001[Music] is all right we're going to bring to order the Liberty 25 governing board organizational meeting for January 13th 2025 at 4:30 p.m. at the Jerry Roy administration building board members present Chris keny and Sarah Schmidt Brian cion Kelly Zimmerman and myself Brian Parks Miss Zimmerman can you uh lead us in the pledge please Ali to the FL of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right we'll move on to item 1.3 approval election of the board president um I'll start with a motion I'll make a motion to approve Brian Parks as board as the board president beginning January 2025 U Mr President I got to am I allowed to ask a question before we go straight
002to motions absolutely hey I would I know it's kind of a equal power thing but before I make vote I would like to know who I would actually like to be the president of the board before we start going through does anybody else anybody actually want to be president I would okay so we have and you president Parks you still want to be president correct yep gu so too all right thank you a second do we have a second second okay I'll call for a vote Mr Kenyon or vice president Kenyon hi uh Mr mitt nay Mr Sone hi uh Miss Zimmerman nay I'm also Anni so that pass 32 move on to item 1.4 approve election of board vice president I'll open with a motion I I got the same question uh who here
003wants to be vice president I would like to be vice president well that makes it pretty easy I make a motion for uh governing board Kenyon as the new board vice president beginning January 13 2025 I'll second that we'll call for a vote uh vice president Kenyan hi uh Miss Smitt [Music] hi uh Mr cion hi uh Miss Zimmerman hi I'm also and I will show that passed uh unanimously um with that I'll go ahead and adjourn governing board organizational meeting at 4:33 thank you guys now we can come down here and start the study session so I think Chris will help you out but you can conduct with us so uh president parks are you you're not looking so hot are you you hanging with us are you what do you what do you
004want to what do you want to do your mic's off Brian sorry guys I think I'm going to head back too bed get feeling better yeah thank you guys appreciate it he all right if we're all ready we'll go ahead and call uh let's go ahead and call the uh work study session to order here at the joy uh Jerry Roi facility board members present Miss Zimmerman uh Mr serion Miss Schmidt myself Chris Kenyan and Miss casianos will lead us we also have um Clyde Dangerfield or Lori here along with our superintendent uh we're going to start this at 4:32 and I'll go ahead and turn this over to miss ctios well good I guess I have to hold it right okay good afternoon or good evening afternoon isk yeah right um Welcome to our
005governing board or orientation so first I'd like to say congratulations on your elections um great job with your presentations and um welcome to the Liberty Elementary School District governing board so today i' like to take the time as um vice president Kenyan had requested about a year ago that we needed to have a new governing board orientation so something that was very specific to Liberty um and so this is our first run at that and we will go ahead and refine as we go along but this is much more of a conversational meeting than it is something that we're going to just stand and present so I would encourage you to ask many questions as you have about your role as a governing board member okay so um again welcome and I love seeing all
006of these new faces here but so encouraged by the direction of this board and the way that you all would like to lead and govern our school I'm curious though um for me personally the reason why I do this work as governing board consultant is because it's been really important to me to dedicate my life to the kids who are looking for a lifeline and the adults that serve them that being said I'd love to know um if you all would just take a moment and reflect what is what drives Your Service as a board member what is that driving force um and if you'd love to share it with us I would really appreciate that but as I said my driving force for my role is very specific to be to make sure that
007the adults that are supporting our youth have all the information that they need and that our kids that are really looking for the lifeline and the adults that serve them have that Lifeline so what would drive your bird service would anybody like to share uh one one reason I'm I think you can hear me one reason I'm Ser uh I'm serving on the board is I spent my the little over 20 years serving in the in the Army serving the country and I got out I had that kind of a gap and a hole in my life and I like I need to go back and serve some capacity to the community and this opportunity came about and so this is one way for me to continue my service um to the community it's the
008first time I've been somewhere long enough to actually be like part of the community and so now I feel like I can give back to the community in this way thank you um you know I uh the reason that I decided to run and to serve um is I've you know used my voice in a lot of different ways in the district since my oldest U was in kindergarten 9 years ago and so I just felt like I was ready to use my voice in a different aspect and to really highlight the voices that I didn't feel like were present on the board and to really be a voice for um you know children who don't always um have a representation special ed education students are really um a big part of my personal heart
009um and also just to give a voice to teachers who maybe didn't feel like they had a voice as a former educator I feel like I can speak to that so thank you um I all my life I've dealt with kids and loved kids service kids um youth pastor worked with Department of Child Safety just uh I have four kids of my own three of which have gone through or currently are in the district um another one will be in the district starting next year so there we go starting over but excited about that um I have a lot of you know love and passion for seeing these kids grow up um and just wanting to be a part of that wanted to help guide them direct them protect them is a huge thing for
010me um and so you know it's one of the things that I can instead of being a parent only dealing with my kids I can help share you know my knowledge my my my care for these kids throughout the district and it really means a lot to me to be able to do this and and it means a lot to my wife and my kids too because they you know as we all will know they uh they feel it sometimes but they're they back this and they really support what I'm doing and and what this board is doing so thank you thank you I am a product of public education in a not great District but great schools within that district and I think my passion is that every child should be in a great
011school like you shouldn't have to move or drive your child an hour away to be able to be in a great school um my son does not attend this District but uh I feel like everybody I know and that lives near me deserves to have a great District um and I was a teacher went to be on that side of it as well so here to be the voice of kind of the community that doesn't have a child in the school um because they're not always fully represented either and then teachers Dr minro would you share with us what keeps you in public education CU we know that this is not the easy job oh it's very challenging you know 30 31 years but you guys have dedicated I mean everything that you guys said
012really resonated with me and you know early on in my life I just knew I wanted to do something to benefit young people to you know at the end of the day make the world a better place is that sound cliche or naive but as opposed to working with widgets or doing other things that I really compliment people I wanted to live a life of service and that was kind of I felt like my dad did that and um understanding that education wasn't the most you know well-paying job and and sometimes well respected in the United States I knew dedicating myself to young people gave me that why kind of filled my bucket like you guys have you guys have mentioned and so that's kind of my why wanting to make sure that our students
013get the best um that we can have the support our teachers to be the best that we can do what's best by the kids and making great schools and so that's kind of my what drives me great thank you would you mind if I asked you the same question there's no reason like as an attorney you have a lot of options well uh thank you um I took a job in Gilbert schools uh 30 let's see it's 1993 so however long that was 33 years ago as the assistant superintendent and um doing the business and legal issues um and I did it for 21 years and then I retired from State through the state retirement system and took the job uh in private practice advising Public Schools so I just went on from what I
014was doing before but now instead of just for Gilbert it's for schools throughout the state thank you well the reason why I like to bring all of that for forward is cuz often times when we're moving along our careers as board members um or just in teaching and in education we often forget why we started because sometimes the pressure gets to be quite a lot and really what I hear us all saying is that we are here for the kids right we're here um for the kids for the teachers for our community but to focus on making our communities better and that is I just want to bring us all back to kind of the core values of Liberty Elementary School District with respect accountability Integrity students centered and high standards being kind of that
015core that guides the decisions of the board so thank you all again for taking the time to give us some of that information um let us know why you were running um and what you're hope what difference you're hoping to make in this process I am curious I know that some of you may have attended the new board orientation in other um with other organizations and was there something that stuck out to you or something that you were wishing to know a little bit more about during this orientation something that we could kind of thread in for you or help answer questions it was a lot it was a it was day a solid today so miss Caso that really is the reason why a year ago I wanted to bring this forward so that
016us as a district when we have new board members whether they're elected or appointed um when you come in there's so much information there that there's no way you can soak it all in right and so um even I've been on the board two years I'm still learning things there's just so much so just this forum is great and then as you know and obviously hopefully it goes without saying as a new member has a question there they should always feel like they can go to another board member or the superintendent to you know answer that question or help them walk them through that question and that really when I came on the board instead of that I got don't you dare do something you know and so that really rubbed me wrong how as
017a new board member that was what was just relayed to me out in the parking lot by then the board president and uh I just didn't want that to happen to another board member we're here to support each other um nobody knows everything so we're walking through this together and I just I want us to be as as United as possible understanding we all come different backgrounds we all have different ideas ideas on how to make things work but working together as one whole unit so thank you thank you so much so um just to kind of go through some of the review from maybe some things you have heard and maybe some things you haven't but what do you feel like your board members like roles and responsibilities what are things that stand out
018to you as a board member as your role or responsibility any thoughts I think one thing that sticks out I think we remember is we're here for like the Strategic and policy we're not here for the day-to-day operations and we don't need to be getting into the the the weeds of the staff's business that's not what we're here for and I think that's a big thing that I think a lot of us forget from time to time it's easy like you want to do a great job and you're like well let me see what's going on but we just need to stay out of that business and let the people that we put in place do their job yeah absolutely thank you uh kind of to piggyback I think it's also important to remember that
019um you know we as a collective board do employ the superintendent he is our only employee but he is our employee and it is our responsibility to make sure that he is meeting our expectations and acting in the best interest of students and so I think that it is the superintendent's job to run the district but it is also our job to follow up to ensure that that is being done to our expectations in you know Student First and all of those things abely any other thoughts about board members roles or responsibilities so just as a a few like highlevel overview um you all are here to do the policym to approve the policies now those policies may be brought forward by community members for consideration they may be brought forward by the superintendent for
020consideration um but you all are in a really unique position here where this community was a farming Community 10 years ago right meaning that it was very much a community that I grew up in so I grew up in Mojave Valley Arizona right very very small town reservation in migrant farmw working is like the primary um means of employment with that being said everybody that we are around um knew each and every one of the governing board members very intimately and any policies that they thought or the school should change or whatever that might be we're often a knock on the door versus an actual coming in and having a conversation during a board meeting so you all are in this unque position and you'll hear me um talk about it kind of throughout the
021board presentation or this presentation today of what happens when a community becomes Urban or you know and was rural not that long ago so half of the community knows what it is to be a farming community and the other half of the community knows what it is to grow up in Central Phoenix so it's um very you're melding two different worlds right now and you're in a unique position within your leadership to meld those worlds and to help those worlds come together in a way that's going to best suit the children so that is where kind of the strategic planning and that long-term visioning comes in helping the community to understand strategic planning goals are and really communicating that through your public relations and your um budgeting how you're approving your budgeting as well so
022really the questions we're asking is am I acting as a board member or I'm stepping into administrative roles so what are some of the examples that might be stepping into administrative [Laughter] roles I think one of the dangers and and board member cenon mentioned this earlier um where as a board member an example of reaching into administrative roles is getting going Beyond around the the actual superintendent and trying to fix a problem ourselves um or deal with an HR situation or you know a number of things there's a number of easy ways for us to go outside of our duties and start stepping on somebody else's um so it's really important that we just kind of keep ourselves in check and know what we're here for what our what our lane is yeah absolutely I
023think like a good way to kind of check is like if is it something I'm going to be voting on because that is that is our responsibility so if it's going to come before us then you know we do need to have the information we do need to have the knowledge um you know and those kinds of things so I think is it something we're going to vote on yeah that's a a really great question to ask when you're um really digging into the weeds of because there are going to be pieces of information that you're going to need in order to make an informed decision about your vote it's different than getting pieces of information to um you know change an actual procedure so I also like to think about it is it procedural
024so at any point in time if it's looking like this is a procedure then that goes to the superintendent rather if it's a policy or a strategic planning aspect then that's where we're really going to look at that's a governing board memb responsibility so just kind of a high level over the focus of the governing board is going to be that strategic oversight those long-term goals um a long-term vision and objectives the highlevel policy inform or high level policy formation and your approval but you guys are accountable to your community directly where our um Administration is accountable to you right and so as you said miss simmerman the only employee you have is a superintendent but he's the head of everything else so it is really important to make sure that the goals um in
025the Strategic plan and the ones that you have envisioned for this District are all being followed through with by him now his focus is going to be so much more operational right so kind of that procedure that we were talking about just a moment or that I was talking about just a moment ago that procedure that um it's a short-term goals here but honestly there is no superintendent alive who doesn't have a long-term vision for their school district they put their Blood Sweat and Tears into this and so they have an idea of where they'd like to see it and they try and communicate that with the board and come up with a unified vision for the district um but they are responsible for managing those Associated risk uh with day-to-day operations where we're asking
026you all to keep your eyes and ears to the community to manage the associate or to navigate and identify the associated risk within the community right meaning we're seeing uh enrollment decline what's going on I've got my eyes and ears on the streets to hear what's happening maybe we don't have enough parent teacher involv or parent involvement like what am I hearing from the parents when I'm out and about what are they saying so what is that Community voice that you can bring to the superintendent to try and navigate some of these pitfalls with school choice being a real thing we need your help we need your help um in hearing what is being said what that public perception is and helping us to develop what the public perception is of the district right now
027obviously we're not just talking about perception perception comes from the meat and potatoes of what's inside our schools so what changes do we need to make there so that the public has a perception of the district where they want to send their students right so it's not just the um for lack of a better term lipstick on a pig type of a thing right we actually want to improve the foundational structures of our system so that our students are getting everything that they need and that includes everyone from our alternative students our special education students our gened pop and all of those that are excelling as well okay so avoiding some of the pitfalls I'm curious if some of the board members that have been on the board for a little longer can describe maybe
028one or two pitfalls that you see and board service I think um the one that comes to mind other than out you know getting out of our lane and our responsibilities is open meeting law um that's a big one that's an easy one for people to make mistakes um what some of the some of the mistakes I've seen in the past have been somebody hitting reply all on an email and it goes to a whole bunch of people uh numerous board members um another one that just you know I've seen and again it's easy to do is before a meeting starts watching conversation in the room because before a meeting starts the meeting hasn't started so you can't have conversations with multiple board members about something even if it's on your agenda because then you're
029violating open meeting law the meeting hasn't started so just just you know navigating that again is is tricky sometimes and I would when you're at an event and and there are multiple board members present and you're in a group like the the image is is what are you talking about and you know I think you know any we all need to be really careful because you know we'll use for example like um the Arts gosh I'm going to Festival of the Arts likely we'll all be at the festival of the Arts together um just cuz it's just a district quite a bit and so you know you just need to be really careful because the public is paying attention you know yeah yep and that's where just knowing what our lane is right um just
030knowing where we're when we're at certain locations whether it be a districtwide thing or something outside the district um you know if somebody has something going on at their park local park and we all happen to see each other and show up and say hi you know just so the public knows that's not not a violation of open meeting law even if all five board members are present as long as we're not discussing there you go what we're going to be voting on um and so again yes absolutely public perception you know you try to avoid these if possible but if you can avoid it you just be very careful with what you're talking about so so I was Consulting with a school district up north um and one of the open meeting law complaints
031that they were having to address was that all five board members um were at a soccer game together and they were discussing School business that had was not on the agenda right so that somebody had overheard them talking about a bathroom leak at the school well as much as that seemed innocent enough they were talking about the construction cost and whatnot it was still an open meeting law violation so it's one of those things to just be really careful with because again we are still in a farming community that has met its Urban like City of Phoenix has somehow Spilled Out to Good Year Buckeye right so we are in this braiding of Worlds right now and as you're trying to navigate how that is going how these rivers are going to um merge together
032make sure that you're really careful in when you're attending the kids events when you're attending whatever you will see your board members your fellow board members all throughout the community and as you're doing that you may have some questions about a specific thing that's happening at the school it's just not the time to talk about it at those specific events so even talking about a school restroom can be an open meeting law violation because it could be an agenda item it could be an agenda item at some point in time and even if it wasn't it's still School business so yeah all of the things so also as we were talking about navigating some of the complaints that you're going to receive while you're at fry shopping or Safeway I'm not endorsing any grocery store
033chain here um or at whatever local you know event or whatnot that you're at you may receive a complaint and it's typically like my son's teacher my daughter's soccer coach it might be something of that and it seems to be relatively mundane it's still a complaint so following this last uh complaint method is really helpful and making sure that you are listening of course and acknowledging that all concerns are valid but sending them to the appropriate person so I'll talk to so and so about this and have them get right back to you right but thank them always for um bringing it to to you as a board member we love to have our community speak to us openly about what's going on but we can't be involved in that investigative process whatsoever because it
034may become a board agenda right it as mundane and it may as it may seem that one soccer coach might have four or five complaints against them right it might not be as easy as what we're thinking it also might be a Community member that's upset that their child were sad out of a specific sock rate that is up to the administration it's procedural and if it does become something bigger you would have to recuse yourself from that and then we would lose your voice on whatever matters that might happen you know as a result so that is a big part we don't ever want to lose your voice in what is happening on the back end if we have to do an investigation and go through a formal process we want each all five
035board members to be able to void what their um thoughts are on the matter I excuse me sticking to the agenda um we're asking that just don't bring any surprises to the meeting like let's have agenda items up front and let's have conversations this helps us to really prepare for anything that is um coming up at the board meetings it also helps us make sure that we have nothing but factual information versus a a lot of concerns or um perspectives versus the actual facts of whatever case is going on um maintaining the professionalism in all of our interactions uh I was with another I was with another um school board and we were the lack of professionalism wound up getting this person in trouble right because people didn't they felt that they were more casual
036with one group than they were with another and so discrimination became um an absolute issue for this individual so knowing that how you treat one is how you treat all and keeping a level of professionalism both in the boardroom and outside of the board room when you are meeting with parents or like interacting with our community is really important and then keeping our public and private roles separate vice president Kenya I know you have students can you kind of give us an example of the ways that you are able to differentiate between those roles yeah thank you so you know this this had been on the board for two years there's been a number of times I've went to you know um volleyball events or things happening at different uh schools knowing what I'm there
037for uh am I there for my child where I'm there as a as a board member um keeping those roles separate is is super important for me uh and everybody because you want to be careful you're not Crossing certain lines um I know before coming on the board I was part of Liberties PTO and talking to uh the superintendent at the time the previous administration you know Dr Shuff had advised me yeah you could stay on as PTO you know on the PTO but you got to be very careful about you being on the board and being on a PTO you know there's certain things you got to be super super careful about and so you know it's just knowing when to choose what direction um I like to do it personally by if I'm
038going as a board member I'll try to wear a badge if I'm going as a parent I won't um and then that not only lets other people know what what capacity I am there but also it reminds me why am I here so yeah that's a really great advice to wear your bad anytime you are representing your governing board role um obviously regardless of being there as a parent or as a governing board member many times the community members will only see you as a governing board member so if you are there in you know to visit your this comes sorry this comes up a lot more when you're visiting teachers right am I hear as a parent teacher conference or am I here as a governing board member and so really being clear with
039the staff of like no I'm here to discuss this issue with my child um or with you know who my gu or my um yeah my child let's just put it that way so I'm here to discuss this issue with my about my child or I'm here to discuss issue um regarding governing board business okay so open meeting law and transparency is key i' like to um when we talk about transparency I'd like to get an idea of what transparency means for you what are some of the the common definitions that we use when we talk about transparency to me transparen means not that was kind of lame but not hiding stuff from the public if we know about it and it's not something that's going to violate any upcoming meeting or if that's already
040agenda's already passed like we need to share the information we had long violate in kind of Law and not try to hide stuff so it makes the superintendent looks better so hide it makes us look better like we we can share it we should share it okay okay I think part of transparency is making sure that it's accurate information and it's all of the information I think it goes back to what Mr ceron was saying it's like well I'm going to share part of it because it's not going to look great if I share the rest of it and I I think transparency is all of it and make sure that it's accurate and I think if we don't know the answer the better response is I'm not sure let me get back to you
041versus giving some misinformation um because then I think it creates a lack of trust and when people feel lack of trust they don't feel the the transparency yeah absolutely so knowing that the majority of board members um no no decisions outside of official meetings right so this is a quorum um avoiding the serial discussions um via text or email and I think uh CL can talk to us a little bit about how sensitive it is with our phones when we're discussing um School business because our phones become a part of public record if we're discussing School business over um text message so that also I like to kind of bring that to the Forefront of everyone's attention that school business discussed on your cell phones it will be considered public record if that is requested
042do not reply all on emails because that can get really tricky as well and that is going to be open meeting law violation anything that's set an executive discussion needs to stay private um and then you know public perception matters so there's a difference between transparency and oversharing right so giving the details of a specific event is really uh or giving the outcome of a specific event that's transparent sharing all of the nitty-gritty of how we got to that decision can be oversharing so I like to remind us to always why are we sharing what we're sharing are we sharing it to Garner public interest for ourselves right public approval for the way that we voted or are we doing it to share um the relevant information about the school district and about the votes
043that we came to yes I would add also that student information is very confidential and so you need to re remember that that everybody has a right to privacy and and student information is not public information go ahead okay I'll probably add that employee information is the same idea to some extent yes you're absolutely right especially personal confidential information like addresses phone numbers those kinds of things that you would um not necessarily want everybody to be aware of so we also like to remind everyone to communicate with some caution um social media text messages anything that's written can become come public information right um and then speaking to the the public we're avoiding sharing like you said student information especially employee information as well like any information regarding the staff and the inner workings like
044we want to avoid sharing that um any information that can come up in executive session right and just think about if we need an executive session to discuss this it cannot be released anywhere else right and if I could just clarify a little bit about employee uh information it actually is public record except for teachers evaluations are confidential by law but uh a person can uh request public records on an an employee you would the district would have the responsibility to redact things that are confidential private information of the individual like Social Security numbers that kind of thing and that also comes to like sharing the facts of what's Happening versus our perception or perspective or opinion about it as well right we want to make sure that when we are sharing information with the
045public that we're sharing the facts of what's Happening um not necessarily our not necessarily not our opinions about what's happening specifically and then directing any of the concerns to appropriate staff members and the followup so not only are we directing it to the staff member but we're making sure a lot of times we just need to check in and say hey if you follow up make sure you let me know right well let me know about your followup or whatever that was would be so that that way if the person comes back to you then you have the ability to say oh well so and so followed up on you know this state so it just makes it a lot easier to keep track when constituents are coming to you they're bringing concerns to you
046you've passed them off asking for the staff member who is going to follow through with that to just send you an email of like hey I took care of this on this date can I just ask a clarifying question to Dr Monroe because there's there's been some discussion about you know all communication from us should go through you so so when when you say staff member you really mean the superintendent right we're not we're not sending it to a principal of a school we're going to send it to Dr Monroe right and so then Dr Monroe will get back to you okay I just wanted to clarify for can I speak just a little bit to that um so yeah I completely agree and that would be as a board member we would discuss it
047with Dr Monroe but if we're advising the person who's bringing the complaint a lot of times they need to start from you know the certain chain of command and work their way up but yeah yeah yeah so if uh if we're talking with a public and asking or they're asking who to go to then yes you're going to start at the lowest chain of command and then go up but if you are sending the complaint into the school then it goes through Dr Monroe and then he will let you know that yes I'll take care of this or it's gotten um and then technology use again we're just assuming that if it's written it's public information so resources we have um access to the policy manual currently you guys have access to the asba policy
048manual do you all know how to get to that yes okay and then you also have your board protocols which gives us all of the communication protocols how to get something on the board agenda um there's also um emergency communication protocols that are in there as well any questions on how to get access to the policy manual or what the board protocols do you know where to locate those that's what we're talking about tonight right in the meeting yeah do you know where to locate them no like besides the agenda no yeah we post it on it's posted on the web page all right so it post on the superintendent web page all right so staying effective and responsible to your constituents is a lot about acting as a team so we've had times um
049in places where board members have decided to act on their own with going to different news media Outlets or whatever um we're acting we're asking that we don't act alone in that any type of news media requests or anything like that should be worked with Dr Monroe um so that you guys have uh unified voice and then we're focusing on the best interest of the LD students so knowing that our students are our priorities they are um where your heart of service like as I'm hearing you all speak about why you're serving you're serving for our students and just making sure that their best interest um is always kept in mind when we're communicating with the public when we're communicating with each other um and when we are uh out and about within their communities
050as well and then be patient your confidence will grow with time um nobody walks in here knowing everything right and being willing to be a student and show our students what it's like to be a good student of a governing board as well um to be in an always learning right we're always learning new things we're always studying um better ways of being and better ways of leading and so knowing that your confidence in that will grow with time but also you are the example so how we treat each other and how we treat our community will reverberate through each and every one of our schools and through our district office and you all do set the tone for the culture of this school in a lot of ways so when in doubt ask um
051kind of the last step so kind practical tips you don't have to know everything um you don't also have to speak on every topic right so listen and learn um before you're you feel the need to speak on the topic keeping our words concise so that we don't have long board meetings I know no one likes a midnight board meeting nobody not our governing board sometimes they're necessary but our governing board our community our um Educators no one likes a midnight meeting so if we can really focus our conversations at the meeting we want to have robust conversations but we also want them to be productive attend the training opportunities I really encourage you all to attend those opportunities to train with each other and to get more information about Schoolboard leadership there are some
052wonderful um training opportunities out there so make sure you take advantage of those and uh you know just build your confidence over time so that is all I have for you but I am curious if there's anything that you all wish you would know or if there's any lingering thoughts before I get going today just say something yes please thank you for your time tonight and uh as uh vice president Kenyan mentioned we we did a a board self-evaluation a while back and one of the areas that came out as weak was this idea of orienting new board members or at least not throwing them in the Deep End right like maybe was Chris's experience and so we're committed to doing that I know we have some tours set up where we're going to go
053see some schools and walk some schools and things like that and so we're committed to making sure you get what you need and uh you know that somehow drinking from a fire hose has slowed and your confidence grows and you guys um can feel uh like you can serve and and how you want to desire it does take it does take some time but and uh I will complement the board um almost everyone here was able to attend our the dayong training which is really helpful we have very very good board members who take their job very serious and um they don't get paid for this and they use a lot of their time at night um on the weekends and so I am here as a superintendent not only do I work for you
054but uh I'm here to support you and get you what you need and so we're committed to helping you as new board members get what you need as you're starting off this new Journey so and I'm really eager to see the board self evaluation this year as we start to move forward because I can tell you A lot of the things that was identified um in our last board self- evaluation we have directly taken head-on um and I can really say I am very proud of this board um and its ability and its uh tenacity to address what has been coming up so I look forward to doing another board self- evaluation with you all um and thank you so much for your time today thank you Miss casos uh let's go ahead and show
055that the meeting will be adjourned at 5:15 and we will begin general meeting at 5:30 okay [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] I [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] oh [Music] what up what up what up oh sh [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] I [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] sh oh [Music] oh [Music] we show that uh we're bringing to order the Liberty 25 governing board regular meeting January 13th at 5:30 here at the Jerry roie administration building uh governing board members present we have Miss Schmidt um Mr serenon Miss Zimmerman myself Chris Kenyan uh president Parks couldn't be here tonight he's at home ill and we wish him the best and with
056that we will go ahead and move to item 5.2 pres of uh Pledge of Allegiance and we would ask that uh Mr Jaden would lead us in this please ready begin I to the flag United States of America and to the Republic for IT stand one nation under God indivisible liy and justice for all welcome to the Liberty Elementary School District governing board meeting we appreciate your interest in the district the five elected governing board members serve without compensation and volunteer countless hours on behalf of our students and staff the President and Vice President of the board are elected in January under state law the governing board may only discuss and vote on matters that are on the the agenda for tonight's meeting agendas are posted a minimum of 24 hours in advance on the
057Liberty Elementary School District web page and at the Jerry roie District complex copies of tonight's agenda are located in the foyer and on the District web page if you wish to make a public comment please complete a request to address the board form and submit to the board secretary before the meeting starts these forms are located in the foyer prior to entering the governing boardroom members of the public will be given a maximum of 3 minutes to speak once recognized by the governing board president please state your name before you speak during the call to the public the public may speak on any item of business on the agenda that requires the board to take action the public may also speak to the governing board about a school district matter that is not on the
058agenda state law prohibits board members from commenting on or discussing the matters presented at the end of the call to the public however the board may ask the superintendent to review the issue or place it on a future agenda a board member may also briefly respond to criticism of a board member or the governing board itself we ask that all speakers show respect and courtesy to others comments must pertain to a matter that is within the jurisdiction of the governing board this is not not an appropriate form to complain about an employee student or others we also ask the public who are present for the meeting to be respectful by being attentive avoid calling out or creating any disruption that may interfere or interrupt the meeting individuals who interrupt or interfere with the meeting may
059be asked to leave by the board president thank you for allowing this meeting to be conducted in a peaceful and productive Manner and thank you for your attendance and involvement in tonight's meeting all right thank you we will move to item 5.3 approval of the regular agenda form I have a motion motion to approve the regular agenda consistent with the board policy BB and temporarily suspend governing board policy with which this agenda may be inconsistent I have a second second all right let's go ahead and take a vote Miss Schmidt this is going to be your very first vote on the board so congratulations and welcome I Mr uh serenon I miss simmerman I and I also vote I that shows that pass 4 Z we'll move to 6.1 attendance enrollment reports and school newsletters
060Dr Monroe vice president Kenyon members of the board happy New Year um here we are in 2 uh Mrs Schmidt happy birthday just on a side note we know it's your birthday so um and she gets suspended at a board meeting at her first so we're glad you're here with us we won't sing Happy Birthday to you but uh but happy birthday we do have a little a little gift for you but uh here uh governing board members are are the enrollment reports uh with attendance reports we present these to you uh uh for your review each month and also the school newsletters for the upcoming month from each of our seven schools are included here as well any discussion no discussion um then we'll go ahead and move to 6.2 uh governing board and
061superintendent recognitions Dr Monro vice president Parks members of the board I am really excited tonight to be sitting next to Jaden Lopez so proud uh of that Jaden is here it takes a big person to sit in such a formal area and uh the fact that he is a student leader at Rainbow Valley Elementary School just shows his courage and his strength being up here but I'd like to tell the board a little bit about uh Jaden and why he was selected uh we're going to start having our a student leader from each of our schools join us on the dis and we value student leadership and uh Jaden is a good reminder of why we do what we do and um uh Jaden inspires us to be better leaders and it gives us such
062hope uh such that Jaden you're such a wonderful individual so let me read you a little bit about Jaden and why he was chosen from Mrs Kagel and then we're going to let Jaden uh read a little something that he wrote about why he loves his time at Rainbow Valley as a student uh so Jaden Lopez is an eighth grade student at Rainbow Valley Elementary School he's been there since kindergarten during his time as a student he's demonstrated many leadership skills and qualities he's responsible hardworking and he demonstrates caring and respect toward others he's worked hard to grow and improve acad mically over the course of his career over his seven or eight years at Rainbow Valley he sets goals he seeks feedback and he practices self-reflection Jaden also has a love for the game
063of soccer he's a student athlete which is a big obligation to represent your school and to get good grades and he serves as a leader on Rainbow Valley's uh boys soccer team so Jaden we're glad that you're up here with us um Dr mohorn will you pass the microphone we took a picture with Jaden before and we'll have him come down and take a picture with the governing board but I'm going to hand the microphone over to you so you guys can also hear what a wonderful young man uh Jaden is like like I've been learning thank you good evening board members and Dr Monroe my name is Jaden Lopez and I am currently an eighth grader at Rainbow Valley I have been a been super fortunate to have been a student there since I
064was Kindergarten rainbow Valley is many things to me first of all it has been my place of learning since I was 6 years old when I came to Rainbow Valley in kindergarten I did not know any English but miss Raina changed that for me while I was already a speaker of Spanish I became a speaker of English with Miss raina's guidance thank you so much Miss Raina as I grew through the grade levels Rainbow Valley teachers not only helped me achieve educational goals to move myself forward they were also teachers who actually cared about me they cared about how I felt when I was happy and how I felt when I was troubled they understood and still understand to this day my personality and what makes me me rainbow Rainbow Valley has special teachers it
065is a place where I feel safe and respected and they are special people who guide me to make good decisions and without them I would not be who I am today our PR principal Mrs Kel is special she cares about everyone and cares about everyone and everything that is Rainbow Valley but what is most important is that she cares about us her students she has a ton of energy she is always out and about checking on all the students she also has the biggest warmest smile that makes me so happy when I have struggled and had to step out of the classroom to reflect on my behavior I was surprised by how I actually felt do you want to know how I felt it was guilt I felt I felt and still feel this way
066because Miss Kel has the special way about her of course I felt bad that I didn't make the best decision in class but the worst part was feeling guilty that I disappointed Miss K she only wants what is best for me and all the students at Rainbow Valley I just want to say thank thank you to all of Rainbow Valley teachers who guided me and thank you to miss Kel for caring so much about my school Rainbow Valley [Applause] hey Jaden before we uh take the mic completely away from you is there any like interesting questions you have for Miss Kel while we got her here and you're all up here kind of put you on the spot you don't have to if you don't want to I'm just put you on the spot when
067would when will we get a good soccer field good good question very good question all right Dr Monro I I think there's a lot of students and principles at their schools that have the same question so a great question Jaden um we are working on it I will answer for Mrs Kagel I know she has given it a lot of attention in all of our schools their soccer fields need a lot of attention so we know it's important to you buddy so we're we're on it but Jaden and uh the members of the board why don't you guys come down and we'll do our students of the month at the beginning of our board meetings many of you have not been here and many have been here but one of the great things that our
068board does is gets to recognize staff and students and so we're going to recognize some students of the month and one of our student leaders Jaden is going to join our our governing board here so uh vice president Kenyan I'll turn it over to you all right well I want to First say thank you all for coming and supporting this uh on behalf of Dr Monroe and the governing board members and myself we are pleased to recognize eight out standing students from our seven schools these students exemplify the values that make Liberty Elementary School District exceptional they embody our core values of respect Integrity accountability high standards and of course student centered their honesty hard work and caring nature positively impact their schools classrooms and Community thank you to these students and their families for
069joining us as I call your name please come forward to be recognized and then stay up here because we'll get a group photo afterwards all right going to say first congratulations from Blue Horizons to Tatiana sales our next one will be from australa Mountain Marlene Ceno [Applause] congratulations conat our next one from Freedom Elementary Millie Mora Asuna congratulations our next one from Los bries Academy Lenny Garcia opz [Applause] all right our next one from Liberty Elementary is Lexi Zimmerman hey Lexi congratulations good job come on over here congratulations our next one will be Rainbow Elementary Ruben baloa Cario hey Ruben all right that's okay we'll get him a certificate that's okay all right uh and then we have from Westar Elementry kisi Bond good okay so why don't you guys come up and line up
070students in front of the board here and hold up your certificates oh one more sorry like we got one more hold on one second okay we have uh from Rainbow we have Violeta Cordova come there we go and then okay so one more that's from Blue from Blue okay all right we got one more from Blue Horizon we got a lot tonight that's good uh from Blue Horizon's Xavier here Alat uh Al sorry all right here over here all right now I'm GNA try to sneak in here let me slide right behind you buddy all right and then we'll get you a prize here in a minute thank you all right yeah we can take um he did he get his certificate he didn't come up we gave it to you can walk that's all
071right there we go Derek are you still around all right we're gonna take another one more picture here job Ruby all right with that if if Mr Jaden wants us hang up here he can however long he wants the rest of you uh if you're a parent we thank you for coming out if you want to go ahead and go home now you're more than welcome to we're going to take little break just let you guys clear out if you want if you want to hang out for the rest of the meeting that's up to you thank you thank you not yet she's you have any update job good job thank you okay we're going to go ahead and continue we're still live right okay we're going to go ahead and continue with um item
072oh 7.1 governing board update and we'll start over there at the end with Miss Schmidt do you have anything for the governing board I don't have anything for the board except to say thank you for uh the welcome and for to the public for allowing me to serve you and for spending my birthday with me tonight so thank [Music] you thank you Mr Shani I just want to say uh welcome to mmid I look forward to working uh with you miss simmerman um I don't really have anything tonight um except to uh you know share that several of us went to the asba conference um and I think that was um you know really useful uh time for us as board members to just kind of learn about our role and you know things that
073we should be working towards and maybe not working towards so um but nothing else at this time thank you um I have a couple things I would like to quickly discuss um one is a little bit personal I over the last couple months have had people come to me or not really come to me but kind of attack me a little bit in a public setting in regards to my faith and I'm curious to why this is re relevant as a board member I have yet to ever see anybody and any board critique somebody's faith I'm not going to get into it a whole lot but I've been asked publicly what I believe what God I serve so just so you know I did bring my Bible if you want to know what I believe
074read this and study it don't take away from it don't add to it and you will know what I believe I'll leave that at that I've never attacked anybody um or treated anybody different because of their faith and I expect that same to be shown to me I also want to welcome mmid this is her for first board meeting and I look forward to working with her and happy birthday again um over the last uh holiday break we've seen a lot of things happen over the district a lot of construction going on a lot of repairs being made to facilities and so it's great to see that things are things are being fixed there's a there's been a lot of issues um that have been fixed and Mr Young had to step out um unfortunately
075I wanted to congratulate him for all that he's been working on but um I just wanted to mention that um I do want to say that something that is very dear to my heart is Public Safety in regards to our district campuses um I've been pushing for this even before I was on the board about trying to get SRO or ssos in every one of our campuses and we found out over the break I don't have all the details I don't think we have all the details yet but we will be getting uh we've received a grant so that now each one of our schools not just the two schools out of the seven but all seven will have an SSO or s next year and we're very happy about that so yes and then
076the last thing I have is uh well in regards to that I do want to say shout out and thank you to uh Dr Mahorn she's pushed really hard on that that Grant and then thank you to the Goodyear and Buckeye police departments they've also assisted with that so very proud of them um and then lastly congratulations to miss Crowley she's uh submitted her retirement uh she's going into retirement she's served our district for quite a number of years have helped a lot of students and has just been a great asset to this district and uh very proud of her and looking forward to her having having a great retirement I mean I I got a long ways to go to get there so uh very little bit envious of her for that but very
077proud of her so just wanted to say that all right we will move to 8.1 which is public comment so before I call out the names if you have submitted one of our public comment um papers you will have three minutes for your comment and please provide your full name and if you resided within the district or outside of the district please refrain from personal attacks foul language or repetition of previous comments and with that we will go ahead and start your three minutes is up there we will start with uh Mr Peter Smith my name is Peter Smith I live in District ars1 15503 D States on or before May 15th each year year the governing board shall offer a contract for the next school year to each certified administrator myself and many of
078the parents of this District expect that Mrs Boris will receive a contract for the next school year and that she will remain at EMS and our patience for Assurance is running out recently you were each sent a petition notification making our expectations clear 848 of those signatures were from residents of this District another 653 were in surrounding areas and able to send their children to our schools through open enrollment at this Point many of us are demanding an end to the board majority's plans and those of Court Monroe to push out our principles as we are now hearing that the principle of Rainbow Valley is at risk of being forced out as well along with numerous District staff who worked closely with superintendent camp we also demand the resignation or termination of Court Monroe there
079are a number of reports of him pulling teachers into off the books meetings at their sites and using his position to intimidate him his termination is within the power of the board to require just as it was over at Queen Creek also within your PO is the ability to police your own Brian Parks is recorded in his own words as having said to Court Monroe you better get down there or I'm going to kill her about our principal Mrs Boris he has stated publicly on the internet he surprised the women in this day and time don't know how to not get pregnant and that statement is incredibly disgusting given the fact that he is on audio judging the severity of a sexual assault on a middle school girl he even laughs about the lack of
080severity at the end of the audio while he may think it was worth a laugh the great state of Arizona did not they sentenced the perpetrator to prison for nearly a year while you cannot remove Bryant Parks from the board you can hold him accountable a core belief of our district is accountability as was recently stated by stripping him of his honorific no one who says or believes as he does should be the representative of our school board it is a position of dignity respect and unity all it takes us three of you to vote for a new board president though I would suggest all of you vote to remove it from Brian Parks no one wants to be seen as being buddy buddy with the guy who laughed about the sexual assault of a
081middle schooler and who can't stay quiet about pending litigation against the district this will cost you nothing politically as these recordings will likely be used by anyone competing against him in future primaries he will likely never make it to the state legislature as he has stated he was being broomed for if you do not support the removal of his title you will be setting up the end of your own political Futures alongside his we expect to see this item on the next agenda all right next speaker we have Johanna Rodriguez my name is Joanna Rodriguez I'm out of District family friends and board members I'd like to take a moment and to thank each board member for being here this evening I'm happy that Amy the coach and consultant was speaking about serving because as
082board members you all were either elected or appointed as a non-partisan to serve without compensation what an honor and a privilege you must feel that you were elected by your community to then turn around and serve it do you serve the schools do you serve the parents The Faculty the superintendent it's the kids their safety their education their teachers their schools I'd like to thank Miss Zimmerman thank you for being the board member that sometimes freaks out over matters that involve our children and the transparency of this board I wish more fellow board members were just as passionate as you were I also wish more B more board members would volunteer their time at things like read live at our schools and other opportunities to volunteer as well I understand a superintendent is chosen by
083the board because that person is meant to have knowledge and or expertise in making executive decisions for the schools within the district that being said please tell us why is it good for estrea Mountain Elementary why are the kids okay to be rid of Mrs Boris why is her contract not being renewed why if there is no list of teachers or faculty that you want out of here why are there countless recordings emails and social media posts that Mak some of you look very dishonest with that statement why is it that the big changes that are involving all of you involve losing beloved teachers and principles that just so happen to be on this non-existent list you had kids here in the last meeting pleading with you don't take our principal away and some of
084you couldn't even bother to look those children in the eye without maybe turning a little bit red or even frustrated I'm not standing here as your enemy I want to understand your reasonings I know some of you board members think we parents are idiots but we're not we're passionate we care we sometimes freak out a little bit but help us understand help us understand this logic serving does not Grant you power serving does not mean you do it alone serving isn't for the week please continue to be transparent please continue to be truthful please be the amazing people that you all want to be by fulfilling the honor to serve and thank you truly thank you to each and every one of you who are willing to maybe freak out a little bit do what
085it takes for the education and the growing and the protection of our kids next speaker we have Amy spets good evening Dr Monroe vice president Kenyan and board members my name is Amy svetz and I am in the district and have been so for 16 years for the past 25 years my life has been mostly about children raising my own being a nanny and when we moved to Australia I was a teacher at the Australia Mountain preschool for the past 12 years I've proudly worked for Liberty Elementary School District in many different capacities I'm currently the office manager at Australia Mountain Elementary I love my do it's a privilege to watch students and families grow I'm proud to partner with Mrs Boris our teachers support staff and most importantly our families to help each child
086grow in their education as well as their confidence in the intangibles that make strong quality individuals over the past five and a half years Mrs Boris has built a culture where who models expects and receives Excellence on a daily basis she has built a community where learning and Trust are in the Forefront teachers show up every day ready to pour into our students the teach the Australia staff remains professional and continues to run like a well-oiled machine despite the unnecessary stress and noise currently surrounding us that is not easy to do but we do it every day because our children are our why and they deserve it under Mrs boris's leadership australa consistently me remains among the highest performing schools in the district it is the only school to achieve an a rating three years
087in a row and is the school with the highest teacher retention rate Mrs Boris knows and she makes sure we know we are not done I'm asking you to reconsider the plan to not renew Mrs boris's contract for the next year I fear the impact on our students and our community the domino effect is going to be staggering and the ones that will be the most adversely impacted are our 569 students in their families I'm also asking you to end the speculation now so that we can focus on what is important our students we all have a responsibility to teach kids more than just the ABCs and one 123s we must all be teaching them what servant leadership looks like not just leadership servant leadership what Community Building looks like and what a culture of
088lifelong learning looks like like there is no better teacher of those three critical life skills for Australia Mountain Elementary than Millian Z bis thank you so much for listening all our next speaker we have Mr Paul Jensen my name is Paul Jensen I'm in the district Jaden I agree with you everyone knows how amazing Mrs Kagel and Mrs lovess are Mrs Kagel has brought back much of what was good at Rainbow Valley the community support has been outstanding she knows the students and cares deeply about the families she is truly what Rainbow Valley needs obviously there is more to do and I know with the leadership that is at Rainbow Valley it can happen if the board really supports them and the teachers I'd like to know how the board is judging the success of
089your mission the majority of the board at the last meeting accepted without change all the kpis developed by The District administration those kpis will be used to judge those exact administrators and you just accepted them even when Dr SLO said one of them was bad what kind of accountability is that Brian Parks agreed that they are bad and said the kpis would be adjusted in the summer can your principles use that same excuse for discipline and math scores you are holding your principles to a much higher standard than yourselves what are you going to use to tell if you are getting the results you want Brian seron I would still like to meet with you if you have time I've always had respect for basis as a great charter school I hope you're able to
090take the good they are doing and incorporate it into the public school setting remember if you have Ambitions to be in the education field is attaching your name to what Brian Parks and Chris Kenyan are doing to Liberty really what you want to be known for in a Google search I've seen glimmers of hope that you are questioning their judgment and hope to see more of that in the coming four years the majority of the board seems to be pushing some crazy agenda with how poorly things are going you may end up proving how faulty an agenda it is and destroying the long-term viability of your cause if you will listen to what Kelly and Sarah are advocating for all the children you may be able to salvage your agenda currently Liberty is not being
091looked at as The Shining City on the hill for great education if you cons continue your Crusade it is going to destroy your cause and reputation just to point out one more problem 18 teachers have left the district this school year most of which paid $2,500 or almost 5% of the average annual salary so far there have only been six certified teacher hires this school year what is happening in those other 12 classes what are what you are doing to Liberty isn't just it will get worse before it gets better it's just plain worse next speaker we have Nancy gray Nancy gray all right there she is uh Nancy gray in District board members and Community thank you all for the opportunity to letting me speak today I share my decision to live a position
092that I was once very comfortable with just down the street at bucka Elementary School District in pursuit of making a greater difference I came here full of Hope and determination only to be completely blindsided by what I have experienced not just on my campus but districtwide and my career I have never encountered a district where political views and personal opinions of leadership take presidents over research science and most importantly the best interest of our students decisions are being made to satisfy those who readily step into the trenches of Education while those of us in the classroom work tirelessly for our students and are left to Bear the brunt of poor policies and practices I've heard time and time again the pride the district takes in removing seal supports and fostering punitive discipline systems but what
093many failed to realize is that the students suffering the most are those that are already being punished enough in their homes children who are love come to school ready to learn children who are not loved come to school seeking connection care and belonging yet as Educators we are being stripped of the ability to address these fundamental needs before academic learning can even begin passionate and dedicated teachers who who teach with their hearts and souls are being pushed out while mediocracy is being rewarded those who confirm without question who jump when told are being praised meanwhile we are Paving a pathway for our students to fall into cycles of failure and destruction I walk away heartbroken know I I came here to make a difference but leave feeling defeated I am leaving the children I have
094grown so close to children who lack a voice and deserve better I am supposed to advocate for students and families but my voice has been silenced at every turn today I refuse to remain silent my resignation is not just a personal decision but a statement the best Among Us those who are willing to stand up for what is Right cannot and will not stay in environments that fail our students to the leaders and decision makers I urge you to reflect deeply the district has the power to change course our students deserve better and so do our Educators who have dedicated their lives to serving them thank you all right next we have Elwood Cutler hello uh my name is Elwood consler people call me Butch uh and uh I am representing We the People again
095and uh I am in District um and uh I would just like to start with did you just state if you live in the district or not I'm sorry yes I did in the district y yes sir um I would like to to start by congratulating uh Mr parks on his reelection and Chris on your reelection and um uh I I got some stats here uh that I pulled from Ada in 2324 teacher experience charts side by side Liberty has approximately 14% increase in teachers with experience Ela and mass scores have gone up 10% overall growth in performance is almost 50% the board is now spending and I love this one the board is now spending $2,000 more per pupil in the classroom the board has consistently put more money in the classroom in spending
096so I would just like to recommend that this entire board continue the path of Excellence that has been set by the previous board the naysayers the devil worshippers the Satan people they're going to come and they're going to yell and they're going to scream okay just let them do it we know the truth about the kids and these people don't care about the kids and if there's a teacher sick out for some reason every one of those teachers should stay the hell out and not come back thank you sorry for the cust our right next speaker we have Shelly cross I'm Shelly can you hear me I'm Shelly cross I am in the district and thank you for uh to the board for letting me speak today um I wanted to speak today to say
097thank you to president Brian Parks vice president Chris Kenyan and Brian SAR sarason um you take a lot of abuse a lot I I started coming to these meetings because I am in the district and it's important children are important to me and um what I've seen is a little disturbing to be honest um the speakers that come up I'm not sure if they're teachers parents parents of teachers at these I'm in the district and hey let her speak um I noticed at the last four meetings I have heard very little from speakers regarding the students it's always about what the teachers want to do or what and I respect teachers but the goal of everything is the students and their education um it has been um all about the teachers and what they want
098I very seldom hear about as the speakers I'm talking about when they come up to speak I very seldom hear about what's going on with the children and things like that um also the last meeting uh uh several posters were handed out regarding bullying and I'm thinking this is odd read a school board meeting um so I thought I'm going to look up the definition of bullying and what it says is bullying is an unwanted aggressive behavior avior among School AED children that's what it said it's not adults adults should be able it's not I would not consider bullying for adults and I don't think anyone should I have noticed a lot of chaos brought to these meetings um to bash the board basically chaos to bash the board adults have a responsibility to take
099part in uncomfortable conversations when we have a difference of opinion tearing down someone's character just because you disagree with them is not helping anyone and it's it's shocking really and the same people come to speak I you I and it's I'm going to try to get more people to come to these board meetings because um it's a little alarming how bad you guys are bashed and I thank you again thank you uh the next one's going to be Bailey Rosco good evening good evening my name is Bailey Rosco I come to you this evening as a concerned parent and constituent within the district several people active on this board have no children within the school district several other don't have a background in education thankfully we've elected two new members to the board who have
100a background in this and who have pledged transparency I want to drop some facts we've lost 18 to 20 plus students in this District alone since the beginning of the year we have five plus admin from the schools especially the district to leave in the last two years we've had a minimum of two weapons incidences four assaults and an unprecedented amount of bullying amongst students aggressive behavior and students acting erratically and putting others staff and faculty at risk these are not due to behaviors the behavior Matrix but a lack of Staffing stack Staffing qualified teachers and disagreements that are happening teaching is meant to help them cope and deal with these disagreements in an appropriate manner but the decisions of this board have removed those teaching methods these are just a few of the many
101things that have been happening due to the atrocities and frankly borderline criminal behaviors and actions of this board we currently at Westar earn such a staffing shortage that our nurse by no fault of her own is frequently pulled out into the office when she's needed in serious medical situations because she's being called away for for duties when she is needed in the nursing office this weekend I had the chance to listen to my children and their friends talk about the lack of teachers counselors and faculty to talk to when they feel bullied feel unsafe or need someone to speak with directly due to the Staffing shortages based off the actions of this board in closing we as parents and constituents are fed up we will host a sckout or a walk out whatever you want
102to call it if we do not see change we ask for Monroe and parks's immediate resignations all right next speaker is Robert cono all right I'm G move this thing around a little bit all right you can start my time if you want all right check check all right my name is Rob cono um I'm actually a parent I actually went to straight Mountain Elementary School actually went to Liberty for preschool uh went to Liberty Elementary School for preschool Elementary School uh which is straight Mountain Elementary School all the way to 8th grade and I was a first graduating class for stray Foo Hills so I I know this school man I've seen the best teachers come and I seen the best teachers go uh during my time there the principal we had wasn't very
103good man uh and to be completely honest with you the fact that somebody as good as Miss Kagel is even to be considered on The Chopping Block dude blows my mind um not only is that staff there amazing and care more about students than anywhere I've ever seen and what I'm hearing now from the people actually go to Australia Elementary now that their principal is on The Chopping Block as well blows my mind what what is it that you all are looking for that calibrates or decides who's worthy enough to run these schools and the sadness is how many all heard that we are the bottom of the hill school you know that we don't matter as much as the read the schools but we have the most amazing principles and most of these people
104are here in their defense uh what blows my mind the most is our students are killers they're amazing kids they formed my students or my my sons into the National Junior Honor Society my son Dominic who's the student council president is present here because he cares like and those are I mean if they're molding amazing children like that what is there what else do y'all want what else could you ask for you know I I don't know what we're looking forward like what what are we holding but all I can tell you is that open your eyes man open your hearts uh step into the school give them a chance just give them a chance give them what they deserve if you're taking any staff member or principal from from estr Mountain Elementary School or
105Rainbow Valley shame on you or I don't know who who's doing this but to be honest with you man you guys have a solid foundation right there and I know Liberty Elementary School District cuz that is me bro and that is a lot of these people here that are probably homegrown too so when we got something good it rarely comes by this town's disappearing man so don't let the best principles go either dude peace all right that concludes our public comment so we will go ahead and move on to item 9.1 this is the approval of the consent agenda if I can get a motion there there or would anybody like anything pulled can I pull 9.3 please 9.3 give me one second okay uh motion to approve the consent agenda minus 9.3 do I
106have a second second thank you we'll go ahead and vote uh board member Schmidt I board member serenon I member Zimmerman hi and I'm also on I that shows that ioves our passes 4 Z and so we will move to item 9.3 okay it was 9. yeah it was 9.3 it was 9.3 yes it was on mine 9.3 okay do you want me to go all right it was 9.3 so good okay go ahead Mr okay um you know I'm bringing this forward because there are uh seven resignations for basically immediately um and five of those are teachers um that could have liquidated damages applied to them um I am not in support of liquidated damages um and I just think it's too subjective um to be picking and choosing who we're waving them for
107um and so um and I think that the criteria that's being used at least one of other person that wasn't recommended meets that criteria based on their resignation letter so um I'm not in support of passing this with liquidated damages applied okay could we get some clarification yeah and again for HR our job is just to to recommend to the board based on the three criteria that are in the teacher contracts that is the moving out of state if a if a spouse gets transferred uh personal illness or a promotion if a person gets a promotion so again we just from HR recommend and again later on I don't know exactly what where that is I think it's under General business we will have uh that just a general discussion around liquidated damages as well
108yeah I know we'll bring that we'll we'll speak more about liquidated damages in a little bit um anybody else have anything they would like to add on this I I just like that I know liquidated damages are a hot topic for everybody um I know a lot of places around our area do that and it's in their contract when they sign it to agree with uh I don't know I know everybody has like different situations when they have to leave and I don't know if that's what we need to look at um more than anything but do I agree so they need to be looked at but it is common practice I believe so if people want to leave for liquidated damages and then my other question was procedur like on mind it also said
109that this was 9.4 so I don't like which what did he get posted at outside mine 9.3 m nine mine says 9.3 right yeah I just spoke up earlier cuz I wasn't sure if I accidentally dragged it cuz you can you know you can drag them and move them around I didn't know if I touched the button accidentally that's why you did yeah yeah so it is 9.3 that was my bad yeah I think I accidentally dragged it it to the to one below and I don't know if now is the time to talk about it or wait to we have the conversation about liquidated damages to just bring up some I don't want to I don't think we should talk about it right now yeah I think we do have an agenda item later
110on where we can just discuss and the board can kind of give us some direction and and talk about these things yeah excuse me presid or vice president Kenya can you please um board members here and Sh do you want to go ahead and reread the motion to 9.4 oh he hasn't made a motion yet okay I or excuse me Zimmerman pulled 9.3 I know but it was posted as 9.3 yeah yeah Mya so do you want to keep it can you want to keep it as 9.3 or 9.4 yeah it's it's on our it's 9.3 on what we have in front of us it was 9.3 when we came into the meeting um yeah I I may have touched the button and dragged it that's why I kind of like said that I move
111it because CU on the computer you can accidentally move it down so I don't think is there a way to move it back um yeah I mean that way everyone can see that that way it all lines up we'll leave it as 9 .3 so if you refresh the screen I believe I apologize I didn't I was not meaning to Sticky Fingers I suppose yeah there it is yeah okay we are back 9.3 yes hey accidents happened go ahead uh I go ahead and make the motion to approve 9.3 with the change that all liquidated damages be waved for each employee do we have a second on that I second do we have a discussion okay I just have a question can I ask a question yeah ask I just wonder is it just for
112this one because we have applied in indifference so I just am wondering is that just for this agenda or how would I'm just wondering how that works because we have can askal it only work for this agenda right now yeah this is just this is just this item that's that's my only question I just want to yeah and I I um just a discussion you know what when I look at this and we've we've had this discussion multiple times so I don't want to keep bringing it up but you know we expect we know our our teachers and our staff are professionals um they're expected to act like professionals to the children to the families they they uh work with every day they are the professionals and so having a contract again with liquidated damages
113and we can discuss what those liquidated damages if we want to modify the criteria for that we can discuss that in a little bit um however I would caution when it comes to voting on this or I would caution on just waving them for this group when it hasn't been waved before and we don't know what will come up later so with that we do have a motion and we have a second so we'll go ahead and take the vote so uh board member Schmidt hi board member uh senon no board member Zimmerman I um and I'm also a no so um so let me let me jump in here president Kenyan so do you want to just advise the board on if the motion doesn't have a majority then it doesn't pass okay so
114what that means uh Mr Dangerfield is needs to make a motion for the uh other option so with that that that failed because it was 22 right so we would uh be looking for another motion does anybody have another motion uh motion to approve the personal action items I will second that it fails so we have a first and a second so let's take a vote board member Schmidt nay board member Sani iard members Zimmerman nay and I would also be an i which puts us again at a failed vote so doesn't pass this way so that would mean um they can't move forward with the with the um person action yeah well they no they could the personel action you can't do the damages everything so we can make a motion to approve everything
115but the liquid yes yeah or or the resignations pardon we could I'm going to make a motion so that I don't break open meeting law um I make a motion to approve personal action items with the exception of all resignations interesting would that work oh that's a motion dations you saying all res so she's making a motion to approve the entire personel action the personal action item with the exception of all resignations so we would not be approving those is what I believe correct me if I'm wrong will get approv no I'm not including any resignations as part of the personal action items that's what I'm saying those are separate things correct the resignations and liquid if I don't appr if I'm excluding the resignations from the personal action items then it does it not
116talking about the liquidated damages or the basically the resignations in general are not AC they're not approved right so we have a motion on the floor to approve the personal action item with the exception of all resignations do we have a second second do we have a [Music] discussion Dr Monroe would this be something um then we could readdress at a later date well I'm going to look over to Mr Dangerfield so yeah just bring it back to the next board meeting okay so those so this motion if it passed everything would pass except for those resignations which would then be rolled over to a next meeting next board meeting yes when when we'd have a f number five okay um all right so we're go ahead and take a vote if there's no other
117discussion okay board member go ahead no there there is quite so no it is serious cuz the affected date on some of these resignations are before the next board meeting so what happens to these people there's no way you can force people to stay here there's no way you can force people so whether you accept the resignations or not they just leave then we're just excuse me the public isn't allowed to speak right now then we um would just accept the resignation if you're going to continue to speak you're going to be asked to leave okay thank you um then we would we can approve the resignations and then if we end up changing liquid liquidated damage or something later then cor that is correct you can't keep people here I mean if they say
118there's no such thing as slavery in Arizona I asked want to put them in a worse position than they're in I I mean I I will agree with that I mean because I don't want want the district to come back and these people leave and then call it job abandonment like I don't want to put our teachers in that position that's what it would do but I also don't want to approve liquidated damages and so I feel like as a board member that's my right to vote that way of course and I would hope that the district would not inflict anything extra on the teachers because of a decision I made as a board member can we amend it to say that we won't make it job abandonment until it's figured out yeah I mean
119it's just a matter of the they would they would leave when their uh when their resignation is effective I just don't want them when they go to go for another job it says they abandon their job it can be handled in the next board meeting yeah I would that's not that's that wouldn't be my intention or my thought my mine would just be and I'm not HR but would be to roll it over to the next board meeting but yeah and you have an agenda item to discuss liquidated damages already so that can be handled there and then the next board meeting you'll deal with this but it's not going to stop the teachers from leaving and it doesn't mean abandonment when since they've asked for resignation approval okay okay I believe we have a
120a motion on the floor by Miss simmerman and Miss Schmidt I believe you were the second was that correct MH okay that's correct we will go ahead and take a vote at this time so uh board member Schmidt I board member C I board memb Zimmerman I I will also vote I so that shows that that uh motion will be approved for zero all right next agenda item we have will be 10.1 this is discussion consultation or excuse me discussion consideration to approve the vary Energy savings project in the amount of uh 10.6 million I would turn this over to young but he's not here so Dr Monroe we will yeah president uh vice president Kenyan I'm going to queue up danne here uh Mr Young had to leave suddenly um ver uh is an
121organization that came and presented to the board in I want to say October November when we were actually over at Liberty Elementary when I I think we had the the voting the polling going on here and so um we brought them back again tonight um uh to present uh and this option that's in front of the board uh and so I'm not going to steal your thunder this time Dane so too late yeah I know so I'll actually turn it over to you I was going to say something but go ahead and Dane vice president Kenyon members of the board today I'm here to introduce Randy falcan and Shandon ropy with ver G uh they're going to present on the $10.6 million Energy savings project and their presentation slightly modified from October uh Jim Gil
122with Gus Rosenfeld who is representing our district is also available if the board has any questions take it [Music] away Dr Monroe to see good to see you CDE um thank you for having us back in uh this is the same project that we spoke of before and we're going to go through it on what we have for what we would call a final project after getting all the data in as we discussed last time I'm looking at it so if you want to start the or I guess I can do it here huh arrows yes yeah all right so we're going to tell you a little bit about who we are so you know I know you guys had some information delivered to you before the board meeting so I'm sure you looked it
123over and ask questions but please ask questions as we go if you want to that's perfectly fine um we're going to go through what we did here at your District to look at everything uh the district assessment that was done here uh which is the audit of looking at everything and then the path forward so we are a homegrown Arizona company um we are actually in 38 States at this point in time uh but we started here and we have grown from this our corporate offices are here so uh this is an area that we understand very very well uh 99% of the work that we do in this state is K12 work so we're very experienced at looking at the facilities that you guys have and what your goals and needs are in them
124um for saving energy so we have uh achieved over 450 million in energy savings um we've done over 500 individual building projects we have three Arizona Offices here um most of our staff that we do is here we perform the majority of all our work here um in your particular case it would I believe it would be all of it um that we would do so um and 90 I guess it goes to the next one 95% of the work is done in house this is a list of school districts that we've done work with um we've done over 70 almost 80 energy performance contracts is what we're talking about here tonight plus we do direct projects with school district so a lot of times they'll call us and they just they need mechanical or
125they need electrical or Plumbing or piping or whatever the case may be um but we're very proud of the history that we have here we have a very good reputation with the schools and I'm sure if you guys have reached out to any of your peers um great idea and I would you know encourage you to do so but our feedback is always very very good we take a lot of pride in that so uh the vision and the in what we wanted to do here and the goals and the priorities we wanted to put in place uh for focal points on looking at your schools so Student Success you want to have the correct environment for your students safe safety and health building needs long-term partnership so when we do one of these projects
126we actually monitor it and work with your staff continuously over the term of the payback on the units so we're pretty uh entwined and going forward um we do operate underneath a statute so part of that is statute driven but the other part is that when you do these just want to make sure everybody is trained doing what they're supposed to and that we're really getting all we can out of each project we do um effective operation systems uh we worked a lot with Bob Young and his team on looking at everything going through everything on how they like to run the buildings and where they see deficiencies um Federal incentives can we find money for this project so you don't have to pay any money for it uh utilizing existing project budget uh utilizes
127your existing utility budget so that's what this is designed to do is reduce your utility costs and use that money for the project so that is by Statute um and we have to adhere to that statute zero impact as taxpayers so this is not like we go out and we ask for a bond and we say all right we're going to increase your property taxes so you pay for this that is not the case here uh per statute we actually have to guarantee what happens annually so that you have a net neutral project which means that we've reduced that budget area so that it can pay for this project so surveyed LED lighting HVAC control systems which is what runs your buildings for temperature sometimes lighting ventilation which is how much fresh air comes into
128a space uh facilities integration which is how you run each area of facilities building envelope which would be like you know window glazing insulation door seals things of that nature uh water conservation which is valves New China urinals things along those lines uh and solar covered parking so we surveyed all these things 62% of your district is non LED which um is actually good for the project because it's a very easy area to save money in uh because LED lighting is so much more efficient so that left a lot of room there for us you have 151 units in your District that are past or near their useful life um facilities doing a really good job of keeping them up it's not not uncommon we see this a lot in Arizona schools um it's not
129like you're endlessly funded so um it's good to have a good facilities team out there working on them uh we looked at demand control ventilations uh mostly I think in your case uh humidity you have humidity issues comeing when the monsoons come in so that creates some problems that need to be corrected um you have an outdated control system that runs your buildings uh your building envelope um has many areas that we can take advantage of we would consider low hanging fruit which means that that it saves money very quickly water usage uh 30 to 50% higher than normal that that's not uncommon either because the diaphragms that were used back in the day they stretch out they need to be replaced um so that's not uncommon to see um and then solar we looked
130at all your SES for solar and when you when I say SES you actually kind of mean meter solar attaches to a meter so we look at each one of your meters and what the load is on them and then we calculate for does it make economic sense for you actually to have solar producing energy for you at that meter um sometimes it does not which means it just it didn't pay for itself so how we how we fund the improvements as I discussed before your annual utility bill now is a little over a million dollars um your new bill after a project is going to be about 560 so uh the first year savings on it would be a little over $460,000 every year kind of attributes on how they're run and a different
131savings but um this is not taxpayer funded this is using your budget right now that money goes to utility companies all you're doing is Shifting it so that it's not going to utility companies and you're using it to make improvements the project that we have all the data is in on it you're looking at a project it's a little over 10, 800,000 uh showing the first year savings again you've add incentives that we can get so that we would be money coming in from federal sources or rebate sources uh to the project of over $970,000 um the projects if you look at the little Matrix below it shows the sites and then across the top it is all ECM so you have lighting hbac upgrades EMS which is the building Control Systems again water efficiency
132etc etc and all the xes show which locations are getting those improvements the reason that there isn't x's in all the boxes is just because it doesn't make economic sense in the places where there's not or things have already being improved at that site in that area and there's no reason to take the new improvements out and put new ones in that would be wasting money so benefits and impact enhanced environment for Student Success no impact to the taxpayers parking shade most of the I think all of them are all the units yeah all of them provide parking shade which is in our state pretty valuable usually because it gets pretty warm um effective operation systems uh meets the facility's needs and the long-term goals uh long-term partnership with us we will monitor this it's
133transparent so the district will be trained how to do this and see it as well um and then we're required obviously by Statute ARS 15-1131 uh that we keep track of the savings and then we do uh annual reconciliation reports uh in our case we actually do uh quarterly meetings with you guys and the Savings in the meter data is transparent so we we'll actually be doing it more often than that but it's required that we do at least once a year for a delivery of a report on what happened if we come up short in the savings then we are we have to write you a check so that's what the statute says zero change order project so this is not a regular construction project where I'm going to give you a price I'm
134going to come back and go oh gee I didn't know this we're going to have to add all this in there's going to be more these are zero ch change order so uh everything is covered in the project if I find something I didn't see when we were doing audits then that's my responsibility uh District fund improvements district is currently paying for the project now so you you're paying your utility bills now so you're you're paying for the project so because it's only a shift in budget and uh there are federal dollars again that are paying for a good portion of the project as well so next steps would be a board approval uh we would execute a guaranteed savings agreement um so we can send that stuff out so we're in statute uh then
135we will have a construction begins there'll be kickoff meetings and a schedule on everything construction on this will take uh probably total from complete complete around 14 months be my guess with everything some some things go faster than others as we move through them but that would be the overall project timeline questions and we we also uh we also have Jim Gil here who can speak uh on some of the financing options that danne can talk about one comment I wanted to just say before the board asks questions and Jim can come up to the mic and answer questions as well is you know these type of projects one of the things that gets me really excited is um and Randy and Jim can speak to this but um communities that have hard times passing
136bonds um sometimes these are the projects that are taken advantage of we know that there's a big struggle with capital funding in the state of Arizona the lawsuit continues we're going to have a ruling in March of this lawsuit that's seven or eight years old but trust me that will be appealed within 24 hours and so um these type of deals um uh as you saw the list I I guess your brag slide all the all the people you guys do business with a lot of districts that um have a propensity to not pass bonds or have voters support a lot of their initiatives this this is kind of low hanging fruit this allows us some Capital planning into the future to take care of our buildings um so I don't know if you want
137to touch on that a little bit Randy yeah I mean I would add this too so you know when we do these we can use a mun list to fund them which typically happens but there's many of them that we do that is a combination of some kind of capital fund you know federal dollars um Bond money schools do them for different reasons but really it when they pull them forward it's typically to help stretch their bond dollars or to get their facilities where they need to be so they're better for the occupants um and then they they pay these off future so it's just a matter of kind of doing it all and getting it done faster and and getting things with um but we've done business with many many school districts um and
138um yeah this this is all we do all right with that we will have uh ask for discussion or questions uh board member Schmidt I have none right at this moment thank you board member Sani I yes I have a couple uh first thanks for coming back out and uh talking to us so how long is the savings guaranteed for in this particular case it's 20 years so 20 years yeah all right so you say in the first year um the savings is going to be 464,000 right correct all right and then um one of the other questions was is this like a one-time deal project so if we are building more schools and they start going down is this like hey we used it now we can't use it again in the future or
139like how's that work how's the program question no we do we typically a lot of these schools on here you see different colors that are on there that represents multiple phases so we have a lot of schools we've done five or six phases with obviously when we go through and do audits now your equipment is all X age right now right but in a few years it's going to be a few years older so maybe some stuff that we would say hey we don't need to replace that now let's not spend that money now that stuff starts coming to the for also new technology and New Opportunities and things like that come to the Forefront so many times we do multiple phases over time some are quick some are further apart it just depends on
140what the situation is okay um and then you're saying the lifetime savings is be like $28.8 million correct so is that what is going to cost us to do this no no the the figure that I showed you on the slide the the 10.8 oh gotcha right there that is your total on there where it says total project size that is it so we would we would Finance out and that's kind of what we're talking about Jim can comment on it and Dame can comment on it to be able to pay that 10.8 with the idea that the savings would be 28 million yeah so that that is being carried by immuni lease in this particular case um and then we work together with the lender and we show them what the annual savings is
141per each year and then they design a lending program that basically lies right with that savings per year and then we guarantee it that way every year you know that the amount of that lease payment is guaranteed another piece of this is we don't use all the savings that we find because I actually don't want to write you a check I would rather say Hey you oversaved which is kind of what we gear these towards um so typically you see anywhere from 10 to 20% depending on school involvement of higher savings on those but they are structured to meet right with those so it's matched uh so to be blunt it sounds like a really good thing so like what's the catch yeah yeah there honestly is I mean these were designed a lot of
142people say that right oh it's too good to be true but it's really it's not I mean it would be too good to be true if the state just funded you and you paid cash for everything you didn't have to worry about it right um but but it's not this is just a project that it's a budget shift it's a way for you to go hey the other side of this coin with without us getting funded is we're paying way too much for utility costs and can we reduce that so that we can drive that money into our classrooms as well so there is no catch um that every almost every state I think actually every state has a statute similar to the one in Arizona for these types of projects um some have been
143doing it for a very long time Northeastern states have been doing this for forever uh Arizona came out with it in two 20091 yeah and then they did a revision in 2012 um we don't write these statutes everybody backing you guys writes these statutes so they're meant to be to your advantage they're meant to be no skin off your nose another way for you to improve your buildings thank you and Jim maybe you can step up to the mic and just add a comment too and Clyde I know you've worked with a lot of districts too maybe you could just just so the board makes informed decisions here yeah uh members of the board Jim Gil with gust Rosenfeld so by way of introduction introduction I am your bond counsil your election Council so I
144know it's a fairly new board but I've been representing Liberty L for 15 16 years in that capacity um what what's here before you tonight this Energy savings contract this lease financing I also do for many districts so the the the districts that Randy showed you I probably worked on three quarters of those around the state um so I have uh my primary representation is K12 districts doing again Bond work but also this kind of lease financing so the question about the what the catch yeah I I really have't identified one um my clients my school clients have been very happy with this structure uh primarily they do it with vary and primarily they do it with a handful of lenders uh that that are very active in this space in this case Bank of
145America has expressed an interest in doing this lease financing at a very attractive interest rate a tax exempt interest rate of approximately 4.2% so that that's all good um you'll Finance it out for 20 years and again as Randy mentioned a couple times it's all structured so that your savings are designed to match those lease payments so that you know the money you're already spending is going to go to pay this lease payment board members and um thank you so much I just want to uh you know say that I met with u Mr Balden and Mr Young um earlier this morning to make sure that I could wrap my head around it um because it did like almost sound too good to be true too and so I was trying to find uh you
146know what it exactly meant so I just kind of want to you know give a little bit more of how I would explain it so that the the public understands is that basically as I understand it the you know the board the district is taking out a loan and we're going to pay it to vary and they are going to do the upgrades in 14 months and so that then we take that Energy savings of you know around 500,000 and then we pay the lease so that we're we're taking the money that we already use for energy that we're only going to now have to pay half and now we're just paying for the improvements that happen all at once um and you know one of the things that we talked about was you know
147it doesn't include our new schools like so obviously we're going to build a new school now we're you know hopefully School N9 in 20 years who knows what the district will look like but that those are not included um but hopefully that we're installing these Energy savings in those schools so inevitably our utility payments will go up but the C the savings to pay for the lease payment will remain the same for 20 years and that the interest is included in the payment that's okay and it's a fixed rate up front and I did I did ask um Dane today and again I'm just trying to be transparent about what we talked about is that um you know if if for some reason in 20 years you know if there's a lower interest rate if
148we could refinance and you know that seemed to be an option and then the other thing I asked Bob about um to make sure that because installing new you know HVAC or whatever would we still be able to submit things to the um FSB you know when they're going out you know 15 years from now and he said yes that there is that partnership as well so I just wanted to make sure that that didn't you know mess us up by doing this so great questions great Insight so the buildings that were doing HVAC at are actually the ones that were Bond funded that the sfb kind of pooo you on right because they didn't build them so when we sat down and went through everything with Bob he was like hey these areas I
149can go sfb he did say that very action so that's really what we focused on perfect and he also said just in general that you know he's going to continue to because you know we're not going to be replacing 151 air conditioning units that he's going to continue to work with FSB to try to replace those that aren't part of the project so M you I think so okay uh looks like bring has more I did so you brought up a good reminded me something the 14 months construction so if we take the loan out are we paying interest during that 14 months or do we start paying once construction's done yeah as soon as the loan goes out you're paying interest on it but remember per statute I have to cover the cost of
150the loan so we've already taken that into account and everything that we're doing so I love low interest rates because that means I can put more stuff in schools in this particular case it's a good interest rate um so we're fair but great point on like if they drop you can refinance them because you can it's a good it's a good move um but yeah all that's taken into account on them can I add go ahead okay one more thing just for transparency sake the incentives the estimated incentives that would just be used to pay down the loan correct correct it's part of the financial picture thank you all all right another questions or comments uh I had a few written down here but they all got answered so I appreciate you thank you for
151the for for the presentation great presentation um and if there's nothing else then I guess we will go ahead and uh take a vote so can I ask for a motion motion to approve the V Energy savings project in the amount of 10.6 million and second second all right let's vote so board member Schmidt I board member cion I board member Zimmerman I and I will also be an i shows that I approves 40 thank you all right we will go ahead and move to uh 10.2 discussion and consideration to approve open enrollment annual capacity for school year 2526 Dr Monroe and vice president Kenyan members of the board this is an an annual approval that's B brought to the board this time of year um by Statute we need to post so parents understand
152where we're accepting open enrollment uh for next year based on current numbers that that roll up um and uh what I want to tell the board is a few things that you're aware of with these uh with with these uh with this recommendation is number one um we look at special education open enrollment very carefully on a case-by Case basis because of our program capacity and so uh we don't have capacity to accept open enrollment outside of the district meaning a student who uh lives outside of the district applying to one of our schools we look at those uh numbers very carefully we post this um what's attached there so parents can see that and then we follow policy is people apply for open enrollment for next year when space becomes available and there's communication
153made to those parents and so this this vote what's put in front of the board tonight is uh meeting the statute that we would be able to post as we open up our enrollment because kindergarten registration enrollment will be just right around the corner here next month and so uh Administration would recommend the board to approve the Open Enrollment capacity with no annual capacity for special education open enrollment students and I can do my best to answer questions I know I I talked to a few of the board members today Mrs Zimmerman um this is an ed services thing that I put my name on so I can do my best to answer those questions but uh this is a yearly renewal and what you see there is what will be transparently posted on the
154web page all right let's start with uh discussion questions uh let's start down at the end Miss Schmidt do you have anything no okay Mr s hi I'm I do miss Zimmerman surprise um okay so uh my concern is we are saying that these classrooms um could we um scroll down sorry thank you um these classrooms for next year are closed so my concern is um saying that we're Clos for kindergarten when we don't know what the enrollment for kindergarten is going to be and my hope would be that if we have enough students that we would open a section because we always talk about wanting students in the district so I hate to close kindergarten open enrollment um without knowing now I just wonder can we um have a time frame because I you
155know I don't want to get in the situation where we were with freedom this year where their Kinder is busting at the seams um and I don't want to put you know teachers or kids in that position again but I also want us to have the freedom to welcome new students to our district so that's my concern is to closing basically any kindergarten classrooms yet when we we haven't even had Kinder Roundup and things like that so yeah it's I think member Zimmerman it's a great point you and I discussed this earlier I think if the board was to make a motion I think you could adjust the wording to remove Kinder and have it be something we watch really closely uh I I do agree we basically uh base our kindergarten numbers on current
156numbers so it's a little bit of a crapshoot because we it's not really predictive whereas we know more or less how many fifth graders from the fourth grade um you know there's a lot of young families and so uh if the board so chooses a motion could be made where you could just uh adjust the wording and remove Kinder kindergarten off there and we could do that move forward good yeah okay just make it sure um I don't have any other questions right now at this moment so with that we'll go ahead and take a motion uh I make a motion to approve the Open Enrollment capacity for school year 2526 minus any kindergarten classrooms is there a second a second we'll go ahead and take our vote board member Schmidt I board member Sani
157hi board member Zimmerman I and I'm also an i let's so that shows that that motion passes 4 Z we'll move to item 10.3 discussion consideration to approve employee work calendars for school year 2526 Dr Mon uh mohorn thank you vice president Kenyan board members you might not have them printed out but before you are 11 different uh work calendars um for the 26 uh school year and I'm ready if you have any questions about anything I do want to as I put in the board update um especially the Friday working calendar that's the uh not the most important one but one of the most important ones that Dr SLO uh sent that out to all of the teachers and just did to survey which one there were two different options which one do you
158prefer and the one that had technically the most votes um was the one that was chosen after that was chosen that was sent out to the tag uh group the teacher Advisory Group for feedback and it was sent out to all administrators for feedback if there was anything glaring is for feedback and there was no feedback received um on that thank you any questions go ahead okay um so uh could we just pull up the certified calendar just so that uh we're talking everybody sees what we're talking about so when I looked at this um my concern is there are no uh work Fridays in April and my my concern really is for administrators um in that as they are you know doing testing um you know preparing their teachers to test like and you
159know I we went a little bit further and and realized that Good Friday is the third so that you know wouldn't be appropriate but if you look at the calendar it's you know they're with their staff March 27th which you know they could train for testing that you know it's later in March for sure but then they're not with their staff all the way till the last day of school and I just wonder if that creates some logistical problems I realized that the teachers may not have accounted for that but I'm just concerned about our administrators not having the ability to be with their staff and um you know I did look at the other option that was in the board update um where it just moved one of the two in February to one
160in April um so you know it's just it that would just be my concern here um yeah and I don't know if administrators want to say anything I know it's really hard to put them on the spot but I did send it all to all of them as well yeah and ask for any feedback any concerns you know before it was um put on the agenda to send to you all as well just to you know for for reasons just as that yeah I didn't get any because I you know we want to hear that before it's brought to you like hey did you think about those types of things and didn't get anything so I definitely hear what you're saying okay any other questions comments okay just uh just to clarify typically when we're
161looking at the new calendars for the next school year um we double check with Buckeye and the high schools and try to as as closely as we can of course it can't be no exact yeah and remember vice president Kenyan that these are work calendars so it's not necessarily the school calendar but it's when different positions when they work and so the top typically we do look at those other districts and make sure there's some Market comparison yep okay very good well thank you for sending out the uh the teacher survey and you know with the tag team and all that because that means a lot especially when the teachers have input on um what they're going to be working next next year so with that we will go ahead uh and take a motion
162motion to approve employee work calendars for school year 2025 2026 all right do I have a second second I second oh sorry all right Miss Schmidt had the second first I think um we'll go ahead and take our vote uh board member Schmidt I board member Shion I board member Zimmerman I and I will also be an I so shows that approved 40 we'll move to item 10.4 discussion consideration of the updated board board superintendent operating and communication protocol Dr Monroe vice president Kenyan members of the board before you is an updated um protocol for how the superintendent the board team operate and communicate uh uh together uh this is not policy this was formed in July of 2023 um a facilitator came in and we talked about how does the board and the uh
163superintendent want to be able to communicate and work together and so there's a lot of practicality to the document it's been touched and revised maybe two or three times the idea is that the board this is the board's document and the ideas that the board signs off on it and and you know we hold each other accountable to this and we strive to work in this direction so you'll notice in this document there's a few areas where um we brought this I I want to say it was November um a few months back and we brought it to the Past board for them to offer some input Vice President Kenny you had some member Bixler did I think president Parks may have and so the things that are italicized was an attempt to clarify or
164or make it a little more clear based on some of the input that was given however with that being said this is the board's document with the superintendent so um it's here for your review and your approval tonight if the board found things that they wanted to change or weren't suitable we could always take it back but this would be something that again the board would informally sign off on basically saying that we all agree to work this way and that uh and that we post it so um so that that's what's before you now any questions all right board member zimman okay um so you know I'm going to pose the same question that I did uh about something else about the last meeting is that I'd really love to have a discussion um
165about different things on this but if that is not what this board wants to do then I will just list my concerns so just you want me to just list them you you can we can y this is the time we can go over that okay all right so on the second bullet um it says Communications between staff and the board are encouraged so I think um you know we I thought we've been very specific that we're really not communicating necessarily with staff that we're communicating with the superintendent um so um if that's the case I think I'm not sure if that word is Staff I'm I'm not sure what that's supposed to mean I think that leaves things up to interpretation there do you think some moreal lines of like District staff well but
166even like I've asked the question like you know if I want a Kad in sta like I could email Dr slope but the way that it's been explained to me is that I should only email Dr Monroe and so then he should email Dr SLO so if if that is the procedure then I just not sure sure that this is worded the way that we're operating y board members on that point um and I was involved in pretty much a lot putting this in together when this first started and I was very grateful we have something like this I think for that bullet point it was more it was more for the encouragement of staff to feel okay to approach a board member that's kind of the direction we were looking at that and correct
167me if from wrong Dr moroe but in the past there were there had been um staff members that were basically chastised for even speaking to a board member and so I think that's the direction we were looking at at that bullet point is basically saying that it's encouraged like if if a if a staff member has an issue and they don't feel like they're getting the results that they should at whatever level's above them then they can come talk to us and that was kind of the encouragement because we don't just represent you know the the stakeholders out in the community the the kids the staff but we all well we definitely do represent the staff as well right we we work for them um uh so that's I think where this bullet point was
168coming to if you can think of a different way we can word it maybe yeah I just I'm just not sure it should be connected I think it maybe needs to be explained because then it says however board requests that will likely require considerable time or have political implication should be directed to the board president superintendent so the way that I read that is like I'm asking something of a staff member um based on what's written underneath of it so I I understand the intent in which you wrote it but the way it's connected I guess is it's not in my opinion it's not clear um I I agree because I think this whole document is how superintendent and the board are supposed to interact with other people not how they're supposed to interact with
169us so I I understand what you're saying I agree with you so Dr Monroe would that be something we can break into two bullet points and possibly have a little more clarification there yeah I mean certainly and again we can go through other concerns that member Zimmerman has or others and and again this is our document so there's no there's no rush if it's not done tonight we want to get it right we want to have some clarity and if these things are ambiguous or big this is the opportunity to make sure it's clear so um I'll make a note there and again we we'll take our best stab at it kind of hearing your discussion and bring it back but I mean you can continue with your feedback if again it we will do
170what the what the board wants we just want to have Clarity in our relationship right um okay so then I'm just counting bullets so people can follow one two so seventh bullet the board will address Its Behavior by a yearly evaluation and by addressing itself to any individual problems such as poor meeting attendance leaks of confidential information um is is the intent that this is only handled at a yearly self-evaluation is that the idea of that well I think the and I'm not sure if the board previous to me did a yearly self- evaluation but I know it's kind of been recommended in policy but at a minimum I think it's once a year I think it's not to say it can't be addressed memb Zimmerman at a different time but I know that there's
171a formal time and Mrs castanos mentioned it and we'll probably do it in about 6 months where we kind of just evaluate ourselves as a board and how we're doing so I guess we could clarify the wording to say at a minimum of once a year but it's not to say it can't be brought up or made as an agenda item or something like that okay but I think you know formally as a superintendent at a minimum I think it's great where we have a formal opportunity every year to say hey how are we doing as a board let's rank it you know let's rate it um so but I I think that that doesn't prohibit us from making an agenda item or talking at other times about it okay um and then two agenda
172or agenda two bullet points down so um this is talking about um it's talking about no surprises um which I understand but at the end it says um that we agree to ask the board president or the superintendent to place an item on the agenda instead of bringing it up unexpectedly at a meeting but then on the second page it says says when requesting a future I item that we should request it at the meeting so I feel like those are in conflict and I personally for transparency purposes believe that we should be requesting agenda items in the public um and not in an email because then the only person that's seeing that is the board president um so that's my personal opinion but I I feel like these two stat stat ments um it's
173at the bottom of the second page are in Conflict yeah that's a that's a good catch I appreciate that that catch yeah we can certainly clarify that so it's not contradicting each other yeah the clarification there you know is that that first bullet point you were talking about um is not surprise you know uh we ask sorry I'm going to read it we agree to ask the board president or the superintendent to place an item on the agenda instead of bringing it up unexpectedly at the at the meeting so maybe that needs to be at the meeting prior to that specific um agenda item because we do this every meeting right we at the end of the meeting we do ask what agenda topics would you guys like to discuss so that has been happening
174in the meetings um and so I think that just clarifying basically throughout the meeting we just don't say oh yeah we want want to talk about that later oh yeah we want to talk without the order cuz obviously this is all ran in order so we do need to bring it up at the meeting at the right spot yeah I just the way that I read the bullet point on the first page is that we're emailing the request and I just think it should be done in public yeah I would I would think and I could see where you would think that it doesn't see say email but I I agree with what you said but we could almost scratch that sentence and just go with go with the one on the second page I
175was going to say just that first bull you and just and while we're talking about requesting agenda items one of the things that I would like to see is like a Google doc where we can see the agenda items that have been requested by um the different board members and when they're going to appear on the meeting so that we're Miss simman we got to make sure we stay on topic okay we could write it down we can talk about that when we get to that point thank you um all right what else do you have okay on the second page um at the first bullet point um it says we have agreed to avoid words and actions that create a negative impression on an individual the board or the district I personally think that's
176very subjective um and I think what I consider to create a negative impression may not be what somebody else create seems to create a negative impression and I just think um I want to make sure that we're not um not saying things or not being transparent just because we don't want to create a negative impression and again to whose definition is a negative impression do you have some wording recommendation on that that you would think I think you could create something along the lines and I'm not sure if I saw it in here but about you know just um once an item passes you know that you support the consensus um but the work in which you come to the consensus and what you bring forward you know I think as a board member you
177have a right to bring forward and and to you know have your opinion whether that somebody believes creates a negative impression or not okay I I I'm pretty sure that that is in there I was just scanning to see if I could find it um okay Point understood um and then the next two bullet points is talking about you know long meetings um you know kind of almost it feels like it's saying avoid discussion and it doesn't say that but it's that's the uh tone that I personally take from that and I think it's really important that what I understand as a board member is that you know we come in with information but we are given information in the board meeting and we as a board should have a discussion and come to a
178consensus and so I just want to be careful that we are not um you know it says board meetings are for decision-making action votes not endless discussion um and you know agree to move the question when the discussion is repetitive I just want to make sure that we're encouraging discussion I think it's important um and it's I think it's really important for us to listen to the other board members perspectives and so if idea is always just like well we got to vote like that's just how I read this um so M on that one I'll just I'll just say um it's here because of past issues I don't think we've ever discouraged um discussion if it's wanted um if I think this has been a pretty transparent board and it's been a very Lively
179board at times um but I think the intent on this at the beginning of that that bullet is to be efficient and effective and so that was the the meaning behind this is just in the past there's been problems where somebody has like a number of pages that they want to read on every item and they want it's just almost like Grand standing so if there's a lively discussion that's to be expected and hopeful you know that that happens because exactly like you said if we can come to a consensus on something that's because of that discussion that's what we're here for and we that's why we're here um but we don't want it just to be over and over and over because at some point the board president does have to or whoever is
180running the meeting does have to say okay it's time to move on because that has been an issue in the past and I that's why it made it into this um document um so I I don't necessarily feel that this is pushing us not to have discussion but just making sure that we're all aware of of what could potentially just drag out a meeting um I don't know if there's could I just add that you could have and there is a wave where an individual board member if it's dragging out they would just say call for the question and then if they get a second on that call for the question there would be a vote to dis to discontinue discussion and have the vote on that particular matter so that would just be a
181procedural way you can deal with the same issue right and so this this just being our our document going back and forth between the superintendent and within the board just kind of that is what we're kind of stating is that if it just continues we can just say move the question or call for the question and I don't know if the the correct term probably is call the question correct right that's the correct term in here we have move the question either one would work yeah and we can and I can play with the wording a little bit because I don't I don't want it to have the feel of we're discouraging discussion so let me just play with the words a little bit so we yeah it's not like we're saying let's not discuss
182let's just get this meeting over with so we don't want to have that but I that's a nice tool as well if someone does if there is a board member that is guilty of doing that that's always in there under Robert's Rule of Rules of Order okay okay um and then the next will appoint the superintendent will ensure that supporting information required for informed decision- making is provided to the board at least 3 days prior to the meeting I I think that the I'm trying to be cautious um but I think the agenda needs to be available earlier and I don't know if that's part of the operating procedure so that because of where the because of where the board meeting currently falls on a Monday and you know it's before a weekend we're I
183feel like I'm scrambling you know and you're scrambling to try to get all the answers and you know yeah I think that can we can pick that up here in in a few minutes when we get to that agenda item but I kind of know what you're you're leaning on okay and again it's a I I want to make sure you guys get the you guys are very busy you get the information in a timely manner and sometimes I'm emailing answers at 2 o'clock you know before the board meeting two hours before so um but yeah I think we can pick that up here in just a few minutes talk about that anym oh okay so I'm on page four now um I just I just want to highlight um something under Personnel it just
184says that the school board establishes the criteria and so I just wanted to point that out and then on the um the second page or sorry page five um so this is now the communication standards um so uh the superintendent will communicate with the governing boards as quickly as possible within a 24-hour period um you know the question is you know uh because of where the board meeting Falls does that include weekends you know um it's just you know I just think it's something you know we'll talk about later so I'm going to leave that for now um and then bport one two three four five sorry I should have not numbered them um the district maintains a communication team te um what does that mean a communication team that's led by the director of
185communications is so Mr dner has kind of a crisis communication team that he has of uh Bob Young Dr mohorn that he meets with every couple weeks every month as kind of a a crisis team if if we were ever had media inquiries or anything like that that he had to work with that team okay um second to last bullet um where it's says that the governing board president and the superintendent meet meet each uh prior to each board meeting to establish the meeting agenda and weekly to discuss school district issues to be addressed so um my concern here is is that you know no one board member has more power than the other and so if you're discussing District issues that need to be addressed with the board President should there be like a
186summary that's sent to the other board members about what um things were discussed um I just want to make sure that we're all getting the same information I guess as I agree and maybe there's some clarifying language there that has to do with like agenda issues or agenda request issues that can go on um uh so we could clarify that language so if a board member asks for an agenda you know we can talk to the board president when is feasible for us to bring that forward to a board to a board meeting so maybe that's the clarifying language that we have there okay um okay on the last page board member ethics um the fourth bullet point says communicate to other board members and the superintendent expressions of public reaction to board policy and
187school programs is that in accordance with agenda items I'm just how does that occur specifically to other board members how are we communicating to other board members without breaking open meeting law expressions of public reaction to board policies yeah we we're we'll work on that language I this was some do Chef language that I Ed so but we'll work on it and cl make sure that it has some clarity was was this if I could did this have I mean is this what we would consider a weekly update I I I don't I'm not sure I I don't think so but what member Zimmerman is saying is like with regards to the open meeting La board members communicating with each other um we certainly don't we want to be careful of that right we want
188to be careful that we're not promoting something that's in violation of an open meeting law so I'm just trying to wrap my head around how it's read right now my question about is if it's already a board policy or school programs we already voted on it right so it's no no longer an agenda item but it possibly could be depending on what it is if we bring it back up well and again if this just has to be straight up removed we could do it if if we're not sure the intent of the sentence so let me take that back and give it a try and see that way there's no question okay um under number six uh bullet point it says support the employment of persons best qualified to serve as school staff members
189and insist on regular and impartial evaluation of all Personnel I'd love to see the word um also put kids first in that statement and uh okay sorry I didn't know if you were gonna no that's okay I just I was just cons I mean it sounds good but how do you do that support the employment of person's best qualified to service School staff members and insist on a regular and and partial evaluation of all personnel and put first I mean just yeah I'm just trying to think of how that would look in there but maybe Dr Monroe you can kind of look at that and see I got it do a little word smithing and then um I just want to point out number eight uh in light of recent things to take no private
190action that will compromise the board Administration and respect the confidentiality of information that is privileged under law that's all I have for this thank you all right does anybody else have anything they would like to add discuss talk about in regards to this document not hearing anything let's go ahead and take a motion uh or would we like to just say table work on this and bring it back sure yeah we can we can do that right they can just give me direction to bring that back do we need to make a motion though to table it because it's it it's an action item okay I make a motion to uh table 10.4 do I have a second second all right let's vote uh board member Schmidt I board member Shion I board member Zimmerman
191I and I'm also an I so that shows that approves for zero moving to 10.5 discussion consideration to approve IGA for the use of Tyler technology School Erp um Erp Pro this is for Dane Balden vice president Kenyan members of the board uh this is an intergovernmental agreement between Maricopa County Tyler Technologies and LD for the usage of our accounting software which is school Erp Pro formerly known as Visions uh this IG is good for 5 years and we have to renew until 2029 it's my recommendation that the board approve the IGA all right any uh discussion no discussion let's go ahead and take a motion I motion to approve the IGA for the use of Tyler technology School Erp Pro I have a second second oh you said second no no I said do
192I have a second second all right let's go ahead and vote uh board member Schmidt I board member serenon I board member Zimmerman I I'm also an I so that shows that it pass is for zero all right 10 points 6 discussion consideration to approve governing board meeting schedule for our school year 2526 um before I pass this over to miss camarada and Dr Monroe um I'm going to ask the board if we can just do a discussion on this as one board member is not present and I I have a few things I would like to say and I believe other board members do as well in regards to this so we might not want to pass it as is but let's go ahead and okay pass it over to miss camarada thank you
193vice president Kenyan fellow Bo board members and Dr Monroe um right before you you have a hard copy a sample hard copy of the potential 2526 school year governing board calendar for Monday evenings at this point um each year it's brought to the board for discussion for future governing board member meetings that will start in the new fiscal year of July and then just a couple of points um while you're looking at it um that our neighboring School dist districts you know they have their meetings on Monday and or the second Monday of the month um both both Buckeye L and Buckeye Union uh they have their monthly governing board meetings on Monday um I thought this would be a good opportunity to bring this um to you today as we have our new board
194members that are also present um just this is only for a discussion although the agenda marked is it's marked action um and that was an error we had our internet down so must have not taken the change so um how however it's up to the board discretion and Dr Monroe I didn't know if you wanted to add anything to that yeah yeah I'll just add a few things members of the board vice president Parks I think as a new board this is the time we talk you know what you guys are all very busy you have a lot of different commitments uh does Monday work we've heard Tuesday brought up um you know uh president Parks isn't here and so this is why this is a good discussion but we're looking for some direction from
195the board as far as what works for all of you in your busy lives um as far as you know when when board meetings occur we heard earlier some concerns about turning around information on a Monday which you know is a real thing I I will say that the thing the only thing that I feel strongly about as a superintendent that I would recommend is I do think it's very realistic that we could go to a board meeting once a month um the reason I say that is I've been in past districts where we went from two to one a month and we were just as effective and just as efficient and then we weren't racing towards the end as was mentioned earlier to get the board the information um it's it's hard to have
196our staff finish a board meeting tonight and then start tomorrow on the next board meeting when it's two weeks out however when it's a month out you're able to have some focus and really be accurate so um we're I'm just looking uh vice president Kenyan for the board to discuss what night is good um we can take it back and play with some calendars and some schedules you know with Mrs camarada to bring it back in February we don't have President parks's voice but um but again we're we work for the board and we um uh we'll kind of do what what you guys want so was just looking for you guys to maybe have a discussion on what you'd like to do as your first meeting as a board as a new board together
197well let's start that discussion um I hope everybody's had a chance to kind of look at this calendar and and this this was just sorry to interrupt U vice president this was just a stab at many kind of uh looking at once a month on a Monday you know but but again we're open to other nights if that's what works better with the board and their schedule we don't want to make a hardship we just know past at least the short time I've been here the two years it's been Monday night I don't know how long it's been Monday night but long time at least six years yeah there you go at least six years so so why don't we go ahead and open this up for discussion um we can start with you mmid
198if you have anything you'd like to State add I'll go ahead and um so I have no problem with it being like on a Monday or whatever my my biggest issue is kind of brought up is with us not having school or work on Friday when we get it Thursday evening I don't think that's enough time for us to react to a lot of the information you mean on a Monday when we get the agenda yes yeah yeah yeah so I when the board meeting is on a Monday is what you're correct okay yeah so I don't have a big issue with the day of the week we're doing it my issue is we're not getting enough time to actually digest send like good questions out and give time for the staff to give us
199good answers okay understood how however a Tuesday could help with that right cuz it's an extra extra I do like the first half of the week though be honest mman go ahead okay um I would be a proponent of Tuesday uh for a couple reasons uh the biggest one being the getting of the information um I personally cannot get through an entire agenda in one night even if you gave it to me on Thursday and if you answered questions on Friday like I just physically it's you know it's a long agenda I think you can see I have a lot of questions um and that's okay um and then you know to be honest to get the answers at 2:30 before a board meeting it's just not enough time and then if I have a
200follow-up question we're like chasing it um the other thing that I think is that we have sports now on Monday nights um or Monday afternoons and I think that is you know somewhat unfair to our principals to our parents who want to be involved um my concern would be uh pushing it to a Wednesday or a Thursday is I think schools have events um you know a lot of schools don't want to do events on Thursdays cuz that's considered the Friday so they have them on Wednesday so I think that could really hurt our staff um so I would be a big propon proponent of Tuesday um the only thing that I want to say about one meeting a month is that I think inevitably they're going to be longer right because we have to
201cover what we've been covering in in two meetings and so I I understand what you're saying um so I just you know when we go back to those protocols and making sure we're efficient I just want to make sure that again we're encouraging the discussion and we're still having those things we're bringing the agenda items forward you know I hate for be like well we couldn't get to your agenda item because it was already too long when we are only going to have one meeting a month so I just want to make sure that we're considering those things the only other concern I have is that typically you know with the personal action items if we only have one meeting a month I don't want to limit us to having like a teacher start to
202you know support students if we're having to wait a whole month to approve that person and go ahead I agree that was a concern too but in my mind we would have if we needed we'd have like an emergency meeting with like one topic we'd come in look at the Personnel action and then boom yes which was which had been done in the past yeah do you want to do you want to speak to that a little bit Dr mohorn because we we kind of have those instances now or at the beginning a school and listen just because you have a we can always call a meeting anytime you know you can always call a meeting but do you want to speak to that a little bit Dr mohorn just for some clarity on the
203calendar we're we're staying on the board item Vice s and Kenyon we're staying here yeah I think we are yeah and I I'm not remember I don't remember exactly when that CH maybe two months ago well just just kind of describe how uh we res how we deal with that if someone was to be hired that we're not waiting 3 weeks for them to be in front of kids you know right now now um we actually do let we have changed maybe 8 weeks ago and we have let people start before um it's pending board approval because actually they have had all their background check they have had everything done it has just been board approval so they know they start pending board approval so we have not waited now for board approval because they
204have every single thing done so they can be in front of kids they have every clearance they have their VP card they have their background check they have everything so when they now we don't wait for official board approval so they know that you are approved pending board approval so if you start today or if you've started today um and you're get board approval tonight you can be in the classroom today because you have all your paperwork done all your background checked all the everything has been done except your official check for board approval that so we have done that so we don't have to wait because before we were having meetings like every two days wait can we get this teacher on can we get this teacher on especially like in July right with
205new teacher orientation that was killing us when we were hiring and then two days later we were hiring and then we were hiring you know trying to get teachers on but we always make sure we have every single piece of paperwork done all the fingerprints all the background checks every single thing is is completed there's not one single thing that's not completed and I would I am okay with that I you know I would defer to Mr Kenyan and Mr Parks because that was something in the past that I believe that you guys weren't comfortable with um in past administration that you really wanted it to come board approved first so you know I my understanding it was President Todd that was the one that wasn't comfortable with that that was my understanding this is
206a yeah this is a practice we currently do and is pretty because yeah it really handcuffs HR departments and principles and it do and you know I'm just going to use you know my daughter as an example to get a paa like you know they're like yep we're waiting for the board meeting that's what we don't want but every clearance every paperwork every background checked everything is everything is clear it's just that final board approved that is the only thing so there's no step that we skip I would just ask maybe that you know uh administrators and above would come to board approval before the start date oh absolutely oh AB oh 100% yes we listen we always try to do that and usually it's extenda circumstances just like just like you said 100% yes
207so those are my thoughts all right thank you uh any other thoughts all right and and I do love that how we do that um I wasn't I I never had any issue with that and uh I'm glad we can get kids in front of uh teachers in front of kids right away um and as was discussed we can pull an emergency meeting anytime so even if we set the calendar tonight which we're not going to we're just discussing but um we can always add another meeting whenever we need it so so let me ask you vice vice president Kenyan are you again just want to have the board give me some direction you know are you wanting me to bring back a Tuesday calendar are you wanting me to bring back a m you
208want me to bring back both kind of based on what we've talked about yeah we haven't heard uh uh president Parks you know what his take on this yet is so I'm okay with Tuesday actually I had a concern with the first Monday of the month um that was that was pushing into some other things that I had going on and and I always made this a priority but if we can move that that's great um list sounding like Tuesday works for everybody here I would like to see a tu possibility and then we'll work on yeah we'll work on kind of refining the Monday one uh the uh the Monday one but we'll also work on a on a Tuesday and then would we be able to start trying out the once a month
209next month well we certainly well we can bring that back yeah we certainly can um we have our next meeting is the beginning of February but we can bring back the February in March one and um we can account for that if that's the case the board wants to do certainly okay we have once I believe it's a board meeting about once a month and I think we have just a couple that couple months that maybe have two months so we could we could look at that and if they start getting one in January in the approved meeting schedule for I think oh sorry sorry I apologize um when I looked at the meeting schedule for this year there was another one for January so I do think that we probably need to bring this
210back okay okay yeah we'll definitely bring it back yep now we need to table it yeah we'll go ahead and table it do we do we C it was just a discussion is does a motion to be posted with an action gotcha that's right so do I have a motion to or a motion I'll just leave it at that uh I make a motion to table item 10.6 and then second second with that we'll vote so board member Schmidt I board member cenen I board member Zimmer I I'm also an I so that shows that that passes 4 Z to table to be brought back let's move to item 10.7 this is discussion consideration of teacher liquidation damages Severance fees Dr mohorn uh vice president no vice president Kenyan and board members um this is
211a conversation that I believe uh vice president Kenyan new asked to be placed on the agend agenda maybe a few months ago uh just to have a maybe I got it wrong um sorry if I did a few months ago go and so we are having the discussion um just right now just to have a conversation about this and I believe I put in the board update just um just some language about this one of the thing we don't have in policy liquidated damages but we do have in the teacher contract which you as the board maybe not this particular board approved every year you approve the teacher contract language every year it's brought before the board um and approved by you as the board um so just some some research most um districts do
212have not every single one but do have some type of liquidated damages what I found is although it ranges the average amount is that 2,000 um $500 I have not found a district that was more than that um so that $2,500 is pretty standard in just some of the districts of course this is not oh I keep going in and out this is not all inclusive um were daart Littleton LaVine nberg Wickenberg Union Elementary Buckeye Elementary and Buckeye Union High School Pendergast tollisen both Elementary in um Union and Fowler and that was just some of the med the immediate ones um that are in my HR Group that I communicate with um very often so those are the ones that do um and just just some points that I just want to um just want
213to uh point out that in this market this is very common just so that we don't have teachers that do abandon their contract and therefore you know abandoned kids we do know that there are situations that's why the contract does have those three cases when someone gets a promotion when someone is ill or when someone's spouse gets transferred um out of state because we know that there are situations that happen and so this is by far not meant to be um something that is a oh the word it's meant to be a deter not a punitive not you know I can't believe you did this but we do you know there is a contract is supposed to go both ways and so it's just meant to be you know a deterrent and so that's just
214some of the information but I I do want to leave it open for a discussion for you as the board of course as well because this is you know discussion and I just wanted to bring information back to you all as well that I had contracts president par vice president Parks members of the board contracts teacher contracts will be coming to the board in the next couple of months and that's where this language is contained is this liquidation fee um uh language and so as as you can see it's pretty standard practice the application of it it varies District to District whether it comes to the board whether it stays with HR or is housed with a different person um I think Common Sense Reigns in a lot of this um I I like things
215to be focused on kids but understanding that sometimes there's situations where they should be waved and they might not fit neatly into all three of those categories uh I would hate to set a precedent where the board becomes the the group to appeal to um I don't think that's the board's role but again we work for the board we'll we'll do what the board would want and so um again we bring this to you just for conversation tonight and maybe even a direction to nudge moving forward so thank you Dr Mor Dr Mahorn um I did bring this as that this be an agenda item a couple months ago in regards to uh somebody who because of the three criteria they were labeled as liquid damages apply however when we found out the circumstances um
216the board thought at that time that that that one individual it didn't need to be didn't need to apply because they didn't abandon their job um and so I I like that direction um but I'm going to go ahead and we'll open this up for the board to discuss and then I'll I'll see what's at the end so um Miss Schmidt do you have anything to add I have a question um and sorry if I should know this but this is a newly added uh to the contracts for this school year correct year it started last year okay um so do we have numbers on how many people resigned prior and then post and is this actually stopping people from resigning their positions or is it just becoming punitive because they're going to resign excuse
217me and they they just then get charged for resigning I wasn't here post I can tell you this year a proximately it is about 5050 liquidated damages waved and liquidated damages applied I don't I don't think it's stopped people I think again that word is deterrent just to think only because and it's and again that's not it's punitive it's just thinking about the kids because in some cases we have classrooms that it's like who are we going to to find like who how are we going to find cover cage first of all find a body to go in there and then secondly are we can we find a qualified person we don't just want a body to me it's not good enough to just find a body to go into a classroom yeah I understand
218I guess that that's kind of the point I'm trying to get at is it working as a deterrent if we have more people resigning with the liquidated damages in the contract than we did prior then it's not working as a deterrent we have to think beyond that then that that's my question that's what I'm getting at thank you board member cator San that was a great question um one of the other questions I had was did we set this up to so teachers wouldn't like accept a job here as a placeholder and then find a job better somewhere else was that then again I'm just not understanding your question so like say I'm job hunting and I I really want to go to Lichfield but I'm like oh Liberty has an opening so I'm going
219to go with Liberty but I'm going to leave as soon as that L comes open was that like a concern I don't think so I don't so I wasn't here we did this I'm trying to figure out why we first implemented this like I don't think that's a I don't think that's what's happening not not to my knowledge I think I think the idea behind it was trying to deter people from ending their contract early from walking out on kids right now has that been the intended result we we we'll have to see and look at that I do know um uh I was surprised when I got hired in this District that there wasn't any type of if someone broke their contract and were let out there wasn't anything like it it made the
220in my view the contract null and void right why even have the contract maybe we should have a work agreement and um but we would have to evaluate you know to um you know board member Schmidt's question are we getting out of it what what we want um what's the need for that but then for me it raises a bigger question what does the contract mean you know I mean really why would we even have that cuz it is a two-party thing you know we're agreeing to employ you for a year and you're agreeing to stay for a year and if you have extenuating circumstances we'll consider those you know it's tough you're trying to be tight and loose at the same time right I mean it's just a it's just a challenge so I
221I don't I think it came as um you know a deterrent let's deter try to deter people from leaving stay to the end don't give up on kids you signed a contract you gave us your word you know and and stick around but life happens you know life happens and that's the hard thing how we try to be understanding with people yeah it's it's a tough one um because I see both sides of it if you it's like if somebody wants to leave why do we want to stay here but at the same time it is a contract like we you say we're gonna that you continue your employment we expect you to stay also so yeah see both sides of it yeah absolutely Miss IM um so I I did do the research um
222and and this is pulled exactly from um uh personel action items in bardocks um we had 18 teachers resign this year um up in until now so I'm counting August so I'm I'm not counting resignations before the year started I'm I'm talking about while children are in our classrooms we've had 18 teachers resign and 11 of those were applied liquidated damages I will say that that number includes the recommended liquidated damages tonight that didn't get through so you know that you'd have to subtract four from that number um but we don't know if they're going to be approved or not so I don't want to say that um and then versus two teachers last year resigned between August and the first meeting in January so to me it shows that it it has not been
223effective um and so I think the bigger question for the district is what is the difference why are people willing to pay $2500 to get out of their contract and I think that's the bigger question that this Administration and this Board needs to ask themselves and I think that we need to think about that and I think the climate survey will tell us a whole lot of information and I think it needs to come forward because the liquidated damages is not solving the problem um what you know I hear what other people are saying it's a contract but I could say that about a lot of things about administrators in this District that I won't get off open meting law but my concern is that I think it's very subjective the the waving of them
224and the the wording says that it's the B the board's sole discretion and so I think it gets tricky when it's being recommended to us and I'm not sure that we have all the information if it's our sole discretion if we have enough information to decide if it meets that criteria um and that criteria at least when I go back to the meeting it was approved in 2024 so February 12th the the specifications for where the um exceptions come from I don't I don't believe it's listed so I'm not sure if that was a policy that was created or approved by the board I couldn't find that so if this board majority decides to move forward I do think that the exceptions need to be in the contract um and I think we need to
225be really clear about whose decision is it is it hr's decision or is it the boards and if it's the boards then there needs to in my opinion there needs to be a lot more information about each particular situation to come to the board so that we can make the appropriate decision um those are my initial thoughts thank you board so I have a few things that of course I would like to say um I am totally for liquidated damages because of all the things we've mentioned in the past and I'm not against teachers at all um Mr uh officer Ricks can you escort her out please she's been told multiple times not to make comments thank you um I'm not against teachers at all I support teachers all the time uh this isn't why
226are we here we don't work for the teachers and that sounds harsh but we're here for the kids we are on this board for the children and so as much as we want to support the teachers we have to put the kids before the teachers and say when a somebody walks off their job they break their contract that's putting those that's interrupting those kids' education possibly for the entire year because these kids do get attached uh other staff is having to scramble to cover we're ending up on paying more because we're having you know over crowded classrooms and and all the other things that come into this so in my mind kids come first and so that's why I'm here and that's what we've said all night I've heard that from just about all everybody
227on this board is kids come first but when we come to this topic it seems like kids aren't coming first we're thinking about only the teachers the teachers that come work for us and I'm so grateful for them um they even understand the kids come first now if we're going to have people we can't also look at last as much as I would like to look at last year's resignations to this year's we it's not Apples to Apples because there's been a lot of things that have changed over the last year including a whole Administration um so there's going to be people leaving because they don't like the administration or or things are being found out or whatever is going on so it's hard to compare apples apples from last year to this year um
228what we possibly could look at if if this board would like if they think the liquidated damages are are too high we can look at reducing that possibly as Dr Mahorn said that um 2,500 was the max that other districts have been using if we want to go with a lower amount we could do that that's an option um I would like to ask Dr Mahorn when you were talking with your cohorts out there in regards to how they apply this the three criteria that we have is that the same three that most of them have or they all have or or is there a way to refine that possibly oh as a Bo I mean as a board you could refine that however you want but those are generally the the three that everyone
229had okay that's what I was saying outside of our district those are generally the three okay but yeah um and then M you make a great point I don't think honestly our job as a board is to hire and possibly terminate that position right here even though we approve the terminations and hirings I think that we should be leaving that to Administration I don't think that we need all the information and we should be able to um trust Administration with that that's something I heard a lot in previous boards is trust Administration trust the administration trust them and then all of a sudden it's don't trust anything they have we need everything 100% so I do think in this instance um I would be in favor of just leaving the discretion at as Administration as
230HR as it has been and it's just coming before us and then when they're when they identify something like what happened a couple weeks ago uh a couple months ago where there was somebody who fell in liquidated liquidated damage category but it was questionable then that came before the board and I think that that to me seemed appropriate um so with that I'll go ahead and send it back to the board um so I first want to respond about you know whose job it is and and all I guess I if I wasn't clear is I just want it to be clear like if the wording says at the board so discretion I don't feel like that implies that it's hr's decision so that's what I'm saying right now is the way that it's worded
231it feels like we need all of the information but I hear what you're saying so I just want the wording to be clear if it's hr's recommendation then I don't think it should say the b the board's sole disc uh discretion because it is going to come before us any resignation is going to come before that is normal so it's just the wording the way it sounds to me right now feels like it is our decision um so that's something to consider some other things that I wrote down could we consider like um no liquidated damages if you like if you initially sign your contract but then you resign before the end of the school year for the following year because I believe that we applied liquidated damages is to people well maybe even into
232the summer so the summer gets tricky you don't think so I hope not okay I don't know I wasn't sitting on the board I can't I'd have to go back in the board dos and look but I just wonder if we could I don't I don't think we have we try to work with the person within like I said it's a balancing act right we want to be focused on the student but if something happened in the summer and the principal's like hey I can hire this person in the next couple weeks that's what I remember we'd have to look back Stephanie but we try to be reasonably reasonable on it it's just a sometimes a tough spot but I understand what you're saying the wording can certainly depending on the board's Direction the wording
233could be made a lot more clear than it is now um and then the second consideration I had is and this is a little dicey but you know is there some wording that um if they choose to stay until a replacement can be found could then they not have to pay liquidated damages now obviously like you know they would then have to make the decision I you know I don't know everybody's personal circumstance now obviously if they are moving for their husband's job that's not going to work right but just another consideration to throw up no I I appreciate the out of the box thinking to find a suitable replacement I I mean I think that's very reasonable I wish it was always that easy but I think that that's I think that that's reasonable
234yeah I mean cuz then we're we're mitigating the interruption for the child right which is the whole point the whole point yes I got something else and that's what I was kinding to go at the beginning when I was asking one of the points you just made uh when I was asking about if teachers were trying to use it as a placeholder and we worried about that it was kind of like the a time limit on the liquid lated damages like if you've been here for like you T like six months of the year like I don't know if you should be required to play the full amount or not I think I don't know if it should be a pro-rated like hey you we you were here for two weeks and you left because
235you found a better job okay then you're paying 2500 you were here for 7 months or 6 months and you're leaving okay maybe it's 500 or 300 whatever um because they did put in a lot they did work a lot of their contracts I don't know if we need to look at maybe a Time window to like kind of prate the the liquidate damage a little bit your suggestion yeah that can be could that be something yeah yeah absolutely um again this is a discussion I think there's a lot of things to to be considered and you know refining the language looking at some of these options that are more reasonable we can certainly adding Clarity to what it is exactly who's the decision maker and clarifying that that language uh but I but I
236want the board to understand we we try to work with people as much as possible with the idea doing what's best for kids you know we it's like I said you're being tight and loose at the same time you know you're trying to be very understanding of people any other comments or questions on this agenda item okay with that we will go ahead and move to 11.1 this is going to be uh board comments or agenda topic requests we'll start down at the end Miss Schmidt do you have any uh agenda topic requests no not at this time thank you okay uh board member San uh kind of a a comment uh that was I don't know if I could address you to look into something during that was said during the public comment is
237said okay someone made a comment about the nurse being pulled away to fill classrooms is that really happening I don't know that we could discuss it at this time but it can be let me yeah let me let me get back yeah let me get back and find out for sure but I'll that be a board update or yeah no we'll we'll find out I wrote down the same thing when that was mentioned too I did as well you have anything else or was that it okay board member Zimmerman um I just would really like to reiterate my request um for um in particular the criteria and procedure of non-renewal for administrators because I think it's very time sensitive so I I would please ask that that would be added um to the next meeting
238and then I would also uh like to have an executive session to discuss the superintendent's contract in particular the timing of performance pay that was supposed to occur um in December and it was not uh on purpose that it didn't occur so okay and I at this time don't have anything else so we will move to item 12.1 which is the upcoming oh excuse me upcoming governing board meetings um so we have currently on here we have February 3rd a work study session regular government board meeting March 3rd regular meeting March 31st is also work session work session and meeting regular meeting um these possibly could change if we're bringing back another calendar but but they're they're there for now they're there for now okay um anybody have any issues with these three that we're
239looking at in the future okay with that we will go ahead and adjourn the meeting show that it adjourns at 8:05 [Music]