001e e e are youall getting set up getting set up frustration statements change thank you good morning welcome to the December State Board of Education meeting today it's a busy time of year I know Educators and staff here at the department are working hard and appreciate all you do we will start with a moment of silence thank you we're gonna start first this morning with the school board member recognition month we have thousands probably of school board members y all could tell us across the state um that serve their local districts and do a great public service to our state um here we have Travis Warren a school board member from Farmington and a asba board member to present the re resolution thank you for coming thank you whereas the quality of Education continues to
002be a Cornerstone of our state's prosperity and a key driver of Arkansas's future success and whereas education forms the foundation for the future of our children and the growth and advancement of our our society as a whole and whereas Arkansas remains steadfast in its commitment to providing its more than 475,000 public school students with the highest quality education available and whereas the dedicated members of Arkansas School Board serve as the vital connection between the community and the classroom ensuring that the needs of the students are met and that the interest of families are represented and whereas these public servants elected by their local communities Tire tirelessly advocate for policies and practices that prioritize Student Success offering their time expertise and judgment without compensation and whereas the Arkansas School boards Association and the Arkansas state board
003of education collaborate to support and guide the state's more than 1,500 locally elected School Board official members who make a critical contribution to public education and whereas the month of January provides an opportunity to honor and express appreciation for Arkansas school board members recognizing the significant time energy and talent they invest in service to our schools and communities now therefore be it resolved that the Arkansas state board of education hereby recognizes and salutes the members of local school boards of Education by proclaiming the month of January 2025 as Arkansas School Board member recognition month thank you thank you Mr Warren thank you for coming in and we have Miss Tammy ringer here as well I know that you all are doing your conferen this week so you have a lot of people here in Lok
004I wish you all the best of luck as you do that and appreciate your service to the state thank you up next we have Miss sarasini to come to present good morning chair board uh secretary ala this morning we're going to celebrate our first kind of non-traditional administrator license and I am so excited uh when I first brought this to Deputy Smith um act 7:32 this last legislative session and learn kind of opened up the flexibility and we're excited we currently have and had had and have we've had the pptl which is a provisional professional teaching license for a long time where if you're someone in a profession a medical profession and you would like to teach in a school there is a route for you go and not having to go back to school
005but we've never had this for administrators and so like lots of times we get administrators that may already have their doctorate and it's really hard for us to say you've got to go back and do this this and this because there's really not a pathway and so we have made a pathway for those who already have a master's or above degrees that focus on leadership and so today we're going to recognize our first recipient of a provisional pathway uh for administrators and that is Dr Tran and he is the southern region superintendent for friendship Education Foundation and superintendent for the Marvel elain school district and he is the first educator to complete this program so today we want to recognize him as being our first and uh he's worked really hard and so today we
006are going to give him his teaching or his administrator lcons exciting exciting um first I just want to say thank you to the Department of Education Miss car U Miss kie sasini Deputy Commissioner Stacy because they've been instrumental in helping um myself and everybody else to get what they need to get and especially for the students um I don't know what else to say but thank you so much with everything congratulations and I'm glad that you're able to celebrate this because hopefully there's others listening that are going to start asking you questions to see what your pathway was and and and what you learned along the way um but it's amazing that the state has opened this up to support that yes comments yeah I wanted to congratulate you uh the six you know when
007I first met you I was asking that question yes okay so you know are you certified all those things um and I'm going to follow suit because I was one of those teachers that wanted to get into administration had a MERS that had all the qualifications accept the additional requirement and so I chose not to so I'm thrilled um that the state is figuring out that flexibility and getting folks that not only want to be in the role but are qualified um exactly what they need and so this is one of those examples where instead of saying oh no we can't do that we said what do you need from us to get that done so I'm thrilled and I'm thrilled that it's you so congratulations thank you so much thank you so much so
008than I just want to say congratulations I know when we talk about the work that our state has done and our board has done with implementing Arkansas learns there's so many different Provisions that focus on empowering parents and raising teacher salaries and early learning and literacy but one of the little pieces that was put into that robust comprehensive education Reform Bill was the ability to do external operators and partner with struggling districts in an Innovative way that we've never engaged in as a state and I know this board many May were were on this board when we were doing board meetings in Marvel Lane and it was a dire situation and um the Friendship uh group came in and said we we want to we want to see how this works and kind of went
009out and led the the charge of reimagining how we support struggling schools and you were right there as a practitioner and expert from day one and walked into what I would consider a dire situation and have really just changed the belief in the community and the expectation that students can learn and providing opportun for them to Excel and um the the the journey is not complete but you're making a a lot of progress and we're really proud of all what you have taken on um to make this happen so congratulations no thank you for that um and just to give you an an update I sent this to um Deputy Stacy and and michila we had a um a partner who visited Marvel Lane and after the visit they sent an email to the principal
010and if you don't mind I want to read to you just a little bit of a snippet of what they saw at Marvel Lane um if I could get it oh here it is so I'm going to Omit some names CU you know uh uh trying to keep the um privacy um but this is from John Allison who is a uh a partner of us in helping us doing mathematics over at Marvel um he said when he visited School I really enjoyed my visit to your school today thank you for welcoming me it was great watching the teacher with her students she will has very high expectations and insists that her students learn and learn correctly I told the teacher that I have been in a lot of schools different schools this year and your
011students are well above many students all over the state in ability um they also better behav and more respectful than students in many of the schools where have been um I also noticed from your morning announcements and overall appearance of the school that high expectations are not limited to the classroom it is a over arching culture of your school I've taught in schools that climb from the depths to unforeseen Heights and I've taught in schools that crash from Great Heights to the lowest Park of a dark Valley what set them apart was a expectations I always believe that high expectations are a necessary foundation for school improvement from what I saw today you certainly have that Foundation that's amazing thank you for sharing that thank you for the work that you're doing um here in
012Marvel Lane and across the state and congratulations again thank you yes we'll take a picture with you and your new certification thank you you two con okay with that are there any changes to the agenda don't believe I've heard any then we will get started on our action agenda it's very short today first we have the Mountainburg School District request for a waiver Miss waram thank you for coming today oh and I'm remiss to not say Miss Woods is on Zoom um so I'll be monitoring that if she has questions and I believe is mberg on Zoom as well no they were here in person oh great thank you s Atwell good well good morning hope Worsham assistant Commissioner of public school accountability for the Department um I am here to request a uh present
013a waiver for um Standard 1 A5 which is class size uh for the mountain Burg School District they are requesting this for one year the district did receive this same waiver last year for one year and are back this year requesting the same waiver superintendent Atwell is here to answer any questions that you may have regarding the request thank you superintendent would you like to make your remarks we appreciate you coming in today you're welcome I appreciate your consideration in this manner we want to welcome and accept any school choice or transfer requests we get uh but in a small District it's hard to up staff whenever our enrollment goes over a threshold and so with 52 students in third grade in two sections we feel that it's the best interest of the students to
014avoid disruption and um we would have much difficulty in foring and Staffing a position at this point in the year so I appreciate your consideration thank you board members I'll go to my right first and ask for questions questions to my left questions I have a question so this is the second year in a row that we're it's you're requesting a one-year waiver is was last year's for the same cohort of students I mean are we just following them along no ma'am last year's was third grade also so those students are in the fourth grade now okay and our numbers were at 48 at the end of the year and uh through the enrollment and transfer request process we ended at 52 um and we've held at that number this year so I also wonder
015about the timing of this you know and I understand that it would be difficult to make a hire at this point in the school year that are we kind of like off SK off cycle in some way as far as looking at at this meet like should we be talking about this in the summertime rather than in December does that make sense I guess not so I can address the spin can request the waiver at any time period and so we are always monitoring um enrollment and when enrollments and fluctu fluctuate so um I believe that the um overage from our side the first time we noticed it was in September okay which was after the school year started um and that's whenever superintendent Atwell reached out to us with um questions about requesting a
016waiver but the district can request the waiver at any point throughout the school year we did change the standards so that um enrollment has to be based off we we check for ensuring that you're meeting the class size requirements as of the October one enrollment so that they can better plan and maybe not have to have so many wers throughout the year okay thank you M for I ask you a question while you're here um it was unclear to me is this a standards waiver request or what we' formally call an act 1240 waiver request so it is a standards waiver request it's for that one particular standard and for the time period of one year okay and we've done this before for class size that is correct why this type versus the ACT 1240
017waiver um there are different requirements for ACT 1240 waivers one of them being the link length of time that they're being requested for um and because these we would anticipate that schools are able to staff accordingly um those these have always been one-ear waivers for that reason it's just for the the the period of time to ensure that we can get Staffing figured out and then may be better planned for the next year thank you for members Miss Hunter questions Mr wood are are the teachers okay with this yes sir we have a building guiding Coalition that mates and reviews and they look at Staffing recommendations and I met with the teachers in question and U they felt like what they do for 25 they can do for 26 sure and it would be more
018disruptive to have those classes split and changed at this point are are the teachers offered more compensation not at this time okay I would encourage you to do that in my opinion Miss ke Dr Arnold questions questions to my right no okay thank you I'm Sorry Miss Woods questions apologize I didn't get to you with that any more okay with that then if no more questions the floor will be open for a motion there is a move to approve the waiver is there a second second there's a second any questions or comments all in favor say I motion passes thank you thank you and thank you again for coming in today next we will have Miss James for a plsb case that we have today good morning Whitney James with the Department um this case
019is one that was on the consent agenda last month that uh was pulled for a review uh we sent notice of today's review hearing to the educator and her attorney and her attorney has indicated that neither um She nor the attorney planed to appear today in person so typically we would swear in the educator anybody speaking on her behalf that's not an attorney since she is not here I can give you a quick um overview of this case um this was an educator who was working as an intern or preer teacher the bismar school district um she admitted that she exchanged in the um that she exchanged inappropriate photographs with a student um via text message um again she was a pre-service teacher at the time which is what brought her under the plsb umbrella
020uh the student was 18 at the time the photographs were exchanged uh the educator had code of ethics training in August of 2023 and and the exchange of photographs happened in November of 2023 uh there were no criminal charges filed that were aware of because the student was 18 and I don't we don't have any evidence that there was actual physical contact and uh there was no true finding from DHS um the educator did self-report her actions and the exchange of photographs to her administrator after um she received a threat from her boyfriend if you don't tell them my will type of thing um the recommendation from the ethics subcommittee was a level three public notification of Ethics violation which is the equivalent of suspension of license for three years followed by level two public
021notification which is the equivalent of probation for two years a $500 fine training reading written Reflections and quarterly reports um the educator requested an evidentiary hearing and then withdrew that request uh to accept the recommendation of the ethics sub committee it went on the consent agenda and then you all uh voted to pull it last month any questions thank you m James can you remind us so even though the educator is not here we will still have to take a vote today yes ma'am what is that and this is where we take three separate votes correct could you walk us through those three yes ma'am absolutely and then we'll open up for discussion so there will be three separate motions the first one being did the educator violate the code of ethics and and if
022the educator did violate the code of ethics what are the standards and this one we're talking about standards one and two um if the code of ethics was violated we'll need a motion to accept or modify the recommendation of the U ethics subcommittee and then you will state what you wish for the sanction to be and then the third motion is regarding the rationale um you can use the rationale of the ethics subcommittee or provide your own rationale and I have that here if you like a refresher on what their rationale was they did recommend the equivalent of suspension so if you uh chose to modify the sanction you might want to also modify the rationale it's up to you thank you we'll start with questions and we can get to that Mr Henderson Mr
023Brad questions okay Mr all questions can you explain to us what happens with public notification yes ma'am that would that would be public in als's and it would it would show um it would show suspension or revocation in als's I'm not aware of what that is in the Arkansas educator ler system so um anyone that looked up her name in that system would see that she has a sanction and also of course we would have a u a state board order on our website Carly sasini just so you know before a district hires they are uh it's in statute that they look within our system and it will have a banner in red that says suspension or probation and so it's very evident when you go to hire someone uh and they look it up
024in our system and that's something that they are to do by law so that that'll be up for three years is that if there is is if there is uh if the recommendation is suspension that will be up for three years um and then there will be probation after that so it'll be up for a minimum of five years if you accept the previous recommendation um additionally um she will not be eligible to work in a school in any capacity while on suspension Miss Hunter questions so I always get confused on this what about other states if she chose to attempt to work in another state yes ma'am they would be able to see through NASDAQ U that she has a suspension in Arkansas assuming that you want to accept the recommendation you're always uh
025you free to modify the recommendation but either way whatever it is if there's a sanction other states would be able to see that more questions Mr wood questions um how how old was she when early 20s early 20s the student was 18 she was completing her internship at the time that this occurred he was a senior I supp he was a senior yes and what were the natures of the what was the nature of the photographs nude photographs um the student my understanding is that the student approached her and they started texting and talking and then they exchanged nude photographs each of them sent nude photographs more question Miss Ken um so the recommendation from the subcommittee I'm reading right now and I want to be sure I get it right was yes ma'am suspension
026or can yes ma'am the equivalent of suspension she doesn't have a license so we would call it level three public notification yes ma'am so without a license um I guess what are you suspending her ability to be counted in ratios or or tell me we're suspending that she cannot work in a public school or Charter okay as opposed to um there's nothing to revoke so that's um and if she doesn't meet the criteria that's set forth all of the the fines and everything that the subcommittee put forth she will never be able to get her license till that is complete so um this is such a unique situation because if this were these were two adults in somewhere in society outside of this power Dynamic we wouldn't be having this discussion but because that Dynamic
027was there and these standards I believe were violated we'll vote on in a minute but um it is I still feel it's our duty to protect children that she could potentially interact with at a later date and so I guess I'm not sure that um can we block something from getting a future license you see what I mean there's nothing to revoke so I wanted to know what is um perhaps a more severe statement that we could make as a board that this was unacceptable without does that make sense you would have to do the level that's the equivalent of revocation okay number four yes she yes ma'am if she had a level for public notification she would not be able to get her license for at right she would not be able to get
028she would not be able to get her license so she just becomes ineligible like yes ma' definitely yes ma'am and can you tell me a little bit more about the rationale of the committee that decided on three as opposed to four for when yes ma'am so they did find that she violated standards one and two um they have listed that she was in her internship of course they exchanged nude photographs um the student was 18 years old and they thought that there was a low negative impact on the student and that was based on what the parent had told the district that we're fine with it he's a grown boy and uh we don't want to participate in the investigation or have anything to do with this um no evidence of physical contact uh the
029interactions lasted one month uh the parent of the student was not concerned regarding the interactions the educator self reported um to her supervisor and took ownership of her actions um and then she knew or I'm sorry she should have known her actions violated the code of ethics she had just had the the code of ethics training in August so I guess the thing that I keep coming back to is the very clear sanctioning guidelines that had this been a licensed educator regardless of Age based on their um the understood relationship between a teacher and a student it would be revocation I mean that's as clear as day so I guess what I'm leaning towards is that um get my notes that we um that we vote that standard two were violated um that we would
030modify it to that level four with the rationale of um just simply the guidelines that are here that would be my thought Dr kener addressed my questions and concern and summarized what I was hoping to accomplish as well thank you Miss Woods questions by you thank you Dr Arnold okay can I ask yeah certainly did did you say that this exchange happened for one month it wasn't a onetime thing it was more than one text message um and I don't I don't believe it lasted it the relationship in in total probably lasted about one month I don't really know how long we didn't have the text messages she did admit that she exchanged them but there were multiple text messages may I ask questions along that so some times we do get the text messages
031why were they not received in this case I am I am not sure I don't know if they had been deleted by the time that she okay that she came forward to the school uh but she did she did self-report but um her her romantic partner or um I don't know if it was her boyfriend um found out about the text messages and told her you know you if you don't report this you know there you know there will be a consequence and at that point she came forward they likely were deleted and again you know the the students parents did not want to cooperate or provide anything okay yes and DHS did not uh pick this up because he was 18 and there wasn't any evidence of a physical relationship okay but without text
032messages there's a vacuum of information um more questions board members one other thing I'm concerned with is the absence of their presence today either her or her lawyer um was there a rationale given um just how I suppose did they reach out and go we're not interested or you know what was the exchange like we did send the hearing notice and we reached out just for our purposes to find out you know is she going to appear just so we're prepared and her attorney responded that they did not plan to appear says a lot Mr Henderson yeah just to clarify with regards to the recommendations we talking three years or five looking at my it would be three years of the equivalent of suspension followed by two years of the equivalent of probation um for
033the subcommittee's recommendation if it is a level if you vote to give a level four public notification that's the equivalent of a permanent revocation she would not be able to get her license or work in a public school or Charter any more questions or comments Miss Woods I'll check in with you again okay question Mr BR yes sir according to the timeline she she went through ethics training in August and then this occurred long after that yes our office provided ethics training to her class at the University in August Are there specific instances in ethics training or is it I I just don't understand how somebody could go through ethics training and uh one of our investigators was at that training and she said that they spent over an hour on standard one and in
034appropriate interactions with students thank I would like to address that we are flipping our um redoing our training because I don't think that one time is enough that it needs to be embedded in the program so as we are making tweak St our state review for our Ed prep programs we're now going to put that part in our uh State review as one of the standards and that we can pull data to look to see uh investigations from which EP because it needs to be embedded and not just a one time and you're done because that's what we're seeing and we just met last week brainstormed and uh hopefully we will be able to update you in the next month or two and reveal what our training will be and what the expectations would be
035in our Ed prep programs because again I think one and done is not enough and that's what we're seeing thank you question Mr so with respect to ethics training I mean in the Ed prep program they go through that before they enter a ever enter a classroom is that correct that is correct they are supposed to but again um as we are evolving with our state review and our uh science of reading audits we're looking under the hood and we're really seeing some trends that we haven't and so we have gone through 13 uh the over the past year and this is where we're seeing um what we we need to CH to change at our level to ensure our students are safe and our candidates are fully aware of what they need to go
036in day one ready because I feel that with social media and all the devices we are learning that times are different when I went through versus what's now and so I know that we need to change as well and that's what we're seeing and we hope to uh provide those guidelines and those um resources for them to use throughout and not just have us come and do a training it really needs to be embedded um within their courses and appropriate places within their courses agreed and I I'll say too um not that this is defendable in any way shape or form but you know it it has it can be a little confusing I guess for those candidates because they too are still students um and but in the setting they are someone who is
037of authority and so they have to recognize that they are uh transitioning also in their roles so um I no I don't understand it but I do understand that particular uh Dynamic so thank you for that yes me ask one more question the P LSB sanctioning guidelines I know these are just guidelines and they're not hard yes ma'am are these public Ma and are these shared with Educators during any sort of training they are public and um I mean I know that our office always when we've done training we always go over those and yes they are shared okay yes ma'am thank you board members any further questions or comments I just want to clarify had this been a a fully certified teacher um same actions it would be level four correct if they had
038a license it would be revocation yes we would call it revocation I think secretary Le and I spoke about this off topic a while ago and he said you know in his training they looked at specific scenarios and this is one of those perfect scenarios that needs to be embedded in that training because it is such a it's an odd thing where we come I believe we need to come down firmly and DHS is like well you didn't really violate anything but our standards are very different and the situation is very different so um hoping that we can add specific scenarios this might be the perfect one and recent enough that it's relevant yes and we just had a full board meeting on Friday and we discussed of really looking at uh the sanctions and
039really going through that process and we had Rich discussion and I know in the subcommittee I don't sit on that but I know Whitney and her team they worked with them as well because we want more clarity and more consistency yes and I will add that in the training she received it was clarified that code of ethics applies to you when you're an intern I I find it shocking even considering her status as a college student and um his status as an 18-year-old senior in high school I I find it shocking that it would have to be told to her that that that is inappropriate um I I I I support the the mo the most strenuous penalty that we can impose to prevent her from being a teacher in the future only because this
040is such a demonstration of lack of judgment and I don't I just don't think that we can trust her in Arkansas Public classrooms in the future um you know I hope that she learns from this and and and recovers from it has a fantastic career as a high upstanding individual in another field but I think we have to protect our class rooms from people like this and I think that um there needs to be a strong message sent to even college students who are looking forward to a future career in education that there is a broad uh separation and the relationship with the students that you teach and that separation is growing you know we we are expecting even further distance in the relationship between teacher and student uh maybe than was expected 20 years
041ago and so I hope that the culture of uh the classroom for future educators will be all kinds of hands off stay all kinds of a way and just keep things extremely high level professional uh to prevent stuff like this from happening yes sir okay so I'll make a motion that we um affirm that uh this educator violated standards one and two okay there's a motion by Miss Keenan and remember there will be a set of three motions the first um is that standards one and two were violated is there a second second a second by Miss Hunter questions or comments all in favor say I any oppose motion passes so I'll make a motion that we modify the recommendations of the plsb board is that correct okay and two two what oh okay I'm
042sorry modify and we wish it to be a level four notice is that what it's sorry there's a motion by Miss Keener to modify the sanction to be a level four public notification yes ma'am is there a second second a second by Mr Rollins questions or comments okay all in favor say I I any oppose motion passes third motion is rational and I'll make a motion that um we explain the rationale to be um based on the plsb sanctioning guidelines that it was confirmed that there was communication about sexual relationships sexual pictures and pl a relationship after the student graduates there's a motion by Miss Keener with a rationale is there a second second a second by Mr Henderson any questions or comments okay all in favor say I I I any oppose motion passes
043just to clarify is that in addition to the previous rationale or is that a new rationale well the rationale that was given were reasons that it shouldn't be level four so I modified it using level four to explain the reasoning that it should be is that yes ma'am so we will make that a new rationale okay yes ma'am thank you sir thank you thank you Miss James we appreciate the work you and your team do we hope to not have to see you um no offense but these are make any promises these are difficult but appreciate also the training that you are working on to go out to teachers so that we see like this few and farther between thank you thank you so much Miss Smith you're here to present us with the 2025
044meeting dates y'all have taken it really easy on me today I'm telling you kept a short meeting for me everything Stacy Smith Deputy Commissioner presenting today um dates for the State Board me meetings state board meetings of Education in the future um is based off of the calendar of previous second Thursday of each month so if there was to be a special board meeting or special work session those could be included as you move forward any questions board members to my right to my left okay with that the floor will be open for a motion approve meeting dates a motion by Mr brag to approve the meeting dates is there a second second a second by Miss Hunter all in favor say I I any oppose motion passes with that that's the end of our
045action agenda we will move on to the consent agenda and board members any items that you would like to pull or ask questions about from the consent agenda to my left we do unfortunately have a number of plsb cases again to my right okay with that I'm going to take just 30 seconds I think I've been on the Soap Box every year and this is my last year to do it item number three is our annual statistical report this has a lot of information about funding and spending in schools and there's often a lot of preconceived misconceived motions out there in the public about money in schools and how it's spent and I always like to urge the public to look at this report particularly those that are invested in their local schools that want
046to have conversations with their school boards but don't know where to start one particular piece I pulled out and have pulled out over the years is per people expenditures which is how much districts are spending per student this is a really hard conversation to have because some districts have a lot greater needs some also are a lot smaller it depends on size as well but as a state we're spending about $113,000 per student um which is a lot if we look back to data 10 years ago we were spending $9,000 per student there's a lot of change in that Federal money and other things but this is a data point that I think it's important to track over time to get an understanding of what's going on in schools furthermore if we look at school
047districts in the state pulled out benville School District spending about 11,000 per kid springdale's at 13,000 per kid litox at 18,000 per kid bille 19 and our top spinner this past year was ocl at 25,000 per student now we have to take into account these past few years we've had a lot of federal money infused into the system so this is not all state money and this is expenditure and some of these have larger expenditures per year but there's a lot of data and information in this report that I think would arm the public to go to their school boards to go to their superintendents to have these conversations to get a better understanding of what's going on in their district and I will get off my soap box now Dr I I could add
048to that um maybe at a future workshop and an update we actually this past year created an additional dashboard that shows the unrestricted fund balances of school districts and gives them more detailed um accountability for what the expenses are for public transparency and it's all it's all publicly available data but we're aggregating it in a dashboard that we kind of rolled out in the last few months but a lot of people may not be aware about it so um as we move forward Maybe the next school year we can highlight that at a workshop to show that it's a user friendly place that's great because a lot of money is restricted and has to be spent in certain areas and districts are sort of tied but that there is other unrestricted funds that um you
049know certainly this is a very Nuance conversation it's not black or white of who has more money and what that means um but I think the more we can arm both the public and districts with information the better okay with that thank you I do think I've said that year I think it's usually on our action agenda item um we will move forward any any other questions or comments on the consent agenda okay we'll have a motion to approve the consent agenda make a motion to approve the consent agenda a motion by Mr Rollins to approve the consent agenda is there a second second a second by Dr Arnold all in favor say I I motion passes thank you it's to we'll keep going okay we will move along to our report section Miss Whit
050low is here to talk about fille school district and I know there's a number here in the audience we appreciate you coming in today especially so early to be here with us yes Sheila Whitlow director of The Office of coordinated support and service and good morning um I'm here to uh provide the a brief update but the school board we have representation from the school board as well as the district interim superintendent here and some District staff that will be here to report to you today but before I turn it over them I'd like to share with you the continued support that we are providing to the district um we have a state leadership coach is on site weekly um sometimes as many as two days a week to work directly with principales as well
051as some of the district level instructional staff uh we also have people from the agency that have provided support the um CES Ridge Co-op is actively uh involved in supporting the district novice teachers providing professional development and most recently I've worked with Pam Caster who's the director and she and I have worked on a ongoing intense direct support for the interim superintendent so she will be on-site weekly uh providing on-site direct support shoulder-to-shoulder support to the interum superintendent also wanted to add that I have been attending the uh board meetings because that was a question and concern when we visit Ed with them in the beginning in August and um I can report that the meetings are being the agendas are being followed and the meetings are run well they are respectful uh conducted with
052professionalism and I've been to work sessions as well so I I'm I'm happy to report that to you as well today um as as far as other things to share I I just wanted to let you know that they are very open to our support and responding to the suggestions that are being made and so we we've not experienced any resistance it's all during our time that we've been working with the Bible School District so if it's okay now I'd like to uh ask Miss uh blankin ship to come she's the serving as interim superintendent good morning I am Jennifer Blankenship serving as the intering superintendent for the Bible School District and thank you for having us to come back and to uh present again we're going to start with Staffing um I texted Miss
053whito earlier this week but you already had this we do have some updates about our unlicensed teachers um we have about six that's going to come off of that list we've had two of our teachers from the Philippines to get their uh licenses provisionals we've had another one gain reciprocity we have an aspiring teacher who will get her license this uh in December this month uh we have another teacher who's also graduating we'll get his license apply for standard I believe we just had two more to pass their practice and they have applied for their license as well so that number is growing going down and the license number is going up uh we do still have the same uh virtual instruction teachers we do we are trying our sixth grade uh principal she's working
054trying to get somebody to actually come in and be on site so we have um she's searching we were sent a list from uh Miss Caster at the co-op and I think it came from Mr Sullivan of graduates so our principles are reaching out trying to see if we can get any of those who are graduating to come in and give our students face-to-face instruction what is meant by when you list virtual instruction there it says sixth math and then all those uh the AP stats and pre-cal and chemistry are at the high school okay yeah through virtual Arkansas okay and we do have facilitators in those room and the MCL and the principal support to go in and make sure that students are doing what they're supposed to to do and also watching and
055monitoring that teacher um and see if they have any issues if they notice Trends or whatever with our students that need to be addressed uh teachers uh and support that they're getting um the observations with the feedback the principles are in there uh we have do have support that comes in work with the principles to make sure that when they're in the educated Effectiveness system that they're giving the feedback that's going to directly help those teachers grow um and we still have the national Sams track which keeps us uh all on track to make sure that we're spending our time on um instruction because sometimes you can get caught up in the management side of things so that's our drive to make sure uh one of the things about our schedules you know there was
056some concern about that we've already started talk for the spring the counselors are meeting with the konics people and we're going to start mapping that out I believe the first meeting starts in February there's a timeline when students um information has to be entered students are going to start during their schedules and we hope to have we plan to have all of that outlined before school is out so that we'll know and be able to see what's needed how many sections how many courses and we'll be able to have those student schedules in July is the goal uh my interum assessments uh most of our students are at level one and level two so we took the interim assessments and they're building a document that's going to have our interim assessments their Atlas assessments from
057the spring to directly compare and we'll be able to see how many are growing that way we're using the colors that was on the that was provided so that we can see this growth when it happens for the next interim right now they're still at level ones and level twos we did have some bright spots with some fours in there and so I think having this document and being able to see that data but more importantly what is each building doing to address and move our students from level one and two up to threes and fours each building already had an intervention time so now that intervention time is going to be tailored more specifically for each student and what are they missing what's the skill gaps what needs to be addressed and how soon
058can we get in there and start addressing those things some of our groups may have to be revamped it's like okay so we no this this group here this is our Target Focus so we're targeting students and how to move them um and we hope that the second interim will be given is going to be more reflective of the growth that our students are doing and the work that our teachers are putting into doing tier one so we're starting in the classroom with tier one and then when we pull those small groups to get more even more targeted intervention that's our plan to move our students from level one and two to threes and four Uh current enrollment update down 51 students and talking to the attendance people and counselors in each building students are
059going to different districts uh some of them have moved out of the city out of the county so we've lost students to neighboring cities and neighboring counties so I'm sorry I I need to just for my clarification you're losing them to choice or they're physic they're moving they are moving moving out of the area out of the area completely out of the area Mr Hammet will'll give the report for the blava school board and then if you have any questions or you want to ask questions now or wait till he finishes either way he fine with me thank you thank you spank ship Des m blobel board president good morning to you all uh before I start with the blobel school update I would just like to recognize one of our teachers who just recently
060became nationally board certified Mrs Kim bird received her national board certification I think that's one of the highlights of my morning that I would love to share with you guys before I give the BL board update thank you um as miss m ship said and Mrs Whit thank you we've been busy in blal doing the work getting this train back on the right tracks um we were cautiously optimistic in our state board um meeting and I can say I'm very optimistic that we're headed in the right direction with some of the moves that we've made um during the past election cycle we have a new Board member Miss Ivory Lewis who's here uh that has joined the blava board of directors we've also um had some very um impactful work sessions um with the board
061where we are understanding how to work with one another understanding the strengths and the values and everyone gets on and gets off at on the bus to understand our roles and responsibilities there um we've also um as a matter of fact we're here at the asba conference this week uh participating uh in the trainings there um myself and board member Aaron Langston had the opportunity to tour at the Academy of math and science yesterday here in in L Rock was very pleased with what we saw uh there was some takeaways that were immediately taking away but we were very open to suggestions and seeing something different and and the model that can be applied in baval as well so I'm very um pleased with that we've also put out an RFP um we've selected a
062vendor educational Direction I'm very optimistic on their ability to come in and provide support around leadership building leaders admin leaders so I look forward to that plan and that scope of work will be approved at the next reg board meeting December 19th we've also had uh interviews for the superintendent position um we've narrowed down to three interviews that were done last week um we're in the process of selecting the way the path forward that's best for us at this time this was kind of an off cycle uh time to conduct a superintendent in search so we're looking at factors that will matter the most at this time during this selection process we have a work session scheduled for Monday December the 16th where we will evaluate and hopefully provide the best path forward at that
063time for us around our superintendent update so with that we'll take questions thank you thank you for for being here today yes secretary so first I also want to report to the board um how much better the circumstances are for the bille students I know I've been pretty critical in the past and um we have to kind of sometimes do that every now and then because we're here to make sure our students are getting the best opportunities they can and we had to be honest about what we were seeing in a an entire School District that was failing students year after year after year we had to break that cycle and she and her team have been active and in moving forward and I I don't know if there's any brne brown fans out here
064but in kind of Dar to Lee she talks about a term about leaning in vulnerability right and that board had to do that they they had to be honest with themselves and saying the way we're working as adults we're not being good role models for students and we cannot be dysfunctional and it was very clear that the community has support for that that school district which is why this is such a special Endeavor because that part of the state the school district in blyville should be a bright spot and the work that they're doing around partnering with an external operator they did that on their own we didn't require that of them as a board they they said you know what we we need some additional support if we're going to be honest about what
065we want to build and and the capacity that we need to sustain let's get the best of the best let's go around the state and see model schools that are serving similar types of students that we serve here and if there's something we can take away and learn from we're going to bring that back to our board so I I feel like this board has risen to the challenge to be honest with themselves to say we can do better Miss blankers ship as you're monitoring that student progress and providing those interventions you're going to see the growth in your students because you're focused on building capacity for teachers making sure we can get the best adults that we can in front of them if if I was to give any message to this board now
066I know there's many board members here is choosing your superintendent is probably the biggest decision that you have to make as a board and as you go through that process as we lean into vulnerability about kind the actions that we need to take as a board do that same approach when choosing a superintendent don't just settle like make sure you get the best of the best because leadership matter matters and I don't think there's any better decision you can make in getting the best individual to run that school and if somebody doesn't rise from that pool and just blow you away and say this is the best that we can get um I'm a fan of Miss blinking ships I think she's doing a wonderful job and sometimes you don't need to go out and
067recruit talent I I I think you could sometimes look in your backyard we we celebrated Dr TR this morning who was an individual that kind of just kind of surfaced um through the process that wasn't licensed wasn't certified but said this is the right person how do we put him on a path I'm not trying to put you on the spot but there there's a there's a place for everyone and you're you you as a board chair in Miss blingers ship as as a superintendent have heated the call and responded and just make sure if you choose a new candidate we are not going backwards so let's keep this momentum moving forward thank you you thank you secretary board members comments or questions question about the process for the superintendent selection why did the board
068find it necessary to conduct the search during this kind of off time uh instead of here we are now it's December you're about to have a meeting to discuss candidates and you know three months from now you could have a whole new pool of applicants that might be interested in moving so so initially um when when the commissioner Stacy Smith came to you guys it was communicated that we had put our superintendent on leave and that we had an uncredentialed in the interim at that time so through this process we wanted to um at at at that time get Miss blankin ship the waiver necessary required to be in the interim position but the lack of leadership was one of the main focuses why we wanted to launch a search at that time it was
069not the ideal time and if Miss blankin ship would consider the board would um make that decision um based on what M blankinship would like to do so we understood that this wasn't the ideal time however our circumstances and the immediate need for effective leadership let let us down this road and and maybe you could kind of expand a little bit more on the role of why you went to get that external operator and what is that support like what what is it that you're asking them to do and and why you feel like we we got to have some continuity yes so the the RFP that went out um we met with three different vendors um the scope of work um was compiled by the district team and the board we worked together at
070a work session you tell me your instruction curriculum your day-to-day needs we understood our need what we wanted to see in the leadership at the admin level and the building levels so when we vetted when we interviewed at the selection process for the the external Partners leadership support direct support was one of the biggest pieces that we wanted to uh deliver on um and throughout that process uh and even the recommendation of the the district admin team uh we went with the strongest partner that could drive leadership and accountability for the blava school district more than anything uh that management peace understanding education and the value of education and how to build leaders was one of the determinant factors there and when you're speaking about leaders you're you're talking about District leaders superintendent principles just
071kind of leadership as a whole of who's running each of our campuses and what are we doing to provide information to support to them yes and then also from the teacher side the direct support and the 101 coaching and I've had conversations with them because we we're going back and forth just trying to make sure that the scope of work is what we need and that direct support for students and teachers rather in all areas because it wasn't just math and science math and English you know everybody's always on math and literacy but they're also going to support us in social studies and science with which are also big areas and we have students in those areas and they need that support as well the teachers need that support and they're going to give us
072that and so we've been breaking down things they've taken my suggestions or the district team the district team has been working hard as well and I think tomorrow there's a zoom set up with uh educational directions and we're going through that and they're ready to get started we're ready to get started and the support they're going to give and provide is probably just what we need at this time Miss Keen yeah I had a question so um Early Childhood is my area of passion and I noticed that between the 2022 the 2223 year and the um 23 24 year that um bille dropped the ABC slots um and I wanted to hear a little bit more about that I know this may have been before your time or you weren't in your current position um
073but do you do either of you have any information about that and that decision and um meeting the needs of of prek ABC PR yes the ABC slots2 23 but it's through our Co-op okay and so that's where those students are enrolled I do believe that we have quite a few that they might have had to add a teacher this summer so I know we have more students than we've had previous so you um I guess what hap um so on the ABC slots that we approved uh recently bille did not have any enrolled and so somehow I guess the money shifted from BL School District to the co-op yes it's been through our Co-op for a few years now okay but and that's in the primary school is that right yes it's located on
074our Primary School campus yes okay great thank you I appreciate your help Dr Arnold questions board members to my right Mr Henderson thank you uh for your presentation and definitely the comments uh when I think about you know your presentation and what I've heard today I I think about the rule of fre what do I hear what do I see what do I feel and when I think about that and what I've heard working really close with Miss whito I'm honored and excited that teachers are in classrooms students are fired up the energy the enthusiasm is incredible um we understand takes time it takes work at the end of the day it's everything's about results and U I'm happy that you and um board member actually came to the academy yesterday because obviously um no
075secret I'm I have an industry background when I think about opportunities when I think about moving forward I'm happy that did see some value on that and certainly something on T it's it's very eye opening to go and see what can be and where we need to get to and see that model in action and um I'm pleased and I I thank you guys for the invite to the academy of math and science and just piggybacking off our industry our steel industry that's in Mississippi county we have a bright future as we prepare to get this right and I believe the industries will be very pleased with the high quality of talent and um and seeing our schools Thrive and do well so it's a win for us all board members any more questions or
076comments thank you thank you for the work you're doing thank you for coming here today at speaks volumes to be a will share that with us we look forward to your going up from here and your success as you work with your students thank you all thank you welcome and congratulations to the new board member welcome yeah thank you for coming today and we appreciate you all up next we have a report on Kip Delta that we had seen last month and asked to hear an update next good morning everyone darl Smith assistant Commissioner of office of school choice and parent empowerment reporting on behalf of the charter board and Charter office on uh for special education as well as some of the other things that are happening at Kip Delta as you know last
077uh at the last meeting that this board placed Kip Delta on probation for uh some special education violations precipitated by lack of services provided to one particular student uh an additional and as the as the charter board has continued to investigate we found some additional things financial management some board oversight some things of that nature that we have uh continued to look into I'd like to update you on some of the some of the actions that have been taken since the last meeting with this board uh there was a new the new superintendent new interim superintendent has been named and may be here today he's in route I think uh act New York superintend is here Kevin Smith and he'll he's certainly here to be here to answer any questions and update you further on
078anything there has been a new board chair named as well uh for the for the district and for Kit Delta I believe he is on his way down from feville in route he hopefully he'll be here soon um in addition to that there have been an additional administrative changes made to the staff at Kip Delta to to precipitate new changes to make to make to that school the special education program has um evaluated and has a plan in place to provide uh services to all identified students in addition to the St the student that was named in our last meeting there has been a contract established to provide related and comp compensatory services to all uh special ed students uh there have been new board oversight procedures that are in place now to uh to
079take better leadership over the district uh we have established new Financial oversight and Staffing including providing Services by apsrc and they're in the development in conjunction with the department or comprehensive School improvement process to help identify further needs that the district may need to continue to viable and be sustainable so at that time would like to may bring up the new inter superintendent Kevin Smith to address any concerns and answer any questions that you may have thank you Mr Smith welcome thank you um Madam chair Dr Moore secretary Leva and Commissioners board members staff uh my name is Kevin Smith I'm the interim executive director of Kip Delta um my new interim chairman George cotton should be walking in any day okay I'm trying my best not to uh delay too much to get him
080here he he was uh uh he's the vice Chancellor at uapb had a meeting this morning he got caught in some traffic but I expect him to literally walk in by me any minute we have Rebecca waram our attorney here uh Sandra doet who is with apsrc uh sped who was helping us uh on the on sped services and try to help us deal with those issues Daniel Rattler our sped director um and uh and then myself and I I want to say uh the part I wanted to say uh and maybe Mr cotton will be here in time to to do that is is first of all thank you um accountability is is important and if it weren't for accountability and what she did in November uh we wouldn't be here uh probably um
081and it was a real wakeup call to to our community to our school um and that's how it's supposed to be uh you know you hope it you don't have to do that but you know it's kind of a tough love thing and you did it and and I'm not just saying that I want to I want to thank you for uh for for what happened in November um I also want to say that you know you could have multiple reactions to that you could be just witheringly mean and give up on us you can let us hang it out to dry uh and think well we'll probably take care of ourselves and we're doing that when we were in the process of acction that uh or you could reach out and really help the
082patient um stabilize and get back uh to where the patient needs to be and and y'all have done the latter I've been around federal and state and local government my whole life I've been a staffer I know what good Staffing looks like I know what bad Staffing looks like and I don't say this to flatter anybody I say it because whenever I see good Staffing uh I know it when I see it and I make sure the people over them know it you have an excellent staff and I just can't say enough uh SEC Mr secretary uh and everybody else what a great job they have done reaching out to us in the last four weeks uh Thanksgiving included to help us and we are trying our best to take advantage of that so as
083you just heard since November what have we done uh we have a new interim chairman who I hope we'll be here soon he's a very Dynamic uh person he's the native of Hela he has a rich background in education and development um we U they made me interim executive director um I have a lot of background in public administration public um government Administration as well as econom or educational policy which by the way um you got to have good policy but you the good policy you have is only as good as your people carrying it out so yeah just want to say that again you have excellent people carrying out your policy and this policy's worked for us uh it's it has gotten our attention we um are going the the actual uh uh the
084actual rules for the kip board was were to meet quarterly um I think that was part of the problem I think Mr cotton and I both think that was a big part of the problem and so they're uh right now moving towards monthly meetings and since November almost weekly um and so the board is engaged the board has heard you and the war war is acting uh we immediately just made some Financial changes um to to help with that uh I would say that uh we also immediately contracted with related Services vendors uh so that we could meet the one of the violations that we had with special education we are now in place as the school uh regarding the other violation with the IP with the student the students family the biggest missing component
085uh on our side of that was Transportation providing adequate Transportation uh we have now a handicapped wheelchair accessible bus we have a bus driver backup driver who have been trained we have one-onone assistants who have been trained and seizures and all the rest of that uh we have everything ready um my goal was to have this resolved before the day but the um the mother mother had to cancel the meeting at the last minute and so it's rescheduled for Tuesday but we are um poised are we're waiting for us is the authority to proceed and we'll be able to um provide those Services um and then finally we U as I said we've done a lot on Financial Services we've contracted with the Arkansas uh public school resource center to help us uh catch up
086and get to be where we need to be on our finances uh we also have a new a fairly new Finance director who comes from them uh with experience and we have some more to do in that uh we had a bad audit uh that we just got we went before the audit committee and we pledged to uh resolve those issues and and to prevent them from happening we also decided uh to start the process of using legislative audits that their audits not aprivate audit so fully accountable um and so forth um and more accurate and I've I'm written down a whole lot more but I don't want to take up too much of your time and I would say that you know seriously um and there's no need to sugarcoat it I mean our
087school was in bad shape um thanks to your actions uh in in November you did get our attention and uh we made a lot of changes and thanks to you we're kind of in the in the ER but the patient depending on the outcome of this meeting the the patient is is stable and um and it probably wouldn't be without you and we have oxygen we have an IV and all that the next step is to is to get the patient out in the hospital back on their feet and where they need to be and that's a lot of that is on us um thank you again for all the support you provided and be glad to take any questions thank you Mr Smith if I can answer that thank you one for for coming
088in and providing an update and the reality is is we're all big proponents of school choice we're all big proponents of empowering parents but the last thing we want is have Choice options just to have choice choice needs to be of value and needs to be of quality and when when we were speaking with leadership from your school last month it was apparent that there wasn't anything Innovative happening it wasn't anything where basic students needs were being met especially violating we we took a sanction on on the accreditation status of this school and there was a sense of my frustration is I felt like there was no urgency to figure out what was going on and find out who needed help and support and coming up with a plan and um I think the kit
089board felt that frustration from from our board and um to their credit took action right and felt like they needed to do a better job in owning the outcomes of the students in the product of choice options that they're providing so in the last I guess about three to four weeks I know Dr Smith and Mr Su and um Sheila but we've had a slew of folks going in there and having very robust honest conversations about um things we have grave concerns over and the response that we're getting now is demonstrating that they're hearing our frustration and they are responding with urgency which we did not feel a month ago so is is your analogies are great you know we're getting things moving in the right direction but we have not arrived and there is
090a lot of work that still needs to be done because if we're going to have Choice options for families they need to be of quality we can't lie of students and families and say coming here is a good thing when it's not and that's what we're going to address and um I think we need to continue to have updates and stay the course I'm I'm very pleased with the progress of the inner superintendent Mr cotton as I guess he's established as the new board chair has responded well and has been in in great communication and we're going to return that campus back to the status it was about a decade ago it was the flagship School in that region in that area and and if they can do it before there's no reason why they
091couldn't do it again and we're going to get these pieces uh put into place to make sure we can restore that status thank you thank you secretary board members questions or comments Mr Henderson to kind of add to secretary's uh comments U box thank you for your comments uh thank you for coming in today and uh I too agree wholeheartedly there are some opportunities and we can't thank you enough for facing this challenge heads on uh when you think about moving forward uh please continue to engage engage in a way you never engaged before um trust but verify yes sir thank you Mr Anderson further comments to my last questions Dr Arnold I appreciate your edifying remarks very encouraging but I and I hope not to put you on the spot but one question is
092left unresolved for me and that could you address why it took last month's wakeup call to draw attention to these deficiencies it seemed like last month I was on this planet and this month I'm on this planet and I've only been here one month so no it's an excellent question and um and you're right uh I think as I said before um I I I can just give you my opinion if that's okay that's all I can really say but I I really think the board had been treated somewhat like an advisory committee instead of a true governing board that's my opinion and um when that happens we all need we all need accountability we need all need we all need a boss right um uh even when I'm the boss my wife's really the
093boss you know there's always um and I I don't think that's healthy and that's really my answer is the board I will say started to wake up to some things U probably a couple of months before the November meeting but the November meeting was that that put it over the top okay thank you for that that was I think very fair um and I want to first of all thank you for coming I imagine there weren't many folks at Kip that were just itching to get in front of us again so I do appreciate you coming and I'm um excited to hear about um the new energy and the renewed relationship with the board that was something that um I was shocked they weren't here last month and um so I'm thrilled to hear that
094they're more engaged and offering that accountability and it sounds like you're starting to move from excuses we heard last month to actions that we're hearing this month and we look forward to hearing more so thank you for coming yes ma'am we're we're we're trying to go from maybe over promising and underd delivering and the other way around so we can under promise and overd deliver it's our goal that your guy and this is Mr cotton just in time I'm sorry this this is really a probably a little bit unnerving to walk in and immediately Mr cotton if you could come join me this is uh this is George cotton he is our like I said our interim board chair and uh I'll just turn it over to him we're kind of I given the state
095gave their report I gave mine so yeah thank you Mr cotton for joining us and just kind of recap I think we kind of went over some of the deficiencies the action plan what the next steps are how we're going to continue this support but the board I think was kind of asking some more of the questions of why did it take last month what was going on from a governance perspective um that led to this and how can we make sure that doesn't happen again maybe you could address that sure and and thank you and good morning and my apologies for being late um uh George Ken I'm U the interim board chair and my day job I also happen to serve as Vice Chancellor of advancement at the University of Arkansas Pine Bluff
096and one of the reasons I'm late is we had a cabinet meeting this morning so I literally had to run from there here um but also I I want to make sure that you understand and that uh I'm a I'm a student of the Delta uh grew up in hel in West Helen Arkansas and uh so for the for me this isn't just an opportunity to get this thing right it's an opportunity also as a resident of Philips County who graduated from hel Central High School to make sure that the children of the Delta have the same experience I have Kevin Kevin and I he probably already told you we're both we have an interesting title in front of our names we're both interims uh I was on the board um I guess about the
097past couple years but one things I want to make sure uh that the board understood is and I've said this before that while the board may not have been sleep at the switch when a lot of this was happening we were most certainly nodding and one of the things that Kevin and I have committed is to make sure that we pay attention to detail uh several of the changes that we've implemented I don't know if Kevin have already talked about but we've been very aggressive in moving to make sure that these changes uh take place and that we implement the recommendations that we're supposed to implement uh we've also as as recently as yesterday the board also knows that there will be no more three and four meetings a year we're going to be meeting
098monthly uh they've heard from Kevin and I almost every single day uh we've been meeting with stakeholders and we'll be meeting with members of the community so uh we intend to implement uh aggressive uh PR uh practices that make sure that we are on top of the finance part that we're making sure that when it especially when it comes to our students and and special ed needs that those are served Kevin was uh selected quite frankly not just because he's sharp and from the Delta but Kevin is a person who's known for getting things done he knows people uh both in the educational and the political Community um my background is professional fundraising so I'm a professional fundraiser we've already reached out to the philanthropic Community uh who uh we also had to assure that
099we're getting this right so long story short uh this isn't just um an educational uh opportunity for us we realize that it's serious and we're responding aggressively to make sure that you're convinced that we're going to get this right and we're going to get it right thank you Mr cotton we really appreciate you being here today and jumping right in to share with us the work that you all are doing board members more questions or comments M Rollins one of the things we haven't heard yet this morning is how are you working with your parents how are you working with your community and building that confidence back with them if if I can and I'm I'm glad you uh you said that is it Rollins um as recently as yesterday I got an email from
100a parent uh and one of the advantages and both disadvantages that Kevin and I both have is uh people know us from the Delta and they have our cell phone numbers so as recently as yesterday I received a initially a text but then a phone call from a parent who wanted to know if we were going to have an opportunity allow them an opportunity to be heard one of the first things we said that we were going to do and we're going to do it is we're going to initiate Community listening sessions where we're going to allow the public opportunities to quite frankly uh not just talk to us but chastise if necessary um you know we had an opportunity to talk to the press a couple of weeks ago and one of the things
101that I told them is that we won't be hiding uh we won't be um quite frankly twisting the truth um we all you know in addition to the community listening listening sessions uh I think Kevin and maybe one of the other members of the board it may have come from a parent also suggested that we provide kind of a community panel who would uh provide input opportunities to us uh we're also going to be having Youth engagement opportunities where younger people will be providing opportunities so uh we're trying to make sure we do that as fast as we can and we also at a retreat a couple ago maybe in three the time is passing so fast indicated that sooner rather than later we would be having a public forum for the public to have
102an opportunity to come in and find out not just what's going on but how we intend to make sure that the kip that emerges out of this is not the kip that uh that people have grown to know really over the past month or so know Kevin Mr Henderson Dr coton uh thank you for your comments um um Kip knowledge is power program model for Kip is every student should get a college degree or I don't know if this does that still exist it is still the national Kip initiative uh one of the things I shared with some people last week is one of the reasons that this is personal to me also is the University of Arkansas Pine bluffer receives a lot of students from Kip Delta the Beville and and hel Ina West
103Hela area and I've gotten to know them over the past four years years so uh It Is our commitment to make sure that that students who actually want to pursue a college education not only have an opportunity to do it but I'm pleased to say at the University we've been the beneficiaries of several philanthropic gifts but we're also trying to make sure that they do it with the least amount of cost necessary so that is still our commitment but again total transparency we're taking a look at everything and we're asking tough questions of ourselves as it relates to the original Mission um Kip once upon a time I'm sure Kevin talked about this and you know this probably better than I do Kip was a shining star in the state of Arkansas we intend to
104get it back to that point but in order to do that sometimes you know tough decisions make make need for necessary for tough actions so we're doing tough actions to make sure we get back to that uh director Sanders okay I'm certain Henderson yeah um you mentioned uh implementing aggressive practices yes you know when I think about aggressive practices when I think about every student should get a college degree is how do you define degrees Yeah uh industry certification our degrees Yeah U one thing I I really like about the Pine Bluff area you have Innovative Innovation centers there yeah uh with the industry in Northeast how cool could it be to create that framework not particularly for a Innovation Center but that level of discipline that prepares students for industry jobs yeah you're right
105and one of the things that that we realize at kit is that you know students learn in different ways and they come to the table with different needs you you're right about the Innovation Hub we've got you know interestingly enough the erdc the Enterprise research and development center at the University falls under my purview uh and you know we're sensitive to the fact that while we want every student to get a college education uh some students go about it in different ways you know we've got students who have two four six year degrees and some take longer uh and we're sensitive to that but also at the same time at Kip we've got to make sure that we're preparing students Bas with those basic needs that they have to be uh College ready uh so
106Kevin as our executive director uh will be making sure that he takes that deep dive and has a real conversation with staff we've heard from staff already who want to be heard and who said that they have some ideas as to how we can turn this thing around and we'll be listening to them as well okay thank you thank you Miss Woods did you have a question someone joined via Zoom can you hear me a little bit louder that is that any better yes thank you great um well Dr Smith and Mr cotton thank you so much I apologize that I couldn't be there I had some car trouble this morning um one of the questions or concerns that I had last month was just regarding your special ed program can you talk a little
107bit about um just quick policies that you've put into place to sort of start building that program back up sure and and that's an understandable question uh there you are the the first thing I think uh was to make sure the related the to use that analogy the first thing is to make sure the patient gets oxygen and gets an IV and all of that stuff and so we had to get the contracts in place for related Services um that was absolute number one and that's very basic I understand but that had not been in place and was one of the reasons we were put on probation um we have a director of special education and we're in the process of trying to recruit two coordinators under her and we're also and we met with
108State staff about this looking some of the diagnostic tools to make sure uh they're being diagnosed correctly um and so that they get the services that they need it's appropriate to their diagnostic um outcome um um as far as we we have an excellent staff uh in place they just need more support and that's hard to do anyone that understands sped knows that it's it's not easy because you don't have it's hard to find people and so forth um but we're we've done I think an amazing job in four weeks to try and get us to where we maybe should have been in August but we are there now and we are making progress on the stuff we should have already done we're not at all as as the secretary pointed out we got a
109long long way to go and I want to save that but we do have those tools in place and they're proven tools that people have worked with the schools before um and they are now there and back in place and and they're motivated I hope that answers your question no no that was helpful can you just tell me um we all I know you said you did an audit and it didn't come back well can you talk about just some of the findings of your audit and just sort of maybe your top three things that you're doing between this month and next month to address those issues yes yes ma'am um the biggest issues were just gaps in reporting and data entry for both income and expenditures it's it's pretty basic stuff um it just
110wasn't entered and it should have been that's the that's a pretty it sounds simple U so we're having to go back and reconstruct those entries some of them are just they're not coded correctly some of it just wasn't entered at all so they're having to go back and find the invoices and find the receipts and at the same time make sure that what's being audited currently is is being done correctly so to do that as you can imagine takes a lot of Financial Resources so we had to bring in the Arkansas Public School resource center and we contracted with them and their team has already started uh along with our our finance director and and her team so we just got the audit ourselves maybe two weeks ago R around Thanksgiving our board accepted it
111uh and then we were at the audit committee meeting maybe a week later to explain it but that's what's in place and we had already uh contracted uh for the financial services actually before we even got the audit um are your current students that are receiving sped Services can can you confirm that they have been receiving them at least since the start of school yes yes well not since start school began but they are receiving them as of now today and and I've impressed on everybody and and and they'll tell you if you run into them that when someone asks that question at this board meeting I don't want to have to make an excuse I want to say yes sir or yes ma'am sir yes ma'am they are in place and and receiving Services
112right now and have has there been any attempt to communicate with those parents when there was a lack of services or is that an ongoing conversation I would say it's it's a it's an ongoing conversation some of the parents have been very proactive you know reaching out to us uh when it comes to communication and some of the parents you know leaving with the teacher or the therapist um but we I guess come back to that analogy we tried to have all the nurses and the surgeons and everybody in that ER not out in the parking lot you know talking about how the patient's doing yet because we want them in there working on the patient so there's been an awful lot of concentration on getting those things in place but I do think you
113know after today one as Mr cotton alluded we're that's the communication is the next big thing there there were issues with communication before and now that we hope we have the patient stabilized and ready to go and and I want to say um thanks to your wonderful staff thanks to you um I'm very confident that we're we're going to ultimately reach those academic goals and be number two in Arkansas Accord in US News and World Report one year uh or or better but but that is the next big thing we haven't done as good a job as we should have but we're going to thank you Dr Mo thank you Miss Woods any further questions or comments okay with that I will reiterate thank you for coming today and more importantly thank you for your
114work we will maybe be in touch as far as when the next update will be and what that looks like thank you both very much we're at your disposal thank youall thank you with that board reports any board members have anything they want to share out from this past month and we will allow our teacher of the year to to share we missed you last month and glad you're here today thank you glad to be here apologize for missing last month had a a visit up to ASU a speaking engagement there so I've covered a lot of ground between now and then or and U cover a few of the highlights of those trips as we go through here uh one of the first trips uh in the biggest highlight I think over the last
115two months was our trip down to McGee uh McGee Elementary was one of three schools in the entire state of Arkansas that was named a National Blue Ribbon School by the art um by the US Department of Education uh they are awarded uh for exemplary achievement Gap closing by the US Department of Ed uh so they they were rewarded for their growth that they've shown in a certain population of their students uh some of the highlights that the US Department of Ed uh really noted was their systematic process to address students academic deficits a strong focus on reading and promoting literacy to students parents and Community The Hoot award which was for positive behavior program now McGee mascot is the ow uh so that's where the hoot comes from and activities to expose students to
116real life learning opportunities as well as the community support that was very evid in the day's celebration the entire Community was there uh city government and um McGee their normal color is red uh the McGee owls uh that day everybody was decked out in blue and uh McGee being a Delta school school over there in the Delta they celebrated in Delta style they loaded up a crop duster full of blue Powder and made three passes over the campus and and sprayed the blue Powder to celebrate it was a really cool day I got to spend the rest of the afternoon with the assistant superintendent Justin Holt who drove me around town and introduced me and the one thing that was very evident is it's one of those communities they they face the same uh obstacles
117and challenges a lot of our rural schools do but it's the community support that they have how deep that support goes and U that's that's a common theme that I've seen around some of our rural schools that are having really good success and my next stop was uh down the road to Wi W has faced a very unique challenge over the last couple of years compared to most of our schools if you recall uh the tornado went through wind and wiped out uh the high school um it's a very unique uh situation up there right now they have a temporary campus uh made of PODS now it's not like a tent city uh they've done it in a unique fashion that really gives it a sense of home it's a sense of campus now it's
118not ideal but it is really the best environment they could hope for until they get their new school um completed which I believe is scheduled for spring of 27 I could I could be wrong about that but even even in that temporary campus that they have right now they're able to divide the pods up into departments much like you would see at a regular campus um one of the things that stuck out to me was their CTE programs it's a strong they have strong CTE programs and it goes all the way down into the sixth grade they have a career exploration for sixth graders I'm a strong believer in the earlier the better ucing our students to possibilities for their future um when I went in there on that day that they um they had
119a coffee store going just like a coffee shop they had students running around the campus uh taking orders from teachers from each class bringing those orders backed with money money exchange had a team in the back making the coffees and then other students were on delivery team but uh the coolest part about it was seeing how excited and how engaged the students were with that entire process now and they do much more than just the coffee shop but uh you can see the excitement when the kids gooll into those classrooms and that they know what they're about to learn today is going to really apply to their future and uh another Stu I made was Clarendon I like to tell people that my feet have carried me through Southwest Arkansas most of my life but
120my roots go back to claron high school and also into the soil of Monroe County uh that's where my parents uh grew up I have a lot of famili still around the area so it was really special to be able to go back and visit claron a lot of people knew me who I had not met yet but they knew me from way back in the day when I was little um but uh one thing about claron high school there was school in school of innovation in 2017 uh claron Elementary was recently named a school of innovation and principal Cheryl Smith um she was named to the extraordinary Educators leadership collaborative and uh Mr vent over there really special to meet him and get to visit with him Mr vent is the longest active actively
121serving superintendent in the state of Arkansas more than 40 years and then some of you may recognize uh Miss Megan Ables up there the 2016 Arkansas teacher of the year she is now she's still in stutgart but she is now the new principal at mein's middle school and uh if you know Miss AEL she is a spark of energy and Spark of positivity and this is just her first year as being principal at means and you can can you can sense uh the influence she's already had on on her building there because it's a a spark of positive when you walk into that building as well um she's instituted a new positive behavior program that's really helped change the the culture at means uh students have applied for leadership roles and they actually act as
122leaderships in or as leaders in uh actively trying to be proactive to uh prevent discipline problems coming from coming up uh she's also collaborated with uh local officials to um and brought them into the um process for the election of student council so she's really tied it into Civic engagement as well it's not just a popularity contest that you know we we see at a lot of schools sometimes and uh she's also instituted a thriving MMS alumni program which connects students to alumni who have gone through that school they've come back and and really tried to be a positive in inuence on the students as well and something in is in the water at stutgart because uh we had a little bit of a reunion when it comes to a toys uh that is 2024
123a toy Regional finalist Julie Landrum as well as our recent 2025 a toy Regional finalist Tanya Herring doing great work at Stuart um also had the opportunity to visit Henderson University's teacher college for professional development day these are pre-service Educators who are in in the middle of the residency they had a full day of professional development um I got to share my story with them of of how I ended up in education my my path to education also ran into two of my former students uh Micah Gibson and pton Thornton they are on the pathway to becoming uh teachers and coaches as well and as y'all know it's happened before in some of my stops it's it it's really special to me to to be able to run into some of my old kids and
124see that they're taking the same path also stopped at ASU for the uh erz ready to teach Summit now these were high school kids and we had high school I'm going to list off all the names or all the all all the schools that we had there these are high school kids who are uh enrolled in the pre- educator programs we had students from Walnut Ridge Truman Jonesboro uh bful Mart tree Marvel Elaine wi Westside Nettleton and West Memphis all those schools over there in the Delta uh have half students in their pre- educator programs and I shared with them the same same story I shared and same message I shared with uh the preservice Educators at Henderson and that was the focus on the first year of teaching no matter how much training you've
125had how prepared you are or how little the first year is hard because the true reward of teaching that we get is not the paychecks we get in at each each month it's the full transformation that takes place at the end of the school year and so the real challenge in that first year to teachers is getting through those challenges as they come up and staying with the game until the end and and that's where our real Joy comes from and that's what I shared with them and really to focus on you're not really in your groove until about year three or year four but I was really excited to be able to share my story with them and also rode around the state made a road trip with Ross white and his crew um
126made a trip down to Harmony Grove as well as hot springs lakeside I just want to point out this construction program that lane Chancellor at Harmony Groves had uh I believe this is year 13 um that the program has been in place and it's changed a little bit in size and scope over the last 13 years but his construction students have constructed 13 homes over the last 13 years and uh these homes are then sold once they're ready that those proceeds from those home sales go back into the program so they can fund the next project and um over the last 13 years uh students have graduated to go on into the business some of them are subcontractors that he's hiring now to uh for to help build the house along with the students and
127and some of them have gone on to open their own construction businesses around the area just a really really neat model um that uh I'm sure there's a lot more of those around the state that aren't necessarily in the construction business but it it's a really cool model for schools to see how they can um really grow their own program just like we should be doing in in in education as well so I'm six months in just some reflections uh that have really stood out to me over these first six months the first of which is the people of Arkansas um every corner I've been to you've got a lot of good people in Arkansas they're very prideful about their communities really passionate about what's going on in their educations but also which really stood
128out to me is the people here at desie you know that's something that doesn't get down to ground level I think on the teaching or for teachers is there are so many good peoples right here at desie that are working hard every day to improve education and um that's I've seen that across the state every corner I've also seen it right here here at desie so a shout out to everybody here at desie and uh rural School challenges um it's the same thing uh the challenges are very similar they might look a little bit different but teacher retention and recruitment is uh obviously the one of the biggest challenges and in regards to work for or work-based learning um the lack of Industry sometimes uh is preventing some schools with coming up with ideas of
129how to incorporate work-based learning um that's where I'm a big promoter or a big supporter of and big Pusher of we've got to build those local Partnerships uh to be able to create those work-based learning opportunities for students yes we might not have a lot of industry but we've all we've all got a post office we've all got a you know City Hall we've all got a courthouse we've all got local government there can be partnership built within those systems to really create work-based learning opportunities for students um and the standout schools uh cattle Hills Academy I I've mentioned them several times over the last several months I really think they're just a a role model for the way rural education can can move uh it's really neat what they're doing and then of course
130McGee uh we said it earlier they they're facing some of those same challenges but they're finding a way to grow their students and looking ahead uh next month I'll speak again in Magno to some of our pre- educator students at the Ed Rising state conference and then January 17th to the 20th I'll have the very tough task of attending the college football championship weekend sponsored by ccsso um so thankful for our partnership with them they've um I mean the rewards that they've given us as teachers this will be our last event but uh really looking forward to that and then February is CTE month a very busy February uh it starts with c day at the capital here on February the 5th and um one of my goals uh this next spring is I really
131focused on Southwest Arkansas as well as eastern Arkansas this first six months is um going to be making a lot of visits to here central Arkansas as well as up into Northwest Arkansas but uh my last thing I want to do is a shout out to one of my students Luis Sano he just recently uh was sworn in to the Arkansas guard uh we have now hit all the three e in our DQ TV program we've had students enrolled we've had students go right into employment and now we've hit the enlistment as well so congratulations to Lise ask my report thank you that's amazing I really think that we have failed as a board to support our teachers of the Year appropriately and I think that we should start supporting them better by going with
132them on some of these you know enriching things that they do like the college football national champion would that come out of my travel budget yes make but I agree it's amazing to hear I I see you as sort of the eyes and ears of Education here in Arkansas getting out to really truly understand and so it's so helpful to hear your Reflections and here and also hear the successes thank you what's going on board members any further questions or comments but thank you thank you I guess we'll see you before that comes in January but looking forward to hearing about that as well with that secretary ala yeah so I I'll keep my comments brief I think one of the highlights I want to thank this board for their participation in since our last
133meeting is um engaging in some of the work around the anxious generation and Dr height many of you participated in some big Community forums and um with support of Governor Sanders and and her leadership to really address the challenges and uh tackle on the addictiveness of social media and the Imp Act of smartphones for children primarily before high school and supporting the work with the pilot program the over 100 districts that are taking active stances and limiting screen time I know that's going to have a major impact in in the quality of education for our students in across the state of Arkansas so um just really excited uh to kind of have our last board meeting at the end of this calendar year I think there's a lot to celebrate and I hope that everybody
134gets a much welld deserved rested time off and spend some time with their family and looking forward to January we'll we'll be starting session there pretty soon and hitting the ground running it's going to be a wonderful time so thank you thank you secretary I Echo that for you and your staff as I know you'll face a very busy January and months to come so thank you with that we do have at least two individuals signed up for a public comment public comment we allow a thre minute period um first up we have Mr Philip Bryant who signed up to speak thank you for coming in today well good morning to all and uh thank you for allowing me to speak I've written a proposal and ladies put it on your desk and uh I
135know that uh education system in Arkansas is not broken well if you don't mind pulling that mic you there you go I the education system in Arkansas is not broken but there's always room for improvement on everything and so I wrote this proposal on reading in the first grade how it can improve and make sure every student in Arkansas can read first grade material before they ever go to the second the governor has authorized $3 million to build another prism here in Arkansas and I know the governor can afford to give another $3 million or more to get this proposal going and I know that uh the state of Arkansas can be number one in Reading in first second third and fourth grade it can happen because I see in all of you the ability
136the desire and the will to make Arkansas number one one in Reading not only that I see the power of God with each and every one of you and we want Arkansas to be number one in something and it can be number one in Elementary reading so I hope you take this proposal read it and don't throw it away but consider what can be done in Arkansas in education thank you may God bless you all thank you Mr Bryant thank you for coming in today and thank you for providing us with that proposal um we certainly I left I left a few copies back here if anyone out here want to pick up a copy of that proposal do so please thank you thank you so much next on our list we have Ashley Hardy
137good morning good morning hopefully y'all can hear me this morning my name is Ashley Hardy and I'm actually the mother of five children but we're going to talk about this morning our oldest daughter named Madison um Madison attended Quitman School District from grade six through eighth grade um and unfortunately a lot of damage was done um and we've since had to forcibly move schools um Maddie was a happy and vibrant student full of life she was a junior high school cheerleader for three years at School District she was a cross country Runner and an AB honorable student until the 2023 and 2024 school year Maddie became a victim of bullying and instead of helping the administration responded it had only been 3 months this Behavior allowed Maddie to fall prey to a predator in Quitman
138School District as she became a shell of herself and in early 2024 despite warning administrators of an inappropriate relationship occurring between staff and another student to to our daughter administrators instead called the resource officer to escort my husband out of the building this was not before my husband demanded our daughter was not allowed to be access to the counselor this was documented in emails this was also documented in our recordings of that day during that incident on Valentine's Day of 2024 this year despite our concerns and warnings the guidance counselor was allowed unlimited access to our child the much older Predator who was three years older for reference our daughter Maddie at the time was 13 and this Predator was 16 years old Mattie was an eighth grader and this child was an 11th grader
139she was allowed instead to gain more access to Harmar Daughter by being allowed unlimited access as well as counseling often times conspiring with the counselor to have our daughter come in for counseling sessions multiple times a day once the sessions were completed Maddie was then never protected once more and was never escorted back to class the Predator was then able to gain control and began psychologically abusing our child that ultimately led to our daughter being sexually assaulted while in school the Predator was then able to continue it and despite our parents concerns um us me and my husband's concerns um and reports of the sexual assault equipment PD the school did nothing and that school remained in school last year and is in school today with zero repercussions never once was DHS called in fact
140DHS was weaponized against us and DHS was called on our family when they came out to our home they closed the case and they weren't sure why equipment PD and Equipment School District had ultimately called them on our family we in fact had a call Arkansas crimes against children and we are the ones who filed a report on our daughter's case after the first sexual assult our daughter went impatient for attempted suicide and unfortunately after 7 days she was you know let out on her way it's an impatience day here in Arkansas and she went back to equitment schools she was there for six days and despite our continued warnings by emails telephone phone calls all of which have been recorded and documented our child Maddie was been sexually assaulted again from that point Manny's
141mental health has deteriorated so bad that she has gone four additional times to inpatient mental health treatment and was diagnosed with PTSD from her assaults depression anxiety and self Haring Behavior Maddie from early April through the end of school never went back to school because she continued impatient in mental health despite everything being done by us from multiple police reports calls and emails the administration still did nothing in fact we were even told we were not allowed to bring our concerns to the quick school board and that it was being handled by any andl administrators the latest response by the school administrator reads in part we have received the mental health records let us know when you would like us to enroll Maddie back in school out of options and unsure if our child was
142going to be alive dayto day we reached out to the Department of Education we were able to present countless emails and phone recordings between us and the administrators and they did find that equipment schools was guilty and they did in fact violate all policies and procedures relating to sexual harassment and sexual assault it is both alarming and concerning the lack of accountability by the administrators and the inability to keep students safe instead of remedying the situation we were forced to leave and change schools to protect our remaining children the Arkansas State Police advised us to protect our other children that we would have to move them because equipment schools refused to protect any of them in fact the Predator had then tried to go after our second oldest child as well today Maddie has continued
143her journey to hopefully recover one day but these acts caused by the direct lack of supervision and inability to keep Maddie and our other children safe along with all the other children's safe equipment schools have not only dram dramatically changed her life but a lot of other children's lives as well and her life will never be the same the hope is that very soon the administrators are held accountable to to the highest degree so this never happens to another child or their family ever again I thank you for your time today thank you Miss Hardy for coming in I I have no words I'm so sorry thank you so much and appreciate and I know it took a lot to come to speak in public thank you yes ma'am thank you all thank you all
144for hearing me speak um I know a lot of us have been silenced but we won't continue to be silenced anymore um I do appreciate the Department of Education finding at least one branch of guilt that you know they were found guilty of and not following policies and procedures but that's just a piece of the pie here um the administrators are still there and are still continuing to allow this to happen to many many other children so thank you board members it has come to my attention that local boards do not always allow public comment our board is always open for public comment and I think sometimes um we I personally would like to see that modeled in every district with that we will be hearing more soon we appreciate you thank you thank you
145all with that is there anyone else signed up for public comments okay board members any questions or concerns before we close out it's a hard way to end a meeting I'm so sorry um but with that our December board meeting is concluded thank you all