately dedicating funds for an additional 100 hours of tutoring for our students ensuring academic achievement and cultural connection remain priorities and so the parent committee will have access to allocate those tutoring hours as they see fit next will ensure investment in Native curriculum and projects in the 2025 Bond we have earmarked of the funds already allocated 1.1 million to ensure curriculum resources including portfolio projects be included that celebrate and preserve native history culture and and the contributions and these are items that will um be developed and um um brought forth with input

012from the community in addition we will hire a tribal liaison so to deepen our partnership with Native families and to ensure sustained engagement for the upcoming 252 School 26 school year uh we plan to put that position in place and we look forward to continued Community coll collaboration we want to strengthen Pathways and relationships so in partnership with the community we want to establish clear K12 Pathways that start with the programs that we already have in place with our Litt list Learners we also plan to develop professional learning priorities so in partnership with our tribal liaison position that will um start at July 1 at the start of of the um next academic year will'll develop mandatory professional learning opportunities for all of our staff and we do believe that it's important to create spaces

013for programs and we recognize the importance of providing safe and welcoming spaces and we believe that we have the capacity to do that in some of our modernized buildings now I took a look at our numbers and right now we serve our American Indian students we have 1,771 and for Alaska native students we currently serve 183 and these are identified and we also have heard from community that there are still students yet to be identified so that's a total of over 1900 students further when I dug deeper into the data I found just the first three high schools um well I guess I'm not naming the high schools in three of our high schools we serve respectively about 300 students and so what's clear to us is that with 19 00 students across our C

014system we can afford to have multiple centers located in our modernize redesign buildings to be able to welcome and create space that our community has asked for and then I want to just say personally it's important to me that we do this work together and in community that we rise together that we partner and co-create a process that honors the voices and reflects the unique needs of native families and students and we stand ready to meet with community on March 3rd 2025 at 6m to discuss the work to discuss the tribal liaison position the 1.1 million in curriculum and other items and also an aggressive timeline so that we can come together in community and begin to move think what I will say lastly is that I believe in our schools I believe in our

015teachers I believe in our students and I believe in our community and I do believe that we have what we need in Portland to move work forward now that obviously means maybe establishing uh more positions as time and budget allows over time but but we're confident that we can take action immediately and not wait it's clear to us that we have fail to serve and respond to the needs of our native community and and I just want to declare tonight that we are ready to take action immediately to begin that work in many of our spaces and with that Together We rise as I continue to say Is our commitment for moving this work forward thank you chair chair Wong I have a question uh superintendent uh Armstrong thanks for sharing that um list of

016items that um you're bringing forward were those co-created with the Indian parent Community or the native Community all of those items were a direct response to requested items that was outlined in the letter um that was submitted by the Indian parent committee so from the academic supports with mentoring from the curriculum resources and a allocation of funds for that um I know in the original report there were um three op options the first was a standalone building and then two other options were to collocate in a modernized space um a native Ed Center and I believe that we're um prepared to to do that in a in a modernized building that we already have that we don't need to wait for a building to be built to begin the work that needs to happen for

017our native students but their their proposal was place where those things could could happen so I'm curious did um yeah there were three options was a list when you formulated it was it done in consultation with the group it it was a response to items that were listed so in the original letter there were three options the first was um a standalone building the second was to um collocate um or actually option two and three were Co locate I think one of them listed was Jefferson but since Jefferson isn't modernized and we believe that we have modernized spaces and because we serve over 1900 native students across our district that um there isn't a place identified on that list because it was clear to community that they wanted to come together and identify a place

018in um in collaboration uh with with us so while I'm not naming a spot I do know that as we know we have modernized facilities and we want to prioritize some of those ass we have modernized facilities with a commercial kitchen we have modernized facilities with a gymnasium we have U modernized classrooms with learning spaces and classrooms that can definitely house and support the request that was in the letter um that was written by um interim director uh chair Brown great thank you for that great report all right um next up we have our student representative report uh student representative would you like to give your report yes all right good evening everyone it's great to see a pack packed crowd so after two weeks you know our students you know are coming back from

019school just adjusting to the regular school life and I want to share some amazing highlights that we've been H that have been happening at our schools so Jefferson will be hosting a Ral recital at January 16th P will be holding a showcase at Franklin High School at January 17th and today Markham students were welcome back to their school [Applause] yeah last month superintendent Armstrong joined me at McDaniel for lunch we had a great opportunity for me to share some concerns I've been hearing from students regarding the phone policy student safety and Facilities it's been great to hear her ongoing efforts to build trust with our community teachers and students as we all know student voice is important and we need to Center in our practice and it's really honored and grateful to here that their

020superintendent really prioritized that and I look forward to seeing her new initiatives about that I'm glad that we had a chance to go in a lunch line you know have be a student and to also just hear the energy in a lunch I I'm so sorry we are truly privileged to have superintendent Armstrong as our superintendent recently I attended a national student board member Association which was a webinar about Communications and student engagement it was great to learn about all the activities and initiatives they have and how I can bring that back to PPS as we all know we've been discussing the phone policy I want to acknowledge the student voice and their consistent and persistent voice during October we shared a survey we heard from over 2,000 students and as a student who always

021runs surveys it is not easy to get their feedback and it was very clear to hear from students that they supported having more of a flexible policy that would allow students to have their phones during lunchtime one of the concerns we heard was safety we know for lots of our students who eat off campus and their school communities they don't feel unsafe and another point is I think with our current policy we have it would require Yonder pouches and for example Yonder pouches would cost over $700 and $25,000 during a year where we having an upcoming budget deficits of over 40 million that is concerning that's why myself and the district stent council is supporting a more of an equitable model that would cost 8,000 that would also recognize what students have shared with us

022and also be supportive of what our students need now I would like to welcome the McDaniel District student council representative Clara okay uh hi everyone my name is Claire Ren Gordon and I am the District student council representative at McDaniel High School I stand before you today to voice the concerns of the students that I represent while I agreed that a much stricter approach of phone use in schools is important for the well-being of our students education I do not believe that a districtwide all day phone band including lunch especially one through costly Yonder pouches will achieve this goal as a student of the second most diverse School in Oregon I've witnessed firsthand the varying needs of our student body we come from different backgrounds with different experiences and we learn in different ways our

023school Community thrives when we have access to a range of curricula and activities that cater to these diverse needs what we need most right now is more opportunities and resources resources that would better serve the academic emotional in social needs of our students rather than a costly policy that may harm the very thing that it seeks to protect we all know that yonder pouches are extremely expensive but my concern is not just about the cost it's about how that money could be better spent at McDaniel our school Community has experienced loss of Staff members elective options and so much more due to budget cuts our school cannot afford any more costly policies at the expense of our students education think of the time the funding and the energy that could be directed towards enriching educational

024experiences at our PPS schools at McDaniel we already have a phone policy in place as JJ showed it's just not consistently enforced and I would argue that it's presented and framed in a way that encourages students to oppose the policy rather than understand the value of reducing phone usage in the classroom if we were to better utilize the resources we already have instead of spending money and wasting resources on an initiative that the district can't afford the status quo would be much more effective as a community we must reflect on why we why we are even considering such a drastic measure in pursuit of a better education for our students I understand that there will be a new F phone policy no matter what but I believe that choosing a policy that restricts phones rather

025than teaching students how to navigate the world we live in with phones can end up being more harmful than helpful in other words choosing a phone ban over students resources is not an option I care about Student Success this new policy is going to heavily impact the environment of our schools no matter what and I urge all of you to pick a policy where students are supported not restricted we can do better than this thank you are you done are you that is all thank you so much um next we have uh public comment uh first we will start with student comments U Miss Brasa do you have any student sign up I do Tate seagull Anna rosan caty Rivera and Clara Ron Gordon thank you um as you all are coming up to the

026podium um the board thanks you for taking the time to to attend this meeting and providing your public comments public input especially from our students is uh super important and improves our work we look forward to hearing your thoughts and Reflections um just kind of quick reminder our Board office may follow up on board related issues raised during public testimony uh we request that complaints about individual employees be directed to superintendent's office as a Personnel matter uh for materials you like to re board to receive pleas hand them over to miss Bradshaw um and if there's any additional materialss or items you would like us to have you can also email them to public comment all onew pps.net um when you begin your comments just make sure you clearly state your name and spell your

027last name you'll have three minutes to speak um after three minutes you'll hear a sound which means you have kind 30 seconds to wrap up thank you may hello my name is Anna rogus r o g o s y n I am an eighth grader at SW Middle School I will be a freshman at Cleveland High School this fall I a softball and soccer player and have played in The Cleveland you softball league since fifth grade and played socer since kindergarten participating in sports has brought me together with my community and made me a stronger Made Me Stronger I am really excited to join the Cleveland softball team but don't understand why players on the Cleveland baseball team have more field access as a softball player I will have to travel to two miles to

028Woodstock Park to practice I'm not sure how how I will get to practice after school right now Cleveland High School softball team also has to travel the IW Wells hitting bar into practice why should there be different access at different schools are we all part of Portland Public Schools as a Cleveland High School soccer player I'll will be sharing the one tur field with two football teams and eight soccer teams and will be forced to practice before school or late at night as a female athlete I think this is unfair and does not support women's Athletics I have learned about Title 9 and in my opinion the treatment of women's Athletics at Cleveland is a clear violation many of my friends at s do not want to attend Cleveland because of poor athletic conditions and

029thoughts that the school is old and run down I am asking you as school board members to please support women's Athletics at Cleveland High School and improve access to field space for our teams please Turf P par so we have a space to practice and play across the street from school just like the baseball team and other p schools including turf at Park and fully funding moning ization for Cleveland High School will have huge impact on kids in southeast Portland Who currently do not have equal opportunities than other kids in Portland thank [Applause] you good evening to you all I'm Kira Guzman r i v r i hyphen guu Z M I'm a sophomore at Cleveland High School and president of the Native Student Union there I am also an enrolled member of the Indian

030education program I am a descendant of the shishoni benic tribes of foral Idaho I also in part Puerto Rican and Mexican I'm here a second time to again provide my perspective as to why PPS should support a native Student Success Center I am both disappointed and angered that I have to be here a second time to advocate for the support my community needs however I am here again because I know that the native students in PPS need this I had hoped that our original request would be welcomed and supported by the board instead it has been it has been ignored and cast aside we don't need just additional tutoring or a tribal liaison we need to be part of the decision- making in every Point our people come from a long history of broken promises

031and our importance and unique needs being overlooked this is why we are asking for a commitment in the bond that will force the school board to act for our native community the decision to not even include the discussion of what would strengthen our community and our faith in PPS to do right by native students shows a lack of commitment by the district this past week I took a trip to M reservation where I was able to meet students of my age and background to live there I noticed the rich community and connection there was between the students I noticed that they all had in common their passion and ties to their culture and they could share that with each other I do not have that here I am the President and only only current member

032of the Native Student Union at Cleveland with only my adviser to to connect with about my culture I feel culturally isolated and at times invisible um because I don't have students who share the same cultural heritage as me a native Student Success Center would bring me the cultural connection and sense of belonging that I and all the native community in PPS has been needing and asking for Portland is home to one of the largest urban Native American populations in the US there are an estimated 60,000 Native Americans who call Portland home and they represent more than 380 tribal affiliations the diversity within our own native Community is significant and in an urban environment it is much more difficult for native people to stay culturally connected being away from our traditional homelands the Student Success Center

033would provide a space for our PPS native students to stay connected with and informed on their culture we know students with strong cultural connections and positive racial ident have higher self-esteem are more likely to graduate high school and are less likely to consume drugs and alcohol with your support we can build this space to Center the needs of our native students and allow them to be both culturally and academically successful the relationship between the native community and education is complex and steeped in mistrust I have three generations of boarding school attendees in my immediate family every other native's family has similar stories Portland Public Schools has the opportunity to Shi this narrative by listening to the native community and supporting our ask for Native Student Success Center May I please finish yeah yeah finish I

034ask you to please consider our proposal and add it as a line item in the upcoming Bond whatever is in that Bond I promise you the that the native Community has been waiting much longer for the educational needs of native students to be prioritized thank you for hello everyone my name is at mdle I startd like to thank PPS and the school for giving me the opportunity to speak here my goal in the next few minutes is to educate those who are unaware of boys volleyball and to advocate for players within theps Community boyb is of the Sports in the country and for good reason volleyball reques team ey coordination strength andal tness through all this comes a fun and exting sport that benefits all aspect of the human body bothal and mental but there

035are others survey or who played scho volb the last years us% of those boys played no other sports in high school this suggests that this emerging sport is reaching kids hav EXP the excit of being on a team and getting involved in funtivities at school and we know that students who particip in areed gryb then in october23 I andal students spoke at an OSAA assembly advocating for high school boys volleyball in Oregon the sport was unanimously as an emerging activity last year and this year we're hoping that OSAA approves boys volle as an official High School support next year ultimate goal today is to get as many athle directors and PPS schools as possible onard and register their respective schools I play on a volleball team and I know there are many many kids across

036the district who want to play all it takes is one student at school to spread the word but it needs School support as well individuals or as a school board to help promote this effort would be greatly appreciated thank you to the school board for giving me the opportunity to speak about the importance andits of supporting volleball and to get approv and offal support PPS schools thank you thank you all of you very well done all right next up we have uh general public comment U BR do we have anyone signed up yes Tyler Willow Dwayne Thomas Susan schler menen Ricardo Ruiz as you all are making your way up um just kind of quick reminder um I won't repeat the the previous guidelines but I just want to remind if there are PPS staff

037or giving public comment uh that they may not provide testimony about students that could violate confidential confidentiality protections under furpa uh this includes testimony using information that could identify students especially in their school Community by use of their direct or indirect linkages such as school grade spe special education or other status thank you for uh making here today for public comment you may begin I'm Taylor I uh my name is t a y l o r w l l auau Taylor wallow um good evening I'm here to read a comment which was written collaboratively on behalf of the community members who have been harmed by PPS policies and therefore may not have the capacity to attend these meetings as a reminder Palestinians have been under a brutal siege for 15 months infants are now dying

038of hypothermia and starvation each day a clear sign of ethnic cleansing and action among hundreds of Martyrs who have been killed with our tax dollars in the past two weeks alone are five Palestinian journalists they were murdered in a clearly marked press van outside of Al Al AA Hospital while one was awaiting the birth of his child this genocide did not begin on October 7th but 77 years ago and the Imperial project of Israel has always been backed by other Empires like the US who rely on it as a proxy for Western interests in Biden's words if there were not an Israel the US government would have to invent one to maintain its superpower status so why is it that in a nation defined by imperialism our schools refuse to provide students with an education

039on this subject we encourage everyone in this room to familiarize yourself with the PPS genocide education timeline in it you will find an established pattern of repression censorship and neglect the most recent iteration of this pattern is an administrative directive on Art and other visual representations in District buildings 3304 ad which was published in August 2024 it states content on classroom walls bulletin boards and otherwise displayed in the classroom must be related to the curriculum those spaces cannot be used for an employees personal expression whether that is related to a political or personal issue the district fails to Define what constitutes a political or personal issue and therefore subject staff to discrimination by administrators in effect the directive legitimizes the discriminatory racist Zionist censorship by administrators in the 2023 to 24 school year that had

040not before been backed by policy using this directive the district has cracked down even harder this year not just on Palestine related curriculum but any public display of support for Palestine a PPS teacher of color was told to remove a shirt with the statement from The River To The Sea Palestine will be free and given a replacement shirt the teacher received an email from their principal that included a forwarded directive for administrators to ban staff from wearing clothing with the words from the river to the Sea Palestine will be free which is in fact a call for an end to the genocide and occupation of Palestine a white teacher wore the same shirt at the same school and never received redirection District employees know what they're doing which is why they have heavily redact emails

041related to this topic when they comply with public records requests there are no more universities in Gaza there are no open schools just as the US government has always attempted to erase the histories of black people and Indigenous populations Israel and the US are actively attempting to erase the humanity of Palestinians in Palestine and the diaspora rather than ensuring access to exploitative military careers via the JC this board should ensure access to a liberatory education until then we'll continue to voice our demands to this board condemn the genocide condemn the genocide in Palestine provide protect swana community members and let us teach Palestine the others that were called you want me to recall their names uh yes please Dwayne Thomas Susan schickler Moen and Ricardo R last call guess they figured out their better things

042to do on Tuesday night um all right uh next up we have um our Union Partners I believe P president Bonia is here and do we have any others ohing all over the place um hello uh Bor and uh superintendent thank you so much for having me um as always I want to start off with Kudos um and I'd like to give a Kudos uh to trise Brown Warren and the entire Markham staff for their return to their building after most almost a full year at Jackson a Middle School uh they had a lot of work to do and they even had one extra day after we came back from winter break to prepare for their students um so their classrooms are ready to welcome kids when we toured the building um before winter break

043as they were still fixing things and you know putting whiteboards up there were several whiteboards that still had the schedule from January for or from the December before uh the storm that shut down their school so it was quite emotional to be over there and see these spaces that they had poured so much into um now rebuilt uh so I'm just very excited for them and uh kudos for all the work uh their principal did to get them back in their building and get them the supports and supplies that they need as well as all the staff and Educators who put in the work to welcome their students um I wanted to first off just speak to uh the bond very quickly um I am very much in support of us having a bond and

044our city passing a bond for our high schools um and for the improvements um that are necessary to maintain healthy and safe schools for our students I understand that the bond is is written in a way that would allow for the buildings to be built with the same specs um as close to on budget as possible and if there is anything left over that buildings will be improved um and so we're hoping folks can get everything they can um at a reasonable price so we can improve some of our other buildings um but wanting to make sure that our Cleveland Community and our idab Wells Community get the same high quality educational experience and and school that all of our other high schools did and maybe even a little bit better because I know there's

045some things we'd like to improve um I think is crucial and so I look forward to them getting the same um if not better than all of our other schools uh and hoping that we can do it on or under budget so that we can improve our other schools that are really struggling um you know I understand some folks concerns about the costs and the bond and why are we asking our community to fund this and I want to remind folks that I think everyone would love to not have a bond to see if we can have a quality public education building for our students we'd like to just get that money from the state um but because of measure five and measure 50 this is the route we have to take um and our

046city and our community has consistently voted to give our students our Educators um and our staff the school facilities that they need and so I look forward to seeing them do that again with this Bond um and I think there there is also a light to at the end of the tunnel um the governor's proposed budget and the press release shared that uh the strike we had in our city really made them understand the the the urgency behind the issue with school funding um she is asking for billions more and I know our district and our and our Union P are going to be advocating for fully funding to the Quality education model um because we have to ask Kai to get what we need um um and so I do for the first time

047um have a little bit of hope that I I haven't had in a while um and I hope that I have hope that we can get a fully funded school system and I have hope that we can have our Visual and Performing Arts Educators our PE Educators our Career and Technical education uh providers uh able to stay or increase their Staffing over the next few years um and I hope that our community will pass this bond to support all of our students and Educators um but hope for me is not something that is passive it is an active thing right so it it comes only with work and dedication so it's time for all of us to get to work to be in Salem advocating for those funds advocating for a removal of the special

048education cap on funding so that we can actually provide those services our students are entitled to legally um as well as free up funds for all all of our students to get the education that they deserve um so I'm looking forward to getting to work with all of you so that we can uh get great public schools for every Portland student thank you thank you president B all right um next up we have the resolution to affirm rights of undocumented students and protocol for immigration and custom enforcement ice access to schools our first action item this evening is the resolution to affirm the rights of undocumented students and protocols for immigration and custom enforcement also known as ice access to schools uh Vice chair to pass would you like to introduce his resolution um sure

049uh thank you chair Wong um one of the reasons that I requested that the board consider passing a resolution which affirms one that the board passed in 2016 is that we know that upcoming changes in Immigration enforcement may lead to concern and feelings of uncertainty for some of our students and families we want our students to feel safe and our administrators and staff to feel safe in our buildings and that's why this is coming before uh the board um superintendent Armstrong would you like to um speak to this right absolutely and I appreciate that the issue is raised and um there is a potential for increased activity involving our immigrant students in their families and so um we have Chief of Staff Dr John Franco and Dr uh chief of schools I'm sorry okay I

050just put you in another position I'm sorry Deborah um chief of schools Dr John Franco and Dr Renard Adams our chief accountability and Equity officer to share with you how we are supporting our students and families at this time great thank you good evening directors stud director as a staff we are recommending to adopt resolution 730 which is by its nature similar to the resolution 5363 that the board adopted in 2016 with the potential for increased activity involving our immigrant students and families we reviewed uh resolution 5363 and updated it to reflect current practices resolution 7030 is the result under resolution 7030 PPS will follow all applicable laws including the laws designating schools as sanctuaries for students PPS staff have been active in conversations with Community Partners including Moma County mesd legal aid Latino uh

051Latino Network ACLU and also the Mexican consulate and other jurisdictions as well as other districts to coordinate around messaging so that our families and students know their rights PPS has sent letters to families and staff acknowledging the concern and distributing information and resources you're all send copies of this correspondence if you didn't get it or if you need it to be resent please let me know or ranne that'd be great uh we have also posted information and resources on our website we have and will conduct trainings uh with senior directors of schools and assistant superintendents with school administrators with pfsp staff front office staff especially uh other school-based trainings will include counselors college career coordinators um Community agents um potentially even uh ptas those types of things anybody who has direct contact with students uh

052District legal council that includes uh Mary Kane in partnership with the office of student support services and Safety and Security are taking the lead on these trainings and um and also um general counsel Sharon ton cray so with that I don't know if Dr Adams you have anything to add but Dr Adams and I and also U Sharon tonry are here to answer any questions you may have thank you before we discuss Let's uh put this on the table do I have a motion in a second to adopt resolution 7030 resolution to affirm rights of undocumented students and protocols for immigration and custom enforcement access to schools so moved second directed to pass moves and director Holland second seconds is there any board discussion or questions I have I just have a question I heard

053you mention ptas and so would the district be providing training all across the spectrum of people that need training including ptas yeah that was a conversation that we had just this past week with senior directors as we were uh talking about who were kind of the student facing level folks that we needed to potentially provide trainings for so if that were the case then it would be yes also we'd be very specific to given um the populations of students where we know they're potentially um where this could come up and that's and we' prioritize that that'd be great it'd be great to have some in different languages if that's uh helpful and also um a train the trainer might be helpful so you're not doing these one-off trainings rather you're training a group of people

054that can then serve as Community Advocates thank you so oh yeah I do I have something to say um I wasn't on the board the last when this the original one was uh done um I was actually teaching a group of uh girls basketball uh seventh grade girls basketball team and and I never played basketball so that tell you how how low the bar was um and when the climate has CH changed I remember those girls coming in to practice crying the fear that they had um the uncertainty that they had you can see it in their face and we're talking about kids right and you know that was a profound effect on me because I'm looking at these girls that I have been coaching for a year and a half now or two years

055now they were seventh graders and um it was devastating you know we really had to sit down and talk um and so I you know I I think you know I wrot little something I think this is a travesty that we even need a resolution like this you know protecting our kids all of our kids should be a given this should not even be necessary every child regardless of immigration status has the right to feel safe respected and supported in our schools yet here we are forced to reaffirm BAS B humanity and protect students from fear of enforcement agencies that have no place in our classrooms or our schools let's be clear this resolution is not about politics this is about doing what is right and I am delighted I when I seen this come

056up um my heart smiled I'm delighted that we're standing for uh children when they need us the most because when you look in those kids eyes as I did when I was coaching them it it's it's something that I wish no kid ever ever have to encounter or go through so I just want to thank us for doing this and know that we're going to do whatever we can to protect our students [Applause] period I just did you win any games we actually won the uh the C Championship nice that year yes I was co- coach so I don't want to take the credits go ahead director Sol it oh no I was just ready to say yes yeah um you I just want to just say you know this during this era if it

057does get tough again just remember to have moments of Grace I remember as a teacher I had a student who after this happened first time uh was late every class and I remember asking why um trying to you know assuming that something was going on and it was because the kid had to take care of the the family do the groceries cook all the breakfasts for all the other kids because they're afraid that um one of the the caretaker of the house the grandma would be deported so it even if the students are not um it does impact the family um I just have a quick question is it possible to just got a get a really brief bullet point points about the differences between this resolution and the previous resolution it's replacing just a

058quick highlight yeah I what I would say is if you if you look at the current resolution 730 I would say there's more specifics around not only federal law but Oregon law in particular a lot of citations from that Vantage Point uh and it's more specific I think if you look at the previous resolution which I have now is um not as specific and so that's what I appreciate about this current one thank you and thanking thank you for putting all the work in this any other board discussion or questions yeah I have a question I know you shared um training will happen for teachers and Educators and other staff will also include Community Partners yes yes and Dr Adams could talk a little bit more about that but we but the piece is like

059what the family engagement as well that's where we really would want our Community Partners to be involved because there are pieces that we're doing with staff but the community pieces are where we would want our Community Partners to be really forward facing with them we and we're talking about like know your rights types of meetings with uh with the community great thank you for your work um the board will now vote on resolution 730 resolution to affirm rights of undocumented students and protocols for immigration Customs Enforcement access to schools all in favor please indicate by saying yes I'm sorry to interrupt we do have public comment on this topic oh thank you uh my bad um public comment we have Mall rasa and Anna aru Aro which I probably said wrong I'm sorry my is

060Rasa r a b ASA I'm a parent at bont middle school and rler Elementary where also the chair of equity and advocacy for f the regler our school PTA I'm the daughter of immigrants a bilingual educator and a proud resident of the colie neighborhood in northeast Portland yeah colie in uh mid December fellow parent Anna and I uh circulated an open letter to you all and to other PPS leaders in that letter we called for Urgent action to protect uh undocumented students and their families in light of the incoming Federal administration's anti-immigration stance the letter was signed by by over as of today 473 PPS community members including staff administrators parents caregivers students and neighbors representing nearly 70 schools across the district these almost 500 signatories which included several School PTA boards shared Our concern

061about PPS is apparent silence on the rights of undocumented students in the wake of the November 5th federal election while we were very encouraged by the communication released by PPS just before the winter break and the draft resolution sign signicantly that was presented here tonight we remain concerned because of the urgency for preparing for whatever policies executive orders or actions may come following the inauguration of the incoming president which as we all know is in just 13 days we're here tonight to speak in support of resolution 7030 uh while we trust that you will all vote to support this and approve this resolution we want to emphasize what we believe are two essential and Urgent points related to that resolution the first is this while the policies outlined in this resolution are vital PPS must

062immediately take action to commit adequate resources and energy to ensure the robust and Rapid implementation of item number five of the resolution which states that PPS will and I quote provide training and guidance to school staff with the assistance of Community Partners on how to respond to ice Personnel who are requesting information about PPS staff students and families and or attempting to enter PPS property end quote in November 2016 the board approved a similar resolution as we've heard of about tonight 5363 which stipulated a concrete time frame this is one of the biggest distinctions between the two resolutions uh which stated that that within 90 days the development of such a plan for training would be enacted we're concerned by the absence of such language in the new resolution and urge the board to move

063swiftly to make a public commitment to a timeline for this essential training and guidance work the second Point item number five also states that quote the district will provide information about rights and protections and support for possibly impacted families PPS must immediately take action to support community and immigrant Le education and mutual Aid efforts related to rights and do so in a manner that promotes understanding that the protection of undocumented students and families is a matter of collective care and is a shared responsibility that must not fall solely on the potentially impacted Community knowing the rights of undocumented immigrants is everyone's responsibility so we're here to ask tonight how will resolution 7030 and especially item number five be enacted when specifically and with what resources will staff and families receive the training guidance and education

064necessary to make this resolution effective we're grateful to hear some of that uh but we really want to insist that PPS must materially reaffirm its pronounced commitment to racial equity and Social Justice by nurturing and creating an explicitly pro-immigrant anti-racist School District with the full implementation of this resolution thank you hello my name is Anna aduo A R A UJ o I am a parent at Creston Elementary and Sunnyside environmental school I am the child of immigrants as well and who both worked in my local public school district in service sector jobs I am a resident of southeast Portland and have taught for more than a decade about issues of cultural diversity and social inequality like my fellow parent I am here tonight to speak in support of resolution 7030 while we trust that you

065will all vote to approve this resolution we again want to draw attention to item number five in the resolution in particular we want to ask what concrete plans and material commitments the district has made to ensure that all PPS staff receive the necessary training and guidance to make every School site a safe space of learning and work for every everyone as a public institution dedicated to education PPS has the skills resources and infrastructure in place to implement a widespread Education and Training Implement widespread Education and Training about relevant rights policies and practices a resolution on its own will do very little what we need is a robust and Urgent plan of action to make every school building a site of preparedness awareness and Community safety as we enter the new political climate that will be

066formally ushered in on January 20th policies and resolutions are only affected effective if they are backed by material resources and concrete commitments to action resolution 7030 is an important statement of the district's commitments but it will only be effective if the education training and preparation outlined in item number five is prioritized and deployed immediately and fully outward facing policies that affirm pp's power to resist Isis incursion into our communities and schools are important but what is more impactful is the difficult and resource intensive inward-facing work of educating training and preparing our schools to protect defend and uplift The Immigrant families that are integral to PPS PBS must materially reaffirm its pronounced commitment to racial equity and Social Justice by nurturing and creating an explicitly pro-immigrant anti-racist School District with the full implementation of resolution 7030

067by doing so PPS will assert our community level commitment to Oregon's status as a sanctuary State and align our district with a national movement towards Sanctuary for undocumented community members thank you thank you both um I'm wondering if we could um ask John um to come back and say what is actually being done specifically okay Dr Franco are you being recalled so I'm happy to talk right now specifically about some of the things that we that are currently happening and then we'll get back to you with more specifics in regards to more details because right now we're also identifying like I said pertinent other folks including PT Community agents those types of things so we first are starting off guidance counselors have been trained counselors have been trained College and Career coordinators we had a

068training with senior directors and assistant superintendents this Thursday we're having uh a principal training and all building leaders within cohorts the expectation is that they're going to deliver that training schoolwide and then um other pertinent pieces will happen with other pertinent stakeholders um as I mentioned and I'll get more details to you in regards to who those people are and what that timeline looks like thank you I also saw that there's been some intergo governmental work as well done yes highlight that I think we're all excited to get this on the table um there's no more public comment correct correct not correct okay all right um the board will now vote on resolution 7030 resolution to affirm the rights of undocumented students and protocols for Immigration and Customs Enforcement access to schools all in favor

069please indicate by saying yes yes yes yes all opposed please indicate by saying no are the extensions student representative kavi please indicate your vote a strong yes very strong yes with a vote of seven to zero with a very strong yes from student representative canavi unofficially voting yes um pass this thank you you everyone I'm Cloud all right uh next we have the resolution authorizing operating agreement between um without sorry with Albina Vision Trust uh we'll be voting on this on February 20 2024 the Portland Public Schools Board of Education approved resolution 6861 authorizing PPS to prepare for the sale of the Dr Matthew profit education center resolution 6861 directed that a timeline be identified developed to identify a new headquarters in you Warehouse site within 12 months that could be acquired on among other

070terms in all in cost neutral to PPS basis so that avt could ultimately acquire the 10.5 acre PEC site in transaction that meets or exceeds the appraise value of the PC resolution 6861 um also Direct that within 60 days minimum criteria for the new headquarters and new Warehouse sites be created resolution 6861 also required a joint creation of a work plan with ABT to fulfill the objectives of the resolution Dr uh Dr Armstrong would you like anything that yeah absolutely I I just want to add that uh our staff has worked diligently over the um first 60 days and it was clear that we needed additional um expertise and work was needed to determine the uh minimum CR criteria so we're continuing in hopes that uh we'll be able to identify new locations soon and

071we have staff here to report out further so thank you for being here tonight we have a resolution 724 which authorizes us for the operating agreement with Albin Vision Trust we have been working really closely with avt over the last several months um determining what our needs are and what other school districts do and and really trying to make sure we're making the right decisions for the long run so that work's been ongoing it's we're right in the thick of it right now we'll be coming back um with report outs on that and the not to distant future so we're very excited to hopefully get the the operating agreement authorized tonight so we can continue to move on as governs our working relationship let's um get this on the table um do I have a

072motion a second to adopt resolution 7024 resolution authorizing the operating agreement with Albina Vision Trust second motion second let's just do it thank you director green moves do I have a second director Holland seconds is there I thought y'all was ready it's too late for these kind of games um is there any board discussion questions I have a quick comment just when this building was renamed a group of black community members advocated for the name to remain if there was ever a time that the building moved and I would like to just Elevate that that was an ask a strong ask knowing that this building probably wasn't going to be here forever that the name uh transfer to any new location so I just like to elevate that thank you appreciate that M BR is

073there any public questions just for clarification uh the minimum requirements and the desired features uh PPS will set both of those and approve the board yes yes okay um then I had a question I asked this in advance but I'm not quite sure I understood the answer um if this is a full cost replacement um the FF which is things used for everyday operations um that those would be covered um but my question was more around when you go deep into this building um there's lots of very customized built in features like our covered loading docks the sort of paint bins um and whole host of other things primarily in the operation side um and those would not be considered they're not desks or copers um the all-in cost um the new facility that they're

074going to cover the cost of would have all those the functionality and those features yes it'll have the same functionality not NE it may not have exactly the same features we may not need as many loading docks for example um whether or not they're covered is you know that's that's that's not typical in in Portland um but but yes all of the features all of the um components of the building that we need to carry out our daily operations and just a question and I'm going to go back to our original um resolution night where we had a um electrician who works in the building to come and um speak and I'm curious about in the establishment of the minimum criteria and the desired features how um going to integrate the um voices and the

075wisdom and experience that people use again not the desks and everything but the more um operational um equipment and features of the building how are they going to be um are they going to be part of setting the minimum criteria they're we're going through that we're just starting that process right now to do the interviews with the Department directors and their staff um to the degree you know that's appropriate in whichever Department it might be um really understand how they use the space um what you know this building's been here for 50 years what can we be doing differently or better um or what don't we have that sort of thing so we can really begin to understand at a much more detailed level what we actually need in order to do our operations um

076every day so so yes they will be in they will be involved okay and then my last question because this again was um part of the staff survey the feedback our parking or this central location part of the minimum requirements well central location is definitely a minimum requirement uh the question exactly where where is Central right because um depends on exactly where you're at and how far you're going um and parking is an ongoing discussion we know that we have a fair amount of parking here and we are unlikely to be able to replicate this level of parking somewhere else certainly not without additional cost so we are looking at what is our need for Park working um what about Transit is there ways for us to be able to support multimodal Transportation efforts things

077like that so um when we come back with the that minimum criteria we'll be addressing the parking as well yeah I thought be sure the board approves that so because my Rec elction is the staff survey had parking and the central location as like the number one issues yeah thanks I had a comment also that stuck out to me FF the fixtures furnishings and equipment and I'm pretty sure we're not going to bring desks from 1970 over to a new spot so that means new Furnishings but then I hope that we're mindful about what we do with all the old Furnishings because there's a lot of carpet and desks and equipment and furnishings here that will hopefully have second live somewhere I hope that if we've got like a highend like the steel case and

078that type of equipment that we can do their buyback programs and do the most sustainable uh we're going to have a big pile of things to get rid of here so I hope it's done in the most sustainable environmentally sustainable way appreciate that thank you yeah I want to say something before we close out but I'm never going to say something before the student because he's smarter than me thank you um for clarity will the headquarters and the warehouse be two separate locations or will they be together hasn't been fully decided yet um we're finding it difficult to find a place that where they can be co-located that would obviously be you know that would be fantastic if we could do that um probably hard to do in the city to be as centrally located

079as we need to be um as well as have both operations and uh the administrative s together that would be the goal but most likely in all honesty it'll be two two locations I I just want to and maybe we can someone can help me understand in in light of everything that we're asking for you know all this stuff we can't afford to keep this building this building is going to fall down it's it's not going to be it's not fully sustainable we don't have enough money coming in to continue to make all the maintenance requests and stuff that need to be done with this building if I'm wrong I'm I I'm just trying to put this out there so that I can get a better understanding but it is my understanding that we need

080to do something or we need to invest a lot of money a lot of money into getting this building where it needs to be at in order for us to continue to stay here which we don't have the money to do so as much as we're sitting here talking about what about this and what about that we need to poop or get off the pot because this building will fall down it is not going to stay it is not sustainable we can't financially afford to continue to keep dumping money into a building that we know is going to to be a a a Civ where it's just going to be bleeding out so we can't save it unless we're prepared to tear down and start all over ourselves we're not in a position to to

081do that so we need to hurry up in my humble opinion in my humble opinion start figuring out how to work with someone who wants to work with us so that we can get the things that we we need to get so that there can be a win-win for everyone involved or we need to stop talking about it and we need to get a lot more money together so that we can tear this building down ourselves and rebuild it back up in the Magnificent way that we see you know this building and it being because I don't see another way and so I just want to make sure that we put that out there for everyone to understand all of my colleagues all of my friends I love y'all we can go eat and all

082that other kind of stuff but this building will fall down and we don't have the money to keep it from falling down so we need to figure out what we're going to do we need to get enthusiastic about working with people that want to work with us and so that we can find a space where we can actually call home and it can benefit the community and that's that's my little humble opinion I just wanted to put that out there I just want to ask one question pigy piggy back what director green said um it's not gonna fall down right now right um 805 no no I was just joking um you can always account all right Miss Brash is there any public comment no no thank you for um presentation on the hard work

083uh the board will now vote on resolution 7024 resolution authorizing the operating agreement with Albin Vision Trust all in favor please sorry did you have a motion in a second yeah I thought we had there was a second then there was a first and then there was something over here it is on the table thank you all right uh back to business all in favor please indicate by saying yes yes yes I'll post please indicate by saying no student representative canav your vote yes thank you resolution 7024 is approved by a vote of 7 to zero with student representing canavi unofficially voting yes next up we have the uh second reading of the student use of electronic devices policy we are now uh will be voting on that today hopefully I am excited to hope

084hopefully finalize this process um I want to thank policy committee chair uh brim Edwards for your work on this and the extra time you made for public comment during our policy committee meetings um do I have a let's put this on the table do I have a motion and a second to adopt resolution 7029 resolution to adopt student use of personal electronic devices in schools so moved second director Bren medwards moves yeah and director green seconds is there any board discussion have a something I wrote for this as well um and I'm going to always advocate for our students um you know whether I agree with with what they're saying or not um I do believe you know the their voices need to be broadcasted and Amplified um so saying when we talk uh when

085we talk and create policies that truly benefit our students we cannot Overlook the power of their voice after all they're the ones navigating the reality I of our Educational Systems every day by actively involving them in the process we do more than just gather input we send a message that their perspectives are valid their experiences matter and they play a vital role in the decisions that will shape their Futures students bring unique viewpoints informed by their diverse background challenges and aspirations their ideas have the potential to identify gaps in our system and propose solutions that are more practical Equitable and effective furthermore including students in policy making empowers them with a sense of ownership over their educational Journey it Fosters a culture of engaged participation where they understand that their involvement and shaping policy isn't

086just a right but a responsibility it also provides us with a clear picture of what is working and what isn't ensuring that policies aren't created in a vacuum but are grounded in live experiences of those that they are meant to serve so I just say let's embrace the value of our students Collective voice because when we listen to our students we build a system that reflect their needs honors their voices and prepares them for a brighter more inclusive future and and reason why I say that is because when I grew when I was a kid we didn't have cell phones you know and so I don't know how many of us you know on this board as adults had cell phones and the in schools but if they're giving us their lived experiences we should

087make sure that we really pay attention and listen to their shared expens experiences because we are not living their shared experiences that's it I I know that the students all know that I'm for the uh cell phone away all day and I've had numerous students email me and by the way we're teaching students how to write very good persuasive essays and I've had also some phone calls and and my good friend here who I respect very much trying to talk me out of it I have we started this because teachers came to us and they were were so frustrated and there were teachers who were trying to keep them out you know keep the cell phones out of the classroom it wasn't working everything they did wasn't working and they said please make a policy

088that we can't so we can teach so we don't have to spend our whole time telling people to put away their cell phones so I am still the voting yes on the all day um if I if I thought it would work to have them let the students have them and just say I'm going to keep it away all day except when I'm at lunch if I really thought that would happen I would change my vote but I don't think it will happen because teachers have tried that already this year it's not happening so anyway that's where I stand student voice I really I have list listened I've listened and listened and I've seen really good arguments but I still think for the sake of the education of all of our children we need to

089get those cell phones out of the classroom thank you um I would just like to share something really quick uh because I've been in contact also with North clarus School District and they were very uh gracious in in handing uh sending me some of the data that they've gotten so this was just if you know from North clas they they've baned phone they're a little bit ahead of us um I also want to clarify that this this policy is just a policy it's just a direction it doesn't tell the district how to do something that's up for the district to decide how it wants to implement it and each school for to decide how to implement it um but the presentation that North clock Miss gave in their board meeting um if you if you

090know anything about nor clockman the beginning of the year they they ban phones all day every day or through school day um the presentation actually started out with a quote from a student and the quote from the student says this I'll just read it this has actually been pretty cool my friends and I are actually now talking to each other in the hallway between classes last year we would just come out and be on snap and then the Bell would ring and we wouldn't have even have spoken to each other I actually get to talk to my friends now now just to kind of show you off my age I have no idea what snap is um I was going to ask for a translation yeah I need a translation on this um so just

091kind of sharing some um preliminary data again I say preliminary because they collected this in October so there's only a month into school right September and then October so almost two months um they said their data showed that disruptive conduct was down 25% fighting was down 50% harassment down 133% and substance abuse down 35% 35 um they also saw a a reduction in chronic absenteeism um they also showed 86% of their students not using their phones throughout the day um 31.4% of students report increased social interactions between classmates and 20 almost 26% of students report this is student surveys by the way student reports increase ability to focus and learn better um 50% of students also reported they had more time with their teachers and students um to teach and learn so so teachers saying

092that teachers actually had more time uh to teach and learn uh sorry interact with students basically um so this is just kind of again this is just a month in and and this is kind of one of the things I want I just want to share because you know we have this this argument and one of the things is that um like like director Sullivan brought up one of the reasons we brought this up we're pushing for this is because you know teacher burnout is an all-time high um after after covid there's been an increased dependence on on phone use and and you know for good or bad there's been impact in the classroom and this is yeah this is a reaction to that but it is it is also the main purpose of doing

093this is focusing on student student achievement um recently I shared with the rest of the board or with a lot of people um there was a a study done by ward in University of Chicago um at all um called brain drain just the the it was done on college students and he tested college students and their cognitive ability and the the closer their phones were to them the worse they did on cognitive ability they compared college students by the way uh whether it was in their pocket whether it was off in their pocket whether it was on silence in their pocket whether it was on their desk or in a separate room and they showed it was a it was a significant decline in cognitive performance the closer it was to them and the easier

094more easily accessible it was um so again and the the the point of this the policy is to is it is focused on student achievement it is also focused on on teachers and being able to to teach um again is a policy there is flexibility built in the policy so that um the district can um respond to to changes and issuances which is why in in good governance it's important to make sure that the policy is built in it not necessarily General but in a in a flex written in a flexible way that's all I have to say about that thank you I just I want to thank um director BR Edwards for you you take on the tough challenges and this is almost as hard as dog parks in the 1990s in the Parks

095Bureau that was tough um and this is a tough one too and I struggled with this personally um kind of going back and forth and a actually after the break I was like okay just let the students decide whatever but the my heart is telling me different and I'm going to also vote Yes for an off and away all day it's going to be hard to enforce yes but the data is clear on on distraction and the cost of switching is great um the data from law enforcement is clear these do not make you safer in fact in an emergency you need to be hyperfocused on a trained adult in the room not on the phone putting it on Instagram or calling your mom you need to it's a it's a it's literally a safety

096issue to be on your phone in an Act of emergency and the current system isn't working it's not working for the teachers and I I say if we if we put this in place and it's really bad a year from now and people are suffering and you can't call your mom and ask if you want pasta or rice for then let's go back but for now you know I want to be outcome focused on I want to give it a try because I think it will increase outcome and social engagement and um I I as a responsible adult feel compelled to vote Yes for this because I think it will help I think it'll help student outcomes it'll help socialization and everybody will be fine without a phone for six hours we can survive that

097uh appreciate everybody's comments and also the really active engagement by all all the board in the creation of this policy um as the policy committee chair we spent about six months on this we had lots of Community input hundreds of comments from staff parents and students um there was broad agreement that we need a districtwide policy so I think that um but I'm G to focus try and focus on tonight is where there was broad agreement that we needed districtwide policy so that policies didn't vary from school to school the discipline didn't vary from school to school it didn't vary from classroom to classroom that in a PPS classroom the place for your phone was off and Away um so I'm really glad that we on that overarching topic of what was best for students

098We There was broad agreement um I also want to highlight um one place where there was not Brad agreement and um that was in relationship to high school students not middle school students but high school students um not having access to their phones during lunchtime um and part of this part of this process um I say we we had a significant amount of um feedback and a survey from teachers um but I will I want to just give a shout out to last year's and this year's um student reps uh for pushing for a student survey and a Dr Adams who worked with the students to conduct both survey and also um also a uh some student roundtables um that we had broad participation from students 2,147 student responses um to our request for students

099to to to weigh in and I'm really proud of our students because they actually were part of that Universal agreement that phones should be off and Away during during class time so our students realize the benefit of having their phones away not being distracted focusing on teaching and learning um they also advocated for appropriately serious and consistently enforced consequences for um if phones were used um and they were supportive of this um as a way to encourage adherence to the policy what they did not agree with was um the lack of access uh to their phones during non-instructional time and um you know I I I wish the outcome um tonight of the policy I'm G to be I'm G to be supportive of it but I wish the outcome of the policy had been

100um inclusive of the students point of view in terms of um letting them have access to their phone um as a parent of three um I do think there's lots of legitimate reasons um during during this school day to check in on work on Child Care on coordinating with others um I also think and um that there are times when our students when they're off campus need to have their phones when they're driving somewhere um and that makes our students safer I don't think they need in the classroom but I do think um there are other times so there was a split vote um on that and the decision was that um they'd be off and away all day um I didn't agree with that but again I'm going to support the policy I I

101do want there to I know supporting the policy and implementing it are two different things but I want us to be very cautious about the way this it's implemented um we have students who are out and about downtown all different neighborhoods in the city and as a parent I I would feel more comfortable for my student having access to their phone when they're off off campus um when I raised this at the last meeting um the the response was they can just rip it open so I'm gonna pass this down and I I know you're super strong but like you can't just rip it open and so um is there somebody who's gonna rip it open no I was laughing because A's here tonight you wrestling we're still talking about that four years later five

102years later but you can't you you can't rip this open yeah yeah so you know this this you know if somebody if a student's phone is in this house they're off campus and they need their phone they can't just rip it open so let's just be clear about that so I'm not a fan of this being the solution and or the and I know that we're not voting on that tonight or the expenditures of funds that's going to would go to one company that has a monopoly on the current technology again because I know there's other ways to keep phones off and Away during the school day so I just be very careful about our advocacy and what we're saying you know what what students can do because when I asked several people to open

103this their response when they couldn't open it was well if I got my knife out and I'm like okay or if you have Tik Tok I'm normally pocket night I'm just saying I get well that's yeah they exactly um so again we're not talking tonight about that expenditure um or how it's going to be implemented but I would hope that's a whole separate conversation um because not only are our resources scarce um but I think there's implications for our students when they're not on campus um when they don't have access to a phone but I'm going to be a yes and again I want to um thank everybody who shared their point of view um and for students um really participating in the discussion and making your voices heard um I think before I share

104my thoughts i' would like to give an opportunity to superintendent Armstrong to share her thoughts about this topic sorry well thank you I appreciate that um so yeah it's a tough one for me I I think what what I will say what I have said privately what I've said publicly is that when we ask for input and feedback from our students then we should listen um I don't support the off and Away during lunch so I guess it would be not the off and away all day I do believe that students should have access to the devices as long as we are an open campus school district for lunch then our students should have the devices I also take that position I support um obviously all of the research and all of the information that

105was collected I think what was most compelling to me is hearing from our district administrators who sat with each of our principles and shared their concerns about um the supervision and management of cell phones during lunch and the amount of resources that would go towards making sure that students do not have devices and quite honestly uh policing or monitoring if students have a phone during lunch or off campus I don't think is our priority I support the um the work about removing distractions in the classrooms during the day and I'm super excited to see what will be the results with increased achievement increased Focus um the opportunity to protect the learning environment for our teachers and I think all of that is 100% spoton in the right work I just don't see how lunch is

106considered a learning environment and so I'm not a voting person in this I appreciate you turning uh the mic over to me and I don't mind being put on the spot I um will always say what I believe to be true and um um so I guess as as it move forward if it seems as if there's already um some decisions and I will say and I apologize for this I say this respectfully I know that we still have public comment and so it is slightly concerning to hear people take positions before we've off offered other people to come to the mic because it seems as if the mine has been already made up and I just want to protect the public process if we say that this is the place where people can come

107and get feedback then we ought to to make sure that we pause and hear that feedback um but whatever the case is we will move forward in any direction that the board gives to make sure that we establish resources and appropriate appropriate support for our students and staff um in the implementation of whatever policy is adopted thank you director Scott step in front of student do we want to actually do public comment as well we're do public comment too you want to do a note I'm happy to do whatever you I mean before you give your comment to the super were you finished you have public comment all right Miss Brash we we have public comment I'm pretty sure right we do have public comment all right let's call them up all right Kaye Lynn

108corge Sanchez Bautista Ian R torto Maya PUO Von geld sorry yeah I can absolutely go first let me just make sure this in the right position am I get to go hello my name is Ian roro r i RTO and I'm a District student council representative at Ro Roosevelt High School I believe that the off andway policy during class time is the most effective way to handle phones firstly I'd like to talk about enforcement and viability to enforce something like an all day phone ban would require a large amount of resource would be y pches are extremely effective and even if the schools came up with an alternative system where they would check phones the front or take them away when they see them it would still require both substantial physical and Human Resources just

109imagine the lis Nightmare and we can't just find it in the budget and push it onto schools to support one of these systems either due to the equity problem when this happens the burden usually Falls much harder on Roosevelt Jefferson and their feeder schools because they have less resources secondly I'd like to bring up safety many students go off campus for lunch and phones are an incredible safety tool that we'd be rash to take away additionally kids deserve the right to have their phones in the event of a school shooting which are becoming frightfully common these days considering Roosevelt had a shooting just outside the school last year and Jefferson had multiple I'd like to tell my family I love them before I get shot and I'm sorry if that's not supported by some uh

110statistics from the police department but I feel that very strongly in my heart locking phones is an enormous safety hazard for that reason thirdly I'd like to bring up the educational use of phones and why it needs to be up to teach your discretion in my leadership class phones are an integral part of our classwork we need to post Tik toks film clips for announcements and many other things in some classes phones can be a very useful learning tool which is why it needs to be ultimately up to teachers because they know what's right for their classes we simply need to support teachers in their decision the other day a teacher that had previously been pretty LAX on phones came back from a break and said I've changed my mind and I'll give you a

111referral if I see it out I did not see a single phone out all day additionally I believe calculator caddies Could Be an Effective solution that balances teacher discretion safety and feasibility lastly I'd like to talk about passing periods and lunch it would be all but impossible to enforce a phone ban during passive periods or passing periods or lunch on top of being pointless and it's even harder to enforce for kids who go off campus creating a huge Equity issue for kids who have the means to go off campus for lunch it drastically increases the resource uh requirement for very little to no benefit additionally lunch is the only 30 minutes kids get every school day to themselves and maybe you're an extrovert and of the opinion that kids should be forced to interact with

112each other but what's next then will the board ban books during lunchtime I think this is a major infringement on the freedom of kids phones are undoubtedly a problem in the classroom but lunch is not learning time you may have your personal thoughts on the impact of phones on society but the fact is they are here to stay and they're significant part of kids' lives kids have their Hobbies interests and lives on the internet not to mention employment it's not fair to take that away from them if it's not interfering with their learning not only does Banning phone your use during lunchtime not improve kids' learning but it even hinders it lunch is where kids can cool down reset so socialize and get ready for the rest of the day and the fact of the

113matter is that this break will be less effective without that phones May finish my statement thus making learning less efficient for the rest of the day an off andway policy during Lunchtime with admin support and room for Teacher discretion is not only the most effective policy but the most feasible as well I know this has been a long fight but it is not over it's it's very hard to reverse or change a policy once adopted so we need to make sure we get this right I urge a very strong vote in the opposition so this policy can be amended to accurately represent the needs of the student and teaching body thank you I have to beat that good evening chair pass prend offer legal council and members of the board for the record my name

114is for San B that part is usually messed up out there I'm not here only as a McDaniel student but also as a student advisor to the Oregon State Board of Education where I represent uh students across the whole state so you can imagine the amount of students that is um I first want to highlight the families from Cleveland and Wells that are here today to advocate for their schools to make your voices heard and to push the school so thank you for showing up uh before I touch on the phone policy though I do want to mention something that director Holland mentioned about the resolution 73 um me and director Holland both reside in the C neighborhood where we both know has a very large number of immigrant families and members and so I

115appreciate that District staff brought this resolution forward and for you all passing it so thank you for that um to tou on the District phone we know that it has been a conversation among students teachers our Union partners and of course our administrators the ones that would be enforcing it um and that you have obviously provided student feedback which as Julie as director Edwards mention had about doctor sorry director commissioner director um um had about 2100 2100 responses and I gave you all statement about last month emphasizing again to reconsider think of all all other other Alternatives due to you know student feedback from teachers obviously not wanting to be any be any part of this with trying to enforce it as their you know teachers their job is to educate and that to enforce

116that's the fall of the administrators as well as the cost of things as we all are aware the $40 million deficit and um ways that school dist are just doing you know going to the stay asking for funding Etc especially with the. billion Bond and I'm again just suggesting again for an alternative to it especially with my friends and I know for sure I know people at Cleveland and not a single one of them actually put their phone that y pouch I will tell you that right now and I will tell you right now in front of you all if you were to enact like next week or after spring bre and you got y Pou I'm G put aone I tell you that right now I'm not myone I can get supension expion whatever

117it STS on but I'm not you first figure out which I first have questions about because sorry direct when comps you're looking very difference of students there we're a bigger School District than North CL we have a bigger budget we have more teachers and everything like that and the other part is you have to kind of decide what you're going to go with is it is going to be the lock box is it going to be the shoe things like against the door like where are you GNA get the funds for that because from what I've gotten told from some of you is that you're still determining where those funds are going to come from and then again the policy isn't quite clear on when this policy goes into effect I'm a senior I have

118like five months me and J have five months left like what's the point in enacting this policy now or like beginning of the next year like that's a question that a lot of students are curious about when when is the policy going to be enacted it'll be nice if you figure out all these questions so then students are actually aware and you can have transparency on the issue just for the record I have worked in both nor clock Missus and PPS so I know the St po I'm glad that you pointed me out thank you this is is um really long because I thought it was like speech and debate where we had like at least like five minutes so um I I might just have to wing it but um uh my main things

119I have to talk about are um just generally what is best for students um and uh budget and safety issues um uh I have a lot of friends that go to Cleveland and to Grant and they um they always say that like it's just so Overkill and it always um it's just an inconvenience and no one even follows it they just put an old phone in the pouch or they just say I don't have my phone and they um and it's it's just annoying like they'll break the pouches and that's such a waste of school money if they're just breaking the pouches is because they they um this is this is some information I got from an article written by Issa hail in our um in Franklin I go to Franklin uh our journalism class

120they have a newspaper and she wrote um Yonder pches cost $25 to $30 per student grant spent more than $60,000 uh on over 2,500 pouches after receiving a two thou $20,000 discount for being a pilot school according to a KGW sourced PPS purchasing order that's such a crazy amount that we could use on so on like so many other things why is it used for something that seems so unnecessary because no one's going to actually follow it and the safety issue the main safety issue everyone talks about is like the lockdowns and things but the safety issue that I think about most is buses because one of my friends frequently misses her buses because she is going to the back of her school to go unlock her phone and she misses her bus which can

121be which is fine because her bus is frequent service but a lot of them aren't so that could be a 30 minute to hour difference which is a big deal in like the winter when the sun sets earlier and um and that means you could be coming home at dark and that's not really good in some areas sorry this would be so much more smart if I had more time just rambling um and um my sister went to um Grant in 2013 to 2017 when they still had access to mobile phones before there was a policy for it and she says that it benefited them a lot to um have their phones because they could use it for their classes and they could use it to connect with each other people say that it's a

122social thing that it makes it harder to to um it's they said that like phones are detrimental to students social lives but I think that they're very um important parts of students social lives in um in the modern day because um like the People Are People the main form of communication is their phones the like I like I want to ask my my friend's phone number but I like they can't use their phone in school and um so I can't talk to them outside of class and so uh like that friendship could be better but it's not because I can't talk to them outside of class and that's so it like kind of goes like against what it's for you know thank you I have ban practice that I'm already late for so I'm sorry

123I have to leave this meeting uh now thank you for uh letting me talk yeah thank you you did a very good job sounded very smart good evening Happy New Year my name is Maya PUO Von geld last name v n space Capital gel D RN I wanted to share my thoughts as a parent volunteer but also as a PPS substitute and Sun School teacher I wanted to thank you as I am in support of an off andway all day rule for all grade levels I believe that a simple clear rule makes it easier to draw the line it shouldn't be up to the teachers to have to constantly B students throughout the day we need a clear cut policy that deals with the issues as a whole and a strong plan for implementation and

124I'll get back to the implementation part at the end I know students both middle schoolers and high schoolers who are responsible with phone use I hate that they feel like they're being punished for those who aren't as responsible and I know we're raising students to be able to go out into the world and make adult decisions and that we are all as adults able to monitor our phone usage on her own but if I could go back and train myself to be able to disconnect from my phone for seven hours a day I would do it in a heartbeat I would do it faster than I could pick up my phone and swipe up to check for notifications my hope is that we're setting up this next Generation to be able to do so but

125better than we are I'm not exaggerating that it's an addiction when I teach middle schoolers in Sun school and my students pull out their phones I remind them they need to be off and away they put them in their pockets and apologize but then within seconds they pull them back out and swipe up to check notifications without even realizing they're doing it it might it is exhausting it's consistent and while trying to get through a lesson only as an after school program teacher I can only imagine and I have seen it how hard it is for our teachers who are teaching every day all day some teachers have that relationship with their students where they say off and away or getting a referral and they are off and Away some teachers don't have that relationship

126with their students and that authority to be able to do so so it becomes an all day battle what I've what I've experienced seen and heard from staff from around the district is that it's a constant battle sorry I'm repeating myself um but not all have the relationship I just said that sorry I didn't get to go through this very much tonight I know that there is a way to make sure cell phones are off and away all day whether it ends up being Yonder pouches or lock boxes I don't have the answer but I believe that it can happen many schools do enforce this all day Rule and the restrictions work I'm not saying Yonder is the only answer and I know that a $25 pouch adds up for every student I get that

127but PPS spends millions of dollars on Tech that allows our students to have better Equitable access to learning and I do believe that restricting phone access for the day is a way of giving our kids a better access better access to learning the way the policy is written it gives space for exceptions and I want to say that not only do I believe exceptions should be made for IEPs and medical reasons but I also believe that when students sign out to go off of Campus or when students are off campus during lunch that there should be a way to be to have access to their phones where cell phones don't help but actually hinder emergency situations on campus they are needed as a safety precaution for students while off campus I also know this is

128a board policy and the implementation is a long process and so I just ask that we do this while including our students and our staff in the decision making and I know that there's a way to do this without waving the white flag and surrendering to the constant pull of our cell phones thank you thank you for bring taking the time to give us public comment any further for discussions comments questions you want to have the last word JJ you you don't want to go no I'm happy I'm happy to go um give the student W the last word um yeah just a few points in response I appreciate the conversation I and I I honestly think we're taking ourselves a little too seriously like I I just want to point out that we're passing

129a board policy here and and there's very uh I think there's a lot of of it's very reasonable to disagree about this one piece about during launch and passing period versus not we're all in agreement on like 80 or 90% it's also a board policy it can be changed at any board meeting in the future by any board member who wants to bring It Forward I also want to point out it's written in such a way which I fully support that the superintendent can change this through the implementation because again often way throughout the school day um unless otherwise permitted under this policy or related administrative directive so we're moving forward with uh uh you know a majority of the board I'm going to support this because I think it's the right thing to do

130to do this um but if it's not working we'll just change it so let's not get too caught up in what we're doing tonight and more think about what's going to be the most effective thing and and watch that as we go forward I do want to take a little bit of an issue with a couple things people said particularly around the student point of view and I guess I just want to caution the adults who are disagreeing legitimately about um sort of talking about whether we're including the student's point of view or not to support your own perspective the reality is we've all listened to the students there's a very big difference between listening to what students have said and agreeing with what students have said and I have absolutely listened to what the

131students have said and I want to be really really clear to JJ and the others I disagree with what the students have said I've also listened to what a lot of teachers have said I've listened to a lot of Administrators who have said who are also supportive of off and away all day so no matter what we do here we're we're going to be listening to everyone and agreeing with some people and disagreeing with others it's the seven of us who it's our job to exercise their best judgment on on what's going to move forward and in my view this is our best judgment on what we should do and maybe we'll find out that it was wrong and we'll change that policy shortly thereafter um when it comes to the safety another just sort

132of caution um I hear a lot of people say oh my kids need their phone for safety off campus there absolutely are very rare but not unheard of circumstances where something really dangerous happens where you wouldn't have a phone our students are far more likely to die as a pedestrian by looking at their phone than they are from any other safety issue out there so if we really are talking about the safety of our students taking away their phones when they're walking around off campus at lunch is going to save more lives then it's going to then it's going to hurt so let's just again we're talking about safety and risk be really clear about that and finally the Enforcement issue also bothers me a little bit oh my gosh how are we going to

133enforce it we enforce all kinds of our policies both on and off campus policies around bullying harassment sexual assault drug and alcohol use we're not following kids around we're not you know sending the the you know the the the school you know uh administrators after them but we do have expectations of our students both on and off campus for a lot of our policies so this is not any different than that I don't expect enforcement would be any different than that I don't expect that we're going to be you know policing our students rigorously you know on and off campus I do think as with all these other policies to the extent things come to our attention we're going to follow up on it so with that I'm going to support this and um I

134guess I'll turn it over to JJ well it's been great having this discussion for the past six months I'm really grateful for all my board members especially Julia who's the chair of the policy committee I think it's really important that we Center our student voice in every conversation we have here at the district level I think we heard very clearly from our amazing student speakers who took the time out of their day to speak how they felt very concerned they felt the safety and the concerns they had was extremely valid I think we see at so many of our schools who don't have you know safe neighborhoods they see a lots of things you know gun violence you know individuals overdosing where sometimes they need a call Authority or trusted adult I believe it's important

135we not only we listen but we listen to understand when our students speak over the course of this time as we've been kind of developing this policy I've been hearing from students how they feel very unsafe their mental health has been declining you know a lots of suicidal thoughts have been coming on to students especially when we've been having this this discussion which I think it's really important to recognize that as a board and as we are in service of our students so I think it's important that in our action we are always and continue to be in service to our students and that's why I'll be voting no on this policy I know as a senior representative to this board under organ law I don't have an actual vote and it won't impact this

136decision but I truly ask my colleagues who I know truly Center and care about students to lead with an equity and an empathy mindset because it's what our students need and I truly believe that we can be able to make our students feel safe and I really hope that we vote now on this policy I just want to say a couple of things I've said this before but there's a spectrum of Engagement I think sometimes what where we go wrong is we don't say hey we're just informing you of this thing in this case with the student survey and working with staff to put that out and really hear from students is really important work and we didn't get back and say along the spectrum of Engagement which is from inform to consult involve collaborate

137and finally to empower we were kind of more on the consult side of this engagement and the promise to the public would say that is we will keep you informed listen acknowledge your concerns and let you know how your feedback is being used or not and so we didn't we kind of failed to say we're going to listen and when at the end of the day when you get up here you have to use your best judgment I am um I've made my decision the way I am because I care about our students I want to see outcomes improve I want to see our kids actually learning in class and not watching movies that's not every student that's some students including uh family members um that are listening to music or watching watching movies or

138doing anything besides listening to their instructor and and that that bothers me and that ultimately um drives my decision no just put a vote right ready to vote let's do this um all right the board will now vote on resolution 70 29 resolution to adopt student use of personal electronic devices in schools all in favor please indicate by saying yes yes yes yes all oppos please indicate by saying no no no any abstentions student represented canavi indicate your vote no I lost count five two all right resolution 7029 is approved by a vote of 5 to2 with student represented consv you unofficially voting no now we can all go to sleep tonight right so let's not go there because there's a YouTube video where the guy takes an expo marker he puts the Expo marker

139on the tip of the rim here and he presses down real hard and it pops off there's also a YouTube video of him putting it on the corner of a thing and pressing down and it breaking so let's not go there and that I couldn't get it off I'm just trying to be respectful and not show kids how to do it but you can look on YouTube for yourself they're not using YouTube anymore I'm sorry I missed what you said I was on my phone thanks director green all right next up we have our the next Hot Topic let's get moving I I just want to say I they left I wish they would to left so there is a uh measure that has been uh potentially um in front of the legislator as far

140as uh 16 year olds um being allowed to vote in Schoolboard elections so I just wanted to let them know that once they be able to get a voice in voting then that could be a voice they use for decisions that they didn't want to have for their for them move forward I'd like to change my vote no you could have waited till student represent was back I was trying to do before right all right our next item uh tonight is to vote on resolution to refer a general obligation bond for the upcoming May special election direct Scott would you like to introduce us I yes thank you Chong and if I'm a little distracted it's because I just got a text at my daughter is locked out so I anyway we're going to do

141this and then we'll figure out what needs to happen glass glass she a at a [Laughter] school I cannot believe I walked right into that well if she were at school she wouldn't be locked out all right let's dive into this Bob package um I I just wanna so um I want to take a moment uh and actually a few moments I'm gonna take a few minutes here um just to reflect on the importance of this bond package that we're voting on this evening um if the voters pass this Bond and I certainly hope they do uh it means that PPS is final is is going to finalize a promise that we made to voters more than a decade ago that all of our PPS high schools will be modernized to be the learning spaces

142our students deserve providing all of our students the chance to attend school uh at least once during their tenure within PPS in a new building it's a huge accomplishment for the district and I think it's something to be really celebrated we started planning for this a year ago uh we had a board work session in January of 2024 it was taken up by the facilities and operations committee chaired by director Holland um at each of the monthly committee meetings between February and June I know we took a break in summer we resume these conversations in October um and uh with us meeting as uh to discuss uh the bond package five times since October both in the school facilities Improvement committee meetings and uh one board meeting and one work session we've arrived tonight at

143what I believe is a very strong bond package that's going to effectively address some of the district's biggest issues issues it is a large Bond at $1.8 billion however it can also be done and passed without raising property taxes above their current rate which our polling has shown is a really important factor for taxpayers in in in our district in addition of finalizing all of our high schools um this bond package also makes a vital investment of almost $270 million for deferred maintenance facility improvements and athletic improvements in the district these are the changes that our parents students teachers have been Dem Landing the bond package also invests over $240 million in new technology and curriculum and I think it plans for a very reasonable 5% for administration and 5% for contingency um we had

144an earlier session for some of you were here uh at uh between five and six to hear testimony on the bond and I do want to respond um to a little bit of that testimony we heard during that listening session and I want to I want to thank members of both the Cleveland and IW Wells communities for being here tonight to strongly advocate for their schools and I want to reiterate that the budget for the high school modernizations has not been reduced so again the budget of $1.15 billion has not decreased and it is fully available if needed for those schools what the board and the District administration is doing is we're asking those communities to look hard at the draft designs that they've that they've been put together over the last year year and

145a half designs that were put together without a budget cap I think it's worth adding to figure out ways to be as fiscally responsible as possible with taxpayer dollars there were a couple people earlier who testified who said that uh Lincoln High School if it was built today would cost $450 million I think we need to be very clear that that is simply not true Lincoln was built for $225 million and it was completed in 2022 construction inflation in 2022 was 12% in 2023 it was 5% we don't have figures for 2024 and Beyond yet but even if we assumed a very High inflation number of 8% and I deal with construction inflation in my other job it is not 8% but if we assume 8% in 2024 25 26 and 27 when these buildings

146will be built that $225 million is equal to 360 million dollar that is the amount we're asking the Cleveland and idb Wells communities to Target the reason I want to be really clear about these facts is because PPS is not asking these communities which include both my own alma mater at you know Wilson Wells and my daughter's High School currently to accept something less than what others in the district have gotten we are asking them to plan for the same amount as other high schools have been built for and if the case is successfully made that those schools need to cost 25% more than Lincoln and other schools in the district that money is still available in the bond we're proposing which is why I think it's actually the package that that that the superintendent

147and staff brought forward um really is manages to walk that line of being fiscally responsible and also saying if we need it the money is there I'm going to summarize by highlighting uh that this bond package continues the long-term capital investment planning that started over 10 years ago before any of us were on this board to reverse the decades long disinvestment in our buildings and Facilities I want to strongly amplify what P president Bonia said which is that this Bond would not be necessary if the state was fully funding education in Oregon however we know that's not the case and I'm grateful that the Portland Community has and Hope we'll continue to strongly support PPS bonds and improve the educational environment for our children turn it back to you chair or to staff thank you

148all right um superintend I don't know if you want to go first or do you want to put on table first before I will pivot to staff and have them uh welcoming our chief operating officer um Dan Jung and our chief of staff Deborah CFI thank you good evening uh unlike I think as director Scott we' had a number of meetings over over the last year we don't have a presentation I think it's the first time we're just here to to answer questions and I think dror Scott did a great introduction so don't think our chief of staff has anything so we're here to answer any questions you may have yeah I guess this isn't a question it's just I want to be sure that director Scott is right that we will be sure the

149wells and the Cleveland high schools are what they expect it's a great question I think director Scott did a great job of explaining that the budget that is in the proposed bond is an amount to cover the budgets that were already established through the comprehensive planning process for all three of those schools so if those funds are needed those funds are available if we are able to uh realize some savings through this current process that we're taking a look at the designs uh then there can be savings that could be uh applied to other school modernization efforts so yes is the answer and I think that's significant because some of the things that we've heard over the last month are like for instance a uh a school not getting a band room or a theater

150being reduced in size or a couple of classrooms being reduced and that's not the intent I think uh director Scott explained it well it gives us an opportunity to look at you know other items that we've costed out and also I think just making sure we bold the the golden line which is um it was a a proposed amount and that the schools the actual complete design haven't been costed out so until we have an actual final design um and then take that to be costed out we don't know the the dollar amount so so we're we're with proposed dollars at this point too so I just wanted to kind of bold and underscore that and I just would like to add one thing which is that final decisions will come before this board so

151staff will not be making these decisions Community will not be making these decisions in a vacuum you all will have an opportunity to vote on the final designs for these schools I'm GNA have some comments on some other areas and some other questions but while we're while we are in this riff um and I want to talk just a little bit about timing because um I feel there's a great deal of of uncertainty that's been created um and I feel like um I know there's a lot of energy in this community to have all of our high schools modernized um and over the years everybody's voted for the high schools and everybody else's neighborhoods so that everybody would get them so I I know there's a lot of energy but I'm also concerned about the

152uncertainty because I feel like we're heading into the um into the referral um without like our most fervent advocates um ready to uh lead the charge and part of it and I'm hoping maybe we can um sort of aay people's fears by having like a better understanding the timeline so initially when the new targets I think it's very helpful to know that that the money is there if it's needed um but the when the initial targets that were lower um were shared there was also going to be a cost study that was in a comeback that was in a come back at at the end of November and we still don't have that so talk about and then I think the other thing that is causing concern is if you're on a design Advisory Group

153essentially um those meetings have stopped and so the sense of we've got this momentum everybody was told in 2020 like you're each school is going to get20 million you're going to do the design you're G to be shovel ready for 2024 that was when we were going to go last year but we're going to be shovel ready when we the next Bond and it it seems like things are stopped so so um to get into this it's going to come back to the board is that going to come back to the board like next month um I would hope we have Clarity of what we're asked what voters to know what it is the project design that that we're funding because it hasn't been entirely clear like it's it's a great question and so the

154the three projects so it's going to be we expect this to be a little bit iterative so what we have asked is the three project teams to go and look at at some opportunities to reduce costs and then bring those back and these are large complicated projects so they're looking at things that takes time to look at what those redesigns could be and to also do thirdparty professional cost estimates of what those are so what we plan on doing here within the next couple of weeks is bring back that first iteration to leadership here not necessarily to to the board but to so of those teams to present and say Here's Where we think we're going are we headed down the right path and we leadership will say yes we think that's right or or

155we need make some corrections allow them time to refine that and then we will bring that to the board or to a committee or whichever way that is say is this the right direction that we're going we don't want to get too far down the line if this isn't something that's ultimately palatable for the board so we want to bring back some initial thinking get some some direction if we're headed in the right in the right direction and then we would continue to refine that uh if if the the decision is the feedback is at that time that that is those reductions are not something that is pal to the board then we will we will change course on there but we hoping over the next weeks and months to bring this to some sort

156of clarity as far as where these projects are headed in their design but but before the voters vote on it that would be ideal it's hard to know exactly how long because we do think this will be a little bit iterative um but that would certainly be what we okay um I think the other place um and I appreciate um so we have a base set of Ed specs from 2017 and I appreciate um I can't remember if superintendent Armstrong or chief of staffy who said we're gonna you're gonna have all the bells and whistles everybody else has which to me that's like okay that's the Ed specs plus and I think if people felt that that was like we've got that commitment so they're going to try their best to reduce costs because we're

157all taxpayers and that's that's a good thing if you we can reduce costs that don't impact actually academic programming um but I think there is this concern that it is going to impact some like the extra CTE space that idb Wills uses or the amazing choir and band programs that Cleveland has or their athletic fields or that there's that's going to be somehow compromised so I don't know can you provide Assurance like is the bells and whistles the basic Ed specs like what everybody else got well that's what's tough about that is until the committee is in space designing and we see I think what um our chief operating officer shared last time is that um all of the schools have things that are above and beyond Ed specs While others may have chose something

158else but I think what would be helpful I mean of course respond but I think would be helpful is to share a couple of things that um have represented uh the team going back and looking at some cost-saving um line items yes so we've asked the teams to look at um as superintend notes all of our projects have some areas where they exceed the Ed specs and other is where where they don't exceed X for a number of reasons there could be special programs and schools or there could be site constraints uh which you know Lincoln for example site constraints around Athletics and so there's always those puts and takes uh what we've asked the teams to go is look back uh on the designs and say are there opportunities to where things are above

159at specs where we might be able to bring those down and also are there areas where we we are designing above the code requirements so something that is above and beyond what's required for a new building and see does that save us material cost so those are two areas that the teams are currently looking at we haven't seen what the results of those are yet okay so um I'm for the bond I I'm all for the bond you did a great talk Andrew thank you um to Scott Rita and it's so good to see it's like we're having a re milon um so I just wanted to make sure I said that publicly that I love seeing y'all here U but getting back to where I was going with this I'm all for the bond

160uh Bond I'm getting concerned that what I had originally asked for is being misconstrued somehow um and that we're losing sight of what I thought the goalpost was and so I want to try to be as clear as I possibly CL can in each iteration to make sure that I specifi the same goal post so that it doesn't seem like it's moving I believe what I was asking for at the time when I was trying to bring this up was a construction audit I literally framed it as such I would like to get a construction audit so that I can see um what we're so that we can understand not just myself so that we can understand how much we're spending and why it's necessary to spend what we're spending because the numbers that we

161um were producing seemed um elevated when you started looking around the city or around the state when you looked at um the Beaverton was it Beaverton that was building a school that was same as us large it was beautiful and they did it for 269 and yet we had specs that said we were going to be doing close to 400 plus million dollars so the the question the question that I was bringing to the table was not ever to reduce the the cost or to Value engineer Cleveland or idb Wells but to really get a uh an in-depth understanding of why we were spending the money that we were spending on this side of the water when less than 10 miles away someone else was um spending substantially less we I was informed that we

162would get a uh an audit of some kind at the end of November and at the end of November we would get an audit that would show this is why we're spending it because I am one to say every single time if if it takes this if this is what it takes to get it done like like Andrew said we've got the money there let's spend it let's let's I don't want to cut a theater I don't want to cut band I don't want to cut choir like I don't want to cut any of those my question is not you know do we have the money my question is can we justify why we're spending how much we're spending on our on our buildings so are you telling me that when you guys are saying

163we're looking for opportunities to reduce cost is that our language for we're doing an audit so we're AUD auditing ourselves and if that's the language for you know we're looking for opportunities to where we can reduce cost shouldn't there be some sort of like who's who's making sure that our numbers are right who's who's making sure that you know we're not I'm just not looking at Andrew like you know I'm G just not look over there because I don't want to deal with why I'm spending that 20 million and so we're just going to focus an audit to me means that it's someone taking a subjective objective look where they don't really care they Ain they just here to tell you the raw facts this is what it is and then they come back and

164then we say dang it really cost us this much or they come back and they say what the heck why have we been spending so much so when I'm looking for an audit that's what I'm looking for I'm looking for someone to hold me accountable so that I can go back to the voters and and the public and the guy that I'm running to at Fred Meyer and they say why are you spending so much money on schools I can pull up my audit that shows that this cost is gone up and that this is gone up and I remember when um plywood was $180 a sheet the same sheet that cost $40 so I remember these these different costs going up but they've come down substantially I just want to make sure that we're

165that what we're asking for and what we're saying we need is what we actually actually need and not just some number that somebody else has made up so the design I thought the design was supposed to drive the the conversation and so if the design itself is driving the conversation the the architect they come in they say this is what we're going to get and this is what we're going to do then they take it to a project manager and the project manager then looks at it says it's actually buildable it's something that we can actually do and then but we're just saying we've got 400 million for a a building now go do something with it that seems like backwards so we need to in my humble opinion again I'm not an expert here

166I preach and so other people can do that part that's why I'm asking for an audit so then I don't have to make this stuff up I don't have to speculate because the audit and the people that run the audit they will do all that for me and that's what I'm trying to figure out when are we going to get that that's what I need I need to know when we're going to get that when is the audit coming back so that we can say with certainty that this is why we're doing what we're doing and it is what it is it's the thank you um should we we should probably put this on the table yeah let's put so moved second third I guess I have a motion in a second to adop adopt

167resolution 7038 resolution of Portland Public Schools Mona County School District 1j uh County Oregon calling a measure election to submit to electors of the district the question of authorizing 1.83 billion of General obligation Bond and providing for related matters director I think Scott Scott moved and director Holland seconded did you did wait who second I was third I know I was I saidd shall we arm wrestle I'm all right you gotta get a [Laughter] you know it's getting late when we're all getting Delirious um is there any board would you like to continue discussion so I I'm gonna have an amendment to put on the table as well do you want me to do that now I can or we can have discussion um well let's let's ask does anybody else else have any general

168discussion questions so I have some I have some other questions and I just want to go so I think what I heard you say is we might not know what the design is until after the election I heard that it will come back to the board but it the design may not come back until after the election so let it might be worthwhile do just a quick bit of like framing and maybe answer some questions about where designs and cost estimates come from I'll do like super quick um so for all of our modernizations they start with with these foundational documents the Ed specs are the one that are most known but there's we have other we have design guidelines and those things and what these these these documents are informed by staff they're in

169boarded by stakeholders they're in boed by different community members and so those those are the foundation when we move into our next phase which is planning that's when we bring on board uh our design teams and thirdparty cost estimators and so what they do is they combine these foundational documents they found they combine the existing conditions of the school the unique programs of the school and they engage the stakeholders including like their designing advisory groups and what they produce is one comprehensive plan so a very very early design and that is ened by a third-party professional construction cost estimator so that's the basis there's other cost but that's the bulk That's the basis for where our cost estimates come from and those comprehensive plans are then approved by the board to include the scope the

170schedule in the budget and that's when we also show where we compare what the Ed specs are versus what's in the comprehensive plan so there's kind of like an an accounting of where those puts and takes are so that's the basis after the comprehensive plan is approved which they've been approved for the three modernization schools we move into the formal design phases and each there's three of those each along the way we get updated professional cost estimates and again that's what the budgets of the the schools are based on all the the three schools were in schematic design one may have just finished schematic design uh when we put them on PA and then ask them to go and say take a look at at what at some potential cost saving options are depending on

171the outcome of that will depend on really that process where we are in the design and where if we need to go back or if we can proceed forward so I I understand your question is when do I get that designed we will have at least a high level before the may vote for sure I just don't know exactly where we'll be because it'll depend on what that information is what the decisions are between now and then and can I just also I mean that's it's normal for our process right like we're further ahead on Wells in Cleveland than we have been with any other high school modernization right normal and we go out for high school monetization at the time of referral the time of referral yes so so typically we are in the

172the planning phase we're not in the design phases so yes correct but we actually last time said because you're last in the process and we know you didn't go get to go to the 2020 bond that we're going to give you money funded so you're further along in the process because it's funed referral comes right right um which was an explicit promise I'm also just looking at the bond advis the bond accountability committee um who looked at at the package and they said like the committee agrees with staff that there may be ways to reduce the cost for these schools however at this time we have no information that would show the cost could be reduced to the lower targeted numbers therefore our recommendations canate on the data we have for the Scopes of work

173we've reviewed um so it sounds like there like we don't we don't see where the cost reductions some cost reductions could be made but not the pretty dramatic what they're they're acknowledging I don't want to speak for the commune but I think which they're acknowledging there is the process that these these projects have been there they all have approved comprehensive plans that have cost estimates they they've been through the or design phases have updated cost estimates uh they've brought on uh General Contractors to help support those so we have competing estimates so we can compare the two to make sure that we're more accurate and they know that we're going through this process to look reductions they don't know the outcome of that yet so what they're just acknowledging is we understand that you're going

174through this process for reductions we don't know what those are going to be therefore uh that's that's the the Genesis of the note yeah I just watched that today sounded like they were saying you have this amount of money that you can use on those two buildings and they wouldn't say more than that because that's all they knew right yeah we we presented the budgets and the funding between the two bonds for Cleveland Jefferson and Wells and then acknowledge that you know between the 2020 Bond and the proposed Bond the total funding is over 1.5 billion what we're targeting is to bring that in under under that amount and they understand where we are in the process so are we getting the bells and whistles the similar similar schools it's just a question that we're

175going to be asked I mean we are Cleveland and IW Wells going to get similar schools I heard all the caveats but just a general acknowledgement that they're going to get modernized schools that have SIM similar maybe slightly different depending on their programming but similar features they are going to be amazing school high schools they are going to be blow your mind cool high schools and as a parent of three who went through Cleveland I will be up there demanding just as all the good folks who are in in green and gold that those schools are amazing and it is our belief that we can have those schools for a cost that the tax pairs can feel comfortable about pain we've seen it all over the country and we're going to see it here in

176Portland Oregon so amazing is similar because I've been apparent yes I Cleveland yes um okay so I have I have another question about Cleveland that came up because when the documents got Consolidated the acknowledgement about um the Athletics um being part of the scope of the um so we we very specifically have funding in the bond for um many of the other high schools um for projects that didn't happen when their modernizations happened which need to happen um but on that list Cleveland's not on there either is idb Wells and and um Dan can you share where that Assurance is that Cleveland Athletics is in the scope yeah the in previous versions and and meetings we we enumerated the modernizations and we had a separate line for Cleveland Athletics all call offsite Athletics it had

177sort different names um and the the backstory why that had a separate line was was a little bit because when that comprehensive plan was approved for Cleveland there was was the note to make make sure to include that so we just held it separately because it had a different budget I think there was just some confusion at the last meeting of December 17th I think staff uh took some feedback and thought that that was confusing to have two lines and so the intent was to consolidate so that the Cleveland modernization does include the offsite Athletics the baseball softball the multi- purpose Fields as well the team is continuing to look at options what the best location is for that because it can't fit on the site proper so that is what will be brought back

178to the board when we relook at the at the clevel and comprehensive plan is is it in any of the documents that like the written documents because that's what guide the I I don't think that's enumerated in the materials here but they can be um I think it would be good to have it included um because most most of us aren't going to be here in eight years okay well there you go here those new stiens um I mean I think it's important to enumerate it because it just all of a sudden disappeared and it when there's other uncertainty it's like I think we should be we should be clear in writing because what I've been told is like if it's not in writing it actually is not a commitment of the district fair enough

179we were trying to we thought we were making it simp Le I think we made it more confusing that wasn't our goal okay um I want to just comment briefly on the um can make up very brief I want to move okay we're kind of behind on time right now okay why don't you go and I'll offer my Amendment after people have a chance to no I'm I'm not going I'm just asking you had a brief comment just no go ahead that's fine I'll just do it my summary comments All right you have an amendment to propose oh you want me to do it now okay okay um I'm moving that we amend uh the res the resolution that's on the table to add $40 million to the 2025 Bond increasing the total bond amount

180to fund investments in the planning for and creation of a center for Native American student excellence and to direct staff to amend the proposed ballot title and explanatory statement effect that amendment that is the motion have to have a motion um so just to explain that um the reason why there's a direction to staff to amend the proposed ballot versus providing specific language because it's not a good idea to be amending ballot title language at the board table so this gives the staff the flex gives staff the flexibility to to add it um I'm going to uh speak to the amendment um I'm also going to ask that because we're voting on it that um public comment be allowed on it because that's what we generally do when we have a um V on an

181action item um so I would ask if people want to a comment on the on the amendment that they be allowed to um I brought this forward in February of 2024 following discussion we had about the avt um resolution in fact the resolution was in our document in our documents tonight to um Provide support for um the action the district was taking to um do something to repair harm that had happened to um the black community and in that the original draft of the resolution excluded mention of the Native Community who is actually here first and so we we did the right thing which we amended it and director dep pass said at the time we need to do more than just say things that we're going to make things better that we care about

182na native students doing and land acknowledgements asking the drumming Circle to come to every one of our um new school openings um and so from that the um Indian parent committee um brought forward the proposal and um I shared that with everybody on the board in February of last year and at every meeting and I have the sort of the whole documentation because there was some question about like this was new it's like it it actually um was raised it was posted with the documents it was commented on at the February March April May and June meeting um then there was a high a dis the the summer and when we came back it got raised again and then the December 2nd meeting there was a whole host of suggestions of like actually we really

183think we know what the native Community wants or we should ask them to create something else and to show they have support and and they came back with a proposal but it's it's not new and um I think we heard there's been a lot of conversation about we know what what they really want is X or they really want is y and I think we should be respectful and um actually let them share what they think is the best way to support their students and you know I appreciate the data tonight that that there's almost 2,000 native students um we don't have a strategy um there isn't a place and I think we've taken lots of steps um which I'm very one of the things I'm most proud of on the board that we've taken

184many steps to address the harm that happened to the black community and black students and black families and I think we should be also taking steps to address harm that's happened for almost two centuries to Native students and PPS um and I to me and I I appreciate um again um director to pass really sort of given me the kick of like hey let's just stop talking about it or amending resolutions to say something um that about like what we feel and we really want to do better um and so putting something in the bond um is a way in which we can respect what the Indian parent committee asks for in addition um I think it's important to also recognize that um we we shouldn't necessarily be comparing two projects that um impact to

185communities that have been harmed um that to say well this is what this community got or this is what they need and so we're going to give you the we're telling you we need the same and I think um you know this this is a great case of representation matters because there's no there's no native um has been a member of this board and so yes one um but the representation the the representation at the table matters yeah I hear you and I think when we talk about representation when Matt Morton was on the board that was one of his reasons the contract with n happen for the same reason you're bringing them now for the Native American for ACD um going by what I was told so don't don't kill a messenger um and

186so while we're talking about America has harmed a lot of groups and I don't think we need to play a pressian Olympics up here with one group versus another group versus Asians that was had got sent to concentration camps in vort I get that right we we can sit here and play a pre Olympics all day long my question for and I don't have a problem with doing the Native American um Center for excellence either my my question is one is we're add are we adding to the original Bond or are we taking the money from somewhere else previously on the bond already that would be one two my question would be we since we're talking about facilities are we going to are we go to underfund because we're talking about $40 million to build

187something is that enough money and where's that data to show that we can actually use $40 million to build something that they're going to need because what we don't want to do is we don't want to underfund something either you know we don't want to be back in 2017 where we're trying to just throw a number in there without really understanding what is it going to need for them to get what they need if we say Okay $40 million and then two years from now it's 60 million then what happens right and so those are some of the questions I would have um but I I want to get out of playing that oppressed Olympic stuff because America has harmed a whole lot of people and so if we're going to try to make it

188right by everyone that America has harmed we need to do a lot more we need to add way more to this Bond than what we have on the table well I think we have made made progress since my tenure on the board and the Investments we've made and I hope we can continue to make them but that's not a to me it's not a reason not to do it and to answer your question um this the way the amendment is drafted it's an ad um there was an earlier conversation that if you wanted to add something you had to subtract something but I will note in February this was on the table along with everything else and no other project whether it was my beloved um Athletics project or your Roosevelt Grand stands none of

189those projects anything in here had to cut something in order to be in the project so um we actually cut a lot of stuff from the original amount that we was going to do when we first started talking about we start talking about almost having $700 million in deferred maintenance we did cut that so there was cuts when we first original talked about a bond that was almost three million three3 billion dollar so yes we did cut a whole lot of stuff when we came back after break so we're talking about what we really need for all of our students and we're going to increase I'm all for increases I've been for increasing and making sure we have what we need for all of our students I'm all for it the problem is if we

190are I don't want to put them in a position that we're saying $40 million is going to get what you need one that's just the building we're not talking about no programming we're not talking about tutoring we're not talking about the stuff that they sit up here and talked about as far as the educational stuff that they need where's that coming from we can give them a building and then what happens if we're not talking about all the way around so when we look at and when we say compare things when we compare like the center for black Excellence they had a whole wraparound program that they had attached to it now whether the building portion is done or not they had a whole wraparound portion attached to that I don't see that with just

191$40 million saying we're going to just build them a small building somewhere for $40 million where's the whole wraparound service that they're they're needing like the other one so I have to compare because those are only two things that I have well their their proposal didn't have building a new building that wasn't in the proposal they made so we also have a we have a federal obligation to educate native students and hopefully much better than we well we have a mandatary to educate all of our kids so it's not that their kids don't get all of our kids got to be educated it's not just their black kids got to be educated Hispanic kids have to be educated white kids have to be educated agan kids have to be educated so the the separation stuff

192is just is I don't know if it's just eating at me today or any other time but we we can't start stop step separating well we have to do something extra for this or something extra for that or something extra for them if we are talking about doing something and I'm all for doing something I don't want to half ass do something I don't want to just say well here's $40 million but we have nothing else to go with that we have no programming we have no um anything that we need to put with that because we have buildings right now and our kids are not getting educated we have buildings right now and our kids are not reading we have buildings right now and our kids are underperforming so just to have a building

193is is one thing I want to make sure that we have things that's going to actually teach them and I just need to know what in that proposal is going to actually teach the kids not just provide a building I think um that's that's great and to build on my what I was looking at with this was actually what I heard Dr Armstrong speaking to earlier so um when she when she spoke she was she was speaking to that she had received a letter and in the letter they had um asked for some they specific things they wanted to see specific things um and that you know making sure that they had a space or making sure that they had these pieces that was some and as I heard and maybe um we can expand

194on that a little bit as I heard it sounded like you addressed every one of the line items or it was every one of the line items was addressed as far as like programming education making sure that and so what I would be hoping is that what we're what you're asking for would possibly be in addition to the programming or whatever it is the that Dr Armstrong has already um said that we're going to be doing and then I would be looking to see if it's about a a space do we already have a space that instead of dumping $0 million into a new building do we have an existing building that's maybe being underl underutilized that we can say hey this is this is what we're going to do as far as like the

195um the programming the other stuff we're spending I think I heard you say $1.1 million as far as curriculum we're working with the tribal unit to um the tribal Nations because I I I believe it's important to recognize that these are like governing Nations that this is not just like a unit of people these are like governing Nations and so we're working with all the different governing Nations to to to come together to say okay does this actually does this actually do and if not what should we be doing because anything that we do for you without you we're actually doing to you and so now we bring all that information together this is the list that you've given me these are the things that you said you want me to make sure that I've

196done did I hit the mark are we are we where we need to be I think if we have a the an inclusive conversation then I I believe that we're winning if it's in addition to I believe that we're winning I I think I've always said um I'm for more like I believe we're doing ourselves a disservice um by having a scarcity I believe it's a scarcity mindset of saying that if we add any more people are going to say no I I'm I'm just I just don't believe it I I believe that I do believe there's a line there there is a line and I just don't believe that we've gotten if we're doing what's right for our kids making sure that they're going to have the um the access the education that that

197we know that they need making sure that they're going to get the opportunities that we know that they deserve that we're positioning them to be the leaders for tomorrow that when it comes down to when it comes down to it that we make the sacrifice today for tomorrow and I believe that's what I heard you say that you're doing and I believe that this would just be uh an addition to I would hope and so I'd like to hear you yeah I want to respond thank you I appreciate that I was thinking about the public testimony when the student uh referenced my comment about uh tribal liaison and saying you like basically no disrespect but that's not what we want that's something that's not even able to be covered with bond funds so most of

198the things that I listed was a response to um the committee's requests or items that aren't even able to be covered with bond funds saying that we're ready to engage immediately within the next six months we have not yet sat down um I had one meeting over winter break but we have not sat down with community members tribal leaders uh families to begin have conversation about you know what might a job description look like I know in the letter requested it was um hiring three staff to do a um engagement process for some of the requested items and so we're prepared to meet one knowing that we are um still working through a $40 million deficit and there are reductions to my staff that we will create to establish this position because we know and

199we hear the call to action and we do know that we need to do a better job um also mentioning um sites regardless of where you all are at on the board with something that's you know erected or established now or in the future um I know that uh we could have siners and modernized buildings now just like we have College and Career Centers and in all of our high schools you know I think it was my attempt of saying like we can be Innovative we can meet Community um in a place to Envision what's possible what stops us from having a native Center like a career and College Center in all of our modernized high schools right so so I think it was more of that call of like let's engage with community and

200here and most of the things that I mentioned are things that would not be a part of the 40 mil million doll Bond because we know that the bond is the building only so I appreciate the opportunity to clarify and say that um that it's a resource that we're in in the in the um 1,000 hours for tutoring um or academic support that's something that we're funding out of a budget that is in deficit um and it's not something that can be funded with Bond dollars just to be clear but we also understand like I said the call to action and um a move that we need to make to respond to our our community um as outlined as one of the items in the letter just a quering I don't know if this is

201for um Dan or for the superintendent um but the staff that you're talking about anytime we have any sort of a capital project there's usually somebody who's coordinating it or running the facilitations right I mean that P is paid for with Bond funds correct if it's a bond project yeah the bond funds can pay for staff that are directly attributable to that Capital asset okay yeah so that's typically more in the Construction office we wouldn't be able to hire liazon uh three liaison folks to plan programming and support within that Center that would be an incorrect as you know that would be an incorrect use of bond funds and so I think what's been clear to me as I've listened to some of the comments is that I don't know if there's a shared understanding

202um from uh the people that I've heard from on what's possible with Bond dollars there also seems to be um some thoughts that a center would be like a unifying place for students to be during the school day and if it's a conversation about building a school a native school well that's a whole different process right so I think it would be important for me and the team moving forward which I'm hoping will become clear as we meet or through public testimony you know what what exactly the ask is for are we asking for a K12 school for Native students is a different conversation than saying uh a center to be able to pull resources and support students during the day because if it's about supporting students during the day then those centers ought to

203be in the schools where students are at otherwise uh would students spread across um all of our sites I I just I don't I don't know how that works and um and I'm open to hear and learn more but it wasn't an option to say like because we have this you don't need to consider anything else it's saying that there's a call to action and there's work that we need to do and we need to engage in it immediately and we're prepared to do that and we're prepared to name resources that can begin to address because one thing I have to say and I I've been sitting with this for the last couple of days because I've heard from multiple members that if we don't do this then um we don't care about serving or

204supporting native students and I want to publicly dismiss and reject that I don't know everyone's personal story and journey but I know that I personally Mentor um Native students in Portland Public Schools and I've done so ever since I've been a chief academic officer so this whole concept of well if we don't do this we mess not that like I I that's not the way that we move together in collaboration and um in the spirit of um doing what's right and best for our students and so I appreciate the opportunity to publicly state that as well director Scott thanks um I think the conversation about how we improve native student achievement is one of the most important conversations we should be having we should be having in every meeting um and and I I think

205you know the districts failed to do that and we failed to do that for decades we failed to do that on my watch over the last six years and and we should start we should start figuring out we talk about it as a board we should start figuring out how do we add student achievement for Native students student achievement for black students student achievement for you know Latino students to every single meeting I'm going to oppose the amendment because I don't think this is the right solution to that problem um a $40 million building um even if it has an impact a positive impact on student achievement five years from now or six years from now when it's built and I don't think that's a certainty um doesn't get at the heart of what I

206think superintendent Armstrong has laid out today which due to the advocacy of people talking about it is actually getting the conversation going about what can we do today not what can we do in five or six years with a bond but what can we do today um I also want to point out because I think it's important the the concept of this was brought forward last year but the proposal didn't come forward until December 17th and the reason why that's important is because I I think I think another real disservice was done to the native Community for whoever has been working with them over this last year to not make it really clear about what a bond can and can't fund what the timelines and deadlines are I mean this is something that again conceptually

207we got an email about from director brim Edwards a couple times this year but but a proposal came on December 17th and that's too late to get into this process and and and again I don't know what was happening there but it's too late to have the necessary staff input the public review the overall discussion and the most important discussion about ultimate outcomes because that's really what we're talking about is what is going to move the needle on Native student achievement and what's going to do that in in the best way and I don't believe this amendment will do that I think some of the things that superintendent's laid out can do that and I think this board um can do a lot of that moving forward but it's going to be more of a

208budget conversation than it is a bond conversation I just want to um reread something that I read when um directors Holland and green and brim Edwards were sworn in in 2021 and it's about the history of this district and it says for 170 years PPS is failing pattern of response toward struggles of communities of color especially black and Native stems from institutional and cultural racism that continues to exacerbate the inequities we see in society today and in fact the origin story of our district is one of a district that viewed black and Native children as bir to educate and I just want to ground um my statement in knowing that that is our history and the I go on to say that the faces and the tactics have changed and the outcomes have not that

209said I want to um uh director Scott I'm looking at you like what is his name on your on your last day um no no it isn't um that when I was looking at the proposal that we got in December and actually hearing for the first time what superintendent um has proposed I've been thinking about and I was a a very strong advocate for a center until I started to think about it and I'm I'm thinking about what my hope is for the Native American and the black communities because we know those are the two communities that they were were failing the most I would like to see and have hope that we can um Institute practices that can that can work with our native students I think we have people in the room and

210in the community who know how to do this work and um and I don't think it's a building I I we can look back to the Center for black excellence and look at the outcomes from that project it's early it's been about four years but that hasn't improved outcomes like we had intended four years ago at all in fact it's there's no shovel in the ground yet um some of the things that came through the proposal um the individual and group tutoring and mentoring the work on shared courses developed for Native students and portfolio projects which I'm a big fan of um natural resource management Project based learning space for art classes those things happen in schools schools that we already have the most I think I talked earlier about Sustainable Building and the most

211sustainable option is to use the buildings that we have currently a single building that needs will require Transportation because not every Native American student lives near a building wherever that building would be the communities dispersed um transportation's always going to be an issue and safety and I would personally rather see our our our current buildings being used built out even programming added and thank you for um talking about your tribal liaison hire the Thousand hours of tutoring and I hope and I didn't write down everything that you'd said it was new to me the first time I'd heard it I would be really in favor of that because what I'd really like to see is outcomes before or four years starting as soon as possible the computer lab the intergenerational learning the community service providers

212wrap around providers those are all things that are uh very much needed in uh communities of color and those should be done with help of Partners um we have a major uh Native American partner that would love to be involved in the conversation uh we heard from the executive director of NAA today I know they don't serve everybody trust me they don't serve everybody but they do want to be involved they want to help they want to partner they want to share resources with us and so I appreciate superintendent your very your quick and responsive um your proposal and I would be support of doing that if we can do it quickly if we can to director Scott's uh Point talk about this at every meeting we should be talking about Native American and black

213student outcomes at every meeting and I'll conclude there thank you done let's do it I'd like to ask for um people if they would like to provide public comment on the on the amendment all right um yeah let's move to public comment uh Miss Brasa do we have people sign up for public comment this would well it but it's an action item that people already signed up for so we open up Theo May we're going to open up for X my mic isn't on um because it's a new item the amendment is new right and but yet we're going to vote on it so because of that I think we need to identify like we're a set number of people that can come up and then see if we have people in the audience that

214would want to come up and actually speak to it um because we are voting on it but I don't know that we had somebody already previously signed up that would have been cleared to get you know to get approved is what I'm trying to speak to yeah that makes sense and um well I guess let's see if is there anyone here who are able to like to provide public comment say it with excitement is there anybody here that would after hearing what we've just talked about would like to come down and share a few words you're the next contestant on the speak your mind so I got two thank you my name is Lucas Hunter I'm affiliate of the yakam nation um and I'm a Portland Kid born and raised um I'm born and raised

215here in Portland and have been fortunate enough to have been exposed to and experience um some amazing things in life and in our community uh we have a beautiful Community but it's changed a lot I'm 31 years old uh I grew up in uh northeast Portland when it was northeast Portland prior to gentrification yeah we know about that um being that I am biracial and living in Two Worlds um it's typically the easiest comparison for the Youth that we we work and experience uh with um I had my own struggles of trying to find identity um and also just to find my place uh in my own uh Community I was fortunate enough to find that through Sports through Athletics um working within community and and those things were fostered for me um I'm now

216about five to six years into working in the community I've previously worked in uh gang prevention uh and youth advocacy and in case management specifically in our indigenous Community um and I appreciate all your points about um you know it should be collaborative I'm I'm not fully against that however the couple of organizations that I can think of that do a lot of the work it's not enough it's not um we do need additions uh I'm going to try and hold off from speaking on a lot of the amazing points that have already been made historically and and um you know that that uh sort of thing however um you know we deserve to heal and our communities deserve to heal this is a big part of healing for us um yes we are spread

217out um we're also underst staffed which makes it extremely difficult to get to all the community that we work with a center for us would create that Center per se and that Community for us to be pour into the youth that we work with and their families uh just want to leave off with uh something that's near and dear to me and it's a uh vision and prophecy by Chief uh Crazy Horse who's an oala L uh Lakota um Chief and leader and his prophecy was that of the Seventh Generation uh typically 150 years uh per se um it's been seven generations and and when we make decisions that we make today we should consider seven generations to come um we're still affected uh by the decisions that were made Seven Generations ago but I

218myself and a part of that Seventh Generation my sister is here our children are and the youth that are in your schools are part of that Seventh Generation Um and when speaking about um this prophecy you know it talks about um a darkness that our people would go through all people of color would go through for those seven generations um but then we would all gather under a tree of life and I believe that this Center is a is a tangible representation of what that tree of life [Applause] is hello again Bard thank you for hearing me once again as I spoke earlier about our tribal sovereignty well I want to remind you all that I have worked at Nia I also advocated in 19 schools um I advocated right next to one of our

219chairs for D I have my bachelor's in social work and I'm a licensed social worker I want to start by reminding you that this isn't an ask this is a need for our mental health we're all suffering this isn't about who was here first this is about who's here now this isn't about what color we are we're we're putting up barriers and walls against each other as we're sitting here visiting on what we need to help our youth now let me remind you I've been in 19 schools I seen where we were suffering I sat by people who wanted to strike I visited with people it's not just our admin who need help at this point point but I want to remind you once again charal history is shared history as we know and as

220sp13 requires all K through 12 districts in Oregon to teach all students to learn all Oregon's history and to honor the sovereignty and the self-determination of native people the native Community put forth the proposal asking for the community to engaged the process in our building for Native Center for students Excellence both programming and physically what we heard at the beginning of the school board meeting was a list of items and the immediate decisions that were made without us this repeat of centuries old productive methods of communication our students and commun community members said it best earlier tonight we are not asking for bigger contracts without outside the organizations or even a tribal Li liion we are asking for PPS to engage with our community and trust us with self-determination of our needs why do you

221trust every other community to do so except the native students and families again we we plead with you to show us that you see native students by voting to include a center for Native students for Native students success as a line item in the bond peace meal Solutions will not solve problems we identified Community Specialists will not teach the Learning Centers of our students a person is not a building or a space work is already required by the state we would where would we gather as Community the capacity of the building the entire district is the key to the system and Improvement of our community remind you a tribal lion is not what we need we are our tribal lazy on and we've been showing you guys that for a long time Pia thank you

222thank you for sharing any further discussion I think for the sake of time all right um I want to respond like to ask us to move to a vote on the amendment and the bond okay I'm GNA just I just I mean I just want to add I want to thank the Indian parent Community for for speaking out and advocating I think your voice has been heard we are listening um there has you know as as a former educator in PPS there has been quite a lot of work um and you know not all of us was successful and I'll give it that and one of the things that I I also know is that you know when we ask our teachers if we ask our teachers you know what what do they need in

223terms of like how to help certain communities and I'm willing to bet because this is what how I would answer is that you know we would like more support right support means people and time and and and it's not necessarily support for a specific Community because any support means that as a teacher I now have more time that I can give to students who need it and more attention for students who need it and I I I just want to really really reiterate the The Advocate that has come out has been great and either way this goes some we are it is a call to action and um superintendent Armstrong's proposal uh means that we can start this work right now we can identify a space a location um when the advantage of doing superintendent

224Armstrong's proposal uh identify current building with a space that you know can be open after hours is that then that building will now have the ability to be staffed or have be open right versus a separate building and there's limitations in terms of of Staffing what bonds can pay for and the the risk of that not being able to be staffed so there there's an advantage a very strong advantage in terms of what I see in Dr Armstrong's proposal and moving forward in that a we can start this work now number two we do need to Center our Native American Community more often and we should be revisiting every board so you know I as as chair I am going to recommend at least you know a quarterly uh formal check-in on on what the

225progress is being done and and what and things are going to be done um uh in terms of addressing the issues surrounding our our Native American communities um with that said I just want to also just stress really quick um I'm very happy that this happened because again reiterate one more time uh what this means is we can start this work now and I think that is is more important than waiting five or six years and so yes with that um I'll give call to a vote I I'd like to say one last thing um my Clos my my closing comments well I wanted to just say there was a suggestion that there never was wasn't brought before it there was Zero curiosity when I brought the proposal forward from staff I had to repeatedly

226ask to have it posted online online that's the only reason why I got OPP posted because I asked repeatedly not because staff took any initiative so I'll just say the whole like blaming on the community they didn't bring anything forward they didn't know what the process was there was repeated requests to have discussion we had people who came and provided public comments so I just want to correct the record we also did not bat an eye by adding $40 million several weeks ago for administration which we needed and I think we shouldn't have bed I with like we need to do it but I don't think there's a reason why we shouldn't also add an increment of of money and I'll just say there also has been a discussion at this board table that if

227we don't do something now we can go out for a bond in a couple years we're not going out for a bond in a couple years we've all seen the polling because if we went out for a bond in a couple years we'd have to raise taxes and we know that wouldn't pass so this is the opportunity right now here and out to invest some capital I would say if somebody wanted a lower amount they they could offer that up but this is this is the moment it's not a million dollars for curriculum over the next 10 years is really very little and what I heard was I I appreciate the spirit which you offered I'm really glad you asked the question about whether it was additive because what I heard from the Native Community

228is like we we want to speak for ourself and I think what you provided superintendent a response but and I feel like what we should be doing is um working with the community just like we said what we were going to do with other communities which is co-create and doesn't feel co-creative right now um so I I hope that we approve this um Amendment and um I think it'll make the package stronger and it's the right thing to do and I just I'm I know we are trying to get to a vote I just I don't I don't I don't want to be misquoted and just to be clear that in the outline and I know it's posted online so I don't have hard copies I do want to acknowledge that all seven of you

229heard that for the first time when I reported so it wasn't anything that any of you had beforehand there had been something that I had been thinking about and then finally put to paper um to present today but it wasn't um just some random items I do acknowledge that it uh brings about 1.6 million in resources from curriculum to a position to other uh tutoring support and it's not a proposal regardless of where you're at or you decide I know that that's work that we need to activate today in all of those items set in conjunction and um in collaboration with the native community so if we have this meeting on March 3D and the community says hey we don't want you to have a trib liaison to do some engagement and to work with

230us then you know I'm not I'm not going to push it I'm just saying that I'm prepared to make the reductions in my budget Now to respond to some of the things I said in a letter but I don't want it to be like oh I just went and randomly tied something the only thing I have control over is my budget and that's the only thing that I took some positions on which is here's some amount that I know that I can allocate now for work that can happen this Academic Year um in preparation for next year so I just I wanted to be clear that that's what that is and and not to I just I want to be quoted correctly thank you um let's move to the vote uh we are no CH

231I'm sorry to interrupt again um I just wanted to note that I received a request to provide comment that was virtual and I just wanted to make sure that you knew no on the amendment or the bond on the amendment we still have public comment on the bond so yeah no no we we we won't the we added the amendment and they said they could be virtual we we didn't say that they one last one and that's it and so if they if they have signed up oh yeah you can stop stop all right don't take a yes she's not there yet she's she's getting on right now that's a great idea uh can we bring up general public comment while we're waiting on the online person okay just a second let me get back

232to Brad blocker Angela Bonia and Jasmine Reese okay Jasmine is I'm bringing her in jine you can be in when you're ready oh my apologies good evening um my name is Jasmine Reese spelled j a z z m i n last name is Reese r e e c e and um I'm a resident of southwest Portland my kids attend um Elementary School in southwest Portland and I just want to Echo and reiterate what um director Scott had said about the bond accounting and the time is now and if there is an opportunity for cost savings we should do it and then also what P president Angel Angela Bono mentioned about us working together and pushing the legislature to fully fund the qem I had the opportunity to attend the um organ Leadership Summit a couple

233weeks ago in in the breakout session on Early Education um led by the Children's Institute former Governor kits Hopper spoke and said that the economist is predicting a$6 billion doll Surplus in addition to Governor kotch's budget and so while I support the bond and while I support cost saving measur me and I agree that we need to support superintendent Dr Armstrong I think that PPS also needs to be strategically prepared to Lobby the legislature to do more than what is in the bud uh the budget for the governor and to extend beyond the legislative Concepts that are currently on the table to look for more funding and more resources um and so I support the bond on I support the work of Dr Armstrong and um what the union is advocating for and what Andrew

234Scott has said and I I thank everyone for their hard work and the project team but I think that uh Dr Armstrong's correct and that we need to rise together and we need to make sure that we're working together collaboratively to continue to close this achievement gap for all of our students and I yield my time thank you next the other two weren't here and I don't have the virtual person yet they're still working on it I know I know that sign everywhere I see it um you're yeah let's move to the vote um all right we are now voting on I don't know how to word this the amendment as proposed by director brim Edwards um all in favor please indicate by saying yes yes all opposed please indicate by saying no no no

235uh student representative conavi yes thank you the amendment um does not pass with the vote of 225 with student represen canav voting yes all right um we will now vote on resolution seven or sorry yeah yeah we will now vote on resolution 7038 resolution of Portland Public Schools Moma County District number 1j mola County Oregon calling on measure election to submit to the electors of the district the question of authorizing 1.83 billion of General obligation buns and providing for related matters all in favor please indicate by saying yes yes yes all oppos please indicate by saying no uh student representating cavi yes thank you resolution 7038 is approved by a vote of 7 to zero with student representative can save you unofficially voting yes uh next we have um reports from our board committees and

236board members who have recently traveled to conferences director suan you want to start yeah um this is from the audit Committee in the audit committee meeting of Monday December 16th the annual financial statement audit and the bond audit were presented the main takeaways in the financial audit were that there were no material weaknesses or significant deficiencies in internal controls related to the preparation of the 23 24 annual comprehensive financial report commonly referred to as the acfr the bond audit showed that Bonds were progressing as planned with some recommendations for better defining of career learning objectives and more effective implementation of the cbse the center for black student Excellence stormy Shanks the PPS is senior director of school modernization presented plans to implement the outstanding recommendations from past audits this was a long meeting and there's

237a lot of reading material associated with the topics the presentation and discussion are recorded and available on ppss website and board book and it really is pretty interesting if you can get into it a bit um another accountability measure for the PPS Bond program is the oversight provided by an independent group of community members who volunteer their time to serve on the PPS as Bond accountability committee called the BAC on tonight's consent agenda there is a resolution to approve Bond accountability committee members it is noted in the accompanied memo memo um in the memo which notes the appointments tonight the BAC membership will reach a total of nine leaving room for additional members our bond auditor suggested that having members on the BAC you have experience in curriculum and Technology would be a good idea

238so I I'd like to encourage staff to keep that in mind as they actively recruit potential candidates with that experience and also board members if you know anyone to refer with experience in that area that would be a good idea too the next audit committee meeting will be in February or March once we get the meeting confirmed I will let you know and I think you a lot of you on the bond I mean on the audit committee saw that long meeting and were part of that long meeting and Julia especially appreciated your your questions during that and people can um can view that I would just note that we need to make sure that the audit committee and the board is driving what is audited given it's our oversight responsibility versus having staff Define

239audit topics thanks I would like to just for the sake of time maybe we could do the conference supports next next board meeting that's okay with you we heard two you got two more to go right each each conference that you go to all right um next up we have the thank you director solvin uh it's a great report um and next we have the consent agender the board will now vote on the consent agenda board members if there are any items you would like to pull uh for a separate vote please indicate those now just just for the sake of keeping Andrew here I want to pull all of them I was gonna pull all over we vote on everyone great all of them have been pulled are we kidding motion for the entire

240consent agenda as one second did you turn on your mic because if you did it it might be official it was okay oh boy this is going to be a long night um uh Miss Brasa are there any changes to consent agenda no great all right we will now uh do I have a motion are we going we did it I moved second each one indiv J no we was joking am I supposed to know [Music] your entire thing sorry director Scott moose and director green seconds the adoption of the consent agenda any board to discussion on the consent agenda all right the board will now vote on resolution 7031 through 7037 all in favor please indicate by saying yes yes yes allos please indicate by saying no student represent uh conavi yes thank you

241consent agenda as amend is approved by a vote of 7 to zero with student representing can say voting yes um with with that the meeting is adjurned thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.