001This is the December 4th 2024 meeting of the Coffey County School Board directors evaluation committee Present our committee members. Mr. Gary Cordell Scott Hansard Tom Ballard and Miss Jones is absent So we have three committee members and According my records you are not on this committee so it is one of the few committees you weren't on So, mr. Gill you're dismissed if you choose to do so Because we know you'll have comments anyway. Nope. All right. So we in 52824, we actually went through and when Ms. Rose was here on the board, we went through the director's evaluation instrument. And that is what's in your packet there. And a little bit of history on this is that. We've had this director's evaluation instrument for a while. When Mr. Pat Barton was on the board, he
002proposed and the board approved at the very end, well, he basically developed the rubrics section that goes in here for determining how to score. That but probably most important something that never got implemented was that there was a whole section in here on performance standards related to Different TSBA scores or not TSB TSB TCAP scores at TSBA in my mind after that last committee meeting but and so that Second to last page on here is really those numbers are to be filled in and then the last page then is the qualitative and quantitative scores so that you get a total score. So there's the more subjective. filling in the one through five section. And then the board counts for 50%, the administrator counts for 15%, and the teacher survey counts for 15%. As proposed here,
003the TCAP achievement data counted for 20% of the director's evaluation score. And there was also a goal in here that doesn't have any percentage attached to it is the system improvement plan, which I do not believe. We have school improvement plans, and I think we have a... But I don't know if we have a system improvement plan per se the way Mr. Barton defined it. Do you know, Mr. Shores? I'm sorry. I know we have a school improvement plan. Right. We have the school improvement plans. But what he had talked about here, and I had talked to Mr. Barton about this, is the system improvement plan. And we have a system improvement plan. Right. School improvement plan. Right. Yeah. And I guess I was confused when I talked to him about what exactly that was.
004So it's kind of, and, you know, so if we're making changes, then that doesn't necessarily have to be in here. But, you know, and I think things have changed anyway with the, with the, our, that Dr. Cornelius came and talked to us about is those TCAP goals. You know, so that may be something that we put in here, you know. Under the quantitative section as well. Are we hitting those goals? And I guess that's a little bit of the background here now. Dr. Powell has suggested that maybe we might want to simplify. Very long and complicated. Yes, it really is And that's what the board wants. I know that mr. Cordell had had some observations last year There's some sections in there that it is almost impossible for a board member to well That's what
005I think there's some things and even in even these two from from Tallahoma from Manchester there's probably things in here that that the board wouldn't necessarily know about but They could ask questions about it when this evaluation is done you'd have an opportunity to talk with the director of schools and say, you know what, we're not sure what have you done to achieve this goal, so to speak. But, you know, again, that's left up to the board. Right. There's so many things it's just hard to evaluate or give a grade on or whatever, because there's so many things we didn't know what the director was doing or responsible for. How do you grade the perception of the director from the teacher, right? Right. So many things that just it was frustrating. Well, I know she's
006got a teacher survey in here, which, you know, the board wants to go that way. That's fine. But if you're going to have 400 teachers responding back, you're going to have 350 different. Yeah, I agree. Knows, I guess, so to speak. Well, and discussing with TSBA, it's not typical that the teachers normally do a director's evaluation. So I would probably strike that period anyway. You know administration yes Board yes teachers. I you know, I think it's kind of you know unusual for For that to take place according to TSPA anyway, so I would probably not do that part My recommendation anyway and So I'm glad you got these samples or the copies for the evaluation from these other three other systems. Yeah, that was Dr. Powell's doing. So the trick is, though, is if we
007are going to replace the annual performance agreement in the contract with the annual performance evaluation, then we need to have some. More quantitative type type goals here and and you know, whether that's something we come up with every year You know and so the evaluation instrument changes every year whether you know whether we tie it to the TCAP scores I Think you know looking at that section And the one that was proposed, that's a lot of stuff, you know, to score on. So that second to last page. Because what's really important right now, what's important to the state anyway, is third grade ELA. You may want to look at some of these other ones too. So I'm open to suggestions on this because this just seems like a lot to me. And if I'm coming
008in as a director and I'm looking at this and going, holy cow. Yeah. Let me say this, too, out of what little experience I've had with it. And I know you've got to have some data to back up some things. But a director coming here, the first year they're here, they wouldn't have any input into third-grade retention because they wouldn't think they could do. Second, third year, that may be something to take a look at. But just an example of what you're what you're saying, you know and same thing with with the grades that we're gonna be getting from each school and the Achieving schools and so forth and so on the first year directors in here probably wouldn't that because that information would have been given over the past years and we're just not
009getting information this year for it So, you know, I don't I don't have any I wouldn't have any problem with having some goals in here that they've got to do this or this or this based on state data and teacher data or student data rather, but keep in mind that the director of schools doesn't necessarily have any direct, any direct, I'm trying to find the word here, he or she doesn't get into third grade and teach third grade. Right. I understand. I guess that's what I'm trying to say. But there should be some that they've met certain goals. I don't have any, you know, that would be a good issue, I think, to look at. But to base their evaluation based on what third grade did this year. I don't think would be a fair
010assessment He didn't have anything to do with it, right well Yeah, I understand that. But the board has, you know, one employee basically. And so the policy is being implemented that should, you know, affect those scores. I guess that's the theory. And so that's kind of what we're looking at evaluating is. Yeah, I think if you're going to go with incentive pay, you need to have something other than just, you know, whether they've been a member of the Rotary Club or the Kiwanis Club or the Lions Club. Right. They could be a member not do anything except build the meetings once right there's something like that. Yeah And that's I think that's in most days under community relations and some of those type things but Yeah, if you're gonna tie in a performance base you
011need to have some data to tie it into Right, right And I guess my perception, you know going back to the contract is that if we're gonna do you know performance incentives that that's kind of a separate goal that's set every year and then the annual evaluation is is Part of that but but it's but it's not where you're if say if you had like I've seen one contract where it was like, you know over a four-year contract term that there's there's $10,000 total 2500 a year if you hit, you know, some specific goals that to me would be separate from from what's in the performance evaluation So those are kind of, I don't know, you might call them stretch goals or something like that. They're attainable, but it's kind of a stretch. That's, yeah.
012We need to get in states. Two things, and you all have hit on both of them. You've got to answer where do you want a director to score this evaluation for it to count towards accountability. And then your third grade, discussion of third grade. accountability that would reflect itself in the contract via bonus achievement that would reflect itself there right so when you're looking at accountability talking about an evaluation instrument that by the way i will agree is too too much i will agree with that as well that doesn't necessarily have to be in there because if it's in your contract that you're, you know, we put in there that, hey, we want to see the third grade proficiency scores coming up. We want to see that. Well, if they received an extra $3,000 bonus
013that year for making a 3% or 4% raise, well, then that speaks for itself without having to be plugged into the actual evaluation. Right. Because in the end, we're evaluating every bit of it. Right. Meeting contract goals. How this looks, the instrument looks, how it scored on there, what score are you looking for, what average are you looking to be above or maintaining, things of that nature, just as you would with a teacher. Yeah, and I'm hearing the same thing, is where those stretch goals we put in the contract are going to be different from what's on the evaluation. And I would tie the evaluation maybe, well... Couple ways to go is we have our TISA accountability report. So those are some obvious goals the I think this District improvement plan is kind of a
014you know That's kind of hard to really gauge, but the TISA accountability goals, that are things that are measurable and time-specific, and they meet all the requirements of a SMART goal. So that's something I'd look at, I guess. In essence, you could veer back to actually creating a performance agreement. that the old contracts referenced that we'd never had and all of this to a performance agreement. And that performance agreement includes this, an instrument, how much it counts for, outcome funding, third grade ELA, certain percentages, but you gotta have a baseline of where you want those to be in an average. What if you were put in there beginning the second year? Right. Beginning the second year of your contract, you would be expected to meet these goals. Meet these goals, yeah. Right. Yeah, obviously you
015couldn't in the first year. I agree. Would we love it? Would I love to be paying bonus money out the very first year? Well, yeah. I agree. That's based on somebody else's information. Yeah, well, that's the trick, yeah. You know and I look at those those numbers those TSA accountability goals that dr. Cornelius presented to us as something that the state is you know mandating on us and then we're saying to the state we're gonna do and Those are measurable, you know, they're all time-specific and and so That probably kind of has to factor in I know those are some of those are looking kind of tough, you know where we're at right now, but But it's certainly a goal. But this first-year contract, the director would not have any input into those. He or
016she would have those goals. For you to set for the second year there, right, right. I would agree. Yes, I would agree with that But but it still kind of revolves and reverts right back to performance agreement to tie all of these things you're talking about Yeah, well then in the one right item because you need a you need a score for your your surveyed right Evaluation you need a certain percentage held against you for Your outcome funding or things of that nature proficiency and third grade, you know Growing the system as well, right? so maybe what we do is we keep the language in the contract with annual performance agreement and then every year the board comes up with those goals and Doing what what you're saying and we tie it back to the
017TC accountability goals and maybe some other ones and he got a few You know, not too many, but some that you should be able to hit, but might be a stretch. You don't necessarily send new stuff every year, new requirements every year, just requirements in that performance agreement. And then we score each year based off either maintaining or getting better each year. I see what you're saying. And then if you don't, based off that performance agreement. Then we need to start talking about other things and seeing what's going on. Hopefully have some discussions Hopefully everybody come together and somebody's got an idea maybe something works. Maybe we change here. Maybe we change there Whatever. I mean cross that bridge one, but ultimately you hope it yeah Well, I like that idea better than tying every,
018because I'm looking at this evaluation instrument and I'm going, man, there's just too much stuff. 33 is quite a few. Yeah, it's just, you know. Outside of the committee, as a concerned citizen here, since I'm not on this committee, I think that is way too much right there, and we need to have more items of different places that all fall back and score in one place in a performance agreement that you've also got to develop a baseline of how low is too low. All right, maybe have all of the science Yeah, maybe have all the science and all the math combined into one or something you could do that Yeah, you get the ELA grade reach, you know in the you could combine all of those all the mathematics all the science social studies And
019then maybe go down to the bottom down there and then put the algebra geometry and all of that That would cut out five You could certainly condense items and things of that nature of the questionnaires of the questionnaire but you still shouldn't steer away from the fact of having a certain number for that document a Certain number that you need to score for this dot this this area and a certain number here And then those three come together to create you We got an issue or we don't well The numbers that, you know, I go back to the TISA accountability scores that potentially affect our budget. Absolutely. Yes, and that should be this one. And that should be this. This document by law says it's got to be here. Right. You got to do that.
020We have to do an evaluation every year. Right. Mechanism. Then we take those items, we plug it right here. Into the contract? Yep. Well, the performance agreement. Yeah, yeah. to become a part of the contract that is referenced in the contract yeah i agree we got what four or five do you know dr blessing four or five tisa accountability goals i probably should be oh We have one for third grade ELA, which is required. Right. And then the other three, there's math, the eighth grade math, eighth grade ELA, and then there's ACT and at the hospital. ACT and. So we got four right now. You can have five, but I think we got four. Achievement at the high school. And that's exactly what you put in there. And you got your performance agreement and reference
021and all of those items. And as it's referencing everything you're taking into consideration annually. Yep. You got your scores. But we need a memo. Yep. And that'll probably have to be in the policy. Okay. So the three, the last three I mentioned, are the ones that we chose to put on the thesis report because they create outcomes funding for us. Right. But the first one is required, but the other three we chose to put on there. And? You know, quite frankly, and I don't know, but just talking with various people, I'm not going to be surprised if we don't come back around and get some seventh grade or eighth grade, you know, the same thing they're doing with third grade, you know, and eventually tie it back to funding, you know. So we're going to,
022the state's going to. Force us to hit Yeah Yeah There is some fourth grade stuff that's going on but I don't remember exactly but but I imagine there's gonna be some middle school stuff too and and Yeah, it is tied back to our outcomes But in that performance agreement, and that's all I'm going to say, in that performance agreement that you'll need in that policy, if that instrument there, your questionnaire, do they need to maintain a 3.5 and above out of five before we move into discussions of, hey, look, we've got to talk about your job here. So the same goes with this same goes with this and you could put them all into one and base it out of three zero to five Lock it like the questionnaire in the performance agreement And if
023you end up in there lower than a three point five or something, all right, we need to have talks here different ways to get outcome funding, and that TISA report could change every year. So just keep that in mind too. Maybe not make it count, but 10% of the consideration or something. Or you just tie it back to the, you know, you just refer back to the accountability case, and maybe we, I mean, we got four this year, but we can have up to five, right? I think so. Yeah. I think you can have this. More than five. Oh, really? Okay, I thought there was space on there for five. I mean, I could be wrong on that. I don't know either. I just know we picked the main one that would get us an
024outcome. But maybe we have five for next year, and that's the basis of your annual performance agreement. So you just tie it back to that. Because really, you know, I mean, I'm in favor of accountability goals that tie back to hitting the standards the state wants us, but also affects our... budget you know and in a positive light so that I think are worthy goals yes they're worthy goals in which you're going to have to have an annual performance agreement yeah to be your tool for accountability right Think that makes sense and then we can tie the bonus payments back to that. Yeah. Yeah, exactly I'm just a citizen. I need to go over and sit so quickly All right, so I agree keep them separate and You know, so the question is do we
025just take out that last page of those? I think so. I know Pat Barton will have a heart attack when we do that, but things have changed since he pushed this through with TISA. So it's a whole different landscape right now. Because, well, for one thing, this is way too much. Again, 33 things is a whole lot. Yeah. Just to get our people that's listening at home. Know I try to do that a lot, but that's a lot of people are watching this and that's what we're trying to Trying to do here, right? and you know and we can We can you know add to the TSA accountability goals too and tie that back in so I don't you know, I don't see where that that would be an issue I mean because the one
026that's required is third grade ELA, right? So the others are Right, right. So you're still saying you're going to go with this 30-page document as your evaluation instrument? I think we probably want to cut it down. I'll second it, folks. You know, I think this has gotten a little, you know, in all fairness to Mr. Barton, I think he did a great job on this, but it's just way too much. And I'm with Mr. Cordell. Last year I went through this, and I kind of went. You know some of these questions are You know, there's I don't know you just any kind of guess and that's not a fair evaluation if you're just kind of guessing Most of these other instruments here that you had access to a lot of them if you look at
027it kind of accumulate what you've got on there to certain areas so speak Well, if you talk to Pat it's got about there they have a incentive It's not in there. No. I don't know how they do it either. I have no idea. But I believe they do. Pat Welch. You talked to him recently, didn't you? Pat Welch. You've talked to Pat too, haven't you? Pat Welch and Tom. Okay. Okay. All right. But I had asked him too, and I believe they have one. I do have some examples of a. Incentives that I can send out to folks that TSBA provided me and I can send that out. All right, so I Don't know if we got the time to really you know, we can When we do the we look at a teacher survey,
028there's a pretty good question. I think our teachers I don't Well, but TSBA says you don't typically survey teachers I'm okay with not I think it'd be important to the board just to know how the You know TSV says you don't include I have to include I think that would be revealing to the board as to what the scoring or the teachers perception Was the director in his performance and in all these areas? Well, I think it's important. Could we do it where we had a teacher at each school? Yeah, teacher advisory panel. Mm-hmm. Well, I think that you know if you do that you're there's gonna be You're gonna have people worried that there's gonna be you know, and we already get that even on an anonymous survey that I could be wrong But
029prior to last year, I don't know that I ever seen a teacher evaluation. There wasn't. It was just last year. We never have. It's always just been the board evaluating the director. Because this is going on my fifth year, and last year is the only time I knew of a teacher's getting an evaluation. How did that get in here? I have no idea. I mean, not trying to be ugly, Robert, but how do we not know how that got in there? I mean, did it just walk in one day and it mysteriously popped up in a folder? The board did not recommend or do anything to, well, we need this survey from the teachers. We didn't, so I don't know. I don't recall it, but I know every year we have to as board members.
030Yeah, I understand. And we've done that. That's what I was trying to do. It just, one day it mysteriously just showed up. I mean, it... You know, and board members come and go, so it might have been, you know, something that the board did at some point. But you've been around. I've been around. I mean, that's what I'm saying. Robert was on the board. If Robert was on the board and Robert didn't put it in there, then there's not but one other scenario that could have happened. It's not that I mind. I'm kind of like Mr. Cordell. It's not that I mind the idea and the concept of it. But there was never a need before. It hasn't happened before. It happened last year. I think that was more politics than anything, just to be
031quite honest with you. Yeah. But. What we got to do is we got to follow what we're supposed to do. Yeah. Right. And get the tools and it all, everything we've discussed for the last two hours, whether I'm in this committee or not, it's all tied together to get this straight between contracts, performance agreements, and policy. Right. And the director is the board's employee, so that makes sense. I'm not sure if we're, if. administrative staff is required. I don't think they are. If we have a director, any director, anyone that wants to know feedback from teachers, fine. Let him do it. But we still have our own opinion. What we're supposed to do by law. What we're supposed to do by law and what he does pertaining to what he's our only employee that we
032have. And I'm also, you know, I've heard of surveys with certain amounts that have went out and certain amounts that were returned back in, and I don't know if that data came from those questions and that's what was sent and the pack we have for teachers. I don't know if they answered those questions and that was the answers we got. I think there was a 60 or 100. between one or two of them, I think there were 60 or 120 out of 700 that went out or whatever. 120. I don't know where that come from and what that was. 120. Yeah. I don't know where that come from, what it was. I just know that board members, nine board members filled out nine surveys as we're required to do by law, and that's exactly what
033we did. Yeah. You're right. So I don't know another one of those magic one moments. What is your what is your opinion on? Like I say if a director wants to know how is that administration feel about him I don't see a problem with that, but I don't think I mean, none of that was ever a board initiative. Right. None of that was ever required by the board that administrators fill out an evaluation to it that I know of, that I was made aware of. I just knew that every year we as board members had to evaluate. Well, and let me put it this way. The private industry that I'm familiar with is. employees don't generally evaluate their boss. It's kind of you're evaluating the employee's job performance and that is supervisor-employee relationship and that's,
034you're gonna get a fair assessment that way because it's a tool not only to determine how you're doing as an employee, but also where you got to improve. It's like the board self-evaluation. Where we screw it up and we need to fix it, you know. It's kind of the cart before the horse. Yeah, exactly. Calibri was coming from the wrong way. Yeah. So, you know, I'm in favor of just, you know, just having the evaluation be the board of the director. It's what the law says. It simplifies it, yeah. There's just a requirement of us that we're supposed to evaluate our subordinate. It's not as much data, yeah. And, you know, so. I'm fine with that personally. So, Dr. Powell, you got any? No, sir. Okay. Feelings on that one way or the other? Well,
035I'm like you. The director is the board's employee, and if the director wants information from teachers, then that would be his or her privilege of getting that for their own information, not to present to the board or the board meeting or anything. Right. And it kind of puts people on the spot when you're evaluating your boss. I think that's kind of hard to ask people to do that. Pretty much tell you what the answer is going to be to that one. Yeah. Do what? So you can pretty much know what the answer for that. If you're evaluating your boss, you pretty much know what the answer is going to be. Oh, yeah. All right. Not necessarily, but I think that's an uncalled for measure just to. Does it matter? Simplify. Yeah, he's stirring the pot.
036I'm in favor of simplifying. Okay, so we probably want to take this thing and cut it down. Dr. Powell has graciously supplied us three examples of local schools. I think Lincoln County one is interesting. Yeah. So we may not be able to whack through all this today because we've got about 10 minutes left here. So this needs to be done soon, though. We need to have an evaluation instrument, although are we required to evaluate an interim director? You know, that's... I think we should. I think we're supposed to because even whether he's interim or director, he is still fully invested with the duties and powers by law of the state of Tennessee as a director of school. Yeah. So which means we need to get this process going because it needs to be done by
037April, I believe. Let me give you a whole bunch of bad ones. Yeah. Our policy says we have to have it done by the beginning of April or the end of April. It's April. April, I think, is ours. Yeah. So if we reconvene this committee again in January and came up with an instrument then, then we could get that out in plenty of time to have it done. So why don't we do that? Everybody on the committee take a... Take these and come up with some suggestions. I mean... Yeah, and what I like about you know, the Manchester one here is they they have your evaluation data But they also have you know, if you look back here annual objectives, so So I kind of, yeah, I kind of, you know, prefer this, but if
038everybody will take these and mark it up and we will reconvene, I guess, in January sometime in this committee and try to finalize an instrument so we can get it done and, you know, what other ideas we can get, but I kind of like modeling it on this, you know. And, of course, I suggested the other day that maybe the director's performance evaluation is, did you do a good job, yes or no? That would simplify it. But I think we need to have more than that. But I really kind of like this Manchester one. So we're credit as due. I tell homeless don't look bad either. No, I mean, I'm talking to Pat. Yeah. Yeah, one of those two. I like it when I do Lincoln County. Yeah. Lincoln County is a little interesting. That's
039what I was, maybe combine the two, you know, and we can do that whenever we come back. And that's, again, that's what Pat was telling me. Yeah, the problem with Lincoln County is there's a lot of written stuff that it's hard to, how do you consolidate all that stuff? There's a whole lot of assuming on that one. Yeah. And yeah, so yeah, maybe combining, you know, look at ours and then combine these two and we will come up with a final instrument. We'll set up a meeting in January. That's a great idea. We have a lot of committee meetings coming up, but a lot of stuff to do. Anything else? Any other comments? So no action item on this on the agenda for Monday. And then we got our action items for the director search.
040So I think unless there's nothing else, we can wrap this committee meeting up. It's been very beneficial today. I think we've got a lot accomplished. Two committee meetings in two hours. This is like a record for this current board. You might want to write the Guinness World Book of Records there or something. Exactly. When and if the board votes Monday at the board meeting on the TSBA, whatever their selection process is there, will you notify Tammy and then she'll start getting back with you on times to come in and do an orientation with the board and everything? Yeah, I think you and I will have to sign the contract, so the board will authorize us to sign the contract will be the motion. And then... And then we'll have to get with Tammy and get
041going on this right away. Whether Tammy will actually come in or whether it's someone from their office, I'm not sure how they operate. Tammy may be the one that comes in and does the orientation and goes over all their information with us. Yeah, and then they get staff working on this. Of course, you're going to have to have some data. As you noticed, I think the one from Milan, because they like to put out information about the school system, students, schools, how many is here, how many students you have. what your breakdown is as far as ethnicity, as far as special ed kids. You can look at that model. Right that was a little brochure that they that they come out with right? But I don't know what all she won't know and it's some
042history about the school system But that's shouldn't be a big problem. Yeah, and I wouldn't at all be opposed putting like a budget summary in there, too You know most of that what our budget is that so they know what they're working with? You can fill us in on most of the Data that we have to have to put in there right if they've time he wants that dad. I don't know. All right Can I? Oh, yeah. I thought you were pointing to something. We've got to have a budget committee meeting next Wednesday. I think we answered the questions we were possibly going to talk about then. I think we answered those earlier today, correct? I both yeah well as far as yeah, but we're still gonna have the meeting about the other part on
043Wednesday There was some question that there was going to be resolved in the budget committee meeting about whether you wanted to direct If we were gonna have to change the stuff you are directors to look at any specific areas So whether you really didn't still have that or not, we may end up can't Yeah, we have a budget committee meeting here yes at 3 and then after that you got to go down the hall Okay, this is next this is Thursday got a capital outlay at 3 to budget at 4 okay Capital projects. Yeah. Yeah. Capital projects. Well, we can bring this. I didn't set it up, so I don't know. Yeah. It will be there. We can take this committee meeting to a close, and then we can hash out other stuff. So we're.
044Had fun.