CorpusRecord 147919

NHSD Board of Education Committee Meeting with Action - Feb. 6, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / North Hills School District
Date
2025-02-07
Location
Allegheny County, PA
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,580 words · about 48 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001you good good evening everybody I'd like to call the February 6 2025 North Hills Board of Education committee meeting with action to order please rise for a moment of silence and putot to the flag pledge allegiance to the flag the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liy and justice for all good evening everybody I'd like to announce that the board met an executive session on February 4th 2025 and also prior to this evening's meeting to discuss personnel and legal matters tonight's meeting is being recorded and broadcast live on North Hill School District's YouTube page images may be posted on District social media um we're coming to you from a different location tonight so I'd like to thank aw batty career center for hosting this

002meeting this evening we had a wonderful tour um before the meeting tonight and a chance to see all the amazing things that they're doing here and they also treated us to a wonderful dinner so I'd like to thank them and just one more announcement before I see if anybody else has anything to say uh there is no school for students on Monday February 17th this is is President's Day and on President's Day the district is again hosting a job fair from 3:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. in the North Hills Middle School LGI room representatives from all district departments and ABC Transit will be available for on-site interviews be sure to bring your resumé and check out our website nhsd.net for additional information are there any other board members with comments this evening Mr santui I

003just wanted to step back from the microphone a little bit uh wow you did it okay so nobody wants to hear Mr Stu's comment right wanted to wish the Jazz ensembles uh good luck for their upcoming Marty gr which is going to be next Saturday February 15th that's all since apparently the microphone do all you can eat pie right all you can eat pie don't miss it I don't believe anybody signed up for public comments this evening so we will move on to education and I have uh just a couple of very quick announcements uh the math task force has Creed two surveys one for parents and Guardians and one for current High School seniors to gauge perception of our math programs survey responses will be analyzed by the task force and used to strengthen

004our programs all parents of students in grades K through 12 are invited to take the survey which will be posted on our website tomorrow Friday February 7th and shared via our school newsletters responses are due no later than Friday February 21st seniors will also be taking their survey in school during that time and lastly kindergarten registration for the 2526 school year is now open online enrollment is open to students who Turn 5 years old prior to August 1st 2025 and live in Ross Township or the burough of Westview again please visit the district website at www. nhsd.net for complete details and now I'm very pleased to introduce Dr Nicole basilla and Gina frell uh who are here to discuss chapter 339 guidance plan you click okay all right good evening um we're here to talk

005about the chapter 339 plan to give you a little background and go over what it entails and what the purpose of it is um the 339 plan is a comprehensive school guidance plan that is required by the state of Pennsylvania for districts to submit every 5 years so typically we review this the board approves that um and we submit it through the comprehensive plan website the purpose is to help students develop academic social emotional and behavioral skills to prepare them for postsecondary Education as well as Workforce training and to explore different employment Pathways included in the plan is the counseling program's Mission the goals the curriculum and our system for delivering Services as well as portfolios strategies for engaging with local Career and Technical centers whoa it up sorry um the mission of the school

006counseling program is to provide services that address academic career and social emotional needs of each student to remove barriers to student progress and to also to empower them to maximize their personal potential to provide a caring and academically challenging environment that's accessible and Equitable to all and to support all students within the North Hill School District so they possess the Knowledge and Skills when they leave North Hills to be successful in today's society and I'm going to highlight um a few of the sections um specifically of the 339 plan um within the 339 plan that's required um again as a part of um the you know to be submitted with the Future Ready index um an individual student career plan is developed for every child K through 12 um the the um the plan aligns

007with career and education work standards um and it specifically addresses um curriculum um I'm going to jump down a little bit but um it goes through career awareness acquisition retention and Entrepreneurship um and um pretty much at the SEC middle and secondary level then that ties in a bit with vocational education training and so forth um and it really um it's supposed to be developed K through 12 and guide a student then into their SEC post-secondary Endeavors um the career curriculum um that we use specifically k through2 um for every child in our district is called smart futures um it is a um career Online Career planning uh and career portfolio um many many schools in the district offer um this specific program and um this program helps us specifically um Target the um Career

008Education work standards as well as the Readiness indicators um that are required through the PA Future Ready index um it and it also integrates Career Education again K through 12 um along with social and emotional learning for every child and each student in K through 12 develops a personalized educational career portfolio so that portfolio involves um six artifacts in every um in K through um five that we collect through their portfolios and smart Futures and then in Middle School another six artifacts and then in high school they required eight artifacts and those artifacts really um you know kind of coincide with again the career um awareness acquisition retention and Entrepreneurship um and two the last two two of them in high school really need to be um focused on what their postsecondary plan is like

009it it needs to be very um targeted um so we work through that the program goals within um the the overall 339 plan each of the levels of um school counselors in our district develop smart goals um that are a very um a general big idea but it's designed to um be tracked through data um we develop goals for academic career and then the social emotional growth of students um and to give you an example um we might Target um student attendance trying to um provide interventions to improve attendance in order to improve academic growth or something along those lines um as a part of the uh 339 plan every district is required to have an advisory I mean I'm sorry every counseling department is required to have an advisory Council uh we currently have

010an advisory Council that um involves about 35 to 40 participants and that includes people in the in the business um world parents administ ators Educators postsecondary institutions um and and a representative from Bay sits on there so we have a very nice core of um of um representatives for the um advisory Council we meet one time in the spring and um the uh the goal is to um have them advise and um review our counseling program and provide feedback to us um and then um yeah so it meets annual um so pretty much what um Nicole and I talked about is um just that the guidance plan is required by state law um it focuses on the career and future Readiness for all students it's directly linked to the um Future Ready PA index um

011and that measures how well schools are preparing students for college in their careers it incorporates the um you know career awareness exploration and so forth and then it um culminates in that career portfolio that is starts in kindergarten and is kind of handed to the students once they graduate um and as I mentioned with it being due every five years so we have the plan drafted for your review um today we're presenting just to give you that background information on it and then the plan will be on the agenda for March 6th um with the vote March 13th so that we can submit it on the 31st there any questions are there any major changes um from the last plan that we should keep an eye out for um no okay no not really I

012mean the the goals change every year for for us that I would say that would be the main thing that that shifts um in general our career goals kind of um remain because we are really working towards um you know implementing the curriculum that we have for students K through 12 um but other than that there hasn't been much of a a change now thanks any other questions thank you both so much we really appreciate your time next we have Dr Williams who I hope she's grabbing her water here to present the pssa and Keystone data review from the 23 to 24 school year welcome Dr Williams thank you good evening everyone so on I am here again to present the pssa and Keystone data from the 20203 2024 school year this will be a

013comprehensive presentation so that is my way of saying that I'm going to be very long- winded so I am apologizing in advance because I have a lot to go over with so I wanted to start out this year talking about the National Data Trends and I chose to do this deliberately because last week there was a story in the news that made national news regarding our scores in both math and Ela at the fourth grade level the 8th grade level and also obviously our data at the high school level as you can see I have just a sampling of the tons of stories that have been written about our academic data in this country I don't offer this data as an excuse or these stories as an excuse for what our data is North Hills

014School District data we take responsibility and own our data we know there is room for improvement we are willing to roll up our sleeves and we are willing to do that work however there's some background information that I think is very important when we look at this data first and foremost I think it's important to note that the basic Trend in the United States in both math and Ela is math it is either we flatlined right we're staying the same as to where we are we have been which has been a steady decline for the past 11 years or we're getting even lower Ela sadly is seeing a more significant dip which we have not seen a long long time in this country so the news is rather sobering if you look at it that

015way however I think there's some other things that you need to take into consideration with that when the pandemic hit a couple of years ago instruction changed tremendously not just the year of the pandemic but the subsequent year after that as such teaching and learning completely changed one of the things that all these stories and all the research is talking about nationally is that there was significant learning loss by our students that to me is a really really broad term so I think it's important to kind of drill down and really talk about what that means it's speaking specifically to a loss of foundational skills every curriculum has foundational skills but there is no curriculum that has more foundational skills than math right as you move up your academic career K through 12 the curriculum

016becomes more rigorous typically start in Middle School moving up through high school is where it becomes the most challenging those foundational skills right you're building the curriculum spirals you build upon that so if you have a weak Foundation obviously you're going to have some challenges in your difficulties as you're moving forward in math the other thing that I think is important to note that the researchers are talking about is there's been an increase in mental health among our students across this nation predominantly looking at anxiety and also depression which does affect how students learn there is also chronic absenteeism that took place during the pandemic and we are still fighting that in this country students are not coming to school for a variety of reasons some is school-based anxiety some of it is there's been

017learning loss very unpleasant to sit in a school all day long for 7 hours and feel like you don't really know what you're learning that you're really far behind and there's other reasons for that as well we continue to see the growing soci economic divide in this country among school districts we have school districts that cannot purchase curriculum that have classrooms with 40 students in it that have that do not have highly qualified teachers because we have a teaching shortage just the day-to-day functions of school in some of those districts are incredibly challenging let alone dealing with some of these other problems that I mentioning the last issue that the research talked about to me is one of the most interesting ones it's talking about a lack of resiliency in our students specifically math resiliency

018they interviewed students and basically asked them from middle school and up to high school kids and even some college kids talk to us about how you approach math problems on a standardized test there were three different answers number one it's real simple I look at the problem I know exactly what it's asking I can answer it just like that I'm good to go number two I look at the problem I think I know what it's asking I'm going to answer as much as I can I'm not going to get full credit but at least I'll get a couple of points number three the most popular answer with regard to math problems on standardized testing is if it looks difficult I skip it I just skip it because if I spend time on it I'm going

019to get angry I'm going to get frustrated I'm not going to be able to do anything else on the test so students are literally for lack of a better word skipping around tests looking for those problems that they can immediately answer and they know the answer to and then the ones hey look a little too challenging we're just skipping them again I offer this as background information not as excuses for the data I'm getting ready to present but I do think it's very very important so as always I'm going to start with our pssa data and I'm going to start with the elementary schools again North Hills data is indicated by the Red Bar State data is indicated by the gray as you can see our elementary schools continue to have very strong data we

020are averaging at least 20 percentage points above the state in every single content area so they're doing a nice job that's kudos to my elementary teachers and our students who are working really hard but I wanted to check those National Data Trends I wanted to see okay are we seeing any of those things that I just mentioned so I went back and I specifically compared our data in 2023 with 2024 to make sure that we're not seeing any significant problems or issues as you can see from this we are experiencing a slight drop in both math and Ela which statistically they will tell you that could be for a couple of different reasons that could be something as simple as this cohort of students do not test that well on standardized tests right some of

021them don't score as well with regard to that however we weren't content to say okay this is a very small slip instead we looked at this data through our K through 12 we have K through 12 monthly data team meetings with different grade level teachers and different content teachers and we really wanted to dig into that data we wanted to look at the big picture what are the standards that we're struggling on or anchors and what can we do about that did we have more snow days um do we need to review that do we need to change the so scope and sequencing what could be the problem for that but now we're taking it even a step further and we are really looking at each student's individual data because our goal is to identify

022root causes what is causing this student to not score as well as we think they should be scoring is there a lack of foundational skills did we miss some foundational skills do we need to remediate and retach is there a reading comprehension issue right we read fluently but not not every student can read what the question or problem is asking and understand what it's asking us to do again tying back to that National Data do students understand the math behind the math that's a standards of mathematical practice right why are we solving the problem the way we're solving it and can I pick out the right formula or right skill to solve this problem and it also looks at resiliency is that a problem or an issue for students is it test fatigue is it

023resiliency right we do all these multiple choice questions I get to the open-ended question and I'm just kind of tired and I'm going to just answer a little bit because I have some test fatigue so the elementary schools are doing a great job again our teachers and students working really hard and they are continuing to analyze that data so we can continue to move forward and offer our best next is the Middle School PSA data as well again North Hills is in the red the state is in the gray the middle school is averaging at least 14 percentage points above the state average I would be remiss if I did not say math continues to be our lowest score at 54.7% we own that score we know that we know we have to continue our

024work looking at math to do what we can do to continue to grow student achievement we know there is room for growth there however this next slide shows you that we are bucking the national Trends and Norms look at the data in 2023 versus 2024 and look at the growth in every single category at the middle school every single one including math which is a 6.3% increase that's a nice increase that's a nice showing in growth and I think that's attributed to a lot of different things that we really focused on at the Middle School teaching the curriculum with fideli reinforcing those foundational skills teaching the standards of mathematical practice right what is the why behind the math do you understand why you're choosing the formula you're choosing to solve this we did a great

025job the teachers did in the administrative team there did a great job of asking um all teachers not just our math our Ela and our science teachers to embed those skills in every single classroom so when you're going into a class we're helping students break down questions so they can understand what the question is asking right embedding those literacy skills in every classroom we embedded math skills in our teched classes our science classes to again reinforce those skills in doing that we offered professional development additional resources for our teachers because again while we want to support our students we can't forget our teachers in this process as well and last but not least I am so pleased with the opt outs I stood here a year and told you the prior year we had 200

026opt outs on the pssas we dropped down to 100 opt outs last year or the year before last year we had 13 opt outs at the middle school and that is because the teachers are telling the kids look we do this test every single day every single day we teach you what you need to know and there might be a problem on here you don't understand but it's okay you can find that resiliency that perseverance because that test is going to help us as your teachers learn more about what we need to do to support you next I wanted to go through the 2024 Advanced and proficient by grade level please note that only fourth and eighth grade have the science data because that's where the pssas were offered last year if you look at

027grades through three I'm sorry 3 through six you see it trending pretty strong right it's pretty steady across and then you start to look in seventh grade where you have 55.2 and you look in 8th grade which is 44.7 this becomes very interesting as well because in seventh grade we have a small group of students who take Algebra 1 in eighth grade we have more students that take Algebra 1 those students who take Algebra 1 in 7eventh and eth grade are required to take the end of course assessment which is the algebra 1 keyone they are also required to take the pssa test in seventh grade and 8th grade grade so we are asking students to learn basically two different curriculums when they're only in Algebra 1 so we teach all year all the algebra

0281 curriculum all the algebra one standards so they're ready to go they're prepared but yet we expect them to take a pssa where those skills don't translate it's not an even swap that's not how it works there's standards that don't intertwine and we're now asking teachers to teach a separate curriculum in a 40-minute period and make sure students are up to par for both of those tests that's pretty challenging and pretty difficult so we went a step further we just started talking to kids and parents and said talk to us about why you're doing so much better in the Middle School on the algebra 1 Keystone than you are in the pssas what is going on with that really simple middle school kids see that as a graduation requirement which it is right you have

029to have Proficiency in the keystones to meet a graduation requirement that's number one number two and more importantly how they do an algebra 1 is going to tell them or help determine what math class they can take the next year so again that's where they prioritize I'm much more comfortable Dr Williams with the AL one curriculum because I learned it all year from my teacher the math a yes I'm going to try but it's not a graduation requirement it's really not going to affect what math I take next year so again a less emphasis on the pssa for some of those students we also need to continue to look at foundational skills in both um sth and eth grade next I wanted to talk about our math open-ended questions if you remember last year I

030I did a comparison about the discrepancy about the open-end of questions for our Ela students who never left questions blank we never saw zeros from our Ela students and open Ed questions versus our middle school math students who could not leave them blank quickly enough right I'm not even going to look at it I'm not even going to try it I'm not even going to attempt it so we really wanted to take a look at that because that's 12 points on their test if you don't do well on the open-ended you are not going to do well on the pssa it is very very simple with regard to that so I wanted to show you the comparison between last year's math open-ended and this year's I want you to notice how much we have improved

031we have reduced the number of students that are taking zero points at every grade level more students are scoring one two three points again do we want them scoring three out of 12 no I want them scoring 12 out of 12 as do their Math teachers but the point is the fact that the middle school all the teachers were introducing open-ended questions in every content area and encouraging them to learn how to do those problems we are seeing growth are we where we need to be no but we're on the right path path and that I think is very important that we are seeing growth and that we are improving and we are on the right path do we still have work to do at the middle school absolutely we do and we know that

032but I am incredibly proud of the Middle School teachers in the middle school students for what they were able to achieve and accomplish last year next is the 2023 2024 Keystone data key ke stones are end of course assessments but are designed to evaluate a student's Proficiency in that content area the keystones can occur multiple times over someone's academic career in the sense that you can take a test in seventh grade maybe you don't take another one till 10th grade you can take those courses at different times so what the state has done is they Bank all of those scores and hold those scores and create a cohort and Bank the scores to the end of their junior year so when we look at cohort data tonight we're actually looking at our current seniors cohort

033data so just a reminder courses that are assessed by the keystones biology can be taken in either 9th or 10th grade English literature is taken in 10th Grade and algebra is taken in either 7th 8th 9th or 10th grade again that's why the scores are banked until their junior year so I thought it was important looking at that National Data and we know the pandemic affected how our instruction looked like and learning let's talk about their journey and what this looked like so again in 2019 2020 our students um our current seniors were in seventh grade and that's when we went into virtual instruction there were no keystones no standardized tests pssas that year anyone who was in an algebra 1 course simply received a p which means you passed if you completed Algebra 1

034successfully you got a pee we banked that score in 2020 2021 we came back but we still had virtual and hybrid instruction so we were allowed to give the um Keystone exams but we were not to use them for any evaluative purposes it was just hey take a look at where your students in at are at that's when our cohort would have been in eighth grade in Algebra 1 those students in 2122 we returned to in-person instruction and our cohort would have moved across the street to the high school and then in ninth grade they could have been taking either biology or Algebra 1 in 2022 to 2023 there was regular instruction the cohort could have been in 10th Grade they would have been taking Ela bio or Algebra 1 and then last year 2023

0352024 they would have been Juniors their scores would have been banked at the end of that year so when you look at this data again North Hills in the red the state in um the black color legure continues to be a strong score for us um 70.9 the students did very well with regard to that biology again getting stronger in biology so that was great the 53.5 but if you look at that 25.6 obviously that is not a score that we want to see right we want to see 90% 106% 25.6 is not the score that we want to necessarily see but I think what we have to do is wind back some things that I just spoke of last year I talked to you about the Middle School the mid-level math cliff and I

036talked to you about the fact that middle school is where the rubber meets the road it is where the curriculum becomes much more rigorous and it is where foundational skills are incredibly critical the content is differentiated for the first time you can take different levels of math and as such those foundational skills become the key because they're going to control your math trajectory in how you do whether you're going to be really successful or whether you're going to have challenges along the way our current seniors were in seventh and 8th grade taking math 7 math 8 during that time that those foundational skills were so critical so not only do we have that academic learning loss but we also have the other soft skills that we teach K through 12 every single day which is

037again that growth mindset right critical thinking it's okay to make mistakes resiliency how are we going to struggle through that study skills how do I study for a test what does that begin to look like so Algebra 1 obviously is an area that we need to continue to look at we need to continue to focus on and we need to continue to grow in um I think the other thing that is worth noting with regard to this is if you take a student's academic career K through 12 and you talk to them about some of those most important Milestones that they hit during that one of the most transitional times in a student's career is the jump from middle school to high school that is huge kindergarten huge transition transition to the middle school and

038then the transition to the high school so not only did we send these students across the street after having the pandemic for two formative critical years with foundational skills at the middle school but then we sent them across the street to the high school so a lot of things to look at again 25.6 we own it no one is um more irritated by that than my math teachers um they were not happy to see that school so we know we have some work however again I wanted to show you this this is not the cohort this is students who literally sat in the seat and took the test during 2023 and who sat in the seat and took the test during 2024 and again if you look at that we are bucking the national Trend

039we are growing in every single category every single one 7% growth and math alone again 28% is that where we want to be no but guess what it's showing me that we are on the right path and we are working hard and doing what we need to do do we need to do more more work yes we do we own that but again we are moving in the right direction so we will do whatever it takes to continue to help grow student achievement another factor I think that's very important to consider when you look at the keystones um are the five Keystone Pathways I think it's very important to think about this when the keystones were first introduced by the state it was you had to take test and you had to take it as

040many times as you could take it until you passed that then changed because the state realized that not every single student um can do their best on standardized testing right so they wanted to level the playing field you can know a lot about math just because you don't get a score in a standardized test doesn't mean you lack math knowledge it just means that's not the right form to show your skill set so the state decided to give five Keystone Pathways to level that playing field unfortunately a byproduct of doing that is it deemphasize the test very simply students and parents not just in North Hills but all around us because I talked to the assistant superintendents all around us talk about the fact that students know that they can meet proficiency which is what

041they need to for graduation requirement in a multitude of other ways that are more important and more meaningful some of just say look I'm not going to sweat it I'm not going to get test anxiety I'm not going to stress over this I'm really not looking for a math career or job that's going to be high-end math with regard to this so I'm going to meet this another way I'm more worryed Dr Williams about what my math teacher telling me because they see me every single day and they're going to tell me where my skill set is in math and they're going to guide me to the next best math class that I need to take so again the other thing that I found very interesting that we're seeing seeing um some of the data

042in the research SC particularly across the United States and in Pennsylvania has become a reality more and more students are saying yes I'll take the math I need to be successful postsecondary whether it's job or an education but more and more students all of them are saying what I want to be proficient and advanced in is financial literacy I want to know what my paycheck's going to look like I want to know about taxes I want to know about saving I want to know about investing I I want to know how I'm going to pay back my student loans I want to know how I'm going to survive as I move forward in life so I thought that was very interesting we now have a requirement to teach financial literacy here in the state of

043Pennsylvania but I thought that was very interesting so what does this mean with regard to the keystones we're still recovering right for some of that learning loss the loss of those foundational skills definitely some things that we need to address and improve upon but growth is occurring which means our data analysis looking for those specific reasons those core reasons as to what is going on um is helping us tremendously to make strides so how do we use data why is this even important why am I standing here talking about this we use it in three specific ways number one we use it to evaluate our curriculum to really talk about again what standards do we need to look at more care carefully how did the kids test why did they test that way did we

044cover it too quickly do we need to add more time how can we adjust our scope and sequence maybe we need to teach this in a different order so it will build upon itself better are the students being prepared for the rigor of the next level meaning are we teaching the curriculum with Fidelity are we teaching them homework are we teaching them how to do study skills what are we doing to level the playing field so every student is having that experience and also important again we can't forget our teachers what professional development do they need in order to be successful it also contributes to the overall evaluation of student placement and this is something that is a topic that I actually had to bring Mrs Kimmer blesy or high school math curriculum leader to

045speak about we use data to make sure students are placed in classes correctly if you talk to or look at any research from the National Council of math matics teachers they are very clear on the need to have strong foundational skills to move into algebra one you have to have those skills so again we need to make sure students are prepared and ready so they can go to Algebra 1 and meet success yes they're going to see rigor yes they're going to be challenged but it should not be um a painful experience because they don't have the correct foundational skills to be successful so we do have a small group of students who take algebra one in seventh grade we do have some students that take it in in e8th grade but the vast majority

046of the National Council of mathematic teachers is saying everybody hold off ninth grade is the best time to take Algebra 1 unless you are advanced in those skills in order for you to be successful so last year as a result of our data we really talked about okay our concerns about how we could continue to improve our math achievement scores and so we decided to create a math task force which is has um curriculum leaders teachers the Board of Education um education liaison on their principles and we work collaboratively to sit down and really identify ways that we can continue to improve such as the math pass Force survey right we're soliciting feedback from students and parents we want to know what you're thinking so we can take a look at it that's very important

047to us I think another point that we sometimes Miss is the math task force is designed to control the things we can control meaning I can't control that eighth graders if you're in Algebra 1 you have to take the algebra 1 Keystone you have to take the eighth grade math pssa you have to take the eighth grade science pssa and you have to take the eighth grade ELA PSA all within a matter of a couple of weeks I can't control that I can't control that the state made five Keystone Pathways that have DM emphasize the value of that test there's some good in that but it's also deemphasized the value of that test because students are able to meet it in other ways I can't control that what I can control is we can talk

048about our curriculum offerings and our prerequisites out of the math task force and talking with Math teachers and even parents and students from last year we talked a lot about making sure that we had enough math offerings at the high school because you have to acrw three credits in order to meet our graduation requirements and one of the things we looked at is we have a lot of CHS and AP classes there one of the classes we have is CHS statistics it's offered for half a year there was interest from parents and students in even the task force in exploring whether or not we could offer it for a half year and could we offer a CHS statistics class for a full year to meet the needs of our students and guess what we can

049it's in the program of studies this year and we are doing that again with prerequisites designed to support students and make sure they're in the right math class we can also control the professional development and support that we offer our teachers what resources do they need what professional development can we give to them we can also continue to work at offering tutoring to our students we do have some tutoring that's available online we also have face-to-face tutoring at the high school albeit not for the entire day so that's something we want to continue to look at and then again we will continue to look for root causes through our data analysis and look for root causes by soliciting that feedback that's why that mass task force survey we take that very seriously so please make

050sure you fill it out so last but not least I started this presentation by talking to you about a big picture right trying to give you enough information so you could see everything and be able to have some background information last year I stood before you and I presented some data that was challenging data where we had to acknowledge that we had room for growth and in that I didn't have a lot of opportunities to show you how we were growing in a year but what I wanted to do was I wanted to show you that that group of students that I spoke right the Keystone data last year where were our seniors what was their math experience all those scores I wanted to show you some accolades based upon last year's senior class so

051we understand that yes these tests are important right we look at how we can change we want to increase student achievement we as teachers want to continue to grow and develop but I think it's important to put into perspective sometimes that one test is not everything that encompasses a child's educational career so I wanted to show you what a few I could have been up here for 40 more slides if I would have printed everything on here put everything on here about last year seniors but I thought you might want to go home sometime this evening so I'm going to go ahead and I'm going to show you a couple of slides I'm not going to read them because you can read and I can actually take a drink of water cuz I'm very thirsty

052and this data discussion is making me very hot so I'm going to take my sweater off as well so here's the first slot and here's the second one so what I want to say is is there room for improvement yes do we own our data yes are we willing to continue to roll up our sleeves and work hard absolutely you will be hardpressed to find more dedicated teachers than you have K through 12 in this school district I want to say thank you to the students for all their hard work I want to thank our teachers for their continued efforts I also want to thank the math task force because we've spent a lot of time looking at this information and this data and I want to thank the board for giving me the time

053to speak about this topic tonight do you have any questions for me I just wanted to make a comment number one thank you for going through all the data um you you mentioned and I and I appreciate that we have to own this right are we at where we want to be no correct are the numbers trending in the right way yes but I'm especially grateful that you added those last two slides I remember Mr sanoi referring to this maybe about a year ago um our kids are more than just a score on a test and uh we have to remember that right and that right there shows the achievement of regardless of whatever that test score is that they've been successful and they're going out in society being productive and that's really important too

054thank you I appreciate that comment I actually mentioned to Mrs Ren back when we were um touring batty tonight when you stop and think about this stuff and you might see some students who come here to batty and we heard all these wonderful things about the students tonight are going out they're in great careers they're doing great things they're starting their own businesses upon graduating from batty they probably know more math than a lot of us in this room because of what they do here we saw a display where they had to do an action re research project which is Ela which is English and defend that and present that all of those skills so again I think it's very impressive when you think of it that way and it does it can be very

055sobering and very daunting when you see those numbers when you see 28% you know you get it's like oh my goodness what's going on so I wanted to try and put it into perspective again we own it we know we have room to grow but there's a big picture as well yeah I okay sorry I have a question about our students that are taking algebra and geometry in middle school and that impact the pssa and Keystone combination those are also the kids that Al have taken a math curriculum that optimizes them for the SATs later on because you want to have Algebra 2 ideally completed by the end of your sophomore year in order to maximize your score in the math section what kind of scores are we seeing out of that cohort on the

056SATs I know we have National Merit Scholars so we're clearly doing well but are we you know meeting exceeding among that cohort we are we are above the the state and the national norms for both the SATs and the acts in both areas both in English and in math I actually thought about putting that statistics it's on the back of every District calendar um I thought about putting that graphic on there but we are we are meeting those Norms because that was something that I wanted to look at as well um so we do take that seriously we're seeing a ton of kids go to college um and I think the other thing another piece to that speaking of the College Bound people that was something we really looked at at the math task force

057as well was looking at the requirements that are necessary for college because there are some colleges that say you only need three credits of math there are some colleges that say you need four credits of math another reason to look at our course offerings at the high school to make sure students can acove for credits because again if you are misplaced at the middle school let me be very clear on this if you are in the wrong math in the middle school it is the gift that keeps on giv it will chase you up through high school right you will continue to struggle and then it's like oh my gosh how do I find three credits how do I find four credits if I'm going to college so those are the things where we really

058pull back and look at what other districts are doing how they're offering their math courses and what does that look like to make sure exactly what you said Mr Stevens that we are maximizing the students potential that are moving the direction of the acts and SATs and need that we have an SAT prep course that is very heavily attended that we do that as well at the high school um that course is booked we could probably teach that at martarelli if we wanted to we have that many students that take it so we are trying to do everything that we possibly can to continue to maximize that potential any other questions for the um the cohort yes that the um that took the algebra test and I always have like I always have to think

059about this a lot how does that number factor in the kids that didn't have to take it right like that's that's the that's the trick right it's like there if you did um only the kids who were taking it the number would be different but correct and then you have to correct and then you have to factor out the students that received the P for the pass because they really didn't pass it because they were in there so that does factor into it as well and again you know I'm not sure if I mentioned this but the high school is starting to see an increase in opt outs because of there being different Pathways at the high school so you know we had that wonderful opt out situation at the middle school we have since

060graduated through that but they're starting to see that more and more at the high school because they've realized there's different Pathways in which they can achieve that so again I appreciate standardized testing and some of what it can tell us but it also is incredibly frustrating to me at times as well because I don't think it is the true Mark or true picture of who we are and what we do for kids and what our kids can do having said that again there is a math teacher in this District that is saying I want my scores higher than that there is not an Ela teacher in this District that's saying I know I can get some more points next year if I teach it this way they are professionals they want to do the best

061they can but it is very very tricky balancing all of those statistical measures into it yes okay thanks yep any other questions yes ma'am are our scores overall are the are the grades of the students in the classes reflective of these test scores yes some particularly noge one they are in other situations it depends some students do much better on summative or formative Assessments in the classroom than they were doing on standardized tests the amount of test anxiety that we have every single year particularly at the elementary and even now in the middle school is a lot higher than I've seen since I was in the in the building as a principal um it creat a lot of panic and anxiety because they feel like they can't do it and the resiliency piece to it

062so I think again we are getting better with that because we are teaching the curriculum with Fidelity we're teaching um the rigors of homework we're looking at our assessments we're really moving in particular at the middle school um trying to make sure we're on the same page across the levels right the vertical articulation in the horizontal articulation so again that is something that we look at that's another piece of data that we do look at what does it look like with your testing data on the standardized test versus your classroom scores we do look at that Dr Williams do you have any um insights into why you think it's just the math that the kids are opting out of and not the literature because if you look at that there's clearly a ton of kids

063taking the literature but not the math I think it is that math resiliency that's why that interested me so much I think because those skills spiral and build Ela literature and reading yes that's very very important but if you're at home and doing some things that those skill sets are a little bit different than if you are doing math where it builds upon each other and I think once those foundational skills start to drop it is very challenging to sit in a math class for 40 minutes and feel like you're really struggling with what that's going to be I think we are seeing that nationally I was blown away by the idea that kids literally look at a question if it's too hard they just don't do it and they even talk to college kids

064who they're saying now don't have the math skills that they should have and I hate to say this but they talk to middle-aged people like Dr Williams and they're saying that we don't have the math skills um that we're forgetting how to do things so yes is it frustrating absolutely it's frustrating um with regard to that but I think math in particular is the one that most people including me it creates more anxiety than Ela and literature does it just does I I don't know the answer to that but I think it is the spiraling of the skills thank you so much Dr William thank you all right I have one additional item under education this evening it's a request for the board to approve a $500 donation from SSB bank for the Ross Elementary

065PBIS PBIS program um SSB bank would like to donate $500 to Ross Elementary School's positive inter positive behavioral interventions and supports program which is an Evidence based tiered framework for supporting students behavioral academic social emotional and mental health when implemented with Fidelity pbus guides and supports social emotional confidence academic success and a positive School climate I move that item four be added to the legislative meeting agenda is there a second D Spade I'll second that thank you Mrs Spade any discussion all in favor I iOS motion carries Mr little you're up with Athletics and activities all right thank you madam president um just two notes before I go on to uh the the item up for consideration tonight number one uh the Athletics and activities board met uh earlier this week and I will be

066sending out a report tomorrow to all of you so check your inboxes for that secondly I want to go ahead and give a few congratulations to some teams and certain individuals um first off congrat ulations to the wrestling team who earned uh the AAA section six championship this is the first time that the team has ever won a section Championship so that's pretty exciting uh the boys basketball has clinged a birth in the wp Al playoffs for the fourth season in a row so there's consistency there and lastly the whii individual gymnastic championships are this Saturday at Moon high school and we will have five student athletes competing uh one Carissa ruckle and bols Presley menager in Vault and bars Paige hollenberger in allaround Laney Del Croy in Vault and Abby mccan and all around

067so good luck to all of them all right item up for consideration this evening is a donation of weit room equipment from op OS PTA this is a request that the board accept the donation of four different weight machines to be donated to the school district for from orthopedic and sports physical therapy Associates or otherwise known as ospa ospta is no longer using these machines in their office and offered them to us to use in the Middle School waight room the following items are being donated by them these are all cyx machines so a leg press machine hamstring curl leg SL knee extension machine and finally a cable column machine I moved that item two under Athletics and activities be added to the legislative meeting agenda is there a second D Spade I'll second that

068any discussion all in favor I opposed motion carries Mr sanui I'll hand it over to you for buildings and grounds okay so hopefully the microphone doesn't hate me still um so I typically don't like to read prepared statements but this one's pretty important and I wanted to make sure that we had everything that we wanted um to say so last year the North Hill School District conducted an audit of the usage of our district facilities we wanted to get a better sense of who is using our facilities outside of school time and how frequently they are used this includes our outdoor athletic facilities as well as our indoor areas such as auditoriums cafeterias the pool gymnasiums and classrooms what the administr ation found was significant and informative so I'm going to review our findings in

069a moment but first I'd like to lead with this after meeting with several local groups and listening to their concerns we are not ready to recommend any board action related to facility rentals as we audited our facility usage we discovered that our usage is high as you'd probably expect on an average year our facilities are used for 40,000 hours outside of the normal school day that 40,000 hour number includes use by our varsity and Middle School sports teams without the district sports teams that number is approximately half just over 20,000 hours used by a total of 153 different local community and youth groups of the non-district group usage about 14,000 hours or 70% is used by Youth Sports organizations STS so there's a lot of data there and looking at it we wanted to create

070a taxonomy of groups that use the facilities and we categorize them into separate tiers based on their affiliation with North Hills and also their tax status so tier one included all of our school sponsored clubs PTA PTO ptso School sponsored athletic boosters local Municipal service organizations and Scout Troops tier 2 included all five 1c3 community and Regional groups as well as youth sports groups not affiliated with the North Hill School District tier three included any outside individual or organization as well as 29 different dance schools competitions and or shows so with this many groups and again it's 153 reserving such a wide range of facilities we came across some areas of concern so just a few examples uh a few of our groups are using the facilities at no cost while also charging a fee

071for its use so essentially they are subletting our spaces from their reservation and profiting from it a local parochial school is using one of our facilities under the veil of one of our youth sports groups some groups are monopolizing spaces and reserving blocks of time out of Simplicity sake they are creating blanket reservations regardless of actual planned usage which then prevents other groups from actually accessing the facilities some of our local youth groups made equipment purchases without notifying anyone from the district the purchased equipment was then left on District property which created a potential for loss for both the youth group and the district so these issues are concerning for both our outdoor athletic facilities and our indoor areas over the past few years the district has made a considerable Financial investment towards the infrastructure

072of our outdoor Fields additionally when groups Reserve indoor spaces the district needs to ensure custodial staff is present to cover any added responsibilities so as a district of course we'd like to do a better job of structuring our facility reservations and managing the facility reservation system we began to consider next steps with the goal in mind to improve upon the current situation while still maintaining access to our community groups ultimately the district came up with the idea of a rental plan but wanted to do it in a way that was not cost- prohibitive to our booster and youth organizations so as I mentioned at the beginning of the of this statement after having conversations with the youth youth sports groups and listening to their concerns we are not yet ready to put forth a proposal

073on the agenda for consideration so that is my report and I'm now going to move to item number two on building and grounds this one is a request that the board approved uh the purchase and installation of four ceiling suspended back stops and key operated electric winches in the Middle School dungeon gym from National Equipment and facility Solutions uh currently only the two main back stops in the dungeon gym operate correctly the four side Court back stops uh don't operate and they're just falling into disrepair uh so they're permanently fixed State due to faulty control switches uh faulty cables and wiring so they cannot be raised or lowered as needed for events uh the inoperability of the side back stops interferes with extracurricular activities as well as some PE classes so considering the age of

074the equipment it is recommended to replace them uh with new rather than try to repair the existing back stops the two main back stops were uh replaced within the last 20 years and are still in good condition uh the current lead time on equipment is roughly 12 to 16 weeks replacement would not begin until summer of 2025 three quotes were obtained uh National Equipment and facility Solutions was the lowest of the three and is also a member of The coars Cooperative purchasing program uh the cost of the new back stops and winches is $39,500 which includes the removal of existing equipment and installation of the new hardware the cost of the equipment will be covered by the capital projects fund so I move that item number two under building and grounds be added to the

075legislative meeting agenda is there a second D Spade I'll second that thank you Mrs Spade any discussion yeah just for clarification do you may know this or not but when we're using the term back stop are we referring to the backboard yeah okay it's the whole system okay right any other discussion can I just make one clarifying Point um related to Mr sanu's comments he used the phrase We which I think is a really good statement we work together as a group and the district and the board work together but I do want to be clear because I was caught with some questions in the community and I was not prepared to answer them because the full board did not see any of the proposal necessarily that had gone out to everybody so if you

076ran into a board member and they couldn't answer your question it wasn't because we were being evasive or trying to avoid it it was because we all didn't have the information right away that was shared with everybody so I just think that's one important clarifying point that we doesn't necessarily represent every individual that sits up here tonight any other discussion all in favor I opposed motion carries thank you Mr sanci do you have anything under community and intergovernmental relations Mrs M uh no I don't just would mention that there was another culture and um climate council meeting I think it was about two weeks ago um and it was another nice meeting what I really enjoy about them is getting to hear from all the building principles they really are all doing really cool stuff

077in the the classrooms so that's my favorite part of them just hearing all the good stuff that North Hills does so um that's all I have thank you uh Mrs Elwood you're up with Finance yes thank you tonight I have a couple items for consideration for the legislative meeting agenda they include items 2 through six general fund bills Capital project fund bills Food Service fund bills budget transfers and payroll for the month of January 2025 and the amount of 3,728 15774 additionally there is one other item for consideration this evening and that would be that the board approves National Life Group is a 403b service provider there are currently 11 approved providers in the North Hill School District 403b plan recently a request was received for National life group to be added under the plan

078only authorized providers may receive ongoing contributions exchanges or transfers to qualify as an authorized provider National life group has agreed to share the information necessary for compliance purposes with the district the third party administrator and or with any other 403b providers as may be required Reed to facilitate compliance within the plan and all applicable laws and regulations further National life group is required to M maintain records of the funding vehicle offered under the plan to comply with information sharing requirements of the plan and applicable information of sharing agreements Voya the district's thirdparty administrator has confirmed National life group has the requisite information sharing agreement and demonstrated compliance approval by the board to add national life group as a 403 prb service provider would be not be interpreted as an endorsement of national life group Services

079District employees are encouraged to contact their financial representative or Tax Professionals in guidance in such matters so I move to have items 2 through 7 under Finance to be added to the legislative meeting agenda is there a second D Spade I'll second that thank you Mrs Spade any discussion all in favor I opposed motion carries Mrs Stevens do you have anything under health and wellness this evening uh the January 21st health and wellness committee meeting was cancelled due to a FID day that meeting will be rescheduled later in the month okay on to M and personel pardon me you're up for personnel okay Personnel items are discussed in executive session the superintendent recommends and I move that the board approve items 1 through 7 um I believe it's actually items two through four can you

080amend your motion items two two through four okay thank you is there a second so moveed all in favor I opposed motion carries uh Mrs renck do you have a report for us on AW B this I don't have a report believe it or not I know I know um but here we are and so uh sometimes I feel like the proud parent whenever I talk about batty because it's I've been able to be the liaison for batty for 5 years and um today I felt like the proud parent like go see all the amazing things so we appreciate that you guys came and it really means a lot that the board got to see what Mrs spade and I get to see and Dr meino on a regular basis when we come to these

081meetings um if your children are participating in batty they are certainly getting top-notch opportunities and uh just so proud of this school so that's really that's really all I have to say and next meeting I will talk more about culinary and the fact you can get your fish for fish fries here I W start are you can talk about it now I won't that's okay no because I forget the date Mrs told me March 5th March 5th know iath am I all right we don't have any other business items this evening so I'll announce that the next meeting of the Board of Education will be Thursday February 20th back at the North Hills Middle School LGI room at 6:15 p.m. and immediately following that meeting there will be a public budget meeting um following a

082brief recess so if you're interested in the public budget meeting please please uh make sure to attend that evening

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.