001all right we are all set so we have the call to order the New Jersey open public meeting law was enacted to ensure the right of the public to advance notice of and to attend public meetings at which time any business affected the interest is discussed and acted upon in accordance with the provision of this act and Board of Education policy 0162 the Board of Education and the Bureau of bamr has caused notice of this meeting to be posted in the uh Board of board office and at the boundbrook uh high school and mailed or facts to the curry news Bound Brook burrow clerk South Bound Brook Board of Education and any other person who's requested individual notice and pay the required fee um Pledge of Allegiance please stand I pledge allegiance to the flag
002of the United States of America and to the public for which it stands one nation indivisible under God I totally blew that didn't I sorry about that folks having a brain for it all right so roll call Mike Mr Ary here Mr ball here Mr bone here Lon here Miss Martinez here Miss Morris here miss Stevens here M Rosano here V here M fio here everybody's here president's comments uh I just wanted to thank all faculty and staff and parents for doing the best they can to make the best of what is the most unusual set of circumstances I know as a teacher myself I said this last time and each week I think it's going to get easier but it doesn't it takes a lot of work to create engaging lessons for the children
003to keep on top of students when they're falling behind um and so as a as a board president I appreciate it as a parent I appreciate it uh and the balro community appreciates it so that's really what I wanted to say um I'd like to um first of all I'd like to thank um Mr B and Mr arrey for their service to the Board of Education um uh M Mr archery has been on the board I think for the last three years maybe four and I know Mr bone you've been here um probably eight somewhere around there um so I just like to publicly thank you guys for your service to the community and to the Board of Education um both of you will be missed um I would just like to uh announce that
004Mr Mr Bale was reelected to the board and the two w in uh winners for the board of education for the other two seats were were Roger zipco and Jay Thomas sy so both of joining the board go ahead Mr I just wanted to concur uh I've enjoyed the tenure that both of you have have had on the board Bill obviously a little bit longer than Tyler but both of you brought uh important discussions different points of view uh and so I really appreciated working with you over the last years so you will be missed and uh good luck and whatever you're going to use to do on your now free Monday nights thank you very much it's been a pleasure serving on the board for as long as I have I enjoyed it a
005lot yeah I just like to say thank you to everyone as well it's definitely been a a learning experience the last three years so appreciate everybody that helped me along the way okay with that I'd like to uh start with the students of the month we'll start with Lamont lamon Annex and Dr s good evening Lamont Annex school December student of the month are Dyan Lozano and Sebastian olera congratulations and we'll move on over to Lafayette school and Mrs Clark for first grade we have Dylan Alano and Matthew Brown for second grade and we'll go over to small e with Mr Edwards evening everyone third grade we have jayen Arias fourth grade we have Anthony Cruz fifth grade we have Quinn zupco and sixth grade eternity Batista congratulations and over at Community School we have
006Mr Santa serma hello everyone the Community Middle School is proud to recognize for December students of the month Brandon Ruiz Fernandez and Doris Amaya inestroza okay um and for bber high school filling in for Mr Smith is Mrs Larson good evening bber High School would like to recognize um freshman Kendall Taylor sophomore Eda Luise Torres Junior araseli prago and senior hostway Fuentes for our students of the month this month all right and we're moving on to our gem Awards and we'll start with Lamont Lamont and Dr s again congratulations with Mrs hindol ker um December's gem recipient Mrs hindel is a team player who is a great rapport with students and staff and is always ready to go the extra mile she has delivered materials to her students homes and always willing to assist when
007need it we are truly lucky to have her as part of the lont anex school family congratulations Mrs hindle and we'll go over to uh Lafayette with Mrs Clark Lafayette Jem for the month of December is Gabrielle an nasta um she's a first year teacher during all the Staffing changes that we had um Mid October to November she always kept the kids at the Forefront remained positive and went above and beyond so thank you Gabriella and we're gonna move over to SMY and Mr Edwards our Gem of the month over at SMY school is Miss Britney chapoli took me many times to pronounce that last name so I'm glad I got a right for her she's been an amazing co- teer this year in fifth grade she usually does science and math but she has
008uh joined herself and her partner to do Ela and social studies with a lot of enthusiasm where she didn't think she could do it and she's done a tremendous job so this Gem of the month is Britney chipowski congratulations and for Community Middle School we have U Mr s surma the Community Middle School gem award recipient is Mrs Laura Zaki uh Mrs Zaki is usually our Pace teacher however this year Mrs Zaki has served as a maternity leave teacher in our science department her colleague describer is having a calm and gentle demeanor this translates into a sincere and heartfelt level of caring toward her students Mrs Zaki has collaborated closely with her colleagues in the science department to create fun and challenging lessons in both the hybrid and virtual platforms she's been meeting weekly with
009her colleagues in the special education Department in order to ensure students academic social and emotional needs are being met the little things that she does such as a verbal warning when a student is not participating or a welcome message rather than a reprimand when a student re-engages exemplifies her sympathetic understanding of what is needed during these difficult times I'm truly grateful to have had Miss Zaki in this role at the Community Middle School to begin this school year and as part of our CMS family thank you Mrs zachi and for bber high school we have Mrs Larson bber High School is proud to honor Miss Mrs Jenifer Nichols um Miss Nichols has adopted to Virtual learning very smoothly she has managed to keep the peer leadership and peer leaders going with virtual lessons and meetings
010holding them to the same standards as when they're in person um additionally she has reached out to students to arrange times to pick up materials as needed and continue to reach out to parents of students who she cannot reach she advocates for her students and their needs while they are home while continuing to hold them accountable she genuinely cares about her students making sure to reach out and ask for help with those that are struggling it has been a difficult year for our freshmen and that they haven't really had a chance to know our school and our staff however they are very fortunate to have someone like Miss Nichols in their corner to help them adapt to the high school life and for the district we have Richard Malin who is our one of our
011apparently Aon translators uh for the district who has um been extremely helpful with uh with a number of things that we have going on especially during this time with covid uh really reaching out to families working with us with the food bank um and just really uh taking a lot of time and spending time with uh individual parents uh communicating with folks and and trying to help um parents who are in need so we'd like to thank Richard for all that he has been doing and going above and beyond so thank you so we're down to committee reports uh the only committee we had was um operations we had operations this evening and we went over the draft of the audit um Valerie do Dolan from naaia will be in probably the second meeting in
012January to go over the audit report for the board um and we should have a final copy prior to that which will go out to the board at that point in time um we also went over uh we had a leak a heating leak over in Smalling in one in the old section um that was fixed and we talked about the push back of Athletics into January um from the governor and NSAA so we are now to the point of open to the public for agenda items only so we have two responses the first one is from Melissa Portillo 675 T Street uh Mrs Romero being moved I think speak for a lot of parents when I say I think Mrs Romero being moved location is a total disservice to our kids at small e
013She translate for so many families Community already has a Bilal staff member I want to know why this is happening um we really can't talk about Personnel matters um but we are making several transfers this evening and she is one of those transfers um we have another one from Kathy X 431 toage Avenue Mrs Romero being moved from to community I find that this move is to service the families in small at this time M Romera has built relationships with family including myself she's willing to bend over backwards for her shoulder moving her during a pandemic in mid year how is How is is that a great service to families that Mr Ramirez helped how is this service to our Spanish speaking families again this is a Personnel decision that um we cannot really discuss
014at this time and that are the only two open uh comments for the agenda that we have um and I don't have any more so we are up to approval of minutes can I get a motion to approve the minutes from 11:16 2020 motion motion Mr fio second second who said the second I'm sorry I missed it Joanna Jo Joanna uh Miss mson second um discussion extensions okay see none Mike roll call solry yes Mr ball yes Mr bone yes M Muson yes M Martinez yes Miss Morris yes Miss Stevens yes M Amano yes Mr valair yes Mr fio yes all right so we're up to Personnel resolutions district and High School um resolved the superintendent recommends for approval the resolutions as outlined in Personnel resolutions under district and high school that is 6.2 through
0156.4 can I get a motion motion motion Mr fio second second second Miss Morris discussion comment okay seeing none M can I get a roll call Mr ay stain Mr B yes Mr bone yes Miss Muson yes M Martinez yes Miss Morris yes Miss Stevens yes M Rano yes Mr V yes M defio yes motion carries we are up to Personnel resolutions middle and elementary resolved the superintendent recommends for approval the resolutions as outlined in Personnel resolutions under middle and elementary school 7.2 through 7.5 can I get a motion motion second Mo motion Mr bone second was that you no Michelle Michelle I'm sorry Michelle it's okay um discussion comment the concern seemed to be that um uh is there another Spanish-speaking individual at SMY now with Miss is Romera moving yes we we have
016uh a couple other people who speak speak Spanish who will be able help out in the office thank you okay see no other comments Mike Rolla Mr ay yes Mr ball yes Mr bone yes Miss Muson yes Miss Martinez like to have stain noted Miss Morris yes Miss yes M Rano yes V abstain and miss defasio miss defasio um I thought I hit yes sorry it's okay right up to education resolutions district and high school resolved the balber Board of Education approves the resolutions as outlined and education re resolutions under district and high school 8.2 can I get a motion motion motion Mr fio second second second Mr velair questions comments discussion I'm glad that we're I'm glad we're adding an investing in the stock market course I think that's a great some sort of
017investment course for kids is is wonderful I wish I had that I was just going to ask is it just the two highlighted classes that are being added I did I miss anything there no I think it's just and the ra the racial Justice is good too yeah no I think it's three I think it's I did miss one yeah it should should have been three it should have been um I only saw two highlighted either Phil was it philosophy or psychology bring him back which we haven't had probably since God Mark that has to be what 20056 maybe um we're bringing that one back then we're bringing stock market and then we're bringing um the one you just mentioned which was the diversity so yeah yeah so those would be the three yeah because
018I only saw the two highlighted so I guess since the other one was already a former course it was not highlighted but that's okay yeah big okay again that that that one course we haven't had in a long time so I'm glad to see that one coming back that was very popular class yeah so is there anything um there anything about votch I I know it wouldn't be in here but votch is an option for high school and V does that V votch does that directly with our with our students we send them a complete list all our students and they do a direct mail okay um this may not be the time to talk about it but when when does information about votech go out to um potential students um it's usually sent probably
019sometime October November of 8th grade of eth grade okay yeah okay any other questions hey Mike broll call alry yes Mr ball yes bone yes M Muson yes Miss Martinez yes Miss Morris yes Stevens yes M Rano yes Mr valair yes and Mr FIA yes we are up to policy resolved that the B Board of Education approves the resolutions as outlined in policy resolutions under district and high school and that is 9.2 can I get a motion motion motion Mr velair second second second Mr fio questions comments I skimmed through these are is this just a lot of housekeeping yes is there anything substant substantial any major changes um there is under um Athletics the and security um they're kind of tying um security and Athletics together with some training um for security uh protocols
020they also have under security there some training for um outside groups that use our facilities at night sa Recreation and things like that so there are some training protocols that are going in there and I've already spoke to um our school uh school safety specialist about doing those trainings when the time comes with those outside groups okay okay okay thank you you're welcome any other questions Mike roll call yes Mr ball yes bone yes M Muson yes M Martinez yes M Morris yes Stevens yes M Zano yes valair yes is the F yes okay we are up to special services resolutions resolve the bber Board of Education approves the resolutions as outlined in Special Services resolutions 10.2 and 10.3 can I get a motion motion motion Mr bone can I get a second second second
021Mr V comments questions discussion can you tell us a little bit more about the um the second one inspired instruction is this something we've had before or is this a brand new training no this is this is a brand new training this is going to be a 4-day virtual training for our prek through six teachers and teachers assistant um um again I know Mark Mark you want to talk about this a little bit or do you want me to I can give a little bit um it's going to be prek through four not six that that changed because of our numbers and we only train up to 80 teachers um basically it's to address issues that came up in our practices with identification of students with special needs um that that's basically what it's going
022to address does that answer the question this is from the audit this is one of our yes to work on okay thank you no other questions Mike can I get a roll call please Mr ay yes Mr B yes Mr B yes M Bon yes M Martinez yes M Morris yes Stevens yes Rano yes s abstain and is the yes okay we're up to finance resolutions uh resolve the Bound Brook Board of Education approves the resolutions it's outlined in financial resolutions 11.2 through 11.9 can I get a motion motion second motion Mr fasio second I think I believe it was Miss Martinez yes yes m um questions yeah the uh the the car's Grant um is that's in line with what we thought we were getting how does it affect our bottom line money that
023yeah that that's additional money that's actually coming from the county freeholders that was they had left over that they didn't use and they they basically gave what they had left over they portioned it out to school districts for reimbursement for of our PP stuff how did that affect our bottom line did that did that fill the Gap that we needed or are we still in a huge hole we're still in a huge hole I think in total mik would they give us 20,000 uh they talking anywhere between 20 and $35,000 depending upon how many districts applied we applied one of the earlier ones and they kept extending the deadline so you know everybody can apply and get it all right and how much how much reimbursement have we gotten all together between local and federal
024um hold on just ballpark I don't need to i p oh actually noine could just want to eat food the fem Grant is uh still pending right we didn't have takes a while obviously right um but we have the uh regular cares grant that we got District direct that was uh better way I think it was $600,000 but I want to give you the exact number it was 629 629 and then we got the cares from the the county and we got what they called a CRF cares Relief Fund which was direct money another 93,94 that's that's what offsetting our child care that was for the child care child care cost that's offsetting all our costs for the child care that we've been doing okay thank you just like I said the hair under 800
025or so over and the theme is still pending so we haven't heard anything back because they thought Co was going to be over and it's not so and supposedly they're they're changing the rules as it comes so I do not expecting a lot back in that okay thank you I have a question on 11.9 can you walk us kind of through what the evaluation would look like and also how how often do we evaluate our program like when was the last time we had we did something similar or have we done something similar okay you're talking about 11.9 yes all right 11.9 is um those are for child study team um independent evaluations so those those are things that are um parents parents may may request um an independent evaluation done outside of our people
026number one or number two if we don't have say a bilingual ldtc we may have to contract out to a bilingual LC to do something or if we run um you know uh bilingual preschool evaluation if we don't have a bilingual person we need to you know contract that out um these the costs that we would pay for those things and this is this is the cap that we have on those costs if somebody asked for an independent one um this is all we would pay so basically this is kind of like a dual full thing it's one it's what um what we pay when we go out if we have to have somebody come in and help us and number two if somebody asks for an independent that's what we're going to cap it
027at for an independent one as well so it's kind of a to thing any other questions okay Mike roll call sry yes Mr ball yes Mr B yes M Muson yes M Martinez yes M Morris yes Stevens yes M Rano yes Mr Val yes with the exstension of check 37207 and 37278 noted and M the fio yes thank you carries other matters to come before the board or new business I can't tell if you're talking or not Michelle no I you know it's just I turned to my husband said I I had something I wanted to say and I got distracted and now I I it'll come back to me at some point so just when it does I'll let you know okay this probably isn't exactly the right moment but I I wanted to
028say that I really enjoyed the online student um teacher I mean the parent teacher that's what I wanted to say it was kind of amazing how how easy it was and I'm not great with this kind of stuff and it went so smoothly I got to talk to everyone didn't have to stand in line didn't have to run up and round and try to find the rooms and had really quality conversations with everyone so I appreciate that how well that went I'm so glad you said that because that is exactly what I was going to talk about um yeah I I mean I don't know if in the future that would be like some sort of model that we I don't know what as far as attendance for for for teachers did most parents were
029they able to to get an appointment that needed one or there parents that were left without a slot I mean how did that go I honestly don't have an answer on that what I'll have to do is I'll have to ask the principles and and kind of get you that data I'll have it for um next month is that okay yeah because I like I said I agree with I concur with Miss Stevens that uh I have never met all of my high school P you know teachers because I'm I'm busy waiting online or running back and forth I I split the load with my husband and he's running in One Direction I'm on the other um so I I I will say just signing in one right after the other was it was wonderful
030so Kudos anything else before we move on um if you guys are okay before I do open to the public um we we have to move um we have to do an approval of the hibs um since it's an approval and we're not doing any reviews i' like to do that now if that's okay yeah that's fine okay so we're going to move to approval of Hib cases middle and elementary resolve the bber Board of Education uh approves the resolution Solutions is outlined in approval of Hib under middle and elementary schools and that is 6.2 Mike can you do a roll call oh wait I need a motion motion Mr second Mrs Martinez now Mike can I get a roll call sure Mr yes Mr ball yes yes m m yes is Martinez yes Morris
031yes Stevens yes Mr Zano yes abstain and and Mr fio yes thank you so we're open to open to the public for discussion and right now we have nine responses so first one is Tatiana 625 Thompson a Thompson Avenue I miss Clash Dojo our next one is from an Marie gonado 15 151 West High Street we need to bring back Dojo it was much more user friendly and easier way to communicate with teachers and get updates younger kids are asked to check calendars mailbox daily they are getting district emails as well as assignments for all classes this calendars uh change during the day and if they don't check again they may not know it's tiresome and stressful for them not knowing what may change from the morning to afternoon parents are overwhelmed with emails this
032takes time some of them away and allows quicker communication and more clarification uh next one amarie gonado again I know that this been asked several times before but can hyperlinks for the board meeting also where ask questions be posted on a district website asked Mr devido to do that last time this came up um it said that it would be done and it hasn't happened yet I will talk to him again about that uh next question is Amry gonado again I know it's been asked several times same question so we'll skip that one um Melissa Portillo 675 T Street um it has come to my attention I think this the same question we had before uh from the other part of the meeting it's come to my attention the board is trying to place Mr
033R community school she's helped so many families as smly who need trans translations why we even consider moving her elsewhere to a smaller school that already has a secretary staff who is bilingual we have discuss Personnel um Patricia O'Reilly 745 Schoolhouse Lane do you think it's prudent to extend remote learning from November 30th to mid January what are the chances that students will stay remote until the end of the school year until June what criteria will you allow students to return in person instruction in January is there any chance that students will have a full day of school eating at their desks the original plan when they return in January or is this a lost cause is the protest from the teachers union the main reason why kids can't have a full day of inperson
034instruction if so what criteria has the teachers union given to the Boe to allow students to have a full day of instruction and in general what is the criteria that will allow kids to have a full day of school private schools have been open more than public schools during this pandemic do you know why this is the case lastly why was a decision made to have Boe meeting fully virtual um there's a lot of questions there I think I'm going to get back to her at with uh or written reply if that's okay with the board well I think um I I'm okay with the written reply but I think that if you're going to to do that that at the next meeting that you should share that so that the public can hear the
035responses to those questions as well absolutely okay we can just add it add it to the minutes if you would like yeah but I think they need to be heard that's fine but I can put it in the minute yes I mean if you if you want me to I'll go one by one right now I mean I mean I I no if you I think that if if you want to have a thoughtful response and that's fine I don't mind waiting I just think that if you're going to do that that the next time that comes around that it that it's shared publicly so that anyone who might have those same questions would like to to hear the answers yeah and that's no problem I can do that okay next one is TR Riley
036nursing homes are now requiring all people entering the nursing home to get tested on site every day they using the test that will will give results of 15 minutes is there any possibility that this will come to the schools I have no idea on that can I also say the rapid 15minute test is only 50% accurate so like they could give them to the nurses but it's not as accurate as a regular covid test is which is I think 85 to 90% accurate I also would think that it would be cost prohibitive unless someone else is paying for it I that seems like a to test everyone every single day is just I think I I I think that would just cost too much well not only that it would be extremely timec consuming to
037try and test everybody every day just think about how timec consuming is trying to get people in through the temperature checks and everything else um now imagine 15 minutes per person at the door just say all right um the next one is Su Del ke from the high school as the board the next board meeting will be the reorganization meeting I would like to thank Mr orchy Mr bone for their service as Boe members um next one is Kelly Helman small school picking back on the board members the virtual parent conferences were mostly successful this year in getting in touch with almost all of my students I enjoyed the format so there's one teacher who is very positive about that um and that is all I have for public comment all right I I just
038wanted to um respond to the uh the first few using Class Dojo and I have to say I know I I I know that when we originally spoke about it that um the use of the Google Classroom um you was so that teachers were using that the Google classroom and and I agree I think teachers should use um the platform um that's provided as far as um giving feedback on work um grades and all the rest of that but as a teacher that is fully remote from my seat um that I have both and I got to tell you that the the class dojo like every morning like I look in if there's six or seven kids that are not in my class yet I get on dojo I'm like your child is not in
039class yet and within within minutes bing bing bing bing bing bing like all of a sudden like people go they wake up their kid they're oh you know I didn't wake them up I didn't know they were and then they're supposed to come after back after lunch and and I go your child didn't come back after lunch and all of a sudden I get like I don't always get them but you know the you know Google classroom doesn't do a text it doesn't it it's a different it's a different type of communication Dojo is for like communicating you know like things that you need to be communicated that are time sensitive like I need your kid now because whatever and I I'll be honest it's it's a free site so I I I don't know
040why we wouldn't encourage any type of communication now now that I'm in in the whole thing um I couldn't live without it honestly as far as I every day you send out a thing your child has not completed this homework and it goes out a mass thing to all the kids that day that did not complete their homework and I'm sending out 15 at one time you know and at least I feel like you know I there's a daily communication that they don't have to go look at an email they don't have to go open something and it it's just a quick way for me as a as as a teacher and and I'm teaching in the fully virtual world since September it's to me it's invaluable honestly it has an autot translate function it's
041it's so much easier as a parent I've got so many emails and notifications I start to ignore them it's background noise but you don't ignore Dojo it it's like an instant message or a text I just I just think being able to text them and say your kid is not here and they'll be like oh I forgot to wake my kid up and and all of a sudden I now they're there if I hadn't had that thing that kid would have missed school that day and Michelle it's it's it's free yes okay if it's another option that will make this situation smoother for parents and teachers I don't see why and it's not it it wouldn't cost the district anything I don't see why we can't bring it back for the short term yeah I
042would I would agree as well being here with with two guys getting multiple emails and having to to navigate through and find it as opposed to something that alerts you I mean I need I need I would really like something a little bit more proactive only because you know we as a teacher at home with my own students I'm constantly checking their stuff now I've just got two more things that I have to ly check and if an assignment gets put in right after I check it then I miss it till the next day and then I feel like a bad parent because I didn't see it and obviously my son is four so he can't read so it's not like he can check it himself so it really falls on me to check lots
043of emails lots of streams and it's as opposed to Dojo which just sends it right to my phone as an alert and I know right away what I need to do so I would agree so what's the disadvantage of Dojo I mean other than the rationale for using all Google platform which getting everybody trained and using that consistently which seems like a good idea why would it be in what way would it be contradictory or problematic to use Dojo as well I just think it becomes a another thing that the teachers have to do because they're going to have to update more than one thing constantly yeah but I don't I think it should be by choice right I mean if a teacher is looking to use the dojo if they're going to use Dojo
044then they're not going to use classroom well no I mean they have different uses I'll be honest Dr Gallagher what I use my classroom for is for inputting class grades doing all my work I post all my work on the Google Classroom right on the stream on the on on the classwork my Dojo is for like hey your kid needs to show up they're not here why are they not here like I can't do that on Google Classroom that it wouldn't go to the parents by the time a parent got to the Google Classroom to even see they already know their kids's not there like so it's they're two different forms of communication and I can see making sure that the people that I definitely agree that they should be using Google Classroom to put
045their assignments on to put the explanation to put um anything you know that supports the the students and the families in and having what they need uh for their lessons but Dojo is more of a a communication of of hey I need you to immediately go get your kid out of bed and they need to come to school I mean I I can't tell you every single day two or three times a day hey they left the meeting is everything okay are you having Tech issues no I just and then they pop back in so that's what I use it for well again and I think from my understanding of things was that they they were using it to push out assignments and everything else so they were not using it solely for just communication
046well then then you can different differentiate between those two things I agree that the the platform of Google Classroom should be for the academics for the for the uh you know for the assignments if because that's what it's there for right I think Dojo should be the informal communication of hey you know like I said I just sent I sent out every day in the morning your kid did not do their homework last night and and I just put all whoever didn't do it and it's just one little and that's all it says and it's just it's then then it's up to the parent to go into with the kid to Google classroom and figure out well what were were supposed to do last night and so that's what I'm saying I just think it's
047the informal Communications invaluable in this in this virtual world because we can't meet face to face at pickup and the teacher says you your kid hasn't turned in their homework for the last cut we don't we're missing that face to face and Dojo sort sort of bridges the gap between face to face we're able to talk it it's and and I understand and again I will we have a principal's uh meeting tomorrow and I will bring this up with the principles tomorrow and we we will discuss this along with um Google Groups which I thought was what the teachers were supposed to use in place of um Class Dojo and see if that's being utilized or not so I will get back to you on this okay anything else all right um we have to
048go into executive session at this time so we're going to Executive session um when we come out of executive session there will be no action taken so we'll be um dismissing from executive session so we will be signing off of YouTube at this point in time so we're going to Executive session under number one number seven and number eight so can I get a motion motion motion Mr five you second second who said second Stevens the stens second all in favor