001Good morning. I'd like to call this special Darien Board of Education Curriculum Committee meeting to order. Today is Wednesday, December 4th at 8 a.m. Our next meeting is January 8th. I'll start with item one, the election of the committee chair. I'll nominate Sarah Parent. Do I have a second? That's Robin. All those in favor? That is unanimous. Thank you, Sarah, for picking this on. Thank you. Good morning, everybody. Thank you for being here. We have a lovely host of teachers and staff here to talk to our first agenda item of the K to C, K to 3 literacy update. So I will turn it right over to Amy to get started. Thank you so much, Sarah. Good morning, everyone. Yes, thank you so much to our staff here who represents each of our schools. I
002want to just proceed our presentation today by again, extending my gratitude to this team. This team has been working diligently as a part of a steering committee, which is about 60 of our staff members preschool through grade 12, and a smaller core review team. And the teachers here today continue to have information to share about their experience with the pilot. with into reading HMH and also thinking about pedagogy best instructional practices for K-3 literacy. So this is very exciting work. I'm extremely grateful for their dedication and professionalism and the research. They've really approached this work, as we mentioned last month, as research experts in their field, but also researchers. So we will today give an update of what has happened since our last meeting, which was one month ago on November 4th, and provide some
003updates on next steps. You will also hear from this team that there is a desire, and I think Dr. Edwin is talking to four members about this, to continue our action research. Really, we have great momentum. It's just that this is a very weighty decision. We want to be fiscally responsible and absolutely do what is the best thing for all of our learners in Derry and public schools. So I will turn it over to Julie Droehler. She'll introduce who our staff members are, or they'll introduce themselves perhaps as they speak later in the presentation. Save some time. Thanks, Julie. Good morning, everybody. So I'm just going to be very brief. And I do want to, I'm going to go out of order a little bit so that I can introduce all of our teachers. And
004it's so nice to have everybody here in person. Thank you all for taking the time this morning. So we have Bess McNamee, first grade at Royal. Linda Drogada, third grade at Royal. Arlie Carr-Harris, first grade at Tocanique. We have Allison Weissert, third grade at Holmes. Debbie Lynch. our literacy specialist at Holmes, Sharon Shea, second grade at Holmes, and Nicole Pantor, literacy specialist at Himley. They will be, they're really here to answer questions today. And I know that at the last meeting, the board posed some questions. We have taken that back to our team. We talked about them in our core review team meeting, and we really wanted input from all of the teachers. So we're still gathering that data, but they can answer some of those questions. So since our last meeting, as you know,
005we had a professional learning day on election day. We had virtual sessions with InterReading and we had grade level collaboration. We're continuing to implement and learn more about the program. When we last met, we had shared the survey results from the InterReading pilot teachers. Subsequently, we interviewed, we sent a survey to our grade one through three teachers who were not in the pilot, who were using our current compendium. So we have some data from them and we have continued to get into classrooms and observe. On November 21st, we had a meeting with our core review team. Those are our 20 plus K-3 classroom teachers, literacy specialists, administrators, special educators. And we analyzed the survey data. We noticed that the surveys revealed multiple perspectives. There were pros and cons from both sides on many of the
006questions. ongoing discussions and scheduling visitations right now. So we want our teachers who are not part of the pilot to get into classrooms and see it. We want our pilot teachers to get into some of the classrooms where our teachers are using other resources such as Word Love for Vocabulary and the new writing units so that they both learn about what's happening. We discuss the strengths and challenges and we discuss the Board of Ed. questions. Again, we really wanted input from everybody. So those members of the core review team are taking them back to their. teams, those pilot teams, so that every teacher can have a voice. We did create a fact sheet. We know that one of the things that the board asked for was how are we spending time on each component with
007inter-reading and with our current program. So we do have that to share. And I talked about the grade level meetings. We are planning additional collaboration time for our pilot teachers. And we have worked with Into Reading because we said we wanted to extend the pilot. They are providing in-person professional learning on January 17th. And we wanted to expose all of our teachers, not just the pilot teachers, to the program so that they learn a little bit more about it. So there are links here to the surveys from the pilot, the non-pilot. I'm not going to get into that. Cass, could you just click the last thing, the literacy block comparison? So this is a little bit hard to read, but you have this in your packet. And what we did was we broke down each
008of the components as best we could. This is an average because each school schedule is a little bit different. So each school uses their time a little bit differently. But this just shows you with interreading how much time teachers are spending on those foundational skills, vocabulary. reading and writing and what it looks like. The small group rotations, there are differences among the pilot teachers about how they're fitting it in. Some of them are fitting it in during their wind time, which was our DI block, our what I need. So we don't have all the children there, but that's one area. And some of them are finding different ways to do that. So they can perhaps speak to that. And then this is the breakdown with our current compendium. And what I'm not sure is clear
009here is the small group is happening within the reading workshop and the writing workshop block. So they, as well as they also have the same wind time block. So this is just. a breakdown by grade level. Do you mind scrolling down? Just so, and again, you have this link, so it'll be easier to see in the packet, but this is just by grade level. The reason that third grade looks different is because the first and second grade into reading have a structured literacy program. It's a separate book and it's really pulled out. In third grade, it's part of their whole teacher's manual. That is something that, you know, I assume that the teachers can speak more to. And I've introduced the teachers. So the other thing I just wanted to show you also, we wanted
010to share the notes from our core review team meeting. So they are linked there and just as a reference. And then. If you just keep going, this is our timeline. I'm not going to go through this because it's the same that you saw when you were discussing the initiatives at the board meeting last Tuesday, seemed like last Tuesday. So that's it. And we can open it up for discussion. And our teachers are, oh, one thing I did want to say, I'm sorry. What's happening in the DERG? I did get some more information. Some of our colleagues are looking at supplementing their current program. Others are continuing with Hegarty Foundation's UFLY or units of study. And that would be Westport, New Canaan. Ridgefield is supplementing with bookworms. New Canaan is looking at bookworms. Greenwich did look
011at bookworms and they... decided that they are keeping what they're doing now currently, so is Westport. Some other districts are using core programs. Wilton, Weston, and Easton-Reading have used various core programs. They're using ARC, American Reading Company, Core Knowledge, and Imagine Learning. So those are all being slowly... piloted slash implemented in those districts. Thank you. I think I just want to start with the timeline, noting that you said you would push this pilot out from what you originally discussed. I don't disagree with that. I actually think it's a wise choice, but if you can just talk to where that puts us in terms of the future planning. So that's on slide eight. Amy, I don't know if you want to speak to that or you want Nisha to speak to that. So what we're really
012looking to do, thanks Julie, is extend the pilot into April. Really, you know, we have... some significant time off of school in December for the holiday break, we'd like to come back and see a few additional units implemented. When we visited Brantford Public Schools, the teachers there talked about almost an aha moment after January. Our original timeline was, of course, largely dictated by the timeline for the budget. And the board has said many times that we're not going to make a decision based on the urgency and timeline of the budget. Well, we realize that is a reality in our work. We want to keep at the core of our decision making what's best from a teaching and learning perspective. And so we anticipate that we would hold a placeholder in the budget for a lesser
013amount than was first discussed because we would really focus first on K-3 and a slower implementation with any resources that we might implement. So it would put us around the April timeframe before April break. So what we would hope to do is during the May, the end of May board meeting, have a recommendation for the board and have an opportunity there for the board to approve the resources or resource selected. So it's my understanding that this would be the agenda for our full board meeting on Tuesday. So this is a conversation that we should just have as a full board so everybody understands that there's a placeholder. And just moving forward. Katie. In the materials, Amy, there was a mention of... of either implementing the program for the next school year or continuing the pilot
014for the next school year as well? How can you just talk about how that fits into the timeline and what you're expecting in terms of next steps for the school year that starts in the fall? Sure. So one of the things that we've asked the State Department about is exactly just that. Is there any flexibility for taking more time to make a very thoughtful and planful decision? At this point, the legislation has not changed, so they are expecting districts to have any district who needed to have a complement or supplement to their waiver and the resources that they were using to have an answer for the 25-26 school year. I wanted to also mention that we continue to invite members of the Connecticut State Department of Education to our core review team meetings. We actually
015also extended an invite to come to any of our board meetings to discuss this topic, and we hope that they will take us up on that. What really we think will happen is that we'll get to the April date and we will have a recommendation. That's our full intention is to go forward with a plan next year for implementing with very supportive, extensive professional learning. And what we would like to do is with whatever resource we've selected, we'll obviously need a different plan for professional learning for kindergarten because this year their focus has been on play-based learning. So we'll have to be thoughtful and intentional about that. And then with grades four and five, excuse me, they would be a year out. So that would be a year that would look probably a little bit
016more like a pilot, similar to what we've done this year with one through three, so that we could again support a slower implementation in those upper grades. They'll just be like the year behind. Right. And I know you know this. I just wanted to say it publicly. That will also come with an additional budgetary implication then as well, right? For the fall. Yes, because right now we're talking about K-3 and then it would be 4 and 5 in the following year. Right. Thank you for pointing that out. So in the original budget materials that we were discussing as a board administration, we were really looking at the K-5 implementation. One of the things I'm proud of is that in Darien Public Schools, although this is K-3 legislation, we're really approaching this as a preschool through
017grade 12 continuum for literacy instruction. And so that's why there's a lesser amount for the year ahead, K-3, with the following year, floor five. Great, thank you. And I would want to point out that beyond that, we would certainly be looking at curriculum in grades six through 12 and any adjustments we might need to meet there as the kids move up secondary level. Other questions about the schedule or budget? Okay. I don't, it's the easiest if we just ask you questions. Do you guys want to, do you have anything prepared to share with us? I'll do it before we get into questions. Just in terms of the DERG comparison and what other districts around us are doing, when you're saying many of them are choosing to supplement with, I don't know what resources, but to
018supplement their existing program. It sounds like it's really Westport, New Canaan, Ridgefield, Greenwich. And was that considered for Gary Dunn as an option? Because the options that you're showing are really just option A, which is into reading the multiplication. and no other options are included. So I just wanted to understand that a little better. So just thank you for asking for that clarification. So we had discussed all along in each of the presentations that there were those three options, options A, B, and C. So option A, and I hope I don't get these in the wrong order, but one of those three options was basically that we would do nothing. We would continue with our exact same programming, the exact same curricular resources that we're using. an instructional approach. The other option, and this is
019approvable from the state, is that we would use the existing resources we have with complements and supplements from the state approved list of resources. And then that third option is that we would use a full, a fully implemented resource that has every component. What the core review team decided was that we know we need to do something different, regardless of what the state's feedback was and the state offered feedback to us that we read in and had noted on our own. For example, the writing piece, the vocabulary, and the grammar. So the core review team knew that they wanted to approach an instructional shift and a curriculum resource shift to better address those areas. So what they did was they looked again at the approved list of resources and into reading was the one full
020resource that the group wanted to look at. There is an option that we could complement or supplement just as those other districts are doing, and that may be a recommendation from from the query. Just to follow up on that, just because basically some of the survey data and the link. Did show in some areas. strong disagreement about whether inter-reading resources really met the need. And I think it was maybe more in the independent reading and differentiation kind of work. And so that's really kind of the core of why I'm asking this question, because ultimately we are going to adopt one resource and do that in full. I would want to understand and make sure that it meets the needs of all of our students. and in which we do currently with our differentiation and small
021group instruction. So that's really something I would love to hear more about. So and naturally, and that's something that we discussed with member Forth and I would encourage that discussion here today. One of the things I would think, Robin, is there will be, this is a very polarizing discussion and has been across the country, right? There are going to be loud voices that sit on all sides of this issue. And what we also have to remember is at the core of our discussion, we've been saying all along that it is not a program that teaches children. It is the teacher that teaches children. So when we say that there is, you know, this one option for interreading, that's a full resource with all components. I would still put forward that we would not be moving
022forward with that resource on a page by page instructional delivery model. That's not the right thing. That's not responsive to our kids. So what we would be doing is taking a look at that resource, the standards, and being responsive to the kids in front of us. And I believe that the teachers in this room and the teachers out in our classrooms right now, regardless of the resource, know how to plan for a full group, small group, and individual instruction. And that is not, that's resource agnostic, in my opinion. Okay, thank you. Greg, I saw your hand. Did you? Yeah, I was going to ask a few questions. One was just as we're thinking about those options, it'd be interesting to just understand what the budget implications are, like the add-on versus the full implementation. What's
023the cost benefit for one versus the other? Then to follow up on what Robin was asking about in terms of some of the different areas, it'd be interesting within the... the survey that was provided and the responses, it looks like there are like certain areas within that where there's pluses and minuses. It'd be interesting to see how that overlays with what are the actual priorities for our district in terms of different areas within this curriculum that we actually want to focus on and we want to get the benefit of to see if those actually are, we actually are getting the benefit based on the survey results. I'll start with just a response to the second part, Greg, of what you just stated. At the beginning of this work, the steering committee and core review team
024worked together to talk about what are our values and priorities, what's our vision for really high quality teaching and learning in the area of literacy, preschool through grade 12. And so when we talked about those values and priorities, that was how we guided the development of Urban Brick to assess then what's on the state approved program and to really look at our current resource in district. So that's something that we continue to revisit. And we'll continue to revisit as we move forward and make this decision. We can certainly provide more details as we move forward in the budget process about the different resources. And if we went with a compendium or if we went with intervening and again, the rollout of K-3 and 4-5 of the year to follow. That's something that we would plan
025to do. Thank you. Just to piggyback on that, I think that to Greg's point, it is really helpful sometimes. I know you guys have been working really hard and really long and all the information is in there, but sometimes it is nice for the board when we're reviewing and thinking about budget to kind of have a snapshot on one page to Greg's point, right? Like these are the numbers side by side. I think that that can just help with clarity because. You guys have done a lot of work. I did want to come back just quickly to the DERC comparisons and note that I have been speaking to some colleagues in New Canaan as well. And I do think it's important to note that New Canaan is actually quite unique in that they have a
026literacy academy as well. And they actually have an OG fellow. And I think that they have. an associate level OG teacher who's training in-house. And Shirley, you probably know better than I do, but I think they have something like 80% of their special education teachers who have OG training. And that's really a component that they're rolling out in district, which is significant. So it would be remiss not to mention that in terms of what our comparative districts are doing. And I know everyone from the end of the table knows what OG is, but certainly when we're coming back to foundations and to phonics, you know, I think that's an important piece to notice. So it's Orton Gillingham. Yes. And we can always like talk more off online on that, but I think it's good for
027the board members, if anyone's not familiar, to have a little background in that as we're talking about early literacy. And then. Sarah, I have a lot more questions, but I'll leave it to structure how you want to get into it. For me, the two biggest things that came out of the surveys, all the data, I really enjoyed reading the notes from the 1121 meeting. I thought that you guys really clearly spent a good day looking at this. It seemed like there were two buckets that people, teachers may have been concerned about. The first being the differentiation piece and how do you reach every student in your classroom? And the second being the professional learning, professional development. How do you as the leaders in the classroom, how do you have enough time and how do you
028structure, you know, your own time and your own learning to be able to best deliver this education or this delivery? So I don't know how you want to speak to the differentiation piece. And is it a scheduling issue? Is it a resource issue? That to me, I would love to understand more because the workshop model does allow for a lot of small group instruction. And especially when, you know, Julie said that some of the small groups are happening during that wind time. Well, the wind time is when some of the students that need the extra support the most get pulled out. So how did they get the support from you all in the classroom? So I don't know who wants to speak to that difference. And just to, there's one other thing in addition to
029those two, it's the who is doing the work that that is a difference of how much time are the students having to practice. I just had to follow up on that. So Sarah, thank you for making that point. I did the same thing. I do want to commend you, Amy. These surveys were incredible. And what I really thought was most valuable were the written responses. So I would love to thank the teachers for the time that you put into what were really... fully developed, very specific thoughts, that's massive for us to be able to hear what is actually happening in the classrooms is the most important thing. The honesty and the candid nature with the comments were incredible. So Sarah, to your point, I was looking for the same thing. I was looking for themes
030because as Amy said, you know, we are going to have a difference of opinion, right? We're going to have different styles. And I would really almost take what Sarah said and combine it into one theme, which was really time. What I was hearing was that we need more time for literacy in the district. And I would say that. what I got from both of these surveys were for teachers who are doing the pilot and teachers who are not is that they need more time. So I didn't even see it to be specific to a certain program, but that maybe we just need to dedicate a larger literacy block in our day to meet the needs for all the students and especially recognizing in K through three just how foundational literacy is to every other subject
031going forward. So I would love to hear more planning about that, you know, and again, Shirley would be an expert in this. A lot of schools that have specialized program and who have higher or complete populations of students that have language-based learning disabilities have multiple language arts blocks in the day. So I would love for us to not just look at the program, but to Amy's point, like, what are the capabilities we're offering our teachers to do the work they need to do? I could just make a quick response to that. One of the things that I say every time we're talking about curriculum. is we have to think about curriculum, instruction, assessment, and professional learning all together all the time. We can't make a curriculum shift or shift in a resource without thinking about
032necessary instruction shifts. How are we going to assess learning and professional learning for the adult learners to support that? Shirley may have comments later about we're in Gillingham because we do recognize the need to bring that kind of resource and training for not only our special educators, but our regular education staff as well. So that's something that Shirley and I have been talking about. And in addition to thinking about a resource curriculum and instruction assessment is naturally the instructional minutes that we assign. So if you recall, we had a recent conversation around even the specialists at the elementary level. And one of the things I said was, we're going to need to look at the instructional minutes in general. It was exactly to the point that you're making right now, Katie, that we really need
033to look at the instructional minutes and what we're dedicating throughout the students' whole school day. and how we're integrating those parts of the script. And now's probably a good time to just comment on that, Katie. We've looked into the New Canaan model also, and I think we may have mentioned it in one of our... board meetings that we're looking professional learning when we go through the budget for og we've looked at phil's model there in the literacy academy of how all teachers will have og and robin to your question it really is a multi-sensory approach og is the basis of that so that would be to to supplement whatever reading program we have but really to build capacity in all our teachers kitty i don't know if it's 80 but it is a it is
034a remarkable percentage of teachers over the years since they started that academy and it's been very successful so we are looking at that model. But just to add, since our teachers are here, just to add a question, maybe in the conversation of, to your point also, Katie, that the majority of students who are receiving specially designed instruction elementary usually is for literacy. That's it. There's also students receiving it for other reasons, social, emotional, or mathematics, but the primary purpose of the primary instruction happens in literacy in the early grades. That said, WIN is a block that we've used to use and we continue to use for specially designed instruction. And it might be helpful to say how teachers are using that time when special education teachers are providing instruction in literacy on the goals and
035objectives in those students' IEPs that also deal with phonology, that also deal with reading instruction, oral reading, comprehension, fluency, et cetera. So if there's a time just without revealing any students... that when you do have that time that you're using in piloting for the students who may remain in your class because they're able to access the instruction that's going on, and there may be students who are at that time receiving resource room instruction to supplement what's either happening within the core of reading instruction in your classrooms or working on scaffolding skills in literacy that they're working on in their resource room. So if there's any way to talk about how you're balancing that, how it works, or maybe it's not a problem and different times happen during the day. Any, any, that'd be great. Thank
036you. Not better. Not yet. Is it working? Yes. Okay. So I think one of the things that is important to acknowledge is that we're all still getting familiar and comfortable with the program. And so the more you do it, the more you start to understand the structure of the program. And so one of the things that our team has started to understand is that if there's a lesson that has an interactive read aloud that might take 20 to 30 minutes, you would lose that differentiated instruction time, right? Because you just wouldn't have simply enough time in your block of literacy for reading instruction. and differentiated instruction. So what we started doing is moving that read aloud to a day before during our read aloud time. That way we can do the read aloud ahead and
037then we find a teaching point for the following day. And then that gives us the time to do our differentiated instruction during our reading block. So that's a specific example that I can think about that helps. Another thing to consider then is that we prioritize our students who we know are leaving during that wind time during the literacy block, not every day, but many days. That way we see them during our literacy block because we know they're not there during wind time. Does that help? I mean, do you feel, I'm sorry. And that's just, I'm speaking for Toganique, not everyone. No, that's a great example. And I know that other teachers have different strategies for addressing all students' needs, whether it's during your different instruction in the class or coordinating it with a special education
038teacher who's working on something either similar or, again, a precursor or previewing some material prior to instruction. So I'm trying to understand if I'm hearing right. So is this program or any other program, is that going to potentially obviate the need for some of the additional instruction and special education needs because it's addressing those preemptively? I'm sorry, can you ask it again? Is the implementation of this program, the right to read, does that potentially have the benefit of obviating some of the need for the additional? Oversight with special education. I do think that it would you think just to add, I think, clarifying in terms of the not resources, but the idea of. The program into reading what we're doing is looking at all the different components of reading instruction with the notion that it
039is addressing all the areas of literacy that children need to be successful readers. So I think what Greg is saying is in terms of phonology, in terms of orthography, in terms of fluency and the other areas, the notion is that a program like this in a very robust way may be a way to intervene in some of those areas of reading instruction for all students. I think the question is, we can't anticipate will that reduce the referral and need for specially designed instruction, but the notion that we're covering all the areas of reading in this program that may suggest that students will receive a robust program in all the areas and components of reading instruction. I think it does, but I think all of our, I think our programs do. Yes. And I think we
040do that as educators. So yes. It does obviate the need or it does not? I think. I think once, yeah, that's. You know, alleviate. Maybe if you look at it as in a robust way of looking at all the areas of reading instruction and the differentiation component to it and looking at what teachers do in their own individualized differentiated way, that it may, we may see that students are receiving instruction within the general education classroom, progress monitoring, looking at the different areas. that may, I don't know, alleviate because there are children with learning differences that will need specially designed instruction, but we might be able to really look at instruction in the general education classroom that might reduce the number of referrals based on student performance, although alleviate probably is not something that can happen
041because children have learning differences and require specially designed instruction. I think it's very hard for me to make that decision or support that judgment call. What I will say, The intent of this K-3 legislation is to ensure that every child is reading on grade level by the time that they leave grade three. And as Shirley just indicated, there will always be children that have various learning differences, and we will meet those learning differences through core programming and any other supplemental resources or supplemental instruction that individual children require. But the idea here is to ensure that our students prior to even third grade are very strong decoders by the end of second grade. That's the intention. We also know to your question about the identification rate, we're looking at students beyond third grade and getting feedback
042from what happens with our middle school and our high school staff and how students are performing there and where we might have some gaps within programming or resources, for example, in the vocabulary or the grammar area. We can't really make a correlation between the identification rate of special education, but this is about storing up very high quality core programming. So the intention is there. That's the intention at the state level, that children will be reading strong readers. And as Sarah pointed out before, and I think Katie as well, when children have the ability to read well by the end of third grade, that's a great predictor of their future success, not only in middle school and high school, but beyond. Yeah, I guess like looking at the presentation from our point of view last week,
043which I wasn't able to attend yet, I agree, like Shirley pointed out that most of the IEPs are related to literacy. So if it's not addressing a lot of that, I'm kind of like, what's the point? And if the goal of, as you just stated, that the goal of the state is that all rate up at every student. So I assume that includes all the special education students are going to be at that level. And it sounds like what we're saying is that the goal is not going to be met. Well, that's not what we're saying. The idea here is that the science of reading and thinking about how we develop in core programming foundational literacy skills is absolutely a part of our research right now. It's a significant part of how we're evaluating our
044current DPS resources and how we're evaluating, for example, the pilot into reading. And also, as Shirley mentioned, our interest in and the literacy academy using OG as a resource and training more staff is exactly getting at what you're talking about. It also might be helpful, Amy, just to look at the notion of what the state wanted. We were targeted in a couple of areas that we really need to look at and wanted this program looked at. And just a reminder, Rob, on your first question, the team here, this core team, looked at several different programs before they selected Intermeeting. They looked at Open Court and a series of other programs and chose this one for the artifacts and the attributes that it had. I think the area that it was looking at that the state
045said we need to really identify were comprehension and vocabulary, I believe, Julie. Vocabulary, yes. And comprehension. And I think the core team felt this particular program really did emphasize that, which is the one we're piloting. I think there were two things in terms of looking at how we're addressing early intervention and pre-referral and looking at other programs. One, to both Katie and Amy's point, OG and the professional learning we're planning, what we'll speak about later at budget opportunities, we're looking at for all teachers to really looking at their different aspects of professional learning for all reading, whatever program you're using. You know, OG is a different basis. So looking at professional learning is one area. The second area is looking at a program that the teachers here today and the pilot collaborative other teachers they're
046working with really feel this captures. all the aspects of reading that the state has said we're required to provide for students in a robust way. So I think that's the two areas. And one additional piece, we've been talking about MTSS, Multi-Tiered Systems of Support. So that's that general education response to individual student needs. So when we see a student that maybe either has a learning difference or is struggling in the core to meet a grade level standard, a grade level expectation, there's a referral to that process, which is a pre-referral. hopefully not only to special education services, but again, to strengthen that student's experience in the course so that there isn't a referral to special education. Yeah, so kind of what I was getting at is if... Even if it's taking a special education student
047and more rapidly moving them back away from special education, the general population where they don't need that additional help. There are budget implications. And I think it would be really helpful for us to understand of the most of our IEPs that are literacy. Do we have an estimate for what percentage of those? are we going to address through this program potentially? And it's not like we're saying, sign your name on the dotted line. It's just like, let's get an estimate for what that would be because there are a bunch of implications that we should be taking into account when considering this program. I understand what you're saying. I think that's hard though to know until you've been in a program for a couple of years, I don't know that you'll see the benefits. I don't
048know exactly how you could, and I'm wondering if like any of the literacy specialists could speak to, you know, what you think, you know, how this program might. lessen the burden, for lack of a better term, on that MTSS or special ed. Or Sarah, also, if some of the teachers would be kind enough to speak to the area of the resources this program has that really looks at different levels of learning for some of our learners. I know we spoke about some resources. I just think that... I think that... I really want to get into all the things about what we're hearing from the pilot with you. I just think that we're missing one piece from the board's understanding to really be able to dive into that and understand it. So just hoping, you know,
049to Greg, to your point, I think that overall. That this moving in piloting this and looking at how what we might be deficient in what we can do better is an evolution. It's a step in the right direction. That's how I'm thinking about this, right, is that we're saying, you know, we have a great school and we have great teachers and. what can we do better, right? So that's what we're doing today is we're talking about how can we put better resources in. And, you know, from my own perspective, I have a dyslexic child. I also have a junior in high school who, you know, when he came into kindergarten, had only the units of study without any sort of foundation supplementation, right? My middle child. started to get foundations. And then my youngest child
050got Hegarty. So that's like another example of how we've always been moving along and looking to. I think, Greg, to your point, like speaking, especially from the perspective of a parent with a severely dyslexic child, right? Is inter-reading going to cause him to be not dyslexic? No, right? That's not going to happen. However, if into reading or a structured literacy program that has all of those components of very explicit instruction on phonics and dedicated components of all of that into one resources that the teachers have. He's, you know, such a student is going to be able to more seamlessly be in that general education classroom and that pull out instruction where they're speaking the same language. I actually had a very clever friend use a sports metaphor talking about when we have a different gen
051ed curriculum versus a more specific special education pullout, it's almost like the kids are playing basketball in their one-on-one and then they come in and they're playing soccer in their gen ed, right? So what I see this program is really doing is aligning the kids to be playing the same sport, whether they're in their pullout or their gen ed. So is that going to help them, you know, progress faster and maybe need less pullout? Yes, that's the hope. Is it easy to quantify? Of course not. They're children and they all develop. But I think that's a good thing to think about. What are our rates now? In two years, five years after we've implemented the programs, what are we seeing? I think those are great measures for us to think long-term. Any of you guys
052want to speak to this idea? Do you think? Yeah, I'm just listening and there's a lot going on between the conversations. I cannot speak to any of the financial stuff. I've been in the district since 2009. I was a classroom teacher for... 25 years in all grades from K to 4. And from what I've seen, we have a really, I do have a really great understanding of how to teach children in each of their grades. I started out with the units of study in my classroom I was teaching first grade, and I felt like I was meeting the needs of my kids. I was able to use the workshop model to actually meet with small groups and move my kids through the curriculum, and they were successful going to the next grade. The differentiation piece
053right now is our focus at our school. I'm a homeschooler. We've been doing instructional rounds for the last two years, going into classrooms and watching each other and learning from each other how to implement small group instruction based on standards, based on success criteria. And we have really seen that the kids right now are really doing the work. When I started it online, we didn't have every. um we didn't have um all the things we have now foundations came into play in 2017. foundations is og base i'm a wilson trained dyslexic therapist we use foundations and all the core programs in wilson all the time in all the grades all the way before you can teach me and now in fourth grade we're on small groups So I don't think we had anything broken. I
054think as we evolve, we add on and we figure out things that are missing and we fill the gaps. I don't feel that from what my colleagues here, my second grade teachers, from what they're telling me, they're clashing with the pilot, that they're able to meet the needs of all their kids. They're not able to really have the time to understand them as leaders because the work that they're doing is so teacher directed. that they're not having the time to really get to know their kids as readers. I sat in a meeting yesterday with my third grade team, and one of my third grade teachers said, I don't know my kids as readers because there's so much time spent with me giving instruction, but I don't know them as a reader as I did in
055the past. So I'm struggling with this conversation only because I've been through the gamut. I've done box programs in my years of teaching, and I've done an inclusive study workshop model. and for my class and my school and homes, we really do feel that the workshop model does work best. And the materials we have are fabulous. We've really honed everything in. And yes, there are pieces the state is telling us that we're missing, but I don't think we're broken. I think sometimes this conversation feels like we're broken. We're not broken. We're amazing. Our students are successful. They're rocking it. And yes, teachers are teachers and programs are programs. but overall we are really a solid district of darien and we need to fill a few gaps i don't know if this program is going to
056do that for our school thank you for sharing your perspective um and again you know this is amy said this there's there's voices on either side of this conversation and there have been for decades and this is it it's a It's a tricky conversation. I just want to, well, thank you, but I just want to say when this comes back, even if it's not the next time, but shortly thereafter, I think it's very important that we see an explicit tie between the pilot, the existing components of the program, how it relates to MTSS, and how it relates to delivery of specially designed instruction. I think that needs to be made explicit for us because I think that you know, we have a tendency to look at things in, okay, here's Hegarty, here's phonics, here's special
057education. And I think literacy is all of those things. So at some point, I'd love to see this committee really look at that from the entire universe of what it means to take a full cohort of K-3 and deliver literacy instruction to them so that we can understand this pilot in that greater context. Thank you. To the point of timing. because that is something that came loud and clear that there's just not enough time in your days. In an ideal world, how would you design your day? Like, what do you see the structure of the schedule being so that you can meet the needs of your student, whether it's with inter-reading or something else? Like, how do you, how would you design it differently? I can only talk for a second. for first grade at
058Royal. And we've talked a lot about this with other first grade teachers. We're in a lot of communication with us doing the pilot. And we are lucky that our reading block backs into our wind block. And that has been really helpful in us being able to do small group work. And then in the afternoon, we have what we are calling the word work, which is the structured literacy part, that, and then we go into writing. So for us, it actually is a nice schedule and they lend themselves to each other. And I would agree with that with third grade of Royal too, because our writing time backs into the following time. And we also have a work block too. So you're doing literacy two different times during the day. Yes. Is everybody doing that or
059no? No. So us at Holmes have a literacy block in the morning that we use for reading. We're trying to fill in. the reading lesson, the decoding, and the fluency all in that time. We have a separate writing time, which is great. What we're really missing is that word work time. We don't have that in our day, and I think that's why. Our reading instruction is not allowing us to pull small groups because the lessons are not designed as a workshop model. So the lessons do take a lot longer than a typical 10 to 15 minute lesson. So we are struggling because we're trying to fit in decoding, fluency, and reading instruction all in one block. Also trying to find time for the encoding piece. It's not as... Sarah, may I just ask a question
060to Jill's question? And perhaps some of the other team members from the core team can speak to that. There has been a lot of training and a lot of work on inter-reading and doing that. And while I appreciate the Successful Package Workshop modeling, I feel about the idea of what we've learned thus far, even though we're continuing the pilot. of how it does meet the needs of students. So is there anyone comfortable speaking about what does meet the needs of students? And it may also do that crosswalk that Jill was asking to about how it may in small group opportunities address the needs of different learners and students with learning differences. If you'd speak about some of the resources or some of the attributes of the program that you feel is meeting what we're looking
061for, not just in vocabulary, but comprehension, but in a reading program to address the needs of all learners. I can't unless you do. Everyone know what works on love is like what that means. Yes. I just want to make sure. Yeah, of course. So in our, oh, sorry. Sorry. In our, in our guidebook and in the HMH like online component, there are plentiful resources in each lesson. Of course, I'm not going to find it quick, but it, oh, here. It shows you small group instruction for differentiation. And on the bottom, there's an if then. So it gives you that if kids need extra support or kids need a challenge. So that's in every lesson. They have resources online for that as well. There is a whole folder on intervention. So for myself, any children in
062my room, I have two that are receiving MTSS support that I can utilize that for that support. And they have dad sheets already created. So that's easy for me to track and things like that. So I have found it. Listen, there's so much and it becomes a little overwhelming. And I don't know that I would say we've had a ton of training in this. I think I would disagree with that because our first training with HMH was about using the resource, which was important and very, very helpful. And we've had some small, you know, conversations with them based on questions we have. And that's been great. I would like to see more collaboration within the district because I think we can learn best from each other because we do have a teacher at my school
063who utilized this last year in New York City. And so she's like a step ahead of us. And she has been amazing to be able to say, can you help me? Does it have this? And she can point me in that direction. So I think for the other teachers, it would be helpful for those conversations. And that's why I know with the first grade, we are in communication with each other and like saying, hey, I found this, you know, sort of thing. I think that, and we've talked a lot about that. a need for that because I think we would learn best from each other and how to do some of these things that are a little bit of, I'll continue saying messy, because when you do anything for the first time, it is messy.
064So I don't know if you want to add anything. The only other thing that we've talked about a lot is that we have access to the grade below, to the grade below and the grade above, any grades really. So we can access all of the materials in order to meet the needs of all of our learners. And specifically in grammar. That's been extremely helpful to go down to some of the second grade lessons, maybe even first grade lessons, right? That some of the third graders need to work on. There's also decodable passages for kids working with fluency that you could totally pull a student to work with them. The online platform on HMH is extremely extensive. There's a lot of things available to you. you know, anywhere from assessment to reading and comprehension, all of
065that is definitely available. It is a lot and we're learning. And what I'm seeing is the amount of effort and time everyone's putting into it right now is extremely beneficial because I'm learning what K-1 and 2 is doing. to then help my third graders eventually. Not right now, right? Because not everyone's using it. But after we've been using it for a couple of years, I do think there's going to be some pretty cool things that we're going to see, hopefully. But, you know, there is a lot to think about. We've talked about that a lot because she'll say, oh, but they can't do this. And I'm like, oh, I just taught that. So because there's not that built, you know, then they are missing a lot of that instruction in third grade, which is why
066they have to kind of go back a little bit. And I understand that, sorry, I understand the new units of study I haven't seen yet, right? And I know there's a ground component that goes back, there's word love. So. you know it's it's just that we have to to check out everything to really get a clear solid uh picture of an idea of what we want but i just wanted to speak on behalf of timing um because that has come up a lot. And for someone who has used the new units of study, the workshop model, and now piloting this program, what I'm finding is this program has an abundance of resources, Bass is right, so many that we probably have not even accessed all of them. But what I am finding for me this
067year is that to execute a lot of these components, it's taking a lot of time. And I think back at my students who are now third graders, And I think when I used the workshop model and I was using the new units of study, I felt like my teacher talk was less. I honed in on those important skills and the kids had more independent practice time to really work on those skills and be thinkers and be incredible learners because it allowed for that time. So the struggle I am having is that I'm doing a lot of work. but how much work are my children doing independently? Because the goal of reading is to be lifelong independent readers. And do they have the skills to carry that on? So when we talk about timing, I have
068the same time that I had last year, but it's being executed in a way to get it in, I don't want to say correctly, because we adapt and we adjust with any model. But I don't feel like my kids have that independent time to practice those skills. And when it comes to small group instruction, I'm running out of time to do thoughtful small group instruction to meet the needs of all my moms. So that continues to be a struggle. When I went into the classroom, Sharon was doing the reading and the kids were listening with the book in their hand for 20 minutes. To me, that's not ideal. Was there an interactive conversation going on between the teacher and the students? You know what I mean? Listen, I'm just a voice here trying to make
069sure I'm not hearing both sides. That's all. Yeah, no, I was just curious. Yes. Thank you. I want to follow up on the conversation that was happening. But a piece that came out of that as well is that there's also a, I'm not sure pilot is the right word, but also a usage of the new units of study as well. And I don't feel like that has been specifically brought to the board to understand how that's going. So I would love to hear more about that. Maybe we can do that after just tying up this conversation. So what I'm hearing. And what I read in the comments as well from the survey is that is that there is a difference in experience, right? By building, by classroom, in terms of how they're implementing. And it
070certainly seems that there's not just time in the classroom that needs to be figured out, but also time for the teachers. And it makes sense to me in some ways that like this year would be bumpy and that we're getting familiar with a new resource. And I would imagine that, you know, like three years from now, you guys would all be flying through it. So to you, Amy. I'm interested to hear like what the plan is. I know that you know that there's a lot of PD, but how do you kind of see that being developed and structured with the kind of like vision and support and dedicated time resources that go into it to make sure that the teachers have the ability to do their planning, to understand the materials, and then also to
071to talk to one another, because it does sound like there are certain classrooms or certain buildings that maybe are having an easier, more successful time. And we want to make sure that all of our students, right, are getting that same experience. And then. Maybe one other piece of that too that I'm interested in that also came out of the survey. And I remember, you know, 10 years ago sitting in this room when there was like a workshop and there was a list of like our reading materials that was like seven lines long. There were like 20 resources. And I was like, oh my God, like, how do you even fit this together? One thing that seems interesting to me is that there are a lot of resources that teachers can pull from to go up,
072to go down, to figure out what works best in there. But I like that it's tied together as opposed to try forcing it together. So that's another thing that I was just hoping in terms of the PD you might be able to speak to. you mentioned inter-reading is coming. Do they have, you know, kind of a program for helping with PD? How do we kind of take this to the next step of saying there's good resources in here, but we need, you know, more time to be familiar? I just want to be cognizant of time. We've talked for almost an hour about this, but I don't want to keep you longer than we have to. So if we can kind of tie things up and we can continue the conversation. Sure. And I'd be happy
073just for the teachers to respond to that concept of all of the resources that are tied together, as Katie was just talking about, and what your experience is with that. But as far as the PD plan, I love your analogy about sports. I think what I would say is sometimes with the adult learners in the organization, the different pockets of time they have to execute teaching and learning is a similar thing, right? There are district goals, there are school goals, there are teacher individual professional goals, there are goals for our students. And then there's time that we use for all different things. So one of the things that I would like to do, and this is again, where you can see different strategy of the district coming together into one to your earlier point, Jill,
074is looking at PDEC. How does PDAC help to drive what the priorities are for professional learning at the different levels, elementary, middle, and high? Then thinking about what is the time during the teacher workday? What is the time in the contract that additional three hours? We did make a request in this budget process for additional professional learning time. And we started talking about PLCs. said I'd like to shift the conversation to overall general professional learning because one of the things that we need to do is to make connections, just like we want to happen in a classroom, between all parts of a teacher's day and a teacher's week and a teacher's month and a teacher's year. So our focus next year for elementary literacy would have to be a very tight PD plan where we
075would connect all of those available days, the full days that we have, all of those instructional minutes for us as adult learners. with a plan to support the new learning, not only one through three. We'd have to differentiate our instruction for our K teachers. We'd have to differentiate for our four and five. So it's in a very similar model, but we would like to see happen in the classroom. PDEC would need to come together with the core review team to lay that out over the course of the year using all available pockets of time. And to the point about timing and scheduling and having some schools to operate at different schedules, is that something that you're looking at to maybe standardize that and bring everybody together and figure out what's working well, what's not working
076well? Yeah, so you may recall my earlier comment at an earlier Board of Education meeting where I talked about instructional minutes and said we need to look at the whole school day and all instructional minutes. That needs to be systemic conversation. Absolutely. And I would anticipate that that would largely be informed by the members sitting on the table, the core of the team. I just have one more thing to add to that. We do have district-wide grade-level meetings that we plan this year. So that's an opportunity for teachers to collaborate. We also build that time into our professional learning days. So we have one coming up in January. If we can find time in February, it's usually building base, but we will look for that. We are also, as Amy mentioned, with our MTSS, we're
077working with a literacy consultant who actually was a consultant with the Hill for Literacy and thinking about. And her goal for us is looking across all of our assessments and making sure that we are targeting, regardless of program, that we're targeting our small group instruction to meet the needs of all learners so that our goal is, and this is really like with the science of reading, we want to make sure that by the end of second grade, all of our kids are solid decoders. So it tends to be, and we have this experience with... math and focus as well. When you have a consultant from the program, it is more directed to the program and the resources. But regardless of program or resources, we want to build the capacity of our teachers. So we and
078we do pull from resources because even with a program, there are other resources. I mean, I see these, but I've been in the classrooms, even with a small group, they're pulling things from foundations. They're pulling things from Jen Cerevalo. And we have curated like the, you know, Hegarty and foundations. We have tried to curate the best of the best. So we would continue to do that. I want to clarify one other piece as far as the professional learning plan. One of the things that I'm hearing loud and clear is that the teachers across the district are looking for more time as grade level, as you talked about this a little bit ago, grade level collaborators. So, you know, you can put on paper also the schedule, but the dialogue of what's happening across first grade,
079across five schools on a consistent and regular basis, that's. That's systemically something we need to work on as a district, providing more time to get out of two or three people or four people talking about something, but the entire grade level across the district. And I know pilot teachers may want to comment on the resource and having everything tied together, what your experience has been. So two things. The first thing I want to say, because I don't want to forget this, is we've talked a lot about I'm hearing a lot about instructional time, instructional minutes. Please don't forget that we're also building a community of fun because we are an elementary school. And one of the most important parts of my day is my morning meeting and my closing circle. That is the building. That
080is our SEL work. And without that being strong, none of this other stuff is going to come into play. So please don't forget about that piece as well. I do want to talk, I can talk a little bit about the vocabulary that's introduced with our interreading. The vocabulary ties to the book, the read aloud that you're doing. And then there are interactive read aloud. questions that go with that, where they still, in my classroom, we still do a turn and talk. Now, inter-reading is probably not suggesting that, but that's something I learned, and I think that's a great skill. So they still will have that opportunity to turn and talk. I actually do like that they all have the same book, because for my struggling readers, they're seeing that, oh, everybody has this book in
081front of them. So I don't. Mind it as a resource that they're all kind of looking at the same book. And then the other thing I wanted to point out is in structured literacy, when we're teaching a skill, say TH as a diagraph, when you do your phonological awareness work, they're using TH words. So with Hegarty, it's not tied to foundations. Sometimes the pacing in Hegarty, you would be ahead of what foundations. would have taught. And so they're not tied together. This is, there is a tie together. So I don't know if you guys had anything early for first grade. I was just going to say that the content is also. cross-curricular. So reading and writing and the structured literacy all tied together. So she's like, Beth just mentioned, if we're working on TH and
082structured literacy, that will be coming up in the decodable text that connects to the interactive read aloud. And that topic currently is Amazing Animals. And that connects to our nonfiction writing, which is about animals. So I think that that's a nice tie-in between all of the parts of literacy that this program offers as well. And we tied that to art. Our teacher is Part of what she's doing with first grade is drawing animals, and that will be the cover of their all about their animal book. Although I will say I personally felt like foundations integrity and the units of study did tie nicely together. That's just the first one. Yeah. So. And since everyone gets a personal, I'll just throw in one personal also. And Bess, thank you for pointing that out. And Linda, you
083said it earlier when you posed the question. Not to minimize, we all come with our own biases, okay, and what we believe children need. But I can't understate the importance of everyone having the same reader and what that means symbolically to children with learning differences. So I just want to point that out. And to Linda's point earlier, the conversations you have during oral reading or during group reading is not to be minimized either, because those questions that are asked and those questions that are posed really are differentiated and allow all kids to participate in the story that they're reading and or listening to. So I just want to say both those aspects to the program. I go online and look at it because it is so comprehensive when you go on there. And I think
084you really gave some explicit examples of that. And I appreciate that. And just one thing, sorry, for third grade with the spelling, if you're learning like QCH words, they'll have fluency passage that has those words in it. So then you can take time for the kids to underline those words just to get your pattern. I thought that was something that. the connection and we are working with the library as well to go over the independent projects for those kids that need that need a little bit of a challenge or they have a little bit more time there's independent projects you could do at the end or during the module that we talked to the librarian and she said she would be love to get involved with two or three of them so i think that's
085interesting One thing I just wanted to say in comparison with the structured literacy, which is the bias part of this program, because OG has come up a lot. I am an urgent practitioner certified. Fundations is Orton-Gillingham for the classroom. What I found with structured literacy this year that I'm using is it's not as multi-sensory in my opinion. And I know that in the district, people are using good practices by bringing back their boards and using materials that will make it that way. What I found when I used foundations is I had a real solid handle on watching kids manipulate letters. doing dictation sentences, which are so powerful to hone in on kids spelling and what they know about words and word parts, which then drove my small group instruction when it came to that kind
086of work. So I could visually see it. If I'm doing the program the way it's intended, and again, we bring in what we know about best practices, I feel like my handle on the kids is a little different because it's not. as, in my opinion, robust in that multi-sensory piece where I was watching kids. So I feel like, again, I'm doing a lot of the instruction there, you know, modeling the sounds after me, very similar to sound cards and foundations, but the actual application of the independence of the manipulation of those letters, I can make it happen if I supplement. But to me, the program is not just intentional. And this is where I feel like the conversation amongst all of you and the entire grades and that's helpful. You know, like this is where
087I feel this is deficient, but this is how I'm supplementing and this is helping. So that. to the point of time is important. It's been brought up that the Hegarty and foundations kind of versus the into reading resource. And I have three kids who are basically high school, college, who started in kindergarten here and did not have the benefit of Hegarty or foundations. And, you know, one who had to be pulled out to get the phonemic awareness. And so I appreciate Jill's point of having a resource that should. address all of those areas. And what I want to ask is, because I've heard people say, well, they have to supplement with Hagerty, or they have to supplement with another resource. Is the Into Reading resource giving us what we are achieving currently with Hagerty and
088foundations? Because I do like the idea of having a resource that ties all of this together. And to me, it does sound like we have a lot of resources that are readily available for teachers and maybe more of this is just a learning how to use it the best so we can best effectively use your time in planning. But I'd love to hear kind of, you know, does it meet those needs to achieve the phonemic awareness and what we're doing with Hegarty and Foundation, who's having a resource that does all of that, I think is a great benefit if we're able to use it effectively. So I, I'm not using foundations as a resource. I'm using the foundations tools. Does that make sense? I don't know if that does. So in structured literacy, you can
089print off parts like the alphabet. is on and you would cut it and it's little pieces of paper. We are fortunate that we have foundations tile boards that's the same thing. It's just that this is a tile board with magnets and this is little pieces of paper. So that's what I'm using as part of foundations. I'm using the tile boards instead of they do have that resource. But I also teach first grade and those would be lost in a half second. So that's why I'm using the magnets from that. And again, I love foundations and Hegarty. This program is not a perfect program. I've said this before. There's no perfect program. Units of study, foundations, Hegarty, it's not perfect. Nothing is perfect. It's how we use it and what we do with it. And for
090the phonemic awareness piece, I am using hand motions and things like that, that I. learned, not just through Hegarty, but for some other resources that I have too. So, and again, that's where talking to everybody could come in because then Barley could say, oh my gosh, I never thought of that. I could do that too, you know, sort of thing. So this program isn't teaching these kids, you know, and I know we've said that so many times. We are, and, you know, using our best judgments as teachers, you know, is what really should be happening. I just want this quick follow-up, which is for teachers that are new to the district, does having a resource like this help? Because a lot of what I think I hear many of you saying is you have 20
091years of experience teaching. And I'm getting to kind of the point of consistency and with our hiring and, you know, getting new teachers in who are teachers of first, second or third grade. Does having a resource like this help to ensure that we have a standardized kind of a curriculum and practice and resources available, especially for teachers that aren't as used to doing what we have done, where we're kind of piecing many different things together? That's a good question. I don't know. I don't know how to answer that. I feel like there's always a learning curve when you're a new teacher. And so I think it's kind of hard to say whether or not it might be easier, but I will say that as colleagues, we take care of each other in that way. So
092if I know that something is working, I would help a new teacher. That helps answer that question. I was just going to say, I think it comes down to good professional development. Yes. No matter what you do. I'm actually new to this district as well. I came from New Hampshire, had 38 years experience. But coming here, I had to learn Dairy and Sweat of doing some of these components that we actually used in New Hampshire, but they were a little different. So I think it's all about that good professional learning. visiting classrooms. So I don't think it comes down to whether this program is the best for new teachers with that. I think anything that we do is you've got to provide that professional development to help those new teachers, good mentors, hooking them up
093with observations in classrooms and providing the best possible training you can. Absolutely. I did. And across the district. Yeah, across the district. Yeah. All right. We, well, last thing we got to go. Amy, I think like for a future date, it would be great to also kind of understand if we were moving forward with the pilot, what we might be retaining of what we have or if it was going to be only things. So that would be a great next time. The one thing that I did want to ask, I hope that we can come back at a later date to understand more about the new units of study, if we can flag that for the next conversation. One thing that we haven't really talked about today that I think is really important is, Mrs.
094McNamee, if you could talk a bit about the grammar component specifically. That's something that I know we've been hearing about for years as an area of concern and definitely something that was mentioned in the comments as well. But I'd love to hear about that. Sure. The grammar piece in first grade is pretty exciting because we've taught them nouns, verbs. They know subject and predicate now. adjectives, the structure of forming a sentence has been. really embedded in this and they are doing a great job of writing complete sentences, knowing sentences have to have a subject and a predicate. And we've heard from parents at conferences or have phone calls that they're like, wait, what? They're coming home and telling me this is the adjective, this is a noun, and they'll say a word and they'll be
095like, did you know that that's an adjective, mom? So I think they're super excited about that learning that has taken place as well. And it's always a circle back, right? We're not going to just do it one time and it goes away. It comes up, you know, often throughout. So often the charts that we have, there are a lot of charts that come with this. They last, they come back, they circle back. They're just not one and done. So there'll be a chart about adjectives, right? And you're going to put it away for a little bit, but they're going to circle back to it and you're going to add to it, you know, and that sort of thing. And those are the things that we assess with the. at the end of each module, there's
096assessment and that gets assessed to see if they have grasped that or not. And if they haven't, then there's the opportunity for some small group work. I think that's another piece that we could talk about for hours is the assessment piece and how long that takes and what, you know, what's good, what's bad about that. So again, it's been a long, lengthy conversation. I appreciate you taking your time. out of your classrooms to be here. It is very valuable to hear from the boots on the ground in the classroom. So thank you for everything. Thank you everyone for sharing your expertise with us today. Thank you. No. Okay, we are going to move on to the geometry proposal with accelerated versus honors. Good morning. Sorry, hold on. Great. Just for Amy, just as a follow-up
097for this, we just got this benefit of getting to listen to a lot of the dialogue between teachers, which I think for our subcommittee was really helpful. The broader board obviously doesn't get that benefit. I think for the broader board, synthesizing, number one is what are the different components of our literacy curriculum that we care about and that are critical, especially for the K-3 cohorts? what are we doing well within those today? What are the gaps or deficiencies? Because I heard that there are potentially gaps and deficiencies. And then how is this new program addressing those gaps and deficiencies? How is it addressing other areas that we're currently doing well? And within the areas that we are doing, we have different programs that are filling those in, Hagerty, whatever it is. Is this replacing those?
098I think what Katie was saying is like, what does the pro forma look like? What are we actually talking about in terms of what it's going to look like? Are we keeping those old programs or replacing them? I think having that laid out pretty simply would be really helpful for the board to understand. So Tuesday night when it's in the agenda and we talk about it, I do think at this level, we can get into the nitty gritty and talk about it for hours and hours. But I do think having the higher level bullet points of this is what we're hearing. This is what, you know. Thank you, Greg, for that. We will work on that. And in addition, Greg, that's exactly what we're trying to figure out right now and why the core review
099team feels like they need a little bit more time. And I want to, again, caution, even if we were to move forward with HMH into reading, as best indicated, we might want to have, we might want to pull in a manipulative, right, for the kids to use. We might want to pull in a different text. We're never going to be, I hope. a school system that just buys a box and implements a curriculum that way. That wouldn't be responsive. And I don't think that's best. I know, actually, I don't think. I know it's not best instructional practice. But we will come back to the group with some more information about the deficiencies. We've talked about it a little bit, especially, I think, last year. But we should revisit that with the group to remind everyone
100and precisely how each of the components that we have now addresses. and comparatively each and every one. And I think the conversation about timing and scheduling and making that standardized across the district is an important one. And whether that's something that's coming next year or where you are in your process, I think is important too. I would like to think that as we come forward with the discussion around the resources and materials that we would adopt, that together we would also be hearing about. curriculum instruction assessment and professional learning instructional minutes that should be a part of it so i would think that our elementary team for review team building principals julie would come back talking about the full school day and what that looks like what does that look like for literacy minutes and
101other parts of our day right just one follow up just on instructional minutes because this did come up with the additional plc proposal that's in the budget right now. So that would be one question I would have given that I'm hearing from a lot of the teachers that they just don't have the instructional minutes that they need. So if we would be adding additional or the proposed additional PLC time, that's one question. And then the other is about word love because we didn't really hear about that. And that specifically is about vocabulary. So we'll discuss word love more next time. When I'm talking about instructional minutes, I'm talking about how we design and set up the actual school day. Like what is the student experience? Something that we need to think about simultaneously is how
102do we invest time for the adult learning that precedes the student learning? So one of the things that we've heard from this group and we hear over and over and over again is they need time as grade level partners. And Sarah, you just mentioned this, to do exactly what we just did today. How are we implementing the resource? What are the challenges? What are the barriers? What are the instructional strategies? And they need time with instructional rounds to get into each other's classrooms. Both of those things need to be part of the PDM move forward. Okay. And so we're switching to Ronnie. Yeah, we're switching to Ronnie. Sorry, Ronnie. No worries. Ronnie, thank you for being here and thank you for getting a crash course on foundational literacy at the elementary level. This is a
103part of our pre-K-12 continuum, right? Always knowing what's happening through all levels of the system. This conversation I just want to precede with, you recall that last year we had a conversation around nine English, nine accelerated and honors. And so Frances was kind of lead off batter. I'm in that conversation to continue with Katie's sports analogy. So this today is a conversation that really is around not changing content specifically, but it's really around leveling. And I know that Ronnie plans to talk about how we will continue to ensure appropriate challenge and how this model would better meet the needs of our learners. So I'll turn it over to you. Thank you. And there is lots of reading and writing math, so it was excellent for me to be here. Good morning, and I appreciate the
104opportunity to speak to you today. We'll be discussing a proposal to update the designation of accelerated geometry to honors geometry, and that's a change that aligns with our goals of consistency, equity, and preparing students for academic success. in the future. I thought you would like a little sneak peek of what our geometry classes look like. So here's about 40 seconds of what it looked like yesterday for freshman geometry. I don't know why it's not going forward. No? You can just go to slide three where the timeline is. Yep. Thank you. So we'll begin with a brief overview of the timeline for geometry at Darien High School. The accelerated geometry was adopted in 1996. Placement criteria was adjusted in 2014. In 2017, we became one of the few districts in our DERG not offering an honors
105geometry course. Currently, we have 70% of eligible students that qualify for accelerated geometry and about 34% enroll. This year, we have 184 students enrolled in geometry, 300, and only 79. in accelerated geometry and last year 180 students qualified for accelerated so obviously many didn't enroll and this could be attributed to several factors students seeking balance in their academic load varying levels of passion for math as they get older or the lack of honors credit recognition for the course which i believe is the majority Our proposal is straightforward. It's to change the designation of accelerated geometry to honors geometry starting in the 2025-2026 school year. This change promotes consistency across the subject areas, and it really mirrors the approach taken with honors biology and honors English for freshmen, and acknowledges the rigorous nature of the course.
106The curriculum revision will also ensure that the course remains challenging and aligned with the Connecticut state math standards. This proposal has really been a collaborative effort involving multiple stakeholders across the district in October 2023. District leaders, DHS admin team, the department chairs, we met to discuss and approve a plan to address accelerated courses. And this collaboration laid the groundwork, as Amy mentioned, for the proposal. And in April of 2024, Accelerated English was officially renamed Honors English. At the middle school level in December of 2023, leadership met with the math department staff and administrators to discuss the proposed changes and their implications for the prerequisites and algebra classes in the eighth grade. And since October of 2023, DHS leadership has worked consistently with the math department, the guidance counselors, and the principal to share updates on
107progression plans, curriculum changes, and upcoming parent communications. And this proposal has broad support from teachers at both the middle and high school levels and has been endorsed by the Darien High School Curriculum Council. To implement this change successfully, we will revise the curriculum, update the program of studies, and communicate these updates to parents and students. We'll also provide professional learning opportunities for teachers to support the vertical alignment and ensure the seamless transition between eighth and ninth grade. And this approach really reflects our careful planning and dedication to maintaining the high standards in our math department. Honors Geometry will offer a little more depth and breadth compared to the current accelerated course. The curriculum will include an additional unit, faster pacing, some more complex problem solving, while also fostering greater independence through no calculator sections. The
108inclusion of no calculator sections is intentional as the end goal is to prepare students for AP Calculus. And this approach really supports the calculator and arithmetic fluency, ensuring that students are equipped to excel in both sections on the AP. exam because the AP exam does have a calculator, not calculator section. All of our honors courses are designed to build these critical skills, creating a strong foundation for the advanced mathematical study. We'd also like to incorporate technology like GeoGebra, which really helps highlight the vision of the graduate competencies as it's a really great tool to explore more advanced math topics, further enhancing the rigor and the relevance of the course. One of the most significant aspects is actually the emphasis on proofs, and that's what you saw in the little snippet video. Beyond mathematical understanding, proofs
109really develop critical thinking, precision, and communication skills. In geometry, proofs require students to analyze given information. plan like a logical sequence of steps and clearly communicate their reasoning. And these are skills that are not only essential in math, but also transferable to real world applications like law, engineering, programming. Additionally, the focus on proofs aligns and supports with our five national common core practices in math. By studying proof students really hone their ability to think critically, solve complex problems, and articulate their reasoning skills that prepare them for success in both academics and life. Here we have some sample proofs. I'll show you both of geometry 300 classes. This is actually student work and that's a teacher correction on the paper there. And as you can see an honors geometry would look more like that. Basically, the
110depth and complexity in honors geometry will push students to engage in higher order thinking and articulate their understanding at a more advanced level. Eligibility for honors geometry will be determined using multiple data points to ensure we can identify students prepared for the increased rigor. These include grades, teacher recommendations, standardized test scores, and exam performance. A waiver option will be available for students who may not meet all the criteria but demonstrate readiness through other means. In summary, this proposal strengthens our curriculum, aligns with other honors level courses, and equips our students with the skills needed for academic and professional success. Importantly, it does not alter any of the pathways currently in place for students at the high school level. All existing progression options will remain intact, ensuring that students can continue to pursue their individual academic
111goals. Thank you. Thank you. I have a couple quick questions. First one being the curriculum revision and PL for teachers. Is there a budgetary impact for this that is currently not? Or is it all wrapped up into what we have? It's all wrapped up into. Good answer. Okay. My next question was, I lost it. Go ahead, Robin. My question is for the existing eighth grade accelerated geometry curriculum for the double double accelerated math students. With the curriculum for the eighth grade. also change to mirror the honors geometry proposed course for the ninth graders. And with the accelerated, because these are the double advanced children that are potentially taking multivariable calc in their senior year, I would think would benefit from having the more advanced level proofs, the maybe more in-depth discussion. But I don't know
112if that's age appropriate. It seems like it would be skill appropriate. Or would there be extra credit or challenge options available? And I'm just trying to understand that a little bit better. Yeah, thank you so much for asking because I love to talk about that and math all day long. So the accelerated geometry course actually is more robust than our accelerated geometry course at the high school right now, as because those are the students that we think are going to go to multivariable calculus. You know, that's the ultimate end game. So they actually have a construction unit that we don't do at the high school. That would be one of the units that we would like to add in if we change the designation to honors. this time there would be no change, although the
113differentiation for those students, it's low floor, high ceiling, like there's no cap. If we really try to present problem-solving opportunities for them, that if they can go further, we'll go further. The criteria for the new honors geometry, is that different than the current criteria for the accelerated geometry? It is. The current is B, and with the change that we plan on making with the curriculum, This was a universal decision in terms of all the stakeholders involved, removing it to a B plus. Okay. And then globally, so we did English, we're thinking about math. Will Western Civ come next? Is that the pathway we're thinking about? Western Civ and then there's a French. French, okay. Okay, so we're trying to be consistent. That fall into the same category of... And again, like Ronnie mentioned, there could
114be a number of reasons why the majority of students aren't enrolling. It's not an honors designated. Okay. Other questions? No? The Weaver process will remain the same? Yes. Okay. So it is my understanding that this will come to the full board on Tuesday night for further discussion and possible action. Are we in agreement to move this forward? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Sarah, request that when it comes to the board, that it come with that larger context of what we're doing with classes across the board, please. Thanks. Okay. Thank you. Robin's good to go. For the Tuesday night meeting, I think it would be helpful to just also address the eighth grade current accelerated geometry course in that curriculum, because that might be a question that board members might have. I'll take that advice. Thank you.
115One other thing to add, if you'll recall, we've included in the budget a new middle school resource. So one of the things that Ronnie can do is also indicate, maybe provide some information about that resource in response to the question about the middle school programming. Thank you. Okay, moving to public comment. Good morning. If anyone in person or online would like to participate in public comment, please approach the podium or use the raised hand icon and wait to be recognized. Once you are recognized, please state your name and address for the record and note that you have up to three minutes to comment. We have no raised hands and nobody in person. Okay, I will entertain a motion to adjourn. Seconded by Katie.