CorpusRecord 157133

Barstow Unified School District Special School Board Meeting - February 6, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Barstow Unified School District
Date
2025-02-07
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,467 words · about 25 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001It is 4.02, and we'll call the meeting to order. Mr. Williams, would you like to speak? Sure. I hand over your heart to Peter F. DeVey. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. roll call, let it be known. We have all five trustees in attendance. Ms. Givens, Mr. Williams, Mr. Useless, Mr. Brea, and myself. We will now move into business from the floor. The board meeting is a business meeting of the board held in a public forum to comply with the Brown Act. It is not a town hall meeting with the board. This is a time for citizens to present problems or questions they feel the board should discuss. Individuals are

002encouraged to address the full board, not individual board members. The law prohibits the board from taking action on items not on the agenda. Requests to speak cards should be filled out in advance and presented to the superintendent's executive assistant. Instructions for submitting remote public comments can be found on our website, busdk12.com, under the tab Board of Trustees. The board has a policy limiting any speaker to not more than three minutes. The board limits the total time for public input on each item or topic to 15 minutes or five individual requests to speak. The president may review the submitted request to speak or take a poll of speakers for or against a particular issue and may ask that additional persons speak only if they have something new to add. Citizens who have comments on or against

003a particular issue may be asked to provide a written statement for the record or sign in agreement with the written comments of another citizen. All names will be memorialized in minutes. With the board consent, the president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public presentation, depending on the topic and the number of persons wishing to be heard. For the record, please state your name. Do we have it this time? We have none. And it is 4-4, and we will go to closed session. I will get you the phone number. Okay. and we are back from closed session and there were no items to report. So next we'll go to, do we have any minutes? No minutes. No minutes. All right. Business from the board. Business from the board. And reports. We have your onsite

004visit report with Dr. Williams. Thank you. Okay, one second gets in. Good evening, Superintendent, the board. I'm here to present kind of a mid-year update of our Unified School District's progress with this agreement with the Department of Justice. Today, we completed a two-day visit with our independent monitor, Dr. Monica Eane, who you met earlier. So I'd like to introduce myself. My name is Dr. Benny Williams. I'm the Director of Support for School Climate here in Barks Unified School District. Dr. Eane and myself, we filled two of the positions that were... mentioned within this agreement that we'll be going over today. So even though we all have a role in this and it's the full kind of commitment from the district for moving forward on this. We play a role that's outlined within the judgment to

005work in connection between the district and the Department of Justice and facilitate communication and collect data and continue progress monitoring and then also reports like this. So annually the superintendent asked that I give this report to our management team. We do it regularly with our site leaders and I've gone to different schools and presented this very similar information. So I'm very happy to bring some of this current information as well as some historical information to the board tonight about a process that started Well, I won't say started, but was memorialized with the Department of Justice. It's September 1st, 2020. So these are two documents filed within the Superior Court of the State of California County, Los Angeles in 2020. On the right, the one that's got the date and the stamp from September 1st, is

006what became the final judgment. Before it was the final judgment, it was a proposed judgment and an agreement in... negotiated between the Attorney General's Office for the state of California, represented at the time by Xavier Becerra, and also worked on by the Bureau of Children's Justice, which I'll touch on a little bit later, and varsity by school district. Well, in order for there to be a court judgment agreement between the plaintiff and the defendant, there was an injunction filed a week earlier. But obviously, one week is kind of swift for justice. or any sort of court proceedings. So this actually began many years earlier in the form of an investigation. And so I want to talk a little bit about that investigation. But before I do, this investigation really is, I won't say centered around,

007but has a great deal of a connection with the practice of school suspension. It is not the only thing this judgment is about. Sometimes it can feel that way or sometimes it gets portrayed that way. And so a lot of things get assigned to this judgment around suspension. And since I've had this job for four years and even before I took this job on as site principal and assistant principal, I had my fair share of suspensions and expulsions. And I developed my own feelings about them through my practice of it. the impact it had on kids, my involvement in it. And so if I'm going to speak about that a lot tonight, I want to acknowledge my own bias. And off the top, I'm under the impression that suspensions do more harm than good. Nothing

008is absolute in anything, especially in education, but just in general. And it didn't take very long to find an article that literally said the exact same headline. So school suspension is more harm than good. So when I speak, I want to acknowledge that lens. I want the board to be aware that I have that lens. I always want to make sure, so it's even more important that what I'm doing is based, or what I suggest or what I say is based in law and in research. And so even though this is where I acknowledge myself to be at tonight, I will provide more information about it. But I want to start out with that. And the reason I said this is so at the core, in 2020 injunction was filed against us, but the first

009time Barstow Unified School District kind of came onto the radar of the state of California was after our 2016-2017 year. And man, that feels far away when we're standing in 2020. But in that particular school year, every school in the state submits their data through CALPADS every year. And so in this case, suspensions are public data. You can find them on the internet. And so that year in 2017, statewide, Statewide suspension exists. So if you pick any 100 kids from any school in any grade, anywhere, any subgroup, anything about them, on average, those 100 kids would have received 11 days worth of suspension during that school year. So that's kind of the state line base number. In the county of San Bernardino, that same year, any 100 kids enrolled in San Bernardino County would have

010got 15. So there's a difference. And, you know, we're starting at 11, going to four days. That's actually a pretty significant difference. You know, 30 percent, you know, it's, you know, sometimes it's hard to measure. But this 100, or these days per 100 count, it's become a standard within researchers looking into this. phenomenon. That year for Barstow Unified School District 2017, the average 100 students in Barstow Unified School District had 45 days. And so... The Attorney General's office at the time, researchers, it really was researchers first who recognized, you know, among the schools that we looked at that have a high use, obviously four times that of the state, three times that of the county, Barsha Unified School District was on that list. And it was a number that stood out. But no place is

011any one number. You know, no one number is just an indication of one thing. And so the Department of Justice began their investigation around that time, I think. Around the time one of the reports came out was probably when the phone rang and said, hello, we'd like to set up an appointment and talk to you a little bit more. But we've also done our own research since then with data. And so as I stand in front of the board today. I can say very definitively that it was not just a one year knock, that between the years 2011 and 2020, our Unified School District used suspensions excessively, higher than our county neighbor friends, higher than the state of California. It was a tool that is allowed by law, that is required by law in some

012cases, but our implementation of it, our final outcome was excessive. And so... Just again, I don't want you just to believe me. I want to be able to bring research to this that says, hey, even though this is allowable, even though it exists, even though there's pros and cons around the negativity, what does research say about the use of suspension? So writ large, here's why it says suspensions are merely punishments and not designed to teach appropriate behavior. Suspensions are essentially non-interventions that have counterproductive effects. Another study shows out-of-school suspensions are hard to justify as educationally necessary because they do not produce the desired improvement to behavior. They harm educational outcomes of the suspended student, and they are less effective than numerous alternatives, less punitive approaches to student misconduct. And then one more. A higher level

013of exposure to restorative practices actually reduces the black-white suspension gaps that exist within the state, in the county, and in our district. It also is associated with higher GPAs. Teacher training designed to improve student engagement has also been shown to both help improve achievement and reduce office referrals for students' conduct. And so... I always want to look to research. I always want to see what it says to make sure we're grounded. And then ultimately, I kind of bring it back to what does that mean for me? What does that mean for, you know, if I'm a principal at my school site, what does that mean for our district? And while we have instances where it's required by law, we have instances where we feel it's very necessary. Anytime we use a suspension, the student is

014not in school. And like I said, sometimes it can do more harm than good. When you use it excessively, like anything, even that's good for you, anything in excess is going to have a negative effect on your organization. And then ultimately, we all live through the pandemic. We all kind of read through that process that the best place for students is in school. And so if we need to make adjustments to make school. safe for those students and others, then those adjustments are worth making. And so After the investigation from the Department of Justice, these were kind of the factual findings that went into an injunction that ultimately resulted in our final judgment. The first one is that research-based fact that says high levels of suspension and wide gaps between similar students in discipline are

015associated with negative outcomes. There's just not a lot of high-performing schools that also have excess discipline or high gaps between different student groups in discipline. The second one is this district, Barsch-Unified School District, the discipline policies and practices resulted in different treatment and disproportionate outcomes. So it wasn't just the number on the page. During the investigation, they found that our policies and practices resulted in these treatments. The district did not adequately respond to allegations of discrimination for some students. Investigation found that important aspects of district policy and practice failed to comply with state law. So things that either we were doing officially or even things that we were publicly saying, hey, if this happens, this happens. The way we were doing things were not always in compliance with state law. State law changes quickly. Something

016that was allowable two years ago or that we thought was common practice two years ago may not be allowable now. So we need to continue to make those adjustments. But we were found in many other things. And then finally, districts admission and enrollment policies had a disparate impact on similar student groups and then low income students. So just the last little bit of data, by the time the investigation completed, it wasn't 2017 anymore. We were at the end of the 2019 school year, you know, right before we get to 1920 and get to our long-term closure. But again, at the time, it was not a single year of an anomaly. It was... the outcomes that were year after year in Bars Unified School District. So in 2019, when that investigation completed, we found that Bars

017Unified had a suspension rate for African American students, 22% rate, almost one in four African American students who attend our schools would have received a school suspension during that year. We talked about having 45 days per 100 district-wide, 138 days per 100 for African American students that year. Our suspension rate was two and a half, that of the state for our students with IEP, students with disabilities. One more here. When we look at all students, regardless of ethnicity group or IEP status, in grades 7 through 12, we were twice that of the state. In grades four through six, we were five times out of the state. In grades K through three, we're seven times out of the state. And again, anytime we're two, three, four, five, six, seven times higher than that in the state,

018we're... we're just getting different outcomes. We're doing something different. It's not, oh, this is the same everywhere. This is the same for us. And, you know, when I go through these, there's always a few items that stick out to me or a piece of data that sticks out to me. When we first had this slide, we created it. We've worked with different principals. Having kindergartners through third grade suspended seven times the state rate, we know. Again, we didn't adjudicate whether each one was allowable, whether the kids really were a danger, whether they really were bad. It wasn't really about that, but obviously at seven times the rate, we need to adjust our practices to change our outcomes. And if students are missing that much school in grades K through three, when our primary focus is

019literacy and reading and learning. It's going to put kids farther back at a disadvantage academically. So when you hear us say suspensions cause more harm than they cause good, the good is a temporary, but the harm is sometimes we see more long-term. And it's not always obvious in the moment. And it's just something we always need to be aware of as we're working through that constant, continuous improvement cycle. That's how we got to on the radar and into the agreement with Barstow Unified School District. I keep using the word agreement because even though the judgment was signed by a Superior Court judge, it was agreed upon by the Attorney General's Office of Barstow Unified School District. Obviously, when you're having a discussion like that, an agreement, you know. Anyway, with the Department of Justice, that's

020a pretty big entity to be working with. But the good news is we can make this, and there are things that, they're all things that are designed to improve our district, our schools, and ultimately support our kids. A few of them are actually currently in the Ministry of Ministry because they had a new story about our monitor visiting with us. The reason they had all this information is because we sent it out to parents. We wanted parents to know that we're part of this judgment. that someone's coming to visit, that we would love to hear from them, we want more information. And so the Daily Press found that notice and we were able to publish part of it at store in one of the papers. And so I'm going to share with you exactly what

021we share with parents, exactly what was in the newspaper yesterday, about some of the things we agreed to. And here it says, a portion of the plan includes provisions for school districts to revise policies and practices on student discipline and to ensure non-discrimination. and to strengthen mental health, social work, counseling services, the Attorney General at the time said. And as I already mentioned, we've been in this for about four years. During that time, we've been developing new policies and procedures with the Bureau of Children's Justice, which is especially given the California Department of Justice. They focus solely on the needs of children in a way that... different than other parts of the Department of Justice. So the folks that we work with, the lawyers that we work with, are highly skilled and trained specifically in

022the areas and needs of children. So we've been working with them. And there are 50 or so items, 48 or so items in here individually, but they all have the same theme. Barst Unified School District agreed to make changes to its policies, procedures, and practices in a number of areas. And all three of those things are connected. Policy, a lot of times we think of board policy, and board policy has changed over the last five years. And it really is the foundation for a lot of our training that we do to create procedures at the schools. Once those procedures are in place at the schools or here in the district, what is the outcome of them? What is the practice? So the policy part. I don't mean to say it was probably the easiest. This

023panel at the time was able to be presented. We were able to answer questions. There was a vote. They get updated. They get published. They're on the internet. It's very easy for any of us to find a board policy at this point. But in the same way that a speed limit sign does not guarantee that everyone's going to go 35 down the hill when they get to the old theater spot. You need to have policies or in addition to policy, procedures and practice to ensure the outcomes that you're looking for. And so I mentioned this a little bit, but I want to really just kind of highlight the timeline of judgment activities. As I mentioned in 2020, we entered into that final judgment corrective action with the DOJ. It was based on... two to three

024years worth of research and interviews. And much like Dr. Nguyen, our independent monitor, came today and visited classrooms, interviewed our staff, spoke with students, spoke with families, those same in-person investigations were conducted in 2018 and 2019. And so since then, we were able to develop this corrective action. And that's what we've been working on for the first four years of this particular judgment. And we're... Coming to the end of the school year, we know the Department of Justice will be coming again before the end of the year, and we'll be getting their final report probably in May again of 2025. At that point, we'll be able to have kind of a definitive, where are we now as we get to the end of our term, and what are the next steps in moving on forward

025from September 2025. Those 40 years with a circle around it. represent a lot of time. They also represent a lot of change within the district. We've made a lot of changes to the things we do. We've also had a lot of change in people. But this is an agreement between Barsfield and Fife School District and the Department of Justice. So here in Barsfield and Fife School District, whether you've been with us two days. Two years, two decades. We all kind of have a commitment because we represent the district. And so even though those things change, our agreement with DOJ remains and we're all working towards continuing what we've done this year with focus on evidence of continued improvement. And there has been some improvement. But I do want to talk about some areas of growth

026and compliance. If I said that suspensions is one of the biggest. items of findings and going into this, then the prevention of suspensions is the goal of the action items in there. Not just the reduction of suspension, the prevention of suspension. I don't have any sides about it here in terms of research, but the research has cleared that actually if you just stop using that particular tool and you don't change your practices and you don't change your policies and you don't provide more supports for students, it's actually much worse than suspension. So if you just go, we're not allowed to do it anymore, take that tool out of the bag, set it over here, and let things go, it's actually much worse than even the high numbers that we have. And so one of the

027biggest things in the judgment is around the process of positive behavior intervention and supports. PBIS is usually what it's called, the acronym. These are some stats from a site visit this school year in September in which we went through 93 classrooms. All over the district, all grade levels, all sites, everybody. And we saw five levels of the characteristics of classroom PBIS. We have nearly every classroom in the district has posted expectations and rules. Anyone who has kids or has been a parent know that you have to keep reminding kids of stuff if you want them to do it each time. It's not just going to be a one-time thing. 80% of our classrooms maximize the physical structure and space. 60% of our classrooms are actively acknowledging appropriate behavior. So instead of just using the... trying

028to prove, fix behavior after it's been bad, acknowledging appropriate behavior, as well as responding to inappropriate and engaging with students. So here's just some data from that. And here's what it looks like functional. You know, you may say, oh, you know, a lot of times we say, oh, this is just the teaching. Everybody does this. This is common. This is intentional with, again. The goal of preventing the behavior, preventing the suspensions. So here's an example from Skyline North. You know, they have their school-wide mottos. By having consistency of it, there's a way to be respectful, responsible, and safe in every part of our schools. And this is the way that students are taught. If you were to go to Skyline Now, they even have new signs you can keep updating. And in addition to words,

029they have a picture of a bear throwing away his trash. They have a picture of a bear standing in line waiting for the water fountain. You know, trying to show kids and remind kids what the behavior looks like, sounds like, feels like, and how we want them to go across the schools. And so this one is very much just a reminder of positive behavior, putting the expectations out. And again, these are in all of our classrooms, pretty much at this point, 98%. It's not always about just the rules of the classroom in the same way that we might be used to them, but ways to bring in some of that social-emotional benefit to children. Here, again, respectful, responsible, and safe, using that same common language for kids so they're used to saying it. Here are

030ways that just, you know, little hearts there. They're not only rules, but they make kids feel better. We're all, you know. Whether you're a clean, you know, clean, organized person, whether it's just you like being around good people like positivity breeds positivity. And so the more we can invest that in school, it actually that's how we reduce the negative, not by by having a bigger hammer. So speak kindly, wait your turn, be a good listener, push in your chairs. And you know, when you start doing PBIS, things like that, it's really easy to say, oh, that works with little kids. But what about big kids who you can't just have sparkly stuff for? Here's an example from one of our secondary schools. For when students are mad, how to go through it. Frustration, people are

031annoyed. Same stuff, different day. I feel that way some days. I know kids do. Teaching them the way through that. What can I do right now? Figure out what can be changed, set my goals, cool down the thing. So many times as a site principal and as I've read through the hundreds and thousands of suspensions, not hundreds of thousands, hundreds and thousands suspensions over the last 10 years, I've read through them and so many of them are the results of a student who otherwise is a good student who's trying to follow the rules who falls into one of these and then makes that poor choice. Once the poor choice is done, we have to deal with it. We can't ignore it. Otherwise, the same way I said positivity breeds positivity, negativity breeds negativity. I'm going

032to go back to this PBIS thing real quick. PBIS is not just acknowledge positive. It is respond to inappropriate behavior. But respond, in this case, sooner. Respond to behavior before. It is inappropriate. And bring the student back down. And then they learned that. That's what they learned to do. We have a school right now that, you know, for the five years of this judgment, has really started tying all of these things together in the most evident way. that we've seen during our monitoring and that's Cameron Elementary School. The award that principal and teacher are holding there is the Platinum Implementation Award for PBIS that we presented at a board meeting a few months back. So once the science came through and once it's part of their logo, it's not just part of their school, but

033it's really part of how they do things. The pages that are flipping through there would have become a very large guidebook for their PBIS process. And then as they start building it and building it, it's not just one part of their classroom. It's everything that they do. It's how they respond to everything. And it all is brought together in a way that is easy to explain at times and that the kids can explain. KIDS. Every kid at Cameron can explain not only what that is, but what that means. And as a result, the outcomes are better. Again, we didn't say we need to change the outcome. We need to change what we're doing in front of it. And that's why PBIS is at the top of the list of things that Barsch Unified School District

034is asking. And we've seen the data district-wide by starting to implement ways to reduce suspensions. So here's kind of an expanded look at 2019. Again, these are days per 100 students, which kind of are measured, but the little number in the brackets is the, what we'll call it, the rank statewide in those particular categories. So suspensions, we were the eighth lowest in the state. Among our African American students, we were the lowest. Students with IEPs, sixth lowest. Grades one through three, third lowest. Kindergarten, the lowest. So that was in 2019 before. This agreement was made in the last year of data available for statewide 2023. While the state number has gone up, our number has gone down. So our practices are making gains that are not just happening through statewide because it's evident coming back

035from COVID did have a big effect. on students and behavior. So we see that in that bump statewide. We've also experienced that bump, but the methods we put in place to help prevent it have kept us from bumping from old numbers. And now we're getting into a new kind of baseline area where we're not the lowest kindergarten suspension. We're 111. We're not the sixth lowest of students with IEPs. We're in the 200s. We're getting closer to that state average. And we're no longer the highest within our nearby districts in San Bernardino County or in the high desert. So again, this is 2023. We have lower numbers of rates per 100 compared to local districts. And, you know, I want us to celebrate. I celebrate. This is proud. When we started this, I didn't know where

036we would land. I knew that we had to implement practices and see where we came to, but I wasn't sure how far it would go. We've made great strides, but I want to bring in a comparison of two other districts that are not anywhere near us in geographicness or in size. Los Angeles Unified School District and Compton Unified. Los Angeles Unified School District, 400,000 students, 0.37. days per 100 students. Again, they use this tool of suspension, but they don't use it at the same rate as the state. They're much lower. And in fact, they had less total days than us that year, despite having many, many more students. When I go to their website, I have not been to their 100 and some odd schools, so I will not pretend to be an expert. But

037when I go to their website, their PBIS is what we're striving for. We can't copy and paste it. We can't say we're now doing this everywhere. But it's the same process that they used to start reducing those things. They started 10 years ago. We started, well, probably 15 now. We've started five. So even though we're used to it and it's something that maybe is even prevalent in the high desert, it is not universal. And it can be addressed through many of the things that are in this judgment. So there's continued action. What's required for compliance? Policies, procedures, and practice. And all three of them need to be in alignment. And that means if we do a policy and it's not quite working when we observe it, then we need to adjust. If we say this

038is what we're going to do in this situation for procedures and the data says it's not working, we need to adjust. And so it's not that. A lot of times you're in compliance and compliance says you will do this one thing, you will check the box, and now you have complied. This isn't a box-checking exercise, unfortunately. This is, we want to see change at your schools. We want to see change in your practices at the district. And so that's what we're going to continue to look for. And when we get our report back from the Department of Justice in June, this is going to be kind of their metric that they're looking at. We're going to keep focusing on classroom PBIs. We have new teachers, new students. We have a lot of turnover. And so

039it's something that requires regular training and regular meetings. Each school site has a PBIs team that looks at their data monthly. We train with their... their teacher leaders every month. We have new SAMs in each of our schools. They're going to be part of that team because they're part of the response to what happens to students. This really is about, you know, we try to put it under a single umbrella, but it really is about everything. Here are a few items from last year's report. We're not getting into many of the items this year, but this is something that was part of the previous report from the Department of Justice that we're going to continue working on. You know, again, areas of training. areas of harassment discrimination and our continued outcomes and practices policies procedures

040for students with disabilities and so that's where we are now and we're looking forward to to the next steps and kind of this continued journey Are there any just kind of questions? I know I breezed through it a lot. I left off many, many charts and graphs and slides that are available in our school sites that I've seen and kind of know about too that we can always make available. But this is just to kind of summarize the judgment in a way, both for the board, the public behind me and on the internet, and anyone else just so we can keep it available, like I said. This isn't some different information that we shared in the notice this week. It's not different information than any other presentations or trainings or publications that we try to

041make. But we want to make sure that we say it as often as we can. So people, when they refer to our agreement with the Department of Justice, we're all working from the same page. So I should pretend, Mr. President, if there's anything else that I can add or any questions that I can. Thank you all. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Adoption of the agenda. I get a motion and a second. So moved. Second. All in favor? Aye. There are no presentations or recognitions. No communication. Nothing on the consent agenda or the discussion items. does anyone have any items for future board meetings they'd like to bring up at this time let it just stop all right and i can't get a motion to adjourn so i'll move do you need to go back

042and close session no closed session uh so moved and second second by mr williams all in favor aye 604. see you guys on tuesday all right that was good

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.