001that's the Pleasant Valley School District Board of Education meeting to order if you could all please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance and then please stay standing for a moment of silence and please keep our Pleasant Valley family in your thoughts and prayers um unfortunately we lost a staff member over a week ago at the middle school so please keep her family in your thoughts and prayers and um Mrs surface please keep her family in your thoughts and prayers this evening too she's going so her family's going through some things so Bernie could you please lead us in the pledge i al to of the United States of America to stands Nation God indivisible withy andice for all thank you everyone again I'd like to welcome everyone that's with us this evening and if we
002could have roll call please here here here pres here thank you I'd like to let everyone know this evening that we did have an executive session of course held today February the 13th of 2025 immediately prior to the regularly scheduled meeting for purposes of personnel matters including but not limited to Performance and or discipline negotiations and legal issues this evening we do have a presentation from Career and Technical Institute by our director and their business manager Dr verga I said it how about that and Mr Brook is with us this evening all right thank you for having us tonight I did promise uh m c this will be quick in s minutes minutes seven minutes too much so first and foremost I want to thank every single person in this room um you guys will
003see in a little bit and it's always seems like every time I come here your enrollment at MCT from Pleasant Valley is just as strong as it's ever been and that's thanks to the school board and your Administration sitting to my right um you guys just keep doing the good workful so I thank you for that so to make this quick uh I'm going to go get right into it um I share this slide every time I present the budget to every school board because we are a little unique uh as you guys know we're not a taxing entity we are funded primarily through the four districts in monmer County um Pleasant Valley obviously poken mountain straber and East straber and how it works it's a fouryear rolling average of ADM which is essentially a
004kind of fancy term for um that percentage uh of whatever that number is that's the percentage of the offering budget that the school district would be responsible for so you'll see Pleasant Valley a little over 21% please don't be alarmed by that Reddit it doesn't mean that your your enrollment is super strong which you'll see in a second it just means um your your budget share went down a little bit uh so overall that's that's kind of the number that you guys will be looking at at the conclusion as you'll see it's ultimately really good news for for the district and all of our districts because of the increase in vocational subsidy that are that Harrisburg keeps putting in current de so uh first enrollment very important so as everybody in this room knows Monro
005County as a whole in the last 10 years School District enrollment has gone down ours just keeps climing um so this year we're about just under 1,200 students uh good news and bad news uh the the good news the demand is so high that we had at the start of the year we had a weight list of over 500 students trying to get tcti um we ended right now with about 340 kids who did not get in that's bad new uh so obviously we're in the middle of our enrollment period right now we actually just met with Pleasant di last week and once again you guys took every one of your slots and some um of course that makes some for digal phone calls with parents and kinds counselors who were fighting for their for
006children so the demand is as high as ever uh overall is about 27% increase in 10 years but 18% increase in the last five so we just continue to grow um as as a school I try to show this to give you some perspective um this percentage if you look at all at all the students in Monro County grades 10 through 12 this is the percentage who attend mCP State average depending on who you ask is between 10 and 12% um we're over 177% um at mcti so overall we do very well and as you guys will see in a second Pleasant Valley uh is by far the largest percentage of any schools so you guys if you look at this if you look at your high school 10 through 12 um graders 24% of
007become so that is by far in a way the highest in the county um it has has historically been but you guys continue to to just grow and I will say that the kidy centers are just are excellent and for those you who attended skills USA um our district competition a lot of the skills from PB did very well so you'll see across the board every school district is doing well but I would be proud of that that chart if I was a Community member at Valley so right to the numbers so our budget isn't overly exciting as year that's why it's pretty quick um so our increase is about 3.92% increase so it's an even $400,000 and where that comes from um is a couple things what is the addition I know you guys
008have been getting your your updates on the addition we're putting on which is going very well um that alone is going to add some cost so maintenance custodia will cost about 17,000 square feet um we're going to be adding a second Auto Tech program which is a staff member of course uh so that alone is going to increase some costs also it's very important that you know that um contract increases uh impact MC directly our teachers don't negotiate salary it's a it's a weighted average of four districts so if a school district increases salary that increases our contractual so that was a big part of it Easter urg as you guys know had an increase last year um and that's that's where ours came from so that's pretty much where the additional cost come from
009savings as I always say it's it's it seems like every year we're losing somebody who's retiring and that's not changing we have some people been here for 30 years for retiring this year um which is a cost savings but I wouldn't trade that for what they they've given to the school so that's where we came in at but I will tell you that number just keep in mind like what I talked about the vocational subsidies is actually much lower for Pleasant Valley and actually all the schools when I explain what Harrisburg has done in the last five years or so so this is the breakdown for each school um so pleasant value guys are second one down so about 3.3% increase it's about 60 around $64,000 um you'll notice the green portion is capital I
010will briefly talk about our Capital fund which is in very healthy right now which is great including the addition but we're not asking for any Capital Money uh and actually when we get to our excess Revenue which you guys usually get the month after um we don't anticipate asking for that either so you'll be getting that that back as well so uh all good news coming back but that is the dollar amount to their Roberty budget that you guys are uh your increase shows but keep in mind what I said and I'll try to explain this as best I can uh without giv boring you guys too long and coming under that seven minute Mark um so vocational subsidy vocational subsidy is money that comes from the state so and actually the governor just presented
011his his state budget and you probably noticed he talked about current tead um and there's an increase there generally the increase that he's talking about is twofold is one is in Grants which is where we get a lot of our equipment um and the second one is something called vocational subsidy depending on what current tech school you you talk about um some schools keep that vocational subsidy at the CTC Center um where others send it back to the school districts mcti historically has sent the vocational subsidy back to the school districts that's what we have always done the good news is there has been a very large increase in vocational Subs in The Last 5 Years so if you this year Alone um if you look at Pleasant Valley again second line if you look
012at that grayish kind of hard to see on the screen but about $457,000 is expected in vocational subjects coming back to PV so what that uh ultimately means if you look at the net cost for what you're sending to mcti actually a savings of about $27,000 when you take that and go over the next five years or the last five years I should say um um this is the net cost School District net expost all four all four schools in the county this is what it looked like five years ago compared to now and really what's happening is what our our budget increase is is lagging behind vocational sub increase which is good for school district it's good for everybody um so ultimately what you're seeing is um an actual decrease in cost uh for
013the school district S Pleasant values about $180,000 in The Last 5 Years um where actually the the cost decrease so even though your enrollment is going up the cost is decreasing somebody may ask why don't we budget that increase and as everybody in this room knows it's hard to budget off of harrisburg's budget um I would hate put us in that position where we budget off that increase and next year it's flat and then neutral so right now just take it as as a win and I will say that you guys and all the other free districts are providing what we need so please please keep that in mind but that is good news capital I mean you guys I know get a monthly update on this so I'm not going to go crazy on
014it but we are very proud of the addition uh it is going very well uh it is on schedule it should be done in June um the windows those front windows actually just went in um so it's starting to come together next uh September we will have our opening which we plan fighting every Schoolboard member there along with all our OC members uh so it is going very well but without boring you so much on that some of the other Capital stuff that is very important that you guys see so this is our capital reserve what we have in capital M you guys for those of you whove been around long probably remember me coming here five years ago six years ago kind of begging for money for a lack of better terms because we
015had no funds in our capital and we fixed that um with your help we made some changes to how we budget um Mr Brook who's saying all the words behind me uh has done an excellent job investing money for us so where we at that bottom green number after the addition is done we still are looking about $2.8 million in our capital reserve which a school for our size that is tremendous and remember before that we had nothing so we had no funding mechanism in pass for Capital um as Sue was very happy to hear when I brought it up I had plans to spend that money already uh so some things we're looking at doing we have some upgrades of the building we have to do electrical service but the more exciting stuff is
016we're trying to expand this school as best we can um without as much cost I mentioned the second autot Tech program our autot Tech program we always have about 40 50 kids on the weight list we'll be adding that second teacher um our business and Hospitality programs being moved which requires classrooms to be renovated the nice um so I was actually up in our old fill head room today and our electric kids are up in the ceiling running wires the carp kids are painting they're putting a new floor down and then when it comes to Auto Tech the carpenter kids will be putting the doors in and getting actually putting up a wall as well so the kids will get that experience save money of course um and then next year you'll hear me talk
017about this at this meeting um we will be starting another program in the 25 26 school year 26 27 school year and it's going to be first respond program so our current multi-purpose room which we will no longer need because of the addition will become our first respond program where kids will under EMP certification um they'll be introduced to firefighting um and additional uh police activity so it's a growing program there's a lot of demand out there so we'll continue to grow um as far as other projects just like every other school we have maintenance we have to take care of our parking lot needs to be looked at um we have a lower parking lot there that needs to be fixed and then I did throw on there at the very bottom I won't
018get into it right now is uh the possibility of another addition um but that's that's a discussion that we'll have another day but overall we continue to grow not just student wise but also in the building thanks to you guys for for all the support that you give us um and to our students so with that said any questions for me Tom can you can you how long 10 can you remind me at the Capital Improvements right now is it more for overdue Renovations or is any of this to combat the rising enrollment so both um so the current edition you're talking about yes so we're able to open up when it's all done free programs so one of them is the second autot Tech program um by moving a current program where adult head
019office was um the current multi-purpose room which is our first responder program that's to and then we open up a computer computer physic th so yes it did it increased our enrollment approximately 150 kids okay great and then the 500 you said kind of on that waiting list compared to like say the previous five to seven years time frame what does that look like yeah it's almost double um and I will tell you that is not I mean I know Mike sitting up there that is not just MC that's a Statewide challenge right now I was at a meeting yesterday we just was discussed so um so we are expecting that number to continue to go up so maybe talking about an addition in the future day maybe not so future day just to I'm
020ready for we've had those discussions and we'll continue to have those discussions I got a couple questions yeah um the starting your SEC the second section of Auto te yes how are you facilitating the equipment needs for the extra student bodies and because I'm assuming it's it's you're just opening up an existing lab and yeah so the existing lab so you're familiar with our building so what's going to happen is our our programs what they have is you have a labr are which is basically the shop and a classroom that classroom that exists will turn and become an expansion of the current lab so all the trainers that we have we'll be putting there so what our teacher plans on doing is all the break training electoral training will be done in that section of
021the lab right behind that is where our current business and Hospitality program is we're going to knock a hole in the wall put a door in there and that room happens to be bigger so that will become classroom space for the two teachers so um it will expand lab space I will tell you it's in a dream world I wish I had bigger lab space because I can't fit 100 Kids our typical program is 50 kids per teacher I don't have that kind of space but it's what would come second question uh the EM program is that redirecting a health C program or is it an addition to it's an addition to add yeah our health program is is really geared towards nursing um and that alone we have 100 kids in there and a
022weight list of so it's an addition and then my last I just want to go back there was a $400,000 increase overall I just want to touch that point again here um um on that 200,000 of it as a result of one of our neighboring districts and their contract and the implications with salary that is reflected back upon mcti and you as a shared school we all endure that cost now that's correct just wanted to make make sure you discuss that thank you anyone yeah I have a question not specifically directly related but um and somebody here may already know this but do you have by program like where the Pleasant Valley like out of curiosity like where the Pleasant Valley kids are yes as far as like program demand yes and is that yeah
023I just like to kind of see that I can even get so we provide enrollment reports to the jlc which has a but we even add the nice thing is actually Dr burer actually presents itself superintendent each month so that way we can start to see especially in the beginning of the year if we have some uh variances where students may start a program but they're finding it's not the right fit and we're trying to bring other students we'll see those numbers go up usually it's pretty consistent after the first month or two but yeah we do get that update I'll share that with the whole board so you have the numbers um not only break down for then also comparatively to uh all the other schools with all the programs um so you can
024see where our students are kind of gravitating towards um and we want to continue to you know help students to a good question District it is different it is just one more question yeah you said 50 students that 50 per one teacher or is that afteron no no no some programs are a little bit different like welding sa is 20 kids per session um that usually would comes down to but the average peram is 25 kids per session and by the way people should get up there board member that the most you gone up there it's a great place up there anyone else thank you Dr Verger thank you Joel um we will place um the budget on our agenda and our next meeting for approval thank you thank you night all right uh moving
025on the agenda student highlights Pleasant Valley High School good evening at the high school we've been extremely busy uh lots of things happening uh since day one a big push that we've had this year was getting student feedback with some of the events from the previous years and how can we make it even better uh an example was uh in the fall we had our pep R football a lot of students came into our office we're asking if we talk to you guys about may possibly a winter one and maybe more Student Center uh but so we basically came up with where every month we've been meeting with the senior class and going over events how can we make it better how can we get more involved and uh we had a very very awesome
026uh winter pep rally we brought back the crush the Cardinal because I feel like that's been getting missing in in the in the mix here and we had a a red cardinal where at the end of it uh we had bat with crushed it was kind of cool to see kids definitely liked it and uh so I mean our students are amazing this year our staff's amazing this year uh we're very excited to show everybody our halfway point here at what's been happening in high school so we hope you guys enjoy it's a PowerPoint uh with some music so enjoy e e e thank you and again looking forward to thank you Mr thank you very nice all right Dr Conrad did we have any Community questions yes uh here we go yes so uh
027good evening everyone there were four Community questions that were submitted uh two Community questions were submitted by um Jordan O'Neal from braw Township uh the first question was regarding Community questions and if the board reviews them so as I stated at the top of the Google form the superintendent reviews the questions um if needed I also reach out to our administrative staff to help answer the questions if I don't know the answer myself um this is basically just an opportunity for the community to ask questions to the superintendent which then I address publicly as I'm doing right now uh and then there's uh if there's time during working sessions certainly you know there's opportunities for public to you know ask more in-depth questions um during that particular section uh the second question um again Ed
028by Jordan O'Neal was regarding adding rules policies of how uh board meetings work um and actually items one I'm sorry items three and 15 on board agenda titled Pleasant Valley citizens provides an opportunity for a community common also attached as policy 903 um public participation in board meeting so it really outlines you know that opportunity for the public to participate um all of our board meetings are recorded they're always available on our PB Bears website under the administration and board of education on the leftand side where it says recorded meetings so at any point if a Community member or staff member um you know want to go back and and look at what was stated about you know particular topic they can always go back and access that um our board uh has and continues
029to follow Robert's Rules of Order which outlines how meetings are run um Schoolboard meetings actually serve as a platform for the school board directors to discuss key issues approve plans and recommendations uh that impact progress being made so it's very uh scripted in that regard and and I say that because there are opportunities during the working sessions for engagement with the community and we'll see that a little bit more this evening which I'm looking forward to um but again there's certain um objectives that need to occur with board meetings as they're scheduled here or in townships alike uh the other two questions were submitted by Jenner oh I'm sorry I wanted to also clarify too that um for the voting meetings that these are not open forms for discussion and I just wanted to clarify
030that because I know often times people will come to the podium for public comment and they'll ask questions um and it's very difficult because it's really not an opportunity to engage in discussion but to to combat that there's always opportunities to reach out to me I have parent meetings phone calls um whatever's necessary just to provide people with the information that they're seeking so the other two questions were submitted by Jenner Rudolph of chest hille Township the third question was uh offering only German 1 and German 2 and not four years um so we have not found a certified teacher for German but we want to be able to offer this for our students uh we will offer German German one and German 2 virtually uh we'll continue to have four years of Spanish and
031next year we're adding French to the curriculum uh the teacher is on the agenda this evening in fact uh and the final question was uh does the school district keep track of comp time for administrators um I stated this back in December so there there's no comp time but employees um who put in several hours beyond the regular workday may be provided with flexibility as so long as it's not not abused and and again refle uh requests for flexibility are determined by the immediate supervisor um our administrators are hired to understand that when they're hired uh they're really going to be available 247 and I can attest to and and Dr Howard as well to calling every administrator uh in the evening um you know in the middle of the night uh early morning to
032address maybe safety concerns or maybe a safe to say um and and obviously that's happening more in high school when we have those discussions but you know they're always accessible but we also have to counterbalance the time that um they're working Beyond you know what would be considered regular business hours um and so certainly we want to uh make our community understand that none of these individuals have earned any sort of extra financial compensation as a result of this benefit but it's that give take that they're um you know willing to uh be available and accessible at a moment's note is to make sure that our staff and students are safe okay um and thanks for your questions and and again the uh link is always on the website the week of the leading up
033to the board meeting so please you know continue to submit questions and I'll I'll do my best to respond to you and honestly if there's something that you need more details for send me an email let's set up a time to meet or maybe a phone call and I can help address uh questions or concerns you might have all right thanks that's it okay thank you um ass May secretary's report please evening tonight I requ approval minutes meeting January 202 and approval February 13 2025 boarding agenda including a correction to item 13d pyramid should be $1,476 29 not $ 24789 which will change the total in that area to $3,886 14,4 so move second I have a motion by Mr burer seconded by Mr Walters is there any discussion all those in favor please signify
034by saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries at this time are there any Pleasant Valley citizens that would like to address the board um this first comment period is on agenda items only if you would like to please come to the podium state your name in the township that you reside in and there is a three minute limit okay see no one approach the podium we will move on in our agenda um Treasures report Mrs surface isn't with us so Mr Walters if you would please thanks tonight I am requesting approval for items 4B through 4 d so move second a motion by Mr burer seconded by Mrs zip is there any discussion yeah coule questions uh one 4B uh the school claims insurance it's about about uh life insurance it's like 2,386
035payments to the consur and um before the M USA remove and repl back stop my understanding is that the high school and the middle school back stops were damed Motors M went on the motors LIF them up anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries uh moving on to unfinished business Mr Fitzgerald uh no unfinished business this evening okay thank you is there any other unfinished business anyone all right moving on to new business uh mon Career and Technical Institute uh um Mrs surface report is there did she provide you pictures or not uh she did I can put them up very quickly okay um but pleas don't ask me which we'll try she has provided just pictures of um our construction report and pictures
036of the addition the ones on the left are uh the previous month I think are November's and then the ones on the right are januaries because we didn't have a meeting in December so um again you can see the um work that's being completed yeah so um it is coming along and as Dr Fergus said they are on track and just one other thing I notic in a report that stated that we had 16 Pleasant Valley students that had outstanding performances I think that's great yes all right uh moving on Mr Galler col only go I you I have no report this evening I will have one for next meeting okay um psba liais on Mrs Z report is attached okay thank you um education report um I do not have anything this evening I
037just have a question I know this week or last last week I can't remember now the visits were to the school districts concerning the ELA um so will we get an update I know that I think the next I didn't see it are we gonna get an update at some point or is it going to wait till that board meeting till I think I think we were waiting on tomorrow tomorrow yeah that's right when majority of the PBI of the ELA special from high school and the middle school um and then they will be doing a survey so basically the next thing is going to happen is at our next board meeting approval will be on there is that correct and I'll the surve everybody that's wonderful that's where next thing you were reading my
038mind okay appreciate that thank you uh Finance report again Mrs surface uh again later on in the agenda um well we did it already yeah cover during the business management section section yeah and I know during our um work session there's a lot of financial stuff that'll be gone over all right Mr Keef Athletics please yes good evening so I'm happy report on January 25th PB girls wrestling competing epcs huge congratulations to Julia trout who placed first Isabelle elos who placed third and Josie fedman who placed fourth so awesome job to all those uh ladies in their first year in doing that and that's an awesome job for for aing that accomplishment I'm not sure what goes on after that obviously there's finals and all that stuff but I'm sure we'll be reporting on that
039as it comes but I do not have that in my report tonight uh another apc's actually state competition on January 30th our PB Varsity cheerleaders competed in States they had a great performance and ended up placing 16th in the state I also want to give a huge shout out to our athletic director for jumping in and doing a great job as a music guy it's a very stressful he was standing there with his finger on the phone making sure he was ready for that moment in time to hit the music because without that when it went right so he's not here to hear that but um I'll tell him he he was emailed this whether you read it or not I don't know yeah uh PB boys basketball finished uh 1111 and qualified for the
040district 11 68 playoff tournament the game will be against Allen at 7 pm on the 18th of February uh so awesome job to them and we wish the best of luck and then lastly is congratulations to Zack Prader who made the boys EPC basketball second team for the year 24 2025 and I will not go through the what I'm deeming now is the Coaches Corner update so it's just a little blurb from the coaches of how the season has gone or is going uh lots of good information there but I'm not going to go through that I'll let you guys read that at your Mee that's it s keep one of our female wrestlers are with us this evening well Round of [Applause] Applause congratulations yes congratulations all right Mrs zip policy report um there's
041one policy on the agenda this evening for first reading policy 905 thank you can I just I know we put something there is there are we talking about putting like a frequency like once I'm going to address that once we approve it okay is that okay no problem okay I do have some things I wanted to discuss all right um Capital Improvement Mr Herer uh we we have not had a meeting since uh our last school board meeting where next meeting is scheduled two weeks from today but um just a shout out to individuals who are been using uh particularly in athletic area and the auditorium uh group uh we'll be starting construction here as soon as school lets out so uh always check to make sure that um you can find space available or
042be working we're looking for all in the spaces because at certain periods of time certain sections of the school will not be available for you so it may require a modification of your uh schedule over the next couple of years a lot of flexibility thank you Mr burer uh technology Mr Clark uh my report is attached for okay thank you Mr Walter security no no information okay thank you uh moving on superintendent please all right well tonight I'm uh seeking board approval for item 7A um I'm sorry 7A is information okay um can I just yes go okay so 7A had to do with the policy 905 which is the citizens advisory committee does anybody have any um thoughts is the policy okay any updates I thought it said maybe well I have other stuff
043but I just meant the policy itself the way it's written I guess I should say we're all okay with the way it's written okay all right so it'll be on next meeting for approval um just to give you some items that I think we should start either discussing or for you to think about so that we can discuss at next meeting would be um as you know in the policy it says the committee should have a topic an assignment so what things would you like um for those topics to be um and then I would like to know if there's any board members that would like to volunteer as the policy states it's three board members um and then do you see this being a committee for all topics staying put or do you see
044like different community members on another topic like if they have expertise maybe rotating individuals from the community just something I thought of but again however the board would like to do it and once you get what are you talking can I just finish can let me having dialogue about well we can we can yeah um and then once once we have the first topic decided upon how are we going to disseminate the process for residents to submit their interest to becoming a a Committee Member another thought I had and then also just to uh continue on in the policy it does state that um the board does need to approve those committee members from the from the community so we have to do all that so go ahead first question I have is I we
045to talk about is frequency I'll throw it out there I think this committee should meet monthly um as far as uh designated topics I think that's going to be a moving Target based on what's Happening Here in our community and within the district but I think every every committee meeting should s should have some sort of I'm going to call it educational component to an educational for the committee to understand and educate the committee as to how some things are handled how things procedurally are done but I that's what I Me by education I know we're in the educational Community here but the committee should be educated on various topics as well throughout the meeting uh for the committee to be effective for them to represent their respective members within the community as well so
046I'm just what I'm Mar to some so far I know you had some Stu no I I agree with you I think the frequeny should be once a month uh same with the topic um I think some of it like we've heard before there's a lot of people coming out here that are expressing a lot of concerns that aren't on our agenda aren't in our radar and if this committee could like see some of those things in advance and like help them educate them as to why things are happening we might you know lower the amount of people coming here and I don't say the nice word complain sessions um Ty and I when I I don't want to make make it sign to the people out the community that we're just railroading this way
047it's it's collaboration here but as you just said there could be times where people just don't understand but the whole idea is we we sit here we're representative of our community but let's expand our community and I think that's what we're trying to do here is somebody may have a great idea and bring it and then we can have a brainstorming session on that as as that committee goes and stuff and come back with the feedback just like we do our commune reports so I don't I want to make it like we're just putting it out there it's educating the committee it's that's not what I wanted to say but there should be an educational component maybe depending on what the topic is I got that any other comments at this one I like the
048idea of frequency of once a month but I do like language being in there to allow the board to have a any type of ad hoc or special meeting depending on say it's something important like a very important building discussion contracted you know teacher contract discussion or or May maybe just in general questions asked um so give us the ability then also to add a meeting if necessary um just to have that language especially with all these especially with all these Renovations going on that monly meeting might be a time to get more discussion out there and with these people you know that are coming they'll be put it up hey this is what's happening or someone comes and says something like you know they already discussed that and you know that type of thing
049I I would volunteer to be part of that committee okay anyone else Bob Clark that I could potentially do it depending on the timing and the dates and time so I'd be attentative but it unless it depends on date time and what that looks like I sacrifice my kids enough I you know depending what what they have going on interested I I think who who would represent the board might be somewhat dependent on what the topic is true so I think we need to maintain some degree of flexibility so that each one of us brings that different set of experiences and you're charge with most of that Pati so having yeah if it if it deals for example would like you're saying with what's going on uh with renovation and how we might think about
050some other options to make it easier for the community at large and our students then somebody from the Capital Improvements should at least be present so and and typically if it deals with with another topic that somebody has an expertise whether it be Finance or education or Athletics whatever it is then U that person should be as a minimum press would it would it be um aable to have maybe two members that are constant and that one's more a rotational one so that gives us all of us an opportunity to sit on that at some point to to hear that community and and if there is an expertise area like Capital Improvements that Norm is there he's not as a normal attendee he would come to that particular item so then you have and that
051gives flexibility too for members who have other uh obligations outside here um but also can be a part of that Community not just lock it into three blocked in I would say that we should have a board chair um since John volunteered to be on the committee in the first place I would say John would be the the the board chair and the reason I say we need a board chair is there's there needs to be a funnel for that committee to have emails going back and forth between that one that one point of contact so I'd say let's designate that as as the board chair for the committee and against Bob not but he stepped up right away on I would say to that that we we need we need to have that point
052of contact person that's that consistent person to establish the meetings or or coordinate everything and all that stuff so I I agree with that if you're willing to do that I agree with that 100% I want to hear everyone so so this will be Revis then as far as right because what it's it's very focused now right like I'm going to give this committee a task this is what they're going to accomplish you're going to provide me with recommendations two two per in one go is that so so I'll try in just because the way it's written now right specific yeah okay so we'll definitely make the necessary adjustments um and I'll make sure that I get that to the board so that way you have um opportunity to provide some feedback prior to the
053second read and adoption um I've worked on an AR uh specific to address some of these and and I really like the conversation we're having because I agree you know we want to make sure that uh we're also respectful of the various expertise of the board members here some that are in finance some that are in business and different industries that might lend itself to a discussion um for finance whereas maybe somebody uh is better suited for education and I think that that kind of creates that equal share opportunity for all of our nine board members to be engaged with our community um so I'll I'll work through and put some things together I think as I'm listening to all of you speak and and this is a great again discussion um I think really
054from my standpoint and maybe we're looking at the short run and the long run and what I mean by that is we're now in the middle of February we know that we're heading into budget season we know in the past um that the budget has been something that maybe some people have questions about it might behoove us to say you know hey and I'm not saying we have to do this but I'm saying maybe we have a discussion about you know a budget committee because that's probably going to be the next thing we discuss over the next several months maybe there's also an opportunity for you know education programs or um know curricul or things like that that that might be another topic as we're looking long term into starting 25 26 so I think
055we we want to obviously be very tactful about you know what the objectives are but I also love the idea of you know that ad hoc like hey maybe we need to do a deeper dive and maybe that can be part of a working session so I think respecting everyone's you know um personal work schedule and then obviously obligations to to our district and and and the things that we love to do for our kids and Community um I I I'll definitely like I said I'll draft some of this these ideas up um if we're okay John if you do or whomever wants to be kind of that chair person I like the idea of the rotation too um I could put the that language into the AR so that way it kind of encompasses
056even to the community hey this is how we're really going to operate here's the mechanics which is the policy itself that the AR kind of lends itself to the understanding of how do we get from point A to point Z So within that also just you know we're talking Community we're talking you as administrators and every so often we' like you some of you to show up some of these meetings give some of your perspectives explanation same with teachers and stuff like that we like them to to come to some of these meetings so we can you know so if there's some Community questions or something that you might be able to answer better than any of us the same what's going on so it's like it's not we're exclud you you are this community
057we all say it's all of us it's the board it's the staff it's Administration so we're hoping invol all yeah I'm just trying to Envision like want it to be meaningful right and productive so I just I just don't know how we're going to manage that which just like defining topics like no I just I you know what I mean I don't want it to be like an hour a month that we're we're feedack on like everything maybe some would email think if we have email ahead of time say okay here are some topics that we like and then I I think we need to come up with that as I said I think as a board we need to come up with some topics and then once you have a community once you have
058a meeting then you can get their feedback and say is there any topics that you might like to see done but I think we have to initiate the initiate it that's what I think yeah and I think it have you know has to have a topic you know I think you mrke did you want to say something I say keep in mind this is version one yeah exactly not jump into it but just ease our steps into it and make sure it's done right I think the the community deserves it we deserve the interaction with the community to make sure that we're being well balanced and looking after why we're up here in the first place being voted to do what we to do um so I don't want to jump into it I want
059to think this through do it right and make sure that we're capturing what the community wants so maybe as one of our working sessions we make this a topic maybe Community comes in has our conversations and we build that agenda together making a standing agenda that flexibility that the end of that meeting all right next month we want to talk about these topics but you stick with the standard agenda and then you open it up this in flexibility the end and also start to look at the members that the community members that are going to be part of this process as well maybe they can start coming give us an idea what they have on and I we have all these different you know we have the Elder the pope you know chest Hill and
060all that get a variety of people from different community at least one representing each of those communities uh what I what I would suggest is try not to get into to more than one Topic at a time because what you're going to find yourself is you're going to be drug in in several different directions and you'll be going nowhere it's kind of like getting stuck in the snow back well plus spinning your wheels but not making any progress yeah plus if we need to bring in certain administrators that have the expertise in the topic some some planning ahead of time so you pick the topic that you're going to have for the next session and between that session and a month later you get the input from a variety of sources so you in fact
061come into the door with an agenda and some information related to that agenda because you know there going to be some people are going to be coming in from the community that haven't seen any of this but you don't want to spend your whole time trying to explain what's on your agenda and the general information let them read that on their own would you limit the the time of the meeting to an hour or yeah I think there should be I do agree there should be a time limit too yeah just so everybody knows what the parameters are all right so Dr Conrad's going to put some ideas together in an AR I believe yeah is how we're going to are we okay with the language of the policy as it stands and then we
062can kind of Flesh it out a little bit more through the AR with the things we've been discussing so far to talk about the vetting process once once we get the ball rolling here the vetting process for community members just throwing us out here now I think just a letter of intent with you know what your background your your angle from the community is um and then I think we should as as a board of the whole be looking at that um and who who that's going to com be comprised of not no disrespect to the chair or to Rob down there but um would you be like like a Google form that would I we should call Google form intent questions that would right what were what their you know intents what they looking
063for tops all nine of us reviewing that yeah representative our community members okay we kicked it around enough at this moment you have that drop ready by tomorrow morning you missed the meeting it was an hour ago okay thank you everyone for all your input all right we're up to Human Resources yeah thank you mking is all right moving on to Human Resources Mrs tonight I'm seing approval of items 8 through 8 e items 8f through 8 G are informational so move second a motion by Mr Walder second by Mr Galler is there any discussion um just letting you know I'm going to be abstaining from 8 D2 relative anyone so 8 B that is getting rid of um not getting rid of obtaining somebody to get rid of one of our online classes right
064yes still be some changes because now we'll have certifi teachers that and I know this isn't part of Human Resources but I was unfortunately we were impacted by that um what is bakle I'm GNA tell you we need to find something I don't know if it's senica Valley or this teach that we were dealing with we should be getting paid back for they're it it's horrific and then somehow I became a student of Pleasant Valley as well with my not my school email or school work email but with my personal email so I'm a little disappointed in that um I think we need to to really look at our how and what we're doing um because it's a little disappointing I think kids are in these buildings for a reason because they don't want to
065be in front of a screen and we owe that to them Community to make that happen so I I I I actually 100% agree with you and I think think all of us from the administration team you know um unfortunately we've experienced this probably more of an increase in the last two years I've noticed um but when we do have uh midyear resignations and uh you know retirements it it really does Jam us up and and I can tell you I can tell you that we've spent hours you know trying to rearrange and Shuffle what we can do to best support students but I think we can all agree and we've had this discussion many times that what's Best in most cases for our students is somebody that's right in front of them somebody that's
066certified in that subject that's committed to them that you know isn't um going to be leaving in two weeks before the start of the second semester you know and and I say that because it's so critical for us to work together and have some um you know I guess way to address something that might be happening I think sometimes we get caught in the midst of you know like just getting a letter from somebody saying hey my last day is you know X and it's we can hold them for 60 days but let's just be honest do you think that the students are benefiting from an individual being held for 60 days so so again it's very complicated I do want our parents to understand that as well that you know this isn't the most
067ideal situation um we found a patch I'll say because there is a certified teacher in those online classes that's at least you know giving them instruction is it what we desire absolutely not I want to be crystal clear about that but we also need to know and have communication if you know somebody's thinking of retiring or resigning like if we don't know that then again we're going to be plugging holes as we've been doing so it really comes back to that communication and really working together to do what's best for kids but I I agree 100% percent with what you're saying and and we we need to do a better job to you know work through when we have those challenges but we also need to do a better job to prevent or at least
068anticipate those challenges from happening but I I agree with you so so what what did and again I can't this question um an older teacher would be able to answer what did what did we do when we didn't have online opportunities but teacher de to leave short short-term sub long-term sub I mean and and again you know if if we're lucky you know maybe lesson plans that we're left I mean in my own experience and not necessarily here but you know there's been times where teachers left and there's no lesson plans so they're they're scrambling to get lesson plans from other individuals um some of the teachers you know obviously will will be um uh education focused and and student focused and and leave that but frankly and I mean correct me if I'm wrong
069but at least what I've seen you know in my previous experience was you get a long-term sub if you're lucky and most likely you're just getting a dayto day and you're lucky to get worksheets I mean let's just call it what it is and sometimes the other the students were absorbed in the other classes that that could be true yeah and Brian to go back to your question problems always been around yeah true it's just it's being spotlighted more right now because of the overall that's always been there and that's always been issues that schools have had to deal with throughout time but I I said just because of the shortage right now there's no Replacements and and for what it's worth and again this is I think important for the community to understand it's
070almost like we have two options we we could certainly go with the easier option which is I can get somebody from ESS and do the day-to-day sub do we think that that's going to get our kids further along and at least cover the the gap of knowledge that they' experience otherwise you know we've pivoted to not use Edgenuity as um the solution but but as a solution to have some sort of you know um curricular and educational continuity in the absence of that teacher that was there at the start of the school year um I just think that you know again from all we've had hours of discussions about this senica Valley and and using Edgenuity for this you know predicament is not our end goal but it's a better goal than having somebody who
071doesn't have the certification who doesn't know our kids on a day-to-day basis um to give them something that they can hang on and learn educationally but I think what Mr Gall said and he's right you know this has been a problem for the last 10 years and this is a better option what we had 15 20 years ago and it's better option than we had five years ago yeah exactly I do know other districts are also and also pivot to online stuff even though it's not yeah off but it's I just have one thing I was just what happens we have I remember we have these teachers teaching college classes with in Pleasant Valley and I think it was brought up there once that some of these teachers are only certain ones are certified to
072teach certain classes what happens if they decide to retire or resign what happens to the students are involved with those college classes we work the college to get I me students have paid for the credit um sometimes the colleges would send um somebody here to do it but we would also have a teacher from Valley sitting in there I would want a teacher position away from yeah no I was just curious you talking about all this that's great inity but if they're taking a college class with an actual teacher that's gonna be that can't Happ thank you okay anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries tonight I'm seeking approval of items 9 through 9 items 9 e is informational second a motion by Mr
073gazis seconded by Mr Walters is there any discussion hearing if none all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries moving on to curriculum Dr Howard yes good evening t i I'm seeking approval for item 10 a so move second I have a motion by Mr Galler seconded by Mr gazis is there any discussion yes first of all I want to thank Mr B the conversation we had about your program studies and I like how you you know fix those problems that were in there very appreciative of that um I just have a question Miss Harris if you have a chance to look at any of those classes that moved is there going to be any problems with our okay just want make sure okay thank you very
074much you're welcome anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries okay moving on to operations Mr snap rule of item 11 a so move second motion by Mr Galler seconded by Mr o' is there any discussion all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone and that motion carries moving on to business management Mrs re I have a motion by Mr Burger seconded by Mr gisi is there any discussion front line that's I know you said it once before front line is a human resource management system um it also houses our um asop system which is our substitute system how we um or actually not just substitutes but how teachers actually account for their time and all employees it's entered into that system
075so there's different levels of the front lines uh we have Frontline Central which is an HR program we have the ASAP program and we also have recruiting and hiring which is how we uh post positions recruit people and keep everything um filed within a system and time stamp the professional growth piece will actually be able to replace at least two other um platforms that we have that we won't need so it'll be One-Stop shopping basically for all of our employees so they'll be able to go to human resources for a lot of the things that they need like Act 48 um we won't have comply our trainings will all be built right in the system and then obviously the gold star uh system is the business office will be the the other system that we
076have and they both can communicate with one another okay so you're saying it's like the asop so that keeps track of personal days there's different there's different components of it so we already have we already have Printing and hiring and we already have Frontline Central now we're looking to bring on professional growth which can do a lot of things for us I guess ask it's like to ASAP so that keeps track of everyone here that's it's just mainstreaming it all into one uh system so it's easier and user friendly to all thank you anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries I'm requal move I have a motion by Mr Galler seconded by Mr Clark is there any discussion all those in favor please signify
077by saying I anyone opposed and that motion carries uh Mr Fitzgerald any new business I just very briefly um we mentioned at the uh the last meeting about various orders that have been coming out by the new Administration that have impacts on on school districts um even since the last uh board meeting there have been a a blizzard of additional ones that have have impacts on Title 9 the EEOC and other areas that impact school entities uh soice to say we are keeping an eye on all of them um at the present time there isn't one that explicitly binding yet on on districts but we anticipate based on how some of the orders have been written that new regulations should likely be forthcoming as we get into the spring so we'll certainly thank you uh
078Pleasant Valley citizens is there anyone this evening that would like to address the board on any item please again come to the podium state your name Township you reside in and um there is a three minute uh good evening Ali R Township and actually Mr L the way for this I'm speaking tonight concerns that I have with Ingenuity the Staffing situation at the high school and some communication currently there are numerous classes that are taught through Ingenuity do staffing issues medals which isn't even through Ingenuity they have to choose other electives Advanced robotics biology ecology chemistry Earth and space science and even physics some of these classes aren't even offered through their online platform so children had to take C classes my son fell in that category he could not take Earth in space science
079so he is in astronomy um this is not acceptable the online classes do not have a teacher they have a keeper of grades no one is actually teaching our children they're watching videos and answering questions that's their education or that thereof to be honest the resources of the teacher is an email if they have a question the letter of the district sent out to the parents stated that a Pleasant Valley teacher would be in the room with the students that is also not true a day-to-day sub is in the classroom with my son F Valley Subs are not PV employees they're brought in from an outside agency they're just monitoring our schools uh these children in class uh big question how much is this costing our district these day-to-day Subs how our school district is
080fortunate enough to have a phenomenal physics teacher yet he's only teaching one of the physics classes who made this decision why is this okay how is this the best for our children my son has a gifted IEP how are his goals being addressed and met for an online platform that does not have a physical teacher teaching him who's going to actually fill out his third marking period progress report the computer program that he watches all day long this is all occurring to this is all occurring due to staffing issues at the high school I think it's time that parents in the community get some answers as to why the staff turnover is so great at the school by someone through this last year and two of his classes and again this year this revolving door
081of teachers is a in core subjects classes where these students need to take keystones these classes are supposed to prepare them for high school and higher education yet they are watching videos none of this is preparing them for high school or for higher education no part of this is challenging them or providing them with rigorous instruction or Hands-On learning opportunities last year his geometry class went through two teachers his biology class went through three teachers our children will never establish relationships with staff when they never know who's coming or who is going this year his last three weeks of his medals class went on without a medals teacher again a vetted teacher left their district for another his Earth and space science class is just as bad this year Ingenuity he was pushed into being
082monitored by a day-to-day sub another teacher I was told and I appreciate Mr Bing getting back to me with answering all my questions wonderful with that so I do appreciate that um another teacher coming on February 17th then yet another teacher replacing that teacher beginning in March but nobody will live instruct him until the end of the third marketing period so with two higher teachers he will still be staring at a computer screen I don't know how this is imp head there is zero consistency and our children are the ones that suffer I can appreciate that the staffing issues are out of the hands of the administrators at the high school however I cannot appreciate the Miss rle I'm sorry but your three minutes are up good evening I'm from Township and I'm speaking on
083a similar issue uh as well um our family was personally impacted by this this year uh as well my daughter's a junior and had uh all intentions of participating in third year of uh German this year and uh her the teacher left the district so approximately a week before the school year started we got an email from her guidance counselor saying we had to pick something else and it had to fit in fourth period because that was the only spot fre in her uh schedule due to all the other courses that were already selected and um taking another third year of a language wasn't an option um so she ended up with an online course and then an art class both of which she found beneficial but um the reality is that um for many
084students High School is their chance to build their resume for college and higher education and most colleges they don't require three years per se most recommend it um my daughter in particular hopes to go on and apply for a very competitive uh major and so she's now at a disadvantage not having the third year of a language when other students will be applying with that uh she and many of her friends were hoping to join the National German Honor Society this year which is now not an option because that's reserved for third and fourth year language participants um but on a bigger picture than just German um it's impacting many many courses and um um many many in my building alone I know five colleagues who have students who have children who've had this experience
085and as Educators we're constantly encouraged to have rigor and engagement in our lessons and in our day-to-day interactions with our students and this is far from rigorous or engaging for our students and it it concerns me for my own child who is a motivated High achieving person for her Readiness for College when this is happening prevalent with increased prevalence and I am a therapist and so I'm as Solutions oriented person so I'm not here to just complain and air my concerns about this I'm here to ask you to start making some solutions and be creative about it we're all aware that there's a teacher shortage um I I ask you to look why we're having particular trouble in this District attracting and retaining them but I also ask you to think outside the box I
086got a mailing many weeks ago from Northampton Community College where many German classes are offered maybe we can partner with them just someone could Skype in and teach our students German like we have to get creative because this teacher shortage isn't going anywhere anytime soon I was raised by a public educator I'm married to a public educator I've been in public education for eight years I want to believe in it I do believe I do it every day but it's getting harder to do that with things like this that concern me so I just I bring it back to you to try and um think hard about ways we can address this that aren't just throwing your hands up and saying there's no German teachers to be found that is the truth but I'm Sorry
087Miss kesy but your time your three minutes are up thank you thank you hi my name is Wendy green and I'm a resident of I to everyone here because I know because and especially board members because you your time and also administration because it makes it a long day but I here to take you back on the concerns of the last two um I'm just wondering what's the plan um for the issue with Staffing and the uity issue what's the longterm plan how are we going to attract and retain staff what's happening how it it seems like there has been an ased as a staff in the last couple of years if if someone could retire they did if they could leave they did um so I mean my son loves P high school for
088the last two years he's had some concerns about his education and how that will impact leader so I just I'm looking to I didn't realize until recently how much this was so I'm here out of concern thank you good evening Ros just Hill toship um I'm here tonight to speak on behalf of my son James um I have a daughter that graduated I'm a graduate my husband's a graduate currently with sophomore daughter that attends a district my son James attends Mac conception in uh canaril James has been playing Ross since he's been in first grade he's gone through the youth glies program um since then for six years now um currently this year we learned that due to the success of the girls team which is phenomenal I I I I'm very proud of that
089that they tried they Incorporated a middle school girls team and a boys team which um we learned this because um we stopped getting the emails for the Youth League and everything else because the boy te and we were told that he was no longer allowed to play I approached the athletic director and tried to have a discussion about it and I was told that oh well that's the way it is he goes to a different school now we live in the district I have children in the district um and I proceeded to research in paa rules which are ambiguous at best Okay um they're up for you you can interpret them in many ways what was clear about them was homeschool children Charter children cyber school children are all allowed to play in District my
090son because he's a Catholic school or private school child isn't allowed to play which I find you know a little disturbing so here's a boy who's been playing it's the only sport that he does he loves it with all his heart he was out there practicing in the snow the other tonight because he doesn't know what to do he had no no box across this here he was denied that and I don't know where to go from here so I'm I'm standing here asking you for your help because I don't understand why this is happening other schools in the valley that I've talked to different administrators school board members they all have agreements with schools they have waivers that are signed they check in with the coordinating schools seeing about their eligibility or whatever else
091his school does not offer lacrosse it's not like he has an option to play there at pel there is no sport there for him to play when it comes to thecross so I'm a little taken back by it I I'm bringing this to your attention I'm asking if someone could look into it and help us with this because I don't understand why other you know um variations or or different Outlets of Education such as Cyber Charter home school are allowed but my private school child is not that doesn't make sense this doesn't have an option there is no other sport this sorry your three minutes are up thank you thank you if anyone is willing to ask questions and willing to help me we'll we'll stay after and I I would appreciate that is is
092there anyone else that would like to address the board you can come up again and I just need to keep my rules if you have something else you'd like to add but we do allow that um seeing no one else come to the podium uh School Board directors does anyone have anything this evening I have something I just like you were talking about Mr Bor was bringing up about the gy and stuff like that I'm curious as to maybe you can answer this when we're getting ready to do that gym is the person who's putting in are they ordering is is this all supplies and everything come with that like we we getting new bleachers we're getting new floors the install the person installing are they the ones that're bringing that so they're they have
093an order and they're coming in and they're going to put all that down and they're not I'm just curious like one is going to begin if I know sometimes we had like we were supposed to clean the floor the one time 10 volleyball season right before that we were saying guess what the floor cleaner didn't come in so now you're pushed at middle school so I'm just wondering if we're going to start this gym floor are we going to have the floor and the bleach is ready to go so when they come here we start we finish it getting ready to be used by everybody okay yeah I talked to the engineers actually today about that very thing um the way it's looking we're not going to have time to do both we're probably going
094to do the Flor oh yeah first and then do the bleachers at a later dat probably next summer is what we're looking at now because the bleachers are I think six or nine months out if you order them right now so the floor we're going to order we they're going to order the floor bring it in put that in then they're just waiting till the following season so that's what it's projecting right now correct it's not fine so so can I pick you back on that so we're going to do the gym floor this summer that's what they're projecting right now okay why wouldn't we just wait and do both at the same time I guess I have a concern we can could we push off both until the the summer of 26 is it
095the same installer though like okay well my concern what my concern is is that taking those new bleachers taking the new the old bleachers out putting new ones in and and you'll have a new floor in and could you damage that new floor that's where I'm sorry they were pulling those out just put the floor in bleaches at all yeah I think she's saying in the removal process the floor might be that's all I'm asking this is the first time hearing this so yeah that's my just be my question for the engineer that's all you know so the floor is going to be done that that's what we're talking about right now just because of the time constraints right now that's not a s in stone thing uh we'll talk about that at the next
096meeting I'm sure I I I think at one time part of the discussion on relative to the floor is there are certain areas where the boards so thin that you're getting parts of it broken off so to some extent that's becoming somewhat of a safety issue yes and I think that's why there would be some people leaning to do the floor as soon as possible uh I understand the possibility of damage uh but I think there's probably ways that that can be compensated so I I don't think we want to answer the question here tonight but it but certainly the question is raised and it's worthwhile thinking about what is the best approach to go forward yeah just like you don't know what's underneath that Flor to cause it to be what it was that's
097like will they undo that for find hello there surprising sort of like that Su with all those bees okay thank you um one other thing I just have going with that is the furniture for the for all we're getting all new furniture for the all the renovations or is that are we getting all new furniture for these Renovations and stuff like that so that's going to be all that old stuff is going to be do we do something like we do with the sports equipment do we put it out there for working on that right now some stuff is not but other Stu will be thank you okay all right anyone else just one Mr Ultimus just keep sticking your hand um the answer that you got probably isn't the best one that we have
098for you um I don't know the rules but I think we owe you a better answer than no um because I I don't understand the rules either so why is it somebody in CCA can play if your school doesn't offer it why can't you play for PV I'm not saying I'm not gain rules this is s keep R's opinion but don't discourage yourself regardless of the outcome okay keep strong keep hitting that wall and as a coach of the five six girls want to come help us out I welcome you to come help us us out but um we owe you a better answer right and it's not um that we can't do it again resarch be I'm not thank you anyone else all right Dr Conrad um so thank you for being here tonight
099and talking about you know your concerns and how they impact your children and that's something that we need to hear more about because we want to make sure our kids are safe they're getting the best education possible and again I agree with you it doesn't need to be that you know well there's nothing we can do um I think that there are solutions um one of the things you know we're talking about wondering why and and you know unfortunately we're in a position where um teachers especially new teachers and and some that are not the more tenure teachers that have invested a lot of time in the district have the ability to um earn more money and and I I can tell you frankly through exit interviews six exit interviews of teachers within the last
100two years cited specifically and it wasn't just all about money but money was a major factor in it and we're talking about a $10,000 bump or so um so it it it's significant and that's something that you know we need to obviously be prepared to to look at and and you know discuss um there there are other things too what is the environment that some of our new teachers uh we had two recently in the high school that left and the environment wasn't a welcoming environment and these are coming from individuals who um you know actually one of them that that graduated from here um and and you know unfortunately sometimes it's that mentality of maybe the gr is greener somewhere else maybe they can get a little bit more money but I also think
101what is the working relationship you know in the high school because Ser seriously we're seeing this more rampid um you know issue at the high school and then I also want the community to understand we have about 300 teachers 186 of them are at the top step of the M of the salary Matrix and I say that because what that means is in order to get to that TOP Step you have to put years of service in which is 14 um when you take a look at the last several years and don't quote my number I'm just trying to you know give give an estimation but I would say that on average we're averaging about maybe like 10 to 20 10 to 15 I'd say um teachers that are of age to retire um and
102or you know maybe are looking to uh you know move on to to greener pastures right um so again these are all things that we need to consider and and you know from my stand point we do need to talk about this this is you know a um an employee you know Union Labor uh thing that probably needs to be discussed uh as as we continue you know obviously trying to work through uh teacher contracts which I know uh both parties are working through right now and that's exciting to see some momentum going but these are some topics that really you know in my opinion should be discussed um in the future because that they impact our kids and and they impact our staff's kids too as well so that's that's an important piece that
103we definitely need to continue to work through it's not it's not a one you know uh solution it's not just finances it's not just you know how I'm treated as an employee with my colleagues but let's be honest those are definitely two factors that that I'm seeing in my exit interviews um so again we need to really unpack that we need to look ourselves in the mirror and say what can we to get do to to get to a better place but you know like I said before I think the solution that we're putting forth is better than the solution that we had but it's not the best solution so we need be very mindful of that and then lastly uh with Mr jixi also and Mrs alimos um what I would ask is this
104I do know that there's that longstanding you know uh challenge with um Catholic schools you know being essentially excluded from PIAA and I also don't know all the rules but I understand you know where some of the dissension has been in the past couple of years being primarily cited that you know the um especially in playoffs I know there's been a lot of Articles published about you know the Catholic schools and have they're able to stack their their um sides so they're winning a lot more state championships so so there's some bad blood I think that's that's mixed in with all this what I would say is that if you if you and it's great if you have contacts with uh Northampton and other school districts if you can share that to both my athletic
105director and myself just about what does that you know waiver or liability because I would certainly explore that as an option I can't guarantee it but I'm also not going to put um Pleasant Valley in Jeopardy of actually forfeiting games because we're trying to accommodate your son and certainly we would have never wanted that intention for your son to not you know be able to continue to play lacrosse I mean I'm very happy that we're offering it here but you're right there there's unfortunately some some baggage that comes with that and I I'm very sorry that that happened because as a former College athlete I would never want students to not have that opportunity um but certainly if you see or coming across things share it our way because i' I'd be more than willing
106to take the time to understand you know how are they kind of getting around is there a loophole that I'm maybe not aware of and and maybe we can work through that process okay but thanks for sharing that because I wasn't aware of that so um oh and then last thing promise uh there are updates to the 2425 school calendar um we've used actually all of our remote instruction days for the school year and we actually implemented one snow day um therefore the last day for students is currently on Monday June 2nd um I've communicated out that the um commencement has not changed that date remains intact uh but I did want to uh direct our uh staff and students and parents to the district website you'll be able to find this change um it's
107been updated so I just wanted to uh make you all aware of it and um you know obviously we're excited about our our own athletes here and and the progress that they're making in their season so you know continue to go Bears and how about them Eagles so but that's all I have to say thanks everyone okay could I have a motion to I have a motion by Mr Galler second by Mr Clark all in favor okay we are adjourned uh five minute break and uh we will then go into our work session meeting e e e in that section and then um also offering that there would then be no public comment at the end of the the meeting of course the chair would have the responsibility to ensure the agenda is being followed
108to maintain order and for everyone to have their say and also to bring the group back uh on topic if we waiver off um of course we would evaluate and tweak the process uh as Mr o'keef said earlier it's version one and um so I'm just asking how does this sound and um uh is it a starting point point for us to try this got to start somewhere yeah proba try a shot see see how go it doesn't go a good way we can adjust all right we all okay Township it's like people talk there any rules on engagement back to the community at that point so somebody comes after the session and they answer a question is it I think we need to answer or get back with an answer we should make things
109up just to get to somebody we need to come back with right information yeah um and again it's okay to say let me get back to you yeah it's okay to say I don't know thank you all right so I will begin then is there any public comment this evening from Community okay good start right all right then we will begin item number one is finance and Tammy you have a long one good evening the first item during our last construction project meeting um it was discussed that if there was an emergency on site during the construction and a decision needed to be made immediately that had a dollar amount attached to it that Dr Conrad should have that authority to approve it on the spot um so we would need to decide on a
110dollar amount it was suggested by cjd our engineer that it's normal for $100,000 to be the author is a authorized amount for the superintendent to approve on spot and so I some feedback from the board how do you feel this would go on the next agenda for official board approval um but I want to kind of get your thoughts before I put something on that I can let everyone know that uh at mcti during the building project that is going on right now we are have also approved um the same type of agreement although not at the $100,000 because the project is not as large as what we are dealing with here at m at Pleasant Valley for some reason and maybe Dr crre you can help me with this I think it was 40,000
111maybe in mcti or I I but that sounds uh 30 or 40 yeah I can't really recall the dollar amount we gave Dr uh verit up to you know but of course he he would then communicate with the whole Joc that that this occurred you know through an email process they hit the rock right things like that we had to do that yeah because some of them were interesting but it it is being done you know like it's so I just wanted to throw that out there so you don't want to hold some of these things could hold the project up if it needed to wait for board approval you know so but and just to be clear I'm not looking for you lateral Authority yeah so I I I don't want that uh but
112but as as something comes up and you know we're speaking with the engineers and uh you know we're talking with Tammy and with Randy I want to make sure that you know if on the Fly you know I was to communicate that this is what the challenge that we're running up against um would you know would you just to let you know this is how much it's going to cost I think that's what we're looking for a dollar amount authorization because again to to uh Mrs ky's point if we have to wait you know for example what happened tomorrow we're waiting you know nine more business days it's it's going to delay and delay and and there are going to be some probably unforeseen things with the scope of the project that we're doing so
113I just uh we were trying to understand what does this board feel comfortable with that Authority being and then obviously making sure that you get uh the information um to move things along I guess I guess my question is like if this problem occurred would you then let Mrs gregy know and she would contact us all by email or text or something like that say Hey this is what we're running into what are your thoughts like she's done with other things and then just get back to you and say okay go for it I mean is that something that's doable I I I mean what H what's at least what's happening what's been happening at mcti was that an issue comes up Dennis sends it out to the J um and says you know this
114this change order is now going to cost $115,000 I just wanted to let you know and then they go ahead and move forward with it because sometimes um with with different people and Engineers that they're coming in they might not be scheduled for another couple days so we're trying to make like you know within I'd say an hour to two hours sometimes not all the time mean certainly if we have some days to sit on it but I I would it would help to move things along without being BL and I actually will say I believe part of the Reon reason mcti is on on a good timeline and a good schedule is because as three or four of these you know emails have popped up and and change orders and expenditures have increased um
115there's just in the notion that we're going to continue to move the momentum so I guess I guess that's what I'm saying you said three or four times so three or four times AT3 00,000 not they would be that we had four times we're going to get $400,000 out the door I think that's going to be quite an a that's kind of my question too like so is it is it $1,000 up two and you hit that threshold that would be the maximum so so he can't so I guess we can't do $100,000 in the next oh here's another one another $100,000 for each I it would be for each item emergency item and just to give you a little bit of background how this would work when there's a change order the change order
116comes in from the contractor that's on site it has to go through the architect and the engineer to be approved inside then it comes to me I'm sorry then it goes to Randy he has to sign off on it then it comes to me and I have to sign off on it and then has go to Dr Conrad he has to sign up on it then it comes to the board for you to go it through so there's a lot of Tik toks for a change order to happen so this is the example I believe that they gave in our meeting was what if they hit a water line or something and there's Waters coming up through the floor and they need to get that taken care of immediately Randy's gonna be the one that's
117in the building and ry's gonna say yeah fix that but he's gonna call Dr Conor and he's gonna say we need to fix this right now but it's going to be another $20,000 that's what we're asking for and just to pick an amount it it doesn't have to be 100,000 it it could be whatever the cour is comfortable with but I believe that the size of this project 100,000 is not an unreasonable amount to authorize that I think let me just speak for a minute she's she's correct it that most of these would occur when you're digging in the ground kind of problems and if if you if it's in the situation where it affects let's say you're in school and you hit you hit a a water line or electric line or the gas
118U you know some other sewage line for example and do we want to wait no you know four or five days week to get insurance or is it something that if we don't solve it we end up with a greater expense because we wait I so so I I I I think it's reasonable to expect that this is probably going to happen a couple of times because we know there's a couple things that we don't know today about things that were done 50 60 years ago and I'm sure we're going to encounter some of that so we need to have some sort of a mechanism and and I I don't anticipate that that we're going to be seeing the kind of thing where we took a bigger problem and we broke it down into three
119or four small parts that's not what we're looking at here we're looking at trying to solve something which we're kind of in a crisis mode and by not acting quickly will be more expensive than taking action appropriately what's that dollar value to you I I I'm I'm I'm okay somewhere between 50 and 100 and I'm not going to try to drive you in the right direction but when you're talking 100 million well not in this case 87 million I guess now $87 million project 100,000 is small it's it's not it's not small change but proportionately it's small okay so i' I'd say somewhere in the 50 to 100 you know whatever the board feels comfortable with I'm not going to try to drive the answer I'm more worried about the lead time in fixing some
120of these emergency problems on some of the equipment coming in SO waiting for a board approval is especially when you're doing a project that set Cal like this where you have time frames to meet no you Absol this is absolutely a necessity probably something we should have talked about a long time ago um that's water under the bridge or whatever the setting is um I think 100,000 is very reasonable um for something like this oh are we all I agree with that yeah with with with a courtesy of yeah of being not being not the board being notified immediately yeah we okay with that then okay yeah off okay um moving on to Item B attached to the cap reserve for 2018 2023 Bond and 2024 bond for January the capital reserve account has an
121available balance of 15 million 8369 7847 at January 31st um as you'll see on the reports um the board approved construction contracts back in December when we did the bid openings um we had discussed in previous board meetings that approximately 8 and5 million for change for alternates in the bids would be allocated to the capital reserve account um so those alternates did not come to 8 half million it was much less so they have been allocated now since the board approved it and we have the final numbers the team room addition of 3,181 700 the gym room bleachers divider curtain score scoreboards and volleyball accessories 174900 Paving in the parking lot 492,000 wire mold and Specialty lining 39,000 and nobody better ask me and Randy left Earth working hard and flashing 84,500 fire mold is
122just like Raceway like it's like usually like stick on and run the wires through slap on so it looks pretty so sound like wires hanging on the there you go um the projects that are listed are the alternates and they have now I just have a question but I I I understand what we have up there is there any way we could put down the dates when you're done because when I was looking like okay why do we need to do the field but then I realized that that Capital done for the field replacement was something that was already done correct correct and the reason that it's carried on here doesn't have would a date that this was done this I can go back and find dates yeah the reason we have to carry those
123because this was no I understand date were because I first looked at it again I forgot I thinking okay this is new that no you said once before pass car over we can see when it was done yeah okay I'll go back and see if I can time thank you um two other projects that are added to c cap Reserve was the BBE carpet replacement estimate of 50,000 this Project's currently out to bid um so we'll have a better price on this uh we bid opening is two Mondays from now the re keing has been added to this as well which was board approved at our last board meeting um the total cost for this project was around 350,000 that the district did receive a grant through Chief Miller's efforts with the pccd Grant and
124Mr vanor we received a grant for 183 539 so the other 166 is allocated to the count reserve the 2018 Bond account has an available balance of zero now and the reason it has an available balance of zero is because we I've allocated the additional construction costs to the what was left in this Bond the 2023 Bond account also has an available balance of zero again because I've allocated the high school renovation costs to this Bond um of the board approved contracts in the 2023 uh Bond spreadsheet you'll notice there are change orders in the second column of a million dollars and that is for the facility Improvement grant that we got so there was a million do taken off of that contract and the 264 987 that's the environmental grant that we received so
125it lowers those two contract prices by those Grant amounts um allocations that are remaining that do not appear on these Bond reports we still have 32 million for the general contractor to allocate and we have 4.9 million for the mechanical contract that has to be allocated yet and 4.7 million in contingency funds and contingency is if we would need it um so that would be part of our next bond issue um I'm going to present there's two or three options for the next Bond I'm going present them in March and then the board's going to have a month so they can think about it Ally from Rond jeam is going to come in April and she's going to explain in better detail um the best way for us to go I'll give you a recommendation
126in March you can think about it and then Aly will come in April and then you can vote on it I know I'm asking a crystal ball question but has Ally said anything about rates she has um the rates are she they're predicting the rates are going to P fairly steady oh okay all right okay thank you yeah I just was like it's so vable out there that okay all right that's good news yeah I talked to her a couple of times the projection is for us to take this next Bond in June originally we weren't going to take it till September um but I think we're going to our recommendation is going to be to take it in June and there'll be a reason why and it'll have to do with being able to
127invest a little bit better okay all right okay thank youcome anybody else have any other questions on these reports just one of the question do we are we still looking for other grants that possibly pop yes under the governor's budget for 2526 the facility approvement Grant is supposed to be come again I believe it's 111 million is what he has budgeted but it's unclear right we're still looking at that possibility oh yeah yeah any gr that comes out will apply for um I am Cen um the EP reports for October November and December I'll give you the balance at December that's 5 mil 15654 this is equivalent to six months of Reserve we are required to hold four months of Reserve so we're in good standing with that anybody have any questions we keep it
128at 6 we keeping it to keep it have to take out after wasn't there something person where once it gets up so far we have to come back no not we have to keep but we're not required to take anything out if we get above I know in the past um funding holidays have been taken right um at you run the risk of when you take a funding holiday say you take it in February you run the risk of in March you end up catastrophic right okay um now you didn't pay in that month and you had catastophic claim and now you're B reserv Timmy in in the past you recall at what level we were at when we took a funding holiday January February of 21 is the last time a funding holiday it
129was that two months we're taking in a row oh okay but do you recall what level we were at when we did that I can go back and look I just be curious to know if to take two we had to have about seven or eight months in there to take to because you can't just take it I know the the IU board has to approve it and then you guys have to approve it right um so it's not the business manager just can't decide not to that right I just wondered at what level we were at when we took the last one I can go back and look B my guess would be seven or eight months okay I'd be curious to know that is this is probably a really dumb question can you
130please explain to me what a funding holiday is um it's so every month we pay our premium for every person that's on our on our health insurance we pay um a certain amount and we pay that every month but because we're in the consortion if you have more than four months in your fund Reserve you don't have to pay it that month that's called a funding holiday not pay your monthly it's like your monthly bill you wouldn't pay it you could just not ours is just just slightly under a million dollars a month is what pay so let's say we I at and I got board approval for March you would see that that $5 million Reserve next month now will be so we are paying for it one way or another like we're not
131just not paying which would be awesome so we're just yeah I'm confused right it'll come out of it'll come out of our fund balance what what you might explain is why it's to our advantage to not have too much in there you know just pay it when we have to because it it's more M because we keep the money we collect the interest on it's more money here in the district if we don't let it accumulate there any other questions okay uh the next item I have is the audit results from the 2324 audit so I want to start off by saying that the 2324 audit had zeroing this is the third year in a row office they're wonderful they do a really great job um okay so the general fund financial statement through June
13230th 2024 our revenues were 119 million our expenses were 117 million our Revenue exceeded expenses by 1.2 million Revenue was over budgeted by 14, 426 and expenditures were over budgeted by 13,1 199 the general fund balance was increased by 1.2 million which now makes it 31 mil 337 686 these are just the highlights I'm going to get into more detail moving forward um so the revenue part uh the revenue was the 14 million over budget and this breaks it down a little bit so on the local level 5.9 million over budget and you are the reasons why real estate we collected $69,000 more than we had budgeted earned income tax was a million dollar more than budgeted transfer tax $823,000 more delinquent collection delinquent real estate and earned income delinquents it's $823,000 interest this was
133the big a big piece of it interest was 3.1 million Andes last year was a good year for interest so we got more than what we had was budgeted and then miscellaneous 622,000 Sammy I know it's probably a hard number to Budget too the Earned Income Tax your income tax is pretty consistent from year to year okay um so the million extra that would oh the million so that would be increases in salaries not here at the district with our our community that that's that people in our community are making more money money that's just where I was going thank you just what I was thinking okay okay on the state level um the basic Ed and special ed we receive 700 $49,000 more and if you remember um when I presented the final budget
134last year Governor's budget wasn't finalized so I had used the year before numbers um and then we got that after our budget was passed Transportation was $15,000 more mental health and safety grants 200,000 ready to learn 25 million which we did not have any verification until after the govern's budget was asked that we were actually getting that and P reimbursement a million dollar on the federal level another big chunk of that was Esser 3.7 million access reimbursement was a little short 140,000 from what was uh budgeted the title grants uh 588,000 we did not get these actual amounts until much later last year they did go up actually it was kind of up and one down and another but overall between the four grants it was 8,000 more and then other 371,000 for the expenditure
135analysis um the on instruction we were UND spent by 440,000 in support we were under spent by 2.2 million and other which the majority of this is transfers iner money we were overspent by 15, 882 how well so if you take the revenue that we we were over Revenue by 14 million and we were over spent expenditures by 13 million majority of that was uh grant money between ready to learn and eser they're not budgeted for so if you take the overspent the over received in revenue and over expenses it's just grant money coming in and Grant expenses going way back out and they weren't budgeted for because we we didn't know what we were can't um so at the end of the day the budget was on target um our fund balance so our
136fund balance U committ our committed and assigned fund balance is 26 million 4886 that's comprised of future Capital needs of 17.8 million and budget stabilization of 8.6 million um our unassigned fund balance is 4.7 million and then on the cap on our cap Reserve side our fund balance is a total of 55,8 42254 52 million 2 52.9 million is alloc is restricted to capital projects and 2 8 million is restricted to debt obligation and just for fun you take if you take the reports in IMB the 32 million from the cast from the bonds and the 8 million from cap Reserve that was allocated and the 15 million that's left over you come up with the 52 million that's where that 52 so it's not like my $52 million in our Reserve that we're just
137woring that 52 million is allocated to something already it's the bonds are in there it's it's the high school projects all of the cap Reserve projects um just to kind of clear that up future Capital needs of the 17 million that part of the money is um allocated it's not allocated yet but it's the intention for that money is for the other buildings to do the cap cap the project improvements and other buildings without having to borrow again um that might be oh no food service so the Food Service analysis from the audit the revenues for for 23 24 were 3 million the expenditures were 2.4 million fiscal year profit for last year was $62,000 woohoo at July 1st 23 was a996 and our net position at June 30th 2024 is a 393,000 I just
138want to note that on 7122 our net position in food service was a loss of $1.4 million in two years the deficit has decreased by a million so next year she WIP out that should be that should be on the positive side next year when I'm up here that is wonderful news it is wonderful news um does anybody have any questions that's all I have for the audit does anybody have any questions on the audit I'm sure everybody read all5 yes did I just was on there is there a place where it states what would P like you say expenditures is there a certain place where it says what we P for equal fees such as special I know we have a lot of special B it's not in the audit specifically it's not that
139would be something I get from you yes that's I don't I can email that to Dr Conrad and we can share that with the board does anybody else have questions the okay let's move on um the next I have next thing I have is the 2425 budget status um this one's for the general fund more numers I'm sure you're um so at January 31st 20125 we have uh our budgeted Revenue was 111 million 576 444 at January 31st we have collected 85 m431 $45 which is about 76% of our Revenue that we budgeted we have collected so far expenditures budgeted 111 milon 57644 we've expended 54 million 378 520 so we've expended about 50% of our expenses at January 31st um so we have U 84 M I'm sorry it's comparable a last year in
140the last column is last year at this time we collected 84 million so the revenue was comparable we're a little far ahead on the expenses um so I did go back and look at that to see what it was this year we had a third pay in January compared to last year we only had two so that's the difference between and that's salary taxes teasers all that any have any questions on the general fund balance status of this the next one I have is the Food Service budget status at this at January 31st so so far this year um we've collected $1.2 million in revenue and we've expended $1.1 million in expenditures you see it's broken down between whitson's expenditures are our labor in Fringe and other um so at this point we're at $110,000
141profit the projection for this year is $3 million in Revenue $2.6 million in expenses and a $329,000 profit um for the Food Service budget at this point in time we're required by um the department of food and nutrition we either have to start our third year rule of that contract with L or if we're not happy for RFP so we are in the third year um I'm happy with linson's it shows that we're still on the right track with them so I need to start the application process for the third year renewal I don't want to start that application if it's a lot of work if the board is not happy with witson or if they're interested in going out for RFP stay with our staff I think I am happy with what I want
142more chocolate more Tater tops I I do have one question uh looking on 31st January we got 1.3 and you you're saying we're going to get 1.7 in the next four month correct well do do we normally get a higher higher participation in the spring this number doesn't include January's Revenue even though it says January we can't build January until the first week of February so we haven't received oh so that's really December correct okay got it the expenses however are through January the revenue is not okay go so Tammy and I don't know the numbers but I probably around this time last year you were here with projections of how much profit we might and I think I don't remember exactly but it certainly wasn't the 600,000 just around, okay I didn't remember so
143what contributed to that a big portion of what contributed to that is we get reimbursement in the state for uh peers and for social P Social Security that we pay in MH so part of what we get in that reimbursement belongs to it's our from our food service it doesn't get deposited into the Food Service account gets deposited into the general fund account when the Auditors come they do an adjustment they do a calculation based on Food Service employees so some of that reimbursement goes over to them so that's a it's roughly between 00 to $230,000 of Revenue that's not recorded throughout the year it's recorded at the end um during the a okay so that would happen again it would but I don't include it when I do the projection okay so that's what
144my question okay so not that is not included in that 300 again to give you a happy surprise I know I'm just trying makes trying to understand it so that's okay so the next steps will be I'll work with to get the contract done and then it goes to the state the state has to approve it once they approve it then it comes to you to officially approve it as I'm sorry so we're in because we voted in 2023 summer of 2023 we are going we'll be going into year three of a fiveyear contract but the state requires you to renew the contract every year yeah so yeah we're going into year three this summer this is year two we're in yes we voted summer of 203 so in March of 28 we're going to
145have to V do an RFP you don't we don't have a choice then because of the five years correct we have to do do an RFP and then that would be for extending it for potentially another five years with an annual unless they change the rules by them but yes okay all right that's yes and RFP is good for five years with winon but under the food under the state rules we still have to the contract every year because if we don't like this yeah okay so we were never tied to this for the entire five years it's working out really well but it is working out well and then py when would we put on the agenda for us to continue for the one year would that come up I can't we can't even
146submit it to the state until after April 1 so Cory from W and I will work on that so maybe by like may we yeah I think I did it with the proposed budget last year if I remember correctly in May okay I think I did so it be reflected as a future expenditure thanks El meal totals cafeteria meal total oh okay so the C the food service numbers for January our January breakfast meals were 19,000 445 our lunch meal meals were 48727 our after school Stacks were 10,748 and our allart sales were 24,1 15225 and my last item for tonight item H the witson monthly newsletter for December is attached for your review just wanted to highlight one thing that's in the newsletter um Chef Paul teaches uh chefology and this in December he
147did with our PBI students he taught them how to make fruit parfet yoga parf for much he did it in a two-part Series so I thought that was kind of so I wanted to highlight that and that is all I have tonight any have any questions we more after school districts now after school oh my goodness yeah de I saw one all right at this time is there any public comment on this that se the finance questions okay moving on to operations nothing okay moving on Transportation I hear I I hear head shaking all right uh we're going to skip the five minute break and we're going to go to technology sure all right uh I'll hop up just to make it easier now you can all hate me uh first of all good to
148see you everyone thank you board directors for having me uh this presentation is approximately 30 slides that's not an exaggeration now here's the good news about it I have zero intent of taking a lot of time on any of them after the meeting if you want to know more information about any individual topic though that I cover today I will share the presentation with you you'll be able to dig deeper and read a little bit more about it okay um last time we were up there was a proposal to have Gemini the the pro version basically bought for some of our faculty members board of directors asked some questions about we need to little more information about what it would actually do so I put this presentation together to try and answer some of those
149questions and hopefully um flesh out the benefits of us actually getting this for our district um and I'll also provide you enough information you can make an informed decision as you should uh so just really quick the whole purpose of Gemini is to kind of hit these points um and primarily we know that one of the biggest issues we have right now in education is that our teachers are as they say overwork they don't have enough time to accomplish the tasks that are demanded of them Gemini would be a way to actually pull some of that back and make their jobs more efficient uh and possibly even a little bit more effective we'll talk about how which was actually the question of the board as we move forward uh there's a lot of words on
150this slide it doesn't just help teachers it can actually help all aspects of our organization um so again as we get through this I'll show you a little bit more about how there are a section for students as well our District's not pursuing necessarily opening up AI to students right now um however we do know that approximately 20% of our students just based on statistics are likely using AI in their assignments already just not through Pleasant Valley's technology so I threw this on here just to kind of show you the difference between the Gemini app which is free right right now if you log on your cell phone or go on your computer at home you can use the Gemini app um we're actually proposing getting something called Gemini for workspace which is a paid
151version of Gemini uh basically the the major benefits is it actually attaches to our Google Suite so we already pay for an enhanced form of Google for our employees it's what we use for Google Classroom Google Drive Google um sheets Gmail all of those are Google uh applications and J and I would actually attach and bolster up every single aspect of our suite uh it also has better encrypting and encoding and protections for our privacy data if you get the paid version is there sorry Jason is there only one level of the paid version there's actually two different levels okay uh the first level and I'd have to get you the exact quotes there is a a relatively substantial difference in price um the paid version the first one actually has a usage limit so
152basically if you're an employee in the district um I don't remember the exact numbers it might you can use it 100 times but then it shuts off um whereas the premium version is an unlimited amount um and you have to remember that every time you use it it would be anytime you prompt Gemini to do something so even if you're using it to help you with Google Sheets it might take you five prompts to actually get it to do what you're trying to get it to do as you're learning it especially that would be five hits so I I would be seeking probably the premium version if we're looking at a whole annual subscription to make sure our teachers aren't Limited in usage have usage monthly or daily again I would have to look at
153the terms of the actual program and if we're interested in that I'll get you the exact details of that when it actually would be back on the agenda for a proposal um so this is just a real basic what is Gemini I already covered that but I want to include it on here just in case you have more questions and part of this whole process is to as you know our policy was accepted in November part of that policy and I believe was actually Mr gisy had asked about how are we training our faculty members that's part of our policy tomorrow I'll actually be going to the Middle School personally and also the high school to speak with our secondary faculty and present on how they can start utilizing Gemini what it looks like um
154also what it looks like for our students and the implications of the policy that was approved so this is part of that presentation it's going to each our faculty members how to write good prompts and actually use it in a good way um again one of the biggest thing is I look at Gemini as being a starting point um if you have to write a letter if you have to do something like that it's a very quick way to get a a base template um in in a lot of different ways which again I talked about efficiency and time that's exactly what we're creating for people they can spend less time doing some of the mundane tasks that they have to they might spend a half hour writing a lesson plan this can cut that
155time down to about five minutes if they know what they're doing um it does not take away the teacher's independent thought it does not change anything about them professionally it just provides them starting form does a reach our lesson template that to into if we do a lesson template what this would do is you could actually have it create sections of that template for you um more importantly it's kind of a kickoff Point again I'll show you a little bit more about that and it it'll probably help you understand it so it can be used in a whole different way so in this specific example it's actually being used for an educational leader and it creates an an alumni Outreach template so you can basically as a principal Say Hey I want to reach out
156to my alumni get them back involved what's the best way to do that can I get a template set up you type it into Gemini it'll give you a framework and the better your prompt is if you say I'm an administrator at pleas Del high school I want to create an Outreach for this specific thing if might be homecoming I want to include these dates and times I want to have it have interactive feedback with our community it'll create a very strong draft for you to actually move forward with um and again it'll do it very quickly when we talk about Educators and again we're going be talking about this with faculty members as well there's ways that you can actually use it to help you differentiate your lesson plans let's say you're a teacher
157you have this great idea in your head about teaching this lesson or you know you have to teach this skill or this content area you can type in into Gemini and say hey how can I differentiate this I have a student who's at a lower Lexile level or I have a student who has these special SD and it will give you suggestions on how you can modify that lesson plan the professional still needs to do the final work let's be clear this is not taking over the entire responsibility but it will help provide them ideas without them having to sit there and make that third cup of tea at night to try and figure out what they're doing generating quizzes this is actually one of the best ways I've seen it you can actually take
158your entire unit plans in the Gemini and say generate a quiz on this content change the depth of knowledge for question three um and Gemini what it does is basically pulls the internet pulls all these different resources together instead of Reinventing the wheel starts pulling from different school districts and different templates that are already created it pulls from the state standards so it makes sure they're aligned and it'll help generate a quiz so if you need to create a 10 question quiz on grade nine you can have it start to formulate that template for you right again the teacher needs to be the final actor here but it'll give you a start Jason let me ask you a question you were so I'm thinking about you know we've talked a lot about common form of
159Assessments right and and you know I know working on uh as as with my departments uh in in previous roles it's always a challenge of getting you know maybe five or six teachers in this particular content area let's say algebra one for example to find time to meet first right to then go through the curriculum and then to kind of take either something that's not there to create it or to modify something that you know they're unaware of so what you're saying is that this could essentially help to shave off time because you could still get the end product of common formative assessments which then would afford our teachers to be able to compare how the kids are doing again not not like a Carro and stick mentality it's just hey let's look at our
160data Maybe is there something um resource that you used that the kids maybe understand in a different way rather than this but you're saying at the end of the day if you put in the right you know criteria we we can get that group of five or six teachers to say hey here's here's a great Common Assessment so what I'm getting at is it takes a lot less time to do a very daunting task that we all like you know have participated in is that what you're saying ex because that's kind of mind-blowing to me honestly is exactly I'm saying and and I'll go a step further you can literally um highlight or tell Gemini what specific Pennsylvania standard you're trying to hit fantastic and it will also align those questions to that standard um
161while AI is not perfect I'll be the first person to admit this right there are issues with AI where it can produce hallucinations or possibly generate some biases it gives you a very very strong kickoff point and we all know that a lot of times when you're meeting as a department half troubles just starting to get the penal so if you can start with hey let's plug them into Gemini it's going to generate 10 question for us now we can review these questions Department change the questions question you're not creating those questions you're starting from that's great what about the format the format you can change so I'm just saying so you want you're giving 10 quiz maybe you want five multiple choice that's something they would you tell it you you can literally type
162I want the first five questions to be multiple choice I want the last five questions short answer on I want one a question that is comparing and contrasting offs how much time did that have save this well that's know random here's the 10 questions I want you to shuffle them around ab and go a step further we're talking about this now if we looking at our district what we already have we can take that as a base template we can then plug those questions into performance matters right and now our school district that has common assessments that were also partially generated with the use of AI again they're still the teacher questions right um we can plug that into performance matters and now we can actually track that in life time and start comparing how
163that's working with so it's it's for me it's all about helping our teachers become more efficient and effective it's not replacing them it's not taking their academic Integrity it's not taking their independence as a teacher it's just helping them kick off ideas yeah I have a question so can you create in in general prompts that that all teachers can access so for instance does every teacher have to generate a unique prompt for what they're trying to accomplish or can I have is there a jumping Point like hey there's a shared thing where uh I need to create a lesson plan and so any teacher can kind of get like a basic um outline of what they're looking for and then kind of adapt to their needs is there something that you can create like a
164I guess a repository a central repository or do they all have to generate that themselves every time individually I think as as a district one of the things that we can do to go with this as a resource is we could actually start plugging little short tidbits on that Google Classroom to say hey if you're generating a lesson plan start with this PRP it'll help standardize it we could also do something where um again we're looking at having more collaborative time for our teachers and more Department time and more team time um especially again primarily we're looking at this the secondary Lev especially to start um because when you're looking complexity of lesson plans and how they generated and what they actually are it's a little bit more conducive to that level right now but
165I do think that to to kind of go back to what you're saying rob I think we can actually have it set up where we can provide this kind of stuff the program itself may not like using this template from Pleasant Valley like it's not going to remember that as a as a thing but we give it the right um information up front and again it goes back to that first question of training tomorrow we're going to be talking about how do you create good prompts we're gonna have garbage that's why I know there's other have we looked at other potential AI things like I know there's like School magic for instance is a big one which has built in that's why I asked that question like I want to create a l plan and
166it kind of has like a button more object oriented I guess yes and less um programming is if that makes sense to youa you're type I I'm a big fan of um of AI right I used it I use my kid for instance he has chemistry right I will tell it generate me a high school level quiz on these on these objectives and give me uh give me an answer key because I don't know what I'm looking at so I get all right now you take this quiz and see if it matches right I can kind of look it up I can actually do that and I use it that's how I do it but I want to make sure that we're paying for something but implementing it in a way that you know we're
167paying for something but we're using it right because I don't want to be too hard and people then get turned off like so I want to be very easy and I and I use it myself I understand when writing prompts if you don't write that prompt right you're not going to get what you want so and just knowing that we have a wide variety of Staff members skill level with the computers right I just don't want to be paying for a whole District license and then we have a small contingent of people that are really leveraging it there will be people that obviously yeah we're maximizing that if you're okay with it let me come back to that because there's that's going to be like the last part no it's a really good question though
168um moving on creating new material based on existing assessments so you can also do it the reverse way you can actually plug in the assessment and then you can create material to help you teach that assessment so you know so while you're looking at generating quizzes off the material if you have a common assessment that you know you have to get to by the end of the the unit and you have a new teacher that's not quite sure how to get there this might actually help them generate a formulated plan to get there so so you're kind of associated to like wi's like understanding by Design backward planning here's what we want to be able to master and let's kind of map this out then Jason can I take that step further to say okay
169well we're GNA you know um focus on like binomials and trinomials and let's say that we want to you know finish that up within three weeks right because here's what the assessment is then not only does it um focus in on the content but then the pacing of the instruction you know that that would go to show growth in that particular you know um area that they should show knowledge of is that correct yes and you can also again doing that if you're doing correctly could even say knowing that we're going to have three days to cover this material give me three differentiated activities that highlight different learning um modes for students give me something that's Hands-On give me something that is um verbal give me something visual give me something's real life application okay
170so let let me sorry I have a lot of questions so let me ask this a little bit like let me take this step further right so I have 18 kids in my class um I have three students that are struggling Learners one is identified with an IP could I take you know now what's generated as the pacing and say how can I modify this for a student that is learning at a you know a grade level behind and and would it give me like or could you ask it for um certain modifications or you know um maybe different prompts that help that student understand the language and semantics are a little bit different like could it get that granular it can it can um it's it's all on how you're using your prompts and
171how you're choosing to keep because every time it gives you a result you can then ask at another prompt based on that result okay so if you choose to you can just keep on digging and digging and digging and digging and every time you do that prompt what it's actually doing is Google searching if you will this gigantic repository of things that are already out there and then it compiles that information and bed into something that's palatable so imagine a large research paper except you're not having to go through every single resource yourself it's just because that's what we do now we click through 15 links to finally get what we want because we compile that as Educators but now you're saying you kind of can get it for us which which again as I'm
172listening to you I mean it seems like one of the biggest benefits is the the time saving that our teachers and and staff don't have and and I I'm I'm there with them because you don't you have limited time to do what we need to do within our given time time but the question that I'm always asking is like what can we do better um how do we collaborate how do we take something and and modify it to meet the students needs so I mean that's that's pretty I didn't know it could do I know it could do a lot but that's kind of mind maybe this is a really dumb question but you know we're always telling our kids or grandkids you know you can't believe everything that's out there on the internet so
173how do we know that this information is correct information this this is part of what's up to the educator and one of the things that we're going to be talking about is how do you actually go back to make sure your information is correct um our educators are Professionals in their craft they're professionals they're knowledgeable about their content right so as they're pulling this information back they've already created lesson plans for this skill and content so they're going to be able to vet this right away and be like wow this isn't quite hitting what I'm looking for or they're going to go look at be like oh no this is actually hitting exactly what I wanted to hit um additionally if there's ever a question they can still go the old school route of looking
174up you know what is the standard for this you know like anytime a teacher does a project and they're creating a rubric it's up to that educator to go back and ultimately compare that to the standard and say does this really get what it's supposed to be doing that piece of the process cannot be left out what we're trying to make more efficient is the initial part of coming up those ideas writing those ideas down trying to differentiate coming up with all these different accommodations we have to do now we can take something that we start with and say you know what let's see what this can do for me let's see where it starts so I'm going to keep going here a couple more questions I think is going to help I can create
175a lesson hook um this actually attaches straight to Google Classroom which is awesome because if a teacher is doing a lesson in Google Classroom you can actually use the AI within Google classro to again start creating your own ideas syi oh my gosh one of the best things about a I has to be be creating syllabi and rubrics I kind of nerd out over this because as a teacher I used to hate creating rubrics it's extremely difficult to actually create a meaningful rubric that is objective right um because I would write something down I be like wow that is such a subjective column I need to get rid of this and you start over and they're like wait a minute why is my number three more rigorous than my number four I got to start
176overing um this you can do it and again because of the database like some that are already out there it it does phenomenal work creating rubrics so again huge time saer quickly just telling what's important so we talked about how you can use it to kind of get a kickoff point this is kind of looking at the other way how can we actually analyze data how can we look at things quickly by using streamline research process I already talked about that right now we can go on Google Scholar pull up all kinds of articles read all kinds of stuff or you can type it in Gemini and it's going to summarize stuff for you it's going to come up with the general trends of current research recap emails my absolute one of my absolute favorite
177features when when I was testing this personally is you have those people who send you those really longwinded emails um I talk I don't send the long email guys myemail never send the long email you pull this up it'll actually recap the entire conversation and bullet points for you if you want to so if you have [Applause] all right soul um no if you have like 20 different response or different people talking it'll actually summarize Jason said Susan said Johnny said um and it'll give you the summary and the highlights and yes it will write a draft to respond Jason could could you use that I'm curious so let's say um a high I'm just thinking high school high school teacher is using um a prompt and so they email out a prompt what it
178go to the training tomorrow just to hold it and go to the training tomorrow forget it no I'm just scary so so but no I forgot about tomorrow uh you can ask questions about your Google drive as well so um one of the best ways to use it is if like on my email uh let's say I knew I got an email from Dr Conrad I don't remember what the subject line was but I knew what the content was kind of and I really need to go back and reference this email I can type in Gemini hey find the email from Dr Conrad where he was talking about professional development and it's smart enough to be able to search my email and find the correct one pull it up so I don't have to know
179the I don't have to do this it's it is to a degree but when you understand how ad is working in the algorithm it's not as scary as you think it's looking for keywords and it's looking for identifiable material with but again when you're talking about time saving it's there um formulas and data analysis I actually recently used this I was working in a Google sheet we were doing a massive grade upload for pbba and I was trying to do something where I could figure out how I could upload grades or detect whether or not a student or credit which sounds really easy but when you're talking about two quarters you have to get the average then you have to discover that it's a semester level course so basically what you end up doing is
180a bunch of if then statements was the stud like is this a credit course or is it a half credit course did this student earn above a 65% if yes then give