CorpusRecord 159631

Board of Education Meeting - December 12, 2022

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Syosset Central School District
Date
2025-01-23
Location
NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
23,615 words · about 132 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Hi everyone. Welcome to the Board of Education meeting. Can we all please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, individual with liberty and justice for all. Please be seated. I'd like to introduce Kristen Howell and the Adelettes and the Coral Pride are going to perform for us tonight. Our Syosset Coral Pride, Syosset High School's first tenor bass male a cappella group since its founding in 2002. We'll be starting the night off tonight with Jingle Bells featuring a quartet with its section leaders, myself, Alan Huang, Luca Alexandru, Blessin Wren, and Michael Zaptino. Please enjoy. Making spirits bright, what fun it is to ride and sing a sleighing song tonight. Jingle bells, jingle bells,

002jingle all the way. Oh, what fun it is to ride in a one-horse open sleigh. Oh, jingle bells, jingle bells, jingle all the way. It is to ride in a one-horse open sleigh. A day or two I'd take a... This selection is Shalom Aleichem, Peace Be Upon You. It is both a traditional Jewish greeting and the titem of a poem commonly sung at the beginning of the Friday Shabbat meal. The poem's four stanzas welcome angels into the home on the Sabbath, welcoming them in peace, asking for blessings of peace, and wishing them a peaceful departure when the Sabbath ends. Please enjoy. My name is Sephora Elish and I'm so proud to be a co-president of the Adolets with Sophia Daniel. The Adolets have been singing barbershop music since 1974. The group was created at HBT

003Junior High School. Over the years, White Christmas has become our official alumni song. Please feel free to sing along with us and from all of us to you, we wish you the happiest of holidays. Closing our performance tonight will be a solo from Michael Sabatino who will be going to Miami soon as a Young Arts finalist. He will be performing Gilby Back from Hamilton. Please enjoy. You say the price of my love's not a price that you're willing to pay. You cry in your tear which you hurl in the sea when you see me go by. Why so sad? Remember we made an arrangement when you went away Now you're making me mad Remember despite our estrangement I'm your man You'll be back, soon you'll see You'll remember you belong to me You'll be back

004Time will tell, you'll remember that I served you well. Oceans rise, empires fall, we have seen each other through it all. And when push comes to shove, I will send a fully armed battalion to remind you of my love. You say our love is draining and you can't go on You'll be the one complaining when I am gone And no, don't change the subject! Cause you're my favorite subject My sweet, submissive subject My loyal, royal subject Forever and ever And ever and ever and ever I'll be back Like before, I will fight the fight and win the war. For your love, for your praise, and I'll love you till my dying days. When you're gone, I'll go mad, so don't throw away this thing we had. Cause when push comes to shove, I will. Kill

005your friends and family to remind you of my love. Everybody! It's... It's not very often that we invite a soloist to come perform at a board meeting, but I wanted to give a little background. A few weeks ago, Kristen Howell called me at home in the evening, very excited. She said, I'm so sorry to interrupt, but I just have to share with you that Michael Sabatino was selected to be a YoungArts finalist. As a music educator, if you go an entire career and you have one YoungArts finalist, it's a big deal. So it's a really tremendous honor. I'm going to give you a little background on what YoungArts is because now a lot of people are familiar with it. Founded in 1981, YoungArts identifies exceptional young artists, amplifies their potential, and invests in their lifelong

006creative freedom. National Young Arts Week is an intensive program for competition finalists to collaborate with peers across 10 disciplines, develop their craft with internationally recognized leaders in their fields, and create lifelong connections. Artists participate in classes and interdisciplinary workshops with acclaimed artists and are eligible to be nominated as U.S. Presidential Scholars in the Arts, the winners of which perform at the White House. So during this week-long intensive in Miami, there'll be a lot of performances. It's really an incubator for really the most accomplished musicians that we have in the United States. To give you an idea, there are 150 finalists across all those 10 disciplines. There are eight classical vocalists that were selected as finalists, and Michael Sabatino is one of them. So congratulations to him. On behalf of the board, we just want to

007say thank you to Ms. Howell, as well as to the Adelettes and to Coral Pride this evening for this wonderful performance. I just want to say that I had the honor to see Michael at Cabaret Night a couple of weeks ago, and he was spectacular. So we're all very proud of Michael, and we wish him the best, and we can't wait to hear. how he does obviously but um thank you to them and we're just going to take a quick recess to get the board of ed on the stage but thank you hi everybody we're going to get started dr rogers Thank you Welcome everybody. I hope everyone's looking forward to having a wonderful holiday season and Happy New Year to all Before we move on with the report from the Southwoods middle school student

008council I just wanted to do two more recognitions in the room so Introducing choral pride and the Adelettes this evening and Michael Sabatino was mr. Alan Wang the president of choral pride who just came back from Indonesia where he was one of two people to represent the United States in the World Wushu Championships. So he came in fourth, fourth, sixth, and fourteenth in the four events he competed in in the world. So congratulations, Alan. And when I was speaking with him, he seemed a little disappointed. So it's in the world, Alan. So we also have a piece of unfinished business from last month. Natalie Sochi was going to be recognized along with the other National Merit... scholars but was unable to come to the board meeting because she was competing for Syosset on the varsity

009volleyball team which was in a playoff match and she scored three important points in on her serve in the third game so we needed you on the court but we have the opportunity to recognize you along with the students that we recognized last month so Natalie can you give us a wave And we do have a certificate for you, and we'll make sure that it finds its way to you. But we wanted to make sure that you got congratulated along with all the other students who are in that wonderful honor. So with that said, every month we have a report from one of our student government representatives. This month we have a report from the Southwoods student government. We have Kathleen Chang, Shane Ellis, and Sophie Wise. So, ladies? Good evening. Dr. Rogers. Good evening

010Dr. Rogers, Syosset Board of Education, Syosset administration, and members of the Syosset community. We are Shana Liss, Kathleen Chang, and Sophie West, representatives of the Southwoods Student Council. Tonight, the Student Council would like to tell you all about the student activities here at Southwoods. Students have been actively participating in a wide variety of clubs and activities that engage us, inspire us, and bring us together as a community. Here are some of the highlights so far. In PeerTalk, students are creating a series of virtual newsletters to be distributed to the school community with the goal of strengthening bonds and bringing social, cultural, wellness, and mental health awareness. Students are writing articles about lung and breast cancer awareness, Albanian independence and Spanish heritage month, as well as national kindness and smile day. Together, these budding journalists will

011bring information to their school community through this digital newsletter. In podcasting clubs, students are working on a movie slash podcast in which students are acting out a skit while reading lines as if it were a traditional podcast. Podcasters will begin working on more lengthy podcasts that will require them to write up scripts, rehearse their lines, and then record the scenes in the podcast. Coding Club is enjoying working in the Scratch app, creating block-based coding projects and games. Some more advanced coders are independently learning additional coding skills in CodeHS with syntax-based coding languages. In Debate or Model UN Club, each week the members are assigned to a subcommittee due to the size of the club. Each subcommittee is led by a membership of the Leadership Council. As a club, the students pick a topic and debate

012their own viewpoints. Then, they act as a delegate from a country, modeling the UN format. In Advisory Leaders Club, students are developing fun school-wide challenges and activities for advisory. Students are promoting positive connections and teamwork with peers across grade levels. The members work as facilitators for the daily and extended advisory activities. Survival Club members are learning about how to survive life-threatening animal encounters and dangerous forces in nature. The students are loving every bit of it. Students participating in the science fair this year have already begun the process of brainstorming ideas and planning their materials and procedures. They'll be presenting their findings to judges in two competitions in early spring. In robotics, students are working to learn the super-powered playing field. Jazz band members are learning and rehearsing several pieces and looking forward to perform later

013in the school year at concerts in the lobby and at the district jazz festival. Two members were selected to the All-Nassau County Jazz Band. Trivia Club holds friendly competitions every meeting. Students are organizing their first holiday party in addition to a fundraiser for Celebrity Policy Research in December. During club meetings, Southwoods Patriot Club members learned about Veterans Day and the three veterans, as well as one active service member, were here at Southwoods. In order to share this information with our Southwoods family, members created a bulletin board to honor our veterans, including agamographs depicting our American flag and saluting soldiers. An announcement was created, including a video summarizing the historical... Story behind Veterans Day and a thank you to our service members, Mr. Darren Annunziata, Mr. Roy Dears, Mr. Mike Simmons, and Mr. Jason Walner. Students

014in Board Games Club are engaged in teamwork, strategic thinking, decision making, problem solving, focus, and fun. Students are strengthening their existing relationships and meeting new friends. In Math Olympiad, students compete once a month in the country math elite. Competitions are differentiated based on skill level. On non-competition weeks, the students brainstorm and collaborate to solve practice problems. The Creative Writing Club members are in the process of building a website with links to all the stories, poems, and essays they have been writing all year. Many students participated in this year's PTSA Reflections Contest. Writing on the theme, Show Your Voice, as well. In book club, students have been engrossed in reading and discussing A Good Girl's Guide to Murder series by Holly Jackson before moving on to the Nile series by Lynn Mattson. Both series proved to

015be exciting, riveting stories for middle schoolers. The yearbook club is currently focused on taking pictures of various school clubs, activities, and community events. In addition, the club is preparing to launch the cover contest for this year's yearbook cover and will be visiting advisories with details in mid-December. Badman Club currently has 75 members, meeting every Thursday for some friendly but skilled competition. The Drama Club just finished their wonderful fall performance titled Just Another High School Play. Starting in December, auditions and rehearsals for the spring musical will be held. The students in Theater Technology assisted the drama club production of Just Another High School Play. Club members assisted with prop production, lighting, and curtains and set movement during the production. The students enjoyed making the props that were used in the play and are looking forward to

016participating in the spring musical production. In Math Fair, students selected the topic for their research paper for the 2023 Long Island Math Fair competition and are diligently researching, outlining, and introducing their topic. Students in the Pride Club have been working to create a mission statement for our club. We've discussed school-wide activities that we can do to bring awareness to the LGBTQIA community. The students continue to connect and support each other. The Wellness Club has been taking part in various activities that help promote overall health and well-being. Some of the activities that we have done or are currently taking part in include creating Zen gardens, student-led origami lessons, journaling for mental health, muscle relaxation activities, positive thought discussions, ways to relieve stress, mandalas for relaxation, as well as individual vision boards. As the year progresses, we'll

017be adding more activities and discussions to help students strengthen their overall health and well-being. Multicultural Club has had a busy start to the school year. Club members gave presentations on Diwali and Rosh Hashanah. Multicultural Club sponsored a school-wide initiative to express gratitude in as many languages as possible on a bulletin board and flip grid. Finally, students from the high school Decca Club gave a presentation focusing on raising awareness of environmental inequities in communities of diverse backgrounds. Art Club has had a busy fall season working on posters for school-wide activities as well as working on pieces for local art contests. The students have been working to promote school-wide spirit days with decorative posters as well as working on group collaborative collage pieces. In Monk Trial Club, students are preparing for their annual tournament where they will

018act out a court case as attorneys and witnesses. They will practice writing oral arguments, formulating questions, and public speaking around a fictional case involving robbery. In Peer Leaders, Southwood students collected over 800 non-perishable food items to be donated to Rock Can Roll. a foundation that collects and distributes food to local food pantries to help local families. Peer leaders created and brand workshops to educate their peers about food insecurity and ways that students can make a positive impact. In addition to the food collection, students raised close to $900 to donate to Rock and Roll. Working collaboratively with Student Council and Advisory, Southwood students continue to make a positive impact on their community. And as for us, in addition to supporting the charitable efforts and fundraisers of all student activities here at Southwoods, the Student Council is

019organizing the Biltleg Mason Toy Drive for the Oncology Unit at Cohen's Children's Hospital. New, unwrapped toys will be collected until December 16th. Thank you so much for this opportunity to share all the exciting activities at Southwoods Middle School. We are very proud of all the great ideas, effort, and enthusiasm that make us hashtag SIO strong. Have a wonderful rest of your evening and happy holidays. Thank you, Kathleen, Shana, and Sophie. And I'll just say, since I consider Southwoods to be my homeroom, I get to participate in the life of the building from time to time, and it's one of the most fun things I get to do in my job. So thank you for all those activities. You kept us breathless. Mr. Rotolo? Thank you. I just want to add on to Dr. Rogers. Thank

020you so much. You guys put in a lot of hard work. We're well prepared. I love the teamwork, and I love the leadership style. Thank you very much. Okay. There will be a public hearing regarding senior citizens and persons with disabilities and limited income tax exemptions. Dr. Ruffo, Associate Superintendent for Business, will review. After Dr. Ruffo's report, the public may comment. Audience to the public rules will follow. Dr. Ruffalo. Okay, thank you. We'll begin our hearing on proposed action concerning the exemption from real property tax for eligible senior citizens and persons with disabilities in the Syosset School District. New York State Real Property Tax Law Section 467 provides for a property tax exemption for senior citizens, and New York State Real Property Tax Law Section 459C provides a similar... real property tax exemption for persons

021with disabilities. Both of these property tax exemptions are subject to statutory annual income maximums. Prior to July 2022, the income maximums for each of these exemptions was $37,399. In July 2022, the New York State passed legislation and then Nassau County enacted Local Law 7-2022 and Local Law 8-2022, which increased the income maximum applicable to both statutes to $58,399. These statutes provide for a tax exemption. on a sliding scale depending on household income, less documented medical expenses and prescription drug expenses. The exemption provides assessment reductions depending on income between 5% and 50%. According to the new maximum income level, homeowners who earn up to $50,000 would have 50% of their assessed value exempt from taxation, where those homeowners earning between $57,500 and $58,399 would have 5% of their assessed valuation exempt from taxation. The Syosset School

022District had previously adopted both of these exemptions and has in the past several years adopted other updated income scales when they became available by the county. There are currently approximately 90 senior citizens households in the district that receive this exemption and about six households receive this exemption for people with disabilities. NASA County has advised school districts that resolutions must be passed by January 2, 2023, to be effective in the 23-24 school tax year. This statute does not preclude a district from adopting the increased income maximum in a subsequent school year for the corresponding tax year. The district does not have any role in determining the eligibility of individual applications as the application process and all of the documentation is handled at the county. The district's role is to decide whether or not to adopt the

023new income maximums consistent with RPTL 467, RPTL 459C, and local laws 72022 and 82022. Okay, if no one wants to speak, then we're going to close audience to the public. I apologize. Next order is approval of the minutes of the meeting, November 7th, 2022. May I have a motion, please? Lynn, seconded by Brian. Does anybody have any questions? All in favor? Opposed? Any abstentions? Next is the treasurer's report and appropriation adjustments. Dr. Ruffo? Okay, the Treasurer's Report shows that the cash on hand for the month end October 2022 was $85,777,976.39. It shows that all bank balances for cash accounts were reconciled to the book balances and collateralized in accordance with the district's banking agreements and investment policy. May I have a motion to please accept Dr. Ruffo's Treasurer's Report? Susan, Jack, anybody have any questions?

024All in favor? Opposed? Any abstentions? Dr. Rogers, can you please give us your superintendent's report? Sure. I'm going to do a brief presentation in a second, and while that's getting set up, I just wanted to report to the board on a couple of items that we have been following. First, I wanted to report to you that we are almost done with our annual visual inspection report. One thing that we are doing a little differently this year, we've asked our architecture firm, H2M, to provide us with estimates on what they think it will cost to repair the things that are identified in the annual visual inspection. As you know, the... district is required to do two types of inspections on schools. Every year we're required to do a visual inspection. We do that obviously with an

025architect or an engineer who goes and visualizes the structure. Every five years we're required to do something more extensive called a building condition survey. that is a little bit more in the ceilings and behind the walls. We think we'll have a pretty good handle on what the facility's needs are, both because we have the BCS from four years ago, but also updated through this annual visual inspection, and we'll have a sense for the board right after the first of the year of what we think the facility's needs might be. Second is the board asked me in... october if i would approach the county about the subject of stillwell park obviously the district was unsuccessful in an approach that we put to the public to try to improve the park and make it more useful for

026both residents and for the school district I was able to connect with the county and had what I would characterize as a very productive and cordial conversation with them. They are thinking about the park and thinking about its need for improvement. And they indicated that their time frame is also shortly after the first of the year. They want to start doing a little bit of engagement. first with the town and then subsequently with us to talk about their thoughts on how the park can be improved and who and how people can be partners in that process. So I'm anticipating more contact with them after we come back in the new year and I'll be pleased to report back to the board on that conversation when it happens. With that said, I want to also bring

027the board up to date on a longstanding project that the district has had dating back to before the the pandemic where we were working on a board goal of trying to have a later high school start time. The reason for... The board's interest in that was because there is a considerable body of research that suggests that students don't get enough sleep and one potential remedy for that problem would be to make it possible for students to stay in bed longer in the mornings. That would require high schools to start later. There are some states that have even required high schools to start later than a certain time of day. So this is not a fringe kind of effort. It is something that... districts across the country and some states are now considering. We have a

028particular challenge here in Syosset having two middle schools and that means that any transportation circumstance that tries to rely on the proximity of the high school to one middle school doesn't really work well because the other middle school is on the other side of town. We also have a challenge in that the length of day for the high school and middle school is longer than the length of day for elementary school. So if you try to move those together, what you find is that you'll have an overlap either with the dismissal time of day or with the arrival time of day. Having an overlap means that you would need twice as many buses. So there are very few solutions that find the sweet spot where the length of day is preserved. but you don't have

029any overlapping series of bus runs. And then lastly, one of the big challenges, certainly when you have conflicts, you can solve those conflicts by having more buses. There's a cost associated with that. But recently, the bigger challenge, even than the cost, is that there simply aren't drivers to drive those additional buses. This has been a challenging project, which is why even after four years of working on it, I don't have neat, sweet solutions that are without any pros and cons. Instead, what you have are a group of tradeoffs to look at and to weigh. So with that said, I'll sort of dive into the study. This is a subset of a much longer study that the consultant did for us. So one thing I just want to point out is that We asked the consultant

030to provide us with three alternatives. I think what you'll find quickly is that there really are only two alternatives to the existing bell schedule that I think are plausible. But they did put together some other things for us to consider in order to achieve what was required of them. I think it's also helpful to just go through some of the operational metrics. We have about 6,800 students who are enrolled in our buildings. We have another 300 or so students who are transported to non-public schools. In New York State, the school district is required to provide transportation to non-public schools. So that will be... We're providing Syosset residents with transportation to their out-of-district or in-district non-public schools. The county has a system where a lot of school districts collaborate together to try and find efficiencies. I

031don't know if this is a real route, but you might imagine, for example, a bus from Syosset that's on its way to Mineola to go to Chaminade might pick up a kid in Jericho on the way in order to try to achieve some efficiencies for the two districts. So there is a lot of collaboration between the school districts to try and find those kinds of efficiencies. but for lots of reasons they're few and far between. We are a universal busing district. The board, long before my arrival, made busing eligible for every student. And we've grown in enrollment since the last time Transpart was here doing a study with us. So leaving aside the non-public school routes, there are 119 routes that are for the public schools here in Syosset. and about 610 bus runs. So

032it gives you a sense of just how sprawling a transportation system this is. We have traditional two-from-school runs. There are some midday runs, say, to BOCES programs that are half-day programs. And then we run late buses after school, particularly secondary schools for students who are participating in clubs or athletics so that they can get home. We talk about busing in tiers. So the high school tiers run simultaneously. The middle school tiers run together. The elementary school tier runs together. So the consultant, in addition to trying to come up with new times for us, does analysis of the operational metrics of the system and does some efficiency analysis for us. Obviously, if you want to free up some buses, if there are efficiencies to be had, you might be able to free up buses to do

033something else. But what they observed was... very short turnaround times between the tiers. So particularly at dismissal, 20-minute turnaround time between the high school and middle school dismissal tier, 29-minute turnaround between the middle school and elementary school dismissal tier. And with an average run duration of 20 minutes, it means that if there's any kind of a glitch, then you'll have a cascading problem where a late bus on an earlier tier... will become a late bus in the next year and then a later still bus by the time it gets to the elementary routes seating capacity is not fully realized we route the buses for full as full of capacity as possible without having too long in terms of time run that means that we generally assign 40 students per bus typically we think of those

034buses being able to carry 50 or so We see elementary and high school averaging 45 per route, but middle school only 30 per route. And as I mentioned earlier, they observed as well the challenge we have of the different lengths of day making it very hard to do programmatic changes. So some of the ridership data, this is for the 21-22 school year, so this is last year data, but we looked at over the course of the year what percentage of the students who were routed to the bus were actually riding the bus. And as you can see, the ridership is higher at the elementary level than it is at the high school for every month of the year. So one of the things we did talk to the consultant about a lot was recognizing that

035since the buses are typically underridden, because obviously parents are bringing kids to school and dropping them off, is there a way to achieve some efficiencies by overriding the bus? The danger in that, of course, is if every kid who is eligible decides to ride on the same day, there just wouldn't be enough room for all of them. But it might also be a way to try and create some additional efficiencies. Because the secondary route and the elementary routes are different, it would be easier to achieve an efficiency by merging the two together. So one partially empty bus and one much more empty bus together might be able to consolidate better. But the downside of that, of course, is having students of very different age ranges riding the same bus. But the consultant raised it with

036us because it's something that other districts have done to try and achieve those efficiencies. So this is a little bit more detail about the planned ridership versus the actual ridership on buses. And you can see, again, at elementary school, more ridership. At the middle school and the high school, less ridership on the individual bus rides. So this comes to sort of the meat of the presentation here, and this is where I'll spend most of the time. At the top is the current scenario. This would be the pre-pandemic scenario. The high school dismissal time is actually a little earlier right now because we were experiencing congestion between the middle school dismissal and the high school dismissal with a lot of cars on the campus essentially too close to one another. So the state... gave all school

037districts a waiver dating back to the 2019-20 school year for the annual hour requirement because of COVID. So we aren't falling short in terms of the length of day, but we will have to alter that going into next year in order to have an adequate length of day for the state mandate. So the two scenarios that were developed, scenario one, scenario 1A, are essentially the same idea. It would have the middle schools go first instead of the high school going first. That allows the high school to start later in the day. The advantage of scenario one, and this is the consultant's preferred scenario if we were to make a change, is that there's more what they call work time between the tiers. So in the morning, there's 25 minutes rather than 20 between the middle

038school and high school tier, plenty of time between the high school and elementary tier. And on the dismissal side, again, 25 minutes, 29 minutes of work time. And their feeling is that you need closer to 30 minutes in order to avoid having on-time challenges with the bussing tiers because the buses just need to turn the runs around more quickly. Scenario 1A is essentially the same thing but with less work time. So the advantage is middle schools wouldn't start quite so early and elementary schools wouldn't end quite so late. That shortened time comes at the expense of the turnaround time between the tiers, and again, the lack of turnaround time could result in challenges with on-time performance and an experience of more buses that are late. We could, of course, take advantage of some of these

039routing... the fact that not as many students ride the bus as are routed to the bus. But you end up getting diminishing returns from that, the reason being the bus has to traverse a certain amount of just physical distance on the road. And even if you say, wow, only half the kids got on the bus that we expected, if you say to the bus driver, go twice as far and pick up more kids so that you're full, twice as far means twice as much. time on the road and so that means the first kid getting on the bus will have twice as long a bus ride as they would otherwise so even though we can think of ways to run the buses more densely what it will mean is that we'd have earlier pickup times

040in the mornings because those students would have to be on a longer bus ride before they eventually got to school so we concluded with the consultant that we probably didn't have many efficiencies to be able to be gained there without really needing a lot more work time and conceding that students would have to be on longer bus rides as i said they did develop other scenarios for our consideration This was a creative attempt to try and take advantage of the routing. I don't want to say inefficiencies, but just the fact that many students are driven to school and marry together high school runs and elementary school runs and middle school runs with elementary runs. Again, the shortcoming of this proposal is that the elementary day ends very early in the afternoon, probably would not be

041adequate for... parents who are anticipating the school to provide child care or alternatively it would mean the need for a very long after school program like scope to accommodate those child care needs and another challenge would be having young students ride on a bus with secondary students again school districts do this sometimes they have monitors on the bus for that reason but they wanted to propose this to us because it met the broad parameters that we gave to them and then Lastly, again, a scenario that I don't think is going to be workable, but again, very creative out-of-the-box idea, which was to have high school students and middle school students ride the bus together, dropping first at the high school and then dropping at Southwoods because both schools are on the same campus. And for

042students who would go to HPT, the bus would drop at the high school and then continue on to HPT, and 10 minutes later, drop middle school students at HPT. The challenge is we think that we could achieve a lot of efficiencies by routing the buses more densely, by combining these two tiers, and that would free up some buses, perhaps to allow us to have some somewhat shorter runs. So this would end up being a two-tier system, a secondary and then elementary, but it would require later end of day for the elementary schools than what we currently have now at 315. may back up against the after-school activities that kids have where they have piano lessons or religious instruction or child care responsibilities, et cetera. So these are the scenarios that the consultant was able to

043put together. I realize that I kind of breezed through four years of work very quickly here, but we really think that probably the only viable scenarios would be the one, and if you were brave enough to have the short turnaround time, 1A, but that would likely result in more on-time performance problems because the turnaround window is just so tight. And I'd be happy to address any board questions on the consultant's report. Hi, I know you said that after school programming like out of the districts, but there's also things that go on after. Are we accounting for the things that go on after school within the district? Like I think some middle schoolers are sometimes bused to the high school for different sports or scope or games or practices and against other people within our areas.

044And if that's all still viable, if we change things. Yeah, the after school activities would actually be fairly straightforward to maintain. The challenge that we have right now is more with the interscholastic athletics because prior to the pandemic, it was possible to identify a bus driver who would essentially be on their way to the high school to pick up athletes. while the elementary run was still ongoing now what's happening is we have to wait for the elementary run to be complete for that bus driver to then return to the high school for athletes and so that's why the games have been pushed back and this is not just a si asset problem all of my colleagues are experiencing the same thing but we do have late buses we would continue with those late buses for

045after-school activities just as we do now Real basic since a lot of what you've been saying doesn't sound very promising. Has there ever been thought into just pushing out the entire, all three schools, start time, whether it's 10 minutes and salvage what time we can? I mean, scenario one already ends at 3.30 for elementary. I mean, has that been an option? Yeah, it would probably be the simplest thing to do is just take our existing system and move it forward 15 minutes and really the impact of that would be It goes at the far end of our constraint to the consultant We said we didn't want to see an elementary dismissal later than 3 30, but it would bump right up against that 3 30 the gain would be 15 minutes on the front end

046for the high school you currently have a 739 start time for the high school, so you'd essentially go to 755, 754. Okay, thank you, Dr. Rogers. So this is not really a question in regards to the consultant's finding. It's more what we do in school. I don't know if it's already being done, but in terms of the curricular, have we given to thoughts, you know, teaching students about the healthy sleeping habits patterns, you know, in terms of to the health and also academic performance and also the consequence of lack of sleep? I mean, it's something that we can do alternatively to, I mean, not to replace the late start time, but it's something that we can do together concurrently with this. This way we can educate the kids about how important it is to sleep

047well and then get enough sleep. Yeah, I'm going to ask Dr. Curry. Oh, there you are. You're hiding behind the speaker. To talk a little bit about our health curriculum at the secondary level and where this fits into the health curriculum, please. Yes, both the health curriculum, the wellness curriculum, and the advisory programs on the secondary level, along with the health curriculum and the harmony program on the elementary curriculum level, address all of the above. The importance of well-rounded balance of sleep. The administration often also sends out notes to the home reminding parents, especially around exam time. as things get busier in the schools, the importance of a balanced diet and starting the day with a breakfast, and also focusing on limiting screen time. And the teachers and the departments also talk about monitoring the

048amounts of homework, as well as due dates and due times for submission of electronic assignments. We've also had ongoing conversations with student groups, with the student government and student representatives, tapping in. into their thoughts and ideas on how to balance things. And something that was shared quite recently from one of our students was that it tends to come in waves, that there are certain times of the year where it becomes more challenging to get a good night's sleep. that's typically around the time at the end of the semester and the end of the marking quarters, as well as for those students that participate in athletics, theater events, other competition events, that there are times where it becomes more challenging, and then they find that that ebbs and flows, and there's times where they do balance

049that out. But it is an ongoing conversation, both formally and informally as teachers, even in our content areas, are constantly reminding students the importance. of finding that balance and making sure they're attending to self-care, if you will. Thank you, Dr. Curry. I was wondering, I know there's some background on this, the requirement to provide a bus for every student in the district. I mean, I know most districts don't do that. And I remember or I recall something that there is a reason we are required to do that. When you look at some of our ridership percentages, it's just something that jumped out at me. So to change the... them they're called mileage limits so what districts do is they adopt a mileage limit and that would sound like everybody within a half mile has to

050walk and that's how a mileage limit is structured so there are a lot of districts that have done away with mileage limits because it becomes hard to say half a mile but not if you're crossing this busy road or that busy road for example so to change the mileage limits you have to do a vote of the public and so as a practical matter what the education community has experienced is that proposals to make mileage limits less generous tend not to be successful. Brian, you jumped on my question, but the follow-up to that though is from the point of view of just a theoretical exercise, if you lifted that constraint, for the consultants how many dimensions of the problem open up to a lot more solutions i'll take the first swing at this uh so

051dr ruffo can get collector thoughts um dr ruffo and mr escobar are responsible for busing so um i would say when we think about the the routes that are very close to school they represent a very short amount of run time on the bus so It's not like we would be peeling away a 40-minute route and then freeing up a bus for 40 minutes. What we may be doing is peeling off a very small route. I don't know how much time it frees up. But, again, one driver per route per tier, so there may be something to be gained from it. But, Dr. Ruffo, have you and Mr. Escobar talked about what a change in mileage limits might accomplish? Yeah, I think that certainly... The most obvious, yes, it would reduce ridership, but in order

052to make a determination of what the impact would be district-wide would require a complete rerouting of the district because, as you said, buses are routed in a way that focus on specific areas and then bringing them into school. So it's difficult without really a full rerouting of the system to determine how much that would provide. I'm going to put you on the spot unfairly. Sorry. Do you know if there are any intentionally short routes that just mop up a close neighborhood or are the nearby neighborhoods on the path back from a neighborhood that's farther away typically? I'm imagining the routes on Transpar, and they are more typically in a faraway. in an out region that then comes into the district. But I certainly have seen routes that, because of all different reasons, may swing into

053a neighborhood and pick up. But I would say that the overwhelming majority are in a specific area and then they come in. Right. So what I'm envisioning is more at the secondary level where we could recapture incremental drivers and buses from routes to potentially... expand in other words to allow for additional buses that might need to free up during that same time period I certainly understand the appeal of trying to free up some drivers particularly given what we've experienced with absenteeism and drivers whether we would whether we would achieve enough freed up drivers in order to make an appreciable difference in start time that I don't know because for the start time we have to move the whole tier right so even if we free up 15 of the drivers in that tier i don't

054know that that lets us move the tier in one direction or another one you mentioned that several states um mandated earlier I mean later start time do you see it happening in New York in the foreseeable future do we have a timeline for that and second do we consider the high school student population you know kids that go to work after school do we consider extra help and clubs how would that affect those very tech kids attending programs after school? Or is it part of the next step in this study? All great questions. So the one state I know of off the top of my head is California. Everything starts in California. They have an 8 o'clock start time for, mandatory 8 o'clock start time for middle schools, mandatory 8.30 start time for high schools,

055with exceptions for rural school districts where there are long travel times. I can't think of any other states off the top of my head, but they're the one that seemed like they had the most sweeping legislation, so that got everyone's attention. I have not heard, other than lots of school districts that have been working on changing high school start times in New York, I don't know of any state regulation that is working its way through the system. I'm not familiar with any bills that might be in committee in the legislature. to do that as was done in California. That was a state law. But it is certainly a possibility. In terms of after school, we surveyed lots of other school districts to find out what their start times are. There are lots of schools that

056start as early as we do, and there are lots of schools that start later. So Jericho is the latest that I know of. They start their high school at 9 o'clock, but still have students who go to the BOCES program morning and afternoon. The morning program, you bus directly to. BOCES, you don't go to the school first, so you just go to BOCES whenever their start time is and the student participates in the program and they get back and there's probably actually a little bit more of their academic day left when they get back to Jericho, for example. In terms of clubs and after school, the schools that have later start times are still part of Section 8. They still compete in the same athletic conference. They still have after school clubs like we do.

057My understanding is that at Jericho, Because they have such a late high school start time, they do run some of the clubs before school. So they're sort of recapturing that time earlier in the day. And they do have a big advantage that we don't share, which is because they're high school and middle school are in the same campus, same building, they can really take advantage of a transportation efficiency there by routing the two routes together. So that's obviously with two middle schools fairly far apart, that's not something that we would be able to capture in the same way. I'm looking at the number of buses for high school. It's about 73 and middle school 72 and elementary school 81. So that means the high school buses are being used for middle school and elementary school

058as well, I'm assuming. And the distance that high school buses have to go probably would be the furthest out of all three levels of school. And that's only 20 minutes. And middle school should be shorter than 20 minutes and elementary school even shorter. And scenario one, two, and three, all three of them have 25 to 29 minutes between the middle school and high school. And if it's middle school that's going first, it should be less than 20 minutes. And if it's high school that's going first, then it should be 20 minutes. But we're not effectively using that. current timeline? Is it possible to, let's say in scenario one, push the middle school and high school towards the right side of the scale and maximize that time, 20 minutes, as the longest between the two? So

059we're now into the next layer of logistical complexity, which is loading times for buses. The what's masked by that 20-minute difference in dismissal time is the loading time of buses So if you think about late afternoon on Southwoods Road there you'll see 40 buses lined up in the circle and then on Southwoods Road by the tennis courts and some in the neighborhood and in Stillwell staging so having all of the buses Staged there allows them to run two and a half waves of buses and they load very quickly and go So the challenge would be with having the high school as a middle tier, you don't have the ability to have the buses all stack up all afternoon long so that they're in the right order, so that they go through the circle in the

060right order. Because if you think of it from a student perspective, you want your bus to be in the same place every day so you always get on the right bus. The only way that happens is if all the buses line up in the right order before they come onto the campus, that takes time. with the high school as a middle tier. what we've recognized is two things one you'd have to speed up the loading time of the buses significantly or the tier will be late for the next runs afterwards so you couldn't run multiple waves through the high school loop like we do now so we would have to build a staging area behind the high school as well more pavement in order to have a place for more buses to stage so that

061you could load all the buses simultaneously because you never know what order the buses are going to come back from the neighborhood and who gets here first who got stuck behind a red light so the only way that that will work is if there's a place for them to stage and they can go right into their bus parking spot like you would do at a greyhound terminal for example or like we do at the back of hbt now so we feel like we've squeezed the the work time between the tiers as much as we possibly can without being completely unrealistic as to what the loading time and the staging time is going to be for all these buses and and yes there are 73 some buses and 119 overall so there are some buses that

062don't do all three runs perhaps because they have a longer run and so they're only doing the middle school and elementary run and some buses are doing partial runs as well so there are just a lot of moving parts i i don't mean to say no but there's just a lot of moving parts dr rogers you mentioned other districts obviously we know jericho has done this do you know of other districts that have done it have you talked to them about these kind of wholesale changes and then I guess I should also ask, where do we go from here? You're a pretty positive guy, and you're telling us two of the options are not workable, and you sounded pretty pessimistic about the first scenario. So I'm just wondering, what's the next step? Well, I'm a

063pretty positive guy, and I think of myself as optimistic, especially around the holidays. I'm waiting beside the chimney to see what happens in a couple of weeks. What I would say is... I don't want to present something to you and say that there's an option that has no compromises involved. So... It sounds like there is a health benefit to having a later high school start time. Given the constraints, the logistical constraints we have, the benefit that we're going to pick up from perhaps more student sleep may come at the cost of some of these logistical challenges that we might have to face. And as a board, you're charged with sort of weighing those two things and deciding where to go. So I want to present this to you in a way that is clear and

064that shows the tradeoffs. so that you can weigh those things as fairly as possible without me necessarily putting my finger on the scales one way or the other. And I think you picked up on the other potentially viable option, which is just push the whole thing forward 15 minutes. When I worked in government, we used to say, is the juice worth the squeeze? So the question is, for the disruption that that would cause, is the extra 15 minutes of sleep, potential sleep, worth it? And that's a question. But from a logistics perspective, that is the simplest and most straightforward way to go. But it might only achieve 15 minutes worth of change. And then these more dramatic kinds of things will achieve. more sleep time but they'll come at a bigger cost in terms of

065the disruption oh sorry um so two things first um in terms of switching the high school and the middle school and i know that we're looking to increase sleep time because it's beneficial and their health benefits why is it that the high school i don't want the middle school students to not to What is it? I can't find the word that I want to say, but I don't want them to lose and have to wake up earlier because I know they have things late at night also, such as basketball until, you know, whatever, 945. So they get home late also, and they also benefit from sleep. So I'm just, I don't want people to, I don't want to switch the problem. So to speak I do know there are other districts that I'm happy to

066share with you if you wanted to talk to them They do do different start times and I don't know if they have the same logistics as Jericho or us or other people But I think Port Washington is one of the districts that's fairly large and they have later start times Across the board is it possible for us to have another scenario? With the high school time at nine o'clock like Jericho, or is this too late? Is it possible to have another scenario with the high school start time at 9 o'clock like Jericho? So the challenge will be that it will likely mean that the elementary school has to dismiss before the high school dismisses. So that may mean that we have a very early... elementary dismissal so you'd be moving the high school let's say

067roughly an hour and 15 minutes so the end of day at the high school would also move an hour and 15 minutes so call that quarter of four so you would have to move the elementary school up a half an hour before that so that you had the work time so it would be you'd have to have an earlier elementary school dismissal by probably 20 minutes. The question will be then where does that put the beginning of the day because that shorter elementary day means it will overlap one or the other of the two runs. We can certainly look at that. And the more I think about it, the more I don't want to do it off the top of my head. So we can certainly, you know, come to, we can explore that and

068come back to the board and tell you what the trade-offs would be. I do know Roslyn was a district that changed by about 20 minutes before the pandemic, maybe six years ago, five years ago. So, you know, they made a decision to make, they were able to do 20 minutes without too much disruption. And so that's what they took advantage of. So great minds think alike. I was thinking what Shani was thinking. She beat me to it. But if we do the 9 o'clock or 9.15 start time, if we could do the clubs before, like Jericho, I don't know if that would work with the early buses, but then kids could voluntarily do that or they wouldn't go in every day so they could have other days to sleep. It would be great because then

069they could start. I know a lot of times in the high school the kids will go to clubs. before sports, so there's a gap between the end of school and the sports start. So if the clubs are in the morning, then they could knock that out for whatever days they have to go in, but then they can go right into the sports, so it may not push the sports back too much. I don't know what that would do. I couldn't even try to do that in my head, the different start times and everything, but just a thought with the clubs and getting sports going after school. Well, certainly we look at 9 o'clock. We'll look at when clubs could go. Obviously, we do things before school at the elementary school now. So we have some

070experience with running a second tier of busing at elementary school where there's an early tier for extra help and like the jazz band and things like that. If you swap it, depending on when the elementary school is, I don't know how it would work with the buses. It may be too crazy. you could always look potentially at doing the extra help and clubs for the elementary school after school. And then that also helps with the child care aspect also. If there's people who need a few extra minutes, they could have the kids do clubs or extra help or something after school. No, I thought it was a comment. Things for us to look at as we review this scenario. Yeah, I mean, my only question about this is, is there data that we can review

071on the incremental changes, whether it's academic performance, measures of sleep, where we can verify any of the potential... you know the the purported benefits right the meta-analysis i read yesterday said from 2021 said basically you need an hour of extra late start time and it generates on average 20 minutes of extra sleep so i don't know if that meta-analysis is right but if we have actual data in the tri-state area or california or it's measurable what's been achieved for the rigmarole that we're trying to go through here that would be helpful to know in advance There was a study out of Glens Falls, which is a small city school district north of Albany, and two things about that study. We mentioned kids. They surveyed students prior to the change. Students were opposed to it. They

072surveyed students a year after the change. Students were enthusiastic about it. And they surveyed students prior to the change and asked them what their... go to bedtime get up time was what it was afterwards and it was similar to the data that you reported from the meta study which is you didn't recapture all of the additional time in the morning as sleep but you did recapture some of it as additional sleep and i think the there is a national sleep time coalition that talks about not just academic performance but mental health aspects, fewer car accidents. There's a laundry list of things that are affected in addition to just their academic performance as a result of having sleep. So I can certainly pull that together for you and share it with the board as well. Yeah,

073and I mean, the only last bit of follow-up that I would have is, sorry, which is that incrementally, by moving the high school start time by an hour, later that we're considering nine o'clock, we may need to toggle the amount of homework back because if we're starting that hour and we're ending that hour later, incrementally, it's not clear that we're going to get to recapture that as sleep if we're starting that whole process later in the day too. I'm not sure that the reason they're staying up so late is always because of homework as opposed to TikTok. No, not yet. I have questions, actually. So, Dr. Rogers, I know that when we spoke to Hank on our school trip, he mentioned something about that they had a period one and two where you didn't have

074to be in school or if you wanted to come later, you had the option. Did I understand that correctly? So, yes. Basically, if you think of their school, we have a nine-period day. They have an 11-period day. Periods one through nine are middle school periods. Periods three through 11 are high school periods. But it's all one building in the same bell schedule. So they do clubs before school. And if you're a high school kid and you want to do a before-school club, you ride the middle school bus. And so you get to school early because you're riding the middle school bus. And if you're a middle school kid and you stay late for something after school, you're riding either the high school bus home as a late bus or you're riding one of the later

075late buses that would be the high school late bus. So they're taking advantage of the fact that both of these programs are on the same campus and they can just run a bunch of tiers to the same building. It's not an option for us. Like, let's say a student, let's say you're an early riser and you want to come in early and you sleep late because that's your tendency. Would we be able to kind of have an early, so we wouldn't have to change the busing. Would we be able to have that option where you'd have a longer, you'd have more periods? Well, the reason why it works at Jericho is because they have the two tiers go to the same campus. So you have middle school tier that goes to the Jericho High School,

076Junior Senior High School campus, and then you have a high school tier that goes to the same campus. Here we have one tier where you could have the bus go to this campus here because two of the schools are on this campus but because HPT is across town to do that you would have to have the bus drop at the high school and then take 10 more minutes to go across town to HPT or the other way around you'd want that the high schooler who wants the later start time would wait and get on the middle school bus go to hbt wait for the middle school kids to get dropped off then keep going to the high school and be dropped off at the high school and then the question is would that bus be

077able to turn around and get to elementary school quickly enough after you added another 10 or 15 minutes to the ride and That's where it starts to break down because you've taken away half the work time That's needed to get to the elementary run by having the HPT kid go across town one of the other things I think we had discussed when we were doing the The weight room was that area that comes from the teachers parking lot to go back out Like where we had the ambulance parked for the football game Even if we didn't change a start time and could we gain any efficiencies from having? Instead of everybody coming to the front of the school going you know going out could we then gain efficiencies? Having like two staging areas like you

078said like at the Port Authority I mean, I know that's at the high school, but since we do have that back road So I feel like the person they wrote the song paved paradise and put up a parking lot but What you have right now at the high school is you have two and a half waves. So there's not enough space in the front of the high school to load all the buses simultaneously. So one run of buses comes through, they load, they go down Southwoods Road. The second wave of buses comes in, they stop, they load, then they go down. And then there's a third wave of buses that comes in that's about half as big as the first two. All of that takes time. The advantage you have with the high school going

079first is that they're all lined up on Southwoods Road and they're all in the right order and they're all ready to enter the circle as soon as the circle is free. The downside is you still have the time it takes for the buses to exit the circle, the new ones to come in, stop, load the kids, fire up, and then go. So if you were loading all buses simultaneously, you would pick up more time. You would dismiss from the high school faster. So more buses would be on the road more quickly after the dismissal bell rings. So to do that, you would have to have. One and a half more staging areas basically the area between the weight room and the traffic circle that's by the barn would be You know like a herringbone shaped

080spot area like you would have at a regular bus depot and then By the pool and tennis courts create again more sidewalk for students to be able to be on while they're waiting for their buses and the buses could be there essentially you're doubling the length of sidewalk from which student could access a bus so you'd be able probably to send save five, seven minutes of time in that turnaround. So certainly if the high school is going to be the middle tier, you need to be able to get the buses on campus and loaded quickly so they can turn around and do the third tier afterwards. But even if it was the first tier, you'd get the buses on the road faster and you would make it. logistically easier to go north. So right now

081going north on Southwoods Road involves making a left-hand turn out of the high school loop, and that's obviously an uncontrolled intersection. By law, we're not allowed to direct traffic in a roadway. Only the Nassau Police can do that or the people they designate it. The bus just has to make a left-hand turn onto Southwoods Road. That's the only way to go north. If they were exiting from the backside of the campus, they could go up behind the bleachers and then exit out further up Southwoods Road by the tennis courts or through the neighborhood like the middle school buses do and then go out to, say, Cold Spring Road. And I know we had spoken about this before, too. Again, in the event, maybe we're early adopters, but... How can we employ technology or we had

082also said is there any way to kind of have an idea where the buses are, who's on the bus, to kind of, you know, we almost like need to look. We do use logistics software. We use routing software to look for efficiencies in the routing that we do. In the last contract that we renewed with Huntington Coach, which is our bus service company, we asked for two things to be added in the tech realm. One is surveillance cameras, so there are surveillance cameras on all buses now. And the second was GPS monitoring. So we don't monitor it in real time. They monitor it in real time. What we're trying to work towards is having an app. that a parent would be able to use that says the bus is 10 minutes away, the bus is

083five minutes away, the bus is three minutes away, so that people don't assume that the bus is not coming if the bus was just three, four minutes late. Imagine on a snowy day when all the buses are backed up. If you know the bus is still coming, you wait on the bus stop as opposed to... fearing that the bus isn't coming then driving your kid to school and then the campus is clogged with cars so we Got so far as to have a prototype We asked some volunteers from the PTA to try it out with us They gave us feedback the feedback was not positive on that particular product. So we've said to the Huntington coach to go find a better product. They're in that process right now It's buggy and there are logistical challenges,

084which is the GPS is coded to a bus. Let's call it bus 133. But bus 133 today might be in the shop. Tomorrow it might be doing, you know, route 14 for HBT. Things change, and by the end of the week, it's doing Route 32 for HPT, but it's the same bus. So they have to recode the GPS to be the different route so that it's expected where it's supposed to be, or if it's a replacement bus, et cetera, et cetera. Now I'm way too deep in the weeds, all of which is to say we want to get there, and there's got to be a technology solution to it, but the technology is not mature enough yet. It'll be frustrating to people, I think. Dr. Rogers, years ago, I know you've been doing this for

085a long time, doing start time for a long time. I actually remember sitting in the audience when you discussed the flipping of the high school and the elementary school. And I remember you talking about that the elementary school may have to end as early as like 1.30 to sort of fit it all in. And then I assume when we had this study done, you gave certain constraints. It was one of those constraints that the elementary school can't end before a certain time, and that's why they didn't spit back a scenario that involved that? Exactly. They offered it as a theoretical exercise that we presented that in public. We got a lot of negative feedback about an elementary day that ended at 1.30. And so we said, look, as a theoretical exercise, it's fine, but we're

086trying to accomplish something in the real world here. So let's put some real world constraints on. And we didn't want to see any. any tier starting before 7 45 in the morning we didn't want to see an elementary tier that ended i don't remember what we said off the top of my head but let's say no earlier than 2 30 we didn't want to see an elementary tier that ended any later than 3 30 because kids have after school activities so we did we put a number of constraints on them and by the time we put all these constraints in place which we viewed as not just logistical constraints but sort of plausibility constraints of what we think you or the public would see as a plausible approach. Those were the constraints that we put

087on them. And these were, within those constraints, the handful of scenarios that met our needs, met our tests, but they came with some serious shortcomings as well. Honestly, last one for reals on the buses. I remember reading somewhere that there's a constraint on... potentially another constraint besides universal busing would be the way our potential contracts could be written for busing. Is there a limitation on the length of time that we have to employ buses to drive during the course of the day? So, for example, is it more expensive to have a lot of buses for a very short period of time as opposed to having a finite number of buses for a lengthier period of time? Is that another constraint that's potentially liftable? The short answer is going to be no, but the longer answer

088is the why behind it. So we typically buy what are called five-hour buses. And what that means is we buy the bus for five hours a day, typically two and a half hours in the morning, two and a half hours in the afternoon. And unfortunately for the driver, a big empty space in the middle of the day where they're not really earning and they can't really go and do something else. So it's the world's longest lunch break or it's a good opportunity to get errands done. But from an employment perspective, it would be much nicer to just have a seven-hour shift as opposed to this split five-hour shift. So it's one of the things that makes it difficult to identify people who want to be bus drivers, school bus drivers, because of the way this

089works. So we can buy four-hour buses, but they'll charge us the same as they would for the five-hour bus, reason being it's still one driver who can't be used anywhere else for the rest of the day. So what they're really charging us for is days times drivers, and then if we use the bus for four hours or five hours, from their perspective, it's a driver that can't. go earn somewhere else for them so since we've taken that driver away from their pool for the day we're going to get charged for the full day for that driver there are some and i'll this is where now it's more in the weeds and i'll let dr ruffo answer but there are some kinds of routing that is shorter than the five hour bus but i would say

090the the overwhelming majority of the buses we hire are five hour buses because that's really all they want all they can sell profitably did i miss anything no that's correct most of ours are five hours and we have some six um but and and it's incremental in terms of cost the difference between the cost difference between a four hour five hour six hour bus is almost nothing it's just like fuel cost yeah right And just given how constrained the pool of drivers is, we want every driver to put as many hours on the road as possible. You know, having a driver and only using them for two hours a day defeats our purpose of trying to keep all the buses rolling. Can we just take a five-minute bathroom break and then we'll get going? Is

091that okay with everyone? Okay, we're going to start again. Thank you, everybody. So, Dr. Rogers. I guess you'll get back to us with some options or some next steps based on our feedback. yeah so I certainly appreciate the feedback I know mr. Escobar dr. Rufo been taking notes as a bye we'll certainly go back and look at your request to have us examine a nine o'clock start time for the high school and see how that distorts the other days for the district but the next step in the process if you want to continue to pursue this would be for us to do what we had done back in 2019 which is to do some public engagement we had done survey instrument we talked to students we did survey of the public and a survey of

092our staff we'd want to engage with our staff unions to get their perspective on this as well so that would be the next step in the process okay thank you so much for that in-depth review lisa do you want to give the board update sure So a few things that the board since our last meeting we've been up to The first thing is Cabaret night on November 10th. We were invited to Cabaret night at the high school It was very exciting students from the choral department. They perform as both soloists and ensembles They took the proceeds from this event and they donated it to the PTA-STA Scholarship Fund as well as to Cancer Kids First, which is really amazing. The show itself was incredible, but the young gentleman that we saw earlier, Michael Sabatino, he

093was one of the performers and he was just really something else. So that was a wonderful night. Many of us were there and we really enjoyed it. the next thing we had was the boces component board member orientation which we were invited to by BOCES. On November 17th, we attended this orientation, and basically BOCES gave us an overview of all of the programs and services that they offer to the district, as well as just an overview of their organization in general, how they function. And we were given a really nice tour of their facility in Westbury, so that was a great evening. I didn't stop to ask if anybody has anything to add. cabaret night or orientation okay i'm sorry i'm trying to move along because of time so just stop me if you want

094to talk And then we were also invited to South Grove and Village Elementary Schools for their Thanksgiving feasts. During the week of Thanksgiving, we were invited there. We had at South Grove, the students performed songs and they danced for us. They also read to us and presented us with thank you cards from all of the different grades. I have a bunch of them here today. I mean, they're so well written and really... written from the heart just thanking us for our service to the district and how they look up to us and they were so happy that we were there so thank you so much these are going to be hung up in our boardroom in the back the student council at south grove actually planned this event and they told us when we were

095there that they planned it using a budget and that they voted on how to use their funds so we spoke to them for a few minutes about how the way that they planned this event was actually very close to what we do as a board so we spoke to them for a few minutes and it was just amazing to see how these fifth graders are literally like little adults they're very very impressive so thank you to south grove Right, and also there, not only did they have us there as a thank you, but they also had veterans there from Syosset-Woodbury area also, and they also had first responders, and they made cards and did the same thing for them as well. So it was overall, it was a really beautiful event. Then the PTA had

096some snacks and whatnot for us too. It was just overall, it was a really nice event. And then from there, the next day, we went to Village, and we ate at their annual Thanksgiving feast. It was wonderful to see the students were all there together eating at these giant tables. I know my kids went to Village, and I hadn't been there in that capacity in years. And just to see this again back in person, everybody was happy, smiles on everybody's faces. The students sang us. song as well their village song and it was I think we just felt as a board just honored to be invited to the schools and be able to sit there as an extended part of the family for each of those schools too so not only did they have smiles

097on their faces but we had smiles on our faces too Does anybody want to add to that? The one thing I wanted to add at Village was that they actually had over 90 parent volunteers for two full sessions. So they probably had more than 90, which was great. And actually, all the parents got dressed up, too. So it was just an amazing event. And then we also had the... Nassau Suffolk School Board Association advocacy events last week. Nassau Suffolk School Boards Association hosted an event where they had veteran New York State Assemblyman Fred Thiel. He spoke about how to effectively advocate with your state and federal representatives and how to be a better public education advocate for your district. We had a couple of representatives from the board attend there. I don't know if anybody

098wants to speak on that. MS. Okay. And then also there was one more thing I think Tom wanted to speak about was the Girls on the Run function. last weekend so we had um a couple of our schools represented and girls on the run and um that day was actually a torrential downpour with 50 mile power winds but um we had an amazing turnout um the elementary school girls um came out i was shocked um they really um you know they showed real courage real leadership because i i didn't think they were going to show up um i didn't even i i ran into and sort of dr rogers He beat me, but no surprise. But my daughter beat me, so I thought I was really proud of her. But I just want to thank

099the volunteers because I was speaking to a lot of volunteers in the pouring rain, and I had asked them, I was like, oh, you know, where's your child? And they're like, oh, no, my child graduated a long time ago, but I'm still. uh... a leader in a coach so i thought that that was amazing and i wanted to thank them for their ongoing service and volunteering to help the districts and i have to tell you observed uh... girls on the run and they get a very very professional job so hats off to everybody on that uh... doctor who fell you want to give uh... report on the citizens advisory committee for finance Yes. The Citizens Advisory Committee for Finance had a meeting on November 7th. The administration distributed copies of the audited financial statements, extra

100classroom activity fund. and the internal auditor risk assessment. We reviewed the audit report, discussed budget variances in revenue and expenditure items. The committee expressed interest in future discussions on alternative revenue sources as well as exploring ideas on saving, potentially saving money on expenses related to short-term borrowings. The suggestion was also made to have the district's attorney join the next meeting to brief the committee on potential alternative revenue sources. The committee discussed recruiting efforts for new members and changing the focus of the committee to idea generation, including creative ways to increase revenue for the district. The next meeting will be held on January 23rd. Thank you, Dr. Ruffo. And if anybody is interested in volunteering for the Finance Committee, I think we're looking for diversity in idea and diversity in background and diversity in occupation so

101we can bring a more holistic view than just everybody being in finance. So please consider it. I mean, I've been serving on that committee for a number of years, so I think this direction where it's idea generating and problem solving is a very refreshing change in sort of the direction that this district is going to go. I think it's going to present a lot of opportunity for a lot of folks out there with some good ideas to potentially come in and help us out. There's a lot of smart people in the neighborhood and if folks want to volunteer and be a part of that problem solving, I think that would be great. Thank you. Okay, next we're going to move to audience of the public. So would anybody like to come up and speak at

102audience of the public? Good evening. My name is Rachel Jacobson. I've been a resident of Syosset for a little over nine years. I have two children at HBT. And I wanted to come address the board today with regard to the November 17th. memorandum that came out from the State Department of Education which when I read it stated in no uncertain terms that public school districts are prohibited from utilizing Native American mascots It goes on to state that those districts that continue to utilize these mascots, including team names, logos, imagery, without approval from a recognized tribe, must immediately come into compliance with the Dignity Act, meaning stop using these mascots. And to date, and we're now going on close to a month since this memorandum came out and received tons of press, the only communication we

103as... residents of the district have received is that the district is awaiting further regulation from the state before commenting further. I reviewed the memorandum and the memorandum does state that regulations will be coming down. However, those regulations state that their purpose will be to clarify how districts can go about retiring their mascots. So my concern is why have we not heard from the district yet that they are going to end using the mascot we currently use, the Braves? The directive from the state is clear and the state has now gone even further to say that if we can see if we fail to end the use of this mascot by the conclusion of the school year, which is now just six months away, we risk losing funding and we're now putting our administrators livelihood at

104risk because they will potentially lose their jobs. At this point, I'm seeking to know where we stand on this and that we need the board. to come together and bring our community together on what has undoubtedly been a divisive issue, as we all know, for at least the last 20 years, if not more. We need the board to bring this community together and usher in this change. And the longer we wait, the more time we're losing. Syosset, I moved here because Syosset has always prided itself on being a leader as a premier school district and a leader in doing what's right. And I could even think back to when the pandemic happens and how quickly we were able to get kids to school and do things that other districts in New York didn't get to

105do. But here we are, we're one of only 60 districts and over 700 in New York State that continue to use this Native American mascot. And now the state is telling us we can't do it anymore. So what are we waiting for? That's what I don't understand. And we should at least now be a leader amongst those 60 school districts. And it's not anything that's now being asked of us, we're being directed to. And I'm here also with another colleague of mine who I think is also wanting to raise this issue. So I figured before you guys responded, it might be useful to hear from her. Thank you. Thank you. I'm Melissa Foreman. I live at 44 Orchard Drive in Woodbury. I have two children in the school district. My daughter is in seventh grade

106at HBT. My son's in fourth grade at Walt Whitman. Full disclosure, I am also one of the co-presidents of the Walt Whitman PTA. I am not here in that capacity. I'm here as a private citizen of the Syosset School District. I am also here to find out what is being done and how we are making strides to eradicate the school mascot. The New York State Education Department issued a memorandum requiring school districts to stop the use of all Native American names, logos, mascots, and imagery in public schools across the state. Districts failing to comply with this measure by the end of the 22-23 school year can be found in willful violation and could face a loss of school funding. One month later, the community still hasn't heard any response from the Board of Education or

107the superintendent's office other than SIASA is waiting for additional guidance from the state. The ruling from the state is both clear in its focus and scope. There is no room for interpretation as to whether our school mascot, the Braves, falls under this directive. Further guidance will only be procedural in nature and should not prevent going forward meeting the compliance deadline. The removal of Native American mascots like the Braves was actually addressed 21 years ago in a 2001 directive from the then Commissioner of Education for the state of New York. The directive asked the boards of education to end the use of Native American mascots as soon as practical, citing the state's interest in providing a safe and supportive learning environment for every child. While many districts complied, Syosset, despite its national recognition for academic prominence,

108still has not. Out of the 731 school districts in New York State, only 60 still maintain the use of a Native American mascot. Out of the 127 school districts on Long Island, Syosset is among the remaining five districts holding on to this antiquated and offensive mascot. Our continued use of Braves language seeps beyond the walls of our schools and encroaches on our entire community. Youth sports organizations, including Syasset Baseball and Syasset Lacrosse, have not only adopted our Braves name, but have continued to use the offensive imagery abandoned by our district. As a result, these racially insensitive images have a continued presence on our fields and in our hallways. This is unacceptable and does not align with Syosset School District's reputation for academic excellence and its commitment to diversity and dignity. There is a strong argument

109that the time for change was 20 years ago. There is no doubt the time for change is now. The sooner we adopt a new mascot, the sooner we eradicate the negative imagery associated with our town. We should be working together to move forward in finding a mascot that positively represents what our community stands for, as opposed to waiting on the state to force us to take action. The unnecessary uncertainty surrounding this situation is causing divisiveness over an issue that is no longer up for debate. We must move forward. The resistance to changing our mascot on the basis of tradition is ignorant, flawed, and puts us on the wrong side of history. Instead of waiting for the state of New York to threaten our funding, we should be setting an example for our children and be

110proactively looking to institute positive change. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, David Friedman 38 Eagle Chase Woodbury Been in this community for 18 years. I have a ninth grader and a twelfth grader and they You know, they both play competitive sport in this town and like the one before People seem to think that it's a an offensive logo I'm also the president of the Syosset Lacrosse Booster Club. We are a registered 501c3 charity in this community. We help out all of our members, most of your lacrosse members that are playing for your high school teams. So everything that Syosset High School does not do, we do. pregame meals. We rent the hub so these boys can train, you know, all off season. We do over the summer, we do summer leagues. We do our practice

111uniforms. We do our practice pennies. We do our shooter shirts. We handle everything. When during COVID was going on and you and we were coming out of COVID, we were back the season after, we weren't allowed to have water. Boys couldn't have water from the school, so Syazza LaCroix's Booster Club paid for the water. Donations from other parents. We take care of it. countless, countless things that our organization does. But as a parent and as a son who's played Syosset lacrosse since he's in third grade and he's played as a Brave through PAL and then was fortunate to move up from middle school into the high school, as a middle schooler he played for Syosset High School, which he still does and is a captain on the team. He's been a Brave. And as Dr.

112Rogers knows, when they're singing the national anthem, and at the end of that song, which is the word Braves is there, every boy holds his hand up with his helmet in his hand, and he shouts out Brave. No one owns the word Brave. Native Americans don't own it. We don't own it. The community doesn't own it. This is First Amendment. This is constitutional. So what I'm here today to find out is what is, like they were asking, what is Syosset's plan? We all know what the memoranda said, but as being part of the, someone in the town who... you know, who runs, you know, a charity, at a booster club with boys, I speak to the other communities. So we'll talk about Manhasset. We talk about Massapequa that are all in the same boat as

113us, Sachem. You know, we've all spoken. I've spoken. We've consulted with, you know, pretty high power constitutional attorneys. And, you know, it's not really our fight to have because it's really up to what the school board's going to do and what actions you guys are going to take. If it moves, I guess, in a direction that's not favorable, you know, then we can seek other outside sources. But, you know, I guess the plan is, are we just going to, you know, say uncle on this situation and cave to what basically seems like an extortion letter? from the Board of Ed, you know, threatening livelihoods of people and threatening funding. And it's, you know, it's a weak case that was one upstate. It states one person's... opinion on on data points that they took from from

114i don't think you know really relevant people but either way the case was was won and you know the case can be fought other places and if we have to we're willing to do that um but as far as direct questions for the board i would say like i said earlier what is the school's plan are you guys seeking to to get an exemption or approval from the um you know, from other tribes that are on the island or elsewhere in the country. Are you guys willing to do a coalition with the other school districts that are in the same boat, in the same situation like the Massapeague was like, Manhasset, Sachem, so on, the other 55 schools, I believe it is? You know, and I guess the outcome, whether you guys decide to fight

115or not, what is the plan? Are we going to lose the name Braves? Who's going to then take up the cost of the signage that's in the gym, the signage that's in the weight room, the signage that's on a million-dollar turf field outside? All right. David, thank you so much for volunteering and for coming up. And also, Melissa, thank you for volunteering for the PTA. Does anyone else want to come up and speak? Hi, I'm Dana Benavoy. I have three children. My oldest, Whitney, is a kindergartner at Village Elementary School. I also have a two-year-old and a one-year-old. So I have many years ahead in the Syosset School District, and we just moved here last year. So we're very excited. This is our first Board of Ed meeting. So I know I've had discussions previously

116with Mr. Escobar about this before, but the issue I want to bring to your attention is a concern I have regarding the photo policies throughout the school district. So in particular, the elementary school that my child goes to, I received an email this past week. about photo policies that state that no parent is allowed to take any pictures inside or outside of the school building of their child at any event. And at any event, they'll be assigned what they call photo paparazzi, which include members of the PTA, class representatives, or event coordinators, which for the most part basically just consists of the PTA boards at our school. The concern I have about this, that this email actually came from a member of the PTA, not from the school. And so while I tried to research

117what the school district policies were with regards to photos, really not much comes up. I understand there is a waiver about children who parents don't want their photos being taken, and that's why there are concerns regarding that. To give you some background, I'm also an attorney. I'm the former assistant general counsel of J.P. Morgan, and where I drafted legal policy is for J.P. Morgan regarding certain matters like this. So my basic concern is if you're taking away these rights of parents, you know, I'm a parent who had a child in preschool during the two years of COVID. We didn't get to see our child in school at all for the past couple of years. The past few months has been the first time my husband and I have been able to see our child in

118school in any event. You know, this is unprecedented. And for us to go in and have security guards tell us, you know, you're not allowed to capture these moments with your child. You can't take a picture with your child, even against a wall, because our school is not letting you. And only certain moms are allowed to have these photos of your child on their phones. What makes those moms? you know, legally responsible compared to us. So I want to be here to advocate that there needs to be a moral code set about for parents. I understand that for a school district, you know, people who are employed by the school district, there can be repercussions if, you know, things are done and posted on the Internet. You know, there could be, you know, repercussions such

119as termination of employment. But for parents, you know, there's really not much a school district can do. If you're going to sue a school district over photos being taken of a child that weren't supposed to be taken according to this waiver, you know it's something that the school district's doing not what parents are doing and there really is nothing being said on this waiver about parents taking pictures so you know with the holiday events coming up i know in our school next week on tuesday there's a holiday event all the parents are taking off to be there and none of us are allowed to take pictures out of our children not we're not allowed to even even if the paparazzi takes a photo we're being told highlighted if paparazzi takes any photos they are not

120to be posted on social on any media platform Even those approved photos count and to give you an example. We had a Thanksgiving feast Last month and this was the first time this went into effect Where the PTA president was allowed to take pictures along with two other people and no one else no other parents could take out their phone and The problem was all these parents, you know relied on this one, you know, this couple of people to take their photos, it all ended up going to the principal who then decided which photos were allowed to be uploaded. And it was her personal decision which ones could be uploaded. And even ones of my husband and I standing against a wall, they weren't uploaded. You know, why? And it took forever. I had to,

121you know, contact, you know, where did all the photos go? What happened? These are, you know, memories. We relied on you guys to provide them to us. it took an unnecessary amount of time for the school to look through all these photos like when you guys should be doing other things better things with your time you know you have to give the parents some trust you know rely on us to make the right decisions we're not going to post photos of children that we don't know it's only our children and we should have these memories we should have it for now we have for later for their future and also for their yearbook we won't have a yearbook in five years if we can't take any pictures thank you thank you so much nina Does

122anybody else want to come up and speak? Hi, I'm Rachel Levinson. I'm a community member and my children go to Walt Whitman. I've spoken here before and used my own words, but tonight I was thinking, since some of my community members have already so eloquently spoken on the issue, I might use some words from people maybe wiser than I about their vision for Syosset. Syosset is a place to prepare students to face evolving challenges in their lifetime and to make exemplary contributions to an increasingly diverse society. Syosset will be known for students, staff, and parents who exemplify patience, respect, integrity, dignity, and empathy. Pride. They will also support students' mental wellness by giving them the sense of safety and belonging, committing to robust character education. Syosset's excellent schools are the heart of the community and

123an essential part of families' lives. To maintain this position as a major community asset, Syosset will be known for a community that celebrates and supports its rich multicultural makeup, engaging parents and intentionally welcoming new families, including those from a language challenge, where a language challenge may exist. So in regards to being one of the last holdouts to hold on to this mascot that depicts... marginalized group in a negative way. I really challenge us to look back at the mission statement of Syosset School District, which is to prepare students to thrive both in the future we imagine and the one in which may evolve in ways we have not envisioned. When the Braves logo and mascot was chosen, We didn't know we were going to be here. Perhaps we should have, just like our grandparents didn't

124know that a lot of their ideas were not correct and would become antiquated and offensive. Why are we holding on to it? Thank you, Rachel. Anyone else want to come up? My name is Adam Weinstein I lived in Sassa School District for about 30 years been a homeowner for the last 29 and I've had one child go through the school district graduated last year and have another one in the school district now and regarding the logo be happy to be on the committee that discusses that further but I've lived on Long Island my whole life went to St. Joseph's School District they're flaming arrows they're dealing with the same situation I don't totally agree or With the some of the concerns that were brought up, although I understand it's a big topic. I understand what

125you guys are up against But my daughter's Native American. She's a hundred percent you Went to the school district if she was here right now and I actually come because I heard one another gentleman speaking earlier I will tell you she thinks there's more things to worry about and that's not one of the things if anything she's happy as hell about the fact that there As a youth and then we recognize the Indians as we do that's one thing we should be teaching the students and those that we What to appreciate how to appreciate it. It's not offensive to them. I have another gentleman that's living in my house who's 100% Seneca and It is what it is. So he feels the same way. So what however this goes forward. My name is Adam Weinstein

126I'm going to stay around. I want to hear what has to be said. But whatever, if there's a committee involved, I'd like to be involved. That's all. Thank you. Thank you, Adam. Anyone else? Hi, my name is Joe Colley. I live at Seven Month Replace South. I've been here about 20 years. I've had two children that went through the school system, and I have one that's in it now. And I'd like to address the Braves issues as well, too. It's no doubt all throughout the United States there have been racist caricatures of Indians. I don't think this is the case. If you just look at the logo selected as a source of pride in the name, we're like little kids playing, you know, I want to be Superman, I want to be Batman. This is

127something that we see as a good thing we want to emulate too. We see characteristics there that we attribute to them. We want to be as good as them. And that's why they selected that name and that logo to begin with. However, that being said, given that the law is the law, decisions have to be made, I'd say why not reach out to some of the local tribes. I guarantee you some of them will be fine keeping the name. Because other than, they'll look at this as just another attempt to wipe out the history and past. When's the last time you'll ever talk about an Indian except when you see it, think of the Braves as a Sasson logo here. So I would hope that rather than just roll over and we get renamed the

128Siasset Snowflakes or something, someone at least reaches out to local Indian tribes because it's their opinions that really should matter in this. Thank you very much and have a great day. And fantastic job on the bus analysis too. Thank you. Thank you so much, Joe. Felisa Wyman for Narcissus Drive in Siasset. I just wanted to go back to the Syosset high school start times and just say I really hope we can get this accomplished it's been like at least four years now that we've been discussing it one will those scenarios that were up on the screen be available somewhere for us to look at And two, I know someone mentioned about flipping elementary and high school. If maybe we can have a little more discussion on that. I don't know why we can't do that.

129I know it was about the buses at the end of the day where they line up, but I kind of got lost in that. I'm sorry. There's a lot of details. But again, we know it's the right thing for our high schoolers. I really hope we could do it. I have a senior now. I know it won't happen then, but maybe for my 10th grader. I don't know. Anyway, thank you very much. Thank you so much. Thank you. Before you go again, does anybody else want to speak that hasn't spoken yet? Okay. Yes, you can go back up. Hi. Thank you. Thank you for listening. You know, just I wanted to respond to a few things that had been said after I had spoken. This is not a debate of political correctness. This is about

130racial equality. The promotion of racial stereotypes by our public education system teaches students that stereotyping of minority groups is acceptable. There is no other ethnic group that is used as a mascot. Human beings are not mascots. It's that simple. Our school cannot stand against racism while actively promoting an insensitive caricature of an entire culture. The resistance of change based on the tradition of... Are you? The resistance to change on the basis of tradition is ignorant and flawed. I wish some people here would educate themselves a little more instead of just spewing things that they think sounds right. Before women had the right to vote, anti-suffragists argued that most women did not want the right to vote because it took time away from caring for their home and their children. These claims were made in the

131face of hundreds of thousands of women fighting for the contrary. The Brown vs. Board of Education decision was met with so much resistance that mobs of armed pro-segregation protesters patrolled the streets in efforts to prevent black children from registering. Both of these events marred our nation's history within the past hundred years. Our reluctance to recognize that our current mascot is culturally and racially insensitive puts us on the wrong side of history. Instead of waiting for the state to act, we should be setting an example. Thank you. Thank you very much. It wants to be said that we're, you know, we're discriminating. I don't think that the children of this school, the sports competitors, for example, or parents or anyone who buys in the tens of thousands of dollars that we sell a year in our

132sweatshirts and our T-shirts and everything would be wearing it if we were just, you know, racist people walking around looking to denigrate somebody. It is honor. It is respect. And when you go ahead, and they'll probably never know, okay, because they'll never be competitive in anything. When you go to a showcase, and I don't care if I'm in Maryland or I'm in Boston or I'm anywhere else in this country, and you wear, as a sign of respect, you don't wear your club lacrosse helmet, you wear your... high school helmet and when the people and the coaches from Yale from Cornell from Harvard from Maryland from Virginia see the red helmet with the Syosset Brave logo on it the coaches come over and they talk about the alumni that have come out of this school and

133they say hey did you know this were you in the school when he was there hey he's doing really well in the program and then they engage And they do it because they recognize one thing, and it's our helmet, and it's our logo, and it's the symbol that our kids run around in. We're not looking to go ahead and denigrate anybody. I've spoken to Native Americans. We gave a gift last year. We bought from the Native Americans, from the Seneca tribe, okay, that made authentic lacrosse sticks for our team. And you know what they did? They engraved the Brave logo into the sticks by hand. And they strung them by hand. And they thought it was great. Okay, I've spoken to many Native American lacrosse players, professionals, college players. No one ever looks at it

134in a negative way, except for the people that don't know anything about what those people have gone through. They read something. They hear about it. They follow the news. You know, when they're wearing their Prada backpacks and their Bach books and their shoes that are made on the slaves of children in other countries, it's okay. But then they find the cause and then they come here and they preach. So, like I said, it's up to the school board to decide what they're going to do. I want to hear what you guys have decided and what steps you're taking. That's all I have to say. Okay, thank you, David. Does anybody else want to speak? Just real quick again, please. Basically, there are plenty of other groups that get picked for logos. Spartans goes back to

135Greeks, and every Greek person's going to get themselves picked. No, you picked them because it's a symbol of honor and victory. Same thing, I'm Irish. Boston Celtics, flighting Irish, millions and millions of rep fronts. They have funny leprechauns and stuff like that. I take that as a source of pride. You're holding us up and looking at us, and I think that's a good thing. That's my personal opinion from my personal background or whatever. So thank you very much, and have a good day. My name is Adam Weinstein again. I didn't say my address before. I guess I was supposed to. My 40 Candy Lane here in Salisbury. So just to add, and I know I came late and I apologize, but again, I think, you know, however this is discussed and discussed going forward, I

136really like to be part of it. I have a family member, like I said, is 100% Ute. I've spent a month on a reservation during my adoption. I could tell you the trial, what I went through for that adoption two years after the adoption. So those of you who have ever adopted a child, you know what the rules of the road are. New York State's different than Utah. Utah's different than Jersey. Jersey's different than Connecticut. Well, I will tell you Indian law supersedes any state law of the 50 states and federal law. So two years after my daughter was born, the tribe tried to have the baby come back to where she's two years old to the tribe. I spent another month at the tribe. on the reservation so before people start talking about what

137we are not doing what we should be doing what you should be doing is recognizing that you know what i've been out i've been out to montauk i've been to other tribes i've been everywhere and this is not an issue for them yeah it's a state with the state's pushing it i get it i know you understand what you're up against but at the same time i think you know we have to see how others do things as well because i don't think it's just a complete sweep of what we should do or shouldn't do i don't agree with some of the things that were said I could tell you I've been on the reservation and what my daughter will tell you because she doesn't want to go back to the reservation and I could

138tell you what my her friend Henhawk is his name, Blaze is his first name and my daughter's name is Chelsea right she's she was born with us so we therefore want to shoot at her birth. I will tell you that you know what they have their issues on the reservation and what we should be doing as a community is helping them out all the communities. Because they have issues there, right? They have issues with reading and writing. They have issues with alcoholism and diabetes and poor education, things like that. This is not an issue for them. If anything, this is what's holding up what they live for, right? Because we recognize them. What we should be teaching the kids is appreciate what it's about, not what's going on in 2021, 2022, and what's going on

139in 2023. Yeah, I realize it's a law that's been pushed forward, and it's something you guys have to deal with. But again what you have as the Braves it's not what what has been said here before that's all I'm saying. Thanks Thank you so much. Anyone else? Okay, so that's gonna close audience to the public So just to start off back to the board communication I felt that this was a very important Item to discuss we know it's the vestive in the community We wanted the entire board here to speak about it and have audience of the public so we can get your feedback, too that's why we're it's actually on the Discussion items that are on our agenda for tonight. So we were completely planning on talking about it tonight The regulations did come

140out on Friday night late, but I can summarize them very succinctly. They essentially say what they repeat what was in the memo, which is the board must take an affirmative vote no later than June 30th of 2023 to retire any Native American mascot and imagery, and that all such imagery has to be removed from the school district no later than June 30th. of 2025 so uh vote to retire it by the end of the year uh have all vestiges eliminated in within the next two years is essentially what it says it does provide for an exemption for um A district that has written permission from a recognized tribe. I've been sort of following the news, obviously, on this since it became public and have seen some statements that sound like the recognized tribes on Long

141Island would. They were statements that I think were discouraging in terms of how that conversation would go, but we have not made contact because, and nor have we said anything about this to the public because the Board hasn't discussed it yet, and this is obviously a task that falls to the Board for its discussion. So as Mr. Bertolo said, it was put on the next... agenda for the very next Board meeting and I wouldn't presume what the Board's action would be so there was no additional information for me to share with the public other than I wanted to share with the public the fact that the memo had happened and that obviously we were going to have to consider it. So that's the new regulations in a nutshell and Would you like me to respond

142to some of the other items that came up during audience to the public just so that we can? Wrap that up so the easiest question to answer is Miss Wyman will we put the presentation up online answer yes? So we post every presentation that's done at a board meeting on the district's website And it'll probably take a day or so for it to go up there. We'll double check it for Spelling and whatnot, but it will go up and then you can look at it more closely and uh... the reason for the difficulty in flipping elementary and high school is the elementary day is shorter than the high school day so if you think about it going first if it's uh... We'll make this easy for the math Let's say it's a six hour day

143in the high school is a six and a half hour day all in if you go before the high school and you have to have 20 minutes of time for the buses in between the two you're going to end up being You'll have elementary school dismissing over an hour and a half earlier than the high school and so that ends up being the end of the day in the middle of the afternoon and it just won't work for parents for Child care purposes And Ms. Medavoy, I know you've had a lot of conversations with our district administrative staff about the photo policy. I believe that we're in the process of working on proposing to the board's policy committee and then for the board's full consideration some policies on student privacy, but also on... photo objections

144and some of the other concerns that we have, I think, coming out of the pandemic. We're excited about having parents back in the building again. I want you to enjoy these opportunities with kids, but also recognize that we have some obligations to families of students who are uncomfortable with having their students' images online or shared by others. And we have our own... reservations and hesitations as we talk with cybersecurity experts about their concerns with images of students that are posted online with identify personally identifying information so we're trying to sweep all of that into an updated policy but I would certainly say that's work that we have to do and everything else was on the mascot which we've just talked about how we've arrived at this moment with the board Okay, so we will have

145a board discussion about that in the next section which is discussion We're going to move on to the appointment of a representative for the BOCES budget review committee Okay Every year Nassau BOCES invites the district appoints a representative For the BOCES budget review committee to assist in reviewing approximately 30 budgets the budget orientation meeting is Thursday December 15th and the budget will be reviewed on Thursday January 12th and Tuesday January 31st the three meetings will begin at 7 p.m. We would suggest that sending two delegates Does any is anybody interested in going and being a delegate? It's budget stuff. So, you know, I care so all right. Do I have anyone else? I know Dr. Park wanted to go I'll go as well. Oh, no, please don't. It's okay. Why don't you two go together?

146Okay. So Jack and Brian, is that? Shawnee, if you want to go, you could go too. It's not. No, you can. It's fine. Yeah. It's fine. Since you already went to the BOCES, is that fine? Okay. Okay. Do we need a motion for this? No. No? Does it? Do we need to have a motion for this? You can take a motion. I don't think that you need to. Okay, so let's just move on. Okay, so we're going to move to discussion items. The new athletic proposals, Dr. Arges, can you just give us a quick update on that? Sure. Several years ago, the board was approached by a number of students who were interested in starting a fencing team and a gymnastics team. Thank you. The board did agree to start those teams, and they've enjoyed

147a lot of success since. We've since been approached more recently by a group of young ladies who would like to see a flag football team started in the district, and they are all staticky tonight. So they're interested in having the board consider that proposal. We would also have, for your consideration, challenger basketball and unified basketball. Unified basketball is a Special Olympics-affiliated sport that pairs up. typically developing students with atypically developing students for basketball experience and Challenger basketball is a middle school basketball opportunity again for atypically developing students to be able to have even more robust support but be able to participate in athletics. Lynn? I'm actually kind of excited about... some of these but I did what I wanted to ask a question specifically about challenge the challenger program I don't know if we would

148bet or if the children would benefit from combining with other school districts for social and body count and things like that more people to participate and even if it would allow us to also share cost it could be a benefit too but just something to think about So I'll ask Ms. Goldthwait to respond to that. She's been doing some research on that program. Yeah, how are you? So for the Challenger program, we can reach out. Working with Mr. Stuber, we're really trying to determine first what's the interest level and then how can we try and make sure we're facilitating this so as many of our students as possible can participate in either the Challenger and Unified. Unified has some more regulations that are associated with it than the Challenger program does, so we could definitely

149seek out first what our current interest would look like to see if it would require us to partner with a local district. does hold the program as well. Part of the challenge is not all school districts run these programs for students, so we'd have to really try and make sure it's one that's local to us and that also needs to have the support of an increase. My hope is we don't need to because we'll have enough of our own students. However, if we do need to seek that out, we always can reach out to some of the local districts that do have current programs running or are interested in starting a program. Thank you, Aaron, and I just want to add on all three of these flag football United basketball and challenger This is again.

150We are a diverse district. We want to have opportunities for everyone at the district That's one of the reasons that we thought this was important to bring up Anybody else I'm excited Lynn. Also, I think this is great Please Susan So I'm super excited about it. I think any opportunity we have to provide these kind of opportunities to all of our students, we should take advantage of. So I think it sounds like a wonderful, wonderful program. My question, and I also think that it provides... not only a wonderful opportunity for these kids who otherwise wouldn't get to take part in sports programs to have this opportunity, but I also think it has the potential to be wonderful to have the mentors and exposure of other kids and to form connections and relationships that otherwise maybe

151they wouldn't have interacted because they wouldn't have had any reason for their paths to cross. So I was just curious about how you know, those kids are selected to take part in the program, the ones to be mentors. And if it's a volunteer basis, if it's kids, if it's going to be for the athletes, if, you know, whatever way. I guess I'll jump in a quick again. That's okay. So the unified program does have some specific rules. So one such rule is that you cannot be a varsity basketball player and be on the same court with the students. However, I was a part of helping initiate this and get this running in a previous district, and we were able to ensure that any student who volunteered in some capacity, whether they were on the court

152with the students or on the sidelines with students, any volunteer, we would absolutely want to try and support that. It is something that both Mr. Stupor and I will have to work through in the... sense of making sure we have an opportunity to have as many students as possible want to participate, whether that means they rotate in into different games, because there is a limited number of games within the season itself. And then ensuring that we have appropriate training and opportunities, because the goal of the program is to really make sure that we're having students come together in an interactive offering where they're learning training to gain friendship and understanding. the more students that we could try and have be supportive of the program in different ways, the better it would be for all of

153our students who would be involved, whether that be cheering on the sidelines, wearing T-shirts, celebrating at the actual game itself, finding an opportunity to kind of pack the stands so we have a lot of people participating and enjoying the activity. I think there's lots of ways that we could try and get our students to play a role in the entire process. Thank you. I really appreciate this. We need to work more on inclusivity, and this is an amazing example of bringing children, students of different backgrounds, bringing them together and working together. So I really want to thank you for this initiative. I have a question about... The logistic though, I understand that we are short in space in basketball. Is this possible because of different season? Do we have space for this to happen? Yeah,

154it's a great question because we are terribly tight in the winter season when most of the sports are indoors But the Challenger basketball and unified will be in the spring season when a lot of the sports come back outdoors and the regular indoor volleyball basketball wrestling fencing Gymnastics season is over So we'll have space for that. With flag football, the challenge will be finding grass space. So it is a somewhat smaller field than a regulation football field, a regulation boys football field. So we're anticipating talking to the town perhaps about going to Stilwell, which has the convenience of being nearby. The district does own a property on Montfort and Schoolhouse. that is used as a couple of little league fields, but it's just barely big enough to host flag football. So that could be a

155location. And then obviously we have the fields behind here, but we have middle school boys and girls lacrosse, plus high school boys and girls lacrosse, JV, JV2, varsity. So there's a lot of demand for these fields. And then we have baseball out there as well that uses up some of the field space. So it's very tight in the spring outdoors, but it's... There's more room indoors in the spring. Thank you. I actually had the same question as Shawnee, but it was regarding the flag football. So you just answered the question about our space constraints. So thank you. I just want to point out that for the flag football proposal that a few of the high school girls had actually approached you. I'm under the impression they approached. the district administration about having a team. I

156just want to say for our students to come forward and ask for something like this, I think is commendable in itself. So I just wanted to say that I'm very proud of our girls for taking the initiative to come forward for something that they want. So I don't have any other questions. I'm good with it. Thank you. Anyone else? Okay. Okay, so we're going to move on to... I haven't heard any... elements of concern from the board so our intention is to move forward with all three of these and I think you'll make a number of our young people very happy with that result so thank you for that okay our next discussion item is senior citizens and persons with disability and limited income tax exemption Dr. Rogers do you want to give a quick

157or Dr. Ruffo somebody give a quick update Yes, Dr. Ruffo summarized it before the audience to the public on the hearing. There is a New York State real property tax law that allows for a tax exemption. What that tax exemption does is it exempts part of the value of the property for low-income seniors or for disabled persons. The cost of that exemption is then socialized over the rest of the taxpayers in the district, as Dr. Ruffo... said the number of people taking the senior citizens exemption right now is known it's 90 and the number taking the disabled exemption is also known six so the What is not as easy to calculate is how many people would be affected by raising the income limits from 38,400 to 58,400. We did some back of the envelope calculations

158using publicly available data. The county doesn't have data that's available in a format that lends itself to this kind of analysis. But we think that... Our rough estimates are it's going to be on the order of a 50% increase in the number of people eligible. So you'd go from 90 to perhaps 150 eligible with the new limits. And the decision for the board tonight is whether you want to do it for this coming tax year. If so, we need to notify the county by January 2nd. If you decide to continue deliberating or take this decision up next year, then you have a year to think about it before you'd have to notify the county. Thank you, Dr. Rogers. So I'd just like to kick it off. And this is a CPI adjustment. I would like

159our residents, our senior residents, to be able to stay here, the grandparents, the people who have supported the school, the people who have invested in our future, which has been successful. Anybody who's also served, I think, is very important for the community to support them. And the fact that we have this opportunity, I think, is a great thing for us to help our community. So if anybody else wants to chime in, please do. Brian? I just want to make sure I understand two things. The last time this was updated, that this district approved, was 2007, and they had set it for, what, three years? So in 2010 was the last time there was an increase to this limit. And before you answer, let me ask my second question. I want to make sure I understand

160that I was looking through the law, and it talks about how if there's a child that's a... a student in the district they're not entitled to the exception that's one of they try understand that one correctly as well so I'll answer the easy question which is yes 2007 and it was phased in over three years and then the child in the district dr. Rufo are you a little more familiar with that yes that that is correct that they it's not eligible so I recognize the difficulty in generating estimates either of the cost or the number of people that are potentially going to be eligible if we were to wait a year would we have any more information about the number of people who would be eligible does in other words does waiting another year give

161us any incremental in for information that we wouldn't have by acting today in other words our estimates gonna get any better I think the short answer to that question is yes. So we're able to calculate precisely what the impact, the number of people who are eligible. what zip code they're in what percentage of their property is exempted under the current exemption the county has that the county has already adopted the raised limits so the county for its part of the taxes will have to figure out who is eligible and who takes advantage of it so we would then be able to wait a year and see who is newly eligible for the county's exemption with the new income limits and then see of that group who lives in Syosset and we would be able to

162calculate this I think with a great degree of precision. Anyone else? You have more questions? I mean more of a concern that knowing that we would have perfect information in a year and having to make a decision in the absence of what I would describe as even a pretty good estimate concerns me somewhat. In principle, right, from my point of view of how we would make decisions, I would have thought that we would have had a reasonable basis for making a prediction a year from now, but given that we would have a perfect basis for making a prediction, I'm not really sure. Why we're not incentivized or why we wouldn't want to wait until we actually had that perfect prediction I mean there is there a reasonable probability that our estimate is going to be

163off by several orders of magnitude I mean if we think it's 150 could it be 700 people could it be a thousand people I? Think it's unlikely to be a thousand people because there are 11,000 households in the district so to qualify for this you have to have both age you have to live outside of a retirement community that doesn't have some sort of fixed property tax arrangement already in place and there are three I think very sizable such communities and and si asset that I believe would be exempted for that reason so you'd have to be living as a private homeowner and you'd have to be Still having annual income of under fifty eight thousand dollars a year So I don't think that our estimates are going to be off by an order of

164magnitude I think what is impossible to estimate is what is the value of the house that is being exempted? So we have the average value of the households the assessed valuation of the households currently taking advantage of the exemption, and we've used that as the estimate to trend forward. There's, I guess, no reason to think that just $20,000 worth of income would create a doubling of the value of a household. It's not enough to pay for an appreciable difference in a mortgage, so that approximation seems to me to be defensible. The numbers overall of eligible people also seem to be defensible, at least in terms of their order of magnitude. Right, and that's just projecting the current steady state of income distribution forward. In other words, if you shock income distribution, right, if incomes change

165meaningfully without house prices changing meaningfully, then in principle the pool of people changes significantly. Well, I think it's safe to say that the pool of people is likely smaller now than it was in 2010 when the when 38,400 was the maximum. So 12 years have passed and that 38,400 hasn't adjusted. So presuming that. Incomes have inflated over that period. Fewer and fewer people have become eligible. So this might return us to the same number or magnitude of people that were eligible back in 2010 when Syasset last phased in its income adjustment. And I'm wondering, I mean, Jack's talking about waiting a year, and I think we have a deadline to opt in by January 3rd. Is that a January 2nd? Is that a deadline to opt in or a deadline to tell the county that

166we intend to opt in? Like, is there a way that we could buy a few more months to do the analysis he's talking about, or are we literally two and a half weeks away from making this decision? You are literally two and a half weeks away. The January 2nd date is not adjustable, and the information that we will get will only occur after people have paid their Nassau County taxes for the coming year. So what we would do is our tax year would run... If you were to delay a year, we would run our tax year as we have run last year, and then we would wait and see what happens with the county's taxes, and then after the county has taken their taxes in, we would ask them for their tax rolls so that

167we could examine them to see who took advantage of the exemption in paying their county taxes. But we won't know that until they actually use the exemption. Is everybody good? Any more questions? Okay. The next discussion item is the use of the Native American team name and mascot. So I'll start and give my own personal experience. English was not my first language. I think we have people on the board who English was not their first language. And I played sports. I played Little League. I played football. I played college football. there were a lot of derogatory names that were addressed to me um and it's offensive so um at our school you know we pride ourselves on diversity um we teach empathy we teach a safe space for everyone um i think we need to

168lead like we lead in every other category and My opinion this is something that should have been addressed a long time ago And I open it up to any other board members Lynn In terms of costs which was brought up I had seen that Certain districts have sent letters to the state requesting that they help fund the changes Would we as a board be able to consider? Sending such a letter to the state asking them to help fund changes and I also saw Someone brought up brave versus Braves and being siacid brave and then Using that figuring out a mascot and it didn't take away so much from being Once a brave, but I guess you would have to change that also I guess they've just felt like it was an easier transition from they

169always felt connected to the word brave and I know that Braves obviously falls under the category and we I think we do need to change and grow and Not continue with what we have always accepted but I do think that we There's a way to honor si acid and who we are that we should keep that into consideration. Dr. Rogers can you give us a little bit of a back history just to refresh everybody's memory? Sure, I'd be happy to so I've been here eight and a half years and When I first arrived in si acid on the side of the football field there was a A student who was dressed in a bear costume, and the bear costume had what I believe would be characterized as a Plains Indian war bonnet, but certainly not

170authentic. And that mascot was nicknamed the Brave Cat. And the Brave Cat was retired that year by the students. The student government president at the time had been in conversation with the Shinnecock nation and had been talking about wanting to remove the Plains Indian headdress and come up with something that was more authentic and more representative. And while the initial conversations with the Shinnecock were somewhat encouraging, uh when more of the shinnecock became involved in that conversation they removed their support for the project and that was sort of the end of the those conversations i delved into the history here when i arrived and when that was going on to try and understand better What had transpired in Syosset what I needed to know about our history and I learned that in 2001 after Commissioner

171then Commissioner Mills first memo came out that there had been an effort a fairly sustained effort here in Syosset to change the mascot Committee had been formed that committee had first Considered the question of whether or not to have the mascots my understanding that they had a member of the Shinnecock common speak to that committee to talk to the committee about uh how the shinnecock felt about that representation and whether they felt they were honored by it or not my understanding is that was pretty powerful presentation and the committee eventually recommended to the board that the board retire the mascot the board did vote to retire the mascot at that time in 2000 i think two and then um the The district held a contest to choose a new mascot. There were dozens and dozens

172of names offered. They narrowed the list of names down to a handful. They held votes among the students to choose from those names, and the name that was ultimately selected was Red Hawks. and uh... contest was held and uh... middle school student one and uh... displayed had came up with us and student artwork that was uh... a red hawk and the district went so far as to change the mascot even paint the red hawk on the wall of the high school gym It's not clear to me what the timeline was from there the district's records aren't that great but sometime within the next four to six months the district reversed its decision and painted over the Redhawk that was on the side of the the gym wall and reverted back to the Braves as a

173mascot so and thus it's been ever since the district has stopped buying clothing or logos that have imagery on it we confine ourselves to the name braves although there are lots of places in the district where in addition to the word braves the logo still persists so there would be of course a cost associated with changing things like scoreboards, the end zone of the field, some padding in the gym, some padding on the field, and there's branding on the weights in the weight room and some legacy uniforms, although the uniforms are largely phased out at this point, but not entirely. So some school districts have asked the state for additional funding. I don't know if the state will be sympathetic to those kinds of requests. But I'm trying to think of their, oh, the one

174other milestone I should mention is that this did come before the Board of Education in the summer of 2020. A motion was made to retire the mascot. The motion did not pass at that time. And that's the last major milestone event that I can think of off the top of my head. Thank you, Dr. Rogers. Anybody else like to speak? I'll go. So before I proceed, my question to Dr. Rogers is considering the language of the regulation that finally came late Friday night. And I'm assuming they talk about not just imagery but names as well. Is that correct? And they have a list of remaining districts that still have. The names in use, is that correct? So do we have, are we past the point of any potential debate in the community? Because we all

175know what we saw as a sample today. This is a small sample of what the community at large would look like if we fill this room. They'll be split in half. As someone who was there. Two years ago as someone who took part in that vote At the time obviously it was in our hands and Up to nine of us none of us were there in 1959 When the name was adopted I'm not sure how the history before 1959 how they derived that name came to that name but So now in a way, the state made it easier for us because it's not up to us to discuss the matter. But at the same time, to echo Lynn's comment, I mean, we effectively would be doing away with a 50-year-old tradition and the connection to

176the name that so many athletes competed under and I have no doubt that they had only positive association with that name. They were proud to be a Brave. So I guess my question is, I mean, you mentioned that the only, I guess I'm trying to come up with a compromise where, I mean, obviously we are not using the mascot. ANY MORE OFFICIALLY, THROUGH THE DISTRICT ANYWAY, THROUGH THE PURCHASES, OFFICIAL PURCHASES, BUT THE BOOSTER CLUBS OBVIOUSLY, YOU KNOW, MAKE A DECISION ON A LOGO AND DESIGN OF THE JERSEYS AND UNIFORMS THEMSELVES. CAN WE, DO WE HAVE A PATH TO... save the name or we pass that and we would need to obtain the written permission, in which case I would absolutely like to reach out to, once again, to the very people that we're talking about,

177like Adam's daughter. Maybe she would like to come. I mean, I'm just trying to, I find it extremely, it's difficult because the community is just... I don't know, I know, but once the public is over, just the procedure. So again, you know, if we pass the point of any chance for a debate, the name has to go, then it's one scenario. But if that door is this open this much, I would like to peek and see and reach out to the local tribes and maybe have a representative come and speak to us, speak to the community. IS THAT AN OPTION? I MEAN, IF, AGAIN, IF WE PASS THE DEBATE PORTION OF IT AND HAVE TO VOTE BY JUNE 30th, WHAT HAS TO HAPPEN BETWEEN NOW AND JUNE 30th? A COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT? WHAT ARE WE TALKING

178ABOUT? ARE WE TALKING ABOUT... I CERTAINLY HOPE WE ARE NOT TALKING ABOUT A 12-PEOPLE COMMITTEE ON SOMETHING LIKE THIS BECAUSE WE ALL KNOW WHAT HAPPENED. I MEAN, THERE WAS A REASON WHY IT WAS REVERSED Back to the briefs. What is it? 2000 whatever it is that you were talking about 2003 what made that change? What was the What prompted that change back? Why did they reverse? Because I'm sorry Yeah, I can't find anything in the record-keeping of the district that explains why the district reversed its decision Obviously if you talk to people who have been here for a long time they have their hypotheses and speculation I prefer not to speculate in public What I would say Quick tour through the state administrative procedures act so When state agencies adopt regulations those regulations do have

179the force of law But in order to adopt a regulation, they have to go through what's called the State Administrative Procedures Act, and that specifies how they do things. So there are two kinds of regulations. There are emergency regulations and ordinary regulations. Emergency regulations are emergencies. They can be adopted immediately. This is not an emergency regulation. This is a regulation that will be adopted through the regular order. The regulation was promulgated on Friday as part of the Board of Regents agenda for Monday in the same way that we put our agendas out on Friday for the board meeting on Monday. The regents met today. I don't know what the outcome of the regents meeting was, but I would assume I'm quite confident that they moved this regulation forward. What they will do is at a

180subsequent meeting, I believe the February meeting, they will adopt this regulation as a final regulation. So it's like first reading, second reading like we do with policies. So they're moving the regulation forward at today's meeting. They'll probably adopt it at the February meeting. I believe it becomes final and effective on May 3rd. So what the regulation requires of us... only an affirmative vote of the Board of Education to retire the Native American mascot and logo and any name associated with it it does not require a place name to be changed so for example my understanding is sachem is a place name that is associated with Native American heritage but they would not be required to change the name of the district just the Native American logo or mascot. That's in the regulation as well. It

181doesn't apply here. So anyway, it would become effective on May 3rd, and then it requires the board to act no later than June 30th. You can certainly act in advance of it becoming final, but that's how the State Administrative Procedures Act works. It's final. The regents could amend their regulation between now and then, but that is atypical in their process. They typically will finalize the regulations and then let them age on the agenda and then adopt them finally. Brian? Just so I understand, Dr. Rogers, so we have to commit by June 30th. Correct. And then there's two years after that. So Lynn's comments about potentially sending a letter to see if the state will reimburse it could happen after that time. Her comment about using the name Brave instead of Braves could be decided after

182that time. Any committee can be formed after that. And his comment as well about potentially seeking a tribe's written approval, that all could happen after. So all we're being asked to do by the state right now is wait until they approve this, have their reg go final, and then we'll have a month and a half to resolve that we hereby commit to. change this name within the next two years. Is that how this reads? I'm looking for the reg because I did bring it with me. And I think the one, here it is, the one change I would make to what you said is I believe that if you're going to have approval from a recognized tribe, that it has to be pretty much immediate. Hang on a second. This part shall not apply where

183a written agreement exists prior to the effective date of this part between a federally recognized tribal nation within the state of New York or a New York State recognized tribal nation in a public school permitting the use of an indigenous name mascot or logo that is culturally affiliated with such tribe a Public school shall not offer or accept any money consideration or thing of value pursuant to any such agreement So it says This has to be prior to the effective date of this part. So I interpret that as being that May 3rd date when I believe this would become effective under the SAPA. So you would have some time to pursue that line of inquiry if the board was inclined to do that. If we do go through the tribal approval and the tribe changes

184their mind later on, then what happens? that is also in the same paragraph it says the tribal nation shall have the right and ability to revoke any such agreement at any time upon termination of such an agreement the public school shall have the remainder of the school year in which the agreement is revoked and one additional school year to discontinue its use of the indigenous name logo or mascot anyone else so I just have a procedure so okay it's the procedural question which is Is it possible for the, and it's two parts, right? Is it possible for us to work on a dual track of potentially seeking approval and or working, developing a working group to potentially come up with an alternative? And more importantly, I guess, from my point of view. Who is responsible

185for trying to seek permission? Is it the district or the school board or is it anyone in the community who's trying? Who is authorized to try and seek that approval? Does it have to be the district or the school board? It says a written agreement exists. The part shall not apply where a written agreement exists between a federally recognized tribal nation and a public school. So you would not be able to have an agent represent you in that it would be a an agreement between the school and said tribe so it would have to be representatives of the school that would approach the tribe and I think you would want I would want if I was representing you to know that it was the will of the board that we pursue that in order to

186know what my conversation with the tribe needed to sound like? So I've been thinking a lot about this because I always try to make everybody happy. And I have a blessing and a curse. And so by nature, I hate for anybody to ever feel not included or hurt by something that we're doing or that they see. So the idea that there's students or children or groups that would feel offended or insulted or excluded by our name or a logo, I find very upsetting. And then on the other hand, I do have a deep respect for tradition. So I was playing with the idea of What we could do to keep the name brave and so if we did something like home of the brave and took away any American Indian aspect to it and made

187it first responders and made it honoring Home of the Brave and you could honor, you know, we could have a contest or honor whoever we wanted, police, military, teachers, doctors, you know, whoever we wanted to, heroes, and we wanted to honor the heroes with the name Home of the Brave and remove any connection to the American Indian. as a compromise to keeping the name but being respectful of... Huh? So, listen, it was just a thought. I was playing with a way to, you know, come up with a compromise. Would that be something that the state would even accept? I can't speak for what the state will or won't accept. I know that... They've been pretty declaratory in the conversations that they've had there is a superintendent's association so, you know, I used to run it

188and they've had some conversations with department staff about this and my Gut is that the department will? look for Clear breaks as opposed to parsing When they're evaluating whether districts are in compliance with this regulation Shawnee Seems like it's put our decision is going to be pretty limited. It seems like we have to be very practical There's a lot of emotion and attach emotional attachment involved with history and but then there is that aspect of Hurting a whole group of people. They don't want to be seen as a mascot But practically speaking we are talking about a lot of money $25 million that we get from state aid that we can't produce through. It will be unfair for our residents to pay that. We don't want to depend on maybe a change in the later,

189right? If we seek the approval from an Indian tribe and then they change their mind later, then we have to go through that again. That doesn't seem like a sound decision that we need to make. But at the same time, of course, it's very hard to make changes, change the tradition. But 10 years from now. students who will be involved in creating new mascot, making new history now, will look back this moment and they will be taking a part of a big event and that's a learning experience for our current students and 10 years from now they will look back and start their own tradition. So I don't see this as all bad. Yes, there is change. Change is always hard. But I think we will be able to start a new tradition from this

190point on. So I don't see this as a negative event. Sorry. I agree. I think that there's... lots of good to be had in the changes that can be coming and getting students involved and creativity and things like that. There's so much to this. There's so many feelings to this that every and everybody's feelings are valid, but it is a it is a really it could be an incredible experience to get the students involved in creating something that they came up with and can embrace and take forward. Anyone else? Dr. Rogers, can you come back to us with a plan? So I can certainly outline for you what a process would look like for staying in compliance with the law. My obligation is to always guide you how to stay in compliance with the law.

191I can certainly outline what I think a process of engagement with tribes might look like for your consideration and then you know I would seek your direction on how you wanted me to move with that plan so I can certainly make that outline for you and then await your direction on how you want me to proceed okay thank you anyone else yeah I mean I sort of asked this question before but is there a reason why we can't progress on both tracks simultaneously yeah and Obviously with the directive, there's not a lot of daylight here. So I think we need to definitely go on at least a dual track where we need to at least set up a committee to. Dr. Rogers, I just want to, I know you're taking notes, so I want to

192give you a second. I just want to make sure I understand. The only thing that would be pressing would be the possibility of. levitan's concept of reaching out to a tribe right the new name setting up committees getting students involved to come up with the new name that's all after june 30th correct well there's nothing that prevents you from starting it immediately right so just rehearsing the three deadlines that I see. The deadline for some sort of tribal approval appears to me to be March 3rd. Is that what I said before? Or May 3rd? May 3rd. It's late. So I would want to confirm that with somebody at the State Ed Department to make sure I'm reading the reg correctly. The second deadline would be June 30th, by which date you must adopt a resolution

193of the board retiring the mascot or risk being out of compliance. And then the third is two years hence. when all the imagery has to be gone. There's nothing that says you have to have a mascot of any kind to replace it, but all it says is that the current logo and imagery and name must be gone. So you could start a committee and have students involved as early as immediate or as late as 2025. The Indian tribe has to have the braves as their symbol, right? You can't just reach out to any. I believe what the regulation said was it's a recognized tribe in New York State, and it says permitting the use of an indigenous name, mascot, or logo that is culturally affiliated with such tribe. So I'll confess that my understanding of

194Native American culture is limited in so much as I don't know if the term brave is applicable to the tribes that were. originally resident in New York or not, or if that's a term that's more consistent with Plains Indians or Southwest. So I would want to educate myself on that as a starter. Sorry, I know I kind of pushed us down this track and I just want to clarify something. So if we reach out to multiple groups and you get hung up on and told something swear word-ish, like nine times out of ten that I think before we start pushing forward with the tenth I think we should all know that so you see my point so that if you reach out to groups and you're consistently getting hung up on I don't think we're

195just running in one direction to find somebody who will sign off on this like that's important information at least for me to enough to find out So the National Congress of American Indians, which is the largest, my understanding is the largest recognized group representing Native Americans, has been pretty firm and pretty aggressive in their campaign to eliminate the use of mascots. I see them as an umbrella group. Obviously, there are different tribes. I've been reading some of the news clippings from around the state. The city of Salamanca in Allegheny County, western New York is on an Indian reservation and about, I believe, between a quarter and a third of the students on the campus are Native American and so they have a somewhat different relationship with the name and the imagery there. But I don't

196sense that there's going to be from the public statements that I've read from a number of tribes in New York that there's going to be a lot of receptivity to the conversation. So I think I can tell you that up front. Certainly the place to start would be the ones, the tribes, the recognized tribes who are here on Long Island since we're here on Long Island. both the Montauk Indians, Native Americans, and the Shinnecock have been quoted in Newsday since this memo came out from the State Education Department saying things that are praising the department for taking this stance and suggesting to me that they would be unsympathetic to someone who approached them with this line of inquiry. Do you think they would be sympathetic to a compromise solution where we do away with the

197imagery, the logo, and keep the brave, figuratively speaking? On what grounds would they object the adjective brave? I'm struggling with that since we all sing the national anthem, you know, rightfully mentioned. Would that would they be open to that at all you feel or well? We don't know we could speculate all night, but you know Right, I think if we're going The point of the regulation is if you're going to keep something that references Native American heritage in any way, then you have to have permission from a recognized tribe. The second question you're asking is if we parse the word Braves into Brave, will the State Education Department say that we've abandoned a Native American mascot or will they regard it in a different way? I don't know the answer to that question. I can

198certainly pursue it. Just as a question, would the board want to hear if we could get a representative from one of the accredited local tribes to come and speak? Do you think that that's a possibility? Because I think we're making a decision. We don't really have a decision to make. The decision has kind of been made for us in a sense, but the only light at the end of the tunnel that we have, if we wanted to try to keep the name, would obviously be through one of the accredited tribes. So I think, and just in my opinion, I don't know how the rest of the board feels, but if we had a representative that would be willing to maybe speak with us. TO EXPLAIN TO US SO WE CAN UNDERSTAND IT BETTER FROM THEIR

199PERSPECTIVE AND MIGHT HELP US TO BE ABLE TO ADDRESS THE COMMUNITY AND MOVE FORWARD BECAUSE I'M NOT SURE HOW THE BOARD FEELS ABOUT POSSIBLY FINDING OUT IF SOMEBODY WOULD COME AND SPEAK TO US. I MEAN, FROM MY POINT OF VIEW, I THINK IF FOLKS AREN'T RECEPTIVE TO OUR PHONE CALLS AND REACH OUT, THEN... I mean, that's more of education for us and for the neighborhood. I'm not sure that really plays into our need to enact this policy, right? Like, ultimately, it's kind of a one-decision variable, right? Like, folks say no, that's kind of it, right? My personal opinion about this issue is complicated, so I think this issue is complicated, so... ultimately write whatever we think isn't at issue. It's what other folks think. So when they say, when they answer no or yes or

200whatever they say, then what we think is largely irrelevant. So asking someone to then come to explain to us why they don't, I think, is a luxury and less of a necessary policy step. Hi, I agree with Jack. You know, it's for our educational purposes, but it's not necessarily changing the decision that we ultimately have to make because I feel like, you know, this was brought up in summer of 2020, and then that was the meeting that I wasn't here, actually. I was not present here. I did it virtually. I did it virtually, and it was very hard. It was in and out, in and out. But at that time, the state didn't give us a mandate, so we were having all different kinds of lively discussions. But now the state is already telling us

201very clearly what we have to do, and we can seek other ways to... challenge the state if you want to call it, but I don't know eventually if we have that choice or not because we're talking about a lot of money that we might be losing. We're a public school, we're not a private school. And I'm definitely certainly open to having them coming here to give us a lesson, to tell us, you know, that's what we were talking about, getting that diversity training. That's part of the diversity training too, but I don't know if that's going to change the ultimate decision the board makes. Now, the only reason why I was saying that was I didn't think that was going to change the decision, but I just think that for people to understand, because we're

202nine of thousands of community members, and to be able to hear from somebody who is a representative from a group would not only help us to understand it, because we may have questions not to change anything, but maybe for community members as well to just understand. what they're feeling is because no matter what decision is made, half, I don't want to use the word half, but there's going to be community members that are going to be upset. If we take a look at the demographics just from this evening, we have like a 50-50 here. So 50% of the community, no matter which way it goes, is going to be upset about it. So my suggestion to just have, if we could get somebody to come and speak, would just be helpful because knowledge is... is

203always helpful but the end result is like everybody has said tonight everybody made really good points there's a lot more than just do we want the name or not there's a lot more behind it than that it's really the decision has been made it's what steps we're taking at this point that's the impression that i'm under the state has already come down and made the mandate so now we're in a predicament where we need to figure out what where to go from here Yes, Lisa, the decision pretty much, I mean, I read the language and it said that there were severe consequences if we didn't follow the law. But in addition to that, as I said earlier, if we preach inclusivity and we preach diversity and we preach a welcoming... atmosphere in a safe atmosphere

204at our school and people move to the neighborhood to be in a diverse that's why I moved here so I believe we have a higher calling because I don't think anybody here would want to be discriminated against and words have meanings words have powers that's how things start so I think we need to move forward with what the right thing to do is and what the law is, that's my suggestion from the board. I remember receiving a video of a presentation from an American Indian person presenting why it was hurtful in the board email. So I think we don't have to wait until we invite someone. We can just Google it right now and we can listen to it. We have it. And so many people have stated why it's hurtful. So we could listen

205to it right now if we wanted to educate people. Dr. Rogers, I remember there was a student petition that was brought. Could you just refresh our memory on what the student petition was? Yes, so I'm gonna get the date wrong off the top of my head, but let's say six years ago some students had the idea for student spirit exercise and the idea that they wanted to pursue was to paint as large as possible the brave head logo in the faculty parking lot at the high school So some students were enthusiastic about that idea and thought it would increase school spirit. Other students thought that it was a bad idea and that it was disrespectful to have cars driving over that image. So the student government held a debate among the students. I attended. The

206student government president did a remarkable job of managing that conversation. Students were respectful. They disagreed with one another and had a conversation that sounds not unlike the conversation that the audience had and that you're now having tonight. And in the end, the student government... decided not to move ahead with the proposal to do the painting in the parking lot, but to pick other ways of promoting school spirit. So there was a lot of student engagement around that at the time, and it was reported in Newsday, and that was the end of it. Is that the event you were at? Oh, sorry. No, I'm recalling, and correct me if I'm wrong, that there was... A petition to remove wasn't there a student petition asking to remove the mascot was there not? There was a change.org petition

207and again I'm sketchy on the date but certainly pre-pandemic I don't recall how many signatures it got it wasn't presented to us that I recall but I was aware of the fact that there was a change.org petition. Anyone else? I just want to Go back to the since we're discussing today, correct? There's no vote. There's no resolution today tonight So again, I would love to reach out to a local rigid allowed Forgot the word they used the local tribe number one and number two We need to really carefully figure out the committee, formation of that committee, what does it look like? I certainly hope it's not going to be limited to student government. It should be absolutely open to the community, to the Braves alumni, going back years. I remember receiving in 2020 quite a

208few, I don't know the exact number, quite a few letters from the alumni and they were heartfelt. And I truly believe that those members of the community should participate in the process and anyone's input should be welcome because otherwise we're running a risk of having a one-sided 12 people. committee that is going to make such a massive decision. You know, it should be everyone's decision, honestly. You know, I mean, we're sitting in this room and none of us are of that descent, right, Native Americans. So therefore, at the very least, we should hear from them, from a Native American representative, in my opinion, and to ensure that a much broader Community participation is ensured. We owe it to this community. We need to also be open because American Indians have spoken. What we are trying

209to do is find the tribe that will allow us, not listening to the whole tribe. Because they have made statements over and over, and Dr. Rogers said it, they made movies about it. And so there is already an official statement from that group, but we are trying to find the one tribe who will allow us. That's what we are trying to do, but I don't know if that is the right path. for us to take. Except no one ran by them the option of the word brave. That's the part we have to consult with them about. That would be doing due diligence when you do away with a 50-year-old tradition of a name. Well, if you, so when I suggested using the word brave, it was separating it completely from any connection to the American

210Indian heritage. It wasn't, so in which case you wouldn't need permission because it wouldn't be representative of or connected to any American Indian heritage or. You know, it would be a whole separate name and a whole separate thing, but you wouldn't need permission in that circumstance because it would be separate. It wouldn't be trying to keep the name in the American Indian context. It would be separating it completely. So it sounded like Dr. Rod. Which may upset everybody on every side. Mine was the same way when I said Braves to Brave. I meant we changed the whole connotation of being a Syosset Brave and figure out a new mascot to go with that and change the meaning behind it without changing, I guess, what people kind of relate to as Syosset. I guess changing the

211meaning and changing what Syosset Brave means, but staying Syosset Brave. Sorry, wait, Tom. So it sounds like actually, Dr. Rogers, maybe we need to try track, which is it sounds like there's an attempted consensus around the idea of brave. And it sounded like what you were saying was, is New York State's going to potentially not recognize that as a legitimate effort. Maybe someone maybe in the bowels of New York State in your Rolodex is still good that you could run that idea. through the third track up there to say, I mean, because it sounded like your first piece of feedback was, yeah, that's not going to work, folks, but I don't know, maybe that's another phone call worth making. I'm just keeping track of the list of work you've given me. So I had on

212my list, talk to someone at SCD to see how they would regard the parsing of brave versus braves. Talk to someone at SCD to confirm the May 3rd date as being the last date possible to execute an agreement with a tribe. Waiting to hear you come to consensus on... how you want to proceed, whether you want to go down multiple tracks simultaneously or pick one track with the other. So that's sort of open. And I don't have any other points of clarification that I've collected along the way, but those two so far. So it sounds like we would like to go down this dual track, or you're saying this triple track? Is that what I'm hearing? No, but I'm just saying, can I get a consensus of should we go down this dual track? Do

213I have consensus on that? Two or three, I mean. I mean, it's phone calls. Guys, you want to explore? So Jack's suggestion was to. reach out to recognize Native American tribes to see if there would be any sympathy for entering into an agreement with us. At the same time, we proceed as though we will be unsuccessful there so that we don't lose time. So it would be pursuing both simultaneously, preparing whatever the committee process would look like for transitioning away from the current logo and mascot and name, while still reaching out to recognize tribes simultaneously to see what their feeling is. So that, I believe, Jack, is a good... Until we got to the end where it sounded like the only consensus that was emerging on the board was around the word brave, and your

214first diagnosis was state ed was going to poop on that, but maybe they won't if you reframe it around the idea that it's not native and it's something different. So that was, like, sitting here, that sounded like the only real consensus that was coming out of the discussion. It sounds like it's just a dual track of what we need to do and if we can repurpose brave. Do we have consensus on that? Sorry, so what does that mean, what we need to do? It seems like the two tracks are what we need to do, because this is what we're being directed to do, plus if we can repurpose the name brave. That seems to be the only consensus that I see here. Yes? No? Maybe? Yes, and the way the repurposing is executed by whom?

215Meaning, you know, who is in a committee? Is it going to be a wide community contest? Are those two tracks applicable? No, just those two, BRAVE and what we are being directed to do. Yes? So, just to see if that would... if repurposing BRAVE would honor what the state's regulations are. Lynn, do you have a question? Okay. Okay. So can we move? So can we, again, are we not pursuing then a local, the written permission possibility since it's the only door that is open? No, I don't think we have consensus on that. No, we don't have consensus on that. Yeah, so those are the only two things at this point. Yeah. No, we don't have consensus on that Okay, exactly Dr. Rogers is gonna come back some answers us. Yes January dr. Rogers will come

216back with some questions hopefully Okay The doctor Rogers the when you read your list of to do items and things you were gonna you're gonna still do all that to get his answers to whether that May 3rd date is really Okay, so there's no unfinished business the following is new business A1 items a one is the approval of staff changes. Can I please have a motion? Shawnee seconded by Carol. Does anybody have any questions all in favor? opposed and abstentions A2 is the approval of the 2022 2023 stipend and hourly rates. Can I have a motion please? Lisa seconded by Susan Does anybody have any questions all in favor? Opposed any abstentions a three is the approval of coaching recommendations for the 2022-2023 Year may have a motion, please Shawnee is seconded by Lynn does

217anybody have any questions all in favor opposed any abstentions? Next we move on to be items be one is the approval of committee on special education recommendations may have a motion, please Lynn seconded by Shawnee. It's a bit have any questions all in favor opposed any abstentions B2 is the approval of committee on preschool special education. Can I have a motion please? Jack seconded by Lisa does anybody have any questions? all in favor Opposed any abstentions b3 is the approval of the school calendar for the 2023 2024 school year. Can I have a motion please? Lisa seconded by Susan does anybody have any questions all in favor? Opposed any abstentions before the approval of the student club charters? Can I have a motion please then seconded by Shawnee anybody have any questions all in favor?

218opposed any abstentions B-5 is the first reading of the policies, student wellness and nutrition, claims auditors, and expense reimbursements. Can I have a motion, please? Susan, seconded by Anna. Does anybody have any questions? You have a question, Barry? Okay. This will be voted on at the next meeting January 9th 2023 Copies of the proposed policy will be available for inspection on the district's website a b6 is the second reading and adoption of the parent and family engagement policy and various fiscal management policies can I have a motion please Anna seconded by Susan does anybody have any questions all in favor? Opposed any abstentions? Okay, we're gonna move on to the C items C1 is the authorization for service contracts may have a motion please Show any seconded by Brian does anybody have any questions? all

219in favor opposed any abstentions C2 is the authorization for special education and nursing contracts may please have a motion Lisa seconded by Jack does anybody have any questions all in favor? posed any abstentions c3 Is the authorization for contracts for federal Part B funds may please have a motion Lynn seconded by Carol Does anybody have any questions all in favor? opposed any abstentions C4 is the exemption for real property tax for qualified senior citizens may have a motion place Shawnee seconded by Lisa Any questions? All in favor? Opposed? Any abstentions? C5 is the exemption for real property tax for qualified persons with disabilities. May I please have a motion? Lisa, seconded by Anna. Any questions? All in favor? Opposed? Any abstentions? C6. is the acceptance of the order report and corrective action plan for the

220year ending june 30 2022 can i have a motion please uh carol uh seconded by brian does anybody have any questions all in favor opposed any abstentions c7 and c8 can be taken together they are the authorization for construction change directive for the cooper power and lighting at southwoods and at hbt can i have a motion please Lisa, seconded by Anna. Does anybody have any questions? All in favor? Opposed? Any abstentions? C9 is the authorization for the deduct change order for the Milcon Construction Corporation. Can I have a motion, please? Lisa, seconded by Susan. Does anybody have any questions? All in favor? Opposed? Any abstentions? C-10 is the acceptance of the Memorial Park Bench donation. Can I have a motion, please? Lynn, seconded by Shawnee. Does anybody have any questions? All in favor? Any abstentions?

221C-11 is the authorization of the disposal of broken surplus and or obsolete equipment and or books. May I have a motion, please? Lisa, seconded by Susan. Does anybody have any questions? You do, Brian? Okay. Go ahead. You can make it. All in favor? Opposed? Any abstentions? C-12 is the authorization to amend the District 403B retirement plan. May I have a motion, please? Susan, seconded by Anna. Does anybody have any questions? All in favor? Opposed? Any abstentions? I want to wish everybody happy holidays and a happy new year and a motion to adjourn. Thank you, everyone.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.