CorpusRecord 152643

Yakima School District Board Meeting January 6th, 2025 at McClure Elementary

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Yakima School District YouTube
Date
2025-01-09
Location
Yakima County, WA
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,390 words · about 86 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] good afternoon everybody welcome Happy New Year we'll call the January 6th meeting of the yma school board to order at 4 o00 Let's see we offer Spanish interpretation services from Jorge with language connection if you need translation assistance in person please check with Jorge for a device and Jorge would you please translate this information oh there thank you we provide live streaming for the meeting the link can be found on our web page under board of directors or by going directly to to ysd7 dogbo meetings if you wish to make public comment this afternoon there are two options available the first option is for commenting on agenda items only and the second option which comes after that towards the end of the meeting is for all other topics to speak tonight you must sign

002two forms the signin form and the guidelines form and if you are interested in watching past meetings you can find them on our web page ysd YouTube channel would you please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all January's character word of the month is generous demonstrating a willingness to give and share freely with others without expecting a reward I will appreciate the generous Grace this audience and board will show me as I start out this new role please forgive the pregnant pauses as we move from item to item we have our yaka land acknowledgement today the schools of the Yama School District

003rest on the ancestral lands of the 14 confederated tribes and [Music] of the people of the yak Nation inhabited more than 12 million Acres across Adams Benson Chalan Douglas Franklin Grant kitas Kat and Ne counties Frank today we honor those native peoples who attack to the land through history Legends and culture we acknowledge our descendants who live in the world today we thank the caretakers of this land who have lived here and continue to live here since time immemorial an acknowledgement is a simple powerful way to show [Music] respect and a step toward correcting the stories and practices that erase indigenous people's history and culture it also honors the truth on as a school district we will continue to build upon our relations with aak nation this afternoon we'd like to recognize I'd be happy

004to I think that would be great Barb would you please call the role director Walker here director Navaro Jr present director rice here president Becket here and vice president Vian NOA is in route thank you director rice appreciate that keep you honest yeah uh this afternoon we do um want to take a moment to uh remember the memory of three individuals who were important to our district darte Medina Fernandez Linda McDow and Guadalupe Orosco their obituaries are noted in boarddocs and are available online please join me in a moment of silence to honor their memories thank you we have two proc ations this afternoon did not assign me you did we're ready oh excellent then then I will I will defer to The Experts to begin we have Schoolboard recognition a little bit about trumpeting

005ourselves but I'm honored to read this the state of Washington Proclamation whereas the mission of Washington's public school system is to ensure that all students achieve at high levels and possess the Knowledge and Skills to be responsible members of a Democratic Society and enjoy productive and satisfying lives and whereas Washington's 1,477 locally elected school boards of directors and nine elected Educational Service District boards are the core of the public education governance system in our state serve more than 1.1 million students have a combined an annual budget of over $15 billion and employ approximately 120,000 people and whereas school boards play a crucial role in promoting student learning and achievement by creating a vision establishing policies and budgets and setting clear standards of accountability for all involved and whereas Schoolboard directors are directly accountable to Residents

006in their districts and regions serving as a vital link between members of the community and their schools and whereas school boards and educational service districts provide a passionate voice of ADV advocacy for public schools and the welfare of school children and whereas it is appropriate to recognize Schoolboard directors as outstanding public servants and champions for public education now therefore I J Insley governor of the state of Washington you hereby Proclaim January 2025 as school board recognition month in Washington and I encourage all people in our state to join me in this special observance signed this n9th day of December 2024 Governor Jay Insley thank you director Walker director rice it's my pleasure to be able to read this Proclamation into the record today for Martin Luther King Jr Day whereas on January 20th 2025 our

007nation commemorates the federally designated Dr Martin Luther King Jr day and whereas this day serves as an opportunity for profound reflection on Dr King's enduring message of Peace his unwavering commitment to advancing freedom equality and justice through nonviolent means and his call for active engagement in service to others and whereas within the yaka School District our students wholeheartedly embrace the essence of this holiday engaging in meaningful reflection continuous learning and dedicated service aligned with Dr King's principles and whereas volunteers of divine of diverse ages will Unite with students contributing to impactful service projects that fortify communic commun communities Empower individuals and build Bridges fostering the understanding and collaboration now therefore be it resolved as the aama School District Board of Directors we Proclaim that the aama school district stands with the nation in recognizing January

00820th 2025 as Martin Luther her King Jr Day dated this sixth day of January 2025 yaka School District Board of Directors thank you director rice in our reports to the board section this evening we'll begin with President Guerrero from yea addressing the board regarding the Dual language uh program thank you Francis testing all right good afternoon today I bring you experts on the Dual language program I know that you are very interested in how programs run in the district and so I've brought the three women who used to be the tosas that basically ran that program so that you have really solid understanding of what it entails to make it successful I'm going to begin with Erica okay good afternoon my name is Erica Rodriguez I'm currently a K5 El teacher at Martin Luther King

009before I served as a Spanish language arts specialist supporting our dual language teachers and prior to that I was at barge linkoln as a um K2 I worked as a K2 early exit teacher and I was an instructional facilitator I do want to give you a little bit of feedback or background on the areas that I help teachers while working on the Spanish language arts so I provided training on the following areas the pedagogical training on how Spanish is learned um reading and writing emphasis on the similarities and differences in the English and Spanish for example English is an orthographic language where Spanish is a Transparent Language therefore they are taught different um the state standard Common Core learning standards that were written to reflect that in our in our standards um training on our

010district testing lectura for both our building teams which is composed of our par Educators and our teachers who use it for Progress monitoring after that I usually met with grade levels and the instructional facilitators to help with their data analysis on the Spanish instruction um currently we have one instructional facilitator that is bilingual and two reading interventionists that are bilingual in our nine schools I also helped um I met with grade levels at the building level to help with the planning for the amplify lectura which is our district um curriculum or Caminos excuse me curriculum and um we worked we looked at whole group how we were to deliver the routines that are different in learning to read English and we worked on El dict which is a big component for our Spanish um Learners

011and we worked on what strategies to use for small groups um I also helped with the training of our Spanish reading curriculum intervention reading curriculum um and that was done with our par Educators in the most part that is who delivers the instruction and we through that we also I also came and coached and we provided feedback for the teachers for the teachers and the parents um we did um dual language we did it as a everyone in the program the toas we did classroom observations where we provided feedback from those classroom observations uh many times we started we implemented coaching cycles for teachers sometimes those coaching Cycles were um through our administrators who felt that they needed some extra help um I modeled lessons we did co- teing we clo planning and one of

012the important parts and I feel a lot of times is missing is that follow through with our teachers so we not only did the coaching and then I left but then came back and um followed through with that we also had monthly um PD after school which compris it as more of a collaboration where we looked at our curriculum and um through our observations there commonalities that we were seeing that needed um to be addressed we addressed them with all teachers versus just the few teachers in the in the classrooms one of the big pieces was training and intentionally planning for what we callente which is our bridge and El pente is where we make those metalinguistic connections um we compare the phonics the morphology we look at grammar syntax and how um to use

013cognates to um teach that academic vocabulary um this the pente is crucial for our students in the Dual language program in our classrooms that's where we're making the connections we take what we've learned in one language and see how we can learn the second language I really it's a real it's so strong that research says if we are really not making the pente intentional in our dual language classrooms our students are missing the biggest part of becoming dual language uh or becoming proficient in the language um I also with our district team which was um comprised um well now it would have been Jamie U Molly and myself we met you we met monthly with our um amplify company and really looked at making sure that what was provided in the amplify in the English

014was also provided in gumos because a lot of times there's that discrepancy of being provided in one language and not the second language um and we ALS I also I am a glad trainer so we really worked in providing that glad in espanol for our teachers trying to incorporate that I know that on the docket for this year was providing that guen espanol training that um our dual language teachers have been asking for so I guess one of the biggest questions is who is supporting our dual language teachers in the Spanish I mean we do have support for them but there's a difference if it's not in that Spanish language um I've heard from numerous people that our dual language teachers are missing that bilingual support that they've had in the past and I'm just

015concerned that we will not retain our teachers as we expand grade levels and add new buildings and I guess the other question would be are we actively recruiting bilingual and biliterate teachers thank you sorry now I have pick it up sorry I'm short hi my name is AA cenko and I am currently a second grade um dual language uh teacher and um last year I went I was at TOA or I was an instructional specialist for Science and Math in the Dual language program that supported the Dual language program um and prior years prior to that I was a math coach as well and so I've been in this district for 22 years I graduated from Davis not knowing a word of English um and so I know that there's success that could happen in

016this District if we put our ducks in a row the right way um I consider myself being successful by the way um I this is I am here basically to just talk to you in regards uh representing all the new teachers and all the new teachers that are part of our dual language program um many of them are new to our profession as well and so uh the need is uh huge not only in the guidance and the coaching of developing them as professionals but also in um teaching them and coaching them on how to best instruct for uh dual language program and so um I advocate for this um for this program or for this support to be SU stain and structure in a way that um teachers new teachers are supported at least

017for the first three years in the program and we've noticed great success just um like Erica said with all the support that we offer I mainly um supported the math and science and um with that success we saw great gains on uh what we can make in the program um despite no longer being uh in a coaching role I continue to have many phone calls and many um emails from the teachers who were we have already established relationships and me being in a second grade classroom right now I am limited on how much I can help I want to help because a lot of the times they call me because they don't know who else to call who is providing that support for the math K5 right now in the district and who is providing

018that support for the Spanish math in the district or science so those are questions that keep me up sometimes at uh at night I answer those phone calls I um answer those emails in my own time because I feel the teachers they need support and when they it's hard for teachers to ask for help but when they ask for help somebody be better be answering that question right and those are the question that the teachers that we have established that relationship with those are not the new teachers those are not the first year teachers in the program those are not you know the ones that do not know anything about dual language and the dos and dos and the non-negotiable in order for us to have a successful program we have tried in the past

019bilingual education and um dual language before and we have not have great success not only to say not to look at the data that we have in math so um my question is um well one of the questions I just recent one of the questions right before break that I got was a teacher a first grade teacher called me and say hey AA can you talk to me about a number bonds our number important in first grade I almost had a heart attack when she said that of course they are and why would you be asking that question it's in your curriculum that's in my inside brain right that's not my coaching voice um uh but the the answer is absolutely yes because number bonds laid the foundation for a deeper mathematical understanding as students

020progress through the grades and in first grade number bonds help students Gras grasp that concept of part part hole and that part Hole uh eventually transfers into algebraic understanding and so no wonder we have a lot of high school students failing algebra because they don't have that Foundation of number sense so that was part of my role um when we develop I was happily teaching in the classroom I was a fifth grade classroom teacher and when the the Dual language uh came out uh and they needed somebody in math that spoke Spanish I said sign me up because that is my heart it's I have a vision that I want to take this uh District I want to help our students become the New Scientist the new mathematic um uh the new uh people that

021have the strength and the capacity to do uh careers based on Steam and so and those are developing on a daily basis and we are yaka and we can have that possibility not if we are not introducing mathematics number sense from the beginning and why do we have do we have so many remedial classes in the middle school so for me I took it as a a restart um role when I had the opportunity to coach math because not only was I used using my skills as a bilingual TOA but I was also um encouraging and developing and resetting that this is the way we um are going to develop and uh strengthen our mouth so um just one more time I want to ask you to please support um and uh to see if

022you know what kind what kind of supports we have in place place that will um encourage our teachers to ask for help what supports will be next year for that dual transition as we move from third to Fourth and as Erica mentioned the um it's crucial for our third grade te for our third grade students to learn all that vocabulary in English we had a formula set up for them to do that formal uh transfer the bridging and as we visited different districts one of the recommendations was that we offer that bridging earlier on because as students from Dual language test in the high school they don't fail because of the lack of content but they fa because of the lack of vocabulary so it's huge for us to be making in the Dual language

023that specific content academic language transfer good afternoon my name is Blanca manrique vivano I'm currently an ELD um teacher at um lisis and Clark I have multiple certifications um and many of you know me I this is my 33rd year with the Yakama School District I've been in different schools and different roles at uh District level and different and within the schools um to support the implementation of dual language um as described in our yd strategic plan I was provided with some training with uh dual language of New Mexico Around The Guiding principles for dual language education and they have seven strands and I'm going to focus on two today which is instruction and staff quality and professional development um I was a lead facilitator for our dual language leadership committee and we were responsible

024for program implementation for our dual language in our district so the kind of instructional support that AA and Erica just spoke about does not happen by accident it is well thought out and well planned for our dual language teachers and that's something that I would like you to take back after today's meeting um we first identify our student and teacher needs by doing learning walks we created a calendar a yearly calendar uh uh that included our nine schools and we would go and we would do learning walks across those nine schools we would come back with our data we didn't carry anything to write with Franny okay and so we collected our data and set high and worthwhile goals for our multilingual students and for our dual language teachers responsible for delivering the instruction then

025we implemented professional development Focus around that data that we had collected and then delivered the important piece about this though about professional development that I think you need to understand is that the teachers have to go back and deliver it in two different languages currently right in Yakama which is Spanish or English and if our teachers have to deliver that content in Spanish we ensured that we delivered it in the language that they were going to deliver it in so they had to teach reading in content then we delivered the PD in excuse me in Spanish we delivered the PD in Spanish also because we wanted to make sure that they have that academic vocabulary that they need to go back and teach it in the classroom so our PD was not in English and

026then the teachers have to go back and deliver it in Spanish absolutely not we have the power of being bilingual and biliterate and we have the power to provide that PD in Spanish if needed or in English if needed not just in English so we also after delivering the PD we evaluated our teacher and student learning uh and we gave the teachers an opportunity to actually evaluate it themselves because they gave us some feedback through through a survey then again we reflected on teacher learning and through some more learning walks and again set some high and worthwhile goals as you can see it's a cycle it's cyclical right so it wasn't it didn't happen by accident we ensured that what we were doing met the needs of our students and our teachers and because of

027this um we had something wonderful happen in Yakama which is called La Academia and we came up with that name was it me it could have been me it could have been the three of us and La Academia is a 3 to 4 day PD that's provided at the end of the school year for our dual language teachers we have had great success so much that last year uh OPI came to visit and spend La Academia with us and when they saw that they were so excited that they wanted us to be able to support them to provide it Statewide and uh my dream was that we were going to have it in Yakama first because we had the power to do it we had the teachers we had the instructional Specialists to be able

028to pull this off and we didn't and I believe Dr Green you have said that we have it here in Yakama we don't have to go and pay millions of dollars to have somebody come in and tell us to do something we already know that works right because we are working with our people here in Yakama so through this um we have had over 100 participants which is so exciting and we offer multiple sessions for our dual language teachers um I'm going to give you a couple just examples uh dual language guiding principles foundations for instructional spaces ofy social cultural competence the third pillar what I would like to end with is to thank you for your time for addressing the professional development needed for our dual language teachers and to meet the needs of

029multilingual Learners in our district and for you to also understand that something like like La Academia doesn't happen overnight it starts from the minute that they have received the training and provided us with feedback the minute the teachers leave La Academia we're already looking at the feedback for the following school year and it takes a full year to plan for that thank you so much for your time my first year of teaching my first moning Spanish conference the parent told me I don't speak Castilian Spanish and any native speaker cringes when they hear me speak Spanish what our dual language program does is to teach proper Castilian Spanish and that's not something that is easily done you are literally if you were in this program if you teaching these students you have a huge Endeavor

030and when um superintendent and I actually talked about this a little bit at our last meeting and I had some teachers concerned about where this program was going and the impression that I got from the superintendent I'm paraphrasing here a little bit we're moving forward come Hades are high water we are moving forward which is great if we're doing it well if those students are going to come out of this program sounding like they come from dirt poor villages in Mexico then why are we doing this if these three people did all of that work last year and they're not there this year providing that support how are those teachers succeeding and if we are growing this program we should probably be adding a fourth tosa not cutting tosas I know this year initially we

031YC tried to keep one but these women aren't stupid they weren't going to take that position and get stuck with the work of three tosas especially when it wasn't couldn't be guaranteed so they chose to go back to the classroom but I'm telling you that if you want this program to succeed and you want it to do well we need all three of them back and ideally we need a fourth one if you're going to grow the program you're going to add more teachers to their plate more training to their plate we need more questions I want to thank you all for first of all your passion for dual language um anyone who's been around me knows that I have been pushing for dual language for a very long time and was very sad when

032we lost the first program that we tried and was very excited to see the second program uh come in and see the um enthusiasm that our staff has for continuing or or for reinitiating I guess um the Dual language program in yaka I think it's necessary and it's only going to help our kids um as you all know this is part of our strategic plan so unless we do something not very smart and and revisit the Strategic plan and say no we're not going to do dual language anymore I think I think the board is still committed to it but as with anything when you've when you're facing budget concerns there has to be a re-evaluation and you kind of have to step back and say okay we're going to kind of work to get

033this going again the car is kind of stalled out for a minute but we're going to get a mechanic in here and and look and see what's wrong with the car and get the car started again um my question really is um if you have teachers that are coming to you for Content information like curriculum information with the example that we got you know for number sense at grade one um do we not have people in teaching and learning that can provide that kind of information no these these are the ones that were responsible for providing that they are working they have been asked to provide a another Academia right um so they're going to throw something together for that but that's not the same as having coaching Cycles um it's the same as the

034the coaching cycles that we do in regular gened classrooms right now it's just focused on their Spanish curriculum so who coaches English-speaking teachers and English-speaking classes if they have questions about for instance number sents at grade one I did I did it last year as well I know but now right now there's an if like if you're not dual language just a regular classroom I think it's important to just share that um the way that it's being portrayed is that there are no supports other than our maybe dual language Specialists but we have ifs in the building and structural facilitators so those do exist in those positions um we have a a former employ that's uh Contracting subcontracting with us buddy who provides ifs with trainings around some of the topics that she's mentioning um

035it's important to kind of think about what you were talking about it doesn't mean we stop doing what we're doing but we have to re-examine build the capacity within the people that we have uh we had three Specialists last year we have one so there have been times where we've had one executive director over teaching and learning and now you know we have more because we have absorbing responsibilities in other areas Beyond just the support of of principal and instructional leadership so um it will take some time but uh we're not giving up certainly part of the Strategic plan moving forward and we do have an A remaining specialist in that role and we'll see where we can go next year with that so uh the last piece of advice I know that we have

036these three ladies that were in that specialist role last year and could have returned to that one position but the statement was made that they were not stupid and didn't want to do that we have people that remained to support in that program and they're not stupid and they're providing that support so we're we're proud that we have one individual in there uh there are districts that don't have anybody so we're talking about unfunded positions and we're talking about uh a crisis in the state that is resonating quite uh in quite an extreme manner um but I'm certainly excited about the passion uh and I've never said Hades or high water but I am committed to I know I am committed uh to dual language I'm very proud that we have that in uh here

037in our district and we've seen great outcomes in part because of the uh people that we have here but in large part also because of the people that we have in the classrooms that also are able to collaborate in that team approach around our PLC concept so we do have plcs that we're going to be talking about and and delving into in our in our board retreat next week and I think that's an added layer of support that's missing uh that we haven't spoken about today so absolutely um if we had unlimited funds we'd love to be adding uh uh specialists at this point uh we're looking at maintaining until the time that we can build those up again thank you for being able to do the Mind meld and help me get to what

038my real question was thank you ladies for your time this this afternoon and I really appreciate everything that you've done to help our students that are in the Dual language program and are biling or as they work toward becoming um bilingual and bicultural and biliterate so thank you very much I'll Echo director rice and say thank you again for not only the information but for your service to our district at this point we'll uh introduce principal Stephanie Casas our Hostess this afternoon here at McClure Elementary Stephanie the floor is yours yes thank you so much good afternoon and welcome to McClair we're really excited to have you and um I know the remaining slides were shared with you ahead of time um so I'm just going to touch on a few slides that may need

039a little explanation and kind of lead into how we make our plans to improve instruction for um the school year so one of the biggest things for McClair is and I've heard this and I even heard Norm say it in the board document that he was reading is making sure that we have a high level of instruction for all students and really looking at what that means um and um dual language is definitely part of that you will see in some of my slides that there is a mention of MLL and students with which is multilingual Learners and students with disabilities and um we have been asked from OPI as our school improvement process to focus on those so if you do see those called out in some of your slides um please feel free

040to ask me about that um so we are also really looking as as you know this um environment right now is really trying to keep our kids safe and make sure that they feel welcome and um available to learn so that has looked many different ways so the one thing that I wanted to share with you that you may not be aware of is all kindergarteners get tested on um different six different categories when they come into the school system and what that tells us is what is their Readiness level um and so that is not always well known that that's what that assessment is is for it's you may hear the term walk kids um around the district so that is um the assessment the kindergarten teachers give to all of our incoming kindergarten

041students um to kind of as their pre-assessment of where they and how ready are they to learn so I have um on this slide and um I know again you were provided these slides so it might be easier um at a later date if you want to look at these Washington is on the top and mlar is on the bottom you will notice that in 2020 and 2021 is missing that was our year of covid um all of this information is also information that can be found on OSI so it's open to the public so I really wanted to just make sure that if you guys had any questions and or asked about it that you might um be able to explain it a little bit that is a very common question is why is

042there a year of Gap um and so that was the year that we had covid um you will see that this is very interesting as far as we when we make our plans for improvement and moving forward and instruction um about the percentage of students so this is the percentage of students who are kindergarten ready so what that means is in all six of those areas so for 23 24 40% of our students came to us ready at a kindergarten level if you look at that information you can um on OPI and I'd be happy to help you guys you can narrow that down to different subcategories if you would be interested um so it gives us a good idea of every year what is coming to us especially as a first year you know

043as we go into first grade and further grade levels we have previous data so this is a good starting point on where we need to provide instruction the other um big assessment that I'm sure you hear about a lot is the SBA and that's the smer balance assessment and what that is is all kids um in third through fifth grade take this assess so I wanted to just compare for you the difference between McLure and um Washington State and um at McClure I'll in the next few slides we'll talk about what we're doing about that to um better improve our instruction and some of that comes back to that kindergarten Readiness what can we build as that foundation in kindergarten in first grade in those early years so that when they do come to these

044standards and test that they are ready to be um more successful in those so again these are available on ospi um the other thing I wanted to point out to you is that science is only taken in fifth grade for elementary school so that is why you only have one percentage for McClure and um Washington State so out of all this we um have created some school Improvement goals and um we have three categories and it's perfect that Omar is going to come speak about attendance because we also have an attendance goal to move from 91% monthly to 95% 90 yes 95% by next year so we have a we'll talk about a little bit of those supports that we're doing to help kids um want to come to school our reading goal is broken

045into a bigger goal for our school which we are um our goal is to reach for 80% of our students meeting composite score and another acronym you might hear um is dibles and that is our reading assessment that all students take K through five so it gives us three times a year a good um bigger picture of what they're needing and it's um composite is the compilation of a whole bunch of subskills so similar to the kindergarten Readiness when I talked about um the different subskills and categories that they test kindergarteners in we also do that according to um research on what skills do they need to be successful reader um and so we are shooting for 80% of our students to meet composite and that's a big formula that you know um research companies

046like to make those formulas um then our math we decided um that as well and this is where you will see um that we have purposely called out our MLL and our students with disability um and we do that because those are the categories for McClure that we were not sufficient in showing growth and so those are identifi identified by OPI and and our school improvement process so by calling them out individually it brings us accountable to making sure that we're also tracking them and seeing how those students are doing through all those assessments and areas that I shared with you um so we are hoping that 80% of students um will meet fluency standard so for um very similar to what um I and the ladies talked about with number bonds a very found

047big foundation is with fluency for kids and that is a Washington state standard that goes through K5 and so our grade levels have focused on their individual fluency standard so that they can monitor that through their assessments to um ensure that they're being successful and then plan their instruction so one thing that I have heard um being discussed um this afternoon already is our plc's and I just really wanted you guys to understand and know um that these are crucial for us and we have put in a lot of effort and commitment to plc's and um our grade levels meet every other week for an official PLC so that they have a longer amount of time so our teachers have agreed to give up a longer part of their planning um to have it every

048other week because we found that we can accomplish more in 55 minutes than 35 minutes and so um but these the four questions um are really talking about what do they know what do we want them to know and what are we going to do about it and so most schools have done a really good job at figuring out how what do they know um and so we're really working on those last two questions of um what will we do when they don't learn it and what will we do if they do learn it because on both ends we need to be providing support um so I just wanted to really push that um with you guys so you understood how important that was to us we are spending our um early release Mondays and

049early release Wednesdays on providing professional development and working with our grade levels um on introducing or improving our skill um of knowing how to communicate with each other um and how to utilize the data that we have and then we also I I know I heard the ladies talk about the instructional facilitator and um we also have our instructional facilitator and our reading um interventionists that play a big role in that too because without that time then they wouldn't be able to meet with those grade levels to be able to plan different interventions when we do have the opportunity to pull them out so this is a just a list of a lot of things I just talked about but I really want you to see and be able to um see in your slides

050that the different things that when we look at the data and figure out what are we going to do now and so what we do is we create action plans for all of our school improvent goalss so for our reading our math and our attendance and we talk as um a school and decide how are we going to make this better um so there is you'll see PLC and both of them math and reading um and a lot of grade level team goals of focusing on um putting faces to our kids and our numbers so that they're not just a number that passed an assessment but that it's a student and we know who they are and um how to best support them academically socially and every other aspect that's needed so I have I

051know we're going to let you guys have some time for questions I am um not planned at all going to show you guys a dual language classroom so that'll be perfect timing um and a kindergarten classroom um just because again if we don't have that Foundation um in place with our EST kids then it's going to continue to be a struggle for them so any questions that was a lot of information Sherry Sorry Miss Casas thank you so much for your presentation I appreciate all the time it takes to pull together that kind of data two questions for you one is on the kindgarten Readiness slide and uh looks like there's a pretty significant jump um 2122 to 2223 can can you do you have any information as to what why we saw such a

052big jump there that's pretty impressive yeah um actually I don't know the reason um and actually when we started looking at that and um we were actually kind of surprised to be honest even with the up um not as significant but in Washington state um because we we had our students at home for those years and so that is was always a big conc concern of ours um I and I know you guys lived it too as what are these kids being exposed to um so you know there we have hypothesis you know on those classroom or on those homes that they do have that extra support maybe they were able to hear and be exposed to that vocabulary and more language for those families that were home um but I'm not really sure you

053know we I would love to dig into that a little bit I did talk to um principal Lucas at the preschool wondering the same thing just seeing if he had seen a a similar thing interest and he um said yes but it's kind of um all over the place as far as you never know what year and that's the hardest part about kindergarten you never know what you're going to what they're coming into um so we we kind of came up with a new question of what was the difference cuz these are kids coming to us um he also he did State though that that that percentage is not all of our preschools and so it's only a small percentage of Yakama preschools and so what he had mentioned that he was working on was

054making that connection to the home daycares the private preschools that we are not in connection with interesting and then a second question is on the next slide um were you provide the smarter balance assessment for the 23 24 um are you able to speak to any trending information if we compare like the previous um year or two and what that what this year's data compared absolutely um we have had again a lot of discussion about how our kids came out of covid um and so it is um I think every year a big um you know we we sit there and think okay what year were they um in during covid um you can really see our kids who had kindergarten online um they are definitely have more gaps than what um as they move

055up throughout their grade levels um but we we really notice that I mean it's just like our attendance if they're here we can teach them and unfortunately for a long period of time we weren't in everybody's living room unfortunately and so we have seen a significant drop and um that's why we have really looked at how can we close those gaps at starting from the very beginning so that when they get up to those Upper Grade levels they don't have so many holes in that um content vocabulary so these scores that we're looking at on the screen if we look at the 22 to 23 and then maybe 21 to 22 um are are you saying it's kind of a flatlined um score over over the last last couple of years yeah over the trend

056data um at off the top of my head I I'm not sure I would have to look at the slides but that's definitely something that we can get very easily um if you would like to see the trend data that is part of OSI and I would be happy to sit down and share that with you it's yeah generally helpful for us to see the trend data to see how um the individual school and District at a hold really is Progressive so helpful to see absolutely thank you and it's different every year so that's you know then then can the the nice thing about the trend data is you know so the our fifth graders here for 23 24 we can go back um multiple years and say okay when they were in third grade

057and they first started taking this assessment how did they do what did we do that worked or didn't work and start to adjust our plan and our action steps accordingly thank you you're welcome thank thanks again for a good presentation I had one question about your action plan you have a lot of good things in there yeah uh one one question that popped into my mind though especially when you talk about maintaining that progress is do your plc's ever meet in crossgrade teams so that you're looking at you know what are our kids coming into third grade with they're missing so that so that there's a little more coordination vertically as well as within the team not as often as we would like um but they do um usually at the beginning of the year

058we are able to bring them it's a lot easier to bring them together um of course scheduling is usually a big we have created a schedule so grade levels could have common plan time so sometimes that crossgrade level is very difficult um but they do work with that's where some of the interventionists come in handy too because they know that knowledge that they could go or ELD teachers um we have actually discussed a lot of needing that with our dual language program um and understanding so we will be starting third grade next year and so really understanding where those kids have come up through the grade levels um and what kind of crossgrade level plcs they can have but definitely not as much as we'd like it thank you Stephanie um this is a a

059very detailed report so thank you it's going to take me some time to to dig into all of this but I do want to congratulate you on having a very what appears to be a very intentional um plan of action for to to address the gaps and to address the areas that need extra focus and it's definitely a work in progress um like we ask our teachers to do um is making sure that we adjust as as needed and how things are going so of course in elementary education this month is also a very tight assessment month so we will be um assessing kids and adjusting those plans of action to to see how are we doing and a lot of that work is done during discussion through our instructional leadership team I appreciate that

060it's been a very long time since we've been able to visit McLure I think we were probably scheduled during Co year and um I think Jamie did it online didn't get to that but but um I appreciate the fact that you're giving us so in so much information absolutely and by far if you need any you know want want me to sit down I can do a Google meet or and walk you through the slides as well for any of you or you're more than welcome to come it's always more fun to see the kids live so thank you very much Stephanie okay so we I have a a question comments as well I just want to thank you for your leadership as well I really appreciate your plan of action I I I enjoy

061reading those things believe it or not um I I also appreciate the the the that you brought up the the early or the kindergarten yeah and I can just imagine that it makes it arduous in terms of providing getting them up to to where they need to be right and so I could just imagine how how tough that would be that work and it looks like you're doing a lot of work and a lot of effort and into that plan of action and so it makes me wonder you know how far behind are they now I I know that years ago it was two to three grades or 1.5 I think on average I wonder what that is yeah currently um on the and actually we can see um when you go to OSI and

062again I would be happy to walk you through you can actually click on each one of these dots and it'll tell you there's actually a color code that tells you um what percentage are testing in at a 2-year-old what percentage is testing at a three-year-old a four-year-old and a 5-year-old um so that is information that we can easily get um and it tells us information like that so you know when I was talking to principal Lucas it was really interesting to get that perspective of the kids he's seeing coming in through our program here in yaka and also the kids who were not reached as well you know I mean we see like Rella said we see a huge jump but that's still 40% so 60% of our kids in yaka are still somewhere right

063and they're still struggling that we need to try to make that connection for them and those families so I can imagine somebody who's behind a grade or maybe 0 five grades behind that would be doable right but if somebody's two grades behind three grades or yeah how much more does that it difficult for for teachers and for administrators and so forth so absolutely I I it just makes me wonder it just highlights for me in my mind that and trying to make the connection with our current test scores yeah and probably being a driver of of that you know the results we're having so my last question is what what are some family level support perhaps intervention that the families yeah um we actually are very lucky to have a hom Ison now um we

064haven't always had one um so the last couple years has been a huge um plus because she is also bilingual um and um I know one of the slides in there shows our demographics but with over 70% of our families speaking Spanish you know they they they may feel that disconnect so really having her and the experience she's been in that role at other districts so being able to bring her in with the and be able to reach out to families that are not either not sending their kids or they're not knowing how to help their students um Even in our dual language we also have to remember our dual language parents if they are English speaking at home they also don't know how to help their children so really trying to make sure that

065our kindergart teachers have that connection with them and then also um when they see um a need for additional support reaching out and figuring out what it is so um she does a really good job at if somebody goes and says hey I haven't seen this person in a while or they're really struggling um could you reach out we also have an amazing betet team which um is a team of our um interventionists myself our Behavior Specialists where teachers can bring students what that they're concerned about and um We can brainstorm different ideas and sometimes that leads also to a lot of discussion of what is their support at home and is that something that they don't have that we need to provide and so just really keeping those lines of communication open from the

066staff and um having somebody to make those connections when they're needed so one I think so you don't have to answer this so do you believe that maybe not believe so I I'm thinking that in terms of family based support I think it might be more difficult to address parent expectations and the home environment absolutely that's kind of beyond our control right beyond the control of teachers and schools and so forth which however that plays a big role in how well our St are doing so I think that's the the problem is and actually um when we bring parents to those meetings um you know if we've if we've um felt like okay it's time to bring a parent in we actually mentioned to parents a lot that it's sometimes more harm than good when

067you're pushing a student they just got six and a half hours of school and then um they go home and the parents are so concerned and worried that they're like sit down for an hour and do all this work and we tell parents that that ends up causing a huge bridge between them because then the kids mad at the mom and you know and so we actually recommend parents like we'll we'll give you some things here some games some fun things to do um as a family to build that bridge together because sometimes and you don't know if they're getting correct instruction at home too so that's always a downfall yeah thank you for the discussion this afternoon do you think 10 or 15 minutes is an adequate amount of time for the classroom visit

068y absolutely 10 minutes would be great just after 5:00 now so we'll try to be back here within about 12 and a half minutes and we're staying in this hallway so we'll be great perfect thank you so this whole hallway is kindergarten our um three English kindergarten rooms are right here and then two Spanish um dual language kindergarten and our autism room so this is our English classroom and so I really just wanted you guys to look around around um some of the information you guys um might see are some t discussion about zones of Regulation and not some of the social emotional see um lessons that we teach our kids and so for him in this classroom each most kids in elementary school have a number and that's how we you can tell they

069have a number spot they have a number um of their that goes with their Cubbies and so as they come in every student picks their number and tells them how they're feeling um and so there's a lesson that they teach at the beginning of the year and that's schoolwide just really talking about identifying their own emotions um so that we teach them once they identify them then they we can help them work through them um so this there is the number bond that they talked about if you were curious when they were talking about a number bond this is the number bond um where they said part part whole and so that's the concept that they're trying to teach kids when like four in the big circle and two and two yeah so it may

070be both one of the other sometimes you'll see depending on where they're at in the curriculum it could be the numbers here the whole numbers here and only one partial numbers here so then you would ask the kids what number do you need to add to this other number to make a hole um so that empty space could be an all different different areas so that they learn um what is the other part and so that's they work on that and then I don't see any oh here um these are called 10 frames and they're it's they do a similar activity where um they may show five and ask them how many more to get to 10 um so they do they use these 10 frames a lot too for different things and as you

071can see they looks like they were counting turkeys and trees and pies and pumpkins that's the great thing about kindergarten is they're always doing something exciting um so it this I and I brought you here just because like I said the foundation of kindergarten is huge we're very lucky we have a lot of work to do but I have teachers who are willing to put in the work and effort so it's kind of a trial and air sometimes and that's the hardest part about Kinder um I was a kindergarten teacher so it's um nice because I have that like sense of homing when I get home in this yes I do I absolutely do and so it's really fun trying to work with um and they don't know this but it's actually one of my

072personal school goals is kindergarten this year so I haven't told them yet sorry SAR don't break the new Sarah is one of our um kindergarten teachers and so so K of Silence Sarah yeah trust me they already know probably Siri has told them um but please look around for a few minutes and let me know if you have any questions um and I'll um be happy to make Sarah answer them for you I'm I'm happy to so this is my teaching partner's room not my my classroom but but we started number bonds today we just started module 4 today and we had hula hoops on the floor so that the kids get up and they are the two ducks and the one frog and how many animals in the pond you know they get to

073do the story problem physically so we just started that today that probably helps some of the like the wiggler kids that can't sit very long feel free to take some of the wiggle seats down and try those ask about the stools actually he got a grant for these as well he did Foundation oh they're literally Wiggles SE yes okay they're good for your court he coming he has a few regular chairs and he did have um there's bands you can put around the bottom of them and the kids can bounce their feet on them if it's just a kid that needs motion we actually moved our autism rooms into the building um about 3 years ago four years ago and it's been the best thing where were they before they were out in the Portables

074um and so we had a runner a couple Runners and a student who had some severe medical needs and um you know so I was getting very good at running with the AED machine and um it's been wonderful we have amazing staff in kindergarten we have K2 and a 35 classroom and um they're welcomed into all of their kindergarten classrooms um and actually I'll have to share a picture with you cuz I was just showing I was trying to get it on the slide deck for you guys and it wouldn't picture but um dur our Christmas program one of our autism students was standing right up top at their music program and it was absolutely amazing and the picture I caught him was looking at like kind of a mischievous which if you knew him

075that would be yeah but so our K12 students in the the autism classroom join either kindergarten or first grade depending for specialist so any and any other time some of the students last year one of the students was with me half of a day um uh just depending on the student and their needs but whenever possible we in integrate all of our classrooms together so and there's one Kinder room that's attached by a door and so we've had a student in there too so that they have easy access back and forth um and then they have lunch with all of our kids and all recesses together so we try to keep them as part of the and they're very popular they're usually our most popular kids in the school so yeah it's been great having

076them right here it really gets them to be in the mix of all of it and they learn that kind of chaos right because that when we talked about that Family connection of you know that's one of the hardest things is that the parents have to take the their children to a store where it's not quiet so if we're providing this absolutely silent environment for them then they're not being that ready for the community um and really being able to do what all other kids are doing and families so that's a huge part too this is our our autism room but you um you can also sit on the swing swing that's [Music] fun um I brought you in here because this is something that again it kind of talks about that Family connection she

077does um a wish for your child so she asks their parents to write down one wish that they want for their child and so um they do it at the beginning of the year and then they um Revisited it today and talked about remember what's your goal for your mom and dad what you want to learn and so it really gets them involved in in understanding what what they want and part of that bringing their family in so that's super exciting and then you'll see um when you heard um can't remember if it was AA or Blanca or Erica but she was talking about um glad strategy so that's um a lot of them are like tpr so that's Total Physical response so a lot of the movement um or a lot of visuals um

078especially for our students in our dual language class because we do have our students who speak only English so that visual connection is huge for them learning and in second grade this is the first year that they start doing um a little bit of reading in English um and so up in Kinder in first grade they only do science and are they're social emot emotional so we have breakfast after the Bell which I meant to show you that Kinder teacher he had by the SC they actually have little lunch trays that they go get their lunch um and that's how they practice for lunch and so they have it in for breakfast too um but they so that will be their morning check-in and social emotional is English and then their science time is English

079and so for K1 they walk kind of they group kids who because we also have ml kids with parents have that have chosen not to have do language and so we bring them over and we help them build that language in English as well and then when you get to second grade is when they start to have core instruction in um English so this is the first year they do I think 20 minutes of their reading of skills in English so it's going to be neat cuz I I will say I'm a huge fan too and it's neat because this is the year you start to see them all come together so a lot of the concern from parents is my child doesn't know how to read in English and and um because we have

080they get all their core content in Spanish and so um second grade is also up Kinder in first they're tested in Spanish and second grade is the first year that they are taught are tested in both for those reading skills so that they can start um monitoring those English skill sets to subskills that I had talked about so this is the year that it'll be interesting to see them make that transition of we tell the parents please just hold on don't don't go out yet um but it is it's hard for our english- speaking families um I know Jam Lee her daughter goes here and we've watched her you know really struggle and um you know she's a great testimony of what that's like cuz she can't help her at home um but it's all

081starting to come together so I I really like how learning is not a secret here the reason why I say that is because over here we have the purpose criter for Success application but everything's written out Y and and so a lot of times and that's the first time I've probably seen it posted like that so A lot of times you know I'm guilty of this we just give a lesson don't even tell them what the purpose is what what we want them to learn or even how to apply that in their in real lives so I really appreciate her that that's she is definitely um a rock star um she is actually only a second year teacher and but she's one of our Paras that she used to work with us um as a

082dual language parah for tbip and so then she went to school and we were able to it was like perfect timing that we were able to snatch her up so we have a couple teachers like that that we've been able to kind of grow with um that's been a lot of fun to see them make that transition so that knowledge of being a a bilingual tvip PA was huge too cuz she learn that English side of it and then was able to transition that into her bom in Spanish so that's cool yeah she's definitely one of the rock star she's a keeper she's a keeper that's for [Music] sure okay welcome back everybody again thank you uh principal Casas for the tour and for hosting us this afternoon at this point we turn it over

083to Omar santoy for our attendance [Music] report all right thank you uh president Beckett uh members of the board superintendent green cabinet members uh my name is Omar santoy I'm the executive director of student services uh here with the yakma school district and um today I'm going to be providing you a brief uh attendance report kind of more of an update as we spent uh some time last year uh kind of waiting in the attendance Waters um and I'm really excited that uh uh to be able to kind of bring to the board um some data that show some progress um and so this is going to be kind of our second year of some progress and so before I get started um I want to just acknowledge some folks who are doing some great

084work um starting with our kids um our students um have uh made great efforts to increase attendance and and we're we're seeing that um uh in our data um our families have uh been very responsive uh they've also been placing some focus on uh increasing attendance and helping us you know uh along the way um our teachers and staff our teachers are doing a great job uh supporting students and supporting our students uh uh with their attendance um and superintendent green you've been sending out you know data and putting data in front of our leaders our principles um have done a wonderful job of kind keeping uh attendance as a centerpiece to um many discussions within their building and their building plans as as uh principal Casas uh shared earlier um and then especially our

085student services uh Department uh that oversees attendance um across the district uh led by Aaron Thomas and her sidekick uh Shan norinsky uh they're doing a wonderful job uh just working with Bill buildings um and uh and providing great leadership across the district um I'm going to be sharing some data uh with you with the board um I just want to remind uh the board uh so some of our conversations last year were around measurement um and so you know we're we're all looking at it at attendance but um as we discovered last year and as we uh uh kind of dug deeper there's different measurements um when we're all measuring the same thing of attendance um and so there's kind of different rulers that apply um and so um the second slide I'm not

086going to present it up here but uh in in the presentation that's provided to the board on the second slide you will have the three measurements uh from the data points that I I will be going over um and to just give you guys uh a quick reminder the the three are uh how we measure our strategic plan goal um and that is uh students that are enrolled beginning of the year to the end of the year 180 days of those students um or of of those uh students uh how many attended at least 171 days okay that's the way that is calculated uh OSI has their own logic and we went through this they they have their own Logic for uh uh measuring what's called regular attendance and essentially what that is is 90%

087of um uh students are 90% attendance rate for students and the way that they um no it's not this one yeah thank you um they uh students who uh attend in our our district 90 consecutive days or more um do they attend at least 90% of uh the days uh in which they are enrolled and so the the funny thing is when when we talked about the discrepancy with opi's data and the data that we produce from Skyward um a lot of that has to do with how we Define an absence and so our district uh every period counts um and so when we look at our our our Skyward data every period counts so if I'm a high schooler um and I attend three out of six periods and I'm there for half a

088day uh that is reflected in the Skyward data OSI um uses a 50% threshold and so that's why you'll see some uh discrepancies between um District data and then opi's data I I just want to offer that as a reminder um we went through that last year and um and then the third metric that we look at is our daily average attendance which is what we uh use uh here at the district most often so jumping into the data our community commitment and this is uh uh for for goal number two of our strategic plan is at least 19 out of every 20 students 95% % will attend at least uh 171 days out of 180 days of the school year our Baseline for that in 2019 again was 10 out of uh out of

089every 20 uh students at 50% um last year when I reported I reported the 23 Benchmark and you can see that at the bottom of the slide um seven out of uh every 20 students met that criteria um we didn't gain in this particular area but we didn't backslide um and so we remained at seven out of every 2 students um met that 95% threshold that is a very tall order um that we are asking kids to meet um 95% uh attendance um but what what we did see an increase is the students who were kind of um moving in the right direction at the 90% And this would be they were present for at least 162 days out of the 180 um we did see that number increase from uh 12 out of every

09020 students to 13 out of every uh 20 students so we did see a slight increase uh at the end of last year on this slide is um the OPI regular attendance rate and that's the Blue Line indicated on this graph um and then uh we also have an orange line which is our Skyward average daily attendance and um OPI uh you can see that uh last year at the end of the year um the 222 three school year we ended the year at 63.5% um and then we did see a bump in that data and this is preliminary data OPI uh is late in uh reporting out this data so you won't find the 66.2 this is preliminary data uh that has been shared uh with me um so that it has not been

091finalized but we do it does look like uh we it does look like we will see another couple Point increase um to drop an anchor and uh you know I've heard the board ask you know hey so where does the the state lie at the end of 2223 school year uh the state was at uh just over 69% um and so we're closing the Gap with the state you know I'm hoping that uh we can uh you know meet and then exceed uh where the state is in regard to attendance regular attendance um when you look at the Orange Line the uh uh reg or daily average attendants um last year we ended the year at 89% and year current year to date is we're at we're maintaining at that 89% and we still have

092half the year to go um so we're hoping that second semester I'm hoping that students have a New Year's resolution of uh coming to school every day um but uh we're hoping to grow that I'd love to see that number increase to over 90% uh by end of school year and the the other thing with the uh orange line um I did not include it here but it is included in uh uh the slide deck that you guys have uh the year-to day 89% is broken down by building and so on the next slide on on your guys's uh slide deck you will see the 89% uh broken down by building um director santoy real quick what I think is interesting to data is that so like you said the OPI Statewide number is 69.6

093or seven but it's also so that's what three percentage points difference or so but our district and you and I discussed this earlier our district has a free reduced rate of almost 90% And The Statewide average is 50 so it is our imp our intendance to date is pretty impressive given our 40 point gap in low income for State correct and and uh looking at some of the other districts with the same demographics um we're seeing numbers very similar to ours and if not we're uh just slightly above uh some of those other districts um and when you look at some of the subpopulations um I I wasn't going to go to this level um kind of granular level but um the students that are experiencing U struggles with attending every day are you know

094students where we have uh High numbers like uh our our mckin vental students our homeless students students with disabilities um low income um uh numbers and so uh we do have higher numbers of uh those populations in in our district and uh we do see um students who may be uh uh who have stable housing they have higher attendance rates than those those who are homeless um and really the last uh you know piece of information I wanted to um share and this is a huge shout out to um the student services department um just is these are things that uh um we feel is probably most important uh in moving this work forward and and continuing to progress in in attendance and um our student services department is leading a uh PBIS uh PLT

095so a professional learning team um and and one of their main focuses is on improving attendance and um so they have representation reps from every school um and so I I heard um uh uh board member uh Walker just kind kind of talk about uh in the school presentation the importance of vertical alignment but uh really having uh representation from every level uh every building uh they're all they come together and um they are setting goals together creating action plans uh they're monitoring their progress they're really having Data Drive uh the discussions uh and driving the work that they're doing together um one of the core features that um is uh evident in that group is just transparent communication regarding the data um and we want that to start at the classroom level right and

096then and and those same um transparent conversations regarding what's happening and the data being um you know at the building level the whole building is having that same conversation um and then we as a district at the district level will have those same transparent conversations and we can share that with our cabinet um and that's the same transparent information that is brought to you know the school board um here and so we can all look at data and and we can all uh collaborate around attendance and improving attendance for our district um and then just the opportunity for uh uh the school teams to collaborate with one another so then great ideas and and uh um experence expences expertise is shared and so if things are really happening in one building and we're seeing great

097you know data associated with those things um they're not living on an island disconnected from other buildings but that uh a lot of those practices can be shared amongst the other buildings and and that work can be replicated um you know and like I said uh you know this has been amazing work that student services has has started and our buildings are are doing a wonderful job um we're seeing move in the right direction um you know I know that the board has kind of uh not wanted to see kind of that heartbeat effect and so I'm really excited that we just have at least two years now um that I've been able to stand before you and we've been able to see increase for the last two years um so with that I would

098just entertain any questions or comments I do have have a question has the district done any research as to we have data right the the percentage or number of absences by school by grade and so forth but as there any research has been conducted to determine the why and so and we heard a comment here that low income there's a relationship between low income and low attendance why is that in fact a correlation do we know for sure if it is what's the reason for that right um and what is what can we do about that yeah and then what are what are we doing if we know that low income is a variable for no attendance yeah thank you for your question and um you know I I don't know that you we can

099draw causation I think we can say uh there's correlation all right and and and we do see that consistent um and what can we do about uh you know this is is continue to educate um uh leverage Our Community Partners uh we can't do this alone I mean like our strategic plan really calls out we cannot do this alone we need to be partnering with our families we need to be partnering with our our child care uh facilities we need to be uh uh uh uh educating constantly um and working with not and not just uh you know kind of inviting uh people to the table and then them just being kind of consumers but really contributing the conversations about how how do we solve this um and it's not uh I would say that

100this is not specific to the the yaka Community um across the state and Across the Nation we see the same uh Trends uh you know with with this data um but I think continuing to uh lean into to Our Community Partners uh you know our leverage of relationships that we have with our churches with our businesses um to make you know attendance um something that is uh important um I think when we I think we can all remember perfect attendance was always preached uh like good every day you know if you don't have a temperature you need to be in school um and then that mentality has changed after covid where we have um said you know if you're not well stay home and um and there's been kind of in addition to um kind

101of uh communication regarding um overall General I I mean more than just physical health but mental health and um and and I I think really us wrestling with when is it okay to stay home and and to be away from school and and when do you need to be um to to provide more education to to families um is really needed and director Naro to your point if you look at the Statewide data on opis must attend twice two times a month it's non-low income attends at 78.4 and low incomes at 61 so that spread you can see you can see it year after year in opi's data same with mckin vinto obviously that correct is why right what's causing that I mean we have the data but what is what yeah but that's just

102a a question on the we that's just my question when I hear data like that why what are we doing about it and what can we do further for that because we know there is a very strong correlation between attendance and academic achievement we know that for sure and it's 9 whatever in terms of correlation yeah the why is I'm stuck on why but I know we can so um I have uh sent to you uh on messenger a list of scholar scholarly articles that uh are research based around the correlation between poverty and attendance so that's something you could look at at your leisure as you're as far as you're talking about the why um it's a variety of factors when you're talking about students in poverty it can be anything from uh unstable

103housing to lack of reliable transportation health concerns family situations so Child Care issues every one of those is a different component that what we've seen over you know decades upon decades as the school doing more and more and more um to become involved in that Outreach component so it's not one thing but it's the Partnerships that we then put in place like example you know what are we doing to try to improve attendance very easily to talk you know we could talk about um Handle With Care the program that identifies when there's a police action something this happens in the homes of our children and then we're prepared for them when they come to school so there's you know it's not one thing but it can be anything from housing to transportation to illness to

104um Health Care um just across the across the gamut which makes it much more uh challenging now now nowadays for for schools to then you know meet the academic needs when you're becoming more and more and receiving less and less to do that and for some of our kids it's all of those things that's correct that's correct it doesn't have to be just one it could be multiple factors and often is yeah um but I really appreciate the second part um director Navaro uh and what do we do um you know I believe that uh what we're trying to do is making sure that we have a consistent High expectation uh regarding uh attendance and then um really supporting and understanding what's going on with our students in this community and supporting them to re

105to meet that really high expectation and not lowering our our expectations regarding attendance but keeping that expectation very high and then offering the supports um thanks at the school level do we have somebody still with our I know we have Staffing challenges but do we still have somebody that makes a home visit when we have kids that are developing a high absence pattern do we do we make that personal connection to the home with every one of those kids yes our our buildings um are diligent in um connecting with families and and understanding um one always inviting them into the schoolhouse uh but then also uh uh sending staff um and not only do buildings have to have you know th those staff members internally uh at the district office um you know our ssos

106are are constantly um you know uh working with families um and so there's there are staff uh in the building and um there there is staff at the district off office that is helping with those home visits because they are impactful hi Omar thank you for the presentation I really appreciate the way you broke out the three different data points that are used to monitor this goal overall um certainly helpful for me to understand what what what we're tracking on um so specific to the actual strategic plan goal 19 out of 20 students will attend school um at least 171 days out of 180 couple questions about that in general what percentage of our student body um is 180-day student I don't have that I I I I don't have that um I yeah I

107would have to run a uh I well I did run a report that's how I got the numbers but I don't have the the number of how many students um that we retain for 180 days I know we have a high uh Mobility student population and so just sure is how how large the sample size is I think that'll just be helpful to understand um and then with the Baseline in 2019 starting at 20 or a 10 out of 20 students and then um you know down to seven out of 20 the last couple of years what what was it and know that you know Co threw a wrench into ev Everything but what kind of has the general Trend been since 2019 uh it has um the general trend has has been um it

108it actually went down I think we were I think I reported last year five out of 12 um when we returned from covid and then covid the numbers were uh during covid I mean the numbers jumped up and so there was uh because attendance was uh when they were remote sure um was measured in a very different way um and so we saw that huge increase and then we we had dropped to five out of uh uh every 20 students and then we've been slowly increasing you know from six uh from five to six and then to seven for the last two years okay thank you um and just a quick comment on um yeah I I I think it's important that I I I will probably always give you guys a reminder of the

109different metrics because it's got to be confusing as a board um it multiple people get in front of you and show uh show data and it's hard to know what's Pi data versus what is Skyward um you know logic driven data and then data associated with our strategic plan and goal specifically goal number two guess the follow-up question to that is when I see the 2024 Benchmark seven out of out of every 20 students but then when you look at the daily attendance that's in the you know high 80s like that that seems I I know it's a different measurement but it's just still doesn't seem to align in my head and so how how yeah I don't get that yeah so um the this is using Skyward uh uh logic and so every period

110And every period counts and so a period M missed so if you're at a high school uh every period missed so once you have six missed periods then it would equal one absence um and so the this would be and this number of with 89% would be 89% of the total periods that Omar could have uh been in attendance and he was in attendance for 89% of um the periods allotted and so absences and and attendance rate um factor in differently because uh in in one case uh six periods equals one absence and this is uh looking at every available period and how many were actually attended so that doesn't mean that um you % of students didn't attend it just means that of those attended they attended 89% of classes of all of our

111students in the district um 89% of every period that they could have attended they they attended 89% out of the 100 um uh that were offered yes so does that mean that most kids miss at least one period no um it does not uh no it doesn't not mean that most it means as a district on upon average then yes so uh yeah an element Elementary in tendance is taken twice yeah so it gets pretty convoluted and then secondary tendences by period so opi's rule is once it's 50% or more so you could technically be gone for sports for a half day and You' no just just the sky word like I'm not talking about the that's by period the other ones States half half or nothing El is an absence Okay so 89% of

112enrolled School District enrolled students attend classes every day no it's uh all of the students in our district out of every out of 100% of the periods they could have attended they attended 89% of those okay there's a lot of math in there yeah right but so here's why this number is important um here here's why this number is important this number is important uh we believe and I believe this is that if we see daily average attendance rate go up we believe that all the other metrics will go up so if kids are in class every period that they have an opportunity to be in class more often we will see attendance increase like it's kind of making the water rise All Ships Will Rise um and that's that's the logic that that I'm

113moving forward um with you know leading in this area is um and this is the closest metric to actual seat time uh in our district and so um the OPI all these other metrics and Logics um can just kind of wipe out and not not account for every student in every period this is the closest metric to capturing every student and every opportunity that they have to learn um and be in class that we can record that and so that's why I feel that this is the most important number that we should be following in our district so I think if if I were trying to simplify that just and correct me if I'm wrong too so that 89% 89% of our students of all of our students are here not not chronically absent they're

114here enough to be to not be chronically absent 11% of them then are missing two days on average or am I wrong yeah uh let me let me just so out of um every period And every student um if you were to take into account every period And every student um of those opportunities 89% were attended okay that's the best way to to to look at that so it'd be like how how how many periods like seven periods in a day six so it' be it'd be 1 time six times however many students we have correct for high school times up multiple times the attendance right yeah but it's based on individual schedule so yes yeah okay yeah because to your earlier point of the math if it was just secondary missing one period that

115would be 84% because one six is 16% so that's why you get higher than yeah yeah yeah okay thank you any other questions thank you thank you very much Omar and I agree at encouraging to see the stability of the Skyward data appreciate it very much this takes us to our updates does any member of the board wish to present an update today director rice um just a reminder that the legislative session starts on Monday and there will be lots of fun and mert had by all all right hearing no other updates uh superintendent green uh thank you along those lines the legislative conference is uh this weekend so there's still time if somebody was interested in attending that the link is provided in the public content of our agenda uh in addition I'd like

116to share that the MLK March uh will happen before our next official board meeting that is on the 20th it starts at noon and the starting point is the corner of fourth and MLK Jr Boulevard which is right on the northwest corner of our Central service area with the the Gesa Credit Union School District Safeway and then the carpet carpet store so um if you're interested people will start gathering around 11:30 on the 20th and uh will March at noon 1:00 at the convention center for the program so that is again um the 20th and I believe our next meeting is on the 21st and lastly a very short uh uh update tonight just want to acknowledge um to you our school board members and actually to the public um the significant contributions of you

117as our as our board we're we're entering our board recognition month um wasda this is actually the 30th anniversary of the recognition uh as it was set forth and you know your commitment to our mission and Leadership ensure that we maintain high standards of excellence and so we celebrate this month and thank you for your dedication uh to our students and our community and your efforts uh because they're essential to our success and the questions and the uh uh goals that you set and approve and policy so thank you uh we'll be recognizing you throughout this month I just want to call that out so that's it president pcket thank you Dr Green item number three we have calendar updates and future agenda topics there's a large list into the public comment section Kristen would

118you like to the listen please all right I think I'm there now thank you very much good evening board um just a couple of things to bring to your attention as far as the calendar of events um I'm going to go over the up upcoming Schoolboard meetings as well as a few of our Varsity home sporting events that I'd like to point out um first uh as Dr greens mentioned we do have a board retreat coming up on next Monday January 13th that is um the majority of the day and it starts at 8:30 a.m. and it is at our Central Services office at 104 North 4th Avenue and then on January 21st um the business meeting at 700 p.m. also at Central Services and coming up that first week of February um we have

119another school visit which I know we all love those we will be at Hoover Elementary um on February 3rd and that will start at 4M there is a long list of Varsity home sporting events that um you can take part in but a few that I will point out tonight are where Davis play Eisenhower so on January 23rd we have Davis bowling versus Ike um at Knob Hill lanes and that's at 3m. and then also on the 23rd we have Davis swimming versus Ike at Lion's pool at 400 p.m. on the 25th of January we have Davis girls basketball versus Eisenhower and that's at Davis at 4:30 and on the same day Davis boys basketball versus Eisenhower at Davis High School at 6 pm thank you very much president Walker I just no Walker sorry

120president Becket I do have uh I need to you're still writing 2020 yes I haven't I haven't changed over yet so I apologize Mr President uh I just wanted to make mention that I will not be able to attend our board retreat just due to work rated meetings uh with my supervisor and I serve on different committees and planning committees um so I'm just not able to break away that day for to attend our Retreat well I can't promise you won't get volun told for something in your absence but we will do our very best thank you for letting us know um this brings us to our first opportunity for public comment this evening do we have speakers signed up Barb not at this time not at this time okay well then then asking for

121a second time do we have anyone who would like to speak in the first option opportunity for public comment relating to agenda items this evening not at this time okay well in a great Twist of faith that takes us to our second opportunity for public comment this evening they aren't normally backtack like this but that is the way the schedule Falls this evening so we have a second opportunity for public comment Barbara has anyone signed up not at this time okay yes do I need to ask a second time on the second one I don't okay well all right since there is no public comment this evening that will take us into our policy governance section which begins with an approval of the 1.1.0 policy the results of the survey were included in your packet

122via board docs does any member wish to add comments or elaborate on written comments for policy 1.1.0 yeah I like to elaborate at mine since it was fairly lengthy so this this is just my my comments or statements regarding that I I did um indicate that our superintendent is not in compliant with this policy um 1.1.0 but it's for goal three I just want to clarify that and so and the reason for that and just to summarize my comment or my my note there is that I I'm not seeing any progress I didn't see any progress because compared to Washington State average score averages average scores um there hasn't been much of an improvement and achievement from uh since the pandemic and the level and my key uh the key issue that I'm struggling with

123in in in my decision is justifying the level of achievement in in terms of reviewing the data so for instance if we look at uh the prepandemic score so I'm talking about we we the board talks about achievement gaps right so in prepandemic data which is OSI um report card as of the measures it's it shows that for La the the Gap was 177% or the ysd was scores were 17.7% below the state average for Math 15.8 and Science was 13.4 below and if you go all the way to 2023 24 very similar if not wider Gap so for ELA it was 17.6 math 19.5 uh so that that that Gap actually widen and then for science it was 13.5 which is very similar so we've we've heard the term flatlining I think that uh

124it's our test scores are no longer the the heartbeat it's flatlined um so I'm just having I I just haven't seen the the increase now so in terms of of the the level of achievement I'm I'm really struggling with that because we see for ELA um there was a a 0.3 increase okay for for for for over last year for math it was a point a 0 Z or 0.7 increase and then for science it it was the heart rate U pattern so again it's just the the level of achievement is what I'm struggling with in terms of the test scores and so if we look at even if we look at the dis disaggregated data if we look at third grade it was a a increase of point of Plus or or increase of

1250.2% fourth grade 7% fifth grade3 sixth grade we actually went down by almost six and a half or five and a half percentage points there was a nice increase in seventh grade and for eth grade it was a 1.5% increase and then if you look at math and I don't know if I should read them all but but they're they're basically all uh less than 0 in% increase and some of them were even less than 0 or 0.5 increase and for science it was the same thing so I'm just not I didn't see the progress compared to the state averages the Gap is in indeed or in fact has has widened in math and the improvement from the pandemic is just not it's it's we we saw that as Flatline the the the gaps are

126still the same and if if not the same they've widen and that happened in math so again this is difficult for me because it's it's um you know this is what we strive for this is all our effort all our money everything that we do goes into these test scores and unfortunately that's what we have to measure success in our school district but in all school districts so uh so that's what I'm struggling with so for me the question was what level of achievement is adequate that's going to demonstrate progress and compliance on this on goal number three and that's what I'm struggling with when it's less than 0.5% less than 1% I I really have trouble um seeing the progress in that and I know teachers are doing great work uh principles administrators priding

127great leadership and I know there's the role of all those variables we talked about today attendance uh the the family related factors or variables um you know the kind kindergarten Readiness all I know all those play a factor but again I just want to clarify that I am looking at the data solely at the data and um I'm having trouble a difficulty with that level of achievement and justifying I have to I have unless somebody can provide me a justification that that a 0. five or 0.2 uh even a 0.9 is showing progress then I I'm all years and willing to change my vote and to support that if I can find a good justification rationale for that so that's why I I'm I voted that the superintendent is not in compliance with policy 1.1.0

128goal number three thank you i' just like to add one comment regarding that um if you read goal number three the very beginning it says Equitable opportunity to achieve core Mastery and critical thinking now I interpret that to mean that is the responsibility of the board and the superintendent to do everything we can to provide those opportunities to our students it doesn't promise results and ultimately the results are up to the students and their families and their teachers on how they perform so I have a hard time reading that that the how can the superintendent be non-compliant if we are providing the opportunities for students to do that so that's my only question about your the conclusion that you've drawn yeah so is the goal and I had to refer to it is it measuring

129opportunity or is that meas measuring outcomes because that outcomes is part of our uh the equity policy is part of yeah it's it's in there so that and you know but you bring a good point in terms of opportunity maybe as a board we need to reconsider how we measure and that's one of the other things that I know Martha had brought up the the fact that this may not be the best way to measure success of our students in the yamal school dist so my my suggestion let's come up with something in addition to osi's methodology right let's show uh I know in the past we' shown um what do you call it um Improvement and using other measures right uh we we've seen that before but in this case we did we only

130have test scores and again the test scores are not showing uh Improvement they are showing Improvement but 52.9% and and then in some areas like seventh grade I think math it was like a three or 5.6 so that's where I'm coming from but yeah uh if we're going to measure opportunity then I think we if we're going to use that as a criteria then we we didn't have any data on on that so I think both um Draymond and Norm bring up good points um the the policy is supposed to align with the Strategic plan and there at least this page of the Strategic plan that I'm looking at is so it just goes into the data and doesn't necessarily say but maybe the full of strategic plan does say that so I think it's

131a good opportunity to confirm um exactly what that says because ultimately in 2026 is when the big evaluation happens right and so we want to make sure that we're clear in exactly what that means um the um so I think that's going to be just a really important item to clarify because that that will dictate um for at least the literal thinkers out there you know very clear it's black or white response um so it's interesting I've not caught that before that it has said opportunity rather than the actual these things will happen I've interpreted the Strategic plan as these things will happen these are the scores we will attain by 2026 so um I think we need to reflect on that um I don't know if the agenda is done for our retreat but

132I think this is a pretty important topic to to clarify consider 2026 is a year away and I think we also have to go by the the superintendent's interpretation and it's pretty clear that all students will meet or exceed the standards as measured by OPI on smarter balance and the the wcas is measured or assessed by OSBI state report data so that's pretty specific to me that that they have to achieve all students are going to achieve whatever standards right in terms of math Ela math and science is my understanding of that so I mean it's it's pretty pretty clear to me that so but that's not the issue the issue for me is the measurement right what is adequate what is how do we determ and this is something I've been I guess I've

133been talking about for some for years and years is that what what and I use the word significant but that's more of a research methodology we would have to to do some analysis on that and and crunch numbers but what is an adequate level of progress is it 2% is it 3% 5% is it 0.5% for me 0.52% is not progress and so that's that's what I'm struggling with not that what we're measuring or how we're measuring but um progress what is adequate in terms of um if we if you if you look at just the numbers there's an argument that we're not making progress right we Flatline and we've all said we use the word Flatline so again that's where I'm struggling with if if I may before I go to Dr Green uh

134we have discussed after the um particularly robust conversation we had about a month and month and a half ago on at MLK on on um academic achievement um we have discussed adding that to our Retreat agenda I've also asked him to include a conversation about the the language in our surveys because similar to director Navaro the question in some situations comes down to that line of of making sufficient process or progress excuse me and again we have five five board members who probably all have a different version of what is sufficient and what isn't so we we will be discussing that a little bit at the uh at The Retreat and hopefully able to U come up with some better language down the road but that's just a side bar so Dr Green if you'd

135like to respond um yeah I I I think well one I I I I'm certainly not defensive in what you're calling Out director Navaro um I'm also not pleased with where we're at so um as I look at our our outcomes um I know that um I know that we're doing the right things as far as uh implementation of our professional learning communities we heard uh the statement here today which at least it's resonating uh with some of our uh of our Personnel that uh we have a lot of brain power here and expertise within our district and um we are you know I think back to Maria lucero's words um at MLK ironically uh where she called out that plc's uh is PLC is the only initiative that we've ever had districtwide in her

13615 years here as part of the district and I think that speaks to the kind of maybe reach out and try to try to grab the shiny you know Silver Bullet approach that that could have existed in some capacity uh but I also know that if you know I am in charge of the outcomes and I just want to make sure that we're very clear about what those are so you know it's hard to hit a moving Target so is I think that this is really a good conversation for the board retreat and um uh and then of course it will resonate throughout our entire um District as it should because um you know it it uh it speaks to the work that our teachers do that our administrators do that uh the process that

137we have in place and I think the the big challenge um in education is talking about outcomes and not getting defensive or not coming up with excuses but there's a defin definite contextual component to where we are and um you know we don't dwell on the challenges that we have in our district but we've had some things that were mentioned here tonight about you know the poverty rate the the challenges that we see socioeconomic we have um you know Rising inflation and and all kinds of issues that are affecting and impact and we are dealing with uh social capital in a a person oriented um business so it does make it uh very challenging but I I do appreciate uh where we're headed with the conversation I'm glad that it's uh part of the discussion

138on at the board and I think that uh uh you know we can move forward with some clarity of what the board really expects because I will tell you right now that if the board expects us to hit our community commitments in 2026 and that's non-negotiable it's not going to happen I mean that is an aspirational goal that we strive for and uh sometimes we we uh you know what's the saying shoot for the moon and you might hit the stars and so that's what we're doing is we're we're making sure that we're making that you know that efforts and and and and uh but um you know it's a longer discussion I look forward to that so uh thank you for for for bringing that up director Naro and I know that um you're

139probably not alone in U in analyzing that and I I think it gives us some uh great reflective uh uh great reflective opportunity and we'll engage in that at the board retreat I think we'll have to share our notes with you so I wish we'd have you there but I know that's uh we'll we'll get those to you there any other comment regarding appr approval of 1.1.0 do I hear a motion to approve policy 1.1.0 I move that the board approve the monitoring report for policy 1.1.0 Global end statement second it's been moved in seconded is there any further discussion all in favor I just wanted to say just make a St real quick so I'm going to vote to approve all of the an report except for number three I don't know if I

140can do that or not but um that's what I like to do or just make a statement that I'm not in agreement that that is the Met criteria I don't know surve not question our evaluation approving report as it there's no need to change I'm not changing anything valuation of the report no we're not changing our valuation the report just accepting the report as presented okay well I just I guess I want to make because I did vote on that number three I said the superintendent was not compliant that's what I'm that's what I'm referring to okay but that's in the report we're approving the yeah but that I just want to make that statement that's all if that's okay with you Mr Walker okay all in favor please say I are we going to

141do roll call for these or not I would rather do a Voice vote for the policy governance approvals with all due respect I I would prefer if we do if you're calling for a roll call vote we can do that too I'm calling for a roll call vote Barb would you please call the rooll director Walker hi director Navaro Jr hi director rice hi vice president being I president Becket I motion passes 5 to zero thank you Barb our policy 1.3.4 president's role was included in the packet via board docs does any board member wish to add comments or elaborate on written comments does any board member wish to make a motion to approve policy 1.3.4 so moved second it's been moved in second is there any further discussion ARB would you please call the

142role director Walker I director Naro I director rice I vice president banua I president Becket I motion passes 5 to zero thank you policy 1,000 point 3.5 board members code of conduct was included in the packet via board docs does any board member wish to add comments or elaborate on written comments I move we approve policy 1.3.5 second it's been moved and seconded to approve 1.3.5 is there any further discussion hearing none Barb would you please call the role director Walker I director Naro hi director rice hi vice president Bea I president Becket I motion passes 5 to zero thank you policy 1.3.6 board committee principles was included in your packet via board docs does any board member wish to add comments or elaborate on written comments I move approval of the monitoring report for

1431.3.6 second it's been moved and seconded is there any further discussion hearing none bar would you please call the role director Walker I director Navaro Jr I director rice I vice president via I president Becket I motion passes 5 to zero thank you policy 1.3.7 board committee structure was included in your packet via board docs does any board member wish to add comments or elaborate on written I move we approve 1.3.7 second it's been moved in seconded is there any further discussion hearing none Barb would you please call the role director Walker hi director Navaro Jr I director rice hi vice president Bea I president Becket I motion passes 5 to Z that brings us to policy 1400 board meetings order of business and Quorum was included in our packet via board docs we also

144have a Redline version with the revisions suggested by director rice Martha would you like to elaborate on the revisions I think we haven't been very clear with um the public and and even with within our board on certain elements of this policy that have not been there um for for instance uh things like time time length of time for presentations we've been all over the board with that if we have outside organizations or outside individuals come and want to present to the board they have been told 5 10 15 minutes depending on who they are and what they want to present I think there's it probably should be a consistent number and so that's in there um these are and there are other other elements within that where we've been less than clear and I

145my goal was to kind of clarify some of those elements I worked with um Bob no on the language for the policy and to make sure that it was in alignment with any um statute that the legislature has put into effect over the last couple of years that we might not have caught thank you for the rationale can we have a motion to approve so that we can have discussion I'm that we approve the uh alterations and amendments to policy 1400 the voice in my ear is reminding me that this is first reading is that right yes second reading second reading yes please president Becket I'd like to clarify there was a first reading of this a last board meeting for the red lines there's been further revision which appear as blue lined on page

146seven uh so it it's basically the second reading with further modification I don't know if the board wants to treat it as a new first reading or whether we want to just treat it as the second reading with some further modification either way is fine we'll leave it to the pleasure of the board I support Second meeting modification so do I would you like to make that in the form of a motion I move to accept this current version of said policy as second reading with further modification second thank you further discussion so um generally support all of the edits um I um I'm not sure that presentation opportunities Li limiting that to 5 minutes is sufficient certainly I'm all for um a efficient uh meeting um and shorter meetings were possible five minutes seems

147just overly short for individuals that present to us um and and as I read this this does not apply to the existing three minute standard for public comment right this is just when people are requesting meeting time for us correct um I I I don't think five minutes is sufficient for um Community groups that are presenting to us there might be some other really important or valuable information so um you know 10 or 15 minutes seems a little bit more reasonable to me for presentation time allotment and I think in addition it's always been up to the discretion of the president to allow uh more time or as fit or are determined by the the situation of the the content you could certainly allow for more time this just establishes a time there wasn't even

148a time in there before which means that somebody could come up and run on for 30 minutes and we don't have any way to back up a decision to stop them yeah no I I appreciate that I think if if we're looking for um an opportunity for the public to engage with us or a group or whatever to to give us information five minutes doesn't allow for any kind of meaningful delivery of information so I think um 10 10 minutes I I think at at a minimum would would be required to deliver any kind of meaningful presentation you can't really get into the meat of a whole lot of stuff in five minutes so I think this kind of uh um goes against the intention of allowing presentations to the board five minutes just isn't

149going to get very far in terms of sharing uh meaningful information with the board so would you like to see that would I guess I'm asking the board as a whole would you prefer to see that five minutes move to 10 or 7 or my recommendation would be at least 10 minutes I could live with that even with a Proviso maybe that like if somebody had a presentation they knew was going to take longer than 10 but it had some Merit could request longer than 10 minutes and with a rationale you know reasonable rationale for that well shy of an amendment to the proposed language do you want to make an amendment how do just say I would like to see the language for the length of time for something along that lines the length

150of time change from five to 10 that's a motion I move to amend the policy before us to increase the presentation opportunities to 10 minutes you'll need a second I'll second there okay we have a motion to amend on the table is there discussion on the amendment we'll vote on the amendment first and then we'll vote on the approval of the policy so in uh at this point a yes vote would be in favor of adjusting the time allotment from 5 minutes to 10 minutes on paragraph five and presenting to the board so Barb would you please call a rule on the amendment director Walker hi director Navaro Jr no director rice no vice president via I president Becket I motion passes 3 to2 that takes us back to our original modified I shouldn't say

151original I should say modified amended motion before us to approve approve policy 1400 1400 Is there further discussion that policy as amended hearing none Barb would you please call the role director Walker I director Naro Jr no director rice I vice president v i president Becker I motion passes four to one thank you all do we have a need for executive session this evening not have a need for executive session that takes us to the end of our agenda we will see everybody well almost everybody with exception of director Naro on the 13th for the retreat and we look forward to seeing you at our next scheduled board meeting Tuesday January 21st we are adjourned job

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.