CorpusRecord 148190

01.09.25 PV BoE Board Meeting / Working Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Pleasant Valley School District
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Monroe County, PA
Material
Transcript
Extent
33,297 words · about 185 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001cring my oh 15 that's wrong yes I told you you're good good good evening everyone I'd like to call the Pleasant Valley School District Board of Education meeting to order if we could all rise for the Pledge of Allegiance and then if we could please stay standing for a moment silence and please keep the poor State of California in our thoughts and prayers this evening and let's see uh Mr Clark would you lead us please down there to of the United States of America and to the stand One Nation God indivisible liy and justice for all thank you everyone sorry again I'd like to welcome everyone that's with us this evening and if we could have roll call please present present pres here here thank you I would like to let everyone know that we

002did have an executive session this evening prior to the meeting uh for uh purposes of personnel matters including but not limited to Performance an discipline negotiations and legal issues uh we have some student highlights this evening yes um so just wanted to inform everyone that uh the month of January is board appreciation month and uh this month we will have uh some wonderful you know presentations and uh information presented from our students and unfortunately you can't see in front of you but there are some post or posters uh from our students and from our uh our staff and then obviously uh on this board over here as well so uh we obviously know all the hard work that our board uh puts forth uh for our school district and I believe we have a presentation

003this evening from the elementary schools all right um so good evening everybody um we did just want to take a few minutes to express our gratitude so on behalf of PVE and PDI tonight laen and I are here to just let you know how thankful we all for all of you um we know that there's a lot of work that goes into this and we're very grateful for everything that you do for our staff our students um the whole Community um but really for for us and Roger and I say this every day what it comes down to is the kids and that's really why you guys are here and why we're all here so that's what we want to share with you guys tonight because they can say it far better than I ever

004could um so you will see a video from our PV students expressing their gratitude um did to that also um we also on behalf of our students and our staff we just have to take this opportunity to express our gratitude and dedication to your leadership um as a building as building leaders you know we seek get to see firsthand the positive impact uh that your decisions have on our school Community every day um your commitment uh to Quality education fostering Innovation prioritizing our Student Success is admired um and we just would like to really take this opportunity to thank you and the kids can do it better than we can all tell on for [Music] okay that was one for e for for for you EX for e I don't know that's those both are

005really great I I want to know who comes up with all the ideas we're going to keep that so that we can just keep surprising you no it's definitely a team effort and and I so many people did help us with it um but really just wanted to again say thank you to you guys and we certainly appreciate it thank you so very much thank you we moving on moving on okay okay so moving on in the agenda um so it's the opportunity to respond to community questions so uh this week there were five Community questions that were submitted uh the first was from uh Kevin bilsky from P Township had submitted a question for the athletic department uh this question was sent over to Athletics uh and they have reached out to him but

006I just want to encourage um anyone that if you have questions regarding things such as schedules and teams please feel free to reach out to the athletic uh Department the question was about um when uh trials would be for upcoming uh sporting events so just again reach out and uh certainly we'll be able to get you a response pretty quick in that regard uh the next four uh questions come from Denise hopley from Chestnut Hill town ship so the first question was regarding the school board and um do they have input into the renovations uh bids and budgets so the bids were discussed with all the board members um they all had uh received information in particular the last two years um we had gone over uh different plans uh some changes with the um

007uh with the renovation project of the high school and ultimately the board uh had the opportunity to decide um which bids they want to approve for the renovation project uh all the board members voted uh back on December of 2024 the second question was regarding spending money on inov in I'm sorry Renovations for courses where there are no teachers in stem areas um we actually do have teachers with certifications in stem areas um as we look ahead for the next school year in particular we're working towards infusing uh cross-curricular opportunities using that stem space um for for really engaging our students on uh multi levels uh of of learning so we're excited for that uh the third question was regarding whether additional staff would be hired and what effect it would have on the tax

008base um so there's currently no plan to add additional administrators or teachers for the 25 26 school year uh negotiations uh with our teachers union um has not started officially so uh we currently don't know what the impact negotiations will have on our school budget um we know that teachers are hired uh based upon the needs of our students and in fact this school year uh we saw an increase in our kindergarten um uh enrollment so we made the adjustments and hired three new teachers in kindergarten as a result of that so obviously it's our responsibility and our diligence to look at the trend data see um where are some of the gaps make sure that people have the proper certifications in order to hire the best staff for our students and then the final

009fin question um was do the board members have input into Renovations and the answer is yes uh all board members have an opportunity to provide input into the renovation project they had opportunities when that information was presented and uh we're really happy with their input because it helps to drive uh an excellent and exciting renovation project that we'll soon be encountering at the high school at the end of this school year so uh thanks for your questions thank you do thank you Dr Conrad uh moving on in our agenda uh at this time Mrs smil secretary's report please good evening I requesting approval of the minutes of the meetings held on December 5th 2024 and December 16 2024 and approval of the January 9th 2025 board meeting agenda so move second I have a motion

010by Mr gazis and seconded by Mrs zip is there any discussion all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone opposed and motion carries at this time is there any Pleasant Valley citizens that would like to address the board if so it's on agenda items only at this time please come to the podium state your name in the township you reside in and there is a three minute limit Jen Hill Township um I just have a few comments on agenda items e 4B CB and e um there was just a lot of things on the uh accounts payable um that you wrote Teck for that I was concerned about um there was two separate things on there it was $10,000 each grants um to people I was just curious who those people were

011um Isabella root and Emily compet I said that wrong um agenda item 4C there was $8,600 payment for dues and fees I was just curious what those dues and fees were for uh there was $151 payment to Aces Gourmet I was just curious whose meals the taxpayers were paying for um and then there was two separate payments for over $27,000 um to Fox Rothchild which is a a law firm I believe um those two payments together more than the salary of a beginning teacher just in one month um just curious if they were Grievances and arbitration that could have somehow been avoided um would probably be better if everybody worked together to find a satisfactory solution and a positive work environment instead of resorting to arbitration that's all thank you thank you hi um Evelyn

012denovo Chestnut Township um item four B treasurers report um who is Isabella an root and why is she getting $10,000 Grant um forc of the treasurer's report um procurement card which is a credit card um there is a dues and fees expenditure of $867 uh can we have a breakdown of that amount and how many people are allowed to use that procurement card um thank you thank you Michael keing chest Hill Township concerning F4 financial statement tuition payments to outside Charter and cyber schools how were you getting kids back to the building this was one of comrades goals doesn't seem to be working out November CCA was paid $100,000 thank you thank you good evening I'm Denise Hy just Township we're close on the questions um for the what I had written in because I

013wanted to know since we don't have them teaching those classes Robotics and physics uh they're sub subcontracted what agenda item are you referring to the questions that well that's you have to wait afterwards okay do not exactly write the question okay so questions I have here because there's two of the ones that aren't clear that you talked about at all all right all right so I'm going on okay agenda items please correct B C D and F financial statements the administration must urgently address the persist persistent issues it faces with unions it raises the question is this Administration unions you you specific what what is the spe the specific question this one would be f with the financial statements so what about the financial okay so what is what what's the question specific to the

014financial statement what's on the document so exactly right piggy backing on um Mrs rudol you seem always get a question from me I follow R and here goes my time eating up so the question is why are we address why are we spending so much money on perhaps arbitration and union dues Union Fe sorry arbitration and matters when you guys are supposed to be going to uh so I guess a better question is why aren't we promoting conflict resolution okay because um unfortunately that that presupposes that those those dollars are specific to Union why we asking but we don't have an answer but but of course so that can't be a why do you always challenge me or question me or bully me with questions when I'm trying to ask a question because you're asking

015you're asking a question outside the wrong or inside the wrong comment period did you not pay now you're eating up all my time did did you not pay did you not pay money to did you not pay money to did you not pay money to Fox and Rob child over $27,000 and what are they for arbitration what are they for okay the point the question is why aren't weing using conflict resolution and why is Administration being trained with conflict resolution in their administrative training okay and I don't know why because why does it always have to be grieved just send it to grievance that's a question that's a question that's why we're paying all this money okay that's a question all right and and the other thing is we need to work are we working

016toward anal Solutions anal an Solutions understanding that it's not negotiable for all these stakeholders we need a positive environment we need to sit down and talk we I I'm going to interrupt you Denise I'm sorry because I think at next meeting you're going to see some resolutions to some things come up but you just need we are working together we are trying to work with the unions we work very well with the support staff Union we are going we are working with the uh teachers union also and you're going to see some resolutions how much money was spent for the taxpayers that we paying all these leg fees for what we don't know because we don't know so all I'm saying is I don't think griev is the solution conflict resolution is okay the next

017question I have is uh the multiple arbitrations we talked about um furthermore the riseing cost of cyber education how are we bringing back those costs with bringing students back into the building um we uh remain hopeful for these changes however um Outsourcing teachers positions with business and physics and Robotics and paying $100,000 to CCA for the taxpayers to be burdened with I don't think that's the solution either why aren't our own teachers teaching it why is we actually hit about four and a half minutes so well if I were able to ask my questions instead of being little or whatever doing there question hold the questions that first first of all all my question first of all let's be clear if you're to come up here it's a comment period it's not a question and

018answer period with the board second secondly secondly the comments Andor questions that you have raised were outside of agenda items okay well listen this is we can agree to disagree I guess but this is but ma'am this is not your meeting this is the me this is the meeting of the board this is the meeting of the board and this is is their business meeting so if they decide and frankly with my guidance that this is something that comes at the second comment period it would come at the second comment period Well we can agree and disagree because they are all on the agenda okay we will move on on the P Treasures report Mrs surface please yes good evening tonight I need a motion for item 4 A through h a second I have

019a motion by Mr gisi seconded by Mrs zip is there any discussion I just like I'm not going to answer questions but like for D they're talking about legal we have there's such things as special education includ that like that yeah yeah yeah and I I wasn't going to bring that but certainly there are a plethora of other issues that that occur in this District well beyond grievance issues for instance within the last month the district has embarked on a TENS of million Expansion Project which required legal guidance surrounding the the bids the awarding of those bids and how to comply with various regulations surrounding a very significant building project so I presume a lot of that is probably dedicated to that and not the grievance arbitration issues there's also is there assessment type things

020going on with there are assessment issues there are other ancillary issues anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I anyone opposed and that motion par I have to abstain from uh four agenda item 4E check 2427 4 six because of relative all right um moving on to unfinished business um Mr Fitzgerald there is no unfinished business this thank you is there any other unfinished business I the email out about the how Thea was selected um yeah it's just we have a curriculum update in the working session okay I just you know it's like it's coming around can you wait till working session thank you anyone else okay moving on to new business Monro Career and Technical Institute yes good evening my report is attached there was no meeting for the month of

021January so we'll be giving an update in February also February I believe Mr will be here to discuss the budget and thank you uh colonal IOU Mr Galler report is such nothing else okay thank you uh psba liaison Mrs Z nothing for the session okay education report um just wanted to bring to your attention that the during our working session which will follow this evening's meeting we are having a curriculum overview presentation and also um there will be discussion on the 2526 program of studies for both the high school and the Middle School uh Finance report Mrs surface yes that will come up later on in the agenda thank you Mr o'keef athletic yes hello happy New Year so as uh all our athletic athletes uh at our all our schools uh while we were

022on vacation those of us who were on vacation our student athletes were practicing and having tournaments and having games as well uh so just a couple highlights I don't have them all um but I do have a few highlights I do want to note wrestling on Saturday September 28th PB boys wrestling did an outstanding job at the 2024 Frank W tournament in tanic with nine individuals placing winners and second place overall as a team more recently on January 4th 20202 PB boys wrestling were awarded team Champs at the South Williamsport wrestling tournament with 10 individuals placing winners and seven medalists on Saturday January 4th our cheer team the PB Varsity Cheer Place second at The District 11 cheer championships and erab the states which will be held on January 30th and 31st in ring Pennsylvania

023um I also want to have a huge shout out to the nazer che team and Coach they took a Saturday morning to allow our girls to go down to their school and as natur as a Powerhouse in cheer and all other sports too uh took their opportunity and helped our girls so I you know huge shout out to them I know none of them are watching us or listening to us but um I think it's awesome to hear that you know that that camaraderie it's uh it's not just about us it's about everybody getting together and making it work just like a community uh lastly 2024 uh Lehi scholar athletes had two from soccer one from boys and one from girl soccer the girls soccer is uh Brianna palmary and boys was Zachary Prader so

024great job to those two individuals uh and just looking forward for the rest of the athletes and sports as they continue through the winter seasons uh there's some been great turnouts at the opportunities I've had to attend the events so keep it up community and great job thank you thank you uh policy report Mrs Z just there's two policies on for first reading this evening thank you Capital Improvement uh Mr burer is attending another meeting um but we have not had a meeting um since the uh special meeting that we had on December 16th to award the bit so nothing new to report technology report Mr Clark uh nothing for you to report this time thank you Mr Walter security I do have something uh the two vehicles that were approved for security over the

025summer have finally been picked up and are in use um with the security Personnel we thank them for adusting up to this point but we're glad they they're F here wonderful we should have had them here on display like we did we been a great opportunity everyone wonder what's going on all right superintendent reports uh tonight my two items are informational okay moving on uh Human Resources Mrs just I just looked at the attendance type thing and last year 30 2% of our students were not in brick and mortar this year is 33% so it's not a drastic increased amount of people that are out our thumbers are down but I just it's been consistently um sorry Human Resources Mrs yes good evening tonight I'm seing a PO of items 8 B to 8h item

026a iation so move second motion by Mr Walters seconded by Mr Clark is there any discussion yes I must abstain from 8D five 6 s and eight spouse anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I I I anyone opposed and that motion carries approval of items 9 through 9 item 9 e is informational some second a motion by Mrs Surface seconded by Mr Galler is there any discussion all those in favor please signify by saying I anyone opposed and that motion carries moving on to curriculum Dr how I have approve item second I think Mr risi on the motion and Mr Walters on the second is there any discussion yes so we're voting on this and I see this was an award ceremony is there any update on what we got there

027will be at the next board meeting so I'm going to ask everyone to wait anticipation okay okay Co for anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I anyone oppos and that motion carries I'm also seeking approval of item 11 a so move second motion by Mr Galler second by Mrs zip is there any discussion could you just give a highl why yes we are working with Monroe he County um and they are working with us that instead of just um going straight issuing um find we going to have KS try a program um when the first that's be run [Laughter] through anyone else I do so okay with regards to debate I know it's not specifically to this topic but do we have in our bathrooms that the um no I understand

028that but do we have notifications that that this premises is being monitored and the reason I asked is I was at the district 11 championships at East Middle School and it was clear in English and Spanish that these These are being monitored so if we don't give those folks opportunity we're going to be stupid enough to do it at least we told you not to do it and we're monitoring I don't think it happens a lot in our evening events I think it is happening during the school day but I think it's been it should be for every you should that's the rule yeah I don't know if there's not in the bathroom I really don't stay outside right outside before they enter there so they know it's actually when you walk into you know

029there a split bathroom and you turn left to go into the men's room obviously where I went to and that's where it was in English and Spanish I do not believe we have that something I I just think we be especially as we no visitors yeah hey don't be stupid but also to people who are there every day anyone else maybe we get a picture of that Mr ginski if you reach up to the whiteall athletic director East excuse me all right all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries operations Mr SE approval it so Mo second motion by Mr Galler seconded by Mr Walters is there any discussion all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries moving on

030to business management business requesting approval of items 13 B 13 I it 13 second motion by Mr surfus seconded by Mr gazis is there any discussion yes I have some explanations of B one and two boundless Federal funding it says uh cost category one is600 Category 2 3% assistance for us to OB the program which is funding for techology so we what I'm saying is the E Grant is there and then this person want to write for us or they help us obtain it and they proper materials that can go under that and it's no that's and that other one which is second one yeah that's going to be this actually for Mass notifications so um we were looking into Blackboard connect as having some issues right we've all discussed that final site is actually

031going to be one of the solutions final site was the owners of black board connect so we are shifting away from that and the re this is actually changing so we got rid of that Mas notification fees as of July one we're shifting providers but they're still providing our website so this is just that contract change anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I all right anyone opposed and that motion [Laughter] carries second I have a motion by Mrs surfus seconded by Mr gazis is there any discussion I I'm not sold on I'm just go into it more about what the actual contract is but $42,000 one year to help short um so there's there's a lot more to it than just that one aspect is actually integrated with all of our

032platforms at this point so whether it be me whether it be slid whether it be um you know Gmail like all of it has that attached to it so the ability to modify change um utilize it to it makes things more efficient the best way to put it so it's not writing lessons or anything like that as a matter of fact when we doove the policy it's not to be used for that but it is to help Engage andh The Learning of our students um by making the job a little more efficient and more um comprehensive for our teachers so there's a lot more to it than just like oh it's it's a less rning software um there is TR is going to be provided for oury on this in February it's going to give

033them much more in depth on how they utilize it and what they can actually do with it um but that's was there a plan B as far as this isn't accepted well plan B is to stay status qu right I mean when we're looking at uh how we can enhance uh you know and and honestly even the innovation of where education is going part of this is so our teachers and faculty members can learn about this tool and therefore be able to communicate it better with your students um we are moving into a generation where AI is going to be used much more by our students moving forward and I do think that moving forward our faculty should have a much better grasp of what it can do and utilize that um and also learn

034what it looks like so they can also identify when students are using it and how they can help the use appropriately large majority are so go ahead are we a front runner here or other schools in this District are the teachers um using any whether it's gemini or any other type of uh AI technology there are other schools that are using AI technology I would say that we are um I don't want to use the word front runner because that makes it sound like we're the first group to do it and that's not the case at all um different different schools are using different AI applications um we chose Je I because it does incorporate with what we're using which our Google platforms um so that was the choice and we did look at multiple

035platforms and we identify option would it be detrimental if we ask for this to be tabled and have a discussion or bring us additional um research not research but maybe even a sample of what it does at our next work session absolutely I mean I guess I would you know for 42 when I the 42,000 just like I went you know and you know I'd like to understand it better you know um that's that's just me personally but I mean I understand it's grant money but still you know um I personally would like to understand the usage of it more than um but that's me so I don't know what the pleasure would be here are you making a motion to the table then I and then just kind of go off of that do

036we do we have a breakdown of what percentage of it would be grand funded like is it 25% say again okay that is actually larger than I thought so it's like 75% I just want to clarify I hear I heard a couple folks willing to suggest a motion to table has there been a motion to table or not yet I know that's I mean I don't make a motion but I mean I can I would like to make a motion to table I'll second all right generally there's no debate on on a procedural motion so we would just vote to see if it's tabled if it's tabled it can always come back at a At a next legislative session all the any more discussion oops sorry you told me I couldn't do that I'm so

037used to it uh all those in favor hold on are we favoring of table or we favoring of would vote Yes to table it it's just to table it's just to table it the item yeah okay all those in favor yes anyone to post okay so it is Ted y okay moving on under new business Mr Fitzgerald uh just very briefly and this is a kind of breaking legal news uh this evening um there was a um we had met this several months ago with regard to Title 9 and uh new regulations went into place in August um and then a whole bunch of lawsuits ensued uh one of which actually occurred in I believe it's the sixth uh circuit um Kentucky Tennessee Indiana that area well today actually was yesterday um a a a

038federal judge in the circuit issued a nationwide injunction on the rule thus and we were already under kind of a separate injunct injunction issue in Kansas it's now over in other words the the regulations from August are are dead um I I do not anticipate that the the Trump Administration will uh want to advocate for uh President Biden's uh regulations so at this point I would anticipate we're back to the previous regulations which were put in place by President Trump before uh that makes complete sense uh so and I think there will actually be more on that topic as we get into the new administ anyway but nevertheless what was pretty significant legal changes in the summer are now are now no longer applicable so just want to give you that update thank you uh

039Pleasant Valley citizens at this time would you anybody like to address the board again there's a three minute limit please come to the podium and state your name in the township that you reside in please hi and gravel pul um I took P last meeting when someone on the board said well it's only a $3 raise I did some math I'm going to use my tax bill as an example my tax bill for school taxes last year was $3,834 92 which means I have to come up with a monthly Inc monthly amount of $395 just to pay that tax bill alone the average salary in this county is $50,000 which reads monthly someone makes $3,846 155 out of that you have to subtract the $319 58 I have to pay every month so I can

040pay my school taxes out of that again I'm using my own personal rounding my electric bill is $290 my capable bill is $190 I paay $400 a month for my medical insurance I pay basically $200 a month per gas and I pay roughly $100 towards my County Township bill which by the way is going up okay both on the township level and on the county level so that figure will go up okay with all that I'm down to $1,080 and 84 cents a month out of that I still did not take out my home insurance which is basically $167 a month my car insurance which is $160 a month okay and now I haven't even that takes me down to8 $800 a month I have not done food clothing credit cards and go the bed

041I have a car payment how is the person supposed to live $800 a month when you say it's only $3 it's a lot of money for somebody maybe you guys think long and hard on how much you raise our taxes because we are getting hit on every single aspect and like I said I took offense it's only $3 to yield may only be $3 but to the senior citizen down the street who has to pay $300 for one medication and we all know they do it this is absolutely ridiculous the amount of money you guys are asking from us we don't have it anymore you guys have to do something thank you to live your Denise CH Hill Township uh so Mr Fitzgerald um why did you answer for the board um um you know

042when you answered me because you even stated that you're just an advisor and you shouldn't be making up the mind for the board so that's how I interpret it you're just an advisor the board can answer if they want you shouldn't be answering for them okay um the other thing I have is that I wanted to say about the Grievances instead of the griev grievance effect um why aren't the administrators being personally accountable for these kind of cost and Fe and unjust actions um people know what's going on and at a minimum the behavior should warrant a reprimand in their permanent records and save and serve as a mark against their professional history why is there no escalated reprimand for individuals who repeatedly engage in the same type of detrimental Behavior work it out conflict

043resolution we shouldn't be spending all this money it's unacceptable the Su the superintendent who leads them allows the griev approach and continue to go unchallenged we have to improve these negotiation skills overall in communication with the administration faculty and staff and we already addressed the Cyber with the teachers having something um all of jobs going somewhere else with Ingenuity instead of having our own teachers who are fabulous okay now down to the questions I don't know if it was I I have them here right in front of me so the question I had was which board members had input into the renovation bids and budgets and then the other question I had was why are we spending the money on Renovations for Robotics and physics when we don't even have the teachers in house because

044you're going to use stem for other areas but that's not my understanding instead we have to subcontract out those courses too um you answered some of the questions and I'm just going to finish with this when you hold all the documents related to these questions you are out you are the only one who can answer these questions therefore you hold all the answers why are you dodging it you you would prefer all stakeholders follow don't ask so I won't tell and that's not going to happen here Jenna Rudolph test Hill Township um Mr a at the December meeting you had asked about B at Ed puzzle in 99 math um Mrs Howard responded that Ed puzzle we stopped Lo using last year and she said quote we have taken nothing away this year um but

045that statement is directly contradictory to what was communicated to the faculty in November um they were received information that they would not be allowed to use those three items after winter break so technically um Dr Howard knew that they would be going away and I believe she chose to sidestep an actual correct answer which is still in my opinion not good um also in the presentation with the Bear's Academy Mr Presby showed a clip of a student using blet um secondly at the December meeting Dr congrad stated he has no problems giving administrators Flex time for obligations that go beyond their Crow trct duties um but it doesn't seem that the same courtesy is given to faculty members who are sometimes hounded for not volunteering for things outside of school in their contact Tool hours

046um in addition or similar to that was the lro um I know last year teachers were paid $58 an hour through a grant um this year we talked about it it was discussed at the board meeting they paid what I believe it was 35 um which is through the district and I understand that the grant money ran out um but I do believe that the program is still just as important and the teachers time outside of school day is just as valuable um it was insinuated that it was a lack of interest on the part of the teachers and I don't believe that's actually the case case um and the last thing at the December 5th meeting uh Mr gazis recommended a Community Committee and I know that was brought um off and wasn't talked

047about um Mrs kesby you said it could be discussed at or sorry it mentioned that it had to be for a specific reason um and I was going to talk a little bit more about that but I do see that it's on your working session agenda for tonight so I am glad to see that thank you okay seeing no one else approach the podium uh Pleasant Valley School directors does anyone have anything this evening on everybody I know you might know theal number the the total number is that if all students get the minimum required grade from the respective concurrent schools we have the potential of our students earning 403 college credits while they are high school um other PD PBI yeah she's there are you guys how is it going with subs and your

048reading specials and and math specials are they still being used to an extent um all I know with all this testing coming up things like really hope that we're not pulling them for Subs when they should be working with our students because that and I see the worry look on your face I'm going to answer this because testing is this week so I'm like going back to the staff absences in my head trying to remember exactly what it would like um we have had Subs in there was actually two people I could never seen before today which was nice to see um so we are getting some um new Subs in which is really nice to see um I won't say that there were no I can tell you that no math Specialists will today

049I do believe reading Specialists uh did help out today during reading testing whether or not they were the ones testing or they were covering classroom I can't be 100% sure I've just been on a regular basis on a regular Cod just use our need be of course we do um but it definitely I think my perspective has been definitely better this year even than last year so our first is we will go for a sub oh absolutely absolutely no absolutely sorry mean to speak for long no yeah I think you I think you answered it really well and I know at least for at PB it's um a period schedule so and like our attend um our guidance secretary will push out every morning like if these are the periods that are we need a

050sub for if anyone wants to like they they offer that option just for staff to just voluntar like pick it up and usually most of the time that is what happens yeah that's true because they get yeah yeah um we put out a survey at the beginning of the year if anybody wants to um give up their prep and and do that um for a pay prep then they can do that as well so sometimes if you know there's first period needs to be covered and there's a teacher that volunteers to give up their first period if they prep then they would fill in uh before we would ever pull a read to get math specialist and that's only in the event that we didn't have a s i just because I we're hearing all

051this thing like we're not getting extra people out for tutor and stuff like that it's like okay that's after school yeah okay but during the school those their first priorities are is are our reading special should be with those kidsing that's one other thing and I'm only ask this freak Mr Jim or ad could you please elaborate on the closing of the gyms starting next year like for the renovations what are are I just only some coaches came to say well no one told us we weren't going to be in for is it a certain period of time years what is how so I asked all coaches to give me a three-year Outlook of their inter murals I have their seasons of course uh just so we know and match those up to the phasing

052plans that are with the plans um our goal is to match up as best we can where we need to put them based upon where the phasing is um and again those uh calendars are due tomorrow tomorrow to me so that I can sit down and kind of overlay everything and then meet with Randy and then Mr smil and then U you know let people know where we need to put them for practices games or whatever but it also goes back to the education physic classes so are they going to be closing down the main gym no no we should we're projecting to put a new floor in Anders over a summer right um so that anybody and I'm using the gym during summers oh yeah I make W lose what and again this is

053just for the community that's baring any lat or you know like you know if something comes in late or whatever you know and we'll have to look to see where we can move people if you know something is not on track for timing wise I'm just trying to stop to that saying that the main gym is going to be closed and then the old gym's going to be closed for for the cafeteria it's like what are they going to do with their phys class so I kind of like just want you to like I mean Dr Howard's actually working on that that right now as far as work are going to be throughout the phasing project classrooms and class like that but I mean we're going to do our best to make sure we have

054G area open um I think it's going to affect the outside group okay thank you very much anyone else like to jump on some few things here I was brought about taxes earlier and uh just want to just get some feedback here I can remember in the 2010s is it the 201s whatever we call it back then a decade remember having a conversation with my wife and how excited she was each year during that time to hear that we had a a 0% increase on our taxes and my first comment back where this is not a good thing and for several years we had a zero and the reason this is not a good thing is because when you look at our budget overall I'm going to throw a number I'm probably off on but

055about approximately 75% might go towards salary somewhere in there around around around 70% goes towards salary that's a huge chunk of our money from our taxpayers but every year there's raises involved every year there's something called P con contributions are going up for those who don't to we pieces that's a state retirement system so as employees get raises the contributions go up based on what their pension is set up for a monthly contribution and a match going into depending on how long they've been in the system and additionally there's a third variable which based on contractual increases with the medical benefits so while I don't want to pay a lot of taxes those three things are always going to be there each here so if somebody can come up with a solution on how to

056make us come in at zero without impacting employment here at our school but still having to deal with those three variables I'd like to know the secret on it because all districts would like to do it those those things go up every year on it so we as a board it's there we have no control over peser contributions Pacers back in 2012 changed how employees were being brought into the system as a way to lessen the blow to the system so employees that were hired after that point do not have the same um contribution set up is what those prior to did so they did come up with that there but the raises bases everybody wants a raise every year even if you're in your own job you want to raise each year those raises

057are going in but that also gets compounded by the contributions that go in to the State Pension funds and what it ends up being for the medical benefits those raises are dependent upon what's negotiated we're currently starting our our negotiation with the teachers right now we'll see what it comes out being but I I personally as a taxpayer don't expect the 0% because I know the money's got to come from somewhere and if and if we're not doing it we're going to pay for it one way or another somewhere down the road so um I just wanted people understand that there's there's a lot more variabl going on with money and there's things that we do not have control over um in those respects and the pie of contributions is a big thing and well

058it's a big thing when you get contributions twice the taxpayer not only pays the teacher her salary and they put into peers which is part of their Union but when the school district matches it I'm paying twice and that's and that's contractual I understand that maybe how about we take this conversation I'm just I'm just putting some stuff out there for people have a bigger understanding of this train has to stop can't not disagreeing with you that was just my thing I just wanted make people understand a little bit more about it that was it I'm done I'm sorry I do want to just add to that because I did um based on one of the meetings we had in November December I can't remember um um I did go through there's actually a website

059where you can pull across the country schools that are similar in size with a population that is of the same economic background um and I I pulled quite a few of those it pulls comparable districts you can pick how many you want to pull 10 20 30 um and and when you look at them our salary and the percentage of our salary is right on par with what what those school districts are our percentage isn't out of whack it's normal for for salaries to be 70 to 75% uh if we want to bring in teachers and we want to bring in staff that we need to pay them what what our neighbor school we need to be closer to the average of our neighboring school districts we need to be competitive where they're not going

060to come here and teach and that and that's what we need we need people that are going to come and we need people that are gonna stay please I'm asking it's not compared to it we have to compare it to the teacher salary or we are not gonna get the teachers here okay and I've asked I've asked three this is my third time so okay thank you I got a question no I'm sorry sorry this is I'm sorry I did want to make one other comment and that well actually I think it's two other comments the the other comment was around the awareness and involvement on the renovation project that is something that we've been talking about as a board and having input on for at least the last 12 months like maybe even as

061many as 18 months we have been talking about it and covering it with all of us here in the working session so we've all had input on that um and then the only other comment I'm going to make is around and I don't remember who said it so I I don't remember exactly who brought it up but it's a it was around a comment around comp time for administr administrators versus teachers and just in general not specifically related to the teachers union that we're dealing with here just in general number one there are two different contracts number two it is far easier to be amicable with a smaller group of people than it is with a contract dealing with 300 inevitably when you do those kinds of things in a contract with 300 people people

062are going to get mad grievances are going to come up so it's easier to manage with a smaller group of people but but more importantly they are managed by two different contracts I'm done now okay yeah there were uh two former employees that uh away over the holiday break um I was going to say something at the uh woman silence but I just wanted to to recognize them and you know thoughts and prayers for their fames is Miss seore and what was the other name the two employees Kath seore I can't remember Mickey all right well I just wanted to during the moment of silence I wanted to oh she didn't hear mea anyone else okay superintendent or marks please Dr Conrad sure just um so just wanted to have con say congratulations to our

063High School varsity cheerleaders they placed second place uh at the districts last Saturday it was really exciting to see how excited they were for their accomplishment uh they move on state so that's incredible for uh for the team and we're obviously incredibly proud of them also congratulations to uh pbh mcti students Ryan fosi for winning the pin design uh for the skills USA competition and Kaylee Clinger for Designing the winning cover for the skills USA uh publication this is something that we go down to Bethlehem our Administration team actually uh very proudly uh Witnesses the great work being done by our students most of our students actually Advance onto skills USA so it's really exciting to see uh you know we're looking forward to that actually coming up in just about a week or so

064uh the comp oh yeah here we go competition is taking place on Wednesday January 22nd so again we're so proud of our students and uh lastly I just want to let you know that um our district had sent out communication this evening regarding a nationwide data breach uh with power school so power school is a product that we use in our district for our student information system uh what was communicated out is that our district does not store um Social Security numbers of our students we actually use what's called ppid and we use um different numbers for our students uh Power School you know is um communicating that they're obviously we the breach they've notified schools uh and you know as we hear additional information of how it impacts our students and families we'll certainly

065communicate that out um I explained to the board this evening that uh right now they're doing a forensic out analysis on the depth of um the breach uh but we don't know how that directly impacts uh Pleasant Valley School District so obviously more uh is forthcoming but I just want to make people aware and and in the communication that was sent out um just for parents and and you know just to take a look at you know if you're seeing suspicious emails or you know phone calls or things just be a little bit mindful because we don't know where it could be coming from but just want to make sure um you know we communicate that out to to our families uh and and again this is not our district this is power school which

066is a product that our district utilizes so um but more to come on that I assume so that's all it was Nationwide it was Nationwide it was ACR actually North Carolina um Louisiana uh school districts pretty much all across the country have been reporting out information so I'm sure it'll be kind of uh big news this evening as well across the country so um just wanted to let you know and um that's all Happ see thank you could I have a motion to add all in favor okay we'll take a five minute break and then we'll go into our uh working session meeting e e e and the first item on our agenda this evening is transportation and it looks like Mrs smil is gonna kick that off fish it up a little bit tonight

067because we have a guest here this evening that's gonna go over our efficiency analysis for First Student Bus routing I'm going to dve really hard to get his name right R that's correct I got it right so R from first student he's going to review the efficiency analysis for a okay thank you um okay everybody can hear me okay um okay so my name is Ral Rick I'm a writing consultant with first student um we've provided a PowerPoint that's that goes over um basically uh how routing works at Pleasant Valley and how we approach uh writing at first St with an eye on efficiency okay um so first of all uh at the first good um and at the Pleasant Valley student location routing is handled by our routing Services team okay so we have

068a and this is Nationwide 60 member uh writing services writer team of routers and these are these router mostly work remotely U and collaboratively online with on-site staff with the local dispatchers managers and so on and often and of course the School District staff as well okay um each riter is is part of a team of four um all four are cross trained on each other's site and that allows seamless coverage when it comes to vac or you know SI days and so on so there's always somebody who knows who knows the routing that's available if the main writer is I okay um the writer also trained on all the major computerized writing software uh at Pleasant Valley that's Edge log but there's also verse trans traversa transfinder those are those are the big three

069they're all cross triangle notes okay uh and there's two main advantages we find to this approach the first one has to do with uh knowing the software okay so they have expertise in all the main softwares and that takes a while to develop they also they're also trained in writing Basics the second the second major advantage is has has to do with employee retention and backup so um it's a good environment to work in so we maintain a strong retention rate and we've always got backups in terms of uh like I said sick days and if vacations and so on basically when wrers are absent okay um so I'm going to go to the next slide um this is a SL this is a list of Basic School Bus riding terms and definitions okay the

070one the main one I want a lot of these are common sense but the main one I want to point out is the distinction between a bus run and a bus ride okay a r is the sum we refer to a r as the sum total of what a school bus does in the day and a run is a sequence of stops servicing a particular school or in the case of Pleasant Valley a PA of schools okay so here typical route consists of two am runs your high school middle school and your Elementary intermediate and same thing in the PM okay we would refer to that as double ride or two-tier ride next slide this is the executive summary normally this is just so you can obviously just so you can look at look at

071all the findings up front if you're not if you don't have time to read the whole thing I'm going to skip this for now and I'll come back okay in terms of uh methodology this is a writing overview and we're focusing on efficiency so some of the key questions we ask are um okay what impact at any District does the does the bell schedule have are we running an appropriate number of routes okay are the are the routes created so that designed so that they're at their most efficient and if if you were looking to reduce rights what would that look like what would you have to do okay in terms of our me methodology in order to address these questions okay first of all we kind of we outline the key Transportation factors that

072affect that are AFF any District okay we look again we look at your bell schedule material that has a Major Impact at at any given District okay um in this case we pulled your edot data from November 204 um we put together a summary of key routing metrics we took a close look at your right timeline that's a graph that shows uh the work assigned to each bus um we did a highlevel review of run composition that's how runs are designed okay to see how it Stacks up against our best practices and and again we we looked at what would need to be done if you if you wanted to reduce RS right um okay in terms of I mentioned uh overview and uh key Transportation factors that affect the district so just a just

073a few an outline here this District covers 114 square miles uh mostly rural hel terrain small communities dotted within um you got about 4,300 students and the population the student body student population stayed pretty steady since we last did a study that was in 2019 you got four Public Schools running on two sets of bell time so two pairs of schools each share bus rides um in terms of Transportation you got 55 big buses handling Regular Ad rids and 34 small buses and vans and that's for special needs and other District programs okay this report is focusing on the 55 big buses okay another uh this this slide is also to do with some District transportation parameters details couple of points here um seating guidelines two per for high school middle school students and up

074to three per for for uh Elementary Intermediate School students and in this District the the guideline is to uh reserve a a seat for all eligible writers which is everybody um so you're looking at for a high school middle school run uh probably around I mean in a 72 passenger bus 48 kids would be the max for High School Middle School in theory 72 for elementary intermediate in practice it's really more 60 to 65 that works um another another key detail is you've got 55 buses potentially accessing your school loading zones that that's a lot in in and out of a uh parking lot lining up and so on and that's obviously is going to contribute to traffic congestion can slow things down especially in the afterno afternoon in and around the schools okay so

075we're going to take a look at the current state first thing is the bell schedule analysis okay so what is the impact of of your bell schedule so um you got a two-tier system high school middle school first followed by intermediate and Elementary okay in the morning there's a lot of time so if you look at your earli school am B 7:20 for the for the high school 9:00 for the elementary that's a lot of time um in the afternoon things get quite a bit tighter okay and there's a couple reasons for that first reason is your high school and middle school have longer instructional days right so that's going to squeeze time a little bit 10 to 15 minutes longer okay and the other big reason is just in general in terms of school

076bus transportation it's it's a lot more time consuming to get into a school and out in the PM than it is in the AM where um buses simply you know they can go in and out of the school loading zones unload and they there a couple minutes okay but that the process is a whole lot uh longer and you've got all that congestion as well so it's it's much tighter in the PM um so let's if you take uh your second school right it's a about time of 2:30 and which what we found is that buses are typically departing from there from a by 238 to 244 is a typical range right and the the prefer time of arrival is 330 at uh the elementary intermediate campus right so really if you when you look

077at that um 330 is you know a a little bit earlier the than the bell time so that's that's the preferred time of arrival but when you look at that you're really talking about 36 to 42 minutes of what we call operating time right um so that includes getting out of high school middle school doing the bus run and Dead Heading back um in all other periods um that is in the morning first year in the morning first year second year in the morning and second to in the afternoon you have the potential to run up for a run to go as long as you know 45 to 60 minutes which is usually the preferred maximum at any District um so the big takeaway here is that the the number of routes that you're running

078is really determined by your first tier in the PM that's how much time is available for your high school middle school routes and that time is constrained okay uh this is this is a breakdown of key riding metrics first thing is we're talking about 55 big buses here um next thing is runs per row that's 1.9 so essentially uh you're averaging almost two routes sorry two runs per route and so you're basically making your two tier bell schedule work um and in terms of writers per run if you look at that figure that's 36.8 so 37 so even with even at a two per seat run you're not quite hitting your full seating capacity and again that's because of that's because of the the time is the actual limit right the first tier in the

079PS okay uh am runs we come up with a figure of uh they average 47 minutes now this is this is based on how we're measuring it right you can see the difference between how we measure the am versus the PM so uh and that has to do with um how they're how how they're laid out in the software right so in the AM we're including the time the time for unloading at both schools right and again that's the morning isn't the issue it's it's the PM no the PM figure we're using here is 33 minutes right so what that how that figure is measured is it's it's from the time of leaving the second School uh getting out of the school completing all the stops on the run right okay so that's that's your

080uh average run time in the PM from leaving the from leaving the uh Middle School it would be to last kid I'm sorry to last kid off to last kid off okay okay now let's say so when you put drop the last kid off you're somewhere out in the out in the country um so you got to that head back to the uh inter intermediate okay so if you if you take 10 minutes as an average Dead hat time 33 let say 9 to 10 minutes that put you right at your 42 for 43 minutes that we talked about earlier right so on average your your basic your runs are are using it all their time okay um and again the main takeaway is time not seating capacity is the biggest limiting factor in terms

081of your school bus riding um so next let's see uh when we do these we always look at uh this this is a feature of any uh Schoolbus writing software programs in edog it's called the route display so what you're looking at here it might be hard to see it you know at this level of detail but let me just describe it so across the top there's a timeline right and you're looking at two column you and vertically it's each bus right so what you're looking at are 2 am runs and the 2 pm runs for each bus um so it's quite visually it's quite apparent that if you look on the left that's your am there's a lot of time between the N of the high school middle school to the beginning of the

082intermediate Elementary go to the go to the uh right hand side to the PM run so you're you're starting with high school middle school run and as soon as they're as soon as you end the Run they you got to be at that school and you can see there's all very little time left between the two okay so that that's how that's what's affecting your rights you got you know you've only got so many time to fill up the bus uh 37 37 WR assigned writers before you got to get back to the school um another Point here is there are a few gaps in the second tier there's 55 big buses 51 of those have uh a high school middle school and intermediate Elementary run um there's three there three of the ones that

083don't have a intermediate Elementary they all they do have a shuttle so 54 are in essence out of 55 double tiered in one way or another um see anything more I think no I think that's the main points of that one um so we we we always look at this to see is there a way that we could we could cut routes by better packaging of runs but you can see right here uh you just can't do that the the only way that you would be able to reduce a route is you've got to get you've got to consolidate High School Middle High School Middle School runs and that's what um so let's see next okay um we ALS we along with look you know breaking down the metric looking at the bell schedule checking

084out the uh route timeline to see if the pack how the packaging works we also do a high level view of how of of how the runs are created how they're designed right and we've got basically from this report I don't going to look up one slide here right just we don't need to go through all six but we've outlined all the 55 High School Middle School runs based on the different sections of the district that they're servicing right um and in terms of I refer to uh best practices so in terms of um best practices there's really three things three principles we're looking at here okay first is that the Run Services a distinct neighborhood or geographic area right second is there's minimal crossing paths right you don't want uh two buses going into

085the same area obviously they have to access the same access roads right um and once you've got those two uh principles in place then you make sure that the STS are arranged in a logical sequence okay um so when you do that you make your you make your runs uh direct streamlined there's there's no redundancy they're not you not sending buses into the same place and you're minim you're minimizing your travel time and your mileage okay now you can see here that these runs they're designed with these principles in mind you know servicing totin neighborhoods minimal Crossing and they arranged in Lo logical sequence you have to take an into count um whether it's am or p.m that determines how you might arrange the stocks um also uh right side pickups sometimes you kind of

086do the minor sequence because you got to turn the bus around right so you might see that reflected here not not everything can be done cleanly in every area and what you'll notice here is there's a one there's one run called 104 right 104 which kind of comes around right we kind we refer to that as a cleanup run because basic basically there's a few outlining stops um somebody's got to do it and the router here just determined that that was the best candidate for the job for whatever reason maybe it's one that doesn't have a second tier for example maybe it has more uh seating capacity left but gener when you look at the if you look through this report you'll see that uh in that all of the in all the sections of

087the district that the rights are are consistent with those principles and it's and poor routing or poor knowledge of the software is not is not a cause of uh inefficiency at the district right the rers know what they're doing I'm going to skip through here and we we also looked at you know everybody's there're always always when you're talking about efficiency there always some interest in uh is it possible to reduce rides right right um and and sometimes that's uh that has to do you know right now Nationwide with there's a there's a a driver shortage there's been one for several you know for many years now so um is it is it possible to to reduce rights How would how would you do that now we've we've already talked here um first of all

088we've said that uh no matter what you you have to get rid of high school middle school runs right okay so how would you do that well the only way you can do that is you have to let uh you have to let more runs operate longer right and and I'm not talking about changing the bell times here okay this I'm talking about just giving your your current set of parameters so um the only way to let them operate longer uh is would be to make more more gaps in the second tier right so so what that would entail is you would have to to look at your um Elementary runs let's say take five in a geographic area and see if you can squeeze those into four okay and it would be that it

089would be that kind of uh those are the kind of numbers I'm I'm talking about they have to be geographically adjacent and if you're already got 30 40 50 kids on a bus you're going to need four or five runs to you know to uh consolidate one right to to put all of to assign all of these students somewhere else okay now once you did that then you would you would be able to run some high school runs longer right um and and then You' end up you may if you're lucky you may end up with some runs some first year runs that don't have a second some second tier runs that don't have a first tier and if you shuffle them around again that how you would try to reduce the ride but that's

090what it would take um now when whenever whenever you do that uh you you need very good it's not something you do it's not that easy uh something that you do Willy nearly let me put it that way right you got to you got to uh be confident in your head CS there a science students but you you also need to know how many students are actually showing up um you and you want to have good runtime tracking right you want to know know how how long these runs are taking um so so you got to make sure you got that data in hand and then you there's uh there's conss in terms of right consolidation okay because you're reducing your level of service right um it if you make your uh if you consolidate

091runs you're going to you're going to create longer right times earlier pickups later drop offs you're going to create some single tier routes um and that may affect you know drivers may have concerns about that that's going to affect how many hours they go right and the last thing is you're taking all the you're taking the slack out of the system you're making it you're making it tighter um and that means it's going to be harder to adjust for new students any new students in their new stops any driver absences drivers quitting okay you're it's reducing your overall flexibility you don't have much room to react right so there's definitely cons if you try to do that um and I I added a slide to this and this one goes from left to right at

092the top to the bottom it's really just showing you what that what that process looks like so starting at the top left you could this is just a sample of eight buses that are double tier red you know the high school middle school or red the elementary or blue okay and then the uh what it looks like on the right after consolidation so what you've done is you've um you've gone to your uh Elementary runs on the right and you've taken out three right you you've put these students on somewhere else and that makes all the remaining runs longer right gotta go got to go somewhere longer and more kids on and we took uh in this example we eliminated uh the high school middle school run three and eight right so we took we

093took two out there this is just this is just a high pathetical example it's not something we did it's just to show you how the process works right now what you've done there is you've to do to do this um you've touched all 16 rums that were in in the sample right every single one of them being affected all the kids all you know all the stops and so on okay in this example we uh what we did is we if you look at the second set of routes we took seven and we moved it down to eight okay so maybe maybe those two canare right um so it took all that to get rid of one route right um and you can see what you're left with you've got if you look at Route

094One um there's no there's no dead head time it's like you get you finish your run you're right there's no slack it there um you finish it you've only got time just to get to the next goal um you've got a couple of singles two and five and three and then the other six and eight those are also really tight so that was just to illustrate how that works um I'm going to go back to the executive summary and just run down real quick the major takeaways again okay so you're operating 55es schedule uh 51 serving rights from both sets of schools three of the others have shuttles um the PN schedule is more compressed that's that's the uh the first tier in the PM is that that determines your number of Rights um your

095your average load for run is 37 Riders and that's because the time in that first tier is too compressed you can't quite fill up more seats right um you've got 55 buses going into the loading zones all at once and that of course that leads to congestion and that also will extend your run times right um which we looked at how the runs are designed and they're designed according to those three principles so that's not a source of inefficiency um and finally if if you're if you're looking at um eliminating rights we outlined that strategy for doing it but it's it's difficult it's difficult to get results with that and it also involves tradeoffs and that was the last take point and so that was just an overview of your writing um that's all I

096had uh are there any questions or I have a bunch so he just gave my head's spinning with all the information he just gave us full diso nice job on but my head's spinning right now I'm a little confused right now I thought we put out $8,000 a year or two ago to have a survey done I'm looking at my board members because we did I know we did we put out $88,000 to have a survey done to see if we were doing to consolidate now that I'm hearing this is this the result of that not through us what's that not for First Student we did ours for free we never took any so where my I'm going to go on us we spent $88,000 to have this done what was the result of it

097CS I can answer um so there was a program that was purchased transfinder was purchased um and we used it to cross check Edge you walk which is for students rally program um we did use it in the first year I believe it was 97 pluses we were able to use that that program to cut it down to 92 this past year Dina went sorry Mrs Bo went directly down to her student and worked with their rallying person because she knows the students she knows where they're supposed to be she knows the area we're actually able to get it down to 87 so we've gone we've in the last two years we've gone down 10 runs now let me jump on another question on that then when we talked about this I and I'm having

098some flashbacks right now did I am I hearing the number correctly that for every bus run that we were able to consolidate was a saving of $66,000 for the school year one one I just remember hear one bus run is $66,000 for the year and that's for that's covering the vehicle the fuel the salary the benefits all that stuff just the just for the bus itself okay so again I just bring this up because again excellent job on the presentation lot of information it just got me going I remember that $8,000 we put out I just want to know what we got for we saved 660 and I wanted that to be brought up tonight I just wanted to make sure we had that that so that 8,000 was well spent that's what I wanted

099to hear good and and the other the other part of this presentation was also to help that unless we unless we would like to put our students on the bus for longer periods of time we've kind of reached the point now where we cut everything that we can cut um with us with working with working together with first student the maximum time we have the the 45 to 60 minutes that's students on the bus not total run time route time so it's from the time from the time that they pull out of the school so it's really basically like PVE and R they load at pvi that load time it takes approximately 10 minutes let's say to get all the kids on the buses and then the buses roll out they go to PVE they

100load at PVE so so we don't really count the time that they're waiting for all the kids to load the bus right so they roll out of PVE approximately 4:00 so from the time they leave the last school which would be PVE till the last student is dropped off that's what the maximum time is that's what the maximum time is and so in the morning that maximum time doesn't include if someone has to go all the way up to the mountain before they pick up a student it doesn't include that time in the maximum time empty it would be the first pick up first time the first when the first student gets on the bus get to and we're really constrained more in the afternoon because they have those buses have to be at PBI

101by between 3:30 and 3 okay and they're not rolling out of the middle school until about 238 240 so we don't really have a lot of wiggle room so if we were to eliminate buses then the bus is out already would be longer than the 45 minutes which then means the buses would be late getting to evi the next SCH so our hands are kind of tied with the time now because of the rural areas that we're going and it's taking a lot of times it takes 20 minutes just to get to the area where the kids live yep okay so I mean you know we we looked at what transfinder had and you know I was more involved with you know into their edog routing system and working with their router and we were

102able to get it down um we did have to actually add one special needs bus because we have had a bunch of special needs kids you know which that fluctuates it a lot you know as they come and how to go out of district and whatnot but we're pretty much we're the lowest we've ever been in the past six years as far as how many droughts we have and as far as cluster stops I don't know how to ask this but our drivers are not changing and he stops right like what we've routed is what they're doing like I know it happens like well can't you just instead of stopping you know yeah at my drive yeah we've yeah we've eliminated all of that so they're following strictly what's routed we do have Exceptions there

103are students that I get that you know on a Case by case may need to get house PI right I get that but yeah we are you know and the drivers are not Chang I guess ultimately my question is the drivers are not changing the routes no no and we have written up some drivers that have strayed from the so they know like we're not changing you know the parents can cry and you know beg and no okay I have a question about Staffing have you guys had any issues with Staffing and and any turnover um and then my kind of second part to this do you see a lot of um interest from our specific Community when it comes to funding bus drivers Yeah so basically everybody is I want to say everybody there's

104a small per that are outside of our community mostly everybody's in community and it's weird because we get so excited because we'll have like a whole of people come in like you know oh we're going to have 10 new drivers we're all and then next thing you know it's like oh retiring somebody's moving and we're always thinking like we're always ahead and then what comes in goes out the weirdest thing we get three we lose two so we gain one so and we advertise and we've um done all the things that we can do all the tricks and we do pay training and stuff like that because a lot of companies do it now so that's what we're doing we're helping them pay for their CDL we pay for their clearances or doing all the

105things to help get them in the door a lot of times they do come to the door they don't even have the money to put out to get a job they can't pay for the clearances they can't pay for a certain thing so now we do that we do that for them so that it speeds up the process is we cannot and we do not want to fail our district we need to have drivers in the door need them as fast as we can so we've even um bre in our training is much faster now where we didn't shortcut it but now they can do it online um from home they don't have to come out of their house they don't have to leave their jobs that they have at the moment so things are

106getting so evolving just like here by us so much better the process of getting people indoors quicker now if we can just keep them in there and then you have you know you know they go out on health issues and they're out for a little while three months the back next thing we know the next person's got to KN they got to go out so yeah it's a constant battle thank you so what's the recommendation as to how often this survey gets done to make sure that we're staying on top of the best routing that we can have to optimize what we have efficiency honestly we run the most efficient program that we we 10 that's that's what we strive on and that's why it was so great when we brought them on I think

107I got them did you I think so was right around is when we brought in the routing team and um amazingly we were running the way we were doing it which was from back in the day when um Pleasant Val had it it was running just as efficient our problem with the number of changes believe it or not is the special needs special needs is what causes our inflow and decrease you have you have kids um coming and going out a district special needs we have this month last mon of them of them come in so it's a constant monopolizing of the buses so that we don't have to create new routes so what we're doing is is we have this route with this bus and this bus is now full but we just had

108new K come in and needs to be on this bus however this bus is full so now we have to figure out can we take somebody off this bus to put it on another bus another child without increasing their time on the bus because there special needs we don't want to do that um does it always work no it doesn't always work but we might be able to move a student put a student someplace else again efficiently to keep so we don't have to add more routes it could be very easily to say this bus is full let's make route that's not how we operate we do what we can to try and keep everything efficient so we you we you are routinely doing this surveying we don't run a survey per se we run

109everything efficiently like we have calls weekly with our router that isn't even here they're on phone they're mapping and they will tell us if we need Dina no because we P Dina in if there's an issue they will tell us that when we need to add a route or not add a route that they're totally out of options of what they can do unless it comes to increasing RS or anything like that so I honestly don't think that this efficiency study needs to be done all the time because that's what we constantly do we're kind of monitoring it weekly I mean even sometimes daily but um we do have weekly meetings with the routing team and sometimes if they you know don't know well what can we do with this student it's like a juggling

110act and we say okay well we can you know put this student on a different bus and you know move kids around keeping them within the time limit and not having to add runs so it's essentially being done live and your biggest is at the beginning of the year and then throughout the year you're constantly right evaluating it based upon your metrics that you're getting what you're getting what you constantly look at it and anytime that we have to add a route or think about in a route it's not like we Wily say we're just G to add a route so we bring everybody into it we bring into it like we have the the backup behind it to show it's not like we're down there just growing things and um we've always been like

111that we've been Fair like we have buses that we know that we can consolidate we've done so um and again the only thing that I see that causes the flops it's always our Min we're always doing that thank you but the 115 through eff now it's going to switch that's going to cause yeah half of our half of our fleet was affected by that added which added time to the run but we can't you know we can't control that yeah um and again when that stuff happens we are on on with our routers yeah all the routers are the team effort then we try to figure out which detour can they take to yeah so anyone else thank you very much thank so the second item on under transportation is 115 right yeah so the

112next phase of that construction they were originally anticipating doing the flip shutting down southbound opening up Northbound they were originally talking about January 22nd um pendot now has pushed that off to the spring yes so they're not doing any changes until the spring and the one thing they did throw out in the middle you know last minute was merwinsburg road so I got notified on Monday that Wednesday they shut merwinsburg road down between 1:5 and Pheasant Road um so our buses can that come from the other way merwinsburg can turn on feasant on road and Detour that way we also have Valley um the Valley Road is also the other detour so while we thought okay no changes now then they threw that rburg road but it hasn't seemed to affect the buses too much

113because we were kind of an anticipating it we just didn't know when um so my my pen. contact is very good like he always gives me a heads up like Hey we're talking about closing this and closing that and then I you know he always gives me enough time to at least plan for the busing how we're going to do it they even had one of the signs placed where it was good for the cars that were pulling out but it was in the line of the buses and I said like you have to move that sign our buses can't see and he actually took pictures and video sent it to me and he said okay which placement do you like better so I do have a good report with the pen do gu so

114hopefully you know he's always given us plenty of time to reroute and you know and we always try to do it like they kind of look at me a little bit more because like the routers don't live in the area so we know the back roads and which certain shortcuts would keep the buses going and not adding additional time so I mean we're working around it as best we can that's all you can do know let that's all you do yeah yeah so hopefully there won't be any other changes until spring anyone else okay thank you Dina thank you moving on to finance the capital reserve to the 2018 Bond the 2023 Bond and the 2024 Bond that at December 31st 2024 November and December are attached I going to review December capital reserve available

115balance was 21 milon 92278 53 the 2018 available balance is 30, 47.99 the 2023 Bond account available balance is 15 million 635 account balance available balance 15, 295 436.48 does anybody have any questions on those accounts moving on the next is the epte report for August and September I'll review September's 2024 balance our EP Reserve balance is5 m374 this is a privileg to 5 and a half months of Reserve we are required to maintain a four month Reserve therefore we in good position at this time any questions on that next up I have the tax collector resolution to discuss tonight um Board of Education prior to February 15th in an election year is required to approve and pass a tax collector resolution so that the potential tax collector candidates know their salary and reimbursement from

116the district for the the upcoming four years that they are going to run to serve so the current tax collectors submitted their proposals and requests which are columns five and six um their first their first scenario was a 3% increase each year of the resolution their second proposal was a flat 10% increase at the beginning of the contract and then that would last through the length of the resolution as you can see both of these scenarios were the district over 35,000 35,000 plus increase over the life resolution um a committee of Mrs service Mrs kresy Mrs sites our assistant business manager and myself reviewed the proposal and the history of the tax collector resolutions and we ran choose other scenarios One Flat 3% increase for the life of the resolution and the second scenario is

117a 4% increase for the life of the resolution as you can see from the charts these options are a budget impact over the life of the resolution which is four years the first option would be a b budget impact of 2966 and the 4% would be $ 49561 the committee's recommendation is to put forth the flat 4% increase if the board is good with this recommendation I would like to move forward to have the official resolution put on on the January 23r for agenda for approval does anybody have any questions so I'm sorry for option one for them was 3% each year for four years correct or 10% now for four years correct and both of those options the three% increase for each year was a is a $35,000 impact budget impact over over the

118four years right and the second option the second proposal that they gave is $38,000 impact on the budget over the four years there's there's history there too so if you look at the history of two resolutions ago I have there's two sets up there if you look at the history the three what there the 3% and the 10% is quite High compared to the other years increases okay um I did do some comparison with the other school districts um straussburg is flat fee they don't go in different groups how we do it uh they it's a flat fee they have um four ship Burrows and they range from $335 to $362 per tax bill salaries in total are much higher but they have a lot more properties tax tax properties than we do um East

119straussburg is a181 per School tax bill flat across the board there's not there's no change changes there and I'm sorry the do the dollar amount represented there that's per tax bill which the total in all of the totals like the dollar amount is that a per tax it is so for the first for the first row each tax payer each PX tax collector currently gets $250 54 here not trying to down6 $254 for the first 500 tax bills then from 51 to, 1500 tax bills they get A180 and then from anything over, 1500 tax bills they get the dollar eight or dollar six oh okay I think you're in the wrong column the that was the 26 27 column but it explains how it explains how yeah okay yeah and that was really my question

120and then there's reminders that go out they go out in um the end of November beginning of December so the number of reminders that go out they get 40 cents for those there's a b tax bills that go out when they go out they $525 a piece they get and then there's the installments there because they have to be mailed out making installment payments for three installments so that the second and third installment have to be tracked and sent out so that's a165 crazy and we reimburse the some of their expenses as well a third their expenses any expenses that the tax collectors have a split between Township count and we did ask if if it would make sense because the other districts have a flat rate if we would transition to a flat rate

121but Tammy explained to us that they've got this under control the way it's all the tear that they have and it's easy to do so we figured we wouldn't rock the boat with trying to go that route we did at we did ask those questions [Music] is everybody okay with the recommendation to move with 4% yes yeah okay okay I'll move forward and have that on the next board agenda thank you um and then the next item that I have is our senior citizen tax rebate program um we did redo this in 2022 we increased the brackets in 2022 um there has been no State changes the tax year of 2024 um so we have to put this on for a resolution as well in the next for the next board meeting um we in

122t for T tax year 2022 we P paid out $ 29,8 80 to our senior citizens in tax rebates and for tax year 2023 we have paid out 19325 Jo senior citizens excuse me in tax reat um I'm recommending no changes at this time to the senior citizen tax rebate um nothing has changed with the state um so we don't need to change anything with ours to match the state so we're we still match correct um so we're as long as um with none of the changes I'll put this on also for the J the second meeting in January official put approval the state opens up February 21st I believe it is for filing um so as soon as they open up we will start getting filings then I just wanted to add a side

123Community note because I don't know if it gets out there to everybody you entire business office is trained to fill out the PA 1000 and the school district form for the senior citizens we hold two days every month in February March and April for senior citizens can come in and we'll we'll prepare if for you it's free you just call the business office and they schedule an appointment I Know Jack Raider's office also does it too um and it's a free service and every Everybody in the business office is trained now to do this can we put do we have that on the on our website I don't believe it is but I can have I thank you and can we also Sue have that in your monthly for the West End happening yes that

124that's I think what we would hit our Market as well idea we're working on one as we speak so I will make a note of [Music] that I think I'm done I'm gonna the cafeteria stuff I'm Miss is going to have for cafeteria presentations this evening okay good evening everyone um items um number f and g are the cafeteria meal totals for um November and December um I'm going to go over item G the cafeteria meal totals for December um the December breakfast meals served were 13,133 the lunch meals served were 36,43 and the after school snacks were $5 5,487 um the alart sales were $1 6,273 60 um and then we also have item H uh attached are the winson's monthly newsletters for October and November for your review any questions thank you you

125all right moving on to operations uh Mr smil all right uh P Carpet brought up counter was counterclockwise please [Laughter] 90° p is the blame well that's close enough they get the to it yeah sorry sideways that's that's the main floor at PBE uh the areas in Orange are the a hallway B hallway C hallway uh the one large hallway there and there's two uh three family rooms on that floor that we're looking to replace uh downstairs there's three family rooms downstairs in the corner go those so there those areas there are almost 10,000 square feet of carpet to be removed uh put new VCT Tile in place uh I think was 1,700 Square F feet of our linear square feet of base molding rubber base molding I did talk to a vendor probably looking

126at around $50,000 to have them come and do all that work uh if you would like me to go further we're goingon to have to put that out to Big it definitely went over the threshold um I can proceed with that could we just do it as we were originally doing it like just so much like I don't know if they could do something over Easter break you know Christmas break summer and then maybe it wouldn't have to go out if we did it in in little interviews buy all the material one time but yeah I mean I did kind of roughly figure out if we were to do it in-house and I was coming up with around $40,000 if we consider our guys wages benefits material uh should possibly save5 to $10,000 I mean

127the timeline was the problem for me because like if you want to try to do this over summer um with the renovation Pro Com the maintenance guys going to be there so you're pulling your maintenance people away from primary I mean and and right and they I mean summertime they're a busy time that's when they're trying to uh prep for the new school year I would just like a plan to see it finally get finished you know because some of that carpet is they're not here anymore but some of that when I was out there for various things is really bad yeah and need yeah it's still for sure so I I mean I don't know what anybody else think as you know you want it all done at one time or you know got

128to keep it out of Summer if we can yeah and it is a [Music] priority okay everybody think have you seen it I seen it it's it's been there since the building was opened let me put it that way there I'm not dising I mean look at what it's costing us to do the high school right and that's because a failure of P of the past not keeping up with the times to to make it right so it's the right thing to do how we do is I think how we have to decide is it peacee or is it is it segmented I I don't know I don't I rely on to give us the best what's what's your in put on what direction I'd rather see it just subed out and get it done

129with just one and get it over with they do that yeah I talked to one vendor like I would try to approach it was uh maybe the second to third week of Summer having to come in that would give us a week to clear out those areas so when they came in everything ready to roll uh he was talking between a week or two for them to do it um I me they got a ride on machine to come rip that carpet out we'd have to rent a machine and to walk behind and it's not a very easy process but I these guys are this is they got this is what they do um you have to have some curing time for the for the glue um to set up and dry properly before you

130put threee coats of wax on top of it so that's Bill mangle school out there so he's got work cut out for him um along with his other cleaning duties for the summer his crew but we could pull that off if in that timeline in the 10 we summer I know Roger has a summer school I talked to Dr Conrad and Dr Howard about that if we can work around that they're thinking with the with the vendor you mean like by using a vendor by using a vendor and then if you would start that process now give you enough time to advertise for the bids get the bids back and be ready for some yeah was it three weeks post it for three weeks we put the RFP out in a week or two I

131have that ready that see I mean and we can I mean if you want to look into doing it as we go it's just it doesn't matter I just Christmas break's not the best time because again the Vance department has things that they can't get to during the school day school year that they that's that's their busy week a low of them take off so it's short-handed the custodians same way you know they're changing filters that week a lot of them take off themselves to have a nice extended break to try to do it during the school year I mean you might get one haul during Christmas break maybe well for the money you're sa for the money you're saving to have someone come in who does it every day professionally professionally not that your

132guys AR good right they're not laying floor every day is I'm sorry you said we're it's getting replaced with a different material yes we're put dial 12 by 12 squ that's it was in when that building was built it was in every classroom carpet carpet it bathro terrible yeah it was bad we actually have a couple boxes of the old stuff we had the die number so we can match it to what it was it all look the same very close are we okay yes okay all right think you have your direction all right thank that on for the next boort meeting yeah yeah to go out to bed yeah okay all right next I have uh reing of the the district except for the high school the high school will be Reed during the

133renovation um this project actually there's a couple people involved Jason and chief Miller actually wrote up the grand money for some of it tamy has that there we go um you can see there that the prices per school what the cost now this is a it's a best lock key system I've used it before it's pretty pretty handy pretty nice uh there's prices per school um key machines in there a couple blanks and get 200 blanks it wi with that price of $5,000 um I'm sorry I don't got my glass's 120 the total cost of the project is 349 91350 um Chief Miller and Jason together wrote the Grant and they were awarded 18339 thec grant that leaves a balance of 166 37450 to complete the project so Next Step would be for me to

134ask official board approval to allocate the add remaining so the reain would be internal doors and external no just the internal just internal the external doors there's not too many of them that have all digital are digital with the swipes well we do have car readers that's some of the doors and plus we have some doors that work off a key that's an a Legion Key system which is like trying to get into four KNX to get one of those keys so I guess my question is like why are we going to return re key internal doors we have like a problem of keys being distributed and there's some of that that the keys were not uh collected distributed properly um some of the doors are knobs instead of levers which are not ADA Compliant

135um Bob can here with the uh the classroom doors speci in the uh recent uh State Police risking vul vulnerability assessment it recommends that all classroom doors should be locked from inside situation should have to mess around Keys that's that is not our right now so thumb lever on the interior Sho that the last assessment uh also with the pccd grants uh they want you when you apply for these grants you save the grants they want you to address the level ones uh in the Baseline criteria and this would be addressed in a base the Baseline one so once we address these this level one issue allows us to go and do better better bigger better things with the pccd grants for here on outfit most of the level ones are addressed other this is

136like they so with this new lock system um been hearing different systems that you can go with based with the arvat reports and stuff um what what do we what is a cost per door you know just with because I know this has security features that we're looking for based on arvat what just going to a ballpark what what is it a cost per door on this new some it depends because some of the locks are mored already yeah so that's cost savings because they don't have to cut the door and some of them will they range from 476 dollar a door to you know some of them are just 48 bucks just got repl a C we're doing some shopping too and I I was curious to know what prices you're coming in at

137is is the PCC Grant an annual Grant normally it is hasn't been released yet for this this okay I'm wondering if there is a scenario where we utilize the grant for a portion of the building I mean we're looking at the this project this renovation Pro in general as a three-year project is it possible to to do a portion of the schools now and then reapply and get more funding from a grant for the the remain but depends it would depend on how the Grant's written written to do all buildings each year we're finding because PC P I said pccd is for all purposes relatively new uh so it's the bugs are still getting worked out but what's happening is is as they're issuing the grant each year they're putting a Tighter and Tighter Reign

138on what it can be used for and this year could be in fact used for what we want to use it for and two years from now this may not be one of the qualifying jobs to have done so we're it's it's it's new and we're finding things how they're doing things and I can agree with you if we don't do it now and do with what the monies they're giving two years from now there could there may or may not be PC CCD money grant Avail and it may be available but it may not this may not qualify for it just like mrke said we're going back to now we're peace doing things together so we do the project and get it all done at one shot that's that's my since I've been here

139I see peace meing and I would like to try to get in the dist piece and a wait and Mandy this will put all the blocks the same across the district walk around so we're trying to get away from from this I mean like some some of the building actually have two keys one for the old section and the new section this this is why we wanted to sort of you guys have a master that will cover the entire District then yes will like each school will have a master then there'll be a grand master for all that would be every school lock key right there's only people that would have that one but yeah yeah I mean and the way the system designed like each key will be stamped say you know we go

140Miss F here Bernie would have H9 it would be stamped right on the key that no out of the key will be stamped like that anybody finds that key all we have to do is return it we can look at the log Bernie's key as far as when people return their keys in when they retire or whatever forever reason they leave the district Key will get back logged back in it will be re issued to the new teacher staff member whatever be fairly or a lot more organized than what it is right now so the only question I have is did we look at the no key option carers yeah I can go around the world at different sites I get think this is expensive that's even more expensive we we have actually part one

141of the things I can add too is when we went to Avon Grove and a few other places they were saying um as they some they had some doors that were some doors that weren't but even talking to um Alex uh in particular about this that sometimes the readers there's a few school districts think maybe books there a few others that um have gone to that but the readers might not always work or there's power um challenges here and there and again I think the cost was was the big you know pressure point for us the maintenance of it the maintenance of the car readers is astronomical uh I mean the key once Keys R I think I actually started going to it and I think the issue they ran to because they didn't hard

142wire them with power they're actually B [Music] they is time time in and out of the building like an employee might work from 7:15 to 7:30 in this building but then somewhere else the rest of the day so getting that emplo well Dr you're that kind of you and I take care of that as far as who's how yeah uh so one of the things that we've done over the last two years is really not only strine our check-in checkout process but we actually have a mastered list that we share with Chief that has uh who has access to what at what at what time and so forth and and again we're we're very um transparent and let them know what times they have uh you know accessibility into the building uh the benefit of

143having you know High high def cameras all throughout too is you know God forbid we have to go back and backtrack we have that we can see it we can pan we can do all the things that we need to um but what we have done is really um streamlined our process to have you know exactly who has access to what when where and you know again it kind of comes back to that safety aspect that you know like is is is a teacher that's working at PVE do they need to have access um in the evening to pvi the answer in my opinion would be no right now can they certainly get into the building is there are there ways yeah of course and and there's requests and things like that that we can

144do um but we really try to keep things more um uh local in that regard that that we have um more high level oversight on those areas so okay thoughts we okay with reing whole district has to get done yeah yeah okay all right okay goward with that then okay all right that was all I had okay that's all I spent enough money don't you think yeah technology report is there anything under technology no no not today okay the only thing well I have to add something just CU cool uh the the bread for lockers uh those those really large lockers that were installed in the high school and the Middle School uh recently M this technology team primarily maintance got them all mounted and ready they're turned on now both in the high school

145and also in the middle school and walking from the middle school today check out the star exams and stuff there was quite a few of them that were being used the teachers love them the kids love them so it's really cool stuff just wonder what they are actually so what do they do punch a code in yeah so it's it's actually if you think of it as a um they're very similar to like a hotel Locker like if you're leaving your jewelry behind in a hotel room you punch in a code you set your code and then you walk away when you come back first say four digits we advocate for our students they're using right now the last four digits of their uh their ID number that way they can remember what the code

146is if they don't remember their code we just say what's your ID number all right um but yeah they L just punch it in it locks if they're charging the device we found that charges are pretty much from zero to almost full in one period so theyes who come in with no charge they can really walk outside their classroom plug it in they go in they do their class they come back out maybe be a bunch they come back out they get it out of the locker by punch same Cod in their R both the rest of the day so it's good stuff and how many bays in the locker 10 each okay yeah that's all thank you okay all right um moving on to policy you want to start this or me uh well

147one thing I will say so I know that this was brought up uh if we want to take a look and have a discussion again about um policy 95 which is the assistance advisory committee um one thing that I would say just from you know the first thing that draws to my attention is um you know the adopted and the last Revis so I just wanted to bring to everyone's attention this was adopted in 2017 less revised in 2020 um meaning that you know it's it's been well over four years so um I I would just just say that obviously we should have a discussion about this particular policy however I think we do need to go through the proper vetting uh process you know whether uh that's getting some insight from psba uh and

148then also just seeing if there's any necessary uh you know revisions or just even reviewing it and just saying that we want to you know keep current with our policies so I just wanted to say that but I guess I can let you okay um everybody has a copy it was in your it was in your folder that Kathy had provided to us um so this was brought up um by Mr gazis I don't remember when sorry early December early December whatever in the auditorium okay I remember being in the auditorium yes um so um I thought i' we'd put it on the agenda for the board to discuss if if this is something you want to move forward with or if we want to um get uh pba's input as to if this needs

149to be updated um or not um but that's why it's on here for input from the board um again you know I just want to bring to your attention you know the purpose and then um The Authority you know as the policy is written down um like to see a group set up like you said stat the last The Authority whatever they get to talk about it and bring have IDE they put some kind of into certain things such as you know even some of our policies we used to have poliy meetings as separate I know we do it as a whole now but how many times are these policies brought to us in for the first reading in a regular session inside the work session and so really have an input as's going on

150they could raise questions um same with the academic the read I know you bring some things that's what I was bringing a uh encouragement type thing here was okay we have this reading program which I'll get more into later you know what was the harm of having what the community say hey this is why we're looking at and see what they what they I just think having board me like this not really much to say three minutes to say something and you can't you know some good questions I grant we don't need the answer but at least keep somebody venue outside of the board I and I I agree I think it's an additional a I think there's an opportunity here if it's done properly I think it's an additional Avenue of communication with the

151community which is something that we all agree as needed right um but I again I want to stress if it's done properly I just don't want this to be a session where people are complaining I want to this to be a very proactive session and and if it's organized well I think it'll be a big opportunity for for us in the community together and to realize that it will be the board's final decision it's not going recommendations correct I I I also I would I would like to see I I agree um I think we need to be very focused and um mindful what that scope is what your expectations are and kind of set that up FR so when we're doing this you know I I know we have like uh student advisory committees

152out here I would love to have you know parents from secondary and every building or something to have away and just so parents have a voice you know or recommendations like sometimes we don't see it from their perspective and give us hey oh yeah that we didn't think of that that's a good that's a good note you know so I am in favor of this in some form I just don't know what that would would look like I think it's something we probably should discuss and figure out like what the parameters like what's their expectation how often do they meet these type of things you know is it going to be you know monthly is it quarterly how does that look what does that look like and I think we need to clearly Define goals

153and expectations before we do it because I don't want to like Hey Okay everyone's coming in Let's us go and what are we doing here that can all be established but going back to Sue's first thing here is we we have to make sure that we're consistent and I I'm going to recommend that we do seek out psba and what they currently have because that's what we do for all our other policies so our first step needs to be to hit psba and get an updated version of this that we can start using as as our template from that and then everything we've said here with the parameters we need go St St well like what's the frequency of the meeting uh you know stuff like that you know topics yeah the agenda exactly know

154and we do we we want to W you know for number five here the widest range of community interests um you know I want to make sure our business owners are are well represented on us as well within the community you know we've got parents we've got uh our local businesses we want to have their input on we want to have our elders on there as well you know and and obviously there's could be some other groups as well but we we definitely want to have that that wide range because it's it's having that opportunity to pull our community together on this but I just first and foremost I I want to see us making sure we're up to date with what psba has out there so we're we're modeling this just like we would

155any other policy I would also like to see us see what other school districts have they may already have a template set up as to what the topics are and how they do it that might help us to get this started yeah I'm just not sure like it would be interesting to see what is a when when other school districts are are enacting right that we have this because I don't think it's appropriate for every do I don't necessarily think it's appropriate out outside of the finances like I'm relying on you guys and the administration to with your staff work through which curriculums make the most sense I'm not not a teacher I don't know I'm not using it so I I mean I'm I I can sit there and and ask questions but I

156I'm not going to be able to offer a lot of input on that kind of stuff just did we pilot it did we include people in the decision so I don't know that everything is it would be interesting to see what other school districts are using when they when they enact this because it's not for everything so who would be moving forward to check with these other districts so what I'll do is um going to say that sounded to volunteer right I already have yeah I know Le strawberg has the exact same policy so I think what I can do is contact psba obviously to to look at to see if there's been any you know updates on that um I only see one legal citation so I'd have to just check the date of

157that citation um certainly if there's any other board members that want to assist me or if you are aware of them or if you're you know working or yeah colleagues in other locations it would be helpful because I agree I think um you know what works from one District might not be what always works for Pleasant Valley but I do think there's a great opportunity to you know have input you know have somebody as a soundboard uh my question obviously is more you know what's the frequency and you know John even when you were talking about like curriculum and policy you know again I'm looking at that are we having multiple advisory committees um you know and if so are they meeting uh quarterly weekly I mean I have no idea hopefully not weekly I

158think that's too far I think that that's too far ahead agree so we just need to see what the what other resources are out there that you know maybe they're moving this forward with like some five or six different models of other schools that and I think if you start making them too often you're not going to have the consistency so I mean not that you want to put a limit on it but I would say monthly just to start with it to get the warm up and see right and your first meeting basically just well I mean it really depends on the content this is the way that it reads now it's for specific things right like the renovation project the specific thing we first of all to understand the policy all going to

159understand the policy what you can and can't do what's the expectations of I will look at I'll look at the surrounding school districts and see if they have a policy for they probably all do but it's just whether they whether yeah whether they uses yeah there I don't know if there's a way we could contact the IU if they could put something out I'll be there tomorrow oh there you go I will put my take tomorrow will okay all right all right anything else on that or can we we'll have it back on the agenda again so I that's great to say that but I think we should put some parameters in the deadlines we have to meet to to get something in place right we don't well I mean I think by next meeting

160we'll have pba's feedback feedback and he's going to IU tomorrow so we'll have feedback for next meeting I'll have with the other districts she'll have go by next month we should be prepared for a first read I mean that should be our goal on the pever yeah then we have to work the you know R okay um superintendent report sure so just a couple of things want to highlight um first I want to uh thank Mrs Harris and then obviously the School nurses uh they coordinated a great opportunity for our students to uh work with St Luke's uh to provide Dental screening so I put the dates uh they're listed there um if you can't see that uh it is March 6th at the high school for I'm sorry at the high school and middle

161school and then it is March 7th for the intermediate and elementary schools uh this would include all of the state mandated screenings for grades uh kindergarten third 7th and 11th uh as well as the students for pbba so we want to make sure we obviously provide that opportunity as well but again just uh I think Mr gazis somebody had brought up the dental van I think we've done in the past so glad to get that back on track so that's really positive and make sure that our kids have that opportunity uh moving on the uh resolution for America 250 PA so I had to do some research because obviously you know I was think okay so this could be a variety of things um but certainly what it is is the sem semi Quinn Centennial

162the 250th anniversary of the founding of America and um so basically what was put forth back in 2018 was um a commission from the legislature and then the governor um and the goal was really to celebrate uh everything that that has taken place in the Commonwealth uh and the focus is for the 67 counties within the Commonwealth to really do some uh excellent activities events programs projects uh to emphasize uh you know how far we've come as a nation obstacles and hurdles to you know continue to move forward uh on but also really just celebrated and and you know as I was watching uh some of the media uh surrounding this you know and I truly believe this that all eyes would be on you know our state the common wealth obviously and then you

163have Pennsylvania you have uh Philadelphia is the birth place Independence Hall you know Philadelphia in the um July 4th the summer if you will of 2026 they'll have some really wonderful um events and and celebrations I'm sure and and ultimately what this is is this is an opportunity for not only all the counties but then also the districts within those counties to come up with some wonderful activities um ways to uh talk about uh you know our freedom and and and independ and uh and and the history of of everything that's taken place over these last 250 years so uh we're very proud to have uh Mr Burger who will um working with other organizations as well uh that's going to be um you know doing uh some great work and then also uh Mrs

164Fields will be spearheading our district efforts and and really working with students working with staff and you know identifying some activities but we're putting this obviously before everyone now because we have a little bit over a year to plan and and that time will go by very quickly so I just want to bring it to your attention and as part of that there's a resolution um that I'm looking to place on the next board agenda that obviously emphasizes everything that I just spoke about so um want to know if there's any questions about that okay so is this to incorporate stuff through all throughout the year representing the 250 years uh no I think what it's its main focus is um to I I guess you know looking at uh you know Fourth of July

165but but certainly throughout the span of probably uh maybe the spring leading into the summer I don't foresee it necessarily being you know uh things all throughout but I think as as we kind of you know Snowball to uh the summer there's going to be you know an increased activity so I think that's the goal and I think it's also nice that for for students to really you know take a look back uh and and look at you know the history that led us to you know the formation of this nation so and then you thinking of having some type of Celebration then for we we are and I think that that's in in conjunction with you know uh coordinating things with uh with with our townships within our County and so forth um and

166really try to get some things coordinated so it it's kind of a call I think to get everyone you know rowing in the same direction at this point so did you want the count well the county um did a resolution and then they reached out the Commissioners the County Commissioners and then they reached out to the school districts asking if we would be willing also to do resolution and they are also having their initial uh kickoff meeting this evening tonight um over at Northam Community College so Mrs Field's there and that's why Mr Burger's he's also there so um we'll get more information from them on it too but they asked for a resolution so it brings you know Community together it celebrates you know the 250 years of this great country and um it

167allows us again bring community together that's what I think believe that sign says something about community so I think it's a great opportunity to do that so we're okay with the resolution going on okay thank you great all right um in your folders everyone should received a draft of the 2526 uh school year calendar I know you know based on some of the things that were happening last year we had to make a number of pivots um and so we we really tried to slow down right uh and really take and take our time to to um you know put forth a plan we basically have been working on this U probably since I would say August or September and and you know each month we've been going back to it and and uh before

168you you know essentially we're looking at a similar format as to what we were doing this year some of the changes I wanted to highlight um as you can see and what we've done this year and then what we're hoping to uh you know have approved at the next board meeting uh for this calendar and this is where I'm asking you all for some feedback back is you know sticking with the two days of inservice uh the two days of new teacher orientation beginning um school would be August 25th uh which is a Monday there would be a 4-day school uh week that week as we've done the past two years um and then following week coming off of um Labor Day Monday then we would be here for four days uh a couple other

169things I wanted to emphasize was actually and and kind of a new change is uh on September 8th we would be looking to do an Act 80 day this will be uh no school for students so again what we're trying to ease them into is three weeks oh September oh yeah you know I'm sorry yeah you know what can I look at your thank you I was looking at the wrong one but yeah so um for this September 12th so it would be the um the second week where they would be uh one two I'm sorry the third uh week where they would have four days um a 4- day work week the second um I'm sorry September 12th the emphasis on that would be um to allow our students with nwaa for our staff

170to actually look at the results of nwaa and basically be able to use that to help Drive instruction for the next upcoming months um moving forward from there uh what we've reduced a little bit is the uh 2hour early um uh or 2hour late start that we were implementing this year we were running into some issues with that um and and ultimately uh when we were try to have uh cross District uh professional development um let's say with the um fifth and sixth grade teachers because they're on two different time slots it never really aligned to the degree that we had intentions for it to to happen now certainly we were able to accomplish a lot of things and we'll continue to but we think it would be just best to have that as a

171full um uh professional development day for our staff so that way we can avoid some of those conflicts uh moving on just again some additional changes uh for this year you know looking at the way that the calendar ends next year uh theoretically we would be off on January 1st uh 26 that would be a Thursday so it didn't make sense for kids to come back to school on the 2 for one day so we thought our staff would really appreciate that as well uh and then you know the students then start fresh on uh January 5th of 26 and ultimately what we would do is uh we would have our our graduation uh commencement is would would still be slated for May 29th so we've been pretty consistent about that for the past few

172years our tenative last day would be the 2nd of June and then what we're doing this year which I think is going to be really really helpful and we want to you know obviously bring this forward is that um after the students leave you know that's a great opportunity for our staff it's our last last time to get uh you know with our staff to focus in on professional development um if there's need for us to bring in groups of teachers over the summer we certainly would do that but it's a great opportunity to really get ready and ramped up for The Following fall so we want to make sure that uh we provide those opportunities so um I wasn't sure you know hopefully you have some chance to to look at this but um

173if there's any questions or anything that our staff can address that you might have concerns about you're not expecting seniors be here June 1st and second are you no they would they would be done no they they would be done that would be their y graduation they would be done yes I've got go ahead I've got two I've got two questions one the 25th that's is that the first day after the fair is that the week of the fair it's after the fair okay yeah the fair the week before week before to okay um on March 18th that's a Wednesday for the ACT why why not the 20th or the 16th yeah so um great question so one of the things that that we do is we track um Trend data and what we find

174is we have higher um percentages of Staff absences on Mondays and Fridays okay um that was intentionally placed there because we felt that if it was on a Wednesday there would be a greater likelihood that our staff would be there and and I really need to emphasize this like we understand that our staff might have some doctor's appointments and and in all honesty I mean we we've had conversation with staff saying you know really want you here with kids and I know that the byproduct of that is sometimes there's no other time to take but those um you know professional development days the problem is we lose a lot because that's an opportunity that we really have about six and a half hours to have some really great professional development and whether or not that

175teacher is there for that particular professional development we're still going to move forward and now they're going to be at a disadvantage so we're really trying to move away from that um and really get uh the most out of of some of those professional developments uh in that particular day trust me we definitely looked at it as the Monday the Friday I I just I got play Devil's advocation I know I had the same question we you know we we represent the community you know we gotta think about child care we gotta think how that's GNA imp who have to share custody and you know three-day weekend with somebody's you know just little things like that um kind of go a long way so but I understand your point of view as well especially if

176you're looking at I just have a question on the uh third and fourth of June I mean I understand what you're saying as far as it's a good time to get development in [Music] but going back to having devel having development on the Friday or Monday someone's going to take off when you're getting there to third and fourth you have how many teachers are possibly going to retire or not return and if they're switching positions okay it might be something else I I I mean I see it I I don't know what the answer is for that because like you said if I turn around and I train all these people now I got five or six of them that retired and now we're going to start the school year so during that in orientation

177is that when they're going to be expected to learn the new math program or the new reading program I I don't know if they answer is if it's new staff coming in we usually have them with their mental or the department chair because the department do have hours on the Sumer that they come in and they work with that person I think the other nice thing about this like with the new Ela program and we know that we'll see on the timeline like all of our core areas are coming up this giv a chance for us to give the initial background to the teachers and I I know our elementary teachers will take everything oh you better believe it so that way we can introduce it and there have a whole summer you know to

178review it and I also think going into the renovation project with the moving of rooms in the end of the year this is going to be very very helpful for us um you know if you saw there we already getting ready so I think at least for the next few years it's really helpful as we looking at our program then we're look at Science Program then um math and yeah so in the block to do with our uh snow days I'll call it the first line says if school is closed due to weather or an emergency staff and students will report to school in the next Act 80 professional development day so does that mean that if School were to be closed whatever January 28th then on February 13th we would not have an act

179dating day is that what that means explain that to me I'm trying to I was trying it it could be now remember we have five FID days um and you know we will always try to prioritize you know whether it's inclement weather or safety emergency to use a FID day um this is actually the first year in three years that we actually had a traditional snow day just given the parameters of of the safety concerns um so I I think what we're trying to say in this is that um we're going to essentially use a fit day however if that is not a viable option then it may become a traditional snow day which then means that we would have to have school the next Act 80 day corre why would you do that I

180I or we could add it to the end of the calendar I mean that's I mean you have the other days you know especially if you signed if you signed somebody commun to do it at 80 days I just I don't know that but we could could it on to the end I mean that's yeah the way I read this this is in the order of how the events would if there was a traditional snow day this is how we would cover that traditional snow day in this order and I'm not sure you want to use an Act 80 day yeah I don't think so I think you need okay so I don't know whether add it to the end either add it to the end or take it out I don't know but I

181don't think you we can we can make that adjustment certain I remember being a parent and it was always yeah June 2nd is the last day of school okay so February 1st we had a snow day guess what it didn't we didn't have to figure out what day it was and now just it's got extend to the next day in June there wasn't well are we losing this day or doing it was I'm just saying I remember my kids were in the system it was this is the last day of school okay if you had four snow days guess what you tack four days on wasn't are we losing a day Easter or it's easy that's good point and and I know that that creates a lot of confusion because I I've seen it personally

182where um a snow St hits and now you're taking um Dr Martin Luther King Jr day or you're taking President's Day and it's really difficult for a lot of so I agree we could just tack it on at the end it's easy it was easy remember school started we knew that day I my kids to go extra day that's a great recommendation and I want to jump back on with what Matt said um regarding March 18th for that I just I agree with you that all the other ones are are back are you know back ping up against the weekend and yeah I I I get the whole Monday and Friday absences that's that's not just isolated here at P that's elsewhere as well and so if we kept it on the 18th so now

183those same people are still going to take off on that 16th to the 20th which means we're paying for a substitute V now our kids don't have a teacher in front of them and then we're going to do that on the 18th so I'm with Matt I I we did it on the other ones just keep it consistent Bank it on a Friday or Monday okay that helps our parents out uh the other question I have here is I see going into the holidays we have these half days I we got we're proposing two weeks off for Christmas break and we're going to start at the Friday before with a half day already yeah that that's that's contractual that's already that that's I I just want to make that known out there two weeks off

184but already putting the parents out with a half day there already for their kids to have to deal with that but that's contractual that's contractual okay just want that okay so just one thing with the fit days and traditional snow days you know is it this is not my idea but then who gave it to you I live with um what about what about having the idea of having fit day next one would be traditional right I mean giving the kids a break just to relax unwind I how much work actually really gets done and let's be honest yeah I know my house I mean they have to be on their schedules but like your class was 45 minutes and you're already down here like that doesn't make sense sure so let's go back to

185Old way of working true traditional snow days to enjoy relax and have fun and it gets tacked on the end of June that's life I graduated on June 17th I think we we certainly can one thing I would say from staff that I've spoken to over the years is that a lot of teachers once they know what the calendar is they're booking their summer vacations and I'm not to say not to say that you know they can't make adjustments in it but I think people start kind of thinking about you know okay so if I'm done June 2nd then what does my June 4th fth look like and so forth so I'm just saying should be mindful of it I'm not saying to that as an excuse um but I think a lot of us

186myself included you know we look at the school calendar to then figure out okay so what what does our time away from work look like um I I'm not opposed to the idea at all about you know kind of doing traditional snow again if that's the will of the I that's why we're having this discussion in draft just to say hey are there things that we're missing as a parent as a community member over the last couple of years are there things that you know you'd like to bring to the table for us to either consider or us to really do um because ultimately we were really trying to narrow that scope of trying to be done in late may but I think we can all agree that you know that's not the end goal

187sometimes it's going to bleed over into June that's perfectly fine because we're still ending pretty early but I just think just trying to get feedback from all you do we know what the other districts have they started to look at their calendar yet they they usually do I'd say sometime in February I mean and and uh usually with our draft I I've been annually sending this to them just saying hey here's what we're doing so we can try to get in sync with things and the reason I'm asking that question I do believe you and you probably know the answer to this for sure that East straussburg uses their snow days first before they use fit days and what why where I'm going with this wondering what the other districts do because of mcti yeah

188again is my concern yeah you know like that's my concern because who uses what first because if the other districts use their FID days first then I'm almost have a tendency to use our FID days only because it doesn't then hurt our mcti students right and and you know and I just want to throw that out in in conversation with the Monroe County Superintendent I think it it just all depends on the parameter so for example if we know that we're getting a big snowstorm right um what I've seen over the years is Pocono Mountain and East straussburg um most likely going to a traditional snow day because of the weight on the wires and the impact it would have even if they were to try to Pivot to a FID day that's kind of

189been their philosophy was that you know this this storm could essentially break down our uh electronic communication so we might as well just pivot to a traditional snow day so I think it really just depends on you know what kind of weather we're seeing you know um what's what's the Potential Threat things of that nature um but yeah I mean we and and as you know the last few years we've typically done FID days first and that's why we've never had traditional snow days because we've never exceeded five for the past three years which which I think is beneficial because then that end date that we said a year ago that a lot of people planned around still stays intact you know and I will be frank I mean there's a lot of great work

190happening during those days but you know there are pockets of maybe not as much or you know is there a better way to do it you kind of have to balance out and I I'm just being a realist here you know let's say there's a a February 12 there's a FID day well is there really an academic um uh if you were to compare academics on that FID day versus tacking it on on June 3rd do you really think we're going to get the academics that we want on June 3 as an extra day that we tacked on to the year in comparison to during the school year so again these are things that run through our minds because we're trying to get the most of what we can especially before pssas and keystones because

191instruction matters and that those one day two day three day if we did traditional snow day we're three days behind so those are things we think about as well so let me ask you this is there a compromise we do we do live instruction Zoom okay like I for instance the district I'm that does not do live instruction Zoom they have a FID assignment that is posted online they do at their every class and usually they have a PR like a week to get it done so if there's a snow day that day so in that Essence the kids that type the computer can go enjoy the snow and week to finish that assignment so I I feel like there's a midr there too I don't know what it look like from educational standpoint but

192I knew some districts do do that so say hey I'm not doing any of this say I'm gonna go play with snow for this day and I got a week to get this thing done I can hand it in for a week so that gives like a flexibility there uh I like the idea of flexibility um I know that one of the things we do try to emphasize especially for like some of our younger kids too is that you know we don't want a student to be sitting front of the computer the entire day let's try to figure out what's balance even for our high school students you know here's the assignment you know I'm I'm here for the office hours um but often times they're actually doing work and the hope is is that

193there's still a little bit of you know balance with them if they want to you know get outside if it's a beautiful day in the snow um so we do try to do that I I think the other parameter though Mr Clark is that um it depends on how the FID day was written like we do have to be um yeah it because that's what we submitted to the state we have we can't just automatically pivot unless we get secondary approval so so it was this something you really wanted approved next meeting or do we have some time this is something that I was hoping to get some feedback and I think I got two good pieces of feedback I think the goal at least in my mind was that you know if if if

194it's minimal changes or recommendations again moving that March uh PD date and taking out the box language I would personally like to put on the agenda because we're you know having this approved much later than we have for the past few years and I think again people are already kind of looking ahead as to you know I want to make you know plans and I want to you know figure out what the last day is what the start day is and so forth so that's very helpful for everyone um I think the discussion about you know the FID days the pivots that's something we can continue to have because I think it's a valid point and honestly we kind of have to see how things are going to go for the rest of this year

195in particular as well um you know and and what are the pros and cons because we we constantly talk about that instructionally but uh I mean I would if there's other than those two changes um if the board would be in agreement I'd love to get it approved and then continue discussions if necessary if you guys are okay with I'm okay with that with pending the two okay I also have one other option I mean not going de with it but I know just with my grand kid out Kansas is that i' say instead of having the third and fourth as your makeup day your last day would be actually the fourth but here in January 21st which is a Friday that's a snow day and so they actually put those days in there so

196now if they had a snow day they knew that they would they give them a day off okay for for the 21st but it was a snow day then they had make it up but they the year end still ended on the fourth because they bu M Mountain West did did similar they build in three or five snow days and if you exceed but if you don't use them school ends early right no for people no it's throughout the year it's throughout like they use certain days not in a row you're saying you're saying one day here one day here think they schedule them yeah I think that they they used to schedule them like so School ended on a Wednesday right like a makeup day one would be Thursday makeup day two would be

197Friday then you would lose like the Friday of president's weekend and like they prioritize priority there's a priority but but going back to what Mr Geller was saying too that that's where I think things that I've seen you become very challenging because you know to to parents to who have planned that hey this is what I'm going to do on um President's Day but now I'm going to take that away and even for our staff I know that that was a challenge because I had to do that about six years ago um so it does it does become challenging it's a lot easier to T on we used to do that we used to take like the Thursday before Easter or the Easter Monday we used to do that and the staff really didn't like

198that so we pulled it back out and we haven't done in a while so I think if we added there for traditional day I think that would make sense or safety day that we can't you know in have instruction so um but does that sound like we can put this on the agenda given those two changes and continue conversations are we okay that yeah okay okay all right thanks before we jump to the next thing only because say we thank the Community member for being here for the working session it's been a long time since we've seen other faces besides us um what is what's the allowance of community involvement during the working session I have it down on the agenda to oh what never mind at the end I have it but I think

199you're asking for during yes I don't know I I I I I did see a hand to the left and I yeah I just don't want to I mean I have it that at the end okay and I you know I just think we'll see something that in the me I just you know this is a long agenda this evening because we haven't had a work session since November so no no I'm just I I yeah I get you yeah okay all right where we at here we're at um building start and end times yes uh so we're looking to make a small modification to next school year so and I want to make sure I try to capture the essence of this so we have the benefit actually at PVE and pvi where our

200teachers arrive I believe it's 30 minutes or so before students arrive um it's actually I believe 35 minutes that they arrive to work and that's a great opportunity because as as a teacher you know you need to be prepared for the day so you have your agenda lesson your PowerPoints are all ready you know all the classroom set up the way that it should depending on the learning activity that day and um it also allows for collaboration so it's always a great opportunity to identify um you know what are some struggles for some of our students maybe a grade level team meeting uh that needs to get together maybe two teachers maybe a mentor and mentee teacher are getting together within that 35 minutes to go over um you know how how things are going

201and and provide feedback so we don't have that opportunity at the middle school and high school in fact uh I'm not sure if you're aware but literally the time that teachers have to arrive and not to say that that some of them are coming in very early but the teachers have to contractually be in the building five minutes five minutes before our middle school and high school students arrive in the building and that can be a very chaotic time and again I think you know overwhelming majority of our staff are getting there a little bit before uh that time but it's kind of like at your own will Pace if you will and and I don't think it's as structured and it's not given that much time for that collaboration and frankly you know it's

202my belief and it's our principal's beliefs too that you know we're we would be a lot further ahead if um staff members had opportunities to collaborate if we were able to have IEP meetings in the morning if it works with a parent schedule that way they can get to work on time and we can get to our classes on time things of that nature um so that what I'm looking to to do is to infuse uh greater opportunities for collaboration at the middle school and high school so here's what that would look like um for next school year the start time for uh teachers to arrive for students to arrive none of that changes at PVE and pvi the only change would be at the middle school and high school teachers would arrive five minutes

203earlier than what they currently do this school year okay five minutes we're also looking to make an adjustment where um they now would have with that five minutes uh and actually let me phrase it this way that five minutes is critical and here's why at the end of the school day at the middle school and at the high school teachers stay after at the middle school for 10 minutes after students are dismissed and at the high school 15 minutes after teachers uh I'm sorry after students are dismissed so we ask ourselves you know what is happening within that 10 or 15 minutes and and and more importantly you know what can we do better with that time now I can tell you in my past um what I did and I I'll call say to

204all of you it's reallocating time right I can't necessarily increase the time because I can't change the contract in that regard the seven and a half hour workday however I have the ability to adjust time and we have to ask ourselves that 10 or 15 minutes at the end of the day is that necessary right we do need to make sure kids clear out but in this proposal that I would have what we would do is take some of that backend time I'll call it at the end of the day put that towards the front of the day and what that would ultimately equate to is um the middle school and high school having 20 minutes before students arrive this to us is is a profound impact on learning and teaching because my teachers have

205an opportunity to be all prepared have their Labs ready at the high school at the middle school they have an opportunity to collaborate with one another um to make sure that their lesson plans are uploaded um you know and then they have an opportunity to meet as a grade team as a department team just even colleague to colleague to do some of the things that we know is happening at the elementary schools so um so that's what we're looking to do literally have the middle school and high school teachers start five minutes earlier reallocate some of that backend time make it more meaningful and and and um streamlined and ultimately uh hopefully get more bang for buck with our teachers having the opportunity to collaborate with one another so um so I I provided that

206to you and then obviously some of you I knew you would have have the comparison for this year which is good again because I want to bring it to your attention that that's how we've looked at this time reallocation but I want to know if you had any questions or if you were able to see some concerns uh from last year to this year and how it impacts uh teaching and learning so teachers that pre time would be theirs you're not assigning them to me the gist of is I would like you to collaborate if you need but you're not saying I have to I I I think that's that's the that's the the goal behind it however um liking you to do something doesn't necessarily mean you'll do it so you know when we're

207talking about teacher uh negotiations maybe that is something that we we talk about because here's the thing um they've done that in the past at PB PBI they certainly um do that now uh at at the at the schools if if they find that it's um something that they have that prep time that they want to collaborate it's certainly strongly incouraged um but take for example Monday right we all know Monday as a teacher can be really challenging because I'm getting my graded papers I'm putting them you know on top of the desk so I'm making sure I have all my resources that wouldn't be in my opinion a good time for teachers to collaborate right but the Tuesday Wednesday Thursday when we gave an assessment from last week I can meet with my teacher

208team and we can talk about some of that comparative data hey any outliers do we have any uh resources oh I found this resource over the weekend you know here I want to share it with my team I think there's that opportunity you teacher right you're darn right when I was at the high school no there 6:30 I had to get my my gym ready I have to get all my stuff but I didn't contract do there but this would be nicer that okay great now I can tune in you know at 635 I I I think I think the benefit uh you know mrki is the fact that like um the students don't come in immediately right and not to say that people are coming in at 7 o'clock right now I know they're

209not but my point is is that like you know as soon as that time comes around you know it the kids are in the building and it's very very quick um it would be an opportunity to even you know like let's say that there's an uh you know a staff meeting you could go on the announcement without interrupting you know instruction so again I I think the the intention of it is make sure that we have the opportunity there because if we don't have the time we can't even have the discussion to try to collaborate but my hope is is that you know we could uh for all the you know 50 things that are happening before students start the school day we have an opportunity to actually make use of that file yep so

210okay go ahead so I have a question so looking at the the start times I understand that what you're trying to C with the teachers right now I'm looking at the student times yes so there's a 10 minute disparity there so first take the high school right normally class start time would be at 7:20 um we are going to start at 7:30 however the dismissal time is the exact same in that scenario so in essence we're losing 10 okay is that how is that 10 minutes being distributed throughout the day where are we taking that 10 minutes from how is it affecting our kids and and that's that's the trade off right so I mean um so we're looking at um will having 10 minutes of you know teacher planning prep collaboration trade off into

211more engaging better instruction I I think from my standpoint the answer would be yes now you know when we're looking at the minutes and hours remember that with with the new um that came forward last year we don't have to abide by the 990 hours 900 hours 180 days there are some parameters that allow us to um uh make better use of the time but from my standpoint you know if that's an opportunity for a teacher to review um let's say assessment data and they're going to group students based on that information um that is probably going to give more bang for buck than um you know having the kids come in five minutes after the teachers are physically in the building and not and and kind of being a rat race at that point

212I guess my that's less of my concern I guess my question was ask is asking so you have to make up these 10 minutes right right now we a bell schedule so where's those where's that 10 minutes coming from we shorting every class by one minute or yeah and on the back end too just I can answer that part then if you want to jump in there but from when we looked at the uh Transportation Time study that was one of the first things we looked at was you know how will this impact busing because theoretically if we were to start um instruction 10 minutes later then we would push everything back 10 minutes meaning that the students would end 10 minutes later than what they currently are but by doing that and keeping PVE

213and PBI at the same times we wouldn't be able to do that otherwise we'd shift everything as a district um and we could theoretically do that but go ahead I'll let you the current year we increased the time between periods at the high school um by a minute one minute when the renovation done we won't have to have that extra time because they won't be traveling the whole way over to jcm so we can take that minute back out yeah the renovation is happening that's not this goes into spec the next year so how we get the 10 minutes back well so in the future makes sense but in the now how does that work we could we could still do it though next year this was the first last year they didn't have the

214five minutes between classes they had the four we could go back to that um and we're looking at how middle schooling how we're grouping grades next year so there'll be less travel time for our kids as well between the classes so so the answer is it looks like you guys are taking it from the in between not a lot of not the instruction time not the instruction that's kind of where not all from the instruction time they're actually trying to have minimal impact on the instruction time but more of the transition time even looking at lunches I mean things like that that we're trying to like take time how are we making up sure we're shaving now that's I'm trying to figure out on the surface but in the details inside yeah exactly and the

215same scenario goes for the middle school too yes yeah yeah but theirs is a little different I think there there is only 14 yeah there I don't know why 14 I'm me I like the idea actually I like the idea that the students report later because I think studies show now that students should start lat they should start later so that piece but yeah yeah I don't think studies say there's a huge difference though between 715 7 no I agree it's probably it's probably high school high schoolers operate better at a.m. has this been vetted through the teachers the people who this is going to impact and effect uh this uh was vetted um when we actually made the adjustment last year year uh for some of the times um so but to directly answer

216your question in terms of like you know putting this out there for polling purposes no because we're talking about five minutes now there would be a difference if this was a 10 or 15 minute adjustment that's where I think we would need to go in and discuss this with I'm not disagreeing with your points right but we can sit on high and make these decisions and say it sounds good yeah but impacts people right right and I want to make sure they're okay with it before I say yes sure I me that's what it comes out I I I I've made some important decisions in my career of my teams that I'm leading I thought it sounded great yeah but it didn't impact to people right and this is this is an impactful it's five

217minutes I get it but there could be some impact and are they going to use the time for what you wanted to do and how do we structure that to make it happen right um again I'm not saying no but I want to make sure the people that are being impacted are involved right because that's a huge criticism that we hear is that decisions are made and we're not involved I I hear it all the time and not just at home making that [Laughter] very ask them just the high school for example they're coming in five minutes extra early but they they're leaving 10 minutes early understand the teacher missed I'm look at the teacher side right so 6:55 they right they're leaving 5 minutes early that's correct okay so basically taking five in the

218front but giving them an extra five five in the back that is correct so that's where we're reallocating that with the middle school middle school so so report five minutes earlier and five minutes ear their work day is five minutes Less in this scenario that you're creating it's the same it's shifting by five minutes I said I I mean I think this is a good idea and I think the teachers are most going to be favorable they're probably already there at that point anyway um if if they're like John down there but I don't like the idea personally of shortening the time frame that they're going class to class if there's another workaround just to think on the back end of it I know how struggling it is for some of the students and feedback

219from my own kids and their friends how they have to look especially at the middle school level yeah not that I have any kids there now but I did and I heard the horror stories of having lugged all the stuff around get to your locker get back because there's no way they can carry there's a lot going on in the middle so if there's some kind of work around you could at least take a look at that um but I like the idea of okay that's if you look at the the flow of where they're going it's like up down left right and and so we're trying to streamline that that you know this would be you know either by uh this floor you know would be near the locker and this would be the

220seventh grade team so those are things that's good good point those are things we certainly look at make these decisions what were you doing down there I asked if they were using the routing [Laughter] software so what's the pleasure of the board in terms of moving forward because I mean talk to the staff yeah talk to the staff a little bit get your get your feedback you do a faculty meeting or okay yeah all right we do that yeah we'll show them the five minutes earlier and then leave five minutes earlier so get some feedback we'll do we could do at the next faculty meeting and that way that actually would duvail with the next board meeting um and then depending on that feedback principles if you guys can give me some of that feedback

221I can Circle it back around with the board so okay um we're under we're up to uh education and curriculum so and I think we're stared with the program in right yes so I am going to start with M after middle school and I will you now these are presentations aren't anywhere near as long as they've been in the past because we really didn't make major changes like we have because we much time the last few years but there are a few things that they keep want to highlight so that's good news yeah we're weing I know we're weing you have's what you say I missed we should have drank that before all right I would normally say good evening but I guess good [Laughter] night um I'm here to present the middle school program

222of studies um not many major changes um a lot of reformatting and reorganizing um for example um under each grade level's electives um I remove specific listings for say banded chorus um because they're not scheduled in the same way that you would schedule um your art class it doesn't go to like a six period and meet during when so instead I move that up into the uh description the sections on the educational program and what we off um so things like that shifting around um I added in some sections because um this is the first time really our students are starting to um become more active in their education and schedule um courses that meet their needs and choices um so we begin with um how does the school year even work the school term

223how it's broken up from uh semesters and marketing periods and what that equals in terms of time um I also included uh information on cohorts or or what you would call their graduating years because now you're looking at your classes and we have uh the class of 2030 wow yeah that made me feel very old when I read that to tell you so it's then broken down into um each grade level each grade level section begins with an overview um a description of what students and parents need to know you every sixth grade student needs to take ABC and d and in terms of your electives these are your required electives you have to take ABC and D you get this many choices I believe in sixth grade it's one elective of their choice um

224the sections are then broken up into sixth grade core classes sixth grade electives and the format repeats for seventh grade and as they the middle SCH they get more choices in their electives ultimately ending in e8th grade where it's more of a flowchart because depending on the courses that you take would impact the number of electives that you take in 8th grade um we added in an orts course as an elective and in the core courses um section um we look to streamline um course requirements um for students who want to take um English honors prep Algebra 1 Spanish one um each course in the previous addition of the programing studies had different requirements and they weren't really streamlined one course wanted a 92 in every single marking period and another course said we're going

225to do a 92 overall your final average so what we did was we streamlined it um so that with the entrance criteria one were recommended and two that we were in line with the high school we found that some of our requirements were out of line with what the high school was looking to do those are the Middle School yes have a TV School whoa that's exciting sort of a feeder program for pbtv great students who have that interest we can get them introduced and then we have those two girls on the PV video future absolutely so at the bottom of page 10 yeah I have it too there's a uh in the Blue Area you need to change the bot to B and my only other comment um page 11 um you have at

226the top the cew I'm like okay what does cew stand for and I found it but it was down in the the context so maybe if you put it up top or spell it out that it's Career Education and work I don't know just my just something I saw I said that's all I had so I have I have not a question just kind want to revisit something just kind of want to understand the thought process so this is not something you changed and something that we did last year we we have the I think I know why it was done Ed light still exist so one of the things we did is we used to give credit for algebra one and Spanish one okay and that was taken away I would assume that was

227created and we have now we have a 20 you have a final get to take that class so I assume they had mirrored the high school class so you had a final that be the high school class and then Essence why you got the credit for the high school class because in essence it should be no different ticket here here so the question I have is we removed the credit requirement you all to earn credit for that particular class in the high school so why are we still doing the final in those two areas those only two classes that go finals if it's in my mind if it's going to be treated like a high school class they should get the high school credit if we're not which is fine then why are we giving

228them a final so ucational Logic on that typic you don't earn high school credit when you're in high school that's how much High School look at it everything you take those classes to say you can accelerate into the higher math um when you get to the high school I'm not debating that why we a final because it is algebra they should be that's is expected like so we know that you take that and it's a keyst test of course you know so we want to make sure they're hitting the same common assessments as I guess I struggle with that logic yeah I feel like if you're going to trat on the high school person they should get that great because by now have a college transcript right like one of your things says hey you're

229going to fulfill two language requirements well all in my transcrip going show one language how does a college know hey and this a keystone course how do you show how do you like yeah I can tell you I've been a high school principal for a long time and most of our kids already came in with algebra and geometry into our high school you're not going into algebra too without having those other courses um so that was never an issue um with Spanish for example um a the AP Spanish course the School prerequisite is Spanish 4 if you don't have the opportunity to take Spanish one at the middle school you're never going to get to Spanish 4 which means you're closed out of the opportunity to earn college board credit and that's typically why you

230offer those classes in the middle school for those kids that are ready to accelerate to accelerate them I mean there I mean that's the reason you take it not to get the high school credit is so you can get to like a calculus if you don't get into math down there it's really hard to let you double in high school like alphab 2 and geometry because that's you can only double with geometry that's why I like T sched that's day also this is just my opinion Thinking Out Loud here you know I also think it's kid-friendly and you might be like what to make them take a final exam in the middle school where the transcript isn't going to follow them of of course we want our kids to meet success but this is probably

231their first exposure to a final exam that takes a that's a whole skill in itself to learn how to prepare for something that dates back to what I learned on September 1st and I think this provides our kids with a safety net where yeah it's a challenge yes it's a final exam but they don't have the pressure of what I do today on this exam is worth 20 it is worth 20% of the grade but it's going to impact me and follow me for the next four years and that's a hard hole to dig out when it starts to calculate into well I think with the credit part I think senior year should be taking the most Rous I led it I was a high school principal for 18 years um and they would say

232well it's my senior year I I'm GNA take it easy and you know what I always say this isn't you taking much challenging because you're going off to college and that's why we try to build them up like that as well so anyone else comments on the middle school okay like M mccut said uh good exra evening Happy New Year too uh at the high school we spent the last two years really going through the program studies fine tuning it so for this year uh the changes we really have is we added AP pre-calculus class and a lot of the big changes is we opened up a lot of courses for underclassman so a lot of the courses from before might only 11th and 12th grade now it's 9th and 10th they give more opportunity

233for our students to take more courses in elected Fields if you have any questions about High School page 13 uh I think that tracking worksheet should say 25 26 school year and I think there's another one the same way page 23 it says the WR schol too yeah there's just a couple of school year uh are page I have page 2 two marked maybe it's 22 again it's just the wrong school year somewhere it's when it's talking about 8 courses yeah advanced placement courses say 2425 so those two okay and and the only other question I have I and I I know you made some changes to mcti I think stuff did I see that we added financial literacy in there where before if you're mcti um you you were exempt from corer Explorations in

234portfolio Okay um but now with the state you're mandated to take Financial okay I know it's sometimes hard for mcti to get to get everything scheduled so are they going to be able to get this done yeah so what we ended up doing we had M Morgan was looking through the programs of mcti to see what credits we can pull from there like for if you're doing carpentry we can pull math credit from there if you're doing cosmetology we can take a science credit um this way that we can ensure that they're getting act all their fed classes and taking all the required classes they need to okay graduate from there that's was my other question okay any other questions yes question sorry that's all right um I know get late so the the the

235in the one line you talked about um the midterm you guys changed the the language of that so surrounding the midterm it's basically if I understand it correctly it's going to up to the Department's discretion when that they give a midterm and if they do give a midterm it doesn't spell out the percentage in there one it says it be a portion of the 20 but it could be five and 15 I don't know that so I um I believe it says 10% yeah yeah page 20 on the PDF or 21 21 on the PDF 20 on the written first and then1 we good are we I'm sorry he's still looking for it okay I was ask question yeah I got I got you so there's there's no there's no percentage so right I guess

236that was my question like is does the department have the flexibility to say hey 5% the fin 15% just right there it's not really spelled out no it would be 10% 10 10 so right so here's my followup question since they have equal weight 10 and 10 is it safe to assume that the midterm covers q1 from Q2 or is the final cumulative q134 or is that just it would be q1 Q2 for Mid Q3 Q4 for so be split okay then that makes sense I going to say if that's final going to be one through four then that weight would be significantly five and 15 make sure that was otherwise this doesn't make sense to me and the other question is and this is more for technology because I live this world is your

237system G to be able to deal with people who decide to give it a r ter versus a notot and that calculation and all that GPA that needs to make that happen because that could be very cumbersome have we consulted technology and the power school system that it will be able to accomplish what we're writing on a piece of paper Chuck has been hard at working the phones the last couple weeks yeah he actually he has all figured out okay okay um this is just question June 5th why June 5th for the AP course what's the thought process of that uh it was I believe that's Friday of the week why it's the year it's the year before though you said you got you can't drop the AP course so if I pick a AP

238course for next year I can tell you that because we've had when I first came we had a lot of people sign up and then large numbers dro totally changed section sections I know those are small sections just like two three sometimes go from remember this okay I just want logic thing yeah and my last this my last thing I swear for shut up home no one thinking this is a question in general so I've had this years before so explain to me your vision of Summer work what the educational value that because it's not inally instruction Le it's not instructor Le right it's mostly busy work it comes out in different tiers like for inst my son right he'll get some of it in June I'll get some of it in July he'll get

239some of in August depending on the teacher right when it's released um then you'll have to get some of it I've had some of it count as an assessment right some of it counts as a homework so I guess standard I'm looking for one standardization for for for kids are taking that and then secondly do we still I know something we used to do but is there still value in that right we're not it's not instru Le um in Ence if I'm assessing a kid I'm really assessing him and how he taught himself over the summer right so if I'm doing it's like did my son teach himself properly so I guess have we looked at that in the recent times or is it something just we've kind of been rolling with is it something

240we should reevaluate at some point I could bring that up to the department chair meeting and get their thoughts on on standardized um I have no problem getting the teacher input about that in their feedback and I think a little bit of a problem we've had and you guys have a work around is um teachers change schedules changing over the summer um like so maybe I'm assign to AP Lit but something happens to section numbers and my schedule changes like in June and then another person has to go in that's some sometimes I know what they've done we've had person who had it previously well I you for example like for instance like my I I my reference to my son right teacher reached out said hey it's going to be done this date here's

241a here's here's your work it's gonna come out this date then that date come comes and goes no communication kid asks no response and finally oh it'll be out it won't be that bad like the week before it came out a so it's like I'm I guess I'm not against summer work but like or why are we assessing on the summer work that was my question like because it's not instructor Le it's not that kind of thing so like I'm not I understand there's reading lists there's other things but I want to make sure that we're not just giving busy work to give busy work some of that feels like that at times if there's value there I'm for Value but if there's not value I don't want to keep doing something that's not valuable

242if that makes sense I agree so if that's something we can maybe look at moving forward I really think that be Val I think it's really good feedback and I know it's something that we've had problems with um the last few years I've been here with summer and I get it this summer we usually get the emails in August right all year if it was done at the end of the year we they kind schedu they have it stuff they plan appropriately and run but it's like some teachers release it at certain times and then it's like they're checking in I don't want to miss it if there that I'm finally done okay anyone else okay under education I just have one thing I want to mention um so I you probably all know my

243daughter-in-law works or pocon Mountain she came home today and she said to me that they had this big meeting yesterday with their parents they're offering this program to their parents that if they have a um an associates degree or a bachelor's degree but not in education um there's a two-year program that they can uh become a teacher and it's through a college in Pittsburgh because they have a shortage so I don't know but you know know maybe you want to reach out I don't know if it's something that you know we'd be interested in or not but it's interesting because of the shortage of teachers so is there a stipulation as the time and service that they're working as a car they have to far I don't know all the details I know they have

244to have the degree the one of the two degrees because PE that's interesting BR P changed the summer the PRX the higher CTE teachers and what they did there is anybody that has a bachelor's degree it used to be four years of full-time document documented trade experience now it's Andor a bachelor's degree in two years trade experience so this is tying right in with what PD did with the CTE Arena to make this doable so Props to them I don't know but they're also encouraging the certificate just wanted to mention it but if you wanted to look in whatever I don't know yeah okay um curriculum review I'll be honest it's not so much a review went back and forth about what to call it it but um I a lot of questions as we

245were talking abouta um and the ELA and we talked about math and so what we wanted to do is just um some questions were asked about NWA so we wanted to answer those questions and then provide a timeline of when things are happening things have changed um you know we're pushing back math because we know it's a lot on our elementary I'm let them take it over so this is probably take about 45 minutes apologize yeah though uh so one of the things here with this overview and and we here is just we wanted to inventory our benchmarking assessment here and I wanted to give you that overview of really all the uh benchmark assessments that we provide uh to our students at the district and so if you take a look at this here

246we broke it down by our buildings that we have and uh there's a lot um and when you take a look at uh how much we assess that it's a lot of instructional time being lost so with this there are three key things that I kind of want to just emphasize and the first one is uh for example at the elementary your QPS here and your cadi that is um the those one so that takes a lot of additional time than a a standard assessment where you just put that kid and get the whole class done at one time you have to work with that that kid individually to do that screener on top of that uh the other thing here we're looking at I said is the the loss of instructional time uh some

247of these assessments take over two days some take three days uh it obviously depends on the grade level it also depends on you know the level of the student going through that that assessment and if you take a look at they're all different platforms so you have your high ready you have the cdts you have star we have the the new Firefly you have Alex you have uh the acadians there are so many different platforms that we're using to assess students compile that data together those tools that this the students use are different depending on the platform and then our teachers that are at typically at the younger Elementary and intermediate uh you know they're going on multiple platforms to get that data and try to compile so there really are three big things there

248that just kind of wanted to focus on when we take a look at this inventory so to switch here you know looking at NWA and why you know it's really good to to have and Implement here is it's all in one platform the data is stored all together essentially K to 12 so we don't have to have a teacher learn how to use one platform and then another platform to gather that data and our students the tools that they're using is consistent across that platform you'll uh you you'll also see up there though we do have I ready and Alex still on there uh because we obviously are not looking at doing a math review yet we're pushing that off and I ready and Alex they have what they classify as a my path so

249we wanted to look at some comparison to help us move forward with eventually our math evaluation of that curriculum and we will get some data between the NW a and also the Diagnostics of I ready and Alex um so that's uh a little bit on on that piece there so can I ask a question so Firefly will go away yes that's and that's a state and it's aligned to the state standards that is correct yes so but nwea is aligned to the state stand that'll be on the next slide oh okay sorry yep so um and I did get feedback from um we did do a pilot and I did get feedback and I did share that with the teachers as well as um you know to be transparent and a that feedback was it

250was taking too long um it was it was it was rigorous uh so you know those are things that we are are looking at as we as we move forward but um once again the the Firefly just came out and you know it's a pilot so I'll turn it over I will say one other thing about um I'm sorry that screen I think the nice thing about nwea it's also going to it's a test that's not basing what they learned that day in the classroom this is like as they're learning it's telling us where they're beiring where they should be with other students the same age the same grade that which we really don't have that right now what we really only see is how are they doing ready on their path but when we

251take that and compar to where they should be it's not magic where they should be onra this is going to show us where our kids are going to be or should be on grade level as as we progress throughout the year and it tracks them the whole from kindergarten the whole way through so we'll also be able to see where are we dipping why is we look at the curriculum at that grade level so we haven't had that so this is going to do this for us and when we when we pull up a student on a screen you see everything on one screen here's where they are on math here's where they are on Ela here where they are in science and it will show you their path it can group kids for us

252it will tell you you need to take these five students and work on this this so can you go back to the last slide only because it's different from what I have we did some upd yeah we thought we thought our last we we thought it more confusing so how often will this be done nwaa yeah um beginning middle and and okay we use that as v um there are um for your Elementary it could be more often if that student would need it um you know that's that would determined based on the kind of test but um the the ones at the elementary are like 20 minutes so the average uh test time here is about 45 to to 50 minutes about a class and the one thing we've heard from parents is kids

253are just Ted we that's why we wanted to show you what has been other tests have come over the years oner don't l l so the goals were to to streamline assessments that could be beneficial to guide instruction to align the assessments to um the standards uh to to tested material uh to give teachers you know uh quantitative data um and then also to have continuity and what I mean by that is that a third grade teacher at pvi can look at the nwaa test data of their students that are incoming from second grade on multiple data points to see who's making progress you know what are some of the gaps and that way they can already start to group and differentiate based on that information and that will take it all the way from

254kindergarten through 12th grade so there's a lot of benefit to having continuity and it's a one less thing for teachers to sign on because you know they're going to IR ready signing in trying to create a report and then going into this other program and going into this other program we're just trying to make it a little bit more streamlined throughout the district if I if I can also pay you back on that for example you would have obviously your math teacher in eth grade that has the I already access um you know they're not going to have access to any of their reading scores or science scores so here that score is all in that so they that could help differentiate you know if a student is struggling in read they can actually differentiate

255part of that with the math alog together issue the lower grades level of like word problems and stuff yeah okay I guess as I'm listen is you said beginning middle and end for the testing so what kind of data are they collecting perfect okay so everybody took care of most of what's on this slide so um so I get to talk less I think um but as far as as far as in between um that'll be covered partly um by the next slide what to do with those multiple data points over the course of the year and um what differentiates the standards aligned um to PA of nwaa from something like Firefly is that nwaa would will um give the suggestions what can we do with this um how do we group kids um Firefly

256because it's from the state it will obviously attach to some of the and I've been through them multiple times in the past couple weeks limited resources right now that are in Zas that are standards aligned um but we've got the resources from our classrooms and Firefly won't group these kids the teachers would still be doing it themselves nwaa will group our kids according to where we have common challenges that need to be met within the same classrooms within the same grade with on the same teams um and so it makes it a lot easier it's it's a huge huge time component to group and regroup your kids effectively for differentiation so this does save an awful lot of time as opposed to multiple platforms um or even just using Firefly for everything which doesn't do

257for you um we already covered continuity of progress um I think Dr Conrad said teachers have data for their students from day one of the school year because they have the previous year's data no more waiting several weeks to get data and have time to look at it before we can start flexible grouping or differentiation with our students um and the nwaa assessments are normed and standards align um Dr Howard mentioned that we have several of our tests particularly I ready um which shows you that a student is growing but that student could be if your your standards are here the student could be way down here and it could show tremendous growth to there but it's not necessarily moving them on those learning paths up to where they need to be it's just moving

258them along at their own pace uh whereas this shows um where a student actually should be according to um the state requirements based on the pssa key if the standards are changed will n WEA [Music] update okay all right the next one moves into the timeline so before I change there any more nwaa questions all right so here is our timeline and so um in just a couple of weeks um in the window between January 23rd and 30th uh we will be visiting betham Area School District to see wonders study sync um which is one of the core resource programs we're looking at for ELA and also visiting the Wilson Area School District to see the inter reading and Inter lit core resources in action in those districts um they've been using them for multiple

259years um so we are um kind of getting a really really good view of where we would like to be with either program as far as like the teachers experience and so forth and there will be an opportunity for our teachers to talk with the teachers at those districts um before they leave they are um close to us proximity wise like another school that uses inter reading and intet is pensbury but that's quite um a bit more of a distance for us guess these are in the area the actual program that's I started to before like he gave nine programs for them to look at where did you come up with those nine programs well they were chosen based on um several factors um for example um they all came from major um educational publishing

260groups um they are all rated at least decently um on aded reports and through the reading League which looks specifically at Thea programs uh and um they are all um excuse me um I looked at myself the top 30 um District in Pennsylvania of like the top scoring districts in pssas and not all of them have their um core resources identified in their their curriculum pages but out of the ones that did um I made a point of of noting those um wonders and Inter reading does appear several times as do several of the others that we took a look at um and that was that was basically how the decision was made so winess Senate bill 801 comes out do we expect to see those on then so when said Bill 801 comes out

261um if they come out with a list of reading programs I I don't know what's going to be on there they're going to be suggestions um Pennsylvania has all based scient State's going to me they're doing the work for us and they're telling us that they're going to present this list with us as well as identifi all of our areas of they are um and and I have looked into that and I think one of the concerns that's coming out in the very most recent research is that there have been a lot of states and one of them unfortunately is Pennsylvania that have jumped on mandates for certain ways of teaching reading and literacy um before the research has come out and so they're actually going on things that are in our mandates that have

262already been kind of disproven to be effective okay so I guess what I'm saying so I don't think that that should what I'm saying is I don't think that should be a concern if these programs are on that list right and my big concern is like I look at I just went on to your psba and I looked at those scores for third fourth and fifth grade and here's one school 73 74 78 80 75 76 74 71 67 62 63 65 76 77 84 to me I think they're pretty good because then there's Pleasant Valley 47 554 54 to me when and someone said oh we want to go with schools that are similar to ours that would be like Pleasant Valley volleyball team looking to east north and south to see how it

263is to be successful and some is going to Parkland who already has pssa P or you know Winning State Championship so are these schools that you're going to Bethlehem forther pssa compared to where well I can say that that's why we looked at what the top 30 schools were using these programs are on it so to visit a school that's using it we just Pi one was in Clos well that's what I'm saying these what are are these two schools what are pssas I I didn't I didn't factor that into consideration because it's we're we're looking at how they're how they're implementing it and and I mean Beth Beth does fairly well but we're we're looking to see the program into to see how it works they a different way we're we're not looking to

264mimic exactly what they're doing we're using it for our students but that's why we prr for a pi we didn't we wanted to say see like I said let's look at what the top schools are using I didn't want to put a bad of people drive them out like but I would think you would know if you're going to these two schools what whether School compared to ours I don't think it matters our goal is school I but I think that so you look offended or upset by that but I think just looking the same here here is what the better schools are using the schools that are scoring better they're using these programs these are the programs we want to use so you should know with their PSS but but they weren't on the

265they might not have been on the list of the top 30 in the state that we looked at I guess is what I'm saying so I feel like they did the homework that you're asking they just didn't do it the way that you are asking if they did it right they didn't look at Bethlehem they looked at the 30 best highest right so what I'm saying is Bethlehem scorers are in the 50s and they're using that program program might be good but maybe not using the proper I got you I got you like maybe they didn't implement it smartly or they weren't given the resources that we talked about this our goal though visiting is to see how they're implementing get their teacher feedback what are their thoughts and then on February 14th we have

266these companies coming in and presenting to all of our elementary teachers and they have the ability to ask questions um so we were just looking let's let them go let's let them see in practice let them ask teachers what do you like about it what don't you like about it get that point then we have the companies coming in but we did choose programs that are used by the top performance School in state that's how he chose atre you can take the best resource or the worst resource it's all right true well that's what I'm saying so if you're going to a school that but but but the point of going to the school was just to ask them what you like about it what don't you like about it um you know like hands

267on yeah yes we already know that it's a program that produces well at other districts and we're looking to purchase program right yeah and I believe hmh is over at East stord it is also but only three to five so we chose Wilson because they are using a k through six which also includes a component of the in literature which we would like for our older students so Bernie can you tell me who who's going to be going on these visits I don't know yet because I have not settled on a final number the people I'm in contact with at each of those places are in their Central offices so they are trying to work out um you know which teachers classrooms would be open to us you know and that depends on how many

268students what else is going on that day um building principl are we going K to six teachers K to eight teachers K to ke right now we're doing K to eight to do this at the end of January we can't really take high school because they're doing like um final exams because they're both on um block schedules and then we'll but we'll be taking high school early in February to look at the upper level if they would like to go okay so we're we're probably not taking that entire committee which was over 20 people unfortunately because we we really just can't they kind of invade the school while they're having class I just okay it depends on how many classrooms they have open if we can take them off that would be fantastic okay but

269they haven't given me number last page of email you have the list you have by people that was that was previously this is the biggest committee we've ever had at Valley we typically only had six people we had saying I think it says at the top like years past these are the people the positions those are the people who um I think I I remember it was those were the people who were on the committee last spring when when we first started this yep there it ISS down but there is okay okay that was only one square this will take so then um we already said February 14th we are having both Publishers come in for a presentation and Q&A session and then teachers will have time to provide um some more feedback about those

270two um and then we are looking to make a selection and put that one up for board approval by the February 27th board meeting on the PD dat on March 19 um if nwaa is approved that's when we would have them come in for a half day training um in various alternating groups to keep them a little smaller for our faculty and administration that would just be um an overview of what it is how it works um what it does for us and then in June on the last two days sorry I don't see any we're on here when we're asking for approval of the NWA that would be at the next board meeting that one's cut off on this timeline because I just ran out well I have the old timeline because it was

271cut off on that one too so when is it next board meeting that gives us time to do the professional development for so the second meeting the second meeting jary yes all right so um so you want board approval for nwaa January January yes before the teachers go and look at this no no this is different okay I'm the ELA program would be uh February 27th so the teachers will go the teachers will have gone the Publishers will come in then because honestly I mean before I would say yes or no I want to hear the teachers feedback because I I'm G to tell you I got some feedback that they were not happy with how they were involved with this committee take it for its worth right I I don't know what was involved

272or what wasn't involved um but I want to hear teachers at that Podium giving The Good the Bad and the Ugly not from you guys I want it from the teachers okay I we heard from some teachers that they didn't but then we also that's that's fine again we hear different things right and I I want to make sure that we're making the right decision on the people who are going to tr truly use it as opposed to again committee on high I want to make sure we're making the right decisions for the people who have to use it sure um so June whatever the ELA new resource is uh we have plans for that uh company to send trainers to give um a general overview introduce the program I introduce all of the resources

273the assessments and so forth before the teachers leave for the summer um so it will be it will be the company doing the training yes it won't be us won't be us okay and then over the summer using the new core resource to revise the K to10 Ela curc what does that mean exactly explain that to me it means to make sure that we have a solid scope and sequence that incorporates the new resource aligned with standards um we've been saying all along that in the past we've purchased things like units of study 95 phonics um for the curriculum and that that was followed precisely with Fidelity exactly how the program is laid out it's not necessarily aligned to the Pennsylvania standards it doesn't necessarily cover all the standards or move at the pace that

274it needs to move for what our students need to do at what time we have a curriculum there's curriculum framework um that we can use to make a scope and sequence in SAS pte did it for us so we're going to use that and the resource to make sure that we have a scope and sequence that is aligned that moves at the appropriate Pace that covers all the thing that things that it needs to cover and who will be doing this department chairs um it's part of their their job functions that they will look at curriculum every summer so they'll do that um we will probably also need input um I know the department chairs don't teach all of the grades so we'll look to get um some teachers um either volunteer by the principal

275every summer teers in yeah bring teachers in to help with that too just this is probably a dumb question but wouldn't you re rewrite or revise your career culum prior to picking a program our ccul ourc WR by the state yeah okay so it's not so it's a okay it's the resource to support that standard or teach that standard Essen yeah the difference is that now we're we're not purchasing this to be our curriculum we're purchasing to use it as a core resource and I I've been in um virtual meetings with PCD where the people from there which that's the state curriculum people um who have said that the phrase that they don't like is implementing with Fidelity you should not be buying something to do it the way a publisher who doesn't know your

276school and doesn't necessarily know your state um tells you how to teach because that does not honor the teachers who are teaching or the students in front of them so instead Implement with integrity and that's what we're aiming to do and and anything we purchase is not a curricul it's a curricular resource to support and I think that's where we've got off track a little bit right and just to add a little bit to that I think part of it is is that there was a time and place not just in Pleasant Valley but in other districts where you literally went from page one to page 100 and you had to be lock step on the page and and if you didn't then there could be consequences and and those days are are gone but

277that's why there's that need for collaboration and here's the standard here's um the content of the core resource how can we Infuse the two to make sure students understand these standards so I guess it's really not a curriculum revision right well it's a core resource how do incorporate the resource yeah howgate the resour okay thank you okay and then that brings us to our September PD day um by the time we hit the September PD day um teachers will have given you know if we have it the nwaa beginning of the year tests in ela Math and Science and so we will have data analysis training from nwaa it's about a two-hour training and it basically shows what you're looking at how to interpret it and then what to do with it then in September

278and or October um there's map reading fluency for Coach training from nwaa with PVE this is something that also is um we're looking to purchase with nwaa the test in nwaa are called map um measures for academic progress and so the map reading fluency for coach we're looking to get K to2 what that is is a digital program that uses Ai and the kidss read into it so this is something that's ideal for during small group time for the students who are not in the small group because if they can't really read yet or they they can't read on level or even if they do and they just need to accelerate they don't always have somebody sitting with them who's monitoring them they're not always doing the best activities you know they might just be

279on a digital program and yes this is a digital program but it has this digital coach and what that is is the students read um they have the headphones they read into the program out loud um and then as they're reading the passage if they make a mistake um for example they might say they John licks to ride his bike instead of John likes to ride his bike well then a micro intervention will pop up and will go over that long ey silent e sound that they messed up on and give them a lesson on it and review it with them and then put them back into the passage but the passage will automatically adjust so there's more of that skill that long ey silent he that John messed up on you just said right

280so we're buying the NWA but then you just said we're going to purchase something else is said this is um an extension of nwaa right so it's not giving us everything we need like I thought us and going automatically give us stuff we need to improve these kids but you're saying it's just going to tell us where it is what's wrong and then we have to buy more from them in order to it's an extension of how are we doing these other things nwaa is the testing it's the Benchmark testing for beginning middle and end of the year the reading fluency for Coach is an instructional to given purchase through it's just purchase through the same sounds pretty NE though I feel like we're slowly peeling the bandaid off see what the prices are for

281this nothing what is the cost of NW I don't know the difference between what we pay for everything else right now and what we'll use for NWA we pay an extra $157,000 I think it's toal 267 for three years years but we will pay every penny out of ready to learn so just just so you're aware like the offset of those other programs that we use your star your gance um you know you're looking that because those would require a three-year estimate as well um somewhere around 100,000 to 150,000 y yeah correct yes so next okay and then um still with nwea in on the February PD Day in 2026 um by then teachers will have given the mid year um Benchmark assessment and so we'll have two data points and nwaa comes back and

282does a quick onehour session um on okay we've got two data points how do we read those and then what what do we do with them to make predictions about performance on the pssa or the Keystone and what do we need to do between now and then to make up any deficits that are left so who receives that training everybody the teachers everybody so all those PDS that you see like in SE that's what this is yeah the only one that's not everybody is the one that specifically says t okay um and then in um if we go back down to the bottom um during next school year we'd also be looking at the science core resource evaluation um and do a review for that um and then the following summer the curriculum integration not

283revision um and then as Dr Howard said um we had decided to push off math until 2026 27 so7 for a review because of the elementary teachers so with we'll need to do a two-year extension then with math twoyear extension for I ready with I think with the middle school it's just a onee extension Middle School we got it a year later yes so you would do Ela in 2025 science in 2026 and then math and math and social studies math and social studies in 20 26 27 both in 2026 yes well to their's I don't think there's any math for for the for the elementary like a PBI you if you're teaching science you're typically not teaching social studies so we thought that that would go well together and we were going to do

284math this coming next school year but it with all of this we we don't want to overwhelm them so so those that teach Math and Science will'll have two back toback but not at the same time no it'll be back toback one year and then next year same same with science and social studies because there are a lot of science social studies um at P but but if we get to that point and we realize just like we we thought do math next we started getting into this and John met with um Department chairs for map and they were like we so why was this decision made to do science with with with the steel standards changing um so we need to look at a a core resource for that um right now they're implementing

285open SED um at the obviously the high school and also a little bit in the middle school so using you know a science Core Curriculum so we need to make sure we need to review it make sure that it's meeting our our you know students and getting them on a great level and making sure that they're they're doing well in their their benchmarks so that's K to six science we're we're we're we're looking at uh you know across the board for up nth grade for bio as well and math would be K to eight to math no I changed that and went MRA and what happens when if if the teachers come back in in February with their um well whenever whatever date their their feedback is due I think it's February 14 and they

286don't like either program did we just wasted a year and a half I I mean I I think the feedback that we had received from our teachers is that both of these programs seem like they're um you know highly regarded and that they're going to help our students move forward um you know at the end of the day decisions have to be made and and you know we're we're seeking feedback from individuals but you know it's our you know responsibility as an Administration team to make a recommendation based on that feedback um so at the end of the day our goal is to have a decision made um and you know people have had over a year and a half to provide feedback and and um you know I think everyone can recognize that we're

287trying to move our district forward with having the right resources available for our staff and students um so I I I I know that being a teacher for a while and they could say as well I know that switching resources you get very comfortable and pieces that you like and it's hard I know there times I agree with the that I was given but we're looking at resources that are are producing the results what we have now is not helping us get to where we want to be and I know anytime you change it part people become very um become very personal and become very connected to some of the things they're using um they may not agree with us but I know what we're doing now we do not have the results that we

288need and I I don't disagree with that but I have heard just as mrke has said that uh I'm that the process used to get where we are are was not necessarily done with Fidelity I guess I'll put it that way I'm sorry and and I you know um I think they wanted to vote they wanted to vote well I don't know that they wanted to vote I I mean I get the one piece where I asked the question before you know how did C CK come out on top after the one meeting and then wasn't the next meeting wasn't even being considered that blows my mind blows my mind I don't understand that I mean it's like a waste of having meetings to me so that's where I'm at I mean I I I

289understand we we need something I I completely understand that and I completely understand where we're at and I'm I'm okay with it but I have to tell you I'm I'm a little I'm a little bothered by that piece I would say for the most part I don't want to speak for everybody would want to keep a c well I just don't know I'll say this I I think you know we had a lot of discussions about where we were and where we would end up and there was discussions about is this a k to you know five program is this K to six is this K to eight so so right then and there you know I don't think we went into the discussions thinking this is going to be a k to Keystone or

290you know like we're going to this going to impact the secondary buildings I think you know our initial stab at this was let's take a look at the lower grade levels because that's where we're seeing some disparities so let's focus our attention there however what we also realize is that if there's not continuity from great you know one grade or one building to the next that's and and so shifting that focus and trying to get people from PVE pvi and getting Middle School feedback that's where we got more robust so could you call th on the play that it wasn't the original plan of course because no one sticks to the orinal plan but what we're trying to do is have people understand that as we made adjustments throughout the process which weren't um you

291know deceitful it was always predicated on how do we have a greater impact on learning and quite frankly I don't think some people are happy with that because they want it their way and as Dr Howard said there are people here that have been teaching the same curriculum and not just in Pleasant Valley I'm saying across you know with the same curriculum for 10 years there's no innovation when you know you're using the same same resources that you've been using for the last 10 years this is an opportunity for us to infuse additional resources and we have awesome teachers that I know will take this and say what a great opportunity they they'll collaborate but like I said at the end of the day our scores and and and I will say this to everyone

292here our scores are not acceptable they're not good enough and and I hope that every person that is either listening or we have conversations when you see 60% 40% 30% of our students that are proficient I hope we're looking in the mirror saying that's not good enough because I that is the critical mass point for us to make a change we have an opportunity to make a change let's make a change and you know what if in five years it hasn't had the impact we had then we obviously have to make some pivots but we do need to really implement this with integrity and we do need to work together at this it's like anything if you sit there right from the GetGo and say hey this isn't work do you think it's going to

293work no of course not and I think we need to break out of that that vicious cycle of well this is just another resource this isn't going to work steals isn't GNA be around forever you know like we have to get past that our kids are not succeeding This Is Us taking those opportunities that some of the selections were made and early on because they wanted to keep a c and if they want with CA I'm sorry 95 sorry sorry sorry thank is for 95 thank you they would that we could keep that yeah and that's why and then when we look at foundational skills I believe it was C did not have the foundational skills but they don't I can't I just I just had to say what was on my mind knows that

294she's stating that like we said it's we we know there has to be a change we all know that and and the teachers that we talk to they know it need to be changed but I guess the idea is that if you're down there in the ditches and you're digging you decide which shovel you want is going to work best for you and and if and if I turn around I turn to somebody say okay you can pick peas carrots or corn I pick corn you say well no the only choices I'm going to give you is peas and carrots well now you making me pick something that I really don't want at all and am I going to make that successful and I want know how you going to hold somebody accountable because you

295say that's the best program you better teach it this way and if it doesn't be successful it's because of you whereas if I tell you say look this is what I think to make guess what I'm old you teacher respons you just told me this is what's going to reach get our scores up to 60% or whatever above well guess what teachers now you're responsible for that if I don't see that we're coming back towards to you right now but I think I think that's the problem is that like no no one no administrator here is ever threatening our teachers that you have to get these scores if anything our teachers our administrator no what I'm saying is that like so so here's the thing though and this is where we need to break out

296of that cycle is that you know none of us are here to penalize Any teacher we're here to say hey it's not working what can we do to help you what resources can we bring in but I think the problem and this is something that we're seeing districtwide is that there are so many different teachers using so many different resources that you know a kid in a teacher A's class can do exceptionally well but then go to teachers b class or have you know a a sibling go to that it's a total different ball game what we're trying to do is level the playing field so that way everyone has these resources we want to make sure that there's teacher autonomy nobody's trying to take that away but you can't have the anarchist uh perspective

297of well everyone just have at it and use whatever resources because that's also what's gotten us into these problems as well also I can't come to you and say you want corn my corn first of all it doesn't align up through and it doesn't have foundational skills how much you like it I can't come here and say let's spend 100 of thousands of dollars on a resource that I know does not do what just because and all of our people don't agree PBI and PVE don't BR on the resource that they want your basic education begins k23 streets third grade again we talked about this before if they don't know how to do stuff by third grade guess what they're prison most of them are prison that's what're those are the on that I you

298don't have that Foundation doesn't matter what I I do want to say though in the in the initial email from August um right around the time that school started that I sent out to the expanded committee to get this going for this year I did make it very clear that we were not at this time sure if we were doing a k to five or k to six if we were going to include and it was going to be K to 578 um k to sit k um 5678 or where we were going and I ended that by saying we probably will not know that answer until after we've had a thorough evaluation of all the possibilities by the committee and so I didn't expect to have the answer to where we were going with

299curriculum alignment and how far of it would go and how many grade levels we need resources for until the end and and I know whatever program it it comes down to our teachers are going to do the best you know and implement it they will they absolutely will there's no if hands or buts about that I just think the the communication could have been better you know I think I'll leave it at that just one last thing I'll say too is that there's always Lessons Learned right so I think as we're looking at our math and science you know that's this is good feedback I mean it is helpful because we want to make sure that you know if we don't know where we're going to end up we want want to you know again

300put that out there in writing make sure we communicate that you know make sure that we're we're involving different parties but I agree with you I mean we can definitely learn from this but one thing that I'm extremely happy about is the fact that you know this isn't uh two or three or six people making it in in a vacuum this is a larger expansive group but but remember the problem is is when you have more people involved in the decision making you have more division amongst the group and I think before we were only were looking at a program K to five or k you know it was a smaller yeah so now we're so the group is expanded too so I get it I get it so all right uh sorry as everybody's

301yawning at I think I'm all of a sudden awake again all right security vehicles I [Applause] nothing they're here they're here all right poor Jim I was GNA put you first I should have done it no worries um just a just a recap I know last meeting was asked about uh Team snap uh their data is a little limited but um I did talk with them and they're looking to give us more data as they redevelop their program but currently in the district over all levels and all sports we have 841 signups that's 841 parents kids coaches that are engaged in using it uh we started chess on it uh since we're in the chess season so they're using it I hope to next year then work with Mrs me and the and the high

302school to uh implement it in our extracurriculars uh so that they can use it as well to pump it out and use it with them uh I also met with um big teams which is our uh West uh westing house or or holding House of our schedules uh we currently use Arbiter for our collection of student um data for health and all big teams also does it so some schools have moved from Arbiter to was called family ID um so I'm going to be looking into them to see instead of paying for two different platforms just get under one platform uh so I'll be bringing that in the future to you as well uh Hall of Fame 124 coming up here uh we had five individuals that were voted in by the committee we had

303Aaron Ferman at Pat Calo Stephanie wor Brad con wallik and Jake sarar uh who were voted into the uh Hall of Fame we'll be celebrating that on 124 I believe Lisa sent out an invitation to all of you and to all the rest we hope to see you all there and enjoy in those festivities uh um one person will not be able to make it um Brad from he's North Carolina now and he has other obligations that weekend so uh he will not be able to make it so four people will be recognized at halftime and during our uh pregame activities will someone represent him uh we're working on that right now uh to figure out how we can do that okay can we Zoom him in I'm sorry zoom them in teams them in

304we had that great on there we could bring them Califoria okay so that's maybe why we haven't heard okay well thank you and the last thing I have um today I had our our EPC meeting and one of the things that was brought up was Cod of conduct at games and the league has decided to work on over the next several months a League wide code of conduct that we can post in all of our facilities um that is across the board the same thing we're going to follow from District to District at all of our games uh we felt that it was um a way to kind of bring Unity amongst all the districts in our league and P expectation that when you go to Parkland or you go to C Mountain East or

305West the uh ban expectation is the same over all of our leaks so uh that was one thing we worked on today in our leag meeting that's all I have you have anything any questions to cond up for coaches or students uh for fans conduct across yeah across the board uh biggest thing though is is our fans um you know our parents uh do a little excited at times and sometimes make wrong choices imagoes any other that's all I have okay thank you any other Mr Reynolds Community how are you good long time no see happy New Year Happy New Year to you it's been far too long yeah happy to be here and doing well yeah well I'm alive I'll give you the back story have time just be careful when you're driving on

306two I'm going through a 33 because I almost died in August oh but I'm here so there's a lot to imp here I'm gonna try to be brief you know because I know it's like almost midnight and I actually came right from work directly here because I was as to do so as Dr con he knows I represent quite a few groups in the community and I'm always there go to Pur and and go forth and get the information and report back so so okay you know I don't have a lot of bandwidth and a lot of time you know I'm dead tired anyway with that being said so I'll go from the back and move forward the most recent I guess with the Athletics quick comment on that so just you mentioned the code

307of conduct so in regard to that you're talking about the parents and and how they present themselves and how they I guess they act in games and so forth and so on but I have to report to you when it comes to some of the sporting teams and this is not a site against any of the coaches but I'm just giving you actual metrics from parents and from players these are actual statements and information in the coaching these when not okay I'll start with myself when I played if you're a kind of sport CID and you were cussing and swearing and and caringo didn't FL there was none of that I don't I don't know how it's done now but on these teams the coach said there if you have players who cannot conduct themselves

308we actually wore you know an actual tie when we went to visiting G other schools I'm not suggesting that the school needs to do that but I'm talking about on these school grounds if you have students that are trying out that they playing and they are cursing while they're playing while they're practicing cursing at each other cursing I don't get that can't wrap my head around what where's it and this your teammates I don't know what your Recs are looking like but from what I understand they're not that great and I'm talking this is from the players I don't know how the football team is doing the basketball but I'm just giving natur so you might want to take a look at that talk to the coaches and find out who's in the ground what's

309going on because these are things is actually transpiring okay so I'll move on that that's the sports in addition so in regard to NOW n WEA I have to say I'm I'm really really I I mean I have no words I'm that's amazing because the prim you guys are getting it or I don't know who came up with this idea but we're late to the party in Southeast Asia they they've been doing this for years and years and years and years this is the reason why I spent a lot of time with Salia this is why they way ahe of the US because they spend time on instruction they're not testing and testing and testing these kids to death they figured it out let's teach the kids we don't have to keep testing them a

310bazillion times and hopefully if this getop it I think again oh and I have to say thank you too I forgot we say this in the beginning Mr thank you so much for because I didn't know how this all work if I had to talk at the end or in the middle but thank you for recognizing you know give me I so with that being said um yeah nwaa that's been done in other countries so hopefully we can do that here and get that going um what else okay um the reing mechanical locks I I I don't know maybe I miss it but you talked about Keys We King and also digital was mechanical locks mentioned because they're about the same CA as Keys they're more efficient they work better and they don't require P

311power so is that not an option to do mechanical LS we are using mechanical they are mechanical they're not oh so you are using mechanical thought wasn't sure if I missed that part okay so mechanical will be great they don't require power so don't have to worry about that okay um the 10 minutes earlier okay so again I don't know what happened I maybe I'm in time work but when I was going to school I'm sure a lot of you can concur teachers you didn't have to tell the teachers to arrive to school early into prepare their Lessing plans that was just built in right so now we have to tell the teachers or make an a mandate like I'm trying to wrap my head around that why say trying it it's more about just

312having time for collaboration that they don't have so right now there's very limited time and actually after the students leave what I'm saying is that they they're sticking around for 10 or 15 minutes we can use that time on the front end to make sure that they have opportunity to talk about assessments and curriculum and things and and parent meetings and stuff like that that that are really important parents do try to call interact with the teacher but I thought maybe I you said I thought you talking about making an amate for them to come in early to prepare for the class no what I'm saying is they would just come in five minutes earlier but you know again they would have an opportunity to make sure they have everything ready for that day but

313they're already doing that so now it's more a pivot to uh collaboration parent meeting IP meetings things like that that would be helpful to use during that time that's all okay and also Dr con so you mentioned about you said the between the buildings yeah SP on that continuity where because again we talked about this before Elementary School to intermediate to the middle school it's like they go to the middle school and it's almost like vaporizing to kind of time work what happened it's almost as if the emphasis on the academic part it's like anticipated said what happened we talk about this even like with the uh the what call the honor Ro and the certificat and things like that completely disappeared until you know you bringing that back even that and even that's still

314not even being done correctly because at the end of the school year the complaint was well you know the kids that achieved honor Ro distinguish honor rooll the markting period is not completed so we don't know we haven't T the scores you know what those kids never got for the fourth marking period they still haven't received so what happens it's like they just like completely forget about the academic part it seems and even in the Sur we get my son he got the survey you know what that survey consisted of you all talked about now listen I play sports in high school and college okay I love sports sports player but guess what for me academics right higher than Sports so when you put out a survey in the eighth grade students are graduating class

315and go okay tell me what your achievements are okay did you play this sport did you particip in that sport what would your this that right and then and then way way way down bottom okay A little one learner by academics I mean what is that what what message ises that send to the kids if trust me the kids notice that severely and then when you do a graduation and you don't really acknowledge the academic part and you you give them a paper bear with their name on it they trust me they they notice that it's almost like it's insignificant so that needs to be looked at as well because I think that's that was that was really I was highly disappointed by that and and you know how how that all go out so

316I don't need to go into that um last thing was um was cool okay so I'm also very happy to hear a lot of discussion about what we've been asking for for what three four years with the community involvement says an Advisory board so I noticed you put out a survey and it spoke about excellence and education and it says u a community commitment and in the survey it was asking should should should that name be changed well I don't know you guys have to tell us because should the name be changed because we've been asking for that for years and this is the first I've actually heard real discussion about it so I think it's up to this board to decide if that name needs to be changed because if there's not going to

317be Community involvement or interaction then yes change the name because it doesn't apply right because that's what that in First Community involvement so hopefully this is not just discussion I'm hoping this is going to turn into something real actual movement towards something that that's tangible so I can tell yes you know they're not just saying words and this might actually come to PO so I think that's probably the last thing let me see I got here Dr Howard your name is here for some reason about the AP you said a lot there was a lot of kids that dropped from the AP classes not not no um in the past so that's why we say by June 5th you have to be locked in like I'm going to do that because we also pay for

318the test if they're going to do that or if they take a they can also get a college credit that we pay for as well so we need to make sure they're locked in so we know we've actually increased our a offerings and our okay but but I will say you are correct when you stated also you said listen you know change is hard we all know change is very difficult for everyone but to your point you know if we keep doing again I don't want to sound like a cliche because everyone knows a statement about the definition of the S right keep doing the same thing and expecting a different result that's what's going on here we keep doing the same thing the same thing keep turning churning churning right but then we're going

319to expect the different why that's just that's that's crazy you can't keep doing the same thing and expect a different result to occur you have to do something different and to Mr OK point I'm 100% on board with him he's spot on you can't just go okay you know what yes we got to do change for the sake of change and the board's going to make this decision here we're doing this now okay let's go well even me I call I mean I'm a principal for design engineer but I still call myself as an underling I go to my team I don't just go okay Ru like okay we're doing this no I go to all my team and go listen what are we doing here do you like this talk to me tell me

320what you hate about it because at the end of the day you are going to be the ones who's going to have to live with it and that's how he SP on you got to talk to the teachers and all the people who going to using it on a daily basis find out what they hate about it what they like about it because at the end of the day you're still the decision makers but they have to weigh in they have to so so thank you very much for hearing you know my guess my list you know I think WEA will be a little more efficient we get out early if we can just interact I can just request this to the board maybe for the community during these sessions mean if it gets too

321extensive and people start talking too loud during overall discussion I think it be more efficient in time if in the moment when you're having discussion like for example like with the keys and with the first oh that's what I want to say first student sorry um you guys mentioned $660,000 so did that money go back into the district it's money we saved saved so saved did it go back into the district and being R distributed for other expenses yeah through our budget yeah of course okay I didn't know because again I know we had I know we had a contract for a million contract student over 5e period so we saved $66,000 because we eliminated 10 runs and the 66k per per run that's your 660 yeah so all that money that we saved went

322back into the district well minus the 8,000 a cost for the software find the efficiency so it's technically like 650 okay I can't do math it's too late I'm sorry toate for me to do ma to the good that's what we say yeah yeah thank you so much all right thank you everyone sleep fast drink some coffee thank goodness it's Friday tomorrow good night gonna have some dinner but I I have papers to it's wrong Pap to

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.