001matter we have enough all right let's get started uh this special meeting and um work session of the board of education for December 17 2024 is called to order all items being considered this evening are posted on PPS website on the board and meetings tabs the meeting is being streamed live on PPS TV services website and on Channel 28 and will be replayed throughout the next two weeks please check the district website for replay times good evening and welcome uh thank you all for being here today um first up is we have the consent agenda uh we'll board members if there's any items you would like to pull for a later meeting or to vote for a later meeting um we'll set that uh yeah uh Miss Brash are there any changes to consent agenda
002no all right any board members have any issues with the consent agenda is there any public comment on the consent agenda no do I have a motion and a second to adopt the consent agenda second director B my words moves and director Holland seconds the adoption of the consent is there any board discussion on the consent agenda the board will now vote on the consent agenda on resolution 720 through 722 all in favor please indicate by saying yes yes yes yes all opposed please indicate by saying no any exensions uh director solivan I didn't hear your vote yes thank you the consent is approved by a vote of six to zero all right uh see sorry I'm just catching up here um superintendent Armstrong um next up we have the annual comprehensive financial report presentation
003would you like to introduce this item absolutely good evening uh we have here tonight with our Chief Financial Officer mang we have Dan Miley from tabbot Corola and warit to provide this annual compreh iive financial report thank you for being here thank you Dr Armstrong if I may just uh make a brief comment before Mr Miley gives a brief presentation I I hope this is okay I know we had a substantive discussion with the audit committee last night on the same topic so Mr Miley is here prepared to to to share some some of that same content if that's uh if that's the wish of of the board and maybe maybe I can just repeat some of what I said last night as well so on behalf of the finance staff and staff and other
004departments we are very pleased to be able to share um as a prologue to Mr Miley's presentation that we did accomplish uh an ontime and uh clean audit opinion where we we prepared content that U that resulted in a clean AIT opinion which Mr Miley will go through we're really proud of that and we're thankful for all of the many hours of Staff time especially staff in the accounting department also the grants team many folks in the finance division in particular um and we unlike last year where we did have one finding we are happy to be back in the pattern of zero findings uh with this year's audit and and um appreciate the hard work of the tkw team especially Mr Miley for being here on two evenings to present uh his work and
005his colleagues work U on behalf of tkw so with that I'll turn it over to Mr Miley thank you good evening um since I went into a little bit more detail last night tonight um we'll keep it at a higher level um if you have any questions um there'll be some time at the end um the annual comp comprehensive financial report is a large document um a lot of great information in there I encourage people to read it um in addition to the financial statements and notes um which has good information in it of itself there's also mdna U management discussion and Analysis which um provides some analysis of what changed and what happened within the district at a very high level um at the full acral basis so what we would normally think of
006as a business um type of accounting also included is um supplementary information which includes budget to actual comparisons and some information about um pension and other post-employment employment benefits and then at the VAR in is the statistical section which gives various financial and operational um ratios of the 10 and some odd Pages only a few pages are actually our work most of it is the District staff it does take a lot of time and energy for them to put it on and time and energy also to audit all of that um we use two different standards um because of a single audit so uniform guidance requires us to use uniform or uniform guidance use requires us to use a government auditing standards and then we also use um generally accepted auditing standards um interum Field
007Works so planning getting our feet wet um that kind of stuff started in May um final field work began in October in addition to the financial statement audit there was the single audit that I mentioned that was over approximately $109 million of federal expenditures that the district made during the year part of the process is to select major programs there was four major programs selected um which covered 52% of expenditures um the independent auditor report gave a unmodified opinion clean opinion so that's the one that you want um that the financial statements are presented fairly in accordance with the US Gap in addition to the independent audits report on the financial statements there's also a report that we give in accordance with organ state regulations also known as organ minimum standards this includes things as
008procurement budget law those types of things addition one of the tests that we um perform underneath to comply with the organ minimum standards is over teachers experience there is some variances noted um more Det details in there as we discussed last night this is a fairly common um finding with school districts always drive to do better try and find the root cause but it's not uncommon additionally there's the report that we include for over internal controls in accordance with government auditing standards we noted no material weaknesses or significant deficiencies in the internal control controls of the districts and then last but not least is the report on compliance um for the federal expenditures um and we issued an unmodified opinion on all four of the major programs selected we also like to make um sure
009that you are aware of certain things one of those things is that the district implemented a new accounting standard um for accounting changes and error Corrections it had no impact this year because there was no errors and no um new no other new standards implemented um next year this will come into being with the implementation of the next um standard which we'll discuss in a little bit um up there is some significant accounting estimates we encourage the board to keep an eye on these um anytime that there's an estimate it allows for management to introduce bias we're not aware of any bias by management but it's also just as part of your fiduciary responsibilities just keep an eye on does that look reasonable um and those things include things like Investments I mean depreciation does
010it are they um depreciating fixed assets uh Capital assets reasonably Bond premiums pension all the fun things we had no proposed um adjusting entries to the financial statements this year we're aware of no uncorrected misstatements um other than that might be trivial um rounding errors that type of thing um we're not aware of any consultations with any other accountants we're not aware of like opinion shopping or anything else like that um gasby the governmental Accounting Standards Board has issued four standards that will be implemented over the next two years uh gby statement 10 one um will change how the district accounts for compensated appes this also includes sick leave um they change the definition from what's paid to what's paid or used going forward so traditionally um C Le has not been recorded um now
011the district will estimate what they think will be used so a large number has potential to show up on the district's financial statements and other liability I also like to take this point in time like I said last night um reality has not changed these are not new liabilities these are not new things the district has always offered sickly it's just how we account for them changed um and then there's some disclosures and about risks that will be implemented next year and then in uh fiscal year 26 um there's some financial reporting improvements and some disclosure of capital assets coming we also like to take a moment to emphasize a shared responsibility for Independence there's certain things that we do to make sure that we are independent but some of this also relies on the
012district to make sure that you don't inadvertently push us into something that could impair our independence um last but not least is the management representation L letter which is attached to the letter that went with the financial statement reports um that's a separate document um I do like to thank District staff it's a lot of work a lot of questions um over and over again until we get the the right answer um we could not do it without management um but we work for the board so um I'm happy to answer any questions that you may have may may I just make one other comment um this is related to the timing and I I know there was a a good discussion at the audit committee last night so on on behalf of staff I
013do want to acknowledge the that we produced the final work product that was posted to board book I think it was Friday evening so that was several days later than we had hoped to to get all that wrapped up and viewable by yourselves uh and the public so that that uh I know uh didn't leave very much time between uh that visibility and last night's audit committee meeting and tonight's meeting so I do want to apologize for that there were more Loose Ends than uh that just uh needed to to all get reconciled and resolved and and um we're happy that we got to the finish line but it was a little bit after uh our Target date I wanted to acknowledge that yeah thank you for sharing that I think um it's also a
014reminder that all our audits are posted in on the PPS website on the the board tab audits um so this is pretty good holiday reading if you're if you're not you know a little bit lacking didn't have time to go to library so thank you very much for that presentation um before we have kind of discussion let's um I'm sorry I gu let's let's put this on the table uh do I have a motion and a second to adopt resolution 7023 acceptance of the annual comprehensive financial report reports of management and the report on requirements for federal Awards some second director Scott moves uh director Holland seconds all right is there any board discussion I just I want to thank the staff for it looks like a lot of work I haven't read the entire
015audit going to be honest I'm curious about the single audit subjects how you came up with the mix of those four um things to look at so uniform guidance is fairly prescriptive on on how we select those the first test that we use is we set a type what we call a type a threshold and that was $3 million so anything above $3 million that has not been audited in the last two years that has if it was audited had some high-risk findings was designated highrisk um by the federal government or if there was substantial change in how the district was operating the program would kick it into a high-risk type A so those automatically get selected then there's a math that we have to do just to uh determine how many what we call
016type B so underneath that threshold but above another threshold um and then we have to evaluate type B programs until we identify that number so this year it came up to four so um and I think three were type A and then we had one uh type B so three of the programs audited were above the three million and then one was below the three million thank you it always feels a little repetitive to say the same thing I said last night but it is a different audience with eight different people watching online um so I would just um thank the staff thank thank the staff uh for all their work on closing the books and and thank tkw for the audit it's it is always refreshing to have a clean audit without any material
017weaknesses um one of the things I I will and I I think I noted last night um you know that that remaining issue with the data around the teacher experience levels of something that we've experienced in the past other districts in Oregon experience it it's kind of an endemic problem I wish someone at maybe the state level would look at how to make that data a little bit more um easily accessible um the other thing I will just note is you know our material weaknesses in last year's audit um were were at least in part driven by some staffing um issues and challenges and so I think it just highlights even more how hard the staff work um because we've continued to take reductions um you know in these areas um with budget reductions and
018so again to to you know what what makes a clean audit without material weaknesses is that you've had staff all year who have been doing their job and putting things in the the pots they're supposed to go in and accounting for things the way they're supposed to go and then the auditor comes in and says you either did it right or you did it wrong um so I'm really glad we did it right um again um even in this lean environment it was nice to be able to see that so thank you um and then also just to follow up staff um we make oursel available to staff throughout the year so we in we took calls throughout the year if there was a transaction that staff was not en entirely comfortable with or didn't
019know quite the guidance um sometimes they rely on us we do the research we say here here's what the here's what gby says and then provide some some advice thank you any other board discussion sure um thank you for the presentation and all the work and congratulations on the clean audit and I'll just Echo um Dr Scott's comments on the the years of exper we've had that before and it always like every time that comes up it's just s of a quirky thing that um gets reported and um to me doesn't at all um detract from um the good work that the team has done uh I have um two questions I asked last night that I did tell staff I was going to ask again um this evening and I think I'm gonna go
020with what I think is hopefully easier question first and this is a question for um Dan young about the or if somebody else can answer it um I'll take whoever wants to answer um about that on page 18 there's um a statement that we had 98 million um dollars from the 2017 um bond that was primarily Investments earnings and that was a surprise to me because we were 100 million short um for the bond and we actually had to put half of the Benson in the 2020 Bond so I'm just curious what what those dollars are that existed at the time of the audit and like are they already allocated for something else what are they allocated for Mr Young and I might team up on this kind of have two different Vantage points to
021this I mean it's great news don't get me wrong but I'm just curious because we had this whole like that's why we hired the bond Auditor in 2018 because we were short 100 million and then sure so the the just kind of recap make sure I'm following so the audit identifies how much is remaining to be spent from the 2017 audit those aren't the same as unallocated funds or savings so those we can get a full accounting but the majority of those are allocated to projects we just haven't completed all the projects like the health and safety projects and I think there's some funds in there probably for Benson as well because that's a split front so those are to be expended they just haven't been expended yet because all the work of the 2017
022fond is not yet complete they were described as investment earnings so that's that's not what they are their unallocated bond funds or their allocated bond funds that are still sitting there because in the audit it says that they're primarily it's on page 18 they're primarily investment earnings I will take a stab at this so investment earnings come in annually for investments from the the bond proceeds that the district has when the those are realized the on the bond team we put those into program contingency and so that increases the the program contingency that can then support uh projects so when whatever that Pro program contingency is used for whether it mean augmenting projects for unanticipated costs or could be supporting new scope of work or could be a new scope work within an existing project
023so from the bond sort of management standpoint investment earnings come in as new Revenue but we don't hold them as a separate line so that line in of itself doesn't doesn't say where those funds are again the remaining to be spent from the 2017 is in existing projects they just haven't been fully expended yet so you had 790 million from which is what approved and this is what it says investment ear earnings 98 million over and above the 790 or is that a semantic that I shouldn't that's not really what it is you want me if I if I can uh take a stab I believe that the investment earnings are are associated with the bond proceeds at whatever points in time the bonds were issued and sold and and U deposited in construction funds
024or what whatever sorts of funds so since the authorization took place in 2017 Dan help me uh remember how many uh bond series of bonds there were I think there were maybe three different issuances of bonds uh connected with that authorization totaling $790 million so in each case the bond proceeds are deposited into construction funds Etc and do generate interest while they are awaiting expenditure so over the course of those six seven years that would be a substantial opportunity to generate investment earnings that's over andove the 790 correct okay right great um and Dan I'm assuming if we want to look at where the 2017 allocations went it's on the um like BAC the bond correct the BAC reports show by uh bomb programs so 2017 the projects what's uh what's funded what's been expended
025and then what the forecast to to to complete this and then my other question um that was supposed to be the easy one sorry um the other question was in it this and I'm just going back to the conversations we had last year with um teachers union and then eventually with the um the governor and the state about just our revenue and expenses and in this audit it says that revenues were up 6.5% or 73 million and expenses were only up 4.8% or 47 million so it looks like actually our revenues were ahead of our expend our expenses and is that explain how that is when we also had to cut 30 million doll last year and then heading into 740 million and it's not because I don't believe it or I'm saying I just
026think it begs the question of like how does is work that we actually have more money coming in than our expenses right thank you director brim Edwards so there there and we talked about this uh somewhat last night uh but just to to point out a few different factors I think the most significant factor is that table on page uh 22 the table and then the accompanying narrative in the in that paragraph and I know not everybody might have these documents pulled up in front of them so I'll try to uh I'll try to uh reference that as well so folks can follow along um the both the table and that language refers to uh in late person's terms all of the district's funds rather than just the general fund so if you think about
027special Revenue Capital funds um Debt Service fund Etc then then we're talking about the total of the increases in revenues percentage wise total dollars uh and the changes in expenditures for all of those those funds together that's what's described in in that paragraph there is I went back and looked at this after the meeting yesterday there is is um there's a another series of descriptions on page 24 which specifies and breaks out uh the components of of those aggregate numbers so on page 24 there's a paragraph for the general fund that uh basically summarizes that the ending fund balance in the general fund decreased by 19 million because we spent $19 million more than than we took in in terms of revenues and that's that's really the most direct connection to the conversations that I
028think you're to be accurate to describe that um while our overall revenues may be exceeding our expenses within our general fund which is the fund on which we pay for generally staff and other more discretionary items that that's the fund that's Contracting and that's that's where the the budget cuts are even though overall there may be out outside of the general fund yes I think that's a fair uh description and in in our conversations about the Gap that we anticipate in any at any given year looking ahead to the next year and we will be talking about that uh to an extent later on in this meeting those are focused on the general fund uh for the reasons that you that you just mentioned director B medwards I will also say there's another helpful table
029in this uh in this aord document it's on page which includes Pages 34 and 35 but page 34 has has a breakout of figures for the general fund so on that page you can see specific Revenue actual revenues in the general fund um line by line likewise actual expenditures in in various categories and um you can see towards the bottom of that page the net change in fund balance in the general fund was uh negative $19 million right so thank you thank you done need to move on um and I want to make sure the other directors have a chance to to talk want to make one comment um I first of all Qui me I want to appreciate your comment about the timing of of receiving it and I also appreciate last night um
030because I didn't support having this discussion and vote on it tonight with such little time but I do appreciate that you said that we could um engage the auditor um and um District staff if we have further questions about it so I appreciate that I also want to note that I'm really concerned that our local option taxes and construction excise tax I think for the first time in two decades had year-over-year Decline and revenue um which is because of the economic conditions in downtown and that's going to put further pressure on our budget thank you I appreciate that and very good questions um director Holland any questions director solivan no I don't have any questions I'm glad and I was able to bring up the pages that were being discussed which made it much clearer
031for me I want to thank uh young for going back looking at it and clarifying it and I also um really appreciate that Julia is bringing that forward so that everybody knows we can ask questions and look and I really appreciate that um and that's all so thank you thank you um Dr Green no I don't have any questions thank you all right awesome and director brim I think um if we if we do have more questions I think this is a really good topic to to also kind of plan for future a committee meetings um I want to thank all of you especially this is a lot of work and this is a huge report and so thank you for being here to to answer our questions um we'll now um we also want
032to want to note that I was going to put this as part of the um audit committee report but guess I'm jumping ship a little bit but the audit committee did refer this out and recommend that um we the board accept the um acceptance of annual comprehensive financial report all right so the board will now vote on wait I think I jumped myself um the board will oh wait sorry Miss Brash is there any public comment no all right uh the board will now vote on uh resolution 7023 acceptance of the annual comprehensive financial report reports to management and the report on requirements for federal Awards by voting yes we are acknowledging that we have heard and received the results of the annual comprehensive financial report all in favor ready uh please indicate by saying
033yes yes yes yes yes yes all oppos please indicate by saying no uh there are no extensions correct all right the resolution 7023 is approved by a vote of seven to zero thank you very much thank you all right um next up we have the audit committee report um director uh Sullivan is the chair of the audit committee but asked me to sub for yesterday's meeting so I'll do my best to give a report um yesterday we met and reviewed the annual Bond performance uh audit f for audit fiscal year 2022 23 with uh our contracted Bond performance Auditors from I don't know how to pronounce this name soberg jerg uh EV evek Consulting as part of sorry I'm really sorry if I mispronounced your name uh sec I'll just say for short as thank
034you as part of their audit they uh they assess the performance of both the 2017 and 2020 Bond programs focused on um the delivery status of the 2017 and 2020 Bond projects they also highlighted some clear uh career learning Equity protocols uh review of the practices um the uh shared some um of their thoughts on the review of practices to deliver the 2020 Bond curriculum and information technology work um the interesting Parts They concluded that in the 2017 Bond program was on track for completion uh we which we celebrate with the opening of the Benson High School on the uh building for the multiple Pathways of graduation program um with PPS addressing some scheduled costs and scope challenges along the way to meet the intent behind the bond commitments uh the 2020 Bond uh for
035curriculum technology are progressing as planned and have strong Frameworks for in place for delivery they did make two recommendations related to the career learning Equity program uh to help the program meet its state of object objectives or suggested that District revise the scope of work um during the committee meeting we also uh received an update from senior director stormmy Shanks on the bond performance audit recommendation implementation plan which probably gave the audit committee a l homework from now on right um did I miss anything for anyone else who is there who wants to add anything um I think it was also um the cbsc wasn't on track and to try to uh bring that up to speed that was another place that uh the bond needed work or the bond one of the bond work
036so um only thing I would add is um just the suggestion that going forward we and this is this is a Board responsibility that um next spring we get the the bond audit and then um review it in the spring versus December um which is relatively late and also the other place where the audit committee really should be weighing in is um on top potential of topics that um we're concerned about with the um with the bond implementation because that was set by staff last year versus um versus the Board having any input and that's an important place in which we can if there's areas of concern or areas you want to elevate or give more detail about that we could have so that those are just other the things that I would suggest that
037we get on the audit committee's agenda this year thank you for that um all right that concludes the audit committee report let's move on to the next topic unless there's any questions from anyone on up here we're good all right uh next we will review the the draft for the general obligation Bond referral language um superintendent Armstrong would you like to start us off on this yes thank you um so we have appreciated the conversation as we work through our our final draft and so we have our chief operating officer Dan young who will walk you through our proposed option for the evening so thank you Dan for being good evening again I have a short presentation we'll walk through um and then we'll get to your questions so that's the run a show tonight
038and then um take any feedback that you may have so really want to just kind of highlight what the the updated Bond option is and then and then answer some questions have come up in previous meetings um so we'll jump in I put together my notes in kind of a quick haste so I might be a little choppier than normal not that I'm always that smooth but uh if you have questions as we go along please feel free to stop me and ask if I'm not clear uh so materials in your packets tonight you should have a copy of the draft Bond language uh the exhibit a which is the updated proposed Bond option uh staff memo on the design modernization process that that was sent out last week and then a memoral about the
039Native American Success Center here are the bond parameters that we were using to develop the bond these should be pretty familiar uh as as I noted uh earlier we're going to C uh touch on just a couple of specific topics uh here's the current Bond program uh it closely aligns to what those parameters were you'll notice that the total is a little over that $ 1.8 billion Target that we were going for by less than 2% uh but it's close and all the other uh goals uh it achieves and so the where the blue arrows are we're just going to highlight a couple of notes uh at the last meeting there are some questions about how facilities uh how we prioritize facility Improvement projects uh so I want to touch on this uh the proposed
040option includes 190 million for facility improvements uh previous ball materials included a sample of how those funds could be spent over the course of the bond which we estimate between 8 and 10 years uh and just noted the need for flexibility in the use of these funds and why flexibility is important broadly is just given the large and diverse facility needs of the district and acknowledging that we have a longer term Horizon this 8 to 10 years and recognizing that our data is not perfect that we have on on our facilities it's a essential that we have flexibility approach which allows us to adapt and respond to needs over the course of time and in the course of the bomb program uh this slide we don't need to to re-review this information again it should
041be fairly familiar but really what the upshot is there's more work uh that needs to be done that we're able to address in one Bond I think we've we've acknowledged that um and du to the the needs we're going to be addressing the highest facility priorities and what we plan on focusing on as much as we can our improvements that improve the facility condition of the district so we probably like that's fine now how do you actually do that prioritization um so I'll explain the process and this is definitely an over simplification uh but due to Resource restrictions uh we can only complete so much work at one time and when we're planning this type of work out in the future uh we typically look uh out 12 12 to 18 months it sort of
042depends and the things that we consider is how much work can we complete over that time based upon the resources both the funding and the staff resources uh and then we look at what available facility condition data we have we have lots of different data points we have our facility condition assessment we have work quarter data uh we have what we call project development requests uh which are requests from schools or other departments for improvements um and so we we look at that data and some of that data is really great like for example we'll look at our roofs and we have because we've done a lot of roof work over the years we have site specific roof analysis so we're pretty pretty confident able to say which roofs are in the worst condition and
043which ones need to be addressed first with the available funds uh when we look at other scopes of work like site improvements and sidewalks and Paving we don't have that same level of data so we really rely heavily on what the current condition is and our boots on the ground folks our custodians our maintenance team to tell us where is that worst condition so if we're planning over the next year to two years where should we prioritize that work and then we really we repeat that for all these scopes of work and they're all important Scopes they all Impact schools they all support learning and so when we're planning out for that Horizon and the amount that we're able to achieve we try to hit the highest priorities and also a spread of different scope
044of works so that is what our general approach is and it's it's ongoing and it's iterative we're doing this on a regular basis uh but that is how we approach how we plan this work and why what this shows as a sample of going through that process over and over over the next eight to 10 years a sample of how we might spend those funds when it when it comes to the end of the day and how we're approaching that work and I'd be remiss if I didn't know emergency and unplanned projects the sample shows about a third of the total budget for that just because of the age and condition of our of our Building Systems uh it's not uncommon to have a failure that impacts or some sort of deterioration that actually impact
045school those become emergent and high priority we even if they're on our list to get done that day that it becomes an emergent item we look to take care of it that day so I hope that's somewhat clear happy to answer questions I have a quick question um so the roof we have really good data on the roof condition because those are included in that long range facility assessment or facility condition um but you said the site work and the sidewalks and some of those other um items that don't come up regularly um we just kind of eyeball it is there a way um when we're out doing work that we can assess the condition of of of our facilities from the site work and a sidewalk and some of those other um you know
046um fields MH so we have better data so we're not just relying on our staff that is walking by one day happens to be there doing some work electrical work sure I was thinking of like a more systemic way of gathering that data for the future yeah it's a it's a great question and um we say we have bad data we just don't have great data and sometimes site that site specific data our facility condition assessment which we completed about four years ago identified over 15,000 deficiencies uh so that's a lot and but the identifies where there's a need so we've got a lot of information of like here is a deficiency that you need to address what it doesn't do is take it to that next step which would be like the project scoping
047what do you actually need to do holistically to address that work and then we'd move into design and bidding and construction so it would take so I guess the point is we have these initial data points we need to prioritize based upon on that to be able to take it to the next level because we can't take all 15,000 plus the additional that that great level of detail where we be able to prioritize and estimate at at such uh a level that we could plan out for decades does that make sense I feel like that okay yes it does thank you any other questions comments discussion director BS yeah go for it thank you um I'm G start with page four um Propst option um I'm G to note that the Athletics which is later
048on has been even though the number is fairly close has been fairly um I love it there's been some cost um estimating that has um I think allows us to more effectively um cover more Fields um so that we would have um it looks like swing space for um at Jackson for the I Wells um and um also um some additional Fields um at Marshall um which would also be um swing space in addition I think it's very prudent that $1 million has been set aside for future um Turf and track Replacements we know they they need to be replaced and so I'm glad to see that so that's just a comment about that um I want to be um I'm not sure if it's unintentional or um but I think we need to be
049absolutely clear about what we mean by modernizations because to date at PPS modernizations have been a rebuild like a totally new building um or a significant major Remodel and I brought this up before but we're continuing to describe the Elementary Middle School modern some as modernizations and are we going to be replacing any Elementary or middle schools and I don't know who to ask this question to but it's currently the way that it's phrased it implies that it's what we're doing for the high schools and my understanding is we're trying to actually um get some cost Savings in the high school so that we can do like improvements repairs but they're not modernization so but it keeps being labeled of modernization so I just want to make sure that I understand what it is we're
050being asked to approve or what is that is in that bucket yes I appreciate the question and it is our belief that um if in fact uh significant cost savings incur that we will be able to put um those funds towards U modernizing um an elementary school or middle school as we continue to look at our needs over um the next several years because it's our belief that um that modernizing the high schools isn't the only that isn't where you know we stop right but as it was portrayed earlier is that Dan has this list of eight billion dollars of something of like deferred maintenance and improvements and that's what the fund would be going towards versus a building a new school new elementary middle school but you're you're saying that's what you mean yes
051I think where we have some of the deferred maintenance and priority scope projects is in that 190 uh Million number and then the other latter part in the bucket not necessarily called out because we want to know what the cost savings will be um should there be any from the high school remodels that would go towards continuing our work on redesigning our schools modernizing our schools uh so I'm just going to speak for myself a board member so that's not at all what I thought it was I thought it was to be added to the 190 million um dollar pot of money um I think I forget you always use the term of what's the annual deferred maintenance like 90 million like a billion dollars yes I um I don't think we've ever put a
052plug number into like we're going to build a new a new school um without some pretty significant con conversation about it and I guess I would be concerned about the all the elementary and middle schools that need sort of basic not the I mean they all need to be modernized eventually but that we wouldn't be putting money into like haax and roofs and the the the mechanical systems which I think is more this other category again the 190 million um so I want a fair amount more information about that because I I would be hesitant to can I just add something in here I I feel like the semantic issue that maybe we're getting a little twisted on I hear what you're saying Dr you you view modernization as a rebuild of a school which
053it can be obviously is for the high schools I think what the super was saying is it may be a rebuild of a high school or an elementary or middle school it may also be other modernizations fixing you know a wing that's falling down right do those other things exactly what I thought it was but my question is if if there's a better word that you'd prefer we use like what is that word and maybe we can just move forward with it because I I think it's I mean I think it's what we've been what it's consistent with what we've been talking about the last few meetings um and and I don't want the word modernization to somehow become confusing yeah well I think it'll be confusing to the general PPS Community because for since
054I don't think it will be but why don't we not worry about what the community thinks and just what word would you prer I think it's important like what what is can let me what is it we're asking our community to approve and modernizations in the 2011 the 2012 the 2017 the 2020 Bond meant like a whole new school great what word should we use we should use like like priority improvements great I mean I'm fine with that priority improvements sounds great yeah okay great so we're so we're changing so we're changing priority scope to say priority improvements and moving the elementary middle line up no I would maybe just get modernizations and improvements and yeah priority improvements priority impr thank you um so I'm confused um about the two lines um one's Cleveland High
055School and the other's Cleveland High School power Park option and neither one of them has a dollar amount um and I know that also was considered so I'm curious is this is the one line Cleveland High School does that mean um just the high school and no um additional facilities improvements and that the one that you get the athletic facilities improvements since they're not in the other document is the pile Park option yeah it's a good question and it needs a little uh historical context when we first putting this Charter chart similar together all the the schools had an in you know a line where there was a budget number and when the Cleveland comprehensive plan was approved uh that was approved for a specific dollar amount and then there was also the pow Park
056option which we called an option which had a separate dollar amount so we were just showing it separate and they were both funded uh the Powell Park option as we call it which could use a better name we'll take suggestions uh but really was uh it was it was first include as an option because it was a piece of property that wasn't controlled controlled by PPS uh which you know we'd be required to do more work before we could improving that and there's also questions about the suitability of the park so the team is still looking at other potential options whether if Powell's the best or if there's another site that is would ultimately be preferred the intent to show is that whatever that option is is funded under that modernization budget line so maybe
057the better thing is not to be identifying P par but just like with athletic facilities and scope yes that would be it would be C clearer it would just be helpful because it's confusing to have two lines and um agreed that's another thing um also last U meeting we hadn't uh a board discussion about the um Center for Native Student Success and and um we have a proposal that's been submitted and I would ask that the Indian parent committee have an opportunity to present their propos to the board um so that's a request because our form has never allowed and it um I think they should have an opportunity to bring It Forward we said the community hadn't brought something forward they brought something forward um and our meetings haven't been structured in which um
058people have been had an opportunity to present present that so that would be a request um and then specifically to are you requesting that for today or for a future meeting well for it to happen um I mean I don't know what our schedule is before our referral but I I think they should have an opportunity to present it it keeps not being included in any sort of the materials and um I think it is a tonight's material uh right but it's justat personal testimony yeah I was going to say that um should there be some minutes allocated we do have the interim chair uh Tamar Brown here from the Indian parent committee if she wanted to uh come forth and present what's in the letter that was submitted but um I don't know if
059we queued up any uh presentation or give give anyone any prompt to presenting anything so um so I don't I don't know she could we could we make an arrangement to give some time on the seventh I'm just curious I mean and it just not that everybody know how I feel around that anyway but I guess my question is we are going to entertain that is there a spot in the current proposal when we talk about these dollars that we're going to really shift or look reason why I say that because I really don't want to waste people's time if it's not something that we can really physically or financially put into this and if we are going to look at that where the tradeoffs going to be at from the number that we have
060here because it's been you know overwhelmingly majority has not want to go past the 1.8 and we gone past it already so I'm just curious if in the essence of wasting folks time are getting people hopes up to really do some do we really have a majority of the board that are willing to really look at what we're going to take off of this to even make that happen or not make that happen I think we need to make a decision about that as well because just having them up here just for the sake of to have them up here and really not being intentional if we are really going to do something as a majority of the board I think we should have have that that discussion at some point before we start bringing
061them up and doing all that as well I'll just note that we have had um unlike any of our other PA bonds we've had no Community forums to hear from the community even to present I mean even tonight um if we're talking about the language where there's not an opportunity for not only people to present but even people to provide public comments um this is the first bond that we've had that doesn't have a bond stakeholder committee um that meets in advance provides a recommendation um so um I'm I'm gonna go back to you this this issue was put on the table last spring and there hasn't been an opportunity and I've raised it every meeting and it has there hasn't been an opportunity and I just think that's the so right right thing to
062do if I if I jump in um there's a couple points I want to make um one it's it's completely inaccurate to say that there was no opportunity for Community input we've had multiple meetings with lots of opportunity for public comment we've gotten lots of public comment um from the community about the bond options so that's been out there um director ber as I understand you did um put this on the table in the spring that was the first time i' had heard of it to my knowledge you haven't done anything to bring a board resolution to direct staff to work on it um you haven't sort of brought that forward in the committee meetings until recently and you've brought it Forward just in that way of saying hey there's a proposal out there which
063we did finally receive and I want to be really clear I'm really happy about the proposal we got I think there's a lot of interesting um ideas and a potential for something in the future what I'm worried about is whether that's even remotely close to something that we would want to or could responsibly include in a bond that we're planning to refer this may it feels to me like in that document there are some requests for facilities which is what a capital Bond can be used for there are lots of requests for improved systems and lots of requests for improved instruction and lots of requests for things that the district absolutely can and should be doing um but that may not be appropriate to be in a capital Bond um and I think doing some
064work is going to take some time not just to fully flesh out what this even should be but then to work with the community on making sure that we're doing what again is reflective I appreciate the group that's come forward but um you know there's there's a there's a big idea here and and what I would maybe put on the table um for the superintendent to chew on and consider is is there a process that the school district could engage in that really looks at the issues that are being brought forward by this community and really looks at the struggles that we know our native students have to figure out what is the best path forward whether that is building a center which was sort of proposed here whether it's um doing something at one
065of our existing schools or programs where maybe it's even part of one of these modernizations um you know doing something in that regard but but it doesn't feel ready to me um to include in a in a bond that we're referring in May I I would just want respond to that is I've tried to be respectful of the process that we've had and the process we've had is to bring things to the the committee which I've done and I brought it last spring and it's not board member's job to direct staff to do anything the job M's job to bring a resolution to the board to get a majority to direct I'll just say there was can can I no no I want to stop this because I think you two should argue offline um
066sorry you let you let him have a long a long time too um so I just want to reiterate in my my stance I think this is I think there's a lot of things in The Proposal that are very interesting and I'm very interested in in exploring definitely um I just want to also share that as a someone who's taught for 20 years I've been very lucky to have many many Native American students and and this is not unique just in you know a lot of our Native American students but this it seems like there's you know anecdotally a high level of a sense of not feeling like they belong somewhere and I think you know that as a teacher when you hear that that just really aches and it's it's one of those things
067where you know I I agree with director Scott in that we really should look into to how to do something well right not not just a capital Bond may be great but if we're trying to create a place where people feel like they belong and and uh in a center I think we really need to flesh out um what's going to work and I think that's that's super important to um and then you know also have time to kind of include all our stakeholders in this as well and and really get community input um whether that be uh building a center in a school or or building programming um you know all that is I think on the table and I think I just want to reiterate as a board member one of my priorities
068is to make sure that uh our Native American students are feel more belonging in the future than they do now last last committee meeting we asked them the community to bring something forward they did and they brought it Forward actually with a lot of community support and in 2020 we actually just put a line in the bond that we were going to co-create the Center for black student excellence and it was going to be co-created there wasn't any really detail at all and that was what we put in what got put in the bond and so I think there's a different standard being applied to Native students and Native families but and I I say last meeting the request was they should bring something forward and they did so um and there's not going to
069be another bond for 10 years um so if we going to want to have a face like this is the opportunity to do it um it's not just about programming and I think this is also about again are we saying here's what we think they need or are we listening to what they are saying that they would like and I think it's very very different and I I it's confusing to say like we don't think they know what they need well I appreciate your comment um director brim Edwards and I appreciate um director Scott's d uh Direction and and suggestion to work with the um Native families and community on uh what it would mean to have um a space that is uh designed with them in mind I don't think that those things have
070to be exclusive of one another I think over the next eight years one of the line items as you all um see in there with the elementary and middle is I think as we renamed priority projects I think one of the things I appreciate in um the letter received by uh Mrs Brown was um sort of an either or either a new site or um redeveloping an existing one although it didn't name an elementary or middle school it absolutely could be you know we have a native Monastery school we know that there's work happening Across the Nation on revitalizing um the native language and I think that with some of the things that they're hoping for or even all of the things things they're hoping for can exist in a modernized redesigned elementary school that
071is grounded in principles uh for the uh first people so I just I want to say that by engaging in a process and um having conversations we have opportunities as we will continue to have conversations on priority projects under modernization of some other sites that could be a win-win um all involved and not have to wait more than eight years that could be in this cycle I think that's the benefit of the flexible language and knowing that we have a pot of money that we'll use to revitalize modernize and prioritize our buildings across the city I really appreciate that superintendent Armstrong because Pasco she hasn't on yet thank you I'm sorry I'm GNA jump in um I really appreciate just hearing from everybody and also Advocate very strongly for being very intentional about putting the
072language um in our bond um as a placeholder even if we don't have details where the building is going to be where it's located how big it's going to be and we can't in the bond um address programming necessarily um but if we're honing to our mission then we need to hone to that mission of creating joyful inclusive learning spaces and this very very much fits in within our um within our our mission in very much within one of the letters talked about the history of our school district and just our national history with Indian education and it's I feel like this board um our values are around leaning into trying to repair or or help where we can and this this is a symbol of that help and a promise for the kids of
073the future you know the kids that we are not serving very well and haven't for for 173 years so I I'm going to advocate for it too and being and being intentional about it not I don't feel comfortable just saying you know it'll be in here somewhere because then you know a roof collapses or something else happens and we don't then have that intentionality so I'd like to see it be very intentionally and and Spilled Out the only thing I just want to say is that with our priority projects being under modernization it wouldn't go towards the um facility improvements or some of those emergency things that happen um but if it is the the direction of the board to list in I guess we would need to know dollar amount and then we would
074also need to know what would come out of the bond to be able to put that in so that we can process that but um I think the win-win is being able to um you know have it be with our modernization and priority projects and we have um time to be able to sit with with community and really understand what that could be um as opposed to um you know deciding do we do we build an exclusive uh Center uh or do we modernize an elementary school and having to make that that choice so just a suggestion I I really appreciate um superintendent Armstrong you speaking to this because you're the first um person who's engaged in the discussion I think that's really helpful and a message um of intentionality um so I appreciate that
075I'm with um director to pass I think we should name it um and speaking of naming it I actually have have some more questions around um the actual Bond Bond language and this is um can I check out the rest before we'll go back to you okay um director Sullivan did you do you have any questions about the respond um yes I have I have concerns I know um Julia says it came up last spring I don't remember that um she also I know at the last board meeting it came up after we' talked about the bond for a long time and put uh numbers down down in certain areas so it seems like if we're putting it in there we have to take it out of somewhere else and I don't see a lot
076of place to do that I certainly see a way to bring the native community in for discussion of the best way to find a place for them that doesn't a special place for them I know there's a lot of work that's been done to try to make the Native American Community feel comfortable in our school but it's not obviously exactly where we want it to be um I feel kind of pressured into this myself that it came just pretty much the last board meeting and now and then of course a lot of letters have come in and nobody would ever say they don't want to have a special a special place for the Native American Community certainly not me but I'm I just don't think the place for it right now is in this Bond
077um doesn't mean we can't be working on one with in the district but I just don't see it as in the bond director just for what's worth um director Sten it came up as part of the um all of the capital Bond work we did in the facilities and operations committee last spring when we were putting together the the larger the larger lists and we had people come and um provide public comment about it at the time so it was a committee level which is my why you probably didn't see it no I did not see it it didn't come to the board I don't think the whole board thank you director salvin director green did you have any questions comments discussion the only thing I would add would be echoing some of the things
078that said I don't um have I believe that if we can figure out the language and that if we could follow some of the things that Dr Armstrong um has mentioned that that could work in um that that could work for us I would like to see um if we're going to a level of intentionality around um do we increase I know we don't want to increase the bond um because of you know we we're concerned about what it could be but is this a space is this a space where we could increase it um by the same 60 million um that we did when we did the center of black Excellence um and then we put that out there um for the community um to to see or are we afraid that if we
079if we increase it by 60 million so that we can include a line item that the whole thing would fail I I know I'm I'm clear on all the the conversations that we've had around it being a gamble um I just from a mindset perspective believe that our Community wants us to do what's there is a line in the sand but our community wants us to do what's right for all of our students um and I don't believe the line is at 60 million um and so and again I just randomly picked that number because that was the number that we had for um the CBE um and so but again I I don't I don't have a an issue with us including some sort of language I believe that it could um it could
080go with the with the um the modernization that Dr Armstrong was talking about um but this could be one of those spaces where we say okay this this is actually so important to us and it's so important to our community that this warrants Us increasing our our bond ask so that we can make sure that we're intentional about being inclusive of it so um that's that's all I've got on it thank you director green director Holland yeah and so I just want to make sure I'm clear with with my my view on this um I would absolutely love to increase the bond everybody I have been there not been a secret of mine to increase the bond um I would I worry and this is just my maybe my own internal um barometer is i
081w worry of us just putting it under the modernization and poverty improvements and for whatever reason it don't get done you know I think you you know when we look about our our communities and I'm saying ours because you know I feel we we we share the some of the same issues is that you know I don't want to just put something out there that's just out there and it doesn't really happen that's happened to our communities a lot that happens over and over again um and so if we are going to look at doing something then I would definitely look at increasing the bond to do that um I really worry about just putting it in because if we start just putting everything in party improvements then I'm G want to put some stuff
082in party improvements and somebody else might want to put something and then all of a sudden we just got this big vague list of party Improvement which we have over a billion dollars of party improvements that we already have to have um so I just really worry about the just putting it in there just for sake of putting it in without having any real teeth behind it um so that's just that's my uh my Su but I I am definitely in agreeance with Dr Armstrong as far as looking at programming some of the programs we can do without it being in the in the in this Bond piece because I think there is a lot of opportunities to do things around our native Community um so that's I just put that out there thank you
083TR if you don't mind if I go really quick and then I'll call on you next oh that's fine just kind of iterate my position on this uh you know as a as a teacher as a former teacher some of these proposals I can in in the in the in the proposal that was submitted to us I can see working um you know again I don't know everything and um I I'm G to say that up front I don't know everything um I I do I have questions about a separate Center I think as from my experience I have a hard time imagining how that would help I mean it may and I could be wrong but that's the thing I think what I would need in order to support a separate Center would be
084if there's information or data from other districts that have done something similar that have worked I am much more inclined to support something that is buils an elementary school program and a middle school program that is specific to targeting um creating belonging and a sense of community among our our native and and just addressing the specific needs of our Native American community um and so personally I think if if we're going to adjust the language I would at this moment because we haven't really had much time to kind of delve into the options and the pathways and and what has worked and what hasn't worked I would I would be supportive of language that kind of reiterates what Dr Armstrong um superintendent Armstrong has said um in terms of I really do worry about committing
085a lot of money to make perhaps a center that maybe may turn out to not be the best way forward and it just took up a lot of time lot staff time a lot of money and resources that could have been put somewhere else more effectively and so I am concerned about that I'm not saying that that is the wrong path I am saying that I'm just concerned about that path and so um that's that's just where I stand I I I I would having a statement that supports our Direction and our our intent to serve those communities 100% um how it turns out I am undecided dor Sal okay um so I'm you know after looking at the bond accountability um report and one place where we have not done our work well or
086at least we are behind is with the um Center for black student excellence and so I'm just kind I mean if we had tons of money of course I'd love to do everything but we don't and I think we just need to follow up and get the cbsc going right uh see how that works and as um Dr Wong said is a sender a single Senter the best way to go anyway we we don't even have that um that information so I'm just thinking it's it's too late to add it to the bond it's it's unrealistic to think we don't have to take something else out if we add it and I think we need to to stay with what we've been discussing up to this point chair um did you want yeah I would
087I would agree with what um direct Sven said um I think I think what concerns me is everyone keeps talking about maybe adding it but but what the it is is is not defined and and so it's not defined in the proposal that came forward and it hasn't been defined by any board members up here and so I just want to remind folks what we include in here the only thing that's can be spent on as a facility it cannot be spent on programming it can't be spent on curriculum it can't be spent on training uh take that back about curriculum it can't be spent on curriculum but it can't be spent on programming or training or operations which it feels like are incredibly important component of what I read in that proposal um which
088is again comes back to the idea that that that we the district has not done its job um defining what it is that will really improve the outcomes for our native students and if we're going to spend $40 million of a district I don't think it's on a community center for Native students I don't think it's on a building I I think it's a combination it may involve some space for sure but I think it involves in other other things as well and I'm going to say something that's really going to anger my colleagues but I'm short timer and so um but I think it's important it's important for the community to hear this the conversation you're hearing up here tonight is performative it's not substantive and that's a problem because we all want to
089do something that makes it look like we're doing something and if we put $40 million in here and we put a line item in here then we're going to be able to say hey look at us we did something for the native community and then sort of like the center for black student Excellence five years from now we're going to come back and there's going to be an audit that says you haven't really done much with that money that you set aside for the native student you know uh Improvement you haven't really done much and so what would be actually non-performative would be if this board did its homework developed a resolution worked with the community on a long engaged process worked with the superintendent or staff to develop a resolution that said this is
090what we're going to do over the next six months 12 months 18 months 24 months for the native Community it may involve investing some dollars in facilities and it may involve a lot of other things that this District could be doing and I'm going to be stepping off the board but that's what I would recommend we do I I I I don't I I will not support this going in because it's not ready to go in it wouldn't be responsible for us to refer to the voters un ready if it is going to go in I do think we should reduce the amount because otherwise why don't we throw another 100 or 200 or you know to your throw another billion dollars there um and and I I I do think though it would be
091really important for this this board to do something substantive not just something that makes us feel good I don't even know how to come back from that performative statement I don't take it personally though um I just want to say when we were talking about the center for black excellence in 2020 it was also very undefined in fact we didn't know if it was going to be a building or if it was a concept and we left it very vague intentionally to allow for the Deep uh stakeholder engagement that You' need to come to a thing that thing has been over the last four years defined and there's been more clarity around it but we didn't put you know we're going to put a red building on Albin and Russell you know in a place
092and and Define it because we wanted it to be directed by the community that that that we're trying to serve in much the way that we've got a vague kind of an idea proposal um I also have a little bit of issue of requiring an advocate from a community to come in specifically into the in the box that we make for them and say well you know we can't do programming and we can't do this and that but we can do something and and is more than performative because this community is asked for them for us to consider including um a line item in our bond that puts a center they haven't to find it it's going to require a lot more stakey holder engagement and it's rushed and I think we could still do
093it just my opinion it's the last thing I'll say about it because I know we need so I'm just I'm just I'm kind of respond a little bit I think when we talk about the center for back Excellence right it was a pilot and we're learning you know things best practices you know from Community engagement to how things could go great right and I wasn't here for it you know when I got presented but I think if if we don't learn from from the lessons of that then we're can repeat the same the same issues that it had and so while we haven't finished it and and got it to a point where we can say okay this is a pilot this is how it worked I think we'll be doing a disservice for another
094Community to put them in that same boat and then once again we're talking about four or five years later figuring it out and I I just I just once again I just keep worried about it we put it in just to put it in and when we talk about the party improvements we haven't even got the cost of what the high school is going to be yet and we're still working on that so it's like we're putting in hoping that we have enough savings to do the elementary and middle schools and the center for uh Native Americans right that that's that doesn't have teeth to me that doesn't have teeth to say we're actually going to do something and so only way that I would be in agreeance with something like that is we actually
095allocate some money to it but not just in the hopes that we get savings from here and then it goes from here then it goes from here and hopefully we can get it in later on right I don't I don't know where we end up on that one so yeah I I guess I was just wondering so that um I can I can work with staff on next is there I mean since we have you know all members here is there a way to just I mean are are we at majority on this or what the direction is so that we can plan forward um is there a way to kind of sum that up and figure out where folks are at and then we'll we'll respond accordingly I don't I don't think we're at
096majority at this point um I think um I think there is a commitment from board that I'm sensing about not being performative and working with our communities our students especially and and that that's probably a voice that I actually would want to hear from most um in terms of exploring potentially a resolution or some kind of um effective way forward um and as for the bond at this point I don't think we have a majority I think that would be very disappointing because we're not going to have another opportunity um and I feel there's a lot of conversation I don't feel this is performative at all um I think there's a lot of conversation about like we know what's best for the native Community or we should be like some board members should be putting
097together a resolution like that is not how we should be proceeding I mean they I say what's frustrating is last last meeting was said we need to hear from the community what they want and there was some suggestions about here's what here's what we need to give them and they've responded with a proposal and they actually you know I want to acknowledge that they they did have like a standalone facility but they said hey there's some other options which I think is similar to what um Dr Armstrong raised which is as part of another um like rebuild they talk I mean they're currently in Indian Ed is in Jefferson um but they talked about also potentially one of the other collocation so it I don't think it's yeah we have to have it the that
098is one model um I think it would be a big Miss because I think you know what would be truly performative is if we came up a resolution we talked about programming then oh we don't have any money for programming and then nothing happens and then it's like the next Bond is going to be 10 years out so come back in 10 years and you know I just say we we haven't had an opportunity to hear from the people that we're that we're talking about um and and is with black students and families native students and families are the other group in this in this District that have had you know 200 years of not being well served so that would just be my piece um can I ask some other questions yeah go ahead
099uh thank you I just want to add that um I don't think there's anything that cludes us from going out for another bond in four years so it it's not a 10-year lockout um what I do have one question I know um kind of sorry but I think we have to move on we don't have the votes to to move that part forward so um I do have a question it it was asked before and I think you answered it but I think it would be good to just kind of publicly say it it's about the admin cost uh projected increase and I know that um we got a response and it was a really good one and I I I feel like it would be probably best to kind of share that publicly um
100as you as you notice in the in the December two option the admin cost was listed at 41.2 or 41.4 million and then now it's projected at 83 right and so I just yeah 41.4 did I not say that that's an old yeah and then so now it's projected 83 I was wondering if you could could speak to that and just kind of share um the reasons for the projected increase in the admin cost yeah good question not a problem and there's a there's a slide that I put up as well that's got some information uh so just the that line item the administration costs that includes expenses basically it's affected to need it to manage the bond project so it includes staff uh staff within the office of scholarization also staff outside the office
101scholarization that that support the bond work uh it it includes Consultants such as our project management construction team members but also like Consultants we do like a roofing analysis or we've done mechanical analysis those detailed analysis that cost money um our cost estimating legal services are in that line item as well our bond performance Auditors uh contracts is in that line uh our bond issuance cost so when we sell these bonds as in the previous topic um when we sell those bonds those come with fees those fees total many millions of dollars those are paid out of that administrative line the district also has an owner controlled insurance policy for construction projects which TOs many millions of dollars uh that is paid out so that is what those uh expenses are for that's what that
102line item is for uh the administration like the estimating is sort of you know a lagging effort based upon the bond scope of work it really depends on what the scope of the size and the scope what the projects are in the bond to be able to estimate uh what that Administration costs are what we've done in the past is we carry a percentage when we do early Bond planning because then it's easy as as the the scope and the cost change uh it's easy to just estimate a number without doing a detailed Staffing plan that you know for potentially dozens of projects in you know 10 years or more uh and then once the bond scope is really solidified we do a staffing plan specific to that Bond scope of work and then that
103that's that we propose as the budget U the the proposed 2025 bond is unique in that quite a bit of the scope is uh isn't specifically described for example example the savings for these future Elementary School Middle Schools or party projects depending on what those are and how much of that goes to that versus the high schools can will will impact what is needed for the administrative Bond program management so therefore there isn't really a way to to develop an Accurate Staffing plan so what we did to propose which is also a common way to do is just as a percentage and so we looked back at what we have what we've spent before on Administration the 2020 for example we budgeted 6% we're spending about we anticipate spending about 5 a half% when that
104is all done uh what looked at other districts that's pretty consistent what we've proposed here is 5% of the total which total is $83 million and it's just that is we think that's consistent we think that's achievable we think that will get us there if there is a savings in that we don't spend that much like we've seen in previous bond that goes back to projects that gets transferred to bond eligible projects and if for some reason that's not enough than the Bond program continu there to cover that so just in summary a very quick One S summary uh you're just expecting 5% of uh would uh of the cost would go into to Administration and the number is bigger because this bond is bigger the numberers bigger yeah correct well yeah and I would
105just add it it's it's it's it's changed quote unquote because we finally as a board have said this is what we want to do and staff have now said okay if this is your package this is going to be our administrative cost I do I want to point out 5% is actually a really pretty reasonable in fact maybe even low number for um a bond um you know with this many projects and I'm actually glad that you think you can get into 5 perc um it would make me a little bit nervous if I were in your job um looking at 5% I wantan to I want to remind everyone because Administration often gets a Bad Name the bond audit we heard last night and all the things that have happened in the 2012 2017
1062020 audit um all those things get done with with people who are paid with the administrative dollars and the things that go right are when those people do their jobs right and the things that go wrong are usually when we're underresourced in that area and so you know whether it's keeping track of project costs keeping things on time and on budget you know doing all of that Community engagement that we as a board want them to do all of that is in this um 5% line item 83 million sounds like a lot but $ 1.8 billion dollar is is a lot and so a 5% admin rate is actually um very very reasonable and dare I say maybe a little bit optimistic so um um I'm glad you're going to keep it that low um
107and and I I wish you luck and do so thank youting I think you should come to the next meeting when you have when there actually is public comment time um that it sounds like you already have signed up for to come and um speak for your community and let your community speak for itself I wouldn't walk away because there this in this format there hasn't been an opportunity and I can understand why you um it was very nice superintendent Armstrong for you to offer that but I can imagine why you wouldn't want to just impromptu like come up and um present but I think you should come next week and speak for your community and I would also next week January I would also like to personally connect too to to hear and talk
108and try to problem solve so if if you don't mind reaching out to me I would love to talk thank you all right last question and then yeah well if we're going to vote on referral I think we should get all our questions out now we're voting on a referral at the next meeting if we are this we should get our questions out um so this is just confirming because there was some question about which ad specs we're talking about because there's been a general discussion of um we're g to try and uh make build the most cost effective high schools as we can using the recommended Ed specs it's 2017 EDP specs we're using correct that is correct okay not the 2013 so just so we're all again we're all on the same page
109of what document we're um using and then the other question I had is um and I don't know if this is a finance question um but if we just now are saying that we had 98 million in interest earnings from 790 million um in in Bonds in our budget we have the interest paid but we don't have any calculation for the interest earned does that mean that you're not assuming any interest earned and that we actually the the net budget we may have more because there would be interest earned correct so there's two there's the bonds always get additional revenue and there's there's different ways to do it two primary that have we have historically had is premium from sales and then interest earnings those aren't guaranteed uh and so the tactic that we have
110taken is that we don't forecast those we anticipate them to some extent but you know they're not guaranteed uh like principal when when a bond is passed so uh what we do is is when when there is premium from a sale that goes into the program contingency that's what increases that the program contingency so it's available for all Bond projects as and the contingency is and then it's the same with the annual uh interest earn based upon Investments every Bond we've had we've always had some interest earns correct and it varies depending on the correct external environment okay I think that's worth worth noting um then I want to talk about the specific ballot um title Lang language um that has been offered that's been posted because this this is what we're going out to
111voters with and um I'm appreciative that staff um has been evolving this over the last um week a concern I had that I mentioned um when the first language came out is that it didn't name the the school and the 2017 and 2020 Bond summary language desate them so I appreciate that they're now Cleveland and idab Wells um so I think those School communities your your projects are listed your school modernizations are listed in the summary and um not being a lawyer I'm not going to try and describe what it is but um the caption the question and the summary which are all posted and there's a Redline version that people could look at um I'm wondering um if you could um I don't know who it is um between the lawyers going to explain
112it explain what the question the summary and the caption together equal um the bond title with all three pieces essentially are they a contract that this board would be making with the voters about what is to be done that it's pretty it's not a contract of course but that's the simplest analogy I can make right and so when you hear like people spending money I'm sorry to interrupt Beyond this I want to let you hear from the the correct lawyer so give us just a second I'll okay Liz up here for you to hear from and I didn't mean to cut you off I apologize that's okay yeah there you go she did not go far in this Bond so do you want to expound on her answer I because I want to share because
113I know there's been you know anxiety um both in the community about like what does it what does it all mean and I think if you look at the language that's been posted now the summary says modernized schools including Cleveland and idb wills High School um and that is as you said um sort of our our contract with the voters it's not just just like maybe we'll do this but like this is our intent and yeah it's the legally binding language in those three sections which are often referred to collectively as the ballot title but that's the language that will be referred to to determine the appropriate spending of these bond funds great and we've also um added in some other specific language so I think uh for school communities that are wanting to know
114like what are the general things that we going to be um investing in that to take a look at the summary and then the second piece of language that is appears before voters is the explanatory statement and explain what what legal Authority that has or what role it has with like our when we're out telling voters like we want you to pass this Bond measure and we're going to do this and here's the language that you use and it's through this language um we're going to refer what role does the explanatory statement have which is longer and which we haven't yet drafted so it's an important piece that needs to be factual and accurate it's a representation of what the intended uses are from a legal perspective and I I want to note that the
115the statutes limit how many words can be in each of these sections which is why the language can be stilted or high level depending on which section you're talking about the ballot title those three sections we talked about before are the first stop of what is the legal commitment the district is make making for the use of those bonds the explanatory statement expands upon that intention expressed in the ballot title and if there's an ambiguity in the ballot title language a court would look to voters would expect us to look to the explanatory statement to resolve that ambiguity and so if we if we were going to do something in addition to that wasn't in the summary say we decided to like re rebuild completely an elementary school it's not it's not in this in
116the summary would we be able to allow it is in it is in the summary language without using those words it's to modernize repair schools for instance that high level language for capital investment is uh defines the authority to spend the bond funds in addition to the specifics that are also listed so it's um it's not exclusive is that I would say that the the uses for the bonds um when you look at uh modernize repair schools replace technology curriculum right those are categories of capital expenses that the the board is authorizing and committing to the summary expands upon that even further it's kind of like nesting dolls of language in the opposite direction if you will but those are if approved this measure would Finance Capital costs including projects that and it lists those
117details because there's only 175 words allowed you want to have broad authorizing language that's consistent with the capital Investments you want to make with with as much detail as you can squeeze in there but that's the the B balancing act with those constrained uh word requirements great um since we between now and when we refer we'll have an explanatory statement right yes that will that will come before you on the seventh so one thing that I would suggest in the explanatory language is somehow to capture I think Dan you did a pretty good job but I'm not sure it's within the the word limit on like how we prioritize um just so people have a sense of we know we have some critical systems that need to be replaced and a upgraded and approved and
118because we only have 175 words in the summary somehow conveying that is like we have you know 10 billion dollars but we're going to and I think you did a good job sort of summarizing like here's how we you know with keeping our flexibility but here is how we apply those resources against the you know most urgent needs needs are the most critical needs um so I hope to see something like that in the explanatory statement because otherwise it's like what what 10 of the 10 billion are you going to pick and what with what criteria thank you I want to give um director Sullivan I saw you hand your hand up earlier and then we'll kind of finish out on that yeah I did but um we went on past that um I do
119have a question though about some of the wording if some of the wording on some of the bond stuff can we just is it Liz we should talk to if we just want to change some little things I'd be happy to connect and try to incorporate ultimately the board will vote on the language so if you think it needs board discussion but if these are we're taking suggest I'm happy to take suggestions yeah if it's a material you should probably raise it now just so if there oh well there was there was one part um I'm having a hard time bringing stuff up and still having my zoom up here but uh it was just the way it was worded it looked like um uh one of the things we were working on was learning
120by modernizing and I think you meant to say learning comma health safety and learning but instead he said he I don't know it's a very small English thing so but in this doc doent the words and the punctuation matter so thank you director S I appreciate that anyway I just wanted to know who to talk to about that chair yeah I just I have one quick question um in the summary language um you talk about the measures not expected to increase tax rates above previous targets is the word targets um important versus previous levels I'll have to confir with Bond Council on that director Scott okay and and I'm I'm fine if there's an intentionality around targets targets didn't mean as much to me as like if I'm a taxpayer and it say it's not
121going to increase tax rates above previous levels just anyway it's a small thing but um thank you and then the other thing I would say in terms of the explanatory statement I I do think you know providing some clarity to to voters might be important there I I would want to make sure any language we include though doesn't bind the districts ability to be flexible as different needs come up over the eight years and I think that's the whole goal of having this is that when we discover new things or you know you can do facility condition assessments every five years and they will change some buildings will deteriorate faster than others and so we may have a priority list today that is different than a priority list um five years from now when we're
122still using these funds so I just want to make sure that we are we're being clear that we are prioritizing and what that's based on but not um sort of locking us into Bad Business decisions um you know in the future I think your slid de tonight actually hit really on that importance of of of being able to make good governance decisions around what we we fix how we fix it thank you and yeah just to rephrase people have gotten a lot of trouble forgetting their Oxford comma so I'm all about the Oxford comma yes oh yes and I am will be happy to be the leader um all right uh I think we're going to move on thank you thank you Dan Young very helpful right next up we have the review of The
123Fall measure of the academic progress data map data is Otherwise Known um yes absolutely thank you chair Wong um as we think about the goals that the board has set um it's a perfect opportunity for us to review fall map data and so presenting tonight is our chief accountability and Equity officer Dr rard Adams thank you for being here happy to be here just give me one second to pull up the presentation someone else Cara says someone else is sharing all right good evening directors um tonight here to share and discuss our most recent matf fall achievement data it's a nice an opportunity to see where our students are performing at the beginning of the school year happy to take any questions at the end of the presentation if you would be so kind first
124we have a couple of just reminder slides we've shared this information before but you never know who's new and tuning in all eight or nine of them um we wanted to First wanted to first begin by providing again some background information on the map assessment it's a computer adaptive assessment and what that means is that unlike a traditional test that may provide the same test items to all students the map assessment changes items a student sees based on their previous response and whether or not it was correct the test begins at the student's grade level and then either increases or decreases in item difficulty based on student responses this continues until the student gets roughly 50% of items correct at that point the test ends and provides a scale score called a RIT score the
125RIT scores indicate where students are quote ready for instruction at a point in time and the RIT score is an equal interval score it's like a it's a number which means we can do math with it we can add subtract multiply and divide it so in PPS we assess students in grade three through eight grades 3 through eight excuse me with the map assessment in the fall and in the winter the data analyses we produce depend on the timing of the assessment and the fall which is highlighted here on this slide each student has a single score for that year and so we can understand achievement at that this or that point in time and we can compare achievement between two two points in time two Falls we'll begin as we have in the past
126by examining percentile rank changes between this fall and last fall this year is shown in teal last year shown in red and the arrows indicate the direction of the change whether it was an increase a decrease or no change in percentile rank as a reminder higher percentile ranks indicate stronger academic performance in examining percentile rate rank changes in Reading English language arts we note the differences in performance of our students by race and ethnicity with black students performing at or near the 25th percentile and white students performing at or above the 75th percentile we do see percentile rank increases for black students and underserved students who are multi-racial large percentile ranks changes for native in Pacific Islander students should be interpreted with caution based on the relatively small numbers of students assessed in each group
127which means movement either way by a few students may cause a bigger shift than we would otherwise see if we were testing hundreds of students at a grade level in mathematics we um looking at the percent to rank changes we again observe differential achievement and our predictable gaps by R and race and ethnicity with black students performing below the 25th percentile and white students performing at or below the 75th percentile here again we see some percentile rank gains for black students and students who are underserved and multi-racial for the next set of analyses we'll be examining the average rid score by subject grade level and race ethnicity we'll begin with reading English language arts and and when we look at reading achievement and the aggregate so this is all students we see that on average
128PPS students are exceeding the expected level of grade level performance for the fall testing window the dark bars note the grade level the dark horizontal bars um across each bar chart um to note the great level expectations for the fall this holds true for the following slides as well for third grade reading Asian white and multi-racial students who are not underserved all exceeded the grade level expectation while black students did not meet this expectation they did show a four-point gain and average risk score over the last school year in grade four Asian multi-racial students who are not underserved underserved students who are multi-racial and white students all met or exceeded the grade level expectation for fall for the grade level both black and latinx students showed an increase of two RIT score points over the
129previous year in grade five we see that both groups that both groups of multi-racial students Asian and white students met the fall performance expectation black students made progress toward the expectation and posted a twoo increase in over last school year so we're seeing some growth in um but it is not quite enough and not enough growth we're not where we um need to be looking at grade six reading Asian multi-racial students who were not underserved and white students met or exceeded the fall grade level expectation here black and Latin next students demonstrated a twoo and threo decline respectively in grade seven black student performance held constant while Latin next students performance increased by two points again here Asian multi-racial students who were not underserved and white students met the fall Benchmark for student performance and
130finally for reading performance in grade eight Asian multi-racial students who were not underserved native and white students all exceeded the fall grade level expectation while not yet meeting the grade level expectation black and latinx students did show a small increase in performance next let's turn our attention to mathematics achievement in grades 3 through eight as was the case in Reading overall all students combined PPS students continue to exceed the fall grade level expectations in grades 3 through in mathematics as was also the case in reading and has been the case with many of our data points when we disaggregate our math MAP data we see that our students of color are furthest from meeting the grade level expectations here in grade three black students demonstrated a two-point increase in their average rid score although they
131did not meet the fall grade level expectation along with Latin X underserved students who are multi-racial native students and Pacific Islander students excuse me want to stop for a second because you know for the last four years I've heard the same same tenor right we talk about how Black's kids are underperforming white kids we talk about Latino underperforming white kids I I want to change the narrative and and figure out a different way to present this information because because when I'm hearing this information and I can imagine with our kids hear this type of information it's it's this um what's the word it's uh demoralizing yes because we're we keep saying this over and over and over we're not presenting this in a opportunity opportunity opportunistic way to where it uplifts our kids to want
132to do better and so if you guys don't mind like I'm sure we all seen the slides we all seen the seen the charts um so if we can figure out a different way to present this that that would be awesome don't want to keep hearing year after year the same stuff the same stuff in we're not you know it's not changing understood I certainly don't take pleasure in sitting here year after year sharing data with you that has not moved um so we can certainly think about um um the opportunity Gap where there are opportunities for more success um where students have um shown some increases and um you know what I want to be clear is I don't believe that our results are indicative of the innate Brilliance and capability of our students
133right um students in our school uh brilliant beautiful and capable just as they are and parents send us their best um and then it's up to us as Educators um it was up to me when I was a teacher was up to me when I was a school-based leader to make sure we were maximizing and optimizing those opportunities for students when they're in the school building with us because they are with us typically uh depending on a school system or a school level for six hours six and a half hours a day so I appreciate can I ask a quick question feedb because I I this is this is such an excellent point director Holland and and I and I want to be a little more specific because I also want to um I also
134want to help you know staff sort of for me this and I'm just so I'm going to throw an idea out there but it's complete brainstorming I mean are are we sort of saying um reframing it as you know um again don't hold me to this but like you know once again this year our school district has failed our black students right and talking about that and then talking about the opportunities for growth so once again our district has failed our black students and there's an opportunity of you know whatever it is 10 20 30 point gap that the district can't improve on moving forward I'm just is that the type of thing we're talking about I was gonna say the city of Portland we're talking about um not using the words like underserved you
135know and words that uh bring communities down and kind of keep them down and instead using language that's like underresourced or where it's putting the bur for the service gap on the institution so instead of the student yeah so instead of just like you know lumping people of color it's like Global majority like brown people are Global majority so it's just turning the like the way we're naming it and I was going to ask us out what you're talking about words are so important yeah oh absolutely you know when when we talking about you know words of you know white suem they they always use words like this right black people ain't not doing well as as white folks Latino is not doing and then for me it's a it's a constant reminder of that
136system that systematic oppression that has been happening for hundreds and hundreds of years and so I'm hoping we can change that Dynamic of the words that we use the words that we choose um like director of the pass was saying that uplifts our kids um and not keep on holding that oppressive words against them because we all know that it's not our kids fault why it's not our kids fault why they're not learning it's our it's a system fault why they're not learning I I don't disagree I couldn't agree more I believe that the burden of student achievement lies solely with the adults in the system I also feel yeah I also feel like I hear a call to action in terms of uh the uh data and I know we're working on multiple measures
137and getting some other things out but I I think I also hear you director Holland saying that um um you or maybe the board and I don't know I don't want to overp but um aren't interested in the standard uh presentations on the data by grade level by race but maybe hearing more about you know what the data has prompted us to do on the system and what it is that we're redesigning constructing building or changing in response to the results that we're seeing which I know is a different frame of looking at it and I know conversations that we're having internally as a staff if that's what you were also sugges suggesting sorry everyone else hears that noise right okay I just make sure I wasn't going crazy okay so the data story um
138the differential performance doesn't really really change across the next couple grade levels in mathematics as you all might expect and so um what I would offer that I can do to the best of my ability um given the absence of um Christina Howard our chief academic officer and Dr Franco our chief of schools who both had family engagements is um talk about one of the specific Investments that I believe can change these data that we've made this year um in this year's current budget rather than continue through the remainder of the slides and I appreciate all the feedback on language was certainly um it is never my intention to um make anybody feel like they're put down or less than so I take that to heart and um it'll be different the next time I
139present data I would also like to add something now I think I think I think may it may be E flat my ears are a little weird today um wherever that's coming from uh if I may add I you know I'm I'm not an extremist in any way on this but you know as a former teacher I I know the importance of map scores and I think it is an important tool so I'm not trying to Discount map in any ways but one of the things also to to to change the script a little bit is also to remember that standardized test including map tests tests one aspect of a student is it important to measure yes it's important to measure I'm not not doubting about that but there's other other brilliances of a student
140that a map test does not test right and and I've witnessed that as a teacher where we have I have students that I thought were absolutely brilliant and they I watch them do their map tests and it comes out a shock like you shouldn't be getting that score and because you know the tests like this tests a certain aspect of cognition a certain a certain skill set and some people work around those have other skill sets that are important too to help them achieve and things like that so I think again I am not trying to Discount the importance I think um s tests like this are a really important measure it's a it's an important tool but also to remember that it measures one aspect and there's so many brilliances of our students that
141we are not measuring thank you I appreciate that thank you yeah um Eddie can I say something yes please yeah I um I certainly think data is important but I also agree about there's better ways to present it but this data also I've been noticing like eighth grade Native American reading third grade uh Native American math and there's big increases and and I think we want to celebrate too so there's room for celebration with these scores as well but yeah I see what you're saying Gary exactly so thank you before before before we go too far I want to um I know that y'all can't see me um that's intentional but as as disgusting as disgusting as this data is and as as terrible as this data is I don't want us to get to
142the place where and I don't believe anybody is saying that but I I want to say it out loud so that it's said out loud I don't want us to get to the place to where we're trying to sugarcoat the data or cover up data because until we change the data it is what it is and this this data should drive every conversation that we have this data should drive every every program that we look at this data should drive every initiative that we think about doing within our um within our school system this data should drive every contract that we that we write this data should this data should be the driving factor that drives and determines um the direction in which we are going as a school district because until all of our
143kids and I mean all of our kids are reading at the levels that they need to be reading at so they're doing math at the levels that they need to be doing math that across the board regardless of what one test says so maybe we do need to look at how we're um how we're testing or maybe we do need to look at how we're assessing and maybe we do need to have four and five um six different assessment points and whatever the case might be so that we can truly assess our kids for where they're at and get them ready for where they need to be but I do not want us to get into a place where we start trying to sugarcoat the data because we don't like the way that it sounds
144and we don't like the way that it makes us feel I am comfortable I'm very comfortable hearing horrible data If It Moves us to the point to where we want to do something and we want to begin to hold people accountable because we have to hold everybody accountable ourselves starting at the top going all the way down to you know what I'm saying whomever it is everybody needs to be held accountable for these getting our kids where they need to be everybody plays a role in it and I don't want us to get to the point to a re brushing over the data because I'm concerned about how it might make you feel I care less about how people feel I'm more concerned with can people read and so again I pray that that's not
145what we're saying I don't believe it is I do believe we can come up with other words because words are powerful and I believe that we we we must stay intentional around letting this data drive the conversation because that's the real story here this is the D there and so I'm done thank you all for allowing me to share thank you director green I'm in 100% agreement also yes thank you for sharing that um director s your hand is still up and then D Hollands after that's a that's a mistake I forgot to put it down D Hollands yeah so Mr uh director green I I I I agree what you're saying and that's not the intention is to to sugarcoat anything I always know you do my guy always know you do the Hest
146the Hest though I just want to make sure that we are being very clear hus is not on our kids it's on our system and just like you know if I'm in a if I'm having my kids at home I'm not go sit there and talk about how you're not better than this other kid right I'm gonna be looking like well why are the schools not offer you tutoring or why are they not sending you homework like these are the conversations that I had with my kids you know and so I just want to make sure that we're we're we're doing that as a districtwide of looking at well how can we do better as a system and not put the own us on know this kid better than that kid can thank you director
147I agree with that 100% could I ask a um data question um do we have the maybe I missed it but do we have the per percentage of students who took the test like um the participation rates coun at the end of the presentation in dependes that's what I thought okay but um but with that I do have I do have some questions um so when we you talked about when we talking about the system and what was happening I guess one of my question is this um map testing is done almost every what eight weeks or so um we have a a typically a five to six week window in the fall and then we have a five to six week window in the winter some schools um based on principal building leader conversation
148um with teachers have also uh decided to test again in the spring but we do not require that from the system level okay so and with and in line with that so one of my questions would be um what specific adjustments are being made to the curriculum or instructional practices based on the map findings within that time period so what I can share I appreciate the question director Allens what I can share is this year we made an investment in our elementary middle schools in a position we called an academic interventionist it's a teacher level position we analyzed uh schol schools map data to look at the proportion and percentages of students who based on those data were not quite where we need and know they can be and we then allocated um positions to
149those schools based on the number of students with the expressed purpose um or intention that the academic interventionist would be working with uh these particular groups of students to help uh accelerate their performance in concert with them being in their classroom with their um classroom teacher who should be providing them with grade level and standards aligned instruction now that's new for this year um in terms of the academic interventionist that position being allocated from the district was a new investment going into uh this budget cycle and so um excuse just but then we have some kind of position like that last year where they had kids that went need additional help went into a certain class I can't remember what it I think it was called some intervention interventionist some schools had hired interventionist but
150we did not make a systemic investment in the position so that's an important clarification I appreciate that um and so that is one um of the we used our part of the Equity Funds because it went from eight to four percent and I thought we used that money fund um the intervention Specialists yes but you're saying we didn't I'm sorry no no no no okay I'm sorry I misunderstood that no it's definitely um a systemwide allocation that we made by redirecting some existing funds so they have it I'm sorry so we have academic inter yes okay new for this year is instead of principal Scott using some of his or her or their funds to fund independently an interventionist we've said hey look you've got 30 students in your school who are who appear to
151be performing not performing where we know they can and should be performing and so we're going to allocate a 1.0 interventionist to your school to specifically support those students in their reading and Mathematics work and and that's been the investment what I'm what I'm up to your question director Hollands um I am in in talking to um Chief academic officer Howard and Dr Franco one of the things we've been talking about is if we believe that having high quality materials and highly trained and highly qualified staff matter we want teachers using the assessment that's closest to the student and the learning experience which would be the curriculum embedded assessments if in a scenario where uh teachers and educators are making adjustments to their instruction based on the units they just taught the curriculum based assessments
152that they just provided to students and how students performed if they're making adjustments to that over time student achievement should increase and students should be growing academ mically so talking about with the map data so if I'm a teacher and maybe some of the teachers on on here can explain too how am I receiving that information and what specifically is being done if I see a kid has a issue with geometry and math versus they might be stronger in algebra What specifically am I the teachers doing to offset to focus in on that keyy it within that time period before the next testing sure there are um standard areas within math and geometry algebraic thinking is is one of those and um I know that we have intervention resource materials that are designed to be
153used with students that are showing those types of skill gaps so when we look at we talked about and I heard it up here we talk about other forms of Assessments um I know I was listening to the C the State education person on a podcast uh today and he talk about fora of inum and I think summary um assessments what how's that differ from the map assessment um I would call the map assessment an interim assessment um in terms of our so you have the daily checks that teachers do an exit ticket uh a drill is what we used to call them when I was in school um then you have end of unit curriculum based assessments and then you have an interim assessment and those happen depending on the length of the unit
154right it could be two weeks it could be a month but then you have an assessment sort of just happened and you can look back over the last three or four or two weeks to determine what adjustments you need to make then you have an assessment like math that in the fall tells you where students are performing um but doesn't necessarily tell you what to do next again as a teacher I would look back at my curriculum related resources to help me because that's what I'm using every day to teach the student and those materials also have um what we call tier 2 supports in them so that we can work with students who are not where we know that they can and should be and then at the far end you'd have a summit
155of assessment like osas which by the time we get those results if not anything we can do the students are in the next grade um you know we can think about what we can do better for this year's fourth graders than we did for last year's fourth graders but the um opportunity to use those data to drive interv ition on students is not very high so just make sure understand so if we were using the map data and we're talking about you know that time period between the different tests you say there's interim tests being done in between those five to six months as well there should be curriculum embeded assessments that are happening at the end of each instruction those how the teacher using those I guess about thinking is if if if I'm
156using this map data at the beginning I'm getting this map data at the beginning so I'm knowing where a kid is at I'm supposed to adjust the curriculum or adjust how I teach that kid and you're doing that at least minimum two times a year by the time the osas data comes out there should be Improvement right because the map is supposed to the map points is supposed to be related to um performance um and since we haven't really been seeing that our OAS data how we transition because this is the same like I said we've been going through this for the last four four years at least since I've been on what are we missing what is not connecting I think one of the things that we often see um in education is um
157I what I I often wonder is do we all believe that all students are capable and Brilliant and able to achieve do I believe that as their teacher I'm able to take them as far as they could go um and I think we think of that as like self-efficacy among um staff and buildings um having a culture of high expectations um believing that when you set a bar with support students can reach that level of rigor um and all of those things have to be in place I mean I I've shared with our principal some of my own personal story where I was not being educated in elementary school I was zipping through my work I was bored I got bullied I got in trouble I got suspended and they were going to put me
158in special education until my great-grandmother who raised me was like no you're gonna assess him and then we're GNA figure out what he needs instructionally and then I went to a different school where they had a higher level of rigor standard what we're trying to do here in PPS through our curricular resources that all teachers have through our professional learning that we provide to teachers is make sure and try to ensure that there's not different levels of rigor going on across all the different classrooms Are We There Yet I would say no we're not we're not there where we can ensure that that rigor is happening are we inspecting that we are we're doing collaborative instructional walks where we're monitoring the implementation of curriculum and the instructional program to try to see where schools and
159staffs might need some additional supports and will we be there absolutely I'm hopeful that that we get there I gu my question is if this if maps and this is only because it's it's been last four years that we've been using the map stuff and we haven't really seen haven't really seen a big change should we look at at least start looking at or thinking about different type of assessments that can help us get there um because when we talk about you know everybody knows the biases in the history of standardized test is there other assessment tools that we can start looking at our looking at um versus just doing the same one and we're still getting the same results I would um my reaction to that would be as I look at our data
160I see similar patterns perspective of what I look at when I look at our postsecondary Readiness data for example we're bringing that in um that'll be finalized in late January we'll be able to bring that to you U most likely in February we see across a lot of different measures of postsecondary Readiness similar patterns right and so what that suggests to me is that it's not the measure that's the problem I'm not saying that and I don't sit here before you to say say the standardized assessments are the be all endall I know they have inherent problems and yet we have black brown and Native students who pass them all the time with appropriate rigorous instruction so so what I'm hearing just want me understand so what I'm hearing is that we need to focus
161on the in rigorous instruction not so much as the map data because if we had the rigorous instruction inevitably the data should go up that is my that is my wholehearted belief so um question I I know is this working um there's a lot of National Data that's showing that um during the school year the students are improving you know who may be a little bit um have not reached their potential right um are still keeping up the same rate as those maybe who are are scoring higher on these tests and where we see that the drops and the dips happen during like summer break is that is that something that we're also seeing in our district as well um well I think we've benefited from um in most of the previous years I've been
162here some funding to help provide summer programming for students who were most at risk for what they call Summer learning loss or summer melt so I it is not my understanding that we've seen it to the extent that you may see it in places where they don't have those summer opportunities for students and certainly um we need to be I would ask us to be mindful that students who are not quite where they should and could be can grow and still not grow enough to meet fourth grade standards in math right because that growth over time has to accelerate and so that's and another part of what we see is that students are growing and they haven't yet made enough growth to be at that grade level standard yeah absolutely thank you so going in
163line with what you're saying right so if you're saying they they're growing but they're not necessarily meeting the academic standard right but they're growing and we're talking about the individualist right if my question is if the interent interventionalist is looking at the maps data right what is he actually doing to help that kid gets better because if he gets it in I'm think in Fall I say September and he sees that he's off where you have five or six months to to help move that what are they actually doing to help that child so I'm I'm going to tell on myself here and say I don't quite know enough in depth about the curriculum to tell you exactly what they might be doing if um I know if Miss Howard was here she could speak
164to the components of the curriculum that are designed to support students who are um not quite where we need them to be and should be Dr Ollin maybe um I don't know if you know but one of my previous jobs is actually teaching teachers um I'd be happy to and if we can find a teacher volunteer to have like go with you as a guided you know as a I don't know guided observation where I can kind of show how things point out how things work and things like that to kind of help understand certain some of the practices that we're having some of the struggles that we're we're having as a district as well oh no absolutely and last year actually I did go on a couple of those walks um and that's why
165I'm asking the question because like when I seen in one of the individualist classroom they had five kids and be honest they wasn't really doing much and so you had one person I don't know if it was a teacher or whoever it was but it was individualist because you had five kids and I didn't see I couldn't go in and tell oh they're working on this or they're working on this so when I went in for the walks they gave a sheet that show what to look for right and so when I went into this class I didn't see those look for so that's why I'm like I hear what you're saying and and I and I think that would be great but I just it just seemed like something's not connecting with that model
166I'm G to say and like even the debrief that we did with those models it didn't really seem comprehensive enough at least for me me you know after we debriefed with the other principles and all that stuff um and so I just when we talk about rigorous instruction and teaching teachers right you know um we have to make sure that we have to be able to make sure that they're doing or have make sure to know that they're doing it the right way at the same time and now and I only went to only did only did two walks I didn't do walks all over is the city but I did two two walks and um were both like the same the same level type of stuff I came down to uh because actually the
167interventionist are in my department so I came down to um uh answer your question related to some of the activities you're doing and actually I could offer um both to answer the question and take you to some of the reading groups specifically that they're doing and I could prepare a response for you too that's a little more in depth but um briefly um what the interventionists do is they do take the map data they also take osas data and they look at where the students are performing but then outside of just informing where they're performing they then have to do a diagnostic assessment to see where their needs are specifically in Reading um and then they have a um some specific reading intervention programs that they use that they run small groups with teach to
168address the gaps in reading for the students so the students are getting the core reading instruction and then very specific small group instruction during the intervention time um to address the whatever the gaps are for them and they group the kids similarly similar I can't say that word but commonly based upon their needs and are we are we and so from that are we seeing improvements at the end of the year when we talk about the osas data because the data I see I don't really see improvements so we are seeing Positive Growth um based upon the individual students goals based on in their intervention plans so so we haven't gotten to the point yet um where they've because because we just started it very intentionally this school year quiet okay um so we haven't
169gotten to the point where they're taking osas data so this so I and I'll share the I can share that when I prepare the response for you I can share the data with you that we're seeing also it's showing um signic an impact for um many of the students um and at that the growth may be significant and we may not see it entirely in osas but we are seeing significant growth for the students I would love to see that oh I would love to see that whole plan from start to finish from you know how they how they use the mass data what kind of how they set up their plans I think that will be helpful as well yes for the kind of sake of time I I really do appreciate your line
170of questioning I this is and just kind of reiterate what director green said this should be the center of our Focus right so I I am happy to extend this conversation um and continue it um would it be okay to if you have questions maybe we could submit it and then we can I know compile answers and then schedule a future meeting to continue discussing it because I mean this is again like like director green that this should be the center of what our focus is on all the time cool it's up to you all right I can definitely put together um a series of questions around um how we're the different assessments that we're we're using um how we're how we're measuring those assessments when we're coming back to to reassess and how we're
171establishing pivot Points so I I do have a series of questions um that I would like to to put together and get responses to maybe that can be part of a um another work session that we do simply around the the data the metrics and how we're going to measure moving forward because I know that um and I'm putting this out there because I know she just hasn't had a chance to spend as much time talking as we have but I know Dr Armstrong has a u a very intense um intense plan to increase our literacy rates um for our um black and brown students and so I have no doubt that this is about to Shi and that this will be the last year that we hear this type of um damaging um demoralizing
172um data um so I I I just want to look at how we're going to be measuring and what we can look for and what the signs will be so yes I would definitely put together a series of questions it it sounds like um if I may that the board might have interest in a presentation on balanced assessment and instructional programming and I could certainly work with Jay and um Miss Howard to bring forth a presentation about that to bring those pieces together yeah I think that's a great idea and director green if you don't mind sending in your questions maybe you could email to um Miss Powell and then we'll we'll start collecting and try to but yeah I think you have really good questions and yeah no problem would you prefer that they
173just go to to miss pal and not the whole board I was just thinking I would put my questions out there for the whole board to see just so that um other board members may seem like oh that's a question that I had so I don't and then we can just compile one big document but if you want me to just send my questions one way I can do that as well um you can do both the the only issue is that you know make sure that as board members don't respond and and have a Serial discussion right so you can send it fair enough fair enough and Miss po will collect it and then we'll yeah we'll com compile it that I think that's a great idea thank you director green and director San
174I saw you had your hand up earlier and then we'll finish on that I had it up earlier um kind of in response to Gary although I I think this plan you have right now is great um know we had an invitation a while ago to go to a fourth grade classroom that was last year and I went and helped her out for about a month just just an hour just to see what it was really like and this was at an indication you certainly don't want to just drop in on somebody's classroom but that's the best way for you to see what's really going on and to understand what the teachers are doing and they're probably not doing it perfectly but just what what they have to do to try to meet the needs
175of a fourth grade student who not reading and one that's probably reading at seventh grade level I mean it's it's just overwhelming so to find out you know what's being done to help me you'll have to talk it's wonderful so I I like what we're doing and I like putting the focus on um on the kids and what we're doing and how we're going to make a change and have that be the highlights of of what we as a a board are working on so thank you uh everybody who's made a an effort to um kind of change what we're doing change it up a bit appreciate it well thank thank you director Sal me you gonna have to talk I don't I don't have for a whole month to go sit in the classroom
176I would love to um but I hear what you're saying no I hear what you're saying y on mute you on mute you on mute yeah I mean I didn't go all day I went one hour a week so um that's all you need to see what's going on all right all right probably wouldn't want to stay longer than that all right so yeah we can definitely like come back to this you know in January far as to have that that presentation and these topics I have I have like four pages of questions only ask three um so that would be great is that something we can to yeah all right I would love that thank you director solvin thank you director Holland I agree with you completely thank you Jo J buo and and
177Renard Adams um very helpful and and always appreciate your time um with that let's move on to the next uh topic last topic for today last thing on the agenda item is the budget work to establish uh budget work session to establish priorities um this is the opport We Begin discussing the 2025 26 budget the goal of tonight is to review the budget principles and policies and discuss our priorities uh Dr Armstrong superintendent Armstrong would you like to introduce the staff absolutely it's my pleasure um before I introduced the team um I just I have a a quick quote so in 1963 Dr Martin Luther King uh wrote a book um titled strength to love and there was a quote that appear in it and said the ultimate measure of a man is not where
178he stands in moments of comfort and convenience but where he stands at times of Challenge and controversy and I think of our interim CFO who by the way is before you in person for the very last [Applause] time and I think about his decision to stay after our um previous superintendent left his decision to stay after our interim superintendent left and his desire to stay to support the new superintendent until a new CFO was named is incredibly um inspiring I'm incredibly thankful and I just wanted to publicly say that um your leadership and your dedication and your ability to stay put um is impactful and I just want to say thank you multiple times over thank you so with that I am introducing our interim superintendent mang Lee and our chief of staff Deborah CFI
179to introduce uh our budget development uh or start the conversation thank you for being here thank you so much superintendent Armstrong I didn't expect that but uh I very much appreciate it and I it's been a wonderful experience expence to to be part of the PPS team and the PPS family for a little longer than I expected I have a quote too um since we're doing quotes I have a quote from Brokeback Mountain I just can't quit you but but I but I but I will uh slowly fade away well to be clear though this is the last meeting that we'll see him in person but I suspect he'll drop in to Pitch hit on Zoom every once in a while but correct yeah and and we're um really everyone in the Finance team and
180if I may speak for for uh staff in cabinet and elsewhere we're really excited about Michelle Morrison coming on board in a few short weeks and uh her arrival has has made me feel so much better about um having an awesome person to to pass this interim baton to so um I know we're all looking forward to her being in in these seats in future meetings about budget so again yeah thank you Dr Armstrong very much for that so uh directors we as is often the case in in budget conversations we're talking about multiple fiscal years in the course of one evening so beginning of the meeting we talked about last year and now we're transitioning to a conversation about next year so this is the first in a series of what we think will
181be four board discussions over the next few months and this is all aligned with the budget calendar which you approved back in October so this is uh getting started and we know it's been a long meeting so we're GNA go Fairly briskly I think but then look forward to continuing these budget discussions uh and I will stay tuned in even if I'm not physically uh visible in the gallery here so you're going to be watching from home I'm going to be watching from home home or maybe Mexico or somewhere else um so the the first part of this this update tonight we did w to sort of ground this discussion including for future discussions on some high level updates about our forecast including our projected gap for next year and I know uh board members
182have seen this type of summary uh in the past several weeks as well but just to recap for yourselves and for for the community we did have when the board adopted the budget for the current year 2425 we had a premonition or an expectation that the year that we're talking about now 25 26 there was still a significant Gap yet to close so that we were talking about about a $70 million gap uh being addressed in two fiscal years and spoiler alert that is still kind of where we're where we're looking at the moment although there have been some some plot twists over the past few months so let me just summarize those when the announcement came out over the summer about these technical adjustments to the current service level methodology that was sort of
183late June or early July uh time frame the governor announced through the work of a of a committed working group to to really look at the CSL formulas and the and the assumptions behind uh determining what the the true costs of the current service level um were just not not enhancing but sort of maintain maintaining the the current levels of Investments and updating them for for increased costs for uh salaries in like uh that was estimated to be up about $515 million which was still well short of the quality education model q but but a meaningful improvement from the prior methodology so that was in in its way encouraging in terms of improvements from the forecast that we had been using for the adopted budget a few months later in October the pur board so
184the agency that runs the state pension system approved rate increases that were very significant in terms of increased costs for most employers in the system and uh significantly uh abrupt cost increases for for many employers including PPS so in a way although the the numbers aren't quite um they're they're in way sort of independent but the net effect is that the better news from the CSL improvements was actually more than offset to the bad by these increases in purs pension costs that were that were revealed a few months later two weeks ago the governor proposed her budget through um written document for the next bium for the 25 to 27 bium which reflected the full $515 Million worth of the CSL adjustments so that was good to see affirmed in in the budget proposal by
185the governor and an additional $85 million uh related to increased purse costs $ 85 million is better than nothing better than zero but but it really is a action of the of the costs of those increased uh Pur rates that are in that third bullet point so long story short we are still back to looking we've kind of come around um this that the barn a little bit but we're still now looking at a gap of about $40 million for next year for for 25 26 I should note though that part of the the arithmetic that's not really stated there is that um because of the magnitude of the pur increases in our estimation that that the Gap is is about $40 million still there's um to a degree a bit of a Reliance in
186our planning assumptions on on tapping into this one-time Pur Reserve that that the district has it's um fund 225 it's it's a fund that was established about 13 years ago if I recall there was a board resolution that was established to help smooth out the annual fluctuations in purs costs and and that fund has about $23 million in it now so in light of the the sharpness and the magnitude of the increases in Pur costs in our staff conversations among each other and then with the superintendent we we've we've started to talk about um drawing some of those funds not all of those funds but because of the the necessity and the and the sharp increases in those Pur costs um we're starting to discuss what a recommendation might look like the board will have
187to to approve that of course so that's just sort of a preview for now young just so we don't lose that point later because I know you're gonna go through a lot of other material I I it sounds like that's exactly what the fund was set aside for was to smooth sharp increases which is what we have and so I think it makes total sense you know this I'm just more saying it for the public it is also onetime dollars and so any dollars we use um are simply delaying the cuts which may be useful to delay for a year or two so we can smooth things out but they're delaying it um I would say to you have 20 to 30 million dolls it seems like you know one one strategy might be pulling
188$5 million do out a year for the next four years which begins to turn it into you know ongoing it's not quite but you can you can at that point sort of say hey we can avoid you know maybe four or five million dollars of ongoing cuts by stretching this out and not using it right away so just all those strategies you're very familiar with I'm just more saying it right than direct SC I don't have any more opportunities right thank you now the question of of the pace of of utilizing those one-time resources is is a a key question to consider and that that example certainly um applies so to to to spend it a little more slowly or or if uh there's a reasonable confidence that the uptick that we're seeing in the
189pur rates is might be more of a 25 to 27 bium effect then that could also um help yourselves and and us feel a little bit more confident about maybe spending it a little more quickly and for example focusing on the upcoming bium could I just ask one really quick since director Scott already interrupted you I figure i' jump on to um I just wanted just one clarifying question this 40 million budget gap for the next year is assuming that the legislature is going to adopt the governor's CSL so worst case scenario if they don't adopt it what may we be looking at 60 million it's great and also it includes a uh spin of the pers Reserve of 10 million so without the CSL without the uh 10 million um our actual reduction is
19073 million just to be clear on that thank you a little later in in this presentation we're g to draw a connection back to the boards and the district's advocacy agenda Chief Kori is going to sort of summarize resmar we know you're very familiar with that but but there is a interplay between these assumptions and what may happen and we hope that it gets better and not worse but um but between these assumptions and what ends up being enacted in the in the final enacted budget state budget okay so the next section of the presentation and the and the conversation is really to high level kind of grounding uh this conversation and this process in in principles and policies and priorities so to take them in order this is a summary of a a document
191that is linked accessible through the uh through the link that's on the slide there I don't know if hopefully folks can access that through uh boardbook uh but there was a resolution passed in 2016 by the board which established budget principles and I'll just say it's not written on the slide but this was also uh connected to work by the cbrc the community budget Review Committee that presented a draft of these of principles there's there's a lot more language in the in the resolution than what's summarized on the right hand side of the slide and um worth worth reviewing when you get a chance and uh or re-reviewing I should say and the board uh approved the the principles in the resolution in uh February or so of 2016 so I just wanted to remind
192the community of of that document that the board approved and these are just a few of the highlights in in that um set of budget principles the next slide restates and similarly has a link to the full board policy about reserves and we know you're all very familiar with this policy because we talked about it a lot pretty intensely last year and including in the budget development process for the current year so but just to restate that the that the board has a policy to maintain a reserve a general fund Reserve between 5 and 10% of annual general fund revenues and as you know uh directors we've been focused more on the lower end of that uh of that range that 5% range uh for a little over a year and that continues for now
193uh unless there's direction to to Pivot to a different Target um that's higher than the 5% that Contin is to be at what we're organizing our our work and our our recommendations to the superintendent and ultimately to the board around trying what what are the what are the uh decisions what package of decisions will can be made in light of these fiscal headwinds that will allow the the budget to maintain that 5% Reserve level and not dip below that because it is a board policy with that that I'm going to uh pass the the mic back to Dr Armstrong to engage in a little conversation amongst yourselves I appreciate that thank you staff thank you team so budget priorities discussion I also understand that uh our our time has gotten away from us but I
194still think it's important to lean into a conversation and then I just want to acknowledge that it may not all conclude but I welcome um thoughts and feedback through 101's or email um or the next time that we're gathered together as a team and so really for this section it's for you to share insights um about what areas are most important to you and then share perspectives on um the strengths and opportunities for improvement here in Portland so let's start off with budget priorities it's really a question and I will ask and um we have some prompts up there that uh seem to come up in various meetings or in previous years but but really it doesn't have to be on that list for you to share um what areas you think as a board
195is most important for the district to focus on over the next three years I was going to say I noticed that um we didn't have anything specifically that said literacy and I know that you're doing a big push towards literacy but um I mean I would personally like to see some focus on uh like early intervention and early support early early learning especially around literacy you know how to hold the pencil how to recognize text um and I mean all of these things are good right student achievement um but I'm concerned about the kids that we uh that we miss when they're young when their first their their kindergarten through let's say second grade Rich Scott so I'll do a lightning round um student achievement classroom instruction and school leadership and the school leadership just
196because that's so important to the first two you can't have student achievement or good classroom instruction I don't think without a good school leader the other thing I'll just I'll call out and just because it continually comes up what's not on here is class size and and and I think this is one of those really challenging things um that um we know class size um can affect student achievement generally the studies show it's really large differences the difference between say 32 and 16 you're going to see a difference in student achievement you're not going to see a difference student achievement between 32 and 33 um it matters so much to the community and that presents this really challenging moment that ever since I've got on the board six years ago you know with now a
197couple different superintendents and going to these conferences and realizing that like that is not what drives good achievement in a school what drives good achievement in a school is a good teacher and a good environment and a good school leader and yet what will turn out hundreds of parents is if their class sizes go from 32 to 33 or they happen to be in a fourth grade that's got 34 students they will turn out by the hundreds and I don't know how we bridge that because to the extent we as a district respond to that and send all these teachers to those places and you know and and drop those class sizes from 34 to 17 um we will you know be one be taking away resources from somewhere else else and we may not
198be having that much of in on class size but we'll make the community happy versus how much do we do what educational professionals say is the right thing to do for student achievement knowing that we're going to make the community mad so I don't know how you bridge that um but I just I'm just gonna throw that out there but those are my three student achievement classroom instruction and school leadership um I kind of want add to that a little bit because and I think one of the things with class size that we talk about I mean it's a very interesting discussion and then we should look at the data but I'm I'm also curious about if that data also includes like rate of teacher burnout because one of the things I know about class
199eyes from what I've seen my personal experience and what I've hear from a lot of other people is that you know teachers probably a higher percentage of than most other groups have a care for kids right and so when when I teach in a year that I have like 20 kids I I have a high level standard for myself and then suddenly when class eyes Ballo and I'm teaching 30 kids 40 kids I still have that same high level expectations for myself my kids and the performance and that just makes me work a lot more and I'm on burnout Lane right and so one of the things I just want to be careful of is like I know there's some class- siiz data but if we correlate that or or sorry if we if we
200cross-section that with I don't know if that's the right term um with yeah with with turnover rate um what are we looking at because we know that turnover is also a huge institutional cost and I just want to so so like I agree that some places class size doesn't make as much difference but it you know because i' I've worked in locals that the class size ballooned and I I could cope okay there I've also worked in some place where I could not and I think yeah so I just want to be I just want to add that yeah and and honestly I didn't I didn't mean that to in any way be a reason for for not doing it I I more wanted to actually surface it because maybe we should just do it
201like maybe because of the teacher you know satisfaction and burnout rates and you know because of the community satisfaction rates maybe this District should put a whole bunch of resources um take it from some of the specialty programs and other things and and put it into lowering class sizes you know you know and and we've talked about this we could you know we asked for this data years ago uh the cost estimates and we could cap class sizes at 28 and it's millions of dollars that gets redirected primarily from unders search schools to to more wealthy schools but like we could do that and there are some good reasons to do that I think if we do it we should be honest that we're probably not going to see student achievement gains from it but
202we might see better teacher retention we might see better teacher satisfaction we might see better Community satisfaction we might see trust go up in the schools and maybe that's a good reason to do it even if the student achievement doesn't go up if our parents and Community believe in the district maybe that will have a positive impact on student achievement indirectly so there are reasons to do it I just I think we should have a really blunt conversation about it yeah and actually that that's actually where I was assuming you're going which is why I said to add to that not to argue against but yeah yeah so thank you for adding that I I agree completely um director B I didn't sayate my statement um I didn't I'll just say it really quick um
203just really quick I think just uh student achievement um I would also I mean School leadership is also important but I also am a little bit I guess I don't quite understand uh because for when I look at this question and plan it for worst case scenario uh when I look at this question it's like what are are we asking what are we protecting right in future Cuts or are we assuming the best case and what are we investing in so I think those are kind of two different questions yeah I appreciate that and I would say I would encourage as you um continue to answer bard um I I believe this will fuel future conversations about what are the tradeoffs for some of those items that you know may cost more that will require
204more resources um sort of the if not that then what can we backrack a little bit I'd like to add to I only said the one the Early Learning um but would definitely be student achievement but also hiring and retaining the best staff and I would say especially at the principal level where we know that that that can having a stable principle will um will will increase achievement thank you director BR mys yeah I mean when the I this mirrors the survey that went out to the community I think that I sent you an email saying how come class size isn't on there just knowing that the community interest um so my question I'd say is like soon this achievement seems like an outcome I'm trying to think what what are those budget expenditures that
205we're saying is going to result in student achievement because obviously student achievement by number one but like what does that mean in terms of of budget expenditures because for me this may be actually it's classroom instruction maybe it's classroom instruction in class size or um but I I'm not sure what that means from a budgetary standpoint so I'd want to understand better is it that we have um you know push in supports or you know tiered levels of support for students so maybe that's what it is I would I would say that okay uh but I think be more specific about what the budget what the investment is um and we know that um high quality instruction is what makes all the difference so I would have to be for that and also School leadership
206it's not those are things are important but if you're just want for wanting to drive changes in classrooms and for students those are the ones for academics I would say great director Holland and I'll go to direct director solivan um I guess for me it just it'll be student achievement um classroom instruction and CTE um Career Technical education um some of the reasons why is that you know when you get kids that are interested in things they tend to want to be at school get excited about school as well so I would say student achievement casom instruction and uh CTE says the B Alum I work there so I I hear you um director Sullivan um I would say hiring developing and retaining the best staff and that should lead to Quality classroom instruction and
207inclusion of all students and certainly achievement so I think get the best St and going to except maybe for physical facilities I can't do much about that but um kind of would make everything else work and director green if You' like to finish it off um I I would go with um the literacy The Early Childhood literacy um the science of reading um phonics of reading um making sure that all of our kids understand that and that they are they're in position by the time they get to the um third grade changing our language from can to will so that would be my number one um I would then go to hiring and devel hiring development attaining the best staff um making sure that we have the right people um in our schools not just
208in the schools but in the right seat um so it may be necessary to move some staff um and do some shuffling to make sure that we got the right people on the bus and in the right seat um that's important um I I also want to say um I know we haven't hit on it much but um I'm G say the physical facilities um I want our kids to know that we intentionally are creating spaces where um they can learn it's hard to learn when you know you got rat poop in places and holes in the ceiling and stuff like that so improving those physical facilities so they actually want to be in our building that they want to be in those spaces and that they feel they can learn um so if I
209had to limit it to three I think that's where that's where I would go excellent I appreciate that so this next one is a lightning round so you get uh one positive aspect of this is thinking of strengths and opportunities you get one positive aspect of Portland Public School SCH and one thing you would change about the district I can go first um a positive aspect is we have people that are dedicated um we have a you know we have people that that want to be here they're mission mission motivated um one thing I could change about the district is um having more of an abil to uh not not replicate the way we've done things and to be open to um really being Innovative in our approaches to everything from the budget to um
210teaching kids how to read I got go uh the most positive aspect for me at the district is our kids our kids is what makes me get up our kids is what makes me want to continue kids it make me want to keep doing U what I'm doing um I think I probably would change um oh God have one I'm G just stick with the Positive okay uh single most positive I'm not not just because I'm sitting next you but I'm gonna say uh superintendent Armstrong as I'm really excited about your Just Energy and and passion and and um as we talked about taking advantage of the sunny Moon period we could make it last two three years like we make it last uh and there's one thing I could change about the district uh
211I'm going to say our toxic relationship with the community and I'm going to stop there because I got a lot of views on why it's toxic but that's not important doesn't really matter what caused it how it happened uh who was at fall um it exists and it's got to be fixed one way or the other dror solvin okay I I think the most positive thing is that I see throughout the district people really caring of about each other and certainly about educating our kids um the change I would say it feels like we're not very flexible when a need comes up that was Staffing seem kind of stuck sometimes and I think Jay Runo said he said we're not very Nimble when we need to make adjustments for our kids and I think that
212probably is something that just takes more money and more people but uh with what we have I don't think we're as Nimble as we could be either that's it thank you I guess I I'll go really quick um I I think one of the huge positives of this district is just the care and diversity of everyone I me I'm talking about students the teachers I mean some of the nicest kids I've ever work with some of the greatest teachers are just brilliant and really creative and really hardworking and really passionate about their work and the the kids that are really passionate about just so many things um I think one of the the one thing I can change I'm just going it's actually kind of a positive because I think D superintendent Armstrong has really
213hit this headon is that in in the past I think there's been a feeling that there's uh people Wen feeling schools and staff weren't feeling supported in this district and I think um superintendent I'm showing you've been kind of really uh attacking this head on and changing course on that so I think that is kind of a positive so uh but it's a lot of work no pressure okay so um one positive thing just our students and our families I think they're amazing um and then one thing to change um that we can't support all our students achieving um at high levels Dr Green you're still with us yes I am because we can't see you yeah that's intentional um so the thing that um the thing that I love about our district um are
214the are the people um I I I love the people that are that are coming this work I love the um I love the the students that that show up um inspite and despite of us sometimes um I I love that they they continue you know that they continue to challenge to um to think differently so I love the people um relationship is King in my world um the thing that I would uh change so that I don't beat on a drum and I can make sure that I'm adding maybe uh different is that we would be that we would be proactive instead of reactive that we would that we would get in front of the problem um and address it versus responding to the problem and I would I would say that across the
215board in everything that we do when it comes to communication that we would be proactive instead of reactive when it comes to um looking at um the needs of our of our kids that we would be proactive instead of reactive that that we that we make the initiative and we be transparent with the community around it and then we um we show them this is what we're doing and this is why and that we wouldn't um respond to issues um that we would be we would constantly stay in front of the issue and be communicating that with our um families and community and with our staff so that everyone understands and it's on the same page around what it is we're doing what they can expect and who they can contact if they got questions
216concerns or irritations thank you so that that was excellent everyone had a chance to go did you go Michelle yeah okay great so yes we that was macro we will have a few other engagements where we're going to go a little bit deeper and talk because as you all know our budget needs to reflect the priorities of um the board and we are going to engage and lean into that process over the next several months so we have just a couple more slides we're going to go really quickly so that we can wrap this up in two minutes and two seconds at least um thank you good evening or should I say good night uh de fory Chief of Staff um I'm not going to read this page you already voted on your uh 2025
217legis session advocacy but for the 20 people out there including my husband hi honey who's watching us right now here is our legislative agenda as a reminder so um we're going to be working very hard on all of these pieces because they all manage to influence our budget in a very very direct way all right next slide please and then um along with the legislative ADV advocacy going hand inand with our budget advocacy is our engagement opportunity um we believe strongly that one of the ways that we're going to achieve uh um Dr Armstrong's one of her priorities of building trust and relationships and get at an uh director Scott's issue around um building trust and relationships with our community is by doing a lot of Engagement opportunities so we've already done a community survey
218which director brim Edwards mentioned earlier uh we will have uh results from that we'll discuss those at the the plan right now du the March 4th uh board meeting we have started principal engagement we have heard in the past that possibly one of the most important people to influence the change in our children's lives are the principles and they haven't felt as engaged in the budget process in the past so we started um with them early early and often and um Dr Franco has been leading up those those um engagement opportunities for principles we're doing focus groups which is uh I don't know if it's a new thing I haven't seen it yet so that's coming up in the future and then educate Our Town Halls um not just reaching the principles but the people
219who are teaching our kids to ensure that their voice is being heard and then um one thing that is not up there but is also um very important is doing some Community forums and we're actually tying them together with our legislative advocacy meetings because trying to get people sometimes out for a budget Forum when there's not really the budget to talk about is a little challenging but if we tie it to um our legislative advocacy work um that's we think is going to be very fruitful there's already been a few scheduled um superintendent Armstrong and director Wang are going to uh Southeast Portland denway Elementary Schools spearheading one on February 10th and we were in contact with several other schools and wanting to hit every quadrant I guess there's more there's five now um I'm
220not going to go there um many six that's right Southport so there's trying to hit every area of our um Town possibly even every cluster to ensure the parents are able to come commune members to talk about their views on the budget and then we will inspire them to go to Salem and Lobby for the lobby their legislators that's right and actually I would love um any of your Insight and feedback into ways that you think we could improve our community engagement thank you last slide thank you perfect all right I just want to say one thing I wrote something for Mayon and so I just want to just kind of just let them know U I just want to take a moment to express my heartfelt gratitude and deep appreciation for you um your
221dedication expertise and steady leadership has been invaluable to this organization and I want to make sure that I give you your flowers now um in times of both opportunities and challenges um your ability to guide guide us with Insight Integrity strategic Focus um has ensured our continued growth and stability we are truly fortunate to have someone as talented as committed as you helping us navigate our path forward thank you for not only staying with us but for inspiring me um you know you're I know you had all kind of stuff to do you ready to retire and the fact that you stayed anyway inspired me to really put priorities in first which is our key and um so I just want to say thank you and also thank you for giving me the push when
222we was at Innovative uh Studios and you pushed me to go and do that uh impromptu skit um but I just wanted to say I yeah just want to say thank you so much um for everything you've done thank you so much director Holland I really I really appreciate those words and uh yeah that was a memor memorable day for me too because you gave me a push to stick around um that on that occasion and other occasions so thank you very much if I can just add one appreciation on my part which is to the staff of the finance division U they were and remain a huge part of of why I or anybody that was in my uh situation was able to to be effective or try as as well as I could
223to be effective it just wouldn't have been been possible or wise to attempt to do so without the the awesome work and the awesome people in the finance division so point of P Personal Privilege since there was a little moment I just wanted to thank everybody there thank you for sharing that was awesome but I have to note that um we forgot to bring the cake there's no cake so okay good because then otherwise the vice chair and I will have to figure out some manufactured crisis to force you back in February um so we can get you cake um I thought you were sign me say that out loud all right um thank you Chiefs Lee and cury I've really appreciate and I don't want to adjourn this because otherwise you have to go
224so we're going to stay for another two hours um well okay I guess I should all right this meeting is adjourned thank you everyone