001sh [Music] la [Music] [Applause] two one two three one two [Music] spe [Music] foree spee [Music] spee [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] for [Music] [Applause] for fore [Applause] [Music] GL speeech [Applause] [Music] spe for [Music] speee [Music] fore fore speeech [Music] [Applause] [Music] ISE foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music] wow me [Music] for [Music] foree fore [Music] speee fore [Music] [Applause] we need to get [Music] [Applause] [Music] that for spee [Music] [Applause] wow awesome they got a heart that was good okay they're gonna do we are [Applause] thank you guys sounds is this it I'm waiting for Jesse Jesse you're good sorry I'm so sorry for that that silence we have to make sure that the TV is recording as we do this but I just wanted to nothing takes me back to my childhood than
002hearing Mariachis uh growing up in San Antonio this was you would hear it every celebration for anything school assembly so just I really want to extend just a heartfelt thank you um to the University High School Mariachi tranos for the outstanding performance and to their talented director Mr Archie Lee Hatton the four thank you so much for your exceptional leadership and dedication I think the first time that I saw the Mari come it was a couple students and it's grown every year so I'm just so excited for this program and you guys did such a great job so thank you so much for coming and we really appreciate it and what's the saying once a Trojan there you go great okay so um gonna go ahead and call this board meeting to order are they
003GNA do another song okay gonna go ahead and call this regular uh Waco Independent School Board is hereby call to order all items which may discussed or voted upon this evening have been posted as required by state law really want to extend a warm welcome to everyone present um everyone who got to to hear these um talented musicians and to our television viewers the board's purpose is to set goals listening reports of the superintendent approve budgets contracts and Personnel appointments and AIC policy for the district we are not here to make management decisions or solve problems of individuals management is the responsibility of the superintendent and her staff and I would just ask if you would please turn off your cell phones to silent if you have not already done so and we really do
004appreciate the time that you've taken to join us and for your interest in wo isdd excuse mebe Inus in wo ISD as the wo ISD Board of Trustees we are held to ethical standards once we take office one of those standards is student centered Focus so we as the Board of Trustees will be continuously Guided by what is best for all students of the district thank you so much uh we're going to move on to item number two public comments do we have anyone signed up okay perfect um are we going to let them stay up there the reason we're gonna have them say stay up here is because they're going to sing another song for us a little bit later so thank you for bearing with us um we're going to go ahead and
005pause right now take time for prayer contemplation reflection Andor meditation thank you moving on to the pledge leaders and tonight's pledge leaders are Leslie Antonio and Jaden careno of bells Hill Elementary [Applause] School allege Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible Liberty justice for all thank you pledge leaders the board would meet me down in front of the day [Music] we appreciate our pledge leaders and invite them to meet our trustees this evening we're going to begin with Leslie Antonio Leslie is in the fourth grade her favorite subject is science she enjoys reading playing soccer and spending time with her sister and her dog Lola when she grows up Leslie plans to become a teacher and work right here
006in wo ISD Leslie is the daughter of Salvador and Maria Antonio thank you Miss [Applause] Leslie our pledge leader tonight is Jaden corano he's a fifth grader and his favorite subject is math he enjoys playing fortnite night and soccer when he grows up he plans to become a professional soccer player Jaden is the son of Juan and Samantha Carano and thank you to principal Christy Ingram for being here tonight to support her students [Applause] and trustees if we could please have you return to the Das thank you very much and I said it to you earlier this evening but happy Schoolboard recognition [Applause] month theas are all over it January is Texas school board appreciation month and this year's State theme leadership for tomorrow's Texas is fitting for the work that our trustees do through
007their selfless service trustees We Begin our appreciation of your service tonight with a special musical selection from the University High Troy hanos instructed by head band director Archie Hatton IV [Music] spe [Music] foree [Music] for [Music] speee for [Music] fore [Music] fore [Music] spee for [Music] [Applause] a huge thank you to our University High School mariachi band the Troy hanos you are always such a pleasure to listen to and we are grateful to have you keeping have you keep our Hispanic heritage alive we have enjoyed having you tonight and trustees would just like to come in front of the Das and thank you for your service amen okay another round of applause for our University High School Troy hanos they have their own mic have their own mic that was fantastic man thank you sir
008that was fantastic love it love it love it dude great singing it's fantastic love it thank you so much good playing man that's great congratulations this is awesome good job buddy fantastic thank you so much thank you man appreciate thanks man so glad you played for us thank you so much this is fantastic thank you fantastic dude you killed it your voice has already changed that was awesome dude killed it loved it hit the high notes thanks man thank you so much I appreciate it can do that thank man it's fantastic thank you again trustees the the public may or may not be aware that our school board members serve without compensation unlike city council members and some other elected officials these trustees sitting before you tonight serve because they truly care about our students
009and staff our superintendent student advisory council members from our middle schools and high schools will be making our presentations to our Board of Trustees this evening trustees when I call your name please come individually in front of the dis Stephanie cord School Board [Music] [Applause] president Stephanie CG is our school board president and represents District 2 president cord is in her 10th year of service as a trusty in Waco IST now that deserves a round of applause that's a decade as an educator herself president cord has remained connected to her Roots as a classroom teacher this perspective allows her to view things through an Educator's lens with a focus on how a decision will affect teachers and students truste cord is a steadfast advocate for listening to and engaging the community in her leadership has
010helped us move important 2021 Bond projects forward Isaiah Tava of wo high school and Alexandria Hatton of University High School are Pres presenting president cordek with her gifts of appreciation from our campuses and our district thank you so much president C we appreciate you and next we'd like to show our appreciation to Jose vdna our school board vice president [Applause] Mr VD serves as our vice president representing District 3 and is in his sixth year of service to Waco ISD vice president V vdna is extremely active in the community and a strong advocate for our students he and his family never miss a chance to support Waco ISD students and staff at various school events and performan performances as a university high school graduate and now parent he continues to be one of the Trojan's
011biggest fans University High School students were Carter Gonzalez and Stephanie Rodriguez are presenting vice president VD with his gifts of appreciation from the campuses and the [Applause] district thank you so much vice president Jose vidna we appreciate you [Applause] we now like to show our appreciation to Schoolboard secretary Mr Jeremy [Applause] Davis Mr Davis represents District 1 and is his fourth year of service on the board and currently serves as our board secretary he is an avid supporter of Waco's youth in addition to serving on the board trusty Davis is the founder of Mentor Waco where he works to assist students in academic achievement and improved Behavior he cares about our kids and is a true advocate for the student voice and education journy Broner and Eli Santos of Lake air monory Middle School are
012presenting secretary Davis with his gifts of appreciation from the campuses and the district [Applause] thank you so much trusty Davis we appreciate [Applause] you Jonathan Grant trustee District 4 please come [Applause] down Mr Grant is in his third year of service and represents District 4 on on the school board with experience as a small business owner and Minister he understands the importance of relationships Grant is a devoted bayor bear alumnus proud wo ISD parent and is extremely passionate about improving outcomes for all of our students having served on various boards and committees he embodies what it means to be a true servant leader from Waco High School Terence Johnson and kareim a Reyes present him with his gifts of appreciation from the campuses and the [Applause] district please help us show appreciation to Jim Patton
013Trustee of dist dist [Applause] 5 Mr Patton is in his second year of service and has been a great asset to wo ISD trustee Patton currently serves on the Waco ISC Education Foundation board and was previously an educator and campus leader in Waco ISD he is a proud supporter who values staff and understands the role our district plays and ensuring wo is a great place to work and [Applause] learn hey sh tell me your name please jasine pots thank you Miss pots [Applause] and now we would like to recognize trustee Angela [Applause] ooo Mr Ooa is a trustee at large and he's in his thir year of service as a wo ISD Schoolboard member Mr Ooa brings his financial expertise as an investment adviser to the team a former educator Ooa was recognized as a
014University High School teacher of the year he comes from a long line of Educators and is proudly married to one and he is able to view all things from unique and important perspectives that serve our district well presenting Mr Ooa with his gifts tonight is Isaiah Tava of Waco High School and Alexandria Hatton of University High School nice wther though thank you Mr Ooa we appreciate [Applause] you and last but by no means least this guy's on fire please welcome Keith gillery Mr Giller is a trustee at large and in his fourth year of service as a Schoolboard member as a deputy Fire Marshall board member and parent he serves the community while wearing many different hats a caring neighbor he is also the founder of tell the world Ministries literacy intervention team Waco and
015the Forever Young scholarship which is dedicated to Breaking the silence against domestic [Applause] violence presenting his gifts tonight our University High School students Ricardo Gonzalez and Stephanie [Applause] Rodriguez Mr Giller we appreciate you thank you to all of our superintendent student advisory council members for T making tonight extra special for our trustees trustees we hope you know that we appreciate you all year long not just tonight and if we don't say it often enough listen to what our students have to say about you what do WD school board members do I don't know School members work um I think they're rich I think [Music] I school board members help us help us and support the school in many different ways they help support parents and students in their educational lives and help support us when
016we need them help they try to do what's best for schools elementaries middles um and high schools oh School members they they they they're a teacher so they they show things to the kids but I know they provide for our school and they help us with things that our school can't get they take care of the school's financial problems like money and what to do to like instruct things around the school if it's broken or anything they also they also create the rules for like the school making sure everything's in order but I really want to thank them for for helping us build this new school that is really pretty and if I can say it in Spanish thank you for helping us grow stronger in our education thank you thank you thank you [Music]
017so gracias Dana mer grai dequ TOA shakron Tak havala Mahalo and all of the 34 languages that our wo students are speaking this year thank you for all you do for our students and staff if we haven't made it clear yet we appreciate you thank [Applause] you and you're getting your stepson tonight I'm going to ask come back down for a community partner really Prosper Waco is honored with the tasby standup for public education award as a January Waco is Community partner of the [Applause] month since 2022 through generous support of the Gates Foundation Prosper wo has shared more than $400,000 with wo ISD to help support efforts to recruit and retain highquality classroom teachers over Prospect wo's 10 years of existence they've sought grant funding to contribute more than 1.4 million million dollars to
018wo ISD supporting such work as placing College and Career Navigators on campuses and Beyond receiving the Texas Association of school boards stand up for public education award is pper wo CEO Jessica Addis and Jeremy roads senior director of data and research [Applause] it's picture and in the spirit of this partnership CEO at us now has a check presentation for wo ISD yes so we are you know it be thank you so much um chairman C chairwoman cwag trustees Dr Spicer for having us here this evening in the spirit of um trustee appreciation um I just want to say thank you to all of you all for your willingness to serve and to lead our district to hire exceptional superintendents um who hire in turn exceptional administrators who hire exceptional principles who hire exceptional teachers who
019do exceptional work every day in the classrooms of wo so we're so grateful for all of you all and it's our pleasure to present to you all this fake chick that has a real transferal electronic funds to support the work to build high quality teacher Pipeline and wakeo ISD so thank you for all you are [Laughter] doing yes yes can y'all just not cash it till Friday the 31st after payday congratulations Prosper Waco and thank you for your continued partnership with Waco ISD thanks next timeby it's not my money thank you so much well that was nice to get a nice little check from Prosper Waco you guys are welcome back next month too [Laughter] so yeah so thankful love to get to see all the kids and just Community Partners such a rich community
020and just so thankful for the good work that's happening here so okay moving on to item number five superintendence report Dr Spicer yes ma'am president c um attendance boundaries committee um we met for the third time last week review draft High School maps and a bigger picture a set of draft maps that incorporated all our elementary middle and high school plans I'm so grateful for the staff parents and commune members who engaged in this work with us talking through the challenges and opportunities that adjusting attendance boundaries Maps brings is heavy and important work we have our next committee meeting on February 6th and we will then be moving to public hearings to engage our community further for those trustees who were able to attend and listen and um I want to give you a chance
021to share any thoughts or takeaways you have from the last meeting if anybody has anything to add all right oh yes sir yes sir something yes sir um it was uh really really uh an active engagement uh they the community that has come together uh every meeting has really worked hard and has really been uh I feel very uh thoughtful in their approach and thoughtful in their uh problem solving and we're trying to do the best that we can for this District absolutely we appreciate the community supporting us yes sir thank you Mr Patton structured campus campus visits since we returned from break I have been back on campuses completing my structured campus visits these visits include me visiting three focus groups a set of students a set of staff and a set of parents
022to listen and learn more about the campus and their experiences it has been great getting to listen and learn more about our individual campus communities and their needs while the staff and parents are amazing I have to tell you that the kids are the ones that keep me on my toes I have been quizzed on names so I was at uh Crestview and they told me I could not leave until I told them all their names and had to memorize so guess what I memorized their names and we took a selfy and then they let me leave and have my parents show up next um they're also asking about giving more recess to fifth grade only because they're about to go to middle school so please make that happen Dr Spicer um I've truly appreciated
023how much our students are aware of how important campus is and their schools and so there's a lot of Pride coming out and there's also giving us a lot of feedback on things we can do better so I can't can't wait to share that with you I'll be synthesizing all this information along with additional data collected since October 15th I'm with you in February at that board meeting um students uh superintendent student advisory committee you guys got to see some of the students that I got a chance to meet with on yesterday and the day before um we have our two High School um represented and then four middle schools and so we got a chance to hear from them and so in this meeting um they are able to tell us so the first
024meeting we had tell us about all day Life School what's going well what's not going well um so we have work and we had feedback um from schedules to food to block scheduling to you name it they were kind of calling us on it so I was like okay thank you this is the work but they were very appreciative because they got to share their voice that's what they kept saying is thank you for listening thank you for asking and so we know um our team was there with me we have to come back and we have to deliver some deliv deliverables for them and so they're very excited about that work and then last but not least um we started 2025 with an important new addition to our team Dr Melissa King NOS is
025a passionate educator with 22 years of experience as a teacher assistant principal principal and District level leader prior to joining us here in wo Independent School District while she has a proven track record for success with increasing academic performance at campus and District levels and a skill with change management what is most important is her unyielding passion to keep students at the heart of her work in 2016 Dr King no was named region 4's assistant principal of the year and went on to receive the distinction of assistant principal of the year for the State of Texas she served on the Texas Association of Secondary School principal's Board of Directors for the last few years of her tenure as principal Dr King nolles has published multiple works on school leadership and presents frequently at conferences at
026the state level she completed her doctoral degree recently where she researched her research focused on leadership development and public education her dissertation has been chosen to represent her University on the Carnegie project for the education doctorate repository and was also selected to be presented at the Texas council of professors professors of educational Administration Conference next week I'm excited to formally welcome our our new Deputy superintendent Dr Melissa kingn no please give her hand as she [Applause] comes come join me I want to make sure sure that the mic is not right in my face um president cord superintendent Spicer and trustees esteemed trustees I am honored to be joining the leadership team here in wo ISD it has been clear from the onset what a special place it is this evening I'm honored to stand
027before you as Deputy superintendent I know we are united in sharing a common mission to ensure that every student in Waco ISD receives a quality education and the support they need to thrive both inside and outside of the classroom I am committed to working collaboratively with each of you to uphold values of equity excellence and accountability in all that we do together I believe we can continue to make Waco ISD a place where all students are empowered to reach their fullest potential and Inspire to develop a love for learning that serves them well beyond the years that they are with us I have been shaped by numerous Educators and educational leaders who have guided me and mentored me over the years and this includes my mother who although she couldn't be here tonight cheers me
028on regardless she was the first teacher who modeled for me what it means to care for the whole child and to never ever give up on our students I would also be remiss if I didn't recognize my amazing husband who has joined me here this evening this June we will be celebrating 23 years together and he's my RO talk my Safe Harbor in any storm and my biggest champion he inspires me to be the very best each and every day so that I can do that for Waco ISD and for our children thank you Kelly thank you for encouraging me I love you my life's calling is to pour back into public education what has been provided for me and I am excited to be able to be alongside the best the very best of
029the best here in Waco ISD thank you all again for your time this evening and for your dedication and service to this community I look forward to working with you all now and in the [Applause] future we we're gonna come down and we're gonna shake your hand but I just wanted to say publicly we're so glad that you guys are here and thank you so much for choosing Waco um to be to be a home I think you're you're right there this is an amazing community and there's some amazing people in this District and our kids are phenomenal so we're so excited to have you guys here [Applause] short [Applause] [Music] I know Santa love no is that uh ostrich okay here we go um I guess that is it for superintendent report thank you
030so much uh Dr Spicer moving on to item number six information items and reports is there anything you would like to discuss Mr Grant no anything I like to discuss Mr Davis no anything you'd like to discuss Mr Vidia no anything you'd like to discuss Mr Giller no anything you'd like to discuss Mr Ooa anything you would like to discuss Mr Pat no ma'am uh okay moving on consent agenda is there anything that you would like pulled Mr Grant no me thank you is there anything you would like pulled Mr Davis no anything you like pulled Mr Vidia uh just 7h 7h okay we're going to pull 7h 7e is there anything oh ruse okay uh is there anything that you would like um pulled Mr Ooa nope is there anything you would like pulled
031Mr Patton Gill Mr gillery told me that he's going to recuse himself from I would like to pull 7g 7g okay so I will entertain a motion to accept the agenda as presented except for 7e 7 H and 7g do I have a motion I'm move thank you Mr Grant as a first second Mr Patton any discussion Mr Grant any discussion Mr Davis any discussion Mr uh VD no any discussion Mr gillery no any discussion Mr Ooa nope any discussion Mr uh Patton no okay all in favor say I I any opposed passes unanimous okay so we're going to go down to 7 G uh purchases in excess of 50,000 under pre-existing bid purchased Cooperative or allowed Professional Service I don't know who is on that one that was me okay Mr Patton the question
032yes ma'am um I have a question about the $63,000 purchase uh from mcra Hill for instructional reading materials for prek through grade two of JH hind okay good evening yeah good evening so um Dr cornblum the I I really have two two concerns um one uh we're practically in February and uh the per request the purchase request is in February rather than say August or September when this could have been used all year long uh 65,000 bucks for three and a half months uh it's a little concerning and then the the second thing I did a little research on this and I know that this program has uh been in the past research-based and in the past have been considered best practices but that had been several years ago and I did a little little
033rabbit dive and uh from education week uh they talked about this program specifically that uh it has no discernable effects on reading comprehension and potentially negative effects on alphabetical reading fluency writing for students with learning disabilities um my I guess one of course any campus principal can ask for what they need but do we not have we not given hundreds of thousands of dollars uh through uh Miss parel's office for um tier instruction and for small group activities for when have we not supplied that for all elementary campuses yes have have we not seen for the campuses that are doing it with Fidelity doing those programs that the district has approved are we not seeing growth we we are seeing growth so my question is too why is this coming before us some February and
034two why is this a program that in the past has been booted out of schools of Ed booted out of school districts for not serving kids with specific needs so let me address your first question so when the administrator at this campus was hired um she asked if there were things that she could possibly do differently um to close the gaps for her students and um at the time my counterpart for leadership approved that and I'm aware that at at the time that this principal was hired there were some some things said um we were we wanted we want JH H to be successful but understanding what may have been said or what may have been construed no one in this district from Dr K Canon down to a bus driver has C launs to
035take money from the district for programs that are not best practice and in the face of the money that we have already provided and I may be the only one that has this concern guys but um we have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on on programs for our kids and if they're working in other schools and possibly they aren't working at this school maybe maybe curriculum instruction can help help them do better on it I my understanding is the other elementary schools in our district who are in Jeopardy of scores are making progress with the programs that you and your department have chosen and that the board has approved correct so this as I said this was in motion so although it's in February for us this specific administrator has had this ball in
036motion for a bit it has taken them a bit of time to get it rolling um as far as the research base it still is research based because it does focus on Phonics phic awareness awareness vocabulary fluency all which align to reading comprehension which are all aligned to the science of teaching reading so it still is considered research base um as far as it's not consider I'm sorry it's not considered best practice though because it's not strong in problem solving skills because what I've read and I'm not going to argue with you because Dena you know so much more than me and I just went down the rabbit hole with this um my concern is that it's not highlevel thinking and the fact that some significant magazine uh articles from well-known educational institutions have deemed
037this program so I'm sorry and I won't interrupt you again maybe it's it it is at the prek-k And1 level so it's the foundational reading skills to support language development and reading comprehension so that's what she's trying to focus on and um like I said the ball's been rolling although it feels like this is to school years in one when all of that happened back when she was approved for that it has um taken them a bit of time she did not have the funding for it and um we worked with her on some funding in different areas to free up some funding for some things but then there was some funding found and so um she's trying to follow through on the approval that she was given in the beginning may I ask why
038um this isn't through State comper title one because if we gave money to that campus out of state or out of state comper title one we would be giving them a disproportionate share exct what we give the other campuses and we use our state comp and Title One funding to pay for the programs that we're using as a district and our systematic approach that is ex actually what I'm getting at if we have used State comp and title monies for programs for across the board for district for elementaries for this specific type of thing I I have a concern accepting that we're going to do this program when we've already got good programs that will help uh and for whatever reason as you say Dr corn Bloom that it's Tak a while to get the
039ball rolling I believe that um your department has been very supportive of these these initiatives that are coming from admin um I just have a question and a concern about the $65,000 purchase for the next three months of school I hear you I'm not trying to put you on the spot or your department because I think you're doing a marvelous job I think we've got the we've got the programs in place that will do the job I think that's what we should stick with with Fidelity thank you thank you Mr Pon does anyone else have a question I have yeah this may be kind of Crossing topics here but when we had the workshop uh last month month before that um we we talked about how curriculum was the same at every campus mhm so
040how would introducing something like this affect that it would be different there and as I said when is that is that what we want though I mean because we seem pretty sure that we wanted similar instruction on all campuses that's correct so I I think I go back to what um was stated to this principal when she was hired and that that's where this process started that comment that statement that you're alluding to was not made by DR Spicer nor the board am I correct no but as I said the ball was roll as I said school year feels like two school years right that almost seems like a lifetime ago like that didn't even happen but that was still a part of this school year and that principal started working on this during this
041school year with that approval before the trans I I have a question on this is it possible for you all to get with the principle and put together uh something that's comparable to this or better can you you know through your department and we can table this and come back to it if we were to make a change I would suggest using the programs that we have in place okay is that your recommendation [Music] yes I agree I mean if if this is not approved I would suggest using the programs that we have in place with Fidelity okay so let's put this uh let let's Okay so from my understanding Dr corn Bloom this um is kind of on top of the curriculum that we have very robust I would say from the workshop very
042robust curriculum that this has put together um and this is being recommended by the principal specifically correct this is a program that she used in the past and seen success with and wanted to bring in when she accepted the position that was a part of that so and specifically where she's wanting to put it so there's a piece that would go in prek all through interventions um it wouldn't it's not replacing any core instruction in Pre pre's con is considered the intervention you know I mean really but there is a piece that goes in Pre there's a piece that goes in in Kinder and then a piece that's in first now our first graders on up through Elementary have the tiered intervention right away kindergarteners start that type of tiered intervention up until then it's
043small group of different things in the classroom they start that type of intervention in the spring um you know where they have the opportunity to be pulled and different things like that um um but this P that this program would be implemented in place of our current intervention through part of it would be tier two in the classroom and part of it would be tier three with the student intervention teachers do we have materal I my understanding we have those materials already in place for like our systematic yes ma'am the district approach yes so this is is redundant from from the information that you you're giving us I move that we table this allow you all to get with the principal come up with a different plan communicate with the principal and we table us
044to a further you know and look at it at further date I I'll agree with that um I I just think um is as Stephanie said we we have a a lot of very robust curriculum um and when it comes to teaching phonics and and I could be completely wrong here but I can't imagine there would be that big of a difference or of all the curriculums that we've already purchased something in there wouldn't fit that automatically now if it's head and shoulders Above the Rest I think we absolutely would all agree that we're going to do whatever is best for those kids to learn but and then we would bring it to but if we can exactly and if we can find something within our own existing curriculum that's similar that we could adjust
045to I mean it's a lot of money it's a lot of money I think Miss Davis is gonna chime in no can we just exclude that purchase that's what I'm texting Pete right now is to see if I can approve sorry Pete uh can I could we I'm I'm I'm looking for the language of how do we approve the Amendments excluding the McGraw Hill 63,000 purchase um request that purchase request on this uh it they're wanting to exclude it or they're wanting to exclude it because it's tabled to be brought back at the next board meeting do have do we vote on tbling okay so what is happening I think the motion Mr gillery made was specific as to this item this item to be taed talking about be taed I don't think he was
046referring to the item in no just a piece of just piece I think that's already I'll second if we need a second then you still have the rest of that agenda to go through yes second for a tabled item we just basically have to agree for a second and it's done we don't have to do the vote on that correct V okay everyone in favor so we got hold on one second let's get this language in everyone in favor of tbling at the McGraw Hill 63,000 until the next board meeting um uh yes we've got a first of uh say I 21 120 is is the next board meeting time for you all to get with the principal look at this and examine it I mean school's going to be over if we don't decide
047something pretty soon so yes we need to do it by the next board meeting when we is if we we get this principle to align right to what we're doing then do and there is no $63,000 purchase does it have to come back here I mean it will not come back okay it will be us doing the work just doing the work okay okay great I appreciate you answering my questions okay so all in favor of tbling the item say I I any opposed I kind of oppose actually just to table it but that's just me the lone person and I know that it's going to be tabled okay great um the I will entertain a motion to accept uh the administration's recommendation that the board trustees approved the purchase request over 50,000 as presented
048I do I move thank you Mr Pat do I have a second second thank you Mr Grant is there any discussion Mr Grant no any discussion Mr Davis any discussion Mr Vidia no any discussion Mr giler no any discussion Mr Ooa no any discussion Mr Patton no okay uh all in favor say I any opposed passes unanimously moving on to item seven H uh Mr Vidia yeah I just wanted uh I guess more information on just what like how are we going to pick these students or are they applying or are we they're applying the with the internship with the city oh yeah Dr corn Bloom the city of Waco internship how the student selected do I actually don't know the criteria on that and I'm sorry I didn't I wasn't prepared to talk about
049this one I didn't look into that so um I can find that out though for you and get that upate sure yep how they're selected for their internship yes okay C I do think that this is a great program though it is it is really excited about that Mr vdia do you have any other questions that that was one of my biggest great okay great so I entertain a motion to accept Administration recommendations approval interlocal agreement between city of wo and wo for this career and Technology summer internship program as presented do I have a motion so moved thank you Mr Davis do I have a second thank you Mr vidna any discussion Mr Grant any discussion Mr Davis any discussion Mr B no any discussion Mr Giller no any discussion Mr Ooa NOP any
050discussion Mr Patton no okay all in favor say I I any oppos passes unanimously going back up to item 7e this is Bid award for maintenance supplies equipment and services uh Mr Giller is going to go ahead and recuse himself from this item I will entertain a motion and I don't have that language in front of me let me pull it up b word where is this if anyone has 7e up thank you and services as presented I will entertain a motion move thank you Mr Grant as do I have a second thank you Mr Davis is there any discussion Mr Grant no any discussion Mr Davis any discussion Mr Vidia no any discussion Mr Ooa nope any discussion Mr Patton no okay all in favor say I I passes six with a recusal of
051Mr gillery oh any oppose nope okay great we got through that consent here we go [Music] um okay we will now open up the board meeting for a public hearing uh regarding the 2023 2024 Texas Academic performance the taper report and that is Mel myel so I had the opportunity to meet um Miss Steel in the elevator when she was coming down for the first time so she is um replacing Denise bells and is now going to be doing everything data and numbers and keeping us on track so miss still welcome good evening Madame President Dr Spicer and Board of Trustees um they gave me the clicker so is it I click ahead and there it is um so we're going to go ahead and review the Texas Academic performance report from 2324 which includes
052lots of lagging data from even the prior year just um how it is presented um you have in your um board brief the in your the over this is the overview but you have the full details um in your linked for you um so for the 2324 uh Waco ISD um doesn't have any actual ratings pending litigation so that's two years of litigation that we haven't seen um any a through F ratings um but they did release the um 24 special education determination status which is needs intervention uh for our district and so they're looking at several um areas for um our special education students um academic performance um post-secondary Readiness um disproportionality um and so we place in that level three needs um intervention um and so we work through um those processes in
053terms of star performance um I have before you um our approaches or or better so included to this is any student that may met approaches meets or Master's um level um for reading math science and social studies and you can see the comparison between the district and the state um here um just let you kind of look at that we will in a couple slides go over a comparison from the prior year to this year here so you can see um the trajectory of those things um so these are our approaches level here good to and this would be the meets level for those same subjects reading math science and social studies um star performance so it does include grades 3 through eight and then High School eoc's um as well so this is our
054meets and above District to State and then our masters um for all four core subjects as well comparing our district and state for the 24 um Academic Year the next slide gives us this is just reading and language arts and it does give us the comparison from um 23 to 24 so how we performed in Waco ISD and the state performed um and the the trend is if the state increased we increased proportionately and if we if the state decreased we also decrease proportionately so we kind of hung in to where we were relative to to the state performance for for those things so you can see at the Masters we increased for an example a percent in the state increased um as well so in in small increments um can I ask a question
055sure if a district um is functioning optimally in all these categories it seems to me and this is my probably least educated in these areas um that the State numbers would grow by more than just one or two points year like 2023 to 2024 uh Masters two points meets one point so my expectation in this is that we see we have some significant but when we are in a hey healthy Rhythm uh I would anticipate more than one or two is this considered healthy on the states I mean the state's growing 1% that doesn't seem very good for our state um so I don't know if I have an answer to represent tea in in what they would consider Healthy Growth or or not um we've seen over the last couple years many changes in
056our accountability system in our in the the star assessment itself how it's scored what types of questions so I think in that transition over the ne you know over this last couple years um you know 23 introduced you know new item types and different things on the star test um 24 um any extended constructed responses that are embedded in almost every content area or the short constructed or you know all of those things are are now being graded like for English you know through a a data system you know through yeah this isn't a critique criticism at all on you to me go ahead those those changes have existed and so I don't until everything kind of is a little bit more stable and and we see we can see with no change a a
057year or two no no I know and and and I know that I mean there the 42nd ranked state in funding for Education uh and a tea that seems to support all these changes happening so rapidly um this number to them should tell them it's not working right and that we need to increase our funding so that uh 1% isn't acceptable Statewide I mean that that's kind of my point is that um they're the ones that changed all these rules and numbers and tests and and um it's not working Statewide I have a question also kind of related yet unrelated to this when did we do when did we transition to online testing was that this year 2023 or was it 2022 do you remember 24 it was piloted two years ago I thought go
058back like I mean we've been doing online testing but when they went to like no more paper request with very limited exceptions was really the 2 three when they introduced the new item types and things that are not as compatible with paper testing um the drag and drops like you know where kids have to maneuver things reading comprehension on the actual computer not being able to highlight verus like little drop downs where like you know there maybe a sentence and they've got to pick the correct word you know they get a selection of words and they've got to pick the correct word there's different types of questions not no longer is it just multiple choice or just uh you know in math some we call them grbl I don't know if that's a a common
059term but you know the bubbled in ones where you you know put your answer in so there's a variety you know math has open-ended where they have to like write you know type in their answer so there's all of those things so that was introduced in the 23 um testing and so okay yep in an effort to it seems like in an effort to make grading easier they've made the test more difficult to take I mean I'm just thinking from my own son's point of view we had to practically hire a tutor just to show him all the tools he could use while taking a test and that's just excluded from the test itself yeah so I mean the state does have opportunities for kids to to practice those things I'm I'm sure you know
060if you're getting somebody to come in where you know we do it through interm testing and different opportunities that kids have in the classroom to practice a lot of the programs we use incorporate those same things so kids have some more consistency with that and of course as they if you got little ones and it's the first time they're doing those tests and it's it's really new and you know once but even older kids that haven't had to be exposed to that it's new to them right as of 23 so I think as we utilize these features I think it'll be more comfortable for students and and maybe not seem like so out of space for them but um it is it is all new for for everybody and that's across the state and so
061that may be where some of those things are yeah that's I want you to say that that was across the state we wouldn't singled out it was across the state right yeah so let's move on um but to answer that like seeing some some stagnant things getting comfortable with the testing they I mean they did you know tea has put out they've changed the rigor of the questions um so that's where some of that comes from too I'm going to go ahead and if we're okay to move on to math um and so we'll see a very similar um experience in the in the math where um of course in the state and and District we've you know see a slight um decrease um in all subjects Miss Ste do we know um is CA
062continuing to ramp up I I know in years past when they would make alterations to tax to Star you know they would they would make they would give a three-year ramp up and then they would stay there for usually three to five years before they made alterations to the test and I know that the test has been altered every year for the past at least since covid so do you have a feeling from tea that that this is going to be where we can start getting a baseline on the test being similar and not being uh being changed do you know what I'm saying Dr Spicer um so um a meeting I was in I don't think that's this past summer I know they are looking at the test and possibly making some changes again
063especially with legisl leg legislation session um coming because there's been concerns so um I don't foresee um the consistency that you're talking about but that's what we need because we don't know it's like we're building the plane while we're flying it right right apples to oranges every time we every year when the test sir and the the forensic knowledge that that our Administration that curriculum instruction that your department yes sir your team needs to know to be able to focus in when the ball when the game keeps changing yes sir we're we're looking from last year to this year it is apples and oranges and that's not fair to our teachers who are trying to F fill in holes sir and not knowing it's it's really frustrating and I know it's frustrating for our teachers
064but we really need to get some advocacy down in Austin on this yeah we're going to have to we're going to have to I will say from 23 to 24 that the the idea of the test didn't change it was still the same formatting but some of the grading the way it was graded and and that was changed and then we don't expect to see any changes this year necessarily but as Dr Spicer mentioned you know there there's constant um looking at the reviewing the data and the test and and what that looks like so um I don't know that we will see a flatline for any extended period of time so here is the the science data um for the district so again similar Trends any good and social studies I will point out
065um this is a a bright spot um looking at at our approaches so more of our kids um making the approaches we we obviously want to see those increases in meets and Masters for all of our subjects as well but um the state stayed stagnant at that 78% and we saw a 3% gain so um we had some good things going on in in um social study so that's 8th grade and our US History EOC are we good yeah all right so we're going to get into some really lagging data um data that really is coming from 2223 school year um and so this is our chronic um absenteeism so again students that are enrolled at least 10 days but have been absent um 10% of the days of their enrollment so um we do
066see a 10 % decrease which is a really good thing um for Waco ISD um in from the 2122 school year to the 22 23 school year um there are a lot of things in place on campuses um meetings to address um these students that are absent and how we can help support them and get them to school um going on and I I think we see those efforts through through this data um so the states decreased about half of what we decreased so that was um a good thing to see there sorry was that a you're okay okay we doc Dr Edison uh stepped up and was became kind of the attendance and making sure that the attendance um you know not being absent kind of was incentivized and meeting with campuses and trying
067to track down students so we're just looking at that data and that data could also be kind of evidence of of his work on that specific issue so thank you so we see that as well is in attendance um you know our our district had you know almost a 3% increase we do see a a small increase um in the state as well but um more than doubled the state the states increase there so getting our kids into school which is the the first thing that needs to happen there through that um Dropout rates so um the students that left wakeo ISD in the 2223 school year so you can see we had a in our seventh and eth grade so they start tracking those dropouts in seventh and eth grade um these aren't necessarily
068kids that just didn't ever enroll in another school it's they may just be students that we don't have documentation that they went somewhere else they could have moved out of state in between a school year they never re-enrolled with us we spend through September looking for these students but if we can't locate them then they would um end up on on the Dropout list that's just kind of the way that works but you can see we've decreased and the state increased and so we're kind of right right where the state is this year so hopefully we can see that Trend continue to decrease for for us there um in our 9 through 12 we we did see um a little bit of a of an increase um for those for those grades um graduation rates
069so um the state gives us a four-year graduation rate so that's our class of 23 fiveyear um so if we recapture kids meaning that they didn't graduate in the four years that from when they enrolled in high school but a fifth year or a sixth year then um and we can identify that they graduated then they would go in a five year or six year graduate and we kind of keep looking at those kids through those six years um and so we see um some increases I know you don't see it here but from the 22 class to the 23 class we did have a about 1.3% increase in that graduation rate just from the four-year graduation rate and again this is all lagging data um so we have different diploma types for our students
070and so they look at how are our students graduating so there's a um the foundation High School plan where they get 22 credits um and can graduate through that plan there's a diploma with endorsements um so there's different endorsements students can get if they've taken a cluster of specialized classes is stem multidis um Humanities public service business and industry um and then our um distinguished level so they've got that endorsement but they have also taken Algebra 2 sometime in um and been successful sometime in um so we'll look at um kind of some of those um diploma types so 74.3% of our um students graduated with the foundation with an endorsement at the distinguished level so um which is an increase um from the year prior being able to give those students those opportunities um
071I'll I'll address the the graduates with the CTS in a in a further slide but well above the state there so um and then this goes into our college career military Readiness so graduating students that are prepared for life after um they leave us in Wake ISD um so our students that graduated annually um with they've either been prepared for college for military or for career and how they're accounting for them um so we can see we've had some increases um from 22 to 23 um a little over 6% um there isn't data for the 2122 year for the college ready and career ready as um um independent things because they've changed how they're um giving the information for our um special education students that have an advanced diploma are now going to be um
072associated with college ready where they were prior years were associated with career ready so they had to kind of move that so we'll get to see those changes in the in the future um and this kind of breaks down the criteria for um being either College ready or career ready um so the TSI component um is students that have met the criteria on a um College ready exam whether it's sat act or the tsa2 um test and so our students that they can meet it for English math or or both and so those are kind of identified there we made some pretty large gains in in that math um success with those kids um in in that area um they can also be identified as College ready through AP exams um obtaining associates degree or
073dual credit horor and then um the career is really um over the industry based certifications um those are continually changing I know we we talked about not being stagnant in the state so they've changed some of those rules and we'll kind of talk about that in the next slide they've reintroduced um us Armed Forces so students um enlisting in the military um after graduation um and they'll can so we've been able to collect that data for the 23 24 and then they've actually gone into an agreement with um the do to be able to collect that information independently from us so that'll be nice and um and then our um students with special education services and how they're graduating um whether they're graduating um with their IEP being complete and um employability skills or Workforce
074ready or the advanced diploma with their endorsement so um the class of 23 had to take an IBC and pass an IBC to be considered um career ready that will continue to change the class of 24 um had to have a level two in a program of study and so um the CT has lots of a variety of programs of study and um they they kind of worked in a tiered system where like the 24 had to have the level two course 25 graduates that are graduating this year in order to get credit for that career ready they have to have two courses in the same program of study and then our 26 and Beyond will need to have um four credits within the same program of study and pass their IBC that industry based
075certification so we'll see those changes come along in the next couple years um and then but we had 53% of our 23 graduates were completers meaning that they met beyond the um the state standard of just passing an IBC but also having those programs of study and finishing their their CTE pathway um where the state had 31% um and then grades 9 to 12 81% of our students are participating in some fashion through career technology education which I think those are some really good things that we're doing to support students um so this is just kind of a profile of our our students and staff here um so this is just our elementary enrollment um and you can see the changes from 2223 to 2324 school year and then our secondary um see that as
076well um our um ethnicity distribution really for the last um three years is really been very similar hasn't really changed um with our student groups African-American and Hispanic being our largest populations um in there but they've they've pretty much been steady um our uh just identifying our students by program so through what students that are being serviced through gifted and talented um our homeless program dyslexia Section 504 at risk economically disadvantaged and Title One what's the difference between at risk and so the atrisk coding um is identified if a student is at risk of potentially not graduating so they're looking at students that may have not been successful there's a variety of things that that academic it's not just academic there's a there's a variety there's a there's a list of things but so they're
077looking at a variety of things um that that come into play with that um one of the things I do want to point out is our students that have dyslexia Services we are seeing um an increase there due to new guidelines on testing and identifying those students so we we will continue to probably see some changes there how um this is probably for Dr Spicer um or special ed how how long do we serve dyslexia do we serve that all the way is it to until they exit the program or I mean can they be dyslexic and still be getting those services in high school yes okay looks different okay okay support okay thank you we don't see the numbers quite change now but to to go with that we've also had the changes where
078students that are served through dyslexia will ALS they'll be served through special education so we'll see that transition and probably see an increase in our our special education numbers just and that's new laws and and guidelines that we have to follow so that goes under the umbrella yeah Special Ed is going to balloon like I I can tell you personally I had two children that had dyslexia services and they just were through Section 504 and had their accommodations and had the supports that they needed um that is no longer you know how how the system works anymore and so um um those students are expected to be served through special education um so we can see an increase in our emergent bilingual um population as well as our students receiving um ESL services and then
079you can just see our a breakdown of our um primary disability types for our special education as well another question please can you um Define students with non-categorical Early Childhood is that just the Early Childhood Program I I don't know I'm not familiar with that I think that they haven't been identified with a specific learning disability at that point is this prek yeah they I think they're too young to be identified with a I'll special education like specifically so our ncec which is non-categorical categorical Early Childhood it's for our 3 to five-year-olds and we would evaluate them they meet the criteria but we're not quite sure maybe they just need some early intervention and so um by the time they're six we have to re-evaluate them however that is going away this year and we're
080starting with a new eligibility it's a developmental delay and so that's something that we're moving into for next year how do we how do we identify them how do you do does a parent call you if they have a three-year-old who's whose speech delayed or something like that how how does a district know how to identify those those children so we work with Head Start we work with ECI um and then if a parent does have a concern or a doctor has a concern they call us and we will evaluate them we have a ecsc Early Childhood testing center at North Waco and so we have someone that's that's what they do they evaluate they have speech maybe OT PT and then we determine if they meet eligibility or need that early intervention and then
081we provide the service is that funded through the federal government yes okay MH thank you and then our this was our 23 teacher demographics um and then 24 not much change um in there so very very similar correct and then our teacher turnover um 2223 so we saw um a little decrease there so retaining some teachers um the number is a little um it includes staff that may have moved to a different position within the district so um if we have staff that's moving out of the classroom from a classroom teacher and to another role they're included in this in this rate so it's a little um maybe misleading at times depending on those other things but I know a lot can you go back oneide the bachelor does this include support staff campus or
082is it classroom teacher this is specifically teacher demographics so a quarter of our teachers don't have a bachelor's degree well 20% have a master M's degree oh so they're not included in that no no I I yeah I think it's their highest highest level of education so he was freaking out right now he we have bigger problems Miss steel do we know um that's what I was going to ask do we know what percent of our our teaching staff is emergency certified or alternatively certified um I don't have that data here um I wouldn't I she wouldn't have that but we could get that that's HR and this is lag data and so you know it has teacher experience on the next slide so that'll give us I I will point out so the no
083degree the 2.3% is probably I'm G to like make some assumptions I know they're horrible but you know we have a lot of CTE teachers and so they can be in the classroom certified you know if we had someone that' been working in the nursing profession for or profession and so they may not have a degree but they they have the Mastery of their content and so so there's probably where most of that comes from as opposed to I think what the initial concern was and so um any are we good on the teacher turnover okay and then teacher experience um so this just is our our teachers with the amount of experience they have compared to um the state and so you can see our our one to five teachers um is is where
084we have a good a good per number of of staff there has that gone down she so that uh one to five years experience at one point in the district it was like 50 almost over 50% one to five years new new teachers so that is to see that a decrease 6 to 10 years experience almost at about 20% and then 11 to 29 years now those are kind of the Vets the so that's that's kind of your bread and butter are those six to 29 years and over you know and I think a lot of that um Miss cwag is from uh teacher retention bonuses and new teacher sign on bonuses yes oh new teacher sign on with experience yes yes um I I I got to watch last year and uh with Dr
085cornblum we were at the base for the new teacher orientation I believe and I ask how many of you are brand new teachers how many of you are one to5 and then I as six to 10 and in tons of hands um I think that program that we put in place helped and I want to tag that on to everybody's put a bug in their ear yeah the um yeah great I I think yeah one point it was like almost 50 over 50% um and I think our district was struggling at that point to try to get any traction so yeah I do think the having quality experienced teachers I know that the principls have done such a phenomenal job of actually recruiting really high quality teachers um they've kind of told me they're going
086out and they're really trying to recruit hard from um everywhere with really great teachers and I walked in and I thought this teacher the second that I walked in had my full attention and I could have sat there for like 30 minutes so really uh want to give kudos to the principles as well for using their networks to really trying to uh get and recruit quality teachers so that's all I have for you any things you yeah thank you so much M Ste appreciate it okay uh that ends our public hearing moving on to item number nine consider discuss take appropriate action regarding the 2024 2025 instructional calendar Dr corn Bloom I will say I liked this calendar I really did huh what what did you say I'm sorry I really like this calendar oh
087good I went through and I compared it to the my calendar I was like oh okay this one makes sense it works works yeah well calendar one and calendar 2 were very similar um but um calendar one is kind of more reminiscent of the calendar we have this year so as you know um we present this to cudak and we presented it to cudak for the first time in December um they gave in input we took well when when I started we started creating them I made two and I was really having a hard time making the third and so we took that to the leadership team and we came up there with a calendar that looked very different um with a much later start date which would have pushed us till after Memorial Day
088um that calendar was made really just thinking about the possibility of wake oh high you know and that that move in although we're hoping that that's not a thing um so um took that back to um cud do got their feedback made changes took it back to cudak again in January um got feedback and then after that meeting it went out for voting so um does does the memo come up Mr um or maybe I have control no well you have the memo you see that it meets all of the criteria the 75,6 minutes um the holidays the same holidays that we have traditionally gotten that are aligned to the universities and um colleges around us um so we try to do that um on this particular calendar I think we have 2 point off
089of the top of my head one maybe um extra days for bad weather um and two early releases so that those are really kind of the high points of the calendar teachers still have planning days on this calendar calendar 1 and two had planning that was the thing with calendar three it did not so all in all calendar one um received 414 votes calendar two received 241 and calendar 3 received 3 64 um Al together we had 876 staff votes and 143 Community votes with a total of 1,9 votes alog together so um when you put the community and the staff together the calendar one obviously which is the one that we're bringing forth had the most votes so we are asking you to approve the 2526 um WD instructional calendar as presented okay all
090will entertain a motion thank you Mr Grant do I have a second oh we'll give it to Mr Davis um do you is there any discussion Mr Grant no any discussion Mr Davis any discussion Mr vid no any discussion Mr Giller no any discussion Mr AOA uh I just have a quick question sure two quick questions one uh when we say planning days do we do we ever do workshops on those days are they truly planning days the principles are allotted 90 minutes basically to pull staff um think of it like if I wanted to go through some data with them from a recent assessment because I wanted them to use their data for planning purposes or if I wanted to send my instructional specialist well instructional Specialists could plan with them but if I
091wanted them to meet with them just about data and them support them in planning or if they just needed to talk to them about something during that time so for 90 minutes they you know they get that amount of time and then the rest of the day and we've we've been clear to you guys that that is we want it to be for our teachers to plan that said the principles can structure that as long as it's allotted to planning and they can ask teachers to turn in an artifact at the end completed units some of the things that we talked about during the during our Workshop so they can structure that time to ensure that that time is used wisely and my other question uh is probably more for Dr Spicer um have we
092talked at all about possibility of changing up I know you heard about it from the student groups probably from a lot of teachers about the start times start schol yes um I know I know we had to do it uh that way because of our we had to go to the tear bus system but I think now that we're yes it did fully staff or closer to fully staff have we started having discussions I know you'd make a lot of friends in this district oh my gosh listen I'm telling yall y'all just like listen take all the heart topic Spicer do them now um but yes the students did bring that up especially my high school students they let me know what time they wanted to start school but also let them know that it's
093a domino effect um I also had some parent groups ask the same question and I did explain which I think our parents I know we communicated it but like just the fact that I was like so did y'all know that our transportation department was taken over by us right they did not know that that's why we start early because we have to do this many routes so I think we had some education to do but it is something we can look at and consider um but like I told the students it's a domino effect if we do this for high school this is what this means for Middle School this is what this means for elementary um cuz high school is like you know let let the little ones go first we'll just sleep until
0949: and you know what I mean so everybody wants a lot of different things however we are going to listen and see you know if that's something that's feasible but at the end of the day we have to make sure our buses also can make the routes get them there on time so that we can have school so we're talking about all of nothing's off the table hey the kids are oh they are they won a result yesterday sir driv yeah yes we're always hiring bus drivers let's say that for the audience everybody please share thank you Mr Mr Patton just want to make sure we are uh Dr cornblum we are still banking extra minutes a day yes good so we have two extra two extra days the minutes equal two extra days right
095now on this calendar the the one that you're being asked to approve right now um we did not put um sometimes President's Day is used as a bad weather day so if we needed to recapture another day we could it's not on there as a bad weather day however we could come back as a board and and make that happen if we needed to if we got into a bind is that it Mr Pat you have more questions okay great um all in favor say I I I any oppose Pastor Jan and I love that Halloween is a holiday you know that was perfect the teachers are probably rejoicing everywhere that was unanimous yes Halloween I saw was a holiday and I thought way to go Federal from Federal federal holiday for Super Bowl as
096well after superow the from the CAC from um then we shared it out then with principal's assistant principles you know different groups and collectively that was heard yes the first person that tells a student I mean classroom teacher they're going to have to host a Halloween party only a day earlier oh yeah should probably duck immediately after they make that suggestion well thank you so much Dr for your great work we appreciate it uh um yes may I make a comment just it just not related to what we just talked about uh Dr cornblum I I just want to publicly say when I pulled the consent item I appreciate you stepping up in answering questions cold not knowing where I was coming from I appreciate your cander and I appreciate your expertise so thank you
097yeah great um okay let's go go on to everyone's favorite topic audits Miss Davis it's good it's very good information it's very good information I just yes very thorough I will say that very thorough as well so thank you for that yes so um we our auditor Mr John deoro from Weaver is here tonight to do a brief presentation brief presentation on the results of the audit great great welcome thanks Cheryl I got the hint with the the brief [Laughter] presentation I want to uh thank thank you Dr Spicer and members of uh the board for allowing me to meet with you this evening to present the results of the fiscal year 2024 audit as Cheryl mentioned I'm John de burough I was the audit partner and I like to uh bring some good news
098to this meeting going through the audit results with you and I'll try I know you had lot on your agenda this evening so I'll try to go through this as quickly as possible but if you have any questions please let me know um I served as the audit partner stepen Smith as the audit manager and just to give you a little bit of context we we started planning our our meeting La I mean planning our audit last spring we uh did interim field work in July where we look at mostly internal controls uh since the fiscal year is not closed yet uh then when we come back out in November we perform the brunt of our our testing and we issued our opinion on the district's financial statements which uh I won't do a spoil
099yet but we'll get to that in just a minute we have to um we have to perform our audit in accordance with several standards generally accepted auditing standards and generally accepted government auditing standards and then we also perform a single audit which called a single audit of the district's federal financial assistance programs um and we also perform compliance of the district uh with various uh things such as the tea State compliance require requirements and the public funds investment act and we utilize a risk-based approach uh as most firms do and this is just because obviously we can't audit every transaction of the district so we look at areas that could be of higher risk and and tailor our resources more heavily in those areas things such as improper Revenue recognition uh especially with the state
100Foundation U funding uh misappropriation of of cash receipts and thing these are considered specific risks um of all districts and and cities and such and we have to look at the controls over those areas and which we did and uh we felt that the controls were strong and uh didn't represent any material weaknesses or significant deficiencies uh some of the more significant areas that we test are federal and state Grant revenues and expenditures uh State Foundation program revenues and related estimates uh construction projects and various uh payables um and then as I mentioned when we came during the Spring we w we look at the internal controls and get an understanding of the processes and then we walk through transactions to make sure that the controls are in place and operating as designed and when
101we were here during the Spring we started our single audit testing and there were two major programs this year that had to be tested as part of the uh Federal single a it uh one of them was the title one program and the Child Nutrition cluster this year um we also perform testing of um The District's capital projects that are going on including bid testing procurement testing uh test of controls over cash dispersements and payroll and what you've been waiting for the results tell us how we did John uh We've issued several reports in conjunction with this year's audit the first is our independent Auditor's report on uh the district's financial statements and I'm happy to report that we've issued an unmodified or a clean opinion which means that we feel that the district um
102financial statements were um in ordance with gap uh We've issued our independent auditor report on internal control of financial reporting and on compliance and happy to report that there were no instances of any material weaknesses or significant deficiencies in internal controls and uh no instances of any material non-compliance and the final uh report that we've issued is the one that's specific to the single audit for the federal financial assistance programs and on that report we've issued another unmodified opinion or clean opinion which just means that we feel that the district complied with all the compliance requirements of the major programs that we tested the title one program and the Child Nutrition program and there were no findings so good news all the way around um I won't go through all the details of our required
103communication they are here on the slide as well as on uh the letter that was included in with the audit uh audited financial statements uh but just some of the the higher uh things that we have to communicate uh we have to communicate whether there were any significant audit adjustments that had to be made as a result of our audit procedures to arrive at the numbers in the final financial statements I'm happy to report that there were none um so congratulations to Cheryl and her staff for another Stellar job uh there was only one past adjustment which uh we both felt was immaterial to the financial statements just regarding the uh the placement of the Arbitrage uh liability with regards to the the bonds um some of the other areas of communication are are significant
104estimates the largest estimate that's embodied in the district's financial statements is a state Foundation Revenue because it truly is estimate changes throughout the year and even after the the audit is over um there no difficulties uh in conduct in the audit we received everything in a timely manner um that we needed to uh to conduct our audit and uh no disagreements over application of accounting principles or anything like that um and then I finally want to share with you a few financial highlights um these numbers come from both this year's financial statements as as well as the previous fiscal year I like to start with the district's uh governmental revenues which totaled $249.90 million uh increase over the previous year so pretty pretty flat with the prior year and it really was the net effect
105of a few things going on the local revenues uh decreased by $15.8 million that was mostly the property taxes and a lot of that had to do with the the increase in the homestead exemptions uh Federal revenues decreased 9.2 million as we saw that the essr programs coming to an end and uh State revenues increased by $26.2 million and this just shows you a side by-side comparison of those three sources of revenue over the past three years and you can see the local revenues uh decreasing uh by 15.8 million State program Revenue increasing by 26.2 and the federal program revenues uh decreasing by 9. too uh similar presentation with regards to the governmental expenditures of the district which total 379.99 million increase over the previous year but most of this was attributed to the 27.9
106million increase in construction uh with all the the construction going on in the district um that was really the the only uh significant increase as you can see here this slide shows you the various functional areas of expenditures and the only one that really increased was uh was that and that's because of the timing of the construction really uh fund balances for the district as of uh August 31st were $188.7 million the majority of that or 111.2 million is in the capital projects fund a lot of that was Bond money that was issued in previous years the overall governmental uh fund balance uh decreased by $129 million but again uh it it's all because of the timing of the construction uh versus the the issuance of the bonds the bonds were issued in previous year
107you're spending down those those funds this year so the fund balance goes down uh unassigned fund balance in the general fund was $6.9 million and that represents uh 39.3% of general fund expenditures which is considered a very healthy amount um finally this slide shows a budgetary uh comparison schedule for the general fund for fiscal year 2024 and overall it was a favorable budgetary variance of $16.7 million and that's really uh comprised of a couple things the revenues were over budget by $1.4 million and expenditures were under budget by 15.1 um so overall U very good audit and again thanks to Cheryl and her staff for um for doing a great job and with that I'd be happy to answer any questions that you might have I just have a comment um this district is obviously
108not without its challenges uh but I just want to say thank you to Cheryl for for making this not one of them absolutely it could be could be a big heading for us thank you Miss Davis Miss Davis can ask a question yeah relating to this slide in particular this one um we had a projected deficit um in this uh slide of Revenue uh and expenses and it looks like we ended up with 7,000 um Less in expenses than revenues is that correct the ACT ual vers revenues overe expenses or I mean million I'm sorry the 161 Revenue the actual versus the 154 expense deficit y that that's my question is um was that I know that we changed the budget quite a bit to get as low as we could but we still had
109an unknown number there um did did we just not spend money that we had budgeted to spend or how did because I was prepared to have a fund balance decrease um greater than greater than that oh yeah fs and not so that about five and half we also injects we had I do we anticipate this next year's Cliff that we've talked about being less steep or tall because we've moved stuff into this year or so will let fected it all for next year's numbers okay so um we adopted a budget with about a $8 million deficit right I would expect that we would underspend that by say half about three to four million anyway typically we have now amended in the 2 million that was left in projects from last year which included the halil
110damage the roofing projects and all and uh open purchase orders we had we had ordered a lot of buses we had about a million dollars worth the the main things was the million dollars in the hail project damage and then a million dollars in buses that we rolled forward because the buses had not come in as of the end of August so those two things the buses some of those buses have arrived not all of them but that million dollars will definitely hit this year it would be on top of that 8 million we had budgeted as a deficit if we get the roofs and all done um that will be to yeah so we should but again I think we'll we typically under spend you know three to four million do so I would
111expect that we are also tonight we amended in some projects because part of what didn't get spent in Esser was some projects for maintenance that never did get allocated so that was part of the 2 million we amended in tonight is going to the maintenance department to help cover some projects that they need to do that's so we've rolled a few things over that will increase the deficit for next year but we're going to still UND spend UND spend yeah um now I still haven't we have had some issues with trying to project student attendance this year because of Tea's new uh system for reporting pems but um I'm getting ready to tackle that we know we are down a few some more students and what I had projected much closer only with it in
112about 60 this year but we'll still lose a little bit of money there I think um overall you know I'm hoping it ends up at you know maybe a four or million dollar deficit in the current year we have a very healthy fund balance as John said of 65 million we've got get we got to stay above 20% is that right under our policy yes Bo policy and we're at 39 right now yes okay Cheryl Keeps Us in good shape thank you well I mean you know we have been I I think the other thing that I do I'm a little concerned about when we had all that eser money we had left a lot of things like we left a lot of things on the table in the general fund that didn't get spent
113because we were trying to spend the exra money first so we no longer have that money we were using that money for tutoring and all sorts of things that we now no longer have so I think we'll see a little bit less of an undere expenditure sure than we have been but thank you so M Davis you're if I heard you correctly we're looking at a 4 million is deficit for next year well that's right now because I have not uh really started it's just you know we just ended Clos books on December I usually start my my first real expenditure projections after January closes because we start getting into that second semester of positions filled and all so um I will we'll probably do a presentation we usually do our first one to kind
114of catch up on where we ended and where it looks like we're going to do maybe in this year and What legisl legislation is looking like right good or bad and um anyway so we'll probably start that February or March time frame okay thank you for your work okay she knows her numbers she does any other questions for Mr deuro okay you know what you did you kept it brief thank you so much and very clear and concise so thank you that is thank you so much a definite art we appreciate it thank you um okay moving on to item number 11 announcements Miss Cox good evening president cwig Dr Spicer trustees I have to say these name plate thank you cards bright colors are a lot of fun um thank you to all of
115our campuses those heavy gift bags are from all across the district all across our departments as along with these signs we may have to think about leaving them up a little longer they make it they bright and cheery happy New Year and welcome to the 89th Texas legislative session I know we've already talked a little bit about it you're going to be hearing more later but we're in it um filing is underway Statewide for the May 3rd general election it ends on February 14th we have more information on our website at w.org elction go check it out um the competition is heating up for the annual wo IST Education Foundation HB celebrity Cookoff on Friday January 31 that's next Friday I know I'm standing in front of three of the 26 Chef teams that will
116be competing um individual tickets are still available to enjoy the taste of the special event that directly impacts Innovative instruction and student Scholarships in Waco ISD I'm not taking bets on who's going to win but I can't wait to taste it so the next day we hope to see you and many of our students and families at at the S oh yeah coach love put pressure on him he's a judge too he is a judge pressure can go that way um the next day we hope to see you and many of our students and families at the synex teen bookfest on the brazes that's Saturday February 1 wo ISD has again partnered with lit Waco to host a fun and exciting literacy family engagement event this year it will be at tennis and Middle School
117um from 9:30 to 3 thank you to Federal programs Courtney Carno I see you over there um nutrition services and transportation for their efforts to support this event provide meals and offer giveaways for attendees um the foll Saturday students from across the district will be competing in our annual Elementary and Middle School U competition at UHS it is a full day of educational fun and competition on Saturday February 8th thank you to our teachers administrators parents and community members and Education Foundation board members and all the like that come to judge um and support this really special event that brings together um campuses from across the district that's what I have for you did did you mention tomorrow is also the chili cook off at Tennyson Middle School I would you like to share more
118at 5:30 I know I'm judging and I think Jose might be and if I understand correctly Wendy correct me if I'm wrong it's it that's a special event that campus holds to benefit the library or the library CL I think that sounds exactly right yes yes y it was a lot of fun last year a lot of fun I'm coming not a lot of heartburn right like it was just lot lots of heartburn lots of fun lots of heartburn yeah anything else that I it's a busy time Co Saturday is it Andrew bilding and and that's at University because I think at wake oh high we have ROTC drill meet there's and 30 schools with the drill meet I'm G repeat with 30 schools participating from across the region yep Central Texas and then uh
119Mr vid told me uh January 28th 28th University versus cleen Ellison basketball basketball it's I mean I think we we haven't beat them in a couple maybe five in a row I mean they're a good team but that's boy boys basketball correct boys basketball be a fun game that'll be a good game we are we are definitely in the winter sports with soccer and basketball and lots of great exciting things thank you for sharing that thank you so much Miss Cox lots of good stuff happening okay the board is going to go into closed uh session at 806 uh this time pursuant of the Texas open meeting act Texas government code 551 sections 072 and 071 no action will be taken when we reconvene call this meeting closed at 9:33 p.m.