001for what sure what are we doing okay oh how we're voting okay I do normally do that but e like czy person like oh my goodness which is actually good though I had yeah two minutes to think about it so I'm that's probably better probably better than the opposite so okay wa can actually my reason I ask if I came to work Tak the Shir off e e e sorry folks that we are running just a little bit behind we're trying to get everybody logged in here but is everyone ready for us to get started started are we good on are we live are we okay awesome well then I uh hello everyone thanks for joining us such a nice crowd tonight today is Tuesday December 10th 2024 and this is the regular governing board
002meeting for the litfield elementary school district I hereby call this meeting to order our first item on the agenda is going to be a public hearing uh I need do we need to make a motion to go into public hearing or we just go we just go okay good awesome this is going to be uh cfov V to talk about our budget revision Madame President members of the governing board superintendent Davidson colleagues family and Community thank you for joining me tonight to discuss the district's first budget revision for fiscal year 2025 we appreciate many of us are here to celebrate some very important kiddos and so we'll do this as efficiently as possible tonight's presentation uh aligns with the district's strategic Keystone of resources State Statute requires districts to revise their budget by December 15th
003in certain situations while the district was not required to revise this December it is customary for the district to up update its budget each December as a reminder our M budget is set by a statutory formula which considers average daily membership as well as many other student characteristic factors the formula is driven in large part by weighted student count or the number of full-time equivalent students served by the district and District characteristics such as special education status to to determine how much funding will be made available to the the district to serve its students for this budget revision average daily membership estimates were REI revised down by 18 students but weighted student count were revised up this is largely due to an increase in special education needs of our student population on this slide you
004can see a comparison of the budget available in m and its various sources compared to the adopted budget the revenue control limit is the funding provided from the funding formula I described on the previous slide it is the ongoing funding generated to support the district students the increase in Revenue control limit is being driven by the changes in weighted student count we previously discussed the change in carryover was caused both by the state's recalculation of the district's exact M budget from last year and uh changes uh from expenditures from FY 24 uh that were estimated in June versus what was actually the case when we closed out in October on this budget revision shifting a budget capacity was minimal the budget for the K3 reading weight was increased due to an increased number of K
005through three students compared to the adopted budget and a small amount was added to regular education in this revision 71.3% of the district's M budget are in areas that directly support the classroom despite minimal uh Revision in the budget provided for each program we do see some shifting of budget from purchase Professional Services to salaries and benefits this is largely being driven by better performance than initially anticipated in filling Transportation positions with our own employees versus Contracting those services to outside agencies as a reminder the unrestricted Capital outlay fund supports construction remodels of facilities equipment textbooks and other items that will last the district longer than a year similar to the m budget unrestricted capital outlay resources are provided to the district via a statutory formula that considers average daily membership or full-time equivalent students
006served by the district and a funding amount per student unrestricted Capital outlay cons considers a prior year student count when determining funding unlike M which considers current year membership each year the state reevaluates and recalculates membership Statewide in September and so in this budget revision we're updating to the state's final figures for last year's enrollment here you can see a comparison of the unrestricted capital outlay budget limit in this budget revision compared to the adopted budget most of the increas in the fund is being caused by a change in the carryover from the estimate made in June from the proposed budget to to the end of the year the change in estimate is due primarily to construction projects that continued into FY 2025 or orders that did not come uh in before June 30th but
007were anticipated to the unrestricted capital outlay budget is primarily budgeted for facilities work Furniture equipment and vehicles as well as instructional materials I also wanted to take the opportunity to speak briefly on other important funds that are presently supporting our capital projects adjacent ways as an example is a fund that allows the district to raise funds from local taxpayers to support improvements that are largely outside of District property but that make entering and exiting District Pro property possible as an example we presently expect adjacent ways to support Street improvements and Sewer improvements along with other similar projects for school 17 our presentation later tonight will briefly touch on this aspect of School 17 and we'll further discuss the planned future adjacent ways levies as we work towards a successful budget for fiscal year 2026 the
008bond building fund is the fund that our bond proceeds are deposited into for use to date we have sold $30 million of the bonds uh that were passed the last November and we will be bringing a request for board approval to sell $20 million of bonds consistent with our bond program in the new calendar year these Bond proceeds will support School 17 and certain school safety improvements this fiscal year The Debt Service fund is the opposite side of the equation to our bond building fund it's through this fund that we pay the bond payments for bonds that our community supports last but not least we have the en water savings fund through which we pay the lease payments for our energy and water savings projects presently our partner VAR G is in the process of
009finding finalizing building envelope improvements at all of our schools installing improved lighting installing HVAC units to replace uh aging air conditioning uh and it's through this fund that we make lease payments uh on those projects at this time I'm available to answer any questions you may have on the the district's first budget revision for fiscal year 2025 Miss Climer did you have any questions no I don't thank you for the presentation Miss Moran no questions thank you Miss Wallace no questions thank you Mr Owens no questions thanks I don't have any questions thank you very much for the presentation I do need a motion to adjourn the public hearing I move to adjourn the public hearing I will second having a motion from Miss Climer and second from Miss Moran I'll call for the vote
010Miss Climer yay Miss Moran yay Miss Wallace yay Mr Owens yay I'm a yay motion passes and we will now move on our next item on the agenda will be the Pledge of Allegiance if I could have you guys stand and join us please next we will take a moment of Silent reflection e thank you and next we are going to move on to what everyone here is in the room for uh to our recognitions and celebrations and this is going to be led by executive director nanas good evening Madame President governing board members Dr Davidson esteemed cabinet colleagues and our valued guest joining us both in person and online I want to start off by welcome welcoming you all and thank you for coming to celebrate all of our students this evening it is
011an honor to address you this evening as we come together to celebrate the extraordinary achievements of our sixth through e8th grade Lichfield Learners these students have not only excelled academically but have also demonstrated resilience and determination earning a remarkable able success on the aasa math or Ela State mandated exams their hard work deserves our deepest admiration tonight we also recognize that such exceptional Student Success stems from the strong leadership and the dedication within our schools we celebrate our principles for their vision and steadfast commitment which alongside with our teachers tireless efforts have cultivated the U the environments of growing graduates where students Thrive and succeed the accomplishments of these outstanding students reflect not only their own perseverance but also the unwavering support of their families teachers and the entire LD 79 Community they set a
012high bar for academic excellence and serve as a source of Pride and inspiration for us all we know that their Futures are bright and filled with bound less potential these high Achievers represent the very best that Lees d79 has to offer and we are confident that they will continue to Excel and positively impact their communities in the years ahead congratulations to each of these incredible students your hard work and determination is a true inspiration to all of us so now would would like to read the names so please come forward to take a picture with Dr Davidson and governing board president zida and we will do this alphabetically so we will start off with Bolen stto Middle School yes and principls uh or their representative if you would please come forward um balen stto led
013by principal Courtney Frasier and stepping in for principal Frasier this evening will be Kim Thomas 8th grade teacher all right first off we have imagin Thomas Rowan Griffin Liliana Flores and Philipe Mand Raga all right congratulations valeno okay next up we have Al Thomas heck led by principal Luke janky all right we're going to go oh and accompanied by assistant principal G giselli Hedges all right first up we have Isabella duas princess gray Jaden toll Jonathan heat that is our El Thomas heck celebrant all right there you go congratulations okay next up Palm Valley Elementary led by Dr Kimberly Hill all right this is a dynamic duel from Palm Valley Elementary being the first year to take on sixth graders all right first from Palm Valley we have Owen mcle and Caleb pno aesome yeah
014congratulations all right moving on to verado herriage Middle School led by principal Meredith noi standing in for her tonight will be assistant principal Chrissy Carberry all right first V Heritage we have Nellis Andrews Brody Weaver Elliot L Monaco Susan G Ryland Fain Jasper sternfield Haley reri and Paige pen all right verado Heritage all right next up we have verado Middle School led by principal Anthony pan all right first up verado Middle School Chloe Chang Kaa Campbell oh grunt me Zoe Scott Samuel Chang Harper Craig Lydia singen San hoarder Carter Casella draa Gillian Haley Peters that's it big smile verado middle congratulations all right next up we have Western Sky home of the wild cats led by principal Cassie Harge all right first up we have Christian killer c three hatch Joshua Beck Lauren Howard Dion
015kurd Eliza Gutierrez Colton Hoffman Alexander vobo Carson Webster Olivia Mesa Cowen Matthews Aubrey Harris Marley hajes jayen Giordano and Van Hildy yes congratulations Western Sky okay and now we have wig let me try this again wig Creek Middle there we go yeah yeah as you can tell I've been here almost three years I still struggle with that one yeah okay I just don't want to sound like Elmer fud when I'm doing this okay here we go led by Sarah Rosenthal principal Sarah Rosenthal okay Wigwam Greek okay here we go Jonathan Reyes Surin Dre U William Lewis Brooklyn Gilberts Malaya glass Isa Buck burger and Zo perz all right once again let's give them all another round of applause these exceptional students embody the spirit of Excellence of Elliot d79 and we are so proud of
016everything that they have achieved okay that wraps up our student celebration uh feel free to grab some water and or a snack on your way out or stay and enjoy the rest of the board meeting okay it's it's just like the budget yeah also parents before you leave we'll be sharing the pictures that we did take up here ourselves on our social media LD 79 Facebook page you can pull them down from there as well we're going to take a two-minute break so we can let everybody grab their snacks and then we'll come back e when mess yeah but it's on my chair then they out out seconds yeah so yeah it was a wild my chair time supposed to yeah I have a picture of my notes if I put them up no they
017would seen them but just for questions right so I was gonna fill it out started early so it was good that's awesome yeah yeah right and it's funny how I practi times recorded myself say this instead of that yeah you got it so just wait for the sign put the back yeah yeah soil oh yes my bud I'll take I oh this for days you got an ear infection so she's like fine Lally it's like you're on your antibiotics those are for you you can't catch it I want to watch BL okay watch I watch Peppa Pig watch a lot of K watch a lot of Peppa Pig yeah sometimes I'm like no we're not watching blippy we're not watching some of this other stuff like let's watch a movie be scar you guys all
018ready for Christmas [Music] that's what are we ready to get started yes like thank you if everyone is ready to go we will move back into our next celebration I I guess it's a celebration uh but a recognition uh by executive director nanas yes um we will continue the evening's recognition um and for this uh second one we will bring up Dr Carter Davidson thank you Mr Nanas and uh president Zima members of the board um tonight we're going to honor Miss Danielle Kimber a for leaving a legacy of dedication and service and so I'd like to begin by saying it with gratitude and honor that we recognize board member Danielle Climer for her roughly nine years of dedication to the Lichfield Elementary School District Miss kimber's passion for advancing Student Success has left a
019mark on the Lichfield Learners LD 79 families our staff and our entire community Through challenging times including the covid-19 period miss climber's leadership exemplified resilience and a commitment to continuous Improvement her contributions have shaped the foundation of excellence in our district ensuring a brighter future for governing board members and for all of our students as we head into our winter holiday break and transition to our new governing board I am confident that the Precedence of Excellence that Miss Climer has set will continue as we return in January to finish out the 2425 school year on behalf of myself our administrative cabinet and the entire l79 family we extend our deepest appreciation for Miss cler's remarkable service Miss Climer thank you for your vision your compassion and support of our District's mission and vision you will
020always be a part of this LD 79 family and as we end Miss Contra has a little token of appreciation on behalf of your work and service in our district thank you Miss Climer I'm sure we're going to take a couple of pictures but uh I do know that a couple of us had some things we also wanted to say at this point so I'm going to let Miss Moran start I don't normally get nervous but I'm feeling really nervous okay I prepared a statement that I'm going to read board member climber has selflessly served the litfield elementary school district as governing board member and president at times over the past nine years she helped steer this District through many ups and downs two superintendent transitions multiple movements including purple for parents and red for
021Ed new school openings significant boundary changes a toxic board member and last last but not least a global pandemic wow it's been a lot in hindsight through it all she has remained a steadfast and thoughtful leader who always prioritized the best entrance of students Danielle I am forever grateful for the example you set and for the immeasurable amount of knowledge wisdom and guidance you imparted to me over the years I am a better board member because of your willingness to give your time and talent to LD your impact on this Board District leadership staff and students will continue even in your absence you'll be greatly missed and I wish you all the best but I am not the only member of the Daniel climber Fan Club former board member Shan HMO sent his sentiments as
022well here I I will start quoting this is a quote from Sean huso here are a few words about my friend Danielle Climer coming for me you know this will be a rhyme first of all let me make this clear Danielle's a true Schoolboard Pioneer opening new schools yeah she made it happen built Foundation strong with vision and passion she fought for the teachers brought in more pay helped to stretch the dollars paved A Brighter Day hiring superintendence she helped to choose the best Aiming High for the district aced every test took the hammer from yamamori ready to lead pushed forward with courage planted every seed survived the honack era yeah she stood her ground kept the focus on progress turned it all around with her kids Noah and Emory inspiring her fight she worked
023for better schools from morning to night she toured the schools Apple py runs and science fairs reading books to the kids showing she cares balancing budgets she helped stretch the dollars so Educators could focus on creating Scholars now the schools in the district shine brighter each day thanks to Danielle Paving the way so let's celebrate her her vision her drive for making our schools and Community Thrive Danielle climber a great leader a great friend a great mom a champion for education she's really the bomb thanks for your time for so many years now it's time to go celebrate by drinking some beers your friend Sean HMO I am not going to rrap that's not my jam I was trying to write down some thoughts and I just kept getting kind of emotional and I too
024have been a little nervous about this because when I joined the board I didn't really know anyone on the board really at all but I was somebody who liked to email the board every now and then when I had a concern and I always always always got a response from Danielle when I did that she was always so kind and always so understanding of whatever it is that I had to say and one of the things that I've Loved about her and that I brought into me becoming a board member is that I wanted to make sure that I always listened to what our community members had to say whether or not I could make a change didn't make the didn't matter it was that we wanted to make sure that they felt heard and
025so that's something I've carried with me always and I feel like I got that from you and seeing what that was like but I was writing down some words and some things is that Danielle is understanding she is open-minded she is fair she is strong and she cares very much about our students yesterday at a swearing in ceremony with uh Steve Watson he said that our most valuable constituents as a board member are the ones who can't vote and that we have to put their needs above everybody and that's one of the things that Daniel climber has always done she has always put the best interest of students ahead of herself and ahead of anything else so this board is better off by having you here and we will miss you greatly this district is
026in a much better place by having you serve these last nine years and your work will continue on I feel very confident in the people that we have coming in moving forward but uh the three of us ladies here have been through a lot and so it's going to be a weird time to not have you up here but I wish you well in your next adventures and thank you for being a great example to all that are here now and who are going to come in the future by your leadership I wasn't expecting all this so I'm going to kindly request I have some words but I'm going to leave them for my board report at the end if you don't mind um I I say they're brief but we all know that's not
027the truth so I'm going to let our board member board meeting go on um and let me reset a little bit and then I'd like to share my my thoughts about this um at the end of our meeting but um I will say thank you this has been some of the best memories of my life both professionally and personally so we'll see if I can get through the rest of the meeting without being emotional but um I I appreciate all of the um love and the nice words I think the the best thing that I have walking away from this is knowing that um this is this place is as amazing as it has ever been and the the future couldn't look brighter and I think that's what I'm most proud of so more to
028come in a little bit once I've reconfigured myself a little bit did you need to take any pictures Sam or okay do you want everyone in pictures now yes everyone should come be in pictures with Miss Climer let's go e e e okay uh now we're going to shift gears and we're going to move on to the next item on the agenda which is public request to speak we have three speakers I'm going to read this little disclaimer pursuant to Arizona revised statutes 38-43 this agenda item provides an open call to the public allowing individuals to address the governing board on any issue within the jurisdiction of the board items not listed on the agenda may be brought to the governing board's attention under this section of the agenda due to the Arizona open meeting
029law the governing board cannot discuss or take any action on items not listed on the agenda therefore pursuant to ARS 38-43 1.01 response to public comment about matters not appearing on the agenda will be limited to individual board members who may ask staff to study the matter respond to any criticism or ask that the matter be put on a future agenda for further consideration and decision at a later date please limit your comments to No More Than 3 minutes and no more than 30 minutes will be devoted to the public comment portion of the agenda when you approach the podium please state your name for the record our first speaker is going to be Mr Mike finegan hello everyone my name is Mike finnean I must say I haven't seen so many parents in this
030room since 2020 uh under much better um conditions tonight than it was in 2020 when we were introducing in CRT and diie uh it's good to see proficient students here after the October 15 2024 LD chronic absenteeism presentation I am anxious to see the effects of your smart goals and action plan going forward and reducing the existing chronic absentee rate of 2,858 students I look forward to seeing this District returning to preco attendance levels within two years and becoming a shining example of success for other districts to follow I recently under found out that the Arizona Department of Education has a target for reducing absenteeism at six years this problem is way too serious and that time frame is way too long to deal with such a serious problem uh shifting topics policy changes to
031public education are coming soon to a district near you some of which are sending education back to the States Universal school choice Nationwide cutting federal education funds to schools that push CRT gender identity and other inappropriate racial sexual or political content on students cutting redundant administrative cost and emphasizing academic Improvement and Merit ability no funding to schools who have vaccine and mask mandates Senators say restricting tax dollars to Local Schools is an outdated idea and should be allocated according to each family's Choice whether public private or homeschooling as public Educators if you really have the child's best interests at heart then why would you not want them to choose a school which will help them become a better student I know the interest in this room are quite different from that idea again I look
032forward to seeing much lower absentee rate results within two years and I look forward to the LD School District becoming a shining example of success for other districts to follow happy holidays thank you our next speaker will be uh Miss Shelley Smith good evening members of the Lichfield School Board my name is Shelley Smith with a little drama and I'm here tonight to request that the facility fee for a little drama and color whales remain at $2 per hour for the 2526 school year and not be increased to $40 an hour Betsy and I have dedicated ourselves to the district enriching and educating students over the 17 years Corda Sierra Rancho Santa Fe Scott Libby and dream Summit are the schools that benefit benefited from the free elective program in lie of payment for facility
033fees for our after school programs these programs aren't just about drama or art it's about the opportunity allowing us to continue offering free free electives creates a win-win situation for everyone teachers gain valuable extra time for meetings or lesson planning at the same time students benefit from a program that Fosters creativity confidence teamwork and critical thinking skills that prepare them for success in school and in life moreover providing these programs strengthen the district's ability to attract and to retain families parents choosing between Lichfield schools and nearby Charter Schools notice pro programs like ours which provide unique highquality opportunities at no additional cost to families or the district these programs are an asset to the community and we share the same Mission as the district to nurture the whole child also this will show the community
034that the district is working directly with women-owned businesses that live and pay taxes in Lichfield District I am proud of the Legacy a little drama and color wheels have built over the years we have many families teachers and administrators who can vouch for the impact it has on students maintaining the current philosop fee will allow us to sustain and expand this meaningful work I urge you to keep the rate at 20 per hour and continue supporting this valuable program please do not raise it to $40 an hour I also ask you for an update on the study of the cost of classroom rate versus the FI field rate why are you charging the same I would like you to have these letters that the students from Rancho Santa Fe and caer wrote to the superintendent
035and to the school board regarding keeping the free elective program so it's aaid two of them next year thank you for your time and I hope to keep working to keep this free elective program to our students thank you where can I hand you these letters or should I get to the secretary if you can give them to our secretary please Julia thank you okay our next speaker is going to be uh Betsy eter good evening um I know the board is considering doubling the facility rental rates for for-profit entities while leaving the rental rates for nonprofits the same one reason given um for treating the two differently is that nonprofits most closely align with the mission of LD and I think there might be some faulty assumptions about nonprofit so I'm going to speak
036to that nonprofits are not free for all all nonprofits are not free for participants the Girl Scouts for for example have an annual dues of $35 which will go to 85 by 2027 to match the current Boy Scout fee other annual costs include uh required uniforms and badges for $35 field trips bringing the annual cost particip for participant of $120 a year and upwards I believe local Girl Scout Troops help keep costs down by not using classrooms that charge any fee for nonprofits cost is offset by participant fees in addition to Grants and donations staff is hired to write grants pursue donors and plan fundraisers Girl Scouts sell cookies teaching the girls the skills involved in selling cookies is part of the Girl Scout Mission today the Girl Scouts are in financial Straits projecting 2024
037operating losses of 5.6 million the CEO of the Girl Scouts of America's salary in 2023 was $753,000 Girl Scout headquarters are on Fifth Avenue in New York it's been suggested that we transform our businesses into nonprofit entities because our businesses already exist transferring them to nonprofit status would cost $3500 to $4,000 UPF front and an additional $1,000 per year our operations are much more efficient than nonprofits all our resources go directly to students there are no middlemen or women no using extensive time and resources to pursue grants donations and fundraising the nature of color wheels and a little drama is that we're available after school on site to kids who couldn't come to a class at a studio we local one-woman businesses run by individuals who choose to use our Decades of experience in our
038fields to nurture the children of this District unfortunately we cannot afford to work for free and we cannot afford to run at a deficit my mission is to educate children in the visual arts empowering them with the tools materials skills time space and guidance to shape their environment in a positive way work with others and solve problems creatively the small business newsletter crown.com recommends small businesses pay rent at anywhere from 2 to 20% of their gross the current facility charge represents about 15% of my gross which is toward the higher end of that window the 30% that Community Ed Partners like young Rembrandts pays includes advertising in the form of paper flyer distribution we're not asking for advertising this year to offset our facility rental fees color wheels provided in school services and materials to
039roughly 2,000 students at no charge to them and at a cost to the district of 7 5 cents a student this seems like a winwin win winwin situation but doubling our rental rates is not feasible for us thank you thank you okay next we are going to move on to the adoption of the agenda and approval of consent agenda I'll go through and see if there are any items items that people wish to pull from the consent item agenda uh Miss climber yes I'm sorry I wasn't prepared give me just one second um I'm sorry can you go to the next person worries Miss marand did you have something you wanted to pull off yes I would like to to discuss and have a couple of questions on item 8.13 board acknowledgement of employee conflict
040of interest for 2425 Miss Wallace did you have any items you wish to pull I do not but I read about the pets in the classroom and it all looked great Mr Owens I do not uh I do not have anything either Miss climber did you find your item I did I had a question on uh 8.10 okay okay um then if someone wants to make a motion minus 8.10 and 813 uh I move to approve the consent agenda minus 8.10 and 8.13 as presented I will second having a motion from Miss Climer and a second from Miss Moran I will call for the vote Miss Climer yay Miss Moran yay Miss Wallace yay Mr Owens yay I'm also yay motion passes okay uh then we will move jump into the items that were pulled
041we will start with I guess this will now be one no I'm sorry yeah 9.1 which is the uh updated 2025 extracurricular training and other stiens Miss climber I'll let you yes my question I understand how the stiens work I don't have any I don't have any issue with that um what I wanted to know was the way that it's presented on this chart it's hard to see this in conjunction with other stiping that we offer that might be similar so because there's only one listed here I'm just wondering in other areas where something would be similar is the cost appropriate you know what are the duties here and how the cost relate to other stiens I only see one stien here so I can't compare them to the others good evening governing board thank
042you govern board Danielle for this great question um yes we when we looked at the stien and the time commitment and the responsibilities that these principles would be taking on as a leader and me coach um we did compare it to other stiens um with same similar responsibilties similar time commitments okay and so this is leader me trainers these are all of the principles that currently have the leader and meet program on their campus or is it is always the principal is it somebody else potentially um the stien is to the cypen approval is to sipen our three principles yes they are all leader and me principles um they did have to be farther along in the leader me process to be eligible to um apply to be a coach in this model um we're
043actually the first school system in Arizona that have done the C and model for leader and me and it's going really really well and we're really excited so this is to compensate them for time above and beyond um what they do in their principal ship because they are committing time outside of their school day um on their weekends to prepare for the trainings um to get other schools up and rolling in the different cores of leader and me um and then as far as comparable stiens we compared it to um our um if they're supervising our psychologists there's a $5,000 stien um if special education that's one that we found similar another one was um coaching special ed coaches coaching so similar coaching positions which would be duties above and beyond their their responsibilities of
044what they've been hired for great totally understand thank you one last question just so that I understand these principles are trainers and or coaches of leader and me only for Lichfield they're not actually compensated by leader and me in any way that is absolutely correct they are they are coaches for Lichfield Elementary School District only okay perfect thank you Miss morand do you have any questions on the side U no but I'll just add to that in case any of of us do not recall that at one point in time we had discussed hiring outside folks to do this and we realized that we had some uh people internally who could do the job for us and at a better price so that was another factor that went into US determining that um this might
045be a better route for us than hiring um outside folks Miss Wallace did have any questions about this item no no questions Mr Owens no thank you uh I do not either so if someone wants to make a motion I move to approve the updated fiscal year 2025 extracurricular training and other stiping charts as presented I'll second having a motion from Miss Climer and a second for Mr Owens I'll call for the vote Miss Climer yay Miss Moran yay Miss Wallace yay Mr Owens yay I'm a yay motion passes next we will move on to this will now be 9.2 which is uh board acknowledgement of employee conflict of interest for 2425 I will start with Miss Moran's questions and then I believe Dr duy is going to speak to this okay so my question
046is when I look at these um conflicts of interests that were provided to us they all make sense um but my primary question are related to the two folks that are the individuals themselves and not their spouses or family members who might have a conflict of interest so my first question is about Jamie Monday as a leader in me Franklin cby having a relationship with them my question is is Ms Monday in any uh position to influence our relationship or purchases that are happening with leader inme or Franklin cuy great thank you good even thank you for that great question governing board Moran Miss Monday is not in a position that makes decisions or influences the district decisions regarding leader and me implementation or decision- making for funding or um processing the program in any
047way shape or form okay and can you provide any more information about what her relationship is with leader and me sure great question Miss Monday um has been a lighthouse um coordinator for verado Heritage which is part of the lighthouse process for leader and me um and she was nominated by leader and me for her leadership at verado Heritage um and accepted as what they call a lighthouse Beacon coordinator which means that she'll be on a panel um outside of Lichfield um joining at other schools that are going after that status very similar to the A+ um judging that um some of our principles participate in so she'll be on that panel to judge to make that decision if other schools obtain that Lighthouse status for lead and me so nothing directly for Lichfield because
048that would be a conflict to be on our judging panel um but for other school systems um that's what her service would be okay and then I really just have similar or the same questions related questions to Shaina Harmon who is co-owner it states here co-owner of Aquatic and writing rehab tell me more about that relationship and what shaina's decision-making process may or may not be I'm going to have to tag one of my other teammates because I am unaware of that employes situation Mr V do you have any information about that employee I don't uh but I'm wondering if Tammy Garrett our director of purchasing who's in the audience might I'm gonna have you wait so you can get on the mic so if people can hear that are watching from home so um
049she is what is listed is she is a co-owner of but it is not a vendor that we use it's not a registered vendor nor a vendor that we utilize um but part of the conflict of interest form is if we should ever become a vendor or do anything of that they would have to recru themselves from any type of purchasing so they would not be able to have any um impact with that whatsoever but currently not a vendor at all with us but has been a vendor in the past or I mean obviously there's a lot of relationships people have like how far do we go that we preemptively would want to make sure that we're over I think we're very cautious so if someone has a question or possibly something that ever could
050be in the future we say it's better to report it and disclose it than not to just so we can have that because it gets flagged in our system um and we keep a list if they're not in our system such as this one is not but we have a list of if anything should ever come up okay so it's anything that could be related to education um for services that would be provided so I get what you're saying like a lot of people could fill things out but it depends and if someone has a question we tell them it's better to disclose than not to which which I completely agree with I just um okay I guess we'll just I get when it gets when I when it comes to that then I just
051am concerned with the consistency because um yeah I just don't know how we Implement consistency if saying uh this policy or we're asking people to do things based on what ifs I'm not asking you to do anything about that right now I'm just um just contemplating that myself so okay um I don't have any issues with this particular uh employee conflict of interest list or any of these F I don't have any concerns about that but I will think about that system I can add some more at a at a high level um so really what the conflict of interests laws because this is more driven by by state law and regulation than it is anything really that we're doing what what it asks you to contemplate is if you have a real um opportunity
052to truly benefit as an individual and so in instances where where you might be a co-owner of a of a company that uh Works a adjacent to education that would be something that the state rules would ask that you disclose um we we are finding that there's always more room for further education of our staff around what those examples really mean um one of the one of the things that always comes up when when we go to training on it which is always comical is the state rules um identify every family member but a cousin um and so so if you're really going to apply it to the letter of the law uh there are really some weird quirks to it but the two that that we've discussed tonight I think definitely fall within that
053Realm of the state would expect them to be disclosed and and it's not even necessarily that we use those vendors as as we've discussed it's just in case we ever are in a situation that we would we have on record we need to proceed with even more caution than we otherwise would because there is a potential conflict of interest not necessarily A real one but but a potential one uh that we need to be aware of as we move forward working with with that vendor or not understood thank you Miss Wallace did you have any questions about this item no thank you Mr Owens no Miss Climer no thank you I have no questions either or someone would like to make a motion I move to approve the board acknowledgement of employee conflict of interest
054for 2425 as presented have a second having a motion from Miss Climer and a second from Miss Moran I will call for the vote Miss Climer yay Miss Moran yay Miss Wallace yay Mr Owens yay I'm also a yay motion passes okay we are going to move on to the next uh items on the agenda which is going to be the approval of fiscal year 2025 expenditure budget revision number one this will be by cfov Von Madame President uh at this point I'm available to answer any questions you may have held from the public hearing um I I I don't have much else to add wonderful Miss Climer did you think of any questions from then and now I did not but I'm I'm shocked that we don't have another PowerPoint deck that you're going
055to go through with us for more budget numbers so I'm a bit disappointed but I'll be okay no questions Miss Moran no questions Miss Wallace still no questions Mr Owens no questions I also have no questions if someone would like to make a motion I move to approve the fiscal year 2025 expenditure budget revised as revised and presented I'll second having a motion from Mr Owens and a second from Miss Climer I'll call for the vote Miss Climer yay Miss Moran yay Miss Wallace yay Mr Owens yay I'm also yay motion passes that was the fastest budget talk ever yes okay next we are going to move on to discussion items and we are going to start with some exciting information about School 17 and this is going to be by principal Jen Mr ensen
056and Dr Stone Madame President members of the governing board I'm pleased to present to you School 17 and its progress we are moving very quickly at this point um as they pull up the uh presentation myself Dan enzen I'm director of construction uh Eric Stone um overseas uh the department and Luke jeni is the incoming principal for School 17 I want to go through a little bit how we got here U first of all we started with a demographic study indicating that we needed a school in the West side of our district um our schools are overcrowded and we needed that added to our district the voters graciously approved a bond in 2023 so that we could build this school along with other improvements throughout the district we went on to uh selecting a site
057through boundary changes we governing board uh approved the hiring of an architect and a CM at risk contractor um we conducted Community input meetings um both at uh was it binotto verado Heritage here a couple different locations I might have got one of those wrong um to get input from the community to find out what they wanted in this new K8 school from there we went on to schematic design that's where we kind of look at some of the input that we had from the school uh from the neighborhood from the school the standards and things like that to start to put together what we wanted to create as a school from there we went to design development which are the plans um where we laid out out the the site we laid out the
058classrooms and how the the plans are going to come together our next step are construction documents those are the plans that are going to go to our authorities of having jurisdiction that will review them for permit um so we're right at that point now uh land acquisition is still in progress um it's going back and forth still with legal and with the the developer that is donating the land to us and we'll locate that in a minute um permitting it will start after the construction docents are completed it'll send it off to the State Fire Marshall to the mar Copa County uh permitting processes and Health Department um we will go through the school facilities oversight board uh staff will review our plans uh for our adjacent ways use of our adjacent ways to verify
059that we're using them correctly we bring that up specifically because there are additional adjacent ways that we haven't seen before in building this school we have a couple half streets um there's an ARG ditch that we do need to varry there's a sewer line that has to go a considerable distance in order to connect so there's a lot more um expenses than we're typically used to and uh Mr Von will go over that with you even further in detail when we get to that point but the school facilities board does verify that we're using them correctly um per the state statutes on how those are used so we are doing it correctly the guaranteed maximum price um it is phased as you know we've already approved one to release the electrical gear um we're expecting
060to phase the rest of the the project out in guarantee maximum prices in order to move the process along because we're still on that tight schedule so you will see something in the next couple months of a smaller guaranteed maximum price and then we're expecting another the larger full one after that um construction start uh I left it very loose with spring of 2025 notice there's not a month or a day that we're going to start it um because we are withholding to the permitting process that we really have very little control over um we're expecting to complete in the summer of 2026 with an August of 2026 opening date so that's just a little bit of where we're headed the next oh next this is a map of our district um you can see
061the location of all of our different schools they're colorcoded by K8 K5 and Middle School the bright yellow one up there in the top corner is um the Zan hero development uh wind rose Community up there Perryville and Glendale Avenue is the location of the site that we have previously selected here's a little bit closer shot of the kind of what you can see right now on Google Earth at least of the site you can see the the large site on the top right is our property um to the left of it is the community there's actually several homes that have already closed uh in the neighborhood currently so that neighborhood is actively uh building and closing and people are moving in besides the rest of the the area that will um house or be
062housed here at the school 17 now you can see down there at the bottom is Canyon View High School that might give uh you a little bit of an idea about where the location is this is a couple pictures I took of the site just a couple days ago in the background you can see Barry Goldwater Peak um there's a MCM Dam right there um and the White tankk Mountains right there at the corner of Perryville and Glendale this is the shot looking directly at our property um the corner property looking South uh East you can see the irrigation ditch right there along glendell Avenue that we will have to relocate um and then behind that as you can see it's raw desert land at this moment this is a rendering of what the site
063looks like um for the design that we're going for right now um this is in like I said construction documents they're finishing up the Civil the parking lots and things like that that will go um as you can see down to the South End we've got baseball softball and soccer planned for the fields we have a playground um we'll have a gymnasium um classroom buildings front office on the top off glendle Avenue is our Bus Loop that's completely separated from parent drop off or parking um which is very important we also have uh lots and lots of parking spaces you know that is a sticking point for Miss Climer in the past I'm just a representative of the people Dan this is what they want more parking spaces with with your last time I had
064to make sure that you knew that we were still yeah we're still paying attention it's important if you've ever been in a parent pickup line you know what I mean because if there was more parking they would park there but they don't they wait in the pickup line and they doing it wrong I'm just saying I'm representative of the people well there are lots of disc yes there's lots of discussions on how parents are going to come in and out how staff are going to park how the buses interact with them so all of those different concepts those are all discussions are made with the architect the city planners um local law enforcement all of those discussions are had so that we make sure that we do the best we can to predict where the
065issues are going to be oh you're going to have naughty parents it's just is what it is Luke's gonna have to bring the hammer he knows what he's doing here's a couple renderings uh from the architect showing uh what the courtyard is going to look like the front of the campus from Perryville in the background you can see the very front office so it helps to guide you um right to that front office so it's very obvious the inside Courtyards got lots of landscape open space spaces outside where the kids can learn a lot of the things that the community input um drove as we designed into the campus here's a couple uh shots of a typical classroom that you'll see at school 17 um many of you that have been inside of our classrooms
066will recognize a lot of the casework very looks very similar the front of the classroom will look very similar with marker boards and Tack boards um ceilings with lights and all those things you you can see on the left uh some renderings from the contractor as they go through and look at the plans to make sure that we have the correct estimating and budgets um indicating all those different locations here's a shot of the uh proposed Lobby that you'll come in if you're a parent and you need to check out your student you'll come into this area here um you can see some of the in the center is the mechanical systems some of the detail that goes into some of these plans and uh multi-stall restroom to the left or to the right on
067that there some elements that I wanted to make sure that you knew that we were paying attention to is um seped um as it's known as crime prevention through environmental design that played a big role in this project um safe routes of school those principles that are National principles that we pay attention to to make sure that the kids can get to the school safely um efficient use of spaces that was discussed quite with this project because we're we have a we have a very good budget but it's always tight no matter what you do um so we want to make sure that we're very efficient with all of our spaces uh we're fiscally responsible to make sure that we're on budget and on time um we try to follow the district standards that we
068have set in our district so that make sure that we can maintain them so that when you go from school to school that you know where you're at and that you can learn and everybody will be able to interact with their schools State Standards there are statutes um that we follow to make sure that we meet minimum guidelines through the school facilities board um uh oversight board and their policies uh energy conservation we're trying to pay attention to our HVAC units our exhaust units um lighting LED um some of those types of things we talk to um all of our support departments to make sure that they're covered that the food service plan for the kitchen and how they they're going to interact with the c campus in the cafeteria those are uh spoken to
069are all the way down to our community ed program that operates after school we talk to them to make sure that they can operate with the school and it meets with uh some of their guidelines and and how they use it uh just for a couple examples and is it best for students in the end we always sit back take a step back and make sure that we're making decisions that are what's in the best interest of the student that they could be able to learn and to grow and to take ownership in this new school um I wanted to not stress but just remind you there's hundreds of thousands of decisions that are made hundreds and hundreds of thousands from the drafter at the architect to the estimator over at the the contractor to
070the superintendent there's just the number of decisions that are made in the design of a school are just just amazing um when you really sit back and look at it um and a lot of people have a lot of Blood Sweat and Tears that have gone into this design and to the eventual construction of the school that they'll be proud of uh the design development plans there's 251 plan sheets so large full full-size plans the project book uh specifications were 2,392 Pages um to make sure that you know that I have read through at least glance through every single one of those pages to make sure that they meet our standards and that they meet um what we want to see in a school um at this time I'm going to turn it over to
071Mr Luke jankee our new principal to go over some additional things all right do have extender all right Madam president members of the governing board uh before we get into the couple names that I'm going to present I'm just going to give you a little bit of background as far as the thought process in bringing the these two names so last year when I got named as the planning principal for this um I immediately started thinking about what kind of Roads do I want to go down when trying to figure out some names for the school um so really it turned into three avenues that I wanted to go down the first one was really Geographic when you look at our our district there's some of our schools that are named after the developments that
072they're kind of planted in so kind of from that Geographic spot um so that was definitely a possibility that I thought about um another one was historic so if you look at uh historical people that have an impact within our district um so that was a route that I went down in my mind as far as like that could be a path that we we go through and then a third route that that I didn't think that we had gone down in our district was a connection to Luke Air Force Base so um geographically we're very close to the base and that's just something we hadn't gone down in the past you know we is there somebody that has a connection to the base that also has a connection to our district that we we
073want to possibly consider to name uh a school after so those were the three Avenues I went down um the geographic one um when it came to the developments it looks like our footprint is going to have a few different developments so that was going to be kind of tricky when we went to the Lichfield Park Historical Society the area where the school is going to be built historically has been called Citrus Park um when I did kind of some litmus testing with the kids that are on my campus right now that are going to school 17 Citrus Park Elementary didn't really resonate with them so we kind of just put that off to the side um they did talk to me about uh a very historic person within our district so that's the first
074person that I'm going to introduce here so Jonathan L rer um we shared a lot more information than I'm going to share here with the governing board uh in the board dos but um Jonathan El rer he circulated the petitions to start Lichfield school that was started in 1917 so obviously a very important person in the history of our district um in the early years he served in the roles of student transporter janitor purchased the school furniture books supplies to get the school started um had the pleasure of meeting with Ron rer who's actually here tonight and his lovely wife uh right before Thanksgiving and they brought their family to meet with the the um a bunch of the administration uh just so that we could get a good feel for their family and they
075got to tell us a bunch of stories that c passed down through the generations um they still live here in the West Valley they still Farm here in the West Valley they've been very successful here in the West Valley the Rainer family has been big supporters of Education in the West Valley so um obviously from a historical perspective the Rainer family specifically Jonathan L rer played a huge role in starting the district and then the rer family has been a Mainstay in the West District ever since then so that was one of the names that I wanted to present tonight the other one um it took us a little while to kind of get down that military route but um Dr doy and and Jennifer Benjamin were at a function at Luke airports base and
076ended up talking to General Rand and had brought up the fact that we were looking for a possible person um with connections to our district and then this um individual was brought up so his name is Major Troy Gilbert so in 2006 major Troy Gilbert was stationed here at Luke Air Force Base and he was deployed to Iraq he had two kids that were going to Corte Sierra elementary school he had a second grader he had a kindergartener he also had a a three-year-old and he had twin 9-month-old um so when he was on Mission over there um he actually gave his life saving 19 special forces operators and countless other soldiers um he also served as an instructor while he was here at Luke Air Force Base so he taught other Pilots how to
077fly so I thought that was a nice connection when it came to education um he was the first person in his family to graduate from college um and then he lived his life on the tenants of selflessness service sacrifice love compassion loyalty and integrity so just this last week we got to meet with his um his widow Ginger Rella we got to meet with General Rand and then we got to meet with the command Chief um command Chief schaer from Luke Air Force Base so we got to get um you know some nice stories about his background as well obviously we didn't get to speak um to him just like we didn't get to speak with Jonathan El rer but just based on you know the the family uh the rer family we got to
078hear some stories um based on the people that knew major Troy Gilbert we got to hear some stories and then we gave um um the governing board some some articles from from both families uh some background both families I I believe are very welld deserving of the honor of having a school named after them both individuals I believe are very welld deserving of having a school named after them um so with that I will open it up to any questions from the governing board Miss Climer did you have any questions um I don't have any questions thank you so much for bringing this um I will tell you just because it's my last meeting and I'm being very you know retrospective I think one of my favorite things that I've done in the last nine
079years was be a part of the naming process of binotto and and seeing the process and vetting different people and really trying to decide um what connection was you know was appropriate to the district um and then obviously being able to see uh her family you know take part in so many of our activities and things like that has really been um really special for me personally so I think that that's really great um I agree with you that both of these people are extremely deserving um it's it's hard to you know to to choose or to give you really any feedback um I'm not familiar with the rer family but I know this is very similar to the process we went through in deciding bin SoDo and really looking at um what these people
080did in terms of what used to be here and getting our district started and you know really being sort of that Foundation which I think is is really important and the fact that they're still here um and still living that Legacy is is pretty awesome um major Troy Gilbert I I lived here at that time I I lived through this so I you know I know at least from my own personal account you know that uh one of our former board members um Steve yamore former president um has a personal connection to this story too so um he was involved in fighter country partnership during this time and obviously provided a lot of support to um this family and many others that were affected by this so um it has been um you know something
081that has been in our community for a long period of time so I I agree he is extremely deserving I will say I like I didn't even consider the connection to Luke Air Force Base and I think that is wonderful why we haven't done that before I don't know but um what a good opportunity they are a great partner to us um several of our students and families come through Luke Air Force Base and other you know sort of subsidiaries of that so um I think either one would be completely deserving and um you guys have a hard decision in front of you miss Maran yeah I agree I mean I think I think it's a win-win I think either um either name is deserving and either name would be a good choice I will
082say I personally am a little biased toward um major T Gilbert Elementary my dad served in the Air Force and um when I think about um as principal jeny uh pointed out when I think about the ability to tie in um this person to his life as an instructor and the sacrifice that he gave for our country um I find that really inspiring I also find it inspiring that a person in 1917 would literally be able to start a school district so um both sides of that I can see I I don't know exactly what other opportunities we're going to have down the road for naming you know when I look at these naming opportunities it's not like at a university where someone's giving us money name something so it's really up to us to
083do that from what we've talked about as a district school 17 will be the last school that we build based on what we know about where we are but we could end up building a separate or different district office facility or we could end up building some sort of uh early childhood education um facility at some point down the road and I feel like especially a district office or um District boardroom type facility would go really nicely with the JL rer naming opportunity because he literally started the district so um I feel like the major Troy Gilbert goes really well with an elementary school itself and the proximity of the school to Luke Air Force Base um but that's just my initial thoughts um on the process so I look forward to hearing more thoughts
084from my board members and and cabinet Miss Wallace um I I appreciate the presentation very much it's very well done um I read the articles last night and I started with the JL rer and I finished the article I was like oh that's it for sure and then I read this article and I was like oh man how do you choose so they're both really great I again this is not anything about this I thought the JL rer was a little quicker easier to say more recognizable than major Troy Gilbert Elementary it just kind of felt like a mouthful so however we decide to whoever we decide to go with that just and that was something that when I talk with Sam Nanz about the name I'm not sure if I want I would want
085to call it major Troy Gilbert Elementary because I think that if that's what we went with I think that he's more than an a soldier I think that he's um after talking with his wife and the people that knew him the best he's a father he's a son he's a Community member and I would if if he's going to be the representative of this you know if we're naming that school after him I wouldn't want it to be just about the soldier that he was Mr Owens um I'm really glad that you guys didn't go with like the typical desert Canyon View Mountain Ridge right like just overplayed so I was excited when I saw these two names because again I don't think you can go wrong um I'm glad I don't have to pick
086can you explain to me what the next steps are though moving forward like we're just going to prove them which is nice but I want to know how I you're gonna ask your students like what's the what's the plan on narrowing it down because obviously you're faced with a tough decision here it's in the news I read it in the news M Mr Rowan thank you for the question it is in the news and certainly we felt like this evening's experience was the first step in in gathering feedback you did see the news article and so um I believe in there was to contact Mr Nan's team and um share feedback that any Community member may have um if well it's not an if when we do choose to bring a name to the governing
087board for a vote certainly that would be an opportunity for public to weigh in through public comment um I know that Mr jeny has talked about once we kind of further the process bringing it to his team to his students to gather some additional feedback um that's kind of where we are right now and certainly would take any other ideas from the governing board yeah I don't necessarily have any ideas other than you know if any community members feel a certain way definitely um find a way to get that to either us or to the administration principal jeny just because U one of the things that's cool is this does represent our our our district and our community and so that's why I think um obviously with JL rer Elementary that's a strong name of
088historical value but um with a lot of ties to Military and understanding the service and sacrifice that a lot of our service members um experience in having that close connection and that first connection to Luke Air Force Base which plays a major role in our community um again very difficult decision but two very earning and well-deserved names and I think the the mascot's going to be an easier decision so but I hope it's not going to be that dolphin that I saw on that photo not gonna be the Dolphins I dolphins real quick just just because um my mother my mother served on a a school board for 20 years and at tson elementary there or tson high school there was a bathroom that was named after a board member so if I can recommend
089U maybe Daniel clammer parking lot at least just I just gonna say that that we need to the parking lot dedicated to Daniel fimr I I appreciate that you said working L of not bathroom so thank you very much maybe at least a reserved parking spot I don't know there you go um I love the fact that our district goes above and beyond when we're looking at these names and that we make them mean something um one of the greatest things that I ever got to do was know Barbara Roby when my son went to Barbara Robi elementary school and she was the most amazing woman I've ever met she was this little old lady would help put together our Roby rodeos we did every year and it was just incredible to like watch her
090and try to tell her she can't carry all the big heavy tables and she'd argue with you yes I can so I love that we do that and I'm I agree with my other board members that we don't want that generic name that's not who we are and that doesn't reflect this district and what's important to us by doing that um both these people are incredible individuals and our school would be a great place to name either one of them after so it is a hard decision I do want to make sure we're getting Community input however we're going to do it when we are deciding when we're voting it will be very important to me to know what feedback we get from the community as a whole so however we need to do that
091I think that we had stuff out there for people to kind of give their opinions when we did Bell and SoDo that was before I was on the board so I don't remember exactly but I know that we got community feedback through that process and so I would really like to see us do that again so that it's not just a few people that are making that decision because the whole Community the school belongs to our whole district and our whole community so let's make sure that they take ownership in the name otherwise I really appreciate this information you shared it was a lot of stuff and it sounds like you're very busy Mr ensen over there and also Mr jeny with running your current school and trying to help build this new school that's
092a lot so uh thank you guys for putting this together for us so um what do you need from us to move forward I'm hearing nothing which is right I know I feel like that they're nothing but Madame President uh at this point in time just we appreciate your support uh for all this work um as you noticed everybody's very busy getting this to happen and um we'll certainly bring additional information to you in the near future and heard you loud and clear about the community feedback peace well thank you again can I also just say one quick thing as we're transitioning to the next line item is um I think Dan very eloquent pointed out like the amount of work and time and energy and decisions and the number of people that touch this
093project that you know me included but several people are like why isn't this just going faster like just open the doors right just start building um and I think it's really important that we've had so many steps along the way where we have interviewed Architects we have gone through the design process we have opened this up to the community we have done all of these steps so that it's trans parent how this process works and that all the decisions can be very thoughtfully made versus just rushing um through the process so I mean as you can see all of the different decisions and project pages and all of the things that D's went through um they all come from people that are working really hard to make sure the school is um as good as
094it possibly can um and not go over budget fingers crossed so thanks to everyone involved okay and with that we are going to move on now to our next item for discussion which is the trust model policy chapter 4 Pages 1- 24 and this is going to be by executive director Satterfield good evening Madam president members of the governing board Dr Davidson and and colleagues um I'd like to go through our portion of first portion of chapter four of the trust policy uh as you can see on our commentary that we provided um on the first one board authority to employ we recommend no change to what was written in the trust policy also on procedure board authority to employ background checks we have no change to what's written in the policy on uh number
095102 for staff assignments we'd like to recommend that we remove the wording or to pass or fail a pupil in a course in high school a rationale of course is that we are an Elementary District only and um so we'd like to see that removed with your approval uh the next item is our employee evaluations we have a few recommendations there um the first one is that we would REM remove small letter B under definition of inadequate classroom performance as we continue to focus on student achievement and also in our support of our teachers in the classroom it's our perspective that quantifying developing as the basis for inadequacy uh if we were to do so that we inherently take away the opportunity for this uh rating to be perceived as an opportunity for growth which
096is really how we understand developing because our new people come in and they may not have all the skills and so we will help them to develop those skills uh the second recommendation we would have under employee evaluations is uh letter M we'd like to keep the optional recommendation striking the word waves and replacing it with maywave that would allow us to uh keep the decision of whether uh the evaluation uh was waved in your hands so it would be at the discretion of the governing board uh we would like to ask that we not accept the optional alternative performance evaluation cycle um and once again I just go back to our focus on student achievement and in our way of supporting our teachers in the classroom as well as our current work on the
097evaluation tools as you've asked us to do we've begun that work and um the addition of an expedited alternative evalu valuation seems contrary to where we're going because we want to build cascading evaluations that all have the similar Focus uh regardless of what category of employee you are um the last one in that area is we'd like to remove employees in the first year employment may be evaluated 90 days after the first day of work uh the removal of this sentence and the need for feedback to employees will be addressed um we're going to look at the language in our contract as well this year before we issue contracts and notice of appointments and uh also that links directly with what we do with the evaluation tool so in many school districts they have a
09890-day probationary period our employees in that category are at will and so we want to make sure that we have complete alignment of everything that um we have the proper language in our contract and that we provide the support opportunity for our classified employees as well as we focus on retention and uh we feel that making this change would be in the best interest at this particular point in time as we look at the policy can I have you pause for a moment before we move to the next one just so that since that's a bunch of stuff in that one did anybody have any comments or questions up to now miss climber yes I have a question page eight I believe it's 4103 uh yeah 4103 the first one where we were um removing
099the item b uhu um can you just tell me more about that I I understand the concept of not wanting to have developing teachers think that there's not an opportunity to advance Etc um I understand that but I guess when I what I would like to know is what what is the time frame in which we would agree to or think would be typical for a teacher in that category to remain in that category so for me I see three years I'm thinking if you're three years and you're still in the developing sort of bottom category of our thing I I think maybe it's appropriate to have a conversation at that point right that they've been developing for a period of time so I'm just wondering what is the is is it the time frame
100issue or is it the word devel Ving in that category that's more of an issue and how do we if if we don't have this in there what are the opportunities to not rehire people or move people into situations if they are not a good fit so in the first three years that the teachers our employed they're considered probationary and so we have the opportunity particularly if there are other circumstances that come up that are concerning that aren't addressed rest then we have the opportunity to not invite them back for the next year um I think the developing is kind of a fine line I I fully understand your point because there has to be a point When developing is not any longer acceptable to me just thinking quickly here this evening I would say
101within that first three years if we weren't seeing them too effective in their categories and they still could have possibly one area that they were developing in uh I believe in the wording in the trust policy uh I believe it talks about three developing or more and we didn't have anything when I reviewed our existing policy we didn't have anything like that and um I did follow up and speak with um Jennifer mclennen to ask her if there was any component of that that I was missing if I ask that you consider removing it and she thought she was in agreement with us that to not have that in there was good so that we could continue to promote um the opportunity for growth but also knowing that we're always cognizant of the probationary period
102and you still what I'm hearing you say is that you still have the opportunity to either move or reassign or not hire back if if for some reason you don't think that that movement is going to happen in a timely fashion to the next level you still have opportunities even with this removed I didn't completely hear what you said I'm sorry so you still have the opportunity to move transfer or not invite back teachers that aren't meeting the standard even with this removed I guess is what I'm asking right yes so on an individual Case by case basis right yeah okay understood thank you okay thank you for the question Miss Moran um on that same I guess I don't I don't clearly understand exactly how this is done but basically you're saying we want
103developing to mean there are things that that we are going to help you work on to improve but ineffective is really the first step out the door right and I think that you know when you talk about a firste teacher who comes into the classroom for them to come in and be even totally effective I believe would be more unusual than the norm because they still while they've prepared themselves they still have so many things to learn about the district that they come to ours in this case but they also have you know they had practice but it's been and in a student teaching situation so they always had someone there to support them so I think we we want to grow people we want to have an environment that Fosters Learning and Development and
104so to me it wouldn't be unusual for a new teacher to have developing if you were to see a large number of developing I think you would also see the ineffective because I think that if you had if you began to see a number of developing that person could also have some areas that would be ineffective which would lead us to um the plan for performance Improvement to show the support and uh then hopefully provide the tools that they might need to move from that developing level to the effective or maybe even to the highly effective understood thank you uhuh thank you Miss Wallace did you have any questions no questions thank you Mr Owens I have n thank you I do not either you already answered them so we are good to move on
105to the next one okay so I believe we're on to uh 4-14 employee discipline we uh do not have any recommended changes there when we move to 4-15 employee termination we would recommend the acceptance of the optional language under letters B and C regarding the issuance of a new written employment agreement this supports the end of the term employees notice of appointment but allows the district to rehire a term employee in a timely manner to retain that employee based on supervisor's recommendation so when someone is a term employee their their contract reflects that end date from whenever they started so they've typically started later in the year and then when we get to that that point their con their work agreement or their contract ends on that given date but they don't have the uh
106opportunity of continued automatically so we have to in essence rehire them and so this would allow us to do that in a more timely manner so that we can you know this is one more tool to help us with our retention I think when we as we work through that that's how I saw this so I'd like to recommend that we um accept that language so that it allows us to move more efficiently through that then under U should I ask do we have any questions on that one okay um then also under that one under letter D in paragraph number one I'd like to ask that we consider removing an independent non-district employee hearing officer appointed by the board revise the next sentence to read the hearing officer shall hold the hearing no later
107than 10 work days after the request for hearing is received and shall provide the employee at least five work days notice of the hearing uh date and then also that the hearing would be reported the language change would still retain the employees opportunity to have that heard by someone other than the immediate supervisor but it would be our next level of administrative person it would um you know it would take away quite simply would take away the cost of a hearing officer um and uh you know we would still have in place the same format where the employee has the opportunity to be heard but by someone above their supervisor and we would still record that so that we had uh the point of references that we need so I believe that would fulfill the
108intent of that policy but just not by hiring an outside uh hearing officer and I've had experience both ways and I think that either one would be acceptable uh for us if it met with your approval did you have a question on this one Mr I do I just have one quick question will is there or will there be training provided for administrators that were supervisors that would fit into this role so that if they have never done this before or whatnot they they would understand what's expected of them sort of what the policy states and then you know would have some support in terms of I mean obviously hearing officers do this all the time but in terms of our employees they might not is there training available that would get them up to
109speed that would be my thought that we would want to do that and that we would actually have and work with our leaders at higher levels about actually the format we would follow in a hearing of this nature about how the record would take place whether there was a need to transcribe the recording who was entitled to receive the recording so I would see it as a very um uh structured uh training that we would provide and um I think that would be good for all of our leaders uh to be aware of that and then if more is needed for those who would be in the position of hearing a case or a matter or concern that we had provided them with what they needed and I think that we could um my hope
110would be that we could always rely on HR for those supportive measures too uh as well as you know possibly even participating in the hearing just ensuring the format and everything so that it's structured yeah absolutely I agree I think that just helps with consistency and fairness across the board if different people are are providing that service to the district that no matter which department or supervisor you would go to that you would get you know a similar experience so agreed thank you M Miss Moran no questions Miss Wallace no questions Mr Owens no questions I don't have any questions either okay and then in uh 4106 we have no changes to recommend and the same is true as in 4107 related to reduction and force and Personnel records okay I think that's all of
111them if anybody has anything else otherwise we are good okay then we are going to move on to the next item which is the aggregate performance classifications of principles and teachers this will be continuing with Miss Sandy here okay so what we've provided for you is what we report to the state each year on the results of our eval valuation or summative evaluation outcomes and as you look at these you will we've shown you sorry as you look at these you will see that um we've provided you what the low and high scores are that are available for each of the ratings both for our principals and for our teachers um I believe I'd rather phrase that as our certified staff so um when you look at our principles the outcomes uh were highly effective
112for all 16 principles from last school year um also um when we go down to our teachers we do have 454 of our teachers who were highly effective 11 effective three developing and zero ineffective um we have been as I shared earlier in my conversation we've begun our work on the evaluation tools and we're also uh in relation to that we're also going to be doing some work on our performance pay plan so that we can work with our teachers and develop uh a plan that is reflective of outcomes of the the performance of The Learning of students um so we're just at the very beginning of that but that's another piece that we're looking at that you could see make a difference in our outcomes um I think one of the things that's very
113difficult when you when I think back over I've had the opportunity to work with performance play since its Inception and one of the things that I found is that as it's tied to money it it's very a difficult spot but it's one that we need to think about in our evaluation tools so that we really are supporting our teachers growth and ultimately supporting student learning and so you know we may see some changes in this in the future um our hope is that we would always have highly effective leaders and highly effective teachers but we know that we all have a learning curve and um so I I would take any questions you have on that I may have to ask for Dr doozy's support since I wasn't here last year but um happy to
114try to answer anything that you would like Miss Climer um I will tell you that this this chart has always given me pause because when I look at the low scores and the high scores for each section I'm concerned about how we came up with those numbers and I've never really been given a great answer and it it probably just going to be what it is but when I look at the low score of 184 out of 270 if you just do the math correct me accountant if I'm wrong it's about 68% so I'm just wondering how the low score is how we devise that score because if I think to myself someone who's scoring 184 points out of 270 that's not a great I would want them to have have and consider them highly
115effective just mathematically speaking um I don't know how this relates directly to you know the evaluation scores so there's a lot I'm missing and there's Nuance there so I guess I'm just asking how are the low and high scores determined for each one of those sections Dr do you see on that sure no problem can support us thank you Miss climber uh Madam President we were just speaking over here on when those cut scores is what we would call them were established and certainly from a historical perspective have been around for a long time um I think uh hence the work that you've asked me and our team to do do this year uh as part of my evaluation is and you can hear the conversation knowing that um we value an effective tool that
116leads to Quality feedback but also that allows us to put together a nice plan to get to that evaluation category where those two items also sync up right and um Can accurately reflect the performance of the individual yeah and so we know we have some work to do with that um not the best answer I wasn't you know just limited knowledge of when those cut scores were established I totally understand and like I said there's there's Nuance here that we don't see obviously and all 16 of these principles could have 259 points and it's not even a topic of conversation my thought is just as we always try and do be really transparent with community members and everybody when you know I think just an average person looking at this would think if my student
117is you know proficient in a a test they would clearly be expected to earn more than 68% of the points so I know that's not Apples to Apples but I'm just putting it out there as a as a um opportunity as we move forward with this evaluation how we categorize this um again I don't think it's going to change Who falls in what category necessarily um I think just from a transparency point of view how did we come up with these how are those cut scores cut scores developed and do we need to potentially look at them every couple of years based on how the evaluation you know evolves and Chang over time as well miss Moran yeah I agree I've had very similar commentary during this section of uh the this discussion for years
118um again it just doesn't reflect where we are when we look at either our grades our school grades from the Arizona Department of Education even our district grade if our district grade is a b we're saying 97% of our teachers are highly effective and we're a b how does that make sense so I understand that that this current scale was put into place because the goal was to pay our teachers as much as possible and so if that is our goal then we want everyone to be highly effective and we want to make the scoring doable to make that happen but I agree with board member climber that that doesn't actually reflect who we are now and so if we just want to give out the pay then let's change the score let's change what
119it's tied to let's give actual feedback that we can grow from and um be be constructive criticism to have that continual growth and development and Improvement and not necessarily penalize teachers for that but help everyone get on the same page again if that's our goal to just make sure everyone gets the most pay possible so I think we're on the same page with that and I just know that it's going to take time for us to get there because we've been talking about this evaluation and maybe how the evaluation process isn't as as impactful as we would like it to be so I guess my question after all that commentary my question is when we sit down here next year do we think we will have a better table that reflects actual performance or how
120long will that process be until we get to that point Miss Moran thank you for that question we will will certainly discuss this uh in our executive session on Friday as it's one of my goals and certainly I can catch the board up with where we are and and kind of what we anticipate seeing um projecting to this time next year because we're currently living in the same system this year the data we present to you this time next year will will be my guess is very similar plus or minus a few things I think we will then anticipate some changes after we go through the change to evaluation tool and process which we'll again to describe more um on Friday okay thank you so you would anticipate next year we will sit down and
121we will say yes we were using the same broken which is my words system and we will say yes this is what we are presenting you based on the previous year but going forward we have XYZ in place this is what we anticipate you know although we would love to have the same results um we don't think that that might be the case since the system will be changing okay thank you Miss Maran I would expect that answer to be yes however I'm going to throw caveat and I know Mr Owen isn't here but as we adjust our tool and as we adjust that process as we move into the spring it's very possible that I could ask him to run some some different numbers to see how things might look again that's in our
122current tool though so if the tool changes some we would anticipate some you know some different numbers but we might be able to run some uh some models thank you Miss Wallace I don't really have a question but I agree with the statements that were said um well I would love to be a district that has 500 or 454 highly effective teachers it's it's truly not reasonable to believe that that's true and no one is growing and developing and getting better from that I absolutely don't want to pay teachers less if this is just about their pay but it's not the the point of an evaluation is to grow and to and to better oneself and to have zero ineffective teachers and only three that are developing in the entire district is phenomenal but maybe
123not an effective representation of growth that could be happening so I'm very on board for creating an evaluation tool that helps teachers grow and better our students experience in the classroom as well Mr Owens yeah I don't think I can say what was said already any better um these numbers should probably be more accurately reflected or similar to what we see in kind of student um scores and letter grades for our school and District as well so yeah exactly what was said previously I fully agree with I just want to say that we were told that to expect a brand new teacher to not be developing is unrealistic so we know we have a lot of new teachers so this obviously doesn't accurately reflect what we were just talking about previously so um I'm excited
124to see these changes finally happening because some of us have been talking about redoing this evaluation tool for maybe the whole time we've been on this board so um I'm very happy to see that we're making progress I'm looking forward to our conversation on Friday to hear more information and to see this actually happening but thank you guys for the information I understand you guys are giving us what you have and what's in place right now so obviously it's not anybody's fault per se um this is the same conversation we have every year when we get this information so I'm sure we'll have it again next year if it has to look the same so thank you guys can I add something else to the conversation um I just want to comment on um what
125was said earlier as well which is part of this process is going to be a cultural change of removing the stigma from developing or I mean ineffective let's leave that stigma there but developing effective and highly effective it's really changing the definitions of those and I think with this um District leadership you have set a culture of transparency and accountability and the ability for people to admit that they have room to grow and be welcomed that they will be able to show that growth and they don't have to always look perfect or always look like they know everything and so I know we're headed in the right direction with this but I do understand that that's going to be a cultural shift and a cultural change um but I really hope that we can get
126there because to uh president zaida's point in order for us to really um make those changes and make these evaluations as effective as possible and have that opportunity for real growth we have we have to be able to do that we have to be able to say as a new teacher we expect you to be developing because we know you have a lot to Lear learn so um I know that's going to be really challenging so um Good Luck you just need to tell them it's like our like K2 report cards that they all start out at like a two and they over time get better and it doesn't mean your kid is doing bad and we have to keep telling the parents no your kids are right on track that's where they're supposed to
127be so that's just how we have to get the teachers to understand it's the same thing okay uh next we're going to move on on to a very very quick conversation super fast uh the superintendent midyear evaluation is going to be on Friday and uh a question came to me I just wanted to get everybody's feedback here while we're all in the room of whether or not we need people so Dr Davidson has goals and they are tied to many different people in his cabinet that are all have responsibilities and making those happen do we want to have all those people at our meeting on Friday to kind of give us in-depth information on the top ICS or do we not need them because this is just the midyear review it's more of a informal
128conversation it's not like official this is what the scores are time I just wanted feedback from everybody else to tell our cabinet people whether they need to be there Friday or not I'll start I would say no I agree that it is a more informal conversation and we don't need specific concrete evidence provided by those people at this time okay Miss climber yeah I think on a whole I agree with that I think if there is um someone you feel could be a better representative of the information right if you're not in the Weeds on that and you think someone else could better give that update I I think invite them but as a whole I mean I would only do that on a caseby Case basis but I mean I think as a whole
129it is more a conversation on you know how the goals have been going making sure you're interpreting them in the way that they were designed right this is the midyear point so if if you're if you're off on this tangent and we're like no no like we meant this kind of thing to me that's this that's the check-in here so I don't think we need you know tons of artifacts and evidence of every single thing you've been doing but more a conversation of this is where we've been headed headed these are the roadblocks we're seeing this is what we expect to see over the next you know semester um so I would leave that at your discretion but I would say as a whole no Miss Moran yeah I agree and I even think well
130I agree primarily because this is going to be the mid year so it really should be as board member cler stated a conversation as to where you are and where we're heading I think even at the end of the year if we're given the evidence in advance we and we have the opportunity to ask follow-up questions maybe you would have depending on who it is um you know a Cabinet member or two available by phone but everyone has job has jobs to do so I don't want someone sitting there for four hours waiting in case the board has a question we should be able to get our questions in advance if we get the evidence in advance to know what those follow-up questions might be um so that's I think a better use of everyone's
131time um for the for the for the year-end review um but for this one yeah I think we go through the process proc and then maybe we learn more about things that we're going to want to know more about for the end of the year as well Mr Owens yeah executive director Stone has to attend no I'm just kidding whoever I I agree I I don't think it's Mission critical I think we want to be um have a conversation um if if there's anybody you think needs to be there to support or back up any you want to present sure but um I'd much rather do it quicker and more informal and and Save You All some time and let you get your Friday work done and yeah I am in agreement I think that
132we're okay to just have that informal conversation and I think that will lead us to know maybe more of what we need at the end of the year even so uh that's kind of where I'm at so if everybody's agree with that that's great we'll just plan on that you all have your Friday to continue your work well who thought Friday the 13th was a great day for Carter's first official evaluation I don't think that was like some great planning on our that was Miss Contra over there I I I not do but we all we all voted and approved it so I mean I guess we have we did Ian we went through many stages I guess that's the only time we all had uh together was Friday the 13th so should be fun
133it's gonna be great miss climber just you know I'm going to be making that Mark on Miss Contra evaluation [Laughter] just okay so uh president itema from a logistical standpoint for us board members do we need to have anything prepared in advance um for Friday's meeting okay so what I would ask of everybody for for that meeting is that you've gone through we've received uh Dr Davidson's self- evaluation um go through it yourself and kind of think about where you are with things and bring that ready to go when we meet on Friday I'm not collecting everybody's scores and stuff this time because this is really meant to be an informal conversation but I do want to make sure you guys know where you feel he lies on all the different items and then we
134can kind of use that as our jumping off point when we are going through this stuff in the meeting on Friday um it would have been sent out a few weeks ago uh I think it was a separate email just with the stuff but I bet Miss Contra can send it out again to everybody awesome she will send it out to everybody again so that makes it easier just to see it but yeah if you guys can just go through that before Friday and then we will try to be as efficient with our time as possible that day I do know Miss Wallace has a hard stop time so we're going to try to get done by 11 is my goal actually so um if anybody else does anybody else have anything else on this
135topic no no okay well then we are going to move on to reports we'll start with Dr Davidson thank you Madame President uh we'll start by wishing our board our staff and our students and Community a happy holiday season um my hope is that all find time to relax reflect and prepare for the upcoming year of 2025 um we'll also give a shout out to our students and staff for their efforts during this midyear assessment time we're excited to see all that our students are learning and uh you know we can reflect a little bit as well from the beginning of this meeting how about those kids um just it was fun to celebrate our students um this evening also a big congratulations goes out to our three teachers who either earned their national board
136certification or maintained their certificate so we have two Educators over at mbel pageant Elementary Shannon laade and Jaclyn Wagner as well as Jamie Stewart one of our instructional coaches so congratulations to those staff members and to continue celebration I'd like to highlight Mr Stone I mean Dr Eric Stone um completing his educational doctorate through Grand Canyon University congratulations Eric and last but not least again miss Climer thank you again for your efforts on behalf of being a school board member and please note as we leave tonight and we do have a piece of cake for each of you if you choose on behalf of that celebration so thank you madam president okay thank you we're going to move on to board reports I'm going to let Miss clber go last um but I will start
137with Miss Moran all right um over the past month I was able to volunteer at two Thanksgiving feasts uh one at Western Sky Middle School and the other at Mabel pageant Elementary both of the events were very well-run kudos to our food services department especially Dr Mary and director Carl as well as all the student volunteers who served um both events were also well attended and thank you to all of the parents grandparents and the siblings who came out to enjoy a time of gratitude and celebration at our schools Thanksgiving feasts are an example of family support and connection throughout our district and I am always excited and honored to be a part I also attended two School showcases um one at bado middle school and the other at Wigwam Creek Middle School thank you
138to principal pedano and principal Rosenthal for providing us with more information about the day-to-day operations student data and culture on your campuses it's always a privilege and learning opportunity when we get to hear directly from the students in our district I also had the usual meetings with Dr Davidson and the Lichfield Educational Foundation this month I am looking forward to attending many holiday events in the coming weeks especially the parade on Saturday and I hope that all of our l79 family and Community have a safe and relaxing winter break as reiterated by Jose Feliciano in the holiday classic felis Navidad felis Navidad pric I want to wish you a Merry Christmas from the bottom of my heart Miss Wallace um I don't have much to share and I will keep it quick so that Miss
139climber can have my time but I also was able to attend the verado Middle School showcase and it was great to see the things that are going on there and see the classrooms and and plans for the future there so that was a really good experience and I am shocked that we're already a week and a half away from being halfway through the school year it's flying by and I wish everyone a Wonder wonderful holiday season Mr Owens um yeah as far as activities I attended the Vado Elementary School turkey Feast um I first started off eating with my kindergarten daughter and that was exciting watching her go through the school line and get her lunch and um and then after that I volunteered I ended up on milk Duty handing out um asking if
140they wanted chocolate or white milk a lot of chocolates all the adults wanted chocolates um Dr Venable and her team did an AM amazing job um the food was delicious I had two um I probably would have had three but they were kicking me out and so I just think it's cool that we were able to do that at all the campuses and have the parents involved and watching the kids eat with their parents it was it was pretty really cool experience um I also want to congratulate Dr Stone on defending his thesis I can't wait for a summary of your um thesis and why you know K8 might be the best model to go to um lastly board member climber two years on the board together I can't believe it's already been two years
141this is crazy like this insane I don't know maybe hopefully like eight years will fly by fast for me too um but I I appreciate I've learned a lot from you um your thoughtful questions um you're much better at words than I am so uh I I learned a lot and I respect you and I appreciate you over the last years and best of luck um with open Tuesday days the rest of your life okay um I was able to attend the vocabulary parade at Ranch of San Fe I know we have a lot of schools that do that it's a super fun event I think it's great whenever schools do things that have families come out and get to engage on their campuses and see what their kids are doing and vocabulary parades are
142super fun because the kids have to make their costumes I love that Rancho says you may not buy something you must make it um my daughter did popcorn and we were making a whole shirt that looked like it was it was a lot but it was fun and we had a good time and I love seeing all the costumes and the creative ways that the kids come up with to display their words um I also was able to attend two of our school showcases at verado middle school and wigon Creek middle verado middle school I appreciated hearing the stories and the poems and the play scenes that the students had written and were're receiving awards for uh the story that one of the girls wrote was very scary but very well written um but I
143was not prepared but it was a great story she did a great job as a writer I was very impressed um and then at wig Creek Middle School are talking with the students they gave us some of the most thoughtful and just amazing answers I think all of us were practically moved to Tears by their raw feedback about um the importance of mental health and being kind to one another and the challenges that middle schoolers face and how they can and sometimes don't help each other but ways that they feel like they could do better and um one of the things they brought up was the Care Room which I don't really hear a lot of students talk about how great the car room is especially at the middle school and they don't have it
144there anymore which was sad to hear that they were missing it so I'm hoping we I know they were kind of brainstorming some other ways to help kids but um it was just really great to hear the ways that they were helped by that on their campus Because we did invest a lot in that when we had money from our Co funds so um I was glad to hear that it was helpful to the students there um also I was able to volunteer at barbari elementary for their Thanksgiving feast um they have the mut on a mission group of ladies come out that are the funniest group of women I've ever met they are hilarious we were dancing the YMCA and handing out food to the students and they were feisty bunch of people but
145they're great and this is the second time I've been able to work with them this year and it was super fun I also got to serve with Dr Davidson so it was nice to get to spend an afternoon with you and see all the families that come out I agree that having the families come out again another great way to get our families on our campus see what we're doing and really get invested in what we're doing on our campuses so um I attended coffee with the principal I've seen a lot of schools are doing that this year and I really like that we're doing that as an opportunity to have our families and community members engage with their principles on their campus uh the one I attended uh principal Zuniga had it specifically on
146safety she had Moss come out our director of safety as well as a police officer from the Avendale Police Department Department talk about the various ways that they are working together and things that they're doing on their campuses with their lockdown drills and their fire drills um and how we make sure to do these things at different times of the day at different places because we can't guarantee that we're going to have a fire at 8:30 in the morning every time right if something were to happen or when you might need a lockdown situation that could be when you're on the playground or in a classroom or at specials or at lunch and so she makes sure to offer different opportunities for the kids to practice these skills um I like the fact that as
147a district we are doing that notification ahead of time now because I feel like we have taken it we are making it not traumatic for our students anymore that was a concern I had before and sometimes with these drills that they can be very traumatic for students but when we're given a heads up and we can let our kids know the kids that that are going to be most impacted by that can be warned that that's coming and that this is what it means and I think that that's very helpful to them uh as a parent my student was involved at a lockdown drill at one of our campuses this past month month and it was a real situation not because somebody was you know harming any students there but it was it wasn't a
148drill and she knew what to do and she understood the importance of being out of the line of sight and so things that she said to me really were moving in a sometime it was kind of sad but also at the same time it made me know we're doing the right thing we're teaching the kids what needs to happen and when and they understand that it's important to take it serious so that was really good for me to see that even though I don't love that we do them I understand why we do them um I also yesterday was able to go to the oath of have my oath of office as along with Michelle Wallace and Scott mikees who are going to be our three new and continuing board members uh thank you to
149the admin team that was able to come out and be there to support us it was a good event uh I will miss superintendent Watson being in charge of that department when he leaves but uh I did appreciate like I said earlier his comments about how our most important constituents are the students and so it was a reminder to me of why I am here I am here for the kids I do that always for me students and what's best for them is at the Forefront of every decision that I make up here and every vote that I do I'm always considering what's in the best interest of students and I appreciate serving with a group of people that all feel the same way um I will miss miss climber being on our board as
150she leaves us but um I'm excited for our new board member coming on and what's to come and I do wish all our families and our staff a happy holidays as we head into that time I agree how are we halfway through the school year that's kind of crazy uh with that I'm going to let Miss climber round us out here this is my final board report so I get extra time just because I'm this is the last time you ever have to hear it so buckle up people um first I do want to start out um by saying I was not able to attend Thanksgiving feast just due to work scheduling this year and I really missed I really missed like being on the campuses U the food is delicious I will say Ryan
151I totally agree it's actually very good um and just seeing families come together and you have grandparents and siblings and aunts and uncles and all kinds of different people so I miss that this year but thank you so much to the food service department and everyone else that organizes that for our families I think it is really impactful in a good way for us to engage um and I want to say thank you to principal Rosenthal and her amazing staff at Wigwam Creek um for hosting our recent School showcase I you know I always enjoy hearing academic progress and how the school is doing um but in this case you know hearing directly from the students as you know we've heard earlier was so impactful they were such an impressive group of young people and
152I think it just gives me hope and I hope you know other people that are lucky enough to be able to hear them speak about their experience in Middle School really understand the challenges that our students go through every day that our families are dealing with at home that our teachers are dealing with with kids in the classroom um and to just you know be kind and gentle with that age group especially because it is it is very delicate and can be challenging um okay so that's the official board report so here here's the here's the real the real meat on the bone um I typed this out because I knew I can I can talk off the cuff and if you think this is long my off the cuff is way longer so you're
153welcome in advance for typing this out um K are going to miss my jokes tell you I I hope Scott is as funny as I am okay all right so I just want to take a few minutes right to share some thoughts as I celebrate my last public board meeting tonight I re wrote and rewrote this report a few times uh trying to figure out how to squeeze everything that I have loved about the last nine years into just a few lines the accomplishments the learning and growth I've experienced the things I'm most proud of as with most really important things words just don't seem to do it justice I've opted to keep things brief in Daniel's terms but I'd like to share a few of my thoughts as I close out this chapter uh
154first is gratitude I'm so very grateful for this experience that was given to me by the voters our district our students and families and my fellow board members I leave here tonight with a full heart truly feeling grateful for the people I have met the memories I have made and the lessons that I have learned it is with heartfelt gratitude that I say thank you um number two is growth this job has pushed me in so many ways is I have learned to navigate difficult times and toine Common Ground I have learned that things aren't always what they seem so always assume positive intent I have learned there are very special people that dedicate their life to public education and I've been lucky enough to work with so many of them and probably most importantly
155I have learned to stay calm to trust in my colleagues and always go the extra mile because I've never regretted it um friendships one of the perks I didn't plan on in this job um was the friendships that I made along the way I find the people that make up this District at all levels to be kind compassionate enthusiastic and full of life and I walk away tonight with lifelong friends and colleagues that I will continue to cheer on for many many years to come one of my primary goals when I accepted this governing board position appointment all those years ago was to leave elld just a little better than how I found it well this place has been has always been pretty amazing um but I do believe the district has made huge strides
156over the last nine years and I'm just really grateful I got to be a part of it all the Blood Sweat and Tears of our teachers and staff administrators board members students families and everyone that makes up LD should be so proud of our accomplishments and the fact that we did it together before I sign up tonight for the final time I'd love to say a few words to some specific people that deserve so much more than this board report recognition can give them but here we go anyway um to Dr Davidson thank you for taking a chance on us we were lucky to snag you when we did um and as if you you have proven to be exactly the leader that we needed you to be a fearless leader who isn't afraid of
157change willing to take on the hard tasks and Empower your team to learn and grow excuse me to make this District better to serve our students I wish you continued success and hope that you will continue to challenge the status quo and grow LD until the district into the district we've all dreamed of to the administrative cabinet what a Powerhouse group of professionals you came together with little experience as a team and began to create a culture of respect and accountability I so excited to see what you guys are going to achieve and I am truly your biggest fan I can't wait to see what you have in store next for this District as the sky truly is the limit to Ryan and Michelle I am so Greatful I got the chance to work with
158you both our time was relatively short but I'm so excited to see the work you two will bring to this District in the future you have both put in the work to be active and engag board members and keep the great representatives of and and be great representatives of every aspects of our community keep up the good work and thank you so much for your dedication to Melissa and Kim it's been one heck of a ride I don't have the right words to express my respect and and admiration for you both your work ethic your integrity and your willingness to step into the fire only to come out stronger on the other side is remarkable we've learned so much together we've agreed disagreed and discussed until we were blue in the face only to come
159out with solutions that were collaborative constructive and added values to our teachers students and family am thank you just doesn't seem like enough to Scott mikees and our future governing board members that have the opportunity to sit up here buckle up the fun is just beginning I'm so glad you've accepted this challenge this has been one of the best experiences of my life and remember you will get out of this job what you put into it so good luck to our L Community teachers staff families students thank you for trusting me with one of our most precious resources your children you have allowed me to stand up for this community in ways I didn't know were possible I have met you along the way in different places and spaces and will cherish those times as
160I move on to become a supportive Community member who logs on to YouTube every Tuesday night I am grateful for you for your trust over the years and I hope I have served you well so I've reviewed all the positive takeaways for my time here on the board all the things I'm grateful for and all the positive memories I'm walking away with there's one part of this job that is still important to recognize there will always be naysayers no matter how hard you work how many emails you return or meetings you take it will never be enough there is not enough time to address every concern the way you want to not enough patience to deal with forces that don't really want what's best for this District um and its students but rather what works
161best for them and certainly not enough money to fix all the Pains of the public school system but for those of us crazy enough to jump into the arena and really get our hands dirty my heartfelt thanks and appreciation so in closing I want to share one of my favorite quotes um that I think pretty much sums up my feeling for this entire experience well there's a lot of quotes but this is the appropriate One That I Can Say on YouTube um it is not the critic who counts not the man who points out how the strong man stump or where the doer of Deeds could have done them better the credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood who strives valiantly
162who HS who comes up short again and again but there is no effort without error and shortcoming but who does actually strive to do the Deeds who knows great enthusiasms the great devotions who spends himself in a worthy cause who at the best knows in the end the Triumph of high achievement and who at the worst if he fails at least fails while daring greatly so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid Souls who neither knew Victory nor defeat thank you I'm gonna beat Ryan to the punch are we ready no thing I have to our administrators report oh my gosh I'm so sorry administrators go ahead okay so uh thank you to our administrators that turn in the reports and I just wanted to do a shout out to Jenny
163tassen from transportation and looking at the fact that we literally have had hardly any routes canceled so yay for transportation like that is amazing and that's a testament to the work that her and her whole team are doing so thank you thank you thank you um I mean I as a parent can tell you my Bus shows up on time every time which never happened last year the entire year so woohoo um but thank you to everybody else that turn in the reports we really appreciate them again community members read them that's how you know all the ins and outs of what's going on in the district and all the good stuff and all the details it's super great information thank you guys for turning in into us we do appreciate them very much and
164with that I'm going to hopefully have Danelle make a motion tonight if she can I move to adjourn my final board meeting at LD I second that having a motion from Miss Climer and a second from Mr Owens I will call for the vote Miss Climer yay Miss morand yay Miss Wallace yay Mr Owens yay I'm also a yay motion passes this meeting is adjourned thank you for joining us tonight guys