CorpusRecord 159488

Monroe Township Board of Education Regular Meeting 11.20.19

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-10
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,790 words · about 77 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everyone the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Mr. Gorski may we please have a roll call certainly Mrs. Arminio Mrs. DiMaio yes Mrs. Kolopunovic yes Mrs. Lange yes Mr. Masters? Here. Mr. Poluri? Here. Mr. Ryback? Here. Mrs. Siegel? Here. Mr. Tufano? Here. Mr. Rudsky? Here. Madam Board President, you have a quorum present this evening. Thank you. In accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey Open Public Meetings Law, the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date, time, and place thereof posted November 15, 2019 at all schools, the Home News Tribune, the Cranberry Press, and filed with the clerk of the municipality. Thank you. Before we get to the approval

002of the minutes, I would just like to congratulate Ms. Arminio and Mr. Chiarella on their reelection to the Board of Education and welcome Mr. Nikitinsky to the board. We look forward to working with each of you on making sure that our students continue to get the best education possible. So at this time, we'll go to the approval of the minutes for this special public board of education meeting of October 3, 2019. So moved. Mrs. Lange, Mr. Pallori, any additions or corrections to the minutes? Seeing none, all in favor? Aye. Opposed? Abstain or recuse? Seeing none we will have the approval of the minutes for the closed session meeting of October 3rd 2019 So moved by Mr. Ryback second by Mrs. Lang again any additions or corrections to the minutes all in favor opposed abstain or

003recuse Okay, then the minutes have been passed. We would normally have our student board members reports at this time, but they do not seem to be here. They are probably involved in their numerous activities as students. So we will go to our presentations, and the first one will be for the unified program, and I'm going to turn the meeting over to Dr. Alvick. Good evening, everyone. I'm very excited to have our Falcon Pals and Unified program from Armand Ratachup High School here with us this evening. They have been recognized by the Special Olympics of New Jersey as a certified unified program. And last month, I was excited to go with them and present to many school districts from the state of New Jersey on our unified program. We were invited to be the the group,

004a panel during the lunch time of a full day of the Change the Game conference. So it was very exciting. I got to present with the students and with Ms. Dillon, Mrs. Ruella, Mrs. Hines, and we were able to talk about all of the great things that we're doing for our students. And then again this past Saturday, we were down in Asbury Park where many of the students and staff members took the plunge and did the polar plunge. It was very cold on Saturday. And to raise money for Special Olympics of New Jersey. But they're here this evening to kind of share with you some of the great things that are happening with our program. So Mrs. Dillon and her students. We are here today to basically express our thanks and appreciation to the board

005for their support of our programs. Like Dr. Alvick had mentioned, we are a unified champion school. We were the number one school in New Jersey last year, and we are the model district for the Special Olympics of New Jersey. They use our programs. They use our programs for other school districts. In fact, tomorrow we actually have a school district coming to visit us during our phys ed classes to see how we operate and what we actually do. We have a very unique program in our community-based fitness program where we have our 18 to 21 year old students in a unified class and on Tuesdays and Thursdays we go out into the community. Tuesdays we go down to the elementary schools and our students, our unified students with and without intellectual disabilities mentor their younger counterparts.

006It's a great experience for all. And then on Thursdays, our community-based fitness class goes out to different fitness-type activities, such as yoga. We go golfing. We go to Jersey Strong Gym, all which is donated through the community. So the township of Monroe is in full support of our programs as well, and that's what we are very thankful for. Today, I'm not gonna do all the talking because I talk so much, okay? I figured I'd turn it over to the people that actually are involved in the program. They are the ones that experience it and they're gonna share with you what they do and what they are gaining from being in the program. Okay, so we're gonna let Justin Marcello speak first. Okay. Good evening. Good evening everyone. I wrote my speech because it's going to

007be a long one and I hope you like it. My name is Justin Marcello and I am part of the MTHS Unified Program. I have lots of fun with all the activities. I like Project FUN, UP Fitness, Zumba with Mr. Comey and all the sports we do like soccer, basketball, bowling and track. Oh, I have it on my pussy jacket. Look everybody, look, look. I also love doing CBF. Oh, hold on, hold on, hold on. I also love doing CBF and when we eat out at different restaurants like Perkins, Comfy, and Americana Diner. I also enjoy working at L.L. Bean. To all of my Falcon Pals, thank you for being my friend. To my teachers, Ms. Dillon, Mr. Shanfield, and Mr. Osner, thank you for helping me to Dr. Alvidge and the members of the

008Board of Education. Please continue to support us. Thank you for listening. And one last thing. Let's give everyone a round of applause and God bless you all. Very well done, Justin. Thank you. He's going to take a selfie with you. Justin is our spokesperson. Can you tell? And now we have Lauren Roble who is actually the president of our project fund club which is a unified club we run after school. She's also very involved in our in-school programs. She's a part of our unified physical education classes, unified electives, and up fitness, unified soccer. She's all about it. So she has a lot to say. Hi, everyone. I'm Lauren. So I've been a part of these programs for four years of the high school, and it really changed me, and I've been... Get closer to the

009mic, honey. Sorry. There you go. So I'm just going to give you, like, a brief rundown of all the stuff that we do. So one of our mottos for the school is saying that it's not us and them, it's we, because it's important to know that we're all students, and it's not fair for some students to teach other students just because they have disabilities, because we're all the same. And some of our unified goals is that, sorry, some of our unified goals are listed on the screen. And another thing that we like to say is that everybody is uniquely the same because everybody is human, but everybody has different strengths, weaknesses, and personalities that makes us different. And so one of the programs that I'm in is a Falcons Pals class, and this is our

010gym class. And Pals stands for Peers Leadership Skills. And we actually have two classes because there's so many people who want to be involved. And another gym class that we have, as Masil mentioned earlier, was a CBF, which is for the 18 to 21-year-old population. And in this class, we work together to do team building, social, and physical skills. So Falcon Pals is for the seniors, and we play all different kinds of games. like bowling, we've played soccer, and we also use our iPads in this class so we can get everybody acclimated to the different technologies that they can use once they graduate. And in this class we're put into groups of like two or three and we all work together. And up there on the screen is a few activities that we do such

011as hiking, bowling, basketball, and a list of other stuff that we do. We do so much stuff and it's a lot of fun. And this is actually our Chancellor gym class. So the marking period that we go to health is when the juniors come in and they get to start the program a little bit earlier to make sure they really enjoy it so they can continue it for the senior year. And I was also a junior pal and I loved it so I continued. So our CBF program is very involved with the idea of independent learning in the community. So for this the seniors are in a senior option class where they stay after school on Tuesdays and Thursdays So on Tuesdays we go into our up leadership and then on Thursdays we go into

012the community and we do different activities and The facilities that we go to they donate their time their trainers they donate all this stuff So we have the opportunity to do different activities And some other stuff that we do is golf, we do yoga on the beach, we go bowling, and that's just a few of the things that we do and the other ones are listed on the screen. And we also go on trips such as we go horseback riding, we do yoga on the beach, we host a social, we go pumpkin picking. So we do a lot of trips within the program, which is a lot of fun. And this is just more trips that we go on. And we also have two clubs after school. So Project Fun is the first one, which

013I am one of the presidents of. And in this club, we do different activities, such as we do arts and crafts, we play kickball, we do fundraising, and we also participate in the haunted high school that we have at the school. And in our club, that's where we create all the games, and we decided on our theme, which we did Disney this year. And those on the screen is some activities and pictures from our club. And we also have Up Partnership or Up Fitness, which rotates every single Thursday between yoga, strength training, and Zumba. And we have a falcons palette and a winter fest. So where the parents and either high school students, we have one for the high school students and we have one for the elementary students. So our parents come and we

014do a painting activity together. And then our winter fest is where some of the high school students go down to the elementary grades and we do arts and crafts with them. And then so some more things we do sports wise is up dance. So our students with ID go are paired up with somebody in our dance team at the high school and they practice together and they also perform at the basketball games together and We are very lucky to have many sports. So we have Special Olympics bowling we have unified soccer unified basketball and unified track and fields and These programs keep getting bigger and bigger each year. So sir unified bowling team and we actually host a Day where we play my touch in so it's Monroe versus my passion for bowling and our

015unified soccer We actually had the opportunity to sign with the Red Bulls last year So we got jerseys we got track suits and we all a few of us flew out to Kansas City and we played a game and The next one is unified basketball and we actually won the state championship in the group B division last year We get uniforms, we get a banner, we get wings, just like that. Yeah, but that's good. This is our track team, just more pictures. A program we actually started last year, which is a lot of fun, is Up Leadership. So our CBF class and a few student leaders go down to the elementary grades into their unified programs, and we work on social and physical skills. So we talk about friendship, and we also play games. variety

016of activities and things for students across the district. Tomorrow we're getting a shipment in of something called Strider bikes, which are balance bikes. And basically what they are is for younger students to learn how to ride a bike, providing core strength, balance, agility, and we can actually have them progress onto a pedal bike. All right, so all of our younger students that we work with in the partnership program will be enjoying this, like, starting tomorrow. Yeah. Sorry. Okay. All right, I think we're about wrapping it up. These are students, they are participants in a variety of the activities throughout our district as far as the unified programs are concerned. If anyone ever has any questions regarding unified programs, please feel free to reach out to me or to any of our students and they'd be

017very happy to explain to you what we're about. Thank you so much for your attention. i'd like to thank you for coming today and telling us a little bit about your award-winning unified program i am very very proud of where we've come and how this board has been supporting you for all these years and we look forward to supporting you for many more i'd also like to personally thank mrs dillon because without her this program would not be the same And she doesn't get the recognition that she deserves. So thank you very much. This is just a very awesome program. So at this time, we have another presentation, and I will turn the floor over to Dr. Lehman. So at this time, I'd like to invite Ms. Papandrea and Ms. Pandolfi's class up. They're teachers

018and students from the Lake School. So as they're coming up. This year, the class spent time in November creating a presentation and a dedication in honor of the veterans of American Legion Post 522. This year, all Mill Lake students were invited to create posters, cards, and sentiments for all the veterans of Post 522. The students' presentation includes songs, poetry, facts about veterans and Veterans Day, and culminated in a bagel breakfast where the students spent quality time with the veterans of American Legion 522. The veterans shared their experiences serving in the United States, taught the students how to fold the American flag properly, played the bugle, and answered all of the students' questions. Their time spent together was filled with patriotism and pride. So, Ms. Pandolfi, Ms. Papandrea. We celebrated Veterans Day by honoring the veterans

019of Post 522. The veterans came and we shared songs, poems, and thankful thoughts for them. A thankful wall of cards at Mill Lake School made a card for a veteran's poem, post 522. spending time with the veterans of post 522. They taught us what the American flag stands for and how to fold it. We made some special cards for you. Please enjoy our video. It's made up of the Air Force, Army, Marines, Navy, and Air Force. Veterans Day is a time for us to pay our respects to those who have served. Veterans Day is celebrated on November 11th because the 19th was signed in the fighting during World War I and II. Later, President George O. Wilson said that November 11th will be Columnist's Day. 1938 was a day dedicated to peace. Before, President Eisenhower

020changed November 11th to Veterans Day in order to represent all veterans from all wars. Protect the veterans by learning what it means Thank you for bringing this program to us today and teaching us a little bit about Veterans Day. I'm sure the veterans who came to your class were very happy that you had them there, and I'm sure it was an awesome day for everybody. So thank you for coming here tonight. Okay, at this time we will go to committee reports. Are there any committees that need to report this evening? Madam President. Ms. Armadillo. Before we begin, I would just like to apologize to the audience for my delaying in getting here. I wasn't sure I'd even make it today. I spent, unfortunately, most of the day in the University of Pennsylvania Medical Center with

021my husband, who needs a procedure, and he happens to be a veteran. I'm sorry for being late, but I wasn't even sure I'd make it at all and hopefully he'll be fine. So thank you very much. Ms. Arminio, your family always comes first and you need to do what you need to do and we all understand that. Thank you. Thank you. So committee reports, I'll start with Ms. DeMeo. We had a curriculum committee meeting tonight. We first reviewed two History, two history curriculum. The first one was World Honor's History. This is, okay. This, World History presents. a panorama of people and their development. And this curriculum is designed to acquaint students with pertinent world events that will further enhance their global perspective and enable them to see human development in a different light. This curriculum

022teaches a variety using... Excuse me. Teachers use a variety of teaching techniques and instructional material that enables students to analyze the broad historical forces that are at work in shaping the world of the 21st century. And what this course really does is they look, the students look at current events and they tie that into the history curriculum. Themes such as human rights, religions, violence in society, global conflict, and cooperation that have shaped our contemporary world, interdependence, world culture, regions, characteristics of a culture, cultural diversity, environmental concern, the relationship between geography and society, and the role of the arts in human development are studied along with other issues which are all state mandated. The second history curriculum we talked about was American Image on a Field. This is a study in American history and culture. It's

023a half year course. The other half is a civics course and they pair very nicely. This class uses films that reflect the issues of the day. Students discern how Film mirrors issues such as social justice, traditional American values, and the complex and often contradictory social, political, scientific, and economic development in American society. It starts off in the 20s, and they watch such movies as The Kid, Mildred Pierce, Gentleman's Agreement, The Best Years of Our Lives. 1950s is Stalag 17, 1967 they watch in the heat of the night, Cool Hand Luke, Bonnie and Clyde. 1970 is Norma Rae. 1980s is The Breakfast Club, Philadelphia, and Forrest Gump. We also reviewed, hold on, Math for Real Life. It's a fourth year senior option. for students who want to meet another math class and basically it talks it

024teaches them how to use math in day-to-day activities it all such as going to the store and using money and it helps prep kids for college placement in addition we reviewed some clubs every year Mr. Colella, our vice principal in charge of co-curriculars, reviews the clubs. And he looks at attendance, and he determines which clubs don't have enough attendance to sustain them from year to year. And they're not quick to... get rid of clubs. They really try to, if they see a club is losing student participating, they really put some effort in place to get more students into, involved in the club. But eventually there are clubs that they have to cancel. So over the past two years they've canceled two clubs and they brought two more, six, I'm sorry. Two years, six clubs, yes.

025And the past, so this year they brought us two new clubs. They're service clubs. The first one is the Patriot Warrior Club. This club will function primarily as a fundraising and community service centered extracurricular organization. Every year the club will pick a nonprofit organization that assists veterans to partner with and assist that organization in its fundraising endeavors. The club will also provide an outlet to students who are interested in joining the armed forces in the future. The second club is the Interactive Club. The Interactive Club are student branches of local Rotary Clubs throughout the U.S. There are over 20,000 Interactive Clubs, including chapters at both North and South Brunswick High School. The mission of this club is to bring together students to develop their leadership skills while discovering the power of service. above self. The

026proposed high school chapter specifically plans to focus on bringing typical students and students with special needs together to participate in projects to help the community. We also, oh, and the other thing is they, there was a club name change. They changed the dance, the club, the dance, jazz dance club to the Monroe Township High School dance team because they really do more than just jazz dance. We also made some changes to our, some of our music classes. So we've. The treble choir, the advanced percussion ensemble, and project lead the way engineering design and development capstone course have all been deemed honors courses and students will get honor credits for taking these courses. All the students of the Monroe Township High School will be eligible for the wind ensemble and honors percussion ensemble. These are... These

027are classes that students have to try out for, but they are honor level classes. We also reviewed a special education program. In February of 19, in 2000, this is the least restrictive environment settlement. So 78 districts in the state were identified through using NJSMART to determine whether they are following the least restrictive environment requirement in preschoolers. Monroe was identified that had a... that we had a high rate of preschoolers with IEPs that are being educated in a separate setting rather than in a mix with gen ed students. We spent a couple years working on getting more gen ed students integrated with our preschools. And so for it to be an integrated preschool program, The class would have eight special ed students to nine general ed students. So we worked on getting more general ed students

028involved in our preschool. We completed all phases of the assessment from monitoring and training from 2014 to 2019. And we have... shown tremendous growth and the district is compliance with all monitoring areas and findings and we're currently awaiting a letter from the DOE that we are in compliance and the settlement is closed thank you thank you any other committee meetings Mr. Toffano Madam President may I ask a question oh absolutely I'm sorry thank you You mentioned about an interactive club and it's going to include leadership and unified programs. We already have clubs for that in light of we closing clubs with they're not active. Why start brand new two clubs? Well, that was asked at the committee meeting also. And it turns out, I mean, these are service clubs. We only have one other service

029club, the key club. And so it wasn't. We're not I think that can you speak more to it because I know the key club is a very popular club So it's basically these two clubs will build capacity we Oftentimes are reached out by the community for support in terms of community service hours. So this broadens the Range of students that we have that we could present to support opportunities, you know in the community So this is just building capacity. This is driven off a student need It kind of is a different niche than a key club. And the clubs that were phased out, again, it's a typical cycle as we take students and they go through their four years here. There may be an interest in a writing club or something like that. But if

030those students kind of phase out and they graduate and the students don't kind of fill that void, we phase those clubs out and we bring new ones in. Yeah, my concern is that we don't want to undermine. the key club and the others that are being very active and productive by creating more and more layers of it. Yep, and that's what we did. We talked about saturation. And are we saturated in terms of our service club? And at this point, the analysis is we actually could use some more service clubs to help support our needs. Ms. Arminio? Yes. Could you have Mr. Lehman, Dr. Lehman, excuse me, could you explain capacity, building capacity? building capacity I referenced that in terms of more students give us more people to send out into the community to help

031whatever our community needs so that's what you're saying the club is for really to have more students do community services and they're asking for it so the community is asking for community we didn't talk specifics in the meeting I can't think of anything but when we So there's a group of students, and we have actually the names of all the, there's probably 30 or 40 students that are interested in participating in these two clubs, and they are different students than are in the Key Club. So the students are saying, we want more, we want to help out, and Dr. Colella has been analyzing, and he gets reached out by, this is the OWN Foundation, that's one specific opportunity. The OWN Foundation has reached out, and our students have gone and helped them with their, any

032of... the walk that they did that they do every spring that type of thing so it's different foundations in our community that that ask for volunteers because i i i've spoken to some members of the community and they had from what i understand it was a service type club um that was refused so i'm gonna i think i'll ask them to reach out again and see if that club will uh fit the bill if you're saying you need more capacity yeah and it's something he'll do an analysis and we'll figure out you know if we need to continue to build or if there was enough interest in general in that because there is a set of criteria in terms of moving forward through the process and also i attended the workshop at the school boards

033and sustainable new jersey has grants for students that so it may go all the way across different clubs so i would encourage the administration to take a look at or the people involved in the clubs to see if some of the Sustainable New Jersey grants would actually work for their clubs. Actually, they're looking to spend the money, so thanks. I believe when students join service clubs doesn't that help them in their college applications I think colleges look for that along with a lot of other things but it certainly helps On November 12th we had a buildings ground transportation meeting to discuss Eagle River day camps hopefully program expansion as directed by the committee administration prepared outlines including floor plan schematics for the special services office space currently leased at Monroe Commons and the FalconCare early

034childhood enrichment program ECE The developer of the Eagle River Day Camp property and committee members asked administration questions regarding the programs, staffing needs, and the thoughts on future growth and expansion. The developer will review this data and prepare a proposal for how he thinks he could develop the Eagle River Day Camp property to meet the committee's needs. excuse me post meeting discussion the committee requested that the administration investigate the practice of our school buses exiting school property and secession onto township roads thereby temporary blocking traffic administration was requested to call the county engineers office in effort to expedite the processing of a flashing traffic safety sign signs project that we explore options for slowing traffic the high school parking lot maybe a groove pavement or speed humps or something along those lines so we will

035hope they'll get back to us as soon as possible anyone else mrs. Lang okay so the policy committee met met last week and tonight we're presenting one policy that for reaffirmation 11 policies for first read 10 of them are mandated and 3 will be presented for their second read to the bigger policies that are up for mandated and that we're going to be passing tonight one is our school district tobacco use policy and vaping so it is policy 5533 and I want to just really think Ms. Malarney, who is our student assistance counselor, Mr. Higgins, the middle school vice principal, Dr. Colella and Dr. Higgins, both vice principals at the high school who worked really hard. We developed a policy with the help of our board attorney, Mary Smith, and Dr. Alvick that really... listen

036to what they were asking for the policy to state as as the administrators of the schools and for those people who think that vaping isn't a big deal if you're following it in the news you'd find out that it really is a very big deal so the first policy 5533 is handling vaping in by students on the school grounds and like I said earlier and There is a big part of education that's been added to it. No disciplinary action has been taken away from it. It's actually stronger disciplinary-wise. And 7434 is tobacco use on school grounds by other people. So that's being presented tonight for the first read. We also have a policy on earned sick leave. And just so people understand that that covers people who are not under contract. And then the last

037one that I did want to bring up and talk about was policy 9160, which was the public attendance at school events that was sent back and the wording was changed so that it now says the Board of Education and or district administration is going to be handling. people who are disruptive or if they're welcoming so that was changed so that that was clearer and just there was a question about the interpretation of wording and the following rules apply according to our bylaws and policies in our introduction that wherever possible language shall be given it's clear and ordinary interpretation so whatever wording we have in our policies is the wording that's the way it's supposed to be interpreted thank you Anyone else? Mr. Polari? Quickly, I just want to wish Mr. Arminio speedy recovery and hope

038all goes well. Thank you. The Education Advocacy Committee met on November 14th. As some of you may recall, we actually engaged a law firm to see the possibility of suing the state. They did submit a draft report on that day, and we did not get a chance to completely review and digest the information, but we'll certainly be discussing in the closed session today, and we requested the law firm representative to come in and actually present it to our public during the December meeting. Also, Dr. Replette, who is the commissioner of Department of Education, is visiting our district on December 16th. A lot of anticipation. I think that tour is being planned for Applegarth School, and hopefully we get some interest in terms of additional funding from the state on that. I just want to give

039a shout-out to Jerry Tague. One of the residents called me to complain that the roof at Applegate School was out of place or is coming off during one of the storms. It was quickly fixed on October 25th. So I want to just give a shout out for the good work they do. Thank you. That's all I have. Okay. Anyone else? I think finance. Okay. Mr. Rutzke. Good evening, everybody. So at the Finance Committee meeting, we first had an audit update. Mr. Gorski provided an audit update informing the committee that the state of New Jersey has finally released their post-retirement health benefit liabilities, as well as teachers' pension and annuity fund pension liabilities, which last year were delayed and caused us some extra work. So this year, everything's on time. Some district-specific information should be released

040to auditors within a week. Although these liabilities will likely never be realized by the district, they are required disclosure in the financial statements. The auditor is materially finished with the audit, with the exception of drafting the reports, completing the audit of fixed assets, completing testing for FalconCare and ECE funds, auditing the cafeteria fund, and subsequent event testing. We expect Mr. Stankiewicz to present the results of the audit to the Finance Committee at our next meeting and then to the full board on December 18th. We then went on to a budget update and where that stands is the budget defense rounds have been scheduled and actually began this past Monday. Principles were directed to prepare budgets in accordance with the board's budget philosophy directives. Mr. Gorski and Dr. Alvick completed and submitted the required budget efficiency

041worksheets, and Mr. Gorski and Ms. Tagliaferro are drafting the budget timeline, which will also be presented at the December 18th board meeting. It is state reporting season, so there's a lot going on with our BA's office with regards to... getting all these prepared or waiting for these reports to come in so I'm gonna throw a bunch of acronyms out there so there's the ASSA application for state school aid There's the DRTRS, which is the District Report of Transported Resident Students. There's the Debt Service Report, and all IDEA and ESEA final reports from year-end June 30, 2019, have been submitted as required. Thank you, Michael. Nice job. Thank you. Anyone else? Mr. Masters. Thank you. We had an ad hoc meeting on the... on November 13th last week thank you for everyone for coming out it

042was a very cold night we've taken the feedback distributed to the team many pages of feedback distributed to the team Dr. Lehman is going to aggregate it for us and present it to at our next earlier before our next December 9th meeting that is the next ad hoc meeting if you want to come back come out December 9th we're going to be reviewing the feedback thank you any other reports May I ask Mrs. Lang something on the use of school facilities, the regulation 7510? When you're ready. I don't know if I have it here. Okay. Well, it talks about, if I may, it talks about The use must not involve gambling or games of chance. For purposes of this regulation, the terms gambling and games of chance shall not include the following. And there's a

043list of that. So it seems to me that we're not supposed to have gambling in the schools, and yet there are games of chance, 50-50 raffles. How do we distinguish between what's actually gambling and what's not? Is there a legal? List of things that would be considered like if someone wanted to have a casino answer that good Yes, because they they were actually the regulation is set by the district by the administration and it was a meeting that was held with with mr Goodall and the heads of the PTOs PTAs and they came up with a list and our board attorney Mary Smith was also there and there was a long discussion about what Constitutes gambling and what constitutes game of chance and that list that you see there was what the administration said that

044they were comfortable with allowing as games of chance and they are legal according to the advice given by our board attorney so that's the regulation which is the responsibility of the administration okay and so something like a casino night would be deemed actual gambling yes and would not be allowed yes okay so if um if an organization a parent organization comes up with something that is not really on the list can they come to the board and ask us to consider it and then we would present it to the policy it would go to the superintendent of schools it's at the discretion of the superintendent of schools that's what the regulation and policy so would that be the the chain of command it would go to those people should they go to their building supervisor

045first or just directly to the superintendent they would go right to the superintendent bring their there's a process for anyone who utilizes our buildings right and they through that process that's how that I would be notified it would be included in their request for use of building well I would think that if someone before they even wanted to do a lot of times they do reach out to me directly okay and that that would be the procedure okay and then on the and I don't know I don't know if it's in school district security for a 7440 But I read it in the past, and I'm sorry I can't put my finger on it, where it talks about is it at the board's discretion to remove someone who they deem disruptive? to out of any

046event in the it's actually the discretion of the Board of Education at the administration which is an arm of the Board of Education working on behalf of the Board of Education so that's why on nine one six zero public attendance at school events which talks about that it says that now it's going to read that the Board of Education and or district administration may bar the attendance of any person at a school event whose conduct constitutes a disruption Okay, I would just say that I'm just and I think I've mentioned this before I think that language is too arbitrary and It would it could lead to abuse I'm not saying it will but I'm saying it concerns me that anybody in this in this community would be removed from an event I think it would

047have to be really egregious not to say I don't believe in security and everyone's You know has a right the whole community has a right to be secure from somebody, but somebody who's disruptive may just be someone who has an argument with another person or has a small disagreement. And I don't want to raise the level of a disagreement or a parent, you know, maybe screaming loudly at a... a sports event to be deemed disruptive because somebody else might not like it. I think we should be very judicious about how we use that sort of thing. So I'm concerned about the language being very vague and arbitrary. And I think from what when Mrs. Smith, when we met at the pre-policy meeting so that we could get the policies together, said that it actually needs

048to be more on the vague side because in different situations the administration is different so if you were to outline exactly where we as board members are and at events so we're not going to be doing it why it says the board of education if a complaint ever came and a board of education had to do a if there was a hearing in front of the board it would be the board's final decision but it's really district administration so it would have to be left up to a district administration from what i understood and implies the um the So secure and they it also covers security if security sees it as a risk if a parent Threatens another parent or a child that's disruptive and that person should be asked to leave and it should

049be that's the judgment of the administration That's there So we're going to be leaving the wording more vague because it needs to stay vague to keep it open To cover all the people that need to be covered well I would agree and you use the word threat and that would certainly be something that we would take very very seriously any type of threat and But I have seen people asked to leave or removed or sort of pushed off the, you know, pushed off a circumstance just for raising their voice. So I'm very concerned about the public, you know, free speech, even if it's loud. But certainly a threat, I would agree, you know, somebody should be removed. I just think we have to be really careful about that. Thanks. I would like to comment on

050it, Madam President. I think the people who are being trained and certified in security, such as Pete Pirro and his group, can certainly make the decision what they deem as disruptive. I agree with... Patty's assessment that probably the language has to be a little vague just to make sure because not the same condition can apply to everybody in general, but that's very typical in any law enforcement that the security that they have the yes that they're looking at it, but it went through the board attorney and went through the superintendent. I don't know. Did it go through their security people? Yes. So everybody had their hand in that policy to make sure that it was done. the way it should be done. I also think that it needs to be vague because a situation between

051two adults may seem not that big of a deal, but when you put that situation in front of children, it may be more damaging than you think. And I think the administration, who knows appropriate childhood development and what children can tolerate at certain ages, really use that to determine whether a situation could be harmful to children. Well, I also think physically removing a parent is also harmful to children too if they see that. But I think that the administration will know how to handle the situation and will take appropriate measures or not take appropriate measures as they deem fit. And you sometimes don't think about everything that could possibly happen, that might happen, and if it's not written down, then you can't handle it, but that's why we need to keep certain things vague so

052that you never know what situation could arise. Mr. If I may, since we're staying on policy and we're back to policy, I just wanted to ask on the vaping policy, the second part of it where you talked about other people's use of vape. products is that with regards to teachers during the course of a regular day or is that at sporting events or that it actually applies to anybody on school grounds so it could be the FedEx person who is on school grounds it could be a parent at a sporting event that is on school it could be a teacher it applies to anybody on school grounds excellent great thank you mr. Raibeck Miss Lange, I have a question. You mentioned school grounds. It's a big topic. If we're having a sporting event and it's

053not on school grounds, it's another different school, I realize it's school grounds, would those policies still apply? I mean, I know when you had a school event. it's considered school grounds i just want to make sure that's clarified right and it is actually any other school district would have their own policy so it would include on that but our school grounds would be like the bench where our kids are sitting um you know the the areas that our students are in is their school grounds so it could be the school bus transporting them back and forth so you don't want you don't want your bus driver to start vaping or somebody i just wanted to clarify that Okay, are we finished with committee reports? Thank you. Okay, so then we will go to public forum

054Anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda, please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record We will limit you to the four minute time limit and when the timer goes off your turn is over and you can only come up once during a public forum So just I was I came to the today and looked at the enrollments Which is in the agenda here page three and you are projected from how many students we had in 2015 and what we have today and if you look at total school We have added only 404 students entire school district eight schools only 404 students in last five to six years five years. So now we are projecting Another 1,500 students in next six to seven years. So this is just

055a remark. Just take into consideration whether our projections, again, you know, I'm questioning about the projections, okay? And if you look at the high school in last five years, we added 295. I know that high school's capacity is 1,800. So we want to have high school to 2,800. So, this projection for middle school, we have surprisingly, these numbers are surprising to me that in last five years for middle school we added only 150. 1624, 1774 minus 1624. So, just look at these projections from the past and what we do is sometimes, I'm a scientist, from past you predict the future. Okay? So at the same time, you have to take into statistically all the... interactive things and look at the projections. I don't know how the things are coming up, but I challenge the number

056that 1,500 students will be added in next six years. And very nice, thank you very much for the good meeting we had on November 13th. Thank you, Lou. Good meeting, lot of good input from the public, and I hope you heard the public. If we want to pass the referendum next year, to look at that, what the public is saying, and take them into consideration. These are multi-million dollar projects, and these are going to impact our education for long term. education as well as operational costs, okay, in long term. So estimated, I'm saying estimated, not actual cost we want on the each project. It is good to have, Mr. Teg always has seen in the IDOC committee, the IDOC committee members ask Mr. Teg, what is the estimated cost? And he gives numbers, that's fine.

057We are not going to hold anyone responsible for that numbers. At least if the public wants, Basic school, you know, medium school or a very high level school. So at least we have a range of the costs so the public next year will decide, at least give them a chance so that where various options come, they have which options to look at, you know, depending on that. So pros and cons also will be great. Dr. Alvish gave us a brief. how it, what way, if you remove the ninth grade, what will happen, I think it will be great, a written analysis, good analysis will be done on that. We'll appreciate that because lot of people are saying. Don't move the ninth grade out because 95% of the schools in every state have ninth grade in

058the high school. So people are worried. So no doubt, what is the cost difference and all, if it comes out, it will be great. Okay, so thank you very much. So appreciate the ongoing adult committee meetings. Thank you. Anyone else from the public wishing to speak? Tamarack Road. Before I get into my comments, I would ask that all members of the board please try to keep your microphone closer to your mouth. Older people like myself can't hear what you're saying at all, and I'm sure your words of wisdom would be appreciated by all. Okay, my questions regard some of the policies that are being examined tonight. Policy 9160, which deals with public attendance at events. As a member of our senior citizens, I would suggest that the board consider allowing anyone 60 years or older

059to attend any school events without any admission charge. Your policy states that it can be free or reduced. But considering that all of our senior citizens are paying taxes to the school system, this would be a very small token. of appreciation if they decide to come to a concert, a play, a musical, or a sporting event. I'm sure they would appreciate it. I know I would. So please take that into consideration before you finalize that policy. My second comment regards the homework policy regulation 2330. I was somewhat troubled, and I think I was even troubled by this when I'd seen it in the past, but I decided to bring it up this time. Your policy requires that homework be evaluated. As a former teacher, I'm quite troubled by that. If I'm a high school teacher

060of mathematics, I could easily have, in the course of one day, I could easily have 75 students. Now, if I gave them... Homework and certainly homework would be given in something like mathematics science physics chemistry foreign languages Daily homework is almost necessary if those students are to master those subjects and if I as a teacher and required to evaluate That homework as this regulation requires I don't think I would be assigning homework, and I think therefore I would be doing a great disservice to my students. Homework is practice in many of those courses. It gives a student a chance to see if they understood. Now I do agree that that homework needs to be discussed the following day, but to be evaluated to me means it has to be collected, it has to be reviewed

061by the teacher, and then the regulation says it must be promptly done. Okay, I just feel that the wording of that regulation is somewhat misleading if because I see from the superintendent's head that that's not what they intend It also indicates that it should be timely Evaluated I looked at your other policies on testing And there's a plethora of policies in there when you do a search for for testing because teachers give tests from time to time I could not find any policy that dealt with the necessity of teachers having to return those tests in a timely fashion. That would also apply to compositions that students have to submit. I know I've heard from my grandchildren, four of them have either attended or are attending the Monroe School System. They have often complained about doing

062a composition and then two months later they still haven't gotten any feedback on that composition. I think that is a tragedy. I have also heard from my grandchildren that when they take a test, yes, they may get the grade, but they do not see that test, sometimes for weeks. And then when they do see it, they're not allowed to keep it. I do not think those practices are in the best interest of our students. Students need to see their mistakes. They need to be able to take it home and have time, not simply have a few minutes in class, give that test, the teacher gives the test out and then recollects it again. That is not good education. So I could not find any policy that deals with... the prompt returning of test results and

063I really decry those teachers who do not permit their students to keep their test. Thank you, Mr. Coy. If they're doing it because they simply want to use the test again, then they're being lazy. Thank you. Anyone else from the public wishing to speak to the agenda? Good evening. Just one before I ask a couple of questions, I just want to mention about this Seva Diwali drive that took place over the last few weeks, organized by the non-profits and many members of the community. It was a very successful drive where we were collecting food and other items for the Monroe Pantry. We had 100 plus students from our schools involved in that. and collected about 6,000 plus pounds of food that was donated to the pantry. I think it's about six months plus supply for

064them. So it was a great success, great engagement by the community, and importantly the students. So just want to make sure the BOE is aware of that. Second... The item is, again, thanks to Lou and others for organizing the presentation on November 13th. I guess the members of the public was happy to have the opportunity to give the feedback, but also you could hear some disappointment in what we saw, the progress, and particularly the information that was shared, particularly quantification from a financial perspective, what each of those options. are going to cost and the goal of the community is to partner with the BOE and the administration so that we can be expedient, make the right choices, and together work to have a successful referendum. So we're hoping that that feedback that was provided, people

065wrote down on the pages, that will be taken and then in partnership with the Board of Education, we can move pretty promptly on that and make sure the concerns are quickly evaluated. Concern also we heard is not sure if March even by March the referendum is going to be ready or whatever the action steps Again, you know, we are losing a lot of time And let's move fast The other piece also I think that was missing, and I'm sure it's all in all your minds, is what we're going to do over the next year, right? We talked about four trailers being added next year to the high school, Oak Tree Library being modified so that two classrooms can be made. So there are a lot of things, expenses, actions happening. Again, that's where if you

066can start thinking about modular expansion while we decide about the referendum and so on, maybe we can even move certain things so for the high school we can maybe do a modular expansion. accommodate, I don't know, 10 classrooms, 20 classrooms by the next summer. So let's think about it, right? Let's think about cost avoidance so that we avoid investing in trailers and it's an expense that hits the operating budget and there's no return on that. So I think let's think about that. What do we need to do for the next year to these longer term objectives with its 1,500 or 400 unhoused students? you know, just as member of the public, just asking for a sense of urgency and let's work together to quickly address this, right, and make sure our school system flourishes and

067our ranks continue to go up. And again, let's keep a very strong dialogue with the public. Our goal is to make sure that we can partner and take the right decisions. But again, information is key and that feedback loop is key. So strongly request for that. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else from the public? Okay, seeing no one, we will close the public forum and we will go to the assistant superintendent's report. Dr. Lehman? So last month I spoke about our partnership with Middlesex County College. So I'm going to expand a little bit on a partnership that hopefully we can develop in the coming year. As we know, our curriculum documents are living documents. We have the ability to revise them, tweak them, to address the needs of our learners. as a result of educational

068topics, strengthen them by increasing their inclusiveness, and broaden their diversity. I recently had the honor of attending a presentation by Dr. Felicia McGinty. She's the Executive Vice Chancellor for Administration and Planning at Rutgers University. She and her team presented to the Middlesex County Curriculum Council on Paul Robeson. Paul Robeson was born in Princeton, New Jersey in the late 1800s. He attended Rutgers University. He was an activist, a scholar-athlete, a writer, an actor, and a larger-than-life figure. Rutgers is celebrating the 100th anniversary of his graduation. So he graduated in 1919. They opened a plaza this year honoring him and his contributions as well as other events took place and they're planned throughout the rest of this year. I bring up this as Rutgers has extended their resources and opportunities to the districts in the county. Whether

069it's to develop curricular resources supporting our work in diversity and inclusivism or visit to campus for our students to meet with staff there to learn about not just Paul Robeson but his influence and contributions during his life. Bottom line is Rutgers has offered support. I'll work with Miss Cass, Miss Cassoletto, though she's retiring and whoever her replacement is and we'll reach out and we'll kind of garner that and kind of embrace that partnership they've offered. If we can get students to participate in some of the activism days they have up there, Voorhees Mall, which is their outside courtyard, they have regular events there and if we can get some students, appropriately aged students, that would make sense to bring them up there and be a part of that process we'd love to have them come

070to the district but we're going to definitely leverage that opportunity and this meeting was on thursday and we'll get the wheels rolling and kind of move forward with that so thank you are there any questions for dr layman okay seeing none we will go to the superintendent's report dr alva Okay, so this week we are celebrating American Education Week in all of our schools. So every school has different activities happening each day of the week. Parents have been invited into all of our schools. I know that some of the parents have been involved in some makerspace activities in the schools. They've been observing classrooms. Lots of fun activities happening to celebrate all of our schools this week. On Monday evening, this past Monday, we held our second whole child parent evening. We had over 100

071parents attend and we've been receiving great feedback. Our keynote speaker this year was Miss Irene Barada. She's one of our district psychologists and she talked to parents about how they can support their children at home with regard to social emotional learning. Parents were then able to choose three out of 14 workshops that they could attend on some of the topics were mental health and adolescence, benefits of mindfulness and meditation, explain through science, movement, building resiliency, content curriculum and concerns, mindfulness fundamentals, study habits, and mental health and adolescence. We actually sent out a survey to all of the parents who had signed up to come to ask them for feedback. And so far we're getting a lot of positive feedback. Many of the parents are saying it was great, they wanted to attend all the sessions.

072They didn't want to just limit it to the three that they, based on time, that they could attend. This morning I was invited to visit our middle school civics class. Some of our middle school civics students you've been seeing at some of our committee meetings and some of our board meetings, some of the township meetings, they have an ongoing project where they're attending and learning more about the local government. So that's why we've been seeing a lot of students in our meetings. But some of them attended last week's ad hoc committee meeting. So they asked me to come and talk to them this morning and share how did the ad hoc get started. So I was able to share with them what the ad hoc has been doing. And I kind of shared with them

073even the history of some of the ad hoc committees that we've had in the past on this topic. They ask some great questions and want to know how to get more involved. So I told them I would keep them in the loop on upcoming meetings, how they can attend the ad hoc meeting, but they can't speak at an ad hoc meeting. But I told them that I would keep them up to date on that. In working with New Jersey School Boards Association, we have begun the process for the strategic action planning. Remember, that's one of our district goals for this year. I will be sending out information about three community outreach evenings that will be starting in January. We invite any community member to attend one or all of the evenings, whatever you have available.

074The current dates are, and I will post this on the website, and I will send out many, many, many. Flyers about this to invite you to come January 14th February 24th and March 23rd. We also have snow dates planned which I will also post on the website but it will be sent out because we really want as many people as possible to join us to be part of the planning for our Districts future with regards to everything we're doing here As was mentioned already, the Siwa Diwali held their concluding activity on November 9th, and they invited me to attend. And it was a wonderful, wonderful ceremony where over 100 of our students in our schools shared their experience that they... we're going to give back to the community. So as part of their Diwali celebration,

075they went around and collected food from our community and donated, as was mentioned, over 6,000 pounds of food to our food bank. Our food bank said that that's enough for six months. to feed our community for six months, which is wonderful. So I was invited to attend. I was invited to thank the students, and I got to hand out certificates. Many of the students talked about their experience and what it meant to them and how it's made a difference in their life and they want to continue to do this. This was actually the second year they've done this, and they're planning to continue it. So it was wonderful to be there. I also want, going back, going to our agenda, I want to commend our Pupil Personnel Services Department because if we look at our

076number of out-of-district placement students, it's a very low number compared to our number of students that we have in the district and the fact that we continue to grow. And it really is because of the programs that our high school students talked about today and our programs that are in all of our schools to support our students with special needs. at all of our schools. So we try to keep our students at home in our home schools where they're with their community members in their schools rather than send them out as much as we can. Also on our agenda this evening, you'll see under personnel, there will be two administrative recommendations, one for our high school principal position and one for the Woodland Mill Lake Elementary assistant principal position. So with that, it's recommended that

077the board approve attached personnel items A through AS. Mr. Polari and second by Mr. Tapano. Any comments or questions for Dr. Alnick? Ms. Arminio? I just have a comment. I know in the past, and I don't know if you can hear me, Mr. Poi? Got me? Okay. I know we have talked about being concerned about some of our resignations, and we don't want good people to leave our community. So I just want to point out that sometimes when you're reading through the resignations, take a look. farther into the agenda because sometimes people resign from one position and then they just take another position within the in the school district so we're really not losing them to another district what they're doing is either moving up or being transferred into another position so sometimes it may

078seem somebody is resigning but it's only a position and um there's we are we are keeping them they're staying within our home district So I just wanted to point that out. Okay, thank you. Any other comments or questions? Okay, seeing none, we will have a roll call. Mr. Tufano? Yes. Mr. Rudsky? Yes. Mrs. Lange? Yes. Mr. Pellori? Yes. Mr. Ryback? Yes. Mrs. Siegel? Yes. Mrs. DeMeo? Yes. Mr. Master? Yes. Mrs. Arminio? Yes for everything abstain on A-O and A-P. So noted. Thank you. Mrs. Cole-Ponowitz? Yes. Madam Board President, personnel action items A through AS as passed. Thank you. So I would just like to congratulate Dr. Kevin Higgins, our new principal at the high school. And I would also like to congratulate Mr. Billy Jackito, who is the new assistant principal at Mill Lake and

079Wilmington. And on behalf of the board, I'd also like to extend our congratulations to both of you. I know you will be a welcome addition at the high school and at the elementary school, yes. And I also would like to thank Mr. Maggiperla for stepping up and taking care of the high school for the past year and a half. There has not been a misstep there at all and I we appreciate everything that you have done to keep us going and and Everything that you've done. So thank you and madam board president. I'd like to Recommend that items a through P board actions items a through P be approved Second. Mr. Ryback, Mr. Masters, comments or questions for Dr. Albeck? Mr. Polari? Madam President, a couple of items. In light of the testimony that was

080given by Mr. Doug Poi, the item number F, does it relate to the homework that he was referring to? Yes, but the change in this homework regulation, so to answer... Mr. Poi's comment from earlier we do not require teachers and this this regulation was actually written by teachers so the regulation is written by teachers we had a homework committee that met for several months we had teachers from all levels on the committee and administrators we also sent surveys out to parents to get information before we wrote the the the policy and the regulation for homework the Teachers are not required to grade every assignment. They are required to review it. So whether they review it as a class when the students come into the classroom, but they are not required to grade every assignment. So

081that kind of answers his question. The reason that this regulation is on the agenda was because the middle school teachers went to their building administration and said the language in their section about the homework breaks. was confusing and they wanted to correct it. So that's the reason that it's up for reaffirmation. The wording of the homework said under homework breaks, any long-term assignment due after the breaks shall either be assigned three periods prior to the break and be due a minute, it should have been either or or and, they chose and. So that that was the reason it's up for affirmation. It was just a a typo really Thank you item L The name itself is concerning roadkill enterprise Being a safety buff in transportation, I don't know what Roadkill Enterprise Incorporated represents and would

082like to learn a little bit more before I vote on it. It's actually an author. I think you had more to say, Dr. Lehman. I wasn't the only one to question that. Yeah. So the middle school is hosting an author visit, and this is the name of the company of the author. It's his LLC or his enterprise or something like that. So I asked for the date. So I will be attending and I will ask him, there must be a story behind naming your company Roadkill Enterprises, so we'll figure it out. But it's really the name on the check when we write the check to FAM. Understood. Thank you. Mr. Ryback? I'm not sure. I'd like to. Based on what Mr. Poy said, which I thought was an excellent suggestion, amend policy 9160 to allow

083citizens, seniors, citizens age 60 and above to attend all public attendance and school events for no cost. Does that have to go back to policy, or could we do that right here? I think it has to go back to policy. I think we need to send that back to the policy committee but I think I second if you want if you need I think we have to make a motion to remove that policy I'll make a motion to move policy 9160 back to policy committee for consideration to allow citizens ages 60 and above free admittance to school events I'll second it Okay, is there any comments or questions? Yeah, the question is do we need two hearings on this too before it becomes? I believe if it's a new policy, we would have to have

084two hearings. So what's the timeframe we're looking at? January. Yeah, it would approve in January. Fair enough. Just a clarification. Are you going to be 60? Yeah. Just currently how it's worded, it does say without charge on a free or reduced. So are we hung up on the or? we could just right now say everybody over 60 is free and we ignore the or reduced and not have to go back to policy there's a big or statement in there an or a word residents of the district 60 years or age of older shall be admitted without charge to all school events on a free or reduced basis it does need to go back to the policy committee though nice try Lola better be safe than sorry I watched the wrong order too I know Okay,

085so we do we need a roll call or can we just take a voice? Okay, okay No, wait one second because I just looked at my notes We had taken out the reduced basis But it didn't get taken out on the final copy that we're voting on so if that's why it reads age older shall be admitted without charge to all school events and that free and reduced basis was taken out because when you say that Older shall be admitted without charge. I have that copy with me. That's what I have. so that's what that's the one that we're supposed to be it says residents of the district 60 years of age of older shall be admitted without charge to all school events and then we had taken out the other words after that I

086don't have those so what we'll go back to the policy committee anyway just to make sure and and and then if it doesn't need to be changed if it's just that we'll be able to do a second read in December Do we need a vote on that motion? Yes, yes. So can I ask how that happens? Because I know it frequently happens that something is agreed to in policy as a change, and then when it comes to us, I mean, and I believe that that happened and they agreed on it, but I think we have to be a little clearer because if it's showing up in the public, we can't say, oh, yeah, we meant something else. So it really has to be when you do a policy change, it really has to be. Right,

087and that's why the chair of the policy committee who should be reviewing these when it's on the agenda because you or somebody else who's not on the policy committee won't know that there's a change. Right. It's a lot. I mean. Having said that and I agree with you there's a lot of policies this year that have been gone through I I can't imagine the volume of reading that has to go on but when the Decisions are made at the committee meeting. They should be highlighted and it should definitely be caught so Okay, so we're just we're just going to vote on removing that from the agenda at this point Then we'll vote on the board action items Okay So it's a to remove Right now mrs. DeMaio. Yes. Mrs. Siegel. Yes. Mr. Tufano. Yes. Mr.

088Rudsky. Yes. This is our mini. Oh, yes. Mr. Ryback. Yes. Mr. Poluri. Yes. Mrs. Lang. Yes. Mr. Masters. Yes. And mrs. Cole yes President policy 91 60 has been rescinded and will be sent back to policy. So are there any more questions on the board action items? Okay seeing none we will have a roll call on all the board action items minus policy 9160 Mr. Master. Yes. Mr. Flurry. Yes. Mr. Tofano. Yes. Mr. Rutzke. Yes. Mr. Ryback. Yes. Mrs. Lang. Yes. Mrs. Arminio. Yes. Mrs. Siegel. Yes. And Mrs. Kolfman. Yes. For an action item, A through P has passed. Okay. That concludes my report. Okay. Then we will go to the business administrator's report. Mr. Gorski. Thank you. As previously discussed, we're going to give a little update on the budget process at every business

089administrator's report. And it was noted in the committee reports that the defense rounds with the principals and directors have been scheduled and commenced. I want to commend Dr. Alvik and Dr. Lehman for pre-meeting with a lot of the elementary schools, lower and upper, because the products that were delivered to the business office required, central office I should say, required very few revisions and were in line with the board philosophy directive and board and district goals. They were very well done. Some required revisions. We expect those in the next couple days. and all of the budget efficiency worksheets have been sent to the county office. We're waiting for the county office to confirm our appointment date where Dr. Alvik and I and Mrs. Allen will visit the county office to present our budget efficiency worksheets, which

090extract a lot of information from the Taxpayer Guide to Educational Spending and compare it with districts in our category, which is K-12. over 3,500 students. Anybody from the public who is unfamiliar with the Taxpayer Guide Educational Spending, I know this was a favorite of Mr. Poi years ago, it is a resource from the state of New Jersey that provides metrics on like-kind districts and provides a plethora of financial information on school districts. Information such as spending per pupil, administrative cost per pupil, Transportation efficiency for the routes, all of that can be determined from the taxpayer guide to educational spending. We're very proud of the results and encourage everybody to take a look at it. It's a great resource. We have not decided on any cuts yet as we don't know the first blush picture of

091what the budget's gonna look like yet. But we will provide an update on that soon. The state reports that were mentioned before, the ASSA application for state school aid and DRTRS report of transported resident students, both have a lot to do with the budget. ASSA used to be used to determine how much state aid a district gets depending on how many students are counted in the enrollment report on October 15th, how many special ed students are classified within that population. The state got away from that model, but it seems like they're heading back towards it now. So these reports are audited 100% and we're proud of the accuracy. DRTRS also goes directly to state funding because a district efficiency rating is calculated from the DRTRS and Monroe has the most efficiently run transportation fleet in

092the county and among the highest in the state of New Jersey and that makes us eligible for the maximum transportation aid award which we receive every year. So that's a little bit of information about the budget. And now I'll get to my report. There is a noteworthy item on my report. I believe it's letter I. And for full disclosure, this is the property that was discussed known as the golf driving range on Applegarth Road. This has been a three-year process that the board has been engaged in. They passed a resolution to go through some... Work with the Department of Education, Division of Facilities, Land Acquisition Requirements. I attest that all of those requirements have been met. This property is suitable to be resolved to be accepted by the Board of Education and indeed transferred this

093evening. Mr. Masters and the Ad Hoc Committee are working hard to determine the what part of this next project. This property is an integral part of the design of accommodating 3,000 unhoused students in the next five years in determining the where. And I want to point that out to the public and to the board. This is a monumental night for the district with this item being voted on. So, Madam Board President and members of the Monterey Township Board of Education, it is recommended that Board Action Items A through J be approved by consent roll call. So moved. Mr. Ryback? Second. Second by Mr. Mayo. Any comments or questions for Mr. Gorski? Madam President, on the item I that we just discussed, a couple of quick questions. Has the Board reviewed the contract of the settlement

094of the property? Just to make sure that we're not putting... Taken on any liability with with the property that's number one and also do we have an idea in terms of the net revenues? in term because I'm assuming that the current tenant is paying some sort of Fee for occupying the property right now So he's not going to be gaining to the board district or is it a loss to the board district? I'm not looking for exact numbers just a overview Good question. The board attorney, Mary Smith, has been an integral part of this process, and all of the liabilities associated with this property have been reviewed. There are none that are being inherited by the Board of Education. That's part of all of these land acquisition requirements and checklists that has to be presented

095to the Department of Education and review all that. We had a title search performed. We have a clean title on the property to be transferred. Then the next part has to do with revenues. The Board of Education is not going to receive any revenues directly from this property, but the agreement with the township and the lessors of the golf driving range assures that the real estate taxes on the property, which if I recall correctly are about $30,000 a year, will continue to be paid until the operations are suspended when the Board of Education needs them. to begin construction of the school. So the township is benefiting with the payment and the continuance of the real estate taxes. Who's paying that $30,000? The owners of the golf driving range to the township of Monroe. Ms. Arminio?

096Yes, I understood that the lease, when we first started this discussion, that the lease for the people leasing the driving range would be over in 2019. Has that been renewed? indefinitely or is there a end date on that it has not been renewed the Board of Education has a right to cancel the lease it is in its final year I don't remember the exact month that it concludes but it's in its final year of operations this lessors have indicated that and again the Board of Education as soon as we're ready to begin work on the property that will request that the operation cease. There's details about that in the agreement. So I understood, and if my memory doesn't fail me, that it was until 2019, which will be over in a month. So my question

097is, are they going to continue either without a lease or it doesn't really impact us? Will they still be there until we need the... And the reason for that is for two reasons. One, I don't want to kick somebody out if they still have a viable business and we're not ready to take on the property. And two, to maintain the tax revenue for the, it's not going to benefit the district, but it will benefit us as a community. So my thought is, are they still? Is that still viable business after the 2019? I believe it is. It will continue for a short period. That lease and that agreement is between the lessor of the golf driving range on the township. But the Board of Ed has a right to have it once we need it.

098So in the meantime, they're paying taxes, as I mentioned. But the Board of Education cannot run a business. That is correct. So once it's our property, we cannot run the golf driving range business. And I believe that lease is over by the end of the year. Right. There is a big sign on their property thanking everybody for being part of their, you know. their business for the last few years and that they will no longer be in business. Okay. And some other questions about taking the property from the township. Was there an environmental impact statement? Are we getting – so that's one question that did the township do. And are we getting all of the documents that the township – researched and everything, all of the documents for this property when they turn it over

099to us, like the appraisals, title, all of the documents that might have been. Because I know that, and again, the biggest one for me is the environmental impact statement. that we usually get when we take property yes the answer is yes on both of those environmental impact statement and all of the paperwork and titles and permanent documents will come to the Board of Ed there is a new requirement that golf courses have to go through an additional environmental testing although this isn't a golf course right it's a golf driving range we mr. takes still recommended to the committee and the board that we go through and have these tests done which we are done so that's sort of my point what I am grateful for the township for transferring this to us at minimal cost

100but now are we inheriting all the cost to do our own tests Because then we're going to start incurring costs that that really doesn't make it a one dollar transfer For the record it's not a one dollar transfer the Board of Education can't purchase land even at a dollar That was one of the original terms that was modified. So how are we? It's free and clear coming to the Board of Ed no payment And what was your other comment? My other question is, are we going to now, do we have to do testing once we get this property that's going to start incurring costs to the district? The majority of the testing is done. There's still some requirements that will have to be submitted to the Department of Education once the project is defined and

101it moves forward. So my thought is, do we have an estimate of what this is going to cost, our testing? Not at this point, but there's not a lot of testing. Madam President, if I may interject. Can I ask a question? Typically when a government entity purchases a property, it's on the property owner to conduct and finish all the environmental studies associated with it. I believe that's the law in the state of New Jersey. So I don't think there should be anything that the Board of Education should be responsible for. Well, what I think it says in appraisals, when an appraiser does it to determine the value under eminent domain, the appraiser makes it very, very clear that they are not appraising the property with any environmental or hazardous concerns. And there is a clause

102in there that says if it becomes environmental or hazardous, that it is the responsibility of the seller. But then my question is, is the seller the landowner? or the township or us, like there will be two removed. By the time we accept this property, it'll be two removed from the original owner. So yes, I agree that it is the seller's responsibility, but which seller are we talking about? And if we begin to incur certain unanticipated costs, again, it's coming out. If it comes out of the township, it's still coming out of our pocket as taxpayers, but it should not come out of instructional. education instructional funds that's really my concern understood the Board of Education has already conducted our tests submitted them to the DOE and all are satisfied okay and they'll be available to

103the public as well yes okay thank you Mr. Mayo but don't we have to do those tests when we build a new school regardless of where it is That's a good point. So it's not those tests are required regardless of whether the land was obtained by eminent domain or purchased from someone else or given to us by someone else, right? That is correct. Okay. Mr. Tavano? So the taxes on that property you said were $30,000 a year. And right now the golf course is absorbing that cost. So once the golf course leaves, we're going to be on the hook for that $30,000. A year. It's a good observation, but the Board of Ed is exempt, so the taxes will be suspended once we transfer it to our ownership. So I have a different question on

104Letter I. Peter earlier mentioned the Monroe Commons, that we lease space in Monroe Commons. Is there any chance that we could use any of the existing buildings on the golf course property until we build on the property? To move the office out of Monroe Commons onto the driving range into any of those buildings. I don't believe that's been studied Just a thought I know we're always looking for space and I know there's some structures on the property. Yeah, just just an idea It's very small it's the office it's very small I don't think I thought there was a house also on the corner that's a different property I don't think that would work so it's the office of the driving we put a desk in there maybe I'll relocate there yeah and I'll telecommute into

105the meeting okay any other questions for Mr. Gorski seeing none we'll have a roll call Yes, mr. Ryback. Yes. Mrs. Arminio. Yes. Mrs. Lang. Yes. Mrs. Siegel. Yes. Mr. Masters. Yes. Mr. Rutski. Yes Mr. Poluri. Yes Mr. Tofano. Yes. Mrs. Kolopanowicz. Yes Madam board president board action items a through J has passed unanimously. Thank you that concludes my report Thank you, Mr. Gorski. I will go to the Board President's report. And I just want to talk a little bit about the Ad Hoc Committee and thank everyone who came out last week. There was a lot of good questions. There was a lot of good comments. There was a lot of good conversation. And I know there was a lot of concern about... the potential of moving the ninth grade out of the high school which

106has not been even given to the Board of Education yet as an option but I think no one on this Board of Education would do anything to compromise the education of any of our students. No administrator in this district would recommend a referendum to the board that would compromise the education of our students. And for anyone to say that or to believe that kind of boggles my mind. The goal of our district is to raise the bar for all of our students, not lower it. We want our students to get into the best colleges possible. We want all of our students to continue to have all the opportunities they currently enjoy, including clubs, sports, band, et cetera. Removing the ninth grade out of the high school would not affect the mandated classes that freshmen need

107to take. It could affect the selection of elective classes, but that has always been an issue. Currently, not all of our students, including freshmen, get all the elective courses they would like to take because they get filled up. This is not something new, but it goes back to the time when my kids were students at the high school. They also had to have a, when they were asked to select elective classes, they needed to rank them according to preference. A student might not always get into the first or even the second choice, but sometimes they have to go on to the third choice as some of these elective classes are very popular with many of the high school students. um this has gone on in the past it goes on currently and probably will continue

108in the future as there are only a certain amount of students that can be enrolled in elective classes the ad hoc committee was was tasked to come up with a plan for a referendum to put the unhoused students in an environment that the community could get behind. It was not tasked with costing out all the plans. To cost out every plan would cost a lot of money and if changes are made, you go back and you have to continue to do that over and over again. Our residents in the adult communities are telling us that they cannot support a referendum that will significantly raise their taxes. We heard that loud and clear at every referendum presentation. we we went to in the skinner communities we as a board have to balance the needs of our

109students with the needs of those who pay for the education of our students and at this point that's the taxpayers when the recommendations come back from the ad hoc committee they will need to go to the architects to come up with schematics be approved by the department of education and then cost it out before something can be recommended to the board of education in the form of a referendum so it's at that time when we get whatever recommendations that come from the ad hoc committee that the board will go and through the process that they need to go through in order to get the costs so that we can fairly recommend a referendum to the public that everyone in the public hopefully will support. And that is the board president's report. So at this time

110we'll go to other Board of Education business. Mr. Tufano? I'd like to, I believe that some congratulations are in order, so I'd like to mention a couple of things. First, I'd like to congratulate the Monroe Township High School freshman team. They are the first The first team to ever go undefeated in Monroe history. First freshman team to ever... Are you talking football? Yeah, I was going to say football. I'm sorry. They're the first football team, freshman football team to ever go undefeated in Monroe history. So that means we have a lot to look forward to in the next few years. I hope. I'd also like to congratulate the 102 students in this school district that are going to Disney to compete in the Nationals. These girls worked very hard this year. They won regionals, they

111won states, and now hopefully they'll come home with a national title as well. Much praise to their coaches who worked so hard to make them the best on and off the mat. Always teach them to be spectacular cheerleaders and spectacular human beings. Mary Lang, her daughter Kelly Lang, all their staff. I would like to personally thank them for all their hard work. They really are very special people that put that program together in the Rec Center. I would also like to thank and wish the best of luck to five students, five athletes that signed their National Letter of Intent this year. That would be Mason Grossman, Josh Estavillo, Brian Skirby, Sarah Kolpa, and Emma Bodmer. This is a wonderful thing. I'm very proud that they are part of our district and they're spectacular for colleges,

112yes, for sports teams and colleges, yeah. And that's all I got. Well, thank you for bringing all that. Thank you. Anyone else? Mr. Polari? Madam President, I just want to first of all wish everybody a happy Thanksgiving, especially my colleagues on the board for giving the time that they do and also the public for participating in the township, especially in the Board of Education. My hope is that sooner than later the ad hoc committee is going to come up with a matrix that shows exactly what the plan is going to be. when each of the elements of the plan needs to be implemented and come up with the cost and I'll be more than happy to assist if should that be needed but I think the time is of essence in terms of addressing some

113of the needs in our district the second point I want to make is last Friday there was a meeting at the College of New Jersey about the safety roadway safety with a lot of our seniors beginning to drive. The vision for 2020 is zero fatalities. Actually, the road fatalities, especially texting while driving, have seen a significant increase. So for the first time, I actually met two commissioners in one meeting. The commissioner, Diane Schicchetti, who is the commissioner of New Jersey Department of Transportation, was there, along with Dr. Replett. And he also talked about how he wants to bring it back to the schools to make sure that... folks are safe. So I thought it was prudent just to bring it up. Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Rutzke? Thank you. If I may just sort of

114shine a light on a Monroe student class of 2014, Mikey Nichols, and a teacher, Mr. Rooney, ran a New York City Marathon in under four hours. With a pulled hamstring. With a pulled hamstring? Yes. Wow. Yeah, I think that happened along the way. Mile 24. Wow. So they completed it under four hours. It was amazing. They raised almost $45,000 for the Reeve Foundation, which in itself raised over $400,000. So I just wanted to give a shout out to them. Yes, very good. Just to let both Mr. Tufano and Mr. Rutzke know, in December we're doing student and staff recognition, and we are inviting the freshman football team. We are inviting Mr. Rooney and Mikey Nichols. awesome thank you Mr. Mayo I just like to say congratulations to Dr. Higgins for being appointed principal of the

115middle school high school I think he's going to do a fabulous job and I'd like to congratulate Mr. Jackato for being appointed for assistant principal for Woodland and Mill Lake schools thank you Mrs. Siegel So I'm just going to ditto Jill with congratulations to Dr. Higgins and Mr. Jacuto. And I also want to thank the whole child committee. I did have an opportunity to go to the parent night on Monday, and it was wonderful. sessions for every age group of parents. And, you know, I was hesitant to go because I have a 12th grader and a high schooler, but the sessions that I went to were geared towards high school parents, and there were some great reference tools that we walked away with. There was one sheet that I think I shared with Dr. Alvik,

116the study habits, which should go to every student in the school district. And I know I left a copy for each of my kids for breakfast, and I had them read it because it was great information that they will use even in college and beyond. Thank you to them. Mr. Masters? Okay. Sorry. Again, I wanted to thank you also. I was at the whole child parent night. I wanted to thank you for the invite. And I wanted to point out two of the sessions. Again, the fostering the healthy study habits. I had a really good discussion about my high schooler, which, again, I wasn't going for high school level. I think that was Edgar Estevez. So I wanted to make sure. called them out and the transition from high school to post-secondary options had an

117excellent conversation with erica friedman especially about bringing into some iep uh discussion into which which was excellent she was very knowledgeable and i enjoyed it very much one more thing I also wanted to just shed some light on, we had, I guess, two of our band students that were invited to play in the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade. Caitlin Bizaki playing the flute and Dominic Diedzik playing the tenor sax. That's one of them. I know you're going to talk about it in December. I thought I would just jump on your thunder there. But yes, I think they deserve a lot of applause. appreciation for that and they're marching with what band it's the Macy's there's a general band that they put them all into they auditioned for and was it and were accepted so will they

118be wearing Monroe clothes so we would know them when we well we could watch them yes that's an honor we have some getting some really great accolades for our kids Mr. Breitbach I know we've been speaking about the importance and how much we want to bring our students to the community and our community to our students as much as possible I'm gonna ask Mr. Siegel to highlight some of this I know the middle school percussion group is going to Rossmoor in December high school would you would you yes speak to that because I think that's terrific Yeah, so under the direction of Mr. Snyder and I believe Mr. Griffin, the high school student, high school percussion ensemble, along with a couple of the middle school ensemble kids, are going to the Rossmoor to play at

119their holiday extravaganza, is what I believe it is, on I believe December 5th it is, Thursday night. So they had done this last year, and they were... The seniors loved it, enjoyed it, so they wanted the kids to come back again this year. So the students are going back again to play for them. So it should be a great night. I'm looking forward to it. It should be really nice. And I know walking around the town this year and going to different events at Rossmoor, the seniors really did love it, and they're looking forward to it. So I'm looking forward to a nice night. Mr. Mayo? So I got an email. Dr. Alvick, we're having a presentation by a Dr. Michael Fallon. Coming up telling you asking when I don't know I'm from where from

120from From I think the career counseling. Okay. It was a series of events that they're presenting He had been here years ago and his presentation is fantastic So I would highly recommend any parents to come out and see him really good Counseling services at the high school. I think it's a lot of activity what you don't know or what I don't know Yeah, it really is a good. He really did a phenomenal presentation anyone else Saturday morning I believe there is a delegate assembly in Mercer Community College is anybody attending from the board I signed up just for okay any other comments about board business okay before we go to the public forum I just like to thank the board tonight for this really great conversation that we've had about everything and a lot about

121education and our students so there's a lot going on in our district there's a lot of good things happening a lot of great programs and it's because of what we all do here and i just like to thank you for the conversation because i think it was a really good wonderful conversation this evening So at this time, we'll open up the floor to the public again for public forum. Anyone from the public wishing to speak, please come to the microphone, state your name and address for the record, and we would adhere to all of our previous notes. Good evening, Christy Skirby, 21 Preakness Drive. I just wanted to give my comments about the Ad Hoc Committee. I did attend, and I was rather disappointed that a lot of questions that the public was raising, there

122were no answers to. And I think when you open up a meeting to say this is for the public to come in and you're asking our opinions on proposals, yet a lot of the information that we would need to make a decision is absent. It's very hard and disheartening to be a part of that. The biggest thing that we've heard through the referendums was, like you said, people don't want their taxes increasing. Well, to bring the public in and have absolutely no... financials associated with any proposals, it's putting the cart before the horse. How can I tell you how I feel on this proposal rather than that proposal without knowing how much it's going to cost? The cost is a big part of it. And the second part, there was an overwhelming concern from parents

123and community members there about taking the ninth grade out. And it was stated that there's been no work done to see what the impact would be. So to sit here and say, Madam President, your statement was almost very defensive to the public raising questions that night. We don't know what the impact would be. Clearly there would be some type of impact, and the parents and the residents should know what that is before we move forward with that. So, you know, you invite us out. and ask us our opinion and then you come back to a board meeting and you make a very defensive statement against the public that came. This whole process is very disappointing. Prakash Parup, 33 Dena Drive. First of all, I would like to thank, you know, my son is applying for

124many colleges. And the help, the counselors, the teachers, the administration, and the website. Important is the website, you know, is excellent, okay? And plus, again, I tell the public also, the parents should play an important role. review what you know it helps a it's like parents teachers and the student have goes hand in hand hand in hand and I think tomorrow there is some for the parents there is a you know here I'm publicly I'm telling the public parents should come especially those who are the ninth grade tenth grade because no one's what college requirements are there. This is very important because the students entering into the ninth grade, I request that take them at least to one university and show them when the others tell what is expectation, you know, the children understand more

125than the parents tell them, okay? So really congratulate and really appreciate and thank, you know, the staff and the teachers for that. Second thing is, again, President, I tell you, cost and metrics, please. The estimated cost for each proposal is very important. And I tell you, all our seniors here in the town, in the nine-gated community, they are not poor. They are rich. You know, and they should contribute for that is the America is we have to contribute for the education There are there are low-income seniors I know there are tax freezes for them who are earning gross income less than 85,000 whatever the taxes are frozen for them We have to educate them to apply for that and get their taxes freezes But there are lot of you know, people are moved in our

126town was seen here. We are millionaires So it is good, let them come and see. Let them come free to what is happening in the schools, so let them visit for different program. They will open up the wallets and donate the money to the school. Okay? So that is my request. So nothing else to say. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else from the public wishing to speak? Then at this time I will close public forum and we will go to the closed session resolution. be it resolved that the Board of Education of the Township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law, Chapter 231 of the Public Laws of 1975, NJSA 10-4-6 through 10-4-21 to discuss the following subjects. Personnel matter, I believe the level three grievance has

127been removed from the... harassment, intimidation, and bullying, attorney advice, feasibility study, litigation in pursuit of increased state aid. Following closed session, action may be taken. The discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists. I need a motion and a second. Second. So moved by Mr. Ryback and Mr. Tufano. could you just have the record reflect that I believe that we still have a personnel item on the list I think it could be more descriptive without giving any identification to anybody so I don't know if it's a district personnel if it's a Student personnel I mean I think I know that I will I will always have to bring this up Unfortunately that I think it could there could be a little

128bit more information as to what kind of personnel matter We're going to be discussing so noted All in favor opposed then at this time we will move into closed session. I Yeah, that's what I have an hour with the other ones. So 45 minutes At this time, the board will move back into public session, and I have a resolution to read. It is recommended that the Board of Education, one, approve the previously submitted separation agreement and general release between the Monroe Township Board of Education and bus driver Susan. Ms. Zelikowicz. Two, approve a medical leave of absence for Ms. Zelikowicz for the period from November 21st, 2019 to December 31st, 2019. And three, accept Ms. Zelikowicz's resignation effective at the close of business on December 31st, 2019. The board president, the business administrator, board secretary.

129board council are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement the aforesaid separation agreement and general release Mr. Ryback Mr. Tufano comments or questions Comments or questions if not roll call Mr. Korski Mrs. Lang Yes Mr. Masters Yes Mrs. DiMaio Yes Mrs. Arminio Yes Mrs. Siegel Yes Mr. Ryback Yes Mr. Rudsky Yes Mr. Pallori No Mr. Tofano Yes Mrs. Kolpanovich Yes Madam Board President motion passes Thank you Our next scheduled Board of Education meeting is December 18, 2019, 7 o'clock PM at the Monroe Township High School. Motion to adjourn. Hold on. No, no, no, wait. I'd like to say something. Okay, I'm sorry. I forgot to thank Mr. Todd Kerkis of the owner of Tailored Living for the donation of a closet to the Monroe Township Board of Education. That was very

130generous of him. Thank you so much. We appreciate the donation. Now I need a motion to adjourn. I'll make that motion. Mr. Rutstein? Seconded by Mr. Tappano. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Then the meeting is adjourned.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.