001[Music] we're going to call the Mee in order roll call Miss nyman here Mrs Scott here Mr up to Grove here Mr Roger up to Grove here Mr Zada here Mr broy here miss dof present Mrs Katz here Mr penello here all present please stand for a pledge of lead us in a moment of silence Al to flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all public comment period number one miss Savage good evening everyone um I first wanted to uh commend you all on these meetings and how they're set up for discussion it seems like after four or five years this is great to see these coming so much and the the presentations I look forward to
002and I look forward to some good discussion um given the timing I I'm guessing I have Dr David Heiser to thank you for that so thank you very much and um my question on policy is as you talk about policy 006 I would like you also to think about the related policy on public participation and consider again the um the opportunity for people to sign up when they arrive at the meeting people like me know we have to sign up ahead of time but I have seen people come here hoping to speak and realizing what they get when they get here you know they're not regulars um that they can't speak and they're disappointed so I think there's a way around the concern that you had about people coming from outside of our district to
003speak and that is just to have a checkbox on the sign up that says I certify that I am a member of this community however it's defined in your policy and if they don't check the box ask them that question here you don't have to ask them where they live um you just have to ask them to certify if they lie they lie what's there to lose right thank you very much byebye thank you takes us down to our presentation discussion section for this evening and just a reminder to our board members um for this uh discussionary period Please make sure you tap on the touchpad draw your microphone close enough to you so folks in here in the audience can hear as well as anybody that is watching the stream this evening it really
004does help in terms of um the uh the sound purposes so we're going to begin we have this meeting broken sort of in half and a part of it's going to be both uh for policy we're going to begin and and the back end of the meeting a facilities update so we're going to begin with a review of policy 85.1 which is the use of generative artificial intelligence and education and it also includes this evening a AI presentation from our director of Technology Mr Dave fight and from our director of The Office of teaching and learning this is Stephanie Landis so i' welcome them to the podium to begin their presentation for board members you should have inside your your handouts this evening I believe a copy of 85.1 uh you also have some facts
005and figures regarding Copa and you'll hear a little bit more about that and you also have a hard copy of the presentation that we're displaying here on the screen and which should be on the stream as well so I'm going to turn it over to miss Lis and Mr fight thank you thank you very much um as we go through this in the copy of the policy that you have in front of you we did highlight some certain sections that doesn't mean that those are the only parts of the policy that we would hope um that the board would decide to include but rather just some areas that we wanted to highlight for further discussion this evening um we know it's a lot and it might be difficult to follow along with all the slide
006numbers tonight so that's why we wanted you to have all of this to be able to reflect on and look at after the presentation as well if you wish to um the first two slides that I have here are just an example for you um in the event that you maybe haven't used AI yourself before um at least intentionally AI is certainly all around us now all you have to do is search for something on the Internet and it immediately gives you an AI generated response to start with this is just one example um this is using an AI tool called chat GPT where I simply typed in some directions uh and said please give me a two paragraph over rview of the history of artificial intelligence written on a sixth grade reading level and
007this slide and the one that comes right after it is is what chat GPT gave me um these tools can be beneficial for example if I decided that this was maybe on too high of a reading level for for my audience um I might say please rewrite these these two paragraphs on a third grade reading level and it would very quickly give me two paragraphs using some different vocabulary in terms that would be on that lowerer level um so all kinds of things that can be done with artificial intelligence we're going to share with you tonight some of the benefits as well as some of the concerns and how we hope to address them here in Boyertown um and and get your input on a potential policy to help us do just that there are
008several things that we already have in place in the district when it comes to Safety and Security measures for our students with our data um Mr fight's going to speak to that a little bit and explain the things that you see on this next slide as well as talk to you a little bit about the children's online privacy protection act which I believe you have a copy of some information in front of you regarding that as well thank you so one of the things that we always do with regard to our protection of our students while they uh experience internet here at the school district is to ensure that we have what we call a single sign on um method of authentication for the student that makes sure that no student enters private data themselves
009we contain the data that the app or the application or the website uses through our clever instance which allows the student to not have to create an account create a password or submit any personal data the data that is submitted is already vetted by the school district and secured on our own side that is what we look at when we evaluate any piece of software any application is used by by a student or or teacher in the classroom and any future um application or instance such as artificial intelligence as we move forward we also have a program called securely which is something that the teachers can use to monitor our secondary education uh students our 8 through uh 12 students to make sure they are directing the students to the proper Avenues when they are
010using the technology in their school Google Apps we also have an agreement with the Google and our Google instance where again we are protected through Copa and furpa to make sure that we are only providing the appropriate student data through our any instance that also ties into our Google app the program clever which you see there in parentheses is the instance that we use to single sign on so that is the device that we use to make sure that the student data is secure and the application does not access anything that they should not access uh in terms of District involvement in artificial intelligence up until the present time um we've been doing a lot to try to educate ourselves and in turn help to ensure that our our students and our staff are prepared
011for whatever future artificial intelligence might include so last year the Burks County Intermediate Unit had a leadership series um this series met three times throughout the year up at Kutztown University and it was open to school districts throughout Burks County so we had sent a team along with many other districts across the county to participate in this leadership series um it was led by um a well-known educational leader AJ Giuliani who has been to Boyertown in the past and presented at some of our our conferences um several years ago and he he led us through several different trainings to help us learn more about artificial intelligence as well as um what are some positive ways that it could be useful to our Educators so we participated in that last school year um as part of
012that administrators have to every five years get what's called act 45 credits much like teachers have to get Act 48 professional learning credits so this was something that administrators could could earn act 45 credits for participating in and along with that there was some assignments that were required one of them being an action plan creation so I had done it for ACT 45 credit um so I had worked on an action plan draft which I had shared with Mrs torsa last year and it was basically just some of the the different steps that we needed to take as we were looking at different things around Ai and one of the things on that action plan was the idea that we needed at some point to have a policy as a district in terms of how
013we would utilize or not utilize artificial intelligence here in Boyer Town um we also have professional learning communities that our teachers participate in and our instructional coaches are often a part of with them and um they help to educate the teachers around some things with artificial intelligence as well the bciu also has an AI network uh that meets in person as well as virtually a couple times a year uh again with a focus on on education around different AI components so we have a number of us here in Boyertown who have been part of that AI Network again to collaborate with other districts around the county and with the Intermediate Unit around that topic we've also engaged in staff conversations um some specific to AI some not yet specific to AI that first piece that
014you see on this next slide has to do with professional ethics training that is one of the newer State mandates and something that we have participated in Mr Han um LED professional ethics training he's run it twice this year for our professional staff um and one of the things that we are talking about doing is having Mr fight alongside of Mr Han provide that training in the future so that we can really embed that AI uh in ethics component as well in that presentation so that all of our staff are hearing that information part of our our regular teacher evaluation process also involves personal Integrity which is one of the pieces that the policy we're going to look at tonight speaks to we use something something called the Danielson framework for our evaluation process for
015our professional staff and the fourth domain of that includes a piece on demonstrating professionalism which comes along with appropriate use of technology in the classroom and then um another piece of technology work that we have been doing this year has been testing our systems I'll let Mr fight talk a little bit about what that looks like so as if uh with any uh increase in technology as you know we uh continually try and make sure that we are educating our staff on not only the proper ways to use it in the Ed uh education field but also the security field making sure that the staff is well aware of all the pitfalls that may go into accessing online information uh our staff is now receiving regular email testing to make sure that we are preventing
016any fishing attempts and any ransomware attacks on our systems by educating the uh end user who is the is the keeper of the portal you might say as with their user account and password and trying to make sure that we are keeping them as secure as possible to identify attempted attacks through an AI uh fishing attempt or any other uh ransomware attack that may come to the district that'll be tied into our professional ethics training that will be ongoing yearly and I'll be um integrating a piece of technology ethics uh to that presentation that Mr Han has already been giving in front of you you have a copy of the sample policy which is the psba policy 8151 um we'd like to go through some of the key components with you this evening and have
017opportunity to have some conversation and discussion with you around those um again it it might might be a lot of flipping to look at the slide numbers on there right now but hopefully it will help you as you go back through and and look at this in a little bit more detail in the future as well um the first page of the policy is really just setting that purpose and who has the authority you'll see that it notes on that first page the the Copa that child online privacy protection act as well as furpa um which is another privacy a federal um Privacy Act that prevents us from sharing student information outside of those who need to know the information and so on so the first page just really provides that background and talks about
018those pieces um but some of the things that we want to point out to you um that are included in this policy that we think are really positive things as you consider whether you want to move this forward and that is it talks about generative AI tools and resources used in district schools and programs shall be evaluated and authorized on an ongoing basis and it's looking at several things age appropriateness for our students um bias making sure that that any resources being used um do not have a bias to them privacy protections as Mr fight alluded uded to accessibility standards and those data security pieces one of the things that we have to determine um if we are to put this policy forward is on the second page you'll see numbered 1 through 7 we
019need to determine who we want the people to be to evaluate and authorize those resources on an ongoing basis we would recommend that the director of it and the director of OTL should both be um checked off there where it says director of curriculum and instruction that would be our director of of office of teaching and learning uh that both of us or both people in these roles would need to really have the opportunity to look at those resources both from that data security and safety and privacy protection angle um as well as from the age appropriateness and the bias and how is it used to support our students academically as well as with determining appropriate AI resources it also mentions um in here that the board directs that only District authorized generative AI tools
020and resources may be used on District computers and in district schools and programs we're really looking at that for students um that's kind of towards the bottom of the second page there where we have it highlighted um really focusing for students that there would be District authorized tools that they would be limited to using when it comes to artificial intelligence um we've looked at a couple different things we're going to talk about this in a little bit more detail on one of the upcoming slides in in terms of what generative AI tools are out there that can work within the parameters of our Safety and Security Systems when it comes to to uh student privacy of data and so on um in addition to that one thing that we would recommend that we think would
021be beneficial would be to have an AR or an administrative regulation to go along with this policy AI is rapidly changing as we all know and there could be AI resources that we're not even aware of yet or that even perhaps haven't even been created yet that you know 6 months or a year from now a a teacher may be interested in using and want to propose that we take a look at to see if it would be appropriate or not for students to use within our schools and we would want to have a process for teachers to bring those to our attention so that we can make sure that those resources are properly vetted and that we've had an opportunity to review them so what we're envisioning is an AR that would look very
022similar to what the teachers are already familiar with and what they fill out when they're requesting a new uh Book for a whole class novel or a lit Circle book they have a form that they fill out with certain questions that they answer to show that they have reviewed it first before they bring it to our attention and then things that we look for as well um so looking for a similar process to review different um materials when it comes to AI resources as well so that's one recommendation that we would make uh Mr fight's going to speak a little bit about investigating AI resources there's some things that we have been looking at again really looking at that that Safety and Security angle in terms of how um you know we can direct students
023to things that would be safe for them to use AI is not going anywhere um and so it's really important that we teach students and educate them um of the benefits as well as the pitfalls and how they can use it safely Mrs Landis and I have had on going conversations with multiple school districts not only in the Burks County area but also in Montgomery and Lehigh counties as we have been trying to investigate the proper course of action one of the things that we are trying to make sure that we can do is provide the teachers an Avenue where the students can remain in their Lane can remain within guard rails of using AI so that we have some sort of Reliance on where those students are going and in particularly on my um
024my end of that making sure that they're accessing it securely and safely so we have been looking at a variety of different resources that would be student resources only as this as the teachers will be allowed to uh peruse and browse as they see fit uh the students will be guided using special guard rails to make sure they're using applications that the district has already vetted not only from an educational standpoint with the office of OTL but from a security standpoint from my office to making sure that student data is protected that we might have a DPA a data privacy agreement with the vendor to make sure that we are providing the uh student the safest and most educationally um Reliant um Avenue using AI so those are things that we're going to continue to
025investigate not only internally here in boyert town but across multiple school districts in Burks Montgomery and Lehigh counties the one one thing I do want to make make mention at at this time there would probably be a cost associated with those guard rails making sure that we're using an application that would be um relevant for them making sure that it is meeting all the standards that we are going to come up with along with this policy uh we don't have those figures in front of you today but those would be things that we would be asking you down the road yes go ahead Mrs nyman do you have an estimate of what it might cost I mean I'm not putting I'm not holding you to it just an idea sure one of the things that
026we would have to investigate very first internally would be where we open this up would this be a k through 12 initiative would this be a secondary initiative would this be starting in grades four and five there are arguments on both sides that we may not want to open those uh that this application tool for all students mainly because it may not be age appropriate and curriculum appropriate one of the estimates that we have used that was used at the East Penn School District which they are currently us using right now is a ballpark cost of about $7 per student in licensing fees for that kind of application that's per a year that would be a yearly cost yes along with this one of the other things that the policy contains is AI literacy which
027is on the third page of the policy that you have in front of you and AI literacy is really all about training and professionally developing all those who would come in contact with AI so our professional staff we would include training during our professional learning time on the use and as well as the ethical and legal implications of artificial intelligence we would need to make sure we're providing training for students on expectations and appropriate use of resources AI is not something that students would be using all the time we want to make sure we are you know continually encouraging our students to think for themselves and there will be many many times where they will be doing work where they will not be permitted to access AI but part of the training is making sure
028that we have consistent um guidance so that students are clear on when they are and are not allowed to use certain resources and training for our staff on on how to kind of put those parameters in place and then Our IT staff uh in the information technology office would also need training regarding oversight and use of artificial intelligence so those pieces are mentioned in the policy as well and something that we agree is critically important academic Integrity is a big piece of this and something that is also included in the draft policy that you have in front of you um this is over on page four and it talks in here about the use of generative AI by students to complete assignments or assess or assessments shall only be allowed to the extent stated and
029outlined by the teacher for the individual assignment or course so again the teachers would need to make it abundantly clear to the students before they started working on something if it is something that they are allowed to use AI resources for or not um and that would need to be clear to them and Stu students would need to you know certainly follow along with that direction provided by their teacher um it also talks about the board permits the use of AI detection tools as an aid to identify potential academic Integrity issues but prohibits Reliance on results from AI detection tools as the sole determination of academic integrity this is a piece we're going to talk about a little bit more um in a future slide and this is something for you to really consider as
030a board um basically what this what this means here is there there are companies out there that promote what they call AI detectors that claim that they can tell if a student copied something that they found somewhere else on the internet um copied something that AI generated for them or if it's the students own thoughts and own words the problem is that these are not particularly welldeveloped at the time at this time there are actually several lawsuits out there regarding these types of AI detection tools at the present time we would not recommend that the school district invest funds in purchasing any kind of an AI detector um because they're not 100% accurate um and there are a lot of legalities still to be determined around those um so whether you wanted that statement to
031stay in there or not so that if there were detection tools down the road that would be uh better equipped that you have it already mentioned in the policy but regardless of whether there are better detection tools out there or not it really shouldn't be the sole determination of academic Integrity it really needs to involve a conversation between the teacher and the student um you know asking them simple questions about well you know tell me more about that idea that you wrote about there and and seeing if they can expand on the things that that they have written and and really dig into conversation with the students and that conferring piece is really important with that as well um but that Integrity piece is something that we would definitely be stressing with our students in
032our classrooms um just as we would you know in in regard to cheating in other ways as well there's also AI generated content verification and this is mentioned in the policy also and this is kind of along similar lines to what we talked about on the previous slide so individuals it says in the policy individuals using generative AI tools and resources have a responsibility to apply proper oversight and evaluation of generated information generative AI tools shall not be the sole determining factor used to make decisions related to Student Learning assessment academic Integrity or conduct so in other words when we're making decisions about student learning for example perhaps we are looking at student data to determine what math course student should be in for the following year we would not rely solely on AI generated
033information to make that determination currently our students use a program called ISL that has uh reading and math skills that students can work on um they take a preest it determines their levels and then gives them individualized problems to work on and practice to do that's based on that assessment um soel in a way uses AI to help ident identify the level that a student is on and provide them those assignments but that wouldn't be the only resource that we would use to determine what math needs a student has for their class the next year we want to get input from the teacher we want to look at other types of Assessments that the student has participated in so the policy speaks to that and says that we should not be using generative AI tools
034as the sole determining factor to make those types of decisions about a student's learning the last thing that the policy talks about on the last page is consequences for inappropriate use and talks about uh if a student fails to comply with policy or District rules regarding appropriate use of Technology including AI um we do have an acceptable use policy Mr fight will speak to that in just a moment um but we would follow our appropriate disciplinary action and or referrals to Legal authorities based on what we have in our in our discipline code and we would expect that stud students and staff would report any violations or suspicious activity to the building principle if there was some sort of violation with AI um we do already have an acceptable use policy and Mr fight's going
035to speak to that yes our existing acceptable use policy is something that is reviewed yearly by both our employees and our staff uh to remind them of the appropriate use of our district resources within our district Network all students are obligated to make sure that they do not any way attempt to circumvent our Network and our security by using the uh District device in a manner that was not outlined by the vision of the board and the the the school district appropriately one of the things that we want to continue to mention as we try and to develop this policy is this is a tool for the toolbox this is something that is ever evolving it's a very complicated tool but it is nothing more than a single resource that the students will be using
036we are not asking to rely upon AI for any data such as Mrs Landis mentioned to promote students throughout their educational experience we're also making sure that the students cannot only use AI generated tools to develop their schoolwork and progress through the school district we want to make sure that it's something that they are aware of because they will have exposure to it as adults and in their higher education um or uh vocational uh expertise moving forward but we want to make sure that we are creating guidelines that don't prohibit from learning about it but making sure they stay within the path uh intended for academic integ integrity and security um along with the consequences for inappropriate use the policy also talks about users of generative AI being responsible for any damages to equipment or
037systems that would result from deliberate malicious or willful acts um or attempting to modify without permission or damage any kind of files or violate copyright law things like that so that would all be included in there as well the last bullet notes that this policy should also apply to student conduct that occurs off school property or during non-school hours to the same extent as provided in board policy on student discipline so it would align with other policies that you already have in place and then we have a few recommendations um that we would love to discuss with you further first of all we strongly believe that we do as a district need need to get an AI policy in place hopefully sooner rather than later um the challenge with this is the policy needs to
038be General enough to Outlast the frequent changes and updates to AI that are happening in our world um so that you're not having to update the policy multiple times a year however at the same time because AI does change so rapidly it is a policy that you should probably look at at least annually to see if there any are any updates that need to be made um as things change in the world of technology we would recommend that P the psba policy would be the recommended template that we take a look at um again as I mentioned before we do not recommend purchasing an AI detector with District funds at the present time um as they really are are not welld designed at the present time and there are still a lot of legalities to
039be determined surrounding those on the next slide we have a few more recommendations um couple things to consider in the policy um one is the staff who should the staff be that are designated to oversee AI updates and address issues there's two different places in the policy where that has to be noted um at the beginning and then again on I think it's page bottom of page four on top of page five again we would recommend that the director of it and the director of OTL should both be looking at these things together to look at it from from both the technology lens as well as the the educational academic lens um the consent piece there is a place in the policy on page two where um I have it crossed out in here for
040you in the Middle where it says slide 17 it says the district shall obtain prior informed consent from parents/guardians before allowing a student to use generative AI tools and resources in school um it's important for parents to be aware of AI and it's important for us to make sure that we are providing clear updates and information to our families um however trying to gather publicity permissions from parents on an annual basis proves to be quite challenging when we're looking to get things from 60 for 6,500 plus students in our district um and again AI is all around us you literally go on a Search tool on the internet and and an AI generated response pops right up um so rather than than the way it's worded in the policy our suggestion would be that we
041as a district acknowledge on an annual basis and remind families that um we do students do have access to AI tools in the district and would be using them within the parameters of the policy that's in place and within the parameters of the tools that are approved by the district um so that would be our recommendation for that piece there's one other thing that I had um crossed out on here for us to have discussion about and that is on page four it says teachers shall outline use of generative AI tools and resources in their required lesson plans at the present time we do not have a district policy that requires teachers to hand in lesson plans on a regular basis or use a particular format our teachers do plan on a regular basis and
042they have things well prepared for their students um but they don't turn in lesson plans or have a a a set template that they're required to use um so unless that's something that the board decides to do differently in the future that line there doesn't necessarily align with the the policies that we currently have in place in the district it does again right above that line is where it does state that parent or teachers need to clearly identify for students um before an assignment or an assessment is given whether AI may be used or not and they need to have clear parameters around that so it does cover that piece that that communication is there that it's part of what the the teachers are planning and communicating but in terms of you know having lesson
043plans that get turned in or that sort of thing we don't currently uh have a policy that requires teachers to do that so that's why I have that part noted that way um and then again as Mr fight mentioned earlier the AI resources that would be limited would be those ones for student use the teachers would have uh a little bit more flexibility in terms of the resources that they are using there's some great AI tools out there that can help teachers make slideshows and things like that that would be really beneficial to them that we wouldn't necessarily have students use but that would be beneficial tools for teachers to be able to have access to and I think that is our last slide um any questions comments items for further discussion on on this
044topic Mr Zada okay just a couple notes and looking at it over the weekend um this is sort of like when we first got computers then we got cell phones it exploded we never got on top of it my concern is are we going to have enough people should this become a permanent committee cabinet position because you are affecting 6,500 students and like you said we walk out of here tonight we're already something's passed us by I I mean the I the I the AI generated stuff I mean you look at what Hollywood was demanding they don't feel they need actors anymore you know we've got things from Tik Tock you can see what they can do but my it scares me because again and we don't know because again this is like computers you
045know we don't know what where the ramifications come or where does it break even where so like you said yearly reviews I can see there would be monthly till we can do this this is actually going to be something like you know it's curriculum but it's actually the outer part of the curriculum so um personally you know like I said I I don't know if you know I don't want to be like the federal government and set up a committee for everything and then it takes forever to but after our our prior discussions and some of that you know like you said I mean it's going to be it's something we're living with we're not going to get rid of it but what's the best way we control it for our students and it's the
046same thing if the parents don't sign off on it do does that student is he allowed or she allowed in the class to use it or you know or does that set up something legal because we didn't get it signed and all of a sudden they get put into the wrong area and they're into something Agee appropriate something that's not right does that leave the liability to the school so do we enforce more so the you know making sure those permission slips or whatever are signed teachers stay on top of that and I know like you said you're now going to have teachers turning in their you know their classes and um we're asking a lot of them but we're also asking what I'm saying is I don't I agree 100% with you I don't
047want to see that person be a chat box you know sitting there with the but I also said to you I saw some different shows where it added instead of a parah you had a they were allowed to go into a certain area for their science class so the teacher was allowed to walk around and the students were allowed to ask certain questions and they were getting answers and then the teacher would oversee I don't see that every class or anything but I know there's some classes we're a little bit you know we're short teachers so maybe we could use a pa um I probably figure my third three-year-old already knows grandson knows more about this than I do so I just my concern is that we don't we don't just sit on it every
048year but you know make this a key issue for this you know for the next couple years so that's my opinion I apologize for taking up that much time but no that's okay it does it's scary but at the same time it it opens up so many things for these for the kids as well as the teachers as well as hopefully for me you know down the road yes it's definitely something that that will need to be Revisited on a regular basis because again it is something that changes rapidly um we're definitely not looking at AI to replace our teachers we have phenomenal teachers and there are many many things that that a a teacher can do that AI is not going to do for our students and so our teachers play a very important
049role AI is a tool um one of the things I'm I think we may have gone through the one slide a little bit quickly but on the one slide we had a link for you um that you can look at at your leisure as well that shows one of the tools that our instructional coaches have used to to develop and create that talks to students about the fact that AI is just that it's a tool and it's not meant to do all of the work for you even when you are using an AI re Source you still have to do your own thinking um the output that it gives you is only as good as the input that you put into it so you need to know what kinds of questions to ask it and
050how to kind of tailor it and um get down to the the level of information that you're looking for it to produce so you know that's an important piece as well and and that Integrity piece that we talked about also is critically important yeah and as you ask it more questions it learns and then the next thing you know you know it's got that correct answer for the for the student you know it can bring it back or you you bring it around you know what's two and two okay four but then times this time that and next thing you know you know you got a student that has all the answers but didn't use the thinking end of it that's that's the scary part and we kind of did that with computers in the
051beginning it's like it's why we ban cell phones in classrooms because they're using it to get answers so it is amazing how much technology has changed even in the in the course of our careers I don't think I even had a computer in my classroom my first 10 years of teaching so it's definitely changed a lot especially over the past 10 to 20 years um one point that you brought up that I think is important that we didn't necessarily touch on that Mr fight can speak to a little bit more um that idea that when when you put something into the AI generator um artificial intelligence then takes that information that you've put in there and uses it to improve prove itself and come up with better answers in the future one of the benefits
052of the programs that we are looking at using is that um it does not share our students answers and information outside of the confines of that program so let Mr fight speak to that he can explain it a little bit better than I can right some of the uh tools that you've already mentioned actually are in development and have already been developed one of the tools that we're looking at is called School AI which actually provides a a environment where the teacher and the student can interact using AI generated questions and answers and then there are tools within that uh application that can allow the teacher to make sure that the student is staying on track for instance we may provide a linear equation in math and allow the students to use AI to attempt
053to answer that question and if the if the student gets off topic and asks a question that is not related to a linear equation the uh actual AI tool will then snap into uh um into um action and redirect the student back into where the prompt that they should be working from these are the tools that are being developed they're continually developed we only have been looking at two thus far there are probably far more than that across this uh the uh un united states that are being used by districts at this time so it's something that we would continually uh evaluate not just on a yearly basis but on a u a monthly basis that's why I think it is important that our recommendation is to tie an AR to this so that we
054can regulate this policy without constantly having to meet and and discuss the entire Topic at at at at nauseum uh making sure that we use it just like we use any app based learning in our classrooms or software that uh teachers may discover to use down the road um those are things that my staff continually look at not only from a security standpoint but from a practicality standpoint on whether or not it is meeting the curricular needs set by our office of OTL Mrs nyman yeah uh I hope we're going to have more discussions like this before we make a decision on this um because I think it's really critical to really make dig down into it uh I do have some questions uh in talking to some teachers I know not necessarily Boyertown but
055throughout Burks County some Montgomery County uh virtual programs how how are we going to control that with AI could you be a little more specific on what I I'm not sure I understand okay virtual programs just say social studies M you give an assignment you have to read a whole chapter or whatever and you have to do this project they can go on to Ai and get all that information without doing the research themselves mhm and come up with say you have to do a report AI can do that report form how are we going to control that correct well that would be part of our ethics and our integrity discussions that we would have with not only the teachers but the students uh but in terms of the tools themselves we don't Pro prohibit
056anything from a personal device so those are some of the the problems that we may incur whether we have a policy in place or not the students have to know the correct and appropriate use of AI within their assignment field um what we will do is when we develop an application that we believe fits the model that the policy hopefully outlines those students will be directed towards that there is nothing outside of our Copa and furpa agreements that students can get to outside of our district resources so it'll be about teaching our students the proper use of those resources that are permitted through our filtering and application um restrictions that are put on District devices so that that that's part of the way we'll guide the student to the proper use of AI there is
057a there is a comp there is a a component of this that is something that is can't be can't be done with technology this has to be taught through basic common sense and learnings that the teachers and the students have to learn what is the appropriate use of AI I can go out and have ai write me a 600 page document and make me look like a nuclear physicist that doesn't make me a nuclear physicist so it's Pro it's very important that we teach the students the proper use of Technology because we will not be able to restrict all uses of AI and Technology from our students okay so I'm a I'm a student and I'm on Virtual and I'm given the quarters or the semester or the years information of what I have to
058do for that course for that year what's to say I couldn't have that done in a week time two weeks Time by using AI what what will be done to that child that student to me for using AI to do all my work and then not learning anything from it handing in all my information and now I can sit there for the rest of the the year or semester or quarter or whatever it is and and do nothing so you brought up a couple important points one is the child's cheating themselves out of an education right and they're not learning anything um we can only control what happens within our virtual program you know we can't control what students are or aren't doing if they're in an outside virtual program but within our our basd
059virtual program um we have our own teachers who are connected to students in those virtual programs and still work to to build relationships um with them and are taking a look at their work so if they see something that's written by a student and it doesn't match the the style of writing or the quality of writing that they're used to seeing from that student that's where it initiates a conversation and a followup and you know whether it's email or a phone call or a zoom session or whatever um that they can be checked in with with with our teachers um or the accelerate teachers who are working with them depending on the level that they're in um and also even if they're in Virtual if they're in our virtual program they're still basd students and
060so they would fall under the same guidelin of our acceptable use policy and our discipline policy um and those pieces would apply to them as well okay so I say I didn't do that and my parents say nope she didn't do that what is going to be the teacher recourse and is Administration going to back them up I think it would be the same as if that happened for an in-person student who didn't produce their own work and and didn't you know cheated on something we would follow the same discipline policies whether it's you know earning a zero and an assignment or having to redo an assignment or whatever has been established in that situation okay um and and just to interject there Mrs nman you know we have some of those things that are
061already taking place they're not future things to look forward to those are things that are actually part of of um what we've been involved in and I'm assuming bard of Town's been involved in even prior to me coming here but in my short time here we've been involved in some of those instances and have worked through codes of conduct and have worked through um the different learning pieces that that come with that um due to the nature of students access to to to to the the the the worldwide web and uh and how we try to develop students understanding of appropriate use okay I guess my next question would be whose word are you going to take are you going to take the student parents version or are you going to go by the teacher
062and support the teacher so we you know we go by what what the investigation leads us to and that's an investigation using multiple folks that would involve teacher Administration certainly hearing the the student side the parents involved in that and make what we believe is the best decisions and the appropriateness based on whatever occurred um in in terms of that there are endless types of accounts that can can and will occur through time so it's working through all those things collectively to come to some type of resolution some of which you know fall within the disciplinary realm of things some which you know have consequences of redoing some of the things in a nature to that that that that you know fit the parameters for for the assignment so you know those are all things
063that you know are our our administrators and teachers are already um working on and we have to continue to develop our staff to be able to professionally develop and to prepare themselves for for that it's it it's it's an added thing that's in the world in which Educators now live okay one other comment and then I'll stop for tonight um with the regard to permission I think that's something that should be done on a yearly basis because what happened if you have separated divorced parents and the child goes from this one to that one how are we going to know that okay this time it was with Mom next time it's with Dad how are we going to control that this is not going to be a any different than what we currently do as
064part of the annual verification for using District equipment uh that is why it's important for us to explore Avenues and tools that reflect our security and our uh uh data of data uh security policies we would not um suggest or recommend any application that did not con uh confined to our current policy of using single sign on and making sure that the the student data is secure from our standpoint so there would be no difference to the uh student using an AI tool versus a math software program that also integrates through clever we would make sure that all the applications that we research and develop with our teachers uh fit that policy as we currently use with any application or software we currently use in the district okay and I would just hope that we're
065we're getting our teachers input from here um definitely um one other thing related to the last question that you had asked um when it comes to to cheating in our students producing their own work you know oftentimes especially when it comes to to writing the teachers are working with students through the writing process and so it's not just hand in a final copy at the end um they have checklists that they're using along the way where students have different smaller chunks that they're doing building up to that full complete writing piece at the end um often revision and editing is part of that process and students have to show the evidence of their thinking and their work all along the way so those types of things also um can help put some of those safeguards
066in place to make sure that students aren't just you know using AI to come up with a writing piece that they hand in at the very last minute uh first of all what Mr Zada said I think definitely reviewing this way more than once a year obviously would be very beneficial especially at the beginning point and also I saw in there something about uh bullying being used with AI so maybe we could put something in there where you know obviously we have a policy against bullying and we have ai procedures and policies so if you bully with AI you basically double down and the punishment would be that much worse not not just take it from here or there because I can imagine some AI bullying could get pretty awful so I'd like to see
067you know students really you know to pay for doing things like that so our current bullying policy does also include cyber bullying so um that may be a policy that you know you want to take a look at and review also to make sure that it covers AI or if anything needs to be updated or revised there that that's considered I want to thank Mr fight and I want to thank Mrs Landis for a wonderful presentation and engaging the board this evening um moving forward with this our plan would be to um modify the um the the the a a5.1 um putting in some of the recommend ations that we you heard this evening bring this back to you at the uh Committee of the whole meeting in March so you see that draft version
068see the changes in some of the language um there could be more discussion with regard to that and if any more modifications you'd like to see um with regards to that can be made we would then bring that forward um at the legislative meeting if the board so chooses um to vote for a first read uh on that remember policies need two separate reads with regard to that so um we can then modify make any changes bring forward at the committee meeting in April for a second read at the legislative meeting in April with the idea of having a hopefully an approval of a board policy with regard to 85.1 sometime May and certainly by the time we start the uh school year um for 2526 not is ultimately the goal here okay all right
069thank you thank you both okay that shifts us down to uh policy 006 and this is the meetings policy this is your design policy of how meetings are conducted in all the capacities in regards to that um I've heard over um my time period being here and the reason I've brought forward this policy a lot of commentary with regard to committees committees fall inside of 006 so I hope to engage the the board this evening in any discussion and possibilities that the board was thinking um in order to move forward um a policy that the board um could consent to in terms of its committee meeting structures and I think there's been some discussion um around some of those uh what is or what what is not committee meetings and uh I want to really
070open the floor up for um the board an opportunity to to share any insights and some thinkings that they may have with regard to Comm uh committees and if you open that policy uh the committee section falls on page 10 of the policy hey Dr David oer mean you had a a conversation prior to this about committees and you had some ideas from other schools I think maybe you could share that with the board and see what people think of that sure you know one of the things that that that I've seen so far and again truly btwn is not running uh committee meetings in a traditional sense no really committees at all um right now so thinking this through a little bit in the terms of the structure of how um your present meetings
071are now with your Committee of the whole meetings and your legislative meetings um it'd be an opportunity uh prior to each of those meetings and right now you have in name four established committee committees um you know one is policy um you have Finance um you have education and student services and and Facilities so it' be an opportunity if you really think this through to be able to offer an every other month opportunity um to host two of those committees one each prior to the committee of the whole meeting one prior to a legislative meeting in any particular month and then the following month host the other two committees prior to too give an opportunity for really for each of the Committees to meet probably five to six times a year um and really a
072good opportunity for us as a board then to sit down and to really Target one or two agenda items that that um those committee leaders would like to engage in um prior to a meeting we're not calling uh board members out on another evening in addition to it's really an hour prior to and really allow us an opportunity to to Target and talk about and discuss or have some presentations made with regard to those one of the things we really need um to move forward with is a real structured policy review um and really engage going through all of our policies and having uh reviews of those edits of those some subtractions of of those but really start that and this would allow a policy committee to do that our facilities we have a lot
073of things to talk about with the board when it comes to our facilities um considerations that we'd want to make any updates that we want to give to the board um in that certainly with Finance you saw we just hosted a month ago a financial meeting um we could be doing that on a more regular basis but in a shorter time period and really allowing the board to interact with one or two things that are on their minds um with regard as we build a budget throughout the year um in addition to you know calling any longer special meetings that that that we would require for for those and likewise with our other committees uh as well so I I I've seen that work well in other school districts um it's engaging it's prior to
074a night that the board is already here um but there's a time limit to that so that it it it it really captures and forces the board to think critically making really important decisions and and commentary um and engaging in conversation for an hour prior to the regularly regularly scheduled meetings and then our community would also see that we've regularly scheduled those committee meetings and they could join um as well so that that's just a possibility and recommendation um if the board has other thoughts or feelings about how they would like to structure I think there's certainly enough involved in the world of of of our school district here that we certainly should really consider running some structured committee meetings throughout the course of a year so personally like after reading the uh the whole
075thing it sounds very much like what you said is already here with the exception of that this is already that it's not built into our schedule right now yeah currently the board does not the district's not calendared committee meetings um this would essentially be calendaring those so typically in I would assume and probably about in a month's time the board would consider a board committee structure for next year and list those dates at the same time the board could also list out those committees when they would meet and if you know that structure would work they could be calendared then every we could post those we could advertise those our community would know about those you would know about those um and we would be able to move forward um once the policies you know
076changed and and and we go through a second read that we could begin those uh ultimately we could be begin those with the start of the 25 26 school year um and it would really be helpful for us as Administration as well there are just so many things and sometimes extending regular meetings longer and and pushing out three three and a half hour meetings to do all the needed presentations and so forth that they become less productive as well um for captured time periods that's something to to consider I don't think there's a lot that would need to be changed with regard to the policy um and I would I did talk to Mr salanic a little bit about this and once we had some discussion I'd bring back any uh thoughts and ideas to
077be able to add um the necessary wording to whatever structure the board would want to consider yeah so um when Mrs Scot Scott and I had discussions with you you had pointed out I mean there's some policies that haven't been looked at for over 15 years so I know it's a hard it's a ton of pages to read but I think just making sure that we are legally updated and um and if there are things uh that need to be brought they get brought and um this way we're setting and you know nothing's done behind scenes nothing everything's out in front we can all discuss it and and hopefully come to a situation where we can all agree on something and move forward but uh there's some stuff in there like I said that's never
078been in there I mean it hasn't been read in 10 15 years where it said it was and I don't remember going over it but um we definitely need as a group to come together to get this stuff fixed because uh it'll just make our Wheels run smooth so one of the other things that I think was a was was a not a good thing was that we did meet ahead of time but we do have to have that agenda setting meeting we didn't really discuss what we were going to discuss except that that needs to be I feel that needs to be part of it that we would just meet that those that are on the and sometimes you have to meet with like facilities would have to meet with you know our head
079of facilities and that sort of thing so you you have to set the agenda for the meeting it makes it easier for everyone that comes can be prepared as to what's going to be discussed but we're not changing any policy we're just bringing it here we're not doing anything with facilities we're just highlighting what's going on so you do need that pre pre meeting to come then to this uh public meeting yeah that's important and it's a it's important in terms of structuring uh the meeting agenda and preparing that the business of the school district needs to be done here right it's done in public setting of the agendas and we do we do that now and bringing an agenda out to the public then and and setting that making that public so similar it's
080a similar structure as you see tonight our special meeting structure is is is that same way it follows the policies that are there um and we can easily do that Miss Diamond you had a question yeah uh as far as I know we are still having psba do our policies is that correct psba is doing the policies yes so I find it ironic that Mr sad is sitting over there and saying 15 years since they've been touched because we're paying the psba to do them yearly So you you're in a structure right now where we get those that may be modified might be changed based on law what has not been frequently happening is that the policy if have not been coming forward here um and that needs to be a structure that that takes
081place there are so many of those we can't do those in a regular meeting we need to start out with a committee to be able to run through and and focus those on a cont traditional committee meeting might bring forward 10 different types of policies and we can go through those during that time period to be able to to make decisions on those so that we can then bring them to a committee meeting for any open discussion outside of that that structure has not been happening to date so we do have some outdated policies if you look through our policies and then I just heard Mrs Scott say that her and Mr Sada apparently met with you on policy and I thought we were not supposed to be doing that anymore because when I was
082on a committee Mrs Scott threw up a thing you can't meet with somebody like that you have to have everybody there so what what's allowable to do is for for a board member or board members certainly not five to come in and to meet to do set an agenda they did come in we met for 20 minutes a half hour to set some agenda items for this evening of what are the two policies they wanted to be SP spoken about in this special meeting decision was made to bring those forward of 85.1 I made some recommendations about 06 and the agenda was set with regards to that so that's an appropriate use of how we can set an agenda so we can bring forward to committee meetings and then share those in those in those
083same committee meetings and that was the that's the structure that I'm proposing that we we utilize does anyone have anything to add or discuss no so ml M darl just want want to make sure I understand this properly we're still going to have committee chairs and Committees of the whole so you have a structured meeting right now that's called a committee of the whole meeting right that's a regularly scheduled meeting yeah um and you have a regularly scheduled legislative meeting that that falls two weeks later so committee chairs are utilized in a way to be able to set an agenda for committee meetings what you're not doing right now is you're not hosting committee meetings I'm proposing that we structure and post a calendar like we do for our regular meetings both the committee of
084the whole meeting and the legislative meeting and calendar those so that we can utilize committee chairs to to help set the agenda to run them to run an a committee meeting and that we have regular committee meetings structured on the same evenings that we have our two regularly strict regularly scheduled meetings I thought the solicitor said if we have committee over the you wouldn't have committee chairs it' be Committee of the whole well you're Committee of the whole right now and we're trying to shift most of the things away uh from voting in a committee of the whole meeting a committee of the whole meeting is really meant to be an informational meeting similar to tonight right it meant to be an informational meeting it's meant to go through all the similar components to share
085with the board so that you have then a couple of weeks to think about what was to hear from your constituent groups and then the legislative meeting to do that what we can't get accomplished in those two meetings are all the other things related to the Committees that we don't have running right now it would help to expedite our review of policy it would help to expedite a number of things that we could then bring back from from Finance from facilities from education to be able to have those board Representatives at the committee at the committee the whole or at the legislative meeting to be able to report out certainly other board members are welcome to attend those committee meetings to be able to be to be ears and and to be listening to the
086presentations and so forth or we're streaming now so those can to be done you know at their Leisure um so that's the structure that I'm suggesting so that we can get more of the business of the school completed um some of which is necessary most especially just want to you know we're talking about policy but related to a lot of our policies right now but there are many other things in other areas that we need to be discussing and it gives us another opportunity to do that you're welcome so I I will speak with Mr sultanic about the language that currently exists related to committee meetings and some of the things we discussed this evening similar to um 8151 I'll bring back at the uh Committee of the whole meeting uh some language a draft
087of of that and for further discussion and if so if the board chooses to move forward to the legislative meeting for a first read of of what those that change could possibly be okay that takes us to a second almost kind of the second half of the meeting this evening and this is a facilities update and we have um two updates to bring to you this evening one um and both are going to be presented first introduced by Mr sheal our director of facilities but presented by um Dewey engineering cha and uh I do see those individuals here this evening um so both an update on the turf field um considerations and our board Town Elementary School HVAC and roof study presentation as well so Mr sh I'm going to have you introduce and and
088um and invite our guests up here good evening um the district reach out to Dewey for both of these projects to get their expertise and design work um first we're going to start with the turfield currently the bit uh permits are out we're waiting for those to get back we're about halfway through um our contract with dwey um so it's a good time for an update I want to make sure the board knows everything that's going into the bid before it hits the street which includes what the base bit is what the alternates are and what they look like do will explain those tonight um as far with Bordertown L we've reached out to Dey to give us their recommendation on the best way to improve the HVAC system Roofing and in turn the electrical
089and some Life Safety Equipment uh they will be be presenting that as well that will be their recommendation so the board will have to make a decision going forward along with the administration on which direction we want to go with that as far as the turf it's informational uh the bids they're they're getting the bid documents completed and then once the uh permits come back and we know that we're good to go they will hit the street so without any more words from me I'd like to introduce the doy Representatives so they can come up and do the presentation thank you good evening members of the board and uh the administration and the btown school district public my name is Jamie Lynch I'm the business practice leader uh for what is now cha um we
090were with you in the fall to talk about both the turf and um the hbac at the elementary school and uh our same team is with you this evening um I just wanted to reintroduce myself um we've been now a part of CHA for about a year we're still the same group that's um based in Bethlehem working uh really 90% of our work is for K to 12 uh school districts still in eastern Pennsylvania providing pmcm work uh mechanical electrical Plumbing design and also Structural Engineering so um it's hard to believe that it's been about a year that we've been under the cha umbrella but it's been very good for us and we remain really unchanged in the service that we provide um happy to answer any questions that you have about that afterwards but
091in the meantime I'm just the warm-up show for Chris holler your project manager who will talk to you about both uh the turf project and the elementary and then Kevin Burns is our mechanical engineer who's worked with Chris and I on putting the study and all the information together so if they're any questions you've got all the experts this this evening at your disposal hi everyone I will try to keep this brief I'll go through the 78 slides I have as quickly as possible I'm kidding it's not 78 so I do want to present to you both the turf update and the Boyer 10 Elementary School update so without further Ado if we could go to the next slide hope I got the click I can do that there we go so this is um
092a design of The Stadium Field um you can see the logo in the center the endzones will have the Bears name on it um I'll go through the stuff that is included in this as base bid design um but all the shaded areas that you see will be Turf so in the D area to the left um past the end zone you currently have the shot put and The discus throw in there those two items will be moved to another area on campus so that that area can be Turf as well next we're looking at field one um you see the logo in here that will be an alternate bid and I'll get into the alternates a little bit uh later on as well um this field here is actually designed where um there's fencing
093around it to protect it from any vehicles or anything like that being able to drive on it um to the left of it you can see a little bit of a walkway there one of the requirements that we have to do is there's Ada parking associated with this field and we need to provide an accessible walk P walking path from that parking lot or parking spaces over to the concrete pad where the district can place um bleachers if they so choose so what's included in the bits um both fields are considered base bit so with the Stadium Field we'll have lining for football soccer field hockey boys and girls lacrosse um we're looking at a two-tone turf field and basically that's two different shades of green just ever so slightly so it looks like you're
094lawn when it's freshly mowed um when you look at it from the bleachers you'll see a dark you know five foot five yard section then a lighter green 5 foot SE 5 yard section and it just gives the appearance of being mowed there's no additional cost to do the two different um collar turfs um so we thought that's something that really highlights um the field um in the stadium netting at both ends of the field to protect soccer balls field hockey balls footballs from from going past the field um that netting will be removable so it's not in the way of anything when you're using it for track and field events um new flag pole um as I mentioned we're going to relocate the shot put and discus and the new Under drain system as
095well as um stormw management um that will be under the under the field as well for field one it'll have all the same lines less football um it'll also have the fencing and The netting um a concrete pad for owner provided bleachers the accessible walking path and again under drain system and um storm water man Management on that that field as well so this is a little difficult to read but I will go through the alternate bids so alternate bid one is to um consider the earth work unclassified now what that means is when we the base bid is it's is the dirt will be classified which means that if contractors run into unsuitable soils rocks anything like like that we have measurements within the specifications that dictate what the contractor owns and what is
096outside of their contract if we come across stuff that's outside of their contract we measure it and then there's some we we pay through it for it through allowances or change order if needed um we ask the contractor to give us a price to deem that material unclassified and what that means is say they say for $225,000 will take the risk and deem everything unclassified unclassified means whatever they find they own um for $225,000 that's certainly a very good risk for the school district where you take that alternate and say okay you find it it's yours if they came back and said it was $200,000 not so much a good alternate to take you you at that point the district would take the risk I think and say if you find something extra Beyond what's
097in contract we'll pay you for it so it really comes down to on bid day what that number is but basically classified we own anything beyond the specs unclassified they own it all um number two was to do a what's called a brock fill on the fields um that is more of a wood grain fill in lie of the rubber and sand and it's it's something that's deemed more environmentally friendly um so we want to get a price for that so on bid day the school district can make a determination on if some that's something that's of value to them alternate number three um typically you get an 8-year warranty with the turf field we're asking them to give us a price to make it a 10-year warranty get two extra years warranty out of
098that alternate number four is the logo at the center of field one um I have it as an ad can certainly make it a deduct if you want to but the the soccer field um would not have the logo and then this is an ad to add that logo to the center of the soccer field and the purpose for that is I think you're using that for soccer field hockey and everything it just gives the the students and the athletes and the parents that come to watch the the games just a sense of Pride that you know that low goes there but see what the price is on bidday and we can make a determination and then alternate number 5A I have 5 a b c and d 5A is to deduct field number one
099from the the bid package so we'll get a number from the contractors and say this is how much you'll save if you don't do field one and then alternate numbers 5B 5 C and 5D really mimic the first three bids but it's just for the stadium so if we're not doing Fe field one we want to take out the price to deem the site unclassified so we just want unclassified for the stadium um we would just want the warranty for the stadium or we would just want the Brock fill for the stadium so that's what those alternates are should you choose to not do 5A so if you select 5A you would be selecting 5B 5C and 5D as well because you're just taking everything that has anything to do with field one out of
100the bid packages that point did I explain that okay great so looking at the prices um this hasn't changed from what was submitted before um you have your base bid and soft cost so it's a total package of about $7.2 million including escalation for the summer 26 we're looking at about 7.5 million um we have a deduct alternate for the the field one that's a ballpark 2.5 to maybe three depending on what the contractors do so that that's a range right now um so without field one we're looking at about $5 million four and a half to5 million um to do the stadium field and then looking at the schedule oops sorry um started designed in December um right now we have everything submitted to the Burks County Conservation District and to the municipality so
101we are working through the approval process to get permits um I would anticipate bidding September October is once we know we have permits and we're good to go um don't recommend going to bid before we have permits because if there's something that needs to be added through the approval process we don't want to deal with with those things after you have contracts plus we can't do any work without permits so it just it's just good good practice to wait until we have permits to go out for bid so we can make sure everything's included in the bid appropriately um that would give the contractors um time to start procuring materials and then I have on the schedule here April through September for doing the work obviously we we don't need that much time to do
102do turf fields but I have that in there because I want to work with your facilities group your Administration and your athletic department to make sure we're not impacting spring and summer activities on those two Fields um thinking through this you know if field one stays in the project we could obviously start with field one um we could start redoing the work for the shotput in The discus areas and the other area that we're looking at with the the school district and then once the track and field events for the spring are completed we could move into the stadium and and do that work so we're working through that again we'll make sure everything's coordinated with your Administration athletic and Facilities to minimize that impact as much as we can any questions on the turf
103good yes I have lots of them first of all field one which is behind that home which has been a nightmare for those people that live there and not having proper netting and there were supposed to be proper netting from beforehand and yet they're getting all kinds of field hockey balls all over their yard hitting their homes uh it's not safe for them to be at in the yard so what are we going to do there so netting at that field is included netting is going to be properly done this time not like the last time I don't know what was decided last time so what they didn't do last I didn't say they did I didn't say they did but I want to make sure that that netting is going to be proper this
104time if I Rec four people cannot be out in their yard if I recall ridiculous if I recall correctly it's either 20 or 30 feet high behind the goals and it wraps around the sides a little bit so if there's something that might shoot off to the side that's also captured I don't remember if it's 20 or 30 ft high but it it's it's high and it has to be expanding enough around their homes that they don't get hit anymore well like I said it it goes across the back of the the field where where the goals are and then it also wraps up the both sides of the field it doesn't wrap the entire field but both endzones I call them endzones there's not football but have you been down there and looked at
105that house I haven't looked at the house but I've been down there yes and that's why we're adding The netting to to to address that thing because we were supposed to have netting before and unfortunately somebody said they ran out of funds and never got it finished well nutting is included in the bit Mr she you know what I'm talking about because we've been down there nting is included in the bid okay um uh where's the cost of the equipment to maintain the field so that is also included in the base bid so we have the contractor for the turf manufacturer providing grooming equipment as well and there's also in the bid that the manufacturer and contractor are to provide impact tests through the length of the warranty and to address whatever needs to be
106done with the field um should something need to be done to make sure that impact testing is properly addressed I didn't see anything in here mentioned that that equipment that we need to maintain it is is included it it wasn't on the slide but it's included in the bid well I need to make sure of that well I can guarantee you it is uh where's the cost of the permits that's in the soft cost so soft costs are permits contingency fees things like that and cost for the shotput and the disc is to be moved and relocated that's going to be in the the contractor's bid price okay I don't see it listed either so that's another question so in the base bid of 5.6 million that's in there and then on the slide four
107where I list stuff included in the bid under Stadium Field I say relocation of shot put in discus throw all right I'm sure I'll have more questions as I go on and do my research thank you thank you yes should we even consider not doing field one with all the sports we want to play I don't want to see us put a field out there and half the kids can't play on it that's did you talk to the athletic director about that how much uh he would need would he need the two Fields we've had conversations with the administration athletic department and the facilities Department um so again making that an alternate bid that's something that the school district can decide on bid day if that's a value that they well that didn't answer my
108question but uh well whether it should be part of the bid or not is not no but I'm talking about the the usage I don't want to put a field in for a couple million dollars and then have the children can't play Mr Paladino can you speak to that just a little bit to try to answer that question for Mr daral when option number one is for is for both Fields if if you're asking me the athletic department our recommendation it would be to have the stadium and field number one both done that would give us the most opportunity for all of our students to be on there at the same time will it be more difficult if we only have one field it'll be it'll be very difficult if we only have one field
109but we were asked to give number of options to the board so that's where we're just bringing everything forward for then the board to make the decision on given our recommendation on what what we're going to do did you just say option one is for both Fields that's the the actual is it the base that's base bid is for field one and the stadium both together and then he talked about a deduct like deducting field one then that would be the cost of if we took that one away well if you take that one away is that going to influence Title 9 it will be it'll be more of we will make it so it's all Equitable but it'll be extremely difficult for everybody to get on there when they need to get on there
110so that being the case why are we even putting it in there as an alternate yeah because we were asked just kidding ourselves we were just asked last year to just bring everything for we want to be just just bring it all forward to say I didn't want to say I'm hiding something from you so that's that's the only reason no we're not saying that but let's be real about this stuff no that's why on the base bid we ask out we gonna have to have both fields we asked for the base bid to be both Fields because that's that's my recommendation is for both oh yeah did you do you have anything in mind on the manufacturer for the fields is there somebody that yes so we did speak with again your athletic department
111and your facilities Department the the two that will be using it and maintaining it um we have I believe four four con four manufacturers listed who they are I don't have off the top of my head I might be able to name two or three of them but I probably don't have all four off the top of my head you know it's it's field Turf astro turf Shaw and Sprint Turf so they're all listed in the bid and the contractor will base his bid on whichever vendor he gets good pricing from but you would know on bidday who your vendor will ultimately be and they all all four of them have the 8 to 10 year uh for your push for the 10-e warrant yes they do they all offer traditionally as Chris said an
1128-year warranty and we see what the pricing is commonly to go to uh 10 years they're all a comparable Turf product should be over at the mic you want me to do that yeah that' be good thank you Mrs please turn your mic off no great so I'll just repeat um for the microphone um the at least the four vendors are field turf asttr turf Sprint Turf and Shaw all excellent uh manufacturers of turf products they're in all of your neighboring districts here in eastern Pennsylvania so we've we have no um allegiance to to any particular vendor or manufacturer so it would be an open competitive um bid process um and uh you would learn on bid day who the vendor is that the contractor is going to be working with so that's how we
113keep it open competitive and then let you know just like the alternates on bid day now is is the subur underneath the the U Turf is that um do you have a standard for that not that we get a good top but then the bottom is uh different uh both top and bottom want to be excellent so the way that the the subgrade is constructed is first on both Fields there's storm water management so the storm water that drains through the turf and hits the underd drains and goes into the storm water system is held in a basin commonly that's underneath the field and it either holds the water and releases it slowly into the municipal system or it allows it to infiltrate into the ground you've got a lot of shale here so infiltration
114is probably a little low above that Basin is the pad on which the turf sits and it's constructed of a very special stone that is highly draining so we want everything to go through the turf through the pad into the under drains there's a specification for that stone subgrade and it's a mix of fine and coarse and there's actually a specification for the the infiltration rate through that stone pad and what we do during construction is we have the contractor construct a demo of the stone pad and do an infiltration test with a thirdparty testing agent to prove to everyone involved that the subsurface is meeting the specifications that we create does that answer your question yes there stuff that goes through now is that is that going into a retention Pond or you talking
115about into the U sewer system so the the uh storm water that goes through the turf through the stone ends up in a underground storm water basin like a retention Pond all right and it's held there so we have to hold on to volume and release it at the right rate and it goes into the municipal storm water system at the prescribed rate so that's approved by not only the Soil Conservation District but your local municipality and then there's also like I said infiltration so then it infiltrates below the storm water basin into the ground and so that's the measure and that's what's submitted in the municipal and the Conservation District permits how we've calculated the storm water system for each field thank you okay stay there I'm sure there's one of those the material
116for the turf that's better than another and maybe you're allowed to tell us that but you could write to us I don't want to I don't want to spend this money and use material that's not up to grade or that it's like if you buy a Chevy or Cadillac type thing I mean I house to explain it so that's a great question is the quality of of the turf so um what we want to do first is make sure that the surface is safe for athletes and so that's the primary focus all of the products that are specified the manufacturers that I just mentioned they're meeting the same specification Chris has worked with your team to understand the blade height the the amount of infill the backing and so all of these products while they
117all have their own little bells and whistles are comparable now they're also appropriate for the K to2 environment for p PIAA competition play We're Not Over specifying and providing something that you might see at your SEC college game nor we doing something that is just simply putting a a rug down on the surface it's something that's specific to the K to2 environment the same field that you'll have you will see it at numerous neighboring districts and um and they're tried and true none of these products will be the first time that you see it installed you'll know from a neighboring District that has the same product how it performs okay is there any way we can do a drill test on the ground before we would decide if we want it to have it unclassified
118or classified uh so some of that work has been done in the form of the geotechnical investigation for the site so field one for instance is uh underlane with Shale what we know is that we're going to have to rip Shale as a part of that project and Shale is considered rippable it's not considered Rock so we've done some of that work already in order to understand what the nature is of that soil but we'll also say we'll see as Chris mentioned based on the alternate that the contractors agree with what we've seen and so you'll know on bidday what they think of how hard that Shale is okay and then I was looking but I would I would rather just do the two Fields but I was looking at the alternate uh if we
119took out field one uh two and a half million uh but we're still having a million point6 in soft cost I think that's a lot if you only do the one field I mean how do you justify 45 4,000 you got that one 4,500,000 for the cost and still have the soft cost of 1.6 million well again that soft cost is a very broad brush it includes the permitting process right so right now we're permitting for two Fields well we got a lot of permits already didn't we we're in the the process of getting the municipality and the Burks County Conservation District it includes the fees for design your designing two Fields so a lot of the soft costs involved are tied to both Fields okay so you're now doing a separate cost to design
120that's all getting thrown in the soft cost our design fee is to do two Fields so yeah the design we're designing two fields for you um come bid if you choose to not build field one we've still done the design work that's what I mean it's to me it's silly to even consider not doing it CU you're just blowing in money that you're you're takeing the district is taking a gamble are we going to do it or aren't we so we're spending all this money why would you do that if you're not going to get bir Fields done I'm not asking you I'm just making a statement but okay thank you yep I would like to see two Fields but my understanding was that if we were only going to do one that the priority
121would be field one and not the stadium that's that's the athletic Department's recommendation and we and we talked about that as Administration Nick can speak a little bit more to it um most of which is the accessibility pieces that the stadium offers um and the ability to host everything there um along with a lot of the Ada compliances that already exist exist the restrooms that exist the services and and and things of that nature that exist there to be able to offer that playing surface for all and as well as yeah thank you as well as already existing lighting so it makes a longer time period to be able to both practice and compete um when we looked at scheduling and and how many sports um could take place from 3:00 to essentially 10:00 in
122the evening comparable to you know we start to lose that light in later October and we really start to run into where that existence um yeah so I don't know Mr paladan do you have anything to add to that another reason we we decided not to go with field one as the the primary if we decided to put lights down there now that brings up a whole different animal for a game management standpoint where now we have to do additional fencing we have to fence not just the field in but the the area of Spectators because with the new lights when they put the new lights up the spill rate is extremely low so it's your field is lit and it's almost a wall of black outside of that you can't really see too much
123out of it and it would be a it would be a game management nightmare to have 500 people down there and you don't know where they're at are they going on other people's properties are they running around around on other fields are they going running in retention basins we have porta potties down there that you wouldn't be able to see in there's not additional uh lighting down there so not like Memorial Stadium is fenced in Bear Stadium is fenced in softball stadium is fenced in everybody when they're when they come to a game they're in that area with an open field we don't have that so we looked at to be able to do all that now we're building instead of just a field we're building a mini stadium so we chose to use what
124we already had and make the Memorial Stadium option one cuz we can get more out of it because we already have a lot of those those facilities down there yeah it'll probably come back to you okay um okay you said about lighting in that for field one are we doing any lighting down there no no like are we doing a parking lot down there an additional parking lot no what about handicapped accessible for those people that want to go there there is that I can I can speak on between the the the endline of field one and Bear Stadium there is a there is an ADA parking lot there and that's where on the one end of the drawing he showed there was a walking path an 80 accessible path going from that lot up
125into the the the area where Spectators would sit at field one okay thank you Mr Palo um I would would imagine you've kept in touch too with the band so this all handle the band stuff because of the cavalcade and yes if if if we only had say field number one done we didn't choose to put football lines on that field because there's a lot of lines on there already um and if they want to host cavalcade they need to do it in the stadium because of the seating it wouldn't be even if we had football lines down on field one it wouldn't work out very well for them because there's no there's not enough spectator seeing for a big event like that so we chose to do it uh put it up in the
126state in that way they they're they're part of the mix they're on the schedule it's accessible not only to my athletic department but to all of our students who are involved in any activity so my question is about the uh the Brockville um that's the more organic healthier version right of what goes into the turf field the Brockville correct and that would cost more though opposed to the bid that we have what we see as far as estimating yes it's it's it's an increas in cost um but we would want to see what that number is on bid day and if it's something reasonable and something the board would want to pursue certainly it's your right I couldn't imagine doing it without that um everyone seems to be a bit concerned about you know the
127toxicity whether it's proven or not or whatever you know I can agree that if we have a safer alternative we should probably go with that alternative and I want to thank you for mentioning the band everybody forgets about the band not here I [Laughter] did where you g where are you going to put the shop put and discus throw field or space or whatever it's called so if you could help me with the field names it it's it's down across from field one across the road from field one we can check that out if you're if you're in if you're in the softball stadium above right field there's a field right above it we call it field number six it's like a practice lacrosse field the shot put discus and Javelin areas are going to
128move up there the reason we chose that area is because it was the closest to the stadium so for practices and meets it's not that far of a walk for those people who are in those events the other area would have been down down here behind Bear Stadium but we're looking at triple the the distance for the kids and I I felt with with coaches and kids going down there there would be times when they you wouldn't be able to see them so we like them we W them up on that area plus that field dries nice it's an open area we can throw Javelin on it we can fit The discus cages and the shop putut area all up there so what are we losing using that the only thing we really be losing
129is some Corner space because where they're going to put the shop put in The discus they're they have to put concrete pads down Javelin is just lines on the ground they're just pain what what was on that field before it was just a practice field for lacrosse it was an additional practice field we have a game field and a practice field it could continue as a practice field and yeah it would still it could still be used as a practice field just not when they're out throwing discus or Javelin um so you intend to still use it yes okay thank you okay and it might come back to you again uh on the bid that I looked at over the weekend before we got this one tonight it said about a practice field and it
130was the same price as here and now I notice the practice fields not on here the same we we call it field one now so that field one is what was looked at as far as practice field so it's field one and I think field one was on here too but I'm not sure I left my copy of that at home sorry they're one and the same so it's field one in stadium is where the work occurs Miss di you referring to that smaller Third Field yeah that was on something I believe that was always just a suggestion and was never really quite a part it was on here and it was the same amount out yeah I think there was the the two words were used interchangeably and was something that we asked um
131uh cha to change um with regard to that because I saw that in there as well so the practice field and field one were kind of used interchangeably we're we're identifying it as field one so that stadium is is is the one field field one is the other I'll look at that when I go home okay sorry I'm just wondering why do we need to have that one back end zone turfed to actually to even bother to move the shot put so it comes down to maintenance and um use of the field with the runoff now the other DD area is already um rubber it it matches the uh running track so we're not looking at changing that one but the one be on the other end of the field um with runoff with the
132end zone and maintenance for the the facilities Department it's just easier to deal with if it's Turf you're not running lawn mowers across the to mow a small area and often times I've I've I've been witnessed to this uh when you you have those situations see where grass clippings and seedlings and so forth they actually then start to grow in the track so so we we do get you have those complications to it um on this picture you have the gray area as Turf the white area on the picture is what so in the stadium that white area is the same material as your running track I called it rubber okay but there's white down here at the one end that's what he's talking about that's going to be the same material as a running
133track it already is it's it already is yeah okay thank you all right so with that we shall move on to the elementary school uh that wasn't hard but that's not a challenge [Laughter] either all right so what I'm presenting tonight is really a refresher a reminder of what we we talked about last time and then with um along with the recommendations on how to proceed with Boyertown elementary school so if you remember we looked at basically four different options we did have a Fifth Fifth being just maintain what you already have um so option one and option two we're looking at um vrfs with the doas so that's a variable refrigerant um flow so what you see on the roof to the right is that unit that provides um um heat source to what
134are called ceiling cassettes and then the unit that's on the left part of the roof is a doas unit and that provides fresh air and humidification so one option of this system was to go all electric um option two was basically the same design but for the doas unit we would be looking at going with gas versus electric for your fuel source option three was looking at a four pipe VAV system with a central heating and cooling plant um to do this one you would really want to consider doing the entire building um not something we think is really needed um it's not our recommendation because you have equipment in this building that's less than 5 years old so we really don't want to replace equipment that's that's new um and then option four was
135to go with a package unit ventilator um it would operate simil similarly to what you have in your classrooms now and then um option five again what we looked at was just repairing the continue to repair the units you have the problem with that is the age of them and parts are becoming very difficult to find um also the the refrigerant is is becoming difficult to to deal with as well because that's being upgraded um consistently um with the elementary school when we came in here last time we were asked to consider looking at an expanded Scope when we first went in so we started looking at the big box spaces um so we're looking at upgrading the heat pump in the multi-purpose room um upgrading the heating ventilation unit for the locker room dealing
136with the library mechanical room upgrading the or replacing I should say the makeup air unit in the kitchen and then also with this equipment is new ATC controls automatic temperature controls um and then um insulating some of the supply duct and and that's scheduled to remain in the multi-purpose room along with that we looked at some electrical system items now if you remember when we first came in we talked about the generator and the Transformer those were included in the estimate um with the first go around so now we're looking at upgrading some of the panels and the the feeders in the building that would be for the entire building and we're also looking at life safety and upgrading the fire alarm system um within the school um again just some pictures of the switchboard
137um these these would be replaced um the generator again would be be replaced we'd bring in a one that's sized larger and the generator would go outside um so looking at what would be recommended for this Elementary School would be the vrf with doas with a natural gas um feed um we think that is your best Energy savings um what we would recommend is the gas feed that comes to the school we would work with your facilities department and size that appropriately for future needs in the school um whether that's the water heater whether that's kitchen equipment whatever the facilities Department says down the road we would like this to be gas and no longer electric um so that feed to the building would be sized and then we could actually you could actually do
138that work and have the proper service to the building for future needs looking at the roof again we looked at four um systems here A T just a question I'm sorry I was looking at the slide not looking at my audience what about the the kitchen now you said about possibly upgrading that it what is what what's our life expect see there now do we have it 5 years 10 years our kitchen's electric now we just size the gas that if we would go to Gas Appliances which we don't use in what he's referring to is we would switch off from Electric to gas uh appliances currently we don't really use a lot of gas appliances in any of our kitchens but we would still size it so that if we would you'd have the
139ability to tie on in the future if you know different food preparation would be done in-house versus what we currently use okay what is the lifespan of what we have there now do we have it there like 10 years and we expect it to go another 10 the kitchen equipment it's a Mis mismatch of a bunch of different years I know the dishwasher there is probably four years old um ovens we don't use them very often I don't really know the original uh by date the steamer's old but that's electric so um and I don't know that we'd switch that to gas thank you yep and again bringing that gas feed to the building I don't think the price would change that much if you increase the size of the line from inch and a
140half to two inches or something like that we just want to make sure that if we're bringing natural gas to the building we want to be proactive and make sure that we think of everything that could possibly be on natural gas should you ever do the work in the future I just want to know what the light band was there already yes um natural gas versus propane you can't use propane you can use propane um typically we'll do that when natural gas is not available um to the school there is natural gas in the street right in front of the school I like Propane better uh the other thing is what's wrong with the fire alarm system that we have the fire alarm system is inspected and operational but it is out of date as
141in most of our elementary schools so where is that mean out of date out of date means that it should have been replaced probably 10 years ago um according to code if you want to file strict code every classroom should have an enunciator and a strobe which we currently don't have in any of our elementaries but we are looking at pricing to update our elementaries to include those life safety features so the the system was put in I believe in the 90s and that they don't service the parts anymore so if something goes like your power supply or one of the cards or even a board you can't get the parts and then we're in an emergency situation instead of a let's update it and do it in a timely manner so we don't want
142into I don't know many things that don't have aftermarket parts but that's okay thanks Simplex is a one that does not they are proprietary based and most fire alarm systems are and also we would be looking at updating the fire alarm system to tie in the mechanical equipment okay roofs um here we were looking at four different options a TPO an EPDM both of those are a single ply um Roof then we have builtup roof for mineral surface and flood coat and gravel both of those are two three layer of roofing and just the surface is different between the two um again we have some pictures of what the different system roofing systems look like um go through those quickly here so the recommendation working with your facilities Department was to go with a TPO
143roof our recommendation is to do TP but bid EPDM as an alternate bid um it doesn't involve more design or anything and it really keeps both manufacturers honest with their numbers that they know there's competition um we always want to make sure we build competition into the specs as best we can to get you the best price and the best value um for for your schools so putting all this together the HVAC and electrical systems are roughly 7.3 million the roofing system is roughly 5.1 now I do want to remind everyone that we do have 1.2 million within that Roofing number to address the maned um roof I don't think we'll need all that but I wanted to make sure that a budget that we present to you was all inclusive as best as we
144could I'm sorry you had a question so I'll stop could we know what it would be you're only uh bidding out a 20-year warranty we could do an alterate B to do a 25 year warranty or a 30- year warranty if we spend that much money how much more is it going to same thing we did with the turf field yep um so the sub total between those two systems is roughly 12.5 million soft cost is just under two we do have escalation in here because for this building it's almost 100,000 square fet and to do this work in the summer I'm hesitant to try and get that much work done in a span of 2 and 1 half 3 months so we're looking at splitting that up between the summer of 26 and the
145summer of 27 so we don't impact um the the functioning of what school is supposed to do so the total estimate all included is about 15.2 million and then as I mentioned with the schedule um you know if the board so chooses at their March meeting to move forward with this we would start the design bid September October around the same time we we be doing the turf um bids um approve things in November that gives the contractors um December through June to start precuring materials and equipment and then separate um the work into the two summers there so next steps um again we're looking at once we have permits and everything we would come back to the board for your authorization to proceed with the bid packages you'd have the numbers in front of
146you we're coordinating the timing of the construction phase with the administration facilities and athletic department and then with the Boyer Elementary School um if the board accepts the recommendation for the scope for the hbac in the roof um waiting for your authorization to proceed with the design and bidding of that project and thank you I was expecting no questions with expansion in the district and we're going roof um the air conditioning roofs uh on the roof we won't be able to go up a floor because we can't go out at Boyer to we can only go up but I don't know if that's a roof that we could actually go up on it it's not just the roof itself um the structure of the building is most likely not designed to accept a second floor
147floor so you would and and I I know this cuz I actually did this for an office building not a school but an office building um you would have to go through the existing building to put columns in to support a floor above it and it would basically be a separate building above the building you have um so it's really not feasible feasible to um look at putting a second floor on that one I do want to re say say this though I do recommend doing the HVAC and the roof together um I don't recommend doing one and then two three years later doing the other one because with the HVAC there will be new equipment on the roof so there will be new penetrations through that roof so I think really you do want
148to do the HVAC in the roof at the same time it's just really sad that it's not going to be done until 27 because I've been after this for a while now because of the poor Heating and that that some kids have been and having to wear coats over there and I pray to God nothing happens over there so I think and and we'd have to get into this once we start getting into the design of it um but the classroom mechanical equipment may be able to be done summer 26 the long lead items are really electrical things right now um switch gear generators and I'm sure everybody's paying attention to what's going on across the entire country with the floods in Carolinas now the floods in Kentucky and the fires in California all those
149things are going to have an impact on lead time for equipment so I don't want to promise you that we can get the work done in the summer of 26 knowing that those are the things outside of this area which will have a major impact on availability of equipment right now lead times aren't too bad with most of the products my concern is once they get going those lead times are going to extend but we have another year to go and it should have been being done this summer not next year but unfortunately can's been kicked down the road for so long yeah I guess there's no reality where it could start this summer right we get bids quickly and things move along or no it's going to take um 5 six months to get
150the design done um we're going to need to get into the school and really do some inspections um we're going to have to do that when kids aren't in the in the classrooms whether that's evenings weekends days that in service days where there's just teachers there and we can poke around and not interfere with them um so to till we try and get things we're going to be at summer and we just the lead time for even good lead times could be three months out so does that mean when you're poking and probbing that you might find other things that are wrong and it could be a different price again it's an existing building you always find something we have contingency built into that into that estimate so there's contingency built into the estimate to
151try and plan for the things that we just couldn't think of without opening up every ceiling or looking behind every wall so cons contingency could be even higher possibly it's always possible but again we try to plan for that we we planned an inflationary number we planed to have contingen design contingency for the for the things that we just don't know right now because we didn't dive into the Weeds on the design and that's all in this soft cost well I want to thank cha for their presentation and discussion this evening and Mr sheal um as well just to close this out a couple things to consider what we'll ask cha to do is come back once the uh bid packages are complete with the fields once the permits have all been issued um just
152to explain all the things that have occurred in in terms of those permits and and um alike and um and just to go back and U either confirm the the schedule that that that they have presented this evening with regard to that um prior to the bid process for Boyertown Elementary one of the things the board will need to consider to have cha move forward with the design phase if you so choose to move forward with the recommendations this evening would be to enter into a contract with regard to that I believe Mr Shi you've received that contract we could present that contract to you as a board at the uh Committee of the whole meeting um for you to review that contract thoroughly speak to that we'd certainly have Mr uh salanic and his
153team um also review that um for your then final consideration in March at the legislative meeting um and doing so and approving that would allow then uh ch to move forward like they said with probably four to five months of of of design phases um to kick that project off so just some things to consider um as we wrap these presentations up Mr up to grow yeah I have one more question on the elementary school you're going to use a bunch of different subcontractors on that project so we would have I think a minimum of two maybe three prime contractors we'd have a roofing contractor we'd have an HVAC contractor and we'd probably have an electrical contractor um as Prime contracts those Prime contracts may have subcontractors with them but those three contracts would have
154direct contracts with the school district are they reputable contractors then do you have I mean are there bonds we we have Bond requirements um I think we require A+ ratings on them them um they have to fill out a contractor questionnaire so we know their financials um but yes historically when we're involved I don't want to brag but historically when we're involved we get good contractors bidding it because they know how we work okay thank you thank you thank you publicon period number two miss you hi again I wasn't sure what you were going to talk about with policy 06 but I was very happy to hear the conversation about the Committees um what was proposed is very similar to what has happened the way they've operated up until about six years ago um about
155a year ago I did speak with Mr panell gave him that historical perspective I actually put together an email describing how the Committees did work um and I'll dig that up and share that with you guys but in a nutshell each committee had a chair or a co-chair as you do and they were assigned an administrative Le liaison and it was the role of the committee chair or co-chairs to work with that liaison to develop agendas and the calendar and I think the one thing we did a little differently than the way you described it Dr David Heiser was um those teams uh determined when they the the key times that they were expected to need meetings based on what was going on like the review of the program of studies for curriculum for example
156um rather than just being one two 3 4 1 two 3 4 but I think and any of that would work and I think all of that would be an improvement so thank you very much for that conversation board comment Mr upter grou yeah I made a comment that we I was having a meeting the following week after this meeting up there at the BCTC and that meeting was cancelled it'll be at the end of the month and I'll have a report after that but it would be for uh March then okay Miss nman yeah I do have a question in regards to the checks uh there was one for Weavers for 20 9474 for ice M for rock salt for six of our school buildings I thought we had if I'm correct Mrs denola
157an agreement with um cdale Township on salt Mr Shield can speak to that my understanding from Mr shei is that c Brookdale did not have um salt that they could Supply to us but Mr Shi could speak to that M Mr Shi can you come to the podium Mr nman can you just repeat that question for Mr Shi I can try Okay on Weavers for ice melt rock salt for six of our school buildings I thought we had an agreement with cobri Dale Township to get the salt from them we do we current we have two kinds of salt we have sidewalk salt which is what we usually purchase through Weavers and we have rock salt which is what we get through the township which is what we run in our big spreaders around the
158parking lots this year has been unprecedented as far as rock salt usage the township actually cut us off during one of our storms um and it's happening to every District who uses Township salt every uh manager or um facility uh facility manager I've talked to had the same issue um it's American rock salt had ran out basically and we were actually trying to get barges um to we were going to go down and buy it off of a barge we were lucky we found a land a landscaper nearby who was able to give us 22 tons which is how we've been getting by so yes we still do use cobd Township for our Rock Sal sidewalk salt we buy from wavers okay so I guess we use more than what we were expecting to so
159are we going to plan differently for next year we do not bulk water salt anymore because when we did it hardened in the bags so we basically go through the year and see how much we need and similar to you saw we ran out you know a quarter of the way through winter so we bought it it's usually not hard to get so instead of storing it in our buildings taking up storage space plus having the chance at moisture gets in it and we lose bags we just buy it as we need it instead of buying one giant bulk um order which we really don't save much on on rockol yeah M yeah it was mentioned a couple meetings back that there was fundraisers going on for the turf by one of our board members
160uh I just wondered how that was going what kind of money that that we have they have accumulated to this point if anybody knows you can't have a fundraiser without knowing what the cost is we haven't even agreed yet on doing the fun what are you laughing at okay so basically it's even the same thing yes you are you'll know what I'm my okay but there are groups that have been put together there has been a couple individuals that have wanted to go knock on businesses now I would not write a check right now because we don't know what the cost is so but also working with Donna and Mooney and Tracy there's money and there's significant money for the water flow so there'll be money coming for that so you keep saying that but
161let me ask you a question if I said we needed money Mrs deol could you write a check for $100 and you'd ask well what's it for well it's for possibly putting an ice hockey rank in would you write the check yeah would you okay for ice hockey I got some good stuff that I want to sell you then for ice hockey I would you said ice hockey don't change it don't change it now let's move it along guys the other thing uh I wanted to ask some of the schools that I've talked to had put in Turf and they had I don't know if it was a company or a person or somebody for naming rights pay for it have we looked at any of those sources uh yes we've investigated one opportunity which
162does not appear that it's um able to move forward necessarily quickly at this time so I just wanted to bring it out and the other thing was we had we received an email that there was a conflict with the board member so my question is what about the votes that were taken when the board member voted and possibly should have not been voted because of the conflict that could be looked at uh that would be something we'd have to you'd want to raise with your solicitor um to determine um the validity validity of of that I don't know any and speaking with him with regard to that so it would be something that um I think Mr panell would need to raise with Mr sultanic um to determine if there's any validity to okay to
163your question I believe we need to do that to assure there is no conflict so I would suspect that I would suspect that Mr P we'll talk to Mr shanic to find that out to to where we have to go review those I don't I don't believe there'll be any changes but we at least need to review them to show that we've have done that yes e thank you nothing else that Mr I have nothing to add okay that takes us down to the upcoming meetings uh we do have um a legislative meeting uh next Tuesday the 25th here at 700 p.m. m in the education center and then our committee of the whole meeting uh in March will be hosted at Washington Elementary School that will be uh take place at 700 p.m. I
164do want to make just one other comment tomorrow our strategic planning team uh meeting uh for those invitees uh we have about 120 folks that have been invited to come on out we did change the location of all the meetings uh we had a little bit of a scheduling conflict and we are going to host out of the West cafeteria so we've sent Communications out we've posted on social media about that change of location thank you to uh Mrs moer for for making sure that we've gotten it out I wanted to make an announcement to uh this evening just so who's listening uh in the public and also make sure that we send an invitation out again to all the board members we welcome you to be there tomorrow evening um as we uh start
165off on our first of five meetings for strategic planning okay and it'll begin at 6 clock at the Middle School West cafeteria is that where all of the meetings are going to be then we're we're going to shift all five to that to that location yeah we had struggled with the high school with a conflict and the library wouldn't necessarily be the greatest place for that we need a little bit more open space so instr we did we did yep thank you motion to adjourn Mee a Dr [Music]