CorpusRecord 152515

Jan. 8, 2025: Sumner-Bonney Lake School Board Study Session Recording

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Sumner-Bonney Lake School District
Date
2025-01-09
Location
Pierce County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,110 words · about 57 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001thank you for being here this evening we have two presentations tonight but we're going to start off um with one from our instructional Services team extraordinaires um around Ela all right well thank you um Dr dent and board of directors for having us here again tonight so like to reintroduce the team here for everyone so next we have Darla opner she is our director of Elementary curriculum and then Cassie be next to her is our director of curriculum for secondary and then next is followed by Steve scholen he is our executive director over secondary and then at the End by bethman um our executive director for elementary so we are here tonight to share um information around our English language arts programs across our schools and what you'll notice tonight is that what we share

002a lot of things are really parallel to what you saw last month when we did mathematics because we approach all of our Core Curriculum in much the same way so you'll you'll notice that throughout the presentation so as we start we always begin with our district promise to know value and support every student because that's why we are here every single day and so it's important to always begin um with the reminder of what that promise is so for ELA goals they're very much the same as mathematics so what you'll notice up there for goal one our goal is that 80% of our third graders will meet The Benchmark um on the smarter balanced assessment by 2026 and then under goal three same exact goal for grades five and eight we want students meeting that

00380% Benchmark on the smarter balance assessment by 2026 so Equity this is exactly what you saw last month we really look at goal one of bringing in our earli Learners regardless of their background we want all of them to have those experiences so that they're solid as they move up into the upper grades and then whereas we continue their education with that rigorous curriculum we want strong instructional strategies happening in every single classroom again this is our list of lots of policies we have um so many under the 2000 series and this is just a light sampling of the things that directly relate to the work that we do in English language arts so we have a budget that's dedicated to English language arts you can see between Elementary and secondary we have roughly $400,000

004um and this is really um a lot of Maintenance work that happens year to year under Ela we do things like um purchase new curriculum sets when we have increased classroom set at say a third grade level at a building um you'll see under Elementary we have a coffee allotment because we used to buy consumables for students but it's more fiscally responsible just to give it make some copies at secondary teachers we find are using more of those consumables so we purchase some of those that are used up each year um you'll see we have some funding that goes in there for professional learning at elementary we support our as web testing with the task force and then at secondary we had some extra cost this year because we have that Ela adoption so we

005have the adoption team and then some framework W writing so that's where the majority of those funds go so outcomes so tonight for board members It's always important for us to know like what do we want you to know and be able to do when you leave here at the end of this presentation so through goal one and through through goal three again we're designing it around the four PLC questions so in that bottom box on the right hand side when you're in that grocery store you're on the walk in your neighborhood here's the two things we want you to be able to do so number one we want you to have some base knowledge around what does literacy look like at that tier one level across the district in all grade levels but then

006number two you hear us talk about SBA as being that Benchmark in our strategic plan so tonight we're hoping that you'll get a deeper understanding around those components of the smarter balance assessment and how we use those in the in the classroom for um instructional purposes so we included the educational specific strategies here again those are in our strategic plan we just put some you know boxes around the ones that are really the highlights of the work that we're currently doing and those are the same as what you saw last week um or this month sorry in mathematics so where are we so we're going to start high at the state level so again you've seen this before so on the left hand side this is English language arts all grade levels combined to together

007and that's with the two the three and the four from the state and on the right hand side that's just a level three or four when you look at the next slide this is where you can see the different grade levels disaggregated so students start taking the SBA in third grade they do not take it in ninth grade and then they take it in 10th Grade and then students who want a second chance or Miss they can take again an opportunity in 11th and 12th grade so again those are State levels so then we want to look to see what does Pierce County look like so if you look at this chart we are number three on the list and if you look at that we are only 1.2 from the top not that we're

008competitive but we know that we can be number one on that list and then we of course put the state on there for comparison and we are proud to say we're 18 percentage points above the state level which is huge accolades to our teaching staff and the great work that they do every day so then we of course rign to our strategic goals we're looking at where are our third grade group and these are and when you look at this table realize that these are different students every single year so what are the third graders one year you know getting on that SBA versus the next year a different group of third graders on and on so you can see our results for third grade we're really looking at 10.5% over the next two years

009to reach that 80% and then you can see fifth grade we got a little bit higher of a benchmark at 13.2 and then a little bit higher for eighth grade um we did see that a dip in fifth and eth and we're hoping that we can rebound really strongly um this coming up year with that so we also watch cohorts of students as you saw us kind of explain that in mathematics so to reach our fifth graders in 2026 we really start with our third graders this past spring they were 69.5 so we look at them and we say can this particular group of kids can we get them another 10.5% higher over the next two years and then same thing for eth graders so we had their data that goes back all the way

010to third grade right out of the pandemic when the SBA looked a little bit different than it does right now and you can see what their Source have looked like over the past four years and again it's a 14.2% for those students um at that Middle School level and I know last month I was probably super excited when I shared this graph with you but again just a reminder at the secondary level we did not have data the state does not give us data by teacher by course at the secondary level our district assessment director put this data together in a very painstakingly way but then I want you to imagine the power of this that didn't exist before this year our principles can now take this data this is an example of seventh grade

011out of middle school where there's three ELA teachers that we now can look at it and say what is teacher number two doing to get better results than say teacher number one so we now can have that conversation where we didn't have that before so that's being used in our with our principles in their professional development sessions that they're bringing back to their building and working with teachers so this is one of our like powerful strategies that we're hoping this year helps bring about um positive outcomes for students and then just as a reminder um this presentation is really focused on tier one and what we mean by tier one that's that first instruction that students receive in the classroom and our goal as an instructional Services team is to make sure that that tier

012one that first instruction is the most powerful and impactful that it can be so that we lessen the needs for students to have any intervention that might come up in a tier two or a tier three setting okay so um what do we need to know and be able to do so there's three things we're highlighting here the first one is that we need to know our students and what specifically they're struggling in in ela we need to know our priority standards and how they're going to be assessed on SBA and we really need to be monitoring progress towards those SBA skills well before the test takes place all right so I shared this graphic with you with math to show you where on the far left is when we look at like state reports

013our score they always report overall scores but we really focus in more at the Target level where we are digging into those standards and groups of standards and how students are performing uh in those specific areas because it really helps inform instruction I showed you an example of how we look at Target data how every Target is assessed in two ways how proficient were students on this particular Target and was this a strength of the test was it about equal um with other areas on the test or was it a weakness and so this is the data we look at with principles and teachers so um to better understand how SBA is scored um I'm just going to share with you a marble jar analogy you maybe have seen this before but this is a

014great anchor to help us understand how SBA scoring happens so I want you to um think about so when students answer questions on SBA um there are some questions that are considered easy so we think of those as small marble questions some are mod moderate and those are kind of our our medium Marbles and then some as you can see are difficult which are worth like a large marble so if we're thinking about filling a marble jar to get students a particular score so um the interesting thing about SBA is that um there is a blueprint that determines the distribution of items that are going to be on the assessment but it is a computer adaptive test so the way students perform on those questions informs the test of the future questions that they will

015see so as you can see the student on the left um answers more if they answer difficult questions the computer's going to give them more difficult questions thus those large marbles filling the jar a student who misses those um large marble questions only gets the small marble questions correct it's going to continue to get those small marble questions so you can see that student jar is a little bit lower okay so once when we take the marbles from all the claims of SBA we think of them as each claim they're earning their Marbles and it gets poured into the beaker that gives them their overall score okay so for student a they answered 30 items correct and as you can see from the marbles many of them were difficult so they had a lot of

016big marbles filling that Beaker okay student B interestingly enough also answered 30 questions correct student B might feel that they did pretty well they answered 30 questions correct however they were only answering the easy ones and when a difficult one would come their way they miss it so the computer would give them another easy one and therefore their marble jar their Beaker is not as full so um that's kind of an interesting way to look at here's student A and B side by side showing the difficulty levels of questions that students are given on this assessment so we're going to do a little activity today so you have in your bag some different size marbles I went with safety marbles today in case this is a frustrating activity for you so if you could quickly

017open your bag and sort your marbles you should be able to quickly put them into three piles small medium large and before we go any further I you have some answers in your packet that I need you to turn over because you can't cheat and look so I've given you the questions in front of you so that you can actually look at them and you're going to see them on the screen as well some of you already did a quick look so you'll know the first they the presentation early I know but unless you memorized which question was which I know we get mark up here he's finan okay all right does everybody have their small marbles their medium Marbles and their large marbles okay we're going to see how well you can identify a

018small marble question a medium and a difficult now you do not have to answer the you don't need to know the answer to the question you just need to be able to look at the question these are fourth grade questions how old are fourth graders about 10 yeah some 10 11 nine 10 okay so these are fourth grade ELA questions if it's hard to look at the screen you've got the questions in front of you in the um black and white packet that I gave you if you look at the color one you're going to see the answers so don't cheat okay here we go are we ready so this first question students reading poem for language arts they have to read the poem and the question is which more exact words best replace the

019underlined words in the poem so what do we think when you think you know hold up either a small a medium or a large marble and this assumes a student is on gr level fourth grade all students take the I see a moderate I see moderate anybody think it's easy some people are cheating right there all right uh question number one is an easy question this is considered easy okay are we ready for number two here we go so they put it in their jar oh put it in your jar yes put that that was an easy so you just earned a small marble if you got I mean even if you didn't get it right you can put it in your jar okay here we go so in this one I did not include

020the passage but a student reads A Passage how big bear stuck to the sky and they have to answer two parts so part A which sentence best describes the theme of the text and Part B which sentence from the passage best supports your answer for part A okay I've seeing people reaching for some large marbles anybody think it's not a large one bill what do you think oh if you have a big marble in your hand you just earned a big marble you can put it in your jar here we go question number three he students are reading a passage lost and found they have to be able to read the passage did I hear anyone say that youd have to read the passage too right which detail from the passage best supports the idea

021that Meera is curious about the tarantula that lived in mbie's garage what do we think this is ready show your marbles see some large some moderate do we think okay here we go with okay here we go it was a medium a mod if you have a moderate you can put your moderate one in the jar uh oh this is what happened okay here we go number four there's s there's only six okay so this is a listening one where they listen to a presentation about how not all bugs are bad then they're going to pick two details from the presentation that best support the idea that pirate bugs are unusual ual compared to other insects two details from the presentation that best support the idea that pirate bugs are unusual compared to other insects

022can you imagine what error do we think kids might make on this one they only pick one right so they have to really pay attention Okay what do we think show your marbles I see gosh I know thanks for playing Kevin okay here this is actually considered a big marble so you can put a big marble in your jar huh it's interesting that listening is harder than maybe because that question and and the difficulty level is really based on sampling when they test students it's a small percentage of students that get a question like that correct so that's what makes it a heavier weighted question okay here is uh they learned about a student writing a research report uh and the student wants more information for her report which website would most likely have more

023information about the ideas she has written so she's choosing from a selection of websites what do we think easy moderate difficult they're probably better than I am on okay here we go it's a medium it's a moderate question okay last one here we go this is an editing um read the sentence and the question that follows my aunt was hungry and wanted to eat before the movie but the rest of the family wanted to see the movie before dinner what is the best way to correct the error in the sentence so they're picking which one is the best way to correct the error in the sentence that's personally okay here we go it is easy that was a small all one okay well thank you for playing along with that um so why is it

024important why is it important that we understand this analogy of marbles okay so this presentation actually um it's for principles it's for teachers and we have a version for students so it's important for our students to understand that questions are going to be weighted differently if our students think gosh if I just guess on the hard ones I get these easier ones so it's important that our students learn that perseverance and that they also um that our teachers are able to see how our standards are going to be measured on SBA and that students have multiple opportunities yes quick question yeah can and this is about the test ofine I'm just naive about it can they choose to skip questions and only select like and only go to the easy ones yeah good question or

025do they have or do they still have to go through a test all in order and and give them do that and do can they keep going and perhaps somebody answers 30 but somebody else answers 50 so the questions do vary some students get um a different number of questions based on how they perform but your question is a great question students can't skip they can flag it and come back to it but they could think about like um how much thought they put into a question like they might just say oh I'm going to get guess and go on this one and then really spend time so it's important for kids to understand that some questions require more thinking and that they're going to earn big marbles I've been in classrooms where teachers say

026guys this is a big marble question I need your thinking right now in their regular lessons so um it's important that our teachers know it that our students know it and that they have lots of exposure both low stakes as like instructional team tasks Jeopardy style um access to these as well as being able to take some practice type situations so um that's why I'm sharing this with you and that we share this with teachers and um and students as well um the last thing that we had talked about was how we need to be measuring progress towards SBA not just in June when we get our um our data back so one of the ways we do that is we're assessing students through our Benchmark testing in elementary that's as web where we're looking

027closely to see what does students have to do on as web assessments so that it's comparable to how students perform on SBA so we're constantly looking at that so that as web can become a bit of a predictor so that we can kind of see which students are on track so this is just an example of how we do that in element and this is an example of how Middle School does this with their map data they're really looking carefully we want to have some predictors in place and not just find out how students are performing in June when we get our results back great thanks Darla now we're gonna talk about how we are going to get there and as Darla just took a deep dive into the SBA and how to break that

028apart and how to help students be successful in that we're going to look at um again like we did with mathematics maybe if I can get this to work here we go we're going to look at elmore's um instructional core which uh we looked at last time so it should look familiar to it we're just going to look at it through an Ela lens so we're going to start with content and um how do we maintain academically challenging content right and we are doing that with our Core Curriculum right now we uh currently use CK core knowledge language arts in elementary and at the secondary level in both middle and high school we're using um hmh collections we also have at the secondary level AP curriculum at Bonnie Lake High School and a couple of

029um courses at Sumer high school and then the IB curriculum at SAR high school with that core that content um as Darla just told us SBA is really important right and it's made up of the stand standards that she talked to you about and so all of our work in our content areas in our curriculum are driven by our Frameworks are driven by Ela standards it's the first look it's what we need kids to know and be able to do that's the primary um and we do that here's an example of a sixth grade um piece of a framework that's and you can see it's driven by the ELA standards and then here's one for uh first grade again driven by Ela standards it's a primary way we ensure that our students are being provided

030the challenging content with that said we are at an exciting time for our district because we are just as you know as you're reviewing we are looking at adopting both middle and high school New Ela curriculum um and I just want to highlight a few things uh for you because this is this is a big opportunity for our district and a couple of pieces I know you've read this but that I wanted to share is that in our process we have used teachers administrators students and parents um as part of this year and a half process we receive feedback from over 2,000 students and 32 teachers and I think the teachers number is actually really higher than that um and what one thing as a leader of this that I'm most proud of is the

031way our district uses our stakeholders in this really important work so I'm very grateful for that um we're also excited about an e um an Elementary Ela adoption coming in 2027 and 28 so um just wanted you to know that about our curriculum adoption and then what we did with that work and so I wanted to also share with you this is the secondary Ela curriculum team vision statement is really important to our team we looked at goal five and what do we want um and the profile of a graduate we really wanted to create this through line what do we want kids to know and be able to do as Ela students as they exit our schools and this is what they came up with it was with this and then a whole bunch

032of other work and the feedback of the students and teachers on what is it that we're going to look for in a new curriculum we've landed on two different curriculums this year we didn't restrict middle and high school to be the same we feel that through our framework writing that we can vertically align it 6th through 12th grade and there were a couple of problems with keeping it 6th through 12th grade with one curriculum so so um middle schoool's recommendation to you is my perspectives and the high school recommendation is study sync um I wanted to share with you because I have the opportunity here a couple of quotes from teachers that wanted to give they had an exit slip and it said what would you want to tell the school board about your selection

033um and so what they said is that the new curriculum that they have recommended to you has a variety of voices and authors they have more contemporary and high interest selections they have a strong scaffolding to meet the needs of all Learners the writing and unit tasks require complex thinking they contain culturally responsive materials and representation of more cultures within the text and that's really exciting um I think it's it's going to meet the needs of our students because I'm going to share a couple of pieces of feedback from students in just a second so that is um our content then our teachers what are we doing with our teachers we're going to continue with these um evidence-based practices that are helping our students um grow and learn but um we just need you to

034know that as we change the content we're going to have to change what we're doing with our teachers and our students and so we will be adapting our challenge is going to be to use the new curricula to enhance our instructional practices so we'll be spending a lot of time on staff development and PD on how to appropriately use the new curriculum to best serve our students and then lastly our students student engagement so um you can have the best curriculum and you can have teachers with the most knowledge but if you are not engaging your students you're not going to get there and so in part of our work that I wanted to share with you is when we surveyed those 2,000 students and they gave us a lot of fun answers I will

035tell you that but one of the questions um was what else do we need to do for you in ela to best prepare you for life after graduation and I'm going to share with you some of their contents a lot of it was well there was always funny ones right um yeah lots of funny ones but I thought that these were these kind of hit the mark with what we did in our work and that was um I would need to have more variety in the different text types that I read because there are certain genres that I'm less familiar with and I want to diversify the content I am exposing myself to in order to prepare myself for a broader network of ela materials after graduation that person might be a for um this

036another student said more critical thinking should be introduced from nth grade another books are good if you can find the right ones and then I would like to see people like me in the stories I read and I'd like them to be inspiring that was a big thing that came out was um we call it windows and mirrors but um about kids seeing themselves but the kids were like but I want to see it in a positive light I want to see you know success and so I share those with you because we know that what we need to engage student is we need to ask them what do you what do you need and so I think that that gave our group a lot of um momentum to find what they were looking for

037and then as you know like I said if you move one of those pieces in the Triangle you have to move the other two so we're going to be doing a lot of juggling in our new Ela adoption um and the work that's coming forward and we look forward to continued um um student Improvement and K through2 Ela by remaining focused on elmore's instructional core all right as Cassie said um one of the thing one of the things we work hard to do is engage our stakeholders and so parent involvement is um a critical element of this and as Cassie said I mean the curriculum adoption committees um and others that you see listed here but a couple highlights I'd like to make um that stand apart from what you heard in the math presentation

038last week uh we've got the book vending machines we've had you know lots of very generous parents in our schools who have made those available to our schools as well as the um um oh gosh what was it the Imagination Library and uh for eligible students this is a a program that makes Books available for students uh prior to entering kindergarten oh pardon me as always we've got to consider how are we going to monitor and adjust based on the learning outcomes that we see um you saw this when we did the math presentation we continue to follow the plan due study act protocol and from the priority the identification of the priority standards those creation of the Frameworks the analysis the curriculum um and then looking at the achievement results we respond to the

039needs so all this work continues to guide our process in ela as well I was this where I have to keep clicking Roger there you go all right here we go okay is get this all up here here we go all right all right so engaging uh with teachers and administrators in our work is critical uh with the selection of curriculum the development of the Frameworks and the assessment systems so but I wanted to highlight a few things from both the elementary and secondary perspectives on the elementary level um we're happy to say we've got uh for you know students that are achieving at high levels High cap self-contained and cluster programs happening across um the district as well as for students who are um struggling academically we've got our intervention the win uh time

040for intervention at the SEC secondary level we've got honors classes we've got apib at the high school as well as um many of you observed last year the read 180 for our students that are struggling with um with reading at secondary um a specific highlight that uh for ELA is last year we did some work to refine or academic acceleration um work that we do in the district and so with our eighth graders based on how they did on their seventh grade ELA uh we last year and we'll continue this going forward but we sent out to all of our families and notified all of our students that um if they scored a level four on their seventh grade ELA um assessment they were going to be automatically accelerated into uh preap or honors English

041when they go into nth grade and um literally this is hundreds of a graders that are receiving this and out of all of those students six families um actually said you know declined that opportunity fully understandable um but uh but we're excited by this um opportunity that we're boing students without any barriers and um and and of course you seeking the families import as well um here we go all right so as we move forward we're continuing to look at how we respond to student performance on the seventh grade SBA knowing that the students earning a level four are going to automatically be accelerated um but we want to look um at what are we doing while they're still in the Middle School are are we placing these same students in an honors class in

042eth grade knowing that they're going to go into High School honors um how are we working with the families to make sure that they understand kind of where their students are achieving now and the opportunities that are coming down the road and then also as we make this adjustment how are we supporting those honors and preap classes at the high schools um so that we're getting the greatest success for our students um as one thing that has been happening is for the last few years we've been focusing on our assessment system and how we're maintaining data from students going from elementary to Middle to high school and our principles have been a real um important part of this work um to ensure that what we're giving them is in a format that they're going to

043use and it's in a timely U manner um all right so what are some opportunities for our Improvement um all right one of one thing that is on our Horizon is is that we know that OSI is working on new Ela standards um and the actual you know date is a little bit inlux but so TBD but but we're watching the work that the state is doing and and working to make sure that we're staying on top of it and providing input when we have our chances um we know that across our elementary schools and um middle and secondary schools uh we've got classrooms that are making sure that to um consistently Implement those interim assessment blocks those are those kind of practice SBA tests um I talked just a second ago about the data

044driven transitions between Elementary Middle Middle High School uh so that kids are placed in uh the best classes possible and um um anyway so at I'll wrap it up at just saying as always we continue to work to find time to provide uh professional development whoops um opportunities for all of our teachers to grow and engage in job embedded meaningful uh learning to further sharpen their instructional skill and we'll wrap it up with bringing it back to the promise where we started from thank you that's it nothing from Beth tonight questions okay perfect she passed out all she did a lovely job handing on the thank you app any questions can the board I I have one I'm so wanted to be able to come to this one and say I had a couple questions

045but so first of all a great presentation and ton of ton of Bo right my Applause for the classroom teachers who are teaching every day but learning on the Fly and doing all that their involvement um I thought as a classroom teacher one of the most difficult things I had is so what do we do with the kids who get it we have so much focus on the ones who don't get it and all the interventions but and I I heard what Steve said is we're trying to move kids up into you know a higher level especially as we move into the secondary but whether it's in the secondary but predominantly I'm thinking about the elementary what do I do with that kid that just gets it and I have whole class or a whole

046group over here that doesn't get it what do we do for them well hopefully there isn't a whole class that doesn't get it um but through core instruction that usually we we shoot for 80% sure um but there're always going to be some students who are ready to be accelerated and so by having the wi time every day that's not just for students who need additional support it's for students who need challenge it's for students who need to go further with grade level standards and so we really are working with our teachers to better understand what what not just having kids working independently that are on and above grade level but how do we strategically select activities um that are relevant to their learning styles and their learning needs without just introducing all new content

047to a handful of students and so it is certainly an area bill that we um if I was just talking with our team about it today like really trying to streamline some schools do it really well and other schools um are focusing a lot on those students who need additional support and there is more independent work so it is an area that we want to work on I think too at the secondary in the curriculums that we've been looking at there a lot more direction for teachers for when students are getting it it's giving them more recommendations I mean it's just as it's evolved over time and then even there's a variety of different stories that a teacher can choose based on Lexile SC scores so that it's you're teaching the same skills but you

048might say okay Steve you're going to read this story cash you're going to read this story and it's based on our reading level and so they they they've come a long way just even in the last eight years since we adopted our curriculum last time on adjusting some of those options for teachers just in the regular Jin Ed who's got some people that are accelerating or or needing extra some you know texts that are lower Lexile scores as well so they feel like they're part of it just real quick I'll just add with regards to Frameworks the extensions that we put into framework also to work with differentiation I mean it is not just right within the wind time but within any kind of lesson especially in the elementary school um you're trying to provide

049um different opportunities for kids uh at the actual work at their at their level and giving them some choice at being able to choose that easy medium uh mild medium thank you very much I had obervation about the testing scoring a four theological me as we were going through with our daughters and planning out high school and looking towards what courses they're going to take to keep on track keep accelerating that's be cool yeah you can now have that opportunity I think that was must have been really good out of the box thinking on the them's part to find ways to accelerate them before they get to high school and have them be able to jump ahead classes one thing too to add to that is we don't have any barriers in our district for

050any eighth grader who wants to go into a nth grade preap English or honors English every single student regardless of their middle middle school experience can schedule they can opt into that class so every one of them which makes us so different than other schools where students have to receive certain scores our our you know academic acceleration is is we're purposely scheduling some students who might not do it based on you know many different factors but yeah that's something that we also just be really proud of that there's there's no Gates no barriers no sores for student to self select and then the academic acceleration word automatically enrolling them in you didn't go back after eth grade just go through their data in eighth grade just to make sure we didn't miss some kids because

051it was off at the seventh and then sent that data on to the high schools as well and I think what that does that's an important part what that does for us is it gives kids who may not have parent advocates pushing them it just automatically puts them there which they should be there because as a prior principal and you're looking at your IB um group it's not I was always wanting to make it um representative of my whole school and it's growing and it's it's starting to do that so this is super exciting because kids are kids are gonna on that same does it have you seen a lot by doing that do you see a lot more students than um being identified and enrolling into the accelerated programs and the IBS on the

052AP so this past year the current freshman was our first year of do doing what I um shared with you so sections like at the I will say already I would say that you know like since the pandemic we have definitely seen the numbers rebounding and and sections growing yeah I just wonder then does that change your Staffing of how you have to do you know Staffing for classes and things to that well I think as we grow our CTE if you can accelerate these kids sooner into these classes that they're required to take freeze them up in their junior year to take more options across the board that are have to do a CTE just makes that more of an opportunity questions once again thank you for your presentation very very good thank you

053all right we GNA continue our meeting um regarding some Bond sale planning welcoming Mark pring yes Brian you want Brian come on up awesome anyone else [Laughter] there so while Mark is while Mark is getting settled I I want to point out something because so right now our sit down yeah this isn't GNA hurt right so our team right now we have Mary urbach right the goddess of all landuse M we have Matt ganians constructions Mary Matt Marina and now we have Mark you could find a CFO just ruined the whole the whole sequence although Lee is our bond counsil and Lorie yeah so we got this same so Brian you're like the outlier right now all right ex bang was you know now you're B so so bees are the CFO but we are

054so lucky well we're lucky to have both of these um gentlemen um but Mark you've been with us for a while and you're going to get to know Mark even better um because what's exciting right now is that if you didn't know pass a bond big old Bond right largest in hisb state and Marina and Matt are ready to start building um but they need some money and in order to get the money Mark's going to help us get the money with Brian uh Brian's going to help us make sure that we're manage it well and it's properly um all accounted for we're going to have committees that give it an extra layer of transparency but Mark is thank you um you really work for but we contract with you so teach us about Bond

055sales okay well thank you members of the board Dr D it's really it's a pleasure to be here and this is the fun part right the hard part is getting the bond measure pass now we get to sell bonds see you know buildings go up it's really kind of it's a neat thing so as again just as a background uh I work with esd112 I started 10 years ago now last month uh a program to provide Financial advisory services for Washington schools on their bond planning and that sort of thing I used to work on the underwriting side of the business so I was kind of on on the other side of the table and now I negotiate on behalf of the districts that I work with and we work with most large districts in

056western Washington and some Eastern Washington as well and it's been a really nice program I think for for district so that's kind of my background and how I have a fiduciary uh duty to the district as working through an interlocal government agreement so essentially become part of your staff like Brian um but just not on a full-time basis so um I'll go over that and kind of rols and responsibilities a little bit so I was going to talk a little about what the bond Market's doing and where we're going some decisions to be made and kind of so you'll feel comfortable as we move along the process but I'm really here to answer questions you might have and if you don't have the best question right now make sure to you know through Dr dent

057and we'll get you you know aners to your questions you have um right now interest rates are you'll see two things on this trend line were're still pretty low in history to what interest rates are were higher than they were during the pandemic but you couldn't borrow money during the pandemic you didn't have Bond authorization so doesn't make any difference when they were back then um but there is volatility in the market right now if you're listening to Cal news and interest rates are moving up and down lately been moving more up than than down because there's uncertainty in the world still and there's uncertainty what's going to go on politics and tariffs and all kinds of topics that impacts interest rates so that means that we need to be nimble and be able to

058have flexibility in our sale plan to react according to those rates but I will say that we can't guess what interest rates are going to do when we go in the market you get the interest rates on that day and that's kind of kind of what you get we try to put you in the best place and make sure you're not pricing on a day that you have competing Bond issues or you know Federal Reserve meetings there's going be some market so we try to put you in the best place we get the interest rates you get at that time so our goals we're trying to achieve the first one is during the election voters were told that the expect a total tax rate of $463 per thousand that's a big one we want to

059get the money also when um you want it for the construction that's another another piece the talk about that a little bit more there's also the potential to refinance or what we call refund the district's bonds that were sold in 2014 and 2015 the there could be some interest rate savings on those and we'll I'll talk about that in more detail as well this is the first time you have an opportunity to refinance those under kind of the way bonds work the savings aren't substantial enough to where we would have done this as a standalone issue because we're not here to just generate fees for professionals right don't want to go through all the work have Brian go through work have you go through the work you do a Bond mission unless we're going to

060really provide it some substantial savings it's worth pointing out that those savings are savings to taxpayers it's lower future tax collections but if we're selling new bonds already and we can put them in there not added bunch of additional costs and generate a couple hundred, with savings that's worth doing so it doesn't take much more effort what's worth throwing this we're be looking at that we going to look at The District's credit rating with Moody's investor service right now your double A3 credit rating uh Dr D would like to be tripa um be the only one be the only one in the state after Belleview I think but um but I will say you're in a good position the Washington School Districts right now have been under a lot of pressure on in ratings for

061reasons you know about right there's problems with Washington School finance and Moody's has taken note of that and over the last 12 months I think out of about 30 districts that have been under review for Moody's probably 25 of them have been down graded or put on negative wat credit watch that they will be downgraded um and just a couple have kept their ratings and the Moody's main anal said to me the other couple weeks ago we were on a call said every District's dou A3 or better is set for a potential look at a at a downgrade now I think you are in a financial position that is enviable U around the state for other districts so I w't say what's you know you're going to maintain that dou3 but I don't see any

062pressure there on my end that's one of the things we'll be doing has been through this process before recently we worked together closely at bethl which is we're saying that you know Brian I've known Brian since he came to Washington and we work through Beth's large authorization as well through multiple sales so I was really happy to have Brian because he knows what we do and he's been through the process multiple times's been great through the process yeah so the other part is you'll get a rating from the Washington school bond guarantee program and that is AAA so investors will look at that say well if you miss your payment on your bonds which you're not going to do because you never even touch the money County collects the taxes and make payments on the

063bonds that the state will step in and make that payment so because of that you get a much better interest rate because they know you got a co-signer on your loan essentially so the rules and responsibilities it's you as a board you're have the ultimate responsibility to approve the sale with bonds so that's why it's important that you understand what we're doing and you feel comfortable the direction we're moving forward uh the superintendent finance manager they make recommendations to you and I make recommendations to them and to you in extension but the other parties you'll see the names of foster Garvey that's your legal council Lee marchisio is the bond Council who's working through he drafted the election resolutions for example and he'll be drafting the resolutions you'll have for consideration at Future meetings to

064undertake their role is to make sure doing everything legally in accordance with local laws state laws federal laws Federal Securities laws um that and if we do everything correct and legal and Dot all the eyes um then they will issue an opinion that your bonds are exempt from the interest on your bonds are exempt from federal income tax that's called the legal opinion and because of that because investors don't pay income tax on that interest you get a lower interest rate so it's important impressive but they're the ones that we're on speed dial I we I talk daily to to these person know glor as well and Brian will be as well the financial advisor I kind of talked about what I do but it's again it's to make recommendations to you that are in

065the best interest of the district and in taxpayers is somebody that has some knowledge about the the bond market and know how things work the underwriter um is a firm that will buy the bonds from the district and turn around and sell them to investors that's their primary role and they will buy all the bonds you know we have $175 million for sale we have different matur there they'll buy all those bonds and then find investors for those bonds they get their compensation by the difference between what they buy them from the district and what they sell them to investors for and we negotiate that in what's called a negotiate sale so I work with the district to negotiate that fee we haven't selected an underwriter so the firms you might have heard of their

066most prominent state are D Davidson Piper Sandler um RBC a couple of big National firms that and um so I'll talk about that in a little bit but that's kind of their role if you think about it in a real estate transaction um they're representing the buyer of your home essentially so that's why they can't have fiduciary duty we represent you're the seller so some of the decisions that we're making kind of internally I wanted to make sure you're aware of but you don't have to necessarily be involved in in these things and they're actually delegated items as part of the bond resolution one is how we sell those bonds and how you select the underwriter you can do what's called a competitive sale where you say on this date and this time we're going

067to sell these bonds to any underwriting firm in the country that wants to bid on the lowest true interest cost and the other way would be to say what's called negotiated sale where you bring the underwriters in ahead of time and then you negotiate the terms you have them help structure the financing the way that works best these smart people so I think you know we have good ideas but they have good ideas as well so in in kind of thinking of a real estate transaction if you had a a school building you're trying to build you had a flat site and the plan you'd used before and everything was set in the market for materials pretty you'd bid that out say the lowest construction cost you going have bid it well if the site's

068not level and you know it's kind of little unique case and you're trying to move things youing the contractor in potentially ahead of time to hopefully avoid cost overruns and that sort of thing so it's a real similar thing the majority of bonds Nationwide and Washington are sold through negotiated sale probably 60% plus are sold through negotiated sale the competitive sales are typically like the state of Washington and real big issuers but we also do competitive sales for for schools as well if it's the right time um in the right decision and it may be that we do some negotiate some competitive but that's how you select that under and then we also have to think about the bond sale amounts um we don't want to borrow all that money at once because you're not

069going to spend it the IRS won't let you borrow that money at once because they don't like tax exempt bonds because nobody's paying them income tax so they don't they don't want them outstanding any longer than they have to be you have to say you expect to spend a certain amount of money within three years and so we work that test and this chart is your cash flow projection showing essentially this first sale being $175 million will get you through uh for a few years and we'll update this every year it'll be kind of keep going work Mar very closely and say okay when you need the money when can we sell it there's some advantage to selling earlier because you can put that money in your investment account and earn some interest on there

070and do some more projects but then your interest cost is higher and that relates to your tax rate so we're kind of doing some you know competing goals if you will um so we're looking at this first sale being $175 million sometime the spring and Brian and I talked a little bit ahead of time in the meeting we're kind of catching up on things and I want to make sure he knew we there's no hurry on this to sell these bonds we're not trying to beat anything in the market we don't know what's going to happen and Marina is saying you know like you know you don't have excavators out there you have dig and dirt if there are costs that that come up um for Architects or professional fees you can pay those and

071then get reimbursed out of bond proceeds so there's nothing driving us to say we got to hit a date of closing on this date and I think that's important know when we're talking about flexibility we don't want to box ourselves in a corner just to hit a you know kind of an arbitrary schedule um the refunding again you know we kind of talked about that that I think adding that in if it works and if it's enough savings to make it worthwhile we'll throw that in if we don't we we'll scrape that that piece out so the competitive negotiated sale the reason I'm recommending negotiated sale on this one um primarily is because of the volatility in the interest rate Market it'd be really nice to have the underwriters on board to G to be

072part of that process we go to a competitive sale you're going to sell it on that day it's hard to move back from that and we don't like what's going on that day then you really kind of get what you did with the negotiate sale we can move a dayto day if we need to um the um Underwriters in Washington have a good history of servicing the you know Washington schools we've got some good strong firms here I do believe that it's not the district's responsibility necessarily but it's it's nice to have firms that dedicate their resources to Washington and Washington k12 and they support the you know wda and Wasa and they um and I think that's worthwhile having it means that they understand Washington schools better than other Underwriters and so when they're

073talking to investors they can represent you better I think by having local presence so we're um thinking what we do is um we will issue a a short RFP major firms that do Washington tools and we'll have them present their credentials prop post fees and then we'll evaluate that and um then make a selection and you often and we we will likely on this one what I would recommend is we have multiple under writers you have what's called a senior manager and then a co-manager so if it's like d Davidson on one p you have them both involved if it's those two I'm not saying it would be but they're the two big players as you've probably heard their names um and maybe it changes from issue to issue I've seen one senior and one

074one senior other and see how they do and that gives kind of ability to kind of gauge how they're performing going forward and maybe do a competitive sale if we think that okay that that would probably be fine for this District so that's what we'll be doing behind the scenes but the selection of the underwriter is actually part of uh in the resolutions you'll be considering one's called the bond resolution it has it's called a delegating Bond resolution so you're delegating to the administrative team and us to finalized Bond sale if we can meet certain parameters maximum interest rate maximum term um we box it in so we're not just you're not giv the indistry you know kind of a blank slate to just go do this have to meet certain parameters like the refunding

075we'd have a minimum savings Target if we can't do that we're not doing it um if we can't meet those parameters we'd come back to you and explain what would changed and we did so that underwriter selection is one of those delegated items it allows the administrative team to make that selection based on what they think and what we evaluate uh would be in the best interest of the district but I want to make sure that you know have some background well how do we choose these guys right and the guys say guys but it's you know these firms and it it would be through a process that we're going to make sure that we're you know kind of doing our due diligence especially with the first sale of a large authorization put them put

076them to the PAC that's a little bit I said this be the best way to put it so the refunding uh Bonds on the 20145 right now we'd think of net of all the additional cost of doing it' be about $280,000 so that's 1.1% we're saying if that is at least 1% that we wouldn't do it it's right there whether we' do it or not and it's hard to say and if we get you know and this was couple weeks ago interest rates have risen since then so it'll be a hit Miss whether we do it but again it's pretty straightforward I think by having a minimum savings Target either we do it or do well we're going to be selling the other bonds one way or another but I would argue that $280,000 is

077real money that helps offset the cost of issues for the new bonds and if we can do it there's no reason not to so again our uh what we're trying to look at for tax rates got to make some assumptions on things you know going forward but these are the same assumptions we're using during the bond planning and this graph would show what your tax rates would look like after all of the bonds are sold and so get up that 463 kind of stay level now these are very conservative we're using 4% growth in the district assess value and we talk about tax rates it's the amount you're leving in dollars divided by the assess value of the district and that comes up with the rate my expectation is what will happen is that rate

078will move down over time and the assess value grows more than 4% and so it'll be kind of generally decline that's what happened at bethl we end up way below what they were Bing tax rate but it's important that we don't want to have the tax bills going up that was really the main thing is look we don't want to have the tax bills growing exponentially each year because of these bonds that's what we're really trying to achieve so if the value of your home goes up 10% instead of four the tax rate would go down and the bill should stay you know approximately the same that's that's really kind of the long-term goal to we that commitment um but we're well within our you know we're just starting this and it's going to be

079a five six year process of selling these bonds and what we'll be doing it's probably worth mentioning it's a little bit of a reverse process but every year we'll be setting the budget for the debt service Fund in the springtime like we normally do in June we'll be looking again taking another look at in October and in the fall before certification say is there any reason to change that did the bond sale plan change you know because we can change that Levy in The Debt Service fund right up to November and well maybe we're going to sell on sooner than we thought or maybe the cess value grew different or something will change that plan operating L change whatever it would be so you'll see not just the during the budget you'll see us kind

080of talking about Debt Service fund budget in the fall as well and that's not to be construed as it we didn't think about it in the spring but we don't have all the information in Spring that we'd have in November and so we'll be kind of looking at that every every fall as well so our preliminary thinking is we know we're talking tonight kind about what the plan would be by February 12th we'd have an introduction of the resolutions and there two resolutions that be prepared by your bond Council one would be that that Bond resolution as I said about a 30 page document sets all the terms and Condition it's really your contract with invests and so what that amounts to it obligates the district to do a number of things one Mak make

081payments on the bonds uh to comply with ongoing um IRS reporting and requirements and data stuff all of which Brian's really familiar with and we make sure that that those get done U but then most importantly it delegates the authorization to complete the sale adting those those parameters uh the second one is the school bond guarantee resolution that just authorizes the district to actually you won't have that in this one I want to take that back because that was already authorized as part of the election resolution so we already have the authority to f canine guarantee and so that'll be introduced in February 12th and with the idea of taking your consideration I don't want to say approval but consideration of the resolution uh February 19th and we will then move forward with the rating

082call um and try to get the the money kind of miday time frame but again there's no hard and set date right now we're thinking April 22nd potentially but with prime coming on board I want to make sure that we're the big biggest lift on all this is what's called the preliminary efficient statements offering document that tells everything about the district big document and it requires information coming from the district so you know we'll give them you know a week to get place we um it's only third yeah but I do I'm comfortable the fact he knows what we're doing so he knows what we're looking for we have a list of need but it might take him a little bit St that there um anyway so I'm I'm really excited about this I think

083we're in good position to execute now and let voters approve rooved and this is going to be a really I think bonds are fun you know tell I can talk about um and I I hope you'll you'll find them interesting and fun and this really as I mentioned when we did the celebration I um I've been you know worked at a lot of districts and a lot of communities that have these things going on it's something you'll be proud of the rest of your careers anytime you drive through here if you live here anymore to see the thing you you've had a lot of impact on kids and that's the most important thing of course that's why we're doing but looking at that nice building and seeing how that that improves the quality of life

084in the community pretty neat thing again I'm really here to answer questions all I was doing is talking we're in good hands seems fairly straightforward I do like the addition of being able to kind of refinance some stuff since we have this opportunity to fold that in it's smart when car I don't understand when we refund if they were to refinance the or refund do have a refund does that does that lower the taxes or go back to the taxpayer in a sense of because we now have more money that we can use before we have to ask them for more money or how does that what we would do is lower the payments on the existing bonds okay so you collect taxes to make those payments so it lower the future tax collection okay

085but it is taxpayer savings and that's why it's like if you can do it you it's never it never hurts to say you're trying to be fiscally responsible and you know 280,000 for you know for looking at Millions okay they're not going to noce that tax bill or even our tax rate but stilles yeah yeah and I think I think it it's still even if it doesn't make a big dent in some of tax payments it still feels like the right thing to do I think you know especially just there to be had it's you know it's not like we're doing a separate all the work for we just would do it honestly for the amount of you know work it takes to do it for that savings probably not pay off it's kind of

086a good fa thing exactly so Mark let's recap uh February 12th the board will have for first reading the first like what the first resolution that they'll need to uh that they'll be asked to take action on at the board meeting February 19th right will you present that to the board or will that would be legal counsel okay and so I I haven't talked to Lee if you would be here you can talk to you'd like him have Lee here for that if he can't make it I can describe to what if it is kind of just what I said it's you know it's the contract between you and the and investors but it is a 30-page document and um obligates the district to do a lot of things we we will have a lot

087of input into that we already have we've already looked at the draft resolution and it's we do enough from our perspective very straightforward on this because it's not a what we'd consider a super complicated transaction because you know property tax is coming in you're not it's not like a sewer Bond where you've got revenues you got to worry about this you're good hands on the legal side but want to make sure any questions you have that we have who you want here to answer the questions anything from you I I don't have anything yeah Tail's real well we just finished bethl last year okay I'm done with bonds how they pass them here well I need to go there and continue this well and because of um The increased information that you're going to need

088to have as a board member and because you're ultimately responsible for this if you look at our Board calendar uh we've been talking about this at the cabinet level but if you think of that as a chess board we're going to need to move some chess pieces around so that we build in time for you to learn about this this is super exciting it is fun it's fun um to understand the process and the what then Matt and Marina are going to do um they went over the whole like process of a or life cycle of a construction you know project but this is amazing and I mean we have the right people doing this work um couldn't be more happy that you're sticking around so thank you I'm not going Brian thank you for

089joing this crazy team so it's a good team yeah but we want to make sure that you know what's going on and we just might need to move some pieces around on that chess board to make room for these conversations yeah again if you have questions questions that come up or one of the you know community members asked you a question that you feel like okay I should ask that you know bring it bring it up there's we're not we can answer any question that comes up along the way great thank you very much congratulations this gonna be fun thank you question yeah a couple things just to mention I think kind of jumping off of that presentation I'm assuming now that we have a bond schedu schedule at some point so what I saying

090was now we have a bond schedule you can now produce a project schedule as my assump which we're developing now um and it integrates the bond sales and the cash flow with the construction so ultimately we're planning to have one document that lays that all out for the entire bond is that like a February March will see that or when do you kind of um I have the first draft done and Matt is working through his email so I don't know if he's actually seen it or not and um we're also working with some architect teams and we need to get a little more clarity on what their projected schedule is in compared to ours so we're we're close I would hope by February we'd have it pretty solid yeah like our first Pond oversight

091committee meeting is in March so I me definitely by then so that we could share it with the absolutely with and and it'll be I mean I won't say that it's a it's kind of a living document obviously be some fluctuation things but it'll certainly be part of that process with oversight and board reporting other thing I had was kind of jumping off the earlier presentation about we had about and Ela and talking about something kind of has spent on my mind is the opportunities for high school students uh who are needed more of a challenge but maybe IB or AP is not for them um or running start isn't an option because either they don't have a car or they don't have the means to do it or they're more into ASB or things

092like that um and what are some of the other opportunities that we could be looking out to the future you know is it college and high school is it things like that that um I just want to start to spark that conversation no action asking for right now but just more what does that look like for kids who are not going to do ibap running term but still need something to challenge them and then the last one I had was just as a group to be thinking about the committee positions that we all participate in Paul leaving obviously there's some that he participated in and usually we ra Shuffle go every once in a while to keep it fresh so just to be thinking about what you people might want to participate in or volunteer

093for or at least maybe get a list of what all thinking about it so you have three uh you have the Safety Committee policy committee and the equity advisory counselor know Paul like would go to the PTA Leadership Council too I think so any of you can go to that um that's not really a district like sanction board sanction committee um so you're all PA just like that committee I don't know kind of he could reminisce about his times as a PTA know that unfortunately I had a second round of repair of brand new washing machine was so my wife threatened my life if I left before he did well maybe that list could include like what are the sanction ones you're talking about that we discuss and then what are the other ones that

094you would like to see ATO oh yeah I me so these are the Committees that that yeah that the board approves per your policy that you um adopted that you can have at least two no well really no more than two members sered on Paul served on the Safety Committee did Rick was on that but did you take his spot on that on safety yeah and then JB you came to the policy committee right yeah so JB J and then Equity advisory Council has been both of you been us too but but it could be right and you even like uh you don't have to have set it's really how you want to organize all of that do you want set people do you just want to make sure two people attend so and then

095you're really good in your um weekly reminders and calendars of letting us know other things that we can attend we just let you sh me know for attending um like PTO meetings or various things like that is that what you'd like us to continue you can totally do that like de North even sometimes we go to cff um uh and I mean that's not a board committee but she attended every once in a while because she enjoyed that it could be just a more comprehensive conversation at our so if we had the prepped up front what all the things that the requires not required we should be at and then the ones that are kind of the the extras that ability right it's that like oh hey I might want to go sit in on

096that and as we have new new board members coming on just it's also an opportunity to educate on what those opportun have a wonderful night

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.