001We'll look for an approval of the agenda. Is there a motion to approve the agenda? I move to approve the agenda as presented. Is there a second? Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. OK, communications to the board. Or excuse me, public comment. The board recognizes the value of public comment on educational issues and provides this time for members of the audience to address the board on any school-related matter not on this agenda. The board can take no action at this time. Each speaker is requested to identify themselves prior to addressing the board and to limit comments to three minutes. So do we have any comments in the room for items not on the agenda? So point of order. So do we normally take public comment for things not on the agenda before we go into
002closed session or is it after? Sorry, it just was a little confusing. That means that we don't take public comment when we come back then, correct? Or I would entertain the idea of doing it now and since we just announced it and also when we come back if the board is interested in entertaining that. Okay. Again, this is items not on the agenda. Right. Let's just call for items not on the agenda once and not have it twice. That would be my understanding. OK. So we're going to do it once, and we're going to continue with doing it now as it stands, as it's written on the agenda. So I'll ask again. Is there any public comment in the room for items not on this agenda today? Seeing none, I'll go online. OK. It doesn't
003look like there's any. public comment online. So we'll move on to public comment for closed session items. So the board recognizes the value of public comment on educational issues and provides this time for members of the audience to address the board on any item to be discussed in closed session. Each speaker is requested to identify themselves prior to addressing the board and to limit comments to three minutes. So is there any comments, public comments in the room on items on the agenda? you can go to the podium and just be sure to introduce yourself. Good afternoon. My name is Marty Bennett. I'm a 30-year resident of the city of Sonoma. I'm a retired instructor of American history at Santa Rosa Junior College where I taught for 25 years. I am also a representative for Unite
004Here Local 2, representing 15,000 restaurant, food service, and hotel workers in the North Bay, East Bay, and San Francisco. I am also a delegate to the North Bay Labor Council. Between 2021 and 2023, our union successfully organized 275 workers at the Fairmont-Sonoma Mission Inn. which is now the first Union Hotel in the Sonoma Valley. We anticipate the first contract at the Fairmont will soon be signed. I want to thank the Valley of the Moon Teachers Association for supporting our organizing campaign. Their members attended and spoke at two rallies at the Fairmont in 2023. I am here to voice our support. for VMTA and to demand that the district comply with the law and vote on the tentative agreement that was agreed to by the district and union leaders last October and then ratified by VMTA
005membership. As a longtime educator, I know that board ratification of the contract is an essential step towards providing quality education for all district students. Why? Quality education means that teachers, librarians, nurses, and counselors are paid competitive salaries, can live in the community where they work, and are not compelled to seek employment in nearby districts given the high cost of living in the valley. Quality education means reduced class sizes so teachers have reasonable workload, sufficient prep time, and the ability to develop curriculum appropriate for varied student needs, and the ability to provide individual attention to their students. Quality education means that teachers and staff are not subject to too many staff meetings and adjunct duty assignments, which cuts into prep time and time teachers can spend with their students. Improving the quality of education in the
006district will directly benefit the children of our Fairmont members and the entire community. We stand in solidarity with VMTA. If there is a strike, I will be on the picket lines with other members of my union and members from affiliates of the North Bay Labor Council. Please ratify the TA today. Thank you very much. Thank you, sir. Great. Good afternoon, Honorable President Landry, board members, and staff. My name is Jack Buckhorn. I am the Executive Director of the North Bay Labor Council, and I stand here in solidarity with the teachers who had a tentative agreement that was signed by this district's negotiating team and their president and was ratified by that rank-and-file membership. You have the opportunity today. to prevent a strike that would do nothing but harm an already fragile relationship between you and
007your staff and classified staff for that matter. So I urge you take this opportunity to honor the commitment that your team made to the teachers. To fail to do that will put in place a I think consequences that the students don't deserve, that they don't, they didn't ask for, that they don't want, that no parent wants to see. You know, to go out on strike during a school year is just something that is not appropriate and shouldn't happen. And there's no reason that it should be happening today. So I just urge you in your closed session to... Just ratify, just agree with what you've already told us. I mean, after you went in closed session when you first received the agreement, it was reported in the paper that it was reported out that that was
008voted on and approved. And then the superintendent sent an email some time later that evening saying that there was miscommunication. Well, let's be clear. No miscommunications. You negotiated a deal. Let's live to the deal. I know you guys. are in declining enrollment you're talking about closing schools that there are going to be fewer teachers i mean when you have a structural deficit that's what happens i don't envy the job that you have but you put your hand up and you ask to take this job and i know you're serious about it and you're going to do a good job but you cannot build trust by agreeing to a contract with your teachers and your classified and then turning your back on them. That is not the way that a mutual gain bargaining situation should work.
009And if there's ever a time that there should be mutual gain bargaining, it's when you both sit down, put all your cards on the table and say, how are we going to solve this mess we're in? We need help. I know teachers are educated. They're smart. They want to do the right thing for themselves and their students. They will do the right thing for this district given the opportunity. So please ratify this agreement, get back to the table, and then solve the structural deficit that you have working with your staff. So thank you today. I don't want to be on that strike line on Thursday, but if called upon labor, we'll step up. And the 70,000 members that I'm here representing today will... take notice and they will be here in some number as well.
010So let's not do that. You have the opportunity to solve that problem today. So I wish you the best in your negotiations. I hope to hear a positive report out. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Is there any other public comment in the room on items on the agenda? Seeing none, we'll go online. Is there any public comment online for items on the agenda today? Ms. Norris? I just want to comment that I'm a parent of a first grader at Elvon Rano Elementary, and I wanted to voice my support for the teachers union and the strike. We are a double union family, ILWU Local 3 and OE3. So teachers, we are 100% behind you. We're ready to show up. We've done this before. We know how to do it. So we have your back. Thank you.
011Thank you, Ms. Norris. Is there any other public comment online? Seeing none, we will recess to closed session. Recording stopped. Recording in progress. OK. I'd like to report out that the board took no action in closed session. So at this time, we are going to move on to our regular agenda. Just a point of order do we need an approval of the regular agenda or we did that before for everything? Yeah, okay, so On our regular agenda today, we have an action item, approval of AB 1200. Government Code Section 3547.5 states that before a public school employer enters into a written agreement with an exclusive representative covering matters within the scope of representation, the major provisions of the agreement, including, but not limited to, the cost that would be incurred by the public school employer
012under the agreement for the current and subsequent... fiscal year shall be disclosed at a public meeting of the public school employer. The intent of this government code is to ensure that members of the public are informed of the major provisions of a collective bargaining agreement before it becomes binding on the school district. The board is asked to consider approval of AB 1200 as presented which reflects the financial impact of the VMTA tentative agreement between SVUSD and VMTA. So I believe we have a presentation on this. Am I on now? Good evening. AB 1200 is something that's required, as you said, any time we enter into negotiations with the bargaining units. So I'm just going to review what we have on the screen here. No number one is salary schedule so the total cost of the
013proposed two percent salary increase as indicated on the tentative agreement is three hundred and eighty thousand nine hundred and sixty one dollars in year two That cost continues into year two because it's an ongoing Salary adjustment then plus step and column included with that and it also moves forward to year three So by year three that three hundred thousand really cost us eight hundred and thirty six thousand Number two is other compensation stipends bonuses longevity overtime differential pay callback standby, etc The cost of this is three hundred and sixty four thousand twenty nine dollars and your two We're projecting that that'll decrease slightly as with year three The statutory benefits associated with that is $217,165, and then that increases over the next two years. The total cost of the proposed agreement is $962,155. Next year
014it goes to $1,039,902, and the third year it's $1,004,000. Okay, I just want to skip to the third page. where it has the multi-year projection. One more, Michelle. So factoring this tentative agreement, the impact of it, as you can see, it lowers our fund balance in 24-25 after the agreement to $2.1 million. In the 25-26 year, it reduces our fund balance to $948,000. And in the third year, $618,368. I'd like to point out that that is below, both years are below the required 3% reserve balance that we're required to keep. And lastly, before I open it up to questions, the county office reviews the district's AB 1200. And I just want to read the last paragraph that... the memorandum that was written by Sarah Lampenfield. Should the governing board approve the TA as presented the
015board should act to address the long-term impact of the settlements on the district's reserve. Therefore the county requires the district to develop a board-approved fiscal recovery plan that identifies expenditure reductions by the 24-25 second interim report to avoid a negative or qualified certification. The multi-year projection submitted with the second interim report should only include budget reduction savings that have been approved by the board to avoid a qualified or a negative certification. So I'd like to open it up to questions. Thank you. At this time, is there any trustee questions? Trustee Bell, would you like to start? Sorry. Thanks, Rena. So I guess. On the other compensation here on line two, that would be the overage payment? The bulk of that is related to the overage payment. So we've included the lead psychologist to the department
016chair stipend. also negotiated was that each department chairperson would receive an increase to $75 for every person in the department instead of the $50 they're currently getting. So that was very minimal, $2,376. The rest of the increase really will go to compensate 42 secondary teachers and elementary PE elective teachers by increasing the per student day class size overage. to $8 as opposed to the $1 that we're currently doing. We had, in the past, we had a $3 student overage buffer for the class size limit. And that was in VMTA's proposal. They've taken that out. So in terms of the $8 versus the $1 that we were previously paying. So that's obviously a significant increase. Is that, I mean, was that in the negotiations, is that based on some other comparable district that pays $8 per
017student, or how does that work? We weren't able to find any district that was anywhere near that amount. And just for clarification, there's several, like I mentioned before, there's only 42 teachers that are receiving this increase, and several of them are getting an amount over $30,000. Whoa, okay. And so... My and you know, so forgive me because I'm one of the newest board members here And so my understanding is that there was a previous offer by the district at a 4% across the board pay increase to our Certificated staff which seems different than what we've agreed to because it's a 2% across the board Increase as well as now about four hundred and thirty four thousand dollars, which is going to go to 42 teachers How does that, I mean, from the perspective of looking
018at this through the equity lens, what's the sort of, how do we go from offering 4% to then getting down to 2% across the board and that significant amount of money just going to those 42 teachers? In our last, best, and final offer before we went to mediation, we did offer the 4%. During mediation and when we reached this agreement, this was the proposal by VMTA, the 2%, and they stated that they were trying to help the district's deficit spending. But as you can see, the... It's not equitable to all of the membership, and it equals approximately the 4% that we were going to offer. Right. Yeah, that's, and, you know, I think that part of me joining the board late, I've been, you know, reluctant, a reluctant participant in offer, you know, in the
019voting for this situation. because clearly based on all my analysis and learning and understanding about the district's finances, we really probably didn't even have the money to offer any raises to begin with, right? And so obviously I'm not going to vote no and hold this up and be obstinate about it. But it's strange from my perspective and being new to public education how... 100% of the teachers have voted to go on strike and in order to, instead of accepting a 4% across the board pay increase to everybody to say, look, we're just going to give, accept 2% and then 42 teachers get that rest of that compensation. I sort of, I'm still trying to understand how this whole business works because to me that doesn't make a ton of sense. And so... From the other
020perspective of this AB1200, which I've never seen before as a new trustee, so we also increased sick days from 10 to 11. And so can you walk me through that? I mean, what was the sort of the rationale for that? What do other districts do? And, you know, what's the utility rate of the 10 sick days that were, you know, under the existing benefits and what was that? Can you sort of talk about that a little bit? Sure. Almost every district in the state gives the 10 sick days we're required to. We've been unable to find another district that offers anything over the 10. This, again, was VMTA's request. They originally requested 17 additional, 17 days. And so in the ARTA or the In order for us to go through the negotiation process, this was
021a give that we gave, was to go from 10 to 11. Currently, last year, over the last several years, there hasn't been more than five people that have exhausted their sick leave. Teachers also have a sick leave bank, so if you have a catastrophic illness, you can pull from the sick leave bank. So we weren't really sure why their request was to go to... more days, but They do get service credit if you bank your sick leave days when you retire you can turn those in for service credit So it does affect their retirement Explain that to me. Service credit, what is that? So it contributes to their... You can get an extra year if you bank enough sick days. You can get an extra year of retirement. Which then increases the... It gets you
022to retirement age sooner, or does it... It could, yeah. Okay, I'm with you. All right. And then... Sorry, if anybody else wants to interject. My other question is that on F... The can you talk about the the minimum instruction hours? So I would sort of surprised as the new trustee to figure out that we're now in 2025 setting minimum instruction hours That so privilege I mean was it not previously established and sort of talk a little bit about that I'll let Kristen address this one. Thanks Sure. Thank you. So Our current collective bargaining agreement with VMTA we did not have an instructional we did not have enough instructional minutes as required by California Ed Code and we were substantially lower in some grade spans with the high school being 21 day it equated to 21
023days a year instructional minutes so one of the things that we wanted our district wanted was to make sure we have the minimum amount of instructional minutes as required by California Ed Code so the TA will do that again I do want to highlight that it is the minimal amount and then another piece of this was we wanted to establish a professional workday And according to our research and experience, most districts do clearly have a start and an end time for certificated staff, but our district did not have an established professional work day. This can negatively impact students in many ways. For example, accessibility to their teachers, parents' accessibility to teachers, relationships in learning. And so with this TA, this is one of the positives that we're really pleased with. We do have that professional
024work day, and our certificated staff have to be on campus 10 minutes before the student bell. And we do have the minimal amount of instructional minutes. We're happy about that. Okay. Trustee. Can I go back to something? Oh, sorry. Go ahead. Trustee Lehman. Yeah, I just wanted to go back to, and David, Trustee Bell, I appreciate you kicking off new as I am to this, to AB 1200. So I appreciate being able to ask some questions here in open session. Going back to one of the first points that David was bringing up, which was the difference between a 2% plus an overage increase. And what that cost the district versus a 4% increase? I just, is it, what is that difference in terms of cost to the district? The current TA agreement of 2% plus
025overage versus if the VMTA had accepted a 4% increase. What's the cost difference to us? Michelle, can you go back to the very first page? And if it's negligible? Yeah, it's very negligible because you can see the 2% is $380,000 and the overages is $364,000, so it's roughly $27,000. Okay, so negligible. So in terms of the optics of what I have heard as a new trustee is this deal with VMTA will save the district money versus a 4% increase. That, in fact, is just not true. sans maybe a twenty thousand dollar difference it could in the out years yeah but not in but not in the current year right um sec second question is can you remind me again this can be an estimate is We just in our last board meeting had a very
026contentious decision to close Adele Harrison Middle School. And that is obviously was not an easy decision. It clearly will be impactful to the students of our district. What was the savings outcome? I know you did a recalculation after the decision was made. Remind us again what the savings outcome was. So we're estimating it to be right around just under a million dollars, $950. sixty thousand And that won't be final until we get all of the master schedules built and get all the staffing. But based on the cuts that we're projecting, those are just the salary savings that we would have in the cuts by combining the two schools. Yeah, and I think where I'm coming from is these decisions don't happen in isolation. We are tackling a lot of very difficult issues at the district.
027So school consolidation is ongoing. We've already closed one. in negotiations with contracts. These are happening in isolation in a sense that they're negotiated in isolation, but our financial situation is impacted by all of these decisions. From your purview, the impact of agreeing to this TA, will we need to continue to make school consolidation and other cuts? this school year and in future years? Yes, you're going to have to continue to make significant cuts this year and out years. Okay. Last question of clarification for me is... Doing the school consolidation, if we were to sell a property, can we use any of those funds to pay for staff salary increases? Now, the sale of property can't go into your general fund for general use purposes. It has to go into funds for repairs and maintenance for
028facilities. Yeah, I'm just going to repeat it back so I understand. The answer is no. we cannot use funds from selling school property to pay for teacher or other staff or salaries or ongoing costs so understand that listen i came into this very late their negotiations had had already gone through mediation and um this is not a great situation for the district to be in i ran on the principle that we would balance the budget and we would keep our education of our children front of mind first both of those things this does not accomplish that what what is really what has really swayed my position on where I stand on this topic is the fact that there is a strike that is imminent on Thursday and puts our children at risk. And the fact
029that our children are at risk on Thursday of not having class sways me in a direction that I want our district to move forward. We are still going to have to tackle the difficult financial situations of the district. And there are going to be clearly further cuts. We can't have it every, we can't cut it every single way, right? I was taught that as a kid and I hope we're teaching our children that we can't have. our cake and we can't need it too i'm not sure where that expression came from but i think it for certain uh is applied to this situation we can't have salary increases small class sizes and all of our schools open and balance our budget it's impossible so we are we are we will be making difficult decisions in
030the coming months is what uh financial decisions is what i understand and that that's all i have on this thank you any other trustees trust teaching I just have two follow-up questions related to Trustee Lehman's comments. I just want to delve a little bit more into the line two of the AB 1200, which essentially captures what the cost is of the increased overage from $1 to $8. And I just want to... I don't know if you can answer this now or you can provide this later, but can you provide like a breakdown? Is this kind of even you said earlier that it would kind of benefit 42 teachers. Do we know is that secondary primary? Could you just give us like a rough? It's almost entirely secondary. Okay. Okay. And then my final question really
031is coming back to the deficit spending issue. I mean, this is kind of highlights like the structural deficit that we're in. So if I understand this correctly, so line five basically gives you the three multi-year projection of what the cost of the overall schedule increased and the other compensation. So the way I understand this is from the letter that SCO provided and you read the last paragraph of it, it looks to me, and I would just like affirmation or confirmation, that with the projected... budget deficits of 2.2 million, 1.2 million, and 330,000. Those would be the minimum cuts that we would need to make to be able to balance the budget. That's correct. Yes, ma'am. But with 24-25, are we able to do any cuts? No. For this year? Okay. No. All right. That's it.
032I do want to have one point of clarification because we've talked about class sizes. I don't want it to be misunderstood. We do have caps on our class sizes. We do have contractual caps and requirements for our class sizes. So we're not going to have 40 students in a class in an elementary school. So I just want to make sure that that's clear. I actually appreciate that clarification. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Any other trustee questions? No, that answered mine actually. Thank you. Perfect. Trustee Bell? So just on F, it's great that we've got minimum instruction established. That's obviously a positive that's come out of this negotiation. But then the rest of it is there's sort of what I see is reductions in levels of obligations by our employees right and there's a there's a
033pay increase relatively across this contract we're paying the 2% plus the 434,000 to the 42 employees is this a typical scenario of a labor negotiation where we pay more money but we then the work hours are reduced for our staff I would say typically not. Okay. But, you know, in negotiations there's always give and take. So typically, you know, the unions will negotiate like they did here, less. adjunct duties or but yeah that always has an impact on students as well yeah I mean I see this as as being obviously a reduction in work hours but it directly affects a lot of things that as it relates to the kids right and so I just you know and as a late participant in this negotiation it's something that it is sort of something that is
034not great in my mind and I recognize the situation we're in the budget and I'm with you know trustee Lehman is that Sorry, layman. No offense, David. Yeah. I've stated sort of clearly to my fellow trustees, I'm not going to hold this up and vote no and be obstructive. I think that we obviously need to avert the strike. We need to move on. You know, I'm leaning towards saying, yeah, look, let's get this done and move on. But I think that... The loud and clear message that I'm hearing from you as well as studying the numbers is that we've got a lot of work to do post approval of this contract and this is just kicking the can down the road which you know we've increased the deficit with these two labor contracts by a
035million dollars essentially so a deficit for 2425 just went from a million dollars to two million dollars essentially right and so and this School consolidation, in my mind, is not going to cover the deficit, so we're going to then have to figure out how we can cut positions and staffing in order to balance the budget, and how is that going to affect the kids, which is obviously something that we're all going to have to deal with down the road. And so that's the totality of my questions, I think. Okay, thank you. Is there any further questions from trustees before we open it up to public comment? Can I ask one last? Absolutely, Trustee Ching. I forgot to ask. I noticed that on the line four of the AB 1200, which is health and welfare benefits,
036it looks like the plans are staying constant. Is that what the 0% means? Yes, we currently pay 90% of health and welfare for employees, and we didn't negotiate a change in that. There is no cap to our coverage. But does that also assume that the cost of the plans are going to stay constant or no? No, the cost of the plans go up anywhere between 5% and 10%, but since it wasn't negotiated to change anything. It doesn't. It does change in the multi-year projection. Yeah. It shows the increase, but in the negotiated settlement, it doesn't change it. Because basically this is not reflecting the actual cost. This is reflecting the benefit that the union accrues. So it's essentially still a 90-10. Correct. Is that correct? And just for reference. Does the 90-10, how does that
037compare sort of generally across the county or the Bay Area? Is that a typical split? I'm going to let Kristen answer that because she did a lot of research on that. Okay. Yeah, so based on research and experience, most districts have a cap. So there is a limit, and every time the rates go up, you're capped. And then most districts pay a certain percentage of the employee. So they'll pay 100% of the employee. SVUSD pays 90% of any plan, including the employee. And some districts also will give a monthly dollar amount. Many of them give $1,000 a month or $1,100 a month. So as your prices go up, all the district covers is. that set amount. I haven't found any district that pays 90% of any chosen plan including family and other districts range from
038their yearly cost is 12,000 which is Napa to Santa Rosa 17,527 and for us it's Believe I had it it is our lowest cost employee for a single is ten thousand and our most important expensive employee if they have that family gold plan is thirty four thousand Thirty four or I'm sorry Twenty four say it again twenty four five. Yeah. Yeah, so there's a big swing But we without that cap in us paying the 90% of any plan Yeah, so we so we would just to be clear so I get the math right We would pay either 90% of the lowest cost lowest cost plan which would be 9,000 and in this and then that or 90% of a plan that costs $34,000 for a family Our cost is $34,000 Okay, so their cost is
039outside of those numbers yeah, yeah and just do you I mean, I don't expect you to know this here, but you could maybe tell me later. Do we have just a sense of what's the distribution? Like, are most of these single for our district? Are we playing generally? Like, what's the split between our... the plans that are for single individuals versus like family? Is it 50-50, 25-75? Yeah, I would be able to give that information. I can pull it. I do know, you know, right around between 50 and 60 percent of our employees have Kaiser. Yeah. So, but I could get, I could get that for you. Thank you. You know, where does it land and who's using what for our benefits. Okay. Thank you so much. Okay. I think Trustee Lehman had one last
040question and then. yeah my last question I was just trying to wrap my head around again I think of things in context and a single year increase of two percent with overage obviously being a being actually a significant portion of the increase in compensation for teachers that's just this year can you just remind me and and folks online here in the past five years do we have a total number for the salary increases that we've negotiated with the VMTA? Yeah, it totals 26.5%. Okay. That doesn't include step and column. Those are just the salary increases. And I think one year there was a one-time payment of $2,500 in addition to that. Okay. So I just wrote that down. 26% increase in five years does not include step and column. Correct. Got it. Thank you. Can
041I add something to that? So I believe that the step and column on average my recollection is about three and a half percent per year is that for Certificated now because we have a lot of teachers at the top of the scale. It's a right around One and a half to one point. Okay Again, I know Trustee Bell had made the comment on moving things forward. I'm still inclined to move things forward. Again, we're not in a financial situation to afford this. It's clear. We closed a school, and we're still $2 million. We're further in the hole after closing a school this year. That is not an okay situation to be in as a school district. Further in the whole meeting, we are continuing to run a deficit and we are continuing to dip into
042reserves that are below, projected to be below the 3% reserve rate. So this is not an okay situation to be in and we need... folks to come along and help us on this path to financial stability. We cannot continue to have friction in our negotiations with our partners, with our community. We need to have everyone working together for a financial outcome that we can all afford for our children. Again, everyone wants to talk about our children. That is what we're talking about, financial stability for the education in our district. We need everyone to come along with that solution, and it's going to be very difficult. We can solve it, but it will be difficult. We are further in the hole. Again, we need to move forward, but we need help from everybody, and I'm confident.
043I know we have incredible people in this valley. We have incredible people in this room, and I know we have incredible staff that can help us get there. So I'm looking forward to folks helping us solve this. Okay, awesome. Thank you. I don't have any questions. You answered all of my questions. And with no further questions of staff by the board, we're going to turn it over to public comment. So I'd like to just get a head count or a hand count online. So if you're online and you're interested in making public comment in regards to this first item on our agenda, if you could just raise your hand so we have an idea of how many people would like to speak. Okay, I'm seeing none. So is there any public comment in the room?
044Okay, just be sure to introduce yourself again. Yeah, great. Well, Honorable President Landry, board members and staff, my name is Jack Buckhorn, Executive Director of the North Bay Labor Council. I've never met a school board member that didn't have the sincere interest of their students at heart, and I see that in this group as well. Declining enrollment. is a problem that many school boards are facing and it's a horrible problem and I appreciate your public service to help solve this problem. I've negotiated many agreements and I don't know how this school board worked but typically a school board gives their negotiators a goal. Four percent. It sounds like somebody from you told your negotiators you have four percent at some point to negotiate a deal. And that's the deal that was brought back. The question
045is, why did they go from a 4% for everybody to 2% for everybody and then this excess pay? And I would say the answer is pretty obvious. I believe that the school, the union... members understand that you're going to be closing schools and laying off workers and they don't want to have classes with 50 students in them. And so when you put excessive, you know, when you go over a certain threshold and you have to pay more, that's an incentive to keep classes smaller and have more staff. Now I wasn't part of negotiations. I don't know. No one told me that. That's just my sense from why would they do that? Why would they go from four to two? And I think it's trying to keep more teachers employed and keep smaller classes. to give
046a better education. But again, that's just my perspective from the outside. The most important point is that you recognize the commitment you made for 4%. You're going to uphold it. And yes, you do need to sit down with those unions and figure out a way that you can be viable going forward, whatever that looks like. They're your partners. There is no school without teachers. And a 2% increase is not keeping up with inflation. And I believe what they tried to do is maintain as many jobs as they could, as well as have adequate classroom sizes so that they could give the education that students deserve. So thank you. It seems to me the sentiment is to move forward, avoid the strike. I fully support and appreciate that. I'm not part of this district, but I
047will do anything and everything in my power to help you solve this problem as well as any other school district. So this is important to us. Public education is important to me and to you. And I do want to help if I can. So thank you for your time. Thank you. Is there any other public comment in the room? Hi, my name is Katie Margreiter. I am a teacher at Adele. I didn't plan to speak tonight. I had my dogs at the dog park and I was listening to the board meeting and I heard some confusion about the 42 who have the class sizes who will be getting the overages. I'm one of those 42. I teach science and farm to table. Science has a class size of 30. I at one point this year
048had 35 in one of my classes. Not only is that over that cap by or over that soft cap by five, I didn't have chairs for those kids. I'm told that that's possibly also over fire code. And I wasn't getting much back. I wasn't getting much help. And the district was not motivated to help because they're paying a dollar. to me each time I see those kids, so every other day, for not all five of those kids, but two of those kids. My farm to table class has a cap size of 27. I currently have 31 in one of those classes. Another class has, I think, 29 or 30. I can't quite remember off the top of my head. So there's... I'm one of the 42 and the equity and 4% to everybody or 2%
049and the overages I think is to help motivate the class sizes to stay where they're supposed to and it's not for us the teachers as a parent I don't want my kids in a class of 35 I have three kids in the district and I'm here as a parent I have a student going to, two students going to Altamira next year. I fear that those classes are going to be 35 plus if we don't have something more financially for the district if they pack those classes well over. So equity for those of us who are getting more students versus everybody, if that makes sense. I'm one of the 42, and there's lots of us, and we are working very hard to get over those overages. Thank you. Is there any other public comment in the
050room? Seeing none, we'll go online. Is there any public comment online? If so, please raise your hand. Okay. Seeing none, we'll bring it back to the board. This is an action item. So we... can have board discussion if we feel that there is more to discuss. Otherwise, I am looking for a motion on the table. I'm ready to make a motion that we approve the AB 1200 as presented. Is there a second? Second. OK. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. Thank you. OK. We're going to keep going. all right the next item on the agenda is item two the action of the approval of sonoma valley unified school district and valley of the moon teachers association also known as vmta mediated agreement dated october 1st 2024. the board is asked to consider approval of the
051agreement as presented so at this time we don't necessarily have a presentation but do we have any questions amongst the board before we open it up to public comment? Okay, seeing none, we're gonna go ahead and open this up to public comment. Is there any public comment in the room on this item? Seeing none, we're gonna go online. Is there any public comment online for this item too? Okay, seeing none, I will bring it back to my fellow trustees for board discussion. Would anybody like to start? questions no I don't I don't have any questions as I've said previously late to the party in terms of the negotiations I don't think we're in a position as a district to offer any raises to begin with but obviously that was done we couldn't put that genie
052back in the bottle and I think that for you know the benefit of everybody let's I'm inclined to vote to approve this reluctantly. I think that this just exacerbates our financial situation, but we're sort of painted into a corner where we need to avoid a strike to... for the children and I think that on an ongoing basis we need to sort of rethink of how we negotiate and really looking at the budget, looking at cuts in terms of, in addition to the school consolidation, the school consolidation is a band-aid on the financial situation, which is unfortunate. That's not the panacea that's going to solve the entire problem. So, look, you know, we've got some tough decisions and, you know, we're going to start another labor negotiation pretty soon. And if we don't get acknowledgement from
053our labor partners of our budget situation, then we're going to probably end up back in a situation with a strike because reality bats last in terms of money and running out of it, you know. So, anyway, that's my thoughts. Thank you, Trustee Bell. Trustee Winders? yeah I'm inclined to just go ahead and move forward and approve it I don't think a strike is good for children and But to sort of to piggyback it there's just a reality. I mean, this is how the math maths and We're not the only district it's happening throughout California and district after district or birth rate is declining We have a massive housing crisis in terms of low-income housing which low in low-income students make up the majority of the children in our district and if they can't have somewhere
054to live then they can't be they can't live here and they can't be in our schools and that is just a real true thing that is happening. Um, you know, I, I'm, I am, I am ready to, to move forward and vote yes on this, but I also just, um, I just want to say that I think it's really important for us as adults. to ensure that our children know that even though we're going through hard times and we're going to have to make cuts, we're going to have to close another school. There's no stopping that or getting around that. Our enrollment is declining. That we may and will likely have to make staff reductions. That is a reality. But I think it's important in this process that as adults, that the adults all stop
055yelling at each other and fighting with one another and paying attention to the children in the room. And reassuring them, we're going to go through a hard thing. It's going to be sad. It's going to be hard. We're going to feel lots of stuff about it, but we're going to take care of you. And we're going to make sure that you're taken care of and that we're going to go through this hard thing together. I think that when the adults all fight with one another and scream and yell, it reminds me of like, you know, parents going through a divorce and they're screaming at each other and the children are sitting on the couch crying. And that's really what a lot of this lately in our district has really felt like for me. And so
056I would just like to just put it out there that I'm hopeful that all the adults in our community can start paying attention that there's kids on the couch crying. And that we need to stop fighting with each other. And instead, we need to start reassuring the children that it's going to be okay. That we can go through hard things together and take care of them. And that's what I would like to see us as a community do as we move forward this year. Doing some really hard things that we are going to have to do. And that other districts all around us are also having to do. It's not a thing we did wrong. It's just, it's a circumstance. The birth rate has changed. Housing is a crisis. These are real things. We didn't
057do them intentionally to be bad people, but there are circumstances that we're in. And so, again, I'm... I'm ready to move forward with this, but also move forward with the understanding that we are going to have to make significant cuts moving forward in order to be able to sustain this and to be able to take care of people and most importantly to be taking care of our children. And I'm not willing to subject our children to a strike, but I'm also not willing to look the other way when I see adults in our community. Not treating each other well in front of children and not paying attention to the children in the room who are crying and they're getting stuck in the middle of it. I want us to do better and that's all of
058us. I want all of us to do better and to be better to each other in front of the children. We have a board norm. that we behave as though their children are watching. And I've always felt like we need to revise that because it's always as if the children are watching. And they are watching. They're literally watching. They're literally in the room often when this is happening. So I just want us to be mindful of that. But I'm ready to go ahead and move forward with this. OK. Thank you, Trustee Winders. Trustee Ching? I'm also Well, I will support this moving forward, but also recognizing that this has, you know, are going to have pretty dire financial consequences for us moving forward. And I also want to echo what Trustee Winders was saying, which
059is that we need to come together as a district. We are a unified district. We're all playing on the same team, and we're all supporting kids, and that's why I show up here. I don't I think it would be absolutely catastrophic for our kids to miss just one day of school and so I think that's why the board is is coming together and figuring out how to make this work so anyway I'm I'm going to support it and I'm ready to take a vote thank you Trustee Ching Trustee Lehman I'll just say I echo what everyone has said before me, and I believe and am optimistic that we have the people in place at the leadership level at the district. I believe that if we can get the right conversations started and going, we can
060solve this as a collective community, and I'm honored to be here and tackling these difficult decisions with the folks that are here, and I look forward to moving this district forward. Okay. So I too, I'm here with the position that I'd like to move this district forward, but I just would like to be very clear that it is so unfortunate that we had to get to a point of a strike. And I, along with our staff and some members of EMTA came together and I was hopeful that this Thursday without a strike, we could have conversations and come together. But unfortunately, We were presented with the strike. And so we had a meeting yesterday in good faith for the students of this valley and to avoid a strike. And we're here voting today. And it
061sounds like we are going to pass this. because we want to avoid a strike. And I just want to be very clear that this is 100% about our students and ensuring that our students do not miss one day of school. So with that being said, I would just like to ask if there's any other questions or comments from the board. And if not, if we could please get a motion on the table. I would like to make a motion that we approve VMTA's tentative agreement dated October 1st, 2024. Second. Okay. Does this need to be a roll call vote? No? Okay. All in favor? Aye. Aye. And it passes. With nothing further on the agenda, we are going to conclude this meeting at 4.57 p.m. Thank you.