001Good evening. I'd like to call this meeting to order at 5.05. Do we have any comments for closed session? Hearing none, we'll close this meeting and go back to closed session at 5.05. Good evening. We're adjourning back from closed session at 6.04. Reconvening, I'm sorry. First, we'd like to take roll call and we'll start with our student trustees. Trustee Asher? Present. Gonzalez, present. And Trustee Jenny Perez, Elizabeth Meigs Velasquez, both are absent. Right. And moving on to... Moving on to our governing board. Trustee Sandoval? Present. Trustee Wilson? Present. Trustee Frutos? Present. And present, Trustee Arroyo. So for closed session, we have nothing to report at this time. Item C, if you could please stand and join us in the Pledge of Allegiance. Item D, approval of agenda. Do we have a motion? So moved. Moved
002by Trustee Wilson. I'll second. Second by Trustee Sandoval. Do we have a vote for student board member? Preferential vote. Preferential vote, sorry. Thank you. And you have to do the everybody respond. You have to take the vote. Board members? All those in favor? Aye. Perfect. So moving on to item number four, annual organization of the Board of Trustees. Item A, oath of office. Newly elected officials, Mr. Jeff Weinstein, District Superintendent, will administer the oath of office to newly elected Board of Trustees. For Trustee Area 5, we have Mr. Manuel Minjarez. Do you want a... So for Trustee Area number four, Nathan Ramos Rodriguez. And last but not least, we have Trustee Area 3, Dr. Daniel Sandoval. So we take the oath of... This oath of office... To be representatives in the California State Government. Say
003aye and state your name. Do you solemnly swear or affirm that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California against all enemies, foreign and domestic, that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California, that I take this obligation freely, without any mental restraint, without any personal reservations, or purpose of evasion, and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter. Congratulations. You will now take nominations for the election of President of the Board. I would like to nominate Ana Arroyo for President. I'll second that. Any other nominations? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Congratulations, Ms. President. Thank you. So now we'll move on
004to nominations for Vice President of the Board of Trustees. I'd like to nominate Tommy Frutos. Oh, there we go. I'm agreeing to meet. Yeah, I'll second them. Any other nominations? Any other nominations? Okay. Just need a vote. All those in favor. So all those in favor? Hearing none, all those in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Do you preferential? Do it. Okay, congratulations. Congratulations. Congratulations. Thank you. Now moving on. We'll move on to item E. Do we have any nominations for Clerk of the Board? I'll nominate Dr. Sandoval as our Clerk for Board. I'll second the nomination. Okay. Hearing a second. All those in favor? Aye. Congratulations. Any? No. No opposed. I'll start it. So the next nomination is for election of school board representative to vote in election of members of the county committee on school
005district organization. Okay. So the next nomination is for election of school board representative to vote in election of members of the county committee on school district organization. Which is basically when the county has to make a decision for all districts. We need to send a representative to the county. So any volunteers? Yeah. All right. Awesome. And then the same thing. So we have a. I mean, I'll volunteer for it. Yeah. We have a second. So second. Yeah. Thank you. And then just all in favor say aye. So all those in favor of those. Can you just back up? Did we? Did we? Did we? Did we? Did we? Did we? Did we? Did we? Who do we nominate? I'm sorry. So the nomination is for Tommy. Okay. Oh, nice. Yeah. I like Tommy. We like
006him. I think. Do we have any other nominations? Hearing none. So all those in favor. Aye. Aye. Aye. Okay. Congratulations. Now we just do the approval and certification of authorized. So moving on to item G approval and certification of authorized. Okay. So we have a second. We have a second. We have a second. We have a second. We have a second. We have a second. We have a second. We have a second. We have a second. We have a second. We have a second. We have a second. And a second. Second. Do we have any troubling parties? Correct. We put eight all against a team. Okay. All right. Eight against a team. Okay. Next. We have another member,tal repeatedly. You,versus. Ten? Ten. You were talking to the president. Yes. I apologize. It's fine. It's all
007right. Back to us. We just want a motion approved or approved by the committee. Like. A motion. For. The Day trait therapy significance items. This is the currentcoon I have. I. and times of the location of the regular school board meetings so moving on to item h adoption of dates times and location of regular school board meetings do i hear a motion to approve so moved do i have a second i'll second it any discussion hearing none um all those in favor aye aye so passed now student board member reports so moving on to item five staff reports of under item a student board member reports who would like to start i'll begin okay go for it uh good evening all um this report i would like to uh touch on our csba on aec
0082024 two-day student board member conference um for those of you who don't know the csba is um the california school boards association um well they're exactly what they sound like the all of the school the school boards are represented within california uh they host a two-day student board member conference for uh trustees such as myself and uh trustee mex and also trustee perez who is not here today unfortunately um so this is my report on our experience there at um the csba aec 2024. so we arrived in there so we arrived to our hotel at around 7 30 am at 7 30 pm i'm sorry um december 3rd um we went uh with the advice of um assuming the board member daniel uh sandoval we went over to um downtown disney and had some italian
009our next day um it was our day one we were at the anaheim convention center we left health clarion at around 8 00 a.m and headed over to the anaheim convention center to register arrived at 8 15 and after some registration issues inside the conference room at around 8 45 uh just in time for the networking session where we go around the room and get to we get other board members contact information and my board members we also meet student board members who are like us because in the state of california uh it is legally required that all school boards have student representation uh the majority of school boards actually that had uh well the majority of school boards with um i'm sorry let me rechase that um my brain's my mind's blanking um so
010the majority of school boards um with student board members were there so most student board members within california were at that meeting uh so we went around the room we networked so in fact in my bag right now i have an entire list of student board members from alhambra to oakland to rancho cucamonga with different contact information that is uh uh we also had a q a session with two student board members in fact a 16 year old student from alhambra usc and a 25 year old student trustee from sacramento county uh we also heard on different leadership styles and how to use our own school districts and school statistical data in order to see where we should direct the majority of our attention to we learned more about the lcap or the lcap and
011how to use our own school districts and school statistical data in order to see where we should direct the majority of our attention to we learned more about the lcap or the local control and accountability plan the california dashboard and the lcff local control funding formulas or formula priorities after the conference we returned to the hotel and we met with the executive assistant ilda sanchez and we went to dinner on a day two we went to disney's imagination campus and we heard a seminar on different leadership styles um how and also how walt disney um led his imagineers and by extension his entire workforce we focused however on the communication aspect of leadership and how to communicate effectively and efficiently we did some partner exercises that required communication which included a drawing to raise like
012game which showed how we needed to be descriptive without telling them exactly what we they needed to draw and we also communicated by designing a like you know a hypothetical attraction at disneyland after that we have enjoyed the park with some friends and chaperones that is all i had to report um however i would like to say that i was extremely grateful for the opportunity to go to the cspa aec it was an extremely educational experience i am really happy i went and i also got to meet some cool new friends that is all i had to report for this week thank you thank you so much for sharing moving on to trustee mex velasquez good afternoon everyone i'm going to be filling in for jenny press today um i want to start with her
013her report on the csba conference she's extremely thankful for the opportunity to go to the csb conference for the second time this opportunity has led her to be a better leader and lately i've been she's been putting putting to work some of the things they talked about at the conference she's excited to hopefully join committees just as her new friends from northern california that have told her about how they are extremely involved in their districts she'd like to also thank all the board members for the entire trip because they gave us a shelter while we're away from home also the biggest thanks to superintendent weinstein and dr sandoval who gave us great record restaurant recommendations she'd just like to say that it was my my her first time going to anaheim and uh and she
014was super excited to see different parts of california and how different it was from our small town i got she got to see lots of different perspectives from other students last but not least she knows we all loved i know we all loved the second leadership training at disney because it taught her a lot of things she's had her first time in anaheim like i always think it's so cool i'm so grateful for her life i love it so much i love it so her that she should listen more. You may be a little tired of hearing her say thank you for the opportunity, but she still would like to thank our chaperone, Ms. Nash, who is always there for her and took an amazing job for caring for both me and Jenny. Also, many
015thanks to our fellow student board members because without them it wouldn't be as much fun. Also, because they were there whenever we were lost, we had each other. And then her report for Glen City. So, Glen City's Winter Fiesta was held at the Santa Paula Community Center for families to come together to enjoy food and festivals. They want to thank the Condor Club and RHS for helping us. The Penguin Patch gift shop was opened for students to shop for loved ones. They also had their annual jog-a-thon with a splash of color. Kids ran and it got colorful, which I seen was really fun. And then my report on the CSBA. I think it was a wonderful opportunity for the board to give to us. I've personally never been in a room full of student board
016members that they were so helpful and had a lot to say about certain issues and just opened my eyes to a whole new other way of seeing things. It was great to get people's contacts and they were very open arms about um like being there for us and it was great to look from different perspectives. I just want to thank the board for uh giving us those opportunities to go to Disneyland it was actually a beautiful experience, and I got to we all made so much new friends and um it showed me how important being a student board member is and the impact that we can have so I just want to thank you guys. And then my um my report for Renaissance. high school after break including me we congratulate them on their accomplishments
017wish them well and will return and will continue to serve as a support for them whenever they need us when we return from winter break students will be given updated graduation plans to help them focus for this second semester dr olivo held a staff luncheon this afternoon to thank to thank the staff for all they do each and every day for our students our students are lucky to have staff who care about all students rhs wishes everyone happy holidays and then so for bedell 75 of bedell students attended the winter wonderland dance and attend an attendance incentive for the first semester today but bedell students and families attended their holiday program and enjoyed melodies and festive music bedell wishes everyone in santa paula happy holidays and a joyous new year now for barbara webster barbara
018webster is completing our reclassification meetings this week we are very proud of our students who have improved their english speaking skills to the point where they are now fluent in english congratulations to them we have begun our countdown to the casp this is a daily reminder to students and staff that we have 3.5 months until our spring cast state test we are all determined to bring up our score our test scores this year we saw some drops in our scores last year across several of our grades the webster community is working hard to show what we are actually capable of in regards to testing finally our p and after school sports and fitness programs are blossoming after a year and a half of changes to these areas we are seeing students improve physically they are
019becoming scholar athletes so congratulations to the barbara webster i just want to say if i if i don't get the chance i hope everybody has a happy holidays and a happy new year so yeah thank you thank you thank you thank you great job i appreciate that i wish everyone a great holiday i hope that everybody deputy daryl ledger is done with the member transition pot迅 and there are so many things we haven't seen in the desktops perché as the计as i hope we can join Great job. Great job. Both of you. So moving on to item B, superintendents report. There it is next slide please. So, with the political climate after November's election, there's been a lot of rhetoric going on on social media concerning. Immigration enforcement, um, and so I wanted to go over
020how. S. P. U. S. D. Handles it. So we, we seek to serve every student every day, and we try to, um, develop the entire child, which means also making sure that they're socially and emotionally stable. Um, in order to achieve these goals, the board adopted resolution in two thousand and fifteen, followed by a board policy number five one four. Dad, uh, dot one three, not to support immigration and for enforcement by local, state and federal. Federal agencies. So the word the board policy that we have actually states the board of education is committed to the success of all students and believes that every school site should be a safe and welcoming place for students and their families, irrespective of their citizenship or immigration status. Um, it also states that district staff shall now not
021solicit or collect information or documentation. Regarding the citizenship or immigration status of students or their family members, or provide assistance. With immigration enforcement at the district schools, except when it's required by law. And finally, the superintendent or the designee shall report to the board in a timely manner. Any request for information or access to a school site by an officer. Or employee of law enforcement agency for the purpose of enforcing immigration laws. Such notification shall be provided in a manner that ensures the confidentiality, privacy and potentially identifying information. So. So, not only in two thousand and fifteen, they prove the board policy. But in two thousand and sixteen, they did a resolution. And the resolution, um, really, really goes into a much deeper way of looking at things. The Santa Paula Unified School District anticipates
022a potential shift in immigration policy has created a climate of heightened concern and anxiety for many district students and their families. Um, other than that, we also await additional steps in the work that will allow the country to continue to conduct its work in a way that ensures safe, inclusive, healthcare and for all students. Next slide, please. Whereas there's no written state or federal law that mandates the local districts assist immigration or custom informants or ice. In the enforcement of immigration laws, whereas the governing board of the Santa Paula Unified School District resolves to provide schools, which are safe places for students, ensuring healthy learning environments where students may learn without fear or disruption. And then the board adopted that resolution, um, in two thousand and sixteen. So, when I look at the results, I
023think it's certainly going to be helpful for our students and their families. And then the board adopted that resolution, um, in two thousand and sixteen. So, when I look at the results, I think it's certainly going to be helpful for our students and their families. So we are in the process of exploring an early childhood development center. This development center will be paid for by a $5.5 million grant that we are in the process of applying for, or actually we already applied. So when I got here in 2021, there was the Isabella Project that I was introduced to. And so with that, I saw that they had identified between 800 and 900 students of preschool age and TK age that were not attending an actual public school. Or even a private school like some of
024the churches here. So in order to make sure that our students at a very young age are introduced properly to education and to improve our test scores, we opened two sites with preschools. And we have TK at almost every site. So the EDC is also going to support the resources. That support our students. Next slide. So we have to rent space. We have a list of entities that are already asked for space whenever we do this. Next slide. So, so far, we have seven preschool classrooms opened at two sites at no cost to families. Seven TK classrooms at six sites. And. And. And we are in the process of training our teachers in the latest techniques of literary science of reading over the past three years and cognitive guided instruction. Creating early reading intervention systems
025for students struggling with literacy, focusing on our English learners. The positive revolts of our literacy and math initiatives will be presented tonight to the board. Next slide, please. So this is really difficult to see. So I would encourage people to go online. go online to see it. This basically gives us enrollment projections for the 26-27 school year. And our overall, we declined a little bit, but not as much as we have been declining. But some of the interesting data that we were able to pull out is our inter-district transfers in and inter-district transfers out of sites, as well as intra-in and intra-out. Next slide. So you can see that we have a lot of intra-district movement. So the top line there basically shows how many students have applied to go to other elementary schools than
026their home school in their district area. And then the same thing with intra-district transfers. But inter-ins, and this is students coming from other districts to us. We also have intra-outs. And so you can see that the intra-outs, one of the things we need to work on is make sure the inter-outs are minimized. And so you can also see at the bottom there the net amount between intra and inter, yeah, internet transfers. Sorry. So this is our proposed EDCD timeline. So the identification of what school we will repurpose should be done by January of next year, coming up very close. We would hire architects consultants for January and February to, during the time of selection, let us know what is possible and what is not possible at our school sites. And approval of DSA in the
027city. And then we would have the IDC, the school district, and then we would have the IDC of the school district. And then we would have the IDC of the school district. for actually any construction that takes place. We then go out and bid for a construction company in January of 2026, and then renovations start March of 2026. And then once that is all done on August of 2026, we would move the TK and preschools to the Early Childhood Development Center. Any questions? It's more of a comment on the first half of your presentation about immigration. So in our talks, I'm part of a state organization, California School Board Association, their delegate assembly. There's a lot of concern out there on what's going to happen with immigration. And I know that the CSBA is on.
028It's following it closely. They're looking at their old suggested policies to make sure that they're still relevant. They'll be looking at new policies that we might have to adopt. But there is a lot of just we don't know what's going to happen. So we are kind of in a wait and see game. One of the reasons why I wanted us to address this now is to show people where we are at as a district and to. You know, reinforce the idea that, you know, we are going to be on top of this as we possibly can. And we'll see, you know, state laws aren't going to change, but federal laws may. So we are it's a I think we can say as the first all Latino board in San Paulo history that we're keenly aware
029of how this impacts our a lot of our families. So. I want to at least address that. I'll address the preschool stuff. But if anybody else wanted to talk about that particular issue. Yes. Mr. Weinstein, could you be a little bit more specific when you say immigration enforcement? You're a little ambiguous there. Any law enforcement agency that does immigration enforcement, we will not be working with and we will not provide them with any information about immigration status of any of our students or their family members. And. On top of that, you know, unless they come with subpoenas and by law, we're not going to comply with any of it. How are we are we getting this information out to our our families that, you know, this is great. This is one good venue. You know,
030having this discussion at our board meeting is there are we using any of our. So we have parents square and after tonight it's been presented to the board tomorrow. We'll put it out on parents square in both English and Spanish. And that way we can also eat. We'll email it. We'll send it out to the board. And we'll send it out to the board internally to all our staff, too, so that they're aware because we have staff that are new and, you know, wasn't here in two thousand and sixteen. So thank you, Mr. Weinstein. No, I think it's just good reminders. I mean, because I do remember back in the day, you know, when as as a parent of three kids in the school district that that information and and I do have family members
031and and the it was scary. You know, all the talks and the social media. So. You know, I appreciate that. I appreciate that. And I appreciate that. I appreciate that. But I do want to say thank you to the board and to the public and the fact that it's going out in our parent square. Wonderful. Absolutely. Thank you. Yes. Dr. Weinstein, our resolution's good or no, but how are we doing in terms of addressing the cultures in each school as well? You know, this culture may be unfriendly to this community and we can pass a resolution reinstating our stance. But what are we doing to reinstate the cultures in these schools that they are welcoming of the of this demographic? So we're one of the first districts that. Have. ethnic studies at our high school.
032And then on top of that, we are looking at our library books, and we will be adding library books of African American culture, Hispanic culture. Every student that's represented in our district will add a number of books so that they can learn about their culture. And we have given a directive to most of our staff that says, if at all you can make it culturally relevant, whatever we're teaching you, then do that. And we have 96% of our students are Hispanic or identify as Hispanic. So it's a large population that's affected. But I would have no reservations about redoing the resolution once more, updating it. I've been around for a while. I remember Prop 227, and that stirs up a lot of memories. Back when I was at the school sites, and to my point,
033this is where I'm going with this. We wanna make sure that we also educate our staff members that asking personal information of some of our families might be a challenge, because some of our families, they don't have full faith in the system. And so we wanna just make sure that our staff members are being culturally sensitive when it comes to, again, just whether it's, health reports, I know there's IEPs that are out there, and those in itself are challenging to understand. So just a word of caution, and maybe some more training on sensitivity when it comes down to working with our community. January 7th is our PD day, Professional Development Day. So we can add that to some of the agendas for certificated staff and classified staff. Just to, attack a little bit to the
034second half of your presentation, Early Childhood Development Center. Can we get the presentation that you showed up onto the website? Because that has not- It'll be uploaded, right? They should be uploading it now. Yeah. Because I mean, I know I wasn't necessarily expecting that. I think that it would kind of behoove us to actually do a formal presentation, not just in a superintendent's report, which, was helpful, but to agendize it, so that people understand that that is coming. It'll be an information item at January 8th board meeting, and then we would ask the board for a vote on the 22nd. One thing that I noticed on the timeline, I don't have it in front of me, right, was there wasn't really any mention of public engagement. We talked about the architects and when to go,
035and all that stuff. But, we need to engage the public on something as big as this. All right. So that needs to be as critical as, talking with the architects. So, I'd like to see that on updated. Now that said, I guess, sorry. I mean, that said, I have been working with Project Isabella for the last five years, trying to get universal preschool to Santa Paula. It is a wonderful project. It is a wonderful opportunity. It's just not something we can spring on our community, right? I mean, we have to get them on board, fully participating in that effort too, and understanding why it's an important effort. So. If our computer people can go back to the slide where it had the intra and ultra transfers. Oh, perfect. Okay. First of all, that's a beautiful
036graph. I really appreciate that. I was wondering since this might be brought up as an informational item, can you help gather qualitative data onto why some students are leaving schools? You know, is it because the curriculum, you know, some schools are called, you know, the health and sports school, and some students just don't want to be a part of that. Mainly just like internally, that internal movement. I would definitely like to see why students are leaving. We can add that to a board update. We currently get our data through the education, services department, who is the one who approves any intra or inter-district transfer. And this was compiled by a company called School Works, which is a professional demographics company. So, but we will update you on that. Any other questions? Okay. I guess moving
037on to item C, committee updates. Does anybody want to start first? What committee updates? Could it be Dr. Sandoval? Sure. Since there's only three of us that have been on committees. Do you have a relatively full report? As I've mentioned before, I'm on a statewide AI task force. We met at CSBA's conference. I was tasked, and a shout out to Dr. Donahue for helping, for doing the work. I was tasked on seeing how AI can compliment, um, employee evaluations, teacher evaluations. And so, we delivered that content, and that will be part of what CSBA gathers and gives out for board members, right, for their information. So, also, at the CSBA Delegate Assembly, which was right before our annual conference, the delegates in our region, region 11, which is Ventura County and Santa Barbara, had elected
038me. as the next regional director for this area. So it has to, there's a formal process. It's not a done deal yet, but barring any hiccups, I will be sitting on the board of directors of CSBA, which is a very influential organization that really strives to help students, right? Keep them first. So I did go to CSBA, but others will talk about their experience. And since I have other things, I'll move on. I did also attend our latest budget meeting. We haven't met for a month, so there's been a lot going on, even with the holidays. I'm gonna let the Trustee Frutos talk about that. I'm also, as a delegate, part of Ventura County's, CSBA's group. We met and we were planning out our next meetings, right? So new board members, and I think student
039trustees can come too. We have a, three times a year we have a dinner, usually in a Monday where the boards of the county meet and talk about different topics. I think the, I can't remember what the next one is gonna be. I'd have to look that up. But expect an email, right? Cause we're soliciting ideas for topics. So you guys have a role to play in that as well. So, and then finally, I'm not, it's not a committee formally, per se, but I did attend our first community schools grounding meeting. It was a four-hour long meeting, and I loved every minute of it. And I don't get to say that very often on our meetings, but it was great. We had a consultant, Manuel Colon, who talked very eloquently about what a community school
040is. And, you know, for those who don't know, it's kind of been talked about as a place where we have, you know, kind of a one-stop shop for different services that our parents and students need. But it really is more than that. It's really a philosophy of how do we engage parents and how do we help them support the students? Because without that, right, then students are off. They're on their own and often have things that are lacking. So anyways, we talked a lot about what. That would look like here in Santa Paula. We do have funding for planning and I think for implementation as well. And hopefully we can expand that not at one particular site, but amongst all of the schools. Right. And again, it's not that every school will have the same
041thing. Right. But they will all have the same philosophy. So, you know, that was a wonderful, wonderful presentation. I hope to see a board presentation on that to get all of us on board of what it was. Trying to accomplish what it's trying to accomplish. Thank you. Thank you. Trustee Frutos. All righty. As Dr. Sandoval passed the buck on me with regarding budget committee. No. So the budget committee, we we work we're working diligently with our our partners and classified services, certificated services, our cabinet. And we're we're spending. We're spending. We're spending. We're spending quality time and diligent time going over what our current budget is, what our attendance track looks like, our enrollment. And and so although not always pleasant, but I assure you that that the work is getting done. I think nobody
042wants to talk repurposing or no one wants to talk movement of any sort. But but I assure you again that. Myself as a as a parent in in this community, once a classified employee, now a teacher and in a neighboring district, my wife, an administrator, I do carry a wide variety of a perspective where I do I am. And I will always consider our students our priority. So again, the budget committee and I give that type of. Credit also to myself. also to all the members of the budget committee, because it's done with class and dignity. And I do want to thank our budget committee for their time and passion there. On a lighter note, I attended the math advisory committee for secondary education. I just want to give an excellent shout out to Principal
043Guzman and Dr. Nasser over at the high school and the high school math team. Just your conversations that go deep and wide to support our students are absolutely amazing. It's a blessing to hear and be around people, colleagues and professionals who really care about kids and really want to do what's right to support the needs of our students. And so that's all I have as far as committees. Just would you like to say something? I want to talk about the two. Has it been a while since we attended? OK. I'm also on the two by two committee, which it's two board members, myself and former trustee Wilson, and two city council members, council member Sobel, former Sobel, and at the time, Mayor Cornejo. And in addition with our cabinet team members from both the city
044and the city. And the school board. The discussions are deep. One of the recommendations that came up was having a joint meeting with city council and school board to talk about the big issues in our community. And one of them is it's enrollment, it's schooling, it's building bonds, and so on and so forth. So we felt that it was important that we would bring our two joint councils together. And have those positive discussions. We celebrated many things at our last two by two meeting. The collaboration with our athletic programs, excuse me, with the recreation department. I mean, what an amazing positive success to see so many students participating and seeing the parents supporting. It's just a great thing. It's a great thing. It's a great thing. It's a great thing. It's a great thing. It's
045a good feeling to see so many people actively involved, whether the athletes, the coaching, the staff, and then definitely the parents. Can't think of anything else of major importance that came out of that. I know we talked about the bonds that two of them didn't pass for our district, but measure R that did pass for the city. And I think that's all that's on the top of my head as far as the two by two. But I look forward to the next one, because we will be talking also. So SROs and looking at how we will be evaluating the success of the program. So thank you. So I serve on the committee for the Brighton gym. They met last week. I was not able to attend. However, they did present schematic renderings of the proposed
046gym, the pool building, and the band building across from Palm next to the football field. The schematics are wonderful. I believe staff had a lot of input. And hopefully, January or February, we should have a presentation by the architects R&T. So just wanted to give everyone an update that they're moving along with now basically what the building will look like. So you'll be hearing a little bit more in the coming months. Trustee Gonzales, would you like to update us on the Student Advisory Council? Yes. Yes. So we have been discussing with Mr. Weinstein our certain issues that are affecting our schools. I cannot, unfortunately, remember anything off the top of my head. That's OK. But for those of you who don't know, once a month, students from leadership students and also leadership students from each
047individual school site, which are the elementary schools, Isbell Middle School, and also the high school, gather in a monthly Zoom meeting with Mr. Weinstein to discuss issues that are affecting these schools. Unfortunately, as I said, I cannot remember anything. However, next council, next meeting, after we have a meeting, a Student Advisory Council meeting, next board meeting, I will update you guys on that. So there are relevant topics that students need to talk about. And we need to get a student perspective on it. So, for instance, what came out of the Student Advisory Council a couple of years ago was that they wanted us to open the gates of the schools earlier because kids were on the sidewalk, you know, and waiting for us to open our gates. So we went ahead and do that. They
048also talk about, you know, what it's like to the Child Nutrition Services and are the lines moving? Do they have enough time to get to the school? Do they have enough time to eat? And all those different type of things. And then we get into sometimes a little bit more serious topics where last year we were talking about metal detectors and how does the students feel about that. And the students were very clear they don't want metal detectors at their school. And so we quashed that. But that's kind of what happens, you know, monthly. Thank you. So item six, public comments. Okay. So bear with me. I have to read a couple of paragraphs on the agenda. We continue to encourage the public to view meetings via YouTube at Santa Paula USD. Public comments are
049welcomed and encouraged by the board within reasonable meeting time considerations in order to conduct the district's business. During this time, the president of the board may acknowledge visitors' request to speak on a topic not on the regular board agenda. Persons wishing to address the board should complete the meeting and submit a speaker form and turn it into the recording secretary. Individual speakers shall be allowed three minutes on any agenda items. The board may limit the total time for public input on each item to 21 minutes. Also, speakers will not be allowed to give their time to other speakers. The board is prohibited from taking action on any item that is not part of the printed and published agenda. Any individual with a disability who requires reasonable accommodation to participate in the board meeting may not
050be allowed to do so. The board may also prohibit the couple of speakers to participate in the board meeting may request assistance by contacting the superintendent's office at 8 3 8 8 2. Members of the public may submit written comments by 3 PM on the day of the scheduled meetings to I. Sanchez at Santa Paula USD.org. These comments will be read aloud into the record. Written comments submitted to the board are limited to 300 words. You're everybody though, because we have about. Have. about 20 speaker forms we're going to change the speaker time to two minutes to allow everyone to speak if not then we would have to cut short and we would like to start with the people present and then move on to the written ones okay so in order received Dina Fiorentino
051please and after her would be Annette Vargas good evening superintendent members of the school board my name is Dina Fiorentino and I am a health aide at McCabe elementary I stand here today the day after my fourth breast cancer surgery to put a face to the to put a face to the decisions you are making in regards to repurposing closing a school decisions that will directly impact not just me but hundreds of our beautiful children Santa Paula community these decisions are important to me and I want to make sure that I'm making sure that I'm making sure that I'm making sure that I'm making sure that I'm making my decisions as I am making decisions as I am they are real lives real children real families as a parent a community member and employee and
052someone who has fought through the personal health challenges I can tell you firsthand how vital it is to prioritize the well-being and education opportunities of every child I ask that you spend a day at McKevitt a school that's been in our community since 1910 spend a day among our kids talk to them walk with them in the hall spend a the day with these families that you will displace. I urge you to remember the human cost of your choices. The students, the schools in our community, such as McKevitt and Phil, are more than just buildings. They are community anchors, places where traditions are formed, relationships are built, and children feel a sense of belonging. The ripple effect will extend far beyond the budget sheets. It will touch the lives of those who live here, who
053continue to raise their families here and who are committed to see Santa Paula thrive. The repurposing of a school isn't just about buildings or budgets. It's about breaking apart families and communities. Friendships will be displaced as classmates will be split apart and stability that these schools provide will be lost. Social connections and a sense of belonging is important for a child's well-being and learning, yet they will be stripped away when the school's communities are torn apart. While I respect the hard work of our district office staff, I must emphasize costs need to be cut in the areas where students will not be affected. Administrative spending, expensive consultants, unnecessary meetings, and other non-student expenses. Go ahead. I must point out that in a few years, some of you may be gone, but families and children will
054be left to live with the consequences of decisions you make. I ask you this. If your own child were attending McKevitt or Phil, would you fight to keep it open or would you choose a temporary band-aid solution? I'm not going to read the rest. I just want to thank you, and I hope that the decision you make is with compassion, care, and a focus on our families. Thank you. Thank you. Very good job. Thank you. We have Annette Vargas, and then after Annette, it's going to be Sandra Andrade. Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Annette Vargas, and I am represented for McKevitt School. And I've been an employee there for a while, and I'm here to talk about let's keep our schools open, because it means a lot to a lot of the
055staff and as well as myself, but we're here mostly for the kids. We do a lot of things. You know, I'm a campus security, and I represent these kids. I speak to these kids. I speak to the parents every day, and it would just break us to know that these kids would be placed somewhere else where they don't even know who the teachers are or the principals or the counselors. And I'm just here to say, please keep our schools open. Don't close our doors. And keep them the way it is, because in 1980 when I was here as an elementary student, you guys had the same thing. And when you guys did it, it stopped in like 1990. So just for a couple more million, let's just keep our schools open the way it is,
056because I mean, to change everything and for it to go back 10 years net from now would be pretty hard for these kids to be, like I said, just placed somewhere else. So thank you for your time. Thank you. Sandra. Thank you. And after Sandra, Kelly Faulkner. Good evening. Hello, my name is Dr. Sandra Andrade. I apologize. Very nervous. I'm a licensed psychologist and parent of a child in the fourth grade at McKevitt Elementary School. I'm here today to express my deepest concerns regarding the social and emotional impact on students when a school is closed or in this case, repurposed. I'm particularly troubled. I'm very concerned about the potential effects this decision could have on my child as well as other children in our community. The closure of McKevitt is not merely an administrative action.
057It is a life-changing event for children who attend McKevitt. Schools are far more than places of academic instruction. They're nurturing environments where children form lasting friendships, develop a sense of identity, and build relationships. Thank you. They're building future relationships that build crucial social skills for many children. The school is also a central hub for emotional support, providing stability, safety, and a sense of belonging. The prospect of leaving this familiar environment can be devastating. When a school closes, students not only face the challenges of adapting to a new academic environment but also the emotional strain of transitioning away from peers, they have known for years. This can create feelings of loss, anxiety, and confusion, and in some cases may exacerbate existing mental health challenges. The process of forging new social connections can be difficult, especially for
058children who may struggle with change or who have special emotional needs. The sense of community that students lose is irreplaceable and the emotional toll of such a transition should not be underestimated. Research shows that the social and emotional well-being of students is directly tied to their academic success and overall development. The upheaval caused by school closures can disrupt this, leading to a range of potential negative consequences, including diminished self-esteem, increased stress, and decreased engagement with their education. For children, who already face significant challenges such as those with disabilities, socioeconomic disadvantages, or mental health struggles, this disruption can have even more pronounced effects. Thank you for your time and consideration of these important matters. I trust that the well-being of all students will be taken into account as you make this very important decision. Thank you.
059After Kelly Faulkner, Elva Samora. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Kelly Faulkner and I'm here tonight as a concerned parent from McKevitt, a school which has consistently stood out in our district by achieving the highest test scores among elementary schools. This achievement reflects the hard work of our children, the incredible dedication of our staff, and the supportive environment we have cultivated together as a community. The idea of turning McKevitt into a TK and preschool facility is deeply concerning to me. Our school has become a vital part of our children's education, fostering an atmosphere where they can thrive both academically and socially. The strong bonds we've built among our staff, students, and families create a sense of belonging that is essential for young learners. This positive culture is what inspires our
060children to reach their full potential. At McKevitt, we offer unique opportunities that enhance our children's educational experience. We take pride in being one of the few elementary schools actively engaged in fundraising efforts toostaing where the students and staff have contributed with their hard work, and to our contribution to a successful district. efforts that directly benefit our students. The money we raise goes toward goodie bags for completing levels Alexia, fun events like bingo parties and color runs, and other incentives that motivate our kids to excel. This level of engagement and recognition truly sets McKevitt apart and helps foster a love of learning. Our impressive test scores speak volumes about the effectiveness of our teaching methods. According to the California dashboard for CAASPP, McKevitt has made significant strides in both ELA and math. This success is largely
061due to the resources we've implemented like Lexia and happy numbers. Meanwhile other schools in the district have struggled with stagnant or declining performance. Changing McKevitt's focus would disrupt this positive momentum and undermine all the hard work that our students and teachers have put in. Rather than repurposing McKevitt, I encourage you to explore other options that would allow us to keep serving our students effectively. Thank you. There are currently two preschools in our district that aren't operating at full capacity located at opposite ends of town for easier access for families who walk their kids to school. If we transition McKevitt, families would have to rely on transportation which may not be available to everyone. Many families are unaware that this option is even being considered. It's crucial that parents are informed and involved in discussions about
062our children's school. If we truly want what's best for our kids, we need to ensure that parent voices are heard. I urge you to think carefully about the long-term impact of this decision. Our school is a shining example of success, a nurturing environment for our children, and an essential part of our community's identity. Let's work together to make sure our students continue to receive the high quality education they deserve. Thank you for considering this important matter. Thank you. After Elva Zamora, Kina Huerta would be next. Good evening Superintendents, members of the board and members of the public. My name is Elva. I have three children at SPUSD, one at Isabella, and two at McKevitt. Have you ever been kicked out of your home? If this Pilat-Isabella project becomes the home at one of the sites,
063those students will be kicked out of their home, away from home. To many students, McKevitt or Thill is their home. It is where they spend the majority of their day. I stand here today to advocate for my son, who is still, has three elementary to go believe it or not he has grown up at mckevitt from two months old to three and a half years when due to the pandemic i could no longer volunteer in my children's classroom this is home to him and to think that if you all decide on closing mckevitt it breaks my mama heart i can't even imagine how difficult this huge change would be on him and all our students have you thought about how many families would be displaced by this closure it is a closure as nice as
064it has been worded repurposed it equals to displacing our current students from their home school to another school and using the site to create a universal preschool the idea is great for the district to be able to provide a preschool but not at the cost of displacing our children especially given the recent struggles during the covert 19 pandemic the loss of families and families with disabilities and the loss of families with disabilities and families and families with disabilities and families with disabilities and families with disabilities familiar relationships routines and stability can increase feelings of anxiety and isolation transition to a new school may also affect students ability to form new relationships rebuild social skills and maintain academic engagement an academic engagement that is showing and cast test scores for the 2324 state test results our
065principal teachers and students have worked so hard reached goals and the scores confirm it McKevitt had the highest increase in ELA and math CASP scores so why are students possibly being punished with a school closure it is my understanding that in the past 10 years the district enrollment has decreased it if it continues to decrease how are you planning to fill in fill up the classrooms at either McKevitt or Thill with preschool students what if this pilot project doesn't work what if the grant is over in two years meanwhile all these children will be left with the trauma and anxiety from their second home being closed and sent to a different school. I am sure that a smaller building can be found for this project. Members of the board you were voted in to represent
066our children to be their advocates to see what is best for our children. Please consider all the possible scenarios of how our children would be affected before making a vote. Think as if that is your child at McKevitt or Thill. Thank you for your time. Madam President can we just please remind our community our presenters that there is a two minute time limit. Thank you. Thank you yeah and also the clapping if we can just move it along because I would like to get through everyone. After Kina Huerta we have Mark Lopez. My name is Kina Huerta and I am the mother of a fourth grader at McKevitt. I am the first grader and I am the second grader at McKevitt. This was brought to my attention quickly and I wasn't sure what I was
067going to say today but after hearing the superintendent say in the beginning that serves every student it kind of resonated with me and thinking when we were asking for this grant for children that are not in our school where were we going to house these children? What happens to all of the kids not only McKevitt? I'm sure all of you are in business. When you give more work to an employee what is affected by that? Their quality. So if all of McKevitt gets closed all of Santa Paula school district will be affected in the elementary schools. I'm surprised more parents are not here knowing that even more students are going to be in their classrooms. Shame on you for not telling us and making this public. Parents Square was out there. Does all of the
068Santa Paula's school school district know that if this is closed who will absorb those children? Who absorbed when Isabel's sixth graders could not go there. Every single school and the parents were not happy but we did it because we needed to as a community and now to hear that you want to close our school now I don't know if many people know it's for low income. My sister is a middle-class family here in the county, in Santa Paula County and she applied for preschool and was denied she was one of the first applicants because she was not low income I would really advocate before telling this what are the requirements of your new preschool to sell that to our community thank you after Mark Lopez Skyla Lopez ready go good evening superintendent board members and
069I would like to provide my personal views on the current proposal to repurpose McKevitt school as you know McKevitt has had a number of years with the highest test scores in our district the school is one of the strongest parent groups friends of McKevitt who provide financial support to a number of programs such as AR bingo Kinder and first grade Target parties Lexia and more the activities provided throughout the school years such as the condo the color run turkey trot and yesterday's aspire winter performance enrich our children mentally physically and emotionally I am continuously impressed with the education my daughter receives at McKevitt as a young child the movement of students more than three times throughout their educational pathway begins to take a toll on them emotionally my daughter has many friends in her outside
070of school activities but not the type of closely bonded friendships she has made over her four-year education at McKevitt she has had the opportunity to grow and watch older children model responsibility kind behavior empathy following the rules and much more TK and preschool students will not be able to see that type of role model behavior when they are only in an early childhood I ask you to please do some more research and to really look at the students families and staff you will be affecting when you make this decision with the rebuilding of our sphs gym that burnt down there have been a number of community members community meetings with the public asking for input and thoughts the same occurred with the update remodeling the Isbell Academy of College and career school site however with
071this large and impactful decision of closing one of our beloved school sites why has there been no input from the public on this momentous decision that greatly affects our children in our community some of you will not be here in the next few years but the choices you make today or in January will affect generations in this community for years to come as you will see in a second decisions based by looking at names and numbers on paper are not the same as speaking to the people who will actually experience the outcomes of your decisions again all I ask is that you take some more time and make a well thought out decision that is best for all students who live in our amazing little town of Santa Paula thank you thank you do you
072have Skyla Lopez after Skyla Ila Hernandez that would be my son doing um hi my name is um Skyla Lopez um I'm nine years old and I go to McKevitt Elementary um I love my school I love my class and I love my principal so if anyone shuts down my school I will be really sad and if I go to a new school I might not go to the same school as all of my friends and I'll and um I'll be um like sad because um well the school will be shutting down and I won't be able to be with the same people that um teach me there and yeah thank you thank you after Hilda Hernandez will have Dr Gabino Aguirre and thank you about the time limit hello everyone my name is Hilda
073Hernandez I have two kids that both of which are enrolled district my son is at isbell and my daughter is a first grader at mckevitt i am here in hopes of convincing the board to not relocate mckevitt students in order to make it a preschool tk school site as you all are aware the caaspp scores for mckevitt are phenomenal the students have increased their scores by about one-third and in some sections even a half and that is all thanks to the teachers staff and the parents of mckevitt students none of the other schools within the district have been able to do the same the stats that the district has provided show it that alone says a lot about mckevitt we are on a roll i understand wanting to provide the community with the preschool tk
074but why not let it be the way it already is and possibly add a couple of mobile classrooms at the mckevitt school site for example so that way the mckevitt students can be the perfect example for the incoming preschool and tk students throughout the years birth rates have declined results have been very positive for the school and the students have been very positive for the school and the students have been very positive for the school and the students have been very positive for the school and the students have been very positive for the school and the enrollment rates also declining it does not make sense to to close the school site relocate students and hope that the enrollment rates will miraculously increase obviously mckevitt students are doing amazing academically this relocation will affect them academically
075and psychologically if this relocation happens it will also affect the students and families that struggle with transportation and walk to school this will result in them having to walk further and cross highway 150 ohio road this will have the most negative impact on marginalized communities who already are experiencing barriers in accessing education if something is not broken then why try to fix it thank you dr gabby nikita buena noches uh i'm dr gabino aguirre and long time resident of santa paula former mayor and councilman uh executive director of uh el centro del pueblo family services center first of all congratulations to our newly elected members to the board and uh we want to we want to make sure that you take this seriously of course and uh but i am moved by the eloquent statements
076by members of the mckevitt community i want to first of all thank the superintendent and the board for bringing up the issue of immigration historically i was immediately moved by the eleno cristo yes and then i'm going to let you go on the next slide thank you thank you So I appreciate the comments on the immigration and the resolution. I'm also here on behalf of the Isabella Project. I'm one of five co-chairs. The mission of the Isabella Project is to provide free, high quality, early childhood education to every child in Santa Paula. Right now, the Isabella Project is focused on three and four year olds. They're currently out of 900 three and four year olds, only 250 to 300 are receiving preschool. The other 600 don't have access. And consequently, as a result, they arrive
077behind their peers at the kindergarten door. So as co-chair of the Isabella Project, I will welcome anybody who needs to inquire further about details about this project. It is a project that will bring in not only new jobs, but a higher quality of education for our youngest children in the district. Thank you very much. Thank you. See how long I can speak with this cough. So moving on to the written comments. Good afternoon, SPUSD board. I was recently made aware of the plan for a major change within the district when it comes to TK students. I am a Glen City DLI parent who recently contacted the office to find out when I can register my son, who will be starting TK next school year. Although I was provided with the registration process, never was it
078mentioned by Glen City staff that I would have to take my son to a different school. I am concerned as to why many of us are finding out via another concerned community member's social media post instead of this being communicated by the district. Will TK DLI be offered at McKevitt? Is transportation being provided for those who reside outside of the McKevitt boundaries? How can I and other parents be expected to pick up at two different elementary schools at the same dismissal time? These are just a few days away. There are just a few of the questions that arise, but I ask that the board please consider the impact this change will have on the entire community before making any changes. Lastly, I'd like to urge for transparency with the SPUSD community because as of now,
079this is yet to be officially communicated. However, a change of this magnitude can significantly impact a child's capability to start their early education. Thank you for your time, Arianna Gonzalez. Good morning. My name is Hermann Solis, and my reason for this email is that there are rumors of McKevitt being turned into a preschool-only school and transferring the kids from K-6 to other schools around. I have a child there in first grade and would find this whole situation stupid since my child has learned a lot from the amazing teachers there and would not want him anywhere else. Also, the inconvenience for childcare since my mom takes care of my son after school and she doesn't drive. She just walks to pick him up. If the rumors are true, this would cause an uproar. I've been in
080contact with other parents, and they find this news very bothersome and will do all they can for this not to happen, as we are very happy with McKevitt School. Regards, Hermann Solis. SPUSD board, I was just made aware by a neighbor that there may be some changes with our elementary schools that will impact traffic in my neighborhood. I live on Pleasant, and I am concerned how this will affect the already high traffic that we experience every morning. Having kids dropped off from all over town to McKevitt and having the McKevitt area kids to be taken somewhere else will cause unnecessary traffic. We have to deal with traffic from the residents coming from 10th Street, drop-offs from McKevitt students within the boundaries at the high school. Please, please, please consider the extra traffic this will cause.
081Thank you, Patty Castro-Taylor. A concerned resident. Good evening, board members, board of trustees, Mr. Weinstein, families, and friends of Santa Paula. My name is Esteban A. Lopez, and I am a fourth grade teacher at McKevitt Elementary. I have been a lifelong resident of Ventura County, but with regards to Santa Paula Unified School District, I am relatively new. Now, well into my fourth year with the district, I truly feel at home here in Santa Paula. As an educator for 15 years, I have had the privilege of working in a variety of districts, schools, and with diverse staff. I have witnessed a wide range of school cultures and families those schools serve. So when I say there is something special about McKevitt, it comes with experience. As you step onto campus, it's palpable there is something different
082about McKevitt. I'm not referring to the physical walls of McKevitt, the beautiful courtyard of the center of our campus, or even the one-of-a-kind mosaics and murals on the walls. It's the people, our fantastic support administration, and staff, our amazing teachers, and our dedicated families. Together, we create a Mustang family. Our Mustang community is unique within the greater Santa Paula community, and it breaks my heart that McKevitt is being considered for repurposing. It's true that if this plan goes through and McKevitt is repurposed, teacher will continue their good work. It's true that our administration and staff will continue to assist other staff and students at their new sites. And it's true that students will continue to work hard with their respective classrooms, but we will no longer be together. And that is what makes our Mustang
083community strong and unique. The amazing staff and administration, teachers, and families we all serve will be dispersed throughout the district, and they will undoubtedly continue to be amazing. But we will no longer be together, and that is what defines our familia here. It is the very idea that together, all these parts, as one gives, as one gives, McKevitt its identity. This identity allows us to faithfully serve our community and the families who rely on our schools to care for and educate their children. In closing, a pending family to serve temporary fix is unfair to the families we serve in our Santa Paula community. My hope is that the board will make decisions that truly prioritize families and their future. I urge you not to see families that are in danger, and that's families teachers and
084staff as members of a dollar sign but as the people who live and work will be directly impacted by your decision thank you for your time and thoughtful consideration of this important matter sincerely esteban lopez fourth grade teacher mckevitt elementary board by only offering tk and mckevitt is a burden to parents and grandparents like myself i drop off and pick up my grandkids at one school now i will need to do multiple drop-offs for no reason that makes sense if this change does happen be assured we will be pulling the kids out of the district and putting them in a district that has the best interest of families in mind ray fernandez concerned grandparent i'm doing him in order he gets the long ones good evening board presidents and members of the santa paula board
085of education i am writing to express my opposition to the proposal to close mckevitt elementary school santa paula is a small community with a population that is over a hundred thousand people and is a small community with a population that is over a 70 percent latino and many families rely on our local schools to provide not only in education but also stability and a sense of community closing mckevitt would disappropriately impact these families particularly those who may struggle with transportation to other schools adding unnecessary stress and disruption to their daily lives mckevitt elementary has been a cornerstone of education in our community and its recent academic achievements reflect the dedication and dedication of the school system to the community and join us in the next lesson of both staff and students. In 2024, McKevitt's CASP
086scores rose to 40.10%, the highest of all elementary schools in our district. This improvement demonstrates the hard work and commitment of our school's faculty and its students potential. The proposed closure would undermine this progress and leave many students without the specialized programs and nurturing environment that McKevitt provides. Moreover, dispersing McKevitt students to other schools would result in overcrowding classrooms and fewer resources for all students. It would also create logistical challenges for families who already face financial and social challenges, making it harder for them to fully engage with their children's education. Closing McKevitt would be a significant disservice to our community. I urge the board to reconsider this proposal and find alternative solutions that prioritize the needs of our students, staff, and families. McKevitt's CASP scores are the highest in the state of Michigan. McKevitt is
087an integral part of Santa Paula and its closure would have far-reaching negative consequences. Thank you for taking the time to read this letter. Derek Luna, former SPUSD board member. This one's in Spanish. Mesa Directiva. Me di cuenta que puede haber cambios en el programa de TK. Mi hija va a la escuela Blanchard y tengo otra hija que entrará al TK el próximo año escolar. Se me hace difícil llevar a las dos. Mi hija va a la escuela Blanchard y tengo otra hija que entrará al TK el próximo año escolar. Se me hace difícil llevar a las dos. Mi hija va a la escuela Blanchard y tengo otra hija que entrará al TK el próximo año escolar. Se me hace difícil llevar a las dos. A escuelas diferentes, pues no manejo. Gracias, Guadalupe Sanchez. The letter
088says, I found out that there could be a change with the TK program. My daughter goes to Blanchard and I have another daughter who will be entering TK in the next year. It's difficult for me to take them to different schools because I don't drive. Thank you. Spanish is poor. I won't be able to do that one. Okay. Santa Paula, you're welcome. Okay. Santa Paula, you're welcome. Good morning. Good morning. Good morning. And we welcome you to the Blanchard Unified School District Board. Through social media I was informed there will be some changes in the schools that affect the TK program. This is a big change and I am concerned because parents were not made officially aware for the district. This will have a major impact on families as we will have to make multiple
089drop-offs creating unnecessary traffic or there will be transportation provided for those that live outside the McEavitt boundaries. This will have a major impact on families as we will have to make multiple drop-offs creating unnecessary traffic or there will be transportation provided for those that live outside the McEavitt boundaries. We are considering our options for keeping our kids together and if that means pulling them out of the district, we will have to go that route. This will mean less money for the district. Please reconsider this major change as I don't see it as a benefit for Santa Paula families. Thank you for your time. Reina Castro, concerned grandparent. Sorry, I'm translating the other letter. It says, . The letter says, please don't make changes to the schools. It will affect us tremendously because we live far
090from McKevitt and I don't have a vehicle. Read the last one, let's see. Hello, Mrs. Sanchez. I would like the following to be read to the board, to the school board. My name is Steven and I am a parent of two children at McKevitt. It has come to my attention that the board is considering repurposing McKevitt and turning it into a TK preschool facility. While I agree with the Isabella project and its mission to bring high quality early childhood education to the youth of Santa Paula, I must strongly object to the closing of McKevitt in order to do this. I find this to be a reckless and disruptive to the 300% plus children and their families. McKevitt has long history in this community. I myself attended McKevitt in 1990 and my children's grandfather in the
09150s. McKevitt has the best community engagement in this city with a strong PTO that is constantly fundraising for the students and staff. We pride ourselves on being able to provide a fun, loving, and safe environment for our kids. McKevitt is one of the only schools that provides fun activities such as the Color Run, Turkey Trot, and bingo parties. According to your own cast report being discussed tonight, McKevitt is the only elementary school that has improved in every category and is one of the only two schools that improved overall. It would be irresponsible to close McKevitt and disrupt the staff cohesion that has brought about these positive improvements. Rather, the board should be looking to McKevitt as an example that other elementary schools in the district should follow. If the objective of the district is to
092improve, then the board should be looking to McKevitt as an example that other elementary schools in the district should follow. If the objective of the district is to improve, then the board should be looking to McKevitt as an example that other elementary schools in the district should follow. If the objective of the district is to improve, then the board should be looking to McKevitt as an example that other elementary schools in the district should follow. If the objective of the district is to improve, then the board should be looking to McKevitt as an example that other elementary schools in the district should follow. If the objective of the district is to improve, then the board should be looking to McKevitt as an example that other elementary schools in the district should follow. If the objective
093of the district is to improve, then the board should be looking to McKevitt as an example that other elementary schools in the district should follow. If the objective of the district is to improve, then the board should be looking to McKevitt as an example that other elementary schools in the district should follow. provide learning opportunities by a highly skilled educational team in a safe and supportive learning environment than it would behoove the board to re-evaluate the repurposing of McEvitt. The staff and parents of McEvitt are going above and beyond in providing all that and more. And that is the last public comment. So our next item A is the 24-25 first interim budget presentation. I want to say thank you to everybody who came and spoke. Thank you. So presenting tonight is Dr. Williams. Good
094evening, board president, vice president, board of trustees, superintendent, cabinet, staff, and community. I am Dr. Marguerite Williams, and it's my pleasure to present the 24-25 first interim budget. I come to the business department with 23 years of instructional experience. I am a professor of business and I am a professor of instructional leadership. I understand the instructional needs of our teachers and our students, and I lead with that lens as it relates to budgeting and resource allocation. So tonight, I just want to share a few key terms that you will hear during the presentation. Average daily attendance, COLA, which is our cost of living adjustment, local control funding formula, which you'll hear in the presentation, and the cost of living adjustment. LCFF, unrestricted revenue, and restricted revenue. I want to make sure that you understand that
095our unrestricted revenue can be used with all these various strings and constraints that we have on the restricted side. Restricted revenue has lots of different guidelines, and we're subject to various constraints that are imposed by external and external emergency systems. So I want to share agencies that limit how we can use those dollars. So it's very, very important to understand restricted and restricted revenue. Tonight, you'll also hear MYP, which is our multi-year financial projections. That is giving you the financial projections for the current year and two consecutive years. Also, I want to point out COLA. It's an increase in funding, including LCFF, as well as categorical programs, all determined when our governor presents the budget. This slide, I want to just say that the budget is referred to as a living document because it's continuously
096being updated and adjusted through the budget. The budget is updated throughout the fiscal year with new information, changing assumptions, and budget to actuals related to expenditures, as well as revenue. The budget evolves with real-world data. So when we build our proposed budget and take it to the board in June, it is out of focus. We don't have as much information as we need at that time, so it's very blurry. Now, we're right now coming to you with our first interim report. The focus is a bit clearer, but there is still some blurriness because we're continuing to get new information. At second interim, we'll become more in focus. Our estimated actuals will bring us into a greater focus. And then when we close our books at the end of the year, we will see clearly. So
097we'll be following all of our revenue and expenditures throughout the fiscal year. So, components of our first interim will include these various forms that will be sent over to our county office which are listed there. I won't read them for you but I will give you a few seconds just to look at those different forms. Legal requirement, we're required byól-ED CODE to submit twoardo feedback reports held. PROMOTED REQUIREMENTS στο PH, QUORUM PRÍCÍ, AND DIFERENT REQUISITES TO ADDRESS REQUIREMENTS AT THE EEG CONSTERTRAINMENT. THEY'RE PARTNERSHIP RESOURCES. THE multiplayerologie intake will also take place in the provisions, elo orgánico y reconduzión y la organización legal lo ähnlich que nos sale alощrenos porSTRA如此. ent ade格adas a sus promos. by Ed Code to submit true financial interim reports to the County Office of Education each fiscal year. Our first interim
098financial transactions are from July 1 to August 31. We will come back to you in March with our second interim. Those will be for financial transactions from July 1 to January 31. The first interim report is designed to identify changes to our budget since we brought our adopted budget to the board in June. It shares overall changes to our revenue, expenditures, beginning and ending fund balances, as well as our reserves. It also provides an in-depth analysis of our budget. It also provides an in-depth analysis of our budget. It also provides an in-depth analysis of our budget. of our multi-year projections using current projection factors that you'll hear about later in the presentation to ensure that we're able to meet our financial obligations for the current and two consecutive fiscal years. Certify, in this case, a
099positive certification based on the current information the district will be able to meet its financial obligations for the current and two consecutive years. The first interim certification consists of either positive, qualified, or negative. The district administration is recommending a positive certification. Because, as I stated, the district is not a state. The district is not a state. The district will be able to meet its financial obligations for the current and two consecutive fiscal years. Here's just some guidance from our county office as it relates to our budget since the enacted budget was signed this past summer. It is true that our physical our cola remains at the 1.07. It also states that it's really important. It also states that it's really important. It also states that it's really important. That we are looking at our multi-years
100to ensure that we're going to continue to be able to meet our financial obligations. There are some other items I want to point out to you as well. Several provisions to allow students to make up loss instructional time, thereby offsetting student absences and mitigating learning loss. These provisions will take place. July 1 of 2021. These provisions will take place. July 1 of 2021. These provisions will take place. July 1 of 2021. That will help to increase our Ada. That will help to increase our Ada. So we're really excited about that. So we're really excited about that. The budget did suspend the planned investment of 550 million to support California preschool, transitional kindergarten and full day kindergarten facility grants in 2425. So we look forward to hearing from the governor on how he will take this
101into account. on how he will take this into account. on how he will take this into account. On that in the following upcoming year. So our enrollment and average daily attendance. So our enrollment and average daily attendance. And reading the chart, that first column is what you saw in 2425 at the adopted budget window. And reading the chart, that first column is what you saw in 2425 at the adopted budget window. And reading the chart, that first column is what you saw in 2425 at the adopted budget window. And reading the chart, that first column is what you saw in 2425 at the adopted budget window. And I'm doing a comparison between that window of time and our current window of time, which is called the first interim. And I'm doing a comparison between that
102window of time and our current window of time, which is called the first interim. that window of time and our current window of time, which is called the first interim. That last column, you'll see variances. So you'll see for our enrollment count of variance of 26 students, our ADA count of a reduction of 50 students. The good news is the district is being funded at a higher rate than our actual ADA. And that is due to LCF Hold Harmless, which the governor put in place to soften the financial impacts to district based on the pandemic. That will be expiring soon. So we're continuing to work with our various departments to increase our ADA. Another area that we're really excited about and kudos go to our IT, a team and our data analysts at IT that
103we had an increase and our UPP percentage, which is 0.84. So you'll see the effects of that in our next slide. So this slide talks about our revenue. Unrestricted revenue, where we are given those dollars to run the district and make sure we're paying salaries and benefits and all of the other operational expenditures, expenditures that are needed. So here I want to point out increase in revenue for our LCFF sources where we're seeing almost a million dollars, $825,000 approximately, and that's due to our increase in unduplicated pupil percentage. So really kudos goes out to all of our principals and leaders who really worked extremely hard in helping us to increase that percentage. You'll also see slight increase in other state, but overall $803,000 approximately is the variance between adopted budget and first interim. Let's move
104on to unrestricted expenditures. These are all of the expenditures that we're going to be talking about today. These are the expenditures, again, that the district makes sure that we are paying them in order to keep our district afloat. Overall total increase here in our expenditures is $5.7 million approximately, and this is driven by adjustments in salaries, books and supplies, and services. The most significant change includes the reallocation of the school district, which is a big change in the school district's budget. So this is a big change in the school district's budget. And this is a big change in the school district's budget. And this is a big change in the school district's budget. And this is a big change in the school district's budget. So we're going to be talking about the reallocation of certificated
105salaries from our restricted program to our unrestricted program. And we're doing that in an effort to normalize our maintenance of effort. In addition, you'll also see an increase in our services and operational expenses. Next slide. Contributions from our general fund to our restricted programs. Next slide. Contributions from our general fund to our restricted programs. Next slide. Contributions from our general fund to our restricted programs. Next slide. See the total number and total remaining accounts. The budget reflects several key adjustments here. There's a reduction in contributions to SPED due to the reduction, movement of salaries from restricted to power. So we're seeing a $2.6 million decrease in general fund contributions, which is a positive for the district. Next you're seeing a slight increase and our routine restricted maintenance. We are using our RDA funds from our
106special reserves fund to offset the general funds contribution to the routine restricted maintenance. Normally the district is required to give a 3% contribution to routine restricted maintenance. We are able to now this particular year use 3.6 million of a balance we had for RDA to decrease and offset the district's contribution. That is a positive. Moving on to general fund revenues. This is unrestricted and restricted dollars combined together. Here you're seeing a notable increase across several districts. We have a positive variance of 3.4 million for restricted and unrestricted revenue. That's also contributed to what we heard at the very beginning, the increase in UPP percentage. Also at this time of the year, we bring to the board all of our carry over for our title programs and other state revenue that has been increased. We have
107a positive variance of 3.4 million. We have a positive variance of 3.4 million. We have a positive variance of 3.4 million. So we are seeing a positive across unrestricted and restricted. Moving on to our general fund expenditures. Again, this is restricted and unrestricted expenditures. And overall, we're seeing an increase in our expenditures, which goes back to what we heard on the unrestricted, where we made some shifts from the restricted salaries to the unrestricted. Also, we're seeing increase in services and operating expenses as well. Let's take a look at our components of our ending fund balance. And this is for unrestricted. We saw an increase of 1.4 million approximately in our beginning balance, which is showing the difference once we closed our books versus what was presented for adopted budget. There was an increase because there
108was new information that we didn't know when we were presenting the adopted budget. Again, we see the expenditures there. Again, salaries is the theme moving from restricted to unrestricted. Also wanna point out that transfer out, we're seeing a difference there, a decrease of 5.7 million. And again, that goes back to moving salaries from restricted to unrestricted. Another positive is the 3.6 million transfer from special reserves to offset our district contribution to routine restricted maintenance. And we're seeing an increase in our ending fund balance of 2.2 million based on those particular items. Now we're moving on to multi-year projections for current year and two consecutive years. These are the various factors that we take in consideration as we're building out the budget for those consecutive years. And you'll see the various factors there in that first
109column. And each year you'll see a number. And just looking at our COLA for this year is 1.0 million. And the third year out, we're seeing a increase in our block grant for K-8 as well as 9-12. The second year out, we're seeing a increase in our revenue for the second year. And the third year out, 3.08. Projected next year to be 2.93. And the third year out, 3.08. This information will be updated at our governor's budget. You're also seeing increases in our block grant for K-8, as well as 9-12. with our UPP percentage, so we're projecting that to continue to increase. Also, as you can see, our CPI is 3.23 this year, and we're looking to see that drop in the next two years. Here's our enrollment and ADA trend. Just want to point
110out, when we look at our enrollment from 5,153 students in 2019 to projected 4,490 students in 25 through 27. Looking at a possible decline of 472 students over the last six years. Our current enrollment is 46. And we're projecting in 25-26 a slight drop to 45-38, and then 44-90 in 26-27. These are our expenditures unrestricted over the current and the two consecutive years. We're seeing small decline in our LCFF from 24-25. We're seeing a decline in our LCFF from 24-25. We're seeing a decline in our LCFF from 24-25. and 2526 and then a little uptick in 2627 so overall we are seeing um from 24 25 and then 20 26 27 just a slight change of about approximately 200 000 when we look at our expenditures we'll continue to see expenditures rise across the current
111and two consecutive years the team through our budget committee and our cabinet we're going to really have to manage that very closely these are expenditures it does not take into account contributions and contributions are running with expenditures approximately 80 million dollars so we can see that our expenditures are going to be very high and we're going to be able to manage that very closely and we're going to be able to manage that very closely and we're going to be able to manage our expenditures are continuing to outpace our revenue multi-year contribution to restricted program so as you can see for 24 25 we had our rda funds that mitigated routine restricted maintenance which the total is 9.5 million again in 25 26 we're able to use another 3.6 million from our rda i'm sorry that's
1123.8 i had to pull my glasses up a little bit that's 3.8 million in 25 26 and by 26 27 we're running out of rda dollars so we only have 800 000 to contribute in that year so you're seeing the contributions um significantly increase because we're not able to offset that with the rda dollars so it's going to be really important to see that we're able to manage that with the rda dollars so you're seeing the contributions um significantly increase because we're not able to offset that with the rda dollars so it's going to be really important to see that we're able use closer to the budget committee thank you community members thank you and i'll be корп k — and uh nosect them so next slide please and our budget committee again is on
113its way to attention so here' um to share with you our pattern ofさい that h we're facing we're facing this is our higher이�ence review today for year which is 7.5 million and 2627 you're seeing a 2.9 so approximately 5.6 million dollar drop from our current year to the third year due to increasing expenditures it is extremely important that we continue to right size our budget in order to ensure that we meet our reserves and that we have a positive certification things to consider as we move into our second interim budget is implement implications of the governor's budget once we find out that information in january we want to know how that will impact our district also settling negotiations related to employee compensation health and welfare and etc will be things that will be important to
114us as we move into our second interim budget continuing to be mindful of our contribution to restricted resources and increase in pension rates will continue to be something on our watch list we will be finalizing our pars incentive to determine the district's contribution and that will also be part of our second interim budget identifying additional reductions to mitigate the reality of the district's contribution to restricted resources will continue to be proposed a fully reallocated fund will continue to serve us to document the expenditures additional investments and how we will continue'll continue to analyze these expenditures as we as the district go forward with the dd planning Pandora Plan fiscal year really to gauge significant trends in the state revenue to determine if the projected colas will hold as they are so we we look forward
115to the governor's budget the district will continue to monitor our state revenue and our state proposals the district faces near and long-term challenges including risk to state revenue forecasts rising cost pressures which we've talked about pension rates the expiration of one-time covet 19 relief funds as well as declining enrollment the board's commitment to approve a fiscal stabilization plan which identify cost-saving measures will be critical in the development development of our multi-year projection for 2526 as well as 2627. i can't end this presentation without giving a shout out to our director of budget and finance lori thoms for the amazing work and her leadership in the department to getting us to where we are i want to thank her and the entire team not just fiscal staff but also to i.t and all of the other
116departments because it takes a team to do the work that we do so i really just want to thank and appreciate all of them thank you do we have any questions the board just going back to uh let me find the is your mic on yeah it's on now okay now i can hear it yeah it's not okay so uh under general fund expenditures you know we saw that you know we had a pretty large variance with services and other operating expenses can you give examples of some of those services and is it are we are we able to to look at some of those and seeing if um you know how we can reduce spending in some of those areas is this for unrestricted expenditures these were combined combined okay so uh the increases
117in combined it carries over from the unrestricted and one of the the largest variance you're seeing there is the difference between um the salaries you're seeing a major difference in our certificated salaries because they were moved from the restricted also the other things that we're looking at there is services and other operating expenses so that could be an example could be a contract it could be in the contract could go over various departments there's also factors where our ma services which special education use that funding source so there are contracts that are there also insurance cost legal costs as well and when we're building our lcap local control accountability plan we're also allocating resources that are rightfully so that need to be placed there so that's also where you're seeing some increase as well thank
118you you're welcome just to piggyback on that i mean that was an increase of 26 on the services line alone i'd like to see a breakdown of that in a future update absolutely thank you um can you um just explain to me in the audience uh when will the hold harmless district um sorry i don't know if it was a if it was a direct ada um can you can you tell us when it will expire or do you have an idea when it'll expire so uh how that works as you look at our enrollment if our enrollment was higher in the previous three years we use the higher number versus the actual. So as you look at our current enrollment, you can tell there that we're getting very close. So on the narrative on
119page four, it shows that for 2425, our P2 number was 4,151, but we were funded at 4,472. So for 2526, we're projecting, and this is only a projection, that our ADA would be 4,075 and the funded would be 4,288. And where it gets really close is in the 26-27 school year where we're projecting our ADA to be 4,019 and the funded is 4,018. So the gap is closing where it's going to be that the prior years are not going to be as high. So we're going to get to the point where we're actually going to have to rely on our actual ADA numbers. But Dr. Santa Maria and his team are working very hard on our ADA and we are looking forward to seeing higher ADA rates. Excellent question. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
120Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. So Dr. Williams, so I guess what I really want to hear right now and for the good of the order is, what's the bottom line? Are we in the plus? Are we in the negative? We are presenting a positive certification. That wasn't the question. Okay, so let me rephrase my question. So in terms of budget going forward, are we losing money? And how much are we losing? Because I know the answer, it's in 5 million, but I wanted to hear it from, from you. So we're looking at a deficit of how much? So let me take you to this slide here, where we look at the revenue for current year and two consecutive years. So we are seeing this year, 73.3 million, and we're seeing a slight decline next
121year of 72.7, and then a slight uptick in 26, 27. And that's all if our COLA remains at the number that it currently is being projected at, but the district has to be very mindful that expenditures are outpacing revenue, because when we look at our expenditures for the third year, 67.4 million, and if you add our contribution amount, we are outpacing our revenue. So then in other words, changing, changes to, how we're spending has to change. We have to make some, some, some major impactful decisions in terms of how we're spending our money. Is that what I'm hearing? That is an accurate description of where we are. And later in the meeting, we'll have our fiscal stabilization plan where those numbers have already been included in these numbers. So excellent perspective there. Thank you. You
122still haven't answered the question though, right? What is our deficit this year? You know, the way that we used to have this, right? We could see the bottom line. What was our deficit? And I have to do a lot of calculations to get to that. I can do it, right? I mean, Danny, but what concerns me is that it looks like we have about the same deficit about $3 million. When you take into the, increase revenues increase expenses the differences in the carryovers um the differences in the transfers right but that's including a 3.6 million dollar infusion from fund 401. the not it's not the reserve it's the redevelopment funds right so there's about eight million dollars in 401 right and the concern I have right is that and this predates you right when we
123were looking over our facilities planning 401 8.4 million is sitting there to help us with our facilities right so electric EV vehicles deal improvements it's it's a one of these funds where we have some flexibility as to where it can go right we're gonna lose that and we just lost two bonds so and we have a list of projects right that we're not going to fund and now we're going to say to balance our budget we're going to get rid of 8.4 million dollars and that concerns me because that means if we have relatively the same amount of deficit from a from adopted to an interim then there's additional 3.6 million dollar deficit because that's including the transfer in like how did we how did that go so out of balance like I can't follow
124the numbers to see like I've seen some of the increases services went up 22 percent which I want to understand why books and supplies went up 21 percent sure certificated went up but that's because we're doing the transfer differently right we're not doing the the the we're we're doing it right because sped was really high we want to reduce the maintenance of effort you know you categorize them as certificated it's got to hit somewhere right it's not just made up money but like I'm really concerned that we're blowing a hole in the budget and we're going to fill it with that fund but I can't tell I can't tell if I could just add when the adopted budget was done there was approximately 3.5 million in restricted expenditures that was not moved to the general
125fund so at first at the adopted budget you saw a lower deficit because those expenditures stayed over in the restricted when we did the MYP the multi-year projections we did not leave those expenditures there because in that next year they're expiring so they had to be moved into the general fund so on top of the already general fund deficit we added 3.5 million approximately in expenditures that's in a fund that's going to be depleted next year and what fund does that that is the LRE the learning recovery so those expenditures had to be moved into the general fund so if I could show this here the deficit prior to reductions for this current year is 8.6 million dollars so the team and the budget committee worked very hard to identify reductions that amount is 6
126million approximately but if you take the 3.5 million in all of the restricted expenditures that were still sitting restricted and move them back to the general fund it offset the great work we did in identifying the six million dollar amount I think that one of the things that we haven't gotten to in the budget committee right is looking at those restricted funds which is something that you know I'd been talking about for a while right because you know we had a bunch of one-time money right you know we put a lot of into that, but I don't have a great sense of what's in there, you know, and what we're going to keep because one-time money is just that it's one time. We can't keep the programming that we had because it was one-time money.
127Right. So I am concerned, right. That we're, I mean, I know that we had to do some of that, right. But there's not a conversation about, okay, well, what are those expenses coming in and are they something that we're going to keep, right. We're just keeping them. And now we're going to, you know, raid one of our funds so that we don't have to make those decisions, you know, or talk about that. Right. And that's, we've got to address that. Like this first interim, there's a second interim, right. There's still time, but you know, that's, that's a conversation we have to have. Right. So, so the RDA is, um, something that I'm concerned about, right. So does this presentation, do these numbers have the deferred maintenance transfer embedded in them? Yes. Can you show me
128where that's at? Cause I can't tell where that transfer is. The transfer that you would not see it in the, in this particular presentation, I can show you, uh, a general ledger where we've transferred those dollars, um, into the budget, just as we did the RDA. We transferred those dollars from fund, uh, special reserves into the general fund. Uh, and that needed to be done in order for us to have a positive certification. So we're transferring 6.3, or excuse me, 3.6 million from RDA. And then we're also transferring another $4 million from deferred maintenance. And we're cutting the $6 million from deferred maintenance. And we're cutting the $6 million from deferred maintenance. And we're cutting the $6 million from our fiscal stabilization plan. Right. So that's a pretty big number, right. Of a change. But
129given that we were, I mean, we, we understood we had the issue, right. But you know, if we have to make those, like those are going to, those are so deferred maintenance is going to be gone. RDA is going to be gone. Like, what are we going to do? You know, I mean, so another, we'll move on to another question. And if I could just add that RDA is, um, being used over three years, we're using 3.6 this year, 3.8 next year and 800,000 the third year. Yeah. So forget a performing arts center at the high school. And I also want to share that, um, the 6 million that you're seeing there on that second line, that says total reductions. It's really not. It's not 6 million. When you look at all of the expenditures
130we needed to bring back from restricted. So it's a wash. We, we identified 6 million, but we brought in more expenditures that couldn't stay there in the next year because that fund is being depleted. So, so this is why I've said this time and time again, and you're not the first CBO I've done this, right. We need to make educational decisions, right. And go from that to, you know, sh � what are we cutting? Okay. What are we cutting then? What's leaving right now? I feel like we've created this list of things in the budget committee cuz they're expedient. Right? And now we're just going to shift all that, that restricted into the general fund without talking about it. You know, that's not the way that I think we should be budgeting. We should be
131know what our number is. What's the target? What can we afford to do? So we've got to get that straightened out between first and second. Anyways, going on to a different issue, the ADA on page eight, the percentage, right? Help me understand this number because we've been getting board updates where our, is that our attendance rate? I guess that's the first question. It's page eight. It's our ADA percentage and as adopted was 90.4. Five nine and 90.01. Is that our attendance rate? So this is what was known at the time. We have collaborated with Dr. Santa Maria's office, as well as VCOE to gather additional information. As I stated, it's what you know at the time. So the results of that meeting with student services and VCOE has brought to light some differences that are
132positive. So that will be reflected in our second interim budget and staff is making the necessary changes to update that information. How can you give me a somewhat of a magnitude of that difference? It had to do with transitional kindergarteners and the birth date and whether they were, they were being counted in the ADA or not. So based on the information that we learned, they were not being calculated in this particular ADA. So once. We that's all being recalculated and we will see a higher number at second interim. But not that much because TK is not that huge. Right. I mean, there's not that many students in it. Right. But I guess the question I have is that we've been seeing on our board updates attendance rates of 95%. What happened? And that's what brought
133to my attention that there was a gap in the information. So once I saw that, I immediately reached out to Dr. Santa Maria and said, where are you getting your numbers here? We're getting our numbers. And then we had a phone call with BCOE about two weeks or so ago. And we identify that the way we were calculating it in attendance accounting that we were missing students with a particular birth date. And I'm happy to provide additional info in a budget update. But we are looking at favorable numbers that you'll see in second. Interim. Okay. I mean, because I'd like to it's important to get a sense of that, right? Because, you know, we're going to be making some big decisions, right? Every percentage increase is about a million dollars. Absolutely. So if we're not
134at 90 and we're at 95, that's a $5 million swing. That's huge. But I did want to notate that we are but we're budgeted on the funded ADA. So not on. But attendance is different, though, isn't it? Our funded ADA is what we're. Budgeted on for LCFF. Okay. So attendance will help like in maybe next year and the year after that. Right. We still had a cruddy attendance rate last year. So yes, you're absolutely right. Having those numbers correct are going to be very critical as we move forward. And as that LCFF whole harmless expires. So excellent point. So did did everybody fill out the income form this year? Because before. In the past, we haven't had 100%. We were told that we would in registration force that. Like, I don't know if that was
135done or not. No one's ever said definitively. Yes, we had 100% compliance. From what I've heard, we haven't. And so I just want to know what that percentage number is. Well, as I shared, there are UPP percentage increase, but parents have the option to opt out and the team. Did an amazing job. Everyone had a script. We explained all the benefits to parents, but we had parents who said, I am above that income level and or I don't want to fill out the form, even though we explained all the benefits. But to see almost a million dollar increase, the team worked very hard. So in addition to the survey that the parents completed, we also had a. Leaders calling filling out paper applications. We did a lot of work to increase that percentage from what
136it was previously. And that's where I was looking at because I was on on on form eight. I hope I'm not cutting you off. Very dark sound. So because my first year on the numbers were really low. Okay. I mean, I think we were at like 30%. Last year, I think it rose to about. 50%. Can you tell me a little bit about where we're at now? Absolutely. On our PowerPoint slide income, the enrollment, the income registration form, the enrollment, the percentage at adopted budget was 83.35. And at first interim, the UPP percentage is 84.19%. So that's an increase from how much it's a point eight, four, eight, 84.84% increase, which resulted in. $825,988. So again, resonating the impact of staff members out and doing the work. And I understand that it's not an easy
137form to complete. I get that. What incentive programs did we have to change that? I mean, what are we doing different to increase that? Because that's why I was one of the reasons why we have our outreach counselors. Outreach consultants. I keep hammering it. That's what I would love to see my counselors. I know that they're doing another part of the job, right? I get that. But having all hands on board and seeing the positive benefits of the dollars, I'd like to see that. So maybe down the road is going forward for next year. Obviously not right now. But what's the plan then for 2025, 2027? I don't know. 25, 26. Excellent question. I truly believe we had all hands on deck. I was just truly impressed with all of the outreach specialists. The principals.
138Everyone stepped up. But what I heard from the field is we have parents who are saying that they are above the limit, so they would not qualify even when we contact them. So that's one part of it. And then we have those that are just opting out. and not wanting to give their information, even though we have a list of benefits. So we will continue to reach out to those parents, but those are two barriers that I see in us getting higher percentage. As I mentioned earlier, going forward, I realized that's the kind of information and the climate that we're in politically with ISIS and all, that could be a real problem. So I just wanna make sure that we get ahead of it and that we do have a plan going forward, because this
139is not an area that we can afford to take a downward spiral on. So, and I also agree, I kept looking at 90.1, 90.1% of ADA and on my board updates, they were at 95. So I appreciate the explanation of it, but I just wanna make sure that that's a good thing. And we're clear on that it's not at 95, it's 90, 90%. Now we're talking about the UPP count, right? Correct, yes. So the UPP is the- No, I'm talking about ADA percentage. ADA, we're going to see a change at second interim. My staff is already recalculating based on the guidelines as it relates to our TK birth dates. Okay, and I know you mentioned that. And we will see that increase. And again, this was brought to my attention when I saw numbers being
140reported that didn't align to numbers I was tracking. So in order to ensure we were on the same page, we came together as department, worked collaboratively, got on the phone with VCOE staff to make sure that we were aligned and corrected. So I really wanna thank Dr. Santamaria's office for that support. Just following up on that income form, is there a possibility that maybe, because if I understand correctly, it's only one form per family. So if there's three siblings and there's one at the high school, middle school, elementary, if the elementary student brings it in, how are you guys aware of to count it for the other family members? Is that tracked in the system? Yeah, that's an excellent question. Our data analyst in IT is magnificent. She knows if a parent says yes and
141the student has siblings based on our data reports, that we also make sure that those siblings are marked as meeting the income requirement. So that it's a lot of detail goes into it. We print the rosters, we assign them by school, we send them out to schools. So it's a lot that went into it to get us to this point. We will continue different avenues for those parents who are saying, no, I don't wanna fill out the form and I'm above the income limit. I was one of those parents that didn't wanna fill it out, but once they said, but it'll help your school get free lunch, including your kids. And I'm like, here you go. And I mean, I didn't have to pay for snacks or their lunch, even though they would bring their
142lunch. So it was a very cost savings. And I remember the incentives were if the kids brought it in, they would have maybe an ice cream party at the end of the month for those who brought it in. So you're sure those elementary kids were asking their parents to fill in their form because they wanted to be included in that ice cream social. Right, we can definitely do some of those for next year. Sounds great. Any other questions? Okay, thank you. I think under future items, I think we all have some concerns and I think some of them, I brought them up on my one-on-ones. And again, thank you, Dr. Sandoval, for bringing up the comments, especially the RDA. But moving on, I'm in charge of the agenda. Moving on to number eight, information. Item
143A, CAF's data update on student performance. And presenting is Dr. Moore. Do you guys want a break right now or after this presentation? Five minutes. Now? We'll take a five minute recess break right now. Okay, let's begin with a presentation of CAF's Dr. Moore. Good evening, Superintendent Weinstein, President Arroyo, board members, and our community still tuned in, I hope. We have some CAF's data that we wanna present this evening. And I just wanna remind the board about three years ago when we would do our data presentations, it really wasn't clear. And some of the feedback I was getting from the board at that time was, I don't really know what any of this means. Are we doing okay or are we not? And so one of the commitments that we made in ed services is
144that once we get some solid data points and we have them now and it's still growing, we would be very transparent in our data. I'm happy tonight with the progress of our CAF's data. We're celebrating growth. We by no means are where we need to be, but we're celebrating the growth and across the board, we are going in the right directions. And I wanna say a big thank you to our principals here this evening who are the instructional leaders at the site, and really pushing the increasing student achievement. But I also wanna thank the teachers. We've had some great initiatives over the last three years, and the teachers have just done incredible and it's starting to show in our data. I also wanna thank my team who are gonna present this evening and we'll get
145through this as quickly as possible and have some questions at the end. So good evening, my name is Tim Smith, Director of Elementary Education. So just to kind of give you a layout as to what we're looking at here, we did a comparison of the 2020, 22, 23 and 23, 24 CASP data. The percentages that you're looking at are the percentage of students that met or exceeded the standards that were presented on the CASP. And so in this first slide, we have the English language art overall scores for the elementary schools. We have the district percentage there, and then you can see the various elementary schools as you go across. We've got, you know, some really good bright spots, schools that made improvements over the percentages from one year to the next, few schools that
146went down, but we're very excited about seeing the progress and the momentum that we're kind of moving forward with that. And then this one here, this is our secondary schools, again, very positive as Dr. Moore said, we're celebrating the growth that we're seeing across the board on this. And as you can see, both with our, with our secondary schools, we're seeing a lot of growth. We're seeing growth in our language arts scores with Isabel, Renaissance, and Santa Paula High School, positive gains in our language arts scores across the school sites. And so this evening, Tim will be presenting the ELA and I'll be presenting the math. Good evening, board members. And so what we have here on our math CASP scores, we see notable gains with Bedell and McKevitt and something significant, and you can
147see that McKevitt definitely stands out. Thank you. So we saw gains in every grade level at McKevitt. And so we see also that Bedell had some nice gains and we can see everything that is in reference to the district data. And at the secondary level, we do see some gradual improvements. We do recognize that we still need to focus and strategically address, maybe, some of the things that we're seeing. And so we're seeing some nice gains. We're seeing some growth across math achievement across the district. And so the next one that we'll be doing is for our emergent bilingual students. And this is, again, the English language arts. Again, you can see across the data there that there are some schools that made gains from one year to the next, other schools that went down.
148As Doctor, I'm going to, we're going to keep repeating this. We're celebrating the growth that we're seeing across the school sites. But by no means do we see that we're where we want to be at. And where we want to be for our students. But it is good to see the positive gains that have been made. And then this is for the secondary. Again, positive gains across all the school sites. There with our secondary schools. Really good to see that we're moving in the proper direction. So when we look at our emergent bilingual math CAF scores, so just a reminder who our emergent bilinguals are. Our emergent bilinguals are students who are both our newcomers as well as our students who are long-term English learners. And so what we can see to point out are
149a big growth. We see growth at McKevitt. We see growth at Glen City from 22, 23 to 23, 24. We see growth at Bedell. So we do want to celebrate the areas of growth. But we also know that we see growth. We also see some maintaining. And we also see declines here. And so in the future and toward the end of the presentation, we're going to talk about some of our focus areas and areas of necessary growth. For our secondary, we can see that there is slight growth and kind of maintenance. And we know that this is definitely an area that we need to continue focusing on in order to bring up our emergent bilinguals. And so the next area we have is the reclassified emergent bilingual students. Tradition, you know, we're still seeing this
150trend even here in Santa Paula. And we've seen this across the state of California. Reclassified students typically outperform all the other groups here. We're still seeing that. But as you look at the data, you can see that we had some declines across the board, particularly in language arts with the reclassified students. We had some that were very high. We had some that were very low. The previous year, and things went down. Bedell will kind of point out that might be, you might look at that and say, that looks a little strange. It's not that they had zero in 22 and 23. They just didn't have enough reclassified students to get valid data. So you have to have 11 or more students to have scores posted on there. And they didn't have that. So that's why
151you see that there's nothing there and that there's a gain that they had of the 27.3. And then going here with the secondary schools, again, we're seeing gains. Santa Paula High School maintained, but still that's not too bad that we're going there. I want to point out Renaissance. What a great growth that they had with the reclassified students to go from 0% to 20%. And it's, those numbers are relatively significant just because it's a smaller population. So anytime you have a child that's making those progressions, it's a good thing to celebrate. And I think that's something that we need to look at. So looking at our emerging bilinguals with regard to our math CASP scores. So we know that typically, as Tim stated, our emerging, our reclassified students tend to perform better than our general
152CASP scores and students. However, like what we notice here is there are some of those declines we do see at McKevitt. That kind of thing. And so we're seeing that growth. And so that's something that we need to ask ourselves, okay, what is happening at McKevitt, as well as what are some of our initiatives that are leading to the growth across the board. And with our secondary reclassified students, we see slight growth. And our SPHS students who are reclassified, that's staying relatively steady there. And I know that Trustee Frutos mentioned earlier about the being present for the high school math team. And we know that there are things that are being done at the secondary level, but we still need to continue to focus. So in looking at our students with disabilities, as we're seeing
153with all the data, we're seeing trends, it's great to see McKevitt with the work that they've done. I'd also like to point out Barbara Webster. They've got a growth there with their students with disabilities. Something that I'd like to point out and talk about here is that when you're looking at this group, students with disabilities, it's all students that have an IEP. So you could have some students that have speech-only services, some students that only have occupational therapy services, some students may be receiving resource specialist program services. And then also there could be some students that are in a special day program. So you could have some students that are in a special day class that are taking the CASP also. So it's, there's a broad range of students that are within there and what's
154going. Again, you know, we're not happy, you know, when you look at the percentages, what they're, it's not great, but again, we're seeing some trends. Yes. Before we go on, I just want to like reemphasize that point, right? Because our special education students are not spread out evenly throughout all the sites, correct? Like, doesn't Barbara Webster have special, Well. I mean, I think that's a good point. I think that's a good point. I think that's a good point. special day classes, but there's some that don't have special day classes. Correct. There are. Do you know what I mean? Yes. I mean that in terms of the, the, the like mild to mild to severe. So there are, so there are two school sites, Kevin and field that do not have special day classes. Oh. Again,
155though, I think it's important to remember though, that even though those, those school sites that do have those special day classes, that's a small percentage of their special education students. Because when you're talking to students with disabilities, as anyone, who's on an IEP okay gains across our secondary schools which is really good to see um you know it's self-explanatory there with renaissance again they had so few students that there's no data for them that's nothing that they've done wrong it's just that's to protect as this is the privacy of those students but it's good to see these gains uh particularly you know at Isabella and and Santa Paula high school because those schools they do have you know not only large populations of students but students who again could fall in those categories of speech
156only occupational therapy only and of course special day class students so looking at our students with disabilities we can see where the gains are and I think that one of the things that we want to emphasize is that our students with disabilities we have expectations that our students who are taking the CAASPP are receiving grade level content and so what we are doing is they are also receiving our cognitively guided instruction they are also participating in our p3cc pre-k through third grade coherence collaborative statewide projects that are focused in math and we do have a tk through 12 math focus and so we know that our students need to have access to the content that they're interested in and that's why we have to high quality instruction and content. And as you can see with
157McKevitt, they are giving students that access and that score is, or those, that achievement score is pretty phenomenal. Looking at our secondary, so we see slight growth. We know again that our students with disabilities, if they have opportunities to be included in the core curriculum, especially at the secondary level, inclusive practices help students to have access to core content that is high quality. And so that is one of the things that we definitely wanna look at in the future is to make sure that our students with disabilities are receiving that high quality instruction, as well as we are providing the training that is necessary for all teachers to be able to excel and teach that math content. So to highlight some of the bright spots that we're seeing, and we'll kind of take a moment
158to explain how this looks and kind of work so that everyone has a good understanding. As you're looking at the chart and the graph, the first four columns there, where it says Bedell third grade, Glancy third grade, McKevitt and Thiel third grade, those third grade classes, you're looking at one years, the 22, 23, 23 students comparing them to 23, 24 students. So it's two different groups of students that you're looking at because they do not have CAAS scores the previous year to look at a cohort. So that's how you're looking at that. So you can see the bright spots and gains that from year to year, even though it's different groups of students, we're seeing good gains with there. As you go to the fifth column over, where it says Bedell third to fourth grade,
159now we're looking at cohorts of students. So we're looking at cohorts of students, we're looking at what the third grade students did at Bedell in 22, 23, and then what those same groups of students, that same group of students did in 24, in 23, 24 as fourth graders. By looking at those cohorts, we're seeing that those students came in at one level and they've increased other. And that's the positive thing we wanna see, which is why we're showing this cohort data this way, because we wanna show that students that are coming in at a certain level, they are being progressed and we're seeing increases in those percentages. Just as far I forget, you're already at 48 slides. What's another two, right? By doing the cohort data on its own, just to make it a little
160bit clearer in the future. All right, I'd like to see the thinking, all the cohort data would be nice to see, I guess, by itself. Okay. So, okay. Cause I didn't pick that up the first time I, Oh, okay. Thanks. Okay. And part of this that we're showing this, these are the bright spots as we're seeing, cause again, you're seeing some school sites, some grade levels that are really doing a wonderful job in moving students along as to where they're going. And it's really good to see. We're seeing that same trend with the secondary schools, with English language arts, again, moving cohorts of students from one percentages, keeping those students and moving them to the next one. And what's really nice to see, and we're gonna point this out later on, but we wanna show
161that out, at Santa, Paula high school with the 11th graders, those students, their percentage is actually higher than the Ventura County percentages for the whole County. So that's a real nice thing to see. It's me still. I move too quick. So now we're looking at the areas of growth. So again, same format that we're looking at here, the first two columns there, we're looking at third grade classes. Again, these are two different sets of students. So we're looking at students at Barbara Webster and Blanchard from the 22, 23 school year, and a different set of students from the 23, 24 school year. And then after that, we're looking at cohorts of students. So again, we're seeing that there are some spots there where students were maintained. Some things are close, but others there are some
162disparity there. So this is where we're looking at, how can we help support these school sites? How can we support the learning that's going on in these classrooms? And then the data with our secondary schools, again, they've got a positive trend upward from cohorts going one to the other. However, though we do, we did want to show, and I appreciate Dr. Garcia putting this in there, how we're comparing to Ventura County overall, and then the California state. Because again, we're seeing positive gains. Students are moving up, but we also know that they're not where we want them to be. So we want them to continue to make that progress going forward. So math bright spots. So as we look at math bright spots, again, what we have is we've got the different sets of students
163that are the first few graphs, so those first three, and then we move into the cohort data. And so one of the things that we see as we are looking at our cohorts of students is we see positive trends, third to fourth, fourth to fifth, fifth to sixth. Now mind, that means last year's third graders, or they were third grade, then they moved up to fourth grade. And we saw that growth in achievement. And so we can see where those red bars are and the change that happened. And so what do we attribute that to? We'll talk about that later, but we've got some great math initiatives going. And we are looking to really have coherence in our system with a TK through 12 math focus that we are very excited about. At the secondary
164level, level. What we see is we see some bright spots. So we see Isbell jumping from that 13 to 18%. Again, we recognize, of course, it's not where we want to be, but we are moving our students. And to be able to move a percent, 2%, 3%, 4%, you know, I mean, we're looking at about 6% right here is actually pretty significant, which means that there are definite instructional shifts that are taking place in our schools. We have Santa Paula High School made a slight change. They're relatively stagnant. And one of the things that we recognize and we'll talk about more in the area of growth is, okay, what is it that we need to do for our secondary? So in terms of our areas of growth, so again, just to give you a little
165bit of a sense of what we're doing, we're doing a lot of work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot of work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot of work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot of work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot of work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot of work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot of work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot
166of work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot of work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot of work on the area of growth. So we're doing a lot that what you see in the first few bar graphs is the third grade and then we see cohort data and so one of the things in terms of our or several things we've got two of our six schools in the third to fourth grade that saw a decline two of six that in the fourth to fifth we're having we see a decline five of six schools in the fifth to sixth grade cohort and so we know that we
167need to focus on the initiatives focus on those high leverage pedagogical practices and we know that we've seen growth and we just need to stay the course on that so our secondary we can see so we see some some , some stagnant numbers there slightly decline and a relatively staying the same in relationship to Ventura County, California, so at the state level what we're what we've seen over the last couple of years is that students are making gains in math and kind of closing that gap that was a result of COVID and all of the challenges that we faced. And so we recognize that we need to really focus on our secondary many of our initiatives have focused on our elementary and so we recognize that that is a focus and with our eighth to
168ninth grade on track transition being led by director or Nellis, we are focused on English and math in order to increase that achievement. I wanted to. I wanted to. I wanted to. I wanted to. I wanted to. take this slide so In I'm in my fourth year. We've spent millions of dollars in professional development in Cognitively guided instruction and then the core of the k2 Literacy I said three years ago. I said these The way we're going to present these to teachers because all the teachers will be trained. These are not optional This is the direction that we're going in as a district These things work and we've got to get our students reading and we've got to get our students understanding conceptually understanding math So I hesitated to talk about this or to bring
169this slide to you, but but I think it's important we have We have identified across the district about five or six teachers who are in their third year of CGI training and Are not implementing they They're they're not struggling they Don't believe in the concept of CGI math and they're not implementing so These data points on the left the red represent individual teachers And so when you look at Third grade four percent nine percent Met or exceeding these are very low scores and so what I asked what I asked my team to do is to point out some exemplars and so the blue side we have the first four columns these are we have a two third grade teachers and two fourth grade teachers that are exemplars that have Have gone through the they're completing
170their three years of training. They're all in they're still Learning they're still trying to learn and understand and implement and you see the date you see the difference in the data. I wanted the last two Fifth grade there's two fifth grades on these two teachers are fully implementing Still learning still still needing some coaching But these are the scores and the reason why I wanted to point this out to you is to understand and to really get the message across The district is that this data we're going to present this data and it's not a gotcha This this data is to really understand that our individual scores Either help the overall data or it hurts it and so I'm going to talk a little bit about You're probably thinking. Okay. So what are we going
171to do about it? So I that's going to be in a in a in another slide Our ELA math district comparison very pleased With this Santa Paula Unified School District we compared our data for the last three years comparing it to Fillmore Unified Briggs and then then comparing it to the county so Santa Paula in the area of ELA just really standing out among the districts, the surrounding districts. And then in terms of math, pretty even with Briggs. And then you can see the comparison and you can see where we are in terms of the county. And so still a lot of work to do, but definitely making progress. So our bright spots. So we have the next two slides are bright spots and growth areas. And so Tim and I are going to co-present
172this slide. So several elementary and secondary schools should notice what increases in ELA and math, just as you've seen. So I'll just do this entire slide. All righty. And so what we see is that we see consistent improvements in, for example, third to fourth grade, as well as other grade levels. McKevin had third, actually, I should say through sixth grade math, where they showed gains. And so we see that our students with disabilities at Barbara Webster improved from 22 to 23. Our SPHS scores are higher than Ventura County, go cards. And improvement in ELA and math scores happened at both Isbell and at SPHS. And then when we're looking at our areas of growth, you know, there's many things that we're looking at. We'll get to the, we'll talk to the next desk, but in
173overall scores, you know, math, something that continues to need to be a focus district-wide. We know it's at the elementary schools. I put in there, particularly in K and second grade, not because there's anything going wrong, but I think now that we've got a coherent, cohesive plan with K and second grade teachers getting the cognitive guided instruction training there in year one right now, we're going to see more improvement as we go along, because it's been very difficult on those, on the third and fourth grade teachers, sometimes, you know, particularly third grade, past several years, when they get there, that's the first year they're really getting those strategies and techniques. And so it's been really good to see that. And then looking at, you know, we need to look at what's going to be our
174literacy focus for third through sixth grade. We made a really good push with our TK second grade teachers with core and looking at how we're using the science of reading. Now we need to start looking, what do we need to do with that for third through sixth grade. Emergent bilinguals, you know, again, we saw places where yes, there's improvement that's happening, yet we know we're still not where we need to be. And so we're going to be looking at that. And then we're going to look at what's going to be our literacy focus for third through sixth grade. And then we're going to look at what's going to be our literacy focus for fourth through sixth grade. And so, you know, how can we provide that support? What are some things and changes we need
175to make with what designated and integrated ELD? And how can we help provide teachers with that training that they need to help students, you know, learn English and help them with these components that we have? Students with disability continues to be a group that we want to get going on and helping out with making sure that we're seeing gains. We saw spot gains in others, but we want to be more consistent across our district and where those numbers are looking something more for our students can do and are capable of doing. And then low income students, you know, that data is very similar to what our overall data is, since we have such a high percentage of low income students. But we've seen gains, we've seen some things that are going down. And again, it's
176that comprehensive effort that we want to put in there to increase the scores and close those gaps. All right, so this is so where do we go from here? Next steps. We're going to complete the so in the next steps, we're going to complete the so in the next steps, we're going to really put forward the results to the other parts as early as possible. So as we waist with we see ready to go, just shortly, but within the next and a quarter of an 1964 survey. In past presentations, I talked about where we are headed as a district and what we've been working on the last, the last three years. Our district has been focused on a lot on teaching curriculum performance matter platform we hope that that is up and running completely next
177year and we'll be doing Benchmark assessments so we'll be able to look at some local data and really give us an idea of where we where we are headed in in terms of the Casp so Benchmark assessments will begin in the 25-26 school year will probably be be a full bore in terms of some grades some grades still may be developing and piloting we're still working through that here's the here's the what are we going to do about it so although the three-year cycle of CGI math training will end this year there it's a three-year training for those teachers who have not implemented by choice or still struggling Tim and I are going to work with dr. Linda Levy to put together a cohort that will include intensive coaching for these teachers so that they
178are implementing and I don't know whether that'll be a one year or a two-year stent but we we definitely when when we say 100 of the teachers will be on board we mean 100 of the teachers additionally the teachers who have resisted have not completed the CGI approach I say mandatory site another cycle we're we're still looking at that uh we may just do the intensive coaching and then in terms of our English learners I'm working with um Dr Ramirez uh to develop or put together an EL task force and we're going to begin that in February and then we're going to focus on integrated and designated uh ELD instruction any questions all right forget pizza shy people um so I want to focus on math a little bit I would tell you what number
179to go but I think they might be a little bit different um you know I think it's really clear when you look at the data that Elementary is it about what 30 percent say uh that's yeah so math in particular yeah roughly like you know District is 20 right a lot of those schools are above that and then go to the next slide and then we get to secondary and they drop off a cliff right right so and it's not to that that Isbell in Santa Paula High or whatever in Renaissance are doing something wrong right I think that there is this natural like transition between like sixth to seventh when kids just because it gets harder maybe more abstract right they're just trying to lose it you know and disengage and so I think
180it's just important right that you know when we're talking because you know I'm about Stan stem for sure right and we talk about PBL and all that other stuff right you know part of what that needs to do is to get kids excited about those fields right and math is critical right and so you know maybe part of that problem is that they're just in a math class that they go screw it right so you know there are opportunities that abound right we need to definitely like you know double down not just on the CGI training right but how are we addressing this drop off specifically and Isabel's going to have to carry a lot of that load right because that's where it starts you know what kind of program are we giving them you
181know allowing them to do right so that's I guess first observation you seem like you want to say something well no and and this was this was a conversation when I when I met with the principals on on Tuesday we we have as a district we've been heavily focused on Elementary and time to change pardon it's time to change yeah and we have and and and the the reason for that is because we keep we keep feeding into middle school and high school students that don't have the foundational skills they they can't read they don't understand math conceptually and so they get they get into the higher level math and they are struggling and so we wanted to shore that up as a district and fix that right um the principals made it very clear
182we need we need additional CPM training the the CPM math is our sixth seventh and eighth uh grade we need additional training so we have coaches right now that are working across the grade levels but we need to we need to intensify that and and and work on that even more actually CPM goes all the way through through high school so um we are focused on eighth and ninth grade math with the core uh with the um on track the course Elementary the on track initiative and so we're hoping to see some gains from that work and that's a three year or that's a three-year project um the I mean obviously sped right is I don't even know where to begin we don't have to go back to it okay but I mean I I
183don't even know where to begin to address that I mean basically if you hit sped in Santa Paula like you're not going to know any you're never going to have high scores like that's what those numbers show me right um and there are lots of reasons look at I had a sped child right I had down syndrome he wasn't gonna be scoring high on this right but you know I how do we get around that and I'm gonna have a similar question for emerging bilinguals but maybe I'll let you take that um we share try to at least but but but how are how are we addressing sped in particular so I'm gonna I uh he looks like had a long conversation with Dr Lawrence I'm gonna have her move this question would be asked
184okay so I mean yeah it's it's concerning right so I I think when we look at this though and we do look we do see progress being made I think the special ed teachers need to have the same level of training as our gen ed teachers have the same kinds of strategies that we're using in general ed we should use in our specialized classes and our kids should have and we're working on these things and we're seeing increases in in their time in general Ed but that also plays a factor you know getting more core instruction in the general ed class with their general Ed peers makes a difference so we're working on those kinds of things that we believe will help us see gains there um you know as far as like Barbara Webster
185who has you know they have a mod severe program and the cost scores weren't up here but many of the kids at Barbara Webster who are in specialized classes take an alternative assessment which isn't up here and and they do really well on our scores are really high there um but yeah I think it's a matter of inclusion on all sides and we should include that data here then too the teacher yeah the teachers being included in all and some are but I think they all need to be included in the same same training and using the same strategies I wouldn't I wouldn't understand why they wouldn't be right right so we're working towards those I think Mrs Smith then oh yeah and well and some of those strategies that we want to use and
186at the high school, middle school, and we do push-in supports at the elementary school, but to help support kids in the general ed setting, you know, would be some of those push-in supports and co-teaching and inclusive strategies like that. I mean, don't get me wrong, right? There's a part of me that's like, why are we wasting our time on these test scores, right? It's two numbers. They don't define our children, right? At the same time, I remember taking these tests. They should be able to do them, right? And so, kind of, you know, two minds of those. Did you, do you look like you were ready to, like, say something about this issue? Well, I was just here to kind of reinforce what Dr. Lawrence is saying and also just make sure there's clarity on
187the fact that we do have special education teachers that are participating in the CGI training that are getting that. I think that's why we're doing it. I think that's why we're doing it. We're seeing some improved scores along that, both RSP teachers and special day class teachers. And I also think one of the reasons we're seeing gains in language arts at particular school sites is because of the core initiative that we've been doing and the intervention that we're providing students. Giving students the basic foundational skills of phonics and phonemic awareness has been a very big game changer for many of our students, including our SPED students, because they're now being successful with their reading skills and we're seeing those gains. It's slow because it takes, it takes time for these things to get caught up
188and for them to show up in test scores like this. But we are seeing those gains, particularly when we're looking at our SPED students with the core data, the Hegarty data and Litterbly data. You know, and, and I think that, and I'll shut up and let someone else talk. I gave you the chance. I think that you pulling out that CGI, graph, that was the, that was the one graph that was the most interesting to me out of the whole deck. Right. And it's, I think you need to do this more, right? I would have liked to have seen that kind of same graph with the literacy, right? That we've been doing. I mean, no, that's K2, so it's a little harder. So we'll be able to do that more with the three, five, right?
189But we need to show that interventions are, are making a difference. Right. And I think what Mr. Smith was just saying, talking about that whole echo sphere that surrounds what's going on is important for us to hear because we're about to slash a lot of money. Yeah. And I feel like we're doing it without this context, right? We can't do it all, right? We can't, but what's working, what's not, and let's make decisions about what we cut. Right, because, but what's working is our will, right? So those are the two key things. Okay. And I think that maybe we have to look that way, as opposed to, you know, just saying, oh, you know, here's a bunch of, you know, intervention teachers, let's just get rid of half of them. Right? I mean, is that
190the right thing? Like right thing, monetarily, right? Is it the right thing, you know, for progressing in this, you know, on these scores? Yeah, no, I'm done. Phillip P.: Yeah. So I definitely want to chime in and, and give a big congratulatory regarding our reclassified students I mean again I've been saying time and time again and through many of our conversations that the the proof is in the pudding here when we reclassify our students we they tend to carry our load here and and these numbers are absolutely fabulous so if you can show slide 12 and 13 again that that would be huge right there because again it just goes to show again that when we when we give excellent or really solid EL instruction right then we get results like this in the aftermath
191right so can I piggyback on that comment right because it's like reclassification is so important right I would like to see you know periodic updates updates on where we're at with that you know how many are first was it first level six levels or whatever four levels right how many are in this and how long have they been there we need metrics to see that because without those metrics like it's hard to hold anybody accountable you know and this is I mean the difference between being an emerging bilingual and being a reclassified emerging bilingual right is life defining so that we need to be laser focused on those numbers and and and I think you're you're going to see I just want to say one comment and then I'll take it you're going to see
192that improve even more because across the across the district we have not been super clear in terms of integrated versus designated ELD instruction and that's one of the things with the with the task force that we are going to define it will impact master schedules middle school master schedules and high school master schedules because we have to we really have to get a handle on that in order to improve prove these scores and that's something that will happen through the task force good evening I just wanted to add because we do we are working very closely the middle school in the high school and ensuring that all of emerging bilinguals have an ELD class and we are very focused at the curriculum that we're giving them because we want them to be able to meet
193the criteria and I have to commend the middle school and the high school and of the elementaries because we're really looking at our students with disabilities who are also emerging bilinguals and looking at what criteria and is it their disability that's impeding them from meeting the criteria then we reclassify based on that purpose so we have been working very closely and you know we're working very closely with the school and the high school and the middle school right now they have three extra periods because they need that extra teachers to be able to service our emerging bilinguals definitely want to be I want to volunteer my time to be on the the ELD task force so I mean if they could be you know if I could attend them at a at a you know
194a desirable time right not in the daytime that would be awesome no it'll be it'll be a great day for us to be able to serve our emerging bilinguals no it'll be in the evening in the afternoon evening I love it so um you talked a little bit about benchmarks in terms of focus next steps are you talking are you referencing benchmarks in terms of IABs or are you referencing what teachers are using as summative or formative assessments in the classrooms so they can use those but um Dr uh Garcia is working so that the performance matters uh platform allows teachers to go in and build a platform allows teachers to go in and build a platform allows teachers to go in and build a assessments so the work that we've been doing just to
195kind of take you along we have had all of the teachers k-12 working on what we call priority standards so in other words in october from september to november what am i covering then we are coming along the back side and saying okay now let's develop a benchmark that measures our progress on the standards that we've taught the standards you teach a whole year of priority standards or standards that really should give an indication those benchmark assessments should give an indication of how we might do on a on a casp assessment so you're saying that the benchmarks are s back like they're s back ask that's the goal okay that that that is the goal and yeah because not it's not enough just to have a multiple choice because right casp is no longer multiple
196choice right it's there's a the writing component so it's it's vocabulary based and and i just want to make sure that that if we the benchmarks assessments are are more in lined with casp right s-back right oriented so okay and then my final question is what's the hold up with performance matters what uh i mean we we kind of adopted the initiative last year i i i'm just trying to get a where are we at are we halfway through the the the completion of it are we close to the end we are uh uh i would say uh three quarters of the way through maybe yeah but i want to say you said what's the snag i want to address that because uh dr garcia has worked very hard we it took a while to
197get uh uh one of our rfps um approved right and so she could not start training and is in the middle of trying to uh backpedal a little bit and get that done so we really lost um we lost the the first semester in terms of the training but um so that kind of that kind of threw us uh behind you want to address that so in terms of performance matters as well as building the benchmarks uh this is really um about having a three year a three year timeline so last year what we did is we focused at mckevitt um and so as you saw in our data presentation tonight with regard to math i believe that was a major like a pretty significant factor in what we saw and so we started at
198mckevitt in order to build assessments in the system before doing a full district-wide rollout we built assessments and worked together with the tk through sixth grade teachers at mckevitt so that was phase one of the pilot this year we have been we built district assessment committees so we built committees uh tk through sixth grade right now we're also doing conducting trainings at the middle school and at the high school in order to teach them how to build items how to build assessments how to ensure that they are rigorous and aligned to all of the standards and there are a number of different uh resources and references that are all aligned to the standards framework that are very important that go from the cast item specifications to looking at deconstructed standards to understanding how we build
199rigorous items that really get to the depth and the depth of knowledge of each of the types of standards that exist so that's year two that is where we are right now each of the committees is building benchmark assessments um and ensuring that they are rigorous we do have some individuals who are piloting out there and then the third year is going to be full-blown implementation of the benchmark assessments we will have training um coming up in january so uh those two things are uh very connected and just and final i just want to just uh just go over the the bright spots um would you agree anyone can answer this that that each individual elementary site has had training in cgi and hegarty and reading uh our new reading science curriculum would you confirm
200that 100 okay now we we have there are a couple of outliers where uh they missed some due to uh being out on maternity leave and things like that but tim is he's working with them so that they they get their full training okay yeah so like if a student went to biddell school they would they would get a similar training that they would get at mckevitt right or at barbara webster or right okay yeah thank you i just want to say i want to say uh one more thing uh about uh santa paul unified school district we are and and i have to i have to commend the teachers i mean you know you have to you have to you have to you have to have to you have to you have to you
201have to you have to you have to you have to you have to you have to have those few that are that are digging their their heels in but it's a very small number santa paul unified school district is really guaranteeing that a student will learn to read and learn how to interact with text at a high level and they'll understand math conceptually you don't have a lot of districts doing that and and i really am looking forward you know four or five years down the line when you when you see these these students start going through the upper grades and middle school and high school will really see the the fruits of the of the hard labor of our of our teachers yeah sorry i have a question um in its regards to special
202education i hear that we're training our teachers in terms of integrating the gender education stuff like that but what are we doing with our paraeducators how are they being trained to support our teachers and to support our students directly since they are directly supporting or directly there for us a certain student or a set amount of students right so right so i think i think it's it's just it's very important to have a strong relationship with your students because they are students and they can be supportive of you know how they are and they can come in and out of school and get help on their own and so i think that's a really important part of our work. Right. So I will say we could do better on that, and we are going to
203do better. We have a professional development, and I think over 100 of our IAs will be doing a full-day training on January 7th. So we're starting. Definitely could improve in that area. Sorry. I was just going to share with you that we are actually working with our paraeducators and being able to learn how to support the students as they're working with the CGI world, which is the cognitive guided instruction. So when a student is faced with a word problem, we don't want them to give them the answer. We want them to support them, ask probing questions, and follow up with that way. So we are actually, we have our UCLA partners who are, are going to be working with our instructional assistants to do specifically that, because we do know that we need to also
204shift the way that they support our students, because, you know, they just, they want to do the best they can by saying, oh, you got to borrow. No, let's let them see how they decompose that, that 70 instead of that seven. So we are providing that training to them, and we did start that this year. Yeah. For the sake of time, I just have a very general question. This has all been very educational for me. I appreciate all the board members' questions. And all your, you know, very detailed responses. Do we find the results of the CASP test to be reflective of the students' grasp of the curriculum and the actual success in school? Well, that's a, that's a loaded question. It really is. One of the things that I want to, I want to.
205You didn't mean it that way. No, no, no. But it is, because we do have. Can I answer this question? There are, there are students who just blow it off and go, I don't want to do that. And you don't want to do that. And you don't want to do that. And you don't want to do that. You know, they, they mark, well, it's not pencil paper anymore. They, they, they just, they, they guess, right? So that's not a clear indication of what that student knows or is able to do in terms of, in terms of standards. One of the things that we're trying to do, we had a professional development with all of our teachers back in September. And we've got to stop saying, well, this doesn't define our students. This, this isn't who
206we, this isn't who we are. But it is the measure. And it really is, when you think of education, it, it is one of the north stars, right? We are tested at the end of the year. So what we're trying to do as a district, we're trying to focus on standards, assess progress on those standards, because all of those standards lead up to this big test that we're taking at the end of the year. So really trying to shift the conversation about, about that. So I, I think the answer is probably no, it doesn't really define what students, students know and are able to do, but for the, but for a large part of the students, it does. And so we've got to change our attitude about that, that assessment. It probably is not going
207to ever go away. And so how do we strategize and really show now in our district, that's one measure, right? That's the state measure. We we are putting together with our, with our performance matters, we're going to have a load of local. Okay. And so we're going to have a load of local measures. So when you talk about reading, you're going to know if our students are able to read, if they're not with our CGI, you're going to know if they understand conceptually math at, at the early grades or they don't. And so we're putting all of those things into place that will help us when we get to our CAASPP to do better on that assessment. But I think it's about, I think it's about changing how we view that, that, that test, because
208it is how we're measured in a lot of ways. I mean, it determines the housing prices sometimes in, in areas, it determines whether or not people are going to move to your community. So the standards are based on the standards framework. And when you go in and you look at the content standards for ELA, math, science, history, et cetera, across the board, that's really where the meat is. And so the CAASPP, it is a measure of what our instructional practices look like in the classroom. Right. And so is, is the CAASPP, you know, just like doc, you know, Dr. Moore indicated, it may be one measure, but it really reflects how our students are able to problem solve or write or read or analyze or critically think. And these are standards that look different than
209when we went to school. And there's been a lot of transformation as well as a lot of educational research. Right. And the standards frameworks have truly transformed. And we are building new types of students. So I think it's important for us to situate that and understand that we want teachers to not just be page turners in the curriculum, but really understand things on a conceptual level. Thank you. Any other questions? Anyone else? Student board members? Yeah. All right. Thank you for the presentation and all the questions. I think we learned a lot. And I know it's getting late. So moving on, Dr. Moore, I don't think you think you're next. Right. Item B, first reading of AP Biology textbook adoption for grades 9 through 12. Can I interrupt really quick? I'm sorry. May I be
210excused? Yes. Any other board members? Yeah. You guys have finals. So if you have things to do, please, you don't have to stay the whole meeting. All right. Are we ready? Okay. Yes, we're ready. Awesome. So this is the first reading for the AP Biology textbook. And just presenting that to you, that'll be a financial impact of about $7,000 for our grades 9 through 12. That textbook is currently posted in our website. And we'll be posting it in the lobby of our district office for 30 days. We'll come back to you in January for the approval. Do we have any questions about the first reading? Hearing none, thank you. Under information, item C, 2024-25 demographics and enrollment projections. And that will be presented. Here we go. Well, good evening. We have a question. We have
211a question. We have a sort of quick presentation. We did a full report that you could look through to see a whole lot more details. But I did want to go over some of the highlights of our enrollment projections and our demographic study. And then at the end, talk about some boundary options that we have looked at. And so our analysis is done by looking at information in the GIS program, geographic information system. And so here we show a map of the school district. And those red dots represent the students enrolled for this school year. We have multiple years of students in our system. So we can do a demographic analysis and look at the different trends. And of course, this boundary here is showing your high school boundary. Your elementary boundary is a smaller
212portion of this. On here we are looking at the elementary school boundaries. And so each color represents one of the elementary schools. Some of the main components besides understanding how to do this. And then we have a little bit of a summary of what we're doing. So understanding how those enrollment trends change over time in our different boundary areas. Is understanding the number of children being born each year. And we get that from the Department of Health every time a child is born. On the birth certificate we have the mother's zip code. And so that information is compiled by zip code whenever a child is born, no matter where they're born. And so we look at the zip code area that best corresponds with your school district. And that's the blue line on this chart.
213And then five years later we see how many students showed up in kindergarten. And so those lines have been transposed to match each other. And so the blue bars are historic kindergarten enrollment. And we see those kindergarten numbers have dropped a little over time. And then in yellow it's showing what we're projecting based on those one, two, three, four year olds that we're already aware that have been born. Now I want to show you a little bit of a picture of the blue line. Now once we get into our five and six year projections, right, we're having to estimate based on those trend lines. And the slight portion of red on those projections is how many of those kindergarten students we're anticipating coming from any new homes that are built over the next several years.
214Another way I like to visualize the data for you, this chart, the green bars represent our current school's enrollment. Whenever we're looking at enrollment data in our report, we are looking at the first week of October. And so we're looking at the first week of October. And so we're looking at the first week of October. And so as of the first week of October, this shows our enrollment by grade level. And that blue line you see running across the top there, when that grade started kindergarten, it shows how many students were enrolled. And so by comparing how many we started in kindergarten to how many are in the class today, we can see what happens to those classes over time. In some districts, right, we see those numbers grow significantly, some may decline significantly. Overall
215here, again, especially those first four years, we're almost staying stable. When we look at our sort of our middle part of that chart, our middle school grades, we have slightly fewer enrolled today than we started with. And when we're looking at our high school grades, again, it's pretty well coincides with what we started with. Of course, there's a significant increase between eighth grade and ninth grade because of those feeder areas in the district. And so as a high level overview, this shows 10 years of history and then six years into the future. This is color code by orange for our elementary grades, green for our middle school and blue for our high school grades. And so we can see over the last 10 years, we've dropped nearly a thousand students from about 5500 down to
216just under 4600. Now we look over the next six years, we do not see as much of a decline. We do see a decline over the next couple of years and then it's stabilizing. That is partly due to the fact that our birth rates, even though they've declined, they're starting to stabilize. And the second piece is that we are projecting just about 1100 new homes to be occupied over the next six years. And there's about 2000 homes being planned, but we anticipate only about 50 to 60 percent of those will be occupied. During the time of the next six years. So we're going to look at the time of our projections for this report. So at the end of our typical study, we always like to highlight, you know, what's our current enrollment, what's our
217projected enrollment in six years and what's our school capacity. And when we compare our enrollment to our capacity. That's what we refer to as our utilization rate. And so on here, if we have any items highlighted in red, it says we're projected to be over capacity and then typically we end up needing to consider boundary changes or program changes to alleviate those challenges or building new classrooms. Here we show we have adequate capacity. We do show that we do have a little bit of an impact when we show the orange color. We're in that 90% range and that can be a bit of a challenge. And so if we don't make any changes right we're okay at our campuses. As you can see, we have different size schools. We have different number of classrooms in
218our schools. And so there are some variances there. But in general, again, we're seeing a little bit of a decline and we do have adequate capacity based on our current attendance patterns. So then after completing that base analysis, we were then asked to say, well, what if we consider some boundary adjustments and that was based on the, of course, the superintendent's report today. And so we said, if we want to look at a basically as a grade configuration analysis. If we want to have an early childhood development center where we're looking at the preschool and TK students on one campus. How would that look in terms of boundaries and so using our experience and doing boundary analysis which again ranges all over the state. I think my very first Analysis I did in terms of
219any school boundaries was about 30 years ago, and it was for more park which is here in Ventura County. So I've been doing this a long time use that experience to help come up with some ideas for you. And so I did develop two different scenarios in the first scenario. Again, we had a lot of comments from the public on this tonight. I looked at what if we used McKevitt as our preschool TK center. And so basically the boundary for that school disappears because it would serve students throughout the entire district area for those grade levels. And then the remaining boundaries would be for our K through six students. And so this one example shows you how those boundaries could look again. Basically, the neighboring schools to McKevitt need to increase the size of their
220boundaries to help absorb the boundary that McKevitt used to Serve. And so it does again, we're still having neighborhood schools. It's just slightly different neighborhoods and we had previously. And so we drew up this scenario and then the other plan we looked at using Phil as our early childhood development center. And so In this one, the boundary Then goes to serve the entire district and we have to backfill that area with our neighboring schools. So again, two different scenarios. Again, we try to look at Where students are going to school as you as you saw in our report, there are some students that attend a different school than their boundary they live in. And whenever we have boundaries that are real close to where the school is located right like for example we're here at
221Glen city and the boundary line between Glen city and Blanchard are running right next to the school. So those situations like that lend to a lot of different transfer patterns. So those situations like that lead to a lot of different transfer patterns. So we looked at that we looked at, right, where the school is and try to keep that as central as possible compared to their boundary. so we looked at that we looked at right where the school is and try to keep that as central as possible compared to their boundary we look at the major highways and roadways We look at the major. Highways and roadways to try to minimize the crossing, but again. Different communities have different challenges. So we looked at all those factors. When developing these boundaries. It was with a
222large crowd. We had here tonight, I wasn't sure if we get some feedback and say well, we should draw our volcano. the line here instead of there but it was more over the whole concept of the change versus what are the best lines to draw in a boundary so we can get a lot of additional feedback as we go through a community process so anyway and again as we get more feedback from the board and the community we can draw new lines we have a computerized program where we draw the lines and then we generate these updated charts and these will show you what the projections are based on that scenario so if in this scenario here in plan a we show what our enrollments projected enrollments are what our utilization rates are it illustrates
223this plan works you'll notice we have that blue color there for mckevitt in this plan a where that becomes our tk school because i don't have a preschool enrollment but the tk would fill up just over half of that campus and so that leaves just under half available for a preschool program there and then again we ran the numbers for plan b and again this one we have space at phil for the additional preschool students based on that program that you would be implementing and so again it's we're here to help you through this process whatever services you need from us will definitely be helping you out to look at different options and so if you have any questions on the analysis we did we'd love to be able to answer any questions first of
224all i just i do want to say good job on on the analysis so i'm looking at plan a or plan b and either scenario would they re like let's say plan b okay would the other campuses but dale blanchard glen city mckevitt and webster would they be busting at the scenes would their classrooms be filled over the the limit are we looking at the combo classes and you know so I'm trying to get an idea of what our classrooms will look at and I want to just want to do a quick reminder I used to work at Webster Elementary and I remember having servicing 600 plus students so just that's my little side note so when I look at these numbers they don't look all too bad but would classrooms be busting at the
225seams anytime we're showing school with the orange color that's saying you know we're getting to that point where we're pretty impacted on our campus are we busting out the seems probably not again the in these scenarios that's two important numbers to look at one is that utilization right if we're getting up there to where we're you know 9899 and then we're busting at the seams but on the other hand the schools that are in orange here are the ones that are still having, you know, a smaller enrollment. Of course, there are smaller campuses in Glynn City. And so I would be concerned if we're trying to show the school with, you know, 700 or 800 students for an elementary campus. But in Orange here, we're still only running, you know, 300 to 400 students. And
226so I think that number is sort of the ideal size of an elementary school. So we have enough students there for our teachers to have some collaboration. Because once we get down, you know, down into the under 200 range, you know, collaboration becomes more of a challenge. And so I think these are workable scenarios. Again, depending on some of the concerns over certain neighborhoods, maybe it would be easier to get to a different campus than the one I've assigned it to. You know, there might be some minor adjustments that may want to be considered before a final approval is made. But, again, this sort of gives you that visual representation. Of what a workable scenario could look like. So is there, I mean, a couple things, right? So, I mean, the first thing that I
227think we should all remember is that utilization isn't just about, like, the whole campus. It's about your classroom sizes, too. Right? And so if you have a low utilized class size or site, you're liable, you're more likely to have a combo class. Because you don't have enough second graders and third graders to run, say, two. Right? In an efficient manner. You know, we have that problem right now with Blanchard, which is my second question. Is there anything that we can do about Blanchard? Because in any of these, if we leave it alone, if we go with A, we go with B, Blanchard is just underutilized. And so, you know, did you look at, you know, expanding that, expanding the boundary? Because I don't think it changed from where it is at now. It did not
228significantly change. Obviously, your boundaries or lines are pretty much moving in a sort of a north-south direction. And if we move Blanchard's boundary towards the east, we're going to be encroaching on the actual campus here. And so it's, there was not an easy shift. And so if you guys have some ideas on a different way to do that, I'd love to hear from you. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I mean, above Santa Paula Street is an easy one, right? Because that is more of a cohesive neighborhood, right? Then, then below it, like you could even pick off some of the below Santa Paula Street in the, from where I'm looking, right?
229I mean, but I don't want to go into, I don't want to draw maps with you right now, right? But, you know, because that's going to be a concern. I think Blanchard is going to be underutilized. And so, you know, I don't know. how you can address that um but even barbara webster at least in plan a has a problem right because webster and theo kind of compete with each other um and so you eliminate theo out of that equation right then barbara webster actually like hits it right and then bedell has that issue right because it's going to have that growth from harvest which we don't necessarily have to put those you know the harvest kids in bedell but then bedell is going to be underutilized so i mean i know i get that
230there's a shuffling of the deck here um and i was just i guess just throwing that out for you know for just not for discussion but at least for us to keep in mind right that that's what really this is about is it's trying to maximize the the classroom size right because i mean i think that one of the things and i don't know if you guys know this we were like second lowest class side maybe the lowest class side average in the county um you know we're not very efficient in terms of staffing those classrooms right now because we're so spread out and we're not getting the benefit obviously because we look like our peers so we're spending a lot of money you know to to have those lower classes sizes right so we
231can have the six schools so it's going to all be spread out i mean at some point it's like okay you're going to spend that extra money to keep that sixth school going or are you going to invest in professional development right because you ain't going to be able to do both um anyways i appreciate the puzzle that you have to deal with thanks i apologize uh community input um you you went into a little bit um how do we envision you know getting the community input um i mean we went through redistricting with with the county and then um you know community members and i think that's a good question i think that's a good question i think that's a good question i think that's a good question um the way we've been doing
232it is you know we're really looking at the what level of community um input are we looking at um when you do the uh trustee boundaries that you're referring to right it's a much simpler process. Where we're dealing with actual school boundaries, it's quite a bit more detailed and impactful, right? As we, if we just say, hey, let's shift this to make the numbers perfect, right? We might be moving hundreds of families when we try to minimize the change so that we're not impacting the whole district. So it's a different process. In terms of the feedback, I think there's, I think, two critical components of that. One is perhaps doing more of a survey to find out, right, is this type of change something we can get the majority of the community to support? You
233know, I've been to lots of these types of meetings, whether it's a board meeting, or we hold a more of a open house at one of the campuses to talk about specific boundaries or specific scenarios. It's, a lot of times when you have people show up at a board meeting, it's the people that aren't happy with the direction things are going. And so we heard that at your meeting this evening. But if there were 25 people that were like not so happy with what you're doing, you know, maybe there's 200 that are happy about what you're doing. We don't know that number. We only know the people that were upset. And so if we can do some kind of survey, we might get a better feel for, is this something that you're interested in? Is
234it something you're not interested in? Or is it something you need more information to make a decision? Because that's sort of the educational component. Of this type of a scenario. And then the other part is once we find out if we're going in a direction or not, right? We have the selection of which campus is best to implement. And then once that is known, then what's the best boundary lines to implement that scenario? So it's sort of a three-step process. And so most of the meetings I've been involved in are that last step is, you know, which boundaries make the most sense, right? We can't move a boundary too far without overcrowding a campus or making the number so small that we have to have combo classes and things like that. So those details are
235really some of the constraints that we have to be careful of instead of just letting the community draw what they think looks good for a boundary. We have to come up with numbers that make sense. And so once we get to the details of trying to fine tune boundaries, right? We can share with you enrollment, and then we can move on to the next step, right? So we have to make sure that we have the right enrollment by grade level for each of the schools to make sure we have numbers that make sense for your programs. And so, yeah, usually the type of input that we get is going to some open house types meetings to show enrollment projections for different boundary lines to get developed for a particular scenario. And then people will give
236us some feedback, say, well, this part of the neighborhood, it's hard to make that left-hand turn during rush hour. Or those types of local impacts that might make a certain neighborhood make more sense to go to one school than the other. Do we have any other questions? I just have, I'm sorry, one just quick question. On your first slide, you show the current boundaries. And I should probably know the answer to this, but for the students that we serve, don't we also serve just everyone within our school? Or do we serve outside of our city limits for the elementary? I know for the high school, we serve outside of our city limits. Because I'm looking at Blanchard and our city limits and like on Beckwith Road. And I don't see those neighborhoods as part of
237our area for Blanchard. The school district boundaries. They don't coincide with our city. Normally don't coincide with the city boundaries. Because the district boundaries are set from when the district was formed. The city boundaries are going to change a little bit over time. And so yeah, sometimes the city may have outgrown the actual district boundaries. So but. Because we have. Yeah, that part is in Briggs, actually. Yeah, we have two county schools, which is Briggs and then Mupu, and those are in the county. Right. But they take some of the city. But yet. Yeah. Those that residential that's so close to Blanchard, it doesn't make sense that it's part of Briggs if Blanchard is closer. Right. And that's why you get some inter-district students coming to your school from that district. OK, just wanted to
238double check if there was some regulations on that. That was it. Yes, it's interesting the way attendance patterns work because of the location of boundaries in relation to schools. Yeah, so Mupu will also affect students who live close to us. Right. Yeah, so. Well, I guess we have more work to do and really looking at that. I mean, another question is, is it common for to have maybe some overlapping neighborhoods who can choose which way? I mean, that's why we have the inter-district, but where if you do a radius within each campus and see where they overlap and allow those parents to choose without making it such a big issue. Yeah, I mean, I think that's a great question. I think that's a great question. I think that's a great question. Yeah. Yeah. I have
239worked with a couple of districts in our state that have a area that they say, OK, you could choose this school or that school because they're sort of in an area that's in a, you know, they can't, you know, it's difficult to assign it all to one school because it was a space issue. And so they allow those neighborhoods to choose between the two schools. So that's I've seen that it's rare, but that is something that could be considered if you want to give some flexibility. The challenge is there, though. You might have two kids across the street from each other that chose different schools. And so they're they might they could be friends and go to different schools. So but again, it's it is something that has been done. But I do see that
240your report does outline how many students are transferred from other districts that are actually there's less kids from that neighborhood going to that school. I don't know if you did a chart to show. I believe there was in the full report. Yeah, we have what we call the attendance matrix. It compares. Where a student lives compared to where they go to school. Was there a school that had more than half of the students being transferred from other districts? I know. I don't believe our normal ratios we see is usually, you know, anywhere from 10 to 15 to 20 percent on average might choose a different school than the area they live in. Unless there's some very special programs, you know, if you had a campus that was focused on a deal. I. Was in our
241gate. Or. You know, things like that, then sometimes we see some unique patterns with those types of programs. But your numbers seem to be right in the realm of pretty typical attendance patterns. Okay. Thank you. Um, my concern was also the overlapping, like, potential, because as a kid where I where I live, I was supposed to go to McKevitt, but apparently it was too filled. So I had to go to school in Barber. Webster. And then since I lived pretty far away from Barber Webster, eventually my stepmom was going to put me back, put me, change me into McKevitt because she couldn't take me to school anymore. Because so because McKevitt would be closer, but it was still full. So I had to go to Glen City. So I don't know how the boundaries actually
242work because they didn't, like, really apply to me. Because I went to schools across, like, the city. And I was like, I'm not going to go to school. I'm going to go to school. I'm going to go to school. I'm going to go to school. I'm going to go to school. I'm going to go to the city. Well, I live, like, not in the middle of the city, but McKevitt was supposed to be, like, this school I was supposed to go to. And then some kids on my block, they were going to McKevitt. So I don't know. It was confusing for me as a kid. Yeah. And, again, one of the questions that was brought up earlier was nice to see why the attendance patterns are the way they are. And again, we're documenting the
243numbers to say, well, there's this many students. there's this many from this school that are going to that school and again there's all sorts of reasons for transfers sometimes it's because you know that's where the parent works or in that neighborhood so they want the kid going to school close to where they work other times it's that's close to where the daycare center is or that's where the grandparents live you know lots of different reasons but one like yours right if this there's not room for you at the school you're supposed to go to then you have to go to somewhere there is space available and so those are typically referred to as overflow situations the fact that your schools have a lower enrollment now than they did over the last 10 years there's probably
244not as many situations where that is impacting where a student can go to school but we still will end up with situations where even though our enrollment is much lower than our capacity if all of our third grade classes are full and another third grade student enrolls right what do we do so there's always going to be those situations that arise unfortunately but yeah we look at all those factors when we look at our enrollment projections any other questions thank you you're welcome okay i'm sorry i'm losing my voice um item nine action items superintendent acceptance of grant deed for 32 palm court so we are at the close of escrow for 32 palm court and the to close escrow the escrow company needs us to accept the um grant deed and um just a
245reminder this is on 32 palm as well as it costs 749 thousand dollars so move oh yeah you can do program yeah yeah i'll make a motion to approve i'll second you have second thank you um preferential vote um preferential vote i'll second i'll second thank you um preferential vote all those in favor i haven't done the preferential votes this there's um as long as it's not a personnel hr then our student board members can vote on the items we have a first and a second all those in favor all right item b educational services approval purchase of furniture for the santa fe high school new building and construction classroom new health health care and wellness classroom and a teacher collaboration room this is a seventy two thousand dollars six hundred seventy two thousand dollars
246six hundred dollars uh for a the building and construction trades and they're they're in the process of uh remodeling the ag warehouse for the um and this this comes out of the cte grant and it'll service our health and wellness and teacher collaboration teacher collaboration prep room so we're seeking approval the grant money uh director now ornelas let me know that this is a grant that needs to be spent by december 31st so we're on a timeline i'll make a motion to approve the purchase of the furniture for this uh building a second okay versus second do we have a preferential vote i'm sorry any discussion first i apologize any discussion hearing none so we'll go to a preferential vote all those in favor thank you passes board all those in favor passes thank you
247so now we're moving on to section c business services for approval of following items submitted by dr williams chief business officer item one approval of resolution number 2024 2025. interfund cash transfer from fund 14 deferred maintenance to general fund 01 general fund 01. any questions i did have one for mr weinstein um because we had talked about and i think in the budget meeting using this for pars so to fund pars right so now we gotta get that from somewhere else no not necessarily because whether we do pars all in one year or multiple years it's going to come out of the general fund Yeah, but I guess the idea was that we had this kind of tucked away, right? And we could use that. Like right now it's going to go in there for
248this year? I mean, we're spending it this year? It would go in this year. Also, you know, we haven't approved PARs yet. So the board has to take action on that on January 8th. And once that's approved, we can integrate it into our second interim. And just keep in mind the budget is for a current year and two consecutive years. So we do have a portion of PARs in there. It will be updated once we have our final list. PARs is running about $2 million approximately over the five years. My concern is that when this first came to us, I think maybe in August, we raised concerns about not doing this. And. And being part of the budget committee, we never talked about this. I don't remember having this discussion. And so now it's being
249brought up again. And I feel like then we're selling ourselves short because we do have other projects and, you know, other projects that need to get done in terms of maintenance and whatnot. I don't know. Dr. Williams, I'm just I guess I'm sharing my own discontent. Maybe I missed it, but I thought we were not in agreement with this in August. And I'm I'm asking why are we asked to do this in December? Excellent question. I think the conversation was that we would wait until first interim to determine if there was really a need for this transfer. And based on the second interim budget, there is a definite need. Whereas if it does not happen, we would be showing a negative in our third year out, which would change our positive certification to qualify. And
250that has a lot to do with those restricted expenditures that are in funds that are going to be expended. So we're looking at the multi year, not just as this year, but we're looking at the package and that's what we're required to do at second year. So we're looking at the multi year, not just as this year, but we're looking at the package and that's what we're required to do at second year. And that's what we're required to do at second year. And that's what we're required to do at first general. I'm sorry. My follow up question. Do you anticipate that we'll be having to make this kind of transaction again in the future? Because if that's the case, that we really need to dig a little deeper and and maybe really cut some more
251expenses. I mean, you said it in an earlier presentation. Our expenditures are are greater than our, you know, our revenue. And again, as a board member. I think that's a great question. As a board member, that that has to be very concerning, because one again, i'm on the budget committee, and and I didn't hear this, and I know we had other discussions that took a little bit of priority. But so maybe the first question is, do you anticipate that we'll be asked to do this again in the future? I think you have an excellent point you pointed out that our expenditures are outpacing our revenue. And so I think that's going to be critical that the budget committee takes a very critical look at expenditures, because, based on that statement, we must make additional reductions.
252The 6 million that we put down on paper was mitigated or offset due to expenditures that we needed to bring back over into the general fund. So it really wasn't 6 million. So I agree. There's more work that needs to be done in identifying reductions. to continue. We continue having a positive certification. The final question would be is so if we're gonna bring a transfer over 4 million dollars. What's our ending balance in that particular fund? If we agree with it, I believe it's about 250,000, and our routine restricted maintenance is also being used to help with maintenance repairs. So it's not like the work won't get done. We are contributing. We're contributing that 3% from the general fund to routine restricted maintenance to ensure that our field facilities get the needed repairs. It's just
253upsetting to know that we have to pull 4 million from a deferred maintenance that we've been diligently placing that money, and I just I mean, I guess I'm gonna be very blunt. But I think we've been seeing the numbers and that we're not running our schools very efficient. That we're we don't I don't want to say full capacity. But at least avoiding combo classes. So I think things have been presented tonight is to, I guess, in a nice way just to show where we are in numbers in our schools. And as we've been told over and over it's the staffing that is the 80% of our budget. So how did we get 4 million in the hole that we need to pull money from? Yes. We need to pull money from the mains of our
254buildings. It's important, you know, for our students to have well lit classrooms. A C. Windows clean floors. But if we're not running our schools at a decent capacity, just as the numbers were shown like we could be at 65%. We should be 80 ish. So I'm not on the budget committee. But I just think it's. Time that we can't do this again next budget. We really need to make some hard decisions and you know, just lay it out and have the town hall meetings to show if we do, you know, need to consolidate or think of how we're going to repurpose a school. And as our consultant was presenting, you know, showing you know, why is it so much lower at Blanchard or more at grace? Still, I mean, all my 3 kids went to
255Mckevitt. And I had to. Same thing as Jenny. One year she had to go to Glen City because they didn't have enough students. I'm sorry they have room for her and it went okay. She came to Glen City because it's the larger campus, and then she got to go back her last year. So it's just we can't do this again. I mean, we hear some information not on you, but it seems like the numbers are not changing much. We have the statistics and we're doing what we can to improve our Ada. But we've been on. We've been operating on a higher. Is it Ada number or after Covid at a higher. Yeah, the whole harmless. So it's it's clear we're not going to have that money, and we just need to show you know facts.
256We I recall before Covid they laid off so many teachers are saying nope, and and we lost all these programs, and then we're bringing it back up. We're not being fiscally sound by operating all these campuses. I mean I grace, they'll make have it I mean they're architecturally the the smallness. I mean this is a small town. We all have history and all on all the older campuses. But something has to be done, and I mean just like trustee fruit shows is saying, you know it's like, Why? How did this happen? The 4 million? How was it? But not on you, and I know you know our utilities things went up the cost insurance everything. I mean even our own homes. I mean people know what they're paying more in insurance and water. But with
257that said, I just and if I could just add the the office of public school construction. We, as a district, are receiving reimbursements for projects that we're paying for. And we brought that contract to the board of maybe a month or so ago, and then I did a board update. So those funds can also be used for repairs. So our schools won't go without it just not made it's not gonna be in the fund label deferred maintenance. But we have millions of Opsc reimbursements that will continue to be used to offset the general fund. I don't have that balance with me but that funding sources there that's not completely accurate right I mean because I mean we have we do have a list of $200,000,000 of projects. I mean, and we can talk about whether
258they're necessary or not. But you know we're not we're never gonna get that kind of money right we have like we don't have that kind of money right now in the bank, and that's not I mean we're gonna have to make choices on what we're gonna do right I mean it'll help for sure. Right? No doubt that that money helps but it's not game changing money. So unless we were to go for a bond again which third time's a charm. Just kidding public just kidding. But to your point though Dr. Sandoval, I mean, I feel like we're, we're, we're not really balancing our books, the way we should be. If it. And I see a lot of excess. In our media. In our meetings, and I know we've talked about this over time. Again, I
259it's something we have to do. I think you're telling us that it's got to get done. We don't do it. We're qualified budget. That's not what we want as a board. We do not want to be in a qualified budget. We want to be more fiscally responsible. But now I'm going to take on that second word responsibility. We're not being responsible, and with all the there's several spending that we've got. So that conversation needs to continue. And there's got to. There's got to come to a point where we have a spending freeze, a spending moratorium. I've been there. I've lived it. I personally have been affected by it. And and that's okay. We're resilient. We're resilient community. We can. We can overcome this. So. So I guess I'll be the one. I'll make a motion
260that we approve. Item. Here at C. one, I believe. Yes. Yes. Can I ask for a roll call before I make this second? Oh, I'll second. I'd like a roll call. Okay. So we have a first and a second. Any further discussion. So I'll start with preferential vote. All those in favor. Okay. Passes and roll call vote. Trustee. Yes. Trustee. Yes. Trustee. Yay. Trustee. Ye. Trustee. Yeah. . Yes. Yes. Trustee. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you. I appreciate all the information. And thank you for bearing with us and our questions and. No problem. Understanding where we we're coming from. Thank you. So on to item four. Okay. All those in favor. A. item numbered oh yes it is see see to approval of 24 25 first interim budget fiscal stabilization plan Dr Williams I just
261want to say thank you to the budget committee the fiscal stabilization plan was created with the team this is just a snapshot of right now more information more conversations will happen this will be updated and brought back with the second interim but of as of right now based on what we've identified and what has been built into our multi-year projections asking the board to approve our first interim budget fiscal stabilization plan any discussion yeah this one ticks me off because this is a piss poor way to tell the district what we're thinking about right and you know I know we were in this in this discussion and we have a lot of cuts to do yes right but a lot of people learn this by the posting you know about things that could affect them
262that is unexcusable right one of the root things that what was one of the goals is on communication right we have got to do a better job at saying what we're going to do right we've got to bring people along because these are people's lives that we're talking about and so you know I don't ever want I'm going to have to yes to this because apparently we have to to have a qualified budget but if this comes again like this and I will vote no I don't care what it does we get a qualified budget tough right we need to engage our stakeholders better than we are on this right which includes having at least two principles like we did before in the last iteration of our budget meeting in those budget meetings because they
263need to be alerted to what's going on sooner than they happen so I don't want to get any more calls about what the heck's going on all right thank you anyone else look I know this plan is not enticing it's not entertaining a lot of us are not going to walk away happy I know when Mr Frutos talked about how he's been on the back end of budget cuts so have I especially in district since I went through here at K through 12. Unfortunately, I will not speak for my other colleague, but we are coming into this budget and we have to do the fiscal responsible thing. I do share Dr. Sandoval's sentiment in terms of communication. We do have to do better in terms of communicating with our stakeholders. And I definitely would like
264to see a follow-up in terms of how we're going to communicate to our stakeholders in terms of dispersing this information. So that way the burden is not shouldered on us board members, especially when it comes to parents, because parents will not know who to turn to. Well said. Thank you. And if I could just add the last page of the fiscal stabilization plan is our implementation plan. And we've been having communication with departments and with our school site leaders, and we will continue to do that and reach out even greater to all of our stakeholders. So we will definitely expand on that. So thank you for that feedback. Do I have a motion? I'll move to accept the table of the station plan. I second. Okay. It's the second. Do we have a preferential vote?
265All those in favor? Aye. Thank you. Board, all those in favor? Aye. Aye. Passes. Thank you. So moving on to item three, award of contract, Santa Paula High School Baseball Field Lighting Project. Thank you. We're bringing forth our contract selection, for the Santa Paula baseball field and where Quincon is the lowest bidder. And this includes six lights and fencing work on the field. Any comments, questions? So I do have a comment or a question about, we had been told about discussions about having the field done at Harvest Park. Okay. All right. And so, you know, and trustee Fruit does forgive me for what I might do to your baseball team, but I mean, our. We don't want to. You can have it. But if it's there, it's there. It's not. Well, because I mean, I'm
266just like, cause again, we just lost our bonds, right? You know, is this a priority project for us, given that we're not going to get everything that we want on that. List like, I mean, I'm just wondering whether that makes sense or not. I mean, how often does anyone know the lighting the necessary? Cause I know like games start sooner. Are we the only school that doesn't have lighting? From what I understand, it's not a baseball issue. It's a baseball field location issue. Our games don't get impacted as a baseball coach. Our games. I've been on the squad for over 15 years. They're not going to get impacted whether there's lighting or not. So ask the question. Your board member. So what was the the impetus for, you know, this project? You know, if they're
267not going to impact or allow us to play more games or provide, you know, better facilities for practice or the actual games, you know, kind of what was this project get started? What was the intent? Oh, at the high school level, um. The teachers gave us feedback that. Because we now start a half an hour later. That the, that the teams in general. Are asking them to the kids to leave class and go. To the field, however, if we put in lights, then that won't be an issue. Because you can play night games. That's not going to be the case. That's you're, you're talking about. You're you're only referencing. Non-league schedules because league games are always going to be at 315. That's guaranteed. So students will be asked to be released. And if anyone's complaining
268about it, I'm sorry, but welcome to high school athletics. It's that's just the culture. It's been that way forever. Um, so I, I, I, I guess I. I guess I don't understand it. So again, it didn't generate from a baseball program. Now who can benefit let's go on that. There's there's a good conversation that you got banned who can benefit from this. You got a potential parking that can benefit from this. You have tennis that can benefit from this. You got the community that could benefit from this. And then of course, baseball could benefit. But we're not, we're not the driving force. Baseball is not the driving force. So again, I don't mean to argue with DJ. Do you, do you have any thoughts on that? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
269Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So would we like to have it, of course, but I'm, I'm a little bit with Dr. Sandoval. I mean, are we really being, are we really being. You know, fiscal responsible by in a, in a project like this, but I don't know, you know, is this, is it grant funded Dr. Williams or No, sir. This is coming out of measure Q Q Dr. Williams, is there a financial impact if we reject the resolution or the prospect of this, if this. If this is placed on hold, this will we wouldn't be spending the 1.2M. That's the financial impact for the work to be done. It would. We would just not move that money out of a measure. Q. It would remain there. And then a little bit deeper measure Q funds could
270then. Go into other projects, like, possibly bright and jam. Is bell renovation and whatnot is not as well. Not as well. No, it's just high school. Just high school. Okay. The band complex, the pool. That whole list of things that we were salivating over going. Boy, can't wait to do those. Well, we can't so. I would at least like to before we move forward, I would like to. Revisit that list of projects. Look at our priorities actually set them this time instead of just hoping that the public is going to vote 1, you know, this 1 time right to get those bonds. So, I mean, I think it's part of our responsibility to use those funds and not just say, oh, 1.2M, go for it. Well, that was kind of what I was thinking. It
271would be nice and helpful for me as a new board member to to kind of understand what are the other needs? What are the other priorities? And then be able to make that. I guess a little bit more of an educated decision. You know, just coming from Fillmore, you know, where I used to live, there was a definite need for for lights on the baseball field so that you can have more kids practicing and whatnot. It's a different situation. But, you know, you can get a lot more use out of a field by putting lights on it essentially allows you to double it. But with with all the other items that need to get done on our campus. You know, and. You know, and. You know, and without knowing, you know all of those in
272a ranked priority type of list, it really feels like I'm making a decision somewhat in the dark. So I'm with Trustee Sandoval on, you know, having a having a priority list presented to us to help us make this decision. We're happy to do that. We presented to the board. I think it was 2 months ago on all of our projects. So with our new board members, we're happy to come back to the board and share what those projects are and provide you a status of order. What's being. in any way possible for you next time you want to get done on campus, you're happy to pass this put on your NASH down onto your campus. That's my previous thought around that happy to do that. And unfortunately, it happens having just gone through all of
273that. I do have to recuse myself. I live within 500 feet of this project. I mean, I was I don't have to. Okay. All right, then I'll vote. So do we want to bow or do we want to table it? Or what options do we have? We need a motion to table or do we have so do we have a motion to approve the project? All motion. Okay, great! motion to approve the project do we have a second hearing none so dies for lack of emotion so now do you have a motion to table it or do we just we can just move on so we'll just we'll be tabled thank you thank you okay moving on to item four approval of dsa fees for green schoolyard grant projects thank you um we are asking
274the board to approve um the per the fees that we will need to pay dsa for the plans for the three schools dsa requires us to submit the check before we submit the plans the actual plans will be submitted within the next three weeks they were presented to the board in november and there were only minor tweaks since that presentation so we're asking that this is approved to pay the dsa fees and this will this cost will be reimbursed by our grant um program for this project any discussion do i have a motion so moved to your second i second a preferential vote all those in favor aye thank you board all those in favor aye aye passes thank you moving on thank you um we're bringing this to the board um to ask for
275approval for ventura transit system which provides transportation for our athletes at santa paula high school they are in desperate need of getting their teams to various uh events and games so we're bringing this forward um for transportation do you have any discussion on that um i'm not sure if we have any other questions um no i'm sorry and this will be paid from our supplemental and concentration funds question will the buses be strictly only for athletics it says athletics and field trips i thought is what i read am i correct okay yes uh school pupil activity and athletics activity so just pure athletics no no school pupil activity whatever that is it's not really defined here okay so i was wondering since how far can these buses go or how far are they contracted to
276go um that will depend on each trip request again and it depends on the request from the high school so i don't think there's a limitation to where how far they can go it just needs to be an approved trip that's followed all of the guidelines in order to allow that to take place okay i'm gonna use this to my advantage Right. But they have to be approved. Do you have any discussion? I only have a question. We've been talking about this for years, and why is it until now that a contract is coming? Because I think we used different providers. Yeah, we used different providers. Did we lower our insurance requirement? We were always having issues for all the years I've been on the board. With this particular vendor? No, not with this particular
277vendor. I mean, athletics in general, we've had a lot of late cancellations from our existing transportation services where it'll be 3 o'clock and they're like, hey, we can't get somebody there to drive the team. So what we decided to do was to we vetted a few companies and tried to make it that they guarantee that they'll guarantee that they have the buses as well as the vans. Are we paying more because they're assuring this in what we're currently paying? Well, we're not going to use FATCO, so that means that whatever money we were giving FATCO goes to them. No, but were they charging us less FATCO? Are we paying more because now we're in a contract? No, they're not. Okay. So we're not matching contract for contract? Well, I don't know if they had like
278a five-hour. Well, no. So FATCO does all our SPED. It also does the outskirts of town. And that's twice a day they're going. I was just a question. With all the problems that they had, I'm happy with the contract. I was just wondering if we're paying more now, if we're increasing our expense by doing it like this where they have a five-hour limit and a minimum. No, it shouldn't increase our overall expenses for athletic transportation and field trips. But I think that even if FATCO is less, if they cancel at the last minute, it doesn't really do us any good. Yeah. No, I'm just saying for purposes of budget, like just where we're at, our numbers. But that was my only question. Do I have a motion to approve? So moved. Second. You have another
279question, Jenny? No, I just wanted to motion to approve, but never mind. Oh, I forgot you guys can do that too. Preferential vote. All those in favor? Aye. Passes. Board, all those in favor? Aye. Passes. Thank you. Item six, approval of the 2425 first interim report with a positive certification. Any discussion? Do I hear a motion? So moved. Second. All those in favor? Aye. Passes. Thank you. Item six, approval of the 2425 first interim report with a positive certification. Any discussion? Do I hear a motion? So moved. Second. All those in favor? Aye. Passes. Thank you. Second. Do I hear a second? All second. Preferential vote. All those in favor? Aye. Passes. Board vote. All those in favor? Aye. Passes. Thank you. Still you, huh? Item seven, approval to the retainer agreement with Arbach, Huff,
280and Henderson LLP to assist the district in specialized areas of law and related legal matters. And this is mainly to support us in the construction of the building. And this is mainly to support us in the construction of creating our construction delivery methods. The firm that we currently have is inundated and not able to get back to us in a timely manner, so we want to be able to have a choice of another attorney on our books to be able to move our work forward as we're looking at lease-leaseback with moving forward with Brighton Gym and Inland Reef. So, this particular contract, any services would be paid out of our capital projects bond dollars. Any discussion? Do I hear a motion? First and second. I'm first and Justin, you have a second. That was the
281other one. That was the previous one. No, this is right another one. Let's do it again, Tommy. Do I? Let's do it again. I need to walk away and come back. Okay. So, we have a motion to approve the lease-leaseback agreement. Second. All those in favor? Aye. Passes. All those in favor? Aye. So, I'll make a motion that we approve item eight seven. And I'll second. Second from Mejia, so preferential vote? Aye. Aye. Thank you. Passes. Board vote. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Thank you. Passes. Item eight, approval, approval, a ratification, CSP farm management agreement. So, this farm management has been doing work for the district. Yes. We've been doing work for the district over the last year, but there was no contract in place. So, we're bringing a contract forward so that we
282can pay their invoices. Any discussion? I do have a, we're not, we're going to, I'm going to have a yes for this, but that means that's right, we owe them money. But I really just got to wonder, like, what is the educational benefit for this, like, if we're having a company come and do trees and then harvest the fruit and then that pays this back? If we're going to spend money on a farm. I think we're losing, right, on the. Are we losing? On the harvest? Yeah. Sorry to interrupt, but. No, go ahead. This is the part where we, once we had other issues, we stopped our farm committee. It was going a different direction. So, it's probably something that I need to. Pick up again and ask to have that farm committee because we're
283losing out on a lot of educational items. We had some discussions in that farm committee about certain contractors who were willing to teach our kids and they were activities of how to pick and there's so many options. I mean, there's so much going on in the county that we're, we're just not doing what we can, but at the same time, the staffing is an issue as well, but having a vendor who can also educate our students would be. Very helpful. So yes, I'm also a little irked, but there was other priorities. So. Pick and choose our battles. With that said, any other discussion? And do I have a motion? I moved to approve the ratification of the agreement. Jenny. I second the ratification. Okay. With that, a preferential vote. Aye. Thank you. Board vote. All
284those for aye. Thank you. All those in favor. Aye. Aye. Thank you. And then nine approval of donations and we have, thank you. Close my. We have two donations, one from Ventura County Community Foundation. Right. Actually. They're both. They're both from. Two different. Ventura County Communication and one is for career technology education program and community engagement initiatives in the amount of $640. And the other one is to Glen City. And the other one is to the Global STEAM Academy and the amount of $320 for a total of $960. Thank you so much. So we have to vote to accept the donation. And do I have a motion to accept our donations? So moved. Second? Second. Preferential vote. All those in favor? Aye. Passes. Board vote. All those in favor? Aye. Thank you. Item D, human
285resources. Item D, human resources. Item D, human resources. Item 1, establish one new five and a half hour child nutrition services assistant at Santa Paula High School. Good evening, board members and anyone who's still awake and watching this. I'm presenting this on behalf of the classified HR director who could not attend today and owes me big time. I am presenting a recommendation to approve a new child nutrition services assistant one position at Santa Paula High School. This is a 5.5 hour, 10 month position with an annual financial impact of approximately $26,500. The position is needed to address increased meal preparation demands as meals participation grows and more meals are cooked from scratch. The current staffing levels are insufficient to maintain operations. Staff have been reassigned between kitchens, creating shortages in kitchen number one, the new
286position will help ensure that both kitchens are adequately staffed to support meal preparations for our students. I'll make a motion to approve item D1, establish one new 5.5 hour child nutrition services assistant. Do I hear, do you have a second? I'll second. Any discussion or comments? Students? Just one, for education, the child nutrition services has its own budget and that is, you know, a little bit of a surplus. All right. So... Thank you. I know there's been feedback from the student council about how the lines move slow, so I'm hoping this will help. Kudos for all the input. I mean, having more staff at the cafeteria and the, well, at the high school would be really nice because us students, we work really hard to keep the lines moving. So, I'm a student worker. It's
287always nice to meet all the actual, like, students. It's always nice to meet all the actual, like, paid nicely cafeteria workers because all the student workers get is minimum wage. I'm not complaining. And free food. Oh, we still have to put in our ID number. Okay. That's... They don't get a perfect join on that. No, because it's HR. So, we'll move on to a board vote. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Passes. Thank you. Thank you. So, moving on to item 10, consent count. 10? No. calendar action item consent items are considered routine and will be enacted by a single motion none of the items will be discussed unless a board member requests discussion prior to the vote of the motion to adopt the consent calendar do we have any items to pull I want
288to pull item D1 just for question purposes and that would be certificated personnel activity report so um yeah I mean you can are you guys okay with just discussing it first before we vote on everything else yeah yeah we can vote on everything else and then do that one separately yeah so you don't want to so I moved to I moved to uh approve the consent calendar minus uh the certificate of human resource activity report I second okay all those in favor say aye aye passes okay moving on thank you so the only question I have for for you um Dr Dunn that's gonna sound awesome um and again it's not a not a negative but but I'm just curious so I noticed on there there's a steam Tosa that's that has a stipend of
289almost 3 000 for steamsters um can you explain that I'm not sure what that is I don't remember sorry my apologies that's what I'm wondering because because I'm wondering if if it's Tosa isn't it flexible hours and shouldn't they be already doing after school hours and not paying additional that's what I'm working and is it a lot funded or I don't know I'm sorry I'm trying to remember the position um this was these were carry over from last month so they didn't make it onto the November um so I can't pull it let me let me get there as well do you have yours thank you Dr thank you young steamers what letter is it uh it is letter um 4C young steamers Glen City uh it's affected I mean it's three percent nineteen hundred
290dollars she's a teacher so I mean it's not carry over from last year because it's a new uh new position here at Glen City I see I see so this is a stipend position this is an additional coin Club club that the steam Tosa is doing at Glen City that's after school hours outside of her contractual time so so she's running an additional group can you see why I would have a concern with that because a Tosa should be flexible hours why didn't agree on that didn't we agree on when we had when we did approve the position that it would reach into our after-school program so again that's kind of what i'm looking at and and and that's why when i see these i mean i think now again i'm just sharing i'm very
291frustrated right now when it comes to budget i i just feel like we keep saying here you go here you go here you go and we're not pulling back on any of the rings and um i actually i agree with you and um i had a discussion today with um uh laurie toms about doing uh cost analysis of additional how much additional duties under you know article 14 um extra duties and stipends um how much we're spending on that so i can bring that to the budget committee the next time we meet um because i share your concerns okay i'm going to make a motion to move to approve it i'm sorry sorry the whole thing i'm sorry yes you're absolutely right excuse me uh let me amend i approve to our move to approve
292d1 certificate of humans resources i'll second so i'm going to do individual votes roll call sorry um let's start with rusty rodriguez uh yay trustee minjares yes trustee sandoval yes trustee frutos yes trustee myself yes and just clarification on these stipends once we approve them and you do that cost analysis of what we're spending that's something that we could not approve the following budget cycle or removing or school year they go yes they go year they're yearly so every school gets a 10 stipend positions and it's up to the school and how they choose to use them um so it is something that i do want to bring to the budget committee because i i do you know i have been processing rfps and i and i was expecting the number of rfps to go
293down as the year kept going and it doesn't seem to be decreasing so i just today i had that conversation and um i'm and i had that conversation with uh when i was meeting with the the classified hr director and with lori thoms and which we're spending in in extra duties and stipends thank you thank you so with that moving on to item 11 board member comments request for future agenda items and that was i didn't have my mic on so item 11 board member comments request for future agenda items do we have any volunteers to start yes asher um hearing from the public comments earlier today i do think that um i know that myself as representative of makevita as mckevitt and also the community of parents and teachers at mckevitt do want more
294discussion on the reaper on the potential repurpose of mckevitt also i think that more community community outreach is needed for this because as we see most people they're finding out through social media instead of official district channels so i think that's something that we do need to address in the future um that's really it so um merry christmas to you all thank you likewise jenny want to add anything else to comment yeah um i wasn't able to say this earlier but a great thank you to everyone um also thank you for the opportunity for to to be ah to be able to go to the csba conference again this year um i got to meet so many people it was truly so amazing and i got to learn that student board members are actually allowed
295to be on committees so i don't know if you would if we could be added to committees so we could also like be a little more involved and i'll invite you to We learned a lot about LCAP. So we were looking at all the stats. Ask Dr. Moore to add you to the list. That would be fun. I think I would enjoy that, just learning a lot more. Also, it said a goal that I wrote down is to be invited to attend functions just like the other board members. I was talking to my new friends. I am in contact with like 20 of them, but there's 168 of us that were at the conference two weeks ago. But a lot of them, like a lot of the, oh my God, sorry, it's late. A lot
296of them go to lots of events and they're always very involved. So I was hoping we could be just a tad bit more involved. So that's pretty, pretty interesting. And just we had a new idea where we could do like a district-wide leadership day for like elementary leadership kids and middle school and high school kids. Maybe that could be like a little, maybe, maybe. But hearing all these budget cuts, I don't think y'all might want to do it. So, but potential. I think we've had nonprofits assist with that at the high school. There's been things like that. So it's not a definite no, it's part of. Yeah, if that's possible for the future, if we could have a district-wide leadership day, that would be greatly appreciated. I think it'd be nice to be able to
297meet maybe future board members, you know, no, future student board members. There we go. So, yeah. Thank you a lot for the opportunity to go to that conference, both last year and this year. It was like truly magical. And I think they both changed me and I'm excited for Asher for the next few years that he gets to do it. I'm a little jealous, but I'm excited for him. Yeah. So thank you guys all again. It's also lovely to see two new faces. I feel intimidated now since it's only three females. I feel like there's like 20 million. Yeah, it's OK. Also, yeah, just thank you to all the staff, all the other staff classified and certificated at the high school and at the district. I just yeah, I see everyone working really hard. I
298hope they get a break over this upcoming winter break like the students do. And if you don't, well, keep doing your job. We believe in your guys' work. So we see all the outputs and that's basically it, I believe. Oh, thank you to Mr. Weinstein, who went to the Winter Variety Show. I believe I heard that you were there. That was pretty cool. That's pretty cool. And to anyone else that attended and yeah, happy holidays, guys. See you next next year, next semester. So that's going to be fun. Thank you, Trustee Frutos. All righty. In the interest of time, I want to just quickly talk about the program. I know it's a little bit quick, but I did attend the pre engineering graduation on December the 10th. I just want to give a shout out
299to our high school students who participate in the program, all of our our our team that helped make this happen from Dr. Ramon Flores all the way down to Oralia at the high school and so many more. I met with Dr. Ramon Flores. He was a really good person. I met the kids and I met Dr. Ramon Flores. And I know with the regarding the Isabella project, I know that our early childhood center, it's a promising thing. It's it's a plus. Being an educator for 30 plus years, I know the the value and the importance of reaching back into our community and our and our young ones and giving them a promising future. I attended the CSBA in Anaheim. A lot of takeaways, excellent workshops on leadership and trying to be a better communicator with
300my colleagues and to my cabinet team. I always enjoy my time with my board members and Mr. Weinstein and families where we get to sometimes just sit and chat and let loose a little bit and not always be so business oriented because when it's time to get business done, it's there. I want to give a congratulatory shout out to Gabriella Ornelas, attended her inaugural or her swearing in as a council member. It was a good moment, a proud moment for her to see all her three daughters there with just white smiles and all. I attended the Boys and Girls Club Christmas party, an opportunity to do some networking with City of Santa Paula officials and the Boys and Girls Club officials. It's always good to keep those lines of communication open. I definitely look forward
301to. Hearing more presentations regarding the LPAC findings, as I said earlier, look forward to being on the task force and diving in a little bit more. And last but not least, again, I just can't say enough. We appreciate you, staff. Yeah, we do wear our colors and we do show a little bit of frustration, but I think if we weren't doing that, we're not being true. I'm not apologizing for that. It is frustrating that sometimes, you know, we don't always agree, but I think that's what is best or that's what makes it best is that we have that right and opportunity and that comfortness to disagree and maybe show a little bit of frustration. But hopefully we never cross the line of being unprofessional because we do appreciate all that you do, our cabinet members
302and teachers and all. And then with that, just happy holidays to all. I hope you get the well-deserved rest. I hope you get to enjoy your time with family and friends. And then coming back in January, getting ready to get the hard work done again. So thank you. Thank you, Trustee Sandoval. Okay. Welcome to our two new board members. Pleasure to have you on here. A heck of a way to start the day. Thank you. Thank you. I'm sorry. It's usually, this is the longest we've ever had. Promise. I met with the, I had the privilege of having lunch with State Senator Monique Limon. It's just a reminder that we need to engage our elected officials, right, because those relationships are important and a lot of things that happen to education happen in Sacramento. I
303went to the pre-engineering program, too. I saw most of it, a lot of it, some of it, a little late. But it's just a reminder of the program we have with the Naval Base that we participate in. I also met with someone from the EDC, Economic Development Collaborative, and a math professor at Channel Islands who are also working with other facilities on the base and will hopefully, because they're getting some grant funding to engage with the base, hopefully we'll be included on that, the high school, so we can expand our pre-engineering program for more of those kind of activities. Went to the Christmas parade. Always fun to do. Thank you, Ms. Sanchez, for organizing that. I went to the Glen City Den Open. That was awesome. Loved it. Went to CSBA, which is always great.
304Went to having analysis swearing in, which I hate to lose her, but she's on to bigger and better things. I didn't go to, but I did donate to the Friends of Farm Workers. They were hosted here at Glen City last Saturday, and I heard it was a great success. So always happy to support things like that. And then finally, just an announcement. There's Gold Coast Health Plan is put aside $1.5 million in scholarship money over the next six years to help increase behavioral health work, or people getting into behavioral health, encourage that. I know that we're looking at a CTE in behavioral health. I think we need to knock on their door and say we have a program that's feeding in, and allocate some of that money for us so that we can give some
305of our, our more promising, most promising students, a leg up and get into programs that are local. So anyways, if you want to talk to me about that, certainly happy to discuss that. All right, that's it. Thanks. Trustee Mechadis. I'll keep it brief. Thank you so much. Very happy, very proud to be here and being part of this board. And looking forward to continuing to learn and get educated. And City Council Chambers and City Council Chambers and I had a great time at CSP as well, appreciate the hospitality to Jeff and getting to spend some time with Marguerite and the staff that went and also fellow board members in the event as well the first day. So, with that I'm sure I'll have, you know, you know, a nice long board comments like Tommy and
306Daniel one day and I'll be a big boy. Thank you so much. Thank you. Trustee Rodriguez. Yeah, I enjoyed my first school board meeting as an official board member I know when I was younger Oh gosh that's like seven or six years ago, I used to attend them as a student so it's always, it's nice to be on the other end. I'll keep this brief I attended the CSP a conference just for one day unfortunately I couldn't make it for the other days. This past Saturday I attended three events. The friends field workers event. I attended the Latino Town Hall awards, and what a popular last plus at us. And I just think it's a great way to really get to meet the people the folks that are setting up these events and I have
307the kids that attend our schools, also attending our events to connect with them and get to get to know them, just to put a face on their name, I mean just to put your face to their name. Other than that, have a great evening everyone. So first of all just thank you for bearing with us at what time. 1107. 25 years, not for like Gabby would say but I guess 25. Anyhow, I just want to say thank you guys for bearing with me, running through the agenda and again welcome to our new trustees. I will do my best with Jeff to try not have an agenda, this long. If not, we'll, we'll do something about it. But anyhow, I just want to say thank you. To having the opportunity to also attend the CSBA meeting.
308I mean for me the highlights. I think I went to my first AI education course. It was very informational. Went on a press, went. Also listened on a presentation on county schools, I'm sorry, community schools. It's too late. Superintendent evaluations which is very important. So that's one of our biggest jobs is hiring a superintendent. So that's one of our biggest jobs is hiring a superintendent. And I think we've done a great job. And also just another presentation that I went to is just the importance of reading and how important that is for everything our students do. With reading they can do math. With reading they can, you know, just it's so important. I also went to other ones but I didn't write them down. I also was able to attend the field workers event that
309was hosted here at Glen City. Thank you to the staff. Thank you to Dr. Sandoval's family that they were great. All the volunteers. Dr. Ramirez, Gina was there. I have a hard time calling you Dr. Gina. This room was packed. It was very nice just to see the students and the families that came and they were able to take photos, drink hot chocolate. I got to talk to Nate for a while. So it was nice to be for a couple of hours. And with that said, moving on, our future meeting is until next year, January 8th. You guys get a break from us. And with that, I'd like to adjourn this meeting at 1110 p.m. Thank you.