CorpusRecord 152423

MLSD Regular School Board Meeting - February 6, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Moses Lake School District
Date
2025-02-07
Location
Grant County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,037 words · about 67 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening and welcome to the regular session of the Moses Lake School directors board meeting it is Thursday February 6 2025 and the time is 6 PM um Miss will you please take a rooll for us Ryan couston here Paul Hill here cin Jensen here Carla Urias Amy brightenstein here thank you so much if you'll all remove your hats and silence your cell phones we'll stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay first up I have um minutes from January 23rd from our regular meeting if you've all had a chance to review those yeah yes I noticed a I think it's a spelling error I

002don't know do we want to correct those probably um see if I can find it it's supposed to say culinary and I think it's it's spelled wrong um so if we just want to correct that um I'll take a motion to approve the minutes with the spelling correction move that we approve the minutes uh with the change as noted s second second I okay our minutes have been approved are there any any changes or additions to tonight's agenda no okay all right so um at this time I'll accept a motion for uh the adoption of tonight's agenda I will move that we adopt tonight's agenda I'll second okay all in favor I any opposed okay the agenda has been adopted okay U we'll move on to recognitions and this week is National School counseling week

003and Robbie and Trisha yes thank you so yes we are here to honor our counselors in the district and I see several amount in the the crowd so we're pleased pleased to have them here and pleased to recognize them so this week I have something written here and I want to make sure I say it just right this week we proudly celebrate National School counseling week and recognize the incredible dedication of our school counselors who play an essential role in the success and well-being of our all our students schools and communities so school counselors do so much more than provide academic guidance they are Advocates mentors and problem solvers who support students social emotional and behavioral development they work tirelessly to foster a positive School environment offering interventions and strategies that help students navigate challenges

004and develop the skills needed for lifelong success but there's more to the story yes which I'm happy to share and acknowledge beyond our school walls counselors serve as a bridge between families and schools strengthening connections and ensuring students receive the support that they need to be successful and Thrive by collaborating with teachers parents and Community Resources they create a network of care that empowers students to overcome obstacles and reach their full potential to all school counselors those who are here and those who were not able to make it we sincerely thank you very much for your unwavering commitment your compassionate guidance and your true dedication to making a difference in the lives of every student every day your impact truly is immeasurable and we are incredibly thankful for each of you and for all that

005you do you are a blessing to our school district and make such a difference on a day-to-day basis and we recognize your hard work and thank you all we appreciate you and all you do and we have some certificates that we would like to award do you want to just have them all comeing up yeah how about if we have all of our counselors just come on up face the board yeah okay so how do we want to do this let's okay I'm just going to start with my secondaries this might be a little because there's so many of you um and I only have oh my goodness yes okay so oh that would help me so Kylie bakes from Frontier Middle School and then we'll have to go oh Karina's here sorry Karina esamia

006from Moses Lake High School I feel like I'm at an award ceremony FL jelly flukiger from Frontier Middle School and Van and Vanguard yes you didn't skip Emily Bratton did you I not yet that's me okay oh Sarah lson from Frontier Middle School she tried to skip over her name thank you Sarah for jumping in to help me with this Chris Mason from Columbia Middle School and this does not go without mentioning Brody and we will make it right with Brody we didn't have a certificate tonight for him Amber Sanson from Moses Lake High School and Emily Bratton is a special visitor tonight from Vanguard Academy all righty representing our elementary team we have codio custodio Valencia sorry custodia Park orchard Elementary congratulations thank you and Jette Serrano Vasquez from grath elementary thank you and

007we have Elizabeth Martinez from Sage point thank you Elizabeth and Mary Cardwell from Midway along with midway's therapy dog Logan Cardwell I'd like to point out that Logan even has his own School B ONN too and she's on her way okay and then Allison McCarthy is on her way she is in an intern at Midway so we thank you very much for all your hard work we are appreciated thank you he's IGN you yeah thank you thank you all very much for all you do thank you okay next up is our consent agenda uh if there are any questions questions or comments or anything I've got a couple poll yeah I had a couple questions too go ahead Paul okay under item C and go to the board summary 26 of 2025 in that this

008is the second time I've seen this um it shows some class overages and extra hours but it's listed as garnishments so I was wondering if somebody could explain yes I can I can uh provide an explanation and I think we need to get a um maybe a different way of labeling um I did ask our uh payroll department about this it's not actually garnishments as you would think um it was some additional um pay that that had to be paid on some time sheets that wasn't run as part of the regular payroll and so they can't call it payroll again they have to call it something different um and my understanding is garnishments is just kind of the stock thing that's in the in the system so that's why it's called that it's not actually

009garnishments so they aren't garnishments okay second item is item D under contracts and it is I got to open it sorry one two three fourth line item down ESD 171 shows a $27,000 contract I see Samy's name on it so I know it's special ed uh and it shows to be for four months is this a recurring see so I do believe that this is part of um something that we had in our m stck list which is contracted services with the estd for special um unique special education uh needs and so I believe that that's what that is and we can provide um further clarification of the actual contract um if you'd like okay I just need to be sure that's the end of my questions that it else have anything else um so

010I had some questions about the almost every one of these field trip requests thank you me too oh all of okay sorry um oh I'm sorry Start um let's start with the CTE one okay a couple CTE I just want to know first one yeah I just want to know for sure that so there's so there's some perdm pay and some sub pay it looks like on there and I just want to know it's not really clear but to me it seems like maybe student cost is covering that um no CTE is covering this this is one of their required um they call them ctsos and I don't know the acronym for that but we do have experts in the audience that can um follow up on that that they go to and so this

011particular one um um the perdum that is just we have to pay for food we have to pay the rate that the state has for us and so sometimes people just use that language per DM for the food so it's just a set price a set meal price for breakfast lunch dinner okay the sub is for two days um is the substitute costs for them being out and that's being paid through the CTE budget as well so aside from the student cost this is 100% funded by either CTE or ASB correct okay okay let's move yeah and I would just say if you noticed that a lot of these field or these student traveling and start calling them student travel trips have come through with this similar looking form this is our new form that

012we're a couple of people have been trying out so any feedback you have have that would make things more clear in the future we can make those adjustments but yeah I mean I can see how the cost can like labeling them the way that they're labeled can be a little bit difficult and so I'm not really sure that we'll ever get away 100% from having to you know clarify and ask questions but I mean we can try and just refine it as we go I suppose um the next one oh actually I didn't have a question about that one already I figured it out on my own and then the the form that for the State Bowling trip uhuh um that was also so this not very clear this one as you see it's not

013in the form so it's not you don't have a consistent look for it so I can understand why it's hard to find the information in there this is one of those events that um they qualified for this state event but they qualified January 31st so the timing is so short um and so this was put in um the funding for this is reimbursed by CAA for the Suburban mileage um ASB bowling for the hotel expenses and meals are on their own except for breakfast so everything's covered outside of Moses Lake School District funds well they and they left today right and that's the other problematic thing I disapprove yeah right so we we did um redo our procedure and so we'll have to talk with visit with you guys some other time about all of

014the subtleties of all the different student travels there's a lot of subtleties but we're really trying to streamline it so it's easier for you to not only evaluate but know what's going on so so I only have a few experiences before this right but uh so that's absolete now like what we saw before because this what I'm looking at is a form that's printed and scanned right like it's filled out online and then printed and then scanned and uploaded to the for which trip all of them all of them except the one that's the Google Doc right right um so that that was my main question is like what like what are these new forms how what's our system of getting these requests and and obviously there's still a little bit of inconsistency here but

015what I what I'm used to is obsolete is that what I'm hearing yes okay so is this what we're going to see are these filled out scanned items and they have to be hand signed then yes now we're still in the transition phase so okay um you know we're going to be working on communicating that out we just had a few groups try the form out because we're we're trying to make it user friendly and get the information that we need so there might be some subtle adjustments here and there but um yes in the very very near future that is going to be systematized okay um because all of these look different anyway still well that's this you have trip request form field trip co-curricular and extracurricular there's two of those categories and then

016we have a field trip during the school day request form does have to be different no so even this week we've gone through reiterate how can we make this this more streamlined so yeah I just had a question on the um migrant um education trip um about the bus that they're taking yes and I have Nick here to explain more about the migrant um if you want to come up to the Podium yes yeah okay so that one is um an event in esd123 which is in Pasco and uh it's for the it's paid out of the migrant program which are federal funds for um students that experience interruptions in their education and uh this particular um field trip is U related to family engagement as well as uh academic support so it's paid out

017of federal funds that we're expected to use towards things like this and then the busing is um that way because Transportation wasn't able to provide and so we had to go with that route what what is an interruption in education you said yeah so so the migratory lifestyle you know they they move around following the harvests and so they might enroll on one school district during a part of the year and then they enroll on a different District during another part of the year and so the migrant program is designed to smooth out those interruptions with extra support okay and so the transportation looks like the funding source is it's not fully listed here but was that the question on the transportation well um it shows that they're taking a charter bus for 1,870 but

018it says funding sources Grant right yeah M the migrant Title One Part c not using charter buses just yeah it was unavoidable in this situation we did we did try you know to use our sources okay locally weren't able to but this is funded through their own Federal program absolutely so it's not coming out of the general fund not at all and theol district is not funding it so okay okay any other questions just a thank you this is so nice having forms that have all the information yeah they're definitely it's better we're getting there they're not perfect yet but we're getting there so okay okay all right so if nobody else has any other questions or comments I'll accept a motion to approve our consent agenda for tonight my motion we approve consent agenda

019I'll second okay all in favor I any oppos okay our consent agenda has been approved all right double check this section here okay it does look like we have one inperson comment I'll just read this little section here and then we'll have our speaker come up all right so when your name is called please come to the podium State your uh name and where you live uh you'll have three minutes to share your comments please keep your comments civil and remember not to comment on specific students or Personnel matters the board will not address your comments during this meeting and if we need to we will refer to the superintendent for followup so our speaker tonight is Kim Pope welcome back welcome just make sure your green light is on no okay push it for

020about five seconds all uh my name is Kim Pope uh from Moses Lake uh thank you for the opportunity to speak this evening my name is Kim Pope I'm the executive director of the Boys and Girls Clubs of the Columbia Basin we currently have a main Clubhouse and five School based locations at North Larson Long View Midway and most recently Vanguard Academy for our teens as most people are aware we do not charge families to have their children attend the school based locations including for the teens we work hard at fundraising which is always a challenge to ensure there are no barriers for the families that we serve as a majority of our club families are free and reduced lunch eligible for example 98% of the families that use our North Club are free or

021reduced lunch eligible 96% at Larson and 92% at Long View our team program has 94% free or reduced lunch eligible families as you can see we're reaching the families that need us most all of these school-based locations rely on the ability ility to utilize facilities after school while in the facilities we completely clean our areas so we do not add burden to the custodians work with all of this in mind I'm here tonight to implore the community vote for the levy Levy without it I fear our clubs will not be able to utilize the school facilities and approximately 700 youth would have no options for after school programming or care my last topic oh wait a second I got another page here um as mentioned these are some of the most vulnerable and atrisk youth

022in Moses Lake although my children are grown I feel I must represent the underserved in the community when when I attended the CAA meetings there were aone parents there who had the means to pay for their children to participate in a sport or activity but what about the families without the means do their children not deserve the same opportunities like many I don't want to see my taxes increase however I can't think of a more worthwhile reason for my tax money to be spent than to help youth I hear a lot of people have said we should go back to the basics Reading Writing and arithmetic while that is great in theory that also means the youth in our community will fall behind everyone else this will mean that they won't be able to get

023into colleges or be selected for good paying jobs in the future they will struggle as adults and not be able to take care of their families or give back to the community because they will not meet the same qualifications as people that received the full educ ation as a parent I've always wanted more for my children than I had not in monetary means but in opportunities to thrive and grow my last topic is second chances I would ask the community whether they have ever made a mistake did they pay the price for that and were they given a second chance if so please consider this when thinking about the school district there was a mistake made but there have been numerous actions taken to correct the error to ensure the error isn't repeated and there's

024a significant change in administ ministration and the composition of the school board can we not give them a second chance again thank you for the opportunity to express my plead at the public get out and vote please keep our kids in the Forefront and our community viable for the future of our youth thank you I had six seconds left yeah thank you so much all right so we'll move on to Old business we have the discussion of policy and procedure 1620 okay so um the last board meeting I brought this policy and procedure forward to the board not necessarily because um we need to review this but it's it's one of those things that um it it deals with the board superintendent relationship and so um I had just suggested that we maybe take a

025look particularly at the procedure which um was written during a certain period of time in our school district um and I don't know that the procedure really reflects um the the way we want to operate um currently so I'm just looking for some uh feedback input thoughts from the board members on how we may um may want to go forward we did include the model procedure that um that wasda has and so um that's a starting point but I'm just curious particularly with the the model procedure if board members have something um any comments or suggestions for how we might want to make that um unique to Moses Lake well I would just like to say that the visits to the school I can't wait to start doing that again because we've been so busy

026so I miss doing that but that's really good for the board I you know and so yeah I'm looking forward to doing in continuing um it all has really just stood out I think good with yeah I haven't seen any changes that so I reviewed a few other Eastern Washington school district um policies and procedures with relation to this school board and and superintend relationship policies um and one section in the kenowick uh one that really stood out to me and it was actually in their policy but I I think that it could relate to the procedure part of it might be can you know we could consider adding it um talked about the mutual respect of between the responsibilities of board members and their responsibility to the community um and then also you know

027the board members respecting the responsibilities that the superintendent holds um so just just kind of having that mutual respect relationship it kind of just really Drew in on that and it was pretty specific so um if I was to add anything that's I might make a mention of that but I will make a note of that and we can we can look at that language from Kenwick and come back with this and again this is a procedure so it's not technically approved by the board but of course it's it's but it's important I mean it's one that I the Board needs to obviously be involved in so um so I don't necessarily feel that it's like it's not so important in my opinion because I feel like it does kind of talk about that but

028at the same time I I just really liked how they worded it so anybody else have any any uh suggestions or anything in there that that's not sitting well with you or anything like that more just a comment if you look at the policy the last time it was revised was November 8th of 2021 and this board superintendent relationship is completely different than what we've had in the past but also just I don't know I want the board to keep in mind though I think that it's important to remember that um not every board has a good relationship right off the bat with their superintendent um sometimes there isn't always lines open for communication so I think it's really important to set ourselves up for success and for future board success so if we're not

029always going to be sitting up here we want whoever takes our place to be able to thrive too so so on that note something that's been pretty fresh for me is just the receipt of information of Education you know like a basic overview of so I don't know if that this is where that would fit in of like maybe a mutual expectation of like you know maybe it is the superintendent's responsibility maybe it's someone else is but to give a briefing you know to kind of catch them up to Snuff on stuff quicker uh like I said I don't know if that's this is the right spot for that or even if it's necessary or if it just needs to be kind of a superintendent's like hey this is just what I've always done so

030just a thought Ryan actually adding something like that in as a guide for the superintendent and the board would be a good idea so I think that's a good suggestion so we can find somewhere to whether it's in this procedure or somewhere else I think that it is important to have something like that written down like within the first x amount of time you know yeah okay and so if you're talking about the procedure there is a section in here in communication so I think that's the one oh uh oh it is you're right sorry and there I'm sorry yes you're correct but we can always add that yeah or you can all right any other suggestions or comments no okie dokie thank you yeah yeah so we'll move on to new business um we

031have policy 1000 um would you Carol like to talk with the board about that one yeah so this is another one that we're just um bringing forward for review there aren't any suggested changes but um again these 1,000 series policies are all about the board's operation and so this is part of part of that um that education p P for for all of us and particularly board members on Just What policies do govern our um our our actions and so um so this one again is just kind of going into um what the legal status of the board um basically establishing the board as a as an entity and we've had lots of conversations about that um we had a work study session um really got into the idea that the board um the board

032exists as an entity and individual board members never constitute the board by themselves and so so that's really what this um this gets at so okay any discussion on that any comments or anything from anybody okay well the purpose of these two is just to review them and then we'll come back next meeting and talk about it um so then um one5 as well yeah so 005 again we've had a work study session on this too but um this really highlights the key functions of the board and I will read those out loud just for those listening um so responsible governance creating conditions for student and staff success high expectations for student learning accountability for student learning and Community engagement so again there are no recommended changes here this policy is already adopted but I

033do think it's important to highlight these things for the board the the community and anybody have any comments or questions or anything about that one okay we'll move on to our inclement weather discussion so since we've had some really cold temperatures recently there's been a lot of discussion around indoor versus outdoor recess and I'd like to just open it up right now for some discussion um and then also have Carol just kind of give us some background information about the specific topic I know that there's been staff that have brought concerns um at different locations there maybe a um a higher P poverty level with their student um body and so concerns that some of these kiddos aren't showing up to school with uh sufficient protection coats you know sweaters gloves so that was some

034that they were concerned about um and espec especially talking the time that they get there and the time that they're waiting to go so the before school and the after school but um I'm sure there's other things we'll cover in this but that was just a couple things that were pointed out comments um I was picking up my kid at gra today and I seen a kid riding a bike with shorts oh my oh my goodness wow what is the policy for clothing in Le he was moving I guess yeah do you want me to give give a little bit yeah I was going to say if we could just talk a little bit about kind of what we what we do yeah as a school district it's great that our counselors are here I'm

035not going to ask them to come up and talk about it but our counselors do have a pretty significant role in all of this um and I know when we're hearing you know the kid riding with shorts and things like that I mean we um we do and I know in all of our schools we have clothing closets they're all nodding right every time I'm in a school office and it's this time of year and a little kid comes down and says I don't have a coat the counselor or somebody in the office gets them a coat so we do um I can't think of a circumstance when we wouldn't have something available or an option available for our kids some of our kids choose to you know go out and in clothing we wouldn't

036choose for ourselves or our own children um and parents you know have the have the the right to send their kids to to school and whatever and of course if there's a concern for safety um again our counselors are going to be the ones that are going to help out with that and so but we do I mean right counselors yes if we were concerned for their safety um so this is a great discussion to have with with all of you here tonight um but we had also become aware of some discrepancies in this policy um and our practices and so we do have a policy a current policy and it's called school closures which is why it's hard to Fig find don't we have something about indoor recess and inclement weather and we do

037um but then there's also a newer law that's come about so this is a policy that we actually had already been planning on bringing to the board next at the next meeting the second meeting in February to adjust so we can get some consistency and the new whack that um came out um specifies 20 degrees as the the temperature for um for keeping kids inside or where it may be hazardous and so we're going to work with Robbie is already and Robbie please jump in Robbie's already working with our principles um to talk about okay you know how do we want to how do we want to get consistent with this we always want to make sure we take into account the windchill um because that's not always clear so we want to just write

038it down make sure everybody's super clear on you know it's this temperature with the windchill and so we are working on revising our policy to uh be more consistent across our system and and also just know that that our our counselors and other staff are amazing at making sure that our kids have the clothing that they need to protect themselves from the cold when it is time to go outside so anything to add Robbie yeah this um given when the concerns have come our way um today was the first opportunity at a principal meeting that I had to just start addressing it with them um the specific concerns and the new language of this whack that we became aware of so we appreciate um the concerned folks folks making sure that we had this information

039for sure um yeah we'll continue to take a look at it and um have conversations because we certainly want to make sure that what we're doing is an accurate reflect is accurately reflected in our policy and procedure and we already are out of line with the procedure we most of our schools as we've had discussions as a team before um operate with a range of temperature 16 to 17 to 20 degrees and then also recognize shorter durations outside and longer durations outside and one of the conversations that we had as a principal team today is that um first and foremost obviously the Safety and Security of our kids we want to keep them safe indoors and Outdoors and Carol addressed some different components of that with clothing um but this year's unique as well um

040um because we also have a limited number of recess supervisors that are constantly cycling in and cycling out so I just want I think the obvious point of conversation as we started is student student safety as it should be but I just want to let you know that's one of the layers of the conversation that we had today also so I I'm happy if you have any other questions to respond to that from an elementary practitioner's um knowledge Point um do you feel like after having the discussions today that that the lower amounts of staff that we're talking talking about that you just mentioned is that going to become an issue I you know we we always do what the law tells us that we need to do bottom line so um that wax specifically

041addresses that 20 degrees Fahrenheit um again always in consideration and we do that now with the feels like temperature the wind chill um but it it it certainly looks like we need to make a change with that 20 degree mark because that's what the whack um asks us to do one of the considerations with the whack too and I don't know if you've had a chance to take a look at that and Ryan and I have had a few different conversations about um looking and gathering information what what districts what districts are doing that are of comparable uh size with us though that's that's not so significant but um in similar geographical locations too what are some of the other policies and procedures um now that may or may not make a difference in consideration

042but also phraseology of the whack is the um 20 degrees Fahrenheit or pursuant to advice of the local authori so Ryan is going to be and possibly already has done is reaching out to our our our health authorities in our district to to get some guidance from them so those are just some of the conversations that we've had in the last couple of days at our level and also with principles I just meant as far as Staffing goes do we have we're we're going to be okay with like shifting people around in that case well given limited Staffing that will present some challenges for us with indoor recess who is going to do the supervision with limited Paras Staffing so when we're talking about increasing the temperature possibly of indoor recess we've been really fortunate

043this season I mean we've had we certainly have had days that we've had to call for inclement weather considering the temperature in the windsh and sometimes that happens in the morning and then it warms up or the wind dies down and our kids can go out um later but that's that's going to be a challenge that we're going to have to address because we only have two supervisory pairs so okay thank you yeah that's I've seen how hard those people work too um okay any other do you yeah what uh just out of curiosity sake where does the clothing come from that is something times provided we have um very very generous families and communities who um recognize the need of our local school children so in many of our sites either the counselors are

044reaching out to Community Resources or we have parents that say I have three coats I have four coats I have some new hats and mittens can we please donate them to your school yeah thank you you communities and schools also is um a partnership that we have with that organization and um they help help out in many many situations but also in what are the resources that you need whether it's food or whether it's clothing um shirts pants underwear socks coats boots all of those things oh the whole okay that's that's great we have a variety of things in our wow that's amazing so these locations have a closet for you know lack a better term but they have a closet we find the nooks and crannies that we can put clothing for our kids

045I've even seen that we have a washer and dryer and we've had we've been able to help students that there have been many occasions that the counselor um uh primarily the counselor but also the principals or a teacher will absolutely um help out in that way as well is is it intended to be gift to the student or is it a is it like a hey bring it back in a couple weeks like what's the most of the time when we're giving out a piece of clothing um we we don't expect for it to be returned because right certainly things like socks and you know undergarments we would never take back even if the things that we could have and should have donated to schools versus you know local Charities but I yeah I didn't

046know that existed so I know not something I ever even thought about but now I will be thinking about it 100% yeah yes um some of our schools um um will periodically send out in their newsletter hey cold weather is coming if you've got any you know clean coats or uh sweatpants or boots that um you'd like to donate please know that we would be happy to accept them okay anything else anybody no all right okay so we'll move on to our information items and looks like Carol's going to give us our financial report tonight thank you so much for all that all right well I have the financial update for tonight and so I'll just go ahead and move through this please uh go easy on me because I'm not usually the one giving

047this but I will try to answer all your questions um so um as we know finances are driven by enrollment so the first part of this is always enrollment comparison um and the budgeted line is kind of that red line that looks a little different that goes straight across um and then the orange line with the numbers it shows the um where we're actually at so we want our actual enrollment to be at least what we budgeted and it's better if it's a little more so um in the case of special education enrollment it is uh above um special that is the one area where if we get too high above then we do you know we run into some um some some ways that we have have to switch our funding around um and

048my understanding is that we're real close to that 16% threshold um but we've been considering how we're going to respond to that and we have some good plans in place for that um so HC stands for headcount so enrollment by headcount comparison um again we are above that projected line and that it definitely is where we want to be right now and um FTE is again that full-time enrollment so that's uh takes into account what percent of the time a student spends at school and so we're um we're again kind of right on on that and so um we need to really be watching that cbtech it has higher enrollment than was anticipated and um so transitional bilingual instructional program so that's what that tbip stands for um and again again we get funding um

049based on on the amount of students that that we have uh anticipate in that program and then running start we have pretty high uh running start enrollment this year you guys have seen all these it's just the next the next next line so I'm just going to keep going through unless you want me to stop um open doors we don't you don't have expected enrollment for open doors and that just climbs as the school year goes on as we find more students that we can re-engage in education and then um Alternative Learning um that's our um digital program and so we can see that that number has been climbing um throughout the throughout the school year as well and then uh CTE um in honor of it being uh we just honored CTE last last

050board meeting and so this got thrown in there it's just hey what's our CTE enrollment like and so there you can see that um that orange line up there at the top is um and we're over at the high school level and our high school includes all of our high schools and then um Middle School CTE is a little lower than what we expected and I'm I'm not 100% sure why that is but um but we can have further discussion if anybody wants to on that one um and then when we look at our general fund so we have those five funds and the the general fund comparison year-over-year you can see their um that's the cash we have and that the shorter line of course is this year so and then capital projects um

051that's fairly consistent for this year we haven't we haven't done any major capital projects or had any um any significant um Revenue into that fund so it's pretty flat um Debt Service um no concern there that's following the usual Trend that that a school district sees you go to any school district really you'll see this this graph looks really similar um and then ASB that's of course the students money the students um make that money and they decide how they spend that money so that's where we're sitting with ASB and transportation vehicle fund I know that we've ordered some buses um but we haven't um they haven't shipped or whatever so we haven't paid for those buses yet but um so that money will just sit there until the buses chip and then that'll go

052down and then next year it'll come back up again um when we look at this this is that three-year comparison of revenues and of course we know that um our expected Revenue this year is quite a bit less than what our Revenue was last school year and so um what's interesting here and important for us to remember and and watch is that um so in 2022 December 2022 we had received 27 uh% of our Revenue um 23 it was 29% and by December of this year we'd already received 32% of our revenue and that's because we know that the um Levy and Lea Revenue that we normally would have is not going to continue on in 2025 and so we've already received a greater portion of our Revenue than is typical for our school district

053at this time um it that's not problematic but it is something to note and um something for us to be really careful about how we watch um and and the reason why we cannot um really relax any of our spending practices at this time so and then when we look at our three-year comparison of expenditures this is the opposite news and this is this is good um in that our we've only spent 31% of our um of our expected expenditures whereas in previous years we had spent 35 and average of 35% and so so this means that we you know our spending has been curtailed and we are um you know we're doing what we need to do to to hold um and not and and we are just looking today at some some cash

054projections and things and um as long as we can continue on the pattern we're on we anticipate that we will um end the year in a in a good spot um a better spot than was originally projected um during the August budget hearing and so so that's good you know we're we're not um we're not concerned that we're we're going down a path that's going to lead us to to you know anything like what happened last year and in fact should end that the year with a higher fund balance than what was anticipated so and then that's highlighted again here to revenues over expenditures in the last couple of um uh t a year um we've had more expenditures and revenues and in December of 24 we had more Revenue than expenditures so that's good

055all right any questions again go easy I just have a comment to say that I'm pretty proud where we're at so yes we're we're making this making the situation work for us and and we're we're gonna keep holding on tight and we're gonna not relax our our practices around spending thank you so much okay thank you and then right into your we can that's why I just start in fact my superintendent report actually adds a slide into this so here we go but Ryan has to help me with getting the thing figured out here okay right on into the superintendent report um I didn't have access to change that budget report and if I had I had wanted to add um just something in that's interesting when you think about school district budgets and monthly

056expenditures and revenues and such and so before I get too far into my superintendent report this is something that I had included in a informational video that I did maybe earlier this week but when we look at the uh the way that money is distributed to school districts in our state you can see that apportionment it does not come on equal Cycles right every month is not the same it's fairly consistent throughout the school year with two significant exceptions um a portion is much lower in the months of November and may um and June and that is because the state anticipates that every school district will have a levy collection and so um so that's that's something to watch and that's why when you've heard um me or Mitch say um you know we we

057get worried in November and we get worried in May about cash flow because the the income into the district is is significantly less during those times we made it through November just fine without any you know any problems there we saw it go down a little bit um and so may is going to be another month where we just have to be really mindful that that fund balance may dip because because we're going to have to use um use what we have in our fund balance to offset that difference in a portion it so okay um so tonight's topics I have for my superintendent report are uh I want to talk just a little bit about information that we know is coming at us pretty fast and furious from the federal government uh I want

058to talk a little bit about moving forward with the facility use at Vanguard Academy for next year um we also have uh some interesting information about our grades 9 through 12 enrollment history that's something that continues to come up as questions in the community and so I thought well what does that look like and Trisha um and actually Brian did a lot of work to figure some things out and so I was going to share about that um I want to share about two committees that have been uh one's been meeting for a while one just started meeting the facility advisory committee and the financial oversite committee and then um some um thoughts that we have about planning for kindergarten instructional hours so we'll start here with Federal changes so um so we know like

059I said there's a lot coming um from the from the federal level right now and there's been a lot of media that's gotten pretty heightened um around some of the some of the things that are being um being decided at the federal level and so what I want to say about those things is that we need to wait for guidance to be developed at both the federal and state levels before changing our policies procedures and practices um so so we we pay attention but we wait until we have the actual guidance um so so it's like the you know a policy can be made made or an executive order can be made but then what what's actually the the the guidance and the the procedure that's that goes along with that we need to know

060that um we need to pay care very careful attention to all that information and we are um we will communicate after we have that clear guidance and um sometimes we do have to respond because you sometimes media um causes a lot of concern for our students and our families and our community and so when that happens we try to respond with the best information we have and be as clear as we can and we just need to continue until and this is always the way it is with these kinds of things you follow your current policies and procedures until there's other guidance that becomes available and so so that's what we're doing in Moses Lake I do want to say some federal changes that we're watching Pretty uh closely and contined you know every day

061to to get new information and wait and see so we have that indoctrination in K12 schooling uh topic that is is in the news um the expanding uh freedom and opportunities for families we have pres presidential orders to withhold federal funds I will say that that order um is um not including our our major educational funds that come so that's a good thing um nor is um at the state level um our governor um ordered a 6% reduction in all all areas except education so so we we know that as of right now those are that's the case um we know we have some immigration policy changes and we know we have the title 9 reversal that's all going on so I don't have comments on these again because we don't have the specific guidance

062um to to go along with all of these but I just want the board and the public to know that we're aware of all these things we're watching them and as we are able to we will provide the guidance and and potential policy changes for Moses Lake School District that go along with it okay any any any questions here it's a pretty big all these things are a pretty big deal and so I'm I don't take it lightly and I'm glad we're keeping an eye on everything I mean there's a lot going on there's a ton of it's like a fire hose out there so yeah it's I like the weight to see because you never know when things are going to change at the last minute either right right and there speculation and and

063folks hear about speculation and they think it's it's reality and it's it's not all the time and so we just need to just need to sit tight and watch and and then follow up on the actual changes and guidance that come along with it okay so I just wanted to um remind the board um and a couple of board members um Paul and Ryan are on this committee but we have a facility advisory committee that was actually started last school year and we picked that back up this school year and really the purpose of that committee is to take a look at um what's what what's our use of our facilities what's the cost of those facilities um how do we make the best choices going forward and really think forward with you know what

064are we going to do you know next year five years from now 10 years from now how are we planning for the good stewardship of taxpayer dollars when it comes to our facilities and so um in September that committee started examining enrollment data and looked at the what what is the staff cost um per student per school so what does it cost you know in all of our different schools um in Octo oober um the committee started looking at the operational cost so we put put the operational layer on top of what do our what are our schools cost for staff uh we had a joint meeting in November December because of the the shortened months there um so um that committee began looking at the use of all available spaces in our buildings so

065you know are we how are we using all of the spaces that we have that'll lead into another topic for tonight the the Vanguard topic that's not the only place where we have space issues that we need to think about um but it's a big one and then in January we talked about uh the ways to utilize the Vanguard building in 25 and 26 to maximize our funds and we had a work study session about that shortly after we had that um that meeting in January so that's what the facility advisory committee has been up to in short um I do plan to have that committee probably in the next month or two report out somebody from the committee not me report out to the board um how how that's going and maybe some of

066the preliminary recommendations that the committee has made so I do so this is where I want to so this this next thing came out of a lot of questions from the community along with the work of that facility advisory committee and so um so this is just it's interesting and I know that um you know this board was not here when decisions were made I wasn't here when decisions were made but we started really thinking about enrollment versus capacity across our school district and our high school population and so the um the bottom Red Line there that flat Red Line um is the capacity of Moses Lake High School um so that's 1800 students and that changed it went from 1600 to 1800 sometime in the late 90s we can't pinpoint it exactly but somewhere

067between 95 and 97 um there was an there was a a renovation in addition to Moses Lake High School and that brought the capacity of that that school to 1,800 that does not include the Portables that are there so so the Portables add some additional capacity but remember Portables are not considered part of the building when the state considers our square footage and things like that so we do have some Portables at Moses Lake High School and then the black line you see kind of climbing gradually those are were the enrollment projections that existed um back several years um 2013 and and forward there so those are the enrollment projection projections that were being used when when bonds were thought of and and things like that the blue line is the the up and down

068line there is the 9 through 12 enrollment across our whole district and we rounded it down to the nearest 10 just to make it a little more simple and because enrollment changes every day you know I mean it can be different on every day um but that's the that's the enrollment um that you see there and so then the yellow line at the top um and I don't I don't bring this forward to to be controversial anything like that but it's just it that would be the capacity if the second high school that was um that you know that we talk about all the time that was approved by voters and there's a lot of controversy and I've publicly apologized that we don't have it and all of that that would be the total capacity

069that we would have we would have 3,400 because that school was um said to um be slated for 1600 kids and so um so that would be the the total capacity we would currently have in our schools if that school existed of course it doesn't but but this continues to come up and people keep asking me this question so I thought well let's let's answer it and then the green line is the current capacity that we have between Moses Lake High School and Vanguard Academy so you can see it's interesting that like right now um that green line the blue line and the black line are all kind of converging the projected enrollment the um the capacity that we have and our current enrollment so it's interesting data um and then this is just a

070zoomed in for the last few years on that so we can kind of see really where that all converges there okay so now um we have some we talked at our work study session on January 16th about some work that Trisha had been doing with our High School principles around um how could we going into this next school year utilize the space that we have because again going back to this we have enough space um between Vanguard Academy and Moses Lake High School for all the kids that we have so how do we then think about ways that we can get out of some rental situations and and um and also expand some programming at Vanguard Academy and so the things that we're ready to move forward with at this point are are two things

071um we have the digital Learning Center and if we move everybody out of that Center get them over to space that we have at Vanguard that will save us at least 61,000 $500 per year and so um so that would be a good a good move um and then we have um the opportunity to expand cbtech and they'll know more as they have kids um signing up for cbtech but they are pretty confident about the fact that we would be able to have approximately 70 additional um students able to attend cbtech and so that would generate and I want to be careful to say this isn't like income that we can put in our bank account um 42 2,000 or so to spend on those students so money comes in money goes out that's what

072we're supposed to do with money in public education you get this money to spend on the students you spend it on the students education and and that's how it works so it's not like we would increase our bank account by $400,000 but uh it would offer the opportunity to serve more students including Moses Lake High School students um through cbtech and so that's a a local and a a more Regional need and so so we're pretty comfortable with moving forward with those two um two suggestions and then um Vanguard staff are currently working on their um project and Mastery based learning program plan for 2025 um and Beyond and so um Trisha and I just have a few follow-up questions for them um around that and so we do anticipate that we will have um

073project-based Mastery based learning in the the name of Vanguard Academy at that school in the calendar year 25 or the school year 2526 and um so that's where we're at with all of that any questions all right um okay and then we have a financial oversight committee that's gotten a lot of attention in the news and it's great um so we started that on January 29th so just I guess that was last week wasn't it um so we had the first the first meeting of that group and it's made up of interested citizens one of the things I just want to clear this up for anybody listening um there was some idea that we had hand selected the members of that group we did not we put it out to the community and advertised and

074said hey who's you know who's interested and anyone who was interested was invited to attend it's made up of a lot of local folks who are um somehow involved in numbers or accounting um so we have some accountants we have some I think uh uh math professors things like that and um so that group got together for the first time and established four important priorities so they're up there ensuring every dollar spent benefits students because again that's that's our whole purpose is to benefit students in public education um to build a bridge between the district and the community make sure we have a long-range plan for our finances and then to support transparency and accuracy and I thought those were awesome priorities we did a little exercise that took all the reasons that they had

075said they wanted to be on that committee and boiled it down to those those four most important ones so we'll develop a like a mission statement out of those um and and go forward from there that group is also um going to be reporting to the board and so um you can expect that in the next few months as well okay now I want to talk a little bit about kindergarten planning so um we have instructional hour requirements for all of our grade bands and so we have a requirement and the so the requirements for kindergarten are unique because because um grades 9 through 12 um the requirement is 1080 hours grades 1 through 8 the requirement is 1,000 hours or you can average that all out and have an average of 1,27 hours across

076grades 1 through 12 but Kindergarten is called out specifically um as saying it needs to have a thousand hours of instruction and there is no second option for kindergarten and um we have known that our plan for um for our um shortened elementary school day um we've always known this and we talked about this um in in board meetings and with board members um since last summer that we're going to have to have do something to figure out what are we going to do to make up the few hours that we're going to be short for our kindergarteners everybody else is fine our kindergarteners are um short by about it's 53 right Robbie so 53 hours um and so so we need to do something about that um so we have had as you guys

077have seen this shown this a few different times few different reasons and ways that we've had this this planning thing that has all the all the big projects that we're working on at the district office and we at least once a month with the district office team we sit down and we we go through this and how are we doing and what do we need to add what can we cross off all of those things and so planning for those 53 hours has been at the Forefront of people's thinking since um since August um and at that time we did share with the board um that you know this that we know we're going to have to figure this out um and so we began working with the ESD first to say okay you know

078are there any waivers is there anything we can can do about this um we then we worked with ospi at the esd's suggestion about you know what are some things that we can do um we started talking with our labor unions about about possibilities within there uh we needed to involve Human Resources because whenever we do anything there's always a lot of Staff involved um and then um principles were brought into the loop and then the next thing that was planned and I just want to point this out um you can't read those up there necessarily but um back in November was when we said okay we need to start meeting with our um representatives from our labor unions which happened in the very early part of December um we and human resources and then

079in January if you could read it it says um that we're going to communicate with principles which happened um February was the time we had um scheduled to talk with teachers um in general about it um and then March was the time planned to um get a solidified plan presented to parents and so um so we've been we've been following that um so we know that we need to continue on through our plan um so the reason that I bring oops I skipped ahead too much um the reason that I'm I'm making kind of a big deal about our timeline um is that um we got um a letter in the mail today from a an anonymous Community member and the letter um was um indicating that this this person along with others felt like

080we have been trying to keep this a secret and I just want to call that out um and say that um there was never any intention to keep this a secret um we were trying to have a really thoughtful process that we worked through to figure out first of all do we need to do anything about this and second of all what are we going to do and how are we going to make sure that we're working through all of the layers within our organization before we communicate and um one of the things that I have really encouraged with my whole team this school year is that we really think thoughtfully about how the order in which we're doing things and being really thoughtful and strategic about our communication and one thing I've said repeatedly

081a lot um is we're an organization of teachers and so we need to be good teachers not only for our students but for our community and um and part of being a good teacher is to communicate clearly and when you know all the answers and not too much at one time you don't just throw it all out to everybody who needs the information everything all at once you do it strategically and in order and so um so I I did want to address that um that we did receive that letter and um that that I I I think that board members probably remember us talking about this in meetings um previously so um so so there was no no no intent to keep this information from anybody we were trying to communicate all of these

082things that are up there the um the red is the Strategic communication so every time you see you know some red up there that's where we're strategically communicating not only about what we do about these 53 kindergarten hours but about all the big initiatives that we have going on in our school district um so I also want to address the idea that um receiving a letter like that is a symptom of something that's been you know a concern of mine for quite a long time and um and I've said this and I'll say it again we need to change our culture in Moses Lake and our school district and in our relationship with the community um things like Anonymous reporting people coming to me and saying well somebody told me this but I can't tell

083you who it was because I'm afraid they're going to get in trouble or um you know um a lot of those things happen and people are people have said you know I've been afraid to talk to you because I'm afraid I'll get in trouble I've been afraid to talk to a board member because I think I'm going to get in trouble and that's a symptom of of mistrust and um and that that's heavy on my mind and people come to me and they say things like well you know I know you're busy and I know you don't want to hear this or they say um they say well you're not going to like what I have to say because I don't agree with you and I say I'm absolutely going to like what you have

084to say um we're never going to heal our school district or our community if we don't have honest face-to-face conversations so um so I'm just putting that out there to to to everybody um here and in the community that we want those honest conversations nobody's going to be in trouble because they have one if we don't have those we're going to continue to spal into um into a cycle of mistrust and I that's not where we need to be so I'm I'm glad to hear that because uh I'm afraid you're going to get mad at me for my short-term memory loss here but uh I I do you mind just going into addressing this like was the a th hours new like was that a new requirement then why aren't we hitting it like why

085did it start off because we had to discuss that for yeah we had to make some really tough financial decisions and I know Ryan this was before you came on the board um and um shortening that school day um saved overall about $3 million for our school district when we when we think about the cost of of addressing these 53 hours for our kindergarteners and Robbie's done a ton of work in this and and has you know a lot more information than than I'm I'm here ready to share tonight because again we haven't worked with our teachers yet on this we haven't worked with our support staff and we haven't we haven't you know we haven't done all of that yet um but by mid-February March we will have according to our plan um but

086anyway the cost the overall cost of having some extra time for our kindergartners will probably cost about $500,000 so that's a net savings to the district of $2.5 million so this is a temporary thing we don't expect this to go on long term but this is what had to happen in order to balance our budget got you I remember too when we initially first had the discussion about reducing the hours that was was that was definitely something that was brought up and it was a concern so it's been addressed before and it's I mean it has been mentioned a few times so thank you for talking about it though yeah again we have to say difficult things and talk about difficult things if we're ever going to move forward agree and yeah thank you Carol

087thank you for bringing it up and I you're doing a great job at addressing all concerns we we are we are all trying our best to do that you know um so so thank you okay peninsula there you go so Peninsula thanks you so here we go I know that's like what is she what is she doing um so Peninsula Elementary School made some for school board appreciation month which was last month so they were working on this throughout the last month some awesome cards where they made thank yous and they so many students signed them you got your pictures are in there so I'm going to give those to all you board members um so I thought that was I didn't want to just leave them at your tables I wanted to point that

088out because it was a really big effort for the the kids and the principal and the staff at Peninsula to do that and they are truly grateful for your leadership of our school district so thank you Peninsula I went to school of peninsula that's awesome so awesome special huh okay that is really special we think Peninsula man that's so cool that's very special out here thank you thank you you get an A oh my goodness this is so cute a see if I can find my son's name on here look at that wow there are so many kiddos that's that's so awesome has a heart I love it oh and the name my daughter's name k that is so oh my gosh I love it very cool thank you so much yes well that was

089a very informative superintendent report that was that was a lot of information but I'm glad I'm I mean I'm it's good that's everything we needed so that's great okay so who wants to do the audit committee I can do it it will be on the 18th okay okay thank you all right 18th at 10:30 10 that's January February February all right so next we'll move on to our student super or our excuse me our student representative comments oh Javier I saw a post with you in it are you sure you don't have anything to sh I think you might we have nothing to share oh you don't this meeting was long enough oh you you guys are always welcome to share that's what you're sitting there for so okay all right going once going twice

090can I I asked a quick see if it'll provoke something is I mean this year is very unique um I never knew about a levy going through high school or anything like that and so I would presume more people know in your grades than mine did what is the what does the climate look like like I what does it sound like are people hopeful um yeah what are they concerned I mean obviously everyone's a little concerned but I don't know what's your report they they're hopeful that they people like learned from the mistakes of what happens when you don't pass it especially when you see the numbers out of 193 only two or out of 295 two didn't pass and it was Moses lake and another uh so they're very hopeful that this time around

091um in a variety of my own classes some of the teachers have expressed their hope at being able to have this burden off of their shoulders and to be able to have that Financial stability for their students and not only for them and like their own paychecks and how hard it is to meet that but to be able to provide what the students need um and I've heard a lot of students um desperate for things did not end for things to like if things don't pass for them to be able to still be able to do things they want this lovey to pass they want the ability to be able to do Sports and to learn and to be able to have their Chromebooks and to be able to not worry about well is this

092assignment going to be printed or am I just going to not be able to do it they're excited to and hopeful about being able to actually have that ability to have what they used to question Ryan that was that was a really good thought-provoking question thank you and great answers yeah okay so we'll start with our board comments who wants to go first well I always have something to say so let me go ahead um we have three more opportunities to show our support in our community coming up on Saturday yes well but the community has three more opportunities to to show support so Saturday there's an opportunity from 12: to 2 and then on the 11th there's two opportunities so if you guys want to go out and wave some signs and show support

093it's been pretty exciting seeing the folks that are out there um even in the cold weather so please uh please take on the opportunities if you have a chance to do that if you got free time and um yeah I mean my life my life is made with a thank you from Peninsula so thank you guys so cute all right Carla I just want to also thank Peninsula that was so sweet it actually brought tears to my eyes it was so sweet so and yes um I'm just thankful for all the work that is happening in our school district so thank you everyone Paul I didn't even see the backside I know I didn't either I just turned it over okay five days and about 37 minutes from now we will know one way or

094the other this District Will Go On I just want to thank our superintendent our board and everybody for all your hard work this has been a long nine months actually almost 10 months now we've gone through a lot and we're going to survive we're not giving up so and that's it for tonight yeah hey good teams win together and better teams lose together and so you know dissect that however you want but I've been um part of winning and losing teams and the funnest ones are the ones that you do it together and so this is a good team you know we're we're getting better every day and I'm super hopeful and proud of the progress and commitment that everyone's shown and it's been uh really impressive and really grateful to Peninsula too was really

095sweet thought for us and yeah I'm grateful for for where we're at and where we're going this is who we do it for our kids our community the service is for them yeah I love this I think this is it's very special um a lot of thought went into this and it it isn't even like you know didn't even take a lot of time I bet but boy it's just awesome um I don't really have anything to share so I just want to remind everybody to vote so um and and that's all I have so uh with that we'll move on to our civil rights hearing that we have and I'm trying to okay so thank you for joining us for uh this important civil rights hearing this meeting is conducted in accordance with Washington

096State open public meetings act to ensure transparency and public accountability tonight we will address an equity concern being brought to the board our goal is to uphold the principles of fairness equity and inclusion in our schools the guidelines for participation are to ensure a respectful and productive discussion please follow these guidelines keep comments civil and constructive and focused on the issue at hand attacks on individuals or person personal character will not be allowed speakers will be recognized in turn uh the party making the Civil Rights complaint will speak first and we'll have up to 10 minutes to speak the district then will have up to 10 minutes to present its perspective the party making the complaint will have up to 3 minutes to provide a rebuttal um and then once the hearing is complete I

097will formally close the hearing so okay so we will start with the uh the party that's making the complaint do we have a timer going do you want me to go oh yeah um and do you know how to turn on the microphone up there okay thank you Trisha hello my name is Larry dagnan I'm a Community member and a teacher at at North when we failed our Levy we um went to a model of only having PE consistently for seven of the 11 schools so seven schools have it full-time right now four only share it so what that looks like right now is in in our school you could have as many as 35 minutes a week but a lot of the time it's zero minutes my own classroom has only had it one

098time in a month where they've had PE you're supposed to have a hundred minutes per week and to to quote Robbie you know we always do what the law requires bottom line that was this meeting we aren't following the RCW the whack we we aren't doing what's best for kids and when I got um a response from the district you had pulled up the percentage of minority population for the entire schools of the elementaries that doesn't show in an honest way really what's happening you show that you know Park Orchard has 11% of our minority population you know Long View has 10.41% yes it does of all minority kids put in one group but when you go to what I pulled up from the state OSBI report card here's the true picture n's Vista is

09926% white North is 31% white Larson is 33% white our non-white students though NS Vista almost 74% North 68% Larson 66% two of your top three are not getting PE and it's not Equitable and it's discrimination it's discrimination to the highest level when you go down and you continue to follow this we didn't follow any kind of methodology for bringing PE into the classroom in an equitable way and the simplest easiest thing we could have done was taking and if I would could get you guys to turn to my page it's one of my last pages it it says step one calculate the base teaching per per School shows nine teachers over 11 schools we could have easily went to a 91th model where every single School gets a 911th um PE teacher that's a

100082 per school so that what what would that look like that's that's four fifths as a fraction so that means every school of the nine who have their teachers would have had their PE teacher there for 4 days and they would Farm out those teachers to the other two schools that are affected to make up to where everyone would have 82% of PE instead of our school Larson lak View Garden Heights getting 35 minutes a week that that's inequitable and it's discrimination and really if do do you have the ability Carol to pull up what I sent you guys on the document not right now um it's it's a very easy and Equitable thing to do all you would have to do and and my example was just each one of the the nine schools

101they keep their four days a week and for example we would pull you know n's Vista would take one of their days would be with with a North K with a North kids and then one of the other schools um say sage they would go to um Lake View and and by the time we were done those are the two schools that lost their full-time PE we would have PE for everybody and one school would have PE you know someone there every day but the other schools would have them four or five days I stand by this is being very harsh discrimination with what I handed to you guys I I cannot stress to you enough the impact that the Discrimination has on the kids they are sad they want things to go back to

102normal you know when I was listening to the student Representatives hearing kids want school to go back to normal be one of the affected four of 11 schools and think oh I didn't have PE this week my teacher called in sick I didn't have it last week and and this it's a continuous cycle what gets kids to to school PE is one of the big ones we all were there and and to keep going and looking at this in any other way but fairness and equitableness is wrong so you know I can I can rest on almost anything that I've said here but your response to the equity and the Discrimination was totally dishonest and to put all those kids into one big um one big room and consider this well you know here's our

103percentages and we with our findings we found that this was not discrimination you can't look yourself in the mirror with that you absolutely can't it doesn't pass the straight face test when when you know two of your top three schools are the schools of the highest color and the least amount of white students it is absolutely wrong and especially when your highest degree of white students has full-time PE all the time all the time so I I rest on that Carol can you start the timer good evening I'm Michelle muso and I serve as the HR Director for the district as well as the Civil Rights coordinator and um I just want to start by um saying I appreciate Mr Dean's concern and care for the students um I think we all feel that and

104I also want to state that as a district we have repeatedly said we understand that the reduced PE programming is not Equitable across schools it is not we are clear and we know that and I think that a lot of the concerns about the programming itself um that that Mr dnan has expressed have been addressed in multiple appropriate Avenues um so what I'm going to focus on tonight is the equity complaint and the equity complaint specifically states that students of minority status are disproportionately affected by the programming reduction specifically talking about the four schools that share two um PE teachers um so what I have done is um we were directed by OPI to conduct a district directed investigation so we have done that um in my role as the as the coordinator for civil

105rights and we have to look at the data in order to do that so um what I did um and we we will have to agree to disagree on what is an appropriate way to do that but what I did is I took the total number of elementary students I identified through the data available on opi's website I identified the number of students that are white and the number of students that are minorities then what we did is we looked at for each school what is their average minutes per week of PE because that is different and then we put that into an annual number of minutes for each school and then we took that number and applied it to the number of minority students the number not the percentages because we have to look

106at the numbers in order to figure out where the percentages fall so we took that number we applied it to the number of white students and the number of minority students okay and then we figured out the total that each group is getting per year so what we found was white students no matter where they're at the total Average White students are receiving 8 1,812 minutes of PE programming per year minority students are receiving 1,799 minutes of PE programming per year the difference of 13 minutes annually is not significant and it does not indicate discrimination looking at the percentage of uh minority students in the four schools that we have the reduced programming that are sharing the the um PE teachers yes they absolutely we confirm they absolutely have high numbers and high percentage of

107minority students however we can't just look at that school's percentages because those schools are smaller so they make up less of the minority students of the district so when we do look at say Park Orchard has the highest number of minority students for the district so if we were to cut back there it would have had a bigger impact on minority students overall if we had cut back the programming there than if we had cut back where we're at so um based on my analysis um and what I have what I have responded to Mr dagnan and um in our official response is that this is the information that we gathered the data we looked at I gave them the percentages I gave them the numbers of the head count and the um average minutes

108per week or I'm sorry average minutes per per year that white students versus um minority students are receiving and that's how we have determined that there is no discrimination yes there's an equity across schools but there is no minority discrimination happening due to the reduced programming thank you and then just I guess it's my night to talk about um the things that we need to change in Moses Lake School District so I just wanted to add that um I appreciate um what Mr degnan is is saying um one of the things that um hasn't necessarily been a focus um as far as as long as I've been in Moses Lake School District which is isn't that long but I think it's been um longer than that is that um we consider the district as a

109whole when we're making decisions um each building is absolutely unique and special and has its has its its things um but as we're receiving funding as we're thinking about programming we have to consider the district as a whole we don't get funding for this school or that school except for in very um you know small amounts in specific situations we get funding for our school district and we need to think about all of our students all of them as Moses Lake School District students and how are we going to make decisions um for them in Equitable ways and I will say that that hasn't been necessarily a focus that we've had and we need to start doing that um so PE teachers is one example and I will say part of what um what is

110expected when we have a situation like like this is that we try to you know we try to make things better we know that we don't have equal PE minutes across acoss our entire school district for all of our kids in some schools they have more and some schools they have less and we have Robbie has presented on that extensively to the board we've talked about it quite a lot and that's one of the very first things that we want to fix um if we have Levy money and and even if we don't have ly money we need to even it out across our district we hope to add minutes um to those places that don't don't have enough right now um but even if we're not able to do that um because the the

111levy does not pass we still to to even it out for everybody and we know we will do that going forward into next school year one way or another doesn't matter if the levy passes or not we're going to to make things more Equitable for every student across our district and we need to do that with a lot of things not just PE we need to do that we need to start our thinking with that any of our counselors still here um we've had a lot of conversations around counselors you know we have one counselor um for a school that has over 500 kids and then the same amount of counseling for a school that has half that many and so we need to be thinking about how are we to even things out um

112for services for for everything principles are the same at our elementary level um at the secondary level we we take into account how many students are there and add assistant principles um at the elementary level we we haven't yet done that um so there are many areas where we know we need to become more Equitable for our for our students for our staff um and and we do PL plan to do that this school year Robbie has very clearly explained why we're at where we're at and and why um potentially changing up the schedules to at this point in the school year to to change the PE plan would actually create inequities in other places so while it may provide Equitable PE Services it would likely cause inequity or um the inability for our special

113education students to receive the services they need because that all those schedules would shift and change so much um that we would be trading one inequity for another so for this school year um we Advocate that we um that we as m stated um we aren't having an equity issue a minority Equity issue for civil rights with PE we do know some students are receiving less PE we're very well aware of that and we know we need to fix it going into next year and we've gone through Great Lengths to determine why fixing it right now mid year would be um would just create more challenges um it would solve one one Challenge and would create more okay three minutes can you restart for so I'm glad Michelle brought up the the minutes and the

114inequity because I I have very differing numbers from hers she has 1,799 minutes of PE annually compared to 1,812 for white students but when you go down and actually look at it if you have an average 36 week school year and you're supposed to get 35 minutes a week as one school that's 1260 minutes if you get 70 minutes per week to PE classes that's 2520 minutes that's a difference of 1,60 minutes that's not 13 minutes no one can look you straight in the eye and say no this is only a 13 minute difference it's not it's it's over 1,200 minute difference and that's totally inequitable so so that number it it's just it's reality and then if you throw in the groups that get three times per week just keep adding 1260 to that

115the Gap is bigger your numbers are wrong they're absolutely wrong this is discrimination there's no other way to look at it so the range of minutes receive that students receive in a school fulltime is 2520 to 3780 if they get it two times a week or three you have four schools getting it once you cannot tell me it's 13 minutes difference when every single time you go to PE it's 35 minutes or more it's impossible your numbers don't add up so four out of the F four out of the five most white schools are served with a full-time PE teacher let that sink in it's it's not it's not right it doesn't pass the straight face test none of it does you need to go to pushing right now you change it all up you

116redistribute everything it will not create any issues having them there in their own School four out of five days is not going to create any more issue than the North students the Larson students the garden Heights and the lake view students have experienced all year so you miss one day a week put yourself in our shoes step into our our world because it's inequitable and is discrimination at the highest point thank you all right thank you uh so this concludes our civil rights hearing for tonight's board meeting uh the board will take all of this information that's been presented tonight and we will discuss at a later board meeting all right so the only thing I have left for tonight is a motion for adjourn move we adjourn second I'll second all right all in

117favor I I okay we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.