CorpusRecord 167963

Special Board of Education Meeting - February 10, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Bellflower Unified School District
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Los Angeles County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,312 words · about 102 min
Collected
2026-06-24

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay good evening um we are reconvening back into Open session at 5:04 um clerk kitfield will report out the topics discussed in closed session were Public Employee discipline dismissal and release the board took no action in close session all right tonight we do not have requests addressing agenda items our first um our first agenda item is the Safety Committee appointment so I would like to propose we talked about this before a standing Safety and Security committee do I have a motion to approve the committee so moved second in roll call please miss Armstrong I miss I Mr critchfield I Mrs Garza i m Stuart I um for this committee I would like to appoint two people and I would like to make sure you guys are okay with that but I would like to per

002um I would like to add to that committee Clerk critchfield and board member sron are you guys okay with being on that committee I I okay awesome all right misso okay thank you good evening board members we have four presentations for you this evening to assist with the superintendent search um our first presenter will be um Mr Ben Johnson from mcferson and Jacobson so Mr Johnson I have to do it too you have to push the button down there and it'll be green on the there you go 955 KS okay um good evening everyone Bor thank you for allowing us to be here today it's just me I just want to make sure that out of respect my colleagues from other search firms are not in the room why I'm presenting and I'll do the

003same thing for them um but honored to be here um it is not my first time in B belflower I was fortunate enough to be here back in 2018 when you did a search presentation and so I'll talk a little bit about that because there was a decision made in that search process to internal but um all the data points that we discovered during that process we still have and and even though I we would do some things um in addition to that I think they would still be valid points to have a Baseline and be able to talk like how the district has progressed since then so um if there's no questions I'll starting from the boards do you want about 10 15 minutes presentation and leave the rest of time open for Q&A

004what are your thoughts okay I'll do that then so take the time you need so that's you thank you um we we all talk about um education and how it's the great equalizer right that if if great things happen at the Das um with governance that's the board and the superintendent right not two separate entities but um the board and the superintendent great things happen in the classroom and so we really truly believe that um our mission and what we do differently is really spending time on making sure that it's the board search we don't have a Cadre of candidates that we move from smaller districts to larger districts right we we spend a lot of time and I'll go through this in a minute on the front end which is the criteria right what

005are the unique things that Bellflower needs um to make sure their Pro make sure your process is good um no surprises to the board so spending a lot of time in background checks and not just talking to people that the candidates tell us to talk to but doing that deeper and reaching out to our um our Network and we have a large Network even though we are a nationwide search firm um all of our Consultants that would be working on the search except for home office are based in California and the unique thing about mcferon in most cases we're the only search firm that uses a superintendent and a board member um like you I'm a board member I've seen many of you at csba I've been a trustee um in aler unified I was

006there for 21 years and um thought I was retired and then one of my colleagues of the county retired and asked me to run so I've been on the County Board in Riverside um for two a little over two years now so a district of 21,000 and then the county you know is responsible for over a couple hundred thousand students so we have I I think the the big piece is that we have a 130 Consultants Nationwide and I what that gives you is is just networking there there are many um candidates that leave California and go to other states and then come back to California um and so that's important um we are a nationwide search firm as I mentioned but we do not hire your superintendent um we help you build criteria that

007would help you identify the traits attributes that you want in your next leader but you select that person I think that's a huge distinction because California is it's large but Southern California is really small and tight right and so sometimes what you see is this kind of um shifting of California candidates throughout Southern California and really slow South um we don't do that so if we find the candidate that best meets your needs and they're in New York City leadership is leadership and so you'll hear people say well California is different of course it's different but great leadership and what you need in the criteria you need you can find that anywhere and so we're intentional about doing that as a priority um and I'll talk philosophically a minute about what I think about when

008you when you start looking at your criteria um so this next Point everyone has a different opinion on but we are passionate and it's one of the reasons why csb had us for years as their only partner and searches that engaging your education Partners is critical and by that I mean your bargain units your community um employees when we did um the and I still have the data from when we did your um Partners um meetings last time we spoke to 90 people throughout the district in 11 separate groups so instead of having like a big town hall meeting where you invite people or you do this online process and we did both of those we met with each of your bargain units we met with um classified certificated um we met with Business Leaders

009we we also met with students and so a lot of times people say well what are what are students going to tell you if you have kids you know students will tell you a lot right and so having that kind of candid discussion with students what you what they need um and with they're looking for a leader you wouldn't be surprised it aligns very well with what the adults said they they get it um and then I we'll talk about our track record in in a second so this will be our team on the search um both um as mentioned I'm I'm a long-term board member I've done over 23 superintendent searches um I think I'm at 25 right now um and then both um Bill hu has done I think close to 42 searches

010and Christy Wilson has done a few a handful um so I'm going to skip over this about why um I think right here the bullet four is probably the most important so the candidates um that we've hired this is McPherson's numbers um 80% are in this position after five years which is important right that's sustainability of leadership um usually doesn't happen because that criteria piece isn't done um I'm going to post a little bit my my my numbers are at 97% of candidates that I've placed are still in those positions um and I've been doing searches now with mcferson for over seven years um bullet two is critical and and I talked about when you think about the search process a lot of people take and really get really narrow about what you want in

011your leader and I would think about being broad as far as things that they have to have but the characteristics traits and attributes skill sets be be narrow but do they have to speak Spanish do they have to have been a superintendent and I I worked with a district where they the the leader had to have five years in the classroom well what if that person was a rock star and was three years in the classroom and then became an assistant principal so thinking broad about what are the outcomes you want in that next leader we would build criteria around that to help you select your next leader um as any person that does this work we work for the board we don't work for candidates um and I think that is critical um and

012it you can see it reflected in the fact that we have candidates with all different background diversity experiences um that help really focus on what you need and what Bellflower needs and you got to like each other too it doesn't seem like it's a big deal but when you're working day-to-day on critical issues the board and the superintendent the governance team have to function together and you can have passionate debate about issues right we should have those in a respectful way but once a decision is made that governance team should be moving forward together all of you in sync even if you didn't originally agree with that and a good leader can help facilitate that um don't rush the process um I I'll say this whether you select us or not if you get to

013the end of your search and all of you aren't having a difficult decision on who to pick and then aren't saying the our last three or four candidates we all couldn't hire if somebody tells you this is all that's out there and these are all the candidates that you have select from don't believe them sometimes it's just timing I've had situations where we just extended the search process for a month um I can think back during covid and we had 12 candidates that were mediocre at best quite frankly and then we extended it for another month we got another 27 candidates and uh one of those it's a not too far district from here and one of those candidates be became superintendent of the year and is a superstar and leads other people so sometimes

014it's just timing so we'll focus on a timeline and I think what you're looking for we can hit with without any problem um but I would say don't ever settle timeline for the quality of candidate because that'll hurt you it'll hurt your students and it'll set the district backwards much further than extending for a month so here's our process um I talked about phase one and phase one is really where we spend time kind of getting the Baseline for everything so um we we really do believe that criteria is critical that that spending the time on identifying those traits it takes a few hours to do that it should never be rushed I know some people just create leadership profiles um and they serve their purpose but really working with the board and not a

015cookie cutter criteria right a criteria that's unique to you in your District um phase two I talked about already I think um once we're selected regardless of who the district is we start and we create the criteria with the board we start identifying candidates immediately we don't just post something up on um Ed Cal or our web page or your web page we really are intentional about um the candidates that we go after because they going to be a lot of people that are qualified um the last time when we started your search process back in 18 um we had 43 candidates for the search so we had a lot of really talented people and I I'll say this respectfully even if the board has internal candidates that are applying for the position that's great

016let them compete like everybody else right because all that does is reinforce that they are the best because they competed in in in an environment that's public I'll I'll talk about the interview process in a second where you can add other people part as part of that process but great candidates can compete whether they're internal or external um phase three um we we do try to do as much of the hard work for you so the objective is that let's say you got have the same situation as you did before that you have 40 plus candidates that apply quite candidly I don't think you'll have that many I think you'll have less I think you'll probably have closer to 30 something that will apply we to the board my gut is between eight and 12

017candidates that we call our short list that um that what we do is screen out candidates that first aren't qualified right like so if you say you want someone that's served on cabinet and that would be a suggestion to you because your district is not a starter District you are not a district where someone that doesn't have in my opinion doesn't have cabinet level or executive level experience um couldn't start off in that this kind of role it's too complex there's too many issues the district's too big um so you would who who's not qualified and then who may be qualified but doesn't meet your criteria we would screen those P people out as well and then we would bring the board a short we call a short list of eight 12 people the board

018would have the ability to review every single person that applied and we would have discussions with the board about who we brought forward why we didn't bring them forward um and where we think the gaps are are we do background initial background checks on those candidates before they even come to the board so we as I said we don't just talk to who they tell us to talk to because most people are going to tell you to talk to people that are going to say great things right they we we we talk to those people then we go what we call three deep and we talk to three additional people to say who else what else do you know about this candidate what else can you tell us about this candidate what else is important

019about this candidate um and then we reach out to our Network um the only time we don't talk to certain people is if that person is a sitting superintendent and in that role only because sometimes unless they're a finalist they're putting their career at risk by um letting the board their board know that they're looking but once they're a finalist when they and that's we go from the short list of 8 to 12 people to the four people to six at the most that the board's going to interview um everything is open right because now you're saying we're going to potentially hire you once you make it to the interview process and so we there's no one we can't talk to we've got to be able to talk to anybody and if they're worried about

020the board that their board that's just a chance they're going to have to take because now you're potentially going to hire that candidate um we do the typical things that you would expect during the interview process right we ask questions everybody asks questions but that is limit liting because there are people that are great at answering questions and great at interviewing and we spend time doing some other things um in addition to scenarios we actually try to set up we can set up pre-interview meetings with the board two board members and two board members to get to know the candidates better in a more of a social setting than just the interview process and when you I forgot to mention when you get the short list of candidates the ones that you're going to kind

021of decide from that who you're going to interview we have video that you get to watch of all um 8 to 10 of those candidates and they answer anywhere from three to four questions that we come up with that'll give you some insight on who those candidates are so we we try to provide as much information as possible before you even make the decision who you're going to um select from that short list to interview um so the interviews I mentioned what the board's role is um a lot of boards like to have Community panels as part of the interview process proc um you may hear that they will preclude people from applying I have never had that happen and and I'll with all respect I'll say if somebody isn't comfortable with engaging with the

022community in a panel interview they may not be the right candidate if you want that kind of process right that that's when we get into that whole discussion about fit um but I am very protective of my candidates too because if they if anything gets out before they're determined to be a finalist that could ruin their career so we we make every person sign a letter of confidentiality um we remind them that they can be sued if anything gets out of that um that closed session kind of process similar to your Clos session um but it is confidential not just during the interview process but it's confidential forever right because that's um their career and so we spend we we think as much information that the board can have before they make that decision um

023the better process you have first of all it helps that candidate um who becomes your new leader it gets community Buy in because they've been involved they do not rank candidates and tell you who to hire and who not to hire they just say here's the things we saw as strengths in this candidate here's the things we saw as areas a potential opportunity and that information is given confidentially to the board so no one walks out of that room saying well they didn't pick the person we wanted to pick because there's no discussion about that there's no discussion about who liked who and who thought was was great um but it does provide the board really good information about is there consistency from between what the board saw and what the panel saw and in

024most cases the panel consists of um a representative from each bargaining unit each board member selects their their represent pres ative and then there's sometimes like one other person maybe a former board member or former exec CEO or something that the board can agree on that could be that but it's a very small group of people that are part of that Community panel once your leader selected um this next piece is uh makes a difference right in and in sustainability phase five is goal setting with the board and your new leader and that's part of the process right the board um and your new new leader determine what what's what's most important for this District right it's not five things it's usually two to three things because under those two to three things right there's

025other subcategories that the board is identified as being priorities and those priorities are based on what the board's vision is right so when we do when I do goal setting I I have the governance team review your mission statement review your goal goals and your priorities because those things can change and if you don't have a discussion about what your mission statement is what your vision statement is and then talk about goals you could be missing a big disconnect between what the group that created those things five 10 years ago maybe or even longer is that still relevant and important to this Sport and if it is great but if not you still have to talk about it because you're the leaders of the district and if your leader leaves for any reason within two

026years we come back and do the search at no cost to the board and I probably have not had to do that at all I'll stop here and leave time for questions because I can prattle one longer than I should but um definitely open to the questions from the board colleagues is there anybody that has questions comments when you when you say um a two-year guarantee and uh for any reason um is there going to be a contingency of how many original board members no has nothing thank you for great question has nothing to do with the board members so even if you had a change in your board and the majority of the board said this person is not working out we would still come back and do the search of no cost for

027the board and that's on the record so ex let me correct myself except for expenses so if there's travel and expenses for the search person um which would be me I live in Riverside so there's there's there's no real cost except maybe in and out but that's about it and then you say confidential until until what in no no end that that was my point reinforcing that the process when the candidates are involved with with the with the board and for the community panel I wasn't clear on that that process is always confidential to the very end until we select for the person you select is open to the community and to the public but the other candidates that apply should always remain confidential because it's confidential right they're their career yes that's okay I

028wanted to make sure that part was clear yes ma'am um thank you thank you vice president Garo yes you mentioned that um we should take our time to select the right person so if we have to extend our deadline beyond the timeline you have given us uh recommended will there be an added cost at that point there's no additional cost thank you you're welcome clerk critchfield thank you madam president Ben thanks for being here I know you've stood there a couple times and uh hopefully this is a lot more pleasant this time apprciate you coming now and uh one of the things uh I I I appreciate you saying is the time and making sure that we take our time and do this properly I know that was a a concern last time and and

029you stood right there and you said exactly that and you weren't willing to say what you think maybe people wanted to hear you stuck to that I think the the time that we take is going to be very important and worst case scenario if uh somebody sticks around for just a little bit longer to help fill the Gap that'd be good too uh but um I am curious when you mentioned internal candidates and then being able to compete uh alongside uh everybody else which I agree um what has been your experience with internal candidates and how do you make sure that they get a fair Shake I I've seen both happen where and it answer a great question I I I like being respectful of people's time and energy and effort so when someone's interviewed

030doing they've put a lot of work and effort in that and I would say candidly I've been in situations where an internal candidate is not ready to be the superintendent I would say respectfully that the board president and maybe another member of the board have a conversation privately with that candidate to say we think you're doing great here but if there's already an internal kind of thought the person's not ready I would say have that discussion don't put them in the position of um for lack better word a courtesy interview I don't think that does anybody well and it also for like a better words cheats the board out of other candidates that may be ready um but if they're given I think giving them a fair Shake is recognizing that sometimes we know the

031good and bad of internal candidates um and external candidates often only present the good but if we do our job well and do background checks you'll get the same kind of level of avoiding hearsay about internal candidates as opposed to what the consistent record shows and not just sometimes internal candidates get beat up because they've had to make hard decisions and difficult decisions and so those people kind of get beat up internally um where if you're in a leadership position and served on cabinet especially in HR and business services where you've made tough decisions or superintendent everything isn't going to be Rosy and so it's being honest and weighing those things um both with your internal and your external candidates and record I always try to say past performance is an indicator of future performance

032and really asking the same things that the same people um as you're going through the process the consistency is really important okay I appreciate just one more question I I know you mentioned and I agree with you leadership is leadership whether it's from New York or from some in California uh but that's a conversation that would happen as far as what the board look if the board was looking for somebody more local in a similar District similar demographic that would be part of the search it would be it would be it's your search so if the board said we really want to make sure our candidates have had especially with the craziness to happen in California recently like we want someone that's had experience in a district that has X number of students um in

033California for X number of years we would make that part of the criteria thank you you're welcome board member Centron could you elaborate more on you you reference background checks more than just the references they provide what is that you do additionally um we ask a series of questions that that are the same of all candidates right how do you know the and I'm not going to give all the specifics but how do you know the candidates in what capacity we talk about strengths and areas of opportunity um we ask in reference checks give me some examples of how they demonstrated that as opposed to just fluffy kind of comments and then we ask those people can you give us two or three additional people that we could talk to um that could also provide

034Insight on that person's character and and skill set and then they give us that information and we do the same thing with those so that's that when I say going three deep we don't just talk to who they told us to talk to we talk to additional people in that process and then because our network not only GL nationally but within California is really strong I mean every one of our Consultants is a member of every major superintendent organization accs and then there's subgroups and sometimes as a board member I get information from my fellow board member colleagues that that um superintendents went get in I think most of you know was really involved with csba for a long time and so um having that Network also helps too does that answer your question almost

035yes yeah thank you you're welcome any other questions I really like the idea of the panel interviews um I think our community is really important so when you talk about you know having representation from our bargaining and from our units and our um our unions I think that's really important um I I'd like to get as much uh feedback as possible so I like that thank you yeah thank you I I I review the education Partners sessions um data points and the level of consistency that we heard from all of those groups and the feedback that we got about um transparency being visible engaging people at a high level the transparency thing came out probably was one of the top things that came out during those last discussions and I agree with you madam president

036that as much as the board can do to show that the community doesn't make the decision that's the board decision but as much as the community can be involved appropriately in that decision um what I didn't mention is that in addition to all of those meetings we also put the survey online in English Spanish or any other language you want um and and we're intentional about making sure that people know what's out there um so people can answer and can be involved and can be connected so the board gets a really good detailed document and I so we create a document with all that information for the board right we create this document that has here's what all this P all the groups said um not names of people but classified said this certificated said

037this cabinet said this students said this and we provide that document to the board we tell you to we tell you we suggest that you put it online and make it available to people and then we give it to the candidates and then when you're making your decisions it also helps the Board and making even more informed decision because this is all the information that you heard as you went through the process it it you take a deep breath because they'll call board members out and they'll say stuff and we don't edit anything except if there's too much profanity um but it it does give you really good feedback to say to your community we heard what you said and you've taken time to say it and we're we're dealing with your children so you

038must care enough um and it's a great document that we we we say make it as available as you can so sorry no thank you board member Centon um yeah I kind of want to just ask this question about track record um can you provide us some references of your previous clients that you have that have used your services that are or can mirror a little bit of our district okay and then I just wanted to take a like a comment I know that uh you referenced being here and helping the board of 2018 out um I just want to make sure that that is not the mindset that this company comes in with thinking that we're the same board or that we have the same NE Necessities or that we're looking for the same

039kind of people that that's really kind of you to say that um candidly I wouldn't be here if I thought that um I I and um I really want to to say thank you again for saying that I I I think that um in in looking at the things that and the challenges boards faced over the last few years I know what I would be looking for and by just the things I've read and heard from about the board it it is clearly a different board and different values priorities but but thank you I appreciate that thank you welcome Mr Armstrong yeah I'm a piggy back it's not only a different board it's a different Administration also and um I do want to ask also though that if if we have parents or or students

040that has uh visual impairments hearing impairments motor impairments or speech impairments will they will there will you provide a way for them to participate we've always done that um and I'll give you personal thing that um see Howard talking about this issue my wife's a VI teacher special at VI teacher and so I would get smacked in the back of my head if I do something to make that accommodation so I I I I do think um and I know what you're referencing it was not the most candid feedback and we've all we've been we've done thousands of searches across the country and we've always always accommodated candidates and those that want to be involved not only from a special needs accommodation perspective but also from a language perspective and so it doesn't matter if

041it's one student or 500 students will do what we need to do to make sure everybody feels like their vo is heard you know I just want to say I appreciate that because um I didn't know you in 2018 but I'm glad that you are steadfast in in wanting to provide your services to our district so I do appreciate that thank you all right I'm a little biased I think I told you when I first was here when I first got in healthcare this was my first territory so I had belflower lington Park Compton South Gate Englewood Downey so this is like coming home vice president Gara thank you president Stuart so you mentioned that you would also do these uh panels in a different language yes do you have people working for you that

042are able to do it in Spanish but not in maybe another language we have um on our team we have someone that is Spanish as their primary language um I would have to use a consultant outside of California to do a mandarin okay um and I just want go ahead no go ahead I I go ahead it's okay and if there were other languages we would talk to the district for example there's no one on our team in California that's Vietnamese is their primary language so we would work with the district to say can we do a panel with using either someone in the district as a resource or through our office trying to find someone else through our office do that but whatever it is we'd make that accommodation okay thank you you're welcome

043I just wanted to say thank you for coming back oh thank you thank you any other questions well thank you so much we appreciate it yeah thank you so much thank you thank you B we're just going to take one minute to bring in our second group Bo president are you okay if I introduce our second group absolutely thank you okay our second group will be Mr Joel Shapiro and Ruth Perez Ashley from the Costa group thank you for joining us this evening good evening very nice to be with you tonight uh as we said we are from the Costa group I'm Joel Shapiro this is Ruth Ashley and uh we we will get started uh the Costa group interestingly enough had was started by our founding member Dr Frank Costa in the year 2000

044so we're now in our 25th year Dr Costco was had been the superintendent in Ontario Monclair for many years and when he retired along with some other recently retired superintendents they started the Costco group and uh I've been very pleased to be a member of the Costa group since I retired as superintendent of about 10 years ago so I've enjoyed it very much see how this is going to work I feel like it never works it's not you it never works but where are they supposed to point at Le as it's not you but where where's the best place for them to point cuz we seem to have to point this way it did work but I don't know if I did that oh okay well thank you okay well Co Costa group we also

045go by TCG and so I want to talk for a moment about some of the things TC and G can stand for first of all trust it's critical when we work with the district that we have a high level of trusting relationship with the board and we pride ourselves on that developing that trust with the board is based on our credibility knowing that we will follow through knowing that you can trust us to live up to all of the guarantees that we give you the other area of trust that's critical is your community your stakeholders a successful superintendent surge not only works to get you the right superintendent which obviously is the end but you want your stakeholders to feel that they have been listened to you want your stakeholders to feel that they had

046an opportunity to be involved and we've been very pleased with the feedback we've received over the years of stakehold holders saying you know what they came in and they really listened to us they paid attention to what we had to say so that trust not only includes the board but also your stakeholders the C for commitment we are committed to your superintendent being successful once that superintendent is hired not just up to the point of being hired but we will work with with that person at no extra cost to the district for up to two years because it's critical to us that we help you find the right person but also help that person to be successful so there's that long-term commitment in addition to our commitment to working with the board C can also

047stand for confidentiality critical in a superintendent search is confidentiality many candidates will not apply if they fear that the search firm in the board will not maintain confidentiality so to get the best candidates they have to trust you and they have to trust us that we will protect that confidentiality and we take that very seriously and the g for guidance we provide the guidance for you based upon our experience but you make the decisions the board makes all the decisions but we really uh pride ourselves on the level of guidance that we can supply next one so a little bit of what we learned about belflower that we're very impressed with a very stable district 10 distinguished schools three National Blue Ribbon Schools a gold Ribbon School District PBIS programs that are recognized for excellence

048a diverse student body and the board and District have focus on Equity achievement and Community I bring this up because this is going to be a district that will be that will really be appeal to many candidates this is a place where a lot of strong candidates will want to come because your reputation is strong and your and the stability of the district and the board is really provides for that reputation so we feel that there'll be no lack of really strong candidates next slide so a little bit about I guess we have to hit them hit them one at a time here okay a little bit about us I will start by giving you my background I retired just about 10 years ago as the superintendent in South Pasadena I worked for 42 years

049as a public educator uh in addition to being the superintendent at the time I was an advisor to Ed leader 21 which is an organization that is focused on bringing 21st century skills to schools throughout the country guess I've prior to going to South Pasadena superintendent I had been the assistant and then Deputy superintendent in Burbank unified I've been both an elementary and secondary principal in my career uh I received I was an aen professor at two colleges for accidental and Cal State Northridge received several awards from AXA including Regional Awards and I'm currently the president of the Costa group in addition to doing superintendent searches which I love I have spent my time since retiring uh as a coach to many superintendents and other District administrators and side administrators and I worked very closely

050with Boards of Education doing governance training governance workshops in fact I'm on my way to do one tomorrow in in another area and I've enjoyed that very much as well let me introduce my colleague Ruth to take over thank you good evening board members and good evening staff it's a pleasure to be here recently I retired from the Long Beach Unified School District as a deputy superintendent of Education Services after 34 years of service and while I started out as an elementary teacher and principal before moving into the central office I spent the last 16 years of my career overseeing both HR and Ed Services I also have experience as an Adjunct professor at Long Beach State and I've spent the last four years coaching numerous administrators and providing a wide range of both operational

051and instructional services to school districts throughout California lastly I am your neighbor as well and while I reside in Lakewood my daughter and her family live here in belflower so I'm always running around the streets of belflower with my two little granddaughters and ultimately they were more than likely be attending belflower schools in the near future next slide I'm also proud to be a part of a group that maintains a record of success 95% this is the success rate of TCG found superintendents who have served for five or more years and the Research indicates that the national average for public school superintendence is between three and four years but it's more than likely closer to three years and just a little over 60% of those superintendents have served for five or more years and whether

052it's a firm that has done 10 searches or a thousand searches no number is more important than the number of superintendents with longevity so at tcg we have approximately a couple of dozen of Partners and Associates that comprise TCG and we are selective in the districts we pursue so continuous communication is key and Dr Shapiro and I will provide frequent updates and you'll have direct access at least to one of us or if not both of us at all times throughout the search the design of this process is tailored and adapted to district and Board needs and one of the ways is by maintaining an open pool of candidates unlike some of the other search firms TCG does not promote its own in-house pool of candidates in contrast we cast a wide net searching for

053candidates who have the capacity to meet the district's unique needs and challenges the search timeline and process details will also be adapted to fit the district's needs and finalized in collaboration with the board additionally full applicant disclosure will be practice TCG does not unilaterally select the applicants to interview unlike some other search firms instead TCG provides the board with an entire list of applicants accompanied by its recommendation for those to interview and the final decision is that of the board TCG will provide multiple wellp publicized and convenient opportunities for stakeholder input as well this will help the board identify the unique needs and challenges of the district and establish the unique criteria for acceptable applicants this leads us to the search and selection process slide so we have five stages or five phases to the

054search process and starting with the pre-recruitment work in phase one we will customize process detail and timeline work with the board to develop an initial needs assessment complete stakeholder meetings and an online survey and with the board we will review assessments and Community input and we'll confirm the district's unique criteria and then during this work we'll also design and confirm an electronic marketing brochure phase two here in the recruitment phase we will distribute the brochure advertise and promote not just locally but throughout the state and Country we'll publicize via TCG part and Associate networks which is strong and robust and we set up and maintain files and records and handle all applicant Communications with professionalism timeliness and Grace just a comment on one of the things that Ruth mentioned when we talk about meeting with

055your various stakeholder groups uh we conduct numerous focus group meetings we will meet with you prior to that and you'll help us determine all the groups that you want us to meet with I worked in one District about two years ago where we actually met with over 400 people because of the number of groups that were determined that we should meet with in addition to specific groups we had a couple of uh Community Forum meetings that were well attended it was very important to the board and I believe it will be very important to you to get a wide range of input from stakeholders in addition to those meetings we provide a survey for people who can't attend a meeting in both English and Spanish to get that information to you as well now once

056we've gone through the recruitment phase and we've received the applications we do extensive record uh reference checking we do that as the as the applications come in and I think you know how important that is you'll find many candidates that look good on paper and when we check references and we go very deep we don't only check the references that they give us we go much deeper than that and talk to people who we know will really know these candidates and then when we get back to you and discuss the candidates you may find that GE this person look good on paper but we found out some things that would cause you to think maybe there's something more to this person so those reference checks are critically important we want to know from the people

057they work with we want to know from parents they've worked with from their supervisor from everybody that we think can give us really good information on that person so we conduct those very extensive reference checks we bring together a panel of members of our firm to help go through the applications and look at the reference checks and help us to determine the ones that we will recommend to you when we meet with you to be the strongest candidates we will give you every application packet that we receive for you to look over you have a right to see all of them and we want you to see all of them then we will prepare our candidate report to you and in that report we'll tell you the candidates that we don't think meet your minimum

058qualifications that you really shouldn't consider we'll tell you the candidates that we think are qualified deserve some considerations and then we'll tell you the candidates that we believe to be the most highly qualified that we recommend that you interview but it's going to be your decision and then we will interview the uh we will facilitate for you the uh selection of candidates to interview next slide then come the interviews and we facilitate everything about the interviews but the board conducts the interviews so we'll meet with you prior to the interviews and develop the questions with you we have a long list of questions that we will share with you but we'll also share specific questions that we develop just based upon what you have determined is important for bflow we'll schedule and coordinate the interviews

059another thing we do and we find this to be very helpful is we prepare a compensation study we'll take a look at similar districts in terms of size and composition of the district and we'll determine what the compensation is for superintendents in those districts because we think that's very helpful to you when you start to think about the the employment contract for your new superintendent obviously you'll make the selection but we'll facilitate that process and when we get to the final candidates we go beyond reference checks we will do intense back background checks we actually work with a detective who will look at people's backgrounds and let us know if there's anything that could be an issue that we need to bring forward to you the last the next one then comes the phase that's

060the appointment of the superintendent prior to making that appointment most boards determine they'd like to do a site visit they'd like to either have a couple of board members or the entire board make a visit to the district where that person's working and talk to people there so we will facilitate that we'll arrange that obviously we notify all the candidates immediately of their status if you want we will help you negotiate the contract some boards ask us to do that others say we'd like just like to work with our attorney but sometimes it's been helpful for us to be a go between with between the board and the candidate in contract negotiations and the other thing we offer to do that many boards have said please do that is to actually prepare the announcement the

061press release if you will for the candidate so that you don't so that that's work you don't have to do we're happy to do it for you back to you so another unique service TCG provides are the services after the superintendent is appointed and we will be here to assist setting superintendent performance objectives we'll be here to conduct leadership or alignment governance workshops as needed and to provide two years of superintendent mentoring and Joel had alluded that earlier that he's going out to um a district nearby to help with that so the proposed timeline and this is obviously to be finalized with all of you um this is just a sample so phase one the pre-recruitment would start immediately and go until the end of February phase two the active recruitment process would last throughout

062the month of March until April 4th to maximize the opportunity for a robust candidate poll in phase three candidates will be selected and interviews will be held between April 14th through May 14th and phase four the new superintendent will be made and appointed by May 22nd at a regularly scheduled board meeting and finally phase five the post appointment services will be provided for up to two two years following the appointment as Ruth mentioned this is a proposed timeline that we think will work but you would make the decision with us as to whether this is a timeline that you want to stick with or make any changes but the amount of time that we've devoted to each of these phases becomes critical we need a few weeks to do all the pre-recruitment we like to

063have about five weeks or so for the recruitment period and so on so uh that would be this will tell you that your new superintendent would be ready to start by July 1st which I believe is critical next slide so we talk about being cost effective our fee is all inclusive we don't charge anything additional at all to what you've agreed on there's nothing additional in terms of any consultant expenses any advertising we take care of all of the advertising uh you get unlimited consultant time and that's critical because when Ruth and I work for you we make a commitment we won't do searches for any other districts we will only be working for belflower and I think you would find that that's pretty unusual most most firms will have their Consultants working in two

064perhaps two or three at a time uh we will have unlimited meetings with stakeholders and we won't tell you that you only get so many meetings and if you want more we'll charge you extra we'll do as many as we identify that we want to meet with and then we get that extra support from all of our partners one of the things we mentioned is that two-year guarantee we will work with your uh with the board and the superintendent to do mentoring but if for any reason that superintendent leaves within two years whether it's your decision or that person's decision we will do a a followup search at no extra charge we give you a two-year guarantee also and this is very rare if at the end of a search you haven't found any of

065the candidates to be somebody you want to select or if you let's say make an offer and that person isn't turns out they can't they don't take the offer we're willing to do a a follow-up search at no extra charge here's something else that we promise you that is a little bit unusual once we place a superintendent here we will never recruit that superintendent for another position it's not unusual for a firm to help a superintendent get a job and then say to that person a few years later we'll help you get a job at a bigger District we don't do that our goal is to help you find somebody who will stay so we guarantee we will not recruit that person for any other jobs next one so we mentioned the all-inclusive fee and

066it really does cover everything that you see there no additional charges next slide and it covers these things that I've already mentioned the compensation study the two years of coaching or mentoring at no charge the the governance Workshop assistance with the contract and all other services next so we make some guarantees that we think are critical and they've been critical for our success in all the searches we've conducted you make every decision as I mentioned before we provide guidance but all decisions are made by the board you get full disclosure of all information on all applicants not only their paperwork but everything we've learned about them you will determine who to inter you'll make the final Choice the choices on who goes from a first round interview to a final round and who you finally

067select again we guarantee that this your selection will not be recruited by us anywhere else and that free search uh follow-up search if a suitable candidate is not selected or if the person leaves within two years I also want to emphasize that we do not have a selected stable of candidates I've actually heard of one situation with another firm where a candidate didn't get a position and was told don't worry we'll get you the next one we don't work that way we know a lot of excellent candidates but we're going to go out and recruit the people that fit the criteria that you determine that as a superintendent you're looking for we do not bring the same candidates over and over to each search okay last slide we re we recognize this is really the

068most important decision you will make hiring your next superintendent we are committed to Excellence in the process and we're committed to finding you the best candidate to to fit belflower and we would be honored to work with you so we thank you very much and we're available to take any questions you might have are there any questions sorry clerk kitfield had occupied my second vice president Gara thank you madam president um in your proposal you also say that you request writing samples can you tell me why you request the writing sample well we do that as part of the interview process and again it's up to the board whether you want to include it or not but we think it's a critical part of the job that the person may have to un certain certain

069circumstances is do a a pressure writing situation where they have to get some information out to staff or community in a very short period of time so we don't ask people to prepare something in advance we give them about 30 minutes and we give them a prompt and we want to see how well they can write at in that period of time because as you know that will come up during the time of being a superintendent many many times we have found it to be a useful part of the process and the second question is um your Support Services can you just give me an example of something that you've supported a a superintendent with before well it there are various things and a lot of it depends on the superintendent and board's needs one

070of the things is helping the board and superintendent to determine the management objectives the goals for the superintendent's evaluation uh if that turns out to be something that's important we will work with the superintendent and you to determine what those goals are and I've I've worked with some boards on actually determining what evaluation instrument they want to use as well so that's one piece but then the ongoing coaching uh I'll give you an example we placed a superintendent uh that started this last July I meet with this person a minimum of once a month in person and I'm available by phone call and uh an email all the time and basically to help them work through a variety of issues that they may deal with because being a new superintendent even if you've done the

071job before being a superintendent in a new District presents challenges that you can't even imagine when you come in so it really is helpful to have that coaching so that's one of the services the other one is the governance Workshop that we provide and um the brochure that you're putting together I'm sorry I don't think that we've ever done that here what does that look like in well I didn't bring a sample but I'll give you I'll give you an idea we we will give put to together a brochure that provides information about the district about belflower that will be important for people to know we will also after we've met with all of our focus groups and then meet with the board again determine what you consider to be the greatest strengths of the

072district that go will go in the brochure also what you consider to be the greatest needs or challenges facing the district and most important what are the most important characteristics you're looking for in a new superintendent that will go into the brochure as well as the application that will be attached for the people to contact us it's really a way of advertising the position so that we want to make make this as appealing as we can to the right candidates and we want it to be appealing based on your criteria thank you clerk chfi thank you madam president uh Joel thank thank you for being here uh appreciate everything you're saying I'm hoping maybe you could uh help me out here because I know uh between the two of you lot of experience very busy

073um and maybe you can help pull back the the the veil for me a little bit here when it comes to uh what you provide for such a small amount uh you know it's like two to three months worth of work and then you all the training and then free repeat of it for two years it just seems like a lot of work for for the firm uh for such a small dollar amount $20,000 for you know potentially a couple years of work can you help me out like just pull back the belt what the financial interest we believe that our fee structure is fair to the school district for one thing we want to make it so that it becomes something that is manageable and fair to the district but we've also found and

074and again I'll point this out as something that may set us apart from from other firms that coaching of the superintendent that is often very valuable some other firms may say oh yeah we'll be glad to do that $10,000 a year or something like that we don't think that that's fair either we think that that should be part of our commitment to you for what we've initially charged so frankly I think we do undercharge but we we really believe that uh we can provide the best services at a very fair price I appreciate that uh you also mentioned you don't have an internal pool of candidates what I mean by that is and again I call it a stable uh there are some firms that we know of that consistently bring the same candidates forward

075to diff districts that are extremely different so we don't believe that that's the best way to determine the candidates to bring forward we know good people and through our network of all of our partners and other people we can identify good people but we don't want to bring you people that are not a match for belflower and what you're looking for so we start fresh in every search trying to trying to recruit the candidates that match the criteria you're looking for right um and and pardon me because you know being on a school board and you've been around sometimes we'll get a PO for like a $10,000 ladder right so uh you know two years of and potentially more of work for this like I want to understand is there a uh what is the

076additional interest in a a client working through the firm to get placed is there anything and this isn't just for your firm but any firm when when you're doing search firm is it just imagine what it would be you mean for the candidates themselves yeah like is there like are they uh the clients in a way no I mean they're candidates we get to know them because we work with them after they've been placed but there's no there's no other advantage to them other than the service that we provide to them as you know during the search and then afterwards for the mentoring great thank you they they don't get any perks in other words great from US vice president Gara thank you I kind of want to have a follow-up question to my um

077colleague so none of these candidates have like a feed to be with you no okay thank you no that's that's I that would be really unethical in my opinion board member Armstrong okay and um thank you for being here and um you said um you would I'm I'm just you said you interview like up to 400 people we did in one District that was a high the highest number I've used I've come across yeah and so you're not going to limit the groups right um let me ask you this um if we have U parents or students or anyone in the community that has uh visual impairments or motor impairments or um hearing impairments speech impairment or any other language other than Spanish and English will you be able to uh ascertain uh uh get

078at a a survey from them well we determine with the district what other languages might be needed for a survey for example and uh Spanish we already have prepared but if it's if you required an other language we'll probably work with somebody in your District who does translation to help us put that together in the right language uh a lot of the services for people with other communication needs we might be working with your District to help identif ify people that you use and that we of course would pay for those people to be available to help us so you know when it comes to perhaps somebody who needs to use sign language or some other things uh we usually find that the districts know the right people and we can work with them thank

079you clerk kitfield thank you madam president um what are your what are your uh your your thoughts your Firm Stance on internal candidates and how do you let them uh compete uh fairly or what are your what has been your experience with that our experience is we like to give them the same opportunity as everybody else now the board will know more about those candidates than we do obviously coming in and when it comes time to make final recommendations I'll be honest with you sometimes there are internal candidates that we don't rate as strong as perhaps some others but we also understand that that a board May determine they want to interview those people because they are in the district but we will give we consider them to be on an equal footing with everybody

080else any other questions um how do you ensure confidentiality uh within the candidates up until the end well it's it's kind of an interesting question we can't guarantee that the candidate will be confidential but it is to their advantage that they be confidential and I can only think of one circumstance in which a candidate did not do that and they actually wound up causing some issues for themselves but we guarantee that we will never discuss with anybody else who the candidates are and we ask you to do the same thing because when if word gets out and I've heard of some examples not from our firm but other firms that word has gotten out that somebody had applied and that per those people sometimes withdrew because they didn't want it to be known back in

081their district and by other people that they were applicants so we take that very seriously to maintain that confidentiality and I don't think we've had a mixup on that ever thank you sir any other questions just one more um the uh in the the process uh have you had experiences with boards who uh would like the current or former superintendent to be uh in some way a part of that process at least in the the finalist stage we have not had any board that wanted that person to be a part and I agree that that's not the best uh way to be involved uh there may be ways in which board members have talked to a sitting superintendent to just get some background information from them about what they think would be helpful but when

082it actually comes to be part of the process We Believe very strongly that it's the board and the board alone that needs to make that decision and we don't really uh advocate for you including any other staff we you're the one 's responsible for hiring and working with that person so uh I have to say in the many searches I've done we've never had a sitting or superintendent become part of that process okay is there any way you could just carbon copy that lady right there for us we'll we'll pay extra for it I've been asked to do that before but uh you know that that gives you a good standard to look at that's very and it could be different depending on the situation whereas we have someone retiring that we absolutely love we

083could include that it's the board search correct sure yeah yeah okay I know when I retired that my board said oh can we find somebody like you well they found somebody very different and he's done a terrific job yeah so there are many different ways of people doing a great job any other questions okay thank you so much we really appreciate it thank you thank you have a good evening thank you Mr Shapiro and Miss Ashley did you want to take a little break or do you want to keep gone I are both of the next they are and what time were they slated to start 6 we're a few minutes behind for the third but that's okay um colleagues do you want to take like a five minute break okay we will take a

084five minute break and we will come back about 620 you guys good all right welcome back we are going to continue on at 6:21 p.m. m oo yes our next presenters are Dr David cash Dr Melissa Moore and Mr Mitch Toria from educational leadership Services thank you for joining us this evening president Stewart members of the board uh thank you for the opportunity to present educational leadership Services proposal to you this evening okay I'm cck thank you so much and welcome all right we'd like to start with a slide that really puts the board at the core of the process some would say that the decision to hire the superintendent is the most important decision that a school board makes and I believe that to be true it starts with all of you you are

085prepared and the best people and the experts about this community to hire your next superintendent it's exciting to see that several of you have business backgrounds educational backgrounds and so you will represent your community well in this process at this time I'd like to introduce our team members first of all Dr David cash after successful career as a trial lawyer Dr cash switched his Focus towards education he worked in a variety of capacities within a school district and became superintendent in three different districts he was in Claremont Clovis and also in Santa Barbara unified Dave is currently the assistant dean of leadership at the rier school of education at the University of Southern California where he taught for the past seven years in addition we have M Mr Mitch Torino on our um Trina on

086our team and he has background in medical research and skilled labor he spent spent more than 20 years in education and has served as assistant superintendent of student services and Human Resources also in Santa Barbara unified Mitch continues to serve in the Santa Barbara County area and currently is a board member in Lomo unified so is a great team member to uh recognize what your process is and how it feels from the other side as a board member uh and then I'm Melissa Moore I'm a recently recovering superintendent I retired from Elsa gundo Unified School District in June and joined the El team I have 42 years in education with expertise in human resources and Innovation and I am on the executive committee also for the rossier school of education and at this time I'd

087like to um uh turn it over oop is me still Mitch Mitch yes thank you Dr Moore Bor Oh wrong way so here's just a quick list of all of the associations and organizations that we belong to through our Associates um most you should uh recognize those I think what for me especially having worked in the HR business the the one that I'm we are most impressed if the work that we do with AXA the association of California school administrators we actually have two of our Associates uh both Northern State and Southern State who are uh leaders in the AXA Academy for superintendent so in that Academy it's not just currently sitting superintendent but also those who are trying to become superintendents maybe not in the next year or two but at least have their

088thoughts on that and the important thing about that is we they're discussing issues that are happening currently or at least superintendents are experiencing now looking to the Future especially with uh our current climate about how they run the school with the board so that organization I think is really important we have a lot of our our people in that and then I think to look at how we span the spectrum of Education we have people who are working on sites with principles and we also have like I said people who are creating superintendent so a very wide spectrum a very wide base of who and how we can help uh District look for their next uh leader thanks Mitch so you you you've heard from from two really wonderful search firms already you're hearing from

089us right now and you hear from another wonderful firm once we're done so why would a board or a community pick education leadership Services what makes us different I think one of the most significant differences is that we have a real clear understanding of the current educational landscape we're not a firm filled with retired people we have current sitting superintendents that our team members we have current County super superintendant that are team members and like uh Mitch we have several current team members who are active Schoolboard members in the state of California um another significant differences our networks that uh Mitch just shared with you across the state we have team members um from all the way as far north as Shasta all the way down to San Diego County and all the way out

090in um in the Eastern sieras as well and we are very highly connected um our roles that we've had throughout the state and the various organizations that we've worked in and led have um enabled us to work with literally hundreds of uh current active superintendents and also individuals who are training to become superintendents of school districts um one of the other differences is that we will have with every search that we do a board member lays on and for this search we're proposing that it's Mitch Torina current board member in Loke Unified School District and Mitch brings with that his experience as an educator and what he what what was not shared he's also married to a high school English teacher so he gets to hear about the reality of high school each and every

091night when he when he gets home or she gets home from work um as as Dr Mo as Melissa shared we have higher education connections uh not just with the University of Southern California where I work and where uh Melissa also provides significant leadership but also with the University of lever Redlands University as well um all of those universities producing um educational leaders a significant El difference and um one that I don't know that you'll hear from anyone else is that this will be the only search that we will be conducting um the three of us we W aren't going to muddy the waters and have five six seven searches being done simultaneously the three of us will only be focused on Bellflower Unified School District which means that once we've had an opportunity to

092listen to you as the elected board members listen to your uh stakeholder groups your community about what they'd like to see in the next superintendent we will then conduct a very unique search that's tailored to the needs that you as board members and your community have identified we're not going to bring along uh candidates who are in other searches who weren't selected by school boards and that those things I think enable us to say very clearly um with transparency to school boards that's what makes El unique and different Dr Moore oops thank you Dave Bel flower Community has much to be proud of you have wonderful schools but and as all educational institutions we all have more work to do and so you need a superintendent to assist you in leading that work um but

093you have many many things to be proud of I know I was especially impressed with your 20 comprehensive Pathways that you offer your student you have multiple Awards as distinguished schools to model continuation schools to gold Ribbon Schools to Blue Ribbon Schools you are clearly unified in your purpose regarding your core values for your future students to have an atmosphere of equity uh commitment to the community as well as achievement so congratulations so we're going to spend just a couple of slides and talk about uh what the search process would look like um and it's probably not that much different than what you've already heard and what you'll hear later um but the most important thing that happens right off the bat is a planning meeting with the board um and that allows us to

094really dig in and listen to you as share with us who you want us to go out and get information from what are your significant issues and concerns and ideas about the next superintendent and in that planning meeting we lay out a calendar that meets the district and the board's needs these events will happen by this day these events will happen by these dates Etc so that it's very clear and transparent not just to the board but also to your community because we'll suggest U that you post that calendar on the district's web page so the community has an idea about oh okay I see what's happening now the board is involved in this um the the search firm is out uh recruiting candidates right now it's that time to do that one of the

095most important things that we'll learn in the planning meeting is who do want us to actually go and listen to in your community um and we'll suggest that we listen to District administrators we we hold faculty meetings we hold staff meetings we have small focus groups with your employee Association leadership teams that we meet with students that we have Town Hall community events so that we can hear from parents and the community members um to hear them tell us what they'd like to see in the next superintendent and we'll also o launch an online survey um that we would have available in English and another language that is that you would like to see it in um that would be available for everyone over a two-e period with all of that data we put together

096a superintendent leadership report and then we'll also give you a lot of the raw data there'll be some data we may not give you just to protect you uh and uh we'll we'll run that through District's legal counsil because sometimes people say things in uh in open-ended survey that probably shouldn't be see the light of day but the most of the data will come to you and it give you pretty clear idea about not only what you as the elected board members would like to see but what your various community members too it'll be disaggregated by students students say this faculty says this staff says this parents want this so that you really have a very clear idea as to what your community is saying about what they'd like to see um and what's wonderful

097about that is that when we get to the interview portion of our search process we have a tool that we've created that will allow you to essentially lay down what skills characteristics experience attributes you and your community have identified with the candidates that we'll be presenting or who have applied for the position of superintendent for the bellower Unified School District Mitch see if I clicked it the right way yes all right is that forward okay so the idea in our Recruitment and selection is the ideal is we get a complete picture from you your stakeholders and your community our job is then to go out and find the people who fit that one of the things that you will also get is maybe not just everybody so we'll tear off who we select as a

098group from what you give us uh 1 two 3 4 and you will get to see all of those applicants not just the ones that we choose who we think that your profile has given to us to fit best but you also get to see some of the applicants who maybe we thought was a lower tier or a different tier for whatever reasons that maybe haven't come to surface or maybe you've gotten information from other people who we didn't get information from regarding certain candidates so that's one aspect that I think might be a little different the other piece that I know wholeheartedly in regards to uh hiring from an HR standpoint is it really has to be a fit there are qualifications and then part of our interview process is to really get that

099fit for what Bellflower wants and what they need and what they hope to get in their next superint superintendent there's also the aspect that once we get a person in your seat that we will be giving them full support in regards to mentorship um it can go as only as 100 days or we can do a full year with that that would be upon request and uh demand from you as the board for seeing that so even if it's person and this is something that I was taught in HR let's say somebody can do the job they should be able to do the job at least 60% but there's going to be 20% Which they're hoping to do and in school systems and in in in everywhere there's there going to be another 20% that

100they don't know because nobody knows it hasn't hit them yet whether it's pandemic or whether it's uh ice coming it hasn't happened yet for that candidate so they're not going to know how to handle this so part of our job is to really help them prepare a wide base of what's possible what's definitely going to happen these are what superintendents are all responsible for but more likely than not what's not on the radar that could happen and that's why we have such an extensive uh group who are doing the work of teaching and helping our new superintendents learn that the timeline we're proposing is absolutely um flexible we did not lock in dates specifically because we need to hear from you what works with everyone's schedule and putting that all together and so it's very

101achievable to start today to dig in to take a look at uh moving forward and uh have a new person in place for July 1st so really quickly I I just want to get to what's important to everyone and that is how much does it cost we have an all-in fee $20,000 for the search um one of the things we will not do is then once you've selected a candidate um have written into that candidate's contract a coaching uh portion of it we would will for an extra fee we will Coach the candidate that you have selected for their first year here at belflower Unified School District as part of our all-in fee of $20,000 and part of that is because we're just committed to finding the best person for belflower and then supporting them

102through their often very difficult uh first year whether they're an experienced superintendent coming from another District or they're an inexperienced superintendent coming from another District or there's someone who's never sat in the chair um everyone needs to have a coach everyone needs to uh have uh someone they can bounce ideas off and learn from and we're committed to doing that as part of our Allin uh fee of $20,000 um one last thing that I want to make sure that we are very clear about with you and that is uh our goal is to meet your and the community needs and that really I want I want to make that very clear we will not bring forward candidates that we do not believe meet the community's needs based upon and what we've heard from you and

103what we've heard from the community um and that I think is very important and with that we'll take questions if you have any for us board member Centron um so in reference thank you for your time all three of you um in reference to the survey you only do the survey in two languages well uh we can do it in more than two languages but typically that's what gets requested two languages and is that additional fee if we wanted in more languages yes it would be $425 um and when it comes to the in-person engagement sessions how many do you do yeah go ahead I'm sorry well we'll do as many as we need to do um in order to ensure that we get all the community input that that we need we also realize

104that that we may hold a a a faculty meeting at a high school or a middle school an invite teachers to attend and th teachers will come but some will not feel comfortable speaking out loud in front of the group so we also give them our cell phone numbers and our email addresses and encourage them to contact us and we can talk to them on the phone or they can send us their input via email um our goal really is to listen and get as much input as possible okay um and with reference to that those engagement sessions you created a list is on your presentation is that restricted to only that list oh no no no no we're in the planning meeting our goal is to hear from you who do you think we

105you want us to hear from the most um in in a community I live in Long Beach so I know B flower I don't know it as well as you but I grew up went to Long Beach Schools um and I know that what's important most likely is that we also hear from other agencies in the community maybe we need to hear from city council maybe we need to hear from law enforcement fire department Parks and Recreation um Youth Services um churches synagogues um whomever we need to hear from okay and another followup to that is uh what what are your methods to report out to US based on the surveys and the inperson sessions like what should we expect to see from your company like do we get you'll get a comprehensive report um

106that we would suggest that again in that you post online so the community can see it as well that'll provide board members with a lot of information disaggregated by in you know individual groups but also around three big Ideas one what are some of the current issues that are the the district is facing that a new superintendent is going to need to know in order to be successful what are some of the issues that the district may be facing in the next couple of years um that a new superintendent would need to be prepared for in order to be successful what skills characteristics experience and attributes would the community like to see in the um next superintendent so the data that you'll get will be around those three big Ideas all right thank you Miss

107Armstrong thank you thank you president uh again thanks thank you for being here um how how do you um keep your client's identity confidential to the end and like and how important is that that's a really great question so um we recommend to boards that they conduct a confidential search because because that encourages the number of clients we have board members sign a confidentiality agreement um because you will have access to all the applications the names the references the resumés the letters of interest for for the applicants for this position um and that has worked very well I've I we've also done non-confidential searches as well um and um and they they you boards get fine candidates the only difference between the two is that sometimes sitting superintendant are less likely to apply in a

108non-confidential search process because they of their fear of upsetting their current board in the community where they live and work all right thank you very much for that also um um do you have any way of um like when you when you're getting when you're Gathering data when you're doing your surveys will do you have u means for getting surveys from uh parents and our students who may have visual impairments motor impairments or uh hearing impairments or speech impairments well we we will not only launch an online survey but we'll make available at every School site a written survey as well and we'll invite the kind I kind of being a former principal I kind of look at principles as being like the mayor of their small community they know every body they know the

109parents they know the kids um and they're in a great position in that role to be able to facilitate uh help us get the information we need from people who may have trouble accessing it in a more traditional way by this being a different means other than English and Spanish would that service cost more no okay thank you very much um um you mentioned something about um oh my goodness I I wrote something down about the new superintendent do are you treating every uh okay if you were to place a superintendent depend regardless of the experience is that superintendent considered to be a new superintendent to where you would provide like coaching Services etc etc we will Coach anyone the board select and belflower whether they've been a superintendent for 20 years or never been

110one okay so new as your your client yes okay thank you um that's it for now board member San yeah sorry I had I should have just asked this question altogether um back to the inperson sessions do you only conduct those in English no we would hope to have uh it trans an interpreter there and probably Spanish I don't know what other was there another dominant language in the belare Unified School District other than English and Spanish yes okay yeah besides English and Spanish yeah what dominic can you fill us in on that what dominant language is there besides English and Spanish typically we translate everything in English and Spanish if there's a particular large population in a specific site we may do further translation but right now we spend most of our time in

111English and Spanish okay so if we want to include all the sites I think we need to consider different languages other than English and Spanish I think that's where I do you remember the last search what languages we did sorry about that I was just going to share with you at one particular site we would probably want to provide it in Arabic okay are there any others that you can think of do we have any other thoughts okay thank you yep so we'd probably look for the district to help us in interpreting um at that school site in Arabic okay thank you and then um you referenced coaching Services could would you be a little bit more specific on what type of coaching Services um and are you available all the time sometimes what does

112that look like for it's it's different with every person you coach um because some people need or want more coaching than others uh we typically make ourselves available to the superintendent at their request I'm currently coaching a a new superintendent in the district that a search that we did up in Northern California and I talk to her probably twice a month maybe three times a month and we text probably six to eight times a month um and in the context of that often I'll also communicate with the board president as well so just to be clear the new superintendent would have to reach out to your agency to get coaching that they may need well or do you have a standard basine coaching service and then you add more to that based on what the

113needs are for that District or that particular person what it it all the coaching is customized to the individual person receiving the coaching okay and you work with them on developing that uhhuh yes absolutely yeah yeah I have one person I'm working with who um needed a lot of coaching to start with and as kind of he has kind of gotten more and more comfortable and confident in this new community came from a very different Community was a very experienced superintendent um and we have talked less and less as the years gone by um I check in with them regularly I'll text them and say hey how's it going I looked at one of your board meeting agendas was that an issue that sort of stuff awesome and then could you provide a reference or

114references um from previous clients who have used your services for superintendent services please uh we did in our proposal oh okay oh thank you vice president Garza thank you um Madam president so my question pertains to your proposal it says um you would also gather PTA leadership um and parents how would you go around balancing that group and finding enough parents to hear from well that would not be the sole source of parent information we would try to we would hope to hold and you know I've Had It Go a number of ways it's interesting in communities hold Community meetings um at your high schools is kind of typically where everyone ends up um in a unified school district and you know people either identify as belf flare or Mayfair probably um and we would

115invite parents to come and um we can't force them to come we would also have an online survey that that we would hope to hear from a significant number of parents who didn't feel comfortable coming or couldn't come at the night of the community meeting um and that's kind of typically how we get the information we would talk to if the board if you directed us to that your PTA PTSA PTO leadership um if you felt that was a significant group for us to hear from but uh we want to hear from all parents not just parents who have decided to become members of the PTA um yeah I'm sorry yeah I'd like to add that in some instances you know people are working right and so if it would um be uh meet a

116different group of people's needs we would also be open to zoom because you can get a whole different population of folks who have to feed their kids at night or whatnot and so they just can't make it to the meeting and so a zoom option uh or two would also be something we're very open to and have facilitated perfect thank you um you also say in your proposal that you would provide up to three individual ESL te members that would be you right just or the three of us will be the the the principal um Partners in the search but we will our entire e El team across the state will be involved in helping us recruit candidates that was going to be my next question how do you recruit candidates from other states or

117what's your net wor word look like our network is pretty huge uh um you know I've trained probably between between 500 and a th000 superintendant in the state of California through my work at USC my work through AXA um and my work through the suburban school superintendence as well as the urban dialogue so um our and that's just me and then we have on as team members we also have Dr Moore Mr Terina um and people who aren't here who two County superintendents who are in the northern part of the county we have Ron kruth who was the most recent president of the super superintendent Council for the State of California um we have down South we have Clint Harwick who was um the president of the association of California school administrators um so we

118we have a very vast network of team members both who are currently superintendents and are retired um who know of and know about people who might be interested in becoming the next superintendent in belflower okay and if we actually um have a superintendent that wishes to go on another search for whatever reason would you would you come back for that superintendent to look for them as being no no no no we we're we're g if we're selected to conduct this search we're going to look for candidates that want to be here for a significant period of time I mean five years for us is is the smallest period of time that we think would be good we want candidates are going to be committed to belflower committed to this community and committed to a long-term

119position as the superintendent uh we guarantee to you that we will not put any candidate that we place uh with uh with your help here in belflower in any other search um and if a candidate comes to us and says hey you know I'm thinking about applying for you know the XYZ school district and they've they've been here only a couple years I my our advice to them will be no you need to stay what's going on let's figure it out we'll come in we'll help if there an issue um let's have a candid conversation remember you agreed to be committed to this community thank you clerk kitfield thank you Madame President thank you for being here uh and I appreciate the personalized touch on the presentation very well done um couple questions one uh

120what has been your experience and what is your uh take on internal candidates oh um we we usually present the board with two options in relationship to internal candidates and and uh those options are one do a a two-step process where you would take all the internal candidates or or the internal candidate and interview them take them through the require them to apply take them through the same interview process that you would you would conduct in a at large interview process process do that make a decision in consultation with the with the search Partners did that person answer all the questions correctly is that the person that you want sitting in the seat if so then you don't need to go back out and look at um other candidates the other process is to have

121internal candidates be considered along with everyone else um and if you do that and I've had we've had experience in both of these if you do that then it's mostly only only fair to those internal candidates to say there's no guarantee that you're going to get an interview because if you're going to compare them with everybody else then the worst thing that you could possibly do is to give them an interview with no real intent that this is the candidate that you could see sitting in the seat um but both of those ways both both of those kind of approaches work well um so that's what we've done okay I app appreciate that the answer um another question and I kind of had it I've had it for the other firms as well um this

122seems like a a lot of work and uh you mentioned we'd be the only search that uh you'd be doing and it' take a few months 20 thou I mean it just seems like such a a small price di compared to some of the other stuff that we see I know some firms will do a there's flat fee and then some will do a percentage of the superintendent's salary uh but yours is just the flat fee correct all in $20,000 when we created education leadership services our mission and our vision is to support school districts in California no other reason none of us are in it to make money as you you can uh tell we're here because we believe strongly in uh how important superintendent leadership is principal leadership is board leadership is we

123do a lot of work around board governance as well and our goal really is to support school districts and doing the best work they can for their communities great thank you and U last question and you might have covered it if I missed it I do apologize uh do you also uh have uh is it your practice to help negotiate superintendent contract or is that not something you guys do on your end uh we've done I've many negotiated many what we will typically do is we'll have a conversation with you about what are the contract parameters um because we don't want to have someone that you interview and then you say oh well here's what the contract parameters are and this person she's your number one candidate and she says I can't work for less

124than blank and then you go oh gee uh what do we do now so we'll we'll make sure that we have that very candid and important conversation about where that is for B Bellflower unified but you have an attorney um and so I my my belief is most likely and we we met in in the break so I I know who he is that's the only reason why I know who he is um so we met during the break um sure is is we would expect that he would be the probably the lead lead negotiator along with the board president in negotiating the contract with your finalist um and I want to be really clear we work for you we don't work for the people that you know were recruiting to be your superintendent so

125um but we wouldn't get in the way particularly when you have Council uh and try to negotiate the contract unless uh we we would be probably a conduit to the finalist candidate and say here here's what what what you know the contract parameters are great thank you board member Armstrong go sorry go ahead yeah yeah I just wanted to add that you know superintendent contracts are public information so it is very easy to do a a wide look at what are the comparables in the area so that we know you know what is the market actually what's the industry standard in this area so that's very very helpful and so we would want to be sure that you're able to make an informed decision thank you bman burnstrong thank you um president Stuart um I

126I didn't see in here maybe I just Overlook it looked it but do you have um what is your Su success rate for three to five years right now 100% for three and five or well not everybody we we we've worked with has been in the seat for three years um some have you know just we've we've completed the search so they've been in it for a year um but those that have we placed over five years seven years ago um are still serving those communities 100% okay great thank you any other questions thank you so much we really appreciate your presentation thank you very much thank you for joining us okay and we have one more presentation for for this evening we have Dr vugo here from leadership and Associates thank you Dr vugo

127thank you so much for being here we appreciate it you have to click the button down there and then it'll turn green up here there you go okay thank you well good evening um unfortunately Sandy thonon our other search partner uh has um caught that virus that's going around and so as a result she will not be here and Dr Peggy Lynch whose uh photo you see up there is not going to be involved in this particular search after all but I do want to begin by um thanking you on behalf of Sandy and myself U like to express our appreciation for you folks taking the time and allowing us to uh present our leadership associate superintendent search uh proposal I'm going to start start with Sandy for a moment just to let you know

128that she is the previous whiter Union High School Superintendent a position that she held for if I'm not mistaken 15 years her entire career was in the Whittier High School um program she has also been the chair of the California collaborative and also the chair of the axis superintendent Council as far as I am concerned me um I'm a senior partner with leadership Associates I've been a senior partner now for the past 10 or 11 years I've completed approximately between 50 and 60 searches I am the former and retired superintendent of paramont Unified School District a position that I held for 10 years there in paramont following retirement I was selected to be the um executive director of the California Association of Latino administrators and superintendents kalsa as well as working out of Washington DC

129as the superintendent's Leadership Academy director where I mentored and coached um aspiring superintendents Across the Nation I'm one of four bilingual partners with leadership Associates and of course we have found that's really an important factor um particularly during your stakeholder input sessions I also have been the deputy superintendant in placent or Belinda and I spent 22 years where I grew up in pic Riva um as a K12 Elementary principal as well as high school principal I was the principal of El Rancho High School U the school that I attended as a matter of fact and that was unique I think I was 35 I needed some humility I remember going to my chemistry teacher and demanding the lesson plans to be on my desk by Friday she reminded me and said Dr V I'll remind

130you you got to see in my chemistry class so that was one thing but prior to moving on to the next uh slide I did want to inform the board that we are in fact the only silver affiliate um Associated and recognized by csba in terms of search firms this I think is a particularly important slide it displays the unique and really outstanding support during the search that we at leadership Associates provide each of these ladies that you see there are former superintendent executive assistants and secretaries and we believe that it will provide your administrative staff and your technology staff tremendous assistance they are support specialist they will be assigned to the school district um exceptional support throughout the district throughout this process uh comprehensive on call support personalized written guidelines templates documents checklist Brown

131act aspects of things and really prompt and very much communication this next one point it there okay is really what we consider to be our why and I'll just go make sure I fill up that and we really do refer to it as our why who are we we're a partnership of active super educational leaders who are committed to providing and improving the quality of education for all California students We Believe certainly that high public quality public education committed to providing an excellent and Equitable education for all children is really truly the foundation of our Democratic Society that every student staff member deserves a passionate caring and inspired leader focused on ensuring all children receive the highest quality education possible and what we believe and what we value is integrity Equity Excellence diversity inclusion accountability

132and certainly transparency and we continue to support I'm sorry I apologize I think that's coming yeah we um continue to support uh School boards and other educational leaders you can see the writing up there highly Prof professional executive searches tailored to your individual client needs challenging and engaging professional growth opportunities and we remain engaged with boards superintendents and other leaders that we support this has been one of the main areas that we have supported throughout the entire time with leadership Associates this next is really a quick slide on additional services that we have provided over the years um we have been um dealing with uh aspiring superintendant County superintendant we serve over 45 districts in California we have worked directly with assistant superintendant all with the idea that one of these days those folks uh

133will be in line for superintendent positions and we particularly think it's important as it relates to leadership transition anytime that uh a superintendent is selected to a school district we believe that there are unique features that need they need they may need assistance on if they've never passed a bond if they've never changed a boundary if they've never U closed a school or dealt with declining enrollment those are all critical issues and challenges that all of our partners have dealt with accordingly and I know that many um search firms to be very Frank with you will utilize current superintendant sitting on the job we do not believe professionally that a current superintendent can balance a search process as well as do the professional job in their uh respective districts so I do want to point

134that out here is a snapshot of all of the partners that we have in our particular organization and I say Partners not Consultants because across the state of California each of us have a vested interest we are located invested in California uh we are not an out ofate organization twice a month the search partners are on a mutual Zoom meeting to discuss recruit uh placement references positions of match and fit on each search that's taking place so in essence you not only have Sandy and myself you actually have the entire team and again a quick snapshot of those here are some of the searches that we've completed a long history of successful searches over 700 searches that we have completed accordingly in fact I just completed Norwalk La marada not too long ago I was

135uh had the pleasure of doing ABC Buena Park paramont El Rancho UniFi beyond that some of the searches that I've been involved with in the mediate Area Pasadena Santa Monica Malibu Fullerton joint Union High School District La Habra as well as East Whittier and So currently this year alone we are proud and really blessed to say that we have done Approximately 80% of the superintendent searches in the state of California up to this date State and national colle uh connections are important in this case we have been responsing responsible directly for many many of the CEOs and executive directors that you see listed there kalsa of course I just returned from a Kaa conference I have worked diligently with Dwight bonds with the Kasa Association we provided the bylaws for Capal to get started as

136a matter of fact and you can see the rest of the list that you see there including AXA and csba this next slide again I'll fill that up momentarily there I want to start with the fact that this uh selection process starts and end with the Board of Education this is your search the next portion of that on the right hand slide that kind of bluish portion is the educational partner input in person as well as virtual meaning Zoom as well as a survey that we will conduct as well um exclusive and extensive interviews with your stakeholders and your constituents we will would provide you a template of those that we typically deal with but we invite the board to add to that list because we know that you know your District accordingly District Outreach

137to a wide variety of Partners it's that what that we use for the position description the job description if you will that position description includes a description of your community your District as well as the characteristics and experiences that you desire most in the next superintendent we do not move forward with that draft without your approval by the way and then we with that position description begin to develop a an executive summary it's practically like a was accreditation report that is provided to you it it contains not only the characteristics and experiences that you desire most in your next superintendent but we also include the strengths of the district but perhaps more importantly some of the challenges that the district is facing that information is a wonderful strategic road map for the superintendent he or

138she along an Inon Junction with the board to go forward that next uh area which is kind of gray if you will is the uh Recruitment and campaign Outreach uh broad advertisement we blast out right now from our organization 1500 individuals are attached to us with respect to Opportunities and jobs accordingly um so we also of course do tremendous comprehensive vetting Financial criminal our application desires that they have three letters of recommendation five uh references but we go much beyond that it's critical to make sure that we have no hidden agendas in terms of any of the U people that might be interested and as a result of doing 80% of the searches currently in in the state of California this is going to sound a little assertive but we know who has baggage and

139so that is an an important a very critical item to bring forward so the Recruitment and Outreach campaign is comprehensive as I mentioned all of the partners are involved in that that kind of brownish uh area presentation of candidates you will be able to review and see all of the applications online we provide that approximately four to five days prior to the candidate selection process so it gives you valuable and extreme time if you will to look over and review the candidates that have applied we of course have already vetted the candidates and will'll bring forward to you what we consider the best match and fit tier one however if there's a tier two or tier three person that you would inquire about we will be um able and more than happy to provide you

140Insight in terms of the information that we've been provided regarding that individual and of course we facilitate the interviews that is particularly important we do not move forward with any of the questions until they are approved by the Board of Education we think that that's an important aspect to this um fin fin interview selection process the uh typical amount is probably between five and six it can get as high as seven could get as low as four in terms of the tier one candidates who are absolutely the best match and fit for belflower Unified School District having said that we will also provide the board with the finalists let's say you have two finalists we will make sure that we know what their parameters are ahead of time what their compensation request is what their

141Health and Welfare benefits might be what are some of their technology needs what organizations have they a desire to join Lakewood rotary for example AXA um csba those kinds of things are real critical with respect to that but um the other thing that I would mention is preserving confidentiality it's interesting in that the phenomena when people begin to apply the phenomena in their current district is you don't love us anymore or you'd like to get more pay so we deal with that very carefully and of course the board um is in a confidential aspect of that as well but we deal with that um very vigorously we don't want someone to be harmed in a current District where they might be interested in this particular district and so again a successful Bellflower USD superintendent search

142Ys um experienced highquality leaders that meet the needs of belflower the broadest and deepest pool of candidates that you can imagine 1500 subscribers to our website by the way 66% of our finalists selected have been women or candidates of color we're extremely proud of that we're California based we're California Savvy we are Partners we're not hired Consultants uh we remain actively engaged uh we just had our Advance we don't call them Retreats anymore leadership Associates Advance during the access superintendent Symposium we spend the entire day from 7:30 in the morning till 6 in the afternoon discussing the most current state as well as most current federal aspects of what is taking place throughout the state as well as the nation that is going to be particularly important for superintendents as they move forward in terms

143of their knowledge base of what's happening and what's occurring and of course we uh provide a 90-day plan a complimentary one an entry plan but always always in conjunction with the board they may have a draft 90day plan but it has to be met with and dealt with in terms of belflower and not generically and so we always do that with respect to the board as well some closing thoughts um it's your search it's personalized but it is broad-based it's highly technical it's competitive it's an all-inclusive cost there are no hidden fees Sandy and I by the way are local she is located in whiter I happen to reside in La Habra uh highly qualified administrative staff full administrative support for the ladies that are in the superintendent's office as well as your technology department

144as I mentioned women and persons of color 66% we're an experienced California firm we have a strong Statewide presence but we also have a national reach as well there are many nationally based superintendents who are interested in coming to California we are passionate and we are committed to this work and so with that any questions that you might have I just wanted to clarify one thing on the leadership Associates Partners we see Juan Garza listed and it is not the husband of Miss vice president Garza I just want to put that out there that she has no relation you can look this up this one Garza has been a superintendent for 15 years in Kings Canyon unified and that is not miss Garza's husband so I just want to say that before we open it

145up for questions that's a good point Mr Mr Garza is located in the Fresno Valley area thank you so much for that and we be stretched from Shasta all the way down to San Diego area Okay um Miss Armstrong thank you so much president um uh Stuart um do you in your search I know you say you you place a lot of you know women of color Etc do you utilize uh National networks and associations to Source candidates we absolutely do during that vetting process we allow the those individuals to provide us additional contacts that might be uh improving their opportunity those could be national uh they could be Statewide as well and they could be local um so we try to work directly with anyone who might be interested and who applies we create

146what I'm calling a partnership with them as well because we realize how important it is for them to move forward correctly and we're also helpful to them we might find something on their application early on that really doesn't um not make sense but might be an error for example we want to work with them accordingly so yes those connections are nationally based as well in fact we've had applicants internationally okay thank you um also um confidentiality how how how are you going to handle that until the end because we may have a sitting superintendent how are you going to handle that well that's a real critical and a great question we know that you folks as trustees are most likely going to be um asked if you will what is taking place what might are

147the next steps for example and we would advise the board members to Simply get a hold directly to us and let us handle those Direct Communications with people who might be interested um in acquiring more information about the steps the timeline the start date uh the process if you will um having said that though the confidentiality that I was referring to to is um providing confidentiality so that the person who is an applicant isn't injured by someone maybe making mention of the fact that they have applied for a new position outside of their District as it relates to the trustees we would require that that confidentiality be some uh be an aspect for this governance team that's particularly important as well okay and thank you I have another question please um you're going to be

148doing surveys and colle in data that's correct um how are you going to um reach parents students or community members that may have visual impairments physical or motor impairments hearing hearing impairments or even speech impairments how are you going to reach those people I would imagine Miss Armstrong that we would work directly with the district and provide an opportunity to have personal conversations and or meetings with those individuals or groups that is something that we are very proud of in the point of having kind of a a a three-way effort to reach your constituents so not only Zoom meetings accordingly personal meetings here within the district and of course the survey and since covid has happened some of the postco survey numbers that we are receiving are really quite strong high volume we will work

149with your site principles as well we will manage that survey and take a look at it on a weekly basis to see what the amount or the volume is and if it's weak or not as high as we think it should be we will create a campaign in conjunction with your site principals and your district office to raise that number so that we can get those voices accordingly but we have no difficulty whatsoever in uh personal contacts and meetings uh with individuals or groups that might have some of those challenges thank you and I have one last question yes ma'am once we get to the end of this search um How do you do you support your placements I know you say I know you have like a two-year guarantee that's correct but how are

150you going to provide any support for them within those two years there's two ways that we can do that we can um execute a contract specific to coaching opportunities for that individual but beyond that regardless of the contract we would be available as thought Partners so if we were successful in the search myself and Sandy would be thought partners for a minimum of a year and if it was an EXT u a contract that would be executed then some of the details of that coaching opportunity that thought partnership that mentorship if you will uh would be available according to the contract but we never ever leave a superintendent that has been newly hired um uh without some support accordingly an example I may give you if I may Norwalk larada Dr Natasha Baker who has

151just been selected we assisted her with her 90 days plan we felt it was important for that 90day plan to be extremely transparent so our suggestion as a thought partner was to provide that to the entire community and not just to the board of education so that transparency really went a long way so there's two ways I think that I would share that with you um an executed contract for more specific mentoring opportunities but we never leave um someone that has been selected by the board um on their own thank you so much sir thank president board member Centron I thank you again for your presentation um just kind of piggybacking um is this additional after the 90-day transition is it additional fee is it a different contract to get a training or a development

152kind of schedule for the new super we maintain a free superintendent Leadership Academy or Advisory Group so one could take advantage of that through the county LA County Office of Education we currently serve 80 school districts who in turn serve more than one and a half two million students so there's that aspect or opportunity we certainly could entertain an executed contract with many more specifics as to what that coaching looks like but we again would be as I mentioned to miss Armstrong uh would be available for for any thought partner mentoring advice um engagement with that particular superintendent we believe it's important for us to be available um anytime that superintendent regardless of whether they're a season superintendent or a a new superintendent to the seat uh we would make ourselves available and that is

153typically for at least a year but again they could take advantage of the superintendent leadership Advisory Group which we Now operate through at least five counties from El Dorado County up in the area up North down to San Diego most of our partners that I saw that I showed you on that list on that map are involved in one way or another as coaches and mentors thank you certainly Clark kitfield thank you madam president thank you for the presentation uh truly appreciate it uh couple questions uh one how do you uh handle internal candidates our handling of internal candidates um is more specific with a um particular conversation with the Board of Education we feel that the confidentiality of that conversation is important uh to deal with in a closed session under Personnel so if

154there is in fact uh a number or certain individuals that might be interested in applying for the position we certainly believe that it's important to compare and cont contrast those individuals with the other pool of people that um the board might be interested in interviewing but we really feel that it's going to be an important conversation during our initial meeting with the Board of Education where we place a full agenda for the board on the topics that we intend to talk about so those topics might be what are your characteristics that you'd like to see those topics are what are some of the uh uh compensation range um it would be things like um what who you want us to reach out to in terms of stakeholder input then that's all in public by the

155way which is very important but then as we get into more personal conversations with respect to who you would like us to maybe recruit and or a little bit better and stronger conversation about the internal candidates we believe that's a conversation that should be held with the trustees the governing team and ourselves great thank you yes um and just a question that that I've just asked everybody is uh how with first of all you have a great reputation I've I've heard great things um and you guys seem very uh active how many concurrent uh searches do you operate at any one time me you mean yeah yeah our partners generally might have two superintendent searches on their docket if you're asking me personally I'm going to be involved in the Orange Unified School District superintendency

156search however we do have four Partners um which I'm happy to say on that particular search that search of course involves I think a school district of almost 30,000 students and so the intent there was to make sure that we had four individuals I happen to be one of those individuals on that search belflower and orange UniFi would be the only two searches that I would be committed to no others okay and the reason I ask is yes sir because the B seems so reasonable uh compared to some other things that we see uh and you said it's all inclusive that's correct um but what percentage after you place a superintendent do you end up on some other uh contract with coaching or is it is it pretty common to have a additional contract once

157they get placed it it absolutely is and it has been a fact it's almost like a corporate model now regardless of whether or not you're season superintendent or a newbie we have felt and I think that the general sense is that people should and have should have a coach accordingly a mentor perhaps and that's why I kind of lessened that wording including a thought partner to be able to pick up the phone and say Hey I'm um dealing with some governance issues um you know which is the most important relationship that I can imagine when I was in paramont for 10 years if I may it was the closest relationship and thing it's the closest relationship compared to my marriage and I've been married for 52 years so my point simply being is those are

158the kinds of things that we want to avoid those pitfalls perhaps those questions um that networking is extremely important right so the the thought partner and so you don't just Place him and then they're they're left alone there is some relationship a part of this agreement but typically it's the corporate model where they'll yeah there's going to be an an additional contract that kind of stay in the network there could be and that's a great question let me give it to you maybe percentage wise I would say that at least 25% stay with what I would consider a minimal um uh thought partner mentoring opportunity and the balance might be 50% that um that take advantage of an extended contract a separate contract beyond their their negotiated contract to have Services of a of a

159mentor and uh to be very honest with you as much as I believe our mentors are the top mentors in the entire State and coaches that might be a conversation with your board regarding cost factors regarding the regarding the Optics of that which is extremely important as well so as much as I stand up here and say we would love to be a coach with you folks as well and we're committed to doing that should that be the case that uh typically ends up as a a an additional conversation with the trustees as well right what what are those those contracts usually look like in terms of amounts yeah um I've seen them as low as $10,000 um there have been some for example in Fresno a very complicated School District that we've maintained coaches

160there as much as $30,000 okay but again I believe I I believe it tends to um navigate itself with respect to the number of students some of the complexities things of that sort right great thank thank you very much yes any further questions hearing none thank you so much I really appreciate you coming and it's amazing seeing you again appreciate it a great deal thank you and good luck appreciate that thank you Dr FDO okay I know we have a lot to think about do we want to take a short break we want to just go for it I only hear Brad break I hear you go for it what do you guys think okay we're going to take a five minute break and we will come back at 7:35 all right we will now

161reconvene into open at 7:38 all right colleagues so we need to discuss a firm um I'm thinking maybe the best way to do it is is there one firm that we can eliminate is there one that you felt was number four on the list that we can eliminate anybody M Centron um I was not impressed with e um Els okay the education leadership services um I think there's a lot of extras when it comes to the language engagement that we would have to like pay for it it also didn't seem like a good fit I know they provide coaching services and I wish I had like a significant reason but out of the four I just something just is telling me this is not going to be a good fit especially the the reason why

162I asked about the references because I looked up their references they're only private schools they have one no they have two um unified school districts that they've placed one was for 32,000 kids and the other one even though it says Unified School District is only 1,700 1750 so I don't know if that's a good fit for us we you know they they work mostly with private schools okay um one thing to note just for our public and in general is um the four different firms the first one uh mcferson and Jacobson the cost was 23,000 the next two Costa and El was 20,000 and then the last one the associates um was 28,000 so just to put that out there for you guys um those were a little bit of a different but the range

16323 to 28 is only 5,000 so it's not a big deal but I just wanted to put it out there um Clark critchfield thank you Madame President um just to be uh first of all I I want to thank all the the firms for for coming out presenting I think they all had really good uh uh things to to say about their companies but out of respect that I won't go down like why I I don't like others but I will say my my top two are mcferson and Jake Jacobson and Leadership Associates uh I think after kind of going through those two I I I like leadership Associates I think that they have a emphasis on their selection process and making sure that it's uh make what was that oh no it's okay go

164ahead we I just asked you for your last one but I understand that you want to go your direction so go ahead yeah if I could uh I think two things I think their their selection process of uh finding the best candidate but also so uh finding candidates that represent our our community is really important and honestly they the the last question they they answered it honestly uh with uh their additional contracts and and we're very open and honest about that question which so that would be mine thank you do you guys have any others that we can eliminate I agree with um board memb Inon um Els just again I can't put my finger on it but there was something missing for me there okay um for me I would probably eliminate Costa I

165could eliminate Els as well uh B Armstrong mic I can eliminate the Costa group and educational leadership I'm really um um I really like leadership Associates but if you could tell me more I mean if you guys want MC ferson then I'm okay with it but I really like leadership Associates okay so it seems like we have it down to two leadership Associates and mcferson and Jacobson um I know again the prices are about are pretty similar it seems like I've heard a lot of positive things about both of these companies in regards to uh their networking and their ability to find superintendence um the only really thing I saw that was different was that I know it was a two-year with mcferson and Jacobson on the superintendent um working with them where it was

166a little bit different with leadership Associates um do you want to add now uh that we have it down to two uh Miss Centron yeah I think um I I think I agree I definitely agree with you that one had like embedded training versus one that didn't however like it could be tagged on however um they said that and I love how they phrased it so let me not mess this up it was thought what feel free to jump Partners thank you um the thought partner process but also um being able to automatically be part of a group that work together of superintendent based on um the LA County Board of and I think that that is like they already come into a supportive group of me like mentors people in the same positions from

167all over LA County I think that's extremely important versus yes I do think it's important to cater the training to a particular person but also the diversity in being part of a a group that are either have more experience than you or are with you on that path I think it's I don't know I I'm leaning more to leadership okay just I mean if somebody else wants to I got you what member Armstrong um could we uh put it out there yeah I just want to hear from um I'm with you guys I would like to choose leadership Associates as well but I do want to get Miss Garza in here to have her say um thank you first of all for doing this because you've made it very difficult to choose these are all

168really great candidates and um that's part of what the job is right so um I'm leaning more for mcferson MC um Jacobson myself I like what leadership Associates has to offer I think that they they sounded great but I'm a little concerned with that we're already at 28,000 000 and I'm tacking on extra things um I'm not sure if that would be too much at some point um but that's just my thoughts and um with the other firm it just seems like it's all inclusive and they would do the same thing for us sorry good point board member syndrome I think the only thing that they said that they were going to ATT on would be adding their mentorship like individual mentorship to the superintendent contract like as a a thing right is there other

169things that I missed that they said they were going to tack on that was the one thing that they did the mcferson and Jacobson said two years um leadership and Associates said that they would do one year that was the main difference in that aspect but when it comes to cost associated with that did they he said somewhere between 10 and 30,000 remember he said it depends on what that superintendent would want okay yeah and if we ever want to you know the additional contract for maybe giving the superintendent some support there's also like they said the uh free superintendent um you know mentorship that there is um but also we can always go to csba and just get a contract from there too so it is an option at this point so for me

170um it just seems like 23,000 versus 28,000 I'm going to go with 23 board member Armstrong oh I'm sorry I never I'm sorry I never turned it off I was ready to call it I believe we have it's down to two so if someone would like to make a motion for one of the firms selected I had add my add on oh if I could board member Crisfield um so so I think that I hear uh the price difference is a concern I would say you know it's a you know 300,000 the the cost of getting it wrong is so high the 5,000 doesn't factor in that that much I wouldn't uh for this I wouldn't weigh that so much and I and I None of these firms that they'll do very well the there's

171additional things that they will present uh as a part of the training and the networking and they all have those networks and and there's contracts for that that we could consider for the superintendent later on um but I I think with uh leadership the reason why I think they'd be my top pick and I really like mcferson Jacobson I really do um but but I think that they were they were upfront about there being additional contracts and how most superintendents uh will do that but that's something we can consider at that time where the other ones I I don't think I I really felt that uh upfrontness about it um so I I don't I wouldn't weigh too much on the 5,000 I would uh I would go for leadership Associates uh but I would

172be fine with Mick Pearson Jacobson as well um but for everything I saw I would I would go for that yeah and just to add on to that the few things that I heard from leader leadership Associates that I didn't hear was they discussed the brown act they said that they like to address the challenges that our district has when talking with superintendant I just thought they were the most thorough I really liked the answer with the um some of our community members with special needs that they would have personal conversations we didn't hear that from the others um so yeah and I like their idea on the closed session Personnel for anybody that we have as a internal candidate so okay so we have it down to three would someone or down to two

173I'm sorry would someone like to make a motion I'll make a motion I just want one more thing one thing I'm sorry one more thing one more thing the reason why because I like both I like both also but um mcferson does keep a database and of of of candidates you know how we we wonder like hey don't have a pool of people that you you you just have to where I mean it's nice it's it's kind of like your your you're you're you're it's like you're punished for it and then you're not punished for it because you you strike these relationships and you know these people and um but they do keep like a database in which they can pull from depending on if they think a client has some of the qualities that

174we're we're looking for um I really want it to be like hey if you got to go National go National if a person's willing to to travel so I'd like to uh unless you guys want to vote I'd want to say uh let's ex out mcferson um vice president Cara I'm sorry I didn't catch that when they did their presentation is that okay because when I thought when he said that we asked that question he said that they do go National correct yeah but they also keep but they also keep a database of people who they have you know they keep a bank they probably all do but I mean okay that's yeah that's not what I I understood from what he answered but but I mean if are we taking motions I we can

175do that we can give I think we we obviously we have it down to our top two I would be comfortable with either of them as well so do we want to go with our top one and then take a motion or do you want to just motion it our top one I i' make a motion and then if it fails that would be I'll make a motion for uh leadership Associates I second do we have any others we need to do a roll call on that first one roll call please miss Armstrong Miss Centron I Mr critchfield I Mrs Garza I Miss Stewart I all right um at this if there is no objection this meeting is adjourned at 751 p.m.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.