CorpusRecord 159339

WUSD School Board 12-20-24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Windsor Unified School District
Date
2024-12-20
Location
Sonoma County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
31,389 words · about 175 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Oh, so you get the, Bill and I are going to share this one over here. Oh, there's that one missing. I think we just have a full house. We can share. I don't talk that much. Oh, come on. All right. it's okay we could share yeah i was telling rich i don't talk that much so um okay are you ready all right um so good evening everyone it's nice to see you all um so we're gonna get started if i could get a roll call mal and ollie lopez here stephanie ahmad here orca gorno here rich carnation here bill adams here kaylee Kylie Hernandez. Here. And Zoe Furmankevich. Here. All right. And now I'm going to ask all of you to rise. And Zoe Furmankevich is going to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.

002Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Thank you. All right, so now I have a series of student readmission cases that I'm going to be reading. I'm in the consideration of student readmission case number 011024.1. The board's decision is to readmit the student with a unanimous vote. All right and in the consideration of student readmission case number 022024 the board's decision is also to readmit the student with a unanimous vote and in the consideration of student readmission case number 040524 the board's decision is also to readmit the student also with the unanimous vote. All right thank you. um so now we're going to move on to item 3.1 at

003this point are there any adjustments to the agenda only a bit on the consent um i'm sorry nothing can yeah hold on a second i want to have a discussion you you can wait though until consent rich okay okay i'll just wait yeah okay that's what it's starting to market right now okay thank you um are there any other adjustments to the agenda nope okay so seeing none we're going to move on to item 3.2 which is public comment on non-agenda items is there anybody that would like to speak tonight please come to the podium Good evening President Lopez, members of the board and district office staff. My name is Rebecca Rocha. I am a resident of Windsor. I'm here again representing the group of parents who came to the last school board meeting in

004November to request that you consider discussing the discipline including suspensions of students with disabilities on a future board agenda. The parents who were here last month could not be here tonight but have given me permission to speak on their behalf. to request that we examine this issue when i spoke to you in november i talked about how my daughter gigi who's here with me tonight is thriving in her new school I also have a typical daughter who's a student at Windsor High School and on the cheer team. I have been to the football games this fall and watched how the coaches and staff attend to the team with such precision. It is known that Windsor is proud of their team. Not only are there lots of coaches, there are medical staff and personal trainers. The

005coaches are watching TV screens you have on the field, analyzing the plays so that you can be the champions that you are. I ask who is the champions for our children with disabilities here? that you attend to the children with disabilities with the same precision and dedication that is offered to the football team this can be done as a cycle of continuous improvement it doesn't mean that we have to point fingers at people or condemn them we simply need to acknowledge that we have a problem that needs to be addressed and come up with solutions I am requesting that you engage in a cycle of continuous improvement around the behavioral supports for students with disabilities in this manner plan do check and act If Windsor continues on the trajectory that it has been on, I

006fear that there will be more lawsuits and litigation. What is worse is that you will continue to harm students and their families. The County Office of Education has closed most of its programs and the non-public schools are full. There is no spot for many of these children. I was lucky enough to be able to bring my daughter to this district that I work in, but I would not have had the option of enrolling her in another public school. please help us find solutions so that our kids can remain in their home schools i look forward to returning when this topic is an agenda item at a meeting in the near future thank you thank you are there any other comments thank you oh i'm sorry no other comments All right, it looks like there are

007none. So I know we can't respond back, you know, to public comments that are made on non-agenda items. But there is an idea that I've had for a while in terms of, do you think it would be possible, Jeremy, in the next year? to have a study session where we could just really look at what are all of the resources for our students with disabilities because when i think about what do we have available for them i have a difficult time picturing you know visualizing what is there and i'm just curious to see absolutely the road map right yeah for sure we can do that what is it that we offer absolutely yeah we could do it in the spring okay awesome thank you All right, and then next step is item 3.3. I'm always

008excited to hear from our student board members, Kylie and Zoe. All right, so first to kick us off, we have Brooks Elementary School. So the recent events were the Student Council Spirit Week, the School Site Council Meeting, and Fifth Grade Awards. Some upcoming events are the Winter Arts Hot Cocoa Stroll, Maddie Brooks Dine and Donate at Casey's Holiday Spirit Week Yearbook Cover Contest. Next, we have Maddie Washburn Elementary. So we have Maddie Brooks PTA Winter Coat Drive, Kindergarten Friendship Day, Second Grade Balloon Parade. And then the upcoming events are the Holiday Spirit Week, Holiday Sing Along, and the Maddie Brooks Dine and Donate. So for Cali Calmecac Language Academy, we have for recent events, Holiday Movie Night, Dia de los Muertos T-Shirt and Spirit Wear Pickup. And then for upcoming events, the Spirit Week Tea

009and Cookies event, Pulse Check Survey, Due. So some recent events for Windsor Middle School. There was a pomo dance performance on December 6th and a coffee with the principal on the morning of December 10th, as well as a band concert on December 18th. So for some upcoming events, there was a holiday spirit week this week, an ELAC meeting on January 14th, and an open house showcase on January 22nd. For big picture learning, a group of students recently went to the Luther Burbank Center on a field trip. Judge Lisa J. Cisneros came to give a civics lesson, and there's a big picture learning informational night on December 10th. So for some upcoming events, students are just going to continue doing their LTIs and enjoy their winter break. For Windsor High School, Leadership hosted a Friendsgiving, which

010is sort of like Thanksgiving, on November 20th, a teacher versus teacher competition from November 18th to December 10th, which included can stacking and sort of a door decorating competition. Leadership sold holiday singing grams from December 3rd to December 6th. One of our cores at Windsor High School, Community Health, had a field trip to the Redwood Food Bank where they sorted green beans. And then there was also a fall showcase dance performance on December 13th. So some upcoming events. There's a Winter Wonderland High School dance offered in Sebastopol for teens of Sonoma County. And students get to enjoy their winter break. So thank you and happy holidays, everybody. We try our best to attend some of them, but we can't really stay for like a whole time. So we usually just go there. I think we

011went to some Cali events. Well, I did. Did you go to? I usually go to the Windsor Middle School events and the high school events. Yeah, but sometimes it gets hard. Fantastic. So thank you. That looked like it was a lot. all right um so now we're going to move on to assistant superintendent report item 3.4 and just so i can this is new right uh i think paul you have asked kind of for updates on plc progress at different things so this is this was what i think would be the best is kind of an assistant superintendent report that is really centered around those topics of interest that you brought up so that's that's kind of where this comes from and i know what all the audience was hoping for was more presentations so

012i got one for you so this date has been a long time coming it's taken us a whole semester to be able to to gauge the progress from our students from the beginning of the year to how they're doing at the middle of the year this is kind of just a little preview of what the principals are going to be presenting in january when they do their scorecard report but i'm going to focus on growth And so you're going to see a series of charts. And so when you're looking at the charts, it's broken up into quadrants. So the higher they are on the chart that demonstrates their level of achievement and the farther they are to the right, that demonstrates how much growth. So if they're over to the left, they did not get

013typical growth. If they're farther to the right, they got more than typical growth. Everything that's kind of that violet dot represents an entire classroom worth of kids. So no kids, no teachers are identified in these reports, but just know that every time you see a dot, that's a classroom. You will see both general ed and special ed classes on here. So there might be some discrepancies in some of the data where they're a little bit scattered all over the place. So just know that this represents all of our students. So we're hoping that we would see all classrooms in the typical growth or that sweet spot range. um so if they're to the left or the right of it it gives you an idea of some of the progress that we're making so we're going

014to start off in maddie washburn first grade early literacy and you can see that we have some classes in the typical growth range but a majority of them are in the low growth so that's something we're going to be looking at for math we're seeing a bit more in the typical growth range of what we expect to see This would be the second grade now for reading, still to the left of the typical growth, but we're having more classes in that sweet spot range. And for math, kind of the same. In Brooks, we're starting to see more classes in the typical growth, and now we're actually seeing some classes in the high growth. On the bottom right-hand corner, you'll see one of our STC classes. And while it's all the way on the bottom for

015the level of achievement, it's remarkable how much growth they are making every single semester. So they're doing some fantastic work in our special day classes at Brooks Elementary. then the same thing for math a lot of classrooms in that typical growth range for fourth grade reading fourth grade math is doing really really well fifth grade reading in fifth grade math so you can see overall Brooks is showing some fantastic gains you got a proud principal right there Here is Cali. So keep in mind that coming in about half of the students at Cali were non-native Spanish speakers. So when they're coming in to take this first grade Spanish literacy, for many of them, they are newly acquiring this language, but yet we're seeing quite a bit of them moving in that typical growth range. And

016then there's for math. Spanish reading looks phenomenal as we see them making more than expected growth. second grade math and they do take math and Spanish as well. Spanish reading, most classes in that typical growth range, Spanish math, fourth grade reading, fourth grade math, fifth grade reading and fifth grade math. Are there any questions? Both are good. When we start to see the achievement going vertically a bigger significant thing or is growth going to the right it strikes me like when you're thinking about i was thinking about going up but when you're talking about the special day class it strikes me that with growth probably they'll be going up to a 45 degree angle eventually i just wondered if you had a sense of sure and it's both both hands as opposed to either one

017but considering our current percentages where depending on the grade level we're anywhere from 75 to 50 percent of our students not on grade level um the farther right the better um and so so growth we're looking to make more than one year's worth of growth um i mean ideally yes all the way up all the way to the right would be fantastic but i would say the farther right because you can have all the way up and left meaning that they were already high achieving but they're not making typical growth so that's what we're hoping for thank you i'm kind of glad that bill mention that because what I think Brooks is doing fantastic I like the fact that they're not only having growth but they are they are moving up I wish I could

018say the same about another site but but I understand this this data now it looks like maybe maybe Maddie Washburn needs to I mean I'm looking at theirs and it's below 40 percent still go back to Maddie I mean that Okay, no go up one go up one one more Okay, like like look at that that does not look like that's Doesn't look like significant growth to me Yes, it's growth for that individual, but I don't think progress is being made towards being proficient It doesn't I mean explain it to me. Yeah. No, I'm not trying to gloss over Maddie Washburn Their results are not where we want them to be. I definitely wanted to highlight Brooks. I definitely want to highlight Callie absolutely, but Maddie Washburn and also, you know, it creates a situation

019where where Brooks third grade, you know, has quite the lift and they're killing it over there. And we're really proud of the work that they're doing. They're also the ones that are furthest along on our PLC process. And I think it shows Cali historically has done some version of PLC since the inception of the school. And it shows. Now, I'm glad you mentioned that because that's one of the things I always bring up. How are we doing on our PLC? It looks like Brooks is doing well in that process if it's reflected in the data that it looks like that we're seeing so I'm I'm very pleased at that just need to and this you know these I'm hesitant to to look from this year to last year because it's not exactly apples to apples

020because we did different testing windows but I can say that our data did not look this good last year we're seeing a lot more more than typical growth and we're very excited about it all right moving up I had a question Brian I'm next to where it says typical growth in parentheses it says 35-65 what does that mean so the the range that's the range so if you see low growth would be 1 to 34 typical growth would be 35 to 65 high growth is 66 to 99 and that's the standard growth percentage so that's like a proprietary percentage that Renstar uses to determine are you making the growth as an average second grade reading student and and I think that needs to be kind of like we're going to really be getting in the

021weeds with this data so when it says like what's your grade level equivalent it's not saying how well are you doing on those grade level standards how well are you doing compared to other students in your grade level um so it'd be possible that like a seventh grade student at cali named bryn could have a 12.9 grade level equivalent because as a seventh grader she's reading at the same level as students who are at the end of their 12th grade year interesting I had one more question is kind of a broader question have you seen any patterns in terms of what is working across all these schools is there professional learning teams teachers working with teachers to discuss students to determine what it is they need to know and be able to do and then

022figuring out when they don't know it what are they going to do about it okay thank you and then it looks like bill wants yeah just one other request i understand this is the ren star and i understand that the class cohort will not be the same class cohort when brooke's third grade reading is shown but i find it particularly helpful when we've done some of the casp here's our cohort of three years from fifth sixth seventh and eighth grade or whatever so as you develop that that helps us see the trends right and we would see okay let's compare the december 24 to the fall of 25 here's the blue from last year and here's the green for these generally these second graders in third grade i think that would also be Which way

023are they moving? Up, down, around? Last year, we let every site pick their windows, and that was a mistake. This year, we're standardizing our windows based on what Rinnstar recommends, and we'll continue to do that moving forward to give you exactly what you're asking for. We'll be able to compare side-by-side how we did grade level by grade level for each site. Grade level by grade level is one. but then the cohort is an advance to which I think once you have the data, you can map it out just to access the data and print it out. So that would be wonderful. Thank you. I had one other comment or just a comment that this second window wasn't opened until December, correct? And I'm just wondering that... To me, when I was teaching, it was helpful

024to me to have the data before conference time so that I could sit with the parents and say, you know, your child is reading at a 3.4 grade level. I'm wondering if you took that into consideration for when you opened the windows. I opened the windows based on what RENSTAR recommended to give us the most scientifically accurate predictions because that's what we were hoping for in terms of being able to compare. first administration to second administration to third administration i had so much pushback from the principals about everybody wanted a different for exactly those reasons but it became very apparent that if we want to be able to say with certainty this is our projected growth and this is what we predict because that's the next report you're going to get is based on this

025growth data what do they predict our scores will be at the end of the year we needed to have those windows exactly the number of days that red star recommends for instruction i can appreciate that i just know from personal experience that a young girl that was in the far red at the beginning of the year was actually into blue and so i was like okay i would have as a as a teacher i want to be able to tell the teacher i mean to tell the tell the parents that they're doing well and they didn't have that data available to them at that time and may have really hear the parents or maybe that's maybe that's what made it go up i don't know that they were in the red at the beginning but

026it's just i i know i know it's hard to get everybody to agree on on a window or when to open it up and and i can appreciate if this is what renstar recommends i was just thinking about it more from the teacher lens what would be useful to them right are there other comments from the board um are there comments from the public on this item nope okay thank you brian So next step is superintendent's report. All right. Thank you. So mine is going to be sports heavy because the end of season. And so first let's talk about football. We had a number of student athletes who made either first team or second team. Offense and defense. I think I'd like to highlight Hayden Anderson who is in that picture and going to UNLV

027on a scholarship. He was our player of the year. We also had a number of first team offensive players, Wyatt, Mason, Lorenzo. Again, I'm not going to read every single name. I think we should just point out that, you know, our athletic teams have really been kind of kicking butt. And football, football had a great year. They had a couple of tough losses that kept them out of the big tourney, which was probably a good thing, but great year overall. Brian, I'll let you do this one. Oh, who's that? So we had a fantastic cross country season this year and we had two runners make it to state. So we want to give a big congratulations to Xavier Surgeon who made it to state as a junior. And who's that? Is that Emily Williams who

028made it to state as a freshman? Not only does she make it to state as a freshman, she is the fastest freshman in the entire Redwood Empire. So all three leagues put together. Yeah. Okay. This is a silly question, but is she related to you? It's his daughter. I didn't know that. Yeah. I'm learning. She meant to follow up with, you didn't thank her mother. She did better than a mother. So I'm owning that side of the genetics. I'm going to move on before Brian gets in trouble. So quickly, right? Let's talk about volleyball. We had a number of student athletes who took home all league honors. Our co-MVP, Brielle Giley, senior, Luzner. Our volleyball team has been dominant, as you all know, for the past couple of years, and that didn't change this year.

029So look at all of our first team, second teamers. Pretty impressive. Other all league winners, girls golf. We had two second teamers, girls tennis. You can see we also had some good quality. victories I'll say there. And then on the right junior, Olivia Wright, she competed in the NCS and finished 37th out of 125. But I think what's most important is she shot a score 96, but that was her best score of the season by 12 shots. I don't know if any of you golf, but that's fairly ridiculous to have your best. Austin, I should let you do this one, huh? 12 shot improvement is pretty, pretty nuts. You know, on a different note, we had a break in a Maddie Washburn. The suspect was apprehended and this wasn't the first school that they had

030broken into. They were also over at my daughter's school, Rebley. So good job. Police department came in. We just had some minor cosmetic damage, but nothing was taken. This is way small. I'm sorry about that. Last week, there was a question just about Ed Services Department. So I just want to make sure I went through it. Historically, you know, again, this is really small, guys. I'm sorry. But I took it back to 1920. That was the year before I came. The Ed Services Department was those positions, the blue or certificated management and the kind of peach or certificated teachers. And then over the years, you could see the trend of what it is. What I did is, I took the budget numbers from right now and applied them to every year, because otherwise it doesn't

031make sense to compare apples to apples. We've reduced the budget in ed services pretty significantly by almost $400,000 over the past five years. So just because there was a question about the positions and the position that actually we're discussing tonight, director of curriculum and instruction and assessment, replacing student services. So if you see the top two, we always have both those certificated management positions and we still have those certificated management positions. The big change was the TOSA for ELD became a coordinator for ELD instead of a TOSA. That was the shift. And that's it. Have a wonderful holiday break. After the next couple of hours, we'll get through some business. any questions guys okay all right are there any comments from the public on this presentation no all right then in that case we're going

032to move on to staff association reports so this is item 3.6 ladies and gentlemen of the jury i'd like to submit exhibit a oh wait we're in the wrong place uh we had a vote last night it was almost split right down the middle between Sheila and myself for president of the union. We have almost 300 members and 64 of them showed up. That was kind of not really good, but it was better than what I expected. I won by a very slim margin. I told Sheila when she gave her speech that I would vote for her because her speech was passionate and said the things that needed to be said. And I said, similar things and it boils down to that we need to be a better team and a better listening group of

033e-board members I reached out to Sheila after I got home and I thought it was split right down the middle so half the people want something how people want the something else I asked her if she would become vice president so that we could work together and be one brain She was a very smart lady. She knows way more than I do about some of this stuff, but I have a really big mouth. So we're gonna be fine. We'll work out together. We were both negotiators, negotiated with these gentlemen for the last two contracts. There's a few things that we're gonna need to talk about. I know that we have two years to go, but there's a couple things that are pretty important right now. And that was a lot of why the vote was

034put down the middle, because... the rank and file felt that we weren't being honest enough or transparent enough as the board and i disagreed with that but sheila brought up some points that make sense and it looked apparently looked that way by a couple things that went on We're not going to be like that. We're going to be out there. We're going to be talking to people. We're going to ask them what they want, and we're going to come to you. And we're going to be amicable like we have been. But you know, sometimes my mouth can get a little carried away. She will be the one going, stop. Let me talk now. I'm going to kick you under the table. I'm looking forward to it. I got two years. We have two years together.

035We're going to try and make things good. We're going to try and be... Be nice. You be nice to us, we'll be nice to you. And it's a pleasure to meet all of you. I never introduced myself. My name is Ross McClure, by the way. I'm a state-certified school bus instructor. I've driven school buses for 23 years. I'm a jacketed steward, as well as Sheila. I'm a negotiator for the last two contracts. I was a teamster for 15 years, and that was a whole other animal, but it taught me a lot about how to deal with things and people. And I'm really looking forward to it. And we had to say. I do want to say, too, that we do have a new treasurer also and a new secretary. So a couple of strong women.

036So we're going to come in strong. I'm feeling really good about it. As I told you before, Ross is amazing. And I'm excited to work with him. I was glad to see the turnout last night at our meeting. Bill Adams showed up. It was wonderful. He set some tone there. I'd like to have more of you coming in and visiting and speaking with our people and engaging with us. And we will be showing up here. We will be here. So I'm just really excited to work with this new team. And I think we're going to really rock it. We're going to be firm but fair. Yes. Firm but fair. It's so nice to meet both of you. And congratulations, since this is the first time I'm meeting you. So congratulations. I'm overjoyed. Ross, I have

037to warn you. I was a Teamster, too, and I have a big mouth. And Stephanie and I, when we ran, she, though, she killed me. She got, like, way more votes. So you're doing good. So Jeremy, though, he's used to having one person with a big mouth and one person that's smart. And so welcome to the team. Appreciate it. Good evening. Susanna Pfeffer, WDEA. CSEA, we want you to know that WDEA stands with you. Yes, we're 500 strong. We can make things happen. So I wanted to wish you happy holidays. Almost winter break. So we're looking, teachers are so excited to be going home for a few days. but in your board packet you'll see that you have our sunshine letter it was submitted October 28 so a little late and we are still waiting

038to hear the district's reopeners and we're eager to get started I wanted to mention that and I did give Jeremy a penalty flag so watch out he knows how to use it and We're going to start using those for some nonverbal communication. Anyway, that's all I wanted to say. We'd like to get started on negotiations and we are eagerly waiting. All right. Any comments from the board on this? No. Even the staff associate? I mean, what trustees runs or? No, staff. Congratulations to you both. It's nice to have you here. It's nice to have both unions here. And thank you for stepping up. as I mentioned last night for leadership I'm a strong believer that strong labor and strong management together makes for a better district and I think we've had the benefit of that

039for years and I look forward to that continuing so again thank you for stepping into the roles nobody yelled at anybody it was good all right any comments from the public on these staff association reports all right so seeing that there's none we're going to go on to board of trustees report i got one so let's go to rich and then okay i'm this is another one of those cool moments i don't know pete if you're i'd send you a text or an email or whatever i don't know if you can pull it up the uh it was it was a i sent you a text that i sent you an email it had a picture in it and so i don't know if you can pull this up anyhow so a lot of you

040guys know i i coached wrestling team for many many years and One of the cool things about Facebook, actually the only cool thing about Facebook, is that you can get friends with all these people and then you can keep track of how all your kids are doing. And like most coaches, once you coach a kid, they're always your kid. And then you just kind of watch them as they go along. So anyhow, I saw that Eric Greenlee, one of my wrestlers from way back when, he, tough wrestler, really, yeah, that's it. He really had a hard time. in school, smart kid, just he hadn't found the thing that really made him excited to study academically. And so anyhow, so Eric, there's a picture of Eric right here. He just graduated from Arizona State University. Eric,

041right after graduation from high school, his mom, super sweet lady, she passed away when he was younger. untimely passing. And so anyhow, he went in the military and he became a Marine at the same time as say his partner, wrestling partner, Alexander Lee also went into the military. He went and got accepted in the Naval Academy. He's one of those, you know, genius like. If there's a 5.0, he was getting close to it. Super, super smart. Yeah. And so he, Naval Academy, super good grades, flies helicopters, still became a commander. Actually, where's my little phone? Anyhow, so Alexander went one route, Naval Academy, and has become a commander. Eric was in the Marines, and he went in and went up the enlisted route. And after a while, discovered that he had skills and that he

042was good at a lot of things, but he didn't have the educational paper and background to kind of prove to the people that he actually had it. So, and he was nervous about school because school hadn't been a, the academic part of it hadn't been a thing that he had had great success with, but he kind of started, he went back to school. He graduated from Windsor in 2012. And so this is what, 12 years later. He starts going to school and started taking little classes and having some little successes and little things he was interested in. Anyhow, long story short, kept going, kept going, double measured. And he graduated, just graduated from Arizona State. I'm super, super happy. The route that Eric took is the same route my dad took. My dad, right out

043of high school, went in the Marines. And he went that way. And then after he met my mom, went to Sonoma State and just started taking. basically high school all over again in college and worked his way up and then got an education that'd be you know when he retired was the superintendent schools and so anyhow eric and i so i texted and i'm trying to remember because i want to say it right so he is uh now going to be uh let's see where is it oh hold on oh that was to i'm sorry pete lee There it is. So he's now he's going to be an officer in the Marine Corps. So the he's switching up from enlisted. Now he's going to be an officer in the Marine Corps. And so anyhow, I'm

044just super proud because I remember Eric struggling just to make the 2.0. And if it wasn't for and Eric's one of those kids that I point to that. If it wasn't for extracurricular things in our schools, he would have washed out. And yet, to do the things that he wanted to do, you had to have a minimum grade point average. So he would force himself to do what he needed to, to barely make it, and to get grades in things that he had no interest in at the time. And yet... stick to it-ness. He's a gritty kid. I'm not surprised at all that he stuck with it once he found the thing that was really driving him. And so anyhow, I'm going to stop at this point. I just want you guys to know that

045these kind of little things are so rewarding. So it's just a reminder that all you teachers and everybody that does everything you have these little things you do with kids You have no idea when and how much of a difference you can make and how it changes their life and the direction it goes and so, you know, I'm really proud Eric and I know his mom's super proud of him too. And anyhow, just another one of our Windsor alumni that's out there in the world doing great things and represent and bring an honor to our town our school and and I'm proud of Eric and just wanted to share that. Thank you for sharing. All right, Stephanie. Okay. So I was thinking about what I wanted to talk about in our board update and we

046had an election too recently and we our town or our district which extends a little bit beyond our town boundaries reelected our two board members who were up and they are being sworn in again tonight, which is very exciting. So I wanted to talk a little bit about teamwork on our board and kind of like my philosophy and hopefully this will be the last time I don't talk about kids. had a board meeting but I think teamwork does make the dream work when it comes to being on a board and I feel like we have a good board so I just want to talk a little bit about kind of a process that was in place when I was elected and kind of how I've seen it and how I kind of understand it because

047for leadership within the board we don't really have a set protocol right we kind of informally have this rotation that we've done starting before I don't know when it started I know it was in place when I joined the board and the way it kind of works is that based on when you're elected you we so we rotate the president and vice president positions right so normally um everybody gets a chance to serve as president and vice president. And it rotates kind of based on when you were elected. And the way I've seen it be done is based on kind of either your seniority, if you were in a non-contested election, or based on your number of votes that you got. And I just want to plug this process as something that I think is...

048really helpful because I like to think about kind of like the alternative of if we didn't have this and what I see on a lot of boards in other places is kind of like people forming alliances and like you end up having like kind of one person who ends up being the leader for a really long time And I like I kind of like the predictability and the like just we assume that everyone on our board is capable of being a leader and That they're gonna get a turn and it does take a while to cycle through which I think can be frustrating Especially if you have to wait for a long time so I have so it's tricky right because it's like We have to balance you know is it fair to have to

049wait for a long time versus do we want to make sure everyone gets a turn and do we want everyone to have that opportunity so I just wanted to plug kind of the the benefits of the rotation which is predictability equal distribution of work fairness I think Like I I just like the fact that we don't even really have to think about it. We kind of know Okay, this person's up. It's your turn like we have faith in you go forward and serve So I wanted to talk about that And obviously we can do whatever we want as a board. So this is just my perspective and kind of like What I think has made our board pretty functional over the last years even before I had the privilege of joining and I think another

050like happy coincidence of the rotation is that We have two females serving in leadership roles. We have two Latinas serving in leadership roles this year. Just happy coincidence We have our president, Malinalli, and we have myself as vice president. And that just kind of worked out. And I don't know if that would have happened if we didn't have this rotation. So I think sometimes things just happen in a way that is really interesting and really cool. So that's, I think, all I have to say about that. Just something to think about. And there are five of us, we all are type A, we all kind of want to be in charge, I think, probably. And one way that we've found that kind of works. That's really interesting Stephanie. I really appreciate your comments. I think

051that they were very well stated and I agree I really like the idea of the rotation and this idea that everyone gets a turn right and that everyone steps up to the plate and does their fair share of work, right? I do want to say it's very important to me that I identify as a Chicana. That's really important to me because I just want to say that I was born in Mexico, but I was raised right here in Windsor. So I really identify with the Chicano experience. So that's really important to me because for me, that's different than being called a Latina. A Latina to me is something else, right? So for me, I have a very specific origin story, I guess you can say. um so i just wanted to call that out but

052i i do appreciate your words and i like the fact that you also uh took your time to call out female leadership you know represented on this board which i think also brings diversity of um points of view right um so with that said i i do want to share that these last couple of months have been extremely busy for me um there's been a lot going on i really had the chance to uh visit um the uh English language learner parents at Cali Calmeca and I had a very interesting conversation there. They had a lot of questions and I think my favorite question that I was asked when I was there is I love that they asked. how can I be more involved? You know, how can I show up to the meetings or

053what do I need to do to be more involved? So we had a conversation about that. And I explained a little bit about how our board meetings work and that it is important to show up. So that was fun. And then the other item that kept me very busy is I had the honor of lecturing to very close to 400 high school freshmen, which was so much fun because what I did is I took a lot of my last hundreds of kids joined. at sonoma state university um so so fun times um so with all of that said that's all i have to report and i was just wondering if there's anything from paul or bill yeah paul did you have anything yeah i i was going to talk more because i think we grow

054numb when we don't mention it as you know there was another school shooting on monday it it turns out almost 12 years to the day since sandy hook in connecticut where 26 little children were killed i think a couple adults We just got to do better we have people coming to our school district because they consider it safer I think it is in some ways But I wonder if we could just take a moment of silence and then I have a happy thing. I want to read Thank you Tuesday evening all the board and the DO staff got an email we get a lot of emails um and we appreciate them and please keep sending them this one started out thank you for all you do and i am editing it to remove 14 different

055staff names because that would arguably let you know what student it might be but it says to the board of trustees mr decker and staff in this season of thankfulness and counting our blessings i want to express my gratitude to the board and district administration for valuing teachers I understand I may have a bias as I myself am a WUSD employee. However, I am writing as a parent of two WUSD students. While I have had the pleasure of working with many fantastic colleagues in my years with WSD, I have only had the honor of having a few as my children's teachers and instructional assistants to date. Then there are 14 names in the email. Each of these individuals have been integral to my daughter's educational, social, emotional, and physical development. Their father and I couldn't

056be happier with the amazing teachers our girls have had, and we thank the board and administration for all the support they give educators. Furthermore, we'd like to thank you for your commitment to education and all Windsor students. I hope you and your families enjoy this beautiful season. What a nice way to close out the fall semester. Happy holidays, everybody. Yeah, that's a great letter. Thank you for sharing that. And Paul. Nothing? Are student board members anything? I know you gave your report, but do you have anything else personal you want to share now? Okay. It's the government. All right. Any comments from the public? No. Okay. So seeing none, we're just going to move on to the approval of minutes from November the 21st, 2024. I'll move approval of those minutes. Thank you, Bill. Is

057there a second? I'll second. thank you Stephanie all in favor aye aye okay thank you all right um so next up we have Pete Sullivan with staff recognitions and this is item 3.9 good evening how's everybody doing uh so before uh you know I don't know I just might crush my look I got something going on here Bill but I appreciate the offer I want to take a moment before we start staff recognitions to celebrate and recognize the commitment, the excellence, and the... the leadership of the people who are right in this room before i celebrate the two awesome staff members at cali so joining us tonight we have leadership both from wdea and csea and then of course our board and student board members and so i'm going to spread a little holiday cheer

058if you'll indulge me i'm going to come around and give you each a little something thank you all very much for everything that you do christmas goodies Wait, but you're going the wrong direction. Thank you so much. That'll be good for my hot chocolate. All right. So the the on-site celebration for our. Cali staff members is going to be held on January 15th at 210. I sent the invite to Jen today, and she is, look at us, already organized. Fantastic. At that celebration, we will be celebrating both the certificated and a classified staff member, and our certificated for the month of December will be Aida Herrera Keene, and everything in here is understated because she is phenomenal. Aida Herrera embodies the heart and soul of Cali. She has created a warm, magical, and special classroom

059environment for her TK students where every child feels welcomed and cherished. It is joy for teaching, radiates like a bright rainbow filled with glitter and sparkle of her vibrant personality. Now, I wouldn't typically agree with something like that, but unless you've been in her room, you haven't experienced the sparkle and rainbow because it's there. Her creativity, passion, and dedication make her classroom a place where young learners thrive and grow. Beyond her classroom, Aida is a true leader and collaborator. Her dedication to the PLC process has strengthened teamwork and instructional practices across our school. She has been a constant source of guidance and encouragement for many new teachers. She's got two. She's mentoring two people this year. Her commitment to students and colleagues make her an outstanding educator and an irreplaceable part of our Cali family.

060And I think I got her on the hook for another year. Yes. Fantastic. Keep reeling her in. Our classified is Gerardo Lopez. Gerardo is a student advisor. He's new as of the beginning of this year, I believe. No, he started last year. Thank you. He's amazing. I remember reading his application and calling up Patricia and saying, you got to get this guy. Gerardo has been selected as Cali-Calmica's outstanding classified employee for his unwavering dedication to our school's mission, creating a safe and supportive environment where students can learn and thrive. Gerardo's commitment shines through his ability to build positive, meaningful relationships with students across all grade levels, ensuring they feel valued and supported. His proactive approach and willingness to take on additional responsibilities demonstrate his exceptional dedication to both students and staff. As an integral member

061of the Cali team, Gerardo consistently goes above and beyond to support teachers and contribute to our school success. His initiative positivity radiate throughout the campus, strengthening our school culture and fostering a sense of community. Gerardo is not only a dependable team member, but also a true role model for the values we strive to instill in our students. He is an incredible asset to Cali CalMacac and is a shining example of what makes our school special. And I'm trying to steal them and make them a teacher, just so you know. Thank you all very much. Any comments from the public? Okay, great. So we're now going to move on to Oath of Office. Very exciting. You guys get to swear. Yeah. So if I may, before you do this out of office, I just really want

062to thank everyone on the board for giving me this opportunity to be the president for this past year. To be honest, I'm not a person that loves the limelight. So this was, you know, really getting out of my own comfort zone. uh you know to do this but i really felt that every single person on this board including superintendent decker and also assistant superintendent williams and pete sullivan i feel that everyone encouraged me along the way and helped me to problem solve when you know that there were some challenges and just really understanding you know our procedures even more you know intimately than i i knew them so i just want to thank you all for your encouragement i so appreciate all of you for you know just helping me to that this was possible.

063You ready to be sworn in? Yeah. Okay, we'll start with Malinalli. Can I do them both? Sorry, I didn't see that. Yes. Do we do them individually though, Jen? Okay, so let's go with Malinalli first. Stand up and raise. Please raise your right hand and read the following oath. Do you have it in front of you? Yes. Okay. So I, Malinalli Lopez, I, Malinalli Lopez, do solemnly swear or affirm, do solemnly swear or affirm, that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States, that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States, and the Constitution of the State of California. And the Constitution of the State of California. Against all enemies, foreign and domestic. Against all enemies, foreign and domestic. That I will bear true faith and allegiance. That I

064will bear true faith and allegiance. To the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California. To the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California. That I take this obligation freely. That I take this obligation freely. Without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion. Without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion. And that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter. And that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter. Bell Adams, will you please stand and raise your right hand. Read the following oath. Thank you, Malinalli. I, Bill Adams, do solemnly swear or affirm that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of

065the State of California against all enemies, foreign and domestic, that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California. That I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California. That I take this obligation freely. That I take this obligation freely. Without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion. Without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion. And that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter. And that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter. Congratulations. okay so thank you so much for that i'm sorry do you want mel and ellen i'll come see you afterwards

066so we sign in the right place and it gets filled in properly okay thank you okay thank you um so now we're going to move on to school board organization and I do not recall the precise way that you know we started this before but perhaps some of you like Bill or Stephanie if you have any other sort of knowledge of past traditions of how this you know began then that would be great I think we do nominations I think typically someone on the board nominates someone for the roles like as they're stated and we typically do vice president first then president and then we'll go through our whole list of like different roles um and you run it through the president election and then we flip seats what's after that happens after new president

067is chosen i say okay all right so um i would like to say that I think when I was in my second year of my term or early on in my term that's when I you know was nominated to be vice president I just remember feeling like I was still very new almost too new you know to really be in that role but I once again appreciate the encouragement so with that said I would like to nominate our newest board member and that is Paul Cagorno just because I would like for Paul to have the same opportunity that I had early on in my own term and I because I really believe strongly in following our rotation and I I kind of like value that above all else and I was vice president this year

068Rich and Paul and I ran together Rich was second Paul was third I am nominating Rich Carnation because I want to stick with I personally want to stick with that I don't know how the rest of the board feels but I would hope that the next year that it would be paul um so that's my position the problem with that is is if we go ahead and elect rich i won't have a chance to be president unless i run again and so and rich won't have a chance to be president he's already been president during this term so he's serving his second term yeah and i know it's it's tough because it's someone not getting something during one term and it it is not fair but i i feel like I'll stop talking, but I

069think you heard my patience already. So if I might, Madam President, I think we have two nominations. Yes. And it might be appropriate to take a vote. Okay. Unless there is someone comments or something. Do we just vote on one of them at a time? I think probably voting in the order they were nominated. Okay. That sounds fair. All right. So I'm all in favor of Polk-Gorno. Did Jen do it or how? Yeah. okay so i'll just uh repeat myself then then uh i guess i would make the motion uh to nominate paul cagorno all in favor aye aye aye okay so that's two and i made the motion to nominate rich carnation all in favor so that looks like three yes yeah okay um so uh next up is there a nomination for the

070election of president i'd like to nominate uh stephanie ahmad to be the president for this next year school board uh any other nominations no uh okay so let's uh take a vote on this one so all in favor of stephanie ahmad uh becoming president please say aye aye aye aye aye all right so i believe that that concludes this voting process so i think yep so you move move name plates and the prizes come and this is great yeah i think plates would be easier these i think these are new chairs right they're kind of bulky yeah i do feel like i'm cinderella losing my shoe over here Thank you. Thank you so much. Thank you. Can I open it? Kind of a small game. Is it correct on the end? Oh, this is so

071nice. What's that? I don't want to see it. Oh. Would you tape them up? Sorry. I feel like I keep hitting you. New chairs or bigger chairs or something. Thank you. Congratulations. Okay. I think I'm taking it from here, yeah? Is that how it's going? Yes. Okay. Sounds good. Congratulations to both Stephanie and Rich. Yep. Thank you. And thank you, Mal and Ollie. Yeah, no, thank you. Thanks, all of you. we're moving on to 5.3 which is our board meeting dates for 2025. we have in the item a submission a submission of dates for the board meeting addendas well sorry i'm reading the file name but this is for 2025. um so i think we need to review and approve are there any questions about the dates please check it to see if there's any

072i believe there's one wrong date in there um it says march 14th and that's a friday yes good catch let's see actually i remember in march we talked about it before i'm trying to figure out because i think we moved it that is because i had a conflict right uh it's in my calendar it's the 13th so i think that's just a typo yeah i think you got it can we make that change to the 13th yes i'm going that third the 19th yeah so the 13th the second it's march 13th then right yeah that's what i was looking at so march 13th Some talk last year about the clashes that we had in May and August with the town green. That's right. You wanted to move those to a different date, right? It can't

073be another Thursday because they still have the same clashes. So we would move it to a different time. To a Tuesday, right? If I might, Tuesdays is the movies. So maybe you could find out when the Planning Commission and the Council are in here. Do they? Okay. Do we prefer a Tuesday or a Wednesday? Do we care? I personally don't mind. It's just getting here a little earlier and figuring out parking, but I don't, but if anyone wants to attend the events, I could totally understand us wanting to move them. I would like to shift those summer meetings to something other than Thursday and maybe just fight because it's really going back and asking when, when the town's in this room and then we'll know what's there available. And maybe we can talk about that

074in January. Okay. So actually I need to intervene here because I do have a conflict. Well, actually, you're only talking about in the summer, right, Bill? Not spring. Which month? Are these June and August? May and August. May, June, and August? Or is it May? Actually, the two June meetings. I see. That actually would be fine. That would work. So as long as it's after May, because I just checked, and from January to May, I teach an evening class on Tuesdays. So it just couldn't be in that period. But any time after May, it would be fine. Yes. Yes. so i'll we'll put those back from the agenda for january yes so you're going to shoot us out a new proposal okay so we will correct the typo in march and jen is going to

075send us new dates for may june and august and with those changes do i have a motion to approve the she's going to give us a new one in january okay so we don't even have to approve this we're tabling it are we tabling this or do we need to do something I'm unsure if I'm right or not, but sometimes I remember things from years ago. So I feel like at this meeting, we're supposed to set our annual calendar because once those dates are set, there are certain things that have to be done based on the setting of the annual calendar. I'm unsure if it's required that that annual calendar is set today or if we can modify it. Again, sometimes I remember things that I don't know where they come from. So I feel

076like we're supposed to set our dates today. Okay. So how about if we set them? with the motion that we're going to in january meeting we're going to adjust the for those summers things because we can always adjust our meetings with a month notice right anyway well you know less than that certain regular meetings have to be set because they have to budget and lcap and you can't you can't approve those things at any special meetings or make any changes so that's that's what's stuck in my head but rich i don't know the law specifically so austin do you know what meetings are the ones where you have to do your Dropped in. Yeah, I know which meetings are the ones which ones are they? So what the one in March has to be before

077March 15th, so it has to be before that one's good Yep, that one's fine. That 13th. So we're good there. There has to be two two in June. Those are good Is any so but those doesn't matter the days, but I think we should set the days now versus coming back I think that we should get them set and figure it out while we're here So do we want to just do, well, we don't know though, if Tuesday night's available. But can we, we know Wednesday, there's nothing happening in here. Correct. Worst case scenario, if we set the meeting, we could always do it over in our conference room. Remind me, is it May and June and August or June and August? Okay. So let's look at a calendar and let's figure that. And I

078could be making this way more than it's supposed to be, but I feel like this is a thing. I just don't remember why. Okay. So June 10th and June 24th. Yeah, those are the two dates. Let's update. So we've got the correction to March 13th, change to June 10th, change to June 24th. And then in August, we need to do those as well. Yeah. So the 19th and the 5th. Oh, wait, I don't. Do we have that one? Oh, sorry. I misspoke. Just the 19th. Okay, so we're making those changes. I'll make the motion. Do I have a second? Yeah, I'll second. Hey, Jen, if you can reach out to the town, because maybe they can move something around if there's a conflict. Worst case scenario, we can always meet over. We can meet at

079the middle school or even at the conference. And I'll find out if I'm making a bigger deal out of this than it's necessary. I'll find out. I know there's something. Okay. All in favor? i just want to say jen you did such a great job with those cones though that yeah you did he really did i i i think they're just stuck to the bottom of my truck I think it was Rich, or was it Bill? Yeah, it was Rich King. It was Rich. Could we also, Madam President, address, I know we talked about a workshop that has moved to January 14th on the bond, one with native education issues in February, and then a third one sounds like we're looking for SPED, and I think maybe we talk about those in January, but our

080meeting is before the 14th, right, of January? our meeting is on the 20th yes yes 14th or something i believe sure and march special thank you okay so we did have to set it okay great so and we can we can cover those on future agenda items at the end of the meeting too if we forget anything right now okay Okay. Jane, could you send us out the thing for the 14th again? Because it's not on my... It's not, but it isn't confirmed yet. Oh, that's why it's not on here. Oh, okay. It isn't confirmed yet. So I'm still waiting for Greg Isen to come back with that. Got it. Okay. All right. Thank you. I feel better. okay 5.4 selection of board representatives and alternate representative to the county committee on school district organization

081this says isn't actually listed in our document where we have everyone I don't think do we who is currently which one it's rich okay this came this came after the fact there was a request for I believe believe for trustees and so there was a seat that opened up if i remember correctly and then rich applied that's why it's separate got it and then are we it's it's a it's a weird situation sometimes they ask us to just vote on other people get again I'm waiting for the one where they say, okay, now you're going to get together and then let's talk about the district boundaries and all that stuff and everything. But that meeting seems to be elusively, I've been trying to get into that meeting now for four years. And anyhow, it's going

082to happen eventually, I hope. Okay. So are we taking action on that item? Okay. Do we have a nomination for Rich to continue? I'd like to continue that one. Which one is it, Rich? It's the committee. county community and school district representatives item by full district organization i dominate rich to continue i'll second and if you have ways that you can help go set their agenda let's or maybe you can write a letter or something to say look let's put these boundaries that whatever you know the issues we've talked about that we'd like to address these things i'd like to have a fulsome out in the open consolidation conversation and i know the former superintendent and former county superintendent would like to lead that so maybe we can help drive a little bit more momentum

083in that agenda yeah because i mean one of the things that has been talked about for 30 something years is getting that little part of windsor that's our town and the people that are windsor residents and they are in the san jose school district and so i'd like to Correct that. We have other areas where every kid in a certain area, all inter-district transfer into Windsor. And they're like, why aren't we in the Windsor district? So anyhow, there's some cleaning up. And now that Santa Rosa is in the turmoil that they are, this is a wonderful time to straighten some things out. I think that's why. I can reach out. I can reach out. They're doing two studies, as you probably already know, West County as well as Santa Rosa. And I can reach out

084to see if they'd be willing to fund another one. Okay, so we have a motion from Bill and a nomination, a second from Malinalli. All in favor? Aye. 5.5. We're just going to go down the list. And we have a, I'll just show you, we have this document in front of us that shows like all of the subcommittees and sites that we're representatives to. So that's what we're going through right now on our end is selecting who's going to be representative to what for this coming calendar year. so policy subcommittee I'm happy to stay on but also happy if anyone else wants to come on to that committee and then we have facilities also under this item 5.5 I think we're doing the yeah the policy and facilities subcommittees right now so if anyone would

085like to be on either well facilities you all decide I'd like to stay on that if you guys want to stay on too Would anyone like to be on policy who is not or I will stay? Are you interested or should I stay on that one? No, I think I've done that one before. So I wanted to do different committees this time. Okay. Sounds good. So I'll make the motion for us to keep our policy and facilities subcommittee assignments the same going forward. Second. all in favor aye aye aye okay now we're on to 5.6 which is all of our school site and community liaison roles maybe we go through community liaison roles first and then we can move on to school sites okay i'll take my cheat sheet and i'm flexible although i think

086maybe i because Is the town or the town representatives like the president and the vice president? Is that how we do that? Is that why I'm on it for? That's that's what we've traditionally done. Yes, that's what we've done. It doesn't have to be that, but that's traditionally what we've done. I'd be willing to stand in for Rich then at the as the boosters if he's going to go into the town council. I'm good with going to town. Now we usually have two. Right. So does somebody else want to also do the town? Well, I think we've traditionally done president and vice president. Oh, there you go. I'm happy to do Windsor Arts now. Okay, good. And I'll stay on WE Foundation. Okay. All right, school sites. For school sites, I was interested in doing

087Cali because I've never been the liaison for Cali. Sounds good. And I've also never been the liaison for Windsor Oaks. Okay. I'd like to do Windsor Middle School, but I haven't done that. Paul's going to Windsor Middle School. I'm good with the high school. I'm always there anyway. I don't bother them too bad. I'm also happy to stay on D-Legs just because I feel like it makes sense. Put Mally for D-Legs. We don't yet. Well, unless you want to. I can stay with. You want to stay with Maddie? Okay. I will do Brooks if that's okay. Does Bill have one? I'll do. Yeah, I'll stay with Maddie and continue. And then I can do both. I need a school. so that would leave big picture learning picture learning do you want to stay with big

088picture learning bill i'll take the high school from rich we just cut a deal oh you did card trading or something what just happened he used the senior card so are you it's because you're older by like two minutes or something okay so you're rich is going to go big picture learning and sokova between the big picture okay so rich is taking a big picture big papa goes to big picture and Bill is taking Windsor High and LCAP do you want to stay on LCAP yeah okay perfect and then North of Arata ad hoc committee I think is staying or am I switching in to one of these because I think you should switch in on that okay Bill is that okay are you in rich yeah that's fine okay anything related to our other

089development i think we should because it's the same concept i almost wonder if that should just be switched to like development ad hoc development right it's they're two different things they are so why would you Windsor creek and just do it should we do property ad hoc because i i'm not there's refusal and that's why oh that's true that's fine let's just add another one okay call Windsor creek will be stepping up okay Stephanie and Bill. And as a practical matter, I think for Paul and Rich, there's a liaison, and except for the one recusal, probably we come back, I think, to the facilities committee for using those standing committees. We have these ad hocs, and then they can come and get more conversations about it. It becomes just some recommendation. um stephanie didn't ask

090weren't you the liaison to the tribe i don't know that we had an official um committee or liaison that we've listed out but i have kind of worked on native american related issues i i think leading into that workshop we're doing in february that would be a recognition of our tribal partners and their you know we have the indian education whatever that group is called red bud resource but yeah i i would i would be okay having uh maybe community liaison towards the top and like an indian ed community liaison i think that's the appropriate position you want two on there because i would i'd like to do that that would be great i think yeah because they have a lot of stuff going on i like the education part of it because there's a

091regional there's a regional piece too that our our folks are leaders for the county-wide and leaders yeah go for okay for the lack of not knowing how to title this why don't you guys find out what proper I think Indian Ed is okay because that's what our yeah but we'll do that as a placeholder for now we'll double check and make sure yeah and then yeah and so Paul and I will do that okay great I think that covers everything so thank you audience for letting us sort that out do I have a motion on our assignments I'll make a motion second all in favor aye aye okay that take a break for me that concludes the reorganization we're going to take three minutes to regroup and then we'll get back and we'll get to

092the meeting and thanks for those who have been waiting Jen do you need this she wrote it all down okay calling the meeting back to order we are going to move on to consent action items rich are you prepared as vice president to do consent Great because you are on call. I can be I mean, okay, so we're moving to 6.1. Hold on a second We have 6.1 through 6.7. I'm giving you a minute. I know that rich you also wanted to discuss an item So why don't we I do first off? I'm sorry. I'm joking a little bit not choking. I'm a Shameless plug but over Oliver's these caramel chocolate thingamajigs are like crazy expensive And half of it just about killed me. So it wasn't the consent items. It was this is my

093dinner. So anyhow, so for consent items, I'd like to 6.2. I'd like to make a motion that we approve 6.1 through 6.7. I would like to have a small discussion on 6.2. okay i'll second and we can discuss thank you okay on 6.2 the uh the question i had is this is something we did before it's a little bit of a reimbursement type of an arrangement with marin but last time this came through um i asked if we could get a copy of the curriculum just like books and everything else that we kind of go through um this talks about integrating things into our third, fourth and fifth grade class. And so I just want a copy of that. We can reach out and get that. I'm sure we can. I sent an email tonight

094requesting. Great. Thank you. So we can follow up with that later. But that was that was it. I just wanted to follow up on that. That way we can kind of see what we're I'm glad they're reimbursing us. Now, I just want to see what we're supposed to. Nothing's for free in the education world. I come to find out. So if they're reimbursing us, they obviously wants to do something with it. and i just want to find out something that we all want to actually do so that was it any other discussion yeah bill just for point of clarification is there any urgency to get this matter approved now or can we revisit in january without any problem with our three staff members that are in this program the program has started okay and so

095our approval will Give us the reimbursement because they've already started taking the release time associated with the MOU So if we don't approve we'll eat that cost so there is some cost on the other end Let me ask you a slightly different way Is this an out-of-pocket payment that these three teachers have done or is this the district is paying for it? Okay, I'm all right waiting till January then I didn't want them to be carrying this load if they'd advanced money to do it No, it's so they said they put in for a release right which is based on this MOU okay and the district paid to participate and we're going to get reimbursed yes no money correct thank you I do have a question I was looking at item 6.6 and then this

096is more out of curiosity but Brian I was wondering is there a specific position that the internship participation is connected to this is item 6.6 I was looking back at our high school principal For the Alliance Medical Internship, the 16-year-olds can participate? So it's just a MOU. So right now, we would need to sign this in order for 16-year-olds to be able to do internships with Alliance Medical. Yes, and I was just curious if there's like a range of positions or there's like, for example, is it like clerical or, you know, what exactly are they doing? Mostly shadowing. But I don't know if we know Malinalli. I mean, it could be any position, right? I think it's just so that we can get students in there. Okay. I just want to say I believe that

097this is really, really fantastic. So I'm very excited for this. All right. Okay. So with that, all those in favor of approving 6.1 through 6.7, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Hearing none, motion passes. 5-2-5-0-2. 2-5-0. Hike. okay and now we are moving to item seven can i give a little shout out oh i forgot i'm sorry because we just approved our personnel assignment order i'm sorry i forgot jerry i just want to give a shout out to our new director So just Annette's been with us for a long time. I think this is going to be a great position for her to move into, Director of Curriculum, Instruction, and Assessment. And proud of you, Annette. So really excited to have you get started doing this work, although you're already kind of doing some of it. So

098very excited. Congratulations. Yes. We'll see you here next meeting the entire time, but go to dinner tonight. Congratulations, Annette. Yeah, congratulations. We're so proud of you. Can't wait to get started. Okay. Thank you for doing that, Jeremy. Okay. Because I'm looking at the Cali team back there, and I know that you're waiting to do item 7.1, so I got distracted. But we're going to talk about Los Chicos Fantasmas, Ghost Boys. I believe everyone on the board has read the book. And I think there will be robust discussion. So just to, so everyone's. kind of on notice i think we're gonna have a good conversation um we'll let you present and then i think the board will have some questions some discussion we'll go out for public comment and then we'll come back and and close

099it out so take it away anybody read it in spanish yes that's what we'll do awesome yeah just yeah ours looks almost the same great well can we go to the next slide excellent So why ghost boys? Oh, goodness gracious. I'm used to just talking loud to people. I guess we'll just take turns doing bullet points here. We tried to make it really concise to help make it be a little bit of a shorter conversation. We think that with this book, students are going to connect better with characters that look like them and maybe live in places that are similar to them. Last year, we read Bridge to Arbitria, and they were not connecting with white kids in the country from the 70s. In this book, right, Steph Curry's on a poster on the wall.

100We think they're going to connect and talk. Our next point is students are already talking about these about race and other issues in their daily life and then this is a way for us to guide those conversations in an environment where we as teachers are able to support them. comment on that one even in fifth grade um we've already this year had conversations about race they're saying racist comments without realizing they're racist and we feel like guiding the conversation is going to help them understand what that looks like what that means thank you and then regardless of their perspectives this book will get kids talking about their reading in a more objective way I don't know if you guys know very many fifth graders and talk to them about their literature, but sometimes it can

101be like pulling teeth. So we're excited to give them something they want to discuss. I feel like even to add to that, finding books in Spanish that they can relate to because they might not have a hard time finding a book in English that they can identify themselves with. But Spanish literature is so challenging for fifth grade and for it to be at their level as well. Hi. The last bullet point is about perspective. This book offers a myriad perspective from the central theme of the story, told from many different sides. It is definitely a fifth-grade standard. This offers an omniscient perspective, the perspective of a person who's passed away, and the clarity and reflection that that offers. It's a unique perspective that's offered in this book. I've never seen it handled in a better

102way before. So as you've read it, you already know some of these possible issues are going to be, can we just read them all? We don't, okay. Racism, specifically systemic racism, economic inequality, police brutality, bullying, weapons, drugs, and death, which sounds really heavy at fifth grade, but it's treated in such a, I think a sensitive way in the book and the way we can talk about it by guiding the conversations will be much more sensitive than them just talking on the playground about what they heard in the news. Do you want to start this one? Yeah. Some ways that we plan to approach these issues previously mentioned are to keep our personal opinions private and stay impartial and factual when discussing the book with our students. Also, should we just do two at a time

103or something? And also making sure that we engage in parent notification of upcoming sensitive topics and even providing resources for them to discuss at home beforehand or during. Sorry, I did three. That's fine. We want to guide classroom discussions, as previously mentioned, leaving conversations open and flexible and providing a safe space for children to, for the students to ask their questions. We want to provide prompts to get the students thinking but not scared, like critical thinking, analytical thinking is so important for their all everyday lives. So we want to really encourage that and I think this book is a great way of doing so. and use classwork based on the resources that are provided from the author. Where did you finish? Sorry. Great. We also want to approach the racism conversations by addressing the system

104rather than the individuals within the system. I think we're clear. And we also want to include counselors and have them available as much as possible in admin participation. And as appropriate, not too in-depth talk about Andy Lopez. Just this is something that has happened in our community just 10 years ago in Santa Rosa. And it does happen. Right. And so we can leave the conversation about, you know, oh, if you have a toy gun and you're walking around, you don't want to be doing that out and about in town. Right. Oh, by the way, hello, we're the fifth grade team from Cali Comeca Language Academy. Totally skipped over that part. I'm Courtney Perez. I just realized that afterwards. I'm Sophia Tzue. I'm Adelina Sanchez. Hi, I'm Mr. G. So I feel like now questions that

105you have, concerns that you may have, things that we can hopefully answer to assuage any concerns you have. Well, I guess I'll go first. I read the book, loved the book. I do have concerns about 10-year-olds reading this book. The main character is 12 years old. I feel these are very mature topics. They are topics that I feel personally are more appropriate for 7th grade and above. I taught 5th grade. I know what 5th graders are like. And I'm just trying to think if I was trying to teach this to my fifth graders, I don't think I could. I don't think I could do it. They're not mature enough, in my opinion, to handle this kind of material. Can I ask what year you taught fifth grade? What year I taught? Just like curious because

106times. It was about. Social media now. It was about 10 years ago. A little intense. May I jump in just from a student perspective and also from a person of color? You're teaching this in classrooms, but for some students, this is the reality. They have to live like this. So being able to introduce this in an environment where it's a guided conversation is extremely important for these students to feel heard and understood and that they don't have to feel alone or isolated in whatever discrimination they face in their everyday life. I don't disagree with anything you're saying. I just think they're too young at 10 years old. In seventh grade, the reading level of the book is too easy. that's another be that as it may for me the topic is just it's it's too

107mature a topic for them I just had a question if the book is part of the curriculum could have like could a parent sign a permission slip whether or not they want their kid to read the book my understanding is if it's approved as curriculum they can't opt out of the book so it would be everybody does this book or nobody does this book that's my understanding I had a question I don't know because it would be like the whole class time we were doing it so we'd have to send them out and then come up with something else and i i don't know specifically that policy have historically it's not a state standard yes you have to teach the standards but right a parent would need to be able to opt out okay so

108i had a question because it wasn't clear to me if um i i think assuming it's uh kelly that it's gonna be read in spanish correct yes okay so you just provided the english version just for our purposes Yes. We have the Spanish copies. Okay, so I have a few things to say about this book. You know, so just in out of the sake of being 100% honest, you know, when I first started reading it, it was hard for me to get into because it did feel like very... heavy-handed almost. But I agree with all of you that I think what really persuaded me in favor of this book, and I think the strength of it is the multiple perspectives. It's really interesting how it's written in different sections from multiple perspectives. So I really

109enjoyed that. And then the more I read it, the more I started to see that this could really work for the fifth grade level. And I also want to say that I completely agree with Zoe because I believe that social media has completely changed the landscape of the type of news that we have access to, which is now pretty much in the hands of everybody. Right. And then also want to say that I agree with the comment about, you know, for some of us, you know, this book could seem like complex, very difficult reading because of the themes in it. But I think for other for lots of children, you know, it's their lived reality. Right. So I believe that this book is very powerful in the sense that I really believe that, for example,

110if Andy Lopez had been part of a class like this, like potentially he may not have been carrying that toy gun. And that's just me. Right. That's obviously like my my opinion about that. But I believe this book to be very powerful. I think it's important. I think it's a good tool to have children discuss these very important topics. because of this influence of social media. It's so important, especially in the hands of all of you who are professionals, to have those structured conversations and guided conversations is really critical. I had a question about whether this aligns with the history curriculum that you're teaching in fifth grade, or if it's just kind of a separate... tool that you wanted to use sure I can comment that I teach us history and you know on the

111English side and The history content that we teach is violent, you know, it's it's historically accurate It's it's from the American Revolution and prior And and we do delve a little bit into the Civil War at the very beginning the school year, but nothing that's current from today. But we do draw upon those themes that were learned about social and civil unrest in the United States and what's come from that. There are some ties. Can I just add on to Trustee... This is my first time addressing you. I don't know how to say it properly. Do I say Trustee Cogorno? You rolled the R. Oh, sorry. The American version is Cagorno. Awesome. Thank you, Kelly. That's the Kelly in me. Your concerns are absolutely warranted. And one thing I just would say is... As teachers,

112we read their private comments to us every week through our social-emotional learning program called Sohn to Grow, where the students have a chance to reflect privately with us in a safe manner. And many of these concerns that students today have around racism, sexism, violence, violence in their home, violence in the community, is brought up on a regular basis. And so whether... Whether we love that about our world today, it is the reality that these kids are facing. Many of these kids, as you two so beautifully mentioned, don't have the capacity or the agency at home to talk about them in a safe environment that's built on trust and love and compassion. Our world, respectively, sir, is much different from 2014, when you were a fifth grade teacher, to 2024, what kids are going through today,

113with regard to the unfortunate unfiltered access that many of them have through social media like TikTok and whatnot, that thrusts these views onto them without our knowledge or even our understanding or our permission. And so we're suggesting that maybe we can have those conversations in these safe environments and get that conversation started. Just to clarify, I have been in a fourth grade classroom like last week. So I know this age group and I know about TikTok. I'm not naive to any of that. I just feel they're too young. And that's my stance. I also agree that they're too young to be experiencing it in their lives, and some of them are. Okay, but we don't have to teach it in our schools. I don't feel like we have to promote this in our schools. Okay,

114and I'm in seventh, eighth grade. It is exactly, it is my opinion. If I just may rebut, we don't want to teach bullying in our schools either, but when that happens on our campus, as it has happened just last week, we choose to respond to it in a safe and appropriate way. Your points are so well understood and appreciated. We just want to counter those. No, I just want you guys to know, I appreciate what you're doing. I really do. I just can't. Vote for it in good conscience tonight. Okay, I'm gonna turn it over to Kylie who has a comment and I'm sure there will be more comments from the board So if you could yeah, it will get everyone a chance to say what they want to say I'm also gonna take it

115out to public comment in a bit and see if anyone else has anything but go ahead Kylie and I'm sorry to interject but I think that there was a strange sort of echo or maybe y'all are not close enough to the mic, but I was having a lot of difficulty hearing you. So when you speak, if you could just get as close to the mic, because I was having trouble hearing. Thanks, Malinoli. Go ahead, Kylie. Okay, first off, I'd like to say that I appreciate all the comments, this conversation. I like where it's going. And I just want to add a personal anecdote. So when I was in the fifth grade, I picked up a book and I was an avid reader. I read ahead because I was more advanced and I read a book

116called... The Hate U Give, right? That's what it was called. And it was a book that tackled inequality. It was a book that tackled police brutality. And it's called The Hate U Give. It was an amazing book. And it definitely shed light on things that I didn't even know I could relate to. Being able to feel seen, feel heard in literature is so important to a child's education. And denying them that access just because it's an uncomfortable topic would be a disservice. to entire communities. I understand that the maturity content might be a little bit of a discomfort for parents. But again, I'd like to place emphasis on the fact that this is some children's realities. They deserve a safe place to talk about, to have these conversations in an educational manner. Denying them that

117would be isolating them, would be depriving them of that opportunity. Thank you. OK. We're going to turn it over to Rich, and then Zoe. Do you want to go? How about we let Rich go first and then Zoe, you can have the floor after. This is going to take a little bit. And I want to make, first off, there's two different tracks. One is this book being in a library. One is this being taught in a class. The other is when it's taught in a class. The topics that we're talking about, all these different issues, right? All issues that should be talked about, people of color, all these different things, the bullying, guns, weapons, all these different things. There is a time that all of them should be discussed. When is that time? Is this

118book the right book to have that discussion? I'm not sure. I was on vacation in Jamaica. of all the things you could do in Jamaica, reading this book was not on the list. And then Brian slips me the book right before our last meeting. And I've been so busy. It was the only time I could read it. So not only did I read it, but my wife, she got to read it too, because this is what you do when you're in Jamaica, you read books. So I want to make sure that one, this book. I don't have a trouble with this book being in one of our libraries. So that's not an issue there. The content in the book, I have an issue with the book at the age that you guys want to have

119the kids read it. And here's the reason why. It's a fiction book. It has, it's not a real book. The topics that are in it are real, but the... The story isn't real. It alludes to some real things. The story of the kids, the Emmett Till, they're going to get on the internet and they're going to look that up and they're going to find out that this book didn't go into that to the level that it could. And I'm okay with that story being taught in history, historically accurate. Because it's important. I was a missionary 40 years ago in Alabama. I grew up in Forestville. I grew up with no different colors in eyes. I had friends that were of color, of not. I didn't notice the difference just the way we were raised. And

120when I went to Alabama, holy smokes, that was a cultural... I mean, I went to the first town I'm in in Birmingham, went to this thing and, oh, wow, look at these big buildings. And I said, what are these? And they go, oh, the churches. And I'd never seen churches that big before. And I go, what church is that? And he goes, well, that's a Baptist church. And I go, what church is that? And he goes, well, that's a Baptist church. And I go, there's that many Baptists in Alabama? And they go, no, that's where the black folks go to that Baptist church. And the white Baptist, they go to that church. I had never been exposed to anything. like that before. So it was very much an eye-opener. So I understand that now growing

121up in Forestville, I was probably a little sheltered, you know, but I, so I understand the need for our kids to understand these different concepts. If this was a history book, I would say, okay. It's pretty heavy history. I think it should be a little bit older kids where you can touch on this particular book, maybe a different book that's a little lighter to introduce the concepts in the fifth grade. Okay. Part of my issue with this book is it's fiction. How is a young person supposed to differentiate? They could read this book and get to where they're believing. that the story is actually real. Where do they differentiate? An older person, a little bit more mature, would be able to have you guys tell them, hey, look, remember, this is fiction. This isn't real.

122So on and so forth. And so that's, you know, I'm with Paul in this, that I think this book and the way it's presented. should be a little bit older group. It says five to seven, fifth to seventh grade is the bracket. Why are we always pushing the lowest side of the brackets? It's not a question. It's more of a rhetorical thing because sometimes these things come up before the board. You know, when we talk about racism and different things, my family is a family of color, all kinds of color. And I remember hearing Morgan Freeman, very well-known actor. He was getting, asked, you know, when is racism going to go away? And his response was, I'm paraphrasing. He says, when are you going to quit asking me about it? He goes, when are you

123going to quit asking me about it? You keep bringing it up all the time. So you keep doing it. My family is all of color. We don't have any of those issues in our family because it's never talked about. We don't have those issues. Now, other issues we go through, but anyhow, the book itself, my challenges, the book is fiction. I'm concerned that our kids won't be able to differentiate between what is real history and what is fake, what's made up. You're right. We have other issues right here locally that historically happened. Bill was the county council when that happened. And so I'm concerned about that. The last part is, and this goes to books in general, I would like to see Windsor become a little more aspirational. And what I mean by that is,

124We know we're going to cover things that have happened historically. We should, because if you don't, people will repeat doing things that they shouldn't do that are short-sighted. But I know that Trustee Lopez was asked to put together a group of books, Spanish books. I had Spanish themes. I'm not saying it right. But anyhow, there you go. Thank you. And and I mean, this is her expertise. She teaches this at Sonoma State and she put together a group of of of. Books that she thought might be a good experience for our people to our kids to be able to go through Maybe we need to do that is have kind of a comprehensive look. I know Diane Hardy sent us a letter About different things and what have you and and one of the things

125actually I'm gonna I'm gonna quote it because I'm not good at it One of the things oh one of the things that she she mentioned which was pretty good She's talking about how the standards for literacy that they place a much heavier emphasis on nonfiction text This is what we're all supposed to be following that it puts a much heavier emphasis on nonfiction texts and she said more than 65% of our current reading list is fiction and it doesn't create and so and we only have about 19 approved books that are actually nonfiction books. This is fiction. I'm wondering if we can do better on, and again, put it in the library. All good. I appreciate the fact that you guys have gone through the process of trying to do this stuff. If this came

126and you said, hey, this is for our seventh grade class, I'd be going like, you know, okay. You know, I think they're... They can, as you teachers can say, remember, this is fiction. And here's the concept that we're going over these things conceptually so we can understand all the dialogues about it. Okay. Fifth grade, I am hesitant that I coach. I'm around these kids every single day. I know what their maturity level is. And, you know, I look at our reading comprehension scores of our kids. We're getting better. I just don't know that this particular book is the one that we want to use to, one, teach things historically accurate, and two, talk about those topics using this book to talk about those topics. I think those topics can be discussed in the fifth grade,

127maybe not in this particular manner. I think that's pretty much... I just think it's a little bit too early, and that's kind of where I'm at. I think it's a little bit too early. Okay, Zoe, go ahead. It's Zoe's turn. I'm sorry. Go ahead. Well, I just wanted to expand on what Kylie was saying earlier. I read that book too, The Hate U Give. I think I was in fifth or sixth grade. And personally, it kind of opened my eyes to a reality I wasn't aware of. I grew up in a privileged community. And I think books like Ghost Boys kind of give kids the option to learn more about sort of a taboo topic and maybe encourage empathy. Because one point that was brought up in the presentation was that Kids like maybe unintentionally

128are saying things that they don't understand a racist or don't understand the impact that they have on people so I think even just reading a book might Sort of make them realize a little bit what they're saying or what kind of impact it could have on people and something that Kylie brought up, but um, I think you mentioned that Reading comprehension levels may be like lower in certain areas because students aren't connecting to what they're reading and they don't feel personally like they relate to the reading. So I think maybe if Ghost Boys isn't the book that we want to choose, I still think choosing a book with more substantial, like just more substance is a really good idea. And I just think also it is a book written for children. So it'll likely treat

129the topic more delicately than a book like A Time to Kill or something. So I think if not Ghost Boys, we definitely need to look at books that regard like controversial topics because just because they're not talked about doesn't mean that they're not happening and I think it'll also be good for kids especially fifth graders who are more they're still learning to developmentally to realize that other people can relate to what they're going through and it sort of opens their eyes a little bit more maybe makes them more willing to reach out for help I just think it's really important to educate people on so I think Ghost Boys is a good idea or if not Ghost Boys a book similar to that Thank you. I completely agree with that. And I wanted to go

130back to Trustee Carnation's comment because I feel like there's something really important that needs to be distinguished. And in this conversation, I believe that it's been getting confused a little bit, right? So I'm also an educator because I teach at Sonoma State University. And there are different kinds of literature, right? There's different kinds of books. So on the one hand, You have books, for example, that are books of history, right? That recount real and true events. But that's different than, for example, a work of fiction where, you know, the learning outcomes are completely different, right? So for example, for works of history, obviously you're trying to understand the events of history and why they're important, how they continue to influence our world today, for example. So it's really understanding sort of a sequence or a

131process of events that are critical and how they influence people's lives, right? So that's one kind of learning with. different outcomes and objectives. And then on the other hand, you have works of fiction, right? So this is a work of fiction that have and come with it different types of learning lessons. So for example, when you're reading books of fiction, you're not necessarily looking for real historical events necessarily, right? That's not the goal of reading a book of fiction. It's really to Exercise your mind in a process of imagining a world that's not necessarily your own. So you're stretching your imagination. You're really thinking in a creative zone, which I believe is equally as important as learning history, right? And I would even dare say even possibly more, right? Because I think all of the

132creative geniuses that we have out in the world are constantly using their imagination, imagining things that... you know, may not be there, right? So they're imagining something completely new. So this kind of brain process only happens through works of fiction, right? The other thing that's really critical about works of fiction that's important and not, again, not necessarily telling true historical events is that you're picking up language, right? You're picking up language patterns. You're picking up new words that perhaps were not part of your vocabulary. And you're thinking in new and different ways. And that kind of learning can only come, you know, that being in that imaginative realm and creative realm can only happen when you're reading books of fiction. Another important thing is that you're getting students to talk to each other, right? And

133that's so critical and that's difficult to do, especially at this grade level in when you're reading just straight up history, right? And I believe that this is what your goal is, is just to get students to talk more, right? So I really believe that fiction lends itself to that. um i also want to say that you know just like zoe shared my daughter also read the hate you give uh i vaguely remember it was somewhere around fifth or sixth grade i don't remember But I do remember the first time she told me what the book was about, you know, she was really excited and I was just kind of shocked because I thought, oh my God, like, what is she reading? Right. That was my first, you know, knee jerk reaction. And then after I

134had conversations with her, I realized how alive she came when she was talking about the book and why it was important to her. And we had a really good conversation about racism and different topics presented in that book. And then later I thought, thank God, you know, for these teachers, because they're taking on these hard subjects and getting us to talk about it, you know, with our kids. I thought that was such a good learning experience. But mainly the gist of what I'm trying to say here is that historical texts are important for certain learning objectives, whereas works of fiction. you know, create a different set of learning outcomes that are just as valuable, you know, if not more valuable. So this is really critical work. and if i could just clarify one point real

135quick rich the common core state standards when they give the recommendation for the percentages between fictional and informational texts they're not just speaking to the language arts period they're speaking to the entire day so science social studies electives that are all dealing with informational texts are part of that percentage so if if language arts is only one period of a student's day then that would be that 40 or that 30 that's supposed to be fictional text so an english class should have a lot of fiction because that's the only time particularly in a secondary student that they'd be receiving that type of reading okay oh well go ahead and respond rich and then bill i was honest i was just quoting uh the information that i got from miss hardy to us in our letter

136and and so i i Two-fold one. I want to make sure Diane knows I read her emails right that way I stay in the Christmas card list but No, I was taking the information she had so again. Everything's a balance act so I Want to make sure you guys understand exactly what I'm saying. It's not the topics. It's not the discussions it's the Fiction, you know is a fifth grader at Cali. Are you telling me that all the kids in that class? their reading comprehension is perfectly excellent to where they can read that. They know it's fiction. They're not thinking, they're not beginning to... They know fact from fiction, yes. When we tell them we are reading a fiction book. Okay, because I coach a lot of them too, and they have a hard time

137understanding some pretty simpler concepts. Anyhow, the point is this. I just think that this book being fiction, And the topics it is covering, I would prefer it to be more towards the closer to the seventh grade classes than the other. I'm not talking about so much of the reading comprehension level of it as much as the discussion point of it. Okay. I'm going to give Bill the opportunity to speak. He's been waiting patiently. Thank you. I also have Diane Hardy's email here. Mine is annotated. which does talk and it is a high school that's so that comes from the high school english department in literature but what i like and it came from um discussions we've had at the board when trustee lopez said hey we seem to be light on our uh chicana latina

138literature and so there was a list and we talked about it and are we and we talked about well what the what the approval process is and should they be in the library or in the classroom but one sentence i will clarify that later because that's not actually what happened but i'll clarify that later i'm sorry yes i'll clarify more of the sequence of events of what happened around that list but we'll talk about that when the item comes i just wanted to clarify how that happened Okay. But, Bill, your point, continue. You have the floor. Anyway, I liked very much with Diana, both in the English department and as the vice president of the teachers union, sharing that. The approved reading materials for students must be teacher generated and I added on my notes

139and curated by the teachers. I absolutely support our five literature experts for fifth graders at our Cali campus who do not come here lightly to us to say we have a mature theme that people can read that it is fiction. I simply don't. That's a distinction without a difference to me. I get that there's historical text. This is literature. And so. This book, I believe, deals with themes. We had a moment of silence to start. These fifth graders know how to get under a desk for shootings that are based on race and gender and hate. So I have confidence that our teachers can look at this, guide them, have them understand. We are reading a piece of it. This is a story. The story is brought from perspective. Some of it's made up. They have

140a dead omnipresent person because that's a real valuable narrative tool. And here's why. Shakespeare did that sometimes. I'm concerned that we have a curriculum approval process. And if we need to change how we're doing that, let's change the policies, not. inflect different policies and criteria when the process is followed. And my understanding is the process has been followed here. That this book has been brought up. We rarely get them to read and we took it home and we spent some homework with that. But I think we have acknowledged there's a gap in this genre, this language, this cultural connection. And thank you so much for our student board members for their heartfelt comments. But I support this. To aspirational Windsor when I say five to seventh grade our fifth graders are good They can read

141advanced material and advanced text as opposed to wait until their seventh or maybe eighth when they're older I get that I get the sensitivity and the heartfelt part of that My view is of course our fifth graders will take a crack at it and our fifth grade staff will say we think ours are ready You see them every day and in that vein I would support the recommendation that we adopt this text All right, Kylie. And just to add on to that, we can't control what fifth graders do when they go home. So we don't know the access that they have to their technology. We don't know what they're seeing on social media or on TV or... on the TV shows that they're watching that might tackle these topics. But if they're able to have

142a trusted teacher at the school, they're able to have guided conversations with their friends about important topics such as this, then we should open that conversation for them. We should invite them to have a comfortable platform to talk about this, especially if it's considering education, like literature. Like I said before, that Zoe touched on. our critical comprehension skills, our critical thinking skills, they might not be able to connect to the text that they're reading. I for sure know that when I don't relate to a book, I find it extremely difficult to read it. I want to put it down because it bores me. But if I see myself in that text, if I see my peers in that text, I'm going to be inclined to engage in class discussions. I'm going to be engaged to

143talk to my teacher and ask thoughtful questions. So I wanted to put that out there. I also just wanted to say if like if we don't believe that fifth graders can handle the complex material then we won't give them the complex material then they won't understand the material so I think if there's another issue with reading comprehension levels it's really important to not assume that they won't be able to understand something it's important to test their boundaries test their limits and hopefully that'll show improvement okay I'm gonna go There's been a lot of conversation. Okay. So I think first, I just want to thank you for being here and doing this because the process for getting curriculum approved is really onerous and we appreciate your time and you putting yourselves out there and being on

144our agenda and going above and beyond because the easier thing to do is just to pick a book that's already on the list. and go about your day and, you know, not challenge us to think about new things. So I just want to say, we really appreciate you being here. And we kind of in line with that, we've been actively thinking about how can we make this process easier where we still have the board, like we still have this body and like all of the processes of vetting, but the curriculum and the books that we're teaching, but where it's just not quite so hard. to do because this is hard. So that's like the first thing that I want to say. And then I, so I am supportive, but I was really concerned when I,

145like, I wasn't sure that I was going to be supportive when, before I read the book, I was really concerned about kind of the descriptors that were used, the, like, whether how much they got into graphic detail or the author. And And especially for this age range, right? You're thinking 10-year-olds, they're so little still, even though I remember being 10 and feeling like kind of older than I perceive. And I know how much kids are exposed to just so much information today. So that's a really valuable part of this conversation that I hadn't really thought about. But the topic that I want to bring up that I think is a little bit tricky is, I think, that is politicization. And I think that's happening with different topics, like kind of nationally, locally, everywhere we're seeing

146kind of like, and this is a topic that is very politicized. And I think that's some of my concern too, is like... We live in a community that has a huge law enforcement presence, huge first responder presence. The author has a point of view, and I think it's pretty clear in some parts of the book how she feels about kind of the intention of different actors and kind of how they go about their jobs and kind of the values that they bring to those jobs. And I think that I was at a meeting yesterday. Has it only been one day? Yeah, one day. Yeah, yesterday at Cali to talk about the charter and this book came up. So it's true. People are talking about it. Like you've gotten people talking about a book and people

147are reading it. And, you know, I have someone who I grew up with who is married to a first responder who is married to a police officer. And I told her I would make her comments at the meeting because. I wanted to give a voice to that. And she was really concerned just about politicization, which I can't say, but you know what I'm talking about, and about kind of like the intention. And that in her experience, people in law enforcement are really trying to improve all the time and kind of strive towards excellence. And that that wasn't totally captured in the book. Strives that have been made and the people who genuinely care about making the profession kind of one where there are no mistakes that are made and and Like I won't comment, you

148know, we obviously there are tragedies that happen And we've had tragedies in our own community but I think a component of this is like keeping parents really involved and I believe there's a meeting that's supposed to happen about the book. Is that that's something that I heard Okay, so a meeting and about bringing in law enforcement and different people from different roles and different backgrounds, because I think this is also an opportunity, right, for, and you've already talked about this, but I think that's the opportunity for kids to really engage and like for that to be the most complete conversation that it can be. So I wanted to raise that side of it too. I think that's all I have as far as comments. Just again, thank you for being here. Thank you for all

149the work that you did. And if there are no other comments from the board at this moment, I'll ask for public comment. Do we have any public comment? flash my tires um the the guidelines for elementary and high school are very different so um by the high school level we'd expect a lot more non-fiction texts versus fiction texts and i just wanted to clarify that thank you all right annette Hi, I'm Annette Zucconi-Montes, your new Director of Curriculum Instruction and Assessment. And I just want to say two things. One, I trust teachers when they go to this much work and put a book forward. I also am the mom of two children of color. who appreciated their experience at Cali and the ability to read literature that reflected what was going on in their friends'

150lives. And so I just really wanna acknowledge that we have two amazingly articulate student board members who support the idea of sharing literature, sharing story. Oh, there's one more point I wanna make. Our test scores and engagement of students who are Hispanic and students who are English learners, their engagement is low and their achievement is low. And I would say that if we expose them to more content that touches their stories, that they will engage. Thank you. ahead Annette could I ask you a question so in your prior job until this evening you were the other fifth grade principal here I was a fifth grade principal and I've been a fifth grade teacher so I read it in English because I am not literate in Spanish. Would you consider having this book? I don't know

151if you're familiar with the book. I would want to read it with my team. All right. That would be something, I think, for us to think of because we have at least four or five copies in English. That if this is an appropriate fifth grade book is to think, well, if it's appropriate for fifth graders, it may be district wide because while there may be a slightly higher or more higher. Hispanic student group at Cali it still is the majority of our students in the district and so it is just as a as a thought yeah okay thank you thank you Jessica Borland, Director of Early Education and Expanded Learning. But I'm up here as a grandparent, parent, and my grandson is a fifth grader. A couple of these teachers are his teachers over at

152Cali. And I just want to kind of bring in my experience and my feelings about this as a parent in the district and having a child that would be affected by this. Um, I can tell you when it, this, when the topic was brought up and the book was brought up, my, uh, my gut reaction was Grayson was not ready for it. Um, he is a kind, sweet, very, still very innocent boy. Um, and you know, that's, that's kind of where my head went. I want to keep his innocence. Um, but I just had a three hour conversation with him about school shootings and all of the violence that's happening. And he's. He's still very protected. Like we, he has a lockdown iPad. He only has the school Chromebook. He's not getting onto TikTok and

153what a lot of other kids are. Kids are talking and he's right on the cusp of being in middle school. This is the perfect time for him to have guided discussions about things that he is going to be exposed to so much more next year. And the kids, the violence that we have going on is immense. Like kids really need to be talked about, talking about it at school with teachers and guided because right now they're talking to their friends and, you know, it's. it's not as supportive as it needs to be at this grade level. So that's my two cents. And, you know, I hope that it is approved and I hope that the teachers can, you know, walk through some of these really tough conversations with the kiddos right before they go on

154to middle school and with all the violence that's happening in our communities. You know, thank you, Jessica. Oh, I'm sorry. We're still doing public comment, right? I think we're done with public comment. So I think you're okay. I think, Jessica, I think you helped me just hit it on the head. You said this is an important topic that the kiddos should have. I agree. They're still kiddos. And I know that since Adam and Eve, every kid thought their parents were fuddy-duddies and that they were always ready. I remember, I'm old enough to remember, I remember the Beatles were on the Ed Sullivan show. All the parents in the country were like, oh freaking out You can't show that pornography on TV The Beatles were called pornography back then or whatever and stuff and then Elvis

155Presley and his little twisties and all that other good stuff I understand that except that forever there's been this youth push Parents pushed down trying to keep them with the dichotomy of protecting them and this and that the rest and all this stuff you mentioned that Grayson, I think next year, these things are going to be more in his world. And maybe that's when he should be reading this book is next year when these things are in his world and not be taking some of these. I asked this question a while back, and that is, when do we have the right? To take away some of these kids' innocence and some of their youthful childhood. When is that time? I mean, that's the question I have. When are we able to go ahead and take

156these kids and say, hey, you now need to have this mature topic? I don't know the answer to that one. And it's a rhetorical question. I'm really not looking for an answer from you on this one. Because it's not a this book or this class or this school. It's really kind of across the board all the way. And that is, you know, when and I just kind of want us to think about that is when is it OK or when is it good to introduce somebody else's kid to a topic that a parent may not want them to have? I mean, I got an email yesterday from a parent about a third grader getting stuff, and I have to go and do my due diligence and do a little research talking about topics that don't

157seem like they should be in a third grade curriculum. I've got to find that out. But anyhow, we're talking about this book for fifth graders. Again, if you guys were saving this book for seventh graders, I wouldn't have a problem. Sixth graders, you know, because of... A sixth, seventh, and eighth grade at the middle school, well, or even over at Cali, I might. Fifth graders, I just don't feel comfortable that, not the topic. I believe that the topics are honest topics that teachers should be able to have with kids and stuff. I just don't know if this is the format in which you take a fictional issue to talk about important things. I don't know the answer to that. You guys teach them every day. You guys think that you should. I don't think I'm

158convinced yet. So anyhow. Okay. I see Kylie. And then I'm going to call a vote after that. So go ahead, Kylie. You can close this out. All right. Yeah, I'll close this off. So I just want to say again, I want to put emphasis on the fact that. This is a lot of children's realities. They live day to day living with this fact. And being able to connect with an educator, being able to connect with their peers in a class setting about this is paramount to their education. Being able to see themselves in literature is paramount to their education. Denying them that access because they're not mature enough is undermining their abilities, their comprehension skills. Again, if they can connect with literature, if they connect to text, it creates an open-minded environment that doesn't deny

159them access. living in a generation where we quite literally have stimulation right there 30 seconds I can google something they have access to iPads they have access to technology where they're going to open these conversation and it might be in a dangerous and unprotected environment so being able to do this in an educational curriculum it will open a conversation that is protected that is guided yeah this is a point that I have to make I appreciate your comment You're right. Any of these kids can get in two seconds faster than I can think it. You guys can find something on your phone and they can read it. And that's okay. Again, the first thing I said, have it in the library. That's okay. This is going from having a kid have access to something to

160we're requiring them to read it. That's the difference. We're requiring somebody now to read it. at the fifth grade level. That's different from having a fifth grader having access to it. I'm not denying anybody having access. Put it in the library, 100%, not a problem. But when you're making somebody read it, that's different than having them have the opportunity to read it. Nobody's talking about not letting anybody have access to anything. It's just, is this a proper age? for that at this point that's it and that's do i have a motion i'll make a motion that we approve the uh text as recommended in the staff report in the presentation by the teachers and i'll second it all in favor aye opposed no opposed no okay it passes i think that was two three two

161Thank you for your time. Thank you for your time. Thanks. And thanks for being a part of our discussion. We love having these types of conversations and we appreciate you being here. We'll get to work on our packet. Thank you guys. Stephanie, could I ask that we move item 7.3 because Danielle's here to present up above 7.2. Let's move up item 7.3 to 7.2. We're going to talk about the. Windsor High School course catalog. Thank you for waiting for hours. We appreciate it. So this will be the first year we are, well, we always have a course catalog, but this will be the first year that we're unveiling a new process. Oh, and thank you, student board members. I know you sacrificed some valuable study time to participate with that. I think they have an

162AP government. We always appreciate a good conversation. Thank you guys. On your final, thank you for being here and for sharing your insights. It's not that you're talking to them. well i'm glad they got some government experience right now exactly guys good luck tomorrow so this is our our new process where we wanted the the board to be able to see the entire course offerings that windsor high school has to offer and be able to track as new classes are added and if classes are no longer being offered be able to track that as well and do it in a time where you can you have the ability to review to think about it so this is just a discussion item tonight there is no action but i wanted to have principal buckman here in

163case you had any questions about the course catalog or any of the new courses that were being proposed for adoption and think of this almost like a board policy this is the base board policy if you will and in future years you'll either have red lines you'll have added language it'll all be highlighted so you know what's changed this is just a very base course catalog board policy concept okay sorry I I did are we taking action discussing this will come back next month under under action this is just if there's any feedback that you wanted to provide to principal Buckman um and she can have uh discuss whatever changes and then bring it back to the board in January I have one comment, but I don't think it's really something that would impact anything

164for this year. I thought everything looked really great. I have just been hopeful that we could teach a Native American history class and fulfill the ethnic studies requirement, have that be one option for fulfilling the ethnic studies requirement. So that was kind of something that I had that I just wanted to share, but I don't. That shouldn't take away from any of the work that you've done, and I think it all. And that is in the works. We're contracting with Redbud Resource Group to help write that course. Perfect. Any other comments? So I had some comments just because there's some things that have been said that I feel are inaccurate. So I, for one, I want to start out by saying that I see all of us, the board, you know, Superintendent Decker and his

165cabinet, you know, teachers, our staff, I see us all as one team, right? We're all on the same team because I believe that we all have the end goal of giving the very best of our school district to our students and their families. Right. So I just want to lead with that. And I want to say that, you know, that there's been some misunderstandings in the way, especially that I was represented in the last meeting, which I was not here, unfortunately, because I happened to get very, very ill at the last moment. So I was not able to be here to speak, but I did watch the meeting. And I believe that there was a misunderstanding of the way that the process of arriving upon. a book, a list of book recommendations that are by

166Chicano and Latino authors, the way that, you know, that came about. Right. So I do want to say that. The idea is I understood it is I was invited to create a list of books that would be purchased so that students could get excited about reading, but that were not necessarily part of the curriculum, right? That they, the curriculum is sort of the terrain of the teachers, right? To develop their own curriculum, to choose the books that they feel like they need to choose, but that this was really sort of a ground zero of. starting the conversation on ethnic studies and getting teachers exposed to some of the books that I believe are the outstanding notable works by Chicano and Latino authors. And that it was an important starting point, right? So it was really

167to open up a conversation. But I do want to say that this was in no way me saying, oh, let me interject and, you know, create curriculum for teachers or, you know, give guidelines to teachers or even, you know, require anything of teachers, right? This is all for the purposes of having a conversation. So these are some of the ideas that I wish I would have been able to say, you know, at the previous meeting, right? On another note, I want to say that this list of books that my hope would be purchased for the Windsor High School Library was created with that in mind, that this would really open up the diverse book offerings for students. So if there was a student, like let's say one of our student board members that said, I'm

168really interested in doing some research or learning more about Latino literature, that they would be able to check out a book. Right. And that that would be offered to them because, you know, quite frankly, I believe we're doing a disservice to students by not offering literature that is expansive and has a diverse range that represents the identities of who they are. And that this is very critical because at least half of our entire school district are, you know, people of Mexican origin, Chicanos and Latinos. Right. So this is very critical as one of our student. board members has already said that they see themselves represented in the literature because if they do not see themselves, it will be very difficult to feel engaged and even further like they matter. So I, in an email, you

169know, to Ms. Buckman and also Mr. Williams, you know, quoted from a doctoral student and also assistant professor Amy Hendricks from Texas Women's University that research. indicates that youth have more meaningful engagements with texts when the texts are fresh and relevant, reflecting common issues and themes in their lives. This focus on relevance benefits all youth, so that's everyone, but it is especially important that historically marginalized youth have access to texts that reflect their identities. languages and social experiences and that this is very critical. So with all of that said, I went ahead and I put together a list of who I believe are some of the most critical authors for the Latino canon, right? So I wanted to explain what that is. The Latino canon are very important works. of literature that are put together

170by people who are literary critics. You know, they're professors, they're academics, they're people that do book reviews. You know, so there's this whole conversation that happens about, you know, how does someone end up in this Latino canon, right? How do we know who are the most important books? And as I mentioned, fiction is so important and critical for... exercising the imagination for imagining worlds that are not necessarily your own but that make you critically reflect on your own world but also that could reflect your identity languages and also your own personal experiences right so it's important for students to be able to get outside of who they are and at the same time also see themselves reflected right it's it's a it's a tricky idea when you think about it but it's important So I

171want to say that, you know, this having these diverse offerings are also so important because I think a long, long time ago, like, you know, when I was growing up in elementary school, there was this idea from teachers about how they taught curriculum that you almost treat your student like there's this receptacle of learning and you're just filling it with ideas. And then you're expecting the student to spit them back out, you know, through memorization. you know, and also via testing, and they're just spitting out facts that they have memorized and digested, but probably didn't think about as profoundly, right? So literature offers this beautiful opportunity for all of us to engage in conversations that are not always neat and clean cut. And to be quite frank, sometimes they're kind of messy. And that's a

172good thing, right? That's a good thing because You don't know where your imagination will take you unless you have these messy conversations, right? So this is just like the book presentation that we had earlier. You know, those conversations are difficult but critical in really problem solving, exercising your brain, getting out of your comfort zone. All of these qualities are so important. So the last thing that I want to say about this, and once again, this is me, you know, just urging. us to buy these books for the library for the sake of having more diverse offerings at our library. The last thing I want to say that Chicano and Latino literature is so critically important for not just the academic aspects of it, but also for students for their own personal enrichment and experiences. Because

173I just want to say that when the Spaniards invaded Latin America, the Caribbean and Mexico. the first things that they, one of the first things that they did besides enact all sorts of horrible violence was that they decided that they were going to burn every single book that they found, right? So this speaks to the nature of why literature is so critically important because they said to themselves, we cannot erase this culture that we have encountered and build, you know, from ground zero to convince them to be like Spaniards. right we can't convince them to do that unless we burn all of the literature that we encounter and since that time Latinos, Chicanos, Mexican people, people from the Caribbean, indigenous people have suffered greatly because they have not had access to historical accounts of their

174own experiences to the poetry of their own experiences uh you know until more recently where we've had this Latino canon you know uh come about and also um other more contemporary works right so in a way it's like through this literature we are actively engaging with healing this very traumatic past that we've been through that has been all about violence, right? So for me, you know, this opens up a window of opportunity, of possibility. You know, what a beautiful thing to do to heal from these incredibly traumatic experiences that have erased our ancestors, that have erased our literature, that have erased our, you know, architecture and our art. it's so important to recover these, right? And I just see this beautiful alignment of things because now we have this state mandate, right? It's the law

175that we must offer ethnic studies and that we must offer diverse offerings, right? I actually took time to read through what are the common core standards for this type of literature and what is expected. And it's expected that we offer diverse literature. So it's so critical. So I know I've gone on my soapbox, but this is important to me, right? the books that I recommended at least half of them have completely changed my life right especially I Rigoberta Menchú which is about an indigenous woman in Guatemala who her entire family is killed in the Guatemalan war right just completely changed my life because In reading all of these books, even though it doesn't seem associated, you know, to my own experience, it made me realize all of the different things that people that came before

176me in regions that where I'm of the region of where I am from, you know, that they went through incredible hardship just to survive, right? Just so the possibility of myself could be here today, right? So this is all just incredibly. important, I think, for also young people that come from, you know, the Caribbean, Mexico, Latin America, that their answer survived and now we're here and we get to read this like beautiful literature that really speaks to our experiences. So I will end with that. Thank you. Do we have any other comments on this item? no okay i getting back to the course catalog piece um i was concerned and wondered where it was going where pages 42 to 47 went it's that's a lot of text and it's like administrative student handbook kind of

177stuff scheduled changes and is that provided somewhere else yeah you need to come up here I felt like that was more important in our student handbook, which is also in our data confirmation. So that way it was a place that parents and students were reading versus the course catalog that not everybody reads. So I want to absolutely agree with you. I just was looking through a lot of important stuff. The other piece is I would urge. Frankly, before chorus is stricken, I know it wasn't taught the last couple of years that we not give up on chorus. It seems to me a one of the easiest visual and performing arts things that's low cost. You don't have to learn an instrument. We can articulate it down to the lower grades. And I think that's a

178different conversation to have, perhaps with Elizabeth Robertson. But I was concerned. I know it's been in there and we haven't offered it. So it's it's kind of a chicken or the egg kind of thing. I do like the ethnic studies. If it's going to be on the catalog, and thank you for sending the curriculum over for that, will that be added to the catalog for 20? Once it's approved. Okay, got it. So do you have a series of actions you would like us to do out of this? Tonight is purely informational. Okay. And often we don't want to rush the board when we give you pages and pages and pages of documents. So if anything comes up over the month and we want to provide any feedback or input, we'll make sure that that is

179discussed and then reflected in when we bring it back in January for a vote. So I would ask that. There's some consultation with our arts plan Tosa on chorus and what we might do about that. I'm concerned that once it's stricken from the high school catalog, it's even harder to claw back because I think it's. an easy, very accessible program to a vast majority of our students, unlike guitar or instrumental music, all of which are important, theater and those things. So maybe we could visit that again. That's a little broader than simply the catalog for your campus, but that was something that jumped out at me. Other than that, thank you for bringing this to us. Can I ask, Danielle, was there any rationale for why chorus wasn't included or was it just not? It's

180pure course selection kids love with the guitar understand so it wasn't it wasn't an active decision to necessarily pull it out It's just based on student interest. Okay, mr Hoffman's guitar classes are packed to the rafters and we yeah We would offer more but we also want him to have honors band and honor strings. Got it. Okay the I'm not sure if it's the right way to ask the question, but I mean Daniel you're like Queen of innovation. What is in this that's new and innovative or a little bit different? What's the biggest change? What's our expectation? Biggest change to the course catalog or offerings or just yeah, yeah all of it Yeah, so I would say that the biggest change to the course catalog is the addition underneath if you look at the cores

181and really targeting which cte sector we're highlighting in those that's not something we've really touched on but obviously college and career readiness is super important to us and our students need to be aware of of what that concentrator and capstone course that they're taking you know which sector that relates to um so that there's there's a little bit more vested interest in them seeking through it right we haven't um i think been as um clear you know as to what pathways students are completing and and where they can take it so i think that's a big part of it um you know having the the sports medicine the intro to sports medicine is something that we're really excited about and um obviously you know we talked a lot about athletics and i think one of

182our visions is to start with this intro to sports medicine and then build that into a concentrator and a capstone which i'm not sure if you're totally familiar with that but that's what they they call the two courses that students need to complete in order to be considered completers right which is what we're hoping for so if we have this intro to sports medicine that moves into a concentrator and a capstone with you know our students being out there on the athletic field taping their peers and and really supporting in that aspect so that's something we're super excited about and then the ECE so the early childhood pathway So careers in child development is in there. And we're really hoping to kind of streamline that process of students once they've completed that pathway. And then

183we're bringing in some CCAP courses, so classes from the JC, having students be able to graduate with the certification needed to then go work in a preschool, hopefully ours, right? That's the goal. And then move on to SSU with that, the MOU that we have with guaranteed admission. And then, right, there are teachers and they come back to us. So I think those are two big additions. that we're excited about and we really want to highlight the um the career pathways you know it's not just the academic piece but it's also the career pathways that we want to highlight cool thanks i mean i know heather's back there listening and that's part of the reason why i wanted to ask too is because the the um i i'm sure you guys do as well but

184i i've been inundated by parents this year and and the students about how They love our new freshman classes the way we have them set up. I mean, it's been received really, really well. at least from what I'm hearing and stuff, even to the point where I'm having some of the kids that I'm around that are sophomores going like, we got hosed because we should have had that earlier kind of a thing. And man, we could have done so much better if we would have had it and stuff. And so, you know, I'm hearing those kind of things that, so it's great to be around all of you innovators that are coming up with things. that sometimes are obvious, but no one ever does them or the unobvious things that, wow, that's like a light

185bulb idea. And so I appreciate everybody's efforts in that regard. Even Malinalli having. setting things up so that way the kids went over to Sonoma State. And I had one of our other freshman gals, she said, she was like, oh my God, she goes, coach, did you know that we can go to Sonoma State if we do good at Windsor? We get, boom, automatically they accept us and we're in. I'm going, yeah, I did. She goes, how did you know? I go, well, because I'm on the board. And I go, and people that. Teach over Sonoma State helped get you set up and stuff over there. And so anyhow, they're all excited. So the things that you guys are doing, even though they might seem like it's just a little thing here and a little

186thing there, all those little things add up to be a really, really good. a really really good experience for the kids across the board of however they want to plug in so that's why i was just curious more like watching a tv show i was curious as to like you know at the very end of a show they say you know this what's coming up next week so that's why i wanted you to tell me hey what's the cool thing exactly so anyhow but um thank you for this and and we'll do more reading and i'm sure we'll hear from from folks as well in between now and our next board meeting but thank you for the efforts Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. No other questions? I don't think so. All right. Reach out. You know

187where to find us. Okay. Appreciate you being here. So we don't have to do like a step. No. Yeah. Just like a board policy, right? We want to touch them so you guys have enough time. Okay, so now we'll go back to the original 7.2 and do the Cali Charter approval. This one is in action tonight because it's time sensitive for the enrollment. We've been searching and searching for the original Cali Charter. We found a version in paper with like some hand scribbled notes from, you know, prehistoric times, and we were able to scan it in and turn it into a digital document. And then we've just been updating some of the minor changes, like adding TK to K, you know, changing, you know, the the star test to the SBAC test and CIPSA to

188LCAP. But we did some major changes, and that was in the way that we are giving priority to enrollment based. So as a charter, we're allowed to give priority to two specific groups. particularly like if you live in the town that the charter is in or if you have a staff member or a sibling. So the biggest change is that we want to... If you've been to the Cali preschool and you've seen them in their tiny little uniforms with their tiny little backpacks, you can see that they are Cali's future. And we wanted to provide a pathway for those students to have a little bit of a preference. It's not a huge preference, but a little bit of a preference to be able to transition from the Cali preschool to Cali TK. um so what

189we did was is for one of the points um you can either get a point for having a sibling at cali because we think keeping families together is very important and then that same point could also be applied if you were part of the cali preschool you get another point for being a resident of windsor you get a point for being a child of a staff member that's both classified and certificated um and then you then everyone has access to getting the points for attending the family night and then signing the parent compact so the maximum number of points that anyone can get is five points um so if you get five points you're basically guaranteed to get in uh even if you get four points you're probably getting in and then we do a

190lottery for everyone that has three points two points one point So I don't have any questions, but I just want to say that I think we need a poster with these small children in their backpacks. And it says that they're the future. Because I remember a long time ago, I was on social media and I saw a picture of these little tiny, and I believe they were Kelly students. And they all had hard hats on because they were breaking ground at Kelly. And it was just so cute. And I feel like we need more of that. Thanks, Brian. So I've been sitting in these meetings and I. I really believe that we, like I love Cali as a program and advocate for it, but I also love to innovate and I think we should always

191strive towards excellence. And so something that I've been, that I brought up at our most recent meeting and that I will keep bringing up over and over and over again until I'm the squeaky wheel that maybe accomplishes something or maybe doesn't, is that language learning happens when you're young. like that's when it happens the easiest, right? Or, you know, I don't know the technical term, but we now have the option of offering preschool. And I think that Cali is the perfect place to go full steam with preschool and have that be like, we can really build the model for what this new. this 2.0 version of an immersion school can look like. And I think that we should jump at that opportunity. I'm someone who likes to take on those kinds of challenges and risks.

192And I think maybe that feeling is still a little bit new to the broader community. And so I would like to see us go even further with the points for preschool and like that we guarantee admission and that we build out the preschool, but there are a lot of concerns about, well, we don't have space and, you know, maybe parents don't want to send their kids to preschool at Cali, or maybe they don't want to send their kids to preschool at all. These were all things that came up at the meeting and to which I would say. then maybe they're not the right fit for this program because if you're wanting to teach in another language. preschool is the best if you want your child to learn a second language preschool is the best place

193to start absolutely but that could also come across as kind of harsh and non-understanding so I think we're in a good place but I would like to us to continue thinking about innovation and thinking about excellence and like how can we create the Cali 2.0 of this time period that also really comes from within cali because at the end of the day if it's not a grassroots kind of momentum driving that forward you know it it won't be as well received as we know um president ahmad i think all of us could be easily convinced um to change the point system once uh we have one more year of enrollment with preschool and make sure that the The preschool process is fully ironed out so that everyone has access to applying to the preschool. Because

194right now we've got like this many slots here and this many slots count for this many students and all of that. I think one more year, like when we, after we go through one cycle of enrollment and we bring this charter back to the board, after all of the language has been updated, I think we would have a much better idea how to make that vision happen. Yeah. i think that's a really good point too is that they're like i think the work on kind of who can get into preschool and how many spots there are and how that's prioritized like that should all happen in tandem so i think we're in a really good place i'm just really excited about the potential for what it could be and the type of language learning that

195could happen at this program we want to hear them say we didn't get into cali preschool now my kid can't get into stanford right thanks a lot windsor yeah exactly okay so if if i could everybody said innovative at the risk of being murdered um part of the problem that we have over cali is we just don't have enough space i know that an idea had been floated once before and then a whole bunch of arrows rocks boulders cars without license plates on them came flying at those who introduced the idea. So I'm going to try and reintroduce it in a way where I don't get murdered. Maybe an innovative thing that we could do is, and to Stephanie's point, that the kids learn the other language younger and earlier. If we were to create

196more space at Cali for more kids at those younger ages, we would be able to have more kids learning Spanish, going to Stanford, and having happy parents and everybody else. And one of the ways that we might be able to do that, and when I was reading this charter and the different things, the thought in my mind and the way that they talk about how the class is and how much they do Spanish at this, and then they have in their inner, all these different things. is maybe we should have a work session or something, invite everybody, so everybody's part of the whole deal, but maybe re-look at the idea of maybe in sixth grade or seventh grade, but maybe seventh and eighth, I don't know, have those kids maybe go and be part of

197a Cali junior high campus, maybe over at the middle school, where part of that campus, teaching just the Spanish part because I remember this if I read this right it's about 50 50 so as far as English learning and Spanish learning so maybe that those age groups those grades could be over there get their English stuff with mix in with the middle school kids possibly or separate I don't know I mean this is all to be this is just an idea when I read through this because we have room over at the middle school area that we could facilitate i believe six seven to an eighth maybe it's just seventh and eighth over there i know a lot of kids leave cali and go to the middle school because of the extracurricular offerings at the

198middle school that that aren't at cali so what if we integrated those over there those kids that they're not in those classrooms over there that gives us more classroom space for the tk stuff as well as other grades instead of having three third grade class, we could have four or five or whatever. But ever since some years ago when Sharon was talking about, well, we're going to need to lower our number of classes and this, it really just kind of just stabbed me in the heart because I'm like, we have such a great successful program and we're having to be stingy with it. And I kind of just come from this thinking that every kid wants to do something should be able to have the opportunity to do it. And I know that there's this,

199you know, if you keep it to where not everybody can get in, it creates kind of an urgency and it creates a little specialness to it and all that other kind of stuff. There's always going to be that anyway. But I'm just thinking. That if we could get all the players together, the community, everybody, and go, hey, what do you think about making more opportunities for more younger people? And the way we can do that, because we're limited just geographically, is to take some of those people in the higher grades where the Spanish part of it, and I could be wrong on this part. But where they're it's the Spanish and the English component is more 50-50. It's rich by middle school It's just a Spanish elective. So so it's it's not even it's what's

200it's an elective period Yeah, so so anyhow, I just wanted to throw that out there since we're doing this Yeah, if we could maybe put a thing with the workshop and we invite everybody just let's have a community forum and say hey We're looking for opportunities in which we can make more opportunities for more people One of the ways we could do that is this and any other good idea or better idea bring them, you know We'd like to listen to all of them and see if we can make that happen. So if we can increase You know 20% are available space for 20% more kids to I understand. Get that. Does that make sense? I understand. Anyhow, with this being here right now, I just kind of want to throw that out there that

201maybe this is something that we can start to motivate, not motivate, morph. And I think Malinale wants to respond. Don't kill me. So I'm going to try not to throw anything at you. But I just want to say, you know, that I so appreciate that you're always thinking like an entrepreneur, you know, thinking about numbers and increasing percentages, right? But however, I think that something that is not talked about enough or repeated enough is the magic of Cali. The magic of Cali is that it tends to be very generational. So for example, at the same school, you could have parents that are dropping off kids of many ages, right? So I think it would be difficult, for example, to have a satellite program of Kelly somewhere else, right? And then the second, you know, thing

202that I find very magical about Kelly is that it tends to be this super tight-knit community, right? So parents get to form relationships with each other. They see themselves as part of the community. One of the most beautiful things is that they see themselves as collaborators together with the teachers. You know, they're all working together, you know, for the betterment of the kids. And I think it's going to be, you know, just politically wrong, you know, to try to break up this community in that way. So I do, however, feel like you're right that this merits conversation in the future about, you know, how do we have enough space, you know, to accommodate the number of students that would like to be there. That is a good, good topic, I think, to look at maybe

203in a future meeting. But, you know, this. community that is part of Cali, the Cali family, if you will, they just see themselves as very, very, you know, tight knit. So, so I think if you start to break it up, then it's not what, what Cali has been. So I just want to say. Yeah. I'm, I mean, I think the, the, this has been a topic that we've talked about for years, right? And there, this has been an idea of like, how can we create more space or like, but I, what I've come to kind of believe is that It's not a decision that can come from outside like it has to be an idea that comes from inside that people want there like if they I think the question would just be the way

204I see it would just be how do you think you can create more space for preschool like that and it would be like we really want to hear from you and know because I've Kind of raised this, you know, we had a big meeting where we talked about this It was very it was kind of controversial a lot of people came But I still think there's value to the idea and thinking it through. And so, but I haven't seen people, like people feel that it's breaking it up. Like that's the perception, right? Is that it feels like it's being broken up. I kind of see it differently. I could see it also being potentially a really beautiful thing where like you could bring in these younger grades and then you could continue that somewhere else.

205But I also know that it's very sensitive and I really want to know. like if there's a desire at Cali to really have that conversation. So far, I haven't seen a strong desire. So that's kind of where I feel like things are. And I think anytime we try to come and say like, okay, we want you to do this, it's, I don't think it's perceived well and responded to well. I do want to say to Rich is I think what your parents want choice and we could do other schools of choice that provide more opportunities for enrollment in our lower grades to bring in those families. And there's lots of different models that we could explore that doesn't necessarily have to be on the Cali campus. Like we could build other programs, other places, and

206still make them programs of choice and give parents different opportunities for different types of education. I have one child who went through the middle school. I have one child who's going through Cali middle school. They are vastly different experiences. Both of them have positives. Both of them have drawbacks. There are experiences that my daughter at Cali is getting, being able to be a TA in the little kids class. She would never be able to do that in the middle school. And that has been pretty monumental for her. May end up making her a teacher by the end of this. But my other daughter got to go to so many more dances and play so many more sports and be around so many more people. But that's what she wanted. um rich i i think i

207think you're on to something and i think we have a lot of different ways that we could execute that see but part of what's making me think about you know mali my entrepreneurial right i'm a grandpa i've got two grandkids that are hispanic and you know we're considering you putting them in cali because i've learned so much being on the board about you know the reason i didn't have my kids go through cali because i felt inadequate That if they asked me a question, I mean, I don't speak Spanish. I mean, I wish I did, but I don't. How am I supposed to help my kid? It's a very humbling thing as a parent, like, you know, because I can help them with math. I can help them with the different things, but I can't

208help with Spanish. And so, and I don't want my kids to fail because I'm not able to help them, right? And so with Zach and Lily coming up. You know, where we think in that process again, I'm going, man, I'd really love to be able to have my kids go there. And then when you look at it, I'm reading this thing, we go through the number system thing like, oh, well, man, we're not. legacy. So we don't get that point. You know, we did whatever you'll. No legacy, I can't wait. I know. I'm just, I'm just using that. Just to clarify. I'm just, boy, those Stanford people sure do get sensitive about that word. Anyhow, but the point system. So maybe I'm aware of the point system and I can make sure I'm at all

209those meetings and try to get up to four or four and a half or whatever it is. Right. So maybe it gets back in. Some people might not know about it and they get caught behind. And I'm really a lot about choice and opportunity for kids, especially if you live in our town, right? And I know that there are people that did not get their kids into Cali and they really wanted them to. So I'm thinking like, how can we make this golden opportunity available for more people? And when I was reading this, I was going, heck, we're really not doing that much of the Spanish part in the older grades. i'm trying really hard not to be a smart aleck and go maybe they read that book in fifth grade then they're old enough

210to now go over to the to a new campus because they've graduated but anyhow um so let's just you know like you said have a dialogue later and do different things so sounds good i'm going to bring it back to the charter i'm going to move us along can i say one thing stephanie i think and i don't know if you had something to say but i saw you lean forward just um I understand and I want to support the staff's work on this. I have a really hard time with those preschoolers who are currently at Cali being told they don't get to go to TK. It's really hard for me to consider that as an option. simply because I know they feel like they're part of Cali right now. So I recognize that with

211the approval of this charter, that may happen. So I just want to make sure we all understand that, that those students may be told, well, you're not a Windsor resident and more Windsor residents have applied. So I'm sorry, but you have to go somewhere else. That's hard for me. Having said that, I recognize how we got here. And so I'm trying to support the process because there's a lot of people involved in this process. But I felt like I needed to tell you that at least. Yeah. Okay. Thanks, Jeremy. Any public comment on this item? No. Okay. Do I have a motion to approve the revised charter? And I believe another one will be coming later in the year. Yes, I'll make the motion to approve this. Do I have a second? I'll second it.

212Okay. All in favor? Aye. All right. Thanks. We'll move on to item 7.4, which is the developer fee appeal from Christofferson Holmes. Good evening, guys. So this item's a little interesting in the fact that you guys don't always get developer fee appeals. It's not uncommon for developers to come in and ask if they have to pay. And I will tell them, well, there is an appeal process. And if you feel like you have a reason for not paying, you can do this. And they never do. They just end up paying, right, realizing that it's just because they don't want to pay. This one's a little different, though. So you guys have the letter that's from Christopherson Homes. They are not appealing whether they pay developer fees. They're appealing whether they pay at the old rates

213or the new rates. And so I'm going to walk you through the timeline of adopting the developer fees and then basically their argument for appealing them. So on February 29th, we issued a 14-day notice. On March 4th, we made the justification study available, basically justifying why we needed an increase in developer fees. And then we had to do a declaration showing that all those documents were then made public at that time back in March. On March 10th, we had to submit another publication back in the newspaper. We did press Democrat both times. On March 11th, we had to then make all of this public in a board document item. And then on March 14th is when we adopted the new fees through a resolution, right? So all that to say is those fees then took

214effect two months later on March 15th. So those new fees took effect March 15th. On July 2nd, the town reached out to us and said that they would like the new updated fees so they could share it with the developers at a town hall meeting. We provided those to them. So then in November, Christofferson Homes came in and they were confused about the new fees being updated compared to the old fees. And the reasoning for that was that the town of Windsor had not yet updated the developer fees on their website. My recommendation, and I told Christopherson Homes this, was going to be to deny the appeal because the town of Windsor is a separate agency from us. We don't have control over their website. I have talked to the town of Windsor, and they

215basically said, you know, there's a disclaimer on all their documents saying they don't know if they're updated fees or not, and to check with the local jurisdiction. With that being said, though, part of their appeal letter is basically saying that this project is really difficult to pencil out and that the increase in developer fees would be roughly $100,000. And they would like to appeal and have us honor the rates that they were given by the town of Windsor. that is the appeal is there any questions for me i have a question do you know because at first i'm frustrated with the with the town i feel like this is kind of on them for not updating their website and that's yeah that's frustrating but i'm wondering do we know that this project will not go

216forward if they have because like guess I'm thinking like do we get are we making a decision between getting some developer fees versus getting nothing if we don't approve this and then they decide not even to move forward with the project and I know we do kind of need developer fees and we want students so kind of turn away how we should be thinking about this so three things there one I've talked to the developer president of the developer And she's under the understanding that we've done nothing wrong up until this point. She's just asking that we simply honor what the town of Windsor gave them. And she kind of understands that this would be money out of our pocket. Money, the dollar amount would be about $100,000. So she would still pay the old

217developer fees, but they're about $100,000 less than what the new fees would be. And then what was the third question? I know in the letter she talks about not being able to get financing. So does that mean the project wouldn't move forward if we said you need to pay these fees? Or they can, it's just tough. Because I think those are very different things. She was planning on being here tonight. An emergency came up and she got out. But I do not have the answer to that question. I don't know if she would go through with the project or not. Okay. The, um, okay. So on this particular issue, I just want everybody to know, I know the developer. I have no, well, I don't know Amy. I know her father, Keith. I've known him

218for a long, long time. Just awesome guy. Super active. Over 30 years of donating and doing all kinds of benevolent. things for communities all over the place. Nothing but just the highest level of respect for his community involvement and being a good person and all that stuff. And so that said, I understand the dilemma they're in. I likewise was in that same dilemma. I put in a permit five years ago with the county on my property, and then I revised that permit. Three years ago because it was taking so long on the county that my wife goes well Why don't we add that to it? So we had to do a new addition to the old addition and And I was waiting for my permit to come through the county so I could go ahead

219and get my building permit By the time the county actually said okay, and I knew this was gonna happen So I'm just letting you guys know and I want Keith and whoever else is listening when we voted for our building fees i knew this was going to cost me a lot more money because the county was dragging their feet on my building permit i don't know how the town of windsor and their project is going but i paid the higher fees um and so i know that the project they're talking about i followed it through the town i know that it's tight i know that they've been saddled with some really I'm going to use the word onerous mitigation that they have to take care of. And it's just an unfortunate part of the project.

220I mean, Stephanie, actually, your question was something really good I didn't think about is, is it better to get 400 grand than nothing at all? But it's a great question, but it's really not something that we can actually adjust because. that the fee is what the fee is and everybody has to pay it otherwise we're we're gifting funds um away um My recommendation to the town would be that on their website that they don't have a dollar amount that they just say, please get a hold, you know, have who they should get a hold of at the district office to get the rates that way. You know, it was an honest mistake. I mean, they're just doing they're posting something as a courtesy. When we're the ones that actually have the rates in there and

221whatever and so I don't think there was anything malicious anywhere But whether they had it posted correctly on their website Up-to-date or not the rate still had changed Sometime before they got their approvals and so You know, I I can't justify giving away the $100,000 when everyone else is having to pay the same amount, even though their project is super, super tight. Hopefully, now that rates are starting to come back down, hopefully that might give them some cushion because just a little bit of rate difference over a big project, not a big project, but a big number like that for them, hopefully will help make a difference. But I can't intellectually in any way justify waving that. I don't see a nexus anywhere that I could hang my hat on with any integrity and say.

222So unfortunately, I think they're going to have to do just like everyone else is doing and have to pay that fee. And if that project doesn't work, they might have to go back and go to the town and say, hey, this isn't going to work. We either have to kill the project or we have to change some mitigation that the town has a lot more deference I think to be able to move in that direction to give them help than than than we do um so that's kind of you know our I feel our hands are tied but that's just kind of our thing yeah I just make a motion recommendation Town fees change, our fees change in the fiscal year. Town doesn't set those fees. Town doesn't collect those fees. And I take their

223letter at face value, but I believe we should simply deny their fee appeal. Two agenda items. We're talking about budget shortfalls. Now, this is a specialty side fund for developer money for things, but yeah, I would make the motion that we not develop for fee appeal as presented. Okay. Do we have a second? all second okay and then do we have any public comment before we vote no okay all in favor aye aye Denying the appeal. To be clear. That's a yes to a no. Exactly. Okay. So now we have a couple openers, right? Remind me how the process is for the first 7.5 and 7.6. Are we just literally reading it? You're just accepting them and approving the Sunshine documents. Yeah. Okay. We're not like holding a hearing. No, you don't have to hold

224a hearing. And our Sunshine document will be coming next month in response. Okay. So item 7.5, we have approval of the Sunshine document for WDEA. Any discussion? I do. I have one question. And it's been here on for a couple years. Is the language that they... our partners have to send to you is it like specific so in other words we hereby demand that we meet that's always run me wrong i'm like that's not the way you say it's your management no no it's not even management it's just like it's management you guys constantly tell me that i have no filter and that i'm supposed to say things nicer there's a better way you know my wife's telling me no no you got to say things to your daughters differently than you do your sons

225and so i'm just curious is this is this a certain type of a uh boilerplate thing that they have to do because it'll be i'd be like Hey, WDA would love to meet with you guys and talk about how we can enhance everyone's positive mental attitude by getting raised or something along those lines. Well, it's just the demand part. And so I didn't know. I've always been curious. I'm not sure. I just assume it's how letters are sent. I mean, if you guys want to. And so I didn't know if they just copied and pasted from years on go. It's like 20 years ago, somebody. That's what I'm assuming. But I don't. That was a good word. I don't know. I've never thought about it, to be honest with you. I don't know if you

226want to say anything, Susanna. go ahead come on give it to me oh excuse me legal ease is not by osmosis demand to bargain it's just so it is okay sorry that's it thank you cool okay great i thought so curious we're covering all our bases tonight so for for both of these i'm kind of curious what it is we're approving we've received received the openers do we acknowledge that we've received them and then we're going to send our response because the items are both that we're approving the proposal for contract negotiations I think yeah you have to approve that you know we're we're going to accept their Sunshine letter and then enter into negotiations there that's really what you're approving and then we have to also get our Sunshine approved by you as well

227so um so i don't know that's why they're demanding to bargain right so basically no we're not bargaining so they've they've asked to bargain and so when we say okay we're basically giving you permission to go ahead and bargain with them is that kind of more or less we have another comment go ahead our response say we like we'd like it's it's required for public notice yeah good yeah thank you so do i have a motion on 7.5 would you make it rich i demand that our staff engage with our partners and do your opener things that we're supposed to where we we trade demands to each other i think that's it was that that was our that was my that was my version of purple motion for approval second okay all in favor aye

228That was both, right? No, you got the second one. That was just for the first one. So we're going to do CSEA next. Please sneak right up here, CSEA, now that we've set the table. Yeah. You're not required to make public comment, but if you would like to, you're welcome. They only desire to. If you desire, then we demand your presence at the podium. No. Okay. Okay, do I have a motion on 7.6? Or if you want to go. i desire that our admin team work with these folks and work out a good contract that's what happens after 9 00 p.m yes yes okay all in favor aye aye okay moving on to 7.7 austin thank you for waiting consideration of approval of 24 25 first interim financial report all right so This is the

229first budget presentation where I've ever had that has been a qualified budget Been a CBO seven years Jeremy's been a superintendent 12 years. He's never had a qualified budget either So this is our first one I will say if I was going to have one I'd want it to be something because of a big surprise that there's no way we could have known and this one had that so at least there is that but let's dive into it brian can you click me all right so what does qualified means you know for us there's three different certifications when we certify a budget there's positive qualified and negative so positive is the school district can meet its financial obligation meaning we're good all three years qualified means the school district may not for the subsequent years.

230And then negative is the school district may not meet it in the current year. So those are the three disconditions. The definition of financial obligation means that 3% of total expenditures. So right now we have $70 million is our total expenditures in our budget. So 3% of that, roughly 2.1 million. We can't have our unrestricted, meaning the money we can use for anything, fall below 3%. I think that's also an important distinction when we talk about fund balance reserves, right? So... we you know there's always a discussion about what reserve percentage is appropriate right i've had a school district where we had a 200 reserve right we had double the amount in our fund balance that we had in expenses um and then i've had some where we're at five percent right there's always going

231to be the argument about it but i think it's important to note that the three percent isn't a recommendation from ed code it is the requirement at which if you fall below that you are now considered qualified and then when you fall below that or negative right so i think that's an important distinction to make um there we go so these are the assumptions i have a red bar up there because that is an area i want to talk about if you look at enrollment projections though there's one thing that's important to note there as it relates from changes from the last budget presentation which was in june So our enrollment projections in June, we had estimated this year to be about 4,710 students. So we came in very close to that overall. I did

232get lucky though, because I thought that they were gonna be at the high school and middle school levels that we'd see that increase, but they were actually at the elementary levels. And because of that, in the out years, you can kind of see that that enrollment kind of stays higher, right? We've always had, historically Windsor has lost. about 100 150 students for a long time but as they come in at those younger grades it kind of flatlines one of the things that i do want to do a deep dive into in the spring as we start projecting for the following year is seeing exactly where those students that did come to us if they were in a district before or where they might have came from because i'd want to see if they were students

233that may be becoming later to us like in seventh grade because you know we get a big bump of students from mark west so maybe some of those students are coming here earlier right so i'd look at those things later on down the road So the enrollment percentage enrollment to attendance percentage so those are higher percentages than we've had Historically in Windsor that 94 and a half is because we came in higher last year than I was expecting Jeremy and I had a bet a couple years ago, and then he wouldn't bet me last year You should have you would have been right last year. We've been 50-50, but you didn't so we I had projected roughly high 93s, and we came in about 94.4, which is great because when we did our roadshows, the

234number one question that was getting asked by teachers was, how can we help, right? And we talked about attendance. We talked about unduplicated percentages, right? And so seeing that enrollment, you know a lot of it is because of those conversations and teachers kind of doing the due diligence. conversations have continued and the other major changes to independent study so independent study now because of short term we can have students make up work by taking homework packets home or whatever it may be and coming back and being counted as attendance so we've created a plan and because of that I feel like I need to bump up our projections for that so you start seeing 95 and a half percent in the two out years I don't think Windsor has ever had a projection of more

235than 94% in this district in terms of what our ADA percentage was going to be. And then it also should be noted that the enrollment projections, we've talked a lot about development in town. They just don't seem to be finishing. So specifically Shiloh, we're supposed to see almost one student per dwelling in Shiloh. That was supposed to be completed in 2023. It's still not completed. One project's projected to be completed in the spring, the other one in the fall or in the winter, actually. But again, at this point, it's pretty tough for us to project those students and when they're going to come because we simply, they keep pushing this back. So it should be noted that those students are not within those numbers, correct, Austin? Absolutely. And that's why you're seeing a slight decline.

236It's not like the declines we had for... you know 12 years but a slight decline because those students are not in those numbers all right so let's look at the unrestricted the yes what's that black dot i don't know what the black dot is either sorry i told the money no it's that one okay yeah i don't know what the black dot is that's 1.4 million 985 if you want to know 985 is what's behind the black dot okay thank you stephanie so as we look at um the three-year projection for our unrestricted side right because we talk about wanting to look at unrestricted because it's kind of your structural piece of it and then the restricted side is all your grants And then obviously if we have grants that go negative, we have to

237cover it with unrestricted, meaning like for instance, we'll show a special education slide later. If special education brings in $4 million and they spend 12 million, we have to cover that $8 million negative from unrestricted. in this district we are lucky in the fact that we only have two programs that do run negative it's special education and maintenance but maintenance is a a education code calculation you have to spend three percent of your budget on maintenance um so that's just a flat requirement whereas um some districts will have to cover other programs like elop or title one or whatever it may be right So looking at 24-25, that was kind of the change that led to us being qualified at this budget period. We had a surprise within special education that I'll talk about in

238a little bit later of a slide. But I don't have to read the numbers to you guys. You guys can see. And that red box shows that that number now falls below that 2.1 number that I had mentioned priorly. Austin, can you share at Adopted Budget what the anticipated excess was for 2425 before our surprise? Do you remember that number? Yeah, it was roughly 3.8 as well. And it had to do with, well, partially it had to do with a lot of things, but. We did see an increase in our LCFFs or attendance percentage So because that attendance percentage went up but then enrollment declined by 17 We did see a revenue increase of roughly 400,000 to help equate some of that million dollar surprise special ed cost And then on top of that, you

239also had what they called the fair market value of cash. So because that was at year end not included, the fund balance numbers beginning and ending change. Sorry, that was really into the weeds. But the ending fund balance for that first year was... roughly the same, but because we had the additional $1 million increase this year for special ed, you had to carry that out into the three years. So it was really like a $3 million hit, if you think about it that way. So special education. So there's an adopted budget in first interim. So this is the million dollar increase that we're kind of referring to. The expenditures, I think it's important to note that at adopted, we had $13.5 million. That was already about a million-dollar increase from the previous year. And then

240now we're up another million to $14.5. We did a deep dive into special education to try to figure out why this unexpected increase happened. We found a couple of things. One revolved around non-public students. uh we had some students move out but the students that moved in were much higher cost to give you an idea one was roughly 220 000 just one student and then some others were over a hundred this obviously is because they have higher needs and so in order to meet those needs they need more supports which in turn leads to more money so that's you know that's one of the surprises in this the other surprise was additional students with ieps coming into the district so when i say coming into the district i mean they they move into the district

241boundaries and they live here right so now we have to we service them because of the increase in students with ieps we have our staffing at a certain number let's call it 20. With additional students with IEPs, instead of having additional positions created and us flying them and then hiring for those positions, we had a contracted agency that we use in the event that a paraprofessional does not come to work. We have them come in to substitute. What was lacking was the process that we have for approving positions to where we're aware of them. We had paraprofessionals coming in to help cover those additional students without the positions being approved, so therefore we weren't aware of it. Now, we still would have needed to have them, right, because we still have to service those students.

242However, we would have known about this earlier, and it wouldn't have been a surprise come first interim. And that's so each of those, so now public school students equated about $500,000 of the million, and then the paraprofessionals, eight of them, which is what we've had to contract for roughly, you know, well, that is the other $500,000. So those two things added up to about a million dollars that we didn't anticipate. And I will say, too, because I think this is important to note. When I look at different programs, like, for instance, special education, I think it's always important to take into account, like, the cost of living. Because if you're going to give raises, you don't just give raises to certain funded people. You give them to everyone. So, you know, special education teachers will

243get a raise, so the cost for special education goes up. I think it was abnormal to see a $2 million increase from one year to the next, especially with a cost of living adjustment of 1%. So I think that's important to note as well. So this is the combined. So this is our budget with everything included. This is unrestricted and restricted. Obviously, I have you guys focus on unrestricted, but I want you to see the combined and total budget. The hard thing right now with restricted is we had such an influx of one-time money that as we got that money and we made plans to then spend it down you're gonna it's gonna this piece of the budget's gonna look like it's deficit spending when it the You we are deficit spending and unrestricted, but

244it's better to focus on that piece of it and know exactly how much we are deficit spending So as we look at the combined budget You know, you can see our beginning fund balance of 14.3 kind of slowly dwindling down to 6.2. And we know of that 6.2, roughly 1.4, 1.5 of it is unrestricted. And then the rest are all grants, whether that's learning recovery, educator effectiveness, so on and so forth. So we make sure all of those programs live within their means and if they're not living within their means then we have to go and address them because we don't want to have a general fund contribution to all those restricted programs. So that's why we constantly talk about unrestricted and ultimately what does the state go look at when they're looking at our

245budget? They just look at our unrestricted budget. Correct. So this is our fund balance. So this is when you look at everything combined, right? So you see the restricted, committed, or assigned. I don't have to read you the numbers, but that reserve for economic uncertainty, that can only be filled with those unrestricted dollars. And because of that dollar amount of $1.4, you could look and see that our total ending fund balance, we have $6.2 million. But that's not what the state looks at when it looks at the 3% reserve. It looks at the $1.4 number because they need to know if you... have to be solvent, you can only use this money. So therefore, we're only going to look at that money. I think a reasonable question from you guys would be, how did we

246get here? Right? I mean, we knew that we were going to be deficit spending. But in some senses, you, us, we rolled the dice on those developments getting done. And they haven't been done yet. So that's put us in a tough spot. And In the past we've been able to hold out because we've had a general we've had a fund balance so we can wait right We're saying well, they're coming and we're okay. Problem is they're taking so long. We're three years later now, right then our first blush we thought they were coming three years ago and We're getting to this point where we're not gonna be able to continue to kick this can and say our fund balance is gonna cover us Because they're taking too long. So that's what that's part of how

247we got here. This was anticipated but then the extra million really put us in a bad spot with special education i think i have to do a quick motion to keep the meeting going because we're after is it after 9 45 or after 9 30 that we have to okay so why don't we pre pre pre-game i'll make a motion that we extend the meeting to 10 o'clock okay so i'll second oh you second all in favor aye aye okay back to the items so jeremy this this re this thing that Austin's putting together. This is, I'm having a deja vu moment because when Stephanie and I were first on the board like six years ago, it was almost this exact type of thing. The board earlier had saved up a pretty good chunk of

248dough. And then with COVID and all kinds of stuff, you know, we kind of ate away at it. And so then, and then it's kind of gone back up, but now we're kind of eating. And I'm wondering if this is kind of a cycle of schools. And I don't know, I haven't been on a board long enough, but, but I'm just glad that we have it. I guess the question, I mean, well, I'm going to save my, well, I'll just, do you mind if we just jump in? Are there any more slides, Austin? uh yeah we have cali and that's it well why don't you just go ahead and do those and then we'll just okay so this is cali um you know we focus on the district a lot because ultimately if cali were

249to go under the district have to cover it everything kind of stems through that general fund of the district so you look at cali uh you know their their budget looks a lot different um Cali only has combined and when you submit it obviously I can go through and filter out to see on my end what's unrestricted and what's Restricted but Kelly's budgets a lot more balanced per se because obviously they receive the same restricted program so a large chunk of that 1 million 62 is uh restricted about 600 000 of it is restricted funds that are being spent down uh so they're showing to be fairly balanced for the budget of their size in that current year um and then i don't need to read the numbers to you in the two out years

250in other words cali we're okay with cali's budget okay with cali that's takeaway rich okay so Being a business guy, it's revenue, expenses, all those kind of things. One is, what is our, and also going through these things, you know, you can see what's, what is our, how much more room do we have at the high school that we can increase enrollment by? Easily. A couple hundred more kids. At least 200, yeah, 2,000 students. Okay, so there's... 2,200 is the total is the maximum capacity that is in our demographic study, but that's that's Hard that we sardine. Yes. Well, yeah, but but easily 200 Well, so there's there's two million there, right? yes if we could get those students yep okay so um but remember you also have to add teachers right it's not it's

251not a a net but it's it's a something so i think we're doing a good job of and with the things that we're doing now with the new catalog and we're going to be attracting potentially even and we are running a campaign actually heather i haven't shared that with you but heather's running a campaign for the middle school and the high school you know in our in our our uh whatever with what are anyhow we have friends in santa rosa they're doing a wonderful job of helping us get more yes sir um folks so that that's on on the one side my my real concern if i was looking at my company and i'm going through all this stuff i'm going wow our special education i'm uh we had a speaker earlier asked that we

252have a big meeting all i think that's great and i think we need to bring this this thing with us to that meeting And we need to say, hey, look, right now, our regular education students are subsidizing our special ed students to the tune of about $10 million a year. And my understanding is that I guess the federal government is not sending. Their share of what is supposed to be coming in correct to help cover that expense They're supposed to be covering 60% of the cost and they cover nine. I believe it currently is the highest they've ever been a 17% Okay, so if the feds are 50% they're short 50% I'm gonna call that five million dollars if you know just discussion so What I'm hoping I don't know I don't recall ever seeing

253this slide before. Is this the first time we put it together? First time because it was very relevant to this one. Yeah. This is like a real big slap in the face of, wow, how have I missed this before or not paid so much attention or however? Maybe it hasn't been as dramatic or it has been. It's been significant for a while. It's been significant for a while. Yeah. I mean, I remember we had a discussion some couple of years ago that I think. 20% of our budget, I think, is special education in Santa Rosa and other schools are closer to like 9 or 10. I couldn't tell you their budgets. And don't hold me to those exact numbers, but we've always asked, what's so special about Windsor's special education program that seems to be

254a magnet of people wanting, what are we doing extra special? Which we never, ever hear the answer to that. But anyhow, so I think we need to do a potpourri of a whole bunch of different things. One, let's continue to... Keep creating this awesome Education place up here for families want to have their kids go to school here. That's one that that helps So our enrollment isn't declining but actually growing to where we're busting at the seams, which is awesome but to this big this is a huge deficit and I Think we need to kind of start to dig a little bit into How do we recapture this money? Is there money out there in the form of grants and other things that we're not maybe aware of, that we could be aware of? And

255on top of that, maybe we need to get our high-level legislators, the biggie dudes, that do feds and stuff and say, hey, where's our money? I mean, here's senators. You're not sending us our money. I mean, you're asking us to do a job. Which is a noble and virtuous and benevolent job, but you're not giving us the money that it takes to do that So how do you expect us to do that? Good job. I've actually had a come just so you know rich Okay, I have met with congressman Huffman. We've had this discussion directly and he is the most major advocate in the country With regard to special education funding and he's from here, but you know, he, his words are falling on deaf ears and have been for many, many years. I think

256he's been in Congressman for at least 10 years. Yeah. Down center fell or somewhere down there. He represents our area, but, but maybe. If our school board, if this is happening at Windsor and if it's happening, it's happening everywhere. That's what my point. If it's happening everywhere, then maybe it's a thing where this needs to become a point of focus for all the districts to get together. to then get together and it is it does that make sense yeah and as you guys know i'm one of the chairs for leadership 40. uh we just met with elizabeth engelken who is our selpa executive director because she is going to be presenting to the superintendents of the county with regard to this specifically so we were setting that agenda so that we can start to talk

257about different strategies for districts and and i mean i could show you the agenda but it is a conversation it's a hard one to solve because really we talk about special education as like the problem but i wouldn't necessarily say that the problem they're they're they're having to teach the students who are having a hard time learning in our general education classes and so this is a very complex problem to solve right and i think it's one that we've been talking a ton about and really it comes back to as paul constantly says it's first instruction that's part of it um and we need to really make sure we can Build up our best first instruction so students may not need special education services at the extent that they do currently in Windsor Right. Well,

258I mean, I've always thought that there are certain things that kids They might need two drops help mm-hmm and it's all they need and and yet they're given five or six when they don't really need them and vice versa some need seven and they're only given three yeah I'm a little sensitive to the issue I mean my older brother he got hit by a drunk driver when he was eight years old and he needed he would be considered what we would call a very expensive person that needed a lot of extra help. And so for him to do well. So we have that responsibility. Yes, sir. And I get that. I'm trying to figure out how we politically say, hey. Government give us I'm just gonna okay. I don't mean to be political but I'd

259sure as hell rather spend our money on Having the state and the federal government close this gap We can put battery operated cars and a whole bunch of other Projects that seem to be politicians favorite thing of the day Put those on a back burner. Let's take care of our kids first And make sure that those things are funded and then all everybody else's special little projects, you know If there's any money left over they can do those. I'm sure I'm not making any friends right now At some of those higher levels, but again Our kids are the one thing We all agree should be priority number one and so maybe we need to to Get the California that you know, I'm not more than its part. Just know that because we had this to

260our special education workshop we're not going to fix this tonight got it okay okay any other comments on think and thank you rich like well well said um any other comments on the agenda or sorry yes i'm losing my mind on the First interim. Yes. So this is just going back to something that Trustee Carnation said about, actually, I was the person that recommended that we have a workshop about special education resources. So when I said that, I didn't intend for that to be a discussion about the budget. I just really wanted the full roadmap of all of the resources within our district when a child is a special education student. So that's different than this. We could do all of the above because it's very, very special education is a nebulous term in a

261lot of ways. It really is. Students are very different depending on what's in their IEP and what their needs are. Yes. And the only important distinction for me, at least in my eyes, is that the workshop that I suggested was to specifically look at our school district from the eyes of a student and their family. Right. And I think that this. also needs to be covered you know obviously we have more discussions about this budget but really just taking time to look at what does our school district look like for the family that has a special education student you know like what were all of the resources that they could possibly connect with I don't know if that makes sense. You look confused. Yeah, I mean, I think we're going to have a workshop on

262special ed. We should have it be comprehensive. I get the perspective that you're talking about. And Rebecca Cumming, I had not heard the term typical to describe a non-disabled student before. But it's all in, right? What we can offer is based on what we can afford. So, but we can talk about the makeup of that. I would just urge us that we, you know, we receive it. This is troublesome. We need to do something. But there are things coming afoot, I think, after this first interim. and i believe the the action is to accept approve what are we doing yeah approving the budget as qualified as this So I would... And our intention is to not be qualified second interim. We have to find the ways to not be qualified, and we need time for

263that. Thanks for reiterating that, because that was the sense that I had, is that this is not where we want to be, and we can figure out a way out of this. But I would like to address the further fleshing out of what's included or not included in the special education workshop, because I think that's important as well. That's why I was... patting rich on the arm and said that's all interesting points but we're not going to solve that today i mean we're just highlighting that we have a hole in the bucket and we need to be doing something about it so i would make the motion that we approve the first interim and do we need to specifically say the word that we are representing okay first interim financial report is all second okay

264thank you do we have any public comment okay all in favor aye aye it is a blue Okay, we're on our last item, 7.8. This is the preschool project. We've all had the opportunity to review the presentation. So give us your, you know, the Cliff Notes version and your recommendation. I mean, go through it, but yeah. Oh, I think your mic might not be on. Got it. All right. So. We've got a couple problems with our preschool project. We lack the space to expand the program, which is required with our grant, our contract. And if we only maintain our current levels, our funding gets reduced to about a million from almost three and a half million. We also, since we didn't pass a bond, we lack the requisite money needed to build this preschool campus

265because the cost is somewhere between 7.4 to 10.2 million, depending on which buildings are chosen to move forward with. This is the project. You can see it's broken into three phases. Phase one is three classrooms. Phase two is an administrative building. Phase three are two more classrooms that we have slotted for potential special education students. We also have an optional play area that would be phase three. Some numbers for you to know our annual funding is 3.4 million required number of students to be served is 240 slots and remember I want to say slots because each student generates a different number different amount So we're currently serving 102 students and they represent 158 slots And if you go down below and you look, just look at full-time because we aren't actually going to do anything

266with part-time. We had thought about it. The ADA generated for a three-year-old, which is what we're focused on, is 1.8. And for special education students, it's 2.4. We have been utilizing our TK classrooms to bump up our numbers because right now we are still early in terms of having all four-year-olds in classrooms. But next year, that goes away. all four year olds are required to be educated in California next year. So we cannot count any of those students in our in our preschool numbers next year. It really does go down to those three year olds who are not enrolled in TK. Right now, I should say our maximum number of students that we can serve if we don't do anything is 90 and we need 240. There's some big impacts if we delay the implementation

267because you might just say well, let's wait and let's hope we can pass a bond in the future, right? But we would lose out on quite a bit of money. So if you look at the timeline on the right 2425 That's where we're at right now. Our current allocations 3.4 million The reason we can get that money is because we're in a hold harmless period we get to build up our program and then have to expand it Let's say we didn't do anything and we only serve the number of students that we have classrooms for That number drops down to $1 million, so we lose $2.4 million. That's not exactly right, though, because if we did build, we'd have to add staff and whatnot. So really, our actual loss of funding is about $1.9 million

268if we don't do anything here. Same thing in 26-27, and then you get to 27-28. Everything goes great. We pass a potential bond, and then we could build. We would hopefully get back up to that allocation, but we would have lost $3.8 million over those two years. That's important when you see the costs in the future. Bigger concern, though, is if we give up those 240 slots, no guarantee we get them back. So if you go down to the third bullet point, we took advantage of Governor Newsom expanding the slots for preschool by 500,000. Prior to that, it had been five years before any slots had been added. There are only this, there's a, there's a set amount of slots in the state. And right now we have some of them. We have 240. If

269we give up those 240 and somebody else comes in and says, oh, I want those slots. They're not available. There's no guarantee we get them back. We might, but there's no guarantee. So that's the bigger concern than even the money. So let's talk about funds available. This is as I see things. developer fees, about $1.6 million could go to this project. CSPP, we don't utilize every dollar that we get for the grant. And so there are some extra money in there that we could potentially tap into for facilities. We are projected to get reimbursement for our Maddie Washburn portable replacement project in 2025, about $2 million could be used. Community redevelopment funds anticipated that we could use about $200,000. And then I'm recommending that we potentially utilize some of the money we've received from the

270Litton Band of Pomo Indians donation years ago. That puts us at about $5.15 million in terms of funds potentially available. It doesn't mean we have to use them, but it's me saying I think we could do that with these funds. But I told you it's between $7.4 and $10.2 million cost. Different options. We could try to add some bathrooms at Maddie Washburn in some of the classrooms. Cost about $120,000. I put culture killer there because what would probably happen is we would displace some of the TK teachers that are currently in their classrooms. They'd probably move over to where I put that red X and the preschool would probably then move into those classrooms. Those TK students are young. Therefore, you like to have them in a. area that's fenced they wouldn't be they would

271also have to walk all the way over to the playground in order to play So this is affordable. The downside is it really affects our staffing at Maddie Washburn. We're going to do a quick extension. Do I have a motion to extend by 15 minutes? I'll move to extend to 1015. I'm almost there. We have many seconds and all in favor, I'm sure. I'm in. So option two would be to add portables. I kind of marked out areas you could potentially add portables. I mean, it'd be somewhere between $750,000 and a million dollars to add these portables. Obviously, there's, I mean, it impacts Maddie Washburn in the sense that it would ugly up the campus pretty good it's affordable downside is we're adding portables versus permanent classrooms on the campus and i don't know if

272they would fit here or not this is me just looking at a google map just real quick if if we went option two we put the portables on there correct bond passes in two years we have the money to build this thing what does it cost us to then have the portables gone away oh that's a good question rich do we have to be in a just just rough and dirty do we have to be in a um And when you get a portable, is it like a one-year contract, a five-year, three-year? You can purchase them. You can lease them. There's a lot of different things you could do. Austin, what was it going to cost to remove the ECC portable? About $500,000 for two portables, so about $250,000 each. They're really expensive. They're just

273as expensive to remove as they are to put in. Got it. So the cost in is almost, yeah, so it's, okay, thank you. Yep. Option three is build phase one. You know what the phase one is. Again, this is at the adjacent park. No impacts to Matty Washburn's campus. Guarantees we get our full allotment, but it's not the full program and we wouldn't have any area, no administrative building. We would have to be bringing in food because there would be no place to prepare. We would need to take out a loan or dip into pots of money that are dangerous to dip into, like deferred maintenance or a general fund, which you all know already, we don't have any general fund dollars that we could really dip into. Option four, cost of $8.4 million. That's

274adding the admin building to the three classrooms. Again, you know, I think you guys can figure out the analysis here. I don't have to go through it. Then there's option five, which is to build all phases. This, you know, is the greatest cost of 10.2 million. But all the analysis from before is the same. This option, though, allows us to take advantage of the funding by the state to meet our ADA requirement because special education students generate 2.4 ADA. Remember those slots that we get to? I remember a lot of these special education students would be speech only potentially students. We're required to educate and we're going to need the space anyway. And we give them a head start. It also allows us to accommodate any IDTs at Maddie Washburn. We discussed doing a campaign

275again at Maddie Washburn, but actually backed off because we want to make sure we have space at Maddie if we're going to have students coming to us. So we've made the decision, the hard decision, to not do any campaign for Maddie Washburn and to just focus on the high school and middle school because we know they have capacity and we're worried about capacity at Maddie Washburn. Downside is of course costs. We would have to take out a loan of anywhere from five to 10 million, depending on which dollars we used. So. If you had to borrow money. Yes. It'll be at the higher 88. So is there a nexus of what would be generated? If we lose those 240 slots, we are not going to get it. And that's the fear. I haven't seen anything

276in California. It can be think it's going to be any different. It doesn't get better. It seems to be getting worse. So are we, can you guys figure out what the difference is? Do you need us to vote on this tonight? Yes. Here's why. Do you have a recommendation? Let me ask you this, Austin. What is the amount that we would generate minus our costs for the teachers and everybody? What's left over? And is that enough to service the interest on that note? Yeah, it's roughly about a million. The hard part, though, is if you the hard part is if you were to charge the loan completely to the preschool program, then in the future, we wouldn't be allowed to charge the preschool program for services that are rendered to them. So like we can

277charge them rent. So like as of now, we could charge the preschool program rent that would go back to the general fund for the rest of however long we have it in their solvent. um that option would be taken away uh in the future if we were to well i don't care how we package it yeah we can have it in five different cups and move it all around but the bottom line is we have we would have a differential of about a million yeah correct okay so so that i i would feel very comfortable that that is more than enough to service know what the interest rate would be on that if we went for option five and had that whole amount and had to I have reached out to two entities that I

278won't name that have both stated they would be willing to offer us a loan at good rates, potentially, if we were to do. I would say you asked me my recommendation. It's either three, four, or five. I don't think we should do portables. I want to get away from them. I don't think we should disrupt the campus at Maddie Washburn any more than it already has been. So I would say it's one of the options, and it really depends on who we want to be. we could do the bare minimum but this is one of our flagship programs and if we don't have a space for families to come in i don't know if we're going to get the the families that who might come otherwise because we've got three classrooms with fencing around it

279and we're preparing for future construction and it's not going to look like the warm inviting place you want to drop your three-year-old off at and you've got to remember many of these families they're trusting us with their little their baby So I think it's really dependent upon who we want to be. We can service our grant with just three classrooms. We can. We can make it work. But is that what our focus is? Or is this a program that we're hoping to bring in families to become Windsor families and to stay with us for the next 13 years? So I think where I'm at is I feel really optimistic about our team and about what we can do. But I think back to the last item, and I think you could kind of look at,

280okay, we just said that we're qualified, and now we're going to do this. I have total faith we're not going to be qualified. I have total faith we're going to pay our staff well, and we're going to give raises. I know we're not supposed to negotiate from the dice, but I have faith that we're going to do all the right things. and that we can still do this but i tend to be a little bit more risk tolerant i think and i because i see it as an investment and i know the team who's behind it and so i feel confident that we can pull it off but i don't know if i'm just one it's important that i interject though because you got to look at all of these these are these are restricted

281funds right so we're not talking about these funds are not available for raises got it that's a one-time fund that's not ongoing speaking generally like how i think like it would be perceived if someone were just watching and they're like well i just wanted to be it's important to note because i wouldn't have i could have put general fund in here i chose not to obviously right i um i have concerns about all that bill go ahead i'll go yeah i just have concerns about um the ability that the school district has to be able to predict how many students would be utilizing Maddie Washburn that are students with disabilities and what their needs are because you said that it was mainly I think you said hearing challenges? Speech. I'm sorry, speech. But Jessica is

282really the expert here. Yeah, I just have concerns about that because I feel like that has been You know, one of the really complicated matters that we have been looking at is, you know, that we've had all these students, you know, that have multiple needs. And I think it's been hard for us to predict, you know, like what is the extent of their needs, as was mentioned before. And the students that we're talking about are students that we're already currently serving. They're located on the Maddie campus in Portables. and we're offering them a better space over with the preschool. We already have all of those speech students. The current system doesn't allow us to offer them a preschool environment, which would actually increase their ability to speak so much better because they'd be with their

283peers. Right now they're only offered, I think it's 45 minutes, either once or twice a week. So we're increasing our services for our current um families our current windsor families only we're not talking about bringing in you know students from outside of the district to serve those um special ed slots that we're hoping to fill or that we're planning for like let's say that we had the best of all worlds and you know we get this option number four you know and everything works out you know to our favor uh if you know the um current projects that are supposed to be developed in the town you know if they send their children to Maddie Washburn. Doesn't that present another larger variable for the future? Yeah, and it's a greater argument to have those two

284classrooms because then we have space. There are also SDC preschool classrooms on Maddie's campus. So we've said these could be for special education. Those two classrooms are just classrooms, right? So we're going to put the students in those classrooms that make the most sense. If it's an SDC preschool, it could be. If it's speech, it could be. um if it's typical students as rebecca mentioned it could be typical students in those classrooms as well it depends on you know the decisions that are made based on the interest in our preschool program but what it does also do is it could relieve some of the pressure on the maddie washburn campus because we currently have three-year-olds in classrooms on the campus and if those developments do happen and we are at capacity at Maddie Washburn, then

285it could relieve some of that stress and we could have one or two classrooms available to take on some more students. It just depends on a number of different things. Yeah, I mean, I agree with you. I think I wanted to hear you say it, but I agree with you because after taking a tour of that school, I see the need and I see why it's limited, right, in terms of infrastructure, why it's limited. So I totally get that, but I still have concerns. I almost wish. that we had this mapping of all of the resources for special ed kids before making this decision, but I realize it's time sensitive, right? It is. But I do have concerns because I remember the last time that we reviewed our budget and we had this big discussion

286about what the future held, a lot was... at least in my mind, hinging on, you know, these new developments in town. And obviously, like, we see where we are today, right? So I have concerns. That is all I'm saying. I wish I had more information. I'm supposed to tell you when to go. I'm sorry. Go ahead, Rich. I'll go. Just so you guys know, my wife's been looking for, we have the little, what do you call them, littles or whatever. There's a waiting list. Yeah. Although you can't put a kid in, there's nowhere for kids to go right now. Everywhere that there's a place for kids to go is, you got a waiting list a mile long. So I have zero concern about us filling up. And our program is way cheaper than all of

287those places. That is not a lie either. And so. I have zero concern about us filling up, being at capacity. I am concerned that if we don't do this, that when the development of these buildings that have been built in Windsor, they just haven't quite inhabited them yet, we're going to get rushed with people that are going to be coming in, notwithstanding the lists of people that aren't even able to get served right now. So anyhow. I look at this just like we did a few years ago over at Cali. And there was a nice building and a nice program that people wanted to be part of. And we made the investment and it's paying huge dividends. And I think we need to do the same thing here. And we have a responsible financial way

288to make it work with the help of some people that have volunteered. So the issue presented to us, I understand it, Jeremy, is the scope of the project. Yes, sir. And to hold those 240 spots, we need to at least build option three, which is $7 million and some change. I support the building out to option five, which is $10 million. And if you go back to the screen that we had, because we just added $100,000 to our developer fees. by getting those people to pay it's about a million dollars a little less than a million dollars to carry 10 million dollars of debt that's what rich didn't say but and at our bond pass we wouldn't be having this discussion but in doing this we are leaning into the fact that yeah we need

289to get a facilities bond maybe slightly different or whatever but that bond will come in and pack back pay off this loan but we have from this even if we just use this for the debt the four or five years of liquidity to pay to get the full project done the right way for this what I think is one of the flagship things certainly for the campus at Maddie Washburn so I would suggest that we from the what I understand you're looking for is which which option are what's the scope I would I would make a motion that we you know adopt option number five the full 10 million dollar build out you can come back to us with that information direction from the board and tell us by the time we meet in january

290we're on track we're or gosh what we thought from loans or other things didn't pan out but i think you're just looking for direction and it is a risk to be sure i mean we're we're in a setback for this and some other things as we you know we have a bond workshop on the 14th of january so we want to get ahead of ourselves but i don't think we will have locked ourselves in overly much before we have that bond workshop on this we're not going to take a loan out for christmas that's evil to do that so well one other thing for the board to to understand too when it comes to the cost of money i i support bill's idea on option five and part of my thinking also i'm we're general

291engineering contractors we build public works right now over the last two years construction costs have been increasing at 11% and 9% year over year. So just on a spreadsheet basis, if we are getting an interest rate less than 8%, we're beating inflation. So if we don't, let's say we went with option three, that $3 million of difference that we're not going to build now. is going to be to the point where we won't be able to afford it, even if we have a bond. It just doesn't make sense. So, and then because there's costs of mobilization, demobilizing and coming in, that if we do it in two phases... that second phase, it wouldn't be 10-2. It's probably 11-8. This year, if you just did them side by side, it'd be added probably a million, a

292million and a half dollars to it. But then you go and stretch that out to over two, three, four, five years, and then you go and do it at even a 6% increase year over year. We're killing ourselves. You know people use debt smartly sometimes a lot of people use debt Dumbly, I'm not gonna use it Less smart less smart this option five Knowing because of some of the things that have been that that the loan and in the abilities It's it's a it's a smart financial investment in this facility to go with option five, utilize the lower interest rates that we have access to available now. And then there's the synergy of doing it all at one time. There's multiple layers of cost savings. And again, like Bill likes to say, for the people

293that are home watching, the three people that are left up. In schools, there's two different pots of money. There's our operating money that we do, that we pay all our folks and stuff. And then there's our facilities money. The two don't, they don't go back and forth. I'm just looking at facilities money, that this is a smart. decision yeah and and and service that debt and um I if you made it did you is that a second right that's what I was asking did he make a motion at five he did yeah then I'm seconding a motion that we would do option five okay so I have a few things to do first I need to another motion to extend the meeting just to make sure we've done that before we vote I will move.

294Second. All in favor? Aye. Okay, then I'm going to ask for public comment. Do we have any public comment on this item? Bye. Good night. Doesn't look like it. Okay, so then I will ask for a vote. All in favor of option five? Aye. So I'm going to reluctantly say I, but I really think that there's a lot of work ahead of us. And I think that everyone knows that, but I'm reluctantly saying I. I understand. And you didn't say I because I'm going to defer to you two because you two are very smart with money. Okay. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Thank you guys. um i'm gonna keep going that's more good item 8.1 is just future items we took care of that earlier so i'm going to ask to adjourn the meeting

295actually i have one thing to say okay i'm sorry it's because i forgot earlier oh uh i forgot one item that i really wanted to talk about that i feel is really critical So recently there was an invitation from CSBA to attend a workshop that's called Immigration Policy and Resources. And this workshop is taking place on January the 23rd from 10 a.m. to 1130 a.m. And I forwarded this invitation to Jen, you know, just in case any of the board members are interested in participating in this workshop and getting this information on, you know, the current immigration policy and also resources for immigrants. So I believe that this topic is really important for us to also look at at a future board meeting because you know since we're having a change of administration it's really

296important that we help families who are immigrants who some of them may be undocumented to feel like they're in a safe environment and look at all of the protocols and know the policies of what we can do to keep them safe and i know i've had this conversation recently with the assistant superintendent at the santa rosa junior college to find out what they're doing and he said that they're already training you know their administrators staff and also faculty and how to talk to for example if immigration officials show up how to keep their students safe, how to not give away their personal information. So they're already establishing these processes for making sure that students stay safe, which I believe is really critical because if we don't keep them safe, then how will they learn, right?

297How will they perform in an environment where they feel it's very ambiguous? So that's all I wanted to say. So I- Where is it at? I forwarded it to Jen. I think it's on Zoom, so it should be possible for. Okay. Is that it? Yes. Okay, great. Thank you for that. And do we have an adjournment motion? I'll move. Second. All in favor? Aye. We out.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.