001Good afternoon. We ask for the courtesy of board members, staff and members of the public that you please silence your cell phones. Good afternoon and welcome to the Orange County School Board's work session, which has been scheduled today, Tuesday, January 28th, 2025, for the purpose of discussing professional learning communities. The public will not have an opportunity to participate in this work session to provide public comment because this is not a regularly scheduled board meeting. No action will be taken and there will be no public comment period in which the public normally addresses the school board on relevant topics that are related to the work of the board. Thank you so much for being with us this afternoon. We have quite a full house. It's nice to see. I'm going to do a quick roll call.
002I believe we have two members that are with us on the phone. Board member Salamanca, are you online? I am here. Thank you. Thank you. Board member Ferrant, are you on the phone line? Yes, ma'am. I'm here. Wonderful. Board member Gallo. What? Board member Vanos. Here. Board member Douglas. Here. And I believe member Felder is on her way and I am vice chair Bird standing in for our chair Jacobs who could not be with us today. As a reminder, board members will not be engaging in outside electronics or digital communication. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. To my fellow board members
003and district staff, when speaking, please make sure that your microphone is turned on and speak directly in so that our YouTube and Orange TV viewers can hear you clearly. Again, thank you so much for participating in or attending today's meeting. We're going to have a moment of silence followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. Now for the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag. Thank you. And I'm going to turn it over to Dr. Thank you. Thank you. ask was now thank you thank you so much madam vice chair so I've got to admit that when I walked into the boardroom I oh my god is it four o'clock I missed a meeting so it worth we're thrilled that we have so many of you with us today to talk about professional learning communities as you
004know we have been working especially this year to try and take things off of teachers plates we've managed to do a few items related to curriculum resource materials the SB uas as well as some of the documentation around strategies for our students with disabilities as part of those conversations we learned or confirmed that there is a great deal of confusion around some terms professional learning communities data process data meetings common planning all of those contributing to time teachers or spending in meetings that may or may not be of value to them and so I tasked dr. Arm rooster to really dive into professional learning communities so that we can have a common understanding of what they are and that is why you see so many people in the boardroom representing the We want to ensure
005that the message is clear and after our presentation today we will continue to ensure that the messaging around professional learning communities spreads all the way down to the classroom level. So we have members here from all of the departments within the Division of Learning including our executive leaders and our principal leaders who supervise our principals so that there is no mistake what we are trying to do and that is to not only gain a common understanding of what we mean by professional learning communities but the structure around professional learning communities, the value of them and what makes them work. It is our hope that as we continue on the path of ensuring that we continue to support our students and our staff we have a common understanding that some of the misconceptions around the data
006meetings, around the common planning are going to disappear and we will all be focused on the work that happens in professional learning communities. So with that said I'm going to turn it over to Dr. Armbruster, our Deputy Superintendent. Thank you. Good afternoon Chair Byrd, Board members and Superintendent Vasquez. We are excited to be here to define and redefine the professional learning community model. Our purpose is to reset, recalibrate the OCPS vision for PLCs, to define commonly used terms associated with PLCs and to revisit our collaborative team meetings and how they are conducted. For the sake of the flow of this presentation we would ask that you make note of any questions you may have on your notes page we have included for you in your folder and we will answer them at the end. If
007you would go ahead and grab that page as you will be using it along the way. I am joined today by a few members of our CAO team and at this time I'd like them to each take a moment to introduce themselves. Good afternoon I'm Mandy Butterfield, the Senior Director for Secondary Curriculum and Instruction. James Russo, Senior Executive Director for Curriculum and Digital Learning. Julie Helton, Senior Director for Elementary Curriculum and Instruction. Karen Furneaux, Senior Executive Director Access and Opportunity. Thank you. So let me begin with some personal history to give you some context to why we are focused on the PLC model. Way back in 1998 I was a young assistant principal of instruction at West Orange High School. I had a young man in my office and was working on his schedule. I
008noticed he had a copy of the book of Mice and Men. I told him that was one of my favorite books and that I had read it when I was in high school as well. He told me he had read it in high school too. When I asked him what he meant he said he had read the book in ninth grade. Then he told me he was reading it again in tenth grade because it was a favorite book of this teacher too. That sounded odd but I came to find out it was true. Teachers chose what books they taught and in this case two teachers in two different grades decided to teach the same book. Not long after I had another student who needed to get out of one class so I had to change
009his algebra one class to another teacher. Two days later he was back and said he couldn't do it. He told me that one teacher started in chapter one and the other had chosen to start in chapter six and would go back and get the first five chapters later in the year. I thought that was true too. Teachers were able to do that. From the teacher's point of view it seemed reasonable but the effect it actually had on students could be immense. I felt like there had to be a better way. In my journey in thinking about doing school better I came across a book titled Professional Learning Communities at Work. Through that book I was introduced to Rick DeFore. The effect was profound and would change my educational philosophy forever moving forward. Based on what
010I learned through my journey over the next couple of years I've been able to learn a lot about what I was doing and what I could be. I started looking at my school and at other schools and with DeFore as a guide realized that we were not the school that we could be. With that in mind we are going to take a journey to four different schools now. Although each school is different they all share the common belief that all students can learn. In fact that is the motto of each of the four schools we are going to visit. Each school has hardworking staff members who love kids and want to do what is best for them. As we visit I want you to picture these schools in your mind as we explain more about
011their belief that all kids can learn. Welcome to your first stop the Charles Darwin Academy. We believe that all students can learn but the extent of their learning is determined by their innate ability or aptitude. This aptitude is relatively fixed and as teachers we have little influence over the extent of student learning. It's our job to create multiple programs or tracks that address the different abilities of students and then guide students to the appropriate program. This ensures that students have access to the proper curriculum and an optimum opportunity to master material appropriate to their ability. Sort of a sort and select survival of the fittest model. I welcome you to your second visit the Ferris Bueller Academy. Here we believe that all students can learn if they elect to put forth the necessary effort. It
012is our job to provide all students with an opportunity to learn and we fulfill our responsibility when we attempt to present lessons that are both clear and engaging. However while it is our job to teach it is the students job to learn. We should invite students to learn but if they elect not to do so we must hold them accountable for their decisions. After all I did teach it. It's not my fault if they didn't learn it. It's theirs. I hope you have enjoyed your first stop the Charles Darwin Academy. I hope you have enjoyed your first stop the Charles Darwin Academy. Here we believe that all students can learn that it is our responsibility to help all students demonstrate some growth as a result of their experience with us. The extent of the growth
013will be determined by a combination of the students innate ability and effort and it is at their own individual pace. Although we have little impact on those factors we can encourage all students to learn and to make them feel special. We are committed to the role that students are given a chance to learn as much as possible and we can and will create an environment that fosters their sense of well being and self-esteem most of our student programs focus on character building and making them feel special. We've made it to our final stop the all-in academy in this school we believe that all students can and must learn at high levels. Our educators love their students and see their role as working as a team to ensure high levels of success. high levels of learning
014for all. We are confident that all students can master challenging academic material and standards with our support and help and we continue to work with them until they have done so. To do this we continually look at data and set goals for student achievement. We celebrate as a faculty and staff whenever evidence of learning occurs. As a school we are constantly looking in the mirror for answers and never out a window. Student learning is our responsibility and we do not shy away from that ever. I hope you enjoyed your school visits. As you learned about each school you may have associated them with schools that you are familiar with. Grab your note taker sheet and take a moment to consider these follow-up questions. Place your responses in the top left corner. Of these four which
015school do you feel like you attended? The next one in which school would you want to work? And then the last one which school would you want your own child? And then a rhetorical question to ask yourself. How much of your own personal experiences influence the way you believe a school should look like versus what it could look like? And another question. How much of your teachers personal experience influences the way they believe a school should look? How much of our teachers, I'm sorry, personal experience influence the way they believe a school should look? Now that we've created some personal connections let's think about how each school responds to a struggling student. As you may imagine it's all over the place. The next logical question then becomes could it be that we have all of
016these types of responses in one school at one time? Perhaps one teacher has one philosophy while the teacher down the hall has a totally different philosophy. In this situation how will we respond when students do not learn is left to the discretion of each individual teacher. Rick DeFore calls this the educational lottery. This happens when teacher autonomy becomes more important than student learning. The question for us becomes how do we move towards all schools having increased organizational effectiveness? This is where the conversation begins for OCPS. As a district we know that all teachers want to do what is best for their students. How can we use collaboration to leverage and respect each other's expertise and knowledge? How can this collaboration help students succeed at high levels and create a consistent and coherent learning experience? So
017now you're going to meet Rick DeFore as he draws on these ideas and speaks about one of the linchpins of a PLC, collaboration. This video comes from Rick DeFore way back in 1987 from his keynote address on professional learning communities at work. DeFore was a public school educator for 34 years, a prolific author, and sought after consultant. He was recognized as one of the leading authorities on helping schools implement the PLC at work process. His commitment to education and advocacy for collaborative teaching environments spanned over the course of four decades. Even now, 40 years later, his ideas and the school he started are still pertinent and relevant to education. As you watch this quick video, consider the following question. What it would look like if we meant it when we said we were committed to
018building a collaborative culture through high-performing teams. We've organized our schools really into individual kingdoms that are staffed by relatively autonomous independent sub- contractors who are responsible only for what occurs in their individual classrooms. As a matter of fact, I think that you can finish this sentence for me because you've either said it or you have heard it if you have been in education for any length of time at all. I wish they would just give me my kids, give me my room, give me my books, and... That's it. That's the story we've told ourselves. The key to being a great school is to just hire really great teachers, give them their books, their rooms, their kids, and leave them alone. Right? Here's what we know to be a hard fact. That organizational effectiveness depends on
019more than just hiring individual people. That individual development, helping a single classroom teacher get better doesn't give you a better school. It might give you a better classroom, but it doesn't give you a better school. Newman and Wheelage did an exhaustive study, eighteen hundred schools over five years, and here's what they discovered. They said, we found lots of schools that had really competent teachers that were unable to raise student achievement because it takes more than competent teachers to create a great school. The task for schools is to organize human resources into an effective collective effort. Pfeffer and Sutton refer to this as the law of bad systems. They say we hire good people, we put them in a bad system, and then we try to supervise them into adequate performance. But effective organizations don't do
020that. They go to work on creating such powerful systems that even mere mortals, average people, can accomplish extraordinary things. As you heard in DeFore's video, a professional learning community can and will happen when a group of autonomous, independent contractors become interdependent, working together toward a common goal for improved student achievement. These schools already operated like the all-in academy that we visited earlier. As stated within DeFore's book, Learning by Doing, the professional learning community process is not a program. It cannot be purchased, nor can it be implemented by anyone other than the staff themselves. Most importantly, it is ongoing, a continuous, never-ending process of conducting schooling that has a profound effect on the structure and culture of the school and the assumptions and practices of the professionals within it. In the original definition of a PLC,
021the school itself became the professional learning community, and PLC meetings were an ongoing process to ensure that every student learned at high level. The PLC process leans on three fundamental assumptions. Assumption 1 is that we can make a difference. Our schools can be more effective. Assumption 2 is that improving our people is the key to improving our schools. Assumption 3 refers to the belief that when a school undergoes substantial improvements, it will directly and positively influence the quality of teaching practices and student learning outcomes within that school. Essentially, meaningful school-wide changes will lead to better teaching and learning experiences for all. These assumptions sit around the foreground of what we are here to do as educators, as the fundamental purpose of school is learning rather than teaching. We know there are pockets of greatness happening
022all across our district. How do we replicate these great practices, and stretch our good schools to great? What is your vision in the future? How might things go awry despite our best efforts and intentions to do the right thing? Dr. Armbruster and a handful of other OCPS administrators were early adopters of the PLC model. The Adlai-Stevenson and Adlai-Stevenson continues to be one of the top schools in the nation nearly 40 years after DeFore's speech. However, as DeFore has explained, the term PLC became watered down to fit current structures and practices rather than schools making the sometimes tougher shifts needed to become genuine PLCs. He coined the term PLC-lite to describe the ways in which schools said they had PLCs. In OCPS, as with other districts throughout the country, the term PLC has been used to
023describe the ways in which schools said they had PLCs. The term PLC has been used as a title for just about every group that meets, and that causes confusion. It will be a transition, but we will need to move away from PLC as the title for every meeting we have. That waters down the real work of a true PLC. Our purpose today is to create clarity on some of these terms that may have been around for a while, but in their tenure have morphed from their original or true meaning. Additional control. The key to contributing factors to PLC-lite could be a lack of instructional planning practices, distributive leadership, and teachers doubting or dismissing the PLC's usefulness. In order to grow a true PLC, there must be clarity around all aspects of it. Consider how many
024perspectives a team of teachers may have. In your note taker, there is a box in the bottom right corner that says the tree. In this box, In this box, In this box, in this box, For you each to draw the best possible tree you can in the next 30 seconds. Now share your tree with the person next to you. What do you notice about each other's trees? Are they the same? Would anybody on the board like to share a few differences they may have found with their tree? Board Member Felder? Turn your microphone. Yes, this was much easier for me to do when I was in elementary school. But anyway, I have leaves on my tree and I have a root bottom where, you know, the ground because the tree comes up from the root.
025Do you want to know why I have leaves? Okay. Because a tree leaves, even though leaves look alike, I believe that they're different. Some about them are going to be different, but they all come from the tree. So when you're dealing with growth, you have to be able to appreciate the similarities and the differences and know that they all work together because everybody's coming from this root. So this bottom, the root, has got to be right so that the tree can spurt. Do you like my analogy? She gets a gold star. I'm a teacher. Would anybody else like to share? Maybe something they had similar or different with their neighbor? Board Member Gallo. I just, it took me 10 seconds, by the way. I didn't really need the big 30, but it's just a tree.
026And I did do roots, too. I just learned recently that redwood trees are all connected together, that the roots are very shallow and they're all connected. I wasn't thinking of a metaphor, but I thought I'd throw that out there since Member Felder did. Not to go off script, but that's a great metaphor for being interdependent. Yeah. Board Member Douglas. This is my tree, okay? It's a metaphor. The trunk of the tree, the teacher, the roots are the knowledge that they inspire to the student, and the leaves are the growth that we see in the future ahead of the student. So that's my tree. Wow, everybody took that way too serious. I'm just saying. This is why our board meetings take so long. Go ahead, Mr. Rousseff. All right. As you notice, without enough clarity. By
027the way, those are all beautiful trees. As you notice, without enough clarity, you used your own experience, knowledge, or understanding to draw wonderful but very different trees. The same has happened with PLCs. Because there is no clarity about the meaning of the words and terms, we have created our own trees in many of our schools based on what we bring from our own unique experiences. They are all nice trees. But they may not be the trees we need. What originally came back to Florida over 30 years ago from Adalie Stevenson High School was morphed into many different trees. Our goal moving forward will be to redefine and reset PLCs in OCPS in order to bring clarity and to improve our organizational effectiveness. As we progress through the rest of our presentation, we will pause to
028clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school.
029We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. We will pause to clearly define important terms as they relate to the overall purpose of the school. Collaborative teams and interdependence are just a few of the words that are associated with this concept. The one OCPS dictionary icon indicates an important term to define or clarify. Within this presentation, this icon will be present when a definition is provided. We have developed an initial glossary of
030important terms and you have a copy of this document within your materials. As we continue to develop professional learning around the concept of PLCs, we will expand this glossary so that we have a common and correct understanding of these words and phrases. This will help ensure that our students are provided consistent and coherent educational experiences, regardless of the school, grade level, or teacher. As Rick DeFore explained in his 1987 speech, often teachers prefer to be independent contractors. However, organizational effectiveness depends on more than just hiring great individuals. The task for school is to organize individuals into an effective collective effort. PLCs consist of individuals working towards this collective effort, focused on learning for all students, whatever it takes, just like the All-In Academy. In this graphic, we define the individual components of a PLC. As
031professionals, or the individuals who are responsible for teaching and are committed to their own and students' learning. Learning is defined as the activities of these professionals that enhance their knowledge and skills. And lastly, these individuals work toward the collective community and learn together and from each other. As we think about the individual terms of a PLC, I also recently shared the definition of both professional learning communities and collaborative teams within a recent Sunday message shared with our Division of Learning Leaders at all levels. As stated earlier, this has been a personal passion for some time. These definitions show the interconnectedness between PLCs and the collaborative teams that make up those PLCs. Notice that they are not the same thing or used interchangeably. The PLC is the school and the collaborative teams are the teams within
032that school. The goal of a PLC is to help teachers improve instruction and collaborate to better serve students. We cannot achieve this goal without working together, interdependently. Collaborative teams are the fundamental structure of a PLC and members work together toward their common goals. The team is the engine that drives the PLC effort and is the primary building block of the organization. The PLC model incorporates three big ideas and four critical questions. We'll take a look at the three big ideas first. A focus on learning is at the top because the fundamental purpose of the school is to ensure high levels of learning for all students. This focus on learning translates into four critical questions that drive the daily work of the school. We'll look at those in a moment. Next, a collaborative culture. No school
033can help all students achieve at high levels if teachers work in isolation. Schools improve when teachers work in isolation. Teachers are given the time and support to work together to clarify essential student learning, develop common assessments for learning, analyze evidence of student learning and use that evidence to learn from one another. A results orientation. PLC's measure their effectiveness on the basis of results rather than intentions. All programs, policies and practices are continually assessed on the basis of their impact on the school. A results orientation. All programs, policies and practices are continually assessed on the basis of their impact on the school. student learning. All staff members receive relevant and timely information on their effectiveness in achieving intended results. And next, the four critical questions of a PLC that drive a focus on learning. In PLCs,
034educators demonstrate their commitment to helping all students learn by working collaboratively to address these questions. First, what do we expect students to learn? What should each student know and be able to do as a result of our instruction? The second question is, how do we know if they're learning? Common assessments are the tools for monitoring each student's learning on a continuous and timely basis. The third question is, how do we respond when they do not learn? We must have a systematic process in place to provide additional time and support for students who are experiencing difficulty. And, number four, how do we respond when they've already learned it? What is in place to move these students forward when they already come in with mastery? We know that collaborative teams are an essential component of professional learning
035communities and they require mutual accountability and interdependency. The primary functions of a collaborative team are grounded within the three big ideas and four critical questions. Common planning is one of the many functions of collaborative teams where they come together to create a consistent and equitable learning experience for students and eliminate what Rick Dufour called the educational lottery. Teams must collaborate to effectively plan for the what to be taught and even more importantly share best practices based on student performance data to see how it is taught that helps students learn best. Data plays an important role in the planning process and should be used within a continuous cycle to inform instruction and show effectiveness of instruction or strategies. It's crucial to remember that in a PLC, all of these functions and more contribute to the unwavering
036commitment to all students learning at high levels. Collaboration that includes thoughtful conversations and social support leading to interdependency and vulnerability is a key characteristic needed for a professional learning community to be successful. A learning culture of trust is formed within the community, which includes shared beliefs about learning and recognizing the challenge of overcoming teachers different attitudes about learning. This concept is solidified through the idea of collective efficacy. This factor involves helping all teachers on the staff to understand that the way they do their work on a day to day basis has a significant impact on student performance. This also means that teachers should not use poorly stereotyped factors such as student's home life, socioeconomic status, or motivation as reasons for poor achievement. Great teachers will try to make a difference despite these factors. The most
037effective collaborative teams are teacher-owned and the process is coached and supported by administrators or coaches. Feedback is critical. Just as all great teams have a coach or a team of coaches, the best teachers are the ones who are the best coaches. The best school PLCs also need coaches. When we work together, we ensure the best possible learning experience and outcomes for students. As a side note to the power of teachers working interdependently, research shows that of all the strategies we can use, collective teacher efficacy is at the top of the list when it comes to the impact on student learning. Research shows that professional learning communities positively impact student teacher morale and retention. This is the most effective way to improve student learning. This is an example of a group that works together to improve
038student learning. By sharing in their inquiry, wondering, and creative problem-solving tasks, teachers lean on each other, develop trust, and gain peer support in their work. When a district and its schools generally embrace the three big ideas and four critical questions, adult behaviors within those organizations begin to shift significantly. School culture improves as teachers build strong relationships and rely on each other, foster good relationships, and build good relationships. This is a key aspect of a group's a collaborative environment. This positive shift leads to minimal staff turnover. As a school principal who fully embraced professional learning communities, I observed an unintended yet highly beneficial outcome, staff retention. Experienced teachers were eager to share their knowledge and new teachers greatly benefited from this wealth of experience. The culture of my schools thrived because of building relationships among staff,
039resulting in minimal turnover. This collaborative and supportive atmosphere enhanced students' educational experience and created a stable and committed teaching staff. Relationship building, social collaboration, and learning from the professionals in the building are at the heart of this transformation. Teachers feel safe trying new approaches and engaging in job-embedded learning, which allows them to problem solve together. This safe space for experimentation and continuous improvement boosts teacher morale and leads to innovative teaching practices. Combining these elements creates a dynamic and resilient school culture where teachers and students can thrive. Here is Rick Defour sharing the difference between a group and a team, or the difference between independent and interdependent. Rick Defour, Director, School and College of Education, NATIONAL EDUCATIONAL LEADER, D.C. There is a difference between a group and team. We ask people to define a team and
040they have said a team is a group of people who work together to achieve a common goal. And if that were true, it would be a group of people working together to achieve a common goal. And if that were true, it would be a group of people working together to achieve a common goal. then 40,000 marathon runners would be a team. They're people who are working together in close proximity. They're all pursuing the same goal. I want to finish this race. And we could say that they're a team. But I don't think anybody would argue that a group of marathon runners are a team. Something is missing. Here are the elements, the three elements that you must have if you're really going to be a team as opposed to a group. You must be working
041interdependently. We must create interdependent relationships. I can run my marathon and I can achieve my goal regardless of what happens to anybody else in the race. But if I were a member of a team, I would have to rely on other people in order to achieve the goal. And they would need to rely on me. So we would have an interdependent relationship. We would have a goal. You can't be a team without a goal. And it would be a goal for which we are mutually accountable. That. Would make us a team. And unfortunately, in schools all across America, we have settled for working in groups as opposed to truly creating collaborative teams. Now here's an analogy that I think makes the point. Here are two of the greatest athletes ever to play in their respective
042sports. And I don't think anybody would disagree with that. Tiger Woods and Michael Jordan, clearly two of the best who ever played their sports. And when they turn professional, ironically, both of them, announced when they turned professional that they shared the same goal. And the goal was, I'm turning pro because I want to win championships. That's how I'm going to define myself. I want to win championships. Now, when Tiger Woods steps onto a golf course to compete in a tournament, he's never working in isolation. He's always part of a group. A collegial, congenial group. That foursome on the golf course, those other golfers that are out there, they can get along just great. But he can accomplish his goals. He can accomplish his goal of winning the championship regardless of what happens to any other
043golfer on that golf course. He can do it all by himself. Michael Jordan, arguably the greatest basketball player ever to play in the NBA. And in 1988, he did something that's never been done before or since. Not only was he the most valuable player of the year. Not only was he the leading scorer of the year, the best offensive player of the year. He was also named as the best defensive player of the year. So, the best offensive player of the year. So, that one man was the strongest force on both offense and defense in the entire NBA. And yet, he did not accomplish his goal. Nor did he accomplish his goal for any of the first six years that he was in the league. Now, why not? He was just as skilled and gifted
044in basketball as Tiger Woods was in golf. Why wasn't he able to accomplish his goal? Because Michael Jordan was a member of a team. Tiger Woods is a member of a group. There is an enormous distinction. Jordan had to rely on other people to accomplish his goal. And until that team could gel, they couldn't accomplish his goal. No matter how brilliant he was. Now, you may be the Michael Jordan of teaching. I doubt it. But you may be. My point is, no matter how brilliant you are as an individual, that does not mean you have a good team or even a good staff. It's going to require a collective effort. So, when you truly consider what it means to be interdependent, the insinuation is clear. I cannot do my job without you. And you cannot
045do your job without me. And we cannot reach our goals without one another. Oh, and by the way, those goals are shared and common between us. We aren't working for different things. Our work is aligned towards ensuring that all students learn at high levels. And because our work is aligned, we hold ourselves mutually accountable towards achieving it. That means every member has a responsibility to do their part. Even one person pulling in the opposite direction damages the momentum of the whole. With all that said, I want to end with some short videos. The first clips are of three artists you may recognize. All giants in the music industry. All unique and extremely talented. On their own and individually, they are the best. And when you think of independent as the lead singer, they are simply
046the best. Now listen to what happens when these amazing singers come together as a group of independent singers. Not a record any of us would probably want to buy. Now let's see what happens when these individuals come together on the same page of music, all rowing in the same direction, knowing that what they do is tied to what every other singer does. The power of the PLC is not in taking away autonomy or individuality. On the contrary, it is taking those unique gifts that each teacher brings to the table, giving them the sheet of music and a room, and then letting them add their talents to the team so that they can sing that song together, united in their purpose. If we do that, we will ensure that all students learn at the highest levels.
047And, as an added bonus, maybe even make sure that no student reads a Meisterman twice in high school. If we will do this well, we will create all-in academies in every school in our district. Thank you. I'll now turn the presentation back over to Superintendent Vasquez for any additional comments and answer any questions you may have. Dr. Armbruster, thank you so much, and to your entire team. This was a great presentation that hopefully begins the conversation of what we are looking to do with professional learning communities. It's not about mandating that PLCs occur once a week. It's not about mandating that teachers have to come to a meeting with their data. It's about joining together for the same goal, which is to ensure that all of our children, regardless of their background, regardless of their
048weaknesses or strengths, that we are all there to ensure they have the best experience and can graduate with choices and pathways. And this is just the beginning. Board members, you know we are an incredibly large district, and one of our greatest challenges is communication and making sure that our communication reaches the classroom level so that teachers understand that they are the owners of the professional learning communities, the collaborative teams, that it has to be meaningful to them, that we do respect them as professionals. And given the time and the opportunity, I know we are going to get there. So with that, we are prepared to answer any questions the board might have. Thank you. We have Member Felder queued up. First of all, to your team, Dr. Ambrose's presentation, thank you so, so very much.
049I was just so engaged. I couldn't wait for us to just have the PLC right here, just start talking, asking questions. I'm going to be transparent while I'm here. As a teacher, I hated PLCs because it was, it was a demand. It was, and I'm so glad that Superintendent Vasquez opened her comments with the thought that we're not about trying to mandate it. Because I don't know how you can do it, whether it can be done, but every school in this district needs to see this presentation. That needs to be the PLC. And then there needs to be some discussion with teachers, and they shouldn't feel a sense of insecurity or inferiority to ask questions and to make commentary or to make suggestions. Because this right here, it's almost like you just want to teach
050all over again because it gives you the opportunity to do what many, I'm sure, people who made a decision to teach, that was in their mind. They saw a tree. They saw the root. And they saw the leaves. And they wanted to do this. And so in not erasing the fact that PLCs sometimes do need to be designed to help teachers, because there are a lot of teachers who love to teach, but they don't have, they have not mastered the mechanics of expert teaching. So they need it, but they want to learn. But you have to know how to ease in to let them know this is how, this is a better way to do it. Because I know you want to achieve this goal. This is a better way. But let me tell you
051something. I really, I enjoyed this work session. I did. Not that I don't enjoy all the other ones, but I do. I told on myself. But anyway, listen. This work session, I guess because I am a teacher, and it's real to me, and I know the frustration of only seven and a half hours out of the day, only 52 minutes for a class, 15 minutes of those 52 minutes you're doing clerical work, calling the roll, telling Johnny to sit down and just writing passes, it's crazy. So you may get a good 30 to 35 minutes of teaching. You might if you're blessed. So I think this, I don't know, Superintendent, how we're going to arrange this, but I think every teacher, every teacher and administrator should see this and have an opportunity to let it
052digest and talk about it. And then wherever they are in their PLCs, how is what we're doing, how does this mirror what we've just seen, what a PLC is supposed to do? Because this would make me want to go back in my classroom and do something different than if I were not successful to do something different, to make learning good and make it exciting. And I love the examples of those different schools. Ferris Bueller, oh God, it's one of my favorite movies. I love those examples of the type of school you went to or the one you're working at or which you would like to have. So in closing, thank you for the work. Thank you for the creativity to bring it to us as a board, to let us see. Because sometimes being up
053here, we forget what people are, what y'all are really going through, what you're really doing. But thank you very much, and I thoroughly enjoyed your presentation. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Member Felder. I'm queued up next, and I'm just going to follow up on what Member Felder said. I think that I thoroughly enjoyed this presentation as well. You definitely kicked it up a notch there, Dr. Armbruster. I was almost expecting, like, I don't know, all of our teaching and learning to, like, stand up and bring out a new song. We are OCPS. I don't even know. But it was really good. It was a great explanation of what the goal is, what the, you know, the why. Thank you. And I think that what we talk about all so often is so important to
054get people to get other adults, get our students to have that buy-in by explaining it and explaining the why behind it. So, thank you for that. I do also just, well, first of all, okay. Is there any possible way that we could get, like, a second presentation where we could maybe demonstration or more explanation as to how it should be done and what it looks like happening in a school the right way just for our understanding so we could understand it all better so those plans are in process this was kind of the introduction we're doing some steps one of the things that we've already brought together is a list of schools that are high flyers and what we'd like to do is rather than a presentation actually invite you to schools within your districts
055to see it actually in action if we can we'll work through the team to get on your calendars so you can actually see where there are collaborative teams doing what they need to be doing in the way that they they choose to do it in very high level so that's part of it we're also schedule our instructional leadership Institute on June 4th is going to be with solution tree where all of our principals and assistant principals will be brought together then in July we're going to be having school teams teachers as well as administrators that will attend the solution tree professional development here in Orlando and we'll have representatives from every school there again to build the vocabulary to build the common understanding to build the capacity of everybody and moving forward we are lucky
056and we didn't want to put charts in we are lucky we have a lot of people who understand and do by-products into it there are a lot of positive schools out there a lot of PLC's as the school and there are a lot of great collaborative teams out there doing the work already they just stay quiet and do their thing and get the results they're shooting for thank you good I look forward to that that'll be that'll be great and then as far as you know the superintendent kind of touched on a little bit we are a big deal of the big district and um and you kind of just mentioned that you know the plan going forward but um do we like what are your do you kind of have like thoughts about how
057we really get it down into those schools in those classrooms where we hear so much that they're not it's not being used properly how we can fix that and make that the way it's supposed to be yes um I I want to say this in in the in the right way yes um I I want to say this in in the in the right way Yes. So the whole reorg structure was in part, I mean, it was a two-year process from a year looking at it, how we could do it, into putting it in. We're only into the second year of the reorg. The whole idea behind the reorg, a big piece of it was to be able to get more, less schools per person down the supports. Also building the cadre models. We're doing
058a lot of things already moving forward where principals are serving on teams. We're sending teachers to other rooms, other areas, other schools. All of those things are already happening. They've all been driving towards trying to create this collaborative environment. So, again, we're only in the second year. So, yes, when I send out an email that says make sure you do this, it's not happening in every classroom right away. But what is happening is it's happening in more classrooms and then more classrooms and then more classrooms. It could be something as simple as a sign on a wall. You could send it out. It may not be there when they come. They may not be able to look at it. But it's on most walls. And as we continue to move forward, it's on even more
059walls. The same thing happens with something like this where we're able to get teachers to be able to see what it looks like and understand it. Once they see it and get it and it isn't mandated that they see the value of it, they choose to do it. And they begin to see it. We develop SBUAs. I know that comes up now and then. Those are common assessments. The power of common assessments is really amazing. If we were to give a test, let's say we all taught the same thing and Karen gave a multiple choice test and Julie gave a true-false and I gave an essay test. There's no way to tell really if our kids are all performing at the same level because on a true-false, you got a 50-50. I was the king
060of true-falses. I could get a 70 on any true-false test and guess at most of the answers. Right? There's no real data. But if we all give a consistent test, then we can at least look at the scores and say, hey, what Julie is doing is wrong. Right? Right. She's working because she's getting 98% of her kids through it. I'm getting 63% of my kids through. I need to talk to Julie. And what happens is they begin to develop device and they take ownership of it. And all of a sudden, they're creating high-level common assessments to meet the goals of the students in their school. And we don't have to do, quote, SBUAs district-wide as a mandate because when the PLC takes off and they actually get it, they own it. And then they see
061the value in it. So it's just honestly it's step by step by step. And we've made huge steps in that. And the model is helping. The reorg that we did is helping to push things down better and better. There's learning because we're transitioning from 27 years of doing it one way to a brand-new way. And so we're working through that. And that takes us step by step. But the goal is I use my hands a lot. The goal is to get us in this direction. And really, the ultimate goal of this is to empower teachers to own the learning of the kids. Right. Right. Right. And that's the goal of the kids within their schools. Within their schools. I like that. I like that. That's what I liked most about this presentation was this whole
062idea of the school being one community together, working together. In the very beginning of my career, I worked at a – after I was in public school, I went to a private school for children with learning differences. And it was a small private school. And all the children there had IEPs. And they were very challenging students behaviorally and academically. But because it was a small school, we worked like that. And I taught third and fourth graders in my room. And we had first and second graders over here. And then the art teacher was like two doors down. And we all met all the time. And we talked about what was working for these kids in my room and what you were doing. It was just constant. But the whole school worked together. Even the different
063grade levels because it was so small. But we talked and we had a common goal to help these kids get to where they could be successful. And it worked. It was the power in that. You're right. When I felt most powerful as a teacher when I was in that situation, when I had other professionals that I was collaborating with. And it wasn't anybody telling me what I had to do or what I couldn't do. But what is working and what's not working. And so I think there's a lot of value in that. So I really appreciate the presentation. I learned a lot. And next we have Member Gallo queued up. Thank you, Madam Chair. And thank you. This was a great presentation. I specifically like the throwback to 80s music because it was by far
064the best decade for music ever. I think you made a comment about boomers and I wanted to honor that. I appreciate that. So I have a question. I love the presentation. I do believe that when, as both members have said, when teachers come together collaboratively, they can learn from one another. I know I've been having lots of discussions with my daughter because she's a first year teacher. And so I'm seeing firsthand some of the struggles that first year teachers have because teachers do want to do good things. They want all of their kids to learn. And there are a lot of challenges. There are a lot of challenges that are outside of their control that are associated with that. That make a difference. Attendance is one of the huge ones. So I guess a couple
065of things is I know that the superintendent has done her kind of roundtables with teachers and whatnot. What information have we gleaned from teachers on the PLCs that are useful to us and then maybe some of the things that are happening that aren't useful to us? Because I've walked into schools. I walked into an elementary school and I've walked into a school that was a little bit different. I've walked into a school that was a little bit different. And I went to my elementary when it was still my school. And the teachers were raving about PLCs. How much they loved it. Back then it was when they actually came together for a whole day. And they just I walked in. I witnessed. And they just loved it. I've walked into schools where teachers will tell
066me they can't stand it. I've had teachers email me going I'm not getting home until 730 at night. Like I can't keep doing this. I can't keep spending all this time away from my family. I'm getting dragged into one meeting after another meeting. Especially our teachers. teachers that teach students with unique abilities because they've got IEPs they have PLCs they have all these meetings they've got attended if they have multi grades in their classroom then they're getting dragged in to all these various meetings so what information have we gleaned and like what can we do because it's this this was this was fantastic and I think this will inspire anybody to want to work together but when you get down to the nitty-gritty how do we implement it and how do we make PLC successful
067in our schools so that teachers don't resent them or not like them or not want to go to them or don't find them useful it really comes back to I believe what what dr. Vasquez says when you mandate things that don't make sense to people like you have it's more important to have an agenda than to actually do the work that you were going to do I take it back to when we used to collect lesson plans every week from teachers and I had a teacher he was a Latin teacher who would write silly stuff in his lesson plans and he wrote it to make sure that I read the lesson plans because he knew I'd come say why'd you write that laughing right it was usually something humorous but the truth of the matter
068is the lesson plans became more important to the lessons at times and that's why that comes up so it's a it's a long way of answering your question we have to make sure that the work we're asking them to do is the work of the PLC which is really simple it's work within the four questions and this is a question that Kelly Padawana shared with me an agenda that she used at Timber Creek ten years ago and basically the agenda is the four questions what are your kids learning how do you know they're learning it and basically the teachers would answer those questions about their classes and that was it all these years later Timber Creek is still very successful and the agenda has changed minor because they're focused on the right four questions that's
069their agenda that's their minutes that's their whole thing it's that simple but we make it difficult because we have a very diverse team of and then it becomes we're having meetings for things that we don't need to be meeting about. They're looking up data that we're providing or should be providing for them. That's training on our part. That's our leadership training. That's what we're working through as well. What our chief of schools, Kathy Shuler, is working with, helping principals, assisting principals, that's the whole purpose of that branch that we're doing now is so that they know how to manage and lead a professional learning community. So I can tell you all the things that I've heard that are wrong, but I can also tell you there are many, many people out there who, when they're
070in the right place, if it's not there, they'll find another school where it is. That's how important it is to them. Karen mentioned and spoke to retention. When you have strong PLC as your school, the retention numbers are very high. When you don't, people come and go and come and go and come and go. There's nothing to buy you in. I used to joke when I started teaching, you would get a number of students, a number of books, and you would be locked in your room, and if everybody came out 180 days later, it was a good year. You did whatever you wanted, however you wanted. That's the way it was. But it was very isolating. You might walk by and wave at people, but it was very. When you have a real professional learning
071community and you're focused on the work of learning, you begin to develop bonds. You begin to develop relationships. You really begin to develop a family. And that's really what needs to happen. You can't mandate this down. It has to really come from them. What we can do, I liken it to being bumpers on a bowling alley. Our job is not to get the ball down to the end. Our job is just to get it back on track if it gets off. And that's what we should be doing as coaches. Andy Reid is phenomenal, but he can't play like Mahomes. But Mahomes needs Andy Reid to be the best Mahomes he can be. That's how we should be interdependent. From both sides. And that's what the goal of this will be. And that's what the goal
072of the RE-ORG was. And that's what a lot of this is built around. Is empowering and then putting the work where it needs to be. So that was a long answer to a very short question. No, that was very helpful. Because I just wanted to make sure, which I knew we had, that we were hearing from teachers. And really getting to the bottom of what they were sensing and what they were feeling. And I always say that if you see a school that has high. Morale and low turnover. It's because you have strong leadership. You see it all the time. And I agree, we can't work in silos. I was getting numbers from district yesterday. And Miami-Dade kept popping up. And I said, well what is Miami-Dade doing better than we're doing? And how do
073we emulate them? Because you don't need to work in a silo. You don't need to recreate everything. If someone is doing something and it's working. We should look to see what they're doing. To see if we could implement it and have it work in a classroom or even in a district. So, thank you very much. Thank you, Member. Thank you, Ms. Gallo. Member Douglas. Thank you so much, Dr. Ambruster. It was a really enjoyable presentation. I really appreciate that. And at the beginning of my career, I remember that we were meeting in a lounge. And things were happening. PLCs were happening in the lounge. Teachers were sharing during lunch what they were doing. Best practices in the classrooms. And we had time to go and visit the classroom and talk to each other. At the
074end of the day, 2.30, 3.30, we were in each other's classroom. Okay, what are you doing that is so successful? Unfortunately, we don't have that any longer. Why? Due to testing. Testing time is taking a lot of our instructional time. So, when teachers think that they have to go somewhere else. For 45 minutes to listen to PLCs that maybe they don't feel like it's useful at the moment. You have to make sure that whatever PLC we're doing, it's useful. It's purposeful. And it is productive. You know, because they feel like they're wasting their time. They need to be in the classroom teaching. They have a pacing calendar they need to follow. So, they're thinking about all the things that need to happen. The time is limiting for a student. It's limited for instructional. Unfortunately. And
075we had so much time before to teach. Okay. Unfortunately, it's been reduced. So, now we have to try to fill in and make sure that our student gets ready for testing. Ready for testing. And we are not thinking about the PLC and visiting somebody else's class. It's all about what is at the end. Okay. So, just want to consider that. The teacher's time. The instructional time. And all these variables need to be considered in order to have a successful PLC. When to do it. How to do it. Let's find the time during the day. You know. That's a challenge. Absolutely, it is. I just wanted to say that. Thank you so much. Thank you. Member Vanos. Thank you so much for this presentation, Dr. Armbruster. I was not in the classroom. So, I appreciate some
076information on what a PLC is. And I'm still trying to fully understand and grasp what it is. And how it's different from a meeting where you're kind of giving an agenda to follow. And so, I guess I do want to. And I understand this is just an introduction. So, there's a lot more that has to be done. I guess my first question is in developing this plan that you presented today. I know. How were teachers involved in the development of this? This actually isn't the development of the plan. This is what we're looking at globally. Moving forward, if you all are happy moving forward, really, is where that all happens. That's what will start happening this summer. That will be how we're going to lay it out. How it's going to happen. That's where we'll
077get the solution tree. All of that. Once we get everybody talking the same language, then that's where we really begin. Again, the thing to remember is that we're not starting at zero. This is happening all across our district. And so, we have pockets of expertise. We have, actually, a lot of expertise. We have, actually, more than I was really surprised at the numbers that came in. So, they're a part of it. It's already happening, I guess is what I'm saying. Where it's not happening, that's where we'll engage and let them go see the same thing we're going to invite you to do. Let them go see how it looks. Let them go see how it feels. Those kinds of things. So, it's not, again, it's not a program. It's a way of doing business. So,
078it's not like we're starting iReady or something like that. So, it's all over the place. And that's what our principal leaders and that have been looking at their schools, seeing where they are, where they need to be, and all of those kinds of things. So, again, that's not a great answer to what you're asking, but it's a mind shift of this is actually the way we're going to do business. And so, teachers have to be engaged and involved with it because it's their show to run. Got it. Thank you. You know how to trigger me with iReady. Yeah. I probably picked the wrong one. I should have gotten somewhere else. Okay. Thank you for that answer. I appreciate that. And I also appreciated when you said that the principals, administrators would be going to, you
079know, some kind of also information session in June to help understand that. Because one thing I do worry about is not having that support, like, up and down in the school. And so, that all, you know, that principals, administrators, and educators all understand how important it is. Because I have heard, you know, from educators right now in schools who don't feel like they're supported. So, I think that's so important. So, I really appreciate that. And I also appreciate that, you know, when you talked about, when you talked about the common assessments, would it be that the PLC develops those common assessments? In a perfect world, what we sometimes do is when we can't get where we're trying to go, we try to do it for people. Right? So, in a perfect world, if I'm at
080a West Orange High School, I've got my group of students. Now, I will tell you that the SBUAs are phenomenal. And if it wasn't mandated on me to have to do it, which it's not, you need to know it's not. We've said that multiple times. But let's say we interpret it as once that's in my mind, I'm not going to use them because I was told I had to. But if they take the time and put that aside and say, hey, let's start with the SBUA and see what it looks like and see how it holds up against what we're teaching and what we've decided to teach, I would use that as a tool. Same thing with CRMs. They're not mandated. But if I was a teacher and I was in a PLC and I
081looked at the CRMs and realized they were developed by teachers and they were developed around kids like we have and those sorts of things, it would be a great starting place. But what happens in the real world is you tell me I have to use them even though I don't have to, but that's what I heard. Now, all of a sudden, they're the enemy. But if we didn't have CRMs and didn't have SBUAs that we had already developed and we were a school, it would be up to us to develop. We would sit down in the meeting and say, here's the plan. We would sit down in the meeting and say, here are the standards. What standards are we going to teach? And we as a group would agree to those standards. And then we
082as a group would create a common assessment for those standards to measure it. And then we would look at that and then we would measure how we're measuring against the state assessments. Are we actually, you know, I can teach you whatever I want to teach you and assess it and it's great and you pass it, but you're not really learning what you need to learn. And that's all part of the process. So in a perfect world, English 1 in this school might look different than it does in the other schools. But it's not. So the test in the other school might look different than English 1 in that school, but both of those schools would be achieving at high levels on the test. So again, it sounds all conflicted, but it's not. So the common
083assessment should be designed around the standards, which should be designed around what the group agreed they're going to teach. And a bad example is, if I'm a teacher in a non-PLC model and I have autonomy, I may have served in the Vietnam War. And this is a true teacher I have. I'm passionate about the Vietnam War. So in U.S. history, I teach the Vietnam War for 18 weeks. And then the rest of U.S. history is before and after. Right? You know that's not a good thing. I know that's not a good thing. But we say autonomy matters. This guy's an expert. He's got a degree. He's got all of this. Let him do what he wants. I don't want, you don't have the right as a teacher to decide my daughter needs 18 weeks of
084the Vietnam War. I have much more faith if the five of you teachers of U.S. government come together and say, one of you is going to say they don't need 18 weeks of the Vietnam War. And you're going to get it down better. And then you're going to decide on the assessment that needs to measure that. And it's going to be given the same way. And yes, the order of instruction matters. Right? Because you shouldn't be doing chapters one through six way before you're doing chapter one or way after you're doing chapter one. That's the power of this. So if a kid moves from here to here, they get all of that. But more than that, now they're doing it. Now you can take the results of those common assessments. And this is the real
085power of the PLC. You can discuss best practices. You can say, wow, Ms. Felder, your kids are rocking fractions. Can I come to your classroom, not because I'm forced to go to your classroom, because I want to figure out what are you doing on fractions. Or can you come to my classroom and teach my kids fractions so I can see how you do it. And I'll go teach your kids decimals because, look, I'm not going to, until we can help each other get better, let's help our kids get better. And that's the power that happens in this. So, again, a lot of words to a very short question. But it's this idea that the group is going to come up with better education for the kids. And, yes, in a perfect world, it's school by
086school by school. But ultimately, they shouldn't be that different. Right, right. Because when you put people together, they're most likely going to come up with something similar. But in theory, you know, the Winter Park group could come up with a test that's different than the Evans-Hill test. The Evans High School group. Absolutely. And they can do that now, except they do it as individuals, which then leads them to 18 weeks of the Vietnam War. And, yes, we can hold them accountable to the standards. But imagine the power of five teachers holding each other accountable versus me running around trying to hold all five of them accountable. When, in reality, now they're working peer to peer. And when their peer says, hey, this is what we've agreed on, that's a lot more power than it really
087is. Why don't you think that's happening right now? Well, again, it is happening in places. But I said it somewhere on page whatever it was. Autonomy is a powerful thing. Like, you and I can talk about U.S. history until we get to a point that we don't agree. And the easiest solution to that is what? You go to your room and I go to my room. It takes a lot of work to be collaborative. Not to be collegial or congenial, but to be collaborative. To be willing to give and take with each other to say, hey, listen, I know that I love Vietnam. I'm willing to cut it down to three weeks. Because you're right. The kids ought to know about, what was it called, World War II? Or they ought to know about the
088American Revolution. But sometimes it's just hard because you don't agree. Maybe you love multiple choice tests. You know why? Because you can scantron them. But everybody else in your group wants to do essay tests, which means you've got to read essays. And so what's the easiest way? And what does our building facilitate, allow us to do? Go in the door, shut the door, and come out in 180 days. So that's what makes it hard. That's why it's been 40 years. Rick DeFore died a few years ago. He passed away. And as he got near the end, I was, I don't want to say fortunate enough because it was very sad for me. But I was fortunate enough to be at his last presentation when he shared that he had cancer and all of that. But
089one of his remarks towards the end was, I've spent 40 years on this, and I still can't get people to understand that working together will always beat working alone. And it's because in education, we are, our designs are you put a teacher in a red schoolhouse, a little red schoolhouse, right? Or you put a teacher in a classroom here and a teacher there. So and then the other big, big hurdle is actually what Board Member Douglas spoke to, which is time. Yeah. Right. Teacher's time has been taken at so many levels because of different things. And then to try to find time to plan together, to sit and collaborate, that has to be a priority. For this to work, we have to look at our schedules and how we're doing our schedules. We have to
090work with teachers to say, hey, how can we make this work? We're doing facilitated planning days now at different levels. High school has been doing it in algebra, geometry, where teachers voluntarily, they're not mandated. You know, they may say that because they've been asked, but they're not mandated. Voluntarily come together. We have 100, 127 math teachers at different settings, and they're spending a day. We've created it to do it as a day instead of having to work. And they're all working together, and they're answering the four questions. And they're working on that. And we're seeing positive growth across our district with that. But it takes a commitment. It means that today they're not in a classroom. Which is tough on students. It's tough all around. Yeah. And I think that the work they're bringing back
091is sometimes worth the investment. And I guess as you continue to develop this, I guess I would just ask, you know, if there's what to think about as we encourage teachers to take part in this and to collaborate, what are we taking off of their plates so that we are actually making time for them to do that? And then just one last question. I just noticed on one of the slides, slide 16, you mentioned AI. And I think that that could be really powerful in alleviating some of the administrative work that some of our teachers do. So I was just curious what if you had, you know, specific thoughts about that or if it was just sort of, oh, we're going to look into it. It seems like it might fit here. No. AI, I
092think, is going, well, we all know it's transformational. It's going to change everything we do. I even, I use it for silly stuff. Just because it fascinates me. I will say this, that I don't believe we can handle AI as an institution if we don't have an organizational structure such as the professional learning community model. Where those who are gung ho, they're already jumping in, they're doing a thousand things, are now there for those who haven't even, they haven't figured out how to spell AI. And I don't mean that disrespectful, but they don't know anything about it. Don't want to say that. I don't want to say that. I don't know anything about it. Don't want to know anything about it. If we don't have an organizational structure like this, it is going to go
093everywhere. And it is going to be crazy. If we are able to get the PLCs to the level that I believe we can get them to, then this is going to help us utilize AI to the best. Because now you're going to have five people, or however, I say five just because that's the numbers I'm looking at, sitting together. Those who know are sharing with those who don't. Those who don't are trying. It just creates a totally different way of, it's about how we do business. It's about how we do business. It's about how we do business. It's about moving from independent to interdependent and all of us working towards the same goal. So yes, it is a piece of it. And not only is it a piece of it in the fact that the
094way we are operating, but it's how do we with this group of experts and non-experts who are sitting together talking, utilize AI to create more time for us to do the job we're really here to do, which is focus on student learning. Well, thank you. I am curious to see how this develops, but I feel like if someone can do it, it's you. So thank you. I don't know about that. That's too much credit. But I will say this to your one comment. I was fortunate to be in a very highly effective PLC many years ago at a high school. And what we found was once they got through the initial, and I believe Karen can attest this, the amount of things that come off of their plate because they are working together is incredible.
095Thank you. Because now when a new teacher comes in, when they would come to the high school that I was at then, they got all of their assessments. They got all of their what we're going to do. What they didn't have to give up was how they were going to do it. The example I use is what we teach shouldn't be decided by the Vietnam vet, right, who loves Vietnam. That should be decided. This is what the standards are. This is what we're going to do. How we teach it is where the freedom comes in. That's where Michael Jackson, Tina Turner, and Bill Clinton are. That's where Michael Jackson, Tina Turner, and Bruce Springsteen come in. But here's what happens is that as you really get into this, you start to realize that you may
096sing and dance and I may use technology. But as we get to a unit and we look at our test scores, your test scores are 95, 96 average. Mine are 32. At that point, I have a moral obligation to myself to say, hey, as much as I love technology, maybe I need to sing and dance. And maybe you need to teach me. And then all of a sudden, we realize there are better ways to do things. It isn't about creating robots. It's about that idea that individual autonomy cannot take the place of what we know works for kids. And in this professional learning community, that becomes the driver for us. So the amount of work that gets reduced for teachers when they have a highly functioning collaborative team is a lot. I mean, that's a
097really technical term. It's a lot. And for new teachers coming in, they have what they need so that they can now focus on, okay, I tried that. It didn't work. I tried this. It didn't work. They're not at home trying to figure out how to create the perfect test. It's there. And then if they give it and it doesn't work, they go back to their group and say, hey, can we make this adjustment? Well, thank you. Looking forward to seeing how this develops. Thank you. I am going to call on Member Ferrant next because she is on hold in a foreign country. Am I correct? She's still on, right? Thank you. Okay. Go ahead, Member Ferrant. Thank you. You can hear me okay? Yes, we can. Okay. So a lot of the questions I had
098have already been asked and answered. But I just want to ask one more time, how will we ensure that every school is heading in the same direction? And I'm assuming it's going to be more with the principal leaders and those kind of smaller cadre groups. I just wanted to ask that. And when will we begin this? Is it in that June and July with the solution tree? And just kind of double checking. Yeah. Honestly, that's without making it any more than it should be. That's my job is to make sure this is heading in the right direction. If you're not here present right now, but there's, I don't know, at least 23 people behind me. There's a bunch of people behind me. They're here because they know the messaging. They need to understand the messaging
099as well. It's their job. It's all of our jobs. It's our teachers. But to make sure that it's moving down through the ranks, that starts here and then goes from there. Yes, again, it's not starting. I want to make sure because I may have confused that. We have this in progress in a lot of places. It's just all over the place. What our goal here is to is to bring everybody up to the level. That some of our high flyers are at. So, yes, it's already it's been ongoing. And I don't want you to think that 30 years ago when it started, it ended then. It's been ongoing and has been successful in a lot of places. The key is how do we bring everybody up to that level that we have in some areas?
100So it's ongoing. But, yes, June and July will be where we really come together as one OCPS and begin that journey forward. And absolutely, it will go down through the exact same way. It will go down through the executive leaders to the principal leaders all the way down through principals, assistant principals. But really this is not a downward thing. Their job is to support and to remove barriers. I oftentimes use the snow plow as the as a metaphor. Our job is not to put things in front of our teachers. Our job is to blow things off the road and get the roads cleared for our teachers. So it's a different mindset and a different model. It's not top down. It's actually the bottom with us there to support. It's not a divide, support and guidance.
101So that's going to be where the real shift may be for some scenarios. Excellent. Thank you so much. That's actually a great analogy with the snow plow. Really just seeing I feel like to me this creates unity. The communication is going to be exponential. So I think we're going to see a huge shift in the right direction as we focus on that one OCPS and focus on unity. I really appreciate your hard work. And the presentation was incredible. Even though I'm over here, just what I can see and hear, it was amazing. So thank you for that. And I look forward to seeing how this continues in the future. Thank you. Thank you, Member Farrant. Member Salamanca. Thank you. Thank you. Mike, this is a great presentation. Thank you for all the work that your
102team is putting behind this. I want to say thank you. Thank you. And really, I'm very grateful that we have Dr. Westbrooks, Dr. Amberster, who have been listening to the ongoing issues we have been having with PLCs instead of just saying or pointing fingers or assuming things are just kind of saw themselves really tackling this on and thinking about our foundation and going back to what has worked and what has been working and maybe where some of those gaps are. are. So I do want to thank you for your leadership on this because it is a tough culture change, especially given how many feelings our teachers and staff might have around. I think PLCs have become a very loaded topic as is. One of the kind of learnings I've had as I do a lot
103of school visits and talk to leadership, talk to teachers has been to your point, Mike, of in this district, there has been successful PLCs in some schools and some departments that have been really effective. And I remember, so I think you brought up Timber Creek as an example. When I was at Timber Creek, I think I was the recipient of some really incredible PLCs because I remember some of my classes would tackle similar topics. So my psychology teacher would be talking about a similar topic than my English teacher from a completely different angle. And I know that they were working together in a way that the reinforcement of the same topic from two different academic contexts really helped me remember some of this. It was just incredibly effective. And so I know from the student
104perspective, it makes a lot of sense. But what I've also noticed is that when there is leadership change at schools, sometimes when that continuity of the successful PLCs fall a bit off track, and we do a great job at letting kind of principals come in and, you know, have autonomy. Obviously, all of them are different leaders. But as we think about the training of leadership and we think about that, I think those are the times when I've seen the most friction. occur, which is perhaps we have successful principal who's been running and overseeing and seen the benefits and invested in successful PLCs. We might get a new principal who maybe is less familiar or has less experience running these. And, you know, teachers' morale gets hurt by the fact that suddenly they've been doing something
105that has been working and they're asking to change it or the structure is different or they're they're not being listened to. A lot of these teachers, they know and they've seen, right? They've been around for a while and they've seen good, bad, and so-so PLCs. And so as we think about Leadership Development, and, as you mentioned, this bottoms-up more approach to PLCs, we need to be listening to our teachers who have seen the various iterations of perhaps the good, the bad and the so-so of PLCs. And I think leadership means to also find ways when we change leadership at schools to have continuity for the things that are working really well um and i i know that implementing that is is what all of you all think about more but hearing from um karen furneaux
106today reminded me of just how important it is right why our parents and community members get so sometimes upset when we change a successful principle that they love so much because i think they worry that what is making the school and these teachers successful maybe might change um and so balancing that autonomy that we give new leadership as well as listening to our teachers what is working i i hope that we can do that a bit more and similar to a member of anos i also i think would love a little bit more detail obviously very being very supportive of the work we're doing now um just more detail on what next steps are right what's the timeline like what what should teachers and principals be expecting as we take on this kind of new
107project uh or initiative to to re think or rebrand some plc's and and that culture around it so uh whenever you you continue to do a bit more of those details and timeline would be great to have it okay that that sounds good i i will share with you the same um the same autonomy rule as a principal i love it i think it's great to see how that the teachers love principals love to as a principal i loved autonomy um you know i probably had t-shirts with it on the back but the truth of the matter is is once i got this once i actually uh and again going back 30 years almost uh once i saw it in action you came to realize that the real power was in in the people in
108the school and to give them that that power in an interdependent way paid off the same thing is really started when Dr. Vasquez and I came back, well when she was here and I came back, it really started then. So a lot of the work through the reorg and all of that has been preparing for this time to where we really do put everybody on the same page. But principals are going to be held to the same kind of expectation and they are. They're working in their cadres, they're meeting regularly, they're doing those kinds of things. They're having conversations. To give you an example so that it doesn't sound like fluff, this past year when our schools did their budgets, historically we did our budgets in isolation and we didn't tell anybody how much money
109we had. This last year they all came together and our middle schools, when they were designing their budgets, made sure that everybody across all middle school had what they needed. If there was a need and there was a reason, sometimes when you get rezoned, sometimes when things happen, you lose funds and those sorts of things. They took care of each other. There was no more in secret. 1 I'm going to have my little treasure and you're not and all of those kinds of things. That whole way of doing business is what we're talking about here. It's where we're 1OCPS. Again, it's not about creating robots. It's about doing what's best for all kids in all schools. And if I sit on, you know, a few dollars here and you don't have any dollars, then we
110need to help each other. We've got to take care of each other and understand that tomorrow I may be at the school that has no money and you may be at the school that does. So I better take care of you while I'm here so that if I end up there, you take care of me. It's that interdependency of understanding we're all part of one organization. Yeah, understood. Thank you, Mike, and thank you, team. Thank you, Member Salamanca. Superintendent, did you want me to call on you next? Okay, we have one more. Member Gallo. Thank you, Madam Chair. Some of the questions that I had, Member Front, and Member Salamanca asked, one being the timeline. And it appears that while there might be a timeline, this is going to be an ongoing process, probably not
111a process that will never be truly complete. I want to say, because I've been reading or listening, because I have to go to Tallahassee, I've been to Tallahassee a lot, leadership books, and I just want to say you're Apple. When you look at corporations, Mike Armbruster is the Apple corporation, because nobody could inspire quite like he can and get people on board. So if anybody. If anybody is up for this task of creating the one OCPS, it's definitely Mr. Armbruster. And we need more Apples in the world, especially in today's world. So two things. I want to kind of expand on what Member Front said about leadership. The same can kind of be said about your team within your schools. So when you have a very collaborative fifth grade team or a very collaborative fourth
112grade team, and a principal comes in and starts rearranging, where to put teachers, it disrupts that collaboration. And in schools, like in any other workplace that exists, there's friction amongst employees. Not all employees are going to get along. Not all employees like each other. Not all employees think the other employees do necessarily a good job. So I guess just keep that in mind as we kind of maneuver and we look towards this process. You know, I know that there is a need to move teachers around at times, but if we have a really good team that's doing things, we're going to be able to do it. And if we have a principal that's doing really good innovative things, and a principal comes in and just moves somebody, because maybe he needs that same innovation in
113fifth grade versus fourth grade, we need to kind of look at the detriment that that would do to that fourth grade team with what they've created. Because you don't lift another team up by trying to, by sinking another team. If that kind of makes sense. If we're using the analogy of all boats will rise with the tide. And the other thing, I want to ask is how involved we've had the union in this process. Because while I know that the superintendent has talked to teachers all the time through her round tables and through all of her community meetings, I just want to make sure that we're involving the union when we have these talks, because it's very important that the union understands the why. Because they're a big communicator to our teachers, or they could
114be communicate things. How do I put this? They communicate with our teachers, and they hear from our teachers. And so when we look at One OCPS, they're a part of our One OCPS, they're a part of our team, and we need them to be our allies so that they understand the why, so that they help us get the messages out, and they help us tell teachers what we're trying to accomplish. And then when they hear things that may be going awry, that they can share those stories so that we can kind of self-correct or pivot to help that school do what is needed. They are part of the One OCPS team. So I just want to make sure that we look at them, and we're going to be able to do that. We're going to
115treat them as an ally, and we include them in these conversations as we move forward. So just as an information, I mentioned briefly in there that I send out a Sunday message every Sunday. Sometimes it's silly. Sometimes it's long. Sometimes it's short. No, it's never short. Sometimes it's 500 words. Sometimes it's a little more. But just for your information, everything that I've shared, Clinton is on that Sunday message list. So nothing that was shared today has not been shared. He has not not. He has not been seen or heard. Now, it doesn't go out to teachers. It goes out to the Division of Learning. But that's on there for that particular reason. So that if he sees something of concern, he can reach back or he can say, hey, what does this mean? Those kinds
116of things. So, yeah. So everything that I've shared through the Division of Learning on the Sunday message, which has been over the last year and a half, every now and then I hit on the whole PLC and where we're at and what the status of it and all of that. He has been privy to and had first-hand access to. So I think that's great. Thank you. I didn't realize that. So thank you for sharing that with me. The other question that I had was about SBUAs. Because I heard you say that they're optional. And I did not realize that SBUAs were optional. So teachers don't have to administer the SBUAs. And if they don't administer the SBUAs, how are we evaluating them? Okay. May I? Yes. So we put out, it's been a couple of
117weeks, maybe a couple of months now, that we are going to be doing a survey of our teachers. I believe the board was also included in that memorandum as a result of the My Teacher Advisory Group. And we pointed out that SBUAs were not required. If they're choosing not to use the SBUAs, then they have to provide a sample of the assessment they're using so that they can ensure it aligns with the standard. And in some of those cases, the data that's being provided to the teachers, and the data that's being provided to the teachers, and the data that's being provided to the teachers, and the data that's being provided to the teachers, they may actually have to provide the data from the assessment that they use. But it's been a couple of, I think
118it's been at least two months where we shared that. We also reiterated that CRMs are not mandated. We shared that teachers will decide how they're going to document the interventions that they're using. And we also said that they may produce that documentation in the event there is an IEP meeting, or there's any type of legal litigation. And so we will be happy to share that again with the board so you can see we went through a list of, and we also addressed the evaluation. Things that came off of their plates as a result of the new evaluation. There were revisions to the evaluation that they no longer have to do. Oh, that's, I missed that memo. So yeah, if you could share with me again, that would be great. That's awesome. So basically what I'm
119hearing is that these PLCs could literally look at the state standards and create their own SBUA, or end of course exam, whatever they want to call it, amongst the PLCs and administer it that way. Yes, and in different settings. Sometimes they'll coordinate on unit tests, whatever we want to call them. Again, depending on what they want to do. As a principal, when I had the PLC, they had to have eight common assessments a year, every four and a half weeks that they would use to derive the data to see if what they were doing was working for kids. Some chose to have more than that. Math teachers had probably 30 of them. So there was freedom and flexibility. What happens is if they are doing that and they're supported and they're doing it right, there
120isn't necessarily a need for SBUAs. However, the SBUAs we have are really, really good. I have teachers that love them. And they are driven by standards. And they are used by a lot of teachers, and they are used by people who have strong PLCs because they're looking at it as why would we reinvent something that was invented by teachers, really? And so it becomes this kind of chicken before the egg thing. But they are used. We have great utilization, and they do see great value in it. Those who don't see value, generally, when you talk to them, it's because they were told they had to use them. Not so much what it was, but the way it was delivered to them. And that goes against the autonomy. I spoke to a lot of teachers that
121do enjoy the SBUAs because it does take something off their plate to create that exam. So are we looking at moving forward with the end-of-course exams, too? Because that's really what they get evaluated on. This was my segue into that. So that's what I was going to say. You mentioned CFEs. That's not CFEs. Right. But the C, if I'm not mistaken, and I believe that Dr. Sasser is in the room amongst the sea of people. I can't see her. So if she is here, wave. Maybe she's listening. The CFEs were created with teacher collaboration. And so teachers actually created those questions for those exams, just like the questions where we gave for the alternative assessment for students with unique abilities. There was teachers that came together to create and give input on those assessments. Thank
122you, Dr. Vasquez. So I would just, it would be great if, since we're over here wishing and looking at the future, I've never been a big fan of the CFEs. I just don't like, what I don't like about, if you were going to give the teacher the CFEs, and the CFEs were something they could discuss in their PLCs to look at and review and ask, and team then decide the standards. I just don't like the cloak and dagger-ness of it. And I don't know a better way to say it. I don't like that they're just so private and the teachers don't even get to see it until they're administered. Like I just, I would like more teachers to have eyes on those CFEs, and be able to discuss them and ensure that they are with
123the standards of their teaching and just kind of make it more of an open process. I guess that's what I'm looking for. And we can get with the team. But remember, that equates to, the faster assessment. So the CFE is the faster assessment. That is how teachers get evaluated with the results of the CFE. And so you have some teachers that argue that they're being held to a higher standard through the faster assessment and not, and wish they had the CFEs. So there is some guardrails and some guidelines that we have to follow because they are used for evaluation purposes. It's not like, end of unit exam or like the SBU ways. Those have a direct impact on the teachers evaluation and their raises. But I will get with the team to see if at
124least the standards are shared with them so they know what is being assessed. But it is supposed to be the same as the faster assessment. Okay, thank you. I appreciate that Dr. Vasquez. And I'm hoping that the legislature will look at that this year and get rid of that 30%. Or 30% of the CFE. 33% because I'm assuming if they were to get rid of that 33% as part of a test score, then we would be able to eliminate the CFEs. Because we have the SBUAs which we could collect the data off of, correct? Like we wouldn't really then, and we have the fast testing so we wouldn't need the CFEs to really collect data. Okay, so faster is only for certain subject areas. Right. And certain grades. Right. Well, the fast test, every, like
125the, it's only ELA, math. Math. So think of teachers. Well, then you've got the EOCs for Algebra 1, you've got the geometry, you've got the biology. High school. Right, the EOCs, but there's some that that's not, there's not a state assessment for every single course. Sure. That's where the CFE comes in. But we use that for evaluation, correct? The same as the EOCs and the faster. But I'm saying if we eliminated, if that part got eliminated from legislature, from state law, then we could create our own way to evaluate the teachers that wouldn't need to be tied to the test score. It would give us the autonomy to determine the evaluations. And maybe the evaluations would be tied to like SBUAs or something different. Certainly if the state decides to waive faster assessments, I'm sure
126we could. But that's the difference between them is that, one, are used as a formative assessment, much like when we were in school, teachers might use an end of unit math test or a spelling bee test at the end of the week to kind of judge where we were on learning what was taught. But the ones that are used for evaluations have a much stronger impact and have stronger guidelines with how they are administered, how they're developed, and the protocols around them because they're used for evaluation. So you think of it just like you would, the faster test or the algebra EOC or biology EOC. There's not an EOC for PE. There's not an EOC for music. There's not an EOC for art. But there's a CFE for all those. Correct. So the CFE equates
127to the state end of year assessment for algebra, biology, and the faster. Thank you. I would just, I get it. I know. We've had many conversations about the CFEs. I would just, because other districts don't do it this way. And I would be curious to know if the districts that are performing well, other large districts that are performing well, do they have CFEs? And I get that this is a negotiation with the union as well. But others that are performing well, because there are some other large districts that are doing better than us, and that will be, we saw it when we had the strategic plan. I would just be curious to know, do they use the same model that we do for evaluations, or do they use something different? And what they use, if
128it's effective, and their gains are higher than ours, maybe it's just something to look at. Yeah, we certainly can have them look at it. But I do know that many of the districts, the teachers have opted to use the scores from the faster exam, or from the EOC as part of their evaluation. So, for example, I am a music teacher at an elementary school. And I, we've agreed, let's assume that this is district-wide, I've agreed that for my evaluation, I am going to take the district, the school math, no, she's, what? Dr. Sasser? Yeah, the students that they teach. Correct, yeah, yeah. Yes. Well, assuming that you're a music teacher, you're teaching, right, all of the third, fourth, and fifth. So, I'm a music teacher. I'm going to take the scores for the faster exam
129from the students that I teach who took that exam. In our district, and I believe, you can correct me, we had teachers that did not want to do that because they said, my standards and what I'm teaching is different. I don't want my evaluation and my raise to be tied to a reading or a math score. So, that's how the CFEs came about. But we'll have our team kind of maybe do a refresher for the board so you, you can have more of your questions answered and see and just remember how this came about. But it is tied to what our teachers wanted. Yeah, no, I understand it. I understand that, but just to remember Douglas's point about teachers being tied up with so much testing. The CFEs is just another test that ties up
130time for our teachers instead of actually teaching our kids. So, I'm always going to be in support of anything that can alleviate and give back time to our teachers. And I understand the process. I understand why we do it. I've never liked that we've done it. And so, I'm just thinking about how to take stuff off teachers' plate and be more mindful, I guess is my point. So, thank you. If that is what was brought to us through the Classroom Teachers Association that they want to revisit that and it's agreed upon that they don't have to do CFEs, that the teachers would take the other scores, we'd be happy to do that as well. Is that why you've been going to Tallahassee so much? You getting that done this year? All right. Is that it?
131Do we have any further business before the board? Oh, super, I'm sorry. I thought, go ahead, Superintendent. Thank you. I want to go back to board members. Board member Banos' comment about how do we know that it's not happening. We know because of our data. We know when we take a look at data, we have children and I'll use, let's say students with disabilities, at X school scoring one way and the same student in another school that is scoring higher. So we look not only at proficiency, we look at learning gains, we look at gaps between subgroups and we can tell that in some schools, zip code may determine outcomes and in other schools, the zip code does not and those children are outperforming similar scores. So we look at that. So, thank you. Thank
132you, Superintendent, for the clarification. I love zip codes do not determine outcomes. Is there any further business? Anyone else have anything for the board? All right. This meeting is adjourned. Our open public comment will be at 4 o'clock.