CorpusRecord 157224

EWCSD Board of Education Meeting - Monday, December 16, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
East Whittier City School District
Date
2024-12-17
Location
CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,044 words · about 67 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening. We're very excited to have everybody here. We do have reserved seating in front for our Mulberry people if you want to come up, or we also have it for all of our people who are being recognized as our community service providers and who give back to our community if you want to sit in the front. But if you want to stay back there, you're more than welcome to stay where you are. This is the one board meeting where I open it and then we're going to take a vote and an oath and then I will pass it on to whoever is elected to be the new president of our Board of Education. But right now we have two amazing students from Mulberry Elementary. If you wouldn't mind coming up here and just please

002introduce yourself, who you came with and what your position is over at Mulberry. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. So as you know, back in November, we did have an election in the country. We were fortunate to where our board has been so stable and longstanding that we actually did not have an election for our school board seats. So two of our board members are going to be sworn in in tandem today. So at this time, I would like to ask Mr. Carlos Aparicio and Mrs. Wendy Carrera to come up to the front, and we're going to do our oath of office. and domestic. I will bear truth and allegiance

003without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion. And I will well and faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am to be. So now every year then we do do a reorganization of our board to elect officers and special committees and representatives of our district on behalf of the board. So first off, we will move on to the election of our board president for 2025. Following the vote to approve the newly elected president, the president will take my gavel from me. I know that. I move that constraint Christine Chacon Kennedy be elected president of the Board of Education and move that nominations be closed Do I have a second? I'm sorry any discussion and I will call for the vote. Mr. Tiaga. Yes. This is dabs. Yes. Mr. Cohn Kennedy. Mr. Aparicio. Yes. Miss Hernandez.

004Yes. Miss Carrera. Yes. Hey Congratulations Okay, moving right along. Okay. It's open for Vice President. So, I move that Lisa Dabbs be elected as Vice President of the Board of Education and move that nominations be closed. Second. Okay. Any discussion? I'll call for the question. Ms. Carrera? Yes. Mr. Tiaga? Yes. Mrs. Dabbs? Yes. I vote yes. Mr. Aparicio? Yes. Ms. Hernandez? Yes. Okay, on for Clerk. I move that Mondo Ortega be elected as clerk of the Board of Education and move that nominations be closed. I second. Any discussion? Any additional nominations? I'll call for the question. Mr. Aparicio? Yes. Ms. Hernandez? Yes. Ms. Carrera? Yes. Mr. Ortega? Yes. Mrs. Dabbs? Yes. Okay. If it passes, Mr. Ortega is now the clerk of the Board of Education. Sorry. Before that, Mrs. Dabbs is now the vice

005president. Okay. Okay, so we have representative for the, what is this, elected as representative for elected members of the County Committee for School District Organization. Do we have somebody on there already? Oh, do you want to do it again? Okay. I move that Ms. Trappisi will be elected as the representative for elected members of the County Committee for School District Organization. I second. Okay. We have a first and a second. Okay. Anybody else want to jump in on that? Yeah, call for the question Mrs. Dabbs. Yes, mr. Tiago. Yes. I vote. Yes. Mr. Aparicio. Yes. Mr. Hernandez. Yes. Ms. Carrera. Yes. Okay passes You're elected. Mr. Aparicio. Mm-hmm. Okay. Now we have to Select somebody to be the voting delegate and board member representative for the LA County School Trust lacks to LA County School

006Trustees Association Is it miss Carrera right now? Is it Ms. Cutter or is it Ms. Dabbs? Who is it right now? Well, I'm currently the rep that I'm going to pass on that opportunity this year. Okay. So I cannot serve as a rep and executive. Okay. I guess Mondo by default win or mr. Cone All right, so I move that mr. Tug of be elected as a representative to the Whittier Oh wait, sorry wrong one. I like I move that mr. Tug of be elected as a voting delegate and board member representative for Los Angeles County School Trustee Association and move that the nominee nominations be closed votes on all association matters and is the communicator I second Any other nominations or any discussion? Okay, I'll call for the question. Ms. Carrera? Yes. Ms. Hernandez?

007Yes. Mr. Aparicio? Yes. Mrs. Dabbs? Yes. I vote yes. Mr. Urtiaga? Yes. Okay. Passes. Okay, Mr. Urtiaga, you're now the next to rep. Okay, now we need somebody for the Whittier Area School Trustees Association. Who is it currently? Miss Dabbs, right? Do you want it again? Okay. So I move that Miss Dabbs be elected as a representative to the Witter Area School Trustee Association and move that nominations be closed. I'll second. Anybody else want to? Okay. I'll call for the question. Mr. Tiaga? Yes. Mr. Aparicio? Yes. Miss Hernandez? Yes. Mrs. Dabbs? Yes. I vote yes. Miss Carrera? Yes. Okay. Mrs. Dabbs, you're the Woody Aeroskull District Association person. Okay. Okay, on for representative to the Joint Powers Board. I move that Mark Patterson be representative to the Joint Powers Board. I second. Okay, anybody else?

008Any other nominations? Any discussion? Okay, I'll call for the question. Ms. Carrera? Yes. Ms. Hernandez? Yes. Mr. Aparicio? Yes. I vote yes. Mrs. Dabbs? Yes. Mr. Tiaga? Yes. Okay. So mr. Patterson dr. Patterson is now there a rep for the Joint Powers Board, okay Next one is the legislative designee for CSBA Who is that? It's me, but nothing we nominate miss. Good. Oh You're nominating her you know money. Oh So I move that miss Carrera be elected as a legislative designee to CSB and move that nominations be closed Second any additional people wanna? Call for the question Mr. Aparicio? Yes. I vote yes. Mrs. Dabbs? Yes. Mr. Utiaga? Yes. Mrs. Hernandez? Yes. And Ms. Carrera? Yes. Okay. So you are now the CSPA legislative designee. Okay. One more. Okay. Yeah. So item number, I move

009that Mark Patterson be appointed Secretary of the Board of Education. I second. Any discussion? I'll call for the question. Mr. Ortega? Yes. Mrs. Dabbs? Yes. I vote yes. Mr. Aparicio? Yes. Ms. Hernandez? Yes. Ms. Carrera? Yes. Okay. Okay. Now we're going to change order a little bit, and we're going to jump over to the District Employee Recognition Mulberry Elementary. Good evening, everybody. I am the proud principal at Mulberry, and I have two awesome employees to recognize. Unfortunately, they could not be here tonight, but I know that we have friends here, so I'd just like to share a few words before we move on. First, our Classified Employee of the Year is Ms. Virginia Ponce. It is my pleasure to share with everyone here how wonderful she is and a fabulous school office coordinator. She is

010truly an unstoppable work machine that knows her job inside and out. She is very, very quiet, but oh boy, is she a beast of an SOC. She is thoughtful, caring, and fun to have in the office. She constantly keeps the office running smoothly by anticipating needs and addressing them before they can become an issue. Family, staff, And I all know that we can count on her for anything that we need. She also works tirelessly with all the millions of clubs that we literally have at Mulberry. It is a tedious job, and she does it all with a smile on her face. And she tells me it's worth it because I know that the kids love the clubs that we offer. We are very grateful for her ability to juggle all of those work details, especially

011me. She is an exemplary SOC, and she is not allowed to retire until I retire. So we're stuck with her. She's stuck with me, too. It is an honor to have her at Mulberry. She is a great resource for us and an even greater gift to have her smiling face greeting us every morning. She is truly an excellent representative of East Whittier's classified employees. Congratulations, Virginia. And our Certificated Employee of the Year is Ms. Cheryl Collegian, and she is an absolute pleasure to have at Mulberry. Not only is she an exemplary teacher and third grade team member, she helps us immensely with her friendly demeanor, team player attitude, and is always willing to go the extra mile for the school. She is truly one of the biggest scholar hearts at Mulberry. Ms. Kalija not only

012takes great pride in educating her students through academics, but also in ensuring their emotional health and their happiness. She takes great care when working with kids and knows them all personally. She truly has a gift for connecting with students on many levels, which is why they will do anything to make her happy. Even with juggling and managing all of the students in her room, she always knows what's going on with each and every one of them. Relationships are very important. She has worked tirelessly to create that environment for all of her students. Thank you for all you do, Cheryl. Mulberry sees everything you do, and you make it a very wonderful place for everybody. We are very proud of having her as our East Whittier Certificated Employee of the Year. And shifting gears to our...

013I think it's our theme of the year, Mulberry, the best in the West. And it's a great place to learn and grow and where we give a hoot. That's also one of our little mottos. And looking at all the little stars in the lassos. Through the PBIS lens, we have school-wide norms which have positively impacted our school culture. Our scholars hoot, and it shows through holding high expectations, owning your actions, offer respect and kindness, and take charge of our learning. Our students also benefit from a variety of engaging activities to help them feel a part of the community, which gives them something to look forward to. Our wonderful PTA definitely helps us with that, and our student council through events and activities throughout the year. and they dedicate themselves to ensuring that our scholars have

014every opportunity to not only learn but also enjoy their time at Mulberry. And speaking of Mulberry, we have wonderful teachers and staff there as well. And it makes me very proud to share that almost every single one of our employees on campus, teachers and aides, are helping in some sort of way with an after-school club. And I was so proud last year, this time we had 15. This year we have 41. So 41 clubs that... can vary greatly. I'm not going to name them all. I'm going to name a few. But it really does help motivate them because to be part of a club, you have to be good, right? And you have to try so hard. And these clubs include art and cheerleading, cooking, dance, folklorico, green club, gymnastics, guitar, Spanish yearbook. I can

015really go on and on. But it really does. show so much excitement for us to be there doing things we love to teach them something that we really enjoy and are passionate about and then learning from them as well. So it really makes us very very happy. It fills me with pride to see our kids so motivated to be at school and participate in something that they enjoy. They really are thirsty for that knowledge and we are so happy and proud to be able to provide that for them. So we do this with love for our students and it's not work. It's a joy. So we are very proud to offer these opportunities to our scholars. And thank you for the opportunity. We use a lot of ELOP money. I always laugh with Dr. Aceves,

016like, oh, I'm your number one fan, ELOP. But our students are very much benefiting. So thank you very much. Thank you very much. OK, on to the Whittier Area School Administrators Association recognition. We're going to, yeah. Where am I here? Wait a minute. Where are you? Just so everybody knows, we're kind of going atypically out of order because we want to respect a special event that the Mulberry staff needs to get to. So we're kind of scrambling to rearrange our agenda on the fly. But longevity pins are under special recognition. I just see the way the school administrators. Okay, go ahead. Thank you. Good evening Board of Education, cabinet members, and our community. I am the proud assistant superintendent of human resources and tonight we do have wonderful celebrations and I will start off with

017the first. Today we are going to be celebrating and returning to a very cherished tradition of recognizing years of service for our members. We used to do this decades ago and we are returning to it just because we do appreciate and we do recognize the importance of having consistency for our students. building community and we know that we are the great and strong community that we are because people come to East Whittier and they stay and they stay for a very long time. So we are very proud tonight to be recognizing three special staff members from Mulberry Elementary School who have reached the important milestone of 25 years of service. So let's give them just a big round of applause. What we will be doing is I will be calling each employee to come up

018here to the podium. We do have these custom East Whittier City School District pins. They do have the years of service and they're different colors depending on the milestone that they have reached. And we really thought it would make it really fun to get a nice lanyard just like they do in Disneyland to collect pins because I will tell you it was really amazing to see just how many years of service we have collectively in our school district and some of our employees are getting up to six pins of back. owed pins of service. So I'm super excited. We have these new lanyards coming and they'll get to wear their pins with pride. So I would love to call up Valeria Gutierrez. Valeria Gutierrez with 25 years of service. And then I'm going to have

019our communication coordinator take a picture of you right over there. And then can we have the board come up? Thank you so much. Sure. Congratulations, Valeria. Reaching 25 years of service, let's give a big round of applause to Lisa Liu. Congratulations. And our next honoree, let's give a big round of applause to Kelly Murphy, 25 years. Congratulations, Kelly. Let's give them a big round of applause. I also want to note that we will also be celebrating our other employees who have reached milestones of 10 through 15, even 20 to 35 years at a later date at a more intimate celebration at Mulberry. But let's give them all a big round of applause for all of their years of service. So, Mrs. Salamanca, if your team needs to kind of part ways, this would be a

020good time to be able to do that. But thank you for making time to come to this as well. Madam President, I'd like to excuse myself from the meeting. I need to attend a personal matter. Thank you. OK. The annual review of exhibit 9320, annual calendar of topics for 2025. OK. This is just an information item that we try our best to predict the things that are going to come to the board that are routine matters and this is just presented each year. There are not a lot of modifications to that over the years. Okay. Does anybody have anything to discuss on that? Okay. Pretty standard. On to item 11. I move the recommendation that the Board of Education approve the attached certification of signatures as submitted. Second. So just point of reference, we put

021all of the staff certifications signatures in there. And then Belinda will be gathering the documents for those of you who now hold office that requires signatures on certain documents at the conclusion of this meeting. OK. Any additional discussion? OK, I'll call for the question. Mr. Aparicio? Yes. Mrs. Dabbs? Yes. Mr. Urteaga? Yes. Ms. Hernandez? Yes. And I vote yes. On to item 12. I move the recommendation the Board of Education approve the organizational chart as submitted. I second. Any discussion? I do have a question. Yes. Where did I see this? On the under the directors the expanded learning opportunities program I was looking at the fiscal stabilization and they're going to be they're not going to be directors now they're going to be Yes, it's going to be a coordinator position. Okay, so should that

022still be on there? We have not that we have not taken action on that item The board is still the board is still considering the fiscal stabilization plan as part of the first we'll leave it like this until okay All right any other discussion? Okay, you call for the question. Mrs. Dabbs. Yes, mr. Tiago. Yes, mr. Aparicio. Yes, miss Hernandez. Yes, and I vote yes Okay Now we're going to go to the Whittier Area School Administrative Association recognition. Thank you, so another celebration tonight We are recognizing our amazing community service partners every year the Whittier area school administrators honor community members from all of the districts that make up our Whittier area and We have an interior internal process as well so that we can recognize our own community members so every year our principals

023and their community do recognize a special community member that have provided service and have made a difference in the lives of their students. And so today we have half of the schools coming up to recognize their community service members. So I will be calling up each principal to come up. They will be awarding the plaque to their community service recipient. And then our community coordinator will be taking pictures up here as well. And all of our community service. awardees are then put into a kind of like a bank where they have a description of why they were nominated and as a district we vote for the community service recipient that will be representing us at the Whittier Area School Administrators Breakfast. So we are excited today to start off with Evergreen Elementary School so I

024am going to call Mrs. Torres up here and I would like to start off. By calling, Ms. Luz Sanchez up here to the podium. Let's give her a big round of applause. So I have a couple of words to say regarding each of our community service award recipients. Mrs. Sanchez is not only a gifted second grade teacher, she is a pillar of dedication, passion, and creativity. She has gone above and beyond in her commitment to the betterment of our school and district by serving in various capacities. As the Reflections Chairperson, she ensures that Evergreen students not only participate in the annual reflection event, but that they are well-equipped and used to spark inspiration. She does this by setting up a gallery of student work for all to see. The community eagerly anticipates the annual Reflections

025Gallery, spearheaded by Mrs. Sanchez. Mrs. Sanchez consistently goes above and beyond to support not only her own students, but also the entire student body. She is one of two student council advisors that is always finding creative ways to get all students involved in student body matters such as attendance, pep rallies, and Friday morning roar assemblies. She truly embodies school spirit and excitement. The Evergreen community is here to express their gratitude for Mrs. Sanchez and the incredible impact she has. had on Evergreen School. May her dedication serve as an inspiration for us all, encouraging each of us to strive for excellence and embody the spirit of the WASA Award in our own lives. Let's give her a big round of applause. Thank you. Okay, next up, we would like to recognize East Whittier Middle School, and

026I'll be calling up Mr. Moore. And our recipient is Gloria Castaneda. Let's give her a big round of applause. Gloria Castaneda has been a dedicated PTSA volunteer for the past three years at East Whittier Middle School. She currently serves as the second vice president of EWMS PTSA. Gloria has diligently manned and controlled Chaos, which is the student store, for the past two years. The students absolutely love the different options provided and look forward to it every week. In addition to her active involvement in PTSA, she is also an active supporter of our AVID program, looking to help out in any way possible. Although Gloria prefers to stay in the background, her constant time and effort truly makes a difference with the East Whittier Middle School community. Let's give her a big round of applause. Okay,

027next we have Granada Middle School. I would like to welcome Dr. Pena. And our recipient is Elizabeth Alva. Let's give her a big round of applause. Elizabeth not only supports Granada, but she is a member of the First Bilingual Baptist Church in Pico Rivera, where she serves and volunteers in various capacities, such as Children's Summer Camp, Caring Hands, which is an outreach that ministers to homeless individuals, and Marriage and Family Life Group Ministries. Mrs. Alva is committed to the work she does at Granada and strongly believes in fostering an environment of community, unity, and collaboration within the workplace among students, teachers, and staff. Mrs. Alba has helped various families and their students in connecting them with community-based resources from local organizations to help meet their needs as well as provide technical support as it is

028needed. We are so grateful to have such a wonderful member of our community. Thank you, Elizabeth, for supporting our Matadors. Give them a big round of applause. Congratulations. Next up, I would like to call La Colima Principal, Mrs. Valenzuela. And also the recipient, Jamaica Ross. Let's give her a big round of applause. We are thrilled to recognize Jamaica Ross for her outstanding leadership and dedication to the La Colima community. Ms. Ross has been a part of La Colima for the last eight years. While she started as a volunteer handing out candies for the drive by trunk or treat during the pandemic, she has now expanded her role as La Colima's PTA president. She is a behind-the-scenes force that has a special quality of seeing other people's strengths to accomplish the tasks of supporting or leading

029PTA events. Under her leadership and superb delegation skills, the PTA has launched numerous initiatives that have positively impacted our school. Jamaica has consistently gone above and beyond, from organizing a virtual read-a-thon to picking up candy apples to leading a bubble run. There is nothing I have not seen this woman accomplish. All the while, Ms. Ross has a full-time job as a program specialist. specializing in curriculum and instruction in a local district, and as a single mother, driving her children to and from practice. Thank you, Jamaica Ross, for your unwavering support, vision, and commitment to La Colima. Congratulations on this well-deserved recognition. Next, I would like to recognize Ane. Let me see, I gotta pull up my little cheat sheet, just a second. We have Ane Vardhanal from Leffingwell Elementary. Ana has been a dedicated PTA

030volunteer for the past eight years at Leffingwell. She is always ready, willing, and able to step in and help however needed. She has served in a variety of PTA roles, from room mom to helping with family fun night, assisting with picture day, to now running our leopard spot store. We are so thankful for her constant support. She comes every Friday to support our spots. PBIS program so our students can go shopping with the pot tickets they earn. We are so thankful to have Ane as part of our Leffingwell community. We can always count on her to follow through and do an awesome job with whatever she is supporting. It is our pleasure to honor and recognize Ane as Leffingwell's 2024 Wausau Community Service Award nominee. Congratulations. Next up, we would like to welcome Mulberry Elementary

031School and Mrs. Salamanca will be coming up. We are here to recognize Monique Nguyen. Let's give her a big round of applause. Miss Monique has been a wonderful addition to our Mulberry family. She is not only a parent, but this is her second year as PTA president, and she is doing an amazing job. With a beautiful smile on her face, she facilitates our monthly meetings, organizes events, secures dates for student activities, and coordinates with multiple entities to create wonderful events for our scholars. From the rodeo with live petting zoo to fun family movie nights, Ms. Monique is there to ensure that our families have the best experience possible. She has made PTA events accessible to all of our families by making them free. while still able to raise money through sales of little treats and

032things for the kids. What a combination of heart and money savvy to keep our cool student events funded. She is a joy to work with and a pleasure to have on campus. Mulberry is blessed to have such a wonderful, supportive, calming presence on our campus. Let's give her a big round of applause. And our last school for tonight, let's welcome Mrs. Songer and Ocean View Elementary School. We are here to recognize Ms. Sheila Fuel. Mom, Grammy, Mrs. Fuel, Ms. Sheila. Elliot's grandma, Sheila Fuel, has been serving the children here in Whittier since 1987. Her service has left an indelible mark, raising generations in our community. Since hanging up her director hat at East Whittier, Presbyterian Preschool, she's found much joy in spending time with her four grandchildren, volunteering at Ocean View, working directly with students,

033and supporting teachers. She enters campus daily with a smile and a readiness to tackle helping some of our neediest young students. Every school needs a Ms. Sheila. Ms. Sheila was honored last year by the Ocean View PTA with a continuing service award at our Honorary Service Awards and was an obvious choice to be recognized for her service to generations of students in the Witter community and beyond. Congratulations, Sheila. You deserve this recognition. Let's give all of our recipients a big round of applause. We would not be able to do what we do for our families without their support. So congratulations to all of you. Thank you very much. We will be taking a short five-minute break for right now. We are back in session and we will move on to a special presentation inside EWCSD

034Spotlight. Videos that we wanted to share with the community tonight. The first one is on our BCOS music spotlight. Hi, my name is Loren Hartman. I'm one of the music teachers in the district. Right now we're at Scott Elementary where I just taught a fifth grade class in music. In my lessons I try to create as many opportunities for involvement as possible. We do a lot of sight reading in my classes. I try to do a lot of activities where there's sight reading notes so when they see those violin notes or trumpet notes they'll know how it's going to go before they even start to play it. I also try to do lessons where they're clapping rhythms from the board. It's complicated as I can push them into those rhythms so that when they get

035to middle school nothing will surprise them. I try to include as many different modalities as possible and kids that respond to those modalities. So some of the songs are more tactile, some of the songs more auditory, some of the songs more visual. That's kind of like my MO. trying to get as many involved in whatever their thing is as possible throughout the course of a single class period. That's kind of my idea as I go into each lesson. Then we wanted to highlight BCOSPE as well. My name is Grady Smith. I am one of the two BCOS elementary PE teachers in the East Whittier City School District. This morning we are at Mulberry Elementary School and I am working with third grade PE students. A couple of goals that we have this year for our

036PE programs are to teach all of our students in this district basic team sports, movement skills. We want to really develop our students' locomotor skills and manipulative skills. and to reinforce that exercise is fun. This morning we are working with our third grade students on a continuation of our soccer skills unit. Our students are learning how to dribble and how to pass to each other as well as receiving the ball in the hopes that we will be able to scrimmage in the third week of our soccer. So as we've talked about before, this is just a small little way to continue to highlight the things that are going on across the district and we'll have videos throughout the... REST OF THE YEAR AS WELL. NEW SPEAKER THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NEW SPEAKER FOR PE DOES

037HE GO TO ALL THE SCHOOLS? NEW SPEAKER WE HAVE TWO ROTATING BCLS TEAMS WHERE THEY'RE DIVIDED BETWEEN FIVE SCHOOLS AND FIVE SCHOOLS. SO ONE TEAM OF FOUR GOES TO ONE OF OUR GROUP OF FIVE SCHOOLS AND THE OTHER GROUP OF FOUR GO TO THE OTHER FIVE SCHOOLS. AND WE HAVE AS YOU'VE SEEN BEFORE WE HAVE STEM. We have music, we have art, and we have PE. Then we also have our fourth and fifth grade violin program that kind of works alongside the BCOS team as well. I guess I just need to clarify. So the kids don't have PE, or this is something that's over and above? This is over and above what the teachers already do. That was my question. Thank you. Okay. On to approval of the minutes for the November 18th meeting. I

038move the recommendation that the Board of Education approve the November 18, 2024 Board of Education meeting minutes. Second. Any discussion? I do have something that I wanted to say about the minutes. Let's see here. Find it. Hang on. It was the report by the EWI Missy. It doesn't mention on there, which I think it needs to be mentioned, that she mentioned that we, on the SDRs, she didn't think we're being fully transparent. I think that needs to be on there, mentioned, at least, for the record. We only put the topics for our CSEA union reps as well as our public comments. But the board wants to change the way we do the minutes, but this is the way we've done them. I just think it's important that that be in there, especially that comment. Any

039other discussion we can bring that up at another that can be a discussion and some other time, okay Okay, thank you I'll call for the question Mr. Aparicio. Yes, mrs. Dabbs. I abstain as I was absent on that night Mr. Tiago. Yes, miss Hernandez. Yes, and I vote yes, okay On to board member reports and comments Mr. Tiago, would you like to go first? Sure. I want to thank the Mulberry staff and students for coming, our students for the pledge, and recognize even though they were not here, the two employees of the year, great job they're doing. And to our principal, I know the staff had to leave, but I wanted to say thank you to them for participating today. Congratulations to our service award winners. I know each of us is probably going to

040say something about it, so I'll be short. It's always nice to recognize those, not only the employees that do great things, but also on top of that, the service to our schools, because they do that on their own time, volunteer time, most of them that are volunteer service. So thank you very much for giving back to our schools, our district, and to our community. Congratulations to Ms. Traparizzo and Ms. Correa for having an uncontested election and being able to have the confidence of the... of the area of the district or the area you live in to represent us and I'm sure you will continue to have you do a great job for us here in the district and Look forward to that Most of a few of us attended the actually yeah, we all attended

041parts of the CSCPA Conference it was here in Anaheim So lots of great opportunities to meet to see it here a lot of things that are happening throughout the state School board related so I thank the district for allowing us to participate in that I know that this week is the last week before winter break so we have there's been winter form or winter activities happening the prior weeks but I know this week there's a lot of them that are happening tomorrow morning I'll be over at La Colima and they'll have an event in the morning so I'll be participating not participating I'll be in the audience for that one And then lastly, winter break's coming up. I want to wish everyone a healthy and restful winter break with family and friends, whatever you're celebrating.

042Merry Christmas, Happy Kwanzaa, Hanukkah, all the things that are important to you. And then Happy New Year. Stay safe and try not to let any of the fun festivities keep you away from school students. We return back in January. But we're looking forward to a nice, healthy and restful winter break for everybody. That's it. Thank you. Mr. Aparicio. I just want to say thank you to Caleb and Camila for leading us in the pledge. Also, congrats to Virginia and Cheryl for being Mulberry Employees of the Year. Congratulations and thank you to all the WASA award recipients like Mr. Ortelia mentioned, just volunteering your time. A lot of these, it's a thankless position and a lot of them, there's not even positions for a lot of these people. They just kind of go out there, just

043volunteer their time. And like I said, it's very hectic on top of their regular workload in terms of also their parental duties. They're still kind of doing all this on top of that. So I just want to say thank you very much for your time and everything that you're helping out our students, our community. So once again, just thank you very much for all those recipients. Congrats to Ms. Carrera for being reelected for another four years. I look forward to serving with her for another four more. And then just lastly, like I said, have a great Christmas vacation. Just enjoy. Relax out there with your family and friends. And we definitely look forward to seeing everyone back here in January. So happy new year. Thank you, Mr. Hernandez. Good evening, everyone. Thank you for attending

044tonight. I would like to start by thanking Mulberry students for leading us in the pledge. Although they have left already, I would still like to express my gratitude as an alumni myself of Mulberry. I see the representation and I adore it. Congratulations to everyone recognized from Mulberry, from Acosta District, everyone. Thank you for all your hard work and dedication. Earlier this month, I was lucky enough to attend CSBA's student board member workshop. I learned many skills that I will be implementing into my course of action, and I thank the district for allowing me to attend that. I also had the opportunity to be a part of the Whittier Christmas Parade, which was a wonderful event. That was the first time I've actually been to the parade, and I lived in Whittier. I was born and

045raised in Whittier, so that was really interesting and a very wonderful experience. It was an amazing float. Yes. Very, very extremely decorated, yes. I had the privilege to ride on our district float with other representatives of our district, so a couple other students from across the schools. The parade was very lively and a beautiful example of Witterians being Witterians. So thank you all for listening, and happy holidays. If I can, Madam President, I forgot to add that. I was participating, so Brooke was right there on the front. She was main stage right on the front, so I didn't want to recognize and allow the district to do that. We had a lot of students. It must have been like 15 students. It was a lot. And then the streets was really crowded. I saw Ivan.

046Ivan was real famous right there. And a lot of other employees that we saw sitting on the crowd, but it was a great event, so I forgot to mention that. Thank you, Mr. Urchak. I wasn't able to attend. Thank you for attending. Ms. Kennedy, I do want to congratulate and thank rather Camilla and Caleb for their work leading us in the flag. So it's always a pleasure to have our students do that. I also want to congratulate our classified employee Ms. Bonsai and Certificated Employee Ms. Kalajian, I hope I pronounced her name correctly, for their hard work and for their award they received from Mulberry. And it's always just a pleasure to see the kinds of things that are. staffs are doing at our different schools. I also want to join my colleagues in congratulating

047all our WASA awardees for their hard work, their time, their dedication. As Mr. Aparicio shared, their unsung hero-ness that they have in terms of what they're doing on a day-to-day basis. It's so great to see that award given to them. I also just want to congratulate Mulberry, and I really love their goal and their motto being best in the West. I think it's just so beautiful and so uplifting and so creative, and it's something that the kids can just really wrap their heads around. I think they'll really enjoy that. And also for the 41 clubs. at an elementary school. I think that's just absolutely awesome. I want to mention that back in November I was able to do two visits and I'm going to continue to do that, two site visits with Dr. Patterson. One

048to Hillview Middle School and one to East Whittier Middle School. I want to let you all know there are some amazing things going on at Hillview and at East Whittier. work in the classroom, work with students, very creative, very inspirational, and it just really made my heart soar. Seeing the kinds of things that are going on at both of the schools, it's just very, very exciting. And the work and the time the teachers and staff there, alongside their principal and their parents, are doing to raise up our students every single day was really, really inspirational. I also want to congratulate our BCOS folks in music. Of course, you know that's my passion. It just makes my heart so happy again to see the kinds of work that's going on there with our students and also

049to have physical education at the elementary level done with students one-on-one, if you will, is really something that is so exciting to see when Prop 13 came along decades ago when I was a very young teacher. It took away so many of the things that were so important to our students back then. So it's so great to see the music and the PE program there. I also want to comment on the CSBA conference. I felt it was really intuitive. And I say that because for the first time ever, there were at least three sessions on artificial intelligence, how it's being used, how it's being supported, and the future of it. Now we know the future is here already with the use of artificial intelligence in many ways, shapes, and forms, from WebGBT to ChatGPT to

050all the other different perplexities. And it was really insightful to see. school districts in California using artificial intelligence with their students in a way that you all might not feel, all might not think is very supportive, but it is. And the message that was very important through each and every one of the three presentations, including one by the California School Board Association Task Force, is that using AI is not cheating. And that is the message that our school board association is wanting to make sure that all our districts understand up and down the state. And they really did a great job in making sure that we were able to understand that. So much more to learn, so much more to do, but it was really, really insightful. I also want to take this time to

051congratulate Mr. Alvaricio and Mrs. Carrera for... joining us back on the board. I'm honored to serve with both of them and love the things and their gifts that they bring to us. I also want to end with saying that I want to also wish all of you whatever holiday you celebrate, whether it be Christmas or Kwanzaa or... anything else that you do it in a way that you feel is meaningful and beautiful with your family. And then I want to wish you all a happy, safe, and productive 2025. We are moving into a very interesting time in 2025. Every year is always incredible, and I know that this coming year will be so too. And I say that because of the fact that I serve with a board that is dedicated to each and every

052one of the students that are here. in the East Gator City School District, as well as the teachers, the staff, classified staff, our principals, our directors from the top to the bottom and bottom up. And I just want to thank you so much. Thank you, Mrs. Tapps. And I will congratulate everybody. I won't name everybody. Congratulations, just like my colleague said. I would really like to thank Ms. Carrera, even though she's not here, for serving as our board president. She did a great job, even through everything she's been through and going through. She persevered, and she did a really good job. Anyway, I want to thank her. I've been pretty busy. I went on December 12th. I was at Granada at their concert, and I was telling Dr. Pena, boy, the sixth graders, they sounded

053fantastic. Mr. Silva really has done a great job there. I was really impressed. And then the next day I went to Laurel and Evergreen to their Christmas programs. And then I went that night, I went to Ceres with the Cookies with Santa. Oh my God, I had a blast. I even got on the train. That was way too much fun. It was really, really fun. So this morning I went to Mulberry for their program. And I'm going to go the rest of the week. I have programs I'm going to go try and go to as many as I can. Of course, I'm retired, unlike some of our board members. I'm able to go if they cannot. I also had the privilege of going to the CSBA conference. And I've been going for many years, and

054there hasn't been a year that I haven't learned so much. And this year I went to some interesting, interesting conference sessions on enrollment. They had, you know, one on enrollment growth. They had one where they mentioned internships for counselors and social workers. They talked about housing for your staff, you know, how they're really pushing that in a lot of districts to try and, you know, bring people on board. But here's what they said about ELOP money. They said, don't spend one-time funds on something that eats. So I had to write that down. I went to a session where they talked about emotional intelligence, and they talked about Project Aristotle, and this emotional intelligence one was really very good. The lady that led the session, she was so good, but she said that she had somebody

055sit in the audience and watch her and tell her what she does all the time, and they told her, well, you know, you seem to do this, so she put little Post-its on her screen. you know, to not do what she said she always, so if you guys notice anything that I'm doing all the time, please tell me and I'll put a little post-it up here. But I thought, you know, the sessions were all really good. I also went on, went to one on the AI. And when we got there, the moderator goes, okay, how many of you are really skeptical about AI? Of course, you know, I raised my hand. How many of you are really on board? It was about 50-50. Well, you know, by the end of the session, I was like,

056I'm almost on board because it was really interesting. You know, it was the things he said, you know, close your eyes and I'm going to tell you this. And he goes in three, just three minutes. It took him less than three minutes to come up with what he did. And it was all through AI. I thought that was really amazing. But he had me almost on board, but there's still a few things that they have to figure out. But that was very, very interesting. But anyway, thank you all for being here. I wish everybody happy holidays and peace and love and all that good stuff. OK? Thank you. OK. On to CACA comments. So I don't know whose earrings these are, but they've been here for like two weeks now. So we're hoping that they

057come back for them at some point. So we're not getting rid of them yet. Sorry about that. So my name is Ivan Pastrano. I'm the chapter president here for our classified bargaining unit, CSEA. And so we just want to update the district or the board on a couple things that we're doing. So we did just have our elections. We have two-year terms, and so we just finished our election cycle. So we have our new treasurer is Christine Wan. She works in the business department at the district. Our secretary is Eddie Molina. He works in the business department at the district. Our vice president is Joseph Riley. He works in the business department at the district. And then I'm president again for another two-year term. Don't work in, oh, actually, I do work in the business

058department of the district. So, and then we have a couple more vacancies that we're going to hopefully fill without people from the business department in the district. And then we've been giving updates on site visits that we've been doing. And so we continued again with some site visits. Joseph Riley and Eddie Molina went out again. They had, they got five more. members to sign up for to join CSEA and our bargaining unit. So it brings our total to 80 now since August of this year. We have signed up 80 new members, so we're really proud of that and I think it's a big deal. Looking at the board agenda, there's gosh quite a few new employees that we're bringing on board. So we'll be talking to them shortly. We'll be doing a new employee orientation

059coming up and then if not, we'll be meeting them at their site. So we're really excited about that. It's getting people on board with what's going on in our district and it's really nice to see people wanting to be engaged in what's happening. for our elections that we just had. We had more people come out and participate in the elections. I don't know if it's because we were giving away some stuff, some raffle prizes at our Christmas meeting, but we had so many more people come out and do that and just want to be a part of that process than even for ratifying money in their pocket. And so it's really exciting to see a bunch of new people coming out and getting involved. And so some new board members. And then, you know, just

060moving forward. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Pistrano. EWEA? Hello. Those are pretty. My name is Missy Michaud, and I am representing East Whittier Education Association. And it is very exciting that we only have a few more days before the break. And what's even more exciting is that today marks 99 student contact wake-up days left until the end of the school year. Just saying. I know, right? Okay. I want to mention someone, a CSEA person. She's in the agenda tonight for separation. She's going to be retiring. And her name is Catherine. She's a Hillview employee. And this is year 46 and one half. Yeah. And so it is really exciting. I just want to, you know, write on, you know. So it's great to see that she's going to, she gets to go do something else

061with her world. So that's very exciting. I just wanted to mention her. 46 and a half years. I mean most of you guys aren't even that old. So that's pretty pretty cool. Excuse me. What does she do? She's Hillview and she's a IA4. I saw that. I know right. Okay. A few things. Last time I was up I mentioned about sports and how we really do think it's important to have standards that the kids must meet in order to compete. And quite a few folks were a little bent because a comment was made that said they don't want to do that because they think teachers would eliminate kids just to be spiteful or something. But I know that East Whittier hires people with much greater character than that. And having qualifications to play sports is

062something that really will prepare a student for the 21st century. When you're in high school, if you don't make grades, you don't get to play. And we have kids who we want to teach that. We want to do that. And we have kids that were like, dude, come on, you got to bring it in. And they will come in and take care of it. They want us to tell them to. And we're not doing that. And I think we're doing them tremendous disservice when they get up into high school. I'm going to bring back this writing program. Boo. It's very difficult. It's difficult for teachers. It's difficult for kids. Freaks a lot of kids out because they have to write with markers, which I know they don't have to, but we just have to get

063the conversation across. We're uncomfortable with a lot of it because of middle school kids laying on the carpet together in front of the classroom. Okay, sitting on the carpet together. We don't have a dress code anymore. It is very uncomfortable with the things that kids are allowed to wear to school now. They come in their jammies. Straps don't matter anymore. It doesn't matter. You know, the girls are often hanging out. And we're talking with little boys and they're just like, and they're having a hard time with this too. A lot of our teachers are having a very difficult time with this. It's putting people into situations where they're uncomfortable and our people should not have to feel that way when they are at school working. And dress code was for modesty. Dress code wasn't to...

064pick on somebody. Dress code was to keep everybody in the same place. We got kids to school. They were dressed for school. They had the mindset and now there is no work mindset anymore. Everything's just a big game and we just it's these are little things that are undermining what we're trying to do as teachers. So, okay. Then our nurses we have fantastic nurses we only have three for the entire district and Removing nurses letting nurses go or even considering that an RN and an LVN do the same stuff we vehemently disagree and to put them on the stabilization plan to remove them, I think is premature. I think it's not safe. And we would really like to arrange some dinners with you all so that the nurses could have a conversation with you and

065let you know why they matter. And I think that's what I got today. Happy New Year, everybody. Thank you, Ms. Michelle. On to superintendent comments. I just wanted to say that, you know, we appreciate everybody and their hard work and everything that they do to take care of our kids and our staff and our community and wish everybody a wonderful holiday season. Thank you, Dr. Patterson. Okay, on to citizen communication. We have any? Hi, dear board member, everyone. Good evening. My name is Connie Lee. I am the district nurse. Here for eight years and I'm here to represent the concern of our health service team about the stabilization plan to cut the credential nurses from three to one and those two are my colleague. So early this month we were told there is no need

066to retain all three school nurses because the LVN can serve a similar role. I would like to emphasize how critical school nurses are and our responsibility and expertise cannot be truly replicated by LVNs. For instance, LVN cannot, for California educational, to review medical order for medication or medical procedure. As of today, we have over 500 students receive medication in our school district. And only three nurses oversee the well-being of the student. So divide equally, we each watch over 166 students on a daily basis. And to reduce the number of credential school nurses to one single nurse, cover 500 students with medication is neither practical or safe. Additionally, credential school nurses are responsible to create individualized health care plan for students both for general and special education. At this time, we have over 90 care plans

067we offer to students. With each student, we not just only create a plan, we also review and train the staff on the care plan of their students. And this care plan is just the start. So we also cover IEP health assessment, something that LVN cannot conduct. So, so far this year, we have 250 IEP health assessments. So pretty much equal 50 assessments per month we have a request. And other than planning, we also attend a meeting to make sure students with a disability receive appropriate health services. And also we support students with 504 accommodation plan, mental health plan. So as a mandate by the state our school district conduct yearly hearing and vision screening which LVN cannot do hearing screening and this year alone we have screened over 3,500 students. So pretty much each one

068of us have screened over a thousand students and right now it's only December. So there are so many responsibilities that our credential school nurse can fulfill. can only fulfill. I'm not able to mention all of them because of lack of time, but it is my belief that health care, the credentialed school nurses serve as a very vital bridge between school, family, and health care providers. So we are here to support the students so they can pursue their education in good health. So I would like to pose a question to a board member and everyone. Is it safe to just have one credential school nurse to cover the various health needs over 7,800 students in a very tiny matter with a very small support? So that's my message for you today. Thank you. Good evening, members

069of the school board, EWCST staff, and community members. My name is Diamela Kerubin, and I'm a health clerk at Laurel Elementary School for the past eight years. I'm also here with my colleagues. I stand before you today as a concerned member of this community speaking on behalf of students, parents, and staff in our district. As you are aware, the proposed budget cuts including reducing our team of nurses from three to one with the intention of having just one registered nurse oversee all the schools. I am here pleading with you to reconsider this decision as the safety and well-being of our children must be our top priority. Credential school nurses provide specialized care and expertise. that go beyond the scope of LVNs. This role is crucial in maintaining a safe and healthy school environment as they

070are trained to assess and treat various health issues from chronic conditions to emergencies. They are the only ones that are credentialed to develop the IEP health assessments for students with medical needs, ensuring they receive necessary support to thrive both academically and socially. We understand the challenges of balancing the budget, but the decision to make To let go of two nurses is not one that should be made lightly. Having one nurse responsible for 13 schools is simply unsafe. It is impossible for a single nurse to adequately address the health and medical needs of 7,800 students spread across multiple campuses. In addition to dual care, district nurses oversee LVNs and health clerks at each campus and provide critical staff. training and ensure the entire school team is prepared to respond to health crises. With one nurse covering

07113 schools, it has become nearly impossible to properly train staff. It can increase risk for our students without adequate nursing coverage. We risk compromising students' health and most concerning, we risk lives. We urge the school board to consider the long-term consequences of reducing our nurse staff. Cutting nurses may save money in the short term, but it could lead to higher costs in the future in terms of student safety and potential legal and financial ramifications of not providing adequate health service. We ask you to find other solutions to balance the budget that do not compromise the safety of our children. Our district nurses are essential to ensuring that every child has a safe, healthy learning environment. Please keep our district nurses in our schools. Thank you. Good evening board members. My name is Rick Bustamante. I

072am a parent over at Laurel Elementary. I just want to voice my concern for the budget cuts for the nurses. It's kind of a no-brainer. I mean, and I want to thank you, Dr. Patterson, for addressing the front gate issue previous for me. But again, my thing is putting our children's well-being and safety behind budget. Mean I get budgets or budgets, but I'm sure there are other programs that you can reallocate monies from Instead of putting our the jeopardy our children's safety and well-being in jeopardy like The ladies had spoken earlier one nurse for over 7,000 students that's a lot of work and If someone needs something at one school and she's at another school That's not gonna be not a good issue and it's a lawsuit. I'm sure so you want to talk about

073budget so again Madam President congratulations, and I just want to pray that and hope that you guys Look at other programs to reallocate monies from and put our the our children's safety and well-being and make that a priority as opposed to other programs Thank you My name is Laura Sullivan. I'm a fourth grade teacher in the district that last month's board meeting I spoke to you about my concerns about our newly adopted writing program units of study as well as our district's slow supportive structured literacy And I want to be clear that structured literacy is different from balanced literacy Which is the philosophy that our district embraces now? Balanced literacy is essentially whole language with some phonics sprinkled in but it's not in an explicit or systematic way. Structured literacy is reading instruction in an

074explicit and systematic way that emphasizes phonics. I wanted to update you on something that happened since the last board meeting. On December 4, a class action lawsuit was filed against Lucy Calkins, Heinemann Publishing, the Board of Trustees at Teachers College at Columbia University, and others for claiming that units of study and reading for ignoring research into more effective practices and using shoddy studies to support their own work. Although the lawsuit is for units of study in reading and what we have adopted is units of study in writing, it should be noted that units of study in writing, our new program utilizes the same methodology as the reading program and was created and sold by the same people being sued. This lawsuit is the first of its kind and was filed by two families of dyslexic

075students who had to seek and pay for outside tutoring to teach their children to read. As a mother of two dyslexic students myself, I know these parents' struggles all too well. I, too, had to pay thousands of dollars for my children to be taught to read by a tutor who taught with a structured literacy program. The balanced literacy program we offer in our district is not sufficient to teach all students to read. I also signed myself up for the reading course that I was speaking with you about last time. It's LACO's Getting Reading Right. and I shared it with you last month. Lo and behold, our intervention specialists are also taking this course, as well as at least one person from the district office. It's great that they're taking this course, but it's not sufficient.

076This course is intended for Tier 1 teachers. This is a way of teaching reading that is Tier 1. That's all of our students. Our Tier 2 and Tier 3 people are being sent there to get trained, but our Tier 1 teachers are the ones that need to be trained. Whether that means bringing LACO onto our campuses to provide training next year or paying for teachers to take this course through Zoom, which is what I'm doing now, we need to be educating our teachers on the science of reading and structured literacy as soon as possible. Next year, the state is requiring us to screen all kinder and first grade students for dyslexia. Many administrators and teachers have no idea what to do with that information once they have it. If they had been trained in the

077science of reading and structured literacy, they would know exactly what to do and how to do it in a general education environment so that the kids who are struggling to read are able to stay in the least restrictive environment. The science is there and has been there for more than two decades. We just need the training. And I want to be clear that the... Okay. Any more? Okay. Thank you all. We're on to discussion items. I need, let's see here. I need a motion. I move the recommendation that the Board of Education approve the agreement with Foresight Planning and Development for Facilities Master Planning Services. I second. Any discussion? I have a first and a second. Any discussion? Do we have any? This is just the first step in our process to be able to

078go through planning for Measure C project. So it's $61,000 and what are they doing? It is a facilities master plan like we did about five or six years ago. But the requirement is to have a new updated facilities master plan in order to determine what the priorities are across the district. So once this plan is finalized, we will be then bringing it back to the board in order to talk about the projects that we recommend as a staff. So this is something that you had to hire somebody for. It could not be done. It couldn't be done internally. Okay. Is the bond, I know that's probably a component that has this in there, but are we required to follow everything that they recommend? No, this is just our plan, but in order to be able

079to be in line for Prop 2 money, we have to have an update. Okay. I just want to make sure if they miss something, we still can add stuff. The board can make whatever decision the board wants to as long as it's in alignment with the bond language. I got you. Okay. Dr. Patterson, a question. Will this group be taking into account, and I know this is a word people probably don't want to hear, but I just have to say it, that potential tariffs and increasing tariffs are going to increase? Everything from drywall to so this is not that's not the scope of this work the scope of this work is to identify a project which and when we Not what cost would be just what product is to identify all the projects that go

080on because a facility's master plan is a multi-year document multi-year document that would not necessarily factor in all the different changing process prices in the market great. Thanks for clarifying. How long do we Are they going to take to present? We were going to have a Measure C presentation today, but we did decide to push it to January. So once we have that presentation, we'll be able to kind of give you like the idea around what all of those steps are. But with the board passing this, we do believe that we'd be in a position to be able to take a resolution to the board to. to make a resolution to actually go out and sell the bond money the bond and then in March potentially start to have this conversation about what staff is

081recommending for the the Duration of the bond to be able to you know start doing potentially some work in the summer And then talking about what long-term projects would be Thank you Okay, any other discussion? Okay, I'll call for the question mr. Aparicio. Yes, mr. Nandez. Yes, this is Dabbs. Yes. I vote. Yes. Mr. Tiago. Yes, it passes for zero on to item two I move the approval the first interim report for fiscal year 2024 2025 and the presentation My second, okay. I have a person a second do we have So we actually have the you have a presentation on this or not we have a presentation. Okay. All right So this is a kind of a multifaceted presentation We are going to be talking about the updated fiscal stabilization plan and then move into

082what the actual item is Which is the first interim budget? So we just wanted to kind of point out, like we've been, so 95% of the information that you are going to see in these slides are things that we've shared over multiple board meetings. So there really is not anything that should be a surprise, but we do have a couple of additional items that we have looked at. Right now, really what we're looking at in the unrestricted MYP is about a $4.6 million deficit when we're in the third out year in 26-27. So that's one of those situations when you, this is what it looks like in the restricted side. And then when you combine them, our overall deficit is $7.2 million. Right now, what we are focusing on is that $4.6 million that's in

083our unrestricted funds because we have greater flexibility. As you know, we've shared this, and those of you who have been president recently or in the past recognize that we've had a fiscal stabilization plan where we submit to LACO every year, and they are basically required to give us their feedback. you know, recommended and say that, you know, we are definitely on the right track to having the fiscal stabilization plan, but we still need to continue addressing the deficits that we have. And now remember, these numbers don't necessarily match because this was submitted back during our budget adoption. So that's why it says $5.3 million over three years there. Basically, some of the things that have staved off, some of those cuts that were a little bit more. I mean, $4.6 million is dire, but we

084have been very intentional with increasing and making sure that all of our students who are considered unduplicated have been counted. So you can see that at that 65% that we currently lay in, that has helped us stave off, as has the 265 students who are in our TK program as well. So even though we have declining enrollment, the addition of TK has really helped, as well as the increase of that 65% of having unduplicated students, which does generate more funding. These are things that we, the first three bullets there are the first three pieces during fiscal year 25-26, which means these changes are going to be made upcoming. So those reallocated positions are ways in which, as one of the presenters had mentioned, or the public comments had mentioned, we have been very intentional about

085moving funds in order to cover a variety of different pieces to be able to support the reduction of that. unrestricted and restricted budget side so those positions right there from the five psychologists all the way down to the six health clerks those positions are not being eliminated we were just able to find alternative funding sources to be able to support those positions the next four bullets are things that are positions that we had either on that list before or those are positions that we had already indicated that those were specific positions hired for a specific amount of time. And then the pieces that were not included in the June 10th budget. So everything above was in the June 10th budget. So the seven intensive behavior assistance, which were funded out of the learning block recovery

086grant, that funding has basically expired because we spent all that money as well. When we did talk to our Title I principals, We did give them the option of finding a way to use their title funds to be able to keep that service. So those are going to stay. Those positions will be staying at both Laurel and Orcharddale. We are recommending one district nurse be reduced in 25-26. We've already spoken to our six instructional coaches at the district office, and we will be... reducing those services by three. And then we currently have two homeschool teachers and we are recommending to reduce that by one teacher. As we look to the next 26-27, which would be a year later, not next year, we are still reallocating four school psychologists. Six health clerks would remain in the

087Medi-Cal funding as well as one district nurse. But based upon the information that we have shared in the previous slides to address our structural deficit, we still are going to need to be able to have... conversation around positions that could potentially be cut. So we are not eliminating two nurses as was mentioned today. It is one right now in 2526. One of the things that we are talking about is in 2627 and all of these are potential items as well as the next page. So I want to be clear. So these are all things that are out there for discussion. Some of these things are going to be influenced by the governor's January proposal. So these are all things that we still need to look at. So some of the things that we are talking

088about is one additional district nurse. We are talking about aligning our staffing to our enrollment. We share our class sizes with our board. So that is one of the things. We are also analyzing with CSCA our IA2s, our 2s, 3s, and our 3s and 4s and substitute coverage. You know, you've heard a lot about swing and how much swing costs and whether or not we feel that those vacancies being provided by... A substitute who's not part of our district is sometimes received differently. And then we are also looking at the 19 current vacancies that we already have with our IAs, 3s, and 4s. And then quite frankly, you know, we right now, we were supposed to or had slated at least three to five of our ELA intervention specialists and instructional assistants to be returned

089to the classroom in 2526. Working with our team we were able to kind of shift some funds to keep those positions but when you're looking at the the instructional assistant and the ALA intervention specialist that's about 190,000. per site for those services. As you recall, last year at this time was when we were talking about the math intervention specialist going back into the classroom. Now we're having the conversation about the ELA intervention specialists as well, which could be a staggered of going anywhere between one to 10 people. We also have some promising opportunities where we are applying for community schools grant. which could give us the opportunity to kind of be creative and rewrite some of these job descriptions and what they do to be able to fund them through the school community grant. But

090right now, our intention is to have conversations with principals, to look at data, to look at needs, and then talk about in 26-27, so after this next school year, which schools... would be least impacted. Every school would be impacted by any of these changes, but we are talking about, you know, these positions have been saved for one more year, and now a second year. So these are also other positions that we just wanted to be able to have, you know, clarity and transparency around. These are also additional considerations that we could look at in order to Find savings to keep some other positions. So we would have three more instructional coaches at the district office. We have a variety of program specialists who support our unduplicated students, our foster youth, our homeless youth. We have

091five special ed support program specialists, and you can read all of these. But these are all things that as we come back and have to look at what will be. POSSIBLE CONSIDERATIONS AS WE BUILD OUT THE BUDGET FOR 26-27 OF CONSIDERATIONS OF LOOKING AT HOW WE ARE GOING TO KIND OF ADDRESS THAT $4.6 MILLION DEFICIT. BUT THESE ARE ALL POSITIONS, INCLUDING THE ONES THAT I MENTIONED ON THE PREVIOUS SLIDE, THAT WE WOULD BE ABLE TO START TO ADDRESS THAT $4.6 MILLION DEFICIT. And then on the classified side, there would be the nine intervention specialists that are IAs at the elementary schools as well. We just wanted to point out that we are going to be having conversations about our instructional assistance with CSCA to talk about other creative ways to be able to find ways

092to make sure that we don't have the vacancies that we have to have the appropriate staffing in our schools to have those conversations. But one of the things that we've talked about and Mrs. Chacon-Kennedy has gone to Washington to advocate for adequate funding under ID. But as you can see from we just wanted to share that you know each year We are spending right now last year We spent sixteen point nine million dollars on top of the nine point two that we were given by either the state or the the federal government for special education so were the state or the federal government to appropriately fund us at that ID a mark of 40% is what they had talked about, which would be the funding? Yeah. Yeah. But even if we got even close to

093that, that would be a significant change. So that's why the advocacy at CSBA and at NSBA and at these coast-to-coast legislative opportunities are so important, because even a fraction, even expediting even a fraction of that money would help us significantly with that general fund contribution. And then just another piece of, you know, we do have a number of three, IA3s and IA4s, and we have 59 one-on-one aides right now. So part of that is conversation about how do we support students, how do we support staff, and then looking at ways in which we are going to potentially address some of the concerns that we do have. When we cannot hire these services on that right-hand side, whether it's speech and language pathologists or psychologists or OT, that's the dollar amount that we're spending out there

094to be able to get contracted services from people that we can't hire internally. A lot of districts have been creative in the ways that they attract. If you recall back in the day when they were trying to hire math and science teachers at a greater clip, they were providing signing bonuses, different ways to incentivize people to take on positions that are a little bit more difficult for districts to hire. So those are just pieces that we are continuing to have conversations about. Are there other creative ways that we can attract people to positions that are a little bit more difficult to hire on the staff side? And then, you know, a lot of our money is spent on extra work agreements, and these are some of the different ways in which extra work agreements are

095done. So those are just things that we're going to have to kind of start tackling. Are there ways that we, this is another way of us to potentially recoup and save money towards that $4.6 million deficit. So that's just kind of a recap of where we were in the different items that we had posed with regard to the fiscal stabilization plan and trying to get to that point where we need to realize, you know, $4.6 million over the next three years. And then Ms. Sorrell is going to jump into our first interim report. But does anybody have any questions about any of that before she moves on to the riveting presentation on first interim? I do. With... the new incoming administration stating that there's going to be dissolving of this and cutting of that. How

096soon will that, if it's done, how soon would that potentially affect us in terms of state? in the county, et cetera? The biggest impact is going to be what they're going to potentially do with the National School Lunch Program, potentially, as well as what they could potentially do with Title I funding. But right now, everything is just kind of waiting to see what the governor is going to predict and what comes out of the Legislative Analyst's Office and those different entities that are kind of trying to make that same prediction. So we really don't know right now. You know, but I even went to a session that was led by school services, and they're saying we don't know what's going to happen. So there's a lot of conjecture out there, so I don't want to

097jump into conjecture. So, you know, it's only a month away for the governor's proposal, so we'll see what that looks like and see if. that's maybe the $4.6 million is worse. You know, maybe it's better. So they seem to be going down the categorical road a lot more recently of one-time funds to be able to augment different things. So we'll know more, you know, in January. And we do have a presentation at one of our February board meetings to kind of talk through. What the implications are for the governor's initial proposal? Thank you. Dr. Patterson, I have a question. So this plan is kind of a snapshot or our yearly three-year plan that and it's just more of an explanation for the public just in case they're unaware. It's a three-year plan that if the

098budget, like you said, comes back better, comes back hopefully better, but right now we have to project out some times of how we're going to stabilize. But there might be times where, yes, it's going to be true what's going to happen because the budget, the monies are not there. There's been some years where it's come back positive and not making any promises, but that's why these numbers have to plan out because it's a three-year requirement that we have to... Stabilize that and it's four point six million. So that's a lot of money They don't want it compounding if we don't have a plan in place. This will be compounded in one year. We just got to make massive changes and so You know, we're that's why we're advocating and trying to get as much support

099and From the governor's from all the entities that can support the plans of what we're doing So it's it's it's an unfortunate part of of the budget issues like we're dealing with right now, but we're hoping for the best. But it's just a plan that we placed so we actually have a plan if what the numbers were projected to come out are true that we have to have a plan. So right now it's early and we're looking at what we can do, but there's still opportunities, but there has to be a lot of things that have to fall in place. And that's what we're hoping for. And I just want to add to Mr. Tiago's statements. You know, with all due respect to districts around us, there are districts around us that had to close

100schools. There are districts around us that went from 3,000 students out of high school, now they have 800 students out of high school. So I really want to applaud the work that Mrs. Sorrell does, the work that you're doing, Dr. Patterson, and the way that our board has come together because there's so much tension and so much divisiveness going on. in one particular district where four schools were closed. I have a very good friend that is a teacher there and it's not ending, it's continuing. So I really have to echo Mr. Urtiaga's statements that we are doing our best to ensure stabilization in our district and it could be a whole, whole lot worse. So thank you. On that positive note, I'm going to turn it over to Ms. Serret. I always get to bring

101the sunshine. So this is just a quick overview. The second interim, as you mentioned, we're updating 24-25 and then projecting 25-26 and 26-27. All the information that you're looking at is when the books were closed October 31st. And as you all know, we come to you each meeting if there are any budget adjustments that need to be made. If we find a change in revenue, if we find a change in expense, we bring it at each meeting so we don't have large swings throughout the year. And we need to have everything into LACO by December 15th, so we're on track for that. We do submit early so they can review it and give us feedback, just to make that process go a little bit faster. So there are three certifications for anyone's interim process, positive,

102qualified, and negative. We are very happy to say that, again, we have a positive certification. This is just showing you an overview in a pie chart format of our revenue. Everything up there is in percentages. LCFF, which is our state revenue, is $98.2 million. The federal is only $4.6 million. State is $10.7 million, and local is $10.6. The next one is our pie chart, again, of expenses. So if we look at certificated classified benefits altogether, that's about 81% of our budget, which is oftentimes when we talk about reductions that need to be made, they're in the area of staffing because it's 81% of the budget. That's 113 million. Supplies are 6.3 million, and services are $18 million. So the next couple slides we're going to walk through are all the assumptions that are a component

103of the budget that we're putting in front of you. So when we presented the budget to you in June, we could not include the salary increases because we haven't settled. So the first interim does reflect the 3.5% salary increase as well as the 2% off schedule. So that's included here. Also, there's been an increase, as Mark mentioned earlier, in the UPP. There's been a concentrated effort by several people to really get that up because we're going to... you know, about $700,000 more by that increase in the UPP. We are using a 94.3% ADA on our enrollment, and that's based on our actuals for the end of 23-24. And then we wanted to also share that enrollment has declined in 23-24 from 7,700 to 7,500, which is a decrease of 241 students. Our COLA rates that

104are in the budget are 1.0, 2.9, and 3.0. That's based on the information that we have now. When we go to the governor's update in January, those could change based on the meetings I've been in. It doesn't sound like they will, but if they will, we'll push those through and bring that back. One thing to keep in mind is we've talked about open positions. If we have an open position, we have to include it in the budget because that's a position that we want to have filled and expect to have filled. So let's say we have 10 positions that still aren't filled at first interim. Then we reduce the budget because they haven't been here, you know, from July through now. And then we reevaluate that again at the second interim. But we do have

105to include those in the budget. And one of the pieces was we had not always taken those out previously prior to Ms. Sorrell, so you would see some pretty significant... swings between what was at the end of the year as we close things out which you know could be interpreted in different ways so I did want to commend this Sorrell on that piece to be able to go through and mr. Pina to kind of go through and chew up our budgets a little bit more timely than we have possibly done we have a great accounting and budget team you guys should be really happy they're really good The last little part is we have 52 general fund vacancies, and those are the components there. So if you add that up together, you know, you've got

106like $700,000, $800,000 that are in the budget that may or may not be spent. So any that weren't filled through now we've adjusted, and then we'll work with HR. If they're still not filled and we do our next report to you, we'll adjust those again. This one is an action item. Okay. Any other discussion? Yeah, one question just that's more probably more for HR so the the 52 vacancies is just because There's no candidates. There's is it I mean, that's what it is Could you elaborate on what you and mrs. Clark did over the last couple of months with your speed dating? We understand we have a different generation of people in the workforce now. So for educators, usually the platform has been EdJoint, which works really well with certificated positions. However, we are noticing

107that for classified positions, a lot of these employees are going to other platforms. So we have been working with Indeed, and that has been a very successful strategy for us, just because it's an easier way to put your information on the platform. You don't have to upload a resume and do a complete application. It's just more streamlined. So we have been using Indeed and have been using kind of group hiring. So we will set dates where we are hiring specifically for instructional aid. you know, three and fours. And it really is kind of like a five answer interview. We line them up, they come in. And then what we do is, because we have a variety of openings, we try to place them based on their experience and also in their needs. And that has

108been really successful. The other, but the other thing is just, it is one of those positions where it, you know, people do burn out. Also, it's a transitional position. So people are usually working. towards a higher position or they're going to school. So I think all those things do impact. And we are working together with CSEA just to try to brainstorm some ideas of how we can make our positions more attractive and then also what would help with the retention of employees. But I think part of that as classified employees, we all know if your goal is to be a teacher or it's going to be temporary because you're working towards that. You're trying to gain experience or try to figure out if that's where you want to stay. Thank you. And when I went

109to the conference last couple weeks ago, they did talk about that, about retaining employees. They talked about affordable housing to try and keep your employees there, internships, things like that. And so a lot of districts are going through the same thing. Anybody else have anything? Marianne, is it true that the budget changes daily? Because I heard that at CSPA. The budget changes daily. Oh, daily. Wow. It's like. Okay, anything else anybody okay? I'll call for the question mrs. Dabbs. Yes, mr. Tiago. Yes. I vote yes, mr. Felicio. Yes, mr. Nandis. Yes, it passes world Item three a public hearing Yes, I will open the meeting at 754 there anybody that wishes to speak to this item it is Public hearing resolution number 10-24-25, annual accounting of developer fees. So tell me about this. Ms. Sorrell,

110could you give just a brief little synopsis of what it does to increase our developer fees? Absolutely. So whenever there's development done within the city limits, depending on how many square feet they add, what type of building it is, the district receives money for that. Those monies can be used for anything that's a new program. So we'll have some good use for it with the TK. I heard there was some talk of them wanting to lower what we get. Actually, we're having a study done to bring back to you that we're expecting actually an increase. Oh, good. And I want to get it into you. There's a couple of projects that are on the books for Whittier. So we'll get those in before they have to pay their fees. Okay, great. Anything else? Okay, we

111will close this at... 755 hey on to item 4 I'm with the recommendation at the Board of Education and DOP resolution number 10-24 25 annual accounting of developer fees for the 2023-2024 FY in the following fund fund 25 capital facilities account fund as submitted second I Have a first in a second any discussion Anything? OK. Call for the question. Mr. Aparicio? Yes. Ms. Hernandez? Yes. Mrs. Dabbs? Yes. Mr. Piaga? And I vote yes. Passes 4-0. OK. On to consent items. Is there anybody that wishes to remove anything from the agenda? So I need a motion. OK. So I move that the Board of Education approve consent agenda items j3 through j9 second any discussion I had a question on one. Let me see if I can find it The one for where you're for Downey

112where you're it's for the depth. Are we paying Downey or deaf students from our district? Okay, right, right, right, right, right, right, okay That's all I that's all I had anybody else have anything no no I'm just glad that you know we talked about it and I know we had a presentation regarding the security cameras moving forward with that and so but money well spent for that and I also have to say that I did I did talk to dr. Patterson about the hill view Employee Catherine's is it still still I don't know how to say it anyway 46 and a half years Who is this person? I can't believe, I mean, that's a long time. Wow, that's amazing. And she's finally retiring. Wow, that is amazing. She must have started when she was 10.

113Anyway, congratulations on that. Okay, anybody else have anything to add? Okay, I'll call for the question mrs. Dabbs. Yes, I vote yes, mr. Aparicio. Yes, mr. Hernandez. Yes, mr. Tiago. Yes, okay passes So our next board meeting is January 13th. I need a motion to adjourn. I so move to adjourn this meeting a second I have a first and a second. Any closing comments, Mr. Ortega? Happy holidays and Merry Christmas and stay safe. Ms. Japs? I want to do the same, wishing everybody a great holiday time. I hope that you'll have a chance to rest and enjoy time with your family. Ms. Hernandez? Like the previous two, happy holidays, stay safe. And students, we can hold it out these last couple days. Mr. Aparicio? Same thing. Happy holidays to everyone. Ditto happy holidays everybody rest

114up and have fun Okay, we are adjourned. Oh I'm sorry. I have two steps. Yes, mr. Arteaga. Yes. I vote yes. Mr. Aparicio. Yes. Miss Hernandez We are adjourned at 7 58

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.