CorpusRecord 157675

Duncanville ISD Board Meeting December 16, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Duncanville ISD
Date
2024-12-17
Location
TX
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,081 words · about 34 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening. I, Dr. Lasanya Flowers, President of the Duncanville ISD Board of Trustees, call this meeting of the Duncanville Independent School District to order. Let the record show that a quorum of the Board of Trustees is present, that the meeting has been duly called, and that notice of this meeting has been posted in accordance with the Texas Open Meetings Act, Texas Government Code Chapter 551. We will move to opening ceremonies. Trustee Vera Cruz, will you open us in a word of prayer? Thank you, Madam President. Good evening, everyone. Please join me for a word of prayer. Lord, we commit this evening's meeting to you, for we have been chosen for such a time as this. Thank you that your presence in tonight's meeting sets us apart. We pray for favor and protection over all students,

002administration, and campuses and their leaders as we approach this Christmas season. We pray for rest and rejuvenation in the new year 2025. Thank you for the simple but life-changing message of your love for us. May we live in the light of your salvation. In Jesus' name, amen. We will now move on to the superintendent's report. I will turn the meeting over to Dr. Goree. Thank you very much, Dr. Flowers, and good evening to all of our board trustees members assembled today, as well as everyone in the audience assembled today. I'd certainly like to start off by wishing everyone a Merry Christmas and a very Happy New Year, and to reiterate the importance of finding that time to rest, recharge, and rejuvenate yourself as we go into the year 2025. Today, December 16th, 2024, I would

003like to highlight some of the exciting things that have happened in our district over the last month. The cover picture here is a wonderful opportunity that I had to be the mystery guest at the professional development for our instructional support staff last week. I really had a wonderful time visiting with them. about the importance of teamwork and about the importance of us making sure that we're always working as a collaborative team to achieve the best results for our boys and girls. I certainly would like to start off by really just pouring out all the pride, all of the excitement that I have for our football team. Let's be clear. Our Duncanville football team had a wonderful season with a 13-1 record. Let me tell you a little bit about this team. This team has only

004lost two games in the last three years. This team, over the last seven years, has played in the state championship five times, and yes, they are and will forever be back-to-back state champions. That's something to clap for, folks. Words cannot express how proud I am of Coach Samples, the entire coaching staff, and all of the boys for the wonderful job they did for truly exemplifying and making sure that everyone knows that we are a city of champions, truly a class act. And we want to give them one more round of applause. We are super excited as we launch the Expiring Principals Program. This is a highly selective cohort aimed at cultivating the next generation of exceptional campus leaders. This innovative program is designed to equip... participants with the tools, strategies, and confidence needed to lead

005their campuses with vision and impact. We're really excited because this was, again, I'll reiterate, a very selective process to select the first three people that will participate in this prestigious program within our school system. Their commitment to rigorous programming is critical to their success, and we know that we have to build a bench of success if we're to have leaders prepared to sit in the principal's seat. At this time, I do believe our first participants are in the room, and as I call your name, if you'll just stand, we want to certainly recognize you. We have Arnetta Bankster, and Arnetta is the assistant principal at Hastings Elementary. It's Arnetta. We also have Evelyn Carter, who is assistant principal at Duncanville High School. And last, we have Shaquita Miller, who's assistant principal at Reed Middle School.

006Again, we're so excited with the impact they will make, not only as they go through this prestigious program, but when they're in principal seats very, very soon. Congratulations. At this time, I would like to wish a huge congratulations to Giselle Moreno. She is the first student in the class of 2025 to receive a full-ride scholarship offer to an Ivy League school. She has been accepted at Princeton University through the prestigious Quest Bridge program. A dedicated and accomplished student, she is currently ranked number five in her class. You know, we were talking in communications today about the wonderful publicity and the wonderful opportunities that our football team has provided us to showcase the incredible things that happen in our district. And that's certainly one of the biggest leaders of that effort is our own quarterback, Keelan

007Russell. We congratulate Keelan Russell. on being named the National Gatorade Player of the Year. And let me tell you a little bit about what this means. This means that every child is playing college football in the country. Our own Keelan Russell has been recognized as an outstanding player there. So we're so proud of Keelan. Trevon Diggs of the Dallas Cowboys, and who is also a University of Alabama player, came out to personally present the program. We're so excited that Gatorade Player of the Year's are not only the best of the best in their respective sports, but they also are role models and leaders of the field. Russell is a member of the Duncanville National Honor Society and has volunteered locally with the Big Brothers and Big Sisters organizations, distributing turkeys to the Duncanville community as

008part of a joint effort with the Dallas Cowboys as well. Russell has also maintained a 3.4 grade point average in the classroom and plans to enroll at the University of Alabama next fall where he will play football. Let's give Keelan a huge round of applause. And clearly from all of those wonderful recognitions, you see that it's always a great day to be a Panther. And again, we continue to celebrate our Panthers as they do great things, as we continue to make better opportunities and better situations for children. Again, happy holidays, and I wish you all the best in this holiday season. Thank you, Madam President. Thank you, Dr. Goree. I'm sorry, will you go back to the slide with the young lady that was accepted at Princeton? There you go. That one. I just wanted

009to make a note. This is one of the young ladies that went on the college tour that Mr. Kane does. And so I just wanted to make sure that we were aware, the board and the community, just going on that college tour. That was her first time being there, and her interest for attending was sparked there. we are seeing byproducts and results of just exposing our students on these college tours. So I just wanted to make sure I put a note there. And thank you, Dr. Flowers, for that too. And I will say that Mr. Cain is doing an incredible job of exposing our students to all the opportunities and possibilities, not only within our state, but across our country too. And thank you, Principal Burns. He's on the picture there. I see he's in

010the audience today too. For all that we're doing to support this space of really growing children is to think. dream as far as they possibly can. So for all of our sponsors and people that have money that they don't know what to do with, you may donate toward the college tours. Thank you, Madam President. At this time, we'll have recognitions by Ms. Wallace. Good evening, President Flowers, Board of Trustees, and Dr. Goree. It is a pleasure to share with you all the donations that we have received this month or since last board meeting. As you can see here, some of the large donations from the Carter Blood. care center we have received funds that are going towards our student council and then we also receive a cash donation from Kona I Southwest Dallas as well

011as Epsilon Sigma Alpha with the Panther Pantry have made cash donations the remaining donations were items that support different efforts here in our school district and we have so many I have to flip the page and so it is It's always a wonderful feeling to know that your community is in full support of all that is available or all that we have going on here in our district. And so we truly just pause a moment to say thank you to our community for always stepping up and supporting our efforts. Are there any questions about the donations that we've received? Thank you. And next we can move into... made with pride. It is always a pleasure to celebrate our students, our staff, and our teachers. And so at this time, I am going to check the

012room. One of our participants, I don't know the weather could have kept him from not making it here this evening, but it is our student. And when I tell you he is precious. He is precious. And so I'm going to read a little bit about Kendon. Kendon is a first grader at Merrifield Elementary School, and he is a natural leader who inspires both peers and teachers with his focus, kindness, and integrity. He was nominated by Mrs. Jones, one of his teachers, because he encourages others, he builds trust, and fosters positive classroom affairs. positive classroom environment. He's always thinking ahead and Kendon solves problems and adapts to challenges with resilience. His commitment to excellence both academically and personally sets a high standard and ensures every classmate feels valued. We are so proud because Kendon is made

013with pride in Duncanville. Although he's not here, he may be tuned in online. Let's give him a round of applause. At this time is Miss Flat Ferguson in the room. Hi, we are super excited to recognize you. This is Miss Tara Flat Ferguson everyone and she is a special education teacher at Smith Elementary School. And she is dedicated to her students and colleagues. She mentors new teachers and she fosters a culture of growth. She was nominated by Doria Telsa, a colleague of hers, because she says that you are trustworthy and you have integrity and resilience. And you create an inclusive environment where students thrive. As both an inclusion resource and self-contained teacher, she says that you set high expectations and you celebrate the achievements of your students. You're always inspiring them to reach their full

014potential. And for these reasons, Mrs. Flat Ferguson, your commitment to excellence, we name that you are made with pride here in Duncanville. Congratulations. and friends of Ms. Black Ferguson please stand. Family and friends stand to be recognized. And we call this moment the end. Thank you all. And at this time, we have an entire crew that we're gonna invite up here. This group is from our warehouse. If I can please have Mr. Rocha, Mr. Gonzalez, Mr. Willis, and Mr. Hanna, please join me at the podium. time if y'all want to face the board and i'm going to read a little bit about you and really i could go on for a really long time talking about all of the amazing things and how supportive and how they serve here here throughout our district but this

015is our duncan-veliestee warehouse drivers luis rocha Rudy Gonzalez and Corey Willis. Mr. Hannah, Joe Hannah, he was not able to join us tonight, but they stand out because of their professionalism, their reliability, and their positive attitude. Whether they are assisting nutrition services during staff shortages or exceeding expectations with intra-district mail deliveries, their dedication ensures a smooth operation, making a positive impact. on staff and students. They were nominated by Mrs. Zamora and she says that they provide exceptional service and that is why they are made with pride in Duncanville. And if they have family and friends, please stand. Thank you at this time if I can get miss flat Ferguson to join and we're gonna take a group picture madam president dr. Glory will you guys come down and join them in the picture in board

016members if you'll just stand where you are and We will have Hillary and Jeff organize y'all for a group picture Now let's take a look at their video Steve congratulates the following students, staff member, and teacher who are made with pride in Duncanville. My name is Kim Van Garner and I am a first grade student from Maryfield Elementary. My favorite part of the day is learning. I like to help other people because I am a nice and smart. When I grow up, I want to be a football player. I want to play running back for the Cowboys. I like to play on the playground and open Christmas presents. I want people to know about me, that I'm seven years old and my favorite color is blue. And I will take my chances for nominating me.

017Hi, I'm Tariq. I am a special education teacher over at Smith Elementary. My teaching philosophy is meet the kids where the kids are. Find what they need to make them be successful. It's just me doing what I feel my job expectation is to be for these kids and the way I want my kids and grandkids to be treated as well. The favorite part of my job is the kids. It's the love, the passion that they show me when I'm teaching them and learning from them their different ways of learning. And the cool thing about my kids, I get to keep them multiple years. So we grow close, not just with the kids, with the families. So it's kind of a neat connection that I get that most teachers don't get. Hello, my name is Luis

018Rocha. I'm a driver for the warehouse. I worked at different places before, but when I started working here, and I'm used to, like, if there's a role that needs to be filled, and it's helping out either children, the people, and just get involved, you know, and helping each other out. And it's just something I enjoy, you know. Yes, the warehouse, it's a... Very close with each other. It's not a lot of us working here, but a few of us that do work here and the drivers I work with every day, we're like a small family, you know, and that makes us feel real proud of each other and what we do and just getting the job done together as a team. Yeah. Hi, my name is Rudy Gonzalez. I work at the warehouse. A regular

019day for me starts at 5 a.m., working at nutrition, helping them out. Then we come over here after we complete running a route, distributing food to the campuses. Then we get over here and we finish up the day by making delivery, custodial deliveries, also picking up furniture, whatever the campuses, whatever the ticket places out there. Most rewarding part of my job is being able to communicate with different individuals on a daily basis and making daily deposits into different individuals at the campuses. Hi, I'm Corey Willis. warehouse driver. The saving part of my day, the job pretty much is just interacting with the staff different because we go from campus to campus and just interacting with if it's just administrative teachers and just meet everybody throughout the district pretty much. I just want people to know

020we're here to help. It's just going there knowing that I'm going the extra mile for the students, the staff. or just whatever needs to be done. Us warehouse guys get the job done. These honorees truly are made with pride in Duncanville. We do not have any communications from citizens regarding a pending agenda item. We will now move to closed session. We are back from closed session. Is there a motion for more information on item 7G? Is there a second? Second. It's been motioned and second. We would like for Dr. Nix to come with a presentation on item 7G. Good evening, Madam President, members of the board. I agree. Historically, the curriculum adoption has rarely if ever garnered the level of attention that we're seeing around the state with this particular curriculum. So thank you for

021giving me the opportunity and the option to talk to you a little bit about it. Just two short years ago, we adopted a new curriculum for math. We came from STEM Scopes. We began to use Eureka and then just two years ago we went from HMH to Amplify. And that was a curriculum pushed by the state and we moved in that direction because Amplify and Eureka were highly qualified, what's called H-Chem, highly qualified instructional materials. Well we were informed this year that as of right now as of next year, Amplify and Eureka will no longer be considered highly qualified instructional materials. Districts are required by TEA to use curriculum and materials that are highly qualified instructional materials. So now districts across the state are having to shift the curriculum for K-5 if they're using Amplify

022and or Eureka. to a curriculum that meets the highly qualified instructional material requirements. So what we are doing is bringing for your consideration for approval the Bluebonnet curriculum. And the Bluebonnet curriculum is, it has a new name, but for the most part, it's the same curriculum. And so I'll break that down in just a second. There are some thoughts around this curriculum because there are elements of religious historical references in the curriculum. And so for an example, there is a kindergarten lesson, or we looked at kindergarten, first grade, fourth grade, things of that nature, lessons. So an example of this would be for one of the kindergarten lessons on being a good helper. This particular lesson references the Good Samaritan story. And it talks about why it's important to be a good helper. And it

023references the biblical narrative of the Good Samaritan. It also states historical references from Islam, Koran, things of that nature, that this is a story that's found in multiple religions. The lesson is not about religion. The lesson is about the standard or the teak that the student is supposed to learn. But this is an example of how it pulls from different historical religious undertones. So there are three reasons why we are asking you to consider this particular curriculum. And each of these reasons aligns with... our district's priorities and goals. So first, Bluebonnet is, excuse my throat, yes please, thank you. So first, Bluebonnet is not a completely new curriculum. Thank you very much. I'm sorry, I just had that good food I was trying to, thank you very much. Bluebonnet, thank you so much. First, Bluebonnet

024is not a completely new curriculum. It's an enhanced version of Eureka and Amplify. And the reason I say this is because we took a look at the actual material. This ties into our priority one, student academic success, and priority three, personnel and professional development. This Blue Bonnet curriculum has been tailored to align with the Texas essential knowledge and skills. It retains the same instructional approach grounded in the science of learning and research based in best practices. Its notable highlights or that it has a stronger alignment to STAR than did Eureka and Amplify. It has the same proven instructional approach, the same lesson frameworks, the same resources. It has extended reading skills, lessons and taught from third grade supporting literacy and development. It has enhanced instructional guidance. We have so many new teachers, so many teachers

025that are coming into the profession that are getting certified or alternatively certified, and to be guided through the curriculum is a huge piece that we want to consider in terms of setting them up for success. This helps us to do that. And there's tighter alignment to the rigor in the format of STAR. So these enhancements make it easier for us and seamless for us to transition to Bluebonnet because from the teacher experience, they're not going to notice any change. The curriculum will look the same. The format will look exactly the same. They won't notice any difference. It will just be a name change for them. In addition to that, the second reason that we're asking for approval of this or the second thing that we were thinking and processing through is all of the challenges

026and all of the changes that we are supporting our teachers through. We potentially will be looking at renovating several campuses next year, which will mean some movement. We are potentially looking at so many new things that we want to minimize change and disruption to the learning environment with the teacher. So this curriculum will help with that because we have invested so much in training our teachers for how to. Implement this curriculum for the internalization process. We've worked so hard on the lesson frameworks on the curriculum documents on the Assessments and the alignment of those assessments amplify and Eureka are out weekly with our campuses to help provide professional development for them They are just getting comfortable with what we have And so that continuity, we wanted to just keep that momentum going as we're experiencing

027all these shifts with our teachers so that the training doesn't stop and it continues for them. And lastly, tied to our priority four, fiscal stewardship and operational excellence. This particular curriculum is of financial benefit for us because of the LASSO III grant that is tied to this curriculum. With Bluebonnet, the state has incentivized our rule of this curriculum by providing us with $40 per student plus an additional $20 per student for printed materials if we move forward with this Bluebonnet curriculum. In addition to that, the grant, LASSO 3, that we are applying for to support with this curriculum, the implementation of this curriculum, means that there's no cost to the district. And as a matter of fact, other curriculums that we looked at, for an example, if we decided to stay with Amplify, for an

028example, Amplify is no longer a highly qualified instructional material. So we would be out of compliance with the state. In addition to that, we could use Amplify. and find other highly qualified instructional material to supplement that, but we would have to pay for that. It would come out of our pocket. And because of our current financial situation, we want to be as fiscally responsible as possible, which is why we're bringing this for your consideration. In addition to that, there are other ramifications for not going with Blue Bonnet. If we choose not to go with Blue Bonnet, we will lose funding for our federal accountability campuses. We have five of those. And the funding for those campuses is very important for us to be able to continue that improvement for students. So those are the three

029reasons. Number one, because really it's not a different curriculum. It's a renamed curriculum. But all of the elements would be so similar that it would be seamless for our teachers. Number two, because we have invested so much in the training and development of our teachers in our curriculum, we really don't want to be that disruptive as we head into next year with everything that we're doing. And lastly, because of fiscal responsibility and the last O3 grant that we have a very good chance of getting as a high-priority campus. it would take care of the financial need for moving forward with this curriculum. So it would be my pleasure to answer any questions that you may have at this time. My first question is, what makes Blue Bonnet highly qualified? You know, what constitutes highly qualified

030is that it's deemed that way by the State Board of Education. And so... The state board determines what is and what is not highly qualified, and I don't have access to that rubric. Same question for me is, just in full transparency, why would the state board of education say that Amplify and Eureka are highly qualified one year and not the next? Right. But those are the mandates that they provide for us, and so we have to adhere to those. So the state just gives us a list of they consider these people highly qualified. Are there any programs, the curriculum, on the state list that do not have biblical references? Yes. So for an example, there's a curriculum on the iReady, as an example. iReady is a company that we partner with, and they have curriculum

031that doesn't have any biblical references tied to it. Here's the challenge with that. I ready we would still lose funding for our federal accountability campuses which means that we would then incur that cost as a district number two if we went with as an example I read I'm just giving an example we would not get the sixty dollars per student allocation So that would not be something that we would get once again tying it to our priority for which is fiscal responsibility and Lastly if we go with I ready there is a complete overhaul with our curriculum department our frameworks our scope and sequence our timeline our Assessments our professional development for teachers our implementation. They'd have to learn a whole new curriculum. We have to train them that's the disruption piece that we were

032trying to avoid and if i could add to that's something that we did just two years ago so we're really trying to be consistent and give this an opportunity to work for students and is there a number or a way to say Blue Bonnet has 21 different references because it's really not just biblical because some of it is other religions as well. So I'll say religious instead of biblical has a certain amount of references, religious references. Yes. So from what we have found and bought with your permission, I have a printout that I would like to share with you just as a reference. So I've prepared for this. So I'm going to approach the dice if that's okay. Oh, sure. This looks like it was planned. It was not. So, Board, what you are looking

033at is as we have gone through the curriculum, we have identified, and I just want to say this for the public, this curriculum is a public curriculum. Anyone can access this curriculum. It's on TEA's website. It's open for anyone to see, to vet, and it has been such since they've released for several months. So what we have been able to find is, as an example, the golden rule. This is a lesson that I just shared with you. This is found in Unit 7, Lesson 1, where it identifies. The golden rule and identifies multiple religions that this is found in right and but just as a historical reference You'll see fifth graders. They have a lesson Steeped around the Last Supper where the fifth graders learn about Leonardo da Vinci's painting, which is based on the

034Christian Bible story of Jesus's last meal. So that's an example of a historical reference in the curriculum. You'll see the parable of the prodigal son where this story comes from the book of Luke in the New Testament. And so there are historical references to teak based standard lessons that we have. All of the lessons that there are, we found, I'm going to use the term minimal, but it depends on what you determine as minimal. Right. In terms of an entire curriculum. Thank you. Any additional questions? Yeah, I've got a few. Coach McNeely? To start off with, what does LASSO stand for? LASSO stands for? Oh, Coach, give me one second. Learning, yes, yes, thank you. Yeah, there it is, there you go, there, very good. Learning Accelerated Support Opportunities Grant. And we're currently in cycle

035three. And this is a grant, Ms. Mignitti, this is a grant that we have applied for for, I believe, the last three cycles. So this is the cycle one, cycle two, to one-year grant. And TA will, it's already planning for the fourth year of that grant. Thank you. Examples are not bad. It says, but then do we have any examples of it referencing other religion other than just the biblical ones? The preparation looks like. The federal dollars are tied just to this? Yes, you know in full transparency, Mr. McNeely, they know what they're doing. In terms of... really incentivizing Bluebonnet and wanting us to use Bluebonnet and Really making it advantageous advantageous for districts to use Bluebonnet and if you don't it's your choice but you'll have to pay for the things that go along

036with that and In addition to that, you know lose funding for other things that you need. So it's all about the money So what I've just handed to you board if you'll turn to page 13 This is just an example to answer Mr. McNeely's question about examples of other religious references. And for anyone that would like to follow, once again, I'm in Lesson 1 of Unit 7 for Kindergarteners. This is just an example. But if you look at page 13, you'll see there where there are references, variations of the golden rule from several faiths. And if you see there, it lists Buddhism. It lists Christianity. It lists Hinduism. It lists Islam. It lists Judaism. And it lists Sikhiism. I hope that I didn't say that wrong. My pronunciation of it. In essence, it's really just

037stating that the golden rule is found in multiple religious historical perspectives, and then they get to the business of teaching the standard of the golden rule. The part that gets me is if it was high last year, now it's not. But now there's no changes, but it's not. Well, there are several changes to the content in terms of, you know, Amplify and Eureka last year was more tied to Common Core than to the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills. What they have done this year with Blue Bonnet is take that same framework and align it to the Texas knowledge and skills. And when you say they, are you talking about the company? TEA. TEA. Texas Education Agency. So TEA is controlling the federal money coming through, too. So, okay. So it's all the state doing it.

038Yes, sir. Trustee Colton? Excuse me. Thank you, Dr. Nix. So this Bluebonnet learning is a totally new curriculum. I mean, you mentioned Eureka and Amplify, but is Bluebonnet totally new as far as the company or the curriculum? The reason I'm hesitating is because it's the same format, it's the same everything, they just changed the name. It is a new version of what they released in years past. So it's not necessarily a different company. And what they do is they go side by side to show that there's very little... difference in the format so that if a teacher were teaching this curriculum they wouldn't notice any difference how they would frame the lesson is still how they would frame the lesson where they go to look for guidance would still be the everything would look the

039exact same it's a new name If I can help with that a little bit, if you don't mind, Trustee Colton, is that when you look at the implementation for a teacher, it is critical that we have high-quality materials. It is what has supported our teachers where they are in the implementation. So what they did that was smart was they gave it the same structure. So for a teacher who may be working on their certification, it's... easier for them to implement that curriculum and see better success from students. Now, when you talk about context, some of the stories, some of those are different, but the format and the structure is the exact same as what the teachers have become accustomed to over the last two years. Okay, but the content is different. That's what we're talking

040about tonight. Right. Some of the stories may be different. The references may be different. So, what is the term? One year. One year starting? Starting at the 25-26 school year. Okay, so the upcoming school year. And when do we have to make a decision on this? Well, we're bringing it for your consideration tonight because there is a deadline for the grant application. So we would need to make a decision this evening if indeed we're going to qualify for the grant because the grant has a deadline of... This semester and what is the amount of the grant? Well the grant cover it's not necessarily the amount of the grant the grant covers as Many students as we have that need the material Okay, so it's $60 per student. How many students are there? I mean is

041that Am I mixing them? No, you're correct in that. We don't have that do we have four thousand seven hundred students from K to five in Duncanville Okay, four thousand six hundred ninety nine exactly Right. The curriculum will cover all of our K-5 students throughout the district. What was the number you said again, Sam? $4,699 rounded up to 4,700 students K-5. At $60 per student, you're going to be looking at around $282,000. About $282,000. $282,000. Dr. Nix, as well, doesn't that cover some of the work with the professional development support that we'll get with that? Absolutely. So that is just what we get per student. We're going to get approximately $75,000 per campus, per content. And 50% of that would go to the service provider that helps with our training and our implementation, and 50%

042of that would go to the district. And one thing, too, I'll add to that, too, when you look at those, that's the professional support and making sure that the implementation is done correct is really critical with our current teaching base. So I believe in the past we've had a curriculum review committee, if I recall. You probably. I can agree. Yeah, so did that happen, this go around? Absolutely. You want to speak to how you did evaluate these curriculums as we looked at what to bring forward? Thank you. So we absolutely took a look at our curriculums. What adds the most value? Of course, those curriculums are internal with our teachers and our support staff, K, early literacy, curriculum instruction department. And we took a look at what is it that we are trying to accomplish.

043What is going to help us accomplish that? And then what is the data trending and what is it showing us? Which is why I listed for you the three-party reasons that we were really looking at bringing this particular curriculum to you. Those are the things that came up in our... Yeah, it seems like parents, you know, have participated in the past. you know because of what we're talking about you know tonight I think it would be helpful to get input from those outside of you know the staff regarding you know what their students are going to be confronted with as far as curriculum is concerned. Are you familiar with you know, public review of the curriculum in the past, or at least, you know, parents participating as a part of the process? Yes, ma'am. I'm

044familiar with that. Historically, that has not been a part of the process when we are adopting curriculum here. The process that we historically have used is the process that we used this time with the curriculum. But more to, you know, we can adopt whatever process that you would like for us moving forward. Okay, so is it recorded? Did we receive a letter stating that, you know, if we don't go with Blue Bonnet that we'll lose all this funding? Is that recorded anywhere? Oh, yes, ma'am. Absolutely. Okay. And I guess, you know, I would like to have a copy of that just so I can understand. Yes, ma'am. Because if there are other like it was mentioned that if we go with I ready It's considered a highly qualified Instructional material, but if we go with

045that one we'll miss out on the 60 per student Correct? That is absolutely correct. Yeah. So, I mean. In addition to funding for our targeted federal accountability campuses. So even though it's highly qualified instructional material. The state knows what they're doing. Okay. All right. Thank you. And I am so excited to have this conversation and to really speak to this, too, because so many wonderful ideas about how we will, as we move forward, ensure that not only the board but the community is involved and has the information that you need to make these decisions. Really excited about the conversation. Trustee Fahey? I'm trying to make this simple for me. It's less core but more Texas. With the teacher format being the same. Yes, ma'am. But scoring for our kiddos would preferably go up because of

046the Texas touch. Is that? Ideally, that is exactly correct. Because it's better aligned to the standards and the TEKS, then there's less work for us to try to make it aligned. I see. Yes, ma'am. Okay, thank you. It's the money. It's the money. I got a few work, but I'll keep my words to myself because I like where I live and my wife will get me. I just... So the states made it clear that the federal money and the other money wouldn't go with if we didn't do anything but this one. You know... The reason that I appreciate this conversation is, as Dr. Reese stated, as we look at districts all around, this conversation is being had in boardrooms all over the state for multiple reasons, whether it's because of the money tied to it

047or because of the religious undertone or aspect or because of other curriculums wanting to be used. So that's why it's so important for us to bring you a recommendation of how we feel we can best move forward for our district, for our children. But to your point, Mr. McNitty, they've been very clear about what they will and will not incentivize. And it's out there for everyone to see. So it's a situation that, you know, here in Duncanville, we are committed to doing what's best for children and what's best for our teachers. So whatever direction you guys give us, we are going to take and we're going to execute. This recommendation is simply what we feel would help us to do that. in the most expedite manner. Is this Blue Bonnet, is this a company? Blue

048Bonnet is not a company. That's just the name of the curriculum. Somebody's got to put the curriculum together. Is it a company? Yeah, it's TA. They own it, yes. Yeah, it's a Texas. We know who owns them. I'm sure we can follow the money. Well, I mean, we are just seeing. The voucher thing duplicated. This isn't our first conversation. If then, if you do this, then you can have that. And this is another instance when if we do this, then they'll do this. And so. I'm glad to know that we're not compromising student needs for money. That's not what this conversation is about. It is just getting a clear understanding or making sure that we understand that our hands are really not necessarily tied because we could not do it, but there's a direct correlation

049between providing the support that's needed. to our students and acquiescing to not really their recommendation, but this is the only thing that they'll endorse for us to receive the funding. Trustee Colton. So would you say that this is the best curriculum available? Trustee Colton, I believe that from what we have reviewed and what we looked at and who we have spoken to, we have found that of all of the people that I have spoken to and we've talked to, individuals who were using or majority of districts who were using Amplify and Eureka for the most part are staying with Bluebonnet because of the consistency in the curriculum. Districts who were not using Amplify and not using Eureka in the past for the most part may be using something else because it's not as disruptive to

050them. So for all of the things that we look at, For where we are going and how we positioned ourselves as a district, we have determined that this is the best curriculum for us moving forward. For what we have trained for, for what our curriculum documents are prepared to support teachers to do, and for what we need our students to learn. So this is why we're bringing this recommendation to you. Thank you, Dr. Neal. At this time, we'll take action on items discussed in closed session. Consider approval of consent agenda items. We'll move to 7C, financial reports. Yes. We can vote on your consent. We can vote on. At this. Go ahead. At this time, I ask for a motion to vote on our consent agenda. I make a motion that we hold a vote

051now on our consent agenda. All in favor, please raise your right hand. Any questions? I'm sorry. We don't have to raise our hands anymore. I'm all discombobulated. Any questions? Comments? Okay. You may vote electronically. Okay. So we'll go the old school way. Please vote by raising your right hand. Okay. We're back. Okay. All in favor, please raise your right hand. Motion carries 5-0. Any opposed? Motion carries 5-0. We will now move to communication from citizens. We have received one communication card. Before you make your way to the front, please allow me to read the following. State law prohibits board members from responding to speakers in public forum unless the topic regards a matter specifically posted on tonight's agenda. The board will carefully consider any concerns expressed and an administrator will investigate the matter. At your

052request, the administrator will contact you regarding your concern. Speakers will limit their comments to three minutes. If more than five speakers are present, speakers must limit their comments to two minutes. If delegations of more than five people plan to speak on the same topic, they should appoint one representative to speak on their behalf or be limited to five speakers. Any discussion concerning specific personnel is prohibited in open session. If you wish to address the board regarding a personnel matter, please contact the superintendent's office to schedule the matter for a future closed session meeting. Having stated that, when I call your name, please come forward, state your name and your address, and you have three minutes to address the board. Dale Kaiser. Good evening, trustees, Dr. Goree. Good to see you all again. My name is

053Dale Kaiser. I reside at 534 Frank Kiesler Boulevard, Duncanville, Texas, 75116. My appearance has changed a little bit since the last time I visited with y'all. I participated in No Shave November for men's health. trying to bring awareness to the issues that men in our society face on a daily basis. And now I'm just trying to decide whether it's going to stay or whether it's going to go. This evening, I'm here to talk to you about a couple of things. First of all, we still have employees bringing home less than they did last year, almost $1,000 less, and I'm one of them, than we did last year. Those same employees are being asked to do more and more. I asked last time for a stipend, but this time I'll ask for something that the cost

054should be very minimal. Give teachers one of the three PDCE days back. We used to have two of them. Now we have three, including January the 3rd. On top of January 3rd that we have to take our time on our calendar to go and do professional development to get off when we used to have it off, this last two weeks on December 4th and 11th while we were in the middle of testing, We had to do an additional hour or so of professional development on those two Wednesdays. Now, the professional development was quite informative. However, many of our teachers were tired because they had been testing all day. So, trustees, Dr. Goree, I have a suggestion for you. Pick a date, January 3rd, May 27th, May 28th. Give one of those days back to your

055teachers. Say, teachers, we appreciate you. We encourage you to go and do professional development. We know that you're doing the best that you can and the best for our students. And so we're going to give you a day back because we appreciate you. The second thing does have a cost, however. We still need additional safety and security help at the high school. Mr. Byrd and the administration cannot be everywhere all the time. We don't know exactly who in the building should be there because maybe 1% of our students actually wear their ID badges. I challenge you to come to Main Street on any given day between now and next Friday and see how many ID badges you see moving around the building. They don't have ID badges. Today we had another school shooting. This should

056never happen. We have to have more security at our school to make sure that Duncanville High School is not on the news for all the wrong reasons. I've also had faculty and staff tell me they're tired of coming to school and inhaling marijuana. They can't be everywhere all the time. So we need additional safety and security help at the high school. We're not a college. We're not a university, even though we're just as big as some of the colleges and universities around. We need the help. Dr. Goree, we need the help. Trustees, we need the help. Thank you and Merry Christmas. Thank you. Thank you for coming to our meeting. Being that there is no further items to discuss this meeting, I'd like to have a motion to adjourn the meeting. It's been motioned and

057seconded. The meeting is adjourned.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.