001December the 4th appreciate everybody being here this meeting is video through YouTube and the public may view that board meeting I will call the meeting of the special board to order this morning and the first order of business is if you would please stand we'll have our pledge of allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Our board chair, Dr. Evelyn Millington, is going to be a little late this morning, but she will be here. We appreciate everyone's attendance this morning on this chilly, frosty morning. Winter seemed to come early this year. We'll start with the approval of the agenda. I know you've looked at the agenda, and we cannot add
002any items to a special called board meeting, so I need a motion to approve the agenda. Mr. Vice Chair, move that the agenda be approved as presented. Second. Okay, you've heard a motion and a second that we approve the board agenda for today. Are there any questions or comments? If not, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, same sign. Okay, the agenda for today has been approved. And the first order of business is the interviewing of our architects. And I'll turn that over to Dr. Bryant. Thank you, Mr. Ellis. I'm very pleased to have our architects from Moseley here today to provide an overview of their qualifications and thoughts on the project. And I'll just remind everybody presenting, the board can ask questions both during the presentation and afterwards. And we have about 45
003minutes set up for the process. We might have a little time there to extend it some, but we're going to really try to stay on schedule. But we also want to make sure, because we're starting a few minutes late, we want to make sure you have the time to present what you need to present. So thank you for being here today. Well, thank you, Dr. Bryant. Thank you, Vice Chair, board members, for giving us this opportunity to be here. I'm Ashley Dennis with Mosley Architects, and we are here to talk about your new Pre-K-12. And first off, I would like to say congratulations. You will probably hear that from all three of your architects that are presenting, but it is a big deal to get this grant, and I know you guys are really excited
004that you did. So congratulations again on that. big step in the direction of building the school. So again, I'm Ashley Dennis with Mosley Architects. I'm the managing principal out of our Raleigh office. I do K-12 schools all day, every day. That is my focus within architecture and within Mosley. We also have Megan Garrett, our project architect on the project with Mosley. Steve Campbell, he's with PDC Engineering. They're our MEP engineer. Blake Hall with Timmons. He is civil engineering and landscape. And then we didn't bring our entire crew, but we have other partners with us. Camacho for our food service, MBP for our consulting, and structural capacity for our structure. So who is Mosley? We are a local trusted partner. We work all across North Carolina. And in the surrounding counties, we are currently doing the
005Greene County Central High School. That's another grant project. Brand new high school on the active campus of Greene Central right now going up. If you're out that way, you will see it peeking over the fence already. We worked in Nash County on their courthouse, and we're also doing the K-8 in Halifax County. Again, another grant project with that district. That was a school site that had been decommissioned for quite a while. It was the old Eastman site, and we're excited to be a part of the team that is bringing that back to life. putting education back on that site for the community. So we're located in Raleigh. I drive all over North Carolina working with school districts very similar to yours. But we are also a nationally recognized firm. We are number three in education
006design in the region. We're 27th across the nation in K-12 design. And then we're really focused on being good stewards of your money. So all of that part in the middle there related to being a community change agent for the USGBC and Energy Star Partner of the Year means that we are making good choices with our design team for our clients related to their dollars. So we want to save you money because, or save you energy, which in the end saves you money. So again, we are North Carolina architects. We've done 23 new schools in North Carolina just in the past seven years. Our square footage for North Carolina projects adds up in the millions. And we are actively working with four districts on their grant projects right now. So we could design any school
007in a bubble. We're good architects, but really knowing how to design a school doesn't come from drawing classrooms and drawing media centers. It's really about understanding how the spaces are used and so we as a company have organized what we call the Teachers Academy in all the states that we work in, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, we're actively doing one, coordinating one in Maryland to speak directly to the teachers. And so this is a two-day event where we bring all of the teachers of the year for that region or for that state and work with them to have them just design the perfect school. And so we do elementary school, middle school, and high school, and we spend time with them understanding how they utilize the space. I say that teachers can teach students in
008a closet, and often they are putting kids in, you know, all of the nooks and crannies to try to reach them and provide the space they need. But if we as the architects can provide the actual spaces they need, we're doing our job. So this activity just really allows us to understand from them and bring that back to our design for you. guys. Hi guys, my name is Megan. So I'll be talking a little bit about partnership with all of you and then some of the design process. Partnership, there's a lot of people we partner with on a project. There's consultants, engineers, there's surveyors, there's a lot of people that go into a team. But the biggest partnership that we feel, and mostly, is the partnership that we have with you. As Ashley mentioned, those
009teachers, the people, the users of the space are really critical to a part of the design process. So partnership begins from the get-go. It's something that's carried on throughout the entire course of our project. Day one, we're asking you questions from the very beginning. We want to know what you like, what you dislike, what works, what doesn't. You guys know this space and we want to really understand that and put it on. And that starts from the very beginning. We're learning as we go. And, you know, we have expertise in doing education. We know these spaces, but nobody knows them better than you. So we really want to be able to understand that. As I mentioned, you. You are the people that really hold the design team together. Throughout the entire process. It's the community.
010It's the teachers. It's the admin everybody involved We want to hear that so you know we can draw these beautiful buildings We can do these design documents, but listening throughout the entire course is what is our focal point? We have to be able to do that in order to do everything else programming I think Ashley's already begun a program for you guys, but this is sort of a back and forth process that we have with you all. We want to understand the square footages, the spaces, the sort of start, that nitty-gritty detail into what actually goes into a building and being able to understand what those functional needs are going to be, how much storage is needed, how many sinks are there. All that feeds into how we lay these buildings out and construct them.
011So we're starting to go back and forth with you guys during this. We can present to you what we think you need, and then we listen and start revising and go from there. And I think what this slide is showing is on the right-hand side, you'll see where we're starting to lay out those programs where the spaces are actually counted with square footages. And then here are some examples of different schools. So design workshop, this is very, very fun. I've been a part of a few and all of them have been so engaging and so wonderful. But this is where the vision gets established for the project. We want to understand what Edgecombe County really wants to see in their schools, what it means to them. words define this county, what everybody envisions this space.
012There are so many ideas that come to the table and those ideas are actually what gets carried on throughout the entire course of the project. So challenges come up and we always revert back to the things that we learned from this design workshop that we set up. Sometimes it's one day, most of the time it's two days, you know, but we start with that vision. We determine a mission statement. We set goals. what everybody wants to see. We divide up into teams where we sort of do little design charrettes and we can actually lay out schematically what the building could look like and the adjacencies of what classrooms go together, how people visualize the circulation between space and start getting those priorities in order and really understand what needs to be done in order to
013lay out the building and then our design team sort of takes those thematic layouts and starts making them a little bit more realistic so everybody can understand, you know, we're going to take these ideas from this group and these ideas from this group and start blending them together. So it's a really, really fun process that we're able to go through and it really sets the tone and starts building that relationship and that partnership that we're establishing from the beginning that can be carried throughout. a few specific design elements that we always consider. Safety. Safety is a huge thing in school and we want to be able to integrate it from the entry of the building all the way through the classrooms, through the entire site. We want to understand the layers that are happening there.
014Who's allowed on site? Who do we want there? What hours? Talking about security vestibules, this diagram shows an entry sequence for what we see a lot happening in schools where you're entering a secure area. There's multiple steps in order for a visitor to get into the building. They're not just freely able to walk in. It's not only considered at the entry, it's all the other entries, what's happening in classrooms, what's happening at the end of corridors. All those things are taken into consideration throughout our design process. Sight lines, being able to understand what teachers need to see in and out of classrooms, down the length of corridors, who's able to see in the building, who's able to see out of it. Another design element that we look at is seven styles of learning. So I
015think we can all understand that people learn differently. Some people are social learners, some people are visual, some people need to be hands-on and to really be able to understand it and grasp the concepts. And knowing that this is a school with multiple grades in it, I'm sure that... from the time you're in kindergarten to the time you're graduating, people have different learning styles throughout the course of their education. So we want to be able to listen, understand how you guys visualize that, and provide those spaces in which people thrive and that they're engaged and that they can really learn. So it's not just one structured classroom a hundred times over. It's being able to integrate multiple ways of learning. So when we talk about multiple ways of learning, one of the exciting things that
016you guys are proposing on the site is the career tech element. And so that academy really provides that hands-on, that visual learning for those students. And we have an expertise in that. All of our high schools have some kind of implication of career tech at Green. Central High School right now. We're in the throes of creating a agriculture science horticulture area with making sure that the pigs have the right ventilation and the solar orientation of the greenhouses is appropriate. So there's a lot more that goes into it than just, hey, it's just another rectangle on the site. And so we've worked with schools that have done things from aquaculture where they're actually growing fish you know and some of it is a learning experience for us. I did not know how to do that when
017I came out of architecture school and so understanding how we can create spaces where they're doing more green screens to where they're doing more hands-on things. like doing the aquaponics and maker spaces and robotics. We want to make sure we have spaces for those. Those are really exciting spaces that we see often in schools, but they're really messy and they require a lot of storage. Storage requires a lot of wall space, and when those things are not thought through early... You're trying to figure out later how you put all of these great ideas that your teachers have and you as a board have into a space that maybe wasn't designed for those bots. And so we want to help do that and create those spaces. We're also going to need to be creative on this
018project. I know that there's a desire to probably renovate some of the spaces that are on the high school site already, and maybe they don't look like the new part of the building. And how do we create those to look like that? So this is actually an old media center. in a high school that we created a more dynamic media center. It actually has a lot of maker space, CTE space adjacent to it. And so created this more academy looking space within a space that a lot of high schools already have that maybe isn't as bright, isn't as engaging for the students. Similarly, maybe the entrance looks a lot like this. We know that there are a lot of kind of low, maybe not as celebrated entrances on schools. And how do we... take something
019and create a new entrance. Maybe it remains the entrance, but all we want to do is just give it a facelift and really draw people in. And that security piece, when people know exactly where they're supposed to go, they have less of an excuse to just wander around the campus because I didn't know where the front door was. So creating those celebrated entrances is a really important piece of that. Working with challenges on sites. You don't have this kind of challenge. This was a grade challenge of 40 feet of fall in between two buildings that we were connecting. But sites and buildings always create these challenges. And so, you know, taking that space, connecting those buildings, creating secure areas for the students to be outside, but also kind of overcoming some of the challenges that
020the site threw at us are ways that we want to be creative on your site. and being efficient. So $62 million is a whole lot of money and it's also not a whole lot of money. You know, things just cost a lot. We all know that. We go to the grocery store, but we also realize that in construction too, that things are going to cost. little bit more money than maybe they did before they came to Michigan. How do we be efficient with that and with your dollars creating layouts that have multi-purpose uses, being flexible with the building, helping create spaces that flexible furniture functions in, and really thinking through how the design goes together so we're creating the most efficient building for your dollars and for your students. continuation of Ashley's discussion about being
021efficient we want to make the HVAC system be as efficient as possible we helped the school district over the last three to four years with several ESSER projects on your campus and we discovered lots of non-efficient systems some of that was because of poor design from the original 60s or 70s or 80s about not providing space to maintain the equipment and therefore it is not maintained it's not as efficient So then there's various types of systems you have across the district from oil or chiller systems to rooftop equipment you see in the bottom. And we want to do what's performed lifecycle cost analysis where we work with you to determine what are some good options that you can maintain as a district and then what are the 20-year total lifecycle costs of that including energy,
022maintenance, and the first cost so that you can help us or you make the decision that is the best interest for your district over the long term of this facility. We also want to work in what we call resilient design. We helped at Princeville Elementary School after the floods to rebuild it, where we made it flood resistant. To a certain level, we raised the HVAC equipment on the exterior of the building. We built new mechanical lofts in it. We did some other things that involved moats. But all of that was to protect it in case the next event, which we all know is coming, within, if you look out 20 to 25 years, it's going to have another event. More than likely in our area, but we want to make everything as possible be long
023term easy maintenance so that it can be used for the district for the long term and We've worked in Terrell County another county where there's a lot more blue on the map than what you have on this high school site and So working within floodplains understanding what the code requires us to do by elevating the building but also being thoughtful in how we design it, creating spaces where there's CMU up to a point on the walls so that if the water does get in, we're not having to replace drywall. You know, thinking about the finishes within the space. How do we quickly create spaces that are easily cleanable so that you can get the students back in? Because... Unfortunately, we can't control Mother Nature, but we do know that there can be floods. And so
024how do we create spaces that you as a district and you as a board are not having to think about where the students go for extended periods of time? And as a site plan engineer, I'm looking outside the building working with the architect, but we mentioned a lot about the floodplain. That is going to be a key consideration with this project, as well as a stream running through the site. So understanding the local processes, working with the county and floodplain administrator on those permits, working with the state and stormwater. Water is key here. We'll have to work through them. And erosion control is going to be very important. to protect the stream and downflow areas during construction, as well as working with MSTA and DOT. MSTA is a division within the DOT that regulates schools,
025and they make sure all stacking and queuing is on your site. You don't have a whole lot of space here, so we're going to be working with all these different localities and state and local to get permits on time for your construction project. But when we look at planning on site, I mentioned MSTA and DOT having to work closely with them to get all the queuing off the road to create a safe site on site and off site so we don't have traffic backing up into the road. Working to separate the cars and the buses on site to create that safe site. Thinking about safety during construction as well. We've done a lot of schools with active campuses that are keeping students on campus and working around the existing buildings as needed. Trying to make
026sure that pedestrians are not crossing drive aisles. We're really working on the site circulation. You got a tight site here up in this corner. So if we can fit everything there, that's what we're going to try to do. But there's some other opportunities on site where we could branch out potentially and expand and work through parking and queueing and athletics and everything else. So it's a lot of stuff to fit on a site, but it's a fun project and we've got a lot of experience doing this. So I talked a little bit about budget, but what exactly are we bringing to the table that helps you as a district and us as a design team fit within that budget? So we have stayed within budgets since before COVID. Sure, it was easier before COVID, but
027there was obviously just budgets were less before COVID. So we were still hitting those, but we don't want to be so far below because we want to make sure we're utilizing all of your funds to provide the space that you need. So being close to budgets is really important to us too. So we want to make sure we're on schedule and we're on budget. And we've done that a multitude of times with districts across the state. Some of the ways we control cost, you know, working with our design team, bringing the right players on our team to be able to do things like work on the site work, minimize the earthwork, make shorter runs of the site utilities, think through those things, the building size, minimizing square footage where we don't necessarily need it, but
028still providing the spaces that you need. The structural and HVAC systems, you know, Steve and his team have worked with you on your likes and dislikes with HVAC, but we also want to do those life cycle costs. Figure out where you're spending money because it's not just the money at the beginning, it's also the money throughout the life cycle. And looking at where the costs are structurally, like is steel or masonry, those things really fluctuate. And so we are tracking those things and want to make sure that we're doing the best choices design-wise for your project. Quality control is something that is very important to us. It's something that we are constantly doing. We're always reviewing the drawings. Reviewing what we have with providing comments to ourselves and making sure those are integrated But it's
029something that is a little bit more heavily done towards the end of the project It's actually personally one of my favorite things because it really gets into the details of the building and how it's constructed These are the drawings that go to the construction team. It's evaluating those who's actually going to be building from them So it's really important to be able to make sure that we're detailing things and drawing things after accurately so that there's not complications happening in the field. Nothing's perfect. So inevitably when you have a set of drawings things are going to be missed, things could be overlooked. So at Moseley we actually have dedicated staff that they do this all day every day. They're reviewing our drawings, they're looking for inconsistencies and errors in our drawings and they're pointing that
030out. They're bringing up really good questions that maybe we haven't considered. coordination aspects with civil, MEP, those are really critical items that all integrate into the building. So when you're past the fun pretty pictures and everything and you're really drawing these details, those elements become very important to us. more so into the coordination we have a program that we use called Navis words it's a class detection program in which most of everything that we're drawing is modeled three-dimensionally so that's not only walls, floors, ceilings, it's structural systems. piping, it's electrical, all these things are integrated together and what this system does wonderfully is it lets us know if things overlap. If you've got a steel beam and you've got a water line that are intersecting each other, it's better to know about that early where
031you can say, hey, how do we find a solution for this and address it now rather than when it's getting constructed in the field and you're running into issues that cause schedule delays. So our goal is constantly reviewing this throughout the process and catching as much as we possibly can in order to control that. Clash detection that was what I was just mentioning a little bit for Navisworks Steve might have some things to add but this is something that all the consultants are working with so it's not just architectural Elements that we're looking at its systems its structure. It's all of those things because you know you can see from the imagery how much Activity is going on and we just if we open to the ceilings in here. I'm sure we don't I would
032you know DNA and one other note about this so one thing you love to do is utilize these programs so that they're benefiting the project through design and then into construction so we start working through these because all the contractors have these programs they're going to do the exact same activity where they're taking our model and putting it in these clash programs and this allows us opportunities to also walk your maintenance staff through the model and make sure that they have access in the way that they want to to all of the systems and the various things that they're having to get up and feeling and change and maintain. And so we utilize that as a way to make sure that before it's built, it also has that ability to really provide the ease of
033maintenance because we know there's not a million of them in the wings that are servicing all your schools and we know you have a lot of schools. So being able to make their time. is also important. But all of those things really go back to this point right here. Firmwide, our E&O, which means error and omission, so that's kind of the stuff that we don't like to get up and talk about in front of school boards, is at half of a percent. Nationally, and that's from three different organizations, it's somewhere between 3 and 7% on projects. So we are very proud of ourselves and know that the effort we put in during the design with our design team on all that clash detection and quality control and just the knowledge base we bring to the
034projects is reflected in that number right there so that we don't have to have those conversations with you. Nobody's perfect. We're going to have some items that are going to get missed, but we keep that as minimal as possible so that at the end of the day we all sing kumbaya around the table and are happy when we're cutting that ribbon. So we're done. I think we did pretty good. So we want to open this up for questions to you guys. Anything we didn't cover or you have more questions about? Thank you for the presentation. Very good. We have some questions that each board member will ask and there may be additional questions that beyond these that board members may want to ask. So I'll kick it off and ask you, what is your firm's
035approach to maintaining a design schedule? We do this every day, but we also have internal micro deadlines that keep us on task. So we know what the end date is. And working in schools only, I call it the yellow buses don't care if I'm late. So I know when schools have to be open. Our design team knows when they have to be open. And so we keep those schedules. And then we also stay on top of the contractor because even if we hand over the drawings, The construction has its own little hiccups, and so being able to work with all of the local contractors and having those relationships so that we can help them brainstorm if things do get a little behind, that's our process, is making sure we're hitting all those micro-deadlines and then
036making sure that we understand what it takes to make sure you open the school on time. And my question is, what is the firm's approach? to monitoring and maintaining the budget? So we do very similar things. One, we have a third-party estimator. We think that's really important. We have a lot of knowledge base. We have a lot of databases because of the work that we do that is this kind of work. It is built solely on schools. We're not comparing you to a CVS or a church, that construction site. type, though similar, is different. And so we're comparing it to costs related to schools. And then we also have a third-party estimator that is kind of checks and balancing us to make sure that we're within budget. And, you know, we may have to have
037conversations about wants and needs. That's always something we do, and that's where those questions that Megan referenced come into play. And then, you know, Steve and his team talking about life cycle cost, which systems and the costs that go into those. Those would be those early questions. If we ask them early, it's easier to stay on budget than trying to ask them late. And rather than just at the beginning and possibly the middle and the end, do you periodically check and monitor this? Yes, sir, we do. The big ones are obviously at kind of those milestones. But yes, we're checking that along the way. We're making sure that using those milestones as barometers for, you know, do we have more money, do we have less, and adjusting along the way. One thing I'll add just
038real quick is we also do alternates to make sure we maximize that dollar amount. We don't want to leave any money on the table. It could be finishes or it could be a portion of the school, for instance, but we do alternates as well. We want to maximize the money to make sure there's nothing left on the table. That's a really good point. And for anybody who maybe doesn't know what an alternate is, it's literally we design a base. And then we give you options that after bid day, you can decide where you spend that. Thank you. Well, my question is, what is your firm's approach to tracking, responding to, and incorporating design review comments by the owner? and other reviews at each design phase. Megan's the one doing it. I heard it in your
039presentation. We listen. It is from the very beginning. In my experience, I've seen it different from different school boards. They may have their own established process that we need to adapt to and follow. So that's part of it, too, is understanding what works for your team and how you want to see that. Some schools formally want review letters, you know, at the end of SDDD and then seeing how we actually incorporate those changes, which I think is a very valuable process, being able to do that because it gives your team a chance to sort of look at it from your own perspective and be able to track those changes. It's not just a conversation that maybe you interpreted it one way, I interpreted it another way. It's actually formally documented and tracked. So, but internally
040we're constantly doing that. We're checking it. It's the same thing as cost estimating. So if we're having a meeting, we're coming to the table, we take notes from that and making sure that we're addressing it. And if it's not addressed right away, we're telling you when it will be addressed and how it will be addressed and creating those. those like creating a schedule for ourselves so everybody understands when those things are happening. A little bit too, we have permitting that we have to go through. We'll receive comments from that. That tends to happen towards the end of the project. A lot of those changes will go in addendas throughout the bidding process. Being able to pick up any code comments, DPI is a thing that we also consider. We'll receive comments through them. submit to
041them throughout the design process as well and we also formally review and respond to those comments and make design changes if those are needed. Hello. What is your firm's approach to coordinating with contractors and providing prompt responses to RFIs, submittals, proposals, and claim evaluations, change orders, and et cetera, throughout the construction? You mentioned some of it, but just kind of... Yeah. So we have... Moseley loves dedicated staff. We figure if I'm an expert in something, there's probably an expert in something else. We're not going to try to be experts in everything. And so we have dedicated construction administration staff. So they are Moseley employees that during construction are out there as much as they need to be coordinating and working with the contractor to make sure that what... our team drew on the piece of
042paper is what is actually being built. That does not mean that Megan or Steve or Blake or myself walk away from the project. It just means that you get the added benefit of somebody who does construction every single day and sees it every single day along with the design team. And so we're working within our programs to receive those RFIs, promptly respond to them because we find nothing good comes from sitting on something and being slow and so that the construction does not slow based on our responses. Good morning everyone. Dr. Wilson, we're just asking each other questions and on yours we'll ask that you do the last question. Jules got one and Ms. Anne's got one and then you'll finish it up on those questions. This is our board chairman, Dr. Evelyn Wilson. Good
043morning. They have done an excellent presentation for it this morning, Dr. Wilson. I only heard about a third of it. Hopefully it was the best third. I was listening carefully. I didn't want to disturb you, so I didn't walk right in. What is your firm's approach to verify an expediting project closeout and contract a punch list completion? So again, that same team kind of stays through it. We create our own punch list. They're going to create a punch list. Then we kind of combine those and then follow up with them to make sure that they're all being incorporated. And then that staff works to make sure that we're getting all of the documents from the contractor for closeout along with anything that's expected from the design team, whether that be as-built drawings or anything like
044that, so that you have all your manuals, all your documents. and a finalized school. You know, if the students are in there and we feel like punch list items are still not complete, then we're working with usually the principal to make sure we're coordinating when the contractor can get out there and then double checking behind them to make sure those are wrapped up. I'm Ian Kent and you were talking about your school in Halifax County, the school in Greene County. What's your current workload? So our current workload is we do have some projects. Those are all in construction. So our design team is freed up on those. We have a couple projects in Guilford County that we are working on. They're two prototypes. So we're like designing the same school at the same time. That
045is not this design team. So this design team is freed up to work on anything, work on this project as soon as possible. Thank you. Okay, I have the last question for you. Architects' relevant experience on projects of similar size and cost meets the required by Edgecombe County. Your experience on those size projects are more similar to that. So we're actively working on the Green County project. It's in construction. Exact same budget. Very similar size because of the fact that it's more high school students, but their population is about just looking at the schools that you're looking to put here. Guessing in my little bubble again that you're probably around 700. And so that's the same population of student capacity they have at that school. So we've done that one. But we have worked on
046schools very similar in size kind of across the gamut, whether that be elementary schools, K-8s, high schools, 6-12s, all the different combos. Thank you. If I could just ask a couple questions. So tell me your view in working with construction management at risk if the board decided to go in that direction. So we are very familiar with that. So I'm guessing that probably any kind of construction that you guys are familiar with is probably what we consider design, bid, build. We draw. Then we put out to bid and then all the contractors put in their numbers and the low one is the one selected if they are apparent and keep their number there. CMAR is... probably in the last 15 years grown in favoritism by school districts. It does provide you with a little more
047transparency. It does also give you, and I think this is what a lot of school boards are very keen on, is it provides you a GMP. So that is a guaranteed maximum price. So you hire us, you hire them. We work together the whole time, so a lot of your questions about cost and schedule, they're on board from the get-go. So we are working step and step to make sure that we're both meeting that. So we hit design schedule, we hit construction schedule, but when they put that out to bid, they are required to come to you with a guaranteed maximum price. that conversation of change orders is not happening. And so you know that everything you chose to put in there, whether you're picking alternates or it's just base bid, is within that budget
048that you have. That makes sense. So that is what we've seen. We have great relationships with all the contractors that do CMAR across the state. A lot of your neighbors are doing that. So Greene County, this is their very first CM at risk job. Halifax County went in a slightly different direction with the design build, but it is similar in the fact that you have both parties. along the whole way so that they got that GMP and they feel solid with their number. Thank you. One final question. So obviously we're on the timeline just like everybody else is with construction, but particularly with the needs-based. grant. I think I probably know the answer to this question, but you see no issues with us meeting the timelines for all that and making sure we're on target
049for the construction requirements of the grant. I think the state provided that date in there that is doable for anyone who is ready to do the project. Not so much that you have to rush, but that you need to make sure you're doing it and not just sitting on your walls. Thank you for your presentation. I think you answered a lot of other questions through your presentation, but... That's all I have. Well, thank you very much. It was an honor to be here. We're glad to have the opportunity. Madam Chair, hopefully you enjoyed the third of our presentation. And hopefully there's some tidbits you'll learn from your fellow board members. But we look forward to hearing your decision. We wish you luck in your decision. And have a great, hopefully, slightly longer. Thank you. Does
050any of the board members have any other questions? Just a comment. I've seen the Greene County and the Eastman projects. I've seen those. I visited them. I've worked at that place and I have a cousin who works at the other site. There you go. If you ask any of them, it's been a good experience on both those projects and they're excited to cut their ribbons as soon as they can. Thank you so much for being here. Thank you. Thank you all. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I'm Sharon. Hi. Nice to meet you. I'm sure you have. I'm sure you have. Sharon, we good? Appreciate Sharon being here this morning. Keep us on
051the straight and narrow. Keep us on the straight and narrow. Good morning. We welcome you here today and we are, are you ready to start? We are ready. All right. We want to hear your presentation so you're welcome to get started. Okay, thank you very much. Hayley Montemayor, Shia LaFerrari, handing out a piece of information for your use now and throughout the day. Thank you. We're going to... I'm Victor Vines with Vines Architecture. We would like to introduce our team first, and then we'll go into a presentation and keep it to 30 minutes, hopefully, and share a little bit more information about our firm, our process, some of the work that we have done that we believe relates to your project. And then after that, we'll open it up for questions. And then if we
052could have like one minute after that to give our final comments, we'd like to do so. So with that, I'm Victor Vines with Vines Architecture. Fred Marino with Design Collective. We're teaming with the Vines Architecture group. Frank Jackson. I'm a project manager with Vines Architecture. Hayley Mata. I'm an associate and senior designer with Vines Architecture. I'm Jeff Schroeder. I'm an associate principal with Vines Architecture. And I'm Keith Downing. I'm a landscape architect with CLH Design, Site Civil. So, Vines Architecture, who are we? We're based in Raleigh, North Carolina. The firm was founded in 2008 by myself. Prior to that, I was vice president of the Rimon Group for 15 years and did an array of work with that firm. We are a MBE 100% owned firm. The leadership group that you see here today will
053be the people working with you on this project. We don't have any hands-off or handing off of the project from the leadership of the term to the leadership and working on the project. So you'll see a little bit more about who that team is, but there are no handoffs. Our portfolio of work is extensively education and academic projects. We do most of our work in what we call is in the public realm. It is county work, city work, state work, libraries, schools, community centers, university work. Very, very, very little private sector. So all of our work is within that public realm where we're trying to serve and try to support the community. We had extensive CMR experience. We'll talk a little bit more about the various ways of delivering the project through construction. And then,
054as I said, we're the architect of record for the project with design collaboratives working with us. We'll talk a little bit more about that relationship and how we found it. This year we were awarded the AIA North Carolina Firm Award. That award is given in accordance with consistently producing quality architecture within a level of client satisfaction for a prolonged period of time. The award is given for a firm that has practiced at least ten years consistently providing projects throughout the state of North Carolina. We were awarded that this year. The people you see here are the firm. These are the people that works with us. They will be working with you as an extension of the team that you have here. On the handout we gave you, there's a QR code I would welcome you
055to visit at some point. When you go to that QR code, you will hear firsthand some of the testimonies from some of our previous clients that they gave as part of the award. So just go to the QR code, you'll go to YouTube, and you'll hear firsthand from some of our previous clients and how we work with them. In 2019, we were awarded the North Carolina State Building Commission Award. The reason this is important is that it is not necessarily a design award. It's not a award just for a design firm. It's an award given by the State Building Commission as a combination to the client, the architect, and the contractor. And so those three entities essentially received the award as a group. for a successful project being executed and implemented. And that was for
056the North Carolina A&T State University Student Center, which is about 150,000 square foot building, 90 plus million dollars. I'm from Edgecombe County, as some of you may know. My roots are here. I was born and raised in Pine Tops, North Carolina. I'm a graduate of Southwest Edgecombe High School. When I went to Southwest Edgecombe High School, there was a consolidation of South Edgecombe and West Edgecombe coming together at that time. And so you're doing something similar here, I believe, where you're bringing different schools together in order to provide a better facility for the students as a consolidated campus. I also am the co-founder of the LSB Scholarship Fund that we established, which provides scholarships for students in Eshcombe, Pitt, Nash, and Wilson, and Wake County. This is a scholarship fund that was established 10 years
057ago. We have awarded 77 scholarships. totaling over about $90,000 to the students in the communities here. And it's something that we're very proud of, something I'm very proud of, and we continue to do that work here. There's a couple of images of myself to the left here. You can see I'm a bit younger. You know, that one on the left, I think the caption is, Victor's giving the superintendent a hard time about student privileges, which I think I was. So that was Superintendent Lee at the time. The other thing that's quite special to me that I wanted to just share with you based on my roots here is that the photo on the upper left is a gentleman named Dwight Jefferson. Dwight Jefferson was the shop teacher when I was in high school. He was
058also, he taught in the evenings at Edgecombe Tech, a community college. He taught drafting. And he allowed me to go and take drafting at night after high school. And that is essentially what introduced me to architecture and got me to where I am today. He was a pivotal person in my life back here when I was in high school and when I was building and what I was able and blessed to do. As I've said, you've met our team. Myself, as principal in charge, I'll be the point of contact for this project. Jeff Schroeder, senior designer. Frank Jackson, project manager. Haley Manta, senior designer. And as I said, we are the core team that will be working with you on the project from beginning to end. In addition, Fred Marino and Scott McGovern. As Design
059Collective, they're our design partners. And Keith Dowling, CLH, which is our landscape architect. Great. Thank you, Victor. So I'm Fred Moreno with Design Collective. I'm president of the company. I've been there for a long time. This is my 40th year this year practicing architecture. Design Collective is in Baltimore. We're about 75 people. We have a small office in Chicago. We've done a lot of work in North Carolina. I'm sure you all have been here. Some of our work we do. Me, personally, I do most of my work, if not all of it, my entire career in the education world, both higher education and K-12. A little bit about our firm, 45 years of rank in business, 75 people right now. The K-12, 35 plus, it's actually about 45 plus or minus projects right now. We
060do new, we do renovations, additions, all of the above. And then there's some examples of some of our awards. And we're heavily involved in LEED and sustainability as well. And that's just a photo of one of our projects. Scale of our work and type of our work, as I said, a large percentage of our work is in the education world, with higher education, K-12. Some of the larger projects may be more familiar to you all in North Carolina or at NC State. We did Valentine Commons some years ago. It's a student housing project right adjacent to the railroad tracks on the edge of campus. We just a couple years back finished a science building for Winston-Salem State University there in the lower part of the screen and I want to say Valentine is about 250,000
061square feet. The state's about 110,000 square feet. We also did the conceptual design for the Wake Forest Innovation Quarter. You see a watercolor rendering there sort of envisioning what the entire campus might look like. Then one of the first buildings we did on the campus was the Inmar headquarters at the Innovation Quarter. At the top right there was basically to combine two buildings and create a headquarters for Inmar. Lower right corner is University of Maryland Baltimore. It's a 425,000 square foot science, research, academic teaching building in Baltimore. Also, in addition to Vines and Design Collective, we have a full service AE team being provided through us as well. And those consultants, in addition to CLH, as I mentioned, are Lynch Mikins, which is our structural engineer, Newcomb & Boyd, VP Engineering, NV5, AV, IT, Security,
062and Acoustics. We have Omer Glo, which is our lighting designer. and Rica Design, which is our food services lineup. And finally, we always have a third party cost estimating firm, which is Varela, which does our estimating outside of what the contractor does and outside of what we do in order to ensure that we're staying on top of the budget and the funds that you have. This is just a quick chart of once again confirming and showing how Vines and Design Collective work together. Essentially, we've broken it down by phase, starting with programming, design, design development, construction documents, and construction and project closeout. And so we work seamlessly together, but you can see that as the project progresses, we will continue to do more and more of it. But there's never a stop or a break
063between the two firms and the work that we do and provide. The Design Collective and Vines met in Baltimore about two years ago when we were asked to design and build and construct the Henry Redd-Olax building in Baltimore for Johns Hopkins University. It is a project that is rooted in the East Baltimore community and so it only made sense for us being out-of-towners coming from Raleigh, North Carolina, to find a partner in Baltimore, which was DCI. And we've been working seamlessly and fully integrated on that project. It's broken ground, it starts construction, and is expected to be finished in about 18 months. So from our perspective, we are bringing to you... the local proximity and familiarity of what we bring as vines to this community coupled with the pre-k through 12 experience we have and
064most importantly to me the national experience that they have and so we're bringing that to edgecombe county for you all on this project so a little bit some of our k-12 experience You know, some of the key things that we need to keep in mind when we're designing K-12 facilities for the 21st century is some of the aspects that you see there identified on the screen and more of them. We try to show you some example photos of a lot of the projects and types of spaces, everything from maker spaces to sort of spaces where learning can occur that wouldn't ordinarily occur years ago. They're outside the classroom. Much of the learning occurs in environments that are not four-walled because kids all learn at different rates and different types of learning that goes on. They
065learn from one another. So some of the photos there you'll see are not your traditional classroom spaces. All kids don't learn just by didactic teaching, and that's what we want to show you there. Obviously, we are about designing 21st century learning environments where kids can thrive and grow and learn. productive members of society in the future. There's a media center there, there's computer labs, there's learning commons, sensory places, teaching kitchens, innovation labs, and both traditional and flexible teaching environments. Much of the environments we design today are about being flexible because none of us really know, although we think we know what the 21st century will be. We're not 100% sure so a lot of what we do revolves around movable furniture that can be plugged in and you can have your laptop on that desk
066or whatever and it can become something else. These are just some of the examples of some of the projects we've done in elementary school, middle schools, high schools. The lower left is actually an experiential learning teaching space on the rooftop of one of the buildings. So we created a green space on top of the roof and actually they have class outside on those sort of those benches that we created. Also, just a very, very, very quick run on some of the projects that The Bynes team has done specifically to brief K-12 projects. I've done schools in Lecklenburg County, two in Haven and Lincoln Heights that were actually, believe it or not, they were prototypes of each other. Also designed the Princeville Montessori School twice because unfortunately in the first time around After we literally had
067finished it, it flooded. And so we had to redo it. And then also schools in Haven, Jeff worked on that one. And then, of course, Wake County Schools, the very E. Village High School, and the Martin Dillard School. And also, currently, right now, working on the E52 Rex Road Elementary School in Wake County. And Frank will speak a little bit more about that. So again, I'm Frank Jackson. I'm from North Carolina. My mother was from Maneo and my dad was from Spivey's Corner. So very local. This is E52, so it's the 52nd Elementary School for Wake County Public Schools. Just under $60 million, 133,500 square feet. This is pre-K through fifth with a core of about 800 students. They will not have 800 students on the first day. They'll start with the fifth grade and
068then they'll sort of backfill as the facility is coming into use. This will be delivered on time and on budget this June. It's under construction currently right now. mostly a brick building and here you can see we have sort of a difficult site I know this may be a little small here And if I could figure out how the laser pointer works. Okay, if you could see that, you can see this area right here and this area right here. That's the only buildable area on the 44 acre site that they gave us. Also, if you follow those topos, that site falls about 70 feet from Rex Road down to the back side of that. So a challenging site, which led to us following the topos, which... gives the shape of the building. We're not trying
069to fight the environment, we're working with it. Because of the wetlands in the center, we also have a lot of trees. This is a greenfield site, so nothing had ever been built on it. Mostly had been hunted on prior to this. And so we tried to save as many of the trees as possible going through this. You can see we have a media center, music, visual arts, cafeteria gym. The pre-K through first is on the first floor, so we have doors going to the outside. Admin is also on the front. This is it from an aerial shot. It was raining that day, so this is about a month ago. Rex Road is to, let's see here, runs along here. And we're adding another lane for slowdown. Parents come through here, big bus loop, because a
070lot of cars come through here. Buses come through on this lower side, bus loop dropping off. And this is, you can see that wetlands running right through the center of this. But by creating this form of the building, we have a lot of room for playgrounds for the little kids that sheltered by the building. We have space that is on the other side for our big older kids to come across here. And like I said, this is a difficult site, but one that we are working very carefully with Wake County and our contractor on to deliver an excellent school. some of our other work of that sort of size. So that was a... A little under 60 million, Henry Edelweiss building, bioethics building that we're doing with John Hopkins. We've already mentioned that. That's 33,000
071square feet, about $45 million. The Durham County Main Library, which Jeff and I did together, that's 48 million. That was 92,000 square feet. That was our renovation. In addition, we actually took the entire outside off of the building. existing concrete building, put another level on top of it and a green roof. Quite a challenging project that was also, aside from the pandemic that happened, that kept them from opening on time, was on time and on budget. Windsor Chavis, that is a library and recreational facility that was being in Greensboro. And almost $70 million, 65,000 square feet. And we had previously mentioned in Greensboro that we did the student union at A&T, $90 million budget. 150,000 square feet. That was the project that we won the delivery award from State Construction. And we work all over
072the place. We don't just work in Wake County and Durham County. We're all over North Carolina. Right now I'm currently doing the North Carolina's Education Association building in Hammocks Beach. That was a facility that was used to teach African American teachers. And because Bear Island was right across from that. That is currently under renovation right now. We're turning it into a... cultural center and a museum component and also for North Carolina Parks and Rec is using it as an event space. In Burdick County, we've done the Tall Glass Water, which was a recreational facility with a large landscape component. Pine Valley Library we did in Wilmington. Jeff worked extensively on that. And we've also done the master plan for ECSU. In previous associations, both Victor and I worked on the pharmacy school on that campus.
073So we're all over eastern North Carolina. Now, here's the exciting bit. Well, I'm going to quickly, quickly go through this, just to mention that budget and schedule are critically important to the project delivery. We... manage them for you, we help you with them. There is the project budget, there is the construction budget, there are reserves, there are contingencies that need to be planned, there are special systems that need to be allocated for, on your visual, and we manage and help you through all that. We have a strict policy in that we plan and design to 85 to 90 percent of your budget. We do not design and plan to a hundred percent. There are multiple delivery methods. I don't know exactly how you all intend to do it regarding the construction, but there is design-build,
074there is CMR, there is contract-registered hard bid construction. We have experience in all of those delivery methods and can advise you and help you with making the selection if you... need us to do that with you. But we have experience in all of those delivery methods. There's a lot, most of the projects this size by the way right now are just going CMR. They are basically essentially you're hiring a construction manager to work on your projects during pre-construction along with what we're designing. Innovative spaces, modest budgets, we know how to balance those and deliver the right solutions. schedule. Right now, you know, we take very, very seriously adhering to whatever schedule it is that you ask us to meet as long as it's reasonable. And reasonable meaning understanding that, you know, it takes time to
075build the project. It takes time to design them, to get them approved. And so we help lay this out for you at the very beginning of the project to manage and meet everyone's expectations. Great. Thank you. Okay, let's talk about school planning principles, K-12 world, different than it was years ago. One of the things we really need to focus on, I talked about this a little before, is 21st century learning environments encompass everything from the site... The building, inside the building, learning environments outside the building, inside the building, septet principle, which are crime prevention through environmental design. As we all know, there's too many incidents going on in the world today. We all need to be cognizant of how do we deal with that in the design of the building and the site. And as
076I said before, kids learn in different environments, both inside the building, outside the building. So there's some of the site amenities here and items that we're talking about dealing with the site and how we can better design a K-12 environment, both on the outside of the building and inside the building. Obviously we want to create a 21st century learning environment. I talked a little bit about this before and particularly in your case where you're bringing together separate schools into one location, both K through 12, I'm sorry, backing up, elementary, middle, and high. A lot of times that's not necessarily the approach that some counties would take, but I understand why you all are doing it, and that's fine. We just need to make sure we're really cognizant of how we separate the different uses, both
077the younger kids from the older kids, and I understand how you want to approach that as well. But certainly we need to be cognizant of... group learning, experiential learning as I said, fields and sports, creating some outdoor learning environments which are in the upper left there. We do a school where there's a lot of outdoor classroom spaces that can be created. The teacher can take them outside and they can learn. As I said, step 10 principles, crime prevention through environmental design, is huge today in the design of K-12 environments. We want to ensure that our kids are safe. Well, how do you do that? Well, you provide a lot of glass, a lot of natural surveillance opportunities. Access management, obviously, is technology as well. And in some jurisdictions, there's a bit of territoriality amongst the
078kids, so you have to be cognizant of that and how you deal with that and how you design the spaces to accommodate that. And this is actually one of the ways we approached it on this particular project was to provide a lot of glass. So you could see in, you could see out, there wasn't anything going on anywhere around the building that someone wasn't observing and seeing and couldn't address. Sustainable design lead is a big thing, particularly in all buildings, but certainly in K-12 environments as well. We have a director of sustainability on our staff in our office, and she will be sure to hold our feet to the fire early on in the design process to make sure that we are going to be able to design you all a building that's energy efficient,
079doesn't cost you a lot of money to operate, and will meet the latest and greatest standards when it comes to lead and sustainability. Obviously those are some of the things that we deal with, or some of the aspects in the design process. Everything from designing for the community, economy, using natural resources, and so forth. As I said before, the big thing in 21st century learning environments is design for, design flexible spaces. The lower right photo, the largest photo there, believe it or not, used to be a gym. And that was what the original program included. We told them, we said, let gyms today are a different size than this gym. You've got to accommodate more space than that space will have. So we convinced them to create a media center. And as you can see,
080lots of flexible types of seating, different opportunities for kids to sit in a bean bag if they want or sitting at a table and talking together with their laptops or whatever. But again, creating soft seating opportunities, different types of seating. That's the media center. And then we actually built a new gym as an addition on the back of the building. So creating some of the flexible aspects, creating zones for collaboration and individual study, making sure that we have access to technology and digital information and how we do that so that it's really good well into the future. As I said a minute ago, visual connections to the exterior of the building and certainly creating, depending on the program, maker spaces for project-based learning. Breakout spaces. Years ago we did K-12 and even higher ed. You
081know, it was about a double loaded car and how efficient can you be and don't have any extra space. Well, guess what? That extra space is where a lot of kids nowadays learn. It's outside the classroom. So you have to provide potentially tiered seating. for open collaboration spaces, and you actually saw another example of this a little while ago that I showed you when I was in elementary school. As I said before, mobile furniture that you can rearrange for informal meetings individually with students or with a group of students who put the tables together into a larger group. And that's actually a project in the upper right there. And areas also for individual exploration and research. So in other words, a nook or a cranny where kids can sit in a corner and kind of,
082you know, be quiet to themselves and be learning. And it doesn't have to be a formal space either. It can be a very informal sitting opportunity. You know, a lot of the spaces we're doing in buildings today for K-12 are collaborative innovative spaces or maker spaces, you might be familiar with that term. Again, movable furniture can be adjusted for a variety of different teaching learning styles. This particular image shows that the door is actually open to the outside right there on the end of the classroom so you can go outside. continue your conversation with an instructor or with another student and you're still learning. You're just outside enjoying the beautiful sunny day here in North Carolina. By the way, when Victor said he's going to his hometown to do a school, I was all in.
083I was all in. We've had such a great relationship on working on the Hopkins project together. This is really a great opportunity. We look forward to it. So in the last couple minutes that we have, Haley and I just want to talk a little bit about how we work. You know, we never think about bringing a preconceived idea and putting it on here. We surprise a lot of the opportunities that we can reach through the design. We also consider ourselves lifelong learners. We are concerned with creating places that are rooted in its place, but also unique to the community that we're serving. So not only looking at program, but also looking at history, looking at site conditions specific to your project. Then we develop. So through that visioning and research, we come up with design
084drivers. These are design drivers that respond to the vision that we talked about through the visioning sessions. This is the first step in building consensus for the project. And through this process, we have an iterative and inclusive loop of presenting and receiving feedback and progressing the design. And throughout the process, we are always going back to those design drivers, making sure that because we had a consensus through those design drivers, that with the design, we have reached that consensus and making sure that we hit that benchmark. set by the design drivers. This is the Windsor-Chavis NoCo community complex. As Frank mentioned, this is a library and recreation facility, so it was not only a consensus needed on the owner's side, but also a consensus between our design team and between design team and owner. Very
085complex project and the first of its kind within the area, so really great that we were able to get it to the start of construction very soon. And lastly, we coordinate and we execute just those same values, that same rigor towards coordination and making sure that we are not only designing a great building, but delivering a beautiful and successful project. Back over to Jeff. And as Haley mentioned, as we talked about a little bit, we're always thinking about how do we design individual projects with specific needs. And so one of the parts of that is just understanding who you are. And so looking at some of the information you have and what you've outlined in your futures or your imagined strategic plan, reading those bullets are just very, very exciting. There's lots of talks about
086individuality. how students can create their own educational opportunities, the goal of everyone being accepted to college, but also this whole idea of creation of community focuses, community partnerships, engaging, bringing in talent, keeping talent, developing talent, and understanding there's different learning needs. And so with that, you know, there's lots of opportunities we'll be exploring on this. There's going to be the realities of site considerations, budget drop-off. How do you keep students, bring students together? How do you keep them separate? How do you promote positive things? But thinking about how some of these things of community engagement can translate into an idea. So some of it's already started within the visiting North Edgecombe High School, which is super exciting to see. But then how can the new project begin to create sort of outdoor spaces, community spaces
087that begin to engage the site as sort of a protected academic focus and outward focusing to bring people together to further those partnerships? to think about how these core programs that we know we're going to have, the cafeteria, the gymnasium, art and music spaces, these innovative spaces, how can they serve to provide opportunities for learning for the students, but then maybe also be places where students can take their knowledge and share it with other community members to create this sort of cycle of learning where you're both learning and you're sharing and you're building these things together. And then thinking about what opportunities exist for the campus. The existing high school currently exists. but how do we think about bringing people together, other opportunities for older students to mentor younger students, other opportunities for thinking about
088the design in such a way that it prepares students for the next step in their lives of going to college and experiencing a campus environment with diverse learning opportunities. And then also thinking about the realities of this project. And there's all these considerations of how do you have carpool, one carpool spot, two carpool, three. Are there multiple bus drop-offs? Do you try and do that simultaneously? But then also thinking about the realities of this project being a campus and as you begin to put a pre-K through 12 school on here, how does it work? What happens if you renovate the high school? Where do those high school students go? Do you build and do you keep the high school open? Do you build somewhere and then transition those high school students into a new building
089and renovate the high school? But what is that sort of phasing? How do you make this project really become from these dreams? and these visions into a reality project that's really going to be a centerpiece and a building that's going to keep the community excited, promote education, but also promote staff that want to be here and want to really bring their best and create this as really a destination facility and a model facility for education across the state. So with that, I'll pause and turn it back to Victor. Okay. We are at 34 minutes and 40 seconds. Sorry, Victor. So we tried to give you a glimpse very quickly of who we actually are and what we do and how we do it. Not so much, and Fred and I talked about this, not so
090much. what we've done. I mean that's that's it's hard to not do that because we're simply trying to make reference but what we're most interested in is what we believe we can do for you and what we can do for Edgecombe County on this project. So with that I'm going to try to address some questions you all may have and then I'll have one final comment. Okay, we have a few questions for you. Mr. Ellis. Some of these you have touched on. My question is, what is your firm's approach to maintaining a design schedule? Our approach is, first, I'll go back to the slide. First thing is we gave, and there's a lot we don't know, so let me emphasize that. But based on what we do know, we laid out what we believe is
091a blood-borne and magnitude schedule for this project based on the phases that you see here. Visioning and programming, establishing the program, schematic design, design development, construction documents, and construction. We've given some rough durations to that. So at the very top, you'll see three months, four months, five months, seven months. Based on our experience, this is probably in the range of what one can expect for a project of this size. Now, all of these can be compressed to a certain degree if they need to be, but we have to be mindful of what's, once again, realistic. The blue on the end down there, the construction phase, the fitting phase. Those are probably pretty fixed. Now, once you bring your CMR on with your contractor, they will verify that with us, and that's what I meant by
092the pre-construction services and phase of the project if you bring them on. Everything from the orange back, we essentially control regarding the designer. Set those we do everything we possibly can to adhere to them We we meet frequently you'll see the little dots on the bottom down there We establish the schedule the amount of time we need to meet who we need to meet with and at what frequency And we hold to those schedules and so The thing we don't want is to let one of those phases slip because it essentially pushes everything out. I'm certain you're going to be trying to meet a calendar year that you're trying to get these schools opened by. And so if that's August of... Pick a number. Don't kick me. August 28, or I don't know, maybe August
09327. I'm not sure what you're really targeting. We need to have the building ready for you. It needs to be what I call shaken down, meaning everything is working probably sometime around May. So the building needs to be ready in May for you to go in in the fall and for you to be able to move in. And so we monitor that schedule very, very, very closely. And once we establish it, we do everything we can to meet it. We have clients that... are non-negotiable once that schedule is set. And so we're accustomed to that. Hopkins is one of them. We have to meet an anniversary, what is it, for the 150 year anniversary of the university and Henry and Alask without going to open. And if it doesn't open... he's going to have to
094leave town. And so we're accustomed to it, we develop it, we develop it with you, and if we agree to it, then we meet our marks on the documentation, design, and delivery. The one thing we don't necessarily control, just to be clear, are some of your local regulatory agency reviews. We can work with them and we like to be friends with them in order to get things through, but they do take the time that they take in order to do approval as far as to proceed to another phase. My question speaks to, and you've already spoken to it, but go back and focus on the monitoring and maintaining the budget. That would be this one. First, you may wonder exactly what I do on the project. I've got a team that works with me, that
095does a lot of things. The one thing I do is monitor the budget. I establish the budget with you. Work and make sure that as we are you know? Jeff can attest to this Jeff is going to come to you all with a lot of ideas And you guys are going to get excited about those ideas And then I'm going to turn around and say Jeff can we afford that idea? And if we can, then we can move forward. If we can't, I'm going to ask that we think about another idea that you like and you support that isn't horrible. And I spend a lot of my time personally on all the projects, monitoring and managing the budgets. The reason is that if we don't do that and we get to the end and we're
096over, guess what happens? We have to do it over. And we have to do it over free. And that's not good. So we are very deliberate and strategic in understanding, as I said at the beginning, there's a project budget. That's your total funding. Okay, you've got to bring some stuff out of that and then you're going to end up with a construction budget estimated not to exceed. Generally speaking, depending on what comes out, your construction budget is usually about 75 to 80 percent of your total project budget to spend on the building and building and constructing it. Once you get that 75 to 80 percent allocated, Then as I said the planet last button we planned and designed to 85 to 90 percent of that So that we are not basically trying to just, we're
097not going to design up to that number because there's too many variables. There's the economy, there's escalation, there's politics, there's elections, there's all sorts of things that drive that budget number. And so we stay and focus on that every fade with the wave. If I go back to the schedule, our policy is... We never leave one of these phases without being in budget. We're not going to leave schematic design and go into design development and be $2 million over. That's not going to happen. We're going to get back in budget if we're not, and then we're going to proceed into design development on budget, and we're going to get to design development, and we're going to make sure we're on budget before we go into the next phase. And when we get here, once again,
098if you have a CMR on board, they're going to be working with us along the way, also saying, okay. We believe you guys are also in budget because they will be required, typically speaking, based on pre-construction services to give estimates at each phase of the project. My question is, what is your firm's approach to tracking, responding to, and incorporating design review comments by the owner and other reviews of each design phase? On the schedule, you'll see these little black lines. Those are reviews and approval periods that we track at the end of each phase. So when we finish a phase, we will make a formal submission to you. And that submission, you will be, you will basically ask that you take as much time as you want, but basically it's about two to four weeks
099of your week reviewing that submission, giving us comments back. We can do it across the table. We can do it virtually. We can receive it formally and written. And then once we get those comments back, we will send you responses. back to those comments with the documents updated to reflect it. Oftentimes we do what are called page flips at the end of each one of those phases where you give me your comment, we make modification, give you our responses, we sit down with you and then we go through the documents and show you where we have made an adjustment. Once we've done that and you sign off on it, We don't start the next phase until you've given us approval to do so based on the appropriate A&O. What is your firm's approach to coordinating
100with contractors and providing prompt responses to RFIs, submittals, proposals, and claim evaluation, change orders, et cetera, throughout construction? And you've covered both. I love this in the presentation. I'm going to not hog the stage. And ask Frank to answer that question because, one, he's better at it than I am. And he is living it every day on a project that is very similar to yours. And if I may, we're starting to get a little tight on your time. I'll be very brief. In short, the contract drives this. So the contract and the specifications will say we have seven days to respond to an RFI, we have 20 days to respond to a submittal. All of those things are timed and working with any good contractor they will be very cognizant of what that time is.
101So it's driven by the contract that you have with the contractor. We respond quickly, mostly because some of our municipalities rate us for our next project based on how quickly we respond. And so we're very on top of that. In addition, the project is sort of a lifeblood is on information, right? We give them a series of instructions for how to build the project. And if some of that is not clear or has been changed by the owner, then I've got somebody standing there with a concrete block and they don't know where to put it. So we're driven to answer very, very quickly. And I'll also add, back to this slide here, the depth of experience that we have with the major players around Barnhill, Valper 80, CT Wilson, Metcon, Skanska. You know, once again,
102I don't know who you all will end up with, but... I'm certain if you call any of them up, they will tell you that they have high respect for the work that we do with them because if we don't respond quickly and efficiently, it impacts them directly. And so we have repeat work with them, we have repeat projects with those contractors and construction managers, and so we take that very seriously. As I said, the range is anything from $125 million down to $4 million and various other things. If there are no other questions, I just wanted to once again say thank you. You know, you all have a very important decision to make. And Fred and I have talked about this. You know, you're looking at the two longers of the two problems. It stops
103with us. And fortunately, it starts with us as well because we're the ones that are going to be doing the project if we're so fortunate to be able to do it. We have an established and proven relationship and partnership. Hopkins is a very, very, very, very complex, very, very, very complex place to work. And we've done it there successfully and we're doing it there successfully. We're fully integrated as it relates to the execution of our design work into realities. We're not a boutique firm. Sometimes people think we are, but we design our work and we get it built. and it's done at a pretty high level. I'm very, very excited about coming back and doing work here in some capacity. It is very meaningful for me to be able to have that opportunity to do
104that. So with that, I'll just leave you with one thought for us. Excellence is the base. That's the baseline. What we're going to do for you all is exceptionalism. Something that is exceptional. So just remember, excellence is the base. So that's what we're excited about. I've been to the site. It's a corner site. I love corner sites. I love sites that are on intersections. And I really think that we could do a spectacular job. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Madam Chair, we just have a couple minutes here. I know everybody didn't get to ask a question, but if anybody had a burning question that they wanted to ask. Maybe we should ask, what's your current workload? We could start tomorrow. Our current workload, to be specific, for vines is we have... a tremendous amount
105of work that has been completed and gone through the firm and is going under construction. And so capacity to start a new project, to start it with the programmers and designers, literally could happen this week. You know, there's maybe two in the office right now that's starting. We run usually 12 at a time through an office at any given time, any given phase. So we definitely have the capacity. We can start this project before the end of the year if you so choose to. And I'm not going to speak for DCI, but I'm sure Fred could. I would concur. We have 75 people and we have staff right now that I'm... I definitely need to get him engaged in a project so we would love to be able to start right away. In fact, I
106think Victor has a contract in his pocket, don't you? No, seriously. That would be presumptuous. We have the ability to start right away, actually, and see who's victim. Anyone else? And my apologies for jumping to the Y-Vines. I didn't realize that you had not been to Washington. Construction management risk obviously is not a concern for your firm, correct? It is not. And there are no issues with meeting the deadlines of the needs-based grant as required by the state? Absolutely not. I thought you'd already answered that because I wanted to ask you a little bit more. Anyone else? Thank you, Mr. Bynes. I noticed on your charts that you worked with our Princeville Montessori school. What year was that? That was... that would have been... You knew it, right? 15 the second time. When was it?
107First time was about 08. I think the second time about 15. That's what came to mind. I think I mentioned it, we were awarded that project and we designed it and it was literally almost, it was like 95% finished if I'm not mistaken and then the hurricane came and it flooded and then we had to evolve FEMA and work with getting it cleaned up and then we redesigned it. Thank you. I know your time. Thank you. Thank you all. We appreciate it very much. Can I ask you a question? What is your biggest concern on the part of the There are lots of concerns. I don't think there's just one. Obviously we're transitioning three campuses into one and we're going to be having school at the same time for the high school. So for me
108that's one of the big things. Obviously an efficient process and use of budget. and want to make sure that we have a design that really brings what we all would call preschoolers up to a level that we feel like meets the educational needs of our students for the future. And there are lots of others I could probably do it. Well, it's interesting that you mentioned the one you did because we talked about this. There's a very important part of this project which is going to be the campus planning of that project. And you know it's not going to be just about dropping the building on the site. And you know we didn't highlight it a lot on our presentation, but we do a lot of campus planning for universities. We've done master planning for North
109Carolina A&T State University, for not only Central University but for the city, state university and what I mean by that is that they hired us to basically look out for the next 20 years and plan their campuses and establish that direction. This is a smaller scale but it's the same process of understanding how those three facilities are going to exist on that property. transition to get yeah well those kids have to go somewhere right so you might want to think about this construction sequencing of those thank you thank you for the for the morning Thank you. Thank you very much for having us come present. We feel like we've got some important things to show you. We brought our team with us. I see. I want you to understand now, these are not just pretty
110people that I'm bringing with me. These are the people who are going to be designing the project. And these are the people that I've worked with. Some are consultants. We've got Wilson Hughes, mechanical electrical. Bruce Queens, our structural. Zach Bradshaw, architect with the firm. Robert Edmondson is our construction administrator, field inspector. Alex Pacey is a mechanical engineer. Jael Lago is an architect with the firm. Wes Moore is an architectural designer. Steve Janowski is a civil engineer. I've worked with Steve for over 30 years. Todd Smith is our site designer. And I am Jimmy Hight. I'm the project architect. And I will be conducting and organizing the design of records for the project. The other thing I think is important is that not just the relationship that we've had and the experience we've had, but we're
111right next door in Pitt County. We're in Greenville. And even though we're in eastern North Carolina, we've done lots of big work in faraway places. Mostly here, around here, but we've done some work in other places. So I'm going to go ahead and start this presentation and talk about who we are to begin with. We are K-12 specialists. That is about 95% of our practice. We have the experience you need to build to your budget. We have a unique approach to school design. We think it sets us apart. It has major advantages. And our design approach is a system approach. We are expert in execution and delivery of school facilities. The approach that we use has everything to do with common sense. It's common sense design. It's also cost-effective design. And of course there are
112two kinds of costs. There's first cost, construction cost. But there's also long-term cost. It's the forever cost of maintaining that facility. We focus on ease of maintenance, which you'll see in these slides to come, and low maintenance. Ease of maintenance and low maintenance. And key for us is school buildings at last. You hear a lot of talk about sustainability, sustainability, where you make it out of this or you do this. To us, sustainability is... is long-lasting schools and the way we do it is what I'm going to present to you. We call our philosophy of school design stewardship of the public trust. We're very serious. We're taxpayers too and we understand that we've got to be good stewards and as designers design buildings that last. So we developed a system we call USA Unitary Systems
113Approach which was coined back in the 90s when we started the development of it. We built over 50 new schools and dozens of additions using this approach. What it is is a set of principles that we use with all our designs. It's not a prototype floor plan. It's not like well let's build a school like this one over here. It's design principles that we use for all of our designs. And it's pretty simple, like we are. As if it was shape, connectors, pinched roofs with overhangs, and platform technology. So we'll go through and try to explain what those mean. So shape, we know that if you build rectangles instead of curves, you save money. That's pretty simple. It's common sense. Everybody understands that. But it also saves money because it's a simple structural design. All
114the beams get the big things out. So you save money in the repetition of construction elements. Connectors are used where they apply in a given design. Connectors we find are a desired feature. Teachers like connectors. They like the idea they've got their part of the building and somebody else has theirs. But they can also allow you to lock all parts of the building. This is really important. we find today even though we developed this before all the security concerns that with a push of a button we can release magnetic hold opens on doors and lock off all the different parts of the doors. Pitch roofs with overhangs. I mean, it's kind of like, really? Well, you know, you'd be surprised at how many schools are built without pitch roofs and without overhangs. The simple fact
115is that protect the walls from weathering. So even if your wall had a leak in it, you'd never know. And we're all familiar with older buildings that don't have overhangs, and they weather. They weather because of the weather. They're designed to last the life of the building and we don't put equipment on the roof. So that's a maintenance aspect. We use wide overhangs. They provide solar shading and rainwater is directed away from the building. We want it off the building. And not only do we want it off the building, we want it underground and we want it to the stormwater retention basin. The point I like to make. with all our clients, especially here in Eastern North Carolina, you know where we are. We have floods, we have low, we have high water tables. Water
116is our enemy. You know about schools that have water seeping through the floors and through the walls. That's our priority is to make sure we design schools that don't have humidity problems, that don't have moisture problems. We live here and we know what we're all available for. So platform technology might be as important as any of the other principles. And what we're doing is we're pulling concrete over the hallways and we're putting mechanicals and electricals and infrastructure technology on that area that's outside. the occupied space. So when things are changed, maintained, you have to go up there and do something. You're doing it without disturbing the students or the staff. It provides a space for all of the utility systems and it's always accessible for maintenance. In fact, it makes the building stronger. Not only
117does it make it stronger, but it saves money because the strength of that core with the concrete on top lets us use less steel. Steel is very expensive in comparison to concrete, so we achieve substantial savings that way. They also create very safe places for kids in a weather emergency. If there's a tornado warning, you go in that hallway, you'll be safe. It gives maintenance folks room to work away from school operations, and we don't take any floor space up of the occupied space for the floors required for this mechanical stuff. When we give you a per square foot figure, we're not including this space. We're just including the occupied space. And we always put stairs up in each of the areas so it's an easy way to get up and down. One other benefit
118it has is during construction. Our schools are typically built faster than other schools because there's more room for more people to work simultaneously. So when they're finishing the school downstairs, these guys are up here finishing the heating and air, the electrical, and running the technology wires. And they've got plenty of room to work. It provides an advantage in better quality as well. But the thing that I want to key on with this, with these slides about the platforms is that What it does, it gives you a way to bring in new technology, new systems, change systems, keep improving the school as the years go by out of the way of the occupants and not disrupting what's going on below. 30 years and 50 schools later, we've proven that the way you design a school can
119save significant cost and at the same time result in a better school building. I'm going to show you some examples of how we've saved lots of money for our clients, but given them better quality of their schools. I do want to say a little bit about sustainability. We talked about it early, but this is the way we feel about how architecture responds to sustainability. Indoor air quality and comfort is critical. So our designs focus on keeping the weather and the water out. Humidity control. We all know what humidity does to books and things like that. And the M word, the mold word, we don't want in our schools. Indoor air filtration. We pay special attention to making sure we've got the proper filtration for our school components. Sustainability. We reduce the burden on maintenance and
120custodial operations by our use of the platforms and specifying the right materials for the interior finishes. We also focus on overall integrity of the building envelope. We use special insulation that completely seals the envelope. We use high efficiency boilers and chillers. Our system that we like to use is a traditional four pipe system, but we use the latest equipment, the highest efficiency equipment. And we also use some strategies such as off-peak ice making and storage where we run the chillers at night when the electrical rates are low and save money by having the ice cool the building during the day. So, metal roofs with protective overhangs, brick, aluminum, and glass exteriors, long-lasting interior construction, long-lasting HVAC systems is what we think sustainability is all about. Protection of the building is the key to longevity. So,
121some slides about cost. What we want to leave you with is the impression that, you know, height, those buildings that cost less but they're better than them. There's no sacrifice in quality. Berkey High School, 18.3% less than the state average. It's a beautiful school. Here's a USA Middle School built for $2.15 for $13.2 less than the state average. Elementary School built for 16% less than the state average. Here's a case study of 23 schools that we built in Johnson County. Over the years, every one of them, and an average compared to DPI cost estimate is 16% less. That's a lot of money. But you also need to look at it this way. You've got a budget, and we know how to meet your budget, but we're going to give you more money. That's what 16%
122less means for you is more free money. So how do we do it? Well, we've talked about the design, but the way that the firm operates is that we're very careful with our programming for the building functions and speaking with staff and all of the stakeholders. We keep our hands on all the pieces all the time. The application of our experience for 40 years. And close contact with the local contractor community. We are Eastern North Carolina people. We know the contract of the community. And you can ask any of them who participate in these sorts of projects about how and why we like to build those schools. So here's a couple of projects you're not familiar with. And we went a little further afield here down in Beaufort, South Carolina. But we did two big
123schools there that have some nice features. High security entrances. We're all aware of security concerns. multiple specialized STEM levels, age-appropriate playgrounds. This is a K-8 school for 1,400 students. And another complex nearby was a 200-acre site which designed a large high school as one of three schools that we master-planned for the 200-acre site. And the way we split it up and the ideas that we used... are sort of related to the concept in a way that what we're going to show you for your project. But you see, it's almost like three front doors on this building. And the nice thing about that is that the gymnasiums and performing arts, they've got their own entrances, they've got their own lobbies, they've got their own restrooms, and we can lock off the academic core from those parts
124of the building. forming Art Center for 625. Both the competition and the auxiliary gyms, specialized teaching spaces, and advanced manufacturing was the focus of their CTE program. Now I'd like to show you a couple of projects in Lee County. And this was what we call the restoration and renewal of Lee Senior High School. So this was a 15 building campus that had been built over, gosh, I guess 40 years beginning in the 50s. And let's see if this pointer works. So the project was evaluated from the standpoint of, you know, how do we help the academic, the main academic piece as far as security's sake and how to get it connected. which of these buildings are so old we need to get rid of. And this campus doesn't even have a front door. So, and
125we need to improve the security of it. We have so many buildings on this campus. So what we did was we decided to take out five of the buildings. And the one in the middle here is the math building. really needed to go because that helped the scheme in two different ways. I'll go ahead and show you the result. We took that math building out here and opened up the campus and gave it some organization by introducing student mall space. And then we built new, we took a couple buildings out here. took them away, and then we built a new two-story section with two-story connectors to these two two-story buildings. So it's a two-story academic complex that has good circulation. Kids are always inside until they need to go to a different part of campus.
126And we gave it a new front door. And so that in its essence is what was the big idea, was the big picture. So that's the new front door of the new Tushola building. And that's the new student mall area. We also introduced a central plant for heating and air conditioning. So we took away all the old stuff in the existing buildings and we built a new building. And we built this building here. There's a new boiler house, and these are ice storage tanks and chiller systems. So all those buildings operate with a central system. And then, of course, this is a picture of the nice lobby at the front door. So we did a complete restoration, which included renovations of existing buildings and building new. Also in Lee County, we took a very important...
127building, Rosenwald High School, I think one of five left in the country, and national landmark, and converted it into a K-5 STEAM school. We call that connecting old and new on a secure campus. So if you look at this picture, you'll see that we've got a gatehouse here. We've got nice ornamental iron fence all the way around the property, another gatehouse here. all the way around. And then of course this is the original building. In the 1950s they built an auditorium onto the 1928 building and also built a gym. So what we did was connect everything together with new construction for a new two-story academic wing and a new cafeteria. And I've got some slides of that. So it's... It's a really nice school and of course the focus is on science and technology and
128engineering and arts and math. The maker space is in that school. We've got a dance studio. Really nice outdoor learning spaces. We do courtyards and when we do them we like to use AstroTurf. AstroTurf is an old material but the new developments are quite nice. I mean it lasts a long time. It drains through and obviously needs no maintenance. So we are involved in three other counties with needs-based grants and these are got a slide of each of those and for Quimmins they received a couple of grants commissioners got a grant and we are underway we're about a month into the construction of a school that combines two schools are closing and one is an elementary and one is a middle so what we did is you can see We've got a middle school here,
129we've got an elementary school here, and then we've got our shared spaces here. So you've got administration in the front, media center, AstroTurf courtyard, art, special populations here in the middle, another courtyard, music, multi-purpose with a stage, the multi-purpose mainly for the elementary kids. And then the middle school gym with locker rooms and health rooms, exercise room here, and cafeteria. And so we've also got a main entrance, main front entrance here, but this is also a main entrance for events. It's the bus entrance, but it's also a main entrance for events in here when we lock off the rest of the school with those doors that I was talking about earlier. That will be delivered in the spring of 2026. Beaufort County, we just broke ground Monday for this school. And again, closing two schools,
130combining it into one. Where Quimmins is about 1,000 capacity, this one is also close to 1,000 capacity. So it combines two elementaries, but it's a pre-K three. So you can see we've got the front building. It's here with admin, media, maker space, gymnasium, cafeteria here, art and music. We've got these two wide connectors that connect this shape. This is where all the classrooms are. We created this courtyard for special populations and the pre-K kids that are in here. And again, this will be a 2026 delivery. And in Bertie County, they got a $15 million grant for a CTE wing, which would have cosmetology, auto tech, HVAC tech, construction tech, ag, and welding. So that brings me to our concept for you for the North Edge Cone K-12. We really like this site. It's got some
131challenges, but we see some tremendous opportunities with the water feature here. And of course, we all know it's low on this end. We've got a couple of buildings down here. They would need to come out because they're too low. And the older part here, we propose to come out as well. to keep the gymnasium here, keep this part of the existing high school, and add on to it as we need to and include a performing arts theater, auditorium, an auxiliary gym, and entrances on this side so that, again, we can begin to lock off parts of the building that are not in use and have separate lobby restrooms. for events in theater, auditorium, and gymnasiums after hours. The K-8 school would be by itself, this part of the site would need to be filled of
132course so we could bring the level up to where it needs to be up to the rest of the school. And it would be elementary downstairs and middle school upstairs. We've got an entrance here with automobile queuing and a drop off here, back out, and then high school here. Also proposing to add a new CTE building here, bus parking in the main. We've got space for middle school ball fields and we've got budget for renovations, significant renovations to the existing athletic fields. So, neat things I think is the open mall concept and we've got that incorporated here. So it ends up being a very secure environment I think with things connected with enclosed connectors and nice open space, secure space for kids to enjoy their school day. That's our presentation. We are ready for any
133questions you want to ask us. Yes, thank you for your presentation. And we do have some questions for you. Yes, ma'am. And we will start with Ms. Ellis. Yes, sir. What is your firm's approach to maintaining a design schedule? We will maintain your design schedule. That is not an issue with us. It has never been an issue. We have a reputation of delivering on time, not just our design services, but on through construction. What is your focus, sir, on monitoring and maintaining the budget? Well, I don't think you'll find anybody better than that than we are. We do several things, but- I think there are two things that really come to mind that I think I'd like to say and I'd like for you all to understand. One is that we've got four decades of
134experience with school construction. We showed you we keep up with our costs. We showed you 30 years in one county how we've been under budget state average with all these schools. And the way that we do that is what I've been trying to explain with the USA system. We know that our schools are economic. We can predict fairly easily what they're going to come in at because we're using these principles again and again and again. But the second thing... That I want to say and I want you all to remember is that we're from eastern North Carolina and we know the eastern North Carolina contractors and we talk to them. We get preliminary budgets from them, people that are actually going to put in the price as we go along with the design. And we
135did it on the Beaufort School, we did it on the Quillen School. They came in right in line and we've been doing that for years and years. What is your firm's approach to tracking, responding to, and incorporating design review comments by the owner or any other reviews of each design phase? I would say my answer to that is immediate. We don't mess around with that stuff. And I'm on top of when things get sent to this man and this man and that man back there and our people. I run the traffic and Rihanna Nunley is our admin. She couldn't come. She had to pay an office and tracking things. But she keeps track of which agencies that we're going to be getting comments from. When did they go to Steve? And I'll call Steve and
136say, you got them? Yes, I got them. I said, where am I going to get them back? He sends them back, and we get them where they need to go. So we know how that works, and I will tell you that we are very good. Choose your firm approach to coordinating with contractors and providing prompt responses to RFIs, submittals. Proposal and claim evaluations, change orders, etc. throughout the construction. Same answer. I know exactly what you're talking about. But we stay after ourselves and our consultants. Because I know what happens when you don't respond to an RFI. Where there was a delay. And this caused another delay. We know how that works and we know what it's all about. And we know that it's important. I mean, you need to give an answer when you get
137a question. And I mean, some of these things I answer at 10 o'clock at night or 5 o'clock in the morning. But I know that it's important and we treat it as such. What is your firm's approach to verifying expediting project closeout and contract punch list completion? Well, that would be Mr. Edmondson right there. He's a mean man. He can be. Actually, I make him be the mean man. He's the bad cop. I'm the good cop. But we, suffice it to say, we get it done. We know it's important. Nobody wants that stuff hanging around. I'd have to say that most of our contractors understand you don't get your money until you finish the job. And I mean finish the job. And we work a lot with Thayne Smith and we coordinate our damages clauses
138with them. And it's so much if you don't finish by such a time and if you don't clean up your mess after that, it's even more. We're very determined about closeout and making sure everything's right. And of course, you know, it's also an 11-month warranty inspection. We come back if anything's broken, if anything's not working right. And then, of course, after that, I mean, our clients call us years after a project. We keep the records. We keep everything. I know what color that wall is painted. I know where to get this. And if you've got a problem, I'll come take a look at it. We stay with the ball. What is your current workload? Well, we just finished the plans on equipment. We finished the plans on buffer. We're finishing the Bertie plans in the
139next three or four weeks. And we need something to do. We need a big project. Good timing for everybody. Alright, I have a question for you. Please expand on how you would engage the community and staff to help design the school. The first meeting needs to be design the process. That's always the first meeting. Sit down with whoever Dr. Bryan says I need to sit down with and talk about. community involvement, staff involvement, how it needs to work. And we've done it all different ways. We've done it all different ways. And I want to do it the way you want to do it. But the first meeting is to design the process, design the design process, plan the design process. That's the first thing. Thank you. couple questions if the board decided to go with
140a construction management risk approach could you work within those guidelines or yes we have we have done and I know obviously with your experience with the needs-based grant, we obviously have different timelines and benchmarks we have to meet with that to align with what the expectations are with the grant. We can meet those with your firm. Absolutely. And make sure we are adhering to guidelines from the state. That's a good question. One other question out of curiosity. Have you done any work in Edgecombe County before? Yes, we have. We did the security. We've done a couple of small projects. Y'all recently did a security project, and I think that's winding down. And, Robert, we've done some small projects as far back as three years ago. Window replacement projects? At West Mill. We did a wind
141replacement project and at Carver we did a wind replacement project. during COVID. COVID was a strange time. I was principal at Carmel Elementary for about 16 years. Yes, sir. And the construction that you're talking about, I remember walking up them steps and going into the top, the part that you're talking about where they did a six-class room. extension and same type of design you know it has become very popular and jimmy we're wrapping up this to find more projects so obviously we'll combine and this came up in one of the other interviews with one of the other architects We're combining three schools into one and there was the obviously with the high school campus Would still need to have school during the process of construction. Could you talk a little bit about that process and
142staging and transitioning during all that? If you can add to that. Right. Well, we did some of that at Lake St. Peter. We had an ongoing construction project on an occupied campus. And I think at the time it might have been 1,600 students there. And so it's challenging. But we've done a number of projects. And most all of our projects, in fact, I don't think we've ever done an extensive school renovation project where kids were moved somewhere else. We're always having to work with those restrictions. So we put together phased plans. So that the phasing of the project has got to respect the movement of the students which spaces become unoccupied and for what time period while they're being renovated. Which areas are they allowed to play in when we're constructing a new building next
143door. Obviously, there's specifications and requirements that the contractors have to adhere to. There's construction fencing. There's provisions for emergency exits out of construction areas that we have to pay attention to. We've got 40 years of experience in working with construction, new construction and renovation on existing campuses that are occupied by students. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I will ask one last time to have any other questions from any of the board members. Hearing none, thank you for your presentation. Thank you very much. Thank you for having me. We thank you for bringing our team with you. Could I give you a comment before we take a question? Thank you. Madam Chair, if it's just, I may add one piece of context here. Unless there's some disagreement from the board, we put this on the
144agenda for decision at the regular board meeting on Monday. Make sure you all have time to process. That's a good idea. I have a question that will give us a little time to look into it. Mosley said they designed Principal Elementary after the flood, put the gates, the flood things, you know, things like that. Right. Vines said they did it twice. Well, the school hadn't been rebuilt, I don't think, but twice. So I'm kind of wondering who did what. You know, I mean... I just noticed we've only had, since I've been on the board, we've only had two floods. I would be building three times. I mean, having an architect three times. So that was something I questioned. We can look into that. Just to clarify that. I remember the insurance would not pay off
145until they raised that and had to come back in and do that because it was the first time it was. Not like that. Insurance that they would not pay off until we raised it so that if it happened again, all they had to do was go in and clean it up and then put those units up. You see, Vaughn said they designed it twice for both floods. And then Mosley said they designed it and put in the flaps and all those things. Would Vines have done it the second time and then we call Mosley in to add the other things to it? In the first phase they did not, somebody did not put it in. Maybe Vines didn't put it in and then FEMA said they would. They would not pay the hell of money
146and said until you put those in. We had to raise it, what, four feet? We got a different architect to do that? I'm not sure. That's the part I'm kind of. I'm confused why we wouldn't have Vines design it the second time and then they not put the flood stuff in. I just want to clarify that in my head. And that might not be... I know the reason, but I don't know who it was. Right. And I just wondered because I knew we hadn't had an architect but twice, and I just wondered if Vines was there the second time while we got Mosley to add the flats in if there was an issue. Or, just to clarify. I remember the reason, but I don't know who did it. I just wondered why we had different
147architects, that's all. That was my only question. Well, I asked the question that I asked because... Princeville was a Princeville Montessori. And I'm thinking that's the piece that Vines participated in. And then the flood came, and that's when we had to rebuild the entire school. Maybe you're right. Maybe he designed it. They designed it the first time. I know they designed it the first time. I remember that. They designed it the first time. Maybe when we had Principal Montessori, they designed it. Then it flooded. They redesigned it. And then it flooded a second time and we got Mosley to do it. That would make sense. I just was trying to figure out. but that does make sense because we did do renovations to make him okay I feel that no need to clarify that I
148just wanted to make sure there wasn't a problem with vines and mostly had to come in and put the flaps in or while we would change it but I think you I think when you said that I think you're right we did put money into the Montessori when we when we We did all the magnet programs. That's right. Yeah. I'm clear. The grant ended and we had to put money back in. You're right. And that makes me feel better. I just couldn't, in my head, put all that together. But I think you're right. Because I was on the board the whole time. My little brain just doesn't work real well. We'll rush through the other time. Okay. urgent sharing hearing none we'll move forward with our agenda item five is where we are and we
149do not have anyone signed up to speak in public comment section so we'll move to item six items for information Dr. Brown Field trip, Southwest Edgecombe High School, 1123. And then also, for your review, there'll be some mid-year graduate applicants. Typically, you ask every year. We'll need your approval on that when we get those. That's the band school. That's Southwest Band here. Yes, sir. Okay. I have for consent, you have the list of field trips there, Southwest High School 2, three of them actually in Princeville, to the zoo, and that's the list for consent. Okay. Do we have a motion? To approve our consent items It has been moved and properly seconded that we will approve our consent items as presented. Any other discussion on the motion? I will take the motion. Let me know
150by saying aye. Aye. Opposed, same sign. The motion carries. Thank you. 7.B, items for action. Mr. Hayes could not be here today, so I'm going to handle this one. This is a sole source contract for $16,019. Purpose of the contract, we're working on some computer coding, professional development for middle school staff. We're pushing Python coding into the middle school. We're working on that. We're excited about it. And we're operating the program over three years. It's provided by, funding for this is provided by PRC 065, which is coding and mobile grant. Seeking your approval for that. It's going to be a great opportunity to build the pipeline for computer coding into the high school level for Python. Thank you for sharing. We would like to hear a motion that only... include the purpose and the amount
151that is allowed part of that action item. Madam Chair, I'll make the motion to approve for the approval of the Edgecombe County Board and TEC-SMART. for the 2024-25 school years of sole source amount of $16,019 using PRC 65 coding and mobile grant funds. Second. It has been moved and properly seconded that Edgecombe County Board of Education would approve the TechSmart for 24-25 school year as a sole source in the amount of $16,019 using the PRCO65 coding and mobile grant funds. Any other discussion on the motion? All in favor of the motion let it be known by saying aye. Aye. Opposed the same sign. Hearing none the motion carries 7.2 B. I'll ask Ms. McDowell to come forward. As she's coming forward, I'll just say this is what I believe is the tradition here. The annual
152funds for child nutrition. It's come out of child nutrition funds. As you all know, child nutrition sort of runs as its own entity. within the budget. Good morning. Well, good morning. Board Chair, Dr. Wilson, Vice Chair, Board Members, and Dr. Bryant. Before you to seek approval to give the staff a bonus in December and in June. I was before you at the beginning of the last year and you approved already the one for December. But as you know, we have four additional schools. So I wanted to make sure that staff would be included also in the bonus and to go on and include gyms as well. But, you know, we have a great staff. Everybody's working short-handed and they do an exceptional job making sure that all kids are fed every day. So I think
153they are well deserving of this bonus. So I'm seeking your approval. Any questions? Right here and now. We need to hear a motion for approval. Madam Chair, I make a motion that we approve the Child Nutrition Staff Merit Bonuses to pay in December 2024 and June 2025 in the amount not to exceed $100,000. Second. It has been moved and properly seconded that we will approve our Child Nutrition Staff Merit Bonuses. to pay in December 2024 and June 2025 in the amount not to exceed $100,000. Any other discussion on the motion? All in favor of the motion, let it be known by saying aye. Aye. Opposed, the same sign. motion carries thank you very kindly thank you for your hard work you look out for your people okay we need to hear motion to go into
154closed session I make a motion under the North Carolina Open Meetings Law, sections 143-318.11a1, a3, and a6 to go into closed session to consult with the attorney to preserve attorney-client privileged information and to prevent the disclosure of student records rendered confidential under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act 20 USC. 1232G and the disclosure of personnel records rendered confidential under General Statute 115C-319 through 321. Second. It's been moved and properly seconded that we will go into closed session. Any other discussion on the motion? All in favor let it be known by saying aye. Opposed, same sign. Motion's carried. Thank you very kindly. In your pocket. This is the home screen. Tap the three horizontal lines in the bottom left to see all the menu items. To turn on push notifications, tap settings, select notification preferences,
155and allow notifications. Tap subscriptions to subscribe to your school. The events section shows a list of events throughout the school. You can use this button to add an event to your calendar, or tap here to share the event with friends and family. The feed is where you'll find updates from administration about what's going on throughout the school, whether that's celebrating a student's success or reminding you about an upcoming deadline. Search Edgecombe County Public Schools in the App Store or Play Store to explore the app for yourself. It's everything ECPS in your pocket. A question or anything that we need to discuss before I power forward motion. to adjourn. I make a motion to do. We adjourn. It has been moved and properly seconded with three people seconded. That we adjourn this meeting. All in favor
156of the motion, let it be known by saying aye. Opposed, same sign.