CorpusRecord 167962

Special Board of Education Meeting - February 10, 2025 (Spanish)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Bellflower Unified School District
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Los Angeles County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,207 words · about 79 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening. We're back, convened at 5:04 pm. These topics were discussed in closed session tonight. We're going to address certain points on the agenda. First, first, CD committee appointments. I want to talk about this. We've discussed this previously. I have a motion to approve. Approved and seconded, Mr. Armstrong. Yes, member center. Yes, this committee. I want to assure you that this... I would like to add the Secretary and C member to the committee. Okay. Great. Well, good evening, meeting board members. We have four presentations for you tonight to help with the superintendent search. The first presenter will be Johnson from JAC. Mr. Johnson, you have to push the button. Good evening, everyone. Board. Thank you for allowing me to be here today. That's me, but out of respect to my colleagues. I don't know if

002there are others presenting, but it's an honor to be here. It's not my first time at Bellflower. I was fortunate enough to be here in 2018 when there was a search presentation as well. I believe a search process was conducted, and it was internal, but the points that were discovered in that process were obtained and compiled, and I believe there are still valid points to have a baseline on how things have gone. The district has progressed since then. If there are no questions, I'll start as I'd like. I'm going to give a 10-15 minute presentation, and questions after that, if you'd like. So, let's get to it. Okay, take your time, everyone. We talked about education and how it's declining, and if big things happen in governance, the board and superintendent aren't separate entities. But

003the superintendent does a good job, and good things happen in the classroom. We truly believe that our mission, and what we do differently, is that we spend time ensuring that in our board search, we don't have candidates who move from small to large districts. We spend time selecting candidates with unique criteria. What the board needs, of course, is to ensure there are no surprises. We spend a lot of time checking candidates' backgrounds, talking to them quite a bit, and doing in-depth research. We have a large national search network that we use from all our consultants who work in different offices in California, primarily. And mainly, the only search we do is for superintendent board members. As you've seen, I 'm an executive member in another school district for 23 years. I retired, and a colleague

004of mine retired, as I said, from the board after two years. In a district of 21,000, the county is responsible for quite a lot of work, so I think a big piece is we have 130 consultants nationwide, and with that, you can see the network and the whole network, the invasion they make when people leave California and return to California. So we're a national search firm, but we don't hire superintendents. We help them create the criteria to help them identify the attributes and characteristics they need, but they select the person. It's a big distinction because California is large, but Southern California is quite small and very compact. So sometimes what you see is this kind of candidate shift from California all over Southern California. So in this South, that's how we do it. If we

005find a candidate who fits within your needs, leadership is about owning your job. We're here because California is different, we say, yes, it is different. But leadership is what's needed; the criteria are found everywhere. So with that intention, we make that search a priority. I'm going to talk a little bit about this. When we talk about the criteria you want to have, this next point is that everyone is different. But we have the Passion for this is why other districts had us as their sole search partner to find candidates for school jobs, taking into account the community and their employees. Well, we do, and I still have the data from when we did the work with you. From the partner meetings, we spoke with nine people in District 11, from different groups. So instead of

006having a big meeting, it's a process of space, so we did something more authentic. We search for certified classified personnel, we work with students, community members, and business owners. Young people can give you information as students. Having these conversations with students, talking about the needs they have, it's not surprising that there are things they share and contribute. It's very important. So let's talk a little bit about the track record we have. This is the search team we have. As I mentioned, they've been board members for many years. We've done about 23 searches for different districts, or maybe 25. Bill has done as many as 40 searches, quite a few as well. So I'm going to go over the whys, but I think the most important thing in this is that the candidates we hire... These

007are numbers of 80%. They are still in that position after the last 5 years and have had this type of leadership. They are usually in place because that criterion is important. These are my numbers: 99% of the candidates who have been hired are still in those positions. This is according to MCF statistics. This second slide is critical. It talks about when you think about the search process. Many people take, well, they focus on what they want in a leader, and I would think that being broad are things they should have, but these are attributes and skills. Maybe they should be specific, but they should speak Spanish, for example, because they have been superintendents previously. I work in districts where the leader had to have five years in a classroom. This time, I think someone was

008there for three years and then became an assistant principal. So it all depends on what you want to achieve, the criteria you want to use to choose. Like anyone who does this type of work, we work for the school board; we don't work for the candidates. I think that's critical. And as you can see, there's the fact that we involve diverse experiences, backgrounds, and histories, which helps us focus on what you need here. And you have to Being well-liked is also something that might not seem like a big deal, but when you work every day with critical issues, the type of governance and the school board has to function. They can have passionate debates on different topics, but respectfully. However, when a decision is made, it becomes necessary to work in sync for the future,

009and a good leader can help facilitate that. So, there's no need to rush the process. When you're selected or not, when you reach the end of your search and have a difficult decision about who to choose, let's say the last three or four candidates you could hire. And if someone says, "Those are all the candidates we have to choose from," don't believe them. Sometimes timing helps us. You can extend the timeframe. Sometimes, during COVID, we had 12 candidates who were mediocre, to say the least, and we extended it for another month and got 27 candidates. One of them, from a district not far away, became Superintendent of the Year, a superstar. These are people for whom timing sometimes helps. The timeline and the guidelines you have are important, but I would say never [Music] Never

010choose based on deadlines; that can harm you and your students. It's sometimes better to extend the search time, and that helps sometimes to find the right person. We're going to talk about the different phases. Phase one is where we spend time establishing the foundation for the entire search. We believe that criteria are critical. Spending time finding the characteristics takes hours to do; that shouldn't be rushed. We look for different leadership profiles; they serve a certain purpose, but working with the board is important. It's not a criterion used in every district; it's individualized to your district. Phase two—I already talked about that—I think that when selecting someone, whatever the district, we start by creating the criteria that the board, in particular, likes. And we start identifying candidates immediately. We do n't choose someone on a website;

011our intention is very important regarding the candidates we look for because there will be many people who have the characteristics and qualify for the job. Like last time in 2018, we had 43 candidates in the search, so there were quite a few talented people, and I'm going to say this respectfully, although the board has Other well-known candidates applying for the position, let them compete with the others because what they do reinforces the fact that they might be the best because they are competing in a public environment. I will talk about the interview process. Other people may be early in this process, but there are great candidates, whether internal or external, in the interview phase, phase three. We try to make the hardest job for you. The goal is that you have the same situation as

012before: 40 or more candidates applying. I do n't think you'll have that many, maybe 30 or so. We bring to the board maybe 12 or 12 candidates. It will be a shortlist. Let's say what we do is we filter candidates who maybe don't have the qualifications you say you want. Someone who has been part of a cabinet was suggested to you because it's not a district that's just starting out. A district where if someone doesn't have executive cabinet experience, they couldn't start. It's very complex, many issues, many topics in your district, so you would need people who qualify. And whoever doesn't qualify, who doesn't meet the criteria you're looking for, we send them... A shortlist of about 12 people is submitted to the board, and the board has the ability to interview each applicant. We

013can talk amongst ourselves about who we're calling, why we're calling them, where we think the lapses or shortcomings are. We do background checks so we do n't talk to just anyone, because everyone will say great things about a certain person. We talk to those people, we call three, we talk to additional people at the same time, we ask them what they know about this candidate, what they can tell us about this candidate, and then we talk to our information network. When we don't talk to someone, it's only because, unless they're a superintendent somewhere else, it puts their career at risk by letting their current employer know they're looking for another job. But by identifying a shortlist of 12 people, six or four interviews per person, everything is open because now we're saying we're going to

014hire someone from this interview process. So there are no things we ca n't talk to, or if we can talk to someone, we'll make sure, and there we'll have the opportunity to talk to them. To contact the candidate, we do the typical things you would expect in the interview process. We ask questions; everyone asks questions, but that's limited because some people are great at answering questions and great at doing other things. We set them up in different scenarios. We hold pre- interview meetings with two board members and two other candidates to get to know them in a social setting. In the interview process, as I said, we create a shortlist of candidates. From there, you can decide who you want to interview. You can look at those eight to ten candidates, answering up to three

015or four questions that we've prepared, which gives you more information about those candidates, providing as much information as possible before you make your decision about who to select from that shortlist. So, the interviews, as I mentioned, the role of the board would be that many boards like to have this as part of their interview process. Sometimes there are people who don't allow job applications. With all due respect, I say that if someone isn't comfortable engaging with a committee in a panel interview, maybe they're not the right candidate. I want that kind of process to help you choose. But I also protect my candidates because if Something that comes out, that determines that they are a finalist, that can ruin their careers too, so we deal with issues of confidentiality and privacy, agreeing that there can

016be lawsuits and information comes out of those sessions. They are closed sessions, just like the ones you have; it's private, it's an interview process, but it's with total confidence and privacy. We try to give the Board all the information possible before they make their decision, the best process possible. It helps the candidate become their leader, to know the system because they have been involved. They do n't qualify candidates until they are going to be hired or not. We're going to say here, "These are the things, the strengths we saw in the candidate, other weaknesses," and that information is given to the board in private. Nobody comes into the room. We didn't want to choose because none of that was discussed, like who liked whom or who thought they were great, none of that. But it

017does give the educational board very good information, so there is a record of what the board saw and what the panel saw. In most cases, the panel consists of a representative from each unit, a board member, and someone else, sometimes a former member. A former member, an executive director that the board can choose—it can be one person, it can be a very small group that participates in the panel. Once they have been selected, the next phase makes a difference. Part five is choosing the new leader with the board of directors and determining what is most important for this district. It's not five things, it's typically three things because within those two or three things there are other subcategories that the board of directors has identified as priorities. These priorities are based on the board's vision

018or goals. I have the governance team review the mission statement and the priorities because that can change. They do n't have a practice of what their mission statement is and what it is, and then talk about the goals. There may be a disconnect between what the group that created those things 5, 10 years ago, or maybe longer ago, and whether it is still relevant to this board. Yes, great, but if not, we still have to talk about it. And if their leader leaves for any reason in 10 years, we go back and do the search at no cost to the board of directors. And I probably haven't had to do that at all. I'm going to Let's stop here and allow time for some questions because I don't know if I'm already over time, but

019I'll definitely take questions from the board. Colleagues, is there anyone who wants to ask a question? When you say you guarantee there will be a contingency, how many original board members? Very good question. It has nothing to do with the board members. If there's a change on the board and the majority of the board says it's not working, we go back and do the search anyway. At no cost to the board. And that's in the minutes. But with the exception of travel expenses, which would be mine because I live in Riverside, there's no real cost, maybe a burger from N'Out. But when you say it's confidential, to what extent? I was emphasizing that the process with the candidates, with the board and with the community panel, that process is always confidential until the end, until

020we select the person they choose. It's open to the community and the public, but the other candidates who applied will always remain confidential because their careers are confidential. I wanted to make sure that part is clear. Thank you, Vice President Garza. You mentioned that we should take our time. To choose the right person, if we have to extend the deadline, or if you recommended us, there will be added costs. There won't be additional costs. Thank you, Actuary Churchfield Ben. Thank you for being here. I know I've been here a couple of times, and I think that's nicer this time. One of the things I appreciated was that you said about time and making sure we take the time and do this the right way. I know that was a concern last time, and you said

021the exact same thing, and you were willing. What maybe you didn't want to say, the things people wanted to hear, you kept to that. The timeline is very important. In the worst- case scenario, if she stays a little longer, more time to fill the gap. When you mentioned internal candidates and that they can compete with all the other people, I agree. What has been your experience with internal candidates, and how do you give them a fair chance? I've seen both things happen. That's a very good question. I like to be respectful of people's time and energy and efforts. When someone is interviewing, they put a lot of effort and work into it, and I would say candidly I've been in situations where an internal candidate isn't ready to be superintendent. I respectfully tell the board

022president or another board member to have a private conversation with that candidate. We think they're doing a great job, but if there's an internal person who isn't ready, have that conversation and don't put that person in that position. It should be like a courtesy interview; that doesn't help anyone. And how can they manipulate the board to favor candidates who might already be ready? But if they're given a fair chance, it's about recognizing that sometimes we know the good and bad things about internal and external candidates, and external candidates only present the good things. But if we do our job and do background checks, we'll get the same level of scrutiny from internal candidates as the records show. And sometimes internal candidates get a beating because they've had to make difficult decisions, and they get a

023beating from within. If you're in a leadership position, on a board, in human resources, in business, or as superintendent, everything isn't going to be perfect. It's about being honest and weighing things up with both internal and external candidates. And to see past and future performance and ask the same questions of the same people while the process is going on. Consistency is very important. One more question: I know you mentioned it and I agree, leadership is leadership. So whether it's from New York or someone in California, it's a conversation that would happen regarding what the board of directors is looking for. If someone is looking... Or someone more local, a similar district with similar demographics. That would be part of the search. It's your search. If the board says, "We want to ensure that our candidate

024has experience, especially with the curriculum in California, we want someone who has experience in a district that has x number of students in California for x number of years," we're going to make that part of the criteria. Thank you. Members can give more details. References, background checks, more of the references they provide. What do they do additionally? We ask a series of questions that are the same for all candidates. I'm not going to give all the specifics, but how do you know the candidates? In what way, strengths and areas for improvement? We ask in reference checks. An example of how to demonstrate that is just as feedback. And we ask, "Can you give us two or three other people we can talk to who can give us an opinion of that person's character and skills?"

025And they give us that information. And we do that when we talk to additional people, not just the people they indicated to us. And because our network is national and in California, it's very strong. Each of our consultants is a member of each organization of Superintendents and subgroups, and sometimes a board member gives me information from other board members, from my colleagues, that the superintendents wouldn't have. I was very involved with CSP for a long time. Having that network also helps. That almost answers your question. Yes, thank you. Any other questions? I like the idea of panel interviews. I think the community is very important when you mention having representation from the unions and units. The unions are very important. I like having the possible comments. I've reviewed the data points from the Education partners,

026the sessions, and the level of consistency we heard from all those groups. The comments they mentioned about being transparent, visible, and participating with people at a high level—the transparency thing—was one of the things that came up in the last talks, and I agree, Madam President, that everything the board can do, the community doesn't make the decision; it's the board's decision. But when the community can properly participate in that decision, what I did mention, besides the boards, is that we also put a survey in English and Spanish online, in whatever languages you want. And we are intentional about making sure people know it's there, that they can respond, participate, and stay connected. That way, the board receives detailed documentation. We create a document with all the information for the board. It says what the whole group

027said—not the names of the people, but the classification said this, the cabinet said this, the students said that. And we provide that document to the board and suggest they put it online so it's available to everyone. Then we give it to the candidates. So when they're making decisions, it also helps the board make an informed decision because they heard all the information as if they were part of the process. They have to take a deep breath because they're appointing board members, and we don't edit or correct anything. At least a lot of profanity falls in, but they do give good opinions to show the community that they were heard and took the time to say it. And we're dealing with their children, so it matters a lot to us. It's a document, and we make

028it as available as possible. Thank you, Mr./Ms. Centron. I want to ask this question about the background information. Can you give us references from your previous clients who have used your services that might be similar to ours? district, and I also want to make a comment. I know you made the reference to being here from the 2018 board. I just want to assure you that's not the mindset of this company, that we think we're the same board, that we have the same needs, or that we're looking for the same kind of people. That's very kind of me to say. Frankly, I wouldn't be here if I thought that. I mean, thank you for saying that because I think that having seen the things, the challenges, and the obstacles this board has faced, I know what

029I would be looking for. From what I've read and heard about this board, it's clearly a different board with different values ​​and different priorities. But thank you very much. I appreciate it. Thank you, Ms. Armstrong. I'm going to back that up as well, but we're not just a different board; it's also a different administration. And I do want to ask if we have parents or students who have motor, visual, or speech disabilities, are you going to provide a way for them to participate? We always have. Okay, I'm going to tell you something personal: my wife is a special education teacher. I'd be in big trouble if I didn't do something to make those changes. I know that What he's saying wasn't the most frank comment, but we've done thousands of searches across the country, and

030we've always, always, always made arrangements and modifications for candidates—not from a special needs perspective, but from a language perspective. Whether it's just 500 students or one student, we're going to do what we have to do to ensure that everyone feels their voice can be heard. And I want to say I appreciate that because I didn't meet you in 2018, but I'm glad you want to provide your services to our district. So yes, I appreciate that. I have a little bit of bias, I think I indicated that when I came here, because when I got into health care, this was my first territory. I had Bellflower, Huntington, Compton, South Gate, Inglewood Downs. This is like coming home, Vice President Garza. Thank you, President Stuart. You mentioned that maybe you would do these panels in different languages.

031Do you have people who work for you who can do it in Spanish and maybe in another language? We have someone on our team whose primary language is Spanish. I'm going to have to use a consultant from outside California to manage them, and if there are other languages, we would talk to them. In the district, for example, there's no one on the California team whose primary language is Vietnamese. So we'll work with the district to see if we can do a panel using someone in the district as a resource, or using someone from our office. We'd look for someone in our office, whatever it takes. We'd make the necessary arrangements. Thank you. I want to say thank you for coming back. Oh, thank you. Any other questions? Thank you so much. We really appreciate it.

032Thank you so much. We're going to take a minute to bring in the second group. President, is that okay? If I introduce the second group... Okay, our second group will be Mr. Jo Shapiro and Ruth PR Ashley from the Costco group. Thank you for joining us this afternoon. Good afternoon. It's so nice to be here with you today. As we said, we're from the CASCA group. I'm Jo Shapiro, and she's Ruth Ashley, and we're going to start the CASCA group. Interestingly, our member Frank CASCA started it in 2000. We're 25 years old now. He was superintendent in Ontario, Moncl for many years, and when he retired, he and other retired superintendents started the CASCA group, and I've been very happy to be a part of it. When I retired as superintendent 10 years ago, let's

033see how this is going to work. I think it never works, but no, it's not you, where do they have to point it? Yes, it worked, but I don't know if it was me. The Casca group is also TCG, because of its English. I want to talk about some things that TCG can indicate. The first is trust. It's critical when we work with a district that we have a high level of trust with the board, and we take pride in doing that. Developing trust with the board is our responsibility. We're going to continue with that. You can trust us to keep the promises we make to you. The other thing is your community, the stakeholders. A superintendent— a successful superintendent search— not only works to get you the right superintendent, but also wants the stakeholders

034to have a voice. They want them to feel that they had an opportunity to be involved, and we've been very pleased with the feedback we've received over the years from stakeholders saying that they came and yes, they listened to us, they paid attention to what we were saying. Trust isn't just the board, but also The stakeholders, the commitment, we are committed to the superintendent's success. When you hire that superintendent, not immediately, but we will work with that person at no cost to the District for up to two years because it is critical for us to help you find the right person and for that person to succeed. That is the long-term commitment, apart from our commitment to working with the board. The confidentiality may be critical in a superintendent search. Many candidates will not apply

035if they are afraid that the board's search will not maintain confidentiality. To get the best candidates, you have to trust us and you have to trust us to protect confidentiality. We take that very seriously. The direction is the guidance. We provide it based on our experience, but you make the decision. The school board makes all the decisions, but we are proud that we have a high level of direction and guidance. Some of what we have learned from BFG, which impressed us quite a bit, is that it is a very stable District with 10 distinguished schools, three National Blue Ribbon schools, one Gold Ribbon district, and PB programs recognized for their excellence. This student body Diverse, and the board has focused on equity, achievements, and community. I mention this because this will be a district that

036will truly appeal to many candidates. This is a place where many strong candidates will want to come. You have a good reputation, and the district's stability is backed by the Board of Education. So there won't be a shortage of highly qualified candidates. Now, let's talk about each of us one by one. We'll start with us. I retired about 10 years ago as superintendent of South Pasadena. I worked as a public educator for 42 years. In addition to being superintendent, I was also an advisor to EdLeader 21, an organization focused on bringing 21st-century skills to schools across the country. Before becoming superintendent of South Pasadena, I was an assistant superintendent and deputy superintendent in Burbank. I was also an elementary and high school principal and an adjunct professor at two universities, Western and Kate North. I

037received several awards from different places and am president of the CC group. Besides advising superintendents, I have spent a considerable amount of time in retirement serving as a principal and advisor for governance work on various school boards. Tomorrow I will I'm going to do that too, and that fascinates me quite a bit. I'm also going to introduce my colleague Ruth. Thank you. Good evening, members of the school board. Good evening, staff. It's a pleasure to be here. I recently retired from the Lich Unified School District as Assistant Superintendent of Educational Services after 34 years of service. Although I started as an elementary school teacher and principal before moving to the central office, I spent the last 16 years of my career supervising educational and human resources services. I also have experience as an adjunct professor

038at Long Beach State University and I was also a trainer for quite a few administrators, doing instructional and services training throughout California. I 'm also your neighbor. Although I reside in Lich, my daughter and her family live here in Bellflower. So I'm always out walking the streets of Bellflower with my two granddaughters. And ultimately, they will surely be attending Bf schools in the near future. I'm also proud to be part of a group that maintains a 9.5% success rate. This is the success rate for TCG superintendents who have served for 5 years or more, and research indicates that the average for Superintendents in districts typically serve for three or four years, but closer to three years, and a little over 60 percent of those superintendents have served for five or more years. Whether a firm

039has conducted ten searches or just one search, no number is more important than the number of superintendents with long tenure. So, at TCG, we have approximately two dozen partners and associates that make up TCG. We are very selective about the districts we work with, and continuous communication is key. Dr. Shapiro and I will frequently provide updates, and you will have direct access to one or both of us throughout the search. The process design is based on and tailored to the district and the needs of the school board. One way we do this is by maintaining a large pool of open candidates. Unlike other firms, we do not promote our own candidates. Instead, we conduct a very broad search, looking for candidates who have the capacity to meet the district's requirements. The specifics of the searches

040are also focused on the needs of the specific district. Furthermore, we have open disclosure of the We don't select candidates for interviews like other search firms do, but we do provide a full list and presentations to those who qualify for interviews. However, the final decision rests with the school board. TCG will provide multiple and broad opportunities for community input as well, so the board can identify the unique needs of the district and these criteria for searching for applicant candidates. So we have five phases or stages in the search process: pre-recruitment phase one, where we detail the process and discuss the needs of the school board, conduct surveys, hold meetings with interested people, complete evaluations and reviews of the input from the school board, and create an electronic marketing brochure. Phase two, the regulatory phase, involves

041distributing the brochure, advertising, and promoting. We are TCG; our networks are large and broad, we have extensive records, and we maintain control of the files and all records according to deadlines and other requirements. Regarding one of the things Ruth mentioned when we talked about meeting with the different We hold quite a few meetings with interest groups, and we meet with you beforehand to determine all the groups you want us to meet with. I worked in a district about two years ago where we met with over 400 people due to the number of groups identified. We also have a couple of well- attended community forum meetings, and it will be important for the school board and for you to have a lot of input from all possible interested people. We have surveys for the meetings in

042English and Spanish. After the recruitment phase, we proceed with the applications. We do extensive background checks and reference research on people. You'll find it's very important that some people look great on paper, but we check and investigate references. We go into a lot of detail in doing that. We talk to people who really know these candidates, and when we pass the information on to you to talk about the candidates, you may find that they look good on paper, but we investigate and find out that there may be other things that make up the characteristics of this We want to know about people they work with, parents, acquaintances, their supervisors—anyone who can give us good information about that person. We do very extensive reference checks. We bring in a panel of experts from our firm to

043review these reference checks to help determine who we will recommend to you as your strongest candidates. We will give you every application and package we receive so you can review it, and you have the right to see it. We want you to see it all. We will prepare the candidate report for you. In the report, we will tell you which candidates may have the minimum requirements, those who are qualified and deserve consideration, and we will also present those we think are the most qualified and recommend for interviews. But it will be your decision whether we will interview them or facilitate the selection of candidates for interviews. Then come the interviews. We facilitate everything related to the interviews, but the board conducts the interviews. We meet with you before the interviews and develop the questions with

044you. We have a long list of questions that we will share with you, but we will also share specific questions that... We've developed a process based on what you've determined is important for Bellflower. We'll schedule and coordinate the interviews. Another thing we'll do, and we find this very helpful, is that we prepare a compensation study. We look at similar districts in terms of composition and size to determine the compensation that might be appropriate for superintendents in those districts. This might help you a lot when you're thinking about the contract for your superintendent. Obviously, you make the decision, but we assist in the process. When we get to the final candidates, we go beyond reference checks and conduct intensive background checks with detectives who can give us information on issues that might be of interest to

045you. The next phase is the appointment of the superintendent. Before making the appointment, many boards want to visit specific sites. A couple or two, or all of them, might come and talk to the people where the person works. We'll do that, of course. We'll notify the candidate about their status, and if you want, we can help you negotiate the contract. Some boards want us to help them, others prefer to work with their lawyer, but sometimes we can facilitate this or act as an intermediary in that process. And another thing... What we can help with is preparing the candidate's press release. This is work you don't have to do; we'll gladly do it for you. So... Another unique service that TSG provides is that after the superintendent is appointed, we do the service of setting superintendent

046goals. We are here for alignment and governance workshops for a two-year internship for the superintendent. We do this with a nearby district to help with that. So, the timelines we are proposing—obviously, they have to be finalized with all of you—are a sample. Phase one, PR recruitment, starts immediately and runs until February 28. Phase two, the active recruitment process, would last all of March until April 4 to maximize the opportunity for enough candidates. Phase four, three, will be the selection of candidates for interviews from April 14 to May 14, and the appointment of the new superintendent will be made on May 22 at a scheduled board meeting. And the post-appointment services can last up to two years after the superintendent's appointment, as Ruth mentioned. This is a proposed timeline that we think works, but you make

047the decision with us if it's something that suits you or if you want to change it. But the amount of time is... It's critical that we need a few weeks for PR recruitment, at least five weeks during that period. That means we'll tell you that your new superintendent starts in July. I think it's critical. We're talking about effectiveness. Regarding costs, all our fees are inclusive. We don't charge anything additional to what you've agreed upon. There are no additional expenses for consultants or advertising; we take care of all of that. You have unlimited meetings when Ruth and I work with you. We won't be working for any other District, only District B, and you'll find that unusual. Many firms have their consultants working two or three at the same time. We'll have unlimited meetings with interested

048people. We won't tell you there will be a limit; there's no limit. We receive this support from all our partners, and we do everything you think is necessary. And we have a two- year guarantee. Working with the board and the superintendent, giving advice, and if for some reason someone leaves before the two years are up, we do a follow-up search at no charge. Two-year guarantee: if in two years we haven't found a candidate you'd like to choose and make a deal with, and the person doesn't take the offer, we are willing to... We also do an additional search at no extra cost. This is another thing we promise, and it's unusual when establishing a superintendent. We won't recruit the superintendent for another position. It's not unusual for a firm to help a superintendent get a

049job and then, a few years later, help them get another job in another district. Our job is to ensure that we find a person who stays. We won't recommend that person for other jobs. So, we've listed all the expenses. The expenses include everything you see there. There are no additional charges, and it covers the things I already mentioned: the conversation study, two years of this counseling at no extra charge, superintendent and board meetings, help with the employment contract, and other additional services. We make guarantees that we think are critical. They have been critical to our success in all the searches we've conducted. You make all the decisions. As I mentioned before, we give the guidelines and guidance, but the board makes all the decisions. You have all the information on all the applicants, all the

050paperwork, and everything we've learned from them. You determine who you interview, make the final decision, the first-round interview, the second-round interview, and who you select. We guarantee another Once your selection is made, it will not be recruited by us elsewhere, and there is a free follow-up search if you do not select a suitable candidate or if the person leaves before the two years are up. I also want to emphasize that we do not have a pool of candidates already selected by another firm. I heard that a candidate did not get the position and was told, "Don't worry, we'll get the next one." That's not how we work. We know the candidates, but we will recruit the people who meet the criteria you are looking for for superintendent. We are not going to bring you the

051same candidates for each [Music] next search. We recognize that this is the most important thing you are going to do: hire your next superintendent. We are committed to excellence in the process, and we are committed to finding the best candidate to fill the position for your District B. We are honored to work with you. We welcome any questions you may have. Do you have any questions for Mr./Ms. Garza, Vice President? Thank you, Madam President. In your proposal, you also indicate that you are asking for a handwriting sample. Why are you asking for a handwriting sample? We do that as part of the interviewing process. It is part of the board's process if you wish to apply. Or it's not a critical part of the job. In certain circumstances, they're going to have to do a

052situation where they have to write under pressure, where they have to get information from the staff or the community in a short amount of time. So we don't give them, like, 30 minutes; we give them an indication, and we want to see what they can write in that time frame because, as you know, that's going to happen when that person is superintendent. Many times we think it's a useful part of the process. The second question is, your support services. Can you give me an example of something that supported the superintendent? There are several things, and a lot depends on the superintendent and the needs of the board. One is helping the board and the superintendent determine the proposed management goals, or if that's something that's important, we're going to work with the superintendent and you

053to determine what those goals are. I've worked with the boards to determine what kind of evaluation instrument they want to use. That's one part. And also, ongoing mentoring. Since we placed a superintendent last July, I meet with this person at least once a month in person, and I'm available by email and phone, basically to help address certain problems they may face, even though one has done the work. Before, that lends itself to obstacles one can't imagine, so having that mentorship is very important. The other thing is the governance workshop that we provide, the brochures that... How have we not... I did n't bring a sample, but I'll give you an idea. We're going to put together a brochure that has information about the Bellflower district. And that's going to be important so that people know.

054Also, after we meet with all the focus groups and with the board again to finalize what you think are the district's strengths, that will be included in the brochure. What are the challenges or areas of need in the district? That's more important. What are the most important characteristics you're looking for in a new superintendent? That's going to be part of the brochure, and also the application that will be attached for people who might contact us. It's a way to publicize the position so that it looks more based on your requirements. Thank you, thank you, Madam President. Thank you for being here. I appreciate everything you're saying. I hope you can help me here because between you two, you have a lot of experience and you're very busy. And maybe you could be a little more

055transparent about what you provide for a minimal amount. Two or three months of work and all the training, and they repeat it again for two years. It seems like a lot of work for the company for such a low amount, potentially a couple of years' work. Can you tell me what the interest is? We think our fees are fair for the School District. We want this to be something they can work with and that's fair for the District. We've also determined that this is something that sets us apart from other companies: the superintendent's mentorship. That's what brings out that; it has a lot of value. Other companies say they do it for $0 more. We don't think that's fair. Neither do I. I think that's part of the commitment, part of the cost. Frankly, I

056think we don't charge enough, but we give the best services at a very fair price. I appreciate that. You're also mentioning that you don't have internal candidates. What I mean by that is like a stable. There are certain companies that always bring the same candidates to different districts, who are extremely different. We think that's the best way to determine which candidates to present. We know good people, and through our network of partners and other people, we can identify good people, but we don't want to bring in people who aren't... They don't match what Belflower is looking for. We start fresh with each search, trying to recruit candidates who match the criteria they're looking for. And excuse me if I'm looking at the board, sometimes we get a $1,000 order for a two-year ladder, and I

057potentially want to understand what the added interest is for a client to work with the company to get placed, or with any company, for the candidates themselves. There are candidates, in a way, they're candidates. We do n't know them because we work with them after we place them, but they don't have any other advantage. At least the service we give them is during the research and after the mentoring. They don't have anything else. I want to follow up with my colleague. None of these candidates have, like, a schedule, a fee to be with you. That would be unethical, in my opinion. Board Member Armstrong, thank you for being here. You said you interview up to 400 people in a district. If we do that, that was the highest number you've ever done. So you're not

058going to limit the groups? Let me ask you this: if we have parents or Students or anyone in the community who has a visual, motor, hearing, or speech impairment, or who speaks any language other than English and Spanish, you will be able to get a survey. We determine with the district which languages ​​are available for the survey, and we already have Spanish prepared. But without another language, we work with someone in the district to help us with the translation into the appropriate language. Many services help people with communication; perhaps we will work with the district with the people you use, and of course, we will pay those people to help us. Perhaps someone needs to use sign language or other things. Normally, the districts know the right people, and we can work with them. Actuary

059Churchfield, what are your thoughts on your company's internal candidates and how they compete fairly? What has your experience been with that? In my experience, we like to give everyone the same opportunity. The board of directors will know more about the candidates than we do, obviously, and when it comes time to make the final recommendations, I'll be honest, sometimes there are internal candidates that we don't rank as highly. Like the others, but we also understand that the board does want to interview them because they are in the district. However, we consider them to be in the same situation as the other people. Another question: how do you ensure confidentiality for the candidates until the end? That's an interesting question because we can't guarantee that the candidate will be confidential, but it's in their best interest to

060be confidential. I can only think of one instance where a candidate wasn't, and in fact, it caused problems for themselves. But we guarantee that we will never speak to anyone else. Who are these candidates? And we ask you to do the same because if the information comes out, not from our firm, but from other firms that someone applied to, and those people sometimes withdrew their application because they did n't want it known in their district or because of other people who were applicants. We take maintaining that confidentiality very seriously, and I don't think we've ever had a problem with that. Thank you, sir. Another question: In the process, have you had any issues with the current board or superintendent, a member, or any current party involved in the process, even in the finalist stage? We

061haven't had any issues with a board member who wanted that person to be kept separate, and I... I think I agree that it's not the best way for them to participate. There are ways the board members have spoken with the current superintendents to get information on what they think would be helpful, but as far as the process is concerned, I think it would be the board, and only the board, that has to make that decision. We're not advocating that you involve any other personnel. You are responsible for hiring and working with that person. I mean, in the many searches I've done, we've never had the current or retired superintendent be part of that process. Is there any way you could copy that lady who's there? We pay extra. They've asked us to do that before.

062That sets a good standard, and it could be different depending on the situation because we have someone who's retiring that we want. Yes, we can include them because it's the board's search. I know, when the board retired me, they said, 'I can find someone like you,' and they searched, found someone different, and did a very good job. There are different ways for people to do good work. Any other questions? Thank you very much. We appreciate it very much. Thank you, Mr. Chapiro and Ms. Ashley. Would you like to take a break? What time were you going to start? A few minutes late, would you like to take a 5- minute break? We'll take a 5- minute break and return around [Music] 6:20. Welcome back. Let's continue. It's 6:21 pm. Mr. and Mrs. Acevedo, our next

063presenters are Dr. David Cash and [Name Missing] from Educational Leadership Services. Thank you for joining us tonight, Mr. President, Mr. Board Members. Thank you for the opportunity to present the Educational Leadership Services proposal tonight. Thank you very much, and welcome. We'd like to start with a slide that puts the board at the heart of the process. Some would say that the decision to hire the superintendent is the most important decision a school board makes, and I believe that's true. It starts with all of you being prepared, and with the best people, the experts in this community, coming together to contact your next superintendent. It's very exciting to see that you all have good, rich backgrounds in education and administration, and they're going to be a very good process for this decision. I'd like to introduce

064our team: Dr. David Cash, as an attorney in the courts, has worked in different capacities in school districts in education. He became Superintendent in three different districts: Claricles and the Santa Barbara Unified School District. He is currently the Assistant Dean of Leadership at the University of Southern California, where he taught for the past 7 years. We also have Mr. Mit Terina on our team, and he has a background in medical research and specialized work. He has worked as Superintendent of Student and Educational Services in the Santa Barbara School District, continues to work in the Santa Barbara area, and is a member of the school board in the Unified School District. It's a great team to recognize the process and how it feels to be on the other side, being a member of a school board.

065I am M. I recently became a superintendent, which I am recovering. I retired in June and joined the team. I have 42 years of experience in human resources and innovation, and also for the Rosfield School District, I am an Educational Services Administrator in that district. Now I'm going to pass it on to BCH. Thank you, Dr. Love Board. So that's a quick list of all the associations and organizations that we and our partners belong to. You recognize many of them working in the human resources business. The ones we are most impressed with are... We California education administrators have two sections: North and South. The Academy for Superintendents—not current superintendents, but those who are also trying to become superintendents, maybe in the next year or two—but they at least have some thought about the subject. And

066what's important is that they're talking about issues that are happening right now, and those who are looking at what we're facing in the future regarding how they're going to manage a district, along with the board. So these are things we're looking at across the education spectrum. We have people working with school principals, with superintendents. We have a very large, very broad spectrum, and that gives you an idea of ​​how broad we are in working with you to find your next leader and be your next superintendent. You've already heard of two wonderful search firms. Now, one of them is going to come from us. When we finish, there's going to be another one that's going to present why you're going to choose us, Education Leadership Services. What's the difference? A significant difference is that we have

067a clear understanding of this current educational landscape. We're not a firm with retired people. We have current superintendents who are members of the County team who are superintendents. They are part of the team as some current teams that are members of active educational boards in the state of California. Another significant difference is that we have information networks of partners throughout the state, as far as Shasta and San Diego County and as far as the Sierra Madre Mountains. We also have very broad connections, and our role throughout the state in different organizations that we have worked with has allowed us to work with literally hundreds of superintendents, active superintendents, and people who are training to become district superintendents. Another difference is that in every search we do, we have a member—a coordinator of the board. Torina

068is the current member of the UNIFI SCHOOL. She brings with her experience as an educator. She is also married to a high school literature teacher. Today is about the experiences when there are high school literature students when she gets home. We have very well-connected relationships, not least with the University of Southern California, where I work, where I also... Significant leadership for Lavern College and the University of Rhine, as well as all those universities producing these educational leaders. A significant difference is one that I don't know if you'll hear from another firm: the only search we'll be doing among the three of us. We won't be confusing the searches by doing five or six different ones at the same time. The three of us will focus only on the Bellflower Unified School District. That is, when

069we've had the opportunity to hear from you as the elected board members, we'll hear from the people interested in your community about what you want to see in the next superintendent, and we're going to do a single search based on the needs you've identified for your district. We're not going to bring in candidates who are in other searches who weren't selected by other school boards. With that, I can tell you that the school boards have a lot to be proud of. We all have a lot of work to do. It takes a superintendent to help you lead that work, but you have many things to be proud of. I was very impressed by the program of 20 different pathways for your students. The following are model schools with the Blue and Gold Ribbon. They are

070very identified with their core values ​​so that students have equity in education. Many achievements, congratulations to you. We're going to spend a couple of moments talking about what this search process will look like. It probably won't be different from what you've already heard and what you'll hear later, but the most important thing that happens from the beginning is a planning meeting with the board. It allows us to hear from you in depth and for you to share what you want us to look for, who you want us to look for, what concerns you, and your ideas for the next superintendent. In that planning meeting, we create a timeline of things that need to happen by a certain date, such and such by a certain date, etc. It's transparent for you, the board, and the community

071because we're going to suggest that you post that timeline on the district website so the community has an idea. Ah, I see that what's happening is that the board is involved in this, the search firm is recruiting candidates. It's time to do that. And one more important thing we're going to learn in the Union It's about who they want us to listen to in their community. We're going to suggest that we listen to district administrators, teacher meetings, staff focus groups, special student groups, community events, and general meetings with parents and community members so they can tell us what they want to see in the next superintendent. We're also going to conduct an online survey in English and any other language they'd like to see it in. It will be available to everyone within two weeks.

072With all the information we gather, we'll prepare a report for you and give you some general data, as well as some data that we won't share to protect you. We're going to pass the information with our legal team to ensure that we don't share any information that's outside the bounds of what's legally permissible. But it will be information that you would like to see, not just you, but community members. It will be separated into groups: students say this, teachers say this, staff say this, parents want this, so you have a clear idea of ​​what your community is saying, what they would like to see. And the wonderful thing about that is... When we get to the interview stage of the search process, we have a tool we've created that will essentially allow you to determine

073the characteristics, experiences, and attributes that you and your community have identified in the candidates you 've applied for the Belfer School Board superintendent position. The idea in recruitment and selection is for us to have a complete picture of the people interested in your community. Your job is to go out and find those people who meet the requirements. What you'll receive is that we won't select everyone, but rather those we choose from the group that meets the requirements (1, 2, 3, etc.). You'll see all those applicants, not just those we choose, who we think fit the profile you 've given us. But there will also be someone who might be a step below what you've been looking for, or perhaps someone you're looking for, maybe based on information you received from other sources that we didn't

074receive from the candidates. That could be different in that aspect of the search. Another issue is hiring from a human resources perspective. It really needs to be considered in conjunction with the qualification and search process. That truly addresses the issues that the Belf district is looking for in a superintendent, there's also the aspect that when we choose the person, we will give them a lot of support in terms of advising; it could be from 100 days to 4 years, it depends on what you need. This is something I discussed with human resources. Let's say someone can do the job, they should be able to do the job at least 60%. But there will be 20% that they would like to do. School systems, let's say, everywhere, there are 20% of things they do n't know,

075and nobody knows yet. Has a pandemic hit them or is something like this coming? This hasn't happened to that candidate. So we help them prepare a broad base of what is possible, what will definitely happen, the superintendent's responsibility, but more certainly, what is not on the radar and not foreseen, that could happen. And that is the work we do: to help the new superintendent learn those things. The timeline we propose is absolutely flexible. We haven't established dates that work for the schedules. of everyone and Ah It's very possible to start today, researching, seeing how to move forward and have a new person in place by July 1st quickly. I just want to get to what's important for everyone: how much does it cost? We have a $20,000 research fee. One of the things we're going

076to do after you choose a candidate is that we have a portion in the contract where we will train or mentor the candidate for the first year as part of our all-inclusive $2,000 fee. Because we are committed to finding the best person for Bellflower and supporting that person during a very difficult first year. Whether they have experience, come from another district, or are a beginner without experience in the district, or someone who hasn't had a job, I bet everyone needs to have a coach, someone they can pitch ideas to and learn from, and we are committed to doing that as part of our all-inclusive $2,000 fee. One last thing I want to make sure we're very clear with you is that our goal is to meet the needs of you and the community. I want

077to make it very clear that we are not going to Presenting candidates who we don't think meet the requirements based on what we hear from you and the community is very important. We ask questions if you have any. Regarding the survey, thank you for your time. We can do it in more than two languages, but typically only two languages ​​is what we're asked for. It's an additional expense if you want more languages; it would be $ 425. And when are the in-person engagement sessions? How many sessions do you hold? We'll hold as many as necessary to ensure we get all the community's views. We might also have a faculty meeting at a high school or middle school, inviting teachers to attend. There are some teachers who come but don't want to speak in front of

078the group. We also give them our email and phone numbers and encourage them to contact us. We can talk to them by phone, and they can give us their opinions by email. Our goal is to listen and get their feedback. Regarding those engagement sessions, you put a list on the press. Is that restricted? Only that list on the... Planning meeting: Our goal is to hear from you. Who do you think you want to hear from? I live in Long Beach. I know Bellflower. I don't know it as well as you do, but I grew up here, went to schools in Long Beach, and I know what's important. Most likely, we'll hear from other agencies in the community, maybe the City Council, law enforcement, the fire department, parks and recreation, youth services, churches, synagogues—all the necessary

079people. Another follow-up question is, what are your methods of reporting to us? Sufficient are surveys and in-person sessions. What can we anticipate seeing from your company? How do you give us a comprehensive report? We suggest you post it online so the community can see it. That will provide board members with a lot of information broken down by individual groups, but as three main ideas: 1. What are the problems the current district is facing that the new superintendent needs to know about to succeed? 2. What are the problems the district may face in the coming years that a new superintendent would need to be prepared to succeed with? 3. What skills, abilities, characteristics, and experience? Qualities want to see the community in the next superintendent. The data, the information, it's going to be among those three

080main ideas. Okay, thank you, Mrs. Armstrong. Thank you, President, again. Thank you for being here. How do you keep your clients' identities confidential until the end of the process, and how important is that? That's a very good question. We recommend that boards conduct confidential searches because that encourages clients to apply. If board members sign a confidentiality agreement, because you're going to have access to the applications, the names, the references, the resumes, the letters of interest from applicants for this position, and that has worked quite well. We've also done non-confidential searches, and the boards also receive good candidates. The difference between the two is that sometimes superintendents who are working don't apply if it's not confidential because they're afraid of upsetting the board and the community where they currently live and work. Thank you for that.

081And also, do you have a way, when you're attaching the data, the surveys? Do you have a way to get surveys from parents and students who may have visual, hearing, motor, or speech impairments? Not only are we going to We're going to conduct an online survey, but we'll also make a written survey available at each school site. Since the previous principal is the mayor of the community, they know everyone, they know the parents, they know the students, and they're in a good position to facilitate and help us get the information to people who have more difficulty accessing it. Besides English and Spanish, that service would cost more, would n't it? Thank you so much. You mentioned something. Oh my God, I wrote something about new superintendents. If you place a superintendent, regardless of experience, that

082superintendent is considered new. Do you provide mentoring services, etc., etc.? Do we train them, or would we train them, whether they've been a superintendent for 20 years or have never been one? Are they new as a client of yours? Thank you. That's all for now. Board Member Sinon. I'm sorry, I should have asked that question. Going back to the in- person sessions, are they only conducted in English? We hope to have an interpreter or translator, probably in Spanish. I don't know if there are other languages ​​besides English and Spanish in the Bow district. Yes, besides English and Spanish. What is the primary language? We normally translate it into English and Spanish at one site. We do more specific translation, but right now most of the time it's in English and Spanish. If we want to

083include all the sites, maybe we have to consider other languages ​​besides English and Spanish. Remember the last research search? I was going to share on a site, and we probably want to do it in Arabic. There are some others we can think of. So maybe we'll ask the district to help us with interpretation, an Arabic interpreter, and refer us to mentoring services. Can you be more specific about the services? Are they available all the time, or part of the time? How does it work? That's different with each person you mentor, train, or mentor because there are people who want more. Typically, we're not available to superintendents when they request it. I'm currently training a new superintendent from a search we did in Northern California, and I talk to her probably two or three times a

084month, and we text six or eight times a month. And in the context of that frequent communication, I sometimes communicate with the board chair as well, just to be clear. The superintendent would have to contact their agency to get what they need. Do they have a referral point, a service, or a training service to see the district's needs? That particular person, all the training is personalized to the person receiving the training, and you work with them to develop that program. If I have a person who works with them, they needed a lot of training, or they already feel more comfortable and confident in a new community. They have a lot of experience, but they came from a different community, and we've spoken less and less as the years have passed. But I check in with

085them regularly. I see one of the board agendas. It was an issue, and that type of person can give us references from previous clients who have used their services for superintendent services. If we put it in the proposal, Vice President Garza, Madam President, my question is pertinent to the proposal that also brings together leadership from the parent-teacher association and parents. How do you find balance in that group and find enough parents? That wouldn't be the only source of information from parents. Hopefully, it's interesting in the communities. I like to hold community meetings. In high schools, it's typically where everyone is in one place. As Bower Mayer, we invite parents to come. We can't force them to come, but we're also going to have the online survey, and we'd like to hear There were quite a

086few parents who I don't know if they felt comfortable coming or couldn't come to that community meeting that night, and that's typically how we receive information. We talk about whether they direct us, whether the board guides us, with the leaders of the parent-teacher association. It's a group that thinks, but we want to hear from all the parents, not just the parents who are board members, and parents and teachers. I want to add that in certain situations, there are people who are working. Yes, we will also be available via Zoom because there are many different people who have to feed their children at night and can't come to the meeting. But the option to do it via Zoom is also something we've done and facilitated. Also, the proposal that three members of [unclear] made would be

087you. We would be the partners in the research, but our team across the state will be participating in recruiting candidates. How do you recruit candidates from other states? Or what does your network look like? Our network is quite large. I have trained and mentored 500 or 1000 superintendents in California through my work at USC or my work at AXA. My work with suburban schools and also the Urban Dialogue, that's just me, and we also have as team members we have Dr. Mer, Mr. Terina, and the people who aren't here, two county superintendents who are part of the County, we have Ran Craw, who was the most recent president of the California State Council of Superintendents. We also have from the south we have Clint Harwick, who was president of the California Association of School Administrators.

088We have a pretty large network of current members who are current superintendents or who are retired, who know or know of people who might be interested in being the next superintendent of Bellflower. And if you have a superintendent who wants to go on another search for any reason, you would come back, superintendent, if you choose us to conduct the search. We're going to look for candidates who want to be here for a significant amount of time, 5 years is the minimum, the shortest term. We want people who are in the community, committed to the community, and committed to a long-term position. We guarantee that we won't be able to place any candidate we place with your help here in Bellflower on any other search. And if the candidate comes with us and says, "Oh, I

089want to apply in such-and-such district." And they've only been here a couple of years. Our advice would be, "You don't have to stay here. What's going on? What's happening? If there's a problem, you need to have an honest conversation. You committed to being in this community." Thank you, Actuary Churchfield. Thank you for being here, and I really appreciate the personalized touch in your presentation. Very well done. A couple of questions: what has your experience been, and what is your opinion on internal candidates? Well, we usually present two options to the boards regarding internal candidates. The options are one: to do a two-step process where all the internal candidates, or the internal candidate, are interviewed. They are required to apply and go through the same interview process that would be done in a general interview process.

090They do that, make a decision together with the search partners. Did they answer the questions well? Is that the person they want in the superintendent's seat? And if so, then they don't have to keep looking for other candidates. The other process is for the internal candidate to be considered along with everyone else. And if they do that—and we've had experience with both scenarios—if they do that, it's fair to the candidate. Internally, I'd say, "Look, there's no guarantee you'll get an interview because if you're going to compare it to the others, the worst thing you can do is probably give them an interview without the intention of seeing if this is the candidate we can see take the position." Those two men Were you able to do it, or did both ways work well? We've done

091that. Well, I appreciate your response. Another question, and I also asked the other firms. It seems like it's quite a lot of work. They mentioned that we would be the only search they would be doing, and it takes a few months. This seems like 20,000. That's a small price based on other things we see other firms do. Let's say, a fee, and others a percentage of the superintendent's salary. But you charge a fixed amount, yes, all $0. When we created SERV Education Leadership Services, our mission and vision was to support California school districts for no other reason. None of us are here to make money. As you can see, we are here because we strongly believe in the importance of leadership from superintendents, school board directors, and school boards. We do quite a lot of

092work in school board governance. Our job is really to support school districts in doing the best work they can in their communities. Next question. This, maybe I already asked you, but sorry, yes, I already did. Is it your practice to negotiate superintendent contracts, or is that something you do? Well, we have done many. We have negotiated quite a few. What we typically do is have a conversation with You're talking about what the parameters are regarding the contracts, but we don't want someone you interview and then say, "Well, these are the contract parameters," and this person is, let's say, the number one candidate, and they say, "I can't work for less than a certain amount." And you're saying, " Okay, now what do we do?" So we're making sure that this conversation is very frank and

093very important. We're going to have it with you, with Bellflower, and you have a lawyer too. I think you probably already met him at recess. I know who he is. The only reason I know who he is is because I met him at recess. Oh yes, sure. He says, " We expect that he will be the person who will lead the negotiations with the chairman of the board and the contract negotiator for the finalist." We have to be clear: we work for you, we don't work for the people we're recruiting to be your superintendent, but we don't interrupt you. Especially when you have legal counsel, we're going to help you get to the final candidate by explaining the parameters. But yes, Armstrong member, yes, I want to add that contacts of Superintendents, uh, it's public

094information. So it's very easy to do a broad overview of comparables in the area to know what the market or industry standards are on that topic. That helps a lot in making a very well-informed decision. Well, thank you, Member Armstrong. Yes, President Stuart, I didn't see it here, or perhaps I overlooked it. Do you have your success rate for, say, 3 to 5 years? What is it now? Is it 100% for three or five years? Well, not everyone we've worked with has been in their position for 3 years. Some people we've completed the search for have been in it for a year, let's say. But those we've had, those we've placed 5 years ago, are still serving their communities, so 100%. Well, great. Thank you. Any other questions? Thank you very much. We really appreciate

095your presentation. Thank you for joining us. [Music] Well, we have one more presentation for tonight. We have Dr. Verdugo here from Leadership and Associates. Thank you, Dr. Verdugo. Thank you very much for being here. We really appreciate it. You have to press the button to stop, and it turns green, and there we are. Well, good evening. Unfortunately, our partner... uh She has the virus and is not here, unfortunately. Dr. Pegy Lynch will not be involved in this search either, but I want to start by thanking you on behalf of Sandy and myself. I want to express my gratitude that you are taking the time to allow us to present our superintendent search and leadership proposal. Sandy is the superintendent of the Wither Union School District, a position she has held for 15 years. Her entire

096career has been in the Wither High School program. She is also the president of the California Collaborative and of California Active Superintendents. [Music] As a person, she has been a partner for the associations for the last 11 years. I have done 50 or 60 searches. I retired from the position I had at Paramount as superintendent at Paramount, and after my retirement, I was selected to be the executive director for the California Association of Latino Administrators and Superintendents. I also worked in Washington, D.C., as the director of the Superintendents' Academy, where I served as an advisor and mentor to other national superintendents. I am a four-member leader of associate superintendents, and I think that is very important. Your sessions, especially with People interested in your community, I have also been an assistant superintendent in Placena and

097also 20 years working in Pico Rivera, principal and head teacher of El Rancho High School, the school I myself attended, I think I was 35 years old, I needed humility, my chemistry teacher wanted me to present lesson plans for Friday, Doctor, yes, I'm going to remind you that in my class you received a C. So it was very pleasant. Next, I want to inform the school board that we are the only Silver Affiliate associated by CSBA as search firms. This is from, this is an important slide, it gives information about the unique and very outstanding work that we do. Those women you see there are executive assistant superintendents and secretaries, and I think they can give your administrative and technology staff tremendous help. They are support specialists who will be assigned to the School District,

098giving exceptional support throughout the entire process. This broad support with personalized guidance and orientation, very much communication, and a lot of information that you need and is responsive to your needs. The next thing we consider to be, why, I want to make sure that the information about us is established. Who we are We are an association of active education leaders committed to improving the quality of education for every student in California. We believe that public education must be equitable and exceptional for all young people in every community. Every student and staff member should have a leader aligned with this solidarity and be inspired to address educational issues with excellence, integrity, diversity, inclusion, responsibility, and transparency. We continue to support other educational leaders and school boards. You can see the very professional searches we have conducted;

099these are opportunities for growth. We remain committed to the school boards and other leaders we support. This is a key area we have presented with Leadership Associates throughout our work. The following information outlines additional services we have provided. Over the years, we have worked with county superintendents in various districts. We have served 45 districts in California and worked with assistant superintendents, all with the understanding that one of them will one day become superintendent. We emphasized the importance of the leadership transition. Whenever a superintendent is selected for a district, we believe they must... Having these very personal skills, if they've never passed a bond, never changed a line, this margin of their districts, these are important things they need to know. Many search firms, to be frank with you, use current superintendents. We don't believe that

100a superintendent who is currently working can do an equal search and at the same time do their professional job in their district where they are working. This is a list of all the partners we have in our association, and they are partners, not consultants. We all have the best interests of the people. We are in California, not out of state. It's an organization where twice a month we have a Zoom meeting to talk, recruit, refer, search, and find the right person. So, they don't just have Sandy, but they have a large team. This is an idea of ​​all those people who work with us. These searches, we have completed a large history of searches, we have completed more than 700. I just completed the one in Norwich. I had the pleasure of doing ABC, well,

101Park, Paramount, Ranch, UniFi. Beyond that, the searches I've been involved in in the immediate Pasadena area. Santa Monica, Malibu, Fullerton Joint School District, and East. So currently this year we are just proud and blessed that we have done for about 80% of the superintendent searches in the state of California. Statewide connections and national connections are important. In this case, we have been directly for many of the executive directors and chief executives you see there. Of course, I just held a conference. I worked diligently on the draft bonds for this, and we started. To begin, we give the information for CAP, as you can see there. This CAP and CSCA SA. Excuse me, this next slide is being presented. I want to start with the fact that this selection process begins and ends with the school

102board. This is a search for you. The next part, on the right, the blue part, is the input from the educational partner in person and virtually via Zoom, and also a survey that we will conduct, exclusive and extensive interviews with your people interested in your district. We will give you an idea of ​​the questions that need to be asked, but we invite the district that Add that list because it's your district. That's what we use for the job description. That position description is a description of your community, your district, the characteristics and experiences you want in your next superintendent. We move forward with that draft for your approval and with that position. And from that description, we develop an executive summary. It's like an accreditation report that we provide to you, which contains not only

103the characteristics and experiences you most want in your next superintendent, but we also include the district's strengths and, more importantly, some of the challenges the district faces. That information is a very wonderful map, let's say, for the incoming superintendent and the board to move forward. And the next area, which is kind of gray, is the outreach and recruitment campaign. We have extensive outreach information. 100 individuals are connected with us regarding opportunities and jobs. We also do a tremendous financial and criminal background check. Our applicants require three letters of recommendation and five references. But we go beyond that. It's critical to ensure that we don't have any hidden agendas of people who might be interested in the position. It turns out to be 80% of the searches currently in the state of California. This sounds a

104bit strange, but we know who's causing problems. It's a very important issue to outline, so as I said, all the partners are involved in this presentation. Those brown areas in the candidate presentation, you can see, and all the online applications, we give them four or five days approximately before the candidate selection process. This gives them ample and valuable time to review the candidates who have applied. And of course, we have already investigated the candidate, and we will bring you the information with the best person from line one, line two, or line three. If you ask if there is a person, we will gladly give you information regarding the information we have received about that individual. And of course, we facilitate the interviews. This is particularly important because we do n't proceed with any questions until

105they are approved by the Board of Education. We think it's an important aspect of this selection and interview process. The typical number is between five or six, but as high as seven, or as low as four, regarding the best candidates for the Bellflower Unified School District. We also give the school board the finalists. Let's say they have two finalists. We make sure we know their parameters in advance, what they ask for in compensation and benefits, health and wellness, technological needs, and the organizations they want to be included in— Rotary, ASPA, and ESPA. These are important topics. Another thing I want to mention is that we maintain privacy and confidentiality. The phenomenon when people apply is that the district where they are currently says, "You do n't want us anymore, you want more pay." So we

106deal with that issue very carefully, and the board is, well, it has this aspect of confidentiality as well, and we vigorously address the issue. We don't want a person to be harmed by being in one district and applying to another. A successful search, because we have the experience, the high-quality leaders who meet the requirements of BF. A very deep list of candidates. Of the 100 subscribers to our online site, 66 have been women or candidates of color. We are very proud of that. We are based in California, and we know California. We are partners, not hired consultants. We remain involved. We do n't have our board. At the superintendents' symposium, we spent the entire day, from 7:30 in the morning to 6:00 in the evening, discussing the most current issues and federal aspects of what's

107happening in the state and also throughout the country. This will be very important for the superintendents in terms of knowledge based on what's going on. And of course, we provide a 90- day plan, an entry plan, but always in conjunction with the board of directors. We can create a 90-day draft, but it has to be fulfilled, and with specific terms, not generically. We always do this with the board of directors. Some concluding thoughts: their search is for diverse personalities, but it's broad, quite technical, competitive, and an all-inclusive cost. There are no hidden fees or costs. It 's very qualified, with full administrative support for the people in the office and also the technology department. There are 66 women. We are a California company with a strong presence in the state and a national reach. There

108are also superintendents based across the nation who are interested in coming to California. We are very passionate and committed to this work. Do you have any questions? I want to clarify one thing: in the Partners' Association, we see Juan Cars, and he is not the husband of Vice President G. I just want to clarify that he is no longer related. You can investigate this. Juan G has been a superintendent for 15 years in King K Unified, and he is not the husband of Ms. G. I just wanted to say that before he mentions that he is in Valle de Fres. And we have connections all the way to San Diego Armstrong. Thank you very much, President Stuart. In your search, you say that you include many women of color. Do you use a national network

109or partnerships to have those sources of candidates? Absolutely. During the investigation process, we let individuals give us more contacts that might improve their opportunities. They could be national, state, or local. We try to work directly with the people who are interested and apply. We create a partnership with them as well because we realize how important it is for them that they They are progressing appropriately, and we also help each other. Maybe we find something in the application that doesn't make sense, or maybe it was a mistake, or we want to work with them accordingly. The connections are based nationally, and we have international applicants. And also, confidentiality—how are they going to manage that to the end? Because maybe we have a current super superintendent. That's very important, and it's a good question. We as members

110are going to ask them what's happening, what the next steps are. We advise board members to contact us if they are interested in getting more information about the steps, the timeline, the start date, and the process itself. Having said that, confidentiality—what I was referring to— is providing confidentiality so that the people who are applying are not harmed by someone perhaps mentioning the fact that they have applied for a new position outside their district. As I told the members, that confidentiality would be an aspect for that governance team. And I have another question: are they going to do surveys and collect data? How are they going to reach parents, students, or community members who have any physical or visual impairments? motor or hearing impairments or even speech impairments. I suppose Ms. Armstrong and I work together

111with the district and provide an opportunity to have personal conversations and meetings with those individuals or groups. That's something we're very proud to do. The point is to have a three-way effort to reach your constituents, not just through Zoom meetings or personal meetings, but also through polling. Since Cover happened, the polls after Cover are quite strong, high volume. We work with your directors on the sites. We're also going to administer the polls on a weekly basis to see the quantity or volume. And if it's weak, not as high as we think it should be, we're going to do a joint campaign with the directors and the district office to increase the number so that those voices reach us. But we have no difficulty in personal contacts and meetings with individuals or groups who may have

112those challenges. I have one last question. When we get to the end of the search, do you support your placements? I know you have a 2-year guarantee, but are you going to provide support in those two years? There are two ways we can do that. We can run a The contract specifically provides orientation and training for that individual, but aside from that, regardless of the contract, we will be available as thought partners. If we are successful in the search, Sandy and I will serve as thought partners for a minimum of one year. And if it is a contract that is executed, the details of that training opportunity, that mentorship, would be available according to the contract. But we never, ever leave a newly hired superintendent without some kind of support. An example I can give

113you is in Norv, Dr. Natasha Baker, who was just selected. We helped her for 90 days. In the plan, we thought it was important to be very transparent during those 90 days. Our suggestion as a partner was to provide that to the entire community and not just the board of directors. That transparency went quite far for us. There are two ways I would share that with you: an executed contract with more specific mentorship opportunities. But we never leave someone who was selected by the board of directors on their own. Thank you very much, Mr. Member C. Thank you for your presentation. Just adding this: after the 90- day transition, there is a fee, there is a different contract, there is an additional fee, there is a different development contract. We maintain an academy. Leadership or

114counseling group that one can take advantage of, that's why the county office of education serves 80 school districts that have between one and 1.2 million students. We have that aspect; we can have a contract with more specific things, like how that mentoring would look. But also, as Mrs. Armstrong mentioned, we are available for any mentoring, advice, partnership, or participation with that particular superintendent. We think it's important that we are available at any time that superintendent, regardless of whether they are an experienced superintendent or a new superintendent, we will be available, and that's like, for at least a year. But they can take advantage of the superintendent's Leadership Counseling Group that we have in five counties, from El Dorado in the north to San Diego. Our partners, who show you that list on that map, are

115involved in one way or another as mentors or actuarial trainers. Thank you, Madam President. Thank you for the presentation; I appreciate it very much. A few questions: How do you manage internal candidates? How do we manage internal candidates? More specifically, with a particular conversation with the educational board. Let's think that The confidentiality of that conversation is important for dealing with a closed session under staff. If there are indeed a number of individuals interested in applying for the position, we think it's important to connect those individuals with the other candidates the board is interested in interviewing. We think it will be an important conversation during the initial meeting with the board. We'll set a full agenda for the board outlining the topics we 'll discuss. These topics would include: what characteristics you want to see, what

116the compensation range is, and things like who you want us to contact as stakeholders. All of that will be public. But when we get to more personal conversations about who you want us to recruit, or deeper conversations with internal candidates, that will be just with management, governance, and ourselves. One question I've asked everyone—you have a very good reputation, I've heard very good things about you, and you seem very active— how many simultaneous searches do our partners run at once? Perhaps they have two or two highly relevant searches on their list. I personally will be involved in the Orange Unified search. However, we do have four partners, which I'm happy to say, in that particular research. That's a district of almost 30,000 students. The intention there was to have four individuals. I'm one of them. In

117that search, Bellfower Orang Unif, I would be the only two searches I would be involved in, and no others. And the reason I'm asking is because the fees seem very reasonable, and you say that everything is included. What percentage, after you place the superintendent, do they have any other contracts with training, or is it very common to have some additional contract once they're placed? Absolutely. And has it been, in fact, like a corporate model, regardless of whether it's an experienced superintendent or a novice? We think that the general sense is that they should have a mentor, training. That's why, to put it simply, having a partner in mind, like being able to pick up the phone and say you have governance issues, is the most important relationship when I was in Paris for 10 years.

118It was the closest relationship I had, more than my marriage, and I've been married for over 52 years. The point is simple: that's the kind of thing we want to avoid. Those questions... Those gaps, that network is super important. Thinking as a thought partner, you don't just place them if they're alone; if there's some kind of relationship that's part of this agreement, but it's the corporate model that there will be an additional contract to remain in the network. It's possible, let me give you a percentage. I would say that at least 25% stay with the mentorship, the opportunity of a thought partner, and the rest would be 50% who take advantage of a longer contract, a non-SEP position. Beyond the negotiated contract to have mentoring services, and to be very frank, I think that our

119mentors are the best in the entire state. That would be a conversation to have with your board of directors, with factors like costs or how that looks, which is also very important. While I'm here, we would love to have a coach with us; we are committed to doing that. That's typically an additional conversation with the administration as well. What are the amounts of the contracts? I've seen them up to $1,000, and some, for example, in Fresno, a very complicated district, we have coaches there up to $30,000 but again I think it usually navigates with respect to complex things the number of students Thank you very much any additional questions none Thank you very much I appreciate you coming and it's wonderful to see you again Well very well I appreciate it and um Thank you

120very much thank you Mr. Berdugo I know we have quite a lot to think about shall we take a break or continue I just hear Mr. Berdugo say break to you he says to follow him Well we're going to take a 5-minute break and we'll be back at 7:35 we're going to open the session again at 7:38 We need to talk about Well one of the signatures I'm thinking the best way to do it is is there any signature we can remove there is any number of a list we can remove someone member central member Well I wasn't very impressed with the educational leadership services I think there were quite a few extra things many extras the language commitment that we have to turn off We also didn't seem like, like, good good this combination

121with us gave us s It has quite a few counseling programs but maybe there isn't a very significant question but the four of us there's something that just tells me that uh These don't quite fit together, perhaps not entirely, because I asked about their references. I looked up their references, and they only work with private schools, or they have two unified districts. One district has 3,200 students, and the other has 1,700. Although it says it's a district, I don't know if this is a good mix for us. They only work with private schools. But another thing to know about the four different firms: MCF Jacobson costs $23,000, the other two, Costco and ELS, are $200,000, and the last one, Associates, was $28,000. Just so you remember, those were the differences. Between $23,000 and $28,000, there's

122a difference of $5,000, no more than that. I wanted to clarify that. Member KCH Field. Well, I just want to thank all the firms for coming and presenting. I think everyone had good things to say about their companies, but I'm not going to say why I didn't like some. My two best are MCF Jacobson and Leadership Associates. I think after... Dealing with those two, I like Leadership Associates. I think they have... they focus on the search process. What was... no, sorry, continue the question. It's the last one. I want you to continue on your way. Two things: I think their selection process, finding the best candidate and also finding candidates who represent our communities, is quite important. And honestly, the last question they answered honestly. With their additional contracts, they were open and honest with

123that question. So that would be it. One to one another. Do any of you have anyone we could eliminate? I agree with member Sintron. No more. Again, I can't put my finger on it, but there's something missing for me with them. For me, maybe I would eliminate CAS as well. Member Armstrong, use your microphone. I could eliminate the CASCA group and Educational Leadership. I really liked Leadership Associates, but if you can tell me more about them, or if you want, McFeron, I'm fine with them too, but I like Leadership Associates quite a bit. So it looks like we have two Leadership Associates, McFeron and Jacobson, as the two finalists. I think the prices are quite similar. I think I've heard quite a few things. Positive aspects of both companies regarding their network of contacts and

124the way they find superintendents. The only difference I saw was that it was two years with Merson and Jacobson in terms of working with the superintendent, something different than with Leadership Associates. They want to add something. We have two, Mr. Central. If I think, I think I definitely agree with you that one had the training already established within the program and the other didn't, although it could be added. However, they said that, and I liked how they presented it, that they should feel free. Thank you. The process of the thinking partner, also that of automatically being part of a group that works together with other superintendents based on the Los Angeles County Board of Education, I think they already come to a support group of mentors, people in the same positions from all over Los

125Angeles County. I think that's extremely important versus... Although I do think it's important that the training be individualized for a particular person, the diversity of being part of a group that has more experience than one that is together on the same path... I'm looking more... I'm leaning more towards Leadership. If anyone else would like to present something... Armstrong, we could say, I would like to choose Leadership Associates as well, but I want Ms. Gars to give us her input. Well, thank you. First of all, for doing this because you have made it quite difficult to choose. They are very good candidates. It's part of the job, right? So I am incl. [Music] including additional things. I don't know if that would be too much. That's my point, but what I think is that with the

126auto-firm, it just seems that everything is inclusive and they would do the same for us. That's a good point. Member C, the only thing I think is that what they said they were going to include would be adding mentoring, individualized mentoring, to the superintendent's contract as a characteristic. There were more things they said they were going to add. McPherson and Jacobson said two years. Leadership Associates said they would do one year of mentoring. But as for costs associated with that service, they said between $10,000 and $30,000 depending on what that superintendent wants. Yes. And if at some point we wanted the additional contract to, like, give the superintendent... There's also support, as they said, the free mentorship available for superintendents, and we can also go to CSBA and get a contract from there. That 's

127also an option for me at this point. So, it just seems to me that 23,000 versus 28,000, I'm going with the 23,000. Member Armstrong, sorry, I never turned it off. I was ready to decide. I think we have... well, we're down to two finalists. Does anyone want to make a motion about any of the selected firms? I have member Crisfield. Do you have anything else to say? Well, I think that although I'm hearing that the price difference is a concern, I think it's the cost of being wrong. It's quite high, and the 5,000 seems to no longer be a factor. As for that amount, I wouldn't give that issue so much weight. Both firms are going to be very good. The additional things they could offer, like their training and network, everyone has a network

128of contacts that we could consider for the superintendent later on. But as for leadership, I think they're the ones I choose, and I like McFs and... I really like Jacobson. I think they were frank about there being additional contacts, and that most superintendents do that, but it's something we can consider at this time. As for the others, I didn't feel that frankness. So I wouldn't put so much weight on the 5,000. I would choose Leadership Associates, but I would be satisfied with McFs Jacobson too. But for everything I saw, I decide on that. Well, to add to that, a few things I heard from Leadership that I hadn't heard before: they talked about the Brown Act and want to address the challenges we have in our district. I've been talking with the superintendents, but I

129think they were the most comprehensive. I liked the response regarding community members with special needs. They said they would have personal conversations, and I like the closed session for staff regarding any internal candidates. So, well, we have one, two, three, or sorry, we are two. Does anyone want to make a motion? I'll make the motion. Well, I want to... I have one more thing... Excuse me, one more thing... one more thing. The reason why... because I like the I like both of them too, but MCF does maintain a database of candidates. Remember, it's not that they don't have a group of people who already have... well, it's okay. It's like they're punished for it, and like they're not punished because they create these relationships, they know these people, but they maintain a database of which

130ones they can use if they think a client has some quality they're looking for. I wanted it to be that if they want, they have to go nationwide to look for someone willing to travel. So at least if you want to vote, I would say that we could remove Merson, Vice President Gar. Sorry, I didn't understand. I did n't understand that in the presentation because what I thought was that when he said we asked the question, he said that they do look for candidates all over the nation, but yes, but they have a bank, a database. Maybe everyone does it, but... Okay, well, that's not what I understood from his answer, but anyway, I think we're going to take a motion. We can do that. I think we obviously have two options to choose from.

131I'm comfortable with either one. I want to build some excitement. For the first one, I move that we take the second. We have other options. We have to take roll call on that motion, Mr. Armstrong. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes, Mr. Gars. Yes, Mr. St. Yes. Well, if there are no objections, this meeting will adjourn at 7:51 pm. [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.