001I will call this meeting to order here here please join me in a moment of Silent prayer or private reflection amen please stand for the pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to theice at this time we'll have the swearing in of the new governing board members Mr Murray this time we'd like to welcome judge Kali with us this evening he's here to swear in the new governing board members as president Harvey just mentioned thank you okay um usually I'm speaking to a more captive audience uh Mr Rose please if you could come forward and I guess you want to stand right here that would be great please raise your right hand and repeat after me I David Rose do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of
002the United States United States and the Constitution and laws of the State of Arizona that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Saint and defend them against all enemies foreign and domestic and that I will faithfully and impartially discharge the duties of the office of lhusd governing board member L according to the best of my ability so help me God congratulations [Applause] you could come forward please please raise your right hand and repeat after me I Evelyn Tinsley do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and laws of the State of Arizona that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them against all enemies foreign and domestic and that I will faithfully and impartially discharge the duties of the office
003of lhusd governing board member governing board member according to the best of my ability so help me down [Applause] conat houst please raise your right hand and repeat after me I Matthew Houston iew hon do solemnly swear do swear that I will support I will support the Constitution of the United States of the United States and the Constitution and laws consti La of the State of Arizona St AR that I will bear will true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them and defend them against all enemies against all enemies foreign and domestic forign and domestic and that I will that I will faithfully and impartially Faithfully andar discharge the duties discharge the duties of the office of the office of lhusd governing board member according to the best of my ability so help
004me [Applause] go moving on to 1.6 governing board election of governing board president and vice president for 2025 and I would like to start off by nominating Lisa Raman for board president Lisa has already served as board president in the past and is the most experienced candidate for this position she's one of the most active in the life of our schools she's already demonstrated her commitment to Student Success and is supportive of our teacher staff and administration she's an excellent example for presidential D duties and District leadership so I would like make a motion for Lisa ran as president there a second thank you for your kind words but if there's no second I'd rather move on to another nomination is there a second this time I'd like to nominate Dave Rose he is a
005a pastor in town he's in town and actively working with the district already he's been a great point of contact so I think he would be a fantastic president to begin I will second that I would like to add a little discussion before we vote um I was very vocal during campaign season about some of my misgivings and objections I would like to set those aside I've already said what I wanted to say and I don't have a reason to say any of that again um I have had hope over the last few weeks I've had uh we've had a training session with our in-house Council and it has given me reason to believe that our new team our new board members are here to be part of a team um there was a spirit
006of collegiality collegiality during that meeting and so um I I would like to overlook the past and kind of come into this with an open mind and a fresh start for the [Applause] here and I would just like to Echo Lisa's words you know it was a heated political season but that's what politics in America is we are here to make this District efficient and good for our children Lisa you you've been on this board and been and been functioning on this board so we look forward to uh any in and all input that you have to help guide us move forward in that direction thank you um um it was a heated campaign and uh I'm glad it's over but um as Lisa said we've had some great meetings and uh we are all
007here to work together and do what is best for this community for our teachers our staff our students our parents and we cannot do that if we're divided we're better together and we may not always agree on on certain issues um but at the end of the day everyone's setting um on this board wants what is best for this district and that's what matters so thank you so uh we have we have a second to for David R for president okay so we ready for at this time we'll take nominations for vice president sorry first we're going to vote oh that's what I thought okay yeah we have to vote David Rose received a nomination in a second so now you will just do the roll call Vote Yes yes [Applause] yes now we will
008declare elected presid thank you I'm honored thank you okay at this time we will take nomination for vice president I nominate Matthew Houston um and the reason for that Matthew is a leader in this community a leader in our County um he has young children and uh has a great vision for this district and uh so it's been great to be on the campaign trail with him and just dear his heart for Lake Abu City and our school system and I think he would be a great leader for this District I will second that yes yes yes yes yes okay so we'll now have our vice president and president move to seats All Right Moving On no not yet couple seconds all right moving on to item number 1.7 superintendent hearing officers for 2025 student
009disip heing thank you Mr President board members filling in for Dr tonight per board policy 5306 and procedure 5306 a the board can appoint a hearing officer to oversee discipline suspension and expulsion hearings per the job description for hearing officer approved December 12th 2006 a hearing officer will be appoint approved by the governing board at the first meeting in January of each year the following hearing officers will serve for 2025 and and funded through Medicaid as needed the director of student services the director of student achievement Director of Human Resources Director of Business Services and we would like to take a moment and say thank you to Becky goerg who has been serving as our um hearing officer uh for the past 12 years and uh we owe her a huge round of applause she
010has served [Applause] this Becky has served this community with excellence and and uh we are now going to be searching for a replacement um to hopefully want to serve our community as long as she has so Becky thank you for your service moving on to item 2.1 I'm uh item 2.1 student achievement new and oh I'm sorry we have to take a vote need a motion we need a motion a second yes a motion to approve 1.7 I'll second any discussion all right move the vote yes yes yes yes all right item 2.1 student achievement new and maintain national board certified teachers with Dr Jamie festel Mr President and governing board please join me in celebrating the following teachers who earn national board certification and our lhusd newest NBCS just like we look for board
011certified surgeons lawyers doctors board certified teachers have proven success these teachers join the 27 other ncts in this District who have demonstrated standards based evidence of student learning in alignment with the five core propositions they have exhibited a deep understanding of their students content knowledge use of data and assessments and teaching practice they also showed that they participate in mning communities and provide evidence of ongoing reflection and continuous learning so we're going to call these teachers up um who will also um receive um a pin and then checks from the kall foundation who will say a few words after so please join me in celebrating Anna [Applause] jaone Anna is a teacher from Starline she teaches reading language arts uh she's certified in Reading language arts in early and middle childhood please join me in
012celebrating April [Applause] Coley April is a teacher at or Classical Academy she certified in Reading language arts early and middle [Applause] childhood please join me in welcoming Sarah Shaw as our newest NC [Applause] sha is a reading interventionist at smok tree she certified in Reading language arts early and middle childhood next please join me in celebrating Andrea [Applause] Montes Andrea is a special education teacher at Jamaica she certified an exceptional need specialist early childhood through young adulthood national board certification must be renewed every five years by submitting videotaped and written evidence of accomplished teaching practice please also congratulate the following teachers who maintain their certificate this year from Lake havu High School Kathy Bagby [Applause] from Nautilus Elementary School ksey Dill from Lake havu High School Chessa [Applause] fry also from L cavu High School
013Bridget hagus from Starline Elementary School Teresa Nick and finally from or Grande Classical Academy Tera please congratulate these teachers who joined a 4% of teachers in the United States who are board certified teachers [Applause] if you are a national board certified teacher will you stand [Applause] up congratulations to all of our ncts and those who are working on certification we would don't go away yet we would like to welcome the lake Unified School District K12 Foundation to say a few words to our national award teachers and talk about what uh the K12 Foundation is is there anybody in the audience left that's a K12 member me and Jamie best of us are up here uh they have been supporting national board certification and LSD for two decades the K12 Foundation was founded in 2003 by
014local Business Leaders interested in supporting the student and staff of Lake Habu Unified School District our volunteer board is made up of Civic and Business Leaders from sectors across the community we are a nonprofit Foundation committed to preserving programs and resources that are essential building blocks to our kids education in future over the past 20 years the KF Foundation has raised close to a million dollars this money this money has been used to support initiatives across the district including recognizing excellent teachers through Sherry daily Golden Apple award supporting peer tutoring at the high school funding stem clubs and activities putting on the academic recognition dinner each year for top high school students providing funds for principles to use at their discretion at each School supporting new teachers during pre-service week and this evening providing funding
015for teachers who are interested in becoming and maintaining national board certification [Applause] the K12 Foundation has provided support for national board certified teachers since 2006 because we know that excellent teachers are a vital part of our schools thank you for your hard work and dedication we appreciate you you all right congratulations to all of our teachers moving on to item 2.2 um Lake ATU City Education Association please welcome Carol nowakowski good evening uh president Rose members of the board directors Community happy New Year and welcome to our new board members uh every two years we utilize the opportunity to provide our new board members with a little insight of what late um historical role is in lhusd so we pride ourselves in maintaining a collaborative relationship with our lhusd directors and school governing board we
016enthusiastically provide lunch uh during the new teacher orientation lunch where we have an opportunity to welcome each one and thank them for choosing lhusd we seek and request for Need for lhhs for High School athletics through different scholarships and award opportuni we offer opportunities for free professional development in multiple content uh areas special education Fine Arts Early Childhood as well as the ability uh to earn a micr credential in various best practices for our classrooms we seek and recognize members in our communities who are public educate educator Advocates we partner with community members for equipment and funding for lhd we follow Arizona legislative session as bills are presented and discussed in committee and on the floor then we communicate with our ld30 legislators regarding legislative impact on lhusd we are leaders we are Advocates we
017advocate for all staff and most importantly we advocate for all students and we look forward to working with each one of you in our continued efforts to provide funding policy and opportunities for LH USC's students staff and Community thank you thank you at this time we're going to open it up to the call to the public we have one call to the public this evening please welcome Karen dander okay first of all I'm Karen vanderjack I am part of PA patriotic Americans for constitutional education I just want to welcome David Rose and Matt Houston and Evelyn Tinsley to the board of the lake UniFi School district and many of our citizens in Lake AVU are excited to see what God will direct you to do to improve your school district our school district I'd like
018to take this opportunity to make some suggestions to help meet the goals of producing strong American citizens who will be our future as part of case we would like to see patriotism brought back into the curriculum this is an investment in our students in our city our state and our country I giving you a copy of the 28 principles of Liberty in front of you uh upon which our country was founded these principles these principles need to be instilled and recited our Cas clubs work towards that goal by paying teachers to have an after school club but we need to go beyond that currently we only have four case clubs in only two schools right now now we have several schools in in the city but they're not from the lake C uni School District
019here are some suggestions of new things you could do to encourage more clubs and have like having assemblies and invite the Marine Corps leag to have a flag folding ceremony those are some suggestions um see page sorry um many schools districts across the have began to implement bringing in prayer and they brought in um displaying the Ten Commandments in our classrooms and even having Bible classes for electives in their high schools I highly recommend bringing these things in I know some parents might object but we are a constitutional republic and we voted for these new school board members to represent the citizens of our city regarding the education of every child whose parents want to be educated in our district those parents can be informed about the Danberry Baptist situation a lot of people think
020that uh there's a a thing called separation of of yes church and state church and state right and is that in there is that in our constitution no it's not in there oh by the way um I noticed that we have our two representatives from Constitution week that would be another thing we really need to implement and and recognize our constitution we have Constitution week actually Constitution day is September 17th so that's another thing we'd like to see come in but I wanted to make sure that everybody here understood the separation of church and state is not in the Constitution and why it's not the Constitution 15 seconds okay well um then I'll have to shorten it up um sorry uh you didn't tell me how much time I had so um bear with me
021just for a second here um it was it was a go ahead I'll I'll you a minute it was an agreement uh between a a church attempt to Jefferson and they said uh the government's getting involved in our church and they uh and Jefferson said well we don't want that we want so we'll just have a wall of separation from church State and that what he meant was he didn't want the government to get involved in the churches not for the other way around so I'd like to see us get more involved by some suggestions I thank you so much uh item number 4.1 consent agenda vote I need a motion to approve the consent agenda I move to approve the consent agenda is there a second a second call for a vote yes yes
022yes all right item 4.2 superintendent minutes regular session I'm sorry actually all of the sorry oh that was part of the consent okay all right sorry all right uh item number six action items student achievement the 2025 2026 and 2026 and 2027 academic calendars um I would like to open this up for discussion um this evening what I would like to see us do is to um discuss some some changes I would like to see with the 25 and 26 Calendar and then table the 26 27 calendar for a work session um because we would like to we need to hear from parents teachers and staff when it comes to our calendars um in looking at the calendar um in the um items when I received the report it seems like we're moving school earlier
023um with a start date in July and um I'm I'm not open to that um I I think that's way too early parents are still doing vacations um so we need to open up at this time for discussion of of changes for this calendar and I'd like you to yes please present thank you Mr President and govern board the cavity Unified School District has historically adopted academic calendars two years at a time Administration meets with the calendar committee representing each site to elicit feedback about the academic calendar the calendar committee met in August and September to review the current adopted calendars the committee was made up of teachers classified staff and administrators eight of the committee members are also lhusd parents suggested changes to the calendar were brought back to the School site for approval
024calendar committee members presented the calendars and a survey was sent out to sites there were 250 responses collected from school site staff overwhelmingly the staff agreed that starting on a Thursday which is one of the reasons that it backs up fall break and an April testing break was beneficial for students and teachers they also agreed that having the Monday op for students in July allowed for teachers to not have to work over winter break principles then held meetings and solicited feedback from parents all Sites shared the calendar during a par parent meeting and parents shared the approved of the academic calendar and they will point out that the parents were like ah July 30th July 31st but in order to keep the calendar starting on a Thursday fall break um they all understood the current
025calendar structure works well with quarters and semesters that are even in an emphasis on ensuring that high school students complete Finals over winter break and so currently our calendar is 45 days 45 days 45 days and 45 days for 180 days we have classes that are a year long we have classes that are a quarter long and classes that are a semester long it's very difficult when you have a class that one quarter is 55 days and the next quarter is 35 days or one semester is 110 days and the other semester is 80 uh 70 days and so we need to have an equivalent calendar because students take classes at our year semester and quarter uh in addition I've heard and I read orchids and onions I hear that uh lots of people um
026want to start later the reality is in order for students to finish winter testing or testing in high school um we have to start then to back up those 90 days State testing also Begins the last week of March and this calendar giv gives um the time to ensure all grade level standards are met prior to State Testing the current calendar format is recommended to be carried forward for the next two years it is recommended that school continues to begin for students on a Thursday rather than a Monday this provides more dedicated time to work with students on rules and procedures and setting the classroom climate prior to starting with content the following week it also allows for kindergarteners to start with a half day to school which has been a past practice and has
027worked well for our newest students in addition this allows lhusd to effectively support novice teachers as they transition into planning lessons preparing materials and Grading student work this calendar continues to have the student work day to start at the begin the calendar year after winter break this supports teachers having time after winter break to prepare for the new semester and work collaboratively to meet the needs of students spaces also created that gives a day off in April there are typically no days off between spring break and the end of the year which is also the time of standardized testing one day at the end of April will become a break that is for both students and teachers students will continue to attend school for 180 days and teachers will work 188 days workday calendars will
028be created by human resources after adoption of the academic calendar the calendar style meets the accessibility requirements for online posting and then they were provided for 25 26 26 27 thank you Dr f d um this time I would like to open it up for discussion from the board but also to the public um this is something that all of us are involved with there's parents in this room there's teachers in this room and um one of the things that we stated when we campaigned is we're going to do things together and work together and so um at this time I'd open up to the board and they will open up from teachers parents anyone in the room that would like to get up for one minute and just give some feedback um as we
029work on this this evening I just have a so you made some remarks at the beginning um I heard you say that you would like to table 26 and 27 for but um what did you say about 25 26 if we could just make some changes this evening go and get it passed um because I understand there are parents who are trying to get summer vacation scheduled um and that is super important we understand that and so I think if we can get the following school year upcoming school year calendar um out this evening and passed and then we can do a work session on the following year um and uh then get that out as soon as possible and then what changes to the 2526 are you proposing uh one thing that that is
030we discussed and thought about is moving the half day to Friday with one caveat on that I've spoke with teachers and parents on this particularly teachers felt moving it to the Friday found Administration just would fill that afternoon with meetings so if we move it to that Friday I would like to make it specific to that the administration is not making meeting times during that time that is for the teachers to to meet with their students to get coursework done or for themselves to take that time off that additionally I did notice this year we didn't take Columbus Day off which I would also like to bring back and then so the half as it currently is we have days on TH or I should I shouldn't say half day it should be early release
031yeah early okay um we have early release on Thursdays and that is when our staff often has their articulation meetings either amongst their grade level or they have vertical vertical articulation meetings um if those aren't going to happen on Friday afternoon when will they happen Administration would move it throughout the week what I mean there is times to have meetings done how long do these meetings take these are things I'd like to hear from the teachers in this in this time for discussion um we've heard from parents both they hate the half day on Thursday because it breaks up their ability to travel um I've heard some teachers like it on Thursdays there's been a lot of um back and forth so I would open it up to people who are here like you said
032you have we have about a minute to give you and what we'd like to hear from you yeah m p please please state your name and the and yeah okay all right happy daily b b teacher I just have a question um have you collected any data about early release Fridays from any area schools I know that Parker does it Parker doesn't have to worry about their daily average attendance because they get impact Aid money so it's not a big deal if their kids don't come to school on Friday I would be curious to know if any other schools have done it and what it does for financial things for the schools because that could be really hurtful if we lose a lot of money because kids they're not going to come on a Friday
033well we would expect I mean you expect parents to take their kids to school and that's kind of in essence what we're saying is and this is what our push back is if parents are making the choice to keep their children that's their choice and I support that more than our dollars we do 180 days and we meet the state requirements for hours so if a parent chooses to take their child that's their choice and I support that so that is my consideration is if a a parent is making the value decision that that child with them is more valuable than our dollars well this is their District isn't it yeah I would just be curious of what the impact has been at other schools and financially what is actually Mr Murray can speak to
034that thank you thank you thank you so so the impact financially years ago that used to be the case um years ago the state had in place what was called average daily attendance um even though that's still something that is talked about average daily membership is how districts are funded so what that means is average daily membership is actually taking into account those who are actually enrolled in school not not whether or not they're here or absent so if a student is absent you're not penalized now if they're absent for 10 days and no one knows where they are um and then they come up somewhere that they move to Phoenix then we have to unenroll them back to their last date in the school district we just get to keep them on the books
035until we figure out where they are so no in no impact to attendance right now currently that can change but currently that does not happen so I I think maybe potentially what would be a good and and we can do this as a trial this year this this coming year and if we say hey this was a terrible idea then we can go back or we can reevaluate that's always an idea but uh what if we were were to move this first day of school to August 1st and then early release to Friday so in order to do that by the way I I made a contingency so in order to do that the only in order to make that happen we would take the day away in April we would take the work day
036away in January and so that would roll everything to Monday the only barrier is Columbus Day because we would need another day and I just want to speak to to that there are days that we go to school 911 Constitution Day which by the way Karen dardu is my favorite holiday SRE day um SRE day ok Conor Civic day we do go to school on days that are a celebration of something and so while I understand that Columbus Day is important I also think it's important to celebrate understand what that is it's our first unit in kindergart we talk about um indigenous people and Columbus and so I would respectfully ask to consider in order to keep the calendar whole that the expectation is that we do something that supports that holiday versus taking it
037off as and doing so that would be in consideration of moving it for half day to Friday so the then my only just my two sense so half day Thursday it used to be half day Wednesday half day Thursday has been around for 20 years and so the reason that we went to it it used to be every other week the reason why we went to it is in many years ago when we cut full-time PE in music at our elementary schools it was to give teachers more prep time and so we do have that hour and a half and over the course of the month there's one day that is a staff meeting if that staff meeting doesn't happen then the staff meeting happens after school on a Monday so if you want to
038say there's to be no meetings and think we should think maybe you should consider teacher feedback here then it means meetings after school so that's that's the cavea is all it does is move meetings so just for you to know there's one meeting that's a staff meeting one meeting that's like across the grade level to meet um when there's meetings that is AC all of the grades across the entire District meet and then there's special education meeting so that's just my consideration and then of course we really want parents to take their kids to school and it's not because money it's because every single hour and minute in the seat matters and so so we and then and then the other consideration is Subs so again these are just things to think about is if
039more people take off on Friday because sometimes it's like oh I'm GNA take off on a Friday but now it's just a half day there's a sub issue and so those are the pros and cons I think there's going to be like definitely like you said kind of like this test trial kind of thing and I know it is very hard for Thursday especially for parents and work that's definitely been a burden on a lot of people and I think it's easier for them especially on Fridays to be able to get out of there a little bit easier compared to the middle of a work week so I feel like we could oh I'm sorry I'd rather hear your and Stage best um I just wanted to just mention something for a little bit and
040maybe see if you can consider um like Dr uh Fel had mentioned we had surveyed parents and teachers about the calendar that we have already voted on I was wondering because this seems like something you guys are very um interested in and changing the calendar how about instead of test driving or testing it now you know you guys want teacher and family input and we're only talking to the people in the room how about we do the calendar of 20 25 and 26 as it is now that's been voted and then this school year we can survey parents and families again using the Alternatives you guys have brought up and then we can talk about that for the next school year yeah yeah actually that's something we were just discussing on the sidebar and and
041that's what I'm glad she Mrs best said that because that is that would be my recommendation is that we do approve 25 and 26 as it's presented and then we have that work session would to have it sooner rather than later talk about the 26 27 calendar because I do think that those are good ideas but I want to make my decisions based on more than just opinions of the people in this room I want to hear from other people and I also want to hear the data opinions are great but data um also hold the place in my decision making yeah absolutely I think that's I would just add from a logistical standpoint we typically passed this in October and November and then the human resource department build calendars that also come before the
042board so we are already two months behind on that and that's required for us to determine compensation contracts all of the above so yes yeah I move to approve just 2526 calendar as is fully as is and we can start on next year's tomorrow is there a second I will second yes yes yes yes yes and then we need and that was what 2627 being okay all right now 7.1 superintendent so again I'm here representing Becky um Dr Stone I know that she wishes she could be here tonight um I would just like to personally I don't get opportunity to do this so much so this is actually kind of kind of nice for a change um well I I would just really like to um congratulate first of all wish everyone a Happy New
043Year um hopefully 2025 is is starts off or actually begins to move a little bit better for many people across the country but Happy New Year and better better things to come on a on a happy note for our people here I'd just like to congratulate our national board teachers again I deal with money and so it's nice to be able to step outside of that from time to time and talk about something again that's much more important I apologize for my remarks of ADA um and talking about dollars because in my world that's important but I totally agree with Dr F Fel that it's about kids it's about quality instruction that's that's at my core so congratulations to national board teachers newly uh certified um national board teachers and those who have uh renewed
044their certification so congratulations teachers and our hardworking staff so that would be my message and I think Dr Stone Echoes that all right 7.2 governing board members uh some exciting news actually for middle school and high school students um last year there were some students working with Miss Bagby Bagby had requested to the Dre uh for the dress code uh to be changed and we're excited to share this evening that um effective Monday students will be able to wear their own outerware uh to school for safety purposes they will be asked to wear their student ID on a lanyard and we are also uh going to be allowing seniors um to wear their senior gear um that has been purchased through any vendor through the high school and this will take effect on Monday so
045that's like letterman jackets and that type of thing yes yeah we also um in our work session we would like to discuss further um further changes and and uh any issues um when it comes to uniforms so teachers staff parents we want to hear from you uh for uniforms both for students and staff and so we want to hear your feedback as we go into work session so is there any other discussion for board members or agenda items that you would like to be added for further board meetings um yes I'm asking for a review for the special ad Department please okay awesome review for special ed all right then any other items something I would like to look at um discuss in our next board meeting is um or or maybe at least you
046tell me if this is something that we need to do in a work session when it comes to our students who who play sports in our schools um to be able to find other ways to cover that cost other than charging our families um that is something that we have heard back from parents during our uh time talking to parents and getting feedback um if that's something we should do in a work session or an agenda item as long as it's publicly noticed we can talk about you know we have broad discretion to talk about what we like to talk about we just have to again let the public know what is on our mind okay awesome Mr we could do just look at the cost of if we were to not charge that $400
047what would the cost of the district be any other items all right this meeting is adjourned thank you sorry I'm sorry no wait we have to vote meeting re rej I'll move to adj I try Matthew Houston sorry Matthew Houston has made a motion toj and I will second all right yes yes yes yes right now the meetings adjourned have a great night