001e United States of America stand indivis and justice for all Mr mirez you have roll call okay next purpose of the meeting is to approve any personnel and other matters properly presented uh do we have any public regarding agenda items and this is for our special meeting seeing none okay next we have um I'll need a motion to approve for election of the LTS as presented any questions or discussion all in favor any opposed next we have academics we've got uh a field trip request b art show agreement at the Palmer mall I it have motion okay motion to approve field trip request as presented and motion to approve the art show agreement at the Palmer mall is presented any questions or discussion all in favor any opposed okay next we have budget and finance
002a motion to approve the participation in the colonial iu20 copy paper janitorial product bid for the 2526 school year the bid will be awarded on Janu on February 25th 2025 B motion to approve an increase of pay from 225 to $2.60 for each of the three elected municipality Tax Collectors for each tax bill payment Collective effective July 1st 2025 and C motion to approve the assessment appeal stipulations as presented any questions or discussion all in favor any opposed okay next we have other business a motion to approve the expulsion hearing waiver form number 54558 as presented all in favor any opposed okay next we have interest interested citizens regarding non-agenda items anyone interested in speaking okay seeing none call for an adjournment of the special meeting all in favor I okay next we will move
003into our regular standing committee meeting uh roll call is the same we've already done the Pledge of Allegiance so next we will have the superintendence report Miss pza thank you I will remind uh the public that we do have one board member um on on Zoom or on call with us this evening so we thank Miss Sando o Dennis for joining us that way I really don't have um much to share out today other than the weather has been uh trying for us this month so we have some back-to-back meetings uh just so the public knows we also do have an executive session meeting tomorrow for uh scheduled for the purpose of personnel um negotiation matters so that will take place tomorrow we have a few shout outs for this month this month is Career
004and Technical Education Month this is also National African-American history month school resource officer day as the February is February was February 15th and February 22nd is school bus driver appreciation day so certainly want to thank um our resource officers and our bus drivers for the work that they do on a daily basis neither of those jobs are easy jobs and uh particularly would not want to be a school bus driver with all the responsibility of of the lives on their buses so we certainly appreciate the work that um that they do in that department and certainly Mr burnhard is here tonight as well and want to thank you for your leadership in that department um this evening the only report I have is we are going to invite our CIT Representatives here t uh T
005not tonight sorry okay my fault um so I think that concludes my report for this evening a little abruptly report move on from there thank you everyone um we're just going to go through regular presentations okay so next we have academics Dr Draper good evening everyone um this evening the curriculum instruction team will be um bringing for you presentations on our um data for local assessments that were um administered in the beginning of the year and also the middle of the year so we're going to be presenting screening data as well as growth data we will also have a presentation by one of our building principales Mr couples at paxos elementary school as well as I'm happy to see here and jabel she is an educational consultant with patan who's going to be doing a
006presentation about their data particularly in kindergarten um after they've been using a program called the ecre program and they're going to give you a little bit more information about that during their presentation and then finally um this evening the cni team will be sharing information about um our Middle School's designation being a cascading uh CSI school so we're going to go ahead and get started with the midyear review thank you Gino so our objectives this evening for sharing this data is we want to be able to to share with you where did we start in the beginning of this school year and where are we at this point at the end of the school year we will be coming back before the board to share with you our end of the year data and so
007for this evening we're going to share the data explain and share with you our midyear progress updates some key data points some of our successes and what we plan to do moving forward from this point on next and so just to provide some background all of the work that we are doing is in alignment with the comprehensive plan that we um drafted together during the last school year and we have here that by the end of 2627 our goal is to increase the percentage of grade three students who are reading on or above grade level and that is by the end of 2027 that we uh plan to achieve that goal however this year our Target is to have 70% of all of our K through third grade students reading on grade level additionally our
008second goal um we want to achieve a profic proficiency rate of 80% or higher in ela and Mathematics for students in grades K to 8 we want to accomplish that again by the end of 2027 however this year our Target is to have 65% of our students who will achieve this Proficiency in ela and Mathematics and so we will be taking a look at um data and sharing with you how our students are doing thus far and we're we are in terms of meeting on these goals so the types of data that we're going to present to you this evening will be a cadient which is primarily for our kindergarten and through second grade students in ela we have our star and reading math data as well ASL um data and we're going to be
009sharing with you both screening and growth data and so I'm going to ask at this time to turn it over to miss Hilton who is going to be sharing our Arcadian sta with you thank you Dr Draper uh good evening everyone so as Dr Draper explained we have both screening and Benchmark data uh the first measure that our kindergarten first and second grade teachers look at administrators is our acadians many of you may be familiar with it uh referred to as dibles so the acadians is a little different than some of our other screening or other benchmarking tools because it is a risk assessment um it indicates which students are on track for meeting Benchmark goals go in future um assessments so it measures criticalness critical skills including pheic awareness phonics fluency and comprehension can
010go to the next screen Gina so the first screen here is kindergarten you'll see that there's the beginning of the year rainbow and the end of or the middle of year rainbow and obviously we're looking for lots of greens and blues um over on the left I indicated if students are in the red or yellow they are at risk at the beginning of the year for not meeting The Benchmark reading assessments um in the future so those are the students that we would refer to at um for intervention both in our win time and our tier three time the blue and the green students are indicating th those indicators show us that those students are likely to meet Benchmark um benchmarks in the future for those critical reading skills so you'll see at kindergarten at
011the beginning of the year we had 53 students on track for meeting uh midyear benchmark goals and in the middle of the Year 66% of them um are still showing that they're on track for meeting those future goals over on the right is the progress report and what we look at in our students is their Pathways of progress and this this measure is in my opinion the most critical measure because this shows which students are are growing typically or above typical progress based on thousands of data points across the country comparing our students to students at the same gr grade level that be began the the year at the same composite score so we are looking for a a score of at least 80% or higher so we should see 80% of our students making
012typical or above typical progress uh leaving for about 20% that might need that intensive reading intervention so you'll see right now we're at 63 for kindergarten so in first grade you'll see not much change from the beginning of the year to middle of year this is very typical for first grade um the middle of the Year first graders are introduced to What's called the ORF and that's the oral reading fluency so it's the first time that we're asking kindergart our first graders to read um connected text so that's very challenging and we're also starting to measure comprehension so moving really from decoding to more comprehension measures and that's very challenging for many of our students in the middle of first grade so you'll see in first grade we are making 54% of our students are
013making typical or above typical progress and we are still and only about 51% of our students in first grade um not at risk or the were that are on track for meeting Benchmark at the end of the year so we have quite a few students in first grade across the district still receiving intervention support during win time and tier three in second grade you'll see this is this is like the the relay race so we're passing the Baton from kindergarten to first to second in hopes that we have students more and more students reading on grade level and less students at risk and you can see that bar looks a lot more blue and a lot more green so that's a good sign and we'll see you see at the middle of year 71% of
014our students are on track at second grade and 63% of them are making typical or above typical progress good evening so we'll I'll review with you the star data uh as well as Exel um so as Mrs Hilton mentioned we're using that a Cadence data to identify both tier 2 and tier three interventions and supports for our students in Reading in grades K2 um the same would ring true for our star data in grades three through eight for reading um and grades 1 through eight for mathematics so star is used for two purposes uh the first is to screen students who are in need of intervention identify those students um and to provide them with that intervention and use this as a progress monitoring tool um but it's also used to measure student growth and
015that growth is from the beginning of the year to the middle of the Year from the beginning of the year to the end of the year uh and across grade SC uh bands um one of the benefits to to the star Universal scale is that we can actually track progress across grades uh in addition to the um how students are progressing during a particular school year Gino you can go ahead and click to the next side um so as you can see here um on the left side uh of the screen what you're going going to be seeing is our fall Benchmark and the percentages of students at or above Benchmark uh and then on the right side there you're going to see the percentage of students who um are at or above Benchmark in
016the winter and then the difference uh would be in that third uh fourth column to the right so as you can see um we're seeing um growth uh in each of those areas um in uh reading as well as mathematics um as listed there with a green arrow pointing up so this is typical this time of year to see those percentages increase once again I want to reiterate um as I've stated previously is that the Benchmark goes up so what students are expected to know and be able to do skill-wise on these assessments increases as they progress throughout the course of the school year um so it's not a stagnant number to say once you get to the 500 you're at or above but that number is constantly moving depending on the grade level so
017the expectation is there is continuous growth throughout the year but that we are also getting students and filling in the gaps so that that they are now reaching that um at or above Benchmark uh standard that we're placing on them by the district um moving over to the far right category there um we did a a little adjustment or an upgrade uh to our presentation and now we can see our screen report right next to our growth report and so that far right column there shows the percentage of students who are meeting their growth Target that growth Target is 35 SGP um and what that means it's typical growth so as Mrs Hilton mentioned typical growth for um the a Cadence data um we're looking at 54 60% of our kids um we've always set
018the standard here is we want to be at 70% so we want 70% of our students to be at typical growth um and right now we are reaching that with many of our grade levels in both reading and math mathematics but there is still some work to do in other grades um and so we're looking at a couple factors that we'll talk about later uh in summary with the data in terms of being able to move that forward right and get higher numbers of students meeting their growth Target uh during the course of a year Doo you can click to the next screen um and this now we're looking at mathematics so as you can see more of our students are hitting the uh growth Target um in mathematics um right now in terms of
019that 70% marker um and we are seeing steadily steady increases in the number of students at or above Benchmark from the beginning of the year uh to the end of the year uh one last point before we go into the iel data um it's important to note that the star data is our closest correlation um to the pssa data so it gives us an indicator on where students are today and where they will be um if they are in a tested grade for example in grades 3 through eight um and so that's really important for us um to be able to see what those end ofe goals are uh and then our progress towards reaching those end of your goals using that star data Gino I Exel okay so we also have U another screener
020if you will um and a way to measure student growth um which ISL um one of the other reasons why we use ISL in the district is to develop individual student growth plans that are B based upon their individual skill sets so there's a diagnostic assessment that's given to all of our students um in K through 8th grade in both Ela and Mathematics that diagnostic assessment then gives our students individual skill plans that our students can work on during the week um and each of those then sets a standard for that growth during the course of the year so Gino shows us the next slide we're able to see where students are in relation to the Benchmark in the fall and the Benchmark in the winter this Benchmark is different uh than the star Benchmark
021it's measuring um different things uh as well as the cut scores are different um from the Star assessment doesn't necessarily correlate as strongly to the pssa but it gives us an indicator of where students were at the beginning of the year um versus where they are today um in that winter assessment as you can see in most of our grade levels similar to the star data we are seeing increases of the number of students at or above Benchmark um um the two pieces there uh that are not is sixth and seventh grade and there are some slight in decreases in those two particular areas once again The Benchmark continues to rise as students progress throughout the year so it is not uncommon to see some of those students not reaching that um and then we
022look at the farri category again which is just as important uh to us is the percentage of students um meeting their growth Target so forl the expectation is that students have 100 points of growth for one school year so midyear that Target is 50 growth points um during the course of the school year um each of our buildings uh pushes students to try to to work towards two skills of proficiency or Mastery per week um and that will be keep them on track for reaching that 50 scale points by midyear and that 100 um scale points by year end um so that's kind of our growth layout there for reading Gino math um so taking a look at math we're seeing similar increases um and or a leveling there in grade six and grade 1
023right now um what we're seeing though is that even in those in the grade for example grade one 80% of the students are meeting their growth Target already at mid year of 50 points of growth um even though we're not seeing an increase of the students at or above um starting off the year at 82% is a pretty high bar um and it tells us a little bit about the progress that our students have made from kindergarten um into first grade and having such a high number in terms of students at or above uh Benchmark once again another data point that our mtss teams are using at the building level to determine student intervention uh and then progress towards reaching their midyear and yearend goals G youo thank you Mr cck and Miss Hilton and
024so when we take a look at this um the data that was just presented to you I will say that um considering that we rolled out a new curriculum this year in ela and Mathematics and it was brand new to all of the staff um with I would say in the beginning limited professional development we still have more profession development that we would like to do with our staff I would say that overall we are pretty pleased with where the data is at this point in time um as Mr said there is still more work that needs to be done because typically we would like to see at least Le 80% of our students who are performing at or above grade level with the understanding that sometimes with that 20% through the use of intervention
025or other services you know students may need um additional support in order to um grow um to meet the benchmarks by the end of the year and so um like I said with this at this point we're kind of pleased with where we are however I mean it does beg for us to ask the questions you know why aren't some students showing the expected growth that we would like to see um particularly around mid year and then what are some other things that we can learn from one another and so through our conversations through our walkthroughs um and reviewing the data one thing that we are going to focus on as a team is to the perservation of time and so making sure that we have dedicated time for ELA and Mathematics and our other
026um content areas and making sure that we have enough time in our schedule to that that teachers can instruct in these areas and that was something that had to be changed um during the course of the year because we were finding that there wasn't enough Ela time you know on the schedule for teachers right and so that was something that we made a a a minor change this year we're going to revisit it again so we can um start the school year off with having the amount of time that we feel would be appropriate for teachers to teach these core um content areas or so bless you looking at our core instruction again keeping in mind that we did roll out a new curriculum and so we did do a soft start this year we
027wanted to give teachers an opportunity to kind of become familiar with those tools but in the meantime teachers were using some of the new materials and then also kind of you know reverting back to what was more comfortable and so we have had the conversations with our teachers particularly Grace um K to 5 at this point in time that you know moving forward from this point forward to the end of the year to really become um to use the core um a board approved curriculum um moving forward and then also looking at That explicit instruction are we making sure that um instruction is being provided explicitly using The Graduate release model where they're is a modeling of the skill where there is guided practice of the skill and then allowing the students to actually practice
028the skill through different genres and in different content areas um also taking a look at intervention um in our conversations with our um interventionist at different buildings we want to um in include them more in in the whole group small group time um during um during that tier one instruction and so some of that wasn't happening um as much and you know just because that was a directive that was given at one point in time and so we want to talk just make some shifts into having our um interventionist involved a little bit more with that time also looking at attendance um you know which is um a factor you know we have where we have students who may not be in school consistently and then we also have teachers who may not be there
029consistently and so we know that um both plays a huge role in ensuring that you know students are getting the knowledge and able to practice it but that consistency is really going to be important for um student Improvement and so also what can we learn from each other you know as you look at some of this data um you will see that there might have been some growth and some grade levels are doing really well and and and Miss hes I know that you did make a request to see it broken down by schools and grade levels which we will certainly get that information out to the entire board um but there are some areas where there is tremendous success and so just begin to have those conversations within our plc's about what's taking place
030in those classrooms so that we can share bre practices across the district and so just to highlight success um Grace K12 they certainly have met their end of the year Target already um by having 65 % um Proficiency in ISL reading um and then also um kindergarten growth at paxinosa elementary school I certainly don't want to take this away from Mr couples and Miss Bell but I have to say that um kudos to Mr couples and his team um along with the partnership of um patan that the growth for our kindergarten students um have grown tremendously um um since the beginning of the school year and so I'm going to stop there and let Mr couples kind of talk a little bit more about that so are we on track to meeting our district on
031targets for this year one in ela thumbs up yes we are and for mathematics we still have um some more work to do and so we're continue to have those conversations um um with our um principals and also um with our coordinators and teachers so for next steps what are we looking at so our M schedule so I talked talked about that a little bit we want to revisit that schedule and increase um dedicated uninterrupted time for ELA and Mathematics and so the focus on on core is 80% is the rule right there um making sure that that time is dedicated so in elementary schools you know we know a lot goes on we want those to be the years you know not just Elementary but all years that students remember um throughout their educational
032career and so we do understand that there events that come up where parent volunteers come in other volunteers come in and that we welcome that but on those days are we making sure to come back and make sure that we're doing Ela and Mathematics so we're going to take a look at that schedule and have more conversation about that um we're going to take a continue to look at our core instruction and our use of the curriculum and so we want to implement the approved curriculum with Fidelity and then um also we're going to continue to conduct our walkthroughs and provide feedback um to our building leadership assessments we're going to continue with the um screening and benchmark assessments that we shared here today but another uh form of assessment that we have to take
033a look at is the program based assessments and common assessments um throughout the district and so each curriculum has an assessment built within it and so we want to begin to implement those during the 25 26 school year so we can better assess um instruction towards those skills and then just ongoing um professional development and so providing that dedicated professional development and coaching which I think is huge I think often times you know myself I remember as a as a teacher also as a voen principal we provide professional development it's like a once and done we hear the information and then expectations to go back and do it but I think what's been very beneficial and what's helpful is to also receive that coaching on what they received and so they have somebody who's following
034up with them who's kind of checking in and and you know to provide some you know tips along the way and so that concludes our portion of the middle of the year um data review before we move on to paxinosa elementary school I just like to open it up if there are any questions from board members um about the data that was presented thus far okay I do sure um so first of all I guess you know I I think it's great we've got growth and we continue to talk about what the growth is the concern I have is looking at a lot of the numbers and still seeing that maybe we have 50% who are meeting that uh Target however we still have that other 50% that's not right so that's a serious concern
035we continue to have that concern we continue to have that issue um so I guess you know looking at a lot of the stuff of how we're talking about how we're going to proceed and everything but I'm curious to know in some of the things like in the walkthroughs because that's it's on there twice as far as the walkthroughs what type of data do you get out of the walkthroughs that is helping to assess all of this can you explain because I I I also think there are some people here that maybe don't understand that or haven't heard any of that information and then I'll get the rest of my question sure and I will say that in the beginning of the school year when meeting with the building principls and we um ask each
036building principal to kind of do conduct walkthroughs throughout the school year and we have have a set Target number of walkthroughs that we ask them to do um as throughout the year so let's say 30 by 30 so in the beginning of the school year 30 walkthroughs by um let's say September 30th as an example and so we always um provide um like some guidelines for and for for things for which they should be taking a look at so we take a look at um domain um two I would say for example which is um classroom environment um so that has to do with is the classroom um set up in a way that will allow instruction to take place so is the environment conducive to Student Learning are procedures set in place so that
037um we have that uninterrupted time for instruction so for example um do students know the routines do they know the procedures are those being taught in the beginning of the school year and we provide time for that to be taught in the beginning of school year so that once instruction begins then the students already know the routines and then there are smooth transitions from whole group to small group students know where the materials are and so forth that's one two we we take a look at the classroom setup in terms of are there collaborative spaces for students to work together you know in groups for Project based learning or just for accountable talk purposes or to have that practice of the skill that's being taught within um within the lesson that day um we take
038a look at instruction so are we hearing are we seeing that gradual release are we hearing and seeing that there is a mini lesson where a a skill is being taught explicitly followed by guided practice along with the classroom teacher followed by practice with with students are doing it on their own independently with a classroom teacher working with a small group for students who may not have gotten it you know from the um explicit teacher from the mini lesson and so I will say that through from the walkthrough data we are we seeing that yes but I will also say that what we are seeing is um where the teacher is teaching and and we're not seeing a lot of practice of that skill with the students and so we have to be able to
039know that students can practice that skill independently in the presence of the classroom teacher and if they are collecting that data to be able to then pull those small groups or to revisit a lesson if necessary so we always provide um like guidelines for when principles are doing those walkthroughs what they should be looking for on a daily basis and then how are they providing that feedback and coaching um to their staff when we go out together as a team we too are taking a look at that and so we may not look at it specifically down to a classroom teacher level we're looking at across the district to kind of say where are we as a district in terms of making sure that um gradual releasees taking place the spit instruction taking place at
040student practice and I would say this last walkth through that we went on is the use of the materials okay and so what we are finding is that um we are seeing pockets of where teachers are absolutely using the materials we are finding that teachers are using other resources that align with the curriculum and then we find it with us some teachers who aren't using the resources at all right and so again being mindful that you know we purchased the curriculum over the summer we rolled it out in the beginning of the year we do want to allow grades for teachers to become familiar with the curriculum within materials but we have to provide that feedback to kind of say where we are as a district and where we need to go in order to
041move forward so that's some of the type of data that we are seeing um and I will also say to um preservation of time right so if we're saying that we are now moving to 120 Minutes you know for ELA or 90 minutes for mathematics is that happening and so sometimes I will say when we've done our walkthroughs we will get there at the start of um maybe the ELA block and is it start starting on time at 9:15 and if it's not then what's happening during that time is it that um attendance is taken place or other things have taken place so then we have to have that conversation or all those routines and procedures in place so that we can begin and in you know on time so those are just um some
042of the things that we take a look at but all of the information that we collect is for our team to then kind of go back and talk about what type of professional development we need to have or conversation to have with that building principles about moving forward again I'm sure I'll have more questions based on some of those answers and looking at this and I would definitely like to see again the breakdown of all the individual schools especially with the data um and and with the Baseline absolutely so um but again going back through I guess to this was one of the concerns when we talked about having an implementing a new instu the new curriculum um was we sort of put a little bit of professional development out there for our teachers however
043um I know in the past and I've had this conversation was in the past we have done it where it was the guides those things were already set up so is that what is we are moving towards now is that that's what you're telling me is that we're moving so we would have guides for the teachers to be able to follow so they had outside resources that they could utilize they had the resources of what would be in the books those are we're we're basing that now is that that's what we're going towards is the goal for this year and going forward yes and and as not to overwhelm our teaching staff at the beginning of the year with a do this by then uh type atmosphere we wanted to allow the teachers that flexibility
044in moving into the new materials and the timeliness of that um to then building those those structures right so identifying specific units from the series that teachers should be utilizing with a specific time frame from which to do that um what we didn't want to do is to while they were being provided with professional development regarding the instructional model and implementation to then be provided with on Thursday September 23rd you shall be completed with unit 2 three and four so in you know change process is something that we've focused a lot of time and attention on um very intentional about that change process and identifying that with our principles in terms of providing teacher support but yes you're absolutely correct in that we are working on those specific documents now um to ensure that there
045is more Fidelity uh but also that we're understanding and providing Grace uh to our professionals who are you know somewhat overwhelmed or were over more overwhelmed at the beginning of the school year with the adoption of these new materials sorry Mike can you say that again that we are did you say we are being very specific on what they should be doing at what point we are building right those those scope and sequence documents that refer to where they should be in terms of pay in so right now their units have been written on skills and there's lots of flexibility over the last couple years in terms of the resources they use to teach those skills so that now we're getting back to something that's a little more routine in terms of the skills and
046it's its connection to the gradual release model and then how the skills are built throughout the course of the year we're going to be more strategic in How We Lay those out for our staff members moving forward in 2526 right now we are still providing much flexibility uh to those but we are strongly encouraging the use of these materials versus some of the things that have snuck in so to speak over the past um and that's because the philosophy was slightly different in terms of our approach we were very specific we went away from a little of that specificity to provide more of the teacher opportunity to find some of those materials and now we're move moving back to making sure that the teachers have kind of that guide um in terms of that process
047as they progress throughout the course of the school year I'll make my comment then so what I will say is the goal of the district is that that we have a standalone curriculum and the materials that are used are regardless what often happens is we buy a series and that becomes the Bible of the work that is happening and what is very critical to our district and all districts is that there is a scope and SE quence not necessarily A A pacing guide or a schedule like you might be thinking about but a scope and sequence of skills and and Concepts that need to be taught at each grade level that scaffold upon each other to get to a desired um understanding and those are in place but yet being tweaked as we go along
048um in part based on the materials that we chose to use to be that resource to support the curriculum but should any of these resources go away should wonders go away should SAS go away way our our curriculum is Standalone and should be Standalone based on best practices science and reading math you know so on and so forth that our students wouldn't skip a beat regardless of what we're teaching I think we're still in that process of developing those best practices with our teachers um but also mirroring it to the materials that we chose to use as the resources for them to get to that endgame okay because I guess that was partially what I was asking is we're utilizing these what we're giv but there's many tools out there so are we allowing our
049teachers the autonomy to be able to utilize some of those things that are out there to be able to incorporate it in with our curriculum and the the books that we have purchased and so what I will say is that in the beginning of the school year that autonomy was given to teachers to be able to use whatever resources that are out there now that we have this curriculum we are asking for them and they have probably haven't had enough time yet to look at all of the resources that are available within the curriculum that we purchased and so therefore um we may we might be able to eliminate the duplicate duplication of materials packets and so forth um that teachers do which also takes up additional time if they if the resources are available
050right in the program that that we purchase so at this point time from now to the beginning of the year I mean the end of the year we do want teachers to to take a little bit more time to take a look take a closer look at those resources to see what's available and we may find that some of the resources that they might have been going towards might be right there embedded within the program so then I'm going to go back to the question of if they don't find that it's getting across to their students what resources do they have if they don't find that there's something in there do they have the ability to be able to go and teach their kids based on something that they find it is aligned with the
051curriculum and with the skills in which um should be taught then I would say yes and I would say I would still encourage the you know I have no problems encouraging I just don't want to take you know we have teachers and they're professionals and I want to make sure that we're giving them the opportunity to do what they were also brought to do and to not limit because you know I just want to make sure we're not sticking them in a box so that's part of my concern but thank you yeah these are all tricky conversations particularly when you're taking on a lot of new um resources all at one time which we did um while the money was available to us the bottom line is we want our professionals to be professionals but
052there is a very specific scope and sequence of skills and um Concepts that need to be taught and learned um and they they vary from grade level to grade level based on a lot of factors from K through 12 um and we purchased materials that were quite um extensive because we knew that they align to the skills that we wanted taught so we are looking for um an honest and Earnest use of those materials but as you stated when they find that individuals aren't being successful based on the materials that they're using or the strategy in which they chose then there's opportunity to shift for those individuals but first and foremost they should be looking at the resources provided to them because they were chosen for very specific alignment to what we were developing um
053but we're never going to uh pigeon hole somebody into only that what is not acceptable is for somebody to couch that on their shelf and say I'm not going to look at that at all there's an expectation that they use those resources look at them to see the value and alignment and then individually for their groups within their class make the decision of what is the best resource for that particular child or group then if I could ask a followup to that I guess if ultimately we're moving towards a guide then what we're looking at is a set of resources for teachers to use that are known to all of the teachers who are teaching that same material and so it would be um a collection including the textbook as well as you know other
054resources that are going to be cataloged let's say um and so it it will allow for like let's say you know 10th grade literature whatever there's you know the materials in the textbook but there's also three or four novels that generally are taught but an individual teacher can decide well this is the one I'm going to do this year somebody else might choose a different novel to do that same year but there're you know they're still available and known to everyone to be able to use okay so this will be one of of the main things as far as the professional development is the the guides yes and I would and I will say that um Miss Hilton and Mr cck have already been working with coordinators to kind of take a look at the
055Frameworks and those resources and what's already um what's already placed in Ed your plan to kind of make that alignment and to have those conversations so yes I I have a request for the end of year review is it possible to have a column showing last year's numbers um cuz I just want to I I would like to see a comparison so we know you know how we're doing thanks all right at this time I would like to um invite Mr couples and Miss Andre Bell to come forward to provide a presentation on their kindergarten Acadian sta good evening my name is Andrew Bell I'm an educational consultant with the Pennsylvania training and technical assistance Network Patton um we're often times referred to as the training arm of the Bureau of special education for many
056years Patton has um applied for and received State Personnel development grants that provide professional development and support to uh districts who come on to the work of the grants that we have we are um currently in a grant that we have titled spell that stands for success for PA early Learners and uh the goal of spell one of the goals is to ensure that students who are at risk for are identified with a delay or disability have access to evidence-based practices to improve their literacy outcomes um schools that come on to this work are required to implement um enhanced core reading instruction that are instructional routines that are explicit and systematic that provide um that systematic instruction that align with the core program that the teachers are using in their Elementary buildings um in reviewing
057the components of the grant the requirements with Dr Draper we said with Eon be willing to bring on a site to this work and paxinosa came on um to this work with us so acri is rolled out one grade level at a time through the three years of the grant so it starts with kindergarten this year first grade next year second grade the following year so kindergarten teachers at paxinosa along with a staff who provide interventions to kindergarten have been engaged in professional development and customized classroom coaching so that they are able to implement these instructional routines with Fidelity with the support of IU consultants and myself um to provide that implementation well um so how are things going so far uh we have been really pleased with the uh teachers implementing this work uh
058these teachers have made a difference in a very short amount of time they've been open they've been committed and they've been fearless and I just couldn't be more pleased so I thank you for the opportunity to work with the administrators at paxinosa as well as these committed um teachers and students it's been a pleasure and I will toss it to Mr couple so he can talk more specifically about what's been happening thank you good evening everyone and thank you for having me and thank you andreww for for all that information um it's a pleasure being here and able to speak upon uh some of the successes that we've had at paxinosa uh but specifically take a look at our kindergarten data um through our erri and our enhanced uh reading core instruction um as Andrew
059said our our kindergarten staff has just been phenomenal uh taking this on as Dr draer came to me late last spring um and we discussed this opportunity that we had um and then we Dove Dove straight in head first um our kindergarten staff with uh Miss McQueen Miss Miss mcneel uh Miss Market uh Miss sell Miss bab have just been phenomenal thus far um getting trained at beginning of the year in September um and really starting to implement uh erri in October so this is a short few months of work um and the fruits of their labor are definitely paying off through some of the data that we're going to take a look at so the first couple slides just kind of give a background about a little bit more about enhanced core reading instruction
060and as we mentioned some of the things um that you'll see with our data and our aadience was mentioned by U Miss Hilton um and also alignment to our wonders Core Curriculum program so evidence-based program tiered approach designed to uh ensure high quality reading instruction for all of our students um as we mentioned this year specifically in kindergarten focus is on providing effective core reading practices um with uh additional support for students who need it as Andrea mentioned um we do have other staff members trained as well other than our kindergarten staff and which we are beginning to provide some intervention supports for those students who we found to be in need of and we're going to continue to do so as we move along this process so erre aims to address the needs of
061all Learners ensuring that reading instruction is rigorous inclusive and accessible for all so three main components here that I pulled out um strong core instructions so you know a focus of us uh not just with within paxinosa but within our district um focusing on Improvement of our core reading instruction again aligned with wonders uh targeted support for our small group instruction as has been mentioned previously um and progress monitoring so regular assessment of students progress identifying areas for improvement and then also always looking at our data um which we'll take a look at in a second here so just some of those components to to make mention of um so key features another word that was used here throughout the evening thus far the importance of explicit instruction modeling reading strategies clearly for all students
062systematic approach sequence that builds on previously learned skills frequent practice and then differentiation um it is a very structured routine based um instructional practices uh for our students for our teachers so there was a lot for our teachers to learn a little bit of time and and implement this in the classroom so some of the benefits that we're um seeing already and hope to continue to see as we move forward uh improved literacy outcomes every student receiving the right amount of support to meet their potential identifying those students who may be struggling and uh providing those students with various forms of intervention whether it be through a tier two and then a tier three and then data driven instruction so teachers can adjust instruction based on those realtime student data what I'll show here is
063just a short minute or so clip um of some Meer instruction taking place this is actually one of our interventionist teachers um providing a tiered instruction with just two or three of the routines that they were um trained in right let's do some individual sounds listen to your name Bella awesome job all right let me good listening are we ready all right let's go through our sounds now okay ready card sound spelling Card Sound spelling s Card Sound spelling do card total sound spelling so again that was sorry again those were some students that were provided another tiered intervention um and it's the use of continuing those e routines with those students who we felt were targeted and needed some additional supports um the next couple slides we'll take a look at are some of
064our our goals and data again just uh through kindergarten and our aradian data um as a e core team we do meet monthly um and one of the areas that we take a look at every month and discuss is our data points so the blue was our beginning of the year data the red we had each individual teacher set goals for their middle of the Year data and then the yellowish color there is our actual data um from the middle of the year goal so you can just see per teacher how they individually uh set their goals and and how those teachers you know are definitely Meeting those goals at the middle of the year based off of their Acadian data this uh data point here will take a look at first sound fluency so
065again uh at the beginning of the year we had 43% of students who were at that Benchmark um we set a middle- ofe goal at 80% so quite High um and we actually reached 79% of our students at the middle of the Year data next slide uh discusses the phoning segmentation there are just middle of the Year goals there for this piece of it um so we had our middle of the year goal and then our actual middle of the year is at 83 um we just set a goal as a group at 85 not really having a great idea about where this should be projected to but we did feel that that is a goal that we should be able to meet um but we'll also challenge our students as well this is a
066great slide here that just um has the comparison from last year uh to be the beginning of of this year middle of the year and the use of ekri um in our in our classrooms you'll notice that last year we had 85 students and this year of 84 so the number of students is very comparable um the blue color is from 23 24 and the red for this school year you have the composite Score first sound fluency phon seg and the nonsense word fluency the bottom will give you the exact numbers of students that met those um those goals so you know you can see a great improvement from 56 to 66 71 to 79 our phone seg 52 to 73 and then our nonsense word fluency 64 to 67 so that gives us a
067good comparison of where our kindergarten students were last year at this time compared to the group this year through erri Mr couples I just want to interject this the data really excites me if you could go go back to that slide the phon segmentation difference is really important to notice if you'll see that that's over a 20 point increase and if children can segment and blend and manipulate phones they're ready for whole word reading so we couldn't say that about our kids at this time last year Well 50% of them but we can say that 75% almost 75% of our kindergarteners at Pax are ready to read whole words based on that data so the other bars aren't dramatically different I mean 10% is a lot 8% but 21% more kids are going to be
068reading they're already reading whole words and they're writing whole words so I just wanted to point that out there's other there's a few other things I want to point out but I'm just really excited for all please do so um and we just actually met with our our team uh last week and we began to set our goals for the end of the year and really focused on students reading right whole words and multiple whole words by the end of the year so um that's our next steps as we move along um and setting our end of the year goals so as was discussed earlier with Miss Helton we we're going to take a look at the ACC Cadence Pathways um and there's just a quick description of of what that aadience Pathways is and
069what it measures and as was discussed uh based on reading progress relative to other students who started the year with similar initial skills take a look at the left there of the uh projection and the pathways that are colorcoded from well below typical to below typical you have typical and green and then the point of focus is that dark green the above typical and the well above T typical that is in blue so we're going to take a look at each of those aspects in our students that are making that grow throughout those Pathways so some more data that that should excite everyone along with Miss Hilton Dr dber right as we've discussed so so again just some other information here regarding uh the Acadian path ways of progress uh establishing individual student progress monitoring
070evaluating individual student progress and rate of growth um and reflecting on the effectiveness of our system and supports within our classrooms teachers and then within our building atosis so um something we are once again meeting tomorrow uh with our kindergarten staff and our intervention supports to continue to have these discussions um and then identifying specific students in each specific area and we we can provide for those students in order to continue their growth so the first one we'll take a look at is well below Benchmark um so again um you can see the 45% so 45% 15 out of 33 of our kindergarten students who were well below in the red right their Pathways and their progress should be taking them to the dark green and the blue as we progress and move through on
071through uh throughout the year this is going to show the students who are in those yellow all right so 47% so eight out of 17 of those students um and the yellow that started off beginning of the year again should be showing that dark green or to that blue well above or above typical progress 69% of our students so a great number here 11 out of 16 all right who started the year in that green so we're on Benchmark all right so 70% of those students are progressing to continue to grow um and get into that those areas um in that blue um so those students who were there it's showing that they're going to continue to grow and move along the path that we want them to and not right scale backwards into maybe
072the light green or the yellow Mr couples knows this is where I want to interject so this this is really important also to highlight because we know when kids are coming in on Benchmark it's hard to move them it it's it's good if we keep them where they are and we keep them in the green but it's harder to move kids and they have that many kids so 60% of their core kids are making above or well above typical progress and if you go to the oh that's the blue kids so these kids came in already above Benchmark and we have almost 60 of them making well above or above or well above typical progress that is very hard to do and this is just just with the explicit instruction being implemented in core since
073October so about two months of explicit instruction and everything else that the teachers are doing their art of teaching the connections that they're making with the kids everything the culture at packs all of that factors in um but that's really really commendable so I really wanted to give a shout out for those for those two key points thank you so in the long run um you know 's proven approach strengthens reading instruction ensures all students can succeed we are seeing that our goal is to provide every student with the tools they need to become proficient confident readers uh especially as they prepare to move on to first grade and together we can make a lasting impact on literacy achievement so um I it's just been a great experience this far as I said our our
074staff in kindergarten has just done a phenomenal job um from the day one when we had these discussions about what this is how does it work what it looks like I will say the training at first is a bit intimidating right because it is a lot um it's down to the second of you know providing weit time for our students very explicit and very routine-based and it's a lot to learn so um just can't commend that kindergarten staff enough for the job that they have done um and then the other staff members that we have on our court team our intervention team you know when we meet monthly um and just the positive discussions that we have when it focuses on student achievement data and where we can go so um just want to say
075thank you again for having us uh you know the opportunity to come here and discuss where we're at and where we hope to move forward so thank you Mr couples I want to thank you you know as the leader of that building um you were open to the change you were open to the challenge right knowing that it would probably be challenging and difficult and also probably to change mindsets you know of people right and but you stuck with it you did it you um consistently gave the message of the importance of this work and it certainly has paid off so many thanks to you and also to Mr um Oswald as well um and your teachers you know for hanging in the air for doing it because um the results are are truly remarkable
076and Andrew I'd like to thank you so much um for your partnership and also for coming out this evening to kind of share in this success this success story with us so thank you thank you so one thing I'd like to highlight here and Mr couple Miss Bell thank you for all of your support and that of your teachers as well but I think that top bullet is probably one of the most important highlights of the slide where it says all students and so I don't want to minimize or U miss the opportunity to say when we say all students we mean all students so students who are achieving um you know typically students who may have an IEP a g um ESL you know all students are captured within that data and that's a
077really important distinction we're not teasing out any subgroup this is this is the student body of paxinosa and Performing uh quite high and we noticed this um you know a few years back when we did uh step by step it was a similar result at paxinosa and some of our other schools where all students really found their feet in in literature in particular and learned how to um manipulate letters and words and sounds in order to become readers and that was a a game Cher as I'm sure it is now when so often we have preconceived notions of what kids are may be capable of particularly around socioeconomic demographic you know there's certainly um you know research and reality out there that kids achieve to this uh to the point that we set goals and
078often if we only expect a minimal amount because of some EXT extraneous Factor then that's all they achieve because that's all we expect of them and so what this proves is when we have high expectations coupled with strong teaching all kids um regardless of their demographic or regardless of their cognitive abilities are able to pick up and learn and Achieve at a commensurate rate and so much to be um celebrated there at paxinosa so great job thank you just like to open the floor any questions for Mr couples or Miss Bell I I have a question are the kindergarten parents aware that their students are part of this program um so I would through our PTA meetings we've had the conversations about the programming um in the grant I'm actually just updated the PTA as
079far as where our our data is this exact information here um so through the PTA those conversations have been happening um uh so I would say through that process okay um what I like about this program is that for the next three years they're going to be following these kids and so I guess the next question would be like what do you think you do differently for your first grade and your second grade teachers especially when you mentioned that you know the training can be a bit intimidating you know what are the lessons that you learned this year that you take into the next two years yeah I would say one of the roadblocks is is the PD time right um and Andrew and I have had many discussions about when do we have the
080staff trained um you know training uh over the summer for staff is extremely difficult as you could imagine um so that we had to come up with some other options um training staff at the beginning of the year um having them out of the building for the two and a half days right yeah is is challenging as well so you have to kind of consider what's the best or the worst case um with those options so um and we have already had conversations about what the training looks like for first grade next year as long as additional staff that we feel need to be trained ESL staff intervention staff things like that um so it's really I think the big conversation uh for us right now is is is that specifically um and any other
081I just wanted to add in I think um for first grade they have the great opportunity to go visit a kindergarten classroom and see it happening in kindergarten because what happens with first grade teachers they're trained next the kids coming to them know what they're doing and they're just learning the routine so they want to feel comfortable about what does it sound like look like you know and so we can model in the first grade classrooms with first grade students at the end of the year before they get the training just to kind of give them a sense of that and then they can also see it happening in kindergarten too to get a sense of that so that would be a couple of ideas so one of the one of the inter pieces and
082it's not so um um Apparent at Pax Noosa is this is similar to what we did a number of years ago a step-by-step and very explicit instruction so any teacher who was around during that period of time have been trained on some of these similar skills um I think one of the things that they'll face at paxinosa is certainly the skills change as kids become more proficient readers and and um decoders of letters and words then the skills have to change as well and so not only does the training take place but also the training different differentiates based on now this new level of reader because you're not teaching those under skills they they're coming to you with them U the other challenge that that paxinosa faces is that paxinosa often um has a has
083a turnover of Staff where there's newer staff coming on board for a whole host of reasons right now he has a grade level that's pretty sparse based on um people growing their families and so I think they're they have one staff member who's the steady and and they're relatively new at that and so those are challenges of uh for leadership to consider and teachers to Mentor one another is how do we continue um to grow our own in these in these times that people are having their own lives and growing families and have circumstances that happen um because those skills um are important whether the teacher there or not and so one of the things that we often have to pay attention and quite frankly sometimes fall short on is those people who come in
084after the initial training has happened so how do we keep that a cyclical training for all staff as they turn over and or just continue to grow themselves as professionals joh thank you thank you and then one final presentation from um cni um department is we want to um just kind of make you aware of the designation of our um Middle School um becoming a cascading um CSI school and so yes thank you uh gin so there are some acronyms here we have atsi and CSI the middle school was um formerly designated as an atsi school which is additional targeted support and Improvement they were designated by the state because there were subgroups that did not meet the threshold or the criteria the Statewide criteria and those subgroups were um um Hispanic subgroup students with
085disabilities and then also economically disadvantaged and so the middle school was designated as an atsi School back in 2018 and so um every four years or so they take a look at that designation to see if those subgroups are ready to um exit or have met the um exit criteria and so um our middle school did not meet that exit criteria and so what happens now at this point in time what the state has decided to do is to Cascade any schools who are Title One schools receiving Title One funds um and designated as atsi to become a Cascade in CSI School CSI standing for comprehensive support and Improvement and so there are two designations there is a regular CSI designation and then there is a cascading CSI designation the regular CSI designation are those
086schools Title One receiving Title One funds um who did not meet the Statewide criteria and they have performed in the bottom 5% of the state that is not our Middle School our Middle School only received this design because um they did not their subgroups did not meet the designation by the end of um last year and so um we are hoping um that along with this designation um there will be additional funding that will be designated for those schools for school Improvement efforts um we will have the support of our Intermediate Unit and then also there may be um some additional support from our state level um to assist our school in meeting um their goals and so the next slide there um Gino just some information for our board there to kind of show
087you the subgroups that were identified and where they performed in um from 2018 up until um 2324 um in comparison with the Statewide average so that you have an idea of how those sub groups have formed and then in ela and the next slide also in mathematics and so the next slide then will then show um what needs to happen and this is the plan and timeline and so the schools were designated we had a meeting with um Miss Jones um to kind of discuss this designation um what needs to have in place in terms of developing a steering committee that will come together both a steering committee internal and external um to develop a school Improvement plan you know for how we're going to ensure that these subgroup groups um are growing and meet
088the criteria by the end of the um 4-year designation and so this month we're going to uh she's going to be conducting some stakeholder surveys and focus groups gather that data and then continue to identify what are some root causes um as to why you know the data looks the way that it is create some goals and then develop a plan and I just kind of outlined there some of our next steps and so again communicating this designation with their families also with staff um we're sharing it with you this evening with their school board meeting and then Mrs Jones we're going to um meet again to kind of determine who she would um suggest be a part of the internal external um committee we have some suggestions there and then we're going to um
089select our plan and Mee and dates for the remainder of the year so that we can develop the plan um together and provide support for her the next slide just kind of shows that the state does provide um opportunities um for the building leaders to participate in to um to get some more information and support on how they can conduct these certain sessions within um their buildings um to help them kind of you know again to with the development of their plan and that's where we are at this point I know that was kind of fast um but this really wanted to kind of make you aware that um the middle school is no longer an atsi school but they are now designated as a CSI school and the reason why they were designated and
090are there any questions I have a question are um the leaders at the middle school encouraged strongly encouraged to attend the um the workshops that the state is providing yes so yes Miss Jones um has this information and she it was Shar with her that she is absolutely more than welcome to have um to go to these sessions along with the team of people um but she was also informed that the IU will also come to uh the district as well and hold sessions with our team so as far as the planning timeline is this more what Miss Jones is handling we're doing it collectively together okay yes um um as far as the stakeholders and the surveys and how is that being determined as far as who the stakeholders are and how are the
091surveys is being sent out and so that is something we're we're communicating with Alis about how she how we want to um handle that the I did send some sample surveys that we could use um to send out to families and then also we have to have um a conversation about the focus groups in terms of who's going to be selected for that so we want to be a diverse group of um people who are participating in the focus groups and so we'll be meeting with her to have that conversation so when the information comes back and the Gathering analysis data who will be that will also be Collective or is that also then going to be M Jones that would be handling that no so that information will come back to the steering committee
092so this um plan is very similar to what we did for the districtwide comprehensive plan where we had a steering committee of about 40 people okay both internal external and then I mean external Committee of about 40 people but we had an internal committee which was primarily the the cni department so it's going to be similar to that where Miss um Jones will have an external committee which will be include parents teachers administrators school board members students and then it's going to be an internal who's going to take the information from that external committee to kind of then analyze that data have some further conversation and develop some goals and bring back to um the external committee okay so I guess my question then is as far as people being involved how is that going
093out to individuals of allowing them so it would be it was going to be announced it's going to um we're going to send out like a notification to say this and we'll ask um certainly parents will be informed the same way we did with the district wide committee to say that this has taking place um if there are anybody who's interested Community Partners as well um will be invited and then school board members will be invited so we're going to follow the same process that we did for the district comprehensive plan thank you sure thank you so much for your time this evening we know that was a long one um but we certainly wanted to make sure that we provided the data and information to you um at this time so but thank you
094for your attention this thus concludes our report thank you is there anyone to be public to be heard any public to be heard on academic agenda items seeing none okay we'll move on to Athletics Dr bolts uh or Dr thetic one of the two of you yeah we only have one item on the agenda this evening um and it was reviewed by King spry uh Matt you can certainly share the the plan for JV to come back to hacket park everything that goes with that then sure um you may remember for uh quite a few years we played a baseball triple header at hacket Park against Philipsburg um over the last couple years uh that field hadn't really been in the state we needed it to be in in order to play um competitive High
095School baseball games but they've done quite a bit of work in the city to improve the facility uh to the point where we'd like to move those games back over to hacket park this year so um just a letter uh basically agreeing to that um and then um just so everyone's aware we will continue to hold the varsity game uh at caola Park uh this year and hopefully uh for years into the future so any questions on that okay is there any public to be heard on athletic agenda items okay seeing none I guess that'll get moved then to the next meeting okay next way budget and finance Mr Trent yes uh excuse me the business office has two items for approval at the next meeting the first is a food service equipment purchase uh
096for a freezer door at East at the high school uh the total price of that will be $7,300 and then the other motion is for a new New Student Activity account for a book club at the high school that's all anyone have any questions on that okay is there any public to be heard on budget and finance agenda items okay seeing none those will get moved to the next meeting okay next we have buildings ground Safety and Security Dr zatic thank you Miss Hess and good evening everyone uh tonight we have quite a few things to present to you as as a board of directors uh mainly two items of Interest we do have Andrew maer here this evening uh who will be providing an update to our Capital Improvement plan uh and we will
097share that momentarily but before we do that Andrew we're going to take some time and talk about our transportation department um this evening we have Mr burnhard here uh who has been with us before uh presenting probably two months ago Ben has been asked to do a deep dive into the transportation department as all of you are aware uh and through that deep dive we have sat together uh as a team and really taking a look at how to improve the department over the next three to five years and where we want to ultimately be um within that goal setting process there are a few things that have been identified as critical you know as we would identify as a high priority on our own Capital Improvement plan it's identical The Identical process that we're
098undertaking here in transportation um so Ben is going to do some pres a presentation this evening that's going to Encompass uh departmental updates and also letters b c and d in the agenda this evening so all of those are going to be wrapped into the slide presentation um and then Dr Schult and Mr rali will also kind of jump in as necessary into the conversation um Ben first off I just want to recognize thank you for being here I know you are very much not feeling well uh and did let you know that you did not need to be here this evening but you felt it was one of the most critical evenings to be here uh so thank you and and I appreciate that uh and want to certainly bounce us over to you
099so um a lot of good information within the slides but we'll you'll take some questions at the end um and then Ben I would just ask maybe before bus Patrol we just stop and answer any questions for the previous three items okay okay well thank you uh I'm here tonight to talk about safety security and Service uh as I uh review our department that's what I feel the trip s's are very important and what I strive for so let's go to the next slide you know okay the 3 s's the transportation department has identified some major gaps in the 3 s's safety security and service to improve the departmental operations and to provide the safest and most efficient Pupil Transportation possible several core items have been identified as needed immediate attention these core items are
100being presented to the school board with the knowledge they need to make an educated decision so we'll be talking about radios tonight cameras and a wheelchair accessible School Bus move on so the first thing let's talk about Communications changing from analog to digital radios okay our three current system hinders the 3 s's we currently have po sound quality poor geographical coverage outdated technology equipment is known longer made we only have one channel available for communication it lacks accountability lacks emergency features lacks working equipment and the system is currently between 16 and 17 years old already so we tested two different uh systems our current provider we tested a system and we Pro tested radios from two-way communication how we tested systems we actually got a radio we put it in a bus and we actually
101drove around with it uh with students on board got feedback from drivers and uh as well as then we also tested geographical areas by actually going out and driving to some remote locations and saying can you hear me now so let's move on to the next slide there so the new digital systems proposing we'll have two channels we'll have a direct channel for operations and a direct channel for mechanic or emergencies this is one thing that is very important as uh if a bus breaks down you know the mechanics uh need to be able to communicate for while they push and pull the bus without interfering with our normal operations usually a bus breaks down r in the middle of a route uh and you know we have 75 other school buses on the road
102they need to be able to communicate uh direct direct Channel which is very nice if you go out on a field trip we have eight buses going to Westchester for a marching band and those buses can talk to another as long as with they're within a reasonable distance from each other enhances safety features I vehicle ID will be visible on the radios so everyone in the district will actually all the drivers will know who is actually talking on the radio and private conversations can be possible right now with the one channel if we have an issue with a student everyone hears that conversation there is no privacy uh in that conversation so the current system uh does not have all these features so when I said we test it we went out current provider sound
103quality was good the coverage was excellent proposed dispatch system uses a VPN the possible communication issues of power internet goes down they're proposing to reuse our existing parts proposal includes a motorer XPR 2500 uh the proposal did not include handhelds uh safety features are good lower initial investment but more expensive the long run the two-way the sound quality was excellent I put it up actually to our drivers to actually let me know what they thought uh one driver actually I was 53 miles away and the driver made a comment it sounded like I was standing right next to them uh proposed dispatch system uses base stations and handheld radios there's no communication reference if power goes out there proposing to use all new parts remember some of our wiring is 16 17 years old uh
104proposed to includes motorer XPR 5550e radios these radios feature a high power audio amplifier these radios deliver loud clear speech with backwind noise cancellation for better intelligent intelligibility their rugged durable design for everyday use another nice feature about them they have large ldd screens that they're easily to seen they're enhanced audio quality and if we ever want to move to GPS using the radios they're GPS compatible as well proposal will includes six uh handheld radios the safety features are excellent High initial investment but less expensive over the long run I can ask you really quick question just to kind of put us all on the same page here when you talk about the proposal including a different uh radio itself and then six handhelds um I know you were really intent on the 5550 I
105know we asked for that model across the board um but the the proposals were not uh I'll say apples to apples in that regard what is so important about the model that you're requesting of the 5550 just so that we understand okay well the the sound quality that it does contain that high power amplifier it has a larger LED screen uh for that's easy to read uh and that it has that noise cancellation feature so it does produce a better quality sound and and right now we do have a lot of drivers that are constantly getting on the radio and asking can you repeat that so this will hopefully prevent that from from occurring in the future that the drivers can hear clear Communications the very first time I appreciate that and then the handheld
106radios just because it's different in the proposals what what are they what is their purpose who would be having those and why is that important to you okay well the proposal from two-way with the six-and held radios they're actually a R7 model which actually have a large LED screen and they actually have roaming capacity so they can pick up from any tower that is in our Network so if we would give it to a say on a field trip we're going to strawberg if we would give it to a teacher they could actually take that radio communication with the bus driver because it does have that roaming capacity uh and we're going to also use the the handhelds for dispatching versus using the proposed system of the telephone type system all right we'll move on
107to the next slide this is where I really feel is beneficial for a a new Digital radio system a new security feature uh as an enhancement for drivers and student safety the new radios will include a panic alarm this will allow drivers to quickly trigger alert to supervisor radios of an incident on the bus so all they have to do is hit a button uh and it will send alert to administrator radios whoever you programing to uh you can program the radios then for the microphone to be turned on remotely for one minute after they hit the button uh which is very nice you can listen in on the bus you can know what's going on if it's a true emergency sometimes they don't they won't have the option to actually grabbing the mic and
108keying up okay uh the new technology will allow for one-on-one conversation preserving the privacy of the emergency as more importantly in the names of the students involved Uh current provider has a panic aler button on the radio while two way communication proposes installing a separate Panic alert button which would be mounted to the left of the driver so anyone knows you know you're sitting in your car your radio is here your right hand you know sometimes if there is a true emergency you know you might be able to reach your radio but a little button drift to your left uh would be quite easy to hit okay we'll move on so price wise we got co-star prices okay so the current provider 100 uh will go there you see the 100 uh XBR 2500 installation
109using existing wires and antenna as a price uh two-way proposed that we get a couple extra radios at the the moment they gave a price for the XP 55 50s there uh in the current provider two base stations two base stations for two-way Communications one of the major difference in that base station is one of them is actually for the garage uh with a large uh horn speaker uh from the two-way proposal uh because it gets rather noisy in the garage that way the garage can hear uh with the current provider the current A dispatch system you see a price there that would be replaced by the 6 R7 handheld radios on the two-way communication we give you a pro uh total price there uh but one thing this was done off of the October
11028th 2024 proposal from our current provider at that time the digital yearly access fee was 46,2 while uh two communication has proposed $25,990 per year for our digital access just in case the board would like to know we are currently paying $29,500 a year for digital access so actually is a significant reduction from what we're currently paying so if you would add some components back in say we want it to go with the new wiring the new antennas you know we want a system that will make us another 20 years you know uh it would be a $75 fee from our current provider to get the kit and I could not get a total labor estimate uh what it would cost for that basically uh they just said it was $95 an hour to install
111so if you just add two to three hours uh per vehicle you're you're talking an additional uh talking an additional right there you know about $30,000 to use new parts and then you also additional 25,000 upgrade to the XPR 550 radios which is the radios that I I'm recommending and if you would want to get a 10s additional radios uh and that's why that's so important if we grow the fleet we have the radios already two radios do go bad they need servicing so it's really nice to have extra radios all you have to do is go out to the vehicle unscrew it screw the new one in send the old one off to get repaired and you we have no downtime on Communications and then uh you know separating that safety feature from the
112radio over to your left hand I do not know a price on that and to add the six handheld Set uh from our current provider they gave us a quote of 5,580 however they quote it for the 3500 model which does not have the roaming capacity at a smaller digital screen and I am told uh from my research that actually motor roller is discontinuing that model uh so that's why I would recommend uh going with two-way for all those reasons so let's move to the next slide just want to let everyone know in case we ever do get in tariff warning these radios prices could be affect by the Tariff warning all right let's move reality yep all right so the my recommendation is two-way Communications excellent sound College uh quality excellent coverage e safety
113feature uh proposed highgrade equipment less cost over the Long Haul uh if you just take the savings that was quoted in the October 24 yearly fee within three years the system will actually pay for itself it's recommended by First Responders uh the eastn emergency Squad uh recommended two-way as well as Lafayette College uh so I went out and actually did did some research and actually got people's feedbacks as well as it's recommended by the colonial IU we can move to the next slide and here are from Britney Williams at the colonial ALU we have been using tway for approximately two years now so we far we had no issues with the system has been a major improvement from the system we had before we do not have any dead zones radios have clear transmission and
114their customer service is excellent I highly recommend them and again like I said we did get recommendations from eastn uh emergency services and Wells Lafayette College so that's the radio portion let's move into video surveillance for our school Vans we all know that we have bus Patrol for the school buses uh but we do not have any video systems for our vans because they do not have Reds so therefore bus Patrol will not do that so the lack of the system hinders the 3 s's currently there is no video surveillance our vans transport students with behavior issues Vans transport students that were removed from regular buses due to their behavior issues Vans transport special education students with IEPs and 40504 plans the lack of surveillance affords no protection for students or driver and also Advan
115lock GPS or driver monitoring so I'm recommending uh a system from surveillance 247 digital video systems uh the cameras record drivers and passenger they high definition picture and sound it's really easy software to use there is no download delays currently uh our principles sometimes get a little frustrated with bus Patrol it takes approximately 40 5 minutes to download one video and then a 45 minutes to upload a video so we're looking about an hour and a half for one video and if our department gets 8 to 10 requests a day that's basically you need a full-time employee just to pull videos for bus Patrol with this system they work on a um a high resolution uh data card where you can actually have extras so all you can do is just pop it out of
116the system put a new SD card in and you could deliver that SD card to the principal they can watch whatever they want when they're done with it return it and then you just pop it in for the next time so it's basically going back and forth there's no delays uh which is really nice again also this system has non-live GPS which means is when you're actually watching it you can actually have a little map come up and it will actually show you where your vehicle was how fast it was going and and you can actually add two additional parameters to it such as we if we want to know the driver hit the brake we could actually the the DVR would record that uh record the spreed the break and any of that other
117activity if you want to program it uh uh familiar with their product and uh I would recommend it so the system price what are we looking at a Zeus 4 channel 10 80 DPR DVR with all this uh included installation event marker again what this will have it's not so much of a panic button like I described but if there's an event that occurred the driver can hit a little button it will automatically Mark the film so it's much easier to find you can go right to that incident uh you're looking at $1,636 per vehicle or for our seven vans $1,452 all right let's move to the next slide so big question is funding uh how we're going to fund the radios and cameras uh Capital will come from funds that are still available from
118the Palmer Elementary Bond right let's we'll move to the next one so this one wheelchair accessable school bus I'm going to uh do this presentation along with Dr Schultz so I will start out I explain why a wheelchair uh is needed uh it increase greatly improves in-house service it can be utilized for all grade levels can be utilized on field trips inclusive opportunities for students District contracts service out to Colonial values or other providers so during the summer we do have a member of the marching band had to get to marching band practice uh we transported them over to middle school we actually had a isolate this student contract that out and they were transported signally also recently we had uh a student at the high school who was temporary in a wlure for 15
119days just for us to contract that out uh was $295 a day or 442 four $ 4,425 for just those 15 days that's approximately $53,000 a year uh if we would contract that service out uh cost would have been more if multiple schools were service that's just servicing one school and overtime in-house operation savings would pay for their vehicle so we explored two different style Vehicles one was um a mini bus and then the other one was a 3/4 bus so we'll talk a little bit about the differences in these two vehicles there's the mini bus and then the next slide is the larger bus the 3/4 bus so we did a compare compare and contrast chart if you wanted to switch to the next and we looked at different types of um engines the
120utility and then what's the same about these vehicles I'm not going to read all of these but the main point here is that the smaller minib buus is able to seat approximately 27 total seats without wheelchairs the larger bus is able to seat 54 total seats without wheelchairs the smaller bus is able to have a maximum of five Wheelchairs and then the larger one can have up to nine Wheelchairs and if you think about that that could be potentially an entire one whole classroom of students who have wheelchairs as their Mobility if you go to the next slide we highlighted the ones that we thought were of benefit for each of these the geographical locations the minab bus is a little bit easier to navigate through Geographic areas the the larger bus can be more
121difficult in urban areas due to the width of the streets just some other uses as you can see we did highlight in green the larger bus for field trips that can fit approximately two classrooms serve several students who are in wheelchairs and then also have their um typical peers with them as well so it does support that full inclusion opportunity for our students and the example that Ben gave for any extracurriculars where students are engaging in those activities they'll be able to go with their typical peers um we also Al and this was something that Ben told me was that they have better vision for when they're able to drive that vehicle as opposed to the smaller minibus I guess there's a bunch of blind spots in in that so of course it's cost prohibitive
122for the larger vehicle but if we go to the next slide we'll talk a little bit about what we decided so we did decide that the larger bus has greater benefits for our students we're able to get several classrooms of students in there transport larger groups as well as have right now we have funds available to be able to pay for this in a couple different places want me to keep going B you want to finish up does matter okay all right so we'll finish up I'll let then finish up this part here all right so big question how we're going to fund the wheelchair access bus at 146,147 was totaled last year right out on Bush kill at Art Road uh so we have that insurance money that just arrived uh $5,000 from Capital
123replacement funds in the transportation department I still have that available in the budget uh approximately $1,825 in funds from scrapping two buses uh some of the buses that we are no longer need it and then 11,300 from access funds uh to get to our total amount for the the purchase the the bus all right any questions or comments first of all uh thanks Ben uh that was great I think these recommendations are are needed um but I do have a couple questions g i I don't know if you can go back to that to the radios and the cost comparison one question I have is if it's co-star's pricing why weren't we getting prices or they providing prices on the same thing like you wanted that radio why didn't the current provider give a price
124if if they're co-stars they should be able to give you a price on this current radio on what you asked for I asked for the XP uh 5,550 and when they did the proposal that's what the proposal came in at so they don't have a contra co-stars pricing for the radio you asked for uh they they do that's what the extra the 25,000 would be they did give me the price to upgrade to that radio so they would add 25,000 yes but if it's co-star pricing so they were that much higher than 2way 141 to the that would have been 146 okay right am I looking at that right yes you're looking at that yes okay I just didn't know why I don't know why it's really not a comparison if we're not quoting Apples
125to Apples in my mind um but I I'm not saying to go I mean I have no problem with the recommendation um the um the wheelchair bus again great idea when you're talking about do we have driers certified to drive it do we have do we talk look into is it additional liability are we any more liable if something happens uh you know if the driver does something or or not trained properly um is it a different insurance rate being a wheelchair van like have we looked into all of the Legacy costs so to speak when when we're doing this have have not looked into the insurance or contact an insurance company to see if there would be an increase in the insurance for that okay I think we should have that information and again
126good suggestions but I think we have to as far as you know you talk about transparency all the costs associated with these purchases I think need to be uh talked about and and proper comparisons and the last question that I have and the big one is I'm really concerned did did you talk to our bonding attorney or anybody talk to the bonding attorney I don't think we can use Capital funds Bond money for non project who's they Kevin Reed from King spry or you have that in writing I think we need our attorney Ken is a I mean no offense but Ken is a just a finance consultant and depending on when the original how the original resolution was worded and I think you're talking about that 10 million extra Bond we are so that
127would have been a different wording and if it's worded properly then you can use that um yeah Mike that that that's what we'd have to look at the original resolution will is in bond is typically specific to a project there might be some language that that refers to other capital projects with leftover but then there's usually a um a lifetime span that those other capital projects have to satisfy in order to count for that I'm not even sure frankly if if Communications and video would would qualify say Capital project we can certainly look into I don't know who did the the actual Bond work but if it's some we can certainly look at the resolution through Ken Phillips the inquiry I'll correct myself through Mike in so was Kevin Reed from spris King spry involved
128in it so what was it a bond or was it a note Bond I'll have to I'll have to get a little more okay yeah I'll have to get a little more information on that okay all right and when you talk about the access again you got to pick your priorities um we know we already talked last meeting about $500,000 short for the the iPad lease so what was the access funds designated for before you got to this stage and we need to think about what we're not going to do that we said we were going to do um but I mean I think they're all uh the radio system you know we need it uh the availability for the wheelchair van for the students uh those those outside Transportation companies are killers and um
129you know just think about the priorities and where what you're not going to do that you said you were going to do with that excess money and so on but I'm really concerned about um that Bond money making sure that we're okay off follow up on that okay so Mike has most of my questions answered um but I for the maintenance plan for the um radios what all is included in that so I know that was more of an optional thing um so like is that you know like we're talking about if something happens to it you know you drop your phone your iPhone you got the insurance plan you pay a deductible and get a new one is that so I guess I'm sort of curious to know what what that is um also
130understanding first year for that plan would be 28530 and then I just want to make sure that the ongoing could either be the 25,000 or 36,000 depending on whether we do the maintenance and with that could we do a if we're doing that can we do a multi multi-year contract um to maybe get reduced pricing or at least have a consistent pricing for budgeting purposes I can check into to about about a multi if we wanted to go with that option I could look into getting a multi-year contract to reduce that price I do not know that answer but that it's something I can find out for you yeah i' just be curious to see what kind of pricing we could get for that if we decide that and whether we are doing the optional
131maintenance program or not and then I guess my other question sort of leads off with Mike is um for the Vans do they need the CDL and actually I guess that would be part of my question is who is loading the students is that you know the concern of of that portion of it yeah well while the wheelchair uh bus no matter what the micr bus or the 3/4 bus you would need a CDL for uh and then so I mean that would be part of their training uh we do train a little bit about special needs it's required by the state uh to get your CDL uh then it would be additional training on tie down points exactly where you put the Q strap tie downs on a wheelchair how to turn it down
132uh emergency evacuation you know what do you do so all that is extra training for the driver that would be assigned to that bus yes yeah I think there's a certification besides just the CDL extra training that needs to be involved with that so you can look into that does anyone else have any questions no thank you sorry we have all these questions What's the timing like when were you looking to have this approval it's up to you Ben so yeah Mike so great question so you know when we looked at this we've been talking about this probably for about four months now you know internally um the reason why we decided to bring it to this meeting was because ideally if we if it if it would be recommended and approved at the February
133meeting um that would allow the time for us to integrate that over the summer to the lead time delivery time installation time we could start the year with that if we back it up a month which we may have to do um it will probably have a minimal impact but it's nothing longterm that we're extremely concerned about but it may end up not we won't start the year in full with full we only have a week right so what yeah so what we'll do is we'll get all those answers to those questions that all of you asked um we'll share it out um if for some reason everything is answered very you know easily and it's all good to go we'll I'll update you um if not then we'll we'll just put it back on
134the March agenda uh for the discussion then approval but we'll get all those answers for you and then provide that to the board all right thank you yeah Ben anything extra for that yeah okay okay on that piece okay so Ben thank you very much I know you're going to maybe jump in here as well um this the next slide G if you can go there uh we wanted to take an opportunity to provide the board with an update on bus Patrol so you know as I think about two years ago we entered into a contract with bus Patrol um there's been some slowdowns there um with some legalities and you know there's been you know kind of touch and go but we are in Full full go mode right now um I've asked John
135rali to be here and Ben to provide some updates uh to some numbers to some areas of concern um and just an overall update for the board directors in our community so John if you wouldn't mind kind of kicking it off and then we'll take some questions at the end certainly so update on bus Patrol from September 1st to of 2024 through January 31st of this year um next slide please so during that time there has been 1,959 violations that have been sent to either the Houston Police Forks Police Palmer Police police or our school district police by bus Patrol of those citation or of those violations sent 1,565 have been approved for citation by those departments 394 have been disapproved for various reasons reasons for disapproval you've had 340 where the vehicle was deemed
136unable to stop prior to the activation of the lights in the stop arm due to the distance it was from the bus at the time 36 violations the vehicle did not pass the bus in other words the driver was able to stop the vehicle uh prior to passing the bus eight violations it was deemed that the driver's view was obstructed in some fashion whether it be by uh roadway obstacles you know tree stop sign whatever the case may have been four violations were disapproved for improper stop arm activations two were um disapproved because the bus was still moving when the red lights in the stop arm were activated and three violations were disapproved for other reasons okay again there's just a caption or recap of the number of violations during that time period the number
137that were approved for citations sent to the driver or should I'm correct that to the owner of the vehicle so you're looking at about an 80% approval rate 20% disapproval rate based on those figures time of day we found that about 29% of our violations are occurring in the a during the am run 71% are occurring during our PM run day of the week cross the board Monday through Friday it's pretty much kind it's even uh no real variations to note and some of our top locations or our top 10 locations for violations if you to take a look at those numbers and you guys would do the math that amounts to about 50% of our um violations or citations that were sent in those 10 stops the loc the top three locations there on
138Route 248 pretty much go from the 25th Street Mall out to Park Avenue that's that location they're on 248 and it makes it difficult because it is a unique situation 248 in that location is a four-lane roadway it's not a divided four-lane roadway so the oncoming vehicles in both lanes are required to stop correct and I'm sorry no legally they're not supposed to block the intersection but by law the vehicle is also not supposed to cross the intersection as well let me CH in a little bit about that 248 I use this data then on designing routes all of our stops on 248 are house stops uh we're stopping actually at the students house and they're all doors side uh so even all going all the way out nazarus road we do not have any
139students in our district crossing nazarus road at all even further out one the road's a two-way Road because I look at this data and for the safety of our our students that's what how I can use this data and say okay we we really this road really everything should be door side so we do have SE several buses that do actually drive around the block to make sure that all of our students are picked up on door side on those streets Set uh are high citation uh violations occur and that's done for the safety of the students and so I know we're only seeing the top 10 here although I'm not sure how quickly they drop off I mean to me having a more than a handful of citations that the same stop would indicate
140you know problems so I I'm sure it's a ton of work for you but to take a look at those anything that has you know more than your one or two off citations I feel like you know would be a good um a good spot to reconsider you know where the actual stop is I don't know if all of these you know I'm trying to the 100 block of North 9th Street what is going on there I mean why would that I mean that's just a traditional four-way stop right like why would there be so many taking a look at that that area of North 9th Street a lot of those violations occurred on Wood Avenue which at that location is a downhill slope going down towards the Seventh Street intersection so again you know
141when you look at a lot of these as Ben indicated yes the 248 stops four-lane Highway the bus is stopping in the far right lane you know door side uh to the students residents uh a lot of these are just plain driver ignorance that are causing these violations I initially my office was receiving a good amount of if you want to say the complaints about receiving a citation in the mail for these violations and often times the complaint was I didn't know I had to stop maybe you better go take your driver's test again yeah I was just saying I venture to say that many of those citations on 248 people don't realize on that four lane road I think that attributes quite a bit to it that on a four-lane road they're thinking well
142if the bus is in the far right lane I don't have to stop and again um you know talking with Palmer Township about a number of these citations almost you know I would say good 95% of them are with the vehicles in that oncoming Lane and even that far Lane that they don't realize yeah you know what it's not a divided highway here I need to stop well I mean Susan that's a great point unfortunately yeah it's hitting them in the in the wallet but you know what it's also gone through the community tremendously that yeah our buses have the cameras on the citations are being sent and I think people are far more aware than they were about a year and a half ago yeah I mean I think that's that's a huge benefit
143of the bus Patrol program is having this data and now I mean I hope there's no one from the media here today but I hope they all grab that slide and I hope it gets on every neighborhood Facebook page also so that people that's part of it is educating the public for the safety of our children and yeah if you didn't know you needed to stop on 248 hopefully you'll see this and realize that you do need to stop next presentation can put pictures on [Laughter] the so so no mic but in in regard to the next presentation in all seriousness you know this was our first you know attempt at the bus Patrol uh presentation and giving the board an update so I guess you know from the board of directors is there any
144feedback that you can give us and something you would maybe prefer seeing next time or additional information or is there any other information that you would have liked to see this evening that we could provide I am interested not that it was missing tonight but I am interested at the rate of collection on those on those citations uh well we don't take part in that but uh just to give everybody a a real quick brief overview what the state did approximately 3 years ago was they took a look at the statute that governs the violation of the bus's red light or or stop arm and they took it out of the if you want to say the the criminal forum and put it into the Civil Forum so in other words when I said that
145we were sending the citations to the vehicle driver that's not the case the C cameras on the bus are reading the license plate and the citation is sent to the vehicle owner for permitting in the driver of the vehicle to create this violation so in other words basically what it comes down to is rather than in the criminal Forum where it is beyond a reasonable doubt they've move it moved it into the Civil Forum where it's a preponderance of the evidence 51% so if I get the citation in the mail and it says you know vehicle owned by John R passed the bus and shows the picture of my vehicle passing the bus say well I wasn't driving it that day that's not a defense the next question would be asked well gee Mr R
146who was driving your vehicle that day who did you permit use it or lend it to so I can either purger myself or pay the fine and that's pretty much how the collection rate goes citation not paid it's sent to a collection agency so it kind of got you coming and going lack of a better way of putting it I think less um necessarily information that I didn't see so much as um what I would like to see the district now do with the data obviously you know we can make changes to our bus rots but also if you look at some of these like the 100 block of North 9th Street to then reach out to the eastn police department and say hey we're having a problem with this specific intersection can you do
147some targeted patrols during the whatever it's the am or PM run you know so that we can e even just to set up with the flashing lights to make people aware you know whatever the individual police departments feel you know is the best way to handle it um again just to try to reduce the number um in those problem areas well and that that's certainly something we can look at I mean the data that I was provided when I made the request for this presentation from bus Patrol um each one of the agencies eastn Palmer and forks and ourselves are provided with this data on an annual basis at you know the end of the the school year for you know you know data that was collected citations issued and everything through the course of
148that particular year so again they can make the adjustments as well um we can certainly make sure you know we're in communication with them to take a look at that thank you thank you yeah I was just thinking you reminded me of something with that I see in some areas uh there's a place in hand over Township near Enzos uh that has a uh kind of a mockery kind of sign it says um you know stopping to stop sign free coasting through $133 plus points or whatever like that I was wondering if maybe the townships or anyone would consider that kind of attention getting signed maybe in some of these high risk high volume areas just I'm thinking aloud you know people notice those signs and I think the one in jackville Ro I'm think
149I think it might actually blink um really drawing attention to yourself so when you uh see that and because it's I know that intersection uh there Jacksonville Road I can see where that gets run a lot but just something to think about out there you know it might be maybe a deterrent as well because they're not going to send you know Manpower people power out there constantly just to watch people for doing that unless there is a super you know unless a safety issue really really arises where people are getting hurt which we haven't seen yet luckily but um just thinking you know just thinking aloud out there just as an idea okay I that's something too especially along the that route or that Corridor and on Route 248 that might be beneficial for some
150signage there at least making the the motorists aware that this is not a divided highway um I can talk with Chief Smith about that and see what maybe we can come up with thank you for so Ben I I think you know when we interviewed one of the things you did in your previous roles and in previous places was very good at communicating your your information out so I would be happy to hear any suggestions you might have on how we Comm can communicate that out to our school community and our other communities around so if you can have any ideas I'd be glad to hear them yeah well I'm sure we can I could develop a school messenger message quite easily uh that will just you know just go over you know one you
151have to stop uh pend do does have some really good diagrams available uh where they say they even have a poster available that you can get uh so I can contact pend do get those diagrams and PDF format and can easily put a together a school messenger uh email that could go out to all the parents and just as a friendly safety reminder this is one you must stop at these type of intersections uh and what's constitute a divided highway and what doesn't constitute a divided highway any other comments or questions for Katie Ben or John no good thank you to the three of you by the way well done and and appreciate the time you put into that uh so Andrew I'm going to just pivot a little bit I mean you're you're still
152going to be up in a minute but I know we have the the maintenance agreement with power Township on there um before I'm going to flip that to after the the capital Improvement Plan update um just as a FYI because I know we've been going back and forth with that um as of recently as as of today um but I wanted to share with the board that you know in 2022 we presented we were back in the library at this time if I remember correctly we presented the capital Improvement plan to the board and As A Five-Year Plan um and what you know how we prioritize those those projects you know what we're looking to to do um so now that we are you know two years three years down the road and we're about
153in the halfway point um we have completed a lot of projects over the past you know three four five years but we also have a couple projects that are uh you know really you know coming up pretty quickly uh that we wanted to talk through and kind of share with you where we are um the elevator at the high school was the most recent you know we recently brought that last month uh so that's you know on our capent you know plan um the Middle School roof you've heard me talk about Ken talk about probably three four or five times um that we are looking to bring to the board for recommendation um over the next within the next month or two um so we felt as a team that it would be really important
154for us to just provide a general update of where we are um the history where we are now where we want to go um and then be able to answer any questions that are associated with that so um we certainly have some you know comments uh you know after this presentation But Ken I'll kick it off to you first because I know you want to provide some historical context before Andrew speaks um and then we can kind of Bounce some answers back and forth yeah sure thank you Dr zatic so uh like you mentioned this a really exciting time uh of year for uh the facilities Department it's the time of year when we're really looking at capital projects and planning for the work over the summer um so uh tonight uh Andrew from C
155ha and myself will be reviewing and highlighting uh the capital Improvement plan um that's where those projects start um and where uh they reside until they they come to the point where we're in design and and going out to bid um so really two points that we'd like to highlight tonight and focus on um we'd like to share our current five-year Capital uh project plan um so that's based on the comprehensive plan uh that was completed in 2022 uh it really it summarizes on a one page uh the district's needs priorities and uh Andor possible grant opportunities um and it's used so that we can uh we can plan from the facility side so we know what projects are coming up uh from our end and it's also used in the business office so they
156can properly plan uh the finance side so that the uh the monies are available to support the projects and that we're realistic on both ends too with the projects we try and look at um planning so that uh the financing is is even as it as it could be throughout each year and then also to make sure that the scope of all the projects are uh are doable to occur over a summer um and then the second part of that is um um you know this time of year like I said we're getting ready to present some of these projects that we're looking at this coming summer now this year uh is a little bit odd because we presented half of a project uh last month that the board approved um for for um refurbishment
157of the high school elevator and that was done just because of lead times on that equipment uh that the contractor would need so that it could occur over the summer but the second half of that project and like uh Dr zadic said the Middle School roof project is going to be coming up uh next month and then in April so uh later on in the presentation um Andrew will highlight uh some of this information G if you go to the next slide so I did mention and and so did Dr zic that the original plan was uh came about in 2022 and you can see the steps that are outlined there number one through six so at that time we did a full scale review we started from scratch uh the previous plan uh that
158we were working off of ended with the pommer project so that incorporated all of the uh upgrades um additions Renovations new buildings to a majority of our elementary school so very successful plan and uh as Palmer was under construction we said hey we need to look at our districtwide uh buildings and update the plan so we can move forward uh so you can see we went down through those steps and quite frankly we continue to go through those steps each year not to the extent that we did back in 2022 but uh we constantly talk about our Capital Improvement plan at our facility meetings uh each month um and uh we look back and we adjust as needed uh we adjust priorities we adjust uh from the financial side uh and then we plan each
159year so it really is a living document that we um that we look at and we uh always are adjusting and uh and reviewing so the next slide here is uh a list of some of the capital projects that we completed over the past five years and this is uh projects that were completed under the previous uh Capital plan and then also the new capital plan you can see the the projects here vary in scope um you can see new buildings there Palmer and chest and the stadium uh renovation and then on the other side you can see projects of a smaller scope like the shaune boiler so all these projects that you see here resided and originated from uh the capital planning process so it is a key document in the facility Department uh
160it really is our North Star it's our guide uh and everything comes from that um one item that we're not necessarily talking about tonight but in the past we've talked about on many occasions and spent a lot of hours here with the board is the high school project so the high school project started off in 2022 in that updated Capital Improvement plan like all the other projects there you see for the major major projects and um you'll see later on in one of the slides uh all of our higher priority items you're you're going to see many of the items listed off of or from the high school and a lot of higher numbers so looking at that back in 2022 that's when we come to realize hey you know we think we met the
161threshold to actually look at either uh Renovations additions you know and then we decided on a new building would be the the right course of action uh for uh the high school and you know on the finance end as well we spent a lot of time talking about that uh so it's really exciting moving along with that Capital project so that's a key Capital project that resided uh and originated from the uh Capital Improvement plan so uh also listed here you can see current capital projects and I'll turn it over to uh to Andrew and uh he'll give you some more detail on the whole process great uh thank you guys um glad to be back in in front of you excuse me um so I I just kind of wanted to go through and
162and give you guys a refresher on on the capital plan how we use it as a tool to identify uh needs throughout all of the building in the district how we how we can try to bring uh objectivity to what can be sometimes very subjective based on people's feelings or or how they see it uh so what we do is we have a an evaluation Matrix so across the top are different parameters right safety curricular value um the physical condition of the the item in question uh a domino effect like how does changing out uh the lighting right upgrading to LED lights how could that spark uh other things to be upgraded as well well if we're changing the lights we'll probably be changing the ceiling uh if we're changing the ceiling maybe we want
163to look at the HVAC condition at that point or fire alarm so the domino effect how's that going to affect other uh impacts or uh other aspects of the building uh down to uh sustainability right so those are those are kind of the parameters that we look at um we give them a rating uh basically a five through a one or a zero and you can kind of see what those different uh scores would mean uh you know how many people do they affect would it close school if something shut down like hey you only have one boiler in the building um and if that boiler went out you know that would close school in the winter um so we have a we have a table that kind of outlines how all those work and
164then at the bottom um going left to right we have importance factors you know there are some things on here that are are you know obviously far more important than others so we try to we try to grade that and give that an importance Factor you know that the school districts out here to uh you know provide an education to students in safe building so safety curricular value and educational impact would all have an importance rating of a five whereas um you know still important energy and and sustainability while that's something we strive for it it's not on the same level uh as as something like safety um so that's that's how when we go through and we identify an item uh okay we need to upgrade the elevator we will take this this rubric
165here and give it a score for each of these different parameters and it will spit out a overall priority a weighted priority um on the next slide uh here is just a snapshot uh of what you know the the most the highest priority items you can see kind of the the grading scale there um and we give an an estimated uh project cost this is back from the last time we updated uh towards the end of 2024 um and like Ken said a lot of these items you can see where they are they're at the high school and that's what had sparked the conversation about you know a major project there um so we can sort this in many different ways we can sort it by category we could look at all your fire alarm
166projects we could look at all your Paving projects together uh we could sort it by building or we could sort it by priority uh so this should look very familiar to you guys um and this is how we go through at at all our meetings and and really hone in on what the you know what projects are we looking at for next year or the year after or or developing that fiveyear plan um so on the next slide uh was the 5year plan that we looked at in 2024 uh during our last um update there uh so you can see the two projects that we had projected for 2025 are the the two projects that we are are working on uh right now going out to bid uh and Ines design um and so again
167what we try to do here is is give as even of a dollar value uh as we can for each year grouping similar projects together together uh to try and and you know uh create savings uh maybe by doing a districtwide Paving project and we can we can capitalize on economy of scale um but this like Ken said is a living document we get together monthly and look at this and and things may tweak projects may come on the list uh due to an emergency uh projects may come on the list due to uh funding availabilities and grants you know we want to capitalize on the ability uh to to you know smartly and and effectively use uh grant money that comes up uh so again you know just a a living document and it's
168it's a way for us to track through uh the project and something that we can look at you know tweaking based on the the administration recommendations ours and the boards um so if you can go to the next slide you know we just want to talk about what what the next steps are and it's it's you know everything that Ken and I have just talked about we continually review and update uh the most urgent needs to the district uh again we try to go after any grants that we can to help help fund these projects uh we monitor The Five-Year Plan uh with with your direction um and we prepare documents and we go out to bid and and then we execute um so you know just a a a synopsis of of how that
169plan is is put together um and it's you know something that you know right now we're working on the the cost updating for uh 2025 costs and just as a a uh something I forgot to mention on that Five-Year Plan is the costs that are listed for each subsequent year they do include uh an inflation you know an assumed inflation percentage uh so that number may look a little different than if you were to look at the the total recommendation list because that's like a 24 or 25 year cost um and then we'll just kind of increase from there so that we're budgeting appropriately and then uh for anybody familiar with with chest this is a great picture really of uh of that finished product when when we had first opened uh we shape our
170buildings therefore they shape us so I I thank you guys for your time and and if there's any questions I'm sure I forgot to turn it over to duck on a roll stay up there it's all good um so I'm sure there'll be some questions but I I didn't want to inter intervene when you were on the roll so um Gino if you can go back maybe two or three slides just go to the very first slide of go back two more um so you can you can stay on on the rubric for a second Gino we felt as a team was really important to add this and we went we had discussions about this and the reason why we felt so important to reground and refresh for everybody on the process itself is because
171there can't be there can only be one priority number one right this rubric allows us when we have discussions internally to make the best decision and remove the subjectivity as Andrew said and the emotions behind it um because it's very easy to just say oh my gosh we need this we need this but that does not provide us a systematic way of of addressing the needs um so we felt very passionate about the rubric itself and why we need to have it in this presentation um another comment G if you can go to the next slide this was a snapshot of our original plan right so there our original plan had probably four pages to this this was really just one of the one of the areas that we took a snapshot of and I
172say that um because if if you do take a look at this and I'm going to just just say it you know to be transparent you can see there are three items that mentioned the public library up on that slide right there okay if you go to the next slide Gino you'll see that within our current fiveyear you will not see that in that 5ye as projects are are planned out there's a couple things I do want to mention for this just to be transparent one is you heard Andrew and Ken both say that this is not a static document it's Dynamic so it is fluid we make changes to it um you know perfect example is you know with the Esser funds we had the opportunity to address the indoor air quality devices at
173the high school middle school that was not a priority eight or nine that was probably a priority you know five or six but because the grant opport allowed us to address those types of needs that is a project we addressed although it didn't rise to the top priority itself so there's always some fluidity there that allows us you know the the decisions to to address them as we see fit um with different opportunities such as grants and you did mention that Andrew um what I will say about the public library is the following um we do the way that we prioritize our our projects um you know first and foremost we look at our list we see where our top priorities are we always and we will always address the buildings with students in first
174because that's why we're here we also then want to address the buildings that serve our students such as Transportation Etc that does not mean that we do not want to address anything else we also as an administrative team board School District recognize that we have a responsibility to the taxpayers in the community to also make the you know address the issues at our at our buildings um the public library being one of those so the most recent conversation which was today um we've gone back and forth as as a team cha alloy our Administration internally um and operations team quite frankly um and we are looking at ways to to make some of those adjustments and address those needs by the library and you know in the the bigger picture of our Capital Improvement plan
175over the next 5 years so we do believe that there are some opportunities within there to add some some Library pieces into the plan um but this was the last document that we had internally and we just wanted to be transparent about that but that doesn't mean that we won't be looking at ways to address other needs within there so just want to make sure we were honest about that and transparent because we recognize that we we need to address a lot um the other piece uh because I think Michael probably asked me this um is hey how are we going to pay for all this um so I just you know upfront and honest uh I believe that the most recent number and we clarify this for the next meeting Jack if we don't
176mind but the the most recent number in the cap Reserve was about 2.5 million now I could be off could be plus or minus 500,000 there I don't know um but that was the the the last number that was was given to us so we will certainly need to borrow for these projects and what we've tried to do is if you see the numbers we've tried to balance the projects and the the cost so that it's relatively consistent you know over the next five years so that we weren't saying hey we need $15 million worth of projects next year but three you know five years down the road so we tried to balance it within the priority list as well um so there's a lot of movement there we do have a we do have
177a meeting uh in the very near future uh with our financial you know people with Raymond James we will be discussing this uh need as well as the high school um in regard to planning and how to to pay for these projects uh but wanted to get head that and be open and honest with everybody at you know here tonight um that those are all upcoming steps so think that captures everything I wanted to say Andrew Ken if I missed anything please feel free to jump in but wanted to make sure we're all on the same page there so I guess now any questions comments anything that we can answer for you [Laughter] like there has to be a question all right I appreciate that okay all right um again I think having the updated
178list because as I was looking at the old one so going through and having that sent to us would be greatly appreciated um trace and I were discussing different things as far as you know the ad hoc so there'll be an email out as far as that's concerned so that we can start looking at the groups and seeing as far as um you know our buildings and grounds and being able to discuss some of the items with the CIP and the high school and also the budgeting part of it so um look for that email but um thank you for the presentation and um if nobody else has any questions okay all right with that and there's other item on the agenda I apologize yes you do Palmer yeah we do have the maintenance agreement
179with Palmer Township Andrew um I know we've been going back and forth and there's been a discussion whether we actually need it or not um you want to kind of share the background there historically yeah um so this is this is something that is typical on on a new construction project to have a maintenance agreement for a set amount of time roughly a year and a half after the project ends that you know the develop is responsible for uh things that may go wrong especially this is a lot of right away improvements that that would be dedicated back over to the municipality um I I've been working with uh King spry's office uh to go over with Palmer Township uh some previous documentation that was um you know put forth when we were working on
180the developers agreement uh to ensure that the the need for the actual um maintenance agreement a and the security that would need to be posted for that work um you know the the one thing that I I'd say right now is that uh when we open the building in 2023 in in September you know about 90 to 95% of our site work was complete um and that's basically been an 18-month period as of now uh what we were waiting on was is getting the spray irrigation system up and running uh back there so you know at a minimum we are looking to try to uh work through what may have already been part of a you know an 18-month timeline that the school district has maintained you know and would be done with kind of
181that responsibility uh there there's other things too that you know there really isn't much out there that's being dedicated back to the township it's all School District Improvement you know one of those uh exceptions would be that walking path in the back that connects the neighborhood over to the um uh the shrin community center area uh so again just working with King spry's office and we should have an update uh by next month appreciate it Andrew thank you very much so m t I guess at the end of the day we don't have necessarily have anything as of right now that will be going to the board agenda um we may have the meeting agreement that all depends uh but the other it is we will make sure we get answers uh to the board
182of directors as an update uh and then that most likely will be on the March agenda uh if I have to take a guess uh Jos if you're having a maintenance agreement on the agenda we gonna is there a draft copy we can have now yeah I can get that toam mic thank you okay with that public to be heard on buildings and grounds agenda items could come to the podium sign your name and you'll be allotted the five minutes to speak okay good evening um so my name is name is Eric Adams and I'm here to represent um if you can try to remember back a few a few minutes ago I'm here to rep represent the current provider of the bus radio communication system so again my name our name of our company
183is Industrial Communications um so we have been providing the service for many years um Mr burnhard made an excellent point of addressing what's wrong with the system today we we understand it better than anyone else and we are keeping it patched together as best as we can to keep the wheels on the bus so to speak um so I applaud uh his efforts to finally upgrade the system I do want to make a couple key points though um the uh the main point I want to make to the board is that there was no spec um no one ever came to us or TWA and said here's what we would like um you know please bid it instead it was just hey can you get us can you give us a proposal so we we
184put a lot of effort into providing a proposal to Mr burnhard and um there was some dialogue back and forth and uh and that was it so tonight I hear things like um well we wanted a 5550 radio and we we proposed a 2500 because a 25500 is much less expensive and still meets all of your needs do you really want a 5550 we'd be happy to to quote a 5550 um another comment was made well twoway is going to put all new parts in the bus and Industrial is going to just sort of hobble things together that's not accurate either we're going to inspect all the existing cables and antennas and we're only going to replace things that were found to be defective uh we approached betham School District betham school the betham area
185school district said well we don't want this hourly rate just give us a lump sum fine so we went from 375 for an installation we raised it to 400 for betham school district so they were happy with that if we did the same thing in your case it would add $2,500 to to the to the job um the most important thing is uh my quote was submitted back in October at that time we were designing a brand new system for for coverage um our company's basically custom designing a system for the eastn area school district so at the time we had to throw a number on it the number was 3850 and mobile um as of Sunday I shared a revised quote with Mr burnhard on Sunday the price is now $24 a mobile and
186that's a maximum number so now we're very comparable now for the annual rental amount we're very comparable to two-way if we are able to proceed with this system with the betham area school district who we are in negotiation with right now that $24 will come down to 18 or lower because it'll be a combined system and we're very close to getting that done with betham the betham school district so so again now we're talking $1,000 difference in the price um the uh I just want to point out I will not don't want to say anything about two-way it's a it's a good company they're reputable but I want the board to know that Industrial Communications is 100% owned by graduates of the East are school district and residents we've been here a long time we're
187designing the system because we're we're vested in the in the in the community um we also have a system in at the bethle school district uh 2A is in Bethlehem but the bethle area school district chose our company not just for their bus system but for all their schools every Elementary School in the school district um we're honored to serve and provide their radios for them uh of course we also provide your radios for Mr rali um so we do your other buildings as well Communications in the other buildings um and the police um so again that's that's the main thing I wanted to say um I just hope that you'll reconsider um the idea of deciding really what you want we're happy to do anything you want put it out the bid and uh
188give us a fair shot at saving uh the school district some money thank you thank you uh is there anyone else in the public no okay all right then next we have educational technology and student supports y so this evening we think we only have two i220 contracts that we want to bring we will have a few next month ktie will have about five next month so far but as of tonight we have the two that we're ready to discuss sure so the first one is for what we called last time an associate teacher which is a on toone par professional for a student located in an IU program this is a separate contract than last time it's just an addition it's um similar language and then the second one is for our Ida Part
189B use of funds agreement this is this comes up every year and the IU houses are idea funds from there we then submit documents indicating what we're going to use our idea funds for and then it gets passed through to the district level this is just an agreement with the IU that they're going to continue to house that and then we request reimbursement from them any questions about either of those hey Dr Schulz I had a question last time about the unemployment uh wording everything yes um I'd like to get a u little history of how any unemployment costs they build back to us over I mean there somewhere we can past history that they build back curious how many times with these AIDS that they could not replace if they're in such need elsewhere
190I mean they should be able to replace them in other districts but I just be curious okay to see what those costs were over the years I I don't know if Josh wanted to yeah no problem no I can certainly answer that we can certainly do the Deep dive for that I will tell you when I spoke to Dr Wolff he did look back there and let me know that there has been zero that they've built back to us probably since at least 2014 we looked at 1415 so there was zero and he didn't foresee that occurring again but to your point we can certainly look at the actual well numbers but to him he he double checked and said there's been zero I mean I'm sure they can find employment for them with all
191the needs throughout the county so correct I just was curious y if we had any charges thank you that's okay okay next we have public to be heard on educational technology and student support items anyone in the public to speak okay seeing none we'll have those moving forward then okay number n other business I have a question okay how are we doing with the Greenwood Avenue project the project or the baseball field or the concession stands or everything above everything above all right so the JB baseball field I sent an update to you probably a month or two ago the under the the drainage the under drainage was done in November all right so that's been done they have to have the grass grow that's what they're waiting for that project is done um the
192concession stand that is actually I believe in the code review piece with Palmer Township right now um we've looked at the the drawings we've been working with them so we did get an update from them today on that that's where it is so they expect that to be completed in the spring uh the con yeah concession stand the the restroom um and then the other uh project the actual Greenwood heart you know heartley they're expecting that to be started and hopefully completed by summer that was the last update that we got uh if anything changes I'll star to let you know okay thank you sure I just wanted to ask the administration um I know we don't respond to public U but if you could address Mr Adams comments and notes that he presented to
193us you know to the board in a separate uh email or cover letter or discussion I'd appreciate uh just so I mean have been a long time vendor they're still a vendor in the district and I think there or the board is at least do um the story on exactly how this transpired and what Ben is recommending moving forward got thank you one thing Dr zic you had mentioned uh recently to the board um some information that the the IMPACT program in Northampton County was um in Jeopardy and I was wondering if you had an update on that on the status of that yep I appreciate that Mr ago so uh for those of you that aren't familiar with the impact project that was a a program versary program brought over uh from Lehigh County
194about two years ago we were actually the pilot here in Northampton County um that allows our first time offenders through disciplinary process uh to essentially complete a program of meeting goals expectations um and then that that offense gets expunged from the record I may not be using the right term expunged but is no longer on their record uh so it's really something that we find valuable um that's the reason why we piloted it um we received information about maybe two to three weeks ago that that was in Jeopardy of being disbanded in Northampton County um and we are in full support of it so you know I will go on record and say that we are in full support of that uh for many reasons but I did ask Chief to just come back tonight
195uh you were probably in the parking lot um but we did talk about this you and I multiple times in regard to where we are as a district our beliefs our values um but there was a meeting that was scheduled for was either last Friday or upcoming Friday um can you provide an update just to this whole group for us I do want to make one point of clarification before uh John speaks and that is our administrative team was in full support of continuing the IMPACT Program not disbanding it um and then we do have some questions that we've worked with John in terms of um how students are um uh identified into into those programs and you don't have to get into all that tonight but uh just wanted to make sure that Josh's
196point was clear that we're in support of the program not disbanding the program yes absolutely and and when I was made aware uh about three weeks ago by the director of the impact project that Northampton County District Attorney Steven barata at the time had elected to uh put the project on hold uh a subsequent meeting between the impact project and Mr Bar's office I think resolved some of the misconceptions or misunderstandings uh that weren't passed on to Mr Bar's office from the prior District Attorney's office so as of right now the impact project is accepting referrals again from us now the way that works is Dr zic indicated uh it's a diversionary program for first offenders so any one of our students committing what would be a criminal offense within our jurisdiction basically the the
197realm of the school day um once it's determined that a juvenile referral would be appropriate we submit that information to the district attorney's office one of the assistant District Attorneys would make a ruling as far as whether this particular student is is a viable candidate for the impact project if they are deemed viable the referral then is directed to the impact project and as Dr zic indicated uh there's a number of uh requirements number of uh different goals that that student has to meet in order for them to quote unquote pass the project and have that um offense forgiven uh like I said it it never really really goes to a formal referral so it's never appears on their record again it's kind of a one-time you know opportunity for some of these students uh
198we've been pretty much involved with it since September of 2023 um unfortunately I don't have any hard statistics for you tonight but just at um observation over the last year and a half uh I think students in our district that have benefited from this program have done very very well we do not see a lot of recidivism or the recidivism that we have historically seen uh to give an idea the project was brought over from Lehigh County uh it's been in effect almost 12 years up there with a great deal of success uh Carbon County and Monroe County are also looking at uh beginning the project as well do of success that that's shown in Lehigh County yeah so John just the other piece that I'll just add to everybody is that we did send
199a letter to uh br's office uh in support of that program to to continue yes so that was sent on behalf of of the administration great uh just um if the status were to change again or becomes in question you know please just let us know thank you okay is there any other business okay is there any public to be heard on non oh I want sorry I wanted to make a comment um so we were talking about the concession stand in the bathrooms and everything else up by the JB baseball field and I'm just wondering is it in our best interest to hold off doing that until we discuss further the new high school and different things that would be going in there yeah so it's a great question Joey we've actually had this
200same conversation multiple times um you know at the time when I'll say most recently being that the high school is six years out seven years out um we decided that we felt it was it was the right thing to still continue with that with that project um because of that reason so that's where we landed um if there's other you know conversations or other thoughts certainly open to those but that's where our internal team decided just wanted to put it out there okay well especially because we're not paying for it it's part of the deal to open the road so okay yeah I just I I realize that what I'm saying though is if we're going to do that and we're going to design it I'd hate to waste the money and have something you
201know if it's putting the money in an escrow account or doing something or putting it somewhere that when we're going back and we're building it that the money is there to fund well the drainage system was part of it that's already taken care of and then it's a bathroom not a not a concession stand so okay I right am I right yeah yeah I just you know location of it I don't I just just wanted to put it out there okay okay there sorry go ahead I I would just note that that is something that that I thought about I I've talked to alloy 5 about it the location of the the bathrooms out there and the facility is going to be located right next to the outside switch gear that is the main electrical
202feed for all the athletic fields there's really not a lot we would do or change to that uh that utility um and the locations of those bathrooms were Incorporated and designed into the original conl track project so it was always intended to be uh have bathrooms out there since the utilities are there so I think there would be very little flexibility of moving those and we really do think it could be incorporated in the new high school design so um you know it quite frankly could turn into a a bigger building or some type of portion like that storage good all good thoughts but I think it can be incorporated into the design you know you never know like an inside facility to train you know I'm just saying or Dr boltz's office well that
203too okay so um sorry public to be heard on non-agenda items no okay and then we can call for adjournment motion all in favor thank you for