CorpusRecord 161788

1-8-2025 Governing Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / TempeElementary
Date
2025-01-09
Location
Maricopa County, AZ
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,194 words · about 40 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001call this meeting to order 103 Pledge of Allegiance a pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the for it stands one nation God indivisible andice for all righty 104 approval of ch agenda make a motion to approve tonight's agenda second a motion by Charlotte seconded by Allison all those in favor say I I I motion carries 105 ceremonial swearing in of the governing board members Dr well I have the honor to introduce the mayor Cory Corey Woods I believe he's coming up to do the ceremon swearing in so I'll bring him up perfect thank you all right so we've got three governing board members who are being sworn in this evening so if I could have Alison yours Jim Lemon and Ray Theory join me down here in the

002front I would say you would think after all the meetings that I've done that I would know how to turn on a microphone by now but different setting you just just freeze up a little bit all right so if you could please all raise your right hand and repeat after me I do solemnly swear or affirm swear or affir that I will support the Constitution of the United States of the United States and the Constitution and laws and of the State of Arizona of St that I will bear true faith I willar and allegiance to the same Al and defend them against all enemies foreign and domestic for and that I will Faithfully and impartially discharge andar discharge the duties of the office of of governing board member of govern board member for the Tempe

003Elementary School District for the temp element School according to the best of my ability Accord to the best of my ability so help me God or so do I affirm congratulations woo thank you again to the mayor uh 106 reorganization of the governing board election of President Charlotte I would like to nominate uh Alison ners based off of her um advocacy on the state and local level for public education her uh fervor for public education and her complete commitment to Temp Elementary School District I would second that will you accept I accept the nomination thank you I have a motion by Charlotte seconded by Jim all those in favor say I I I motion carries Al is our new president [Applause] and I suppose as my last act I'll move forward for the election for

004the vice president and then we'll switch seats it'll be a whole thing 107 uh election of the vice president M Mr President we have three board members who have children in the Elementary District we have two teachers who have taught in here in Temp and so I think any of those would make a great addition as Vice president excellent very good do you have a name attached with anything you like to well I I would you know when I first got on the board I was vice president I knew nothing about some of the procedures so it was really helpful to be on the vice president and the agenda committee and you learn a lot and uh so I would ask if Ry is interested in that um only a Show's not gonna fight me

005oh there'll be a rumble afterwards it's okay okay um yes we have a motion by uh Jim seconded by Charlotte for Ray to be our vice president all those in favor say I hi hi motion carries he's our vice president now comes the very fun part where we all switch chairs just got s e thank you now we'll go to um 2.01 presentation of the 2024 governing board president Eric Miller Dr disco thank you Madame President members of the board I'd like to take this moment to thank our 2024 president for his year of service as governing board president Mr Eric Miller approved boundary changes for th Frank nevit and CMS to ensure students attend schools closest to their home address he approved the rebuild of Connelly and Curry schools successfully passed the m and

006daa overrides supported the district to receive grant funding to purchase electric buses and infrastructure and we are the largest recipient in the state for such award and supported the partnership with the Toyota Foundation which resulted in the district receiving over $5 million to provide stem and food Mobility programs and services to our students I appreciate your leadership your thoughtfulness throughout this year here thank you for taking on this responsibility thanks for the countless hours and dedication that you put into this role your most important accomplishment that you that happened while you were governing board president was when my Michigan wolver rigns beat the Washington Huskies for the 2024 National Championship I couldn't pass it up because a year ago I we had a conversation about that um and I and and I have a small

007token of gratitude for [Applause] you go Blue Eric would you like to say anything I appreciate all those kind words uh tuskies did beat Michigan in September of this year so they had a small payback and that respect but uh it's all worth it really to help the kids and so that's really why I'm here and uh really I am supported most by my fellow board members so anything I do is really for them and above all that it's the staff and so I just want to thank really all the staff for all they do so thank you thank you Eric for everything this year 2.02 presentation the introduction of the 2024 2025 interest based negotiations team Mr minini thank you Madame President members of the board Dr droll um this is a brief presentation

008but a really exciting one uh this year marks our 20th year um participating in interest based negotiations um for for our district so um it's very exciting per per policy HD um we have two groups that are recognized in interest based negotiations we have our District administration team and then we have um tea um who are are recognized to enter into negotiations and so tonight I want to introduce the team uh members that were able to make it um and then kind of just give some overview of the process and and where we're at so I'll start us off and then I'll ask for Mr Gonzalez come over to introduce the uh Association side so um on the district uh admin team we have myself and we have Mr Eric Thompson our Chief Financial Officer

009we have Colleen love principal of curry Elementary and I don't know where if I saw her there she is okay um she's going to be our non- voting member and it'll be her first year on the team so we're really excited to have her voice um on the team uh we also have Miss Vernie sharp who's been a long-term member of the IBN team she is the principal of nevit Elementary Dr Sharp excuse me thank you for that correction Dr Sharp that was my one opportunity wasn't it Dr Sharp okay we also have Mr Matthew Strauss uh I'll get that one right principal of agular elementary school so and I'll have Mr Gonzalez come over here to introduce the association thank you Mr gu Madame President members of the board superintendent Driscoll so introdu introducing

010the the rest of the team um so myself I am the it customer support manager Allison Holden who's in the back she is our Pace teacher at Ward we have Christina palaran she is our office man manager at Conley Middle School we have Taylor web she is our language arts teacher at Mosley Middle School uh Kelly BLK who is also in the back right there she is our behavior interventionist at agular elementary and then our non- voting member is Sean Coker he is our carpentry manager over at the Brogan facility so that would be the the rest of our team and then we'll go ahead and have Mike give our introduction it is our 20th year so it's very exciting it is so one of the really cool things um about interest based negotiations that

011I want to remind the board as we enter into this um is that every employee in our system has a voice their vo is through the uh IBM process we sent out an annual survey that survey actually went out on December 9th of this year prior to Winter Break um and closed yesterday at 5:00 p.m. so we gave a a very large window for people to voice their um input on salaries benefits working conditions what the team does is we take and we compile that information we enter um we actually go through line by line and read every single comment that is made on the survey um after going through that process we do create a list of Hot Topics um and then we from there we go through our process of trying to create

012a plan um that we present to Dr Driscoll and then ultimately to you as the board for approval anything that's approved by the board goes into our work agreements and contracts for the following year so this is done annually um and we're really excited about this year we've already met because we seem to get to the end of the process and go we got to hurry up hurry up so we've already met as a team to come together and talk about those hot topics um we're going to really dive into the survey our next meeting will be next Friday the 17th um and we're really excited about uh really getting started in it so and if you have any questions I'll answer those otherwise this is our team and we're excited for our 20th year

013are there any questions no Mr MGH I'd just like to say how much I appreciate this process and thank you to everyone who has volunteered to do this I know that it's going to take a lot of extra time that you're unpaid to do but you're going to be representing our staff our teachers and our children and um I'm grateful that we do it this way so that you're representing yourself instead of us just telling you what we want from you so thank you Mr minini okay for the invigorating presentation of 2.03 the open meeting law to everyone that's still here in the room with us thank you for staying this is going to be um really interesting and you don't have to stay but it might be interesting for you to know why we

014don't always answer your emails directly back um so and what rules and regulations we have on what we can and can't do so thank you Madame President thank you for that very appropriate introduction for our presentation and just uh before I get started it's really nice to see the coll collegiality um between your board members because that's not something we see with every board that we work with so kudos to you so my name is Carrie O'Brien I'm an attorney from gust Rosenfeld and I've been working with your District um for the better part of six months now so um they asked me to come and speak with you tonight about the open meeting law um which as a public body within the State of Arizona you're obligated to comply um the goal of the

015open meeting law is to allow the public to know what the governing board is doing so I want our presentation to be meaningful and please ask me questions if you have them along the way so I'm going to briefly talk on just different problems we've been seeing um with school district governing boards and then I'm happy to answer any questions so the interesting thing about the open meeting law is that it doesn't stand alone it interacts with other responsibilities that you have as a governing board so the ways uh you can see the open meeting lies in the middle and then your different responsibilities as a governing board are in um the boxes around it so for example when you're considering an expulsion of a student or you're considering terminating an employee you have to

016do that in a manner that complies with the open meeting law so sometimes that might require that you meet in executive session to review ex um confidential Student Records or Personnel records um you also have to comply with conflict of interest laws in a way that complies with the open meeting law um and so the there's different ways in which your board will operate to comply and fulfill its obligations as a school district so what's a quorum a quorum is simply a majority of your board vacancies count towards that you don't have any vacancies right now um so for your five member board um a quorum would always be three members so for any matter that comes on your agenda um it has to pass by three so if for some reason um you had

017two two then the matter would not pass um so there's always a lot of questions about abstaining and whether it counts um towards your voting um so if you abstain as a member you still have a quorum um does abstention count as a no vote no it does not um we recommend you know if the question were to come to us um from a governing board member that unless there was a conflict of interest a statutory conflict of interest um that board members vote a matter up or down rather than abstain we've seen a lot more abstentions um often around political issues um and so just for open meeting law purposes it's better if the member votes up or down so that they issue you know their opinion to the public on the matter so

018agendas so agendas are always um challenging and you have a great governing board secretary who prepares your agendas um one thing that we see come up a lot is how specific does it have to be so the public needs to understand by your agenda items what's the possible action that's going to take place your your governing board uses board docks right so there's items within it that talks about for example the recommended action of the administration and that's intended to give the public notice of what the board might do so then the public can decide whether to come to the meeting or not um one issue we see a lot is whether um so you have to publish your agenda 24 hours ahead um most boards publish them online some they also have um physical

019posting locations can you change an agenda once it's been posted generally the answer is no for example if I changed my presentation for tonight's meeting you know last minute that would be okay uh a governing board or an Administration can't add for example an additional employee that wants to be hired ahead of that 24-hour period or add a voucher on ahead of that 24-hour period that needs to be um solid for the 24-hour notice period so as governing board members and your superintendent you can provide a brief summary of current events at each board meeting and I assume that happens on most agendas is that right Heather for most agendas you have that so um we we get questions a lot on what does brief summary of current events mean um it's it's supposed to

020be related to what's happening in your school district I have worked with other districts where a board member might use that opportunity as a moment to express public opinion on an issue outside of the scope of what the governing board's Authority is um that's always a delicate issue right um so in those cases I usually suggest that the board president remind board members ahead of the presentations that you're supposed to maintain um the boundaries which are a brief summary of current events so most often what we see is you know the superintendent telling you what great things have been happening at your schools in the district um board members might be talking about events they went to in the community um to let the public know what's happening in the school district so let's talk

021a lot a little bit about technology right so you have these great tools right you have email you have texts um how does that interact with the open meeting law so it gets messy so our recommendation is usually that the superintendent um push information kind of One Direction to board members that it's not used as a dialogue um between board members so um your superintendent might give you a weekly update um and telling you what's happened in the district during the week um essentially the open meeting law prohibits board members from using email as kind of a conduit to hold a meeting right so you can't discuss um or propose items that might come before the board um in in a future meeting so we sometimes get um open meeting lot complaints where um someone's

022alleging Something's Happened over email and then we're required to produce those emails um to the Attorney General's office so our rule of thumb is to um use your email for professional purposes I assume you all have temp Schools email accounts right so it's really good to keep your personal email separate from your governing board email the hardest thing is if we get a request from the attorney general for emails and a board board member um conducts board business on a personal email account right we don't want to have to ask board members to look in their Gmail and provide us with documents so just kind of keeping those things separate is a really good rule of them text messages can they be a public record yes they can be if there's District business going on

023so we know that in general people are using texts all the time right I text with clients sometimes um it's just kind of a quick and easy way to get information but just like emails um it matters the content of the message not the mechanism used to transmit the message so just like emails um your text messages could be a public record so I'm not sure does the district provide board members with cell phones no okay great so then I would suggest not texting board me between board members that just keeps it nice andle clean right so if for some reason you get a public records request for text messages of governing board members on a specific topic then you can just tell um the person who asks the question that you don't text about

024board business so that just keeps it nice and clean um one thing that's always a good rule of thumb for the open meeting law is to avoid using your phone while you're um on the dis right um You might be texting someone about when you're getting home right or please pick up milk um or something for school lunches the next day but the public doesn't know that right so if you're on your phone um you know scrolling or texting the public might think are they talking about board business right and that should happen in in an open Forum so it's just a good idea not to be on your phone during a board meeting and again um keeping your your phone and um your email and text messages separate from any District business all right

025all right so let's talk a little bit about statements to the Press so um social media um is is used a lot by board members um I have seen situations recently where you know candidly with more divided boards where perhaps a board member who felt like they weren't heard during the board meeting expresses their disagreement through social media this could be a public statement it's not necessarily A a violation of the open meeting law right because it's kind of one board member expressing their opinion on something that's not um an issue with Quorum or it doesn't trigger the open meeting law um one thing to stay away from would be using the district's logo in any kind of social media post right because that just gives the appearance that it's an official board statement or

026board action when in fact it might not be all right calls to the public so if there's a controversial issue on your board agenda or if the public has concerns about something that's coming before the board I mean common topics might be boundary changes um that's probably the biggest thing I've seen recently um the district can Implement reasonable time place in Mana restrictions right so you might not want um to spend two hours listening to members of the call on a call to the public if you can hear the concerns of the public in a different way so there are tools you can use to hear from the public in a way that doesn't clog up your board meeting so sometimes um boards suggest that members of the public submit their requests and um by

027email another mechanism where um a board was just getting bogged down with many many members of the public wanting to speak at board meetings um they implemented a tool on their website and said we listen right and it invited the public to come and talk to administrators if they had concerns about something that was happening at the district so there's different ways of dealing with that so if for some reason there's an issue around um calls to the public becoming unruly the the board president can Al always call for a recess um and then if a board member wants to respond to a call to the public you can do so in compliance with open meeting law only at the conclusion of all the calls to the public right so I work with a district

028that had an open meeting law violation where um the board president responded kind of in the middle of calls to the public and that was a no no because the open meeting log clearly says you have to wait until the conclusion of all um statements from the public um and it's not supposed to be a discussion the the typical response um from the governing board at the conclusions of the call of the public might be to ask Dr Driscoll to look into the matter and report back to the board um but it's it's not usually a good idea to get into a discussion if someone's um expressing their disagreement on the Das all right so I just want to talk briefly about executive sessions because I'm getting way in the weeds in open meeting a

029law and I don't want to bore you to death but there's eight reasons why you can convene an executive session and that's a time when the board and then staff that um you determine are needed to be um in the discussion is held outside of the presence of the public so the highlighted items are the most common reasons why your board might convene into executive session um the most typical one where I would be with you would be for legal advice and you have to have an attorney present if you're convening an executive session for legal advice um we talked a little bit about you can have um the persons you've determined are necessary in your executive session that's most always includes your superintendent um for personnel the district would be required if for example

030you were reviewing an employee in executive session um for a statement of charges to terminate the employee um you might have a notice of an executive session Personnel the employee doesn't necessarily have a right to come into the executive session but can get um the minutes from the executive session the board could invite the person in but is not legally required to do that and then the board secretary also has to give notice to the employee um 24 hours ahead and they could request that that discussion happen in public I've never had um an employee request the discussion happen in public but that is a right of an employee or of a person that you're going to discuss um this obligation also applies to applicants so for example if you were conducting a superintendent search

031and you were reviewing applicants in executive session they would get noticed um of the personel executive session so You' use the exception for confidential records for long-term suspensions or expulsions um you might be reviewing medical records or teacher evaluations so records that are confidential by law would be reviewed in executive session legal advice so usually that that's on a specific topic I think I met with you a few months ago to talk about Title 9 and so that's not intended to just be an opportunity for the board to talk about something else right you're talking about a specific topic and the public gets notice of what that topic is on the agenda um there's another executive session provision that's for negotiating contracts that's um more rarely used um typically for for um superintendent contracts where

032you're advising um the board's attorney how to proceed with a contract of course executive session discussions are confidential um and only the entire board can wave privilege not one board member all right so um from about 2020 so like the covid era to till 2023 we got some confusing guidance from the Attorney General on whether the open meeting law applied to committees and so I just wanted to briefly talk to you about that as well um because it created confusion we have some clarity now so Arizona law requires um that if the governing board essentially creates a subcommittee so if you take legal action on a properly noticed agenda to create a committee then that committee also has to comply with the open meeting law it does not include a committee that is created by

033the single head of an agency so for your school district um your superintendent creates lots of committees to do good work right that'll come forward to the board on certain things right so you might like your interest based negotiations for example um you know it's an administrative committee you might have a board member serving on it you might not um where you're doing administrative work um um doesn't have to comply with open meeting law so that's what we thought was the case we got some confusing guidance from the AG's office um there was a a violation for another District I work with um it was really around like covid era issues and so there was some confusion uh with school lawyers really about what whether administrative subcommittees have to comply with open meeting law so

034we were really kind of walking on eggshells um because we wanted to give school districts good guidance and not create an open meeting law violation um so for example there were some violations found with um school districts that had meetings between the superintendent and board members where they met in groups of two and two and one um and then there was a violation where a board member sat on what was a purely administrative subcommittee and so we were kind of surprised by some of that so in 2024 there was a good AG opinion um that came out that really clarified some of these issues um it was for two large school districts it was for Scottdale and Paradise Valley um and it upheld the use of administrative work so it kind of came back to

035the conclusion that we thought was the case in the first place right so if your superintendent creates a subcommittee to do some work even if it may come before the board as a recommendation then it doesn't have to comply with the open meeting law and that's really helpful so there are some nuances to that so if your District you're probably not doing this districts in 2022 and 2023 were doing a lot of textbook adoptions with Esser money um but since that money's run out we're not seeing that as much but if um you were doing some textbook adoptions those committees have to comply with open meeting law if the board forms a committee right that would be an action to form a committee um then that would have to comply with the open meeting law

036and you may have policy that creates committees so examples of that would be audit and then if you have a meet and confer committee that might also have to comply with open meeting law so that's really it I'm happy to answer any questions you might have on open meeting law Miss Windor thank you madam president uh quick question and I I think you already know the answer but just want to clarify sharing tempy Elementry social media posts on ours since it has the logo on it that's okay for us to still like share or forward that yes it's just if we create it with the logo correct right so I think it would just be if you kind of took the logo and made it look like it was an official District action or official

037District publication when it wasn't that's just confusing for the public thank you for the clarification Mr bran thank you so much I appreciate you always um having our back on all of this and I also appreciate a board that really works hard to to follow these laws and Eric Miller having work down for the state for a while we'll tell you that um we we follow the rules and he's he was grateful for it when he had that position so thank you for your presentation thank you have a good night thank you now if everyone feels like they just went on a trip to Australia and you're 9 hours in and need to stand up and stretch feel free to do this real quick and I appreciate you staying for that 3.01 approval modification of

038minutes for the December 18th 2024 governing board meeting do I have a motion I make a motion to approve the meeting minutes of the meeting of December 18th motion by Mr Lemon second second second by Miss Windsor all those in favor I I motion passes Madam president that's four to zero Ray can't vote oh yeah Ray Ray abstained good job thank you uh 4.01 approval of consent agenda do I have a motion I can make a motion to approve the consent agenda approved by Miss Windor second second approved by uh second by Mr Miller all those in favor I I four all four passes one abstention 4.02 approval of summary we It's all under consent agenda right so we're good I do want to um send a little a couple shoutouts um from the uh

039sun produce Co-op uh they've given us a donation of a value of $ and um it's and another donation actually it looks like right Heather of $5,000 for fresh fruits vegetables for our families um they do so much to us so shout out to them I appreciate that all right 5.01 open call to the public I have six cards we're going to have an invigorating video to watch next persons wishing to address the board must fill out the request to address the board card and submit it to the board's executive coordinator prior to the start of the board meeting per governing board policy BH public participation at board meetings the governing board president shall set a time limit on the length of the comment period also per governing board policy BH for items on the

040agenda individuals will be called upon when the item is introduced for topics not on the agenda citizens will be called upon during this portion of the meeting under open call to the public in compliance with the open meeting law the governing board will neither discuss nor take action on items raised during this portion of the agenda when necessary issues will be taken under advisement and placed on a subsequent agenda during the open call to the public issues addressed must be within the jurisdiction of the [Music] board okay our time is 3 minutes and I'll start your time when you come up the first is going to be Rebecca Miller and just make sure that the green light is on when you go up there and feel free to adjust this hello all right um dear

041board members my name is Rebecca Miller I am an alumnist of the Tempe Elementary School District um I come to you as an employee I'm a full-time SLP speech language pathologist at coling middle school and in my most important role I'm a parent of two very awesome kids one being represented there and they actually are both um gifted students at Rover Elementary and my son jack is super excited about going to Connelly Aspire next year and joining the team there and so really my purpose for coming to the board um I I wasn't aware that more discussion was being um brought up during the dece December 18th I would have liked to have been there but I couldn't so I just want to come to the board and share um just um some information um

042based upon my view of the last two meeting sessions and discussions on the boundary changes and and proposals of programming changes and I'm really T encourage the board to look close at how those changes could impact gifted programming for our students in the district um I know when I kind of heard rumors about um possibly the Conelly Aspire program disc continuing or being phased out that um shot a read alarm for me as a parent and also as employee because I think it's clear to know that the programming that we offer for our gifted students is very different from say honors courses that are offered at the middle school level or even supplementary Pace um instruction like they get in elementary school so I just want to encourage the board members to go visit Aspire

043see um the really important project-based learning and critical problem solving that is going on in this program and um take that into Factor when we are making future decisions about programming in our district so thank you for your turn thank you next is Christina is it s Hana am I saying that correct s Hannah s Hannah thank you green correct okay uh members of the governing board in Dr Driscoll thank you for this opportunity to speak my name is Christina sad Hannah uh I'm a teacher educator and I've worked in education for 28 years my child Darren is a fifth grader at Aspire I'm nervous about speaking in front of you all um and my daughter Evelyn attended Broadmore and Aspire at Connelly she's at mclintoch I'd like to briefly discuss the plans to combine

044the Aspire program into a K8 Aspire at Arondo um um we've heard the rumors for a long time and I've I've heard more rumors that it's going forward um I was really surprised uh as a parent in the program I've never been asked what I thought about a combined program uh moreover Dr Pew came to Arondo to host an information night for parents about aspir at Connelly our children were invited to attend the open house at Connelly my child's really excited to attend aspire Conelly especially for the elective options and the opportunity to leave Elementary School behind uh he wants a new experience it feels like the district's been um not really forthcoming about what's happening here um so I have three concerns um first I know we're concerned with enrollments all districts are I

045just think it's really strange that there hasn't been a listening session with parents um especially parents currently enrolled in the program there have been a lot of decisions in the district that I haven't personally agreed with I didn't love the schedule CH the school start time changes we adjusted we paid for kids own I don't love the schedule it doesn't align with my schedule at ASU in any way we adjusted I'm starting to feel like this adjustment is not one that I want to make um second my child like many receiving gifted Services struggles with anxiety and when he heard that this might be happening after he had toured and was pretty sure what was going to be happening next year he couldn't even talk about it at home um because we don't have any

046answers for him and we don't know what this is going to look like and finally I have a few concerns about the district's commitment to diversity with the K8 Aspire program um as I'm sure you know the the fifth grade Aspire class uh is not reflective of the district's diversity um it especially in gender diversity it's 20 boys and one girl um and while I know that the district has made real efforts to increase diversity in the gifted program by doing test prep and things like that with students who look like they can um pass the test there are some real issues at the eighth grade level with students who had the 94 for td3 but don't have the 97 for um Peggy pay it's heartbreaking when they don't have that and at least when

047it's in the current School model they have friends from their elective classes if we move those students into one K8 that won't happen for them so I'd just like to encourage you to take a step back and do a listening session with parents and really listen um and I'm out of time but thank you the next is Andrea Goodmanson hello members of the board in Dr Driscoll my name is Andrea Goodmanson and I am the proud parent of two students that have gone through the Tempe school system my son lexon is currently a fifth grader at Broadmore and has a attended tempy school since kindergarten he is in Pace and he has loved his experience both in Pace and also in the general education setting as we began to look for middle schools for our

048son we applied to both Mami and Aspire knowing that we wanted to have options that he could explore after going to the tours of the campuses lexon fell in love with a Spire at the Connelly campus he was excited not only by the core aspired classes but also by the electives that were offered at Connelly I'm here before you to express my disappointment in hearing that Aspire is potentially going to be Consolidated and moving solely to Arondo and turned into a K8 program I believe this is a detriment to students such as my son who are not only defined by their giftedness but also by their other areas of Interest such as music and the Arts and sports is a right of power passage that many students look forward to to get to go to

049Middle School including lexon and I feel like that if we do not have this option my son is not going to have the same amount of growth that he would have if he was going to Aspire at Connelly as a parent of a gifted child I wish that we'd been surveyed or informed of our options in a more forthcoming way and that we are what we were seeing at the Connelly tour was what is not going to potentially be what our children are experiencing if they choose a Spire for their middle school I know that my son lexon must decide which school he wants to go to in the next few weeks and I also know that that is before the decision will be finalized to move the program to Arondo I urge you to

050consider extending the deadline for parents such as myself that are in the position of having to choose which program to go to and um so that we would be able to decide if we wanted to go to the K8 option or if we wanted to go with one of the other options that our children have also qualified for and I also encourage you and urge you to have a process that invites more voices such as mine to the table when you're looking to make major decisions about our children's education thank you the next is Phillip lamur is it Lamar or Lamar help me lar thank you Lamar you're I'm going to change that to an a thank you madam president governing board members and Dr Driscoll my name is Philip Lamar and I'm the band

051director at Conley Middle School the Conley jazz band has been selected to perform at the Arizona music educators conference on February 1st at 1100 a.m. at the Mesa Convention Center this is a huge honor to be selected to perform and represent middle school jazz education in the state of Arizona the students will be performing in front of music educators from across the state in addition we'd love to formally invite you to this performance which is open to the public I've been proud to teach in td3 for the last 28 years and the support of the music department has been from you and the temp Community I've got invitations if I can give them to you yep you can give them to Heather and Che get them to us thank you so much when I looked

052at that card I was like that's not his name thank you for helping me fix that Heather you're going to have to help me schimmer slimmer Slimmer yay all right good evening Dr Driscoll District leaders and members of the board thank you for your service to students and families all over the district and for the opportunity to speak I'm Heather schlummer I'm a td3 alumnist former teacher here and proud parent of two kids that have either gone through or currently enrolled in td3 I am incredibly grateful for the positive experiences my family have had in this District I actually married an an alumni as well and my mom was a teacher and my mother-in-law was a teacher here as well so td3 is really important to us um I'm here to comment on the school

053choice options and related boundary changes that are being discussed I recognize this is not an agenda item but will likely not have the opportunity to attend future meetings as I begin teaching a evening course next week as an educator and Public School advocate I recognize the complex challenges all district space to provide students with a quality education with insufficient funding and insufficient legislative support as a participant on the strategic planning committee a few years ago I appreciate that the district is responding to these challenges through the lens of innovation as a district administrator in a West Valley Community with declining enrollment I can absolutely sympathize with the difficult decisions that you guys all must make as a parent I have some questions and concerns about the changes being considered though while no decisions have been

054made officially I understand that there's a lot of work that must be done behind the curtain in order to craft well-developed proposals before they're brought forward for stakeholder input I've been at those tables I get it um changes hard always and you're never going to please everyone I get that and I'm trying to trust that as more information is shared some of my hesitations will be resolved here's what I'd like to offer as a consideration for you as you continue this important work if a decision is made to make significant changes to school structures timing will be absolutely critical open houses have already been held many students have already registered for middle school and we're entering the most stressful time of year for educators taking the time to fully discuss the impact on neighborhood students

055potential participants in these amazing programs and shape proposals through stakeholder input as well as ensure all eyes are dotted and tees are crossed will be be critical for any bold moves to be effective I'm worried that done poorly this could backfire and you may end up losing more people than you keep thank you for your time again for the important work you do and for asking the hard questions Ryan caral okay hello um I'm not as well prepared as the people who spoke before me but I do want to Second everything that they have said um hello Dr Driscoll members of the board Community leaders um I'm not as well prepared but I I'm here for a different reason which is that my kiddo's in kindergarten and he hates school on Monday he spent 30

056minutes before he went into school crying until I reassured him don't worry I'm talking to your teachers we're going to work this out you got to use your voice and prior to that 30 minutes that or that he was so upset crying I guess it was Tuesday going back to school I want to share what happened the last day of school before break which was December uh 20th I think um I got a stack of papers of the work that he's done today a lot of worksheets and um I I praised him I said good job you've been working really hard you've been learning a lot and he said no Mom I cheat I said what what do you mean he said well I cheat because I won't get to go to recess unless I

057finish all my work now my kids um we've learned that he has some visual tracking disorders I've written his teacher for the last two months prior to that saying please don't make him do handwriting please don't make him read it it's hard and you know until we can get his 504 meeting but I think just without the 504 meeting she felt compelled to try and meet whatever goals are set for for reading and writing and so I wanted to share with you what my son who's gifted also um does to get to be able to go to recess he scribbles there's about 3 hours of reading and writing each day that he does it and he scribbles patiently sitting at his desk so that he can go to recess for 5 minutes the other part

058of recess is 20 minutes after lunch 25 minutes in 7 hours for a 5-year-old um the academic expectations placed on these young children is inappropriate um I see I'm running out of time I just want to ask that as as we move forward that you please look at giving them the skills that they need to deal with the social emotional stuff that will benefit all kids and uh to whatever extent you can under the state law and state rugs please please support play soci emotional development and back off of academics to whatever extent you can thank you 6.01 discussion consideration and possible approval of the director of Safety and Security position and the corresponding job description Dr disco do you want to talk about this I'll turn it over to Mr manini thank you Madame

059President members of the board Dr roll um this job description um this is this is something that um we as a district are moving in a very positive direction under the topic of Safety and Security um it is something that Dr Driscoll um and our team takes very seriously and so over the years as long as I've been part of um District leadership and um I've watched The Evolution we've we've made strides in the Department of Safety and Security uh but this position is an opportunity for us um to really enhance um and have a person very dedicated um to Safety and Security so um you know in the past we've had a chief safety officer we've had an assistant director of safety and so this is an opportunity to have somebody to spearhead the

060initiatives emergency preparedness plans um School sites all the things associated with our school safety so um this is really exciting we have a lot of work that we're doing it Dr Frisco is very passionate about this uh work um we have obviously members up here on the board that have um students in our system I myself have students in our system so um we're going to make sure that we do this right and this position is going to be a great start for us any questions related to the description Mr Lemon thank you madam president um will we get applicants at that salary range so I did some research um I did uh connect with some of our surrounding districts and um some of the gurus uh behind it and I wanted to make sure

061that we had a competitive um seller range and so to answer your question yes um I think it's more than competitive um and so obviously we'll um once approved we'll post the position um and U obviously we anytime we post a position we're going to look at what our candidate pool is and make adjustments if we if we need to so uh but this is this is definitely being a new position it's not something that we are uh ever going to settle with we're going to make sure that we get the best for our district thank you you're welcome thank you Mr mcin 7.01 board information Miss Windsor oh did I do something wrong i' would like to make a motion to approve the director of Safety and Security position my gosh we just approved

062it in my head I'm all about safety you know that is there a motion to approve Charlotte just made a motion all Second Great Mr Miller second thanks guys we have to vote yep hold on I'm just Gathering my thoughts um I was way ahead all those in favor I I opposed motion passes 5 Z thank you team 7.01 board member points of information Miss wior just want to say uh how happy we are to have Ry on board with us and uh everybody's sworn in and we're good to go so that's great thank you very much for being here Ray Mr Lemon thank you um I think this is probably in my recollection the first time we've had three males on the board at the same time but I'm not sure I don't remember

063that far back just a comment but we've always had females in leadership in this board in this district and I appreciate that and thank you those that have joined the board and thank you for being our leaders I appreciate it thank you Mr Terry would you like to say anything thank you all for welcoming me to the board I'm happy to serve with you all um it is true that there's collegiality here I was at the uh new board member conference a couple weeks ago and that is not the case in every District it it is unique to be here and it is special to be here it's um inspiring to hear some of the um some of the stories and um it's leaves me with a lot with a lot to think about so

064I'm definitely thrilled to be here I have three kids who have gone through this district one who's a fifth grader at Broadmore uh my other kids are older they're all college age one's a college graduate um they were all at Broadmore and then the Aspire program at conate as well um so I'm happy to hear all of those comments and I'm happy to get to work with you all thank you thank you I too am excited to have you up here Ray welcome um I'm always grateful when we can have now two teachers representing our district so thank you to both of you for what you do and um second to Mr Lemon uh your institutional knowledge is uh we're just so grateful to have you and you're able to help us many times when

065we have to go back and say now why is it that we did it that way the first time and what do we need to do about it this time um I'm grateful for for all of you Eric and Charlotte I wish you a great new year and I'm I look forward to working with you guys and um with that said I wanted to thank everyone who came here tonight on our behalf um we had house elect member Janine Connelly we had a house member-elect Brian Garcia we had Senator Mitsy Epstein we had senator-elect Lauren QB we had a pre we have our previous board member um Miss Marge CI who's here with us today uh we've had the mayor Corey Woods and I say this because we are so fortunate to have a community

066who elects Pro public school advocates for us at the state level and I'm grateful that they came here tonight because not only were they showing their support for us but they were also showing the community support for our schools and it's a big deal um I think Ray can second this too being in other districts it's it's not everywhere that we have this community that really cares about our kids all of our kids um I'd like to thank my family who uh got me through this election cycle and um I have over 120 years worth of Education experience between my family and my friends who are here um I had friends who met me at 7 8:00 in the morning jumped in the car hit houses I have my girlfriend from grade school here Christina

067who uh took the phone calls when I just either needed to cry or scream or say what am I doing this for and her mom who would just send a text and say I love you and um and her son Sydney's here today and I get emotional on that because this is why I do this I do this for you guys and I do this for my son Brody who's also here who I can't even I can't see him but there he is hi buddy um so I just I I'm most excited for what are capable of doing in the United States of America for our kids with education and Trent you just loaded up the car loaded up signs loaded up rebar said come on let's go turned on the music and off we

068went and every single time I'm just so lucky um all of us up here will tell you that it takes an army and you have to be very connected with your family to be able to either a do what all of our staff members here and our admin are doing CU it is a family affair it takes an army to raise our children and we all want to be a part of the best that we can be we have teachers in this room who care about our children not just the moments they're teaching them but they care about our children the moment they leave the moment they go to bed the moment they're eating dinner and I'm just grateful for this community and being there for them so um thank you to our families and

069um and that I think is going to wrap up our meeting hold on I got to get to the right page page no I got more I got to tell you all about what's going on don't I in the next yeah I'm not ready yet okay 8.01 announcements and upcoming events the agenda committee will meet on Wednesday January 15th at 11:00 a.m. all schools and district offices will be closed in observance of Martin Luther King Jr holiday on Monday January 20th 2025 the next regularly scheduled board meeting will take place on Wednesday January 22nd 2025 at 7:00 p.m. in the Karen Arondo governing boardroom of the Sanchez administration building 3205 South Ru Road Arizona Tempe the building that we're in now the Tempe Elementary School District spelling be is Thursday January 23rd 2025 at 9

0709:00 a.m. in the Karen Arondo governing boardroom at the Sanchez administration building same address the tempy elementary Love Your Heart 5K sponsored by tea will be held Saturday February 15th 2025 at 8:00 a.m. at kuanana Park which is at 55 00 South Mill Avenue in Tempe and now 9.01 meaning adjournment do I have a motion motion to adjourn tonight's meeting motion by Miss Windsor second and by second Mr Terry thank you have a good night everybody thank you so much got a vote oh shoot see I'm I'm a guppy I'm ay uh does everyone do you guys is all those in favor of ending this meeting I is there anybody who's not in favor of ending this meeting motion passes 5 Zero thanks guys

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.