001of how not to be a terrible School Board member uh Mr Ten okay super so at the board's request we're doing we're restarting our book study that we had been doing in the past and I want to point out a couple of things really quick now we can just spend you know 10 15 minutes um uh talk about whatever insights you had as you studied first of all the the title of the book seems a little edgy and it's not in certainly not intended to be from my point of view I think probably as a you know marketing tool they they tried to come up with something that was a little bit funny it's a common thing I think I mentioned this to the board when we first started talking about it I looked up
002just really quickly did a Google search is this is this the only kind of approach that this has taken I found online in 30 seconds how to be the absolute worst back packer at the campsite it's intended to get you know people's attention toward how to be a good Backpacker at the campsite right that's the idea how to be a horrible teacher tips and tricks to do your worst obviously we're not you know suggesting that teachers are horrible in general what not there's no suggestion of that there six easy steps to becoming the worst parent ever and not to be outdone by the others seven classic mistakes of new superintendents so those are all those are all you know this this kind of a we're going to take the opposite approach in terms of the
003title or whatnot to be a little bit funny and to highlight what's what's a real positive thing to do which is the idea obviously was was behind this book there was no intent initially nor now to say we have terrible board members or we have people that that show a great potential to be terrible board members or whatnot and and as you saw uh going through it it each one has lessons for both administrators particularly the superintendent and for board members so that was kind of the thought as we just kind of go through together again not not meaning to be edgy or or point fingers or anything at all I hope that everybody's everybody is clear on that all right we're we're not offended good okay I just didn't want to didn't want to
004offend at all again this was brought to us um where else is it we just found out is there's another district oh I remember what it was I was at a yay County Administrator meeting uh just a couple of weeks ago and one of the um one of the administrators there who works around the state was visiting and said hey you know what I just I just heard about this great book you might consider his book said hey we actually doing that PSD and she thought that's terrific you're ahead of the curb so there there are definitely other boards across Ariz known and across the United States that use this for the very same purposes that we're using it for and hopefully it it'll help us all get even better working as a team to
005to govern our school district effectively so each of these is broken into scenarios how many are there Terri all they're all called terrible habits there's 28 of them uh so if we do two a week we'll be done with this you know in a year and a little bit we'll see if that's the pace we want to keep or not but terrible habit number one was humiliate a district employee in public obviously the titles of each of these are things that we don't want to be doing right and you what do you remember from the scenario we all read this the last few days maybe just a board member can share with us what the scenario was I can yeah so we it was essentially that someone was giving a report and the report wasn't
006done very well as far as the information that was being presented wasn't presented in a professional manner and it just came across pretty unprofessional sure and the board member really wanted to correct that situation in public instead of instead of either through the superintendent or you know just letting somebody know that more work could be done ahead of time before the presentation but absolutely now you those of you who've been with us for a while been watching these for a while correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think we generally have the problem that is presented as the context here in the first place the reports that we get from our folks are generally quite good and informational and whatnot in fact Kelsey's going to give us another point or another report here in
007just a few minutes and I told her now we're specifically talking about this scenario I make sure it's solid no problem so yeah there you go there you go yeah um the the part that I I kind of spun off of this was uh almost during meetings pointing out where there was a mistake and I did a last meeting just with the um uh with the resource officer I mean within that contract there were some items that were left in there was PHS when it was Grant mountain and then the grant Mountain I and I thought I probably could have done better homework and just said said hey look there are some typos in there rather than announcing it publicly I thought I was being a steward of hey I'm doing my homework and I'm
008showing it but not necessarily having to do that in public so I mean it so I took that and kind of okay put a personal hit on myself that fair enough good reflection yeah that's the form that we see we received it from the city but you're right we shouldn't have assumed that you know the city had crossed all the te's because they they had left the word PHS in there instead of grand Mountain whatnot so yeah good good point and good reflection so for each of these as you recall there's kind they they present the scenario here's what the school board member did he usually uses his own name as the terrible School Board member that that Richard uh my board member Richard did this could Richard have done a better job and obviously
009the the um the correct response so to speak was instead of pointing out in a meeting or uh getting with the person in advance and saying Hey Kelsey I looked over your report and this is kind of a mess or what were the other options uh contacted your fellow board members and said this is this is crazy they keep doing this what's the matter with these people or say hey you know what you guys I'm going to get into the the nitty-gritty details of running the district let's come up with a procedure to make sure everything is right and then the last one was no you're were fine in the first place why not just point out in a meeting the the correct response they said was you know get with the if you see
010something in advance you know give the superintendent point that out and that's that's her job or his job to get with those folks say hey we can do better we can do better with this if we're going to present something in public we got to make sure that it's ready for prime time so to speak any other takeaways from from this one uh for me the when they were talking about option for the quote um yeah talking to the other board members it says this violates the principle that the Public's business should be done in public and I think that's been as a new board member I've known each one of these other board members outside of the school board before I was elected to the school board and it's a little bit odd for
011me to to not be able to you know discuss together things uh that the the Schoolboard business needs to be done in public and that was a a great under um reminder for me and then the final option the quote leadership by humiliation is a Hallmark of a terrible School Board member and it's a Hallmark of a terrible leader and uh and I uh I love that uh that phrase and and thought you know as a as a parent as a school board member as a as an owner of a business I need to make sure that I'm being as a good a leader as I can be and humiliation is not one of those attributes that I want to lead by so great I think what I took away is just being out in
012the schools is important too this doesn't just apply in a a meeting situation but um when you're out in the schools recognizing your place uh that you're you're not there necessarily to evaluate or to criticize or to you're there to observe and to see what's going on and to create those types of relationships with the with the staff that you interact with um hopefully putting them at ease I think it's always a little hard to put people at ease because you are a board member and so people obviously try to do their best for you when you're there but you know trying to just let people know I'm not here to evaluate you I'm not that's not my role I'm just here to see what's going on great insight there are a couple of things
013I if I might things that I underlined or highlighted under the superintendent's Lessons Learned one was safeguards should be in place for the review of all materials going to the board before they're sent off if if we were starting to see any kind of an issue with that I would be even more assiduous about that than I am now I always check with people right I never you know I'll be honest I got with Kelsey a couple times I said how's it coming do you have any questions you need anything and she's I got it and I have not looked over it I'm going to the the information she's going to share is not going to be new to me the format in which it'll be presented and the order and whatnot is going to
014be new to me but I have developed great confidence that anything that Kelsey produces is far above what I'm going to produce so I'm very confident with that if on the other hand there would you know the roles were reversed and Kelsey was saying Clark's really not you know Measuring Up absolutely we should put something in place to say Hey you know if if it if we're going to have a presentation from Mr Smith we've seen a a couple of times that Mr Smith is not quite hitting the bar let's put something in place so that'd be a good lesson uh that I could learn from that superintendent could work on creating rapport with board members so they will fre feel free to let her know before the meeting if they receive substant substandard materials
015Etc so that's that's a lesson to you know have a good uh relationships that that your board members feel comfortable sharing concerns with you of any kind whether you know large or small last thing that I underlined or highlighted part of the superintendent's job is to help prevent board members from looking bad so I'll work on that I think you all look pretty good right now but that that's that's uh shared in the context of when the board member Richard whatever his name was board member started to say this is a mess right in the in the scenario you guys what are you bringing crazy stuff to us for the superintendent probably should have stepped in and said you know what that that's that's a great Point really appreciate you bringing that up we'll follow
016up on that you know Offline that kind of a thing rather than have the board member continue to dig themselves a little deeper falling down the wrong path so all right so there's terrible habit number one we just got a couple minutes left terrible habit number two is negotiating for the district who remembers this scenario and could summarize it for us really quick so I think basically this is um the board member hears from a constituent who happens to be the president of the teachers union and the that person wants to ask for help in a negotiating situation yeah um this is what the teachers want right we don't see the superintendent doing it we need your help and and since the teachers union supported the the candidate uh he felt that he could take
017that on and didn't feel like saying you need to bring this situation up with the superintendent in the proper negotiating situation okay so very good one of the things I underlined from the context which is absolutely true it kind of led the person to maybe thinking that wasn't ideal in this situation but last last sentence part of last sentence when the teachers are happy that is good for everyone in the district you're just trying to make sure they're happy I I can see the mindset of the board member in this scenario and the mind what led to that mindset the the idea that when teachers are happy that's good for everyone in the district that principle is absolutely true the best thing I can do for kids success is to put good teachers in front
018of them and the best thing I can do to keep good teachers in front of them is to make sure that we're doing everything we can to to support them in in multiple ways in multiple ways in terms of you know supporting their their um their teaching craft in terms of making sure that they're uh reasonably compensated to make sure they've got a great principal who's there for them to make sure that they feel like they're being listened to there there's 10 things that help a teacher feel supported reasonable class sizes all of those go into that and it is true if teachers are happy then by and large you probably have a successful district and and the opposite is true so that that principle Rings true but this person in this context their suggesting
019probably took that a little too far so um what what were the different options that were presented anybody share those to go what did the person do what did the person do in this situation what was one option well they kind they agreed with the person that there needed you know they didn't understand why the negotiations weren't going the way the person had hoped and that they would be talking to the superintendent seeing what's going on yeah I agree with you we should have lower class sizes there we should have more teacher compensation I'll take that on what's the problem with that according to this well what the person should have done was thank them for calling and let them know that we're informed and you know we will have more discussion about it but
020not not commit one way or the other to what the district's going to do and how the district's going to be moving forward and that there's people in place that represent the board in that negotiation already right and I think undercutting the the superintendent's Authority in that case um you know by kind of giving away negotiating position or or whatever May that that was highlighted here for me personally that's much less of an issue then undercutting a majority of the board maybe the rest of the board totally agrees with that person in which case super you're eventually going to be going in that direction maybe a majority of the board doesn't agree with that one board member or that Union president and you're not going to be going in that direction and for a single
021board m remember to say this is the direction that I'm going to try to make sure we head is probably skirting the edges of appropriateness I think that's the key is is you're a single board member you have no power except as a board um and so I think it's important just to remember that we can't make those decisions sure and typically the board isn't involved in those negotiations if there are negotiations Yeah we actually have a li different format than many uh districts might where unions have a a little bit different legal authority to operate than they do in Arizona we we don't negotiate directly with the teachers union about what's going to be in contracts coming up we certainly seek their input as we do for all of people who work in our
022district and our constituents of our district whether or not they belong to our Teachers Association or not one one other question I have maybe we just wrap this up again something I highlighted and underline it said um you should not be beholden to any group you must see yourself as representing everyone in the district those are important principles both of them right if you if you got a group of 12 of you that you're working with there there's a real problem there there's 68,000 people that you represent um and then it says this your decision should always be based upon what's best for children in your District I think everybody I've ever worked with on the board has that at heart many of you express that openly and then the next sentence and I agree
023with this usually that will coincide with what is good for for teachers but not always can you think of an example off the top of your head where probably need to roll in the next meeting okay yeah maybe just kind of food for thought are there scenarios in which a single teacher or a group of teachers might say we want this and though it's it's almost always best for students in general Student Success there might be scenarios when it's not you need to be kind of thoughtful about that all right that's it for this week thank you yeah that okay I'm going to call this uh meeting to order it is 5:15 uh for the February 4th 2025 PSD school board meeting um so welcome everybody um we'll start with the pledge of pledge of
024allegiance Vanessa would like you to lead Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God andice uh the next item is the approval of the agenda um before we take a motion to approve it we do have one exception item uh 7b1 it's an out of state travel for the challenge club uh Matt Dean is not here he's actually announcing at the uh at the soccer game the girls soccer game but Adam Neely is here correct oh there he is thanks yes sir all right okay Jane Jane okay we'll keep moving on just um we'll just Mark in the uh the meeting notes that Jane is not present when she does come in try a little bit if we can okay so
025for item 3A I'll take a motion to approve the agenda with the exception so moved moved and second in all in favor say I I I um item four approval of minutes item 4 a approving the minutes for the regular study and voting session meeting of January 14 2025 can I get a motion uh so moved motion second I'll second Mo second in all in favor say I I I item five uh presentations item five a Career and Technical education student we got Max mcvickers here and Miss Bailey come on up hi everyone good evening thank you for having us um my name is Miss Bailey Tiffany Bailey I'm our CTE director of presca High School uh thanks again again for having us this evening uh yet again this month we want to highlight showcase
026boast brag on our amazing upper classman students that are graduating with many honors um but specifically talking about um last month you met Hannah block and then this month we're introducing you to Max mcvickers who will be walking across the stage in May um max is a PHS two sports scholar student athlete who has been on the uh 4.0 list with his 4.0 GPA he's a member of the PHS mountain bike Team he wore the points leader jersey for the entire 2022 season so he was younger obviously than he is now so obviously a very talented athlete at a young age he won the northern Arizona division championship and placed fifth in state he's a varsity player on the pH best men's volleyball team and the 2024 All Region middle blocker he's been nominated for
027leadership roles at school he's on our salt team the student athletic uh leadership team he is um academically well-rounded and has taken many AP courses and many dual uh enrollment courses including mine when I was still in the classroom I had him as a Spanish 101 102 student and um additionally he's taken advantage of our multiple CTE offerings he was in jzi as a freshman freshman and then you will hear about his experience through um taking Aviation courses through our Mountain Institute Career and Technical education District offerings we call it mic Ted and our on campus offerings of sports medicine with our trainer Trent James as the instructor um so without further Ado I would love to introduce you to Max and get to know a little bit more about him thank you Miss Bailey
028um hello everyone maxw MC Vickers um I first want to thank you all for the opportunity to come speak in front of you guys um it's big pleasure so I'm gonna talk to you guys about my kind of experience in high school with my CTE experience um those three courses which was Bailey mentioned was Sports medicine J Ry and the aviation field um so first a little bit about myself um I'm on the mountain bike team at presk High School uh men's volleyball team and I also enjoy the outdoors with my friends uh that bottom right picture is a picture of me biking in Alaska and above that is a picture of me uh skiing up at snowball um so these are some of the things I enjoy doing this next slide is um a
029little bit of a portfolio of accomplishments I've had throughout High School 4.0 GPA Deans List all four years of high school um two two sport scholar athlete played three three Sports my freshman and sophomore year as baay mentioned I was part of salt I partook in Special Olympics my freshman in sophomore year and I did J Roy uh my freshman year um so the first uh tte program I would like to move into is my Aviation course that we did so this Aviation course I was kind of I didn't really know what I wanted to do early on in high school I kind of wanted to do everything I kind of wanted to be a firefighter at first and then I wanted to get into the aviation industry whether it be Air Traffic Control um
030flying airplanes uh being an engineer on airplanes or working with drones and this program kind of allowed me to see all aspects of those things uh we got to work with flight simulators in the bottom right um up top is the Hands-On drones that we got to work on and then this bottom middle is the radar simulators that we got to work with with our professors there um they all did a really great job um helping with us out with that hey Max Max is that at the YC campus or is that at PHS that is uh the YC campus out near the airport Ruger yeah the Ruger campus right yeah um so I had the most interest in unman air air systems so I got my um FAA unmanned airor systems uh certification which
031means uh I have I'm a certified drone pilot um and I can use that to now reach out to companies and contract my skills out to others so that's just one one other thing that I have in my back pocket and the other things I didn't um take as much interest in but one thing I really appreciated about this program is that it got allowed me to see if I had interest in these programs so the next CTE program that I that I went into is sports medicine I've been in sports medicine for the past two years um it's run by Trent James he does a great job of um being a source Med trainer and also teaching the classes he does both jobs there so some of these pictures are us at our clinical
032rotations at the football games and that top left is inclass we were using play to kind of make different parts of the body and one of the things I really Joy about this class is that we can learn in class kind of about different ligaments or different muscles and then in the games we can kind of see like what actually Happ happens if somebody gets injured we can work with the athlete just like we do in class and we can translate that directly to um athletic training so athletic training was something that I or I guess I should say the medicine field um in general something I had a little bit more interest in so that's um helped me kind of make my decision for college which I am going to University of Health Sciences
033and Pharmacy on scholarship um to play volleyball there and I'm still kind of deciding what I would like to make major in I'm in between physical therapy um some sort of doctorate degree or maybe some sort of surgery degree so but of course that' be way down the road so that's kind of what I'm doing there um sports medicine also has a club called HOSA which I'm the vice president of the HOSA club which allows us to go on trips like we're about to go on a trip and later this February it's going to be with Bradshaw mountain and Chino Valley High school and it's going to give us more Hands-On opportunity to um understand what we might be doing in the medical field um and yep that's SP and that's the last slide I
034have so does anybody have any questions about kind of the CTE programs that I was in or my experience with the CTE programs I'm wondering in your your work with the athletes like in football or any of the other sports yeah what what was the what was the biggest benefit you gained in helping an actual athlete and then what was the most challenging situation you dealt with I think the benefit I gained one of the biggest things was kind of the confidence that I gained from actually working with athletes from taking what I learned in the classroom and translating that onto the field um I think that was probably the biggest benefit that I got I think the biggest challenge was remembering all the steps to the process because if a athlete had a problem
035you had to think back to all the hours in the classroom that you spent working on different skills you got to remember which ones for which sort of injury or condition that the athlete had are the courses in the sports medicine Arena all dual enrollment or are they high school credit High School Credit only okay I wasn't sure if all the CTE were doing en dual enrollment I believe the sports medicines one were just uh high school credit but he earned dual enrollment credit with the aviation yeah awesome so back what certifications are you walking out of high school with you mentioned the UAV and yeah so um the UN and air systems certification um first aid certification uh CPR certification and we're doing the program called OSHA 10 and that gets us kind of
036a deeper certification within the medical area if we complete that field so that'll be another one that I get at the end of this year that's great w so I'll be graduating with four different certifications I'm going ask a different question totally off base but yeah how many pres preservation or presentations have you done like this throughout your high school uh one this is it and you nailed very well prepar nice job seriously great job appreciate it yeah awesome awesome you can probably see Max is unique in several ways one an exceptional student a great young man very well spoken Etc not every one of our students is this way but he's representative of a large number of our students who really have a lot going on you're sitting next to a couple right here
037you've already you've already seen that from from Vanessa and and Carly as well um the other piece that's that's relatively unique is he's been a part of three different CTE programs we don't have a lot of students who've been able to do that but we do have a huge What's the total number of students enrolled in CTE one way or another roughly about 530 530 530 out of out of 1500 kids at the school and they're largely for upper classman so it's a it's a very large percentage of our students are involved in one way or another Max sounds like he's heading down a track parall to my own son who took some CTE classes got some certifications that could have put him right into industry and instead of doing that right away he absolutely
038could have done that he used that as a spring board for his university studies and and very successful uh engineer now as a result of what he learned at Prescot high school I'm hopeful you'll you'll be on some some similar paths here Max thanks for being here to awesome thank you guys so much than Max Max's Max's proud parents are sitting in the the back row there thanks Amy and Brian good job good to have you here congratulations on raising such a great young man yeah awesome um we're going to move on to item 5B standard-based report cards Kelsey all right good evening everyone so last month we were able to talk a little bit about standards based instruction why we are making a movement towards that and implementing standards based within our district so
039the end result of Standards based instruction is standards based grading and standards based report cards so I'm here to show you a little bit about what that means for our district and where we are in that Journey um just for something to keep in mind this is our goal to is to start standards based report cards next year with kindergarten through 8th grade students so one of the things that we had to do as we embarked upon this journey is we really had to look at grades and reflect upon why are we giving grades and why do we report grades through report cards and so the biggest components that we had come up with were first and foremost it was to communicate academic progress and performance not only to parents but to students and for
040teachers to have a really good grasp on where each one of their students is at so a report card should inform parents um and students about where they are towards grade level expectations on grade level how are they doing that information should be used for teachers to guide instruction they're constantly assessing whether that's through formative assessment or summative assessment but how are they using that information to guide future learning opportunities encourage student growth if students know where they're at and they know what the end goal is they're much easier there's an easier path for them to get there if they don't know what that end goal is and they don't know where they're at they're they're kind of floundering they don't know where exactly they should be focusing their their energy and their attention um
041really to open some dialogue as well with parents we want that report card to go home and if parents have questions concerns we want them to easily have some information to have that that conversation with their teacher and then establish accountability we want we know that our schools are accountable for teaching grade level standards and so we wanted some way to track that to make sure that we were on target we didn't want to wait for the end of year assessment to come back which is the aasa and go oh that's how we did we wanted to make sure that we were tracking that all throughout the year and again communicating that to to all stakeholders so as we reflected upon the purpose of a report card we really had to review the system that
042we had in place and so this you have a a copy of this in front of you in case you couldn't see all of this um this is an example of what you might see as a parent in our district so this is a screenshot from um a student there's no identifiable information on here but um this is typical of what a parent would see most parents can click on any of those grades and you can see a list of assignments and how students did but this is what a report card looks like so I have some questions that I would like to ask you as you look at this report card so I want you put your parent hat on for a second and I would like to know do you know what your
043child was expected to learn it let's say looking at quarter three do you know what your child would be expected to learn does that give you that information no for unless you click on it right unless you click on it and then is it as specific as you would hope most of the time it's just an assignment name or a test name ass if they got 73% 93% but not necessarily skill like in power school we could see that and we click on it see what they're missing corre or not correct but that's that's the extent of it yeah um so does this help you with the question of how was my Che progressing towards proficiency where are they at are they on grade level are they not even if you were to click on
044those and see the list of assignments or assessments you're probably not going to have that information very clearly what are my child's strengths would you be able to answer that one what I don't know sub potentially correct it allows you to see that but yeah not always even sub matter wise because I know there's all teachers grade differently teachers have different things that they're looking for and correct certainly our kids know what teachers they want that are going to grade them easier or harder or whatever you know what I mean and so it's not always a reflection on their skills just because they get uh or their natural talents necessarily correct so would you be able to identify areas for improvement yeah like so like spelling obviously could improve our spelling situation so but nothing
045specific nothing specific you're you're told okay we need to work on spelling as a parent you where do I start what am I going to do where where do I focus my time and energy do I just focus on a few words at a time are there any skills in particular there's not a whole lot of information even if you click on assignments you're probably not going to see the skills that would help your student become more proficient and the big question again that that home and school connection is how can I support my from here you could go um okay we're going to work on spelling but again you don't necessarily know the skills to work on so while this does communicate some information it's not really actionable information all the time that can
046pinpoint and Target what students need to continue growing and so that's where standards based report cards come in we know that our students need to learn the state standards in order to be proficient but we know that those are skills that are necessary for them to become productive citizens when they're done with with schooling um so standards based report card it evaluates student progress on a continuous basis towards specific learning objectives or standards um instead of traditional letter grades it provides more detailed feedback about proficiency so is your child proficient on a state standard or not we'll talk a little bit about the scale that we'll use here in a second um but truly standards based report cards are here to help teachers students parents understand exactly what a student needs at any given point
047in time we know that learning is is a progression and our students are in a variety of places so it really helps create some steps for each and every one of the students in a classroom so give you a couple of examples so if you were to get a report card let's say quarter 1 this is typically what we would see a 95% most parents are going to see this and go okay they're doing pretty good and not necessarily think about it again um we see an a we're we're pretty happy with that most of the time that means that they're doing well but are they at 100% have they mastered the content that they need every student has areas that they can continue to grow and develop so how do we help them if
048you were to get a standards based report card this is what quarter 1 would look like in instead so you see very specific skills that a student would need and what they were learning that quarter we'll talk a little bit about um the threes and twos and what those mean here in a second but from here you're taking math and really narrowing it down to individual skills when you get this information you can clearly see so the threes here mean they're on grade level a two means that they have some area where they can work um but one of the examples is I can find the product of a two two-digit number as a parent that's tangible I can help them with that I know exactly what I can do to help support my child
049as a teacher I know exactly where that student needs to work in order to continue to meet proficiency so that scale that you see is the same scale that we are going to be using as a district and it's from a one to a four what you can see down here is that a one is not meeting the standards so if you're using this bicycle analogy um means they're they're riding the bike they've got some skills but they're not ready to do it yet without those training LS a two means you're progressing towards the standard okay they're they're pedaling they're working they just might need somebody there to catch them if they fall um they might not be completely stable and independent the three that's grade level expectation um they're doing exactly what they need
050to do at that level they're right on target we could have decided to stop at a three but again we want to challenge those kids who maybe have already mastered that content we don't want to forget anyone so if they already have it we want to continue to push them so if they're a four it means they're exceeding that standard they're going above grade level expectation um this one is funny you can ride the bike but you can also do those stunts you can do jumps you can do flips all of the things so that is the scale that we will be using and again this is this nice visual kind of helps parents get an idea of of what what does that scale mean how are how are they using that to Define um
051proficiency or Mastery towards a standard are these aligning with the standard-based test though are so if we see this and we have 10 12 areas and I know my my uh son is he can do um Define four-digit or number sentence I can hardly read but um is that aligned with our state standard yes would you okay yes so that's so then if we need to work on that one area then when they go into the test we're saying that that's an area they they ought to do well when they go into the exam yes great question so these skills that you see here are taken directly from State Standards now these skills might be one standard there might be three different skills embedded within one standard but we've broken them down um I'll show
052you an example of what it's going to look like on our report card but that just gives you an idea of it is very skill based letting letting teachers parents students know exactly what they can do nice and then where our our cfas our common formative assessments that we've implemented this year are testing these skills so they are aligned that's how we're going to know whether student is a proficient at that skill or not and that's through Beyond textbooks the com for or you're not necessarily so yes we we have borrowed those assessments from Beyond textbooks because they already had assessments that were aligned to the standards okay so what are the benefits we're kind of go back to some of those key philosophies in the purpose of Standards based of report cards um but
053it sets a clear understanding of learning goals this is a lot of the work that we've done the last two years we've talked about state standards are normally a sentence maybe two with a couple bullet points underneath that's all the information we get it doesn't necessarily say here are all the things a student need needs to do in order to be proficient at that standard that's where we partnered with Beyond textbooks because they had done that work to develop that success criteria for each standard what does it take to be proficient in that standard so we now know we have the end goal and it's the same end goal for every teacher before with that one sentence there could have been five different interpretations of what that standard meant now we all have a very
054clear idea of what is the end goal that we're all working towards targeted feedback so we're giving those common formative assessments those cfas to students after we've done instruction with everyone and then if we're doing some retach opportunities we're giving that to them again to track how they're doing and really identify within that standard what are the skills that we still need to work on with those students instead of saying oh we've got the whole standard we're just going to teach the whole thing over again what we're seeing is when you really break down the information from those assessments it might be one or two little things that could help clear up some misund understandings for a student could be one component that they just need a little bit of extra practice with so it's
055in the end saving us a lot of time um instead of just guessing at what they need we have very targeted information and we're able to give that to teachers to students and to parents about what we can do to help each individual individual child um this one goes to kind of what you had just talked about which is greater consistency and Grading we're using those formative assessments everyone's giving the same assessment for the same standard and has the same grading expectations right now we are seeing teachers are grading in a variety of ways giving different assessments based on their understanding of those standards which again it's not their fault it's the system that we're in and we just don't have enough guidance from the state so they're doing what they can but with the
056structures we've put in place over the last couple years we have a lot of consistency within what those standards mean and how we're assessing them increased student motivation students sometimes sees that they have a d or an F it's really easy to give up but if they instead have okay here's the skill we're working on next you just you got this we're working on this it's a ladder for them to continue to to work through because they're building on skills um they might not be proficient but we use the word yet a lot so you don't have it yet but we're working on it sometimes D's and Fs are very discouraging and can cause children to give up and we do not want that differentiated instruction this is a piece that we're really working to
057master and develop this year as Educators um taking that data from those assessments based on where students are and creating intervention opportunities and extension opportunities for those kids who have already mastered content so really meeting each child where they're at on a regular basis when it comes to um the essential standards that we've identified standards based report cards are going to improve that instruction with parents we can more accurately and confidently tell parents here's where your students at here's what we're working on here's where we're we're trying to get them and to me this last one is probably the most important shift with all of Standards based instruction and standards based grading and it is that shift to a focus on learning we know that learning happens over time and each child learns at a
058different pace instead of just a focus on grades if we're just focusing on grades what you're going to see from students is compliance I'm going to do this so that I get this instead of I'm doing this so that I can learn this so that I can grow and I can do this next and I can do this next we want our our students to have a love of learning want them to be excited about it and we want that to be celebrated at the same time we want to make sure that they're excited about all of these skills that they're developing um throughout their time with us so challenges not only with standards based grading but with um standards based instruction there are a few so this first one is just confusion about the
059system we are used to doing things within the a Toof system that we grew up with that has been around for a long time I will tell you we are kind of behind the pendulum swing when it comes to standards based report cards there's a lot of districts who've been doing this for a decade um so there's places that have shifted but sometimes it can be hard to grasp we've spent two years of laying ground work with our team teachers and our instructional staff to get them ready and now our focus is on how are we going to help teachers prepare parents and families for this shift it's not something that we are ignoring we want to make sure that parents are confident when they read a standards based report card and then can go
060okay I know what my kids's learning I know where they're at I know where they're going I know how to help them get there so really building that team with our families difficulty in consistent application again this is something that we've spent two years laying groundwork on in the district of training our teachers bringing in formative assessments from Beyond textbooks bringing in unwrapped documents which give us clear outlines of what a standard means those are the pieces that we've had to put in place before we were ready to move forward with standards based report cards and then again impact impact on students what does this mean for them again they're really familiar with the grading practices that they have now if I turn in all my work I've got a good chance of getting a
061good grade um really flipping that in the mindset around not just doing work for grades but doing work to learn um and to reap the benefits of that so you have an example in front of you of the standards based report card template that we've created for K8 but then I also created a sample one for you to look at so we could talk through what do each of these components mean so what we have here is this is what most of our report cards K8 will look like next year um we've got all of our student identify information we will have school information here you will see days present days absent how many tardies do those do children have again that's a really good indicator for families and for teachers of maybe they need
062some intervention around coming to school um is that a barrier to them learning we want to make sure that that's that's at the Forefront then here you have the um the key this is really how the grades are to be interpreted and it's the exact same um language that we used in the in the bicycle piece so a four means highly proficient they're working above grade level standard three is proficient a two they are partially proficient so they've got some skills they're just not quite at that that grade level yet they've got some gaps and then minimally proficient they're they're lacking quite a few skills they don't have the skills necessary to be on grade level and then what you'll see is some students will have separate report that will be primarily special education students
063who maybe are not working on grade level but they've got IEP goals that are based a little bit different than our grade level expectations and then this last one means not assessed at this time and we'll go through an example of that on on this next slide here other components that we wanted to really be clear with parents are Support Services we want to make sure that a parent knows if a student's in reading intervention we want them to know that that's happening um if they have a 504 or an IP or they're an elll we want to make sure that that's communicated and that's clearly somewhere where both parents and teachers can access that information and ask questions if they have any questions however we also know that a part of kind of what
064we want to report on is not just progress towards standards but some of the study skills and the essential qualities that are really needed to be a good student and so we came up with schoolwide and really these are districtwide core values that we want to see in each of our students that we know are going to help them be successful and good community members within our school so we are reporting to parents on how are you how's your child doing here so if they for instance maybe are not as productive in class they're not using their time wisely we want to make sure that parents know that so that they can support at home and we can support at school so this is page one page two is where we get into individual standards
065so here you can see examples for ELA and math um I will tell you on our actual report card it will be longer than this you will see all of the standards for the year on here um but when you see here the in quarter one these were standards that were taught in quarter 1 these three standards were not taught yet um those were are coming up later in in the year then you can see Quarter Two they introduced a new standard and then by quarter three they had taught all of those standards um so a two means they're not quite at grade level they're partially proficient they have a lot of skills they're moving towards grade level but they're not there quite yet um and again these can change over time if they earned
066a two in first quarter doesn't mean that's where they're at Forever um again we learning is a is a progression and it's progress at different times for each kid so teachers will be able to change that grade for a standard if they are seeing that a student has mastered that so Kelsey is that determined by the the formative assessments that's going on yes okay yes so we'll start with the formative assessments however after like first quarter for these standards we do have some additional ways that that can be assessed so we do have some online learning platforms that do practice teachers will be able to see have they mastered it here not just on that formative assessment are they are they providing or demonstrating Proficiency in different ways and then they'll be able to change
067that based on some additional data points later and so I'm assuming that for each of these standards proficiency is defined somehow like yes it's not just up to the teacher saying you got 70% on this assessment or 80% on this assessment and it there's there's a definition of what this means so that it's standardized across the board yes that's where those unwrapped documents from our partnership with BT has come in they provide what that looks for um then with our formative assessments every formative assessment is five questions so we have defined as a district and this is based off of veil's experience if you have if you get five out of five you're highly proficient so you are performing above grade level if you get a four out of five which is an 80% you're
068at grade level so you're three and then we've scaffold it down from there so we are using that to help create um these final grades on the report card as well yeah great question so this is just a mini version of what you will see on the real report card just to give you an idea of what that looks like um when you when we do have our full report cards completed example the the standards you see under Ela or math those are not all of our state state standards there's no way we can test for proficiency on every single one of our state standards throughout the year so we have decided to narrow that down to what the most essential that are needed for that grade level and for the grade level Beyond and
069that's where you see these you're still going to see 20 to 25 standards um in each of these categories it's not that we're not teaching the rest of them they are just supporting standards that help support the standards that we have um identified as essential standards and then two additional pieces that you will see on report cards are specials for K4 so that's art music and PE we'll have grades for our K4 students for fifth through 8th grade our elective teachers have also identified essential standards and they'll be reporting on those um those are not built yet because we're working on embedding all of this into power school and there's some formatting things that we're working through and then the last piece you will see are comments we want teachers to be able to communicate
070any additional information that's going to help parents understand where their students are at and then next steps so we have our our template completed as you can see um we are working to update essential standards that are being taught in each grade and each subject we did initial work this year to identify those essential standards but we came into this year as this is a learning year we might have to make some small adjustments teachers have been talking about that have been working through that all year and so at the end of this year we'll identify okay we now know for sure these are the essential standards we want by quarter so that work is something we will continue to do throughout the end of this semester um we have Our IT department building this
071report card within power school we have to build that and customize that just for ourselves so working through that making sure that all the information populates correctly we are creating communication and a training plan for families we want to make sure that we have enough support that families really understand what this report card means and how they can use that as a tool to help their children and then additional training opportunities for teachers as we roll out a new report card system um we want to make sure that they're supported every step of the way as well so we're working on all of those different components at this time and that's where we're at you have a question that's a lot of great information um we have Brett and I have actually been visiting our
072schools these last couple of weeks and this has come up a lot especially uh in our elementary school levels and I have several just quick questions when it comes to grades when you're looking as a parent at Power School will parents be able to see how their child is performing on those individual cfas or will there be more of a general uh progression than that like or will it be as specific as how each CFA has gone terrific question yes so in power school when you were to click on the grade from that first page that we saw each individual standard will be there and you'll be able to see how they've done on those cfas so you can see their first CFA if they took it if they need it a second time you
073can see the second one so you can see growth and progress within the power school platform yes we want to make sure that that's transparent and that's K8 but even our high school teachers are giving these formative assessments based on standards you will see them in high school um grades when you click on that in power school as well okay Kelsey great job uh excellent presentation very informative um Jen asks really good questions and I ask really basic questions so I got a couple for you um kind of feel like I'm coming in partway through this has been a lot of groundwork and so where have we seen this effective you mentioned Veil School District I've heard that come up a couple times is there other school districts that have used this effectively and is
074there some school districts that have tried this and haven't been successful um I know I know you guys do your homework I'm just kind of wondering what the background backstory is on some of this yes so standards based instruction and standards based grading has been around for about 15 years um in some places is probably even longer um the largest push was in the early two mid 2000s um Vil is a district who's doing this incredibly well and that's why we partnered with them they spent years building their instructional resources around great level proficiency on standards that's something that the state doesn't provide to us so they created it we were actually in the process of starting that and then we came across BT and went okay if we partner with them it's going to
075save us three to five years and we can jump to where we are now um so Veil is one and they are one of the top performing districts in the entire state so what their system and what they're doing is working with students um right now more of the bigger schools are doing this than not they're they're implementing standards based report cards Flagstaff has them Deer Valley has them I think Cave Creek so some of the really large districts have already implemented this humbl implemented standards based report cards um I want to say three years ago but again they spent years working up and building to to implementing so and they most of those school just seen positive outcomes from from this procedure yes most schools do where you see some school districts not as
076effective is when they don't spend enough time training families on what this means um if you were to give a report card to a family who's never seen a standards based report card it can be really overwhelming and frustrating we don't want any of our families to feel that way we want to make sure that they have all of the knowledge needed so that they can understand what's on those report cards and they really have some actionable items of how they can help their their child and I noticed there's a mechanism for the teachers to to respond to parents or comments is there a mechanism in place that the that the families can answer the questions back to the teachers or so we have lots of communication ways for for families to get in touch
077with teachers at the elementary we use everything from Blackboard which is our communication system they're really great at collecting email there's a program called class Dojo that allows them to connect through an app um at our high school we're seeing some similar things there's a program called remind where they can text back and forth without personal information it's all through the app so we have quite a few ways that families can connect with teachers all throughout um the one other area I do want to stress that we've seen standards based report cards be effective is we implemented standards based report cards in kindergarten about eight or nine years ago I think 2016 so it was my first year when I was um principal at Taylor Hicks and that has gone really well um being an
078elementary principal we didn't have families who didn't understand that this is what they knew but our teachers did a really great job of talking parents through that so we talked about them at back to school night parent teacher conferences and then all throughout so it was really successful and it's been really successful in our kindergarten and my last comment is I love the I love the increased motivation I love I love the focus on learning to learn not learning to get a grade and I I went to school for a lot of years and and I was learning to get a grade A lot of times and it's been later in life where I've said I want to I want to learn this material because I because I I love it right and so I'm
079excited about that Prospect me too um one question I have is uh will power school work with this for our students and families okay yes so we so the assessment platform that we have where students are taking those formative assessments feed it's partnered with power school it feeds directly in so those grades are automatically imported into the grade book so teachers can see them there parents can see them there um it and then our report cards are built within power school and printed out through there so they they talk very nicely to each other okay so we don't have to change that platform no no no no they'll be work on the back end to develop this but there are lots of districts including humble that okay does just this correct so Kelsey what would
080a teacher's grade book look like so you have homework you have assignments you have the formative assessments walk me through kind of uh what all that encompasses and then what does it spit out on the end and then how does that tie into a GPA you know because obviously Max and Kaylee and and Vanessa are looking like that that really transitions obviously as they're trying to go through a school so the GPA is probably the primarily Prim primary reason we're not doing standards based report cards at the high school level um because they for the system that they're in and for colleges and and all of that they still need those traditional grades we're going to be working on embedding some standards based grading within there which is you'll see an assignment or an assessment
081in their Gradebook aligned to a standard so we can track progress that way um grade books will look different from K4 to 58 so in kindergarten through fourth grade primarily what you're going to see are the common formative assessments or benchmark assessments so you'll see progress towards that um the days of just doing completion grades oh you turned this in I'm going to give you a grade for that you will not see that as much K4 um there might be a few things just for tracking purposes that teachers do but it won't necessarily translate to a grade most of just the grades that will come out will be based off of the skills in the standards when you get to fifth through eth grade they will have a few more of those things because they
082are doing practice assignments they are doing additional components that will feed into oh um those citizenship core value grades that you see on productivity so if they're not turning in work it'll be based off of that from the grade book does that help answer your question it does okay so then what are we going to do next steps just for getting assessments and then also getting them prepared to take the state exam at you know above ninth grade what are we looking at so that's we're doing the all of the common formative assessments aligned to standard so they're doing all of the same work they're just not translating that to a report card at the end which is what K is doing so my question is does do parents get that feedback on not not
083they will they will because it'll be within their Gradebook they'll be able to see here's the standard here's how they've done on that standard on that whether it's the formative assessment or The Benchmark we're also working to better align classroom assignments and activities to each standard so there's a way in power school that we can say okay here's practice for this standard I can tag it as this standard so a parent can go in and see all of the work for one standard you're able to sort it and go okay I know how they're doing on this particular standard for this quarter Carly Vanessa what do you think did I call you Kaylee earlier yeah I'm sorry it's okay yeah only my like seventh time here wow and look Miss got us these nice better
084tags for nothing it's hard to see from here I know I moved it just in case you needed the help thank you spicy that's yes I think it's a great idea I was just talking with um a teacher at preset high school today about a big problem that we see with um like grades you just submit a grade or an assignment for a grade and I think if if this works it like really work like I think that it could really change the way students perceive school and I think that's really important yeah um I think for me I feel like the biggest part about this like the biggest um I guess benefit from this would be a big boost in confidence I feel like um me and my two younger brothers and my older
085brother that already graduated we a lot of the times we base oursel off of letter grades and especially my mom when uh my brothers get report cards and and things um she's always kind of asking me like oh what does this mean or like um what what are they learning and I'm like Mom I don't really know but um I think with this I I feel like even for myself I think I have a better chance at explaining things to her and I think uh especially for my younger brothers they have a boosting confidence yeah thanks no more going to Disneyland for straight Ace that's right [Laughter] buddy well we don't know we don't know not yet right never tested that there yeah any other questions for I do have one more I was wondering
086if this what kind of impact will this have for students who are not achieving by the end of the school year you know I think in the past we've had some struggles with knowing when it's appropriate to have a child reped grade or when it's appropriate for uh intervention more serious intervention for a student moving forward and it feels like we'll have a much more clear perspective of where a child is and whether or not they're really ready to go to the next grade level yes um one of the benefits from standards-based grading and and instruction is that we know exactly where they're at on grade level expectations how far below are they are they at grade level are they above so the ability to intervene much sooner on very specific areas of learning um
087can happen faster um from what you're seeing it's not as subjective of like well I think they're low in reading so we're going to address these things because I think this is what they what they need we have data to show they've got this or they don't have this so it helps us narrow that focus and intervene immediately which is why this year we spent so much time building in um intervention opportunities because teachers are giving that formative and the next day sometimes even the same day you're seeing them start to add some of those interventions in um our previous assessment platform we only gave that three times a year and it was on all of our grade level standards so it didn't give teachers a lot of really actionable data they have immediate actionable
088data in their hand so they're assessing students um every couple of weeks on standards and they're able to adjust instruction immediately yeah i' really appreciate that I was about to mention it's not like we've been wandering in the dark without any data to inform how to intervene when students need interventions but the the the real key for me is it's it's more immediately available and actionable than it has been in the past I think it'll help us take great strides toward helping students progress y well said all right great thanks again kson thank you all right moving on to item six item sixa summary of current events uh Mr Tenny yes sir okay we got a couple of slides here thanks for being here Mick Vickers is thank you so much for being here Max
089thanks buddy great job Max take care Tiffany thank you for being here congratulations thank you app it pretty cool good stuff lest you think that Max and Vanessa and Carly are the only Stellar students at Prescot High School got some additional evidence recently that we've got other outstanding kids uh there uh the Flynn Foundation scholarship is a scholarship many of you may have heard heard of before my understanding is up through recently I don't know we've got firm data on this but we were told this once recently from the Flynn folks that there are more Flynn Foundation scholarship uh winners from Prescot High School than than any other school in the state that's our size so for you know we're punching well above our weight as far as this is concerned there's a there's a
090rigorous process uh for applying for this and being selected for this students have to be Stellar in essentially every area and we had two finalists um for this or two uh and two semi-finalist thank you two semi-finalists for this and then they're down to the final stage you can see the data there over 200 high schools from across the state um uh worked with students to to nominate over 1100 candidates for this and these are top students to begin with right it's not like you know you pull a Clark Tenny out and say oh maybe this guy will work nope these are kids who are are fantastic and the cream of the crop from the cream of the crop 1100 students Statewide we're down to 35 kids and one of them is our friend Malia
091harosa at Prescot high school so we want to congratulate her on that and we're excited to see what the next steps are my understanding are there's usually about 15 to 20 students were awarded this scholarship so she's got an excellent chance at this point we're really proud of all of our kids who considered this and and have the qualifications have applied in the first place kind of a neat um honor for her next we had some great things happen sports-wise you've probably been following our girls soccer team ranked number one in the state and our boys basketball team ranked number one the state many of our other very successful teams at Mile High Middle School they just had they just participated in the Middle School State Wrestling champions championships excuse me and they were uh
092they came out Victorious they were they were the champions um particularly three student the entire team participated in one way or another but particularly there were three students who who placed especially highly Jeremiah vill Anda was the state champion in his weight class um I I won't point out that he weighs just about the same as me so there there's that um good for him for I mean he's he's a big boy and wrestled against some other big boys and came out Victorious he would have pinned me in seconds I have no doubt uh Riley rickets was second place in in her State Division and then Henry Hampton the fourth was appropriately fourth place in the state and there um their efforts added to the team scoring and the team came out as the champions
093of the entire State kind of neat and you can see the the various assistant coaches who helped volunteer to make that possible for our kids we're really proud of them Cesar estorga the last one mentioned there is he related maybe to officer yes okay there you go so yes this is our new our new uh student resource offic at Granite Mountain um upper elementary school as part of the the coaching staff there that's great Brian will you explain this for us Brian wasn't expecting this to be no um if you do your job well you get this you don't you get fired so that's pretty much the summary of it um you know there's just so many reports that we have to do and um and this one just has to do with if you
094have a bond that's outstanding that you're still paying there's increased um disclosures for transparency that you have to upload and do and they put it in something called an Emma system that anybody can go to and so um I I got this and I I actually threw it away so someone in my office took it out um and so obviously they're recognizing for longevity wise you know put getting them in on time and having them accurate and so um Brian's a modest guy but we get accolades from the auditor general and from various auditing um companies that work with us and from this organization all the time about the excellent work that he does and being transparent and accurate with our financial reporting as we talk with you about uh over the coming months where
095we're at budgetarily and what we recommend going forward and and how we compare to other districts you will see that we are in very very good hands with our finances and I do know who gave it to Sarah out of my trash and that will be uh debt will be paid to [Music] tomorrow I just want to say yeah yeah so thank you for the recognition and then finally we want to you bet thank you Brian really really appreciate the work you do that's outstanding sorry if that embarrassed you but do do that we promise we won't fish other things out of your trash and put them up on the screen here very often at least uh we want to recognize the passing of of two icons in in presc history who've made a lot
096of impact on uh our school district and on our uh city and county one is Cal ctis who was a longtime teacher uh for us ctis Junction that's his family and there was an excellent write up in the paper Sunday was it Sunday that that there you go and his obituary ran was it also Sunday or did that come out yesterday I want to say it been yesterday there you go anyhow ctop for us for 27 years is that what I'm remembering something like that and was a great coach and then after his his career teaching for us once he retired he was on campus almost as much as he had been before you couldn't have a PHS sporting event that this guy wasn't there supporting the students and the coaches and the families pretty
097neat he will be missed another great gentleman who passed recently was Roy Simmons Ry was the I think three-term mayor of Prescot in addition to a County supervisor and also the husband of our former HR Director Christa Simmons and we we note um and acknowledge his passing and the great things that he did for our community and are saddened by by his passing and our heart goes out to his family as well want to just make note of that I think that's all I have thanks for putting that in about K and relly very special um you know Cal was a State ofing Community he said he was sitting in that booth that is named app named after him um just all the work that he did with uh not only baseball but you know
098just within the community survived a I mean I realize it was 99 years old is that we're yeah I mean he just yeah yeah Adam for you like bu for Snickers that's that's I'm just doing a cow impersonation so I did that because he used to always announce at all the basketball games all the all the um uh baseball games he just knew C's voice and he had a vice grip of a handshake for 99 years so pretty amazing and then relly I don't know Sarah you're really close with them as well and really tight with Christa but you know just uh he didn't know you really didn't have enemies he was just everybody was your his friend and you know he uh he just shined always shined and just a a very very kind
099heart we'll miss him um how about the uh board members start with you Brett update um in the last month Jen and I have started our listening tour so our goal is you know lots of people have asked us what are your goals for for school board and we decided we wanted to listen to see what teachers and staff and students and parents had to say before we uh created Created our goals and so this um Clark's actually set these up for us and I think he spent a good part of a day making getting the calendar ready so we appreciate we appreciate that and it's uh very much appreciated and we have had a great time and usually over the lunch hour we'll go to a school we've uh we've been to let see
100we started at B A Jud and then we went to Prescot high school and Taylor Hicks last week and I think we have two more this week we're going to uh this campus here and then uh uh Lincoln School and it has been fantastic we have uh I've learned a lot uh Jen I've learned that Jen is uh well vered in uh school board and parenting issues and I have a lot to to learn to catch up uh so I appreciate uh her help I have to ask her for acronym definitions regularly and then I've also been to many of the Prescot high school basketball games and um enjoy being on campus and meeting people and I I tell you a couple of times I've had a teacher say there's no place I'd rather be
101I am in my dream job and that I think is uh speaks a lot to to the the district to the administration and uh and um it's it's a it's great to be a partner with this school district than BR well I've been hanging out with Brett at at all these schools and um it has been really incredible I just have to say the staff is amazing and it's it's not only our teachers I would say we have had a lot of PA professionals come in and speak to us and share with us their experiences why they do what they do um some have so much energy I can't even believe it I'm like wow you are in the right job um I would say the thing that has stood out to me the most
102is just the in incredible dedication of our sped departments they come and they advocate for their students very very well um from all levels of of District level all the way to our parapros that are spending day in and day out walking around with their student and it has been really impactful I've been uh blown away and learned so much about what they're doing um and I think for we went to the high school and um we were we were not their facilities are very small where they eat lunch those teachers we were in a separate classroom and it was really amazing how many people came to visit us and talk to us and see uh let us know what they think and how things are going and again a lot of people just saying
103this is the best job they've ever had so it's been really uh eye openening really positive um very much a desire to constantly see the district get better so it wasn't a you know it could just be a complaining session and that hasn't been our experience at all so and uh Jen talked about uh today she talked about maybe um finding a a way that we can record some of our our what we've experienced some positive things that they've said some negative things and maybe at our Retreat we could get on the agenda and we could uh present some of some of that and see what we'd like to maybe maybe yeah so we can share with the rest of you what we've learned okay great Andy um I've been working on setting up my
104regular visits with our specialist director and visiting schools that way um haven't been doing my usual monthly visits at the high school yet but I do go up to the high school once a week for other things and I get to meet with students individually and as a group up there um I just want to Echo what Brett and Jen are saying you know every teacher I interact with every staff person I interact with is polite and friendly and does their best to make sure you feel and have what you need to do the work that you're there to do so um you know can't speak highly enough about what our staff is doing and I know that's the same at all the schools I've just focused on the high school uh one thing I
105do want to point out I did try to go to a basketball game that was advertised for a home game on uh MLK day and it turns out it was at a Showcase Event down in Phoenix but presca was the home team so I showed up at the high school and it was about 30 degrees outside they said you can stay and watch the soccer game and I'm like I am not dressed for soccer Outdoors um so I didn't get to see them play I haven't been able to get to many events up there this spring yet um which I I'm sorry I missed but um looking forward to maybe getting to some more uh I'll be attending the board operations leadership training SE seminar in Flagstaff on Friday this week um and I think
106that's it great uh just a couple of events uh for Lincoln uh we've got the family dance and auction um which is a big fundraiser for the school hosted by the PTA and that's this Thursday we're not auctioning families to be clear oh this is true yeah I hope yeah sounds like it might be sorry yeah um then reading and feeding as a monthlong uh reading program at Lincoln and and they're going to be um reading uh the goal is 100,000 minutes for the month and and there's also a feeding component of this and so it's all an effort to develop great citizens uh great basketball games great soccer games just met uh just left the soccer game uh with uh it was senior night for the girls so can't believe we're at senior night
107already and uh and that we're we're well past the middle of the year um and then Brett didn't say it but at one of the basketball games by a Jud sang at uh at the for the national anthem his son sang in there and uh yeah his pipes are very loud and but we actually sang two national anthems that game so it was a little confusing patriotic but we were very patriotic that but but I am always amazed at the at the patriotism and reverence of all of our students anytime we we play the national anthem and it's just a husher grow uh across the crowd and and everybody acts appropriately um and then um I think that's all I have for that uh Carly uh you're next oh good um I went to the
108regional Yavapai County Spelling be yeah it was very impressive I never made it that far um for a good reason like I had literally never heard of half of those words I was like and like neither had the women like the professors presenting it they were like what does that mean and they didn't know either and everyone spelled it right and that was the craziest part so that was just really good to get to interact with it was like all of Yavapai County and a b a Jud sent home um like little flowers with us and it's just really nice um National Honor Society I love my club we're doing a toiletry drive right now we're partnered with Stepping Stones youth we also have our talent show on the 26th of this month at the
109high school and we are introducing it to the entire District this is the first time we've opened it up to the community and the entire district and not just PHS students um so we're hopeful that we will get a younger generation involved on Thursday this Thursday mock trial has a scrimmage at the juv in front of in that courtroom um and it's just a really good opportunity because our actual competition is at the courthouse um but the judge there is so nice and she's so like critical and way that lots of students need before a competition so it's a really good opportunity for them and obviously it's a good opportunity for anyone to just get to stand up there in an actual courtroom in front of an actual judge um and discuss a case and
110next Thursday is J razzi's military ball which they put on every year I I'll be going this my third year and they have a very big ceremony and it's just really great um for their Club it brings them together a lot and it just gives you um some awareness of the procedures they do and things like that that's all great all right so um yesterday a began their super their Super Bowl Drive um they're collecting um any non- perishable food items so if any of you want to go donate uh to support any of the two teams correct me if I'm wrong is it the Chiefs and the Eagles it is I'm not a big fan but you know my my my four um it's always it's a Taylor Swip um and then our mic
111Ted we're having a campus Tour on March 12th uh like Miss Bailey mentioned like how we've been mentioning these past couple meetings um miic T offers um one to twoe programs um for classes sophomore through seniors um we have I think three campuses um and students are able to go tour them and kind of just get a f of what um classes they could be taking uh next year and then January 15th uh interact Club had a welcoming party to three of our foreign exchange students they are from Germany and Vietnam uh they were able to uh kind of just learn about programs and extracurriculars that are not offered at schools um in their home country so I think that's a very nice thing that PHS has to offer and then like we've been mentioning
112Sports uh on the 30th um our boys and girls girls had their basketball game against Bradshaw I'm pretty sure both of them won oh yeah uh now they're standing the boys are standing at a 9 to1 and a 9 to1 record and then the girls are at a 9 to2 and then Our Ladies of S Club we've been making some Valentine's Day purses for our um homeless ladies at the um for the soup kitchen so these purses we've um filled them up with a bunch of different toiletries uh you know Necessities basic necessities um that a women may need and won't have or not always have um resources to and I would just like to Echo off of what our board members were saying for our special education programs I do want to say thank
113you all very much for everything you guys do um my my youngest brother he's 10 he's at a j he uh has Down syndrome and so he he's been at Discovery Gardens AB Jen and Taylor Hicks and the progress he has made is amazing every day he um gets off the bus he has a huge smile on his face unless he was sleeping in the bus his but other than that he is always super excited Super um motivated uh in the early mornings when he has to go to school and uh he just learned a lot of stuff and I do want to say thank you all for for thanks Vanessa he's a great young man neat to see him when we go over there all right item 6B uh Community comments shared with the
114governing board anybody have just a lot of comments about our upcoming yeah item that's great the one thing that we got we received a a a comment from Judge Carman is that who's working with you at mock trial or she is actually not one of our judges but she doing the program at pres guy school that does um the like social media awareness um but she's not one of our mock trial um coaches but she works like pretty closely with Miss Lee who's the right the law teacher and our mon trial advisor but she's doing this like really big really wonderful program about um like awareness to the students at PHS right now about like social media and things like that yeah we just received tremendous feedback from her just about the just the professionalism
115of our our kids and just how they're they treat their their basically heads and tails above even some of the other schools that they kind of see and uh I think as a testament to the kids themselves obviously and the group that we have but it was very gracious of her to at least take the time and and write a letter to all of us about that yeah it was super neat she just mentioned that of all the schools she goes to that our she finds our PHS students to be the most engaged engaged and responsive and that's that's pretty neat feedback she gets to a lot of places and has some good perspective that way and what a great program that one judge one school piece that Carly was referring to where she there
116there judges that might meet these students under other circumstances if things go sideways in their future and they get with them early and they say hey here's some decisions you might want to think about you may not have thought about if you do this this could this could go wrong quickly so really think twice and we know it's been impactful for our students as well it's part of our Freshman Academy course where she and another judge come in and present that's great thank you all right next item is item 7A consent agenda are there any items anybody would like to highlight or pull questions um I do Jane normally has been reading um lately the donations and Gifts um so I'll be highlighting item 7 A2 um we had a donation from yaai title for
117$500 the PHS choir a donation from presc Lakes pickle ball Club $200 to the PHS choir um donation from GBU life um $100 to put wherever we need it most a donation from Signal Hill Petroleum uh $54 52 cents for PHS Athletics a donation from Brad bergamini uh pllc a donation uh in the amount of $1,250 to PHS Athletics thanks Brad and Jen um a donation from uh Andrea Kelly $25 to Lincoln Elementary a donation from Bonnie and Tom Deo uh $2,000 to the PHS challenge Club a donation from preset Sunrise Lions Foundation a check uh for $22 or $22,000 75 OR7 2275 you know sh you're probably better at that 20 two Discovery Gardens um and then there's uh several donations that we recognized Les Fenderson Mr Fenderson to all of us uh last
118month um but in memory of Les Fenderson there were several donations one from Nancy relly for $50 to PHS Athletics uh Barbara Ry for $50 to PHS Athletics and then Dr George and Judy Sarah $100 of PHS Athletics all in memory of Mr Fenderson that's it um moving on to item 7B need to approve yeah thank you do that a lot um I will consider a a a motion to approve the consent agenda so moved moved do we have a second second moved and second and all in favor say I I I and opposed okay now moving on to item 7B study and voting session um do we have any calls of the public two okay in the order that we received okay one and okay I just want to read this uh before we
119start the uh the public comment uh thank you for showing interest in the public process our governing board is interested in hearing from all who want to speak we are also determined to maintain appropriate deorum please be sure that your comments are respectful and constructive are specific to the voting item for which we have signed up to speak if a speaker Strays off topic for too long they'll be asked to conclude their remarks we want every person who is interested in speaking to be treated with respect and to have their full time to speak so speakers will be called to the podium uh this will occur in the order of voting items in the order that individuals requests to speak to each item as your turn to speak approaches please move uh to be near
120the podium to ensure smooth transitions if speakers are not ready uh when called they may be moved back in order that shouldn't be difficult with the two uh we plan to give every speaker up to three minutes um if you're still speaking at three minutes you'll be asked to finish but we also reserve the right um to listen more if we if we'd like to okay so um brief uh polite Applause after a speaker is fine if you're so inclined uh no shouting please while a person is at the podium please no comments or other uh intentional noise such as cheering or booing from the audience during their comments if public Quorum is not maintained we will recess the meeting under or until order can be restored per open meeting laws board members are not
121allowed to respond to public com ment except to clarify misinformation if necessary all right so our first uh person is Andy Nelson Andy good evening uh District administration and uh governing board members thank you for your service um I am here as an individual not coordinated with any other and my comments in emails that predate this evening are well known in those emails I received answers regarding the current public policy uh regarding I'm sorry policy regarding public comment that in effect stated this is the way we do things and it's served the board well and we have no cause to change I feel as though this opportunity is a similar to a solar eclipse um when the Sun and the Moon have aligned to actually make public comment about public comment the study and voting
122agenda BB reads Community comment M shared with board members board members May Briefly summarize the comment or concern shared with them by the Community member board members may not read or present lengthy prepared statements or letters from community members why the heck not uh one board member explained to me that board members would mention Community comments if they felt it was appropriate and I would add if they ever remembered to do so this is a very subjective and conditional criteria the public comment must be then be summarized and repackaged by a board member in their own words to make it brief what is wrong with a letter being read for its proper context and what is lengthy my letter that was read in December's meeting was timed to be read by myself in three minutes
123but I was not allowed and I understand why no instruction was given for how that letter was to be read by the board member in full or in part or even if it was to be anonymous or not and I make no apologies for asking it to be read now adoption of uh 7.b do3 would stifle public comment even further I ask for a no adoption vote next bedh any individual Desiring to address the board about a topic that is agendized on the study and voting section of the agenda can you give me one example of a public concern that was communicated to board members and then mentioned during a public comment section of the agenda and then actually made it through the gauntlet to become a study and voting agenda item I can't and
124this is the very reason I am concerned that our voice is being stifled because of a prohibitive process even if a public comment were to be mentioned and some day were to make it to the study and voting agenda they would have to vigilantly check the agenda each month to see month after month wondering if their concerns would actually be addressed then they would have to sift through the agenda to identify exactly what was being studied and voted on the language is cloaked in legal jargon that no one would be able to decipher unless they were extremely in uh informed here it is again 7.b do3 consider adopting the proposed changes to asba policies bedb and bedh that's all it says I don't think anybody understands what that means I ask for a no vote
125on adoption of both these policies is the district who writes these agendas trying to make it hard for the public to understand and participate stricken from the record stricken from the former policy if the if this were to be adopted other words open call open call for public comment Do you want to build trust and transparency make open public comment more available what is the district afraid of thank [Applause] you Miss uh an Marie De Carlo thank you I appreciate the chance to be here tonight I'm going to read because that I can be succinct so my name again is an Marie De Carlo and I'm going to start by saying my understanding of the open public comment here in this district is that unless an issue of concern has been placed on the voting
126agenda just what the gentleman had explained public comment is restricted only to such items this differs in uh from other school districts uh both Dewey Humbolt and Chino Valley provide for public comment that's very open they allow three minutes per speaker up to a total of 30 minutes on any issue doesn't have to be on the voting agenda it's kind of like that listening session you go to the schools to listen to what they have to say this is the Public's way of coming to you and it's easy they don't have to sift through material agendas definitions they can just talk and tell you what they think under your current guidelines public concerns must be made known through private communication with one or more board members by phone or email from what I understand at
127least a few board members must think the concern is relevant or important enough for it to be brought forth as an agenda item only once a concern comes as an agenda it item then the public can comment in essence this methodology is a form of sensorship a true open comment Forum would allow any taxpayer to address the entire board with the time limit of course to be respectful on any matter of concern in front of in front of other members of the public in attendance on any issue of concern not necessarily those on the voting agenda or those that have been screened ahead of time I would think the board would welcome this opportunity from the community frankly this would not disrupt your meetings or other important items on your agenda and at most it
128would just extend maybe the board uh meeting by a small amount of time in return you and the other members of the public would have the opportunity to know what's on the mind of the community even if the concerns voiced are criticisms of the current policies or whatever the case may be the current method of bringing concerns to the board creates a lack of transparency and does not adequately give the public the optic that you are hearing and listening to all concerns probably most importantly public comment uncensored at the monthly board meeting is vital because it allows other members of the community to hear the concerns of other taxpayers something they're not going to get to do if it's going through an email and then through a sifting process and that that would make them
129aware of any other concerns that other taxpayers may have I just want to take one second to hearken back to the covid pandemic to illustrate the importance of what I'm advocating for many school board members I was in Pennsylvania at the time to with in Arizona who were absolutely well-intentioned thought they were adhering to the science with the masking and social distancing rules many parents strongly disagreed but were made to comply had they not had the freedom to speak at board meetings important information about the dangers of masking and the mental health issues brought on by social isolation policies would never have been heard by the Schoolboard members or other members of the community we should always provide for a free and open Forum to help you serve this community in the best way possible
130thank you for your time and consideration [Applause] uh so item 7b1 consider approving an outof State travel request for PHS challenge Club students PD staff members and volunteers to travel to the San Juan River in Utah from June 8th through the 14th 2025 Mr de all right well hi everyone um I of course have the privilege of representing our amazing challenge Club um so if you guys don't know much about that it's uh quite the program with outdoor adventure but Outdoor Learning opportunities and I think they've done a great job this is the fourth year that they're asking to go on this San Juan river trip um I think the key details for you is that it's going to be uh 18 students unless they can get the um the permit up to 25 and
131not 18 students excuse me 18 total people um their usual is about a 3:1 or 4:1 ratio when it comes to um having some kind of chaperone to students on this trip so those are the big pieces that I think they've done great with it it's been a great learning experience for them um and they get to experience the uh full river rafting that they can any questions what's your recommendation oh well as you can see I love the idea no I I really do I I think this is a special program and every year these kids come back talking about this trip as being something that they just won remember for the rest of their lives so I don't think that uh I can imagine better response than that from kids who experienced this
132Adam would this be the third time that the challenge Club has taken this specific trip don't fourth I had to double check with Mr Dean who yes is supervising soccer otherwise he would be here to uh give you all the ins and outs of this is this a different timeline than it was previous years I I don't remember it happening in June I guess yeah I believe that they pushed it back back into the summer um I'm not sure why it probably was related to permit availability okay I just um I think it adds a concern of heat in in that Canyon uh so I'm sure they'll factor that in but that's it's a it's a much more hot time of year that time so you know I I feel confident that that we've got
133some uh experienced people on this trip who would be able to uh deal with whatever issues come up but I will I would happily voice those concerns to the team too and Mr Dean is leading it is that yes y okay and I would like to voice my confidence in Mr Dean I was like interested in this program for a little and he is like so passionate about this like I would have never guessed and then one day I talked to him he like loves the outdoors and he like just and has a as well so he understands the concerns of like a parent perspective as well and um I would just voice my confidence in him and his ability to lead this team I would trust him to leave me through like the Amazon
134jungle that's pretty good recommendation no Carly I'm gonna quote you on that that was really good yeah all right thanks Carly um I will consider a motion to to approve an out ofate travel request for the PHS challenge Club students PSD staff members and volunteers to travel to the San Juan River in Utah from June 8th to the 14 2025 so moved I have a motion to have second second motion second all in favor I all right another great year thank you so much all right item 7 B2 uh consider adopting the proposed changes to asba policy advisory 808 volume um 36 36 great all right it uh 36 uh number uh six from November 2024 Mr binder yeah thank you so this uh this is a uh policy or actually a regulation revision um
135around a uh specific deadline and some details of what is required in an IEP uh just a little background uh all IEPs all students with an IEP um one of the crucial pieces of that especially at the high school level is to have a plan and deadlines uh in there about uh their their progression towards graduation um it's something that the teacher the student and the parents all work together on to make sure that everyone's on the same page working towards that graduation uh this regulation just simply ensures that that uh that plan is in place by the end of their nth grade year uh I can tell you as as principal of mile high this was a common uh discussion and a component of the IPS at the middle school level so this is
136nothing new for for our district and certainly is not going to make uh a whole lot of we're not going to need to make a whole lot of changes because like I said it's already in place um but just making sure that that is uh in the regulation and we're aligned with the state regulations any questions on that this one we often have new um state regulations that require us to to at least consider changing our board policy that matches with procedure we've had in place for a long time this is a good example of that sorry I flipped it over yeah yeah what we this is a huge advisory that was put out um do we know the specific pages I mean I I had it last time it's near the end all of
137them are underlined and they're all I'll tell you in just a second here yeah it has to do graduation it's quite a ways down the very long document um oh it logged off and I know we discussed this at the last meeting I just wanted to pull it up on my computer just to review okay thank you yep anybody have any concerns of the 30day period I actually talked to some of the um teachers at the high school regarding it and they indicated that we have been practicing this for a very long time and they actually have almost always instituted uh graduation goals and graduation dates with their students through their IEPs as part of their goal setting process is what it sounded like to me absolutely I'm just ballparking but I'd say maybe two
138out of three times there's a new law that triggers policy advisory from any of the policy um subscription Services says hey you need to write this in your policy something we're already doing all right uh no further discussion I'll consider take a motion to consider adopt the proposed changes in asba policy advisory 808 volume 36 number six from November 2024 so moved motion a second second motion second all in favor say I I I None opposed um item 7 B3 consider adopting the proposed changes to ASB policies bedb and BH uh Mr binder all right thank you so uh two different policies here but uh obviously somewhat related uh the first one BB uh just a little clarification we actually revised this uh policy relating to the the format of the board agenda last summer
139um and uh you know we worked with our uh our district attorney we worked with the county superintendent make sure we understood all the different components uh the the uh Community comments section uh was included and uh the most recent addition is to basically provide additional clarification on what that uh what that section of the agenda should include and so um that's that's bedb do we want to do you have any questions on that before I move on to bedh or you want me to explain them both and then we questions are we taking these as separate votes or as One V there's there's one agenda item if you prefer to table one of them or change one of them or what not you certainly can separate them out prior to the vote but they're
140being presented as one agenda item let's start with the discussion on BB first okay and then we'll the side just as as history I think we instituted this in our agenda in 2022 um as a response uh because we had this discuss comments on an open call to the public um and it was it was determined at that point by the board that the open call while there are benefits to it it also presents the opportunity for every we could have every month we could have preaching to us we could have someone presenting information that uh you know is tells us that all school buses should be painted green um things that are not relevant to the work that that we do so the community comment section was added at request of board members uh
141to allow for them for the the board members to present information they've received from the community in a board meeting um it is not meant as a filter it is not meant as anything other than an opportunity for those types of things to be brought forward um and that's the purpose of the community comments section um if board members are not bringing comments forward then I assume they're not receiving comments from the community or they're not doing a good job at bringing them to the meeting right right so can you read exactly what we're adding on this one what that blue type yeah so this is uh bedb uh section F2 uh Community comments shared with board members and the uh the addition would be or the proposal would be board members May Briefly summarize
142the comment or concern shared with them by the Community member board members may not read or present lengthy prepared statements or letters from community members yeah so the verbiage on this is Briefly summarize is what we're looking at right yeah that's the big change I I agree with this in in theory because it's not agendized we shouldn't be bringing I mean it's it's a violation of the open meeting laws if we come with a with a topics and agenda and we carry them out and they're not brief it is a little ambiguous to me though that that um you know you know what what constitutes brief and what constitute Len lengthy I I don't know if uh I mean I don't know if we need to dial that in a little bit more but but
143I think the concept is good yeah and and in line with open meeting laws yeah is there something you'd like to see in I don't know I I uh it's a good question I come up with a without a solution um I think we probably can deal with that and we be respectful um but I'm okay with the way it's way it's written okay what do you think John I would like to see us have uh potentially a way that our public can comment easier maybe than emails or phone calls or you know the more personal touches I think even the emails you know like we were able to receive from Andy this these upcoming upcoming into this event it kind of creates an open meeting struggle in and of itself because all five of
144us are placed on a single email all five of us cannot communicate on an email so then we each have to respond individually and then it's responded again to all of us in an email and so it just creates a bit of a open meeting conundrum because then we might be hearing each other's opinions without us intending to hear one another's opinions outside of the boardroom so I was trying to brainstorm some ideas as to how we could make sure we are collecting that information that for sure the The Giver of set information is being informed as to the status of their question as to the status of whether or not it's being considered for an agenda item whether or not it's um been heard and received by all board members the the thing I
145do in practice in my own business is using things like Google forms or something of that nature where they're given a receipt it is automatically sent Never by never determined by the superintendent whether or not to send it on to the school board but that the school board can be added to every single uh Google form receipt does that make sense like when you if you don't know what Google forms does when you respond it sends to whomever you have set it to go to and that can't just be willingly Changed by the topic that is brought forth so everyone would receive it um we would all have the contact information of the person if we wish to gain more clarity if we want to go to the superintendent and say I would like to
146see this on the agenda we can talk to Stan in the same way letting him know that we want to see it on the agenda obviously if more than one of us says that then automatically we're going to see that on the agenda but it would allow for us to have some real Clarity around what the public is wanting without necessarily having to take public meeting time to potentially I mean sometimes it's going to be great like tonight's I love hearing from both of you um super well prepared sometimes times when you have an open meeting I've sat in many a meeting over the years and sometimes those public comments have nothing to do with anything at hand um nothing to do with something we can even do anything about and I think it can
147cause some frustration because we're all going to sit and stare at that person and say nothing because we're not allowed to say anything on a non- agendized item so this would allow us um to make sure we are are responding to that someone's being heard and that there's some sort of process in place for them to hear where they are at in the in the chain you know that this is where it is and this is what's being considered um I do think it's incredibly important that the public feel heard that is hugely important I I feel that very strongly I'm not sure that the accomplishment of getting things on the agenda or even maybe the public being heard will feel any different in an open call than in the way that it's being held
148right now um but I I would prefer to see us I mean of course there's still those same ways to communicate we can't tell people you can't email us but I just know for me I even messag Clark and I'm like I don't really know what how to like handle the fact that I keep seeing the same responses from all these board members you know like I want to make sure we're following procedure and all of those things so that would be my that's just my initial like thought is perhaps making sure we're providing a clearer way for both directions of communication and that the person who's who is submitting the request or submitting the concern is either then invited to come speak um to the board or or we are at least able to
149gain the clarity around whether or not we need to make that an agenda item now or in the future I think I think logistically that's potentially very doable that the concept I think is an excellent one it's one that I've not thought of before I don't think it's been brought up before but if I'm hearing you correctly just to clarify uh maybe we have a Google form link on the website if you want to communicate the very same thing to all four five board members please fill out this form and then as you suggest that could automatically be sent to the five board members separately so there wouldn't be a reply all feature that puts you at risk for for open meeting law violation things really it's what you do not what people share with
150you that that that uh position and does the public see that under the forms so the rest of the public because then it becomes open sir yeah are you asking are we going to share that with every one of our 68,000 constituents certainly not would we tell the person who's filling out the form that this would go to all five board members yes that would that would be the idea I think right would there be a way to have a running uh list of of concerns that have been brought to the board so that it is available if someone were to want to look at a website and see what other other uh issues have been brought for yeah or if a constituent if multiple constituents see the same thing they can say you know
151I agree with that and I agree with that person and I'm going to weigh in as well I mean it might be that that is absolutely a possibility you might want to consider whether or not it's in the best interest of the district to do that we get things all the time like you know I don't like Mrs Smith who's my daughter second grade teacher and somebody else me too or you know the basketball game starts way too late my kids you know a lot of different the parking lot is this we we get feedback from people all the time sometimes about things of of significant import like we're talking about tonight sometimes of things that I'm not sure that it would be in the best interest of the district to list you know how
152many people are upset with Mrs Smith or how bad the parking lot is in some cases in other cases I can totally see that but automatically going that direction it might be problematic in ways that we're not considering right now just off the top of my head we're we're kind of going into BH as well do you want to explain that a little AB yeah so uh as as you're pointing out yeah BH um relates to the public participation at board meetings uh the idea aidea with this one is uh really for for a long time the practice has been um well actually I'll I'll back up legally right the board has a lot of different options of how they uh what they allow in terms of public participation they can have the open call
153and allow the public to come in and speak on any subject as was just mentioned they can put some limits in place um for example right limiting uh it to a voting item or they could say were not interested in having the the public speak at all at our board meetings and um for for many years the our PD board has opted to have the the second option there and have um the public allowed to come in and speak to a voting item and if they wish to speak on a topic other than one of the voting items um right they can they can use one of the other communication tools whether it's email or scheduling a meeting or other possible um options that maybe set up might be worth noting that the the default
154legally is no comment from the public our board has chosen to stay away from that extreme it's also chosen to stay away from the extreme of anybody say anything and and found what the board to this point has determined as Middle Ground whether or not you see fit to continue with that is of course up to you but right so uh the idea of the proposed changes we had actually a couple different board exhibits um that reflected um and were was very clear on the idea of having um the public allowed to speak to a voting agenda item and uh the practice was obviously that but uh bedh was not as clear on that and so the the intention with this uh proposal is to align all three of those things the practice the all
155both exhibits and this uh bedh policy um I'll read it just uh to make sure you understand where you have it up there but uh any individual Desiring to address the board about a topic that is agendized on the voting section of the agenda shall complete form um request to address the board again that's one of the exhibits that um is more clear and give this form to the superintendent's Administrative Assistant prior to the start of the study and voting portion of the agenda or board meeting and then uh section D also um again clarifies that we're um I'll jump down upon uh conclusion of the public comments individual members of the board May respond to any criticism made by an individual uh who has addressed the board and that I think was mentioned in
156uh Mr gas's uh introduction to our public comments section so uh again really trying to align current practice with um with our policy and our exhibits so I have a question um going back to section A yes it says on that study and voting section but that hasn't been our practice this is a this is a duplicate where it's maybe that's our practice the study and voting session is the portion you're in right now yes just clarifying further for the public what what we mean by that but it looks like according to a that if it's an agendized item study or voting a member a member of the public could speak to it are we we take out are we taking out the study and only allowing them I mean that that's been the practice
157though hasn't it we're just clarifying we're clarifying the practice exactly like Andy said our our decad long practice what's written and what's intended we want them all match but if we wanted more input from the public could we change it back to study and voting session so that the public would have an opportunity to talk about any agenda item or is great question so the study and voting session is this portion of the meeting that we're in right now okay to clarify that those are agendized voting items and it's referred to as the study and voting session of a study item on the agenda and a voting item on the agenda are not separate they're the same thing there's information items discussion items and voting might be study is like the first reading am I
158understanding that right potentially or this discussion is we're studying the issue okay and and I think we could always have the discussion of an open call I mean I think that's a separate issue from this this is just clarifying what we currently do I mean if if the board desires to look at a full open call to the public then I think we should have that discussion maybe as a future agenda item you know we can always table this and look at this as a future agenda item to to discuss and talk about well the merits and and negatives of an open call to the public my my problem with the open call is that we can't respond to the public and so they they they it becomes an air my grievances more than it
159becomes a a productive two-way conversation and um you know I hate the fact that somebody's got a grievance and they want to air it and then we are are made to be silent about it and uh that that that to me is not productive right I would like to be able to see if maybe when we do have a first reading that that we could hear then and then the following month we may hear again from someone else because now they understand it better um just like we get the opportunity for two month you know to look at it for one month and then and then have another opportunity to look at it before we vote I think it's great if the public has both of those same opportunities um and one of the points
160Andy made was if we could clarify maybe be more clear in our agenda item as to what the discussion is versus um identifying a policy that maybe might be hard for the public to find we know where to find it but it might be challenging for someone um in the general public to know what that means I don't know if that's allowed I mean you know what we can do what we can't so um when I complete the full the board packet there's agenda items that we post and then each agenda item that has an attachment you'll see a little PDF um icon the members of the public can go onto our website they can go on to board books which is the software that I use to prepare the agendas and those attachments are
161all there fully available I don't know what comes to me and what apparently everything that comes to me yes that's on the website you click on agenda and it pulls up the agenda I think that's excellent practice no attempt to upis fact opposite is true so yeah I'm probably in the camp same camp as Jen that I'd like a little bit more input from the public but what are our options yeah at this meeting yeah that's exactly where I'm at I I I can appreciate why we we have a public comment prior to to a voting item because we can discuss it just like we are now and when we can't we can't do it an open call to public however we're not necessarily F providing a platform that anybody can say come up and
162voice a concern that the public can hear and that's why I asked the question if you you're the comment that is sent to us can the public see it I'm afraid of of uh you know next door type of platform I don't want that to happen so we already have something like that it's called Facebook exactly so so I'm not but what I feel like is we we're going to this could be a very healthy discussion one that could be put in our Retreat which is an open public forum uh in our Retreat that's coming up um because I think we have a lot of great ideas and then we ask that maybe we come up with some other ideas as well from the staff just kind of what you've seen I I mean human
163nature is yeah I'm a I don't like criticism I don't think anybody really does and to sit up here and just take criticism is not a healthy way to just receive information so if it's constructive you know I want it to be uh constructive I hope it's constructive but it's not all the time and I see where in certain public entities they put limitations on open call to public so then it becomes a limited call to public anyway so I'd like to find some ground but I think it this is a robust discussion that needs to occur um are there any other comments because I think I want to split this this vat if I can I I'll just mention that Jen what you what you brought up about a Google form I think that
164would be pretty I want to run it by Dave Pei our our uh attorney to see if there's any open meeting uh implications that I'm not thinking of but I've been doing this for a little bit on kind of both sides of the Das the city council and here and I think that's really workable that's that's a venue where you know if if Mr Nelson or or anybody else had a had a comment it could get to all five board members as is and there wouldn't be the the uh possibility of kind of the Cross talk that gets us into a gray area with open meeting law it would go right to you and you you could you could get back with them individually and it would be the effective equivalent you know always except
165for we wouldn't provide you know public theater venue uh for people but um you you'd hear from everybody in in one click to all five board members and that would provide an additional if if people are really interested in getting their message to you that provides yet another Avenue I like it if people are interested in transparency well that's you communicating with them that's not them being able to communicate with others in public that's that's not your responsibilities to provide that venue if you want to provide that venue there are certainly other districts that do that we could consider that but that's that's not one of your legal responsibilities to do so and I'm not hearing anybody leaning into the open call the public piece at this point well I I just I'm curious do
166we need to take a vote on this can we leave things as they are we table this um have a discussion at our Retreat um and and get this nailed down to a place that everybody feels more comfortable with my my only concern would be that currently uh policy and Exhibits don't exactly align other as well if we if we could align them and then even you know whenever it's time to bring it back to the the board and right have that discussion but so that's the alternative is go ahead and and vote on this make a decision tonight if it if it's in alignment then we can still have the discussion at The Retreat on if there are additional changes we want to make right right have a future agenda item to discuss overall
167public comment and whether or not the policy needs to change okay so what alignment there's two um I see it in b bdh as alignment I think there's BB is just further CL clarification correct yeah about your intent for the for Community comments if you intend for that to be a forum for people to go around the other piece of policy you got great don't don't make any changes to the wording and and leave that open to each board member swim in the future but if youc if you intend your standing policies to be in effect the way that they are intended by board members I'd recommend that you add that wording but it's up to you feeling on BB bedb is it is a we're we're defining it specifically that we are sharing public
168comments that we're hearing and then if we are considering more of a um transparent more open um means that the publicans speak to I'm okay voting on bedb um but tabling bed I think the EDH is the one that is is causing us more well I think it's causing us more struggles among the fact that our exhibit does not match it so if we could get our exhibit currently to match bedh and table I would go the opposite as you stand is what I mean you you could do both table B and then you bring that up a month from now and another anytime you want you you can revisit this every month you can focus on Student Success instead or you could talk about this many many times it's completely up to you and
169I I'm fine tbling it for a month even if we're not aligned um just because I think more discussion is better than less discussion yeah with what alignment would would we need to speak on um one um paragraph a right taking out the study and voting yeah so the exhibit makes very clear A and D the the exhibit makes very clear the wording in in a from this policy so this is the policy we felt the language is unclear that's why we're bringing it to you the exhibit makes very clear what the board's long-term policy and procedure has been okay that our long-term policy and procedure literally for decades matches with the exhibit but depending on how you interpret it may or may not match with the wording in the policy itself which is why
170Andy's bringing to a recommendation to make all of those match now if you want to change how you do that I think that's a separate issue that you should bring up as soon as you're wanting to bring that up month from now whatever so in bedb I know we're focused on um the community comment section but if you if you go down to g2a uh so this policy the agenda policy it it says public comments on study and voting session topics so again that's that's another policy that doesn't quite align with bedh they they're kind of saying slightly different things and so um and then be what is it BH is is the form that is used um for the community comment so again there's the exhibit on the board there that attaches to refers
171to and is referred to within BH this bede makes very clear what study and and voting agenda item and topic are you addressing or if there's a a public hearing we have a public hearing on the budget some other things each of those is open for public comment in your meetings in addition to the many other ways that people have to to to get with you this is a venue for that so this is our been our procedure for years what the board has confirmed time and again over the decades again moderate middle ground in my view but you may feel differently clearly some members of the public do um but it it's clear what we are doing and intend to be doing but the policy attach this is a little bit ambiguous in its
172wording so I thought let's just clear up that wording nobody's asking to change anything right here at all so you you could table it and just leave it it'll remain ambiguous until you address it another time or you could confirm the wording match everything up and then come back to this issue of an open call in the future if you like there's there's a number of ways to approach it I think to align things as I look at bedh I I think taking out study and was a mistake I think that should be included in there yeah because then it aligns with bedb and that's the title of the section of the agenda sure we don't when people see that we've had people in the past say wait a minute you're talking about this it's
173a study item I thought I could speak to it we we've literally had that from people in this room in in the last couple of months so we thought let's use this wording make it more clear for average person in the public who comes to it would line up with our agenda better if it said study and voting session because that's the language we have in that yep in the each agenda as we move forward and we have to change BB in two different spots to make it match the study and voting as well no it already says study and voting right it it does say it in BB but if we remove it in BH there isn't study and it's just voting yeah so item g2a aligns with what is currently in there and
174then item um h no yeah g2b has studyed and voting s that that's the title again that title was confusing for some of us on the Das as recently as 30 minutes ago it's clearly confusing for the public we were trying to clarify that for you good idea should we clarify it every in all in all locations exactly and just make it the same we'd have to study and voting session and all yeah let's table it I feel like we we there are some refinement we have to do uh to this um for one I I just want to say that I appreciate the discussion that we've had even with the public I understand their Viewpoint and I'm and I'm open-minded to it I really am um Mr Carlo in particular we had some good
175discussion and you know she she made some very valid points that really opened my eyes and so I I think um we I think we table this one it's a very healthy discussion um figure out how we can get this more open to the public without opening up the the district to something that you know people just talk off the cuff and we're not able to prepare and and whereas we had when we have a study and V uh voting session or item we can intelligently discuss it because we've have at least done some homework um in preparation for it but I understand the screening you know the the the um the issue of perceived screening we would hope we'd be good board members to put something on the agenda I think we have we
176talked about class sizes we've talked about SC uh uh scores things that have been brought to our attention I mean there's several items that I mean have come to me and I know that we put them on the agenda or even during the board meeting well we've had we've had a request to have someone come and basically talk about creationism that's right in our in our meeting so and it took two board members board members to do that so that was a direct result of the community comments coming forward and getting an agenda item on the on the on the agenda for us okay so I'd like to go ahead I guess I would make the motion that we table item uh 7 B3 for further discussion I have a motion to have a second
177I'll second motion second all in favor say I I I any opposed okay all right we will table that um what I'd like to have it on the um a discussion at The Retreat for one let let's talk about whether it's best at The Retreat we got you you've added one other thing tonight so I think we've got seven substantial items for your retreat that could take anywhere between this has taken longer than I anticipated for instance could take anywhere between 20 minutes and an hour and a half each um you you might be looking at a 10hour agenda first of all secondly because you're scheduling The Retreat during the day it may be less accessible to some members of the public who work and so you you might want to totally open to whatever
178you want but you might want to consider doing it at okay our next evening meeting people are yeah and again once again up to you but if you really want to dig into the the mission and vision and school schedules and some of the other things that you talked about then you probably want to leave yourself time for that so adding another substantial item to that may or may not be what you want I I like the idea of coming back to it as soon as we can okay what do y'all feel I mean it's not a better public participation or at least more open to the public if it's not during the work day potentially if you do it at your March meeting you're looking at a difference of you know between seven and
17910 days depending on when we schedule the the uh Retreat so to speak and again like you say in the evening so that opens it up to more people being here which is what I'm hearing you want and I like that idea yeah all right uh so uh we're going to table this we'll table it so the March 4th meeting um and and that's a 30-day period for us to get public input as well more um robust conversations okay item uh 7 B4 consider approving um changes to the current PD bus rental and field trip schedules uh Mr Moore all right thank you um it's been a little bit since we've looked at um our rental schedules and specifically wait a second well um let me back up we rent our buses up because it's
180a good Community thing to do um especially for our camps around um uh the city uh we also have lots of field trips and athletic events that um require a driver in between the morning and the afternoon routes uh and so we just need to make sure that we're always looking at the cost when it comes to what bus drivers make and in this case specifically what we're trying to draw when it comes to our drivers to to drive a rental it's not in their contract it's not something and we need them to because it's also a revenue one of the few uh things we control on a revenue side is the rentable buildings and transportation um to the community uh but the current rate is actually lower than what their hourly rate is as
181a bus driver and so we haven't looked at this in a in a little bit I thought was 2019 is when we founded an agenda Kim Barker our transportation director us thought we addressed a rate tweaks in 22 but it has been a while and so really we're looking at looking at um changing a few things and I try to color coordinate in your book uh or in your attachments and it's really just um taking the driver rate from a rental standpoint from $30 an hour to 35 um our drivers do not make that amounts uh but they do make the 20 the 21s and when we do rent to our community it is a for-profit activity for the district and so the every raise we give and their rate goes up it closes that
182gap for profit um also the the daily vehicle rental fee from $130 to $150 um that is again really Personnel related on the amount of time Gary chartier our um our Civics rental Kim Barker Jenny Merck and the admin assistant works on these things um and they their their pay has increased when it comes to field trips um we were having our sites through tax credit or whatever their um uh their funding sources uh pay $25 per hour because that includes benefits we're what we're really doing is asking for our drivers to get paid $22 for uh a Civic rental and that then puts it so that we're operating at a loss $22 plus Ben benefits is about $26 and like 70 some cents so we're asking we're not here to make money off of
183our schools at all and so it's really more at cost and so we're asking from a field trip standpoint for it to go from $25 to 27 is a few pennies over what the cost is including benefits and then also just because fuel has went up um a dollar to a15 per mile and you may say it doesn't cost that much for you know the buses get seven miles per gallon or six um you do the math that's more than what it costs the mile per gallon really offsets the maintenance cost the depreciation of the buses and all of those activities because that's not a chargeable thing and so from a diesel the yellow bus we're asking for it to go from a dollar per mile mile to a115 per mile um and then also
184the white activity buses go from 90 cents a mile to a15 cents a mile and all of that is really just more inflation prices salaries going up based on minimum wage and that's the recommendation to the board who drives the white activity bus that we don't pay them uh lot usually it's the coaches oh okay we're already paying them we're already paying them so there is a driver cost wondering who's who's driving they're the GPS automatic drivers you know we just do an open call the public come and just say hey who wants to drive a bus but we rent the white buses to the public as well right or not I I can't think of scenarios in which we've rent because I see no driver charge on the white buses like if a school
185needed a bus for six kids they like the coach drives so that is the white buses if if a if a driver if let's say a coach wouldn't able to drive and we would provide a driver through Transportation there would be with them so there's but 99% it's not going to be you know Sky School renting a white bus and providing their own driver correct they're only used internally it's internal and they're and thus covered under our our comprehensive liability insurance for vehicles so really this the whole driving of this is is buses cost cost more 100 I just had a bus priced out and it's $197,000 for a yellow bus now um and uh and also really from a driver standpoint the incentive for having them Drive above and beyond the routes right now
186they're they they're making less some of them than what they're driving around and we want to raise that to $22 an hour and and U for them plus totally makes sense y so the the propane buses that we've gotten had that been a bust is that what is they have very limited use because of the lack of horsepower really they can't go up and down they can't go down to Phoenix they can't Hills are not very F spots probably is an issue so we do have uh we do have some routes but they are specifically for those routes because it's it's when the it's in the Wheelhouse they work for flatter in town routes we certainly have some of those we have a few down Phoenix and back there's a range issue and the yeah
187absolutely okay okay so definitely diesel is it diesel obviously Yow buses are decent okay gotta all right um any more discussion on this or do you want to vote okay I'll take a motion to approve the changes to the current PSD bus rental and field trip schedules I'll make that motion motion have a second I'll second motion second all in favor say I I uh not opposed them um we have information and discussion items uh 7 C1 uh School Board primary or summary budget report Mr Moore before I say as presented you might notice that I did put asteris next to some of the funds because in the previous governing board I can't remember who it was but asked excuse me thank you I suppressed who asked it because I know you're going be asking
188lots of stuff me and it just is going to kill me so excited about this I actually did that during the board meeting otherwise I would have forgotten she's gonna ask good questions I'm just I think that's subjective can you define good um Brian won't agree with that oh I'm just anyway so it has the asteris and what does not allow carry forward and if there are any questions as presented thank you um item 7 C2 future agenda items so we know we're going to do uh revisit the two policies now we can we can do it during the retreat but like I mentioned there's is there a downside of putting it on the agenda so the public knows that it's a possibility we're going to talk about it or do we have to well
189I think you want to make sure we're going to talk about it or they would come and then if we don't get to it we have to talk about it at length but I think to talk about right yeah and I understand like just you know for the interest of how many items we have on the retreat and stuff you know I think it's I'd love to hear more from from the public that's not the same letter you know and um because just and honestly it's you know how many people really and out of the scope of the whole population what are we looking at so I think that if we we can really reach that during the meeting and maybe just kind of limit a little bit we'll look at the items on there
190um I think it's going to be robust again I love the idea of having a way for you to hear what people say and get it on the agenda if two of you agree I think we kind of got that in place frankly but we could provide another Avenue yeah okay um okay um so that's an any other items we want to see what about the bio Jud intercom system it's already fixed is that [Music] done I love you I'm just kidding I I heard these two school board members fixed it yeah we were it real hard while we were there and jened the wires were crossed I just we know a lot about that stuff is it too soon I know you guys did a bunch our our I'm sorry our principal brought it
191appropriately to the attention of the IT department and two days later it was fixed awesome that's how things are supposed to work awesome good job two days is too long days buddy hey love the color of your house by the way it looks great yeah all right um and then item 7 C3 uh book study uh for March 4th will start again I thought that was very fruitful I loved it yeah it was cool I was feeling like I could read more chapters but since we only have 15 minutes to discuss it we should probably keep it to two I'm like oh we can't actually talk about those chapters we're going to have to Lim we knocked it all out in 14 minutes and 30 seconds perfect perect perect perfect um so March 4th is
192our um next meeting starting at 5:15 for the regular study and voting and then the 14th is a full PD um uh day for PD no students can I just extend an invitation to all of you you're welcome to come join any of our sessions um it is my absolute favorite PD day that we put on we call it a choose your own so we have about 40 different sessions um that are being offered in three 1our blocks and most of the sessions are being put on by our very own staff members so sharing something that they're passionate about something that's working in their classroom but you're welcome to come join any session or just to come and visit that day if you're available but it's a lot of fun and there's a lot of
193learning that happens so do we need to let you know in advance that we're coming or we can just show up you guys can come and just join any of them that you'd like and where's it at at presc high school pres High School yep from 8 to about 11:30 that morning okay great thank you um and then so uh observance of President's Day so it looks like a 4-day weekend so 17th is off and our board