CorpusRecord 158939

MARSD BOE, Regular Action Meeting, 12 - 19 - 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Huskievision MARSD
Date
2024-12-27
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,119 words · about 68 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001The New Jersey Open Public Meeting Law is an action to ensure the rights of the public to have advanced notice of and to attend the meetings of public bodies at which any business affecting their interest is discussed or agreed upon. In accordance with the provisions of this act, the Matawan-Aberdeen Regional School District Board of Education advertised this meeting on June 5, 2024 in the Asbury Park Press and Star-Ledger. These notices were sent to the municipal clerks of the Borough of Matawan and the Township of Aberdeen and the Matawan-Aberdeen Public Library. These notices were also placed on the district's website. Can we please stand for the pleasure of the audience? Ms. Biles? Here. Ms. Martinez? Here. Mr. McEverett? Here. Mr. Montone? Here. Ms. Scott? Here. Ms. Farrell? Here. Ms. Warren-Pete? Here. Ms. Scully? Here. Ms. Powell?

002Here. Okay, be it resolved that a closed session be convened for the purpose of discussing privacy, personnel, and legal matters. The subject matter of these discussions will be disclosed to the public when the reason for confidentiality subsides. Although the board cannot guarantee it, the length of the executive session is estimated to be 30 minutes. Afterwards, the public meeting of the board shall reconvene and proceed with business. Action will take place. Can I have a motion and a second to go to executive session? I'll motion. I'll second. All in favor? Aye. We are in executive session. So everybody sit tight and we're going to go to the next room and then we'll be back. students in band now. I can only imagine, Mr. Wells, what the marching band will look like in the next few years.

003So again, thank you so much and have a good holiday. Mr. Wells and Mr. Aronowitz, congratulate Mr. Josh Aronowitz. We recently received notification that the Directors of Athletics Association of New Jersey has selected Mr. Aronowitz, our supervisor of athletics, for the sectional award of merit recipient representing the North 2 section. Mr. Aronowitz is being recognized for his outstanding achievements, dedication to student athletes, and professionalism throughout his career as an athletic administrator. They have acknowledged him as the Director's Association of New Jersey, so it gives me, I'm so happy and proud that you're representing the Matawan-Aberdeen Regional School District, Mr. Aronowitz. So now Mr. Wells and Mr. Aronowitz are going to recognize our state champs, our Matawan Aboriginal Regional High School. We're here to honor the band tonight. We all know they won the state championship

004and we've recognized them over the last couple of months, but really honored to be here tonight because today we're going to give them something that they can take home forever. And I want to thank the board for allowing us to do this tonight. And I'm going to call up our directors, call up his students. And like I said, we have a lot of marching band, future athletes, which I call them, who aren't athletes, a varsity ladder. You're going to get your state championship sweatshirt tonight, March event members. Congratulations again. Good evening, everyone. My name is Noel and I'm the director over at High School Cuisine. Marching Band this year had a wildly successful season. We are so pleased to announce, yes, they got state champs. We got second in the nation at Allentown J-Burg from

005Stadia. So by one point. So we got a score of a 95 at the end of the season. We had a massively successful season. show this year so we're really happy about all of that. Also, we announced, not announced, sorry, we also got recognition lately, we also bumped up a class. So we got bumped to what we call open class, so it's a lot more competition, a lot more festivities to go along with that. So really successful. We're growing the marching band. We're growing the band program up at the high school. Mr. Smada up at the high school is doing a great job with the concert band, and we're really excited to be here. So thank you. Now let's see who read the Google Classroom and showed up. Jacob Marcotta. Ben Bellisi, Henry F. Fines,

006Jack Convery, Kaylee Fedico, Jordan Williams, Dylan Casillas, James, Michelle Merriffel, Dave Priachko, Addison Levieri, Liam Schmankowski. So a portion of our marching band. All of the wind players and most of the percussion players are here tonight. Our guard is currently practicing for their upcoming competition that they have. So a lot of them couldn't be here tonight, but we also got a bunch of concerts for them. So they got first in the nation and first in the state with the inspection award. So we're really proud of them. Thank you. Alright, one, two, three. One, two, three. Thank you. To begin, Mr. Wells would like to thank all the donors of the MIRC CARES Winter Wonderland Holiday Feast to support families in need within our community this holiday season. Mr. Wells would also like to congratulate both

007our 2024 Educator and Educational Services Professional of the Year, Dr. Neil Jackman and Ms. Amanda Longo. The Mattawan Regional High School Student Personnel Services Department is excited to announce our College of Career Planning Series for Parenting Students. Please join us on Tuesday, January 28th for an Understanding Financial Aid workshop, and on Tuesday, March 11th for our College and Career Fair and FAFSA Assistance informational workshop. Both sessions will take place at the high school beginning at 7 p.m. This past Tuesday was our Winter Band and Chorus concert, which was a great success with many students involved. Last year, the Matawan Aberdeen Educational Foundation graciously funded a grant for the initiative Husky's Closet. This grant allowed for the purchase of paint, clothing racks, organizational materials, and prom dresses. Husky's closet is currently managed by the Women's Empowerment

008Club at our high school, and they are collecting donations of clothing, household items, and toiletries. They are also currently looking to connect with families in need. Another fundraiser is coming up this weekend. Please support our Making for Life team at their 18th annual bake sale tomorrow, December 20th, 7-10pm, Saturday, December 21st, 1-10pm, and Sunday, December 22nd, 12-3pm at AMF's Drathmore Leeds. This bake sale, led by Wendy Levy, is raising funds for a Drathmore student in medical need. We are also supporting the Making Headway Foundation for Children with Brain Tumors and the Jamie Levy Memorial Scholarship for Volunteerism and Community Service at MRHS. Students across all grades work together to make goods and work with Sally and Jere. We hope to see you there. I'll be there. The MRHS PTO is still accepting membership for the

0092024-2025 school year. Membership is essential in funding programs, improving our school, and assisting teachers and students with the resources they need to be successful. Thank you for your support. Cambridge Park students and staff were excited to welcome the month of December. It's the most wonderful time of the year at Cambridge Park Elementary. On December 3rd and 4th, over 300 parents attended conferences to hear the latest updates from teachers and specialists on how their children are performing in school. Cambridge Park also held its second annual book fair, which raised over $7,000. This money will be used to purchase books for all classrooms to support the pre-K and kindergarten curriculum. A special thank you to the Cambridge PTO, Mrs. Ripple, who organized the event, Mrs. Alvarez, and Mrs. Barrow for setting up the wonderful scholastic books. The

010students really enjoyed shopping. During the week of December 16th to 19th, parents and guardians attended the annual winter sing-along during the students' music classes. This wonderful event was organized by Ms. Amanda and Mrs. Grafani. Thank you to all who attended. Thank you to all the Cambridge Park parents and staff who generously donated to the MARSD Cares event and the Cambridge Park PTO toy truck. This month, the students and staff enjoyed a bash of the trash assembly and a special visit from Frosty the Snowman. On behalf of the students and staff at Cambridge Park Elementary, Principal Barrow would like to wish everyone a happy holiday and a wonderful new year. Happy 2025. December has been a festive month at Ravine Drive Elementary School. They are wrapping up their holiday school spirit week, which started with toasty

011toes and comfy clothes, and is wrapping up tomorrow with festive holiday wear. Their holiday shop was yesterday and Tuesday. Students were overjoyed with the opportunity to buy items for their loved ones prior to Christmas, Hanukkah, and Kwanzaa next week. Ravine wishes everyone a restful and relaxing holiday and new year and hopes you have the opportunity to spend time with the people you are closest with. At Strathmore, students enjoyed the annual PTO holiday shop last week. Strathmore wishes all families a great winter break. Cliffwood would like to extend a heartfelt thank you to all of the students and families who attended the Aberdeen tree lighting. It was truly a magical evening and it was so uplifting to see the joy on the children's faces as they sang holiday songs. Their festive spirits spread happiness throughout the

012night and Cliffwood is grateful to have been part of such a special community event. They also had a wonderful turnout at parent-teacher conferences last week. It was fantastic to see so many people and to continue building the strong homeschool connection that is so vital to student success. Thank you for your ongoing support in shaping a positive and enriching learning experience for our young girls. In addition, we are thrilled to share that Matthew Wong, a senior at Mattawan Regional High School, recently visited Clipbook to present four different flag designs he created for the school. Matthew spent an afternoon with Clipbook students explaining the meaning behind each of his designs and teaching them fun facts about the history and significance of flags. Afterwards, he was voted on their favorite design and we are excited to announce that

013we have a winner. The flag is currently being made. And once it arrives, Matthew will return to Cliffwood to present the flag. Cliffwood will proudly raise it on their school's flagpole as a symbol of the community's spirit. They will keep you posted on the date and we would love for you to join in celebrating this wonderful moment. Cliffwood had a successful PTO winter party on the 13th in their cafeteria. It was a festive night filled with music, games, a basket raffle, prizes, and photos with Santa. They were especially excited this year to offer a sensory room and a more relaxed photo experience with Santa, ensuring all students could enjoy the evening. Finally, the Cliffwood PTO organized a family dinner night at the new Viva Margarita restaurant on December 16th. The restaurant generously offered 25% of

014proceeds to benefit the Cliffwood Elementary PTO. Cliffwood thanks the community for their continued support and wishes everyone a wonderful holiday season and a joyous new year. Lloyd Road Elementary School held their Winter Chill event last week sponsored by their PTO. It was a great night for students that included hot cocoa, winter craft activities, candy inspired games, and more. A big shout out to the Lloyd Road PTO for all of their hard work and support. Lloyd Road students and staff are enjoying Holiday Spirit Week this week with fun activities and themes that include dressing like your favorite holiday characters, holiday hat day, ugly sweaters, and wearing your favorite holiday colors to spread some cheer. Lloyd Road Elementary School is once again partnering with the Scripps for a school spelling bee. All students receive their grade level

015spelling bee study list and classroom spelling bee will take place when we return from break in January. The winners of the classroom spelling bees will have the opportunity to participate in Lloyd Road School Spelling Bee that will take place at a grade level. The final winner of the Lloyd Road School Spelling Bee will have the opportunity to participate in the Scripps Regional Spelling Bee Leader this spring. Lloyd Road wishes all families a happy holiday and we send Our best wishes for a happy, healthy, and joyous new year. MAMS held its winter concerts recently. Students in the band and chorus performed over two nights with seasonal music selections. As usual, attendees were impressed by MAMS students' musical talents. Thanks to everyone who attended these events. Ma'am's family did a great job of donating toys for Toys

016for Tots. Congrats to Mrs. Taleo and Mrs. Pecorino's advisory class for collecting the most toys and winning the cookies and hot cocoa party. Thanks to student council who did a great job of organizing this fundraiser event. NJHS and student council will be holding a Winter's Wishes student faculty basketball game on January 15th at 5 p.m. This event will benefit the Make-A-Wish Foundation. Students can sign up for a five-person team during lunches starting this Wednesday. This is always a fun event for our school students and staff. This concludes my report. Thank you. I'll turn it over to the tenure celebrations for December. Okay, so we have two folks receiving tenure. Unfortunately Mrs. Nielsen was unable to be here tonight but she received tenure here in December. But we do have a continuation of celebration for Sam

017Veen who I'm gonna read a little bit about. So first of all let's give another round of applause for Dr. Armadillo. I just wanna get it to his next line. What's up? Mr. Levine is a teacher of music at Lloyd Road Elementary School. He's a passionate educator who wholeheartedly loves seeing his students excited about music, singing songs, and learning the history of the various genres of music. He gets special joy from hearing students sing in the hallways the songs that they learn in class, just as we did tonight. Mr. Levine graduated from Rutgers University. University George Mason, I'm sorry Mason girls. I'm sorry Mason's bra school of the arts It is there where you continue to hone his craft and further explore the magic of music Sam is currently continuing his educational journey at Rowan

018University where he studies for his master's degree When he isn't working hard with our Lord Broad students, road students, Sam enjoys doing jigsaw puzzles and other crossword puzzles. When it comes to travel, Mr. Levine enjoys traveling to places such as Ireland, Atlantic City, and of course, the Jersey Shore. A favorite food that he loves to enjoy is bangles. Locks. Anything. All of everything. Sam speaks highly of his fourth grade teacher, Cheryl Metz, and his high school vocal teacher, Susan Connors. These teachers encouraged him to believe in himself and celebrate his many qualities. It was through their guidance that he learned patience, creativity, and how to create a community-based classroom. A quote that Mr. Levine lives by is, life is good. Let's give another Lloyd Rhodes applause for Mr. Levine. Thank you so much. Actually, before

019we go into the strategic plan report, I just wanted to say greetings and happy holidays to all. Over the last two weeks, we've had the opportunities to visit schools, attend events like the play at the high school and with the concerts, some winter activities, and even some of our leaders were dressing up, particularly the one at Cliffwood. She was dressed up as an elf and riding a little tricycle to every single classroom all week long, so she's very tired. All this is done in the spirit of the season. It's an absolute wonderful opportunity to showcase talented students and staff. A heartfelt thank you to all who volunteered or donated to support our families during the holiday season through MARC Cares and Making Winter Wonderland a success. We're so appreciative. It was an absolutely beautiful event.

020While it is a great time for many during this holiday season, we also recognize others may be experiencing some challenging times during the holiday season. Please know the district is here to support families and be sure to check our website for any community resources now and during the holidays. even when we're at Wafaa break. I want to thank the parents for completing the lunch applications and thank the board members for continuously pushing parents and getting the word out there the importance of the lunch applications. I'm completing them as it supports our budget. This year we had an increase in completed applications by 159 students. So in terms of school security update, we met with the private contractor, as I mentioned at the last board meeting, specifically discussion and the proposal was for class three officers.

021We will be looking to finalize the contract and start effective February. More details to follow, and I'll share more with the board in terms of the details and the finances. Our school security is able to support Ms. Leo's through private. I do want to thank both chiefs for providing input and support and we will continue to collaborate with the PP to ensure school safety. And this is actually, and it's on the board agenda this evening. Our continued collaboration is. is throughout the memorandum of agreement this evening where we have to work with our police chiefs and the department. The MOA outlines mandatory reporting to law enforcement with things such as possession of controlled substances on school grounds, firearms, sexual offenses, bias-related incidents, planned or threatened violence, and potentially missing, abused, or neglected children. So although

022it did not work out in terms of... collaborate in terms of the partnership and the town support with funding we do anticipate we obviously are still continuing to work with them At this time I'm going to ask Mr. Liebman to go over our strategic plan scorecard and I'd also like to thank Mr. Liebman for expanding it and kind of getting into great detail on it. I'm really excited and I hope the board is happy with how this is going to turn out as we discussed it at the last board meeting. While we may not have a lot of information on here, what it will look like by 2030 is really exciting and I anticipate a lot of work in progress with the district. Thank you. Thank you, Mrs. Perez. So if you would take a

023moment, you have at the dais the scorecard, the two pages, colored sheets. I'll take that. You also have the electronically effects. These you can take a look at. So what I'll do first is explain the organization of it and then we'll get into some of the... how the data comes to us and then what the data actually looks like. So the district scorecard, this is first, it's a draft. So what we're looking at now is a snapshot of the data that we currently have accessible to us. By the time we get to the end of the school year, we'll do this again and we'll have this school year filled in so that way in July we can post this on the district website and our community can see what a full year snapshot's going to

024look like. We're giving you a preview of it. So in terms of organization, it's broken into nine sections. So the white fog over the black cells. So those are the nine sections that are reflected in our current strategic plan. So that's important to know that what we're really looking at is the strategic plan, which is a 60-page narrative. We've broken it down into qualitative measures. So you can really start to see... what that action plan looks like and how we progress through it year by year. And if we're successful in meeting goals, if we're on target, or if we're not, you'll be able to see it. If you go to the second page, the bottom of the second page. There's a color key and so the color key is really important because if you don't

025want to dive into the actual numbers of data you can just look at it and you can see how the colors progress through each of the columns of the rows. So if you were to see a blue box it means that we have met or exceeded a goal. If the green box means that we're on track to meet the goal so we're showing the progress. The yellow is the track map. You see the yellow, that's a caution or a warning where we haven't fallen fast, but we're not quite far enough yet to make progress. So we're monitoring, we're keeping an eye on that particular indicator. Red would show that we have regressed or we have not made progress. And then the orange represents the baseline data. So that's the starting point. So that's the organization

026pieces without the colors look like what colors mean and you can see just again at a quick glance going from left to right that there is a baseline of school year 22-23 and then as you move towards the right it takes us all the way to 2030. The idea that we're looking at so many years over an expansive period of time is to take us through the current strategic plan which brings us to 2027 in its current edition. And then this would bridge us to the next strategic plan which would get us at least at a minimum 2030 and then beyond. What we're going to share with the board when we have the final data for this year, we're going to show you the revised strategic plan in a one-page document. So it's going to

027talk about mission, values, goals, all in one piece that supports this document. So now we'll take a closer look at what some of the data actually looks like. And instead of reading through the notes, I'm just going to share with you where the data comes from. And you're going to start to recognize, oh yeah, we've heard this before, or we know when we've heard this in parts of the years. A lot of this data is seasonal. So the first one, under student success, the reading on level by the start of grade three. So you'll see that there's no data at the moment, and that's on purpose. So this will reflect progress that students in grades K through 2 as they work through foundations and phonics. You heard me talk about that the past couple of

028years. So because it's being reintroduced this school year, we're really creating the baseline this year. So moving forward, when we start to measure the success of foundations and phonics, we will start to fill that data in. the next couple under student success so algebra one for high school and algebra one for middle school when i have presented in october state reporting those tests assessment results come from the october report students who are graduating and life ready you heard mr wells present this in september school links former Naviance. School Links is a program that we use with our high school students and one of the components of School Links it assesses career aptitude. It's a career interest inventory, that's one piece, but career aptitude is equally or if not more important. Because it's our first year

029using School Links, this year will be the baseline for that data. Alright, then the last one in that section, students graduating, college career technical ready, that's our graduation rate. So you actually heard me present that in July for the previous year. That data at the moment is embargoed but will be released in April and that way when we see this at the end of the year that data will be included for last school year. Alright so section two is curriculum, instruction, accountability. Almost all of this comes from the October presentation that I do for the board of state assessment data. It's actually posted on our district website so anybody at any point can see that October presentation. You can see where the data come from. towards the bottom of the same section. So section number

030two, students who are enrolled in advanced courses, AP, and that is students taking AP assessments. So you can see that we have baseline data. Students who are enrolled in advanced courses are actually trending in a very good direction, which means that there are more course offerings and more students are taking advanced courses. That's good news. The number of students taking the AP test, you can see that's reflected in blue. So we met or exceeded our goal, so we may want to actually look at that goal and if we want to raise that or not. And then work-based learning participation, that's also a school-based program, so this is the first year of that data. Item number three is student engagement. The first 1% of students in extracurricular activities. So we do keep track at the middle

031school and high school of students who participate in clubs and sports, interviewer sports, varsity level sports. This is the first time that we're actually collecting the data to report out. So we did create a baseline data. At the moment it's showing us students who have signed up. It doesn't always reflect active participation, so we're going to work on that piece to really get numbers to see from the fall who participated in extracurricular activities. So that number will be tweaked a little bit as we get better data. The next one, percent of students, ISS, OSS, so the board, you see every month, you see suspension reports, so all we needed was collect each of the 10 months and put it into one particular number. So that's data that you already have access to. percent of students

032with lunch participation, so we just heard the press speak about that. And then the last one on this page, percent of student attendance. So we have a goal of 90% of our students attending school 90% of the time. So we are trending in the right direction. However, you're going to hear a lot more about student attendance from me at the January RAMP, where I talk about our... Corrective action plans for chronic absenteeism so not back into that now you'll have more information with you'll ever want when I represent that in January On to the second page so technology. We're looking at a couple of components of technology building at the moment. We're still mining that information Number five under personnel, position vacancy rate. So every month we keep a list of open positions and at

033the end of the year we close out vacancies based on who we have hired and then we roll vacancies over to the next year. So we do keep that report. So that's where that information comes from. It's an internal report. The next one, number of employees with five plus years of experience. So that's based on the rehire list, which the board has access to. And then the last section, participation of staff in our staff morale survey. So that's something that we've been doing in the district now for a few years. And that gives staff an opportunity to give feedback in terms of staff morale. So how they're perceiving their role in the district and how we can improve their experience here as employees. We do track that data. The next one's going to be issued

034when we get back to winter break. And so we'll have that data for you in the spring. Number six, community engagement and communication. So this is a new one and so this is encouraging the amount of exposure that we have through social media, the district website, community forums. So partnering with the district communications. Again, this is the first year this year we're doing that so it's going to be the baseline for this year. Number seven is for operations and maintenance looking at completed work orders. So we do have a software program that can keep track of that for us. So we're working through that data. We'll have that in the spring. Number eight, financial audits. So you heard a little bit about that. This evening you'll hear more about that next month. And number nine,

035which is SEL, mental health and wellness for students. Number 9.1, that's the percent of in-founded. The board has access to that each month. And then a physical security audit, that's something that I do as my role as security supervisor. So each spring, we do that audit, and I'll have updated statistics for that. So that's the organization, that's the overview of data. We'll dive a lot more into what the numbers mean when we have all the data for the June meeting. Ms. Gross? I was just wondering, Mr. Liebman, under college and career readiness with foundations coming in, wouldn't, please correct me if I'm wrong, couldn't we do a baseline now so we know that, is there something at the beginning of the school year to even know we needed foundations to see how it grows? Because

036why would after foundations a year have that be our baseline? So we do a universal screener. So students have already been assessed. That was in September. When we come back in January, they take the next part of that benchmark. So we could use the data from the universal screener to the benchmark from September to January. We could use that to create an average and have that as our baseline. So when we report out in June, we could have that particular data component. But you didn't so educationally is there a reason not to I just think we're so hopeful about what the program is going to do for us I would think you'd want that. I mean just what's your thoughts on why you didn't do that initially? There's got to be a reason. I know

037everything you do is a reason. There is. So there's a couple pieces to it. So we'll have that information, but we have teachers who are still being trained on foundations as that program progresses through. That's the first piece of it. The second piece of it is we want to take a look and see comparing... class to class so we have it in three different grade levels kindergarten first grade and second grade we want to be able to see what that data looks like individually is that the best way to report out on it or do we look at it collectively as an elementary component report out as a three grade levels so we have the data but how do we present it best in this particular forum so that's the decision that the team looks

038at along with our directors and our cabinet what's the best way to present that data So we have a whole bunch of numbers at the moment. What's the best way to go disaggregate it? I just have such high hopes for the program, switching and investing in it. So I'd love to see where it was and where we go rather than using that as a baseline that I may be completely off because I don't know. You let us know. Yes, we will. Thank you. Can I ask a couple of questions? Overall, I love this. It's so much information in one spot. To me, this is like a dream. So I think this is great. It makes me very happy. One thought, when we're talking about percent of students taking AP exams, I think it's helpful to

039understand how many are passing as well. I think it's actually pretty high, the number. But it's just helpful for us to understand how effective those classes are. I was just attacking on, do we have data on who gets the three and above? We do. And what I can do is in July, when I present on NJGPA, that's the high school assessment, I can also present AP data with that. That would be helpful. So I can just add another couple of slides to that presentation and you'll have the full picture. Because a lot of teachers do it at... I think it's back to school night where they present. And it's pretty impressive when you see the numbers. Some of these classes, I mean, they have a pretty high percentage of kids that are passing. So just

040a thought. Yes, very high. So I'll share that with the board as well. Perfect. And then I know, obviously, we've seen this data before. As soon as you put it in color, I don't know why, it brings everything to life, visually seeing it. So when I see the yellows and the reds in the, well there's only one red, so that's good. But the grades, the elementary up through eighth grade, particularly the literacy. So this is 23-24 data. So we've already obviously planned for 24-25, incorporating this, I'm assuming. So we don't have the next round of information until October 2025. Right. So when we develop our budget this year, I'm assuming hopefully we've made some progress this year, but we may still want to continue the momentum here. So, like, that's what I love about this

041chart is, like, when I look at it and I see the yellows and reds. When we think about budget and choices that have to be made like to me, it's like right there You know like sure yeah, and I'll give you a little bit inside that particular section a couple of things at the first Don't be afraid of that yellows and the reds especially for early on. It's early in the morning It's okay because that will show us growth over time if we see reds and yellows Later on, that's going to be a concern. Later on, being 27, 28, 29, that's where it becomes a bigger concern. So it's okay to see some of that here. For this particular section... We don't have the info, the board doesn't give the information until October. We get

042it in August, still way beyond budget. We get it in August, it's embargoed for the public until October. However, when we give I-Ready assessments, that's aligned to the standards, the same standards that are assessed here. So we actually get previews at its very, within statistical points, very, very close to these results. So we do kind of... That's good. It's engaged so we can kind of feel out how things are working, what needs to be... Because even as you're writing curriculum in the, you know, summer, you know, potentially those areas may be, you know, where we need to focus more. So just a thought. But thank you. I love this. May I ask a quick question? We won't have more information until October 2025 on certain areas here, I see. But is it possible to get,

043like... a snippet of what's happening sooner than that. Because that's a whole year from now. So that's great for us to see in the scorecard, but do we get to see like half the year? And if any of these numbers have improved? Because this is like, I'm talking real time. What's happening versus assessing it another year from now and looking at a scorecard? Because the kids are every day going to school. What are we doing? I know we have action plans in place. But can we break it down so we can see if there's been improvement in a six-month period? versus an entire year? I don't know. Is that... The short answer is no. Because we're talking that particular section. That's based on NJSLA. And so if you were to have a conversation with teachers,

044they would want the exact same thing. They would want to have real-time input from that assessment. And it's gotten better over the years. It used to be months and months, or sometimes not at all, getting accurate data. The DOE has shortened that window to where this is probably the best we're ever going to get it. if we're looking at just this particular section of that particular assessment. We do have our own in-house programs that can give you what you're looking for. So if we find, we get through this year, the feedback from the board, feedback from our staff is, can we look at this and speed up the data with our own in-house measures? The answer is yes. We'll share it. We'll give you a little insight with the board now. So Mrs. Perez and

045I have been embedded in this work for months and months. We've gone to trainings, trainings have come into the district with our principals. In the next year, our principals will be doing a building scorecard. That's where you're going to start to see at the building level, which will be made public, at the building level we're going to see things a little bit more specific. Where you I think that's what you would want to see in terms of faster results and how you can see that faster We need to deliver periods of time months No, I appreciate that because this is this is great. This is very informative But like like my brain is processing what's happening now versus the prediction. So Overall to look at it year by year. This is awesome. This is an

046excellent tool but again what are we doing day by day by day or month or in a six month period so that's that's great to know that that's in the future and i'm sure we have action plans in place even though these numbers are very close to being in the orange or the green um i'd love to see that there yes next year okay thank you so when we do our strategic updates it shall happen again in the spring and then at the end of the year that we report out to the board in public, what we could look at is to see those assessments that we have in-house because they could be predictors to what you're going to preview or we can expect in October. It's not 100%, but like those I-readies will be

047an indicator of what a student may perform at JSLA. So, you know, we could share that information, but knowing that the caveat is not always with 100% certainty, but we have an idea in terms of how kids are going to perform. Thank you. Thank you. Can I ask another question? Um, Millie, I think this is addressed to you because it's about the staff morale survey. When you presented to us, what everything you were doing was so phenomenal, and I'm wondering why only 38 percent responded? Was there something... I know in my experience sometimes people don't feel like it's anonymous or like do you have any, like it's about staff morale and yet people aren't willing to share about staff morale to make it better. Do you have any sense of what's behind that 38% and

048why it's not higher? So some of them, exactly what you said, that some of them, some staff members still believe that it's not anonymous. So we do work with Mr. Barocca in terms of, you know, he gets the word out there that it is and we try. The 38% is actually higher than what we originally, had our first go around so we're hoping that you know now we're going to be administering a survey in january so we're hoping that that'll be a higher increase you know we want more and we want more feedback um we have been in our go around with staff around particularly like so in the fall we went out to the buildings for um you know the staff will come in to meet with us like for coffee or whatever volunteer

049basis before they arrive to school or maybe after school And so we've been getting collective feedback from there. So that's more of a, I guess, kind of like the qualitative because it's conversations, discussion, and just kind of keeping an open door. So that's been helpful because even though it's 38 while it's low, the value in those discussions is obviously really beneficial to us in terms of where we're going. So you feel really comfortable with the qualitative data you've been getting to make change even though it's not showing up in a survey? Correct. Yes. Yes. They're not answers, and you know, what they bring up are not answers, quick fixes, but they are in terms of like particularly like going into budget, there are definitely things that they are sharing that we know, okay, we're on

050the same page, what priority is, where their concerns lie, so they feel free, and that you wouldn't capture in the staff not serving. And nor would they share that because they don't think that it's, you know, so they feel like just talking about it and then walking away is okay too. So it's kind of strange, but. Thank you. I just have a quick question about the categories. So these are categories that we as a district, the administration has determined we're going to use to measure ourselves against or at least coming from say the state or? I think it's a strategic plan. Oh, from the strategic plan. And then so we are doing another strategic plan. So these will still remain those key measurements? We, the admin team, think that they should because they, especially if

051we're just trending and we're not meeting target, we think that they should remain the same. But I think that's a discussion that we'll have to have as we get closer to the strategic plan, this current one ending. Which a lot, and Mr. Lina mentioned this about the training that we've been going to with our provider, EAB, they even have different thoughts in terms of strategic planning. that is a little bit different than school for us in terms of timeline. So we're not necessarily doing a five-year plan. We're doing a three-year plan. So then you can change, you know, it's achieved, it's not, and you move forward and it's under the three-year. Like one of these, you know, some of these we're going to achieve well before the end of this five-year plan. Right. So if

052you do, so those are some of the discussions that we're having. And we're learning a little bit more in terms of that. And when we get ready to... When we are getting towards the end of the current five-year plan, that's the community is involved in that strategic planning. So I'm hoping that we can make sure that they, whoever comes to those strategic planning meetings and gets involved, you know, some of this is, they're going to have to do some homework, I guess, just to know, like, you know, what we want to, what our goals should be for the next five years or at least three. Agreed. And not to get out of the strategic planning rabbit hole, I'm sure Yemi was suggesting this possibly too, is that typically when you have a strategic plan where

053you're heading towards the next planning phase and you have goals that have not been met yet, that's the first presentation to the people doing the strategic plan is here's some ones that the administration or whoever recommends that needs to be carried forward. That's definitely the first part of it. Are there any other questions about the strategic? District's core priorities. Okay, seeing none, we'll move to, thank you so much. We do have a couple of business items back on the agenda, a little further up. Can I have a motion and a second to accept the minutes as presented? I'll second. Can I? Yes, okay. Ms. Files? Yes. Ms. Martinez? Yes. Mr. McGovern? Yes. Mr. Montone? Yes. Ms. Scott? Yes. Ms. Farrell? Yes. Ms. Warneke? Yes. Ms. Scully? Yes. Ms. Powell? Yes. I have a motion and

054a second to accept the correspondence as listed in the packet. I motion. I'll second. Do we have a vote? Ms. Files? Yes. Yes. Mr. McGovern? Yes. Mr. Montone? Yes. Ms. Scott? Yes. Ms. Brown? Yes. Ms. Warnke? Yes. Ms. Scully? Yes. Ms. Bell? Yes. Okay, I have a short board presence report. This is the last meeting of the year, and I want to wish all of you happy holidays. Hopefully you had time to rest, relax with your families, or have time, excuse me, I don't know how to get it. Rest, relax with your families, eat all the goodies, and enjoy some celebrations. Very quickly, I'd like to review some notable achievements of this board and administration in 2024. This won't take forever, I swear. One, through Mrs. Scholey's leadership and the help of Ms. Perez in

055this case, the negotiations committee consisting of Mrs. Scholey, Ms. Pylos, Ms. Martinez, and myself negotiated a new contract with the MARA in record time. Two, with Ms. Case's efforts and the tireless work and patience of the whole board and all of admin, our district was able to adopt a budget that may not make everyone happy all of the time, but it works for our district and, as we saw this year around the state, could have been a much more difficult experience. I think that does mean a lot to me. So through this Martinez's leadership and the help of Dr. Rawls and admin the policy committee Consisting of this Martinez and super gopher miss rule and this morning key developed a policy to minimize the impacts of cell phones during school day supporting our students academic

056and mental health The board communication that started with a social media page by Mrs. Scholey last year blossomed into a robust combination of social media messaging by Ms. Warnicke and a community newspaper column by Ms. Scott, building the board's reputation as the source for accurate and complete information about district happenings and what we do as a board. So thank you guys. Starting a few years ago and certainly ramped up last year into this year, every member participated in an aggressive schedule of training, resulting in our board achieving certified board recognition by the New Jersey School Board Association. So everybody deserves a round of applause. This is by no means an exhaustive list. And through it all, we continue to review and approve hundreds of action items, celebrated the district's wins with another few celebrated tonight,

057mourned the loss of friends and community members, said goodbye to retirees and hello to new hires, watched preschoolers ride tricycles into their gym, and watched high school graduates throw their caps in the air. So 2024 is just a year, but it was pretty amazing. Thank you. Now business, business. Can we go to the curriculum and instruction agenda? Thank you. The following recommendations are for action this evening. We recommend for the board to approve, A, travel as listed on the travel agenda. B, under B other, we're recommending the board to approve field trips that are listed on the bottom of page one and onto page two. This includes some revised field trips and some new field trips. On page 2 of 3 under item number 2, we recommend to the board to approve the school safety

058and security annual review statement of assurances for the 24-25 school year. Item number 3 on page 3, we're recommending to the board to approve the seating for our high school baseball team to travel to Delaware for preseason games. Item number 4 for our high school wrestlers to attend the state wrestling tournament that's in Atlantic City. Item number five, to approve the number of agreements between the district and Aberdeen Township Police Department. And number six, the memorandum of agreement between the district and the Mattawan-Virgo Police Department. That concludes curriculum and instruction. And I have a motion and a second to accept the curriculum and instruction endeavor. I motion. I second. Do we have any discussion on this? Really? Okay. Seeing none. Can we move to student services? Under Student Services, we're asking the Board to approve

059the following action items this evening. Item number one, this is a revision for a student who had district placement. Item number two, we're recommending that the student for added district placement for 24-25. Item number three, to approve the agreement with the provider as listed under number three. Item number four, to approve the following band-aid side instruction for the students as listed. on page two item number five for us to the board to approve the agreement with the YMCA of Raritan Bay item number six for us to approve the agreement with Planet Fitness as listed and item number seven is a revision for Keys Academy tuition for students that includes student services can I have a motion and a second to accept the student services agenda all motion all second do we have any discussion I

060have a question about how the Planet Fitness memberships were arranged or communicated. They do a lot of community things like I know in the summer they give free memberships if you have a student. I know that it's like a happy-for-membership. I'm just wondering if there was any thought or effort to try to get them to donate to those memberships. If I could add on to what you're saying, I'm a Planet Fitness member myself. I pay a $50 membership fee and $10 a month. So for a school, when they get free membership over the summer, this seems like it's not a fair price for us. I mean, it's not much. We're not talking about much money, but just what you're saying, when we look at it, it seems like it's not a fair price for us.

061We can bring that back and address that as well. And if this is a program that could be something that we want to expand and with that opportunity perhaps come up. And then I just had a question. I put it in my questions I sent in but I don't think it was changed. Under the first the Kingsburg school district the tuition, the total cost under cost and then underneath the rationale don't match. I think they should. Right. Shouldn't it be because all the other ones match or is it not to exceed? It's the tuition plus the counseling services. So the services can exceed 5625, but if services are, say, not rendered due in absence or something, it would be plus that. So there's two separate things. Correct. It's just listed as tuition, but it's actually

062tuition plus counseling. Right, so the tuition is 23, and then sessions. Got it. So the 5625 is actually separate. Perfect. Any other questions? What are we going to do about that for the vote? Are we going to vote on this and then discuss it and see if they'll do something next time or is this we're going to talk about going back to them now for this? My recommendation would be for next time but that only means I'm going to vote for the board. I'm okay with that. I just wanted to make sure I knew what we were voting on. Nice listening. Okay, thank you. Any other questions? Seeing none, to the personnel agenda. Thank you. The board has all the items that I'm asking you to take action. Item number one, we have under termination

063and appointing number listed. Item two, we have legal absences listed. Some were omitted from our last floor meeting. And item three, we have appointments as listed. And item two, we have an administrative leave as listed. That concludes the personnel walk-in items. From our regular agenda for personnel, we have items that we are asking for action. We have items A and B, resignation and retirements, as listed. There is a retirement that is amended in A, and then we have two resignations listed. Item B, leaves of absence, as listed with and without pay. which go from page one to page three. Item C, we have appointments and new hires. Item two, we have breath instruction, special program for DSL, funded nights. On page four of 10, we have extracurricular activities. Item three is listed, which includes our

064unified sports, our hourly activities as listed, the Lord Road School for one-to-one aides. Item four, we have instructional assistants and substitute teachers as listed. And item five, we have home instruction with which list, I'm sorry, from page five to page number eight. I'm sorry, page number seven. On page number six, we have staff array changes, which includes overloads. Some have been amended, as you can see. to cover leaves of absences. On page 9 of 10, we have a continuation of those overloads. And on page 7, we have college observers as listed. On page 10 of 10, we have item 8, we have volunteers as listed for the middle school and high school. And then the other, we have if three reported incidents were confirmed. from november 14 2024 and then we have items two which

065is moving compensation items three addition to pay and finally item four affirmative action team member addition based on the registration that includes the personnel agenda and a motion a second to accept the first person personnel agenda no motion second I know I had mentioned in the questions, and I'm not sure if I read the answer, so I apologize. I just, on resignations, how come this one person is there a day? Is that right? Am I looking at this right? Yes, you are correct. Okay. And this other gentleman is only three months or did they move or I mean like do we I'm assuming we always do an exit interview. Yes. So we know. Yes. Okay. We do. And you can see later on the agenda he's listed that person is listed also later in the

066agenda. Okay. As a volunteer. Oh, okay. And then as I always I had that head. written in the questions and I say this every month very concerning the leaves and the amount of times that the leaves are I Understand people get sick people have babies medical whatever But these are I've never seen I have to say I could probably say never seen an agenda where I have where there's multiple months For multiple people so it's concerning to me Not only for the continuity of the classroom or for what these teachers are doing, but we're tirelessly trying to save money, save money, save money. And then when you have people that are out, that's a lot. It's just, it's frustrating. So, again, I know some people have to be out, whatever. It just seems like all

067of a sudden there's a lot of months in here. So I just ask, like, What do we do for coverage for months if we can't find subs? Well, a lot of the overloads that you see, which again goes back to your original concern with the finance, those overloads are for those coverages. And sometimes you see amendments and changes to those so that we spread them out so that we aren't. you know for me other speakers out yes yes so um it is a challenge um but we are we're definitely aware of it and trying our best and we're you know we're going through the process to make sure that they're all above board right perfect thank you you're welcome um home instructions so i know we have a lot here is that typical for this

068time of year i feel like it is but i'm just going to ask it just in case It varies, but it is typical as you get deeper into the year. I mean the good news is that we're doing more in-house coverage. Which is great. So we're saving money from that standpoint. Yes. And students are able to see our staff at Bridges. And also just remember when we talk about home instruction it does include discipline but also students who may be out on medical. So. Is the sprinkling of both? Yes. Or is it heavy on behavioral or heavy on medical or is it kind of a combination? It's a combination and you'll usually like on the mental health side you typically see a spike November, December and January. Yes. Okay. Thank you. Are there any other

069questions or comments about the personal agenda? I just wanted to say that I'm not seeing that many long-term needs of absences, but with the ones that we are seeing, I'm really happy for those families that are having babies or need to take leave for their family and those who can be covered medically and be able to safely come back to their jobs. Thank you. Okay, any other questions or comments about personnel? Same comment. Can we do the policy agenda? Thank you. We have a policy for first read and we have a policy for second read on the agenda. And I will go through the first read first. And policy under maintenance and repair. It's a minimal change in this policy. One of the key changes is including updated code, administrative code. Another key change in

070this policy was that it was mandated for all school districts that there's a requirement to employ a certified educational facility manager, which was a key update to policy 7410. Moving on to policy... by law 0131. Key in this, well, A, regulation was added to this policy. Term regulation was not the original policy. The second important piece was giving the board the pleasure to abolish a policy or a bylaw or a regulation in one city at one board meeting. The third piece to this just speaks to the fact that this 0131 is not mandated. The third policy, employment of support staff, essentially the only change to this is moving from the language of NCLB to ESSA or No Child Left Behind to Every Student Succeeds Act. That was ultimately the change in that policy. Policy and

071Regulation 5320. immunizations that again very small changes I know there was discussion with the term legal guardians using that policy somebody updated code includes rights when it comes to immunization which is reflected from the Board of Health and inject a 57 before legal guardians was removed or recommended to be removed in that policy And finally, for fire and fire drills, key to that regulation, rather, 8420.1, it includes added language, again, updated language from NJSA, 18A, and 18A 41-5, that directly aligns with the school district's responsibility regarding fire safety mandated by law. and that regulation guide are mandated and must be adopted by the board. That concludes first read and we have a second read for approval or adoption of parent organization which I think there is discussion on that policy for a possible table. Motion

072and second to accept the policy agenda. I'll motion. Second. Okay, and then can I have any discussion? Yeah, I would like to motion to table the second read for policy 9210, parent organization. However, can we have discussion on that now? We just need a second. Okay, so a second on the motion to table? A second. Okay, and then any discussion on the motion to table? No, I just have a discussion on the policy itself. All right, so I'm going to just have to take it. Okay, take a roll call on the motion at table and then we'll go back to the discussion of the policy itself which we can continue to talk about. Ms. Files? Yes. Ms. Martinez? Yes. Mr. McGovern? Yes. Mr. Montone? Yes. Ms. Scott? Yes. Ms. Guero? Yes. Ms. Warnke? Yes. Ms.

073Scully? Yes. Ms. Gisbel? Yes. Thank you. Motion at table. All right, so now any discussion on any of the policy agenda? I'd like to just, if I could please talk about the immunizations and the guardian. It's personally, I feel strongly that people who are guardians sometimes have actually taken on an extra burden of being in that position. And I think they should have just as much legal representation when it comes to their children's health as a parent. So when I saw that taken out, I was really concerned that we'd be taking that right away from legal guardians. So I only see a hindrance in taking it out. I don't see anything positive that comes from taking it out. And leaving it in doesn't hurt anyone. So I'm very much in favor of keeping it in

074unless, Dr. Walz, there's a reason that you think it should stay out that I don't understand. Well, as I mentioned the it's not a mandated policy so the board does have the liberty to keep that language in I'll defer to David if there is a legal aspect to this. This was brought to my attention sometime during the day today for the first time I was tied up in meetings and didn't have a chance to look at it but oftentimes what these process rate policies are intended to do is simply align our policy to some change in the regulation itself but that's all that's happening here. We may or may not have the discretion to change it. I don't know if that's the case or not. I've got a chance to look into it. But I

075can get back to you. And if it turns out that we're not required to take it out and the board wants to keep it in, I'll let you know that. If it turns out we have no choice, I'll let you know that too. Thank you. And this is just a first reading on this one, so we have time. And those changes were not recommended by the policy committee. Those were recommended by Strauss SMA. Correct. Okay. Because I didn't have any say in that. Oh, I get that. Thank you for clarifying. I agree with you. I think that legally if we don't have to take it out, I would leave it in as well. Yeah, no harm, no foul. It seemed like it was working backwards. Yes, agreed. So I just have some questions for, I

076guess, insight into how the district works with the parent organizations. So my first question is about facilities use. So as a parent organization or as a parent organization that uses this school in their name, so for example, Forty-Four, ATO, they get to use school facilities, and they obviously don't have to pay for that, right? So does somebody have to be on site? So say there's an evening... event like a dance or bingo night does somebody from the building administration have to be at that event if it's a PTO sponsored event no so how does the insurance get covered for that event the PTO should be providing us to get an insurance so the PTO is responsible for having insurance at events that they sponsor in our buildings So if they don't and even if they

077do, then our insurance takes over. Can you speak louder, please? So whether or not a PTO provides a certificate of insurance, then our insurance backs up because it's our building. So it doesn't- We have Senate. It honestly doesn't matter then. Well, it does because they're supposed to be signing off that their year is under their insurance. It goes to theirs first, but say their deductibles or things weren't met or whatever. Or the policy wasn't paid. So we backfill whatever theirs doesn't cover. It's not that we backfill if they don't have one. They are required to have one. Okay, they're required to have what they should when do they show that like any of the year that it's covered for a year or for every event or what's the procedure? Every certificate of insurance is different

078because it depends on when They signed up for their plan. So their plan typically runs for a year, but depending on what they do. Like, we have a ton of different people that rent the facilities, and some, you know, can run 825 through 824 for the next year. Some run 7-1. Some run calendar year. It depends on when they became an organization and when they declared themselves that they needed insurance. And who's responsible for... Getting that so so for example if it's the Lloyd Road, they go night with the Lloyd Road building principal be responsible for saying can I see your certificate? It depends on who fills out the information on flow cap. So there's a program that they log into. Every organization and every school does it a little bit differently. Some PTOs will

079go directly to the school secretary and assist, and then some will go on and ask for it themselves. It all goes in differently. To flow path. To flow path. To the program. Right. That lets them know that that space is available for that date and time that they're looking for. So they would upload their certificate of insurance to their phone? They should be uploading it, but if let's say a school secretary assists and they don't have it, then it's somewhat tracking them down to get it later on. So I think something for the committee to consider when they're reviewing the policy, if it's something that we're... they provide certain kind of insurance, then we know that once that policy, if that's what's going in there, it's approved, then it's our responsibility to come up with

080a process to ensure that that does not happen. That the secretaries or the office staff now know that they have to upload that information or the PTOs just start doing it themselves. Like our grant programs, in terms of our schedule. Right. And we've been trying to work with the school secretaries that when they are meeting to, you know, maybe help them walk them through to create a username and password so that they can log on and do it themselves. So that way they're not repetitively asking them all the time. What about, so the next question I have has to do with tax reporting, tax ID. So I think that we received information that they all, the parent organizations have their own tax ID number. So I would like to confirm that it's their tax ID

081number and they're not, say, using the district tax ID number that they had for, you know, past PTOs that have passed it on, right? So from time to time. We take a little journey to all the banks around us and then we give them our tax ID number and ask them to see all the accounts associated with that. Typically, a lot of the times we find it when their statements are coming, say, to either that location or to central office and then we know that our tax ID number and then we'll ask them to remove it. There are times where we don't know, that's why we're very hands-on with asking a lot of our staff when it comes to a lot of our extracurricular activities and we don't just then give out the W-9 or

082the text. you know, accept form on purpose and that we ask them, you know, send us the contract and the business office will send it to that organization on your behalf so that those copies aren't just floating around because what winds up happening is they will take that with them to wherever and then that's enough for them to assist in opening, which is why then we take the time to go around to the banks to see what is in our name. Yes, so let's follow up and see, make sure that the tax ID numbers that the parent organizations have are independent again. We wouldn't necessarily see that until, you know, like I go to the bank and ask to see what's under our tax ID. I don't collect anything from the PTO with their tax

083ID on it. That's something that they do independently through federal and state documentation. And we don't, maybe... Because there's nothing they're giving us that we need that shows their tax ID. Legally, they don't have to show that to us. a parent organization showing that they're tax exempt, that whatever they're purchasing tax exempt, they're doing it with their own tax ID number. Do they have to satisfy us that they're tax exempt? Yes. Well, I think we are entitled to ask that they present proof that they're a tax exempt organization. I think we're entitled to ask if we're allowed to see proof of their individual transactions. No. I take the position that while we don't run the organizations, we don't own them, but in terms of establishing minimum expectations for fiscal responsibility for anybody using our name

084in our facility, I think we're at least allowed to ask. that they present satisfactory proof that they're a tax exempt organization because people donate any money to them, reasonably expect that unless they're told otherwise. So I think we have a right to make sure in terms of community protection that no one's being misled. And then I guess lastly I just want to know how the organizations, I'm sorry, did anybody else have any questions? I'm just going to get the quick update. How the organizations determine the best use of the funds. So we know that some of the fundraisers are really, really popular, they're a lot of fun. We like the community spirit aspect of those. But they do raise a lot of money. And I'm just wondering, what would be the process for the building

085principal and the parent organizations to determine the best use of that? Is there a wish list from the principal? Or does the parent organization say, we would like to use this fundraiser to raise funds for a specific thing that the school needs? and just it's not in the budget to have so you know there i don't know that there is a protocol for that But just curious as to the communication on that end. I mean, they could say, we want to, we've had this before, right? We want to buy a piece of equipment for the playground. And so they have a fundraiser. And then, well, it's great. And we love that. The equipment is not insurable, for example. And then what happens? And maybe the community has been told that this event is for this

086equipment. And then there's a whole. So typically their bylaws or their charter or their mission state what? their purposes and then you know the principals to meet with them to ask for potential items in this district they happen to buy a lot of stuff independently of the district what we could make as a recommendation is that when they're doing what's in essence that's called a direct donation that then they allow us to purchase and then we approve it as a board agenda item as a direct donation for XYZ and then if they were purchasing say a piece of playground equipment we would then get that quote, make sure that it's insurable, all the things that we need to do behind the scenes and then we would just ask that they write the check directly to

087the district and then the district purchases it because then all warranties and things come through the district which we would need. to offset whatever playground equipment. Say there was a slide that was broken and they wanted to ensure that the slide got repaired, we would then show them that invoice, give them a copy of the purchase order. That way they have identifiable financial stuff behind that, and then we just ask them to reimburse us. Can I just point out one thing just following up with what Lindsay said? In my experience with organizations like that around the state, many are under the impression that they can simply decide they're going to raise money for some purpose they think is valid and just dictate that it's going to be donated to the school. I think a lot

088of people may not understand that nothing gets donated to us unless we're willing to accept it. And I think if they can be made aware, and again, no one would expect to know that they may not know what the law says about it, but nobody can donate something to us that we're not willing to accept. And if they know that in advance, maybe that will prompt the kind of discussions you're talking about, where they would then see that it's in their own interest, so they're not wasting their time to reach out to the principal in advance to find out what we think our needs are. But if that word can be spread that nothing is donated to us unless we're willing to accept it, they might want to find out in advance what we might

089be willing to accept. Well the other thing I'm thinking, I mean a lot of items like we're talking about here are larger dollar amounts perhaps that if this becomes part of the discussion there could be maybe a rule of thumb threshold on a dollar amount. So obviously we don't need to decide that the sandwiches that are brought in need to be purchased by the school. I mean we might do that, but we might not. But the bench, the slide, the... the overhead display whatever it is that's something that I would say anything that you know we're going to utilize for years to come what would be considered equipment I just wanted to give a quick policy update so Obviously we're talking about 9 through 10 and we tabled it and I just wanted to explain

090that the committee and Dr. Walton's administration We decided it would be best if we gathered all the clubs and the boosters and the organizations information and that way we could kind of make one policy for everybody not just PTO because there are other organizations that fundraise and collect and whatnot. So we obviously needed a little time. Administration needed time to do that. So the reason we kind of put this on hold was just until we get that information. and we're due to meet again in mid-January. So we can add that into the policy. Is there a procedural piece that we need to know about how long something can be tabled or what the next step is once it's tabled? Well, if you want to go technically by Robert Schultz's order, which frankly I don't recommend

091because frankly Robert Schultz's order was not written for nine member school boards, but if you want to go by Ruben Schultz's order, as far as I'm concerned, it can be brought back to the table whenever the board wants it to be brought back to the table. Technically, it's automatically back on the table for the next meeting if you want to get real technical, but as far as I'm concerned, no, the spirit of it is not violated. You can just decide for yourself. Is everybody comfortable with that? Suspending Robert's rules for this day and age. I have a question. I don't know if it's policy, will it be policy driven or, you know, bylaws of every entity or group that we're working with driven. But I've noticed a real trend just in my experience as a

092parent in the district of participating in activities that are incredibly expensive. for our kids and I'm finding a lack of equity and access for our kids that if their parents don't have the $10 for the one as a lawyer to walk into the dance and the $27 for the kid to walk into the band competition because their parent has to come so the cost of family affordable. $60 to walk in, not even the door, into the high school. You know, I think that we need to discuss inclusivity and making sure that maybe there could be a suggested donation of a certain amount and you know, it's understood that our parents and our families that can pay it will absolutely do that but we're shutting our doors on so many of our kids and our families

093by putting a price on everything that they're not participating and they are, you know, backing themselves away from being part of our community because they can't afford to. And I think we need to, you know, I find that as a big problem. I think we need to do something about that while we're talking about, you know, tightening things up. That's a good point. And you're right, I'm also observing as a parent that it is growing, that the charges here and there, they're getting excessive or high or whatever you want to say. I know one, not solution necessarily, but another idea kind of thing. When I was at Strathmore PTO, early on, the PTO would receive a... oh god how is it even done i mean it was basically no the pto gave to four events

094gave tickets to the school nurse because the school nurse knows what kids needed and don't i mean i think the school nurse has that confidential information and so when kids walked into the dancing at the same tickets everybody else had but or they were on the list as if it has paid but school nurses made that happen and um that i mean because I mean, the philosophy of Stratford PTO was exactly they didn't want to shut the doors on folks that even a $5 dance charge was going to be kind of a pain in the butt and influence over the course of the month whether dinner was going to happen. So with those charges and it's unfortunate that and I agree that they are increasing everything is increasing in terms of price. When the principal

095does know that a child or a family wants to attend, we know that information then we do go to the PTO and say hey let's donate something. Unfortunate is that we don't have that dialogue with our admin. in the buildings and the support staff because they're the ones that know and they may not come forward. But we have to identify them and say, okay, why aren't they coming on? Why aren't they part of, you know, why aren't we seeing their families attend and participate to support their child? In terms of privacy, you're not going to go and say, I want to come, but I can't. Right. And then we have chronic absenteeism for our kids who feel disconnected. And I feel like it's all connected. And I think it's not just families in need. either,

096it's families in general as well. Like sometimes it's very expensive for a family of four, five, whatever it is, to go to any event in district. It's not even just BTO, it's any in district. I mean, that's your night out. So it's something to think about. I couldn't agree more. I think, I don't know what the answer is, but there has to be a better way. to not fund but to provide these events to everybody in that class or in that building. And I don't know, I think that's something that we should probably maybe bring up with the PTOs and the booster clubs, all the clubs or all the event coordinators out there. But no child, regardless of your deadline and your cost, should not be allowed to attend. So there has to be a

097better way to do it. I just don't know what it is, but I agree. It's always confused me because we have fundraisers, right? We're going to the burger shop and here and the tricky tray and all that. Those are straight-up fundraisers. So you're paying and you're raising funds to then provide our kids events. So why do they have to pay to go to the event and not be raising funds? So that's where I would have been confused. PTO is providing these events, not to pay for the events again. in my opinion. But perhaps treating child-oriented activities less as a fundraiser. At least the fundraiser should think of that. That's advice. We can't tell them how to work. There's been time for the Trunk or Treats and those types of events where people have been told,

098no, you cannot come, you cannot pay, miss the deadline. So I think there are better ways to do it. We just need to brainstorm and come up with that because I agree 100%. It shouldn't happen. So I just want to point out though, if they're doing a fundraiser and they are saying that they are raising for a particular event, they have to use the funds for that particular event. I don't think the fundraisers in general, not for the particular event, but then the particular event comes and people cannot attend the event. So it's not that they're fundraising for the particular event, it's a general fund. Right, it's a general fund. And then they throw events and you still have to arm a subcommittee. Right. I thought we just raised funds for that for me. I

099don't know if there's a reasonable expectation to use legalese, David, of asking where, like, for example, there was a recent fundraiser where I know tens of thousands of dollars were raised, so some kind of insight into what that is budgeted for. Is there a reasonable expectation to ask for transparency in... You know, I think we have to be careful about crossing the border and micromanaging those decisions because for a whole bunch of reasons that we have discovered this discussion, we have to remain in our place with them. I think we can insist on basic, you know, basic floor of fiscal responsibility to make sure that, you know, organizations being run generally on the up and up, if you will, but to get more into their decision making and judging whether they're making the right decisions.

100that's what's us in a position with for what reason we can't be sure the answers all of us should join our own schools no but I completely agree like no students should not be allowed to attend to be back if they want to attend me then yeah so the policy committee will on this once we have a little bit more information And we will have a new draft at a point in which we feel that it's a good draft. That's excellent. I'm part of that committee so I can't wait for it. I remember we had a Lume presentation at one of the, was it Ravine? Right, and so that was awesome and that was funds raised, was that funds raised by anyone else? In addition to, right, but PTO helped to raise those funds. So

101that was at one of our meetings. So it would be interesting if maybe like occasionally we could get the PTO of a building to come and talk to us about what they've been doing. in the building, maybe on a rotational basis once a year or twice a year, that way we can see what's happening. Because I really appreciated that presentation and it would be helpful for us to kind of stay involved in the buildings and the fundraisers that are happening. I mean, not maybe the little ones, but the bigger ones that are raising the money that we're talking about. That would be great, an idea. We could probably include that as we go to each building. and include that in your school presentation group is probably the best way to do it. That also might

102be very helpful for the PTOs when it comes to membership. You've got the parents there. I mean, like, it's a win-win. Ms. Perez, do you have another meeting with the PTO presidents coming up? I think it's scheduled for January. January. All right. Maybe if you could update us, maybe some of us could be there. Thank you. That was a really great discussion. Anybody else have any discussion on policy? Moving on to the finance agenda. Good evening. We'll be looking to take action on the following items. The board secretary's report for the month of November, payroll certification, as well as acceptance of the November report, secretary's report, treasurer's report, approval of transfers for the month, approval of the bills list for December, moving on to page two. We are just extending the negotiations attorney for the

103regular remainder of the school year. There's really no change for that other than we just did an upset in the group chat and we need to do that. Approving the minimum wage increase for the start of January for the state as well as the agenda for the assess rates due to the increase on page three. We are doing the added district placement for Keensburg that is tuition into the district as well as added district tuition for the Keens program. Our 25-26 annual preschool program plan that we just discussed last month, we just needed to have a resolution for it. We revised the acceptance of the Trinity Church. They did provide us with additional coats for the student body. And we just wanted to say thank you. Our routine travel reimbursement needed to be increased due

104to our spending the funds that were approved in July. We're hoping this gets us through the end of the year. 13 is the sale of disposal of assets. We do put an estimated value to them. They will go on deals if we hope that that's what they sell for. We cannot guarantee that. If they do not sell, then that's typically when we go to places like and it gets sent on the dollar to recycle those items. So everyone knows. Fire evacuation drills for the month. bus evacuation drills that happen twice a year for all the buildings and then approval of the in-district routes this typically happens earlier in the school year however it was just missed due to new leadership in the transportation department so if you see spares we need spares you know things

105do occur where buses will be in the shops and then those spares going to take over the routes while we wait for our bus to be returned and that would conclude finance Thank you. Can I have a motion and a second to accept the finance agenda? I'll motion. Is there any discussion on the finance agenda? I know I have one question. I just wanted to thank Ms. Case for just making sure that the computers aren't just tossed and dumpster. And that there's an effort to try to, you know, at least make a few dollars every dollar found these days. So thank you. So my quick question is so on the spares you're saying that that's literally the vehicle is a spare. Correct. A vehicle is a spare. We need those right now. We have day

106runs that we also post. We have field trips. Some schools have half days, other schools don't. We also need it in case we have to add on around mid-year for whatever reason that there is going on. So just a little mixture but that's why it's listed on there. We want to account for every buck that we have. Sure. Are there any other questions or comments about the finance agenda? Seeing none, we'll move to public comments. The Board of Education recognizes the value of public comment on matters of interest in school community. Individuals wishing to speak must state their name and municipality of residence. Comments are limited to three minutes duration, but an individual may speak a second time after all others who wish to speak on the topic have been heard. All statements should be

107directed to the Board President and no participant may address or question board members individually. All speakers are requested to express themselves in a civil manner with due respect for the dignity and privacy of others whose legal rights may be affected. Please note, while it is not the board's intention to cycle comment on matters of legitimate concern, the public should be aware that if their statement violates the rights of others under the law of defamation or invasion of privacy, it may face personal liability to be in their party. If speakers are uncertain of the legal ramifications of their comments, the board urges them to seek guidance beforehand from their legal advisor. Are there any comments from the audience? Okay, seeing none. Can we take a vote on the agenda, Sister President? Ms. Files? Yes. Ms. Martinez?

108Yes. Mr. McGovern? Yes. Mr. Montone? Yes. Ms. Scott? Yes. Ms. Farrell? Yes. Ms. Warren? Yes. I have to abstain from personnel section B, line 2. Mrs. Golden? Yes. Yes. Do we have any unfinished business? I have a question. Now that we've transitioned to Los Chatos Food Services. Do we have a point of contact that if we have concerns or questions as a parent as to what's being served? Very frequently we start to see these social media posts about the Slurpees or even not the Slurpees, that's a new one, that's a new one. But the cookies and the ice creams that are being provided to the elementary school buildings and how we can kind of tailor that a little bit. I've been to Pay Central many times to provide our funds for these things, but I

109want to be able to curtail the snacks. So right on the website there's a food service. The 1-800 number? Not the 1-800 number. The food service will give you a match. His name is Ralph. You would just reach out to Ralph. You can go over, you know, if you only want them to buy, you know, two a la carte items or whatever you want. So please reach out to them directly because then they're going to be able to put it into the system so that any cashier can see. what requests were not there. So it's not like the old system where you could do it yourself, do you have a chance? You never could do it yourself before either. They would reach out to Caroline and switch it. So same thing here, reaching out, making

110sure for our friends. There's also the moment. Maybe we could put that on our social media page. We did at the beginning of the year, but I think as we kind of transition into winter, it's going to get a little bit more exciting. And so, you know, there's not so much outdoors time as there is, so if we could just repost it, that's not a problem. And one more question. Slurpees. Do we have any update on the Slurpee situation? Because... Is that a real thing? It was there. Yeah, it's a real thing. It was going to start at the ice. I was in a cafeteria. What's so funny? So was I. Yes, cool. Great. Why? It used to be just the high school had that kind of stuff. Are we drawing nutritional guidelines? Like, don't

111we have to? I mean, we can't have soda when it's a piece. Whatever type of slurpee they're offering does follow the state code. There's no way that's what we're doing. I honestly need to eat with nachos about it. Carrots. We might have to curtail the slurpees. Thank you, Ms. Brokaw. Thank you. Can somebody talk to Ralph about this? I'm going to talk to Ralph. Like, come on. Like, let's be real. You just dropped sales in the cafeteria. Yeah, I mean, I don't have kids in the school, but when I read that post, I was like... What? Like these kids bounce off the walls and they're stuck inside. I'm sure the teachers appreciate the slurpees. Well, I mean for the kids. Of course. The energy. We need Ralph. Just don't be there when they break. That's

112it. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for bringing it up. Any other new business or unfinished business? Okay. Seeing none, we do have a very short session. Executive session. Very short. Can Be it resolved. Are we good? Sorry, I have a quick question. Can you give us a quick update if you can on the top of your head on the social media lawsuit? No. That was a quick update. I don't know what the motion is going on. Some decisions are coming down. Let me find out and I'll circulate an email the next day or so. Okay. Yeah, I just wanted to, I kept forgetting to bring that up and I figured there's maybe an update already or not, but just to remind myself to make sure that we can bring that up. Thank you. Okay,

113so be it resolved that a closed session be convened for the purpose of discussing privacy, personal and legal matters. The subject matter of the discussion will be disclosed to the public when a reason for confidentiality subsides. Although the board cannot guarantee the length of the executive session is estimated to be 20 minutes-ish. After which the public meeting of the board shall be convened and proceed with business. Action will not take place. Can I have a motion and a second to enter executive session? I'll motion. All in favor? Aye. We have entered executive session.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.