001At this time, I'll call the oath of office swearing in ceremony to order. We are here to administer and witness the newly elected governing board members take their oath of office to comply with Arizona revised statutes, Article 4, Oath of Office 38-31, officers and employees required to take loyalty oath form classification. As governing board president, I will administer the oath of office to Denise Destish. Stephen Scavara and Mary Jane Ziola. At the conclusion of the swearing in, Jenna Bowen, a testing officer, will give further instructions to governing board members regarding the signing of the oath of office document and provide notary services. Ryan McGinley will take photos during the event to post to the website. At this time, I call forward Denise Destish. Before any officer enters upon the duties of the office, the officer
002shall take and subscribe to the following oath or affirmation. I will read the oath of office in sections and then pause to allow you to repeat out loud the section just read. I, Denise Destish, do solemnly swear or affirm that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and laws of the state of Arizona. I, Denise Destich, do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and laws in the state of Arizona. That I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them against all enemies, foreign and domestic. That I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them against all enemies, foreign and domestic. And that I will faithfully and impartially discharge the duties of the Office
003of Governing Board Member for Dysart Unified School District Number 89. And that I will faithfully and impartially discharge the duties of the Office of the Governing Board Member of Dysart Unified School District Number 89. According to the best of my abilities, so help me God. According to the best of my abilities, so help me God. Thank you so much. Congratulations. Thank you. Now at this time I call forward Stephen Skavarra. Before any officer enters upon the duties of the office, the officer shall take and subscribe to the following oath or affirmation. I will read the oath of office in sections and then pause to allow you to repeat out loud the section just read. I, Stephen Skibara, do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and laws
004of the state of Arizona. I, Stephen Skibara, do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and laws of the state of Arizona. That I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them against all enemies, foreign and domestic. That I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them against all enemies, foreign and domestic. And that I will faithfully and impartially discharge the duties of the Office of Governing Board Member for Dysart Unified School District number 89. And I will faithfully and impartially discharge the duties of the Office of Governing Board Member for Dysart Unified School District number 89. According to the best of my abilities, so help me God. According to the best of my abilities, so help me God.
005Okay. Thank you so much. At this time, I'll call forward Mary Jane Ziola. Before any officer enters upon the duties of the office, the officer shall take and subscribe to the following oath or affirmation. I, Mary Jane Ziola, do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and laws of the state of Arizona. I, Mary Jane Ziola, do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and laws of the state of Arizona. That I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them against all enemies, foreign and domestic. That I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them against all enemies, foreign and domestic. And that I will faithfully and impartially discharge the duties
006of the Office of Governing Board Member for Dysart Unified School District Number 89. And that I will faithfully and impartially discharge the duties of the Office of Governing Board Member for Dysart Unified School District Number 89. According to the best of my ability, so help me God. According to the best of my ability, so help me God. Thank you. Congratulations. Congratulations to all of you. Thank you, everyone. At this time, I'll call the normal meeting to order, and we'll start with the Pledge of Allegiance. Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. First up, we have a public hearing for fiscal year 24-25, expenditure budget revision. Dr. Croteau? Thank you
007madam president Tonight we have a public hearing for fiscal year 2425 for the expenditure budget revision and miss Spidell will be doing that and Are you going from the podium? Are you going from right there? Okay, Mary Dell staying right there and doing it. So This bed a lot floor is yours It's been here for the presentation to load. There we go. So thank you, Dr. Croteau, Madam President, members of the board. Tonight we bring to you the very first revision to our fiscal year 24-25 adopted budget. So this is our budget revision number one. So as required by statute, if I can get myself on. Here we go. All right. So as required by statutes, districts propose and we adopt the budget by July 15th. And we may be required to do a revision
008if we receive notification from ADE that that revision is required. In our instance, we don't have a required related to our budget limit, but rather we just wanted to ensure that the board is kept apprised of any changes to our budget specifically related to our enrollment counts that we have this year. Those require adjustments as well as known carry forwards. And so we'll go over in detail a little bit more about what's. requiring the budget change tonight. And as always, the revisions require and all budget adoptions require a public hearing. So the primary reasons that are impacting the budget are noted below. As you're aware, when we initially propose and adopt the budget, that's in the summertime, we're making enrollment projections on what we think those student counts are going to be as we are
009funded on that average daily membership or ADM. And so at this point, we now have known enrollment counts. And so the numbers I bring to you tonight are going to reflect those most updated counts from the state. Additionally, when we finalize our annual financial report in October, we now have known actual expenditures, and so we make those adjustments for those known carry forward amounts, and that'll be reflected in the updated balances. And then finally, the largest changes related to ADE, any approved grants to the Department of Ed. At the time when we bring it to you in the summer, those are still initial allocations. At this point, we have known allocations from the state, as well as known carry forward. So as mentioned, the largest funding, the way the school districts are funded is through
010our average daily membership or our enrollment counts. So when we initially estimated in our adopted budget, we had an ADM of 21,900 students. We were very close on the mark. I know as mentioned in previous meetings, we did have a decrease for 21,812, so really a reduction of 88 students. That was really a combined. change between a decrease in our K-8 counts, I'm sorry, an increase in our K-8 enrollment compared to the decrease in our high school counts. And so that net overall decreases 88 students. Because the decrease was primarily in our high school counts, we received what's called an A weighting for those regular education categories. High schools are weighted more. So because we had a decrease in that count, we see that reduction in that A weighting. And then finally, we also receive
011what are called B weighting. It's add-on funding that we receive from the state for any special education add-on categories, any English language learner population, et cetera. And so we saw the largest increase in that category of students from 6,380 up to 6,838. So overall, our weighted ADM is going up from 32,683 at our adoption to the 33,015. So once we receive that funding, we embed that into our budget limit. And so our maintenance and operations, that's where you'll see the largest increase. That is what primarily funds the majority of our operations. Our salary and benefits, as well as our general operating expenses, are embedded in that maintenance and operations fund. So due to the increase in the overall weighted ADM, as well... as the increase from was initially projected, we are now embedding that additional
012budget limit of about 2.6 million in the maintenance and operations fund. Again, this reflects funding that we're receiving from the state for those expenses that are already incurring as we've had higher students in those special education categories. Our capital funds, the two primary ones I bring to you tonight is our unrestricted capital. That one is a very slight adjustment from what we had in our adopted budget, just primarily to reflect final interest revenue that was earned. And then really the largest one you see there is our emergency building renewal grant program. As you know, that's the funding that we received through the school facilities division. When we adopted our budget in the summer, we put in a number of, you know, planned at least a million dollars. Hopefully we receive an approved applications. As of
013this point, we've received $7.9 million in approved projects. Those include primarily roofing projects at Dysart High School, Canyon Ridge, and Kingswood. So we're pleased that we have been approved for those projects through SFD. And again, great job to our Maintenance and Facilities Department. They're consistently applying and trying to seek additional revenue sources. And so if that number changes, we'll obviously bring that to you at the next revision as well. Our classroom site funds, slight decrease there, just primarily, again, to account for our final interest earned in those three funds from our annual financial report. And then finally our special projects funds. There are a number of funds, as you know, when we provide the overall detailed budget worksheet on page six, it's made up of quite a significant number of other funds, but I wanted
014to highlight these three primary grants that we received, the summary of those. Our overall federal grants have increased. Again, the primary change on this was related to now known allocations from the state as well as known carryover. So those are the balances you see reflected. Again, our food service fund also, we've seen increased activity in that fund, and so we're just estimating that we expect to see increased budget activity for the remainder of this fiscal year. And as always, the information that we have, detailed reports are available on our website. I know the board has been providing in advance the detailed budget to review, as well as it's been posted on our board docs. So with that, I will be happy to answer any questions. Any questions from the board? Audience as well, right? Yep,
015moving on. Thank you. Moving on to recognitions and celebrations. Dr. Crotto. Thank you, Madam President. Tonight we have a few recognitions and celebrations, and we will start with an amazing choir performance. And Mr. Musi will introduce our guests. Thank you, Madam President, members of the board, Dr. Crotto, and guests. You can see from the festive group that's coming in, we have the Valley Vista Choir, and they're here to perform under the direction of Mr. Preston McDonald. So, Mr. McDonald. Floor is yours. So I was blown away by the beautiful Christmas Carol thinking wow It's just so amazing and then you come out with bridge McDonald oh my goodness Shelly You guys probably don't know but my one of my two daughters was in Valley Vista choir in bridge obviously as you know is such a
016special special song and for you guys to perform that tonight just as Touched my heart and just means the world to me and something I'll never forget and beautifully done as always but Thank you so very much. It was beautiful Next we have the presentation of the National Blue Ribbon Award dr. Croteau. All right now we get into the part of the Place where the board's gonna be up and down a lot. So here we go for the next few things It's with great pride and excitement that we present the National Blue Ribbon award plaque to our governing board this evening that we Received in November in Washington DC. The National Blue Ribbon award is one of the highest honors the school can achieve Recognizing excellence and academic performance and progress and closing achievement gaps
017this Distinction celebrates the hard work, dedication, and collaborations of our students, staff, families, and community. Shadow Ridge High School has demonstrated a relentless commitment to creating a supportive and innovative environment where every student can thrive. This award represents not only the tremendous efforts, but also the collective support of this board, which continuously champions the success of all schools in our district. On behalf of the entire Dysart Unified School District community, it is our honor to present this plaque to you as a symbol of the incredible achievement of Shadow Ridge High School. Thank you for your leadership and ongoing dedication to educational excellence. We celebrate this milestone together. Here tonight to present... The governing board with this award is the administration from Shadow Ridge High School, Principal Miss Cedrica Hester, and Assistant Principals Amanda Logan, Jennifer
018Chernikoff, and Tiffany Byrne. If you could come forward. Governing board will join them for a picture in the front. Next we have item D3, Dr. Crotto. Thank you, Madam President. Tonight we celebrate a truly historic achievement for our district. For the second consecutive year, our district has earned an A rating from the Arizona Department of Education. It's the highest distinction a school can achieve. And for the first time in our district's history, we have no C-labeled or D-labeled schools. This is a moment of celebration and testament to the power of determination, collaboration, and unwavering commitment to our students. This year, 18 of the 24 schools have received individual A ratings with the remaining six earning strong B ratings. Together, these achievements mark a turning point for our district. They show not only the progress we've
019made, but also the excellence we are building and sustaining across all of our schools. It's also a testament of our staff's commitment to the professional learning community network that we're building. Tonight we're here to honor the leaders of our A-rated schools. Principals, your leadership is the foundation of these accomplishments. You have created vibrant, supportive, and high-achieving learning environments that inspire both students and staff to reach their full potential. Your work has helped to define what success looks like in our district, and tonight we celebrate you. I want to express my deepest sincere gratitude to our governing board and cabinet members for their strategic leadership and their vision in this district. To our teachers, staff, and students, your hard work, resilience, and passion have made this milestone possible. This achievement belongs to all of us and
020it reflects the collective strength of this entire community. As we present these awards to our A-rated principals, let us reflect on how far we've come. Achieving no C labels for the first time in our district's history is an accomplishment that we all can take pride in. It serves as a reminder of what we can achieve together when we aim high. work hard, and believe in the potential of every child. Let us celebrate this moment and use it as a springboard to even greater success for our future. And tonight we're going to have everybody come forward. We have great shadow boxes with some A's in here. And we're going to present first the governing board with your A-label shadow box. So if you can come forward, we'd like to do that. Cabinet, please join me. All
021right. Ready? On three. One, two. While everybody is finding their seat, there's a little saying on the bottom of this shadow box that they said, and it says, excellence is not a skill, it's an attitude. And that's what they all display. So thank you and congratulations. Moving to item D4, Dr. Croteau. Thank you. Our last appreciation and celebration tonight is to our three governing board members that we celebrate. This evening we honor and celebrate three governing board members who have selfishly dedicated their past four years to service of our schools and community. Your unwavering commitment, countless hours of work. and passion for improving education have made a profound impact on the lives of our students, our families, and our staff. Through challenges and triumphs, your leadership has guided our district with vision and integrity. On
022behalf of the entire school community, thank you for your service, your dedication, And the lasting legacy you leave behind. You always have a special place in the heart of our district. And I'd like to present each of you with a plaque. I wrote a little something about each of you, so I'll go one at a time. Another plaque. You guys are going to need a cart to get out of here tonight. Yeah, we're going to go in front and take a picture. Ryan's going to do a picture again. But up first is Ms. Chaffin, if you'd join me up front. All right. All right. Ms. Chaffin, your creativity and forward-thinking mindset that have helped us navigate the challenges and embrace new opportunities. Your ability to inspire collaboration and build bridges has strengthened our district in
023countless ways. Thank you for your tireless efforts and unwavering belief in the potential of our students. Thank you for what you've done. A little plaque for you to take with you. Thank you. Our plaques, so you can see, they say thank you for your service as a Dysart Unified School District governing board member and it has their years of service on it. Next is Ms. Pritchard. Your steadfast leadership and thoughtful approach to decision making have been a source of stability and guidance for our schools. Your dedication to ensuring every student has access to quality education has inspired us all. Thank you for your commitment. to excellence and your heart for service. Thank you for what you've done. Thank you. And Ms. Grant. All right. Your passion for fostering a supportive and welcoming community has touched
024the lives of countless families. Your voice has championed the needs of students and staff alike, always advocating for what's best for our district. We are deeply grateful for your compassion, dedication, and vision. Thank you. Thank you for what you've done. Thanks to all of you. Next up, we have audience with individuals. We have two speakers this evening. I'll read the statement. This is the time for the public to comment. Members of the board may not discuss items that aren't specifically identified on the agenda. Pursuant to ARS 38-431.01H, action taken as a result of public comment will be limited directing the staff to study the matter, responding to any criticism, or scheduling the matter for further consideration and decision at a later date. In order to facilitate accomplishing the business of the district in a timely
025manner, a time limit of three minutes will be imposed for each individual or group addressing the board. When you approach the podium, please state your name for the record. First, we have Tracy Sawyer-Sinkville. Thank you, Dr. Carotto. Members of cabinet it's been a while since I've seen you the purpose for me being here tonight And I know Joe did not think that I was going to be here is to publicly Thank you for your years of service. I served two years with you Oh, I'm sorry. My name is Tracy Sawyer sink bill I should know that and a former governing board member of dice art. I served with you for two years And I want to make sure that you know Your time with Dysart is not forgotten. I appreciate everything that you've done with
026me and for the school district. It takes a special person to sit up there and it's no easy task. There's rewards, there's challenges, and I am grateful for serving with you. Please don't stay out of the schools or stay away from Dysart. The principals and teachers, they love to see even former governing board members show up for events anytime. And so I even still go over to the Cactus Cafe. Great grilled cheese, grown-up grilled cheese sandwiches. They are the best. But please, don't be a stranger. And if you still need something to do, you can come join me over at Dysart Education Foundation. So again, thank you for all you've done. Next we have Marissa Garza. Yes, my name is Marissa Garza. Good evening, ladies and gentlemen of the board. My kids go to Surprise
027Elementary. It's a very great school, great teachers, great administration. As a concerned parent, I am saddened. to have to address this matter that concerns the sixth grade class. On December 5th, 2024, a horrific film was shown to the entire sixth grade class of 11 and 12 year olds. The video called the 10 secrets of Egyptian was shown with extreme erotic material that exposed all 86 children to material that was not appropriate for this age group or any age group. The film was rated TV 14 and as expressed in the beginning of the video, not to be shown to children nor as a parent was I given the choice and the chance to decide whether my child should see such a graphic video. My question to you is where was the teacher during the showing of
028this video in all four? and why wasn't it watched before showing? Being a parent, we look to the curriculum to make sure we can provide the best education for our students. But if a teacher is capable of showing videos that are not in the curriculum, what chances do we have to protect our future? Please, so please think about the children that were affected by this video and what is going through their minds and the question that parents have to question, the parents and family have to answer in the upcoming days after viewing this video. The innocence of my child along with 86 other children were taken from them. And I have to apologize to my daughter every day. for what she had to see and the photos were given to the board to viewing because
029they are not to be viewed by anyone younger. I mean, they're very vulgar pictures and it was shown to all these kiddos and I'm just worried for the safety and the well-being of their mindset at 11, 12 years old. Thank you for taking your time and listening. Thank you and just for the the record we do have the copies provided by Miss Garza that will be handing to dr. Croteau and dr. Croteau can you make sure that both the board and Miss Garza are followed up with on this Yes, ma'am. We will do that. Thank you so much. Thank you That's all we have Next we have consent agenda. I'll entertain a motion. No, I'm so sorry. I'm skipping ahead F1 superintendent update. I have been talking a lot Thank You madam president just some
030short updates tonight But some important ones so to eighth grade students at Luke Elementary Medina shoot Shugi and Jocelyn Sanchez have published a book on Amazon titled Anything But Perfect. Medina began writing the first draft in sixth grade and shared it with Jocelyn, who then offered to illustrate it. The two decided to submit the book for publishing, and it was officially released on Amazon. a couple weeks ago during break. So both girls were incredibly humble. They didn't say anything at all until it was published. So in addition, Luke's staff book club is going to be reading the book next month. And so they have two published authors on that campus in eighth grade. So we want to congratulate Luke, and what an awesome accomplishment. So congratulations. Want to again thank our outgoing board members for
031your support and for your commitment to this district and the time you spent I'd like to welcome our new governing board members congratulations on being sworn in tonight and we look forward to working with you and Last but not least happy holidays to everybody We hope your break is amazing and that you get time to unwind and ready to go in January when we're back at it So that's all I have. Thank you Thank you. Next, we have governing board update. I just want to say I have certainly enjoyed being on the board, visiting all the schools multiple times. I have learned so much in the last four years. Thank you, everybody, that has answered all my crazy questions. But I have to say, educators have way too many acronyms. I always say, now what
032does that mean? So I appreciate your patience with me, but seriously, it has been a real honor to serve on the Dysart board. Thank you. I will echo Ms. Grant's sentiments. It has been an honor to represent our community and to serve our community the past four years. I want to thank you to our community and our voters for putting their trust in me. It has definitely been a wild ride, a very great ride. I have approached each vote through much prayer and consideration, and you should know that I have voted my conscience every single time. When I was first running for the board, I would people ask, so why do you want to get into politics? I'm like, I don't. I don't. I just think I could do some good. They're like, okay. The
033decisions and the votes that I have made have not been political. They have been for the better, for the absolute best for our district. And every vote I have cast has been what I think is the best for our district. And we have amazing teachers, amazing students, amazing staff. I cannot tell you what a well-oiled machine this is. Our cabinet is phenomenal. Not only are they top notch at what they do, but they're incredible people who are hardworking and they really do just want to do their job. They just want to do what's best for our students and our staff and our district. So I want to say thank you and thank you to our fellow board members for all of your hard work. And just, it's even in the tough discussions, You know, I
034feel like I still have so much respect for each of you. And so I just thank you for bringing your viewpoints and thank you for also voting your conscience. And thank you to Dr. Croteau for letting my infant son roll around in his office during a gender review. If anybody was here for the reception, you understand why I don't always visit schools because I'm literally running in circles. But thank you for always being flexible. And Ms. Bowen, thank you for all of your hard work. Thank you so much. You know, all you have to do is say, hey, can we do this? Yep. Awesome. Thank you. So she doesn't always get the spotlight, but she's phenomenal. And I want to say. One last thank you to all of our law enforcement officers who show up
035at our schools every single day. They choose to be there. And this is not lost on me. I know I say this quite often, but I cannot thank them enough for being in our schools. As a parent, I would feel safe sending my son to a desert school. So I just want to say thank you to all of our officers for showing up. It's been quite wonderful. So thank you for all of your hard work and Merry Christmas. So I'm going to apologize in advance because it's probably going to be a little lengthy. I did not know how to put everything into 16 years into something short and sweet. So please forgive me if it runs a little long. For the first time, I felt like I was speechless and without words. That never happens.
036As some of you know who attend all these meetings, they usually always have something to say. But, gosh, in 2006, it was strong advocate, persistent voice, determined to make a difference. That was the tagline I ran on almost 20 years ago, and it just seems like only yesterday. As I've been reflecting back on my years of service, I am proud of how far this district has come and feel blessed to have been part of the successes and celebrations along the way. The Dysart of today is a far cry from 20 years ago. During that time, I was a new Dysart mom receiving letters from the state advising that Dysart failed to meet adequate yearly progress. And it gave me a lot of concern. I had two children of my own. So I contacted the superintendent
037who scheduled a meeting with the assistant superintendent, the director of business and finance, and the school principal. And I sat in the conference room of the school and little did I know then it was probably the most important interview of my life as I sat there and looked at them and said, tell me why I should enroll my child in a Dysart school. And the rest is history. My oldest now completed her kindergarten year, and her kindergarten teacher encouraged me to run for the board, and here we are. There's definitely been a multitude of positive, heartwarming memories during my 16 years of service. During my tenure on the board, I had an exciting opportunity to advocate for public education on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C., participate in 16 graduation ceremonies, witnessing over 20,000 graduates cross
038the stage to receive their diplomas, and I even have my name on a handful of our schools. But then there's also the not-so-heartwarming memories of recall threats and during angry comments during call to the public, such as being called the devil in front of my daughter. who was sitting in the audience or being terrorized by months of harassing letters being sent to my home. Thankfully there's a, I just can't make this stuff up, memories that bring humor and balance to it all, like having a pen thrown at me from across the dais, being in the middle of two other board members as one threw a shirt at the other, or nearly being pushed off the surprise stadium stage during a graduation ceremony as another board member raced to receive, to give a diploma to another
039graduate. Those memories plus so many more are responsible for making this experience simply unforgettable. Over the years people have asked why I would choose to continue serving on the board, especially when things got contentious. After all, this is an unpaid position. And my answer was always the same, I do it for the kids. That's what's always kept me grounded and always allowed me to sleep at night when hard decisions needed to be made. When you're in this seat for the benefit of children, everything becomes clear. After serving on the board for four terms, you get a handful of opportunities to serve as board president. One of the practices I instated, which I hope will continue, is the practice of opening our board meetings with a student performance. My rationale was twofold. First, it was a
040great way to draw parents and community members into the boardroom. We all accept the reality when the boardroom is packed. We know that they're not here to listen to us speak We know that they're all here for the kids as it should be But perhaps while waiting for the performance to begin parents scan the agenda see something that interests them and stay for part of the meeting Suddenly we have the potential to engage our community which fosters more involvement which only serves to strengthen our district The second part of my reasoning was to serve as a reminder to this board that this is why we are here Before we start our meetings, especially those that may be contentious, we are captivated by the performances of our students, which not only serves to lighten our hearts,
041but it grounds us and reminds us that they are our focus. They are why we're here, and they are what keep pushing me forward, even through our toughest times in this district. And I hope it's a tradition that will continue for years to come. To say I've been honored to serve this amazing district is an understatement. I've thoroughly enjoyed being a student advocate and I'm so thankful to have been in a position to drive positive change to ensure our students can excel academically. One of the best superintendents in the state and one of our former superintendents, Dr. Gail Plotnick said, all students can learn, no exceptions. And I've always placed tremendous value in that statement. I would ask our incoming board members to be good stewards of upholding those principled words. Be the eyes and
042ears of parents who work two jobs to keep food on the table, which prevents them from being able to be in the schools advocating for their child. You be their advocate and ensure academic growth is occurring for all students. Students may learn differently, but they are all capable of learning. Obstacles may pose challenges, but they never equate to impossibilities. Mother Teresa said, I alone cannot change the world, but I can cast a stone across the waters to create many ripples. We didn't become an A plus district with our lowest score being a B label by being complacent or accepting mediocrity. So again, incoming board members, ask questions, be the ripple, and continue building the road to academic success that has been laid out for you. You are fortunate to come onto the board with an
043amazing administrative team waiting to guide you. But administrative staff come and go. What's constant are the students. So your decisions need to be based on what is best for them. Always being mindful to separate adult issues from student issues and doing what is right by them, not what is popular amongst special interest groups. The children of this community are counting on it and they deserve no less. In closing, I'd like to thank each and every community member who entrusted me with their vote each election season. I'd also like to thank our amazing administration, teachers and staff members, past and present, for putting up with my ceaseless questioning, persistent demands for accountability over the years. We've been through it, and we've come out stronger. I've learned from the best. I'm a better person for knowing you.
044If some of you haven't already been part of my life, let the service notice that you've been drafted as a lifetime member. Sorry, not sorry. Ask Shelly. There's really no point in arguing that. To Don Densmore and my Amigas, what may have started as a trauma bond has grown into friendships that I hold dear to my heart, and your ongoing support over the years has meant more than you could ever know. And last but not least, I'd like to thank my family. who's been on this crazy ride with me since I first campaigned in 2006, from my husband who always provided his full support, patiently dealt with the ups and downs that go along with being married to someone in public office, including braving 120 degree heat, getting signatures every summer, to my parents who
045taught me that it was okay to ask questions as long as you did so respectfully. So you can blame them, shall we? Next time you see my mom. And the value of what it means to stand up for what is right. And finally, to my two daughters, who have been on the sidelines watching my Dysart journey unfold since the age of three and six. Many think a board member's child gets all the perks. And that may be true for some, but not for our girls. Most of the times if an incident occurred, where they were negatively impacted, they endured it silently and asked that I not bring it to the attention of administration because they didn't want more attention to be drawn to themselves. It's not easy being the child of a board member and
046being subjected to the rumors or unkind words of peers, but I've always admired their strength, resiliency, and how they handled themselves with grace. Thank you for your patience and understanding over the years. I couldn't have done it and gone down this path without you, and I love you all with all my heart. In my final words, I'm going to leave you with some lyrics that have personal, sentimental meaning to me in more ways than one and seem most appropriate to share with all of you who have been a part of this life-changing chapter of my life. I've heard it said that people come into our lives for a reason, bringing something we must learn. And we are led to those who help us most to grow if we let them, and we help them in
047return. Who can say if I've been changed for the better? I do believe that I have been changed for the better because I knew you. Because I knew you, I've been changed for good. Thank you all so much. That's all I have. I suggested that Ms. Pritchard summarize everything and keep it short, but I'm so glad that you didn't. I don't want to make my board update about me, but I just want to thank all of our retiring board members, each of you. I want to thank you for all the times, even though we have disagreed at times, all of us, but mostly we have agreed and we've worked together and we've all had the same goal ultimately. I just appreciate each and every one of you. I forgot to add one more thing. Thank
048you all for the beautiful reception. It was beautiful, thoughtful. Thank you for the amazing gifts. I just really appreciate it. The plaque, everything. I appreciate all the planning that went into it. It means a lot. So thank you. Thank you. Okay. Moving. Now we're moving to consent agenda. And I will entertain a motion for the approval of the consent agenda. I move the governing board approve the consent agenda items as presented. Motion carries. Next, we have information discussion item number one, Dr. Croteau. Thank you, Madam President. Tonight we're going to receive some information on our state assessment system. We have our chief accountability officer for the state of Arizona, Mr. Sean Smith, is here to join us. He is also the one who did our study session, so he's here to chat about our assessment
049system a little bit and answer any questions you may have. So, Mr. Smith, thank you for being here. We appreciate you taking your time out. The floor is yours. Thank you so much. Thanks for having me back. It's a pleasure to be with you here tonight. It was exciting to see all the celebrations of the accomplishments and the public service and hear the amazing choir. So thanks for having me. And I think, again, I really want to express my appreciation for your board and your leadership who show so much interest in learning about the tools that are available and trying to use those to advantage for the students that you serve. Jumping back into the discussion that we'd looked at a few weeks ago, I think as a board you often deal with one of
050the challenges that we deal with in the accountability system in general, which is we receive these state assessment results, right? It's an assessment that's designed to measure student performance. And then we also face the challenge of trying to use those results to examine school efficacy, educator quality in school. accomplishment, right? And often those are not the same thing, right? That test does a good job of telling us where the needs of our students are, where the status is at the end of the year, and where we have, where each class is at instructionally, but then trying to take that and interpret that as far as what that means in terms of the organization can be a little more difficult. And I like to talk about it a lot of times in medical terms. You know,
051we're familiar with medical tests. Those tend to make sense because we all know that you don't go and do a medical test unless you have a really good reason. We are interested in the results, and we know that the results are going to be used for something meaningful. And I look at it, you know, when we're in educational leadership or if you're the governing board of a hospital, the individual... medical results of patient tests would not necessarily tell you much about how good the doctors are that you're working with, right? When you kind of get that status, it's important. It tells you a lot about the needs of the patients, where they're at, the health of the community, but it's not necessarily going to tell you are your doctors doing what they're supposed to, are
052they achieving what they need to. For that, you really need to see multiple test results. You need to see the work that's happened with individual patients, not just, you know, in the state test results we'll get like, hey, here's this group of third graders from this year. and then next year we'll get next year's group of third graders and we'll see how they compare. That's a very different result going back to that medical analogy versus seeing one patient and seeing how they did after treatment when they've seen their doctor, when they've gone to school, how do they do subsequently after that? Those metrics that we kind of talked about in the past where we have the growth metrics, a lot of times when you're trying to make those decisions and come to that understanding about
053what have our... and educators been able to do, we see that best oftentimes when we look in the growth and the change year to year, right? Those can be hard discussions too. Sometimes we're not seeing the progress that we wanna see, but that's really where we kind of see those things. I'll pause for questions before I go too much farther on there. I don't know if we wanna have more of a discussion or you want me to keep just talking, but any questions on that concept? Keep going? Okay. And then the other concern I hear a lot, and I get this frequently from people all around the state, come to me and say, hey, look, statewide we have a pass rate of about 35, 40%. Isn't that terrible that 60% of kids can't read or
054do math? And I have to remind them, like, that is not what those test results mean. It's not the design of the test. And I spoke with our head of assessment today to just kind of say, like, as an expert in test design, how do we interpret this? You know, how do we understand the context of the results that we're getting back? And she directed me to the performance level descriptors. And what's interesting here, you can kind of see this is an eighth grade math standard. So every year, well, however, not every year, but every time they work on the test, they'll bring together groups of educators, they'll look at questions, and they'll try and map each of these questions to one of the performance level descriptors of either minimally, partially proficient, or highly proficient
055to see where each kid's at. What's interesting, if you look, you know, I like, I mean, it's interesting to compare the definition of minimally proficient. to highly proficient. So a minimally proficient student should be able to identify linear equations in one variable with one solution, infinitely many solutions or no solutions. Identify the solution to linear equations and inequalities with rational number coefficients. On the other side, what you see is generally not a difference in so much ability, but the quality of what they're able to do. A student who's highly proficient can then go on to explain how some of those work, right? A lot of times you're going to see very similar performance. This was one that I had to put up there because it embarrassed me when I was looking at it. on minimally
056proficient there, it said identify, a minimally proficient eighth grader should be able to identify cube roots of perfect cubes less than or equal to 500, whereas a highly proficient should be able to do that for cube roots less than or equal to 1,000, and I was really worried because I'm a data scientist in real life, and I couldn't identify perfect cubes under 500. I'm like, oh my gosh, like what is, like what's the cube root of 343? I don't know. So. My point here is, in general, what we're measuring on this test are levels of proficiency. We tend to not see, I mean, we know we have students who are sometimes behind grade level, sometimes far behind grade level. That's not necessarily what we're seeing all the time. We're not getting into that level of
057detail on minimally proficient. Many students who are minimally and partially proficient Again, drawing your attention here. A partially proficient student in this particular standard is going to perform very closely to a highly proficient student. And when I asked our head of assessment about it, I said, you know, like, how does this work? Are there questions that are, you know, at the partially proficient level and then some that are at the highly proficient level? She said, typically what you see is that the distinction is how consistent. those students are able to answer the same kind of questions. So often what you're seeing when you're seeing different performance levels is not that one student has absolutely no idea how to do any of this and the other one has all these concepts that they don't, but sometimes
058they're going to be more consistent on a highly proficient student is gonna get almost all the questions right every single time, whereas partially, middle-year or proficient are going to vary in that to some degree, right? And I know your district's done a lot of work. A lot of times the That's another thing I want to highlight here. These tests are not designed to identify the individual or the needs of individual students. You know, all of you are probably familiar with the standards documents. I was at an English learner conference today and they were handing out as prizes bound standards. They were like, okay, we're giving away a bound copy of the standards. I'm like, only in education would that be a thing where there's so many standards. Like, oh, great, I don't have to copy
059that and pay to have it bound. There's a ton of standards. And if you think about... to measure each one of these, we need several questions to see, are they getting it? Is it just random chance? If you took that entire giant book and tried to have our students sit through that, I mean, we'd have a month straight of nothing but testing just hours and hours. So again, the design of this test is, it's a summative test that's very much designed to see what patterns do we see amongst all of our students? And then you've got excellent staff who do a lot of work to fill in those gaps with local assessments, with formatives. The teachers in the classroom are going to have that expertise to try and say, all right, here's the pattern we
060see overall in the needs. And how do we translate that down? How do we understand specific needs then of a given student? I'll leave you with one lesson or one last analogy because I love analogies. But I was thinking, you know, if I was trying to explain like how this kind of works, like this is kind of the world we live in with like if I was going to rate pizzas, right? We live in a world where there's Little Caesars and there's Domino's and there's Papa John's and then there's Chivo Pizzeria downtown that has a wood-fired oven and fresh mozzarella in it. They're all pizza. And, you know, none of them are, like, none of them is like a handful of gravel and grass that, like, okay, when we're down and minimally proficient, I mean...
061Maybe that's dominoes. Is that controversial to say here? But, you know, it's still pizza. Like, you bring dominoes, like, nobody's going to be upset. Like, everybody's going to recognize that that's pizza. And, you know, we all like to go get really delicious pizza. But what this test is able to measure is more in line with that. It's a test that's designed to measure eighth grade. And so it's going to pick up, are the students really... high on the end of eighth grade or are they kind of struggling on there? So again, you want to look at those results carefully. You want to understand them in context, which is very important since the tests are designed to identify student needs and abilities. The better you can kind of understand what information it's giving back, the more
062you can and make wise and informed decisions, right? Again, so just, that's a concern that I hear a lot. You know, hey, we've got to, I'll hear sometimes schools, you know, like I'll go out to these schools and they're like, oh, we've got 65% pass rate and, you know, our community's upset because a third of our kids can't read. I'm like, you're in like the top 15% of schools in the state for achievement with a 65% pass rate. It is a rigorous test. It's designed to capture the needs or the performance of almost all students in that grade level. And it's not designed to hand out kind of a participation trophy or an A to Domino's Pizza just because it is pizza, right? It does meet the minimum threshold for pizza, but the test is
063designed to measure a scope and the range of kind of everything that's out there. I must be hungry. I'm really belaboring this pizza analogy. I apologize. So let me stop there. Any questions that I can help answer? Information that I can give you that will help you as you're using that for your work? I love the analogy. I just want to thank you very much for including that. I know that you and I have had some conversations in our last study session, and I used that example as well. Just, you know, people in our community think that our children cannot read. If we've got 40%, 35% to 40%, that it means that the 60% are not. at grade level, they can't read, they can't do simple math equations, et cetera. But as Ms. Pritchard was
064commenting earlier, it's like why should I enroll my kid in a Dysart school? And if those are the metrics that are advertised out there on the Auditor General, on ADE website, greatschools.com. That's the baseline that incoming parents that maybe especially not had any experience recently with the education system. That's what they're seeing. We also hear consistently how poorly we are performing as a state compared to others. Yet other states are not measured with the same rubric. So we can't say that we're whatever number we are this month in reality. So what, if anything, is ADE working towards, is the state board working towards to maybe bridge that? Great question. So I think we've got several projects kind of in the works the last board meeting Monday We talked about some work that's being done as
065far as standards alignment identifying essential standards. I mean you're hitting on the key the key difficulty here, right? We publish these test results, they go into the newspaper, and I mean, we go back to that medical result. Like most people respond like me when I get a medical test result. You know, I get back numbers, it's like, uh-oh, this thing says 173, I'm gonna die. And I go to the doctor, like, am I gonna die? They're like, no, that's normal. The numbers, it's difficult to make sense of those numbers when you're not. intimately involved in like hey, we're building that test. So we have that legal requirement to publish that out. And I think one thing we can do better is provide that context. Our superintendent and our agency leadership are working diligently to try
066and make adjustments to that test that could be more informative to the public. We're looking for ways that we can do that. We've been working from an accountability standpoint on some projects to try to make those letter grades a little bit clearer so that it provides context and we're saying not just, hey, you got 19.3 points in proficiency on your state testing. Is that good? Is that bad? And so we're working on some stuff to report back that and say, hey, when have you achieved success? Where are there areas for concern? Our hope would be, I think, if we can do the work that your board has been actively engaged and proactive about doing, where we're trying to understand what the results show us and bring in as many people as possible to the conversation,
067I think that's one of the biggest steps that we can make is just clarifying that communication. Thank you. Well, I will say thank you for coming out again. Our study session was... incredibly informative because you know like Ms. Donsmore hinted it's like our mindset is oh my goodness 40% of our students tested proficient. I do think this is important information for us to know as a community, as a board, especially when we're talking about teacher pay. You mentioned that a test score is not evidence of a teacher's effectiveness because there's all these other factors in. And I think around the state, boards around the state, like in theory, okay, yes, you test. Your kids pass. You're fine. Here's a check. But if you've been in a classroom, you know there's so much more to student
068proficiency than one tiny little snapshot. You know, I... I just thank you for doing this and thank you for this information. I appreciate you coming out and working just to explain to us. And I do believe, will we be having pizza at the next board meeting? I mean, will y'all be having pizza at the next board meeting? But thank you so much. I appreciate it. Thank you. I have a quick question for you. Yeah. I'm not quite sure how to articulate it, so maybe you can help me out, if you can get the gist of what I'm trying to get out, but do you feel like the state will ever get to a point to where they pick a test and stick with it? So then we're able to measure growth and student success because...
069Right. So we can measure proficiency, right? Until they change really what, because it's like splitting here between what's proficient, what's growth, like all these different semantics. And so there's a part of me, if I wanted to get to the conspiracy theory side, I was like, is this convenient? Because then when election season comes around, nobody's held accountable to, hey, when I was superintendent of the county or the state or whatever, it's like, you know, there's no data there to show if you went up or down, because up, the... the test changed. Districts then though are unfortunately unable to measure growth for their teachers and students to do what they need to do, whether it be really knowing where the students are at, did they truly grow? Is it an issue with curriculum? Is it an
070issue with teacher instruction? Is it an issue with superintendent? And we never get to know because it's like, ah, they changed the test again. And it's just like they always do that. And it makes me wonder a little bit. Why haven't we just picked one and stuck with it so we can consistently measure? I mean, mostly we're the government, so we enjoy messing with people. But it's a great question. Obviously, you know, there's factors that play into, you know, federal requirements, state requirements, and we'll get kind of legislation that we have to adapt those to. There's... To your point, there are a few metrics that we can kind of look at that will show some consistency over time. And I think what you're hitting on is the exact right question to ask. Like, how do
071we actually see what's happening when there are going to be changes to the test? I mean, we know even when we have the same general test, obviously the form is going to change every year. It's not going to be the exact same questions, right? So all of those challenges come together. There's a couple reference points that are really useful. So we look at, if you're familiar with the NAEP national testing, that gives kind of like they call it the nation's report card. It's the same test administered to a sample of all students around the country. And what's interesting, you can kind of see is Arizona has progressed fairly well. And you can see as you compare. our test, what they'll do is they'll give you a band, you know, like where does your proficiency cutoff
072lie in terms of, you know, kind of the national standard. And so we've seen our proficiency level. over the last several years to where it's like, all right, we're up now where when we say we're proficient, that's very much in line with the national standard for proficient. So you get some kind of looking at that, it's not gonna be perfect because it's not gonna be for every school, but you can kind of get an idea of where does that benchmark head. And then the other one comes back to some of the discussion that we've had before. When we look at those growth numbers, the value there is that we call them their test agnostic. So if the test changes, it can account for that change in test form or even a whole entire different test
073because we're able to see what can be expected for any given student. So those growth numbers can remain very consistent across years, across tests, and that's why they become such a valuable source of information because we can kind of see like, hey, the The yardstick that we're using may have changed and we're reporting back different numbers on different things, but we're still able to see, are we seeing strong evidence of learning here locally or are we seeing gaps where certain groups of our students aren't progressing at all? So the growth numbers, the national benchmarks, those will stay consistent. And then I will speak to, you know, like I can't speak to every administration. I do, I can give a shout out to our current administration. The discussions that we get to have with them are
074based in student, the welfare of students and their best interest. And, you know, Superintendent Horn on day one, when he came in, he's like, hey. look, when I got here, the last time we had Ames, he's like, I really didn't like Ames, but I didn't want to pull the rug out from anybody. And he's adopted the same idea since he's been here. He's like, I'm not in love with ACT and AASA. I have concerns about some of these things, but for the sake of consistency, he wants to keep that as much as possible. I appreciate that. Thank you. Thank You Sean appreciate you appreciate you taking your time and appreciate you working with our district. So thank you very much Thank you very much information item to doctor proto Thank You man present tonight. We
075have two Improvement reports and dr. Asai will introduce our guests our fruit I'm so sorry. Our first school is Rancho Gabriela, which are Mattingly principal. I almost called you president Aren't you first? I'm so sorry. Nope, nope, nope. I will instead introduce Joan Wick, who is not the president, but the principal of Surprise Elementary. Good evening, Madam President, board members, Dr. Croteau. My name is Joan Wick. I'm the proud principal of Surprise Elementary. Our test scores from last year, from the previous year to this current year have gone down, but we do have an action plan in place that we are following and I'll be explaining that as we go through the PowerPoint. Our growth for this current school year was a .78. Our goal is to be 1.0 or higher within that so we
076can be medium or high growth. In Azela, we didn't get all of our points for Azela, but we did move students, our pre-emergent students. We had 22% the previous year. We only had 11% of our kids in pre-emergent. Our students moved to basic. We went from 31% basic to 38% basic. And our intermediate kids also moved for 33% to 39%. So we did have good growth in our Azela numbers. On our CIP goal, our goal is to increase... proficient, highly proficient by 5% and decrease our minimally proficient and ensure a 1% growth. Things that we've done so far, because our focus, we had a big gap for our EL students and we have to close that gap looking at our benchmark data by 2% already. We wanted to do a 5% decrease from our gen
077ed students and our EL students. So we wanted to, we employed in... 15 hour a week IA to work with our EL students along with our EL teacher. We have our IAs, our Instructional Assistants, those acronyms that Ms. Grant was talking about, sorry, to be able to work with our kids in the area of reading for that. And then using our teaching and learning specialists to be able to help focus on our zero to... three-year teachers so we're really taking all hands on deck and working with our students and our new teachers to make sure that we're going to reach that goal this year for safety and referrals decrease it by five percent in referrals we have For the first semester we are down 3% in referrals in the cat different categories that we look
078at so we are happy We're happy that our numbers are decreasing in the behavioral components And then culture and staff, we want to increase our parent engagement. We do have at least one parent engagement night every month. This past week we had our Candy Lane reading night, and we had 159 families join us for that. So we were very excited to see that, and all the kids in the pictures, and Santa was there, and it was a fun time. We know that we have a gap between how the district performs and how we are currently performing. Again, we want to work with all of our students and make sure that our proficiency level and our kids are growing within each of our areas. So we do, as I said earlier, we have it all hands
079on deck. process that we are using everybody to help run some small groups, pull small groups. I'm helping out in eighth grade math class to pull a small group. Mr. Centeno is pulling small groups in fifth and sixth grade ELAs just to make sure, along with our TLS, our dean and everyone, to make sure that our kids are getting what we have. We are happy to say for our attendance last year, end of the year attendance was at 88% and we have been averaging 90%. Our kindergartners keep falling in the 89. All of our other grade levels are at 90 and above for attendance. And we're making those phone calls home, sending the letters home, reminding parents how important education is and how important it is to have them at school every day. Questions? Thank
080you for your presentation. Can you tell me a little bit about your action plan? Yes. So what we're doing is we have our whole third grade. grade level is brand new this year. So we're putting a lot of focus with our TLS and our math coach to be able to go in and do some modeling, working with the district people also. Modeling for the teachers, co-teaching with the teachers, whisper coaching with the teachers, providing PD for them to make sure that they have the knowledge they need to present the curriculum to fidelity with all of our kiddos. And we're doing that with all third through eighth grade teachers that are less than five years of experience. Have you been able to identify what you think is the cause for such the proficiency gap with your
081school? Like, is there anything in particular through the data or anything you've been able to identify as the underlying cause or where the root problem lies? I want to say the root cause would be looking at the attendance. In the previous years, when you look at our attendance, it's always been in the low 80s and the students not being there, so trying to catch them up every year and filling those gaps. And then we're having our reading specialists really identify where our kids are at reading-wise to ensure that they are getting the skills that they need. Also with our ESS kiddos. In the past, they've been pulled out a lot more out of classes. This year we are pushing in. So our fifth grade ESS kids outperformed our non-ESS kids on the current benchmark. So
082that was amazing because that was a new model for us. And all the other ones are right just a few percentage points behind their peers because they were getting pulled out and not getting all of the curriculum. This way they're getting pushed in and then towards the end of the course or class period they're getting pulled back to the table for small group or going back to the ESS classroom to get that extra support to reteach what was just taught. So we have a couple different models in there to get those gaps. So like we didn't get all of our EL points this last year. Our ESS kids did get us our points. We didn't get our attendance points. So we're really trying to focus in on those areas. What kind of district supports are
083we providing to surprise elementary actually a mayor focus spots We're doing a couple different things, Member Pritchard. Thank you for asking. One of our focus is on EL. Surprise has over 100 EL learners. So we're making sure that they had targeted intervention, working with them on their schedule and best practices. In addition to that, our math specialist, Ashley Robbins, has been there working to annotate math lessons. They are following our IM program. However, sometimes when a lesson plan is given to teachers, if I don't really dig into it and preview it, I miss essential parts. So we've talked about how to really identify the objectives, how to measure, do a check for understanding, going out the door, and then really to annotate in between. In addition to that, our English language arts specialist, Danielle, has
084been there working with teachers on really that backwards planning and design to make sure the standards are taught at the level they need to be taught at. One of the problems we identified was, although there was teaching to the standards, as you saw from Sean's... Sean's presentation, the standards are really complex the farther you get. And sometimes I'll just teach. I call it teaching before they send my colon because that's the easier part of the standard. So the help of the specialists are helping teachers to go down and really dig down and teach the whole part of the standard. And the final thing is the ESS support and working with the... with the ESS team to design a more integrated model that's push-in. We know when students are pulled out lots of times, when they're
085not exposed to the grade level standard, we can't expect them to perform on grade level. And then in addition to that, our director of curriculum is walking with Ms. Wick to really assess learning. I was there two days ago. Two days ago, and I was able to walk into classrooms. I'd been in one at the beginning of the year, and it looked, I could tell that the administration had been working with the teacher. It was just, it was tighter classroom management. We know well-managed classrooms are classrooms where learning takes place. Kids, when they were asked to pair share, all participated and were able to explain the concepts the teacher was asking. And that doesn't come with just saying, please change. It comes with work and... co-planning with teachers, making sure that instruction's in check when
086they go through the classrooms. Thank you. Thank you. Questions? Thank you. And now, I would like to present Char Mattingly, proud principal of Rancho Gabriela. And please know, Mr. Mattingly is wearing his tie and Rancho Gabriela colors to support. Thank you. All right. Good evening, Madam President, governing board members, Dr. Croteau, and cabinet. I just got to fix this real fast. So my name is Charlene Mattingly, as you heard, and I am the proud principal slash president of Rancho Gabriela Elementary School, and it's my honor to be with you this evening to share Rancho Gabriela's continuous improvement plan. So I will start by reviewing our data from last year and then share our goals for this year. This slide highlights Rancho Gabriela's AASA proficiency data comparing school and state averages over the last two years.
087So in 23-24, our school average for ELA proficiency was 57% compared to the state average of 40%. And our school average for math proficiency was 56% compared to the state average of 33%. And when compared to state averages, our students truly shine, scoring 17% higher in ELA and 33% higher in math. So while our proficiency scores are strong, we were just shy of a full year's growth, achieving .81 in ELA and .78 in math. Oops, sorry, compared to the state average of 1.0. So we have a plan to increase student growth, which I will get to in a slide down there. Azela, so our English language learners made significant strides on the Azela, which measures English language proficiency. Our percentage of students classified as proficient doubled from 13% to 26%, and our percentage at intermediate
088proficiency level grew from 13% to 27%. We also reduced the percentage of students at the pre-emergent and basic levels reflecting positive trends in EL instruction and support. Our average growth on the Azela assessment was 1.04 and the statewide average was 0.52, pulled from ADEConnect. So based on our data, we set goals for this year. And our first CIP goal focuses on academics. So this year we aim to increase our math and ELA proficiency by 3%, as measured by AASA, and reach 1.0 or higher in growth. We also aim to decrease the percentage of third graders minimally proficient in ELA to 25% or less, as measured by AASA. And we also are working to increase the percentage of our kindergarten through third grade students to perform at or above benchmark to 75%. So we want 75%
089of our students to be at or above benchmark at DIBELS at the end of the year. GOING BACK REAL QUICK, JUST I WANTED TO SAY TO HELP DRIVE THIS SUCCESS, WE'RE FOCUSED ON GROWING OUR PROFESSIONAL LEARNING TEAMS. THIS YEAR WE'RE WORKING TO DIG DEEPER INTO THE FOUR PLC QUESTIONS AND RESPONDING TO DATA STUDENT BY STUDENT, STANDARD BY STANDARD. So moving on, our second goal relates to safety and our third goal is aligned to our culture. Our staff is dedicated to safety and holds monthly drills and safety meetings in addition to maintaining positive and safe classroom environments by consistently implementing our Rattler expectation and Dysart values. And this will help us to decrease our behavior referrals and increase our positive referrals. Additionally, we implemented a support one student initiative, we call it SOS, where we pair
090students who need a little extra care with staff members to ensure the students who need it the most have positive, meaningful relationships with staff members. And in order to maintain our positive culture, we continue to hold monthly community events and include student and staff celebrations. So speaking of celebrations, thanks to the incredible dedication of our staff, students, and families, some who are here tonight, I know some had to leave, Rancho Gabriela has proudly earned an A-label for the third consecutive year. We've also, our EL proficiency has increased 13% from last year, and our ESS proficiency in ELA increased 14%, and our stakeholder satisfaction based on a survey given last month is at 93%, and that was given to staff in our community. So while we have our celebrations, we do have some challenges. Our main
091challenge is in the area of growth. Like I showed you earlier, we didn't get to the 1.0, one year's growth. So we have some actions that we're working toward improving our growth scores, such as targeted win groups based on student data. We are offering Saturday school and clubs before school for an extra layer of support for interventions and also enrichment. Students are setting goals and tracking their progress on standards mastered to help foster ownership of their learning. And we're holding contests and providing rewards to motivate student progress. While we still offer traditional rewards or awards for honor, role, and principal lists, we also want to recognize the students who are showing growth. So with continued dedication from our teachers, students, and families, we're confident that we can meet this challenge and reach our growth target
092this year. And that concludes my presentation. Thank you so much for your time and attention and support of Rancho Gabriela. Thank you so much. I have a quick question. Can you explain what WIN groups is and then what are you doing on Saturdays? Sure. WIN is what I need or you probably are used to us calling it Tier 2. So that's our intervention time. And for Saturday school, it's for third and fourth graders working on standards selected by the grade level teams. And they're working on the students that are already at benchmark. So we're trying to, that question number four from the PLC questions about what are we going to do for the students that already know it. We're spending so much time during the school day on the students that. struggle, we want to
093offer something, an additional layer of something besides what they get during the school day for those students that already know it. Okay, great. Thank you. Sure. And are teachers getting paid extra for this Saturday school? No, because I'm doing it. Are you serious? Yeah. Wow. Okay, are you getting paid extra for Saturday school? No. It's fun for me. You can ask Steve. I look forward to it. It's not... Does Steve bring you coffee at least? He makes it every morning, but he doesn't bring it to me on Saturdays Well, I appreciate what you do I just want to make sure we compensate you properly and I want to make sure you're not getting burnt out Oh, no. No, it's actually very fun. It's fun for me to get to know the kids better and to
094pitch in Thank you. Yeah. Thank you moving to item. I three dr. Cordo Thank You madam president Tonight we have the Mid-year report on the progress of the superintendent goals that you said for me. I believe it was back in July so I'm here to Outline where I am at or where the district is at because my goals are also the principal's goals and the school goals and Also the governing board goals. So quick update on where we're at. I know you have an executive session later, but to publicly Display where we're at with the goals. So I'll go through it. I'm not gonna read all the bullet points, but goal A, obviously we have four goals. Goal A is academics. Every student in all schools will be prepared with the knowledge and skills to
095achieve college and career success. Goal one is design systems that promote academic achievement. And goal two is design systems that promote college and career readiness. So where are we at with that? The progress towards the goal. So far in goal one, we have our content specialists have observed and visited a total of 613 classrooms. That was by November, so it's even greater now, and offered multiple professional development opportunities to our teachers. According to Benchmark 1, district is on track to perform above the state average for proficiency in both ELA and math. In our principal data chats, you know I hold with cabinet. We have held both of them 100% with principals at the start of the school year and after Benchmark 1. The goal two part, all high school senior transcripts have been reviewed to
096identify students eligible for the Art Seal. You know, we've done a very good job on the Art Seal and we will do an amazing job with that again. College and career readiness, our CCRI, as you would know it from the labels, the discussions with the district have been completed with 100% of our high school C&I assistant principals. So we are progressing very well towards goal A. Goal B is our culture and leadership. Again, Dysart, the main goal, Dysart Unified School District will recruit, train, and retain highly qualified staff to cultivate a culture of success. We have two goals in there. By the end of the 24-25 school year, we will increase in Dysart's recruitment efforts to hire staff. And by the end of 24-25 school year, Dysart's customer service plan, which we call Dysart Cares,
097will be further expanded. So how are we doing in that? The district has hosted in five job fairs to date. That is incorrect information because as of yesterday, that will be six job fairs to date, and they have been very successful. The report, to tell you, I think the economy is changing because we had 91 people show up, and we hired close to 40 people yesterday. So they have been very, very successful. We're very excited about that. In advertising, digital display ad provider was changed in order to increase the impressions and clicks while minimizing costs. That's all our tech stuff. So we are out there with a footprint in all our social media and all that. So you can see there. Goal two, all administrators have participated in professional expectations and customer service training. provided
098by the Human Relations Department. So we are both, we're progressing on those goals also. Goal C. Safety, we take safety very seriously and the goal, overall goal of the Dysart Unified School District culture will consistently be reflective of safe and secure environment for all stakeholders. Goal one there that you've said for me, by the end of 24-25 school year, all campuses will have conducted safety checks, audits and inspections. Goal two, throughout school year 24-25 identify and implement additional safety protocols policies or procedures as necessary according to current industry standards and practices There's actually four goals in this safety area. Goal three is throughout the school year, 100% of non-compliant items that require immediate attention as identified through our safety drills and inspections and audits will be addressed. And the fourth goal in our safety area
099is by the end of the school year, training will have been expanded to ensure all groups are performing safety measures successfully with immediate support and feedback. So how are we doing in goal C? or goal C, goal one. Comprehensive safety audits have been completed for three campuses with five additional campuses scheduled between January and May. We did an executive session on those audits, so you get to see what was going on there. All sites undergo random safety checks at least once per month. That's been totaled at 220 safety visits with an average of 19 visits per week. Additionally, a district-wide safety system for drills has been implemented, ensuring all required drills are completed and verified. I will note for this board, you may have seen a report on the Auditor General that just hit the
100news yesterday that our schools are not performing in a safety area. I will tell you, our district is not part of that audit. We did not have a single school, and we exceed. The state as a matter of fact they will be visiting us very shortly to see our model that's occurring next week So we are not part of that audit and our schools were not audited Goal two new guidelines for daily site coverage by administration along with an athletics and event guide brand new this year Safety at athletic events and all the events we have is very important They have been implemented to streamline emergency operation plans at both the district and school levels These measures have reduced redundancy and enhanced efficiency during emergencies. Call three. Our tactical audit out briefs are conducted to
101re-inspect and address any non-compliant items. Areas of concern identified during the audit are documented in the out brief, reviewed collaboratively by administrative team and safety operations, and followed up through meetings or emails to ensure corrective actions are implemented. The documents reviewed regularly until all issues are resolved. I think you did see evidence of that in our audits last week or last time we... We met to discuss that. And the fourth goal there, state safety officers complete state-level training prior to sharing their roles, while school resource officers participate in monthly training with their agency and with the district. Additionally, our security guards undergo monthly training now, and random safety walks are conducted regularly. So our safety departments are doing a very good job in the safety area and progressing towards our goals. Goal D is the
102last goal. It's our resources. Dysart Unified School District will identify and maximize available resources to support student success. Goal one there, using input from district stakeholders, identify, prioritize, and allocate and monitor budget resources to support district goals. And goal two, maintain fiscal compliance and accountability as evidenced by timely budgets, annual financial reports, and a clean, unqualified external auditor opinion. So how are we doing there? Annual department meetings with department administrators and community committees have been scheduled for this whole year. I think you've witnessed some of that. You heard me talk about the various committees that are formed, one of them being our cell phone committee that's got together and got a lot of reports and looking to bring that to the board early in the spring. District and site budgets are readily available on the
103finance department's website. Monthly budget status reports have been distributed to the governing board departments and schools. As of November, departments have submitted their five-year capital projections. These projections are currently under review by cabinet and will be finalized in the coming months with project prioritization determined by the availability of limited capital funding. So that's something this governing board, we had that discussion about. being proactive instead of reactive and setting a plan and that plan is well in place. Again, we will be presenting that probably in a study session coming up in the near future. We're aiming for February about what are we going to do in the next few years to assure that we're in a good spot. And goal two, training and professional development sessions for finance staff and administrators has been scheduled for the
10424-25 school year. Three meetings have been conducted to date and there's some more still planned all required budget and financial reports as well as mandated state and federal reports have been submitted on or before their deadlines and our annual comprehensive financial report for 24 is currently being prepared and is scheduled to the governing board in April and that is a highlight of this Spidell's year She gets very excited about the annual comprehensive financial report. So it is a good thing. But we are progressing very well towards our goals. And I would just like to point that out. And we'll be glad to answer any questions you may have about the goals. Well, I will say thank you for clarifying that. Because last week I was sitting there and I saw this news article. And I
105was like, no way. No stinking way. No, no, no way. And I was going to send it to you, but it was 11 o'clock at night. I was like, no, we're not doing that. And then I was going to send it to you the next morning, but then I forgot. So anyways, but I was just like, there is no way on earth that our district could be included in this because we have made safety such a priority. So thank you for clarifying that. Thank you. I was also going to mention that. But you addressed it already, and I know our commitment to safety is, I mean, it's incredible. I don't even really have words for it, but we take it very, very seriously, and I am sincerely appreciative of your focus on keeping our students
106and our staff safe. I know you shared that article with me and I think usually we are sharing them like right at the same time. I think we have the same app or something, but you shared it with me first and I had not even seen it yet. So I was shocked to see that that is happening in other districts. And again, just appreciative that we're not involved in anything like that with our emergency operation plans. We are on top of it at all of our schools. Thank you. I just want to add too, I know we're going to have an executive session, but just want to thank you for your leadership. Thank you for your steadfast focus on academic achievement, accountability. we've never not had Cs and here we are. And again, that was
107on your watch. I know you'll say with your team and I know there's a huge team involved and everyone has their contribution, but it's sincerely under your leadership and your expectations that you set for your team that made this possible and I appreciate that. How fiscally responsible we are as a district, huge accolades to you, Marydell and your team. And then like Ms. Densmore was saying too, the safety aspect of it. This is just such an amazing district and we have such an incredible group of just dedicated administrators and again, your leadership leading that charge. So thank you very much for all your hard work. Thank you. And I will say it is an amazing team. So a lot of that happens because of the people we have and the people in the organization and
108their commitment to making this a great place. I would like to point out that you've made quite a few of those staffing decisions. So I'm building that team for Dysart. And it's amazing teamwork that you guys have. I also want to make sure that I don't forget to mention the renewed focus on student success. You are meeting and exceeding each goal, in my opinion, just in looking through these. It's check, check, check, check, check. I mean, I see this in every single conversation I have with you, even just in the mundane things. I mean, you tie it back to the goals. In every action and opportunity that we have, if you're looking for a resolution, you're always tying it back to the goals. and you understand what the goals are and how to achieve those.
109Just very impressed with your leadership. Continue to be impressed with your leadership and looking forward to meeting and exceeding the next goals we set. So how about that raise? Just kidding. Aren't we getting a raise? No. Come on, it's our last meeting. Just give us a raise, Dr. Cordo. One percent. One percent. I'm totally joking. And I will say ditto to everything. Where we are now, there's always room to grow. There's always room to grow. And I love the fact that we are cognizant of there is always room to grow. But we're on the right path. So thank you for your diligence and your leadership, always being approachable and being a human, but an excellent leader. You know, everybody knows that. You're not putting up with stuff. We don't play around. We don't play we
110don't play But we also celebrate the wins. So thank you. Thank you. Okay moving to action discussion item j1 board monitoring of adopted policy chapter 3 business operations dr. Krodo Thank You madam president. We continue with our monitoring of our adopted policies. We are on chapter 3 and Miss by Dell will explain the minor changes we have in Chapter 3. Mary Nell? Madam President, members of the board, as mentioned, tonight we are reviewing policy Chapter 3 business operations. We have reviewed all of those attached policies in detail again to ensure that they are according to what we're doing. And so no policy changes recommended beyond those minor grammatical changes noted at Policy 3-101, 101-01, 102, and 103 that have been provided for your review. At this point, I will stand for any questions. Thank you
111so much for your attention to detail any questions or discussion from the board I move to approve revisions to policies as presented motion carries Moving to item J to dr. Cordo. Thank you madam president We are recommending to approve the 2425 revised expenditure budget that miss by Dell Presented earlier in the meeting and we have no further presentations. So we will stand and any questions or for the vote I move to approve 2024-2025 revised expenditure budget. Motion carries. Moving to item J3, Dr. Cordo. Thank you, Madam President. The next items have to do with some HR business, and Mr. Manningly will take the next four of them. So, Mr. Manningly, the floor is yours. Madam President governing board members the first item on Action and discussion and J is the nine contracts that we're asking
112you to approve based on the recommendation from legal counsel pertaining to are certified admin and licensed employees that work in this district. The reference that I will share with you, they're exactly the same with one reference in all nine, and that's where there's a new language put in. It is not a new law, but new language, and that's 15.509, 15.512, and 41.1780, 58.03, and it's basically the language that says that another safety net. to say that if you engage in unsafe practices, you have to tell us about it. If you work for us, you have to be fingerprinted. If you don't work for us and you provide a service, you have to be fingerprinted. And if you want a fingerprint clearance card to work in our district, there's a list of things that the government
113must abide by to check to make sure you have never been convicted or awaiting trial for it. So that's the language in all nine of these. Maybe I... deflected a question from Ms. Grant. So with that, I'll stand down on that one. Any discussion from the board? Just liquidated damages, are those included in all contracts? Yes, ma'am. Governor, board, president, madam, yes. I move to approve administrative certificated and licensed employee contract language and benefits packages for the 2025-2026 school year. Who was that second in line? Ms. Grant. Motion carries. In the essence of time, I'll make the motion for the next one. Is that okay? Sure. Okay. If anyone would like to have discussion, just jump in. I move to approve the eligible certificated and licensed staff for reemployment and authorize the issuance of employment
114contracts for the 25-26 school year. Second. Motion carries. That was four, okay. Madam President, governing board members, this next agenda action discussion item is for our classified employees. It's called an NOE, acronym standing for Notice of Employment, for our exempt, which is our annual salary employees, and then our hourly waged employees. Everything is identical from last year, with the exception of the three laws that I just mentioned. The same vernacular is in the NOE as well. Is that just for item five or is that for item five and six? That was just for item five. Item six would be identical to what you did without me saying anything. Okay. Thank you. I move to approve the notice of employment language and the benefit packages for hourly and exempt classified staff of the 25-26 school year.
115Second. I move the governing board approve the issuance of notices of employment to eligible classified staff at their current positions at the 2025-2026 salary level with benefits commensurate with the position. Second. Motion carries. Next, we have a request for future agenda items. I was like, no, no, please don't. I would like to request one, and that is for the, you mentioned the volunteer process with the fingerprinting. I would like just an information item, and it doesn't need to be the next immediate following board meeting, but it can just be within the next few next ones. It's fine. Volunteer process with fingerprinting, sorry. Yeah. Just an overview. I move to a, do you want to do this? I move to executive session. Yeah, move to establish. I move to establish an executive session pursuant to ARS
11638-431.03A1 for superintendent's mid-year evaluation. We're in executive session. Motion carries. Sorry. At this time, I'll reconvene the regular meeting. And we're on action discussion item M1. And I move to approve the written summary of the superintendent's mid-year performance evaluation reflecting the superintendent's satisfactory progress towards achievement of the approved goals for the 2024-2025 school year. Second. Motion carries. Congratulations and thank you very much. Thank you. Second. All three of you are voting for it. Nothing popped up for me. Will the board members actually get to go home? Waiting for Jill. I did vote. It didn't come through? Oh, yes. Oh, that's OK. Boring. I told you it would happen. Oh, I'm the only one. Pritchard out. Chickens.