CorpusRecord 148193

PVSD Board of Education - 12/5/24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Pleasant Valley School District
Date
2024-12-05
Location
Monroe County, PA
Material
Transcript
Extent
23,837 words · about 133 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001for e e e check 1 two 3 check check one two e e e one I'd like to call this meeting on Thursday December 5th 2024 to order Dr Conrad could you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance followed by a Moment of Silence of course I'd like to ask everyone to stand good evening okay we'll do start off with the pledge and then uh afterwards just take a couple of minutes uh thinking about loved ones uh for moment of silence so I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America to the it stands indivis andice thank you everybody could be seated Mrs stuff could we have roll call please Norm Berger here Robert Clark here Michael Galler here John gazit here Suey pres Ryan o'keef present Diane surfus present Matthew

002Walters here Melanie Zep here tonight we are celebrating our December students of the month so I'm going to turn it over to Mr pompelo to kick this up hey good evening everybody um very proud to present the students of the month and like I say every time parents thank you so much for your for thank you so much for your partnership with PBE in all the schools because without the parents support there's no way the kids tonight are getting the Awards all right it's a 50-50 partnership so we're going to start off right away I have Miss Shuster kindergarten teacher come on up and can I have the family of maralo Morales terz to please come up to be honored and Mr Rodriguez please come up and help me out [Applause] here got you so

003don't mind me I was asked last minute to come and translate so I'm going to do it in Spanish for the family good evening where would you like the where do you want them to stand okay okay Mar pa okay [Applause] we'll have it in English too um it is a pleasure to be here tonight to represent Mary Paula Morales Torres is the kindergarten student of the month Mary Paula is an exceptional student she just recently moved to our area and spoke no English but because of her hard work and desire to learn she is mastering every single kindergarten skill that was taught so far to date each day Mary Paula comes to class with a beaming smile on her face and eager to learn she is kind polite hardworking helpful always has a positive

004attitude is a good friend and is a wonderful role model for other students each month I asked my students to nominate a classmate that they think would be the next student of the month and almost every single child in the class nominated Mary Paula she is always happy and follows all directions she's a pleasure to work with and is wonderful to watch her grow I am blessed to have Mary Paula in my class I am proud to call her my student and I confident she will achieve remarkable things in the [Applause] future all right next for our first grade student of the month we have Miss anderton come on up to present cheryn aguo and the whole family come on up guys [Applause] congratulations good evening cheryn all of your teachers are also very proud

005of you for your me for many reasons the biggest reason of all would be the respect you have towards others you treat everyone with great kindness in the classroom you are inquisitive and not afraid to take chances especially when learning new things cheryn is a biling student who goes above and beyond to help her classmates especially those classmates who need a little extra help because they are just learning to speak our language cherylyn includes everyone when working together in conversation or in play she is not one to enjoy being in the spotlight and becomes very shy when she is praised but Shar and you deserve this thank you for working hard daily helping others and for treating people the way they should be treated may you continue to love the gift of learning and as

006an unknown author once stated your education is a dress rehearsal for the the future that is yours to [Applause] decide all right I have one more second grade teacher Miss Gordon come on up and can I have Alexander Fleming and the whole FL Family come on up to be honored [Applause] good evening I am pleased to introduce to you the second grade student of the month Alex Fleming in addition to being an exceptional student Alex volunteers as a tutor for first graders during Home Room every day Alex embodies the characteristics that we all want to have he is kind compassionate responsible trustworthy and hardworking I am very fortunate to have Alex in our class this year and I am proud to have him represent the future of Pleasant Valley congratulations to you Alex and to

007your parents you truly deserve this award [Applause] so I'm very proud of my PVE kids they're doing amazing things um Good Luck other schools I do have the cutest I think I win that award um I do have two highlights really quick for PVE um Friday December 13th we have our toys for toss parade down at school um from 9:45 in the morning morning until about 10:15 looking forward to that it's always a great and what's so cool about that event every single toy stays inro County so I love that um and the other one is very proud of my my staff um we had 14 turkeys go to families in need uh right before Thanksgiving so they had um I got some feedback from the parents just just a great Community giving back so

008thank you for that and um pvi and Miss Albright it's all you all right good evening um very happy to be here tonight to talk about our third fourth and fifth grade students of the month for pvi um we are going to kick it off in third grade and I have um Mrs Le Mo here to present the student of the month for third grade Charlotte blundetto [Applause] good evening it is my pleasure to be here tonight to introduce our third grade student of the month Charlotte blundetto Charlotte demonstrates excellent character and responsibility she works extremely hard and willingly accepts new challenges Charlotte reflects upon her work and revisits her mistakes using them as an opportunity to learn and to grow Charlotte is an inspiration to her peers and a true pleasure to have in

009my class we are PBI proud of you [Applause] Charlotte okay next up for fourth grade Mrs siip trth is here to present our fourth grade student of the month Riley [Applause] rufo good evening it is my sincere pleasure to be here tonight to honor Riley rufo as student of the month Riley was an obvious choice for many reasons one of them being the effort she puts forth in everything she does in the classroom and Beyond in addition to being a hardworking honor rooll student Riley participates in chorus band Girls on the Run soccer lacrosse and I've probably missed a few in all of these activities you can count on Riley to be prepared organized actively involved and to give it her all while while her academic and extracurricular achievements are many it is her kind

010heart and willingness to help others that impresses me most with or without being asked you can rest assured that Riley will step up to help a classmate friend or teacher when she sees one need she does this with no expectations of anything in return lastly Riley's positive attitude and sense of humor make every day that much brighter I'm fortunate to be her teacher and look forward to spending the remainder of the Year watching her grow and learn and can't wait to see what amazing things she does in the future congratulations Riley and family and keep up the great work thank [Applause] [Music] you and next up um I present Mrs serba who is here to present our fifth grade student of the month rosin Romano [Applause] hi good evening everyone congratulations to rosin Romano our

011fifth grade student of the month it is my absolute honor to speak on the exceptional qualities that make Roslin an amazing student she's worth recognizing When Miss Albright asked me to speak I knew I could write a book on how wonderful she is however I promise to keep it short and sweet Roslin has a drive for learning that is evident in everything she does it is not uncommon for her to go above and beyond requirements to reach her own personal level of success she will fight for her learning until she reaches that goal and then some her consistent effort in class and commitment to Excellence in her schoolwork is truly admirable not only does she work hard academically but rosn also has a keen awareness of others she is a shining example of a positive

012student always bringing cheerful attitude and her willingness to help I chose Roslin this month because each day she demonstrates exceptional leadership qualities that by actively supporting her classmates volunteering to assist others and being a positive role model she does all of this with a kind heart soft personality and lots of smiles you would never know if Rosalyn was having a bad day because she travels throughout school with her smile and positive attitude it is absolutely infectious we all can agree that the world needs more Rosies Rosalyn is a natural leader and team player with her peers watching her in action is always comforting because we all know that Roslin that sorry with rosn the team is in safe hands whatever job is present it will get accomplished because of her leadership so rosn thank you

013for all of your contributions to our classroom Community we appreciate you I am looking forward to watching you grow in whatever Direction your dreams take you watch out world this girl is going places thank [Applause] you all right and then um just a little Spotlight we wanted to highlight our upcoming annual Tree Lighting Event and chorus concert on December 12th um everybody's been working really hard to put it together we're very excited to see it and hopefully we have a really great turn up so we will see you there and now Mr McCutchen thank you Mrs Albright U it's a pleasure to be here tonight representing the Middle School to introduce our students of the month and we'll begin with sixth grade could I'd like to invite the family of Cassidy tomchi to come on

014up and the teacher who who nominated her Mr [Applause] Whiteford good evening it was without a doubt an easy choice this month to make Cassidy has shown hard work throughout this year she tries her best on every single assignment she does she goes above and beyond on every assignment she does you consistent consistently she is working on something in the classroom no matter if it's a free moment a Home Room Time end of the day she is always working on some assignment that she has to complete and that assignment could be months away that she has to complete she's ahead of time on anything she's a wonderful student she's extremely nice to talk to very polite works hard on everything I couldn't ask for a better student to have in class I wish I had

015a full class of kids like Cassidy so congratulations you truly deserve this you are somebody that we will see and hear about throughout the years to come while you're in Pleasant Valley and into the Future No Doubt you have a bright future out of you thank [Applause] you okay and for our seventh grade student the month i' like to call up Brady FL in and family nominated by Megan Gower wait you guys were up here already hold on second time up here you guys are definitely a star family tonight so I'm here as Brady 7th grade science teachers celebrate his accomplishments in the classroom in and out of it as our student of the month this for December I almost forgot what month we in and I'm so excited his quiet nature belies a student

016full of life and humor he is always willing to take responsibility for himself while still taking the time to help out his friends along the way his grades are excellent and his respectfulness shines through to every teacher and student he meets a little bit goofy a lot of intelligence and even more personality that makes him stand out above the others he is a great student to have to represent our seventh grade student of the month and I'm proud a little self ly because he's awesome that he's with my team this year a big shout out to his parents and the people in his life who support him he is truly an excellent [Applause] student okay um and for eighth grade we have Miss aan Mr avanos Satur AI come on up with your family please

017sir [Applause] [Music] um I was given Specific Instructions by Mrs Snider who wanted to be here AI she had a family emergency so she said Miss Fields I'm going to type this nice and large so you can read it I'm I'm going to follow along I hope I don't digress but AI you're a great kid and I'm honored and pleased to see that you're standing here with us today AI is a wonderful student selected by the 8v team he is hard workking and advocates for himself when needed he isn't afraid to ask questions try new things and being wrong doesn't discourage him from trying again Avi is a social person yet when it's time to buckle down and get to work he's able to do it seamlessly he greets us with a smile treats his

018classmates with respect and brings new ideas and creativity to our classrooms so your whole team feels this way about you AI well done sir AI we this is your team we are glad to have you on our team this year and I'm glad you're part of the Middle School keep it up thank you parents for your guided support and everything and encouragement of yourself [Music] [Applause] congratulations once again to our middle school students and families it was a double header for the Flemings tonight um but I do just want to pause for a moment and pay tribute to the families because we can't do what we do without you it starts at home and and and thank you we have great families in our community um and you allow us to do what it is

019that we do here um a quick Spotlight for the middle school I just would like to invite everyone to come on out to support our band and chorus program next week we have our winter chorus concert and our Winter band uh concert I know Mrs Michaels and Mrs Shoemaker work extremely hard and we're grateful for all their hard work and we hope to see you next week at our concerts so thank you and I'll turn it over to Mr [Applause] boand good evening Dr Conor and the schol schol board it is my honor to introduce the uh high school students of the month ninth grade we have Isabella London Isabella will be spoken about from Mr masello [Applause] hey miror uh good evening Pleasant Valley Community merry Christmas and happy holidays um it's with great

020pleasure that I have nominated Miss Isabella London for the student of the month award Isabella was a student of mine at PVE when she was a kindergarten student a first grade student and a third grade student I still remember as a kindergarten student her walking into the gym uh at the end of the day every 11th period or not every day but 11th period with her backpack on since it was the last class of the day and then when I checked my class rosters back in I think it was the second week of August and I saw Isabella's name on my one of my class rosters I was very happy that I would have the opportunity to work with a student who I always had great admiration for um Isabella is one of the kindest

021uh most respectful students I've ever had she'll do anything that is asked of her and she'll try her best at any task whether it's in the gymnasium or the health room uh you're always going to get 100% out of Miss London uh speaking of 100% Isabelle is off to a fantastic start in her High School career she currently maintains a 4.0 uh grade point average um as an eighth grader she received the President W for highest average in her class um any class with Isabelle is automatically better uh she's an All-Star student who makes everybody around her better um she makes classmates better she makes me better and um in my opinion that's what PV Pride is All About uh one of the amazing qualities that sticks out um in in regards to Isabella is

022her ability to go be a go-getter and take the initiative on get things done um I wish I'd see more of that in my career for example a few weeks back Isabella missed a class due to a meeting uh she came to me and she asked to make up their work I said no worries Isabella you have time make it up tomorrow in class is it a big deal at all Isabella just went ahead and did it on her own it was there the next day although I had no issue giving her that time it did make my job easier so thank you Isabella um I just want to take a moment and thank a few individuals first whoever put Isabella on my schedule for my class roster thank you um if I'm back here

023next year please add her to one of my class rosters again uh second thank you to Isabella's parents for raising an amazing young lady you both have a lot to be proud of um the last thing I want to say to you Isabella and I'm glad I get a chance to say this in front of mom and dad you're an outstanding student uh you have a wonderful future ahead of you and you're an incredible person and you have so much to offer to this world [Applause] congratulations our 10th grade student of the month is Payton mcginness Payton was nominated by Miss vant [Applause] all right um good evening everyone my name is m baland and I am a teacher here at the high school um I'm honored to say that I nominated pton mcginness for

024student of the month as well as Mr stroll her math teacher um Mr stroll and I share a lot of common thoughts I can tell you that so I'm also speaking on his behalf as well guess he could not make it here tonight um all right uh Payton is a role model student who demonstrates PV Pride on a daily basis it is truly a privilege to have her in class as a matter of fact Payton I'm not going to lie I bragged to some of your former and current teachers about how I was coming tonight to present this award and you know what they all said oh that's awesome she's so great I love her so see that smile says it all they know she's active participant who is also respectful and class would never

025be the same without her Payton always arrives to class on time organized and motivated to learn she always possesses a positive attitude and sets goals for herself to achieve anyone can set a goal or make a plan but the difference is that pyton executes the plan and gets the job done which is what makes her so successful I met Payton last year in nth grade when she first came to the high school and this has always been the case Payton strives to continue to better herself even though she is already an honorable student she has perfect attendance and has never been a behavior issue Payton makes all of her achievements seem so effortless and she does all of this hard work wearing a contagious earto ear smile that will brighten any room in case you

026haven't noticed there is no doubt in my mind that Payton will continue to be a hard worker and keep striving to do her best to be successful in the future pton please keep reaching for the stars and be yourself because you are truly amazing with that radiant smile you have congratulations on receiving student of the month you truly deserve this award and I want to thank your parents for being so supportive and involved in your education thank you our 11th grade student of the month is Mason ostrich and to speak on his behalf is Miss schimminger so Mason actually could not be here tonight uh one cool thing that he did today he's actually an ambassador for the Children's Miracle Network and he was actually on the radio today which is pretty cool and he's

027actually at that event tonight speaking to students so I'm going to speak on his behalf uh Mason's positive attitude sense of humor and love for school is absolutely amazing although we could do without his loud and proud love of Mondays it's been a privilege to watch Mason navigate through what life throws at him and still shows us every day he's ready to learn the uh resilience and strength that Mason exhibits is a force to be reckoned with and it's an honor to continue to watch Mason grow into his young adulthood as he's preparing to transition into his senior year Mason is a prime example of a student who demonstrates bare pride and we should all be proud and now for our 12th grade student of the month it's one of my favorites mallerie gity Maller

028was nominated by two teachers one uh we have officer Robert Mahi and one of our guidance councel is Miss Payton storms um M officer uh Mahi will be speaking on her [Applause] behalf hi mallerie good evening my name is Rob mahiti and um as you know I'm one of the school police officers and I'm honor to speak on behalf of mallerie tonight and I've nominated her for a student of the month during the school day this building you know obviously I'm not one of her teachers but this building becomes AIT of a city of in and of itself it's walking students cafeteria learning and it's not just about learning it's also about how to treat each other on one particular day just a couple weeks ago I had to write this down to stay on

029track and also not be emotional about it but we had an incident with a not an inent but speak with an administrator another student and it was a roller coaster of emotions and M if you know mallerie unsolicited shows up at the perfect time she spoke this we stepped back a little bit we heard her she she asked the student if he was okay asked um what she could do for him and listened he spoke she listened he spoke she listened it was beautiful and again perfect timing she assured him things will be okay and expressed to trust in her and his friend to trust in himself as well um I swear you couldn't have made this up she says you're probably worrying about something that didn't even happen yet and we've all done that

030so for mallerie to have said this I couldn't believe it it was we I really I want to step back I told you mallerie that day you should be a counselor it was amazing so since then I particularly watched more and I just I just kept seeing mallerie this isn't this wasn't just one day I was just privileged to witness it that day she does this on a regular basis she speaks to children speaks to other class speech 99% of the time she has a kind word first she don't have to she doesn't have to hear it first and that's an excellent trait mallerie embodies the values that we hope to see in our students and it's it's a privilege to work with you mallerie deserves this recognition as student of the month and I'm

031privileged to have the opportunity to speak on her behalf so thank you [Applause] direct refle you congratulations again to our high school students of the month so uh two spotlights we want to showcase for the high school um I want to give a big PV shout out to our drama students uh for their very funny uh production of get smart we hope every saw it it was absolutely amazing uh another shout out to Mr and Mrs maulan and Mrs Moors for uh the excellent uh production for them being behind the scenes and the other one is our next week we have a couple big things going on in the high school we have on December 10th we have our chorus concert and then on December 12th we have our art um our art showcase followed

032by our uh band concert so we're hoping to see everybody out there uh it starts at the course concert 7 o'clock on the 10th and then on the 12th we have our art show is going to be from 6:30 to 7: followed by our band concert so again um big things happening at the high school thank you and next up is gonna be our Bears [Applause] Academy I'm going to be the quickest tonight we actually have our building highlights for coming up soon uh Bears Academy will be presenting our student of the quarter at our next meeting uh in j thank [Applause] you congratulations to all of the de December students of the month I believe they're taking pictures out in the lobby If the parents and the students teachers and principles want to go

033out there for the pictures you can come back for our regular board meeting if you would like okay we'll move for forward with the meeting I'm now going to read the notice of the reorganization ation meeting for December 5th 2024 reorganization meeting of the Pleasant Valley School District shall be held Thursday December 5th 2024 at 7M at the Pleasant Valley High School auditorium this meeting was scheduled and approved at the December 7th 2023 school board meeting at this time we will accept public comment on board reorganization meeting agenda items only at it will only include items 1 through 14 on the agenda at this time you can come to the podium state your name place of residence and there's a three minute limit Jenna Rudolph Chestnut Hill Township I'm here tonight to talk about the

034reorganization of the board current policy allows board members to hold the office of president vice president and treasurer for only two terms equivalent to two years consecutively yet our current board President is on her third consecutive term and most likely seeking a fourth let's talk term limits why does a system of government have them well to avoid the age-old statement absolute power corrupts absolutely and if you ask almost anyone in this community after the last board meeting and the sneaky agendas they would most definitely say that there is corruption among the officers of this board of education at the last meeting you Dr Conrad mentioned monturo versus Jim Thorp you stated that the case projected Board of Education members from being removed from their position what you failed to explain to to the community is

035that Mr montimurro was elected board president and then removed from that office without his knowledge and without following protocol the ruling does not suggest unlimited terms nor does it permit officers to hold them it simply states that a board of education cannot remove elected officials from a position without prior notice your twisting of that court case last week was disgusting as it relied on your believed ignorance of the community excuse me you lied and tried to trick us elected officials often forget that they are representatives of a larger population and of a community many decisions of this board of education have done nothing but wreck havoc on our children our teachers and our community we have lost teachers midye we have lost experienced administrators only to have them replaced by horribly inept and inexperienced ones

036you have voted to give massive increases in pay to those inexperienced administrators as well you further have increased the number of them to an ungodly amount clearly the current officers on this board questionable morals and others who might influence better decisions are stomped into silence furthermore I remind you and the rest of the community of the grand jury report not so long ago the current board president Sue kresy was involved in those reports of nepotism retaliation and abusive power and still sits at that table she has held an officer position for way too long and her elected position for even longer keeping her in the president seat will only put us back there and drive this District further into the black hole is currently careening down finally 5 years ago I stood before you in

037this very same room as a faculty member I read a portion of a speech from our then Association president begging you to negotiate with us begging you to talk to us five years ago the teachers union almost went on strike and the woman who sits in the president's seat then sits there now you want to talk about term limits that is why we need them thank you [Applause] good evening Denise hopley Chestnut Hill Township uh policies for reorganization policy change to eliminate term limits for board officers must have a clearly defined purpose that serves the community's interest and cannot be taken L that's not an agenda item for the reorganization meeting it's eight nine and 10 re-election of the board well if you're speaking about the election this evening yes but it policy is not

038up in the reorganization meeting excuse me policy is not up or for consideration in the reorganization meeting is your agenda out of order by the way from last week to this week it changed so before that it it was that the agenda was accepted and we were able to talk but now I see it's ahead of it so I should be able to talk about the other ones or you object every single one this is this is a specific statutory meeting to reorganize the board there is another public comment section after reorganization about the agenda itself didn't you just say it was about the agendas 1 through 14 Mrs smil just said it was items 1 through 14 when she introduced it she said 1 through 14 one through 14 on the reorganization of the

039board so what specific item are you we just had another uh Committee Member speak about the presidency so why am I not allowed to talk about officers she just she just said the same thing ma'am if you are talking about officers by all means but we're not talking about a policy policies are not up for consideration in this section of the agenda so the word say officers and candidates in my statements am I allowed to continue proceed and we'll we'll hear what you say Thank you so do I start over with one and am I getting my time back are we starting over we're at about 50 seconds so you have about 2 minutes and 10 seconds no I need my 15 50 seconds back because we were discuss discussing this so I I do

040ask for my time at back ma'am you were at 50 seconds you have two minutes and 10 seconds go ahead so we demand concrete evidence showing why other candidates are not more qualified to serve as a board officer the board has a critical responsibility represent the community's interests it is essential board officers rotate in accordance with community elections for new boards to ensure proper representation communication and transparency are not negotiable principles for our community the board president must ensure that the Community Committee and the officers meet regularly guaranteeing ample opportunities for Community input regarding this policy excuse me strike that open dialogue with the community is essential to address many questions surrounding the candes and the officer ships the issue is not just concerning it highlights significant loopholes that undermine election process it's hard to

041ignore the parallels to a rigged election most board members appear to be already know who the president will be or the officers which is deeply troubling the outcome feels predetermined we must question what is driving and changing the board officers why now it's critical to know the discussions that are behind in the executive session according to the policy excuse me strike that according to the officer elections occurring during executive sessions again why now why are the stakeholders being excluded with this important change and why now open the dialogue with the community could eliminate many of these questions term limits are essential we look forward to term limits and they are necessary [Applause] okay seeing no one else the public comment on this section is closed it is time to take nominations for a temporary board

042president I will now take nominations for the election of the temporary [Music] president Diane surface second let clarify we will only need single nomination to put a individual in consideration do we have any other nominations okay seeing none the nominations are closed as the nominations are closed and Mrs surface is the only candidate nominated I move for Mrs surface's election by acclamation for the position of temporary board president all in favor I any opposed the temporary president Mrs surface you may take over from now from this point forward caught a little off guard election of officers following nominations be it resolve that the board of school directors of Pleasant Valley School District approve the election of a temporary board president this term expires December 5th of 2024 so I'm calling now for a nomination for

043the election of the board president I nominate Mike Galler I respectfully Decline and nominate Ryan o'keef I to respectfully Decline and nominate John gazis accept are there any other nominations I nominate Sue kresy okay we will now take a roll call vote let's um first let's get a motion to close nominations okay we close close the motion for nominations is there a motion and a second I motion okay secondry all right good now we have two names on in consideration um this being Thursday this is my fourth day of reorganization so I am on top of these um usually what we do when we have two names is a roll call and then the individuals when it's your turn you you speak the name of the person you're voting for it's probably the easiest way

044to do it could we have a roll call please Norm Berger uh Sue craer Robert Clark Su kresy Michael Galler John gasi I'm sorry John John gazit myself Sue [Music] KY Ryan o'keef John gesi Diane surus uh Su kresy Matthew Walters Su kresy Melanie zip Su kesy five for so I want to thank my fellow board members for their support and I will be making some comments at at the end of the meeting at this time uh could I have nominations for the election of a board vice president nominate Mike Allen I respectfully decline to nominate Ryan O'Keefe unfortunately at this time I have to respect the decline maybe next year I can uh when workload lightings up I can take that on but not right now nominate myself I'd like to nominate Matt walers

045oh I'm sorry I got do that don't I are there any other nominations could I have a motion to close nominations I so second I have a motion and a second to close nominations all in favor excuse me s s out I don't I don't know why are the 11 of you when I was school there is raise your hand if you're School Board member count them one is on the phone one is on the phone okay sit and on the phone she's a board member you asked okay sir we need to continue our meeting please uh okay we close nominations did I call for the vote all those I think I did okay um okay could we have roll call again my ask board members to State the candidate that you would like to

046vote for nor bger Matt Walter Robert Clark Matt Walters Michael Galler Mount Walters John gazit Matt Walters Sue kesy Matt Walters Ryan o'keef Matthew Walters Diane surface Matt Walters Matthew Walters edain Melanie zip Matt Walters pardon the interruption board members if you could please speak into your microphones when you're doing this we're having a hard time hearing over here thank you thank you is there someone in particular or everybody it's it's just it's just in general if everyone could speak a little clearer and in the microphone so we record it properly thank you okay thank you okay moving on to item 11 um mcti joint operating committee mcti Authority representative and psba liaison and psba voting delegates um first one is uh mcti Joc representative it's a three-year term um these are appointments um I

047would like to stay if everyone's okay with that um as a j member um the Joc alternates we have always considered the rest of the board as Joc alternates so I would like to continue that uh mcti Authority um unfortunately uh there was a passing of our previous representative Leon Bart lip so uh we do need to have a replacement for him um is that an appointment or is that a a vote do we uh I think it may depend on the Articles within the The Authority you know what why we we vote and then we we're safe yep okay um I I'd like to nominate Dian surface for the authority no no that's that's not the authority though I thought that was you did okay all right Mike would you like to do that

048I think it's a one year once a year meeting is what I I think it is yes um so I'll I'll make a motion for um Mike Galler can we have a second okay I have a motion in a second all those in favor please signify by saying I I I anyone OPP post and that motion carries thank you uh psba liaison at the present time it is Mrs zip U Mrs zip would would you like to continue uh yes please okay that that is an appointment so again uh we'll have Mrs zip serve in that capacity uh psba uh voting delegates um previously it has been Diane and Mike Galler uh would you like to continue I know it's a virtual meeting I believe I would prefer step down you'd prefer step down it

049is but I'm pretty sure it's a virtual meeting right yes okay uh is there anyone that would like to um step up to do that as a voting Delegate for psba okay Rob okay Mr Clark and Mrs surface will be our voting delegates at uh for psba all right um Pleasant Valley School director does anyone have any comments this evening okay superintendent's comments anything uh for this one Yes actually good evening everyone thanks for being here um I did want to say congratulations to both Sue and to Matt um I'm excited to continue the successes that we're seeing here in Pleasant Valley and uh I really do appreciate working with uh all of the board directors that are here uh you know there's a lot of dedication and commitment to our district to the community

050so I appreciate their stewardship uh and their guidance um as leading Pleasant Valley forward so thank you all right could I have a motion to adjourn the reorganizational meeting so move all in favor I it was Mr I I'll you know what I'll do I'll repeat who made the motions and then that way it'll be clearer for you was Mr Galler and Mr Clark I think we'll do it that way probably be better okay um okay we are adjourned um I'd like to call our regular meeting to order and I'd like to let you know that we did have an executive session it was held this evening December the 5th 2024 immediately prior to the reorganization meeting for purposes of personnel matters including but not limited to Performance and or discipline negotiations and legal issues

051uh this evening we have student highlights Mr van bis from the PV Bears Academy sorry thank you so much and congratulations board members it's good to be back up um I'm actually going to invite my team uh up with me my my small But Mighty crew of PV Bears Academy I have to say I do work with the best team just because anytime I ask them to come out they're always here and I think that's an awesome addition so we actually did things a little bit differently uh tonight and I hope the board doesn't mind um instead of doing just student highlights we want to do just an overall kind of state of pvba um it's it's a little bit more involved I apologize for that but I think it's worthwhile because again I don't

052know if a lot of people actually know what pvba is and it might be a good opportunity also for our community um to see a little bit more about what our program has to offer and what we do so really quick I put on the board enrollment information um enrollment information is a little bit interesting when it comes to well some of my numbers are actually above the curtain so that's a shame but the good news is the enrollment information is last year for the entire year and this year year this is a dashboard that we create yearly just to make sure we can see it yes I apologize board members uh if you need to move please feel free to do so um the most important numbers here is you got 371 all right

053that's our last year's total impact number so I say it's a total impact number we're a very fluid program we have students who are in and out of our doors um our program gives our community flexibility and that's an important thing because if a student can leave and then come back to the brick and mortar that's a student we kept in Pleasant Valley the entire time what we found is that students who leave our Pleasant Valley Community we have a harder time retaining those students um so we want to make sure we keep them with us uh what you cannot see is up here our current number of total impact students for this year is 380 380 and that's right now so last year's number for the entire year was 371 and we're currently already

054at 380 students really quick before I pass it off to my team this is a vision that we created last year when I took over the principal ship of the program it's a pretty easy goal statement really we want to make sure we strive for excellence in education this is at the top of every single faculty meeting agenda and our committee our crew our team can actually speak to this because what we do is based on these bullet points so our goal is always to create improved attendance and achievement all right just like brick and mortar provide inclusive School environment we want our students to feel like they're still a bear expand communication with our families align curriculum for seamless Transitions and of course we want to be the best uh electronic option for our

055students we know that the brick Mort setting is best for most of our students but for some students who choose to go cyber we want to provide them the best opportunities if they stay with us I'm actually going to pass it off to our newest staff member uh who is Miss liven Guth who joined us as the pbba counselor hello everyone and thank you it's a pleasure to be here tonight and as a first year counselor it's been a an honor to step into this role and kind of build this program from the ground up so my goal as the pbba counselor is how to make cyber students feel like they still have a voice while completing academic through a screen all right so the first slide I'd like to show you is our Google

056Calendar booking page I actually set it up so that students and parents can book to meet with me whenever we have about 25 minute sessions throughout the day it'll come through our email actually as counseling video calls over here it'll go to the parent student myself and anyone else who we want to invite to said meeting this is how I booked a lot of my senior meetings in the beginning of the year I sent out a lot of emails to parents and students and I just gave them this link and I said book me for a time that works for you and it was extremely successful in getting student engagement up here are some of the forms that I created to make it kind of easier to access me while online one of them is

057my senior meetings form in which I had some kids fill out some Fields such as what do you want to do what are some goals and aspirations you have I have my letter of recommendation request form it's very impersonal over cyber so this gives me some extra background details to help personalize letters for students to gain them admission into college and additionally I have another credit recovery form over here just to kind of keep track of things and then I link them all to spreadsheets so we have access to data in a very easy format personalized graduation plans are something that I take a lot of pride in so you'll see a snapshot of a personalized graduation plan for a student that I created she actually has 10 credits as a senior and she's attempting

058her final two years of school in one year um my job as a counselor is to give the students the tools that they need to be successful she came to me and we created a plan so if she pulls this off she will be my nomination for student of the month for sure um this student was given a two-year graduation plan laying out exactly what classes need to be taken for graduation these are just some of the things that I send to parents just to kind of give them a a real look into what actually I do behind the scenes and what credits their child needs to graduate this student is an mtti building student taking supplementary classes in order to be NCAA eligible I created this plan for her flexibility is key so one

059of the main draws of the program is that we are super flexible so if parents can't attend phone conferences again they have access to my phone calendar and I'm also able to provide very detailed step-by-step breakdowns of grades so this is an email um actually that I was commended for I I am known for writing very very long and detailed emails because I find that uh I like a lot of detail so I think that parents do too this is an email basically um I sent to a parent that couldn't make one of our parent conferences um she basically just wanted to know a breakdown of her kids grades and stuff so I sent the time log which um is able to let us know how much time the student spends on certain things and

060the progress report with explanations of what the parent should be seeing now I'm going to pass it off to our pbba K through 5 teacher Mr kusky thank you I just ask a question while you're at the podium yes so um let's take our senior class yes if if a student didn't sign up for a a phone conference or a parent do you still reach out to them to try to set something up oh of course it's all documented um I make sure to send out mass emails multiple times and then for the stragglers who I notice who haven't responded I'll send them personalized emails and tag their parents as well so we try to get engagement as much as we can we do what we can with the tools that we're given thank you

061thank you hello everyone uh again my name is Mr kresy I am the pvba k35 teacher of record often I'm asked the question so what is it that you do so hopefully by the end of this presentation with the words of Bob Ross I'd like to create a happy little image of what a PVA pvba teacher's day looks like okay so bear with me as I go through this because it's it leads up to my day okay so upon arrival to school I will open export and save a daily report which gives me the complete overview of all my students as I get to my students then it's of to going into each individual student so as I get into each individual student um I can see a lot of different things from this this

062one record again mind you that I go through this with each of my my my students for in my classes so I can see uh the grades of the student uh which is right here I can see the pacing of the student which tells me that they're ahead of of pace that they're on Pace or they're behind the pace uh I can also see at the bottom where the recent activity I can see for each day the time that they spent what how much time they spent in each of those subjects and the total of that time spent on that day so for each those courses um which then brings me to seeing where and what area the student would need help with for example if they're behind and pacing or have a low grade

063uh then I would direct my attention to uh logging in as the student so up here I can click on this button log in as a student so again this is done for each of those students so once I log in as that student this is what they they have on their screen so this is like their home room check-in list this is their calendar this is what they have to do for that day that particular day so what you should see here you should see the check marks the check marks tell me that they are completed with that activity for the day if they do not have check marks that means that they are working on those skills for that day um so I looked at look for the check marks um and make

064notes on which courses need attention and plan my activities or lessons for our Google meet sessions that happen later in that day um in this particular example uh sorry Mr kresy just had a question um so do students and parents I'm looking on the left left now to look at the progress because I know I understand you're talking about the Daily Progress for the students but on the left side that screen or snapshot is that accessible to the students and parents to understand how they're progressing through the curriculum this is yeah this is their like this is for Tuesday like the day the specific day this is what they have this is their current score this is their current progress this is just their their home room checkin where they need to go before they

065click on one of these things up here for activities to-do list courses and then they have the option to open this up and then this from here is where they go in and see by day they can look at it how it's laid out every day for the next uh to the end of the Court wonderful thank you what is their PE class consist of PE physical education oh phys yeah pH that they have is that something they do on their own yes they have to record uh they log their activities uh the program actually has its own coursework where they have to go in and you can see for every grade it has their own fed courses uh log activities sometimes it's uh they have to chart you know how long did it take

066for you to dribble 10 yards um did you were you proficient at that where you do you need help with that so they chart their progress as they go throughout the course so they do it once and then they do it again later so they're charting it themselves and Grading themselves parents yeah parents for fed specifically yes um so so in this particular example uh you can see that for this particular student I would need to uh address or mark down to in my notes that this student is working on money and decimal operations for math uh sound and light for science social studies or the colonial age so uh in my notes I would jot that down make sure I I keep that um in play again this is all based off of the

067previous screen which they were ahead or behind or or on Pace this is where I would um look to see for um adding some different lessons that I would need to teach them when I when we get to the Google meet sessions all right um this one uh this is where I would go into now again with the the grading if the grades were low um or needing of concern uh these are all my classes and obviously it goes down to fifth grade so each of these classes I would have to click on and I would go into the grade book so upon the grade book uh would see what they got uh for quiz quiz assignment quiz grades and assignment grades uh lesson planning of the day would come from those past two slides

068which I would look at their grade so obviously if their grading grade was low with one of the uh key subject areas in one of those activities ities then I would make a note of that and address that when we meet via Google meet um also emails phone calls will be set up based upon looking at uh student data um from this slide and the previous slide all right then it's off to grading um and this up here this is a this is my dashboard so this is what I see when I come in in the morning I see that they need grades or students um submitted assignments to be graded uh this is an example of what students turn into me uh this is a math example so obviously you know I go through

069look at uh what they did as as as their activity or their work I make comments and messages the messages if I need to um give it a grade based off of of of what I see and um submit it back back to them um there's another example of a of a language arts activity with teacher comments um and again they have to um have the written work and I grade it submit it back to them same thing so um this slide indicates U more examples of student work that was submitted to be graded based on assignment rubric this this display of work demonstrates that the student receives grades for projects throughout the course assignments as well not just the paper pencil variety all right then the meat and potatoes of my day meeting with

070the students so here are you can see three screens this is one screen middle screen left screen I have three screens sitting in front of me um so my gole meet sessions with my breakout rooms are over here um uh again breakout rooms were for addressing the student needs and going into the lessons that were generated through the data mining that was done in the morning looking at those previous slides when looking through what was done uh was gone over um uh also um possible reinforcement introductory or enhancement activities are presented to the students as an individual or group uh I had to blur out the students here but this is what you know we're doing an activity here with the students you can see that they're engaged in doing an activity as I'm sitting

071at my desk answering a phone and answering emails at the same time so it's it's it's quite a process throughout the course of the day and of course we don't just do that we have some fun too as we're going through the courses some Halloween activity that we did together and we get to dress up um in addition to all my Google meet sessions throughout the day um they have an addition additional time to schedule with me on one-on-one appointments um they can discuss any concerns that they might have or sign up to have uh their synchronous assessments taken with me that are schedule throughout the program itself so they have to log in um at this time and I give them the assessment piece U via Google meet okay which is which is quite

072different from where it was last year so very quickly um so hopefully I was able to demonstrate the day in the life of a k35 pbba teacher at the beginning of my presentation I wanted to give you a happy little image of what the day of a pvba teacher looks like hopefully now you can see the whole picture and a lot of Happ what are your numbers student wise how many students do you have at each grade level so I have I have the numbers I can give that to everyone if you give me one second in December of 2024 for uh the Bears academy uh what we do see is kindergarten we have one student first grade one student uh three and third six and four fourth grade and then three in fifth grade

073and we've talked a lot about how um you know we see a lot of transition in and out of the program throughout the year uh you know more so in the secondary and you know as we were looking at a little bit earlier I think uh you know some students are coming into our district uh lacking credits and in a traditional high school schedule they can only take a certain number of courses which may not um get them to that next level and I know Mr vanor uh has always also said too that there are some students that are taking a full you know load of classes at the high school but then in the evening um you know taking online courses for some credit recovery and things of that nature because the goal is

074to make sure students have the opportunity once they graduate from Pleasant Valley to you know have a very prosperous future and uh unfortunately some of the timelines uh that may have um you provided complications earlier in their High School career um wouldn't give them that opportunity so but hopefully does anybody else have questions about the numbers the numbers uh if you want also it was a savings too correct because we had to pay a minimum amount sorry say it again was it not a minimum amount we had to pay for C Val to do it whereas this way we're saving because we don't reach that minimum now that that is correct yes um we switched the platform one of the reasons we actually gave you some more time with Mr kresy and that was intentional

075because we switched that platform over from last year I wanted you guys to be able to see that yes the students are actually doing physical work they actually have to submit things now uh the individualized assessments is a very different feel and it's a much more personalized approach especially to our youngest Learners um where you know despite I don't necessarily agree with how he presented it I agreed that the lot of cyber education doesn't work and part of the reason for that is because it's not personalized um and that's what we strive to do especially to our K through 5 level so um the last piece I do have I do want to turn it over yet to one last piece of our cyber program and then we'll get you guys get back to your

076meeting here uh Mr bmom thank you I'm the learning support teacher at Bears Academy I have students in grades 4 through 12 I'm the case manager for 50 students at Bears Academy and then also provide learning support for over 60 students so inside of those sessions we're doing small group and individual student support sessions this way students can stay in contact with other students have that social interaction which we feel is a huge part that we need to uh keep kids involved with rather than you know just feeling isolated working from their home um inside of there we're addressing their grades and their progress uh different assignments there may be a geometry assignment that's giving multiple students uh a hard time we'll break that down we'll review um some lessons going up to there to

077make sure they have the prerequisite skills to be able to accomplish that also a big piece of cyber is the flexibility it can be great but it can also be a disaster um so we're just we talk about how kids stay organized manage their time make sure that you know they don't get behind they're staying on Pace they're being successful and also manage their individual needs um along with that uh we're progress monitoring students IEP goals using our as web for reading of math we're taking writing samples we're making sure students are growing and progressing through the curriculum uh another large piece of my position is holding IEP meeting for students and parents making sure we're addressing their needs their strengths um the different pieces you know to the student and how we can help

078them be successful um the last piece then would be monitoring students progress in their grades and creating plans to help students be successful are they spending enough time on the class are they doing well are they struggling with the essays are they struggling with quizzes where do we need to look at and and fine tune and focus in on during our session so that's uh what I do throughout the day with 60 plus learning support students coming and going through Google meets phone calls emails um collaborating with Mr kresy at the elementary level senica Valley teachers at the secondary levels Miss L with the counseling and the graduation plans and Pathways and those kind of pieces thank you hey thank you everyone uh I appreciate your attention hopefully it did provide you a little bit

079more feedback about what our program actually offers so we show students you guys see so what it ends up being is it's different at every level right K through five our students are going to need more support um and we know that and the parents know that coming into our program we're very clear with them actually Mr kresy has an entire it's almost like um a very well-written like binder of this is the expectation if you're are a K through five parent especially K12 you have to be a learning coach we don't expect them to be the teacher they are not teaching their child content but they do need to make sure that their student is getting on they need make sure their student is logging into those sessions they may have to help them

080with some of this material um I do think that K12 is a little bit more of a uh it's similarish to a homeschool model in the sense where if a parent not willing to do the work to get their kid going if they're not going to be nudging their child in the right direction it's not successful um the students and parents who are very engaged and they want their child to learn and they're involved the teacher record is the teacher um for grades 6 through 12 it's a little bit less Hands-On just like it is in in our middle and high school program it's a little more of a transition and what ends up happening with that is the parents are emailed a daily report all right and that Daily Report gives them the progress

081their student has on every single course every single morning it's telling them is your child on Pace is your child passing all their courses and if the answer is not that helps them have the conversation with their child if the child's not doing well they can always reach out to us like through our Google Calendars like Miss Liv and shared um they students also have the ability to access teachers live teachers over at senica Valley teachers who are highly qualified and they can set up times to meet with them as well so there's a lot of areas where children can get support if they're needing it um and as far as the parent side of things again whenever we have problems the parents who care they contact us we get to support thank you yep

082yeah um there's there's quite a few times actually and my team is probably actually nodding behind me um because literally just today I was having a conversation with a parent who was having problems with attendance we take attendance in cyber just like we do in brick and mortar and if students aren't doing what they're supposed to be doing I'm the person to say to them hey you know what this probably isn't the format for you and if you can't get back on the right track you're coming back to Brick and more um it's not because we're trying to penalize students it's because it's not for everyone if it's not working for you my team is not going to let that child just fail or fall through the cracks so um something that we do every

083day is double check uh one person who's not here for my team is Miss Moore since she's come on to the team her attendance and what she does in tracking student progress and stuff like that is incredible um we've run a ton of siips this year to make sure student attendance Improvement plans to make sure our students are doing what they're supposed to be doing and holding them accountable so yeah question for you um do you spend much time interfacing with any other your counterparts but in the county or any other surrounding areas and what feedback if you do what feedback are you getting from them about their programs that we might want to consider for here so in our area it's Unique we've got a bunch of different uh kind of programs available most

084of them are using Edgenuity or Imagine Learning to some extent um East straussburg uh most of our schools in our area are actually utilizing that um the difference is different schools are having different levels of their own teachers facilitating the courses and how did they actually get to that level of involvement and each of them do it differently it's very unique some schools do it as a stiping position some schools do it where they have full-time teachers in most cases where schools have an entire like uh program themselves it's usually morphed from something that happened before so like for instance Pocono Mountain had their Academy if you remember back in the day they had the alternative educational placement that's what became their cyber program so it's it's kind of interesting how these programs kind of

085develop and it depends a little bit on what the teachers want what the community wants and honestly what we can facilitate and how many people we have um so right now I'd say that we're we're right in the middle of what we're offering as far as uh most of the districts of mon County have their complete program on their own but again they came from something different um so for us it's like building from the ground up I hope that helps y thank what is our next step what's my next step correct saying that like I said if we can eventually get to our PV teachers to teach all grade was like Mr Craig had five k to five what's the next step to try to involve our teachers because you're stating that it's so

086much easier when they come to our Cy school but what if it's our own teachers teaching that what where are we at that it's it's challenging and there's a lot of there's a lot of different uh it's a multifaceted issue I'll put it that way um just yesterday I was actually speaking with um Imagine Learning um requiring or asking for some information about what their programs what do they have to offer um I'm actually in contact with Sonica Valley as well about some of what we're how is our collaboration working with them and what we can do to enhance that so I mean what my own personal vision is for the program versus where we can get to realistically uh you know I don't know if this this is the right format to have that

087conversation as much as looking at it and saying hey what's going to be best for Pleasant Valley and working with the central administrators the community the teachers and having that conversation but again depending on who you talk to I think everyone has a different vision for it so I I think it's going to be you know if we're going to move in a direction make sure we're doing it deliberately making sure it's well planned out making sure it's going to be successful if we do choose to take a step in the right direction just like we did with K through 5 it was done very intentionally you know training happened before we tried to force anything to anyone and the teachers were agreeing to it before we tried to move in that direction so it's

088not just an administrative thing it's also a teacher thing we need to make sure we're we're doing things right I think I can add a little bit to that I I would say what we're doing as a district is assessing and growing and what I mean by that is if you recall um before uh I guess when the pandemic had actually occurred uh I know that we as a district struggled to have an offering online and um if you look at the sheer number it's factual uh and you can look at uh and I have the data too I could share that uh later but um you look at the number of students that were on um a cyber program that was offered at Pleasant Valley before the pandemic spikes up to about 700 during

089the pandemic and then um you know there was just a lot of um challenges and and even we experienced challenges with VN um the feedback that we got from many parents was that it's not as engaging uh so we looked at other opportunities uh both Dr Howard and I had experience with Edgenuity and you know we talk about assessment and growth when we first made that pivot to um Edgenuity we started off very small we had a very uh I think one individual you know uh as running the whole program as it was actually a year before that um we've included more teachers uh because we realized that there was a need and we have excellent teachers in the district but these individual teachers I mean the way that they're able to multitask and support

090students who have different um experiences in school and maybe some different barriers they've done an incredible job so I think for our perspective you know we're continuing to make great strides and we want to make sure that we're offering uh excellent programming so that way students remain in our school district I mean that's really what the goal is um so so I think you know even looking at this year we're going to continue to assess uh how the implementation is for this year and then as we looked we've already had some discussions about you know how do we add a middle school te teacher that has a mid-level certification that can actually help our students the challenge be to be honest is that if this is all predicated on certifications and so what I mean

091by that if you are a high school certified teacher um for biology you don't have a chemistry certification so to put that in perspective if we're going to run our own program I need a salary and benefits for a chemistry teacher and a biology teacher and a geometry teacher and an algebra teacher so it it becomes a little bit different of a ball game in the High School uh but it is something that our team has definitely discussed and we're looking to infuse additional opportunities for our staff to be part of that but I also think you know through contract negotiations and through other avenues we do have to work together to determine what works for our staff and most importantly the reason why we're he what's best for kids so yeah but I I

092did want to just end to with Mr vanis and his team they do an incredible job and again the growth that I have personally witnessed since I've been here is is incredible um you know we're catering to support education for students who um you know feel that maybe the traditional brick and mortar isn't the best fit for them uh and so again as a district we have an obligation to support the parents and students of our community to give them that um excellent offering and what I'm seeing here tonight this evening thank you for your commitment there's obviously a lot of time and effort spent to um create individual plans for the students and I really applaud the great efforts happening in the um Bears Academy so thank you perfect thank you thank you Mr

093vanes Miss miror down there do you have a report for us this evening hello yeah she's being very patient hi hello sorry okay um is good to be back November was a great month at the high school um we had a lot going on I'd especially like to highlight a couple things uh the Pleasant Valley Scholastic scrimmage team currently has an undefeated season and our last match is taking place this coming Monday our spot in the EPC championships is secured yay um the team also competed in the PBS league for the first time in a while I don't know the exact year um and we defeated Northern Lehigh in the first round and Southern Lehigh in the second round um the episode for round one will air on PBS 39 on December 29th and on

094the PBS website so definitely tune in um not to spoil but we like totally destroyed them sorry um the PB the PV debate team has also qualified for the EPC championships which will be attending tomorrow at Nazareth High School uh and the debate team is also going to be participating in the ncfl winter debate league for the first time ever big things happening uh and the drama club performed their fall play Get Smart on November 23rd and 24th and everybody loved it the cast and crew worked super hard to make sure everybody had a great time and they absolutely succeeded in my opinion and tomorrow our students who achieved honor rooll and distinguished honor rooll will take part in a ceremony where they're recognized for their academic efforts in the first marking period and a

095couple weeks ago I want to highlight that our school was visited by a representative from Rachel's Challenge which is a nonprofit Organization advocating for a positive outlook on life and an end of violence in honor of Rachel Scott who was a victim of the Coline shooting um many of our students accepted Rachel's Challenge to look for the best in others dream big choose positive influences speak with kindness and start their Chain Reaction so that's great big things happening at the high school that's all I have for today but stay tuned for developments and all of these I'll be back mayor and good luck to all those team seems competing yes and plus and definitely bring us back all that information uh Dr Conrad did we have any Community questions this evening uh yes uh we

096did actually we had four Community questions that were submitted um the first one was from donio weak from chesten Hill Township she had asked if administrators who attend the board meetings receive comp time um and you know what I want to respond is that uh there there is no comp time there's uh time that's been provided to principles and directors who attend board meetings given the fact that you know the people here my Administration team um have obviously been working since 4 this morning um and so we have to be mindful of that uh there's there's no uh financial gain there's no Financial benefit there's no overtime for our administrators and in fact you know if you look into their uh CBA there there's no hourly you know parameters for them and I say that

097importantly because I think the community needs to understand this um our administrators are available and accessible 247 um they have the means to be you know uh receive a phone call if it's uh something dealing with safety as Chief Miller and I have had many conversations and Dr Howard at 1:2 in the morning um and and that 2 o'clock concern whether that's during a school day or a weekend um or holiday even like Thanksgiving uh it doesn't matter because we have to attend to the students that we have uh to support in the community um so my administrators um they have that availability the the accessibility to respond to those emergencies um and and frankly you know building administrators and supervisors also have the uh availability to provide flexibility to their staff as long as

098that's not abused and you know we we we're very grateful during um students of the month we have teachers that uh may be here uh you know this evening but they're here at at at a a challenge where maybe they're missing a doctor's appointment so do the principles have the ability to work with staff so long as it's not negatively impacting our um student achievement and students in the district of course and and that's something that they work out with them I think that that's that's a benefit of trust right you know everyone that's here whe whether board members who've worked a job and then are committed and coming here to support the community or administrators or are teachers um you know counselors everyone is accessible um and have to be because at a moment's

099notice uh there could be an emergency that we have to attend to so we try to be very Mindful and flexible to that and I think the administrators that you know have been in our district completely understand that and if you were to ask them I'm sure they would um you know explain to you that yes you know this is a 247 job and you know uh whether it's 9:30 at night looking at the weather last night or you know 4 in the morning and and chatting with the other superintendents like this this doesn't stop um but we do it because we care about the community and our students and and we have to continue to move forward so um moving on from there the second uh question was submitted from an gravel from pul

100Township regarding the work session meetings um so there are no minutes for the work session meetings and and I want to make the community understand so we do two board meetings per month and those two board meetings are voting meetings um as you know with a large District we have a lot of personnel items business transactions things of that nature that we need to have formal business for and frankly you know because of Roberts rules which is you know guiding principles of you know organized meetings whether it's your Township meetings or through board meetings we really don't have the opportunity to engage in dialogue so I'd say about two years ago our board and I had a discussion about how can we actually engage our community if they have questions and so what we have

101is actually working sessions and so the working session occurs usually after the first uh board meeting and so we do the voting portion and then we have our Administration team who's there that evening as well and they are presenting information on curriculum safety Athletics and that's an opportunity that we've continued to encourage our community to come out and ask questions that you have um the beautiful thing that that we try to do is again through full transparency all of the board meetings that we have not only are live streamed um through a a multitude of media right now okay and I appreciate the parents and family members that are at home watching this at this moment but it's also recorded and so anyone at any given time can go back and say hey I I

102had an obligation I wasn't able to see what they're talking about for the reading curriculum or you know Athletics but you can go back and everything's posted right there on the district website it's always been there that you can um go back and actually see what we were discussing and the other part of this is that you know communication's essential right so we provide opportunities in fact I met with a parent uh this morning um for about an hour she had some questions about some things that were happening in in the district and some concerns and things of that nature any of us myself included our Administration team will take the time we're here to support the students and the community so when community members have questions and and you know quite frankly the facts

103might not always be out there on social media um I would encourage people to come and talk to us about it because if you have questions just like we're doing right now we're trying to answer those questions um to the best we can so I would just encourage those individuals to um go to those working meetings the other thing too is we we have what's called Committee of the whole and what that means is that there are nine um elected officials here uh and and they all have an important voice so when we have any discussion especially during these working sessions um we as a district have found that it's best to make sure that everyone has representative at that time to be able to share some insight and that might be a little bit

104different because in other school districts they might have a committee of let's say three people who kind of drive a committee like let's say Athletics and these three individuals want to hire a particular coach but one of the things that we've talked about as a board is that we should all be privy to the information at the same time in the same way so we can all make it an informed they can all make an informed decision of what's presented um so hopefully that does explain a couple of things the uh last two questions were the exact same question from Don Yos weak and Sandra uh B barunis uh from Chestnut Hill uh and the questions were concerning the superintendent resignation which will be addressed I believe later on by our solicitor so that will

105be um forthcoming and if not then I can certainly add to it um towards the end but uh certainly have an opportunity to to address some of those um things to provide some clarification of how things um have transpired and you know there's some I think things that uh need to be um expressed and also understood from our community so that's all I have thank you Dr Conrad at this time Pleasant Valley citizens is there anyone that would like to address the board on agenda items only during our first session uh if so please come to the podium state your name and the township you reside in and there is a three minute limit this is policy time right yeah policies are included that are on yes making sure I got it right you got

106it right all right back again and gravel pul Township uh I spoke a couple years ago when you decided to change parents to stakeholders um principles to administrators and now I'm speaking on term limits no offense Su time's up um with the new president coming in term limits will be on Congress term limits will be everywhere why does a school district not have term limits I think everybody should take a turn you knew when you become when you ran for this this was a possibility this is an outrage that someone else can't take the helm no offense to your time's done um someone else really needs to step up we need change in the school district we need different voices um enough's enough come on people I mean you recline you decline joh Mr giki

107you know he deserves a chance all right no offens again um I understand we're going into to your experience is welcome but I think you should ventor somebody else cuz no offense you're not going to be here forever we may have these board members for quite some time thank [Applause] [Music] you seeing no one else approach the podium I'm sorry I have a question sorry sorry no no don't don't don't apologize I do have a small small thing in this public in this session that we just did I I looked at the agenda listing I'm sorry Janet duner Pok Township I think I have to say that I'm sorry sorry again you know always remind me can how can we talk about this if it wasn't the secretary's report wasn't an approval of the board

108meeting agenda does that make sense I can show you the papers that I printed because last week it was printed out differently we did the Pleasant Valley citizens after we did the secretary's report this time we're doing the Pleasant Valley citizens and it might just be because there's two meetings but I think there's a a flip and I don't want to have any anything come back at us that we did things out of order I think you are absolutely right I think we should have approved the agenda and then done public comment right Kathy it's how it should have been I know everyone's tired I'm tired too sure that's how we've done it pre and that I'm just I have the papers because and then that just brings me to my speech so I I'm

109going to be very brief because I know everyone's tired and that's it kind of goes into the term limits and and I think what you have to understand is that term limits are not just about Schoolboard members it's everywhere in the media it's everywhere in the government and I spoke on November 25th I was a little heated that night I walked in because I was frustrated that night and it wasn't my best moment but um I still support the idea of term limit and the reason I'm saying that is be it's being able to speak about this for the people is our three minutes in this constitutional republic to be involved longevity in our government has not necessarily brought leadership to its best stance and being an elected res representative in this local community should

110always be about serving the people and others and I know we do that we try that but government is an agency of stewardship and I I had that word written down before you even said it Dr Conrad because it is about stewardship it's a it's a different term that we need to embrace um the reason for term limits for elected positions has been called for in all our levels of government the board may have its reasons behind closed doors or even in public for the reason of supporting termet not term I hate this thing when I have to go back and forth but I do support the term limit idea and and the reason I say that I was surprised by the lack of enthusiasm no that's okay just I was surprised by the lack

111of enthusiasm for wanting to be the president or wanting to be the vice president and and I hope that you realize that the people did elect you it is a humble honor to be there and I and I do think that you believe that but you should foster that desire to want to serve in that leadership in that role of the president or vice president and it is not against you Su personally this is a time of change in our country we're hoping that more people and I hope that more people start coming I wasn't coming because I was very busy doing other things and I I just hope people watch it and and embrace it and keep coming that's all I can say but thank you for your service I I just wanted to

112respond to your comment about term limits I think it's a I think it's an interesting topic um and maybe as a general premise I I agree with the idea maybe globally um but but the issue I think for me is one of of of a legality and you know if if a district were to enact a term limit whether it be for president vice president or or frankly any appointment that they they um they Institute I'm not so sure it's it's legal and I I'll give you an explanation if you look at the school code which talks about appointing officers it doesn't in that since have term limits within the state law so five boards from now nobody is on the board that's here and somebody wants to be a board president for a third

113time if say we have two two two uh terms as the limit I don't think there would be anything to prevent that a policy is a policy but the the law the law if they wanted there to be limits there would be limits so I appreciate the the the um the issue but I I I just think I I don't even know how placing that into a would would be consistent with the law itself I I understand that okay but we the people it's local you guys are local okay would like to keep understood understood now this is going to be the second reading obviously you guys are going to pass it because it's already on there but remember we the people want to have this and this is our local government and I think

114our we should have the right to say CH limits to the people we V in oh understood understood and I I would concur with that too I think we'd all have to go into it even if there were a policy down the road to term limit that it is more aspirational than it is binding okay okay um anyone else at this time yeah he's G he said he was going to address it with her one sorry I I sorry Denise hopley Chestnut Hill Township why is the policy up for review if we are asking you not to change the policy5 why why is it up for a second discussion we are asking you to keep term limits because we should have a diversity here we have a diverse and very intelligent board why can't we

115use all our board members why do we have to have and no why do we have to have a fourth term president I don't understand this you ask us to look at the policies we're looking at the policies we take our time to come every time we try and back everything that's best for the students oh something wrong uh Denise I I can hopefully address your concern if if you don't mind would you like why are we doing 05 well let let me explain so um so what I had stated at the last board meeting was yes that this uh o5 policy did come from that uh decision in Jim Thorp Area School District uh what I believe I also said too and if not I apologize but um the idea is is twofold one

116is that we ac we receive recommendations from um Pennsylvania School Board Association there legal team on recommendations for policy and as they review our policies one of the things that they don't have in policy 005 is a recommendation for term limits now what's interesting is this so first off um but can I stop you one second but let me finish because I think this will make sense to you but it's already in place term limits are already in place no no no and this is what I need to clarify if you look at the policy right now and I would encourage anyone to go on board docs and look at policy 005 one thing that I think is very glaring is this I believe it's almost a recommendation in terms of the term limits however

117it states very clearly on each of those term limits with an aster and I don't have the exact language so I apologize but essentially the board as a whole can determine whether or not they feel it's in their best interest to um you know change uh you know change that or not so the fact that it's not in policy 005 is actually a moot point because when it's currently in its current interation right at this very moment before we're even voting on a change in a minute it actually limits the um you know it it it recommends um the potential for limits but it also says very clearly that that does not have to be the case if that's the will of the board and I think from from a from a governmental perspective um

118we there are nine board members here and I think what's a little bit different is there's not an executive order of power from the board president of a board of a school board you know president ky's vote is no different than that of um any other board member here and her vote cannot Trump somebody else's and supersede that so there are nine people here and obviously mathematically there's a reason that there's an odd number because there if there's a split vote of a four four there's a fifth person to sway one way or the other um so so I definitely hear what you're saying and I think that this board definitely values what you're saying because I agree I think that there's benefit for all of us to learn um you know the the ropes

119and you know what what it takes to um you know lead a a school board I'm very happy with the direction that we've headed in and the direction that we're headed towards uh but but I just want to say that like in the current iteration of the policy right now what just occurred with um you know Mrs kresy being uh voted again as president is number one coming from her colleagues um and and elected officials before you because of the stewardship and the belief that they believe that she can continue to do a great thing and we've I think as a community can see some really great things happening in Pleasant Valley but also um it it's well within their rights to make that determination to um you know bring on uh and and support

120everyone that's why we talk about having Committee of the whole is that we're all here to have an equal voice I don't have a vote I don't need a vote I make recommendations and then the board then ultimately makes decisions based on that vote so I'm just saying that as it's currently you know stated right now it's really a moot point it's it's it's being recommended that it's not even addressed in the policy because at any point if the board chooses to sway one way or another they have that right to do so sure okay since it's since it's just hold on this hold on I want to stop the Q&A at this point and if you have a comment you can I'm going to set I'm going to set at zero to start your

121three minutes okay plus the 50 no I'm gonna give you the three the full three 50 oh we're not there yet no go ahead from before go ahead so this was this a that's your take on this whole matter with the term limits okay this isn't the community because Community has no knowledge of what the board is deciding the community has no knowledge that the board's going to decide this way and we're going to follow this policy we're not going to follow um the policy here that's on the agenda we've no we have we're not Clairvoyant yet okay we would love to be able to read your mind we would love to be able to see let's work cohesively together so we can get term limits in here so we can hear everybody who have

122been tremendous leaders in their own right in this community I don't see where it's beneficial for people to have fourth terms and again that's your take but the community is not we there isn't enough transparency for us to agree with you I can't agree with you on that and I don't see the benefit of having all these term all these uh people in the same position for years I mean change is good that's what we've all heard so you should get everybody an opportunity too and everybody should step up on the board and they should all take their turn and they should want to have somebody else and again if it's predetermined then that's what it is but again that's your take but the community is not being [Applause] heard seeing no one else approach

123the podium Mrs smil please good evening tonight I'm requesting approval of the minutes of the meeting held on November 25th 2024 and the approval of the December 5th 2024 board meeting agenda second I have a motion by Mr burer and seconded by Mr Clark is there any discussion yes uh first of all I have to abstain from the vote because I was out of state with family um however I did watch the video twice since I've been home Sunday and today um there was incorrect information given when someone asked about salaries how they're determined and they were told that act 93 is negotiable act 93 is not a negotiable contract that is something where three board members meet with Administration and decide what they want to give them as salaries the only contracts that are

124negotiable are the um professional staff which includes teachers nurses U guidance counselor special ed Etc they negotiate support staff which is custodians maintenance um our Secretary General secretaries cafeteria those are all negotiable supplementary contract with a number of you asked about that was coaching advisors that is determined by Administration they decide what they want to pay who and what they they established their own contract so should answer your question you have any else please reach out I have no problem answering it correctly thank you anyone else all those in favor please signif I'll be saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries Treasures report Mrs service yes tonight I'm seeking approval sorry item 18 A through C A being informational so move Galler second I have a motion by Mr Galler second by Mr

125Mr gazis is there any discussion yes uh Tammy the Rendell All-American the football jersey laundry for 6,175 how often do we do we Jersey wash those jerseys that that invoice is for all of football all levels and it's for the entire season okay so at the end is when they do it all then they do they store that then for us to as well or is that has to be stored in our I think it's returned to to athletic at the end but they're they're cleaned it's all the sanitary it's part of the PIAA rules thank you you're welcome anyone yes yesy I'm sorry I need to F from 18c check self okay thanks Mrs Z thank you thank you anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone opposed and

126that motion carries moving on to unfinished business Mr Fitzgerald uh yes and good evening again I I wanted to revisit um the meeting of November 25th and and clarify what I believe were some misunderstandings surrounding the intentions of the board and uh Dr Conrad that evening um now while I was not there um I I I knew full well what the intentions were that evening and that was uh for the board and Dr Conrad uh to enter into a new 5-year contract now I I I suspect for many of you out there you're wondering well why was there a resignation on the agenda and I I will tell you you know frankly just looking at the agenda I would ask that same question Dr Conrad unlike anybody else in this District uh comes not just

127with an employment contract but a commission through the state and if the district were to enter into a new contract and commission with him he would effectively have to resign his current commission and that was the intent of the the multiple action items for the 25th a resignation from the the current Commission in contract to be then reappointed to a new five-year contract and commission that's why they were connected together so uh frankly I apologize if if that was not clear but that was the global intention of the board um with their superintendent that evening thank you Mr Fitzgerald is there any other unfinished business yes I'd like to chime in sure I'd also like to uh talk about last meeting I prepared a statement here that does not reflect this board as a whole

128but me personally having this meeting back in the auditorium brings back memories of four years ago the dark times this district and board was pulling out of I definitely don't want to see us go backwards we need to do better I left our last meeting on November 25th with my head spinning to our community did we handle things correctly prior to meeting regarding the plans and actions to the agenda no we didn't but I do commend sue for taking ownership as board president and at several times trying to explain things but being shut down by the community hindsight is always 2020 and everyone makes mist Stakes community members please don't lose faith in your board members look how far we've come in just 3 years moving forward from those troubling times please understand we do

129approve contracts and agreements for employees across the districts and those documents when presented are open for discussion however when it comes down to individuals we do not discuss Personnel issues in public meetings and thus no comments are made from Schoolboard members regarding such issues the public raised several concerns that singled out a specific employee in this case our superintendent regarding rumors and accusations thus becoming what could be become a Personnel issue while it was a Personnel issue I believe that could have been handled better by that employe James we had 17 or we had members at the podium 27 times on November 25th with the majority of them commenting on concerns about your contract and rais proposal during the public comments you heard the discontent and rumors as to why this was happening seeking work

130elsewhere accepting another jog strong arming us Etc I anxiously awaited for agenda item 21 which is director superintendent comments hoping to hear some words of encouragement from you regarding those rumors and to reassure your utmost commitment to our district and community that never happened our community was looking for feedback instead you avoided the subject and when our community realized that you would not acknowledge their concerns and rumors they left and all you could say is thanks for coming out as they walked out during your remarks James I've always supported you we've come a long way in the past three years however your lack of response and reassurance along with your actions since the last board meeting has me placed in a stance for moving forward I will not support opening your contract until expiration [Applause]

131nothing this evening we will meet on Monday December 9th thank you J Colonial IU Mr Galler we have our one monthly meeting next Wednesday I will have a report prepared for January's meeting okay thank you uh psba liaison report Mrs zip nothing to do with this CH thank you Mrs zip uh education report I do not have anything this evening to re to report um Finance report Mrs surface called for later in the agenda athletic report Mr ' yes good evening I'd like to say uh all of our winner athletes are doing an awesome job uh putting some wins up on the board uh it's a good Collective effort from those teams and I want to put a huge shout out to our first ever win for our girls wrestling team that was a debated

132topic up here at this board and look what they're doing they're they're winning um so I'd like to give a huge shout out to those girls I wish they were here we could stand up and give them a round of applause that's all can do and to close I'd like to see this support at our events as well to come support our students I know everyone likes to to gripe and moan at us but and I'll take it but uh let's let's go support the kids thank you thank you Mr o'keef uh Mrs zip policy report policies on the agenda tonight for second reading and approval thank you uh Capital Improvement Mr burer we haven't had any meetings since uh our last board meeting however we got notification that uh there is a solution to

133the fees uh for our renovation project uh be looking forward to seeing the results thank you thank you um technology Mr Clark nothing at this time thank you Mr Walter security yeah I just want to say um Pleasant Valley was the recipient of the pccd School Safety and Security Grant which is $183,500 um and we'll have more to follow with that I have a question for Mr Walters uh is there a chance that you could uh provide the not the 16th meeting but the following one in January I know we had this once before but the number of security and number of police that we have um total and what they are by shift like how many do we have per shift and at what building so like is there 9 to five so many

134are there after school how many are there and then Saturday and Sunday are these shifts um are these regular shifts or do we pay these people overtime during that time okay I need to link with the solicitor and the chief to make sure I what information I can give out I don't really want to tell people about you know right in and out of what the security doing but uh let me link with them and whatever information I'm able to give you on that I'll have for that January meeting okay thank you I also have one other thing here since we're out of there new business um this goes for everyone here involved it says policy 0031 board communication as an elective representative of the citizens of Pleasant Valley the board member has the responsibility

135to listen and acknowledge opinions recommendations complaints concerning the school district by the citizens parents Guardians and students as member of the governing body of the district the board member has the responsibility to listen and acknowledge the opinions recommendation complaints concern the district by professional as well as a nonprofessional employees of the district District education law fact sheet school boards are accountable to the residents of the district they serve and who elect them this means they the board have the responsibility to keep the community informed and must make all decisions using input from the public and the members of the community citizen advisory committee this is policy 905 the purpose of this advisory Comm which we do not have the board recognizes citizen advisor committees and other AD committees that can be useful in keeping the

136board and administration informed with regard to the community opinion and representation representation of the community and the study of the specific School issues an advisory committee shall consist of at least one board member interested Community residents and District administration when appropriate when creating the the uh advisory committee the board shall Define the committee's assignment appoint the chairperson appoint residents that are interested that can help for special contributions approve appointment of the residents staff members and students recommended which could be from the superintendent seek the wildest R the widest range of community interests and backgrounds the board May set dates for preliminary and final reports the recommendation of advisory commission shall not reduce the responsibility of the board which shall be free to accept or reject the amended modified committee recommendations meetings for the advisory committee

137are not regular meetings of the board board and shall be open to public only upon invitation in reading this and because I've heard this brought up a number of other times by other board members in the past that and citizens where is this committee at tonight I'd like to make a motion that such a a Citizens advisory committee be established operational and presented at the board no later than the January 23rd 2025 meeting and I need that's a motion so I need a second Mr you need a second folks you need a second from another board member hold on uh Mr gazis uh Mr Fitzgerald that is a new business that is a motion that I made no unfortunately and we're still waiting by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court on this very topic um right now

138agenda has to be set 24 hours in advance only what I'll call the Minimus items can be added to the agenda um establishment of this committee I don't think we meet that threshold um so I would ask that this might be something to be considered on a future agenda so this could be added on on the December 16th special meeting that will be up to the policy for agenda setting so that I believe that goes through the superintendent that it's going to be ignored again or does that mean we push it to a further date because it's quite obvious the community wants something said in the last meeting like I said I watched it twice and it's quite they want some saying things and I don't understand why we the bo are not giving the

139people who elected us here why are we not giving them that representation Mr gisy I would like to I know you read portions of that policy I would like to personally read the policy go for it um to make sure because for some reason in my mind I understand but what you're saying but it has to be I think the policy says it has to be for a specific topic just not to have a committee to discuss anything and everything so I just want to make sure you know citizens advisory committee policy 905 whatever you want to call it bring it up bring I have written down um and we we could look at putting it on that agenda on uh our special meeting but typically when we have a special meeting it's usually a

140one aggenda item and um that is to do since I know that's out there too I might as well explain that too the only item that's on that special agenda for the 16th is the awarding of the bid to do with the high school renovation project because the bids are due the 12th I believe the 12th so uh that was going to be the only item on that agenda bids are duing the 12th we start the evaluation on the 13th right with a report on the 16th right to the board but we could definitely look at it for in the month of January put it on the agenda for the first January meeting I don't know the date off the top of my head but what takes it so long to put it on the

141agenda yeah it's been something that's brought up in the past so I don't understand why it's still something that's been my suggestion would be it probably can go into a work session discussion item for that first meeting in January I hear you m Cher I really do but I also know that like you said it's been dragged out dragged out we need to push it forward thank you all right Dr Conrad um superintendent reports please sure okay so uh tonight I'm seeking approval for item agenda items 21b and 22A items 21 C is informational second I have a motion by Mr Burger seconded by Mr Walters is there any discussion yes policy 005 I know it was mentioned a number of times the psba this is an email from psba all right nothing in the

142public school code limits term limits of office however school districts May establish their own board policy creating such limitations as mentioned on the phone psva does not provide any legal advice we always recommend Consulting your school solicitor so there was no legal ad no legal advice from psba thank you anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I I no anyone OPP post all right moving on to uh Human Resources uh Mrs fulman good evening uh tonight I'm seeking approval of items 23b through 23d so moved second I motion by Mr gazis seconded by Mr Walters is there any discussion all those in favor please signify by saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries I'm seeking approval of items 24b through 24d item 24e is informational so moveed second motion by

143Mr kazis seconded by Mr Walters is there any discussion just for the community purpose this is the supplementary contract this is one of those that are set up by administrator it's not something that's negotiated just familiar with that anyone else all those in favor please signify by saying I I I anyone opposed and that motion carries uh there's nothing this evening for curriculum so we're going to move I would like a question about curriculum oh there's no motion okay in the curriculum um I Heard as I read Mrs gresy asked about the uh programs that were choose for reading and it was stated that there was two that were chosen that she I think she stated that there was five of them that were brought forward and then the question was like how did it

144get from five to two was that something that the teachers actually said they wanted those as their final two or was that something the administrative team decided that it was that final too please only answer that question I don't want a lecture that's three miles long who did it was it the teachers that thre it down the two or was it the administrator that's all I want to [Music] know okay and this was research correct okay then I'm confused why education weeks which a superintendent gets because I read it uh said that the Wonders read program has gaps in its alignment to reading and does not offer enough support for teachers it also stated it's unlikely to lead to literacy success of all the American public school children I want to know like how did

145something like that become the one of the final choices if our teachers and our administrators picked it and also just because I've been with this district for so many years back when we used to have choices our teachers had the actual choices we have all those big blue signs at PVE that all the success that we had and then when the superintendent decided to let their administrators start picking programs our literacy program would down the dumps and now it sounds like we're heading that way again I'm not saying that's where it's going to be but if our teachers are the ones that are in the trenches then they should carry a heavy say as to what our children should be learning because we all know that first of all and foremost those are the people

146working with our kids our administrators not to say anything wrong about administrators but the administrators that I know that are involved in here none of you have element experience okay the article that you referenced was that a fact or was that an opinion excuse me I said the article that you referenced that was written by someone the one that was education week that comes out of your office that was that was that a fact was it empirical data and and data or was it opinion had a survey listed with yes it did well I I'll take another look you have that we new paper do you read that newer I I do but and I also saw the article where the Lucy Caulkins program is actually going to Federal Court um was not picked by

147teachers either but right and and and so I I want to make sure the community understands this I actually um had an opportunity to go down to PVE about a week ago and then talk to a few teachers at pvi and the feedback I got actually overwhelmingly from both groups at PVE and pvi is that this is the first time ever in the history of the district and one person said that they've been here for 26 years mark my words and they said that they've never been included to this degree of providing feedback and guidance on what they believe is going to be impactful and it's interesting and I want to share this too um the the individuals said that in the past the individual when when the the individuals there was about you know

148five or six people I guess traditionally that picked out the curriculum for reading for example um and and I guess what they shared with me was that uh it always came down to whatever's the cheapest right and and we all know that sometimes when you go cheap you don't get the same quality and the same value and um what was interesting is when we had that discussion and Mr pompelo was there Dr Howard was there um our curriculum leaders were there uh and and we talked to them about you know we're not so much that's a that's of course a factor without a doubt but this is more about what resources do you need what's the continuity in fact in another meeting that I had with our teachers just two weeks ago I asked the

149teachers in the Middle School are you familiar with the curriculum that's being implemented at PVE and pvi and I will tell you the answer was no because we haven't as a district had vertical alignment that means taking a look at our reading curriculum and when the students leave fifth grade at pvi and then go to the middle school and sixth grade we haven't had discussions to the degree that we should be having about what are the gaps what are the challenges and so we as an Administration team and with the great work of our te teachers have said let's collaborate let's talk about how do we get to a better place and that involves more feedback and more people so I think we're actually doing a tremendous job with that and again I'll I'll make

150sure that uh I review every article that comes about with the programs I know that that's something we're vetting and I will tell you that we've actually reached out to all of uh not all but a number of schools in the area that actually have both programs and we've committed to our teachers that we will take them to to those schools so they can actually see it in play and then share that feedback with their colleagues about Pros cons challenges so that way at the end of February our goal is to have a reading curriculum selected and that timeline's critical because if we were going into February with five options we're supposed to give professional development to our teachers in in June how can we expect to do that if we obviously don't have time

151to take care of them so I think that that's really important for for all of us to understand is that there's more people involved with the process there's a strict timeline that we're trying to make sure that we set our teachers up for Success um and and that's going to be looking at this uh across the board and and again you know obviously what the program that we had utilized may not have had the impact we were hoping to so we'll continue along with those curriculum and November 21st 2024 and also in the uh education week it talked about that does this program have guaranteed results because it states that now most schools are going to guaranteed results meaning that the district only pays so much up front and if the students don't reach their

152goal then that program forfeits the rest of their money however the district has to make sure that their resources are available for the students so that is a guarantee do we have is that program any one of those programs have a guarantee of success because it's quite I that over the past couple years we're not reaching that success level so we need somebody that's going to guarantee that we're going to get that yeah that's that's a great point and that's something obviously that you know we're looking to triangulate the data meaning like you know we're going to be using different assessment tools to see if students are making progress um right now we have a number of assessment tools but I don't think that they're um being utilized in the way that we would hope

153in the sense that uh we're not comparing uh to other students and and and grade levels across uh you know the state and even Across the Nation so that's something that we've been having discussions about with nwaa and other assessment tools to really evaluate that and that's a really good point from a contractual standpoint um if that is an option for us to say if you know within two years we're not seeing growth that we would hope I would certainly hope that we can back out of a contract um and I'll look for um that in the future because I think that we should have those guarantees but remember we have to implement things with Fidelity in order to implement with Fidelity we have to have the trainings necessary so our teachers are set up

154for Success right you can take the best program in the world Dr Howard and I talked about it today but if you don't have the um you know the the Charis to teach the curriculum and the resources and the training that's necessary it's not going to succeed and that's something that we realize in the past there may have been gaps so we're trying to obviously alleviate those gaps but very good points all right since we're on curriculum I have another situation I want to bring up maybe less contentious as that one um Dr Howard I can't see you but this is to you bit 99 math and Ed puzzles are those programs going away um we have a list that we're working with for our teachers to make sure that the resources that we're using

155in classrooms are used across the board we have several resources that are used in some classrooms and not all so we have been working with the building leadership to look at those lists they're not done but we are looking at the lists so the feedback I'm getting it's they are banned anded edpuzzle is because Ed puzzles a lot of putting kids on the computer in the classroom and we want to get away from that and have more of the teacher interaction so edpuzzle would be Yes edpuzzle actually we stop we stopped using last year okay so who banned it who came up with that idea who approved it who because we paid for it our but our our it's it's run it's going to run out and we used a lot of that during covid

156um and with the teaching but now that we're back brick and mortar we don't want to do as much of that and back to get 99 math is there reasoning for I I don't know about 99 math I cannot answer that one because I don't think that's on the list that we're still looking at I know Ed puzzle was last year I just know specifically from a sixth grade student that lives in my household yeah she's very upset yeah um and I don't know nothing's been and they enjoyed it so I hate to say we take away something that's educational right enjoyment because for me I like it I'm going to continue to do it and I'm going to succeed we just have to look at things and make sure they're on grade level and

157that all the teach teachers are using it so it's not just one classroom and you know the others we have taken nothing away yet this year we are looking at it still just to P back that I also got six gr feedback especially on booking especially on booking yeah and we have to look at how it works with the math program we have and is it giving helping us get the results that we want so you know those are other things we're looking at but nothing this year we're looking at it it will it happen yes there will be a list um does that come to us to make that decision though like do we make that you that proposal and we we say yes or no based upon facts I'm asking no I that

158that would it just runs out it depends we have to look at all of our resources and what we're using and what you know we use a lot of money from Grants for this we can't pay for for everything so we have to look at the resources that are being used and are they being used across the district or across the grade level uh or is it just some teachers are doing this and supplementing with that and other teachers are doing this we're trying to get some some consistency with what's used and having it support our academic goals and the resources we're using and some of them aren't doing that so that me I'd be more than I I could be more than happy to share it with you when when we're done I encourage

159my sixth grad to actually contact you awesome I would love it I I would love it I would love she does well I'm over there every morning so tell her to grab me I start the day there all right does anyone else under curriculum okay okay moving on to operations Mr SMI good evening tonight I'm seeking approval of item 26a so move Galler second a motion by Mr Galler seconded by Mr gazis is there any discussion I don't want to discuss that I have a I have a comment here uh we'll be coming up this coming summer on uh facility availability and so I would encourage all individuals whether it's Athletics or other activities um to stay informed about what's going to be happening during the renovation process and there will be times when certain

160portions of the building as a result of renovation will not be readily available and particularly those that are from outside the Community our community at large that use our facility um you might have to make other plans or certainly change your schedules uh on how often H you can use a particular facility or or whether or not the facility be available so um hopefully these individuals will be notified and and that uh they have time to to make other plans as necessary thank you yes um Dr Conrad has instructed me and uh James Kinski to reach out to these groups and keep them as updated as we can as this process goes along someone else no I want to talk afterwards all those in favor please sing by saying I I I anyone oppos Mr

161SM and that Mo motion carries Mr SM question last uh board or last time I was president Mr kesy and I asked about the carpet of PBE um what's the process what where are we at on that uh uh Dr Howard and I are gonna get together and discuss that is that something we hope to get done maybe over Christmas break or is that something that has to be a summertime job or that would definitely have to be a summertime job okay and I know when I was there there was water filters put on the uh um the uh water machine what do you call the fountains for the kids drink out of are those water fountains still being filtered with that water I'm sorry I can quite hear that at the water fountains at

162PVE there were filters put on them because of the dirt that was coming at them are there still filters on them are they being maintained yes okay thank you all right all right moving on to uh building reports our Administration team here is is here this evening thanks for being here um as well and is there anything that you would like to add to your report I would just say things honestly are actually inspirational a lot of great great Mr papel I got a question for you first of all I want to tell you make sure you pass on our congratulations to GI giero she was student of the month appreciate that um I have a question this is probably both you and pvi um what has happened with our learning I know we don't

163call it l l o anymore we call it tutoring or something like that usually that ran from from October to May and as of to date I hear there is nothing at all for these kids that need help I mean we're what are we waiting for I know we're saving money I don't care who respons it but I want to know why we're not working with these kids who need it yeah the money issue or what sure I I can answer that uh we we posted for that we did not get the turnout to offer it so we um went to tutoring and the buildings that we had teachers that said that they would do the tutoring we are having it so we do it by we need the teachers so if they applied to

164do it we we're having it we are not having it at the high school we had no teachers applied to be tutors uh we have the most at pvi so did you not call this a tutoring program which that means it has to be a teacher because I was told that there was parents that applied for it and they're told they couldn't do it is that tutoring now just it's for the teachers correct I I can add a little bit more context to this I guess my whole thing is that something should be done with these kids who need it I mean if we only have a couple teachers then let's use let's take them and work with the kids that we can get in there until we get more teachers I mean not to

165keep pushing this program off or halfway through the year uh I I can provide some context so um last year we ran the lro which is the learning recovery opportunities program um the program we had paid teachers I believe it was $57 an hour8 $58 an hour thanks um and what that entailed was that there would be I believe it was like an hour of kind of prep time to get ready for it is that yes and then and then um they would uh instruct and so obviously at at $58 an hour that that is pretty substantial and we had a conversation U with our teachers and with our Union saying listen this is through a grant money and so of course we want to make sure that we put value to um you know

166their efforts uh because we're not running that through Grant dollars that's being run through the general fund the amount had dropped down to what was it 30 35 $35 and and so unfortunately I think with the the decrease to $35 um we didn't get as many individuals as we were hoping to um support the students and and again we can't run a program if we don't have that support after school and I think you know we have a number of teachers that are uh you know coaching and doing other things after school and and I think you know people just have to weigh decisions uh it is unfortunate and so we've pivoted from that lro program as we ran last year to modify it ever so slightly but I think we only have about two

167or three teachers per building pvi has a few more okay yeah um I think it was like two in some of the others not at the high school you only have two or three that signed up for that program because that's not what I heard four four zero at the high school what was the Middle School two two one at the high school or middle school I'm sorry sorry and then one one and then Pete so so that's one and three that's four seven and how many have pvi maybe maybe seven okay so we're talking 11 total teachers in the district the $58 just so you know that was out of the Esser grants that came out specifically for learning L and we don't have that anymore that's right yes so we tried we really

168did we think it's great for people to stay after the buildings that have teachers that signed up we going to do it and we we've been meeting about it we have the busing signed uh um the busing ready to go met with the principes this week they said let us prep our teachers we're going to be ready to go when we come back in January so yes and how long is it run is it running January to May yeah to the end of the year yes to May and if more teachers decide they want to do it as the year progresses we will hire them and uh proceed yeah yeah yeah we definitely encourage if if they have time in their schedule and they can support the students that are struggling you know please let

169us know and we'll um move forward with adding those individuals so all right um any oh that was PVE I guess I want to skip pvi so all right at actually our meeting sign up for it they're really excited for awesome it'll bece great thanks what about the Middle School anything are SCH excellent thanks and then High School okay great thank you so much Mr Bo on you said on November 20th you had the Rachel Challenge and you said the opportunity to sign up how many did you actually have signatures from kids who signed up for that racial challenge we actually still so there's no signatures yet okay thank you all right thank you uh moving on to business management Mrs smil uh H up Air Academy oh goodness well MREs you said that um

170if new if the students in your school they need school physicals or dentist have anybody gone forward and taken up that taking up and who pays for that do they have to pay for it themselves is something the district's covering it it's done the same exact way the buildings are done so for instance sometimes schools do pay for physicals for like athletes and stuff like that they can take part of that as well they even better there you go because I I oversee the nurses as you all know so we do school physicals um they were done in the fall they do go through the list of all the kids registered reach out to the parents get permission slips signed St Luke's sent to Pas here in November because that's when we do school physicals

171the DST van comes around same procedure as with the physicals the School nurses figure out who needs what and then the kids get their teeth checked um last year we also added the service that if a child needed um minor work done minor cavity things of that sort um parent can come or fill out the paperwork and we can take care of that for them so I handle setting all that stuff up with my nurses in St Luke's great thank you you're welcome business management Mrs B I am requesting approval of items 28b through 28e so move second I have a motion by Mr kazis seconded by Mrs surface is there any discussion yes Mr SM can you explain how they do the free breakfast like at PVE or is that something Mr papel like

172how do these kids get their breakfast at PVE um PVE I believe is still breakfast in the classroom it's delivered to the classroom you're not doing in the classroom anymore okay it's what perod so they're getting their meals at the classroom okay and then how is that reported that it reports the we get so many free breakfasts how does that report it that we know how many people are getting it the the when the students get their breakfast um they have they swipe they get a meal they go to the register they swipe same for breakfast same for lunch and then the swipe is an electronic count they're not placed outside their door and they give it to them when they come in we did classroom breakfast at the beginning of the year okay until

173the students got used to everything and it's up to the building principles how they want their meals served I don't dictate that pap wants steak and potatoes what works best for their buildings is how the meals how breakfast would be served we started out with breakfast in the classroom and it looks like we moved to it not being in the classroom now I was just wonder when he said to the classroom that's why I was wondering about how there might be other issues with uh pets that might come to visit that's why the reason [Music] that thank you okay anyone else all those in favor please signify saying I I anyone opposed and that motion carries I am also requesting approval of item 29b so move Galler second I have a motion by Mr Galler

174seconded by Mr gazis is there any discussion hearing of none all those in favor please signify by saying I I I anyone opposed and that motion carries under new business Mr Fitzgerald uh there's no additional report this evening thank you Pleasant Valley citizens is there anyone would like to address the board this evening please come to the podium state your name and the township you reside in and there is the three minute limit hi Anne grael PK Township I've been taking notes it's scary that if the teachers are making this decision and if Mr giki is correct one of them is useless as a teaching tool I'm scared for the teachers or our students obviously we're not hiring the best if they pick something that's that bad secondly assessments I spoke about this last week

175how many more assessments can you possibly take on these kids if the teacher is that bad and they can't figure out what kid struggling what kid isn't how many more assessments do you possibly need when do these teachers get to teach these kids and again I'm going to go back a recommendation from pasbo is not law okay if we want term limits then maybe you should guys listen to us for once okay I knew it was going to pass I said it when I was up here you had no intention of taking that back so obviously none of you want to listen to us and then you wonder why we all get frustrated and upset I'm sorry I haven't been here in the last few years but I'm I was also working on the solar

176for pulk Township I can't be everywhere at once I am one darn person okay and when I come here only thing I get you do what the hell you want you don't listen to anyone in this audience ever and you proved it anyway thank you hi Denise holey Chestnut Hill Township uh the administration your Administration team building activity over the summer at the racetrack raises serious questions what kind of legitimate team building can happen at a racetrack Additionally the receipts for the expenses why was the district money and time allocated for an off-site building activity instead of finding opportunities within our own Community was taxpayer money used for this or was it St Luke's money given used for our students what kind of message does this send to our students and the community about building

177morale do you really need to take a team to eras track in Allentown meanwhile many families are struggling to afford basic necessities like heat and food yet our Administration T staff is taken to a racetrack with their meals reimbursed this is unacceptable in the next team building activity are we going to go are you going to go to an MMA fight last year's Choice involved weapons and this was a racetrack there seems to be an alarming escalation here and it's no wonder our students feel unsafe in the school how much will the next activity cost tax payers who are already grappling with high cost for food medicine heat shelter and clothing this culture of excess must change I've read that Dr Conrad has resigned and you accepted it will you adhere to District policy and

178initiate a proper search for other qualified candidates how can we be assured Conrad was the most qualified candidate for PV this needs to be established transparently will stakeholders have a voice in this process and will contract when will con Conrad's contract be um discussed if not is it when what about the rest of the Administration staff why aren't stakeholders being considered and evaluating their performance are we reverting back to the good old boys club mentality effectively stifling any chance for real change the stakeholders in this District have already endured enough of this outdated good old boys club approach it's time to shift towards accountability and a community engagement remember we lost a great number of Veteran teachers that felt the te the students educational needs were not being met because of things your Administration either

179put in place or refused to help by the way needi add inexperienced young Administration that said you will teach them and you gave them significant salaries despite their inability to do the job [Applause] Janet duner pke Township again and um Dr Conor I see that you have comments coming so I don't know what's going to come but what I'd like to say is thank you to Mr Galler for the letter that you did read in this meeting um and Mr Fitzgerald we were explaining that at the last meeting about the resignation being put up and then the set we it was explained and it made sense that it had to be that way but the events surrounding that night didn't need to be that way and Sue thank you for your apology that night you

180did take ownership of that night and we did ask why it wasn't prepared for ahead of time because it seemed like there was enough agendas handed to the people who waited outside for an hour to get in we're not going to relive all that I thank Mr Galler for the letter that he wrote his words were very very good thank you and um basically one truth is is behind this and and the public may not know it will have to be left to uncover it on their own or will be perception of that reality and one of my first employers my first manager said to me always remember that people's perception is their reality and I think the community is suffering from that we've suffered from this for eight years since covid we have a

181lot of social media putting things in people's heads we may not always know how to react as people I suffer from it sometimes too but from you Dr conrade we expect it better and what good is your written if your what good is your word if the written word of that contract wasn't good I I I wrote this down I I for three days I've been reading reading your contract reading the case study for the for the um the no not the term limits I went through that too but the sunshine act and and knowing that we were stuck here because nobody understood yes you can move something from your agenda you can't add something to agenda we were we were all um taken aback that night so I guess this is just your action

182or inaction Dr Conrad has placed the people and it's it's harmed our elected representatives I I value each of you that are here I value our elected Schoolboard members who are volunteers in the state of Pennsylvania at least this section of Pennsylvania and I'd like to keep it that way so I don't want to abuse their time by that action that happened last week there will come a time that I might speak up even about student of the month I hate to ruin that but again these are our elected officials who are working for the people all of these people are our salaried people who are paid by tax dollars and we appreciate them we can even appreciate you Dr Conrad if we can build trust and I don't know what's going to happen I

183I can't read that but I think student of the month takes up a lot of time on our elected on our Ed people and we have a big project that is coming up and I even think to the point where Mr kazaki brought up about the citizens being involved in another policy and I did write that down it's a okay I'll go I'll speak I I know it's time to go home no no not you should clarify that with everybody just for sorry just for clarification we do do not have a working session this evening Angeles where the warmth was right okay go ahead that's Teresa grego ches Hill Township um I'm jumping all over because I have all these notes from tonight but I just wanted to say I was very um disappointed to

184hear that our let's go Bears guy was madebe moving on and I thought you know I was part of making that contract for five years years so not to honor it for five years I was very disappointed in that so I said well what's one snapshot that I can just bring to the table tonight and I really appreciate the presentation from the Bears Academy um you know being a numbers girl when I was on this board Numbers Never Jive they never added up and it's like oh well it depends where you get them from but the 380 or whatever that you said tonight was different than what the board report enrollment is okay so I'm just going to say I went back Dr Conrad your first board meeting with us was December 16th 2021 so

185I went back to compare you know what is the state of the district three years later okay so the we changed the name you know it was the pbca now it's the Bears Academy we thought we change the name maybe more people will come it's a whole different program you did tonight say something like 700 people during Co yeah VN that was during Co it was like 73 I'm going by just by memory from what I when I was looking this up this information but back in 2021 it was 251 in our cyber Academy there are 243 listed today that's down eight from three years ago we still have over 400 outside Charters yes we've come down 56 we have come down in three years but we're still over 400 we have 10 more in

186private schools and our brick and morar is actually 63 less than it was three years ago so again this is just a snapshot that an ordinary citizen can get on there go to the the the the enrollment reports and just compare so I say thank you Mr Galler so I I from my bottom of my heart I say thank you and I say if you guys are the only nine in this community that would like to break a five-year contract make it three and give them all this money take the Pulse of the immunity and rethink what you're going to do Mr Galler you summed it up very nicely Dr Conrad I think you're on a really good step forward but there is so much more work to be done here and I applaud you

187stay follow out the five years and let's see where we are then when it comes to the reading program first grade teacher of 34 years you know there might not be one reading program across the board from K to 12 so maybe you need to look at what's best for K to2 is not best for three to five and Dr Conrad yes we've done extensive times where our our teachers got together and we did roll over what happens at this grade to this grade to this grade we did that years ago but that has to be done so I'm glad you're doing that the okay all right I'm gonna step down thank you okay go ahead one more com teres GRE ch 9905 please check that out we listen to Ron Reynolds come to this

188meeting every single week asking for it I asked for it it's not the same as the operations it's not a dialogue at that operations meeting you need this policy we have the policy we just don't follow it so if it's there let's fulfill it and please look at that adapt it to what's what we need to do Sue by looking at that language okay thanks Merry Christmas thank [Applause] you any oh anyone else sure if he was hi my name is Tanner kutzler and I'm from Chestnut Hill Township uh I'm a student of Pleasant Valley high school and I wanted to address a problem that I've been having with the administrators of the school for the past two years um it's regarding the flag salute policy and the citing of the Pledge of Allegiance um

189there's a big discrepancy between the board policy and the handbook policy along with the Constitution of the United States for a citizen um I'm going to read the two policies I'm going to point out what the problem is the board policy reads students May decline to recite the Pledge of Allegiance or national anthem and to salute the flag on a basis of personal belief or religious conviction students who choose to refrain from such participation shall respect the rights and interest of classmates who do participate the handbook policy states it is the responsibility of every citizen to show proper respect to his or her C his or her country and its flag however students May decline to recite the Pledge of Allegiance and may refrain from saluting the flag on the basis of personal beliefs or

190religious convictions students who choose to refrain from such participation shall respect the rights and interests of classmates who do wish to participate in a meaningful ceremony a student who chooses not to participate May either stand stand or sit remaining respectfully silent um the handbook policy when it says that you may stand or sit it kind of restricts the freedom that you have to protest the flag and that's where the problem comes in um I was walking in the hallway one day it was about two months ago I want to say and a teacher asked me to stop because it was during the Pledge of Allegiance I respectfully said it's within my rights to continue walking and she told me that I must stop so I stopped I had a conversation with her about it and

191end of conversation she was like all right go to your class have a good day I came into school the next day and my first period teacher told me that I had a in school suspension I was never informed of that beforehand by email or anything but so I went to in school suspension I talked with the administration about it and they said let's go to the board about it um I think that if you look at similar cases throughout history we can go to Tinker versus de Mo during the Vietnam War when uh two students were armbands in protest of the war the school tried to prevent them from doing that the two students sued the school and they won the case through the Supreme Court of the United States um I don't think

192it's right to restrict our students rights to protest especially when it's not lwd vulgar or distracting other students I never got in the way of other students and I never prevented them from exercising their rights and I would just I would just appreciate if you guys were able to review the policy uh try to find a grounds where students can express themselves to the extent that they would like to without obviously it becoming lwd or vulgar or disruptive and yeah so that's that's been a problem for me so that's all I got thank you anyone else okay seeing no one approach the podium Pleasant Valley School directors does anyone have anything this evening I've got a couple items uh I'd like to go back uh Dr Howard when you were talking about lro uh I

193just want to confirm a few things so last year um we were still using Esser funds for that okay and when we were using Esser funds just to clarify that's meaning it's coming from a grant that's not costing our taxpayers any money because it's obviously through a grant last year when we had the lro running how many teachers were involved ballpark not even a ballpark 12 and that was at a rate of60 some dollars an hour how much 58 58 okay and now this year the rate was reduced to which is how much an hour 35 an hour and we have how many teachers that came out for it 12 12 that's what we said 11 12 when they added that's all noted on that can I just can I piggy back Mr ker on

194that sure okay before the lro program what did we have Mr pompella and it was done after school okay thank you sorry Mr G I just just trying to make sure everybody's aware of where the monies were coming from at what rate and what we're paying now and where the money's coming from now sure but what I'm trying to just I want to make sure our community understands that was out of Grant monies at that higher rate now when we don't have the grant monies available it's in our general budget we had to lower the rate and I just want to point out what the turnout and teachers were at that point that's all second item I have here uh from some of my community members questions about the Google form that gets submitted into

195uh superintendent for questions I don't know who can answer this but as a recipient when you send something on a Google form is there something that's coming back like the marked receipt saying that it was sent and received by recipient I don't know who's going to answer this but I hope somebody can and I can answer it Google forms have a setting when you set them up to actually have it so it can do that I do not know about the particular setting for that form that you're speaking of so can we have something set up so it automatically generates that to the community members sending it yeah so it'll automatically respond back to them your responses on that form basically letting you know that you submit it yes okay so hopefully community members that

196had questions on that are hearing that right now so we will have that set up you will get a receipt saying that that was received on pv's end uh the last thing I have for my comment ments are um I've had community members coming to me about accessibility and how we respond back to people uh one we have the Google form enacted for Dr Conrad to be able to respond directly uh we put that in fourth uh second thing is and I've always done this and we've said it how many times we're available after board meetings how many people stick around and talk to us we've made oursel available in the past prior to meetings we had an hour nobody showed up we set aside then a half hour nobody showed up last thing is

197the email I just want to reiterate on the emails when you email and you include all of us in an email and somebody responds back it's business the only person I can respond back when you email all of us is the board president you want to get a response emails directly I just want to point that out because I'm hearing people compl we email the board they don't get back to us I'm giving you some insight on this if we operate in more than three people it's business we can't even go out in a community I me Heck if we'd want to go out and have a beer together we all can't it's it's a beer uh but seriously people don't understand we anytime it involves over three of us it's business so it's not

198like we're trying to blow you guys off on stuff it's these emails but you need to understand that I've helped out several community members they've emailed me directly I was able to go to Dr Conrad or rather personnel there be able to work with them on that but you got to be able to understand how it works we can't get back to you and be conducting business I go back to three years ago we were in a very dark place I just want you guys remember that we've come a long way we've come along with with Dr Conrad with the board the way it is here we've made ourselves way more accessible than it's been for as long as I can remember but to sit here and listen to community harping on us about not

199being accessible or not being here for you guys are not listening to you I call BS you have to understand how it works that's why I'm trying to explain it to you guys we are here for you but know the proper channels to go through with it we will support you beyond that I just want to say have a great a great evening have a great holiday everyone anyone else this time I yeah uh Miss Harris I know I probably missed this but can you give me an update on the BHA in poke are we heing that or is that going to be next year or what so their inspection with the state is this week where the state will come into pul and look at the rooms that they staged right now they have

200two full classrooms um that we housing at PVE temporarily early till after the holiday break um they did hire a third teacher and staff for that room who are currently training with the veteran staff in the two open classrooms um so they're doing great out there I've gotten positive feedback um from the staff at PVE from the parents things of that sort but are we moving are we going to move to Pok then over Chrismas breaker that be they will be moving to poke after the Christmas break okay at some point we had to wait for the state to come in cu state had to inspect their space I know you were telling us that we wouldn't do it either halfway or at the end that's I just wonder if we had something yeah we

201kind of wanted to do it a more of a natural break instead of just like on a random Wednesday because yes app the children that they they teach it would just throw them off right thank you you're welcome I have one other thing uh the Hall of Fame committee will be meeting on Monday um we have seven first year nominations and five second year nominations uh no third year so all the third year have even been picked that so thank you Mr K is that a good number John um it's up is it not yes yes thank you anyone else yes picking back what Mr Galler was talking about is it possible for us to set up a instead of a messaging to the superintendent but it's messaging to the entire board so that message

202goes to all of us at the board and then it's addressed at the board meeting justce Dr Conor advice um because I get it there's so many emails that we get and I want to jump in and say something but again I know I can't because that's as you said it's discussing business um so is that something we could set up and have as an opportunity to give feedback to the community that is coming to us as board members during the meeting yep how about during work session still meeting well I understand we do it but it's it's giving the feedback back so we have to come up with some type of system to accept the feedback give it and then 360 right back can we um again add that to the work session to

203discuss I'm fine with that is that right I'm bringing up the idea yeah I understand so can we add that to the work session as an idea to discuss I think that could also segue into what John was talking about earlier about the that Community Committee that might be something that could segue just two quick things sorry missp wants to mention something and to go back on the Google form just a quick um update currently that Google form does not collect email addresses um it's set up to be anonymous so people can commit they can do their comments the problem is for us to send a receipt back to the recipient the person who sent it we would have to make it so it collects their email address so it may be something we want

204to consider um whether or not we want to turn off that function and have it go back to those people or if we want to keep it Anonymous um but we can have both let me let me ask you this so you can obviously I understand the anonymous part of it but when you submit does it not say successfully submitted and give you some type of onscreen display notifi notification yes it does give the immediate notification of you've submitted the form to confirm that it did go through so it's not just like I clicked it did where to go yes if if the concern was that that people were not sure whether or not what they were doing was actually being seen or going through or being received uh they are they do provide that

205feedback immediately but they do not receive a copy back to their email unless we have a collect their email address so then my question is is James when you get your correspondents how do you know who they're from because you're saying who they're from each time are they signing their name at the bottom I believe on the form so I I can show you uh I have a spreadsheet and it has the individual their name um the township and then the question that they're asking and um the yeah so okay does that make sense so so when they s an effort for all of us to be transparent why wouldn't we want to know who it's coming from and get that and as a recipient you get the time stamp receipt back just saying anyone

206else I would just like to make one comment uh to a comment that was made earlier one second Sorry Miss did have said oh Mel forgot thank you to I a little understand col position right um traditional position the challenge with I think with this position in general right is that in order to have one of those positions like the president or the vice president or the treasurer feel like there's a lot of time that's required there during administrative hours at at the school district right and for me and other people that are more restricted during the day because our our work hours aren't flexible I wouldn't be able to I appreciate what they're saying right but I wouldn't be able to serve the board in that kind of capacity right so there is some

207there because there are I mean it requires a good deal of time I feel like after school hour some of us support the Bo in that so I do want to say that but I also want to say you know the president of the board can't make decisions on their own right they preside over make sure the Committees have people on them we are so we're all there anyway and then you know they represented Bo the whole board um in their Communications right like they're the person that represents de they can't really do anything on own without from the bo so I just want to put that out there because I do think I don't want people think I there are people have to have the ability to get into schol and and support the

208board in that and is Li fact you don't have do that uh so I just I K just want to put that out there and there was someone out there that dat a comment and I just I want to correct it because it was wrong and that is that um I joined the board member [Music] um and at that time the contracts were allti and Su was not president when that happened nor was she president year before so I just want that to be that's not what happened and that's that's what there um and then I did one other day um the just want to go back and AC thank you Mel um I did write a number of things down that I I did want to comment about and um actually um Mr Galler

209and Mrs zip just took uh a number of those no no no that's fine a number of those I do just want to continue on um the comment that Mrs zip did start about the contract uh that when Dr con R um the first evening our very first board meeting was actually reorganization if I remember directly here yeah and we were up there though we were up there and um uh so it was reorganization I I did become president that that evening and we were also served a strike notice from the professional staff that evening to that they were going to go on strike so I want it to be known that we worked very diligently with the new board and Mr Galler Mrs surface were on that committee Mr Berger was on that committee

210also um and we worked in a very timely manner to get all the contracts negotiated and approved so it is incorrect that we didn't do that it we did it uh so I just wanted to clarify that statement also um anyone else okay Dr Conrad superintend whoops one more she's I'm [Music] sorry I what also is a challenge and and I know that you guys you said it and and you heard it also the representative of the really try to take it it I mean they're trying to coordinate n people addition people right they're doing a lot of work trying to everything and also take a good deal you know deal not positive energies because people certainly aren busted down the do to the school board meeting to tell us how wonderful things um I

211me that's another challenge right really trying to find someone is willing to put in that position all the time because it's exhausting uh and I than for really TR to take a okay Mel okay all right thank you Dr Conrad um so good evening everyone uh I'm looking down in front of me and there are just a ton of notes that I have and and um you know as is normal I think it's probably best to go off the cuff a little bit um you know there's a couple of things that that I I wanted to say um and certainly I'll have hopefully an opportunity to say them and say them and articulate them the way that I think are true and genuine and something that maybe you can understand um one thing that I

212just written down I I made a comment to myself that says uh when things aren't said misinterpretations occur and as I was writing that down I was thinking but there's also sometimes that things are said that might not be factual and might not you know be all of the details and um you know I I first off I think I can start by just saying like I appreciate you all being here tonight and for those of you that have met with me and have talked to me till 12 o'clock at night in months and years past um to those of you that we had a conversation right after the board meeting right because I value your time and I need to understand where you're coming from so I can genuinely you know we can try

213to work together and I can understand your perspectives right um and and so I appreciate you know it's 10 o'clock at night we're all here um you know everyone has work tomorrow and and again I'll try not to belabor everything um but I I truly mean that when I appreciate you being here tonight because you're here for a reason and you know you're here hopefully to to seek understanding but I also am a realist and I understand that sometimes there are situations that no matter what you say and Al articulate as you can be you can't change the hearts and minds of people okay and and that's a hard thing for me to accept because I try to uh take time to get to understand different perspectives and I don't I know that sometimes we'll

214agree to disagree um but I've done a lot of reflecting since uh last Monday and a lot of reflecting over over Thanksgiving um and and another thing that I had written down and something that I just keep on saying over and over again is that trust takes time you know know I had asked uh there was about 80 or so people that were at the last board meeting and I apologized that we didn't um know that it was going to be that large you know I again we hear that there's going to be some people coming but uh I I don't want people to feel that they don't have the opportunity to come or have to sit out in the cold so I I personally apologize for that I didn't think it was going to

215be um to that degree uh but but when I asked people at the end of the meeting I said how many people have have been to a meeting recently the reason I asked that question isn't ever to be disrespectful it's to engage my audience it's to understand okay like have we met before have we had dialogue and conversations um and if we haven't maybe there's an opportunity for something to begin I I met with a parent that literally was at that meeting on Thursday or uh last Monday and I met with her for an hour and a half today two kids in the district one kid in the district one to be coming to the district we had a great conversation because we talked about some of the challenges but we also talked about growth

216and we know we haven't you know we're not where we want to ultimately be but I would say if I reflect back from when I started here December of 2021 there's been a lot of positive changes maybe not every change is perfect right um but again that idea I really want that toally resonate with you is that trust takes time and it's like how much are you investing into building the trust and relationship so we can at least have a respectful dialogue um there was a lot to process that night right like I I walked in and expected something let's just be frank uh and and that didn't happen so I think that shock in all is something that I was trying to internalize but maybe this wasn't as articulate because I I do try

217to seek to learn and to listen I needed to really take in what the community was saying what were the concerns they were very valid concerns and again I appreciate those concerns being brought to the table and sometimes it's hard to address an entire public um as it is you know compared to like one or two people uh that we can have a conversation with cuz I I truly think the flavor of the conversation is often different when you have 88 people that have one frustration that they want to share versus you know a few parents or individuals or teachers or whomever that have concerns um I did try to answer some of your questions and and here's the thing I I I I said this today to the board um I don't think I

218realized that I up up until this very evening this was a missed opportunity on my part because one thing I didn't realize and I apologize for not realizing this is that I believe that part of the challenge that I was experiencing on Monday was you know does this community believe in me you know what's the rationale for continuity why are we doing something sooner than later things of that nature right and and I tried as best as I could at least in the mind frame that I'm in and put yourself in my shoes for a minute if you can but just trying to you know answer those questions that that you know I think you you had asked um we've seen a lot of growth in this district and and I've committed since day one

219even before I sat in this seat on that first evening that I am absolutely dedicated to Pleasant Valley and I've never wavered from that I come in every day I wake up at 4 in the morning when I need to because there's a snow squall and we have to make sure that our kids and buses and everything's safe but I'm committed to Pleasant Valley and in reflection I feel like my silence made some of you question is he committed what's this intention you know why is he resigning I would I I can tell you right now I I absolutely was like I don't want to resign I don't understand you know why we have to resign to rehire like I I that doesn't make sense to me it really doesn't because it's the furthest thing

220and I I literally quote quote this it's the furthest thing that I ever had in in my thought with Pleasant Valley we've seen some great progress and I'm committed to continuing that progress and I'm committed to working with the Bo um if I didn't answer your question or if you have additional questions or want to engage in dialogue I I you know you can call me you can meet me you can email me I emailed about three parents this evening that had questions um six o'clock I think it was probably 5:30 because we had executive session but um just trying to make sure that people get the answers that I can reach out to and there are sometimes as we were talking about where um sometimes people will reach out to the board and not

221me so I'm not privy to that which is hey maybe that's the intent but if you reach out to me I can promise you you're going to get a response um good better and different that's your call but I'm going to respond to you because you have questions and I want to answer those um again I I I apologize because I feel in reflection that I didn't articulate my commitment since day one and 10 years out of how committed I am to district and how much I am proud of and PE proud of the great things that are happening here um I I believe this board wants me to be here I think that our Administration team I think our teachers uh want to see this progress I think too often we've seen so much

222change over in everything not just at Pleasant Valley any District there's there's change over and and change is good but change can also be challenging and it it could be volatile because it's just you know a bouncing ball that you're constantly following and that could be very challenging as well well but I I do want to at least leave you with this tonight um as the superintendent and the proud superintendent of Pleasant Valley School District every day that I've come and every day that I continue to come to Pleasant Valley I'm committed to this District I'm committed to our family and community and most importantly and I really mean this I'm committed to the success of each and every student and I understand that there's some people that might have various opinions they might not

223have kids in the district currently or maybe they've graduated but as a community our kids are our future and I'm committed to making sure that we are giving them the best resources tools to be successful to articulate themselves the way that we know that they can and honestly I've seen greatness coming from every graduation class that I have personally been at and I've seen the students make such great progress because of each and every individual person that's in this room whether it's parent Community member staff member security that makes a recommendation on student of the month every one of us has a Mark that we're going to make on a student and as I've been leaving you with board meetings I really wonder what is the mark that we're going to leave with students and

224and ultimately what's the mark that we're going to leave with one another so I encourage you if there's questions that you have or you want to sit with me send me an email call me I take the time because I want to make sure you have the answers um did want to Pivot real quick because I did want to again clarify something that was stated in I don't want to not say it because then it might be misinterpreted um going back to that that team building um situation that was not paid for by the taxpayers like unequivocally I will show you the receipt come and see me it was not paid by the taxpayers and it's team building every person that has coached a team everybody that's been part of a team everybody that's part

225of a work team team building is important and I'll tell you what in the last three years when I first came here first word I've always heard was the culture and cl climate is toxic it is a revolving door we don't trust anyone and I'm not saying it's perfect but I will say that the level of trust in my opinion has greatly increased but as I said before trust takes time and I'm going to ask those of you I can't change all your perspectives and Minds if you have a fixed mindset but if you're open to dialogue and would like to know how I feel or what you feel that I can help to to do that's going to better OPP you know provide opportunities for our students I'm all ears because I want to

226make sure that PV continues to be an excellent place for work education for our community and I'm committed so I just want to share that with all of you and again please reach out to me call me set up a meeting we can talk um it's a little bit easier from my perspective that way and I apologize my silence I think a lot of really what I was trying to do was take it all in and really understand the perspectives the frustration and the validity because there is with the concerns of the community but I'm here and I've been here and I will remain here to answer anything that you have with questions or concerns the dialogue that we have here at the board meeting is great I appreciate all of our board members because

227you all bring perspectives and you know uniqueness that that's going to add to the success and pleasant value so again I appreciate your time I hope I wasn't too long-winded I know I can be sometimes but I I truly believe in Pleasant Valley I believe in our staff and our students and our community and our parents so um with that being said I appreciate you being here and um that's all I have thank you Dr Conrad um I want to wish all of our Musical and our band and our chorus and all that's going to happen next week unfortunately I'm gone next week so I'm not going to be able to make any of those performances pictures oh that'd be great that would be great but I I wish them all the the luck and

228enjoy enjoy and um again our next meeting is a special meeting as I spoke before um and hopefully one item on the agenda two yeah it's December 16th yeah December 16th um I know someone asked about the time again we changed the time to 6 PM because that was the will of the board we when we discussed it just because it's a one item agenda we want to get in and and get out and and uh so it was the will of the bo to set it at 6 p.m. so um all right could I have a motion to adjourn Some Mo I have a motion and a second all those in favor okay safe travels home everyone sleep fast as they say if you have to get up in the morning

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.