CorpusRecord 149731

Crystal City ISD Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CrystalCity ISD
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Zavala County, TX
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,916 words · about 44 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001788 uh [Music] 39 first thing on the agenda is just the honor uh roll call Victor president pres Mr Vince M here Mrs Peggy Young oh I am here Mr s Houston absent and Mr Gabriel esposa yeah okay item number three uh moment of reflection what time did we call the meeting to order sir3 I mean 5:30 number four uh audience the patrons don't have any okay item number five uh action out of May discussion action to approve the district's annual financial report for the uh 2023 24 school year ending in August 31 uh 2024 the this Mr Eid will and Mr Solomon will present uh our annual financial report good afternoon have a copy of the audit report in front of you will turn to page three this is a certificate of the board

002where the board will Le the need to approve or disapprove this audit tonight turning to page five this is your audit opinion you received modified opinion that in our opinion the financial statements are presented fairly and Conformity with General accepted accounting principles as of the end yes sir can you uh just have Mr hon settled now he just came in so that he can follow us okay I'm sorry he'll turn to page five sir thank you this is our opinion this is our opinion that in in our opinion the financial statements are presented fairly in Conformity with General accepted accounting principles as of August 31st 2024 starting on page eight is the management discussion and Analysis this is the same information that's presented in the body of the financial statements but it's presented in a

003graphical and narrative format as we go through here you'll see we have condensed comparisons to Prior years we have pie charts of your revenues and expenditures again this is the same information but it's just presented in a different manner the body of the financial statement start on page 16 on page 16 this is the statement of net position this takes all of the funds of the uh school district and presents them all together under the full acral method of accounting uh you normally keep your books and Records on the modified acral method accounting and then we're required by General accepted accounting principles to convert them to full acral method of accounting for these two two first schedules uh this is a good schedule because it shows uh all of your assets uh your your Capital

004assets net of uh depreciation plus it shows all of your uh liabilities for your pensions and other post employment benefits it also shows our bonds and our other debt that's required so going down this page the top part of our page is assets the middle is are deferred inflow outflows of resources uh then we have our liabilities and then deferred inflows and then our net position at the bottom of the page our total assets in the end of the year this is this is this is districtwide under the full acral method of accounting was 55 mil 827 you can see that we had uh top part we go from the liquid uh assets to the to the less liquid so we had cash of 2.5 million our property taxes at the end of the year

005uh 2.3 million net of an allowance for doubtful accounts of$ 279,000 uh we had some due to other governments some small assets and then we get into our Capital assets we have had uh land of 92,000 buildings net of depreciation of$ 4.7 $47 million we had furniture and fixtures net of depreciation at 2.4 million and then we had Construction in progress at the end of the year of 425,000 again total assets 55 m8270 end of the year though sounds like January that just happened this end of the year is our end of the year which is August 31st and again this combines everything all of our different funds and all of our different Holdings so for example when you see buildings that's not what the building is worth that's what we paid those were our

006out of Pock what our out of pocket cost either to acquire or construct uh do we have any questions from the board was he going a little bit fast than that we have a couple of board members that are new and uh uh I want to make sure uh as we go through it we get into the fund statements that you are normally used to seeing I'll try to slow it down but this is I'm not going to say it's information you don't have in control but like when we get into our pensions which well just in case I mean somebody has some questions let me if you do please stop me if you have a question like when we get into our deferred outflows these this is basically dealing with our part of that

007the 695 was our deferred charge on refunding our debt that happened many years ago and we're advertising that over the life of that loan however those big items there are the 3.6 million deferred outflows for pension and the other post-employment benefits this is information that basically comes to us straight from uh teacher retirement system it's information that really you have no control over we just get that information and required to drop it into your financial statements you'll also see later on we'll get out you have some pretty good siiz liabilities for that again this is something you have no control over the things that you do will go on down to the Li abilities we had a little bit of accounts payable bills that were incurred but not paid until after the end of your

008fiscal year of $90,000 uh other large items we had acrude wages payable because at the end of the year uh we school starts uh earlier than August 31st so we have some uh wages that are are accured but not paid until in the next fiscal year so we acrew those and expense those to get a good cut off between what actually happened in this current year we get into some of the larger items under the non-current we have uh $2.3 Million worth of loans and leases that are payable in the in the next year again we'll see a note on this later on that'll show you a detail of those we have total notes and uh bonds and notes and leases at the end of the year longterm of 33,2 45 33 million yeah 33

009million that's a little different we also had uh a discount on our bonds of 2 2.1 million that again is being advertised just like the Deferred charge is over the life of those bonds and you'll get expensed that uh every a little bit every year then the the the big items the 10 million and the 4.5 million for uh pension and O other post-employment benefits liabilities that's what I was talking about earlier uh those are or your share of if everyone was to retire what the school district would have to pay this is a large number it's no different for any other entity uh uh when uh the governmental Accounting Standards Board required us to start putting the pension liability and the other post employment benefit liability almost every school district in the state of

010Texas every city came up with a negative uh net position uh net assets because of this so you're no different uh this is just your share of that liability uh also we get into the Deferred inflow of resources this is the same information this is this is just information that comes to us from uh the the TRS and we're required to drop that information in when we look at our net position we had $13 million that was invested in capital assets net of debt we had $643,000 that was restricted for uh federal and state programs $3.6 million it was restricted for for Debt Service uh 1,222 it was restricted for Capital uh projects and then we had an unrestricted net assets of a negative 15, 451 I want to skip the the next page because

011I think we'll see it uh a little bit more what you're normally used to seeing on page 18 and 19 this is the balance sheet for the various different governmental funds that you you're in what page 18 19 what page page 18 and 19 we have uh four funds we have the general fund the special Revenue fund The Debt Service fund and the capital projects fund and then we're got a total of all those on the far right hand side of the page under the total governmental funds follows the same format we have our assets at the top of the page our liabilities and deferred inflows at the middle and then our fund balances at the end so going down the JN fund column number 10 you can see that we had total assets in

012the J fund at the end of the year of 2,685 864 we had a negative cash amount of $371,000 we had property taxes that uh for property taxes that had been assessed for all years and not collected at the end of the year of $1.7 million we have an allowance for some that we think are not collectible uh you Norm nor will collect all of your property taxes because eventually those property taxes will be sold uh if someone doesn't pay for their property taxes however there is a certain amount for business property taxes where people have uh you know have to pay tax on say their furniture and fixtures of their their businesses and sometimes you will never collect those because if that uh business goes out of business and leaves town uh there's no

013assets for the the appraisal district to come in and sued yet so we do have an allowance but for most of the part all of your real estate taxes eventually when that property changes hands uh there's a lean attached to it so you will get that money eventually uh we have an amount it's due from our other governments of $24,000 uh the general fund has a due from other funds of $1.3 million uh again total assets $2.6 million not the world page 18 liabilities of the general fund we had $2.5 Million worth of liabilities accounts payable at the end of the year again bills that were incurred but not paid until after the end of the fiscal year of 90,000 we had again acred wages for the general fund of $75,000 and we had due

014to other funds and we'll see some breakdowns of these later on in our notes of $1.4 million a little bit of recruit expenses and then the the unearned revenue of 2.68 which is amounts that uh will we receive from the state but we will uh we will report those as revenues in future years and then the unavailable revenues for property tax is 1.5 million if you'll notice that is the offset to our property taxes minus our un un uh uncollected uh allowance for uncollected taxes so if you take the 17 million and subtract the 206 off of that that's going to get back to that 1.5 million unavailable property taxes we subtract our our liabilities and our deferred inflows from our assets at the end of the year we had a negative fund balance in

015the general fund of 1,374 502 special Revenue fund uh we had total assets of 44 44651 uh again we had a a negative cash in the in the uh special Revenue fund of 169,000 however we had a $214,000 that is a receivable from the state or federal governments that should be coming in probably already has come in but at the end of the year uh they still owed us money so that's why uh we're just our assets are 44,000 but we have an amount that's due to us from other governments we also had a little bit of account payable at the end of the year and a little bit of uh approved expenses so our liabilities were 51,70288 mil 227 uh we had 2.2 million dollar worth of cash at the end of the year

016had the same thing with our property taxes but these are property taxes that were uh specifically levied for The Debt Service program uh 515,000 with allowance for uncollectibles of 72,000 we also have a due from other funds of $1.4 million giving us total assets 4 milon1 22787 we have the same unavailable revenues for property taxes like we did in the general fund this is $543,000 so when we subtract those from our assets we have a fund balance in The Debt Service fund all of which is restricted and cannot be used for anything other than retirement of long-term debt of $3.6 million capital projects funds you close this Pro uh this fund out however we had a little bit of interest that came in after we closed it out so we still have a, 22 $222

017in that fund I guess now is a good the time as any to talk about this uh you know we have negative fund balances in our general fund um this is a violation of uh the state law uh we have uh negative fund balances U several other funds we'll see later on also the big issue that we have is we borred money from our debt service fund which is a violation of federal law state law I'm sorry um so I'm probably not telling you anything don't already know but we have we we you'll see later on where we were required to to spell this out uh if you will turn to page 22 and 23 this is your schedule statement of revenues expenditures and changes in fund box we have our same uh four funds

018across the top of the page uh and then the top is our revenues then the middle is our expenditures then we have our other financing sources and use and then finally our change in fund balance and what our fund balance is going down the general fund we have total revenues uh for the year ending August 31st 2024 of 19 milion 985 you can see that 10 10 million 8 came from our local basically most of that was your property taxes we had state revenue of 7.3 million and then Federal revenues of 1.4 million our expenditure in the general fund were 29 million 39 314 uh you can see the breakdown between instructional at the top which is where the majority of your expense is $13 million on down uh we've had a significant amount of

019plant maintenance towards the the middle of the page we had uh $4 million worth of PL plant maintenance this year uh so again our total expenditures 29 milon 314 we subtract our uh our expenses from our revenues we had excess expenditures in the general fund of 9 million 650,000 51 we had uh $2 million that was transferred in from other funds we had $783,000 that was transferred out to other funds which we'll see a little bit a breakdown of this later on so after the transfers we actually had a decrease in our fund balance for the year in the general fund of 8,302 873 we started out the beginning of the year with a $6.9 million fund balance so therefore we have a negative fund balance of 1,374 525 one thing about that column believe

020correct me if I'm wrong in this case general fund includes the Child Nutrition fund along with your there the two you can't separate them because they're in this statement they're required to be combined together so you a years ago and I don't know how this happened but you're allowed ta will let you either account for your child of nutrition program in the general fund or as a special Revenue fund and years ago it was decided you know before we even came on board that it would be included in the general fund so most of the money in the federal program revenue is the child the various Child Nutrition programs and you'll see on the expenditures 35 Food Service most of that is the cost of the food service program question these are all actual expens

021expenses right we done yes the special Revenue fund again like uh M solman said this is everything with the exception of the child of nut nutrition program uh we have total revenues of 3, 59,6 79 uh our expenditures were 3,99 we would expect these to be equal out that's the normal of the way that the federal program work uh usually you spend the money in advance uh ask for reimbursement from the the the state through for the federal programs and then they reimburse you uh so normally we're used to seeing these basically you know if you you know your expenditures and your Revenue should balance out to zero we did have a excess uh we do have some uh and that's the way it is with all of your federal programs we do have some

022state federal uh State special Revenue funds in here and that's why we come up with the negative fund balance on those because we actually spent more money in those than we actually receive what happens uh if uh youc you allocated so much money uh in federal funds or and you sometimes you don't spend it all and then the one year you apply for the same correct and if you I this is outside my area but I think if you don't spend it all a lot of times those funds will roll forward to the next year because a lot of these programs they don't they don't just end on August 31st they cover uh a a different period so you have the opportunity to still spend those funds if they've been allocated and budgeted to you

023uh you can spend them in the next fiscal year even though that's for this 2023 project years am I correct well so it's backwards from the way you would normally think of it yeah we spend the money first and then we get paid for it so we have to put lay the money out and then the other thing is our fiscal year ends August 31st for most of these These are grants most of the grant programs they end on September 30th so that's a month later so that could be why we have a negative fund balance because sometime in September we asked for that extra money and it came in in September because we were still in the grant year so we will set those up receivables usually to I remember last year or the

024year before you told us that uh the the K program falls under fiddle funds or state funds what's that rear in technology no I think what what you're referring to is you did not spend your allocated allotment from TAA and there are certain uh areas that they require you when they give you your your lump suum of of state fundings they're requiring you to spend a certain amount of it in specific are 55% but are you going to spend it like like I I remember at that time you told us that we had under in 241,000 probably in the career I think this year we only got about 52,000 was it because we didn't spent right we got because but you still spent that money you received you just did not spend it on career

025and Technology uh in the in the federal program side of this uh like I said you you are you when you do your budgets to the for a federal program you tell them this is what we want and they will allocate that much to you again if you don't spend that within the the Year you still can can spend that because that program in the Federal's eyes has not shut down so uh I think in my I don't believe you're ever leaving any of those Federal programs on on the table no yeah so just so you're talking about something completely different than Federal programs what normally happens in the federal programs is the federal government let's say title one they tell tea you're going to be the grant administrator and the last thing ta wants

026to do is return funds so you go through the year and let's say you and I'm make up numbers you get $10 for title one and you spend $9 at the end of the Year ta does not want to write a check back to the federal government for the $1 you didn't spend so they'll usually go ahead and get permission and tell you we're going to roll your dollar over into the next year and you'll be notified of that not before the year ends but at some point after and that's how they do it because they don't want to they get the money they just haven't given it us they don't want to return it now while we're talking about federal funds one of the things the problem that we have is when they give

027you this money they're going to say okay we're going to give you $10 but we're going to let you use 50 cents of this per indirect cost overhead for running this program for us we're going to give you 50 cents in the past the district has used that full 10 for funding the program and not taking that 10% back to the general fund is indirect cost so puts it into the into a different column right so you know it's again the money is all being spent it's just that that uh and and in your case you know your school wide so you're going to have that say that teacher in there whether it's paid out of the the the federal funds or out of you personally out of the general fund really doesn't matter for

028title one but you're you are allowed to take those indirect costs back to the general fund to cost to cover overhead uh the the next column on page 23 is our Debt Service uh fund we had total revenues of $4.5 million most all of that comes from our uh our local taxes uh our expenditures for our Deb service 2.6 million uh we had 2.2 million that was for our our principal on our debt service and then we had 1.4 million for interest e legal uh the only problem is that we left about $1,000 we didn't we got some more interest so again uh there would be nothing wrong uh since we don't have this capital projects fund anymore for transferring that, 22 out uh and making sure that it's in non-interest bearing account for a

029little while so we can zero it out if you'll turn to page 25 uh this is the the statement of net position for the proprietary fund we have a uh self- Insurance Fund and that's what this is this is uh these proprietary funds are for uh we had a total assets at the end of the year of $882,000 we had an amount that was due to the general fund of $1.3 million and because of that large uh payable back to the general fund we resulted in a negative net position in our uh our Fu uh proprietary funds again this is another violation of of uh the state law you can have negative fund balances in any fund we'll turn to page 26 this shows where our uh revenues expenditures and changes in net position for

030the proprietary fund you can see that we brought in $2.8 Million worth of Revenue uh we spent uh 3.6 so we had a uh operating loss in our proprietary fund of $565,000 however the big problem was we transferred a whole bunch of money out of this fund we transferred uh uh and and that's a that's a typo because we had uh the second line there should be transfer out not two transfers in so we had a uh a total transfer out and a decrease in our uh operating income of 1 m183 resulting in our uh negative net position of $417,000 starting on page I'm let's go to page 28 uh this is the producing funds these are funds that don't belong to the school these are mainly your your school activity funds however we're required

031to account for these and present them this is money that is not the school's money it is the the various different classes uh cheerleaders whatever but of that we had uh $96,000 at the end of the year we had $680,000 that was due to other funds and then we have $889,000 worth the fund balance the next page you can see that we brought in $135 $334,000 in from our uh various different uh uh funds uh stud Student Activities you know your cheerleaders your class funds Etc they also spent $150,000 of their funds so they had a decrease in their uh net position of $115,000 however they had 5,000 there to start with so we have $889,000 left again that is mainly there just for presentation purposes and it's required by TAA but again these are

032not school funds starting on page 30 are the notes to the financial statements these are the notes that are required by General accepted accounting principles these notes get longer and longer every year uh one of the parts I would like to point out to you if you will turn to page 38 this is a schedule of inter fund payables top part of our in fund payables the bottom is our in fund transfers so this shows you that we in the in the uh general fund that we transferred uh 101.3 million in from other funds uh or out to other funds I I'm sorry we transferred in and this is the big one you look up there at the Debt Service fund we transferred in uh $1.4 million in from The Debt Service fund and that

033was your big big problem doing that uh I don't know I'm I'm pretty sure that net amount is a lot higher than that right now because I think this was just this is just as of August 31st but uh it's my understanding that amount is a lot higher now again these numbers are as of August 31st 2024 uh on page uh 39 this is the capital asset activity shows what happened during the year in our Capital asset activity and you know again the the increases which start out with our beginning F beginning balances and our various different types of of act uh assets and then our increases or decreases for the year in the ending so the main thing I'd like to point out is you know we spent $1.5 million on uh on asset

034plus we have $425,000 that was in capital uh Construction in progress mainly on the I believe it is the the stadium improvements and things like that uh so you know even though we had a we were in a pretty bad financial shape we spent over $2 million on Capital asset activities here if you'll turn to page 40 this is the the changes in Long debt it shows what our our various different long-term debts were at the beginning of the year what our increases were our decreases in our ending balance and then the amounts that are due within one year so uh the main thing I'd like to point out here is that you know we paid down we're we're still making payments on our note as of the end of August 31st uh we we

035uh are cranking those out and if you'll turn to page 41 this shows what we're going to have to pay in the future years uh so in 2025 we'll have to pay 2.3 million for for principal and 1.4 million for for debt so that is what The Debt Service fund is set up to do is to make these payments there's a lot of these notes in here that are dealing with your your uh pension plan and your other post employment benefits again this is information that basically you have no control over it's just lifted straight out of uh uh the the uh teacher retirement system and then we we place that in there as required um let's move over to page 52 we're required to report that you know any kind of budget variances that

036you have and we'll see this a little bit later on but basically you have negative budget variances in every function in your general fund uh they were all uh negative variances we also o had negative variance in the child and nutrition program so that's just specifying there what's going on Note number s on page 53 I can just make a note about the so normally the unfavorable budget variance that is as you started the year and you passed a budget I'm not sure I wasn't here during the year whether there were any budget amendments passed during the year but traditionally as you get towards the end of the year because you now have whole you know 10 months 11 months of actual Administration would normally come to the board and ask for a budget amendment

037to make sure you don't have a giant variance you don't you and in the business World a lot of times you'll you'll have a budget that's your budget if you miss you miss but for schools no you can't miss you got to have a positive number there so best practi is come the 10th month the 11th month where you have a pretty good idea of where you're going to land at the end of the year and you would do a budget amendment to adjust each one of these items to what you think is you're going to actually land at e you said we were negative in our TR in our food service program corre and we'll look at that in just a minute let's on that thought because we'll look that in detail this is

038just where we're required see that in detail also on page 53 uh is where we basically are telling the leers financial statements that you used 1,418 th000 out of the uh bar it from The Debt Service fund which uh again was is not you know uh a legal thing to do so that you will uh be needing to replenish that in the future there is an error here because I was under the assumption that you had already declared the the financial exellency as that the way you say it U Apparently that is not a saw or um I was under the impression that it was this was done back in December so before we send this into tea I'd like to get that corrected because that that's not the truth uh doesn't this have to

039be in tomorrow yes there's no problem I can get that corrected really fast uh but need to go into is like a pdf version so he just needs to type the correction right uh also again we have here that you know the decre you know the decreases in fund balance you know the had a decrease in the general fund balance of $8.3 million and a decrease of $1.8 million in the internal Services fund and as a result of this we came up with our negative fund balance of 1,374 in the general fund and 417 in the C in the internal Services fund uh one of the things that we have to uh assess is whether the district has the ability to uh be a going concern which means that you can stay open for the

040next 12 months and from what we were told by management you know you have things in place and so we we were able to assess that it's probable that this will happen so that's that's what basically that not is say now let's turn to page 56 this is the general fund like we looked at before but this time we're comparing it to your budget uh follows the same format we have the revenues expenditures the middle of the page financing resources in the towards the bottom and then the we have our original the final amended budget and then what the actual was for the year on the on the page 57 and then the far right hand is a comparison between that actual amount and our uh final amended budget and I'm going to say right

041now that your budget was pretty much a mess um included in your general fund budget was The Debt Service Revenue words that amount so your revenues were a budgeted revenues were overinflated by the amount of The Debt Service fund revenues however the expenditures were not so it was a a Mis misleading budget to begin with and we'll see that when we look at The Debt Service fund so that's part of our problem because we have you know TW 25 M million budgeted for revenues however our actual revenues were only1 19 million so we have an unfavorable budget variance in our Revenue size of $5,500,000 now that's not all of our problem because our debt service will actual was only 4 4.5 million so there's still a million dollar variance in our revenues between what we

042anticipated bringing in and what we actually did but when we get into our expenses that's where it really falls off the rails because we had anticipated that we were going to spend 8,580 we actually spent 29 milon 314 so we had a total unfavorable budget variance in our expenditures of $1,805 and that's you know and you'll see later on we we we we put this in as an internal control problem because uh there was you know you as a someone should have been seeing this and knowing that we had a problem uh and uh it I don't know when it finally came to the attention of someone and start started looking into this but uh this went on for a long time before anyone ever realized we had a problem and as a result I

043think there were some uh discretionary spending that was made you know that that might not have been done had you had good records U and so again you know I don't want to beat a dead horse but that's you know that's the fact that I think that you're you're trying to to make steps to or you have made steps to try to move so we can get away from that we had a budget that said that we were going to have a increase in our fund balance of $6.6 million that's what we had budgeted for we said that we were going to actually bring in uh bring in $6.6 million more than we brought in where we actually our our our total budget variance between what we actually thought and what actually happened was $16

044million so that's you know again that's that's the main thing is this is this is a a you know someone was not looking at these numbers and giving you as a board you know good information to know how to start adapting to what the situation was if you will turn we're going to skip a couple of pages and go into uh fact I'm G let's go straight to your budgets on the child of nutrition program if you'll look at pay age 66 and 67 this is your Child Nutrition program again follows the same format we have our budg original budget our final amended budget and then what our is and the difference between the a variance between those two amounts and even in Your Child Nutrition program we had anticipated that we were going to

045bring in 1.7 million we actually only brought in 1.5 milon so we have an unfavorable budget variance there of 177,000 on our Revenue side on the expenses we had anticipated that we were going to spend 1.5 million we actually spent 1.9 million so we have a $41,000 uh unfavorable budget varant in our expenses so when you total it all together we we had had a budget that said we were going to have an increase in our fund balance of $180,000 uh however you know it actually came in with a $398,000 loss so there's a total budget variance there of 700 uh $578,000 I I thought Food Service paid its way not necessarily but uh again my point I keep trying to harp to is you have to have good numbers to know and there's other

046other things that we'll get into later on that that that I'll tell you that you know showed me that you weren't having good num to deal with The Debt Service fund this is one I guess other than the fact that you Bor from it it's it's a a positive other than the fact again that we didn't budget for it if you look up there at the top on the on the page 68 we don't have any budgeted revenues in this fund you know they were they were just budgeted for in the general fund by mistake and again I can't tell you why that was or what happened there but um you know we did have a budget for our expenses so you know you had budgeted according to your budget you said we're going to

047not have any revenues coming in but we actually did have $4.5 million came in so again this cames in with a positive variance there are 4.5 million again I want to point out that wasn't enough to cover what you lost in the general fund because even if we did put those numbers over in the general fund you still would have had over a million dollars less Revenue in that fund the expenses uh pretty much came in it was just a different allocation between principal and interest but in total uh we had a $10,000 favorable budget PS there we did transfer money in uh and again I don't know why that transfer in was done from the general fund there was $83,000 transferred in from the general fund so at the end of the year the

048The Debt Service fund has $3.6 million which is you know when you consider that you getting 4.5 assuming that next year's taxes 2025 taxes were comparable we still have good funds to to to pay our debt with but we might not have the cash because we're reiring the cash to put into the general fund so that's something that you need to monitor to make sure that you know we have a plan to get this cash in back into The Debt Service fund fortunately probably with the the the current year taxes is probably enough to cover your debt service without even any fund balance again I haven't got into that deep into it but again that's something that you know staff needs to monitor that to make sure that we do have the cash to make

049our debt payment just as a point of reference on this this was we we had a balance in that account of $3.6 million August 31st that's after we had made all of our required principal and interest payments then the year starts over we collect tax taxes we'll make payments in February payments in August with what comes in this year plus whatever we have however I'll caution you on that is even though just because you have a fund balance doesn't mean you have the cash no because part of that cash was used to spend to to to to loan to the general fund for example at the end of the year you had $2.2 Million worth of cash even though your fund balance was uh 3.6 million if you will turn to page uh 73 uh

050because you receive more than $750,000 worth of federal uh funds we're required to do what's called a single audit which means that we have to uh do some extens some more test on your federal program one of those is to uh assess your internal control and compliance uh overall and that's what this opinion is on page 73 and 74 and I would like to draw your attention to the last paragraph uh it says we did unidentify deficiencies in your internal control uh that are in theany finding question call so we're going to look at that a little bit differently uh also the next page uh under compliance uh we did have uh of those four items three of those were compliance issues that were going to be reported on in our findings and question cost

051which we'll see a minute page 75 this is our uh report on internal controls and compliance only with your major federal programs we're required to pick a federal program that will meet our the the satisfy that it is high enough to meet as a major major program we go in and do more extensive test on that particular program and in this case we our major programs were your title one uh and also still our covid-19 erra funds that we have left we have still programs that we did on and in those instances we found no instances of non-compliance in those programs now turning to page 78 our schedule of findings and question cost uh some of the things that I point out that are different than in the past if you'll look under uh the

052summary of auditor results at the top of the page we did disclose that we did have significant deficiencies in internal controls uh then starting on page 79 uh this shows our findings and uh the the first finding is basically uh we had I believe it was 53 different journal entries that we had to make at the end of the year and because of these journal entries you know you're most of them were in your federal programs I will have to say that too uh along with the budgets that we saw earlier this is an indication that you know we have poor interal control them uh we expect some Journal I'll give you right I mean nobody's perfect and we're we're picky we come in and we make we want things mov around but to have

053this level of journal entries that tells us that there is a lack of internal controls you Auditors are not supposed to come in and just you know fix your books your books are supposed to be in auditable shape when we get them and they work so that's what this uh uh finding is uh you have anything to say about that well just in summary I mean there there are four findings none of them were ones that I think going into this process that were unexpected Ed they things that we've talked about openly amongst you know at previous board meetings we did discuss earlier the negative fund balances that you had uh negative fund balances in the general fund special Revenue fund and the internal service fund which are a violation of State LA next page

054under page 80 uh budgetary compliance you know you're supposed to have a budget and that budget is supposed to be relatively accurate uh you know the fact that you know I I did point out there that your general fund uh Appropriations exceeded the the actual amounts by 10 Milli 805 which is 58% you know that's you know to have 58% you spent 58% more than you really thought you would and that's just uh like say someone is I mean that that should have been a red flag for somebody early early on you know cuz I guarantee this didn't happen right there at the end of the year so again to have that level of journaling uh of budget compliance issues again every we saw earlier every function in your general fund you know was what

055had budget Rance every function in your special in your your child and nutrition had a negative budget VAR there so uh these are are major concerns for us and then the last one again is dealing with The Debt Service fund foring The Debt Service fund Debt Service funds are strictly to be used for Debt Service and Debt Service only now once you get your bonds paid off if there's money there you can move it wherever you want to but until those bonds are paid off any money that comes in has to be spent for Debt Service nothing else um and I'm sure you know this you I think you have already self-reported this to TVA am I am I wrong on that yeah it's it's it's not something that they don't know about but you'll

056probably be hearing from them if you haven't already and then on page 82 and 83 This is information that uh was received from the school district of what they're planning to do about this mainly that you know we've you know for years we've been telling you that we uh you know we recommended that you hire a fulltime business manager uh and I hate to say it but I think you see why we were were so insistent on that uh nothing against Consultants but uh there's a lot can be said for having someone in house day to day that sees this and can devote 100% to it so that's a help I I I believe that you know again we've contracted with someone to come in and help uh I don't know what Mr Kim's uh

057uh responsibilities are but you know you're you're taking action on that but it's it's going to a hard go I'm not going to sugar coat it I mean it's just like you know example I got in trouble with credit card debt early on in my life and you know uh it takes a long time to get out from from doing that so it's it's the same thing with the school district uh because not only do you have to balance your income and expenses in the current year but You' got to make money to make up for what you've done in the past so it's going to be a tough road for you starting on page 84 and 85 this is the schedule of exp of federal Awards this shows the various different Federal programs that

058we did receive money for or spent on uh and our total federal expenditures were uh 4,272 again that's going through it pretty fast uh inside your audit report the very first uh page there should be some some individual here and this is the first one the one I'd like to discuss is start as part of our engagement U basically this is our management letter to you it's basically just going over the same information we talked about I mean we we've gone over all this before but we had you know it it's kind of goes more into detail of what our problems were uh with the federal funds uh we had you know a large number of adjusting entries of course the negative fund balances and and the budget fances and all funds and then our

059uh debt problem so again we're required to present this and this letter will have to go to te also to so um questions got a question P go that you did you get an answer oh yeah Mr M I guess um typically the budget Varian is when would they start putting botus like during the actual year I mean at what point would would you say if you want the legal answer you're not supposed to spend anything unless there's a budget there so you know the main thing is we had a terrible unrealistic budget to be with and I remember sitting here last year when I was with you say the same and I was telling you that you know you had received over $8 million in the past two years from uh Esser money and

060that all my other school districts were increasing their fund balances and that you had a decrease in your fund balance but at the time you had a balanced budget for next year and I remember telling you that you know I don't know if those numbers are correct but you know if that's the case more prior to you but apparently you were given some bad information I would I would say Mr Martinez in terms different parts of the budget you'll start to know at different times of the year so the revenue you'll know like tax revenue you'll start to get information once you get into October um before that you're sort of you're there's some element of your guesstimating majority of your tax revenue is in by this point in time so if you haven't made

061your tax revenue you're not going to uh you know you can count this point end of January you can count on your your payroll being relatively equal in my opinion you know it's it's pretty much a a 12 12th every every month you know is what you can count on again you had a lot lot of big projects uh you know we U you know had a lot of building projects there uh I think there were some still in process that you haven't been able to fulfill but again you know as a a business manager you shouldn't be spending that money until you come to the board first and say hey board we don't have this money what do you want to do about it do you want to you know so that again those

062those numbers should have been known by someone within the organization and we are working on a budget amendment for this year to come back board in February and correct last year's budget because again the budget that's been adopted for the year that we're operating on is again a balanced budget but it was created in the same manner as last year's budget so in your audit it doesn't say who exactly I mean where exactly um like for instruction we spent $2.1 million more than what we should have um does it say how we did won't say that now I could sign that information for you or your your staff could but um I again I'm sorry I didn't do that the fixed asset P part of this audit but if I did I could give you

063those numbers exactly I do know that the 4.25 425 million that's in Construction in progress was for 425,000 425,000 I'm sorry that was for the uh improvements at the the field um I think that there was there's another scoreboard I think we had a a pretty sizable amount for scoreboard another big I do remember this that you spent a lot of money for bat remediation yes I believe there was like over 200 to $300,000 that was spent to remove bats where those were I don't know but there was a not an instruction well that's a necessity the other ones were bad recommendations to us the fence was another one that and that and that one hits a lot of our school districts this last year because there's a lot of this safety stuff because of

064our EV Val shooting that you know no telling how much that has cost the state of Texas school districts and the state doesn't just open up their fair share of that either that's exactly what I was going to say I mean mated that we it's an unfunded mandate yes State the uh things that we need to do and they told us you got a Securities officers fense this that we never got a hardly any mean that's that's we're seeing that over all of our school districts they're you know that the unfunded safety part of I would just say just in terms of like where was the variance there it was all over the place and it's really hard to to nail it down and go well it was this and we could tease it out

065and give you if you really wanted information like why did we miss on instruction by $2 million how much of that was payroll how much of that was non-payroll we could give you that information in the end it's it's in the past and I think as you said he was surprised going to laugh into the budget that that you're looking at that had variances that it was projected to be balanced in the first place and it's it's not surprising that we missed it's the magnitude that's that's what it was and I think that's a that's a combination of of one that the the budget wasn't wasn't based in reality and then there didn't seem to be any tracking of it throughout the year so as things went things were going were off there wasn't anyone

066raising their hand coming to the board coming to miss bionas and said hey we have a problem last January last February in March and said the school year just continued to proceed through and you know some of these cases we were probably over budget in March April already and we're out of budget money but no one came to this body and said hey this is a problem we need to do something about it I don't have anything to base this on except a gut feeling but probably it wasn't until you ran out of cash that it became a problem when all of sudden we didn't have cash to pay bills that's when somebody started looking and saying what's going on what incompetence well you could for the last three years I mean when you made

067your presentations you came to us and you strongly recommend that that we had our wrong business office and he came another year strongly recommended that and he came again and finally I mean this year uh we were able to put it together and on that thing that and saying well nobody came to question yes we were questioning the person that was in charge of uh finance and everything that we had don't about it I mean I mean I mean we really I mean you believe the person was saying I mean I mean even when we adopted the budget for this current year I mean he said it's about balance budget I mean we're not going to go back and check well was this taken out of the debt we just took it for granted that

068what he presented to us we had the money and it was going to be a balanced budget he's right I mean a lot some of us especially some of us kept asking him whoever it was I I know you don't want to go behind but it was simple he couldn't provide an answer and I'm not that smart I'm probably not the smartest here or anything but oh she's pretty smart and I know she would ask him where's the there's no wiggle room there's no wiggle room you could never get an amount where's the stuff documentation I forgot it I'll bring it two weeks later I'll bring it three months later I think the one thing you know I'd like to get across to you as a board is don't take anybody's word for from now

069on you know yeah ask ask make them just documents to show I don't know if you were getting you know financial statements on a monthly basis but you know I I asked for revenue and expenditure for the last three years I gave up I I just we used to get them so we could kind of follow but I finally gave up we didn't get them again this is what you hire somebody for but you still have to you know someone needs to know that this person is doing their job you know um you know so you know at at the least I would like to see you start getting you know very simplified financial statements that would at least show you where you stand so it won't come as a complete surprise again I you

070know it wasn't until we ran out of money that we realized we had a problem something the thing we can go I want to go back and say well I mean that's a pass what it could have should have to now move forward and and unfortunately you know I I I I didn't want to sugar coat it's going to be hard it's going to be very hard you're going to have to make some probably some hard hard decisions uh that are not popular but um you know unfortunately that's the only way to get out of this so any other questions it's there's some more questions I mean we're going to go ahead and uh back to item a uh discuss an action to approve the uh District annual financial report for the year 23 24

071school year and then in August 31 24 Mr the recommendation is that the Board of Trustees approve the district's annual financial report for the 2324 school year ending August 31st I'm going to we have has to be submitted to Tuesday so uh I'm going to make a motion that we approve it and because it's something that has to be submitted to the I don't know what would happen if we didn't approve it or can we send it unapproved I think you're probably probably just result in more problems District me to me second Motion in Plain Talk this happened you could put your hand head in the sand and pretend it didn't happen Mr E prepared this audit and went through the audit in in the appropriate way and we provided our information and he audited

072it the way he supposed to unless you have an objection to that that he did something that was you know in some way wrong or or inaccurate or that you believe that the numbers he's reporting on don't reflect reality there are situations like that where I've heard of school boards saying we are not going to accept this because you created this this whole what we believe as a school board is a whole another fiction about what happened and that's not that's not you know that's not the reality I could see that but but with respect to this Sor I'm making the motion because second we have a motion we have a second uh concerns discussion not in favor guess uh there's a question I guess um you know these letters are dated January 10th and

073yes i' like to seen these at least a little bit earlier now yes that's only discussion I have yes in fact we had discussed this last year at this time too that we wanted to start earlier and we did start earlier but unfortunately the problems that you had made it last a lot longer but yes I agree with you we would love to have this where you have it in hand U I literally was printing this before I left because I finally got a response back that I needed to put in here so yes I agree with you more discussions questions and then we need to make sure that it's noted those Corrections need to be corrected before it submitted to the references to the financial excy will have to be yeah we're going to

074v on it to make sure we get it yes once we vote on this and everything this will be posted on the website yes we have to submit it it'll be posted on the Chris City website the corrected one the corrected one corre okay let's take a vote all in favor so no motion pass thank you Mr re thank you Mr re okay uh action item uh B discussion to approve the uh the uh Declaration of Financial compl and authorize a me to TA let them know why just the rationale behind this is just that we have to resubmit because we exceeded the 20 days the holidays got in the way of the submission so we have to resubmit to ta so essentially what you're doing is is U voting again tonight for the Declaration

075of financial excy president so move M fonus wait uh go ahead a motion Mr do we have a second second second by Mr M questions discussion I we approved this on December the 6th and I look over here on the day that it goes out if I'm reading this correctly you sent it on January the 10th and they received it on the 13th or how are we reading these dates uh they should I don't know it they go out direct mail I don't know Anna unless you know when t received it but my problem is December the 6 was a really long time ago I don't see how this St can get out in in the correct time we submitted on that date on what day so tea is January the No No January the

076what on it cuz you scri went out on the 10 it went out on the 10th that's a long time from December the 6th you got to remembery that around that time I mean holidays the mail I mean gets uh backed up and all that I'm I'm not putting an excuse we submit it late what happened I do not I I don't see how we don't take care of things what happened we just we submit a Le I feel like you it's too long I just don't get it mixed up in the who's supposed to turn who's supposed to submit is supposed to be my department who's supposed to turn it in was bu needs to turn it so we ended up turning it in and now we got to do this again huh and

077it's going to be mail tomorrow tonight tonight the business do it or who's going to do it business or are going to do it does this affect any of the decisions that we've made no because it's the record that you all voted for the original one you all still voted on December the C ages but I mean technically technically it hasn't been submitted so I don't know if there's any come back or anything legal wise that can happen at Le so but we can discuss it with the attorneys my understanding is that uh that's why they send us back the letter so that we could resubmit it uh and I did visit with Mr CR and Mr Cru said we just had to resubmit so okay uh all in favor to uh you make the

078motion right and was there a second yes in favor against 52 uh five uh four and two uh against uh Motion One exstension 431 4211 421 go close Okay at this point in time uh we're going to go into close session uh pursuant to Texas uh government code section 551 074 and 551 071 and the opens of the op meeting uh Act and the time is it is 6:42 [Applause]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.