001[Music] like to bring to order the Liberty 25 governing board study session for December 16th at 4:30 p.m. with the Jerry roie administ ation building the board members present is Chris Kenny and Paul Bixler Kelly Zimmerman and myself Brian Parks Mr sarion is not with us today um agenda item 1.2 Pledge of Allegiance uh member vixer can you lead us please I Al to the the United States of America and to the Republic one nation indivisible so move on to agenda item 1.3 trust policy transition this is part two this will serve as the first read of the chapter three of the model policy program Miss Gass good evening board members sorry that just I wasn't expecting to be that loud um good evening and thank you for coming and joining me for this work
002study session we will be going over chapter three of the trust policies the intent of this work study session is to ensure that these policies that the trust has offered align with our current existing policies so just as a reminder we can't really make any changes those would have to like if we were looking to change the core intent of any one of the policies those would have to be brought to the board in a separate session so today's work study session is very much just alignment with the current policies how we'll run is I will um go ahead and call out the policy number and if we have any questions concerns or comments um that we would like to go over we'll do that for each policy number any questions before we get started
003okay so we'll start go ahead you said um that we're just working on alignment but I thought that last time when we talked about policy that we are like moving over and so we are giving some ideas about potential revisions that will then come back for a second read is do you want to speak to that Dr Monroe or would you like me to well I think we can follow the formula that we did last time if anything comes up and make note of it and again everything will have to be decided on as a second read whenever we do that to the board okay but yeah I think there's certainly things that can be discussed or brought up and but as far as a decision- making or anything like that that would be at
004the at the second read but yeah I mean if there's the homework that the board did if there's notes I think we do like we did last time and we keep those minutes yeah so we'll keep the notes but as far as um I think Dr manroe what we're speaking to the intent of this if there are changes to the policies to the existing policies that one of the board members is suggesting can that be navigated in this meeting or would we want to navigate that in a different meeting well I think it can certainly be brought up tonight uh nothing would be decided until a second read and that would have to be you know brought forward at that time so I think we could follow suit what we did the last time all
005right any other questions okay so let's start with policy 3-100 or I'm sorry 3-101 the budget adoption is there any questions concerns um or comments on this okay permission to move forward 3-101 a for the procedure 3-101 B 3 d10101 fund balance 3-102 fiscal management or Revenue 102 okay moving on to page eight 3-102 a 3-102 pointb 3-102 C okay on page 12 3-102 pointd yeah I do have a couple questions on that one um it talks about petty cash a lot in this first of all how much do we do we normally keep petty cash around on our campuses and at the district office do we actually have petty cash no board member Brickler we do not have petty cash philler we really don't have any no right no okay yeah I just wondering
006because that that seems like a really good way to get us in real big trouble yes so I would highly suggest we not have any pay cash sitting around okay and my like question for number one it says whenever cash is involved it is recommended that two people share the job of recording counting and verifying I don't know if you know does it need to be recommended I think two people is isn't should always be double-checking them I think that should be policy like pto's that's usually an R bylaws that two people have to count it so I'm just I don't know that word recommended yeah agree board members Andia we should have two people counting cash all the time so I'll take that out and put in should 3-102 doe 3-102 or I'm sorry
0073-13 on page 15 yes I do have question on that one uh there is a sentence in here that talks about the uh time frame of a warrant when that will be honored um I'm guessing a warrant is something like a check or cash dispersement then we've made a vendor is that correct yes yes remember pixler that is a warrant is a check okay yes uh and then it says that uh uh after one year if that warrant hasn't been exercised it becomes void that's correct so if somebody does not uh use that or cash the check then they can't after one year is that correct that's correct think it always request for a reissue that check but yeah it would be void at that point do we have that happen have we had warrants
008go on on cash yes we have yes I mean it's not frequent but yeah I mean there have been some times where there's checks that haven't cleared and this just go back into our account huh interesting all right yeah I found that an interesting thing and seems like a long time out too a year seems like a long time yes but uh yeah I had no idea people would just Let It Go they don't need the money I actually I'm sorry thank you um I had a question on that one too um Miss pixer brought it up is a year too far out meaning how does this handle your reconciliation so my where I'm going with this is typically in business world it's a quarter right yes so is this something we would want to
009modify for the be better behalf of the accounting department or do we leave it this same that's great question for member um or excuse me president Parks basically it's an outstanding check and every when we have that reconciliation we have all of our outstanding checks in the reconciliation so it just rolls over from month to month to month until we finally get to 12 months and then that's when it's we would just take it off of our reconciliation so it's accounted for I was giving you the opportunity to make a change if you wanted to so if you're okay with that I'm good thank you thank you any other questions okay so moving on to three-13 pointa procedures 3-13 pointb 3-1 103 Point c 3 d103 point e yes I do have a question on
010e um it talks about overtime and the compensation that occurs and it says that when you acrew more than 15 hours of overtime which would be compensatory uh which is actually 10 hours of time over your regular time so when you accr that 15 hours it goes to money we start paying them do we have many people that acrw and I'm assume this is hourly wage people right uh uh certified folks they're on contracts it doesn't matter how long so it's really the hourly wage people that are being impacted by this do we regular pay people for their time and a half after they've exceeded the 15 hours great question Boardman Brickler um we don't like for people to acrw over time but if they do then it goes into comp time and then they
011can use that as their basically their PTO if they want to take vacation and then they would get the time and a half at that point um otherwise if they go over 15 hours which is rare um I haven't seen that yet where somebody's gone over 15 hours over their time or so they would be like 55 hours um I haven't seen somebody do that but we would pay them out straight straight overtime for that right according to this we would have to yes once you get to that 16th hour that 16th hour actually becomes money exactly can't be taken as comp that's right so yeah R rare rare I have Haven yet to see it now there was a a time uh and actually started here in Paradise Valley at the district there there's
012a question that an hourly person had about being paid for extra stuff they did which was essentially working games and stuff after school which put them beyond their 40 hours and uh when that was brought forward uh the State of Arizona decided that you can't do that that you cannot work more than 40 hours yes and I remember us having to tell my staff uh that they had to go home they weren't allowed to stay and do extra things does that no longer exist now it it's you can stay but we're going to compensate you at time and a half or no we can't have anybody stay over 40 hours if they're going to P stay over 40 hours they going to get paid their comp time and then if they get paid comp time
013if they say over 15 hours over that they get paid time and a half so but I'm assume there's some kind of process to uh to allow that right somebody has to be asked permission to do that absolutely yes yes by the principal and by me and Dr Mahorn for sure okay and I'm assuming we're telling all of our hourly people that 40 is the magic number absolutely yes we discourage the use of overtime you have because of the implications so we try to be flexible with the employes get their jobs done 40 hours for yeah I know it cost lots of districts thousands of thousands of dollars they had to go back in and pay time and a half you think because they're working something different that they don't have to get paid for
014but they do right if you're working your working even if it's a different function right yeah as long as they're here they're working for the school district yeah all right thank you moving on to 3-14 it talks about uh inventory and what's needed to be as far as uh tracking of of materials and properties by the district and it makes the statement that we have uh we have to have an inventory of every unit that costs $50 or more do we actually have that do we have an inventory of everything that's $50 or more in the district so our stewardship listing actually is $1,000 or more it's not $50 or more but so we might actually want to update that to the thousand bucks which is what you kind of see right up there but
015yeah the stewardship listing is anything that's $1,000 or more yeah I just wondering because there got to be a lot of things that exist nowadays is $50 why I mean you can buy a pen for $50 now I'm assuming we don't have an inventory of everything that $50 or more that would seem to be endless good catch okay 3-15 3-106 three's Dash one's oh sorry I we're on page 3-106 point8 3-106 pointb 3-17 I had a question um the last kind of paragraph where it says the superintendent is responsible for the preparation and presentation to the board any other report as required list is list some reports is there a reason that there's just these certain ones it does say like you know it can include uh any report as required by state or federal
016law including but not limited to I'm just curious if if these were singled out for a particular reason or you know how did we come to these reports so the superintendent designates me to go ahead and prepare these reports for him and then I take them to the board for approval um and so these are just these are basically the reports that are annual reports so you got your K3 reading report the Tei report your classroom site fund report the AFR so yes these are annual reports that we we complete on an annual basis okay and and these are inclusive of all of them are there other reports there's also like a budget so there's going to be some other reports I wouldn't say this is like everything everything but it's it's close I mean
017this is this is 80% of the reports that would be in there you're going to have a budget this is just talks about fiscal accounting or fiscal accounting and financial reporting there's going to be other policies that discuss budgets okay I assume this is based on what's in statute yes for reporting what the requirements are yes the only other report would be the budget like our our main budget so the proposed budget our adopted budget and then our revised budget that we do in May those are also in statute okay I don't know if if you think they should be included in this or you think they're covered in the policy about the budget yeah I would just say Clyde let's kind of maybe we have a conversation with the trust because I know those
018are the reports we do every year but if they're not outlined in statute is that just the list that we have or do we need to add the budget but but now that Dane says that yeah the Tei the classroom site fund narrative summaries Transportation reports those we do annually so board members zman my guess I don't know for sure is that's why they're probably listed here because we do those so it's not just like an example or anything like that I think there's a specific policies I think there's specific policies on the budget itself yeah so and there the reports are included in that so these are the additional reports you have to do the budget is the main report I mean for this school district that's the big one yes any other questions
0193-10 7.8 on page pointb 3-17 c 3 d107 pointd yes on D M um it talks about the number of absences consecutively a student can have before they are uh withdrawn from counting on the ADM uh are we following through on that and how does that affect our funding if we're no longer counting them on ADM yeah so we got 10 on that 10th day the student needs to be withdrawn and once that student's withdrawn then he's we is no longer included in our ADM right so it actually drops the number of students that we have exactly so it does have an impact and cons starts again right actually when they get that 10 days they've already exceeded the amount of allowable absences in the school year anyway so um does um do we inform
020the parent when that that 10 days is hit that 10 consecutive days do we contact them so they they are aware that they're no longer enrolled at this school and could be in violation of state law yeah I want to say they're notified at like three absences or five absences a and you know some people might withdraw some people might enroll their child somewhere else and just not be on our books until we're contacted for records right so but yeah the schools will notify when you when I hit I think you hit three and then five es the parents are notified yeah I just have been involved with situations where custodial parent that were shared custody and one of them didn't know that this child was no longer going to school and so that became
021kind of an issue so I'm glad that we're informing the parents that if they are meeting that 10day consecutive threshold 3-10 7.e page 36 3-18 3-10 18. a 3-19 did have a question on that one okay um Dane or Mr bton this uh where it says this is page 40 uh right under governing board approval that dollar amount I'm not sure if it's there um I know recently we had just made a change and this was because of purchasing um lowering an amount I just wanted to make sure that what we have here and I know there's other places where this comes up that mount matches what this policy is going to be so I don't know if you know for this policy in particular this 3-19 if that's correct the 100,000 yes the 100,000
022is correct that the amount that we lowered was the $5,000 for the maintenance where we had to come to the board every single time we just wanted to give Bob the ability to approve that without actually getting quotes and so that was the amount that we lowered but yes we you know anything that's $100,000 or more we're coming to the board for absolutely okay I just wanted to make sure thank you sir and can I just clarify because I'm not sure where it is in here but just to clarify that when something is $10,000 or more the district contacts like procures three bids but not necessarily coming to the board but when the it's over 100 100,000 then they come to the board is that did I understand that right so if it's 10,000 to
023100,000 we're going to get written quotes and make sure that we get you know select the lowest quote um but if we do a bid it's going to be $100,000 or more and then we're going to go out for bid and we're going to have different procedures on that bid and then come to the board with some type of a process who we want to actually get that bid okay and the one that's 10,000 to under 100,000 is that uh is there a certain number in policy how many written quotes you have to get it is three okay I just want to verify thank you yes that's that's true yes unless we're using Mojave or contract uh we already have a vendor that's under contract and then we don't have to get the quotes because
024they're already giving us great pricing yes yes so Mojave is a Cooperative so we have different cooperatives that we are on and basically we can just use that cooperative for pricing and that would be for like air conditioning like that type of Maintenance or something okay maybe I could add something to that when it's a Cooperative that Cooperative does the bidding they do the three quotes or the three bids U so that the bidding is already done it's just there's a contract that the district participating in through the cooperation 3-10 N.A just to clarify I think uh miss simmerman this is where you were the what you were talking about that very first paragraph there yep 43 first paragraph yeah that's what my note says pointb okay I had a question on the second page
025of this uh page 46 at the top says a contractor subcontract or vendor or any employee of a contract okay um it's talking about like contractors having a fingerprint clearance card and then it says [Music] um it says they may exempt someone that's not determined to uh they may exempt the superintendent May exempt from this requirement a contractor subcontractor vendor that whom the superintendent has determined as not likely to have independent access or unsupervised contact with the students as part of their normal job I'm just a little uh concerned you know I don't know if we could be a little bit more specific what does not likely mean do we want to um take any kind of risk here with students um that you know we have a contractor that and not during school [Music]
026hours with just my opinion on that before Dr Monroe uh chimes in on this possibly when I I think that this gives a little bit of latitude to the superintendent's discretion there's certain things I can I can right off the top of my head think of you know you have some crazy animal come on campus or something you got to call Animal Control do we know that they have a finger print clearance card we not sure but are we going to hold that up you know it kind of gives a little bit of leeway where he can make that decision um you know I don't want to box him in too much with the wording of it but uh Dr Monroe if you don't mind yeah I mean I I'd really have to think through
027it uh carefully because I mean that I mean that's a valid example you know you have a loose dog or a wolf on campus or something but and honestly I don't I'm drawing a blank I'm trying to think of a time when maybe I was a superintendent and someone I knowingly didn't have a fingerprint clearance card was on I I don't I don't know what that would be I I can appreciate your sentiment but I know that it's important to the board um so I mean I could go either way but I think I just need more time to marinate with thinking about that language and I'm just I understand what you're saying and I don't want to I'm not trying to discount it it just say a contractor or a subcontractor or a vendor
028to me that's somebody that we're hiring like somebody coming to get a stray animal I think is you know a different different scenario than it's being presented here um but I you know I'm just offering my voice the only example I could think of is maybe like a Core Construction and then if they're hiring like if they have subcontractors that they're hiring out they may or may not have fingerprint clearance cards obviously we would like for them to have fingerprint clearance card and I'm sure core does but if they're just constructing the building and they're not actually going in the building or they're not going around students while this well the they're just building the building or helping us with Renovations then I think that's why they wouldn't have to have fingerprint clearance card I
029think that's a little of a slippery slope in my opinion um now at a new build I can appreciate that okay but when we're talking about working on campus with students um like I'm I'm going to use the example of Liberty in the preschool like sure the transportation facility there's nobody over there but there's definitely some sort of like work they're doing some pipe or something that's right at the gate where kids come in and out I don't know that's I'm just I'm not sure how yeah I would say just give us some time on that like I said I I honestly wasn't thinking about this paragraph prior to this meeting so I yeah let's give me some time on that one so we are now at about 4:57 um I would like to maybe
030put the rest of this on pause at what time or are we okay oh okay I just wanted to make sure because I saw everybody trickling in thank you okay I thought the governing board meeting was starting at 5 and I'm like um okay thank you all right so 3-10 N.C 3-19 n or Point D sorry 3-21 facilities page 50 I had a question on that one um right under construction maintenance this page 50 halfway down right the the second paragraph there the board shall construct and maintain all district facilities and buildings is the board responsible for maintaining the facilities I mean is that just the language there can you explain that one to me I'm just Clyde I'm going to look to you uh I think that's that's sticky because I think the answer
031is yes and I think what's expected is we work with the sfb for and one could argue whether it's funded or not that it's an expectation of us but how it comes about that's a that's a different thing if the sfb doesn't fund it do we have to go out for a c Capital Bond or or what have you but I think the expectation is yeah that we do maintain I'm I'm sorry and you mentioned me a little bit what was the question again Chris I'm sorry right there on page 50 um halfway down the second paragraph under construction and maintenance it says the board shall construct and maintain all district facilities and buildings um in accordance with the state local and federal requirements you know and it continues on there um talking about the
032codes but I do understand high level board is responsible for all the high level things that happen in the district so I do understand that I just that maintaining the district facilities kind of threw me through a little but I think I know where that's supposed to be yeah it's the the board's responsible for all of it that you have it through your staff you know you've got your maintenance department all those things that that's right in the mandatory require um mandatory responsibilities of the school board we won't have you start painting the schools on Saturday the board so okay 3-2018 3-20 1B 3-22 facility use 3-22 pointa hold on a minute let's jump back to 3-22 a uh schedule of fees direct expense shall be adopted annually include the following classes of usage um
033C fees a on page 56 um I know we did that a while ago but I don't think we've done that yet this year have we I'm sorry so the schedule of fees the direct expenses shall be adopted annually include the following classes of us so the board approves what the fees are for the use of our property or our facilities um I'm Bob I'm looking I think we approved it in the summer I don't know if there was I don't think there was any changes to the fee schedule but okay I just want to make sure I underlined it because I'm like I was sit in my memory going I know we did it over a year ago but I couldn't remember so thank you um I had some comments about this as well
034I uh went back and looked at our current policies for the use of facilities and I think that we're missing quite a bit in here I think this needs to be more defined if you're looking at our old policy it's KFA and kfb um one of the things that I think is really missing in here is who uh like the facility users how do they access the property is there a district employee always on the property that was in our old policy I did not see that in in the new policy um and uh also in the application process um it talks about who makes the decision for um the facility use um and I think it's I just want to clarify I guess maybe that it so it says the initial inquiries for the
035use of the school facility should be made to the appropriate School principles or site administrators to determine if the facility is available and obtain approval for the application process to move forward um upon approval by the building administrator so I just want to clarify that it is the building administrator that's making the decision on whether a facility can be used we we'll do some we'll do some work on this and bring this back because there's some things that are delineated in policy and then there's things that are in like the the handbook that becomes a procedure so uh as a former principal I never approved without the district's approval the facility rental to a church or any other group um and so we can do some work on this and make sure it aligns policy
036we stay higher level and I'm not sure why some of those details are in the policy but then uh the regulation is kind of through the handbook and the procedure so we can do some work on this Bob and make sure it aligns with our practice and that it aligns with statue okay and then if we could look back at our our other policies and make sure that we're not missing some key safety issues I think um also on page 58 um in the middle it's going to start talking about elections um posting of political signs and other electioneering activities shall not be permitted on school property at any time including on election day at school sites using as pulling places my question for legal is can you make that stipulation or is that against
037statute it well um no actually the statute does say you can't use school property for election signs that's what the statute says I know we had an issue that came up on Election Day this year and I was asked about that and I I talked it over with my partner at our office and we decided looking at it from a constitutional issue that when you invite the the public here to um use a facility as an election location then the general rule is a 75 limit you know 75 foot limit and any other facility besides the school facility that's the 75 limit is foot limit is the one that applies but you do have a statute that says you cannot use a district facilities or uses or resources to uh influence the outcome of an
038election so really would be the governing board's call in my opinion um in that on that particular day you've created a limited public forum for that activity of the elections and that the 75 foot rule would apply for that day but the statute goes on all the time statute is always there and the legislature adopted a statute says you can't use school facilities or School resources to influence the outcome of Elections so if you want to influence if you want to implement that and make that the rule here then you I in my opinion you should post it so that people could see that and that everybody would be informed CU I think that there are also people that are in parking lots on Election Day you know and that is absolutely school property so
039I think we need to I think this really needs to be refined defined and make sure that we are following the statute that we're following the 75 foot line like and I applied equitably across the district I don't know that are any of the schools actually being used for election sites yes here too they are okay well so I agree it may be something you really need to look at and Define uh when I was in Gilbert we use the 75 foot rule rule on the day of the election um but other times you cannot use it at all but that was the way we did it there but we the board can decide because there is a statute that says says you can't use school facilities so if you want to do that I
040think you just need to inform everyone and probably have something posted on the day of the election that says the 75t rule is not what applies it's a school facility you have to go outside the school off the school property and I I think it we need to be real careful here that like school property and the sidewalk and like County property and city property are different things yes the uh side the sidewalk and outside the sidewalk the front sidewalk is considered um a public access or public area so that's the limit of the school property would be to the outside Park uh inside line of the sidewalk I know that excuse me I know that this isn't in this section but it is directly tied to what we're talking about the very second to
041the very last page of the entire pamplet here at the very bottom it's talking about private vehicles on Election Day um and that this is Page 118 so the very last paragraph there says on Election Day if if a PLL school is using a PLL as a polling place a vehicle displaying electioneering messages may not be parked within 75 ft um limit designated by election officials so that kind of plays into it as well which is interesting because a lot of times you think bumper stickers off limits but this is basically saying anything that like you said Can sway election right needs to be outside that 70 foot rule that's correct but I think doesn't proba isn't there a li an exemption for private vehicles or not related to an election may be parked on
042District property by Personnel board members parents and visitors before election okay that's before it says my understanding is there is an exemption for V private Vehicles though yeah that's my understand can put signs in their cars you know what I mean and park them on the in the parking lot so election day is always controversial it is everybody wants to push the limits a little bit but yes I would ask that we get some clarification and if it comes to the board the board make a decision so yeah thank you all right okay 3-22 B 3-23 visitors I had a question is this the same thing as volunteers or is this something separate I didn't see volunteers listed in this part but is it is it going to come up later okay yeah so it
043will come up in chapters four and five okay so I just had a clarifying question about like current District it's probably uh more like procedural but from my understanding right now if parents want to come in and like have lunch with their child in the cafeteria they have to go through the volunteer process is that a correct statement or no you know what I would have to look to Dr Mahorn I don't know if that's correct I don't want to misspeak do you know that for sure do we need to get back I'll get back but I don't think so we'll we'll get back I don't want to okay provide anything that might not be accurate okay 3-20 3.a that's on page 3-31 Food Services page 3-30 1.a 3-31 pointb 3-30 1. C 3-31 Point
044D 3-31 Point e 3-32 Transportation uh I just had a question um if we do not service high school students in our district do we need to have number two as part of our policy and then um number three it says students ADM admitted via open enrollment policies who may be eligible for transportation under state or federal law we talking about um special education students but I'm not sure uh or is this the mckin vinto it's both it's both exi okay but are we are we doing an open enrollment for special education students and then transporting them we we probably need to research that one because special uh special education students students with disabilities is in number four and mckin vento is a number five so I'm trying to I'm trying to think what situation
045would warrant that yeah that's why I put example it's a weird situation but I'm sure the trust probably knows why that was put in there because yeah mcken vento and special education is below I just think the key word is open enrollment who are we transporting on open enrollment because I assume that's open enrollment outside of the district so I think probably we need to clarify does that mean outside the district are we talking about and again I open enrollment to a school within the district why are we transporting them when the other ones required by state law are covered yeah I think yeah I think we could look at that there's probably something that we're missing an exceptional circumstance that fits that I also have a general question about that uh this particular policy
046did that change uh a mile out was it was that always that way I recall there being a change in that sometime earlier this year uh boy off the top of my head I don't know and I don't I don't think dandi is in the audience um so I don't I don't know if we I'll have to get back with you on that I don't know if we change that mile or you know there's obviously exceptions to it when safety comes into consideration but yeah my my recollection was I actually asked a question about whether or not it would impact our funding on transfer ation because it seemed to be a difference uh it seemed to be farther out than what it was I'm wondering if the mile still accurate is at now a mile
047and a half because it seems to me that there was some change that occurred yeah I'll get back to you on that I do remember you asking in a board meeting about I don't remember if it was the same exact situation but yeah let me let me look back and see could very well have been about high school students but I okay it did seem to me it got farther out okay 3-30 2. a 3-32 pointb 3-32 point C 3-41 safety and Emergency Management we are now on page 87 3- 41. a 3-41 pointb 3-41 point C 3-41 Point D are you at at e or D I am now on E 3-41 Point e yeah this is the only place that we have anything that's a different color yes is this um does that
048indicate our policy that's not in the trust policy words that language in our policy not in the trust policy is that correct yeah so in September um the board changed a significant amount of policies and we wanted to make sure that those policies that the board change and the intent of those policies were incorporated into the trust policies so that that way the intent of all policy is transferred over so this is the only place that the intent of the policy that we have might have been a little bit different than what the board or what the trust had offered us so we've highlighted all of those sections in this blue green turquoise esk area color no if we just went with the trust policy this would not be in there correct so our decision
049whether or not we want to have that language in there as well well we won't decide that now but that we wanted you to be aware that's why there's the little key up at the top updated District policy even though the blue doesn't quite match but it would come to a second read and this this was about Pest Control applications and the procedures that Bob's department does uh I think that it was 72 hours was the was the real uh difference there but we had just adjusted this a few months back right so again it will come down to that second reading and if we want to keep this language in there we need to make sure that's mentioned correct and the intent of this change specifically was to give the district enough time to
050um notify parents within the 48 hours so seems like a good idea yeah 3-41 pointf 3-42 yeah 3-40 2.a okay quite a few things um first it says that this is about uh Freedom of Information Act for those listening um it says I the district shall respond within five working days acknowledging the receipt of a request I think that's way too long we this board has been talking about customer service 5 days to to to respond an acknowledgment of the request I think that's not I don't think that's very uh appropriate um and then I really think that um we need to come up with a reasonable amount of time I think the amount of time that um the district currently is taking for Freedom of Information acts is not adhering to statue at this
051point it's a reasonable amount of time you know we're sitting on things for weeks for a single sheet of paper and I think if we're going to be transparent with the public and we want the public to trust us then we need to be able to respond to things in an appropriate amount of time things that need to be redacted long requests I think is a different story but a single sheet of paper for weeks I think it's unacceptable and I think that this policy needs some very specific things and I also think that the records um can be sent electronically and that's not listed in this policy either as I read it any other comments suggestions okay 3-42 pointb uh I just had a question for legal um it talks about personal devices uh
052um that are you know for uh you know can be requested in Freedom of Information Act you know can that be held up legally because um you know if it can't be held up and and it's not common practice then I don't think it should be in policy um it can be held up legally it's it has there have been examples of that um I personally was involved with having to review someone's personal devices that people were edging were being was being used for um public purpose you know so uh it wasn't a school district but I did actually have to I was the one was reading the text messages so um yes the courts will enforce that okay but it would take a court to be involved we are not pulling people's cell phones
053no certainly that's not something that's automatically done you're right it would be a court order where you would um that would be requested okay so I I think that we should look at this policy then because I'm sorry I sometimes when I don't Mark exactly where it is on this page I have to go back and find it but thank you [Music] um yes it says it may be subject to public disclosure and inspection as public record even if personal devices are used to communicate regard uh regarding District business so they may be requested the public May request those and then then it'll be up to the individual depending on if they're an employee it won't be up to them really but if they're a board member something like that then it would be up
054to the individual what they're going to do with that request so if it's an employee you're saying that the member a member of the public can request an employees cell phones and the district will produce that information would be expected to if they're doing B District business if they're doing dist District business on the personal device that's not what they're supposed to be doing and they could be requested yep and and so does the district have a policy uh not a policy um a procedure on how that is handled not that I know of I I only know of this happening in one past District that I was in um because of court order or litigation or what have you but I don't believe we have a current procedure for it it's very unusual but
055it does can happen I understand so I think that if we're going to have a policy then we should have a procedure to back up that policy I don't because then you get into this it happens and now we're like deciding on a whim based on the situation how to handle it I don't I don't think that is again transparent in my opinion okay 3-42 Point C 3-42 pointd 3-43 technology we are on page 100 at this point 3- 43. a 3-43 pointb 3-44 Insurance 3-44 a 3-44 pointb 3-44 point C 3-50 1 elections we are on page 3501a 3-50 oh on a yes um so uh in the last sentence in the first paragraph it says the district shall not distribute any material concerning the proposed increase in the budget via any student enrolled
056in the district but the district can provide actual information so are you saying that that factual information cannot be distributed to a student through a student so you mean like we can't send home a piece of paper with the student even about factual information I'm just clarifying that's what we're saying here yeah I don't think you're supposed to send home use students as um methods of delivering that information that is my understanding yep okay even the factual information it has to be like email okay email or um mailed or whatever yeah okay yep 3-50 1.a 3 d501 pointb uh this is just a clarifying question for number four I'm just uh since I worked on the override and I'm just curious why do they not allow the do you know why the reason why the
057governing board's not allowed to set a a pro statement for a bond I'm just curious the thinking I know that we can't I'm just no this is for a bond not an override tell me where you're reading oh sorry number four number four the last sentence the governing board may not submit St I'm on the P wrong page oh 113 okay not to exceed 100 words each submitted to County public governing board may not submit a pro statement No the governing board does writes this original statement in the pamphlet that's for the O for the O for both a bond and an override they're the very first written statement about the purpose of the override right these governing board members can't write a separate Pro statement you're you're on the one you're on the main
058statement that is written for the purpose of the bond or override but they do write one for the override they are one of the pro statements of the 10 submitted but it says it's okay I mean I'm just wondering yeah this is the bond though I know that's why I'm asking do we just I assume this is statute right yeah yeah I believe it is let's check that Clyde let's check to make sure sure because I I hear what she's saying and I I want to be sure cuz I do know yeah in the bond pamp it's all board it's kind of the board's letter what they're putting out to the public but the governing board may not submit a pro statement I know it's the first in an override it's like the first one
059provided but let's just make sure okay I don't want to short Chang us or tie our hands if we don't need to 3 d502 3-53 had a question about this you know um it's very clear that you know in statute that you cannot use School resources or anything like that so if somebody were to do that what are the consequences and do we have procedure for that in this District well that would fall under kind of personnel discipline if an employee broke the policy yeah that would fall under kind of Staff discipline or what have you if they if someone broke policy and are you talking about the violation of the law itself because there is a complaint process that you follow with the county yeah with the county actually the County elections has county
060attorney's office has someone that's designed supposed to handle the election complaints but the district isn't going to hold their own employees also you know what I mean accountable I guess is what I'm asking here I know that there's you know like according to the law but I'm just asking the district yeah that would be the procedure yes the staff discipline when you sign when you are an employee of the district you sign to obey all of the policies so if someone was in violation of the policy which could have been made for a complaint to the Maricopa County Attorney's Office there would be staff discipline whatever that looks like okay hey 3-50 3.a um okay on number two at the bottom um political buttons t-shirts says governing board members personnel and others sorry acting on
061behalf of the district shall not wear political buttons t-shirts hats or other items displayed on their persons or apparel that are designed to influence the outcome of an election in a classroom in an other instructional setting or at a school sponsored extracurricular activity at which they are supervising or assisting with supervision or organization of the extra extracurricular event I'm not sure that we need the word governing board members in this part because we're not doing any of those things we are not in a classroom we're not in an instructional setting we are not supervising anyone at an extracurricular event um so I just think to limit people when it doesn't meet the criteria of what's listed here I read that I read that as two things so you don't want governing board members sitting at
062the Das the de wearing political t-shirts and the other piece of it is in the other instructional setting so it's two separate things so I'm I'm actually fine with the way this is written because like you know we don't want to be wearing buttons or or make any political statements while we're sitting up here or in any other function that has to do with the school district so that's the way I read it I just I think this is a little tricky with the First Amendment and it's not preventing teachers the way I read this and this is you know this is this policy is quite long I think if you go I think if we go to number six on the next page and it says C I just think we need to be
063real I think we need to be specific here to protect ourselves our employees so this is talking about petition circulation and and you have you can do it outside the classroom outside any instructional setting and you can do it at school sponsored extracurricular event as long as you are not supervising or assisting with the supervision so that's saying at a soccer game on school property you can collect signatures that's what this policy is saying so I mean I think we need to decide if that's something if is is statute supporting that statement I mean I I think it could fall under the First Amendment right but I just think we need to have a discussion and be real specific here um and making sure that we're not infringing on the First Amendment right but that
064I just want to clarify that that that can be done because I want to protect our employees I think they have the right to do things um and I think there's been a lot of question about this so I I just want us to be clear here yeah I think one thing you have to keep in mind on this one of the reasons why teachers not supposed to wear political uh buttons and so on in classrooms it's because of the amount of influence they have and I think what this is talking about when it talks about governing board members is that amount of influence that a governing board member might have on the public and you're not allowed to use that influence to to do something as far as voting but I think you're absolutely
065right I I don't know as a governing board member whether or not we should lose our first amendment rights uh when we become a governing board member uh I I agree with you I think this is this says something I don't agree with doesn't it really just say when you're at your official capacity when you're representing the district no it says when you're at the event as a member it says all this is not an instructional setting you're talking about a board meeting correct but that's a governmental action well it could be extracurricular you might be at a socer okay then I think that the wording if that's the direction we're going then the wording needs to be changed because it does not say that in this policy right now okay all right we'll look
066we we'll have to look at it yeah we will review um any other questions on chapter three yeah I'm sorry number eight says candidates and their representatives persons acting on the behalf of the district shall not permit okay I think the key word that we need to listen to persons acting on behalf of the district shall not permit candidates including but not limited to candidates for the board and the representatives to announce their candidacy or Advocate their election or the defeat of their opponents in school build buildings on school property except for times when they are participating in a public forum does this include uh public comment at a board meeting well that's not a formal Forum I think what they're talking about there as forum is if it's the public are invited to come
067and learn about some particular particular activity that's going on a political activity a bond or override something like that then they have um and an organization puts it together and that's created as a public form and people invited to participate in that okay so we are saying in our policy that there are certain things that cannot be said during public comment at a board meeting by the members of the public yeah 15511 wouldn't allow it on District property okay well it wasn't enforced both ways but that that is the law any other questions comments on chapter three um okay so on page 118 again this is just talked about in a in a lot of different ways so permitted activities um is this B you know I think we just really need to decide on
068as a board in in consult with legal council but are we allowed to do things at school sponsored extracurricular activities I see that as like a a game which would be on school property but it just says if you are not on duty so you know a bunch of teachers come to a soccer game like I just want us to be specific so that our employees have clear expectations okay that will conclude the first read of chapter three of the trust policies president Parks we'll show that the thank you m casanas you're welcome that'll conclude our uh study session at 5:36 [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] what [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] i'
069like to bring the order uh the Liberty 25 School Board public hearing it's December 16th at 5:45 with the Jerry Rover roie administration building board members present is Chris Kenyan Paul Bixler Kelly Zimmerman and myself Brian Parks Brian s cion could not be with us today agenda item 3.2 hearing to discuss considerations for School attendance boundaries L let's see El uh Loretta Umbro L bra's Academy and um blue Horizons beginning 2025 2026 school year Dr Monroe pres president Parks vice president Kenyan members of the board for our current policy were to have a public hearing when boundaries are recommended to be adjusted and so that's why we are having this hear hearing on the agenda right now and so um at 3.3 if there was any red cards where people wanted to be heard about
070the boundaries before a presentation was done later that that's why we have that here in this public hearing vice president keny do we have any red cards for public comment no we do not okay um thatd be 3.3 call to the public hearing and since there's at there's no calls to the public on the School boundaries um we'll go ahead and adjourn the meeting at 546 Miss camarad did you need a few minutes okay we bring to order the Liberty 25 governing board regular meeting December 13th at 5:47 p.m. with the Jerry roie administration building board members present is Chris Kenyan Paul Bixler Kelly Zimmerman and myself Brian Parks uh member Bixler will you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance please Al to the un States America to theice Welcome to the Liberty Elementary
071School District governing board meeting we appreciate your interest in the district the five elected governing board members serve without compensation and volunteer countless hours on behalf of our students and staff the president presid and vice president of the board are elected in January under state law the governing board may only discuss and vote on matters that are on the agenda for tonight's meeting agendas are posted a minimum of 24 hours in advance on the Liberty ele School District web page and at the Jerry roie District complex copies of tonight's agenda are located in the foyer and on the District web page if you wish to make a public comment please complete a request to address the board form and submit to the board secretary before the meeting starts these forms are located in the foyer
072prior to entering the governing boardroom members of the public will be given a maximum of 3 minutes to speak once recognized by the governing board president please state your name before you speak during the call to the public the public may speak on any item of business on the agenda that requires the board to take action the public may also speak to the governing board about a school district matter that is not on the agenda state law prohibits board members from commenting on or discussing the matters presented at the end of the call to the public however the board may ask the superintendent to review the issue or place it on a future agenda a board member may also briefly respond to criticism of a board member or the governing board itself we ask that
073all speakers show respect and courtesy to others comments must pertain to a matter that is within the jurisdiction of the governing board this is not an appropriate form to complain about an employee student or others we also ask the public who are present for the meeting to be respectful by being attentive avoid calling out or creating any disruption that may interfere or interrupt the meeting individuals who interrupt or interfere with the meeting may be asked to leave by the board president thank you for allowing this meeting to be conducted in a peaceful and productive Manner and thank you for your attendance and involvement in tonight's meeting we'll move on to agenda item 5 point three the approval of the regular agenda do I have a motion Mr President I move that we approve the regular
074agenda consistent with board policy bedb and temporarily suspend governing board policy with which this agenda may be inconsistent have a second second we'll call the vote uh vice president Kenyan I member Bixler I member Zimmerman I I'm also un I will show that pass 4 Z move on to item 6.1 attendance enrollment reports Dr Monroe president Parks vice president Kenyon members of the board merry Christmas happy holidays I hope you enjoy a happy New Year and enjoy the holiday season with your families uh I think our students staff families are very excited for the winter break and that's coming up in just a few days so I I wish everyone a happy holidays um as you could see in the enrollment report uh we're currently trending I think it's about 150 152 students from this
075point last year of growth which is exciting and then uh one other thing I wanted to mention I think Dy was in the room but uh uh Rainbow Valley and transportation department participated in the glow on Monroe parade in Buckeye and I was told today dandi that we somehow won an award is that right first place so um it was it was pretty amazing experience it's a cool new tradition that Liberty is going to be involved in at that glow on Monroe parade in uh in Buckeye and was really proud of Rainbow Valley Transportation for being a part of that um and then I'll turn a few minutes over to Dr mohorn for update on discipline student discipline uh president Parks vice president Kenyan um you could bring up the slides for discipline it is
076an attachment on at least I see it as an attachment there should be other there's three SL there yeah right there so once a month you receive a update on discipline um the second slide talks about the professional development um our professional development for December has not happened yet it will happen on Wednesday um our administrators will focus on safety so for the first time the Buckey PD goody your PD M and MCSO will be conducting a joint tabletop exercise will with our building leaders so we have not had this yet we last year we were able to get Goodyear PD but we were not able to have Buckeye and MCSO uh join us so this Wednesday all three PDS will be together in this room and we will be doing a joint tabletop focusing
077on active shooter so they are looking forward to that in January building leaders will be looking at examples of real discipline referrals and processing them together to do interr reliability and in February um they're going to drill down into individual School discipline data using a data processing protocol so looking at the time of day things are happening where at in the buildings outside the building maybe on the playground really drilling down and seeing where the data incidents or the discipline incidents are happening so if you look at the Third slide and you look at the data this is where um these are real live data as of just last Wednesday and this is our referrals they may look high to you but remember this year is Baseline data we are getting accurate data we have
078told the principles you have to enter all of your referrals into Synergy and this year they are doing that also please remember that in the month of December also usually the month of February and March um the discipline issues usually do heighten they do go up right before breaks right before winter break and right before spring break usually discipline issues do rise so when you see these numbers and it seems like maybe they are high they are high usually before breaks um Behavior does Spike so that is what I have for discipline for December thank you Dr mahor all right we'll move on to 6 point Sorry could we make a comment about this agenda item okay uh I had some questions about um the numbers in home rooms um we have some classes that
079are sitting in the red that have been sitting in the red for basically the entire school year I went back and looked at these Home Room reports and so I just want to know what is the district's plan why have we not posted these positions um in order to keep class sizes low um the override was passed and part of what we promised the public was that we were going to maintain this ratio and so we set these targets um and so for example in Freedom we are the Kinder target class size is 22 and at Freedom it's been sitting at 28 so that's six over the entire school year so I just want to know what the plan is how are we supporting these teachers we've already lost the freedom kindergarten teacher I can't
080imagine has to do with these high numbers we have had a posting for a kindergarten Freedom teacher uh there have been interviews that have been done and as a teacher hasn't been able to be hired yet so it has been posted for a while now I I personally don't see it on the website so I know that Mr Ardon just did an interview last week for a Kinder teacher okay have we considered um hiring a Pera to support these K there there is AA there at least one if not two perah and in addition the teachers are getting paid class overage it doesn't help but yes there is at least one perah and uh he did do at least one last week and I believe one the week before so it's he is interviewing okay
081and so is that is that true for the LBA um second grade class that's sitting at uh 33 uh Miss Schaefer had done an alternate plan with LBA okay and that teacher is okay with that plan yes she she's met with her team and I approved an alternate plan and and her teachers approved it as well she went to the teachers first okay and the rainbow second grade at uh sitting at 29.5 and the target is 24 I didn't know anything about rainbow but I had talked with the other schools extensively cuz it's been sitting at 29 in October 29 in September 29 in August so it's been there the whole time um so I think we need to make sure that we are honoring our promise to the voters and I think we need
082to make sure we honor our teachers you know that we set these class Target size and we're and we're supporting them so that they feel supported and um and then the the other only other one in red this month is a blue at third grade but this is the F or blue I apologize in red over the target size um this is the first month but I would encourage the district to be proactive um and making sure that we are honoring these class Target sizes Mr deminsky has already talked to me about that okay so I think we need to look quickly at the rainbow situation since it's been this way the entire school year um Miss Zimmerman um that was outside of the agenda item if you wish to pull things that are outside
083of the agenda item you need to do that at the end of the meeting the agenda item has The Home Room class updates that's part of the agenda item so I'm not speaking about something that's not about the agenda it is in the item well that's not how I read it ma'am but anyway so that' been we'll move on to uh 6.2 the governing board and superintendent recognitions Dr Monroe yeah if we can invite the board down uh we're going to uh recognize some employees and volunteers from estria Mountain on behalf of uh Dr Monroe the governing board members and myself the Liberty Elementary School District is proud to foster a community and culture that motivates and recogn izes those who make exceptional contributions to our students they embody our core values of respect Integrity
084accountability high standards and our students centered we aim to reward excellence and show appreciation not only to our staff who achieve significant goals and exhibit exemplary behaviors but also to our dedicated parents and volunteers who make invaluable contributions to our schools and classrooms as as I call your name please come forward for recognition and we'll take a group photo afterwards so and the the principal is here she's here good I also want to say um the Arizona Furnishings um I'd like to thank them for their contribution support because they gave us the the donation to hand out flowers to all our wonderful teachers so we want to give them a big thanks so first on the list is joonie sheesley and I guess she's not here with us tonight but Johnny sorry um I guess
085she's not here tonight with us but we'll give her a round of applause for Onsite staff is Christine Moran District support staff Mindy karfa parent Ashley wries and our volunteer Crystal Carbone okay guys their certific all right if the teachers and some of the people in the audience want to take them moment and leave you can we won't make you stay here but you're of course welcome to stay move on to item 6.3 Loretta's Umbro Elementary School um construction update Bob Young Mr president vice president members of the board uh we had a walking tour of the site last week and a couple of the members joined us we're glad to walk through and tonight we have Whitney bun from Core Construction who's going to give us a presentation on what's going on over there
086at the school they're doing a great job and things are looking good thank you Mr Young uh president Parks distinguished members of the board thank you for this opportunity to give a quick construction update on the Loretto zombro Elementary School um my name is Whitney bun I'm the project uh director for core and the main point of contact uh for this construction project uh I just wanted to recognize a few of our team my team members for core Zack f is the project manager and then Eric Decker is our superintendent and also uh the architect um on this which is DLR group and David Schmidt the architect and then Jim lamb the construction administrator who's also here with us tonight so diving into this I think the last time we were here um we were
087getting the approval for the guaranteed maximum price for the school and so now we've been able to make significant progress on this job and I just wanted to share with you a few numbers um of how we're doing so so far we are just um over about 88 days since we've been able to get on the site and since then um as many of you know with construction comes a lot of heavy equipment and a lot of dirt moving we've we've moved so far uh 39,000 cubic yards of dirt um and through the through the end of this month we we're projected who have about 13,500 labor hours that have been spent so far on this project uh it's currently about 27% complete and we are on track um as we noted at the board
088meeting about three or four months ago that we were going to have three of the buildings complete and ready for school to open at the beginning of the 25 26 school year and so we are currently on track with our schedule and doing really well there um 1,400 cubic yards of concrete port and just to put that into context that's about 140 concrete trucks you know the big cylinder trucks that you see come to the site um in terms of uh the open web wood trusses and I joist we have about 10,000 fet of that that are being delivered installed this month as well so if you haven't had the opportunity uh to drive by um you'll be able to see that going in before the end of the winter break uh by the end
089of this month we also have installed over 42,000 uh cinder blocks CMU uh 8816 blocks um, 1500 linear feet of glue land beams That was supposed to be updated but there's been uh nine uh heavy heavy machinery that did all the dirt moving there was nine pieces of equipment there um we're total cost to complete about 5 million here's what I'm personally proud of zero neighbor complaints so thank you community for being so generous uh uh of our noise and sometimes of our dust um we appreciate we appreciate you very much and and if any of you would like to come visit the site don't hesitate to to stop by and check in at the trailer um and and we Al also are expecting one Santa Claus sighting this winter break so really quick I'm
090just going to fly through um a video this is what it looked like the day after we started so the farm field was still there the crops um were we we we were able to have our earthwork mover contractor and they were able to hire uh some of the local farmers to cut the rest of the crops down as low as they could we used the leftover water in those ponds as some of our construction water and that was used to to to keep all of the Dust down and and to start moving that dirt and so in this next um video here you'll see that you know we've already gotten rid of all of all of the crops and we started building what are called the pads for the for the construction site and
091so here you'll see kind of from an overview some of the equipment that's on site moving the dirt around on the left side of the screen that's a a scraper and that's picking up dirt and moving it around the site and then and that was about 90 days after or I'm sorry 30 days after we had started so in this next uh video here you'll see this is only 30 days later so we'll do like a aerial progress phot photo every 30 days and you can see we've already got all of the footings installed the concrete footings you can kind of see the layout of how the buildings are going to look on the on the bottom part of the screen that's the parking lot we don't have that completely built yet but that will
092be finishing by the end of January um and so you can kind of see we're we're digging inside of each of the buildings for the utilities like the plumbing the electrical and in this in this last video you see we've made significant progress now on the on going vertical and installing those 42,000 blocks um so far and much more to come and so we've got some of the concrete that's been poured and um there's a water truck kind of keeping the the ground wet and keeping the dust down and just wanted to thank uh the Liberty Elementary School District for your guys' support um Bob Young director of operations for uh the district he's been great and this this is a a pretty fast fastpaced project for us um and just want to thank you
093guys for your support the decision- making and and being there um when we need questions answered so we appreciate you uh so with that I I guess we could open it up to any questions or comments from the board or just quick comment um I I'm impressed by how quickly you guys are getting everything moving and uh every time I drive by there it's there's more progress and more progress um with everybody freaking about drones and Buckeye you know now we know why but uh thank you thank you so much for that that was a good presentation welcome member Bix member Zimmerman I just wanted to thank you for the the opportunity to take the tour was really uh insightful and just being able to really put my eyes on the design where the buildings
094are all of those things um just appreciate your guys' time and that footage is is really incredible to see what you been able to accomplish in such a short amount of time so I appreciate that thank you I'll kind of segue off of that I I got to do the tour as well and I think one of the things that caught my eye the most was all of the individual projects that were going on at the same time in the project management and how you were able to deal with issues that came out of nowhere so to speak that could have put you behind and you able to work with those and um you know it's just keep moving and keep keep pushing hard we got a school to open in August so thank you
095thank you appreciate it thank you Whitney Jim we appreciate you being here and appreciate the presentation thank you thanks all right move on to item 6.4 Loretta Umbro Elementary School update Mr Bruce nebinski the principal of blue Horizons thank you than you president Parks vice president Kenyan Mrs Bixler Mrs imman thank you for allowing me to speak tonight Dr Monroe and cabinet wanted to give you just a very quick update on some very initial planning things that we've started to think about for the school nothing that I'm going to present to you tonight is set in stone um these are some working ideas that we've surfaced in talking um with stakeholders talking with some students um and just talking with our district to say what are some options that we have for the school we
096know why the school is there to our fabulous 36- year veteran Loretta zumbra this is a picture of her pretty much on day one when that sign went up and I wanted to show you compared to and you just saw the awesome Drone footage that I cannot compete with but this is what we had on December 4th the last time that I was at that site and I'm consistently amazed every time I drive home uh down lower Buckey just to see the the progress that our Architects and our construction people just talked about um they're doing a great job been able to be on site about three or four times and see the hard work that they are putting in they truly are dedicated to making this school a worldclass facility um working very hard
097so very exciting is the planning principle to just see that development that takes place over time so Furnishing zumbro these are one of the big things that we got to start thinking about before our students arrive next August of 5th we have had meetings that have taken place regarding furniture options um one of the things that we did is we took our both our furniture people and our construction or excuse me our Architects through blue Horizons knowing that Loretta zbro will have some likings according to Blue Horizons and we got some instant feedback from our teachers we spoke with about eight or 10 teachers we asked them what are you getting the most out of in your classroom what kind of furniture do you feel your students are getting the greatest benefit out of what
098furniture things in your classroom aren't working what are things that are in the way what do you need in terms of storage what is appealing to you not just in the classroom but in the hallway so we got a lot of actionable feedback from our Blue Horizon teachers um and took that into our Furniture meetings that we've had with companies to say this is what our current teachers are telling us they get the most bang for their Buck out of we don't want to reinvent the wheel with this furniture we want to make sure that if teachers are getting useful things out of it that the teachers that we bring to zumro or that we hire for zumbro will have the same impact we definitely want to continue tradition of flexible seating options building color
099schemes which you've ever been to Blue each of the five buildings has kind of a different color scheme we want to continue that thought with Loretta zumbro since there will be five buildings and of course as I mentioned before teacher needs for both storage and space that is very important to teachers where do they store their things is it in the way how can they keep their classrooms uncluttered but also safe for their students we sent an initial survey to the families of blue Liberty and L Rea students and the purpose of this was to bounce some ideas off of nicknames so one of the things that gets overlooked is when we have a new school we need to have a nickname for that school so we talked about uh we had a initial list
100of 10 we kind of paired it down to three by talking to some people and uh kind of eliminating some choices that didn't fit into our district and we kind of came with the final set of The Navigators the sand sharks and the aviators you'll notice if you know anything about military and airplanes a lot of them have kind of an aviation theme which we kind of wanted to do right off the bat so we in this survey we asked students to kind of rank and their families rank of these three nicknames which one was their favorite we also got input from Loretta zumro because again this school has her name on it and we want her to have an impact on that school both in nicknames and colors we want her to have her
101stamp on that she deserves that so in our initial survey and again this does not mean that we're going to be the Reda zbro Sand Sharks but the survey that we had Sand Sharks was the leader with 54% some of you might say what is a sand shark well it is not an actual animal um we do have a lot of sand here in Arizona uh in looking at the military theme I was able to discover that the sand shark is a name that the Marines it's the Marines over the Army no I'm stuck give to one of their uh attack helicopters so it's a name that is on a helicopter and we figured if we're going to go for it let's go for something that the Western Valley hasn't seen so Sand Sharks kind
102of right now is out in front we'll finalize those plans and and communicate that to our stakeholders as well along with our nicknames we wanted to propose some color schemes and starting from the idea that we didn't want to copy any of the color schemes in our current schools you'll notice our options are a little bit outside the box so we had an option of teal sand and black as well as purple sand and black teal sand and black was the leader of the two color schemes that we did by with 77% you may not know it but Letta zumber is a big fan of teal as is the planning principal don't ask why we just like it we even did the slides in teal so again I'm not standing here to say that the
103um the red umbrell will be called the sand sharks and our colors will be teal sand and black but we wanted to get some working ideas and see what our stakeholders our children that are going to be attending that school thought about that so I would say this is leading the pack we have had some discussions with Furniture companies about what this type of furniture might look like in a school and we actually have some exciting ideas if we proceed with this color scheme those are things that we will finalize in the next four to six weeks so that we can get the ground running on that some additional notes uh these are possible and I stress possible future programming items for consideration these are not things that I personally am married to or not
104married to these are ideas a phonics emphasis possibly school uniforms possibly implementing cursive implementing a unique signature program and possibly a back to- Basics traditional math curriculum the thinking on that is we have seven schools in our district in adding an eth School having a traditional program that might be a little bit different than other schools or maybe having something like curs of or uniforms may give parents an option in our district to come to that school I also want our board and our audience to be cognizant of the fact that this school is going to be very very close to the Avendale school district there are a number of homes that are going up right across Citrus and we want our school to be an option for them if they choose to send their
105school children right down the school right down the street if they choose to stay in Avendale we respect that but we want to have an option for them and some of these are things that they may appreciate again these are things that we have surfaced then that we will work on in January and February we have some meetings with our curriculum Department we have some meetings with our business department that will be taking place over the next two months to kind of iron out what some of these things might look like this is not a comprehensive list nor is it a set in stone list and again I do want to stress that our next steps this is where I come in and start to hit the ground running with what we're going to do
106to get ready for zumbro we have to have enrollment estimates and as we look at our scenarios tonight and as we decide about our scenarios will each come with estimates on what our enrollment might look like based on current housing as well as based on the percentages that we may take from Blue Horizon families and from Las breus families as well student registration we have to get the portal up ready to go because those families are going to have to start registering their students come winter and spring so we're going to get that going I don't have it on there but we do have a Kindergarten Roundup date that we have finalized for February that we'll probably hold here at the district office since we won't be able to hold it at zro those types
107of things that all of our schools do each and every year we're going to hit the ground running and do those Personnel planning and Staffing we'll be meeting with HR to talk about what that's going to look like LD the uh excuse me Liberty Elementary School District landing page that is a web page that will be there that will be existing that will have all of the information about how to register what important dates are coming up what do you who do you speak with if we' like to have questions about lettra that would be me so we're going to have all of that on a web page just like we have with the other seven schools and their web pages as well Community meetings will take place both at Las breus and at Blue
108Horizon those will take place this winter in which I will get up I will talk about our vision for the school answer any questions that people in the community that might be attending or at as Umbro or might be outside of the community might have questions about should I send my child here so we will do that we're going to have a community site open house probably on a Saturday morning in very late March or early April where we're going to invite the commity to come out again it won't be in finished product but we'll be able to have the community to come out answer their questions I plan on pounding the pavement very very um extensively I'm going to walk those streets walk those new neighborhoods and say you may not know me but
109I'm going to be the new principal of this school can I answer any questions that you have what are some things you would like to see in your school what are some things that you would like to avoid and get some feedback from our stakeholders that is the most important thing I have never designed a new school I have never opened a new school I going to rely on what people are asking for in a new school and what they're looking for and take that back so that we can make this an experience that they're going to send their children for for many many years so thank you for letting me provide a very brief synopsis of where we're at I am hopeful with Dr Monroe's permission that I can do this every couple months
110leading up to the grand opening in August of 2025 so that you can be aware every step of the way where we're at and I'd be happy to answer any questions that anybody has vice president Kenyan just thank you that's a good um good update and I look forward to seeing what's going on in there and I'm glad you're uh surveying the teachers the kids the staff everybody the the stakeholders around the area that it's very important so thank you thank you Mr keny member Bixler member simman you know I really loved when you said that you were going to knock on doors I think that is a great way to engage the community that um I think as we'll talk about later you know we didn't have any parents come to talk about the
111boundaries and so I think finding new ways to reach out to parents and really meet them where they are is absolutely critical so I love that you said that um I think that's very valuable so I really appreciate your commitment to doing that um I think as we start to think about a signature program which you know uh Loretta zumbra will absolutely need one you know I think it's an interesting concept to kind of consider a traditional model because um I think there's been some push back about you know implementing it through across the district but if we kind of almost test Market it at a school my concern is though that we have the data to back up that that's what parents want um because uh as we'll talk about later with the boundaries
112you know we're going to be opening it small we're not going to be at capacity not near capacity and so if we allow people to continue on open enrollment and they stay at blue because they're not in support of a traditional model like it's it's concerning to me as a board member that we're not using our capacity uh appropriately I guess and so I would just really encourage the district um to really truly seek that parent input um and make sure that's what parents truly want um because I think it's important that we focus on the students that we have in our district that are zoned for our boundaries versus trying to necessarily attract students from outside the boundaries I think yes that's great if we're able to do that in the process but I
113think always our students that live within our district should be our number one priority thank you Mrs em thank you I say thank you Mr ninski um I look forward to your leadership in this project and looks like you're off and run it so again great presentation and thank you thank you president Parks thank you so move on to item 6.5 Business Services presentation Dane Balden president Parks vice president Kenyan members of the board uh this is where I get the opportunity to brag about the business services department and the great things that they do every day as soon as we get our part point up there awesome so um our job in the business services department is to optimize budget allocation enhance fiscal responsibility and increase funding sources to ensure all students receive a
114high quality education and this is coming directly from our strategic plan there it is all right so meet our team so Crystal is the the accountant notice I put the before it she's awesome she does everything cash reconciliations po she's just she's amazing and then we got Lupita Harper who's the new lead she took over for Addison and Jackie is the new payroll specialist um and then on the upper right hand side you'll see Caitlyn she's grants everything um so and then Cassie also does a really great job of paying the bills so if you need a bill paid she's the one to go see uh Megan K Kennan is our procurement specialist uh she's been here for 6 months but I think she's going on six years she's her wealth knowledge is just amazing
115I learn from her every day um and then Mandy is our warehouse supervisor and she loves delivering packages uh so Santa Claus has nothing on Mandy so she does a really really good job all right so on our web page if you take a look at it we got some great information on there um we got our average teacher salary so in fiscal year 25 it was 60,000 and FY 24 it's 58,4 69 so a difference of about 1170 or 2% and then we also have some information on financial transparency so we have our Acer up there which is our annual comprehensive financial report and so we have that every year our Auditors heinfeld and meech come in and they just left a couple weeks ago and we actually just received our draft Acer for
116FY 24 um on our website we also have our budgets so we have our proposed our adopted and our revised budgets we have our AFR which is our annual financial report and then we also put Financial recognitions up there that we receive so from gfoa we get a certificate of achievement and then from asbo International we get a certificate of excellence every year and then you'll also see the Liberty Elementary District spending report some AC accomplishments that we've uh had so far so since started in July uh we gone through a performance audit so Crystal has really been doing a great job on this since we started last March um so thank you for all her hard work on that um the annual audit for heinfeld meech we just like I said they were here
117a couple weeks ago and we've already um completed that we've got our strategic goals cash handling so we implemented lumus truck so they were before cash was being brought here to the district from the sites so now we're and then we were counting it and depositing it but we're like why are we counting money two times it doesn't really make any C so now we're just having lumus trucks go and pick up um pick up the money directly from the sites so that's increasing our cash handling um we're doing internal audits uh We've implemented monthly office manager meetings where we have the month office managers come monthly to the district office and we just talk to them about things that they have going on um and then we also have budget meetings with the principles
118where we look at say hey what's your M budget what is your capital budget here's what you started with here's the PO that you have open and here's your encumbrances and here's your ending budget um so that's been nice as well um so far we have 1,84 purchase orders open um so we're about halfway through the year so great job great great Testament to Megan she's doing excellent work uh and we've paid 2,187 invoices so like I said when I say Cassie loves paying invoices she really does so that'll probably double um since we're only halfway through the year um we have 11 payrolls process um over $9 million paid in payroll and they've all been paid on time very close to Breaking that streak this past payroll but we kept it alive so we're
119in there we're doing all right and then uh 1.4 million in expenditures and grants here to date so that's Caitlyn she's doing a fantastic job of making sure that we're getting reimbursements and that we're getting expenditures through all the grants that we can and then all of our reconciliations have been completed through October 2024 so again shout out to Crystal she just does a fantastic job making sure that our reconciliations are up to date um and then again we have over 1,000 packages that have been been delivered so shout out to Mandy like I said Santa might try to borrow her but he can't have her so we're just going to going to keep her on her end um School Finance 101 so tax credits and audits went really really well um I just wanted
120to say thank you to everybody who came out and participated in that Miss Bixler thank you for showing up to the tax credits and to uh the the audits classes that we had and for supporting us we really appreciate you so thanks for being there and for giving us some feedback appreciate that um aside from that school Finance 101 revenues I was sick last week and I had to cancel it so we had several community members show up um and they said they're interested in attending so we're going to reschedule that but I didn't get any community members sick but I did get my wife sick so so she's mad at me right now but anyway so we'll go ahead and reschedule that 122 revenue streams okay so slide six so this is so Loretta
121every Tuesday Loretta zumro goes and reads to the students at Blue and she came to me in my office and she said hey can Business Services participate and go read to the students and I'm like why would I want to go read to the students like what does that even mean like and I'm like and I went to Dr Monroe and asked him and he said yeah I think that's a great idea and I'm like okay so then we kind of came up with the schedule and so we were on a rotational basis and so we go and read to the students and I tell you what like it's been one of the most fulfilling things things I've done um it really gets to our why and I just I appreciate her even asking and
122for Dr Monroe allowing us to you know the ability to to do that because I know a lot of superintendents that wouldn't allow allow us to do that so here's a couple pictures of us reading with the students it's just so cool just to like get down there and just hey you know read with them for for five minutes so um it was it's been great it's been great all right this is Blue Horizon so this is a picture that we got from Bruce um basically they or we had a Furniture contractor that was requested a picture so that we could make the furniture at Loretta zumbro look like the furniture at Blue so this is their science lab and of course I was at the Lor zumbo groundbreaking which is really neat to already
123be opening a new school uh or building it or at least paying the bills that for the people who do build the school um ready for just being here for 5 months that's pretty neat and then there's me Secret Service of budgets that's tman row at the uh groundbreaking but you know you got $33 million in instruction so it's it's very very expensive project um and then if you add up all the rest of that between M and O CU it's you know going of for the most part be an empty building so you have to fill it with people you have to fill it with supplies you got to fill it with capital and Chromebooks and things like that and Food Service U equipment so that's going to be another another million bucks so
124you know upwards of $34 million and this is kind of in other duties designed I was volunt told to go to the Volleyball Championships over at Las Pras and it actually was pretty neat again it's one of those things where you're like I don't want to go to that and then you go and you're like this is awesome so it just was cool I took my son uh it's just right down the road and we pretty much walked there and he actually took up volleyball he enjoyed he enjoyed watching it so it was pretty neat and this is close to the last second to last slide here this is where we went to Liberty Elementary and we got to dress up and do preschool trick-or-treating so the preschoolers lined up and went down the way
125and we just handed out candy to them for for trick-or treat so that's all of the business services team so I'll leave it up to the board if they have any questions vice president Kenyon thank you Mr Bren that was a good presentation um I'm glad you're feeling better thank you uh just real quick so revenue streams 101 once you get that ability to reschedule that that would be great um and then especially those last pictures I mean getting to the why it's so great to see admin getting out and you know exposed to these kids because that is that's why we're all here absolutely right that's that's why we're on the board that's why you guys have a job that's that's what we're here for we're here for these kids so thank you so
126much for doing that and I can tell it's made an impact on you and I believe it has on the rest of the your Finance staff and you guys do a great job so thank you and getting creative with uh going out for those grants that's a lot of grant money that you guys bring into the district so thank you appreciate that thank you member Bixler member Zimmerman thank you for the presentation I have no questions at this time thank you thank you Mr Bal I appreciate your time and I love the uh teaching seminars I think we all need that and we could all understand a little more about how budgeting and how Finance happens and school districts as I have found out it is very complicated so thank you for doing that we
127might we really appreciate it and I know the public appreciates it keep thank you all right we'll go to uh 7.1 the governing board update to vice president Kenyon thank you uh Mr President so I don't have a whole lot other than I just want to tell the district they're doing such a great job with all these different um projects with these kids throughout the winter season throughout the holiday season Christmas season we're seeing all sorts of different shows going on throughout the district and it is amazing to watch these little kids um I'm not sure which was more entertaining watching the little kids try to perform at their best and or watching their teachers trying to make them perform at their best in front of their parents and staff and it's just a wonderful
128thing to watch um other than that I just want to wish everybody a Merry Christmas and happy New Year because we won't have a board meeting again until after that so thank you remember BX yeah I do have a report um to describe my feeling of hurt for the loss of something I truly treasure as deeply into my core only begins to give description however I reflect with pride on the positive accomplishments achieved over the last four years successfully returned to inperson instruction instituted a 4-day instructional week opened a new school completing an extensive renovation one of the existing schools began the construction of a new student transportation center and started building L zro Elementary School successfully passed an override replace 13 of our aging diesel bus fleet with 13 new electric vehicles actively managed
129the continuing record Community growth that could have negatively impacted our schools dramatically improved student performance all while receiving recognition for financial Excellence every year my simple presence on the governing board is evidence encouragement and empowerment to the children that are otherwise disenfranchised I am honored to be your servant to the public I leave you with four observations distilled over the four years of my tenure one of the significant factors that prompted me to run for the governing board in 2019 was my recognition of the lack of stability in board membership the power of shared history cannot be overstated with the exit of the longest serving current board member this flaw continues another motivating factor in my decision to pursue a seat on the governing board is being uniquely prepared for membership I am proud to
130say that I am a professional Public School educator I consistently use my voice to advocate for the professional Public School building administrators classroom teachers and instructional support staff I am and will always be unabashedly proud to declare that I am one of you I am the only board member from the previous board with over from the previous board from this current board or from the future board with over 35 years of direct professional Public School experience with the last 18 years specifically dedicated to the observation ass M ment and Improvement of classroom instruction I know how effective teaching looks I have an intimate knowledge of the Arizona standards I have the proven ability to recognize Inspire and support the delivery of an award-winning instructional program that meets the needs of an Ever diversifying student population
131with unique learning needs this will no longer be at the board level the political part party ship partisanship on this board has become palatable the inclusion of Highly inflammatory highly politically partisan rhetoric now a part of the locally penned revision language of policy igd is ample truth but this was further confirmed when the then board vice president stated in defense of the revision language political you bet how is this reflective of the nonpartisan mission of an Arizona Public School Board also a special notice was the use of shared terminology in defense of the revision Language by a quorum number of the then board membership terminology I had never heard before that day this raises alarm as to possible open meeting law violations sadly this is not a singular instance over the past four years finally
132the results of the no November 5th governing board election it is clear that my consistent advocate positivity experience expertise honesty transparency and professionalism and doing what is right for all district stakeholders was a far less consideration than my being a transgendered woman what I say do and vote meant far less than what I wear now is an opportunity to hold up a mirror and ask yourself is this who I want Liberty Elementary School District number 25 to be to my sisters and brothers that truly share the belief in the sanctity of the promise of equal privacy safety and access to a free appropriate public school education for all children I'm sorry that my Val you my very best was not good enough to my sisters and brothers I bid you fairly well Miss camarada can
133you note for the record that Miss Bixler has left yes I did a roll call thank you Miss simmerman uh first I want to just uh wish our um families and staff a happy holidays I hope that you enjoy this break um I especially wish our staff a restful Break um I'm so grateful for the incredible work that you do with our students each and every day um and I hope that you enjoy this time with your families um over the past two weeks I was able to attend Coos and caroling at um estrea Elementary as always miss landash um and Miss McAvoy do an incredible job of highlighting our students and bringing holiday cheer um and it's just a really fun Community event so I appreciate that um I also just wanted to take
134some time to um highlight some of the um uh accomplishments of trimester 1 for our schools um across the district we have our Ela Mastery at 43% which is up from 3% um from last year at the same time and we have m ma across the district at 35% mastered which is up 5% um and certainly you know that's not the level that certainly is the goal but I think that it's important to recognize Improvement and that happened across the district in trimester 1 and I want to make sure that our Tech our teachers feel that recognition um I'd also like to highlight a couple of grade levels across schools that really made significant improvements and um just want to be able to highlight them and recognize them um in ela at em at Australia
135third grade is at 76% Mastery um which is um 21% up 21% from last year and I huge gains um I just want to make sure that I say specifically that I am comparing third graders from last year to current third graders so it's not a cohort um also at Australia fifth grade is at 80% master stream up 5% from last year so obviously they um are appr proven being able to um you know reach students at a high level and then eighth grade at a stray is at 68% which is up 12% from last year at Las prus in third grade they are to 68% which is 20 up 23% from last year and fifth grade at 69% which is up 18% at Rainbow Valley in second grade they are at 51% which is
136an improvement of 27% um and so uh I believe at the last meeting Mrs Schaefer talked about how important it is to acknowledge that growth and for our teachers to feel success so I think it's really important that amount of growth is is uh is to be admired um in math um our we had two schools that increased their school average proficiency um a straya 41% to 52% that's up 10% and Liberty across um their school their school average Mastery in math went from 29 to 40% up 11% um australa third grade again is at 60% up 25% from last year and 7th grade is at 60% which is up 12% from last year uh Freedom at fifth grade is at 49% Mastery which is a 37% Improvement um Los Reus third grade is at
13775% and fourth grade at 64% comparable to last year but again great levels of Mastery um Liberty second grade 62% Mastery up 23% and West our second grade is at 68 % so again um I just want to say as a board member how grateful I am for our teachers who just put in the hard work day in and day out hour after hour and I just want you to feel recognized and appreciated um for all the hard work and it shows in the growth in this District so thank you so [Applause] much thank you Miss zman I appreciate that um I just want to say I get out to a few things things here over the holidays but um you know I'll follow up with Miss Zimmerman and um one of the things that's
138always interesting is Miss Miss landash puts on a heck of a show at uh Australia she does it constantly and you know I I she's she's probably not given the credit that she deserves but she's she's an outstanding uh teacher at Australia so I want to thank her for all the work she did all right move on to uh 8.1 call to the public uh we you'll have three minutes on the clock um we'd like to have you uh state your name and if you're in District or out of district and we'd ask that you address the board and not the audience Please Mr or vice president Kenyan yeah we have a number of them and I apologize if I get your names incorrect you can correct me that's fine uh Katie hi here here
139sorry Hi um my name is Katie H and I am in the district good evening my name is Katie hire I have three children I Pro um one promoted from EMES last year into high school and two currently attending EMES I'm familiar and have had multiple personal experience experences working with Dr Monroe and Dr Mon horn as well as Miss camp and many of governing many of the governing board members I love our EMES Community as well as our district Community I worked on the last successful override knocking doors handing out pamphlets making testimonial videos to be posted online as well as asking friends and neighbors to put signs in their yard while expressing from my heart the importance of what the money will do for our kids and our teachers this is not my
140comfort zone the importance of the issues as well as the firsthand experience on campus drives me to be a doer to do everything in my power to make a difference in October I noticed some issues with teachers on our campus being worried about what next year would look like if they could stay at EMS or if they would have to find new schools to work at this was a surprise to me I volunteered daily on campus and couldn't think of any reason people would be unhappy I heard rumors of Mrs Boris being pushed out my husband and I attended coffee with the superintendent and expressed Our concern we were told that changes happen but there wasn't a concern for EMES Dr Monroe assured us there were no personal grudges moving to two weeks ago the
141concerns from teachers are stronger than ever and when I see Dr Monroe on campus I asked him about it I offered to have a phone call to discuss my concerns or a meeting I expressed my concerns again and asked if advocating for the teachers and Mrs worris with an email or making comment a governing board meeting would make a difference and he said no I asked if there's anything I could do to make a difference and he said no no I found out that Mrs Boris had been offered a job at the Loretta zumbra school I find that a huge compliment that she would be offered that position what a huge undertaking Mrs Boris made the decision to stay at Ames in return in return Dr wro no longer sees her as part of his
142vision why would you break something that is working so well we have fantastic teachers who come back each year many with their own children in attendance our students are thriving they feel safe we received another a rating the community on our campus is healthy and coming back strong after struggles of covid Dr Monroe mentioned to me evaluations and performance for reasons Mrs Boris might not come back how would that be a concern when you asked her to open the Loretta zombro school I reached out to president parks and he said he would do whatever Dr Monroe recommended how how are we going to get voters to pass on overrides or Bond when the district isn't caring about its teachers principles or voters I can't ask those around me to support something don't feel good about
143I know from working with you Dr Monroe that you do care about our schools you care about every school in this District I know from talking to you pleas this is our community this is my home where I live please don't root sorry ma'am your time's up next speaker is Suzanne McAvoy um my name is Suzanne McAvoy and I do live in District I am speaking to you as a concerned constituent and a parent regarding the recent uh discussions about changes in leadership at Australia Mountain Elementary since Miss Lindsay Boris took over EMS we have been in a-rated school three years in a row a feat we hadn't achieved since 2011 student performance continues to rise I am alarmed by the notion that there could be shift in direction that may threaten the progress what
144spec we still have not been told what specific changes are being considered how they align with the mission of fostering student achievement removing Miss bores would inevitably lead to the loss of talented qualified teachers who have fostered a nurturing environment where students feel safe and love this is critical for Learning and Development I urge you to consider how this decision will alienate the majority of the constituents have who have come to trust and support Mrs boris's leadership as we approach decisions regarding the upcoming Bond and override renewal renewal it is vital to maintain that our community our community's trust and connection to our schools losing support can have dire consequences such as uh particularly impacting essential programs such as art music PE and reading interventions all of those positions are paid for by the override
145if Miss Boris does not return you will lose the support of the australa community which will lead to a loss of the override renewal which will have a crippling impact on our kids you can look at the data you cannot win an override or a bond without this community up the hill without effective reading interventionists and the support of special teachers our students RIS transitioning from a well-rounded education to one that is significantly watered down it's crucial that we work together to ensure that every child has access to a quality education they deserve which includes diverse learning opportunities and tailor support I implore you to do what is right for the students the teachers and the community supporting the of Miss boris's contract is crucial to maintaining our high standards we have worked so dig
146digly vigilantly to achieve at Australia our next speaker is Miss Carrie Jones good evening my name is Carrie Jones I reside outside the district boundaries but as a former Liberty administrator teacher and parent I make the drive to show up for its staff and students that I still care about as it is more than obvious that your decision regarding Miss borus was unwise at best I will leave addressing that to my colleagues and EMS families I want to begin by thanking board member Bixler for the years of service on this board I appreciate all that you did greatly I've missed to meting so welcome Mrs Zimmerman Mr Kenyan and Mr cerron wherever you are listening you are back for additional terms Mr cerron you have yet to establish a reputation and there is still time
147for you to earn the respect of your constituents both of you are smart enough men to do the math and to see that those who voted clearly and strongly showed their preference for new leadership on this board the vast amount of votes separating Miss Zimmerman from the two of you and the large amount of votes separating M Schmid from Mr Todd must send you the message that you have to do better to earn the trust and votes of people in the future Mr Kenyan on your profile you say that you are a devout Christian and I call on you as a fellow believer to please choose integrity and honor above all else when you make your decisions please do not be swayed by anything other than grace and truth Mr Parks I want to thank
148you for deleting the false claims within your District board profile that previously stated you graduated from University from which you had only done a brief certificate program honesty and transparency is truly what we all desire so your action on making this more truthful is appreci app you've also unfortunately stated that you would ensure that all district funds necessary will be allocated to putting qualified staff on campuses for children with you not voting for any further administrative positions until that takes place unfortunately you approved several administrative positions while we still have underqualified and understaffed positions in our campuses this board changed public comment months ago claiming at the time that it was being done to ensure that everyone had more time to speak um as they were allowed to comment on multiple agenda items if this
149was the truth at that time that it was done to allow more voice why have you now taken that away and put it back at the beginning again we have a dichotomy in your words and in your actions math is something we've talked about a lot so here's an interesting math fact there are 58 school districts in Maricopa County the vast majority of them are represented with Facebook accounts do you know how many of these districts have taken away the ability for their Community to interact via comment one the Liberty Elementary School District in Bucky Arizona is the only District in Maricopa County that prohibits their community from commenting on district and school Pages School Board please direct your superintendent to have true transparency which allows for interaction questions praises and participation those who stand
150at this Podium to praise you come without data evidence or examples they're few and they stand here and say you are great doing great they're allowed to speak and slander without your redirection at stop again please do better we have numbers and we will continue to present them truth will surface next speaker is Heather Hedges heus I'm glad you guys all know each other good evening everyone my name is Heather hegedus I am an esta Mountain Ranch Community member and the fifth grade ELA and social studies teacher at estray Mountain I I am also the international baloria primary years program coordinator I work with the K5 Team Planning and updating units reflecting on them and communicating needs and strengths having a principal with an IB background is invaluable to me Mrs Boris and I reflect
151and improve on our action plan for the pyp program to help ensure we offer the best IB experience for our students I would be unable to do what I do without Mrs boris's IB knowledge the IB Program takes a lot of work but we do it because our mission at Australia is we do what is best for kids three years ago Australia received an a rating from the state of Arizona Mrs Boris celebrated the achievement with our staff and told us we needed to work hard so we could do it again the next year not because of the rating but because we do what is best for kids the following year we earned an a rating from the state again miss Boris told us how proud she was of us and we celebrated the achievement
152she then told us we have work to do that she was confident that we could earn an a rating again because we do what is best for kids this past year australa earned an a rating for the third year in a row this remarkable achievement is due to the hard work by the australa staff we know we are supported and that Mrs Boris believes we can do great things we don't do this for the recognition we do this because we do what is best for kids we are a family at australa we lift each other up encourage each other and rise to meet challenges together we do this because we know the head of our family Mrs Boris believes in us and supports us Australia is successful and high achieving because of Mrs Boris Mrs
153Boris thank you for all you do we love you and we support you thank you next speaker is stormy Garner good evening my name is stormy Garner I'm a resident of Australia Mountain Ranch a second grade teacher at Australia Mountain Elementary and a proud mom of a third and fifth grader who love our school and have had nothing but positive experiences at EMES I also grew up in this District attending Liberty school from kindergarten through 8th grade this community has shaped my life in profound ways and I'm deeply invested in its success at the start of this school year Dr Monroe you shared a photo of your family and you emphasized how they are your why family is at the heart of what we do at AAL austalia too our school is more than just
154a workplace it's where we bring our families build lasting connections and create a thriving Community 20 plus teachers at Australia have personal ties here either alumni or current residents and we share a deep pride in our school at the head of this family is our principal Mrs Boris she has been a Corner Stone of this campus for six years fostering a positive supportive work environment that encourages staff and students alike to flourish as a parent I saw this firsthand and it's what inspired ired me to become a full-time teacher at EMES Mrs Boris is the reason many of us stay her leadership is unparalleled and her commitment to our students is unwavering and now we find ourselves asking who is listening to the voices of this community when we ask Dr Monroe we're told that
155the board drives decisions when we ask the board we're told that the decisions are left to Dr Monroe where is the accountability our petition has almost 2,000 signatures our community is speaking loud and clear who will be our voice Dr Monroe I've heard that you have a vision for our school but I ask what Vision could possibly be better than the one that we have under the under Mrs boris' leadership removing her would devastate our school our staff and most importantly our students I urge you to think about your own family and how you would feel if it were torn apart please do not tear ours apart thank you our next speaker is Mark aguire my name is Mark aguire I'm a resident within the district just go ahead and start US Supreme Court ruled
156back in 19 1984 that once an agency does agree to accept public comment however the commenting system cannot be operated in a discriminatory or Viewpoint restrictive way with that said the lady who walked out here um Miss Bixler that's what leadership looks like two of you board members you sit here and you talk and you talk and you talk and that's all you do you have no idea what leadership looks like in fact that leader you emailed and demanded that she set down because of the way that she of the way that she dressed and yet you call yourself a Christian my savior My Savior loved everybody how about your savior just the ones that dress like boys or just the ones that dress like women the white ones all of them I see that
157you have the scenarios for the for the boundaries it's truly unfortunate that you the superintendent the CEO of the district District did not listen to the previous CEO of the district and simply do your job and go negotiate with the developer that one move that you did not do cost taxpayers of the state because this school is funded with sfb money millions of dollars because a lot of people don't realize it wasn't supposed to go where it is now the farm family who I'm friends with they really appreciate it they really appreciate it and lastly to the employees or should I say to the leadership here what happens when your staff realizes that they are the ones who have the power because they showed this State what true power looks like in the red [Music]
158fored you will never have a bond passed again you will never have a override renewed with this current leadership mark my words it will never happen thank you next speaker Peter Smith my name is Peter Smith and my children go to a Mountain Elementary we live in the district I like EMS it's been a fantastic place for my children to learn and develop that's because EMS has a staff focused on their own professional Improvement student growth and well-being and that culture is a direct result of the leadership of Mrs Boris you were warned in October not to move or end the employment of our principles Parks then made a clear attempt at that October meeting to create a narrative that he appreciates Mrs Boris the principal of AA Mountain even though audio of him describing
159his own conversation with Maro had already surfaced online where Park stated that Monroe had better get over there before he killed her referencing Mrs Boris you don't get it both ways you either appreciate her or you want to kill her as with most politicians what they say in private when they don't think there will be consequences is what's true then we have Mrs Boris not receiving a contract for the next school year after having turned down an offered to run the new school so she's good enough to run your Flagship school but not good enough to be kept at a elementary once again you don't get it both ways here's what I think you all are trying to do with your little game political Go Fish Parks has it out for her and doesn't want
160her at Ems for some reason the hope was that by moving her to a new school you'd sever her parents support structure within the district so that later you could non-renew her contract for the next year without much fuss from us the parents well I'm here to tell you there's going to be fuss we will not stand by while you turn a stray Mountain into a poorly run Fight Club like the other campuses are turning into under the board majority and Monroe's guidance as the current superintendent if Mrs Boris does not receive a contract for the principal position of a stray mountain with pay and benefits consist consistent with her current contract and reflecting any pay increases the other principles receive I will be walking and knocking to line up support against the entire board
161majority block that can start in January or it can start in July based on how many angry people are here I don't think I'll be alone next speaker we have April Smith hi I'm April Smith uh I do live in the boundaries uh and I am a parent and a small business owner I'm here tonight because I'm deeply concerned about the actions of Dr Monroe and the treatment of Mrs Boris our principal at EST Mountain Elementary when I learned that Dr Monroe privately told Mrs Boris that she would be placed on the non-renewal list and would not receive a positive recommendation unless she resigned on her own I was outraged this is not how we treat an effective and beloved leader in our schools yet this is is how many of our leaders have been
162pushed out since Monroe was hired I recently received Natasha Camp's letter of resignation despite the district blocking my freedom of information request for it it confirms that her resignation was not her choice either according to the district website her position is not being filled until next school year this means that for the rest of the year there was no one at the district office to support our academic programs or address student concerns in response to the news that Dr Monro is trying to push out Mrs Boris I start a petition supporting her desire to continue as the principal at AA Mountain Elementary with Just 4 hours over a thousand people signed it today today we have 1,879 signatures with 70% which is about 1300 coming from within our district boundaries these are not just a
163few outliers as Mr Parks has suggested these are concerned parents teachers and community members who are demanding accountability the remaining 30% of signatures come from staff and family members who are equally alarmed by what is happening in our schools if this board continues to support Dr Monroe as he pushes out exceptional staff members like Mrs Boris it sends a clear message you do not stand for parents rights or for the stability and success for our schools this is not an isolated incident Dr Monroe has a history of this kind of behavior during his time in Cave Creek he employed similar tactics a former highlevel administrator for with over 20 years of experience revealed that Dr Monroe eliminated entire departments under the guise of saving money only to rehire his own staff for higher salaries he
164non-renewed administrator's contract and then replace the position with two people costing even more money in just 19 days he told an entire department of 17 people in Cave Creek they would not have contracts the following year five of eight schools in the district were placed under new leadership this is all public knowledge if you Google it from the news articles that were written there's over 42 news articles about Dr Monroe The Cave Creek District lost almost 300 students in the 2021 2022 school year and according to reports from the Department of Education less than 50% of students residing in Cave Creek attended those schools this is already happening here Cave Creek parents even reached out to our board before he was hired warning against his appointment These Warnings were ignored and our now our district
165is facing the same pattern of instability and mistrust the board's decision to hire and retain Dr Monroe despite his track record and to quietly Force our highly qualified staff like Mrs Boris out is unacceptable if you truly value the voice of parents teachers and students you would not be allowing this to happen Mrs Boris has proven herself to be a leader who cares deeply about her students staff and our community her work speaks for itself and she has the full support of our community time's up next speaker we have Aaron Johnson my name is Aaron Johnson and I am a member of the community in the district and with that I'd like to thank you for this opportunity to speak before you um I stand before you as someone who believes in what I am
166doing uh and what my family is doing what do I mean by that my family well my wife and I are both teachers we both live in a stray Mountain we both work there and guess what our kids go to school there I take that back my son he will go to school there next year my daughter goes to school there now what an awesome Legacy I mean I have the privilege of even having some of the board members and your students in my classroom Mr cion is not here tonight Joseph cion Mrs IM Connor Aiden Mr Parks Matthew Joseph all wonderful kids been a prev privilege to get to know them and to have them in my classroom but on that how many other teachers are here tonight with that same Legacy how many
167other teachers live in work at and send their own kids to this school I guess you could say we're all in and on that level it's not like when we leave for work we're really going anywhere because we're just going to an extension of our home so I stand in front of you just to mention my support for the community that we've developed at Australia which in large part is to do with Lindsay Boris I believe that the school that we work at MIRS the core District values respect Integrity accountability high standards and student centered after else after all why else would we send our kids there if we didn't believe that uh in midst of all the political Strife in this world I just feel like it needs to be said that this is
168not a a political issue it's not a republican Democrat issue we're just trying to maintain a well oiled machine again i' just like to thank the leadership uh of Mrs Boris this helped to make austr Mountain an awesome a-rated and ascending public school and I hope that she's given the opportunity to extend her career as the principal of ARR Mountain Elementary as she has made clear she would like to thank you for this opportunity to you know uh I know it's hard work being up here and I appreciate all that you do thank you next speaker is Holly B hello my name is Holly B and my husband and I bring our children outside of this District I am here tonight as a very concerned parent and volunteer at EMES to express my dismay over
169the non-renewal of do of our principal Miss Boris to say this is a tragedy would be an understatement I have been lucky to volunteer in private Catholic and Public Schools over the years and never have I come across a more positive productive and nurturing School Community this 100% starts from the top with Mrs Boris she has the admiration of her peers the respect of her school parents and the love of her students even those younger siblings that haven't quite entered Kinder yet miss Boris Works tirelessly to make more with less both money and FTE her staff is dedicated and willing to go the extra miles necessary because they feel valued and appreciated and you've seen the data that backs up her students performance an a-rated school three years running is no easy feat you've also
170received the data compiled by Dr Ashley King which clearly lays out the negative toll a principal change would take on our children in every way that matters safety security test scores teacher turnover and absenteeism not to mention the monetary cost which is significant to say the least I implore you you to rethink your decision our kids deserve the absolute best school Community they can get and that only happens with Miss Boris as their principal thank you next speaker is Amanda Herrera hello good evening my name is Amanda Herrera um I'm here as a parent and a teacher at estrea Mountain Elementary I've had three children go through our school district my oldest is 30 years old my youngest is 17 my youngest child and I started at estr Mountain Elementary the same year and again
171he's now a junior in high school um this is my 11th year teaching at asraa Mountain Elementary for the last six years we have become a very tight family unit under the amazing leadership of Lindsay Boris Miss Boris has a creative an environment of mutual respect care and consideration at estrea Mountain between the leadership the staff and of course the students because of her efforts estria is consistently one of the highest performing schools in this District as a seventh grade math teacher I am consistently one of the highest performing teachers in this district and have Tau many of your students in fact last year on the aasa state test 95% of my students showed significant growth that is amazing that is so rare I achieved it thanks to the leadership of Miss Boris I'm also
172one of the small handful of remaining highly qualified Middle School Math teachers that our district has left with our District's current focus on customer service and business no successful business would risk losing any of their best employees this is what Miss Boris is she is one of your best employees we to straya Mountain beg of you do not tear our family apart doing so has the potential to destroy all of the progress we have worked so hard for it would have long lasting negative effects on our district our school of australa mountain and of worst of all our students there's a risk of losing amazing teachers and staff if you take our leader away from us we are all in this business for children our only goal should be what is best for children and
173at esta Mountain Elementary Miss Boris is what is best for children thank you we have Camden and Crystal Lea good evening everyone my name is Cam Lord you go good evening everyone my name is Camden Lea and I'm a sixth grade student at EMS in my opinion I don't think Miss Boris should stop being our principal I think Mrs Boris has had an amazing influence on our campus and the students whenever I first came to Yia she made me feel welcome and wanted she checked up on me to make sure that I was fitting in and if I was having a good experience something I noticed from my experience in other new kids is she not only did this for me but she did it for everybody that's one reason why I think she should
174stay Em's principal another reason is she's always finding a new way to make our campus better if it's a fundraiser or more teacher she's always finding a way to make it better also she treats all kids equally it doesn't matter if it's a good kid or a bad kid she will always see every way for us to improve an example is I remember in School in second or third grade she let the older kids Mentor us they helped us learn different Char characteristics they helped us learn to be caring even if we didn't want to be Mrs Boris did that for us because she cares she cares about our Improvement she cares about our growth she's always finding ways for us to be proud of ourselves each other and our campus also she always rewards
175us for hard work like The Color Run fundraiser and the Harkens fundraiser we would help the school out and then be would give rewarded for helping her school she so she would not only reward us for hard work she would show she showed us what hard work pays off for that's why Mrs Boris is not only a good principal she's a good Mentor for us that's why I believe Mrs Bor should stay Em's principal thank you for your time I'm Crystal Lea this is my daughter and we attend uh myia Mountain Elementary School throughout the last four years I have seen the growth and development of school I have brought behavioral and academic challenges to Mrs Boris all of which she has been fully receptive to and provided support and guidance for I believe that
176the district and board should be supporting the positive momentum that she has produced the data shared with the board by Dr King highlighted all of the areas of growth and Excellence at EMS Mrs Boris should receive a contract for the next school year for EMS next speaker is Suzanne wolf Walt I'm Suzanne wal I live in the district about a mile from Australia since about 2007 I've served as the Community member of site Council knocked on doors for every LD political action committee and led the pack that passed the last Bond in 2019 in 2013 I was a founding member of cougar community volunteers and am the volunteer volunteer coordinator at Australia there's a rumor that the district will not offer a contract to Mrs Boris this spring even though the data on Australia academic
177performance demonstrates that she's a very successful leader and staff and families are very much in favor of keeping her as our principal the quality of misss Boris leadership and management is demonstrated by recent district testing results and by the fact that we are in a school for the third year in a row Ashley King's recent letter to the board cites academic studies from 2018 and 2012 examining the financial cost of replacing a principal and the teachers who would leave with her much more important than those financial costs is the cost and the toll on students and their academic achievement there's a significant negative impact on math achievement for two to four years after a principal leaves the negative impact on reading achievement is significant four to 5 years after the departure of a principal replacing
178a poorly performing principle makes sense replacing an exemplary one like Ms Boris when when we should all be celebrating her outstanding performance and when the stakeholders overwhelmingly want her to stay makes no sense in her letter Ashley King quotes a statement in the community engagement and support section of the board's strategic planning update from October 7th it says the district benefits from a highly engaged Community with active participation from parents volunteers and local leaders however there's a need to address Community mistrust and improve communication to fully harness this support Ashley says when both anecdotal and quantitative data support the retention of a successful principle but the board seeks non-renewal Community distrust of the governing board is essentially guaranteed well said Ashley governing board please and Dr R please do not act in ways that guarantee
179Community mistrust next speaker is Ryan Burch hello my name is Ryan Burch I'm in District my children go to school at Westar um I'd like to say uh start by saying thank you to the past and the present board members volunteering your time is no small feat and I do appreciate the board and the time they sacrific away from their families um seems like the theme of the night tonight has been leadership um from the looks of it so far it's been mostly about Mrs Boris displaying great leadership um which creates loyalty I think everybody here has seing what that looks like tonight right unfortunately the subject that I feel I need to bring up tonight to the board is poor leadership the subject uh is basically the public discussion about specific details involving Kaye
180kak's lawsuit against the Liberty School District some context for those who do not know Kaylee is currently a well-known advocate for children's rights and happens to be a name the namesake Behind kayle's law she was assaulted by a soccer coach within the Liberty School District when she was 12 years old that assault happened many years ago but nonetheless it happened despite the president Brian Park's board position he inappropriately discussed the details of this case in a very public setting now I would like to everyone to keep two things in mind all of this conversation was recorded there is record of this and the other thing to keep in mind is that he is representing the Liberty School District by doing this the Liberty Elementary School District right um when he's doing these things now he
181made disturbing comments including blaming the victim's parents making light of the situation um direct quotes where the parents are accountable for most of this exploitive that I won't say here today uh furthermore Brian Parks downplayed the severity of the situation saying saying seems like a little Overkill that she's in a lawsuit there wasn't even penetration not once did he discuss how the coach's actions were abhorent not one time did he put any blame on the coach whatsoever now I'm concerned Why president parks would publicly discuss and shame Kaye and her parents this way especially while representing the Liberty school board but excuse me I am concerned the board would try to push out a 30-year public educator with all that experience off the board like President parks and others tried to do with Bixler superintendent
182Monroe believe you have four daughters of your own I'm not sure how you would feel if someone if something happened to one of them and then someone was trying to downplay that I'm sure you wouldn't like it very much and I doubt you'd want them to be the president of your child's School Board um I urge the board to understand this is a problem these narcissistic Tendencies have no place anywhere near the decisions that affect our children and representing in V the voters and the parents of this district is a privilege unfortunately Mr Parks I do believe you Unworthy of this privilege these actions are unacceptable and I urge president parks to take respons posibility for his words and actions and I personally believe the only suitable option is resignation thank you next speaker is
183going to be Mike lion good evening president Parks could I address the audience on a non-confrontational issue it happens to do with Bixler I'm sure you do may I just say one thing that I would encourage people to look at his history and the Liberty School District to learn a little bit more about him who he is that's all I was gonna say so I won't go in anymore um uh my name is Mike lion I live in the district I'm a lifetime Ka teacher and uh I spent 24 years in the Navy as well um I believe that leadership starts at the top and uh I think you're the top something that uh Mr Balton brought up just just caught my ear because I was a chief negotiator on our school Union back in
184Wisconsin and the number that you threw out unless I misunderstood it was the teachers would be getting a 2% pay raise and Mr Parks I think you know that the CPI is running between four and six and if you want to retain teachers they're not even keeping up with the day they started the district so I would ask that you maybe consider a little bit more than a 2% pay raise um otherwise I think the door is gonna you're not going to need to fire people because they're going to be walking out of here um uh Mr Kenyan you're a pastor and I would ask that you somebody else Mar this up too that you consider pastoring your teachers um because I think they need a little help at this stage it seems to be
185going the winds are all blowing against them and then I'm not going to talk my three minutes the the last thing I noticed was there's a saying that goes if it isn't broken don't fix it and I think we're trying to fix things that don't need fixing and I will relinquish the rest of my time next speaker is Ashley Wright my name is Ashley Wright and I do reside within the district I'm a parent volunteer at estria it's no secret how I feel about Miss Boris I've spent the last two months up here telling everyone who would listen how I believe no better there's no better principle for Australia that she truly cares for not only her staff and students but their families as well she's proven time and time again that she's not just
186highly qualified for position but Irreplaceable there are many parents like myself that bring their children to Australia for not only Mrs Boris but also the highly qualified team she's assembled at Australia her staff not only holds the average for most years in the district but also the most years in teaching that's a true Testament to miss boris's leadership after all when you're looking for advice look to the experts knowing how many veteran teachers and children of teachers and administrators from other schools and board members have their children at australa I feel like I'm in the right place the district would like because to believe that the unhappy teachers who have resigned that's 13 for those of you that are counting are making way for new highly qualified teachers in the district if that were true
187we wouldn't have 17 teachers in the district on emergency certification while it has been said that we have a certified teacher in every classroom they have failed to made the distinction between a certified teacher and a highly qualified one according to the Arizona Department of Education website emergency certificates may be issued at the request of a district or Charter School Superintendent when an emergency employment situation exists if highly qualified teachers are beating down the door to come to this District why will we be able to qualify for emergency certification don't get me wrong these people are true gifts to the district willing to step up when we need the most while I would never underestimate their passion for teaching this is why why is extremely important to surround yourself with both highly qualified supportive principles
188and Veteran teachers without Miss Boris said a stray I'm afraid we going to lose many of those veteran teachers I know many families will look elsewhere even going back to their home districts president parks and board memb cion wherever you're watching from please let our children continue to enjoy the qualified leadership and positive learning experience that your children have both benefited from please don't cost a district more money and our students their progress by not renewing Mrs Boris recognize the amazing work that she and her staff are doing and will continue to do by offering her her a new contract it is not only the right thing to do for our students but it's also the best business decision for the district as a whole next speaker is Carly Wright hi there my name is
189Carly Wright and I do live in the district um so I'm actually speaking on behalf of someone because she cannot make it she's currently in a basketball game at efhs so this is her letter dear board members District administration School staff community members my name is Lily hire I apologize for not being here in purm currently playing in my freshman and JV basketball games for St Foot Hills High School wrote this letter so that I could still convey my message just through different means which is why I asked my friend Karly Wright to read it for me I'm a nth grader at efhs and I recently graduated from Australia Mountain Elementary School during my eighth grade year I was lucky to hold the positions of president of the student council njhs member basketball MVP soccer
190MVP and band member since my graduation I have assistant coached the boys volleyball team for em EMES I've spent roughly 5 Years miss borers and I've witnessed firsthand her effect on her students and the strong bond she's built with them she worked hard to build a relationship with me and my brothers during my time at EMES I felt safe and seen and I knew I was in a place where I could succeed pulling Mrs Boris away from her school will not give the new school the magic she has at EMS so sorry because her magic trust and respect has to be carefully cultivated something that she spent years doing at EMES those are values I've learned during my time in the Liberty School District I love our district and I'm extremely grateful to have our
191who for our hardworking staff teachers PTO and board members I'm very proud of all that we have done here and I'm sure that we will accomplish in the future I would like the board and superintendent please reconsider keeping Miss Boris at EMES I wish for the current students and all the students that have yet to attend EMES to be educated with the same nurturing and safe environment that I was thank you very much for your time Lily hire I would also like to add on my behalf Miss Boris doesn't just touch students and parents but she also touches people who she doesn't even work with my amazing band director um allowed me to come here and Skip an event cuz he knows how important Miss Boris is and how important she is for this district
192and he gave me the opportunity cuz he knows just how much we I love her we love her everybody loves her thank you for next speaker is Paul Jensen good morning I'm Paul Jensen I live within the district I'd like to start by recognizing Paul Bixler and commend her for her four years of service I don't think there is a board member in Arizona that has taken more harsh criticism than Paul Bixler she joined the board knowing that many people would misunderstand her for who she was but also knew that she could bring a wealth of knowledge passion and education passion for education and desire to help every student through public education Mrs Bixler has demonstrated her commitment by taking unfounded harsh criticism for who she is not what she believes and is doing for
193public education we only spent one year together on the board but I was able to see firsthand how much she really cares about educating students when going to the ASB events she frequently had students she had taught decades ago come up to her and share how they had how she had impacted their lives and what good they had brought to her to them Miss Bixler I hope you will be able to look back on your service on the board knowing that you tried your best to do good and we all appreciate your service I am proud to have served with you and want to make sure everyone knows what a great person you are I'm also truly grateful for all the hard work work that Natasha Camp has put into this District she has been
194with this district for a long time and devoted a lot of her time and dedication to make it what it was we were in a big mess when she came to the district and she helped us pull out of that and rebuild Liberty into what unfortunately it appears this board is trying to destroy if the board could see past whatever issues that have Arisen to cause her to leave you would have have a valuable asset to help rebuild Liberty thank you very much Miss camp for all the work you have put into your job and all the great things you have done I truly hope you are able to find another District that can challenge you and bring you the joy and love I know you feel for Liberty you are truly a great leader
195and I'm grateful for all that you have done for us we will always fondly remember the Natasha Camp stool under the podium now uh for my thoughts on Miss Boris in business high-profile people are let go to send a signal and others are attained to show what type of employee you want looking at Mrs boris's accomplishments it appears that kindness High student performance a community that loves you and a dedication to the district is not of value while I know this is not true please be clear for your reasons for allowing her to leave so that other Prin principles will know what you are really letting her leave for otherwise the they will be confused as to what they need to change and us as a community sorry Mr Jensen your time's up next is
196Keith Johnson hello my name is Keith John son I do live in the district I come to me from a guess a different Avenue in the fact of that I am a sixth seventh grade ELA teacher this is my first year and I'm having a wonderful year it's been great um I appreciate the uh certificates that I have received from this board uh in recognition of the accomplishments of my students uh even the little dumb dumb suckers okay they love those uh but I'm thanking you for that three years ago I re retired I was able to retire a little early uh from a corporate uh work world uh I come from Learning and Development uh that's going to come up again uh in that learning development uh had the ability to travel go different
197places meet a lot of individuals do a lot of great things uh that was with big companies like with Amazon chewy so it's it's been a it was a great ride uh but in that uh I actually encountered some individuals who uh adults who acted like children and I thought you know what I've got the opportunity now is my time to just go ahead and move to the side uh live the good life here in Arizona play a little Golf and just ride my motorcycle do a little fishing and just enjoy life I decided to do some substitute teaching just to keep me busy well little did I know that a uh Miss Boris came out and met me at the uh recess field and she leaned towards me and said would you consider this
198is on my first substitute job assignment okay my first one and she asked me if I'd be willing to take on a shortterm long-term position sure I'll do that that went well got a chance to go out and see some other uh schools after that shortterm longterm was over then she came to me with a I got a longterm short-term position for you that teacher's coming back from her leave so we just need you for a while until she makes it back and I thought well I'll do that so I did it you know what happened the teacher didn't come back and she asked me would I be willing to do this full time and I'm like that's not what I signed up for but because of everything that I was able to do and
199able to uh I really enjoy it uh I said yes so this is my first full year of doing this and truly what I can tell you is within Learning and Development I am doing the greatest learning and develop because of Miss Boris she came to me asked me to do it I'm willing to do it and it's just been a wonderful ride and I don't want that to end she brings a lot of great uh just everything uh to the table she found something in me I've even had some students asking me to uh teach forever and ever and ever I'm saying I don't know if I can do that but I truly found my why and when I mentioned I was in Learning and Development I I'm doing the greatest learning development now
200sorry Mr Johnson your time's up next speaker is Jenna Williams congratulate Kelly Zimmerman for her position on the board and I would also like to thank Mr uh Paul Bixler for her service and she will be greatly missed the next that I have is I would like everybody here to just listen to what has to be said guys I don't know you know these parents are idiots where the we run School dist because we don't like it go find somewhere else to learn so and I looked at him and I said look I'm just going to make this simple for you we're in conference said There Eyes got this big I said you retire this year or you will be publicly humiliated and he just looked at me and goes you can't do that I
201said watch me you guys I don't know you know the these parents are idiots I've been asked by the mcrc couple very powerful republ reference State s 26 the education education we run you know I go find somewhere elsewh so guys I don't know you know these parents are idiots you know we've slowly like since we since we changed the um superintendent um and had control of the board um 62 teachers on our list as did you know did you did you know a lot of the bad ones are disappearing right and you have to do it kind of very selectively I can't pull them out of all one school but I'm moving them too right you know what I have to leave I laughed in court I called court and I said dude you
202need to go down there and take care of this because I'm a killer and you know the thing is for me I'm you know one of the top officials in the school district I have to maintain a certain amount of professionalism no matter what guys I don't know you know these parents are idiots like what I did what we put forward you know look this displine policies for Teacher than kids that's what I had to say you're Zero Tolerance too you up you're out of here you know So merel's Gone we're g to get rid of she I'm done I'm done yeah we're done with it so like in part of some swingers swing that was some of the comments made by Brian Parks all right your time's up next speaker is Johanna Rodriguez hi
203good evening my name is Joanna Rodriguez I come from out of District as a parent a PTO participant a school registered volunteer and an active member in Liberty School community and that of Goodyear my family and I moved to goodye in 2017 with absolutely nothing in me that wanted to move to this place but yet here I am as my kids grew up and began school it was just in time for wonderful covid that came and rocked everyone's world to say the least now I know like some of you like me were terrified to send our kids to school and like me I know some of you lost ones to co so exposing all of our kids to the unknown was gut-wrenching and terrifying but thanks to my silver lining of my neighbors in the
204outside District they told me about a wonderful school called the Str Mountain Elementary with every bit of hesitation and gut-wrenching but encouragement from them we go out of our way our community goes out of our way to bring our kids to this school and I have not regretted that choice much to say I do still regret moving to good here nonetheless aa's faculty staff and Community was an answer to our family's prayer as I became involved in PTO and also as a volunteer on this camp campus I get to see kindness and action I get to see teachers and the principal take their hours their challenges that the kids bring to them whether it's tossing chairs curse children cursing at them flooding toilets kids being too tired to even go to school the list goes
205on and on and on day in and day out without once have I seen Mrs Boris lose her cool and if we're honest all of us would have lost our cool so kudos to you Mrs Boris and to every teacher in this school and also in this community because I've seen firsthand what you've had to deal with and it's rough and yes kids do need tough love but we start with love not tough so consistency integ Integrity reliable approachable even tempered and even relational are just some of the amazing qualities I see firsthand by Mrs Boris and her staff that follows after her from what I understand of what board members have said they made it crystal clear that you superintendent you are responsible for the decision of not renewing Mrs Boris contract and I
206also understand that you want to take the school into a new or different direction and well if that is a result then my children and I will not be joining you on your new journey and I think there are a lot of parents here who also will agree with me on that I can tell you that from an outside Community we are not in favor of your decision inside the community they're not in favor of your decision so clearly sir you are taking this inappropriate action all on your own or maybe with the help of others that they don't have to necessarily be named we already know so lastly I will say to you board members that you say it's up to him but you take the vote don't just agree to whatever he wants
207you are here to whatever we want not what he wants your times up Mr President that concludes the uh public comment all right we move to we move to item 9.1 the approval of the consent agenda does anybody would anybody like to pull a consent item I'd like to pull something sorry uh I'd like to pull 9.3 okay PLL 9.3 um do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda with the exception of 9.3 I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda with the exception of 9.3 second uh go for the vote Chris or sorry vice president Kenyan I uh Miss imman I I am also an I I'll show that past 30 all right let's move on to 9.3 Miss immerman uh I just want uh you know for transparency purposes there
208are uh two extra Duty uh pay in the total of $487 per day uh for two it um employees and um I just want to say for the record that I it's not that I don't think they are deserving of extra pay but I would just like uh District administration to explain how um that um number was calculated um and if there is a precedent that has been set previously yes I can jump in and Dr Monroe can correct me if I'm misspeaking but we do not uh there's a precedent when Beth strickler left last I believe it was April May maybe March or April when she left um that was done before before we hired DNE in July so we had some months where there was a gap and so we did have one
209person who was filling in and what we did with then and I can say what we did now is we took the lowest um pay for an incoming IT director at the daily rate and we split that between Rob and Loretta and at first we don't do anything we just all jump in if we have a member somebody that's missing and so it's been since uh August September and since it's been months since we've been able to find someone that's why we now are paying Robin to and Loretta to fulfill those duties because we haven't found anyone yet to fill that position okay and so what has been done to try to fill that position it has been posted on asbo aspa our Liberty website it's been posted on indeed it's posted on handshake which
210once it's posted on handshake it posts on about 20 other sites that it automatically posts out it's posted on um NAU website um I can't think it's posted in lots of different places where we try to uh get people Dr Monroe has put it out um through some of his contacts trying to get it out especially since it's a cabinet position to as many different um I've put it out to my West Valley HR people which is about 80 80 people or so so just hey we have this position open if you know anyone that may be interested please have them go to our website and apply yeah um you know I just would really encourage District administration to not force people to resign in the middle of the year and then we wouldn't be
211in this position um because that's what happened here that's what a severance agreement is that's what happened with Beth and now we're in that position with Natasha camp and I have the emails and the receipts to back it up so I just encourage you not to force people out in the middle of the year we wouldn't be having to force people to do extra work all right um we'll move to approve agenda item 9.3 move for a motion I move that we approve 9.3 second go for the vote vice president Kenyon I miss IM I I'm also an NA that passed 30 all right move on to item 10.1 discussion consideration to approve the Strategic plan kpis keep performing indicators miss casano good evening govern sorry good evening governing board members um I am here
212today to discuss the strategic plan we have went through and developed um the goals the Mission Vision and values um do we have the clicker by chance sorry thank you so the purpose of our conversation today is just to review the Strategic plan where we've been um and then look to the approval of the keeper performance indicators so just as a reminder um the strategic planning process has been in the works since about November December of last year it began with the board doing a self- evaluation first the board discovered or went through the self-evaluation process and then developed and approved their person or the goals for the board from there we moved on to Gathering uh Community feedback and feedback from our principles and from our teach teachers the focus of learning as you
213can see here um these indicators not listed in any particular order were what was important to the parents Administration and staff from that we developed the Mission Vision and value statements that you see here and the core values we also conducted an in-depth SWAT analysis strength weaknesses opportunities and threats and some of those findings are here from that process we went through and developed the priority areas and we're able to identify what priority areas that the board and the administration would like to focus on as you can see the instructional services and employee Excellence um along with effective systems safeties and resources family and Community engagement Communications and marketing from that process after we developed those goals the goals were approved in October of last or I'm sorry October of this year by the governing
214board then from the goals the Administration has gotten together and determine how we are going to measure our progress on each item so the key performance indicators that I present to you today are the indicators that were developed by the administration they were reviewed by the board members and then they were feedback was provided that feedback that was provided was then incorporated into the key performance indicators and they are now there for your approval these key performance indicators are meant to be just the starting point so this will be a working document the Strategic plan will be a working document as we move forward but this will give us a place to start so that we can actually measure the progress of the district and of the board members so our next next steps is
215to get the approval of the key performance indicators and that is what I'm asking you all for today any questions vice president keny um no questions at this time other than thank you you guys have put in a lot of work thank you for administration um this takes a lot of time and everybody involved in doing this I mean we've been working on this for many many months and I'm glad we're at this step so thank you absolutely Mr um I just want to say that um I wasn't able to give feedback and so I'd really like the opportunity to do that now and I asked uh Mrs Bixler before she left if she was able to provide feedback and she wasn't either so I'd really appreciated if this board and District administration could have
216a conversation about some of these key performance indicators because I think this is very very important work and I just want us to make sure that our key performance IND are reflective of the goals and that they are set up um as we in the term of like setting goals smart goals that they're attainable that they're specific so um are we able to have that discussion tonight just a real quick let me just chime in here uh Miss casos who developed the kpis for the the that are currently in front of us the kpis were developed by the district Administration um did the any staff or teachers anybody have any input on that yes the Administration has worked with staff and I don't know the teachers let me be honest with you there I don't
217have that answer but I will tell you that I did watch the administration go to all of the different School Districts The principls and whatnot and to gather feedback right okay so this came from the actual people who were driving so they they created the kpis what they thought was best for their schools and their teachers yes okay so I'm we can have that discussion now but you know I just wanted to make it clear we as a board did not set the kpis those were done through te all the way down to the teachers excuse me all the way down to the teachers again I can't say that it was done all the way down to the teachers but I can defer to Dr Monroe for that I will tell you that there was
218significant of feedback provided in the kpis and that's why it took the last two months thank you Dr minro yeah the kpis are very I don't want to say fluid I guess the word would be dynamic we're really anxious to get started uh Dr SLO has been a big part of it helping them be uh quantifiable or uh more measurable U there's still some baseline data that has to be identified on a few of them but that doesn't start uh stop the work from from progressing but uh we've worked with Mrs castanos each Cabinet member through their staff which could potentially go down to the teachers uh the principals and the teachers if needed and every Cabinet member as you could see every department is reflected in the in the kpis those are indicators and
219so kpis change and so as we as we measure how we're progressing um those kpis may be adjusted uh quarterly or twice a year once a year as we go through things that's the nature of kpis they indicate how we're how we're achieving our goals so um by no means are they quote unquote polished and I don't know if they're ever I'm sorry finished I don't know if they're ever quite finished cuz that's the nature of kpis and I guess the word is dynamic they're they they change and they adjust as we achieve things but um but we're we're ready to start to get to work on them and so I I think that this is a good document and we'll continue to be refined as we work at Dr slow on some of the
220numbers and the measures and then we can start to report to the board on how we're achieving you know some of these cap what are those indicators so if you have a few questions you'd like to ask okay well I will give my for the record I will be uh discussing what um I have some concerns because as a board member it is our job to provide the checks and balances and represent the constituents and that's what I'm going to do here so with priority area one and goal one I think that the amount increase from uh 10% every year I think that is uh unattainable for the long term for the 5year you're asking people to be at a 76 proficiency rate which would be um about 40% above the state average in math
221um I think a much more um attainable goal would be 5% every year um and even I'm okay with 10% the first two years to really get our proficiency up um but then 5 years because I think it's important for our teachers to feel success um and to feel like they're working valued and if we're constantly telling them well you didn't meet it you didn't get 10% I just I just think that's demoralizing to staff and so if you look at the ELA one um it says 8% so I would just advocate for 5% as well um and I again I I want it to be an inclusive conversation so I don't want to move on I don't want to just State my opinion I'd rather us have a discussion um I feel like that's
222what as a board we're supposed to do is to come to have a discussion at the meeting in the public but if you don't want to then I'll continue on with other things I'd like to State about the kpis okay um under goal three uh the first kpi is to increase the identification and enrollment rate of the gifted program by 3% annually um currently the district average um for um gifted education sorry hold on let me look up my notes um if it's helpful that Baseline data is actually on the document that oh yes thank you so much okay so it's uh 4.3% and the national average is 6% so if we are increasing uh the identification and enrollment of the gifted program by 3% we are going to be way over qualifying children um
223and I don't think we should just qualify children for gifted to meet a goal like if they're if they qualify for gifted then absolutely we should qualify them but I think to have a a rate of 3% means we're over qualifying them and we're not doing it for the right reasons like we should be qualifying them because it's needed um and honestly if you take the data down which I really appreciate Dr SLO and the amount of data that he has provided this District it is immeasurable um we don't have a problem identifying gifted students at our non-title one schools they are at 6 and 8% but at Title One schools they are between 1 and 2% so I would really advocate for a goal of identifying gifted students at Title One schools because that's
224where the underidentification is happening M if I may yeah um Dr Monroe do you know where that 3% came from from what I recall it was pretty attainable but go ahead on the gifted um I'm I'm going to actually look to Dr SLO because we were talking about that so Ed do you want to come up Dr SLO you want to come up to the to the microphone when we were talking about gifted identification increasing the identification enrollment rate of the gifted program by 3% annually um uh so Ed talk a little bit about some of our conversations that we had on that well originally I had thank you very much Dr Mar um originally when I looked at the indicators um I actually put the same note that you're reflecting I went and found
225what the national average was because its giftedness in some ways is in the population and so I asked what's the population it was six around 6% so increasing it a lot year after year after year obviously it occurs exactly what you're saying you're going to be overidentifying and you may not identify that many kids because it's not just a decision it's actually a the an identification of measurement that that one does so my first reaction was um 6% was the national average uh in different po uh sort of in general populations um and that was my my original sort of notation to it thank you because I would I would agree with Miss Zimmerman where we don't want to be identifying like we don't we're not on a a hunt right we're not trying to
226to fabricate numbers we're not trying to do anything like that but you're saying 6% is National um and we're looking at for our goal saying 3% within the district 6% the literature says 6% of a national population uh that is a sort of a median for the whole sort of large population in the country uh but in other subpopulations that number can change it can be overidentified in uh certain sub areas of the population or in the communities that they're in and it can be too high for other areas so you get into the socioeconomic type distributions across the country right so the danger is if we lower this number too much we could be letting people slip through you know kids who should identify gifted we Overlook them I think my original I think
227my original comment when I was thinking about it and I was looking up the national is that it's not a matter of us simply identifying somebody with that trait or that characteristic it's are we measuring enough of the population so that if they're there we identify them and then can provide services uh based on that measurement so I think I made a comment early on about it's not the identification percent it is the uh it's the coverage are all of our students being in some ways considered for being I'll say gifted tested that's too simplistic uh and what's that rate and should that rate be going up uh not just the identification but the actual sort of testing and uh finding out where these kids are in our different campus populations okay but aren't we
228already doing that I believe that we screen in kindergarten and test all students in second grade is that correct that's correct in second grade we test all the students so we are we are doing that so from just from a measurement standpoint there are if I if I'm correct because I'm not a gifted person a not a gifted person you are a gifted person think higher of yourself than that I'm not an expert in how one identifies other than I know through the measurement process through the testing process there are very specific testings that they go through and if those scores are high enough then they move in or get designated as uh potential candidates for the gifted program so my original reaction was I I didn't know that we were testing everybody I don't
229know the conditions on it but it is not simply raising it to three to six to you know eight or nine and then just you just keep going because that gets out of what the sort of the natural distribution in the population of young kids are so the goal itself is somewhat um you can't just have an increase like Mrs Zimmer said is saying you just can't have 3% 3% 3% 3% because that's not the nature of the trait that we're trying to measure so some someplace you're going to top out on it so one of the one of things I got to point out here and this is unique to the way that the district has done this in the past um these are starting points these are points that are goal for this
230next year and then the board has the option at the end of the year based on the results we get back to modify them and so that was one of the new things that we're doing so annually next summer whenever we get our numbers back we'll revisit this and adjust our numbers accordingly and that's why I say this is a starting point this is a point where we say this is our goal for look at the next year we're already below what we have now if we could raise that 3% if we raise it 1% will come back and say well what what happened what's the day to tell us and make an adjustment so these are what I'd like to think of is are these the question I always put for are these realistic
231kind of attainable goals the first year is this something we look at and then revisit them at the end of the year so that's I just wanted to throw that in but this is a 5year strategic plan correct okay so we're writing the goals like with the goal that at the end we're going to accomplish them at the end of five years so I I hear what you're saying and again I'm I'm not saying that you need to get rid of the kpi I just think that maybe it needs to be adjusted because I don't think raising it 3% annually which is what the kpi says is an appropriate goal but okay I'll move on um kpi number two um it says um 75% of special education students who have been enrolled in LD for
232a full Academic Year and whose annual IEP goals initiated by LD will meet at least 75% of their IEP goals and I have a concern that why are we only aiming for 75% % of our special education students to meet goals um again it goes back to goal writing and as a parent of a special education student I can tell you how critical it is that we are writing measurable specific and attainable goals every single year in their IEP so if we are doing that accurately I think we should be expecting 100% of our special education students to meet 75% of their goals because that means that we've written goals that are attainable in that year so I don't want to Short change our special education students and say we're okay with only 75% of
233them no no no these are our some of our most vulnerable students we should be working extra hard to support them so um I have a concern with that kpi okay [Music] um we'll go ahead and move on to um priority to employee Excellence um these particular um kpis under these goals are what I am most concerned about um if you look under goal number one the goal says LD will attract recruit and retain high high sorry high quality and appropriately certified sta to create a supportive environment that guarantees all students learn at a high level okay it says that we will attract and recruit and retain but none of the kpis talk about a retention rate or the rate of Highly certified or uh excuse me we'd call it something else highly appropriately certified
234I just I think we are missing a big big part of that goal the kpis do not reflect the goal and that first kpi improved the perception of a supportive climate so we don't care about improving the climate we only care about including the the perception I'm just I just I'm sorry I am not okay with that I cannot support kpis that don't Target what the actual goal is and I'm just so sad that we cannot have a discussion up here I just don't understand how this board can sit up here and be okay to say that we only want to improve the perception is that what this is about we should care about our teachers and what they really think I'm just shocked I'm Sorry Miss simmerman we don't all freak out like you
235we think we sit we might talk we might have a discussion but please don't attack like you have okay okay I think I think on that one uh Mrs Zimmerman one of the ways we try to one of the ways you try to measure culture ins climate is through is through surveys um of Staff right and surveys are perception data and I think that's probably why you see the word there um because uh that that's how you get after measuring how is the climate how is the how is the culture and so I think that's why you see the wording of you improve the perception of a supportive climate because that would be reflected like in the spring survey uh the perception that would come through in that data so I think that's probably why
236that that word is there okay um you know I think that these kpis you know there should be some sort of uh in order to improve the perception as you've stated then we need to know what what is the satisfaction with the district and I think if you want to improve the perception then people should be perceived to be satisfied and so if we're offering a climate survey then I feel like we should be including that data and it and it's not here so um goal two um the kpis are just kind of talking about providing PD and I just wonder if there could be a um like how is that measured right we're just talking about providing PT PD I apologize but how do we know if that PD is successful um could we
237have some sort of um you know how are we measuring whether the PD is successful um and so I think if we're really trying to move the district we should be moving past just um providing a service but rather showing some sort of improvement or things like that so that would be my note about that okay um on to area three which is effective system safety and resources um goal one it just says hold a at least one community meeting each quarter to uh support for voter approved uh funding measures such as a bond or override um just I just think it needs to be more specific about what kind of meeting um and then the kpis 4 and five um I just have what is a baseline but you said that that is this
238is a working document so that you'll add the baselines uh goal two uh I had the same thing about Baseline I just think it's really important to know where you're starting in order to be able to prove that we have improved um and some of the Baseline data will be established right now as well I mean so we We'll add it when we have it but some of it we're trying to establish what that Baseline is okay and is there a reason we're not using like last year's um data to create the Baseline well we are when there's data available or when we have the appropriate data for it um but for some of them we're trying to establish a baseline if we hadn't met measured it before okay um goal area three goal two
239um kpis four and five so the goal reads LD will Implement effective and efficient operations regarding facilities grounds warehouses utilities and systems to maximize responsible use of taxpayer dollars um kpis four and five I'm just not sure if they fall under here and so if you could help me understand how they fall into this goal train all principles to become proficient in school Erp Pro and fully understand their site budget to optimize resource allocation for Student Success yes so we basically just want that's kind of what I talked a little bit about earlier is actually having those budget meetings with the principles and going over here's the so schooler Erp Pro is our accounting system and so we're showing them here's here's your budget for M here's your budget for Capital here's what you have
240what you started with what you've used what your expenditures are what your PO are so that's basically training the principles on budget reports okay and so are we filing that under systems for the goal is that how it because it just talks about like operations regarding facilities grounds warehouses utilities so I you know I'm not again yeah I I think that's safe to say it's falling under systems and we haven't really to my understanding done that with our principles and and really empowered our principles to be able to have access and be able to read those reports so they can make responsible expenditures so systems to maximize responsible use of taxpayer dollars yes okay and then number five decrease the percentage of money spent on Outsourcing of special education services again I'm just wondering how
241that falls under goal two of yeah we'll look at that real close but I would say for now it's still under the systems there may be another place where it goes better but uh but we've yeah we've DED you know we're trying to dedicate some efforts into bringing more things inhouse being more financially efficient as a system here in special education so we can examine that but I think it would be under the systems okay umbrella area four uh is uh and Community engagement um kpi number four it says um to conduct annual climate and culture surveys to assess potential uh excuse me parental satisfaction and engagement levels um I just think that there should be a goal here um not just conducting the survey but what are we doing with that information are we
242trying to improve the satisfaction of our parents um I think we need to do more than just conduct the survey um area 4 goal two kpi 2 just again baselines um area four goal for uh LD will embra uh Embrace and adhere to customer service standards that ensure positive interactions and experience for parents students colleagues and the community um I just want to make sure that this applies to the everybody in the district including the district office um area five marketing and communication goal number one kpi 3 is about publishing um positive uh media stories I just curious are we uh are those that they're being written spontaneously by people 10 positive stories are we paying to have stories written in the news paper that are positive of the district uh that's no those that's
243not anything that's paid um it it really it's what the what the uh media would pick up uh and so we'll do we'll do press releases here and now but we want to make a concerted effort for um getting positive message out there with video or what have you but it's not anything that we pay for but it really depends on if the media wants to pick it up so we send a press release um you know and then some media Outlets might might run and and push that so we're trying to find really good positive embedded stories to tell the tell a good story about the district okay um goal number two the kpis are aren't written for the past the first year so in a 5-year strategic plan it just seems like the
244goal or the kpi should be written past the first year um and same thing under goal for the kpis most of them the timeline is um this summer so again if we're writing a 5-year plan I would just uh like to see us you know extend that goal and continue to work on things throughout the five years that's all I have thank you I just like to reiterate that the board had been working on this since June um the board the five board members that were sitting were seated at that time all the way till till recently um had the input a lot of the input is the directions we wanted to go with with the different areas of the goals so um I'm comfortable with where we're at with this for our first year
245um we can revisit a lot of this as we end the year and we can update it this needs to get pushed through tonight so we can be be put put into play and we can start measuring our uh our Prof efficiencies and all the other pieces involved with our strategic plan so with that um vice president Kenyan um I'll call for a motion all right uh right before you give the motion Miss simmerman I want to apologize I kind of snapped a little bit and I apologize for that um some of the stuff that you mentioned I'm agreeance with where we should take a closer dive but I I do understand the need to get this moving and so we can start collecting the data the wonderful thing about this is we are able
246to to look at it and modify it as needed um and so that's that's a good thing about this um but with that I will go ahead and make a motion let me get on the right one I make a motion to approve the Strategic plan kpis I'll second call for a vote vice president keny I miss IM nay and I'd like to explain my vote I'm also on I I'll show that pass two uh go ahead Miss imman um I just cannot support the kpis as they're currently written and I just would really like to see some revision work done move on to 10.2 discussion consideration of prek primary instructional resources for 60-day review Susanna Finn good evening president Parks vice president Kenyan board members and Dr mono this evening I will provide an
247update on the progress of the uh preschool primary resource adoption this is for information only not for discussion The District administration held two meetings so far on December 5th and 11th to ensure new preschool resources are ready for the 2025 2026 school year meetings are public with minutes and videos available on bardocks next we will initiate a 60-day review period to gather public input on the following resources Frog Street and ready to advance in April the District administration will present the recommendation to the governing board upon approval resources will be delivered to the teachers um to be on time before um the the start of the new school year um I do have my preschool experts joining me today if you do have any questions feel free to ask and I will seek their support
248vice president can I don't have any comments or questions right now M I don't have any at this time I don't either thank you very much appreciate your time thank you it's just informational so we'll move on to item 10.3 discussion consideration to approve recommendation for uh Loretta zumbro Las prus Academy and blue Horizons Elementary School attendance boundaries beginning in 2025 2026 school year uh Dr mohor and Dr SLO will be with me president Parks vice president Kenyan members of the board Dr Monroe we would like to bring to you um our presentation and our recommendation for our braries um so um this is our presentation Letta zumbro Elementary School attendance boundary considerations so we want to give you some background about our planning and Communications um so we uh the district website in the
249news there was an email link and Resource page the LD social media so we had two parent meetings it has been on on social media several times Derek has put that on social media um the email link has been up it's probably still up uh Dr Sloat has personally responded to every email that was uh sent to him with any their questions um just comments anything he has personally responded um additional resources were also available um parent messenger uh parent messenger uh was sent out about our meetings we had one meeting at Blue Horizons we had one meeting at Los breus we unfortunately did not have as as high of attendance as we would have liked to um had we had technical meetings which we just called that was a a staff meetings where we
250had in included Dr uh SLO myself um we asked for parents from Blue Horizons and uh Los bces we had one very involved parent from Blue Horizons and I just wanted say thank you to Ben I cannot remember his last name but he was very active attended both meetings at Blue Horizons and Los prus and our technical meeting and gave a lot of great input um again those were our community meetings we have November 7th November 14th and then we had our governing board study session on November 18th so a lot of this you've already heard because we gave you an update on November 18th so our boundary planning our primary considerations most immediate first of all I would say our most immediate is student safety also uh for blue Horizons as you know blue
251Horizons as of today is probably about a,0 students so they are buring at the seams so we needed to remove both the immediate and long-term capacity crowding conditions at Blue Horizons for L Brees we need to prevent projected capacity crowding due to Reg growth so they're not at capacity yet but due to the growth around um Los breus they're projected to reach capacity for Liberty and Loretta zumbro we want to provide sufficient near and long-term capacity utilization and Dr SLO will talk to you about that later and stability design our boundary Solutions so that they're stable at minimum for 5 years we do not want to be in front of you 2 or 3 years down the road saying oh we need to change boundaries again we do not and we won't be in front
252of you in the near future saying we need to change boundaries again because we were wrong supporting principles and considerations boundary coherence maintain neighborhood Integrity we do not want to split for all costs we do not want to split neighborhoods down the middle so some kids from one neighborhood go go in the same neighborhood they go to this school other kids go to this school we don't want to do that allow for capacity flexib ility um for uncertainty unforeseen New Growth um allow for open enrollment in and out of District um one thing to think about for blue Horizons if with these new boundaries if parents um are redistrict and they have to go to the new Loretta zbell there will be an option to open en roll to Blue Horizons and they really want
253to stay the caveat will be they won't get Transportation so as a family you'll have to think about I really want my student even though they're slated to go to the new Loretta zumbro I want them to stay at Blue Horizons I will need to transport them that will make a difference if you're a if you're a parent if I have to provide transportation will I be able to do that that's something to think about um allow for families preference if I have siblings matriculation for those stairs Transportation thinking about the time and the distance and something we have to think about as a transportation department is the cost and of course we talked about safety um for the Walkers and Street costing parents will send their kids um bu it it's good year goody
254year is going to um provide us I believe um with they're going to redo that street right there so there will be a light cuz right now there is not a traffic light right there that will help with this the crossing right there I think this is where Dr sloat's jumping in thank you yeah president Parks members of the governing board uh thank you for letting me talk a little bit uh or continue our conversation about boundaries so this first slide here is the current boundary area for our district and what I've highlighted on it is the growth region and unfortunately in the decision- making process uh and the boundary planning process things become more easy if growth is evenly distributed across the geographic area uh because you can draw a lot more uh scenarios
255when growth is distributed more evenly this is not the case that we're facing it's the Citrus Road Corridor that's where the concentration of growth is um and you can see the green uh uh region so you have this area that is right around Loretta zbro and you can that's between um two major major crossroads uh you can think of that as a walking area that's going to have 200 160 some odd students I have the exact numbers uh uh down here and then immediately north of that along Citrus Road is the Amber meow La provada future growth area and that's another 260 or 280 students uh between uh between those two areas and really just to the west of those there's nothing there's no future plan development uh at least right now on the 10-year
256projection uh timeline then when we look at Vista De Montana that has about 250 students in it so considered a high density High enrollment area but that's completely built out so if you look at the way our boundaries are set up right now and where the growth is you can almost see this pivot area it's a no-brainer to draw a boundary in the immediate quadrant of the new school because all the kids are going to reside right next to that new school and be Walkers immediately but then you go up north to Amber Meadows and La Prada there are no students there now and there will not be for probably two maybe more years and when that develop those developments start to play out they're not going to just all of a sudden have you
257know a thousand homes in it it's going to take time for those to play out uh with that so there's really nothing going on in Amber now for the next year and a half two years we don't think right and then Vista De Mont so you have this sort of pivot point in that growth region on which to do the boundary planning and so there is going to be no perfect solution to this that's going to meet every need with that any questions on that just uh I just wanted to highlight it it's this concentration in a very small Regional area that really limits how you can start carving the these places the geography up and still not uh subdivide if you will a neighborhood draw a boundary down at neighborhood street and let me
258just interrupt Ed just a point of clarification something that was mentioned earlier that the board heard and that the board knows Amber Meadows and Amber Meadows La provada was an original site when I took over the district and uh we attempted to negotiate quite a bit I just want to clarify this um we attempted to negotiate quite a bit uh including the City of Goodyear however it was not reciprocated so I will just State clearly it was in the best interest of our district to move off of that because near the end the negotiating party wouldn't even come to the table so I just wanted to offer a little clarification I understand the board is aware of that but just to have it stated publicly okay I I see lean the microphone um I feel
259like it's probably somewhere but in that first um you know kind of green region right where Loretta zumbro is how many kids reside in that area right now that are currently going to Los brius do you know approximately I don't have that number in front of me there is some development in that area because those students currently go to Las prus I don't have that number um in front of me the total count on buildout in that area sort of that quadrant is 282 students at the fiveyear Mark and so there's quite a bit of development that's occurring right now both with uh vertically and new ground being broken in that region so the total is 282 that we're using at the 5year mark from the projection if that helps uh with that so the
260two areas that become important that are really in play are Amber Meadows in La Prada and Vista De Montana those are the two those are the two areas you're not really going to do anything every next to Loretta zumbro um Los prus is really taken care of it's a logical boundary scenario to have all the students um the 508 students that live in Los prus area below Lea zumbro continue to go to that school so it really comes down to how do we relieve Blue Horizon which is going to be over the 10year period a basically filled school at or above capacity over that 10year period how do you relieve that school um uh Del Rel it um and make a consistent boundary plan that's going to last that's going to have that fiveyear minimum
261and it's not going to cut neighborhoods up with that so that's the task that we really got down to so we developed the six different options with that and scenario one scenario two and scenario 4 through all the feedback we got and through staff working in the data decided Well knew we needed to sort of pair this down but scenarios one and two simply don't relieve they don't meet the most basic criteria of relieving Blue Horizon they really don't do that at all scenario one doesn't do it at all and scenario 2 just barely and then scenario 4 was an option in which we broke the good way to put it we broke the cardinal Rule and that is driving uh or or putting a boundary uh boundary line right through a community literally in
262the backyards on surface streets so those three scenarios that staff and from the feedback are being brought to you are scenarios three five and six you're going to ask which ones staff is recommending I think six and three are the two options but for very very different reasons of making the decision that I'll talk about with that so those are the three options that we'll deliver today so here in some detail is scenario 3 what are the characteristics of scenario 3 it is relieving Blue Horizon by about 157 to 160 students it brings blue Horizon's capacity utilization at the 5-year mark down to 88% So Below 90% it leaves open about 115 seats or about 4.3 classrooms no 4.1 classrooms of 28 students on it so does it relieve blue Horizons in our first check
263mark the answer is yes it does does it relieve it substi it only does so moderately it is over the uh over the timeline blue Horizons in this scenario simply will be a large school and it'll probably be manage through the management of IND district and out of District open enrollments and whether they're approved or not if that makes some sense so this also impacts the least number of families in the area because remember there are no families in the Amber Meadows sub area it leaves Vista De Montana at Blue Horizons but it only drops their capacity utilization to 88% everybody else is good Liberty Los prus and Loretta zumbro plenty of room plenty of room for open enrollments and that kind of thing so that's number three then if we jump to number number
264five we draw a logical boundary but we move Vista De Montana into the red as Umbro along with Amber Meadows in this scenario where we leave vist de monia in Blue Horizon Blue Horizon becomes a very large school at year five or or stays a it stays a large school through to year five in this scenario since we're moving so much high density down into Loretta zumbro Loretta zumbro becomes a a a high capacity school so in year five the Loretta zumbra the utilization rate is at 93% leaving only 61 open seats and 2.18 sections so you've just transferred the problem of growth from Blue Horizons to Loretta zumbro so how do you manage Loretta zumbro under this scenario you have to manage it through open enrollments of in District and out of District students
265to keep it below Capac keep it below um its its utilization capacity so that is a logical one and then the third one is kind of splits that difference where we move Vista day Montana into Loretta zro but we leave Amber Meadows and La Prada at Liberty we just simply don't move them at all because no one's there right now so what happens in the five years you transfer it from Blue Horizon to Loretta zumbro and in this scenario the third one then the capacity problem becomes at Liberty in the fifth year and you can see the capacity utilization is at 89% so again three scenarios one blue Horizons is at 88% here Loretta zombro is at 93% and here Liberty is at 89% something else well I'm talking into this that's not that's not
266going to work at all one thing that something else we want to um note about this one um this will this is our recommendation again the board can take our recommendation um they can pick you all can pick five you can pick three number six is our recommendation based on our meetings our feedback the emails every all the research we have done something else to note is number six also is the best balanced if you look at the numbers in the 5e it's the best balance is it going to be exact absolutely Ely not it is the most balance at the 5-year marked so it balances out as best that it can all of the buildings so that's something to also notice something else every single scenario no matter which one it is all six
267all three there's going to be some benefits and there's going to be some concerns No Matter What scenario it is the all of them will have benefits all of them will have concerns and let me let me just say something uh I appreciate the work and the approach to this Dr slow Dr mohorn in a past life having dealt with a lot of boundaries you're really it's almost like a game of Risk and you're trying to use your predictive demographics as best as possible and you know we would be very naive to understand that we can't control the market we can't control the growth rate we can't control the charter schools that move in on our boundaries there's a lot of variables that we can't control and so I appreciate you guys bringing to the
268board Eyes Wide Open here's some benefits but here's the pros and here's the cons because it has been my humble experience that there's no perfect option when you're doing boundaries it it is a little bit uncertain but we're really trying to predict into the future but who's to say the economy doesn't recess you know in a year who's to say you know housing goes through the roof even more so than it is so there's a lot of variables that we certainly can't control and there there's just a lot of predictive work that's done and so as you as the board has heard me say as we project into the future I always use the crystal ball analogy where for a year or so it's a little clear two it's starting to get a little murky
269but every year it gets a little it gets a little murkier but I think it's very realistic to say you know at at a minimum of five years we don't want to mess with the boundaries but understanding that things could happen we're going to have a new president of the United States we're going to have a new governor in 2 years and who's who's to say some of some of the impacts of the economy uh who's to say that people aren't going to flood the Letta zbro I mean this is the first Domino we're going to do and what's to say in January when we ask the parents that there's a higher than normal amount of parents that want to go to the new school to the shiny new school so so there's a lot
270of variables that that we just have to do our best to to uh almost like a social science to predict but I want to applaud the work um that Dr slow and Dr mohorn has have done and uh I wish that we could always say with 100% certainty but again we bring this to the board as a recommendation and um there's a lot of work done in the append appendices and I know Dr slow has really dug in about as deep as you can go on these things he's gone down the rabbit hole quite a bit and so I just wanted to help the board understand that but that as Dr mohorn says we're not changing the boundaries in five years listen if things change we could be back in three years or or or
271four years but I will just remind the board these are good problems to have we're growing so these are good problems to have as opposed to say Roosevelt who right now is considering closing Five schools so I I just want to add a little perspective that it's it's not an exact science as we do this a comment to make and a con and a consideration when trying to decide on this we're not recommending number five because it puts all the high density into Loretta zro it leaves no room for open enrollment and we recognize that there's there's development occurring both in that quarter but it's on both sides there's development a lot of occurring immediately to the east so this scenario just simply doesn't work both the number three but also number six works it
272has lots of capacity in Loretta zbro and it gives us a weight and see um perspective on what'll happen to Liberty because how Amber Meadows plays out in the years ahead is going to determine how soon we have to come back and address this so This lot uh this one provides chance for us to come back in three four years with new forecasts and new understandings of the economy and the Housing Development and make some adjustments uh on it and how would we make adjustments on it if the if L if Liberty starts to fill up and get really close then you do have the option to go back up into Amber Meadows which will not be fully built out and take the the southern part of Amber Meadows and move it out of Liberty
273and put it logically into the rombro so that would be one approach to this choosing this particular scenario right right that but it leaves a lot of a lot of open enrollment both at Los prus and at Loretta zumbro in the time vice president Kenyon yes thank you Dr SLO and Dr uh mohar you guys have done a fantastic job and I know you guys have especially you Dr SLO you've you've put a lot of time and effort into this um thank you for also reaching out to the community and and you know trying to navigate this best you can um obviously there's no perfect scenario um I do like scenario 6 like you're saying you're recommending um with the caveat of we'll see what happens with Amber Meadows you know it doesn't seem like
274I'm sure you've talked with Miss Donnie over there and and the transportation department and tried to figure out logistics on this number six was what she recommended as far as busing goes and Logistics with busing as well thank you and I do like that you know Liberty here there's there's room for growth you know there's there's some space here in the back so um so personally I'll I'll support scenario six as well we tried to think of everything even though it's impossible it's absolutely impossible Mr thank you I also wanted to thank Dr slope for meeting with me um last week to make sure that I was fully prepared and and understood all the D to U make the most informed decision that I can um as I look at the two scenarios I'm just
275going to kind of share my thoughts between scenario 3 and scenario 6 I think um honestly we could go either way um with scenario 3 right now the initial impact I think provides the least amount of impact to students um moving students from their school so Blue's only been open for 3 years so some of these kidss had to move schools 3 years ago um to move to Blue from Liberty mainly right it's three years just three years is it four blue four years I think it's three yeah it might be three or four yeah three okay um and so by keeping Vista De Montana with blue you know it just reduces the impact to students to families that are already established there um and you know it opens with a lower number right at
276220 but you know remember that we're only opening the school k6 so every year we're going to gain some students just by adding the next two grade levels and so then at five years um it keeps Loretta zumbro at 700 and keeps blue you know roughly 100 under capacity and if you look at the current open enrollment from Blue it's very minimal compared to all the other schools in the district really so in terms of keeping room for open enrollment at Blue I don't think it's as big as a concern as some of the other schools just on the history of it they're they just don't have a lot um and um my concern here with scenario 3 is is that it keeps Liberty small okay and we're really not using the capacity at Liberty
277um it's still you know very small compared to what it's built at now um what we haven't really talked about tonight is is the preschool um and I think that this is going to be an unpopular opinion um is that if we do scenario 3 I would Advocate to keep the preschool at Liberty because it utilizes the capacity at Liberty because Loretta is going to grow into its capacity in scenario 3 um my concern with keeping it at Liberty is that it's not set up right for preschool we don't have bathrooms and classrooms um right now the preschool classrooms are split up I'm speaking in personal experience my daughter's in the preschool so I'm not speaking out of turn um but I think that there are things that we could do to make it better
278we could move the junior high classrooms out of that Wing turn that into a preschool Wing sure there'd be some things that have to do but I think it's going to utilize the capacity and leave the room for growth at Loretta so those are what I think about scenario 3 scenario 6 my concern is um busing kids across boundar so that uh La Prada right we're kind of you know I don't know the exact bus route but you know potentially we could be driving through Loretta zumbro boundaries to get to Liberty um and so um and then it would be stable for 5 years uh at Liberty but then that area is going to grow so then potentially we're at capacity at Liberty this would allow I think the preschool to stay at Loretta zumbro
279for an extended period of time and I talked to Dr Monroe last week about the wing at Loretta zumbro being built for preschool and how valuable and important I do think that is having it set up for preschool so I certainly could be in support of that and it keeps it stable it keeps it centrally located I don't personally like this idea that we're moving the preschool around so if we you know we take it from Liberty and then we move it to Loretta and then it gets too big and we got to move it back to Liberty like I just think those are some concerns so I like that at scenario 6 it does that um but I don't know I think it's a tricky one I wish that parents were here to share
280their thoughts I mean that's for me as a board member I just would love for parents to have a voice um because it's going to impact them you know we're making a decision about their children's lives and where they're going to go to school so um I just wish we had that input to help us make this decision thank you Dr SLO Dr mohorn um I I looked at the data and the underlying data on this and it looks to me um you know scenario 3 did have some positive points on it but I think scenario 6 had the room for growth especially in the high growth areas which is a little unpredictable but I think we know where it's going um to miss Zimmerman's point I don't want to be you know you know
281changing boundaries later because we have capacity issues and moving kids back I think this one would prevent that I think it keeps kids where they're at we also have the opportunity with the Open Enrollment if kids of parents want to keep their kids at uh you know blue Horizons they sure as heck can so um so I I thank you very much I appreciate the presentation and with that I will call uh for a motion Mr President I'll make a motion to approve recommendation number six for Loretto zumber Elementary School lost B's Academy and blue Horizon's Elementary School School attendance boundaries beginning the 2526 school year I have a second second call for roll call um vice president Kenyon I miss simmeron I I'm also and I excuse me I'll show that past 30 all
282right move on to 10.4 possible action to convene an an executive session pursuant to AR ARS 38 431 A1 discussion to consideration of assignment of a public officer governing board policy CBI and cb- evaluation of superintendent in ARS 38 43103 A3 discussion or consultation for legal advice with the attorney attorneys of the public body evaluation of the contract of the superintendent I'll call for a motion uh I'll make a motion to convene an executive session present to ARS 38- 431 A1 discussion or consideration of assignment of a public officer governing board policy CBI and cb- evaluation of the superintendent and ARS 38-43 1.03 A3 discussion or consultation for legal advice with attorney or attorneys of public body evaluation contract superintendent do I have a second second okay I'll call for a vote vice president Kenyon
283I uh Miss Zimmerman hi I'm also an IO that passes 30 and I show we go into executive session at 8:55 [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] what's the what [Music] Sho up up [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] this [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] the [Music] the [Music] the [Music] up up up [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] oh [Music] up up up oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] the sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] what up what's up what's up [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] up [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] up [Music]
284sh [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] the I [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] the [Music] up up up oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] up up up sh oh [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] the [Music] up up up [Music] sh oh [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] she [Music] oh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] the the sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] theit [Music] sh [Music] up up up [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] that's [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] sh [Music] up
285up [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] up up oh [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] up watch [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] the [Music] up [Music] what oh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] what [Music] up up [Music] oh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] she [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] up oh [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] what [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] what what [Music] sh
286[Music] the [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] the [Music] what [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] theit [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] oh [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] a [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] Up's up [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] what [Music] up up [Music] sh [Music] theit [Music] what I want I [Music] shoot up up up [Music] oh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] what [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] the [Music] what [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] oh [Music] sh oh [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh oh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] sh [Music] what the I [Music] oh [Music] oh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] sh [Music] the [Music] sh [Music] up [Music] all
287right we're back from our executive session um we'll move back to item 10 Let's see we don't need to vot to Recon yeah so yeah we're going to adjourn the the well I'm going to go through board comments and topic request so 11.1 does anybody have a board comment or agenda topic request uh I just have one agenda request um I'd like an agenda item to discuss the criteria that has been established for non-renewal of Administrators what the process and procedure is um how you inform the governing board of those decisions and I'd like uh legal to oversee uh Overlook the the not the policy but the procedure to ensure that the process is uh fair and just and that we're not opening our elves up to any lawsuits thank you Miss emmerman um I
288don't have anything so upcoming board meetings 12.1 uh January 13 work study session and regular governing board meeting Monday February 3rd work study session regular governing board meeting and Monday March 3rd is a regular governing board meeting I'm assuming everybody can make those um with that President Parks if you don't mind um yes I can make those however I would like to I guess I should have probably mentioned this in topics um I would like to see if Mondays if we can look at changing the board meetings from Monday to Tuesday or another day of the week if there was another option that might work I know we've done Mondays for a long time and that may have to be yeah vice president Kenyan in the in the um uh uh January sorry I'm a
289little slow the January board meeting that was going to be an agenda topic since we have a new board starting about schedule so that's something the board can discuss as far as how the frequency of meetings the night of the week now that we have two new board members what they're availability is so we can talk about that in January sounds good thank you thank you vice president Kenyan with that we'll adjourn the meeting at 11:14 p.m. [Music]