CorpusRecord 162552

Roosevelt School District No. 66 Governing Board Meeting - Jan. 7, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Roosevelt School District No. 66
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Maricopa County, AZ
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,149 words · about 101 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001happy New Year as previous Clerk and vice president of the board I will be presiding over this meeting since the term of the previous president Shelley Jackson ended last year we will proceed with the election of new officers shortly I call this Mee to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance in a moment of silence you may be seated next on our agenda we have the swearing of our new board members Mr Michael buts Miss Victoria cash Coro and Miss Tatiana Pena and I'll pass it to our superintendent Dr Portillo thank you thank you uh uh board members executive team Roosevelt Community um our board members have already been officially sworn in um as new board members by the Maricopa County Superintendent but we will ceremoniously SAR them in tonight as it is tradition

002in our district so we would like to have all board members come to the front um and then our new board members will be Sor them so all yeah let's all go to the front and our Deputy s so I will lead uh the new board members in taking their both and we will pin each of them and then we will pause for pictures all right if you can raise your right hand please all right so repeat after me I state your name do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and laws of the State of Arizona that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them against all enemies both foreign and domestic and I will faithfully and impartially discharge the duties

003of the office of Roosevelt School District governing board member Roosevelt School District governing board member according to the best of my ability so help me God I do affirm thank you e e e next item on the agenda is 1.04 recommend that the governing board approve the agenda is there a motion to adopt the agenda items as presented or are there any items that need to be pulled for further discussion Madam clerk um before we continue into the adoption of the agenda I do have an item that I would like to pull off the agenda By Request of administration um which is item 1.07 and it will be Place back in the next um governing board meeting that's taking place on January 21st perfect thank you is there a motion to adopt the agenda with

004item 1.07 being pulled I Mo we adopt the agenda with that adjustment second all those in favor I I any oppos motion carries next item on the agenda is roll call Mella can you please thank you madam clerk um roll call for this evening's regular meeting January the 7th 2025 I will begin with Mr Michael butes buts I'm sorry Mr buts Michael buts just say I I um I just want to say that uh I'm um excited to uh excuse me Mr Butz we just do a roll call so just say your pres sorry okay next we have Dr Megan frankowitz here Dr Ashley Hajj here Miss Victoria Coral present Miss taana P present Madame clerk we do have a quorum present for this evening's regular meeting thank you next item on the agenda is

005item 1.06 is the governing board reorganization for 2025 which is the first one their business is to elect our President and Vice President according to policy BDA board organization meeting we review the policies related to the board organization so according to our policy the board must meet in January following an election If the previous president president is present they will preside and our case is the clerk from the previous board to preside as we will learn that the the vice president assumes the duties of president when they're not Pres present now we review the policy and roles of board officers policy bdb board officers the duties of the president at Roosevelt School District is to conduct meetings in accordance to student outcome focused governance consult with the superintendent on behalf of the board maintain order

006in the meetings and oversee the board calendar duties of the Vice President are to act in place of the president when absent to ensure counting and recording time to monitor the amount of time spent on student outcomes support the president and prepara and preparing for the board meetings at this time would someone like to nominate a current board member to assume the role of president for the Rosevelt School District governing board for 2025 I'd like to nominate Dr Ashley hod for president are there any other nominations I accept a nomination or sorry is there a second Madam clerk if I can have a second and then my apologies I second thank you I accept the nomination all those in favor of me being the president please say I I I any oppose motion passes thank

007you I look forward to working with all of you at this time with some of my to nominate a current board member to assume the role of vice president for the Roseville School District governing board for 2025 I would like to nominate Dr Megan frankwit I second I accept the nomination all those in favor of Dr Megan frer Woods being the vice president please vote I I any oppos motions Carri welcome VP thank you so much appreciate it looking forward to serving on the board thank you the next item on the agenda is to recommend that the governing board approve the minutes held on December 3rd Madam CLK um at this moment that item was pulled off so we yes you're right thank you student outcome Focus governance is the next item on the agenda

008see have and I would like to get the presentation up give me one moment in 2023 the board embarked upon the journey to align our framework at the board level with the incredible word that happens every day in the classrooms with students at the center as a reminder the entire RSD board is committed to engaging our South Phenix community in gathering meaningful insight the board you see on this slide was the Catalyst for this framework and we're excited to continue the work with the new board members who were sworn in today RSD vision is a community to sorry Community United to create better futures for all through education student focused student outcome Focus governance um is our focus on improving student AC academic ACH aient success to research-based policym and decisions to increase learning outcomes

009based on the community's values envisioned for the district the school board will set goals and guard RS for reaching that Vision in short student outcome focused governance means that the board puts students out cones in its success first in every single decision that we make through this framework we have adopted board behaviors that emphasize Synergy and teamwork to Define our vision and goals this approach helps us to set clear targets student outcomes establish core values to identify our non-negotiables and Implement measures for progress and accountability to monitor where we are and where we're headed our ultimate aim is to enhance Student Success achieving these goals requires effective systems and processes as well as your voice advocacy and encouragement or and engagement Advan so what that looks like in practice is 60% of our time in

010board meetings are spent on student outcomes um we adopt the budget that prioritize adopted goals and guard rails the superintendent evaluation is focused on adopted goal adopted goals and guard rails our conduct as a board is rooted in our guard rails RC communic Community collaboration and Collective vision and we increase our two-way communication regarding goals and guard rails in alignment from the classroom to the living room and if you're not familiar with our goals who go over our academic goals that we adopted 45 and five the percent of fourth grade students that score meets grade level or above on AA Ela will increase from 20% on August 2023 to 45% by August 2028 the second one the percent of fifth grade students that score meets grade level or above on AAA Math will increase from

01111% on August 2023 to 45% by August 2028 the percent of seventh graders that score meets grade level or above on AA Ela will increase from 22% on August 2023 to 45% by August 2028 and the last one the percent of 8th grade students that score meets grade level or above on aasa math will increase from 12% on August 20 23 to 45% by August 2028 our Bard guard RS gu number one healthy board conduct and discourse gu number two board operating procedures guard R number three student outcomes Focus decision- making guard Number Four Financial integrity and guard rle number five Community engagement so these guard rules are how we decided that we wanted to govern ourselves we will be discussing this more in depth at our study session on on January 21st please join

012us and then our superintendent has guard r g number one in attaining the board student outcome goals the superintendent shall not go without proactively sharing updates and plans on budget or enrollment that will change the current landscape and stability of our district to stakeholders including board members students parents staff and community members guard number two in attaining the board's student outcome goals the superintendent shall not fail to consider the climate survey results to ensure a holistic approach to student development addressing academic social emotional and the physical well-being which includes after school programming and wraparound Services guard number three in attaining the board's student outcome goals the superintendent shall not allocate District budget resources in a manner that does not prioritize and support student outcome focused goals ensuring that the financial decisions directly contribute to the

013academic and devel de developmental success of all students gu number four and obtain the board student outcome goals the superintendent shall not fail to implement and maintain effective strategies for the retention and development of teachers including promoting from within to ensure that they have a positive impact on students as evidenced by data and the last guard for our superintendent in attaining the board student outcome goals the superintendent shall not fail to ensure progress toward existing atsi and CSI status which ensures students with special needs and English Learners in African-American students receive Equitable access to highquality instruction resources and support services tailored to their unique needs to promote their academic success in overall development so as a parent student Community member or a part of our staff you can join our board meetings the first Tuesday

014of every month and it's so nice to see a packed room tonight um so thank you all for being here and you also can hold us accountable um to the goals and guards that we have adopted and help us move our students forward and with that being said I will pass it to our superintendent thank you Madame President members of the board executive team and Roosevelt Community um in guardrail number two um it is emphasized that we have a holistic approach towards student development including an emphasis in physical well-being our District offers physical education at every campus as well as inter Scholastic Sports in December we held our District's Division 1 and division two boys teams and girls teams playoffs and Championship Games Dr battle and Mr oel will lead us in celebrating our winning

015teams and our staff okay Vanessa slide over here this is the right spot for it okay Madame President okay I'm just going to you are now the board president I was running around back there yeah congratulations than mam president HJ members of the board uh Dr Portillo Dr battle executive team we had a very exciting basketball season that wrapped up just before winter break um at times basketball could be a little too exciting uh the principles could tell you that um but I want to just share quickly about the sports season um I have a picture for us too we made two changes uh to the sports season um if I could uh for our new board members share a little bit about um some of the changes that we made a lot of it

016was wrapped around the core values um mainly um this idea of collaboration um this idea of inclusion to make sure that all students there was more playing time more participation we were hoping for more sportsmanship which we also got um so we had a regular season that had no bearing on the playoffs um and that allowed for our coaches and our players to not feel this pinch of like oh we got to make the playoffs we got to play we we just like have to win this game um teams and players don't have to worry about the making the playoffs matches could focus on skill development sportsmanship and learning the game second we split our tournament into two divisions based primarily on School enrollment everyone made the tournament and every team received a minimum of

017two games no matter what this gave more opportunity for schools to make what we call like our Saturday which is our Championship day it's a big deal um I want to give a thank you to South Mountain High School for hosting our Saturday championship games they did not charge us for the rental we just paid a small maintenance and security fee yeah I also want to uh thank our district Sports Coordinator Marvin petett this is him right over here his uh day job is PE teacher at Campbell which he's also excellent at And he moonlights as all things logistics for sports including uh securing referees working with Transportation working with the SES boort coordinators um so at this time if we we have TG bar on Deck we are honoring the championship teams the most

018outstanding players in a new award the core values award where we honor teams and players that exemplify our core values such as collaboration kindness and integrity first I'd like to welcome our division 2 girls Champions that is the TG bar Thunderbirds coach and athletic director are here tonight as well as their principal Miss hagy with them also our special guest is the most outstanding player of the division 2 tournament this is Eve Sharp picture here too Eve this is the first of many photo opportunities for you in your career great and for our uh Team TG bar you guys can walk uh your team can walk around this way and then we can get our next team in here uh thank you so much to TG bar okay our champions for the division 2 boys

019game it is John R this cobras um unfortunately we do not have our uh tournament uh outstanding player quante Pride we do have the dream buau here of uh Mr ruus and Mr uh good Rich who are teachers at John R Davis this is their second straight Championship John R Davis was also the boys Champion for volleyball and with him is their principal Miss Tiffany Gilbert Mr Excuse me Mr sandbach and Mr slake thank you all right thank you team Davis whacking up championships thank you Mr sbach next the division one girls Champions the Valley View Eagles their coach is here today their principal is Mr Larry leice with them is seventh grader Payton baton the most outstanding player of the girls tournament is becoming a familiar face she was here in the fall as

020the volleyball most outstanding player and you couldn't be here tonight uh but Dr Wes little is the Sports Coordinator for valy viiew he was also the coach of the second place uh boys team valy viw is also second place in the boys championship finally our division W boys championship their entire I believe most of their team is here we just invited the most outsanding player in one email but there was another email that did say the team could come and it was buried so not only did they bring their whole team but they read their emails so the division one Champions the Sunland champions is their coach and Sports Coordinator mrisa their principal is Miss Amanda Hicks the most outstanding player of the tournament once again jiah Perryman Mr dve dures is here too Davey

021where are you will you raise your hand it was between Josiah and Davey they both were excellent players Sunland had an excellent season congratulations to them all right this one's going to take all right thank you to Sunland and if you guys would put a gap that all right finally our two core values Awards so uh once again these are new Awards um exemplifying um our core values we honor teams that uh showcase collaboration kindness and integrity among other core values uh there were two teams selected for basketball the first is the Percy L Julian Eagles the Eagles Sam at the same time voting was happening for the schools displ greatest sportsmanship the schools were selecting players from their own teams that displayed the core values the two School the two students selected from Julian

022were Elise Mahia Perez and Nathaniel Sierra give them a round of applause then finally uh Southwest School our other core values winner let's give the Southwest a big round of applause Southwest received a bunch of love from other schools they were Far and Away the leading vote getter for the division one core values award the two students representing Southwest today are lesie Bernal and Gabrielle Luna here here with Southwest to we have assistant principal Tim Garcia as well as their principal Miss bario all right thank you so much let's give Southwest one more round of applause I just want to and we are going to get to academic achievement here in a second but we're going to have a little Logistics uh uh change here it just dawned on me that I've got three straight

023uh items here on the agenda um I just wanted to say thank you to everyone for supporting Sports and RSD the season um on last year's parent survey Sports opportunities was listed as the top priority for parents um we are especially I want to thank um all of our admin who are here the principles and assistant principles they stay late to supervise all of these sporting EV so let's give our principles and assistant principles a big round of applause I can say as a as a former principal that that is a really fun job except at this times that it's not uh so thank you thank you to our principles for staying late on Friday nights coming on Saturdays we really appreciate that okay so we are going to do a quick transition here I'm

024going to have um Miss Susa one of our teaching and learning Specialists um if we could have the teachers who are going going to be recognized um come to this hallway right here and we're going to have our students come back um to the lobby so if you are a teacher that is being recognized tonight if we can have you line up over here our students um if you're going to um line up behind the teachers and we are going to do our um we're gonna slowly transition to our next thing thank you president hjj thank you so much and congratulations to all of our Sports winners the next item on the agenda is 2.03 celebration of no year academic recognition thank you madam president uh members of the board executive team and Roosevelt Community

025one of our values is celebration as we progress forward in our academic goals we are pausing to celebrate both students and staff who demonstrated notable growth and or proficiency during our midyear December testing period Dr battle and Mr oo will lead us in celebrating our Scholars and our staff thank you Dr guo and also thank you governing board president Dr Hodge members of the board executive team and our amazing Community who's here tonight nights like this really are exciting that's why we're here right it's about the children and it's about what our staff and students excuse me our staff provides for our students to accelerate their learning so tonight we get to celebrate that and I'm honor honored to be able to do that with that said we're going to first recognize teachers that displayed

026exemplary achievement on the star winner assessment which is our Benchmark that predicts how well our students will perform on the aasa first we want to recognize teachers for incredible results on Star early literacy assessment and that's Martha Chavez and graciella regero from Valley View Elementary and also Grace Meyer 6% of students in kindergarten met their growth goal at valy View and 87% of students were proficient on the star early literacy assessment thank you so very very much next Jennifer Roman and Lydia Flores first grade teachers at Caesar Chavez come on out % of students at Chavez met their growth goal on the star math assessment and 76% of students were proficient Joseph R and Del m p teachers of CLE good to see you over 80% of the fifth grade students at Campbell met their

027growth goal on both the star reading and math assessment Campbell students also had the highest proficiency rate in the district on both fifth grade reading and math assessment congratulations next sixth grade teacher at VH Lassen come on up 96% of students at Lassen met their growth go in the star reading assessment congratulations and finally for our staff Jennifer Laughlin seventh grade teacher at VH Lassen 80% students in the seventh and eth grade met their growth goal on the star reading assessment congratulations oh yeah if we can have all the teachers come join we'll line you up and we'll do a group photo for to start off our 2025 all teachers that were recognized come on over please as they take this photo what a big thank you to the teachers in all of our schools

028in Roosevelt School District and we want to thank you for supporting the goals here in the district's mission this is good stuff next we are excited to share with you a sample of amazing students we have across our district these students displayed both high growth and high proficiency on both their star assessments all of these students were in the 95th percentile or higher for growth as well as scoring high proficient on their reading and math assessments first and foremost from Campbell Violet Panton greator TG bar Kay stum sixth grader from Bernard black Tristan figura seventh grader from TG bar Eileen Perez hold on okay eighth grader from Caesar Chavez Z G and congratulations to all of these students for their incredible work and progress during the first half of this year I would be remiss

029not to thank their parents for your support and all that you do with their thank you they're getting ready for this folo I also want to recognize Mr oo you're amazing thank you for making us all look good this evening we appreciate you and thank you principles and leaders for all that you've done as well to make this possible for our students and teachers you're welcome uh to stay for the board meeting we also have uh cookies for our students in the back if they're in left and a a place to take uh pictures in the lobby if you'd like thank you so much that's the best part of the meetings is being able to celebrate our students and our staff thank you again and congratulations the next item on our agenda I'll give everybody

030a few minutes to to settle out the next item on the agenda is item 2.04 progress monitoring Maye check and interim goals and I'll pass it to Dr Portillo thank you um Madame President members of the board executive team in Roosevelt Community like all other organizations focused on performance we are consistently keeping an eye on our progress we are now at midye our students took their test in December and we are utilizing those tests to affirm what we are doing well and what we necessarily need to uh shift as we approach mid year Mr O will be reporting to you how we are performing at midar checks towards achieving our fiveyear goals and I will chime in as needed okay okay thank you good evening again Madam president members of the board executive team again

031my name is Nick OVO I am in fact the director of research assessment and learning I just Moonlight as the district Sports Coordinator uh for Roosevelt um so uh excited to also uh share with you tonight about this um and this does tie uh pretty closely to some of the students that we just shared all of that was uh based on their midyear data okay so um I I share this each time um just want to Norm around um my role and and how our data discussions look um I want to share that this is more of a medical analogy I'm more about the diagnosis and we have a lot of really great people in the room uh that deal with the prognosis mostly the people at the Das here um so diagnosis identifies the

032condition prognosis predicts the future so when we get to questions um I'm happy to um answer questions but again um there's there's people more informed than I that will be able to answer some of those questions as well um I also want to add that this looks a little different than most of the other presentations that we do now in our um outcomes Focus governance um so we are doing a presentation like this three times a year where we look at Benchmark data um and then eight times a year we're looking at each of our specific goals um there's four goals we look at them twice a year I might be stealing Dr Portillo Thunder a little bit on that calendar but that's the that is the the rhythm of what we're trying to do

033here um as I mentioned mentioned I I mentioned a medical analogy I'm actually way more about the sports analogies um on the left you have uh this is Steve sarian the head coach of Texas Longhorns actually put in this slide before I knew that ASU was going to play Texas thank yeah let's get it out it's still it's still fresh um on the right you have the head coach of ignasio conchos that's Ben rote uh last year we took the halftime analogy to extreme and created a parody video of schools heading into winter break for halftime including sideline interviews like you see in the picture um the point is is that we're just getting out of halftime in Roosevelt School District um similar to sports it's time to look at the data reflect and then

034make adjustments and that's actually exactly what our teachers did yesterday so uh was a day of professional development a day of uh time to look at the data um I even got to hear from um Valley View and see their presentation and the data that they shared with their staff um and it was very data aligned and thinking about making adjustments which was great all right so what we're looking at today is our star midyear Benchmark data as Dr Portillo mentioned um so every district has um District benchmarks that help to inform their state assessment we use star which is a product of Renaissance um uh president Jackson if she was here would would and and we do this for our board governance is also always looking for the headline um and the headline for

035us is that we have good news to share um all of our proficiency is up and we're going to talk about also though how that aligns with our goals that we had set for 2028 our interterm goals um uh very ambitious goals to get to 45% um based on the goals that Dr hodj mentioned earlier okay so this slide I just want to give uh the community everyone just a a little star Renaissance 101 um so the left- hand side it just our types of Assessments again reading math and early literacy these tests are computer adaptive or otherwise known as Dynamic um if you've ever seen like the GMAT or the GRE these are uh tests that get harder or easier based on how the student is doing on the test so unlike your more

036traditional assessments not all students are getting the same questions um reading is a second through e8th grade assessment math is first through e8th grade early literacy is kindergarten to first grade we also have computer computer-based measures these are just a sample of them uh one is an oral reading fluency test that mainly our second and third graders take our uh students also take another test expressive nonsense words just to give a sample there's more um and they're typically all one-on-one assessments so on the right I'm looking at what a teacher would uh be looking at in their class the the colored squares uh speak to proficiency green highly proficient blue proficient yellow partially proficient red is minimally proficient um the scale score is more for the test makers to Define cut scores the the smaller

037number is percentile rank which is just a national rank of how that student where that student lands um across all third graders across the country so the top student would be in the 57th percentile among third graders nationally and then finally we're looking at on the other side is the oral reading fluency so I can see that on uh for the first student hasn't taken it since August 19th um but the second student took it on December 11th they read 142 words per minute um and this is helpful for a number of reasons so I could look at this and see um I'm looking at the fourth student down or excuse me the third student down 143 words per minute very fluent reader but scored partially proficient um so as a teacher I would be

038thinking that I have a fluent reader but there are obviously some comprehension apps and then there's more data that they can go and look at um what standards um are students um struggling versus showing strength so a lot of really great assessment uh data that we get um in December for our midyear Benchmark okay so I'm going to show you some um of our big picture districtwide data next and this is for our reading data again second through 8th grade so this graph showcases how students did from last year compared to this year the purple is our 23 24 um our green is uh our current year our students can actually take this test as much as they want and we try to have our schools as much as possible take this test once a

039month it's not a very long test um but we're really looking for Benchmark data at the beginning of the year middle of the year and end of the year and track the uh percent completion across the district um and this way we're able to have some normed data and so you can see here that as a district 2nd through 8th grade started the year higher in August and are continuing that ascent and continue to be slightly higher than where we were last year in terms of reading proficiency that's just to say that this is this is the current number where we stand right now in the winter of this year and I put an animation in there all right next up this is our reading proficiency across student populations across the entire District again purple

040last year and uh green teal is the current year both winter data okay this is my pause to talk about student growth percentile we just talked about proficiency and I want to talk about student growth percentile just a little bit um it's a very important uh data point um not necessarily that we know exactly what student growth percentile does but for K8 schools um student growth percentile represents 50% of our letter grades on ASA um so it is very important to at least have a working understanding of it and to know how it impacts um our report cards and our letter grades um so this is a an example of uh visual of what growth percentile looks like so imagine in the middle second dot in the middle there before it fans out is a

041whole bunch of students took a test and they all scored exactly the same then the next year all those students take the sixth grade test they were fifth graders they all scored the same we're comparing how did those students who scored the same in fifth grade do in sixth grade compared to their peers so obviously higher is better um we recognize students today who are all in the 95th percentile or higher for both which is to say for us from fall to winter that they showed some of the greatest growth uh possible among their peers and again this is what the state is using this number um in terms of our growth score for our state letter grade uh star this test does it as well so it's a great helpful tool on Star to

042see how our students progressing compared to their like peers okay so again this is our reading proficiency scores and I just very very quickly want to show a comparison of our SGP so again standard growth percentile this percentage represents the students who made the percentage of students in our district who made average or high growth so it's combined um and it's not it's the the bar is the 35th percentile so if you're in the 35th percentile or higher for growth um then you meet this number so as a district right now we're at 59.4% you heard in some cases today there was um teachers who had 80% 90% of their kids who were in just high growth um so we have pockets of great success um and right now you can see that um we're

043hovering just about the same as we were last year and again this is a comparison just to give you an idea of um SGP in terms of population as well um if if I may so again the uh the student growth um uh Pro um percentile percentile is really important for us to look at because we if we were running a race um and we all had different starting points we want to make sure that that whoever's at furthest away from the finish line that they're progressing at a faster rate that they're progressing at a faster rate so that's why it's important for us to track this because we want to have more students at least at average growth but we really were trying to hit the highest growth possible because we're wanting to close

044that Gap right between um where they are and then where the rest of the peers in the state are um so that's why it's an important measure for us to be looking at and for us to track as a district as we are um we have a long ways to go to reach our five-year goals so we can't just progress a little bit each year we have to progress at fast rates in order to close that Gap so that's why we track that individually by student then uh by by classroom by grade level and as a district thank you Dr poro um mam president Dr Boro that's a a great time for me to U mention too that last year we had two schools Cesar Chavez and percel Julian who what we say maxed out

045on their points they received the full 50 points um for growth and what's nice about the SGP is that um even if you have a lot of students who are minimally proficient coming into the year it is comparing you to those students who are also minimally proficient and where Julian and Chavez did so well was getting a lot of high percentage of their minimally proficient students to make high growth um which is why they had such high growth scores um so um it it's all about moving students no matter what level they're on and and getting them to show significant growth okay so I'm going to go through the same for math uh this is 1 through eth this time so our first graders take the math test um again our percentages very similar to

046what we saw from Reading um starting um just a little bit bit higher but then making slightly more growth um you can see that that line is is not parallel um there's a slightly higher increase in percentage from fall to winter than we saw last year and um to share with the SGP scores again very similar um so the growth really about the same um with students who are coming in a slightly higher proficiency as a district slightly higher proficient excuse me and this is math proficiency by um student population I just want to note too that um in parentheses on the bottom this was true for reading too uh represents uh what we call our end count or just the number of students that we have who took the test so that's our um

047first through e8th grade students by student population who took this assessment and then here it is again for SGP I took the end count number off this is getting way too technical but I took the end count numbers off because SGP measures students who took both the fall and winter test so those numbers are going to be slightly smaller because not every student took both assessments all right and finally early literacy data early literacy is kindergarten in first grade this is um foundational reading skills so where our reading test is more comprehension based um this is um more um phonics phonemic awareness uh letter um uh site words I'm looking over at Miss Susa can I get like a thumbs up yeah that our K3 expert is here um so um this is just again

048for kindergarten and first grade and here is our uh proficiency and then I'm going to show SGP for our winter as well so a big increase um not only is is 49.1% um significantly higher than uh last year it's it's really we're at the highest we've ever been um for early literacy on Star so that is a big uh a big um celebration and um again ASA is just third through e8th grade so we won't see this success this year um but we really are um as a district building a great foundation for um years to come as these students move into third grade and then again SGP nearly identical in terms of the students percentage of students who are making average or high growth I'm going to switch gears uh uh president Hajj uh

049just mentioned our board governance goals but I put it in here um just to very briefly talk about um uh our goals and where we stand on what we have as our interterm goals so on top of having 2028 board goals we also have goals that uh help us to meet these goals this year so for instance for fourth grade if we want to be at 45% in fourth grade we really need to be thinking about our first and second grade cohorts um so there's those percentages again freezing up here there we go and I want to share just where we at are with some of our interim goals at halftime so the First Column is is the goal that we set for ourselves that we wanted to be at um when we got to

050the midyear Benchmark uh the second column represents the the third column represents the percentage where we stand and the fourth column represents last year's percentage which is what was our percent proficiency at this time in the winter and then the final column is the schools that did meet that percentage goal that we set and again we set very ambitious interim goals because we have a very ambitious uh 2028 Target goal so in order to get to um 45% we're definitely going to need to see movement in our early grades for example for that fourth grade ELA test and we are seeing that I think again most significant is our first grade early lit um at 45.6% um last year that kindergarten cohort showed a lot of positive gains so it's it's really nice to see

051that um that is continuing so I I would just like to note that um as we sent as we set the midyear benchmarks for this year the goals this is our first year doing this so we may have been overly ambitious we're calibrating right but we we believe our students can do this and so much more so with the efforts that we've made we've seen growth in most areas in comparison to where we were last year at this point we're not quite at where we had set our goals and it might be that our goals mid year were um maybe too ambitious but we wanted to be ambitious so that we could push our system forward so again it's important to note that we in comparison to last year at this point we're we're higher

052so we're getting better um I would like for us to to move to get better faster um but we are getting better our staff is working incredibly hard so that's why we wanted to include last year's percentage and it might be necessary to recalibrate our mid Year's goals um and in a couple of slides we're going to explain um part of change theory yes thank you so um this this part of change theory is the plateau of latent potential so it's important to note that most of the time when um a system is changing or growing um when we start we have these ambitious goals right and we would like the trajectory to go straightforward and very like like The Black Arrow that's that's symbolic symbolized there and um and that's where we would like

053to be but really um research shows that when um change is being implemented there's this kind of initial Valley of disappointment where we're creating um the uh the base and creating the systems to make um us be able to to do the right things towards reaching our goals and have the right practices in place towards reaching our goals but we're actually can expect based on Research a line that looks more like the yellow where it's more like it has a curve or an initial beginning where it's not quite um changing at the rate that we would like to see considering the effort and the investment that we're making in making that change so we wanted to bring that up because again this is research based and um based on unchange theory that what actually happens

054with most changes so I want us to um keep um pushing ourselves forward as a district and moving moving fast and growing at fast rates for our students and also want to be realistic and grounding ourselves that we may be just like most other organizations that experience change in this plateau of lat potential so I I I do want to appropriately um ground ourselves in reality while also continuing to push our system forward um if we don't push our system forward we're not ambitious then we will continue to replicate the same results we've had received as the past and we want to make sure that we are pushing kids forward pushing our staff forward pushing ourselves our board our parents our community forward as much as we can so anyways um not as an excuse

055but also but also just to ground ourselves in reality we wanted to bring up that this may be what we're experiencing since this is what most systems experience as they initiate change thank you Dr Portillo um and I would add to that like this graph there is results that are going up so we are seeing um positive results and we set linear goals uh that uh linear interterm goals towards our Target goal so this this uh really does uh match nicely with what is happening in Roosevelt um next up I'm going to talk about our SGP um interm goals so we also talked about setting a goal um and uh giving credit to board member Frank although I think this is the third time I've given you credit on this on this uh but it

056it was this was very wise and I'm going to paraphrase that uh what we were trying to do is also measure not just students who are making average or high growth but really tracking students who are making high very high growth 65 SGP or higher uh with the thought that in order to move a proficiency band from minimally proficient to partially proficient partially to proficient um that students need to make growth that is in the 65 65th uh standard growth percentile or higher that if students are doing that year after year um that they are going to get to proficiency so we want to celebrate um uh a number of schools and grade levels that had school that were uh grade levels with 45% or more of students at the 65th SGP um so I

057highlighted two uh we recognized Cesar Chavez their two teachers today for example 61 over 61% of students uh were met the 65th SGP or higher not just average or high growth but this is just high growth um and again uh Dr battle uh mentioned this with Lassen that Lassen was over 88% um of their sixth graders in math um so these are these are really um incredible numbers and this is pockets of of what we want to see more of obviously which is um teachers and grade levels making growth that is going to get us to um that 45% proficiency number and then I have just an asteris there that 30% of the students across the district were at or above that 65th percentile for SGP and then for reading um similarly um but I

058would say slightly higher 33% of students across the district scored at or above the 65th percentile that's pretty close in line to what would you would want for a standard Year's growth uh and I mentioned this back in I believe May that not only are we seeing higher Proficiency in reading but we have been seeing um a lot of a higher growth in Reading relative to math uh and Miss White attributed that to all of the work that has been happening in the lower grades with the science of reading um a lot of uh foundational reading work that has been happening at our lower grades um and again um we we recognized uh the two Lon teachers in sixth seventh and eth grade um for their outstanding work and and you can see there's there's

059a number of other um celebrations around the district I think it's again important to note that more than a third of our students across the whole District are reaching high growth so that's an important celebration for our district we want to increase that even further but to have a third of our students that does show that we're progressing in the right direction we just want even more kids than a third um as we move forward but a third is is pretty good considering we've implemented a lot of our changes only for a couple of years so yeah we're excited to see that um and really excited to see those first and second graders as they reach third grade um and then start showcasing um their strengths on the um double ASA assessment the state assessment

060when they become third graders um next up again this is a little bit uh getting into what I was mentioning earlier the prognosis uh uh piece um and so if you if you have questions about this I'm I'm happy to give it a shot we also have Miss Sarah Gomez and Miss Elizabeth Susa here from teaching and learning um they are very excited to take your questions uh if if there are especially about Ela and reading um we did have someone who um at the last minute was not able to come uh for math but again we're we're happy to answer uh questions if you have math content specific questions so for ELA and reading ongoing professional development connecting adopted instructional resources into reading into literature and writable those are some of our resources in

061third to e8th grade as designed for optimal Ela and writing instruction uh teaching and learning has had a big focus on writing this year uh writing a writing prompt is a piece of aasa um so uh that was kind of the the next step for us as a district to um have writing assessments um and more uh writing within our essential standards uh second modeling and coaching support for the implementation of inter readings structured literacy block with K2 teachers to enhance instructional practice aligned to the science of reading again our younger grades uh teachers have uh received a lot of uh professional development around the science of reading best practices and we're seeing a lot of great gain from that and then finally instructional planning to provide purposeful scaffolding for essential skills in reading and

062writing lessons during our professional learning teams and then moving oh excuse me and then um ongoing coaching and learning walks skipping over to math a focus on tier one instruction um this has been a big uh piece for teaching and learning and um I've uh I told Miss White many times that this is the right work is that we want to get that initial tier one instruction right and not bounce right to um intervention or trying to fill gaps that if tier one instruction from K8 is Good from the beginning we're going to see a lot of positive gains uh second continued engagement in professional learning teams uh that align with District pacing guides and the creation of unit plans that support teachers in meeting diverse needs of students during tier tier one instruction and

063a a lot of talk um in in our meetings with site leaders and across the district about Target task alignment um that what we are saying that we're doing is the work that is actually happening in the classroom and then uh finally for math learning walks to gather data provide feedback and refine instructional practices with what the work that we're doing with project momentum a lot of uh a lot of that work is universal it's for every content so you may have heard a little bit of overlap with Ela and math and that's true we've got a lot of um work going on that it transcends content that's all I have thank you thank you so much and now thank you questions from board members Madam president yes uh I don't have any questions but

064I did want to say thank you for taking the feedback into consideration on how uh some of the graphs were displayed and and respond to that feedback so thank you thank you I wanted to add to that too I I did give some feedback to the graphs ahead of time they were a little hard to understand at first so I really appreciate that you did make those adjustments thank you hi Mr AO um two things I wanted to just celebrate um one I just appreciate the focus on kind of trajectory changing growth because those are ultimately students who are going to move levels and grow proficiency so just appreciate us keeping an eye on that so that we can talk about growth but specifically who's growing um and then also just wanted to highlight for

065our new board members those coaching and learning walkthroughs I think um you know I know some folks have had a chance to go on those yet if you haven't um it's a really great way as a board member to be able to see that alignment from The Boardroom to the classroom so just uh plug for the learning walks um I have two questions that I think might be as you get your pen ready um I have two questions and some of these might just be actually a future study session because I know they're they're big complex topics but I think I would be curious to understand as we talk about our long-term strategy um one is we talked about the fact that you know 30% of our students districtwide have made that high level of

066growth um and I love that you named at Chavez you know we know that those are minimally proficient students who are growing um and I think the question of who are the students who are making really high growth are we moving low students to medium students and we know that our interventions in this those spaces are effective is it hey the high students keep moving and the low students aren't moving so I think just as a board the picture of like who is growing quite a bit and who is not growing um how that overlays with some of those numbers and some of those groups I think as we dive into future study sessions I'd be interested to learn because I think it also tells us what interventions what curriculum what spaces were really effective

067in so appreciate all that lens and you know sparked that question for me um and then this one is again I think another question that we may not be able to answer right now um I very much appreciate naming that you know I think in my experience as an educator and my experience is apparent takes a while before things take off and we feel that impact um but I also don't want us to be in a place where we look down the road and say hey we should have seen increases and we didn't and so we missed an opportunity to give feedback so I think then the question is if we know it's going to take a while for that growth to happen what are the indicators that we as a board are measuring to

068make sure that we're actually on track um and then we're not saying hey we thought it was going to be fine and then you know we were in the value of disappointment and then it becomes the plateau of disappointment so um just I think that's a question I have is like what are we then looking to to say hey are we on track or not because I think what concerns me looking at that data if it doesn't change is that the trajectory is not changing that line is at the same angle so as many kids are growing now as they were last year even though we started with that higher percentage so I think like underneath the surface what are those data points we're looking at to make sure that we're holding ourselves accountable um

069and then this is a quick hopefully a quick question but I'm I was really curious about um and this might be for the superintendent it might be for someone else but it looked like when we looked at the number of fourth grade reading schools that hit their goal it was seven and then fifth grade cre it dropped to two and so I was just curious if there's something in the school model or the grade levels that caused that to just be a different number or if that's just a you know trick of the data but wanted to just see if there was something that explained that difference numbers because I was really excited by that fourth grade number and fifth grade is is just about one year away yeah I would I would um I

070would highlight that fifth grade on that chart was the only uh had kind of the lowest proficiency increase actually maybe even a slight decrease and uh one of those schools we recognized Campbell um so Campbell and Valley View were the two and were pretty significantly higher above so it's almost holding up that uh that uh percentage this way you would see that in fifth grade we we talked about fifth grade I don't know if it was our November board report um that those that's a cohort of students that represents our uh students who started kindergarten virtually and then in first grade uh you know whatever that looked like that second year which was for me as a principal even more difficult and it just seems that that has been a cohort that's that's been a

071little bit low um proficiency wise and so that that is something that we've had an eye on and um last somebody can correct me on this but teaching and learning had uh been looking into PD specifically for our fifth grade teachers yeah I appreciate that point because I I do think you know there there's reasons why a specific Co might be low and then it's our job to use those reasons to find and identify those you know things that are going to help move them and so you know having a fifth grader at home like is that more funic support is it something else more strategic so just look forward as we unpack that one because I do think you know while we're saying hey our lower students or our lower grades as they move

072up will be that you know five and 45 and five group we also want to make sure we're doing our due diligence for those um older students as well so appreciate that context thank you and I'd like to say that um this midar check and focus on assessment um that we're this new practice that we're engaging in is really helpful because this is the moment where we start planning um how are you going to utilize our resources for the following year right so as we're looking at our student data and what our students are telling us that they need um through their performance then it helps to guide what are the plans how are we going to utilize our time our classroom schedules how are we going to use our resources to provide intervention for

073um for the specific cohorts that we see and in the specific areas that we see that that need is there so um that datadriven um uh allocation of resources is really important so it's it's just in time information I appreciate that thank you so much superintendent you have any questions um so for me thank you again for answering all the questions that the board members sent cuz some of mine were answered as well and I guess just a wondering that I have um what's working at Chavez and Julian for the the high growth and can we replicate that across other campuses yeah that's a great question probably a longer question I think that we could be happy to um without I don't want to call them to the table right now but for a future

074one we I we would absolutely do that um again they they really benefited last year datawise from getting minimally proficient students to uh make High growth and for ASA what helps is that actually gets you like double points if you think about like a video game um there's double points involved for moving minimally efficient students to high growth um uh I I actually uh talked with Miss bachari specifically uh the principal at Chavez about what's going on in first and fourth grade um and the things that stood out are um and we've seen this in the data too is having even teachers that are in their second third fourth year it's just like getting one extra year at that grade level to be able to like learn the content and go through it um and

075then being able to work well as a team so a couple of times just hearing about teachers who are who are willing to uh work um with a partner and learn from each other and grow and be on the same page um kind of an epiphany I had um I was asked by Dr battle to your question to go and look at sites and my Epiphany about PL plts and professional learning teams is we say like the research says you got to meet um but really what I have seen is that that good teachers innately want to collaborate and get better and are are willing to work together and there's others who other teachers who might be like oh this is compliance we just got to get through this but the teachers who make the

076most of their um Wednesday early releases in that time um is what I am hearing anecdotally about um the teachers who are who are showing great growth um but again um we would be happy to get um more from you from Miss zler and missia and as we're as we're looking at our teacher retention again having that extra time um to be more familiar with their content more familiar with their um resources that we have so as we're looking at one of our guard RS is teacher retention so that's um also a perfect just in time um measurement and assessment to to help us determine what are we going to do with our resources as we're looking for um uh creating our salary schedules so we want to make sure that we're retaining our our

077teachers past year four into year five um of course we want to retain all of our teachers but as we see that's that seems to be um a very spec very special time in a teacher's career when they're starting to get some air under their wings right and they're starting to um to show um more so and generally speaking right more so um that that performance proficiency so we want to make sure that we um are using all of this data to inform all of our operations as well thank you so much we appreciate it thank you the next item on the agenda is public participation and we do have some public comments um I will read the ammunition first personal attacks upon board members staff Personnel or other persons in attendance or absent by

078individuals who address the board are discouraged presenters are cautioned that statements or representations conc erning others that convey an unjust or unfavorable impression May subject the presenter to civil action for defamation and with that being said I call Jazelle Nava to the podium Madam president will you give three minutes for each person or how many minutes would you like to give each um participant two minutes please press your mic for us please thank you good evening members of the board my name is gel agilar Nava and I have the privilege of experiencing firsthand leadership guidance and constant commitment of principal Larry leice I had the honor of serving as student body president for two years I am the class of 2021 and I learned many skills and valuable lessons with the mentorship and guidance of

079Mr Lei from the very beginning of my journey as president he took time from his busy schedule to not just discuss school matters but to teach me what a real leader is he taught me the importance of finding my voice and so much more additionally my request isn't just for me I have younger siblings Who currently attend valy view Leadership Academy and I also want them to experience the same guidance as I did with great sincerity I ask you to consider allowing him to keep his role as pres principal at Valley View Leadership Academy he has not only impacted me but has helped hundreds of students thank you for your consideration thank you next we have David N uh dear members of the board my name is David ail NAA I'm a proud graduate of

080valy view Leadership Academy where I had the privilege of having Mr Larry PRI as a leader I am writing I am writing to express my support for keeping him at valie instead of transferring him to another school when I was at Valley viw I was when I attended valy viw it was struggling with performance and it was classified as a dchool under Mr L pri's leadership we experienced a remarkable transformation through his dedication and ability to inspire both students and staff our school Rose to a b School ra rating now on track to become School the dramatic Improvement reflects not just better grades by strong School Community one of the most impactful lessons Mr priest brought to our school was teaching us the principles of of the seven highly effective people he didn't just focus

081on academics he instilled life lessons that I continue to use this day these habits taught us how to be proactive prioritize what matters most and think when win in our interactions with others Mr the priest commitment to helping students succeed went far beyond the classroom shaping us into more responsible and capable individuals as a graduate I can proudly say how much his leadership shaped my educational journey I went I want my younger students to have the same opportunity I had I have had the privilege to learn at the school led by Mr lepri who deeply cared about their growth wellbe and removing Mr Lei from Valley View with the stuff the progress to eventually becoming an eth school I urge the members of the board to reconsider this the decision to transfer Mr leest his

082work is far from done at Val Leadership Academy and his continuous leadership is critical to Our Success please allow him to stay and finish his incredible work he has started thank you for your time and consideration thank you next we have Ethan Torres got you hello my name is Ethan taus I am a student at Valley View Leadership Academy yes we are Roosevelt yes I am an eagle once an e always always an eagle but most importantly I am leader why you ask because Mr Larry taught us the values of being a leader and me please let our principal Mr Larry stay at Value VI thank you love learn indeed have a great day to e away thank you so much Ethan for using your voice next we have Sonia NAA good evening steam board

083members faculty fellow parents and students I am Sonia NAA I stand before you today as a parent who has experienced the incredible impact our principal Mr Larry lapri has had a value viiew Leadership Academy two of my children have graduated one is currently enrolled and our youngest will soon follow throughout this journey Mr lpri has been a constant source of leadership and dedication in October of 200 four we received exciting news the students and staff of valview leadership academy earned a b letter grade school from the state of Arizona for the third consecutive year we've been just a point or two away from a name and this is a clear reflection of the hard work dedication and strong leadership that our principal has provided we have made remarkable progress in both academics and school culture

084and we are well on our way to even greater success changing leadership at this critical time would risk undoing the academic progress our children have made our children both current and future deserve the stability and consistency that only he can provide we are on the brink of achieving greater success and Mr laprice is a key to ensuring we reach that goal I ask you to carefully consider the long-term impact and keep him where he's making such profound difference as a Al as a as a former student of Ros Linda Elementary I personally can tell you the impact that our principles Mr B and Miss Lopez had not just on me but the community so impactful that the name was changed to Irene Lopez please allow our valy View Community to experience and have their own

085mysty and Miss Lopez through Larry lepr thank you for your time thank you next we have Meen OES sorry if I butchered your name Amy if you can please come to the front so you can interpret please okay we give her four minutes please I've been a member of Valley View for almost speak to the mic I've been a member of Valley View for almost 20 years my my children have attended that school during all three of those uh principles and now we're with Mr lprice two of my kids graduated um from the school one of them is in ASU right now he's a member of the Honor Society and he and he also received a scholarship college and my other um my other son studied at um South Mountain Community College and also the

086uh Mesa Community College is I I know how important it is to have someone who um is a good head of the school and someone to guide the school and all of the teachers at valy view have been a fundamental part of their education um and I saw all of the graphs that were presented and I saw how important it is to have consistency consisten the consistency that's needed to um to be able to attain the goals I've never understood why you want to interrupt something that's working so well instead of continuing on someone asked why the students in fourth grade had more um had better performance than the ones in fifth grade that's why a lot of times that's why because of the changes and that's that's a lot of times what happens is

087there's a change there and I'm a mom who's very present and I know how hard the students at Valley View are working we might have had a few differences uh Mr and I but he's not my favorite person but I also know and I understand how much and how hard he's worked for this school so we're don't listen to me and don't listen to uh the teachers listen to the students because we're trying to form leaders here and when the leaders when the When leaders talk the adults we want to shut them up thank you next we have Carlo Roger Rodriguez hello okay good evening Madame President and board members as well as our exec team my name is pear Rodriguez and I'm the band director music teacher student Lighthouse sponsor one of the Leader

088in Me coordinators the core Arts leader the girls soccer coach and our Roosevelt music department leader these programs are all a great Showcase of the talent and stability we've had at Valley View and you see them every board meeting on your screens in fact if you walk the district Halls you'll find their photos everywhere when Mr Le PRI joined our staff he catapulted us head first into increasing student achievement it is not a secret that stability breeds growth it is also not a secret that instability breeds Chaos on our campus in the last 14 years we have had two School leaders and yet at the district level we've had five superintendents and many more department leaders however valy VI remains stable many of us remained on staff for decades and retired because the stability provided

089by our school leaders was so stable that the grass was the greenest because we watered it together the hasty decision to move our school leader without our input is extremely risky in a time where public education is in crisis I believe that leaders should be alleviating hardships not creating them we have questions about this decision for example rootedness is one of our core values in RSD valy view is so rooted that people in The District staff District staff bring their children there under Larry's leadership how does moving him align with that value with teacher retention at Al low this will cause great Educators to leave our district valy viw has had the highest retention with Mr lapri as our leader this has the potential to disrupt that that will then cause a ripple effect of

090students leaving our strong campuses disrupting our incline in student enrollment is this decision a reflection of the focus to retain and cred Educators and school leaders thank you a few sentences all right thank you so much next we have Curtis Adams good evening congrat congratulations to you all being sworn in my name is courtesy Adams I am not only a parent at Valley View but I'm also the daughter of one of your very own Educators in this District so I'm deeply rooted in Roosevelt School District and I take everything very seriously now originally I planned on coming up here and pleading my case to why we really deserve to keep Mr lpri as our leader at Valley View and I've never seen teachers work as well together as they do under his leadership also we

091spent so much time as parents being involved with him last year he probably is very much so tired of us and he knows us like the back of his hand and we're going to approach him about anything and everything we believe in um I think what bothered me most and why I chose to speak up today is I'm so used to the district involving us as a community and letting us have a voice letting us have a say in the decisions that you do make being that you I know your job is not easy and I know you have so many different things to focus on but we want to be here and we want to be a part of it um the numbers the numbers will show you the students will tell you the

092parents will tell you the teachers will show you we spend a lot of time building up our community especially at Valley View we do support all the other schools in the district absolutely and all the teachers and staff that are involved thank you all but we would really like to keep our leader thank you thank you next we have Ranna Rios good evening good evening Madame President members of the board my name is ran and Rios and I'm a second grade teacher at Valley View I have worked to Roosevelt School District for 13 years and 11 of those years have been at Valley View but today I come before you not as a teacher but as a former RSD student I recently learned that my most influential teacher at RSD named Mrs Sylvia Dunn from

093my time at Julian passed away on New Year's Eve what you need to know about Miss Dunn is that she truly was what my principal Mr Le PRI calls magical she believed in each one of us sou being kids and always pushed us to do our best I was one of those lucky RSD students that got to experence the magic of misone and my life is forever changed however I can't say that every teacher that I had during my elementary school years had the same lasting impact on me at Valley View when I send my kids off to the next grade level I know that the magic does not stop when they leave my classroom I have experienced and witnessed amazing teachers who love and go above and beyond for our students at Valley View

094they are more magical teachers on our campus than I can count with my two hands and that is truly thanks to Mr Larry laprice since he has become our leader scores have increased en Roman has been amongst the highest in the district and we are now a lighthouse school he has taught us all how to be that magical teacher that every kid deserves respectfully I worry that some of the magic our students experience every day will cease to exist next school year without Mr Lai the students will bear the consequences of the Swift decisions being made which may prompt staffed on our campus to pursue New Paths and Lead Valley View this will affect student outcomes and teacher retention which was just mentioned earlier important to the RSD board I hope you will take the

095time to listen to our concerns because my students deserve to have their own misses done every year they are enrolled here at Roosevelt School District thank you thank you next we have inh helica Mariner good evening man president board members Dr Boro Dr battle my name is Anica Moreno and I am the administrative assistant for Valley View Leadership Academy my boss my heit is Mr Larry the priest and I guess it's a little bit more personal because I am his assistant I work closely with um staff at Valley View and I just feel that the decision that has been taken is a wrong decision that you are doing to valy view Leadership Academy when asked why he's being moved we were told because his I guess his guidance what he does needs to be given

096to other schools but if it ain't broke don't fix it it does not need to be fixed at all if other schools could come in model Valley View he is a leader he is a leader like they said not only to our staff that we have represented here from our cafeteria staff from our classified staff from our certified staff he is a good man are we perfect valy view is perfect no we're not do we need to fix stuff up yes we do do we all get along sometimes we may not but at the end we do work together and Valley View is outstanding and one of the reasons why and we all know leadership is always the key to making sure everything in our school works the way it works the way is increased

097is because of leadership and everyone following that leader I do not understand why this decision is made hopefully you guys will be able to change that now again this is going to end impact not only our students that love Mr lpri you guys are not there every day to see how the kids run to him and hug him and mess around with them and play with them you guys are not fair to see the impact we're just here sometimes I see we're just here looking at numbers or favors I don't know I don't know what's going on but this decision is not right those kids will be impacted and I know staff will be impacted thank thank you next we have Jessica zimer hello Madame President governing board members and members of the exec team

098I decided to speak today not just for myself but for my Valley View education Community my name is Jessica Zimmerman I've been at Valley View as an instructor coach since 2015 and in Roosevelt since 2011 I live in South Phoenix and I bring my kindergarten son to Valley View I'm rooted in Roosevelt as an educator mother and Community member our principal Larry Le PRI came to valy VI in 2018 and since then has moved the needle for our community moving our school from the D to an A or a few points from an A see we think we have it in the bag um leading us to attaining worldwide accreditation as Leader in Me Lighthouse school and valvie is consistently one of the leading schools in the district and you you heard it today before

099Christmas break it was decided without her input or climate survey that our community would be losing Mr laprice um as he would be moved to Sunland school next year I want to give you a little history lesson for those of you that are new to Roosevelt with being here 15 years I've seen firsthand what removing a principal does to a school and the negative impact that it has on the community in RSD Sunland used to be an a school strong in sports academics culture um Valley View leadership had a lot of sunon leadership transition over to that and we similar in a lot of ways and when that principle was moved in 2018 forcibly there was a mass Exodus of teachers a revolving door of Administrators sunlands yet to recover and are still working really

100hard but dropped returning staff letter grades and overall performance and while they're working hard to craw out of that rate um due to that system shakeup the move is dooming value you to the exact same state with the values of rootedness because this is my community and their integrity to do the right thing even if it's really hard paired with habit 8 find your voice advocating for those who deserve it I urge you to reconsider the movement of admin in an effective system and a hail Mar attempt to make another school effective thank you thank you and our final comment for tonight is Carmen Terell good evening Madam president and all members of the school board here tonight um I appreciate the opportunity to speak here and I'm here to say that there was just

101Daya talk about schools and Road Roosevelt and Lon really stood out and it's messed up that the school from what was said possibly and at the last meeting Lon is one of the schools that's being closed down even though the students had growth in it reading and math benchmarks also there needs to be some kind of accountability on what's happening with the schools that are closed and what helping the community looks like because hear one of them is for a Esa resource center and if that happens along with more closure of schools Roosevelt District may not be possible due to Esa and other non-community benefit entities that will cater to not only just existing private Charter and Esa voucher based schools and instruction but will possibly cause more decrease in housing as well as Community

102too so the question is is what does this look like in terms of school closures in terms of equity in this community and I challenge board members and the community to speak about all these concerns and many others at the capital if possible in regards to these issues thank you thank than you m superintendent um can you please follow up with everyone who had public comment tonight thank you thank you all for coming and speaking to us and we heard you and our superintendent Isaac team will be in touch with you next item on on the agenda is the superintendent's report and I'll pass it to Dr Portillo Madame President members of the board executive team in Roosevelt Community we are about to start our superintendence report which um today is our top happenings I

103I did want to um ensure the board that I will be reaching out to the to the people have commented today um we do have um an effort to try to schedule a meeting with the parents um and we've given several options of meeting dates for this week and next week and also want to make sure we CL ify with our community that we do not have any um schools um in process to become an Esa Hub so I just wanted to make sure that that you all knew that we don't have um any plans for an Esa Center we do have an Early Childhood Center um so that would be for our um fourth through five-year-old um students so just wanted to clarify and I'll follow up with the individual to to make sure

104that that that's um clarified okay so our top happenings all right so uh Rosevelt School District in collaboration with volunteers from its Community partner Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona held its holiday food distribution at Bernard black entrepreneurial Academy during the season of giving they spread warmth and Goodwill to families in need and together they demonstrated the power of community and the spirit of support ensuring that no one went without this holiday season the South Mountain Phoenix police precinct partnered with angels on patrol to hold the inaugural South Mountain Shop with a cop event this heartwarming initiative in collaboration with Target Chick-fil-A and other local donors aims to bring joy to the Roosevelt families during the holiday season two students from each of our campuses were able to fill their shopping carts with gifts for

105their families and for themselves RSD extends its gratitude to everyone who participated and contributed to spreading happiness throughout our community's families congratulations to our district basketball champions in division 2 the TG bar girls defeated Chavez and Davis boys defeated Julian in a hard hard one battle in division one the valy vi girls and Sunland boys brought home the trophy thank you coach pet and Mr oo for organizing our sports program thank you to all the staff who work to coach and support our athletes at each school to the community for your tax credit donation ations and to South Mountain High School for hosting our Championship Games congratulations to all of our players and let's give a round of applause to all of our teams for a fantastic season the Roosevelt School District transportation department took

106a well-deserved moment to celebrate their tireless efforts and dedication with a festive holiday Branch this Gathering was an opportunity to recognize the team's unwavering commitment to ensuring our students have safe And Timely daily Journey we extend our deepest gratitude to the entire team for their dedication their professionalism and the heart that they put into every mile that our students travel and with that I also want to take the opportunity to welcome our new Transportation director Mr Jason Kyle if you could stand Mr Kyle comes to us from Los Angeles where he served as a regional supervisor in the LA Unified School District's transportation department he has successful experience in leading a transportation team and we are happy to have him leading with us here in roselt and just to mention today is his second day

107in our district let's see um valy view principal Larry lepri and instructional coach Jessica simmerman recently penned an article for e School news about engaging students with the district's literacy platforms the programs that we purchased for curriculum and making recommendations for other districts who are seeking own their own tools in improving learning um Kevin beum the Arizona Cardinals offensive tackle recently visited Co Greenfield Academy of Design and Innovation to celebrate stem week with students during his visit beum um shared his passion for Education technology and teamwork um Kelvin engaged with students highlighting the importance of stem fields in sports and everyday life and encouraging them to pursue careers that combine creativity science and problem solving Kennedy welcomed Phoenix Mayor Kate Gago and District 8 councilwoman Kisha Hut Washington to inaugurate the loving Library space allowing

108students to immerse themselves in their favorite liter literary works the mayor and councilwoman engaged with students about the vital importance of reading every day a big thank you to the loving Library ambassadors for participating or partnering with Kennedy's Family Center and with the generous support from Amazon uh that made this possible for us in December Val's sixth grade band and Eagle band opened for the Southmont Community College Latin jazz big band a great experience for our students for over 30 years Valley View Eagles have traveled North to participate in their acts and Lead leadership camp in Prescott as students learn to do art projects conduct um science experiments and learn more about leadership we thank Miss Pera Rodriguez for organizing this opportunity Del view Eagles visited the Phoenix Art Museum where they examined and discussed

109art from over 600 years ago the Firefly installation was among the most popular exhibits featuring thousands of fireflies suspended from the ceiling local law enforcement agency spread holiday Joy at Genson and bar schools through their heartwarming shop with the cop event also uh meanwhile Julian students were treated to a festive celebration at the team court with gifts and seasonal fun and the Lopez PTO with the help of Santa distributed thought thoughtful gifts and gift cards to all of their students these special moments created lasting memories and deepened the connection between our schools the community and law enforcement and that's all I have for you today thank you thank you the next item on the agenda is 4.04 board member update um Madame President I would just like to say I'm really excited to serve with

110all of our new board members so congratulations on being hopefully more than halfway through our first board meeting um and just appreciate all of you and excited to serve alongside you does anyone else have like to share anything okay hearing none we'll move on um the next item on the agenda is 4.08 is the Rea report I'm Dr Martha Thomas the president she's coming to the podium happy New Year everyone Madame President governing board members Dr poro our executive team my Rea and RSD colleagues and our sou Phoenix Community I am Martha Thomas social worker and president of Rea as of today we currently have 346 members and we'll continue to reach out throughout our uh campuses and um we're going to update our our yearly schedule for that um I want to congratulate our

111again our transportation department because they were the first Department to make majority status in our district um following them was um Bush school and then Campbell school so we're we're getting there we're just doing it piece by piece um we are also going to we're rescheduling our ESA event that we were planning for our all of our classified staff are our classified members um in doing a celebration of them so we're in the process of getting that rescheduled um pretty soon and I'll let you know as soon as we get that solidified um we also prior to break had sent out a survey to all of our members we wanted to get their thoughts their opinions on the closing of our schools I now have all of that data so we're going to put it

112all together for you in a PowerPoint and you'll see that in the coming month um at this point we're going to focus on um doing our elections because we still have three positions open for our executive team and so we're going to focus on getting those filled and also um focus on our delegate assembly with the Arizona Education Association so getting those positions filled are there any questions that you might have for me Madam president uh what three positions are are vacant they're executive board members okay yeah just we have currently we have four okay um as we increase our membership for every 50 members that we get we get another position for executive board um through aea which means when we go to our delegate assembly um which AA hosts and puts together then

113um at this point I want to say we're going to end up with 13 of them so that means that Rea can have 13 votes votes to elect any president vice president all those positions for the Arizona Education Association so the more members we have the more votes we have to to um participate in the Arizona Education Association thank you Dr Thomas you're welcome any other questions from board members thank you so much Dr Thomas thank you the next item on the agenda is 4.04 rein vinon Roosevelt as you all know on December 5th the board voted to repurpose some campuses to close the financial deficit and provide additional resources to students the board directed the superintendent to provide an update at regular board meetings here is the first update and I will pass it

114to our superintendent Dr Portillo thank you madam president um members of the board executive team in Roosevelt community yes the board has directed me each month to provide an update so each month you will see um an update of that month's current work and then a preview of what we'll be doing next um this month because we've only been back from our uh winter break for two days um uh you'll mainly hear you'll only hear from me but in future presentations you might be hearing from other members of the team and or subcommittees that were establishing to lead some of this work so again just reor ing us with our vision and Mission we as a Comm we are a community that's United to create better futures for all through education what this means to

115us is that we work hand inand with our community to make all of South Phoenix better by focusing on our area of expertise which is teaching and learning we lean on our Community Partners to further meet the needs of our students and their families through their areas of expertise and focus our mission is to build strong foundations through authentic and Innovative experiences to ensure success for every student we want our students to be successful in life and most immediately after they promote from e8th grade and move on into high school and that has really anchored Us in creating the goals that we selected and also the guardrails these are our current strategic priorities um the plan a strategic plan expires in 2025 so this this year um so our Roosevelt uh reinvention includes developing the

1162025 strategic priorities and the Strategic plan so we'll be working on strategic planning this year um so here's the summary of the um events um or not events but the actions that we've been taking on as a board um so again the reason why we're redesigning um our district uh and creating a new strategic plan is because the old one expire is expiring but also because we want to ensure that we are utilizing our funds to maximize Direct student impact uh prioritizing the academic programs and services that build better futures for all of our students across all of our campuses and we want to gain long-term Financial stability for the district so that we're not um uh every year having to make um big changes and or cutbacks that we are stable and we're able

117to continue to have a district that moves forward and has those resources to be able to achieve the goals that we have set for ourselves and we want to expand academic and extracurricular programs for students so all of that costs money though we're moving in the right direction we know our parents have been pretty loud and clear in saying that they want expanded programming for our gifted students and then more opportunities for extracurricular Sports um and other programs in our district and again that costs money uh we also want to create more competitive salaries and career opportunities to attract and retain our quality employ es and that again requires us to have Financial stability and predictability as create create long-term Financial plans not just year by year and then we want to utilize our properties

118to collaborate with Partners in strengthening the south Phoenix community and providing those services to Roosevelt families so we want to expand our opportunities for uh rentals um for small events or um or um time committed events like say a tournament or a volleyball team or a basketball team that's a community club but also we want we want to make sure that we enter into long-term relationships and Partnerships to lease our our our buildings to um partners that might support us for example the partners that were lining up for the Early Childhood Center over at MLK so the data that we looked at we can go to my next slide please thank you so the data that we looked at is really just on time the student achievement data because it's helping us to make some

119important decisions um in our district so this this includes um the um the planning of our of our school calendar of our School academic schedules of our District budget um our employee compensation and our service delivery plans so we've been focusing on in January again l December and January since we only been been back for two days so some of this work will still continue within the month of January is that we've updated our website and communication plan when it comes to the Reinventing Roosevelt so we've been able to archive all of the the previous presentations we gave to community all of the um the information that was there that um that was uh the timeline um all of the data everything that we used is now archived in the website so that that people

120can um refer to the past but then also so that we're maximizing our focus on the present and on the future so we we have already done um some some significant changes to the Reinventing Roosevelt website on our district um website then also we've engaged in a comprehensive um special education audit so our external um special education audit is well underway we selected an external auditor um to conduct this um this assessment so that we are able to use an outside experts view to help us to improve services for our students um today the executive team met with our um director of special education and the auditor so that we could hear some preliminary um information and results the report as a whole should be ready for the board's review in March again this is

121a comprehensive assessment which includes not looking only at uh data student data but also looking at data um as far as um interviews that have been conducted with um staff members with General Ed staff members with special ed staff members with um with a district leadership with special ed leadership campus leadership and then we're now adding um interviews for our special ed parents and interviews with um special ed students so that we can have a whole comprehensive um data set to look at as we plan forward um for our special Edge Services we know that that's an area that we absolutely need to grow in um so uh we've been engaging in that um comprehensive audit um again the preliminary results will help us to inform um our general our whole districts plan because the

122specialed students belong to all of us right so our ownership of our special ed students is really the General Ed responsibility um so we'll be able to um use some of this data to inform us again as we start creating the um the professional development calendar our um School academic schedules to ensure we're providing the the adequate amount of time focused on Intervention our District budget our employee compensation and then also um our service delivery plans for Special Education team uh students um also we are ordering the same type of external comprehensive audit um for our English language learner um services and then a systemwide equity audit um so I will be actually meeting to review um some of the drafted and ensure that um that there's nothing missing um in the scope of work

123before we put out those procurement um um calls so that um we can have external um agencies put in for procurement so that we can possibly hire them um to come in and do these audits we also um um have begun the planning of how to honor and repurpose our our schools so we're starting first with our leadership and then creating committees um of uh alumni parents and Community who can come in and give us ideas but already our principles are beginning to honor some of the um uh or creating events to start honoring some of our our schools that will be closing and being repurposed and then also um well we meet on Thursday with our principles they'll also have time to um continue to work on their events that they're creating to welcome

124from students and families to those receiving schools um the other thing that we've been will be working on during the month of January is um looking at um creating and finalizing the scope of work for an RFP or a consultant to come in and support us in U managing all of the work um associated with the repurposing of buildings so we know we had a consultant in the fall um that scope of work has already ended because that was a preliminary work and now will be a competitive process for the Springs work the actual implementation of finding um and um and um and um creating all of the the necessary background work with leases and all of that for those Partners um and we'll also have um a facilitator for our strategic planning so um

125I know I have strategic planning as the last bullet as well but know that we are putting out an RFP also to help us create a a strategic uh robust approach towards our strategic planning um the pass facilitator that we used um when creating our last fiveyear goal is definitely going to be one that will be considered but we also um will be putting out an RFP for an open competition for that work that work will take approximately a year to be able to complete um all of the Strategic plan um for the 2530 um 5e um um work of the future of the district um also in January what we'll be working on is the development of our budgeting so the final budget won't go to the to the board until later on in

126the year but we have to start budgeting now right we've already started making some preliminary decisions but we have to start budgeting now as we um work for um next schools Year's activities um and again we're really wanting to create a Five-Year Plan um for our fiveyear strategic plan which requires us to look at our budgeting and our finances in a more long-term um way that that we've been doing now where we've been looking at budgeting year by year even semester by semester we want to make sure we have long-term stability so we're beginning the development of that budget and also then um continuing the work of pursuit of additional grants so um we have already um partnered with an outside um uh grant writer to help us to get more grants um our current

127current Grant um writing team continues to work on grants as well but they are they're tapped we have written so many grants right they're very active in the pursuit of Grants but we also have a lot of actions that we want to um engage in that are maybe are not academically um driven but that um that that there are grants out there that can support us for example in the creation of after school programs or um Improvement of our some of our facilities so we have an outside grant writer that we've consulted with to help us um where as help our um existing grant writing team um so that we're complimenting the work that they're doing and pursuing more more funding coming into the district um also we have um we are developing the uh

128Staffing standards for the upcoming school year so really looking at all at the district office at all departments and then at campuses by size and need to um see what is the adequate Staffing needed for each of the campuses as we create those those standards moving forward um we also will be engaging in um creating the salary schedules for all of our employee groups knowing that we have selected certain um groups already that we really want to Target though we we're considering all groups we know that we have um a difficult time with um our having enough drivers for our students so we want to increase um salary schedules for our CDL Drivers also many of our trades we're not um competitive right now um with other districts with our trades people so that would

129be our um hbac for example our our um AC our our um all of our trades our plumbers our car Carpenters all of those type of Trades and also we have spoken already about our need to improve the salary schedule for our special education staff and then um both certified and classified and also know that we have um a huge need to emphasize um um to increase um our investment in our math um achievement which includes then salary schedules that are looking at hard to fill positions such as math now I've noted those those are not going to be the only ones but we are beginning salary schedule creation um so we can have those ready for input um from other groups and then ready to bring out to you for possible approval in the

130upcoming month um and then also working on the contract shells um the contract shell is the cont contract itself and the wording within the contract um uh that's going through legal council we just recently received that so that should be ready to um put forward to you um in at our next meeting our special meeting which is January 21st for our principles and then renewals for those returning principles at our next board meeting um again we we told our principles committed to our principles and then also stated publicly and to you that we wanted to have our principles be the first group that we um address when it comes to renewals and non-renewals um because we know that this is the time where um districts are competing for the best um principles and we want

131to make sure that we give all of our principles knowing that they're all very strong the opportunity to go and compete in other districts if they were not renewed in our district we want to make sure we're respectful and we give them the opportunity to compete for those positions and then again the last bullet is strategic planning um as we've analyzed all the work that we need to do and all the um data that we need to get from these um external audits um a lot of the strategic planning um will be all of the data collection and information collection and all of the planning itself so that strategic planning is beginning but we're not engaging um Community yet until we have all of that data collected and we we've um we've um selected our

132our strategic planning facil it Ator and then created the timeline all the meetings all the stuff that needs to be scheduled so you will see more um active external um participation in the strategic planning towards the end of the semester or the towards the the closure of the school year and then moving forward into the fall all right and that's all I have to report for the month of January thank you questions from board members uh yeah I had a questions can you back to that slide that you just or I'll just look at what you have there well one of the things you were talking about that um some of the schools that are um being repurposed that they are already planning events or they're having ways to commemorate um those schools and the

133historical figures I did see that um MLK day there's going to be an event is that wait okay do we have any more information on that by chance yeah that'll be coming um soon so that um is being planned by um MLK and the and the community um that is around there around the MLK schools um so there is a committee planning that we'll have more information to you um shortly but it is going to be um on January 18th um and you should be receiving invitations in your calendar if you haven't already um to participate um one thing that is exciting to outside of honoring of course the legacy of Martin Luther King and the work that he did is they also have selected to recognize um two individuals one who was a previous

134principal at MLK um from years past and then also Miss Shelley Jackson um alumni of um MLK and then also um also um you know our previous board president so yeah that's exciting as well um and then another thing is um with those schools that we're still discussing how they're going to be repurposed you mentioned that are we are having um meetings where community members can participate in that do we have any dates available so people that we don't yet because we are selecting an an objective person to help lead that work but yes thank you for for reminding me and us of that um the work will involve um not only us looking at data from the C City of Phoenix planning but also then eliciting input from um the community and really focusing

135on including input from the immediate neighbors because those neighbors that own homes around the schools we want to make sure that they have a voice since they purchased a home next to a school we want to make sure that they have voice in um and what will their the campus in in their Community will be repurposed to and then also um where we have um contact with the um namesake of that school we want to make sure that that family is also included in um in that for example the Davis Family at Davis School um with that in mind also since we had several um people that came and spoke on you know behalf of what was happening with these schools and they they shared a lot of interest um is there going to be

136any attempt to make sure that they're also receiving that information yes absolutely yeah we have all of the phone numbers and um and names of those that approached us and we have had one group meeting where we invited them but we would have more thank you any other questions comments not a question but I would be remiss if I didn't name that you know while many staff members were on winter break the fact that we are two days into January and this work is is moving forward and I just want to commend the executive team for the work that was done in December leading up to winter break over winter break and over the last two days to be able to bring such a summary to the board so just appreciate that I Echo her

137sentiments next item on the agenda um is approval of the consent items is there a motion to approve the consent item consent agenda items as presented so moved is there a second second all those in favor I I I any oppos motion carries next item on agenda are action items item 6.01 expenditure of bond funds for student transportation vehicles with an estimated cost of 1,593 $330,000 and4 is it oh sorry let me go back up I'll pass it to our superintendent thank you madam president uh members of the board executive team and Roosevelt Community um this is a reminder that um this expenditure is part of a greater strategy to reduce our dependence on contracted Services um the strategy includes not only this purchase but also uh CDL training for our current van drivers um

138also ass signing bonus for any current van driver who becomes a bus driver and also any external um bus driver who comes already with CD license to our district um a recruitment stien so any employee that is a ble to recruit a person with a CDL license will also receive a stipend also increase in salary schedule for CDL bus drivers and also um now that we have our new director looking at routing changes and efficiency so it's a a holistic um strategy to reduce our over dependence on um external um Contract Services for um for transportation um given the needed uh provisions of transportation services for Route coverage um and Kento students uh both General Ed and special ed students um versus the transportation services that are outsourced um due to our shortage um and

139our unbalance of allocation of our traditional buses versus um the number of special ed buses that we currently have it is advantageous for RSD to purchase ESS buses only at this time um not any more General Ed buses Andor Vans um purchasing wheelchair buses gives the department uh the flexibility to service both wheelchair and ambulatory students as well as other special education students as these buses are equipped with variable seating um meaning seats that can be added and or omitted as uh needed per student um the purchases of the mini buses also increases flexibility as certified van drivers can legally transport students in the minibuses uh enabling RSD to count and submit route mileage within ad compliance so it's important that we are able to charge for and receive that um that route mileage back

140and the mini buses have a 14 passenger capacity versus a white fleet van that only seats 10 um students um which enables us to uh look at Route cons consolidation were applicable um we also do plan to trade in five older um Regular Ed buses towards the purchase of the new um bus to to offset the cost of the new um bus um purchases that that will be a slight offset obviously it's still a large um purchase that we're making um those five older buses are currently out of service um longterm and POS a hardship for us to continue to repair them so um trading them in will allow us to to um trade off some of this um some of this expenditure um pending tonight's approval the delivery of these buses is estimated to

141um be no later than April of this year so it'll allow us to quickly start weaning our ourselves off of the um the related the the contracted services that we have been um engaging in with the outside companies and um also the um the uh budget budget source for this is our last um uh bond which was approved for expenses for this money was approved for expenses in transportation specifically for transportation Vehicles so it also is not affecting our current budget and also um the money that we're spending through that Bond cannot be spent to reduce our deficit any discussion or questions I just wanted to clarify so the this um this funding is going to go specifically just for the vehicles not for all the other things with the Personnel okay no it has

142to be spent the bond what we are approving right now is to allow us um we're asking you to approve is to allow us to spend the bond money to purchase vehicles and the bond money can only be used for vehicles because that's what was approved by the voters we'll still have money left over from that particular Bond afterwards too okay yes we still have money in the bond in the previous bond for other projects like uh building projects and other categories that were approved by the voters but this particular bucket of money was approved for transportation vehicles and there will still be money left in that bucket from the bond for vehicles as well or is are we going to meet the cap at that point Madam president um paa paa board member paa

143um yeah we'll still have a little bit of money left in the transportation um I can get you exact numbers uh I want to say we had about $2 million left over um but you have the opportunity to move into any category you can increase any category by 10% So in theory we could take that other half a million dollars and move it over into one of our other buckets um the few buckets we had if I'm not mistaken was technology uh maintenance costs and then like building construction so that's what sunland's coming out of so if I remember correctly we had about $40 million left on this Bond 25 million of that is Sunland and so a lot of it is spoken for this is another chunk of it so we're still spinning down

144some of that money and I have encouraged both our um technology and uh uh oh I forget the name of him um buildings and ground what do we call them here director of facility yeah um uh i' I've explained both of them that we do have some money so they're working on a plan to spend that down a little bit any other questions for discussion yeah Madam president yes um so you mentioned that um this will replace some Contracting Services is do you have like a a ballpark number of that figure it's going to replace for the that we're paying for the Contracting Services it'd be my pleasure um board member buts uh to provide that specific data for you I would be speculating at this point um and I have a general idea of

145it I would love to be able to give you more accurate account of what that transition might be um part of that is and I'm pulling data too from our mckin vento students transp ation which we are contined to increase uh historically uh here in Roosevelt we have increased our student enrollment in mckenny vento numbers so we're doing some prediction for next year uh so therefore two things and why I mentioned mcken vento those would be our van our van students that are um on those but then also the transition from the Vans to the buses um might be a little bit complex at this point in time so your specific question for us to provide for you is what the cost differential might be correct for the buses being purchased and the change that's

146a work in progress and we will have that for you shortly awesome thank you um pleas and also just want to clarify that that number shifts because the the enrollment in the population and the needs of our students shift um so it may be a um changing number each time as mckin vental kids come in or leave our district and or students with special needs are identified with a need to be transported um so it it shifts and that's why it's hard for us to um give you an exact number today okay thank you uh the other question is um you mentioned that these buses will be used for ESS students so does that mean that they will not be used for any other students it allows us the sorry the purchase of these vehicles

147allow us the flexibility because they can be used for both but we can't use our regular buses to transport our special ed students okay I special students who require Transportation on their IEP correct thank you I think that um I wrote down some notes so em me um I think that was that was pretty much it um as far as discussion um I did kind of want to talk about that uh before we vote on it um I know that uh you know we just kind of voted to close schools the previous board did and and so um my question is um were these numbers were were were these uh requests for proposals prepare prior to the transition of the last year to this year and was that ready to go to a vote last

148year um around for this specific um need for the for the buses if that makes sense am I making sense um no so we've had a general strategy that we know we want to wean ourselves off of the external Outsourcing of all kinds of services in our district including Transportation so um this is a portion of that General strategy so we've been talking about that General strategy um there is a um a long um lead time to get buses in so we were worked extremely hard to be able to pending um today's approval to be able to have um those buses in by April because it's usually taking about a year to get those buses in so yes we did start preliminary work um to be able to be prepared for today's meeting for you

149to take a vote on it I do want to um emphasize again that the this expenditure is coming out of the bond and the bond was approved by our voters for specific purposes which cannot be used for the deficit because our deficit is structural which is costed primarily through our biggest expenditure which is our staffing so this is for purchases a vehicle so we can't use this money for um to offset salaries that's those those two funding sources cannot be combined correct which is kind of why I'm a little bit I guess confused if if we had the money the money was approved right I guess it seems like this would have been already kind of pushed through last year or you know before the new board transition because if it's going to take time

150for the buses to get here what you know what I mean okay and if I might um president Hajj thank you and also govern Bo Mr um buts good question what we've had an opportunity to do since last year is really evaluate our resources so we had in place um strategies to purchase buses which really weren't the specifics of our ESS buses so because our strategy in Roosevelt was different than it is now and for compliance reasons we need to have transportation specifically for our special Edge students so buses were in the budget for Bond but we transitioned fortunately we didn't purchase those buses in previous years so given the assessment and evaluation with our contracted consultant as well as our finance department and our own staff evaluation we realize that we are creating um

151more of a challenge to support our student travel by staying on the same trajectory so now we have those dollar they're still within the realm of which we can spend them so we haven't expired the previous bond funds and so we're utilizing those in a more efficient manner so fortunately we did not uh for whatever reason um that didn't come to the board although there were buses purchased last year as well as uh White Fleet uh We've pivoted to what our students need versus just a plan of purchasing more buses and um last summer we began working with an external consultant also also like like you've seen we've had to have fresh eyes looking at a lot of our operations so we began in the summer working with an external consultant who um began to

152advise us as to best practices and work and we also have had a um vacancy in our transportation director position until now day two so we um began working with our consultant to help assess where our needs are which at this point we don't need to buy any more regular Ed buses or Vans and we've that we need to buy um transportation Vehicles so we didn't do it in the fall because we were assessing that need we had a vacancy working working through a consultant but we really want to um Rectify our over dependence on external um um uh companies and um we worked really hard to be able to expedite the delivery of the vehicles by no later than April if pending approval today no later than April so that we can accelerate um

153getting them on the road right so it's it's part of a holistic um comprehensive strategy which um began we began the research of what was happening and identifying where are there areas to be more um efficient and effective in transportation back in the summer sure and thank you for your answers um my question is is and I'll speak for myself um it it feels a little bit uncomfortable voting on a $1.5 million um even even though I know the money was already kind of uh allocated um you know there was a lot of contention about closing schools and just the addressing the perception uh that you know us new board members are coming in and and and voting yes to spend you know m.5 million um and just just wanted to address if that perception

154is out there that that's not what's happening this money was already allocated like you said so thank you yeah I appreciate that point um board member bets I also think the point that you made um superintendent ptia about the fact that we were transitioning to a director of transportation is a really important one to highlight that some of those big decisions or big purchases would have come with the onboarding of that director versus when we didn't have that director in place so I appreciate that clarification as well thank you if there's no further discussion I will entertain a motion can I just have one go a minute okay so um I just wanted to be clear that I did my due diligence of looking into this because if anyone knows me I do not want

155to spend money like this like this high of numbers so of course the first thing I had was an allergic reaction to the numbers um but I have to say I was really thankful that um you guys did your due diligence have given me everything I asked for I asked a lot of questions like how what's on The Fleets what are our current numbers like how many students how many routes that sort of thing um and um I was able to receive all that material to um feel pretty confident that that this is being done you know in in a proper manner so thank you for that or president one last question okay regarding the bond money right so if if so this decision has to be made obviously because we need to spend the

156money right is there a time frame is there is there a penalty on on on waiting to spend the money because and I say that because um you know we still have to get through uh you large uh process and and kind of seeing what what's going to happen with families and and uh decisions that need to be made um we've heard a lot of community voice about um about all of the movement and we we really don't know what our enrollment numbers are going to look like after we kind of get through this right so um my question is does this have to be made now and if if it if it does then then that's fine but I just want to kind of bring that that point up for myself as a as

157a voter yeah yeah so we don't have to spend the money now because of the bond we should spend the money soon because we are over um spending or not over spending but we are spending out of other funds not the bond to cover the cost of these Outsource services so the cost of the Outsource Services is impacting our deficit whereas remedying it as quickly as possible including the purchase purches of these buses will help us to rectify the problem sooner um so it's it's not a pressure of that we have to spend by I by a certain deadline though there is a deadline we still have time um it's more so the pressure of um uh reducing the impact on our budget on our m&o budget because the purchases of these vehicles will not

158be out of our M budget but the current overdependence on Outsource companies is coming out of our M budget okay thank you and and the money that we are currently spending in is that's coming out of the M that's related to the going into our 2 to three years uh um uh cushion right absolutely yes all right thank you thank you any other questions or comments with that I'll entertain a motion I Mo we approve the expenditure of bond funds to purchase a student transportation Vehicles is there a second second all those in favor I I'm gonna say no nay just just because of my personal hesitation but okay so it passes 41 next item on the agenda is 6.02 award the award of the contracted transportation services RFP 20255 0229 to two vendors identified

159and I'll pass it to Dr P thank you so as I just mentioned we have this over Reliance on Outsource Services um but we do in the meanwhile have to use these Outsource services so um due to the S the shortage of CDL bus drivers and also our our lack of Fleet to be able to transport our special education students we have issued a request for proposals for contracted transportation services um that that went out in November the RFP um requested vendors to submit qualifications um in information about their drivers and their bus fleet um and it was issued uh via the Arizona School District um um collaborative which is an electronic procurement platform um an evaluation committee determined that both Legacy Industries LLC and desert Choice Transportation LLC would best fit the needs of

160our district and would be the most um um effective and efficient um selection and that they should be recommended for Award of the contract any questions for discussion okay I entertain a motion oh I I had a quick question how long is this contract for again sorry thank you Miss pin govern board members that would be for the this year the school year and of course Mr Gonzalez can add more um to it if I might just want to emphasize what Dr ptio said is that we are and have exceeded the number of resources if you will Outsourcing it's really important if you would be so kind to understand that we are in a situation that we must transport our students um by our drivers and also having the equipment in order to do so

161for lots of compliance reasons so this is coming before you uh to ensure that we are following board policies and procedures that as we exceed that threshold we need your approval if possible to make it happen and Madam president just a clarifying question um I think to um board member Pingus point then as we you know look at school consolidation and we look at our updated routes we can then evaluate whether or not that need is is still present as we go into the next school year is that correct yes so so what we're looking at is the is for you to approve that we give the contract to these two companies the actual details of all the routes and the daily work that they would be doing that all will be led through um

162the work that we've analyzed so far and then through the input of our director so right now you're not spe uh approving a specific amount you're um approving that we give it to these two vendors and so the goal is is basically to have them temporarily until we can train our staff up because we're encouraging our staff to get their CDL licenses um so this is only temporary until we can rightsize that department correct yes govern reward uh president Dr Hajj exactly that's our goal and I want to commend a couple departments um not only the great work with the transportation staff has been trying to manage a very complex situation especially this year as they've learned what compliance issues exist as you all have seen in Prior audits um and also what you've also

163reported that we are spending three times is more than any other District I in our emo so want to call that out but also our our finance department our human resources who have been instrumental in putting some efforts in incentivizing so that we can keep this temporary um we don't find this to be as efficient as we could um based on the Integrity that we have as a school district so the decisions you're making here this evening will help us to meet those goals you are there any other questions or comments with that I'll entertain a motion I move we award the contract of Transportation Services RFP as identified in the agenda second all those in favor I any oppos passes unanimously item 6.03 sof for purchase from vendor she with an estimated cost of

164$114,000 I'll pass it to Dr Portillo spot here so the roselt school district relies on Microsoft Office 365 for essential productivity tools such as email uh document creation spreadsheets and presentations these tools are vital for both instructional and administrative operations additionally Microsoft server licenses are required to maintain the district's Network infrastructure and ensure secure reliable access to digital resources renewing these licenses now will ensure uninterrupted access to the software and systems that support our students our staff and our administrative functions the renewal alignance with the district's commitment to providing highquality technology supported educational environment so again this cost is for the entire District all groups all employees um some students um and its estimated cost um is not to exceed 114,000 thank you is there any discussion or comments Dr Boro um members of the

165board I'm just really grateful that um you know to have studied this one too again any big numbers make me a little nervous um but um seeing that this is actually how we we function as a district like we don't have any of these Services there's no way we can do anything we can't do any of these PowerPoint presentations for our classrooms um we can't send emails to our staff um or even the students can't even you know type out their documents for their projects so um when it comes down to that cost that's actually a very reasonable cost for everything that we're going to be getting with those services so thank you for um for having this any other questions or comments I entertain a motion I'd like to make a motion is there

166a second I second all those in favor I unanimously next item on the agenda is item 6.04 and progress monitary mid midyear check inum goals Dr P do you have any comments on this one we're just asking that you approve um receipt of the um report that was presented earlier by Mr O any questions or discussion sorry can I hear that again it's just um a formality of accepting the report that we presented earlier today so as a part of our framework um the executive team or the team will present data to us and it it's our responsibility to approve the data if we were okay with the report are there any other questions or comments I just wanted to repeat again that I was really grateful for that presentation for the diligence made to

167present it so well and and to explain it so that we understand where we are with with that progress um Madam president I think the only thing I would just reiterate is um some of the questions around where students are growing and how that overlaps with um different student groups um would just love that presentation either sent to the board or in a future presentation um but aside from that again just appreciate the the work and just to clarify you're speaking about the request of moving one kids from one one group to the and measuring how much kidss are growing from minimally proficient to the next level and specifically it was as we think about the students who are hitting that High student growth percentile are they our lower students are they our higher students

168are they members of specific groups um just what data we have on who is achieving that so that we can um better dial into and understand what's working in classrooms with curriculum with teachers or with schools okay thank you thank you Madam president um my only uh comment is that uh you know with accepting the report and thinking about the data and the growth um you know just uh being concerned with the comments and feedback and concerns about um changing of the leadership and how that may impact uh growth in the future any other comments I understand the motion I move we accept the progress monitoring Report with the midyear check and interim goals second all those in favor I passes unanimously the next item on the agenda is the board meeting calendar um so

169I'm not sure if you all had a chance to review it if you want to take a moment to look at it and make sure that you're available in those days and at that time and Madame President just to clarify um we are setting the start time then at 5:30 for all meetings is that what I'm seeing that great thank you that is correct I sometimes show up at the wrong time namely very early so I appreciate the clarification thank you are there any other questions or comments um I just wanted to verify that this is going to be reflected as well online okay okay and then if for whatever reason something happens in the future and we have to make adjustments we can adjust this correct okay thank you boin I think the important

170thing as long as we have the lead time to be able to post it we can make those adjustments um and then I I from our experience last year I won't speak for the future yet um but the idea of there were times where we didn't have a specific topic scheduled so we ended up canceling that meeting but that way the hold was on our calendars in case that that was a need Madam president um I just had a question about what was the thought process behind calling a study session a study session versus um a regular meeting so regular meetings are the ones that we have to have and so um what we did was we added study sessions because of the frequency of meeting and being able to talk about different topics it's

171it's more of an informal meeting um for us to to discuss different topics so for example I don't have it in front of me but for at our next board meeting we'll be we'll be diving into sofg and more about the policies and procedures so it's more of a study session and place where we can go back and forth with all of our exec team and whoever else we invite and Madame President if I am correct because I know we had to have a few special meetings those are also meetings where we're not actually voting on anything we are being presented information for discussion um if there is something we need to vote on then we hold a separate special meeting for that vote is that accurate correct we have the special meeting and the

172study session all them the same night and we may do the special meeting first or vice vers if there's something that we need to vote on and sometimes we might eliminate and it's only study session or it might be study session and special meeting or just a special meeting so um but we want to make sure it's held on the calendar and properly posted so looking forward um that's why it says study session Andor special meeting follow a followup question with that one um has there ever been a case where you know we changed a special meeting or study session to a meeting where we had to vote because of priorities okay thanks yes yes so the special meeting if there is an item that we need to vote on so for example we talked

173about we remove item 1.07 so that may come back up next meeting so that we can vote on it it'll be a special meeting on the 21st as well as our study session and to follow up with that it wouldn't be that um we would know in advance that we have to vote on something or or does it have to be that we know in advance that we're going to vote on something or could it be that just we decide because we're in Quorum no Ma so we will know ahead of time what items will be on the agenda and if it's a special meeting or not yeah and I think in any of those situations we can always opt to or decide as a team not to vote um or to postpone that vote

174um but that gives us the option to be able to vote in that meeting to be able to hold that vote we can't hold that vote if it's not posted in the community is not aware so that's the difference between the special meeting um so just like we have to post for Community um and I know from our experience we've gotten great communication from the district about any items that might be on that special meeting agenda I appreciate that we have that diligence that we're that we're making sure we do not um hold any votes without first telling the community thank you absolutely on agenda are posted at Le at least 24 hours in advance and if there's no other further questions or comments I'll entertain a motion I move we adopt this very close

175bonding um spending lots of time together Board calendar um for the 2025 annual year is there a second second all those in favor I passes unanimously see next item on the agenda is information discussion I don't think we have any and there's no executive session tonight and the last item on the agenda is adjournment having concluded our business is there a motion to adjourn a motion that we adjourn I second all in favored

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.