001okay well I don't see the link I guess technically we don't have to be on the zoom comes so I understand why but like the agenda in one the in another and and majority of them are from Mary so that doesn't help me n it like I wish that she would just like subject yeah awe shirt I love it speak got e good morning good morning morning good morning so glad to see all of you here this morning on this cold cold chill day but the sun is supposed to be out later today so we'll keep our fingers crossed on that before we start our meeting we're going to go ahead and start with a moment of silence and just be thinking about the children of Arkansas and really why we're here today okay thank
002you so much we're going to start I know Mr Oliva has got some really great announcements to make this morning yes so our first recognition is going to be to introduce uh to our board the 2025 Arkansas teacher of the year so I'm going to turn it over to Capri if uh if I may and let her begin the festivities good morning good morning so Capri Salam I'm the Arkansas teacher of the year coordinator and today I have the distinct honor and privilege of uh welcoming and celebrating and introducing a dedicated fourth grade math and science teacher at Chanel Elementary so in the palaski County Special School District she is the 2025 Arkansas teacher of the year and she is a 25-year veteran educator I know she does need even look 25 so how can
003she be teaching for 25 you know but miss Will coxen has made a lasting impact on her students her students consistently rank in the top 3% on state standardized assessments and and her learning through real world problem solving activities is really what engages her students in the classroom and I've actually seen her in action I've watched her teach and I felt like I was fall in love with math all over again which really says something because math is not my strong suit but someone posed a question to her that really stuck with me her best common practices that academic vocabulary that she constantly revisits every single time and she calls it her her version of looping and so I really thought that that that was so special about her to really set the foundation for
004her students so she will begin her Year's service with the state on July first and so you all know that she'll be here on the board as a non- voting member for the next year and my hope as her coordinator is to really see her get into the classrooms and provide professional development to Math teachers all across the state on how they can Implement some of those same best practices she is a native of Dumis and so I had to plug that she's taught both in Arkansas and Louisiana and she has done some some of her course work at that other university in Louisiana and since we're in Arkansas I won't you know mention that right now but it is my pleasure to introduce to you all our 2025 Arkansas teacher of the year G
005will [Applause] coxon good morning members of the Arkansas Board of Education I'm truly honored and humbled to stand before you today as the Arkansas teacher of the year this recognition is not just about me it reflects the dedication passion hard work of my incredible students supportive colleagues and the entire School Community I am grateful for this opportunity to serve in this capacity and I commit to using this platform to continue advocating for Education across the state together we can create a future where every child has the resources support and opportunity to reach their fullest potential thank you so much for this incredible honor and for your ongoing commitment to education in our state [Applause] so I if if I want to add we we want to welcome Miss wil Cox in to our board I
006know she's going to be a wonderful addition and um like many of the teachers we have in the great state of Arkansas I've had an opportunity to visit her classroom and and talked to her students and it didn't take long being in her classroom to realize that she is truly distinguished in a master educator and for her to be able to use her platform and support some of our academic initiatives Statewide is something that we should honor and cherish and I know um our especially our math team has got their pencils out and and ready to book you up and and have you be a mentor to Educators across the state so we're really thrilled and really honored um to have you join the team and um it's going to be it's a wonderful year
007and I always tell her but it's really easy for me to remember Miss WL coxon's last name because when we did the announcement for teacher of the year we had all the students in the elementary school come to an assembly and it was a surprise and Governor Sanders was there and we made that announcement when you have probably 500 or So Young Elementary students all screaming at the same time Miss will coxen it was truly a remarkable event and it's like the easiest thing for me to remember now because she is truly a rock star and you can just see that with the students and with the school so welcome yes we welcome you I know you said it was an honor for you to be here but it's an honor for us that you
008are here and we really look forward to your serving on this on this board and helping the board as well bring ideas and and your thoughts to our issues that come before us so thank you I think we'd like to get a picture yeah I don't know if any guys has a comment um real quick I just want to let you know I know exactly what you're going through right now what you're feeling inside where where you really don't know what the next year provides um I just want to say this you're going to find yourself in rooms with people you never thought you would be in there with you're going to find yourself in conversations that you never thought you would have and don't for a second think you don't belong in those conversations
009and in those rooms because you belong there based on the work that you've done with your kids and so don't ever let the impostor syndrome start setting in you'll hear about that here in a couple of days in California just uh you belong wherever you end up over the next year you belong there and enjoy the ride you she's going to be awesome she's so good introduce next we're GNA hear from uh Mr Wyatt Ross white well good morning Ross white director for the division of Career and Technical education so happy Career and Technical Education Month if you didn't already know February is Career and Technical education month so we can't go without celebrating that so I'm going to read you a lot of information and then we have a short little video so bear
010with me as I go through this so um Career and Technical Education Month is a time to celebrate reflect and build awareness around Career and Technical education in our communities locally regionally State and as a nation um to provide you a little bit of a picture of what Career and Technical education looks like in the state of Arkansas we've got some statistics for you today so currently in Arkansas we have 33,700 two students enrolled in grades 5 through 12 in a career in technical educ ation course this semester um these courses are offered on all of our campuses across the state in addition to our 31 secondary Career Centers that we offer with our postsecondary partners last year in Career and Technical education we had 4,680 industry recognized certifications that were earned through coursework by
011our students in addition we had 1,781 students who earned a certificate of proficiency or technical certificate um through their postsecondary partner as well as some additional associate degrees all prior to High School graduation and a total of 36347 college credit hours earned through Career and Technical education coursework um this year we currently have 8,754 students who are enrolled in what we call work-based learning and work-based learning is that opportunity for students to work while in high school and so part of their um day is going to work with an employer in business and industry and they are earning high school credit for that but at the same time getting that hands-on experience um and then the last last piece is our Career and Technical student organizations and we've had a lot of those students come
012before you before um but in the state of Arkansas we have eight Career and Technical student organizations so those make up FFA FBLA Deca HOSA TSA skills USA FCCLA and Ed Rising so the alphabet soup as I like to call them um but they all serve a great purpose um and their goal is to build the skills that we're learning in our classes and provide our students opportunity to connect with business and industry through compet competition and Leadership opportunities and so I always say Career and Technical education is thriving in the state of Arkansas and furthering our students towards enlistment enrollment and employment um and we're excited for that so I'm going to read you the proclamation that um Governor hucke Sanders signed on February 1st um and I'll read you that and then we'll
013show you this video um so whereas Career and Technical education offers students the opportunity to gain the academic Technical and employability skills necessary for True career Readiness whereas students in Career and Technical education programs participate in meaningful experiences that improve the quality of their education and increased student engagement and achievement whereas Career and Technical education provides student with career exploration opportunities earlier in their educational experience which enables them to make informed and beneficial decisions about their academic coursework and pursuit of established programs of study and career Pathways whereas leaders from business and industry Nationwide report increasing challenges related to addressing the skills Gap and connecting qualified professionals with available careers in critical and growing CTE related fields including Healthcare energy advanced manufactur uring and information technology whereas Career and Technical education prepares students for these
014and other fulfilling careers by offering integrated programs of study that link secondary and post-secondary education leading to the entainment of Industry recognized credentials whereas ensuring that employers have access to the qualified Workforce is a crucial step in ensuring productivity among the business and industry communities as well as continued American economic growth and Global competitiveness and whereas a core pillar of the education reform law Arkansas learns is Readiness plac in a stronger emphasis on policies that prepare our kids for the workforce not a lifetime of government government dependency um so whereas Career and Technical Education Month is state of Arkansas for the month of February we got a video so um before we start the video I just want to add and commend Ross and his team if if you remember when one of the kind
015of big tenants of Arkansas learns was making sure that we empowered families and provided multiple Pathways for students because we know not every student is on the highway from K12 to University and we need to build a system with many exit ramps and onramps and um I always like to remind the board as we're engaging in this work and getting ready to go into maybe a a deeper level of how can we provide more opportunities for our students and families but we had to we had a task with Arkansas learns with requiring every High School to not only have three career in technical education programs that led to a certification where a student could become a program completer but one of those programs had to be on the newly developed Statewide High skill high demand
016High occupancy list so that was a huge lift in a lot of work and it just shows the passion and dedication around this work not only with the division of Career and Technical education but the folks that are leading this work and and have the boots on the ground to realize that this is important and we just want to commend our leaders and our teachers for making that happen that requirement went into place to start this school year and 100% of our high schools met that requirement so this is something that we are embracing as a state and going to continue to be a national leader on so as we Proclaim Career and Technical Education Month um it's it's also an opportunity to reflect on the journey that we've been on and take a time
017to celebrate where we've been but no we still got a lot more work to do more hello I'm the 2024 Arkansas teacher of the year Bo mccastlen and here at the state capital we are kicking off CTE month celebrating CTE day at the capital behind me are schools from all across the state of Arkansas sharing their CTE stories let's go take a look so you know Career and Technical education is really all of our careers sometimes people default back to votch and think you know maybe if they were in school 20 years ago what it looked like but you know our focus is on preparing students for careers and that is any career that exists out there you know uh when I was appointed to the State Board of Education you know that was a
018very very typical moment for me because I knew then CTE is at at highest value and I love the directive of the learns legislation for career Readiness so I grew up on a farm and with my grandparents and my dad and all my family being really active in agriculture when I got into high school and I saw that there were classes for agriculture I immediately knew that that was the path that I wanted to take so my plan originally was for the healthcare and deca has helped me combine both of those two together so I've been in uh branding for merchandise uh for Mercy which is a hospital and I've been in just all the business parts and I've learned to combine my passions together and I've been looking at businesses in the medical field
019so that's how DEC as and CTS helped me throughout this year I have learned a great deal of skills and learned how to communicate with others and it has given me the confidence in to be able to lead others but given me the confidence in myself that I have potential and I can live a career of success and fulfillment I just truly believe that students need that opportunity to be involved in Career and Technical education regardless of the program and pathway I think that it's extremely important to get them exposed um so that they can find their passions and then once they go on to that next step after high school they can you know get a job or they're going on to secondary education or they're enlisting in the military whatever that looks like
020but I think that giving him those opportunities is extremely important just uh one question several years ago there was discussion about some of the industries they were U hesitant to have a student less than 18 on their premises because of liability is that still an issue or we see in Pockets but I will say really since the pandemic it has been a world change in work-based learning um most of them now are like we need the we need people and we need people who will show up and be there so we've seen a tremendous in really for all being able to engage in work based learning opportunities um I know from like my prior experience in the classroom when I was in a district I was in charge of our internship program and we had
021about 30 to 50 kids that kind of fluctuated from year to year and it was kind of that constant conversation we had to have employer kind had to be the squeaky will usually made it through there are a few that just have age restrictions based off the industry manufacturing is a great example really big traditional acad a lot of times they're able to not be in the plant side of it on the floor but maybe in an office area or different pie um but we've definitely seen the number um increase tremendously and it's a na kind of a nationwide conversation around work-based learning right now um if you look at anything around Career Technical education you'll see it touching it um and we can see it continue to grow in our state especially around youth
022apprenticeships pre- apprenticeships more and more conversation um and so I continue to expect that number to grow for us do we have any further questions or comments we have two uh board members online this morning on Zoom Dr Sarah Moore who is our chair but she is joining us by zoom and Mr Randy Henderson uh do either one of you have questions for Mr White I really don't have I really don't have any questions uh I just want to say that uh you know I really enjoyed that opportunity to be able to speak on behalf of CTE uh it comes in no secret that I'm very passionate about CTE so I'm very happy to share that uh I'm glad that things are going in the direction that it's going in with the state of Arkansas
023Dr Moore did you have a comment or question no thank you for asking great to see you all great job BR you well great work we appreciate you coming and sharing that information with us so thank you keep it up do we have any uh changes to our agenda this morning anything we need to pull and look at deeper Mr Henderson Dr Moore okay we'll proceed then with our agenda no I don't have anything go ahead okay thank you Miss James our first review hearing is Candace Roberson it is case number 24135 the educator is here with her attorney this is one that she objected to the findings the evidentiary hearing that was back in July and she has requested a review and just a quick overview of the procedures um anyone who is going
024to be speaking that is not an attorney would need to be sworn in the educator will have 10 minutes to present her objections and then the plsb will have 10 minutes to present our argument thank you so anyone testing um we'll need to I I need to swear you in uh the educator is here if you would like to swear her in I don't anticipate her testifying but we can go ahead and swear her in she's right here do you swear the testimony you're about to give is the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth I do I need to swear you in as well the attorney okay you have you have 10 minutes good morning thank you kindly for uh hearing us out this morning my name is cord cantrol I'm an
025attorney in Cersei I represent Miss Robson this morning and uh I just want to begin a little bit by telling you uh about her qualifications uh as to why we're here miss Roberson is a 10year educator with state of Arkansas she has a master's degree in educational leadership she's certified uh prek through fourth grade teacher she's certified in District leadership she's a certified reading interventionist and she has a dyslexia therapist endorsement she is a highly qualified educator the facts that lead up to this event are somewhat unfortunate uh Miss Roberson is a four and a half year educator at mcro uh School District over in east Arkansas and and during that time she served as the reading interventionist at the high school she worked with four or five students at a time helping them cultivate
026their reading skills during that time at the high school she has no disciplinary actions against her she has no negative job performance evaluations uh her students are thriving the teachers at the high school love her her students love her there was no reason for her to uh have left the job or be removed from that job instead uh the district has a vacancy come up in the kindergarten classroom and uh the person who was uh in that uh in that role left and broke her contract with the school district and uh that left the school district in a bond and they moved Miss Roberson from the high school interventionist role down to a kindergarten uh classroom Mr Roberson has only nine weeks experience as a kindergarten teacher and even then she was not a teacher
027she was only doing that during her student uh teaching experience while she was in college that was 10 plus years ago she has not been in a kindergarten classroom since so they move her from a role where she's thriving where her students are thriving in the high school to the kindergarten classroom and this is a rough classroom to say the least uh the previous teacher as I said had left had broken her contract uh had no consequences of doing so 11 out of her 15 students in the classroom needed some kind of behavior plan uh there was only or there were none in place there were students in that classroom that had IEP needs uh and special education needs that the district was not meeting the district did not provide her with any AIDS in
028the classroom did not provide her with any pair of professionals to help adjust to this new role and in fact they uh they moved her in at the 9we Mark and asked her to put in grades for the previous previous teacher she had no knowledge of what the previous teacher had done it was received no uh no guidance had no idea knew nothing about these students and was asked to put in grades for them they received she received no assistance from uh an Educational co-op there was an Educational co-op that could have sent in Behavior Specialists could have sent in professional help and the district did not do that for her which leads us to an incident that occurs and it's unfortunate Miss Roberson Tak her class out to recess one day uh there were
029supposed to be two other kindergarten classes with her two under two other kindergarten teachers were supposed to be on the playground with her she takes her class out there uh the other teachers do not tell her that they're not going the principal doesn't tell her that they're not going and during that period of time there are two students who um were Troublesome for Miss Roberson they had uh engaged in a pattern of beh Behavior towards her they had taken items from her class they had caused disruptions in the class they had bothered other students and they were supposed to be in ISS during this day I had the principal followed through with her disciplinary recommendations to the parents and to miss rson but instead they are in regular class and they have acted in such
030a manner this day that they have wasted their 30 minutes of free time during the day so miss Roberson as they're going to recess sends these students to the office so that they can sit out their recess time and instead have an educational time with the principal the students uh deviate from from the other students heading out to the recess and they go towards the office and during that time they speak to three different Educators they speak to a counselor who directed them uh who directed them to the lunchroom where the principal was they spoke to an interventionist who had directed them to the office and then they spoke to the principal herself uh who sent the students back out to the playground without letting Miss Roberson know that they were going back so miss
031Roberson believes these students are in the office nobody lets her know that they are headed back out towards her on the playground what happens next happens in three minutes there's been some reporting that it was about 20 minutes in length but actually what happens takes about three minutes to occur the children leave the lunchroom on the far side of the playground and they walk towards the end of it away from The View and behind the back of Miss Roberson they then walk directly behind her back you can see in the video of the school district provides that it they walk directly behind her there is no uh viewing of the children by Miss Roberson she has no idea that they're even there and then they proceed out the far open gate of the playground uh
032there's an open gate uh um that is left open we don't know how it got left open but it's left open by the district and these students walk out the gate walk around the school and come back in the front office door of the elementary where they are then taken in takes about three minutes to occur Miss Roberson after she comes in from Recess is told that her students are in the office and she says great well that's where they were supposed to be and then she finds out that they walked outside the gate and around to the front entrance of the school and she's mortified she's horrified I mean this is an open gate that leads to an open road anything could have happened to these children at this point in time there was
033some uh reporting done there was some uh forms taken where uh it appears that Miss Roberson is not upset about this event that couldn't be further from the truth the video shows her in shock she covers her face she's mortified she's terrified as to what could have happened to these children this is is not the only time this has happened in the school district either this gate has been left open multiple times throughout the school year uh they've had children go out the school before uh with no consequences to those teachers and now they have tried to take corrective action to fix those but all while painting Miss Roberson as a scapegoat as to why this gate was left open when we had our hearing the superintendent could not tell us whose responsibility it was
034to close that gate only that the buses go through there and that somebody's responsible for for closing it but it was not closed and conveniently the cameras are down as to that particular location outside the gate the Administration has tried to blame Miss Roberson they've tried to paint her as a scapegoat here they've threatened her and uh that just couldn't be further from the truth as to what M Roberson's educational background is as to her feelings toward the students and to the position she was put in she was taken from a very successful role in the high school placed in the Elementary kindergarten or in the kindergarten classroom where she had no experience and had no support the uh mcro Elementary principal herself was new on the job and did not provide her with any
035assistance or training as well did not follow through with the plans that they had put in place for these behavior issues the original recommendation from the state was a suspension the maximum amount of probation a fine and some classes the new recommendation before you is three years probation of fine and classes and today what we're asking this board to to consider is is not uh not the recommendation from the plsb uh this is a district failure they're trying to paint Miss Roberson as the scapegoat they're uh it's preventing her from obtaining gainful employment preventing her from being able to take care of her family uh her husband is an educator a lifelong educator as well they understand the importance of Education they understand the importance of taking care of children there was a DHS case
036that was opened in this case as would be expected and uh there were charges of endangering there was charges of neglect charge of lack of supervision and DHS only found that there were true findings as to lack of supervision uh no findings of neglect no findings of endangering there's been no criminal charges filed against Miss Roberson uh and DHS importantly has since found that Miss Roberson does not present any kind of threat to children and would recommend uh that and she is not going to be placed on any maltreatment report or finding Miss Roberson simply wants to help students succeed and she simply wants to help students read better which is critical in this state we need better reading my mom is an elementary librarian we understand the importance of reading so we are asking
037this board today to let a good educator back in the classroom to help boost reading across the state of Arkansas thank you you uh Whitney James with the Department um couple of clarifying items Miss Roberson is not been removed from the classroom the recommendation was probation of course it's not final because this case hasn't been to you yet for that decision um what you heard from her attorney today is largely her version of events and I'm going to speak about facts um you had the transcript in the packet that we sent to you so you know what the testimony was at the hearing you know that she testified and had several different versions that differed from her interviews with us and you also know if um when youve read over the packet you can see
038that the hearing subcommittee did not find her testimony to be credible um the educator in this case has requested a State Board review after the hearing panel lowered her sanction um at the hearing we argued that the appropriate sanction was suspension largely that was because again um she's not credible if you watch the videos you can see that there wasn't just lack of supervision in you know on the playground there was also lack of supervision in the hallway and you also see that the students walked right in front or right behind right in Miss Roberson's area where she would have seen them before they walked out of the gate so her argument that they were in the office and she wasn't expecting them to be out there it just doesn't make any sense and it
039does not um it does not correspond with the video evidence or the witness testimony um she does have 10 years of experience a master's degree in numerous certifications um as her attorney described on November of the 30th of 2023 while at recess two students in her kindergarten class walked by Miss Roberson as you saw in the video and walked to the side of the playground where they where they exited through a gate and walked around the campus through a parking lot near a busy road thankfully the students were not injured they showed up at the front door of the school where the counselor let them in and was one wondering why the students are coming to the front door of the school when they should be at recess um again the counselor let them in
040and determined they had gotten out of the gate when Miss Roberson was walking back to the building after recess she did not notice that the students were missing from the group even though she claims the students were in alphabetical order another teacher commented to her and that was she testified to that at the hearing and she also told us this in her inter in her interview that she had mentioned and Miss Roberson two of your students were in the office and Miss Roberson said what are you talking about my students aren't aren't in the office they aren't missing um the school counselor took the students back to class she testified at the hearing that's the first time she took them anywhere she took them back to class after recess and Miss Roberson apparently had not
041noticed that the students had been missing for whatever period of time that was um when questioned by her Administration in our office Miss Roberson did not accept accountability she gave different version of events that did not match uh what others were saying and it did not match the video footage Miss Roberson makes numerous excuses for the incident including the gate should have been locked miss Nick the teacher that informed her that her students were in the office shouldn't have been in the office the superintendent yelled at her the students had behavioral issues she had never taught kindergarten before the district didn't offer proper supports the ethics training didn't cover lack of supervision she had had code of ethics training in August of 2023 which she stated at the hearing she didn't remember having she claims
042that she knows the eight standards well yet she failed to properly supervise her students which put their safety in Jeopardy at the hearing she stated it's my responsibility to supervise the student yes but when they are leaving an area and I'm unaware of what they are doing how am I supposed to supervise them when they leave the safety of the supervision willing it was their choice to leave they were being supervised by me safely and securely she mentions at another time they the students left my supervision she also stated I just trusted this children the children wouldn't betray me and do that I didn't ever think those children would be capable of that but she also testified and her attorney mentioned today that these students had behavioral issues at the evidentiary hearing Miss Roberson gave
043testimony that was inconsistent with her recorded interview with our office the video footage and the witness statements and testimony in her interview with our office she stated again when the teacher Mrs Nick asked her do you know some of your students are in the office she said well not at this time I sent them at the beginning of recess Miss Simmons sent them back out at the hearing she testified I knew they were in the office so she said that she did know where they were but that she didn't know where they were we're not sure which is which is correct or which statement she's going to stand by um she stated at the hearing that she did not see the students on the playground but as you saw in the video they walked right
044by her right before they walked out the gate um the video footage shows the students going out to recess they were with her with the other group when they went out to recess that is on the video if she thought they were in the office then she didn't see them as they were walking out to recess um that indicates that she's not supervising them in the hall like I said earlier um there's no evidence to support her claim that she sent the students to the office and the counselor walked them back out the evidence is that she did not properly supervise the students and as a result they were able to exit the gate she did not provide credible testimony at the hearing and her testimony was inconsistent with the evidence and her previous statements
045she's not taken accountability and there's a perance of the evidence to support that she violated the code of ethics thank you we now can open the floor to um board questions M Woods do you want to start thank you so much um I have a couple questions about the protocol for taking the kids out to recess Mr overon would you go go to the mic all right so your testimony is or through your attorney that you had sent these two students to the office prior to recess did you just send them out the class on their own did you drop them off what what what did that process look like no ma'am we had talked in class the one that was coerced out of the gate by the other student had had a discussion with
046me he had turned the water faucet towards the wall and sprayed water all over the floor and we spent time cleaning that up and I discussed with him since your math instruction was missed today and you did this instead then we're going to sit out at recess and on our way down there I told him I said you need to go and talk to the principal you need to go and have a discussion with Mrs Johnston and you need to talk about your behavior because the next consequence needs to happen I clipped you up and down today and this is you're not responding to that so the next thing needs to be a discussion with the principal so she can make her decision about what is the next consequence they followed me out to out
047to recess they made a distraction at the door and AA came the counselor AA Simmons came to the door and asked what they were doing they said we are waiting for the principal she said she's not here she's on lunch duty so they stayed there at the door because they knew they were not coming to recess and the interventionist came and asked them if they needed a jacket they said no and she said go play She also so Carrie also Carrie bowling also confirmed that they had spoke to Ava and Ava said no I did not and so when they knew that Julia was in Miss Johnston was in the lunchroom they walked down the awning to the lunchroom and knocked on the door and Julia Mrs Johnston the principal approached them I saw them
048having a conversation with her I assumed she took them in with her by the way of the lunchroom and I was watching the rest of the group my back was not towards them and on video you can see they do not go in with Miss Johnston they go behind my back and walk out of the open gate that is a bus entrance in the morning and in the afternoons that was left open by a custodian That was supposed to close that gate when she came to Duty after she parked her bus and she did not I was not notified by the office that this gate had not been closed the cameras were down on the side of the building where they walk walked on the sidewalk safely under the awnings to the front door there
049is no camera footage of those children in a parking lot I'm okay I don't mean to interrupt you but I'm concerned here's where my concern is that you left them unsupervised like you didn't walk them into the principal's office or into the office area and I'm not familiar with the setup of your school but I assume there's an office leading to the principal's office so you're lining them up for recess do you walk them to the front door and ask somebody to take control of them here's my thing they're five and I have an almost 5-year-old and I wouldn't trust him to like go down the hall if I had not been by myself with my other teacher team I would have done that but there were other students who were fighting in the classroom
050that day there was a student who had autism who had been kicked in the back in his calm down area by a student who was out picking up some of the recreational items that were left by fourth grade and I was monitoring those two students to make sure that the boy who had autism wasn't attacked again and those two boys were waiting for the adult at the door where the camera was on them okay so you're taking your how many were in your classroom 15 that day they were all present okay so you had 15 students you're walking them down the hall you tell those two to peel off and wait there by the door I tell them yes you were you were going to go to the principal's office during recess today right but
051do you drop them off at the door of the principal's office they are they wait they do they wait so they're left unsupervised right there or the outside the door is my yes or no they're not unsupervised there's an interventionist right there we are you drop them off with the interventionist as you're walking out the class they do they play there's no restriction on the areas they can play on the playground no no no no I'm not concerned about the playground what I'm concerned about is as you're taking them outside what happens to those two children do you hand them off to another adult they come out with us they come out with the class and they they understand that they're not to not to be playing because there is a consequence the procedure for
052students who are at level one infractions may walk the perimeter of the fence which is a very large playground which is inappropriate for 5-year-olds especially when the gate is being left open on multiple days okay and there are students who are Flight Risk who look at the gate and it's been reported to the principal that this student who is a Flight Risk chose not to go out the open gate and there's not an action plan ever put in place by the principal as to why that gate is still being unlocked okay and I'm not I am concerned about a gate being open but that's not my question my question is these two students I'm trying to figure out where the failure occurred did it occur did you leave them adults didn't take them in when
053they were sent to come off of the playground and the action plan was told there was no there's no consequence so the behaviors are continuing nothing is going to be corrected until there is a consequence I understand that man but I need to know where were these two children you're taking your 15 students out they are on the playground so they do come out to the playround with you at the aw at they standing there at the awning in within your supervision so they're still under your supervision at this point okay so that seems inconsistent with what was said earlier where you said you sent them to the office and they never came outside with you no they were sent to the office but they weren't allowed to come to the office by Ava and
054she did talk to them she did not allow them to come because Julia was Miss Johnston was not in there so they go to the lunchroom to so they may have no supervision at this point in time is what you're saying so you walk outside with 13 other students and leave them in the hall leave who in the hall the two students at issue they were never in the hallway okay so they walk all 15 students walk outside with you outside okay at what point does Ava come and get them that's a good question you can't see that on camera okay there's no camera there okay so then all 15 students are under your supervision what's the protocol for taking two students inside you the protocol is all three teachers should be on duty okay
055but they weren't but there was only one so there's no protocol okay I don't know what to do okay all right my second issue you didn't have any classroom experience I understand that 15 5-year-olds is a lot at any point in time prior to taking the job did you say hey I don't have classroom experience I did I asked them at the at the week when they asked me to finalize grades that were not entered by me no before that I did so you're reading interventionist up at the high school and they say hey we need a kindergarten teacher do you say I'm not a kindergarten teacher I've not been in a classroom in 10 years this is not there was no choice for that when your superintendent tells you what to do you do
056it okay did you at least tell them I told them I was looking for another job it it would be recommended to the board but it would probably not be approved okay there was also from the packet that we received there was multiple times where like the principal came in and said hey we've got some classroom management issues this is the schedule you're supposed to follow is it your Tes I was on schedule okay I may have more questions but I'll turn it over Mr BR I have some questions um um one qu uh just first and foremost uh did you open the gate when you no ma'am I did not can you tell me what role you played in establishing implementing or ensuring compliance of safety protocols at the school Behavior addressing Behavior right
057away it was documented through discussions with the principal and the parents did you help write the safety protocols for the school no I did not were you responsible for ensuring um implementation of the safety protocols like running can you rephrase that in a different way um were you ever given the responsibility of setting the practices that ensured safety was maintained at all times we were never educated on what to do if there were cameras down the camera was down that day and they knew in the office and the secretary was on lunch and didn't notify um I'm not sure if she notified Chris Snyder the technology director that that camera was down before she left to lunch and AA took her position but we should have been contacted by schedule who was going to be
058out there that day on at the time that that camera went down that there were no cameras on the outside of the building and that the gate was unlocked are you aware of any consequences or training that the principal or the superintendent were given um to ensure that better better safety protocols were in place I do know that the superintendent did attend a Morgan Nick training during the summer for missing and exploited children so um I think back to my first year teaching and and um tell you a story of a misstep of mine um we're in the middle of State Testing we have everything covered we've been given all the all the practices that we're supposed to do never leave the children unsupervised you know stay with the test there's all these things so
059that um and it's pretty scary as a first year teacher how serious this test is and we're in the middle of like the second day testing and this sweet little girl throws up all over her test and I froze I didn't know what to do I went to the phone and I called the office no answer who knows what was going on I called the nurse no answer who knows what was going on and I look at this classroom of 25 children who I cannot leave with the test and this one little baby who is sick and crying and needs attend you know assistance and I could I was just frozen I didn't know what to do do I help do I leave the 99 put the whole state testing put the school at risk
060and take care of the one child or do I tell her to clean I mean I didn't know what to do and um it was one of those situations that you don't are not prepared for until you're there um I think about how many times I've been on recess dudy and I'm focused on one child telling me a story about the dream they had last night and I'm so focused on that kid and engaging with them and giving them my attention that something happens in a far Corner that I miss because it's that's just the way it is and I think that this comes down to um two things first of all um I do not believe that you are responsible for setting protocol for practicing the drills for um having systems and processes in
061place to prevent these things um I also uh do not um think that the that the decision that we're faced with today is based Bas on your actions during the incident I think it's more about your reaction afterwards um I think um the frustration with both the plsb board and administration was in sort of a lack of accountability so um I am of the notion that teachers are human and mistakes are going to happen but we have to also be vulnerable enough to say I wish I'd had I wish I'd done things differently and learned from this them um I think I've taken up enough time I'm going pass it just get my thoughts out thank you go ahead Dr Dr Mo did you have any questions for Miss Robinson thank you yes I do
062of Miss James if that would be okay yes ma'am can you walk with me through the the thinking of the plsb committee and can you remind um was there two hearings the initial hearing and then an evidentiary hearing so this one went to the ethics subcommittee and then um Miss Roberson requested a hearing so just the one hearing and okay I can read the rationale and remind everyone of the sanctions by both groups if that would be helpful yes okay when this initially went to the ethics subcommittee on May the 3 they found that Miss Roberson violated standards one and two um and they recommended training reading written Reflections quarterly reports and found that um her license should be suspended for one year followed by probation of license for two years plus a $300 fine
063uh their rationale was video evidence shows that the educator left multiple kindergarten students unsupervised the students were left unsupervised for approximately 20 minutes the educator has two true findings from DHS for child Mal treatment the educator showed no remorse for her actions she took no accountability for her actions her account is inconsistent with the evidence moderate to high negative impact on students she should have known her actions were a violation of the code of ethics and the only mitigator it looks like was this was her first year as a kindergarten teacher um following the evidentiary hearing the sanction was lowered to three years probation um of $250 uh coursework reading written Reflections quarterly reports the rationale there was video footage illustrates the educator allowed multiple kindergarten students to leave uh a supervised area multiple students
064were not properly supervised which led to those students leaving the playground through an open gate close to a public road Educators showed no remorse and no accountability for her actions her account is inconsistent with the evidence educator should have known her actions were a violation of the code of ethics she has two true findings from DHS for child Mal treatment thank you yes ma'am so it it is not common that we're going to see I mean so the the S the initial sanction was lesson yes the the three years probation and took away the one-ear suspension um it is not common that we've seen you know seam hearings like this after that initial was lessened um can you speak to those three years foration it allows you to continue to teach in the classroom but
065um you know your District's under under the understanding is there any sort of work by a district if they hire a teacher who's under probation um the district would be able to see that she has a violation of standard one they would be able to see in ALS that she is on probation um whether or not they would choose to hire her after knowing that that that would be a decision that the district would made but the probation will not keep her out of the classroom okay and then as far as the DHS goes based on what I read um it was a finding but name didn't go on any list is that correct and so that doesn't jeopardize a license correct she would still be eligible she's not on the child Mal treatment I've
066never seen that before but again I haven't been doing this long enough to say whether that's typical but um she is not on the child Mal treatment registry but the true findings for um supervision or neglect to supervise were upheld okay but because she's not on the list that doesn't impact linger yes ma'am that is correct okay thank you those are all my questions right now I appreciate it yes ma'am Mr Henderson did you have any questions or comments no I do not M James can you kind of walk us through voting process here yes ma'am so for these cases there are three motions and the first is whether the educator violated the code of ethics and if so uh what standards in this case we have standards one and two on the table um
067the second motion is what the sanction is and you all can choose to modify the sanction or uphold the sanction of either the ethics subcommittee or the hearing subcommittee and then the third motion is the rationale which you can pick and choose you've got two sets of rationale you can choose one the other pick and choose add your own so just I'm clear what's on the table is the probation for three years the fine and the classes Reflections quarter report that is the recommendation of the ethics hearing subcommittee you're free to modify that that was the most recent recommendation yes ma'am and then one or two in the rationals can you go over those again yes ma'am um the rationale of the ethics subcommittee was uh video footage illustrates that the educator allowed multiple kindergarten
068students to leave a supervised area multiple students were not properly supervised which led to those students leaving the playground through an open gate closed to a public road Educators showed no remorse and no accountability account accountability for her actions Educator's account is inconsistent with the evidence educator should have known her actions were a violation of the code of ethics educator has two true findings from DHS for child maltreatment and that's rationale number one that is rationale of the hearing subcommittee so I can tell you let me compare just real quick um the main main difference is that the ethics hearing subcommittee removed the language about 20 minutes because at the hearing it was not totally clear how long they were unsupervised um and they also removed the mitigator that this was her first year as
069a kindergarten [Music] teacher and let me see I believe they also removed the statement that there was a moderate to high negative impact on students okay other than that they're pretty much the same do we have any other questions of Miss James is she currently teaching still or no no I took the advice of Miss James and took a position at uaccb in the fall and I taught adult education at Batesville in their County offices that I resign can you step up to the microphone I taught adult education classes to student high school students seeking diplom High School diplomacy in shark County but it was too far of a distance for me to drive and I wasn't making enough money okay what are the M Robertson what are the employment opportunities what districts are you
070close to if this District would not take you back there are 17 districts in our Co-op I'm ineligible to work get the riverv viiew school district because I left that job to go to mcro so that leaves me with 15 districts to see gain full employment with thank you I want to clarify I did not advise uh Miss Roberson regarding employment um she had initially requested to move her hearing date out pending the DHS decision and I always ask anytime we're moving anything out are you working in education and they informed me that that she wasn't I just want to clarify that I didn't give any advice to her regarding that I do have one question sure um could you clarify then the judge Stevens's order of January 13th in relationship to our votes today
071yes uh let me let me find those orders real quick um like I said I've never seen this before however I don't know um if this is something that that is commonly done it looks like uh they made a settlement agreement of sorts to not proceed with the hearing uh maybe you can explain that better perhaps I can uh I represented Mr Ron during that as well um and we entered into a stipulated agreement uh it was the recommendation actually of the State uh that was the original recommendation that she uh basically admit to the true two the two true findings of lack of supervision but she would not be placed on the maltreatment list because DHS did not feel like she was any danger to the children and there was no impact on the
072students as to what happened so that was actually the recommendation of DHS and that was what we entered into an agreement with and just so I may clarify that as well that was one of the big reasons why we wanted to come today was because they did that uh DHS you know while they did find that that was a true finding they did find that she does not pose any danger to the children and that what happened here did not have any kind of negative impact on the children in this case and so that's why we're more or less that's why we're here today thank you so part of I'm just making sure I understand so part of the that stipulated agreement was her admitting that she had failed to supervise the children it was
073that we would not contest that we would enter into the yes okay okay board if we are ready to vote our first vote is did Miss Roberson violate the code of ethics standards one and two I'm not sure the correct language on this but I move that we find Miss Roberson did in fact violate standards one and two I'll second all those in favor say I I is anyone opposed Dr Mo did you vote Dr Moore yes if you don't mind getting I can hardly hear you I can hear others better I'm sorry but I voted yes okay Mr Henderson yes thank you now we uphold the sentence of threeyear probation or modify you would decide if you want to uphold or increase or lower the sanction so the next motion would be I move
074that the sanction U should be upheld or modified upheld modified and if it's modified State what you would what you would like it to be modified to yes ma'am I'll move that um we modify it that she receives no license suspension or probation oh excuse me no license suspension a one-year probation and we keep the recommended training course work with monitor progress and the fine the $250 fine no okay sorry say that again I'm sorry sure see if I can remember okay so I moveed that we U modify the recommendations we remove the license suspension change it to a one-year probation and we keep the recommended training coursework with monitored progress and remove the fine I will also add I will second that I have a question though can we stipulate that the district provide
075her with a mentor as part of this or no or is it something we can ask for after the fact no ma'am this is her sanction yes ma'am so it's been moved in second second yes okay all those in favor say I I Mr Henderson is that yes yes okay Dr Moore yes motion passes and then we need to decide on the rationale yes ma'am rationale number one rationale number one is the rationale of the ethics subcommittee and it has the moderate to high impact and it also has the 20 minutes um that the students were left unsupervised I believe those are the two main different oh and the um mitigator that it was her first year as a kindergarten teacher okay and then rationale number two rationale number two is the same basically minus
076the moderate to high negative impact and first year as a kindergarten teacher and the 20 minutes that the the students were unsupervised there any questions but didn't we say between the original and the second that the 20 minutes got erased because that was Inc that's correct yes ma'am the second one does not include the 20 minutes the Moder to had negative impact the first year as a kindergarten teacher have ation so I'll make a motion that the rationale for the updated recommendation is that number one it was not the responsibility of the educator to ensure the consistent application of safety protocols that falls on the administration and number two I do believe we do believe that mistakes were made um and a mind shift is necessary for um additional accountabil on the part of the
077educator I guess to sum that up teachers are human we all have things to learn um but I do not believe the events were solely her responsibility but her accountability was is the motion to add that to the sub the hearing subcommittee's rationale I'd like to replace all that but that's the vote of the board I'll second it if we add it to I do I mean that's true okay you have to have a factual rationale right this has more detail that supports the sanction if that's okay so in addition to yes okay addition to I'm confused now rationale number one rationale number remaining rationale yes ma'am perfect um the rationale of the hearing subcommittee video footage in addition to the rationale that Miss Keener just gave us video footage illustrates that she allowed the
078multiple kindergarten students to leave the supervised area they were not properly supervised which led to students leaving the playground through an open gate close to the public road No Remorse no accountability for actions inconsistent account is inconsistent with the evidence should have known or actions were violation and to True findings from DHS yes plus the yes that is your motion okay second and I will second it okay all those in favor say I I is there anyone oppos anyone opposed okay okay motion okay thank you thanks sorry it's fine it takes a little while to get it ironed out this is what we need to do okay thank you all for your time do we need to take a short break are we okay to proceed yes ma'am the next review hearing we have is
079for an educator Miss Evelyn James it is case number 24129 we had an evidentiary hearing in this case on October the 30th of 2024 and Miss James has requested a review and okay I I wasn't quite sure what she miss James okay Miss James is here thank you she came in during the other hearing um just a reminder of the procedures swear in anyone that is speaking um who is not plsb staff or an attorney um the educator will have 10 minutes to present her objections and then the plsb will have 10 minutes to provide its argument Miss James do you want to come come to the mic good morning I need you I need to swear you in before you start okay do you swear the testimony you're about to give is the truth
080the whole truth and nothing but the truth yes ma'am okay thank you you've got 10 minutes I think you can see the clock behind us um first of all thank you for your time and I came because I the first date we got the dates mixed up and then the second date we were in the middle of testing and I could not take off so and I did not want to come I didn't want a decision to be made about me as an educator with have me speaking up for myself because that paper doesn't represent me and who I am and I think the the biggest statement I um for me was that the educator didn't show remorse and that is absolutely not the case and so I don't want anybody to ever think that
081I'm a I'm a parents I have two children I'm a single parent I have two kids in college so harming children is not something that's what I do um I love kids so I didn't want that to be um a mitigating Factor um I'm trying to y'all have to excuse me my my eyes are terrible um uh so I did I'm trying to find the the paper I'm sorry excuse me because I just wanted to highlight some things and it's this is not any way U me saying oh I'm not accountable for anything or I don't have any remorse for anything so that's not what it is it's just some things that were stated in the complete picture was not given here we go um the first thing is so so in the in your
082evidence the North Lot School District says that I was told that I will be placed on an intensive support plan in May 2023 which was true however when you look at the reasoning the reasoning has absolutely nothing to do with tests the reasoning was because I I let a parent know the last period of the day that their child came to my class with a gash on their head and a Bru and I I I knew that I had had a conference the day before with this parent about some issues that the child was having I did not want the child to get on the bus and go home like that and I asked the child said well did you go to the nurse and he says yeah so another little boy says oh I
083took him to the nurse okay so I get to work the next day I'm getting lambasted because I contacted the parent I'm like you know what I'm supposed to do like literally so he was injured at lunch in front of some security and an admin and he was taken to the nurse and none of them called him so four periods later I got him and I was the only one that contacted the parent but now I need to be placed on an intensive support plan and for me I felt like that was retaliation because y'all clearly had no intentions of telling the parent and it was just boy stuff I have a boy he threw the ball on the thing and the boys got mad so they jumped on him for you know they're boys
084and they're rough and he didn't want to say anything anything cuz he's got his boy bravado so that was it to me but you if you fast forward I asked to be moved out of the building um because it's a hostile working environment and I was denied a transfer and then they employed three people who were not certified at all and I am certified to teach science 7 through 12 in Arkansas and left me in the building so then I get to work in August and every other court teacher has two preap classes I only have one and with the exception of one another teacher I have the most teaching experience in the building okay so then I get this inclusion class and this is the class that that's in the paperwork that you have
085because I didn't have issues in the other five classes I very rarely write kids up I'm not you know we're doing stuff so we don't have time for all Shenanigans so I don't write the kids up and this particular class not only is it an inclusion class there's 30 kids in the class 12 of them have iups I got three kids that have that don't have IEPs but they came from the AOE with behavior issues it it was just toxic I'm getting cursed out every day to Crazy to every day I'm reporting I'm like hey can I get can I get a co- teacher I had one the year before no it's science you don't get one hey y'all got all these kids in here I need some help and I'm not afraid to say
086hey I know I've teaching for a long time but I still need some help this is a lot and so it was just a buildup like every day you know other teachers are like wo that class that have them they're like woo that class but but the math the math teacher the English teacher they have a co- teacher the social studies teacher they had a Paro in there with them so only the science people didn't have anybody to help them with the same rotation of kids so this particular the first incident I just wanted to highlight I did not go towards the child I like I'm standing here talking to you all he's eating and I'm like you're not supposed to be eating in class go throw your trash away so instead of him walking
087around the behind of me he tries to come in between so I put my hand out I was like hey go that way right so when he comes back from the trash can he does the exact same thing he gets on on me so I put my hand up on the shoulder I said you clearly want my attention today you are so adorable and I play with his cheeks I said now will you please go sit down so it wasn't an interaction that was aggressive or negative or anything and he was in my space I never went into his space and you know touched him and that I felt like that needed to be illuminated and so there was there a really long Gap in there because I had Co I had um that's why
088I can't see so I find out that I have diabetes high blood pressure I had a hemorrhage in my eye and me being super teeder I'm like oh I'll just wait till Christmas to get my eye fixed well that's that can affect your mood and it's over stimulating when you you're trying to compensate so here I am this next that this when we come back um from I came back after the co after the being sent home all that all the other stuff I that this new student never seen him before cuz he com you know and come he came when I was out so here I am this particular day the day before the student he he traps me up in the classroom after class alone and there's nobody upstairs I'm upstairs in the
089corner the other teachers have walked the kids downstairs so he's still in the room and so he's following me around the room and I'm like hey you you got to so I had to go out in the hallway and close my door to get him to come out of my classroom and it was very aggressive and so I told the assistant principal okay and it was like whatever well I have PTSD um it was very triggering for me because when I was in high school and I didn't it's and I didn't realize that it was just triggering for me when I was in high school my classmate um he stabbed the teacher in the room next to us and then he came out and he's covered in blood and it nobody did anything about it
090we didn't get counseling we didn't get therapy they told our parents we were already G to a football game so I carried that so I don't like kids too close to me and I don't like to be alone in the room with them and I never really like identify what that was like oh okay you've been traumatized that so here I am he did it that day and then that afternoon we find out one of our students was in a house fire and my co-workers like oh my God I feel bad cuz I'm the reason he got suspended and he was at home and I'm like no it's not your fault you know it's just horrible day we get up and the boy died so this particular day it was just bad all the way
091around and so it that that's not an excuse that's just the reality of like a school day and it was horrible so this child the the that we're doing is very open-ended you just have to make a statement do you agree or disagree so there is no right or wrong answer I can't tell you what you agree or disagree with he couldn't accept that as an answer so he what you didn't hear was him calling me dumb stupid and cursing at me and so when he told me to shut up my response was no you shut up was that appropriate no and I understand that but in that moment I I I was having a bad day and it was horrible day you know I've looked at the the statements they're all inconsistent the handwritings
092but and these are the same classes so you all can see the handwritings look different and it's the same exact class how's a handwriting different how are kids writing the exact same thing on a statement all of that to me um is you know terrible but then when you fast forward I have no paperwork that this child is Special Needs it's not in the es it's not in E school I don't have it it's nowhere so there's nothing nothing that says this the only paperwork I have said that came from the school that he came from says he doesn't have anything he's not receiving services but the mother took to the internet because she couldn't come upstairs that day and fight with me and you all should have that audio from the office where she's
093trying to come and be combative with myself and the math teacher so she takes to the internet and she's portrayed this whole story this is child special needs and there's nothing saying that he is and I did not respond to her until she got on my Facebook page by bothering my 78y old mother then she was bothering my children and then she's harassing me so that's why I filed a police report on her because she was harassing me um and and not representing the situation well because she's an she's an influencer so she's making money off of these post she's making money off these likes and she I have James sorry your time is up yeah I saw that sorry okay we're going to hear from the other Miss James with the Department we if
094you want to sit right here so we can ask questions if we need to thank you hi Whitney James with the Department uh Miss Evelyn James has been a teacher since 2004 uh she began her employment employment with the North lck School District in August of 2021 she was a seventh grade science teacher um she has referred herself in our interviews as an excellent educator an overly trained educator um she has not accepted accountability she denies that she violated the code of ethics or District policy the evidence presented at the evidentiary hearing proved otherwise um she's displayed a pattern of physical abuse and verbal abuse towards students the allegation in this case is as follows on September the 1st of 2023 Miss James allegedly forcefully grabbed a student by the neck during class and started
095pulling on him other students filled out witness statements that Miss James put her hands on the student either by pulling his ear or neck or putting her hand on his eyes later on November the 9th of 2023 a student will call S2 who had been complaining to his mother that Miss James was mean to him and would not help him in class took it upon himself to record part of the class so that he could document the way that Miss James spoke to the students uh that that recording of that classroom um interaction was in the documents that we sent to you um and I'm sure you heard that um that Miss James made statements such as you're talking to me like I'm stupid and slow you are shut up that's why I don't like
096you because you got to constantly say something to me shut up shut up she says shut up to the students repeatedly and this was just an 18-minute clip of one class on one day um following this Miss James engaged in a Facebook argument with the students parent and others on Facebook where others could see uh Miss James insulted the parent discussed 504 plans and IEPs post poed about how the student who recorded the interactions in class had been transferred from one District to another other parents and students were engaging in this on Facebook um and also had posted other things about Miss James's behavior and incidents in other districts um in this case the appropriate sanction is suspension of license followed by probation the allegations are inappropriate communication with the student plus inappropriate interaction with
097a student the starting sanction is probation however in this case there's moderate severe a level of impact of the students there's evidence of Prior similar Behavior willful or intentional violation of the code of ethics she's a veteran educator uh these aggravating factors take us from Pro probation to suspension um that is what the hearing panel found that's what the ethics subcommittee found and that is our argument here today thank you we have any questions for Miss James Dr Dr Moore do you have any questions Mr Henderson do you have any questions I do not at this time okay and I don't either sorry I could barely hear you thank you okay so miss James would you go over the how we're going to V yes the first motion is whether or not the educator violated
098the code of ethics and if so what standards this one is another um one and two the second is the sanction the State Board May uphold the recommended sanction or modify it um the sanction was I believe the same between the two groups that reviewed the only difference is the fine was lowered to 250 at the evidentiary hearing and the rationale was a little different different can you just for a second so it was suspension for how long the ethics subcommittee recommended suspension of license for one year followed by probation of license for one year there's some training cour workk readings and a $500 fine the ethics hearing subcommittee upheld the one-year suspension followed by one-year probation lowered the fine to 250 and gave the same trainings um and other recommendations sorry and then you
099were saying the rationale do you need the r no I thought you were gonna read it I oh I'm so sorry I I certainly can do you want to wait till we get okay okay yes okay so then our first um motion will need to be did Miss James wildlight the code of ethics standards one and two I'll move to substantiate uphold that she violated standards one and two second we have a motion that's my motion second by Mr all those in favor say I I is there anyone opposed okay our second motion then is to or modify for probation and suspension move to uphold second motion is to uphold the onee suspension with oneyear probation training with the $500 fine it was 500 at the ethics subcommittee lowered to 250 at the hearing so
100we need to de side either which way yes ma'am you like to go yes ma'am so that needs to be in our motion yes ma'am if you would uh if you would like to uphold the oneyear suspension followed by one-year probation you can list whether you want 250 or 500 and then you want to uphold the rest of the recommended uh trainings and coursework oh I would like to uh for the motion to be upheld with the modification of the fine reduction to 250 so we've got a motion is there a second second second all those in favor say I I Mr Henderson yes Dr Mo yeah okay all right and then our final motion needs to be on the rationale yes ma'am I'll move we the rale okay second then moved in second it
101to uphold the rationale was that of the hearing subcommittee of the subcommittee okay the hearing subcommittee yes I'm sorry we have two subcommittees okay okay thank you and all all right we need to vote on that all those in favor say I I anyone opposed Dr Moore yes mron yes thank you thank you thank you m James everybody take a deep breath those are always very difficult okay our next um item of business is graduate Arkansas Charter and I believe they have a recommendation good morning hope Worsham assistant commissioner for public school accountability um the rules covering standards for accreditation for Arkansas Public Schools uh standard 1- C11 require that all students test 95% of their students in the state Summit of assessment in grades three through 10 or three through High School excuse me
102um we have two buildings this morning that uh are in their second year of not meeting that requirement for 95% tested the first one is graduate Arkansas Charter High School um they are here to um address the board the department um is recommending that they remain in accredited side of status for their high school they did make significant Improvement in the percent of students tested uh across the past two years doubling the number of students percent that they were able to test um and we believe that with continued support from the department and remaining inited status that they will see significant Improvement this year as well so I will um turn over to believe the district is going to speak and we have the slides for you if you would introduce yourself as you come
103to the microphone let us know your your name please good morning Katie Hatley superintendent graduate Arkansas so um thank you hold on one second I'm sorry I see people waving back here oh sorry I don't think it's a hearing I don't believe this is a hearing were you appealing y y'all weren't doing appeal y were you appealing the citation we are you are appealing yes ma'am okay oh okay I thought you were just going to present so no ma'am did we receive a letter to appeal um it was we did receive a request to speak to the board um and I was I did not understand that there was an appeal but okay we did rece re add official so all of you that will testify this morning I'll need to swear you in so
104please please stand who's who's going to be testifying okay do you swear the testimony you're about to give us is the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth yes okay can you introduce your yourself again okay I didn't quite I didn't quite hear your last name I'm sorry yes ma'am Katie Hatley superintendent graduate Arkansas thank you missley go ahead good morning state board members um assistant commissioner Smith um we come today again to appeal the accredited cited status and with our presentation you'll see the many reasons why today we travel with our entire leadership team um but we have two test coordinators who will present the material to you I'm sorry do we need a do we need a timer is this that kind of yeah they'll be there's a time limit 15
105minutes 15 minutes 15 I'll do it thank you I'll take care of it for you my yet I miss Dr more than this morning always you're doing great don't start the timer yet the clicker is malfunction don't start it yet I'm ready whenever you want okay we'll go back to Jacob couldn't have handled this so I'm glad yeah thank you thank you Stacy you're right so many of you may not know much about graduate Arkansas and our mission we educate students 15 to 21 years of age or 14 and if they're in the ninth grade but our mission um States simply states that we provide personalized learning opportunities to re-engage disconnected students to help them earn a high school diploma and Pathways to lifelong success um our vision is still to become the nation's leading
106model for Dropout recovery and Credit Recovery education through Excellence excellence in student support instructional Innovation and Community Partnerships and at this time I turn it over to our coordinators if you would please introduce yourself and really get up into the mic for us good morning my name is Katherine Gano and the district test coordinator uh this is our data pulled directly from my school info in each of our subgroups our testing percentages have doubled or more than doubled last year compared to 2023 with the exception of the African-American subgroup we had the largest growth and highest achievement in our Hispanic and Latino subgroup and I also serve as the Esau coordinator so this was a huge source of Pride for me as much of that subgroup is um our English Learners and I get the
107pleasure of supporting them as well uh We've included 2022 percentages on this slide as well for historical data overall we have shown tremendous improvement from the previous year's percentages here is our enrollment growth over the past few years uh we currently have 653 students and last year our enrollment was at 490 we've tested more students year after year with the growth in enrollment and more students tested means percentages carry more weight we must now test more students um now than ever we have put systems and Personnel in place to ensure that we have the capacity to test any student required to participate last year we tested 3177 students in writing but only 298 of those students were counted in our Ela participation as a whole since there were separate testing windows for writing and Ela
108last year this limited our student completion some students who attended the writing test session didn't or were not able to attend the ELA test session which was held over a month later now that both tests are within the same test window we can better ensure that each one is completed to provide an accurate Ela participation percentage we do want to acknowledge that desie worked with us to pair writing data with Ela data however this was a challenge for us as we tried to get students to complete in-person testing Thomas Coy with graduate Arkansas thank you all for having me good morning board I I know I've appeared before you in a different capacity many for many years so I'm thankful to be back here today um one of the things is we did want to
109address with you is this remote testing approval so last year we started the writing assessment as Miss quondo said um we were doing all of those in person we were having students to our campus we were traveling across the state trying to get students tested in writing we were informed then that we would also have to do our Ela testing in person as well if a student started in person they had to finish in person now I will commend the state and I will commend especially um Michelle Johnson and her group and in um in assessment and assistant commissioner Worsham they have all worked with us they've been attentive to our calls our concerns and I think they put PL put things in place for this year that will make it much easier for us
110but it was a challenge this was a source of stress for us last year it was a source of frustration and then when we finally got approved to test remotely it was kind of a source of relief right we could we could get some of these students tested in in multiple methods um so I did want to commend desie for that um this year I want to assure you all that we are ready for inperson and virtual testing because the state released a commissioner's memo and released information about the um remote testing agreement early in the year we have been collecting those we have over four over 300 students I believe that have remote testing agreements in place so we can test them remotely we still have a plan and we'll get to that in
111just a minute about how we test students um in person as well so if you look at this map this kind of gave gives you a breakdown of where a lot of our students were concentrated last year so if you don't know anything about our school we are both an inperson and a virtual model we try to um help students recover from credit deficits or students who've been uh maybe U Traditional School just doesn't work for them we serve them all we take them all so any student who um needs to enroll with us that fit the requirements the age requirements they can enroll with us absolutely so if we look at these 16 testing sites across the state these these represent places that we actually travel to and this was not just one day
112we traveled during the writing we traveled during the uh open window and we also traveled to these sites during makeup testing so all of these sites represent maybe three trips or more to each of these places um y'all this was a team effort it wasn't just several of us getting out driving it was everyone it was our teachers we would we would drive we are thankful for the educational co-ops who hosted us the public libraries who gave us spaces to test um community centers community colleges often times we had to pay to rent those spaces but we went to these places and we met students and if I can just give you a real quick personal thing of the sites I went to what made the most difference to me is actually getting to interact
113with the students who often would only join us virtually figure out how they came to us maybe what wasn't working in their school and that's not an indictment of their school it's just how did they end up with us and why are we serving them so you know it took a lot to get me to leave the department I was here for a long time but I feel like I'm in the right place because our students are really doing great things and our school is really doing great things and again this is a whole team our entire leadership team our teaching team we have core teachers in every area we were all out testing not to mention we did not put on here Little Rock North Little Rock Jacksonville the places in central Arkansas where
114we would meet our Central Arkansas students in person they would come to either our campus or we also set up some opportunities for them so if you look at our our breakdown we did a lot of traveling last year a lot of work to get a lot of students tested we are doing after hours testing um I bags under my eyes if some of our other folks have bags under their eyes we're doing this right now with our interim testing we offer remote after hours testing if the students have a remote agreement in place we offer that from 4:30 to 9:00 p.m. while we're doing interims also while we're doing summative assessments so I wanted to point out that it's not just the regular school day because I believe that our students um circumstances happen
115to all of us right economics happen to some of our students some of our students work full-time some of our students are homeless some of our students are parents and we have to accommodate their schedule so we are doing everything that we can to try to accommodate them so that they can be present for testing one thing that we did this year last year we did not use the atlas um assessments we we when the state released all those we started using Atlas assessments because we're trying to build this culture of accountability in our school if we can get our students accustomed to logging on to the atlas um portal taking those tests I believe that they will then show up for Summit to so we are doing the interim assessments we're in round two
116right now we've got people testing right now while we are here we'll be testing this evening as well the benefit of that and one of the great things that the state has done in providing that for us it provides quick score results um which will help us guide instruction and strategies we hear a lot about that we hear a lot about intervention um it's a challenge sometimes to get our students to show up for intervention but what we do is we look at those scores and we have created week small group support for our student scoring in level one and level two there is required participation in the intervention group so you may already be asking like well what happens if the student isn't there right you just told me that maybe they can't be
117there during the day we record all of those there's an exit ticket we are also um we are a Mastery Program so we have turned off prescriptives like students cannot accelerate quickly if they do not assess so there's a consequence we don't deny them their educ tion we don't deny them the support but we do tell them you're not going to get to rush through this class or this program if you don't participate in our testing so those are some of the strategies that we've done to try to encourage and um motivate our students if you will to uh to perform and to show up so finally we have plans for improvement another thing you might not know about our school every student has an academic advisor every student has a success coach um our
118success coaches kind of deal with the extraneous if you will our academic advisors deal with um again the academic piece right so what we're trying to do is enhance communication through our entire team of support to get students engaged so what you might see at our school is you might see an academic advisor calling a student four or five times especially if they're online only hey I need you to test need you to test and need you to test well if they're not responding you'll see our success coaches step in and our success team led by Mr Johnson who is here is fantastic y'all they they have the the motivational skills that oftentimes we don't have as academic advisors but they are wonderful to encourage support come back to the academic team and say hey
119this student is struggling with this can they test tonight at 7:30 absolutely sure we you know we're going to do whatever we can to accommodate them we're trying to again offer flexible inperson and remote testing times we've talked about that so I won't revisit that when we met with uh desie on a zoom some of our support Zooms for the 95% tested that we're required to attend have been great they've added um some encouragement around test completion incentives so we're trying to incentivize not only our teachers and our our staff to encourage students but also our students who actually um take and complete all of their tests we are partnering with Juvenile Justice systems if we know that a student has a parole officer or a f officer we're leveraging that so that we can
120perhaps motivate a student to show up and to do what they what they are required to do and we're in the process of creating local educational support hubs so one thing that we learned last year through our traveling to different places is and I mentioned it earlier the personal part is that it was really meaningful to me to see our students and to figure out what they were doing a real quick story because I've only got a couple minutes we had a student who showed up and dad brought her to testing and said are they going to be done by 11 because we've got chicken houses and cattle Farms it reframed my whole thought about the students participation she works she works from 6:00 in the morning till 4: in the afternoon and that's just
121the reality right I don't we don't look at that as as pity so but I but I say that to help you understand that when we create these local educational hubs our desire is to really connect with our students because we believe that if we connect with them that they will be more inclined to participate and and I couldn't be prouder of this team that sits behind me I couldn't be proud of the work that we're doing because we truly are reaching students who I believe are underserved in our states and that Traditional School doesn't necessarily work for them I'll turn it back over to miss Hatley so as you can see from the presentation we're a non-traditional model we we really are in the trenches meeting the needs of students who really need us
122the most um I was a coach growing up traditional settings um I was bled to teach in other states um Arkansas I mean Hawaii and Alabama and I was still just attracted to at Rich youth that that has been my purpose um to finish out my educational career but I want the State Board to see that we are meeting the needs and we are following um D to give us a plan of support we just put it on stairs to make sure we go above and beyond to try to meet the needs of these students thank you so the uh request from the Department is to have um to continue uh the citation status for graduate Arkansas High School um they have made significant improvements we commend them for that and we feel like that
123with the continued support from the Department they will continue to make improvements to meet their 95% tested and then we do not request any further action past that Bo do we have any questions so we could remove them from cided status that's within our discretion so that we bring the recommendation for you for them to main insided status and then is the board's decision of what to do with that so but because this would be their second year they're inited status now is that correct that is correct and so the normal progression would be that they would move from cited status to that is after two years so if if they do not um meet their 95% tested after this year's citation then they would be moved to probationary status which then could have other
124consequences other actions thank you Dr Mo do you have any questions I do have one question does this have any relevance does this go in front of the charter panel and does it have any relevance on their Charter um this does not go before the charter panel um because it's a standards for accreditation request but I do believe that Mr Smith um may have the the school discuss their action plan with the charter panel upon uh renewal okay thank you Mr Henderson questions yeah just just my um clarification U uh what what are we what is the state the the department is asking us to do once again so we're requesting that the the school is currently in cited status for this particular standard we are requesting they remain in cited status for one additional
125year um as they implement the action plan that they have discussed today good questions no I don't think that's protocol sorry questions I think my question is you've talked about how far they've moved what percentage have they changed uh so they went from 25% tested in ela to 61% this year 61.9 actually so almost 62 and they went from from 26% tested and 23 in math to 50% tested this year so they've doubled the percent of students they've tested um and they have made significant uh implemented significant changes to their system to ensure that that happens so so being in cited status aside from the fact that they are in cited status does this does that limit them in any other way it does not limit them in any other way in fact it provides
126um requires a plan of action from us and then additional support from my office um however we can be helpful so if we remove sided status your office doesn't assist um we would assist at the normal level that we do with other schools um so that more general assistance um but with this situation we are more in touch with the building we would be working with them more closely okay if we remove sided status and they do not meet that goal again does the clock start completely over where they're in the first year SED again yes it will and okay so another hypothetical um if they remained inited status this year and then we come back next year um then we're we're not compelled to move them to probationary status we could we could again
127just keep them inside of status um the rules do require that after you've failed for two consecutive years that you shall be assigned probationary status um so that it that the rules do require that that you shall be now then there's fur you don't have to take any further action past that at that point is there a time frame on the probationary status it is for one year y but whereas s it doesn't really have any ramifications probation does that is correct could no sorry could could doesn't require could yes may is the right word I I'll just say I'm just so impressed with the work that you all do I remember you here last year and you know I I'm so just impressed then even more so now so congratulations for the the progress
128that you've made Miss Handley I know you wanted to say something a minute ago you want to come to the mic and go ahead the chair's allowed to do that so you can the chair can do that so so I would take that opportunity I I'm from a family of 12 I had strict parents so I can I can obey real quick um I just wanted to say that yes we did appear before the State Board two years ago and that um accredited SED status was released um just to know the charter has been in existence for 14 years and under my leadership the whole time the whole that anytime we've been in any trouble with a state is the 95% not tested but once again I mean I understand federal law but I also
129understand State compliance um so by no way am I able trying to overstep or anything like that I just don't feel that we're comparing Apples to Apples you know we're not testing you know 15 to 16 year olds we're testing I get emotional we're testing 18 and 19 year olds who are in the ninth grade too so it's kind of different thank you I wonder if if this is um one of the things that this is such a a little pocket um can you tell me again tell me a little bit more about um other schools that are similar with non-traditional populations and sort of where they fall um in their testing percentages so there are only two schools that we're bringing to you today um both of them are Dropout recovery or prevention at
130RIS student populations there are a few other programs that serve similar populations and they are not on the list today um what I would say is with the um implementation of online testing the population will be easier to reach um and again I feel like the the building has done significant Improvement under um the support that we've been able to provide and maintain contact with them and I just wouldn't want to see that fall off um in in the future I think that um they they're committed and and they'll and they will meet their goal I struggle to your point into kind of brought up is just saying we're applying traditional rules to a non-traditional setting and that's hard right but also it is the rules we have so that's my conflict well and and
131I'll go even further on that conflict because you know the work that you do is so amazing and I think that having the additional support of the state by being incited status is a plus um so I hate to see you lose that I mean and you might say well we don't need it we've got our we've got our plan and we're going to we've planned our work and we're going to work our plan and if that's the case then I mean I I don't know but I I'm very conflicted about you know easing up on any support that you may have also wonder um seeing as there's no direct consequence at this point for staying in cided status and you the plan is um we're confident about the plan um I say we my
132thoughts are we stay in cided status um prove it to us gets that 95% we won't see you here next year um and if we do perhaps that was the right decision that maybe moving to a higher um tier of consequences would be the right time so in the meantime we might look at the rules is that a form of a motion um yes I'll make a motion that we oh sorry I I cut him did you have anything okay ready to move on um I'll make a motion that we um approve the recommendation of the department which is to maintain excuse me to uh for graduate Arkansas to be in um cited status for their second year okay is there a second second second by Mr brag is there any further discussion Dr Moore
133no questions thank you okay Mr Henderson no okay no questions okay all those in favor say I I is there anyone opposed I'm gonna oppose just just because I'm still conflicted so say no okay okay the motion motion passes thank you and y'all are sharp looking group thank you for coming can I make a comment do you mind um again I just want to acknowledge that and I think this board today does acknowledge and recognize um the the students that you work with um not everybody opens their doors and goes after kids who have not been successful and you do and I know Miss worsham's recommendation today was not to impune or we made no recommendation other than meeting the standard right we're here to support you we applaud you um no recommendation as further
134as actions upon you today so keep doing the good work keep working hard um and hopefully next year we're going to fill this place with balloons and say we made it to 95% all right so congratulations on your work so the second request that we bring to you today is for the same uh standards for accreditation uh 1- C11 which which is attest 95% of students the school that uh we are recommended to remain in cited status for their second year is Premier High School online um part of the Premier high schools of Arkansas group I will say for this particular um District they did have three schools on the list last year and they are down to one they have as well made significant Improvement they have gone from approximately 50% of their students
135testing in uh 2023 to 90 and 93% so they are very close to meeting that Mark um similar uh request as before the department will continue to support them directly um through the efforts of an action plan they have made significant improvements we do not request any further action than for them to remain in cited status and the district is here to speak um on behalf of the request I just want to clarify real quick so are we because this wasn't clear before are you accepting the citation there are you doing an appeal so they do want to appeal the the cited status okay I'll need to swear you in before we start do you swear the testimony you're about to give is the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth I do
136if you would please really get to the mic and introduce yourselves I'm Dr Dennis Felton Jr I'm the vice president of school operations for response of a Arkansas good morning my name is Susan provenza and I'm the superintendent for respons at Arkansas thank you for having us here today now we were just clarifying with the Department originally when we prepared this presentation uh we were going to talk about three schools and so uh we're just going to focus on Premier High School online and so once again uh we are here to appeal the state's recommendation to put Premier High School line uh as cited status for our accreditation and as you can see here um we barely MISD demarked um we understand that the state and federal has guidelines on test participation uh but we
137do also believe that it's not the intent to penalize small schools that may have one or two uncontrollable circumstances in which students are not taking a test and so you see here where we had 90.4% tested in ela and 93% tested in math and so also just showing you all our improvement with our online we almost double our participation from 2023 to 2024 so you see where all students in ela where we tested 50% we came back with a 40% increase and tested 90% of students and you see in math where we had 51% of students tested we came back and had a 42% increase in student participation so one of the things that we do U very similar we Ser a very non-traditional population when it comes to our Premier High School students often
138these students are struggling uh they're dealing with chronic absenteeism may have been dropped uh from previous School District due to lack of attendance a lot of students have previously dropped out of high school and so we're engaging them back in the high school process and so um wanted to commend our team of the efforts that they put together to test students remotely to set up testing locations to to test after hours alternate days just to be flexible for our families which represents that big increase you all have seen from year over year one of the things we also as Implement a new state assessment it does bring its challenges and one of the things that we noticed that the state had information that if a student hadn't completed 75% of cours work they would not
139be able to they shouldn't be participating in the end of year assessment um so we realized when we looked at our data we did have students because we are Mastery based and we're able to track where students are in their coursework that enrolled late in the school year had not met their requirement that still participate in the assessment and so what we did is we compiled data to see which students participated in the state assessment who actually completed the 70% threshold the students who participate in the assessment who did not meet the 70% threshold and so just moving forward we're just um here committed to let you all know that we continue uh to put a strong participation plan together and be flexible for our families to communicate with those families to test early as
140soon as the testing window opens and continue to provide a myriad of options whether it's in sight I mean on site remote after hours on Alternate days maybe like a weekend day to bid to get students tested and so here what you're looking at is we've took the data that we got from the state we went back and look at our own data and we broke it down based on which students actually should have taken a state assessment and met that coursework requirement and which students actually participated who should not have been participated and should have been removed from the testing roster and you so where we tested 50 students in algebra one we should have just tested 14 students we tested 42 students in Geometry where we actually should have had 19 students on
141that roster and so breaking down those students so we identifi eight students who did not take the ELA assessment in Premier High School online of those eight students one student was incarcerated uh in juvenile justice so we were not able to test that student we had six students that enrolled in the school after the testing window had closed and so as previously stated by our district last year the way the testing windows were set up where we tested writing in one window early in the spring semester and then later we started our other assessment so if a student enrolled after the writing window was over with we did not have the ability to test that student and then we had one student that was just dealing with a tech uh technology issue uh with their
142device which we was trying to troubleshoot which hinted their from actually completing the assessment after they logged on and so as we know there they'll continue to be uncontrollable um circumstances I I want to commend our team our principals our teachers our student engagement specialist our success coaches they were constantly on the phone contacting parents they were setting up remote testing locations we were going to certain communities to make it more accom uh make more accommodations for those students and also putting together different things that way if a student was having maybe like a transportation issue or there was a device issue to set up where they can actually come in sight in one of our campuses and so also what we did to compile the data we took the data from the students who
143actually had completed 75% of the coursework and who took the state assessment and you see on our end of course Science assessment the adjusted completion rate is 100% we tested five out of five kids controlling those variables when you look at the math assessment we're supposed to test 36 kids and we tested 33 students which end up adjusted participation rate of 91% that's no longer applicable and so uh just know that we recognize the accreditation standard we recognize the um the standard that's set by the state and the feds and and once again we do not feel like this standard is um was written to penalize small schools that have one or two uncontrollable circumstances that's outside the school's control to be penalized for not meeting that threshold and so when we look and see
144where we have 93% and 94% of students tested um we're appealing because we want to be an advocate for our staff and our our teachers our principls that work relentlessly to make sure that we have those 40 and 50% increases in our participation rate in closing I feel like we have strong participation plan we've continued to work with the state on that participation plan I guess I can go to the extent to say I feel like after working with the state two years we have a solid plan and that's why you've seen our schools at 95 or above and the ones that don't make the mark that land around 9 3% and 94% is because of those uncontrollable circumstances thank you so from the Department we are recommending that um Premier High School online only
145remain in accredited sided status for one additional year um through that status we will continue to provide support and work with them on their action plan to reach the goal of 95% tested and see questions um one clarification So when you say the UN um the the circumstances out of your control really boils down to the eight students noted that that is correct and and just to credit the department department has adjusted the testing sessions this year that way uh writing is not totally separate window but we're highly mobile uh school and and students sometimes are um coming in later uh because we are serving we're taking all students we're taking a lot of students who have not been enrolled in school and so getting those students on boarded we're not turning students away just
146because we started State assessments however as you can see from six students we're penalized by enrolling those students to give them opportunity to earn credit towards graduation because they're not participating assessment window that's already been closed by the state right you know so it's difficult given the context of our prior case the decision we made uh when you compare it to these um real circum well these numbers and the circumstances behind those numbers and I will add one point of clarification the writing window yes there was an original window at the beginning of the the t uh that was in March for this year only because we had to field test um but uh there was also an additional window inside of the the larger window um where students were able to take their writing
147assessment if they had missed it to his point there could have been students that enrolled after that as well um there is an appeals process inside of our assessment Corrections uh where schools are able to tell us reasons why certain students weren't able to test and in some cases we are able to remove them from their population so these six did go through that process and it was determined that they should not be removed from the numbers that they should be included yeah I would have to go back and look at the exact six students that he's referencing if there was um documentation provided or um if we were were able to remove them or not I would have to look at that but we do that another question um the one student that was
148incarcerated um with a non-traditional setting like this are they unenrolled after 10 days 10 consecutive absent days um I wonder if that's students should shouldn't have been unenrolled um um and then with the the other you know I think the number set at 95% to offer a cushion for those circumstances like that um I'm my thought is if those six students truly had an opportunity to take that test then we stay at cided if those six were really enrolled after all windows were closed then we should they shouldn't be cited that is that's going to be enough to push them to 95% and above right so I almost need more information on on those what are What's the total number of students that you have in your high school what do we because earlier when
149you showed the numbers you were saying like 50 students 14 students number PR High School online last year we sered right under 300 students okay and so in your algebra and geometry courses 50 I was confused between there was 50 students taking algebra but 70% of them hadn't completed the course so you thought only like 14 should have taken the test so what's so your cohort of a grade level of students is about 50 taking a course at a time is that what yes that's okay so for for the board um the department is always going to come with a recommendation of a cited status for anybody that falls below 95% that's that's just clearcut for us when you get into a small school district and you see that they're missing it by in in
150essence for 93% in a small District you're that's one or two students that they're missing it by this is not a heartbreak or a heartburn for us if this board today decides not to site this District okay um I will say though in the presentation there were some things that made my eyebrows go we need to look at that or do some more education around that figuring out where we are on this Competency Based piece when it's time to test kids when it's not U making sure that they understand um the portal for being able to say hey this kid shouldn't have tested or not tested it shouldn't be counted against us we have we have things in place for that I think there's probably still some education and partnership that we need to provide
151to them which we can do um but when you look at a district that's just that close again this this is not if if you guys don't go with the recommendation that's okay all right we're always going to come if somebody's below 95% because that's the standards that we've set for accreditation all right but this is where you guys have some discreption that's very hopeful as we differentiate between the two cases yes and I'll just offer for those of you that are new I think it was faille last year that we took off of citation because of like two students and there were just circumstances beyond their control so it has been done before and I noticed they're not back here and they are not back this year so sometimes like hopefully I won't see
152you next year so what is the status of the school with other standards are you cited for any other standard violation no this is the only one Dr Moore did you have any questions no not at this point Thank you Mr Henderson okay anyone else okay we we'll need a motion then I would move that we remove the cited recommendation second it's been a motion that we remove the site recommendation all those in favor say I I anyone opposed okay thank you good job thank you good job just a question is is it worth evaluating the to to have a different standard for these situations promting different rules yeah so when you're look at like graduate Arkansas the one previously so their Charter is a charter for like an alternative learning environment so they don't
153get an A to f grade so our state law does already differentiate but because they are um a a high school within the state that they are expected to meet standards for accreditation that are set 95% is um a federal law that we have to meet in testing kids and so that's where we've set the standard for the state I will say bringing districts who didn't have 95% tested was not something that we used to do we added it to the standards for accreditation around covid time and if you remember right after covid we had a very large group that didn't meet 95% and we asked you guys to wave all those right and so this is fairly new as far as bringing districts who don't meet that number 95% I will say with graduate
154Arkansas they made a significant increase from 20% to 50% I feel like they have an aggressive plan that next year I think that they'll make another jump um premere went from the 80s up into like right there one or two kids so I feel like the attention we're bringing to it is is worthy um but I think you guys made a good recommendation today and congratulations to you for the work that you dok that's all of action yeah because that be in the the action agenda correct and then that would we could then move consent and then she could leave that work so that's you want to take a break sure okay we'll take a 10 minute break e yeah e for e e what e e e okay we're going to go ahead and
155get started are youall ready back here do we have any new business today sorry wee back in session new business okay we had no questions on the consent agenda or nothing that was pulled so we'll need a motion to either approve or accept the um consent agenda okay Mr Henderson makes the motion second second Lisa all those in favor say I I hi anyone opposed okay next we're into um reports I can find my page we're at the um board board report who's first Sorry Miss K were you ready yes I was just looking who's first had to find my place okay um if we can pull up the oh look with the clicker okay thanks okay um just to kind of update you guys on what we have been busy doing in the committee
156on early learning um and I'm going to kind of go backwards just a little bit but um meaning that I'm going to talk about the learns act for just heartbe um often um so Governor Sanders when she put the when the learns Act was passed uh what was included in there was a unified Early Childhood uh care and education and we'll say that term a lot unified but what does that mean and I think this report is our very first Glimpse at what that means and how this can be really helpful and we're so excited about it um I'm going to jump to is it these on the side okay Miss kener do you want to tell us who's on your committee oh sure gosh I hope I don't forget anybody but yes um so
157uh Miss Gina Dicky she um works with aate childhood services and is just an expert in all things CH Early Childhood um we have a representative from a private school in Northwest Arkansas Cole Lester from Shiloh Shiloh Christian um she uh is also an early childhood expert and um represents both the faith-based community and schools Early Childhood centers within a school um within more of a larger K12 system um we have John um Chad oh Chadwell Chadwell excuse me I want to get his name right he uh serves on the economic development Commission in um Jackson County so he represents the communities and larger uh businesses um Senator Jane English is new to the board she has always been a big advocate for early childhood and didn't hesitate when I asked her um specifically with
158legislation and things going through she's a great resource um Fay uh dismuke out of was childood Nance Center in um remind me the city Camden I believe uh runs a six-star center down there and it is phenomenal she is uh a whiz with grants and making um you know shoest string budgets turning it into gold so she's phenomenal um let's see that's five let me think who else um oh Morgan warington she is works on the governor staff uh used to be the education policy director um she's now moved on to bigger and better things but still is serving she's also the mother of two young children in child care actually should say child care one she just had a brand new baby in November I believe who joins her every day at the office
159and that's phenomenal so having um a representative from the governor's office as well as a brand new mom is just fabulous um let's see who else am I forting Jackie Goan who runs the uh Head Start Coalition so we've got Head Start representatives and I feel like I'm missing we have a family home child care here shayen Lane who runs a six-star family home Child Care Program that's nationally accredited similar there she uh it's just remarkable what she does and she's we're thrilled to have a representative um from family home child care anybody else feel like I'm missing somebody if I if I need no I should have had I could pull a list up but it might take me just as long to find that tab in my computer so um going from memory
160was probably faster yeah and we specifically chose each stakeholder based on the stakeholder list that was written and to learn so it was very strategic and and making sure that everybody was represented um and then we've added a few extras as well so um this unified Early Childhood care and education system um sort of bringing everybody into one department and division was critical especially under the leadership of secretary Lea who has um has been such a wonderful advocate for getting that implemented um and uh anyway let's dig again so I'm only going to go over just a few pieces it's a lengthy report and I wanted to just hit some highlights and some opportunities so I'm going to start um let's see right here so this page is what I mean when I say this
161is we are now positioned in a better spot than we've been in a long time being able to bring all these numbers together School Readiness assistance is our new um phrase raising for child care assistance from the CCD um ccdf grant that we get from the federal government Arkansas better chance has long been with the Department I shouldn't say long but it's been with the Department of Ed which meant that those two were separate until the learns act Head Start Early Head Start as a Federal grant that goes directly to private providers um having uh bringing Jackie and her office into the department of Ed now means that they're also with us the one piece of data we're missing is the one piece that didn't come over in the learns act and that um shows
162you right there how important it was to get everybody in the same house eidt is the early intervention day treatment it is through um Medicaid so it is so heavily regulated um through Medicaid that it really needed to stay in DHS it is um not going to be ignored by us at the subcommittee it's certainly a piece of the Early Childhood World um and we are working closely with um the secretary over there to try to get that data and to get some communic ation so that we can have a full Glimpse on a single page of the funding and the children that are being supported so this is huge we're thrilled to see that um in fact I just Monday was invited to visit with advocates in Tennessee they are considering making the same
163move and they're scared um understandably so there are hiccups in in any transition um but after hearing some of the stories in Arkansas and seeing the success and seeing how streamlined things can become um they're much more excited their biggest fear in doing this is and moving it into the department of Ed is pushed down and I've spoken about that too I don't want three-year-olds learning the way first graders do um and uh it needs to be developmentally appropriate so um ensuring them that that can happen and all these wonderful things can happen as well was was a fun opportunity and kind of getting to brag on us over here in Arkansas um so having this information in One Singular page is is huge it's going to give us an understanding of how money can
164move and shift and um ways that we can improve um next I wanted to look at some access numbers um let's see no let me go back I think it's I had it down as page 11 but now I don't know which where the numbers are sorry now I'm way off um I'm so sorry y'all that's why I shouldn't be giv the clicker dang and now I'm off the whole presentation um I'll just go off the cuff if you're F if you would like to flip in your page on page 11 we looked at um the number of providers by site type oh look at you doing it for me that's amazing thank you um on page 11 the number of providers by site type um one of the numbers that I want you to
165p pay attention to is the family home child care so in the early 2000s it's um we had over 900 we're now down to just 204 that is alarming to us this is not the slide that matches it may be slide 11 but um Slide the patches um it'll say um site uh Provider by site type I think something like that license yes right there so if you look um licensed and registered Family Care Home in the last year those numbers have continued to drop one of the things that we're doing is looking into the why in some of these things so we know this what we see up here is just the tip of the iceberg we had to look into okay why are family home childcare not getting license why are they not
166engaging with us why are there fewer of them out there um one of the things that we believe is happening is that our licensing is not designed for them and for um sort of non-traditional schools monor nature things like that so over the last year and a half we have engaged with pillars license excuse me pillars um Group which is evaluating our licensing and um helping us rework that um again getting all these numbers in the same place is what enabled us to kind of dig into the numbers so we can dig into the why so we can eventually find Solutions um the next page I'd like you to go to is says 23 on here but it is um talks about the site type and their quality rating so you'll see um that's it
167site type by quality rating just I want to mess it up again um in that I want you to look specifically at that EID number um based on these numbers 93% of our eidt centers are in the one to three star range now eidt works with our most vulnerable populations those with diagnosed delays those with um those that need that extra support that's of concern to me and I mentioned it's not in our unified but we are going to pay attention to that um that's definitely a larger discussion for another time but it is on our radar so I just wanted to point that out to y'all as well um next if you'll look at uh the context on page for me it says page 18 let's see oh I'm sorry I skipped the workforce
168let's look at um Workforce data this is an opportunity as well we don't have enough data to truly understand our Workforce um one of the things that we also know and this was hard a hard pill for me to swallow I'm very institutionalized I love a good degree I love a good certification but we know that that does not directly correlate to student outcomes we also know that we cannot pay Early Childhood teachers in our current system for a doctorate a M's maybe even a four-year degree it is unreasonable for us to ask every Early Childhood teacher to go and spend a fortune getting these degrees um and then to make sometimes minimum wage so um we've got to start looking at Workforce and compensation based on what we know to be student lead to
169uh positive student outcom so we're looking into ways that we can um offer bonuses and compensations for compensation for those that are showing positive interactions um the other thing with Workforce data our professional development registry right now does track teachers and their um license their certifications but it uh is a not a great measure of it for instance I'm in there three times because of three different emails so it's counting me three times there are instead of of correcting or it's just messy data it's a little foggy um so that's an opportunity something we're going to work on um lastly I want to look at the context page let's see if I can find that there we go shoot I did it again how do you go backwards oh there we go okay so in
170context that very first first bullet more children are served now than before using our ccdf funding so the very first thing that the subcommittee dug into was the ccdf grant uh there are a lot of federal federal requirements Federal Regulations there are also a lot of levers and slides and switches that Arkansas can turn off or turn on or move and we dug into all those different things that can shift and because of those decisions because the board appr proved them we are now serving 26 more than 2600 more students than we were previously this is more than we have served since 2018 this is huge that's more families working that's more kids in care um it's an increase of 177% just from the last year alone now what that does mean is that we're
171out of money we're now uh beginning to use a weit list and that can be disheartening because it a weight list gives the Optics of children not being served but guess what they weren't being served anyway fact 2600 that could have been were not being served so I'm thrilled that we are now maximizing the grant that we've been given here in Arkansas despite what the Optics of a weight list might bring um so we're celebrating that it also gives us a sense of urgency we have kids on a wait list we have kids that are ready to be served we have programs that are ready to serve them and it gives us a sense of urgency in finding that money and shifting those funds around from adults to more children so I'm excited about that
172as well um I guess that's about it for now I could go on for days but I won't stand any further between you and lunch so thank you I appreciate your time can I question yes of course oh I'm so excited somebody cares I mean it's very basically so don't get super excited okay well we were going back to the children served by the quality rating and you were talking about look at the e and how 95% um were in the 1 to three what is what are we looking at in the levels why is that a big well that is something that we're going to dig into later um you know Jacob talks about building a house one the systems Foundation is accreditation standards in early childhood it's licensing so we're working on the
173licensing from there we'll work on these other pieces quality rating is going to be one of those other pieces So currently our quality rating and Improvement system um you go in and you get a snapshot of a program program and that program is given essentially a grade A rating one star um is basically licensed uh two star is going to be a little bit above that three star a little bit above that we go all the way to six stars so um right now in writing high quality is three to six stars I disagree with that in my opinion it should be five to six stars there should be a mid quality and a low quality um but I also understand that it is uh economically level three is the most profitable because of ratios
174because of what tuition you can bring in versus how much you have to pay work for so we've got to dig into that and figure find a better way um in the meantime um programs are choosing to stay at level three because it's going to cost them too much to be high quality and they can't make up for it um however like I said with the IDT they are um funded differently they are better funded so I'd like to hold them to a higher standard and I think more of them should be in the higher quality ratings did the did the center number concern you as well yes but I also understand um because of that um it's it's just a complicated complex situation right now and yeah I'd love everybody to be at six
175stars but um these are private businesses too not everybody wants to run at a six-star level um but I do believe that every child should have the opportunity um to attend a six star if their family so chooses so a lot of them don't have that choice and that's not fair to our kids so what are some of the uh factors in the quality writing just generally that makes difference in one to three or four or five um T you probably speak to this a lot better our ratios is one of them but I'm going to let her um yeah let me let me talk about that one for a minute it's a great question so the current system is we use two national tools one's the environment writing scale it was developed out of
176Chapel Hill in North Carolina so it's very research-based heavy it looks at the environment Mr brag it really focuses on what's in that environment it's not a bad tool it was the only tool for a very very long time Across the Nation but the learns act calls for us to use use a new tool that's more predictive of child outcomes and so we're using class we're doing a pilot with a tool called class another National Tool uh developed out of Virginia and a lot of states and and communities are using this tool so class is more narrow and it's focused on teacher child interactions it's focused on what's happening in that classroom um and in the report you'll see data about some of that pilot I think we had 182 programs in cohorts one and
177two and our scores are really good because we have a long history of doing quality with the former tool but it's starting to get more predictive of child outcomes but it also tells us areas as Miss Ken's pointed out of improvement that we can do like instructional support for example is a lower score in class typical of the first implementation for that tool like a lot of states and Head Start for example who uses that that was the lowest score for them but it tells us we need to push our professional development into that area so that we can support instructional support I forgot one thing that I'm that I absolutely love it's my favorite question too oh good okay so if you'll look on um page 10 in your packet there's a slide there
178with some really pretty colors and boxes and that is our very first Glimpse at those class domain scores so each domain is something different whether it's instructional strategies or positive climate things like that and I want you to look at where we fell now to be fair to Arkansas these numbers are going to be higher than we expect for the entirety of this day this was a voluntary pilot based program so um those that uh engaged were those that were excited to engage so most likely these are the ones doing a really good job and saying come assess us um so we do expect for these scores once we implement it to go down but you'll also see two very clear opportunities here right now with professional development um we're doing a bit of reactionary
179hey I hear this is a problem let's create something here I noticed that teacher welfare since Co is down let's do something here and instead we need to be more proactive but we didn't really understand what was happening in the classrooms this class assessment tells us exactly what's happening and exactly where PD should be um focused so I'm super excited about using this um and a very prescriptive uh guide for how we will use professional development dollars so perhaps we can even shift more more money back down to kids on your on your quality rating Schools page or that page where it talks about schools I was just looking to see who was in the 4 to five to six level are does that also include private yes it does so um Tennessee for instance
180has a requirement that if you are licensed you must participate in this quality rating system in their quality rating system Arkansas does not so for a long time my previous school did not engage in QRS they were like we're doing fine on our own we don't really need to engage with the state and for our data it is critical that we understand the landscape the child counts um so we're trying to encourage more schools though they don't have to to participate the only it is required if you accept um public funds but a lot of programs don't in fact I think it's just a little under half so it's a huge chunk of our services and I think that's I think that's kind of the flip too that we're being pushed to do is create
181a system in which it incentivize folks to want to be a part of it right so even when you look at the the K12 between public schools and private schools you know incentivizing private schools and and and public schools to want to do something and be in the same group whether that's professional development whether it's teacher training giving people opportunities but not necessarily starting to dictate to the private World on how they do their everyday business right same thing in this world um private providers and public schools have been working in this space for a long time and there's a lot of lessons to learn from this space for K12 but I also think there's some lessons in K12 that we need to figure out like how do we open that up more so it's
182not so separate and you had a question no I think that was answer oh okay great very good report I'm just so excited that we're starting to understand this and move forward it's um certainly we're are in a position now to make some real change and always my gratitude um I say this often but you know Stacy's very very involved in this and in the weeds like I am and I can do that in one area Stacy's able to do it in all the areas I don't know how but yes she is phenomenal so thank you and thank you Tanya for your help along the way well I appreciate you bring more of this Focus to our board I think that's really important you've been able to do that and I appreciate you very much
183to okay does anyone else have a board report I know you do Sarah did you have a report this time Sarah do you have a report this time award report by any chance no I don't thank you okay Mr Henderson would you report this time I do not okay glad you were both able to join us today Mr mlin did I say that right close enough we know what you right that's why my kids call me coach Mack because I can't get it right no for Masten you can bar Smith anytime um just start off it Phils it feels like it's only been a couple of weeks since I spoke with all of you because I've been that busy busy but in reality it's been over two months but uh just glad to be back
184here uh just to start off right before Christmas I had the honor to uh deliver the commencement fall commencement to uh SAU graduate students um as somebody who was on the six-year plan to a bachelor's delivering a commencement speech was never on my radar nor on my bucket list but uh very thankful to the MU Rider family and Dr Connie Wilson down there and Dr Goa for um putting it on my bucket list and and allowing me to mark uh mark it off uh was truly an honorable experience for me so very thankful for that then just a couple weeks later I was back in Magnolia uh speaking to um a bunch of great students at the Educators Rising state conference uh these are students that are in pre-education programs uh you see the young
185ladies right there on on the left uh with the state officers for the student organization we talk a lot about being day one ready uh after speaking with those three high school students I believe they would probably be day day one ready the day after they graduate uh just a very impressive group um even uh just last week at CTE day um meeting state officers there and then I spoke to uh the DECA state conference earlier this week it's so refreshing to see students who have a path and have a dream and in a plan and uh I encourage you to attend as many of those State conferences as you can because you really get to interact with those students and it really really fills our hearts with hope again and um you see the
186differences being made on a daily basis then the big trip in January of course um national championship game was a weekl long event during during Atlanta uh that's my buddy Mark low he's the Ohio State teacher of the year who just happens to teach video production as well so on day one we were just like that way a year ago but then you throw on the fact he's an Ohio State grad Ohio State fan was really awesome experience uh for him it was cool for me to be right there in experience with him but you know we've all been to the events and on field recognition events at sporting events sometimes you pay attention sometimes you don't so I was wondering how this would go over um you couldn't see this at home but this
187was right before the national anthem if you were watching and they and they lined all of us on the 10 yard line on the field and this is as everything's prepping for the national anth and I was fully prepared for you know three4 of the stadium not to be paying attention there's 70,000 people gave us a standing Novation and just an amazing experience for for all of us and and really hit home I don't know if there was a dry eye of the entire cohort but uh very special night uh CTE day at the capital which is watch our video on the other day and then some personal news for me that I'm excited to share with you uh recently I was um it was announced I was named to the presidential leadership Scholars Program
188um some of you may be familiar with it it's a it's it's a learning program that's facilitated by The Clinton Library the bush 43 Library the Bush 41 Library as well as lbj's library and uh this is the 10th cohort the 10th year that they've been doing it but uh there goal is to just um to teach leadership through the lens of their administrations and so it's an opportunity for us we're going to be able to learn from uh President Bush President Clinton as well as members of all four administrations uh we'll here in a couple weeks we'll be in Dallas we'll get to hear from uh President Bush and then we'll be back here in March at the library as well really need opportunity but what I'm most excited about is how we're able
189to bring what we've learned back and apply into our own communities each of us um like I said there's 57 of us I'm the only teacher um so we're talking about CEOs of nonprofits uh um all sectors cover but each of us have to have we're required to have a presidential project uh that we're working on throughout the the co throughout the program and it's a project that we we we required to implement into our own communities for civic good and so you heard Ross mentioned earlier about work based learning uh opportunities my project is based on creating work-based learning opportunities for students in in rural parts of our state um you know it's it's one thing to be in central Arkansas Northwest Arkansas where it's easy to I'm not saying it's easy but there's
190more more ability to form Partnerships with industry well in some of our communities the school might be the only main industry but that doesn't mean we can't form Partnerships with local government with city government with uh count government local businesses to create some learning opportunities for our students so that's what my project will be based on I'm excited to come back and implemented my own community and hopefully we can scale it out to be Regional and even across the state we have any public comments coordinate by any chance do we have any public comments or Mary okay I guess this meeting is no we've got she's going to do the um commissioner's report for a legislative update I'm sorry I didn't know that he thought he was gonna do that for us later we're expecting
191as much enthusiasm well and um secretary leeva apologizes for not being here I'm sure all of you know we're writing the the Heat of the legislative session and he is up at the capital um representing and and making doing his magic um so uh nothing to report on his behalf but I did want to take a few minutes just to kind of talk to you all about the legislative session um before I dive into that though I was going to recognize um Madame chair if you don't mind um Ken Bragg and I know he's been very involved as well and Dr Arnold has been very um very involved in attendance and so if there's anything you all wanted to share before I got started yeah I just wanted to uh commend secretary Aliva for his
192presentation before the uh joint House and Senate education committee recently he about the nape scores I don't know if you could have painted a clearer picture of where we are why we are where we are where we're going and how we're going to get there it it was just uh he was a well prepared just remarkable presentation and I know that a lot some of those leg legislators that did not support the learns act I think we're impressed with what what the learns Act is is doing and and going to do and I I just want to make you know officially commend him for that presentation so yeah he' appreciate that I thought it was wonderful and I know Mary shared that with us so I hope all of us have had a chance to
193look at it um I'd love to have his PowerPoint presentation yeah we can make that available yeah because it's definitely I agree Mr BR it should be required viewing for all public school he'll never be accused of sugar coating that's for sure is it is it on YouTube or on the State website maybe I mean I think it's recorded because I went back and watched it later yeah as a public meeting I believe they do record them and keep them main maintained on there um but we can definely can go to the legislative website and look up the committee history that day and it'll it'll be it's wonderful anyways thank you for bringing that upate it Dr Arnold did you want to add echo of that and the also add that my perception of the
194House Education committee and the Senate education committee is that they get it and that they're supportive and that they're working hard on our behalf absolutely well um I'm not going to go into a lot of detail again I think most of you know um the session started last month um um we kind of started off um the first day with the governor giving her stateof the state address and setting forth what some of her priorities are um she definitely uh expressed her commitment to higher education and increasing access for all students to Advanced opportunities for Accelerated learning opportunities um and for making uh making it easier removing some of those barriers that might be in place and so um I think you will definitely see her legislative priorities come out very soon um and get
195more information about that um she also made mention of um making summer EVT so like some of the free meal programs more accessible and continuing those the free lunch and breakfast programs making those financially sustainable um and she's done that by making available some of the medical marijuana funds um to these programs and in fact uh Senator DM filed I'm going to look it up here real quick um Senate Bill 59 um recently and it has made its way through the Senate it um and at least through House Education committee um so that every student in public school has available to them a free breakfast um it's the same breakfast that everyone else gets so there's no singling anyone out but even if they don't qualify for the free or reduced lunch they're going to
196have breakfast available to them um several Educators testified at committee you know about a student can't learn if the the The Sounds in their stomach are louder than the teacher and how important it is to make sure that students are there and that we're meeting even just those basic needs we provide them a computer and pencil and paper um it was important to provide that breakfast to them as well so that they can um have the nutrition and energy they need to be there and learn so that was something I know that was very important to her um she also pointed out in her State of the State address um her continued commitment to no cell phones in schools um I'm sure I know some of you attended and most of you have heard she
197did some presentations with Jonathan height the the author of The anxious Generation Um and the dangers and and the impact of cell phones and screen time on students and so um working along with um Senator Tyler de um and representative John Eubanks they also um filed Senate Bill 142 the Bell tobell no cell act um which would prohibit the use of cell phones in K12 Public Schools um it doesn't mean that kids can't have them they just need to be inaccessible so whether that's in a backpack a locker a pouch that's completely up to the school district um we just want to make sure that kids are focused on learning and not being distracted by their phones during during instructional time um so those were some of the the priorities that the governor set out
198what I handed out to you all is just kind of a very high level summary of what has been filed so far again this does not go into detail um as of a couple of days ago only two education related bills have gone through the whole process meaning they've passed the house they've passed the Senate and they were signed by the governor and are now enacted so one of those had to do with tuition waivers for National Guard solders soldiers and Airmen um currently they already could get um tuition assistance to ition waivers to attend public colleges and universities well now that extends to postsecondary certificates or credentials um the governor has of course also made um made it known about her commitment to Workforce and increasing our Workforce and making sure that we're supporting
199that as much as we are postsecondary education um so there was that expansion of that that w w tuition waiver program um there was also act 25 which is a merger between the University of Arkansas and East Arkansas Community College um most of our community colleges already fall under one of the two University Systems University of Arkansas or Arkansas State University so this just brings East Arkansas college under that UA umbrella um on the next slide starts the list of other um bills that have been filed that concern um K12 education again I did not go into any of the details this is just to give you an idea of the number of bills that have already been filed even though we're only a little over a month in we expect to still see a
200lot more um and it can cover anything from you'll see school start date to standards to um mental health teacher contracts employee contracts literacy tutoring grants um if you have questions about any of these you can easily access everything on the the legislative website um or you can reach out to me feel free to reach out to me if you have questions or or to Mary and she can get through um I'm also going to throw Ken out there because I know he uh he is being very actively involved and keeping up with these and so if you just have questions about what does this actually do um after all of this is over of course we always provide a summary uh for school districts and for you all of these are all the bills
201that passed and these are all the new changes that are going to occur in education um but this is just to give you an idea of what has been filed so far um one more that I do want to point out is Senate Bill 206 um we worked with representative Burks and Senator croll to increase the amount of our literacy tutoring grants that was something that um was created by the learns act and we made $500 available to some of our lowest performing students so that they could get uh tutoring assistance um we saw a great use of those but not as much as we had anticipated and we had funds left over so we increased that amount to $1,500 um $500 was a great start and students were able to get tutoring but with
202$1,500 they can continue that tutoring and and more students can um access that and hopefully help increase their their academic um performance um on the very last slide is a few just last bills that deal with higher education um even though those don't impact you directly just thought you might want to see that there um again are a few because we we track everything from early prek to to higher education post-secondary education um and and Workforce and so if again if you have any questions about any of these whatsoever we're happy to answer any questions um but that's all I had to present to you today Cradle to Career thank you that's right Cradle to Career that's what Jacob always says um Athletics be involved in any of these or is that like a separate
203issue because I know there's like three bills for Arkansas Athletics but know whether those would be on here or not um I think there are a few I know that got included so like there was one about coaches and Athletics personnel and their access to locker rooms and where students might be that was house spill 125 um I can CLE I'm trying to like refresh my email because I can't get the bill numbers but it was basically about um athletic transfers between schools school districts and then from public to private I didn't know if that would fall in this WR or not um it probably is something if it was filed in the last two days it probably didn't make the list but I I will continue to keep you guys updated and so again
204this was as of the 11th and things change every five minutes around here but um we'll we'll continue to keep you updated on again bills that are being filed that impact education they're not all going to pass lots of lots of things get filed because we didn't include everything on here that's been filed um a lot of the times bills get filed that don't ever even make it to the committee for discussion sometimes people file things and then they they change their mind and don't run it um or you know for whatever reason they they just end up not making it to the house or the Senate and so didn't want to overwhelm you with them but um that is one that probably is going to make our our record if it has to do
205with a K12 institution a highed institution um or an early pre prek program we're probably tracking it in some way I'll find you CU if that would come on or not yeah it's out there but I checked with glance yesterday because looking for it and it hasn't been presented yet oh it hasn't okay okay can you update us on the four day five day um there has not been any legislation filed on school calendars yet okay do you see it coming I I anticipate yeah there's been a lot of discussion around that um and we've had some community communication with legislators I know that are very interested in that so I definitely anticipate something um we just haven't seen anything filed yet yeah we we're starting to get emails on I would imagine so I
206know we are as well okay thank you any other questions thank you good job chair someone might make a motion to close the meeting second and I think you guys 1230 right they've got lunch for you and then they're going to go you guys know 12:30 right well and that's why I was curious I