CorpusRecord 157321

School Board Business Meeting 12/05/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Scarborough Maine Public Schools
Date
2024-12-06
Location
Cumberland County, ME
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,808 words · about 44 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening and welcome to the Scarborough Board of Education business meeting. The date is Thursday, December 5th, 2024. Can we call the attendance please Ray? Yes. Ms. Callagher? Here. Ms. Leon? Here. Ms. Lindstrom? Here. Ms. Peterson? Here. Mr. Rockensire? Here. Ms. Tarpenian? Here. Ms. Tarpenie-Huff? Here. Ms. Ledger? Here. Ms. Roskima? Awesome. Thank you. Would everyone please join me for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Agenda item 4.0 are adjustments to the agenda. Are there any adjustments this evening? No, there are none. Agenda item 5.0 are the Oak Hill Players White Christmas Ensemble recognition. So would you, I'm sorry. Oh, who are we, who is, I don't

002see. Oh, there. Come on up. Yes, please. I couldn't see you. I apologize. So this is Jonathan Meal. He's the director. So we can start with a number called Unhappy. And then we'll have a number by Noel Gagel and Jeremiah, say it. What? Jeremiah. Violet. Violet, I knew that. And then we'll have an ensemble number by Christmas. And then the final one will be, I get one more. So there you are. And this is Mrs. Emma, our wonderful musical director. There we go. Okay. What care I who makes the laws of a nation that those will take care of its rights and what care I who cares for the world's affairs as long as I can speak. It's popular song. We sing a funny song with crazy words that roll along. And if my song

003can start you laughing, I'm happy, happy. Let me sing a sad refrain of broken hearts that loved in vain. And if my song can start you crying, I'm happy. Let me go down blue. My song, reach your shoe and start a new path for me. I'm happy. Let me sing of Dixie's charms, of Swanee's shore and mother's arms. And if my song can make you homesick, I'm happy. Let me prove the low down blues to lift you out of your seat. If my song can reach your shoes and see you tap in your feet, I'm happy. Let me sing a pixie's charms, a swan is sure in a mother's arms. And if my song... can make you homesick, can start you laughing, can start you crying. Welcome to provide context if you'd like. She like

004left. I thought you were going to say that. Martha, who just sang that song, misheard from a conversation she was overhearing on the phone, and she thought that Bob was trying to sell the Christmas Inn. And so I got mad at him, and I left for New York to do a solo engagement. But then, really, he didn't want to sell it, and so he came to see me. I also apologize because I'm kind of sick right now. Thank you for being here. I'm back on the shelf and I'm blaming myself but it's you. I didn't do right by me as they say. Tell you. How high is the sky? How high today? Why they have you? spring cold will do. Or I could travel, tell me where you go. How far is the journey? Dear,

005if I ever lost you, how much would I grow? How deep is the ocean? How high is the sky? Don't leave yet. Don't leave yet. Does anybody want to say anything? Yes, please. I just want to say I saw the performance three times. And that sounds crazy, but I was blown away every time. It was better every time. You guys just are so amazing. I think there's like three board members crying right now. Anyway, I think I just want you to know that, you know, I brought my little kids and they were just totally enamored. You guys. You guys have more influence than you think. And I think like everybody in my house is walking around saying, oh yeah. Anyway, you guys, you guys are just amazing. And every time I see one of these

006performances, I'm just, I'm just absolutely blown away. So thank you so much for coming tonight. I thought you guys did a fantastic job. I had chills from listening to all of you guys sing. And I do this thing where when you guys are all singing together, I try to, if I can match the voice with whoever is singing. But you guys just harmonize really, really well. And you guys are very brave. because I don't even like having these cameras on me. But you guys stand up there like nothing and just sing your heart out. And I think it's wonderful. So good job, guys. Thank you. I will just say also when I'm sick, I sound just like you. That is exactly how I sound. I also saw, I saw your second to last play. And

007I was really struck when I, or musical, I was really struck when I was reading through the program, how many of you are still young? Like you're not in your senior year, right? And so it's really, really incredible the amount of. the range you have and the vocal variety you have and the way that you can stand in this room. And I didn't even realize we had acoustics this good in this building. It's just, you are incredible. You are absolutely incredible and you should be so proud of yourselves. And to Jillian's point, I did also see a lot of young kids in the crowd watching you. And I, it was one of those times where I was at first, I wondered if it was the story was going to. resonate with them because, you know,

008it is an older story. Right. And, um, I personally love it, but also I'm, um, I wondered what they would think, but everybody was totally the entire time eyes glued on you the entire. show. And so there is a lot of power in that, in recognizing that younger kids are looking at you and looking at you as role models and looking at you and thinking, hey, I can do this too one day, maybe, right? And there's a lot of power in that. So I hope you recognize that. And I hope you realize how meaningful this is for everyone in Scarborough, the older generation, the younger generation, and everybody in between. So thank you so much for all you do. And I hope we can make this an annual thing because this was incredible. Yeah, I

009just can't say enough to thank all of you for being here tonight. I know that after I saw the show, I had reached out to Mr. Meal and Mrs. Jensen to see if this might be possible. And it was just really exciting how it all came together. I think I pitched this performance and your musical. at every meeting that I've been at for the past month. So hopefully that increased your ticket sales. But again, I just have so much pride when I listen to all of you because these, when we talk about creating opportunities for students and providing support for a variety of programs and pathways for our students, this is a great example of that. So thank you all for everything that you've done. Thank you. Do we want to give this a minute

010to allow them to? You're welcome to stay if you would like to hear the rest of our board meeting. Oh, I'm sorry. Please come up, please. Mr. Mr. Meal, did you want to stay? Do you want to come up to the microphone for a minute? Yeah. Yes. Okay, can you see? I just want to thank everybody so much. We're probably missing 13 to 15 people as well tonight. And so kudos to all of you for filling the room with sound. I don't even know what to say, how much fun I have with these kids and how talented they are and hard work. This is a hard process, and there's a lot of days where they sit and sit and sit and wait and wait and wait. And so there's a lot of hard parts to

011this, and so I really appreciate them very much. This means a lot to us, too, to come here and do this. This is huge. So thank you all very much for the invitation. Thank you. You're welcome to stay if you'd like, but you also can leave as well. Thank you and have a wonderful holiday season. Thank you. All right. Thank you so much. Agenda item 6.0 is a superintendent report. So for this, I'll turn it over to Diane. Great. Really hard to follow up on that performance. So I'm just going to give you a pretty general report this evening. First of all, you can see on the slide, this is just our monthly enrollment report. So again, not much of a change from last month. Our enrollment is remaining very steady. for sure, but definitely

012want to be sharing that information with you on a regular basis. So I'm not going to read through that, but certainly it is a reference for all of you to take a look at at your leisure. On the next slide. Wanted to just convey some information. First off, although I was up at four o'clock this morning beginning to answer the superintendent text about whether anyone was calling a delay or no school, I'm sure I don't show it. But anyway, I was very pleased that we were able to have a full school day as scheduled. But it is that time of year to be sharing some weather-related information with all of you. Abby and... And Grace are probably looking at me like, come on, lady, like, let's have a day off. But anyhow, there will be

013plenty of time for that in the coming months. Just as a piece of information, we will also put this in our newsletter tomorrow. You know, based on the calendar that was approved by the board this spring, there will be two traditional snow days this year. And any additional weather-related days will be asynchronous remote instruction days. Our building leaders and our school staff are finalizing plans and procedures for those remote days. And we're also establishing a dedicated web page. It's not quite yet live. But Ray has been working on that with our webmaster. And it is on the header page going to explain the overall procedures for those asynchronous learning days. And then there will be a tab to each of our school phases so that parents can have easy access to information about. what the

014expectation is in terms of what kids should be doing. So we're hopeful that that becomes a stronger piece of communication than we might have had in the past. I would just remind all of you, we have had literally one asynchronous. remote storm day since the board approved these in our calendar a couple of years ago. So we haven't had a lot of opportunity to learn from our practice and to make our best better, but we are certainly working on that. So that is something that as soon as that goes live, we'll also be sharing with all families. The other piece of information that I wanted to just share with you tonight, if you take a look at these photos, our seventh grade integrated team, as you know, that we have one team at the middle

015school that. is really focused on outdoor education more so. And they have been working on a stewardship unit in conjunction with the Scarborough Land Trust. And so the photos that you see are actually from an afternoon just a few weeks ago where our students were working on the trails right on the middle school campus. And so these photos actually were received from a film crew that came to the school. The Department of Education is really looking to highlight some of the exciting innovations that are happening in schools across the state. And they had reached out to us. And so we had made some good connections. And so the person from the video crew, who is not part of the DOE, but was hired by the DOE, and he's from, not even from the state of

016Maine, but after his visit on the 20th, 22nd, he sent along some of these photos and he said to me in his email, first of all, his email was titled Restored Faith in Humanity. And I was just like, oh, like, who is this email from? And like, I can't wait to read what the content of this is. And then as I went on to read it, there were, you know, these were three of the photos of several others that he shared. But what he said was he felt so privileged to have spent the day with our students and said it was a special experience that was the most enjoyable part of my journey across the state. So again, I think that just speaks volumes to people from outside of Scarborough recognizing the great work that

017we're doing and some of the innovation that's happening here. So I do expect that as these short clips get put together and the DOE is putting these together as part of a PR campaign to promote public education in the state. I'm going to be really excited to share with you what that final product looks like. So just really wanted to share that with you this evening. Thank you so much, Diane. Are there any questions? I, of course, have two. Okay. The website for the snow days. I think that is incredible. So thank you. And thank you, Ray, for working on that. I know every, anytime you do something new, there's always hiccups and there's always bumps in the road as we try to iron out the kinks and get used to doing something. And so

018one of the things that we did here was just an overall concern with communication. And so I think this is really awesome. And this is a really great way to hear feedback and take it in. And then. do something in response. Are assignments going to be posted there too? Is that the plan or what do you think that will look like? I mean, it's different at different levels. At the middle school and high school, the assignments will be posted through Google Classroom because that's the way the kids are used to it. At the K-2 level, there'll still be the paper packets that will be sent home, but there'll most likely be a PDF link to what's been sent home at the different grade levels. And then like... on the special education side, you know, more

019individualized plans for kids that needed more, you know, something different that will also be sent home by the case manager. So like, in all levels of the paper copies sent home at the K five. Yeah, and I think one of the pieces of feedback that we heard was that, you know, parents really wanted on as it pertained to those packets that go home at the elementary level, more information about what the expectation is in terms of how much should kids be completing. You know, if there are 37 activities, I'm pulling a number out of the sky. Am I expected to do 37 activities with my child on this day? And so we talked about that a lot with the team. And so there is going to definitely be more clarity in explaining to families what

020the expectation is with those. okay that's awesome um that is really cool i'm really excited about that thank you i think that adds um just another layer of transparency and makes it easier for people to find information so really thank you thank you both for that and then on the seventh grade integrated team i can't remember if i asked you this before but is there a plan to expand that so that other group other teams can participate as well or is the plan to just stick to one So we haven't really dug into what an expansion could look like, right? Because as you know, we received a MOLLE grant last year, which is an outdoor learning. integrated something or other unit. And so we have, you know, one team that's doing that. So, you know,

021I think that is something that we'll continue to talk about. And I think just as, you know, we saw this evening, like as we saw Oak Hill players, one of the hallmarks that I have a lot of pride about in Scarborough is that we create multiple pathways for students. And so, you know, I think that as the middle school develops more of this outdoor education pieces, those things will be accessible to all teams. So you don't necessarily have to be on this team to utilize the trails and so on and so forth. That's really exciting. Yeah, that's really exciting. We're super excited. Thank you. All right. Any other questions or thoughts? All right. Agenda item 7.0 is the chair report. I actually don't have too, too much to say tonight. I think we'll hear about

022it in committee work, committee reports. But I did want to wish everybody, this is our, well, we have one more meeting, but we're getting into the holiday season. So I just wanted to wish everybody a happy holiday season as we get started. Our next meeting on the 19th is just a reminder is the workshop. The first at six o'clock, it'll be on AI, which is actually interesting. I actually meant to say it at our policy meeting. So hopefully people are watching. There were, we did hear some public comment about the intersection of cell phone use and AI and how that's the next tool coming up for kids. Right. And I think the reality is AI is already a tool. being used by our kids. And so Jen Day is going to join us and she's

023going to really talk about what that looks like at the staff level and at the student level and give us. I'm sure just because of her past, my past experiences in her workshops, a wealth of information. Yeah. And Katie Vitro, our curriculum director will be joining her as well. And she'll be speaking more to the curriculum aspects as it relates to AI. So, you know, I think they're going to be a really powerhouse tag team because Jen is our tech expert. And then Katie has a very strong technology background, but she's coming at it from a curriculum lens. So I think those. to pair together will be really helpful for the board in terms of beginning to think about what AI looks like in our school district. Absolutely. So I am excited for that. So

024that'll be a six o'clock workshop and then our meeting, our meeting at seven. All right. Agenda item 8.0, our committee reports. The first one is building. So Jillian and Alyssa. All right. Do you mean to just, all right. All right. So we had a couple of building meetings. We had on 1118, we had the full SBAC2 meeting. We officially elected James Kroniken to the leadership as the secretary. He keeps really great notes. It's really great for us. And then we discussed. the desire, the decision to hire Harriman and Harriman also came and did a presentation, answered some questions. And then, as you know, the next thing we did was a joint town council meeting. And we had that presentation. There was a full overview of both bodies over current progress and next steps. And then

025once again, our decision was. to hire Harriman was presented there. We had our last meeting on Monday. Harriman presented a timeline, which is on the next slide. The committee is currently in a data collection mode. We will spend January and February doing a deep dive into the four options. The committee will weigh in on the strengths and weaknesses of the four options made in phase one. And then, of course, we would welcome any feedback from the board and, of course, the council on any of those things, what you see as your strengths, those strengths and weaknesses. We also started up to subcommittees. That was the communication and site selection. So the reason for site selection, because we don't have a plan yet, right? Like there's many options out there, but we need to start looking

026at land if there is the potential that we will buy land or need to buy land for one. I think actually three of the options would require buying some sort of land. So we need to start looking at that. So we did a little bit of work on what our guiding principles would be. And because of the sort of diverse needs of the land, we basically arrived at a very short list. Like basically it's land that's available. I can't remember the other thing, but. Yeah, it was like not in an industrial area with a friendly approach and one that has, allows for equitable bus times. Yes. Oh, yes. Yes. We'll do a little bit deeper dive into the word equity, I think, with the committee. We also heard about the survey, a survey structure. a

027survey structure would look like. We will be surveying a few times. There will be a survey coming up at some point. The communications committee will actually work on that. And so we have, we also had, the communications committee actually met the next day on Tuesday. Yes, the next day on Tuesday. So my gosh, it's already, week's already lost, but. had a really great meeting, have a little bit of a plan started. I mean, these guys are hitting the ground running. And then I think site selection also had a little overview of what they would be doing. And already, like, everybody's popping up. What about this piece of land? What about this piece of land? That's been it's been fun already. People are into it already. So our next meeting is December 16th at 6 p.m.

028And the subcommittees will meet to be determined. Those will get a cadence and get those out to you. If you're interested in joining any or listening to any of those. Our goal is just to collect data, review building deficiencies and discuss programming and enrollment. And if you could go to the next slide. Maybe. Maybe. If you want. Oh, no. Oh, there we go. All right. So this is the timeline that Harriman presented. And it's a little hard to read, but you can blow it up on your screen. So you can see, though, the green is the SBAC2 meetings. The yellow are joint workshops and the blue are community forums. And so you can see that there's a lot of involvement. both the community forums and the elected bodies throughout this process. I think that there's

029a very well thought out plan to how to get us to where we need to be. So I think everybody feels really solid. There's a really good path forward. Any questions? Good. All right. We'll carry on because you have the next communications. I know I'm ready to be done. All right. And so we, the communications committee has put together a couple of Canva. event things. What's the word I'm looking for? Anyway, this one out, there we go, flyers, there we go. This one went out in the, or will go out in the school newsletter and went out in the town newsletter last week. The town has published the last couple of weeks, last couple of times, some upcoming events. So we did talk about the round table that is next week at 6 p.m. 12,

03012, I guess that's, yeah, Thursday, 6 p.m. Wentworth Learning Commons. People can come in person or on Zoom. There is no specific topic. People can come talk about whatever they want to talk about. We'll be doing our spotlight next week, next meeting. And we're just continuing to try to. Get out the word about what we're doing. So just little, little bits. So if anybody's interested in coming to the workshop, they will, they should now know about it because it's been advertised multiple times. And of course, if anybody has any ideas about where to communicate, let us know because we're putting things out on social media and in the newsletters so far. So that's about it. Is there any? No, there's not. There's not. I'm sorry. Yeah, there's not a specific agenda for the roundtable. I

031mean, we'll do introductions and then people can talk about what they want to talk about. Do you have the volunteers you need for that board members? Oh, yes. Freyla stepped up for this one. And so it will be Mitchell, Freyla and I and then Alyssa signed up for the next one. And I already got it written down. So awesome. Are there any other questions for Jillian? Thank you, Mitchell. And thank you, Freyla, for stepping up. And Alyssa for the next one, too. Thank you. That's super awesome. All right. Jenna, it looks like it's your turn. Yes. So our next meeting, well, our meeting was postponed because it was during Thanksgiving week. So we have now moved it to 12.16 at 5 p.m. So stay tuned. All right. Rayla, you're up with negotiations. Negotiations are going

032well. We have done the custodial food service contract. Those folks will get their retroactive pay effective tomorrow, which I have a shout out to the business office for getting that done so quickly. I think that'll be great news for everybody, especially right at this time of year. And then we are going to get started on the teacher contract. We have a date on the calendar next week. So that's the biggest of the contracts that we do. It's this year's contract, and I look forward to getting to work on it. Any questions for Rayla and Helen? All right. You're next to me. We had an amazing policy committee meeting before the business meeting today from five to six. Yeah, 5 to 630. And we are working on the student use of cellular technology and other devices.

033I know that the board members have received a lot of email in the last few weeks about this policy. And I, you know, it's occasionally we hit a policy that that It generates a lot of community interest, and I'm always really excited when that happens because we all know how I feel about policy. But when I see community members come out and engaging and having discussions about what's best for our students, that makes me feel really positive about our community and how much they care about what we're doing at schools and how invested they are in making sure that. this district is functioning as best as it can. So we had a lot of attendance at the policy committee meeting today. We had a lot of public comment, almost an hour of public comment at

034the beginning of that meeting. We heard from students, we heard from staff, we heard from parents. I think we're getting a lot of information and we're trying to think about the process of how to evaluate this policy in a way that keeps the community engaged and with us so that we can. together come up with the best policy for Scarborough, which I am excited to continue that work at our next meeting on January 2nd. I expect that we're going to move to include the rest of the board in some of that work as well, whether we do a community forum or something. And during the work on that policy so that when that policy gets. submitted for first reading that you have had an opportunity to review it ahead of time because I think it's

035really important with all the interest that we are very considerate about how we make sure we hear all the voices in the community to make a policy that works for everybody or the best we can that works for people. Other than that, once we get done with that, we're going to move on to school use facilities and student transportation and then back to reviewing the older policies, which we sort of neglected for the last few months with all the other policies we're updating. We will move to second reading, our last of our discrimination harassment complaint procedures. I know you've missed the 17-page Title IX procedures and my long-winded explanations about due process. But we have one more to get through. I will bang that out and then those will be done for now. Other than

036that, just keep reading your emails. I think I'm happy that we're getting so much community engagement. I think also is allowing board members who are not able to attend the meetings, although we definitely had board members listening to this meeting, to really get all sides. We're getting a lot of points of view in our email and I think that's helpful because it's covering a lot of what we're hearing. So yeah. Yeah, and I'll just tack on, if you can keep, as a board, if you can keep the week of January 9th kind of tagged in your calendar, one of the things we had talked about, this is abnormal, this isn't something we've typically done in the past, but we're trying to figure out a way to incorporate community feedback, which they are really interested in,

037from what we heard today, really interested in expressing their opinions and their views on. the cell phone policy and you can see by the influx in our inbox this is a really big thing. This is a big topic and this is something that impacts a lot of people. And so what we had talked about is meeting January 2nd, starting the work and then having a almost like a hybrid of a workshop and a community forum. Our workshops and we typically have them, those are opportunities for us to learn and it's not an engagement with the community, but this feels like a little bit of a different. thing because the community, I think it's important for everyone to hear from the community. So we're kind of tagging that week. We ran out of time to really

038set a date. So I think we're going to do it offline. But if you can kind of keep that week just marked in your calendar. All right. Are there any liaison reports? Oh, wonderful. All right. So First of all, the town council liaison is now Bill Donovan to the school where I had a nice chat with him today. I really like him. I think, so I got some updates for the committees. I think the only two that really are relevant are finance. That'll be John Anderson, Karen Shoup, and Don Cushing. And communications will be also Don Cushing, John Anderson, and Scott Doherty. And then the liaisons to the school building advisory committee will be April Sider and Bill Donovan. And if you want to know about the shellfish commission as simulator. i don't know i

039don't know what else would be relevant um and i think that's there's there's a lot going on uh on the town council side the only things that are interesting maybe to our process um Maybe there's a moratorium that they're looking at for the white industrial zone that shouldn't impact any land that we might be looking at, but it might. But they're also looking at wetland setbacks. And that might be. really important to any land that we might be looking at. So it's something worth keeping an eye on. Fortunately, we have points of contact that will keep us up to date on that. But if you haven't had a chance, it was a really interesting, sometimes a little tense discussion last night, but certainly very interesting to hear about. So I'd recommend listening to it. I

040think that's really it. Awesome. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Agenda item 10.0, our student report. So we'll turn over to Grace and Abby. So at the middle school, the Unified Club worked hard to plan a spirit week that was fun-filled and educational, so all students could feel like they were included. Inclusive School Week was an annual event which is held during the first week of December, and some of the spirit days included Neon Day, Color Day, and Camo Day. The Unified Club also planned activities for crew to increase awareness of disabilities and promote inclusion. Each crew watched two video clips. And lastly, at the middle school, on Wednesday, the Unified Club met to decorate sugar cookies. They ate some and then shared the rest with the Scarborough Public Safety staff. And then at the

041high school, students involved in Oak Hill Players performed the musical White Christmas, which we heard from earlier. And it was really, really excellent. They did a great job. Okay. There's a lot of cool stuff happening at Wentworth this past month. As a part of their science unit on weather, the third graders had a special visit and assembly by WMTW Channel 8 News. The students had an informative presentation and an opportunity to ask questions. A super special part of the day was the opportunity for any third grader to broadcast live for weather at your school. It was really fun and educational and it was a great experience for all of them. Also, due to the recent election, students in Wentworth's social studies classes learned about the branches of government, the electoral college, how elections work, and

042more in some very creative ways. Some learning communities held their own student elections, some visited mock polls to vote for their favorite candies and activities, and some took a walk up to SHS to safely see the real polling place in action. It was overall a really fun day and everyone learned a lot. That is very cool. And not to put you on the spot, Abby, but do you mind sharing with the rest of the board what you shared with the policy committee, the things you've learned at the school from students about that? So Abby's been doing some looking at what other students feel about the cell phone policy. And so she shared some pretty insightful information. Overall, most of the students don't feel the need for a... a bell-to-bell band. They feel that they need

043their phone, but, like, not to use it to play games or during class, but mostly for communication, especially, like, communicating with their parents. And in high school, there's lots of clubs, sports, and, like, other activities that they need to, like, coordinate to get rides and, like, what time they need to get picked up. Another thing is in high school, you need to learn how to be responsible. and know when you can and when you shouldn't use your phone. Especially during study halls, sometimes if people finish their work, they don't have anything to do. They feel that they should be allowed to use their phones if they really don't have anything else to do. So yeah. That's awesome. And something I learned from you that I hadn't thought about this before, because one of the things

044I've been thinking about is the high school students at lunchtime. And you brought up a point that I hadn't thought about, and that's that your classes are all on Google Classroom. And so you have Google Classroom, you said, download it on your phone, and you can watch educational videos before a test. Yeah, I use Google Classroom throughout the day just to check due dates. And then Lots of teachers post classwork, and so they post what we're going to be doing and, like, the homework questions. So throughout the day, I can use my phone to, like, search up how to do a math problem, or, like, I can watch a video online or use it. Another thing I do is, like, I search up, like, articles, like, to help with, like, world studies or, like, English,

045something like that. Of course. Sorry. Oh, yes, absolutely. And I think a lot of students also have like their school email on their phone too, which can be helpful because if a teacher emails them and the student needs to see it like immediately, like, oh, come see me during A-East or whatever, it's easier for that student to access it on their phone, like at lunchtime when they're not having their laptops open or something. It's just, I think, yeah. Sorry, I have a follow-up question. When I was in high school, we did not all have computers. So I'm not fully understanding of the structure of what's on a computer versus what's on your phone, how the day flows and everything. So do you mind if I ask you guys a couple questions about managing your day

046as a student right now in today's technology? So my understanding is you all have Chromebooks from the schools. Is kind of everything that... would be on so the everything that you guys are utilizing the phone for is it also on the chromebook is it kind of different easier to navigate kind of things like that like what's the student experience behind that um it can be i think students like i choose to have google classroom and my school email on my phone um but yeah i would say yes i mean if a student has something on their phone it's likely they also have it on their computer if it's related to like education like google classroom and gmail and power power school is actually a big one i have power school on my phone so i

047can see when grades like come through yeah power school i use like On your computer, you don't, like, get notifications every time your grade changes. So sometimes, like, I'll get a notification that, like, oh, I missed an assignment. And then, like, I'm able to, like, easily get to the teacher and ask, like, what happened or, like, what was the assignment that I missed or something. Oh, wow, that's really interesting. So I think overall the difference between, like, computers and phones is, like, Like the notifications part, like you use it more like your phone. You can like tell like classroom when something gets posted, like a teacher posts an assignment. It's harder to tell that it was posted on your computer, but like it shows up on your phone so you can see more clearly what

048your assignments are, like what showed up on power school and things like that. Okay. Thank you very much. It's been a hazy spot for me. So I appreciate you guys kind of clearing it up. And one more thing, the school laptops also have a lot of websites blocked, like even educational websites and YouTube videos. And in some of my classes, like there'll be a video or a website that we have to go to that will be blocked on our school laptop. So our teachers will say like, oh, pull it up on your phone so we can access it. So just like another way in which phones can be beneficial during the school day. I have another question. Are you able to chat with other classmates through your laptops? Not really. I mean, there's like a

049chat feature in Gmail, but nobody uses it. If necessary, yes, but it doesn't happen. Because I was just thinking, if you guys are working on like a group assignment, what is the preferred method of... communicating with one another if you guys aren't in the same room? Usually text, sometimes email, but it's just, you know, I mean, how it is. It's just easier to do it through phones and text. Yeah, okay. And Grace, have you heard anything from fellow students about the cell phone policy or? Yeah, I've heard from both students and teachers. Actually, most of my teachers do not believe that a cell phone policy is the current, like a more restrictive cell phone policy is the correct way of handling it. And a lot of students also believe that too, that, I mean, we're

05016, 17, 18 year olds. And it just feels very. restrictive. And like Abby said, once we go to college and are out in the real world, they're not going to be taking away our phones at our jobs. I mean, that's something that we need to learn how to do, like by ourselves, we need to learn to like regulate our phones and know when is an appropriate time to go on it and when it isn't and teachers also don't like I mean I spoke to my AP human geo teacher today and he said like he doesn't like policing students for their phones like if teachers have a problem with it um a lot of teachers have like phone trees where they'll have students put it up um at the front of class and students if they

051need to access it the teacher can um like have them access it, but teachers don't want to be like forced to do that. I'm curious if the, I don't know the structure this would look like, or if, if the policy committee thinks this would be helpful. I have been obviously receiving all the emails and reading each one in full. So it's brought up a lot of different points of view that I appreciate kind of having the opportunity called to the forefront. The one thing that was kind of really interesting to me was this idea of like technology isn't going anywhere and high school is a time to be prepping people for that. kind of doubt, again, wasn't really a big thing when I was in college to be having these discussions, but I kind of

052doubt that colleges will have phone trees and restrictive bans and all of these types of things. And, you know, taking that opportunity to learn how they function in an educational environment. I don't know if it would be beneficial to speak to some recent... Scarborough grads about whether they found that it was actually helpful transitioning into the college atmosphere, or any atmosphere they choose to go into, but it seems to be focused on education right now. And whether they felt it was better to have a functional workflow for organizing. There's tons of apps that you can use. I use it in my job in order to arrange my tasks, what I need. you know, are we setting our kids up better when they have something they can flow, like a workflow process they can flow into

053college? Or are we really hindering them by not allowing them to have that developed to then spring into all the changes that college brings along? I think those are really insightful questions. And here's the really exciting news. We have a board member that just recently graduated from Scarborough High School that likely can answer your question. Those are some great questions. The college I went to didn't provide laptops or computers or anything. So most of my college work I did was through either my phone or my desktop. So a lot of it was done that way. But if it was like work that professors or teachers wanted us to bring home. it was physical, here's a piece of paper, draw a wiring diagram sort of deal. I definitely think that, yes, in most colleges, from what

054I've heard, there's no bans or anything. It's down to a professor. And even then, at that point, you're being treated as an adult. You're there learning to be a functional adult. They're just going to say, hey, put it away. Or if you're not paying attention, you're not going to pass. Pretty much, yeah. So it's really bringing your own consequences on yourself at that point. So I don't see where, kind of where to draw that line if there is a line to be drawn for things like that at the moment. But I would say. Phone usage with school can be a great thing because there's a lot of things that I'd prefer to do on my phone versus prefer to do on one of these Chromebooks. There was like through COVID, there was a lot of

055like calls and everything that was like, oh, there's that. But hey, I'm going to go grab a snack. I just moved it over to my phone and paid attention that way. And that probably wasn't the best thing to do at that point. But in all honesty, I would have preferred to be on the meeting on my phone instead of my laptop where it anchors me to a point. Sure. And I know it was recent, but just for clarity's sake, because I've only been on the board for a few months now, the cell phone policy was the same as it is now when you were there, correct? Correct. It's the same policy. And to my understanding, the current policy is saying, hey, you're not supposed to even have phones already, but it's not. the policy doesn't

056align with exactly what's happening in the schools at the moment too. Yeah. And just as a point of information, I think the high school, what's recently happened is, and Diane, you can probably speak more to this. Our policy was last reviewed in 2017. And so it is, it's been a while. and phones have definitely changed quite significantly from 2017 to now. The policy does have a carve out no phones during academic time. And remember, our policies are meant for K-12. So they're very overarching, very... broad, right? Because it's covering a large swath of people. You're covering four and five-year-olds to 18-year-old and 19-year-old. So you're covering a wide swath of people, right? It's up to the buildings to make specific procedures. And so our policy said no academic time, including study halls. And then later

057there's a carve out for teacher exceptions. So what's happened at the high school is that the high school is really aligned. with the policy and is really following it as it's written right now. And so some of the emails we're in receipt of are because the students are no longer allowed to use their phone in study halls and in what's called A-East, which is like their homeroom, for lack of a better word. How would you, advisory period? It's their advisory. Right. And sometimes you do activities, right? Like once a month or something, you do activities as a group. Yeah. Yes. And that actually starts at the middle school. They have advisory, they call it RISE. And so they have advisory groups. And again, as the girls have really nicely described, students can tag a teacher

058that they want to go receive extra help from. A teacher can tag a student if they want to see that student for extra assistance. So that, again, we're kind of leveling the playing field and making those opportunities for extra help. equitable for all students. So you don't have to stay after school with a teacher if you're, you know, not able to get a ride home or you're involved in another activity after school. So we build in that into every student's schedule so that that work time is there. But to Shannon's question about the recent change in practice at the high school, as we started talking about this policy and policy committee, I did have conversation with Principal Theriault to point out that that was one place where the high school was not aligned with board

059policy. And I feel like the board sets the policy for the district. And it's really important for the schools to be following the policies that are set by the board. board. And so I did ask him to please ensure that they were following the current policy. That being said, as you all know, that policy is under review. So it's a good time for all of you to be able to provide your feedback. And I did just want to say, like, I've been really impressed with the student response to this and all the emails we're receiving. I think it, I don't know that I would have done it as a student. I think it's really commendable that you, that your student body and is, is finding a voice to email in and all of those things.

060So I just wanted to say something encouraging because I think that's really great that they're doing it. I would tack on to that and say, not only are they finding a voice to do it, they're backing up their voice with very valid points. Their communication has been really respectful. And a lot of it are things, like I said, it's a perspective that sometimes we don't think about as adults, right? Sometimes we forget what it's like to be young. And so to hear their perspective in such an awesome, respectful way has been really awesome. Yes, I will say there have been a number of emails that I've read that I was absolutely floored by the way it was so eloquently worded that I felt really good about putting my kids through our school system. Awesome. All

061right. Well, that was a lovely conversation. Thank you. I have a husband in tech. He said it didn't sound like AI. Thank you both for your updates and thank you for sharing with us what the students are thinking right now. That's really appreciated. All right. Agenda item 11.0 is general public comment. Is there anyone here wishing to make public comment this evening? Is there anybody online? No. All right. We'll close general public comment. Agenda item 12.0 is continuing business. 12.1 is the second reading of policy ACABR2, employee sex discrimination harassment complaint procedure. So I mistakenly read the agenda wrong and thought this was not here for this reading, but it is. Yay, second reading. So this is the last of the policies. There's a set of four policies having to do with sex discrimination and

062harassment as a result of Title IX. I feel like I've said this every day for the last four meetings straight. Final policy is the procedure that would accompany the policy that generally prohibits sexual discrimination and harassment of employees and protects the workplace and makes sure that nobody has a hostile workplace environment, ideally. This procedure lays out if somebody believes that sexual discrimination or harassment is occurring to themselves or another, a mechanism for them to report it. And then it takes you through who gets reported to. Title IX specifies there has to be a Title IX coordinator. and my coordinator is responsible for implementing this procedure. Specifically, that's the Title IX change. And it defines who would be involved with that. So a complaint and all the definitions of how to work the procedure. Like I

063said, a complaint can be made by somebody experiencing or who believes they've experienced this type of harassment or somebody who believes they've witnessed this type of harassment. It then takes the school through a process. in which to investigate these allegations that are being made to determine if they believe harassment has happened, to take steps to protect individuals during that process, both who have been accused of this type of conduct or who have been subject to this kind of conduct, and also to protect the workplace in general from this type of conduct. Once an investigation is complete, a finding is made that this kind of conduct has occurred or has not occurred, and then the results. The results from that are what steps are taken to address whatever conduct, if conduct is found to have occurred

064that is not lawful or is considered sexually based discrimination or harassment, what steps are taken to ameliorate the harm caused by that discrimination and ensure that it doesn't happen so that workplaces are safe moving forward. If findings are made, either that harassment has occurred or has not occurred, there's an appellate process that goes to the superintendent so that decisions can be made. reviewed if somebody feels that that procedure or the law is not being followed. Other than that, it looks a lot like our student policy. We made some language changes to specify this is not the educational environment, but rather it's a workplace environment meant for the staff who work at our school district. If a student was to experience this harassment, they'd be in the other policy that we just concluded, I think, two

065meetings ago. Happy to take questions. All right. Are there any questions for Freyla? Is there anyone wishing to make public comment? All right. Do I have a motion to approve the second reading of policy ACABR2, employee sex discrimination and harassment complaint procedure? So moved. Second. Is there any discussion? All in favor? That shows a unanimous. Thank you. Agenda item 13.0 is new business. 13.1 is a November resignations, retirements, and new hires. This is a non-action item. I'm going to turn it over to Diane in just a second, but just to give you some background as to why we're doing this, Diane and I. had had a discussion about retirement from the district and our policy. One of the things is, is that the board should be made aware of any retirements and resignations. So we're

066bringing ourselves in compliance with our policy. And so this is the, that's why this is the first time you've seen this on the agenda. Yeah, so Shannon and I discussed this, and as she said, moving forward, this will be a monthly item for you. This is very standard for lots of school boards, if you take a look at what's happening in other districts. It is under new business tonight. I would, because the board is not voting on this, I would advise in the future that we just put it at the top of the agenda with minutes under a consent agenda for. because it is not something that the board needs to approve. It's basically just an informational item. But again, I would just, I'm not going to read the information. I would just. ask you

067to take a look at your packet as an FYI item to let you know about that. Retirements, you are probably not going to see in full until the spring because although this is the time of year where people begin to put in their intent to retire, those things are not. carved in stone until the end of the school year. And so those are things that were squirreling away. The only time that you would see a retirement other than at the end of the school year is from time to time. We do have employees who might retire as of December 31st or at a different time of year. But for those folks who are sharing with us their intent to retire at the end of the school year, you will see those at the end of

068the school year. So hopefully this is a helpful piece of information for the board. All right. Are there any questions? All right. Agenda item 13.2, bless you, is the middle school donation. Yes, really pleased this evening to share with you a number of donations, actually, and this middle school donation is the first. And so you can see in your packet a letter from Kate Bolton, who is our Director of Business and Finance. The middle school received a donation check in the amount of $1,425.04 from Hannaford Health Schools. These monies were. the result of parents who donated while shopping and they made the middle school one of Maine's top participating schools, which qualified the middle school for a thousand dollar bonus. So that donation of $1,425.04 will be used for all three grade levels for special

069events. And it will also help to fund a wellness day at the middle school, which they have not had since 2019. We had done that in the past, and that was a really well-received, great event for our students, and I'm excited to hear that that's coming back. And so we would respectfully request that the board approve acceptance of this donation on behalf of the middle school with many thanks. All right. Do I have a motion to approve the middle school donation as presented? So moved. Second. Is there any discussion? I forgot to ask, is there anybody wishing to make public comment? All right. All in favor. It shows unanimous. Deep gratitude. So thank you very much. All right. Agenda item 13.3 is the Blue Point School donation. Yes. So you will see this letter from

070Dr. Martin, who, by the way, I did want to just add Kelly Mullen Martin, who is our Blue Point. point primary principal just defended her dissertation in the past two weeks and earned her doctorate. And so that's quite exciting for her and very exciting for our district. So Dr. Martin writes this letter to you as the Board of Education. They also received a generous donation from Haniford Health Schools. Theirs is in the amount of $1,422.04. Seems like four cents is an exciting amount. And they attached a copy of the check. They are very grateful for the support and the support that our local grocery store provides. And they are going to utilize this donation towards their student scholarship fund that works to support students and families with various needs at Blue Point School. All right.

071Do I have a motion to approve the Blue Point School donation as presented? So moved. Second. Is there anybody wishing to make public? All right. Any discussion? All in favor? That shows unanimous. Also with deep gratitude. Thank you very much. All right. Agenda item 13.4 is a Pleasant Hill School donation. Yes. So again, you see this memo written by Kate Bolton. The Pleasant Hill School received notification this week of a donation in the amount of $500 from the Maine Environmental Education Association. This donation will be used to purchase supplies for the grade levels at Pleasant Hill School as they explore the Scarborough Land Trust during field trips. And so we would respect. fully request that the board approve acceptance of this donation with many thanks. All right. Do we have a motion to approve the

072Pleasant Hill School donation as presented? So moved. Second. Is there any discussion? Anybody wishing to make public comment? All in favor? And that shows unanimous. Thank you so much. All right, agenda item 13.5 is an appointment and 13.5.1 is a middle school theater advisor. Yes, I believe that this candidate might be in the room this evening. And so we're very pleased to recommend Jessica Dumas as the middle school theater advisor for the coming season. All right. Is there anybody wishing to make public comment? Would you like to come up and say anything? The one thing that I would add is Jessica has been an integral part of a lot of the work happening at the high school in Oak Hill Players for several years. She's also, I believe, a graduate of Scarborough High School. Yes,

073yes. And so she got her start. as a student. And so it's really exciting for us as a district to see alumni come back and serve in this capacity. Certainly Eric, who's sitting next to her, is in the same situation. And so again, when we talk about the value of these programs for our students, they really lead to careers and choices that our students make into adulthood. So this is really exciting to see. All right. Do I have a motion to approve the middle school theater advisor as presented? So moved. Is there any discussion? All in favor? And that shows unanimous. Thank you. And congratulations. Remember my voice. I'm like the girl that was ill. I can fill in. All right. If there are no objections, we will adjourn tonight's meeting at 8.20 p.m. Seeing

074none, we will adjourn. Thank you so much. Have a good evening.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.