CorpusRecord 149435

CSISD Board Meeting 1/24/2025 - Workshop

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / College Station ISD
Date
2025-01-27
Location
Brazos County, TX
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,373 words · about 36 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] all right we're going to call to order our Workshop rescheduled for today Friday January 24th 20125 12 p.m. uh welcome everybody Declaration of a quorum uh five here today to absent welcome everybody thank you all for being here bring item see hearing of citizens we don't have any item D we're going to open up our public hearing to receive a presentation related to The csisd Tech academic performance report paper for the 23 24 school year good afternoon Mr hak Dr har rder I'm here to update us with our public hearing for the Texas Academic performance report for the 2324 school year so for last school year um this taper report contains details for the district and our campuses on our academic performance Financial reports staff programs as well as demographics there's a lot included

002in this report we'll start with the district performance of our state of Texas assessment and academic Readiness the star performance our attendance rates dropout and graduation information as well as college readiness um including those ccmr indicators will be it will be part of it uh will'll include our district profile which is your student information their demographics staff information as well as program information there is also additional compiled information as part of this report including some team's Financial reports our accreditation status which we are in credited District our campus performance objectives the special education determination which we meet requirements uh report on violent or criminal incidents student performance on Post in postsecondary institutions as well as will refer to our house B three goals excuse me so the main components of this taper report our star

003our postsecondary Readiness student and staff demographics as well as publicly shared information so we're going to begin with our star results um this is a overall look at it since we broke it down earlier in the year uh this is our grades 3 through eight reading uh state is in blue College Station ISD is in red you'll see across the bo grades 3 through eight or above the state this is all at the approaches passing level then we have grades 3 through 8 math uh once again state is in blue College Station ISD is in red uh remember for our seventh grade we have an advanced program uh FasTrack and College Station ISD for so for 7eventh grade math uh the majority of our students are taking above grade level math and not on grade

004level math grades five and eight science and grade eight social studies once again the state blue College Station ISD in red once again of the state and then we move to our end of course assessments uh these are taken as they finish up that High School course um again the state and blue College Station in red and we have succeed the state then postsecondary Readiness which is also linked to ccmr graduation and Dropout we had 1,030 graduates in the class of 20 three our graduation rate was 95.8% which was uh almost 5% above the state annual Dropout we look at the other way 2.8 we went a low percentage we were at 2.8 while the state was at 6.3 college career and Military ready graduates with all the multiple indicators as outlined in accountability was

005a 70.5 we are there a little below the state and then when we look more at our graduates our Advanced dual credit completion is at 41.5% which is below the state however look at our AP grads we have 30.7% of our graduates that have participated in advanced placement courses where the state is only 20% the next category is college ready graduates now this focuses on their sat act and TSI performance as College ready graduates and we were above the state 60.2 and then they pull out just TSI criteria graduates and that was at 56.9 well above the state we highlight our Advanced PR Sprint program we are uh we usually get an additional word as a district for our advanced placement exams across all of our subjects 30.7% % of our 11th and 12th graders

006graduate having participated in an AP exam while the state's only at 24% then by subject I broke down the participation rates uh simular across our four core subjects the biggest highlight for me that I want to point out for this district is our AP performance out of all of our students who have take AP exams 81.5% of our students meet the criteria the state's at 53 well above the state and those students who not only take the AP exam but me the graduate then we look at sat act participation uh for our ACT SAT we're 67.6 where the state is higher we have our students register we do not do schoolwide days we're State usually we have a lot of districts that provide a schoolwide day 61% have met that criteria well above the state

007our average SAT score is 1132 above the state and our Act is at 24.5 well above the state then we break it down to staff and students who is inside our multiple campuses uh as of snapshot October of 23 we have 14319 students our attendance rate for 2223 because it lags a year was 94.9% again above the state this is the breakdown of those 14,000 plus students by race ethnicity our special populations of economically dis dis advantaged emergent bilinguals at risk special education programs so uh 504 dyslexia and gifted and talented and then we move to staff for 2324 we had 2,11 employees um and that breakdown is shown here we're 48% of those are teachers for our 48% of the teachers the overall staffs here is our we have 1,09 total teachers 28% of

008those actually hold an advanced degree our average experience is 12.5 again above the state and our turn teacher turnover rate was at 17.6% which is p the state which is a good and here is our years of experience with 3% being beginning teachers all the way to those with over 30 years at 3.5% and then all of this report is online and available as well as multiple other pieces of the report so now I'll open it for any public Com or questions out of curiosity why don't we do a day sat day distri when we are tracking ccmr and the SAT act so many of our students have right met that college entrance criteria that um we the counselors work with those individual students to offer them the opportunity and they provide it very much

009so we have a lot of students with TSI great anything else no just that there's a lot to be proud there and I obviously we've said this many many times I mean we do in almost really almost every metric um outperform the state when Premier school school district and the state but it shows but I also we've also said here though too I mean I certainly believe and I hear from others as well that we still have our other in we still want to be even better than that right and still continue to to grow our all of our students so yes you know it's not just comparing to the state right it's it's tracking year to year are we getting better and um those are important always another way to track and look at

010T and see how more how we can get better yeah and I love that this is available for everybody to see it's it's the state you know does this yeah I can ask you that does this go have you already presented this to the state and like I mean or is this how how I know they're requiring each reports how does that system work to do the take it actually starts at the state and then it goes down to each and every um Lea in the state and then the each district is required to do a public hearing or a public report uh usually by spring break perfect thanks anything else thank you very much that will close our public hearing bring us to item e attendance ofate um Dr har Rider excuse me Mr

011hor Board of Trustees I have some great information to show so I just wanted to kind of talk about we talked about an attendance incident that was started here at College Station ISD and we're really excited about what the results are the reason for doing this again is just to get those kids back in class that we lost from the P pandemic uh we know that we're still down below what we have previous and we also know that when we have kids in school they learn better they achieve better they test better and it's just better for our community uh another thing is yes we are funded on Ada versus enrollment and there is big numbers associated with that with kids being in school and getting that additional funding because we staff based on enrollment

012and we get paid first on attendance uh this is kind of what it looks like when a kid misses the day of school so you can kind of look at that if they've missed two days a month they've missed 20 days in a year 12% of instruction and that is 17 hours of math 34 hours of reading and writing and a year and a half of Education by the time they graduate from high school so it's very important to get those kids in school and I think our principles have done an amazing job of working around that rallying staff and getting the parents knowledge to get them back in class so this is kind we what we're looking at we were at 94.9 at the end of last school year we're at 95.3 this year

013and yes I did the math on that if you look at our current students and you take them at 95 .3% that does add up to about $385,000 in additional funding for our school district so it is big money we do know that we've got to kind of keep that push and rally because to the end because sometimes when the sun comes back out and it gets warm and we're not taking snow days kids want to uh stay at home so we want to get make sure that we keep that percentage up and our kids are staying in school so this is kind of what it looks like because when we work with our principles this semester and kind of taking a look at I do want to point out this information but then I

014also want to cidate our secondary campuses if you look at last year's information and you look at a grade level that's the percentage of attendant per grade level so you can kind of see when our F our seniors get up here and they get a little senior itis their attendance drops down a little bit and then we do and we're hearing back from those Elementary principles of just ways to incentivize those um early Ed and prek students to come to class and sometimes those parents think of that more of a daycare versus education and so we've got to get those kids uh in our classrooms kindergarten you know the first time out of their home they they get sickness a little bit more so you can tend to see that but you can kind of

015look at a historical information based on attendance and grade level uh this is some celebration this is just previous year when we did our incentive this year we looked at a three-year average and that was really just a kind of a reward campuses that had already gotten their attendance up from co uh and look at a threeyear average but this is year-over-year and you can see the huge strides are campus have done our biggest ones would be Rock Prairie Elementary A&M Consolidated if there was an award she would have gotten it uh but they are up to 95% huge strides from previous years but there's only one campus that didn't move the mark which is really exciting now this is when we take into account you know if you remember the incentive if they get

016about. n they get the full amount so they get their enrollment base times five U dollars and so everybody above the top uh line got the money uh College Station if you look at the three years history theyve grown the most over here and then same thing Rock prair shows up as well so you can kind of look at everybody above the line of getting the full uh percentage the full $5 anybody between the line are getting a dollar to $4 okay but uh great growth here so you can kind of look at the starting point everybody above grou this is what it looks like on a payout basis uh we're going to be giv $34,900 back to our campuses and it's huge dollars if they continue this process remember we have an additional multiple

017if the district can meet their rate and then they can continue to keep their their uh attendance rate we're going to multiply this amount by five and so they can see as much as 10,000 50,000 going to a high school campus to to utilize for programs and growing students so it's big dollars does anybody have any questions all right thank you thank you uh2 cell phone survey results all right Mr orac members of the board uh I have results from our recent student cell phone use survey this is a part of a conversation that the district has been having for some time um as you are aware um the district for a little over 10 years is a bring your own device policy which allows students to bring personal devices including smartphones to help aid

018instruction um uh following the bring your own device policy and just with the enhancement of technology and the proliferation of social media and with phones just being more a part of our Lives um the Sha committee um developed a recommendation for the board in 2018 to restrict cell phone use on campus to approved educational use only we'll look at the current policy as is stated now um as the Shaq committee um amended it in 2018 but really that was just to to provide some consistency across the board in the district and um and ensure that our our teaching staff and our schools really had the final authority to say whether or not a cell phone could be used um during academic time and then last spring sha recommended that we continue to evaluate the cell

019phone policy to limit distractions and off task Behavior again cell phones just continue to be a part of the conversation as we have students um in our care um during the school day we have to look at what is going to be the best option for us as a school district and for our schools to make sure that we are um providing them with the the safest and most productive um learning environment possible so our current policy um we're not going to read it verbatim but basically just says that the the teacher in the classroom has final Authority for the policies and procedures in their classroom as it relates to electronic devices specifically cell phones here as we're talking about about it um and then um gives a little bit of guidance on how um

020teachers and schools can move forward if if those policies and procedures are not um followed by students um and then it's broken down by a grade level in campus um with giving our older students at the middle school and high school level a little bit more freedom to use their electronic devices during the school day during lunchtime um during passing periods during breaks um and then at the high school level giving some guidance on students being able to use earbuds in at least one ear as long as a teacher or administrator isn't giving them Direction so that's where we're at currently with our policy um and really our next step to continue to evaluate it kind of taking that recommendation from Sha to look at it was to to get some Community feedback and so

021that's why we disseminated that survey so we provided the survey during the month of December for intermediate through high school students staff and parents and Guardians um to give us some feedback we also um throughout the the fall semester had the opportunity to get in front of some staff members through the teacher advisory Council and deic to talk a little bit about uh some of the implications of cell phones in the classroom what they're seeing on a day-to-day basis get some direct feedback um provide us with some information that maybe we're not seeing on a day-to-day basis that they are we'll talk a little bit about that as that it came out in the results so here they are here we'll start off with just um who filled out the survey who completed we had

022about 4,400 um of our community members respond to the survey completely with the majority of those being parents and Guardians um and then our students our next highest population at staff um a little over half of the folks who filled out the survey were associated with the high school and then the other two quarters intermediate and Middle School um looking here at our demographics we'll talk about parents and staff first and then we'll we'll talk about students and why that graph looks the way that it is but um our pretty pretty similar results and outcomes for our parents and staff filling out this survey matches the aggregate data that we had on this first slide um close to half are associated with high school the other two quarters intermediate and Middle School um you'll notice

023that our intermediate students um overwhelmingly filled out that survey and admittedly that's because we had one specific campus fill out um it seems like almost every single student on that campus filled it out so Props to that campus that that did that um but U it does give us some good insight into maybe that particular campus and how students are using them at a fifth and sixth grade level um so we're kind of taking that caveat as we roll through some of these surveys and really looking at the the staff and the parent data um as we're as we're moving through this um so we asked five questions and allowed folks to provide some comments and we'll look at some of those but the first question we asked really kind of goes back to the

024idea of uh bringing your own device to school and that being an aid for Learning and so we asked how often are cell phones being used for schoolwork or for positive learning experiences um and you'll notice of the students that that filled out the survey um they're saying that they're not using it um or they're rarely using it for schoolwork um we asked parents um how often they believe that cell phones are being used for positive learning experiences and it seems uh parents believe that they're being used occasionally but not all the time and our staff um kind of has that same sentiment based on the results all right and then we asked um the the inverse of that um are how often are cell phones being used for nonacademic purposes um students are um

025responding at least those that responded to the survey that they're not using cell phones for schoolwork and they're also not using them for things that aren't school work so again we're taking we're taking the results as they came in um but um but parents parents believe that um students should um generally not be using their cell phones during the school day as relates to non-academic purposes um and then we ask staff how often they actually observe students using their cell phones for non-academic purposes okay so one is believe I'm sorry I one was believe and one was observed well I mean because a because a parent can't observe their student during the school day um you know using their cell phone but a staff member can so we wanted to ask these questions honestly so

026that we could get honest feedback as a parent they'll take it from their student oh I'm using my cell phone for this and that but you know it's going to be their perception um not as much of an observation for them um and so we had to we had to tailor those questions to those different demographics as we were asking them so for staff they're observing students um those that respond to the survey are observing students use their cell phones for non academic purposes um for the most part pretty frequently or sometimes I think go ahead and when I read that I think the important part of it too is that the parents the the should language as opposed to what is actually happening there was that's that's that's different too so yes actually yes

027it's the should I agree that um it's not what they're doing it's what they should be so sure well and it shows that there's a big dispar a big difference between what parents think their student should be doing versus what staff thinks is happening I mean that's a pretty big difference all right um we asked about social interactions because this um this question really kind of came out of some conversations that we had with parents in um our coffee chat sessions as well as um looking or asking staff members kind of what they feel like their um biggest concerns are and so we wanted to ask about um how they're noticing students behaving um in relation to cell phone use um we asked students how they feel that um using cell phones at school affects

028their social interactions with peers um for the most part neutral um but pretty even Distribution on the the answers for positive somewhat positive negative and somewhat negative uh parents are also of the understanding that their child's social interactions as relates to cell phone use is fairly neutral um but there's there's definitely a population of our parents that believe that students using cell phones during school time um is um can't can be promoting some negative behaviors and social interactions or affecting them negatively and then we asked staff how do they think uh cell phone use affect social interactions among students during the school day um a little over half that responded to the survey noted that it was negative um and then the the next largest um answer was somewhat negative all right and then we

029asked um about some of these concerns and again these these were from some responses that we had from parents and staff about um some of their concerns and so we wanted to provide them with some options to select um their concerns and then we also provided them with an opportunity to to fill out um any additional concerns that they may have students for the most part um parents and staff um feel like cell phon are a distraction um their main concern was that cell phones can be distracting and then the distribution for students um between cyber bullying and screen time was fairly um similar and uh screen time for staff and parents was was also a concern um for staff it seems like they're seeing cyber bullying also being a piece of that as well

030um these were these were really just the the most common things that were um written in the comments um students um had concerns about uh cell phones uh allowing other students or themselves to to be able to cheat on schoolwork um getting them in trouble and then across the board for student staff and parents decrease social interaction was was mentioned quite a bit these comments not multiple choice these were comments and then just we kind of just paired them down to make sure that it was ebly easily digestible for for a viewing audience and for yourselves um parents um lots of comments about exposure to inappropriate materials or things that they may not approve of or or they don't have control over what their students are doing or what other students may show them on

031an electronic device so that was a big concern of our parents and then staff most notably um wrote in the comments that um they were noticing that uh cell phones were causing trauma between students during the school day rumors fights those kinds of things okay Poli enforcement so we looked at the policy um we did want to know kind of what everyone's perception was of the policy and how well they feel like it's being enforced um for the most part across the board it's um it's understood that the policy is usually being enforced um with rarely being the the next highest um choice on there that was selected um across the board there and then we asked um just about the idea of cell phone potentially being restricted um further or or not restricted at

032all during the school day and so um for the most part not not a big consensus across the board here from our community um students and parents um both align with uh how the current policy is is currently written um as far as allowing students to be able to use their cell phones during the day bring them to school have them for academic purposes and then as the policy allows as it's written in the handbook for those designated break times like for lunch passing periods before and after school um those kinds of things staff were the were the only ones that uh highlighted that full restrictions would be supported um with a little less than half of the staff members that respond to the survey noting that there um and then we did uh provide

033an opportunity for people to leave additional comments just any thoughts or comments that they had about cell phone use during the school day um stud students and parents their their main comment that that they provided to us was that they would like to continue to have the ability to have a cell phone on campus in the event of emergency that that was the main comment that was provided students also mentioned that they do use their cell phones to access online resources um schooo was brought up quite a bit that students are using their phones to get online to access schoolo Agy um and then specifically at the high school level had a had a number of comments about students being able to communicate with each other for classwork as they're doing projects and things like

034that um parents and staff again more concerns written about distractions drama social media texting mental health was a big piece of this as well um and then with our staff um quite a few comments about other devices like headphones smart watches we did get um some feedback from our deic members and from our teacher advisory Council specifically about our younger students at the elementary and intermediate levels maybe not bringing a cell phone to school but having access to a different kind of device that allows them to communicate um one or two way to their parents allows them to text or call just those numbers or they do have some kind of Smartwatch that allows them to voice text or send their parents a voice memo and um those were brought up as well for consideration

035and so kind of our key takeways looking at the the data in the aggregate um generally students um are of the students that responded are saying that um cell phone used for academic and non-academic purposes tends to be nominal I will say too not a not a frequent comment but we did have quite a few again because the a lot of these kids were Intermediate kids that responded a lot of them um were saying they're not using a cell phone during the school school day because they don't have a cell phone um so again taking that as caveat to the data that we actually have um and then again distraction being the main concern across the board for our student staff and parents um parents believe or feel like cell phones should not be used

036often um in general um and a little more than half of those folks that responded uh would support a policy that allows phones for academics and during those designated break times um staff members that completed the survey observe cell phon being helpful for learning on occasion and observe frequent non-academic cell phone use um again concerns for distraction cyber bullying drama initiated by social media texting and a little less than half support restricting cell phone use completely while some would allow for academics only and so kind of looking at these takeaways as we discussed these um as a leadership team um because our community didn't have a general consensus here there's there's not really a recommendation we're moving forward with um um for any policy update at this time we'd like to take these uh data

037points and dig a little bit deeper with some of our campuses and get some more information about how how they're using the district policy to implement it at the campus level um lots of good Insight from our teacher advisory Council about how individual campuses are using the overall District policy to um either be more restrictive or provide a little bit more freedom depending on the the campus um but again because not we don't have a General consensus across the board here in the community um not not necessarily moving towards any recommended policy update at this time so um any questions comments journ discussion about cell phone news during school I have I'm not TR I formulate a specific question but because there is a lot to to um to take in I am very glad

038we uh did the survey and try to address the um because there are a lot of people on both sides of this issue we probably heard from we've heard from some of them um and also glad you point out it's it's unfortunate we didn't have more high school students respa it's almost like the student part it we really do have to take for the grain OFA salt for many reasons but also because they were there was just some intermediate and that's a different ulation um I mean to me the things that that um Stand Out is that all of them this thing was it's distracting and I think I mean I know it's distracting I have a up already and try everywh um but if you put the the staff that um that they think

039it's a negative for their they I mean I don't know if you want go back to that one about what do people they think is negative or not I mean you take negative at 50% and someone and somewhat negative at 34% how do you think cell phone use affects social interactions among students during the school day I mean that is that is huge to to me and um so in my mind that's kind of the big picture question is how because I think I I would agree with that um um how do you balance that then with some of the positive uses of the phones um and particularly yeah schoy I mean I think we have taught our kids over the last few years to you to use schooly and use use it in other

040ways um and but I I don't know and then I think the other thing is the the enforcement One stood out where was the enforcement question um I mean you pointed out for staff usually is a high point but so was rarely I you know the same so I think another thing that I hear is the consistency um I think we heard that in the teacher advisory Council as well that that so maybe there's not a recommendation for any change to our policy but I I would think um at a minimum consistency in my mind would be something that would be would be helpful um and again and I then my last one some other people speak is I you I put I mean I do care about what the parents think for sure um

041but as we talked about they're they don't see it in the classroom as much so I really put a lot of weight on what the the staff um says about this you know and how it's affecting not only the student learning but also you know just the student growth and and relationships and the that social part that you talked about so yeah basically a policy is only as good uh as those that are enforcing the policy so whatever is written on a piece of paper is there it's the staff it's the administrators that are enforcing the policy so you've got right now K through six really we don't we don't have any issues so it's functioning fine all three middle schools from my understanding are a little bit more restricted than the high school and

042all three administrators feel like that process is working so you have so many mixed reviews between teachers and a lot of our teachers I would say staff-wise a lot of them were probably are secondary because they deal more with cell phones than Elementary and intermediate uh it it is kind of split they can be restrictive right now in a classroom if you want to and so we have some classrooms that kids know you don't bring your cell phones you don't talk about it others cell phone is free reign so I think the next step for for us besides showing the data to our entire team is potentially our two high schools uh because from a different District level with all these mixed results basically you're back to square one because it's pretty much 50/50 on

043each side so if uh what I would like to see is our high schools sample their own students and their own uh staff members give that data and then their leadership teams decide if they get more restrictive or not and what that looks like because in the end if it's something that they took information from their campus on develop their protocol chances are it's going to be enacted and it's going to work uh otherwise it's us as big brother coming down telling them what they're going to do and nothing's going to change so I'd like for them to take that deeper dive and decide as a campus do they need to get more restrictive or things working the way they feel like they should be working I think the slide we haven't talked about that

044jumped out to me um is where it's talking about what how parents believe they're using cell phones versus let me see this one right here so this is how parents the way I'm reading it believe students should be using their cell phones versus what we see our staff are actually observing students using their cell phones so to me that says that what our parents are generally saying they believe isn't what's happening in the schools to me that just jumped out because that that says to me that we do have a discrepancy between what our parents might would think is right and what's really going on and how we solve that is for you know you guys to think about but um I see a lot of concerns when we have um parent and and the

045one about the concern there was one just called concerns um I mean parents do have some legitimate concerns or else the the blue high slice would be bigger and um obviously our staff a place where we feel like there are concerns with cell phones so um I know it's a really really complex issue to figure out the best way to do it um but anyway does it just looks like we still have some work to do no for sure and I think what we're giving you now is a big picture across the district over 4,000 responses so if you take those campus principles regardless of what level it doesn't matter to me decide to take that next step and I think it'd be good for them to to get their data zoned in to their

046kids their teachers their parents and then have a conversation of hey we think we want to explore change based on what what we Middle School folks have said then I think that's definitely a step in the right direction because you're probably going to come up uh with a new protocol that you have a shot to be successful because everybody kind of came to the table and read I think in the end no matter what I mean the nation's dealing with this every school district's dealing with it um my wife put it best to me I never thought of it this way when we were in school we went to school we got there you know at 8 then we got done at 4: and then extracurricular and then we went home and all the stuff

047that happened at school happened at school and it stayed at school because if someone called you they called you on the landline and maybe you had a conversation but you didn't have to deal with it until you got back there 12 hours later and and I didn't think of it that way and all cell phones do is give 24 hour access to kids all the time um my statements here are going to sound like we just need to cut cell phones out put them in bags magnetic bags whatever I I get it I can sit here and say that um I I think we have an issue just like everybody else it's one of those things we're going to have to work on um but as far as as parents knowing or believing what their

048kids are doing doing and this and that if you see your kid at home however they're acting on their phone is how they're acting on their phone at school I mean that's that's just my personal opinion um so that shouldn't be a shock but at the same time what our staff is seeing on that blue right there with frequently at 671 um I don't disagree with that um I I can probably guarantee it and um it's it's it's weird cuz on our policy also if you go back to that first slide we put this in in the teachers hands and that's the struggle and I get it and I I don't want them to have to do any more work in they are doing but um the the unfortunate piece and flip to the next

049one I'm sorry electronic devices are allowed for acceptable educational use before school during lunch and after school so long as use device do not interrupt the educational environment the the PE piece on this policy right here acceptable education use I promise you before school during lunch and after school ain't doing anything educational on that phone I that's just that's just where we're at and that's fine at this point there's only so much we can do like Tim said big brother we can only go so far at this point um it's one of those things we're just going to have to keep working on I love polling your high schools individually seeing what each campus looks like this is a big 20,000 30,000 Viewpoint I get it you bring it down to campus level I think

050you're going to get some info that's very good feedback then we can adjust for them so that makes sense now my biggest concern moving forward you know it's kind of like our legislative priorities that you guys adopted that we wanted more local control so a biggest concern moving forward is there's multiple bills that have been introduced at the legislative level none have been heard yet within the next four to five weeks they will be and so uh there's been some threats uh from the commissioner of Ed that cell phones restricted that concerns me from a standpoint of of now there's big brother coming down and we're having to Institute potentially a a new law with cell phones that we don't feel like fits our community and so that's when that becomes uh problematic of what

051that's going to look like but we're not going to borrow trouble we'll see what happens uh it won't change our approach and what we want to do um moving forward with some additional surveys to kind of dial in some results have we are there other similar districts our size that have implemented like full restrictions like do we have any of that data or think someone into play this year so it might be worth looking at to see if they had success yeah we have uh just anecdotal um information from districts around the state um for the most part reports at least on the administrative level have been that it's been helpful um to remove the distraction um uh again here in our community I think the results kind of show that the idea of having

052a cell phone at the school is helpful especially for our older kids when they're involved in extracurriculars or um you know they need to get in touch with their parents um I think that's a fact of our world today and I think that the the results here show that um but yeah we can definitely dig into some more specific information um yeah a lot of school districts made some significant changes this year and I think they they'll probably be digging into how affecting their outcomes and I'm sure we'll see some some results from that by the end of the school year yeah the surprise for us is some of the districts that we've looked at that had done surveys which is why we did one their survey results did not mirror our survey results they

053were very much uh 60 plus% against cell phone use from parents and staff ours were more closer to 50/50 even some were 70 plus% yes get R and so there was much more support to have kind of an ultimate B then our data that's obviously not what our parents want at least 50% of them don't so it's a little bit different well I think it might be helpful for us to if if we're going to reach out for other information and other surveys to be really specific about the type of cell phone you know uh policies we might be considering because I think it's different to say Hey you cannot bring a cell phone on campus a parent would feel one way about that versus you cannot have that cell phone on during school hours

054in a case of an emergency they're going to flip that phone on and call their parents you know um they can turn it on as soon as the bell rings and see if their parent has said hey after school you're doing this instead of this so it could also be that that just maybe some more specific directions on what parents are thinking too because I look at I would look at that as a parent in two very different ways yes and I want to be extremely clear in black and white we are not exploring any policy where students would not be able to bring a cell phone on campus none at all that's not even up for discussion yeah because I would follow on on two things one I like when you pointed out um

055again that slide about what the parent think it or believe is going on so to to see those numbers what that are 70% believe um either nearly never or rarely should be used right that was almost all and then to follow that back up um and and I and again I'm not sure if it should be used or are they thinking they're not using them um and then not want to restrict them more the other so I I'm like I'm not sure I'm I'm aligning those those two their answers there right they're saying they never should be used or or rarely used and um but I I think your point is is right that it's it's um we're not saying nobody hears the proposing yet no phones it's just really how do we restrict them

056and limit the those dis or how we could possibly and limit distractions and have kids focus on academics and the other thing I wanted to make and is kind of a little bit to your point Jeff on looking at the policy um and this is a question too I think some of the research out there outside of just um limiting phone is when do what what age do student does this most impact students I mean at least some of the things that I've seen it's not your Juniors and seniors they're maybe maybe learning how to um handle things better maybe um it's those it's those middle younger grades maybe it is the fifth sixth seventh and eth and um so I just think understanding and differentiating like we do in our policy but really understanding

057the different needs that the different ages is is still really critical to you I'll I'll just ch in here and uh try not to talk too much because I'm getting my voice back but um and I I'll start by saying I'm coming from this the Paradigm of of the the research that I've looked into that this is a major problem whether the the the kids I I appreciate us getting their opinion but if you if you look at cell phones it's almost like a drug and if you ask or an alcohol if you ask somebody they have an alcohol problem even if they do they're going to say no so looking at what the teachers and the staff are seeing at the campuses I think is the most important thing to do um so that

058being said I'll also say that I come from this little Paradigm of as a school board as a school administrators so often we are reacting to what higher levels of government require or mandates that are put on to us and this is an opportunity I think especially if we have a situation like this where you've got and again I I kind of interpreted Austin some of this a little bit differently than you did I I saw it and again maybe it's just more my Paradigm I'm looking at this at it's a lot more negative uh but this 50/50 split that this is a really an opportunity for for us as a school board to actually take a lead on this issue and the administration and and not necessarily just follow what the kids want or

059the staff wants what is actually best for our school district and our students um and so I think looking at and many of y'all Dr hark Ryder and some of other folks have mentioned the idea of you know grade specific campus specific um that that's probably the the best way to go about doing it so I I appreciate yall trying to kind of look at it from from that Viewpoint um but it it's it's something that I think we need to change whether whatever that might be um again you you are looking into it more and talking to the the campus folks is a good idea but uh I I would just urge you know I've got potentially you know less than a year left on the board and to not let this die because

060it's just that important and I think as far as col station ISD and doing its little part to to help the Next Generation because um we've got a mental health crisis out there and some of the research puts a lot of in on these things that we carry around each day anything else I I can't I I need to add that I do support that and not letting this this end as this needy gr I think there is certainly more to continue to learn about it there is more and more research happening and if um and then there's more of for us to learn throughout our own um District too so all right it was a lot easier when I just have to worry about staying out of my s's office you never did before

061I was thinking about that the other day I was like we don't have other there's not pay phones so yeah so you can't just you can't just say hey no phones Because unless we it's it's it's crazy all right that'll bring us to a journ and we'll see yall here in minutes

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.