001good evening everyone welcome to the December 19th 2024 organizational board meeting of the Banning Unified School District Board of Trustees the time is 5:30 please be advised that a recording or broadcast of this meeting is being made at the direction of the board clerk Ruiz please take role if you can trusty Yano present truste Martinez la present trusty novales present I am present and president trumman present please let the record reflect that we have a quorum item 1.2 Board of Trustees oath of office I read that superintendent Davis will administer the oath of office to the reelected Board of Trustees to initiate their new four-year term okay so if we could have our board members who are reelected come down and then I will uh swear each of you in is that too far you
002feel like you're too far away you can come closer if you want just yeah okay yeah that's good excellent you know I think um we should be okay okay are you guys ready so this is the swearing in so you're going to repeat after me so this is the swearing in of trusty Mara agano uh trusty Lucy Martinez Alara and trusty Laura Troutman did you guys think I was going to forget your name okay yeah okay so you're going to raise your right hand and you're going to repeat after me this is the oath of office I say your name that was good do swall do solemnly swear or affirm that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States can you guys hear them back there okay good and the constitution of
003the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States hey let me go back sorry that I will bear truth faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservations or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter excellent great job please give them a round of applause congratulations e is all right sorry about that item 1.3 election of President this item is for the board to nominate and elect a board president for the 2025 calendar year at this time we will be we will begin the nomination and voting process
004for the office of president of the Board of Trustees Mr Davis will you please share how this process will work so good evening this process will follow the Robert Rules of Order which will be the board will take nominations from the floor now the floor is not the audience the floor is the board so any board member can nominate themselves or another member a person cannot said that a person can nominate himself or herself a member can rise and decline the nomination during the nomination process so the way it will work is any one of you can nominate make a first nomination that nomination needs a first and a second and then the board will vote if it does not receive a first or it does not receive a second it dies and then we
005ask for another nomination but if it receives a first and a second then there's a vote if that vote is approved by a majority of the board then that person is the president if it does not receive the votes needed in a majority then we move on to the second nomination and so forth and we'll follow that same process for the clerk after the president good with that okay all right would anyone like to make a nomination please State the name of the nominee I nominate Shelly is there a first I'll first I'll second okay I have a first from myself and a second from trusty Martinez Laura to nominate Shelly Excuse Me Miss Ruiz for the position of board president all those in favor say I all those opposed say nay the motion passes
006congratulations to trustee Ruiz 2025 Board of Trustees president we're skipping to 1.4 election of the clerk this item is for the board to nominate and elect a board clerk for the 2025 calendar year at this time we will we will begin the nomination and voting process for the office of clerk of the Board of Trustees would anyone like to make a nomination please State the name of the nominee I Nomine Myra anano Nom is is there a First what she say Myra is there a first I'll second I have a a first from trusty Martinez Lara and a second from myself to nominate um excuse me truste angano for the position of board clerk all those in favor say I I I all those opposed say nay the motion passes congratulations to trustee angano 2025
007board Clerk of Trustees item 1.5 election of voting representative at the annual County committee meeting on School District organization elections this item is for the board to nominate and elect a voting representative to attend the 2025 annual County committee on School District organization elections at this time we will begin the nomination process to elect the representative to the annual meeting would anyone like to make a nomination please State the name of the nominee can I nominate just can I nominate trustee oh my gosh I'm sorry I'm so nervous trusty novales um no I declin thank you trusty Marin is Laura would you like to accept do I have a second or do I have a first I I first a second okay I have a f first from trusty angano and a second from trusty
008novales to nominate trusty Martinez Lara for the position of board representative all those in favor say I I all opposed say nay hearing none the motion passes congratulations to trustee Martinez Lara 2025 Board of Trustees representative okay item 1.6 Board of Trustees 2025 regular board meeting schedule this item is for the board to adopt the proposed Board of Trustees regular board meeting schedule for the 2025 calendar year is is there a motion and second to open and discuss item 1.6 I move to open okay Leslie excuse me Shelly will second I'm on um I'd like to discuss um i' just like to move um Thursday May 15th to the next um Thursday if that's possible that's the only one that is that the 22nd I don't have my May May 22nd yes second okay are
009we all okay with that yeah okay great can we make those changes Mr Davis yes we did look into that and we do have the space and there will be no issues with that perfect thank you any other question or discussion okay I have a motion from Trust angano and a second from trusty Ruiz to approve item 1.6 all those in favor say I I all opposed say nay hearing none motion passes 5 Z Item 1.7 adjourn organizational meeting do I have a motion to adjourn the organizational meeting I move I second I have a motion from trusty novales and a second from trusty angano to adjourn this meeting all those in favor say I I I I all those opposed say nay hearing none motion passes 5 the organizational meeting is adjourned at 5:43
010p.m. item 2.1 call to order welcome to the December 19th 2024 regular board meeting of the Banning Unified School District Board of Trustees the time is 5:44 p.m. please be advised that a recording or broadcast of this meeting is being made at the direction of the board president Ruiz did ask that I uh run the meeting thank you um as she is a bit under the weather okay clerk angano please take rooll okay okay so clerk angano present Lucy Martinez laara present Leslie novales Shelly of President Shelley ru and Laura trowman present please let the record reflect that we have a quorum item 2.2 Pledge of Allegiance would someone like to lead the Pledge of Allegiance Mr Davis sure absolutely item 2.3 adopt agenda are there any changes to the agenda no changes are there
011any board requests to change the agenda no do I have a motion and second to adopt the agenda as posted I move I'll second I have a motion from myself and a second from trusty Martinez Lara all those in favor say I I I I all opposed say nay the agenda is adopted with a 5- Zer vote item 2.4 student board member comments he is not here today so we'll go to item 2.5 opportunity for Community comments Clos session items did we receive any Community comments we did not receive any comments are there any comments now okay item three the board will now go into close session the time is 5:46 p.m. okay item four we are back from closed session the time is 7 o'clock clerk angano please take roll uh I'm present Mya
012angano uh board member Lucy Martinez Laura present board member Leslie novales present uh president Shelley Ru present board member Laura Troutman present please let the record reflect that we have a quorum okay item 4.1 report from closed session uh um clerk angono please share item 3.1 in Clos session the board received information and was updated item 3.2 in closed session the board received information and was updated as well item 4 thank you for sharing item 4.2 opportunity for Community comment Open Session items have we received any Community comments we did not receive any comments are there any comments now no okay item 4.3 BTA comments I would like to welcome BTA president Anthony Garcia Martinez Laura for committing for another four years um I know it is a huge time commitment and uh it is
013appreciated um second I just want to congratulate uh president Ruiz and secretary angano and uh trustee Martinez Laura for your new positions congratulations and third I just want to wish everyone a Merry Christmas and hope everybody gets time with their family and a well deserved rest thank you thank you Mr Garcia item 4.4 cssea comments I would like to welcome CSEA president Jennifer Sano is she online no okay item 5.1 superintendent comments so good evening or president Ru clerk aano members of the board our community thank you for being here this evening just a few things to report I want to talk a little bit about our athletic programs uh we had a great fall season as we've talked about uh our football team track and field cross country and now we've moved into soccer
014basketball and wrestling so we've already had a lot of success already I believe um our girls and boys basketball team are doing very well as well as our boy soccer team is doing really well well so we're continuing to uh show the magic this year turning around our sports program so that's really good to see so I want to thank all of our athletes uh for their hard work and their commitment in the cold that's coming next I just want to talk a little bit about academic achievement tonight there's going to be a presentation by Educational Services uh about our dashboard and I don't want to get ahead of that I just want to say that we continue to have students grow we're continuing to grow in our district and that's great to ask for
015and that's what's happening uh next I want to thank our all of our people who have participated in the Banning Real Talk podcast if you've been on that podcast can you raise your hand okay okay we have oh all right we have some people who've been on there miss Torres I didn't see that hand up there okay there it is all right so want to just thank you for being on that show uh when I go from place to place people do talk about it people do uh share that they appreciate hearing from students they appreciate hearing from staff it really paints a picture of our community that's not coming from my voice it's coming directly from our staff voice uh I think uh our last Monday release was on our di program dual immersion
016and uh I just I get I'm having a little Goosebump episode right now because it's just powerful in terms of what has happened historically and what we continue to do and people are still here making that program grow uh so I want to thank everyone who listens to it if you haven't listened to it you better ask somebody but we want you to listen but uh I think we are all booked out for this year or just about okay so we have a few openings left for this year if you're out there listening and we'll take listeners from uh or participants for next year too so we want to keep this going because it really does show what we are here in Banny next I want to talk about a couple weeks ago uh we
017had all five board members attend the California school boards Association uh conference which was in Anaheim I think there was I don't know 4 to 6,000 people there uh this is from board members throughout our state where we uh had opportunity to listen and learn but we also had some time to uh socialize and and relax a little bit and enjoy each other's company so I want to thank the board for their time uh from being away from their families from being out it's it's it's a lot you know I typically go to bed as soon as I get home so staying up later it's a lot so I want to thank you guys we had a great time and those things are important for us as a governance team to continue to grow finally
018I want to congratulate our board president missell rice um look forward to working with you this next year and I want to thank our outgoing board president miss Laura Troutman uh as a superintendent you have have an opportunity to really develop a relationship with the people that you work with um and it's not all easy it's not all rainbows and sunshine it's uh there's some challenging issues there's some challenging things that come up and there's some conversations that happen from here to there and we have to kind of determine how we move forward and how we stay Collective that doesn't mean everyone agrees but it means that once the conversations happen we move forward as a team and I'm really proud of this board uh for their leadership as we continue to move forward collectively
019together for the benefit of the school district and our students in community so thank you very much and finally I wish everyone a Happy winter break but I miss our students we don't have students tonight this is a non-student day and I can feel the difference you know from the start so to all our students out there I know some of you follow me on Tik Tok and Instagram I know I know I see you you talk to me about it you want a picture when I see you so I just want to thank you for being involved and engaged and keep moving forward keep growing and just know this we understand sometimes we forget as adults who work with you every day that you're students you're growing you're learning you're developing you're not perfect
020none of us are but we're here to support you and so let's work together as a unit but our goal is to ensure that you're prepared you're inspired um and that we educate you so thank you thank you Mr Davis item six count consent calendar the recommendation is to approve consent calendar agenda items 6.2 through 6.4 as provided all matters listed under the consent calendar agenda are considered to be routine and enacted by one motion and vote there is no separate discussion of these items prior to the time the Board of Trustees considers the motion unless a member of the board or ad administrative staff request that specific items be discussed and or removed do we have a motion and second to approve the consent calendar agenda as provided I move I'll second I have
021a motion from trusty novales and a EX and a second from trusty Martinez Lara all those in favor say I I I all opposed say nay hearing none motion passes 5-0 item seven uh 7.1 Nicollet middle school presentations I would like to invite Dr Cammy Thomas principal at Nicollet Middle School to share tonight's presentation so before Dr Thomas gets started you was supposed to look up remember um so before she gets started I just want to say this because some of you guys might be saying well she was just here and actually that was the end of last year that we started this so we looked at the C calendar because our board agenda not the presentations but the agenda was relatively light we had some space so we wanted to move up one of
022our sites and so we had a principal meeting last Tuesday looking at our our last Thursday looking at all our principles and Dr Thomas volunteered she says I would like to go and fill that spot because I want to update the board on the work that we've done so I wanted you guys to know that thank you Dr Thomas thank you good evening board president ru re distinguished members of the board superintendent Davis my colleagues and the Banning Community I am Dr Cammy Thomas your proud Palamino principal at Nicolette middle school and I'm here tonight not only to wish you a happy holidays but also to give you a midyear update on your favorite Middle School here in banding Unified School District but before I do I want to revisit the slide that I left
023you with back in May um to just kind of update you on what we were looking forward to in the 2425 school year and what we've done so we did in fact send a large group to the Avid summer Institute which helps set the stage for our schoolwide Abid strategies implementation we have a lot of training scheduled with rcoe uh our partnership with them is very strong so that way all of our classroom teachers in all departments uh have the opportunity to solidify their understanding of avid practices for the benefit of all um quite a few of you have students at my school and they all have the advisory 7th period where Abid strategies PBIS and bar strategies are taught and we use the agenda and we have all of our teachers checking our kids
024second set of eyes before they come home so we're really strong with our abet implementation this year I'm also really delighted that Mr Worthington is now our new director of special education after he was with us so we are working very closely with our special education uh Team to make sure that the collaboration between the teachers and case carriers is happening regularly that we have students in their prop proper placement and services and supports within the least restrictive environment are in fact being provided to all of our middle schoolers We are continuing with our I ready program and watching our kids grow in their grade level progress in both Ela and math we will soon have more Jane shaer trainings for our teachers not just in ela but in history and in science as well
025and we are continuing the Irvine math project and enjoying collaboration for the six seventh and eighth grade levels PBIS and our Pack Track program is still growing strong uh our very first gar asada fries Fiesta was enjoyed by more than half of our Nicollet students and our next event which is ramen and Boba Fest will be celebrated on January 10th and my heartfelt Thanks goes out to uh Mr pulsifer and the nutrition services team who made that event that first event and this next event happen so we are going to put Ramen hopefully on the menus for all of our schools maybe but Nicholas will uh nicholet will be premiering that at our second packt Track event which is very exciting uh we also have our PBS points being redeemed regularly with our beautiful rolling
026cart so the kids are super excited about making good behavior choices and being uh integrated in the school Community we also know that I talked about our expansion of band offerings and growing in that program and those of you that attended the Winter concert over at the banding High School pack the Performing Arts Center uh we had a really packed house in the PAC and that was so cool for our kids for our Orchestra and for our band we also had our musicians and color guard pair up with Banning High School for the cowboy Christmas we also have our Cadet Corps going to XTC per they participated in the bont Veterans Day Parade which was great because they showed Mountain View over in balmont how a parade is really done so I was proud of
027our cadetes for that and we are having such a great time with our Mariachi Club if you went to the PAC meeting that was hosted at Nicollet you got to see the club in action so so we're really excited about that club growing and more kids having instruments in their hands uh we've been giving a lot of time in our smart Wednesdays back to the teachers for collaboration they have time every week for grade level or Department time we also have time for collaborating uh in terms of our bar program bar is not just with sixth grade it is with seventh and eighth grade so we are constantly calibrating lessons looking at data and talking about the the wellness of our students ASB and Webb have also been busy making sure campus is a place
028where the kids want to be and we've had a lot of events and student support in the classrooms with our web students going into the younger grade levels seventh and sixth grade classes to give peer-to-peer lessons and delivering tutorials and we have indeed started this year strong and I'm proud to for uh the fact that our team has been making this magic happen with the collaboration with all of the different departments so I said that everyone wants to be at Nicollet and I compared some data from last year this time last year to this year and although we see about a 1.25% Improvement on our Ada uh we can tell that it's still growing we have kids that are coming to class we know that they want to be part of pack trck and they
029want to show that they want to be integrated in our school Community oh this also means that 492 students were packtrack qualified in terms of their attendance so that's outstanding and you can see that we have a lot of stuff going on at Nicollet just in this first semester you can see why they're excited to be here and meet our packtrack expectations it's not just to help them to be successful but it's going to help them be successful as Broncos over at the high school and Beyond and speaking of being successful and prepared for Life Beyond school I just want to mention that our Mesa which is mathematics engineering science achievement uh they attended the annual stepcon conference at the borens Technology Center in October uh they had lots of science um experiments interactive technology
030and they had Roundtable discussions with professionals about what they could do in the future with stem as adults they also competed in the annual UCR roller coaster Challenge and submitted eight roller coasters and completed with uh they competed excuse me with 17 other middle schools and they had a really fun time applying their physics knowledge we also had a competition with coding uh the UCR coding competition which was a week long of event and I have to congratulate Fernando Moto Munoz for placing in the top tier of the coding students who he competed not just with middle but with high school students so that's very exciting so with all of the fun things we have food days like the high school has our pack truck events the dances our Color Run the Turkey Trot we
031have kids that are looking beyond the context of middle school so we have all of our fun rallies we have our music events we had our Winterfest not too long ago our students of the month are continuing our dress up dat lots of fun things are happening at food day we also had um a fundraising opportunity where you could pie a teacher in the face so that is Mr Tucker covered in pie so we have lots of cool things happening our kids are really enjoying the lanyards believe it or not I actually have a handful of students who have certified plushy Palamino pets with their lanyards I've got some hippos I think that's a capy Bara I don't know but the kids are really eating up being immersed in the nickelite culture our sport sports
032teams are killing it we had our flag football get their third championship in a row which was exciting uh so really good things are happening for sports and for Cadet Corps and just all around for our students at niolet Color Run we will be repeating that experience in Spring we will have another one we will announce the date as soon as we get one on the calendar now I'd like to talk about um some discipline now as many people know and as I can can recall coming in as a brand new administrator 3 years ago Nicollet has changed in terms of its reputation I'm very proud of that because the work that the Administration has done our teachers and basically everyone involved to make the school a better place it we're seeing it we can
033feel it you come on campus it's a different place and I presented to you last time how accountability for student Behavior was getting stronger and our documentation is absolutely tightening and we're really seeing what uh discipline challenges we're having both in the classroom and outside of the classroom so we are in fact actually seeing less incidents on campus and I was really pleased to see this data comparison when I ran it today since our last day with students was yesterday and I wanted to give you really real numbers if we break it down you can see that in October this time last year we had a had 119 suspendable incidents that says 56 in October this year there's 103 suspendable offenses last November there's only 45 this year 51 last December there was only 20
0347 this year we're doing something that's helping these children to make better Behavior choices I actually had to run this twice and call my brand new assistant principal in who is a math Guru I was like someone make sure I didn't do this wrong so I was even I was really impressed um with this data and if we break it down even further I showed the data for the year at the last um coffee and tea with Dr tea that I had in in October so for November and December want to just take the data a little bit further so we're really doing a very great job in our discipline office of cataloging wire kits coming into the discipline office what are the referrals looking like and you might notice that in the graph and
035this is all the brainchild of my awesome AP Mr uh Mr Brian Downer you can see that we have a spike in this year for incidents in comparison to last year which is in the yellow if we break down why it's actually tier one behaviors Petty def science in the classroom they are cussing they are doing something that's not a suspendable offense it's kid Behavior they're middle schoolers that need guidance there are kids that need better Behavior choices and as we are doing more mediations with our team with the help of our ATS with the help of our teachers who are using restorative practices our counselors who are helping do those conflict mediations we have actually done 205 mediations this year which I really think has positively impact what our discipline looks like in terms
036of suspendable offenses we're mitigating a lot of problems simply by sitting the kids down and talking through issues it's taken a lot of time and a lot of work but I truly feel that it's making an impact with our students this is also thanks to the work of our bar program which again is not just at sixth grade it's at the seventh and the eth grade level and every month our teachers have dedicated time during smart Wednesdays to talk about our students who have higher seal needs um we have our ATS team at site is no longer at it is with us which has been a blessing truly to have the alternative to suspension team back at nicholet we have our very strong PBIS program rewarding those positive behaviors and again the high standards in
037the classroom thanks to the Avid training and the best practices in our classrooms I truly believe are helping our school as a whole to raise the expectations and the kids are rising to the occasion 100% uh I had the opportunity to go into classrooms throughout the semester so some of these pictures made it on social media some of them did not but you can see the kids are doing presentations they're creating they're co-constructing they're having discussions uh we've had a lot of really cool math talks happening if you ever get the opportunity to come visit come and see a math class these kids are getting up and doing these math problems some of my squirel children they are getting up and using that energy to go around the room and do math problems there's lots
038of talking there's lots of work still to be done to be certain there's a lot to be done in terms of inquiry and getting the kids to use academic vocabulary but we are right there my friends we are right there on getting these kids fully and wholeheartedly prepared to rise to the expectations at Banning High School and I say that because I ran this data and I apologize again to Edith for taking so long to get this presentation to her because I really wanted the numbers to be correct when I presented to you tonight so 614 students at Nicollet have no D or F grades in semester 1 that's 63% of the school have a b and c grades now grades aren't everything but I'll tell you we've got some smart kids on this campus
039who not only are meeting our attendance goals or meeting our Behavior goals but they are killing it in the classroom with no D andf grades so way to go all of my palominos that are watching parents your kids do not deserve coal they need to get whatever it is they asked for for Christmas because that is outstanding I'm so very very proud of our kids now I want to break those numbers down a little bit because this is just so exciting and shout out to our math coach Miss Roland for helping me with these numbers I taught French not math so I appreciate her help for my sixth graders there was 354 A's 243 BS 166 C's and only 74 DS and 91 FS those sixth graders did a fabulous job so my elementary colleagues
040thank you so much for sending us prepared little sixth graders my seventh graders the highest category was a grades for seventh graders 327 A's that's outstanding and for 8th grade we had 261 A's but we've used the word magic a lot and Mr Davis used it and I used it at the beginning of my presentation but I have to tell you there's no magic involved here because it takes a family this entire Palamino family which is the board my colleagues this community and the families within it to make this work it is not just the administration it is it is everyone together to help make this happen for our students so thank all of you guys for your support and we really look forward for continued success in the new year and as we head
041into semester 2 so I hope all this makes you as happy as it did me today running the data I I do have a few questions it's okay Dr Thomas thank you um so the first one regarding the incidents that we have with the numbers are those reported or logged numbers let me go back on this one yes so these are incidents by month for suspendable offenses these are a violations like fighting sea violations like they brought a vape this isn't kids that are let's say they're getting in an argument or they horse playing this is just suspendable offenses this isn't NE this isn't tier one things these are things that would get a kid suspended off campus the education code violations quick question real quick I'm sorry do we know why there's a spike
042in October in both OCT um I hate to say it but unfortunately thanks to social media there is this phenomenon called fight toober uh it it yeah I'm not a fan of social media as you know I've got a very strict cell phone policy for a reason it's because of that so when we've experienced long breaks which parents please monitor your kids social media thank you the next two weeks might be busy um the kids will find time to see what the newest challenge is uh and they might participate in that but if we look at this the reason why we see spikes in our graph it's because of just incident statements being reported this Spike and this graph isn't showing you necessarily this everything was a suspendable offense it's just how many kids visited
043111 and made a statement so we see that Spike because the kids do not have this fear of reporting the kids hear me say every Monday if you see something say something join the Google classroom and I give the Google discipline classroom code and they know that they are able to give a statement um in confidentiality they can give it at home um but this is just showing that we have an increase of kids reporting something or kids that are having an increase in in um tier one behaviors so the other thing if you go back to that last slide sure so uh if you look at September we have a holiday in September there's a three-day weekend there is no other break until we get to November so that is a long stent of
044time where people kids anyone is just in this space and so it it kind of elevates however a lot of districts have uh address that and we have addressed that with uh our Union and staff so next year we will have a break there will be a break in October that gives at least a little bit of a pressure point where people can catch their breath until we get to November so hopefully that will help but I know that's a part of it as well a three-day weekend or I think it's going to be a four day a four day yes but in addition to that having events for the kids to look forward to and having those really high standards within our PBIS program it's working because the kids know hey you don't want
045to make that choice because you could take yourself out of pack trck and especially with our sixth graders who think it's really exciting to be part of this it's it's new to them they're like oh yeah let's make the better choices so I know that just with that break being put in in October and the different systems we have in place these numbers are going to keep going down okay and my other question Dr Thomas um with the slide that follows this one the one with the okay so for tier one um how many of these are repeat incidents do we have that data you know I I would love to be able to look up that number on Aries but as Mr BGA knows we've had some fun with creating queries on Aries so
046he and I will be talking with Dr MOS on how to get the right figures to see because that's my that's my curiosity too um because the way that Aries is set up to make queries there are ways that you can create codes that can help you see that I personally just don't know what to put in for that and I don't know that you would either but that's something I'm curious Ino so we have a couple different um Google forms that we use to catalog data there's a lot in there this is just what we've been presenting for the last couple of months in terms of but repeats yes I absolutely want to take a look at that a deeper dive because one of the other means of correction that we have been doing
047is smaller focus groups with our kids that are the repeat offenders I think I have about on campus maybe 40 kids who are consistently in 111 for one reason or another they're out of class for one reason or another so although it's not reflected in here we do know who those kids are but I can get that for you once I have a query okay that would be awesome as a followup and then I'm all about Di and I know it wasn't really mentioned on this presentation so hopefully in the future we can also get more information on the offerings that we have at your school and what we're looking at to make it more rigorous for our kiddos and how many obtained their skill of by literacy or on the path for that yeah
048and I apologize for not doing that they actually have had some really fun events they went to the tamali Fest not too long ago they really did enjoy that we have um also had a lot of discussions with our students about the expectations we have for them in the classroom as well as for their behavior so we're opening those conversations uh with the SS process to make sure that those kids stay on the straight and narrow too so they are on that trajectory to get the Seal of biliteracy so yeah absolutely next time I appr out I'll make sure I have more for Di but shout out to miss Gonzalez for all her work for Di any other questions I just have a comment um thank you so much for giving the the students ways
049to communicate that are not physical I think having those VOC you know giving them a voice and vocabulary and and ways for conflict uh resolution is um so valuable for them and I see how um positive you are and it's it's really wonderful and thank you so much for that because I think it's very important for them to have that voice and know how to use it thank you also thank you for taking the time to move your presentation up and doing it today it's it's really appreciated this is this is great these are good numbers this is great progress I'm very impressed thank you very much yeah takes the team so thank you ladies and sir okay item 7.2 Educational Services 2024 dashboard presentation I would like to invite Dr KY Bush and team
050to share tonight's presentation good evening I'm president Ruiz I'm Clerk anguiano distinguished members of the board superintendent Davis a extended cabinet and the community this evening um I'll be talking a little bit about our 2024 California dashboard um just a reminder of course of our mission statement which is at the foundation of all of the work we do um to prepare Inspire and educate our students and so um just a quick recap um the California dashboard is part of our state's accountability system um all districts and county offices um report their progress based upon um the eight State priorities um our dashboard for this year is going to show us the growth we've made from 23 to 24 and this growth will be based upon the number of points a student is away from an
051identified standard that says that they've met standard and so you'll be hearing me talk a lot about distance from standard and all of that means is how many points on average by grade level and subject were our students um distance from standard and so we look at two factors the status which shows us again how close they are and one other thing that Dr Thomas didn't point out that I will point out about Nicollet particularly with their math is that they had significant growth as a School site in terms of how closer our middle school students are towards getting to the standard level for Math and then as you see here there's a five levels and those levels range from very low to very high and then the more important piece is the growth that's
052where we are going to continue to focus on is how are we moving students and we clearly saw an example of that um at Nicollet as our teachers there are making an impact and moving our students forward and so you'll see that growth also comes in five different categories ranging from increased significantly to decreased significantly um and just to note um there are two um priority levels where if we see the numbers go down that's actually a good thing and that's going to be for chronic AB is aend for suspension everything else we want to see the numbers go up okay and so we will jump ahead um you'll notice here for the year 2024 um we are at red and I will say this even within a color we can still have growth as
053an example last year we were 72.6 points below having met standard on average we increased by 7.1 this year we're at 70.3 points but we were able to still demonstrate that we had growth and so by having grown those 2.3 points it was still enough where we're not classified as having gone backwards and so just and I'll point that out again because you'll notice sometimes with the colors you may say well if the color is different as long as we've shown growth within that color and there are certain thresholds for how many points of growth we need to make in order to show that we've moved forward for mathematics um similarly um we are at 108.9 points below standard we've grown 2.8 points and so the thing to note again is that there was growth
054made even within the shift of a color change and can I say it this way I'm sorry I just feel compelled um so the way it works with a California dashboard is their calculation or their what do you call that yes the no algorithm their algorithm basically says we need ex amount of growth to keep you in a color and even more to advance a color correct even though you're growing so we have growth but we went down a color because of their algorithm and so that's what's really important to note the note is We are continuing to grow and we will do this later I think in um the superintendent's uh M year evaluation or evaluation we will break down all of those components in terms of student groups where we see growth in
055certain groups but we don't and then those are the questions that we should be asking why with these student groups or why in this area are we not growing so sorry no no that was an excellent clarification um because that is very true for each of these um priority indicators there are set numbers of points that if you fall within this amount or this threshold it's considered this color if you fall within this threshold it's considered another color and so Mr Davis is spoton correct um in that okay so our English learner progress indicator and so last year you notice we made a significant jump we at 51.8% of our students of our English Learners who made progress on the lpac and this year we had 32.1% who made progress which means they're still making
056progress but it's considered a decline because it did not meet the threshold minimum amount of points the state has designated for a particular color and so we have already been digging into what are some things that we need to look at in terms of our ELD instruction um and we also note that there was an adjustment in the terms in terms of the number of years that students can qualify to be considered a long-term English learner and that is now seven years our College and Career indicator um we are at the prepared level and so we are in orange and last year was our Baseline year and so we are at a 19.6 um threshold for this year um and in terms of the state's threshold of color um assignment that places Us in the
057orange category for College and Career readiness for chronic absenteeism you'll notice here for 2024 we saw a decline of 6.9% which is very good because we want this number to drop we want this number to be zero and so we were yellow last year we're still in the same color um but we have made significant growth in terms of reducing the amount of chronic absenteeism which speaks to student engagement getting students here at school having them to stay here in school graduation rate I'm very very proud um not only did we increase it by 2.3% but it was enough based on the state's threshold to bump us into a green category and so we're very proud of the work um that our schools are doing K12 tk12 or preschool 12 excuse me because work at
058every level matters all of our students will eventually matriculate and we're very proud of that our suspension rates have also declined which is a very good thing um in this one you'll see that there was um a change in color which simply means we met the state's threshold criteria based on their algorithm to put us in a different color but we are declining which is what we want to do and so I'm just putting things all together we know that our focus is going to be making continued growth and focusing on what can we do to improve some of our practices that is going to continue but some very good news that we do have to share um we had a meeting with the California um collaborative on educator education ex educational Excellence so many
059acronyms um and essentially what this group does um for all school districts who have student groups who may have not or who may have received a red in two or more priority areas they look at those districts to say what are you doing to meet those student groups needs and so while we were identified um we made so much growth within our student groups that we were able to exit so we're very proud of that because essentially what that means is we are moving students student groups out of those lower categories and so that is a major part for those of you um who remember hearing about program Improvement years ago and ayp this is sort of the updated accountability model and are there any questions about our did you go over the graduation slide
060did I I may have not been paying attention maybe I was just waiting for thunderus Paws or something I know but that's okay I did and and I'm going to back it up because yes that one does deserve a round of applause because we want our students to leave all of our students to exit the ban Unified School District with a diploma so yes we are very proud of that and it does deserve a round of applause and and Mr Davis I did mention from preschool on up every level contributes toward students exiting our district proficient and prepared very very important Dr Cy bush thank you for this report I did have one question um on reclassification uh was I correct in reading that we didn't have any reclassifications this year um we are still
061in the process we have not I we haven't solidified numbers yet those numbers will be coming later on in the spring okay for reclassifying students from being English Learners to being redesignated fluent English proficient because we will all o want to look at their elpac scores in the springtime to help us make those determinations thank you for that clarification any other questions or comments thank you very much Dr KY bush item 7.3 innovation technology presentation I would like to invite Mr Bara to share tonight's presentation not up there yet uh one second hopefully it's up there soon um uh good evening board president Ruiz uh distinguished members of the board superintendent Davis cabinet Banning Community um I have this slide here as a reminder always a mission statement what uh our focus is here at
062B Unified School District uh here to try to give you a quick brief update on uh technology some of our prior re an updates I do my best to make sure that I don't bore you um or lose you um as I go through these slides uh so uh some of our focuses right now are um cyber security and uh staff device replacement Cycles uh as we all know cyber security is one of the most uh concerned areas of Technology uh there's many threats uh and areas where uh information can be lost and compromised um some of you may be wondering what the what cyber security is there's a lot of definitions out there that exist uh one of the most applicable is that uh cyber security is the practice of protecting devices networks and
063data from unauthorized use and access cyber security isn't just a thing it's not one single piece of software one single piece of Hardware it is a combination of uh resources on our network uh you can see here some of the key pillars of cyber security are to identify protect detect respond and recover uh to these incidences incidents that may happen in our networks I'm also going to talk about our St staff device staff and student apologize there's an error there I should say both staff and student device replacement cycle uh these are important to help us with our budgeting planning um and to also keep us up to- dat with any of the Innovations and changes and Trends and Technology uh user Hardware um and that sort of thing so that we don't stay out
064of dat as uh technology as Trends uh uh change uh when I walked into this environment here some of the you some of the cyber security challenges um in areas of concern were user password requirements um centralized antivirus and endpoint protection uh consistency of tracking of our uh assets uh not just infrastructure but then user assets uh student Chromebooks uh tablets uh device laptops uh that sort of thing uh purging of departed users uh profiles and their accounts and data um as well as end user device patch management and updates basically making sure that all of our devices that are in our end users hands are up to- date receiving the latest patches um and are not uh um uh compromised so in order for us to um get an idea of where the district
065was at so when I first walked into this environment it's you you what what are current practices what exists becoming familiar with all of those areas uh in order for us to have a a road map a plan moving forward um on some of those areas that we felt we were um uh we weren't as secure in uh it's always best to go after the go and seek out the uh the help and the advice of Industry experts so we didn't do this alone uh we actually went out with a a consultant um to De to up um develop a security posture review and basically what they do is they took a look at the existing environment uh we had to give them access this took a a lot of time with between myself and
066other members of the its department and they cross reference that with some some key areas so this is kind of a shrunk version of what we went through uh the four areas in the security and Architectural maturity uh platform uh was our endpoint device endpoint Systems Operations Network and other just broad things like backup um Cloud management that sort of stuff so you if you look on the bottom of the of the screen here you'll see this maturity scale similar to Dr K's uh kazy Bush's presentation you could see how color schemes and shows uh growth and areas of needs so uh the one difference in the color scheme which I was was interesting and love interestingly enough matched with the exception of that gray because it was unknown or non-existent which unfortunately does happen
067even today's environments uh so you'll see there G the red as we all know it's a gap it's usually means something really bad uh that orange means we're evaluating it or we're changing it we're doing something different uh that yellow means installed now you would you would think that hey if it's installed it's working uh that's not always the case which was unfortunately our case here at Banning and then you got operational is it working uh is it doing what it's meant to be doing um but there's still another level which is optimized is it up to best practices is is it designed the way it should be do you have proper training on your staff uh to support it um that sort of thing so as you can see here what I did was
068to try to um um give you an idea on those four categories of what some of these areas look like uh there were subcategories many of them as high as eight so what what you'll see here is in our endpoint area um endpoint area in this category here was all yellow um there were some red but overall it was yellow which basically means we had a lot of stuff installed but none of these things uh were actually uh operational optimized or up to up to par our operations as you can see here was red this is an area of huge concern which is what we're uh some of our focus on right now one of the highlights was on our Network this things this area was like say our firewall um secure access uh remote
069access to our Network that sort of stuff and then other you can see there's a couple of Grays there these things are just non-existent in our environment um with that yellow there on that data protection because we do actually have some uh data protection resources they're just not uh U operational or optimized at this point or at the time of the security posture review uh so after we went through the security poster review uh now it was time to start rolling up the sleeves and uh um identifying where we should start based off of there these industry experts suggestions and recommendations uh so basically you see here is most critical less critical shortterm and long-term uh so um most critical obviously these are the areas where hey we need to hurry up focus our attention
070on these areas identify how we can hurry up and uh fix this under the short term and what can we do longterm uh moving forward 6 months 12 months and kind of uh what what that road map looks like um short-term uh most critical were privileged access management that sort of stuff is basically uh an end user having administrative access to a device um older accounts that sort of stuff things that can create a compromise in our in our environment uh unified systems management this is basically all-encompassing Asset Management uh not just with Hardware but software as well what do we have out there what exists uh endpoint detection and response basically uh modern uh antivirus uh we all we've all heard about the the old ways of protecting systems with antivirus as things as
071Trends and technology and threads have become more sophisticated and in Innovative so has the way that they uh protect systems and um we didn't have any of that stuff in our environment uh the long-term things like email security um in tune deployment these are basically patch management ensuring that our devices have a are on an ongoing schedule uh we're not relying on end users for updating the devices we're centrally monitoring Cally pushing out these uh uh uh patches and updates to devices uh and an and an uh sa sasc Workshop um developing this is a a hybrid type of a solution which also requires training as most of these do so uh kind of putting together a workshop for the team so that we all know what we have to do to protect our our
072Network our data and our resources uh less critical areas over the short term thirdparty risk management uh what sorts of services uh resources do we have out there again are they up to best practices that sort of stuff if or not um basically working with the manufacturers and vendors to make sure that that happens uh pen testing this is penetration testing this is something that I don't uh foresee us having to um uh go through anytime soon what this basically does is you hire a firm and they uh it's called ethical hacking and they basically try to see what they could do to penetrate our environment um whether it's uh um um leaking data gaining access to our systems um seeing if a user out there uh um would open up to uh some spam
073fishing attempts for ransomware and other type of of threats that come in and then of course over the long term is best practices and these are working with manufacturers uh ensuring that our systems are up to what their suggestions are for Best Practices adopting standards um like uh cyber security standards for example working with uh organizations like CIS uh centers for Internet Security uh developing their models for cyber security National Institute for standards in technology uh uh adopting their standards um best practices I've even met with our cyber security um cyber security uh insurance companies uh Keenan um to identify what their best practices are on insuring our uh ensuring safety um of our Network and our resources as well so uh hopefully I didn't uh lose anybody there on that long that really exciting
074um road down cyber secur so um student device replacement cycle we actually have uh there's two types of uh uh devices for our students we have classroom sets and we have takehome um for this isn't consistent throughout all grade levels uh we're still working on developing that consistency and that standard for the district uh so what you'll see there is um um obviously you see a lot of scratch out there on 9th 10th and 11th ninth our high school students they do not have a classroom set they've been onetoone with their take-home um um so our focus last year and this year has been on third uh through 8th grade what you'll see here is it's a year to year-over-year um uh a replacement cycle um that takes us through the life of that device
075so as of right now we're adopting a four-year device life uh expectancy for our Chromebooks for our students uh so you'll see last year as you all know back in 20123 that was a large purchase of Chromebooks so we use that to form and develop this uh replacement cycle for classroom sets uh 2023 we deployed to third through sixth grade of classroom sets 2024 you'll see there we we did 7th and 8th grade uh you'll see that in 2025 and 2026 there's no plan for classroom sets for those grade levels um and then 2027 will be the first year of replacing devices for the classroom sets uh so this helps us again planning budgeting uh that sort of stuff these are the take-home uh this is the take-home I also want to make sure that
076we all understand that these are this is a guideline this is a baseline these documents are fluid there's a lot of things that can change uh these uh these plans these schedules um so this this take-home uh schedule here that you see if you follow the color code it basically takes the students as they matriculate year in and year out uh what our goal is is that when we send a device home for a student it stays with them throughout the life of that device until it needs replacing upgrades uh whatnot uh so if you take if you look at the peach color there on uh for fourth grade in 202 3 uh those are the four that we deploy four grade levels we deployed last year they'll have it in fifth grade in 24
077they'll have it in sixth grade in 25 they'll have it in 7th grade in 26 and then they'll be looking for a new device in 8th grade in 2027 staff device replacement cycle uh it's a lot to look at um so staff Dev device replacement cycle so you you can see here we have a breakdown of all of our school sites in the district office we also broke it down even further for our uh um are three employee user groups uh reason why we did this is because those three employee user groups do not use the same type of device uh there's a lot of different needs at district office level from school site to even Administration uh so we need to be make sure to understand that and be unique and sensitive to those
078needs um so uh we broke down uh the number of devices uh number of employees by School site I had you could see that empty column there in 2020 and 21 it's because my understanding of the district during those covid years went out and made it a large purchase of devices that were mainly focused for certificated there's been some movement with that so we're still trying to kind of capture all of that um but if you focus on 2024 which was this year this was the first year of that device replacement cycle uh we just finished the tail we just finished the the phase one of that which was focusing on the certificated staff the teachers uh phase two will get it well phase two will be replacing the devices for our classified in our
079administrative staff um and as you see there it's got a four-year device uh life uh so in 2028 they'll be looking at a replacement um of a new device and then um 2025 you'll see the the two campuses scheduled for their new devices and so on and so forth so I know I covered a lot I probably went over it pretty quickly so I don't bore you uh but that's uh actually all that I had to cover um on some of our key areas that we've been working on uh they're actually not praying in that picture there um it's actually part of a uh team building activity that took place uh so I decided to use that as a picture to kind of showcase the team and uh their happiness any questions I I have
080a few questions yes ma'am thank you okay so first one is on the staff um table where do where do substitutes fall into that so where we what we're doing we have basically two primary categories for our substitute teachers that are not included on this um so typically with our long-term Subs uh though they get treated as a traditional employee they'll they'll receive a device that'll be assigned and allocated to them they'll receive an user account um and that'll stay with them and that's because you when these long-term Subs when they're here one month three months the entire school year um it doesn't make sense for them to use generic accounts our daily subs those the folks that come in one day two days and then are gone uh some of them we only see
081from time to time so we are working on a substitute student initiative to provide the de provide a set of devices uh to each of the school sites with a generic account uh so that they can log into the device they have access to uh curriculum um uh uh materials that they need for the classroom instruction uh anything that they would have access to for that one or two day period but we have that in place or we're still working we we've deployed uh as of right now I believe we've deployed to four sites I believe hemc H Heming cab is and Hofer have already received their devices I believe Central has already received one of the challenges that we actually have is that we haven't received all the devices back from the teachers so
082we're we're hoping to get those back so that we can allocate those to the school sites for the daily subs and then um my other question is going along with the computers um I know for our arts program initiative that we have do we have computers for our art teachers for our art teachers I don't see why not but I feel you're asking me because there might be a chance that they don't but I don't see why our teachers wouldn't have a computer okay can we can we make sure that they do have access that way if they do need a computer they can have their own computer versus maybe borrowing the teachers and teacher not having yeah we don't want anybody borrowing devices so um and my understanding that what uh the the certificated
083numbers here should include those art teachers I don't see why they don't unless I'm missing something so I'll definitely make sure to follow up with that and ensure that our teachers do have devices and then I'm so sorry Leslie I know you have questions too and then our I don't know if it's the right word the smartboards they all work in our classrooms right say that again the smartboards the screens um they all work teachers can use them I I apologize I just I I I want to make sure that I get the we get the right phrases smartboards is actually a manufacturer and that's they were one of the first innovators of those devices the devices that we actually have in our environment are new line boards we do have a few Smart Ones
084that still exist um I know that there's been some challenges with the the device uh this this replacement cycle um at those School sites where they've been having some issues connecting to them uh and everything we we F we monitor the ticket the ticket queue and any issues that have been going on uh there has been some issues but we've been resolving those as we get to them um I believe the last time I checked the queue was down to only a few tickets at each of those School sites uh but we do understand the importance of getting those things up and running so the team understands the urgency and addressing those tickets okay thank you and then my last question is I I know you're a IT person do we have um I don't
085know help me Mr Davis it's about like a districtwide calendar and I know it goes with our website and our sit so that our parents can easily access events and upcoming things to plan so that's a I'll try to I'll try to do it under a short or did you want to address that Mr so you already tried um so some of the there's there's a lot of challenges in developing the districtwide calendar um and uh um Mr Davis has definitely stressed the the urgency behind this we've been working to try to develop something some of the challenges that we have is that the the the calendar at hammerling doesn't talk to the calendar at Cabazon it also has to do with our practices and the policies that we put in play where if a
086hling event is taking place like say um back to school night and it doesn't say hammerling back to school night and all the rest of the the the the parents Guardians Community see that then you end up having an issue because everybody's going oh wait a second it's back to school night but it's at hemmerling they think it's at their campus so there's there's some challenges there with that process in ensuring that users enter the data correctly but there's also that cross calendaring challenge that we're working on um so the new uh well it's still new it's it's we're only a year and a half into the our new uh AP thrillshare uh website uh so we've been working with them to try to see what we can do to uh resolve some of these
087issues and provide this districtwide calendar um so that we can uh provide that to to the community so in essence uh Mr bero will be working with uh Mr me and the rest of the team to see how we have a place let's just say on the website where we and I know there's like two calendars on there already but districtwide calendar we can see everything so that is that is going to be the next priority that you guys and I know we've talked about it but we're going to move past talking about it and we have to make it happen so we'll have further conversation about that that's F my question's very simple um when we were talking about cyber security I know a couple of years ago um the California state had grants
088specifically for cyber security do they still exist and do we qualify so some of those grants have already expired so there was actually a grant that was uh just uh initiated this last year I know that on the state level and the federal level they're doing what they can to try to help curve some of these or lack of funding issues with cyber security so this latest round that just happened it's it was uh my understanding I believe it was through usack which is the same organization that provides funding for rate uh did push did have a cyber security Grant um very limited dollars and it was basically um kind of tailored towards those school districts that have already went through challenges like the LA unified um so fortunately to us we haven't gone through
089those uh yet I'm superstitious all knock on wood but uh um those dollars were pretty much uh already earmarked for those districts that had went through these ransomware attacks or data leaks um and everybody that I talked to all of our vendors our rate Consultants basically said hey we can go through we can write the grant but it's you probably got a 1% chance of it coming to a Banning it's it they're going to they're going to focus on those school districts that have already went through those uh cyber security issues incidents okay thank you and then I had one other question um when we replace these uh devices in uh 26 27 28 and maybe I don't know if this is for you or or for Mr Herrera um is does measure o can
090we use some of that measure o money for that typically bonds are not utilized for equipment such as technology devices we do have technology infrastructure on the project list however for actual computers uh that would be other resources thank you thank you Mr Bara item 7.4 Business Services first interm financial report for 2024-25 this item is for the board to approve the 20242 first interim financial report is there a motion and second to open and discuss item 7.4 okay I move I second I would like to invite Mr Herrera who's already prepared to share tonight's presentation good evening president ree clerk angano distri Miss board members superintendent Davis members of the ban unified team and the community joining us both here in person and digitally today as part of the December cycle is providing the
091board an update on our budget uh known as the first inter reporting and before I get into the presentation would like to take a moment here and highlight a few things uh Dr Thomas talked about her music program over at niolet middle schools and we see it here now in a different context the Winter concert we see the brass team there trumpets really going on and we see some um Bells also you can tell it's Christmas right um so want to definitely thank them for uh being able to Showcase them on our presentation also would like to thank um everyone that is involved here School sites and department but especially uh Mr uh Eddie Ramos here and his fiscal team and working through the very delicate and Ever Changing budget process every day it keeps
092on changing it keeps on refining um and so his team is always ready to work through whatever is coming our way budgetarily great so getting into what is known the budget cycle and um providing a couple of things here rolling into the budget projections we went ahead and closed the 2023 24 un audited actuals which known also as the books of last year those weren't finalized when we last reported on the current year budget back in June so now that we have the UN audited actuals beginning balances are revised including carryover unearned revenues and really folded into our current and subsequent year projections it is also based on a conservative um number of assumptions here including enrollment attendance and Staffing we do have more upto-date information helping us further refine those projections and it is
093also a three-year projection So currently we are at the 3:00 here of this graphic um in terms of the budget cycle itself and more to come here in terms of what is to be expected in the next few months the report does include expenditures as of October 31st includes a threeyear year budget projection for the current year and two subsequent years leading up to 2627 uh there are the uh different types of certifications and I'm happy to report that b Unified School District is reporting a positive certification on its current and subsequent years meaning that we are on trajectory here to meet our financial obligations it is a board approved report that is usually by December 15th today is December 19th and because of the timing with the organizational meeting we already submitted everything to
094the county this is really a formality to go through the approval process and provide that information to Riverside County Office of Education and I'll have here Mr Ramos provide additional information on projections thank you Mr Herrera so as part of the first interim process along with accounting for all the financials looking at how we ended the year we also work very closely with the school sites and student services as well as Educational Services to look at how is our enrollment looking so off to the left you'll see in the graph um our 2425 the current fiscal year we have our projection for the 2526 fiscal year in the middle and over on the right hand side we have the 2627 projection of our student enrollment now some of the highlights back in June when we're
095closing out when we were uh developing the budget we estimated that we would have about 4,275 students now when we did a kind of like a snapshot of our enrollment in October on census day our enrollment was currently 4,237 I was coming in a little bit short however it's the enrollment Trends and Analysis is a collaborative effort with student services so we checked in today and it looks like our student enrollment is actually on track with our June projection so although in October it was a little bit low we're kind of looking like our projections in June were were valid one of the uh cohort movements from our students moving from fifth grade into sixth grade and becoming a palomino um previously we were seeing a trend of a negative 9% meaning we were losing
096some students now that trend has decreased so we were previously losing 9% of those students now we're losing about 4% so we're seeing some improvement now as Dr Thomas did that presentation now alls I can think about is ramen because they're they're implementing a lot of incentives for those students they're having some nutritious meals doing a lot of fun things so when we see these Trends improving of our students going from fifth grade to sixth it's no wonder why because of all of the great things that our schools are doing now the uh we are also seeing smaller transitional kindergart classes coming into the district and at the same time when our 12th graders are graduating those classes are really large and so we're having smaller classes move in and we're having uh our graduates
097are some larger classes it does kind of look like it is declining enrollment but because it's different sizes of students coming in now our transitional Kinder uh age requirement will be fully implemented in the 2425 uh excuse me the 2526 fiscal year now so at a very high level let's go ahead and take a look at the revenues and expenditures from first interim so off on the left hand side we have our combined general fund revenues now when we say combined general fund we mean our restricted funds as well as unrestricted now our total revenues was 86 million and off to the right hand side we had our total expenditures at 96 million so our revenues 86 million expenditures larger at 96 million and I'd like to highlight some of the um some of the
098expenditures and revenues that we identified we currently are this budget includes one-time revenues of 1.5 million and that includes interest income we also have one-time expenditures totaling 5.8 million now some of the things that make up that 5.8 million is spending down those carryover funds from prior years as well as some one-time funds now when you remove the one-time income of 1.5 million and you remove the one-time expenditures of 5.8 million and we look at the unrestricted general fund only we have a surplus of 400,000 so which which is really good to note as part of the interim process we take a look at our adopted budget and we do a comparison against first interim so during the first interim process we look at all the latest Staffing we look at all of our expenditures
099and revenues and we say okay what are our updated information let's bring it into the budget now we we do a comparison to see how close we were at adopted budget um just for measurement some of the highlights from our changes is 5.4 on the left hand side 5.4 million in increased revenues and that includes recognizing the full award for the expanded learning opportunities program as well as recognizing some of that interest income some of the expenditures that we're showing in this budget are the one-time off schedu off salary schedule payment to employees as well as utilizing some of the supplemental and concentration carryover we had a 0.20 decrease in our reserves so down at the bottom of the graph on the right we like to keep our reserves intact as much as we can
100and so although the revenues and expenditures are changing we want to keep those reserves as close as we can and so the reserve change was 0.20% it was a fraction of a percentage some of the uh some of the one-time funding we received is from the expanded learning opportunities program in this graph illustrates the funding that we have received and the funding that we fully spent the majority of these one-time restricted funds have been spent down by September of 2024 um you'll notice that the expanded learning opportunities at the top does continue it's kind of really dependent on the State climate um however we have utilized the majority of these restricted funds for one-time expenditures so um in the 2425 fiscal year we had a total of $10 million in restricted one-time funds and you'll
101notice in the subsequent years it decreases to approximately 7.7 million and I will hand it over to Mr Hera for Ada review multier projection thank you Mr Ramos and so now taking a look at a three-year project rection here this uh this here is the table of the major assumptions of development of the three-year budget cycle so first we like to highlight the average daily attendance we have been projecting in the past say 91.5% um average daily attendance meaning the frequency of which students attend school that has been upgraded to about 91.8 and as we do get more enrollment as Mr Ramos explained that number is also anticipated to increase also given some of the initiatives that the student services department alongside with the support of our school sites are working on we are also
102in what is known the three-year average funding uh mythology here uh with the state in terms of our lcff local control funding formula taking advantage of the fact that even though we do have declining enrollment we're able to average out the highest Ada um in those last three years so that we can benefit from you know what is the funding mechanism that best benefits the school district another figure would like to point out that may change here as the cpat sensus day information is being finalized and revised is that the unduplicated P percentage it's currently at about 91% there is an expected increase of to about 92% so working through that process that may yield additional funding for supplemental concentration and last but not least one number that we keep a close eye on is
103the cost of living adjustment for the current year we did see a significant drop from what was previously projected around this time of year last year at 3% went down to 1.07 also projections for 2526 there's a lot of conversation at the moment at the state level in various agencies currently using the most conservative number at 2.46% all speculation until there's the final econom factors collected later on in April where we'll go ahead and Implement into the projections for the new budget looking at the multi-year projection in terms of figures looking at combined balances I would like to direct your attention to the deficits that are currently being projected please note that this is the combined projections including unrestricted and a restricted general fund and so it does include the recognition of expenditures without revenues
104for prior Year Awards carryover um and so that way uh we we do see here a quite a bit of a you know a sticker shock here in terms of that deficit but when we go ahead and drill down a little further into just the unrestricted general fund as Mr Ramos explained even though we have a deficit of 3.9 in the unrestricted general fund looking at that same area just again looking at unrestricted resource ources here it is 3.9 however there is a small surplus of about $400,000 in the current year for various factors one of which is the recognition of Interest which we've talked about quite a bit as we closed the books last year there is Cash balances higher interest rate that are generating this very unique Revenue source for the district that
105is absent in our projections moving forward because of the uncertainty with that interest income so so better picture than what we saw back in June because of the revenue that we're recognizing currently looking at a small Surplus um if we continue to go down to figures our reserve for economic uncertainties did Reduce by 2% but that's all really AR rhythmetic because our actual increase to the revenue excuse me reserve for economic uncertainties is the amount of about $300,000 so our reserves are a little bit larger than they were back in June just because it is a divisor of expenditures we have more expenditures projected therefore it decrease our Reserve also including the assignments um and the reserves for economic uncertainties is known as a reserve cap um as a reminder there is a reserve cap
106triggered at 10% um in the current and subsequent years and will weigh under that 10% there uh another um item I'm worth mentioning here is that the the deficits we see in the subsequent years of 1.1 and 800,000 those are uh true deficits and those are going to be discussed as we continue to gather more information from the state in terms of the cost of living adjustments also get more up-to-date information in enrollment average daily attendance to see how to address those deficits if indeed they will be materializing in the subsequent years looking deeper into the components of the fund balance this is a uh table here showing the difference between adopted budget and first dinim so back in June to today here in December and so we'll like to highlight a few items without
107going too much into details since these are items that we have seen in the past uh there was a change to the unrestricted program carryover and that's really just the recognition of expenditures um without the revenue and so that is a place ER there for those dollars also uh there is supplemental concentration carryover expenditures that we're projecting in the current year that's why we see a decrease of almost half a million and there has been as Mr Bri said here a lot of work going on in the technology um department and our infrastructure so we are still continuing to carry on a line item to work on the infrastructure we were able to increase that by 500,000 also expecting a textbook adoption in the very near future future and also carrying forward the cost um
108of the Labor Relations um agreements as it relates to Health and Welfare in the subsequent years all in all we were able to maintain and increase about 800,000 are components of the fund balance in terms of our next steps uh we're seeking the approval first dinum also Governor's proposed budget will be released in Jan January we will be hearing about a lot more information as it relates to the state budget and its impacts to prop 98 which is funding for school districts including including community colleges we uh we will also be providing in January the update and presentation on the financial audit report from last year um and that would eventually lead us on to our second interim in March so with that are there any questions no questions thank you very much Mr Herrera
109and Mr Ramos okay any discussion or questions no let's see is there a motion and second to approve item 7.4 I move I second I have a motion from president Ruiz and a second from clerk angano to approve item 7.4 all those in favor say I I all opposed say nay hearing none motion passes 5-0 item 7.5 Business Services annual certification of signatures this item is for the board to approve the annual certification of signatures is there a motion and second to open and discuss item 7.5 I move oh second any discussion or questions I have a motion from myself trusty Troutman and second from president Ruiz to approve item 7.5 all those in favor say I I I I all those opposed say nay hearing none motion passes 5 Z Item 8.1 Educational Services
110School plan for student achievement this items for the board to approve the school plans for student achievement for Cabazon Elementary Central Elementary hammerling Elementary Hofer Elementary Nicolet middle Banning High Banning independent study and New Horizons is there a motion and second to open and discuss item 8.1 I'll move a second I'm sorry who Moved thank you any discussion or questions no I have a motion from trusty Martinez Lara and a second from trusty novales to approve item 8.1 all those in favor say I I I all opposed say nay hearing none motion pass passes 0 item 8.2 Educational Services Western Wheels conference this item is for the board to approve Banning High School Automotive teacher attendance to the Western Wheels conference in Las Vegas Nevada is there a motion in second to open and discuss
111item 8.2 I move I'll second any discussion or questions I have a motion from president Ruiz and a second from trusty Martinez laara to approve item 8.2 all those in favor say I I I all opposed say nay hearing none motion passes 0 item 9.1 Human Resources University of Nebraska at Kierney memorandum of understandings this item is for the board to approve the University of Nebraska at Kerney Department of communications disorders memorandum of understanding until agreed upon termination between parties is there a motion and second to open and discuss item 9.1 I move I'll second any discussion or questions okay I have a motion from trusty novales and a second from trusty Martinez laara to approve item 9.1 all those in favor say I I all oppos say nay hearing none motion passes 5 item
11210.1 Business Services deduct change of order 01 districtwide roofing project Phase 2 this item is for the board to approve deduct change order 01 for contracts with best contracting company and the Garland Company Inc as provided is there a motion and second to open and discuss item 10.1 I moved open a second any discussion or questions no I have a motion from president Ruiz and a second from truste novales to approve item 10.1 all those in favor say I I I all oppose say nay hearing none motion passes 5-0 10 point2 Business Services notice of completion districtwide roofing project phase two this item is for the board to approve the notice of completion for the ban and unified school district office District y roofing project with best Contracting Services is there a motion and second
113to open and discuss item 10.2 I move I'll second any discussion or questions no I have a motion from Clerk angano and a second from trusty Martinez Lara to approve item 10.2 all those in favor say I I all opposed say nay hearing none motion passes 5 item 10.3 Business Services camera system Phase 2 project this item is for the board to approve the camera system Phase 2 project adopt resolution number 25-12 no sorry yeah just the camera system phase two project no okay oh is there a motion and second to open and discuss item 10.3 I move I'll second any discussion or questions I have a motion from Clerk angano and second from trusty Mar excuse me trusty novalis to approve item 10.3 all those in favor say I I I all opposed say
114nay hearing none motion passes 5 Z Item 10.4 Business Services contractual agreements this item is for the board to approve and or ratify contractual agreements as provided is there a motion and second to open and discuss item 10.4 I move I'll second any discussion or questions I do have one question on uh the Irvine math project when we started that was that um is that the total amount the $189,000 is that the total amount Dr Cy Bush that 189 would be the total amount pending approval of this evening's um amended agreement okay and or this or this Academic Year okay because we I thought we approved uh last year for this Academic Year that is correct we used it last year um which was the 23 24 school year um we started with our secondary
115sites um and we had um additional money that was spent um for those secondary sites and a small group of our instructional coaches and so this would be a separate separate agreement from the one the money that was spent for the previous Academic Year okay and this 60,000 is that going to the elementary schools um this will be primarily focused at the elementary school to provide teachers an opportunity um to step outside of the class if you will um and observe um some of the staff from Irvine math project to model some of the lessons um that include number talks um and it gives teachers a chance to see um others enact the lessons and they also have some time to work in their professional um great level teams okay and I had one another
116question too um while we're talking about elementary school um are they going to have an opportunity to have any professional development so they can take over um like in the summer are are we planning on doing anything for our elementary students or elementary teachers so it's not just coaches they will have an opportunity to engage in this I from personal experience I can say this was an amazing program and um our teachers spent um about six weeks doing this um in the summertime and it was very the money that we spent on that um didn't have to be repeated because we then we had our coaches and we knew what we were doing I'm just kind of wondering if if we have some kind of a plan for this um to encourage our elementary and
117middle school teachers um in terms of um summer work we actually and this was part of the previous group um did provide some days um in the summer which was actually it wasn't the summer it was before this just before um in right after instruction end it so which would be the end of May um and what we find is we usually get a large number of teachers who participate um but we also try to be mindful that you know many times teachers do like some time um to be off and so we were trying to get it so that we could have this um provided for them during during the school year um and during the day but that is to say that we can still explore um some ways to still provide some
118additional training um and to work with our teams to see what um would work in terms of some suggestions but we would really like to be able to get input when we if we're able to move forward with the training in the spring to see what may be needed next before we make the decision to plan for it for the summer if there's if it is determine that there is more training needed at that time we would evaluate to see what our next step should be and the best timing want to provide it thank you I had a quick question Dr KY Bush just for clarification um the Irvine math project it's supplemental right not supplemental strategies it is not a curriculum okay and that means it's supplemental in the sense of these strategies can
119be used with any math curriculum okay thank you I hate to do this so I just for clarification Miss noas cuz I when you're asking that question it sounds to me like you're asking when we bring something in and we have outside consultant trainers come in on curriculum instruction and we're training our staff we're training possibly osas or other instructional coaches will that transfer on to the coaches right or the internal staff to then be able to train staff is that is that part of your question as well um no I I'm not quite sure no my question was um I understand the coaches and and that's a really important part of it but teachers getting handson so that it's not peac meal so that they have a an opportunity to really see it in
120action so because I'm thinking of time is of the essence as far as our students every day that our students don't have the strategies then you know we I just was wondering if if it's possible for our teachers to have it and then have the coaches as a support system okay does that yes okay sir okay thank you any other questions or comments all right I have a I have a motion from Clerk angano and a second from myself trusty Troutman to approve item 10.4 all those in favor say I I all opposed say nay hearing none motion passes 5 item 10.5 Business Services monthly fiscal Services reports this item is for the board to approve monthly fiscal Services reports Bank reconciliations purchase orders warrant summary and Commercial warrant registers is there a motion and
121second to open and discuss item 10.5 I move I'll second any discussion or questions I have a motion from Clerk angano and a second from trustey Troutman myself to approve item 10.5 all those in favor say I I I all opposed say nay hearing none motion passes 5 Z Item 11.1 board members comments thank you um first of all I would like to uh congratulate president uh Ruiz um and uh clerk angano for their new positions and um I know it's going to be a fabulous year and um I would also like to um congratulate Mr Davis superintendent Davis on his new book uh courageous fire passionate leadership thank you for that I am looking forward to uh reading it over the holidays and it's it's very exciting that we have such a scholar uh
122no it's great and thank you and I I would like to um thank you all for your hard work and wish you a very very Merry Christmas and a and a very peaceful restful I know you guys have worked very hard so thank you yeah okay so first of all I want to thank Laura for being being a great um board president this past year um thank you for taking us all into account and um helping us navigate this the whole year with Mr Davis it was good and I congratulations to um Miss Ru I look forward to working with you um as our board president and I will help you as much as I can as a clerk and Lucy yay for another year as being a representative you're like a rock star in
123that role so thank you for um stepping up for that again so I appreciate that I know this last month since our last meeting there's been so many great events for our district for our students and families that everyone participated in um from the band concerts to sports just everything the performances for the holidays at the schools um just thank you so much for um providing this opportunity for our students and our families to experience um how great our students are um so thank you for that and I hope that everyone has a restful holiday and that you guys get rejuvenated close this year up good and start a new one next year thank you I'd like to also wish everyone a happy holidays and I hope you get much rest much needed rest and
124relaxation congratulations to president ruy congratulations to clerk angano Lucy for maintaining your role for three consecutive years now congratulations you're you are a rock star in this role okay uh so I have a speech good evening everyone as a Schoolboard member I feel a deep sense of responsibility to speak out on behalf of someone who has not only been an exceptional leader within our district but who has also touched the lives of my own children and countless others the recent decision to resend the administrator of the Year award from Johnny Baker is one I find both troubling and unfair and I feel compelled to offer my full support for him I had the privilege of knowing Mr Baker for nearly a decade he was the principal of my son and daughter and from the moment
125they walked through the doors of Cabazon Elementary I saw firsthand what true leadership looks like he cared about each child's growth well-being and future my children and many others are better for having had him in their lives for the past five five years as assistant superintendent of Human Resources Mr Baker has continued to demonstrate an extraordinary commitment to this District in this vital role he has worked tirelessly to recruit retain and support our staff ensuring that we have that we have the best Educators and support Personnel to serve our students the decision to resend the administrator of the Year award in my opinion my personal opinion does not reflect the reality of the tremendous work and Dedication that Mr Baker has shown this is a leader who has devoted years to shaping this District someone
126who has been unwavering in their commitment to our children our teachers and our community it is my role to ensure that we make decisions that are in the best interest of the entire Community we strive to support the those who work tirelessly to make our schools better and we recognize Excellence where it is due to resent this award undermines the principles of fairness transparency and recognition if we as a district cannot stand behind those who have demonstrated exceptional leadership and dedication then we risk losing those excuse me the very values that make us strong it is essential to understand that the administrator of the Year award is not a fleeting acknowledgement it is a reflection of the impact a leader has had over time thank you I wanted to personally congratulate Mr gon our student
127board member but he is not here him and our soccer team brought home the trophy after their tournament that he um decided to attend instead of going to the conference in Anaheim because he wanted to support his team and they brought the trophy home so congratulations to our soccer team at the high school I also wanted to congratulate Miss Cole I noticed that she is now gone but Central Elementary did win the trophy for the uh Christmas parade this year so congratulations to Central Elementary for winning the Christmas parade um and I wanted to tell them thank you for the beautiful concert their Christmas concert was the two-parter and it was really cute to watch the little ones get really into all their performances and the older kiddos give it their all because it was
128like almost their last year or their last year so thank you to all the kiddos over at Central for making our holidays very special and joyful um congratulations to my colleagues once more and I just want to wish everyone a very Merry Christmas and a very um well-deserved restful break please please please stay safe thank you to all of you from the bottom of my heart as always for all your hard work and dedication during the whole year not just during the academic year but during the whole year thank you all right I'm going to try this um I want to thank you guys for trusting me to take on this role I want to thank you for being an excellent leader this year and I want to thank all of you for your time
129dedication and love for our students please enjoy your time off spend time with your families you deserve it okay item 12.1 future board items are there any future board items anyone would like to add um I know we briefly talked about it but the um maybe a presentation sometime soon for um the metal detector devices that we have yeah okay right item 15.1 adjourn meeting do I have a motion to adjourn I move I'll second because I can I have a motion from Clerk angano and a second from myself Laura Troutman to adjourn this meeting all those in favor say I I all those opposed say nay hearing none motion passes 5 this meeting is adjourned at 8:45 p.m. e e e you later okay for