CorpusRecord 159487

Monroe Township Board of Edcuation 11.20.18 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,612 words · about 93 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening everyone. The meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order. Please stand as our student board member leads us in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. May we have a roll call, Mr. Gorski? Certainly. Mrs. Arminio? Here. Mr. Braverman? Mr. Chiaro? Here. Mrs. DeMaio? Here. Mrs. Kulponowicz? Here. Mrs. Lange? Here. Mrs. Carino? Here. Mr. Ryback? Here. Mr. Russo? Here. And Mr. Rudsky? Here. Madam Board President, you have a quorum present this evening. Thank you. In accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published

002by having the date time and place thereof posted November 15th 2018 at all schools the Home News Tribune Cranberry Press and filed with the clerk of the municipality. Okay at this time we will go to number five on the agenda approval of minutes. For the closed session meeting of August 22nd 2018 I need a motion and a second so mr. Ryback second mr Mayo any additions or corrections to the minutes The corrections have been made right that I sent out. I believe they have been made. Yes. Thank you. Okay all in favor opposed abstention recuse recuse this mrs. Lang and miss Carino Okay, the public board of education meeting of September 12 2018 Mr. I back mr. Mayo again any additions or corrections to those minutes? Okay all in favor aye opposed abstention recusal Mrs.

003Lang miss Carino and for the closed session meeting of September 12 2018 Mr. Ryback Mr. Mayo comments questions additions or corrections seeing none all in favor opposed abstentions or recusal Mrs. Lange Ms. Carino is going to abstain we have a lot of presentations on the agenda this evening so our first one is for the special olympics of new jersey and i will turn this over to mr goodall good evening everyone welcome to monroe township high school those in the community who are here tonight we have a special presentation from new jersey special olympics On November 3rd, at a reception at Rowan University, the Special Olympics of New Jersey presented Monroe Township High School the National School Championship Banner to acknowledge all the work of our unified programs. Ms. Kathy Dillon, along with some of our

004students and parents, are here this evening to share some of the accomplishments of the program. So at this time, we would like to invite those who are going to share some of the accomplishments to come on up to the podium. Hi, I'm Sam. I'm a senior. I've been part of the Unified program for two years. I can say that the Unified program has really become all of our homes. It only has being a member of this program allowed me to find an encouraging space to discover the best parts about myself, but it has gifted me amazing friendships that I know will last long, long, long after I graduate. For the majority of my life, I was very timid and I found it very difficult to express myself in larger groups. However, after just being in

005the first block of this program, I found myself already looking up to many people in this program for how amazing natural leaders they all were. And they really inspired me to come out of my shell and taught me to always dance like nobody's watching. There's no doubt in my mind that this program has made me the person that I am today. The Unified program has given me amazing role models and even more amazing friends. I cannot thank Ms. Dillon and my peers for allowing me to be part of such an amazing family. Hi, my name is Katie Belko and I am a parent of several of the children that are in this group. Some special and some that are just as special. And these are the reason why this program exists. And the courage and

006strength that they learn in these programs, the friendships that they develop, as well as the abilities that they learn that they don't get when they're not. unified with each other and when they're working together. So the hard work that goes into this program, not only through the students that support the program, but also through teachers like Ms. Dillon who really make the program shine and make it what it is and are dedicated and determined to make sure that all of our students in Monroe Township are unified in all that they do and in not just sports but in a lot of other programs through Project Fun and some other items that you know other things that we do and now to have this program and Mr. Goodall I have to call you out here to

007have this program moving down to the lower grade levels elementary which one of my daughters is also going to be involved in so that we have unified sports programs and unified programs throughout the district and not just in the high school so that we can all be together moving forward. And one of the little thoughts I had this afternoon when I was preparing to speak tonight was that this is how we make a difference on a local level, but this is how we start the wave to make the difference in our town, in the state. and as a nation. This is the only way that we can do this is if we do this now and we do it together as a small group and we move forward. So thank you. Hi, my name is

008Sue Riser. I apologize for putting my back to the board. Thank you for the opportunity to share here tonight. Special Olympics. Wonderful. Job proving. Providing. Opportunities for our athletes and we appreciate it. However, unified programs provide something more. The opportunity for athletes to participate with their peers in their natural sports environment, which is their local home and community. Our athletes attend school with their teammates and participate with their peers for a continuity of support. The success is evident in the increase in the population and of course the medals won in some of the sports. My family would like to thank the board. of education for their continued support such valuable programs for our athletic community especially these athletes. On a personal note, I see our kids around town. I see the kids in a working

009capacity. I see them in a capacity of coaching. I see them as a parent of special kids. When we go to the library, kids from the high school are saying high fives. Five years ago that didn't happen. Four years ago that didn't happen. I see kids at the lunchroom table interacting better. I see kids high-fiving in the hallways better. I see kids going to local areas like Stop and Shop and greeting other people in the hallways. And sometimes it's disconcerting because you don't know who's saying hi to who, but it's carrying over. It's making our little town a much better place. Thank you again. Thank you so much. Ms. Susan Colacello from the Special Olympics. Hi, everyone. I am pretty honored to be here. I think, as many of you know, this is the second

010award that Monroe Township High School has gotten. We honored the school on Friday night as our Unified School of the Year at Special Olympics New Jersey. So I just want to throw one statistic out there. Nationally, 17% of kids with intellectual disabilities spend less than 80% of their day in a general education setting. And that's what drives us. Mrs. Shriver started Special Olympics to create opportunity for her sister, Rosemary, who was disabled. And to create that opportunity, and I think I was so excited because people are mentioning the word opportunity. but it's youth-led, our Unified Champion Schools movement. So I'd like all the youth here, because this really is their thing with Ms. Dillon. It takes Ms. Dillon to make this happen, but it is all the kids. So if you guys can make two

011rows. Who's going to accept the banner? Right here. Okay. You, Julia. Come on up. So there are eight schools in New Jersey. This is the first year we've awarded this banner in New Jersey. Eight schools. and 221 in the entire country. And in order to earn the National Unified Champion School banner, the school has to meet 10 standards, and they're not easy. And so I really, again, I want to shout out to, I'm really tiny. Oh, Mr. Ron. I want to thank you so much for supporting this. I get a little emotional. So if you hold this. Okay, so on behalf of the district, I just want to thank the Special Olympics. And again, recognize all of the students, the parents. and especially Miss Dillon, who's the driving force behind our unified programs. You make

012us all proud. Congratulations, Monroe Township High School Unified Program. Congratulations. Mrs. Califano, I'll help you hold it up high, okay, because I'm tall. You want to walk it out so we can get in the picture? Because we're going to have to hold this up a bit. Mr. Gordon, we'll let the tall guys hold it. Great job everyone. Thank you. We would like to thank Ms. Dillon for her support of these programs. She does a phenomenal job with our students. We are very honored to accept this banner and we will wear the t-shirts that you gave us with a lot of pride. Thank you very much again. okay and continuing now with number seven on our agenda we continue with the pride grants presentations with from the MTEA and I'm going to turn this over to

013Mr. Goodall thanks to Monroe Township Education Association or MTEA we are sharing our pride presentation this evening from Woodland School Ms. Danielle Kutcher has been using yoga and mindfulness practices in her classroom for the past six years. She is here tonight along with Dr. Adam Lehman, school principal, with several students, past and present, and parents to speak about how this is helping students deal with stress and how it impacts the family dynamic. You want to go up to the podium? Hi, good evening. Hi. I'm Danielle Kuchar. I teach fifth grade at Woodland School. For the past five years or so, I felt that there was a need in my classroom with the students for social-emotional learning, and I introduced a program for yoga and mindfulness, and I have a few students here to tell you

014how it's helped them with self-regulation and coping. Hi, I'm Sarah, and I'm in Ms. Kuchar's fifth grade class at Woodland. Hi, I'm Leah, and I'm also in Ms. Kutcher's fifth grade class. In our classroom, we practice mindfulness and yoga every day. We learn strategies to help us focus, be calmer, energized, and to stretch our bodies and mind and have a more positive attitude about the world. Not only has this helped us in our class, but it also helps me at home. For example, I use it during homework or in fights. I do too. In the middle of doing my homework, I stop and take a few mindfulness breaths. One example of what we do is balloon breath, and I want you to help us do it too. Sit up straight and put your hands on

015your stomach. Inhale and let your balloon inflate. Now exhale and let your balloon deflate. Breathe in through your nose and imagine your balloon inflating. Breathe out through your mouth and imagine your balloon deflating. Notice how you feel. Next is Olivia. Hello, I'm Olivia, and as a past student of Ms. Kutcher, I strongly believe that the yoga program that she teaches helps us students incredibly. Yoga is the study of meditation that also includes breathing techniques and specific postures which can be used for relaxation. As I grew up, I had began going through the stages of being nervous and anxious about things like school and sports. By using the breathing techniques and certain yoga resources that Ms. Kutcher taught us about, I could use them and persevere. As I went through middle school and now up to

016high school, these things worsened because you're worrying about things just as simple as your grades. They impact you every day. Your day practically revolves around school and you need that time to just calm down and relax. Yoga tends to be overlooked and ignored, yet yoga can decrease your stress that is built up and release your negative energy. It truly makes a difference to your day, and yoga has been a great, reliable resource over the past few years. Ms. Kutcher, as you know, has been part of the Yoga for Classrooms program. It is a yoga program for schools that promotes learning readiness and a positive school environment. Ms. Kutcher has her favorite word, mindful. Mindful is the perfect word to describe this program. It keeps the children aware of their goals and this program helps them

017achieve these goals. It keeps them calm when they are stressed or even when they are bored, it gives them something to do. During our classes, we are always doing something, whether it's educational stories, poses, singing, or just relaxing, we are always having fun, laughing, and smiling. This program guarantees an outstanding outcome. At the end of the year, we made a music video to Michael Jackson's Billie Jean. Us students sang along and described how the special yoga cards and techniques that we learned helped us with school and other stressful day-to-day activities. I now want to present this music video and hope this changes your perspective on yoga for classrooms. Thank you very much. I think we could probably use you before the next board meeting. I was going to say, Mrs. Kutcher, if you don't mind

018coming up and doing a session with the administrative team. We're developing the budget for next year, and we have to fit it within a 2% cap. So if Mr. Gorski has us really sticking, we're going to need that. But thank you for all you do in the classroom, and thank you for coming tonight. Okay. Next on the agenda is a bond referendum update. And before I turn this over to Mr. Goodall, I'd just like to make a comment in regard to some Facebook postings. And if the board distributed any data as attachments to the agenda online before an explanation can be given via presentations, we'd be doing the public service. And because I could explain that a little better. Sometimes presentations are worked on until the last minute. Sometimes the presentation, the information in the

019presentation changes at the last minute, or we might not have some of the information that is being sought by particular people. There will be many opportunities during the next few months to have your questions answered in regard to the referendum. We'll be using the district website. We'll have a referendum Facebook page. We will be doing numerous presentations within the community. You can always email your questions to any of the administrators. this is a very important referendum we have coming up in march of 2019 and we all need to be together on this um to make sure that it passes or to even to get the correct information sent out or being given throughout the community so we will have a referendum update now but we look forward to working with everybody in our community to

020make sure that the correct information is given out and that we pass this referendum So, Mr. Goodall, I'll turn it over to you. Thank you. And Mr. Tague, tough act to follow, the first two presentations. But Mr. Tague, Director of Facilities. Good evening. Tonight we're going to have a presentation on the upcoming referendum. Before I turn it over to our architect, though, just give everyone an update on how we got to where we are today. You may recall that on March 13th of this year, 2018, there was a referendum for a new middle school. That referendum failed by 143 votes. After that referendum failed, the steering committee reconvened. They evaluated the results, data, public feedback, and conducted a post-referendum survey to get a feeling on why it failed and what people from the community wanted.

021The steering committee then presented to the Building and Grounds Committee, and at the August 22nd, 2018 public meeting the board authorized a new referendum for March 12th of 2019 So March 12th of this upcoming year second Tuesday will be a vote for referendum This referendum will include the same new 1,000 student middle school that was proposed previously on the golf range site at Alpgarth Road And it will also include a 1,000 student addition to the high school The public will have the opportunity to vote on the middle school as it is, or the middle school and the high school. So once the board authorized this at the August 22nd meeting, we started the process for the referendum. This involved a resubmission of the middle school project with cost and date adjustments, and a full submission

022of the high school project to the Department of Education. The full submission includes the educational specifications, the design schematics, and cost estimates. The New Jersey Department of Education has reviewed the project applications for both the middle school and the high school projects and issued what are known as PEC letters, or preliminary eligible costs. The board then passed a resolution at the October 17, 2018 meeting accepting the terms of these letters and are now expecting to receive the final eligible cost letters from the Department of Education, at which time that will cast in stone the actual dollar cost for the projects. Between now and March 12th of 2019, members of the Board of Education, Administration, and Steering Committee will work on an informational campaign to inform the public about the referendum vote. At this time, I'm

023going to turn the presentation over to our architect, Mr. Rich Alderiso, principal with the firm of DI Group Architecture. I'm going to present from this side, if that makes sense. Okay. Thank you, everyone. I'll quickly go through this. You'll probably see this a few times over the course of the referendum, so I'll go through this quickly, going through the high school first, just to explain what we're proposing here and how we think this will address some of the enrollment issues that we're currently facing. So this is, just to orient you, this is Schoolhouse Road, Prineville Road. This is the existing high school building here. And we're basically proposing a 129,000 square foot addition to the school. It's a three-story addition built to accommodate 1,000 additional students. Just a couple of items worth noting at this

024point. Basically... We're trying to create an addition here that will generate a seamless transition from building to building. We want this addition to look like it's always been here. We're trying to take advantage of a piece of site that was carved out when we built the original high school that was earmarked for a potential addition. And that's basically this piece of property here. This is just to orient you, again, the existing bus drop-off. This is the loop that goes out to Perrineville. And then parking here, the middle school is down here. And basically what we're trying to do is preserve the entrance to the building, same bus drop-off, but we're trying to accommodate, again, the influx of 1,000 additional students that we... see in the demographic studies. Just to give you a sense of some

025of the attributes of the building, this is basically a 30-classroom addition. So we're looking at 30 general classrooms, six science labs, four self-contained special ed classrooms, three resource rooms, two engineering labs. satellite cafeteria and servery, culinary arts lab, an auxiliary gym and locker rooms, and a music and band room. And that really captures the addition, which is again a three-story addition. So just the way this is organized, this is, again, this is the bus drop off on this side. This is where students enter. And what we're trying to do... is basically create a much more open common so when students come in, again, we could accommodate the current population plus a thousand additional students. Right now, if you've experienced this space in the mornings, it's unbelievable. We actually, we came one morning and we videoed

026the entrance of the students after the drop off and it was just very, it was incredibly dense and just In about the 15 minutes it took for the students to filter into classrooms, you almost, it was basically standing room only. Excuse me, do you think you could hold the mic closer? It's really hard to hear. Yes, I'm sorry. Thank you. Sorry about that. So again, what we're trying to do here is create a much more, an entrance that is more conducive to the amount of students that we have here. And again, when you look at this plan, it's basically general classrooms, auxiliary gymnasium, locker rooms, engineering labs. There are special ed classrooms throughout this footprint. stacked science labs and shared prep rooms and we're also looking at with the addition trying to address and make

027the existing building as efficient as it can be there are there are a couple of spaces this being one of them where we're looking to repurpose the space in part in order to create other opportunities on other floors so part of the part of the renovation component of the project involves subdividing this media center, creating a flex faculty space which frees up spaces, existing space on the upper floor for special education suites, offices, conference rooms, child study space. And we're also converting the distance learning lab to a professional development space. Second floor and third floor are very similar. As you can see, we're really trying to create a seamless transition from the existing footprint and corridors right into the addition. But again, classroom space, stacked science labs. When I say stacked, basically we're placing the

028science labs one over the other. Science labs tend to have a lot of plumbing, a lot of mechanical equipment. The more aligned they can be from floor to floor, the more efficient the construction is, the less expensive the construction is. We share chases for plumbing and mechanical equipment. Also, again, resource rooms throughout. And this is, this space down here within the existing building footprint is currently faculty lounge, faculty workspace. And they're very crowded, very small spaces right now given the current faculty population. Again, on the first floor. We're proposing to take part of this space and dedicate it to faculty lounge, faculty workspace, again, professional development so that on the second floor these spaces can serve as they're very well equipped to serve special education classrooms and there are office suites in the center which

029lend themselves to child study, conference rooms, breakout spaces. There are toilet rooms in there. So it becomes a very, I think, efficient use of space that right now is being very overworked as a faculty space. Third floor, again, very similar plan. Classrooms, stacked science labs, special ed integrated throughout, resource rooms. Again, the special ed suite in the existing part of the building. And again, kind of a seamless alignment from building to building. And that's basically what we're looking to do here with the addition. Again, this will accommodate 1,000 students. And we think it will, again, help with circulation and some of the issues right now that we're seeing in the school given the current population and anticipated population. The middle school, which I'm sure some of you have seen before, this is kind of a

030refresher on the middle school. As Mr. Tague noted, this school is proposed as a three-story middle school, new construction along the golf site on Cranberry Station and Applegarth Roads. Basically, a 152,000 square foot building, three-story classroom wing, one-story core wing. The site lends itself very well to the footprint. We're trying to create a very compact, very efficient footprint. We're separating bus circulation from vehicular circulation for regular automobiles. The building is sited very well for drainage, for a play field. And we're just footprint-wise and also programmatically, we're just really trying to create parity between this school and the existing middle school as far as classrooms, course spaces, and whatnot. Again, this is meant to house 1,000 students, 6, 7, 8. It's a 30-classroom. building, six science labs, 30 general classrooms, six science labs, six special ed

031rooms, nine resource rooms, three per grade. We have a media center, art room, materials technology lab, 650 seat auditorium with vocal and music, a vocal music room and a band room. This also has a gymnasium, a auxiliary gym, locker rooms, and cafeteria, kitchen, servery, culinary lab. And on basically again the way this footprint is set up is that, I go back to this, this piece of the building out front is a single story building containing all the core spaces, the gymnasium, cafeteria, media center. performing arts area. And then the building in the back is a three-story wing, basically for all the classroom space. And it's really organized in very efficient bars, if you will. So each of these bars contains a type of space. The top bar is the media center and art room. This

032piece right here is performing arts, music. This is the athletic bar, if you will, and this is the cafeteria, culinary, servery. And each bar is connected, I think, with a very efficient spline that brings students out to the classroom wing. As you get to the upper levels, basically the classroom wing is the only wing that goes up first, second, and third floor. So second, third floor, again, very efficient, very similar, stacked utilities. We have classrooms, special ed labs, science labs with prep rooms. There are three resource rooms per grade within the facility. One of the other things we're trying to do here, we have the admin area, but we're also proposing a special services office suite here, which currently are, to my understanding, they're in leased space throughout the district right now. So we have

033an opportunity here to not have the leased space within the district and bring that, the special services right into a building here that the district owns. So again, very, it's a very compact plan. And just to take you through this one more time, it's 30 classrooms, six science labs, six special education rooms. Nine resource rooms, media center, art room, materials technology lab, auditorium for 650, vocal music, band room, gymnasium, an auxiliary gym, and then a cafeteria, kitchen, serving area. And that's really the building in a nutshell. Are there any questions from any member of the Board of Education to Mr. Alderiso? hi can you go back on the middle school and show me the bus routes and the ingress and egress in terms of what streets and how because i know some of the communities

034in that area were concerned about traffic sure i could maybe stand up over there and can you identify the streets as you yeah is that better yeah i think so okay um applegarth road okay use the mic applegarth road Cranberry Station route. Applegarth and Oak Tree schools are down this way. Basically, buses come in from Cranberry Station. Here is the bus parking. This will accommodate 260 cars, 25 buses, about five vans. So we have spots for buses, buses, buses, buses. And the drop-off would be... through the sidewalks and here are the entrances from each of those areas. All right? Parent drop off separated from the bus drop off. Come in here, come through and out or come in. So the buses are going to actually pass the exit for the cars, right? As they're going

035from... Cars can either exit here or here. All right, but if buses are backed up for any reason, weather or whatever, they won't be, so. It's a pretty long, so the buses, the bus parking starts here and it comes all the way to here. So again, a 25 bus set up and they shouldn't be backed up. They should be able to pull in. Pull in, pull in, pull in. And again, they're not contending with cars in front of them. Right. How are they exiting then on Applegarth? Yes. So it's a separate exit and entrance for cars. And what's that on the left? That's a play field. That's a play field. Yes. So how much from the McAdam, let's say, to... the next landowner would that space be? Do we have an idea? When you say

036from... No, from the edge of that, right, where traffic would be to the next landowner. I don't know. It's far. It's far enough. There'll be privacy. Oh, yeah. This is all... I wish I had a Google map. This is all wooded. Literally. Densely wooded. Okay. I know that was a question that some of the adult communities had during the first referendum. So if we answer those questions up front, that might be. We should probably know the distance down the road for our community education. And I could have a Google map for the next one so you could really get a sense of how far those properties are. And I have one other question. When we talked about the use of this building and overcrowding and we talked about this media space, I mean, this is

037considered a library media room, right? Right. Right? Weren't there many comments from the audience and even from people on the board that talked about this space being really underutilized? So are we going to have this much of a space in the middle school? Because we talked about how... It could have really been better used for classrooms and things like that. I mean, I happen to like libraries and media spaces, but I don't know that in going forward in the future for educational purposes that this kind of space is necessary. I know we use it for meetings and things, but in terms of overcrowding and utilizing class space. I mean, that doesn't seem like a new design is what I'm saying. I think we've had some criticisms about the square footage here and it not really

038being utilized on a daily basis. So can you answer? Yes. The way in which these... what were libraries function today is so different as a media center, as a true media center. We see them being used as maker spaces, as media centers, as editing labs, and they don't require as much space. You don't have rows and rows and rows of stacks. I remember when this was designed, so there are six stacks here now. We probably had... 15 shown on the drawings originally and it's just the spaces aren't used that way anymore so this space this is the proposed media space for the middle school and I think to answer your question it's a much smaller space it's commensurate with the way those spaces are really used today and the way we see them being used

039and it will be built out differently it's then then this room yes And can you tell me what else would be in a media space of that sort? So they're just, they're much more flexible space. They're more set up towards that side of the room where you have loose furniture, where you, sometimes we're integrating stand-up workstations. There's opportunity for large and small group instruction within those spaces. So their design is much more flexible space. You're not encumbered by library stacks anymore. They can be set up differently. They can be set up as classrooms. They can be used by the community, but they're smaller. I mean, in general, and this one, this is a much smaller space than what we're seeing here right now. Is that what... Like the teachers and staff need I mean I'm

040sure there's two there's the original planning phase and then after approval The you get the input from teachers and specific furniture and set up and that's how we constructed the high school and And are now adjusting because in 2002 it's not the same as 2018. So we have the reconfiguration of this room. That's what I'm hoping, that we learn our lessons and we learn from, and I think the criticism has always been constructive, that we learn from that and not just do another cookie cutter building, that we actually utilize this space in a much more futuristic way. So I'm just I'm just echoing that though some of the criticism is fair and sometimes it's difficult to project 20 years From the opening of a building and where education is and we do use this room

041during the course of the day But probably not as originally planned it does so we're reconfiguring that to do some things differently does this room get used for multiple classes at a time like more than one classroom more than one instructions it's the same subject area it's part of our online learning experience I've heard that you know sometimes the kids are distracted from from other sessions in the past unfortunately we had one class that was last year in here while kids were using it as the media center but we've now moved it towards our digital online learning environment so they are teaching and engaging on the same subject area with the appropriate number of teachers to supervise and maintain order And one more question. Is this similar to any other school in New Jersey that

042you've built or that you've designed? There are certain aspects of it that aren't. Okay, but it's not one same design. No. No, I mean, to your point, lessons learned about how to condense space, build these buildings more efficiently. You know, a setup like this, and forgive me, next time we do this, I'll have this enlarged. As we develop the design, this is a very schematic design, as we develop the design, we do meet with the end users, we do meet with the community to get input and really get a sense of how the spaces are being used. What I was going to say, an area like this, we've done this before in other schools in that it really allows you to save space. Instead of making this bar longer, If these two spaces, which is

043science lab and classroom and prep room, if these were stuffed in here, this bar becomes way longer. This move allows you to really keep the footprint more condensed. You're excavating less. You're digging less. You're moving less earth. It just makes for a very compact plan, especially where the site is a little narrower. Thank you. So there's not another school that we can use as a reference for the middle school? Another school locally, because the high school print was similar to South Brunswick High School. Exactly. There's no other school we can go to and get a feel for what the middle school would be? No, I mean, this isn't a, yeah, it's not really, it's not stolen from another footprint or anything. It's really. You know, it's unique to the site, it's unique to the feedback

044that we've gotten so far, and it's really unique to the program that's necessary. to accommodate the thousand students and some of the other spaces that you need within the building. I have a question just for clarity. You were talking about the buses. You said 25 buses. Those are full buses, not vans. Correct. Okay. And the auxiliary gym is attached to the main gym? So if necessary, it can be opened up? Yes. So that's the auxiliary gym. That's the main gym. Thank you. Rich correct me if I'm wrong, but I remember Jerry once saying that we designed this building in order to work with the shape of the land so you have one of the classrooms below lower than the The ground floor and then you have one above it so that we're not having to

045move a lot of land correct the the site slopes about 15 feet from from this road to this corner and So this is the three-story wing so as the site slopes down we're taking advantage of that slope to build this wing Down into that slope so from the street this won't even look like a three-story building It's really going to start to fall off, and it really works well with the topography of the site That's why this building is oriented the way it is It's taking advantage of the slope as it you know just picture this site going like this This is a single story wing And that's exactly right. The lowest level of this is down below this wing, and then it steps up. So from the street, again, it probably will look like

046a two-story building. And again, it's going to require way less excavation, a lot less earthwork than if we were to just try to build this up. The addition itself is about 129,000 square feet. Anyone else from the board have any questions? Seems like we don't have any more questions. So thank you for the update on our referendum for March. Thank you. We'll have an opportunity for the public to ask questions during the public forum agenda items. So at this time, we'll go to our student board members' reports. Okay, so I'm going to be covering the high school first. So Coffee House was held this afternoon in the Commons, and there are a lot more throughout the year. Students can audition and display their talent at singing and performing, and anyone is free to come and

047enjoy refreshments. MTHS Challenge Day is being held November 27th and November 29th, and this amazing event is hosted by an organization that travels from school to school and creates unity between classmates through life-changing activities. And once again, anyone is free to take part in the event. Parent-teacher conferences are on Monday, December 3rd, and Thursday, December 6th. It allows parents to meet with teachers and discuss students' grades and performance in classes. And moving down to the elementary schools, Woodland, Oak Tree, and Mill Lake are holding a PTO-sponsored holiday shop from November 28th to 30th. And Oak Tree and Woodland, they celebrated American Education Week by allowing parents to visit the school and classrooms for scheduled programs. Adding on to Manon, the high school clubs held a few events the past month. MTHS Future Business Leaders of

048America held their annual Haunted High School event and raised money for the Mama Mayor Breast Cancer Foundation in support of Brent's Cancer Awareness Month. DECA held their 15th annual car show as a benefit of Alex's lemonade stand. Even though it was a cold and cloudy day, 70 cars, trucks, and motorcycles came from as far as Delaware to raise over $1,000. Lastly, the Science Honor Society held Astronomy Night where the community members had the opportunity to meet professional astronomers and do pertinent activities. Applegarth is holding a band and chorus concert on December 14th. Thank you. Thank you very much for your reports. Committee reports. Are there any committees that need to report this evening? I know Mr. Mayo has one. We had a curriculum meeting tonight. We first reviewed a proposed high school club called Lights,

049Camera, Action. Club proposal The advisor will you will be Boris who we see every month here The lights camera action club will bring students together with an interest in making short films whether they are in front of the camera as An actor or behind the scenes as a writer director cinematographer editor or crew member the club will allow students currently taking Monroe Township High School video production classes the ability to use existing school equipment to extend the filmmaking experience outside of the classroom. The club will also afford those students who are unable to take video production classes due to scheduling conflicts the opportunity to follow their passion to make a short film. Lights, camera, action members will be granted studio time to work on submissions to various filmmaking competitions hosted in New Jersey. We also

050reviewed the new computer programming curriculum at the high school. In order to be recommended for this class, you have to get a 75 or above to be in Algebra I. Computer programming is designed to introduce the fundamental concepts of computer programming. The course emphasizes problem solving, design skills, and program analysis and testing. Students will solve problems in mathematics, science, business, and other areas. Hands-on use of the computer is emphasized. The topics include fundamentals of program, variable and data types, arithmetic operations and assignment, decisions, repetition, functions, arrays, classes, and objects. We also reviewed the visual arts curriculum for grades three to four. So what the administrators did is they reviewed the previous visual arts in grades three to four and they found that we're moving towards more digital art in the middle school. And they talked

051to the kids currently in the three to four grade about what they liked and didn't like about the art program. And as a result, they found that kids who are not skilled in like sketching and painting become uninterested in art. So what they've done is they've broadened the media in the visual arts for grades three to four. They're exposing the students to two-dimensional art, three-dimensional studio art, mixed media art, in an effort to allow students to express their personal creativity in a variety of ways. The new curriculum features STEM activities and cross-cultural activities in every unit. The unit plans emphasize personal reflection, critique, oral and written, and appreciation. Students will be developing digital portfolios that will follow them throughout their enrollment in the departmental programming. These digital portfolios will allow the teachers to be able

052to critique the art and it will allow their parents to see what they are creating in school we also had a review of the basic skills program currently our basic skills program in grades three to five occur after school and the proposal now is to move that basic skills during the school day with replicating the basic skills program currently in place that we have for grade K to 2. So the grades K to 2 is currently during the day. Currently grades 3 to 5 is after school. We're moving 3 to 5 to during the day. And why is this? Well, 25 to 27% of parents district-wide decline their child's attendance due to after-school conflicts. They disapprove the lengthening of the school day and have a general disbelief in the program because students in the program

053rarely exit out. After-school basic skills bestows additional courses for the district due to transportation, staffing of teachers, and paraprofessionals. The after-school basic skills program currently does not align with RTI. Therefore, the tracking of interventions and remediation does not take place at the same frequency as it does in basic skills during the day. The benefits of moving the basic skills to during the day is that the basic skills will now, during the school day, will now align with the RTI and the tiers for intervention. Skills will no longer be taught in isolation. This will allow students the ability to immediately transfer skills and knowledge taught. It also allows for increased communication between the basic skills teacher and the homeroom teacher. And it also provides for a reduction in cost to the district. This the whole curriculum

054committee felt that this is going to be a really good benefit to our basic skills students And if you have any questions you can ask story We also reviewed the The the ESL report card The ESL report cards were revised this year by Ms. Karen Breski, the ESL teacher, and Dr. Rozelle to align with the WIDA standards and better inform parents about their children's growth in the areas of reading, writing, speaking, and listening. These report cards are given in addition to the district report card. The elementary report cards also have learner behaviors that mirror the district report card. The K-3 grades have trimester reporting and the grades 4-12 had quarterly reporting. Linked at the bottom of each grade band's report card are the can-do statements that reflect what students are able to do based upon

055their currently proficient level. And that is it. It was very interesting today. I encourage everybody to come to curriculum next month. Thank you, Mrs. DeMeo. Any other committees that need to report today? Okay. Unfortunately, ma'am, we were snowed out on Thursday, so all of our committees were canceled, unfortunately. We had a couple things to discuss, but we did not get a chance to reschedule. Okay, at this time we'll go to the public forum. Anyone wishing to speak to the agenda, please come to the microphone, state your name and address for the record, and we will adhere to our four-minute time limit. At the end of the four minutes, the timer will go off and your time will be over. And according to our policy, a member of the public can only come to speak once

056during each public forum. So again, this is for agenda items only. Thank you president, this is Prakash Parab from 33 Dana Drive With three from the October meeting agenda attachment understand that high school expansion will cost us about 71 million dollars middle school about 75.8 In 2018, middle school we had projected 68.8 million. Now it has gone to 75.8, so about 10% increase. Recently, the Princeton is expanding their high school and middle school, and the cost is around $40 million. And what they did was they had town hall meetings and presented to the people what they are planning. They took the input from the people and they split the expansion in two stages. So they're starting expansion in about $20 million first and additional $20 million. So $40 million they are expanding high school and

057middle school. I don't have the details of the square foot. But looking at New Jersey Education Facility Construction and Financial Act, I just Googled it and found this. Footage per public pupil per middle school is 134 square feet per pupil. For 1,000 students, it will be 134,000. We are estimating 129,000. That's good. But the cost as per the October meeting... is about $143 per square feet. So if you multiply 134,000 square feet by 143, it comes to $19 million for the middle school. So how this number, 19 million, now it is going to cost us 76 million. So what is the difference? 19 million is construction cost. What is the difference? So we'd like to know that. Similarly, for 1,000 students, we estimated square footage for per student is 151 per student. So for 1,000

058students, it will be 151,000. We are estimating today 152,000. If you multiply 152,000 for high school expansion by $143 for square footage, it comes to $21 million. So where this number 71 million comes? Mr. Gorski, do you think you can? Sure. The Board of Education engaged a professional engineering firm, Epic Management, to come up with a cost estimate for the middle school. And you're right, Prakash, the first middle school referendum was 68.8 million. This one's up to 75. And the increased costs were advertised at the time when we went around for all the presentations for the bond referendum. They were anticipated because, as Mr. Tague has demonstrated in the past. construction costs on these type of projects go up about a million dollars a year. Sorry to interrupt because of the time limit. My question

059is 20 million the estimate is coming. Now the cost is 76 million. So how do you explain the difference? That's my question. I think that's a complicated question and I want to invite you to our office. We could have a conversation with the cost engineers who came up with the figures. There's eligible cost, there's non-eligible cost, $143 as a state figure. But I will tell you that the $75 million estimate is accurate. It comes from a professional engineering firm. And a lot of the cost increase from the last time we went out for the referendum to now is due to increase in commodity costs and anticipations of the effects of tariffs. I would like to see the details. Thank you. You're welcome to give me or Jerry Tager a call, and we'll be happy to

060host you anytime you want. Good evening. Andy Polori, 16 St. James Street. Along the same lines, I was looking at a couple of items that were shown today. One was the middle school in terms of the facilities and also the circulation. I think there's a lot of concern from the citizens in terms of how the traffic is going to work on Applegard Road as well as the side streets. Are we, as a part of the planning and construction of this, looking at how the traffic circulation is going to be and the impacts on Applegard Road at all? The district's transportation director, Mrs. McDonald, was intimately involved in the design, also studying some preliminary traffic information with the projected number of routes needed for this, how it would integrate in the tiered busing system. So we're

061certainly concerned about the traffic flow. And keep in mind this site location. is not utopia. There were not a lot of options as far as land availability in town. So we're gonna do the best with what was available and we'll make it safe and we'll make the busing routes efficient and least impactful on the community in their mind. Well, it is encouraging to see multiple ingress and egress to the middle school. One of the concerns that I have also in talking to a lot of citizens, especially the senior, is are we creating a Cadillac with the new middle school? Let me rephrase that. Is there going to be a difference in amenities between the existing middle school and the future middle school? Is there anything we can do to bring the overall cost down? Is

062anybody looking at to see instead of spending a $75.8 million for middle school, are there efficiencies that we can look at to make sure that the number is not as high as 75.8? i think we'll be looking at that as we go along but we want to make sure that both schools have parity and and the programs that we have in this district drive the construction of the building so that we want to make sure that one middle school doesn't have more than the other middle school so we're looking to address those needs at this point and as we move forward we will be looking at those kind of things thank you the last point i have is the uh the circulation at the high school. I drop my daughter off every Tuesday morning at

0637 o'clock, just getting through Schoolhouse Road, past the high school, make a left turn, make another left turn to the back of the middle school. It's just a nightmare. It takes anywhere from 20, 25 minutes to 35 minutes. Adding another 1,000 students to that and more buses going through there, more traffic, I think we need to start looking at... another entrance and exit to the middle school. I don't have a solution to that, but unfortunately, but I can tell you that we probably need another entrance off of Perrineville Road to make sure that the traffic is not clogged up on Schoolhouse Road. Those are my comments. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, Peter Tufano, 10 Catherine Street. I have a question about the new middle school. Is there any anticipation? of future growth. I know we

064can't build in anticipation of growth, but can we somehow make sure that we have a foundation built that will hold maybe another story or the location of the school is set in a way where we can put an addition on because I think the biggest fear people have in this town for voting for that referendum is that we're going to build this school and then two or three years down the line we're going to need another school and it's never going to end because the developing is never ending. It seems that developing is never ending. So is there any way we can... get the architect to give us an assurance that if we need to put another level on the school or an addition on the school that that would be something that we can

065accomplish yeah i'll let mike gorski talk about that but i believe that we did the same thing with the middle school that we did with the high school that there's a footprint at the high school if we needed to build another um a three-story tower addition for the footprint of um just classrooms but we're adding on to more than just classrooms but Mike I'd like to briefly begin the answer and then I encourage you Mr. Alderiso to chime in about the structural addition availability but the demographic projections are that there will be 2,000 middle school students ten years from now And the way these design schools are set up is to almost evenly split that 2,000 load, 1,000 at each school. So we're confident that this will take care of that sixth, seventh, and eighth

066grade demographic of students up till 10 years where this discussion has to come up again. But Rich, do you want to take the possibility of adding on to it after that point? I just want to I want to add one more thing in case he can answer both questions at the same time is the foundation for the current middle school not able to handle another level on top no it's not able to no we've looked at all options at the middle school from adding to the back to adding a different area and connecting it and adding up and it's it's just not feasible that's why I'm Hoping that we learn our lesson with this next middle school so that we can put another level on if needed because we're gonna need it I think Sooner

067than ten years. We're just trying to get to the next slide It's not just a matter of accommodation of students to it's a congestion of students when we when we contemplated the idea of additions at the middle school With what's existing with the high school and the other campus location there? It's not ideal to have that many students concentrated in one geographic area like that Part of the problem too with the current middle school is even if you could and we can't add classrooms the core facilities cannot hold any more students they're having a difficult time even with the students that they currently have in the trailers so the the cafeteria and gym in the gym and the Media Center gymnasium locker rooms right are just cannot hold any more students okay, so this This

068is designed, and I'm sorry I did not mention this before, this is designed so that these corridors can continue and we can accommodate an addition on each end of this, which would house, again, it's a three-story wing, probably six more classrooms in total. And again, once you start to go beyond that... Again, the core facilities start to get overworked and don't really serve the population that, you know, if you were to add 20 classrooms to this, it just does not work with the core facilities. But to add six to eight classrooms, certainly doable, and we're planning for it. And there's no way to build the core facilities in anticipation of growth. They just, again, that number, that cost, that $75 million turns to $90 million, turns to... Well, I'm just saying, I think people would

069pay $90 million rather than have to pay another $70 million for another middle school 10 years from now. At this point, your time is up. Your four minutes. Thank you. Good evening. Ram Rangnath, 6-0 in Strive. A very helpful presentation. Thank you, Rich. But it would have been really helpful, Madam President, if... for the agenda, if there had been some more information on this referendum attached, we all try to look at the agenda, are there some things, maybe some of those pictorials or some information or a synopsis could have been included so we are more prepared rather than trying to strain our eyes here. learn everything, right? Because the more prepared we are, the more informed questions that we can ask because time is limited. Right, and I addressed that at the beginning. I don't

070think you were here when I did that. But we will also put this presentation onto the website, so you'll have the opportunity to review it there again and then ask any questions that you have to the administration. Okay, thank you. I was a few minutes late. One of the things I didn't hear in this presentation is it's the construction, but what about the delivery approach, right? And I know some folks have pushed that. Can we have a very agile approach of delivering the new middle school and the new high school? Like, for example, you know, can, let's say, half of the facility be up and running in two years? So you address... the issues rather than waiting for this big bang five-year delivery. So I didn't hear much about that creativity in delivery and so

071on. I don't know whether that's a separate presentation or separate piece of work. From the public, I think what we want is like we are behind already, five years behind. This meeting should have been happening five years back. So how do people or members of children in the schools today and maybe going to high school, let's say in three years, benefit from these rather than waiting for five years. Well at this point if we pass the referendum in March of 2019 the middle school should be open in September 2023 so that would only be a three-year period a little less than three year period You could not it would be not beneficial to open a school when it's halfway finished Well, you're having a construction project where you're having middle school children Rich do you

072mind speaking to that about a phased in approach of the facility in terms of building? The school was planned to open September of 22 22 So the idea of a phase completing some of the construction to use the facility is the possibility of that or the practicality of that It's very challenging. Even, you know, building, doing an addition is challenging. It's a much more complicated project than an out of the ground building just because of the logistics of building while students are in school or over the summers between school. So trying to build part of a building, open part of a building. It's been done. Again, it's very challenging. It does add to the cost of the project. Things like fire alarm systems, typically they're designed, built, and approved by the local code enforcement agency

073in their totality. So it's very difficult to build part of a building, get a certificate of occupancy, and continue to build onto it. Rich isn't it also unattractive to have construction going on while you have students in the building or and disruptive It's very difficult. It really is it If we you know when you know you're going to do that you design the building around that that wags the dog It really does design with pedestrian links and distant breaks between Footprints so that you can safely do that so yeah, so so I guess I think we should think about this. We have to be creative here, right? We can always find the reasons not to do it. Like at work. To get something built quicker than. Correct. Last six months while half of the floor

074was renovated, they were doing it in parallel. Work didn't stop at my business. Well, part of the issue right now would be that we would have to wait for all the approvals from the state. And then after we get the approvals, we need to have it. How long does it take to do the designs elements and get that done? It must take about a year. About a year. About a year. Right. So so at this time your four minutes are also over. Oh, I thought I didn't I think he was explaining I think you should That's all part of the four minutes. Really? It's been that way Okay. Thank you. I work MacIntyre 552 spots at English Town Road My first time at this meeting I'm not sure how it runs when I was trying

075to look at this paperwork real quick My son is goes to the middle school. He was attacked physically. I Went there and I hit dead ends everywhere. I went at the school What happened was after he was attacked, the other kid was suspended for five days, sent home. There was no resolution. There was no nothing going on. What happened afterwards was the tension was built up. And then there was verbal threats of weapons. The kid is a self-proclaimed gang member. So I've been very frustrated. I went to the school and I got nowhere. I went to the police station. I got nowhere. I went to an anti-bullying specialist. I got nowhere. I went to three places. I had three dead ends. I'm beyond furious on how the whole situation is handled. I learned a little

076bit about the anti-bullying, that there was something to be filled out, and I was supposed to have this report within 10 days. This is over a month ago. So I'm trying to... Understand how we you know talk about we got blue ribbon schools all this stuff and everything safety there's ex police officers in there there was a Threat with a knife and then because I got notified and the police got notified approximately three hours later There was no knife found so they determined it wasn't a knife then they attached a parrot to this kid and Even after the power was with the kid the kid attacked another kid threatened him with a knife while the power was God knows where So what's going on in the school is not working. I'm trying to hold my

077composure on this whole situation. I don't want to get out of my own head. I got to do whatever I got to do to protect my family. So I'm trying to go to all the proper channels, and I'm hitting dead end. So I was told to come here, and now I understand you got to talk about it. If you can, Rob Goodall, acting superintendent, if you can contact my office tomorrow, we'll meet as soon as we can, and you can talk to me about all of it. what you're encountering and we'll come to some resolution. I'll be more than willing to listen to what you have to say. I'm a little familiar with it, and I didn't know that you were going to come here tonight. Everybody I spoke to I told I was coming

078here, and again, I didn't know the format. I don't know how this works. I work 24 hours a day, and I don't have time to run. Come and talk to me. I'm more than willing to talk to you about this. If you want to call early, I'll make it work. Okay. That's what I'll do. Mrs. Baracallo is my secretary. And how do I get your contact? Is it on there? Just my number here. It's Mr. Grebel's name and his extension. Okay. Anyone else from the public wishing to speak? Krishna De Kalle, 11 Jake Place. I have a question on the middle school that is being built. How many students is it being planned for? The middle school? Yeah. I believe it's for 1,000 students. So... Are you looking at an intake of only 1,000 students

079over the next five years, plus the 500 students that are unhoused currently in middle school? Yeah, so when the school is open, we will have to redistrict so that some of the students from the current middle school will be going to the new middle school. And both schools will have, I believe, room for expansion of students. You're looking at what a ten year five year growth or a ten year growth because if you are already adding 500 students from the existing middle school to the new school The effective capacity of the new middle school is only 500. We're looking at ten year growth ten year growth You're only thinking that there will be only 500 additional students that are coming in a Ten year growth they expect 2,000 middle school students total within the next

080ten years. Okay 2,000 Right. And are you going to have any town halls where you're presenting your plans for the referendum? What kind of impacts are there going to be the taxpayers? What kind of project plans are you looking at? What kind of phased project approach do you have? Do you have any plans for the... Down halls. So our first is December 3rd at the library. It is sponsored by our teaching association. And we've already booked League of Women Voters are going to host us in February. I send out articles to publications within our planned PRCs, inviting if anyone wants us to come and for us to present. You'll hear it in my superintendent's report. We will leave no stone unturned to present. all the facts and how it impacts so voters can make an

081informed decision. We will have many town hall presentations. We're going to have a Q&A. We're going to have a referendum. Facebook page just for the referendum we'll have many opportunities to get the information to the public so looking at other school districts when they have a referendum they have it on their home page as well of the school district do you have any plans of putting that referendum information on your home page yes and when would that be available to as soon as we get the finalized financials Approval. Yeah, I would reference you know if what we did before we had a wonderful website with a plethora of information pertaining to the referendum We're gonna we're gonna do the same thing and would we also be able to see a cost breakdown of the middle

082school and the high school? In that different absolutely and you could open request the preliminary information on that now if you wish Okay, and lastly is this architecture final for the middle school or is this still a proposed architecture? This is the final because this is what is going to be on the referendum in March. You can either vote for the middle school or the middle school plus the high school addition. And that is already set for the referendum. The question I had was more about the architecture of the middle school that is presented here. Is this architecture final? Yes. Okay, and then the land is all tied down for the middle school, right? The township owns the middle school. We can have the middle school any time that we would like. They will give

083it to us. I believe they had a resolution last year that at their meeting, in a resolution, made that statement that they would give it to us. We do not need it right now, so we don't want anybody to not utilize that land because it's now being utilized by the Gulf Range, and they have a lease up until, I believe it's December 2019, so we won't need the land before that, so we look so that they can keep their business and the township can still have their tax incentives there. Last question. The minute friend, I'm sorry, but your four minutes are up also. All right. Thank you Lois cash to Vince 20 Pine View Court. I have two questions one regarding the curriculum committee report Recommending or suggesting that the elementary basic schools program be

084aligned during the school day I I get all those reasons and I work in an elementary school. I get it, but I just I'm worried about or wondering about additional classroom space if the program is going to move to during the school day when regular instruction is going on you're going to need classroom space so I just hope that's being taken into account it is being taken into account it could be a push in program where the the teachers and the staff comes into the classroom works with their classroom staff or it could be a pull out in some cases and we will have the room for that okay very good second questions regarding the plan for the middle school in the back there's one playing field is that a turf field for field hockey

085soccer and if so is that all that's there because As far as I know, at least, you know, outdoor sports at the middle schools is field hockey, soccer, baseball, softball. I don't know if they do lacrosse there. But how are you going to accommodate the outdoor sports? Mr. Tague, would you like to answer that question about the... The purpose of the athletic... Facilities at the middle school. It's a general recreation field and the desire there would be to go with a synthetic field so that it will give us the ability to have more use. The site itself though, it's a 35 acre site but about half of it is what you see there on the footprint. We're on about 17 acres. The remaining 17 acres are wetlands so we can't encroach any further back so

086that's kind of all you have for athletic area. We will not be we will have comparable sports at both middle schools So if the current middle school is has a baseball team and they're using a different facility the news the new Middle school will also have that opportunity to have so you'd be transporting students right current field, right? Okay. All right. Thank you Good evening, Chrissy Skirby, 21 Preakness Drive. I'm just wondering why we haven't looked at doing something different. The referendum failed, and there were a lot of concerns, a plethora of concerns, different reasons why people voted no. And it doesn't seem like any of that has been addressed. For instance, I know there was a lot of parents talking about why not an intermediate school? Why not a 5-6 school? you pull out

087the fifth grade out of all the elementary schools and you pull out the sixth grade out of the current middle school and make an intermediate school this way you have you open up room at all the elementary schools because nobody's talking about what we're going to do at the elementary level we're talking about opening a school a high school and a middle school if this passes in 2022 what about the elementary schools they're overcrowded now too but but it seems like that's dropped off thought process so what what are we going to do at the elementary schools in the meantime currently sixth grade at the middle school does not participate in you know quote-unquote middle school activities they don't participate in clubs they don't participate in sports then they don't participate in the pep rallies

088middle school activities start at seventh grade so why not have a 7-8 school and pull out the sixth grade have a 5-6 school It seems like you save a lot of money that way, too, on not having to have double sports teams, double coaches, double plays, everything double that you have at the middle school. I don't understand why we're not looking into that. Also... We keep talking about this land that is still in the courts. It's still being decided. It's going before a three-judge panel. We're still in litigation over land. We have no idea how much that's going to cost the taxpayers. That, too, was another huge issue why people voted no. It's still an issue. So I don't understand how we're going out for the same thing when we haven't listened to what the

089concerns were. Why haven't we had town halls before we put out a referendum to get everybody's opinion and then go back to the table and come up with a referendum that the entire community could support? But we're being given the exact same thing. We've given our input and it's not been it hasn't been looked at or taken into consideration We're going back for the same thing. You need to convince the parents in the town that this is the best plan But we're not doing that. You're trying to shove it at us again without listening to the concerns that people had. We should be doing what other towns are doing. East Brunswick went away from having two middle schools. They have intermediate and then junior high school. Princeton, too. Princeton has a middle school, and they're

090building an intermediate school. I don't understand why we think that two middle schools is the answer. just from an educational standpoint if I recall it so many of the meetings that I attended we had a large committee meeting student growth advisory I'm sorry confusing committees student growth advisory committee were about a hundred residents and community members administration teachers participated the idea of a grade five six building was brought to the committee and there was a lot of concern about the number of transitions that a student would make going from primary elementary middle middle elementary through for grades five and six and then on to the middle school so and also you're looking for property in a centralized area because all of the residents in the town would attend that school and the idea of fifth

091graders on a bus for that length of time was discussed so that idea was kind of dismissed among the committee and the idea of building a separate equal middle school was the next step for the committee which ultimately you know why we're sitting here today One of the top sorry your foreman. All right. I just want to finish my sentence Princeton has one of the top high schools in the country We strive to be like Princeton. Maybe we should take a lesson from what they do. Hi Cindy McIntyre 552 spots for English Town Road We might myself my husband were here tonight because the principal of the middle school told us that Tonight before this meeting went on that the board would meet to speak about the incident that happened at the middle school with

092our son who was strangled by another student who was on house arrest for a terroristic threat against a police officer. I would like to know where I find the rules and the regulations and where are these laws that allow non-law-abiding students who have a violent... problem to sit in the class with the rest of our kids who are law-abiding, who makes those rules and how come we're not allowed to know or separate or have some sort of... Safety measure put in place for this certainly and I invited your husband to come in You're more than welcome also to come in if your schedule is available We do discuss student issues at the board meeting in a closed session confidential setting But I'm more than willing to meet with you and your husband to discuss the

093issue and I would prefer that we do that Because there are student confidentiality Of course you would like it confidential. You know what the whole thing has been confidential The victim here is hush-hush and the perpetrator is being protected. My son was slashed with a razor blade. Another female student was slashed with a razor blade. We have to go to work and put our kid in Monroe Middle School and we're afraid to keep our kid here because it's not safe. There are no rules. There's nothing in black and white that tell us that, you know. These are the rules. Apparently, the law is on the side of the, not on our side. They're on the side of the person who's not doing the right thing. So let's meet and we'll review every one of your

094concerns tonight. Okay, let's just keep it a secret and make like it's not happening. Thank you. Anyone else wishing to speak? Tiffany DelVal, 93 Hoffman Road. I am a... mother of three girls, two-time Girl Scout troop leader, and also one of the service unit managers for Monroe Girl Scouts in our area. Every year we put together a show for the Girl Scouts, inviting not just the Girl Scouts and their families, but also our whole community to see the show. It's called World Thinking Day, and that's a day for Girl Scouts all over the world, USA, we celebrate on February 22nd where we think about we're not alone. There's many of us out there in all countries and we may be called different things, girl guides, etc., but it's all for the same purpose, to make

095the world a better place. That show... comprised of all of the Monroe Girl Scouts and we've done it two years now where over the course of months the girls learn about a country that has Girl Scouts they make a presentation on it presentation board display. They make a craft associated with that country or region and then they have to perform a skit or dance respective of that country. This year is a fun twist. We're doing Night at the Movies just as a side note. So we've had even more people. do it. So girls who want to study Japan are going to dance to Kung Fu Panda, but it's all doing the same. It's all doing the same thing. But the past two years, we've had it at the High School Performing Arts Center. We had

096about 200 Girl Scouts in the show and their families. So we had a crowd of maybe 400 to 500 so we had to have it here being that it was a Saturday we we rented we called all the appropriate people Linda Furch she's great in the past we speak to Wendy Wendy Serby she's excellent but they advised us that there's a significant cost for us to have this show there We're paying custodial fees of $967, which we're being charged for security and all these other costs. And it turns out to be $1,600 just to have the show in our school, in our town. So we were hoping that being that we're a nonprofit. all the money that we generate for this show kind of it pays for itself and we would we wanted it to

097do more that money is supposed to go to girls who have earned their gold awards that are graduating from high school to go to college we use that money for community projects that we're doing so I wanted to see if there was anything that the board of ed could do being that the Girl Scouts were a non-profit organization because on top of us paying $1,600 just to have the show there. We also, we use the sound that is affiliated with the school. It has to be the Union Reed sound, which they're wonderful too. And even the janitors that are there, they're great, but we always have to have two janitors for... eight hours when the show it's the show is only two hours long and girl scouts access the building probably two hours prior to

098the show because reed sound also needs two hours start time and then we use that for a rehearsal but to have a security guard there i don't know if if that could be explored do we need the security guard for the whole seven hour block do we need two janitors maybe we could just have one or if there is even a special rate that could be for nonprofits school business administrator yes I'll be happy to meet with you and go over the specifics of the Girl Scouts needs perhaps a custodian can be shaved I don't know how many people are going to plan to attend. I'm not that familiar with your exact event. Perhaps security could be. Right, you know minimized or eliminated depending on how many people are there obviously crowd control is the

099most important thing, right? But with regard to the cost it's all driven by policy, right? It's public taxpayer funds which pay for the utilities in the school the staff the Custodians and the policy is designed so that the Board of Education doesn't profit off these Nonprofit events occurring in our schools, but we recoup the costs so that it's not public funds being paid for non-profit private events right so um well if there's something yeah that can be worked out let me get in my car to be happy to meet with you and that's great if we could shave some some uh expenses off that may be uh thank you thank you very much is there anyone else who wishes to speak to the agenda okay seeing no one i will close the agenda and we

100will go to the superintendent's report mr graham thank you mrs kalavanowich as part of my report tonight i'd like to revisit something from the last report as previously mentioned I want to inform the school community of our efforts to support all of our special education students and their families. You saw a great presentation tonight. By working with parents of special needs children in the organization known as CPAC, or the Special Education Parent Advisory Group, the goal is to make the group more meaningful and influential. A general meeting of CPAC is scheduled now for November 29th. from six to eight here at the high school media center. I encourage the entire community to attend. but that is an official meeting so we're meeting November 29 6 to 8 in the high school media center and we

101will use the Falcon Flyer to remind folks about the meeting and I'm happy to announce and I'll let the board know when we finalize a date that we will be into soon announcing our first annual CPEC Winter Fest party for elementary children and details will be shared soon with finalized dates and specifics and I just want to thank the teachers at our elementary schools who were involved in the project and I'll be more specific once this has more details but I just think it's a real important thing to do I also wanted to thank Rich Alderiso for his presentation tonight on our two referendum projects. The administrative team and I know the board are committed to informing the public on all of the details of the referendum. Our first public appearance will be Monday, December

1023rd from 4.30 to 7 p.m. at the Monroe Township High School Library. The library and MTEA is sponsoring brownies and books. In the children's section, they'll have book readings for kids, and we will be stationed in the main library to detail information on the referendum. if you or your organization would like our team to detail referendum points to your members please contact at the board office to schedule and I wanted to thank MTEA president Beth Ann Augsback for scheduling this and arranging this group for us at the library and we really appreciate MTEA's efforts to support our referendum Typically, as superintendent, as building principal, I get a lot of points said to me about things that are said on social media, and I typically don't address them because most of it is inaccurate and false.

103But I wanted to take an opportunity because so many... people within the community contacted me about you know where's our curriculum at I'm seeing all these posts student performance and the programs that you have in the district and was recently criticized a lot on social media and in addition to that a lot of the criticism was targeting our assistant superintendent dr. Alvick and or ela supervisor and world language supervisor dr. Roselle And the superintendent, I wanted to tell the community, these posts are completely false and inaccurate. Our curriculum is all up to date and aligned to current standards. our programs from AP courses, honors programs, engineering programs for our more rigorous students, and all of our middle programs such as AVID who are addressing kids in the middle, and we have so many programs throughout

104the district who support the kids who are most in need of programs, our special ed students, basic skills we talked about. our programs that we have collaborated on from the Board of Ed the community the most importantly the teachers the students the administrative team are second to none and we have to take advantage all students have to take advantage they have to be responsible for their own learning there's so many things available to the students in Monroe Township School District And I just wanted to let Dr. Alvick know and Dr. Rozelle know, I'm 150% acting superintendent this year and former high school principal. I work with them every day behind the work that they do for kids. They are outstanding educators, and I just wanted to make it a point tonight to, you know, not

105give any credibility to these social media posts. And then on a final fun note, I want to thank Mr. Ryback for joining myself, the high school administrative team, and staff in participating in our annual No Shave November. And the contest, it is sponsored by the advisors and the grade level committees at the high school. We do that each year. I see Mr. Ruttsky tried to join us at the late Rules are Rules, so you can't be part of the contest. The only thing I was wondering if I... volunteered to shave my head but keep the beard could I like stick in at the end rules are rules but we'll talk about the contest next year and my vote is for Mr. Ryback to have the most distinguished beard I just wanted to thank you the

106kids really enjoyed that you participated and so did the teachers who were involved that's all in fun and for a good cause so thank you for doing that my pleasure and you brought it out to be a lot of fun and so I did it and I know principal of magic parallel also joined us in and he's getting grayer and grayer by the day as he's finding out but just thank you for all who participate it's a lot of fun and looking forward to shave december 1st so with that madam board president and members of the board of education it is recommended that personnel action items a through a i under the superintendent's report be approved by consent roll call Mr. Ryback and Mrs. Lang. Any comments or questions for Mr. Goodall? None? Okay, seeing

107none, we will have a roll call, Mr. Gorski. Mr. Chiarella. Yes. Mrs. Lang. Yes. Mr. Rutske. Yes. Mrs. Kolopanovich. Yes. Mrs. Arminio. Yes. Mrs. Carino. Yes. Mr. Ryback. Yes. Mrs. DeMaio. Yes. Mr. Russo. Yes. and the board president personnel items a through ai has passed thank you and if i can for a second miss samantha mcleod is she still here she's over there and she's going to be congratulations she will be serving as interim principal of mill lake for a few months and i just want to thank her for her contribution and stepping up and serving the kids of mill lake so thank you miss mcleod Madam Board President and members of the Board of Ed, it is recommended that Board Actions Items A through R be approved by consent roll call. Mr. Reimach, Mrs.

108Lange, comments or questions for Mr. Goodall? Ms. Arminio? Oh no, I'm sorry. Board Action A through R? Okay, yep. On J, it's the agreement between the Monmouth County Arts Education and Monroe. It's twenty twenty nine thousand five hundred dollars for student participation Do we have an idea of how many students are participating in that? Includes in transportation? Oh, okay. No, just a sort of around 845 860 29 500 860 no 34 34 34 students okay not to exceed that so there might be more I guess yeah okay and on n we had a lot of paperwork for this evaluation models and rubrics for the following staff I know we're supposed to approve it but I mean I have no training on on that and would have liked to have gotten a little bit more of

109an explanation and everything for approving this so I think it was just just to say yes to everything without really understanding I don't know that that serves us well as a district but I just wanted to comment that would be the reason why I'm just gonna abstain on that anyone else okay we will have a roll call on the action items Board action items board action items a through our mr. Russo. Thank you. Mr. Ryback. Yes This is Cole Polish. Yes. This is the Mayo. Yes. Mrs. Carino. Yes. This is Lang. Yes. This is our mini Oh Yes to everything abstain on n so noted Mr. Rutsky. Yes, and mr. Chiril. Yes Board action items a through R has passed and that concludes my report Thank You mr. Goodall we will go to the business

110administrator mr. Gus mr. Gorski thank you I would like to thank very sincerely all of the transportation staff specifically the bus drivers the dispatchers the secretaries who make calls to parents and instances where buses were running late as well as all of the facilities staff who made this Thursday's early and unexpected snowfall very well handled for our district. I'm very pleased to say that we did not have one single mishap district-wide from a transportation or facility standpoint. And that's what an in-district, quality, committed staff brings to Monroe Township. Mr. Goodall, Dr. Alvick and I wrote to these individuals in an email after that day thanking them for their very professional efforts. We would be remiss if we didn't do so again at the board meeting with the public present. So thanks to all of the

111transportation and facility staff. I guess they beat out the New York Transit and the state in general. So congratulations to the drivers. Madam Board President and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education, it is recommended that Board Action Items A through C be approved by consent roll call. Mrs. Lang, Mr. Chiarella, are there comments, questions for Mr. Korski? Yes, Mr. Chiarella? I just have two comments, no questions. So number one, I wanted to thank the MTEA for the very generous contribution, $32,000. $32,109. Wayne holiday would not forgive me for leaving off that sizable some on the end there and then and then also for Mr. Is wrong He's still here. Thank you for the yoga mat. So I want to thank you for that too I just saw your name your wife's name also.

112So thank you and we're gonna use them at the next board meeting, right? Yes Yes, thank you free board meeting yoga Thank you, Mr. Chiarella. Anyone else? Yes. Mr. Mineo? The last, there's a sentence that says the above action authorizes the business administrator to sign and administer contracts and or purchase orders. Is that just for C or is that for all of the board action this evening? By statute, my position has the authority and that's authorized at. the organization meeting also via board resolution. So I have the authority to sign contracts and execute and commit district funds through purchase orders. Yes, I understand that. So this sentence encompasses the whole board action items, A through C, is that correct? And beyond? Yes. Okay. Anyone else? Then we will have a roll call. Mr. Rutske. Yes.

113Mrs. Carino? Yes. Mrs. Lange? Yes. Mrs. DiMaio? Yes. Mr. Chiarello? Yes. Mrs. Kolponowicz? Yes. Mr. Ryback? Yes. Mr. Russo? Yes. And Mrs. Arminio? Yes. Madam Board President, Board Action Items A through C has passed. That concludes my report. Thank you. okay so we will go to the board president's report and um i would like to congratulate andy polari rupa siegel and peter tifano as their newly elected board members i think I think this will be the first time in many years that we've had three brand new board members on our board starting in January. I'd also like to commend the other candidates, especially Krishna Tikal and Lou Masters for their candidacy and for the support of all our children. And putting your hat in the ring is not always an easy job. And so I

114commend them for their efforts in becoming board members. But now that the election is over, it's time for all of us to move on, and it starts with everyone here in this room and everyone on the outside in respecting each other and respecting the opinions of everybody. And even if we don't agree with everybody, we need to work together. We're all here for children. We're all here to educate children. We're all here to pass a referendum. And as I've said many times, we all are here for kids. We look forward to working with our new board members come January and hope that we have a really good and exciting year. We have a steering committee meeting next Tuesday, November 27th. All members of the steering committee have been given responsibilities and assignments such as FAQ

115sheets, PowerPoint presentations, financials, webpage, media, newsletters, principal communications. We have a big job to do in the next few months and we will keep you updated at every possible time. time that we meet and through different venues such as you know the website and the presentations Mr. Goodall already mentioned that the brownies and books at the public library on Monday December 3rd starting at 430 that will be our first informal presentation we looking forward to having meeting many people there and ask answering your questions and finally on behalf of the board at the wish everybody a very happy Thanksgiving. At this time we'll go to other board business. If there's anybody who wishes to speak. Mrs. Mrs. Lane? Thank you. I have a couple things that I wanted to share. First of all, I know

116the student mentioned the DECA car show for Alex's lemonade stand. It was absolutely freezing out there, but they did a wonderful job. The wind was unbearable, but it was so much fun to talk to the car owners and to visit with the cars, and I think that's a great event that keeps going. Yesterday, Mr. Ryback and I attended... a veterans day presentation in miss lisa papandreas and miss danielle pendalfi's first grade class over at mill lake school and it was absolutely fantastic the these two teachers what they did with their students to honor our american legion post 522 vets It blew me away. It not only just blew me away, it made me cry. The children sang for them. The children read information about being a veteran. The children, they were so wonderful. And at

117the end, the veterans turned around and taught the children all about the American flag and talked to them and answered questions. And the Veterans Post presented... um the children and and that classroom with a flag and in turn that thank you veterans of post 522 flag was made by the children's and that was given to post 522 as a gift and it was a beautiful um an absolutely beautiful presentation and just a little side note because we had our unity we talk about doing um Having inclusive programs throughout the district that is an inclusive classroom where I think those teachers should be really proud of how they co-teach together how they worked with all students so that everybody is a part of that population So that was very important for me to share with you

118guys tonight The Monroe Township High School PTO did a crafts fair this past weekend. That was I got in trouble for spending too much money. But every year it just keeps growing and growing and they're doing a fabulous job with that. I also, on the November 14th, got to attend the Kids Who Make Magic ceremony for radio station 98.3 and two Monroe students were identified and were awarded. uh junior thomas ayman who is here at the high school he was recognized for setting up a theater program and for the work that he does within the township with his friends to clean up the walking trails and to do environmental things and i think it's important that when little things like this ha you know it was a pretty big deal it was a one we

119were at dave and buster's and it was a wonderful night i think it's important that these students get recognized for that too and i have one last thing that i wanted to share i i have had the privilege of being our delegate assembly representative over this year and on saturday we had our last delegate assembly meeting and this time because there were no proposals or any resolutions brought up forth and just so that the public understands the delegate assembly what it they bring the new jersey school boards association brings together representatives from every school board in the state of new jersey to step to basically decide what we as school boards need to lobby our legislators for so it can be changes in school funding it can be changes in testing whatever that might be

120and school boards bring resolutions to the the committee to get voted on and worked on so that that then the legislative branch of the new jersey school boards association can get that word out to the state so this time though because there were there were none we had a presentation by lucille davis who lucille davis was our former head of education superintendent yeah like she was the head of of Commissioner of Education thank you and Mark Magner met Mark Magyar is yeah he is on Sweeney's staff and he works in especially in school funding and things like that and they brought up some very interesting things that are going to be happening I would like to recommend it for anybody who wants to know what the state is proposing or working to there's a document

121online called the path to progress and jay dot work and it will it's really outlining what they're looking to do to for bringing more funding to the school districts and it's very interesting to go to these meetings prisoners So many different districts. There are districts that are angry because they're going to have to raise their taxes on their that they've never raised their taxes to meet the needs of their students. They relied on aid and now they're losing that aid. There are districts who lost aid and are trying to figure out how not to cut too many programs. And then there are districts like ours who we're still looking to get more money. But from everything that. they were saying, especially with this path to progress, is that that is coming and forthcoming. Two big

122things I'd like to make a note of, they are definitely talking about the consolidation of school districts. And the reason for that, it would be to deliver better education for all children. So integrating K to 12 and getting rid of all the K to eight, K to five, K to six districts into big regional school districts. and they wanted to actually stress too that one of the things that they're trying to do to help out with the funding is to make sure that the state starts to fully fund the extraordinary costs of special education they've recognized that they haven't done that in the past it's partly because the state doesn't have the money to do all that funding but they're really working on that so i just wanted to share that that was you know

123it's a really wonderful meeting to get to attend and to be part of thank you Patty welcome Patty's back I'm back she's going all over now thank you anyone else If everybody else is done with real business, I just want to take a moment and thank Mr. Goodall for not only recognizing me for my newfound beard, but for more importantly, not encouraging me to shave my head. So I thank you immensely. That's what I'm here for. I was scared to death when I threw it out there. Sometimes it's not by choice, Mr. Rutsky, but you're okay. Well, thank you, Mr. Rutsky. I'm not offering to shave my head. There's no other board business. We will go to the public forum and again anybody wishing to speak Please come to the microphone give your name and

124address for the record We will are here at here to our four minute time limit and at the end of the four minutes when the the Timer goes off your four minutes are concluded 33 Dana Drive in this today's agenda. I didn't see the expenditure for the last month The financials? Yeah. They were not. We have, maybe Mr. Gortzky can explain it a little bit better than I can. Very short. I don't want you to take my time. Please. Very short. I have two, three questions. September's financials, including the business administrator's treasurer's reports, were presented in October. October's will be presented in December. Okay. That's in compliance with the 60-day requirement. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Understood. Thank you very much. The most important thing, I'm seeing the parents here today. The child, you know,

125I don't know the details, but... has a report, has threatened, the middle school child has threatened the police, was under house arrest. Now, he or she is sending a signal. Please listen here very carefully. This has happened in the past. We don't want to see any shooting or anything. Then we all be sitting here and crying with candles. Okay? Please look at this very carefully. This is for all our children. And we should hope that child we will take care of and something, action is taken in a nice way and his behavior, his or her behavior changes. But this is the message. So take it seriously. The parents are sitting here, you know. So what's, did you get the message? I believe we've got the message. We will look into it. Okay. Thank you. Thank

126you very much. Because we've always said safety and security of our students has to be number one in this district. So please. We will let Mr. Goodall do what he needs to do. We want to. This has to be very transparent. We are not going to take anyone's name. As an example, we as a public want to know the child. with trouble is coming to the class, allowed to sit with the class, and is cutting, taking line. Dr. Parha, I'm a little uncomfortable where the conversation's going. There's student confidentiality, and I'm more than willing to listen to the parents, and certainly we take all of these issues very, very seriously. And I'm sorry to interrupt you, but I think it's going in a direction. If the policies are not accordance to be transparent to the

127public, then the policies have to be changed. So what are the policies we want to understand? Please. Policies, when we talk about students, it is confidential, and we cannot discuss that in front of the public. No, no. The policies from the government, the policies of bullying. how the policies are, if the student is coming and threatening, police problem and all. How they have to be handled, we would like to know those policies. I believe they're on the website. I have no time to go to the website and search. Dr. Parab, we communicate whenever there's been a security issue, a student safety issue, we communicate with the parents. The community, if we have to, through the police, we put out as much information as possible how the situation was handled. Okay. And we will do that

128in any circumstance. Okay. Thank you. Andy Palluri, 16 St. James Street. I had the opportunity to speak to a couple of legislators this week, and I just want to update you on what the mindset is and what's coming up next week. On November 26th, which is next Monday, the legislation is going to vote on the legalizing recreational marijuana. And listening to the parents of the child who is being threatened and being bullied, it's really disheartening. And I think we need to make sure that with this type of legislation that are going in the government, the kids are safe. And I don't need to over-emphasize this after the last speaker, but I'm sure you all get the message. So I want to make sure that we're taking action towards that. The one other comment that I

129want to make is that when we start making these presentations, We need to think about how we take the presentation to the people rather than having people come to the presentations. What I mean by that is in the last referendum, we had close to a dozen meetings. selling our ideas and things like that. And I think the average number of attendance was four to five people in some of those meetings. And I think if we actually go to the senior communities and talk to them during one of their celebrations, same thing within a community like the Indian community, when they have an event, carve out 10, 15 minutes to make a presentation on what we're trying to accomplish. That to me would go a lot further than what we have been able to accomplish. That's

130all I have. Thank you. Thank you. Eric McIntyre, 552 Spotson English Town Road. I have one question about the paperwork here. Again, my first time here on an unfortunate reason, but you have this violence, substance abuse, estimate of violence, and all this stuff, and you have one incident for the Monroe Township Middle School, and it says fight, but then two slots under there you have assault. So, I personally know that there was three incidences, a thousand percent, there's not a doubt in my mind. There was probably more, but there's three that I know within this time frame. And the one that I'm talking about with my son, I don't know why it's being labeled as a fight when he was attacked from behind. because he had the luxury of being in shape and being a

131good kid and handling himself during the situation. So then it's called the fight when he was attacked from behind. I think that's appalling. And I see right down here that you do have an option to put assault. And there's only one incident. So this is straight false. And I will come speak to you tomorrow, but there's so much that I got to say. And the doctor spoke about these are the signs. These are the signs before something happens and everybody cries afterwards. I'm not going to let that happen. Again, do you understand my frustration from hitting three dead ends from the highest level possible? Police, school, anti-bullying. I'm not the type of person to even do that. So I broke what goes on in my head to try to do everything 100% the right way.

132And I'm hitting brick walls. And I'm not going to handle it. I'm not that person that's going to accept it. You know, so I'm giving it one day, and I need this resolved. I need something to happen. So tomorrow I will give you all the time that you and your wife need to talk about your frustration about how the situation was handled, and let's talk tomorrow. Anyone else from the public? Nancy Schaefer 34 first Avenue Nancy Schaefer 34 first Avenue on behalf of the 13 Paris that transportation we did an excellent job on Thursday as well keeping the kids calm and Happy just to let you know. Thank you Hi, Ram Rangnath, 6-0 in Strive, Monroe. A couple of things. Thanks for recognizing my wife and the donation of the yoga mats. Just to clarify,

133it's 50 yoga mats, not $50. The question I had when you approved that item J, I hope I can ask about it, about the Monmouth County Arts and Education Center, $29,000. We said 34 students, right? I recall receiving something from middle school as well. I think the Middlesex County, we do some arts program with them as well, where I think our middle school students are sent. So I'm just hoping that we are looking at these multiple line items holistically, right? We're paying here, paying there, we're busing students there, busing students, you know? Does it make sense to look at things a little bit more holistically and make sure we probably do it in one place where we have better, you know, efficiency in how our spends are versus kind of leakage in many different places?

134Thank you. We'll take that into consideration. Thank you. Thank you. Doug Boyd for Tamarack Road. Because of where I'm sitting, I've been staring at that schematic of the middle school, the proposed new middle school. And a member of the public asked about the plans for being able to expand that. at some point in the future. And the gentleman here from the architectural firm indicated that the expansion could easily occur on each end of that classroom wing. But as I look at that schematic. I don't see that there's sufficient space there at all for that, so I'm simply pointing out what I've observed on the schematic. I realize it's only a schematic, but I think it's a good idea that they have the possibility of expanding for additional classrooms, but I think they need to plan

135for that expansion in terms of designing of the driveways and things of that nature. Thank you. Thank you. I have a question on the referendum. If the referendum passes in March, when do we get our shovels on the ground? I believe Mr. Tague is not here, but I believe it would be a year and a half after the referendum passes, and then it would take a year and a half to build the middle school. Just trying to understand, can we shorten that year and a half between the referendum, the time it takes to pass between the referendum success and shovels on ground? Well, to open a school, you're not going to open a school like in March or April or May. I understand that. So you would have to, I don't see how you could

136do it to open it September of 2021. Yeah, but then if you're spending a year and a half just trying to get everything ready can we that I Would invite mr. Ticali to call mr. Tague and I will have a very intelligent thorough conversation about the matter But we wish we could shorten that timeline but there's there's submissions and Approvals that have to come from the state before you can get going and and you have to follow this very rigid timeline Okay, we'll have that corner just thank you mister. Please give us a call Chrissy scurvy 21 Preakness Drive. Mr. Goodall. I have a question. I wanted to ask you in regards to personnel If an employee of the district calls a parent a derogatory name Like for instance a piece of shit. What is

137the protocol on that? Does the administration handle that or does that parent have to file an ethics complaint in Trenton? the parent or community member should take the issue up with me As a start, okay, and I'll call and make an appointment with your office to see you. Thank you. I'll be duty 10 arrows away I just wanted to get a sense that regarding the parents sitting over here Talking about assault on their kid Would it be possible for the members of the public to know how the issue was resolved in the next meeting? That's a that's a or how can we be more aware of how something like this can be handled better by the members of the public We could learn how to do it better and teach you teach that or give

138you that but we cannot talk about the specific issue between Children I'm here because I'm a bit concerned With the fact that they're like going from pillar to pillar And the ultimate resolve is coming to the superintendent. So if that is the case, then we can knock on his door. So I'd like to know that, and we should make the community aware of that too. I mentioned in the past, and I was speaking in my role as principal and also with my colleagues, if things happened at other schools in the past, we communicate as best we can, whether in a letter home to parents or communications or Blackboard Connect, whatever communication system that we're using, as much detail as we possibly could, reassuring parents that whatever the situation is. that it's safe to be in

139school and that your children are safe. Details, because we're dealing with a lot of minors here, were prohibited from discussing because of student confidentiality laws. Yes, but I think all that we need to know is in future if something happens to someone else, what's the course of action as a parent that we need to take? Or what are the steps we need to take to resolve that situation? Well, certainly you would speak to the building level administration And then if you find that the issue is unresolved you can go up the chain and typically the superintendent Would be the next step. Okay. Thank you anyone else from the public Cindy McIntyre five five two spots with English Town Road if hypothetically your Student was in the hallway and walking and somebody Strangled him from the

140back and stopped him, pulled him down and stopped him from breathing temporarily, just say that happened to somebody's kid, would you expect the school to call the parent and let them know that their kid was attacked in school? Or would you expect the student to text his father to come and get him immediately? And the other part of my question is, at what point then... do you do something about having it happen again to the same kid or somebody else's kid, hypothetically speaking? All of the administrative team knows to communicate with parents related to an incident within a reasonable amount of time. Not knowing all of the specifics, it's hard for me to comment on that. And it's hard for me to speculate. responding to some of the comments that you're making. And I'm more

141than willing to have this conversation tomorrow. And we can go over, I will give you all of the time that you need to discuss, because I know that you and your husband are upset on how this is handled. And I will give you all the time that you need tomorrow, and we will discuss this matter. but you know communication is key and at times because of digital media and Kids can text their parents before a phone call could be made because that's how we outreach typically either that or email to parents now so so what would you I'm sorry without knowing all the details like, you know, I'd like to keep that to the conversation tomorrow, right? We can so yeah, so that was basically it like what would be a reasonable time frame? What

142would you expect? I don't know all the particulars of this. 45 minutes or after the incident? Depending on the situation, within a few minutes, it could be a half hour. It all depends on the situation, but within a reasonable amount of time. Okay. Thank you. Hello. Rushing Jarawalla, 18 Maxwell Road. My question is more about the middle school and high school referendum. And as I understand, there are two options. It's either middle school only or middle school and high school. If the referendum fails on both of these counts, I would like to understand the timing on the next steps and the impact it will have on, I guess, the students in the meanwhile. Well, if it fails, we have to wait six months before we can go out again. So that means we can't, if

143we went out with the exact same thing, we couldn't go out until September. That would delay the building of the school another year. That would probably mean more trailers, definitely at the middle school, possibly at the high school. And every delay that we have will increase the cost of the referendum more. And so I mean let's say if this fails second time I mean there is no reason to think that it would pass the third time around. Is there like a limit on how many times the referendum can go and like steps beyond that? Well, after two to three losses of the same referendum, we can petition the state to come in. They would do a facility study about unhoused students and the facilities, the schools, if they're overcrowded. They can tell us that after

144they finish their report that we have to build a school. We would be building a state school, which probably would not be the equivalent of a the current middle school They won't give us any money to build that school so it would fall back on the taxpayers but every delay that we have because that could take a year or two for them to do with study is Going to increase the cost of building a middle school a middle school and a high school addition Has this happened in New Jersey in the last couple of years? And so the other reason I was asking is to get like a ballpark. on the time that it would take the state to do their thing. And then I guess when it comes to that. So let's say, for

145example, with the referendum passing in March, we are talking about September 2022. If we had to go to the state route, I mean, are we looking at 2025? Like ballpark number, I'm obviously not asking anybody to know exactly. Well, I can't give you an exact number. But if we decided, we're hoping it doesn't fail. So that would be the best thing for, if it fails, we could do one of the two things. We can go out in September again, but chances are it's the same referendum. You know, we would have to look at the. how many people voted this, how many people voted that for that and see if it would be feasible to go out again. If we petition the state, I have no idea how long it could take them to do a

146report, to come in and do a... Has it happened recently? Anybody? Sorry. Has it happened? Freehold Borough, you could find an example of the state coming in, overriding the referendum vote which defeated Freehold Borough's referendum. authorizing the school district to go ahead and sell bonds for that school project freehold borough is very different than Monroe don't don't assume that those circumstances are going to be the same with Monroe's demographics that it is extremely unlikely that the state would come in here and and subsidize the project all right thank you so much it doesn't happen very often Once every few years or something that state will come in but We need to work to pass this referendum. Right? My kids aren't even at the school right now I'm just concerned that you know, what's the worst

147case could be Thank you Anyone else Nagar Bacha, 15 Harvest Street Drive. I was just searching online with respect to the square footage cost in comparison to how many kids and everything, the $143 and all that. So looking at it from an eligible cost perspective, that the state would say, for example, for the middle school, if they say $19 million is eligible cost, have they guaranteed that they're going to give the money back towards the construction? Or are we raising the full $76 million? Madam? What were they going to give us at the... Bear with me one second. The state, based upon our preliminary eligible cost letter, has committed for the middle school project debt service aid in the amount of $7.5 million. Okay, so during the duration of the repayment of the bonds principal

148and interest the state will reimburse Monroe Board of Education 7.5 million Okay, but going by the calculation that Dr. Parab explained, right, it comes to $19 or $21 million. I think it was $21 for the high school and $19 for the middle school. So how does that compare to the $7.5 million that they say is qualified? Respectfully, good question. I don't follow his math and his calculation there. We'd have to have a further conversation because we have a cost engineer who came up with these figures. The state comes up with eligible and uneligible costs for the project. They base state aid upon eligible costs. And that's what resulted in the $7.5 million state aid award for the middle school. For the high school project, there are more eligible costs, even though the project size is

149less, and that's why that's been a preliminary eligible award of $11.5 million for the high school piece. So it's a very complex calculation, and I would invite you to give us a call if you want to go through that further. Okay. Thanks. Anyone else from the public wishing to speak? okay seeing no one we will close public forum closed session madam may i just ask a question you know it's sort of i i only sort of developed the question since the public forum um since there are a lot of questions about this referendum could we have a specific board of education meeting addressing most of these maybe we can have a meeting and sort of have an open meeting with our residents and our stakeholders obviously we're asking them to one vote for it and

150two but also the steering committee is not how many board members are on the steering committee Three. Three. Okay, so the rest of us really have not been able to absorb all of the information. So I would really like a, and the board members don't have to come if they don't want to, but to have a special meeting with as many board members who would like to come and members of the public, like a town hall meeting, with a real in-depth. Q&A. Well, not just a Q&A, but I would like to really go over these documents. Now that they're available, I'd like to review them, and I may have to go into the board office. But if every individual person goes in to talk to either Mr. Tague or Mr. Goodall or Mr. Gorski, I

151think it's a waste of resources like ours. If we can all get together, and I think I like when I hear members of the public asking very intelligent questions, and a lot of them are you know, far more advanced in either financing or building or anything than I, and I'm learning from them. So I would ask that we also, as part of our outreach, do a specific, a special meeting for this. We could do a special meeting. And invite the public. That would mean that a quorum of the board would have to come, too. Well, if... I think we could work around that. If a quorum of the board doesn't come, we can still have an open meeting. It's just no action could be taken, just like the steering committee. I mean, the steering committee

152is making decisions, and then the whole board, we're just sort of, you know, I feel a little bit behind the eight ball when the board as a whole should be making these decisions. before these schematics even come up. So I would ask that we get brought up to date with details. We can do that. Probably wouldn't be before January. No, of course not. But I think it would be a good start to exposing the public and the rest of us because the steering committee really doesn't make, we still have to approve these things as a full board, correct? Absolutely. Okay. Yes, we wouldn't do anything in regard to the referendum that we have to without the approval of the Board of Education. So that's just a request for January. Okay. So closed session resolution be

153it resolved that the Board of Education of the Township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law Chapter 231 of the Public Laws of 1975 and JSA 10 column 4-6 through 10 column 4-21 to discuss the following subject harassment, intimidation, and bullying. Following closed session action may be taken. The discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public. at such time as a need for confidentiality no longer exists so moved second uh second mrs lang miss de mayo all in favor aye opposed abstain okay at this time we will move into closed session so at this time we will move back to public session and seeing no one in the public our next scheduled board of education meeting SCHEDULED FOR DECEMBER 19, 2018, 7 O'CLOCK PM

154AT THE MONROE TOWNSHIP HIGH SCHOOL. MOTION TO ADJOURN? MOTION. I WON. MS. LANG, IS THERE A SECOND? MS. CARINO? ALL IN FAVOR? OPPOSED? OKAY. MEETING IS ADJOURNED.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.