CorpusRecord 159292

Sonoma Valley Unified School District Board Meeting 01-16-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
SonomaTV
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Sonoma County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
36,729 words · about 205 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

00115 seconds so i just ask that everybody respectfully start to quiet down so that the people on zoom and the people in the room can hear please OK, good evening. Our report out for closed session items. Item number one, during our closed session, the board voted to adopt without modification the written decision of hearing officer Donald Scott sustaining the dismissal of a permanent classified employee, employee number 3348. The vote was unanimous. The vote was five with five yeses. Let's see, for item number two, no action was taken. For item number three, no action was taken. And for item number four, no action was taken. So now we'll move to roll call. Trustee Bell? Here. Trustee Ching? Here. President Landry? Here. Trustee Lehman? Here. Trustee Winders? Here. And we'll stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. I

002pledge allegiance. Okay, before I ask for the approval of the agenda, I just wanted to make an announcement that our Prestwood Elementary students will not be presenting this evening. They're going to join us next month, I believe. So we will be approving the agenda with the modification that we do not have student presentations tonight. So is there a motion on the board? I will move to approve the modified agenda that does not include the student presentation tonight. I'll second that. All in favor? Aye. Thank you. All right. Juan with language people is our translator tonight. Hi everybody. Happy New Year everybody. Thank you. Okay, tonight our Norman inspiration is going to be provided to us by trustee layman boy Thank you. Good evening everyone first time I get to do this and I appreciate having

003a large crowd to be able to speak to I'm going to share a quote from Ruth Bader Ginsburg for folks that are younger and don't know who she was she's best known for a vacation on equality and women's rights she often had a quote she did not coin but she shared and I believe it relates well to the current state of our district she's often said you can disagree without being disagreeable And my translation for that is it's perfectly normal to have different views, beliefs and positions. In doing so, she believed that it was best to be respectful and to focus on compromises that helped our society. My hope is that we see compromises as a strength. It illustrates our ability to find solutions and it lets us find common ground and to move our

004our group society organization forward. I am personally optimistic about the direction we can go when we're working together to find solutions. And I absolutely implore folks here who are listening on the call and throughout our community to lean in and help. Our district is in a scenario where we can use help and we need all the solution finding and support that we can get. Contract negotiations are adversarial in nature, but that does not mean we need to be adversaries. We are here, I believe, for the right reasons. And I say we, and I truly mean everyone here. I believe most people are here in the goodness of their heart and thinking about the education of our children in our district. And I do believe that we will disagree. And I do ask that we do

005so in a manner where we are not disagreeable. And that's my inspiration for today. Back to you, President Landry. Thank you, Trustee Lehman. Okay, we are going to move on. We're going to move on to communications to the board in regards to public comment. The board recognizes the value of public comment on educational issues and provides this time for members of the audience to address the board on any school-related matter not on this agenda. The board can take no action at this time. Each speaker is requested to identify themselves prior to addressing the board and limit comments to three minutes. So before... We get started. I would just like to see a raise of hands of how many people we have in the room this evening who would like to make public comment on items

006not on the agenda. And can someone give me a count of those in the hall who also may have their hands up? And while they're counting, if you're online and you're interested in speaking on items not on the agenda, if you could please just raise your hand so that we have an idea. Five outside. Okay. Okay. So we've got 20 in the room, five outside, and I'm... One out here. Okay. Okay. So just to make sure that everybody has an opportunity to speak, we're going to limit the comment time. Point of order the board has the authority to do that for the efficiency of this meeting. Everyone will have an opportunity to speak We're just going to limit the time which we've done before and it's not unfamiliar to this community To two minutes each

007if you have it written and there's someone else who will continue for you. That's completely acceptable We want to give everybody an opportunity To be able to speak and we do have additional people online as well So we are going to now go to public comment in the room Thank you. Hi, my name is Nora Albright and I timed this to three minutes So I'm gonna talk as fast I can last night a comment was made Let us remember that there are children in the room. This is both comical and insulting I have not heard anyone in recent history talk to the board as if the children are not in the room To address the children in the room I also want to remind you that it is literally an educators job to know the

008students in the room In my classroom, I know their reading scores and their actual abilities. I know their math scores and their actual math needs. I know how they write. I know their ELPAC scores. I know who needs more time, attention, a different seat, a quiet time in their day. Who needs to take a break or go for a run or walk. I literally know their voices when my backs are turned. We tested my superpower recently. I know their family lives. I know who needs to have breakfast and who skips lunch, who will be late, who's never absent, who will get a call midday to change where they are supposed to go after school. Who needs X, Y, and Z? I know not only the students in my room, but the ones next door and

009down the hall. We are a community of learners who support and love one another. The love and support we have for our children in the room and in our community is unwavering. We show up for the students and put our own personal emotions, lives on the back burner because it is our job to know and love and protect and teach the students in our rooms. when we hear conversations about class size and overages it is because we know the students in the room and we know that there are too many students we are not going to be we are not doing those students we sorry let me read that again When you hear conversations about class size and overages, it is because we know the students in the room and we know that if there

010are too many students, we are doing those students a disservice and they will not be able to get all they need out of their education. It is not because teachers are greedy and see overcrowded classrooms as a cash cow. Overall, the entire board made comments that approving yesterday's TA would put the district in a financial situation that would cost us more jobs, more programs, and overall, more would be taken from our schools, students, and community. This situation we are in is not the teacher's fault, and I beg you to stop that narrative immediately. The responsibility of this situation is firmly planted on people who are sitting in the chairs in front of me. Unfortunately, some of you inherited this mess, and just like you, Just like us, you are forced to deal with the fallout.

011I'm so sorry. Your time is up. If there's someone who wants to continue. Someone finish it. Thank you. I'm Chrissy Leodini. I teach second grade at Sasserini. And to finish Nora's, might I remind you that you have had this TA since October. Had you voted on it, then you could have voted no, and we could have gone back to the table. Instead, you ignored your own bylaws, then made the teachers out to be the bad guys. You forced VMTA's hands to strike and then started a smear campaign that I do not think you will recover from in this community. How dare you? We beg you to remember we are not a business, we are a community. We take care of each other. We take less of a pay increase in order to support a failing

012budget. We work together for the students in the room. Thank you. Hi, my name is Teresa Gerhardt. I work at Adele Harrison Middle School. I am here on behalf of the Adele Harrison staff. We want to congratulate our principal, Kelly Criss. Kelly Criss was named Middle School Principal of the Year for Region 4 by the Association of California School Administrators. Region 4 serves Mendocino County. Lake County, Marin County, Sonoma County, Napa County, Solano County, and Vallejo City. Congratulations, Kelly Criss. You deserve it. Thank you, Mr. Hart. Congrats Kelly Chris that's amazing. Hi my name is Veronica Gray I'm a ninth grade CP and honors English teacher at Sonoma Valley High School it's my 11th year lord help me. Can't believe that we're that we possibly even did a strike it's I'm I am absolutely just

013baffled by that. As an English teacher one of my primary responsibilities is to teach kids to think logically to do and to do dicional analysis right to really look at the words to figure out what is being said how it's being said and what it's trying to persuade of. The letter y'all sent out today, and I did use the word y'all. I'm from California. I don't care. I'll use it if I darn well please. Was incredibly manipulative. I'm actually really thinking that maybe I should have them take it apart for the ethos, pathos, and logos that was so manipulatively used. I'm not sure if that's against any policy. CTA, let me know. I think my honors students would have a field day with the absolute garbage and vitriol that came through that letter and the

014statements for almost every single one of your mouths. Shame on you. And I hope that they are watching this now because YouTube is amazing and they can be. So hey kids, what's up? And I promised you I would say the things that I said, if not more. But let me be clear. You have done such an incredible disservice by the words that you said. All you had to do was vote it down three months ago. That's all you had to do. We would have gone back to the table. Now while all of you were not exactly in these positions, some of you in the positions three months ago, it doesn't take away from the fact of the words that you said last night. And perhaps you should go back and watch it again and really

015hear what you said, how you said, and who you were talking about. Because those kids the ones that you spoke of hearing us they heard what you said about the people they possibly care about the most of the schools their teachers no offense to CSEA but we're with them a little bit longer most of time and they're amazing individuals what they do too, but they heard what you said and heard you blame these individuals for Well the crimes of yours and your predecessors Bravo. She said sarcastically. Bye. Thank you, Mr. Speaker I'm Leslie Nicholson, and I have a bad voice tonight, so I apologize. But I'm here to support the teachers. I just want to say that I do not have any... encounters with parents in this community whose kids have graduated where their kids

016are doing poorly. I am so amazed. All of us parents are so incredibly grateful to the teachers. You guys are boots on the ground. Our kids are doing fantastic and it starts in elementary and goes through. And thank you, thank you. You guys have done an amazing time. job with their kids and I cannot tell you how many alumni would be here to support you. I want you guys to take the time to please come and spend time in the classrooms. I don't think you get it. I you guys need to see what goes on every single day I do and I'm so privileged to work at Alvarado and see how hard these teachers work and see what they do as well as the other teachers but I'm at Alvarado please do not bad mouth

017these teachers in public please please know that this is a small community and we need to support each other and be unified no more divisiveness find creative ways to support these teachers you have no idea how hard they work and how hurt they are and i'm i just i really really beg you find any way to come together and heal this and do it for the kids and the community let's be proud of the school district we have thank you thank you miss ms goulton Morgan Momsen, I teach at Alvarado School, and I just want to read some quotes from your latest message to the community and make some comments. First quote, the Sonoma Valley Unified School Board of Trustees made a difficult but necessary decision, one that prioritizes the stability and well-being of our

018students. One thing that prioritizes the stability and well-being of the students is supporting the teachers who spend the majority of their time with said students or planning for said students. Continuing to send message to families, the community, and the press that villainizes the teachers who spend so much of their physical, emotional, and mental capacity caring for, coaching, and educating the students is not prioritizing the well-being of anyone. Something else that prioritizes stability and well-being of the students would have been voting in October, November, December or hey including it on the agenda for tonight when it was posted Friday instead after countless emails and public comments begging for you to include the TA on all of those agendas you waited until we had to use our last resort another quote our students cannot afford to lose

019a single day of learning it absolutely blows my mind that you can value students learning so much while continuing to talk down about the very educators who are providing this invaluable learning every chance you get You talked down to us in board meetings, to messages in the community, and even went out to dinner in public places. I would like to make it very clear to the community that teachers are taking less of a raise than offered to defend and protect smaller class sizes. The part of the TA that leads to, quote, significant financial consequences is the piece about overages. There's a simple solution. Don't overcrowd the classrooms. It's clear school closures will mean sending more kids to each school But that does not mean they should all be placed in classrooms that are already at

020capacity You state that as adults, our behavior matters, especially in front of our children. They are watching us closely, and they need to see that we are capable of working together for their benefit. Yes, our behaviors matter, but so do our words. They are watching, they are listening, and they're reading. So I hope moving forward, you reconsider why you even decided to join the school board in the first place. And remember, we're on the same side, the students. Thank you, Ms. Munson. I don't really like to write down what I want to say, but I knew I was angry and I wanted to make sure that I got this stuff down. In 21st century, we don't usually get to say, how dare you that much. But listening to you last night, really that's one of

021the few things that I kept shouting that I can repeat here. How dare you imply that by exercising our labor rights we're betraying our students? Maybe you should use your interest in student voice to find out what those students think about their teachers actions. Maybe those board members who encourage their family members to cross our picket line and take scab work could imagine, could examine the values they're passing on to their children. How dare you characterize our puny raise as irresponsible? I don't remember hearing that when our superintendent got her 4%. Or, don't take the applause out of my time. Or when you spent $90,000 on a portrait of a graduate process that district admin used to run themselves. Or when you just spent $33,000 to hire a group to help us with scheduling equity.

022When you have a superintendent with a certificate in educational equity from USC. How dare you characterize our overage increase as a big raise for a few? There's a great teacher in our department. He's teaching enough students for six contractually sized classes. But one of those classes is broken up and jammed into the other five, speaking of what's best for kids. So now, instead of paying him the 20% more he should receive for an extra class, you're now going to pay him $8 a day. Big victory for us greedy teachers. And that's not going into his supplemental retirement like the extra class would, so you're stealing from him for the rest of his life. I also want to respond to our newest trustee's comment that we have district leadership who can have conversations with employees. But

023I'm going to have to pass that on right here. I also want to respond to our newest trustees comment that we have the district leadership who can have the conversations with employees on these problems. Employees have been saying well that will be a new experience. Okay. Right now, our district admin is known for entering school spaces without acknowledging there are people present or for their policy of not answering emails from teachers. Right now, there is no communication, trust, or mutual respect, and it's sad. Because years ago, when we had many more students and, in fact, many more newcomers, things weren't that way, so they don't have to be. A new teacher was concerned about retaliation if she went on strike. And one of our classified people said, hey, don't worry. They need to know your

024name to get to you. And unfortunately, that sums it up. Thank you. Thank you both. Hello. My name is Brianna Gorman. I teach English at the high school. I'm also a Sonoma Valley High School alum, class of 2017. I am typically not one to voice my opinions publicly, but after your hurtful and divisive words at the board meeting last night, I can stay quiet no longer. Last night, you called my dedication into question. You called every single teacher's dedication to their students into question. Let me tell you about dedication. It took me five years to obtain my teaching credential. It cost me approximately $20,000, not including the $17,000 in student loans. I worked three jobs as a full-time student to make ends meet because I wanted to be a teacher so badly, and I did

025it. I now work at least 20 hours over contract hours every week. Yes, I counted. I went to Staples yesterday and spent $150 of my own money on ink so I can print out my students' research articles. I stay after school to comfort students who just need a shoulder to cry on because high school is hard. I spent my summer begging my family and friends to donate books to my classroom so that I had enough for all of my students. I spent my winter break updating the 10th grade curriculum to be more inclusive, fun, and entertaining. When I use a sick day, guess who still replies to emails from students? Guess who still comes in to teach even when I am sick and pregnant because there's no sub available. My dedication is unwavering in my

026stories, not unique. My fellow teachers do the exact same thing because unlike some of you, we are only here for the students. You think I work this hard for the cushy salary or my super lengthy lunch break? I do this because the kids deserve it. You stated last night that you felt backed into a corner and that you are just so sad it had to come to a strike. 90 days. Took you over 90 days to vote. I ask that you never call our dedication as educators into question ever again. You are right about one thing. The children are watching. They watched last night as you disrespected their teachers and made us out to be lazy and money hungry. They are watching, but you are the ones who need to do better for the children,

027not us. Thank you. Good evening, Dr. Chin and trustees. There's a lot of energy in the room, a lot of love in the room. I think that goes without question. I think what really needs to be discussed, not here in front of everyone, but in your own private life, is the failure of your methodology, not your intentions. Because as the trustee said, you went into this adversarial. I've spoken to this board, the predecessing board, and boards for 20 plus years. Because I'm a former teacher in the district. I taught almost 30 years in Napa. I was president of the Napa Valley Educators Association, the largest union in Napa County. We never actioned. We never actioned against the board. What did we do? We talked to them. Every single week. And we used interest-based problem solving.

028Now, you have a staff member who is an expert at it, and we have teachers in the faculty group who are experts at it, because everyone who represents NAPA, either their site or their administration, gets trained over and over in the principles, the techniques of interspace or non-adversarial bargaining. No, bargaining is not inherently adversarial. Resisting interest of your employee group is inherently adversarial. You need a better way, not a better heart. You need a better way, not a better heart. Now, I've spoken with many of you about interest-based. You expressed an interest in it. Time to get up off your komoseyama and do something about it. Thank you. Thank you next speaker Shelly Ryan a teacher at Adele the MTA vice president Last night we finally understood why this report refused to vote on the

029October 1st agreement for 93 days They didn't like the deal their team negotiated on their behalf This is embarrassing for the district. You are basically admitting you do not trust your team But your team agreed to this deal. If you don't like it, then don't approve it. You have voted no. You could have voted no on it back in October. Trustee Bell, you said that if you don't get acknowledgement from your labor partners about the reality of the budget situation, then you would probably end up facing a strike again. To be clear, this was not an economic strike. We were not going to strike because we didn't like the terms of the agreement. We were going to strike because you refused to vote, and by doing so, engaged in unfair labor practices. trustee lehman you

030expressed your belief that you have incredible people in leadership positions in this district who make necessary decisions to set the district on the right path so does that mean the next time you designate a team to negotiate on your behalf you will swiftly approve the deal you reached and not scapegoat the teachers for any financial implications Last night, you threw a tantrum and finally approved the deal that your team agreed to, and you dragged the teachers through the mud and blamed us for the structural deficit and the financial problems of the district. Trustee Ching, you said that this deal would have dire financial consequences for the district. Trustee Lehman, you said it was clear the district is not in a financial situation that can afford this. And Trustee Bell, you said the district probably didn't

031have the money to offer salary increases at all. You guys do know your bargaining team offered us 4%, right? If we had accepted the 4% you offered us, would you still blame us for the structural deficit? I'm going to let Amy finish the sentiment. Thank you. Thank you. Amy Lucchetti, teacher at Adele Harrison. The one-time money in the deal you approved last night was plenty for overpacking classrooms. The teachers took less money in our paychecks and in our retirement benefits because we felt so strongly that the normalization of overpacking classes has to stop. We needed a penalty high enough that it would act as a deterrent. 42 teachers this year will be getting overage checks, some of them quite large. That means there are at least 42 over-packed classrooms in this district. That's on you.

032But if this penalty works, we expect far fewer over-packed classrooms, which means far fewer overage checks in future years. Which means we are actually hoping that for the benefit of education, For the education of students in this district, we get paid less in multiple ways. We had to make selfless sacrifice because this district refused to do the right thing on their own. The last thing I want to say to the Board of Trustees, you are not heroes for taking 93 days to approve the deal, despite how you tried to portray yourselves in the meeting last night and in the message to our community today. We have been negotiating this contract for almost a year. We have been working for more than half of this school year without a contract. We have had a deal reached

033through mutual agreement for 93 days. It took a strike to get you to do your job. You are not the heroes. Thank you. Next speaker. Is there any more public comment in the room? Going one. Let's get it. Here we go people Laura Monterosso You will receive no thank you from me You have delayed this vote since October the October board meeting you have created chaos this week Confusing educators parents and students with your 11th hour special board meeting on Tuesday and your additional board meeting on Wednesday The MTA filed an unfair labor practice against this board because they have delayed the process and not follow their own board policy This could have been settled 28 days ago 40 days ago 65 days ago the community should be aware that this unfair labor strike could

034have been avoided had it had the board i can be like had the board and superintendent chin done what they told vmta on monday january 6 that they would do they told our team that they would have the tentative agreement on the january 16th meeting for discussion and a possible vote but on friday january the 10th Superintendent Chen told VMTA presidents that the tentative agreement could not be on the board agenda as an action item because the board president didn't have the approval of the board to put the action item on without consent from the board. So VMTA notified the school board that we would be striking on Thursday. But suddenly, on Monday, the board posted a special meeting for Tuesday. They said they couldn't do that last week. Suddenly, on Tuesday, the board posted

035a regular meeting for Wednesday to vote on the TA. You may ask, who was not telling the truth? Why didn't... Why didn't they post these special meetings last week? Because they have been delaying this vote for 93 days and they thought we can just delay until February. You ask why did they wait? And we ask why did they wait? Delay, delay. Again, the board created the chaos this week. VMTA had a strike plan to inform the district, parents, community, giving the stakeholders plenty of time to plan for their own family's needs. Remember that the board created the chaos, not VMTA. We did our due diligence. We gave time to the parents, followed the rules, the law, but this board decided to turn your week upside down, leaving everyone confused. Thank you, Ms. Monterosso. Do you

036have someone who can finish for you? Of course I do, Ms. Landry. So I'd like to just remind everyone in the room that the kids are watching, even though we've all said that. Yeah, they are. So point of order, point of order, point of order, point of order. We need... To be kind, please. Good evening. Kaylee Boer, English teacher at Sonoma Valley High School. The end result is a win for VMTA with the approval of the ten of an agreement that we have been waiting for the board to vote on for 94 days. But in return, they delayed, confused, and made our SVUSD families' lives uneasy. This is not a board that is following the rules. This is not a board that cares for the TK through 12 community. This is a board that creates

037chaos. This is a board that is not proactive. This is not how we educate our kids, but this is the example that this board is setting for our kids. I can only hope for better in the future. We all know the saying that actions speak louder than words, but in this case, this board's actions have shown us how this governing body works, and sadly, it's not collaboration with your community partners. Let's hope that you can do better for the children. Thank you both. Next speaker. Hi, my name is Lisa Vallott. I'm a fifth grade teacher at Sasserini, and I have students in the district for the last 14 years. Problems don't disappear when you ignore them, and neither do teachers. Even though the board states they followed the law in the letter today, let's be

038clear. You did not follow procedure. Never has it taken four plus months to approve a TA. I want you to know that your dismissive actions and the board members comments yesterday have devalued the morale of teachers to a new level of low. The way the board members picked apart our hours of work, the overage pay based on packing classes, and our benefits and health plan was pathetic and it was a show of pomp and circumstance. Yes, this district is in a financial crisis, but teacher salaries and benefits did not cause the problem. In reality, the financial drain is the lack of special education services with an inclusion site that supports ESN students of the Valley instead of busing them outside of our district. The financial drain is the legal fees incurred over John Kelly's tenure.

039The financial drain is the payout of ill-hired DO executives in previous years. Making decisions based solely on analyzing the budget is faulty. logic when you are making important decisions about schools consider the human element consider your community and your constituents thank you hi Justina Montana flowery school thank you for voting on the October 1st TA not because I was desperate for it to be approved I did hope it would be but because I was sick and tired of the stalled process I get it that school consolidation has required a lot of your time and attention, but January provided a lull between consolidation conversations. So I, Pollyanna me, fully expected to see the TA on today's agenda. Perhaps I'm revealing a lack of understanding, but I couldn't figure out what you were trying to achieve by

040leaving the TA in limbo week after week, month after month. You heard from countless educators who asked you to agendize it and make a decision. Even if you voted no, that would be fine! Just agendize it! If it was in the district's best interest to return to negotiating, that would have been fine. My frustration was regarding the lack of action. VMTA did its part. Why did the district force us to plan a strike in order to resume the process? We had no other option. This time-sucking ordeal has left me feeling confused, angry, and unsupported by the district. Then comments in last night's meeting came across as insulting, though I realize they may have shown a lack of understanding. Unfortunately, those comments were followed by a condescending email to teachers that was sent by the board

041this afternoon. It's obvious you're upset with us, but you can see there's not a lot of admiration for you in this room tonight either. I'm concerned about how we move forward when there is such a lack of trust between us. You claim to have followed policy and the law and acted in good faith. If that's true, then somehow there was a failure to make the process clear. You say your negotiations were transparent. I wasn't on the bargaining team, so I don't know if that's true or not, but it certainly resulted in a lot of confused teachers. So here we are with a one-year contract that will conclude in just a handful of months. Thank you. It looks like... So just really quickly before we start the timer, if you're standing on the... Wait, hold on

042one quick second. I think that the cord might... Yeah, so will you test it, please? Hello, hello? Perfect. Thank you. Okay. It looks like you should plan on scheduling a date for the next contract ASAP. And I hope you facilitate a more efficient process the next time. Jason, obviously you... only recently had a role in this process. It's unfortunate it required a planned strike, but I wish you well in your time on the board. Today, you wrote, we are committed to doing whatever it takes to move forward together. I hope you meant what you wrote, and that you can rebuild trust and put this chapter behind us. Thank you. Next speaker. Good evening. My name is Maggie Marvel. Thank you for allowing me to address you. I'm here to speak on behalf of the students,

043teachers, and families of the Sonoma. I am here to speak on behalf of the students teachers and families of the Sonoma Valley District I recently read the letter sent to the board and Superintendents regarding the tentative agreement between the valley of the moon association in the district I have several concerns about the board's actions as well as the board's incentives first I want to highlight the district is now operating in the positive and there was no requirement for the district to send this agreement to the county the board's decision to do so appears to be a calculated attempt to shift blame from any potential school closures or cuts onto the teachers this is an unfortunate attempt to vilify the very people who are at the core of our educational system teachers classified staff and all

044those who make our schools run smoothly without them there are no students in the classroom or revenue No educational environment and yet this board by offering a less than standard ways Demonstrate a clear failure in our fiscal planning for the stuff that staff that our children depend on every single day when I spoke to Sarah Lappenfield Lappenfield the other day she assured me that this letter was a routine letter sent to the county the board's implication that this agreement is a cause for potential financial difficulties suggesting that living wage for teachers justifies more school closures or cuts to its resources is misleading to say the least gaslighting the public with half-truths and fear taxes is not the action of a responsible governing body it's a last-ditch effort from a desperate group trying to avoid accountability

045i want to address the lack of transparency the board has shown both to the public and to the county if the board is truly committed to its fiscal health and the community deserves a full independent audit it is clear that the current district leadership has lost the trust of all the sonoma county teachers and parents i ask you to consider the true cost of your actions not just the district's financial health but to the more and the well-being of very people who are expected to teach our children. There's no school district without schools, and there are no schools without teachers. The district can exist without a board, but it cannot function without the educators and the staff that make the classroom come alive. Any basic economics should refute the board's current of action. We do

046not generate revenue without students, and students cannot attend school without teachers. Closing schools and cutting teachers only harm the educational experience for our children. It would reduce our revenue and depend... The irony is not lost to me that the board spends time on personal grievances... Next. speaker please thank you this irony is not lost on me that the board spends time on personal grievances while the teachers are juggling far more than can most imagine teaching socio-emotional learning planning for emergencies and trying to make up for the loss of arts programs teachers often have to take on multiple roles educators mental health professionals crisis managers all white all while earning advanced degrees, continuing education, and meeting ever-increasing demands. Yet the board meets once a month and can't seem to prioritize the fiscal health of this district

047or the staff who work tirelessly to support our children. This community is watching, and we are beginning to look into what our options are for holding the board accountable, especially if the fear-mongering continues. Your current conduct of bullying and vilifying teachers does not serve the children of Sonoma Valley. and frankly its level of hypocrisy no longer goes unnoticed it's time for the board to stop playing politics and focus on creating an environment that respects the dignity and worth of the educators who do the hardest job in the district every single day thank you thank you Good evening. My name is Laura Schumer. I am a teacher. And I'm here again because I was noticing my notes from, I think, last month when I was here. And actually a lot of the same comments and the

048same themes that are working. But what I'm realizing is maybe you're not aware of what we actually do. Because I'm not sure how many of you have actually been a teacher. So I'm here to personally invite you into my classroom at any time to please come and shadow us. But I mean all day, not just for an hour, not just for a 20-minute visit. Because I'm not sure you're aware of what our day actually entails and the amount of work that we're actually doing. Because if you think that I get there 10 minutes before the bell just because you put it in the agreement, you're wrong. Most teachers are there somewhere between 10 30 and 30 minutes in an hour before school and are usually there 30 minutes to an hour after school unless we

049have an appointment So giving us a professional hours. We don't need them. We're already there and beyond we take work home We grade papers we respond to emails and the point is that We don't need a number of hours told to us what we need to do for our workday We do it because we care not because we have to or we're told And my point is that if you really, and I truly mean it, please come to my classroom. Please come. I think many of us would invite you in. If you're not sure that we're working as hard as you think we should, and you don't think we earn the money that we should earn, which we're earning less than probably other districts around us at the time. Truly come see what we actually

050do. I don't actually know what any of you I wouldn't say that I know what all of you do in your job without actually having been there So I couldn't make decisions for you on your job But you all have to make decisions for us and if you truly don't know very much about public education Because you haven't been a teacher just because you had a public education does not mean you're able to make decisions about public education So please come and get to know us and please use your heart because those words that you've said about us have harmed morale. You've seen how many people have filled this. So even if you want to, in your hearts, be making an equitable, kind message, it's not coming across. And that means time to think and

051reflect. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, Ronette Weston from Sasserini. I wasn't really planning on talking because I always tend to get really upset when I come here. But I just wanted to say that all I got from last night was I felt threats, and I feel like you're coming after us. And next year, like you're already talking about shutting down the schools, which we said could be a discussion. People even said in this room that possibly we wouldn't have to close another school. And then also our benefits. I can tell that's going to be a big battle next year. I was just disappointed in the quality of the meeting last night. And I just hope you guys can do better going forward and less bully tactics. Because if you were in my classroom, I would

052have asked you to step outside for a little one-on-one heart-to-heart. Thank you. Hello, my name is Deborah. I come from another county. I chose to work in this community because I know all the educators here go far and beyond for their students, and I wanted to be a part of that. I arrive an hour early, and I stay an hour later beyond contractual hours because I know the dedication needed in order to provide the best educational experience for my students. We truly only have in mind the best for our students and our families. For you to undermine our effort and not acknowledge our commitment to education of our students is simply disrespectful. And one thing to end this, we teach our students to acknowledge if they have done wrong, we take accountability. And so do

053we as teachers. So for you not to do it is telling our students the opposite message. Y ahora yo voy a hablar en español porque ustedes yo sé que no están hablando realmente para toda la comunidad. Como me ha enseñado mi papá, ser maestra es un llamado. Being a teacher is a calling. And we all here have answered that call. Todos aquí hemos respondido a esa llamada. Estamos dedicados para los miembros de nuestra comunidad porque los estudiantes son participantes activos en nuestra comunidad. All the students in our classrooms are already active members. So for you to come here and tell us that we are not doing our job and that we are not giving our students, community members, the best that we can is not okay. I end with this question. Are you guys really

054supporting our community? Because it's not noticeable. Thank you. Thank you. Jessica Coffey, teacher and parent. I believe the opening comment was to work together, to disagree and not be disagreeable. I believe the statement contradicts the announcement sent out this afternoon and the comments made last night. such as it sounds like they are asking for more money and asking to work less. The strike was cancelled because we, the teachers and staff, do put the students first. Our hearts are in the classroom. Ask any teacher to log the hours they put in. Those hours far exceed any average work day. We work through our lunches, after school, weekends and more. In addition, many of us work a second or even third job to make ends meet. So no, a 2% raise along with an additional, I repeat,

055additional 15 hours of adjunct work beyond the hours of the school day is a very minimal ask. Monetary support for increased class sizes, where mind you some classes do not even have enough desks for the students, is a very little ask. Mistakes are made. Mistakes that have been made financially, public reports that will be corrected on paper and not publicly is wrong and extremely disrespectful to all of us who come to work every day. We strive to teach our students to know what is right and wrong. to own up to their mistakes and to apologize when they know a wrong has been committed publicly. I am proud to be part of this amazing family, to be part of this union of teachers. We are here for the children. We are here for education. And we

056are here for each other. Thank you to my fellow union family members. I am proud to stand with you. Thank you. I'm Regina Meyer, third grade teacher at Prescott Elementary. Dr. Chin, if you could put your computer at half mass, that's how I get my... classes attention. I would really appreciate eye contact. First of all, you keep saying remember kids are watching. I have two students here right now, one sitting in the front row. You know, and what they're seeing tonight is a room full of people who love them and care about them and will fight for them. And that's what they're seeing tonight. I want to clear some things up. Trustee Landry, you said in the last two board meetings you were really surprised more people were not in attendance. That's because we were

057spending all of our extra hours prepping and preparing a strike that could have been completely avoided by signing the TA three months ago, which I'm still a little confused about because at one point you will claim it didn't exist. So still kind of confused about that one. Also, trust me, Bella, you... talked about the adjunct duties that we have now a reduction of five hours from 20 to 15 and you said oh teachers are working less and getting paid more do you think we're paid for adjunct duties guess what that means five more hours we get to use planning in our classroom and for our students shame on all of you for not taking ownership of the chaos you created thank you thank you hello my name is I'm not part of VMTA, just full

058disclosure. I am wearing red in support of education, which is the foundation. for any citizen to be able to read, to understand, and be able to make a decent living. And to belong to a union, I do belong to a union. I feel that the conversation last night that was discussed wasn't very pro-union. It was a lot of anti-union. And I want to wish you guys, first and foremost, Happy New Year. I think we need a reset. I like to believe that part of conversation that we were talking last night, I was listening. And if you want a partner, I think we need a reset of relationships. I really feel like this is where the trust needs to start building because I'm standing in front of you. I have four grandkids that are going through

059the system. I am very concerned. And the master facilities have not turned out very good. We've got basketball fields that nobody uses out in the back of Sonoma High School. There are decisions that were made. So please don't put that on the back of people that weren't part of that decision making. Yes, we are all in this together. You guys have a difficult job, but I'm standing before you as a community member urging you, please work on the respect because that's what we want to start with. We are your partners. We're all family here. We live here. So please, start that process. Having stuff come out in the newspaper and marketing and writing words as community doesn't exactly feel like it based on what's been going on. So I think we can all do better.

060I appreciate you guys. Thank you. I wish you the best. Thank you very much. Next speaker. Good evening. I'm not a parent of any student. I'm just a community member. Most teachers do this because they're passionate about teaching children. They spend a lot of time at school. They spend a lot of time after school. My sister was a teacher, and I used to live with her, and she routinely would work till 10, 11 o'clock at night to prepare for the next day or make sure some child's needs were met. My feeling is you're being a school board member I would hope that you ran and joined because you care about kids You care about teachers and you care about our community Communities that have high quality education of I know we are in a very

061high real estate market anyway, but Prices of housing stay high crime rates are low. It's better for the overall community in general It just kills me to think that you're not advocating for these teachers. I mean, teachers year after year work with less and less. I mean, if they had to get paid an hourly rate, they wouldn't even make minimum wage. So I hope you join the bar because you care about kids and you care about public education because that's what you have control over and that's what you're supposed to be an advocate for. So I'm gonna keep fighting I'm gonna keep coming back and making sure that that's exactly what you guys are doing and I just want to say Thank you very much to every single one of you For doing what you

062do for all these kids. You've got your hands full class sizes are too big Best way to do that is to lower class sizes So, thank you Thank you Hi, I'm Crystal Morgan and I work at SVHS. I have worked with the in the you know school since elementary, junior high, and high school. I am totally talking about something different. I think we need to have playground like swing sets and nine square four squares at all high school at schools. Kids need something else to do. Talk about phones. Well guess what? Give them something to do. These kids you walk around they're all in a circle. They're all like do do do. I'm gonna text you but you're right here. Give them something to do. Keep that kid in them. Keep them young. And also,

063that's one thing. Another thing, can we please, whoever's in charge of food, can we get a box of apples and a box of Nutri-Grain in the office? I can't keep avoiding it. And the kids, they need it. After the kitchen is closed, they're hungry. They come by. Ms. Crystal, you have any food? I'm sorry, you don't have any more. We need to have it. It's free, right? It's implemented, right? We need to feed the belly, feed the mind. Helps with behaviors, helps with anxieties, helps with all of it. So please, can you guys collaborate and do something to have some type of food accessible to not only our teachers when they're in a 504, students 504s, they're in the counseling office, they're hungry. They're so hungry for food, but yet sometimes they don't have time

064to go to the kitchen, whatever, whatever. But really, please, swing sets. Students love to swing. Teachers love to swing. It's actually good for them. It's helping. It's relaxing. Just a little thought. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Ms. Morgan. Next speaker. Hi, I'm Heather Gobey. I am... the unicorn at Adele. I was so excited to take the job to give kids, thank you for saying hands-on, something to do in a different way with art. I'm very excited to be one of the examples of Prop 28 money, but I have to tell you this has been a really hard year and I've been a teacher a long time, not here and not in this role. I have a master's degree. I have children in college. And I make in this job as a point four

065roughly $2,000 a month. I have three outside jobs. I'm a yoga therapist. So I can bring these tools to my kids. When the consolidation talks were going on, I kept saying words matter. Be mindful. Please don't gaslight and don't angle because it's just damaging. We're all in a tough spot and we need to work it through. My day starts around 530 or 6. I get up, and I have a mixed-level class of 6th, 7th, and 8th graders. I have between 30 and 33, depending on my newcomers, maybe 9 or 10 newcomers in each class. I have to translate slides for art that I have not done because I am so busy with all the requirements that I must have to remain in my job, hopefully. For next year, I'm enrolled in a full-time CLAD program.

066I'm doing teacher induction. I've been teaching for over 25 years. And this is what I have to do to be here. So when I hear the things and the comments about teachers, and we're saying that the classes are too... Too big. The kids can't learn. I can't get to you. In fact, I've tripped three times today. And two students hit themselves while trying to get by. Two dropped materials on the floor, and one chair fell over because there's no space for them with the materials that I'm bringing. It's not a safe thing. And I want to do this with these kids. I really want to. Thank you. Next speaker. Hi, my name is Anne Marie Sebastiani. I work in the district. I've worked in the district off and on for a really long time. And

067my role is a school counselor. And I feel like I've heard, you know, Be kind we have to be respectful don't be disagreeable And I think the reality is it's okay to be angry right now, and so I think we really need to honor The anger that you're seeing and you're feeling in this because that's healthy that's part of the whole process So I don't want to negate that part it's a huge part people are pretty upset and I think you need to sit with that for a minute because We keep saying, be kind, be respectful. And it's like, okay. And we need to really honor. People are really upset right now. So I just felt inclined that the kids are watching. And I want them to know it's okay to be angry. It's okay

068to show your anger. That's being a human. That's being a human being here. So I wanted to put that out there. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Mary Mellinger. I'm pretty sure I'm the only person in this room that has seen as many boards and as many superintendents as anyone else. I'm a 40-year educator. This is my 37th year in our district, the district I know and love. This is the first time I have ever felt so hurt and disrespected by this board of my livelihood, of what I've done for 40 years and why I've done it. And to be told that I want overages for classroom money is going to break the bank here? I had overages last year. I had a class of 28 students where my cap was 23.

069I received overages, but it didn't help what happened in that classroom every single day of what I needed to do to meet the needs of those students. I felt so strongly about it. I took a combination class this year so that those students would no longer be in a class of 28 students, which they had been in first grade and second grade. So please don't tell me that I'm doing this for the money. I do this because this is who I am as an educator. And to be told and disrespected in this way. I feel I have, I'm at a loss of words to be treated in this fashion for something that I have worked for for so long and how much I love this community. And you created chaos in our community this week.

070Complete and utter chaos. Children coming to school. What's happening? What are we doing? Are you going to be here? Are you not going to be here? Families, what can we do? What should we do? Everyone, none of us needed that. This whole town didn't need it. Thank you. Hi, my name is Brandy Melendi. I'm a fifth grade teacher. Oh, go ahead. Are you sure? Okay. I am just going to bounce around because a lot of what I wanted to discuss has been touched on. Trustee Bell isn't informed on adjunct duties. Last night he said, so we're paying teachers more money for less work? And I was so surprised that district administrators or anyone in here didn't take a moment to explain to him that adjunct hours are, It's work we're not paid for. For example,

071I run student leadership with my co-teacher Morgan Momsen, and we do this during our lunch period. And we exceed 20 hours in order to run a club that organizes extracurricular activities for the student body at El Verano School. So, even if the adjunct hours are decreasing, teachers exceed hours of employment to help provide opportunities for the students such as family nights, school dances, and sports supervision. I wanted to say that the Parent Square message sent to families at 3 p.m. villainized teachers. You were basically apologizing for approving the tentative agreement. I want to clarify that you could have voted yes or no on the tentative agreement months ago and if the tentative agreement wasn't presented to you promptly after the agreement was signed in October Then just something wrong. You should be looking at our

072district leadership. We have a trust issue Perhaps the school administration should be more forthcoming about what has what has happened so that we can move forward from this dysfunction One can admit fault and continue to strive to fix the issues I want to also tell you that even though you're trying to make yourself better with the community. I trust that the community will stand with us because we stand with the students. Thank you. Thank you. Is there any more public comment in the room? If I could just get a count for how many more we have in the room, just because I want the people online to have an opportunity as well. And there's quite a few. One, two, three, four. Is there any others in the hallway? So I just want to confirm we

073have four people in the room left. Okay, five. All right, perfect. So we'll do five more in the room and then we're going to go to public comment online. So if you're online and you have your hand raised, please let it. Okay, perfect. Hi, I'll make this brief. My name is Pamela Lutoff Simonson, and I am a parent that pulled their children from the district. And I would like to make it clear, it was not because of the teachers. I have been educated in the bond issue, and my father's been very... involved in trying to understand the finances of the school district. I have a son that's a junior in college and a daughter that is a senior in high school. They would both be here supporting all the wonderful teachers that I am always

074so thankful for. Even when they were not attending a Sonoma Valley high school or middle school, they always remember. what they learned from their teachers. I chose to pull them from the district because of the choices that were made. I did not feel that they were for the teachers and I feel that they are the boots on the ground. They make the most impact for my children, which are successful because of all of you. So thank you and I'm just hoping. that you stop the narrative towards the teachers. I know your position is difficult where you're at, but really they are the star. And if everything else with the finances, the choices that were made, if that wasn't there, I'd still be here because of all of you. My children would be here. So thank

075you. Thank you. Hello, Mark Stolich. I'm speaking on behalf of my wife, Sonia Castaneda. Maestra Castaneda, as all our students know her. She's a teacher at Adele. She's been with the district over 20 years, and she's amazing. She wants to say that words matter. Palabras son importantes. I build a community of students, parents, and teachers, and it goes far and wide. Words matter and I'm here for all my students and families. I ask that you never again tell the teachers, our community, or and our listening kids that we can't have our cake and eat it too. Your words matter and I want you to know that your words will matter. And on a personal note, it's horrible what you've said about the teachers. They dedicate their lives as a husband. I see it. I see

076my wife working before school, after school, weekends, vacations, summers, you name it. I've seen her put hours in to help her kids, to help her classroom, and to support her son, our son, excuse me, and his teacher. So they do a lot more than just teach. They are the backbone of this community. Thank you. Thank you very much. Next speaker or Hoban teacher at Adele Harrison middle school As I listened to the meeting last night, some questions and thoughts came to mind. Trustee Winders, would you agree that families deserve affordable health care? I think you would. That's what I think about when I think of you is how you advocate for people. Yet at the board meeting last night, I heard questioning of our health care, which I would hope that you would be celebrating

077the fact that the teachers in Sonoma Valley. have affordable health care for their families it was also unfortunate that some misinformation about the health care was put out there but not surprising trustee bell i would think you would agree that a livable wage everybody deserves a livable wage so when you speak about no raise or a cut in a raise and and then want to villainize us for having a 2% when you offered a 4% and a 2% is below the cost of living. It's puzzling. Trustee Landry, I'm sure you would agree time with our families is priceless. That's kind of what I think about when I think of you as family. Yet, I feel like the board has robbed me of countless hours with my family. My daughter texted me just a minute ago,

078Mom, answer the phone. I've missed my last volleyball game last night for Sadie. Why? You answer that question. Trustee Ching, I thought you were a kindred math spirit all these years. We've talked math. I wonder why you're blaming the budget deficit on a 2% raise. Trustee Lehman, I hope I can expect more from you, but by signing off on that email at 3 p.m., that's what broke me today. That is what made me cry on the way home. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, I'm Vinny Mansfield. I'm a senior at the high school. I feel like the board needs to hear from a student. So for people who protect children and students from bullying, you bully your teachers. Good job making an example. Not going to call out names, but one of you, instead of listening

079to these important public comments, you choose to text and scroll on your phone and look on your computers and ignore these underpaid key figures in student education. These student these teachers do so much more than just teach if students need someone to cry to they are there if Students need someone to rant to they're there and yet the board doesn't understand that they are more than just a teacher As a student in the room I fully support these teachers the student the board should have made maté at three the Superintendent a long time ago because at least she would have cared about the teachers and the students. Thank you Thank you. I believe there's two more public comments in the room and then we'll go online My name is Marty Bennett. I'm a 30-year resident

080of the Valley. I also represent Unite Here Local 2, representing 15,000 hospitality workers across the Bay. And I also am a delegate to the North Bay Labor Council, 70 union affiliates and 70 members. Our union just organized the Fairmont-Senoa Mission Inn. and the Valley of the Moon Teachers Association was strongly supportive of that successful organizing campaign. We cannot thank them enough. That's why I am here to stand behind these teachers. Ratification of this contract was a step towards quality education in this district. Competitive salaries, reduced class size, Increase prep time. Increase resources for the classroom and not to high paid consultants and higher salaries for administrators. Quality education directly benefits the children of my members at the Fairmont. I am grateful that a strike was averted, but I want to warn trustees. Don't go down

081this road again and force these teachers to threaten a strike for quality education. My union just went through a three-month strike, 90 days, against Hyatt, Hilton, and Marriott. We know how important community support and labor support is. This is a one-year contract. If you go down this road, teachers must threaten a strike or strike again the entire labor movement my union the North Bay Labor Council we will stand with these teachers we will be on the picket line thank you we will see that we have quality education in this community thank you very much My name is Ronnie Fabian. I'll be quick. I wasn't going to plan on talking. I work at Presswood in TK. I'm in IA. And I just want to say how excited the kids were today to see their teachers. When

082I parked my Suburban, as soon as I hit that gate, I had kids running up to me and hugging me and telling me, did you see my teachers here today? I'm so excited. I got hugs from TKs, Ks. First, I don't see the big kids on campus because they have a different lunchtime. I had a girl today in class today say how excited she was that I didn't go bowling because that's what her parents said we were going to do today because they were talking about strikes. The children were so excited. I have never seen them smile. I have never seen them so happy to see all the teachers on campus, and it warmed my heart. And I love my job. I love our schools. And today meant a lot to the children to see

083their teachers on campus. Thank you. So that will conclude our public comment in the room. We are going to go to public comment online. So if you are online and you would like to speak on items not on the agenda, I ask that you raise your hand. I'm going to do a count of hands. And we're going to try and stick to that for efficiency here. So again, if you would like. OK. OK, so I'm seeing eight hands raised. We'll start with Miss Flores. You have two minutes. Good evening, board and superintendent. I wanted to speak on the fact that I hear a lot of complaints from your teachers currently, but I know a teacher that works far more hours in the local Sonoma community than these teachers currently. And not only is she a

084professor at the JC, she's my co-defendant in her current case because the Sonoma Valley Boys and Girls Club that you were contracted with They allowed over 40 children to be raped at that club for over a decade and they are now silencing the John Does through our tax dollars and the victims have not received restitution. So when you have virtue signaling to claim that these teachers, the board, and essentially the Democratic Party that is running Sonoma County cares about illegals, the undocumented. You don't because John Doe, number one, was deported after becoming a whistleblower. He took his own life. And so the media refuses to share this story. I won't stop speaking up about this. As I've stated before, my father was personally involved with facilitating in some capacity with this case. And so it

085saddens me that you continue to contract with an organization that is clearly racist and has no problem that Latino children were trafficked and did not receive restitution. So I do appreciate President Landry. She is the only trustee that responded and was genuinely concerned about these children. So I'm tired of you guys playing Democrats versus Republicans and bringing up race because she is a white woman who leans conservative and she was the only one who actually cared. So God bless you, Ms. Landry, and I hope the rest of you find Christ that supposedly care about children in that district. Thank you, Ms. Flores. Our next speaker is Ms. Hagan. You have the mic. You're muted. Okay. Can you hear me now? Yes. Okay, thank you. My name is Jennifer Hagan. I'm a parent in Cinema Valley.

086I want to express my concern regarding the recent decision to pass over Trustee Celeste Winders for the position of Board President. Traditionally, the vice president has moved into the presidency. I apologize for interrupting you. That's actually an item that's on the agenda. So this is just right now. No problem. Just maybe if you could not take your hand down and then when we do public comment for items on the, yeah, then that's when you would join us. And that is the first item on our regular agenda. Thank you. Yeah, no problem. Our next speaker online is Ms. Marsh. Good evening, everyone. I did not watch the board meeting yesterday, but probably by about 10 o'clock this morning, I had a lot of people telling me about it. So then I went and watched it. And

087then when I thought things couldn't get worse, I saw the letter that was sent out from the board today. And I mean, I don't suppose any of you meant to insult all the employees in the district, but you kind of did. You know and there's a huge amount of misinformation on the current board for example this idea that declining enrollment is a really bad thing for Sonoma is just not true because If our enrollment declines and our tax dollars stay the same or go up We have more per pupil so we may have We may need smaller facilities for a time, but we have more money to spend. And, you know, similarly, others mentioned, you know, trustees not understanding that adjunct duties were not paid or even understanding what they were. But also this idea,

088you know, I keep thinking that things can't get any worse in the district. And now I'm beginning to let go of that feeling because it keeps happening. And I don't even know what can be done about it. But you could be in another strike this school year because there is still no contract for the coming school year. You could be in a strike in the fall. So just like you just kicked the can down the road. I think that a dysfunctional board empowers. a weak superintendent and that is what has been happening for the last several years. A dysfunctional board empowers a weak superintendent. The current superintendent has no status in the community or even at the schools. Thank you, Ms. Marsh. I'm sorry, but your time is up. Okay. Can I just say? Thank

089you. Ms. O'Hara, do you have the mic? All right. This is Karen O'Hara, former Dunbar teacher, now a Presswood teacher and Presswood alumni. I also have two children in this district. I just need you to know that this month, while I'm teaching my kids in third grade, I highlight Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. this month. And I have students memorize parts of his I Have a Dream speech to teach them how words are powerful. So I've put a little spin on this. So in my case. I have a dream that I can inspire my students to become successful and respectful citizens in our country, in our community, in our world. I have a dream that I can work in a school district that supports and uplifts me and my coworkers. I have a dream that

090our valley can stand together and support public education. Dr. Martin Luther King also said, true peace is not merely an absence of tension. It is the presence of justice. Yes, there's a lot of tension in the air, but that's because our union is standing up. And I'm so proud to be a VMTA member, and I'm proud of all of our hard work, because we are standing up for the justice, and we are standing up to show kids words are powerful. And we need to show that to our community. We are standing together, and we need to let you know. that we have a voice and we need to be respected. We're teaching our children that and we need to be respected as well. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. O'Hare. Michelle, there's no last name, so

091you have the mic. You're muted. There you go. Hi there. Hi. My name is Michelle, alumni parent, local business owner, active. really caring community member and tonight most important role a supporter of the teachers there are so many teachers that are in that room right now and that have spoken tonight that made an incredibly positive impact in both of my daughter's lives thank you teachers and I'm very sorry that you're in this position my biggest question for the board right now is now what I'm asking for reflection any leader Any decision maker? Any sane individual? Would see. And feel and admit. How broken and terribly divided? Our district is. I am asking now what? I am asking you to slow down. I am asking you to back up. I am asking you to apologize. I

092am asking you to admit. that deep-seated issues are at hand. Trust is broken. Transparency is not there. And both must be rebuilt before anything can be dealt with in a way that will positively affect the students in our district. My question is now what? I urge you to reflect. I urge you to rebuild. I urge you to hit the reset button. before anything else is done. Please be a part of stopping this madness. Please ask for help if you need it. The harm is done. It's deep, as you can see in the room this evening. facing that reality, honoring how this situation is currently making so many people feel and show up is essential. Michelle, I'm so sorry, but your time is up. I apologize for having to interrupt you. Thank you for your comments.

093Now what? Thank you. Thank you. Ms. Jones, you have the mic. Hi there. My name is Emily Jones-Rubledo. I am a parent to a flowery student. I have two very different things to speak about, so I'm going to speak very quickly on the first one. Recently, there was an email sent home indicating that in order to volunteer, we needed to get live scan fingerprints. I wanted to bring to your attention the lack of access to live scan. live scan fingerprinting in our town as both the police stations machine and the ups store are currently unavailable this forces parents to travel to petaluma creating an inequitable barrier to volunteering in our schools many families may not have the resources to make this trip or cover the cost which was thirty dollars and this limits vital support

094for teachers and students i urge you to explore the solution to this The second topic is simply that this week has been really tumultuous and devastating for so many in our community, leaving us feeling disheartened and disappointed. I'm speaking as a parent and as a child of a career educator and as someone who deeply values the role of our teachers. that they play in shaping the future of our children. I want to acknowledge the hard work of our teachers who show up every day for our students, often under challenging circumstances. Their dedication deserves our unwavering support. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Jones. Okay, our next speaker is Mariam B. Can you hear me? Yes. Wonderful. I'm a parent not related to any teacher in the district. I just wanted to say that it appears the

095relationship has been strained between staff and district and board, has been strained even before the labor negotiations went all astray. And it seems that the district offices were disinterested in the employees in general and rarely seeks any input from the staff on all the issues that the district is currently facing. they are the ones dealing with the fallout from the decisions that the board is making and without knowing any of the details of the negotiations and missing the the meeting last night the communications that have been sent out recently um and today um really read negatively and um really froze the the teachers under the bus and even without knowing all the details it really um is obvious that there's a blame game going on for even an outsider. And I don't know how the

096district expects to retain any quality educators when you treat the staff the way you treat them. And again, with declining enrollment, people pulling their kids out to go to private school, and the quality of the education suffering and our scores being low, this will not get better if you keep treating the teachers the way you are, and they are actually all going to Petaluma or other districts. They are valued there more and make more. So I urge you to find a way. to retain the teachers we have because they're the most important part of the school district basically. We can do without anybody else in this district except for our teachers and we need to value them for the work that they do and not throw them under the bus every chance you get and

097blame them for any other shortcomings that are out of their control basically. Thank you. Thank you. Ms. Guerin, Stephanie Guerin. Okay, hello. Hello, my name is Stephanie Guerin, and I couldn't be there in person, but as a parent and a community member, I had to speak because I'm just tired of the lies. The communication to the community is appalling. It appears you are trying to spin a narrative to the community that favors you. I was in person in that very room at the board meeting where you said the TA had passed, and then you stated you had no idea what this October TA was. I'm sorry, but you guys are not the heroes in this situation because at the 11th hour you guys decided to approve it when you had months to do so. I

098fully supported the teacher's right to strike. And you know what? Maybe if you guys in your meetings would put your phones down and respect the speakers and give them eye contact, you might have more success and more support in your roles. Thank you. Thank you. Our last speaker on line is Ms. Fudum. Jessica? Hello, my name is Jessica Feudem. I'm a parent of two Altamira students. And in your letter and in other scenarios, there's a phrase for everyone to behave like our children or the students are watching. And I want you all to know that my students are watching. They attend, my students, my children are watching. They attend school board meetings. They are with me on Zoom right now. And what they see are their teachers who they cherish, their teachers fighting for justice,

099for fair compensation, fighting for respect. They see their teachers not giving up. So thank you, teachers. We appreciate you. We love you. And we see you. Thank you. Thank you. Ms. Vargas, I see that your hand was raised earlier and it went down. I'm going to make this our last speaker online. Ms. Vargas, you have the mic. You're currently muted. Yeah. Hi, we can hear you. Yeah, so my name is Angelica Vargas. I have four kids at the district. And me prometí no volver a participar en una junta. Pero esto cada vez es más indignante. As the teachers made this decision, I question myself. What do we have to do as parents to be able to be heard? Because yesterday it was mentioned that this forced decision was made by the children. But all the

100decisions that have been made lately have lost their place. None of these are being made for the children. This process is understood to be... Why do we speak in Spanish? Because the same way you felt is how all the Spanish speakers feel. Never heard, never information available in Spanish. I spent hours of late talking with the community. But now I realize, not even because it was free for you guys, you didn't see our community needed. The community, they will suffer the most. Not counting the mess that you have already on your table, but I know that that is going to be a point. It's going to come out later today. I feel tired. The community is tired. The kids are tired. It's time for you guys to wake up and start taking decisions. They really

101are base for the kids. Thank you, Ms. Vargas. Okay, so we are going to take a five-minute break. I'm just going to give like a 30-second heads up. We're going to start the meeting in about 30 seconds. If everybody could please take your seats and quiet down. We are going to reconvene in open session. All right, thank you. So we are going to move on. I'll wait until it's quiet. I might have to. We're going to move on to item number 13, which is our reports. And our first report is from Ms. Clemons, our student voice. OK, before I forget, I just wanted to say that I agree with what Crystal was saying about the snacks in the office. Because whenever I'm in my leadership class, we'll try and make someone go to the office

102so they can ask if Crystal has snacks. So we're always really hungry. So other than that, I'm excited to announce that finals week went well and everyone had a good break. And once we got back, students went through course selection. I'm excited to announce that this year, SVHS is offering a new healthcare pathway, as well as some new science classes. There are also many new performing arts electives, like oral interpretation and beginning guitar. Last weekend, our school hosted a boys wrestling tournament with 30 different schools from the Bay Area. It was great to see the amount of participants and support. Coming this month, there will be a winter rally as well as a Lunar New Year celebration, which is in collaboration between leadership and the Asian Pacific Islander Student Union. Currently, leadership is also working

103on Sonoma's Next Top Dragon that will happen in February. We want to increase participation and revise it. Male and female senior students can participate and win prom tickets. If you are a teacher slash parent, make sure to tell your students about this opportunity coming up. More information will be posted soon. A small reminder that as college decisions come out, seniors can go to the CCC and post what schools they got into. On a different note, as you guys all know, Valley of the Moon Teachers Union almost went on strike today as a result of the school board's refusal to vote on a signed agreement by the board's team and the union. As a result of the board's lack of cooperation and disrespect for the teachers, the union was led to no other choice but to

104stand up for themselves. All the students at my school and throughout the district are in support of the teachers because they are the most hardworking and best role models for us. Good teachers, like the ones we have in our district, are what make students feel safe at school. We interact with them every day, and students depend on our teachers. We need them to be respected. But the board does not understand this, as they don't interact with the kids or know the kids like the teachers do. They claim they want to make the best decision for the kids, although the best decision for them is to be kind to the people they care about. We were shocked that the vote was not put on the agenda for three months. All the teachers needed was a vote.

105You do not care about the teachers until they threaten to strike. From my perspective, after I've attended all these meetings, I believe you guys have used your power to bully the teachers. You have blamed everything on the teachers and have been super manipulative. I feel you see them as below you. All this chaos this week was caused by you guys, and once again, you put the blame on the teachers. Your blaming has not worked on all the students and community. We are aware of what you guys have been doing, and I ask you guys to take accountability for your actions and especially the disrespectful messages you sent out this week and that you have done in the past because I've kind of noticed it's a pattern. Thank you. Thank you. Our next. The next report

106is our VMTA. We appreciate the opportunity to address you today as the co-presidents of the VMTA Teachers Union. We are a very tired Laura Hoban, a math teacher at Adele Middle School, and an extremely exhausted Dennis Hausman, a physical education teacher at Sonneville High School. Again, if you haven't picked up the narrative... You can come talk to me individually. I can tell you what's going on. Let us start by thanking you, to our parents, our students, and our community, including our labor allies like Marty Bennett and Jack Buckthorn for their support of our willingness to go on strike and to hold each of you accountable to the law and to demand the respect the dedicated and hardworking educators of Sonoma Valley deserve. It is unfortunate that this board undermined its own action after three and

107a half hours in closed session in the last two days to come in last night and engaging in misinformation, excuse making, and devising rhetoric instead of taking responsibility for your own actions. It wasn't our teachers, our students, or our parents who caused this problem. All you did last night was finally, after three months, clean up a mess you yourselves made. But instead of using it as an opportunity to move forward and bring our community together, you pushed us further apart. Perhaps you're familiar with the idiom, when you're in the hole, stop digging. Last night, you dug a hole so deep, you might want to consider buying a very tall ladder. Last night was a textbook demonstration of cowardice. over leadership and of a board that took deeply flawed budget information as gospel instead of doing

108its own homework and working with its own committed and hardworking educators to truly understand what is it that our students need to thrive. No, you have not done your homework. And if last night was a lesson in leadership, I don't think I need to tell you what the great, the dedicated educators of Sonoma Valley would have given you. A lesson in leadership. You can measure a leader by the leaders they produce and generate. You're making my job easy. So let's correct the record on a few things. I'm not a genius. My brother is a rocket scientist at NASA. But I can tell you this. Two is a smaller number than four. A 2% wage increase costs the district less than a 4% wage increase. The 4% proposal you were so proud of worsens the deficit

109more than the TA you ratified when you remember that your district office administrators also take the raise through a Me Too clause they have in their contract. Weirdly, that wasn't brought up last night. Educators agreed to less money in this TA because we were negotiating in good faith and understand that there's a mismanagement of the district's budget. It might have happened before you got here, but it happened. The money spent on class-sized overages is the money you pay so you can save money by not fooling staffing our schools and providing the levels of support the students deserve. The district can avoid paying overages for the rest of the year by staffing appropriately. No one wants to be paid for class size overages because none of us want class sizes that are over our cap To

110put some context to this an English teacher for example who maybe has 21 students over their allotted class size of 28 so 21 students in their five classes in a one essay assignment It takes roughly 5 to 15 minutes to make edits and corrections Taking the quick grading time of five minutes, which is really not logical. That teacher is spending an hour and 45 minutes just in grading. That does not include the corrections, working with the students for improvement on the assignment, maybe inside class, outside class, at lunch, at break, putting it in the grade book. That's just one assignment for the extra 21 students. We don't want the extra students because we want the students to receive the attention they deserve, which is why we have class size limits in the first place. Instead

111of attacking VMTA members last night, you could have been honest with our community about years of financial mismanagement by the board and the administration. You could have asked your CBO to explain why we spend more than three times the average unified school district in California on professional consulting services. That is where you actually spend more in your budget. You could have asked your HR manager if in her research on sick leave she talked with our neighbors at Old Adobe Union School District about the 12 sick leave days per year their teachers enjoy. After last night, I'm not convinced that your administration negotiating team shared with you any of our discussions at the table, our rationale, or our comparable districts. Healdsburg is a comparable city and district. We are both basic aid. It will take our

112members 35 years to make what they make in 30 years. In closing, you have a lot of work to do to repair the harm and damage you've caused over the last months and at last night's meeting. And I'll include today's email after school. VMTA members will work with you in good faith as we've always done. Not because you are the school board we deserve, but the school board we have. The school board our students and educators deserve would stop digging and start rebuilding. Thank you. Thank you both. Kimberly, CSCA? Wrong one. Kimberly, I'll just ask that you wait until everyone clears the room that's clearing the room. Out of respect for your time. Just a few more seconds. Sure. Go ahead. Thank you. Good evening, Sonoma Valley Board of Trustees, Superintendent Dr. Chen, and District

113Directors. I am Kimberly Smith, your CSCA Chapter President, Area B, Region 24, Chapter 376. The chapter has been very active these past few months. We have increased chapter meeting attendance with special guests to provide information to chapter members. Sorry, I just lost my place. For money-saving tips, district leadership, and other guests who have explained to CSEA members how CSEA provides overall. It is very exciting to me as the chapter president to know more members are attending meetings, reading the contract, and participating in CSEA-provided online training. I can't stress enough to members to know their rights. We will continue to be busy with sending chapter members to the annual CSCA Paraeducators Conference, which is in Ontario the first week in March. We are working with the district on this. There has been money provided by the

114state specifically for classified employee professional development. I want to report to the board and a huge thank you to the district and Sonoma Valley High School, thank you Molly, for helping us host our first Vitalant Blood Drive. This was very successful with 23 slots to fill. We had 22 people sign up and 19 successful donations. And some of us have already been notified how our contributions have saved lives. Thank you again everybody for participating in that we have a new communications officer Starting this month Sarah Tevis. She is the health assistant at sasarini She is also the sasarini site rep the eboard attended this CSEA installation just this past Monday on January 6 the chapter ratified a tentative agreement with SVUSD Thank you to Terry Hernandez, Gina Parisi, Leonela Armenta, who have joined me on

115the negotiating committee. Also to Andrea Dealy, who recently stepped down from this committee and is now our chapter vice president. The chapter also ratified a much-needed revised job description for paraprofessionals. This revised job description has been over a year in... making sure the job description more aligns with the duties of the instructional assistants in the severe and moderate classrooms. A third item was ratified where CSEA and SVUSD worked thinking out of the box, a way to provide an opportunity to those who are close to retiring. CSEA encourages the board to approve these three items presented tonight. The chapter has new t-shirts, I think a couple people are wearing them. And we have been distributing them and our members have been proudly wearing them. Coming up on the 22nd, we will be taking a special donation

116which will be sent to the CSEA Dorothy Bjork Fund. This fund offers members throughout California to apply for emergency assistance. Of course, this special donation will help with the members in Southern California who have been affected by the recent and continued wildland and suburban fires. Classified employees are always willing to reach out to help their fellow brothers and sisters and lend a helping hand. CSEA Chapter 376 also offers the chapter members who have a graduating student from any high school to apply for a chapter funded scholarship. Students can check in with the Sonoma Valley High School College and Career Center. CSEA and Union Plus also offer additional extended educational scholarships. Last year's recipient was Connor Cheeseman. He won $2,000 from CSEA Chapter 376. Once again, SVUSD classified employees who work less than 12 months are

117able to apply for the Summer Assistance Program for the year of 25-26. This state-funded program helps offset those that work less than 12 months. It is a great program. The chapter is thankful the district recognizes and offers this to the classified employees. Only 60% of the districts throughout California offer this program to classified employees. Now that I've caught you up on all the wonderful happenings that CSEA Chapter 376 and the association provide their members, I hope you can all see why this union is recognized throughout the United States. CSEA is a model for other member-run unions. We know there will be challenges coming and I encourage all to work together for the betterment of the students We need to build a lot of bridges We are classified employees and we are essential employees and we

118are educators as well Thank you for giving me time tonight to catch you up better together stronger United Thank you And our next report is from Chief Cunning. Good evening, trustees, superintendent, student voice, who's not here anymore, staff and community. Since the last board meeting, there have been two incidents to report. December 16th, the Stop It app was used to identify a threat. It was between two students and Deputy Esponda began working with the administrative staff at the high school and conducted a basic investigation and working with the administrative staff of the high school were able to identify that the best solution was going to be to refer that student through the CAPE program. CAPE is the Sonoma County Mental Health Crisis Assessment Prevention and Education Team and that rather than entering that student into

119the juvenile justice system, that was a much better option. And so that's where it went. On January 7th, a physical fight between two students at Creekside High School occurred. Although this fight took place, had it not been for the immediate intervention of Principal Liskum, it may have well been worse with injuries. Instead, Principal Liskum alerted staff and began working to separate the two. Deputy Esponda was on the high school campus and rushed to the facility along with campus supervisors and the high school administrative staff. Principal Liskom had separated the two at the point Ed arrived. Deputy Esponda remained at Creekside campus to ensure the situation did not elevate again while Creekside admin investigated and determined the situation was best handled through school discipline. No report and no crime was charged. When staff are present and

120able to intervene and de-escalate, as Principal Liskum did in this case, the outcome is always better for the involved students and any others observing the situation. This week, the two sergeants that are assigned to the Sonoma Police Department are in Texas. They're at what's called an active attack incident management program called ALERT. And it's a program that's provided through Texas State University. It's a grant-funded program. And they're there to do this train-the-trainer program so that when they come back, they can provide better... active attacker training to school staff, administrative staff, as we've been doing every year for the last few years. It's just an updated and more advanced program. During the last two school board meetings, I personally sat up here and I've held my tongue. I did not want to brag or jinx the

121success, but Deputy Nespanda and I have participated over the last approximate two months in a very competitive ping pong tournament at Creekside High School. I will say age did prevail. Deputy Nespanda and I brought our best game, and over the last two months of this tournament, we actually won. Thank you. It was impressive. We would like to thank the Creekside students and staff for inviting us to enjoy that time and getting to know many of the students, albeit maybe across the net. And we are sorry for winning. Although not a new problem, we've been seeing a significant increase in gang-related taggings across the Sonoma Valley. There have been reports of late-night altercations, which we have learned have been identified as run-ins between opposing gang interests. I would encourage the schools, community centers, and other family

122education centers to look for and consider increasing outreach and education. to pay attention to the indicators like clothing, language, writings, and have open conversations with your kids about gangs if you are concerned. This was a priority for many years and for many families, but as the gang activities have waned between 2015 and now, many of the programs have lost support. As we are seeing an increase in this, parents and community need to become involved in their kids and what they do when they are not at home. We will work with the school district and provide a list of resources in the area that may help parents with early recognition and intervention. Many of us have witnessed the horrible outcome that gang membership can cause and I'm afraid we are getting to the point that we

123have to address the situation before we are back where we used to be. Lastly, we are at the end of the first week of traffic pattern changes in the high school parking lot. Monday was absolutely horrible. Tuesday and every morning since, to quote Crystal, has been very calm. The afternoons are something we are working on. We have the Caltrans traffic light engineer coming to assist us with an adjustment to have the green light held longer for traffic leaving the campus after school. Once that is complete, we believe the end of the day evacuation will happen faster and safer than it currently does. We have another week of the trial and discussion with Principal Kiss and her staff to determine if this is a better way or not. And the last thing I really want to

124mention is the I did hear during the public comment about live scans. Yes, there are only two machines in the Sonoma Valley area. We have one at the police department and then UPS used to have one. My understanding is the UPS store will not be. bringing their machine back so we will have the only one ours is down our server was sent to of all places pasadena you can imagine that that has now been shipped to the east coast and so we do have a delay and that is not by any plan it's just the way sometimes these computers work we do expect to have our live scan back up and running in the we're hoping within a week or two thank you thank you okay we now have our superintendent report So I want

125to start off my report by asking us to just take a minute to acknowledge and show our respect for the fire victims in Los Angeles. So our thoughts are with the communities that have suffered devastating losses of both homes and lives. I especially want to extend my support to the superintendents of LAUSD and Pasadena who are having to figure out how to support their students and where they're going to place their students as many of their schools have burned down. As many of you know, LA is my hometown, and it really breaks my heart that many of our families and, like others expressed, just other educators are going through a really difficult time right now. I also want to take this opportunity to introduce a new employee to the board. So I'm going to ask

126Harold Wigg if you can go up to, or just stand up. That's fine. Harold is a new program manager in our business office. He has experience working in private organizations in the area of business operations and accounting. And I know most of you are probably thinking he looks really, really young. But he does come with lots of experiences. He served as an assistant director of operations where he supervised, evaluated a large team. And he really worked on providing high quality deliverables where he worked. So we're just excited to have him and just welcome Harold to the team. I also want to recognize Hudson Gerrida from Sonoma Valley High School. He was recognized as the Press Democrats Player of the Year for football. Hudson was also recognized, I want to get this right, as a Redwood

127Empire Conference Mountain Division Player of the Year. Congratulations to Hudson. And we know that he's going to be able to choose a quality football program, and we wish him the best of luck. I also want to share with the community that beginning this month in the newsletter that we send home, there's a section there for information about school consolidation. As you know, today you're going to be presented, board, with a transition plan that is really kind of a... a high level transition plan, we do have more details to share with you. That transition plan covers information about how to bring staff, students, and families together. It doesn't really talk about the logistics and operations, but I just want to reassure the community and the board that we do have a logistics. operations list that we've

128also shared with some of our teachers so that they know the tasks that we're working on that we're accomplishing and so on that newsletter section we're going to be updating it every month just letting you know what has been accomplished what tasks we're working on so that we ensure a smooth transition from our campus at a Dell to Altamira And then lastly, I just want to congratulate our transportation manager, Stacey Ledoux, whose hard work was able to secure a grant for us. We now have five charging stations for our buses, and it's just right in time because he shared with us that a couple of them have gone down and are no longer functioning. So we have now five charging stations, and then if you recall, a couple of months ago, you... you approved purchasing

129two additional buses that will support transportation for our students and we do now currently have those buses so I just wanted to update the community about that thank you okay thank you dr. chin we are going to go ahead and move along to item number 14 which is our consent agenda The purpose of the consent agenda is to act upon routine matters in an expedient manner. Items listed are usually considered routine and are acted on in one motion. It is understood that administration recommends approval of all consent agenda items. There is no discussion of items unless a member of the board requests removal of an item to be inserted at an appropriate place on the regular agenda. Each item approved by the board shall be deemed to have been considered in full and adopted as

130recommended. The board is asked to approve the consent agenda items as submitted. President Landry, I'd like to remove 14.9, the Safe Schools Resolution, per community request for board discussion and action. Okay. Does everybody? Okay. OK, wait. Hold on one second. Is it different than this? Yes. OK, just one second. Let's just talk about. Oh, sorry. No, that's OK. So we're going to pull 14.9. 14.9. Could we make it 15.0? We already have a 15.1. That's what I was asking. How about 15.1A or B? 15.1B. Do you want to get 15.1 done first? CHRISTIE WOOD. OK. So we're going to do 15.1 as it is, and then we're going to add item 14.9 into the regular agenda as item 15.1B. So it will come after 15.1. OK. Trustee Bell, did you have another request? CHRIS MARTIN.

13114.2, I have a question on the ratification of contracts under 50,000. Okay, so you'd like to pull that and place that can we place that is that number five Which is contract number five with crisis prevention Institute, okay So where would you like that placed? Okay Yeah, okay, so Okay, let's let's make that 15.12 B. President Landry, can I make one request? Yes. For the sake of time and in public comment, we did two minutes earlier. If we could do two minutes for the rest of the agenda items today to ensure we get to what I think are some really important regular agenda items that are now kind of falling down the list. just be a request to do public comment at two minutes for the remainder of this meeting. I would agree with that.

132I would actually disagree with that. That's typically our practice when we have a lot of comment in the room on one particular subject. It hasn't been the board's past practice if there's not a lot of comment on a specific subject. And so I think it's only right for consistency's sake that we maintain our past practices. I mean, if there's only one or two public comments on each item, bumping them down to two minutes doesn't seem in alignment with our practices. Okay. So I would agree with Trustee Winders. Why don't we just kind of monitor as we go? We can see what the line is, and then if we have to adjust back to two minutes, we can do that. So I would just... Okay, that sounds good. So we're just going to monitor as public

133comment as we go. Is there any other items that any trustee would like to request be pulled off the consent agenda? Seeing none. So I will move to approve the consent agenda. Do I need to? We have to approve it, right? Yeah, so I will move to approve the consent agenda, excluding items 14.9. 14.2 is there a second second okay all in favor aye aye Thank you. Okay, we are going to move on to our regular agenda. So the first item on our regular agenda is public comment on board officer elections. So I have something to read for context. During the board's December 13th organizational meeting, it elected the board officers. Subsequent to the meeting, the board received a complaint alleging that by not affirmatively asking if there was any public comment, the board had

134violated the Brown Act. While no member of the public was prevented from providing public comment and no Brown Act violation occurred in December, to address the concern of the community, the board has agendized an opportunity for public comment on the officer elections for this meeting. Is there any questions from the board? Seeing none, we'll go to public comment. So is there any public comment in the room in regards to the board officer elections? Seeing none, we'll go online. Public comment online. Okay, David, you have the mic. I'm sorry, sir, you are muted. I had to unmute. No problem. Go ahead. Okay. Anyway, first of all, you did it again. You did not call for public comment on the consent calendar. But anyway, I had no comment on it, but you have to at least ask

135that. Any case, I'm going to go on here from 15.1. When you elected the officers of the board last month, you did not provide any opportunity for the public to comment, even if that was not a technical violation of the Brown Act, which I believe it is. It is not within the spirit of Brown Act and contrary to best practices. The Sonoma City Commission's agenda for election of chair and vice chair specifies that there will be public comment. This is happening in tonight's planning commission meeting. One, selection of chair. A, chair calls for nominations for chair. B, public comment. C, vote, etc. I also checked out the San Francisco Unified School District board meeting, and they, too, asked for public comment when electing officers of the board. You must redo the election of officers at

136your next board meeting, as I definitely have comments as to who I would believe would be the best president of a board of trustees. Also, having the election at 2.30 just before a closed session instead of with the rest of the open session item minimizes the public's chance for input. Thank you. Thank you, David. Ms. Hagan, you have the mic. Okay. Hi. Thank you. I started to speak earlier. So I just wanted to say that traditionally... In the elections, the Vice President has moved into the presidency, reflecting continuity and recognition of their contributions to the Board. However, this precedent was disregarded in Trustee Winder's case, causing questions about the integrity and fairness of the decision-making process. It is troubling that personal feelings held by Trustee Ching and Trustee Bell against Trustee Winters appear to have

137influenced their votes. Such personal biases have no place in decisions that impact the governance of our schools. These actions undermine not only the principles of fairness, but also the trust the community places in this board to act in the best interests of all the children in the Valley. Trustee Wenders represents a vital underserved segment of our community, one that often struggles to have its voice heard in decision-making processes. By denying her the opportunity to serve as Board President, the Board has sent an unfortunate message that the needs and perspectives of this part of our community are not valued or prioritized. This decision risks alienating those who already feel marginalized and reflects poorly on the board's commitment to equity and inclusion. And I would encourage the board to reflect on this matter and take steps to

138ensure that decisions are made based on merit, equity, and the best interests of our entire community, free from personal bias or favoritism. Our schools and students deserve leadership that upholds these principles without exception. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Hagan. Ms. Norris, you have the mic. You're muted. Yeah, it's Drury Norris, not Norris. Hey, so I wanted to chime in on the brown adulation that happened in last meeting as well. Love the little wry smile, love the facial expressions, very classy, very professional. The fact that it happened at 2.30 in the afternoon felt really fishy. It happened without public comment. And the aspect that really troubled me going back and watching this after it was posted. was how it all went down. It almost felt like watching a wedding where there's the formality, the passing of

139the gavel, and someone says, you know, any objections? No one's expecting to object. But this board jumped into action. It was seamless. Trustee Bell was waiting. He said it. Bam. Ching seconded it. Okay? And then bam, bam. Vote, vote. And so the part that troubles me about that is that as far as I understand the Brown Act, is that you're not supposed to meet with more than two people. You're not supposed to have a meeting in private. So how is it that this happened that every person except for the person that was getting booted out knew about it. There was like a little bit of shock where we like consulted legal, is this okay, what's going on? But how did the other four, including the two new people, how come everyone was on the same

140page? That's something that troubles me as someone who watched that go down. It was really, it makes me question if this board is doing things above the board. And then the other thing is that If this turns out this was a Brown Act violation, my concern is that all these decisions, these incredibly momentous decisions that have been made, does that jeopardize their validity? So I think we should be doing everything by the book because if it turns out that that wasn't valid, then are we going to have to go back and redo all those votes? Thank you. Okay, and I'm gonna go ahead and just call you by your first name because I don't want to unintentionally mispronounce your last name. Josette, you have the mic. You're muted. Yeah, I have to unmute. Josette Broziker,

141while there is a contention that not calling for public comment before nominating and approving board officers is or is not a Brown Act violation, let me say that honesty, transparency, and always involving the public is the obligation of any elected body, such as a school board. The election was held at a very, very short open session before a closed session that the public was totally unaware of instead of at the normal time of an open session when a large number of community members would be attending. a trustee that can chair these meetings in an informed way with a full understanding of the diverse student body that you have is needed now more than ever. In my it is if if my child was in your schools i would not only be ashamed of what happened

142i would be angry and and after general comment that i saw tonight i see that this is not the only issue where the board does not value honesty transparency and value and respect the people in the community before them thank you thank you josette Just last call for any other public comment online before I turn it back over to the school board. Seeing none. So I would just ask my trustees, or my fellow trustees, if anyone is interested in changing the way that they voted. So I'd just like to start the conversation like that just for full transparency. Is anyone interested in making any changes? And if we have a majority, then we will go ahead and place a re-election or the election on the February 7 agenda. So I'll turn it over to you

143all to discuss. No, I'm not going to change my vote. Trustee Winders? Well, my vote was an abstention. And I'll just say the reason that I abstained is that it wasn't following the historical practices of the district, going back to the records that are available through the archives back to 2016. And so that's why I abstained, because I couldn't support something that wasn't following the board's historical practices. I would not change that abstention for that reason. And I still hold that. It's not even my belief, it's just a fact that the historical records going back to 2016 that are available up into the archives demonstrate that historically the practice of the board has been that the vice president is nominated to the president role. And then of course at that point trustees can use their

144vote and they can vote yes or they can vote no or they can abstain and they always should use their vote. to go with their conscience. But historically, the practice has always been that. I think the part that I take issue with is that in 2020, board president Ducaro, actually it was 2019, excuse me. In 2019, board president Ducaro has resigned from the board. Vice president Kelly. became then responsible for her duties, but remained as vice president. And if you look at the headers of the agenda, there's no president listed because that's how that process worked. And then in December, Vice President Kelly was nominated and then became President Kelly for the school year. So it was actually a very identical situation to the one that we found ourselves in this year. So I just,

145for me, a core belief of governance. is that while there's policy and there's practice, practice is what creates stability and predictability for community in a district. And I just felt that it was important to provide that. And then lastly, I just want to say that When I was elected to Area 2, it was an interesting experience because it was the first election where the Voters' Rights Act had been put into place, and you only could vote for a trustee in the area if you lived in that area. Prior to that, everybody in the Valley voted for every trustee in every area, but you couldn't run for that seat unless you lived in that area. And so right before the election, when I ran in, That had changed through a board decision and action and was

146in alignment with the state guidelines. And so the reason I bring that up is that in my area for the first time when I was elected, it was the first time that a trustee in that area had been elected by only the people who lived in that area. and what I view that as that's a self-determination that's a community's determining for themselves how they wanted to move as a community and they did so with the belief and the understanding that the predictability of the practices of the board would continue and that they as area two would have the opportunity to have at least one year when their representative was able to lead the board just as every other area is provided that opportunity for at least one year during their elected, their chosen elected officials

147term. And so. That is the reason why I abstained and I wouldn't change my abstention because my abstention was rooted in good governance and what I was trained in my masters in governance training which I dedicated a lot of time to and took very seriously. So when I show up here to do the work, I show up here to do the work. I do the work as I was trained. I think that policy practice and procedures are really important. It's how I do my job in my professional life and it's how I do my job when I show up here. So that's all I have to say and I would always entertain the will of the board to not move it forward or to move it forward but I would remain with my abstention vote

148at this point for that reason. Okay, thank you Trustee Winders. Trustee Ching? I would entertain another election. I don't think that my vote would change, and I do have a difference of opinion about past practices. I don't personally believe, and I have never believed since joining the board, that past practices should constrain, or the past practices of a prior governing body should constrain the current practices of the current governing body. And there are a lot of past practices that I didn't agree with 20 years ago when I started attending board meetings in 2004. And I think that as a governing body, we should determine what our practices are. And just because somebody started a practice 20 years ago, I don't feel an obligation to follow those practices. So that's a slightly different view. And I

149would say that. The person who is voted in as the chair is really the person who's facilitating the meeting, and I don't feel like that should change how we represent our constituents. We represent all five areas equally. That's how I view it. So anyway, that's how I feel about it, and I don't have more to say. Okay. Trustee Lehman? I'll make a short comment. I ran to be a trustee and with no expectation for any further title or position or responsibility. I'm honored that my fellow trustees elected me vice president. I'll fulfill the duties of that role. And I have no preconceived notion about any future positions on this board. I'll do my best to represent my district. And to trustee Ching's comment, I will also... and equally do my best to equally represent all

150five districts. I view the role in the same sense that we are elected from one district. We are here to represent all districts and I'm honored to do that in any capacity that this group elects me to do it in. At this point, I probably would not change my vote either. I think it's best we move forward. That would be my opinion. Okay, so I'm hearing some, I'm hearing Trustee Winders wouldn't change, oh go ahead, yeah. I'm sorry, I just feel compelled to correct something. So Trustee Ching, you completed Masters in Governance as well, correct? Yeah. So you and I both have the same training. Okay. I think that we're the only ones who've completed it so far. I think there's some who are, have you completed? Okay, so there's three of us. So in

151Masters in Governance, we are trained. The board president doesn't just facilitate the meeting. So the board president sets the agenda with the superintendent. The board president and the superintendent are the ones who are in direct communication with legal counsel. Other trustees can, of course, meet with legal counsel, but they have to go through the board president and ask if that's okay. There's many things that a board president does. The board president speaks for the board and communicates to the public on behalf of the board. So I just want to make it clear to the public that the board president doesn't just facilitate. facilitate a meeting and we've been trained that in masters and governance and so I I just feel compelled that it's important to make because the community doesn't take masters and governance so

152they wouldn't know that but some of us take it and complete it and are trained in that so there's actually a lot more responsibility that goes into being a board president than just facilitating a meeting and so I just think it's important for the public to be aware of that since they don't receive the same training we do trustee Ching would you like to respond okay yeah um So you're right there there is a list of duties that we define in our bylaws but essentially the board president doesn't really have more authority than any one of us in terms of like our vote it's true that they have these extra duties so I anyway that's people can you know read it in bylaw you know 91 21 so But I'm curious, Trustee Ching, because we're

153having, so let's have a conversation, right? Let's have a courageous conversation. I hear, and correct me if I'm wrong, I feel like what I heard was that you've never supported the past practices, and it's not something you support, except. I've watched you. I mean, this is your second term. So for four years, I watched you nominate vice president into president and vote yes and second vice president into president every single year, except when I was vice president. And so I'm curious when you don't support something, why every year you did it, except for this year. And so it just, it's a little bit confusing to me. That's all. Well, I guess the point that I was, the way I was thinking at the time was that you were actually serving as president. And I guess

154that's the way I perceived it, that you were serving as our president. Except you received the same board communication that all of us received from legal counsel prior to the meeting, explaining to us for that particular item that I was not board president, that I was vice president, fulfilling the duties of the president temporarily. because the president had resigned and it's no, and that it's no different than say, if the president was sick for a meeting, the vice president would fulfill those duties, but the vice president doesn't become the president. And you were sworn in in 2020 when trustee Kelly was present, was board president. And he had done the exact same thing when trustee Duke Rose had resigned. So I'm sorry. I just, I feel like it's a bit disingenuous. to say that it's

155not something you supported when historically that's the practice you've participated in. And I don't want to argue. I think it's important for us as a board to just do our job and move forward. But I also think it's important to have courageous conversations and to not pretend that something's different than it is. I work with everybody. I collaborate with everybody. I'm here to do good work for kids. I didn't get elected onto a board to be best friends i got elected onto a board to do my job and to work and in my job every day i'm in meetings with people that we have differences of opinion we may have personal feelings but it doesn't matter we're getting work done for children and we're coming out with good conclusions and and good collaborative work for

156children and so i just hope as a board that we can move forward with that work that's my intention that's the work that i do when i show up here every single board meeting it's the work that i do every single day i put in about 20 to 30 hours a week as a school board trustee outside of being in the meetings. And when I'm doing that work, that's my focus. But I also think that it's important to have courageous conversations and to say the things. And if I did something in my duties as vice president, if I did something in my role of taking on the duties of president when Trustee Knox resigned, if I didn't do something or I did something badly, I would like to hope that my fellow would say, hey

157Celeste, in the future, hey Celeste, when you did this, it wasn't correct. And I didn't get any feedback like that. So I was a bit surprised when it was time for me to step into a role that I assumed based upon past practices that I would do, that that would happen. Because nobody had communicated to me that I had. perhaps done something wrong or wasn't doing a good job and so I just hope moving forward in the future if I do do something and I'm not doing a good job or you think that I'm doing something wrong I would just like to hope that my fellow trustees would actually tell me because if I don't know I can't do better I just assume that what I'm doing is correct and that nobody has a problem

158with it so in the future I would just appreciate a direct communication that you know you'd expect something different from me thank you CHRISTIE WOODARD. OK. Thank you very much for that explanation. And I just want to be completely transparent with my fellow trustees as well as the community. So this was not a Brown Act violation, and we wanted to write this by the members of our community who requested the opportunity to have public comment. So we did not have to do it. We chose to do it because we value our community and their opinion. What I'm hearing from my fellow trustees is it doesn't sound like anyone would be changing the way that they voted. Therefore, for the efficiency of our meetings and getting back to the work for kids, I'm suggesting and I'm

159just asking for confirmation that we are not going to be doing another vote and election in February. If I'm incorrect, please let me know. But what I'm hearing is since no one's interested in changing the way that they voted, then it's really not worth the time to do it since we are not required to do it. So if I could just get confirmation before we proceed forward, I would just appreciate that. And please, by all means, if I am incorrect in that analogy, let me know. No, I'm fine. I'm not going to change my vote. Same I'm not changing my vote. I think for efficiency purposes the best use of our time is to move forward We have a lot of other agenda items today and on future meetings and future months ahead Unless others

160are changing their vote. I would suggest we close this item and do not put it on a further agenda Okay with no other comments from the board. I'm going to say that we go ahead and proceed forward to what is going to be 15.1B. It's 14.9 in the consent agenda that we pulled. No, that's the resolution. Yeah. Oh, I did. I apologize. Oh, I think I did say that, and I just misspoke. I'm sorry. I apologize. Yeah. So. Just for clarity, yes, we're going to the resolution, which is 14.9 in the consent agenda. It is now being considered 15.1. I wrote it down as B, and I misspoke. It's 14.1A. My apologies. okay so this is one that I asked to be pulled and got some requests from community to pull it out of just

161wanting to have a discussion get some clarity and also get some reassurance and so I I did ask for it to be pulled on behalf of the community some of the concerns that were brought up on this item was wanting to get clarity um there was concerns about a 90 days and wanting to be 60 days in reference to the 2017 resolution and then there was questions regarding the district of developing a plan for students in the event of a parent or guardian detainment to ensure that the agents and ensure that the agencies providing child care before and after care also have been trained just as a matter of due diligence I reached out to our partners about that they I believe are one of their representatives is on zoom to answer questions for the

162board and regarding that who have shared with me they are also in process in their trainings and their policies and procedures but I do know that we should have one of them on zoom should the board have questions because I know there were community questions on that so that's why i pulled the item and those were the concerns that the community had raised regarding that item okay thank you for the context and i just wanted to say i also received these emails and i did received uh did receive trustee winders email requesting to have this pulled. So in preparation for conversation and just for clarity and clear communication to our community, I've asked both Dr. Chen and our police chief, Chief Cutting, to speak on this resolution because It just seems like there's just some

163concerns that I think an explanation will help resolve. And so before we go to public comment, we're going to have them speak on this as if it's a presentation. So we are following our procedures. So obviously I also saw the emails and the concerns from the community. I just wanted to share and give a little bit of context because when you look at the document, it looks like we've put together a resolution and we're just starting the first step in this work. And I just wanted to clarify to the community that we have done a lot of work prior to this resolution. I know that there was a concern about the current. document and it not having more language or more detail but what we wanted to make sure is that the community understands that

164we're reaffirming the 2017 resolution and we're adding we're not substituting the resolution so we're adding to the 2017 resolution because we feel that the language in the 2017 resolution still stands and still is appropriate we also know that this is probably going to be the first step because this is a board resolution. It's not a board policy. Um, I know that many, um, districts across the state of California are putting together, um, policies right after our, um, administration, our new, um, federal administration comes into play, uh, into place because we don't know quite yet what those changes in policy from the federal government might be. So we're trying to be both proactive. and we're going to have to unfortunately be reactive based on the changes that the new administration might put in place so i

165i just wanted to um let the public know that again it's not what we have in 2017 still stands and we're adding to that with this new resolution i also wanted to share with you some things that we've done so far in terms of this resolution because again we feel it's a priority to ensure that our families and our students feel safe in regards to immigration. So a few things that we've done so far is in one of our newsletters, we have put information for parents to ensure that they update their emergency contacts. That's really important for obvious reasons. If we have parents or families who are put in situations where they can't come to their children immediately, we want to make sure that we're able to. provide support to those families by having the

166next person kind of in line who's going to take responsibility and supervise children. So that has gone out. We've also put out information about resources regarding immigration to our families via newsletters. And then the County Office of Education provided some resources to us and we passed those along to our administrators. And I know that they've put those in their newsletters as well so that there's information for families if they're in situations where they need some support. We're also working, like Trustee Winter said, with our Boys and Girls Club because they are our after-school providers. And I know that we do have Carrie online if anybody has questions about that. But we've also been working with La Luz, talking to them about what they've been doing to give information to our parents. We just had a

167conversation today with Immigration Services. I know Vicky's in the room just in case you have questions for her as well. And then we've also been having constant communication with the Chief of Police. Chief cutting in regards to his protocols and the conversations and relationships that we have with each other in terms of what would what would it look like if we are faced with certain situations and how we communicate with one another. The other piece of this is training. I want everyone to know that we have trained our principals in protocols on how to address federal law enforcers who come onto the campus. We also have provided protocols to our office managers and our community liaisons at this point. We are going to be moving forward with additional training for our teachers and our classified

168staff just in case they also run into a situation. where they're going to have to address a federal officer. And so there's ongoing training that's going to be happening. And like I said, we anticipate there's probably going to be some changes at the federal level. So as we learn more, we're going to obviously include that in the training and have continuous communication with our families and with our staff. So I just wanted to... give that kind of brief synopsis because I don't want anyone to think that we're just at step one with this work that we know impacts our families and can be very devastating to them. So I'm going to ask Chief Cutting if you can come up. Good evening for the second time. The relationship between law enforcement and the communities they serve

169is unique as law and order is a necessity in every community. In the ideal world, All people would make the right decisions and choices for the safety and security of all. Reality is that every community has good people that make bad decisions and some people that are driven with dangerous or violent motives. Since most of modern society has the latter, peace officers are a necessary balance in every community. When we discuss the relationship around schools and the youth, it is significantly more complex than what I just said. I have stated several times, the truest victims in our society are kids, as they are where they are by no decision of their own. It is for this reason that I am supportive of this resolution that you are considering. Two years ago when I began my

170role as a police chief, the concern that was spoken to me by parents, school staff, students was a feeling that the campuses were missing some key safety elements to provide the needed security for students to learn. This led to many discussions with the community, school staff, school district, and yes, the school board, to identify what the role of your local law enforcement could and should look like to fill a gap, if there was one. What was learned from this was that no matter where you stood on the view of law enforcement and society as a whole, locally, there is a trust in the Sonoma Police Department and the Sonoma County Sheriff's Office to do the right thing and make the right decisions that ensure students are given a place where they can feel safe to

171learn and not worry about what happens outside the four walls of the classroom. From this, we set to developing the community resource officer, a role that was designated or designed to ensure that it added a level of safety for the students and staff that felt there needed to be more. And we also needed to be very careful to ensure that the students who are not comfortable with law enforcement's presence are not threatened by this and that all exposures and experiences are positive to build or in some cases rebuild that trust. Today, as many young people in our community are learning about how these situations may impact their lives, it is more important than ever for me to stand before you and speak to the fact that all of your local law enforcement agencies in the

172state of California cannot inquire in any way about the immigration status of anyone that we come in contact with during the course of our duties. If through an investigation we learned about someone's immigration status, we are not documenting that for any future immigration related issues. And if we have learned about this status, we cannot communicate that with any immigration official. In other words, it is not relevant to local law enforcement where you are from. It is also important to understand that there is a difference between the Sonoma Police Department Sonoma County Sheriff's Office and federal law enforcement. agencies, immigration officials. Federal law enforcement officers are not bound to follow California state law, as I am, and every California peace officer is. They are bound to follow federal laws and policies, of which my voice is

173no louder than any of yours. Our commitment to all members of the Sonoma Valley community is that we will follow all laws that govern our roles and actions. If you call for help through 911, a neighbor, you flag down a patrol car, or see us on a call, local law enforcement will continue to come and will not ask or report any immigration information as it is not our business to know and is unlawful for us to do so. Today, I stand in front of you to make it clear. to everyone that there is no language in this resolution that affects or changes the supportive relationship that we all have together. The trust we all have of one another allows us to meet and discuss any concerns and change what or how we interact and communicate.

174Student safety and security is the job of the school, the district, the parents, the students, and yes, your law enforcement. This will remain our top priority for all of our students. Thank you. I just wanted to add, thank you, Chief Cunningham, that moving forward, I know I mentioned we might have to write additional policies, and I forgot to mention that the Attorney General of the State of California has put out guidance, and so our intention is to follow the Attorney General's guidance so that everyone knows that that's the standard and the resource that we're intending to use. Okay, so at this time I'll turn it over to questions from the board and then we'll go to public comment and we'll bring it back for discussion. So is there any questions of the board for either

175Chief Cutting or Dr. Chen? I have a question. Why aren't we just waiting until we get direction from the Trump administration, from the Attorney General, and why don't we just do this once instead of do it now and then do it again? Like I mentioned earlier, we have to be proactive and reactive. We, I think, have to understand that our families right now are feeling threatened. They're feeling scared. They're reaching out to us and they're asking for support. And so as... We have to, again, provide education for all students regardless of their immigration status. So we have to ensure that our parents and our families feel safe and secure in sending their kids to school. There are some things that we already know. And like I said, this is not the first time that this

176board or boards across the state of California have put together a resolution like this. And so we're... We're going to, again, this is a resolution when the federal government, if and when, which more likely than not they will make some changes, we're going to have to have conversations about policy. So it's more than just a resolution. It's additional policies. And so to add to that, there's also pending state legislation regarding educate schools and immigration that's being moved forward. And so the bottom line is our families are afraid now. There has already been reports of ICE making appearances in Kern County and in some other areas. And so this is a very real thing for very real families. And in 2017, immediately after the election, because of some of the talking points that were put out.

177This district already saw an immediate drop in attendance. There were families that were afraid to bring their kids to school and our attendance saw a significant and sudden dip. which is why this resolution was written in 2017 was to provide that reassurance because there was a lot of concerns that children were unable to access their education because families were afraid and they were rightfully afraid. So this is a situation having talked with some of our partners too and having talked with some folks in some other districts that I know and work with it's such a fluid situation that every single district in the state of California and in other states are going to have to constantly adjust and constantly revisit their practices, their policies. There's probably going to be multiple updates because it is a

178fluid situation, so it's going to change. So if we were to wait, we would wait endlessly because there's really no end to the story. It's something that's going to continue to go on. So I think it's something we're going to have to work on as a board continually. Is there any questions from Trustee Ching or Trustee Lehman? This is questions, right? Okay, I just want to make sure. Comments later. Could you just remind me which of our board members was on the committee that helped refresh or update this resolution? Anyone from our board? or I'll revise my question and just ask so I'll tell you who worked on it and where we we got our references from so Jillian who's our director of basically student services worked on this I know she got some some

179input from you trustee Wenders but we looked when we looked at the updated language we looked at The resolution for LAUSD and San Diego Unified because they're the two largest districts in the state of California. And we know that when they put out policies, they've been vetted by many of their attorneys because they have lots of attorneys on their payroll. And so we wanted to ensure that what we had in terms of our language had been vetted. And so we used both of their resolutions when we drafted this one. Thank you for the context. OK. With no further questions by the board, I will turn it over to public comment in the room. Is there any public comment in the room on this item? Just please introduce yourself. Yeah. Hi, my name is Vicki hand

180run I'm from Sonoma immigrant services and I wasn't gonna make a comment But I would like to answer your question why now? because you serve the families of the district and this is what they're asking for and Also because the Attorney General has recently updated their policy and you should also update your policy to reflect that Thank you I'm Claudia Robbins. I'm on the North Bay Rapid Response Steering Committee. We were instrumental in starting this resolution in 2017. And we strongly support it. I'm delighted that the board has brought it up again. I think it's imperative that it be acted on immediately. And I'm glad, Superintendent, that you have been doing what you have spoken about tonight, starting already to see that. staff on sites and office members know about the policy, starting making plans

181to educate teachers and other community partners, working with community partners. So I'm very happy that this is happening. I must say that the 2017 resolution, which is very detailed and was based on looking at Los Angeles and also Santa Rosa and other resolutions in the area. I think has a few flaws. And that may have been in the implementation, because I hear more, you're speaking about more now than I was aware of in 2017 in trying to follow this through. But I think that particular, the trainings and very consistent reports to the board on this resolution and the actions are extremely important. for our community both our students, our families, our teachers, everyone who works in the district, a bus driver, everyone. This is affecting us all. So the 2017 resolution required that the superintendent

182report on the implementation plan, and we actually assumed that such an implementation in the plan existed now, that it was happening every year, but it sounds like maybe we're starting again in some ways. So we request that in the... the Superintendent Development Implementation Plan instead of within 90 days as the 2017 resolution stated, but 60 days, hoping that that's possible because this seems like an emergency now. The 2017 resolution also said that the superintendent will provide training for site administrators and school and district office personnel on how to respond to requests from Ives who are entering our school property. We think everyone should know that, not just office personnel. Every teacher, every employee in the district. and that information that we both trainings and information posted in appropriate places for every every district employee to

183refer to all right so we look forward to ongoing reports and collaboration and the posting of our rapid response number right thank you thank you next public comment Hi, Dennis Houseman, VMTA co-president, and I'm just here to say that all of our educators will teach anybody you put in our classes. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Houseman. Is there any other public comment in the room? Ms. Smith? Kimberly Smith, CSEA chapter president. I just want to thank you and recognize that you're offering to train all staff, not only... you know that includes the kitchen staff and the bus drivers and thank you for acknowledging that thank you thank you miss Smith is there any other public comment in the room seeing none we'll go to public comment online if you are interested in making public comment

184on this item I just ask that you please raise your hand Josette you have the mic Okay, so my comments are going to have to change a little bit because it was very unclear to anyone reading these two documents that the 2017 document that this is just an addendum to it. It looked like a replacement, which I think is there's no clarity there for those of us in the public to really know exactly what is laid out in this resolution and I would suggest that you somehow clarify that because one is very vague and one is very precise And the last thing that I would say that you need to really, well, not the last thing, you really need to think about is the main fear is that people are not going to send their

185children to school unless that's very clear. And the reason I know this is because I attended the January 10th Special Board of Supervisors meeting where there were two hours of public comment with two minutes each. each allowed and you can see the mass of speakers. Two-thirds of the speakers spoke about this. They spoke about what will happen when children are separated and also the fear of sending their children to school. Board of Supervisors recognizes this as the number one issue before them. So that is why I'm speaking tonight. And like I said, after the way I've heard miscommunication tonight on many other issues, I would really suggest that you clarify. that these two resolutions what exactly is the entire resolution otherwise i don't think the community is really going to understand what you have here

186thank you thank you josette david you have the mic Hi, yes. First, I just want to say that I support everything said by Claudia Robbins in terms of the change in the additions. One other thing that I would suggest is that you add language to the resolution that adds to, not replaces, the 2017 resolution. Otherwise, others may believe it is a replacement and not take into account anything in the 2000 resolution. Also, I want to thank the board. in pulling this item from the consent calendar. Otherwise, since you violated the Brown Act, you did not ask for public comment during that consent calendar. I would not have been able to comment on this resolution at all. So thank you. That's it. Thank you, David. We will bring it back to the board for discussion if

187there's any trustees who would like to start our board discussion on this item I just can we clarify with in light of some of the comments is their language in here that there are we clear that this isn't a replacement of the 2017 doc, but this is a amendment I think the solution here is putting it's the formatting is actually putting it together because what we have in here it says we're reaffirming the resolution for 2017 but we don't have the 2017 resolution attached to it so somehow I think formatting those two things together might help So and I'm not going to make a motion here but Hypothetically we wouldn't vote on this tonight then in order to get those two things put together to be able to vote on them in that way or

188no I don't I don't think you have to wait to do that. Okay, honestly that we our community can wait for that It's just if it's a formatting thing and we can make that really clear that we're combining both the 2025 and the 2017 resolution yeah so i just just to be clear then the safety of of our children and our community we will still uphold even if this was passed and it would be somehow um i guess amended or combined with the 2017 document is at post this meeting we're saying so that basically what we're doing is we're taking the 2017 resolution and this the language in this resolution and we're literally putting it together okay okay understood Trustee Ching? Yeah, I had a couple of suggestions, but I don't want to delay the

189approval of this resolution. I mean, one was, can we provide it in Spanish? Because I had a lot of questions from Spanish speakers about that, why we hadn't translated it. Number two, it also seems like somewhere in here, I would feel comfortable. having a clause that affirms or at least recognizes that we will honor the policies or the letter that was actually sent out by the Attorney General in December. Because that encompasses a lot that you're not going to put in as detailed resolutions. So anyway, those are the two things. While I realize that this is an affirmation of the board, I'm much more concerned about what are the tangible things that we're going to do on the ground in terms of making sure that... how we run these trainings and whether they're going to

190be, I know that administrators are trained, but how are we going to reach out? Are we going to do a train the trainers? Can we partner with our community agencies that can actually do maybe? all the community should be able to have access to doing, you know, like Zoom trainings to understand what people's rights are. So anyway, I know it's a lot to ask of our community partners. No, so can I answer that really quickly? We are already doing that. We are talking to each other about how we can possibly partner to do some of these trainings. There are, again, if we think about this in general there's some sensitivities that we have to consider so in some cases our partners will have to do certain things and when we're talking about our staff the

191district will have to do something so we are already communicating about how we're going to do that okay that was it trustee wonders yeah so i think that my request is to sort of bring some clarity to this being an addendum to the 2017 and making it really understandable for the community would be that we develop a page on our website where we have the 2017 resolution and then we have this addendum to it with the explanation that this is an in addition to and then within that an FAQ pay section that outlines in really understandable language, not sort of edu-speak and board-speak, but language that common. folks who don't have to speak this stuff would be able to easily understand the main points of it. This is what this means. This is how you'll

192be safe. This is how you'll be protected. This is our commitment. And then within that, I think what's really important is to emphasize families. to help them understand their rights under FERPA. So FERPA is the federal law that protects your students right to privacy. Nobody has a right to access your child's confidential educational records, including their emergency contact form, unless they have a court order. So the only person who can access it is the staff. If They need it. They need to have a reason. Like random people can't just come in and pull the file out. Or you as the guardian or the parent. The only other way anybody would be able to do this, they'd have to provide for our district a court order signed by a judge. And that's a pretty hard thing

193to get. You're not just going to go walk in and get one. But I think it's important because I think a lot of families don't know about FERPA. They don't know about their rights under FERPA. And that having that explanation on the FAQ page would be a really good way to get them to do it. important place to have that because that's a protection that already exists right now because it's federal law. But I just think a lot of families, they just don't know about it. So that would be sort of my trustee request to help mitigate people's ability to understand that this is an addendum to the 2017 and that they're able to have something. And then the last piece I would add to that, if we could also have a video. where we

194have somebody explaining in English and in Spanish all of those things because I think it's really important for us part of language justice is also to not assume literacy and to make sure that there's something that's accessible for everybody so if we could create a video explaining all the things that are on that page for people. Okay Trustee Bell. So my problem with this is that We're saying it's a reaffirmation, so it's stuff we generally already know. We know, according to Chief Cutting, that there's a 2010 letter from regulation from ICE that says that ICE is not allowed to enter a school campus, a church, or whatever it is. We're not even referencing that ICE letter from 2010 here in this document, which is probably the most important thing that says current ICE regulation prohibits

195ICE from entering a school campus, right? And that may change. It may not. Who knows? It didn't change throughout the whole Trump administration previously. So this document is kind of performative if it's not referencing ICE's own policy that says that they cannot go into a school campus, right? And secondly, I don't know why we're taking a political position on this document by saying not assisting. And we should be agnostic politically. There's people in our district that believe illegal immigration is bad. There's people that believe it's a good thing. And so by saying not assisting... Sorry, by saying we're not assisting is essentially endorsing that we believe that illegal immigration is something that we agree with and we disagree with federal law, right? And so if we just remove the political aspect of not assisting... We

196should as a district be following the letter of all laws, state, federal, everything. And if we disagree with that law, there's a process to go change that. And we're not legislators. So I'm great with some resolution. I'm just not great with a document that doesn't include the current ICE regulation because that's what governs what ICE does today. And correct me if I'm wrong, Chief Cutting. then I think we should take out the not assisting aspect. We just follow the law as a school district because we shouldn't be picking and choosing which laws we think are good and we're going to assist and ones we don't like and we're not going to assist. That's political and that's not what we're here to do. So that's my take on it. Okay, thank you. Did you want to

197say something, comment to that? So I don't know if Chief Cunningham wants to answer that, but what I'm going to say is in 2010, there was probably a reason why in 2017 that letter wasn't included, and it's probably going to change. We also know Homeland Security Director is going to be changing in January, so he may come up with, there might be another letter. What we're anticipating doing is following the letter of the law. from the state of California, which is this attorney general's guidance. So I don't know. And I again, it's the will of the board because this is the board a board resolution. But my recommendation is that we align the resolution with this guidance, just like every other district pretty much is doing in the state of California, including CSPA. Okay, thank

198you. Does anyone else have any commentary? I do. Okay. So We're elected officials, and by definition, that makes us political because we get elected. By saying you're going to be agnostic on something politically and not taking a position is literally taking a position. So I'm going to go ahead and take a position. And my position is that human beings aren't legal or illegal. They're human beings. And they are members of our community. And their children are children in our school district. And they have a right to be protected. And it is our responsibility to protect them. And there is nothing more terrifying. as a parent than the thought of being separated from your child. And there's nothing more heart wrenching as a parent to have to come to somebody else and say, if I suddenly

199disappear and cannot show up for my child, will you take care of my child? Because I've had that conversation and I am that person to some people. And so That's a big ask for somebody. So I'm going to tell you, I'm sitting here up as a trustee and I'm very political and I absolutely will protect with my absolute life our children's right to attend school safely and without fear. And to know that their parents will be there for them when they get out of school. And their parents' right to be able to show up and get their children safely and feel safe on our campuses. That is my responsibility as a trustee. That is my responsibility as a community member. That is my responsibility as a neighbor. And that is my responsibility as a human

200being. So I'm not agnostic on it at all. And I think that this is about protecting our families because I saw the dip in attendance out of fear because people were afraid to bring their children to school because they were afraid to leave their house. They were afraid to go cash their checks. They were afraid to go to the store. So maybe it's hard when you've never had to live with that kind of fear to imagine what that fear feels like. But I would hope that out of a place of empathy, in your own quiet moment of silence, you could reflect on what that might feel like to not be able to get to your children. And I will protect our family's right to exist and to come to our schools and feel safe and

201welcome with my absolute life. So, yeah, this needs to happen because this is about families feeling safe. And I'll stay. political forever on that one. Any other commentary? I have something to say. No other trustees have anything to say. Okay. So obviously this is an important resolution to our community. And I, I just want to acknowledge that. I also had a hard time with the words not assisting because while I can further read that it says except in instances when the district is provided with the warrant. So let me explain the reason why I struggle with the language that's used here. I don't want to give a false narrative of safety, and that is important for transparency for our community. So I do believe that this language, if we, you know, could be changed to

202be completely clear that, you know, It says not assisting with all of these things. And then at the end, it says unless. And so we just have to be transparent with our families. And so if we're going to make changes and referencing that ICE documentation, I see where that could be put here. So it's clear to our families. We're going to do all we can with training to protect the kids and to help make them feel like it's safe. But we ultimately do not get to say to federal agents who show up to school with the warrant that they cannot be on the premise. And so I just don't want to give this false sense of hope that this school district or our teachers or our staff and administrators can do anything when that happens.

203And so I do struggle with this language a bit. I'm hopeful that if this is not... You know, if we're going to make some additions and changes, then that's information that's extremely important because it gives our community, you know, if there's a click link that we can take them to, we don't need to include the document necessarily in our language, but have it there so it's clear that they understand and make it clear that we're not saying that we're not assisting because I also don't want our educators and our admin to feel like we're suggesting that they don't. comply with federal law. Like that's definitely not the message that we're trying to send here while we're still upholding the safety to the best of our ability for our Children. And then I'm just gonna say

204one other thing that I'm kind of tired of in this district. And I'll be honest with you. I hear from our Children and they're tired of it to our kids or students. The students in this valley are students language beyond since this is a document in regards to immigration status. On page 192 is what I'm looking at. The second bullet point says, welcoming all students, staff, and their families, regardless of characteristics, including legal immigration status. Why? And then it goes on to say, gender identity, sexual orientation, race, ethnicity, religious affiliation, or other protected classes. Are we really at a point where we have to include all of that? I really feel like I Point of order I'd like to finish, please. I really feel like as a district, we also need to acknowledge there's other

205children out there. who maybe are not of legal immigration status, who are just kids, who don't have all these other things. And we need to acknowledge that all of our students are students. And we as a district have a standard that we don't have to list all of these things. We need to treat people equally and be kind to everyone. And I just would encourage us. And you can disagree, and that's fine. I respect that. But I also feel like I need to be a voice for the kids and the families who are speaking up about this. You don't have to show up as something other than yourself. You are welcome. You are a human, like Trustee Winder said. We're all humans. These kids deserve our utmost protection to the best of our ability under

206what we are capable of doing under the law. And so it's not something that I'm asking to change in this document immediately. I'm just saying I think we need to set a standard that we're welcoming all students. and families regardless period we don't have to call everything out because if that's the case there's a lot of things missing in here and there's a lot of you know identities and other things that we haven't acknowledged and so in that case we're not recognizing everyone and so CHRISTIE WOODARD, M.D.: That's my comments on that. I'm not sure what to do at this point because I'm hearing from our community that there's things that they want us to add. I'm hearing that we can't put this off any longer. I'm not really sure what the will of the

207board here is to do because I do feel like this document could use some work. We have a study session on the 23rd. Should we ask to, you know, are we interested in maybe moving it to that agenda so that we have some time to look at this and make adjustments? I'm just, I will be willing to entertain the will of the board. I'd like to suggest that we move it forward and to Superintendent Chin's point earlier, this is something that's probably going to come back to us probably. regularly because the situation is fluid and changing there is pending state legislation there's things that are going to change what we probably will need to continue with amendments because of it being a fluid situation but to get something in place now and then regarding sort

208of the question that you had on some of the language, I believe some of that explanation of that language is in the 2017 document. Sort of hence kind of some of the confusion. The 2017 document, I believe, I don't have it in front of me, but I believe it does talk about that not providing assistance to, unless there is a court order. those that's where that language is and it's in alignment um i don't want to speak for chief cutting but i have read some of the sonoma county sheriff's statements they've been they're saying effectively the same thing that unless there's a court order they will not be providing assistance and that's our law enforcement agency that's saying that so it seems appropriate that a school district would say the same thing if if local

209law enforcement is That's their position is why I see chief cutting nodding, but I don't want to talk for you And I know that the audience online can't see you so maybe if you wouldn't mind I just because I don't want to put words in your mouth Yes, you're correct the the law is pretty clear that that language is in several several aspects of the law to the California codes and in reference to the letter that Trustee Bell was talking about in 2011 immigration officials authored a policy which states and identifies sensitive locations. In 2021, Secretary Mayorkas reaffirmed that letter and included some additional locations. I think Vicky's probably more... adept in talking about that document and the potential future of it but there's a lot of as far as using that as a reference

210in this and this I would just caution that that document on the 20th could completely go away it could it could remain intact I've read and heard conversations from the federal side both directions on that document and I think it's anybody's guess today what's gonna happen that would be my only caution on that but I would I would reference anything like that to to an attorney okay thank you chief cutting for that clarification trustee Bell I mean I think this document is incomplete it's also sort of referencing things that I'm not prepared to agree to and so I think we need to table it we need to look into it let's you know Monday something's going to happen Tuesday something's going to happen let's let's spend time on this when it's a properly prepared document

211and not rushed this is performative at this point in my mind so that's my position on it so I I feel that there's an urgency tonight that we need to approve this it's not perfect We need to reassure our students who are in fear. I understand the performative side because I'm hearing from teachers that they would like this communicated in a different way. It doesn't have to be through a resolution. But I think I don't really want to spend more time on it now. And I'm willing to, I'm actually going to make a motion. I'm going to move that we approve Resolution 2512. with the modification with an additional preamble that states that this is in addition to the statements that we made in 2017. Is that complete enough or do I need to say

212it again? Yeah, and I would second that. Okay, we have a second on the table. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. No. Oh, sorry. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. All not in favor? Oh, sorry, sorry. That's okay. I'm not in favor. Okay, thank you. So the next item, okay, so just point of clarification for the board. Are we moving on to the next item that was pulled? That would be the CPI contract. Yeah, so I had it written down as 15.12A. Absolutely. Yeah, so it will be at the end. So we'll be moving on with our regular agenda, and we're going to take a five-minute break. Sitting here so patiently and we truly appreciate your patience. Thank you. Absolutely. Is everyone else on the board okay with that? Yes. We'll move 15.3 up to right

213now. What? 15.3. Yeah, we'll come right back to 15.2 after this just for clarification. So again, just for clarification for the board and for the community, this is a presentation. We will go to board questions after the presentation. Then we will allow for public comment. And then we will come back for board discussion. Good evening, members of the board, President Landry, Superintendent Chen, Dr. Chen. I'm Amber Williams. I'm the coordinator of Ed Services here. I also oversee the Curriculum Advisory Council, which is the process in which these courses come through. I just want to start off by saying these courses and realignment came from a lot from the teachers. And so we started that process as early as we could and tried to double dip into our meetings so that we could get these on

214the course catalog for the high school students. And so I'm going to hand it off to this amazing team to present to you and to be able to answer any questions that you have. Thank you for having us. I'm Molly Kiss. I'm our principal at Sonoma Valley High School. And with me tonight is Wendy Swanson, who's our incredible work-based learning and grants coordinator at the high school. And Wendy's been a big part of bringing these courses and our new health care pathway. So I really wanted to have her with me in case you guys have specific questions. She may have some info to add. So she's here with me tonight. So we have three new science courses that we want to speak with you about today. The first one is physical and earth science. The

215second one is applied chem and biotech. And the third one is our nutrition and medical terminology. And I'll explain a little bit about that when we get to it. But it's a CCAP course. I'll explain what that means. It is those second two courses that relate to the health care pathway. But you'll hear more about each of them in just a little bit. So the first course we're going to talk about is physical and earth science. So this course, we kind of wanted to go into what the reasons are for why we're proposing a new course. So really the idea is NGSS, those are our next generation science standards. This course is tied to the NGSS curriculum. It meets the Lab D requirements. So those are those A through G requirements. It meets the requirements

216of Lab D. It's an interdisciplinary science, which means that it can help students meet their biological or their physical science requirement, which is nice for students because they can kind of pick how they want to apply it. And I'll show a little bit later how that fits into like our course sequence. The reasons also we wanted to look at introducing this course is really to increase student success and interest in all science coursework and careers and to increase student preparedness for when they get to the other course offerings at our high school in science, both CP and AP and CTE offerings. The proposed curriculum and textbook information is also linked on that slide. So what were we trying to solve by bringing this course? We really wanted to bring a course that we feel will

217improve student success. We think it's really important when students get to high school and they enter their freshman year that we're setting them up with courses that they can be successful in. We want to make sure that their first science course is something that they feel a lot of success in so that they'll want to continue into those other science courses and possibly also consider more of our advanced offerings when they get later through high school. So currently with our Living Earth course, which is the freshman course that students take, 40% of our freshmen are not meeting A through G standards, meaning they're not earning a C or better after semester one. They're earning a D or F. We also believe that having this course in the freshman year, they will meet their physical science

218requirement. We think they'll have better success. The Living Earth course that students take now, it's very language heavy. And we just find that their students' ability when they're in that course, it's been a really challenging course for them. And so we really think that this earth science, it's really real life applicable, that students may find more success with it. It also does not have like a math requirement. So in terms of like if a student was to jump straight into something like chemistry, there's algebra involved in chemistry. So we really feel like this gives students a chance to take their algebra course or whatever math course they're in in ninth grade, get that base level math before they move on to our other science course. But we'll also talk about how students have options. This

219won't be the only option, but that's part of the reason for us offering it. I kind of already talked about the rigorous aspects to living Earth and the language acquisition, the background knowledge required, the science skills. So that's part of the reason that we believe this course will be a better fit. We also believe that this will lead to, I kind of talked about this already, but increased preparedness and success in our other science courses. So if we can have students experience something positive in the first science course they take in high school, we hope that it will lead to increased interest. I have the statistic there that currently only 90 juniors and seniors are taking science classes. And so our hope is if we can have students have a stronger foundation when they start,

220they'll want to continue on and take advantage of those more, the other offerings that we have in science. And then as well, physical earth, I kind of stated this also, but it's more relevant. It's observable for all students. It meets the standards and it's an improved LabD. So we really feel like it's serving multiple purposes for our students. And this next slide just goes over a course description, which goes over what the course itself covers, as well as the units of study. Again, it shows that all grade levels can take it. So while we're intending it to kind of be this introductory course, there's nothing stopping a student who starts with something else in their freshman year from taking it later on as well. It is a full year course. It is that Lab D

221requirement for A through G. And the textbook is listed there as well. So this is a slide I wanted to spend a little bit more time on just so that everyone can see kind of what the different options are for students and how we intend it to set. So you'll see up here, there's kind of this question of like if I'm an incoming student to the high school, as an eighth grader right now going into ninth grade, do I plan to take three or more science classes in high school? So, and this chart is not intended to be like you pick one and then you stay on it. Students can switch at any point should they change their mind. But if as a student I know I think I don't want to take three or

222more science classes in high school, I can start with that physical and earth science. I could take living earth and I could choose to be done with my science requirement and have met the basic requirement for graduation and have met the requirement of one year. of biological and one year of physical science because that earth science is interdisciplinary. If I'm uncertain, similarly, I can do physical and earth science, living earth, and then I can go on to more science courses. So nothing's stopping me when I do physical and earth science and living earth from continuing on to those other offerings at the school. If my primary interest is in ag, I can do ag biology my first year. I could also do physical and earth science my first year and go on to ag bio

223or ag soil chem in my second year. So there's kind of multiple options there. But if I go into high school knowing for sure I'm interested in ag, starting out with ag bio is still an option. For those interested in environmental science, they'd be starting out in physical and earth science, going on to living earth, and then they can look at the variety of offerings for year three and four. We have AP environmental science, environmental sustainability, AP biology, chemistry, AP chemistry, lots of options. For those interested in the healthcare pathway, and you guys will hear about that a little bit later, but I did just kind of want to point out where that fits in this sequence. Starting out with physical earth science would be the plan for this year, this coming school year. Later

224on, we're going to plan to offer a biology and community health course. So that could also be that first year option. The Applied Chemistry and Biotech is the other new course that I'm talking about tonight that relates to the healthcare pathway. So that would come in in that second year or in the third year as well as an option. So that's where that healthcare pathway sits. And then there's also the CCAP courses, which I'll talk to you about. On the far right, you'll see AP. It is an option for students if they feel like... they want a little bit more of challenge and want to start out with that Living Earth course in their freshman year, nothing is stopping them from doing that, and they could. But this isn't at all to say that in

225order to take AP, you have to take Living Earth as a freshman. No, this is just one option for how to get to AP. So you'll see in a lot of these other columns, there's still AP in that year three and four. Nothing says that you have to follow this. So we may have some freshmen who choose to take Living Earth in their freshman year, but we're kind of seeing that maybe the majority may select this physical and earth science course. And then from there they can go on to AP Bio, Chemistry, Physics and then access other AP courses as well if that's something they're interested in. But I think a key point on this slide is that really our AP classes were open enrollment. They're for all students. It's really just about do you

226have a passion for science? Is this something you're interested in? And if you're a student that knows you are and maybe you have a strong science base and you want to start out in that Living Earth course, that's still an option. But you can see where the Physical and Earth Science course sits. Okay, so going into our healthcare pathway. Applied chemistry and biotech is the first one of the courses in the pathway that we're planning to offer for next year. So this next slide just goes over kind of the background of the healthcare pathway and how we came to looking at this. So pathways are definitely a big part of being a comprehensive high school. It's something that we know can lead to post-secondary completion as well as employment. So it's a priority for us

227to think about how we can get students involved in the pathways at the high school. We really want to think about what are the areas that our students are interested in so that we can offer the pathways that they'll want to join and Wendy offers many career panels at the high school and our most popular one every year is nursing and healthcare so that's really we've seen from our students that that's an area that they really have wanted preparation in and so that's really part of what led to us applying for some grants in order to bring this healthcare pathway to our school You'll also see some information on there about how health care and social assistance is one of the largest industries in the county. And so there's multiple reasons for why we really

228want to bring this pathway to our school. But I think our students' interest in it is definitely primary because we want to make sure that if we bring this, we'll have students that will want to come to the course. We've also offered some... info sessions on the pathway as we've launched it. So we had like a table at the electives fair. We also had one of the professors that would be involved in the CCAP course come and share information with students. And all the sessions related to this have been jam packed. We have had tons of students in the CCC really interested. So it really excites me to think about bringing this to our school for the students. So going into the funding for how this healthcare pathway will be funded, there's two different grants

229that are related. So we have the K-12 Strong Workforce Grant, which we got together with Petaluma City Schools. You'll see there we obtained a three-year grant in 2023. The amount is listed there. But really in order to create healthcare pathways and provide opportunities for our students. And then the second grant is the Golden State Pathways grant. In 2024, we were awarded a four-year grant for $374,000 to further implement a healthcare pathway at the high school. So these two grants are what will be used to fund these classes. There's really no cost that will cover the cost of the instruction, the textbooks, the materials. All those pieces are covered by the grant. So going back to kind of what we talked about with the other course, the reasons for the pathway and what we're trying to

230solve. We really want to have, again, a clear path for students who are interested in the healthcare field and relevant courses for them. So we feel like this combined with the dual enrollment opportunities. students can have the potential to graduate with college credit when they finish high school. And that's huge because when students experience the success of like, I'm already going in with college credit, I've completed college level work, they feel that much more ready when they're going on to their next steps. Also, we talked about this, but the huge shortage of healthcare professionals and the job opportunities that exist there for them, right? So we want to prepare our students for employability after high school. We also think about our dashboard as well and thinking about how our students are prepared for college and

231career readiness and having participation in completing a pathway is a piece of that, a really important piece. And so this can be a great opportunity to help our students be more prepared and college career ready. And as I mentioned, we have many students who plan to go to the healthcare field after graduation. You'll see there every year 150 to 180 of our students have attended the career talks on the healthcare field. Okay, so just going into how we picked this course specifically for the healthcare pathway. So it is designed to be the second course in the healthcare pathway. I talked a little bit earlier about that bio and community health being the first. course but we felt like this was a good course to introduce for a few reasons it is a ucci course which

232basically means that there's already a through g approval for it there's existing curriculum unit plans textbook like kind of all the things that we can use to get the course kick started we also felt with introducing the physical and earth science course for next year rolling out two new courses at that ninth grade level could be a little bit messy so we felt like starting with this course um was a good way to kind of have students be able to get in, join the pathway, make sure there's interest, and then we can always add that bio and community health class the following year. It also offers an alternative to regular chem and ag soil chem. So like for our students who know I'm interested in healthcare, it's giving them another option, which we think is

233really great. And it also includes a lot of hands-on learning, which we feel like we know our students enjoy that. We feel like that is, it makes sense to add to our high school. So this just kind of goes over the overall focus of the course, the unit plan. I'm not going to read through it, but that is there for your reference to just kind of get a sense of exactly what the units are that are covered in the course. And then again, the next slide just goes over the textbook, which it uses our general high school chemistry text. So we already have that. It's not something new that we have to get in a biotech lab manual. But again, textbooks also covered through the grant. So just drawing your attention back to that course

234planner that I showed at the beginning, the yellow highlight, that's where that healthcare pathway sits. So we kind of already kind of have a plan of the overall vision for science at the high school and where this fits in. Okay, so to talk about CCAP a little bit, which is our nutrition and medical terminology courses that we want to offer next year. So one requirement of the Golden State Pathways grant that I talked about at the beginning that relates to the healthcare pathway is that students do have to have the opportunity to earn at least 12 hours of post-secondary credit, so that like college credit, through dual enrollment CCAP. So CCAP stands for College and Career Access Pathways, courses or IP courses. What that means is basically that we need to have a JC instructor.

235come to the high school to teach the dual enrollment on our campus. So it's making those dual enrollment courses really accessible for our students. And I think that's huge because one of the areas where we've struggled in at the high school is that for a lot of our students, it's hard to get to the JC. And so many of them may not go to the JC to take a dual enrollment course if they don't have a way to get there. So bringing it on to the campus really makes it accessible. It can be part of their schedule, which is really cool. And I think it also just kind of helps increase that college awareness by bringing it on to our campus as well. And the other piece is that it has to be offered within

236your bell schedule. So that's why I'm saying it's going to be part of their regular schedule. They'll just go over and get to take that class on the high school campus. So our plan is to be able to offer nutrition in the fall and then medical terminology in the spring. So they're both one semester courses, but it is required for the students to sign up for both. They go together. And that would be part of the healthcare pathway. And then later our plan in the following school year would be to roll out some of these other courses as part of the healthcare pathway. So an intro to medical careers, a psychology, and then an opportunity for an internship. And then there are some other courses that we could consider as well as dual enrollment options

237that the students can take at the JC that are relevant to the pathway. Like they can take anatomy. The reason anatomy is hard to offer at the high school is that there's a very specific lab type classroom that you have to have in order to be able to offer it. Because that was something students had interest in was could we offer anatomy at the high school. But there is opportunity for them to take it at the JC. So these are some of the other courses that they'd be able to also take advantage of in relation to. the pathway. So the outcomes that we're hoping for by offering this course is really that students will have more options for completing their A through G science requirement in an area that they're interested in, in a career

238field they're interested in. It is applied science. It's relevant to their interest. We feel that having that will also help us increase our A through G completion rate because if students feel like yeah, I need to complete A through G and now here's this course I'm really interested in. They'll be even more likely to do that. It also allows students to, like I said, earn that college credit while they're still in high school, which is a really good way to help. prepare them for those next steps. So when we presented this to CAC, we kind of went over the advantages and disadvantages of approval or non-approval. And so as you guys have heard, some of the advantages of approving is really that greater college career readiness, launching a healthcare pathway, and generating just courses that

239interest our students. For us, the disadvantages of not approving would just be less college readiness for students, less preparation for our students who are interested in going into healthcare because we don't have really courses right now that are catered to that. And then lastly, the grant funding that is tied to this pathway. So there is the potential that if we didn't launch these courses, we may have to return some of the funding for the grant because the grants are really tied to the idea of us developing this healthcare pathway. And I think I already stated this, but just to make sure it's really clear in terms of expense, because the CCAP teachers are teachers at the JC, the JC covers their salary. So there's no cost to the school for the teacher. So the only

240cost is the textbook and materials, which are covered by the grant. And I think that's it, if there are questions. While she walks over here, I just want to do a shout out to Molly and Wendy for all the work that they've put in along with the members of the CAC. But also I want to recognize President Angelica Garcia from Santa Rosa Junior College. She's been an advocate of this and has been really reaching out to districts to get our pathways going. Wonderful. Thank you so much for this amazing presentation. We'll turn it back to the board for questions. Trustee Ching? I also want to tell you how excited I am for this because I've been like advocating this for it seems like over a decade. So I'm so excited that this is happening for

241our students. This is fantastic news. I just have a couple of kind of factual things as it was hard to absorb all of it by looking at the slides and the presentation. So is the are we rolling out both Earth? the earth science class. The Living Earth already exists. Correct. But there was the other one. I guess I just want to be clear. What courses are we rolling out this fall versus the next year? So this fall, it's the three courses that are on the front of the packet. Those are the only new courses being rolled out. So the bio and community health that I mentioned that's related in the health care pathway, that would be for the following school year. OK, got it. And is the applied chem biotech? class is that also kind

242of a good foundational course before kids take AP chemistry or I mean, are they completely unrelated? No, it definitely could be. It's intended to be in the healthcare pathway, but we have open enrollment. Kids could come in. Yeah, and it's intended to cover the same types of foundational content that chemistry covers. So it wouldn't be any different than a student taking chemistry and then going on to AP Chem. Yeah, I mean, because we've never, at least when my children were there and at least up until very recently, kids were really intimidated about just going straight to AP Chem without having some foundational like knowledge. And it's a pretty stressful environment to just jump into AP Chem or AP Physics, for example. So and then I did have a question about just to clarify the CCAP

243credits, this limitation of 12, that's specifically for this pathway or just any dual enrollment? Generally, we limit 12 credits. To the kids? Yeah. So it's actually not a limit. It's required by the Golden State Pathways. To offer at least, right? You have to. It's the opposite of a limit. You have to offer at least. You have to give them an opportunity to earn 12 units. 12 credits. Yeah. And it's with every Golden State Pathways grant that's required. Got it. That's really exciting. And then just with the funding again. The grants that we're sharing one with Petaluma, right? The $1 million and then the other $300,000. That is just to cover, it's not... It's not basically a pass-through to Santa Rosa JC to pay for instruction. It's for... No, because those instructors are already employed with

244the JC. They're just basically saying, here, you're going to teach your adjunct class here with the students from the high school that are enrolling. Got it. And actually, Ann, there's actually even a third grant, which is the CCAP grant, which is a $100,000 grant to help establish... the CCAP classes. So it doesn't actually go to the teacher's salary, but it goes to all the preparation to get ready for those instructors to come and teach. And we don't have to worry when the grant expires at the end of three years we're not going to be able to afford teaching the class anymore? That's the part I'm confused about. Yeah, well, I mean, theoretically, we ought to have, I mean, it might even be possible that some of our existing teachers can teach the applied chem and

245biotechnology or the the other one that we're thinking about adding in next year. So it may not even really increase our teacher load, you know, based upon the, you know, enrollment numbers and things. So I don't, you know, it's not, the big expense in creating a healthcare pathway is the equipment. And, you know, facilitating. everything that needs to be taught in a classroom. Yeah, because what we're curious to see, and we'll have a better sense once we finish course selection in January, is like how many students sign up for Applied Chem and Biotech, right? Because presumably some of our students who maybe were taking chemistry may be going into Applied Chem and Biotech. So we kind of have to see what the impact is, right, across the board on the science classes. But because it

246is grant funded, it gives us this nice advantage of being able to kind of try it out and have something. additional while we kind of see what the impact is across the board on the other courses. All right. Well, kudos to you guys for making this happen. Thank you so much. Thank you. Are there more questions? Yeah. So I'm a little unclear on what happens when the grant ends. in three years. Do we then pick up the cost of the JC teachers? No. Do we pick up the cost of our teachers who are now teaching these new classes? Well, who are teaching the physical and earth science and the applied chem and biotechnology class. The nutrition and medical terminology class will always be taught by a JC instructor. So we've, okay, so I mean this

247is just something that we obviously, from a budgeting standpoint and looking at it in the future, we need to be aware of the fact that this is a one-time grant for three years and then it goes away, right? It's actually two grants. One grant is for three years and one grant is for four years. And to clarify about the physical and earth science, we're not anticipating needing to hire an additional teacher to teach it. What we're anticipating will happen is that our living earth sections will probably, because right now, right? all freshmen pretty much are taking Living Earth. So if we're saying most freshmen are going to take physical and earth science, we're going to be able to staff that with our existing staff. It's just trading out how many sections of physical earth science

248we have and how many sections of Living Earth. So that's not like a new teacher we're hiring. The applied chem and biotech will be someone new we're hiring just because of the... the credential that's required. So it's a CTE credential and they have to have, in order to have that CTE credential, they have to have had experience in those fields. So we have like a whole list from the county office of like relevant jobs that they can have held to qualify for that CTE credential. But again the cost of that position paid for over through the grant. Can I just add to that only in terms of the grant? So the golden pathway grant is something that is it's not a pathway that's given by an organization it's actually from the California Department of Ed

249and the governor has put in tons of money and has pledged that that money will continue for a pretty long time because his goal is to have dual enrollment in the high schools. I mean, there's some districts now that have early college high schools that that's all they do. So I don't see the likelihood of this money going away. Yeah, I mean, if I could just add to that, the original... The original offering of the GSPP, the Golden State Pathways Grant, was $500 million statewide. And there's a huge push in the state, you probably already know this, for pathways, for dual enrollment, for CTE. The K-12 Strong Workforce Grants happen every year. We've gotten, I don't even know how many now, probably like 40. 14, 13, something like that, K-12 Strong Workforce grants each across

250the last six years. So the money, there's constantly money for CTE pathways sort of coming out of the state. So I can't imagine that there's not going to be an end. And it really provides, it's provided all of our CTE programs with a lot of equipment. It'll help equip these classrooms. like Dr. Chin said, there's a lot of money that just is going to continue to flow because the state's putting so much emphasis on it. And in the Golden State Pathways Grant, the state identified five priority areas, and health care was one of those. Other questions from the board? I am so excited about this because I've heard so much from our students that they want this when we were doing different listening circles and then just different opportunities I've had to sit down with

251students. This is the thing that keeps coming up over and over and over for them. And I understand why. When I was in high school, we had JC classes at the high school, and I took them. I took them every single semester, and it was just, it was... probably it was such a boost to my confidence as a student to know like I completed a college course and I got an A. You know, it was just a boost to the confidence. But one of the big things that I appreciate about this is the accessibility piece. So is this is really making another access point for success in science that I think is really critical for our students who are different learners, who learn differently. and creating that platform for success for them is just another

252pathway to success and the accessibility to the college courses. Because when we had JC classes at the high school, like back in the day, in the olden days when I was there, look at Deanna, she's laughing at me because she took them too. We went to school together. It was the reason we were able to take them was because they were here. Like we didn't have transportation. We didn't necessarily have the ability to get to and from the JC at night and those kinds of things. And so it had created that accessibility point. And then when that ended, that accessibility point for a lot of students who have more barriers went away. And so I love that we're doing this because we're really. we're really addressing that area of college and career readiness that we

253were deficient in as a district. And we were deficient specifically with specific groups of students that we weren't creating that access point to. And so I really want to commend the work that's been done on this. I know this was a heavy lift. And this was a really big, big lift. But you're addressing something that has been brought to this board over and over and over again each year when the dashboard comes out that And it isn't anything that any of our staff have done wrong or school. It literally was an infrastructure thing that we didn't have the pathway created and you have created the pathway. And I just thank you very much and thank you for addressing a very specific request that our students have made to us as a district and you've addressed

254that for them. And I know we need more folks in healthcare too. So this is just a win for the entire community. I really applaud you. Thank you so much. Thank you. Any further questions from the board? No? Thank you all. I appreciate that. Just a quick update. President Landry had to step away. I'll be stepping in her place procedurally to run the meeting going forth. The next step in this would be public comment. Do we have any public comment on 15.3? Kimberly Smith, chapter president for Sorry, CSEA chapter president for chapter 376. I just want to thank all the hard work and especially Molly who stepped out. She is an amazing leader. And just to hear that student voices were heard and recognized. This is a great pathway for students, for student careers, and

255the betterment for the health care for our community, which is really important. And I hope that this opens the door for more pathways for additional careers for our students. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else in the room? Nope. If not, we'll go to online. Seeing no hands raised. We will bring it back for board discussion. Unless anybody else has discussion, I would make a motion to approve. I second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. I'm an aye too. And thank you so much for that presentation. I apologize. I had to step out. It was beautiful and I'm so excited about it. Thank you for all your work. I too am excited. I got a little nervous running my first vote there. I am excited for it as well. Thank you. I apologize. So we're going

256to go back to item number three. Go to 15.2. But item three on the regular agenda, which is the approval of the nominee. Oh, wait. Hold on a second. Yes. Yes. Okay. So item 15.2, consideration of possible action, naming of the Sonoma Valley High School Science Building. Dr. Chin, you are going to present this. So I was in September. I'm looking at the date when we established the 90 day. So there's board policy around naming buildings or fields or other areas of our campuses. And back in September, there was a petition request that, I'm sorry, that a request to open up the time period for a petition to be put together to name a school was established. I know that VMTA President Dennis Hausman made a request at that point and I think he actually

257said it in public during his report that he was interested in possibly renaming the new science building after our long beloved educator, science teacher. night and so I know Dennis did a lot of work to try to gather all of the signatures for that petition and actually submitted that and so now we're at the point where we have a petition with signatures and the policy now is for you to consider the name and to take action on that tonight okay thank you so I will open it up to board questions at this time does anyone have any questions No. Trustee Bell, do you have any questions? No? OK. We'll open it up to public comment. Is there any public comment in the room on this item? Dennis Housenco. VMTA president, sorry it's a long day,

258night, week. Hopefully I don't have to convince you too hard. Again, this person taught in our district for over 50 years. I once had a goal of I wanted to teach the most students in this valley ever. And I figured because my class sizes are a little bit bigger than his are, I might be able to accomplish that. I'm not sure I can do that. So that's still a ways away. So again, I want to again recommend we name the Mr. Knight science or whatever his request was. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Hausman. Is there any other public comment in the room? Seeing none, we'll go online. Is there any public comment online for this item? And seeing none, we'll bring it back to the board for discussion or a motion to approve. I would

259just like to suggest to the board that we go with Dean Knight Hall. I believe that that is a preference for Mr. Knight. It also just sounds very regal. And I just, I cannot imagine naming this building after anyone else. He's a legend. He's an icon. He's a treasure. He's not only taught the most, he has also taught generations of students and families. So I support this. And I would just like to suggest as a board, we go with Dean Knight Hall. Okay. Thank you, Trustee Wenders. Any other? Is that a motion? No. No. Oh. OK. I will make a motion, but I just wanted to make sure that we're following the procedures. I assume, and I didn't see anything, that Dean agrees to this. OK. Because that's part of it. He likes the hall.

260Yeah. It is real. All right. Mr. Houseman, I think, did some talking into. Thank you, Mr. Houseman. So I'd like to make a motion that we move forward and honor Mr. Knight by naming the science building as the Dean Knight Hall. Is there a second? I second that motion. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Awesome. Thank you, guys. Thank you for your work on this. So we're moving on to item 15.4, approval of issuance of publication of school accountability report cards, also known as SARC, for the 2023-2024 school year. And Ms. Casillas, our associate superintendent, will be presenting this. Good evening President Landry, Superintendent Dr. Chen, Board of Trustees and Sonoma community, all public schools in California are required per state and federal law to prepare a SARC, a school accountability report card and

261disseminate it to the public. There are requirements in terms of the content of the plan. All schools have submitted their SARCs, all principals have reviewed it and it's ready to be prepared and shared and we request your approval this evening. CHRISTIE WOOD. Wonderful. Thank you. Any questions from the board? Seeing none, we'll go to public comment. Is there any public comment in the room on this item? Seeing none, we'll go online. Is there any public comment online for this item? And seeing none, we'll bring it back to the board for discussion and or a motion to approve. I propose a motion to approve. CHRISTIE WOOD. Is there a second? Second that. CHRISTIE WOOD. All right. All in favor? Aye. CHRISTIE WOOD. Aye. CHRISTIE WOOD. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Casillas. All right, 15.5, action approval

262of middle school consolidation transition plan. The board is asked to consider approval of the middle school consolidation plan as presented. I'm going to introduce Amber. She's going to be actually stepping in for Jillian, who wanted to present this to you tonight, but it was her son's birthday, so we let her celebrate her son's birthday. If you recall, this is... Part of the resolution that you all passed when we talked about school consolidation and we had talked about how quickly we could get you something. Again, this is a high-level transition plan that focuses on our social-emotional supports for our students and also focuses on how we're going to bring staff, students, and families together. It does not... contain information about operations and logistics however, we do have a task list for operations and logistics that I've

263shared with both the board and like I mentioned earlier with with our teachers So I'm gonna hand it over to amber to present the high-level transition plan. Good evening members of the board again I'm Amber Williams. I'm the coordinator of ed services. I'm gonna say happy birthday to Nolan Beale Happy birthday, bud All right, so in response to the board's resolution, we've crafted a preliminary transition plan for students, families, and staff. We'll be gathering more voice from our community as we implement this plan to make sure it addresses everyone's needs, concerns, and hopes for our students' future. Our first listening circles start in the next two weeks with students, and the feedback from these learning opportunities will impact further decisions. Staff will also have chances to collaborate with one another, for example, the January 22nd

264collab time and the February 14th PD day. This will be the beginning of our work together and the staff and student input will be crucial in planning future activities and events I'm excited for this opportunity for our students in Valley and today I was able to participate in the social justice and equity conference at SCO and a quote that Resonated with me after that today is that community is medicine Thank you. Thank you very much. Miss Williams. All right, so I will bring this back to the board for questions Trustee Bell? I don't really have any questions. I've just got a comment. I think that I went to a PTO meeting at Presswood recently, and I think one of the biggest concerns for the parents was transportation. So I think from the perspective of this

265is great, the transition plan, all of this sort of stuff, but I think we sort of, I think a lot of parents, their first thought is, how is my kid going to get to the new school, right? And I get that and I'm just saying, trying to communicate that to, I don't know how we sort of can get that out and cover that to the public and so they sort of understand that and then, you know, there's parents that are fearful that the bus is not going to take them to their new school, right? So let me answer. I think I mentioned that when I opened up, and I know I'm speaking really quickly because I'm looking at the time, but we do have a logistics plan, and the transportation and busing is part of

266that. We are already looking at how many... Routes are are going to be needed And like I mentioned earlier during my report we're also going to be Notifying our parents via the newsletters as we're accomplishing some of these logistical tasks so that people know what we're doing I think the other part that needs to be told to the public is that some things are needed to happen first before other things, right? So we have to know how many students are going where. We have to know where they're coming from. So, like, I'll give you an example. Right now we've sent out a survey to find out how many students are going to come back and then how many of them are going to need transportation. So we're going to use that data to then work

267on routes. So that's part of the process. All right, any other questions from trustees? Trustee Ching? Do we have an idea about the timing of when we could get more sort of information about sort of the academic side of the transition? Like when do we expect a rough first draft of a master schedule? What courses are going to be kind of offered? Because the campuses seem to have quite not very different but you know they have distinct courses that they're offering I know that parents are concerned about this I know faculty want to know like how how is the how are we going to be organized so anyway I'm just curious timing wise when when can the board sort of expect us kind of see that rolling out In terms of the scheduling process, our

268counselors are wrapping up the course selection process for electives. The beauty of the consolidation opportunity is offering robust electives for both schools and both counselors. Chal and Christine were able to work together and collaborate so that they would have a similar presentation and one comprehensive. menu of options for electives so we're reviewing that now they just finished and we will be analyzing all of the sections and the needs in terms of what a potential schedule could look like i know that there are some staffing implications too depending on credentials and other staffing decisions on who's teaching what classes we believe that we could probably have a draft to probably beginning of march right now we have a we could provide you with numbers in terms of how many students are potentially enrolled in the different

269classes, the different courses. So, yeah, I would be very interested in just seeing, like, what are the courses being offered. I don't think I need to see what enrollment is. And what was the other question I had that was related? Yeah, so are we... Are we combining the courses that we're currently are we losing any courses I guess in this kind of merger situation or we redesigned the courses that we're offering? We are still taking a look at the courses right now nothing is set in stone we're going through the course request process to determine numbers and that will determine the need for the classes. And then I also with respect to the dual immersion program So my knowledge is based on my kids going through it in middle school. I'm just curious, are we

270doing the same sort of sequence where social studies is going to be? I mean, has that been thought through, and is there kind of a rough plan of are we just going to mimic what is being currently done at Adele Harrison? So we are committed to continuing with the dual immersion program at the new middle school. Right now, the way this... Spanish language arts and the dual immersion history class is being taught. It's a combined class 6th 7th and 8th We are proposing for next year that we have grade level specific courses So the sixth graders are learning together the seventh graders are learning together and the eighth graders are learning together So it'll be a little different from what we're offering this year in a combined mixed level course to separating out the courses

271by grade level but still maintaining Spanish language arts and the dual immersion history class. And just a quick follow-up to that. So the original rationale for doing the multi-age course for social science was I believe that there were like three different modules that were kind of rotated through so to make sure that the kids got all of those particular subject areas in social science. So sometimes if you started in You know, you needed to go through that whole rotation. And at sixth grade, sometimes it was offering the second module. And I may be misspeaking. And then, you know, sometimes in sixth grade, you might be getting the third module. So the idea is that that whole organization of the course will be changed. Sixth graders will be learning sixth grade history in Spanish, just like

272sixth graders are learning history in English, and the same for seventh and eighth grade. Okay. All right. And we could provide you with the course offerings once we have that, Trustee Ching. OK. Thank you. Any other trustee questions? No. You want your questions answered? I have one procedural question about just generally, does the board really operationally need to actually vote on this transition plan? Because I feel like this is a staff. I trust what the staff is doing. I feel like this isn't really a policy decision. So I was just very confused, you know, if the board really does need to ratify this. Because it's a dynamic process. Anyway, I'm just curious because it's kind of confusing to me. Well, but if it gets changed, do we then have to re-vote on it? I mean,

273that's the problem. we kind of just let staff decide because if it if it then changes material they have to come back to us for approval right and we wouldn't really want that in my mind so i i'm i'm not an attorney but i'm gonna go back to what was written in the resolution the resolution that you all approved and passed said that you were going to look at this transition plan and vote on it today so that's what's written in the resolution that you already approved And if I recall, that was our commitment to the community in our last meeting. So if what I'm hearing is we support staff and we don't need to further in, you know, as these transition plans come before us, are you saying that? having them be as a

274read, just information only, and not having to vote on them just for the sake of the fact that there will be additions and subtractions and all sorts of other things. I think at this point we're voting on it because that was a commitment we made to the community. And like Dr. Chin mentioned, it was in the resolution. But if the suggestion is that we state that we support staff while we'd like to be you know privy to the information in this transition and course selection and all of that you know we can make a statement as a board saying we trust you we don't feel that it's something we need to prove for the sake of not having it return for approval when things get changed that was very wordy but i hope that made

275sense i think i can offer some clarity to that so in the resolution what we specifically said we were going to do was that we were going to approve a high level transition plan that was basically like the outline, which is what this is, that we weren't going to sort of approve and nitpick every detail, but that we were going to receive a high-level transition plan. We would approve that as a board as our way of taking ownership over the decision that we made and moving forward in the process. But I think because we had specified it was a high-level one, that that left it open, that if as things... change and as more information comes through and we need to make adjustments that the staff can make those adjustments they don't need us to

276approve those adjustments that this because when I read this what I look at I'm not looking at something that's very very super detailed I'm looking at what we asked for which is a high level transition plan to give us an idea and give the public an idea of like this is these are the areas that we're going to be working on and this is the timeline the rough timeline they'll be work that the staff will be working on them but that there'll be more details that get filled in under each section. That was the way I understood our resolution and our intent behind it. When I went home that night, I felt like, oh, should we have included that in the resolution? I just felt a little like, you know, I feel like I'm overreaching.

277what I'm supposed to be doing. So anyway, I just wanted to express that I was thinking about that. And if we do want to approve this at a high level, I would just say that, you know, I guess I don't see the focus area of academics. Like academics should be one of the priority areas, right? Which is the, what are we offering? It's like student voice, community building. families, and then staff. So anyway, I, but I don't want to, I don't really want to, I don't want to nitpick the plan. I think I've decided like, hey, this is where operations comes in. And, you know, we need to sort of stay in our policy lane. So I just wanted to throw that out there. Just to quickly respond, I believe also in the resolution, the

278plan that you requested was for how are we going to bring the communities together and address social-emotional supports, and that's what you have here. So that's why you don't see the academics. I think the other piece of this is to your point that typically many of the academic, instructional, and programmatic decisions don't lie in. the governance team, it lies within my purview and my team's purview. Part of the reason why you see again the high level is because we want to include the input of our teachers and our students. So that's why you still don't see all the details because what the teachers and what the students feel is important to them may not jive with what the governance team Knows about what they need or want right? So that's why I think it's important

279that you recognize that it is high level and we are going to get input from those people that are being impacted. Thank you for that clarification trustee both um, so when we talked about this I was thinking it was more of a timeline of critical dates when we would deliver the academic plan the transportation plan the capital improvement plan, all of those things that was more of a timeline of the events. I mean, I get this and this is great, the transition plan, but that would be step one. This is the date for the transition plan. And then transportation plan would be on another date. Because I think what people in the community really want to know is, when am I going to find out the academic plan? When am I going to find out

280the transportation plan? When am I going to find out when the seismic work starts? And so I'm wondering, I mean, we must have a timeline of a lot of these sort of critical points of decision-making or being able to present that. And so if there's that timeline, I think that would be very helpful for everybody. Well, the timeline is between now and the fall. Everything needs to get accomplished, right? So the fact that we have an operational and logistical list that has all of those things, like I said, that I've shared with all of you already and that I've shared with the teachers. they we all have an idea of what's in there the timeline again it could vary right because it depends on what like I just mentioned some things come before others but

281in terms of like what needs to be completed it all needs to be completed before we start school in the fall I've sent it to you guys a couple times now Okay, thank you with that. I think we'll go to public comment, right So if there is public comment in the room come to the podium, please Dennis house and co-president VMTA again some there's not a lot of staffing in here I just want to advocate for again right now they're scheduled to be a principal and a vice principal I just want to advocate for some other administrating position whether it be a dean of students or another vice principal somebody to help out in their first couple of years of the transition thank you mr. Hausman is there any other comment in the room public

282comment in the room nope seeing none we'll go online looks like we have one person online miss Tiffany Briggs you have the mic hi thank you guys this is Tiffany Briggs I I'm speaking on behalf of parents in this and just wanted to go publicly and invite you know all current fifth grade students and parents who are our next PTO meeting which is January 23rd at 530 at the Altamira library we have already reached out to Adele's PTO group so I just wanted to put it out there that we are meeting next week and we look forward to collaborating thank you thank you Ms. Briggs so just to just so the community heard that it was next Thursday the 23rd at the Altamira library at I know it was if you're still online, can you

283come back? We're going to elevate. You're still there. Can you just repeat the date and time? I just want to make sure the community hears that it's a little bit hard to hear. OK, sorry, it's Thursday. January 23rd at 530 at the Altamira Library and also to just a quick shout out that that's we're all celebrating our 100th day of school that day, so that's kind of cool. Awesome. Thank you very much. And I appreciate you repeating that. We were all wrong on the time. So thank you for that clarification. You guys, it's after 10.30. Okay. Ms. Shoshana. Oh, where'd you go? There you are. Ms. Signer, you have the mic. Hi. Shoshana Signer. Parent of an Adele student. Yes, I think that the transition plan that we saw today wasn't exact or on in

284the notes wasn't exactly what we expected. It seems very thorough and for one route. And I think Trustee Bell kind of sort of said exactly what I was thinking as well, which is that it would be very helpful to have something that feels a little more concrete. I think we are expecting that. It sounds like maybe there is a framework out there. I don't think the parents have had a chance to see that yet. So I would suggest that as soon as possible, those more concrete items should be given to the parents. And we've already heard, you know, been hearing some things about which classes will be offered and may not be offered. And I'm not talking about electives. I'm talking about other courses. And so it's getting a little, I think that should be

285cleared up pretty soon as well, because there's a lot of conversations out there that can very quickly get people feeling riled up and emotional. So I think that the more information we get, the sooner, absolutely the better. So thank you. CHRISTIE WOOD. Thank you, Ms. Signer. Is there any other public comment on line before we bring it back to the board for discussion? All right, seeing none, is there any further discussion amongst my fellow trustees? All right, seeing none, do we have a motion on the table? I motion to approve the middle school consolidation transition plan. CHRISTIE WOOD. Is there a second? Second. CHRISTIE WOOD. Thank you. All in favor? Aye. Action item 15.6, a motion to designate the Altamira Middle School for renaming. The board is asked to consider a motion to designate Altamira

286Middle School for renaming and open the 90-day nomination period for renaming pursuant to AR 7310. Would you like to speak on this? So you see this on the agenda. We had a board request from one of our trustees to open up the the time frame for renaming Altamira so I'm going to hand it over to Trustee Ching if you want to explain well I just thought that this would be good timing since we are going to be merging two schools and I had actually wanted to do this in 2020 when I first got on the board but then we were in the middle of a pandemic and it seemed like a lower lower priority so I just wanted to give Open it up for the opportunity if the community wants to take this, especially the

287kids and the parents and the staff, if they want to use this as an opportunity to start afresh and have ownership of the name of their school. I did have a technical question, which is, you know, we closed the nomination in 90 days. Let's say that there isn't clarity on it. and the kids and parents need more time, would we consider that, like, extending the nomination period? I mean, I don't know if that means that we have to change our policy or review our policy, but I'm just going to throw that out there. But anyway, I did request this, and I wanted to facilitate the process if the school administrators and families and students want to start engaging in this process. All right, thank you for the background. I appreciate that. Is there any questions

288of the board? My understanding, because I remember when we developed, when that policy was developed, the 90-day period, but my remembrance of it when we were having a discussion, there's nothing that would prohibit us as a board from making a motion in an agendized board, meaning to extend the 90 days. There was nothing in our policy that would prohibit that, which... I would interpret, and I'm not a lawyer, we don't have a lawyer here right now, but if there's anything to prohibit it, then it's allowed, effectively. So I think that we could do that, and that would be under our purview as a board to do that. Okay, thank you. I have the same recollection, actually, but we'll trust the bell. Can I show my ignorance? Why is it called Altamira Middle School? It was

289named after Father Jose Altamira who founded the mission in Sonoma. And so that's why it is named that. Trustee Lehman? Well, and so. I don't have a question, but I would like to second Trustee Chang that this is a good time for us to do this with the mergering in the middle schools. For many, many years in Sonoma Valley, there have been a lot of conversation, a lot of requests from community to rename the school for a lot of reasons, mostly the history that's attached to Father Jose Altamira. and it's it's a very dark history um and there's been a lot of community members who've always been very very concerned about the fact that that's the name of our middle school and so with the merging of our two middle schools together i also heard

290from students um i think this is important to share when we were going through the consolidation process we heard from a lot of students and one of the things i appreciated with our students is they were coming to us with things they'd like like suggestions they're like please don't close my school but if you do here's some ideas i have and they had great ideas and one of their ideas was this like could we rename the school could we pick a new mascot where we get to pick it together um they also wanted to have a field day together and they want to have some field trips together and they had really really great ideas about bringing their school community together so i agree with you trustee shang i think that if ever there was

291a time to do it this would be the time and opening that 90-day period feels very very appropriate to me I have a question, and it came from a few constituents, and I didn't have an answer, and I apologize because I didn't ask this prior to the meeting. But is there a significant cost associated just for transparency, and I want to make sure I get that question answered. So I'm sure the answer is yes, and I'm assuming we don't have exact numbers, but do we have an estimate of the cost and or what that would entail? And I don't mean to put you on the spot. It's okay to report back. I appreciate you. Just standing in the hallway. Entertaining the idea. One of the biggest costs is going to be redoing the gym floor.

292That's probably going to be about $300,000 because it has a big... What is the wolf the big wolf in the middle of the floor and it says Altamira and then also the stands say Altamira the sign in the front that says Altamira that's not going to cost too much, but there is a lot of signage over there that's going to be significant, but the biggest cost is going to be that gym floor. A follow-up question to that is our bond money that we're planning to use for some of the renovations. Can that cover? Could could these costs fall under? If there's many left available The one question I have is when was the last time that floor was refinished three years ago Three years ago three years ago. So I mean, you know, look if

293we do it Let's just wait till the next refinish and then it it's not three and a grand is it? We have to sand it down because that's the only way to get that off. You're going to have to sand it down and then refurnish it. Can we make that decision later? Yeah, I mean, you can leave the gym floor that says Altamira on it, but... For history's sake, let's just leave it. Okay, so there is a cost. Okay, so thank you. Yeah. Yeah. So thank you for clarifying. So just for the board to consider, I mean, I do think it's important, especially since it's something that the students have asked for. And I think that for the purpose of unity for them, that it is important that we do this, but this is something

294that we have to consider because there is a cost associated with it. So we want to just be thinking about that as we move forward. I would just ask that we kind of decouple the two items. This item is asking us about a motion to rename cost associated with renovations. I would assume would be a... separate discussion I don't know how that how that works but that would be my request is to decouple the two like move ahead and approve this I know we still do public comment but that's where I stand okay well then with that let's take public comment in the room few things one the Again, just polling my students and having a conversation with my students. I do obviously they want to name the dentist's husband in middle school, but we're

295not gonna go with that but basically the Sonoma Valley Middle School is by far that what they're all again I teach high school so they've all gone through middle school, but that's kind of the consensus and I throw out Valley of the Moon once in a while and they're like Sonoma Valley Middle School and just for reference A young dragon is a dragonette. So the wolf, if you just put some flames coming out of it and throw some wings on that thing, it could be like a dragonette. So I was in high school. The high school was the Tigers, and the middle school was called the Rascals because that's a young tiger. Horrible idea. Thank you, Mr. Hausman. Ms. Smith? Your phone's here. Can I text people? Sorry, I'm punchy So I have a question.

296I have a couple questions So Rena probably could answer one is with the district. I mean this could be a community bridge building opportunity if we could have a community fundraiser to pay for Updating the name and the mascot and I also want to know or ask the question, oh, I forgot to say my name. Thank you. I wanted to know how will the community, the students, the parents, how will they have that opportunity? Will there be a form online? Will there be a Google form? How will they be able to make the suggestions for the name and the mascot? Thank you, Ms. Smith. And I think we have an answer to that now. So I think it's a really important question to answer. So would you like to take that, Dr. Chen? So we

297would use our typical communication channels newsletter website a flyers I know that the administration's already thinking about how to engage the kids more than likely and I see knots because of me we know that's happening but more than likely Both schools really want to engage the kids and you'll probably see not Unless everybody kind of comes together before it comes here. You're probably going to see more than one Possible name and we'll let you know which one comes from the kids But yeah, it's just advertising it and putting it out there so that families and community also are aware that they can Submit a petition. So there are the requirement is that we have to have a hundred signatures per name So that's that's really the only stipulation OK, so for the students that are

298watching, hopefully you're all in bed because it's 10.50. But listen, for everyone who's watching, just so that you understand, I'm just going to reiterate that. So if you have an idea for a name to rename Altsamara, to be able to get it in front of the board for consideration, it needs to have 100 signatures with it. That means 100 people need to support your idea, and they have to sign. for it so you have proof that you have 100 people who support the idea. So just for clarity. That was public, yeah, public comment in the room. Laura Hoban, Adele Harrison. I just don't want the fifth graders, let's not, because sometimes we think like, oh, it's middle school students and it's a middle schooler, so just don't forget about getting this information out to fifth

299graders because they're going in. Thank you. That's a great addition to this conversation. I don't think we have any other public comment in the room, so I'm going to go online. We do have public comment online. Tiffany Briggs, you have the mic. Hi, Tiffany Briggs. I had some concerns in regards to cost. Obviously, the gym floor is one big expense, but the other thing to think about is PE clothes and sports uniforms and all the signage. And I guess on the tech end, that's a little easier, but rebranding a logo costs something too. Spirit wear. all things that obviously are doable, but I'm very concerned about how much this will cost. And in reality, I don't think a name change is necessary to create culture on our campus and a community on our campus. My

300concern too is that Dunbar still is kind of considered Dunbar and but Woodland Star co you know coexists on that campus and I feel you know whatever happens down the road with Adele that it will always be Adele and I would hate to erase the name of Altamira completely that's my two cents and I hope to petition to keep the name the same at least for the first year and see if it really has a true impact on how our kids come together. Thank you guys for your time. Thank you, Ms. Briggs. Heather, G, you have the mic. Hi, thank you so much. I think it's funny because it seems like it's not a big thing, but it is. I do think that This is an opportunity to create something that people can get behind

301and it has to be new. And unfortunately that does come with a cost and that is something that I think the Adele teachers were trying to express wasn't really reflected when we were having conversations. when you think about the students at adele coming over to or um i i really think it has to be something where we're coming together as a community especially when it's been so bruised um i think it would benefit to keep it neutral um having the children vote that's a great idea sonoma valley middle school is super neutral um I think it comes with the decision that was made to merge schools and it's our responsibility to help the kids right now. And I think that if you think about middle schoolers, this is an important thing in that regard. And

302that adult attachments to names like Adele or Altamira have to be painfully grieved and let go of. for the sake of the students creating a new school that can thrive. And I think that we should consider this an opportunity that we can get behind. Thank you, Heather. Ms. Signer, you have the mic. Hi, sorry. I can't believe I'm commenting so much today. I agree with the last caller. I feel like that as well as something that is sort of, again, sort of on the sort of buy-in idea of really getting parental and family buy-in. It seems like an important step if it can happen. I also work in the construction industry, and I've got to say $300,000 to refinish a gym floor seems incredibly excessive. I really, I hope and encourage that you definitely go

303out to multiple contractors when you price out these things. And if some of it is the cost of putting a new logo on, maybe that's the one thing that doesn't happen, at least in the immediate time frame. Thanks. Thank you, Ms. Signer. It doesn't look like there's any other public comment online, so I'll bring it back to the board for discussion and a motion to approve, if someone would like to make a motion. I'll move to approve the nomination period for renaming of Altamira Middle School I'll second All in favor? Aye Thank you And we are going to move on to 15.7. Action is approval of the AB 1200. And Ms. Sipes is going to give us a presentation. Thank you, members of the board. Dr. Chen. First, I want to start out by... Correcting

304there was an incorrect statement made in public comment and I just want to provide you with factual information California Assembly Bill AB 1200 is a law that was passed in 1999 to improve fiscal accountability for California school district the law requires the school districts to create a multi-year financial plans identify funding sources and make public the cost of the employee raises it also gives county offices of education more authority to monitor school districts whereas In speaking with Sarah Lamphinfield at the County Office of Ed, She said that typically they always issue a letter in response, but they only really have to if you're qualified or negative, but because of the status of our financial condition, that's why they issued the combined letter yesterday. The AB-1200 that I presented yesterday was more comprehensive and included both

305negotiating. agreements so I'm not going to go into this one in a lot of detail because the one yesterday had the multi-year projection that included both this and VMTAs but the cost of this proposal is $180,073 for the first year the the TA that was approved was a 2% on salary increase and a 1% off which means the 1% is only this year. And I think we agreed, Kimberly, to pay that at the end of June or at the end of the year. And so moving forward, they will only have a 2% added to the salary schedule, and that 1% falls off next year. In addition to that... We have typically spent about five hundred thousand dollars a year paying out vacation For ten and eleven months classified employees because they're not allowed for the

306contract to take it throughout the year in order to help provide we think it's a benefit to the employees to take their vacation and They're also Miss Smith off also addressed the summer assistant program which provides income to classified employees over the summer months when they're not working and the state pays the biggest portion of that. It used to be funded at 100% and we really don't know how it's going to be funded until the end of the year when the governor decides how much to put in there. So that will typically save us, we're projecting that it'll probably save us close to $200,000 this year because we're starting halfway through the year and then next year we don't know what it'll be so I just projected $250,000. In addition to that, CSEA also agreed

307to max the top tier of the health insurance plan at At the top Kaiser rate, I think there was only 20-some employees. You heard last night that the top plan could cost $32,000 a year. If they pick the top plan and they're insuring their family, they agreed to cap it at the top Kaiser rate, which will save us about $26,000. Also included in this is the statutory benefits, PERS and... All the taxes that go along with it. So like I said, altogether, the cost of this plan for the first year is $108,000. And then the district will actually be realizing savings in the subsequent years. Questions? Thank you. Questions from the board? No questions? Did everyone have their questions answered? Fantastic. I will open it up to public comment in the room. Is there any

308public comment in the room on this item? Just stay there, Dennis. Miss Smith, oh, thank you. Kimberly Smith CSE a chapter president and we we did work long and hard and we did go back and forth and I do appreciate the Protocols that we followed CSE a does look at this legally so They're in agreeance and we just asked that you pass this TA tonight. Thank you Thank you. Any other public comment in the room? Seeing none, we'll go online. Is there any public comment online? Okay, I see a few hands just went up and then they went away. So if you'd like to speak, just make sure you raise your hand. Tiffany Briggs, you have the mic. I'm sorry, guys, I won't keep you long. I just wanted to thank our classified staff too

309for the preparation of today's possible strike. There was a lot of people, custodial, just everybody that implemented things quickly to make today's possible strike and the students being on campus successful. Classified staff had a lot to do with that. So I just I wanted to give a big shout out to them and thank you for Kimberly Smith and the bargaining people for all that you guys do. Thank you, Miss Briggs. Is there any other public comment online? If so, please raise your hand. Miss Salcido, you have the mic. Hi, I just want to echo what Tiffany said. I think the CSEA staff really stepped up or classified staff stepped up on short notice. The other thing I just wanted to point out is that We've only got half a year left and my understanding is

310that this contract will take effect and my concern is that we might have to take if I understand correctly and maybe I don't but you guys should let us know whether we have to take our vacation between now and the end of the school year and what impact that would have. And I just don't know, like, should I be planning to take vacation or is that going to start next year? That's all. Thank you, Ms. Salcido. We'll be sure that you get that question answered. I don't think we have the answer to that at the moment, but I just want to acknowledge that we will get that question answered for you. Is there any other public comment online? Seeing none, we'll bring it back to the board for a motion. I am hopeful that we

311don't have any more discussion on this. I propose a motion to approve 15.7. Second from anyone? Second that motion. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Thank you. So our next item, eight here, is approval of the tentative agreement between SVUSD and California School Employee Association, CSCA Chapter 376. Yes, members of the board, before you is a tentative agreement between SVUSD and CSEA Chapter 376. We met on several occasions and reached an agreement on Article 7, wages, Article 9, health and welfare, Article 12, leaves in Article 25 duration, and we're requesting approval of the tentative agreement. Okay, thank you. Is there any questions from the board on this item? Seeing none, we'll bring it to the public for public comment in the room. Voting on the TA. Okay, seeing none, we'll bring it to online. Is there

312any public comment online on this item? Seeing none, we'll bring it back to the board for approval. Is there a motion to approve? Can I ask a question? Absolutely. So, I mean, I can ask this question of... They can start taking their vacation now, but we're not expecting them to take all of their vacation in the next six months that we ratify the approval of the tentative agreement between SVUSD and CSEA Chapter 376. Is there a second? Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Thank you. I just want to make a note here. Miss Lake, you had your hand raised, unfortunately, after we stopped public comment, but we're very interested in your comment. Please feel free to email the board, and we'd be happy to take a look at your questions or your concerns. Sorry about

313that. All right, moving on. 15.9, approval of the MOU between SVUSD and CSCA Medigap eligibility 2024-25 fiscal year. Miss Scythe? It's me again. Hi. The current contract has a Medigap eligibility where employees who have been with the district for 20 years and would like to retire could get five years or five years. We would pay the 90% of the health insurance up to five years or until they reach Medicare eligibility. And because of the anticipated layoffs, CSCA asked us to... Extend that to 18 years. We would still only pay five years of the insurance and it theoretically it would cost it would save the district money in the long run because as health insurance rates continue to escalate where Providing them with the insurance at a lower rate now as opposed to two years from

314now in addition to this we'd also like the board to extend this to Classified management as well to allow them the opportunity to take advantage of this Okay. Thank you. Is there any questions with the board in regards to this item? No, okay. Sounds good. We'll take it to public comment any public comment in the room miss Smith Kimberly Smith chapter president for CSEA 376 and we did we did we were trying to be creative because the last two years the pars was offered to classified employees which that is was unusual and we understood that the district could not afford to do that again this year but we did look at numbers of years of service from classified employees and that a lot of them weren't eligible for Medicare. And that's a huge part is

315the medical part, why classified employees work longer. And so that's why we were trying to come up with a more creative idea. So CSEA did review this through the 610 policy, and we would suggest that you pass this MOU. Thank you. Mr. Hausman? VMTA co-president, again, a gracious thing to do. I would hope we would look up something for the VMTA members as well for a retirement incentive. That would be great. Thank you. Thank you. Is there any other public comment in the room? Seeing none, we'll take this online. Is there any public comment online? Please raise your hand if so. Seeing none, we are going to bring it back to the board. Is there a motion to approve? I propose a motion to approve 15.9 action approval of the MOU between SVUSD and CSEA

316Medigap eligibility 24-25 fiscal year. I'll second it. All in favor? Aye. Thank you. All right, moving along. Action, excuse me, item 1510, action, adoption of resolution number 25-11 regarding accounting of developer fees for fiscal year 23-24 pursuant to GovCode sections 66001D and 66006B, annual developer fee report and five-year developer fee findings. It's a mouthful. That's a mouthful. It's me again. School districts can use developer fees to improve school facilities and accommodate new students for new development. The charges are imposed to developers of residential and commercial properties within the school boundaries. The fees are used to help school districts address impact of new development on their facilities. And what can the fees be used for? because I know this is going to be one of your questions. Constructing new schools, adding classrooms to existing schools, or

317approving existing school facilities. What can they not be used for? Routine restricted maintenance, books, classroom materials, and teacher salaries. So on page 103 of the report, it shows that our current Rates are $3.31 for residential, $0.54 for commercial industries, and $0.08 for retail storage. We had a beginning fund balance of $2.1 million. We had an ending fund balance of $2 million even. The money that we collected was $518,000. The bulk of that is residential. And we used the money to... We actually used the money to pay for facility use of Arnold's Field for the Sonoma athletic program. We installed security cameras at Sonoma High School, $427,000. We constructed an additional restroom facility at Presswood Elementary, $210,000. And we paid professional and legal consulting. for $6,534. This also has a plan for how we plan to

318spend the money over this next year and which is again, sorry, we did some repairs at the Sonoma High School. baseball field we're going to be refurbishing using it to refurbish the portables at Altamira and installing security cameras at Altamira and that work will begin probably starting in February so we're asking for approval of the plan thank you bring it to the board for questions Yeah, I have a question and I don't expect you to know the answer because I'm sorry I didn't talk to you about this before but I was looking at a legal brief around developer fees and I was curious, I mean there's an issue in California where cities, municipalities counties sometimes waive developer fees or they reduce developer fees. Does that mean like so for example there's a there's a hotel

319that's being proposed to build downtown and I can't remember there was a negotiation on on reducing the developer fees. Are we still entitled to the same amount of money even though the city is collecting half as much? Right. We are. And because how do you how do we enforce that? Because some cities have had issues where the school district didn't really collect the full amount of the developer fees. Our Sonoma County is really good with making sure that that they get the receipts and the forms filled out before they'll issue a permit for anything. So we've worked very closely with them. Just want to make sure because I know there's there's been some negotiations And there's gonna be you know There's a maybe a new development at the Sebastiani property and I also want to

320make sure that we're not kind of Keep our eyes on like SEC because that has pretty major ramifications Thank you. Any other questions from trustees? No seeing none. Okay. We'll bring it to Room for public comment anyone in the room would like to make public comment on this item Okay, saying no public comment in the room bring it online miss Briggs. You have the mic I'm feeling popular tonight I I was just curious when the security cameras came up in regards to Altamira Is that something that could be moved because I know Adele just received New security cameras is is that something that can be moved and I know probably it's probably good to keep some security out of Dell if it's sitting empty since it's so close to the high school currently. OK, thank

321you. Thank you. Do we don't have an answer for you right now? That's a great question and we'll try to get that answered for you. Yes, it can be. Oh yes, yes they can be. We do have an answer. Yeah, so the answer, yes. Okay, so the answer, nope. You're absolutely right. The answer is yes. CHRISTIE WOODARD- Yes. I know I don't need to, but I think that's a good question we can answer. It's also 1115. And she's still on, so I'd like to entertain answering her question. So yes, we can move them. A good point by my fellow trustee is we're not acknowledging the fact that we want to just by answering the question. The answer to the question is yes, they can be moved. OK, bringing it back to the board, seeing no

322other public comment online, is there any discussion? No? A motion to approve? I propose we approve 15.10 as it stands. Second. All in favor? Aye. Thank you. 15.11, action approval of the job description paraprofessional in special education. Thank You Miss Oogren good evening members of the board dr. chin superintendent community so the paraprofessional job description is prevented for you to consider adopting starting last year we've been collaborating with our CSEA partners on updating job descriptions we did several of them last year and we continue to do them We have followed the bargaining process and we have an approved MOU with CSEA for the paraprofessional special education. We have a comprehensive special education program for students and over the next few years we'll be adding more services to our program. Our program includes the following support

323for students with IEPs. We have push-in support in general education, resource pull-out support, mild-moderate support needs classroom, more to come next year one-to-one support and we have a moderate we have moderate to severe ESN classrooms preschool through grade 12 currently SVUSD has one job description I a special education for a range of settings why we need this paraprofessional job description to improve service to students and invest in our staff It aligns the role and responsibility of our unit members serving students with moderate to severe disabilities in ESN classrooms, including behavior technicians that provide one-on-one support for students as per their IEP. We're currently facing a staffing shortage, particularly in the area of IA special education and BT, which is what it's called right now. And they're especially challenging to fill. We can attract and retain

324highly qualified staff. We will be able to reduce turnover, which is really important with students to have consistency. And we can reduce a reliance on contractors, which is costly to our district. When we don't hire our own, we do have to go out and go to agencies and contract. This job description includes a requirement for training, which our current special education IAs in ESN classes have been asking for with our district behavior analyst, and it creates time for monthly training, collaboration, problem solving, and data-driven decision-making for students with extensive needs. It'll increase the number of hours from six hours per day to 6.5 hours per day so we can support students from bell to bell and then also have their paraprofessionals there before and after school. It creates a more comprehensive staffing model that aligns

325with our special education plan. In summary, the paraprofessional job description and those unit members in this classification will be assigned to support students with moderate to severe needs in ESN classrooms or as a one-on-one support to students. The title also better defines the job our unit members perform every day, paraprofessional. Thank you very much. I'll bring it back to the board for questions. Is there any questions of the board? Okay, fantastic. Then we will go to public comment in the room, please. It's me. Kimberly Smith, chapter president for CSEA, chapter 376. This, pretty much what Kristen said was this does align with the actual duties that the IAs, currently they're considered IA special ed, and when you compare what an IA special ed is doing in a general classroom, IA, special ed, are doing more

326extensive one-to-one care. And they are paraprofessionals because they do collaborate within their own classroom. And they are kind of their own little community. And they work really hard. I always advocate for training so and I've listened and heard and just advocate to the board to pass this paraprofessional job description and we have been slowly picking away at updating the job descriptions because there's a lot that are outdated, were outdated, and were at least halfway there. So anyway, I just really support this. It's been a long time coming. Thank you. Thank you. Is there any other public comment in the room? Seeing none, we'll go online. Is there any public comment online for this item? Seeing none, we'll come back to the board for a motion. Sorry, yes, board discussion. Or a motion. First of all,

327I just want to say I'm really glad to see this item on here. Some of the staff who are in these positions came to me about this job description issue and really just. did a really great job of just sort of outlining the need and the differences and I think that and I completely agree with them and as a parent of a child and with significant disabilities who had an aide I know that you know that's the I in the IEP right that there's very individualized and it comes at different levels and especially looking forward that we are going to have to expand our special education program and offerings as SCO begins to bring closure to some of theirs we're going to have students who have medical needs and there's and more significant behavioral needs

328and so this is a really this is really important that we're doing this work now because we're getting ahead of that but we're also uplifting and upholding the actual job that the professionals in this position are doing every single day that they haven't really had before for many of our children with more significant and extensive needs oftentimes their relationship with the paraprofessionals in the room um are deeply key to their access to learning and sometimes their their willingness to to try new things that they weren't willing to try before to build some new skills those relationships become very close um so i just i want to acknowledge that i'm glad that we're doing this and i also want to take a moment to acknowledge that it is 11 20 p.m and one of the people

329who's doing this job who came to me with this and gave up her time to explain in detail and in very real ways why this is important, she's still sitting here right now. That's how important this is to her and that's how important these kids are to her. And so I just want to acknowledge you, Deanna, in the room. And I want to thank you because you've given a lot of years of service to our students with disabilities and your commitment to them. And thank you. I know you've worked hard on this as well. And I appreciate that you're sitting here right now. I would love to make, oh, go ahead, Anne. Trustee Ching. Go ahead. OK. So because you're here, and because you're here, I just want to give a little bit of context

330of the time that has been spent by you with our students with special needs. So when I was in Mr. Hausman's PE class at the high school many, many years ago. Sorry, guys. That's when I first met Dina because she was an aide to a student who was in my PE class. So your commitment to not only the students but staying in this community and staying with our schools and our students is just very admirable. We really appreciate you and all the work you've done. And there was other people here that also hold this position that had to leave. So I just want to acknowledge that we have some really special people doing this job. I just really appreciate you. So yeah. So okay, at this point, I think we're probably ready to go ahead

331and make a motion. Yeah, unless we're going to name a building after Dina. Which we might. I'm really going to make her cry. You keep it up. You're getting a building. Is there a motion on the table? I'll make a motion to approve this item. Is there a second? I'll second it. All in favor? Aye. Congratulations. 1512 well we still have one more after this so 1512 action approval of the Williams settlement quarterly uniform complaint report for the period of October 1 24 to December 31 2024 good evening board of trustees Dr. Chen I'm happy to announce that we have zero cases reported for Williams wonderful thank you any questions from the board no seeing none public comment in the room public comment online Seeing none, bring it back to the board for approval. Is

332there a motion? I move to approve the Williams Settlement Quarterly Uniform Complaint Report for this quarter. I'll second that. All in favor? Aye. Okay, so our last item is going to be considered 15.12A, which is page 47 in our board packet. Oh, excuse me. I'm incorrect. It's page 46 in our board packet. This was a request by Trustee Bell and so I'll hand it over to you. I just have a question. We're paying $18,000 for training for staff based on the Youth Truth Feelings of Safety Decrease. And so one of my challenges is that we've got a lot of training. involved in our work as this board. You know, we've got training involved in our hate speech policy. Have we completed that? Where are we on the training of the staff and of the students

333and things like that? And now we're doing, you know, we're going to spend, and it's obviously a grant money, which I get. It's not quote-unquote our money. But this is not... You know, look, tell me it's absolutely necessary, but if it's not, then why wouldn't we be using potentially grant money for literacy, numeracy, education, the core competency of what we should be teaching our kids? That's my question on this one. So if you could sort of talk about that and let me know. What was that, Dennis? No, so this training is actually a response to some of the concerns that you all brought up at the beginning of the year when we mentioned that there were many fights. happening at the high school mostly and at the middle school at the beginning of the year

334we got together as I mentioned to you before with Chief Cutting with Officer Esponda with Jillian with several other folks to talk about what what is the root cause of that happening and what we realized is that just like we have MTSS for academics we should also have MTSS for behavior And we had talked to Molly about this and she mentioned that a couple of years ago the high school was provided de-escalation training and that's considered tier one. That's for like, that's how we respond to most kids who are showing inappropriate behavior, but we need more training and more support for those students who provide or who are demonstrating more severe behaviors. In addition to that, we need more training for addressing the needs of like those high risk students that not just show demonstration

335of inappropriate behavior once or twice, but have some severe problems. So in order to address the most intensive kind of behaviors that we have on our campuses, we decided that we needed additional training on top of just the deescalation training. Because the deescalation training provides support for our staff to to kind of talk down students who kind of again get escalated and could potentially get into fights and so this is a response to that I met with our Sonoma Valley Ed Foundation they potentially raise funds based on our needs they don't have necessarily money sitting in their bank. What they typically do is say, what is the need of the district? And when this was happening, we went to them and said, we don't have necessarily a pot of money to send our folks to

336training. So they stepped up and raised money to get this grant fund for us so that we can send our staff to get that training. Now, the intention of this is that we sent a team. And it's going to be a trainer of trainer model, where they're going to come back and train our staff on how to not just do de-escalation, but do more intensive support for behavior. Yeah, when we get there. No problem. Yeah. Any other questions? No, that's helpful. That puts some perspective on it. Thank you. And I think it's also important to put the perspective on why the staff is going to training, because you know, when you look at this, if you know the staff, you see one person who's actually at the high school. So the context of this being

337staff training staff, that's a model that I believe staff has asked for, right? Like that is something that I've, I believe I have heard for other instances, right? And so we're honoring that as well. So that is a context that you wouldn't know if you were to read this, but having the explanation, it makes sense. Any other questions? No, okay public comments Oh, no, no. This is considered an item on the regular agenda. Hi, Laura Hoban, Adele Harrison. I just wanted for Trustee Bell, for the students to get to the academics, a lot of times the behavior has to be in check, like unless they're ready to learn. So it is really important for learning to have this training for people so that kids can then access the academics. So that's what I wanted to

338say. CHRISTIE WOODARD, C-CAP, Awesome. Thank you. Any other public comment in the room? No? Online? Seeing none, bring it back to the board. We do need to approve this because it was in the consent for approval or deny. Sorry, I don't mean to sway anyone. We need to vote. I'm sorry, guys. It's late. Is there a motion on the table, or can someone please make a motion? I propose to approve the item as Okay thank you. Is there a second? I second it. All in favor? Aye. Okay with that we will go to let me get back to the back of the book here. Board reports. Just keep in mind we do have an option to email these to staff given the time it being 1135. Mine's not a report. It's just when it's time

339to adjourn the meeting, to adjourn the meeting in the memory of somebody in our community we just recently lost. And so I could do that now, or I could do it when it's time to adjourn. I'll leave it to you. Let's do it when it's time to adjourn. OK. Yeah, just in case people have requests. Or we could, yeah, because it seems like it's important, and I don't want to dilute it. OK, so board reports, can we agree that we will email them? unless anyone has anything pressing no okay 17 future agenda items I definitely have some but I'm also happy to email those to staff how do you guys feel about that okay and I didn't take public comment I don't On these? Okay, let's just clarify for the community once we get to

340this point in our meeting, reports, and future addenda items, we do not take public comment. This is not a violation. Thank you for clarifying. I just want to make sure that's clear. And with that, I'm going to let Trustee Winders present. Thank you. I just tonight wanted to adjourn our meeting in the memory of a Sonoma Valley community member who passed the other day after a battle with cancer. Scott Hales was an incredibly kind and compassionate person who was committed to the arts. He was an amazing photographer himself. And he was a devoted supporter of local musicians of all ages, especially our young musicians. He walked the talk in his beliefs that all people are deserving of their basic human rights and dignity, and that people deserve housing, food, care, and learning. And our community

341was better because of Scott, and he will be very, very missed. And may we carry on his legacy of love, equity, compassion, and justice in our own work and our own lives. And I thank you, Scott, for wherever you are in the universe. We celebrate you, and you are a wonderful and amazing man. Thank you. Thank you for bringing that to us. And with that, and much respect to Scott and his commitment to our community and his family right now, sending them love and prayers, we are going to adjourn this meeting at 11.36 p.m. Have a good night. Have a good night, everyone.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.