CorpusRecord 157787

Board of Education Meeting: 2.11.25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Elmbrook Schools
Date
2025-02-12
Location
WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,954 words · about 122 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening. I'd like to call this meeting to order. The required public notice of this meeting was sent to Community Newspapers Incorporated and Metropolitan Press on February 7th, 2025 and posted on the doors of the district office. Additionally, meeting notices and agendas were distributed to the City of Brookfield and the Village of Elm Grove for posting and posted on the district website. Let the roll call show that all board members are present. Will you please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance led by Isabel Perry? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Isabel. May I have a motion to approve the agenda? I move. Thank you, Jean. Made the

002motion. And Preetha seconded that. Is there any discussion? Hearing none, all those in favor of the motion, please say aye. Aye Any opposed thank you that carries on voice vote our first agenda item of the evening is the high school student representatives report Mark Thank You Scott would like to welcome our five student reps we're gonna start with quick updates from Brookfield East and then we'll go to Brookfield Central for an update and then we'll come back to our topic Brookfield East what's going on Sure. So for our arts highlights, Genesis Acapella competed and placed second at ICHSA quarterfinals. They are moving on to the semifinals on March 15th, and they also hosted a mock performance for the school during an excellence period on Friday. Unaccompanied need minors, the co-ed acapella group is also competing

003at ICHSA this weekend, and we have the spring play coming up. For our activities highlights, we had FBLA Region 7 Conference. On February 1st, we had 20 individuals qualify for state. Freshman information night was January 28th. We had several clubs and sports have tables at that, and many freshmen got informed on the school. Brookfield East forensics team placed third in the medium teams at the Sun Prairie West Tournament on February 1st. And Student Council hosted their annual Senior Bingo Night on February 6th with 45 senior citizens from the community attending. For our athletics highlights, the Spartanettes placed top five at state on February 2nd. The Varsity and JV Brookfield Boys Swim and Dive teams won conference championships. And the Brookfield East Wrestling Team won the battle for North Avenue against Brookfield Central 51-27. We also

004have spring sports season kicking off. For academic highlights freshmen sophomores and juniors partook in various hub periods during excellence to learn about and solidify their academic plans Scheduling for next school year also closed yesterday at 8 a.m And students are starting to look ahead to early May for AP testing. Thank you. How about at Brookfield Central? Yeah, so starting off with our academic highlights We recently learned that Brookfield Central has five US Presidential Scholar candidates in our senior class this year Kartik Ramachandrula was named a 2025 Regeneron Science Talent Search Scholar one of the country's most prestigious math and science competitions and we also had our class of 2025 valedictorian and salutatorian announced with Josh Wang as our valedictorian and Kartik Ramachandrula as our salutatorian moving on to activities student council's spirit of excellence portfolio

005was submitted to the Wisconsin Association for Student Council for review highlighting Brookfield Central's most important events and accomplishments throughout the last calendar year. All Brookfield Central FTC robotics teams qualified for state and our GearHeads team traveled to Madison to talk to senators about the program. GearHeads is also currently ranked sixth in the world. Our mock trial team qualified for state and we also had a successful senior ball on January 25th. Our DECA chapter is sending about 40 students to a state competition in Lake Geneva from the 23rd to 26th. For arts, we had our successful winter play from Thursday, January 30th through Saturday, February 1st. Our music students are looking forward to solo and ensemble competition on March 8th at BC. And we have our Lancerettes team going down to Disney World in Florida for

006a competition from this week Thursday through next week Monday. Moving on to athletics, our senior point guard Anthony Rise reached 1,000 career points. our boys ski team qualified for state which is the 16th and 17th upcoming and our boys swim team won the conference championship and will compete at sectionals on the 15th finally we had our successful unified game this past Friday February 7th with Brookfield East so great month for BC Great month for both high schools thank you busy places hey You guys had the topic of course selection some of you do not have to do course selection this year because you're aging out of our system congratulations some of you just did course selection let's hear some insights from you and your classmates on what you heard from folks related to course selection

007let's start with the first question what factors do you consider when choosing classes for next year who would like to start The factors that were considered at Brookfield East were a lot of people mentioned difficulty, rigor, and course load. They wanted to understand what they can achieve and they wanted to pick a level of difficulty that aligns with that. Additionally, a lot of people mentioned interests, passions, or intended major. This included if they found a subject fascinating or they knew that this was a course that would probably help them for what they wanted to major in. then lastly a lot of people mentioned the graduation requirements including the having to reach the certain amount of math classes or science classes and the Specific ones they have to hit to reach their social studies credit. Thank

008you Evan How about at Brookfield Central? So just adding on to that some of the factors that Brookfield Central had were prerequisites peer reviews on the classes themselves future goals and endeavors for jobs or technicians or technicians teachers class lengths and then graduation requirements as you stated similar answers from both sides you guys covered a little bit of a second question which was about interest in subject anything to add around what type of influence that has on course choices as you said we mentioned it it's the primary factor for most students at Brookville Central and then in addition to it there was rigor as she explained and The only thing it didn't really have much influence on was the credit fillers. So like PAD, personal finance, those type of classes. Isabelle, anything to add? Just

009repeating what he said, interest mostly happens with the extra classes outside of the required courses. We did find that 75% did say that it had a large influence, especially on that difficulty portion, on what level they should take, whether it be regular, honors, or even AP. And then especially with those electives on what they personally wanted to do guided them a lot towards their answer. We've worked really hard to make sure we have options that align well to future educational interests and career goals What did you guys hear from your classmates regarding that? 90% of our respondents believe that yes, they align very well. A lot of people mentioned the launch strands we have offered. I can speak from personal experience as I'm in the launch future teachers and it's been an amazing opportunity and

010I know for a lot of people in other strands to get that real life experience directly while you're still in high school. The many... ones that people said they felt there was a lack was with global studies, law, and politics. As they said, outside of AP HUG and AP GOV, there isn't a lot of options surrounding that area. Evan, anything to add from Brookfield Central? So we also got mostly yeses. We felt that there was lots of variety in business, engineering, and STEM specifically. The only critique that our school came up with is the fact that it might be a little too tailored for specific paths, and they wish there would be more variety in career clusters. Great, thank you. The last question is a question that we often ask to see if there are

011areas we can improve. What did you guys hear about one thing we could change to the course selection process? What would it be? So the number one thing we had was an easier format. We talked to Mr. Gritzmacher about this, and we were explaining how we wish there was an academic planner just as a course loadout so we could actually see it itself. And then another one was more alternating options. Alternating day? Yeah, alternating day options. So choir kids and band kids often have that, but they wish there were just a few more classes, because some classes totally could work well alternating. And it's a subject that it's always talked about, and it's a little difficult to actually put in place. And then the last one we had was offer launch for a single semester

012class. as many kids believe that they would take lunch if it wasn't their fall semester. Great, thank you. Isabelle, anything to add from EAST's perspective? Following with agreeance with a couple of them, all choice difficulties always come up. And we had a lot of people saying that they find the IC layout for course selections to be very unfriendly, especially a lot of freshmen mentioned it. So people who aren't familiar kind of don't understand it as much. But things that are new on our end is increased awareness surrounding required classes, especially the fine arts one. A lot of people don't realize that those are required, and they sometimes have to fix their schedule to make sure to get those courses in. Other people mentioned individual counselor meetings about scheduling. We do have group meetings, but they

013aren't very specific on the individual, and some people think it might be helpful that everyone can have that personal attention to have someone talk out what a good option for them would be. In addition, some people mentioned perhaps more cooking classes. I know we have those in the middle school, and I think some people might miss them. Is that because people want to eat? I think so. Okay, just checking. And then lastly, some people mentioned perhaps building into the layout explanations and descriptions because sometimes the names on the courses aren't exactly too intuitive. So perhaps getting a quicker option to those course descriptions or having them built into the system when you are picking courses. Thank you for that feedback. Evan, something to add? Yeah, so I just forgot this one point. The deadline date.

014So students find the deadline date to be a little too quick as say you're taking a class such as Honors English 10 right now. Depending on how difficult you are or how hard the class is, you can decide whether you want to take AP Lang, for example, in your junior year. A lot of kids take that jump or don't take that jump depending on how they're doing in the class. And they just wish the deadline date would be pushed to three-week grades of the third term. sorry I forgot about that one great thank you that's good feedback you guys recognize that you start the entire budget process for us with the course selection at the high school level and the middle school level that drives everything for us so moving the deadline gets really difficult

015to match some other timelines that we need to match but we'll certainly take it into consideration with that any questions from board members So thank you guys so much for your presentation. So I have a question and Isabel you touched on it a little bit. Do students feel like there is sufficient guidance for course selection from counselors or staff or the academic and career planning office? I do believe so. We have mandatory meetings with at the beginning of the year so in the fall there are counselor meetings that are organized by grade level. So like mine was I believe end of October where there was about 15 kids with my counselor and she went over here are the requirements you need for junior year. Here is what you can do to start prepping for college

016because that's something I'll have to think about for next year. But then I also think the accessibility for counselors are very High and often and you can sign up for individual meetings. So while I personally don't think we need to mandate individual meetings perhaps considering Promoting awareness of them. So saying like if you need help figuring out your schedule Here are the resources to directly go to your counselor. Anybody else have anything on that as well? As Isabelle said, there's a lot of opportunity. We have LancerLink that is plenty of opportunity for us to talk to teachers. Lancer Block, you can always go and sign up for a future teacher if you have questions about the class. And then we have our career day, or not career day, we have our course selection day, which

017is huge. It helps a lot of students figure out what gaps they need to put in their classes. So I fully agree that there's a sufficient amount of help with course selections. well that's great to hear thanks mary um thank you all as usual for keeping us in the loop on what's going on and i hope your heads don't get too big with that power that mark told you you have about driving everything we do with the budget um evan when when you heard some feedback about looking for more variety in the um clusters in launch did there were any specific recommendations that you heard there was no specifics um I know from last year that depending on, like, the internship you can get, it can tailor what cluster you're in. That can be something

018I check up on and bring back to you the following meeting. Sorry about that. Oh, no. If there are things, and they probably could go to Mrs. Farley and be more effective and come back to me, but it's good to know that. People are thinking beyond what's available and if they can add some information to that we can be more responsive to it. So thank you I tech add on that one. We did get a specific comment on that. Some people feel as there's a very large arrow towards the healthcare side of STEM and a lot of people would have liked to seen more STEM that isn't the engineering strand or the healthcare strand because we have a lot of different healthcare strands outside of launch including like anatomy and physiology and they would like

019to see like a different focus stemmed launch that goes outside of just medical. Good suggestions. Jean? You mentioned that a reduction in fine arts requirements was something that folks were thinking about and I must have missed the detail around that So I've never actually really had this problem I'm in orchestra so my fine arts credits get filled but I know that that alternating schedule and that ability to be in music isn't a opportunity for a lot of people and I think the large problem is when it comes to the fact that the fine arts classes are term classes and sometimes term classes get difficult to fit into the schedule and also some people just aren't very hands-on and they don't like having to take one of those fine arts classes so I think a lot

020of people would prefer a Reducement because then it doesn't mess with their scheduling abilities and they They get to take classes that they think they would enjoy and like, and I feel like some people just end up taking an art because they have to take an art and they don't enjoy what they're learning. And then I wondered, you talked about the availability to schedule to see a counselor. Is that an option for your Lancer Black and your equivalent at the east side? Sorry. We can schedule a meeting with our counselor at any moment during the day. There's 15 minute days. There's 15 minute meetings and there's 30 minute periods. All you have to do is send your counselor an email or schedule it on Calendly and you will be released from class. And I believe

021they can help you with anything you need during that time. But you couldn't like you could sign up to see a particular teacher during that time, right? But if you have the option to sign up for a counselor during that time would that be a fuller? necessarily So you cannot sign up on an efficiency for a counselor that being said you can still Schedule a meeting during that time to meet with the counselor. Thank you Any other questions or comments I have one. Evan, something you said kind of sparked this when you talked about the career clusters. And my question was, do students feel locked in when they take certain electives? So, you know, if I'm a sophomore or junior and I've started out, obviously with languages they probably do. I mean, when you start

022with Spanish, you kind of got to keep going with Spanish. But does it work with other electives, too, where you kind of start? in the woods area you kind of start down that path of medical and then you feel like well I'm kind of stuck in that is that a feeling for some of our upperclassmen or do you feel like well I did medical I don't really like that I'm gonna switch so if I could answer this a lot of the feedback that I've heard with this area I guess is that Whenever kids select their freshman maybe sophomore year courses as they're trying to explore career options and they put those electives in a lot of their other Slots are filled by those required courses and then once you get into junior year and you're

023starting your Applications for colleges and trying to figure out what you want to go into I think a lot of kids feel like they don't have the time to go change their focus I guess to a different career cluster based on their electives they're taking So I think it has more to do with the amount of slots that are filled by required classes than it does with necessarily feeling locked into that field because of the electives. Anyone else? If I may add, I believe that it's a very important thing to understand though, as feeling locked in, it's better to feel locked in in high school than in college. And having this ability to have an insight into what your job could be in the future is- Vital I would say My I can speak from

024personal experience as my sister was really thinking physical therapy was her calling and then she took launch and it wasn't but that's okay because It's an opportunity to discover if it's your calling or not. That's awesome. I mark. What do you call that a graduation? when students realize in high school that they shouldn't be following a certain career path. It's a lot cheaper than college tuition being wasted. Yeah, so tuition avoidance, I think he says. Tuition avoidance, right. Yeah, tuition avoidance. Yeah, helpful. That's insightful. Thank you. Anyone else? Any other board member questions or comments? Thank you for being here. I'm sure you have a lot to do to get ready for a regularly scheduled school day tomorrow, I hear. So I understand it's regularly scheduled at the moment. Yeah, say your yeah Beeping with

025the text message from that changes Okay, thank you. Thank you being here Our next agenda item is the citizens forum which is an opportunity for members of the community to address the board on items that fall within the purview of the board but are not on tonight's agenda and we do not have any request to speak during the citizens forum Which brings us to the consent agenda? I'll start with a motion, and then we'll ask if there's any items board members would like to pull. Does someone like to make a motion? I'll move approval of consent agenda as presented. Thank you, Jean and Preetha. Are there any items that board members would like to pull? Hearing none, all those in favor of the consent agenda as presented, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Thank you.

026That carries on voice vote and brings us to our action items for the evening. I've got a couple here. We're going to start tonight with the board vacancy. And it's with heavy heart that we remember that Linda's not with us. And with the passing of Linda Boucher, it obviously creates a vacancy on the board. There are some state statutes that govern this process, as well as some school district policies. And board members received an email. kind of summarizing from legal counsel some of the main points. And I've asked Jim Carroll to be here tonight. And so Jim, if you just maybe want to start out by giving us the 10,000 foot view in terms of statute and policy. And board members, I think on this topic, there's a couple of suggested motions in here and

027we could make other motions as well. But maybe we would start with discussion on this so we can kind of get our feelings on what we would like to do. And then as that becomes more clear with the consensus, we could entertain a motion. So Jim? Good evening, everybody. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess I first just wanted to say very briefly my condolences on Ms. Boucher's passing. Some of you know that I spent a few long days in this room sitting literally at her right hand, and she was very kind to me, hadn't really worked with me before, and we got through that process with good humor. So I was very sorry to hear of her passing. So to, as you said, Scott, to provide a kind of a 10,000-foot view, and I have

028my cheat sheet up here in the form of my phone. I'm not checking Instagram. The statute that applies is Statute 17.26 of the Wisconsin Statutes, obviously, and it is titled appropriately, Vacancies and School Boards How Filled? And to give you the key points, again, some of which I think you've received a summary of, but just to give those in this public forum here, and we also have to talk about board policy, but we start with the statute. So the fundamental kind of key point is that The vacancy is filled by appointment until an election is held to fill that seat on a more long-term basis. And so a person who is appointed then holds the seat until the elected individual takes that seat. And the statute provides that the successor is to be elected at

029the next spring election. So in this instance, because of when Ms. Boucher passed, it is at the upcoming April election that her seat will be, I guess, I don't want to say permanently filled, but filled on a complete basis, I guess you would say. And then there is also Board Policy 8124, which, again, just referring to my cheat sheet, talks about the appointment process. So saying all that, you can all obviously look at the statute, but what's I think the crux of the issue here is what do you do when you have a situation where there is a relatively short period of time between when that seat on the board becomes vacant and when it will be filled via the election. And the unfortunate reality is that the statute doesn't exactly say. It does say

030that it shall be filled by appointment. And it also does include a time component where it indicates, and I'm going to look right at the language of the statute, but if the remaining members of a school board do not appoint an individual to fill a vacancy within 60 days of the date on which the vacancy first exists, the remaining members of the school board may fill the vacancy in accordance with the school board's policy under 120.12 sub 28. So it has a, there's that time component of if 60 days elapse and the vacancy hasn't been filled, then the board can have a policy as to what it would do in that instance to kind of move the issue forward, or move the process forward, if that makes sense. And your policy then, in turn, says

031if the vacancy is not filled within 60 days, the board can fill a vacancy by a majority vote before using other methods. if the board is unable to fill a vacancy by majority vote the president will select two nominees for the board to vote on again so it all gets a little arcane and i think the reality is that there are situations where i think we could cl you you as a board could clearly say it doesn't make sense to appoint someone to fill a vacancy if say that vacancy occurred Mere days before or the day of an election or something like that where it was a really short period of time But here I wouldn't say that's the case and unfortunately neither the statute nor the guidance that's out there nor the case law

032gives an Absolute and I know you love it when lawyers come up and say well it depends, but that's the reality it There is not a clear you must fill this vacancy by X date or you are violating the statute So I think that leaves you with essentially two choices, which is to either move forward with your process to fill the vacancy by appointment. And I frankly am not sure what exact processes you've used in the past to do that or when that last occurred. But certainly, you know, you would think it would involve in your policy calls for essentially seeking interested parties and putting together. what you would expect of them as far as application materials and then reviewing those materials in a transparent fashion and then making a decision so that is your

033that is your first option is to initiate that process even though we all understand that that would be for a relatively relatively short period of time i think your other option is to not fill the vacancy via appointment And I would say that I think that is the riskier option of the two. I understand why, again, I understand why you might think, well, does it make a lot of sense to put in all this effort and to put somebody in that position for a short period of time when then you will have someone elected in April? But I do think the more cautious approach is to initiate that process because the statute does say that that's how these vacancies are filled and that they shall be filled in that manner. So there is some gray

034area. I wish I could give you a more definite answer. I wish that the statute provided a more definite answer on... What's really the fundamental question here? Which is when is it too short of a period of time that you really need to appoint someone? I think there is a point where that is clearly the case But I think where where things stand here as to when the vacancy occurred with with miss Boucher's unfortunate passing We're in that gray area So I hope that frames the issues, and I'm happy to do my best to answer any questions if I can, but that's where I think things stand. Thank you, Jim. Are there board member questions, I assume, for Jim or comments? So just to summarize, you can do whatever we want, basically. I don't think

035I said you can do whatever you want. But what I did say is I do think you have some discretion to exercise here. I still want to reemphasize that I think the more cautious approach is to start the process, fulfilling it, even if you say to yourself, well, they're not going to be here for that long, and that's going to be a lot of work for... a relative relatively little reward i guess i would put it um and furthermore who's who's interested is there somebody out there who wants to do this can you find somebody perhaps who has some experience uh working because it's a lot as as i don't have to tell any of you uh whether you're newer or whether you've been on this board for a while or whether you've been on

036other boards it's a lot to learn and um so i i can understand why you might be reluctant and But I still think that that's the best way I can answer that. Yeah, I appreciate that. Can you tell me what you say more cautious is in? What's the risk or where's the liability or where's the problem? Where's the roadblock? I think there are a couple risks. I think one risk is just you may have some members of the community or of the public who are dissatisfied with the fact that you did not act. Obviously, I can't speak for those people. Usually, as I don't need to tell you, there are differing opinions on lots of things that the board does. So you might have some, I guess for lack of a better term, public relations

037issue. But also legally, which is I'm here to talk about that more than I am about PR, you could face some risk of litigation. And there has been litigation on this issue in the past. I would prefer not to stand up here and explain in great detail how that litigation might unfold, but there is the possibility of litigation that would be attempting to essentially force you to take action. Would there have to be some type of a, like someone was negatively impacted in order for the lawsuit to take place? That's a good point. So that's a concept that's generally in the law called standing, that someone has to have a harm, right? But even if you, in responding to such litigation, could argue that this person doesn't have standing or doesn't have a reason to

038pursue it, that doesn't mean that they wouldn't. Okay. Thank you. Are there other questions or comments? Kathy? Thank you, Jim. So I guess my... My question is because there are two options for a motion and second motion is that we do not fill because of obviously there's an election going on about to happen so I understand the risk because anything can go and laws could be interpreted into whatever but I guess my question is as it stands currently by the statute and by our current policy size the risk that there might be you know even people with outstanding are we in compliance with the law and our current policy and are we okay to make that motion to not fill because what you're explaining right because it's kind of like then okay then why is

039this other motion here right but the motion is on our agenda and i'm just wanted to be clear that if that motion were to be made because it's been agendized that Current policy and current statute allows us to make that motion. I think the statute is not clear on What time frame applies? and when you are, by what point you are required to act. And I'm sorry I can't give you a better answer than that, but that is the truth. I don't think the statute is clear. It does not set a deadline. It does not say the board shall appoint someone within so many days, nor does it say if there are fewer than so many days prior to the next election, the board doesn't have to fill the seat. It does use the word

040shall. And that a vacant seat shall be filled by appointment until the next election. And so I think, as I said, all I can say is that the risk, I think there is more risk to not acting to move forward with an appointment. And when I reference the 60 days, that's both in the statute and in your policy where there's kind of this, if nobody does anything after 60 days, the process is accelerated. And so that suggests that it's at least implied that you should act within 60 days. But it doesn't say definitively that you have to. So act within 60 days but no deadline to fill date. Correct. There is no deadline in the statute or in your policy. Right, so act within 60 days, but no deadline to the fill date. Yeah, I

041think that's fair. Yep. Thank you. Mary? Thank you for the clarification so far. As the board clerk, I've been poking around and finding the same nebulous things that you've articulated. But I would like you to clarify, and I think you've been asked this question already. The election is April 1st. The Board of Canvassers will meet on April 7th to validate the election results. And assuming that there is a clear-cut, not super questionable result in that election, the next board meeting is April 8th. But we wouldn't customarily seat. a new candidate until the end of the month because we have people filling the seats. In this case, we don't. We have a vacancy. And I thought, is there a possibility or would it be inappropriate to say that we would fill the vacancy after the conclusion

042of the canvassing for the one month prior to the election wouldn't be a starting the three-year? term early, but it would be our process of filling the vacancy because then we would have a decision from the community. My concern is that, respectfully, my concern is that, to me, that almost muddies the waters a little bit. I would say if you're going to start the appointment process, if you're going to appoint, then I think you start the process. If you're not going to, then you don't. so I understand I think I understand that the thought process there but I I guess I would not recommend that approach okay I'm just and and that's only in conjunction with what we have to talk about in terms of what a realistic timeline would be to do the process

043because we're really only talking about the March board meeting and the April board meeting understood thank you Sam I think, to me, I think there's an even bigger risk at proceeding or going down that road if the current people. So it's a unique situation where Ms. Boucher decided not to run for re-election. So she was not even going to be on the ballot. And I imagine then if we then seek community for applications, then I would imagine the two existing candidates would apply. And I think that that could become a bigger threat to here as well. I mean, what if we can't? you know would nominate them and they're already saying they're willing they're you know completely qualified and one of them 50 50 chance will well maybe unless there's a write-in will win so

044is there a bigger risk going down that route as well knowing that that could also take place and then you would have election interference and all the stuff that could go along with that if if the majority decided to put one of those people on the board i i certainly understand the point i don't know that that would give rise to valid legal claims from whoever was subsequently defeated in the election. But I think you would, I mean, it is potentially problematic. I don't see that as as much of a legal risk, frankly, as I do of public relations and sort of, for lack of a better term, image risk, that it would. potentially cause problems, but I don't know that I see it as a big legal risk. But I see the concern, I

045mean, no doubt. I just want to clarify I don't want to discuss hypothetical what people are going to do there might be hundred people who wants to join for a month and a half or none so I don't want to say what ifs candidate when I think this discussion brings a forethought of our intent and I don't think it's a good discussion to have hypotheticals I think we need to decide whether we want to fill because the statute and the policy is very clear it's a shell so within 60 days we have to start the process and there is no specific deadline to fill i think those are the things we just need to those two are very clear and you know we vote on that all the hypotheticals i just think we're treading i

046don't think we need to have that discussion my person personally it may come off as some intent that I don't think we need to have a cloud over our discussion. Can I just ask a legal clarification based on what Kathy just asked? The 60 days is not just for us to start the process. It is to fill the vacancy. Is that correct? Well, it actually, let me just go back and make sure I'm reading the statute accurately. Yeah, it says if the remaining members do not appoint an individual within 60 days, then these next steps can occur. So it says if they do not, in other words, if the vacancy is not filled within 60 days. So it's not just start the process within 60 days. It's complete the process. Well, the problem is that

047implies that. You might not have completed the process within 60 days, right? So I'm not I know that sounds like kind of a tricky answer, but that's the reality It's saying you should it's it's arguably saying the idea is that you fill it within 60 days But you might not and then if you don't then here's what happens next So since this somewhat falls back to our policy if we were if the policy was written different from our on our board Would that would this be a different conversation? The policy, there are differences in the way that boards approach this issue in their policies, but I think your policy as it stands is what it is. I'm thinking for future. So if this policy was written differently that says, oh, if a vacancy occurs within

048120 days of an election or, you know, it was already whatever, could we then, would that be a different conversation today? Or are we going back to Wisconsin statute more? No, I mean, the statute takes precedent. But the issue with policies is policies can be used to fill in blanks where there isn't an answer in the statute. I think that would require a lot more thought and analysis. I do want to be careful to Kathy's point about hypotheticals, about diving too far into them, but I certainly think there is some room to, if you were so inclined, to modify your policy going forward and try to answer some of these questions differently or more thoroughly. But I also think, as it stands, the policy is what it is, and I know you're not suggesting otherwise.

049Gene or Priyat, do you have questions? No questions, thanks. Okay, well thank you Jim and board member comments thoughts here is we and we do have a request to speak after board discussion so if we just want to go around and make any comments that we have as individual board members and then we'll take the citizen request to speak so Start the process. Let's say we get volunteers who want to you know be part of this and say the board just cannot agree on any of the people that applied so either there's a deadlock or we just can't agree to within that six like what is the recourse after that 60 day if that were to happen So here's what your policy says okay and if the vacancy is not filled within 60 days the

050board can fill a vacancy by a majority vote before using other methods it doesn't specify what those other methods are and then if the board is unable to fill a vacancy by majority vote the president will select two nominees for the board to vote on again thank you that policy sounds as if it's written once a process has begun so there would be nominees and there would be maybe it just didn't get done in 60 days and so then we moved to some alternative methods almost assuming that we have names and applicants in the hopper so i just want to point that out other thoughts as i consider what is coming before us in the next two meetings in terms of substantive decisions there's not any sort of huge are we gonna sell hillside or

051are we gonna other big decisions that we've made historically it is a short amount of time The learning curve is steep if you're if you haven't served on the board before I don't have a feel for a board members prior board members in the community and whether they'd be interested in serving for Right now there's 84 days left until a new board member would be seated I can't imagine we'd finish the process in any much shorter than a couple weeks. It might leave 60 days Perhaps we'd be done by the March board meeting and they'd serve for two meetings I understand statute says, as it does, that the process would begin, but I'm torn, frankly, with a lot of work and a lot of conversation bringing people forward and perhaps doing interviews and getting someone

052appointed and trained and then serving for a very short time. So I'm admittedly torn between not filling and starting a process. because we run a risk of someone saying we're not doing our jobs and I feel as a board member who's appointed to or who's elected to make decisions that weigh the various salient points that go into a decision that I think that that would make sense to at least entertain that possibility so First I just like to say thank you so much Jim for your explanation I Appreciate what you've said about risk for us. That's something that I'm taking into consideration I also again appreciate the words of other board members here talking about the The amount of work and time that would go into filling this position for such a limited amount of

053time. So again I think I've considered both of these options but again Jim your discussion about risk for us and what statute and our board policy state is helping to clarify some of my questions so thank you I appreciate everybody's comments so far and I too am leaning toward beginning a process because I think it is what is expected of us to fill the seat or see who's out there. The one issue of significance that may be coming before the board during this period of time, we're going to get a report on. the school start time committee and I suppose we have some control over when we agenda is an action a decision on something of that significance but that is a significant issue that there's been a lot of conversation about and it and

054it is things like that that would concern me about the short runway we have to getting someone up to speed on a decision of that magnitude Maybe we should vote. I don't think talking about pending vote for action item for future agenda I just am not comfortable discussing that and for that to be a deciding factor whether we're gonna address this agenda as item today I'll share my comments and then we do have a request to speak I've been all over the map it's it's I appreciate Kathy your sentiments about hypotheticals but hypotheticals are running through my mind to help me weigh whether it's feasible, valuable. I think Jean made a good point in terms of what's on the calendar this spring. You know, April kind of ends, it's the last board meeting of board

055terms, and so big things are sometimes there on those agendas, curriculum things, and we don't have heavy, heavy lift in curriculum this year. We don't have facility decisions in March. When is that final recommendation coming on the school start time? And so something would come in April, May, time frame. I think for me the crux of the issue is accomplishing the work of the board. Can the board work with six? We wouldn't be able to work if we see a lot of 3-3 votes coming. A 3-3 vote by Robert's Rules is a tie and fails. I don't anticipate that. I know it is hypothetical, and we probably don't want to go that far down there, but I've got to think that to help me make a decision here. I lean towards not filling the seat.

056I understand there's some legal risk there. But I take comfort in the council that there's six of us to make this decision, and if the rest of you felt like we would fill it, I would ask that we solicit first former board members just in the sense of helping us because they would hit the ground running. They've served before. They understand the committee structure. They're familiar with policies. I don't know if any of them would be willing to serve. I have not asked any former board members myself if they would. We'd be kicking the tires a little bit. But there's seven or eight out there that potentially could serve for two board meetings. But again, I feel like the six of us can do this work. When I was on my second year on the

057board, maybe, Dick Brunner moved, and it was about this time of year. It was before an election. He was not up for reelection, and we left the seat vacant at that time. I don't know if it was, again, I didn't go back and look at the calendar to check. Was that within 60 days? I don't know that we looked at the policies that carefully when we did it then. Maybe it was my first year on the board. it was early early on but again the board was able to accomplish the work with six so we didn't feel the need to fill the spot with a seventh so that's where I'm leaning but if this board wants to fill it I would say that maybe we so we would then obviously talk about process and how

058we want to proceed with process and maybe we would consider asking former board members first you have a request to speak something oh yeah go ahead Sam and then I'm sorry. I didn't mean to try to go last. I was just thinking what you said. It helped me clarify that. If the law was abundantly clear, obviously I very clearly want to follow the law. That's extremely important. And the fact that there's vagueness and there's a – I understand that it's cautious versus mandated are two different things. I think trying to fill this presents more conflicts and more harm to the community. I think that this would – right now my – I rest in the thought of not filling this until the April election. And if it's a legal risk, then we take that risk.

059But I think it's a very cautious and prudent risk as well. Thank you. We have a request to speak after board discussion. Angie Pingel, a resident of the district, will speak to us. I do have a few points that I'd like to make on this issue. First... I want to just make sure you're really hearing what the word shall means. It means it's an obligation. It's an obligation. And when I look at your policy, not only do I read item number four, but I also read item number five. And it says a vacancy on the board shall be filled by appointment by a majority vote of the remaining board members. Such appointment shall be conducted in accordance with open meeting laws. And that's your own policy, policy 8124. And the way that I see as

060a resident of this community the crux of the issue is that by not doing what the law requires and what your policy says, you are usurping the authority of the people who voted at the organizational meeting and approved a seven-member board. You are taking away the protections that your constituents put in place when they said they wanted a seven-person board. How many years and years and years ago? So I think that you need to go ahead and you need to follow what your policy says you're going to do and what the law says you're going to do. And while it may not be convenient, And it may be risky, especially in light of your recent loss on the appeal of the lawsuit that was brought in response to the board's last attempt to fill a

061vacancy back in 2020. That doesn't mean you just get to skip it. So when you say you're going to have a PR nightmare, that might be true. You've already gotten negative press in the Journal Sentinel. You've already gotten it in the Waukesha Freeman. So... Let's skip it and see how that looks later on. How are people going to interpret that action? Are you afraid to do your job which is required in your own policy? I don't know. I don't like the way it looks as a resident of this community and it does certainly concern me. Would like to see that you guys would do a roll call vote on this important issue since you are taking away the rights of this community when we appointed a seven-member board And I think this is an important

062issue. I think you should follow your policy and you should follow the law Thank you Thank You Angie Ask a follow-up question. I I can't where were you saying that it shall be filled? And it says shall be filled by appointment, but it's not saying within a time frame. It says a vacancy. You have a vacancy, and it shall be filled. By appointment. Yep. So I think you can read that both ways, shall be filled by appointment, versus it shall not be filled by an individual or shall not be filled by a recommendation. It means that you have to do something to fill this. You need to appoint someone to fill that vacant chair. Yes, I agree. Jim, what are your thoughts on that? wording on that because I'm not a lawyer, so I'm confused.

063Thank you, Auntie. I'm sorry I forgot your first name Angie Pinkman Angie I'm sorry so I mean Angie absolutely read it correctly so sub 5 the Board of Education has the authority to appoint qualified individuals to fill board vacancies a vacancy on the board shall be filled by appointment by majority vote of the remaining board members and then the open meetings provision which I think is sort of ancillary here So it does absolutely use the word shall, but I also agree that the key question here is the time context of how quickly that needs to happen. That's where I don't think we have a definitive answer from the statute. But both the statute and the policy do use the word shall. There's no dispute about that. Any other comments or we could entertain a motion

064Kathy I think you need to read this policy 8 1 2 4 as a sequence 1 2 3 4 5 so you just reading 5 that's the end result of 1 2 3 4 that's how I read that policy it's a process that we're required we shall and if not then we'll go to five we can't just take five it's it's sequential from one through five and that's how i read it i appreciate that i it just it's so confusing to me because point four then says that the vacancy is not filled within 60 days so i it seems like a poorly written policy then to not be much more specifically and clear about that and obviously something we never thought about or never caught before but it's confusing it doesn't seem to be really

065clear i i'm torn mary um a couple of thoughts kathy when i read number five i'm in agreement with you i think the second and third sentence is there refer to how the board of education will exercise the authority to appoint qualified individuals so the assumption there is there's a qualified individual selected so i'm not as hung up on the shell there because that to me is the process exercising that authority and in number five This was this policy was written in 2017 my little bit of research found that in 2017 the state of Wisconsin required all school districts to create a policy in the event that a vacancy was not filled within 60 days So that's why the 60 days is here and the if the vacancy is not filled within 60 days Indicates

066to me that there are times when the vacancy is not filled within 60 days and that There needed to be some guidance after that. So again, process statements of majority vote, the majority can't be reached, the president picks two, and we vote again. Still got to have a majority vote to get that person appointed. So it is a murky mess. We're not in a court here trying to figure out which of these prevails. I do think we are public servants, and within that, the transparency of doing our work, it may be in the best interests of the school district to begin a process. whether we're looking for a certain type of person or not, hypothetically, to find out if there is a qualified candidate at all who would be willing to take this on. So,

067Mark, this comes up, you know, now we're talking about process and is it feasible, and one of the questions when we start making a motion or we consider a motion, can we do this in the time? What would it look like? What would a potential timeline for... appointing someone to fill a board vacancy look like again this would just be a potential it would be fast the challenge will be we have some travel schedules that take some people out of the decision making process so we have some tight windows we would probably begin the process immediately as soon as the board directed us to create a posting process and then have a window of time where applications could be solicited. And then under previous action, the board president and vice president brought candidates forward for

068the board to interview. And then from there, the board did interviews and made selection. You could foreseeably do that in a month, but it's tight. Everyone's here together. Mary? I looked at the calendar, too, because I think should we decide to go that way, we have some meetings to set up because these are public. open meetings to make these considerations. And then assuming we found someone who was acceptable to the majority, there would be a very rapid escalated learning curve to get on top of some of the issues that we have been grappling with that will come before the board in those two meetings. The next meeting we have is March 18th. So that's the target we'd be chasing to have somebody appointed by March 18th. So that's more than a month. I would want

069it fast. I don't like doing things fast because I think we don't get good reflection when we do things fast, but I think we would be able to open a an application window if you will for a couple weeks And we would need to confer. I know you've got travel coming up. I've got travel coming up We have we have to take a look at when we could legitimately meet to do this not just to do it for the sake of doing it, but to do it right. If we're going to do this, we need to do this right. So March 18th is the date by which we'd have to have somebody sitting in the chair prepared and given the orientation they'd need to make the decisions that we'd need made. Why March 18th? I

070understand that's a board meeting but there's why that date that is beyond 60 days because technically March 12th would give with 12 13th would be the 60th day So why March 18th? Well, that's the next meeting. I understand. And it's not just appointing someone by then. It's getting them sworn in, getting the paperwork done, and then orienting them, getting them up to speed on the issues. So you couldn't just put somebody in who we voted on on the 17th, I don't think, and effectively expect them to be ready to roll on the 18th. The 60 days was a question I had, too, because... I know the 60 days falls somewhere in the middle of March, and if it were based on the first meeting that we had where we were made aware in an official

071way, then I think the 60 days falls on Saturday, March 15th. we still have time within the 60-day window to conduct as I said a process by which we can find out if we have viable candidates and then meet to discuss that but I'd sure want to know when those meetings are going to happen if we're not going to fill within six days per statute I don't want to put because of the meeting date rush to set some kind of March 18 deadline because there's a meeting We got to find a qualified person. There is no deadline and I don't think that's a discussion for this I think we need to vote and then See what we're doing. But now just by a committee member board member saying nice March 18 deadline I just think

072that's inappropriate at this point of discussion Well, it's just a factor. I'm not trying to be inappropriate. But if we don't have somebody who's seated by the March 18th meeting then we only have the April 8th meeting where we would need, where we would be able to have a seventh vote at the table. And if we, then we're going beyond the 60 days. I know we can do that. We have laid out in the policy the process to do that. I'm also thinking of the respect for the time of a person who would be willing to step up and do this for a single meeting. If it doesn't happen by March 18th, it's already just someone who's willing to step up and serve and get caught up for two meetings. It's a very awkward and

073unusual situation we're in. And I want to be, I just, I'm trying to make sure that. My colleagues here in the community at large Understands my thought process in this because I'm very conflicted Scott I don't disagree with you that the six of us can work together and probably could manage I'm not sure that there's a single right or wrong thing to do here, but The one thing we don't know is whether we have a viable candidate and we won't know that unless we initiate a process One more complexity. What if we vote on this and it's 3-3 and it's high so then it fails so then it's... Well then our policy, state statute says each board should have a policy in that instance and our policy does address what happens if we get to

07460 days and haven't... Then you pick two people to present. No, that's not the first thing. The first thing is that a majority of the board may appoint a vacancy and then... by majority vote. Then if we can't do that, then the president selects two nominees and we vote on that. And then are we ready to vote? Well, first we need a motion. So someone would like to make a motion. Again, if you're looking for some wording, there's some suggested motions in there, but I just put those in there as potentials. Those are not meant to be the only two. I'll make a motion to... Direct the board president and the administration to bring forward a replacement Appointment process for action. I don't want an action in a March meeting. I think I'm not gonna

075put a deadline on that. So That's the motion. We have a second. Is there any discussion of the motion? Yes, if we don't put a time Deadline on it. We will not have a meeting at which to discuss it and any Although I'm leaning in this direction. I think we need to understand When we're going to meet to make Decisions if this is just a motion to bring forward a process Then no process begins until after we've met and and affirmed it. So If you're not comfortable with March, we should probably find a time and if this is something that we're time is of the essence that ought to be taken into account I don't have an amendment. That's just my thoughts I was just about to ask if you had an amendment. Sam? I

076appreciate your input on that, Mary. I think that we don't know. I think everything we've always said, give direction to the president and administration, it's often without a time frame because I don't know the process. We don't know how many candidates are going to apply. We don't know the availability. I think we have to assume that they're going to make good movement towards making that happen in order to be obligated and follow the less more cautious route by. attorney so I think I'd rather leave a date off and yeah just what you said I want to be real clear that we're on the same wavelength because you want to know if there are candidates we can't know if there are candidates till we meet to approve this process based on the motion. We'll have to

077set up meetings for that. Yeah so so if that doesn't happen I mean it could happen after the March meeting if we don't put something on here it may not happen by the March meeting and if it doesn't then we're at a point where we don't have we haven't we haven't said go to the process and we still won't know if they're a candidate We can set up a meeting anytime it would be a regular board meeting a special meeting And you don't feel concerned about putting a date on it I trust Scott and Dr. Hanson to do their job If I could offer an amendment to the motion that we would like them not just to bring forward a process but we would like a process initiated because if we bring forward a process

078for approval that means they're gonna say here's how it's gonna work we have to approve that at the March meeting well we want to prove that maybe next week and the process gets going so if we would if we would direct the board president and the administration to initiate a replacement appointment process that will get us moving so we have a we have a proposed amendment but we need a second before we can have more discussion on that What what exactly does that can you write it take out of this because this said and I think Sam you read everything up to the word action I did so the move the motion is to direct the board president and the administration to bring forward a replacement appointment process for action How would you amend that

079specifically? Jean's gonna write it down I want us to caution. We're here to agendize vote what we're going to do about vacancy, fill or not fill. You're adding on this amendment is operationalizing the motion that is to be approved. So it's preemptively you are operationalizing into a motion that has not been approved. I would be very cautious. I think Jean has the floor to. clarify the amendment because the amendment was presented i just want to know what it is the way i understand the motion it would mean that the process gets defined and comes to the march meeting and we approve the process and then once we approve the process it gets started after that and that would be That would be we'd start the process where I believe we have discussed we'd like to

080start this next week so if we would direct the administration and the board president to initiate a process that would mean to start like now for replacement and then the Action is taking we didn't need the rest so need the rest of that time boundness because it's initiating it today Gotcha, so instead of bring forward initiate and then end that process The amendment is to substitute the word initiate for the words bring forward in the original motion And put a period after process I'll second the amendment It's been made and seconded and Kathy's caution of let's be careful about operation And for every vote for every amendment and original motion I want a roll call for every vote that we're doing right now So you can see how the motion would read if the amendment

081Get ready for action Yeah, it ends at process with the amendment Kathy I really want to know your perspective I don't understand what you mean by operationalize the motion so if we approve let's say we are approving to fill There is a process already in place that's gonna automatically trigger them You're adding you're taking an action before taking a vote to say yes this we were gonna do it You're doing it simultaneously. We did not agree to any of these. We didn't vote. And why are we directing someone on things that we didn't vote? That's the motion is to- Correct. So we just have to say we're going to fill as written. It's either fill or not fill. That's what we're voting on. If we vote to say- Yes, Phil then there's a process already

082in place. That's just gonna automatically trigger I just don't think we need to spell it out. What is the process in place then for filling out like Mark summarized policy. Yeah, it's in the policy. We're gonna ask inside I mean they would this is not the first time you've We're doing this There's a precedent we got an email about the precedent that was used to So listen, so there's a process that exists that I think the administration be ready to put together but more to your point Kathy, I think if you are if you are looking for a filled not fill Then when we get to the motion on this if you're a not fill you just vote no Because this is the path to attempting to fill And if you don't want to attempt

083to fill, then you would just vote no. See, that's the thing. That muddies it. Why can't we just vote fill or not fill? Because we don't know if we're going to get a qualified candidate. So if we vote to fill without all this amendment, no one can do anything? Is that correct? We still have to approve the candidate. So if we say we fill. Mark you can't take action per policy to go do what it is that you have to do to get candidates elicit post That's my question. Yes, we could yeah, thank you Yeah, that would be enough authorization. I mean she she's saying if the motion were as simple as We're going to fill the vacancy then tomorrow the process would start. I mean Mark and I would talk good Required to have

084a motion for that if that's already the policy Think based on what we've been presented tonight. We've been presented that choice by that definition. We're just following the law so We don't have to vote on whether or not we're following the law following the policies, right? We're voting whether we're gonna fill or not it's a yes or no question I think it's simple and then if we if we vote yes that's filled whether policy or statute as we discussed for last hour then there's a motion that's gonna take place if we say no then nothing happens I don't see any bit of a difference I'll vote for either one I guess because I think they're both the same Kathy do you want to amend the motion No you could No you can have another amendment

085can't you No you have to vote on this amendment. Okay so we have an amendment to change some of the wording in Sam's initial amendment and the change would result in the wording on the screen. Any further discussion? I just that I can support this because it expedites the process. This is a roll call vote on the amendment. Jean Lambert. Yes. Mary Wacker. Yes. So the motion has been amended now Kathy do you want to make a different amendment you want to simplify it No but I will ask for four minutes after we vote no no go ahead I don't need to make amendments Any further discussion I'll make the amendment then I'll move to we change him I would say if it's important enough make the amendment let it go and stand by what

086you believe in I think that's a good way to publicly state it and you know otherwise let's move on I'll make an amendment that we move to fill the vacancy that's my motion Kathy would like the motion to just read strike all the words and then it would just read we move to fill the vacancy Is there a second? I'll second that. OK. Any discussion? This is a roll call vote. Kathy Lynn? Jean Lambert? No. Brita Curtiara? No. Sam Hughes? Yes. Mary Wacker? No. Scott Wheeler? Yes. Three yeses, three noes. Motion fails. OK. We're back to the original motion. Any further discussion? All those in favor of, oh, this is a roll call vote. This is a roll call vote. My bad. Getting your steps in. And this is the original the motion as as

087amended on the screen thank you so the motion is to direct the board president the administration to initiate a replacement appointment process We'll be in touch. We will have a series of meetings coming up, so we'll get with everyone's calendars and work through the process. Thank you. Our next action item of the evening is committee assignments and liaison designations. And thank you, Jim, for coming. As a member of the Board of Education, Linda served as the chair of this Community and Legislative Engagement Committee and as a member of the Personnel Committee. She also served as the liaison to the City of Brookfield. We will have obviously new board appointments with new board members in the spring, but we're talking now about the fulfilling of these responsibilities until then so I propose that I be Named

088the chair of CLE and that Mary Wacker become a member of the personnel committee This maintains Gina and I not serving on the same committee so we can still plan our agendas without a walking quorum and no one on their preferences in the last April Wanted to be a liaison to the city of Brookfield except Linda So a gene has served in that capacity. Oh really? I wasn't I also wanted to be on the personnel committee and see it on your sheet I saw that Yeah, it was your first choice Sorry, I looked my bad if I missed that so you I guess I was just curious because I mean I I am interested in the personnel committee appointment I just wondered what your thought process was because you didn't you haven't reached out to

089me and I just didn't know if that Simply I just went back to those papers and it was Mary's first choice Was it I don't think it was your first choice. It was the first time and then I changed it with conversations with you. Yeah, so That's my proposal so I'd be looking for a motion to For these appointments as presented or a different motion if somebody feels that something else should be done Oh, I was starting to say about the city of Brookfield Really one of the major things we have there is just working You know when there's a meeting about the current tids and Jean has represented us there in the past and so That was my thought process there. That's probably the only meeting that might happen between now and when we

090appoint new liaisons. So since you had already done that in the past on that particular TID, it made sense to me. That was my thought process. Sam? I might have been the Economic Development Commission, so I apologize. Maybe it wasn't the City of Berkley. I don't remember. But I'll make a motion to, I guess I am interested in the personal committee. I looked at my calendar. I'm open for those dates. I'd love to. a more senior member have a little bit more you know opportunity to to step into that role over the next few months knowing that it'll all change in a few months so I'll make approval of the committee assignments and board liaisons with Scott Wheeler as the chair and Sam as the personnel committee appointment and the WOSB delegate with Dr. Preetha

091Kudarata and the city of Brookfield liaison Jillian Lambert I have a question. Because it's coming to the board for action, but I know there was a CLE meeting and personnel meeting which I walked into Mary at the meeting which I wasn't aware. So how does that work? Do you have a vested power to appoint without the board approval since the meeting occurred without our all our you know our prior knowledge or any communication since it requires action how does that work because it seems like you and mayor already served in that capacity without the board action i just did that temporarily we've we've had Committee members appointed temporarily in the past when somebody for example lost an election or was not reelected and we just needed somebody for one meeting board presidents have typically not

092just myself but preceding my time have appointed somebody for a meeting so I just appointed I served for one meeting and Mary served for one meeting pending the action we take tonight based on precedence the policy is silent on it I second the motion so any discussion on the motion that Sam made Yeah, I too am very interested in staying on the personnel committee. I did get to sit in on one meeting already. I don't know if we have more than one additional meeting that we're covering in the absence of new assignments being made, one or two. How many more meetings? Two? Two? Okay. But, yeah, I... have done my homework backing up and and finding out what's going on on that committee and would very much like to serve so I'm going to Oppose

093the motion as presented in the hope that I can continue to serve. Thank you. I met their questions or comments Sam I apologize publicly for not reaching out to you Or catching again. I just went through the preference sheets and thought for two months When I personally assign people to committees, I try to give everyone their first choice if they can. So it just seemed like a natural opportunity to slide Mary in there as her first choice. I did not approach other board members to ask. So Mary's already been to a meeting. I'll probably just vote that way. But you could serve equally as well. It's not a vote of confidence or a lack of confidence. Any other comments or questions? Okay, all those in favor of the motion as presented please say aye Aye

094Clarification that's not the motion You're right. That's not the motion The motion is the same presented is different than what you see on the screen behind me the motion that Sam let me just clarify before we vote This is that I would serve as chair of CLE sandwiched around the personnel committee and then the liaisons as presented with dr. Kuti are and Jean Lambert That's Sam's proposal that was seconded. That's what we're voting on at this point. That's the motion if it fails someone else can make a different motion Which I think is the point that maybe yeah. Yeah, this is the actual motion. Nothing's been amended Okay, all those in favor of the motion that Sam made as presented. Please say aye aye Those against No, no, okay that motion fails I would like

095to make a motion to approve the committee assignments and board liaisons as presented in board docs Any other discussion all those in favor of the motion please say aye aye any opposed no thank you that carries on voice vote we have our next agenda item is the proposed meeting schedule as we discussed at the last meeting It's unusual in the sense that we're approving the calendar early enough that the administration and other personnel can plan around our meetings. And yet we have board members that we don't even know who's running next spring that would be at the tail end of this, that would be serving in May and June. And so the idea here is we're kind of proposing almost a rolling 14-month calendar that we'll approve every year with the idea that... Every year

096we may need to kind of weigh in on the April and, or sorry, the May and June. I almost said that, the May and June meetings. Just because we have, again, new candidates running and we don't know next year who, at the beginning of next year, who will be running in the school board elections. if incumbents will be running and who's running against them and so anyway we approve those kind of with an asterisk next may and june are on this 14-month calendar you'll notice the meeting cadence of generally speaking a board meeting on the second week of the month it's not every single month that way and then if board members would put a placeholder as just uh if it needs to be a work session or a closed session discussion discussing mark's contract

097or hey we suddenly need to appoint a new board member and so we would have some meetings already on the calendar that we could Plug those kinds of events into those Fourth week meetings and you'll notice that in September the annual meeting kind of takes the place of that fourth week so that's just a general cadence meeting spots can still be moved and with That I haven't received any specific things other than Sam did have one comment. I think that he wants to make Potentially a change on the calendar. I didn't hear any other receive any other updates or changes that needed to be made so Sam do you want to talk about your proposed change and then we can entertain a motion yeah I was just looking at the March of 2026 that as

098you're just getting further in the month it just a lot more obligations that time of year with travels and things like that so I'd love to move that I would like to understand why the we're moving to instead of the second week which is the general time frame to the fourth week of March when For just a staffing reason as in the non renewal time so that that historically has been a short window of So I think the regular meeting is March 10th the second week And then the blue would just be a placeholder meeting in case we need a work session in case we need so I did I Misunderstand how that was worked. I thought it said the green was Green is the regularly scheduled regular. Okay additional. Oh, I'm Okay, I thought

099it was moving it. Did you want the March 10th meeting to be moved to the 3rd? No, March 10th is fine. I like that date, actually. That's a better date. So there's not necessarily going to be a meeting on March 24th. It would be as needed. Okay. So we have a place. It saves Christy the work of contacting people and are you available. And again, we occasionally miss board meetings and we occasionally miss work sessions and things. Attendance is rarely 100%. for a board member over the course of a year but this at least kind of forecasts that hey we're kind of planning on that 2-4 cadence and again you'll notice December's different July is different there are some differences other questions or comments yeah the 22nd of September is not an optional meeting it's

100the annual meeting and this this calendar then doesn't address a concern I raised When we talked about the calendar previously that that long gap between the 9th and the 9th of September and the 14th of October This last year resulted in a period when we had seven Special add-on meetings because there was a lot of business to transact during that time So I think that is too long a gap and I think that the annual meeting Shouldn't count as the optional meeting because it's not We would add a board meeting to the 22nd in way past history. We used to do the budget hearing and the annual meeting and a board meeting of business, and we had paired it back to handle the business on the first meeting in September and then later in October.

101But you're right, we have found ourselves with lots of business that needed to be transacted. So the hope is that we would be able to manage between. the really one month period between the 9th of September and the 14th of October is a little more than a month that we'd be able to manage that but if there would be too much business to be done we could put together a board meeting after the annual meeting on the 22nd That's kind of brutal That's a lot in one night. I just wonder if we might want to put a second placeholder on the 29th I think the best course of action is just to play it by ear right now. Okay I'm not voting on this but I mean June to July also is five weeks So

102I mean it has all worked out and I think that last couple we just had a lot of business we were doing and I know it's a lot of meeting but I think things have simmer down but there are other weeks that are five week difference I see but that I'm voting but in a 52 week year the five week span is gonna happen a few times well and that's why we added the optionals and so I like that the other question I had was that May and June of the current year are different than on this than what we have Correct tentatively scheduled so we would be making a change to dates we had reserved and I just want to point that out Thank you for drawing attention to that and again one of

103the main reasons for May the board means currently May 20th Changing it to the 13th allows us to not have one of those extra meetings because we do need to meet before May 15th by state statute to approve teacher contracts But we could do it the regularly scheduled board meeting if we meet on the 13th So board members that would change our May board meeting that's currently scheduled this would supersede any other discussion do we have a motion on this okay I entertain a motion I'll move approval of the proposed board meeting dates as presented I'll second any discussion I would just like to credit Brooke for the creation of this document that we're looking at right here that makes it really clear what we're trying to accomplish and she spent time pulling that all

104together so kudos to Brooke Can I second that? Those little footnotes in blue are incredibly helpful to know what's going on at that time. Trying to get better. All those in favor of the motion, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Thank you. That carries on voice vote. That brings us to our last action item of the evening, the recent gifts to the district. I'd like to present to you the gifts to the district that were received in November of 2024 in the grand total of $16,721.46 by the donors listed on the screen our deep appreciation for your support of excellence in Elmbrook this list will be on the website in the section titled gifts and will be there for the foreseeable future and with that I move approval of the gifts to the district

105for November So moved Second are you seconding Mary I moved approval Oh you moved sorry I'm seconding Thank you we have a motion by Jean and a second by Mary any additional comments I would just add thank you to all of our wonderful donors All those in favor of the motion please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Thank you. Carries on voice vote and concludes our action items for the evening and brings us to our first discussion item. Pam is making her way to the table I believe with some guests. Good evening. I'd like to do an introduction before I introduce the guests then. So the districts in general employ benefits consultants to gain expert advice on designing and managing employee benefits packages, which can help optimize costs, ensure compliance with regulations, cater to specific employee

106group needs, and ultimately improve employee satisfaction and retention. Some key reasons to utilize a benefits consultant include creating a customized benefits strategy aligned to the district's budget needs, optimizing costs by comparing insurance plan provisions while maintaining quality coverage ensuring regulatory compliance consultants have access to a wider range of providers and plans in the marketplace they provide assistance with employee communication and education they manage the monthly claims analysis and reporting and they provide a team approach. The R&R Insurance Consulting Firm will include two benefits consultants, a data analytics advisor, two strategic well-being consultants, a claims specialist to support employees with billing questions, as well as compliance support. So the district has worked with USI Insurance Services for the past 12 school years to provide health insurance consulting services. This service has not been competitively evaluated during

107this time. Administration decided to engage in a request for proposal process from five firms to evaluate best fit for these services. In November, a request for proposal was sent to the following firms. Gallagher Benefit Services, M3 Insurance, Marsh McLellan Agency, R&R Insurance, and USI Insurance Services. All five firms submitted a proposal for consideration. a team of seven individuals screened the proposals against a rubric that evaluated the proposals for local presence and experience in the education marketplace breadth of services size of service team strategic planning experience innovation renewal negotiations data analytics and reporting capabilities ancillary customer support such as legal or underwriting communication capabilities health care clinic management experience strength of references industry reputation alignment to elmbrook's culture and values and value in the pricing model the screening team consistent consisted of superintendent dr mark hansen

108assistant superintendent for business services ben prather finance director mitzi cass benefits and wellness coordinator jennifer johnson wellness champion and teacher michelle bond and myself Four firms were then invited to participate in an in-person session that consisted of a presentation and a panel Q&A presentation. R&R Insurance was overwhelmingly the top choice of this committee. Here are some of their highlights as to the reason why. R&R Insurance is an independent and local insurance agency. The district engages with them for our property and casualty insurance. They have over 60 education clients in Wisconsin. We believe they will be an innovative partner and will introduce many program solutions to determine how we can continue to provide high quality and affordable health care benefits. They excel in communication and are committed to year-round employee education and engagement. They believe firmly

109in transparency with fees. They do not receive commission from stop-loss insurance, pharmacy benefit manager transactions, network percentages, or captive fees. They do not have ownership in any of these provider partners. I then conducted references, and references had some of the following comments. R&R has excelled in their ability to negotiate costs on stop-loss insurance and our pharmacy benefit plan to save the district hundreds of thousands of dollars in the first three years of being self-funded. I've appreciated their help in creating a care navigation program and helping us to evaluate and contract for direct contracts on our plan. They work closely with our on-site clinic to help funnel staff to use the health plan effectively. They are very proactive with forward thinking and come regularly with ideas. Our consultant has presented to staff at the back-to-school event

110and shared cost containment strategies. It was so well received that staff have requested she return next year. The administrative support is great, and they are extremely responsive to staff who reach out directly to them. The monthly meetings always include the manager of analytics and data strategy. They always deliver a high-quality product with their presentations and written materials. They do a great job with engaging the benefit task force, and they are invested in employee education. The recommendation to switch to R&R insurance was presented to the personnel committee on February 4th with unanimous support of the three committee members. We are in the process of negotiating a two-year contract for a fee of $93,996 each year. There is no fee increase for year two. R&R insurance would become the agent of record April 1st, 2025 and would

111support the district with no fee for the months of April, May, and June. contingent fee metric type plan performance would be examined in year one and would be determined and implemented in year two and with that I'd like to introduce the two consultants who would be working with the district Michelle Froelke and Chris Kramer to come up to the podium to say a few words insurance we are one of the area's largest independent fiercely independent agencies in the state about 225 employees Michelle and I have over 60 years experience one of our niches if you want to call it that is an education whether it's a public school a private school the university we have a lot of educational experience Michelle actually used to be a teacher so she she brings that to the table

112as well From the depth of services, they are extremely robust. We have our own analytics team, as Pam talked about, and what really gets us excited about that is it gives you guys the opportunity to make informed decisions. We're going to have a lot of great ideas that we bring to the table. They're going to be rational and thoughtful, but at the end of the day, we want some science to back it up, and that's where our analytics team would come in. we also would incorporate the well-being unit that we bring to the table at R&R that will really help drive your current initiatives and perhaps spawn some new ideas to help people live healthier lives and in the end save themselves and the district money through these initiatives but really want to also thank

113your team your administrative team and the staff members that volunteered to go through those RFPs there's a lot of work that goes into them but also evaluating them having a well organized rubric that was used for the RFPs as well as the interview process a lot of time went into that so I think you can be very proud of the of the administrative team that your your employees put together We're looking forward to it. I think a big piece for Chris and I is feeling passionate about the organizations we work with. There's a lot of companies that are out there, and we'd rather work with people that we like and really feel like we can do some good, and it's a perfect fit for Elmbrook Schools and R&R. Thank you. Are we ready for questions,

114Pam? Okay, are there board member questions or comments? Sam or Jean? I'd like to make a couple comments. I served on the... Committee that reviewed the RFPs and interviewed the various folks that came in to offer services to the district and we had some healthy conversations after presentations in terms of which is the best fit and I would concur based on our criteria that we evaluated that R&R does lead the group in terms of their Independence I think is important the fact they have educational experience. I think it's another important concept they're local to the community and The years of experience certainly that they have in the business They're big enough, but small enough to do what it is. We need and so I will support the Recommendation for our honor. Thank you. Um, I

115just my first couple questions are to to you Pam Just to remind everyone. What is the total health care budget? for Elmbrook schools each year Sam I don't have that off the top of my head 17 million we're projected it's I'm sorry I do remember we're projected at upwards of 18.3 million with the hope of coming in at 17.5 and you explained to me like your process what was it like when you interviewed all of the other all the vendors what was that Can you give me the real quick version of how that process went? Yeah, absolutely. We asked for a 20-minute presentation. We provided some data in terms of our recent claims experience with high-cost claimants and our escalating total health care spend. And we asked the firms to come in and sort of

116demonstrate what approach they would take to analyze our data and help maybe make a correction in the spend with their services. After that, we had 40 minutes of scripted Q&As. So standard questions asked of each of the four firms. In your research, what were you seeing in other school districts for their insurance costs over the years? Have you seen other districts, have they all been going up kind of incrementally to what we're seeing here as well? There are some success stories, but I would say a lot of districts are facing the same concerns with escalating health care costs. We're not atypical. Were there any districts close by that you'd found that? didn't have this dramatic cost increase? Mark, I believe New Berlin is an example. It really comes down to if you're fully insured or

117self-insured on the experience you're having right now. If you're fully insured, you're most likely experiencing a 10% to 20% increase in your premiums. If you're self-funded, you can control those costs a little differently. And we've got a couple examples regionally, including Elmbrook, where we've controlled those costs, but they're starting to escalate because pharmaceuticals are skyrocketing and we have a whole emergence of stem cell research that's hitting the pharmaceutical market, which will be upwards of a million dollars in claims. So New Berlin, were they not seeing the same 20% increase year over year? They're self-funded, so they have experienced a little better performance over the last few years than we have. What's a little better? Do you know offhand? They have not had to increase their premium share with their employees, where we've increased it by

11812%, 13% each year over the course of the last two years. And then, Pam, where do you see the biggest savings for us in the medical health area? I'm going to defer to the experts on that one. I was just curious what you thought. I'll come back to that question then because I do have other questions for you guys. 20 years ago, I ran an organization, and I was only looking for health insurance for about 100 people, 150 people at the time. And I've learned that a lot has changed over the last 15 years since when I stopped doing that. So I don't remember PBMs. I don't remember all that stuff. I've taken a crash course for the last two days trying to learn and understand this as much as possible, and it's taken way

119more than, I don't know how you absorbed it in an hour presentation, but it's taken me like 15 hours trying to figure all this stuff out here. And I'm very well connected in the insurance world. I know a lot of good people out there and my business networks and all of that. So one of the things that came up for what I saw was PBMs and the incredible amount of, The way they bill, from what I understand, is that they charge the really big organizations a smaller amount, and then the smaller organizations pay the higher, higher premiums for pharmaceuticals and all that as well. So it's kind of becoming a three-letter word, PBMs as well. So what is your plan with PBM? That's a great question. First step is we're going to gather the facts.

120We need to see what you have in place right now. What does your PBM contract say? Is it being adhered to? What type of prescriptions are employees on? And then what are the alternatives? So the first step is just gathering the facts and seeing what's involved with it. From there, there's analysis of the PBM. There's a service that we work with that has information on 40 different PBMs or... pharmaceutical solutions because they're not all PBMs there's some that are called solutions and we utilize that tool to try to determine what makes the most sense for an employer the district in this case and is there a better fit for starters to Mark's point the pharmacy is just getting out of control across across the country Do you have any current schools that you have taken

121out of the PBMs and find other alternatives? I'm hearing success in that area, and I guess I'm curious what you have found. Yeah, there are alternatives other than a PBM itself. There are buying cooperatives. There are some programs that work outside of the PBM. You have to be somewhat careful with that to make sure they're really doing what you need it to do. But yes, I have a university down in Illinois that has a PBM, and then they have a program that runs outside of the PBM. And we analyze that for certain high-cost drugs to see if it's a better deal. So would it, okay, I was also told that a lot of organizations, they get $4 plus per prescription. Do you guys get any payment at all for any prescription whatsoever? We do not.

122or services nor the PBMs or stop loss or the captives when that is actually a case for a lot of other very important piece for transparency for our own. Nor are we getting compensated. So you get zero. And we're not getting compensated. We're not getting a transaction fee per PBM. We're not getting a percentage of the discount from your network or anything like that. How is your fee determined, the $96,000? That's a is that your only so that's just you're charging that contract Do you have any incentive for to drive our price down at all? What do you what is your incentive? There's gonna be a content in year two. There's gonna be a contingency portion of the contract that's gonna be based on medical loss ratio and then a Part of will be based

123on pharmaceuticals. So if we don't adhere to that we don't get paid that amount Can you tell me a little bit more about that? It's 10% of our fees are at risk. So again though because we're coming into the district not knowing what programs were in place at this point. They were put in by prior to us. We need to look at your premium equivalents to make sure they were set properly. And once we have an idea of what programs are in place and how it's running, then we're going to come up with a metric that would be agreed upon between the district and R&R that says in year two, these are the fees at risk. So, and I don't understand this, maybe Pam can answer this, why do we have to wait to sign

124a contract before you can tell us how you very specifically will save us money? For the 2025, if I may, for the 2025 calendar year, those programs are already in place. They were put in place by the current agency. And that runs for the calendar year currently? Everything's running on the calendar year. So this contract begins in July, though? Right. Or April, May, June. But those contracts don't change. That's just when we're taking over the consulting component. So your pharmacy isn't going to change in July? Your stop loss isn't going to change in July? You're not allowed to change that? No, because of the way the contracts are set up, they're locked in for your year. Okay, can you find other alternatives? Even if there's a contract, like you said, you can have your PBM,

125but then also find alternatives of cheaper drugs. Like if you find a drug that, I mean, I've heard some of them are $7,000 for the premium branded one and then $3 for the generic or whatever. Can you do that right away? We can start the process of looking at programs like that, yes. You can't initiate that or can't start buying those at cheaper rates right away or anything like that? It's not. quite that easy. Educate me then. That's what I'm trying to understand. So Sam, what you're talking about is what's called plan design and plan design occurs in prior to the January one deadline. So we would roll out plan design changes. That's not what I'm talking about. I'm asking, can you also, he just said you can have a PBM and then you can

126have an alternative. I'm just trying to understand. That would be a plan design change and you can't do that until Jan one. Okay. All right. And so we would be doing the research with R&R prior to the start of Jan one, 2026. Why was this put together to start a benefit services contract in the middle of the year versus waiting until that time frame? It's a nature of how we run our plan design. We do a first of the year plan design. Some people do a first of July plan design. It's how our plan design has been set up years and years ago. And if I might add, making the change now in the period between September. to look at how the programs are running and then also do the analysis to see what are

127some of those additional programs that can be put in place for January 1st. There's a lot of analytic information that has to be gathered, a lot of the data that has to be pulled together, RFPs for the pharmacy solutions. So that doesn't happen overnight. So we have all of this time as our runway to learn about what's in place, what has worked, and what are the... items that haven't been input yet. So that for that January 1st, it's already in place. Because those will really get implemented probably to start like in October, but they won't come to fruition. So really this value of service we're getting between whenever the contract begins through December is your ongoing maintenance, you're answering questions and taking care of claim problems and things like that, you'll take over for our

128existing provider. then and then the rest your time has been just ramping up for next year or what's the value in this year I guess this calendar year right it's doing all the planning and strategize and analysis of potential programs for your next year to try to contain the costs Additionally the items that we can do something about now working with your clinic working on the employee education That's definitely something that we have found that is a kind of can often be a mess because starting in May when we're working with the district we're able to go for PD days but we've actually given already Pam some educational information about promoting Teladoc So where there's a lot of things that we can do for employee education, and the reason that's important is teaching people about

129those care navigation opportunities of where they can go for lower costs. So it might not be those big giant ticket items right away in May for the pharmacy, but there's a lot of other information and trust that can be gained in the upcoming months of 2020. Okay. So our insurance, who manages our insurance? UHC currently manages our insurance? UMR? Okay. The UHC umbrella? Okay. I heard, and I'd love to know your thoughts about that. There's a conflict of interest with UMR, which is part of UHC, negotiating rates with UHC. And I know they say that they're not sharing information, but I don't buy that one. one bit at all. What do you do for, what is your recommendations for a replacement of UMR or UHC? Do you guys have like a smaller and more independent

130companies that you work with? Is that part of your recommendation that you're going to be bringing to us for next year? There would be a lot to consider. Michelle and I just did this for another school district where right now they're fully insured, but they are going down the path of self-funded. So part of that process was a third-party administrator RFP. where we looked at the different options there. And it depends on what you want to get out of it. Are there other options? Yes. There are more boutique options that give you more control over the various components within that third party administrator. So that would be something that we would definitely suggest taking a look at and seeing if it's the right fit for this district. And a change in a TPA takes months

131to do that? not to just do the evaluation because the TPA is then in charge of your entire plan design. So that whole summary plan descriptor. 60-some pages, getting line item to make sure that the coverage is running the way the district wants from one TPA to another is a really laborious process. And so it's picking the right TPA for the district. Is UMR the right one or are there one of these other options out there? And then making sure that the plan is set up, again, for January. And that's why, again, the district's timing might seem a little bit off just because a lot of people are thinking of just that deductible reset for January. but there's everything that has to be exactly right before January 1st. Okay. So I read in your RFP

132there that you're managing Greenfield. Greendale. Greendale. I wrote it down wrong. I can't read glasses. Greendale. Thank you. I know, right? How long have you been managing Greendale? Since 2018. And what have their rates been with them? What have their rates since 2018 been to present? It's public. Everything's public. Right, okay, but I guess you can look that stuff up too. But the recent analysis that was done for Greendale when they moved from fully insured to self-funding has been a $3.7 million savings. I hate to even... When did they move from full insured to self-insured? In 2020. 2020 so since 2020 have their rates stayed pretty low or have you seen continual increases in there as well There have been some increases but they have been able to make changes in network or adding in

133a well I think it's the next Nexus network similar to Elmbrook here but they have maintained their Plan design made no plan design changes still having a $250 single deductible and a $500 family deductible with a hundred percent coinsurance since 2018 So having been able to manage that with also staying within their budget for this entire time period. A significant portion of that too Is the education directly with the employees getting the buy-in from the staff Here's why we're doing certain things with the self-funded plan such as direct contracting for things like physical therapy and their their on-site clinic Teaching people this is why you want to at least consider it because at the end of the day today's claims are tomorrow's premiums Today's claims are tomorrow's plan design so if you can get your

134teachers and staff to buy in and Have some thought into where they're going for care and when they seek care it can pay dividends allows them to offer such a good plan So you do you know offhand like what their premiums what their total health care costs have have changed over I know that you said the premiums to say the same but that's different than what the total cost is have you Seen a total cost Sam I could get you a summary of Greendale's performance. We are in networking with them all the time right now I'm sorry if this is this I'd like to have these questions answered now if that's okay don't know that the business of the board can wait we have a series of policies that need to be read and finished

135I can certainly connect with you around the details of the performance I'd like to just finish answering my questions here publicly if that's okay sure Sam go ahead but thank you This is a $17 million decision, and to pass over this in 15 minutes is foolish and unwise. I'm not trying to hurry you along in that, but just in terms of Greendale's performance. Well, we should take this really serious. This is very, very important to know. If we're going to be hiring a company that's going to be the high-performing company that has a proven track record of success and not to just pass over it like a quick decision. So I want you to ask your questions, but Greendale questions may not. really help us with a number of decisions it does help us because

136it tells us how good they are as a company if they've taken over greendale in 2020 and they've maintained their rates at a low level then they're working really hard for the district that's what we want is a company that's going to work really hard for the district and if that's where they are they're going to be able to tell me that and that's going to be a great decision right so how do we else judge their performance if we don't look and see how they've done elsewhere and i think that should be a good public discussion to have To answer that piece of it, Sam, then I can tell you that the district has maintained their premium levels, they've maintained their benefit, the quality of their benefits. Their overall costs, have they increased over

137time? Yes, but they've also added people to their plan designs. They've also had high cost claimant situations that are out of the control of the district or the members that are on their plan. But I can also tell you that they're extremely satisfied with the plans and the rates that they have in place. And they're celebrating that they're on target for their budget for this year again. So whatever they are managing with their budget, they're very satisfied with the services that they've received from R&R and the rates that they're paying for their stop loss, for their pharmacy benefit manager, as well as... You know, there are direct contracts that we have in place. But I don't know the numbers. I just can't tell you the numbers off the top of my head. I'll be honest

138with you. That would be good to know. And I appreciate that people are happy with that. But some people like to keep paying more money. They're just happy that, you know, it's not too much more because it's government. And, you know, some people view it as an endless supply of money. So when I talk to private organizations and other businesses, they like to see their premiums go down, and they are really active about watching because it's their money. So as a constituent in the community. I think it's important to know very clearly how well are you performing. Are you keeping their numbers down? And that's important. And I just want to know that you guys are going to work really, really hard for the district. And keep our numbers down because that's where the success

139is. I guess when I've studied this more and I've got into this more, I've seen a lot of creative ways that people are bringing expenses down. And I just want to know where you guys are at on that. And then just my final real question is that... One of the other things that someone shared with me was the high-cost claims and a way to manage that. Do you have any creative ways that you've seen to be able to help move that off of the cost or to minimize that or other options out there? The high-cost claimants, there's always going to be some that are uncontrollable, but there are, again, programs out there that would be brought to the table for consideration. One example that some other districts have been considering is called Samaritan Fund. If

140you're familiar with that. I am. But that is a program, technically it's a voluntary program, right, where you as the district pay a fee to the Samaritan Fund, and it is a hefty fee, but then that person voluntarily leaves the program. Okay. And 100%. And so that's something you're familiar with and you've done with other schools? Programs like that, absolutely. Great. And then just to final, there's no, I know your fee, I just want to make sure I'm very clear on this, because I don't understand. I feel like we've asked these questions in the past, and everyone says, oh, we don't get any kickbacks, we don't get any commissions, we don't get any overrides, we don't get any, if you don't ask the question really specifically. And I've heard of your organization, I've done business

141with you guys, you're a good organization. So to be really clear, there's no override commissions from big insurance companies at all that comes back to you guys whatsoever. We are not taking overrides from any of the carriers. Do you work on any type of incentive with other schools or other districts where if you bring down the cost by X number of dollars, you guys get a higher fee for your hard work? Do you do things like that? There are a couple that we're doing that, and that is, it's interesting you say that. We're members of what's called the Shuriks Global. It's an international association or membership of independent agencies like us. executive team lead for benefits just came back from the conference and that was one of the most prevalent topics talked about. There's more

142and more organizations, districts, private employers are seeking that in their contracts. Okay. I'd be a fan of that, to be honest with you, because that gives incentive for you to work really hard and find those ways and I think that that'd be something I would be willing to support in exploring that. So thank you for all your time and I really appreciate it. I'm done with my questions. Thank you, Sam. Are there any other questions or comments? Kathy? So I am not opposed to change. I think it was good. I think served on personnel two years, and when I got on two years ago, we reported in the meeting there was a significant spike in infection, cancer, and multiple sclerosis diagnosis. So that's of course a huge flag because those are treatments that you need

143perpetually and you know you Don't want anyone to have that ever right So I guess you know the concern because those are uncontrollable I mean the treatments out there treatments, you know, they should have access to those treatments So the concern always was I mean, it's always gonna go up. That's just health care. That's how it is and Yet you were told no everything is fine. Everything is fine. And now all of a sudden we had ish I don't know maybe it was time to part with the USI So I guess my question to you is so we if we approve this we basically have two services overlapping until the other expires correct your first year So no we would end services with USI on March 31st we're obligated to continue paying our contracts through

144June 30th R&R would become the agent of record April 1st, and because we're paying our other contract, they have agreed to no fee for that first three-month period. But contractually, there's two overlapping? The contract with R&R wouldn't be, the effective date on it would be July 1. And then after your first year, the fee may go up, and after you... look into our programs In year two assuming we hit our performance targets we would get the same fee that we got paid in year one so there's no inflationary adjustment to that if we did not hit the targets our fee would go down in year two Were the five companies who bid for this given like high level of our basic data just to do some you know real-time presentation on how they could help

145with whatever data provider or was it just this is what we can do for you kind of presentation the the four firms that were invited in firm presentation were given some basic information about our recent claims information so I heard you say all the programs we have to find out what your programs are because I'm thinking like I shouldn't say it but are you sure you want this? I mean not that it's bad, it's huge. It's huge and your cost seems like pretty not a lot. But just wondering if you're walking into, I know you've been doing this forever, but just walking into not just trying to get another account but just really looking into it and seeing. understanding what you're walking into is what you know That's why we have a great team at

146R&R we have an analytics team that is chomping at the bit to dive into the data and see what the data shares with us one of the things that was very clear in the whole RFP process was that you as the board and then Dr. Hansen and Pam and the others wanted communication consistent communication It's not always going to be good You may not like some of the things you hear when we get into the data But you're gonna get it you are gonna be able to make informed decisions based on what Michelle and I and the analytics team and others Provide you with and if there's things you're not seen Let us know I mean, it's a two-way street to have a successful partnership. So we're very confident we're going to be able to

147work well with you guys. And we're not afraid of hard work. We're not afraid of tough conversations. It's what we do. I've been doing this since 1993. Thank you and I mean pharmaceuticals will be a wild roller coaster coming up and then and one question I did ask at the personnel was of course with any contract you always have to ask is there a conflict of interest in you know getting into this contract partnership and there was no conflict of interest between the board and R&R and I'm always supportive and independent so thank you for your time Thank you Kathy. Other board member questions? All right this will be back next month as a action item thank you okay our next discussion item of the evening is the school start time committee we welcome Jacob

148Eisen did I say your name right? Yeah Eisen Eisen Howard got you without the R Howard got you Good evening everyone I'm here to talk about the school start time board committee first one to introduce myself my name is Jacob Eisen I am a proud father of two children in the Elmbrook School District one at Pilgrim Park go Vikings and one at or no Panthers and then one at Burleigh go Vikings so I was really excited when this opportunity came when it was came out in the email in September and as you So I'm here to talk about my experience here and kind of how it's been going from my perspective. So as you all know, you as the board voted for the authorization of the School Start Time Committee on October 29th. There was,

149much like me, there was a lot of interest and individuals wanting to take part in this committee. Over 80 individuals actually completed the necessary form to be a part of the committee. I think it was decided at that time that because there was such an interest that everybody would, we would essentially take everyone into a very large committee that started, actually the first meeting occurred in November. and we've averaged about and actually one of the nice things about it other than the fact that 80 individuals were invited that there was nine students that were actually invited to also take part from the Elmbrook high schools and middle schools which was very refreshing because their perspective was then I think very very important when we've been discussing what we've been discussing in our meetings. We've averaged

150about 70 individuals per meeting since then and that's just a result of you know illnesses or work-related obligations or school events. A lot of band concerts seemingly occurring on Tuesdays at night. So again, we have met three times since the beginning of it and most recently in the mid-January. They've been two-hour sessions and they've been facilitated by the district's chief strategy officer, Mr. Chris Thompson. One thing I've really appreciated is that we get two hours of time to make these discussions and we do so in a very efficient manner. But I think it's done in a way that allows for a real healthy engagement of people being able to exchange their kind of... concerns or interests based on the things that they were talking about a lot of shared viewpoints a lot of really great

151table work being done so kind of like everybody comes together to talk about the topic at hand and then we kind of write down what we took from it and then kind of as a group kind of review the material and then kind of from there um talk about kind of the things that are on that agenda one of the things i do appreciate chris does is he does have an agenda and a direction for every single meeting so The first one being just kind of like a review of the materials particularly the research that kind of prompted the committee to be coming to formation and So while we do have a lot of discussion is definitely kept in pace to meeting our objective of giving you guys a recommendation in March I should say

152actually our next meeting is actually next week Tuesday and at that point we've already we're kind of discussing scenarios of what we would like to focus on toward the recommendation we're looking to finalize those as well as talk about a district survey that would be sent out to kind of get feedback from the community Another another Component of the committee meetings is actually kind of a follow-up meeting that individuals volunteer to take part in initially we had like tables that individuals would facilitate at and from that 15 team members were chosen to kind of take part in that I volunteered of course to be part of that follow-up meeting and which is held virtually and it's really just kind of a recap of how the meeting went you know whether we hit our objectives that

153particular agenda and just kind of follow through with essentially the kind of the pulse check of like how each table went how people felt that they felt heard the questions they were asking things that we potentially were missed and just little bit more focus or directivity as we moved on to the next topic of the subsequent meeting again it's been very I think it's done very efficiently and it's allowed us to kind of really hone in on kind of what we need to talk about during that follow-up meeting So the first two meetings were really kind of exploratory. We did get materials prior to the first meeting to kind of review and read, particularly about the research and position statements, as you see on the slide. We have research and position statements that we primarily

154focused on and have kind of informed our kind of thinking as we move into the sleep research and the state legislation. That's followed in and obviously the with just I invite you to look at it But really the focus being that as children move through adolescence that it's very clear that research says they didn't eat at least nine or more hours of sleep every night and obviously that's driven by entry into puberty changes in circadian rhythms and just other factors that promote that promote the insurance that children are going to be able to not only academically perform well, but also are going through developmental milestones and achieving like good healthy life. One thing that we also looked at is that what states have already enacted this kind of changes and California and Florida are kind

155of leading the way already having enacted these changes where school start times are being mandated to start at least until after 8 o'clock and there are other states that are kind of beginning this discussion and their own individual legislation. So that was, you know, there was a big focus on the research and from that emerging questions about the inherent complexities that come with this kind of discussion. There was a very smart man who made a water balloon analogy who I thought was very, very good about as you squeeze the water balloon, all their parts shoot out of it. And, you know, a lot of those complexities that we talked about were just, you know. the what the changes could be if as we look at the current three-tiered busing model and how impacts full start

156times i learned a lot about busing that i never thought i would ever know and the associated kind of factors that kind of influence us including extracurricular activities child care and then just kind of even things um hazardous zones Very interesting phenomena. But again, we actually had an opportunity to review all of these as well as look at attendance and co-curricular participation data. It was very informative and just kind of demonstrated that while we obviously are using the research as our guiding point toward making a recommendation that we also had to take into account these other complexities that can impact school start times and other factors. And so finally, We're working toward making our final recommendation to the board here on March 18th and where we also, part of that recommendation may also be board

157policy changes. Again, this coming Tuesday, we'll be really focusing on our start time options so that we can really then build a plan around that, what policy changes would need to occur, and then likewise, consider a survey needs, a district survey to be sent out to kind of get feedback from the community, and what questions are gonna be the most appropriate to target. getting that information. And then likewise, or then the following meeting, we're going to be looking at the survey result feedback and then finally coming that final consensus of our recommendations, which we will then present to you March 18th. And with that, I'm going to do my best to answer any questions or comments you have. Thank you so much. That was a very great presentation. Good job. Sam. Thank you, Jacob. And

158also, thank you for volunteering. I know that you don't get paid as much as we do. So appreciate that very much. So on the presentation then on March 18th, will you also, is this something that you guys are looking at to the, if there's going to be a change in costs to busing or any of that, is that something that you're going to be bringing or you're just going to come and say, this is what we really would like to see happen? I'm not 200% familiar with this process. Yeah, I believe there's a recommendation. Whether there's going to be a sort of a cost associated, I think has obviously been discussed and I would think. The notion of it being cost neutral is obviously always going to be a favorable thing. I don't necessarily know

159if that's going to be something that's going to be presented at that time or what those associated costs are going to be. So you're not giving that information in your guys' determination in this process or your recommendation is not going to be looking at that information? No, we haven't gotten as far into the process yet as to kind of solidify what our choice would be and if there would be an associated cost to it. Yeah, if I could add to that and fantastic job We're not getting into the Chris has done a really good job of telling us where cost may become a factor where policy changes may become a factor where busing issues may become a factor and that will be noted I'm sure because that those those qualifications are riding with each of

160the proposals that we're looking at whether it's going to be a the dollar I don't anticipate that's within the board scope to come up with the exact dollar amount that would become operationalized once we once we really look at the proposals and and start doing the board work So I guess the follow-up question then if this is being presented in March and then I'm guessing voting in April will there be information maybe Chris will know this If a proposal is coming there'll be information for the proposed cost and everything The way I envision it is they'll have a recommended model or maybe models if they want to give the board two options say And it'll take us some time to sort through those models so I don't see the board necessarily endorsing the recommendations like

161we have in in the past on task force work like virtual school an example I think we're gonna need to read where the board wants to go with the recommendation first and what additional details you are going to need to get there and then we're gonna have to get that information and then bring it back for discussion and action but I don't see all of that happening in a meeting or it could take the entire night I mean you know because we're spending 15 hours just in this task force group to get to a point of a of a solid recommendation I'm anticipating whatever it might be But there are a lot of complexities here, you know survey feedback all the data For example hazardous zones one, you know if If the recommendation is to

162have the sheriff do a study or the county sheriff to do a study to eliminate or reduce or create walk zones, not eliminate, but create walk zones in this community, that needs to happen before we could ever act on one of the recommendations. That would be an example, and that's going to take a while. You know of no current legislation or conversation happening at the legislature about changing schools to our time like they did for California and Florida? Okay. I just didn't know. There's not going to be any pressure outside from us to do this. No, but can I? There are municipalities in the state that have already done this. Madison Schools did this two years ago, and we got a good look at what the hurdles have been, because change always presents hurdles, but

163how they have implemented it. And I know Chris talked to people there. Chris and... Michelle have talked to people in Madison we also took a look at models in the suburban Illinois the northern suburban Illinois schools where they have also implemented these kinds of changes based on the research that we've looked at too so well it's not statewide in Wisconsin it's happening municipality at a time And I said to the group if it can happen in Florida and if it can happen in California the two bookends it could happen anywhere somewhere in the middle well I'm excited I think this changes time is a positive thing so I'm looking forward to this presentation thank you so much other questions Kathy thank you for all the work and it's right you have to decide what you

164want to do and approve that motion before you can operationalize any actions thank you I just want to thank you for a really excellent presentation. Getting to be part of this group has been a real treat for me and I came in as a skeptic. Chris knows that I came in as a skeptic with this many people, but the quality and the collaboration involved in the discourse in this group of people has been phenomenal. I was at the state convention and attended a couple sessions on communication where they made strong cases about information versus engagement and this has truly been an activity of engagement with a wide swath of the community and I think that bodes very well for coming up with a you know, if 70 people can come up with a recommendation it

165bodes well for engaging the rest of the community in a change should we approve a change because change is always going to Be met with some resistance Thank You Mary Prita and then Jean. I just want to say thank you It was a very thorough presentation and I really appreciate the hard work that has gone into this committee and again yourself and all of the volunteers who are there doing this. So just want to say thank you. I'll say ditto. Jacob again, thank you. I, you know, when I voted in favor of this committee, it's because You know, six is good. Seven, we have to make the decisions, but it's such a complex and nuanced issue. And so I appreciate the multitude of perspectives, and I can only imagine the table conversation and the things

166that are happening. That's what I wanted to see is kind of that, you know, what am I not seeing? I'm just one person, so it's really great to have seven deep perspectives. that will then combine and make a good recommendation to the board, and that makes our decision-making process better. So again, thank you for your time. It really is going to make a difference for students every day. So thank you. Thanks for having me. Our next discussion, we're starting into policies. Here we go. I think we can move through these decently quickly, depending on questions. So each committee chair will take their respective policy series. The first one is the 2000 policy series. Gene. Bringing policy 2111 forward superintendent of schools position description and the revision is the change for the assistant superintendent for human

167resources Any questions for Gina on the 2000 policy series? Okay, that'll be it back next month on the consent agenda direct any yeah, Sam Sorry, I do have a question. I'm under the board superintendent under the 2111 right Just clarification. I want to understand, like, from what I understood, the makeup of the Board of Education is the seven elected members, and then there's on the, under the Board Superintendent Relations, the first paragraph, the very last sentence, it says the superintendent shall have the right to speak at board meetings on all matters before the board. Is that the state law, or is that just something that we're adding into the policy above and beyond that? I don't know that it's law Mark do you It's part of our existing policy but I don't know the origin

168of it I'm just confused like if it's the seven board I mean of course we want the superintendent to speak we want that as an option but given that as a right to speak it seems like it's putting on the same status as the elected positions of the board members so I don't understand how we would have that as a policy that says shall have the right to speak because it's not an elected position Mary did you have anything The 3000 policy series So we reviewed three policies at the January 22nd F&O meeting and all three were forwarded to the full board for discussion and approval the first is policy 3120 which is the preparation of the budget documents we are reconfirming this policy no changes were recommended And that was unanimously approved during the

169F&O meeting. Next was policy 3180, the fund balance general fund. Again, a reconfirmation with no changes recommended. The third was policy 3271, which is the rental of musical instruments. And again, that is being reconfirmed with no changes recommended. All three of these policies were unanimously voted through to the full board for consideration. Thank you. Are there questions for Preetha on the 3,000 policy series? That'll be back in next week's consent, or next week's, next month's consent agenda. Jean, the 4,000 policy series. Bringing 4,000 policy series 4,100. Equal employment opportunity has been revised with guidance from legal counsel that EEO policies apply broadly to discrimination and not narrowly as written. So you'll see that those revisions have been made to move from the language of harassment to discrimination. And they suggested removal of some, removing redundant

170language that binds the compliance officers to take certain actions. For example, having to transcribe oral interviews with the complainant, having to provide status updates to the parties. The proposed changes none of them are legally required But nor is language that's being stricken Legally required but they minimize the administrative burden and allow for more flexibility and processing and investigating complaints of discrimination Mr. Jean Sam so just logistically speaking and 4100 and 4405 We have listed that Pam Casey and Chris individually in there is that should we just leave that more open to Assistant Superintendent of Human Resources or do we need to be specific on the name of this just prevent having to change this every time there's a I don't expect anyone soon but I don't know I thought best practice for us was to

171not do that So general guideline in this space is to have a name so people can associate the name with where to register the complainant general guideline and if that is there something that kicks up if that person were to change roles or something we have to bring the policy back and revise it with a new name they generally don't want you to do positions because it doesn't have a personal name to it when I attended the school board legal conference they with these type of policies that they add specific names for the very purpose that mark is yeah I don't like it either but I think it is strongly recommended if not required in the case of yeah who to contact then moving on to 4101 on discrimination based on genetic information revised as

172well the complaint procedural lines to the procedure outlined in 44 05 harassment revisions aligning the investigation process to discrimination investigation process as well and 44 15 alcohol and drug-free workplace revising aligning with the terms outlined in the drug-free workplace Act and I think Kathy you could raise the question in terms of controlled substances and that that be more broadly broadly defined rather than has it had been narrowly illicit drugs My memory is not serving me well and this so the controlled substance I mean so Wisconsin now is allowed to buy some controlled substances right and in forms of with actual THC in there how do we handle a situation like that even though you is it legal to buy but not allowed to have on Just like I guess alcohol would be that too, right?

173You're allowed to buy it, but you're not allowed to come to school is there a way that that we would have to test for that or Spell that out differently at all or no. So this policy did have attorney review and encouraged us to use the controlled substance Wording so as to be broad because that does include Products that might be made legal that aren't right now that we would consider a controlled substance still and would be prevented to be in the workplace with So we're in good shape. Okay Thank you Okay, thank you the 4,000 policy series will be back next month Please contact me with any questions Kathy the 5,000 policy series the one policy that came back one five one four four point three we four four point three we had a

174question about the duration of you know record-keeping so if you look at the edited version the explanation that Dan Scott and Chris was at the TLC meeting because this falls under student policy for the record keeping for other meetings we are updating this to be in court in accordance with other policies and then retained footage relating to a student will be retained per student record policy 5125 so the question came well does that mean You know it's gonna be kept so any inquiry that is made so for example Example that Chris gave was if there's a parking lot incident, so there's an investigation That doesn't mean every investigation is found guilty, right? So it wouldn't be fair for them to like keep that on that record if it's found according to the 5125 policy that

175it should be on it's deemed to be on the student's record it will be kept on record for that purpose only so with a question about 60 days and what if there's a pending investigation and all that so the clarity was provided and this is strictly pertaining to student record and employee record we have pulled out because we have its own standing employee handbook and protocol policy. So that was clarified and any other questions on this record keeping? I wondered about the change from 60 to 120. Did you say it and I missed it? It was 60 and I think it was from certain meetings. Correct. Because it was recommended from prior meetings we had about open record and public. Here comes Chris with all the answers And storage requirements we can't do 120 days

176and really haven't been able to do 120 days with the amount of cameras that we have now we have over 450 cameras in the district and to record and retain that amount of data 60 days was was manageable and financially responsible similar to what's being done in other districts in terms of that time frame Yeah, and I think in our past experience, I mean if there are needs those are identified within a week or two of an event happening and then the data is recorded and offloaded and then we have it and then the Investigation takes takes place and if the date and if the data is no longer needed it goes away Like Kathy said if it becomes a record it becomes a record From what we remember too, Chris, that if there was

177something that an incident did occur that is permanently saved in that student's record as well right so that footage is saved and there is that backup is reserved indefinitely correct If the investigation proves that it should be on the student record because just because someone said hey Mark did something and Scott and That you know if someone's accused of it they do investigation just because Scott was investigated on someone's report that doesn't mean that Goes on his record per se that wouldn't be fair. I don't remember it that way I thought it was any incident that came up it would go on their record If you said there was a fight in the hallway and I grabbed the footage and I found out there was no fight in the hallway and you named a kid,

178a student. Yeah, okay, of course. And I found out and I did the investigation, pulled the footage and found out there wasn't a fight in the hallway and the student involved wasn't involved, it's gone. It's not that student's record. It's nobody's record because there is no record. If it became a discipline incident then it becomes a student record Would it be on both students whether it was one kid's fault or not would it be on both of those records would maintain that footage Victim and the attacker If you have any questions please send them to Chris Thank you that concludes the 5,000 policy series who do have a request to speak before we jump into the 6,000 policy if that's okay Kathy Angie Pingel a resident the district is going to address the board again

179As we all know I am the owner of a service job My son Ben has a service dog who has been an amazing tool for him and has become a member of our family with all of the wonderful things she does for my son. So I really wanted to take a very close look at policy 6007. And federal and state law about service dogs is very, very clear. You want to make sure you're following it. You don't want to add things that aren't required under the law because then you can be People can allege discrimination issues against you. It's just a very slippery slope that I would advise my clients not to go down. And I just wanted to point out a couple of things that are not well founded in the law. So first

180of all, in the very beginning of the policy, it says all service animals in district facilities and school events must be in compliance with legal requirements. That is, be licensed and have required vaccinations. The only vaccination that's required is for a dog service animal, and it's a rabies vaccine. There are not more. There's one. Then as you go down, you talk about removal. There are very specific requirements about when a service dog can be removed from a forum or a public event, and you don't really reference it. You just say that there could be limitations on the presence of a service animal imposed by... building principles. Again, slippery slope. You might want to reconsider that language and take another look at it. In the next bullet point, you talk about training, which is well established

181under Wisconsin law, and you say that district students who are service animal trainers can't bring them to school. I'd suggest you reread the statute and make sure that you're in compliance with Wisconsin law. Then I keep going down and I get to the numbered items at the bottom of the page. And you've got a reference to a statute in number two, Wisconsin Statute 17401 Sub 1. Not sure that that's what you meant because that statute is entitled restraining actions Against a dog and sub 1 is entitled killing a dog. So I'm sure you didn't mean that So that's got to be some kind of typo and I would ask that you get that fixed Then when you go to the next page You've added some new requirements that are not found within federal or state

182law that animals have to be spayed or neutered Not true While many legitimate service dog companies do spay and neuter their dogs for training purposes, it is not a requirement by law. Nor is animal being treated and kept free from fleas or ticks. Well, I'm sure you would love that because nobody would want a dog in sight that has that. Still not required by law. One second, Angie. Can you leave the microphone on? You go down a little further and you restart the numbered list, and there's this number four about whether an animal shall have a harmful impact on other students or staff members. I'd suggest you review that one as well. Might not be allowed under the law. And then this last paragraph that was added, huh. Definitely not required under the law. I

183should not have to contact you if my son's service dog is going to attend a school event with me. That's beyond what the law requires. You're putting on things that... Just aren't there and could be detrimental to us and cause us not to bring our service dog Which would be detrimental to my son and in limit his access to events? So I would suggest you want to reread that section as well and make sure that you are complying with federal and state law and if you have any questions I'd be happy to answer them because this is something that is near and dear to my heart and as a service dog trainer We've spent a lot of time covering what the requirements are under the law Thank You Angie okay with that Cathy the six

184thousand policy series Emily you got those notes that Angie mentioned I think well first we'll go through six thousand most are reconfirmed typos and I'll talk about what Angie had addressed any questions or anything else other than the six zero zero seven point one and policy and practice state. Two statements. Any other questions on the other policies? Board member questions on any of the policies? Okay. So maybe those two, and I did read it, and I was trying to go through all the statutes. So one ask was going to be just make sure that because these are TLC and involve students and lots of federal. civil rights and ADA laws. I was gonna ask Emily just make sure all the Wisconsin statutes are correctly cited just because we were adding the statutes this time just

185to be consistent with how we've been improving our policy. So those things that points that Angie had mentioned if we're adding policies in addition to what the statute allows because statute can be very vague I just want to make sure those are legit because a lot of the if you look at the legal references there's a lot of it involves ADA civil rights laws that you just want to be very more maybe just go through it with finer comb just because those are So you want to just take that back to the committee then? Yeah, maybe I'll do that. All right, let's just do that. So you're taking back 6007? 6007 and 6007.1. I could also comb through it, but maybe something I may forward you to just kind of vet through it just because

186they do cite pretty hefty federal law and civil rights and ADA. Are you talking about civil rights and ADA from the student perspective? Because we're quoting it and there's some words as Angie has pointed out that are in addition verbatim which a lot of policies we do but we just want to make sure it's not overstepping what I the protection of the Rehab Act right and the ADA and the civil rights section that was mentioned so just want to find comb that because those are very tricky you'd never want to step half step more than what it's allowed so I think it'd be good to do just due diligence to make sure I would think there would be there would be certain requirements on the part of students and safety and health and such requirements

187on the school end how those interplay with the requirements for service animals we'd have to figure out just like um the like sort of greater good cannot impinge on someone else's rights right so that's where we don't want to go and these laws are to make sure that individual rights are not violated based on the greater good kind of thought. So I don't think it'll hurt to just kind of go through a fine comb. So I'll take those back to the committee. Kathy, yeah, and I think also there are district policies like the 6157 about animals in the classroom in general that would be things we ought to take a look at in addition to the federal and state laws. There may be policies that are built in. at the district level that have to

188be taken into consideration well we'll go take those two back because it's on the docket if we need to bring no I'm just saying that's a reference point in six thousand seven point one so we'll go through it and see what we what path we cross then we'll we'll connect the dots okay thank you any questions about the six thousand policy before we move on all right that brings us to the eight thousand policy series it's me Couple of things here the first policy 8200 is a recommended rescission mainly because it's in another board policy some of the information 8300 and it's also addressed in Wisconsin State statute directly and so there's really no need to have a district policy that talks about absentee ballots polling places those things that kind of live in Municipal

189municipality world more than our world as a school board And then the policy 8510, just two revisions here. One is the, I guess there's... Yeah, two reasons that we're removing the time frame to add an agenda item just striking that language and The no later than March first phrase in terms of setting our board calendar. That is our practice But we felt like it was fairly restrictive just to have the date on there Why does there need to be a deadline a specific that such a specific deadline on the school calendar again? This isn't school calendar. This is the board meeting calendar. So Those two changes were made with that policy. Any questions on the 8,000 policy series? Okay, hearing none, that'll be back next month. Just contact me or Chris Thompson if you have

190questions. The 9,000 policy series, a few more changes here. I'll go through these. The first one, 9301, just as a reconfirmation, 9630, just removing the words administrative procedures. because we have the practice statement, which is the administrative procedure. So there's really no reason, again, redundant there to have that wording. The policy 9660 in regards to legal counsel, we're removing the attorney attendance and then just the language that's duplicative and just at the bottom adding references to state statute, which again is a... change we've been making across all of our policies. Policy 9670, board membership and organizations and reimbursement. So removing some duplication language here and honorariums which Think Mary was the only one on the committee to even know what an honorarium is I was not aware before we had the conversation and then just

191to update the expense approval process which was a little outdated and Didn't even match our practice statement form Which is the next thing we'll talk about and then adding references the statutes there and the policy as far as the corresponding practice statement again removing the duplicated the duplication language and updating the IRS rates, and who approves what expenses there. Any questions on the 9,000 policy series? Okay, hearing none, that will be back next month. Contact me or Chris with questions. That concludes our discussion items for the evening. Brings us to the Board President Report. One second while I switch tabs here. So I attended two major events this last month since our last board meeting. One was the WASBE conference and had a lot of great conversations there, had a chance to go to some

192work sessions for board presidents, presentations, and I think Preetha and Mary had an equally awesome experience, which will be... part of our agenda just a little bit later in the discussion by exception items but one of the things several conversations struck me but way there was a I heard it repeated several times the sentiment that Elmbrook is the district that everybody wants to be from a couple from vendors and then also other board members from different districts, people I didn't know. And it did cause me to think about what makes Elmbrook great. And so... I'm a scientist guy, like to think of formulas and reactions and what makes a formula go. So I thought, well, the formula for success, it's got to include engaged students. It would need to have involved families, competent and excited

193teachers, an educated and active electorate, and then a dedicated board and administration. But we're not the only place that has those elements. I think there's other places in Wisconsin that have those. So what makes Elmbrook special? And I'm not sure I have the answer, but I think that one of the answers as part of the formula is the people. When I was a teacher in high school, we had Friendship Week, the week of Valentine's Day, which is this week. And so out of nostalgia, I wanted to just write or state a quick friendship note to each of these groups of... people in our Elmbrook community. First of all, to the parents, thank you for choosing Elmbrook and trusting us with your kids. That's no small thing. When we think about parents sending their most precious...

194person often in their life their own children to us in our schools and we take that responsibility very seriously. To our staff my friendship note would be keep up the amazing work. The dark days of February are a real phenomenon in education. Certainly I felt it as a teacher and as an administrator it was my job in February to keep our teachers going and so I would tell our teachers you can make it until spring break. And it will feel sad in daylight. You think daylight savings is the turning point. It's not because it actually gets dark again in the morning. You're like, ah, I lost the daylight that I had. Hang in there and thank you for making a difference for our students every day to the administration This brings me to the second

195event that I had a chance to attend with dr Pritha kudiyara and Mary Wacker to celebrate the second year in a row of our district being ranked in the top 50 in the niche rankings and Certainly as a board when we have one data point is good and we celebrate it But that does not a trend make and two data points is better. And so Kudos mark to you and your administrative team again got a chance to be with the administrative cabinet That would be the principal's assistant principal celebrate with cake Because the things that we're doing in terms of improvement in our buildings and making a difference for students every day happens there with great leadership So thank you and keep up the good work and congratulations Thank you for helping implement the board's

196vision. And to our community, many people choose to live in Brookfield and Elm Grove because of the schools. 80% or so of residents do not have school-aged children. Some probably have grandchildren here, but... That's a lot of people who live here that maybe don't have a direct connection to our schools. So as a school board, we promise to administer your tax dollars judiciously and keep our schools at the top in the state of Wisconsin, which is a great value add for not only the village of Elm Grove, but also the city of Brookfield. And with that, I'll conclude my report. Are there any questions or comments? Okay, I think we're to the discussion Informational items discussion by exception only are there any thing that board members would like to discuss? Either way I was there

197via video were you in there in person? I wanted to discuss that the next parent network meeting will be held at the district office or via Google Meet on Wednesday, February 19th from 12 to 1 p.m. So that's first of all. There are two upcoming programs for Parent Network. On Wednesday, February 26th from 7 to 8.30 p.m. There is a program. called TikTok, Snapchat, and AI, oh my, helping young people navigate technology in the modern world. That will be held at Wisconsin Hills Middle School Library, and there is information and registration information available on the Elmbrook Schools website, the parent network link. Also on Monday, March 10th, there are between 7 and 8.30 p.m. A presentation will be done. entitled Driving Factors of Teenage Depression and Anxiety, How to Minimize Risk and Build Resistance, by

198my friend Dr. Charlie Gabler, Ewing, and that's going to be held at Pilgrim Park Middle School Library. Again, information and registration link will be coming soon. So I just wanted to keep everyone updated. Thank you. And one of the things that Parent Network's been discussing is programming for next year, and there really are a lot of exciting things planned, and it's been a great resource for parents that have chosen to engage. So hopefully everybody will. Are there other items the board members would like to discuss? Okay, hearing none. Close to being done at 9, but I don't think we'll make it, Mark. Here you go, your superintendent report. As Christy pulls up the superintendent report, I wanted to... Thank the community for making our schools so vibrant I had a chance on a Saturday in

199sweatpants and a sweatshirt to go visit one of our schools They invited me to to appear at the chess tournament and inside that school I found the field house was full of a basketball tournament. The robotics facility was full of kids with robotics and the chess tournament encompassed about a third of the school. And then I found a CNA class running in one of our classrooms, and I found an ACT prep classroom running on a Saturday morning at 9 o'clock. The building was full. I couldn't park legally anywhere on campus. It was amazing. So that's why we built the schools, and it was really a testament to how this community focuses on kids and focuses on kids' success in school. So thank you for everybody. Another event that warmed my heart was this past Friday.

200We had our second unified sports basketball game and celebrated the contributions of Hannah Christensen, who helped us get this all started. That picture you see there is a picture of the Brookfield Central and Brookfield East unified sports teams. There was not a dry eye in the house. It was a full-capacity crowd. standing room only amazing amazing experience so congratulations to everybody involved in that another major event that occurred at brookfield east was the bandorama which is the east side of our community burleigh dixon tonwanda pilgrim park and brookfield east all had a band concert together in the field house at brookfield east they finished with on wisconsin it was spectacular amazing event In addition to that at Brookfield Central, we had another Battle of Brookfield. Battle of Brookfield is often associated when Brookfield East plays

201Brookfield Central, but this Battle of Brookfield was our robotics program, and some of you had a chance to show up on a Saturday. I got there on a Sunday. So Saturday was the high-performing teams, and Sunday was the rookie teams that are just getting started, and the energy in the building was amazing. So congratulations to everybody involved and all of the parents that make that amazing event happen. We did have a musical recently involving the Sound of Music, and we have two other musicals on the docket yet. So we do about six musicals a year. These two coming up. Tonawanda is this week, and Brookfield Elementary School is on February 28th through March 1st. You can get tickets at the Sherrilyn Wilson webpage. These are amazing opportunities to see our kids in the performance realm.

202Fine arts is certainly vibrant in this community. The academic success of our students continues. We move six students on to the regional spelling bee. This is a picture of the spelling bee competition at Wisconsin Hills. Many of you have heard us talk about the Elmbrook Promise. That's a promise that if you join us as a freshman in high school, we'll get you access to 25 to 30 college credits before you graduate. This is Maya Oaks. Maya Oaks is in her, what will be her second year of college because she earned 27 college credits while in Elmbrook, and she's on track to graduate a semester early, earning a degree in supply chain. So congratulations to Maya. Some of you had a chance to go to Madison and celebrate with Liz Nelson Liz is the associate principal

203at Pilgrim Park Middle School and she was recognized as the 2025 also associate principal of the year. Thank you to everybody involved in celebrating her You can see her presenting on the left. She got a standing ovation the picture in the middle is the State superintendent and also staff and then the picture on the right is the Elmbrook team that had a chance to travel to support Liz and celebrate her. Jean, thank you for representing the board at that event. Another thank you to the Elmbrook Education Foundation. You know that they partnered with the district staff to combine the Thank You Thursday and Engage in Excellence nomination process. Over 2,100 nominations were received as of Sunday's deadline. So now our job is to cull through all of those and find out the nominees that will

204move forward as semifinalists and then ultimately finalists. So thank you to the foundation for their amazing partnership, and thank you to our community for stepping up and offering gratitude at such a deep, deep level. If you're looking at your calendars for something to do on March 13th, this is the amazing Empty Bowls event at Dixon Elementary School. If you've not experienced it, I would highly recommend it. It's an art show gone wild. And it's amazing fundraiser for the Milwaukee rescue mission really good work Amy Jacobson is a master at pulling this off. It's really great community event So if you're available from 530 to 730 or some part of that on March 13th The gallery night and empty bowls night will be at Dixon Elementary School The art in the back of the room comes

205to us from Wisconsin Hills Thank you to mr. Knuth's art students for their contributions to the beautification of our boardroom And finally, the update on open public records requests. We've had 14 to date. Ten of those requests have been generated by one person, and to date our legal costs since January are about $1,000, with the month of January being about $500. With that, I'd open it up to any questions that folks may have. That concludes my report. Thank you, Mark. Can I get a motion to adjourn? Second. I think we have a motion and a second. All those in favor of adjourning, please say aye. Aye. Aye. Thank you. We are adjourned.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.