CorpusRecord 162296

Feb 13, 2025 - Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / LHUSD Lake Havasu Schools
Date
2025-02-14
Location
Mohave County, AZ
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,724 words · about 82 min
Collected
2026-07-01

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001awesome Crystal those especially e e e I call to order the lake havu Unified School District governing board meeting for February 13 here here we're going to have a moment of silence prayer and private private reflection amen would you please stand for the to the FL flag of United States America and to the repic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all you seated good evening I want to welcome all of you to tonight's uh governing board meeting we have a lot of exciting things on tonight's agenda um Jeff sign uh some information for you tonight as each agend item is before you um once the board is done speaking we will open up for calls to the public on each item that is included for those of you

002potentially that want to speak to an agenda item but you did not sign up um so no that will be available it will be three minutes per speaker um if there's a lot of speakers on an agenda uh we potentially could limit that to a certain amount for and a certain amount against also tonight we want to welcome um a dignitary in the house Arizona state representative Leo basuchi is with us tonight so representative welcome and now we'll get to it our first uh tonight is um 2.1 spotlights and recognition with uh lhca Carol norowski directors staff and Community uh this week the House and Senate education committee has been very busy um I have four that I picked out to share with you so I've already given that to you um House Bill 2169

003We are following everything in it but if past if you turn to the back page I've highlighted um instruction uh instructs a Gover board for school district with a student count of more than 5,000 to provide the public with a live feed of each governing board meeting we used to do that in the past during Co and such and when we stopped I will tell you every time we have a board meeting even tonight is it going to be live no it's not live but um it is something that I know our community wants and would appreciate um the next one is 1427 this one I love requires Arizona schools to require each full-time administrative employee of the school to provide a classroom instruction at least once per school year as a substitute teacher outlines

004exemptions from the requirement to substitute teach at least once per school year I know even tomorrow our site is short to subs and we're always searching so that would be amazing I know sometimes we do have some principles and AD and directors that have been in our classrooms but um that's a requirement uh the next thing is 1472 um this one I think you all need to be aware of is it requires a school district governing board to prepare a budget not just for one year but three fiscal years uh rather than to immediately follow the current year so I just give you a heads up that that's out there um we'll be following it for you just to keep your bre and then the last one which is um a concern and not just

005a concern it's just it's not that it's a horrible thing it's just it's time and requirement of our teachers um and it so right now K5 is required to get a literacy endorsement and this is now mandating that applies the literacy endorsement requirement to certify teachers provide literacy instruction in a special education program or setting in any grade level So currently it's K5 and so this will push it all the way through K 12 um the main concern always is is um fortunately right now with our letters it's being provided by ad um so we do have the grant so hopefully that would be offered during this but is a lot twoyear commitment uh so on our on our staff so just keep that in mind if it does pass that your staff is working

006really hard to fulfill that also I'm following as always prop uh 123 there are two bills there's one in the Senate and one in the house scr 1015 and HC 1047 neither have hit a committee yet and it's my understanding there will be a few changes before it does but once it hits um I plan on a letter writing uh party you'll bear us hears from me often so and um so and the other committee members uh that will be reading or seeing it um that we want we need to get it on that ballot um as we know it is sunset there is enough funds to take us into the next year but as of right now the following year we don't know what's going to happen and then I want to finish off

007by I sincerely thank you president Rose and board me board member reman for the collaboration on a 2526 compensation package we truly appreciate the time you took to listen to our staff's needs and concerns and uh look forward to the agenda item 6.4 passing this is going to be the beginning of an unmeasurable impact for our district our community but more importantly our students this gives us the opportunity for our principls and our district to attract and retain quality staff needed and so again thank [Applause] you all right moving on item 3.1 we will now open up for calls to the public Lanna good even me good even my name is Tamara Weaver and I have three children 12 n and seven currently enrolled in L cisu School District I couldn't have been more excited

008to read in the newspaper that our school school board is considering a policy to ban artificial food dieses from our schools aside from being a parent I am also a mental health therapist I'm a licensed social clinical social worker in the states of Arizona California and Nevada I've worked in the mental health field for over 22 years and I worked for County Mental Health for 20 years after retiring I now run my own private practice and Consulting business I can tell you in my experience in the mental health field that unfortunately many children can often be diagnosed with conditions such as ADHD and given psychiatric medications unnecessarily there are countless families I have encountered that when I ask them to consider eliminating food di from their child's diet are shocked at the major improvements in

009their child including improve attention and focus reduce Behavior outbreaks and aggression improve sleep control over their emotions and less anxiety the problem is that food dyes are in many foods that are marketed towards children such as cereals snacks chips cookies Etc these foods are also though many people may not be aware are not always colored Twinkies have red 40 chocolate pudding has red 40 marshmallows have blue food d tortillas have yellow food done Etc many adults here maybe wondering well I had the same Foods when I was little and I didn't have any problems well actually you did not right because the foods that we had when we were little did not have these toxic artificial food dies and chemicals in them um because unfortunately we have an incompetent Food and Drug Administration in our

010country for example food D number three was outlawed from makeup in 1990 because it was known to cause cancer but the FDA still allowed it in our food that we eat right up until last month they finally outlawed food D number three due to pressure from parents and some wonderful legislation that went through unfortunately that legislation only applied to Red Dy number three and not red 40 or the many other toxic fuit dce I'm happy that we have RFK working on this issue in Washington DC and I feel that there are going to be many policy changes that are going to come down regarding food D and I feel that our district is going to be ahead of the problem by working on this um other countries do not allow these chemicals in their food

011big Food Corporation makes two version of the same snacks one for America with toxic chemical seconds okay um my personally have reactions to these uh food dyes and I have not expected others to cater to them but some couple things you might want to keep in mind I have no more time go thank you [Applause] awesome welcome would you help welcome our students tonight I'm sorry this is good evening Mr President and members of the governing board my name is Molly seic and I am a very involved sophomore at LJ I hold multiple board positions in service and career-based clubs and I'm a stud student government's class vice president I am also a very proud member of our school and City's youth advisory Council I a member of our school's Lighthouse team and our next

012ke Club president my passion for our school and Community has taught me that Civic involvement for students is more important now than ever we want to serve as a spokes for our peers and are here to do exactly that today we look forward to working and collaborating with you and to have the opportunity to be here with you tonight thank you um this even too tall for me good evening president Rose members of the governing board and the public my name is mey sner and I've been a student in like C Unified School District since I was a little KN um I'm now currently a freshman in LHS I believe I firmly believe that it's important to be involved in my school and community so I'm a part of havy Youth advisory Council I'm the

013vice president of student council's class of 2028 along with the member of student athlete leadership team or I'm a track and swim athlete and a member of our lhhs Lighthouse team tonight my peers and I are here to build a strong relationship with this new governing board and the public we're really excited at the opportunity to work with adults who would like to be connected to the students with [Applause] they good evening governing board members and Community my name is Elijah ason I am a student government president of the class of 2027 Molly Macy and I are here tonight as ambassadors for the student body we know how powerful having the connected student voices for bringing Solutions forward we are in discussions with our Administration and involved teachers and advisors with the goal of building

014a relationship with the school board so that you might hear the ideas and concerns of those who interact with the school daily the students we are collaborating with the lighthouse team to use the leader in new platform to expand our student voices we sincerely look forward to being your team with this board in the future and we'll do our best to represent the needs and hopes of our student body thank you thank [Applause] you that's incredible that made my night item uh 4.1 consent agenda before we vote on the consent agenda I would like to move it 4.6 to 4.13 so that we can uh discuss it separately but I move to accept the remaining items of the consent agenda a second yes yes yeah so I make a motion to approve item 4.13 which

015would be um with from human resources and are at will work agreements and contracts for 2526 a second so the only reason oh get another discuss oh yeah go ahead the only reason I wanted to pull it out for discussion was because um there have been some changes to the contracts that we're off offering our employees and I just wanted to make sure that they didn't get lost in the shuffle um there's nothing bad about any of these changes like I said I just wanted to highlight them um so we are keeping our $2500 penalty for before the contract term expires um but we are adding some additional language that emphasizes reputational harm to our district and opportunity cost to our district um the second change I wanted to point out was that there is

016um an increase in our salary reduction notifications so our district retains the uh ability to reduce salaries due to a budget shortfall um and that is how it's been in the past as well but now we are providing a 20day notice before implementing that so that's a benefit um to employees although we never want to have to use that in the first place the Third change is um our resignation process so before when um an employee resigned we asked them for a reason for their resignation and they were certainly free to leave that blank but we did ask for it um in our contracts for the 25 26 year we will just be asking do you accept the contract or not you are still welcome to provide a reason for your resignation but we're not

017including a space for it on the form the fourth thing is Furlow this is another thing that um it's standard employment contracts that we never want to have to use them but we have um put in language to impose up to seven unpaid burlow days and then the fifth and final thing is that um there are changes to stick leave and paid time off in the sense that um before they were spelled out in your contract and now they will be um governed by board policy which board policy can change mid year uh prior when those sck leave days and paytime off days were listed out in your contract we weren't able to change them at all mid year without reopening contract negotiations this language leaves room for them to change mid year without contract

018negot a again it's not the kind of thing that we would do the only reason we would do it would be to um well let me put it differently ideally the only reason we would ever do that is to is for the employees benefit never for their detriment but it it does leave the language does leave that possibility open so again I don't think any of these changes are negative but I wanted you to be aware of them all right is there any I'm going to it up is there discussion from the board and we'll open it up to the at this time uh I will close discussion from the board and open it up for anyone that would like to discuss this item all right yes yes yes yes all right moving on item

0195.1 Business Services uh 26 athletic participation fees Mr Murray thank you Mr President board members as part of the discussion item tonight just prior to the passage of the voter approved M override in 2016 athletic participations participation fees were as high as $800 to participate in High School athletic programs like C Unified School District number one currently charges up to $200 to participate in sports programs at Thunderbolt middle school and $400 to participate in sports programs at the Lake havu High School the participation fee is collected each year sport programs rely on funding uh sources such as tax credit gifts and donations auxiliary and maintenance and operations uh to provide athletic opportunities for students summaries of Revenue beginning fund balance and expenditures for fiscal year 24 are attached to the discussion item now we'll open

020up for discussion from the board um so this is an item that I have brought before the board this evening um and talking with with parents that have their children in sports they um had expressed some interest they would like to see that fee lowered um especially whenever our students are still paying for um other things so it's not a one one fee that covers your uniforms and and know all of those things and as we know you know the economies has went up things are tight for families and we want to do what is best for the families of this District um so I brought this before the board to discuss um and speaking with the athletic director he was definitely um open to us discussing this and uh very excited for whatever and

021and supportive of whatever we decide tonight so um I'd like to open up Matt I know you had some inform and Mr M just looking at the so if I understand this correctly we are still in the in the black 735,000 at the end of the year if I understand this correctly correct that's that would be the beginning fund balance for this fiscal year and this is for our athletic department correct for both thunderbow and the high school so it to me know Sports and Athletics growing up was one of the best parts of school in fact it's probably the only part I likeed uh in high school I know that's for many boys um and many students as well going through going through this so when I hear that $400 Mark to me I

022know there are families that that may be prohibited um and so I I would like the board to put it on the agenda item for next to cut it in half I know to to take it wipe it completely out would be the goal but I think it would be wise to to cut it in half see how that affects the budget going forward uh and make a determination after that no I totally agree um I think this is something that's important and we want to be able to open up opportunities for All Families to for their children to be able to play sports we don't ever want a student or a family to feel that their child cannot participate in sports in our district because they can't afford to pay the money and um

023so I I just want us to be able to really hone in on this and do what is right for the student at the end of the day we we want to be able to promote Athletics and kids be able to love sports and and build relationships and friendships and and do all the things that that come with sports and uh so yeah I I definitely support C that in half and it's per child not family correct so if you had four children it's $1,600 okay and and Mr Murray could you explain so when when a family pays the $400 um would you be able to explain tonight where exactly we as a district direct that money so depending on how they pay if they pay via tax credit it goes directly to the program

024that they specify so some some individuals will will be very specific and say I want my money to go to football at the high school so the tax credit program is set up to where we can we can restrict those funds directly to that specific program we have a lot of people from the community that come in and say I really don't have a preference I want it to go to Athletics so then it goes to what's called an all reference or all Athletics account so then that gives the School site the ability to then determine where they need to use those funds in the all athletic uh program so some people don't elect tax credit they they don't have a tax liability and they just want to come in and and pay the fee

025and so that would go into auxiliary and then there are those within the community and and even through our booster programs where they will just make a donation so that will go into the gifts and donations fund depending on what what their their preference is we can restrict it down so that those monies are used only for that specific preference thank you Mr M is there any other discussion from the board I really do think that would be nice I mean I know there was a time even I had a hard time to be able to pay for some of of the sports so I'm I'm for it I'm in favor at least of discussing it I want I do want to make sure that we um think through all the consequences both intended and

026unintended it does sound like our Sports programs it does actually cost us quite a bit of money to provide those Sports to students so there's travel um a lot of our teams participate in sports that are in Phoenix and so they travel often for games um most of our coaches are within our are teachers and so if they are gone for the day for a game then they have to find substitute coverage so I just want to make sure that we're thinking through ramifications before we approve something um and also thinking of maybe additional funding sources or where that money could be made up from um I did have one idea was suggested to me by someone else that um because we choose or because we charge facility use feed um like for instance to

027have a suit heat to use our Fields I'm not even sure if that can be re redirected into an athletic fun but if it can that might be something that we consider it in whole or in part yeah you know the I saw the email here from Mr zapa and and I understand that there is higher costs with us being in a rural District but I don't think we should pass it on to the family right I think Sports and Athletics and physical activity is so important to our children that providing that extra cost at the burden of the district is valuable you know we don't have the benefit of being in Phoenix and being able to do those things so we as the district should be taking care and making sure our children have

028those opportunities so I I definitely think that's a valuable expenditure to and then to not pass that on to the students I think it's worth it and to compare where we are with other districts that surround us uh this was provided by our athletic director um Kingman School District Mojave Valley School District do not charge students a fee um Parker charges a dollar um then some regionals uh Buckeye un $50 individual cap $10000 and 150 family cap um Willow Canyon $150 per athlete and per Sport with a $300 cap uh Sunrise Mountain $100 per sport $200 individual cap and a $400 family cap um so and then some others uh Tempe Union $50 Gilbert and Higley charged between 150 to150 and Flaga Union $200 so that that just puts us in comparison um in my

029opinion we seem to be on the higher end uh of the districts around the state and would definitely like to see us come on the lower end so well and the one question I have we're looking at this so I'd like to maybe keep this as a discussion for next week before we move to a vote on it making a decision next month or next month thank you um and and do it as if okay we cut it in half how much is that actually changing the dollar value here and you know what is that going to reduce the 735 to 550 to 6 where is it and and and then I'd be interested in your opinion on how black do we have to be how how much in the positive Revenue do we have

030to be I mean we're not you know it's good to have money in the bank but we want this Athletic program and these funds to be going towards our children so having almost a million dollar in the ath going forward each year I'd like to hear where you're comfortable with that where maybe our athletic director is comfortable with that and really see what the difference is hey we cut this in half and it only drops us 100,000 that's something we can eat so if I can point out up here the you'll notice that there's no fund balance or Revenue in the maintenance and operations line so right now we rely on auxiliary gifts and donations and tax credit as the primary funding source maintenance and operations which is our general fund which 85% of teacher

031salaries and benefits come out of Maintenance and operations um you can see that m is acting as the absorbent so revenue is really only 428,000 that comes into the programs based off of that $400 or the $100 $200 at Thunderbolt and then all of the expenses maintenance and operations is filling that Gap in the tune of in this fiscal year 321 ,000 that's been fairly consistent over the years in the $300,000 range so you'll notice that travel is one of the big expenses definitely top three and as Mr zampona pointed out in one of his emails he shared the fact that most of our competitions happen in West Phoenix so five typically 50% of the games are at home 50% are on the road so we are traveling 50% of the time sending a bus

032or to m per game down to West Phoenix whereas the competition in West Phoenix they're competing they're out of their 50% of their games if they have 10 games one of those games is up here the other four away games are in West Phoenix so they're kind of in their neighborhood so they're not traveling 200 miles each way like we do for 50% of the time so that's where those costs just really begin to just just the Skyrocket that's the that's the hard part for where we live G absolutely absolutely but anything any reduction I would say that you're going to see a reduction in Revenue because the fee is cut and then but I'd like to see what that number is so because then we can make that determination of this is the amount

033of students that are paying this fee this is the total we're getting from it this is the total we're losing if we cutting it half once we have that number we can look at the budget and say this is doable or this is not if it comes to the point where the the gas funds and those things balance we may have to look at something maybe capping it to the the family cap a household cap something like that to can figure that out but um I I think we can move that to next meeting's discussion I can I can get total number of participants and then calculated against the $200 for high school $100 for Thunderbolt and then that should tell us exactly what our Revenue istic well and just a question for Mr Houston

034but um are you thinking of the being um per individual or per family and and that number obviously I'd like to see where the numbers because like in this email the sunsize the Sunrise Mountain 100 per sport 200 individual cap or a 400 family cap so something along that line I'd like to see the numbers to see where out we need to fit in there um but I would like to to I'd like to get that number before we really make an establishment how the Fe schedule should work that's the scenario that stood out to me the most too that made the most sense yeah so okay any other discussion from the board all right moving on to action items uh tonight we are going to start with uh action item 6.1 thank you Mr

035President board members first reading of model policies will be presented for review discussion and possible action the trust proposes style revision to the following policies in order to improve Clarity this includes punctuation and numbering policy 1301 Rules of Order policy 5-24 students with disabilities procedural safeguards individuals with disabilities Education Act idea policy 5-48 hazing prevention the trust proposes style revisions and a substantive change to policy 5-23 High School High schol school districts are now required to inform students and their parents legal Guardians of the of the anticipated date of graduation at least one year prior to the anticipated date and are required to begin transition services for special education students in the freshman year the trust proposes to the trust proposes to divided procedures implementing policy 5306 into two parts one for student suspensions and

036one for student expulsions the governing board proposes procedure 3-30 1.1 safe and healthy school lunches to ensure the health and safety of all students by prohibiting the use of certain additives and ingredients in school lunches that are known to pose potential health risks thank you Mr Murray um tonight we are going to discuss um the the safe and healthy school lunches and uh this is something that I'm extremely passionate and excited about and um whenever I've seen that my colleague at the State House began working on this bill I reached out to representative basuchi and said hey um I want to work with you on this because I would love to do this in our district this is a district that loves kids and we want to um provide better food better lunches and um

037luckily for us of the owner of our our company our provider tarar is um someone that is also a big proponent of this and I'm a champion for this as well and so tonight we um are going to have a couple of speakers on this issue I am honored to welcome um Arizona state representative Leo Bei to the m to discuss this bill tonight first of all I just want to say thank you guys so much be here today president Rose thank you for reaching out I know you reached out how do we how do we get a district involved pass to theare spoke about it and why this is so important and I think the thing I want to talk about is how you know I can't blame my parents a lot of people

038in this room because years this we just didn't know we didn't know doing we didn't know chemal are doing for our B for our to but now we do now the science is there you know the bill that presenting that IED last a fantastic bipartisan support and um the list that we with this B this prob I don't the only we know we want to make we start someone we want to make sure we start with the that have the DAT very important for me to make everything because of what it may or may not do we want scient data and pro behind it all these it so you see in my 2 all of those have the data why shouldn't be our and now we're not talking about children in talk ad so you

039think about that think about our children consuming these items um obviously need of and dat is reason single one of these because they have and they even it's not 100us they issues test seeing in the lab we're going to take the approach we're going to remove it stud it and it's good ex cies cereals and it's inter you go to Europe anybody I'ma the wine and iceam feel great you don't you don't have that feeling when do that here and then when you look at the lab you realize don't have things in and there's a reason for that and so I'm excited manag Miss she's here [Music] this dep involed and compies and it not this to we can do it and right is on the market now so the great news is we're at

040a point I think in society in manufacturing of food that by this money is literally designed for you Market milant reason I love this because allow District okay this is our try keep it clean we use our food supplier or we can go to Walmart or we can go to farm market or we can go to get these that also helps the commun in my op talking about more local market op this is such a great thing it's super excited to see that this P happen today is great news I think for everybody that's behind this and so it's exting and I hope you guys continue moving forward really the first sooud you guys thank [Applause] you we have a that we're talking $10,000 permanent ra for our teachers so now it's going to pass

041I know it's going to pass we have the v i Ved for that just try to make that our staff is being and I just want to point outly legis we have always about your community your District who you represent I always about that came from this District school high school I love this place I love but we do things right right when we give raises we give to the teachers we don't sweep it somewhere else we provide Health we do so many things right that so many other schools are not doing and so I just want to know how proud am what you've done this school board previous School Board this has been just a model for a lot of other districts to say how does Ed um previously wait a minute you guys

042have freeth for your teachers Andes and you still have all these you have kindergart you still have they couldn't believe that you guys were able to figure this out and so I just want to say thank you guys so much for all you do every teacher in here every administrator everybody in the school board that's involved you guys have been KCK and I'm app [Applause] all right at this time I'm going to invite our uh Food Service supervisor Miss T to the mic good evening Mr President members of the board a few weeks ago board president Rose asked me to analyze our food purchases considering representative beuchi's upcoming bill I reviewed hundreds of product data sheets for School meals adult meals and our catering the good news over 98% of our purchases met our high

043standards for School meals reduced fat sodium sugar and are all whole grain Rich our poultry items are all natural hormone free almost all the produce we purchase is grown in the USA when available we purchased local grown organic and most of it's grown in Arizona we even Incorporated Arizona grown grass-fed beef into our menus during my review I did find some items less than 2% that contain the ingredients identified in representative beuchi's Bill no items contain pottassium bromate propo paraben or brominated vegetable oil however one icing contain titanium dioxide which is a whitening agent found in powdered sugar due to this finding we will no longer purchase that [Applause] product we've also identified Lucky Charms Fruit Loops blueberry poptarts dill pickles and the strawberry flavored milk these items are part of did let's see here

044um these items are part of a school meal and contain a couple of the Dy ingredients identified in repres representative beuchi's bill as part of the high school snacks and alart offered whole grain lowfat Cheetos Doritos A reduced sugar orange ice cream bar and the rehydration sports drinks are all identified to contain ingredients in a representative VII bill due to these findings we are actively seeking better alternatives to these products School Food Service strictly adheres to all federal state regulations that require mandated levels of calories per grade group whole grains sodium sugar and fat limits in all of our offerings this new District policy and upcoming legislation will be no different we will continue to review nutrition and specification labels to identify any items that contain the ingredients identified in representative cheese bill I was

045just notified today after all the pressure on some of our local manufacturers that Shamrock Foods is reformulating it strawberry milk to remove the dye everybody's happy now let us ow theand better from these manufactur together we can push for Real Change awesome thank you so much all right before discussion um we will take motion I'll move to approve 6.1 a second all right now we will open for discussion all good um at this time we would love to give anybody in the room um that would like to speak to this item uh man that was cut off by the uh now's your time come on up is right okay all right so many people um tagged me on social media come today so I don't allow my kids to have any food diet at all

046um I have them bring their own snacks for class parties if it's somebody's birthday they have their own organic treats um but there's a couple things I think you guys need to think about is one the school nurse the medicine that they give has been Rec in it the Tylenol the ibuprofen I know that's something totally different just maybe something to think about for the future I have my own Die free Ibuprofen that I leave in the nurse's office for my and I um when they have like popsicle otterpop parties there is Die free otter poops there's also simply Doritos and Cheetos in case you want the same manufacturer makes them without food d simply okay sorry um so I just wanted to add that I believe that the school district will have less behavioral

047problems improved concentration and focus in the students which will result in better testing scores and better student outcomes for all of the students um so I'm just very happy that you guys are leading the way and very happy of who I voted for so thank you very much thank you is there any other discussion from the public Chef Chris come on up as well use them um so um I want to thank you and you for bringing um and and Miss for do her hard work and for uh Robert k j for bringing this stuff the national momentum at me so most of talking about is really a manufacturing a national manufacturing problem as Mr B said um tah as you learned with your phone call from Bruce is a company started by a crazy

048man who loves food and loves chefs and in early 1980s he was sick of working for the standard contract and so we're a chefing company and we we want to be on the Ed of this sort of initiative um one of the benefits we have here is that we're on a cross reimbursable Arrangement so that what the district puts before us we do we're we're the management company and that's it we don't necessarily we provide our expertise to make that happen um so we don't use any of these additives in your list or any others that I know of other than sort of salt and sugar items um in our production of recipes locally um we have found as an out a very small number that are in manufactured General Mill cereals uh flamas flamas

049um and sports strings so um we have removed and stopped purchase already of all the items we found including Lucky Charms which make some students man at me uh and we're running out whatever small stock we had we run on a sort of a weekly turnover so um I believe that we will be able to reach your first M post by spring break so eliminating it from all breakfast and lunches uh the other mile poost the 2027 mile post is the much harder one and that is these popular chips um Sports strings for athletes um the the other wall we're sandwiched against which an mentioned is the um Federal smart snack program so I took the syes and I took the Annies which were suggested and I put them in the calculator and they are

050not full grain Rich they we too much sodium and saturated fat so they're not comply it and everything we sell whether it's alart all those items are only alak cart so they do not use School funds they're specifically designed and we specifically have to price them so everything that goes into that person's transaction the labor the cost of goods the storage everything is in that price which sometimes gets people angry when our prices are higher than Circle K um so that doesn't use the subsidized money we will continue to work on that um I had a wonderful meeting with one of Bruce's Sons who's our head of procurement today and and our head of dietetics and nutrition who are fast at work contacting our larger supply network and working on these problems so and if

051it comes to the point where we make that decision where we're just not going to have fla we'll have baked potato chips something without the dice and that's what we'll do we're we're so got home for this and I know Bruce spoke with you about his mission and his Bel this change in administration is going to lead to nothing but good for our program and your program so we appreciate the opportunity thank you thank you Mr President Che Chef Chris Chef so during this process we've had several meetings representative basuchi we had that meeting with you as well but off you know in a separate meeting between Chef Chris and and Miss ta they pointed out uh a practice that they developed not too too long ago but before this ation even started to even

052come to light and you just shared wasn't very it wasn't really the most popular thing but it really made me proud of not that I'm a proud guy but it just made me happy and pleased that that t her and our people are trying to be forward thinkers so could you just share what you did with green eggs and ham is coming up again but can you just share I mean again wasn't the most popular thing but it was Forward Thinking and definitely ahead of this conversation so can you just share kind of what you did to so uh green I inherited this and I'm probably its biggest enemy in terms of the frood side of it but Green Eggs and and I I wear the cat and hat costume and I go around to

053the schools when we serve green eggs and ham and um you know there were all sorts of problems with it when I inherited it and as we were coming back out of Co I had an opportunity to sort of rethink it and redesign it and so it was grey food dying eggs and was ham like turkey ham and and um so we you know really thought through what is the best process for this so they're you know of course vegetable purees and vegetable based powders that can color to this stuff um and then we also switch to half a green egg so the the portion size we have we made half of it green which the kids don't really want but they they get you know it's all about things and so and then we

054do half of scrambled egg with the green so was that yeah but just a substitute for the green Dy you used you used spinach or something like some type of to color it green wasn't the most popular I think though that it was kind of nice to see in all of these um conversations that have been had since then that we have people here that are trying to be Forward Thinking well before this conversation even started and and I want to brag on onar her uh so representative basuchi and I had the great honor of attending um along with my wife Crystal um the mahog um inaugural ball in in DC it was packed and the owner of of this wonderful uh group was there we didn't get the meeting but he is very passionate

055about this so um invited him to the table and um I just want to share with the board what that looks like um is the the tarar fam is coming together with Lake AB unified for us as a district to set the standard Across the Nation and to really be the district that says we've done this and now you can too and as the president of this board that is our vision for for this board as a team is that moving forward that we are setting standards uh and examples for what school districts can look like and Achieve when people come together in unity and lay down our our opinions and differences and say we want what is best for kids and so tonight as the president of this board I'm honored that I'm almost

05699% sure that we will be the first school district in the United States of America to make this policy so thank you thank you [Applause] all right bring it back to board discussion any it's just crazy hearing this I'm so proud that we're going to be able to do this it's like deja Ru though because when we were running Matt this is all you talked about like it's finally happening so I'm proud about this it's a great night all right well yeah go ahead of all us Center I just realized my mic was off um this helps us Center our um discussion around specific ingredients and if we have disagreement we can pinpoint the source of that disagreement instead of squabbling over word choice um I did have a couple questions because I was trying

057to look up each of these specific ingredients um I have no problem with all of the being listed I could find I found a source for that um this was from the international Journal of Occupational environmental health but it said online us approved dies raise health concerns of varying degrees and I found literature to support the elimination of brominated vegetable oil and actually the FDA did ban that it's been banned since July of 2024 and I found literature to support the elimination of potassium bromate um it's l to nephos toxicity and mitogenic effects um the only thing I I couldn't find two citations for uh or citations for two of the ingredients and you know it's kind of one of those things like I just might not have access to the right subscriptions because they

058say the lies are free but the truth is sometimes behind a pay wall so that's good the newspaper will quote you tonight behind the pay wall of the newspaper but the two ingredients that I could find support for were titanium dioxide and purpal paraben so I know this is a first reading and we've talked maybe about waving the first reading but if we wouldn't I I think we should have this as a first reading and still come back to this next month as a second reading um if my colleagues agree um that way I can know that I making decision okay yeah so yeah and ref could you speak to to her question while we have the the expert in the room um just for the record I'm not a doctor or nutritionist so I'm

059wrong just play one yeah so the titanum dioxide uh this is one that um oddly the chem chemical company founding the hallway their lobbyist and said uh you know we'll we'll leave you alone if you just remove titanium Dio from your list of all these items um I have a great staff I have great researchers and interns and they pulled up this list that I have here that um I gave to all of you on the board happy to share so the thing with titanium dioxide um is they've done studies and they how they do these St doing Petri dishes and they obviously put you know um the testing in there and what they found was it's toxic but not at high levels the problem is it stays in your organs permanently and so the

060reason why there's so much backlash is that if you continue to eat these things over and over and it continues to stick in your body and it doesn't completely get taken out um eventually you're going to have an excess amount that will be problematic but with these research obviously these tests you don't have 30 40 50 year studies that can say okay we know for sure in year 50 this is now going to cause liver cancer or whatever they do know that it does stay in your body and attaches to your orans um in small amounts and they're saying well the small amounts aren't toxic well at some point that will turn into a big amount and so the data is there happy to provide more um uh references if you need them on any

061of these um like I said we did a deep dive on making sure the only ones being included had the data to prove it um and so I'm always happy to prove that and look like I said before this list is going to grow it might even change um things come off and on when studies happen um and so import to to know that we understand that as a legislature and we thought about how do we handle that and we we decided look we're just going to come back if we need to every few years if things change I think you're going to see a big change now that RK junr has been brought into the mix because the thing that happened with art R three is completely to me is Criminal I mean you

062have a die that they said caused skin cancer but they still let us eat it for 35 years because it was hidden and the only reason it got changed was because they knew the tide was shifting at the federal level so um I understand you want to make sure that the data is there I am the same way and this is why I made this list is smaller instead of having you know you can go into seed oils you can go to all these different things we didn't do that um but I'm always happy to provide data you guys obviously the board it's your call um what you want to do now this will remain in my list um at the state level so obviously if that passes and get let's assume it goes into

063play in September um you guys can obviously change it then so obviously up to you guys figure that up thank you yeah yeah this is absolutely wonderful the fact that we are are able to directly affect our food this is something we have to do thank you thank you for speaking on this is kids get these things in their body and it gets builds up to a toxic level and we do see those behavioral issues we do see see issues down the line and looking at this titanium dioxide nanop particles the only purpose of it is for wiing food it it what they do to our food is for Aesthetics and so we are putting manmade chemicals in our food for Aesthetics or preservative purposes where it just really shouldn't be there so and especially

064when you know we believed the FDA was acting in our best interest like you said we can't blame people we thought we had a government body that protected us and we now know that they were not acting in our best best interest especially when all of these are banned in Canada you you don't get the the the toxic levels in these um so I think going forward tonight uh is is fine um if it was just these two um that you had concerns with I I think their basis for you know what whitening food strengthening dough resisting R these are chemical additives to uh to assist in the ultra processed food process so I have no problem getting them out getting them out tonight Mr vice president president I do want to point out that

065um you know mentioned before the good news is is 98% of the food list that's in the cataloges um does not have any of the stuff that's the great news and you are correct Mr Houston a lot of these almost all these things are for Aesthetics right they're like you're right titanium dioxide literally all it does is whiten the food so it's not like this is a nutritional benefit to you to have this in your in your item so if you don't need it in there and there are alternatives then why I agree you you go that route if you can't play safe like Europe and everybody else does um unfortunately we don't do that in the United States but hopefully that changes I'd like to see high frose corn syrup added to this list

066whole other happy to talk about thank and um you know I I'm willing to move forward and even W second reading on this tonight this is a bill that um I I was in education committee when this past education committee and I can tell you from being there and have an opportunity to speak um to legislators on both sides of the aisle uh this is going to pass um legation 100% and I'm very proud um that is our representative that has championed this um and I'm proud that we get to be a district and and we get to be in line with what is coming down the road with state law um also in conversations with our provider uh these are things that they really don't have in their doze anyway um so we're already

067as a district in alignment even with the two items that member Raman is in question of we do not have those currently in our product and uh so waving second reading tonight or not voting is I'm opposed to that thank you I'm not quite ready to vote yet I I would like to talk about um I I assume that boosters would not be affected by this because like our concession fans aren't held during school hours corre okay and then what about um our schools often host events like Grandparents Day where things like cookies are brought in they have to be store bought but they're brought in and then they're served to students and their families are we including that or we saying only the things that are sold or served by our food service just

068take can you speak to that please or Chef is just for food we produced if someone bar up in we're not going to go into policing every item that enters the district represent basuchi can you speak to that because that will be in the in the law as well uh Mr President obviously um it's up to you guys you have you're doing your own thing in my bill it's very clear that we're not stopping parents from providing their child with what they want I still believe in Parental ch and you know if they want to bring a give their child bag of flam H Cheetos have at it that's their choice it's their child um this is talking about obviously F that you are providing yeah so I think you are safe to say that

069if you have some kind of school party um and they want to bring something to the trial cupcakes I mean I don't know if you want get down to that nitty-gritty and getting that stri on it but I will say that in our bill we're saying um within school hours but the parent if they provide it we're not you're not Stu there and this policy would liit that so thank you well it's it says School Meal providers and vendors so it does not add in its definition outside that puts my mind ease about that and I then I have to do one more thing absolutely um I was wondering if we can add or if we want to add a clause for self-report um you know food service is a big industry and it's um

070there's hundreds of Products that come into our kitchens every week with different product codes and there's for human error so can we put in a clause there that um says that our food administrator can self-report without penalty I mean the way it's worded now it kind of sounds a little bit mistrustful so I'm glad you brought that up actually um there was talk of what happens if schools are not complying um with this law assuming it get passed passed inside by the governor we did not go the route of penalty uh we went the route of ad is going to uh provide a form to the schools and say really saying are complying to this law if you are we're going to post it on the ad website that this school is in compliance if

071you're not we're going to let the parents do what parents do if they find out that school is not complying because we know what mama and bears will do if they're not complying with these things um so I my personal recommendation is you kind of do the same thing right you kind of do that the self check um putting a penalty that's going to do anything the whole point is let's encourage and we made ad are the same thing that we' agreed on your ad job to encourage schools help them get there like how do you get to this point to your these These scuds are out that we know are toxic Let's help you get to that point um and then we will report on who's doing it who's not and let the parents

072figure that out if they want their child in that school or not all right thank you how would you want that yeah and we can add that in our motion my off again um it does make it I'll read it again just in case for the viewers um any violations of this policy will result in immediate corrective actions and potential termination of contracts with non-compliant vendors so it does make it sound like one strike in your out to me um so we could say non-compliant or or vendors or food service members um May self report without you know record correction will be made without um without without risk of termination can we add that so yeah so at the end of the sense any violation of this policy will result in immediate corrective actions and

073potential termination of contract with non-compliant vendors however vendors May self report without um fear of termination okay great we need a a motion um Motion in a second okay we not that yes yes yes and now at this time I would like to motion to wait second reading of this policy I second yes yes yes right we are officially the first school district to have this thank you item 6.2 staff compensation Lisa ran member Raman is going to be reading this this evening okay okay so the district continues to strive towards better overall staff compensation the governing board will consider the following changes to the current salary schedule we will be increasing all salary schedules by six steps and steps will be paid to recognize longevity as follows I'm going to read out a bunch

074of dollar amounts so steps zero four Z through four actually I'm going to do it through all the salaried workers first so salaried workers steps 0 through 4 would be 1,000 steps 5-9 1,250 steps 10 through 14 1500 steps 15 through 19 1,750 and steps 20 and more and this is inclusive of prio would be 2,000 for our hourly workers step 030 through 4 would be an increase of 50 cents steps 5 through 9 63 cents steps 10 through 14 75 cents steps 15 through 19 88 cents and steps 20 or more inclusive a prio would be $1 for our Administration steps 0 through four would be an increase of, 1500 steps 5-9 would be an increase of 1,875 steps 10 through 14 would be 2250 steps 15 through 19 would be 2,625 and steps

07520 and more inclusive of prio would be 3,000 for our supervisors steps 0 through 4 would be 1,250 steps 5-9 would be $1,562 steps 10 through 14 would be 875 steps 15 through 19 would be $ 218750 and steps 20 and more inclusive a PR would be 2500 for our salaried support workers steps 0 through four would be 1,150 steps 5 through n would be $1,437 steps 10 through 14 would be 1,725 steps 15 through 19 would be 2, $1250 steps 20 and above inclusive of prio would be 2,300 a motion to approve as presented second all right at this time we will open it up for board discussion um I am very excited about this agenda item this evening um this is something that um this this new board is very passionate about and

076whenever um I started working on this I uh reached out to to Lisa to member Raman and said I want you to come alongside me on this because she is the the longevity board member here in the district and I believe in Partnership you're not and um I believe in Partnership and uh we're a team and we must work together this is something that she has also been passionate about um with her previous board members and um so we came together and we met with the um our Teachers Association here in the district and uh and said look let let's do this and we brought the superintendent in um as well as business services and HR um this has been a team effort and uh it's something that's been a long time coming our employees

077matter without you from the janitor to the bus driver to the person that answers the phone to our maintenance stff to our facility management teams to our office staff to our par pros and most importantly to our teachers our principles and our administrators we're a family and um we you matter without you without people this District would not succeed would not be here and uh would not be have the opportunity to be in my opinion um on the way to be the greatest District in the state of Arizona that is the goal of this board but we need to take care of our people and um so I'm very excited about this and um it's just a start um but I want you to know all of you that you matter whatever your position is

078in this District um we are thankful for you and we want you to stay we want you to come back and um and know that your voice to this board matters um we are available and know that we always have an open door policy to you um so tonight I'm honored to uh present this to this board any other discussion from the board I also wanted to make sure that the our um local Education Association received thanks they deserve a lot of credit for working with us yes they do and and to add to that um to add to that whenever um Carol and Joel came to the table um they felt a sense of relief to know that this was something that all of us are passionate about and I just want us to

079honor them for a moment because this is something teachers they have been working and staff and and I I want to say this that when they came to the table um I know they're the Teachers Association but they were very clear this needs to be for all staff because everybody matters so please give them a um yeah this was uh fantastic work Rec Dave um getting this there because this was one of the main concerns we had this is one of the main concerns of the district how do we keep people how do we retain people well when you can have a competitive wage at in and out better hours and and things like that it's hard to get people to stay and work this is the right step in the right direction if you

080want a good product you have to pay the price for it and investing in the people in our district is how we produce that product so thank you to everybody here and this again this is the start we we hope we caning more of this type of of action for you yes any other board discussion before I open up call to the public well I I did want to point out so this proposal is based on a certain Assumption of Risk by our board um so this uh proposal is sustainable for between two and three years with what we currently have beyond that we are are relying on a couple of ifs and unknowns so the first if would be um if we can get an override to pass locally in 2026 and then the

081second if would be um The Proposition one two three changes that that Mr B is mentioned so um we want this to be a long-term sustainable um salary schedule but and it is for the next couple of years but beyond that we are going to be relying on our community to keep it sustainable and I feel like you know you can say what your priorities are but how you spend your time and how you spend your money proves what you actually value I think that this salary increase is a way of our board showing that we do value what we say we value we value teachers we value all of our staff we want to be able to track the best and the brightest and so um this is consistent with that absolutely and and

082I want to speak to um a future override um just so we're in we're all together we in session I can do this um I've already began having meetings with key players who were part of the last override um members of our community um who were champions of that such as Steve gy and um we are already casting vision and working um of what that looks like and I'll be putting together a committee to work on that as well um some of the things I've I've already had discussion with member Raman as we were uh working on this um salary increased was smaller classroom sizes and being able smaller classroom sizes to be able to hire more teachers if we if we're going to set the standard for the nation we got to do it

083the right way and we can get the community involved this is a community that loves kids and loves teachers and um so I'm excited to begin the work on that and and to the directors on that just as we are doing these types of things I'm really interested didn't want to keep the data on retention on the teachers brought in on those interviews and things like that are potential candidates saying oh you guys have an attractive pay scale so those are the things especially as we go to that 26 deadline and things these are the types of things and facts and figures that when we bring forth an override said look this is the money speaks we brought people in we had better retention we had better test scores um and that's what we were

084hoping to bring in that so collecting that data moving forward and be successful keeping this PA go because I I really like the way you said that is this is what matters we are going to put our money where our mouth is and we're going to we said we were bringing raises to teacher and we're doing it at this time at this time um I would like to open up a call to public on this agenda item would someone please shorten the mic for Miss bons all right there you go oh okay hello hi hello I'm Christina bonsing I've worked at benol middle school for six years my passion is teaching I came from being a a manager at a bank before I started working as a teacher as you can imagine that was a

085pay cut um and now I have two young children one's in the district he's five the other is three I pay $200 a week for her to go to school so I can still teach my children and I call them my children in my room so I just want to say thank you for considering this and putting this on the board because my husband's working his butle for support us so thank you [Applause] thank you yes man good evening my name is Christina M and I am a teacher of the district with law the longevity I've been here this is my 21st year in the district and I want to say that this is the first time in a long time that I can go home and proudly say to my husband that we are

086getting a contract that is going to have something added to our base my husband is a firefighter he has only been in the service for 14 years and he has by far as you can imagine surpassed me and me with I have a master's degree a bachelor's degree and we just have not been paid what we have been able to be competitive with in the state and what I want to thank you more so is because I am in that year 21 and I am on that downhill slide is thank you for um bringing uh our base pay to $50,000 so that we can attract teachers that are invested in our district that want to serve our students and want to learn from the best because we do have the best in this district and

087I think it's a little deceiving I'm just going to point out to the public when they're looking at that we have friends that are like is that enough is that okay with you when you see six steps every one of us are going to go down six steps so we're all going to get six steps in addition to that longevity the longevity is based on steps not years so when you look at the year if you're thinking of a year 10 teacher they're not necessarily on step 10 so there is still room for teachers to grow but I just want to thank you for also allowing us not only the opportunity to make that base and change but also thinking about our district as we need all staff we need our Paras all the way

088up to our admin and we could not do this job without them so we appreciate you making sure that all staff are represented in this so thank you I'm also really short sorry all righty um hi my name is Sage best um I started teaching in our district in January of 2020 year um my husband is a laavu City firefighter and has been for over 18 years um we both grew up in leav Unified School District since Kinder all the way to high school and we're both um lhhs alumni um we have three children one at or gring Classical Academy one at Thunderbolt middle school and one at the high school I would like to think that we are very invested in serving our community as well as watching it grow I would like to

089start by saying thank you to our local aea representatives for preparing this and to the board and our Administration for allowing us to discuss it um there are many Professionals in our district who work hard to meet the needs of students every day but there are also moms and their dads and grandparents and coaches and tutors and business owners and volunteers having the increase in salary pay will incred will be incredibly beneficial not just for my family but for all teachers and it doesn't there this will benefit the much needed retention of par professionals counselors occupational therapists speech and language Pathologists and psychologists along with the many other important positions that we must have filled to um meet the needs of our students but most importantly this will will impact students and I know it

090will and that's why we are all here thank you [Applause] is there any more for the call to the public seeing none I will close and we'll bring it to a yes yes yes [Applause] yes at this time a motion to wave second reading and okay we're good never mind I was just making sure yeah all right moving on uh to item 6.3 budget review member uh Mr Vice President thank you Dave and uh this is something that we had talked about on the campaign is that when we steep in as a board we're going to make sure all um things are uncovered we have a good picture going forward so uh in our commitment to transparency in all areas the governing board will engage with Brisco Consulting Group to conduct a comprehensive analysis of

091operational revenues and financial management mechanisms as a standard external review the process is advantageous for the district at any point in the fiscal year regardless of the current level of Financial Health this analysis provides an in-depth review of Financial inflows and outflows budget controls and optimization opportunities it helps ensure Financial practices are transparent aligned with the district goals and presented in a way that is understandable to all stakeholders Brisco Consulting Group has over 20 years of experience in management operations and financial oversight everything is Guided by one principle working in the best interest of children specifically Brisco Consulting Group supports Public School Systems in achieving Financial transparency strategic alignment and operational excellence Mr Brisco has collaborated with school board members and administrators to enhance their understanding of public school finance and Foster inter agency cooperation

092Brisco Consulting Group specializes in providing external Financial reviews that deliver Clarity actionable insight and practical strategies tailored to the needs of school districts the work is centered on employing empowering all stakeholders school board members administrators and community members with a deeper understanding of school business there will be a focus on producing reports that are clear accessible and designed to benefit everyone who relies on the information for decision- making regardless of their financial background this time we'll call for a motion on motion um to accept the budget review I second I now open up for discussion from the board um I first want to say um that we are incredibly thankful for our business and service department um this is this review is not because we think there is issues in that department U this review

093is based on we want transparency to the community um that is something that we uh believe in District believes in um this is bringing an extra pair of eyes who is a professional works with school districts around the nation uh to just maybe point out some things that our district didn't think about so this again is um we don't believe there's any issues we are so thankful for Mr Murray and his team and uh what they do for this district and um again this is something um for us to offer more transparency to the community and uh to come back as a board and along with our directors as we are casting Vision to move forward um and be able to use as a tool so thank you and thank you Mr Murray for your

094helpful any other discussion I have two questions um so how was or who chose Brisco and how was that company chosen um so so um Brisco was contacted through our national school boards Association that we work with um Dr Stone our superintendent spoke with them um they had put out and and there's certain areas of expertise that are very limited and this is one of them um School finances is very as Mr Murray will tell you is very difficult and there's a lot of federal laws and state laws that must be met and um so you can't just have any auditor come in or Budget Finance Company come in and look at your finan and know what they're looking for what they're doing um so this is some an organization Mr Brisco this is exactly

095his scope of work and um so that that's our show yeah so this was a recommendation from nsba or a different organization uh it was a recommendation of nsba and after our superintendent spoke with them she felt comfortable with the company as well so okay um so okay so in a situation like this what we're really voting on is three things one is if we think a budget review is necessary who we want to provide that service and um how much are we willing to pay for the service and typically when you have something a service that you would like you request multiple bids um and then the um board members are able to discuss those different vendors because the price tag for this is below a certain threshold we are we do not have

096to do that um but I will say that only having one choice to choose from as a board member feels like it eliminates um half of of the choice that I should have as a board member I should be able to weigh on weigh in on the if The Who and the how much and in this case I am only able to weigh in on the if I don't disagree that a budget review is needed and so I'm going to for tonight I'm going to um I believe that our District's need for a budget review outweighs my own personal procedural objections to how this was done but in the future you know we talked about how transparency and local control are important to us and so in the interest of transparency and local control I

097would like a menu of choices in the future okay and and just to be clear the reason this is before you and and to touch on what uh member Raman has pointed out uh this did not have to be placed on the agenda um this could have just been uh directed by the superintendent um to our business director to move forward with contract um as the president of the board I requested that she put this on tonight's agenda because again this board wants transparent transparency to the community um of what we're doing what's happening um we're not going to operate behind closed doors and and hide things from you so um but I do take under advisement your your recommendation as well so thank you member ront yeah and just again super superintendent Stone had

098had interviewed with them and discussed with them and she felt comfortable so I I feel comfortable based on her recommendation as well as the recommendation from the organization they are reputable and uh I also but I I I do agree I would also prefer the process it does take a little bit longer maybe a month so but it does provide us that extra level AB all right so the superintendent she definitely did mention that to us too for the fact that it was hard to find the right person because this is a special thing for when it comes to the school um I'm super thankful for Mr Murray and his graphs and his outlines and and how I could just read everything but having a second pair of eyes won't hurt um especially to help

099find to be able to do more raises or anything about I mean absolutely why not right i'm to approve oh I was going to open up for call um we've already motion yes yeah at this time we're going to open up for call to the public on this item all right seeing none we'll move to a vote Yes yes yes yes all right moving on to item 6.4 uh curriculum review in our commitment to transparency in all areas the governing board will engage with JC Adams Consulting to condu conduct comprehensive curricula and instructional materials review specifically for the combined criteria of accuracy bias free content grade level appropriateness content richness effective practices and classical education elements this review will provide the board staff parents and our community with the information that will inform our curriculum

100work and the purchas of any additional materials when needed JC Adams Consulting is being uh procured as a sole source as no other curriculum Auditors reviewed specifically focus on accuracy bias free content and classical education elements this time a motion uh to approve uh the curriculum review a second at this time we will open it up for discussion so uh first I want to say we're not changed we're not here tonight to discuss changing curriculum we're not here tonight this is not to start questioning how our teachers are teaching in the classroom or to bring any teachers um uh under under question um so the uh just so we're aware JC Adams um is a former K12 director from Hillsdale University and he was their k k through2 director for curriculum um in speaking with

101him whenever um Dr Stone and I were able to speak with him his focus is to come in and help train teachers to help find areas that maybe we are lacking uh for example we know that some of our schools there are areas where testing scores are lower and we need Improvement and so his his whole goal is to come in and help make us better his goal is not to come in here and strip apart our curriculum his goal is to provide transparency which is something that we promis to this community and to our parents and um I know that a lot of times our teachers question or and having private conversations with with teachers there are teachers who have asked for more training when it comes to certain areas of curriculum and more

102help and so that's why this is before us tonight um because we want to be able to provide that transparency and uh we want to be able to um help our teachers be successful in the classroom and provide the training that you need and not just have a day hanging out um in a boardroom and hear some paperwork for you but have an expert come in and who who's an expert in classical education and can give us direction of how we can improve give us some direction and maybe find things that we are not doing well um and so that is the point of this tonight so thank you that's all yes absolutely and during the campaign one of the things that parents would would what is the curriculum and that was an answer that

103is still challenging to get and so I really am looking forward to this curriculum audit to to finalize and really hone down what our curriculum is so that if a parent comes and asks we have something to give them that they know exactly and that we know exactly what is going to your children so uh this is fantastic I have to say I was one of those parents I was that's what I ran on um so it'll be nice for to be able to have consistency throughout the schools strengthen them even more all right any other discussion from the board so I have the same questions that I have for the last item so um who chose this V I say how it was chose or what criteria you were looking for but who chose

104it it it was through recommendation of our school boards Association and what is the name of that uh is the national school board's Leadership Council National School Board Leadership Council and um so they work with school districts across the country um and school board members the majority of our board as a as a member of that was offered to to all board members were offered to be a member of that organization and they give us recommendations uh based on organizations and and contractors that they work with Across the Nation um and in looking at Mr Adams resume extremely impressive um worked at Hillsdale University a long time and was um much part of of the K12 um opening whenever they got into the K12 education and so we're very excited to invite him into our

105district um and this is his willhouse our our curriculum is his willhouse and so we're thankful for that okay and then so we did not receive multiple bids for this because as it says in the um statement we use Soul Source because we didn't feel like or not we I won't include myself in this because I wasn't included in the decision making process for it but um you and the NS BLC felt like this was the that JC Adams Consulting was the only firm that offered um the services based on accuracy bias free content and classical educational or classical education elements I wonder if the search parameters might have been a bit too narrow I'll use an example like this if I were to say that I want to provide tires for the district I

106would have to put out a bid for proposal and I would probably get you know the usual suspects good year maybe Michelin and Ki um if I were to put out a bid for proposal and I said I want to provide tires for the district but I only want to use a company that where their name starts with a g and ends with an r that would only lead bid year and so I it I do feel like this decision was made in such a narrow way that of course we only received one company that fit the bill because we didn't open it up broadly enough and so um would be again if we're talking about the if The Who and the how much I don't object to a curriculum review being done so the

107question of if is already answered for me but The Who and the how much I would have liked to have had a chance to review or to consider other vendors and I think that that could have been done if it had been opened up a little bit more broadly and again it does come back to the transparency piece and the local control piece because if you're receiving recommendations from an organization that is outside of our community we are giving up a piece of our local control to do that and I appreciate your your input member Roman um first all organizations that we would contact are outside of our community so let me point that out um number two you you had the opportunity to join this organization as well that was presented to you by

108the superintendent which you did decline um and the superintendent also did do a search herself um to see what other organizations were were available to provide this same review and um to her uh report to me they did not exist um and what is best for what we're looking for when it comes to our specific curriculum um so so that's how that was but I I take under advisement um your comments thank you so much any other board members all right um we will now open it up for call to the public question [Music] I do a lot of things and and that you do it every single time and it's verying to have me and not and I apprciate that you are of and I do agree that there are some other grps um

109that we could contact we are an analy are very white middle class but we do have options just you're doing a great job needer L don't and Par but they also the on want to come about things and it's like I remember thank you thank you thank we to the endit H my name is teacher High School I've been teaching here in the district this is my e Year yes e year um I'm also in LHS alumni um grew up here since I was eight years old um I only have a clarifying question when it says that you're looking for classical education elements will that only be applying to the curriculum at or Grande or are we also looking at that at the high school and the middle school and then if we are looking

110for classical educational elements in those areas as of right now I know that at the high school we have not at least in our department areas talked about classical education being introduced at the high school level is that something that then we're using this to use moving forward this is to inform our decision on curriculum on how to look at areas in our curriculum where there are holes and fill those holes or areas in our curriculum that we are doing successful and make sure all across the district that it's being successful thank you curious because class schal educationals I believe or not required at the at the middle school and high school right so or grand Classical Academy is our only classical education is that is a teaching style however all of our schools use

111cor knowledge um which is foundational at many classical schools up through e grade mus um my one question would be for transparency if this conversation I understand the session could we table the vote tonight and could there be an opportunity for a special work session where all four of you would be able to be in attendance with staff that wants to come and speak to where we could share with you what our curriculum actually is because the the terminology of Hillsdale Classical Academy or the classical curriculum for all of us we know when they do the the audit or the review I've already spoken with President Rose and Mrs Tinsley about this they're going to find that we are not in compliance because five of the six elementary schools were not under that same um

112transfer to The Classical Academy That was supposed to be special to or Grande to offer something different to our families who wanted that and so I just want to know if there's an opportunity where teachers we can share with you this is the curriculum that we use this is how we use it this is how we were trained and have that transparency before bringing someone in to tell us what we already know so thank good evening welcome hi there I'm Brian zel I teach us history at the high school this is my 27th year and I've taught history most of all those years uh I just want to say um in all those years I don't think I've ever come across any content that was non-biased so um good luck finding that material um one

113of the skills that we we teach our students is while reading history and reading the news and things like that be able to identify bias and to be able to check sources and and be able to understand that so I tell my students don't take anything I'm saying for granted or or as as gospel you know double check and uh I just want to um make a note about that and it's one of uh one of the great skills that we we need to all learn and uh but as far as finding by is free good luck thank you all right my crystal anded three graduated I've never had an issue with the curriculum but to me like sitting back and listening it seems like it's assignment vers the actual curriculum that becomes a question

114because there you can find it the teachers do to us your Consulting Group do they use it across the nation are they vers in Arizona and what we have than all right any more call in the public all right we'll bring it back to the board for discussion and then a vote um I I want to say this I'm I'm not willing to pass this on um this is something that parents have asked for and we're we're going to provide that to parents but again the I I want to explain please is this is not a got you moment for teachers this is not us trying to find problems with you or how you teach this is us as a wanting to equip you to help make you and this District better um I can

115tell you I did have a meeting um and and shared with our our Teachers Association that we were looking at this and and ran this by Carol um and and she had some questions we answered them and we're here to partner with you this isn't I I just want to be very clear this isn't the board versus everybody else this isn't the board versus teachers and I understand not every decision that we make you're going to be happy with but we also represent parents as well um tonight this board met the wishes of every employee and fault with you and partnered with you to give you a great raise because you deserve it and just as you deserve a great raise as an employee of this District our parents deserve the things they are asking

116for and that is transparency from this district and so um I plan to move forward with this tonight thank you did did you like it the idea of having a work session so we could meet with teachers and make sure that what we think we're looking for is actually we're looking for so so here's where I'm at and and I miss muscleman thank you for bringing that up I think having voting on this do you know I I plan to move forward with this but I would love to still have a work session that we're we're a team I want to be very clear um as you know i' I've been visiting some of your schools as well as some of the other board members this board is here to partner with you um again

117we're not here to point fingers at you and and say you're doing this wrong and we need to do this we're here to find how we can improve as a district and bring our scores up let me be very transparent we have got some scores in this District that are very alarming I'm just going to be very clear and this board is committed to to helping equip our student achievement department and our teachers to fix that and we can't do that if we don't move forward in these areas again it's not always fun but it's NE necessary and we owe this as a district to our parents as well so thank you so I don't disagree with the necessity but I do disagree with the urgency I if we tabled it if we tabled it

118for tonight and had a work session we could still vote on it in the March meeting or we could even hold a special session if we wanted to and vote on it if you felt that we needed to go forward as soon as possible um but I think having a work session would give us a chance to clarify what we even are looking for when we contract with this vendor it's $28,000 at least for this service to our district and so don't we want to know what we're even in the market for before we put out this kind of money Mr I tend to join with David on this I have no problem with setting work sessions in order please I have no problem setting work sessions in fact I would like to do that

119and getting up front with us and the teachers and establishing those things as this moves forward I think would only help the process uh but again when you are taking over a board you coming in and being responsible for the district and part of that responsibility is making sure you understand what you have in front of you this company has come highly recommended from our organization that we are partnered with Dr Stone found them to be highly credible I find them to be highly credible I do understand that non-bias and these things some of these criteria they are goals and metrics they're looking at that does not mean that us going forward we're instilling a non-bias criteria obviously there's bias in everything we do but having some of these metrics to look where we at

120and how are we doing these things is important so I personally are also going forward with I do want to ask one more question what scope are you considering are you considering every single Elementary our middle school and our high school and are we also considering all of the electives taught at our high school or are you just considering content areas like English social studies at all of the schools correct yes that's it English and social studies yes I I believe at this point that's what we've been providing do you have some input I I my understanding was a full what is being taught to our students across the board because we have questions of different elementary schools teaching different things whether or not that's happening we want to understand that because whether or not

121the teachers think that's happening parents think that is happening and we are the representative of the parents and of the community and one of the main questions I had and that's it's a conflict some teachers say everything's great it's fine the people in the district but the perception by many parents is that there's issues okay at this time uh just for transpar Dr aesto if you could help with that pleas so what I'm reading in this document is that there is a transparency review for primary districtwide uh resources so that would be K through six all of the resources inclusive of all of all of the different areas and then there would be a quality analysis specifically for social studies and literature k12 and then there would be new resource vetting moving forward for all

122subjects and Library materials and can I ask a question for clarification I will be honest I can provide all of the questionable things but I do think the board has said we want to do this work it was pretty clear in the election and so I think as long as the board says we know that there's going to be things and I think as teachers we say we know that we want to abide by Community standards then we can have the discussion of you know what this nice gentleman found this but we really understand that this piece of literature is important for this reason but the discussion is there that moves us forward I want to comment uh and and thank you Dr Fadel and your comment alone is the very reason that we are

123having this discussion tonight that you could provide the questionable things and so that tells me as a president of this board that we've not done our job to be transparent with Excuse me to be transparent with teachers to be transparent with our community to be transparent with parents and that's unacceptable and as a district transparency and curriculum is key we should never ever have anything that is questionable being taught so that that that's my reason for this so can can I just clarify about questionable so just thinking about like Odus I mean thinking about things of violence and understanding and so I'm not suggesting that there are things but knowing in historical documents we all have different um room for what makes us uncomfortable and I do think it's extremely important and we do do

124that work of communicating with families about every single story that we talk about all of that work um you know people have different feelings about historical events and so I didn't mean questionable but things that are thank you for controver but again the the the point of this and and and I've said this a couple times now is we're not bringing our teachers into question we we are simply saying we want to improve as a district and I I don't think we should have a problem with that I think that us wanting to improve as a district should be key for all of us in this room everyone here loves kids we all love kids and and all of you that teach you love teaching or you would not be a teacher um and and

125so the the point of this is us coming together um I'm to discussing your your your position um but I just want to be clear that a review is happening because it is what is needed to make us the best District ever and and partnering together so um I I just want to clarify that with with everyone in the room tonight I'm sorry the call to the public has been closed I absolutely want this I'm sorry um I absolutely want this review done I I'm just going to beor as a parent I did ask teachers I did get in there did I go over the books not 100% because I put trust in my teachers not the thing that there wasn't trust but the thing is is some of those teachers will say will say

126we are a Hillsdale curriculum are we you we're not that's weird because other parents though still think right now to this day that we are close close because teachers one school okay I do I do have just one more thing to say so I will be voting no tonight on this because this is not an emergency this is important but it's not an emergency and I feel like we had the very sensible uh suggestion to hold a work session as you can hear from this room um regardless of whether you think you are representing parents there are a lot of parents in this room that do not age with you here and probably broader in the community um and if you're going to say that you're taking parent concerns into account that means all the

127parents concerns not just the ones who spoke to you on the campaign Trail and so I will be voting no not because I do not I do want a curriculum Revo I just want it done the correct way especially since we are spending $28,000 of our money to do this it needs to be done carefully and correctly not hastily [Applause] all right at this time I'm actually going a motion to take this into executive session I'll second yes yes y for e e e back we're back in session at this time um I'd like to discuss um this contract that we have yeah yeah yes second yes yes yes yes okay um so so this contract does cost our district is it so this I believe was also because it it comes in installments with

128something that did not have to come before this board tonight and and take a vote the reason that I requested this to be done um and we went into executive session because I thought we had to discuss the contract privately so that that's on me but um we want transparency that's why this is on the agenda I don't ever want this community our teachers our staff to feel that we are hiding things from you that we are doing I believe in in working together I believe in Partnership th those things are important um not just with teach teachers but with parents and we have to do what is right for this District when we look at our test scores all of you in the classroom you're doing your best you're doing your best with what

129you've been given and I want to make sure that you're being that us as a district that we're giving you the best option available to you so that that was the whole reason of this this again I just want to clarify uh we're not trying to bring an outside source to come in here and tear this District apart to find aha moments to to say teachers we got you that's not this this is us bringing transparency to everybody to our parents that have have questions things and and I understand people can can get a little out of control on social media with things I believe me I know but we owe this community transparency when things are question and so that's my statement this time to close discussion I just have one more thing to

130say then can you answer the question why does this need to be voted on tonight before a work session is conducted and I and I guess my my opinion is even if we get to a work session we bring the whole District together and there's there is the discourse and I think we should have that regardless and do this together as much as we can we do this a month we're still going to have the same desire to do this if it's coming from the district the information I want an outside source of information because these are my eyes on this as the authority on this board and not to say in a legal in a legal sense it's a conflict of interest the the the district that I'm seeking to review and seeking to

131have authority over is the one then providing me the information that I'm seeking and asking but if I still have questions it those questions will need to be answered by an outside source and at the end of the day we have parents in the community that don't have these answers I have talked teach who and I have not got these answers done has it been in a work session no but I don't think that a work session is going to answer all my questions and so at this time based on the the the the recommendations of this organization in this program who gave it Dr Stone's recommendation I I do believe moving forward is appropriate I want to have this work session and I understand some of the push back but it is as I

132in my opinion you know attorney as a board member I want this for my understanding for my ability to govern this board as a vote on this board for the education of the board that's where I stand and I want to say this and then I'm going to call for a vote is we have accountability to the to the voters of this community but not just that we are held accountable on a state level um there are bills that are coming down the pipeline that hold school board members on a higher level of accountability than ever before because everything that happens in this district from curriculum to our buildings maintenance to how our employees are treated how our money is spent at the end of the day the the five people that set in these

133seats are the ones held accountable by the state of Arizona and we're going to do our best and uh offer everybody the best to be the best teacher offer the best curriculum and uh that means sometimes we may vote on things and there may be disagreements when you walk out of here tonight I don't want you to hate us I want you to understand that we care about our teachers we care about our classrooms that we want to partner with you and that is important to us partnership as a district is important between the board and those of you that are in the trenches every single day and uh so I'm question that I'm asking and I hope I give a straight answer why does this vote need to happen before a work session is

134held that's that's all I want to know why does why does this have to happen tonight instead of two weeks from now well March if if we moved into the March meeting but we don't necessarily have to do that either again doing the work session I'd love to do it I don't think it's going to answer on my question so it's in essence it could be two weeks down the line but that's now two weeks down the line that we're not engaging in these contracts moving forward that that's that's two more right doing things to me it does not strike that the work session is going to resolve our issues and we're not going to do this it's just going to be two down two weeks down the line we're going to spend several hours

135in an executiv or work session more comment more things and we're still going to do this we I there is curriculum issues in this District that I have spent the last year in in in the campaign as we've entered into the board I'm continuously getting comments on the curriculum and for me it's a yes vote today because this is something I promised this is something I said I was going to do and I'm going to be a man of my word and I'm going to vote Yes on it yeah and that and that goes for me um we promised this and you you may not be happy with our promise and and you're not always again going to be happy with our decisions but we're going to do what we said we were going to

136do and uh so I'm I'm ready to move for a vote at this time yes yes no yes right uh moving to item 7.1 superintendent in Dr Stone's absence um i' i' just like to express my appreciation for the three high school students who were here this evening I think that speaks volumes as to not only them as individuals uh but to perhaps their their parents the community uh for sure uh the teachers in their lives I know the three of them are well connected uh and have been throughout their Elementary Middle School and now High School experience there have been uh many many of you most some of You In This Very Room uh who have made an impact in in each of their lives or at least in one of their lives um

137I just I was impressed I sat here as an observer from the side and um just really impressed with with who they are as far as trying to again be a representative of that Lighthouse team and to engage with adults uh is just extremely impressive and I know that there are countless others who are not here tonight that equally could have lined up behind them and and did what we just witnessed tonight so on behalf of an employee of the district a Community member a parent um a husband I mean just just me as an individual I'm extremely proud of them and for each of you uh and for the board to be able to accept their invitation and welcome them in I think that it was uh it speaks volumes to who we are

138as a community and as a school district so thank you yes and I I join you in that and they had actually approached us when we had our work session on the calendar they had boldly come up on stage and engage with me and I actually told them um I would like to discuss opening up a student spot for them in the spotlight and recognition section uh just like we have for the Education Association I would like a every time we meaning we have a spot for those bold students to come and speak to us so I would like to have that opened up for them and have that as a permanent part of every Bo meeting and I if I could just add a little further to that's happening at the elementary level I

139witnessed it at a elementary school at Nautilus Elementary School um I I watched I I was a Observer um right there in the moment with a preschool student who gave part of a schoolwide tour to five or six complete strangers uh amongst other um District administrators and and and teachers uh but I was just extremely impressed with watching that happen and I think that that is something we need to focus more on is just is is just recognizing the fact that they can actually speak to an individual to an adult and have a car and carry on a conversation without looking it at a device so it was just impressive it starts at four years old absolutely awesome all right moving on to uh 7.2 governing board members uh comments Andor suggestions for future agenda

140items I I want to start tonight by saying I appreciate every member on this board there is going to be times that we don't agree but please do not take that as we are not in unity um and that we're not committed to working together um um and if we all thought the same and had the same look on everything we would uh it' be a pretty boring life and um so I I am very thankful for every member for Lisa who has been um a long-term member on this board and uh I'm thankful for our directors and uh there are things that we may not always agree on and see I to eye on but these are directors that are committed to the success of this District uh all three of our directors um

141have committed their life to Lake Abu Unified School District and we are thankful for that that commitment um and teachers staff that are here tonight um I'm excited that you got a win and that you got a pay raise and you deserve it and we are thankful for you and your voice matters I I want you to know those of you sitting in this audience or watching online whether you're a parent you're a teacher you're a staff member in some capacity you always always have a voice in this district with this board even if we agree to disagree your voice does matter to us and we appreciate you that's all I have thank you any other board members well just to go along with that um you know we had four decisions to make and

142we agreed unanimously on three of them so that's 75% that's pretty good it's a big win well sorry and just one more thing I can't believe I forgot to say this at our last meeting but I love our new setup and I want to thank the people it possible we have our laptop set up with our agenda already prefilled on it and um I just want to thank the IT team and the people who made this possible and Lisa I I just want to commend you and thank you you know the campaign was heated three of us offic is Maggie you're the Lo board member left and I have appreciated your grace in helping us in things open meeting laws just the exective session type stuff I've appreciated your cander and your VAR and those

143types of things so I it been a pleasure working with you so I thank you for getting the the on the um sport that's thank you for get you those numbers thank you for getting those next ones and just that only if um for the agenda if we need whatever the calendar is Mr President for getting a student Spotlight yes absolutely um actually already have a student I think from Miss bagby's class that I will be reaching out to her for that but I want to say this to to kind of go off what Matt said the campaign was heated and as it it can be and there were times that that member Raman and I would go at each other in a very professional candid way C and people were like oh my gosh

144these two are not going to be able to work together it's going to be horrible and I just want to say it's been fun her and I have have built a relationship over these La this last month and um again we don't always agree but um it it's been it's been great and uh I'm honored to to sit on this board with her and and um and I want her and I to be able to be the example that differences can come together and make a difference so thank you differences can come together and make a Payway yeah that's sure yes absolutely representative B yeah yeah well if you got his number tell him to work on that uh Federal smart snack rules get RK on that all right at this time uh item 8.1

145I need a motion to adjourn I move to adjourn I second yes Matthew Houston yes yes yes all right meeting the Jour thank you for being here

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.