001okay I would like to call this meeting to order please um can we please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Mr Ramirez can you please to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you very very much oh thank you thank you very much um roll call um Miss fobian absent okay Mr Guerrero here Mr Ramirez here Mr Beach and I'm here we do have a quorum okay we will continue okay all now I go to adoption of the agenda Miss Lille no recommended change no recommendations okay motion to approve the agenda as presented so move okay second okay we have a second motion passes no no vote we vote okay all okay you see
002I'm getting there I'm getting there I got the wrong one all those in favor all those in favor say I I all those oppose a eyes have it okay so motion passes okay subject to um C uh call to the public there's nobody there I don't have to do motion nothing okay executive session uh subject is the county treasure matters and got to read all of this right executive session uh notice is hereby given to the general public that the governing board of the Santa Cruz uh Valley Unified School District number 35 may vote to hold an executive session for discussion or consultation for legal advice with its attorneys and or for discussion or cons consultation with the attorneys to consider its it po its position and instruct its attorneys regarding County treasur litigations and
003related matters I you the governing board's attorneys May participate in P person virtually or by telephone a motion to convey to Executive session in the conference room number 125 second second okay all those in favor say I all those opposed no okay eyes have it okay we are going to be going to room e e e Rec convene to regular session don't move second second okay all those in favor I all those opposed okay okay eyes haveit okay we are we convened okay uh number three a presentation a superintendent report Miss lunderville thank you m president um just a couple of announcements um congratulations to all of our students who participated in the spelling B the county level spelling be last Friday um unfortunately we did not come in the top two but it's still
004of the great experience for our students um congratulations to girls soccer they have um made it to a playin game for the girls for a state playoff title um wrestling know one state female qualifier but I'm not aware if there are any males um your T this weekend Dr boys have a tournament this weekend so hopefully we get some gentlemen in into the state qualifying um wrestling meet we do have one far um and girls basketball um they are po to they have two two regular season games left but they're they're going to make it into to the playoffs as well um a quick update on the pool um and the Aquatic Center the heater is on and functioning the pool is currently at 69 degrees um it was 71 so it's kind of vacillated
005a little bit we're um we've been monitoring the use of um the propane um because this is a new project for all of us and so we have been looking at that our intent is to open um in on the weekends in the next few weeks um but the heaters do work they are functioning um our goal um temperature is 78 degrees that's the recommended um and then we'll need to we'll probably come back with some discussion once we have an idea of costs um enrollment for next year um preschool Kinder and open enrollment will begin March 1st we're excited about that um and then many of you have asked questions about um Title 9 um just an announcement that the district has um immediately reverted back to the 2020 regulations um from the new
006Administration and we are working with um the trust to determine whether or not we just reopt policy but we will need to bring that back um to the governing board and to the community um other than that that's all that I have M president thank you thank you very very much moving on uh governing board uh member report uh Mr Guerrero nothing to report nothing to report uh Mr Ramirez thank you get VAR here what I'll just pass on to Mr Beach Mr Beach hey thank you for the pass okay I just received it I think uh February CT month so I want to thank Mr Nado and his staff for getting our kids you know I think we have an amazing CTE program yes and it definitely gives our kids our students here at
007RI Rico High School a different pathway other than the traditional College route so thanks to Mr Nado and all his staff and all they do for our rear recal students uh yes uh Jess skyo uh she's our female wrestler she did take sectionals uh she's just as good as her brother Jesse James Octavio goo he's got like four but uh I really think that she has uh the technique and the strength to actually uh take a State title really so I'm really excited uh it's going to be in two weeks from now and uh she' be our first female at a female all state tournament uh to become the first state uh Champion out of Rico you know and what's cool about it is we have a state championship wall and her brother Jesse's there
008he would be right next to him so oh wow yeah her picture and her stats so best of luck to Jess uh boys uh regionals are this week so hopefully sneak one or two in and then the following week is uh state so good luck to all the rests up there uh thanks all the principles I know I sent you an email but uh thanks for all the gifts I'm supporting them right now and uh I did I just want to say I did win a PA award so I don't know if any of the board members received a PA award if you did don't voice it because I want a bask in I got one I told my daughter and she goes Dad they have so many awards over there but this is the
009best one right she just looked up thank you for the PO word and uh that's all I got thank you all righty good job Mr y MREs SM thank you um yes I also want to thank you all for the gifts that you gave us they're really cool so in the past I had asked you to give them to the kids but somehow or another they made them back to me and I'm happy with them so but uh thank you so much and appreciate it I I want to try to get out to your schools I've been really busy with my own job down south so it's been kind of hard this year but want to get out and of course out there to give you a hard time just like to visit you guys
010say hello let you know that I'm around you know so don't feel intimidated if I do go just for constructive purposes only so because I know you guys do a good job you guys know me well if I thought it was a serious problem trust me I'd be there as you well know might not like to like that comment but you I'm just being honest with you I don't see anything I think you guys are really strong you do a great job have great representation in our district great leaders leip so all across the board even you making so thank you um I want to congratulate uh Damian Daman Ramirez senior at R Rico High School competed in the criminal justice leadership and took third competition good job good to go and shout out to
011sank katano for taking the lead in The District Step Challenge cool although it might be a little unfair because the munch they have to take more steps than the older and I just wanted to share something with you um that's I was trying to look for and I had on my phone um Tom Horn who I'm not a big fan of but he partnered with uh cartwheel which is um tella health program and they're offering services for rural districts so I just wanted to know whether you guys knew anything about it or whether were involved in that yes Mr Ramirez I had a meeting last Thursday with cartwheel and um we have another meeting scheduled marks March 6 to review the agreements thank you because you know anything for our kids anything that we can
012get you know for our kids the state good thing and we all know that a lot of kids suffered a lot of mental health challenges during covid and even after after that so anything that we can get to help our kids out I'm all for so thank you madam president I appreciate it thank you thank you very much to all of you uh yes the same piggyback on everybody you know thank you very much especially to the to the principles and the schools for all of their gifts we were really really fantastic like always you guys go above and beyond okay thank you very very much you know to make us feel good and make us feel you know that we that we deserve all this but in actuality you guys are the ones that
013deserve it because you're the ones that do all the all the work over there but thank you very much you know and uh just uh congratulations to all the people and you all the students that are participating in sports you know especially uh the boys that are going to be going for the wrestling uh you know congratulations and I hope they bring you know they make us proud again you know always always um uh I was able to go to the to the twac fair okay and it was I have a lot of fun with that okay um and um you know seeing a lot of people seeing so many I mean it was just so packed over there you know Mr Fanning was running up and down all over the place and you know
014so it was really real really a lot of fun to go down there and you know and see all the community and a lot of people all the kids and everybody you know trying to have a good time and everything so also um Mr um uh Chavez you did something at your school with a hand where the kids came over and did that I don't know what it was called but I got pictures of that you know what was it called I'm sorry Mark your P yeah because the kids did so good with the testing and all that stuff I thought that was amazing I thought that was really really cool you know the kids were all there you know your kids I had got pictures from your kids you know and they're all putting
015them there that's you know that's what it's all about you making our kids feel that they make a difference and stuff so thank you kudos to all of you and um and that's it thank you very much okay so moving forward number four information discussion action uh Santa Cruz Valley Unified School District policies Miss lunderville I'm just going to hand out a couple samples lender these are the saying that you sent this right on the slide nothing changed I apologize there's one additional um it reads Apache Junction on the bottom it's a sample of an existing policy that Miss FR I don't know how to turn this on do it need to be on for the all right so um during our last meeting we talked a little bit about um liquidated damages it's been
016um a topic that I think is important to the board um and so I developed just a quick um developed a quick um PowerPoint just to guide our conversation um and we do not have to make any policy adoption tonight but we do need to determine we to because we have contracts coming out soon and we'd like to bring back any possible policy revisions to the next board um so the first question um and I believe um mrto brought it up District wants to assess liquidated damages um if Andre I don't know if you can click on the link that is right there um I went ahead and pulled all of either liquidated damages um policies um you can see it's quite substantial um the one thing that I found if you scroll down on
017you can see these are all of the districts that have a policy pertaining to liquidated damages or reporting to the Department of Education which is no longer um something that that they that they look into um when someone vacates but um most districts have a policy or a procedure um directly related to liquidated damages what I did find is that the amount are all over the place yeah some districts charge a flat amount you can go back to the presentation thank you um um a lot of districts charge One Flat amount so it not matter at what point in which you request to be released from your contract a flat amount one other thing that I noticed is that districts have some districts have very specific reasoning behind when those damages can be waved others
018do not so um you if you can go to the next the next slide so um as I mentioned the average ranges for liquidated damages are kind of all over the place um currently our district has a tiered system so it depends upon when you request to be released what amount is is charged we certainly can to move forward with with assessing liquidated damages um we certainly can do that tiered system or we could determine one flat rate saita for example is going to One Flat raate um and I don't know if Miss caber is here but I believe it's 1,200 1,00 so regardless of when requests to be released the assessment would be 1,200 um this whatever we do decide it has to go in employment contracts so again we'll need to make make
019a decision how we thought to move forward um so I'll pause there so the first gu discussion point for the board is whether or not we want to move forward with assessing liquidated damages um part of what um districts use is one we're trying we it kind of puts us in a bad position two have someone leave mid mid year right um we sometimes have to pay out that individual leave um and then there's portions of a sub or whatever so um that those are some of the struggles that and some of the reasoning why initially this board had moved that assessing liquidity well me personally I think we should uh assess or not assess liquida damages so I think it be yeah would you like me Mr Guerero what do you think what are
020your thoughts I just have a couple questions I think the biggest question I have is does it sounds like everybody across you know everybody's doing right say everyone the majority said no but it was challenging for me to find a district that is not imposing some level of monetary damages does does this discourage anybody from coming over to our district I mean have we had that discussion or or or anything like that does does it discourage people from employment or anything like that because it's pretty standard I can tell you that it it's never been a question I hire a number of individuals here and I've never had anyone ask specifically about liquidated damages I think what's important is that if we do choose to move forward with this that we have very specific criteria
021in terms of who is charged and when they are charged and um and you know really flesh that out because I think for this board there's been there have been some gray areas and I think my recommendation is to firm that up should we choose to move forward I don't say something there I think it's tacitly understood that every district has this so no it's not really doesn't determine dissuade anybody I don't know I I think the shortage is what it is and I don't feel like this is this is not a reason why we consistently see even when employees when employees leave our district they usually fill out survey with the reasoning why I've never once had that specific topic be deterrent or a reason anything else Mr G uh not at this time
022Mr AMZ yeah well to me it's quite obvious it's very obvious it's Common Sense very super obvious vious that we have to have a way to hold people's feet to the fire like any other District or otherwise principles will struggle they these guys can just take off on you whenever they want to and there will be no consequence imagine having that kind of a world here we have to have a way to hold their feet to the fire with regard to their contract so for me it's clear we need that we need to assess the damages but that's not really what's in question for me that's not what was in question what was in question were the extenuating circumstances that we had and that's a big can of worms there and I I would strongly
023recommend that we we discussed this with a superintendent when he comes back in a study session because there's a lot of stuff that we could put in here to to be more on guard so that we're not treating one person one way and another person another way that's what we've done here it's disgusting because people can come back and they could sue us for it we're not just thinking it's not just indiv idual here it's not just me or like I mentioned before Mr Fanny because really those our situations were parallel and we got treated differently completely differently for the same parallel circumstances and we're going to get sued if we're not careful with this kind of stuff we have to be we have to be consistent just like parents have to be consistent just
024like leadership has to be consistent just like the governing board has to be consistent we have to be consistent with our rules and how we we enforce them so otherwise we're going to run into a lot of a lot of problem so I would strongly suggest that we have a study session which means that we would sit around all of us and discuss it and come up with a A list of things maybe for the extenuating circumstances and it would take some time so I'm glad that you had mentioned we shouldn't we don't have to vote on anything tonight because I thought we should we don't have to vote tonight but please keep in mind that if as we approach contract season and I believe those contracts are set to be brought to the board
025March the first week of March that would only leave the next meeting to really nail down the specifics um and and if if we if not we can we can't go back after we've already approved contracts and issued them and add a clause for liquidated damages um as I mentioned in the very first memo that I sent to the board as it stands right now there is no circumstance that um allowably grants anyone to wave those liquidated damages the way it stands right now there is no procedure or policy in place that this medical or mo mo spouse moving the way it's listed right now it's in the contract we should be assessing it to everyone and they shouldn't have the opportunity to even request to be released without them so so if I'm hearing
026what Mr ramz is saying uh I'm just looking at the existing one that's in the contract you have the process for waving uh damages uh let me go first let me see yeah the contract just has the amounts yeah so process for waving damages employee notification and resignation uh process which is pretty standard uh then it gets reviewed by superintendent and HR department and then it comes for uh to the board what I I would recommend uh just for common practice is maybe we should go into executive session to discuss uh the individual because if the superintendent says I want to wave it but there's three of us that don't agree we go into executive session uh you could say you know we're not consistent this employe uh such and such and this employee same
027exact circumstances and then we can uh have a discussion and then come and take a vote have that option is always listed on oh that's an option but what he's saying is that we should always do that sometimes people feel uncomfortable tell you that I've seen that happen with a lot of governing board members they feel uncomfortable to discuss it you know open public also that there's issues as you well know as everybody knows here that we don't want to discuss in open public because it's embarrassing to individuals we also don't have the right to do that unless we notice them and give them the be here somewhere there's certain rules I I mean do does the board even have an appetite to have extenuating circumstances we don't need to have any pro any procedure
028or policy I do I think that there are extenuating C circumstances there are there are a lot of them there they're things that we can't even dream about in this in this room here there's so many of them the we do have them and they happen to families and there they're tragic things that happen and we should have extenuating C circumstances unless we're just absolutely heartless you know which we're not right that is in our thing we're professional advancement within the educational SE sector uh retirement through Arizona State Retirement uh relocation uh verified medical needs uh there is if a spouse moves correct out so there is uh that's not in policy right now though no it's not but this is this is a Rec this is the prior policy that we had with some
029additional massage language that that I put in there just so the board had a place to start um if they if they chose to do so I like Mr Beach's idea because that could maybe even prevent a study session if we have that and people would be able to discuss it in the governing board executive room and like I think honestly the superintendent's kind of caught off guard on that one he himself I think didn't really remember flashback he can't I mean he's got so much on his plate he's not going to remember all those details so I think Mr Beach is right if we just had a chance if we made a policy we have to go in there and discuss it you know if it's something simple we're just going to go for
030a minute and come right back out but if something that we weren't we didn't foresee it's kind of nice to have that discussion the the recommended language is job transfer of a spouse medical or disability reasons job promotion like someone moves into being a principal we we usually hav't or or you know a different higher level position um and then a lot of districts have other exception or good cause reasons that could then be discussed in executive session um but but we do need to determine the parameters we can't just go into executive session and not have the parameters if that makes sense um I mean every District that I have come across including those who still have asba it's they're pretty standard advancement transfer of a spouse or a medical medical reason there are
031times when it's in the best interest of our district either for legal reasons um or behavior of an employee you'll go ahead and cut ties with them that good cause ex exemption allows the board to have that conversation and executive session and the superintendent too what' you say the superintend with an executive session with what I meant is that he has his say with regard to explaining things just to yes so yeah and if and if you look at any any time that this board has been asked to wave or assess liquidated damages they have had the option to go into executive session so now that you guys are aware of that you definitely can do that but for example if I'm on the next governing board to resign and I don't I just I
032just want to you know I come up with some reason and and I ask and's and that my reason doesn't matter the way it reads right now is I have to pay $1,000 there is no we cannot continue to have discussions about requests for liquidated damages moving forward because we don't have any parameters in which to operate so looking at the proposed one I I like it I would add at the end uh payment and enforcement will receive an invoice upon resignation payable within 30 days unless a waiver is granted non-payment may result in legal action or report State education agencies as permitted by law just to add that one paragraph to uh the existing draft as far as the the amount it says uh to be determined yeah I left that because I think
033you guys I actually like the amount on the current uh contract language which was the three the two and the one the 32 3 two one but I think if I'm hearing you we need to move forward on this and I think a lot of things you know if if we have concerns to to just go into exec session right I would like to see that added on there that we have to go into exec session for each single one this way nobody's caught off part of of policy Mr rire I can I can ask normally we we don't dictate and policy that the governing board's required to go any into any executive session he already explained the whole shebang and I don't want to go over it again but that's that would lay a
034lot of my ask that that question because I don't know we can what kind of what type of language we can put in too and it might not be if you want to add it uh we could just say you know I'd like to go into exec session to discuss because like you said you we don't have to go to every single one I mean why if we know the reason I mean and it's and it's valid or whatever one of the other things that we have that we get the the recommendation from our principles and we need to take those into consideration too you know the principles also have voices you know and they say well you know what I I agree that this person should you know be you know we should you
035know get the the money on then sometimes they say let's just let it go because they've been having a real hard time all year we don't know that you know what I'm saying but the principles do so we have to also take into consideration the principles you know what they recommend okay because that's what we've been doing the last couple of times is you know it was you know um principal recommend recommends that we assess damages or principal recommends that we wave the damages and we've gone with that you know the majority of the time now if we have issues okay then we can go to Executive session if we see that we're not in you know in agreement with all of us but I think that the language is is what I can excuse
036me any reservation is that the option to go on Executive session is agendized always it's required procedurally under the statute the employee also has the right for you to to be present well they they can ask that it be discussed in both that's why when sometimes when people start talking specifically about the employee you'll see me kind of you because unless they have given us notice that they're fine with us talking about them in Open session we should go into a s anyways yeah for out of respect well it's it's it's it's covered by law by law they could sue us for talking about them in an open board meeting without their so we should always go on Executive session so um but I'll pull the statute Mr Ramirez so I can confirm that it
037always otherwise we're just G say business as usual and then nothing's going to change and and what about the the reasonings that is there is is there other I think that's standard I think that's standard yeah and some and we're not adopting any of this we're going to bring it back another time just want to see us do something about the extenuating circumstances and be more consistent about it right it's my angle so the way this reads right the way that we're proposing is that there would only be three valid reasons medical relocation of a spouse where the individual is being promoted to a position that is higher than what they're currently where they where they're currently at again Dr lunderville I I have I think that that doesn't that's going to not Encompass all
038of the possibilities all the all the things that could come about and we make it there could be so many things that happens to a family an individual all kinds of things nothing said in there about death in family Etc there's so many things that could happen and that we don't we can't even dream right probably fall under other exceptions or good cause reasons that then could be discussed during the executive session as to why um I think that I think having those three main reasons really help people think about whether or not their circumstance is is extenuating um but of course if someone's spouse passes away and they need to move on to that's a discussion that you can have an executive session if they have a child that is ill or a family
039member that that's ill and they're not going to qualify for extended leave or FMLA sometimes that's in our best interest and we may I think talking about it I keep pointing over there because we that's where we go but but going into executive sessions allows you to have those conversations freely where then you're not breaking anyone's confidentiality rights in an open session right the root of this problem is why have we allowed why have we uh ruled one way for one person and ruled another way for another person when they have the exact parallel that's ridiculous even you and I talked about that once I mean I I think I think by really having a policy and a conversation and an understanding that we will go to Executive session if anyone on the board wants
040to have a discussion um would help Pro some of that um also as board makeup changes um I think it's important that that we provide new board members or returning board members with training on understanding understanding the policies um it is a lot initially I I but um I do think that that we I agree I think we need to have a more I that your board needs to have a more consistent approach to be reviewing them I I really appreciate that comment I think I'm still trying to understand right um you know I heard heard something about retention right I I I don't think this is the tool for retention um I understand the consequence of people leaving you know Midway and stuff like that um but I don't think this is a tool
041for retention right for me retention is treating people well you know giving opportunities all that good stuff right so you know this is just strictly for the purposes of making up money of what it cost to get somebody else hired get them through the process and all that stuff is that correct pretty much and jar is here as well um if I I but I mean for the most part that that is that is true um we never try to I've never used it as an administrator as a tool to threat it's not intended for that it's intended to protect the district for the losses that we're going to incur as a result of having an employee the other thing that sometimes that sometimes the board I don't know if they're aware of or not
042but we do have challenges covering classes so that means other teachers now they're compensated for it but they still miss out on planning time or I I can tell you personally as the assistant superintendent I've covered multiple classes and I've gone in and covered when we've been short with sped teachers because you have to have certain credentials to be in that room um I mean that's a loss to have you know a district level person going it's not a I don't I don't feel like it's a loss our kids need what they need but but if you look at the the big picture I had to sacrifice something to do that um and I think our administrators can also attest that they spend time covering classes as well so so a quick follow-up question to
043that is have we looked at these numbers to make sure that they still coincide I don't know how old they are or still um up to date yeah so I currently that's our current contract language is less than 30 days less than 60 days and then any anything after that it's 321 um other contract languages other districts I was able to receive there's a 15 some districts charge a, 1500 flat fee it doesn't matter when you leave other districts are charging 2500 for less than 30 days um others are are charging a th000 if they've completed more than 30 days so so the dollar amount like I said it's all over the place um Miss Brown also reached out and and Miss Cabrera we reached out to other districts to get information and it was
044all over the place I think you guys will agree there wasn't like a standard I I saw one District as low as $750 so the dollar amount I think really on on geographically where where the district is located and also just the shear number of we we don't have I know it seems like we have a high number sometimes like looking at what agendas and people leaving but I think in the big picture we really don't have a lot of implo making that requ yeah it's okay with the board i' they go ahead and move move forward I I I would agree so what what I can do is I can um take all of the feedback and and create a draft um would we like it out just policy or procedure a poliy a
045policy is is I think a policy would be a lot better right I I I don't have a a any any other any any concern either way I think with a policy we can attach statute but do keep in mind that the State Board of Education is no longer in the past if you just left your contract the State Board of Education would um take your your teaching certificate away I don't know if they had the right to fine I I I'm not sure but they are no longer I believe Dave said they don't do that so I mean that that piece of it um is something that you know kind of falls to the to the district to decide at this point even despite that in spite of that we still have to have
046a deterrent ourselves to protect the district well yeah it definitely can yeah that would be nice if you put put that together and send it out to us if um if anyone has any additional language or um things they'd like to see added have a chance I like what Mr what Mr um Beach was saying you know to put that little Club so you know you got that one okay because I I like that one I think we need that one there as well you know so that so again not to be mean with anybody but I I don't think our int to make it a punitive thing it's it's what we need to do to protect to protect us and to protect you know our principles and our and our teachers and everybody else
047so and your students because if you got a teacher that's there for you know for for half a year whatever and then you're like you know they're barely starting to you know to you know to get with that teacher and then the teacher is gone and a different one comes in it's really I also do not want teachers who don't want to be here to exactly that that that yeah there's that little the gray area we want to try to do what's best for our students and I think adhering to whatever the board decides and then using the executive session that you have agendized anytime there's a request for release that probably be a good practice okay sounds good thank you thank you on the okay so now our next subject uh B uh propose
048and prioritize topics and possible dates and times for future board meetings Miss lunderville haven't received um thank you madam president I have not received any additional requests for future topics does that list still good it looks good look at it you have it MH yeah so does anybody have does have any anybody have any questions additional topics they'd like add okay yes I'd like to get an FYI on the cartwheel what tell Health art wheel that went out from the superintendent for the rural school districts so if you could give us an FYI on that to see where we stand and what we're doing I'd appreciate it okay all right anybody else anybody else have anything anything to add no no all righty um so we move on right consent agenda uh approval of the
049consent agenda um any there's no recommended changes to the consent to read any matter on the consent okay here we go all right so there any matter on the consent agenda will be removed from the consent agenda and discussed as regular agenda item or items upon the request of any board member does anybody have anything to add anything Mr no what about you Mr ramz no Mr Beach and I have none either okay so um motion to approve and accept what what is it yeah and rectify the consent agenda as present as presented sorry so moved second second okay um what is it any further uh discussions no no all those in favor say I I all those oppose nay eyes have it motion carries what [Music] else I do Al righty so now how
050do iour do okay this meaning is a journ at 610