CorpusRecord 155606

January 2025 Committee of the Whole Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / School District of Superior
Date
2025-01-07
Location
Douglas County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,897 words · about 50 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001oh I'm not going to go fix it I was going no I'm not going live it's fine they're tenative probably not going Happ me fix that well good evening everybody and welcome to the committee the whole meeting for tonight Monday January 6 2025 like to call this meeting to order we have met compliance with official notifications roll call please gsky here Taylor here Ed Gallagher here Nick Olson here President Steve Olson here ni Schumacher here all right this meeting is a meeting of the Board of Education held in public for the purpose of conducting the school district business not to be considered a public community meeting there are the time for comments by members of the public during the meeting as indicated on the agenda members of the public wishing to address the board on

002any of the topics including included on tonight's agenda may do so by signing up in the public comment signup sheet by the entrance prior to the start of the meeting the board requests refraining from making any comments involving personally identifiable information about students staff or Administration comment should be respectful focused on the items being considered by the board and will be restricted to three minutes in length action taken at today's meeting is to forward the recommendation for final approval at the next regular school board meeting on Monday January 13 2025 first up comments by members of the public C is not next up will be our report from our superintendent just have one action item uh this is an annual approval that we bring to the board each year um our gymnastics co-op with Maple

003requires board approval on an annual basis we have other co-ops that are not required every year and so you see those every other year that's why they're not here um so I don't know if you want a motion in a second and then can ask Ella for any additional a motion in a second do you have anything you want to add to this action item think so well I um I was just kind of talking to Steve too but this is a yearly one um is really I don't say cracking down but um there's some sports that are heavily co-oped and turning into Super schools if you will um gymnastics is a prettyy typical one at that I think because of the cost and the amount of equipment and Equipment cost I think what the

004WIA is trying to do with this yearly um reup of the co-op is this form it used to be just this I'd send it down it'd be done this is just one tiny part of it now I have to go through the application process online and and really work with Ryan Smith over at Maple and said what are we doing to try to individualize our programs and um now with just a two of us and then being a very small school I don't see this being a thing but some of the bigger schools around Madison Milwaukee all these that are four schools of our size that are cooping together um they're trying to break them apart essentially so that's why this is a yearby year we see them girls hockey too so that application is

005much longer than it was even when I started here five years ago um but this one I think is is good when you look at geography of where we're at there's one place to do gymnastics within a I think from here to ashin away um it it's not a point where we have 35 girls from our school that are getting bumped out by Northwestern kids um it's a small pool small team right now so I I think that's kind of what this Co-op looks like um each Co-op just like every other situation is a different situation but that's why girls gymnastics is year by year that up but it is getting more int reviewed and question right yeah yeah right you guys have any questions there other documents that show that this is a CL

006with Maple that I mean I was looking at this one so there's other stuff that this goes with Y so in December Maple approved it and did the same process um so Brian's already submitted his school board approval um so this is just ours and then again I have to finish it off here by February 1 to submit it and I assume I think this question has been brought up before but I just want it to be public so there students that are participating have to pay fees correct correct so um essentially what we do at the end of the years we look and see what was the total cost of gymnastics um they pay the fees they they pay to their school and then we get a check we divide it by 12 girls

007how much it costs for travel for rental for all the supplies coaching contracts divide it off the cost and then we send a buildest and they pay us their shair for student for their student for their student any further discussion hearing none all those in favor signify by saying I hope it carries sign this right now all right next would be our board committee report first report teaching and learning committee Mr Schumacher all right just an information item tonight special education department update Dena Hagen director of student services and special education welcome back thanks all right I'm excited to share with with you some information about special my favorite favorite topic um okay all right so I just wanted to remind you of what the special education department consists of um of course we have

008the three of us here at the district office I wanted to highlight um Christy ranched the special education coach that we hired this year new position new old position um but going very well Christy brings a lot of experience to the table so we're working very well together and I'm I'm extremely pleased with that hire um and then in the buildings we have the rest of the folks that make up the majority of the the team in these these people are amazing um I wanted to share with you some numbers some updated numbers so this is a fiveyear trend of special education percentages so the blue bars are us as a district and what our percent rate of students um with an IEP is and then the white bar is and I just realized on

009the screen you can't see the percentages so it goes I believe from 14 points for the state Y for the state 14 point something in 2020 2021 and then it's crept up to it's just around 15 and a half years Statewide so we're a couple percentage points above the state um however I will say um 177% in my experience is is a lot lower than I've experienced when I worked in Minnesota I was like in the 20s um with a lot of districts there so um always figuring how we can best keep our numbers as low as possible I think uh Wisconsin has a really good framework for um intervention of students before um figuring if they need special education but um we'll just continue to try and stay as close to the state level

010as we can um this is just the disability category breakdown for us this year so most of the students with IEPs in our district um have so for a learning disability of some sort um with second place being uh a speech and language disorder we're seeing a lot of um speech and language issues from what I hear from the speech therapists as a result of Co still had a lot of um situations where speech was interrupted language was interrupted so it's very interesting to see um some of those Trends I also wanted to add some numbers about the special education budget so I think that's helpful for you to understand and know too so we have a total special education budget in this District of about $.3 million um we get some revenue from the

011Federal government as you know but it's only $1.3 million so that doesn't cover much um I'm not sure if you're aware but that um formula of federal funding for States based um from 1993 is when they did that calculation and haven't uh recalculated it since and of course we all know that we have a lot of unfunded Federal mandates in special education and the federal government continues to underfund um what they're supposed to they're supposed to fund 40% um we don't get nearly that much it's it hovers around 133% um so then we can submit some of our um expenses for reimbursement from the state and that reimbursement rate is 33% and um if you remember there is a large to increase that percentage of reimbursement to 60% which would be very great um but

012that only accounts for about $ 3.35 million in revenue for us so that all added together that means Dave has to then transfer 6.7 million from the general fund to cover all of the expenses in the district for special ed so we need that increase any questions on that budget at all okay all right I wanted to celebrate go so I'm I'm just wondering on a Continuum um expenses over time is what does that look like in Prior years I I mean I know you're newer but maybe even right David you know yeah we've been averaging in six million over a number for the transfer yeah thanks I think CH was asking like overall expenses or trans yeah right yes CL or St s right so from LA and Dave can speak to prior to

013me hopefully but um last year to to or I should say 2324 to 2425 stayed the same um as far as budget goes with the exception of you know the increases that were needed for salaries and benefits but other than that there wasn't a budget increase is it safe to say that special education expenses really only go up and don't go down we can really only yeah because there's a maintenance of effort requirement where it says you cannot spend L Mone and then you where with d like hey that's make Cuts can you cut a teacher no because you cannot do that there's stipulations within the maintenance of effort like says can do that so but it's not like expenses are going down expense I just like go down anywhere any expenses are going a

014lot higher um the other part of it is when we get a really high needs kid um that's when expenses can just explode I think did you buy an $10,000 iPad or you know things like that that are Special Assistant devices yeah so are there grants if you do all of a sudden have a a student with very high needs that you know financially a district maybe can't necessarily afford the state does have a I have a category of high cost student aid um which we're going to do an application for one particular student and I haven't been through that process in Wisconsin before so we'll see how much that generates I'm not I can't remember how much we could possibly get back um but it it also has to meet a threshold like and

015I can't remember the formula either um at this point but you know has to be a certain amount to even qualify as a high cost um student as well wow oh wow but do get into that about one on on y okay thank you for that yeah you're welcome you know what that number is Dave you said that there's a mandate I'm spending so much on special do you know where that number Falls can't spend L you can't spend less it's year to year you can't spend less year we said yep so if it increases at all then you're held to that new threshold of spending you can't go further down um there is some exceptions um to maintenance of effort which is a federal law um like for example if if a a a

016person retires um and we replace that person that high cost staff member maybe with a cheaper staff so maybe a savings of 20 or $30,000 that's allowed um we have been able to voluntary it's not like to just cut a budget we have been able to not replace uh folks who have retired though right and because the costs that we've incurred is still higher than the threshold before right because we've we've had people retire but we haven't replaced them right and so that's would been able to do that right it's it's it's the whole amount um basically so you there is some wiggle room with the like I said there's a couple of exceptions to the rule when it comes to I mean there's it's just like everything else 80% of your expenses are residing

017benefits you guys really push to make sure we're not spending more own supplies and things like that or find cheaper ways to to use the programs we have out there because she knows if we're going to be competitive with our teachers and give you know x amount of increase that's going to eat that's going to make it so weed regardless of how much you saves on the supplies he's going to see that just on salary I hate the backup but on the on the chart where we can and you don't have to go back oh you could that one right there disability one TR the learning disability and the specific one LD or sld and then the other one that U I don't know that a lot of people know about the oi yeah so

018other health impairments you're right I misspoke when I said second place was other health impairments so this is an interesting category because um it usually uh it it usually has students that have some sort of Health impairment as it implies that's documented by uh a medical um documentation says there's something getting in the way of their learning however um what falls in this category commonly is ADHD um and there we have a lot of students with ADHD or ADD and so that's that's one of the most common um ways that students are qualifying in that category um but otherwise you can have other diagnosis and conditions but the bulk of it makes up that add ADHD does that help Steve yeah for everybody um yeah the other part of it really is the 504 then

019right you go through the 504 application to see if they really qualify there first which can then automatically kick in the special education needs right and we have a good process in the district where um folks are considering whether a student needs B four plan versus a special education plan the difference is when a student needs special education they need specialized instruction they need special education from a teacher that's specially trained to address the needs with 504 plans it's mostly around accommodating and modifying um as a legal document to you know meet that student needs under law so thank you all right so I want to celebrate a couple things we're continuing this here with the paperwork support for the special education teachers which feels really good because we know that um special education paperwork

020is a burden um but our folks do a really great job um we're continuing to offer the pizza and paperwork nights quarterly so um we have we have about 16 to 20 people that come every quarter here to the boardroom and have some pizza and work on their paperwork for three hours and we pay them for that so that works out good can I just talk about that for a second I just want for those who maybe weren't here but the balance of paperwork and teaching for special education continues to be the most challenging aspect of their job um they've got to fit in many aspects that and the paperwork piece is just a significant piece of that and so we've heard that for many years through listening sessions or meetings that we've had with

021our special education teachers the challenges around this we've tried to brainstorm I've tried to steal some ideas from other districts on how they've supported special education teachers I actually we took that from a different districts um and it had worked for them so we tried it here on the piz and the paperwork um so we're continuing to try to come up with ways to help them balance balance that but it's been through those conversations we've had with staff that it's been an ongoing concern to try to so it's not just like for fun it's it's it's an intentional way that we're trying toate carve out time and support and pay for people to be able to balance that piece of their job if that makes sense yep so and the other to take it away

022from the student you know right otherwise they'll have to miss time for servicing students to be able to complete an evaluation report or something so yeah yep um and the other thing we're doing to support them too is allowing for paperwork days each quarter as well where they can get a sub um for a half or a full day um each quarter to be able to oftentimes they'll come here in a quiet space and work on their paperwork as well so they really appreciated that um couple other celebrations uh uh we have our students with IEPs having achievement growth in all of our buildings after reviewing the report cards so that's excellent I'm digging into that more to really draw out some of the exact data that we can use going forward to really get

023at you know where we can work at improving um curriculum and resource menu this is something that I put together last year um to ensure that we have enough curriculum and resources to teach towards our IEP goals and objectives for kids um we really didn't have um I call it the ice cream menu because it's got a little ice cream on top meaning that special the special education is scoops on top of the Core Curriculum um not a replacement for the Core Curriculum because we work really hard to keep the kids uh exposed and a and and their access to the Cor curriculum that all students get but then they have their special education on top of it but in special in special ed you need a lot of different things because we have a

024lot of different needs and goals and so we have a menu now where if we have a writing need here's the the things the district recommends that we know are research based that we know are recommended that they can you know use and and work from so that menu continues to grow and that's exciting and lastly the steering committee um continues to work this is a representation from all of the buildings across the district I meet with them every month um and uh they have a goal this year of really building um program continuity from prek to 12th grade meaning that whatever is happening in special education in prek can transfer more easily to Elementary can transfer more easily to middle school high school and it can flow a little bit better that's their hope

025and dream so we're working on that um we still have of course some challenges and priorities that we're working on um it's always a challenge to work to respond to challenging student behaviors um and so we've done some good work over the past couple years and the principles are doing an excellent job working with the resources that they have in their building and then also with uh myself and chrisy um going to work with teams and just try to strategize and try to build um individual plans for students that have challenging behaviors um so we'll continue to just explore things to do um to help with that and then general education and special education collaboration I what I mean by that is this is something that's required by special education law that special ed teachers

026and General Ed teachers collaborate together on behalf of students with disabilities and their progress with curriculum and IDP goals the challenge is finding the time for them to do that and so through plc's through master schedule changes we're constantly trying to make sure that everyone has that time um set aside so that they can collaborate and make sure everybody's understood IEP is directing this to do for that kiddos so that's I think the end of what I have do you have any other questions for me my question might be a silly one but there ever kids that are coming off IEPs like you work with them to a level where they're OB with not lifelong disability but are they coming off to yes yes not as many as we'd hoped for but they do exit

027we do exit students and that brings up a good question because I've always wondered why that's not a federal indicator um because I think it should be because there the federal government you know monitors all of this data for special education but the one thing isn't how many kids exit from special ed um but um yeah we try and do that as as soon as students meet their goals and work really hard to determine whether they still have a need for special education versus they might just benefit from it that's something which we worken on changing too thanks yeah anything else have you noticed any chall Alles in your departments with the shifting at the elementary level the shifting of all the students oh no actually I haven't no it's been a very smooth transition

028um yeah that's a great question okay thanks Dina thank thank you so Mr olon Right Mr Schumacher operations committee I have no action items no discussion items informational items the school preventative operations maintenance project at Bryant Elementary David C Director of Business Services I just want to read into discuss the prev maintenance we want to perform at Bry Elementary so we have to do tucko project that has to be done there we had somebody come in and look and they said you know your school is about 30 years old your windows are 30 years old you should really replace your windows soon and if you do it now you're going to have savings because they're tearing up all the the side of the wall to do the tuck point so they also want to do

029the windows um so I have about got estimates probably going to add about $200,000 to the tucko project um I'd highly encourage doing it because they're going to do a whole bunch of work on that siding and then if we don't do the windows at the same time they're going to tear some of that down to put in Windows um I don't see Bryant closing anytime soon I anticipate that school is probably going to be there for another 30 years being used as an elementary school so I think investing in that would be the the most the wisest thing to do because otherwise it's just going to cost us more money down so I just wanted to let the board know about that um Bob's already got the estimates in place so it's just a

030matter of letting our Engineers that created it get it set so it can go up for bid so do you have any any idea of what the savings is by doing it together uh well they didn't have the exact number because they don't know when you're going to go in and do the windows so it's just a matter of it's like if you're doing sighting on your house do one of do windows at the same time you're Place Windows sometime soon as Great Lakes been looked at then because those two buildings were built at the same time yeah but uh that's we're going to take one at a time what's the tuck Plan cost well it costs 600,000 to do it at Four Corners because we just never did it yeah so no it's would

031cost $600,000 at Four Corners if we haven't done it at Four Corners it's another lot type of discussion we going to get that done um every year it's going up 10 to 20% because of what it is is tuck point is the concrete I guess it's in between the bricks so the moisture gets in between the bricks Gets behind it freeze and pause and that's where all the damage occurs um is Four Corners just as old like I not the building but the tuck point stuff or which one which one is priority I mean you guys are asking for Bryant first but why what is the rationale behind that yes I think we have to make a solid F of what we're going to do with all schools going forward you don't want to you

032know invest a lot of money at different schools unless you have a solid plan and Bryant's in that centrally located place where that school is going to be a school that's going to be used regardless of any situation that takes place building it is I I struggle with that because I think advocating for the rural school is very important too at this point and so I don't want to make this decision and then say well we did that so we need to close four corners and again I know this is all just like super down the road discussion but I just don't want that to be a factor in regardless of when we do it we have to do it so it's a matter do we do it this year do we next year do

033we three or I think this is also part of the long range I shouldn't say I think it is part of the long range facility plan and so we have a thought out process from Project to project you can't do them all in the same year so being able to have these Stager out was part of the r significance working to Four Corners this past summer being a lot of work put in last summer to Corners you know when it was last tuck pointed for Corners it hasn't been I would assume all those schools from 95 have not been addressed so and that's where it gets into the Deferred maintenance right when we're looking at a budget of hey we're a whole $2 million we have to layout teachers it's really hard to come back

034in the back end and say hey let's put this amount of money in there when we could um when we when we're making other cuts at the same time um and that you know those schools we have to come with the long SP the big thing right now is there is so much up in the air between State funding Federal funding and we passed an operational referendum and I'm already thinking about what we're going to do in four years when we have to go back for operational referendum telling you right now my update later on we'll get into a little bit more on the operational referendum side of it but it's not a very it's not a good temperature out there in the room and an operation friend creat another fiscal CLI yeah yeah it's

035a $5.5 million fiscal clip where we have to figure out what we're going to do with that whole time make sure we're on Solid Ground so we can make the the right decisions if it's just for next year yeah it's an easy choice but we have to fory and David it sounds like I mean all the schools need work we saw the chart right and so there was money put into four corners this summer Bryan like it's an equity thing that all the schools you know as you can mathematically make it math uh fix those different things get into I don't think it's a either or thing with four corners right we don't want to run two I mean we could look we don't want to run two projects at the same time because then

036all of a sudden you have the amount of people that are going to bid on are going to reduce because why you take this one it's like it's a summer project in which we have to make sure that it's done we only have July you know August to get this project done they cannot lead into September do we have a timeline on the long range facility plan like when we can put priorities and numbers to this is what we're doing like is that is Brian's tuck pointing on the top of the list yep so that's a huge document we had last year to down look at it it kind of comes down to you break it down these are our Reds these are highest you know highest things that need to be done we get

037the top point that need to be done at Four Corners Bryant Great Lakes you have the rops that need to be done at the middle school and Northern to on it and kind of something we look at each year it just that that facility plan will bring it down in my mind what I would like to do is probably br great export Corners in that order and then we have to figure out what we're going to do on the roofs worried about the roofs what are we going to do um Bobby probably isn't an agreement on it but we have to figure out a way to make those roofs last longer as what it comes down to because that's such a huge expense that if something doesn't change at the state level I don't know

038where we're going to get that money because that would require a capital referendum top of the operational ref we just passed top of the operational refer we will need to P for years are and that's part of our strategy in the past has been to reduce interest expenses on a capital referendum that took place in 2016 which we hopefully can get done quicker Expediting those payments and then maybe renew that cap refera but stretching that those rofs out for 12 more years that's that's going to be it's be hard that priority right that's the worst roof or no the old this the Middle School the Northern Lights true other than this one is it worth it to do some value engineering on how much those projects cost y so we've done that a couple times

039um even cisa I think a that did our study they came up with terrible numbers um it goes out and Bob's done it pulled it before I wish he was here because he knows the terminology there's certain types of roofs you can put on is it one that's from what I understand one is glued to the roof and the other on with the rocks are thrown on top of it and you want to use you should use the one with the glut on as opposed to the Rocks because every time you walk on the Rocks one it can a hole on the roof um so when he's gone out he's gone estimates for both like what do you want do you want this roof that's going to last for the next 20 years or you

040want this Ro it's going to have last for the next 40 Years of course if you buy the one that lasts 40 years it's cost you or cost you more money but the longterm Savings of life is going to be signant but that's where you run into the issue even when you construction on a new new building when people start needing to cut they're going to cut on that stuff oh it's just by the 20-y year one is was to the 40- yearold because we don't have the muchoney I guess what now we're paying for it so go on our bus situation again like we need to learn from that of kicking the can down the road it doesn't do us any favors and I guess um um Mr President Dr stari um something that

041I I'm hoping we can see is just like an updated list from Bobby because it still had like Superior on it so that can again just like re-evaluate those numbers if he could do a presentation um that would be really helpful but um I'm in full support of of moving forward with this again knowing that additional things will be coming forward in the future be good to that full picture again want to talk to Bobby about that okay yeah and that's something that'll do not only Bobby but also um as Engineers that assist with that wordss and they're going to take those off the list and reevaluate them if they have rof evaluations every single year course C is another one we have to figure fails I'm glad this is just an informational item yeah

042decisions yet anything else any other question oh I'm sorry that concludes my rep thank you Budget Insurance Mr Olson uh two action items we have Gs gifts grants and bequests administration recommends approval to accept gifts grants and bequests receiv received December 2024 motion to approve have a motion and a second any discussion thank you we appreciate all of it an amazing Angel fund donation I mean all of it's amazing but it's pretty rare that's amazing no further discussion all those in favor by saying I I I motion carries next action item open enrollment Administration recommends 60 spaces for general education open enrollment and zero spaces for special education open enrollment for the 2025 26 school year approve and a second any discussion so uh we have this on every January we're required to have this

043as an action item that the board acts on uh this has been the uh standard amount that we have put on as an action item with the 60 and the zero question came up about why do we have zero spaces for special education that's primarily because uh if we were to enroll students midy year we would be raising case loads just goes back to our paperwork issue we're talking about earlier um it's challenging to higher special education teachers during the prime hiring season it would be nearly impossible to hire additional if Case loads went up in the middle of the year so being able to keep case loads manageable has been the rationale for that that's pretty typical for most districts to not I think so but what I've seen how many um spaces do

044we have filled right now know that off top of my head you know that David okay hearing no other discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I motion carries I have no discussion items and a couple informational items update on school district tax levy Mr David C all right um so I just wanted to give an update the um of mon because that's turned into a very big thing um first of all I just want to start with this is not a a presentation to justify the jump in taxes people are outraged about the jump in taxes and they should absolutely be outrage both the jump taxes but they need to know why there was a jump in taxes and let that outrage be directed in the right spot or having an understanding

045of I hear people say I went to Christmas and my brother went up to me and said thanks for increasing my taxes um the operational referendum did not increase equal stat say 100% we did not lie Amy and I in the board did not sit in the room to figure out how much we're going to jack everybody's taxes up the operational referendum increase taxes by about $4 and 28 to $430 for $100,000 to start out with this is how the tax levy gets created I don't get to make the numbers up this is a highly regulated state statute State mandated spreadsheet that says this is how much you guys are going to levy on taxes this is how much revenue you're going to get from us I just wanted to show that because it's not

046something where we just write a number down and slide it across the table this past 30th I had to we had to pass two budgets so I had to create two budgets at that time I was cursing everything out because it was a lot of work to create one budget much less two budgets that made total sense and came across and had correct numbers I'm glad we did it now because unlike a lot of other districts on their pass operational referendums they have this estimate say this is how much your operational referendum costs we don't we know our operational ref referendum cost $146,000 and3 that's how much an operational referendum SP your school district cost this year that's spread out over all municipalities in the school district again that number comes down to $4 per

047$100,000 in property value the way you get that is you have 146,000 and $3 and you divide it by the b650 mil 6713 in value to the state says the district has again that's the number then it's out of my hands I give the bill to all six municip IP alties and say this is how much you owe me city of superior owes 76.2 16% of the 24.9 million how they de that up that is 100% the job of the municipalities again I want to reemphasize it again the difference between passing and failing is $146,000 the state tells me what the percentage is that's what these numbers are right here the state says this is another thing we'll get into later but the state says the city of superior's value went up 5.9% year-over-year the

048average was 6.6% increase that means that City Superior owns less of all the property within the district and that number gets down into the minutia we're not going to get into it but that's where you don't see exact numbers so when it comes down to I send the bill out to the city and then they got to figure out how going to Deb up so for the city is superior it was like $19 million was to up they then Divi up by using the assess values of their property so this was an example because I hear everybody say everybody's taxes went up and everybody's paying through the not no the only people that are yelling are the people that the taxes went up if your taxes went up you're standing in the corner keeping your

049head down hoping nobody looks at you this is an example of somebody that had a home that was assessed at $210,000 last year got reassessed at ,000 seems like a really big jump right no this is cool this is awesome the assess value went up 37% the average for the city of superior was an increase of 60% on all property if your assess value went up less than 60% doing good if it went over 60% not doing as good the other part of that is the average increase on res residential homes was 70% which means if you got to the average of 60 what I tell people is when you talk averages there's somebody higher and there's somebody lower um there's companies and I went looked at a few of them that not small companies

050large huge companies where somebody might see an increase of $200 on their school operational referendum but then they this other large company had $9,000 it's all based upon how the city assesses it so people come back say how much did my operational referendum cost they come in they say oh my God you said it was going to be $7 for $100,000 but look it cost me $212 you lied but when I talk to him I tell him go back and see how much did you pay last year in your referendum stuff you paid $845 for your referendum stuff last year by us passing an operational referendum we were then able to reduce the amount of Levy that was tied to the capital referendum so the operation referendum gets that this person in this example paid

051$764 yeah that's good enough $764 in referendum this year that's $79 less than they paid last year so this person's like yeah you should pass a whole bunch of more operational referendums because now I'm paying less taxes that's where you get into the issue doesn't work like that so this person super high level all numbers stayed the same they'd say well this operation reference cost me I save $79 by you pass so now let's go look at the somebody that had the big increase this person had $187,000 home that went up to $393 all right I had to double check that because that's 110% this person is paying some taxes so their taxes went up $1,800 and they're coming back and they're saying you said it was going to be $7 for $100,000 why am

052I paying $289 wait what did you pay last year and I come at 751 so your operational refer and made it go up by $289 that's where you run into the issue your assess value went up 110% the average was 60 so not only are you paying more in taxes overall you're paying more in taxes on that Capital reference that be passed in 2016 so if last year your share was $750 I no yeah last year your share was $750 this year that share was actually probably $900 that's where that's getting tied into it so that's the number one thing I want people to understand is the operational referendum did not cost people a lot it was the the reassessment and the reduction in eqa and then this is one I pulled from Parkland because

053Parkland did not assess their stuff so this person had $173,000 home and it's still worth 173,000 pretty much what arkland did Arland did assessment last year so they had jumps last year this year they kind of stay flat so this one their taxes went up $132 it's because school tax went up eqa went up the total referendum went down $3.95 so again they look at and say wait a minute last year I paid 460 and this year I'm paid in 457 so you can't it it's it's if you're going to do you have to do app oranges the number one thing we told people is when this referendum goes through your taxes will go up by after everything that blew up before the break I even was guarding myself the Amy actually found it for

054me where she pulled up the one Community event that we did it and it literally had me saying this is how much the operational reference is going to cost you your taxes are going to go up in all like because we're getting less from the state I can't say whose taxes are going to go up right I can't get down to the individual Mel but on average it costs $4 or $100,000 for this operational refer see State Equalization Aid when we get into State Equalization one thing is um I ruffled some feathers sobody sent out an email out saying hey you know the information you're sending out there is incorrect when I look at it you know we're both right there has been an increase of the state to the equalization aid for public education

055noted in there it said it went up 22% since 2015 2016 I think of us during that same time period inflation went up 29% so we don't have as much money to spend as it was before but yes the amount Aid was increased it just didn't keep up in inflation at the same time Superior had a huge drop Equalization Aid and that's because our red we reduced expenses they're called shared cost expenses and we had decline in enrollment I declining enrollment was mentioned in there as well I don't take declining enrollment as a huge item in there because everybody is experiencing de it's like taxes if everybody's experiencing it we're all experience it the same um the state said the difference between the aid and the total funds needed to pay by the property owners

056so what happens is they reduce Equalization by $2.7 million let's just say they kept it flat the revenue limit that we had they didn't they increase it by 700,000 let's say this 2.7 it stay flat that 2.73 automatically has to be paid by the property tax owners it doesn't mean we get any more money I get the same amount of money this is like you're driving your car and you're with your buddy your buddy decides to put 20 gallons in your 30- gallon tank doesn't mean I have more than 30 gallons in my car it just means he put more in now they took now my buddy only put 10 gallons in and now I got to put 20 gallons so we have to pay more to get it in so the number one C

057cause for property tax increase was due to the state Equalization a for the uh um District to Superior going down another thing they noted is superior pays less in property taxes compared to other districts again true it's not my job to tell you what maple soen or all these other school districts paying property taxes my job is to tell you what the superior school district is I look at at a micro level I'm not at a macro level all I can tell you is we are paying more taxes and is that right I don't think so but that's that's part of what we have so um you have fun doing this not it's not fun anymore but I've created a spreadsheet out there so I can actually tell people what they have on individual basis

058those examples are very very helpful though the screenshots of the property taxes I mean that just it's so clear and I really appreciate you doing can I ask when does the Capital One Drop off 37 37 that's so there's a spreadsheet out there that shows that on the tax on that sheet too so right on so this what this is is you can go out and look at your tax bill and you go in and just enter how much you paid last year how much did you pay this year so in this example they paid less they paid less in uh uh referend so so they go on their assess value went from 162,000 to $240,000 change at 48% again you guys hear that 48% that means it's less than the 60 the total referendum

059for 2023 last year was 6.8 million the total referendum for this year is 6 825 the cost to the owner equal out to this much this is where I'm getting deep into the weeds where it's like this is the percentage that you own of the state of Wis of the school of the city of fit the city of super they own 0.95% of all the land in the city is superior which means they're responsible for 09 0.0095 of the referendum I sent referendum this year was $ 6,852 th000 now people want to know well how much this referendum cost cost me well the easy way to do that is how much did it how much would it cost you if you fail if the ra refer operational referendum would have failed this is the total

060tax Lo for the city of superior the cost of the owner would have been the $625 185 which equals 93% so this person saved let's say this referendum failed the tax bill would have went down $10.34 the equivalent $430 I've done it for about 10 different households over the day today I didn't trust my math at the beginning this is solid this will tell you right now exact if you're assess value jumps up I actually used the one that was up 110% it came down to $430 and the literal amount was you took this $430 multiply by the assess value that get you the total cost the so um the numbers are solid operational referend do not cost more it costs less than what cap now I'm done talking we can you go back to

061your other thing I go page two I think it was sorry page three so one of the questions I get all the time in regards to this and I have no answer for it but maybe it's that second to the last column I hear like town of Oakland is paying more and school taxes but th superi hasn't got up at all um is that because of that percentage and that so what it is is so back in the day the state Chang the rules because back in the day if you they would use the assess value so if City Superior came in and said ah we're going to assess our value our value is $1 billion nobody and everybody else assesses there is the proper amount you're underevaluated to Mak your tax out State figured

062out out really quick that people are gaining the system so now when you come in and the city's per says my value is worth um 2 4 billion the city or the state of Wisconsin says I don't care your value is $2.7 million the 2.6 or 2.4 whatever the city makes on their assess value that's just for their own internal use the state of Wisconsin will comes back and tells us this is I cannot don't ask me I don't know how the village is superior's value went down last year but it's saying that their value went down last year so those people in the village Superior paying loss in taxes because they're same pay their tax will be building down the average increase was 6.6% again this is just like with the assess value in

063your home if your number is greater than 6.6 you're getting more of the bill if your number is less than 6.6 you're getting less of the bill so city of superior actually got less of the total tax liing this year compared to the last year man they they got a big increase let's see I think hard say but 20 something per you make that bigger it's just so 223 it the bottom right there wasn't the city of superior out of compliance with the last assessment they were supposed to do appraisal yeah so it's been while yeah so and that's where it gets into that's where I don't like getting into deep into the the cities um that the city's business as far as they didn't assess their stuff they didn't and they know they didn't

064the state of Wisconsin says that you need to be within like 15 or 20% they weren't even close um so this gets them back up y I think the unintended ramifications were the people that have homes that haven't been assessed in years and all of a sudden they get reassessed in J yeah y um it it the city was out of compliance but it doesn't really affect the levenue that the amount that the city's going to pay because the state of Wisconsin being set for us so this comes from the Department of Revenue I know it says be top but this is the exact go find that on their on their website but that it says you're seeing these like you see this 22.8% increase and that seems really big um but when you're talking

065with smaller numbers that's why you affecting it as much and that's why you can't that's why when I say it's going to cost you $71,000 that's an average for every single person the whole District across six municipalities might more for for Oakland and less for Superior and that's where you get the average so that percentage there of the assessment whatever is basically the driving reason why one top might be P significantly more than say Thomas Pier or even vill's Pier there y right so yeah it's uh because they they're more so if they go and build some fancy company out there uh somebody builds a multi-million dollar mansion on there or something then that's going to jack up the value and then the equalize value of hland will go up the state sets the percentage

066that we can Levy the taxpayers correct yeah so the that's off the revenue limit so and so then do we just go with what the state says or can we change our percentages that we Levy our taxpayers according to our needs up to that percentage does that make sense you go up to you cannot exceed okay can over levy on your debt Services which was has been done in the past um but that's the only way to do it and when you do that you can only use it as to pay off debt so you know 38 or 39 stuff yeah you can only go up to the revenue limit that's the other part what people need to understand is we're really advocating increase this number right here how much we get per 11, 11,327

067for us 11,325 is that's the that's the floor that's the minimum that districts can get the big thing that people need to remember is if they increase this number this 11,325 but they don't increase the amount of money they set aside in the budget toward Equalization in then all that's going to happen is they're going to push that expens that's another big thing I think we need to focus on is don't just increase it and let us don't give us the right to tax you more right back fill it or categorical Aid it's outside Revenue limit it's outside Property Owners just if they bumped up the categorical Aid that's and sped because again the red one that doesn't affect taxpayers yeah I think it's unfortunate the timing and we all knew that that you know

068this going hand inand with the referendum was kind of a bummer but we had to I had put it on the ballot this time because it was the proper time but to do um I had somebody come up to me and say well man it's too bad that you guys did the referendum should have did it next year right y right you would not have passed because right if people are upset now if your bill went down $10 are you not going to be upset right and they are you know so that's where like I said I'm already looking for five years ahead and we have to figure out how we gain the trust back in the public because right now I don't think they believe right everybody i s and talked to and explained

069it to like oh that makes sense but that's like few more right so and I think I think the hard part too is as a board member I knew the impact and we were trying to get the word out but then hearing that you know these um you know as they came in and did these new numbers on the homes that it would be minimal impact I think that was the hardest part because I as a board member voted accordingly to that too thinking okay this won't be bad that impact won't be terrible you know and whether it was known or not it just was a big hit to so many people and and I felt I felt terrible too I mean I was very few you guys would be in you know the top

070School fin it's super complicated it's unfortunately but also the big part of is that big hit that you seeing right now absolutely nothing to do with an operational referend we once have been able to pass this operational referendum we've been looking at a 2 million 2 million to 2.5 mil on the deficit going into next year certainly not fixing that Brian we're not looking at repairing schools because we ain't going to have the money so I just want to add I know um David was a part of some of these but the League of Women Voters and the Wisconsin public education Network we put on I think two um different Community educational forums about public school um funding and it there wasn't a huge turnout and so um even when we're offering it was even

071a virtual two different times evening and and lunch break um you know people want to be outraged but we gave them tangible Solutions before the referendum came forward so that people had a better understanding and I I just I know we continue to try to do that to to build Community Trust um but you can't force the horse to drink the water as they say but we do have priority at Superior days um yes so I am optimistic about that and I'm going to continue to be optimistic about that able to discuss it with people even at Superior days there was a lot of different people there that had a lot of different agendas and priorities that they wanted so pretty much every yeah School's number one that's yeah love thanks David thank you D

072David not yet fund 10 revenue and expenditure any highlights low lights online this is where our expenditures exceed our Revenue because this getting money in but we're right on right on we need to be we get our B expenses Compu benefits will just keep hitting every year and that'll be espe bo Insurance got here the next couple weeks and get that 10% and that's actually one of the wasby proposals is to um change how those payments um come forth because every District faces a challenge like this so yeah who know it will go anywhere but it's on there thank you David appreciate it and that concludes my report Mr President next our legislative committee following up with that Laura gapski oh no that's that isn't it not about that okay um okay sorry um so

073the wasby delegate assembly um in resolutions packet has been shared um there was a total of 12 um um resolutions that were brought forth um I think the the main one is um the Blue Ribbon Commission on school funding um which includes 20 Rec recommendations about school funding because it is a Statewide issue um there are a lot of different options put forth um under you know they make the proposal there's the rationale and then they propose um this Blue Ribbon campaign different um potential solutions that they're asking the legislature to move forward on um I did send it to David because it's from it was from 2017 they modified it it in 2019 and they're using the same document which should be compelling to everyone in our school district and in the state of

074Wisconsin that we are still pushing forward things that were recommend Ed in 2017 and where are we financially only worse off um and these still have not passed um and so I believe um as I was going through those 20 different recommendations and in the past I was one of the delegates um there's a lot of debate about that we're setting the bar too low on the sped reimbursement rate um it it should be a higher bar I don't know actually Ed what that's going to look like um are they going to allow us to make potential recommendations to resolution 01 because it's already a document so like other resolutions we can make uh proposed amendments to it and for this because it's a packet and it's put forth by the commission are we allowed

075to ask for edits or amendments I don't know the answer to that we are well I know that's not the process at the convention they they do ask for modification they've done it in years this is a different this is a packet that is put forth by a commission you're saying this is the original document not the resolution not the resol actual resolution that says support the Blue Ribbon cam commission recommendations right how do you say I'd like to edit the recommendations of a document that is put in the legislature like make recommendations to that here's what we propose so I don't know the answer to that because I've never seen I've never served as a delegate when they put forth a packet like that right it used to be individual sped reimbursement was a

076individual resolution all of these were individual resolutions when I had been on there um so I just wanted to note that um the spread should be set at a higher bar okay still way too low I think the highest was 60 in one of the yeah 60 is what we have a group of a lob we have a lobbyist that um joins forces with the superintendant the business uh managers the special directors and the principles and they all they all represent all the administrative group and we're all looking at a minimal ask of 60% some people have said 90% but Max and the lby one yeah which I was like we're no our common yeah we've been very consistent with 60% minimum mask yeah yeah um so just a couple other um highlights um a

077lot of the other resolutions um we're focused on teacher retention mental health um The lure making that easier so that we can help their professionals on a route to be able to fill some of these teacher shortages that um State superintendent Jill underly has highlighted and and brought forth as almost a crisis in the education field um I didn't see I mean as a board I think I really want to incourage all of us because Ed speaks on behalf of the whole board I do not just sorry about that thanks Brook so you're going to speak on behalf of the entire board so I just hope folks um if you do have recommendation modifications to just run that by the whole board um by the next meeting so that Brook can do a good job

078um making sure that um we're speaking as one voice um there was also um about decoupling private schools and Public Funding um that is something that I this board will consider the 40 um and then also one other thing that uh came up that I thought is just important to think about as a board is the truy issue which um in Minnesota is actually a child protection response and not a law enforcement response um and so just something I wanted to draw folks attention to um that that was um they're talking about a solution for that which looked okay but also I think um personally I've seen a child PR response with a lot better providing supports for younger for young kids yeah so um yeah take a look at that um you do have

079to log in C at the but to their website in order to access that and then I did email out the blue ribbon campaign um the the document from that to all of you that was a little bit harder to find because there was issues on the ledge plate page like went to an air um okay so there were sorry I kind of messed there was no action items that was the discussion um any other discussion regarding that so I just need to know from all board members if we are in support of all of these when I go into represent us if there's anything that you want modified amended uh questioned um that's something that I can bring forth as well the big thing I wanted to point out is last year please go

080over this packet to the resolution submitted by member school boards these were not necessarily adopted um but uh school boards can push them forward there that night and so I need to be able to know how the board feels about these uh we did have one brought forth last year that didn't go through again but they pushed it through and because we hadn't talked about it as a board I did not feel as if I could vote on that um and actually it was unanimous that or not unanimous but it was overwhelmingly agreed upon by other school boards that we were just not going to vote on it because they didn't feel prepared either so please look through these because schools may push them forward so by next week if I can have how everybody's

081feeling what are those at Great uh it's the resolutions submitted by member school boards I believe an document I think an sent it in an email it's also last weekly update too yes so please look at both so I'll add it to this weekly update too you have to you to sign in for it sorry yeah that's the one that's that's the ones that they are actually proposing right now um that we will vote on for sure these ones are not on the agendas necessarily but School boards can add them that's you're the delegate is there a secondary delegate um yeah we voted on yeah there is one yeah I know it's not me are G no um okay any other discussion on the discussion I all right there's no informational items and that concludes

082my report Mr President thank you next is policies and rules committee Mr Gallagher all Administration proposes approval of changing the following policy based on the recommendations in order being compliance with state and federal law updates one action item is the first reading of policy 5330 administr administration of medication uh and Emergency Care motion to approve second so MO and a second I just wanted to update this came from Neola I asked Bren to look it over these are her this is the the conversation that we had she supports this um she's not able to be here with us tonight so if there's any questions let me know and I'll get that answered for next week yeah okay so I know out at Four Corners we don't have full-time nurse coverage can you talk to me

083yeah they have one they have they split with Bryant okay yeah so tell me more about that so my understanding is he has housed at Bryant four days a week he is at Four Corners the other day however he supports both buildings virtually so like when you have to complete the paperwork and the things that go along with school nursing he does that from either site but he's physically at um Bryant four days a week and four corners one day a week what is med dispersement with like Ben all of our office staff are trained in how to do that and so when he's not there just like in any other building our office staff take care of that and they have to have specific training by brenn that include first aid too and stuff

084we have people at each building who have first aid and CPR training and that's not necessarily the office staff it might be a teacher or some other people but we have people in each building who are able to do that um now just say for some of the green highlight stuff that's added that just kind of Falls in line with state law as well so yeah this comes stra out of new law um any other discussion on this policy car no discussion all those in favor signifi by saying I I any opposed passes uh no discussion no informational items and that is it thank you Personnel negotiations Miss Taylor all right I have a couple of action items Administration recommends approval of the January 20202 new hires and separ operations report 202 what 2025 approv

085second you want to click on it it's a short one yeah all right discussion hearing none all those in favor please signify by saying I I all opposed motion carries Administration recommends releasing Bobby matherly director of buildings and grounds early from his 2425 school year contract per his request for retirement effective May 16 2025 with the liquidated damages provision enforced motion approve second there any discussion so if we approve this then who who's responsib who will be responsible then for operations whether the year oh we will be posting the position and hopefully hiring before his departure right we don't in the event that Jamie we'll come up with a plan's such a busy time too I know spring plan part of yeah we set to suceed Sure super much detail he's put in a very

086small plan so we may have some internal that will be maybe prepared and qualified maybe we'll see hopefully all right well Bobby is watching and it's free time we're going back to watch this me I just like to say thank you to him first I am in service I certainly appreciate what he's done over this time here so in the meantime we'll try to get a long range facility update um next month or the month after retirement before any further discussion hearing none all those in favor please signify by saying I I all opposed motion carries I have no discussion items no informational items so that ends my report Mr President thank you this time I will entertain a motion to adjourn second motion second to adjourn tonight's meeting all those in favor signify by

087saying I motion Carri

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.