001Good. All right, I call this meeting to order. Please stand for the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Roll call. Mr. Exhibitor. Absent. I talked to him a couple of hours ago and he said he was coming. Uh-oh. Mr. Yutzi. Present. Dr. Feig. Here. Mr. Freund. Here. Mrs. Geyer. Here. Mr. Grabiak. Here. Mrs. O'Rear. Here. Mr. Olson. Here. And Mr. Shipley. Here. All right, next section is reorganization. Nominations for temporary chairperson. I nominate. The board has asked to accept nominations for a temporary chairperson for the purpose of reorganization. Now? May I? Yes. Okay. I nominate Dwayne Friend. Thank you. Second. I nominate Scott Olson. Any other nominations? Okay. The
002board has asked to close nominations for a temporary chairperson. All those in favor? Aye. Second. Sorry, go ahead. I need a motion. Second on the motion to close nominations. Okay. So the board has asked to close nominations for a temporary chairperson. I need a first and a second. I'll make that motion. Second. Good. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Read the name. Yeah, well, excuse me. Go through the roll call and you can vote for whoever you'd like as temporary chairperson. Okay. And it's a majority of those voting. So with eight people, assuming everyone votes, and this goes for all of your offices, you'll need five, or if less than eight vote, you'd need four. Okay. So roll call. Motion first. First or second? All that was there was to close it. Yeah. So essentially,
003what we'll do next is go through the roll call list and have each person vote for. Okay. And then we'll have a vote for the candidate that they want to vote for. Okay. Laura, who are the two candidates? We have Dwayne Frund and Scott Olson. How can the existing president be a temporary chairman? It's just for legal purposes. You can do that. You can? Yeah. Yep. We never have. Okay. Here we have. Ready? Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Frund. Dr. Feig? Olson. Mr. Graviak? Mr. Frund. Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Yutzi? Mrs. Geyer? Frund. Mrs. O'Rear? Frund. Mr. Olson? Scott Olson. Mr. Shipley? Frund. Six Frund, two Olson. All right. So, next section says the board is asked to appoint. Is
004that what we just did? Yes. Okay. Perfect. Number three. Nominations for president. I nominate Dwayne Frund. Hold on. Let me read this. Temporary chairperson calls for nominations for the office of president for a one-year term. I nominate Scott Olson. I nominate Dwayne Frund again. I need a motion to close nominations for office of president. Motion. Second. All those in favor? Aye. I need a roll call to vote for president. Okay. We have Mr. Frund or Mr. Olson again. Dr. Feink? Olson. Mr. Graviak? Frund. Mr. Olson? Mr. Olson? Mr. Olson? Mr. Frund? Frund. Mrs. Geyer? Frund. Mr. Olson? Or Mrs. O'Rear? Frund. Mr. Olson? Scott Olson. Mr. Shipley? And Mr. Shipley is absent. Again, it is six to two. Oh, sorry. Mr. Yutzi? Mr. Frund. I mean, Dr. Feink, if you want to provide discussion, go
005ahead. Okay. I wanted to provide discussion before this was . Well, if you want to provide discussion. It was never called for. It was never called for. If you wanted to provide discussion, you could have asked for the opportunity to provide discussion. It was never called for. In my experience, having this is my third reorganization, there's not typically discussion on the candidates. But if you wanted to provide discussion, it was certainly your opportunity to say so. And I'm providing you that opportunity now. This is my fourth term as a school director. And I've been horrified as what I have seen at the hands of Southmoreland School District Board presidents for the last three to four years. I've watched our students have failing achievement scores. There were seven straight years of tax increases. And a number
006of scandalous issues have plagued our district. Tonight, this board had the chance and the opportunity to turn all of this around and bring this board back to an honest, ethical, and education-oriented body. I wanted to believe that there were, at least five honorable people on this board who would vote for a positive, productive change. I guess the public can look at each vote. And they can make their judgment as to what this holds for the Southmoreland School District in the future. I think this is a disgrace. Thank you. You're welcome to leave. The board has asked for nominations for the Office of Vice President for a one-year term. Well, a motion to add. Okay. Thank you. Open nominations. Okay. Let's do a motion to open nominations for Office of Vice President for a one-year term.
007Need a motion. I'll make a motion. Thank you. Need a second. Second. Yes. All right. All those in favor of open nominations? Aye. Aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay. Nominations? I'd like to nominate Stephanie Geyer. Second. Any other? The board has asked to close nominations for Office of Vice President. Motion. Second. Second. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? No. We don't have to do a roll call. No. Right. Gotcha. All right. So at this point in time, the motion would be to approve the nomination of Stephanie Geyer as Vice President. That's just a voice vote. That can be a voice vote. Okay. So any discussion on that motion? All right. No discussion. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye.
008Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Deals with PSBA, new legislation, the things that PSBA puts out to local school boards to, you know, keep them informed of what is new, you know. PSBA is a private organization. It is a private organization. And I do not understand why we in any way, shape, or form appoint a liaison to a private organization. Because it's a group that was created to provide resources, insight, and an opportunity for advocacy for public school boards in Pennsylvania. And each school district is
009permitted to have one of its members in particular be a close contact with the association overall. Why are we obligated to do this? You're not obligated to do it. You're permitted to do it. Can I ask a question? Who was the liaison last year? I think it was Mr. Frun, I believe. Who? I think it was Mr. Frun, wasn't it? No, I was liaison before I was president. Who was last year? I think it was Mr. Graviak. I don't think there was one. Was there? I think it was Mr. Graviak. Did he go to any of the meetings? Richard, can you tell us what you did as liaison last year? I don't think I went to any of the meetings. No, the IU stopped having meetings. No, the IU stopped. Not IU. No. PSBA. This
010is PSBA. No, but I understand. Our PSBA liaison would go to the IU for their PSBA meetings. The IU stopped having this. So if we didn't need it last year, why do we need it this year? I was a liaison in the past, and I went out there nearly once every month to try to help things with the school districts, with the PISRs. I went to 44 school districts in the area, trying to brief them on what they need to know. I was active in it. Apparently nobody else cares. So we might as well not even have the position anymore. Okay, so you're saying you'd like nominated? No, I don't want nominated. To do it right, you have to participate. If you're not going to do that, there's no sense of having one. This position
011should be eliminated. Okay, thank you. Nominations for PSBA liaison. I need a motion. Dr. Pfeiffer, are you making a motion for that? I need a motion and a second to open nominations for PSBA liaison, please. I'll make the motion. Thank you. Second? So moved. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Opposed? Who did they nominate? Nobody. We're just opening it. Who? The nominations are open. The nominations are open. Yeah, so no one's nominated yet. I nominate John Newtsey. Second. Can I nominate Sam Esipiter? Because it sounds like he knows what to do. It was a lot involved. I went out once every month and stayed Friday, sometimes Saturday nights. They provided lodging. Oh, wow. And I went to most of
012the 44 schools. I don't know what you're talking about. I don't know what you're talking about. There's a lot of schools in our area. I don't know if they're still there. I mean, I think a lot of the school districts in our area because the P'sers, that's right when the P'sers collide. I don't know what you're talking about is what we're talking about here. I don't think it's the same thing. It's the same thing. I don't represent our school district at the PSBA in Harrisburg. When Sam couldn't go, I went to seven of the districts locally when he couldn't go. Would you also nominate? Sounds like they have a good... It was a waste. Thank you, anyhow. Thanks, anyhow. I'm declining my nomination. So you're deciding to nominate the other two this week. It was
013a waste. Thank you, anyhow. Thanks, anyhow. You're declining my nomination. You are declining that nomination? Yes, because I couldn't do it to the extent it needs. I got you. All right, the board is asked to close nominations for PSBA liaison. I need a motion. I'll make a motion. Second. Thank you. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. So now the motion would be to approve Mr. Yutze as PSBA liaison. All right, I need a motion to approve Mr. Yutze as the PSBA liaison. So moved. Second. All those in favor? Discussion. Discussion. Does Mr. Yutze want, you know, you're okay with that nomination? Okay. Okay. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Good. Good. I need a motion to open nomination. Nominations for the Southmoreland Education Foundation representative. I make a motion. Permit for one year. I need
014a motion. Second. Good. Thank you. All those in favor to open? Aye. Nominations. Before there's a nomination, I have a question. Has this board ever received a report from this foundation? Isn't this the foundation? It's been in existence for two years. Have you ever received a report to the board? To the board? Can you tell me what it was, Nicole? I do believe that it's... When Christy was on the board, Christy Smith, that she opened up right, I think, at the end of her term. Are you on the foundation now? No. I will... I remember when this foundation was started. This board has never received a report. Sure. I will note, just because I'm not sure to what degree this may impact that, Dr. Feig, but as a 501c3 entity, they do have to have
015independence from this board of directors, and so that limits the degree to which... This board is allowed to have any control. It may be seen as a measure of oversight if someone from the foundation reports to this board. So, if you're looking for just a status report, that might be... Or a balance sheet, that might be fine. I think, though, that if I was the foundation's lawyer, I would want to make sure that they weren't essentially giving this board oversight over the foundation. Mr. Luke, is she aware that they were obligated not to... I think, though, that they were obligated not to give athletic money, and there have been issues where people have tried to get money from the foundation, and there was a disagreement on the purpose and so forth. And I think if
016we're going to send a representative to the board in an official action like this, the board should be officially told what's going on. Thank you. Any nominations? I'll nominate Dr. Feig. I wouldn't go near it. I'll nominate John Yudze. Poor guy. What would I do? He just seems really eager to serve. I'll take it. All right. Any other nominations? All right, I need a motion to close nominations. Motion. So moved. Second. Foundation representative. Thank you. All those in favor of closing nominations? Aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay. I need... Motion to appoint Mr. Yudze as a Southmoreland Education Foundation representative. So moved. For a one-year term. Thank you. So moved. I need a second. Second. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Opposed? Board meeting calendar. The board is asked to approve and authorize the secretary to advertise
017the following board meeting dates for 2025 as per the Sunshine Law. All meetings will begin at 6.30 p.m. in the Southmoreland Middle School, 200 Scotty Way, Scotto PA 15683, unless otherwise posted. Public notice will be posted and advertised to the public not less than three days before the first meeting in January. I need a motion. Motion. So moved. Second. Discussion? So, question. If I remember this past year, didn't we have two meetings in June? We did have two meetings in June and we were questioned in June why we were having two meetings. So we tried to streamline that a little bit. There's always an opportunity to add meetings. Yeah. With that meeting in June, that's for the regular and budget voting meeting. Most likely would be a longer meeting. Yeah. We'll be here till midnight.
018Yeah. Could we start earlier, possibly, on that meeting? Is that something that we would need to amend now, or we can amend later if we decide we want to do that? Yeah, so the secretary doesn't have to advertise right away. They just have to be advertised prior to the meetings being held. So typically, I think the advertisement would include all the meetings, but there's a little bit of time to fine-tune that. Okay. So if the board's will is to move up the time that you start the June 24th meeting, you could certainly do that. I'm just asking because, like, at the top of it, it does state about the 530 executive, 630 discussion voting. So I just want to make sure that's not, like, necessarily set in stone if we need to. I can't be
019here any earlier than 530. Okay. We'll cross that bridge. Okay. All right, I need a motion. I move. Second. I think you have the motion. Yeah, we had it. Okay. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Good. Signature authorization. The board is asked to authorize the change of any or all signatures of all appropriate accounts to coincide with the officers elected at this December 4th, 2024 reorganization meeting. And that notification be forwarded to the Secretary of State for the use of facsimile signatures in accordance with the provisions of the Uniform Facsimile Signatures and Public Officials Act. As amended. Second. Discussion? What signatures, what signatures are going to be authorized? Nothing actually changes. These are, this motion is just in place if the President and Vice President had changed, but they actually remain the same. There's no
020point in voting on it because there is no change. I think it still needs to be voted on. Yeah, that's fine. Part of the process. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? We need the executive session? Aye. Yes. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. There is a need for executive session, so I need a motion to now move to executive session. Motion. Second. Thank you. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Thanks. And we'll ask if everybody could clear. So we were just in executive session for personnel, student, and collective bargaining. We'll return to our regular session. Okay. Our... one second our next section is reports citizens call I'm
021sorry our next section is citizens comments I don't have any citizens comments all right our next section is reports superintendents information okay so in lieu of my superintendent supportive I've one thing that I have I've included our updated list of current grants that we have applied for received and been denied for just for the board's information and then I'd like to give my time up today to our two companies that have come in to to speak to us about our guaranteed energy savings project we have the McClure company we have constellation so what's going to happen here is I will go ahead and pull up their presentations up here on the screen and for the public they can come up to the podium speak roughly 20 minutes or so each and then the board can
022ask away and a four favor project commissioners please read through this report again Any questions? The board has received a copy of these presentations prior to this meeting, so they can review it. And we'll go from there. Okay. Just so all things being equal and fair, our first company is McClure. So if McClure would like to come up and present, I'd appreciate that. I'll pull up your presentation. Consolation, if you wouldn't mind stepping outside while they present, we'd appreciate that. Thank you. No, you're good. You're good. And we're going off that presentation you sent the other day, correct? Correct, yes. So who's doing – are you doing most of the speaking? Yeah. So if you kind of just give me like a little head nod, I'll just go ahead and I'll progress. Thank you. Okay.
023Okay, good evening, everybody. My name is Eric Petrazio. I'm an account executive with the McClure Company. We're an energy service company located here in Pennsylvania, actually based in Pennsylvania. With me tonight is Mike Scales, our project manager for your particular project, Nick Minotti. Nick is the project development engineer. And then Dave McNally. Dave's our local vice president who works out here on this side of the state. And helps all of our operations and all of our projects come to fruition. We appreciate the opportunity to present to you this evening. There's a tremendous amount of information that we've gathered. I don't think 20 minutes is nearly enough to scratch the surface, so I do want to make good use of your time. I want to make sure that we're hitting all the points that are important
024to you. So on the presentation you have there, you can just kind of flip through. And obviously we have introductors who the people that worked on the project. But the next page really talks a little bit about us. So we've been established – we were established in 1928. We've been established in 1953. We've actually done close to $2 billion of ESCO in the state of Pennsylvania. We've done over 230 projects in the state of Pennsylvania alone. In the last 10 years we've done about $1 billion of ESCO work across Pennsylvania. That's a tremendous amount of work in our school districts. You would be hard-pressed to find a county in the state of Pennsylvania that we haven't worked in. We're very proud of that. Obviously it takes a lot of hard work to get these projects
025across the finish line for our schools. The project team that we put together for you. Is a project team that has done about $200 million of work in western Pennsylvania in the last 5 to 7 years. We're very proud of that. That requires a tremendous amount of discipline to make sure we're providing our clients with an excellent project. A good report. Making sure that everything is done properly. So we're excited to continue to provide this team to your district for the opportunity that you have here in front of you. You can go to the next one. This is – okay. This is very important here. When we originally sat down with the administrative team, we looked at all of the different things that we were asked to pull together. And there was a lengthy list
026of information that we were asked to look at. What we did for the district is we phased this into three different phases. But what I want to share with you is that you can choose to implement anything on this list at any time you desire to do so. We were just looking for some structure to provide you. And this is the way that we developed it and lined it up. So you can see on there. Most of the projects, one through – I'm having a hard time. One through ten is really focused on the high school with a couple of little ECMs in there that have subletters to them. I believe lighting is broken out for the middle school. And then building envelope is also broken out for the middle school in one through ten
027– or excuse me, in one through – Six. Correct. Yes. So the reason we broke them out that way is to allow you to decide ultimately what you implement. But do give some structure to this presentation. Before we begin, do you have any questions about the energy conservation measures we've developed for you? Thank you, Nick. Okay. I have a question. Yes. Are energy savings guaranteed? Energy savings are guaranteed, yes. Under the state law, Act 163, we're required to guarantee them. I have a question. As far as the hardware goes, particularly the lighting, what is the warranties on that lighting? Typically lighting is a five-year warranty for bulbs. When we do a project, typically we provide a warranty for workmanship and craftsmanship as well. That's typically a year or two years when we go to contract.
028But ultimately the bulbs are either warrantied for a period of five or ten years. It depends on the manufacturer who we have. Nick, for this project. So – and I don't want to spend too much time on everything here because, like I said, there is a substantial amount of information. But I did want to talk a little bit about the energy that we had found here at the district as far as your expenditures, how much energy you're using and the opportunity to save some of that energy to help offset some of the costs of this project. And when we look at it, you're using almost 3 million kW a year in electric. And then in natural gas, you're using a substantial amount there as well, over 100,000 ccf a year. That's a lot of electricity
029and gas. It's not tremendously different than a lot of your peers who haven't gone through these projects and upgrades. But it's a lot of electricity and gas. And then you have the integrated HVAC, building envelope, lighting, controls, electrical components. So I guess commensurate with your peers, you're very similar. But what we see within those numbers is a real opportunity to help drive savings down and really provide some dollars back that help offset this project. As we go through on the next page, you can actually see the subcontractors and the vendors that we've selected for your project. I would say every one of these individuals within this group here we've used on the project. We've used on multiple projects with great success and we've had excellent experiences with each of them as our clients have as
030well. I would say that the district has probably talked to some of these subcontractors as well in the past. So we look to duplicate these projects at every school we go with. We have an excellent process that we go through and we look to continue to use these relationships that we've developed over time to provide value to our districts. Really drive down costs and make sure at the end of the project it's above expectations. So that's the first thing. Next page is the HVAC. When we look at the high school HVAC, essentially what we're recommending is a replacement of all of the units within the building, the project, and then anything that is a terminal piece of equipment that wouldn't be replaced will be recommissioned and get new controls on that piece. So you can
031see on the next page we actually call out all the scopes. Excuse me, one more. I'm sorry, Dr. Boone. Right here you can see all the different scopes that we call out. I do want to note that there is some work that we're doing. We're making some significant differences to what you have versus what we're recommending. And I believe this solution provides a better opportunity for the district. What's the warranty on HVAC units? So HVAC units warranty carries from the manufacturer depending on what it is. But right now they're changing Freons, different Freons in different units and stuff. Are we going to get a system that's going to be obsolete in two years? Three years? Well, they're doing, they're, I guess they're going to do away with the drugs. What are they going to go
032to next? What I'm worried about is we get it and in three years we need them serviced. Well, you can't get the Freon because it's so expensive. We should have something to cover those units for at least five years because the Freon is going to, you don't know what's going to happen here with the EPA. It could change in a couple of years because Freon changes year to year now. Right now that dry Freon is expensive. It's like $90 an ounce. I don't know. It's like $100 an ounce. So they just required us, as Dave mentioned, to go with a new Freon coming up this year. So all the equipment that we're buying from now on in perpetuity is going to be the new Freon. We can't obviously control what the government requires us to
033do as far as regulation for Freon. We can only really play within those rules. What I'm worried about is if we get it and in three years those units are obsolete. We got to have some kind of guarantee that. I would say that I would not think that they would mass produce equipment and then make it obsolete in three years. I would say that we would have to buy a unit in the past. And that was with R22. As you may recall, R22 was outlawed through the Montreal Protocol a few years back. So it is more difficult to get R22, obviously. Understand that. But with the newer Freons they provide a little bit better. That 410 has only been what, two or three years and it's already obsolete. So it's like you buy a unit
034and Freon is obsolete in two years. What do we do? We're sitting here. We got units that we can't service. We got to buy new ones. So we need to. We have a guarantee for like five years. I would assume and I would expect that they would mass produce enough Freon to serve the units that they're making them put in. You expect, but we need to. We should have something in writing too, which we can talk about that later. So I believe you were starting to touch on it, but we're not just getting a like for like replacement. You're actually re-verifying the engineering designs to make sure we're getting what we need. Correct. Nick, go ahead and share with them a little bit about what we found when we were in the building here. So
035McClure does all their mechanical and electrical engineering in-house and I think that's a huge benefit to this project. So we don't only engineer it, but we purchase the equipment direct. Obviously, if Mike runs into an issue on the project, it's a phone call. It's a quick, easy, you know, fix if we do run into any issues with installation. But all of your indoor air handler units will become packaged units. They're easier to maintain. You get better efficiency. So things that, you know. Might have cooling. It's got a long free online running in the building somewhere to a remote condensing unit out on the roof. That will become a packaged unit all in one nice, neat bundle and it will be put outside. There's also a couple of areas through here that you can kind of
036see in area C that are just individual unit vents. We're going to combine those and it's going to be served by upsizing a unit and then we'll install VAVs to serve those areas. It's just a little bit of a challenge. It's just a more efficient way. And actually there is some cost savings by doing that. So we looked at that kind of holistically throughout the building. And two areas in particular, rooftop 10. So we're going to remove rooftop 10, which was a small single zone, and four unit vents and install five VAVs. And by doing that, we're going to upsize one unit. So you kind of eliminate five by upsizing one. And that kind of trickles throughout this project. You know, we're looking for efficiencies throughout. Also included with this, we're going to provide building
037controls building wide. So it's everything in the building will be under one control package. It is through OZ Controls, who is one of our partners. We've done tons of work with these guys all across the state from Meadville all the way out to Somerset County and up and down to 79 corridor. In addition, we've included a two year service package to provide service and maintenance. A lot of these pieces of equipment are very technical. We want to make sure that Calvin and his team is fully trained on those units. But we also want to provide ancillary services and maintenance. So that provides a benefit to the district on that end. Let's see, the next page just talks a little bit about what Nick mentioned. We can go to the next one, Dr. Boone. We were
038asked to look at replacing the windows here in the high school. We've replaced probably a million square feet of windows in the last five years. When looking at the windows, we have a lot of them. We've looked at the windows. We determined that they're really not in bad shape. They may need to be modified with new hardware. There's very few material defects and failures. So maybe new hardware and new accessories on those. And then we'd seal those windows. An alternate option on the next page would actually be to replace the windows. And we've provided costs for both. So you can see what those look like. The next page is the interior exterior doors. We'd recommend replacement of those for safety and safety. Obviously, a lot of the doors have damage to them. They're in poor
039shape. They've been abused pretty bad over the years. And that's just indicative of doors on a school building. You would not be the first school district to have schools' doors that need replaced within 30 years. Unfortunately, they take a lot of abuse. Building envelope here in both of the buildings is a huge energy saver. I don't know if you can really see the picture on the far left, but that's actually daylight coming into your building. So all around the building, if you think about it, there's cracks everywhere. We're actually going to seal all those cracks up in the building and provide a tighter building for you, which actually does a lot more than just tightens up the building. It reduces your energy bills. It reduces your run time. It improves your indoor air quality. It
040provides a better comfort for the people in the building. So there's a lot of great benefits with that. When we were here, we did notice on the next page, Dr. Boone, the electrical system is over 50 years. The useful life on that is about 40 years. We're recommending replacing those systems. To prevent any issues with them, we would replace switchboards. We would provide cleaning of all the gear that's not replaced, torquing of all that, and then a testing on it to make sure it's running and working properly for safety components. From an NFPA standpoint, are we out of compliance and out of code on what we have currently? NFPA is at 70F now, I think it is. I would say that you'd probably be grandfathered in just because of the equipment. But if you were
041to put in new equipment, you would have to bring it up to compliance. I wouldn't say you're out of compliance. I would say that you're grandfathered with what you have. But I would recommend replacing it if you're going to continue to utilize that system. The other thing that I wanted to mention on that is your current service is 4,000 amps. You technically only need 2,000. So during the replacement, we would right-size it, and there is a cost savings by not replacing it with what you have. So we looked at your equipment. We looked at your demand, and we sized it appropriately. Next is the lighting. There's a lot of text at the top. I'm sorry. There's a lot of different things in there. So like I said, we broke it out. We broke the high
042school out. We broke the auditorium out. We broke the low-voltage switching upgrades for your lights, and we recommend doing that for your lighting. Your low-voltage switching is old and causes a lot of issues with controlling those lights. They're deteriorating. They're becoming hard to find. So we'd actually recommend removing that low-voltage switch. And then we have the middle school as well. So we broke that out. You can actually see the lighting there in the building and then the switching panel. Next is the middle school. We've provided select upgrades at the middle school. A lot of the infrastructure there is still in really good shape with the exception of the five rooftop units and the one dedicated outdoor system that you have and then some of the exhaust fans. So in the elementary school, what we would
043do is we would bring the entire building on one control platform like we did in the high school. And we would actually recommission all the existing to remain equipment and also provide a two-year maintenance program on that. So you would bring both platforms from both buildings, or I guess technically three, all onto one network platform for Calvin and his team to be able to control and modulate those buildings. You can see on the page right before that, Dr. Boone, I'm sorry. You went a little back. One more. One more down. There it is. So you can see the scope in here. Which units we're replacing, what air handlers we're replacing, the control, the commissioning, and then the service plan. Next is the automatic transfer switch for the generators. We recommend that the maintenance staff has
044had a hard time with those units. So we would actually recommend changing out that automatic transfer switch so you have that unit in good shape and continues to work. On ECM 9, we then get into the building. We're going to go back to the building. We're going to go back to the building. We're going to go back to the gymnasium upgrade at the high school. We essentially would replace those bleachers, move them back, provide two new scoreboards. One would have an LED board, and then we'd also provide a new sound system for that gymnasium. Are those bleachers still going to be retractable? Yes. Yes, they will be. And there will be ADA on both sides. Let me ask you this. If we get new bleachers that are retractable, what's the deal like with food and
045stuff? I know ours are destroyed because of food, popcorn. Food, popcorn, stuff in the tracks. Are these new ones designed different, or do you recommend no food in our gyms? I would recommend no food in your gym. Exactly. That's just me, though. That's just me. That's exactly what I wanted to hear. I think it's probably hard to deter stuff from getting in tracks, unfortunately. Well, I know the ones we have now are ruined because of that. And then the next page is actually the Ruskin Stadium locker room addition, LED field lighting scoreboard, and sound system upgrades. When we came in, we were asked to develop the system. When we came in, we were asked to develop this locker room addition down there for Title IX purposes. We've actually engaged our partner, the EI Architecture, to
046develop this. So we worked in conjunction with them to price and pull this together. And you can actually see on the next page a rendering of that or a site plan of what that would look like. You can actually see the location where we would put it. This location is ADA accessible, and we provide accessibility to all the public as well for the public bathrooms that we will put there. They're from wrestling matches. They recommend. They're from wrestling matches. Next page is the LED lighting for the field. You can see an example that we put in there from NGU, which is our lighting partner here we've picked. The next page is the scoreboard. We have several different options that the district can choose from. We've included the most expensive option, but if you decide to
047go with a lesser option, that's something that we can ultimately do. And then the next page is really the pricing matrix. So when we look at the different prices that we put together for the project, phase one, which focuses mostly on the high schools, about $7.1 million. Phase two, which moves into the middle school, elementary schools, about $3.4 million. And then phase three, which is the high school boilers, and the reason we removed them is because they're still in good shape and there's still life in them. And I would recommend continuing using them until they are end of life. There's no reason to rip them out yet. So I would say that would be the last thing you may want to do. And we've incorporated the stadium and the high school gymnasium upgrades in there.
048And then on the next page, you can actually kind of see the breakout of it. So phase one, 7.14, with a savings of 1.8 and operational savings of 32,000. And we are required by the state law to list capital avoidance. This is the cost that you save by doing the project today to make the legislation whole. For a total savings of 7.4, but really when we're looking at dollars that you're spending, it's in column two and three. 20-year energy and 20-year operational. Phase two, 3.4, 1.3 savings, 27,000, 2.1 of capital avoidance. And then phase three, really it has a little bit of savings from the boiler and from the field lights. You can see 4.9 with $144,000 savings. Some capital avoidance and then the total savings. Essentially all the projects we've developed here for you
049today is about $15.5 million. With an energy savings of 3.3 million. Operational savings just a hair under 60,000. And a capital avoidance of 8.6 million for a total savings of about $12 million. So essentially this evening you were at a point of selecting a company to finalize a contract with. As I mentioned before, this is essentially a menu that you can pick and choose from. We're not saying you have to do phase one, phase two, phase three. You could say we want a little from phase one, a little from phase two, and a little from phase three. That's completely up to you. But if you're going to do your selection, that's really when we would start discussing and finalizing what that contract would look like. And what we would present as a contract that we
050would have the board then vote on if selected. I got one other question. Yes, sir. To put the AC units in that on the roof, how base, how detrimental was it to the roof? We just had new roofs. You have more steel. If you have more steel walking over the roofs. You have more steel on that roof than you would ever need. There's plenty of space to put units on that steel. No, I'm just talking about the people walking over top the roof. Oh. So, I understand that. So, we work very closely with Garland, who's your roofing manufacturer. We've actually done quite a few projects with Garland. We have excellent relationships with them. And we'll actually have one of their guys on site while we're installing roofing. So, it won't void our warranty. For the
051warranty to make sure it's intact. We've actually incorporated the cost to have Garland come in and do that in the project already. Because that's important. Yep. And because you do have so much steel up there, we're able to reuse a lot of that. Any other questions? I have a question. Yes, ma'am. I added up your numbers and I got 15,000. 15,936,991 dollars. But you said 15,500,000. We're not that far apart. So, the issue that we have with that is when you start adding bonding into the cost and bonding comes below the line and permitting, it changes the cost as you fluctuate through it. Okay. So, my number 15,936,991 is probably in the ballpark. Now, when you talk about these savings of 3,381,000. How is this spread over, is it a 20-year period of savings? It
052is a 20-year term, yes. So, you divide it equally by 20 years? I mean, I don't know how you do this. No, no. Typically, it's not equal. So, what we do is, well, actually, Nick, this is your job. You can talk about this. This is what you do. So, energy savings in our performa, we call it, are escalated. So, savings are escalated at 3%, which is the typical escalation of energy costs. Annually, you know, over the 50-year period in the United States. So, we escalate, you know, year one savings at a rate of 3% over that 20-year term to get, you know, because that's essentially what will happen. As your bills increase, your savings might increase. As rates change, there will be fluctuations. If there's a hotter or colder year, we'll take the weather into
053account. So, everything will be normalized. And then we'll deliver in year one. Okay. So, in year one and year two, what we call an MMV report, and this will show you and actually give you a full report on what your savings look like. And as long as we meet our guarantee and or exceed it, and if we do exceed it, it's your money. We don't take it or share it or split it or divide it. If you save above and beyond what we guarantee, it's all yours to save. If energy costs decrease, we don't save as much. So, if we do not meet our guarantee, we have to write you a check or come in and perform work to make sure that you guarantee it in your savings. So, we're measuring energy based on units
054and what you're paying for units today. So, we can't predict what you're going to pay in the future. So, we have to baseline this somehow. And we baseline on the units consumed versus the amount that you pay today. Mrs. Mondock has a cash flow in the proposals that we've given her. It has line by line, year over year, for each phase of the project, and it shows the year of the savings. But if energy costs decrease? Yes. Okay. If energy costs decrease, you'll make a... If energy costs decrease, then the amount of savings will be by the value of the cost going down. But you'll still save the amount of energy we guarantee. Right. Because at the end of the day, we're going to guarantee units of energy saved. And how that translates to dollars
055will be dictated by the rate you're paying, obviously. So, that phase one is the first, like, six and a half years. Phase two is the next six and a half. Phase three is the last six and a half. Is that right? I would say no. If you were able to look at the cash flow that Mrs. Mondock has, it will actually show you each one of the years for the phases of the guarantee savings. Well, you have phase one, phase two, and phase three. That was my question. And all the Xs in phase one, there's a few in phase two, and there's almost none in phase three. And I just don't have a clear picture of how that... If there's an X next to that ECM, it's included in that phase. If there's no X,
056it's not included. If there's no X, it's not included in that phase. So, perhaps the answer is each one of those is 20 years. Correct. Is that 20 years? So, if you look at line number one, ECM one, high school with HVAC, building-wide ATC, if you look at the energy savings in the fourth column over, it says 20-year energy savings is $864,508. That is the amount of energy savings that you will garner over 20 years by implementing the project. Well, I have the same numbers that you gave. A concern that I have is if I look at a $16 million project, and I know approximately what one mil is worth, it would cost us somewhere between 106 and 110 mils to pay for this. And that increase would be absorbed every year for I don't
057know how many years, and that doesn't even count anything else we have to pay for. Am I right, Mrs. Mondale? Kind of. That's a different subject. I believe looking at this, you have to look at basically we're going to have these costs anyhow with the energy that we're currently utilizing. So, what they're doing is they're making us more efficient in our energy, what we're actually using. Well, I'm looking at after you deduct the savings off of the 15 or 16 million, you're down to like 20-year savings. So, that's the cost. Okay. Thank you. I'm going to go back to the $12,600,000. And if you divide that by 20 years, I think it doesn't come up to much more than a mil and a half a year or something in terms of savings. But it could
058cost 110 mils to get a few mils. I spent a lot of time looking at this, and I don't think we have to sit here and pretend like we have $16 million and we don't care. I mean, that's not the— Oh, not at all. No. Not at all. Which is why I contacted the person that does bond funding just to see what borrowing this money would look like for the district. And then you would actually take out the proposed debt service, less any savings, and then that would be our true cost to the district. Well, the true cost comes down, according to this, to $12.5 million. If you subtract the savings from the total cost, you get what's left, and that's $12.5 million. Okay, that's our cost. And so that has to be spread out,
059and the savings are spread out. I'm concerned about how this gets paid for. And I'm sure these guys are familiar with these concerns if they work in other school districts. But right now, if I understand correctly, we don't have to say we're doing $15 million. No, we don't. Correct. We can choose who we go with, and then we can kind of pick and choose off that. Yeah, do the lights, don't do the boiler. Make a decision who we use. Correct. So you're saying we can break this down. Right now, they list 16 different options on their paper, 16 different things. And I don't know how you go about pulling out, I don't want this, I don't want this, I don't want this. I don't know. I don't know how we do that. Can I make
060a suggestion, if I could? I would choose a firm and then work with that firm as your partner to determine where your greatest areas of need are, right? First and foremost, I would look at HVACs as your largest expenditure. It's the oldest assets you have. It's the biggest thing. You know, I would start there. And that's kind of, that's what you're doing when you're selecting a firm to partner with. You're really looking for a partner that's going to sit next to you and provide you with that professional information where you can then make educated decisions from a position of power where you have the information as opposed to just being forced one way to do something or another. So that's really one step in the process. Okay, I was just under the impression that everything
061you have listed there you considered a need, no? Everything we have listed on there is what we were asked to pull together by the administrative team when we started back. I have another question. How much of our high school and our, all of our middle schools is air conditioned? What percent of our buildings are air conditioned? All of it except the gym and the high school. All of it except the gym and the high school. The whole high school? The gym, I don't think any of the gyms are. That would be lovely. We have AC in the gym here on this project. I'd be interested in getting some information to tell me how much of our buildings are actually air conditioned now as opposed to this proposed. It's in this presentation, ma'am. It's in this
062document right here. It is? Yeah. If you'd like to, I could show you where it is. Keep going back, Dr. Boone. Keep going back. You want the first one? Yeah, that's the first one. So it says right here. It says right here, heating, cooling unit, ventilator. Right in there in red. So you can see everything in red, the little red boxes. And then it says heating only, just a ventilator, air handling unit. And that's a little bit more of a peach. So you can see down here in the corner, heating only. In the gymnasium, heating only. And then one more down, it says direct expansion hot water air handling unit. And that's yellow. You can see in the yellow, that's cooling. And then you see where it says rooftop units. So we're looking at blue,
063purple, green, dark green. Single zone, chilled water, multi-zone, chilled water, cooled cold water, single zone, DX, multi-zone. So the only places in the building that aren't technically cooled are F and these areas down here off of A. Correct? That's not the way it is now, or it is the way it is now. Is that what you're saying? Yeah. That's the way it is now. Okay, thank you. That's existing conditions, yep. Yeah. And if you went to the next two pages later. You can see what our proposed solution is. Page five. We're still keeping this area heating only and I believe that's the shops, Nick? Yeah. The wood shop and it might be a pile. So we traditionally don't provide cooling in wood shops in areas like that because there's so much exhaust in the area.
064Or are you just sucking out all the cold air you're putting into it? I know you guys have another meeting. I don't want to encroach upon them. I just want to be respectful of everybody's time too. Any other questions you guys have? One last question maybe for Mr. Scales. Can you talk through the on-site project management and how that would be handled? Once a month prior to start and once. It is much like we did at the end, but there's a lot of pre-planning. So the kids are out. So Mike will have, like he said, that construction manager will be here every single day stationed on site managing the subs. Mike will work with that construction manager in conjunction to make sure the project's smooth. Okay. Thank you. Anything else from anyone else? All right.
065Well, thank you guys very much for your time. We appreciate it. We look forward to the opportunity to work with you. Do you want us to stick around? We'll wait after the next meeting's done? Or would you prefer for us to go? Whatever you'd like. That's up to you guys. Okay. Are you guys going to be selecting tonight? Yes. Okay. So we'll stick around. Thank you then. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Bye now. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. You need an air-condition, too. Yeah. I think we need to I think we need to get about the EEC for now. Get a mask anymore. I was laying way over my head. We need an air-condition, too. Good thing there's people that understand that in the world.
066I understand the majority of it anyways. They started talking about Los Angeles extract. Yes. Useливо Kind of Certified Development. Yeah, Downloaded. The same way the state passed it. Loan restorations determine products. Now the United See's I don't know how lost you are. Me. I think I think the exterior window is great and then the light is good that's it that's it that's it you can't go let's begin the HVAC we get Calvin I need to turn that AC up by the way crank it up with everything that's our mortgage 35 just open that door it's not 23 it's not perfect I know snow suit I have to overall you've got to be I'm sweating under my snow suit I bet it feels good after freezing all day no it doesn't yeah it's hot Dwayne we're
067going to have before we vote on this are we going to have time to talk about a couple things here yeah I mean there's always discussion I mean I got some opinions on some of this stuff I mean the biggest thing I'm worried about these AC units they're changing this free line like it's hard to tell what's going to happen here in the next year I mean they're talking about throwing a lot of those regulations out we go with the drive free on a 410 it might be obsolete I mean I got a unit in my shop it's going to be three years old they're free it costs more to charge it than what you used to buy in the unit alright I have to pick out a lot of work she works until 10
068Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam Sam we'll take care of it it's 250,000 dollars for a scoreboard they have a scoreboard listed somewhere the scoreboard is 242,000 it's a quarter of a million dollars five times that's a quarter of a million dollars for a scoreboard that's a four-square-foot Look at the number we came up with, 35A. As soon as you guys are ready. We're waiting on you. This is my own. Can you get the handouts now? You can. Sure. Move fast. We're trying to get a 20-minute deadline. That stretched to about 30 minutes. So you have about 30. I'm going to be fair.
069So we have a coffee for IGA. We have additional coffees in the box. We brought you three. As far as the appendices go, we brought you one coffee because there's a lot of them. Yeah. We can provide you electronics or more if you want. I have trouble sleeping. I'll take one of those. Right here is perfect. I'm telling you. If you have enough. Oh, my goodness. Oh, this is the locker. Perfect. Thanks. As you're presenting, if you just want to kind of have a head nod or go to the next slide. I'll control it from up here. You got it? For sure. OK. I'm going to skip some of this stuff because it's things that we talked about already. As you remember, I mean, we were here on June 18th. We did a presentation on
070preliminary assessment. We went through all the GISA information and all that kind of stuff. If you want us to go through that, we can. But I'm sure we don't. I'm going to introduce our team. Go ahead. At the mic. I would say just go ahead and use the mic. I'm sorry. I know. Mr. Smith-Hull was in the background. Kind of give me that. Give me that look. Thank you, Ron. Hello. I'm Ron Krahaski with Constellation Energy. We are thrilled to be here tonight. We've been working with the district for over a year now. Our first formal meeting with the administration staff was back on December 20th of last year where we introduced ourselves. I'm going to speak very quickly because, of course, we want to move on to the scope. I know we're pressed for
071time. When we were here in June on the 18th, it was myself. Sean and Tyler. We did our presentation and competed with the qualifications proposal on August the 18th. After that, we shortly got a call thereafter. I'm sorry, the 14th. We got a call thereafter inviting us to do a competitive IGA with McClure who just gave their presentation. At this point, I would like to introduce Larry Gudlecki. He is Constellation's Executive Director for Sales and Marketing. He's been a member of the board for a number of years. Thanks for having me. Also, we have a couple more engineers who have worked on the project. Alex Laffey and Steve Rogers, they're here as well. Larry, if you want to say a couple of words, and we'll get on with our presentation. Good evening. As Ron said,
072we'll try to keep this on schedule in time, but it's a pleasure to be here. I love working with school districts because you have a lot of challenges ahead of you. You're owners and operators of facilities. We appreciate it. Thank you. And deferred maintenance is something that every year you're trying to figure out how you address it, and every year it gets more. And so I hope as we go through the scope today, we can talk through the areas that are critical for you. We've seen some things that look critical and think they need attention, and there's some things that maybe you can wait a little bit to address. And so I hope today that we can talk about how we're going to address deferred maintenance for you, how we can bring value to the
073district. I'm excited by the work we've done in western Pennsylvania. I would encourage you, if you want to check references with us, please do that. Ron can give you the references. We've done a significant amount of K-12 work. We understand how to operate in school buildings, not only our staff, but the subcontractors that we bring in. I'll say to you, as the leader of the Pittsburgh office, it gets a little bit tough at times because there are times I have to tell subcontractors no. And they wonder why. I say no. And it comes down to safety. Like, we have a very stringent safety process that we apply to every subcontractor that works for us. And if they don't meet the safety requirements, I can't bring them to your job site in good conscience. So from
074a company standpoint, I just want to leave you with that before I pass it to the team. As we go through the implementation of this project, safety will be front and center. Paramount as we're working around students. As we're working around faculty. So with that, I'm going to turn it over to Tyler Kokenauer. He's our lead TSM, works directly for me. He jumped in to develop this project. So I'd like Tyler to walk through the scope with you so you understand the measures that we saw as we went through the facility. The areas where we believe deferred maintenance is an opportunity to be addressed. And Sean Trable, who was one of our lead engineers. Sean will be here to kind of support and provide some additional insight into the systems that you have. So we're
075going to go ahead and get started. Thank you. Real quick from a safety standpoint. Do you guys utilize like an ISN or a similar system or do you have an internal grading? So we use EMR ratings as a starting point. And we do have a safety officer who all that information goes into the safety officer and then he grades the contractors out. So he'll base it off their EMR, base it off their incident rate. And then that's we have a metric internally that we manage to. And if they're outside of that, unfortunately, we have to go to a different subcontractor. Okay. Thank you. You're welcome. Hello, everyone. Glad to be here. I'm going to turn your attention to slide. I believe it would be slide six. That has the utility analysis overview. I'm sure that
076you heard that in the last presentation. So I wasn't going to go over that again. I was going to go over the list of potential upgrades and where they're located. It's the table that has all the ECMs in the checkmark. Yep. So you can view this as the menu. You'll see there's all the ECMs or energy. You can see the conservation measures that we've identified through this process. And on the right, wherever there's a checkmark, that's where that scope will be implemented. And like I said, it really is a menu. You get to pick and choose the ultimate scope of this project. Now, I'm going to just jump right into the scope items that we developed. And Sean's going to help me along the way. First up is LED lighting and all the schools, Ruskrim
077Stadium and also the maintenance garage. We spent over five days auditing every single light fixture and light bulb. Throughout the district. I'd like to thank Calvin staff for allowing us to do that. And funny enough, our lighting auditor is actually a Southmoreland School District alumni. But everything in the district that is not currently LED lighting will be upgraded, both interior and exterior. Next up is the auditorium lighting upgrades at the high school. That will be a complete system upgrade from the control panel in the back that changes the light levels and the colors to the dimming rack in the back to all the lights and the house lights in that facility. It will be a complete. Brand new LED system. A lot more functionality and it lasts a lot longer. A 50,000 hour lifetime. So
078this upgrade is really built to last for the district. Next up is building envelope upgrades that's sealing the perimeter of the building, keeping the heating and the air conditioning in, keeping harmful pollutants and car emissions outside. So there are several pictures of pipes that aren't insulated, doors that have cracks in them, exposing air. Also in the roof wall intersection. It's missing insulation as identified in several of the photos and the arrows there. So like I said, weather stripping, insulating, sealing up the entire building. With those roof wall intersections, we'll be putting energy board up there, which is a fancy word for the fiberglass with the foil backing on it. And then it's sprayed with, you know, styrofoam spray. Poly spray. So it's done airtight with a good R value to it. Seals out all the
079air. Next up is building automation. So this is a building automation system upgrade, which is the brain of the building. This is primarily focused at the high school where the system is the oldest and in the greatest need of repair and upgrade. So currently it's a pneumatic and digital system. So it runs on air pressure and digital controls, which is an older system. This would be removing all the components and upgrading to a brand new digital platform. So this is all the wiring throughout the building, all the sensors, getting rid of the old pneumatic tubing throughout the building, and sensors, valves, everything for a fully functional system. There'll be a front end that'll be able to access both schools so that Calvin and his team can go in there and set schedules, adjust set points,
080and making sure students and administrators are comfortable within that space. And something that we do is we do a nonproprietary control system. What that means is you're not locked in with one vendor going forward. With this system, there are multiple different vendors out there that can work and service your system. This gives the district flexibility. Funding is free. There's a lot of different ways that you can get the best price, financially, and with different contractors to be able to get the best price and the best contractor. You're not locked into one contractor for the rest of the term of your system. I'm going to add that the basis of design we've been using, we will be using with your facility, was a Johnson control system with a Tritium front end. Correct. That's what you currently
081have employed throughout the campus, and that's what we were asked to use. And we use a very reliable contractor to do that work. We tend to lean on them all the time. But the good thing about that particular system is there are other contractors in the area that also do it. So it's not specific to a specific vendor that you're tied into and they plant their flag here and then you're stuck paying their high bills. You can shop this stuff down the road, which gives you great buying potential. John? Following from Tyler, ECM 6, which would be HVAC related items, is rooftop unit replacements. At the elementary school, middle school, and the high school. At the high school, it's currently to replace 17 constant volume, multi-zone, and one variable air volume unit. And six rooftop
082units at the high school. Five of those units are basically a direct replacement. One is a dedicated outdoor air unit. Multiple occasions on site visits that I've been up here. We were noted from. From Calvin's staff that it has made a lot of issues and just peeking around opening up doors to. There's an enthalpy wheel that's inside for energy recovery and it is seen extremely dirty that the unit was never running when we were there. It's the largest unit that the school has and it's in poor condition. So our intention is to. We did a load study on both buildings. load calculations for heating and cooling demand throughout every day of the year, every heating degree day, every cooling degree day, and was able to actually reduce outdoor air to some of these rooftop units
083to the zones that they serve. So essentially what that means is you don't have to condition as much air, which, again, saves in energy. With the units at the high school, as you can see from the photo, it probably doesn't do it as sort of just – those units are sitting roughly five, four and a half to five feet off the ground, which makes them extremely difficult to service. So currently now if they have an issue or the unit needs reset, you have to carry a ladder around. You're climbing over the existing dunnage and or structural steel that's around the units now and having to open up cabinet doors to get in them. We will be putting service platforms around the units to make them accessible, safe to service. With part of this, will you
084be training Calvin's folks on how to service the units and all that? That would be included within the scope. At the end with operation, maintenance, all of that, yes. Okay. Following would be ECM number seven, air handling unit replacements. Currently at the senior high school, there are six air handling units that serve the LGI rooms, the gymnasium. And a shop. The shop does not have cooling in it currently. The wood shop, we propose to add cooling to that, which would be replace that air handling unit in kind, leaving these units indoor, all of the units indoor due to not having to do new roof work on a – your roof was just replaced, not have to do roof work up there for these units. And also one, serviceability. It's easier to service inside. The units
085last longer. They're not exposed to the elements. And then again, to service the units outside, you can service them inside. So that would be six units. Add cooling to the wood shop and add cooling to the gymnasium. Can I add one thing? Yep. Up on the rooftop units that, you know, Sean referenced the structural steel. Again, they're high. They're hard to serve. Part of our quotation is bringing them up to code with catwalks and things around it so your technicians or your people that want to work on it can get up there in a safe way, work on it. Not have to worry about falling off a ladder and getting hurt on it. Following ECM8 glycol system upgrades. So glycol keeps the hydronic systems from freezing. Hydronic coils that are inside the units that provide
086the heat transfer, they – the glycol keeps those from freezing. Currently, Calvin and his staff has to manually add glycol to the system, which adds time to their day doing so. And also it's – this is automatic. It's currently there now. It just does not work anymore. So it's to replace these in kind to get the system operating as it should. ECM9 exhaust fan replacements. Again, at the high school, this was our most efficient building. This is replacing 45 exhaust fans. They're currently belt drive. We would be replacing them with energy efficient ECM motors that would have a potentiometer on the side. It just changes on resistance. And to – Easily adjust airflow and aid in balancing. As we know, there's current fans out there now that do not operate at all. So we would
087be replacing them. And certain fans do not have motors in them. ECM10 unit ventilator replacements. Replace 19 heating and cooling unit ventilators. One of them is DX direct expansion uses refrigerant. The rest of them use chilled water, hot water. It's replacing them in kind. Are the in kind replacements, like we've got the best equipment and that's why we're going in kind? Have you done like an engineering analysis to give us what we need? Yeah, correct. So what I'm saying in kind replacement is basically same performance data. We did, as I mentioned prior, we did a full load calc, load energy study on the building. And yes, that's what's required. In kind with performance data. And again, in dimensional and in the type of unitary equipment it is. You know, the manufacturer could – it's not
088going to probably align with what's there. But there again, we'll work with your staff to give you more than likely what you want. It goes through a formal submittal process to make sure that, you know, what we're proposing aligns with the – Next ECM is chiller replacement at the middle school. This chiller, it's a small chiller. It serves the administration area. It's just for summertime use to aid to not have to fire up the large water-cooled chiller for just a small area of the building. And lastly on the mechanical scope is retro commissioning. Retro commissioning is assuming that – assuring that your entire building is operating from point to point. So somebody is sitting on a computer hitting a button telling a damper to open. And a guy is at that damper ensuring that that
089damper opens. And that's for every mechanical piece of equipment that there is. We have an allowance included within this scope item that would correct any issues that were found during – any issues or deficiencies found during this analysis. Mr. Notes? Yeah, sure. Why not? Next up we have window upgrades and door replacements. We had worked with Calvin initially if the plan was to replace some of the windows. But analyzing the condition and doing the best fiduciary duty to the district, it was deemed that we could make repairs to those windows. And not replace them and save a substantial amount of money. So that was our approach here. We are going to re-cock the outside of the windows and in between all of the glass to make sure there's no air loss. We're also going to
090repair where needed all the hardware – latches and handles, roto operators, blind operators. So whenever we're done, those windows will be fully operational and completely sealed. In addition, there are 20 interior and 4 exterior doors that will be replaced. They have the typical wear and tear that you might see in a high school from students interacting with them. And it's also a safety and security issue. We walked the site with the facility staff and we'll point out exactly what doors needed upgrades or improvements. Also through our IG investigations, we were asked to look at putting security film on the elementary school classrooms, which we did. There are 47 doors at the elementary school that will receive security film. So that is also included in that program. Thank you. And we're going to look at the
091price that you will see. Next up, we have parking lot paving that we were instructed by the district to investigate. So that would be to repave the areas of the parking lot that haven't recently been paved. New line striping, rubber curb stops. We walked the entire parking lot with facility staff and other folks to identify the key areas that needed those improvements. And especially along the bus pool around. I'm going to give Kim a shout out for that because we walked around that parking lot for an afternoon too. So we're going to look at the parking lot. Next up is the lighting upgrades at the Russ Grimm Stadium that are on the field. There are currently four poles, two on the field house side and two on the visitor side opposite of it. Those will
092be replaced with new LED fixtures. The poles will remain. Those new lights will come with a control link, control platform and monitoring. So you can turn them on, turn them off, dimming control. Also has performance monitoring and 24-7 customer support. In addition to just lighting, there's also a control platform. So if you're using white lights, we've also added the ability to have color as an add-on. So for performances, graduation, homecoming, there'll be the ability to have that extra feature as well. This comes with a 10-year warranty for labor and materials. So for the next 10 years, you don't have to worry about a thing with those lights. Next up is the Russ Grimm Stadium scoreboard and sound system replacement. We actually brought a sample of the sound system and the scoreboard that we plan on
093replacing out to the district and had administrators and the facility staff see it, hear it to ensure it was loud enough, to ensure it was bright enough. So there's an actual rendering there of the scoreboard. It's a full LED scoreboard. There's no digits or fixed marketing. So there's also a truss at the top and it'll have an integrated single source sound system. There'll also be a brand new control panel up in the field house to operate that system. It comes pre-programmed with the ability to show videos, integrate in a camera, and then have it set up to focus on games. A lot of different features. It will fit on the existing structural steel that you have now. We had an engineer look at that and analyze it. So old scoreboard comes off, new scoreboard goes
094on. And the one that we've included is 7 feet by 24 feet. Tyler, was that the same size as the sign we brought up and had demonstrated? It was a little bit smaller because it was a demonstration and had to fit on an 18-wheeler. But this will be larger than the one that you had seen. Next up is the gymnasium sound system upgrade. We were told it wasn't loud enough in there. So our solution is again a single source sound system that'll be mounted on the wall, a new amplifier that'll go back in the storage room behind it as well. So completely functional system. We are going to leave the speakers in the ceiling because they are connected to the PA system. So if the PA system still needs to inform students or staff of
095anything going on within the gym, they still have that ability. Now we have the restroom stadium locker room. We spent a significant amount of time interacting with the district. And working on our end, we actually hired an architecture and engineering firm, Bucard Horn. There are some renderings there and I did pass out a set of drawings that outline that. I'm actually going to turn it over to the architect who can discuss that in detail. Thank you, Tyler. My name is Chris Urban. I'm an architect with Bucard Horn Architects located in the Pittsburgh office. Constellation asked us to help them out with the conceptual design for the Russ Grimm Stadium locker room. Could you put your microphone, please, if you would? Is that better? Okay. So we had the opportunity to walk the site and the
096existing facility to analyze both with the goal to provide a new locker room for female athletes as well as additional storage capacity for the buildings and grounds. We developed a number of conceptual schemes with the primary objectives to be accessible, secure, and cost effective, ultimately resulting in the proposal you see here before you. And I apologize, we have the boards there that they don't show the same images. We were going to do this differently, but we're kind of pressed for time, so. But they want to show both of them still. The proposal you see here is a standalone single-story masonry building for the new locker facility. And then the storage facility would be its own standalone pre-manufactured metal building. We're proposing to place that on the existing, the location of the existing storage shed that's
097up on the upper portion of the site by the parking lot. We believe that this is the most cost effective solution. More effective than building a two-story facility out of masonry because you'd have the added cost of a heavier structural system, additional masonry. Really for a storage building, the pre-manufactured metal building is the most economical and fastest way to go. For the locker room facility itself, we sized it for about 25 lockers on the perimeter of the room with an open area in the middle for benches or just an open area. They have a dedicated shower room and toilet room as well. And then there's also an independent family, there's two independent family public restrooms. Those will be located in close proximity to the stands and the bleachers. For use during events. There's also a
098separate coaches and trainers room that are accessible from the outside. And this way you won't have to worry about going through the locker room to get to those rooms. And instead of enclosing them, we're not enclosing them as a cost effective measure. That way you don't have the additional masonry to enclose a corridor that you then have to condition as well. The pre-manufactured building, as I mentioned, would be a more economical option. But it's also in a location that's better suited towards that function. Keeping any vehicles that might be bringing supplies or picking up supplies away from the public area of the concourse and the bleachers. And with that, I'll turn it back over to Tyler. I have a question. So part of this would be part of the public's use as well? If you
099chose it to be, we were kind of directed to provide that. But again, this is a... Part of a process. This is not a final design. Again, we would hope that we're going to engage refiners to take this to exactly what you're once in need of. So again, it's up for debate. One thing we do like about where we position that locker room, down below the fence. But that up against the parking lot where people are roaming around. There's a game going on. Big play. Everybody's looking at the field. And you got a couple people standing in the parking lot. Because that's where the locker room is. Didn't think that was a good fit. Everybody's down below the fence. It's pure. I should mention too that the way we sited it, we positioned it where
100there's the current, what was the original, I believe, session stand. That location of the site is relatively flat. It's up against that hillside. But the location where the building would actually be is more or less flat. Meaning that you'd have less regrading to do. And then in addition, the way we sited all of the doorways. They'd be visible from all of the more public areas. So that you can always have somebody keeping an eye on those locations. Thank you, Chris. So I know we're pressed for time. And we want to be conscious of our time limit. So I was just going to make a couple last comments about the project. There was a question about training. We provide training on every single ECM. Whether it's a light bulb, a control system, or mechanical items. For
101more complicated items, we like to do two trainings. One after it's installed. And then teach the staff how to operate it. And then once they've had some time to acclimate to those systems. And they get some more questions after they use them. We come back and do an additional training. And with regards to ATC. Controls for the building. The new control platform. We provide a ton of training. And we're happy to. Because the smarter your folks are at operating their building. The less nuisance calls we're going to get. The less complaints you're going to get throughout the facility. So from a financial standpoint, it makes sense for us. And this is a fully-ended. Engineered solution. Like Sean mentioned. We have building locals. We had a third-party engineer actually have drawings. And make equipment selections. So
102this is fully engineered and ready to go to contract. And we have a firm belief that we have the best solution for the district. And lastly, I know we mentioned that we were up there. We were required to provide a bid bond. We have a bid bond. And also a letter from our surety company. Stating that we have the ability to bond up to a $150 million project. And have over a total of $2 billion in total bonds. In the capacity as a company. As you can see on the economic slide on page 28. Each ECM is there. And the associated costs that roll up to the $10.7 million figure you see there. Like I mentioned earlier. This is a menu. This is your project. You get to pick what you ultimately want included in
103this. And we hope to be selected to go on that journey with you. On that question. What I'm sure you have a minimum of what you want to do to actually take this project. On. Is there a dollar amount or number of projects that you would be the minimum projects we would do? As far as a dollar amount? Well, we have 17 ECMs. Correct. How many ECMs would we have to commit to to make it worth your while to take this project on? We'll do any size project that you ask us to do. Small, large, anything in between. It's your project. We're happy to support any way possible. I have two more questions. They're both electrical. Sure. We talked about transfer switches and switch gear. What did you think about our switch gear and transfer
104switch? Did they need any addressing? I don't remember being informed that you were having any issues. We're not having issues. That's what I'm asking. I didn't know if you had looked at those to... We had looked at all the infrastructure. We were given a very specific list from the administration to go after and investigate, which is what we had provided. Okay. Those upgrades, if that system is still working the way it should and there's no issues, it can keep operating for us. We're not going to have to spend a substantial amount of time. And that upgrade does come at a significant cost without any energy savings. So we tend to focus on the critical needs that affect the students and staff and also generate the most amount of energy savings. And we'd be more than
105happy to evaluate anything you want to... No, I'm not sure what they found. I'm just inquiring. If we look at switch gear and we walk through the building, it's not like a few years back where we could walk around with building personnel and open up panels and look inside to see what their condition is. There's arc flash rules, very stringent requirements to be able to... You're right. Yes. We'd have to have an electrician on board. He'd have to be suited up. Suit up, yes. Okay. That's a whole different story. So next on page 30 is the most important part about that. That's the energy savings. So as you can see for each of the ECMs that we had proposed there, you can see the units of energy savings, the operation and maintenance, which is parts
106and repairs that the district will no longer have to pay for, a total of the energy and O&M savings, capital avoidance by doing these upgrades, and then a total as well. And speaking with the energy savings, we just didn't put our finger in the air or do an Excel spreadsheet. We did a building model on both buildings that looks at how the buildings are built, the materials, all the HVAC systems. So those buildings are modeled and then each upgrade is simulated in there to have a high degree of confidence in those energy savings. Did you do that internally or with a third party? We had a third party engineering firm do that just so that you knew that there was a degree of accuracy. In those IGAs, there's actually a letter in the first sleeve
107of it that's from the engineer that actually did those with their professional engineering stamp on it attributing to the accuracy of those. Oh, in the bond. In the bond? Yeah, in the binder. Oh, okay. In the binder. Real quick. Okay. Talk through your project management. And once construction begins, Constellation, and Constellation's involvement and such. Well, I would like to talk about it, but he was a project manager at our company for about eight years, so he could speak to it. So I was distracted for a second. What was the question? Just talk me through your project management process. Hey, can you talk into the microphone, please? It goes out to the public. I'm sorry. Yeah, project management. I've done it pretty much my whole career. I transitioned into a sales role a few years ago,
108so I was actually a supervisor in our project management side of Constellation. So very thorough. We have a very, very competent group of project managers. Actually, the vice president of construction and engineering is in our office in Warrendale. He would have been here tonight, but he was chewing a piece of bubble gum from a trade show that was kind of stale that we were giving away, and it popped a tooth, so he's not here. That's the best story ever. Fantastic story. I got a piece. Like, you can't make that up. Bazooka Joe. That's pretty nice. Yeah. Yeah. So our project managers are very well trained. You know, they're going to put your project through the process. They're going to make sure they submit on all the equipment. They're going to vet out everybody from a
109security standpoint. They're going to work with your key people to do that, whoever's appointed. Make sure everybody, you know, can work here and passes those clearances and keep records on that. They're going to schedule everything. They're going to coordinate with your staff. As far as the logistical concerns are concerned, to make sure that things are done safely, efficiently, and nobody's put at risk. You know, Larry talked about, you know, our safety a little bit earlier, and it's paramount. 4.2 incident rating requirement and a 1 EMR rating, which, you know, it can be tough. We have to turn a lot of contractors away. Our guys train a lot. They know what they're doing. You know, they're going to coordinate with whomever is appointed. To oversee this on your side of the table, which I'm assuming would
110be Calvin and his staff. We're here to make it easy on you and make sure the project is, you know, built properly and safely at the same time. Somebody's going to be on staff here whenever we have subs here working to make sure that happens. You're going to have weekly or biweekly, depending on what's agreed upon, project meetings to make sure everything is well rehearsed, well coordinated, bought into by the staff. And everything with the school, as far as, you know, your day-to-day operations. We work in occupied schools. We work during the shoulder seasons. We work in the summers. We work at night. We're very familiar with working in a K-12 atmosphere. So you're in good hands with Constellation with that. Thank you. Thank you. During construction, is somebody on site at all time? Yes.
111I have a question. Yes. Correct me if I'm wrong. I have the total cost of your proposal. The total cost of your proposal here is roughly $14 million with $374,000 in savings. Is that correct? I just need to know if that's correct. Yes. I want to add something, though, to page 29, Dr. Boone, if you can take us there. So with regards to the total cost of the project, on the page before this, we identified the 10.4 number. On page 29, we have project economics for additional scope. Next page, Dr. Boone, please. Additional scope. Oh, are we missing it? Hold on. I'm getting there. 29 on that. There it is. You had it. There you go. So with regards to some of the things that are on this page, Title IX building, gymnasium painting, gymnasium
112bleachers, and district signage, there was a whole lot of things with regards to these particular matters that we couldn't really get a really firm grasp of exactly what the school would want. Right. Right. Right. I mean, signs, it's all over the place. I mean, you could just do safety and security things. You could do signs just to, you know, tell you where to go, nice little, you know, cozy signs that tells you go this direction. There's just the sky's the limit. So what we did is we, on all these ECMs, we used, you know, the best knowledge that we had to put forward a budget. We think this is what this is going to cost, but what we would like to do is approach this from a second phase perspective. Get engaged. Do a first
113phase. And while we're doing a second, doing that phase, we'll put this, we'll come up to a final design with the Title IX building. And there's going to be a lot of changes. Believe me, when people start getting, you know, you're getting two cents from, you know, the AD and the superintendent and the parents and the people that use it, it's going to change. So rather than just throw a whopper of a number on this and, you know, hey, we got it covered. We'll do whatever you want. We can change. We didn't want to do that. So as we go through this process and we refine what needs to be refined and we come up with a final, the final expectations on that, we'll put it back out on the street. We'll get firm numbers.
114We'll expose them to you and we'll work together to take it to market to get you the best pricing. So these are just kind of like best guests. I mean, if you told us right now, yeah, we'll take the price, we would probably agree to it and say, yeah, we'll do it. But we think we can save you money in these areas. So we just don't want to shove them into the first table preview. We want to get you to be more obvious to this and say, okay, this is the number we want and this is what we're going to do. It wouldn't be right. Any other questions? Are you, I don't recall if I've seen it or not with looking at both proposals, but as far as down at the field house, like, are
115you able to bring, like, we're like up to code with all of our, like our ADAs and stuff. All that can come up to code. Well, everything that we're going to do and touch and build. We're going to be ADA compliant. That's a given. Yes, absolutely. Everything will be done by professional architect at firm that's, you know, who will do that for us and, you know, it'll be done properly. Are you existing structures that are already there? Well, just, yeah, basically. I mean, again, we can do more than what we're suggesting here. Once we get this is just a rough kind of draft of it. Yeah, we think this is what we're going to come in at, but, you know, we want to go to work and, you know, try to do our best. We
116want to get the best out of what you want and put it back to the open market and bring you back to best prices. The scope that we were working with for that, what you see here is the Title IX building was mostly what this is, which is a standalone building. We didn't include too much work in the existing facility. We're pulling some utilities out of the existing facility, but we weren't at this phase looking at upgrades for ADA and everything with that facility. There are some complications with that one, and that was honestly one of the reasons we are looking at a standalone rather than adding on to that building. The nature of it, it's a masonry building. There's no insulation. It was more difficult to add on a new code-compliant facility than to
117build a standalone. Yeah. Understood. Thank you. Any more questions? I think we're good. Thank you. Thank you, guys. Yes, thank you. Well, you certainly know where we live because we've been with you for a year now. Pam, are any of these upgrades covered with any grants right now or anything? I'm sorry, what did you say? Any upgrades, any of them covered by any grants? We've gone after grants for a couple of them already for the past three years. We haven't gotten any, but we've applied for, they're within that list that I have provided. Specifically, we've gone after a lot for the stadium and the museum. But there's no money available. In the lighting. Right. We've gone after them. The last three years, right? Yeah. Yeah. Seven minutes to finish. I have a coughing attack. Yeah.
118All right. Solicitor's information. I have no report tonight, Mr. President. Thank you. All right. Next section is personnel. The board is asked to approve the personnel log for December 4th, 2024 as attached. All salaries are included and all clearances are current and on file with the administration. So moved. Second. Discussion. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed. 2024, 2024. 2025. Cafeteria. Remuneration rates. The board is asked to approve the following remuneration rates for the 2024, 2025 school year. Substitute cafeteria slash food service personnel. $11.75. Can you, sorry, I have like something caught in my throat. So it's bothering me. This is what we're bringing substitutes in on? Yes. Okay. So moved. Second. Discussion. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed. Aye. School dentist resignation. The board is asked to accept the resignation of Dr. Weigler, Kreisinger Family
119Dentistry as a school dentist effective immediately. So moved. Thank you. Second. Second. Discussion. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed. Precision HR agreement. The board is asked to approve an agreement with Precision HR for substitute school psychology services as attached. Need the motion. So moved. Second. Discussion. I think this is a very, very bad move on the part of this district. Very bad. And it will not serve our students well. Why is that? Dr. Feit, can you elaborate? Why is it a bad decision? You're talking to somebody who was a school psychologist for 30 years. That's fine. I just want to know why you feel that it's a bad decision. First of all, you have no idea what you're getting. And it isn't just a matter of coming in and evaluating. It's doing classroom observations. It's
120doing the evaluation. It's writing the report. It's coming back for the meeting so that you can develop an IEP. There's a lot involved in this. A lot for just one child. This is not an appropriate way to provide services where you just pull somebody in off the street. All right. Thank you. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? No. Do you want to show of hands or otherwise just so that the board secretary can indicate who voted yes and no? Let's do a roll call. Roll call, please. Mr. Zipater? No. Mr. Yutze? Yes. Dr. Feit? No. Mr. Freund? Yes. Mrs. Geyer? Yes. Mr. Graviak is absent. Mrs. Ureer? No. Mr. Olson? No. Mr. Shipley? Yes. Mr. Walsh? No. Mr. Graf? No. Mr. Geyer? No. Mr. überall? No. 4, 4. Our motion fails. What was the vote?
1214 and 4. 4, 4. I think you ought to reconsider using the services of the local intermediate unit. That's a guaranteed source of service, and they're local and they're right here. You know who you're getting. And you know who you're getting. And if you have a problem you can pick up a phone and they can be here for all these meetings. You start scheduling people who live in Pittsburgh or something like that. Complicated and very important factor that can affect somebody for life Can someone elaborate on why I mean motion failed motion fails and fill all right? Thank you Next section is buildings and grounds he said investment grade audit so Sure, I guess what you do is Somebody can propose to plug a name in and then you can see whether that name gets
122five votes I'd like to motion from McClure. Oh, we have a first Well, we have to put a name in the motion for McClure. I'll make a motion for consolidated a constellation, I'm sorry, all right, so Well, you can Right. So McClure was was first proposed. So I guess what I'd recommend is I mean you can do it two ways You could either have a motion. That's that's simply to approve McClure and then a motion to approve consolidated Or constellation excuse me, or you can do it the same way that you did it for president and vice-president each board member could indicate who they've you know Who they want to have and if somebody gets five then then you move forward? Yeah, let's let's do part B there We'll do a roll call just say
123who do our voting for in this instance, whether it be McClure or Constellation do we want any discussion prior to yes, but should we do just We just need to have a motion and a second on the floor first. I need the motion. So moved. Second. Second, thank you. Discussion. What is this for? Consolidation? Either. Either. So this is just an audit. This is not committing to anything, any upgrades. This is an audit. This is choosing who we're going with. Yeah, just an audit. We're not committing to any. In January, we'll decide whether we're going to do it or not or what we're going to do. Or what section we're going to do. This is to enter into a contract with one of the two vendors. But not committing to anything. Correct. We're just choosing
124a vendor to bring it around. Roll call vote. Mr. Yutzi. McClure. Dr. Feig. Constellation. Mr. Freund. Constellation. Mrs. Geyer. Constellation. Mr. Graviak is absent. Mrs. O'Rear. Constellation. Mr. Olson. Constellation. Mr. Shipley. Constellation. Mr. Isipiter. Constellation. Constellation. 7-1. Also, I noticed they have a female engineer on their team. She should come and talk to our girls about being an engineer. Yep. They should let you talk. Yeah. I was like, girl, girl engineer, I love it. Before the meeting ends, Mrs. Mondock gave us a sheet, and I have some questions about that. The sheet that she passed out tonight. It's on financing options. Yes. Can I start? There's really no motion on the floor, but... There isn't. No. We just wanted to explain to you, correct? Well, we know the vote. I mean, we know the vote,
125but... Yeah, this is not nothing that will be voted on this evening. It was just to give you an idea of what financing for the projects would look like. This is disgusting. So that's the end of that, right? Mm-hmm. So can I ask you questions about that? What does she... You passed this out. I don't know what... That's what she was just saying, though. Yeah. It's not on the agenda. This is not on the agenda. No. I can... It's related to everything on the agenda. Well, why don't you call her tomorrow? Yes. If you would call me tomorrow, I'll be happy to discuss anything with you, Dr. Feig. You're kidding. Well, that's what was suggested. This isn't up for vote this evening. It's not for a vote. I have questions about it. And you can
126ask those questions tomorrow. Why did you pass it out tonight, then? So we can study and kind of get an idea of what we could be looking at. Right. Just like a sample. We're talking about a potential debt service of $35 million. This applies to every item on the agenda. But it has nothing to do with anything right now. It's just a sample. It has something to do with everything on the agenda. Right. We didn't vote for any of it. Okay. Next section is closing exercise. You're not allowed to ask questions. Citizens' comments. This is phenomenal. I see none. I need a motion to adjourn. So moved. Second. Discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Can I discuss finances? Thank you. I just had a question about it. I think they want the question. It
127wasn't on the agenda.